<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jon Stokes on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jon Stokes on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 00:22:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Confessions of a Progressive Gun Nut]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/confessions-of-a-progressive-gun-nut-ae0e6a8f6146?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae0e6a8f6146</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guns]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-control]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Nov 2016 15:29:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-30T04:40:30.091Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>I wrote this piece back in July of 2016, and circulated it to a few folks for feedback before declining to publish it. It just seemed a bit too crazypants and tinfoil-hatty, with all its talk of totalitarianism and dystopia. In light of recent events, it suddenly seems a lot less out-there.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gfV5TlzPVbdYzDdrQwANUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The author at SHOT Show Media day in Las Vegas, about to fire a grenade launcher. He missed.</figcaption></figure><p>Over the course of my years-long engagement with smart people on all sides of America’s gun debate — from coffee shops in San Francisco to private suites off the floor of the gun industry’s annual Las Vegas trade show — I’ve come to believe that there are really only two broader ideological camps that people fall into when it comes to the right to keep and bear arms.</p><p>No, the two camps aren’t “blame the shooter” vs. “blame the gun” — that whole discourse is a sad sideshow, and I think both sides are probably tired of swatting each other with the same limp bromides (“the only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun” vs. “here’s what every entry in this catalog of otherwise unrelated horrors has in common: guns!”).</p><p>Rather, the real divide between the pro- and anti-gun camps is much deeper, and is rooted in their sharply divergent readings of the history of human relations. To use a ten-dollar word from my years as a humanities grad student, what we have here is a clash of <a href="http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hermeneutics/">hermeneutics</a>.</p><p>Not only do both camps reason about the present and future on the basis of different interpretations of a shared past, but the gun control argument is so exhausting for everyone involved because it ultimately forces each side into the uncomfortable position of arguing for the truth of grand propositions that it actually hopes are false.</p><p>Despite all of this, I do believe there’s a faint glimmer of hope for finding common ground. But before we can discover what we have in common, we have to understand where and how we truly differ.</p><h4>The Moral Arc vs. the Vicious Cycle</h4><p>Any given gun control discussion may work its way through topics like hunting and other hobbies, or delve into theoretical questions of individual liberty and its limits, or cover the practical nuts-and-bolts of who really needs what type of firearm for which hypothetical use-of-force scenario, but all arguments over Americans and their firearms ultimately end up in one place: a dispute about the usefulness and legitimacy of the constitutional right of private citizens to keep in their homes the tools of violence as a last bulwark against tyranny.</p><p>How you view the Second Amendment — as an embarrassing relic of a barbarous past, or as a last-ditch deterrent against the rise of domestic tyranny — depends on the shape you see when you look at history: an arc or a circle.</p><p>Folks in the anti-gun camp tend to believe, with Martin Luther King Jr., that, “the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice.” These are people who have faith in Progress and Perfectibility, and who will warn you in all earnestness that there is a “right side of history” and you had better get on it. These folks aren’t having any talk of a hypothetical fascist dystopia in the US; to them, that’s paranoid fantasy from a bygone era, and meanwhile there are real lives being lost to gun violence right now.</p><h3>David Atkins on Twitter</h3><p>Your visions of a fascist dystopia in the U.S. are hypothetical. The kids dying from gun violence today are real.</p><p>The other camp, which I confess to being a lifetime member of, sees history as cyclical, with no real long-term trajectory. We take it as self-evident that there is nothing new under the sun; human nature doesn’t change; and humans keep re-learning the same painful lessons as species. To those of us who are members of the “human relations go ‘round in a vicious, bloody circle” tribe, the concept of any sort of long-term positive trend in the way we relate to one another is not only lunatic, but actively dangerous.</p><p>In this respect, despite the fact that I’m a Christian, I find myself sympathizing with the atheists who look on in frustrated wonderment as otherwise rational people bend the knee and send their petitions up to an invisible man in the sky, as if that would solve a single pressing problem faced by humanity.</p><p>Whenever my liberal friends bring up the magical Moral Arc to buttress their argument on some issue or other, I think to myself, “how could someone so smart be so stupid? Are they really willing to put their trust in this smug, secular eschatology? How can they believe, on the basis of a few paltry decades of mostly mixed evidence, that the great Moral Arc of the Universe will eventually, over the very long term, ensure that their ‘right side of history’ wins out in the end?”</p><h4>A Costly Deterrent</h4><p>Despite the way I tend to vote and the liberal causes I tend to support, my circular outlook on history makes me a poor progressive, because while I fight for progress I really just don’t believe in Progress. All of my work in this world is to achieve a momentary respite for me and mine, until whatever rough beast, its hour come round at last, drags us into ever more technologically sophisticated forms of savagery.</p><p>This admittedly grim outlook explains the conviction of “gun nuts” like myself that, sooner or later, the developed West’s relatively recent experiments with civilian disarmament will end badly for all involved. The oppression of the unarmed many by the armed few has happened in many epochs and in diverse cultures. It happened in Feudal Europe and Feudal Japan. It happened in the Antebellum South, where African Americans’ access to guns was severely restricted, and where slavery was enforced by gangs of armed whites. It’s happening right now less than a thousand miles to the south of me, in Oaxaca, Mexico, where a militarized narco-state is massacring disarmed civilians for protesting neoliberal policies that we in America invented, perfected, and exported.</p><p>Guns in private hands, then, are viewed by the “vicious cycle” camp as a way of pausing or slowing the circle of history’s rotation back toward tyranny. The civilian populace has a right to maintain a credible deterrent* against the pretensions of any armed and organized gang, and that right is the one that underwrites all of the others — or so the theory goes.</p><p>But even the most ardent Second Amendment supporter must admit that the price of this deterrent is high and paid in blood. Every year, innocents die because people like me believe that an armed citizenry is the final guarantor of freedom. And when someone points out the lives that have been saved by civilian disarmament in countries like Australia or Britain, all we can do is offer the same fear-mongering hypothetical: “Just give it time. Human nature has not changed, and eventually the armed and organized few will turn on the unarmed many.”</p><p><strong>*Note</strong>: It bears stating explicitly, because I’ve seen this come up time and again, that wanting to preserve private ownership of guns as a deterrent is not even remotely the same as actively preparing to shoot at police or American soldiers. Not every homeowner who keeps a large dog with a vicious bark is eagerly expecting to maul an intruder.</p><h4>Contradiction and Defeatism</h4><p>“But the government has drones and tanks and lasers,” the anti-gunners argue. “Surely you don’t think a bunch of untrained hillbillies with assault rifles can stand up to such technologically advanced weaponry?”</p><p>This is the number one practical objection raised against the pro-gun camp’s “guns as a bulwark against tyranny” argument, and it is fundamentally defeatist, which I know can’t feel good to the otherwise optimistic progressives who make it.</p><p>Regardless of what I think of that argument (“not much,” in case you’re wondering), I cite it not to poke holes in it but to illustrate the way that the gun control debate ultimately puts anti-gun progressives in the uncomfortable position of arguing for the supreme omnipotency of the modern security state. Such people must maintain that any violent popular uprising against true oppression, at least in the advanced Western nations, is already hopelessly lost before it has even begun. The same federally coordinated police forces that are called in to crush popular protests with batons and pepper spray, that gun down the innocent in their homes in no-knock raids, that execute unarmed black men in the streets, and that confiscate citizens’ cash and valuables without due process of law, are exalted as practically invincible by the anti-gun left.</p><p>As a corollary to this, progressives must also believe that the mechanisms of liberal democracy, as broken as they presently appear, can and will be peacefully restored to their former glory by non-violent protests, international outrage, loss of allies, sanctions, and eloquent appeals to the common good. In other words, that mighty Moral Arc has lot of work to do, given the recent track record of most of these tools in advancing the cause of human rights in much weaker countries than the US.</p><p>I’m fairly confident that even as the left is saying these things, though, they’re secretly hoping they’re not right — that if the <em>absolute worst</em> happens, then, well, screw it, there may be some slim hope of a successful popular uprising.</p><p>But I’m actually worse off than the anti-gunners in this regard, because find I myself arguing a position that I’d dearly love to learn is a sick mistake.</p><p>My dream for my young daughters and their future children is that the progressive’s faith in the Moral Arc ultimately proves justified. With every nasty glimpse I get of a nascent American fascism, I pray that history really does have sides and that me and my fellow civil libertarian “gun nuts” will be judged harshly by future generations for being on the wrong one. To have history condemn me because I wasted the lives of the innocent and most vulnerable in a pointless effort to secure freedom against a threat that never materialized is the <em>best possible outcome</em> for someone in my position. And boy, does that suck.</p><p>Ultimately, then, the private ownership of weapons of war is an issue that pits each side against its own hopes for the future. The anti-gun crowd finds itself arguing for the unassailable tactical superiority of the present neoliberal order, and the pro-gun crowd finds itself making the awful case that horrific deaths in the present are necessary to prevent a dystopian future that it fervently hopes will never come to pass. These rhetorical contortions from both sides of this debate are painful, both to execute and to watch.</p><p>Even worse, each side no doubt finds itself in moments of silent envy of the other’s position. There is a strain of old-school leftist that still fantasizes about the revolutionary potential of smallfolk and small arms, while many on the right are bone-weary of America’s costly, endless wars and wish they could live in a world where swords are safely beaten into ploughshares. Neither side, though, is convinced enough by the other side’s vision that they can bring themselves to do more than trade sneers and smears in public.</p><p>Thus we find ourselves at an impasse. But it doesn’t have to be this way.</p><h4>The Way Forward</h4><p>I wish I had some clever argument that could reconcile both sides of this debate, but I don’t. I can, however, offer the anti-gun optimists the secret to defeating my side completely and decisively, and fortunately it’s something that we can all agree we want: the return of broad-based prosperity.</p><p>To use a metaphor from finance, <a href="https://www.thetrace.org/2016/09/harvard-gun-ownership-study-self-defense/">guns are increasingly a short position on civilization</a>, and they come with all the limitations a short position entails — namely, a capped upside and an unlimited downside. As long as the future of a shorted asset looks grim, people will keep piling into the short side in ever greater numbers. A short position becomes untenable, though, when the outlook for the asset changes for the better and it begins to appreciate, forcing the shorts exit the trade and cover.</p><p>Thus the anti-establishment rage and fear for the future that’s surfacing across the developed world is the pro-Second Amendment camp’s greatest ally, because it brings more and more investors into the “short civilization/long guns” trade. (This is <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3420864/More-Germans-arming-wake-Cologne-sex-attacks-gun-sales-threefold-areas.html">true in Europe</a>, as well.) People watch the collapse of revered cultural institutions and the apparent disintegration of the postwar world order, and they know deep in their gut that the worse things get the more they’ll be left to fend for themselves. So they reach for that one tangible bit of individual sovereignty and political power that’s still left to them: the gun.</p><p>If the anti-gun camp wants to change the definition of American gun ownership from “costly but necessary backup plan” to “antiquated and ridiculous waste of lives,” then the best thing they can do is work tirelessly to prove gun owners’ fears wrong by showing us that the moral arc is real and is still at work in our present world.</p><p>Note that the recent gay marriage victory isn’t nearly as potent in this regard as the left would like to believe. Marriage equality was marketed as having a massively beneficial impact on a very small slice of the population, and absolutely no impact on the rest of us in our day-to-day lives. But for <em>all</em> of us, regardless of our sexual orientation, there’s still economic stagnation and uncertainty, and in many quarters there’s a spreading fear of getting robbed, raped, or gunned down by the uniformed few to whom the left would offer a total monopoly on force of arms. Leave these fundamental insecurities unaddressed, or give them populist lip service on the campaign trail while working hand-in-glove with well-connected elites to preserve an increasingly shaky and bloody <em>status quo</em>, and gun sales will keep climbing.</p><p>I honestly hope that progressives can break the hold of guns on the American imagination by helping to usher in a new era of common prosperity in which legions of formerly anxious gun buyers rediscover that they still have a meaningful stake in this shared project we call “America,” but if history is any guide, I’m not optimistic.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae0e6a8f6146" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trump’s Election Rigging Claims: Democrats, It’s a Trap!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/trumps-election-rigging-claims-democrats-it-s-a-trap-84783814097b?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84783814097b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Oct 2016 19:38:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-19T15:35:12.516Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*O26IOYtA-ewxq4QBNqq7jA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Everyone is rightly outraged by Trump’s claims that the US election is being “rigged” by dead immigrants and live CNN anchors. But in attempting to rebut Trump’s <a href="http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/F/FUD.html">classic FUD</a> campaign, the Democrats and their media allies may be making a very serious error, one that could play right into Trump’s tiny hands.</p><p>The problem is this: Obama and the many pundits who’ve responded to Trump’s election rigging claims are too quick to dismiss longstanding concerns about the dangers of paperless e-voting machines. Such concerns are either ignored entirely, as in <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2016/10/the_gop_created_the_rigged_vote_myth.html">this recent Slate piece</a>, or dismissed as overblown, as in <a href="http://www.cnn.com/2016/10/18/politics/obama-trumps-rigged-election-claim-whining-before-the-games-even-over/">Obama’s mistaken assertion</a> that it’s not possible to rig a national election because the system is “too decentralized.”</p><p>But what if our election system is vulnerable, and the Russians were to hack the vote and hand what polls indicated to be a clear Hillary win over to Trump? At that point, all of the folks who’ve been going on about the unassailability of our voting system would have a very hard time making the case to the public that the election was, in fact, rigged. They would have walked right into a trap, and when they attempt to climb out of it, Trump supporters and Putin’s online troll army would keep them down by bludgeoning them silly with their own quotes.</p><p>My point here is not to scare people about November, but merely to insist that there has to be a way to counter traditional GOP scare tactics around The Voting Dead and suchlike while still inserting the very important caveat that our election system is vulnerable to electronic manipulation and will remain so until every last paperless e-voting machine is replaced with a machine that leaves a voter-verified paper audit trail. Everyone who rebuts Trump needs to give a nod to the realistic possibility of electronic election fraud, in case they need to revisit the issue come November.</p><p>So, the TL;DR is this: the way to respond to Trump is not to claim that our system is immune to manipulation, any more than, say, the way to respond to anti-vaxxers is to insist that there is no <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis">replicability crisis</a>. As annoying as it is, we have to debunk specific claims while maintaining the crucial caveat that our system still needs work.</p><h3>Appendix: Still Hackable</h3><p>Many of the folks writing about Trump’s claims are technically clueless, and they seem to view the vote hacking issue through the lens of Y2K —i.e., something that academics and UNIX graybeards stressed about a long time ago and that turned out to be nothing.</p><p>Of course, it may well be nothing. I’m certainly not predicting a Russian hack and a Trump victory in November. Yet it’s important that everyone is clear that our election system remains shamefully unfixed nearly a decade after it was electronically overhauled by the <em>Help America Vote Act</em>.</p><p>There are still voting districts that use electronic voting machines that produce no <strong>voter-verified paper audit trail</strong>. What do I mean by “voter-verified paper audit trail”? A proper electronic voting system would allow a voter to make his or her choices electronically, then spit out a paper receipt that records those choices and that can be examined, verified, and handed over to poll workers for secure storage in case the election needs to be audited.</p><p>An electronic voting machine that does not produce a voter-verifiable paper record for audit purposes cannot be audited, and if it cannot be audited then there is no way to positively verify that its results were not tampered with.</p><p>(On a related note, whenever you hear someone like Obama claim that there has never been a verified case of large-scale voter fraud here in the US, you should understand that this is technically true, but it’s true because <em>the existence of such fraud is currently impossible to verify</em>. QED, I guess.)</p><p>As for Obama’s point that our election system is too decentralized to rig, this is, unfortunately, wrong.</p><p>First, thanks to the electoral college, you only have to rig key districts in swing states to turn the election. Furthermore, you don’t need access to each individual machine in those districts in order to tamper with them. Rather, these machines all run firmware that comes from a central vendor repository. If you can infect the vendor’s firmware with a bit of vote-flipping malware that wipes all trace of itself after the election, then you can infect all of the machines via the update mechanism.</p><p>It’s also the case that paperless voting systems usually upload their votes to a central tabulation computer to be counted. So you don’t even need to get malware onto the voting machines — you just need to hack that central tabulator, which I would guess is typically maintained by elite infosec ninjas on the level of the guy who ran Hillary Clinton’s private email server.</p><p>But I could go on about this, <a href="http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2006/10/evoting/">and at one point, I did.</a> Here are some more recent links, in case you’re interested in learning more:</p><ul><li><a href="https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/07/the_security_of_11.html">The Security of Our Election Systems</a>. Bruce Schneier has been on top of this for years, and his hair is still on fire because it’s still not fixed.</li><li><a href="http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/08/2016-elections-russia-hack-how-to-hack-an-election-in-seven-minutes-214144">How to Hack an Election in 7 Minutes</a>. A Politico piece that details the exploits of the Princeton team that has also been on this for over a decade. They are gravely concerned about 2016.</li><li><a href="http://www.cnn.com/2016/08/29/politics/hackers-breach-illinois-arizona-election-systems/">Officials: Hackers breach election systems in Illinois, Arizona</a>. I throw this out there in case you’ve forgotten that parts of our election system were already hacked this past summer. We still don’t know who did it, or why.</li><li><a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/12/us/politics/obama-russia-hack-election.html">Obama Considers ‘Proportional’ Response to Russian Hacking in U.S. Election</a>. Despite his aforementioned bluster, Obama is evidently concerned enough about the possibility that the Russians might hack our election that he had Joe Biden go on TV and actually threaten them over it.</li></ul><p>For more info, I recommend spending some time with Google, or following the links in the above articles. These concerns are real, the people raising them are serious professionals, and this stuff should have been fixed a decade ago.</p><p>I dunno. Hopefully, November 8, 2016 will be like January 1, 2000 — the source of many dire warnings from computer geeks, but otherwise unremarkable and apocalypse-free. But hope is not a plan, although at this late stage it’s all we have left.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84783814097b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[This PBS Newshour interview on the AR-15 is deeply flawed.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/this-pbs-newshour-interview-on-the-ar-15-is-deeply-flawed-74dfa399916b?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74dfa399916b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[guns]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ar15]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-control]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Jun 2016 14:31:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-15T15:10:26.301Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This <a href="http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/its-the-weapon-of-choice-for-u-s-mass-murderers-the-ar-15/">PBS Newshour interview</a> on the AR-15 is deeply flawed. Specifically, all the stuff about the 5.56mm NATO round is misleading.</p><blockquote>The ammunition for the M-16 or the AR-15 is a 5.56-millimeter bullet. It’s a very small and very fast bullet that does a lot of tissue damage when it hits a person. So just the tip here is the bullet. It’s roughly the size of your pinkie tip. But it’s propelled forward by a massive cartridge of powder that shoots this at a very high velocity, creating a bullet that can punch through targets, whether they’re human or otherwise, with a great deal of lethality and power.</blockquote><blockquote>The other thing about this bullet is, because it’s so small and moves so fast, it tends to tumble or become volatile when it hits a person, and so it tends to create a very wound and very difficult-to-treat wounds. Again, it’s a military weapon. It’s not designed for hunting, where you might want to preserve the meat so that you can eat it. It’s designed to wound or kill soldiers in combat.</blockquote><p>The problem with the above is that it’s true only for certain types of mil-spec ammo, which is indeed available to the public. But the civilian market has a huge variety of other types of 5.56mm — some 5.56 ammo is made expand upon impact, others to fragment, others to tumble, others to go right through body armor like a needle. It all depends on what you buy.</p><p>It’s also the case that the AR-15 can be trivially modified to fire a variety of calibers. The Sig MCX used in the shooting, for instance, is also available in a .300 Blackout chambering. This is a much larger .30-caliber round that has a completely different set of ballistic properties than any flavor of 5.56mm round. Most ARs can fire .300 Blackout with nothing but a simple barrel change.</p><p>So, what the interviewee describes above is a single point in the large possible space of AR-15 configuration + ammo combinations. It happens to be the point that the M16 occupies, but it doesn’t even remotely apply to all civilian rifles. You’d never know that from watching this slanted video, though.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74dfa399916b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I “Need” an AR-15]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/why-i-need-an-ar-15-832e05ae801c?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/832e05ae801c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ar15]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-control]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guns]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jun 2016 21:35:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-20T14:08:34.837Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Once again, there has been another mass shooting involving a gun that looks like an AR-15 (it’s technically a Sig Sauer MCX, which may or may not be an “AR-15”… more later on this definitional issue and why it actually matters beyond mere neckbeard pedantry). And, once again, the calls have gone out to ban the “black rifle” from civilian sales. “Nobody needs one of these weapons of war”, is the <a href="http://digbysblog.blogspot.com/2016/06/nobody-needs-semi-automatic-rifle.html">common refrain</a>.</p><p>Yet, if the statistics from the National Shooting Sports Federation can be believed, <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/13/owned-by-5-million-americans-ar-15-under-renewed-fire-after-orlando-massacre.html">some 5 million Americans</a> have decided that they do, in fact, “need” an AR-15. Are all of these people bloodthirsty savages? Delusional survivalists? Military fetishists? Insecure men with tiny… hands?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q1AP2iktMQvJAZW7-4I_HQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image courtesy of Oleg Volk</figcaption></figure><p>If you’re prepared to answer ‘yes’ to all of the above and consider the case closed, then please move on and don’t read anymore. This article isn’t my attempt to justify anything to you — it’s not a defense of what’s in my gun safe or of the AR-15 itself. If, for you, my AR-15 ownership is <em>prima facie</em> evidence of my mental instability, sexual inadequacy, lack of a conscience, or what-have-you, then I honestly don’t care what you think about this issue. You can go back to broadcasting your own moral superiority on social media, and I can go back to tuning you out until your rage therapy session is over.</p><p>No, this article is for the genuinely curious — those who assume that 5 million of their fellow Americans are not inhuman or insane, and who want to understand what set of rationales, no matter how flawed and confused they may ultimately turn out to be, could make an otherwise normal person walk out of a gun store with an “assault weapon.”</p><p>By the end of this piece, you probably still will not believe that I or any other civilian actually <em>needs</em> an AR-15. That’s fine. My only hope is that you’ll go forth better equipped to talk about gun control based on an understanding of how real live people view and use these firearms.</p><p><strong>Note</strong>: Before I get started, if you’re like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSQBiW8je-Y">Rep. Alan Grayson</a> or <a href="http://www.politicususa.com/2016/06/12/bernie-sanders-bluntly-calls-automatic-weapons-ban-orlando-mass-shooting.html">Sen. Bernie Sanders</a>, both of whom I admire greatly and neither of whom seems to know the difference between a fully automatic weapon and a semi-automatic weapon, please <a href="https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&amp;ion=1&amp;espv=2&amp;ie=UTF-8#q=full%20auto%20vs%20semi%20auto">Google this issue</a> before reading further. This semi- vs. full-auto distinction is not even remotely minor, and when you read up on it you’ll see why. The rifles I discuss in this piece are are not “automatic weapons,” they are semi-automatic.</p><p><strong>Update</strong>: After you’re done with this piece, before you take to some social media channel to inform me that I don’t know the difference between a “need” and a “want”, <a href="https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/i-think-the-need-framing-of-the-piece-from-the-headline-to-its-repetition-as-a-trope-in-the-1eabeea7ae21#.c559d1yft">please read this</a>.</p><h4>Weapons of War</h4><p>The AR-15 was originally designed as a weapon of war, for man-killing and not for hunting or for target shooting — this is an obvious fact. But this is also true of most popular firearms throughout history, including your grandpa’s lever action hunting rifle.</p><p>The vintage <a href="https://www.henryrifles.com/">Henry lever action rifle</a> — the quintessential 20th century deer rifle — was originally deployed to devastating effect in the Civil War.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FPvQViQ36NuU2DGjOhiruw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Wikipedia</figcaption></figure><p>As much as I’m convinced that Wikipedia citations are a sign of laziness, the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_rifle">Henry entry</a> is worth a read:</p><blockquote>For a Civil War soldier, owning a Henry rifle was a point of pride. Letters home would call them “Sixteen” or “Seventeen” Shooters, depending whether a round was loaded in the chamber. The US Government purchased about 3,140 (early versions with inspector marks) in late 1863 to early 1864, mostly for Cavalry units… More Henrys were purchased by soldiers than by the government. Many infantry soldiers purchased Henrys with their reenlistment bounties of 1864…</blockquote><blockquote>When used correctly, the brass framed rifles had an exceptionally high rate of fire compared to any other weapon on the battlefield. Soldiers who saved their pay to buy one believed it would help save their lives.</blockquote><p>The Henry was the AR-15 of its day, and it was followed over the years by the invention of the even more effective semi-automatic firearm, and then by a succession of long guns that we now generally take to be suitable for civilian use.</p><p>My point in bringing up the lever action rifle is that civilians have been buying “weapons of war” for a very long time, since the black powder musket days. This is partly because soldiers who come home from wars to enter civilian life often want to buy a version of the weapon they were trained on and trusted their life to. And it’s also because “military grade” is widely (if sometimes mistakenly) understood to mean “this technology has been tested in the real world, the kinks have been worked out, and its reliability and effectiveness have been proven in the field by an entity with the resources of an entire nation at its disposal.”</p><p>Thus it is that since the dawn of the gunpowder age, gun buyers have snapped up military hardware, because that is often the very best hardware they can get their hands on. In this respect, today’s AR-15 buyers are no different than yesteryear’s lever action rifle buyers.</p><p>This is all part of the reason why I, a civilian, “need” a military-grade combat weapon. I don’t want to shoot and miss; I don’t want the gun to jam because it’s dirty or cold; and I don’t want to hit my target and then have it run off into the woods and die lost and wounded because I didn’t “bring enough gun”. Like my grandpa with his “military-grade” lever action rifle, I want a modern firearm that’s popular (which means parts and training are cheaply and widely available), ergonomic, rugged, accurate, and reliably effective, so that none of the aforementioned bad things happen to me when I’m shooting.</p><p>But, you’ll argue, isn’t the AR-15 <em>uniquely</em> deadly? Unlike the lever action rifle, isn’t the black rifle a weapon of godlike power, suitable only for putting as much lead on the battlefield in as short a time as possible? And in their desire to own one of these turbocharged weapons of mass slaughter, which is clearly overkill for anything but mowing down herds of humans, aren’t today’s AR-15 buyers uniquely twisted and callous? Isn’t it time that gun buyers settled for second or third or fourth best, for the “<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/05/opinion/end-the-gun-epidemic-in-america.html?action=click&amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;clickSource=story-heading&amp;module=opinion-c-col-top-region&amp;region=opinion-c-col-top-region&amp;WT.nav=opinion-c-col-top-region">good of the their fellow citizens</a>”?</p><p>The short answer to all of the above is, “no”.</p><p>The slightly longer answer is that your understanding of what the AR-15 is “for” is all wrong, and says more about Hollywood’s portrayal of black rifles than it does about how these guns are used in the real world.</p><h4>“Say Hello to My Little Friend…”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*XdtylUZhwnkphbt2ZBVJiA.jpeg" /></figure><p>If the AR-15 were a weapon that’s suitable only for indiscriminate, spray-n-pray mass slaughter, then <em>it wouldn’t be so popular with police</em>.</p><p>There is no conceivable circumstance in which a police officer — not even a SWAT team member — would need to mow down hordes of people. Yet the AR-15 is the “patrol rifle” of choice for modern police departments from Mayberry to Manhattan. And when you understand why police need the AR-15, then you’ll understand yet another reason why I “need” one.</p><p>The AR-15 is less a model of rifle than it is an <a href="https://www.wired.com/2013/02/ar-15/">open-source, modular weapons platform</a> that can be customized for a whole range of applications, from small pest control to taking out 500-pound feral hogs to urban combat. Everything about an individual AR-15 can be changed with aftermarket parts — the caliber of ammunition, recoil, range, weight, length, hold and grip, and on and on.</p><p>In a the pre-AR-15 era, if you wanted a gun for shooting little groundhogs, a gun for shooting giant feral hogs, and a gun for home defense, you’d buy three different guns in three different calibers and configurations. With the AR platform, a person with absolutely no gunsmithing expertise can buy one gun and a bunch of accessories, and optimize that gun for the application at hand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XMsiFxib6dz_FV2w3y5OGg.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1akx2jO1RA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1akx2jO1RA</a></figcaption></figure><p>Similarly, the individual members of police and military units can tailor the AR to a specific mission without the help of a professional armorer. Barrels can be swapped out, calibers changed, optics added or removed, and the gun can be totally transformed for every type of encounter, from a long-distance sniper shot at a hostage taker to a close-quarters drug raid in a crowded apartment complex.</p><p>So cops and civilians “need” an AR-15 because that one gun can be adapted to an infinite variety of sporting, hunting, and use-of-force scenarios by an amateur with a few simple tools. An AR-15 owner doesn’t have to buy and maintain a separate gun for each application, nor does she need a professional gunsmith to make modifications and customizations. In this respect, the AR-15 is basically a giant lego kit for grownups.</p><h3>Jon Lech Johansen on Twitter</h3><p>@jonst0kes In the hands of police, AR-15s magically become &quot;patrol rifles&quot; instead of &quot;weapons of war&quot;.</p><p>Indeed, anyone who tells you that <a href="http://www.slate.com/blogs/crime/2013/01/02/gun_control_ar_15_rifle_the_nra_claims_the_ar_15_rifle_is_for_hunting_and.html">the AR-15 is bad for hunting and home defense</a> has absolutely no idea what they’re talking about, because by definition an AR is a gun that can be exquisitely adapted for those niches and many others.</p><p>To return to the Sig MCX that was used in Orlando, the “AR-15ness” of this gun is debatable — it takes many of the same accessories as an AR, and it fits on an AR lower, but unlike a normal AR it has a folding stock and a piston-driven operating system. Because of this, the MCX is the perfect example of the degree to which the “AR-15” is more of a loose collection of standards than a specific collection of parts. Its very existence is emblematic of the adaptability that’s a big part of the AR family’s appeal.</p><h4>The Weapon of Choice for Everyone (Including Mass Shooters)</h4><p>If you’re still with me, then maybe you’re beginning to understand why the AR-15 platform is the most popular type of rifle in America. The AR-15’s incredible flexibility, accuracy, and ease-of-use combine with its status as the most thoroughly tested and debugged firearm in military history to make it massively popular with shooters of all stripes, from hunters to home defense buyers to competitors to police. Parts for the AR are available literally everywhere, and the Internet is chock full of maintenance information and training videos.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*IgeM-dJkSvDoRnvTHk_Daw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="http://www.dogfightink.com/ARparts.html">http://www.dogfightink.com/ARparts.html</a></figcaption></figure><p>The rifle’s popularity is almost certainly the main reason why mass shooters increasingly reach for it when they go on a rampage. Think about it: if you’re planning to shoot up a room full of people, are you going to reach for a rare, exotic weapon that you have little experience with, or will you select the familiar option that’s easy to train with and that you have plenty of practice time behind? The answer, for anybody who shoots, is the latter.</p><p>When it comes to operating a firearm under pressure — whether it’s the stress of combat or the excitement of competition — familiarity and muscle memory are <em>everything</em>. It is impossible to overstate the degree to which this is true. I recently got my hands on a <a href="http://www.springfield-armory.com/products/m1a-socom-16-cqb/">Springfield M1A</a>, and I spent my entire first range session with my laptop open to YouTube just trying to figure out how to work the gun and change magazines consistently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/950/1*Kc4iuuvdPkbdalaNtaKk4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Springfield M1A above is a modernized version of the heavy, wood-stocked service gun that the AR-15 replaced.</figcaption></figure><p>The M1A is an amazing gun (a closely related weapon is actually used by the Marines), but despite the fact that the M1A fires a much larger, deadlier .30 caliber bullet, if I needed to shoot under pressure I’d reach for the smaller AR-15, simply because I can operate that rifle — engage a target, change magazines, troubleshoot and clear a jam — without much thought or effort. I can do all that because the AR-15 is what I know, and it’s what I know because it’s what everyone else out there knows.</p><h4>The “Defense Rifle”</h4><p>At this point, you may be thinking: “ok tough guy, if the AR is so flexible, why not configure it to be a defense rifle instead of an assault rifle? BOOM!”</p><p>I see this “defense” vs. “assault” nonsense a lot, and I just shake my head, because a “defensive” firearm has the exact same characteristics as an offensive firearm.</p><p>Specifically, in a defensive situation, you always “shoot to stop the threat”, which is a police euphemism for “shoot to kill”. I’m not aware of any place in the world where you can go and get professional firearms training and be taught to aim at an attacker’s limbs, or to shoot in a manner that is “less lethal”. Every defensive handgun class will train you to keep shooting at the vitals until the attacker is down. (And even if you were trained to shoot at limbs, you’d need a gun that’s even more controllable and accurate, because moving limbs are harder to hit than center mass!)</p><p>To put it another way, there is a spectrum of force, and a firearm of any type is always at the “lethal force” end of it. Once you’ve gone past fists, tasers, and batons, and gotten to the gun, you are no longer in the realm of trying to preserve the attacker’s life; you’re trying to preserve your own.</p><p>It’s also the case that, contrary to what you saw in <em>First Blood</em>, adrenaline-fueled humans are hard to kill, even with a rifle. The more fast followup shots you can get on-target, the better your chances of scoring a hit that will stop the threat. This is why smaller caliber rifles and pistols like the AR-15 and the Glock 19 are now dominant in police departments and militaries across the globe — smaller bullets mean you can carry more ammo, which means you have more chances to make that fight-stopping shot.</p><p>So the “defensive rifle” (as opposed to the “assault rifle”) is a nonsense idea that exists only in the minds of people who know nothing about guns. This being the case, you can’t fault gun owners for not buying or building such a weapon, because that is not a real thing and never will be. An assault rifle is a defense rifle, and a defense rifle is an assault rifle; these two concepts are identical — such is the very nature of armed combat, in which one person is trying to prevent himself from being killed by killing the other guy first. Anyone who “needs” a defense rifle “needs” an assault rifle, because they are the same.</p><h4>If You’re Gonna Kill the King, You Gotta Kill the King</h4><p>So there you have it: the above represents a few reasons why I and a few million other non-crazy Americans own and shoot so-called semi-auto “assault rifles”. (For the pro-gun people, I realize that “assault rifle” means “full auto” to you, but it doesn’t to most folks; and it’s a made-up political term anyway. It really just means “any scary looking gun that we don’t like and want to ban”, so please spare me the nitpicking for using the term to cover semi-auto ARs. We lost that definitional battle a long time ago.)</p><p>You may reject all of the rationales offered above, which is fine. It’s totally respectable for you to admit that you don’t believe the rationales for AR ownership outlined above are legitimate, and therefore we should outlaw civilian ownership of a very large category of weapons. But what isn’t respectable is to argue this way, and then to turn around and claim that “<a href="http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/obama-to-gun-owners-im-not-looking-to-disarm-you/">nobody is coming for your guns!</a>” That’s insulting, and we both know it isn’t true. Stop doing that.</p><p>If you’re serious about banning guns, you can talk about banning all semi-automatic guns, or about restricting guns to a list of approved models or actions. This is may not be politically realistic at the moment, but at least it’s consistent and rational. But talk of banning just the “AR-15” — as if that’s a specific model of gun that you can just up and ban — is technologically infeasible and ultimately <a href="https://www.propublica.org/article/why-do-democrats-keep-trying-to-ban-the-guns-that-look-scary">counter-productive</a>.</p><p>All you do when you make a lot of noise about assault weapon bans, noise that you can’t even remotely back up with legislative action, is to boost sales of the very weapons you hope to eliminate. Truly, if you’re gonna kill the king, you gotta kill the king; you can’t just loudly threaten to kill the king, then lamely attempt to give him a wedgie (and fail at even that), and then not expect blowback. Here’s how that approach is working out:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/309/1*hpdizpnRtEtO1igvLciPow.png" /></figure><h4>Postscript: What is to be Done?</h4><p>For what it’s worth, I do actually believe the fact that this violent nutjob who had been interviewed by the FBI three times was able to get a gun is so obviously messed up that it’s foolish to suggest otherwise. In an even slightly less crazy world, this guy would never have had a weapon — not even a Cricket children’s rifle.</p><p>I’m gonna be super duper honest, here: I think even the NRA is looking at “unhinged Muslim guy who had ISIS sympathies” and also thinking that such a person probably should not have had access to guns (albeit for different reasons than your typical leftie). But just like when you’re in the supermarket and you see some awful parent verbally abusing their kids and you think, “this person should have been sterilized before it got this far”, but you’d never actually suggest that because you don’t want anyone sterilizing <em>you</em>, the NRA is not likely to express this sentiment in public.</p><p>I’ve been thinking about this issue for years, and I actually do have a pretty detailed proposal for how to use network effects to keep guns out of the hands of people who shouldn’t have them. At some point soon I’ll publish it for everyone to ridicule, ignore, or (since it’ll be <a href="https://github.com/jonstokes/shootercontrol">on github</a>) to fork and/or create pull requests. I don’t think we’re powerless, and I also believe that there’s an approach to “shooter control” (and not “gun control”) that we may even be able to get the NRA to sign on to.</p><p>More to come.</p><h4>Appendix: Further Reading</h4><p>My own journey with the AR-15 began with this long <em>Wired</em> piece I wrote in the wake of Newtown: “<a href="https://www.wired.com/2013/02/ar-15/">The AR-15 Is More Than a Gun. It’s a Gadget</a>”. This is still the longest and most substantial thing I’ve written on the AR platform — I attended the SHOT Show in Vegas, interviewed gunmakers and enthusiasts, and generally did old-fashioned reporting. This piece covers the history, development, and present culture around the black rifle.</p><p>More recently, I’ve written on the assault weapons ban in the context of a discussion of smart guns for <em>Tech Crunch</em>: “<a href="http://techcrunch.com/2016/04/30/why-the-nra-hates-smart-guns/">Why the NRA hates smart guns</a>”. (Although, the <a href="http://techcrunch.com/2016/01/05/why-obamas-smart-gun-push-will-misfire/">predecessor to that piece</a>, which is about the general problems with smart guns, is a lot better than the NRA-focused followup.)</p><p>Finally, if you want to read a frustrated rant that’s <em>way</em> too long, needs edits, and should have been broken up into at least three pieces, check out: “<a href="http://www.alloutdoor.com/2015/11/12/why-fake-moderate-gun-owner-orgs-like-arcog-fail-every-time/">Why “Moderate” Pro-Gun Groups like ACRGO Always Fail</a>”. This is my attempt to answer the often asked question, “why is there no moderate alternative to the NRA that attracts middle-of-the-road gun owners?”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=832e05ae801c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The NoCMS Manifesto]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/the-nocms-manifesto-2f3faf8a17cb?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f3faf8a17cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[content-marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Feb 2016 20:10:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-26T21:50:06.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zlrtsrzhfEz0BiyyWjVZNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve been thinking a fair amount recently about life in a post-WordPress world. Specifically, I’ve been pondering what a fully modern CMS might look like if it were designed in 2016 from mature, stable technologies with the goal of giving publishers the flexibility they need to solve their number one problem, i.e. how to make money by typing things onto the Internet for other people to look at.</p><p>There are a lot of ideas out there for how to keep the content business afloat: crowdfunding, paywalls, voluntary subscriptions, native advertising, and so on. I don’t know which combination of these approaches will be the answer, but I do know that it will take a lot of iterating for different publications of different sizes in different niches to figure out how to keep going in a world of rising ad blocking and declining CPMs.</p><p>Given that there’s a massive amount of business model iteration between today’s online publishing world and a sustainable, profitable future, the number one thing that a CMS can do is enable that iteration. This means maximum flexibility, the kind that a monolithic CMS platform like WordPress can ironically take from you in the name of “extensibility”.</p><p>Note that a flexible, modern CMS isn’t just important for folks in the media business. In-house blogs are an increasingly critical part of an online presence for businesses of all types and sizes, as the slow implosion of online advertising is ironically making quality, original content more valuable again in some quarters. If clickthrough rates are in the toilet thanks to either slow-loading banners or ad blockers, then SEO becomes an increasingly crucial source of traffic, and email becomes increasingly important as a user retention mechanism. Google is getting smarter and better at identifying and surfacing quality content to search users, so more non-media businesses are standing up in-house publishing operations because good content brings good traffic and good leads.</p><p>The TL;DR of this first section is that publishers need maximum flexibility from a publishing solution — they need to be able to try literally anything to extract money from users and advertisers, and marketers need maximum flexibility for using content to attract SEO traffic.</p><p><em>Note</em>: <em>This post was originally published on the </em><a href="http://collectiveidea.com/blog/archives/2016/02/18/rethinking-the-content-management-system-for-2016/"><em>Collective Idea blog</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Now, I keep saying this word: “flexibility”, and I know what you’re thinking: “isn’t WordPress basically the world’s largest Swiss Army Knife?” Yep, and that’s exactly the problem. As a publisher or content marketer, I don’t need a giant multitool; I need a construction kit. I need Lego, and in particular I need the much-maligned modern Lego with all the pre-fab parts that let me quickly assemble a school bus + Malibu mansion mashup, driven by a cop in riot gear.</p><p>I’m going to call the modern, flexible, revenue-oriented CMS that I envision the “NoCMS”, loosely on the model of the “NoSQL” movement. “NoSQL” stands for “not only SQL”, and it’s not so much about ditching SQL as it is about augmenting it with different kinds of key-value and document stores. For me, “NoCMS” isn’t about getting rid of the CMS, rather, it’s about shrinking the CMS back to its original role as a multiuser platform for managing content, while leaving all the other stuff — distribution, monetization, community, and other aspects of online publishing — to a loose collection of more purpose-built tools.</p><p>Of course, I’m obviously not the only person thinking along these lines right now, in fact I’m sort of late to the party. Software like <a href="https://middlemanapp.com/">Middleman</a> and platforms like <a href="http://contentful.com/">Contentful</a> and <a href="http://netlify.com/">Netlify</a> are already making great strides in this direction. And at <a href="http://www.collectiveidea.com/">Collective Idea</a>, we have our own static-site-generator/CMS product, <a href="http://get.harmonyapp.com/">Harmony</a>, that we use on some client projects. We’re in the process of rewriting it from the ground up, and this piece and its followups are part of the internal conversation that we’re having around our “Harmony Next” project.</p><p>Whenever you’re considering a new piece of software it’s important to identify stakeholders. For a CMS, you might think that the process is straightforward, and it is if you’re just talking about a personal blog. But, if you’re trying to build a polished online publication around multiple voices that can not only help you with SEO and lead generation, but also let you experiment with new ways of monetizing content and community, then you have to broaden the circle of stakeholders to encompass more than just “people who hit ‘Publish’”.</p><p>Before we can design a new CMS, we need to look at the types of people who matter for a serious online publication, and outline each type’s needs and quirks. This will help us come up with some design goals for a CMS that works the way we need it to in 2016.</p><p>Note that my target audience for this hypothetical NoCMS publishing platform is not solo bloggers or the non-tech-savvy. This is for people who are serious about content and who have access to at least a little bit of programming and editorial talent. You shouldn’t need rockstar programmers or editors to run a publishing shop, but if you have access to the talent then you shouldn’t be held back by the limitations of a monolithic blogging platform.</p><p>Now, on to the stakeholder categories.</p><h4>Readers</h4><p>Readers come first, always. Here are the technical (i.e. non-editorial) things that matter for readers, even if they don’t always consciously know it:</p><p><strong>Mobile first</strong>: This may mean responsive or separate layouts. But assume that most of your traffic will eventually be mobile and optimize accordingly.</p><p><strong>Speed and page weight</strong>: 9MB page loads and 30-second waterfalls are symptoms of a broken business model. A great CMS shouldn’t prevent publishers from assaulting their readers with fat, JavaScript-heavy pages that grind away at their bandwidth quotas and laptop batteries, but it should definitely actively enable publishers who want to keep page weights down and speeds up.</p><p><strong>Ad blocking</strong>: This is here, it’s not going away, and pretty soon it will be as commonplace as email SPAM filtering. There’s no use throwing a tantrum about it, just figure out how to deal with it.</p><p><strong>Tagging</strong>: In many cases tags are terrible UX for surfacing published articles—they’re great for communities like StackOverflow, but I’ve never been part of a straight-up content site where anyone actually clicked on these. However, they’re good inputs to an algorithm that can surface relevant content.</p><p><strong>Sidebars and “related content” units</strong>: Most popular, most emailed, related stories, stories from partners, and the like are all click magnets and can drive up engagement metrics like time-on-site and pages per session.</p><p>Any CMS front-end that’s intended for serious use will have to take into account all of the above, at a minimum. And when someone else comes up with a reader-facing idea that seems to be working really well for them, the CMS should make it easy for you to copy that idea on your own site.</p><h4>Writers and Editors</h4><p>Here are some things that writers and editors care about when using a CMS.</p><p><strong>Familiarity and ease of use</strong>: “We really love to take non-tech-savvy writers and train them to use this flashy new CMS UI”, said no publisher, ever.</p><p><strong>Version control</strong> (auditing and rewind): Editors need to know who edited what and when, and they need to be able to rewind it.</p><p><strong>Locking</strong>: If someone is editing a post, then they don’t want anyone overwriting their changes. They also don’t want anyone <em>watching them edit</em>. Seriously, there is no large contingent of writers and editors out there screaming for a collaborative editing interface where they can see each other typing in realtime; there are only programmers who are high on the latest JS framework and who are dying to mangle a UI with it. Just implement a WordPress-style locking function and forget about the collaborative editing thing.</p><p><strong>A good source view + preview combination</strong>: Any serious CMS needs a good source view, because the people whose job it is to make content look nice for readers need to be able to edit the source. Related to this, I think the Medium-inspired in-place editing trend will fizzle out, at least for everything but casual applications. That sort of thing is fine for a site like Medium that is what it is, but if you’re serious about having a hackable CMS then you can’t box in any of your editors or layout people by tying them down to WYSIWYG-only. They need to be able get in and edit the source.</p><p><strong>Image gallery support</strong> with ease of upload/import and insert: This is something that WordPress does really well, and it’s a critical element that’s missing from many would-be WordPress replacements. I think that back-office-only solutions like <a href="http://contentful.com/">Contentful</a> and <a href="http://buttercms.com/">ButterCMS</a> don’t take this seriously because they don’t know how huge it is for writer productivity. Selecting images and sprinkling them throughout a post is a giant, tedious pain, and it’s the last thing any writer or editor wants to do before hitting “Publish”. But posts with images vastly outperform large blocks of text, so it’s a necessity. So make dealing with images in the editing view as painless as possible.</p><p><strong>Post statuses</strong>: The ability to flag posts as having various statuses, and then filter posts by status, is critical to an editorial workflow. A CMS should support “draft”, “pending”, “scheduled”, and “published” statuses at minimum, but bonus points for letting editors create their own statuses and filter by them.</p><p><strong>Scheduled post support</strong>: Serious users need to schedule posts to go live at a certain time. Also, this feature cannot ever fail: if it’s too early, then you blew an embargo and may get sued. If it’s too late, then you missed a scoop.</p><p><strong>Permission levels</strong>: Writer and editor roles at the very least are needed to keep everyone in their lane.</p><p>I could actually sum up 90% of the above discussion of writer/editor-facing issues by saying, “just copy whatever WordPress does, and make it look like WordPress, even down to the color scheme and icons”. I know that most people reading this just had a seizure when I said that, but the reality is that everyone you will ever hire already knows how to use WordPress. There is zero on-boarding with WordPress, and zero user support. Over the course of my editing and publishing career, I have worked with retirees who live in rural Mississippi and who are still double-clicking on hyperlinks, and even those people know how to use WordPress.</p><p>Another way of putting this is that the WordPress has many serious problems, but none of them have to do with the back office interface for CRUDing assets. Everyone may hate the way WordPress looks, but at this point we’re all familiar with it, and that familiarity is a huge advantage for any publication that uses it and hires freelancers.</p><h4>Community</h4><p>If you’re putting in enough effort to be at least semi-serious about publishing, then you want to be at least semi-serious about community, as well.</p><p>Of course, I should say at the outset that in my experience communities are impossible to build intentionally, i.e. if you start out saying “I’m going to create a community about X” you will probably fail. You can’t just spin up a thriving community out of nowhere, no matter how much money you throw at it, which is why most companies that want to own online communities just identify existing ones and buy them.</p><p>That said, you want to have the infrastructure for it if lighting strikes in your particular case, and you happen to get a community of commenters who care about your content and your brand. It probably won’t happen, but if it does then it’s magic and you’ll want to capitalize on it, so it makes sense to leave the door open for it.</p><p><strong>User accounts</strong>: Users need to be able to make accounts so they can comment, and more importantly, so that they can hand over their email addresses. More on that in the next section, though.</p><p><strong>Comments</strong>: I know that many publications are moving away from comments, and I understand why. But unless you have a really good, well-thought-out reason for not having comments, you should just have them (see the “leave the door open” bit above). Nested or flat comments is up to you, but I think that Disqus and Facebook have accustomed users to a certain level of nesting, so I’d go nested on any new project.</p><p><strong>New comment notifications</strong>: One of the biggest things that a good blog does is bring people back, and one of the best ways to do that is to send commenters an alert whenever there’s a new comment in a thread that they’ve participated in. Facebook and Disqus both do this to great effect. (I know that <a href="http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/BuildingCommunitieswithSo.html">Joel Spolsky thinks</a> these thread notifications actually prevent people from coming back, but Joel Spolsky is wrong about this.)</p><p><strong>Moderation tools</strong>: You will have to moderate, period. Don’t even consider a comments system that doesn’t offer at least basic moderation tools. You don’t necessarily need things like upvotes, karma, and user messaging, but users should be able to flag a post, and mods should be able to delete posts and ban users by IP.</p><p>You might argue that the items above shouldn’t really be part of a “CMS” discussion, and you may be right. But I put them in here because community is such an important consideration when thinking about the big picture, that it’s critical to keep it in mind when thinking about a CMS.</p><h4>Number Crunchers</h4><p>Number crunchers are the people who are responsible for taking the assets in the CMS’s database and turning them into money. That doesn’t just happen all by itself, and in fact in many cases nowadays it doesn’t happen at all. But if you’re going to have a fighting chance, then here are some things you need to think about:</p><p><strong>User accounts</strong>: Giving away your user accounts to FB and Disqus is a mistake. Don’t do it unless you absolutely cannot spin up and host your own commenting system. Make people give you an email address in order to sign up. I say this, because in 2016 comments aren’t valuable — everybody in the world has comments on everything all the time, and most of them are abusive, off-topic garbage. No, what’s valuable is having <em>users</em>. If you’re not going to have users that are <em>your</em> users, then there’s no point in having comments. Furthermore, if a user isn’t committed enough to your brand to create an account, then they aren’t likely to contribute anything worthwhile via a comments box, so you won’t miss them. (And on the flip side, if you’re not offering enough to users to entice them to create an account and engage, then you need to reevaluate what you’re doing.)</p><p><strong>User analytics</strong>: You can’t get money from people you don’t know, nor can you sell an undifferentiated mass of “eyeballs” to an advertiser. The more ways you can slice and dice your audience’s data, the better. If at all possible, you should own your own user data. Don’t just give it away to Disqus, FB, or Google Analytics.</p><p><strong>User communication</strong>: One reason that you want to own your own user accounts and data is so you can communicate with your users in order to ask them to come back and visit your site, or so you can sell them things. Email marketing works <em>really well</em>, so you need to be able to capture email addresses so that you can do lead generation and implement user retention strategies.</p><p><strong>User payments</strong>: Whether you’re building a paywall or doing some crowd-sourcing scheme, you need a way for your users to give you money directly. That way, you can experiment with offering different things and figuring out what, if anything, people will pay you for.</p><p><strong>Advertising</strong>: In this age of ad blockers, it’s important to be able to serve your own ad assets in a variety of sizes and formats that are loaded server-side. If you can insert ads server-side, you can make them indistinguishable from content. And when I say “ads”, I also mean lead-generation widgets and the aforementioned “related content” widgets that sell more of your content to users who’ve landed on an article page from a search engine.</p><p><strong>Gated content</strong>: More publications are going to start experimenting with paywalls in various forms, and probably sooner rather than later. They’ll do this because they’re going out of business anyway, so they might as well give charging readers a shot before they close up shop. Thus a publishing platform in 2016 must be able to painlessly accommodate tons of experimentation around different types of paid content strategies, whether it’s per-article payments, site-wide subscriptions, network-wide subscriptions, crowdfunding, or whatever else someone will try next. Even lead-gen sites will want to “paywall” content by requiring a user to give up some data — an email address or some survey answers — before viewing certain content. At some point, therefore, you’ll need a way to determine if a reader has taken some action on the platform that has granted them permission to access a particular piece of content.</p><p><strong>TBD</strong>: The most important revenue-related item on this list is “TBD”, because it’s the one that you’re going formulate, deploy, measure, and then either iterate or abandon. And you’ll do this over and over again until you either win or run out of money.</p><h4>Dev and ops</h4><p>These are the folks whose job it is to support and empower all of the above folks, and who worry about new features and web-scale delivery of the assets that are in the CMS’s database. I throw them in here because they think about things like query and view caching, query plans, CDNs, static pages, and all of the platform-dependent plumbing that goes into making a site fast and scalable. Increasingly, they also have to find ways to get half a dozen different pools of user data to sync up.</p><p>I won’t break out any of their issues in detail, though, because we’ll have to sort out what the CMS tech stack looks like, first.</p><p>If you’re shopping for a publishing platform, or you’re considering designing one, then all of the above are things that you need to think about.</p><p>Yeah, you can just use WordPress and get most of that stuff. But it’s also the case that there are tons of third party services and mature, maintained plug-ins for popular frameworks like Rails and Django that do everything (and every little tiny sub-part of everything) I’ve described above. Not only do you not need a monolithic CMS platform like WordPress, but you’d be a lot better off if you could and mix and match and play around with all of the options that are out there, to come up with a combination that works for you. Nothing listed above is rocket science — all of the problems outlined here haven’t just been solved, in most cases they’ve crushed five or six times over.</p><p>The challenge lies in integrating all of these elements in a way that’s performant, scalable, and (above all) flexible. The question for the NoCMS in 2016 is, what sort of platform will let a publisher — one who can afford only a part-time, intermediate-level developer — put all of these pieces together, and then swap them out swiftly and cheaply as they iterate their business model?</p><p>Stay tuned for Part 2, where we’ll talk about software, and about how to divide up the above along meaningful application boundaries.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f3faf8a17cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I, Mr. Robot]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/i-mr-robot-c132820ee56d?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c132820ee56d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entertainment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Sep 2015 15:10:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-09-08T15:14:24.279Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>software, dystopia, and the view from 2005</h4><p>I was in the lobby of a tire shop outside of Austin, Texas, when I started writing this piece. I had been trying to ignore the lobby TV so I could <a href="http://collectiveidea.com/blog/archives/2015/09/02/why-i-joined-collective-idea/">wrap up some work</a> with a colleague in Michigan for a client in Bahrain, when a news segment about smartphone and social media addictions came on.</p><p>“Yeah, this talking head is right,” I told myself. “I should skip Facebook this morning and write that <em>Mr. Robot</em> thing I’ve been ruminating on.”</p><p>Besides, I try to put a daily limit on the number of smartphone videos I see of police shooting unarmed citizens, which seems like half my feed nowadays. It always weirds me out that such atrocities pop up in the same stream as, say, photos from my childhood best friend’s recent bird hunt with his stepson. When everything comes at you constantly in a single stream, it’s all equally banal, which I suspect is a feature, not a bug.</p><p>So I closed the browser and fired up my text editor to write a think piece about this ad-free TV show that I’ve recently started watching on a “TV network” (what even is that anymore?) that I wouldn’t know how to tune into if my life depended on it.</p><p>Now, none of the above is even remotely remarkable or interesting. Indeed, even pausing a moment to marvel at such spacetime-bending techno-wonders is lame at this point — shellshocked think pieces about the accelerating pace of cultural change are so 2014. But as jaded as I am, watching <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mr._Robot_%28TV_series%29">USA’s <em>Mr. Robot</em></a> really brings it all home to me at least once an episode, and I just have to get this off my chest.</p><p>When I watch <em>Mr. Robot</em>, it’s like I’m watching dystopian sci-fi, except <em>holy crap I actually live in that world on the screen</em>. As I sit there on the couch I think back to 2005, before the iPhone and Facebook and Twitter and YouTube and Tinder and Instagram, before we all jumped feet first into “<a href="http://techcrunch.com/2009/05/17/jump-into-the-stream/">the stream</a>”, and I watch the show through my pre-stream eyes. This practice triggers for me the novel sensation of having suddenly woken up in the future, and that sensation is part of the reason I enjoy the show. It’s like the inverse of virtual reality’s “presence” effect — I know that the world on the screen is real and that I’m actually in it, but I somehow don’t quite believe it.</p><p>This is what makes <em>Mr. Robot</em> so utterly compelling: it’s dystopian sci-fi about the <em>right now</em>, and it works because so much of “right now” is so new that it still has the potential to blow our minds when we grind it up and snort it in little 43-minute lines.</p><p>For those of you who watch the show or plan on watching it, I want you to borrow my 2005 glasses for at least one episode. To help orient you and jog your memory, here are some things that were true about the world in 2005:</p><ul><li>There was no YouTube, and video on the web was still rare and flash-based.</li><li>It would be two more years before Netflix streaming would launch.</li><li>Thefacebook.com was still just a college thing, and the appeal was mostly for undergrads.</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/matter/the-web-we-have-to-save-2eb1fe15a426">Bloggers were rockstars, and hyperlinks still mattered</a>.</li><li>The Motorola RAZR had just been released in late 2004, and 2005 was the year that it blew up. It was tiny, and it was huge. My non-techie sister could do <em>email</em> on hers.</li><li>3G cellular was state-of-the-art, and 4G wouldn’t be introduced for another three years.</li><li>Web advertising was quite profitable — wildly profitable by today’s standards, even. I won’t give any numbers, but <a href="http://arstechnica.com/">Ars Technica</a> and other independent publications could afford to pay writers well enough that we could actually poach programmers and engineers from their day jobs and turn them into journalists.</li><li>Amazon was two years away from releasing the first Kindle, and one year away from launching Amazon Web Services.</li><li>This was the first year that I and many others finally ditched paper maps and Google Maps print-outs for dash-mounted GPS units by Garmin and TomTom.</li><li>When Hurricane Katrina took out New Orleans in September of 2005, there were no smartphones to document any of it. Those of us on the Gulf Coast in the storm’s aftermath got our information via <a href="http://www.eschatonblog.com/2005/09/op-ed-which-wasnt-run.html">word-of-mouth rumor</a> and broadcast news reports. Also, I spent a bunch of time in shelters <a href="http://arstechnica.com/security/2005/10/disaster-livecd/">helping abruptly displaced storm refugees</a> use internet-connected PCs and one-off message boards to reconnect with their scattered friends and family, because there was no app for that.</li></ul><p>As Josh Brown ably pointed out in <a href="http://thereformedbroker.com/2014/09/06/crowdsourced-terror-hyper-competition-and-the-acceleration-of-acceleration">a 2014 post</a> that I still think back to periodically, it’s not just that the pace of change has accelerated in the past few years, but that the rate of acceleration has accelerated — we’ve hit the second derivative. Is there a third derivative in our future? Could we handle it if there were?</p><h3>Software, network effects, and feedback loops</h3><p>I have various hypotheses about why things have suddenly sped up so much, and I’ll share one of them, here:</p><p>We’re moving more of our social and economic lives into software, and everything about software is volatile because software is</p><ol><li>easily changed, and</li><li>a force multiplier for human efforts — the good, the bad, the naive— in any sphere.</li></ol><p>These effects are further compounded by network effects (networks of computers and humans are a force multiplier for software) and feedback loops (networked software is a force multiplier for the human activity of producing networked software). The result is that the ride just. keeps. getting. faster.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lQBupiuOR8jWwh0yeIXIKw.gif" /><figcaption>A flash crash in GOOG. Source: <a href="http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4171.html">Nanex</a></figcaption></figure><p>The <a href="http://www.cbsnews.com/videos/whats-behind-wall-street-whiplash-and-global-market-volatility/">whipsawing</a> of our <a href="http://www.wired.com/2010/12/ff_ai_flashtrading/">largely automated stock markets</a> in recent days is just a taste of what can and will happen to every sphere of human activity that we port from meatspace to networked software. And as with the stock market’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Flash_Crash">flash crashes</a> and melt-ups, those changes will be catastrophic for some and wildly profitable for others.</p><p>Think about what’s already routine: we now live in a world where an individual’s career and entire stock of social capital can flash crash to zero thanks to a single ill-advised tweet; where a swath of the country’s marriages can flash crash thanks to a hack; and where a small bakery’s bank account can melt up thanks to a national backlash against a national backlash against a local incident involving a wedding cake.</p><p>When I think ahead to what the world will be like in 2025, I’m kind of terrified. Forget about climate change and terrorism and all that — I’m worried about what we’re going to do to ourselves voluntarily. I’m worried that the sensation that I get when watching <em>Mr. Robot</em> will become a regular feature of my life, and that I’ll routinely find myself looking at a screen full of “right now” and seeing something out of a dystopian sci-fi show from ten years ago, five years ago, or even two years ago.</p><p>The crazy thing is that we’ve barely gotten started. There is so much that has yet to be ported from meatspace to the ‘net, and every part of our lives that’s already on the ‘net will be refactored with increasing rapidity. And when I say “the ‘net” I don’t really mean “the web”, because the web as we know it is a sad mess of cave paintings compared to what’s right around the corner.</p><p>In the next five years, possibly sooner, VR and augmented reality will sweep over the developed world like a tsunami; the earthquake has already happened somewhere at sea, the wild animals have headed to high ground, and those <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/22/facebook-oculus-rift-acquisition-virtual-reality">outsized</a> <a href="http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/21/7026889/magic-leap-google-leads-542-million-investment-in-augmented-reality-startup">investments</a> that have attracted so much media attention are the tide going out — we’re all just milling about on the beach while the wall of water closes in. We’re going to live inside our software, and it will live inside us. If you think VR is overhyped, you will be proven wrong shortly, when an infinitely malleable force multiplier for the full spectrum of human genius and depravity takes up full-time residence <em>inside your eyes</em>. Forever.</p><h3>A ray of hope?</h3><p>Interesting times, for sure, but I have one more hypothesis I’ll share, and it’s a little less terrifying: the human capacity for dealing with an overload of novelty is finite, and at some point we’ll start to bump up against those limits, individually at first, and then in demographic cohorts. Some of our networked software deploys will be rolled back into meatspace, and like all rollbacks of production code, those moments will be both painful and educational.</p><p>Maybe this last idea is just wishful thinking on my part — the hope that my kids will inhabit a world I can recognize, or at the very least be tethered to a networked software construct that’s less spiritually toxic than the stream. Either way, I don’t think it will take us another ten years to find out what’s next.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c132820ee56d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It could happen to you]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jonst0kes/it-could-happen-to-you-611a1cdd3ba0?source=rss-852e228e57ea------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/611a1cdd3ba0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Stokes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Apr 2013 17:15:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-04-02T17:15:41.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*VRHpnehlryYf3MRB.jpeg" /><figcaption>FLICKR: walknboston</figcaption></figure><p>My pregnant wife just called me a few hours ago from SFO as she was boarding an airplane to Austin, TX. &quot;I got an email from Chase saying that our checking account is overdrawn, and all our assets are frozen. None of our cards work. They gave me some number to call.&quot;</p><p>Of course, I flipped out. But I also knew immediately what had happened. I&#39;m currently disputing a laughably bogus 2007 income tax bill with the MA Department of Revenue, a state in which I have not lived or earned income in since 2003. I live in CA, and the Chase account in question was opened in Chicago. But I had a sinking feeling that, in the world of the multinational megabank, niceties like state borders don&#39;t matter anymore. My guess was that MA had called Chase (they have not sued me or sent me any sort of court order) and Chase just handed over all our assets there to MA.</p><p>A call to the number provided, a visit to my local branch, and ultimately an on-the-record discussion with someone from Chase&#39;s executive office confirmed that I was mostly right. The MA Department of Revenue had filed a levy against me in MA, and when the state notified Chase of the levy, Chase dutifully froze everything but (lucky me!) has not yet transfered any money out. The perky Chase lady on the phone told me that on March 4, unless MA has lifted the levy, Chase will clean out my accounts and hand everything over to MA. Again, I have not lived in MA or earned income in that state since 2003, and I worked with a CPA to pay all of my state and federal 2007 taxes in full and on time. I did everything 100% by the book, and yet here I am in 2013, with a negative bank balance and frozen assets.</p><p>Welcome to America, 2013, where bankrupt states aggressively pursue long-gone former residents with insane tax bills and levies, and where the banks, as a matter of official policy, will hand over every last dime in your account without even knowing or caring whether the request is valid and enforceable.</p><p>Here&#39;s a bit more background, so you can understand how crazy this all is.</p><p>I moved from Massachusetts to Illinois in 2003, and I opened my Chase account there in 2005. I also hired a CPA and dutifully paid all of my state and local tax, in full, every year including 2007. I moved further west to California in 2008, so imagine my shock when in January of last year, I got a letter from the MA Department of Revenue claiming that I owed them a jaw-dropping sum for 2007. Again, I hadn&#39;t lived there or worked there since 2003, but I did own part of a business that was headquartered in MA, and the state was using this fact to harass me for income tax money. How much money? At least 10X what I&#39;d actually owe them if I really did owe them income tax for 2007; or, to put it another way, roughly 10X what I paid Illinois in 2007 on the advice of my Illinois CPA.</p><p>I didn&#39;t just let this nasty MA tax claim ride, thinking it would go away. I put my California CPA to work on it, I hired a tax attorney in MA, and I even hired a CPA malpractice attorney to go after my Illinois CPA on the slim chance that Massachusetts is actually right and I do owe them something. I filed appeals, submitted papers, and generally stayed on top of it. So I wasn&#39;t overly alarmed when a few weeks ago, the MA Dept. of Revenue sent me a notice that they were filing a tax lien against me with the MA Secretary of State&#39;s office. But I didn&#39;t freak out, because hey, this is part of an ongoing dispute where they&#39;re clearly way out of line, and I have some very good people working with me on this... and besides, I don&#39;t own any property in MA, so what are they going to do?</p><p>And then, without even sending me a copy of any kind of court order or document, they&#39;ve suddenly frozen and are on the verge of confiscating all of the funds in my out-of-state bank account.</p><p>After talking to Chase, my next call was to the MA tax attorney that I&#39;d hired to fight with MA over their insane tax bill.</p><p>&quot;I&#39;ve dealt with this once before, with Bank of America. And the guy was in California, just like you. Chase Manhattan is not supposed to freeze an out-of-state account like this, and MA knows it. But MA does this because they know they can get away with it.&quot;</p><p>I then headed down to my local Chase branch, and where I talked to their legal department and got them to confirm that this is their policy. I also played the journalist card and got them to put me in touch with someone from their executive office who could speak on the record.</p><p>&quot;The management stands behind the decision to freeze your account,&quot; she said. She argued that because Chase has a minor presence in MA (a few non-branch offices), they&#39;re subject to MA jurisdiction and have to comply with the order to freeze my account, regardless of where the account was opened or is currently located. She also said that I had agreed to all of this madness when signing up for the account, as part of Chase&#39;s terms of service.</p><p>Apparently, my contract with Chase stipulates that Chase will turn over any of my assets to anyone who comes knocking with any kind of official-looking levy or lien, and Chase &quot;does not have to determine whether the legal process [behind the request] is valid or enforceable.&quot; They just hand over all your money, and if the request was bogus then that&#39;s not their problem, it&#39;s yours.</p><p>There is nothing I can do at this point but file an appeal with MA, and hope the freeze gets lifted before Chase turns over our frozen assets on March 4th.</p><p>And I&#39;m one of the lucky ones. We use a foreign bank for the vast majority of our assets, and keep only a small amount in Chase for bills and such. Even if Chase hands over all of the money in our accounts to MA, the worst thing that wil happen is that my wife will be stuck in Austin for three days with only an American Express card (which hopefully still works) and/or that I&#39;ll have to send her some of the cash we keep on-hand for emergencies via Western Union. Oh, and I&#39;ll have to pay a ton of legal fees to recover the money, which would probably end up costing me more than MA took. So I may just have to let MA rob my bank account, with the bank&#39;s help, of course.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=611a1cdd3ba0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>