<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jordan Hedberg on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jordan Hedberg on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jordanhedberg?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:06:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jordanhedberg/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Governance by Scapegoat]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/governance-by-scapegoat-a8b0562af5e3?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8b0562af5e3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Oct 2023 01:59:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-03T01:59:27.231Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The use of a scapegoat in politics is nothing new, and for Custer County Commissioner Bill Canda, who has proven himself incapable of actual governance, relies heavily on what I have come to call governance by scapegoat. For the past ten weeks, his devoted followers, who now style themselves as “The Investigative Citizens Committee,” have filed into public meetings looking for a new scapegoat victim since they succeeded in recalling Commissioner Tom Flower. This time of year, budget hearings should be the focus of the Custer County Board of Commissioners (BOCC), but instead, each meeting is focused on deciding if they will scapegoat Commissioner Kevin Day or former employee Braden Wilson next, or perhaps both. Canda not only encourages the “Citizens Committee” but has made it a custom to approve every request the committee brings to him. So far, two executive meeting records have been released, and more are being requested, along with waiving the cost of all the requests the committee has asked for. The committee, which is made up of Sangre de Sentinel employees plus close political friends of Canda, is not interested in the truth they claim to be uncovering as they have proven repeatedly to be immune to facts.</p><p>But as I said, the scapegoat is nothing new. As the insightful Luke Burgis points out in his 2021 book <em>Wanting: The Power of Mimetic Desire in Everyday Life,</em> the practice goes back to the start of known civilization. The Torah holds an account that once a year on Yom Kippur, two male goats were decided by lot to be either sacrificed to God or sent into the desert to be taken by the evil spirit Azael. All the sins of the people were expelled with the goats. In 1530, English Protestant scholar William Tyndale’s translation of this story from Latin called it in English the “Scapegoat.”</p><p>As Burgis highlights in his book, the Jews were not unique. The Greeks had their own version where instead of a goat, the community would select a “pharmakos” a human castoff from society such as a slave, beggar, or deformed person, and stone them to death. Aristotle called the killing of pharmakos a “catharsis” moment in which the process of releasing strong emotion through an external event discharged the hateful energy of the community and brought unity and peace. It was during plague that the use of pharmakos seemed to be the most used as a single person to blame was impossible by rational means and so the community would randomly pick a person that they considered an outsider and heap all of their rage and fear onto the unfortunate victim.</p><p>It needs to be made clear that we cannot expect ancient peoples to have had the same moral foundations that we posses now. As the classicist and writer of Roman history, Tom Holland has stated repeatedly, “Before the crucifixion of Christ, the moral order of the ancient world was that the strong did as they pleased, and the weak suffered what they must.” And imposing their strength is what Bill Canda and his followers do in meeting after meeting, trusting in the complacency of the majority of the citizens to not care as they sling the mud of an endless stream of baseless accusations on people they have decided to make their own<em> pharmakos</em>, to brand community members into something evil that they can openly ridicule and drive away.</p><p>And as Burgis points out, the person being accused does not actually have to be guilty to be made into a scapegoat. “A wave of accusation, in which enough people model belief in another person’s guilt, can transfigure an accused person before our eyes. We don’t see them as they are because they are a mirror of our own violence… in a single moment, the guy standing on the outside… takes on the appearance of a monster — a murderer… all because he happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.”</p><p>To cover up his lack of understanding and competence, Canda has spent his past seven years as commissioner transforming community members into something that his supporters can ridicule and metamorphicly stone out of the community. He first tried, unsuccessfully, with this author, violating his oath of office and the First Amendment by using his government power to try and punish the Tribune for protected speech. He then turned on Commissioner Tom Flower, encouraging and signing a recall against Flower for a mistake Flower had made and that Canda remained silent about while it happened. With Flower gone, Canda has now turned his attention to scapegoating an excellent former employee, Braden Wilson. Not satisfied with publicly firing Wilson to the cheers of followers in a public meeting, Canda went over the head of another elected official (detailed on page two) to alter bank documents and try to stop a severance check to the terminated Wilson. If the scapegoating campaign against Wilson fails, Canda has already set the stage to try and oust Commissioner Kevin Day, who, unlike Canda, knows a thing or two about how the county operates and is interested in actual governance.</p><p>The practice of scapegoating in the ancient world came to an abrupt end when the Jewish high priest Caiaphas tried to bring peace to troubled Judea with the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. The problem was that Jesus had spent his life teaching the opposite of the existing moral order. When the crowd, heavily influenced by Greek culture, tried to stone a woman accused of infidelity, he stated, “Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.”</p><p>In John Gray’s review of Tom Holland’s book on the history of Christianity <em>Dominion</em>, he summed up that our culture has rejected the collective need for a scapegoat in favor of the liberty of the individual. “If you regret the rise of Christianity, you must regret the rise of liberalism, human rights, and belief in progress as well.” Liberalism is a product of Christianity, both of which reject the use of the scapegoat sacrifice in favor of a New Testament. Those new testaments are what give our culture the liberties we currently enjoy. The acceptable use of scapegoating community members for the catharsis of the angry few ended 2000 years ago on Calvery.</p><p>It is time for this community to demand that the ongoing and barbarous campaign of trying to resurrect the practice of the scapegoat method of governance directed by Commissioner Bill Canda and <em>Sangre de Cristo</em> Publisher George Gramlich come to an end. For as we have seen these past years, there is no satisfying their desire for more goats to be sacrificed.</p><p>Jordan Hedberg</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8b0562af5e3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Survivorship Bias in Journalism and History]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/survivorship-bias-in-journalism-and-history-5649cc7509e5?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5649cc7509e5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-hedberg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[survivorship-bias]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[facts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Aug 2021 00:22:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-01T00:22:16.328Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I was talking to a friend and reader this past weekend over the phone and he brought up a point that I do not spend enough time on in the paper, and that is the problem of survivorship bias.</p><p>My friend had pointed out to me that one of my recent stories on the proposed sales tax increases to pay for a new justice center has come across as unbalanced. His point was that in small communities there are less people to pay for needed infrastructure and so taxes tend to be higher. By my stating it would be the third highest in the state, I was telling a fact, but perhaps it needed more context and history to be truly an honest and objective inquirery into the subject.</p><p>He was absolutely right of course; decisions are attached to the environment that an agent lives in. In simpler terms, our choices depend on the reality that we face here locally. Adding more context to a story like the sales tax issue will rarely be misplaced effort.</p><p>But this brings up a bigger problem in journalism when providing context on a story, a problem that I have never really seen mentioned in the journalism business; that is, explaining the “what ifs” that make up the context of an ongoing news event.</p><p>Known as more technically as Survivorship Bias, we humans tend to notice and pay attention to what happened instead of what did not happen. It is natural to pay attention to the things that happened and respond accordingly. But the modern world has forced humans to have to deal with situations where the valuable information is found in what did not happen. The problem is that we are not wired to automatically understand this point despite its importance in a complex world.</p><p>The most famous example of Survivorship Bias was documented during World War II when allied bomber planes suffered heavy losses during bombing raids across Germany. A group was assembled to try and figure out ways to modify the planes so that more survived. The group documented in detail the damage done to surviving planes that returned home. After they had enough data they suggested that the areas with the most documented damage be reenforced with armor. The statistician Abraham Wald went against the military’s suggestion and ordered the parts of the plane with the least amount of damage be reenforced with armor. His reasoning was simple yet counterintuitive, the planes that returned survived despite the damage documented. The planes that not return must have been hit in the areas least documented in the surviving planes.</p><p>The survivorship bias blinds us equally in many other parts of life were we only see those things, people, events, technologies, that have survived and fail to take into all those that did not.</p><p>This happens in history and journalism frequently. We place far to much credit and importance on what ended up happening and not what did not happen. When events take place, the results are rarely a forgone conclusion as they take place. Yet afterwards, the events seem obvious. The old saying hindsight is 20/20 comes in here. We do not work through the “what ifs” often enough when writing history or newspapers.</p><p>So back to the original point that started this look into Survivorship Bias. My friend was right in saying that I needed to compare tax rates in other small communities to see if they were higher than average due to a lack of population density to pay for need projects. The answer in Colorado is that sales and property taxes are generally higher in mountain towns, but overall population is not a good indicator of tax burdens. Eastern Colorado has low taxes and low populations. The difference seems to be the amount of tourism. The two highest sales tax cities are Silverton and Winter Park with other areas like Aspen, Crested Butte, Summit County, Vail, and Telluride all coming in high in both property and sales taxes.</p><p>But even here, it is important to not engage in naïve empiricism. Tourists play a factor as governments see it as a way for outsiders to help pay for the costs of infrastructure. But it is the mountainous terrain itself that also increases some costs of construction keep populations limit due to water and road access.</p><p>There are even further problems with the story I wrote using the logic above, there could have been more context on why so much money needs to be raised for the Justice Center. While the Tribune has tracked the Justice Center project for over five years, it is hard to get all that context into a new update on the subject. While the Justice Center Committee selected a large court and jail building to prepare for future growth in the county. The Tribune did not go into details on the other options that could be possible such as additions to both the jail and courthouse. I committed survivorship bias by only reporting on what ended up happening.</p><p>And this is the catch, my story was factual on everything that I reported, I even did some future consequences to the effects on the poor or problems from a recession with sales taxes. But I did not go backwards in time to fully bring into context the “what ifs.” The problem with the historian’s and journalist’s craft is that we focus on facts and take those facts at face value. It is considered to be objective and fair. But unlike physics where facts can lead to future predications (me dropping a pen will cause the pen to fall, a fact of gravity that does not require context) facts in journalism are tricky things. Context is everything and the process of exploring what ifs is often called opinions and biased journalism.</p><p>Journalism deals with both an uncertain past and often an uncertain future and trying to condense the complexity of the world into 800 words or less is problematic. But when faced with uncertainty, the solution to that uncertainty is obvious; precaution.</p><p>In journalism this means looking at a series of facts from many angles, to work hard on context, and to resist the urge to create a narrative that takes over the reporting. Just relying on the facts as they come does a disservice to both the readers and the subjects of a story. Survivorship bias is not easy to handle, but knowing the problem is a big part of the battle of what to do in the future.</p><p>-Jordan Hedberg</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5649cc7509e5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not Playing a Zero-Sum Game in Ranching: Chapter 2]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/not-playing-a-zero-sum-game-in-ranching-chapter-2-c1567b00369b?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1567b00369b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[farming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainable-ranching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cattle-ranching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antifragility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grassfed-beef]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jul 2021 00:11:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-22T00:11:16.153Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eeFO2cxrQ6Q-0bk4LmD_TA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The Problem With Grain Agriculture</strong></p><p>While I was still living in Denver, I started to act on my dream of becoming a farmer. My aunt lived nearby and had a large corner lot. I convinced her to let me put in a garden along with raising a few backyard chickens. There was a simple joy in planting a seed, adding water, and seeing it grow. Of course, there were all types of problems with the garden. I learned first-hand how many different insects love to eat brassicas, that a rabbit or squirrel can undo months of work in an evening. And that there is nothing you can do when a big hail flattens and strips a garden in 5 minutes.</p><p>I started to feel like I was battling nature to grow food. I set traps to kill mice, I was killing cutworms as quickly as I could, plus I tilled and killed parts of the lawn to make space for the plants I wanted to cultivate. There was a certain Puritan fatalism creeping into my mindset as I worked a tiny plot of soil and was rewarded only with pain. It was this pain that I was feeling about my garden that I could not understand. Growing my own food was supposed to give me feelings of accomplishment and inner peace, not a fatalistic pain.</p><p>My frustration with trying to grow even a few vegetables is nothing new. The history of agriculture is one based on battling nature to eke out a meager existence from the uncooperative soil. Anthropologists have suggested that humans turned to agriculture because as a species, we had hunted most of the earth’s megafauna, our preferred food source, to extinction. The cultivation of grains and tubers was a last-ditch effort by humans to avoid extinction. Looking back at my first attempts to garden as a guide, I have a problem with this theory as it fails to explain why only a small fraction of humans turned to farming, while the majority adapted to the lack of mega-fauna and remained hunter-gathers.</p><p>Agriculture is hard and fraught with a constant risk of famine if a crop fails. The first known city, Çatalhöyük, in modern Turkey, had periods of settlement followed by times of total abandonment. It is unlikely that every person in Çatalhöyük died, and then others settled the city later, which means that the residents had the ability to leave (or were captured) and survived outside the city. I speculate that those trying to grow grain got fed up with the constant frustration of grain agriculture. The life of the hunter-gather is a vacation by the standards of a grain farmer. Only around 20 hours per week are dedicated to food gathering by known hunter-gather tribes. Compare that to the constant work of a grain farmer through most of history; 70 to 100 hours during the year was dedicated to rice farming before mechanization. Even today, farmers either work constantly on the farm or must take other jobs to support the farm because of the low return on the crops grown.</p><p>There is another twist to the comparison of farmers to hunter-gathers that I never see mentioned in the anthropological literature; hunting and gathering is fun. We humans seem to be well suited for tribal life. The rush of excitement during a hunt or the joy of coming across a patch of edible mushrooms feels natural, even primal, to humans. Michael Pollen records tapping into these deep hunting and gathering instincts in his Book <em>The Omnivore’s Dilemma</em>. Pollen, a desk-bound modern man easily slips into a state of flow during his hunting and gathering trips in the mountains and hills of California. All thoughts of modern stresses slip away when one is looking for prey, or hunting for mushrooms. And the return to modern living after such an excursion is often a painful experience.</p><p>So why would some humans at the dawn of history decide that the natural thrills of our instincts should be traded for the suffering of agriculture? To me, the answer lies in power.</p><p>For the economist turned anthropologist James C. Scott, it is not possible to separate the power of the State from grain agriculture. Grain allowed for extreme inequality to form for the first time in human existence. Kings and their soldiers could take grain as a form of payment from those that were cultivating the land in return for protection from rival kingdoms. Grain was unique at the time because it could be stored for long periods of time compared to most other foods. This ability to store grain was good for saving food for the lean years, but more importantly, it allowed rulers to “tax” citizens on a store of value for the first time. Grain became the first currency of the state, and with that currency, came all the burdens a state places on the people growing the grain.</p><p>As humans tinkered with grain agriculture as both a storable food source and as a store of value, it is not surprising that Çatalhöyük was repeatedly abandoned as the reality and abuse of power in a grain state became obvious. As Scott chronicles repeatedly, for many people within the state’s control, leaving and joining surrounding tribes of hunter-gathers was always an option in early history. This option to leave frustrated rulers even as late as colonialism in the United States. Many of the founding fathers of the United States commented on the problem of men living on the frontier who, when captured or enslaved by native Americans, chose to stay with the natives when given the chance to return in prisoner exchanges. Sometimes, the captives would return to civilized life, and finding it oppressive compared to the hunter-gather lifestyle of native Americans, would return to the tribes and become members of that group.</p><p>Simply, grain-based agriculture is full of hardship and risk. Where the hunter-gather lifestyle is full of thrilling-danger and leisure. We are instinctually attracted to the later condition.</p><p><strong>Why Grain Agriculture?</strong></p><p>So, if humans so disdained early agriculture, why did it become the dominant form of human subsistence and why did humans repeatedly abandon agriculture in places like Çatalhöyük to only return to it later? I speculate that we humans crave a steady paycheck. Grain agriculture provided a steady food supply despite the toil (at least it gave the illusion of steadiness). At the beginning of grain-based farming, people mixed the growing of grains with traditional forms of hunting and gathering. These provided a much steadier stream of food compared to just hunting and gathering. As the state grew, it became more sophisticated and learned how to subtly control the population to keep them from running to the hills to avoid excessive taxation. In addition, civilizations learned how to battle or buy-off the pesky “barbarians” that roamed on the margins of agricultural civilization.</p><p>Regardless, the main reason agriculture succeeded was the feeling of a contestant and measurable form of food production. A steady, weekly paycheck is an addictive thing and I have gone much of my life with the desire to earn that “regular” paycheck. The question we rarely ask ourselves is, “at what price am I gaining consistency?”</p><p>The cost of consistency in modern agriculture is staggering, and it is all born out of a primal desire for steadiness of food. In the end, the exciting and superior, though dangerous, life of the hunter-gather was traded for a domesticated and (supposedly) predictable life of civilization; a civilization that was built on grain cultivation.</p><p>The problem with grain agriculture is that it is not consistent over the long-haul and it engages us, humans, in a war against nature, a war that in the end, we cannot possibly win. Over the years I have learned that it is better to work with nature than to try and blindly fight it when it comes to growing food.</p><p><strong>Nature is Not a Zero-Sum Game</strong></p><p>A zero-sum game is a game in which the success of one player, must come at the expense of the opposing player. In football, a touchdown is only gained at the expense of the other team’s failure to stop the offense and vice versa. But outside of the world of games, nature is not zero-sum.</p><p>Over the years I have observed that when we graze our cattle in a manner that mimics that of herds of bison that used to roam this region in thousands, overall biodiversity flourishes. Our fields are full of grasses, shrubs, trees, rabbits, mice, birds, turkeys, dear, elk, antelope fox, coyotes, squirrels, insects, earthworms, and many other species of life. Cattle, when managed properly, work themselves into the rhythms of nature. Compare the rotational grazing of our cattle using electric fences that mimics bison herds to the efforts of my first farming efforts growing a garden in Denver. Worse, when I attended College in rural Illinois, I watched as fields were tilled and left bare every winter, from horizon to horizon. Compared to the degradation of industrial agriculture, our cattle are part of nature, and managing them properly increases all types of life that live in a grass-based ecosystem (I will get into what “properly managed” later).</p><p>When I plant a garden and try to promote one type of crop at the expense of the rest of the surrounding ecosystem, I get engaged in a zero-sum game with nature. Even this past growing season, we had to trap and kill dozens of mice, rats, ground squires, and find ways to kill flea beetles, grasshoppers and keep out the deer, plus rabbits. Our garden is often at war with nature, locked in a zero-sum game; our livestock is not.</p><p>Nature, despite the naive recitations of “survival of the fittest,” is not zero-sum. This was proven by James Lovelock and Andrew Watson who demonstrated in a 1983 paper and computer simulation that self-interested organisms can collectively produce a stable and sustainable planet. Daisyworld is a hypothetical world orbiting a star whose radiant energy is slowly increasing over time. The planet is only populated with two lifeforms: black and white daisies. White petaled daisies reflect light, while black petaled daisies absorb light. The simulation tracks the two daisy populations and the surface temperature of Daisyworld as the sun’s rays grow more powerful. The surface temperature of Daisyworld remains almost constant over a broad range of solar outputs as the daises compete and find a balance that keeps the planet’s temperature consistent. The two types of daisies are engaged in a survival of the fittest, but in their struggle, they manage to create an ecosystem that is more sustainable than could be achieved if only a white or black daisy existed. The cooling and heating effect of each daisy finds a stable temperature that both can survive, even though the sun is constantly increasing in temperature. Even though both types of daises are technically competing, through their competition, they have reached a symbiotic relationship that ensures they both survive.</p><p>Daisyworld is simplistic, and our earth is vastly more complex, but the simple rule applies to all species that are fighting for survival. Take our cattle and the grass they eat. A naive observer would say that the cattle are causing the grass to go extinct because the cattle eat the grasses. But grass and large ruminants have created a symbiotic relationship. Grass grows blades-of-grass that are tasty to ruminants such as cattle. The cattle graze an area like a lawnmower over a yard, trimming the grass, composting it, and spreading the new fertilizer across the field. The hooves of the cattle also stir the ground, working in grass seeds for future sprouts, and trampling annuals, saplings, and bushes that would compete with the grass. The stress from grazing causes the grass to kill off some of its lower roots and use stored energy to send out runners to create new, connected grass plants. In short, large herds of ruminants and grasslands have created an ecosystem together.</p><p>Over time, the soils of these grasslands have become some of the most biologically active on earth. The deep soil of the American Midwest was created by the process of large herds grazing grass. This relationship created additional ecosystems of birds, predators, and aquatic life that evolved along with the symbiotic relationship grass had with ruminants.</p><p>Of course, I am simplifying here. The point is that natural processes often use competition between species to create a better ecosystem for all the species involved. While this idea of homeostasis is well understood by ecologists, one phenomenon is often left out of the discussion: Antifragility.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1567b00369b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/not-playing-a-zero-sum-game-in-ranching-chapter-2-c1567b00369b">Not Playing a Zero-Sum Game in Ranching: Chapter 2</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain">Learning Through Pain</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Ignorance of Killing a Coyote]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/the-ignorance-of-killing-a-coyote-78f44f37aafb?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78f44f37aafb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[grass-fed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mistakes-of-a-rancher]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ranching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coyote]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Jul 2021 02:25:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-18T03:25:33.596Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*--LNxjB9ZzAA85mZPzm0Qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An ally lost</figcaption></figure><p>One of the sure signs of spring are when the buzzards nest on the trees in town. They spread out their wings to catch the morning sun in an ominous embrace of the thawing bodies they intend to find. Death is one of those things that happens all winter long. And life on the farm here is not any different.</p><p>The first week of setting up new electric cattle fence is always an interesting one here. Spring is often considered the season of renewal but one of the things that I’ve learned over the years is that winter is the season of death. It was one singular death in the field as the snows melted away in the warm spring sun that caught my attention. It was the carcass of a coyote, white and grey fur still intact but the guts and eyes gone from the body. I knew that the coyote had been shot by my neighbor from the balcony of his mansion 75 yards to east. Despite the coyote being on property I rented; the neighbor had taken it on himself this past winter to kill the animal. The death of this coyote bothered me because it was done for no reason other than coyotes are meant to be killed by people that live in the western parts of the United States, particularly by bored retirees in mansions. This death was a disturbing one because it came from such a senseless place</p><p>There has been a strange tradition built around the idea of shooting coyotes in the American West. It was always assumed by ranchers in the area that coyotes would make off with the calves on a regular basis, but when I was talking to my grandparents that grew up on ranches in yampa Colorado they rarely reported coyotes actually killing any calves. Sheep were more vulnerable than calves. Of course, there might have been a time when coyotes did start to target the calves of ranchers and sheep ranchers that had moved into the area but it’s unlikely that they did it just because they want to do hunt and target the week calves and lambs. If there ever was really a time when coyotes started to target livestock it probably had something to do with the fact that ranchers in the area had been disrupting the ecosystem, by eradicating the preferred prey of coyotes such as mice and rabbits. It is a human habit to blame a creature without thinking through the steps we humans have made that brought a species into conflict with us.</p><p>Because I wasn’t raised in a traditional ranching family here in the Wet Mountain Valley of Colorado. I often don’t have a frame of reference to understand some of the habits and traditions that I see other ranchers in the area take part in. In many ways, our grassfed beef operation is so new, that we’re having to discover ranching one step at a time. The problem is that we are doing this discovery process without the benefit of all the wisdom that previous generations had learned. Over the past seven years I’ve gotten somewhat used to the fact that I don’t really know what’s going on either in traditional ranching or in the type of ranching that we practice here on the ranch. But this time the sight of that dead rotting coyote carcass in a field of lush green bothered me.</p><p>The person that shot the coyote, an otherwise friendly neighbor of ours, wasn’t even a rancher. He, like most of the people that live in the area, is a wealthy retired individual living in a mountain mansion after a successful life as a middle manager in corporate America, with a stint in the military. He has a nice tone of voice when he speaks with you and a friendly smile. You could picture him as an old farm boy in the Midwest when he was younger. Despite the friendly attitude of my neighbor, his act of killing the coyote triggered anger in me. Unlike previous generations of ranchers, I don’t view coyotes as a liability to our ranching operations. In fact, I view coyotes as an asset, one that helps keep in check the destructive rodents that till up and destroy our native grass fields. Coyotes, in other words, are vermin eradicators that don’t require a minimum wage.</p><p>I’m not the first person to consider coyotes as an asset to grassfed beef operation, the always engaging grassfed beef rancher Jim Gerrish in Idaho wrote in the Stockman grass grower about how he calculates the value of a coyote. In the short article, Gerrish highlights in a incredible amount of detail exactly the value of a coyote in regards to how many moles, voles, and pocket gophers a single coyote can eat in a day, week, and year. In the end, Gerrish estimates the value of coyotes that eat otherwise pasture destroying rodents to be in the 10s of thousands of dollars per decade. And unlike chemicals coyotes are a natural part of an ecosystem that do not carry any unintended side effects when they do what they evolved to do.</p><p>In my region of the United States we have what are known locally as pocket gophers. These little guys have the ability to churn up tons of soil in a short timeframe. This leaves whole sections of fields completely devoid of grass and can cause erosion if enough soil is tilled up. Coyotes are skilled at catching and killing pocket gophers. It is estimated that a single Coyote can kill and eat 10–30 mice and voles per day. And again, they do not even charge minimum wage.</p><p>I must be careful here not to demonize voles, mice, or pocket gophers. They are also a part of the ecosystem and have a role to play. I have noticed that many rodents tend to eat the plants we sometimes call weeds. Weeds are often annual plants that grow quickly in an effort to produce seeds. Left unchecked, annuals will take over an un-grazed or over-grazed field. From observation, rodents prefer these plants when they are young and tender. In addition, the pocket Gophers Dig long narrow tunnels that can cover an entire field. These long tunnels often reach some of the creeks that border my grass fields, and water flows through these channels, sub irrigating many of the areas that are far away from the creek. Let’s also not forget that pocket Gophers till while they dig their tunnels and this often brings organic material from the surface down to deeper areas increasing the hummus found in the soils.</p><p>So, what in the end did the dead coyote in my field represent? To me, it represented a lack of humility in the face of nature. To shoot a coyote for no other reason than a false narrative that coyotes are bad for cattle ranchers. Our ecological awareness has become so stunted in modernity that few can recognize the complex systems, with their many interdependencies, that surround all of us. To me, the coyote was an asset and it presented no danger to my heard of cattle. Even if it did represent a threat, can I honestly say that my farm is better off without the coyote in the ecosystem? In nature, it is not easy to make straight cost/benefit analyses.</p><p>Ecological ignorance is nothing new and it seems to be humanities birthright. One of the most extreme examples of ecological ignorance is that of Moa Zedong’s Four Pests Campaign that lasted from 1958 to 1962 in communist China. The concept was that a massive campaign to kill off mosquitos, flys, rats, and sparrows would increase grain harvests in China. This increased productivity would allow the dictator to sell the excess for foreign currency and use that currency to modernize and develop China’s industrial-military sector, plus help pay for a lavish lifestyle for the communist elite.</p><p>While it is understandable that the Chinese communist party wanted to get rid of rats, flys, and misquotes, why the focus on sparrows? Sparrows were seen as pests because they ate some of the grain right before harvest. The campaign to eliminate all the pests was successful beyond the hopes of Moa. Tens of millions of sparrows were killed. Worse, flys and mosquitos were also eliminated, for a short time, depriving the sparrows of their manly insect food source. The fact that sparrows ate huge amounts of insects, insects that liked to eat grain plants, had been completely ignored by the communist party in their mad dash for cash. With the sparrow population destroyed, insects had a huge advantage and their populations started to explode. Instead of a bumper crop of grain, famine gripped China during and after the four pests campaign as insects ravaged crops. As the mulitcapactivr risk expert Nassim Nicholas Taleb pointed out, “the sparrow had a small tax and ate some of the grain, but it earned its keep by eating insects that let the crops thrive in the first place.” China had to buy and import hundreds of thousands of sparrows to try and heal the damage.</p><p>The ecological ignorance cost the Chinese population dearly. An estimated 15 million to 55 million people died from the famine started by Mao. What happened to Mao? Judging by his portly photos, he remained well fed.</p><p>Yet this is not a judgment on people from an earlier era in a distant land. Americans in their push west could be better seen as a rolling tsunami of ecological devastation at a biblical scale. First, the bison herds were purged in an effort to starve the indian population. This led to a large buildup of prairie grass and an increase of locust swarms that spread east of the Mississippi, destroying crops and crippling agricultural production in the Ohio Valley region. Cattle from Texas were than used to graze the now abandoned Midwest. But these cattle were wild and not suited for the northern regions of the plains. Several freezes led to tens of millions of cattle dyeing in the winter. This led to butchers using anything they could call meat and selling it. This in turn poisoned hundreds of thousands of people and lead to the creation of the USDA.</p><p>I could go on about the cascading destruction that followed mankind’s expansion west, but to realize that we have not learned much from others about the complexity of nature, and how we harm ourselves when we meddle in nature, is the point of this essay, of this attempt.</p><p>The fact that an asset of my fields was killed by a boarded retired person is a fitting analogy for the disconnectedness of our society. To add salt to a wound, that neighbor, and his neighbor that leases us grazing ground, buys all their beef from Costco; which is a three and half hour round trip drive to Colorado Springs. Somehow, they have convinced themselves that our beef, that eats their grass, is not worthy of being eaten. It does not even cross their minds to buy beef from us. The ignorance and disconnectedness of these actions is often more than I can bare.</p><p>I often wonder if the buzzards are waiting to feed on us, as we collectively march-off one ecological and cultural cliff after another.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9sI5l9JLxONphhmy0eKJ_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The buzzards waiting for the dead to thaw</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Post Script: The Antifragility of Coyotes</strong></p><p>One of the ironic things about Coyotes is that the more that you try and kill them, the more they reproduce and spread. Once only found in southwest, the Coyote is now found in all of north America. Coyotes increase litter size as the population goes into decline. Also, the killing of wolves left conquest of the continent wide open to the Coyote.</p><p>I can only hope that more come and hunt my fields.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78f44f37aafb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/the-ignorance-of-killing-a-coyote-78f44f37aafb">The Ignorance of Killing a Coyote</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain">Learning Through Pain</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Politicians Need Privacy]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/politicians-need-privacy-e76055f0cd0?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e76055f0cd0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politicans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sunshine-laws]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Jan 2021 02:38:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-12T02:38:23.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Having more transparency in the political process is a good thing; right? As a culture here in Colorado, and in the United States, there is an ever-growing belief that the ills of the political process can be solved using the tools of the digital era. These tools of transparency consist of live streaming, online meetings, and digital recordings of all meetings. Even during my short time as a reporter for the Tribune, I have seen Custer County Commissioner meetings go from a few people listening to a meeting, with official minutes posted almost a month later, to hundreds of people logging into a Zoom meeting to take part and watch live every moment of a Board of County Commissioner and Board of Health Meetings. These meetings are then posted to Youtube so that every second can be watched and dissected by viewers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YDv4IehtoN7plqnyJtQvpw.png" /><figcaption>No elected representatives have privacy to make good policy</figcaption></figure><p>Custer County is not unique in live streaming government decisions, the push for transparency has infiltrated every part of the government with the exception of courtrooms (I will return to the wisdom of this later). There has never been a time in history where nearly every moment of an elected leader&#39;s decision-making process is recorded in such detail. All of this digital transparency has ushered in a new era of responsible governance where a majority of citizens overwhelming trust and respect the decisions of every level of government…Wishful thinking.</p><p>Mistrust of the government is as widespread as it has always been. A quick glance at the <em>Wet Mountain</em> <em>Tribune</em> from 1901 shows that the same types of arguments, the same circulation of political hogwash, the same politicization, mirrors that of today. All of the <em>Sunshine Laws</em> and other transparency efforts have done nothing to deal with the normal problem that arises from the political arena.</p><p>In fact, I am now going to argue that the massive transparency push has made political governance worse, not better.</p><p>The problem stems from a decrease in privacy in the modern era. Gossip between persons in a small community is natural and acts as a safety valve at a small, local scale. But with the advent of the printing press and newspapers, topics of gossip, which no human can resist, started to make it into print that had a far larger audience. The increased scale of gossip has caused lots of problems for several centuries now. If you glance at the Peaks of the Past section of this week’s <em>Tribune</em>, or any old paper, the meat of the newspaper was all of the gossip of who had traveled where, and who had suffered that, and so forth. Privacy is fading and the digital era has accelerated the destruction of our private lives.</p><p>It was the philosopher Umberto Eco that described the concept of the need for leaders to have privacy in the posthumous collection of essays <em>On the Shoulders of Giants, </em>a collection of oral presentations at the<em> Milanesiana </em>Festival in Milan. Eco argues that leaders need privacy to work out deals with adversaries, and the act of compromise means that some leaders will have to back-down from election promises to keep the peace. Without the ability for private discussions, leaders are forced to never back down from their political talking points because they will be viewed as traitors to the cause if they publicly reach compromise with political adversaries. Eco pointed out that if elected leaders cannot compromise, they cannot govern effectively and only the most radical diehards will end up winning elections. A bunch of political extremist leaders unwilling to compromise in order to never have to save face is an explosive recipe for disaster.</p><p>When I first read his argument, which was just a passing comment on his subject of <em>“Untruths, Lies, Falsifications,”</em> I was instantly jerked back to my first assignments covering the BOCC meeting in Custer County for the <em>Tribune</em>. At first, it was three commissioners holding public meetings in a small room where there was free (bad) coffee and nobody from the public. There was also no video or audio recordings. Those commissioners were replaced by three new commissioners that ran on a transparency platform and quickly set up video recording equipment for the meetings. A political upheaval and a recall soon followed that claimed two of the commissioner&#39;s jobs with just one barely surviving.</p><p>In hindsight, the difference between the first board of commissioners I reported on and the second, was the video camera. Commissioners&#39; meetings can get tense, as different elected individuals representing different districts and with different governing ideals clash when certain political events arise. This is natural and expected. Politics evolved in large measure so that differences between different groups could be settled without actual violence and bloodshed. Compromise and settled deals, however imperfect, are better than armed conflict.</p><p>Before the live-streaming camera showed up, the discussion on some subject would get heated, it was uncomfortable to sit in the room with three commissioners occasionally shouting at each other. But through the anger and tension, agreements were made, and the business of the county went forward, often not in an optimal fashion, but with agreement from all the elected representatives involved. As a reporter, I focused mostly on the vote, and a few words would go to the discussion that led-up to the vote. While the commissioners often disagreed with what I wrote, the end message that got to the reader was the result of the vote, not the ugliness that led-up to the vote.</p><p>In retrospect, that changed with the camera being brought into the room. The focus of my writing moved from the result of the discussion to the heated discussion itself. This was because I could watch the video endlessly and quote the discussion and emotions second by second. If I ever glossed over a particularly heated part of the discussion, a reader or competing publication would be sure to bring back into focus that “so-and-so said this horrible thing at minute five of the recorded video and he should resign!”</p><p>How can our elected representative leaders come to agreements when every second of their actions are criticized? We do not live in a direct democracy. We elect representatives to do their best in our interest, not to endlessly micro-manage every action and word they make. But that is what is happening.</p><p>Already I have heard commissioners say that they cannot take certain actions because it would be “political suicide.” Leaders that do not carefully watch every word they utter and speak from their convictions are tarred and feathered because it is easy to go back through the video and pull factual, but out of context, statements from the video. The hardest actions for a leader to take are the ones that are right, but take courage to execute. But it seems impossible for courageous actions to come from an endlessly heckled leader.</p><p>I have not seen any courageous actions from leaders from the local to the national level during the pandemic. And it is during trying times that we expect a leader, somewhere, to show courage and do the right thing. But I cannot see how any elected leader could ever step away from the wave of populism that got him or her elected when they know they will be called out as a traitor the second they are seen as moving away from the platform that got them elected. Political platforms are often wrong, and we would want leaders that have enough sense to do the correct thing when the situation demanded.</p><p>But that is a tall order in the 24/7 streaming “transparency” world we have created. Perhaps it is time to give our elected representatives a little privacy to do their jobs.</p><p>-Jordan Hedberg</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e76055f0cd0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Humanity Collided with the Problem of Induction]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/when-humanity-collided-with-the-problem-of-induction-5a4c97d42a62?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a4c97d42a62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[covid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[custer-county]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-of-induction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Dec 2020 01:43:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-30T01:43:26.112Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Originally published in the <em>Wet Mountain Tribune</em> on December 24, 2020</p><p>In the year 2020, humanity collided with the Problem of Induction. The question is, did we collectively learn anything from the pain caused by our crash? To answer that question, we have to first understand what we ran into, and then decide if the lessons learned can be applied to future problems.</p><p>The Problem of Induction can best be understood as the limits of evidence. Longtime readers of this column know that I often refer to the analogy of the Thanksgiving Turkey as described by the probabilist Nassim Nicholas Taleb. The parable goes as follows with a few slight modifications on my part:</p><p>For 1000 days a Turkey is fed every day by a friendly butcher. The Turkey has a staff of statisticians who use evidence-based models, charts, and computer models to show the Turkey that butchers love Turkeys. Each day that passes, the statistical confidence of the Turkey grows. Then, a week before Thanksgiving the butcher comes and cuts the Turkey’s head off.</p><p>There is a limit to what evidence can show us, but we often forget that fact in the moment. 2020 was a crash course in the limits of evidence. Just like the parable above, statistical experts failed to realize that looking for evidence with COVID-19 was not possible since the disease was new to humans. The timeline of events in 2020 speaks for itself and highlights the struggle leaders found during the spread of the COVID-19 virus.</p><p>In January the World Health Organization stated there was no evidence of person-to-person spread of the virus. A few weeks later, the World Health Organization again came out and said there was no evidence that stopping international flights would stop the spread of the virus. By early February the World Health Organization was saying there was no evidence that the virus was airborne. A few weeks later the Centers for Disease Control stated that there was no evidence that masks helped slow the spread of the virus. In late February the Colorado Department of Public Health sent the <em>Tribune</em> a press release stating that there was no risk to Colorado citizens from COVID-19. The <em>Tribune</em> refused to print any such press releases which earned the scorn of the then Custer County Public Health Director, with her sending a nasty email saying “I wish you would leave your opinion out of such things and that you would just print what the experts send you. You know, be a real journalist.” So far, 6,000 Coloradans have died since those original emails back in February stating that there was “no risk from to the people of Colorado.” This author’s grandfather is among those killed by COVID.</p><p>The common problem with all the above examples is that just because there is no evidence, does not mean something is not taking place. Probabilists often use the short phrase “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” Even now, the same problem continues to dog experts and common citizens alike. A new strain of the COVID-19 virus has been discovered in the United Kingdom and this version is much more contagious than the original COVID-19. The United States has decided not to block international flights from the United Kingdom, citing that “there is no evidence that it is any more deadly.” Planes land at Denver International Airport every single day from Europe, many transitioning through the United Kingdom. Just like the beginning of the outbreak, we are hoping that the new strain is not a problem. The evidence will come far too late for us to do much to stop the spread of a new virus.</p><p>At this point, we now have evidence that COVID-19 has a mortality of 1.8 percent with proper treatment. There is hope that the new vaccine will bring the pandemic to a close and we can return to a life where other humans are not kept at arm’s length. But again, this is all based on hope, not on any type of fact or evidence.</p><p>Locally, the problem with evidence continues to dog the conversation. People point to the fact that “there are no COVID deaths in Custer County,” implying that since there are no deaths, that the response to COVID was not needed. The question that should be asked is “what would the deaths be like if we had done nothing?” This question is never asked and is a struggle for most to grasp.</p><p>2020 is coming to an end, and many are hoping that 2021 will be pandemic-free. But do we know that? No. Are we sure the worst of the virus is over? No. And can we honestly say that doing nothing would have been better? No.</p><p>There is a lesson to be learned from this year, and that lesson is learning and exploring the limits of what evidence can show us in times of emergency. We take extreme precautions when a forest fire is raging because we have no real idea where the fire will burn or how fast it can grow. The same precautions we take towards forest fires are easily applied to pandemics. Precaution first, evidence second.</p><p>But I do not have a lot of faith this will happen. Our natural instinct to the pandemic seems to be evidence first, precaution second. That is not the lesson we need to walk away with as the year closes.</p><p>— Jordan Hedberg</p><p>Publisher</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a4c97d42a62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A moment off of the treadmill]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/a-moment-off-of-the-treadmill-17867fbb7231?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17867fbb7231</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Nov 2020 02:26:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-26T02:26:57.344Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Over the years I have learned to appreciate Thanksgiving over all the other holidays, and no it&#39;s not because of the food, because it asks a fundamental question we humans often forget to ask ourselves; what are we thankful for?</p><p>Philosophers since the dawn of history have consistently noted the dissatisfaction that permeates mankind and tried to hint at the source of this deep-seeded need for more. Why do we always want more?</p><p>One of my favorite parables is known as the paradox of progress. There are many versions of the story, but all follow the same line of thought. (This version is paraphrased from the great, and sadly late, David Graber in his magnificent book: <em>Debt: The First 5000 Years</em>)</p><p>A missionary was walking down the beach of an island paradise and he came across one of the native islanders sitting on the beach gazing upon the ocean. The missionary asked the native why he was just laying around on the beach doing nothing. The islander looked at the missionary and asked what he should be doing instead of sitting on the beach?</p><p>“Well,” said the missionary with an air of knowing experience, “there are a bunch of coconuts in the trees here, you could gather them up and sell them.”</p><p>“OK,” said the native, “and then what?”</p><p>“With the money, you can hire others and have them gather even more coconuts to sell.”</p><p>“OK,” said the native, “and then what?” “You can buy and plant more coconut trees and start an entire coconut plantation, with a processing plant to sell even more coconut products!”</p><p>“OK,” said the native, “and then what?”</p><p>“Well, then you would be a very wealthy man, and with that wealth, you could just lay around on a beach all day.”</p><p>We always want more, and we delude ourselves into thinking that once we get that little bit more, then we will be satisfied. But we are never satisfied for long, and we again feel the strong desire for more. But to what end?</p><p>There is no answer to the paradox of progress, but I would wager that our society has skewed heavily towards the belief that more of everything is the only path to fulfillment, and it is painful to us all still to still feel unfulfilled. I often find myself falling into the same trap of progress.</p><p>The concept of giving thanks allows us to get off of the treadmill of life for a moment if we so choose. The odds of any one of us even being alive on this earth is a probability of such small likelihood as to be a speck of dust next to the sun.</p><p>This Thanksgiving, I am going to take a moment to sit by a creek here in the mountains and take a step off the treadmill, even it is just a moment of thankfulness. Perhaps in that moment, I might find another moment off the treadmill of desire and progress, and perhaps another moment, followed by another, and another…</p><p>Have a blessed Thanksgiving.</p><p><em>— Jordan Hedberg</em></p><p><em>(Published in the Wet Mountain Tribune on November 26, 2020)</em></p><p><strong>Post-Sctipt:</strong></p><p>I in no way suggest that it is possible to get off the human treadmill for more than a moment. At some point, we need to accept and learn to channel our constant need to escape from our ultimate doom. Striving for more is how we humans cope with what we know to be our death. And from each one of our own selfish needs for more, we make more for those of us that follow.</p><p>I rarely hear anyone suggest that our inability to be personally satisfied is precisely why our species succeeds to the extent it does. Perhaps our own inability to secure happiness is why our offspring will thrive.</p><p>Just a thought.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17867fbb7231" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mistakes of a New Rancher]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/mistakes-of-a-new-rancher-59260c0f2ae9?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59260c0f2ae9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ranching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning-though-pain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-gray-philosopher]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nassim-taleb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rationality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Dec 2019 03:40:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-22T00:13:42.369Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Mistakes of a New Rancher: Chapter 1</h3><p>When I was working as a broker-in-training at a Charles Schwab call center, I would often stare out the window near my cubical. On clear days, I could see a massive snow-capped mountain in the distance. Staring at that mountain, I remembered that as a boy, I looked at the same peak but from the opposite horizon. As call after call was piped into my ear by a computer, I dreamed more and more of my childhood ranch located on the other side of that same snow-capped mountain. The thought of returning to the ranch gave me comfort during my self-imposed servitude.</p><p>Seven years later I am cradling a frozen calf in my cabin living room as the newborn cries out in pain, blood spirting from its nostrils and mouth. With tears on my face, the calf lets out one more cry as its lungs fill up with blood. For a moment the calf is still as it suffocates. Then, the death spasms consume the newborn and I squeeze the dead body hard to keep the corpse from trashing the rest of my living room. A minute later, all life has left its body. I carry it outside and lay the body in my frozen pickup truck. The calf’s mother bellows a long, desperate call.</p><p>This is what I had dreamed of in my cubical seven years earlier?</p><p>I had left the city to find relief. Freedom from the dullness that occupied my existence. The dream of returning to the land, of self-reliance, of living in nature, all seemed to be the solution to the closing box of urban reality.</p><p>The morning after the calf died, I drove my truck up the hill, and carried the frozen body into the woods. I placed it under a tree, next to the body of a calf that had died five days earlier. In my sorrow, all that I had done, and all I was doing, it all felt lost.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n9U354lmVxvw6rUwxx5RLg.jpeg" /><figcaption>1:30 a.m. Three hours before death</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Things Suffered, Things Learned</strong></h3><p>The death of two calves in November came from a series of mistakes that had started the previous February when the neighbor let out his bull, certain that it would not detect our herd of cattle a few miles away. Within hours I was using my body and a heavy iron rod to stop the bull mounting two young cows that I did not want pregnant. At just a year and a half, these heifers (female cattle that have not had calves before) would suffer from pregnancy at that young age. Nine months later, those two cows had two premature calves, and both died from problems with lungs being underdeveloped. I learned the lungs are one of the last organs to develop in mammals during pregnancy. Premature birth and lung issues go hand-in-hand in the human and bovine species.</p><p>It was the philosopher and doer Nassim Taleb that taught me about the Greek concept of Pathemata Mathemata, learning through pain, in his book <em>Skin in the Game. </em>The local veterinarian/cowboy Kit Riff has another term for the ancient Greek saying, calling it, “The school of hard knocks.” Both hit on a fact that learning almost always comes through pain.</p><p>This is counterintuitive. In the culture I was raised in, we believed that you could learn by studying books or in a classroom. Memorizing facts and taking tests is still considered “learning.”</p><p>While at Charles Schwab I spent evenings and weekends reading about farming and ranching. I read all the sustainable farming books I could find. Joel Salatin, Elliot Coleman, Allan Savory, Wendell Berry, and Allan Nation were my favorite farming authors. But while all these books are great, there was a warning in all of Joel Salatin’s book that advice could only go so far. The only way to learn how to farm, was to start farming.</p><p>With two dead calves, I was definitely learning how to farm through pain.</p><p>As I thought about the situation more, I realized that there was even more to learn. While it was easy for me to blame the neighbor letting out the bull, the only reason my cattle were nearby was because I lacked redundancy in my beef herd.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ij1ZwXvuOHaNsFUetbFgnQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hundred-year-old posts do not add redundancy</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Taming Randomness through Redundancy</strong></h3><p>The worst drought in the area’s history had prevented most grass from growing that summer. The lease I had the cattle grazing was a desperate move for the cattle to eat grass from two summers ago. I did not have the money to buy hay, and if I had had the money, hay prices had quadrupled from the year before.</p><p>In short, I lacked backup for unexpected dry periods. Hay the year before had been affordable. I could have had extra hay in the barn in anticipation for such eventualities (I live in an arid climate after all) but I had rushed the cattle purchase, eager to take action with my cattle herd.</p><p>In addition, the area the cattle were grazing had a hundred-year-old fence, which did nothing but slightly inconvenience the cattle as they pushed through the rusty and dull barbed wire fences. We had done our best to fix the fences, but it was a huge and mountainous area.</p><p>Again, Nassim Taleb has pointed out that redundancy in modern culture is considered inefficient. But becoming efficient causes fragility. Without enough savings in the bank, unexpected events can lead to our ruin. And as Taleb states, “Redundancy is ambiguous because it seems like a waste if nothing unusual happens. Except that something unusual happens — usually.”</p><blockquote>“Redundancy is ambiguous because it seems like a waste if nothing unusual happens. Except that something unusual happens — usually.” -Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Antifragile</blockquote><p>What I learned from two dead calves who’s frozen bodies now sat under a tree in the Colorado Wilderness, was that while the neighboring bull being let out was the precise cause of the deaths of my calves, the lack of redundancy was the overall cause of the sorrow that was flowing through my heart.</p><p>The bull was random, but we knew the cattle were not contained. Unwanted bulls getting into neighboring cattle herds is not uncommon in cattle country, and our fragility exposed us to this unusual, but not totally random, event. From the lack of extra hay in the barn to the pasture with an old fence, I created a fragile situation.</p><h3><strong>Only What Kills You</strong></h3><p>The calves dying was a particular low point in my fledgling ranching career. <em>“What was I doing” </em>kept running through my brain as I looked at the black calf lying in the white snow. I did not seem prepared. I still lacked enough redundancy, the stress of my life was taking a toll. This was not the relief I had dreamed of as a broker-to-be at Charles Schwab.</p><p>But strangely, I did not desire to try and go back to that more comfortable life. While in that moment my suffering was great, one thing I had come to notice was that relief is not something humans can or want to obtain. Total relaxation for long periods of time does not seem to make us happy (assuming we even know what happiness is) and while ranching was not what I had thought it would be, I knew I was much more alive than I had ever been in the city.</p><p>The anti-enlightenment philosopher John Gray has an excerpt in his book <em>The Silence of Animals: On Progress and Other Modern Myths, </em>I have come to turn to when I start to yearn for happiness. <em>“Human beings are more likely to find ways of living well if they do not spend their lives aiming to be happy. This is not to say we should pursue happiness indirectly — an idea also inherited from Aristotle. Rather, we are best off not looking for happiness at all. Looking for happiness is like having lived your life before it is over. You know everything important in advance: what you want, who you are. Why saddle yourself with the burden of being a character in such a dull tale? Better make up your life as you go along, and not be too attached to the stories you tell yourself on the way.”</em></p><p>I made a mistake turning to farming to find happiness, but that is a mistake I am glad to have made as my connection to reality grows each day, with each mistake.</p><p>While I have made many mistakes, I have not made any mistakes that have killed me or threatened my entire farm. Dying calves is heartbreaking, but it hardly threatens my existence as a rancher. It is only what kills you, that keeps you from learning from pain.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uh1_t92GUb5kdvDusutcqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>I left a career in finance to move into an unheated and unplugged trailer and learned how to ranch</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>The only definition of rationality</strong></h3><p>Strangely, this discussion of learning from pain brings us to how to define rationality. I have done, according to the conventional metrics, many irrational things in my life. Leaving a career in finance, moving into a 29-foot trailer in the mountains, ranching, and many other crazy actions have brought me to a point where I can look back and realize that none of those actions would have killed or ruined me.</p><p>I did not have money, but that also means I did not have anything to lose except time. There is nothing I have done, or could do, that would blow me up from a ranching or business perspective. Being poor comes with a freedom to take on trial and error with limited losses to property or life.</p><p>So the mistakes I have made are information. Valuable information. Knowing what <em>not</em> to do, is the true definition of knowledge.</p><p>This brings us to the last point, again made by Taleb. “<em>Rationality… is only what aids survival and avoids ruin. Rationality is risk management, period.”</em></p><p>For this rancher, learning through pain is part of being rancher. It is part of the adventure of life. And no adventure is truely thrilling without risk, pain, and struggles. Otherwise, it would just be a walk in the park.</p><p>There are many lessons still to learn. But as long as actions to not lead to ruin or death than mistakes should be treated as painful and valuable information. In fact, it is important to take and learn from as many small risks as possible. I have to remind myself that while these calves died, the lessons I have learned, will keep others from sharing the same fate.</p><p>It would not be important if it was not painful.</p><blockquote>For the robust, an error is information; for the fragile, an error is an error. — Nassim Nicholas Taleb The Bed of Procrustes: Philosophical and Practical Aphorisms</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59260c0f2ae9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain/mistakes-of-a-new-rancher-59260c0f2ae9">Mistakes of a New Rancher</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/learning-through-pain">Learning Through Pain</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Letter to Stewart Band about Mariana Mazzucato (Sent 2014)]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/letter-to-stewart-band-about-mariana-mazzucato-sent-2014-cfad08b0f65a?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cfad08b0f65a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stewart-brand]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nassim-taleb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-entrepreneurial-state]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mariana-mazzucato]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Oct 2019 17:10:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-30T17:13:04.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Letter to Stewart Brand about Mariana Mazzucato (Sent 2014)</h3><p>Dear Stewart Brand,</p><p>I have been deeply troubled by last nights presentation by Mariana Mazzucato. Your nice emailed summary of the talk pinpointed my uneasiness. In all of the talk about innovation, research, progress, private, public, returns, profits and investments, a fundamental long-term subject has been left out of the discussion. As is often with such discussions that are deeply ideological — basic and fundamental assumptions about the texture of reality are made without much regard. Where — in this discussion of progress — are the questions regarding risk?</p><p>It is not my intention to talk about investment risks, but rather the long-term risks to individuals, communities, nations, and humanity itself. In the political battle of private vs public both sides agree that “progress” is a universal good and the only dispute seems to stem from which side deserves more credit; public or state? Yet, no one seems to question at what cost is progress being made?</p><p>I can hardly disagree with Mazzucato that deep technological discoveries often stem from government spending (though I do believe that, Haug, Taleb, Scranton, Beaujoan and many others listed in Nassim Taleb’s Book <em>Anti-Fragile</em> would disagree that directed research was responsible for innovation and randomness played a larger role than Mazzucato would admit). If fact, the more I think about it, the more state sponsored technologies seem to come to my mind. Let me start with some of the more important “innovations” that the state has created in the past 100 years that I am forced to deal with daily.</p><p>100 million acres of land in the United states will be planted this spring with a single crop; corn. This massive undertaking of corn planting would not be possible without state sponsored technologies that date back to the 2nd year of World War I. Pesticides sprayed on those 100 million acres are a watered down grandchild of gas warfare deployed in the trenches during the war. Although the Germans were the first to successfully deploy chemical weapons the British were quick to catch up and the United States brought the technology home after fighting to kill bugs (rather than humans).</p><p>Of course, chemical pesticides might not have been very efficient if not for another tech that evolved in the trenches; mechanization. Tanks were designed to wade through mud, trenches, gas, and bullets to kill enemy soldiers. Chemical fertilization also came from the war where the Germans figured out how to create artificial ammonia-nitrogen to keep the armies supplied with explosives. Once again, the “peace dividend” you mentioned in the talk was deployed as pesticides, tractors, and chemical fertilizers, and a new agricultural boom was born that 100 years latter would see the farm population in the United States drop to 500,000 and inspire such works as <em>Silent Spring</em> (not to mention the effects of surplus monocrops such as high-fructose corn syrup, heart disease, feedlots, pollution, and the Big Mac).</p><p>These are just two state sponsored techs that have wrecked huge amounts of environmental, human, and communal damage to the entire globe. So now the solution is to have the “state” invest in “green” solutions to save humanity from state sponsored innovations as suggested by Mazzucato? Also, if we are so eager for the state to take the financial gains of it’s innovations than the current anger at Monsanto should be directed at states rather than Monsanto; for it is only using technology the state created. Maybe a class action suit can be leveled against the government.</p><p>Hopefully you understand my train of thought without me having to write a book and give a talk to clarify my point. Here is the core of my argument: “<em>risks that individuals or the (small) private sector is not willing to take are too dangerous for society to bare</em>.”</p><p>I am a proud member of the Long Now Foundation and I am glad that you brought Mazzucato to speak, yet, blind faith in government innovation is not worth the risk for the long term survival of civilization. It is not even clear if we can survive nuclear technology in the next 100 years let alone the next 10,000. Let us not suffer from the survivorship bias.</p><p>Thank you for your work on this wonderful foundation.</p><p>Sincerely,</p><p>Jordan Hedberg</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cfad08b0f65a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Get Grass-Fed beef for $3.60 per Pound]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanhedberg.medium.com/get-grass-fed-beef-for-3-60-per-pound-4453f0be1c62?source=rss-e335b3c1d8fb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4453f0be1c62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[joehedberg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[starting-farmer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[carnivor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grass-fed-beef]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Hedberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jul 2019 01:53:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-15T01:53:49.962Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am giving up one of my little secrets that have helped me to build my cattle herd. For me, this is how I arbitrage the price of beef cattle ranchers get paid vs the price customers will pay for grass-fed beef. The profit I make is enough to make a profit that gets invested in my ranch. But more importantly, it generates cash-flow from cattle that is quick.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fWlMBK0KXf7EQgkhnhMG4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>I write this from Colorado, so what I have learned is based on my experience here. Each area will be different, but the same rules apply, but results will vary.</p><p>I am not worried about giving this information up, because much of it depends on building relationships with ranchers, butchers, and does not rest just on money. I have the connections and relationships in my community because I grew up here and have known most of these ranchers for decades. I trust them, they trust me. Most of my customers do not have the time or interest in developing the network this opportunity requires.</p><p><strong>Here is how it works</strong></p><p>Ranchers often have cows that they take to the sale barn and sell as “butcher cows” or “butcher bulls.” These are animals that did not get pregnant or got old or some other reason. They are affordable. I pay the market price in this area of Colorado which is $.60 per pound live weight of the animal. (Prices as of July 14, 2019.)</p><p>Now. This beef is nearly always 100% grass-fed beef. These cattle have been on pasture their whole lives, and beef ranchers NEVER feed corn to cattle that are just for breeding. Some exceptions depending on were you live; leftover ethanol corn, brewery grains, and other waste products. But in my area, and for most ranchers, butcher animals are never fed anything but grass forges.</p><p>Also, these cattle are not given chemicals or drugs because again, those things are expensive, and cattle on pasture are generally healthy.</p><p>The most amazing part of butcher animals is their taste. It&#39;s like aged wine, the older, the more flavorful. Of course, it&#39;s too tough for most steak cuts. But it makes great ground beef, and the tenderloins are out of this world.</p><p>There is a lot of room to talk about cuts from old animals. But the ground, tenderloin (filet) offal, and bones are all tasty and wonderful.</p><p><strong>The Opportunity</strong></p><p>I just took a butcher cow from a long time rancher friend, a man I trust and I know his beef is always on grass. I paid $810 (1350lbs @ $.60) for the animal. The butcher cost the same $810 (coincidence on what he charged for butchering). So I got $1620 into the animal, and will get about 450lbs of meat in the packages. So $3.60 a pound for premier, top-of-the-line grass-fed you cannot get at any store. And those tenderloin roasts, well those are show stoppers at any event!</p><p><strong>The Rancher</strong></p><p>Ranchers do not like strangers, but they like NOT losing money even more. If you offer market price (contact the sale barn ranchers use and ask about the last average price for butcher cattle). And to pay for the brand inspection, the rancher just got a 15–20% bump in his profit by you offering to pay for market price. The sale barn charges a commission on the sale of his animal, has to pay for a brand inspection, transportation, and time to the sale barn. All of this adds up. You offer to pay market and brand, well you just made his day. You can offer an additional $.05 cents per live weight pound if he hauls it to a butcher of your choosing.</p><p><strong>The Butcher</strong></p><p>The butcher will make or break the taste of your meat. Call ranchers, small community members, google-search butchers. The smaller, the better flavor and care they will put into your cow. Make sure you direct them to keep the offal. To keep the full tenderloin roast. And give you soup bones.</p><p>MOST IMPORTANT! Direct the butcher to only hang for 7 days or lessm(they will know that these means) and to cut out the gland-meat out. So much of ground beef flavor comes from what the butcher throws into the ground. Nearly all the off flavors or gammy-ness comes from the butcher grinding the drying outside meat and gland meat into the ground. Corn-fed beef masks butchers being lazy and grinding everything. My butcher’s heuristic is “If I would not eat it, I do not grind it.”</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>What I just laid out is how to get awesome grass-fed beef for $3.60 a pound. But as you can see, it takes time, connections, and some risk, especially in the butcher department. Its why I do not care about giving up this info.</p><p>The average consumer is not going to take these risks, or learn these lessons. But a few will, and that isgood for the consumer and the rancher, and the small butcher.</p><p>But anyone that wants to get into farming or ranching, this is a great way to generate cash flow and customers as you build your new farm. And the ag community (that raises cattle) will welcome you as one of their own. Nothing breeds acceptance like a good commercial transaction that is good for both parties.</p><p>You will learn, you will make mistakes. But its the only way to learn and get better beef.</p><p><em>-Joe Hedberg</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4453f0be1c62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>