<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jordan Lei on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jordan Lei on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jordanlei?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 18:09:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jordanlei/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Learning New Concepts with ChatGPT]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/geekculture/learning-new-concepts-with-chatgpt-fda95c4f9eda?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fda95c4f9eda</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chatgpt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[studying]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jan 2023 04:01:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-04T04:01:45.521Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UOzMx5X-618BgocstCaBQw.png" /><figcaption>Image by <a href="https://openai.com/dall-e-2/">DALL-E 2</a>, an image generation AI</figcaption></figure><h4>Pairing Artificial Intelligence with the Feynman Technique</h4><p>Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have led to some pretty incredible breakthroughs, from being able to generate life-like images to being able to write human-like text from a simple prompt. <a href="https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt/">ChatGPT</a> is one of these ground-breaking innovations, a <a href="https://chat.openai.com/chat">chat bot</a> that is able to mimic human dialogue in a conversation. Within a few days of its release, the internet was abuzz with <a href="https://twitter.com/bentossell/status/1598269692082151424">screenshots of conversations with ChatGPT</a>. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2022/12/28/chatbot-cheating-ai-chatbotgpt-teachers/">Teachers worried that students would use it to cheat</a>. <a href="https://www.techradar.com/news/in-the-wake-of-chatgpt-google-is-worried-its-behind-the-times">Headlines declared that it would soon replace Google.</a> I began to wonder: how could I use ChatGPT to gain a deeper understanding of a concept I was unfamiliar with? And if so, what method would work best? Cue the Feynman Technique.</p><h3>What is the Feynman Technique?</h3><p>Developed by renowned physicist Richard Feynman, the “Feynman Technique” for learning involves an <a href="https://www.colorado.edu/artssciences-advising/resource-library/life-skills/the-feynman-technique-in-academic-coaching">iterative process of studying, explaining, and simplification</a>. Simply put, the Feynman Technique involves the following steps:</p><ol><li>Pick a topic. Choose a topic you want to learn more about and try to understand some component of it</li><li>Explain the topic in simple terms. Teach this topic to another person or explain it in a way that a layperson would understand it.</li><li>Identify the gaps in your knowledge. As you explain the topic, identify places that you struggle to understand.</li><li>Review the concepts you didn’t understand and simplify them. Then rinse and repeat, using the newly synthesized knowledge.</li></ol><p>The Feynman Technique addresses a common fault in most approaches to learning — it’s often easier to <em>receive</em> information than it is to <em>convey</em> information. Asking to explain a concept in simple terms reveals the underlying gaps in knowledge in ways that highlighting words from a book or writing down notes from a lecture cannot. Furthermore, it is a targeted approach to learning — you can start with a broad concept from which you have a vague understanding and gradually narrow down until you get a more fine-grained grasp of the details. I like to think of it as carving a sculpture: first you begin with the overall shape, and then begin to refine the details, until eventually you are left with a fully-rendered form.</p><h3>The problems with building from the ground up</h3><p>When I learned about this topic, I was incredibly excited to try it out. But I quickly realized that using the Feynman Technique on a new concept also poses its own problems:</p><p>The first problem is what I like to call the <em>bootstrapping</em> problem. In learning a new concept, you are, by definition, a novice. That means that you’re probably not the best judge of how good you are at explaining a topic. Additionally, you might not catch whether something in your explanation is wrong, which can prevent you from understanding later concepts that build upon simpler foundational knowledge.</p><p>The second, related to the first, is the problem of <em>unknown unknowns</em>. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780123855220000056">As a novice, you’re faced with the problem of not knowing what you don’t know.</a>Even if your explanation is free from factual errors, it’s hard to know where the gaps in knowledge arise. For example, amateur guitar players might learn a few chords and think they know everything, while expert musicians know there is always more room to fine-tune one’s technique. This phenomenon can lead to early stopping and a false sense that you’ve finished your exploration, even though you’ve just scratched the surface.</p><p>The third problem is the problem of <em>direction</em>. Once you’ve uncovered your gaps in knowledge, you’re still left with which one to choose next. Experts in the field might know which directions are dead ends, but as a novice, you’re traveling blind. If you’re learning alone, this often means sifting through opaque language in a topic you don’t understand or needlessly going down rabbit-holes just to figure out the next step.</p><p>These three problems of <em>bootstrapping</em>, <em>unknown unknowns</em>, and <em>direction</em> are all easily addressed if you have someone with expertise as your counterpart in the Feynman Technique. Experts can give you feedback on your errors, help you identify your gaps in knowledge, and point you in the direction of interesting avenues of future inquiry. This version of guided learning brings out the best in the Feynman Technique and makes it a powerful tool for learning. Unfortunately, experts are often in short supply, and the Feynman Technique, for all its benefits, is a fairly one-sided exercise. The expert’s role as listener is basically to sit there and provide feedback on a topic they already know like the back of their hand. In the absence of a frequently available and extremely patient expert, however, we must turn to other solutions.</p><h3>ChatGPT as the counterpart</h3><p>That’s where ChatGPT comes in: the counterpart of your dreams. I’m sure I’m not the first person to think of combining the Feynman Technique and ChatGPT, but I’ve been surprised to find that there are surprisingly few resources online for how to approach this integration — and even fewer that describe <em>why</em> ChatGPT works as a counterpart and where it falls short. A quick search reveals a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zkr9h7obIXc&amp;ab_channel=DavideRadaelli">YouTube tutorial about using the technique to learn mathematics with an earlier language model (GPT3)</a> and a scan of late-stage Twitter yielded just <a href="https://twitter.com/WilliamsonMark/status/1599546715862093824">one post where the roles were reversed: ChatGPT as the active “explainer” and the participant as the passive listener</a>. Before we understand how ChatGPT can be used for the Feynman Technique, we need to understand <em>why</em> it makes sense to use it in this context.</p><p>First, ChatGPT has an extensive knowledge and expertise of a wide range of topics, making it a good candidate for free-form exploration of topics. While it occasionally makes factual errors, I’ve found from my own experience that it performs more than well enough to be a powerful tool for guided learning. Additionally, as a conversational agent, ChatGPT is a natural candidate for the Feynman Technique, which works best when there’s some form of interaction or feedback. Finally, its widespread availability as a <a href="https://chat.openai.com/chat/">free online tool</a> makes it a scalable and highly accessible technology for learning topics in-depth, beyond simple search queries.</p><h3>How to use ChatGPT for the Feynman Technique</h3><p>That brings me to the actual implementation — how do you actually use ChatGPT to learn with the Feynman Technique? The following section describes how I personally implemented the technique; it’s possible that there are many other ways to do this effectively, but this is what worked for me.</p><p>It’s important to note that it’s actually a bit awkward to begin using the Feynman Technique with ChatGPT. If you try to ask it to “try out the Feynman Technique on [topic]” you will typically end up being on the passive (listening) end of the dialogue as ChatGPT goes through a somewhat verbose description of what the Feynman Technique is and how it could be applied to your topic. Asking for a step-by-step walkthrough also results in the same failure mode.</p><p>Instead, I’ve found it helpful to start out with a simple question: “Can we hold a conversation where I try out the Feynman Technique and you listen and give critiques”?</p><p>Below are excerpts of my conversation with ChatGPT, where I try to learn more about the topic of snowflakes. I’ve edited a few sections for brevity and clarity.</p><blockquote>Me: Can we hold a conversation where I try out the Feynman Technique and you listen and give critiques</blockquote><blockquote>ChatGPT: Sure! I’d be happy to listen to you practice the Feynman Technique and provide critiques… [proceeds to describe the Feynman Technique] … Would you like to choose a topic to practice the Feynman Technique on now?</blockquote><blockquote>Me: Yes please. I have chosen the topic of Snowflakes and I will try to summarize in my own words. Are you ready?</blockquote><blockquote>ChatGPT: Yes, I’m ready! Go ahead and summarize the concept of snowflakes in your own words.</blockquote><blockquote>Me: Snowflakes are crystalline structures formed when the temperature outside is below freezing. Snowflakes often take on symmetrical patterns, often in the form of six-fold symmetry. How did I do? Could you ask me some questions to help me understand this further?</blockquote><blockquote>ChatGPT: Great! You have provided a good summary of the basic concept of snowflakes. Here are a few questions that might help you further understand and explain the concept: How do snowflakes form? What factors influence the shape and symmetry of snowflakes? How do the physical properties of snowflakes, such as their size, shape, and structure, affect their behavior? How do snowflakes contribute to the formation of snow and ice? Can all snowflakes be seen with the naked eye, or are some too small to be visible?<br>[provides brief context on how to use these questions in the Feynman Technique]</blockquote><blockquote>Me: [begins answering the questions above]. The size, shape, structure, and behavior of snowflakes vary — you know, to be honest, I’m not really sure what affects these things. Could you verify what I said is true, and help me out where I’m struggling?</blockquote><blockquote>ChatGPT: Yes, what you have explained is generally correct. Here are a few additional points that might help you further understand the concept of snowflakes…</blockquote><p>ChatGPT goes onto give more depth to each of the questions, and I ask for directed guidance on more questions that will deepen my knowledge of the topic. For example, later in the conversation I learn how the structure of snowflakes influences their ability to absorb and reflect light (those with a more complex / irregular structure scatter light in more directions, making them appear brighter). I won’t belabor the point. As the example above demonstrates, ChatGPT can be a powerful tool to learn new concepts in a directed way.</p><p>Of course, the method isn’t perfect. As mentioned before, integrating this technique with ChatGPT has common failure modes — setting the right framework for practicing the technique early on in the conversation seems to be important. I’ve also noticed that asking for increasingly specific feedback often results in somewhat repetitive responses (such as “give more specific examples in your explanation” even after examples are added). Importantly, when using ChatGPT — as in any language model — it’s necessary to consider its broader implications on the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/10/technology/ai-chat-bot-chatgpt.html">spread of fake news</a>, <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-12-08/chatgpt-open-ai-s-chatbot-is-spitting-out-biased-sexist-results">perpetuation of existing cultural biases</a>, and <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/joemckendrick/2022/12/21/who-ultimately-owns-content-generated-by-chatgpt-and-other-ai-platforms/?sh=3f3f013f5423">the ownership of intellectual property</a>. It’s hard for anyone, let alone a model of human conversation, to strike the proper balance of nuance when describing complex topics. While ChatGPT is a good place to begin your journey to mastery of a topic, it’s certainly not the end. Ultimately, the goal is to reach a level of well-earned confidence in a topic to be able to consult actual experts and peer-reviewed sources.</p><p>Despite its drawbacks, I’ve found that using ChatGPT to learn new concepts has been an eye-opening experience. It has taken a self-learning exercise that used to be awkward, due to the <em>bootstrapping</em>, <em>unknown unknowns</em>, and <em>direction</em> problems, and turned it into a fairly fun conversation. More importantly, I found the experience to be much more collaborative and active than my earlier interactions with ChatGPT, where I typically asked a few random questions before eventually getting bored. Here, I was finding myself more and more excited about learning, even for a concept as seemingly simple as “what is a snowflake”.</p><blockquote><em>In conclusion, using ChatGPT to learn new concepts has been a highly effective and enjoyable way for me to expand my knowledge and understanding. The interactive and collaborative nature of the conversation helps to keep me engaged and motivated, and the ability to ask questions and get immediate responses has been particularly useful in clarifying any misunderstandings and deepening my understanding of the material. Overall, I would highly recommend using ChatGPT as a tool for learning new concepts to anyone looking to improve their knowledge in a fun and interactive way.</em></blockquote><p>That last paragraph, by the way? Not my own — but you can probably guess the author. Happy 2023 everyone, here’s to a year full of learning.</p><p>Sources:</p><ol><li><a href="https://openai.com/dall-e-2/">https://openai.com/dall-e-2/</a></li><li><a href="https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt/">https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt/</a></li><li><a href="https://chat.openai.com/chat">https://chat.openai.com/chat</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/bentossell/status/1598269692082151424">https://twitter.com/bentossell/status/1598269692082151424</a></li><li><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2022/12/28/chatbot-cheating-ai-chatbotgpt-teachers/">https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2022/12/28/chatbot-cheating-ai-chatbotgpt-teachers/</a></li><li><a href="https://www.techradar.com/news/in-the-wake-of-chatgpt-google-is-worried-its-behind-the-times">https://www.techradar.com/news/in-the-wake-of-chatgpt-google-is-worried-its-behind-the-times</a></li><li><a href="https://www.colorado.edu/artssciences-advising/resource-library/life-skills/the-feynman-technique-in-academic-coaching">https://www.colorado.edu/artssciences-advising/resource-library/life-skills/the-feynman-technique-in-academic-coaching</a></li><li><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780123855220000056">https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780123855220000056</a></li><li><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zkr9h7obIXc&amp;ab_channel=DavideRadaelli">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zkr9h7obIXc&amp;ab_channel=DavideRadaelli</a></li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/WilliamsonMark/status/1599546715862093824">https://twitter.com/WilliamsonMark/status/1599546715862093824</a></li><li><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/10/technology/ai-chat-bot-chatgpt.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/10/technology/ai-chat-bot-chatgpt.html</a></li><li><a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-12-08/chatgpt-open-ai-s-chatbot-is-spitting-out-biased-sexist-results">https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-12-08/chatgpt-open-ai-s-chatbot-is-spitting-out-biased-sexist-results</a></li><li><a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/joemckendrick/2022/12/21/who-ultimately-owns-content-generated-by-chatgpt-and-other-ai-platforms/?sh=3f3f013f5423">https://www.forbes.com/sites/joemckendrick/2022/12/21/who-ultimately-owns-content-generated-by-chatgpt-and-other-ai-platforms/?sh=3f3f013f5423</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fda95c4f9eda" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/geekculture/learning-new-concepts-with-chatgpt-fda95c4f9eda">Learning New Concepts with ChatGPT</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/geekculture">Geek Culture</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What the Canyon Knows That the River Does Not]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/what-the-canyon-knows-that-the-river-doesnt-2489e283c22c?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2489e283c22c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uncertainty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[perspective]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[modernity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Dec 2022 06:00:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-03T06:04:44.248Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mPal7goPyBWo-MNFBMvh5g.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/JEq_2UJoTtg">Photo by Jad Limcaco on Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>The Role of Patience in the Modern Age</h4><p>If you haven’t ever been to the Grand Canyon, just know that words cannot do it justice. Carved into the rugged plateau is a chasm of weathered rock, stripped back to reveal layers of ancient sediment, stacked one on top of the other like a wedding cake. Flanked by massive cliff faces, the Colorado River meanders gracefully en route to Lake Mead. As an observer of this natural wonder, you can’t help but be stunned to silence, the way you might lower your voice in a cathedral out of respect for a holy place. Embedded in the cliff face is a record of the history of the Earth itself, a chronicle of battles fought over spans of time that are incomprehensible to us. Even the trees bow their heads in reverence. Here, even the harshest cynics can catch a glimpse of a feeling commensurate to wonder. It is all the more surprising, then, that such an incomprehensibly vast structure could be built by the humblest of architects, the very same Colorado River that has been meandering on its merry way for the past several million years.</p><p>I have been thinking a lot about patience recently — the abstract concept, the skill, the virtue. Perhaps I’m alone in this, but growing up I felt that although patience is a virtue (cue the eye-rolls and sighs of despair), it’s a <em>boring one</em>. To be a champion for patience is akin to being a bit of a party-pooper. To be fair, on the surface level patience provides very little to recommend itself; the idea of delaying gratification for some indefinite reward in the future is not exactly inspiring, if you get my drift. And yet, very few noteworthy achievements were ever accomplished without a great deal of patience. I would like to make the case that in the modern age, patience is one of the most underrated virtues we have, and a tool that we can use to center ourselves in an uncertain world.</p><p>I think it’s a little funny how as individuals we systematically overestimate what we can accomplish in a weekend but systematically underestimate what we can accomplish in five years. In some ways, it’s even perhaps a little surprising — one might expect that we would be able to have more control over short-term factors than we do over long time horizons. And yet it’s long-term thinking that often makes all the difference. Recent research has shown time and time again that the willingness, ability, and commitment to thinking long-term can reap great dividends. Take the famous Stanford Marshmallow Test (and its later variants) — in these studies, children were presented with the option to either take an immediate reward or delay for an even greater reward [1]. Those who were able to delay their gratification were shown to have a wide range of better life outcomes, such as SAT scores and educational attainment. Or consider the now-famous 10,000 hours rule, inspired by the research of Herbert Simon, William Chase, K. Anders Ericsson, and others (and later popularized by Malcom Gladwell in <em>Outliers</em>) — the idea that it takes on average ten thousand hours to achieve mastery in many areas of expertise [2]. While the research around expertise is much more nuanced than the simple rule-of-thumb, the notion that expertise takes time and concerted effort is well-established. Finally, consider grit, a psychological concept championed by Angela Duckworth [3], which shows how perseverance and passion over long time horizons is a powerful force in achieving one’s goals. On one hand, the implications are somewhat sobering: there’s no shortcut to mastery. To be good at something — to be an expert, you have to put in the (often grueling, tiring, boring, not-so-fun) work. A bit of a bummer, if you ask me. And yet, there’s something hopeful about the idea that given enough time, it’s possible to be — if not an expert, at least proficient — in a wide range of skills. Hollywood loves to portray greatness as something that is <em>inherent</em> to a person; when we watch a biopic of a great individual, we see their greatest and worst moments played out on the big screen, concentrated into a story that is narratively compelling but ultimately reductive. We look at those who have achieved great success the same way we look at the Grand Canyon — what force would be powerful enough to create something as monumental as this? To stare upon vastness is to obliterate one’s conception of the mundane. And yet these exemplars of greatness often not only have humble beginnings, but humble middles and ends too. Mark my words, I am no great individual, but I have seen this play out in a much smaller way in my own life. It often crosses my mind how little I knew about any field the moment I stepped on campus when I was eighteen years old. And yet, after four years, just like everyone else, I graduated with a degree — and enough confidence in my own knowledge to pursue graduate school. It begs the question — what could I do in my next four years? Where did that confidence come from? Was it more like the sudden eureka moment, or was it more like the flow of water over rock? As the river flows, it is blissfully unaware of the progress its made — each passing cohort of water molecules makes essentially no difference to the unyielding rock. But the canyon, with its memories collected over millions of years, knows what the river does not.</p><p>I think I could do with more patience in my interpersonal life as well. I cringe when I count the number of times I wish I had been just a bit less rushed, just a bit more calm, just a bit more forgiving to those around me. Certainly, the version of myself I aspire to be would have all of those qualities, and more. In my own life, I have seen how in the fullness of time, my relationships with my family and friends have begun to deepen in meaningful ways. Coming from an immigrant background, I have had firsthand experience of how my family heritage, and in particular my parents, have shaped my brother and me. But it wasn’t until recently when I stopped to consider just how much my parents have changed because of us as well. Over the course of several years, our dinner table has been a place of healthy discussion and debate. The walls of our house have heard their fair share of disagreements, many of which resolved quickly, others not so much. But the one thing that has always been a commonality within our family was the trust that we would always be there for each other — in other words, the patience that we would come back to a point of understanding and mutual care. There was a point in time when I wouldn’t have thought it possible for us to say “I love you” on a regular basis. Now, my parents say it every time we say goodbye on the phone. We grow, we adapt, we hold onto each other. In spite of all our imperfections, with the patience and persistence to continue deepening our relationship as a family, we have grown closer than ever. The same is true for friendships and other interpersonal relationships; it’s often the case that those who we love the most are also those who we have been hurt by the most. To be clear, this is not meant to justify the pain of being hurt by those you love — indeed, there are many cases where a relationship becomes so toxic that the best course of action is to remove oneself entirely. Instead, what I’m trying to underscore is the idea that in relationships built on trust and patience, there’s an understanding that things might get rocky sometimes. Even in the face of pain, loss, or hurt, there is room for reconciliation and growth. Some of my strongest relationships stem from a place where I trust that regardless of the disagreements we have had in the past, or those we may have in the future, we will always find a way back to one another. In a world that offers sparse guarantees, this trust has been the closest thing I have found to faith. Love may take many forms, but one of the most important, for me at least, has been just showing up — for all its diversity and complexity, there is a kernel of simplicity in saying: <em>don’t worry, I’m here. I love you.</em></p><p>Patience also has implications on larger societal scales. In her iconic work <em>All About Love: New Visions</em>, bell hooks explores the connection between interpersonal love and the kind of love ethic advocated by those who enact social change. I think the same is true for patience. When we adopt a myopic worldview, the status quo is all that is and all that ever will be. Like a flat-earther roaming the world on the ground, the “flatness” of the world seems self-evident, even self-consistent. It’s only when you zoom out that you can see that the earth is indeed round, and that change is in fact possible. It’s so often the case that the impossible always that way until it is realized. It may be hard to remember that early in the Obama Presidency, gay marriage was such a highly contentious issue that it was largely avoided as an issue on the campaign trail. Less than a decade later, in 2015, the Supreme Court ruled that same-sex marriage was legal. On the surface, the support for the legalization of gay marriage seems like a groundswell that swept the nation over the course of a few years, but in reality it was the result of the repeated and unyielding effort of activists, organizers, and normal individuals who chipped away at existing systems of power for decades. Today, legalization of gay marriage is broadly supported by the public — a recent Pew Research poll finds that 61% of Americans expressed a positive view of legalizing same-sex marriage [4]. What was once thought to be an impossibility is now seen as the norm. Who knows what concepts we find distasteful but immovable as part of the status quo today will give way to new innovative solutions in the not-so-far (and not-so-imagined) future? Who is to say that social change might not happen across the globe at a pace we did not account for; change in large part due to the unrecognized but constant efforts of those who are working tirelessly behind the scenes? Too often social movements sputter out because we are not engaged enough to see them through to fruition. If we were slightly more patient with our expectations for the pace of progress, might it be possible that we would free ourselves to consider futures we formerly thought were impossible? In the modern age we are faced with endless examples of shifting social norms, attitudes, and practices. A stunning example is the shifting landscape in how we interface with technology. In 2000, the iPhone didn’t even exist; now, almost everyone has a mobile device in their pockets that they use on a daily basis. If you wanted to watch a YouTube video, you would have to wait another five years before the company was founded. 2000 was also the year that Google outpaced Yahoo as the dominant search engine. These staples of modern life, things we now see as inevitable, were in their infancy a mere two decades ago. And yet, despite the evidence that technology and social change are moving just as fast as ever, we seem even more determined to believe with a resigned helplessness that the trends that we observe today are those that will persist.</p><p>These technological shifts, instead of giving us encouragement that change is possible, have somehow exacerbated our preferences for short-term solutions over long-term gains. The speed of communication has given rise to increased demands to provide responsiveness and low-latency at the cost of more careful contemplation. At the risk of sounding old-man-yells-at-cloud about it, we have entered a race to the bottom where there is a considerable push towards speed, efficiency, and convenience. While there are certainly merits to the benefits that this technologically-forward future will give us, it’s worth considering the costs. I fear that in the midst of our high expectations, we run the very real risk of undermining our patience in other aspects of our lives that don’t follow the exponential growth of Moore’s Law. We are watching before our eyes the erosion of public trust in institutions [5], the politicization of expertise, and the refusal to accept the structural scaffolding of our democracy. In many of my own circles, interpersonal relationships have felt transactional — if not by choice, by circumstance, as people around me move from city to city in response to the rapidly changing demands of the modern economy. We spend less time with those we disagree with and we retreat to our echo chambers. Instead of being seen as an area for growth, healthy disagreement, and problem solving, conflict is now seen as a terminal diagnosis — why bother spending time with people who you disagree with when you can spend your time more comfortably with people you do? Better yet, why not spend your time alone? In a world that promised increased access, we have chosen to close ourselves in. When you build a house with glass walls, the first thing to do is buy some damn curtains.</p><p>I’m not arguing that patience alone will solve all of these problems. Quite the opposite — patience alone has very little to offer; but combined with persistence and a focused approach to change, developing patience creates a scaffolding for dealing with modern challenges. Nor am I arguing that patience is always a good thing — at its extreme, it can manifest in stubbornness, a dogmatic unwillingness to change, waiting for the sake of waiting. That kind of rigidity is infeasible in a world that continues to demand us to think on our feet. But patience and flexibility are not incompatible ideals. The willingness to stay one’s course and remain adaptable is possible, and the kind of foresight that allows us to envision a different future is the fuel which allows us to orient our efforts in the right direction. Instead, I worry about a society where we are so scatter-brained, so unwilling to deal with the uncanniness of delaying reward, that we accept the status quo as the default. That, too, is a form of rigidity, and it is one borne from learned helplessness. This kind of helplessness has a kind of twisted self-consistency; one that absolves its observer of confronting dissonance. If you live in a world that is fractured, why bother spending the time to plan ahead? Why bother cultivating practices of patience in a world — with organizations and systems so much bigger than you — that seems to be hell-bent on pushing you in the opposite direction? Learned helplessness, for all its faults, is resource-rational. F. Scott Fitzgerald captured the absurd futility of this effort in the last line of <em>The Great Gatsby</em>, “So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.” Why bother?</p><p>The truth is, I’m not really sure. I can’t argue with the self-consistency that learned helplessness provides in the short term. It’s a compelling narrative, but I hold onto the conviction that it is false. My belief, founded on the sparse observations in my own life and the seeds of research beginning to sprout in the field, is that a different kind of consistency may emerge on higher levels of abstraction. Just like it makes no sense how a river could create a canyon until you look a few million years forward. Just like the world looks flat at first until you take a few million steps back. The transition from one equilibrium to the other is not easy. Indeed, it requires a suspension of disbelief and an embrace of idiosyncratic behaviors that run counter to the myopic way of seeing the world. The idea that patience is a form of active resistance might be new to some; certainly it is a new concept to me. But it is one that I intend to cultivate more deeply over the coming years.</p><p>Personally, I plan on incorporating patience into my routine in the following ways. First, to exercise my capacity for persevering in the face of likely failure, I plan on embracing amateurism by starting new hobbies and deepening the ones I have already. In my own work, I have found that on the other side of <em>almost giving up</em> is a payoff that is rewarding in and of itself — even if it’s not the one I had initially anticipated. Second, my goal is to embrace uncertainty — the discomfort of not knowing what the future holds, something that my therapist reminds me of regularly but I often fail to do. My research is a good place to start with this — in research, outcomes are never certain, and grappling with new projects will help build my confidence in the face of an inherently stochastic future. Finally, I plan to deepen my interpersonal relationships. I would like to organize group events and build communities, even if that means the risk of getting hurt and seeing groups evolve, change, or even fall apart. Even if not every group is a success, I can remain open-minded to the possibility that over time, many of them will deepen into stronger relationships that may exceed my own expectations.</p><p>I have no guarantee that any of these things will work. I don’t even have a guarantee that erring on the side of patience is a good idea, despite the conviction that I <em>feel</em> when I think about the many ways it has served its purpose in my own life. Like a river finding its way, I’m sure I will face my fair share of setbacks, hurdles, and failures along the way. But maybe that’s okay. Maybe the most patient thing to do is acknowledge that I don’t need to know the answer right now, today, or ten years from now. Perhaps only time will tell.</p><p>[1]<a href="https://bingschool.stanford.edu/news/bing-marshmallow-studies-50-years-continuing-research">https://bingschool.stanford.edu/news/bing-marshmallow-studies-50-years-continuing-research</a><br>[2] <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/sports/sporting-scene/complexity-and-the-ten-thousand-hour-rule">https://www.newyorker.com/sports/sporting-scene/complexity-and-the-ten-thousand-hour-rule</a><br>[3] Duckworth, Angela. <em>Grit: The power of passion and perseverance</em>. Vol. 234. New York, NY: Scribner, 2016.<br>[4] <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/11/15/about-six-in-ten-americans-say-legalization-of-same-sex-marriage-is-good-for-society/">https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/11/15/about-six-in-ten-americans-say-legalization-of-same-sex-marriage-is-good-for-society/</a><br>[5] <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2019/04/11/public-trust-in-government-1958-2019/">https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2019/04/11/public-trust-in-government-1958-2019/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2489e283c22c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Fiction of Light]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/a-fiction-of-light-7da2a0fc8f65?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7da2a0fc8f65</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[short-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[perspective]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Apr 2022 20:21:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-29T20:21:37.838Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bZQYcl8_HOHHzT9zXZmQUg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Waves<em>, P</em>ainting by the Author</figcaption></figure><p>“I don’t think I’ve ever seen one like that before,” River says, stretching his arms skyward as if he is about to cast a spell on the horizon. His hands land with a soft thud on the picnic blanket, draped over the roof of our rental car. “It feels like I’m seeing the whole world for the first time.”</p><p>“A moment frozen in time” I echo. In front of us, the world slowly unravels in broad strokes of pastel pink and tendrils of orange. Bright streaks of violet cut across the sky, as if the heavens were being unzipped, the stars and galaxies above spilling open onto the quiet world below.</p><p>I sweep my hands on the soft surface of the earth toned fabric, my fingers trailing over muted browns and mossy greens until I find River’s hands. I brush my thumbs over his knuckles, tracing new patterns — new constellations. <em>How familiar these hands are now</em>, I think to myself, <em>and how strange it was at one point to be holding hands at all</em>. I remember it well, even though it’s been over a year since. <em>Dylan</em>, River whispered, looking into my eyes, <em>is this okay?</em> I liked the way he said my name, the way he rested on the first syllable as if he was considering what to say next. The way he did it again before we kissed in public for the first time. We walked around the local dog park that day, hands intertwined. It’s a funny thing, how little control we have over what moments eventually become memories. <em>All of a sudden, the world really does look different. </em>I point at a flock of small birds headed northward for the return of the summer. We watch the trees rustling in the wind, like reluctant dance partners trying to find their sense of rhythm. In front of us, the earth undulates in sweeping waves, out toward the edge of the lake.</p><p>“Pretty different from the big city, huh?” I say. I think about the sunsets back in New York, where the jungle of steel and glass shatters the light like the mirrors of a kaleidoscope, scattering shards of sky onto the sidewalks below. In the city, the air feels electric — people of all sorts going about their lives, hurriedly shuffling about. Try to stop to snap a photo of the sunset and you’ll almost certainly be elbowed by some Wall Street big-shot on his way to the subway station. And that’s on a <em>good day</em>. “Tell me about it,” he chuckles and rolls his eyes theatrically, taking a long breath of air and letting it out in an exaggerated sigh. In a few days we would both return to the rhythm of that colossal beast. I lean my head on his shoulder, staring up at his soft brown hair glinting red and gold under the light of the setting sun. In this light, River’s hazel-brown eyes take the color of amber. He hums a tune. My head moves with the breaths he takes, riding the waves of the pauses between his melody.</p><p>“Every time I hear that song, I think of you,” he whispers to me, ruffling my unruly hair. When I was a kid, my hair would get tangled into knots, and my mom would spend ages trying to straighten it out with a bristly comb I dubbed “the porcupine.” These same knots currently form a labyrinth for River to meander through and fidget with absentmindedly, a refuge from the oppressive order imposed on daily life. <em>So I heard this song and I thought of you</em>, River said a few months after we started dating. <em>Send it to me — I’ll listen to it tomorrow morning</em>, I replied, but ever the enthusiast, he insisted I listen to it right then on the phone. I remember the sound of the crackle of the phone as River played an unintentionally lo-fi rendition of the melody. To be honest, I wasn’t sure if I liked it or not on my first listen. Last year it ended up on my Spotify Wrapped most-played song of the year.</p><p>I hum along, trying to harmonize my <em>hmmm’s</em> with his <em>hmmm’</em>s but miserably failing every time. I never had a gift for music, and I doubt I ever would. He holds back a smirk. “Come <em>onnn</em>,” I say, breaking into a laugh. I shoot him a look. <em>I’m trying my best.</em> Then he starts giggling — and I don’t mean in a demure Victorian I-can’t-believe-she’s-showing-her-elbows kind of way. This hooligan starts giggling as if he caught a couple writing notes to each other in class in third grade. So we both start laughing until we fold like lawn chairs into each other’s arms, and I begin to think to myself that <em>there is nowhere else in the world I would rather be.</em></p><p>“This sweater looks good on you,” I say, holding onto him and playing with the hood. He tells me with a look of pride that he thrifted it junior year of undergrad and was surprised it wasn’t completely ruined with its years of use. That makes me feel old, which really isn’t the vibe I’m going for, so I make a snide remark about how we were both reaching the ripe-old-age of twenty three. “Isn’t it a <em>shame</em>”, he says, tilting his head in response, “how time is wasted on the <em>young</em>.” He squeezes me tighter, and I spread my palms on the fabric of his sweater. Under the warm hues of the sky, it appears almost a dark maroon or violet, the kind of color that a photograph can’t capture but a well-trained painter could. It wasn’t the first time he had worn it. It was just the first time I saw it like that.</p><p>We both go quiet as we watch the last hints of color vanish over the horizon, the rosy red lips of the sky pursing closed giving way to night. “Color is a fiction of light”, River breathes. I look at him, expectantly. “A quote… I think it’s from Tacita Dean,” he says. I think about how it’s a shame that he wants to be a lawyer. He could do so much more for the world as an author, or poet, or philosopher. An artist. He pauses for a moment, and then goes on: “I love that line because it challenges so much of how we see the world. Colors seem like such a fundamental part of life — it’s one of the first things we learn as kids. But it’s all made up, a bedtime story we tell ourselves. Even the same object can take on many colors depending on the light that’s available — like how the sky isn’t always blue, but sometimes red, orange, or all colors combined. The colors we see are a fiction told by the light. And even within the visible spectrum, we can only see a fraction of the light that exists. Our mind takes that and attributes meaning to it: blue for calm, red for anger, and so on. So really color is a fiction of the mind as much as it is a fiction of light.”</p><p>“That’s gorgeous,” I say, thinking to myself about what it would look like if we could break free of the chains of fiction — if we could see things as they were, instead of how they seemed. The world as we know it is built through the lens with which we see. So much of our understanding is painted by our visual experience. What would it look like if we could see beyond our narrow slice of light? What kind of art, literature, history would we have? “What would a poem about ultraviolet be like?” I asked abruptly.</p><p>River scratches his head. “I don’t know. Maybe someday we’ll find out.” Then he furrows his brow. “Doesn’t it strike you as a little bit sad, maybe? The fact that we’re constrained by our circumstance — the limitations of our mind’s narratives, to see the universe in a certain way. That so much of what we know is just a fiction of our minds?”</p><p>“I think it’s kind of beautiful in a way,” I counter. “The fact that we can take what little we have and move mountains with it. Sometimes I think about how we’re just some silly little apes running around playing god. And yet, I think about how much meaning we bring to the things we do, the way that we <em>care</em> for each other and build complex networks of things, with the little skills and tools that we have for understanding. I think we’re special because of the way that we choose to understand the vastness outside of our own narratives, that even if we try and fail over and over again we are not content with being indifferent to the world. It’s true that we’re confined by our own fictions, but the fact that we take those limitations and choose, despite the odds, to try and make something worth living for…”</p><p>He nods. I can tell he’s got something on his mind, but doesn’t know quite how to phrase it. River has this contemplative face, one where he tilts his head slightly and appears to look <em>through</em> you but not <em>past</em> you, as if he’s physically weighing your words in his mind. It’s a look I’ve gotten to know well over the past year. “What if most of what we know is just a trick of the light? What happens when the lights go out?”</p><p>I stiffen a little, feeling a gentle gust of cold wind pass by. Suddenly, I feel confronted with a universe that is so much bigger than I know. The stars hang above, twinkling as if they expect an answer. “I don’t know” I say softly. The night feels close, and I shudder a little. “Just because something is a trick of the light, doesn’t mean it’s any less real. You called it what — a fiction of the mind? The colors we see aren’t any less real than the things we know, the extent to which anything is real is, more or less, the extent to which our brain has fictions for them. And even when the lights go out, it doesn’t mean they’re gone forever. Those fictions shape the way we see the world, the way we build it in their absence.” I’m not totally convinced of my answer, but River seems satisfied and doesn’t pry for more. Sometimes I feel like we have entire conversations in the spaces between our words.</p><p>He pulls on a loose thread on the picnic blanket, twirling it around his finger. I imagine him pulling on that thread forever, until the entire blanket becomes one long string stretched up and down the shore. He holds my hand, but the warmth of the sunset has been replaced by the chill of the night. I think about how just moments before, we were in the car singing Disney songs at the top of our lungs, chasing the sun as it dipped low in the sky, painting the whole world a warm yellow glow like Midas in his final days of glory. I take a breath, trying to revive our conversation about color, light, and fiction. But for some reason, partly because I’m tired of skirting around the inevitable, partly because I’m prone to self-destructive behavior: “I take it you’re not staying in New York.” It feels like a rope has been released around my chest, and my ribcage relaxes as my heart thuds.</p><p>“I haven’t decided yet,” he says, looking away. “Let’s not talk about it now.” He raises his intonation towards the end as if he’s asking a question, the way he always does when he wants to change the subject. It’s his way of using his voice to stand up and walk out of the room, and he knows that I know it. <em>When will we talk about it, though?</em> I bite my tongue and convince myself it’s from the cold. I swat away a few mosquitos before curling up next to him. We fold the edges of the blanket over ourselves like a wonton wrapper, bringing ourselves close. We’ve relegated ourselves to another one of those silences where what is unspoken is so much louder than what is. After a while, River stretches his arm. For a second I’m afraid he’ll try to soothe me with some old cliche about how “everything will be alright” or “we’ll be just fine” or worst of all “everything happens for a reason”. Instead he uses the loose thread he was pulling on earlier to tickle my nose. <em>The absolute nerve of this guy</em>. I swat it away. He gives me a mock look of sadness, puppy eyes and all. And then this fool begins to sing — slowly, and softly. The opening lines of <em>I Want It That Way</em> by the Backstreet Boys. The song that <em>he knows</em> is my go-to karaoke song, to the extent that I could sing. The song that River — bless his <em>goddamn</em> heart — actually learned the harmony to so he could support me in my uncoordinated siren song. So anyway he’s singing now. And making the most ridiculous faces.</p><p>I’m not made of stone, and <em>I Want It That Way </em>is a certified bop, so I join in — reluctantly, and then all at once. Before long, it’s just the two of us, belting to the sky like dogs barking at the moon. I see the edges of his eyes crinkle into a smile, and I can’t help but do the same. He brings his face close to mine and I can feel his stubble run against my cheek. It’s a strange and beautiful thing to know how someone feels with you — to notice how their body and self fit next to yours. I can tell he’s smiling without even looking into his eyes. “Tell me why-yyy” we shout into the heavens, and I swear I can see the stars sparkle in their reply, amused at our mortal shenanigans. The moment the song is done we both exhale in unison and lie down to face the constellations. Our hands find each other and we hold tight, as if one of us might float away into the emptiness of space.</p><p>Color is a fiction of light. I think about the quote in my mind, letting it run like a tap in an overflowing sink. We are circumstantially confined by what we can know — the sunset has no notion of the day that has just passed, nor the night it leaves behind. It just <em>is</em>. And in that moment, we just are.</p><p>I don’t know it at the time, but barely six weeks after we sing at the top of our lungs to the universe asking for answers, <em>we</em> begin to fall apart, our relationship spilling over into abstracted swirls and loops. The next few weeks will be filled with their fair share of clementine hues, the soft kisses, lazy Sunday afternoons, and <em>I think every day about how lucky I am to be with you</em>. They’ll be filled with lilac tunes, soft jazz playing in the background as we cook evening meals together, chatting about how the world has gone to shit: <em>they don’t make them like they used to, do they, Dyl? </em>Pear-green shades of hikes in Hudson Valley, quiet walks near Battery Park, and <em>what do you want to do this evening? </em>Hints of mysterious mauve, the side-stepping around what’s really going on and <em>when are you going to decide if you’re staying in the city</em> and <em>have you decided where you want to go to law school? </em>The occasional yet increasingly prevalent crimson, the <em>why can’t you just lay it off for now</em>, the <em>now’s not a good time</em>, and <em>you always do this</em>, followed by an ultramarine <em>I feel like I’m not being heard</em> and <em>I know I’m hurting you and I don’t know how to fix it. </em>A soft, but hesitant splash of blue-gray: <em>are you even willing to try? </em>Finally, obsidian. <em>I think we should break up.</em></p><p><em>Yeah, me too.</em></p><p><em>I’m sorry.</em></p><p><em>Me too.</em></p><p>In the days and weeks after, I’ll forget the quote about color and fiction just like I forget myself, digging myself deeper into colors I feel with no vocabulary to express them. There’s the ever-present color of <em>if only.</em> If only I had said something different — if only <em>he had tried a little harder</em>, we could have made it work. If only I didn’t have to stay here for another few years, if only we had waited a few weeks to find out that <em>he wasn’t going so far away after all</em>, if only I could retrace my steps and find the right combination, the right code to unlock the right future, <em>if only</em>. I always imagine <em>if only</em> to be something like aquamarine, the shimmering kind that you see on children’s stickers that at one moment feels like it’s more blue than green and the next the other way around- a color that isn’t quite sure of her own beauty, a blend of possibility and melancholy. Then, of course there’s the <em>what if</em>. What if there’s a chance he still misses me? What if I never find anyone else who cares for me the same way again, who sees my insecurities and loves me not in spite of, but because of them? What if <em>I</em> can’t find a way to care for someone else again? <em>What if </em>alternates between a deep wine-like purple and a splendid golden ochre, a facade of regality and legitimacy. And of course moments of <em>memory</em>. The way the dill pickles in the canned foods aisle remind me of the way he used to say <em>“Dyl?”</em> when he couldn’t locate a missing sock. The way my hands grasp at the blankets in the middle of the night for comfort that isn’t there. The way he said <em>hey — is this okay? I want you to feel safe with me, always</em>. I reach for the space where his hands used to be. Memory takes all colors, but often it takes the color of old film and sepia tone. I’ll try to place these memories back into the moments from which they arose, but I will realize quickly they no longer fit. How could such an abundance of care be so quickly replaced by its absence? I will wonder if he’s as torn about the breakup as I am, and when I come to the conclusion that he doesn’t, I’ll be left wondering <em>why</em>.</p><p>Sometimes, when it’s bright outside, it takes my eyes time to acclimate to the light. When I close my eyes, I’m not left with pitch black as I would expect, but the negative image of what I saw before — everything I saw the moment before I closed my eyes preserved in a flash, with all the colors reversed. The negative image shifts and swirls, colors blending in illusory and impossible ways, before eventually settling back to the ether from which they came. The absence of color forms color, too. <em>Color is a fiction of light</em>. <em>Color is a fiction of the mind</em>.</p><p>That doesn’t mean it’s any less real. What it does mean, however, is that the finality with which we see the world is just as illusory, a fleeting band of sunset that is neither cognizant nor capable of understanding what comes before and after. Before we met, I couldn’t fathom the thought of walking hand in hand with someone I loved down the street. While we were together, I thought there was no other way it could be done. Once we fell apart, I wondered if it might never happen again. It’s funny how little control we have over what moments become memories, and what strangers become familiar. These may be fictions, but they are <em>ours</em>, to seek, to care for, to nurture. If we are lucky, we may find others who are willing to share their humble slice of light — so that in their presence we might share a story or a life, and in doing so face the mortifying possibility of being loved.</p><p>That night, as we pack up the blanket and stuff it into the trunk of the car, I have no idea what the future has in store. Before we buckle our seatbelts, I look into his hazel eyes, a purple brown hue reflecting the deep night sky. The way the dashboard light draws silver lines around the silhouette of his hands. Around us, the crickets sing their caramel tunes as the blanket of evening descends upon us. The street lamps bow their heads as we drive on, projecting cones of marigold onto the highway. We sit quietly as the lights streak by, stunned to silence by the fictions we cast.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7da2a0fc8f65" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Love Letter to Tomorrow]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/a-love-letter-to-tomorrow-df222e36ff31?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df222e36ff31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[asian-american]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Mar 2021 16:49:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-26T16:50:38.504Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jc-HdFYFBzO9P9s3rmsdvg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Enjoying hot pot with friends. Digital painting by the author.</figcaption></figure><h4><em>And Other Stories of My Asian American Upbringing</em></h4><p><em>Author’s Note: these stories I’m about to tell draw upon many complex and diverse topics — none of which I will be able to explore in full. This set of stories is but one in a tapestry of works among the diverse experiences of Asian Americans in the United States.</em></p><h3>Thanksgiving with Fried Rice</h3><p>It’s a cold winter day. After my family parks on the curbside, we carry our foil-covered dish to the door. <em>Happy Thanksgiving</em>,<em> come on inside!</em> We’re immediately flooded by the familiar smell of home-cooked Chinese food; the aromas fill the air, followed by the sounds of oil over sizzling heat and the familiar greetings of family friends. I scan the room, trying to take it all in at once. In one corner, a handful of adults laugh and chat over a game of poker. At the obligatory “kids table”, a handful of children sit and stare at their phones, absentmindedly tossing around some Mahjong pieces and arranging them like dominoes. The endless trays of food stacked together for the potluck resemble presents under a Christmas tree. That’s when I see it: in the middle of the kitchen island sits a beautiful Thanksgiving turkey, stuffed with sticky fried rice.</p><p>For many Asian Americans in my community, myself included, food has been a common love language. Perhaps that’s why this memory holds a special place in my mind, even after all those years. The feeling of community, of all of us huddled together in one house escaping from the cold winter air, sharing stories over a meal that was as idiosyncratic as our own experience; in a way, it felt like a singular representation of the crossroads where I so often found myself. Turkey stuffed with fried rice. <em>Where else could you find such a thing?</em></p><p>As a kid, I sometimes resented my identity for making me feel out-of-place. I wasn’t Chinese enough to confidently carry an identity around a past I had long forgotten; I could no longer read or write in my <em>mu yu </em>(母语), my “mother language”. At the same time, I wasn’t American enough to fit in with my classmates; I couldn’t relate to their pop-culture references, enthusiasm for local sports teams, or their taste for music. And it wasn’t for lack of trying. On the weekends, I would go to Chinese School, a Sunday school dedicated entirely to making sure I didn’t lose my grasp on my 母语; as you can probably guess, at ten years old I wasn’t entirely thrilled at the idea of spending a perfectly good weekend morning taking classes. At school and elsewhere, I tried my best to blend in, but I could never quite shake the idea that very few people in my school — the teachers, the students, <em>anyone</em> — looked like me. It didn’t help that one of my classmates once walked up to me and said “my Mom says we don’t like Chinese people.”</p><p>Whether I liked it or not, there was always a little bit of tension between the <em>Asian</em> and <em>American</em> parts of my identity. I’m not proud to admit it, but there were plenty of times when I was embarrassed of who I was. That shame wasn’t innate, it was learned through years of experience. I remember feeling embarrassed when my parents struggled to answer simple questions in English, or when they stumbled over their sentences as they tried to communicate to locals. I remember being embarrassed of the way my food smelled when I brought cold lunch to school or extracurricular events; if the mere appearance of the food I brought wasn’t enough to tip off others, the pungent smell of soy sauce was usually enough to garner a few side-glances or snide comments. I remember looking in the mirror and wondering what I would be like if I were white, and then feeling ashamed of even letting that thought enter my mind. <em>Will I ever be enough?</em></p><p>I’m still tackling some of the residual emotions today. At the same time, growing from these experiences has shaped my life in significant, sometimes unexpected, ways. I’m incredibly proud of my family’s story- the more I learn, the more I recognize the depth of the love and sacrifices they made to come here. My father is now in a managerial role where he leads a team with passion and dedication. My mother got a PhD in brain-computer-interfaces and is now working as a senior research scientist in machine learning for security. I aspire to have the tenacity, grit, and bravery that they embody on a daily basis. In my personal life, I have taken my family’s traditions with me. Those who know me well will know that I often have dumpling-making parties, where friends can gather at my apartment to make and (more importantly!) eat homemade dumplings. We’ve also done homemade hot-pot, a tradition from my family’s southern-Chinese roots. My friends and I would cook and chat for hours as we discussed topics ranging from the most recent midterms we’ve taken to current events and domestic politics. We’d often end our meals with a signature snack from the Asian supermarket. Over the past few years, I’ve come to redefine what it means to <em>fit in.</em></p><p>As immigrants, we hear this all the time: <em>why aren’t you doing more to fit in? Why don’t you just be more American?</em> To those people, being an American means one thing: being more like them. To those people, the vision of America is one of uniformity; a culture where you’re either all-in or all-out. But there’s another view of America, one that is aspirational rather than prescriptive. This could be an America with dumpling-making parties and turkey stuffed with fried rice, an America where we can gather around a table and reminisce about our pasts while dreaming about our futures, an America where no one has to wonder <em>am I enough?</em> If we have the courage to imagine that reality, one day we may be fortunate enough to see it realized.</p><h3>Goodnight, I Love You</h3><p>In traditional Chinese families, it’s uncommon for parents and their children to tell each other “I love you”. The direct translation, <em>wo ai ni </em>(我爱你)<em>, </em>is usually used between romantic lovers, and even then, it’s not used as commonly as it is in English. More generally, Chinese parents are often more reserved about displaying exaggerated outward emotions. This story is a familiar one, a confrontation of the traditional versus the novel, the familiar versus the foreign.</p><p>In my conversations with other children of first-generation Asian Americans, I’ve felt this tension play out in a variety of ways. In politics and activism, the older generation tends to be a bit more moderate and reserved, sometimes even hesitant. It’s easy, as the younger generation, to believe that the older generation is slow to adapt, that they’re holding onto their roots and unwilling to let go. In dynamic and uncertain times, that sense of tension gives way to urgency, as we begin to feel like the older generations are resisting the necessary changes needed to radically transform society towards a brighter future. In the midst of these discussions, it’s often easy to forget that our parents, many of whom weren’t much older than we are now, chose to leave the comforts of their own country and set foot into a completely unknown culture. These are risks that I wouldn’t dare to take myself, yet my parents took the leap in hopes that my brother and I would have a better future; a future that at the time was far from guaranteed.</p><p>In short, first-generation immigrant parents, <em>our parents</em>, have a much better track record of radical change than we give them credit for. Radical change whose rewards, as it’s often forgotten, would primarily fall on us, not them. Given the time, our parents may continue to surprise us with the lengths to which they are willing to adapt and change in the face of new information, new questions, and new understandings of the world that we live in.</p><p>Over the years, I’ve seen my parents evolve. In so many ways, they’ve blended these two cultures beautifully, taking inspiration from their own past in China and integrating it with their new experiences in the United States. Our home is a unique collage of cultural references, with paintings of scenes from Disney movies as well as traditional Chinese watercolors adorning the walls of our rooms. When the Olympics are on television, we watch intently, rooting for both the American and Chinese sports teams (double the fun, and many more victories to cheer for!). At the dinner table, we’ll often chat about domestic and international politics, discussing the diverse perspectives of Americans, Chinese natives, and Chinese immigrants; a kaleidoscope of interwoven viewpoints that has led to several thought-provoking discussions about our own place in it all. I’ve seen them adapt in the way they’ve raised my younger brother and myself, having moved away from the more traditional <em>tiger-mom</em> model of parenting towards a more growth-mindset approach.</p><p>Over the years, we’ve developed a few new traditions of our own. Every evening, my family huddles around a foosball table and plays a round-robin tournament until one of us inevitably ends up shouting loud enough to alert the neighbors. At night, before we head off to bed, we gather for “fruit time”, where we enjoy some fruit and occasionally kick back with a nice book to read for half an hour. And finally — this is my favorite one — we always end the night by saying I love you.</p><p>When I first began what has now become a nightly tradition, I simply said “I love you” without expecting a response. I knew that my parents loved me; they didn’t need to tell me that for it to be true. I could tell they loved me every time they picked me up to send me to swim practice, or when they woke up at 6 AM to drive two hours to a debate tournament. I could tell they loved me when I came home to an impeccably neat room with perfectly folded clothes (none of which was my doing). I could tell they loved me when, in the darkest of times, they would always be there, with a bowl of soup or a warm hug where I could choose to hold on and never let go. And so, when they began saying it back, I had already begun to let go of the intense symbolism with which I held that phrase. Those three words served not as an action of love, but as a reminder, of a story woven into my own identity. A story of sacrifice, of setting foot in the unknown, for an uncertain future. A story of hope, and loss, and love. A story that began thousands of miles away, and many years ago, across the vast ocean, from a place where I was born.</p><p>Every night, I hear waves from this ocean crash against the shore.</p><p><em>Goodnight, I love you.</em></p><h3>A Love Letter to Tomorrow</h3><p>It’s a warm, summer day in Dallas. I’m sitting with a group of friends, eating pho at a local Vietnamese restaurant, watching the shadows flicker through the windows, dancing on the carpet below. The restaurant is mostly empty, so the owner has a chance to strike up a conversation with us. We ask her about what brought her to Dallas, what motivated her to uproot herself from her native country and travel to America. She said something that has stuck with me ever since: <em>Ever since I was young, I was told that in America, you could find Heaven. Today, I’m still searching.</em></p><p>Her story is a hymn that rhymes with many other immigrants in the United States. In my native Chinese, the word for America, <em>mei guo </em>(美国), literally translates to <em>beautiful country</em>. For so many immigrants, the promise of America leaves a strong impression; for them, the city on a hill is not only a metaphorical ideal, but an aspirational goal for their own lives and those of their children (for Chinese Americans, where San Francisco was often the first point of contact, the city’s name 旧金山 literally translates to <em>old gold mountain</em>). The American Dream was ultimately a recognition of the <em>dignity of humanity</em>, driving faith in the ideas of opportunity, justice, and equality. For many, America is the Heaven they could see, a place where opportunity and hard work were paths to a better life. And, sadly, many are left searching.</p><p>I was reminded of how far we are from finding Heaven this week, when a hate crime was committed in a massage parlor in Atlanta, killing eight individuals, six of whom were Asian American. Racism in America is not new, and it takes many forms, as we’ve been reminded in the past year with startling frequency, from police brutality to the terrorist uprising on January 6th. I worry that the dialogue we are using to describe these acts of violence has become impoverished in its ability to evoke the humanness of these situations.</p><p>Whenever hate crimes are committed, I see people treating the perpetrators as monsters and the victims as martyrs. I understand where they’re coming from: when a terrorist commits a hate crime, we seek a narrative to latch onto. But when we play this game of angels and demons, we conveniently forget the humans involved; we ignore the underlying forces that could have motivated a human being to commit an atrocity of hate, and we ignore the human toll of the victims by portraying them as martyrs for a cause they didn’t volunteer to champion. Make no mistake: recognizing the humanity of the perpetrator doesn’t entail forgiveness; instead, it’s an urgent reminder that we, as humans, are capable of truly horrific acts of violence. We cannot ignore the centuries of violence, racism, and discrimination, often perpetuated by fellow citizens and bystanders, that serve as the backdrop for these acts of hate. When we paint the aggressors with broad-brush words like <em>monster</em> or <em>mentally-ill</em>, we are not doing a service to those who have passed away. Rather, we are using our language to sweep under the rug the uncomfortable reality of the conditions which we as a society have created to enable this violence to persist, a society where a human could believe in false narratives surrounding Asian Americans, or Black Americans, or anything but straight-white-male-Americans. We conveniently choose instead to distance ourselves from <em>those non-people</em>, <em>those monsters</em>, and then proceed to wash our hands of it.</p><p>In painting aggressors as monsters, we also subconsciously reduce victims to martyrs. It makes it easy for us to believe that the victims died to galvanize a cause, and to forget the complexity of the lives they lived. These weren’t perfect people; they were so much more than that: they were human people. Think about what you want to do most when the pandemic is over: maybe meet with your friends, see your children, attend the movies with those you love. They will never get to do that. Think about the things you’ve always wanted to do: places you’ve wanted to visit if you had the time, books you’ve wanted to read, the things you’ve wanted to say but haven’t yet had the chance to. They will never get to do that. Think about the things you’ve dreamed about, and watch all of those futures close abruptly, an ink-stained period ending in the middle of a story. These weren’t martyrs, they’re just like you. They lived their own lives until hate cut them short, stories that were rich and full of love, loss, happiness, embarrassment, and everything in between. You would’ve loved to meet them. But you can’t. <em>Do you understand?</em></p><p>Every time we come face to face with racism in America, we dehumanize the perpetrators and victims at our own risk. In failing to engage with the humanity of this violent act, we wipe our hands clean of the situation. Don’t worry, we say in the back of our minds, the matters of Heaven and Hell are beyond our grasp as mortals. We ignore the societal scaffolding that enables violence to take place, and in doing so, eliminate any chance that we have at addressing the root from which this insidious tree grows. Is it any surprise that a year after phrases like “the China Virus” and “the Kung Flu” took headlines by storm, something like this would happen? Is it any surprise that after years of spreading the idea that the country is being “taken over by immigrants,” that something like this would happen? Is it any surprise that after centuries of perpetuating the myth that Asians (especially Asian women) are submissive and weak, something like this would happen? How often are we willing to be surprised?</p><p>It’s a common misconception that criticism implies distaste. In the context of the immigrant experience, this is often manifested in the statement <em>if you hate this place so much, why don’t you go back where you came from? </em>In reality, those who care most deeply about a country will seek ways to make it better. Just as you would give advice to a friend or family member when you feel they have been led astray, an individual who truly cares about the country in which they reside will use activism as a tool to inspire others to dream of better futures within our grasp. America isn’t Heaven, and it may never be, but it can still yearn to the <em>human</em> goals and aspirations that we set forth. If you’ll repeat after me: <em>more perfect. </em>Our critiques of today are love letters to tomorrow.</p><p>The story of immigrants is an overwhelmingly human story, the story that F. Scott Fitzgerald alluded to in the Great Gatsby when he mentioned “boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the wind.” The current state of racism in America reminds us that we still have a long way to go. At this time, it is more important than ever to have the courage to imagine a better tomorrow, to seek with reckless optimism the reality that could be while also acknowledging the bitter realism of the reality that is. These two realities have always been present in the minds of every immigrant in this country. When I think of my identity as an Asian American and a POC in America, my heart swells with pride at the audacity of those who came before me, and those who will come after, who continue to press onward in the face of incredible odds. Those who, despite the odds, continue to write love letters to a tomorrow that remains tantalizingly out of reach.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df222e36ff31" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[(Human) Domain Expertise in the Age of Deep Learning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/human-domain-expertise-in-the-age-of-deep-learning-89b3381c5cba?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89b3381c5cba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[expertise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deep-learning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Sep 2020 15:39:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-27T19:53:19.024Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>It’s a burgeoning area of AI—but where is it headed?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*niahTCunozqou61vMV9FAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image from <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/person-holding-chess-piece-700971/">Jeswin Thomas, Pexels</a></figcaption></figure><p>It’s a bit of an understatement to say that Deep Learning has recently become a hot topic. Within a decade alone, the field has made significant strides on problems once thought to be impossible, including <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1077314219301183">facial recognition</a>, <a href="https://openai.com/blog/better-language-models/">generating text that mimics human writing</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/r?url=https%3A%2F%2Faiartists.org%2Fai-generated-art-tools">making art</a>, <a href="https://www.alphagomovie.com/">and playing games involving strategy and intuition</a>.</p><p>Given the buzz surrounding the (seemingly unreasonable) effectiveness of these algorithms, it’s easy to get lost in the extremes of speculation and skepticism towards Deep Learning. Instead, I’d like to focus on the following issues.</p><p>First, what is the role of human expertise in a world where Deep Learning is becoming more prevalent as a problem-solving tool? Second, where is the field of Deep Learning headed, and how can (human) expertise help move it forward?</p><p>As we will soon see, these two questions are intimately related. But first, let’s start with the basics.</p><h3>Deep vs. human learning</h3><p>To get a better scope of the picture, it helps to get a common understanding of what we mean when we refer to Deep Learning.</p><blockquote>Simply put, Deep Learning refers to a broad range of algorithms, very loosely inspired by the human brain.</blockquote><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_learning">These algorithms take the form of networks, known as Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), which iteratively improve as they encounter new examples</a>. It’s important to note that the kind of learning we refer to when we talk about Deep Learning is a very narrow subset of what we as humans might consider learning.</p><p>Human learning often involves the ability to explain, generalize, and even teach concepts that we have come to understand, all of which encompass different forms and levels of learning. It turns out that a lot of the questions surrounding these variants of learning are still open problems in Deep Learning, ones where domain expertise may play a large role.</p><h3>Explainability</h3><p>While Deep Learning algorithms outperform other machine learning methods at a wide variety of tasks, they are often notoriously difficult to interpret. Often, these networks are so complex that it’s difficult to know how they made their decisions. Like your pesky third-grade math teacher, we want these networks to “show their work”.</p><p><a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.14545">This problem of understanding how and why a network arrives at its decisions is known as <strong>explainability</strong></a>. <a href="https://towardsdatascience.com/an-overview-of-model-explainability-in-modern-machine-learning-fc0f22c8c29a">In machine learning literature, this term is often used in conjunction with concepts of <em>interpretability, understandability</em>, and <em>trust.</em></a><em> </em>Explainability is important because it gives us a better reason to trust that these algorithms are doing what we want, and enables us to troubleshoot them when problems arise.</p><p>It’s important to note that explainability isn’t a one-way street. In the vast majority of cases, you want to explain your decisions <em>to someone</em>. That’s where expertise comes in. Just as a doctor knows what information should be included in a medical report or diagram to reach a diagnosis, domain experts know what components are necessary to make sound decisions in their domains.</p><p>These experts are not simply peripheral consultants; they are necessary players in designing and implementing good problem-solving algorithms. Experts know what information is relevant and irrelevant to making a decision, and this domain expertise is incredibly valuable in constraining the kinds of algorithms that are worth considering. At the end of the day, it will be the experts who will be able to see if a decision is made correctly, and what steps need to be taken to fix it.</p><p>Without experts, we cannot design good algorithms, period. It’s telling that <a href="https://www.alphagomovie.com/">when DeepMind decided to develop AlphaGo to defeat one of the reigning world champions at the game of Go, they regularly consulted with Go experts to design their algorithm⁵.</a> This idea is so important it’s worth repeating again: domain expertise isn’t peripheral. It’s the whole damn picture.</p><h3>Generalization</h3><p>Another key aspect of learning is the ability to <a href="https://developers.google.com/machine-learning/crash-course/generalization/video-lecture">generalize. In the Machine Learning community, generalization refers to the ability to learn beyond just the examples you’ve already seen.</a> Any college undergrad knows how to brute-force memorize sections of the textbook, but how well do they really <em>know </em>the ideas they’ve crammed into their heads the night before? The test lies in the ability to answer questions that test similar, but slightly different information to the concepts they’ve studied.</p><p>It’s no different for Deep Neural Networks (incidentally, there are a lot of similarities that can be drawn between DNNs and college undergrads, particularly in terms of decision-making efficacy, but I’m writing a Medium article and not a novel so I’ll leave it at that).</p><p>There are two main kinds of generalization: generalization within distribution, and out-of-distribution. The first refers to examples where the examples you use to test your network are similar to the ones you used to train it. If I train a network on, say, thousands of pictures of apples, it should be able to identify new apple even if it hasn’t seen that specific image before. DNNs are actually fairly good at this.</p><p>But while DNNs require tens of thousands of examples to identify an apple, humans and other intelligent animals can learn after just a handful of examples. <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.05046">This is known as few-shot learning (sometimes used in relation to zero-shot or one-shot learning), referring to the ability to learn or generalize over just a few examples.</a></p><p>The second kind of generalization is out-of-distribution learning. Ever notice how your athletic friend seems to be good at not only running but also football and swimming? Or how the math whiz in your class is also great at physics and chemistry? That’s because those concepts, while distinct, are related. <a href="https://ruder.io/transfer-learning/">The ability to take one skill and apply it to another domain is known in Machine Learning circles as transfer learning.</a></p><p>Like few-shot learning, the idea of transfer learning centers around the idea that it shouldn’t take thousands of examples to learn concepts, especially if you’ve already learned a similar task before. Importantly, learning a new task shouldn’t require that you <em>unlearn</em> the old one.</p><p>Again, human expertise is necessary to understand how to approach the design of these algorithms as well. When you talk to experts, they often tie distinct examples together, while also describing their differences: “Playing guitar is <em>kind of like</em> playing piano, <em>except</em>…” This is exactly the kind of thing that transfer learning seeks to mimic. Seeking expert opinions is the key to understanding if transfer learning is effective across the domains it seeks to transfer to.</p><h3>Meta-learning</h3><p>A deep (pardon the pun) question in the Deep Learning community is how to develop algorithms not only to learn but to <em>learn how to learn</em>. This idea of learning how to learn is known as <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.05439">meta-learning</a>, a term just as confusing as it is mysterious.</p><p>The key behind meta-learning is this: often what separates an expert from a simpleton is the <em>way that they practice.</em> The best violinists in the world practice for hours on end, but they do so smartly — that’s what makes them the best. If we can develop effective algorithms that can practice <em>smarter</em>, then we can make significant strides towards more-intelligent agents. It’s not hard to see where the value of expertise comes here too. Different domains require different approaches toward a variety of definitions of success. To practice well as a pianist may look very different from practicing well as a swimmer, for example.</p><p>What “smart learning” looks like may vary from discipline to discipline, ultimately requiring the informed design with human experts at the lead.</p><h3>Looking forward</h3><p>As impressive as the accomplishments of Deep Learning are, it’s hard to imagine that any of these networks would have achieved their level of prowess without the experts that were consulted to design and structure them. Human experts, not AI agents, facilitated the curation of datasets, the design of reward functions, and the deployment of these algorithms. On top of that, it’s up to human experts to translate the outputs of these algorithms to decisions and insights in the real world. For now, humans are the agents.</p><p>In the future, as Deep Learning becomes more prevalent in industry applications, people outside the field will be faced with adapting their roles to accommodate these new and unfamiliar statistical tools. As domain experts, they can contribute meaningfully by considering the role they play in facilitating the ability to interpret, transfer, and teach these algorithms to learn and perform better within their domain of interest. They can interface with ML researchers and engineers by helping to narrow the search space of possible algorithms.</p><p>I like to think of the role of expertise as constraining the set of possible algorithms from <em>infinity </em>to<em> finite</em>, and the role of ML researchers as narrowing from <em>finite</em> to <em>a few</em>. I leave it as an exercise to the reader to determine which of the two is harder.</p><p>Human expertise isn’t dead, not by a long shot. In fact, in the age of Deep Learning, it may be more important than ever.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89b3381c5cba" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/human-domain-expertise-in-the-age-of-deep-learning-89b3381c5cba">(Human) Domain Expertise in the Age of Deep Learning</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Perfectionist’s Dilemma]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/the-perfectionists-dilemma-16743d768ae7?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16743d768ae7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[perfectionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2020 00:36:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-10T00:38:00.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7CXpH0I-BtncQT9oKSySvw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/902vnYeoWS4">Image by Christophe Hautier on Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>This article centers around the core idea of perfectionism — people who refuse to accept any standard or outcome short of perfection. <em>It’s important to note that perfectionism is a real, diagnosable psychological condition. </em>In this article, I talk about the more colloquial, non-clinical term of perfectionism as a loose term for people with (unreasonably) high standards for themselves and their work.</p><blockquote>The best is the enemy of the good.<br><em> — Voltaire</em></blockquote><h3>The Problem with Perfection</h3><p>Perfectionism is complicated. By setting high (and often unachievable) standards for themselves and those around them, perfectionists can challenge the status quo and push the boundaries of what is achievable. Perfectionism is often rewarded by masquerading as strong work-ethic and perseverance, all of which are indicators of success both in and out of the workplace. At the same time, there are major downsides to perfectionism¹ ² ³, many of which stem from the same source:</p><p><em>Perfectionism is exhausting.</em></p><p>While I don’t consider myself a full-blown perfectionist, I can certainly relate. There are evenings where I’ll stay up way later than necessary working on projects, even past the point of diminishing returns (sometimes I study for exams to the point where I start <em>unlearning</em> material, which leads to more frustration). I’ve found myself fretting over binary decisions which <em>both lead to good outcomes</em>, simply because I’m afraid the one I choose won’t be the best … and bombarding myself with counterfactuals after (if only I had chosen ___ instead, I would <em>truly </em>be happy). In the worst case, I’m hesitant to even <em>make</em> a choice out of fear of making a misstep, which often means I pass up the opportunity altogether (I guess I won’t apply to ___ unless if I’m totally ready to make that career step). It’s not hard to see how this kind of rumination would leave you exhausted after a while.</p><p>Perfectionists are no strangers to these scenarios, nor are they strangers to the consequences. There’s a treasure trove of articles showing that perfectionism can have negative impacts on both mental and physical health. While these articles do a good job of pointing out what perfectionists are doing wrong, they rarely hit at the root cause — it’s easy for die-hard perfectionists to dismiss their advice as being vague and inconclusive. What’s to stop perfectionists from having their cake and eating it too?</p><p>Turns out, the problem with striving for perfection isn’t a lack of effort (perfectionists put in too much effort as is). The key to why perfectionism is so incredibly exhausting lies in the most unlikely source — math.</p><h3>The Math Behind the Madness</h3><p>Let’s start with an example. You’re throwing a party for a large social event, full of guests you’re eager to impress, and you’ve been tasked with preparing the food. In a perfect world, you’d know exactly how many people would show up, and prepare exactly the right amount of portions — if you know 100 people will show up, you’ll prepare 100 portions. But the world isn’t perfect — it’s noisy. Sometimes more people show up, sometimes less.</p><p>More likely, the number of guests that show up will look something like a bell curve with 100 guests on average, subject to some variance (let’s say the standard deviation is 20). Well, shit. That’s not very helpful, is it? On a bad day you could have as few as 60 guests, and on a good day you could have up to 140 guests.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/411/1*4NhkolJ9eUFvdyE1me1PFg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/392/1*sA_pnsXIcq1ccLqTSMpsgA.png" /><figcaption>These two charts show two different views of the same phenomenon. The number of guests is 100 on average, but sometimes you’ll have more or fewer than you anticipate. In the first graph, Y = the probability that X guests show up. In the second graph, Y = the probability that X portions is enough to feed everybody.</figcaption></figure><p>Above, we have two charts. What do they mean? The first shows the distribution of guests — as predicted, it follows a bell-shaped curve (also known as a <em>normal</em> or <em>Gaussian</em> distribution), with the most likely outcome being that 100 guests arrive as planned. The second chart shows something different<em> — </em>it tells you, based on how many portions you prepare (on the x-axis), the probability that every guest will be fed (on the y-axis).</p><p>If you’re a lousy host, you might just prepare food according to the <em>average attendance</em>. In graph 2, it shows that 100 people in the x-axis corresponds with 0.5 on the y-axis (Fig.2, yellow). That means that half the time, everyone will be happily fed; the other half, at least one guest has to go hungry. Those aren’t great odds if you want to keep your guests happy.</p><p>Maybe you have reasonably high standards and you want to ensure that under 90% of circumstances not a single guest will go hungry (Fig. 2, green). In that case, you can see from our chart that you’ll need 126 portions; that extra 26 portions is like a “risk tax” that you pay to stay on the safe side, in case a few extra folks show up.</p><p>But what would a perfectionist do? For a perfectionist, 90% isn’t good enough — what about the other 10% of situations where a poor guest will be left hungry? No, that won’t do. A perfectionist needs to ensure that under 99% of circumstances not a single guest will go hungry (Fig. 2, red). You might expect that a few extra portions will cover the difference between 90% and 99%; after all, with 26 extra portions you’ve covered 40% of the risk. You might expect that 5 or 6 portions should cover the remaining 9% (if it were linear, that would be the case). But no. To be 99% sure that no one goes hungry, you’ll need a whopping 147 portions!</p><p>This is the math behind why perfectionism is so <em>exhausting</em>. It took only 26 portions to get from 50% to 90%, and it took another 21 to get from 90% to 99%! We like to think that the effort that we put into our work translates linearly to the reward, but in reality it doesn’t — each additional unit of effort leads to slightly less reward than the last. What’s worse, the cost of effort scales linearly — each additional guest requires preparing a new portion of food, a plate, utensils, and a seat at the table.</p><p>In short, perfectionism is wasteful<em>. </em>All those extra portions go into ensuring that no guest is left hungry, but for the vast majority of situations, there’ll be food left over. That wasted effort is precisely why perfectionism isn’t so perfect after all.</p><p>This simple example serves as a surprisingly useful framework for <em>how</em> one might go about dealing with perfectionism — it shows how an additional unit of effort translates to rewards and costs based on this bell-curve analysis. It also tells you <em>how much</em> you should scale up or down your standards — you should stop when the costs outweigh the benefits. And because of the Central Limit Theorem⁴ (roughly speaking, stating that distributions will tend towards a normal bell curve with repeated sampling), the framework is robust and generalizable to a wide variety of situations.</p><p>It also gives interesting insights into where perfectionists operate best. The amount of effort put into a task is related to the <em>standard deviation — </em>a measure of the uncertainty of outcomes<em>. </em>In settings where rules, expectations, and rewards are clearly defined, perfectionists prosper because of their ability to control the situation and set high standards. Performing on standardized tests and getting good grades may have come easy to perfectionists, who had clearly marked rules for how effort could lead to a reward. In situations where there’s a large level of ambiguity or uncertainty, however, perfectionists struggle. In those cases, the risk tax is higher. For example, choosing to leave a job or hop between industries might leave perfectionists in a constant state of unhappiness. Unfortunately, we deal with a world that’s noisy — now more than ever before, we are asked to anticipate and react to a dynamic and uncertain world.</p><h3>Practice Makes Imperfect</h3><p>The problem with perfectionism lies not in our lack of trying but rather the <em>fundamental constraints of statistics</em>. It’s a well understood problem in operations theory, where the so-called “last-mile” of fulfillment (think Amazon package delivery — the last mile refers to the distance from the warehouses to your specific address) is by far the costliest. While the example of throwing a party is obviously contrived, it’s not hard to generalize to other areas of our lives. Maybe instead of plates of food it’s hours of your precious time, or dollars spent on a project. Maybe instead of guests you’re trying to impress it’s your significant other or your boss (hopefully not at the same time). Whatever the case may be, the key to overcoming the dilemma of perfectionism is to understand how your effort translates to outcomes.</p><p>Will the extra hour you spend on this presentation <em>really </em>make all the difference? Will studying at 2AM the night before your exam <em>really </em>improve your grade all that much? Is losing a night of sleep <em>really</em> going to give you that promotion?</p><p>To be clear, I’m not suggesting that you lower <em>all your standards</em>, and I’m not even suggesting that you lower your standards by a lot. The key here is to minimize wasted effort; your effort should be distributed in a way that aligns with your own goals. Choose the things that matter to you and do them well; for the rest, recognize what you gain from living a lifestyle with less waste. As we saw in our example, a small reduction in standards (e.g. from 99% to 90%) can lead to a significant reduction in stress due to wasteful effort. Even a reduction from 99% to 98% will often save you way more than 1% of effort. Those savings can be better distributed elsewhere to move your career and life forward.</p><p>One possible solution, then, is to <em>purposefully </em>lower your standards on things that matter less in your life. Not a lot, not across the board, just a little. Go from 99% to 98%. The world won’t end if your clothes aren’t folded perfectly. Your friend will forgive you if you show up 5 minutes late. It’s okay to spend a little time for yourself every day. If the thing that is keeping you from setting out on your goals is the fear of not completing them to your standards, lower them slightly and jump in — you’ll often surprise yourself by the quality of work you can achieve without being burdened by the fear of failure.</p><p>There’s nothing fundamentally wrong with having high standards; the world needs people who uphold the highest standards of quality in their work. At the same time, pursuing a standard of perfection in every aspect of life isn’t only mentally taxing, it’s at best unsustainable and at worst impossible. The modern world calls for people who adapt well to changing and uncertain environments, a setting where the traditional perfectionist will likely fail.</p><p>The key to adaptive perfectionism lies in understanding how effort interfaces with outcomes, and how to divest and invest effort in places where it can be used optimally and with minimal waste. With this in mind, perfectionists will be able to thrive and make informed decisions in a variety of settings — and in doing so, bring ̶m̶o̶r̶e̶ just the right amount to the table.</p><p>[1] “Perfectionism.” <em>Psychology Today</em>, Sussex Publishers, <a href="http://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/perfectionism.">www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/perfectionism.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/perfectionism">Perfectionism</a></p><p>[2] Rettner, Rachael. “The Dark Side of Perfectionism Revealed.” <em>LiveScience</em>, Purch, 11 July 2010, <a href="http://www.livescience.com/6724-dark-side-perfectionism-revealed.html.">www.livescience.com/6724-dark-side-perfectionism-revealed.html.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.livescience.com/6724-dark-side-perfectionism-revealed.html">The Dark Side of Perfectionism Revealed</a></p><p>[3] Knight, Rebecca. “How to Manage Your Perfectionism.” <em>Harvard Business Review</em>, 26 Nov. 2019, hbr.org/2019/04/how-to-manage-your-perfectionism.</p><p><a href="https://hbr.org/2019/04/how-to-manage-your-perfectionism">How to Manage Your Perfectionism</a></p><p>[4] Ganti, Akhilesh. “What Is the Central Limit Theorem (CLT)?” <em>Investopedia</em>, Investopedia, 28 Aug. 2020, <a href="http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/central_limit_theorem.asp.">www.investopedia.com/terms/c/central_limit_theorem.asp.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/central_limit_theorem.asp">Central Limit Theorem (CLT): Definition and Key Characteristics</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16743d768ae7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Onward]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/onward-hourglass-ch-8-32008d3068f6?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32008d3068f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Sep 2020 06:51:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-04T06:52:04.266Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RxJOFpNnTEqWGvsnMKqwqA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/hXOGHaGCtdA">Image by Aron Van de Pol, Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>onward</h3><p>This is the final chapter in a series of pieces about our modern relationship with time and the future. Titled <em>Hourglass</em>, It’s an exploration into how our abstract view of time has changed in modernity, how it has met (or has yet to meet) the needs of the present, and what we can do to better prepare ourselves for what’s to come.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/hourglass-our-modern-relationship-with-time-ed9538a498ec">First Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/when-more-becomes-too-much-7a9c53836571">Previous Chapter</a> / End.</p><p>Things have changed a lot since the dawn of the Industrial Age. As we stepped into modernity, our very concept of time and the future changed. Throughout this series, we have seen how science, art, and technology have worked together to bring us into modernity. This current moment is a testament to our tenacity and the vast interconnectivity of the narratives that have brought us here.</p><p>The present moment isn’t perfect — it has its deals of challenges, many of which we are either facing today or will face in the near future. But then again, the present was never perfect, and likely never will be. Contrary to what it might seem, I’m not a pessimist about the future; what fool would spend eight chapters to write about the inevitable? No, no. Quite the contrary. To dismiss our current problems as unsolvable is the only way to ensure that it’s true, and equally dangerous is to forge ahead without thinking first about the consequences of our actions.</p><p>Every point in time is marked by its own struggles. The struggles we face today and tomorrow will someday give way to a new set of challenges, ones which we will be forced to face. This is the nature of progress, I daresay the nature of existence. Our time on this planet will either be marked by these challenges, or, should we choose to face them, marked by our solutions to them. While I have no better idea than any other person what lies ahead, I have a few pretty good guesses about what tools we’ll need to carry forward. And it’s with these tools that I’d like to begin the ending of our journey.</p><h3>For Us</h3><p>The future is, and has always been, a collective effort. Our ability to face challenges lies in our collective ability to roll up our sleeves and get shit done. Here are a few things that we need to do, and do well:</p><ol><li><strong>Better Forecasting. </strong>In chapter 3 we talked about the invention of the weather forecast and how systematic, data-driven forecasting revolutionized our ability to foresee the weather. We talked about how superforecasters used evidence-based techniques to hone their forecasting abilities, and how such techniques could be applied in real-world settings. Today, businesses and governments can utilize these techniques to better evaluate the likelihood of future events and respond to them effectively. Simply put, it’s hard to know how to respond to something you don’t know is coming.</li><li><strong>Better Communication. </strong>It’s a common trope to promote awareness of an issue after it is brought up, as if it were a panacea to the problem itself. Not so. Communication is a necessary but insufficient component to change. On issues like AI, climate change, and polarization, the solution lies in effective education of the public paired with appropriate actionable items. This might seem straightforward, but if you take five minutes to read about fears of artificial intelligence “waking up and taking over”, you’ll quickly realize how far we have left to go in communication, particularly when it comes to new technologies. This involves partnerships with the government and experts in the field who can help dispel myths, address relevant concerns, and communicate the path ahead.</li><li><strong>Collective Action.</strong> This sounds wishy-washy, but it really isn’t. As we saw in the chapter on AI (chapter 6), standards-setting and guidelines can only be effectively selected through collective action. No single company or country can meaningfully regulate the actions of all players, so it requires collaboration across all major players. This is especially true of issues that deal with societal and ethical implications, such as artificial intelligence or climate change. Collaboration is difficult, but possible — and most importantly, necessary.</li><li><strong>Government Action.</strong> <em>Groan, groan.</em> I know, I know. Again. Not a popular one, but a necessary one. Government action is separate from collective action because there are certain powers the government has that citizens and corporations don’t — namely, the power of broad-based national regulation. While free-market enthusiasts may shake their fists at the concept of regulating industry, it’s important to recognize the possible benefits to having a unilateral set of guidelines for controversial issues. The U.S. Government, in particular, has been hesitant to commit to any meaningful courses of action on AI ethics, climate change, or gene editing. Given how prevalent these issues will be in the near future, the government and its electorate would do well to pay attention. The second role of government is to assist those negatively impacted by these changes — what will we do to help people who are unemployed due to automation, or homeless due to rising sea levels? Some people have proposed universal basic income or a wealth tax to solve these issues, but no concrete solutions have been made.</li><li><strong>Funding Research.</strong> Research is the basis by which we accumulate more knowledge. Simply put, the most foolhardy thing a government can do is to shut off the research pipeline. It’s the institutional equivalent of closing your eyes and hoping others can’t see you. The key phrase is <em>proceed with caution</em>, not <em>stop altogether</em>. In chapter 6 I go into more detail on how funding research into algorithmic ethics can be deeply insightful; this is generalizeable to other domains as well.</li></ol><h3>For You</h3><p>But of course, collective action requires time and coordination. Thankfully, there are plenty of things that we as individuals can also do to prepare for the future.</p><ol><li><strong>Better Planning.</strong> In chapter 2 I talk about how trains invented our modern concept of scheduling. Since then, computer science has given us incredible new insights into how to optimally schedule tasks and ensure that they get done efficiently. If you’re curious about these, or other algorithmic optimizations you can perform at home, you can read <em>Algorithms to Live By</em>, a fantastic book written by CS professors at U.C. Berkeley¹.</li><li><strong>Self-forecasting. </strong>We’ve talked about how forecasting can benefit organizations — thankfully, you can do it on your own, too. If you’re curious what other superforecasters think about the future (and I hope you are, because some of their predictions are <em>fascinating</em>), here’s a link to the <a href="https://www.gjopen.com/">Good Judgement Project website</a>. If you want to learn more about Prof. Tetlock’s findings, you can read his book on <em>Superforecasting³.</em></li><li><strong>Curiosity. </strong>In case you haven’t made the connection across these different chapters, a common underpinning of human progress is curiosity. It’s what led Einstein to his understanding of relativity, Cajal to his discovery of the neuron, and Shelley to the plot of <em>Frankenstein</em>. While curiosity isn’t something that you can instill in yourself in a day, it’s possible to start in one place and expand your knowledge from there. For a general look into the universe and the wonderful mysteries it holds, I recommend <em>A Short History of Nearly Everything </em>by Bill Bryson⁴. Also by Bryson is a marvelous book that looks inward into the human body, <em>The Body: A Guide for Occupants⁵.</em></li><li><strong>Activism. </strong>There are a lot of ways you can make your voice heard, on a number of issues. After you’ve well-acquainted yourself with a topic, it can be helpful to engage in local activism. <a href="https://myreps.datamade.us/">Here’s a link to find your local representative⁶.</a> Even if you don’t intend on calling your representative, I encourage you to visit the link so you can familiarize yourself with their names and faces.</li><li><strong>Self-awareness. </strong>Both Yuval Noah Harari and Ezra Klein have suggested that we engage in mindfulness in the modern age⁷ ⁸. Unfortunately, mindfulness has become such a loaded word in recent years that it has almost lost all meaning, so I’ve opted to go with an alternate term, self awareness. Adapting to the modern age will require acute self-awareness and introspection on our part, especially in a world where there is too much information and too little processing time. Our ability to filter information, reflect on our emotions, and develop an enriched understanding of ourselves is paramount for our individual success and wellbeing. <em>Why did that news article make you so angry? What about that social media post made you anxious? What identities are those advertisements trying to target?</em> These questions, and more, are an integral part of self-development, one that requires intense effort — dare I say vigilance — to maintain.</li><li><strong>Simplification. </strong>This goes hand in hand with self-awareness. Now, more than ever, we are dealing with a world full of noise. It should come as no surprise that entire industries have blossomed out of our need to organize, self-regulate, and minimize our contact with this firehose of information. It’s more important than ever before to simplify the present so we can have some clarity in the future. <em>More isn’t always better. </em>Modern content wants us to consume, react, and respond immediately to everything from email to tweets to Instagram posts. Resist that temptation. The overwhelming amount of content can lead to cognitive overload or even fatigue on the issues that really matter. Take things one step at a time — it’s not possible to do everything in a day, but it’s possible to do something. Make that something count.</li></ol><h3>The End</h3><p>This marks the end of our journey — but also, the beginning of yours. My hope is that this series gave some insight into how we’ve used and molded our little slice of time here on Earth, and how we might be able to better chart a path forward from here on out. These changes take time, and they take practice — just like any skill, the future is hard to master, and no doubt we will fall over and over again until we get it right.</p><p>But that’s our story, isn’t it? Falling down, getting back up, then falling down again. There’s a rhythm to it, a tempo of improvement that resonates down that infinite thread. A heartbeat of persistence. If you tug at it just a little, you’ll feel a hint of resilience, a tensile strength extending from the very first <em>what if? </em>all the way to the edge. It’s enough to make you think, looking out at the clouds floating peacefully below.</p><p>Enough to make you realize, standing here, how far we’ve come since the days when we would look up at the sky and wonder, without a clue in our minds, whether the rain would come.</p><p>[1] Christian, Brian, and Tom Griffiths. <em>Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions</em>. Macmillan, 2016.</p><p>[2]</p><p><a href="https://www.gjopen.com/">Good Judgment® Open</a></p><p>[3] Tetlock, Philip E, and Dan Gardner. <em>Superforecasting: The Art and Science of Prediction</em>. , 2015. Print.</p><p>[4] Bryson, Bill. <em>A Short History Of Nearly Everything</em>. New York : Broadway Books, 2004. Print.</p><p>[5] Bryson, Bill. <em>The Body: a Guide for Occupants</em>. Anchor Canada, 2020.</p><p>[6]</p><p><a href="https://myreps.datamade.us/">My Reps</a></p><p>[7] Klein, Ezra. <em>Why Were Polarized</em>. Avid Reader Press, 2020.</p><p>[8] Harari, Yuval N.. <em>21 Lessons for the 21st Century.</em> First edition. New York: Spiegel &amp; Grau, 2018. Print.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32008d3068f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When More Becomes Too Much]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/when-more-becomes-too-much-7a9c53836571?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7a9c53836571</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aging]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Aug 2020 02:06:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-13T02:06:44.331Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FclmdVZPp6O2fuq4xwhT7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>New York, by <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/2vmT5_FeMck">Denys Nevozhai, Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>on overabundance</h3><p>This is the seventh and penultimate chapter in a series of pieces about our modern relationship with time and the future. Titled <em>Hourglass</em>, It’s an exploration into how our abstract view of time has changed in modernity, how it has met (or has yet to meet) the needs of the present, and what we can do to better prepare ourselves for what’s to come.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/hourglass-our-modern-relationship-with-time-ed9538a498ec">First Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/machine-minds-a59cfb8d8d14">Previous Chapter</a> / Next Chapter (next week)</p><p>For the past few centuries, we’ve lauded abundance, singing the tune of <em>more is better</em>. More information, more goods, more trade. What could be wrong with that? And for the most part, we’ve been right. By almost every metric, the modern world is a better place and time to be alive than any time in prior history. Global life expectancy has <em>doubled</em> since 1900¹. In the same time, global GDP has skyrocketed from $3.42 trillion to well-over $100 trillion today². Within the last generation, more than a billion people were freed from extreme poverty³. The global literacy rate has increased from 42% in 1960 to 86% in 201⁵⁴. I could go on. In short, we did good. Today’s people can live longer, eat better, and afford more than they’ve ever been able to before. But this sudden influx of abundance poses increasing challenges in the modern age, particularly in developed countries who have reaped the benefits of abundance for decades. At what point does abundance become <em>overabundance, </em>and how do we grapple with the consequences? Is there even such a thing as too much of a good thing? And, notably, what happens when we fight over the most scarce of resources — time?</p><h3>Selling Air</h3><p>Imagine for a second that you owned a business that sold air. How would you sell it, and for how much? Would people buy it?</p><p>The challenge lies in the fact that air is a <em>public good</em> — it’s both nonrivalrous, meaning it isn’t limited in supply through consumption, and non-excludable, meaning you can’t prevent people from sharing it⁵. The behavior of public goods diverges from your typical supply and demand; their behavior can be surprisingly non-convergent in practice due to the game-theoretic situations they elicit⁶. The behavior of public goods is complicated by the fact that scarcity in supply is no longer a limiting factor — the supply curve goes completely slack, and the bottleneck is a combination of a person’s willingness to pay and their capacity to consume. In simple terms, public goods are hard to deal with because they don’t fit neatly into simple market dynamics dictated by your typical introductory microeconomics course. And it’s most unfortunate that they are so finicky, because as it turns out, the most valuable commodity happens to be one of them. That’s right, information is a public good⁷.</p><p>In the data-driven economy, there’s a saying that has been used so many times it has become almost a cliche: “If you’re not paying, you’re the product.” So the theory goes, if I watch a video on YouTube, I’m not the consumer — rather, my attention is forwarded to an advertisement, whose company pays YouTube and keeps the lights on, so to speak. So long as YouTube supplies a sufficient number of eyeballs glued to a screen and some company demands their attention, the world goes on its merry way. This is a common diatribe from people who are discontented with the way that companies dehumanize their end-users. If we’re the product, we don’t have agency. If we don’t have agency, we don’t matter. We might as well just be inanimate objects, pieces of plastic moving in a giant conveyor belt. But here’s the problem. I don’t <em>have to choose YouTube</em>.</p><p>If YouTube were, say, an apple orchard, it could grow apples and sell them to a customer. Nowhere in that equation can the apple grow a pair of legs and scurry off, to, say, a competitor orchard. In that sense, an apple orchard’s value isn’t determined by how much the <em>apples</em> want to be <em>in the orchard</em>. At the end of the day YouTube still provides content to me — and everyone else — in an effectively unlimited way. The better the content, the more value to me, but the supply still remains more or less the same. As long as YouTube’s servers are running, everyone can, in theory, have access to YouTube, and the only bottleneck to an infinite consumption of the stuff is our willingness or ability to keep watching. This creates another relationship between the users and these companies, resulting in a heavily asymmetrical two-sided market where one end of the market behaves almost like a public good⁸. If you’ve ever interacted with Uber, Amazon, or Netflix, you’ve been a player in a two-sided market.</p><p>While two-sided markets are well-studied, a variant of modern two-sided markets pose a challenge. First, they are deeply asymmetric — it’s trivial for Netflix to provide content to a new user, but a new user needs to spend a non-trivial amount of time committing to consume that content. Second, some of these networks decouple revenue generation and their value proposition. In Uber, for example, the value generation is in providing more drivers, and the more drivers there are, the more the riders want to join in on the service (so-called “Network Effects”⁹). But take an example like YouTube — if the content is better, that’s a direct benefit to the viewer. But the viewer doesn’t pay the bills, advertisers do<em>. </em>Hence, the decoupling. And the problem gets worse from here.</p><p>As technology progresses, more and more industries are being shifted towards markets where the bottleneck is not the ability to supply a good, but the ability to consume it. Technological innovation also enables highly non-linear growth, where the change in marginal revenue outpaces the change in marginal costs — a process we define as scaling¹⁰. The economic challenges of scaling are rife with nonlinear processes, which for the time being we won’t go into too much detail. Suffice it to say that the behavior of businesses that scale through tech is, by its very definition, nonlinear, and that such nonlinearities are far from intuitive.</p><p>Let’s use Facebook as an example. Facebook’s ability to provide the offering for the user gets easier and easier the more users there are. At the same time, the user is constrained by a number of factors — their schedule, their commitments, their boredom — on how much time they’re able to commit to scrolling through Facebook (the aforementioned asymmetry). This means that in order for Facebook to acquire new users, it needs to compete with other offerings for their <em>time</em>. And since each additional user provides more value to the company, Facebook will continue to try harder and harder to get their attention.</p><p>Not all businesses will experience all of these phenomena at once — asymmetry, decoupling, and scaling — but many of them, especially those that are heavily involved in gathering and disseminating information, will experience a combination of these factors throughout its lifecycle.</p><p>This is what some people miss when they describe companies like Facebook and Google as advertising companies — the idea that the user is the product glosses over the fact that these companies are still competing for your attention, the consequences of which play out in the public sphere. They’re not just shuffling you off to advertisers, they’re competing for your time — the bottleneck in the pipeline. And the nature of this time-based competition has important ethical consequences, which we shall see shortly. The laws of scaling, two-sided-markets, and quasi-public goods will come to define the modern age, not just in information and data-driven fields, but a wide variety of other markets as well.</p><p>If you were fortunate enough to take a college course on scaling, little of this would be news to you. But most introductory economics courses gloss over public goods, two-sided markets, and scaling, despite the fact that increasingly large players are operating according to those laws. This is a problem because, like it or not, these kinds of markets are here to stay. And they’re here to win.</p><h3>Buying Time</h3><p>I should note that the competition for your time extends beyond companies like Google or Facebook, but also to content providers, such as news networks.</p><p>In Ezra Klein’s fantastic book, <em>Why We’re Polarized, </em>he explores the systemic changes that have led to greater polarization in the United States. As the chief-editor of Vox, he’s incredibly familiar with how modern economics has shaped the political landscape. In a telling section of his book, he explains:</p><blockquote><em>We can’t rely on people to read us out of duty; we have to compete with literally everything else for their attention. Rachel Maddow is at war with reruns of The Big Bang Theory. Vox’s YouTube channel competes with Xbox games. Time spent reading this book [Why We’re Polarized] is time not spent listening to the podcast Serial. The logic of this extend to the very edges of our conscious life and beyond. Netflix’s CEO Reed Hastings famously said his biggest competitor is sleep. This is the context in which modern political journalism is produced and absorbed: an all-out war for the time of an audience that has more choices than at any point in history.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>— Ezra Klein, Why We’re Polarized [11]</em></blockquote><p>In short, news companies aren’t just competing with other news companies. They’re competing with Netflix, Instagram, and the Superbowl Halftime Show — all for a slice, a tiny fraction, of your time and attention. He goes on to talk about how the modern era of content-saturation has led to the pursuit of virality, exemplified by <em>Buzzfeed </em>articles that cater to core identities of their viewer base.</p><p>By this logic, it should come as little surprise that polarization is taking place in the United States and elsewhere around the globe (though, it should be said, at a more moderate pace). Content providers, of all sorts, are driven to provide content that their viewers enjoy, that speak to the underlying principles and identities that their viewers feel attached to. News organizations are no different¹¹.</p><p>Polarization extends beyond news organizations into political institutions themselves. Gerrymandering and the existence of party primaries have been proposed as drivers of institutionalized polarization¹², although the evidence for these associations are rather weak¹³ and require further investigation. Klein points to two other institutional norms, the filibuster and the debt-ceiling, among others, as possible sources of polarization within political institutions. One thing is clear: political polarization in political institutions is getting worse¹³, and it’s likely here to stay¹¹.</p><p>It should come as no surprise that as a whole, the electorate is more polarized than ever before. In a process known as <em>partisan sorting</em>, voters self-sort themselves ideologically into the partisan system. Increasingly, voters have come to expect their own views, and the views of others around them, to fall into one of two ideological camps¹³, further exacerbating the issue of polarization in the news and in government. This vicious cycle of polarization is one that is unlikely to end in the near future, and it is up to us to come to grips with how to mitigate its nastiest consequences.</p><p>Political polarization is a multi-faceted issue that can be viewed through a wide variety of lenses. But one informative lens is that of overabundance, and the ways we have been left to cope with its implications. Political institutions, slow and bureaucratic by nature, are poorly equipped to deal with diverse and rapidly-changing choice sets — consequently, the polarization of the voter base can be seen as a reactionary consolidation of the electorate’s set of identities, collapsing a multidimensional voter base into one of two camps. Simultaneously, the polarization of the news can be seen as a reaction to the sudden explosion of content — one that motivates news organizations to put out content that is more sensational, eye-grabbing, and identity-enforcing in order to compete for viewer time and attention. These forces illustrate how today’s institutions and systems struggle to grapple with the problem of too much — too many choices, too many identities, all wanting <em>more</em>.</p><p>As it turns out, political systems aren’t the only ones grappling with this problem of overabundance. There are other systems, much closer to home, that struggle with it too.</p><h3>Death by Lifestyle</h3><blockquote><em>In 2011, an interesting milestone in human history was passed. For the first time, more people globally died from non-communicable diseases like heart failure, stroke, and diabetes than from all infectious diseases combined. We live in an age in which we are killed, more often than not, by lifestyle.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>— Bill Bryson, The Body: A Guide for Occupants [14]</em></blockquote><p>As far as animals go, humans have had a pretty great run, particularly in the last century or so. Today, there are more of us than ever before, and we’re leading longer lives, as well. As of 2020, the human population approaches 7.6 billion¹⁵, and the average human life expectancy is 73 years old¹⁶. While these two figures are a great achievement, they also have significant repercussions in the modern world.</p><p>First, on life expectancy. Humans, seemingly, have never had it so good. Yet, as Bill Bryson aptly points out in <em>The Body: A Guide for Occupants</em>, we may have reached a point of diminishing returns. In his own words, “we have become much better at extending life, but not necessarily better at extending quality of life¹⁴.” Despite living longer, a good portion of their later lives are spent in nursing homes and hospitals, away from their loved ones. Not to mention the fact that retirement is a chronically underfunded pursuit in developed countries, a surefire way to ensure that the elderly live a lower quality of life as time goes on. As people age, the quality of their life declines, and we are reaching a point where we are simply keeping folks alive without regard for what kind of life they will be living. As a result, we have approached diminishing marginal returns on how long we live¹⁴.</p><p>Slowly, our lifestyle catches up to us, in one way or another — whether it be through heart disease, diabetes, or cancer. Our extended lifetimes are pushing us to the brink of lifestyle-related diseases, ones that have prolonged consequences and lead to a slow and drawn-out deterioration of life-quality¹⁴. And overabundance certainly isn’t helping. The availability of simple pleasures that have reduced our need to leave the home and stay on our feet has taken its toll. As of 2012, obesity and obesity-related illnesses accounted for three times as many deaths as malnutrition and hunger¹⁷. The human body wasn’t built to deal with overabundance; for the past hundreds of thousands of years, food was scarce, and you’d be wise to eat as much as possible while you could. Not so in the modern age. The tragedy of the common age lies in the fact that our biological vessels are unprepared to live in an age where calories are in abundance, and we are the ones who suffer for it.</p><p>But suppose you aren’t yet old and senile, and that you’re not overweight or underweight. Life is better for you, right? Not necessarily. If you’re poor and you get sick, there’s a good chance you won’t be able to afford healthcare. A good 1 in 6 Americans report at least one financial barrier to paying for healthcare¹⁸. Beyond the immediate adverse effects on the patient, this can lead to worse conditions down the line — one notable example is in the prescription of antibiotics; low-income patients are much more likely to under-dose on antibiotics, which not only fails to adequately cure the disease, but collectively drives up rates of antibiotic resistance¹⁹.</p><p>But suppose you’re wealthy and living in a developed country where access to antibiotics is not an issue. Life is good, right? Herein lies another dark side to overabundance: overprescription and overtreatment. Recent studies show that up to 20% of medical treatment may be unnecessary²⁰. At the outset, an abundance of tests, prescriptions, and treatments might not seem insidious, until you consider that almost all of these procedures carry with them some risk of harm to the patient. In particular, the drug industry has been adamant in pushing out as many prescriptions as possible — often to people who don’t need them²¹. The result is a framework shift in the paradigm of treatment, not as a passive effort but as an active one (“ask your doctor if you have the following symptoms”). In every waking moment, we’re trying to find something, anything <em>wrong with us</em>, and in the same blink of an eye, there are people waiting to give us an answer.</p><p>This is not to say that doctors or medical providers have insidious intent. On the whole, the vast majority of them are trying to do the most good possible and heal patients as quickly as possible. But the problem is that this attitude of healing people before they are even sick can have disastrous consequences¹⁴. The modern age has given us a vast array of pills, prescriptions, and tests, which have helped extend and uplift the lives of many. At the same time, we have expanded the definition of what it means to be sick. Feel some pain? Take some ibuprofen. Can’t fall asleep? Ambien might help. Got a headache? Why not ask your doctor if this headache drug is right for you?</p><p>To paraphrase Bryson, we’ve reached a stage where we’ve got better medicine than ever before but we’re sick more of the time¹⁴. One wonders if the tradeoff was worth it, after all.</p><h3>The Rest</h3><p>As I mentioned earlier, humans now have approximately 7.6 billion members in their ranks, and before long, we’ll welcome the 8 billionth member of the <em>Homo Sapiens</em> fan club. A notable achievement. Unfortunately, this population is exerting an undue burden on society and the natural ecosystem of the planet.</p><p>The ecological impact of each modern human is measured in a unit called a global hectare (gha), a measure of biological and ecological productivity. In 2012, the planet’s biocapacity stood at 12.2 billion GHA, roughly 1.7 gha per person²². The ecological per-capita footprint of the U.S. was 8.6 gha as of 2017, meaning if everyone lived the life of a typical American, we would need 5 earths²³. As a reminder to the reader, we only have one.</p><p>The unwieldy demands of the modern economy and lifestyle have contributed to one of the most pressing issues of our time: climate change. Since the late 19th century, global temperatures have risen by 1.62 degrees Fahrenheit (0.9 Celcius)²⁴, and are projected to rise by another 3.2 to 7 degrees Fahrenheit (1.8 and 4.0 Celcius) by the end of the century²⁵. While this change seems insignificant on paper, the severity of climate change has been unevenly distributed, leading to higher volatility in many areas of the globe. The scientific consensus is clear: the impacts of climate change are due to human intervention. Our modern practices have led us to the very brink of ecological collapse. <a href="https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/">These impacts include but are not limited to: ocean acidification, melting ice caps, increased severity of natural disasters, and sea level rise²⁴,</a> <em>all of which have extended and unintended consequences for humans</em>, which, I remind the reader, also live on Earth.</p><p>So pervasive is our ecological disruption that many scientists have deemed this era a precursor to the <em>sixth mass extinction</em> <em>event</em> for biological life on our planet²⁶. Even without the official diagnosis, conservative estimates indicate that around 200 to 2000 species are headed to the chopping block every year, never to return, with high-end estimates around 10,000 to 100,00⁰²⁷. The sad truth is, we don’t know how many species are out there; it’s very possible that the havoc we wreak will be upon species that have never been discovered, and never will be. Other species at risk, largely due to the impacts of climate change include some fan-favorites: the common clownfish, the emperor penguin, the arctic fox, the monarch butterfly, and the koala, just to name a few²⁸. What a lonely place it will be without their company.</p><p>Beyond the impact to the ecosystem, climate change has an undeniable impact on the human inhabitants of Earth as well. In the U.S. alone, the destruction associated with extreme weather and health costs total up to $360 billion annually²⁹. The health costs of climate change are likely to be even worse as rising temperatures exacerbate the spread of disease³⁰, something the world seems uniquely unprepared to deal with. The problem of overabundance has, therefore, dealt us a double-blow: the increasing population has a dual contribution to the spread of disease and ecological collapse, both issues that are likely to get worse in the coming decades without proper mitigation strategies.</p><p>Despite this imminent threat, governments have been hesitant to act. Most notably, in 2019 the United States formally indicated its intention to withdraw from the Paris Climate Agreement³¹, leaving it in the warm company of Iraq, Iran, Turkey, Yemen (currently in conflict), Sudan (also in conflict), Libya, Angola, and Eritrea³². The lack of effort from the government in this regard can only be described as a reckless act of endangerment, not only to the citizens of the world, but the fragile ecological systems that provide them a home.</p><h3>More is Less is More</h3><p>For centuries we have touted abundance as progress — the idea that more is better was not only celebrated, it was gospel. In the pre-Industrialized world, these principles guided nations out of poverty and into an age where people lived more productive, healthier, and longer lives. In the modern age, however, we are beginning to realize the limitations of this seemingly unending growth. The abundance that we have created comes with a hidden dark side, and the strain under which it has placed our political, economic, and ecological systems is coming to a breaking point. The idea that the systems from which we reap such abundance can continue to support us forever is a fantasy. Someday, something is going to give.</p><p>Make no mistake: in no way am I suggesting we pull the plug on the economy, the markets, or the government. That would be just as bad, if not worse, than going ahead full speed. Rather, I am suggesting that more focus be put onto the mechanisms by which overabundance can have unintended consequences. The main idea here is to proceed with caution, and in the concluding chapter I will discuss how I think we can do so effectively. Many of our existing systems are well built for problems of scarcity; that’s the reason they were able to propel us this far into the modern age. But I’m afraid that we are woefully unprepared for an age where overabundance (and the expectation of plenty) isn’t the exception, it’s the norm. Ultimately, how we tackle these issues will determine our success as a society, as a species, and as stewards of this planet where we’re so fortunate to reside.</p><p>In the introduction to this series I promised you that I would bring you to the edge, the place where the present meets the future. Throughout this series we have shown how our concept of time and the future have changed, from a uniform, unchanging force to a fluid, relative one. Today, time is perhaps our most precious asset — the one thing that remains scarce in a world of overabundance. This is it. Welcome to the edge. One word of advice? Look before you leap.</p><p>Next Chapter (next week) →</p><p>[1] Roser, Max, et al. “Life Expectancy.” <em>Our World in Data</em>, 23 May 2013, ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy.</p><p><a href="https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy">Life Expectancy</a></p><p>[2] “World GDP over the Last Two Millennia.” <em>Our World in Data</em>, ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-gdp-over-the-last-two-millennia.</p><p><a href="https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-gdp-over-the-last-two-millennia">World GDP over the last two millennia</a></p><p>[3] Roser, Max, and Esteban Ortiz-Ospina. “Global Extreme Poverty.” <em>Our World in Data</em>, 25 May 2013, ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty.</p><p><a href="https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty">Global Extreme Poverty</a></p><p>[4] Roser, Max, and Esteban Ortiz-Ospina. “Literacy.” <em>Our World in Data</em>, 13 Aug. 2016, ourworldindata.org/literacy.</p><p><a href="https://ourworldindata.org/literacy">Literacy</a></p><p>[5] Fernando, Jason. “Public Good Definition.” <em>Investopedia</em>, Investopedia, 24 July 2020, <a href="http://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/public-good.asp.">www.investopedia.com/terms/p/public-good.asp.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/public-good.asp">Public Good Definition</a></p><p>[6] “The Demand for Public Goods.” <em>Mnmeconomics</em>, 23 Oct. 2011, mnmeconomics.wordpress.com/2011/10/22/the-demand-for-public-goods/.</p><p><a href="https://mnmeconomics.wordpress.com/2011/10/22/the-demand-for-public-goods/">The demand for public goods</a></p><p>[7] Rolnik, Guy. “‘Information Is a Public Good.’” <em>Pro Market</em>, 15 May 2020, promarket.org/2017/06/30/information-public-good/.</p><p><a href="https://promarket.org/2017/06/30/information-public-good/">&quot;Information Is a Public Good&quot; - Pro Market</a></p><p>[8] Kagan, Julia. “What Is a Two-Sided Market?” <em>Investopedia</em>, Investopedia, 6 Apr. 2020, <a href="http://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/two-sidedmarket.asp.">www.investopedia.com/terms/t/two-sidedmarket.asp.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/two-sidedmarket.asp">What Is a Two-Sided Market?</a></p><p>[9] Banton, Caroline. “Understanding the Network Effect.” <em>Investopedia</em>, Investopedia, 29 Jan. 2020, <a href="http://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/network-effect.asp.">www.investopedia.com/terms/n/network-effect.asp.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/network-effect.asp">Network Effect: What It Is, How It Works, Pros and Cons</a></p><p>[10] Katherine, Gustafson. “What Is Scaling in Business &amp; How Is It Different Than Growth?” <em>Lighter Capital</em>, 17 Sept. 2019, <a href="http://www.lightercapital.com/blog/what-is-scaling-in-business/">www.lightercapital.com/blog/what-is-scaling-in-business/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.lightercapital.com/blog/what-is-scaling-in-business/">What Is Scaling in Business &amp; How Is It Different Than Growth?</a></p><p>[11] Klein, Ezra. <em>Why Were Polarized</em>. Avid Reader Press, 2020.</p><p>[12] Nivola, Pietro S. “Thinking About Political Polarization.” <em>Brookings</em>, Brookings, 28 July 2016, <a href="http://www.brookings.edu/research/thinking-about-political-polarization/">www.brookings.edu/research/thinking-about-political-polarization/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.brookings.edu/research/thinking-about-political-polarization/">Thinking About Political Polarization</a></p><p>[13] Mansbridge, Jane, and Cathie Jo Martin. “Negotiating Agreement in Politics.” <em>Negotiating Agreement in Politics | Government Innovators Network</em>, 29 Sept. 1970, <a href="http://www.innovations.harvard.edu/negotiating-agreement-politics.">www.innovations.harvard.edu/negotiating-agreement-politics.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.innovations.harvard.edu/negotiating-agreement-politics">Negotiating Agreement in Politics</a></p><p>[14] Bryson, Bill. <em>The Body: a Guide for Occupants</em>. Anchor Canada, 2020.</p><p>[15] Bureau, U.S. Census. “Estimated 7.58B People on Earth on World Population Day July 11.” <em>The United States Census Bureau</em>, 10 July 2019, <a href="http://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/07/estimated-seven-point-five-eight-billion-people-world-population-day-2019.html.">www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/07/estimated-seven-point-five-eight-billion-people-world-population-day-2019.html.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/07/estimated-seven-point-five-eight-billion-people-world-population-day-2019.html">Estimated 7.58B People on Earth on World Population Day July 11</a></p><p>[16] “Life Expectancy of the World Population.” <em>Worldometer</em>, <a href="http://www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/">www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/">Life Expectancy by Country and in the World (2025) - Worldometer</a></p><p>[17] Adams, Stephen. “Obesity Killing Three Times as Many as Malnutrition.” <em>The Telegraph</em>, Telegraph Media Group, 13 Dec. 2012, <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9742960/Obesity-killing-three-times-as-many-as-malnutrition.html.">www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9742960/Obesity-killing-three-times-as-many-as-malnutrition.html.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9742960/Obesity-killing-three-times-as-many-as-malnutrition.html">Obesity killing three times as many as malnutrition</a></p><p>[18] Weinick, Robin M et al. “Who can’t pay for health care?.” <em>Journal of general internal medicine</em> vol. 20,6 (2005): 504–9. doi:10.1111/j.1525–1497.2005.0087.x</p><p>[19] Barker, Anna K et al. “Social determinants of antibiotic misuse: a qualitative study of community members in Haryana, India.” <em>BMC public health</em> vol. 17,1 333. 19 Apr. 2017, doi:10.1186/s12889–017–4261–4</p><p>[20] Lyu, Heather et al. “Overtreatment in the United States.” <em>PloS one</em> vol. 12,9 e0181970. 6 Sep. 2017, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0181970</p><p>[21] Brownlee, Shannon, and Judith Garber. “Overprescribed: High Cost Isn’t America’s Only Drug Problem.” <em>STAT</em>, STAT, 1 Apr. 2019, <a href="http://www.statnews.com/2019/04/02/overprescribed-americas-other-drug-problem/">www.statnews.com/2019/04/02/overprescribed-americas-other-drug-problem/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.statnews.com/2019/04/02/overprescribed-americas-other-drug-problem/">Overprescribed: High cost isn&#39;t America&#39;s only drug problem - STAT</a></p><p>[22] “Ecological Footprint.” <em>WWF</em>, wwf.panda.org/knowledge_hub/all_publications/ecological_footprint2/.</p><p><a href="https://wwf.panda.org/knowledge_hub/all_publications/ecological_footprint2/">Ecological Footprint</a></p><p>[23] “California Has the Same Size Ecological Footprint as France. How Do Other States and Countries Compare?” <em>Global Footprint Network</em>, <a href="http://www.footprintnetwork.org/2017/01/31/california-size-ecological-footprint-france-states-countries-compare/">www.footprintnetwork.org/2017/01/31/california-size-ecological-footprint-france-states-countries-compare/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.footprintnetwork.org/2017/01/31/california-size-ecological-footprint-france-states-countries-compare/">California has the same size Ecological Footprint as France. How do other states and countries compare?</a></p><p>[24] “Climate Change Evidence: How Do We Know?” <em>NASA</em>, NASA, 27 May 2020, climate.nasa.gov/evidence/.</p><p><a href="https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/">Climate Change Evidence: How Do We Know?</a></p><p>[25] “Predictions of Future Global Climate.” <em>UCAR Center for Science Education</em>, scied.ucar.edu/longcontent/predictions-future-global-climate.</p><p><a href="https://scied.ucar.edu/longcontent/predictions-future-global-climate">Predictions of Future Global Climate</a></p><p>[26] Greshko, Michael. “What Are Mass Extinctions, and What Causes Them?” <em>Mass Extinction Facts and Information from National Geographic</em>, 26 Sept. 2019, <a href="http://www.nationalgeographic.com./science/prehistoric-world/mass-extinction/">www.nationalgeographic.com./science/prehistoric-world/mass-extinction/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/prehistoric-world/mass-extinction/">What are mass extinctions, and what causes them?</a></p><p>[27] “How Many Species Are We Losing?” <em>WWF</em>, wwf.panda.org/our_work/our_focus/biodiversity/biodiversity/.</p><p><a href="https://wwf.panda.org/our_work/our_focus/biodiversity/biodiversity/">How many species are we losing?</a></p><p>[28] “Animals at Risk from Climate Change — Animals At Risk from Climate Change.” <em>The Global Education Project</em>, <a href="http://www.theglobaleducationproject.org/climate-change/">www.theglobaleducationproject.org/climate-change/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.theglobaleducationproject.org/climate-change/">Animals at Risk from Climate Change - Animals At Risk from Climate Change</a></p><p>[29] Leahy, Stephen. “Hidden Costs of Climate Change Running Hundreds of Billions a Year.” <em>National Geographic</em>, 12 Dec. 2019, <a href="http://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/climate-change-costs-us-economy-billions-report/">www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/climate-change-costs-us-economy-billions-report/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/climate-change-costs-us-economy-billions-report/">Hidden Costs of Climate Change Running Hundreds of Billions a Year</a></p><p>[30] “Climate Change and Public Health — Climate Effects on Health.” <em>Centers for Disease Control and Prevention</em>, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 20 July 2020, <a href="http://www.cdc.gov/climateandhealth/effects/default.htm.">www.cdc.gov/climateandhealth/effects/default.htm.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.cdc.gov/climateandhealth/effects/default.htm">Climate Effects on Health</a></p><p>[31] Hersher, Rebecca. “U.S. Formally Begins To Leave The Paris Climate Agreement.” <em>NPR</em>, NPR, 4 Nov. 2019, <a href="http://www.npr.org/2019/11/04/773474657/u-s-formally-begins-to-leave-the-paris-climate-agreement.">www.npr.org/2019/11/04/773474657/u-s-formally-begins-to-leave-the-paris-climate-agreement.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.npr.org/2019/11/04/773474657/u-s-formally-begins-to-leave-the-paris-climate-agreement">U.S. Formally Begins To Leave The Paris Climate Agreement</a></p><p>[32] Apparicio, Soila, and Natalie Sauer. “Which Countries Have Not Ratified the Paris Climate Agreement?” <em>Climate Home News</em>, Climate Home, 13 Mar. 2020, <a href="http://www.climatechangenews.com/2020/03/01/countries-yet-ratify-paris-agreement/">www.climatechangenews.com/2020/03/01/countries-yet-ratify-paris-agreement/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.climatechangenews.com/2020/03/01/countries-yet-ratify-paris-agreement/">Which countries have not ratified the Paris climate agreement?</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7a9c53836571" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Machine Minds]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/machine-minds-a59cfb8d8d14?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a59cfb8d8d14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[deep-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 01 Aug 2020 18:46:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-04T06:41:28.321Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g8EDtyhWL5_HjIANogigfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image from <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/EUsVwEOsblE">Adi Goldstein, Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>on minds</h3><p>This is the sixth chapter in a series of pieces about our modern relationship with time and the future. Titled <em>Hourglass</em>, It’s an exploration into how our abstract view of time has changed in modernity, how it has met (or has yet to meet) the needs of the present, and what we can do to better prepare ourselves for what’s to come.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/hourglass-our-modern-relationship-with-time-ed9538a498ec">First Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/history-shattered-5d5ad3e03124">Previous Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/when-more-becomes-too-much-7a9c53836571">Next Chapter</a></p><blockquote>If the human brain were so simple<br>That we could understand it,<br>We would be so simple<br>That we couldn’t.</blockquote><blockquote>— Emerson M. Pugh</blockquote><p>Inside that head of yours is something magnificent. A processing unit so complex, so mysterious, that even those who have dedicated decades to its study have barely scratched the surface. An organ so dynamic and interconnected, some have called it the most complex system in the known universe. I’m talking, of course, about the human brain.</p><p>The study of the brain, and that which it confers onto humankind — the gifts of intelligence and consciousness, have captured the human imagination since times of old. In some sense, replicating this process in an external setting has been a deep-rooted goal of humankind for a long time. A mind made from a machine, not from flesh. Before modernism, romanticism, before all the <em>isms</em> that have come to define our modern age, there was the will to understand who we are, and what mad force of the universe compelled it to create, within itself, a small and insignificant being capable of observing it. Some sought the stars for answers, others sailed across the world. But it wasn’t until we started looking <em>inward</em> that we finally uncovered the intricacies of the mind.</p><h3>An Artful Mind</h3><p>If you’ve ever seen the pages of <a href="http://www.drawingsofleonardo.org/">Leonardo Da Vinci’s sketchbooks</a>, you’ll realize that the illustrations before you are well-ahead of their time. Mechanical machines, anatomical studies, and drawings of flora and fauna explode out of the pages, a sublime marriage of art and science. It is here where you will find sketches of the mind that are nothing short of extraordinary.</p><p>In 1487, Leonardo drew what he called the <em>senso comune</em> (literally, <em>common sense</em>), the linkage of the senses. His early sketches hypothesized how visual information was transferred to the brain via the optic nerves² ³ and how sensory input would be conveyed, via the spinal cord, to the muscles of the body⁴. By 1509, Leonardo used his knowledge in sculpting and molding to map out the structure of cerebral ventricles, the hollow cavities in the human brain⁴. His work in understanding anatomy had led him to some of the greatest breakthroughs in the inner workings of the mind at the time. Sadly, his work did little to influence neuroscience, as he rarely published any of his work³ ⁴. It would not be until over <em>four centuries later</em> that Walter E. Dandy would develop similar techniques for mapping the brain⁵.</p><p>In 1887, another artist-scientist would make a significant discovery on the inner workings of the mind. Using a silver-staining technique (“Golgi staining”), Santiago Ramon y Cajal was able to isolate brain cells for the first time. The staining technique allowed Cajal to view a small subset of the cells at a time, turning what used to be a convoluted mess of grey matter into a clear, pristine look into the underlying neural circuitry. Take one look at the sketches he made from his discovery and you’ll once again see the interconnected nature of science and art. It’s almost like looking at an old, hand-drawn map: each neuron is drawn with exquisite detail, its dendrites, axon, and cell body clearly outlined in an interconnected network⁶.</p><p>His work, rendered beautifully on paper by his own artistic talent, demonstrated a number of things: first, that the brain’s computing power rose from a vast array of diverse and differentiated neurons, and second, that they operated in a network-like fashion — propagating information from one end of the cell to the next, onward and outward in spindly fibers to other neurons⁷.</p><p>Later contributions would compound evidence for this “network” style correspondence in the brain, particularly in the visual cortex, the region responsible for making sense of visual information. The visual cortex consists of many distinct layers of neurons, that propagate information deeper and deeper into the network, much like sports fans doing “the wave” in an arena. Information is passed from V1 to V2 to V4⁸, and later to the inferotemporal cortex, where images are integrated and processed⁹. The question, however, remained — how might we, as humans, model these intricate neural networks?</p><h3>The Mind and the Machine</h3><p>The modern computer has come a long way since the mid-twentieth century, when large, monstrous behemoths with switches and dials were used to calculate missile trajectories and send people into space. What used to be stacks and stacks of metal shelves and tubing can now fit neatly in the palm of your hand. Modern digital computers use <em>algorithms</em>, a set of step-by-step rules, to make calculations. These calculations take inputs, such as a tap on your screen or a number, and translate them into outputs, like a Facebook post or a bank account statement. These calculations may seem simple individually, but they can get ever-more complex as more layers are added to existing modules. Take Google for example — it consists of an extensive list of search results, a massive infrastructure required to connect and rank those results, and a distributed way to deal with multiple requests at once, just to name a few functions. With such complex systems, it might even be possible to attribute some level of intelligence to them — not biological, of course, but artificial.</p><p>One modern development in artificial intelligence is known as <em>machine learning</em>. The basic idea behind machine learning is that we (humans) can write algorithms (code) that learn to adapt better and better every time. Suppose I give you a very rudimentary game, like Tic-Tac-Toe. If I play a game once, I can have the computer store it in memory. If it wins and I play the game again in the same fashion, it will play its old strategy. If it loses, or if I play a different strategy, it’ll try to change things up — and once that new game is done, it’ll store it in memory again. This is a very rudimentary example of adaptive learning, and it’s pretty clear to see that it won’t get you very far. For a game of Tic-Tac-Toe, we might make some headway, but we aren’t going to drive cars with this thing anytime soon. To do that, we’re going to need to try something a bit more complex.</p><p>Many modern machine learning algorithms use a learning method called <em>gradient descent¹⁰</em>. It sounds fancy, but it really isn’t. Here’s how it works. Imagine you’re tuning an instrument; a guitar, for example. You pluck one string, and it sounds a little bit off. So you turn a knob a little bit, and it sounds worse. No good. So you turn the knob in the other direction, and it sounds better. Great. So you turn it ever so slightly in the same direction, plucking as you go, until you get the string to play the right key. Do that for all the strings and you’ve got an instrument that is completely in-tune. What you’ve done there is a manual version of gradient descent. You’ve got an <em>objective function — </em>something that defines what you’re trying to do. In this case, it might be a tuning fork or an iPhone tuning app. And every time you “sample” the input by plucking a key, you know what direction you should turn it in, based on whether your objective function tells you you’re getting closer or farther away. Do this for multiple strings, all at once, and you’ve got a system of learning modules that get progressively better over time.</p><p>Inspired by the architecture of the brain, computer scientists realized that they could stack these computational modules on top of one another, mimicking brain behavior. Suddenly, you’ve got an algorithm — several “layers” deep — that can model all sorts of different cool functions — from images of cats to whale sounds to stock market prices. This is the essence of most modern-day machine learning algorithms, and the basis of neural networks (so-called “deep learning”). These represent some of the most powerful computational tools we have in our wheelhouse today, and we’re just barely scratching the surface of what’s possible. So — the million dollar question is — what is possible? Let’s find out, shall we?</p><h3>Redefining Impossible</h3><p>What’s so special about us? What’s one task that is so hard, it would be difficult — no, impossible — for another animal or machine to beat us at it? For a long time, the answer to this was chess. In the 1980s, the notion that a computer could win a chess match against a human was a laughable notion. But in February 1996, the DeepBlue algorithm defeated Gary Kasparov, the reigning world chess champion, at his own game¹¹. <em>Okay, fine</em>. So computers could beat us at chess. No big deal, it was’t that interesting anyway. Why not try your hand at Go, a game so complex that the number of possible moves exceeded the number of atoms in the universe. Surely, <em>surely</em>, this was a uniquely human task. In 2015, Google DeepMind unveiled AlphaGo, a bot trained by neural networks to play the game. It won 5–0 against reigning three-time European Champion, Fan Hui¹². And that was just the beginning.</p><blockquote>In late 2017, we introduced AlphaZero, a single system that taught itself from scratch how to master the games of chess, shogi, and Go, beating a world-champion program in each case.</blockquote><blockquote>— Google DeepMind, on AlphaZero [12]</blockquote><p>The past decade has resulted in a veritable Cambrian Explosion of neural network architectures, each specializing in different domains. By pitting neural networks against each other in a rivalrous fashion, you get Generative Adversarial Networks¹³, capable of rendering faces so real that <a href="https://thispersondoesnotexist.com/">a dedicated website has been made for entirely artificially generated photos of people who don’t exist</a>. These networks can turn photos into artwork¹⁴, paint-by-numbers¹⁵, and fabricate images of celebrities and world leaders (so-called DeepFakes)¹⁶. Other “species” of network specialize in processing language and language-like variants. By using selective “attention”, these networks, called Transformers, are capable of generating text so similar to human writing that the developers opted to withhold releasing the source code to the public¹⁷. Other transformer variants are capable of generating music that mimics the style of other composers¹⁸. The list goes on and on — bots that can detect heart disease, play videogames, drive cars. These are not musings of a futurist — these are things happening right now, as we speak. We’d do well to tread carefully on the next thing we deem “impossible”, because based on our track record, there’s a good chance we’d be wrong.</p><p>Contrary to the hypotheses of most science fiction writers (and, sadly, many pop-science journalists), the risk we run with artificial intelligence isn’t likely to come from <em>generalized intelligence </em>anytime soon. That is to say, it’s unlikely that computers will develop to the point where they are conscious, intelligent, and outperform humans at virtually every task. The fear of AI overlords isn’t totally out of the realm of possibilities, but it’s a slim one, at least for now. That’s the good news. There isn’t going to be a robot that can be you better than you can be you, at least for now. The bad news is that it doesn’t have to be.</p><p>Already, humans are finding that machine learning models and AI agents are capable of outperforming themselves at a wide variety of tasks. This isn’t a problem in principle; technology of the past has typically enabled the creation of new jobs, new opportunities, and new ways of life. We’ve seen how the invention of the train and the telegraph led to massive improvements in science and innovation, leading to a massive boom in industry growth from the Industrial Revolution. Old industries die, and new industries emerge, like phoenixes from the Schumpeterian flame (if you got that reference, we can be friends). So the story goes. Unfortunately, the scale and pace at which these industries may be replaced may far outmatch our ability to relocate workers to new positions. In simple terms, not every truck driver can become a computer scientist in a few years. And it’s not just truck drivers. Clerks, deliverymen, sales representatives, and even lawyers might go out the window in a few decades¹⁹. The thing is, AI doesn’t have to be better at you at <em>everything</em>, it just has to be better than you at <em>one thing</em>. That one thing? Your job.</p><p>It’s important to note that (as of 2020), artificial intelligence doesn’t have any markedly <em>sinister</em> intent. Machine learning models don’t <em>want</em> to take over your job, nor do the engineers coding them <em>want</em> to replace you. But it doesn’t really matter, now does it? That’s effectively the same thing as saying “it’s nothing personal”, as you send an employee out the door. So what do we do about it?</p><h3>En Passant</h3><p>First, we need to decouple the science-fiction from science-fact. While fears of artificial generalized intelligence (AGI) run high, the real threat isn’t what’s happening in the future, it’s what’s happening right now. Redirecting the national and international focus onto the problems of today (job loss, data privacy, data ethics) is paramount to ensure that careful steps are taken towards the right direction. That requires a coordinated effort between computer scientists and journalists to dispel myths about artificial intelligence and focus on issues that may actually pose significant risks in the future. <a href="https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/employment-law/pages/artificial-intelligence-discriminatory-data.aspx">For example, algorithms that calculate your credit score or decide whether you should be hired shouldn’t be able to discriminate against you based on race²⁰.</a></p><p>Second, we need companies on board. Many companies have stated outright that there needs to be better alignment on AI ethics. They’re right. And they can’t do it alone. In a previous chapter I mentioned <a href="https://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">Google’s Code of AI Ethics²¹, </a>pointing out the fact that it’s incredibly vague. Unfortunately, at the company level, it doesn’t really matter how vague or specific your policies are if you can’t be reasonably convinced that all major players will follow them. The future of ethical artificial intelligence requires alignment across the vast array of institutions that are major players in the field — a “UN General Assembly” on Artificial Intelligence, if you will. And as ineffective as that may sound, at the very least it would indicate some message of alignment between the major players about the state, direction, and concerns of the technology at hand.</p><p>Third, the government. I know, I know. <em>Groan. </em>I’m not thrilled about it either. The government hasn’t exactly had the best track record for dealing with these kinds of problems, and this one is proving no different. But, like it or not, the government must play a role — in regulation, yes, but also in dealing with the potential wave of mass unemployment that will follow. Plans of implementing universal-basic income have been rolled out somewhat effectively on medium-to-large scales, especially as a response to the coronavirus outbreak (unfortunately, these successful rollouts exclude the United States, whose performance in this regard hasn’t been as stellar as its stars and bars would have you believe). Analyzing the impact of UBI in these contexts may give us valuable data on how to move forward. As for regulation, AI policy in the US predictably lags behind. In 2017, Congress passed the FUTURE of AI Act²², which among other things established a federal advisory committee, which in laymen’s terms amounts to practically nothing. Congress sets up advisory committees for <em>everything</em>. New bills introduced to the House are a bit more promising, with <a href="https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-resolution/153/text">H.Res.153</a>²³ targeting some of the societal implications of artificial intelligence mentioned earlier.</p><p>Finally, research. While the idea of ethical algorithms might sound like a whole lot of frou-frou for most, the field itself is actually incredibly rigorous and analytical. We have already made strides in data privacy with the development of a new concept called differential privacy, which encapsulates in a mathematical way a lot of the ideas about privacy we want to instill in our algorithms. There’s a fantastic book about it written by Michael Kearns and Aaron Roth, professors at the University of Pennsylvania, which you should read if you’re interested²⁴. Investing in the research of designing ethical algorithms could be the difference between feeling around in the dark and having a flashlight in our hands when it comes to developing algorithms for the future.</p><p>These are just a few things that will be necessary for us as we move into the new age of artificial intelligence. These tools will come to define our relationship with technology as well as our place in society, and we had better come to grips with reality quickly.</p><h3>What About Love?</h3><p>There might be something that has been bothering you all this time about my deep dive into minds, both biological and artificial. Earlier I mentioned the gifts that our brain gave us — intelligence and consciousness. What about consciousness? The ability to recognize that we are feeling, thinking beings?</p><p>Unfortunately, we haven’t a clue. For millennia, philosophers thought that the two were one and the same. It appears, at least for now, they’re not²⁵. To date, we’ve successfully created agents that can play chess, master facial recognition, and play music, but all without a lick of self-awareness or emotion. No remorse for the pawns, no glee at a smiling face, no sublime feeling at the flow of a melody. These machines can’t experience the most basic emotions, let alone complex ones like regret, embarrassment, or love.</p><p>It might be the case that consciousness, and the emotions that arise from self-containment, is hard — computationally, mathematically, possibly even biologically. It’s a well known fact of behavioral psychology that we are more emotional than intelligent — that our emotions rule over our rationality. At the end of the day, we are <em>feeling</em> beings. Our rationality arises from the emotions we feel, not the other way around²⁶. So perhaps our future lies in unlocking some part of our emotional being, allowing us to differentiate ourselves from the intelligent agents we have created. But this is all, of course, speculation.</p><p>In the next few chapters we will discuss, among other things, what happens when the systems we built care more about intelligence than consciousness, about accuracy over emotion. We will discuss that all-important motivator of progress in the technological age: data, and what it means to live in a data-driven economy. We will discuss what happens when enough becomes too much, and how we can live in a world with both too many resources and not enough to share. All this in the near future, whether you read it or not.</p><p>But I’ll leave you with this. Our minds are some of the most magnificent systems in the universe, and we aren’t even close to cracking what makes them work. It is, in my opinion, the most noble of causes to understand how to model and understand it — to know thyself, if you will. But along the way, we must be vigilant in knowing what we give up when we create systems that can outperform us on an intelligent level. We’ve come a long way from the days of World War II, when we used computers to crack encrypted German messages. We’ve come a long way since the days of the Space Race, where computers were used to calculate trajectories of rockets (and the people inside them) into space. We’ve even come a long way since the introduction of the personal computer into our modern homes. Today’s algorithms are faster, smarter, and more adaptable than the algorithms of old. When we order from Amazon’s Echo, we do so not because some AI overlord is forcing us to, we do so because it’s convenient. Same thing for why you prefer to watch free videos on YouTube and search the internet on Google. We listen to music on Spotify, and are pleasantly surprised when its algorithms pick similar music for us. We like having more and more content to view on Instagram — hand-tailored to our preferences. In short, the AI revolution won’t be loud. It won’t come with the sound of robots knocking down our doors. No, no, no. Let’s be very clear: the AI revolution will happen because we wanted it to. Because at the end of the day, <em>it was just so much easier to leave the door wide open.</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/when-more-becomes-too-much-7a9c53836571">Next Chapter: When More Becomes Too Much→</a></p><p>[1] Reuteler, David. <em>The Drawings of Leonardo Da Vinci</em>, <a href="http://www.drawingsofleonardo.org/">www.drawingsofleonardo.org/.</a></p><p><a href="http://www.drawingsofleonardo.org/">the drawings of Leonardo da Vinci</a></p><p>[2] Philo, Ron, and Kevin Petti. “Leonardo da Vinci: Images of the Brain.” <em>The FASEB Journal</em> 32 (2018): 781–8. <a href="https://www.fasebj.org/doi/abs/10.1096/fasebj.2018.32.1_supplement.781.8">https://www.fasebj.org/doi/abs/10.1096/fasebj.2018.32.1_supplement.781.8</a></p><p>[3] Penttila, Nicky. “The Hidden Neuroscience of Leonardo Da Vinci.” <em>Dana Foundation</em>, Dana Foundation, 30 Apr. 2020, dana.org/article/the-hidden-neuroscience-of-leonardo-da-vinci/.</p><p><a href="https://dana.org/article/the-hidden-neuroscience-of-leonardo-da-vinci/">The Hidden Neuroscience of Leonardo da Vinci | Dana Foundation</a></p><p>[4] Isaacson, Walter. <em>Leonardo Da Vinci</em>. , 2017. Print.</p><p>[5] da Mota Gomes, M. “From the wax cast of brain ventricles (1508–9) by Leonardo da Vinci to air cast ventriculography (1918) by Walter E. Dandy.” <em>Revue neurologique</em> (2020).</p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0035378720303799">From the wax cast of brain ventricles (1508-9) by Leonardo da Vinci to air cast ventriculography (1918) by Walter E. Dandy</a></p><p>[6] Bentivoglio, Marina. “The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1906.” <em>NobelPrize.org</em>, Nobel Media AB 2020, 20 Apr. 1998, <a href="http://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1906/cajal/article/">www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1906/cajal/article/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1906/cajal/article/">The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1906</a></p><p>[7] Bergland, Christopher. “The Father of Modern Neuroscience Was an Athlete and Artist.” <em>Psychology Today</em>, Sussex Publishers, 27 Jan. 2017, <a href="http://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-athletes-way/201701/the-father-modern-neuroscience-was-athlete-and-artist.">www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-athletes-way/201701/the-father-modern-neuroscience-was-athlete-and-artist.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-athletes-way/201701/the-father-modern-neuroscience-was-athlete-and-artist">The Father of Modern Neuroscience Was an Athlete and Artist</a></p><p>[8] Huff, Trevor, Navid Mahabadi, and Prasanna Tadi. “Neuroanatomy, visual cortex.” <em>StatPearls [Internet]</em>. StatPearls Publishing, 2019.</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482504/">Neuroanatomy, Visual Cortex</a></p><p>[9] Tanaka K. Inferotemporal cortex and object vision. <em>Annu Rev Neurosci</em>. 1996;19:109–139. doi:10.1146/annurev.ne.19.030196.000545</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8833438/">Inferotemporal Cortex and Object Vision - PubMed</a></p><p>[10] Pandey, Parul. “Understanding the Mathematics behind Gradient Descent.” <em>Medium</em>, Towards Data Science, 17 Jan. 2020, towardsdatascience.com/understanding-the-mathematics-behind-gradient-descent-dde5dc9be06e.</p><p><a href="https://towardsdatascience.com/understanding-the-mathematics-behind-gradient-descent-dde5dc9be06e">Understanding the Mathematics behind Gradient Descent.</a></p><p>[11] Eschner, Kat. “Computers Are Great at Chess, But That Doesn’t Mean the Game Is ‘Solved’.” <em>Smithsonian.com</em>, Smithsonian Institution, 10 Feb. 2017, <a href="http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/what-first-man-lose-computer-said-about-chess-21st-century-180962046/">www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/what-first-man-lose-computer-said-about-chess-21st-century-180962046/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/what-first-man-lose-computer-said-about-chess-21st-century-180962046/">Computers Are Great at Chess, But That Doesn&#39;t Mean the Game Is &#39;Solved&#39;</a></p><p>[12] “AlphaGo: The Story so Far.” <em>Deepmind</em>, deepmind.com/research/case-studies/alphago-the-story-so-far.</p><p><a href="https://deepmind.com/research/case-studies/alphago-the-story-so-far">AlphaGo: The story so far</a></p><p>[13] Goodfellow, Ian, et al. “Generative adversarial nets.” <em>Advances in neural information processing systems</em>. 2014.</p><p><a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.2661">Generative Adversarial Networks</a></p><p>[14] Zhu, Jun-Yan, et al. “Unpaired image-to-image translation using cycle-consistent adversarial networks.” <em>Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on computer vision</em>. 2017.</p><p><a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.10593">Unpaired Image-to-Image Translation using Cycle-Consistent Adversarial Networks</a></p><p>[15] Salian, Isha. “Stroke of Genius: GauGAN Turns Doodles into Stunning, Photorealistic Landscapes.” <em>The Official NVIDIA Blog</em>, 18 Mar. 2019, blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2019/03/18/gaugan-photorealistic-landscapes-nvidia-research/.</p><p><a href="https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2019/03/18/gaugan-photorealistic-landscapes-nvidia-research/">GauGAN Turns Doodles into Stunning, Realistic Landscapes | NVIDIA Blog</a></p><p>[16] Roose, Kevin. “Here Come the Fake Videos, Too.” <em>The New York Times</em>, The New York Times, 5 Mar. 2018, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/04/technology/fake-videos-deepfakes.html.">www.nytimes.com/2018/03/04/technology/fake-videos-deepfakes.html.</a></p><p>[17] Radford, Alec. “Better Language Models and Their Implications.” <em>OpenAI</em>, OpenAI, 11 May 2020, openai.com/blog/better-language-models/.</p><p><a href="https://openai.com/blog/better-language-models/">Better language models and their implications</a></p><p>[18] Payne, Christine McLeavey. “MuseNet.” <em>OpenAI</em>, OpenAI, 29 June 2020, openai.com/blog/musenet/.</p><p><a href="https://openai.com/blog/musenet/">MuseNet</a></p><p>[19] Garbade, Michael J. “10 First Jobs That Will Be Eliminated by AI.” <em>Medium</em>, Medium, 30 Aug. 2019, medium.com/@ledumjg/10-first-jobs-that-will-be-eliminated-by-ai-c5c481b5ecbb.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@ledumjg/10-first-jobs-that-will-be-eliminated-by-ai-c5c481b5ecbb">10 First Jobs that Will Be Eliminated by AI</a></p><p>[20] Smith, Allen. “AI: Discriminatory Data In, Discrimination Out.” <em>SHRM</em>, SHRM, 28 Feb. 2020, <a href="http://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/employment-law/pages/artificial-intelligence-discriminatory-data.aspx.">www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/employment-law/pages/artificial-intelligence-discriminatory-data.aspx.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/employment-law/pages/artificial-intelligence-discriminatory-data.aspx">AI: Discriminatory Data In, Discrimination Out</a></p><p>[21] Pichai, Sundar. “AI at Google: Our Principles.” <em>Google</em>, Google, 7 June 2018, <a href="http://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">AI at Google: our principles</a></p><p>[22] “AI Policy — United States.” <em>Future of Life Institute</em>, futureoflife.org/ai-policy-united-states/?cn-reloaded=1.</p><p><a href="https://futureoflife.org/ai-policy-united-states/?cn-reloaded=1">AI Policy - United States - Future of Life Institute</a></p><p>[23] Lawrence, Brenda L. “Text — H.Res.153–116th Congress (2019–2020): Supporting the Development of Guidelines for Ethical Development of Artificial Intelligence.” <em>Congress.gov</em>, 27 Feb. 2019, <a href="http://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-resolution/153/text.">www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-resolution/153/text.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-resolution/153/text">Text - H.Res.153 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): Supporting the development of guidelines for ethical development of artificial intelligence.</a></p><p>[24] Kearns, Michael J., and Aaron Roth. <em>The Ethical Algorithm: the Science of Socially Aware Algorithm Design</em>. Oxford University Press, 2020.</p><p>[25] Harari, Yuval N. <em>Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow</em>. [Toronto, Ontario]: Signal, 2015.</p><p>[26] Haidt, Jonathan. <em>The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion</em>. New York: Pantheon Books, 2012. Print.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a59cfb8d8d14" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/machine-minds-a59cfb8d8d14">Machine Minds</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Monsters We’ve Made]]></title>
            <link>https://jordanlei.medium.com/the-monsters-weve-made-f101fa084569?source=rss-c6338bd93f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f101fa084569</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monsters]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jordan Lei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Jul 2020 18:45:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-25T18:48:10.222Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qM7eWSlg7o2jpO-W.JPG" /><figcaption><em>Valley of Aosta: Snowstorm, Avalanche and Thunderstorm, William Turner. Wikimedia Commons.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>on monsters</h3><p>This is the fourth chapter in a series of pieces about our modern relationship with time and the future. Titled <em>Hourglass</em>, It’s an exploration into how our abstract view of time has changed in modernity, how it has met (or has yet to meet) the needs of the present, and what we can do to better prepare ourselves for what’s to come.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/hourglass-our-modern-relationship-with-time-ed9538a498ec">First Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/mortal-prophecies-hourglass-ch-3-2af76f886719">Previous Chapter</a> / <a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/history-shattered-5d5ad3e03124">Next Chapter</a></p><p>But first, let’s talk about the end of the world.</p><h3>The Day the World Ended</h3><p>On April 10, 1815, the world ended. It began with a rumble, from deep within the earth, a hunger reminiscent of old gods and titans that had been left disregarded for too long and refused to be ignored. Next came fire. The sky erupted in flames, plumes of smoke covering the sky in sheets, raining down ashes. If you were close enough, you’d be lucky to scream before you were killed on the spot. Rivers of hell poured down the countryside, destroying everything in their wake. <em>Well, fuck.</em> We had a good run, didn’t we? Humanity had finally met its match.</p><h3>The Year Without Summer</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*X1q1hix34VsSvfEZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Mount Tambora. Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure><p>So it must have seemed for anyone living near Sumbawa, Indonesia at the time. Mount Tambora’s eruption was the largest recorded volcanic eruption in human history, 100 times bigger than that of Mt. St. Helens¹. In roughly 3 days, 175 cubic kilometers of volcanic debris was ejected into the air, comprising of about 50 cubic kilometers of magma². In colloquial terms, that’s known as a <em>shitload</em> of magma. No one knew it at the time, but halfway around the world, Europe would be plunged into nearly two years of winter, earning 1816 the nickname “The Year Without a Summer”. These next few years would destroy the livelihoods of countless farmers as failed harvests and poor crop yields drove them into hunger and famine¹. In short, 1815–1817 turned out to be a pretty terrible year for just about everybody. But, fortunately for us, some people didn’t quite get the memo.</p><p>On that very same year where summer was robbed from Europe, a small group of English tourists decided to self-isolate in summer villa near Geneva³. Picture this: a group of young adults, holed up for the summer (which was really the winter), in a nice little villa, the storm outside battering at the windows as a warm fire crackled inside. A perfect time to exchange spooky ghost stories. Also a perfect time, these rascals decided, to get <em>hilariously and ridiculously high on opium¹. </em>And so they did. Let’s meet the crew, shall we?</p><p>Two poets, Lord Byron and Percy Shelley, were present. But most notably was the to-be novelist Mary Shelley, who over her time in dreary, wintry Switzerland, would write <em>Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus </em>when she was only 18. The story follows Victor Frankenstein on his attempt to create sentient life — known simply as “the Creature”, the being, described at first as beautiful, begins to repulse Dr. Frankenstein once he realizes what he’s made. In a desperate attempt to find love, the Creature turns to his creator in a plea to make him a companion. Victor adamantly refuses, turning the Creature against him, ultimately spelling out death and destruction for Victor’s loved ones, the Creature, and Victor himself⁴.</p><p>Modern portrayals of Frankenstein show his beast as a horrid creation, a destructive force that inspires fear and terror. But it misses out on the incredible nuance of the story itself. A key feature that is often overlooked is the alleged <em>beauty</em> of his creation at first sight; indeed, Frankenstein modeled the beast after an ideal, hoping to create a being that was better than himself. It’s not until later that the doctor deems his creation hideous and wretched. A second point is the lesser well-known subtitle of the book: <em>the Modern Prometheus. </em>Prometheus was a titan who shaped humans out of clay. In a famous act of compassion, Prometheus stole fire from the gods and bestowed it upon mankind — a tool so useful that they, too, could become god-like. As punishment for his hubris, the gods sent him to exile, forever chained to a rock and having his liver eaten by an Eagle every day. Victor, like Prometheus, suffers from his hubris in creating something that he wishes to be greater than himself, leading to his eventual downfall.</p><h3>The Postmodern Prometheus</h3><p>The themes in Shelley’s novel are perhaps more relevant today than ever. With the creation of novel gene-editing technologies like CRISPR-Cas9, it’s now possible to make selective edits to DNA⁵. These may prove incredibly useful in treating diseases like HIV, sickle-cell anemia, and cancer⁵. But the bigger question remains about the use of this technology beyond their ability to heal — it’s not a question of <em>if</em>, but <em>when</em>, these technologies will be used to enhance or modify humans in ways we can’t even imagine⁶. True, current technologies are still in their early stages, but progress is accelerating faster than regulations, and we may soon be looking over the edge of creation itself⁶. <em>Frankenstein</em> can be viewed as a warning for the road ahead, one which we need to treat seriously; in order to avoid making catastrophic mistakes. <em>Descent with modification, indeed.</em></p><p>These themes extend beyond our physical bodies to encompass our minds as well — an idea we will return to in a later chapter. Already, companies like <a href="https://deepmind.com/">Google’s DeepMind</a> and <a href="https://openai.com/">OpenAI</a> are using brain-inspired algorithms (also known as “Deep Neural Networks” or “Deep Learning”) to generate music, drive cars, and win at strategy-based videogames. If you’re hoping that these companies have strong ethics guidelines and detailed plans for the road ahead, I have some less-than-encouraging news for you. First, the guidelines that the government has on these novel technologies are more or less nonexistent, or at the very least laughably insufficient. One needs to look no further than Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook CEO, and his testimony to Congress to see that our politicians are totally out of their depth. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2H8wx1aBiQ">Here’s a now-infamous exchange from that hearing:</a></p><blockquote><strong>Orrin Hatch [R-UT]:</strong> “How do you [Mark Zuckerberg] sustain a business model in which users don’t pay for your service?”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Mark Zuckerburg: </strong>“Senator, we run ads.” <em>[7]</em></blockquote><p>That was in 2018. Facebook introduced ads in 2007, over a decade earlier⁸. It’s also hard to imagine a case where companies can successfully self-regulate; existing ethics guidelines sound more aspirational than actionable, and most are often incredibly vague, and not particularly insightful. See for yourself: <a href="https://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">here’s Google’s set of AI guidelines, written by the CEO, Sundar Pichai⁹.</a> But this chapter isn’t about the specifics of artificial intelligence, it’s about what Shelley’s story has to say about it. And it turns out, quite a lot. <em>Frankenstein</em> is an exploration into the creation of sentient beings, and the consequences it holds for us. Victor was lucky. His Creature wanted a partner, something he was presumably able to provide if he wanted to. What if we create intelligence for which we have nothing to offer? More on that in a later chapter.</p><p>These are all fascinating exercises in creative imagination, ones that people far above my pay grade have been chipping away at for decades. But I want to refocus for a second on Mary Shelley. Don’t you worry, in a few chapters we’ll return to the story of mankind and its future; after all, this is what I promised a whole three chapters ago. But for now, let’s focus on <em>Frankenstein</em>, not what the book spells out for our future, but what it did to our past.</p><h3>The Monsters We’ve Made</h3><p>If you leaf through old epics, you’ll find countless tales of adventurers and heroes. You’d come across Prometheus, who as we discussed earlier, gave fire to mankind at great personal cost. You’d come across stories of Hercules, of the Trojan War. But one thing you’d find is that all these stories would have been set in time periods long ago, filled with adventurers who tackled a primordial world that was wilder, larger, more impressive than the tame world that humans at the “present date” currently occupied. Take the <em>Aeneid, </em>written by Virgil around 20 B.C., for example. The stories that he recounted happened a full millennium before he wrote a single word! Of course, there were always plenty of people willing to write about the present, but the instigator of the plot was almost always human or supernatural in nature. In other words, the plot was driven by existing or past technologies, agents, or beings. <em>Frankenstein </em>changed all that.</p><p>For the first time, the story is moved forward not by an act of God or man alone. Set indeterminately in the 18th century, the story is modern and more or less contemporary with Mary Shelley. Victor creates his so-called monster from technology that did-not yet exist out of a medium, electricity, which was not yet fully understood. The future, not the past, was of interest — it was bigger, more interesting, more dangerous. The past was taken off of its pedestal, and the future came in to take its place as muse. In one fell swoop, Mary Shelley had created a beast of her own, one that would have incredible consequences for the future of literature. She had written a story, set near the present, using technologies of the future as the main instigator. She wouldn’t know it then, but she just invented the genre of science fiction, mind you, at the age of 18.</p><p>Today we equate science fiction with stories of space travel, alien technology, and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Qm_UJML54">fantastical book covers</a>¹⁰ with their unique, wacky style. They captured the popular imagination, pushing the reader to imagine what comes next. As an art form, they detached themselves from other narratives that held fast to things currently in existence: old ways of living, old means of communication, even old gods, and replaced them with entirely new and alternate realities that were dizzying and disorienting, packed full of creative ideas about the future and the present. Science fiction was engaged in world-building, yes, but also future-building. By constructing worlds that were compelling, emotional, and complex, science fiction authors convinced readers that the future might hold something strange, something exciting, something, well, new! In short, science fiction helped pioneer the future as we know it — not just by presenting us with alternate realities that might come to fruition, but by challenging us to consider how our present might fit into that greater picture. In short, science fiction was a way for us to experience time travel (in itself another concept that many Sci-Fi writers began to explore) from the comfort of our own homes.</p><p>There were many things Mary Shelley didn’t know when she exchanged ghost stories with her friends. But cut her some slack, she had just invented a genre of writing; you’d be exhausted, too, if you had done the same. She didn’t know that the same volcano that had shrouded Europe in an unusually wintry summer would also tinge the sunsets remarkable shades of red. She didn’t know that the same year, a man by the name of William Turner would transfer these brilliant hues onto a canvas, marking a significant step towards abstraction in painting. Out of the winter would emerge a movement that had irreversible consequences for mankind. In 1818, Théodore Géricault would unveil his work <em>The Raft of the Medusa, </em>widely considered to be a seminal piece of work in this movement. This new intellectual movement emphasized humanism and liberalism as the paragons of morality, leading people towards enlightenment. At the same time, artists and scientists alike explored the power of emotion over rationality, an interplay that continues to this day in philosophical and scientific dialogue. This movement, later dubbed Romanticism (for its focus on emotions and individualism), would prove to be so influential that by 1882, German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche would proclaim that “God is dead … And we have killed him.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*80wDZO_Kuk-NyEzZ.jpg" /><figcaption>The Raft of the Medusa, Théodore Géricault. The image that started French Romanticism. Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure><p>Since Romanticism, many philosophical and scientific movements have reshaped history, but the core ideas of humanism and liberalism remain strong. In some ways, this was the monster that Shelley unwittingly released upon the world — a movement that neither she, nor any of Romanticism’s unknowing participants could stop in its tracks. Perhaps I wasn’t exaggerating when I said the world ended on April 10, 1815, the year when Mount Tambora erupted. In the aftermath of that eruption, humans developed the most powerful tool that we have today: the future — that everlasting flame of hope that sustains even the least religious among us. For the first time, humans were sacred — our very life, our minds, our will, defining the moral compass of the modern world. We were the ones who would wield the torch of the future, and we were the ones who would bring it into fruition. The old world, and the old order, lay bare before us, shattered and in pieces.</p><p>But as Shelley astutely pointed out, creation comes at a cost, and nowhere is it more clear than in the consequence of her work, and the work of other Romantic artists, scientists, and philosophers. When Nietzsche made his now-famous declaration, he didn’t do it out of glee or self-indulgence. He looked at the world the Romanticists envisioned, one in which humans, not God, play the central role in creation, and he realized the cost we paid for it. In creating our future, we had killed God.</p><p>It remains to be seen what monsters we will create in His absence.</p><blockquote>What was holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives: who will wipe this blood off us? What water is there for us to clean ourselves? What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we have to invent? Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us? Must we ourselves not become gods simply to appear worthy of it?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>— Friedrich Nietzsche</strong></blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@thunderflash.lei/history-shattered-5d5ad3e03124">Next Chapter: History, Shattered →</a></p><p>[1] Broad, William J. “A Volcanic Eruption That Reverberates 200 Years Later.” <em>The New York Times</em>, The New York Times, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com./2015/08/25/science/mount-tambora-volcano-eruption-1815.html.">www.nytimes.com./2015/08/25/science/mount-tambora-volcano-eruption-1815.html.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com./2015/08/25/science/mount-tambora-volcano-eruption-1815.html">A Volcanic Eruption That Reverberates 200 Years Later</a></p><p>[2] Klemetti, Erik. “Tambora 1815: Just How Big Was The Eruption?” <em>Wired</em>, Conde Nast, 10 Apr. 2015, <a href="http://www.wired.com/2015/04/tambora-1815-just-big-eruption/">www.wired.com/2015/04/tambora-1815-just-big-eruption/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.wired.com/2015/04/tambora-1815-just-big-eruption/">Tambora 1815: Just How Big Was The Eruption?</a></p><p>[3] Wood, Gillen D’Arcy. “The Volcano That Shrouded the Earth and Gave Birth to a Monster — Issue 31: Stress.” <em>Nautilus</em>, 31 Dec. 2015, nautil.us/issue/31/stress/the-volcano-that-shrouded-the-earth-and-gave-birth-to-a-monster.</p><p><a href="http://nautil.us/issue/31/stress/the-volcano-that-shrouded-the-earth-and-gave-birth-to-a-monster">The Volcano That Shrouded the Earth and Gave Birth to a Monster - Issue 31: Stress - Nautilus</a></p><p>[4] Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft, 1797–1851. Frankenstein, Or, The Modern Prometheus : the 1818 Text. Oxford ; New York :Oxford University Press, 1998.</p><p>[5] “What Are Genome Editing and CRISPR-Cas9? — Genetics Home Reference — NIH.” <em>U.S. National Library of Medicine</em>, National Institutes of Health, ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/genomicresearch/genomeediting.</p><p><a href="https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/genomicresearch/genomeediting">What are genome editing and CRISPR-Cas9?: MedlinePlus Genetics</a></p><p>[6] Harari, Yuval N. <em>Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow</em>. [Toronto, Ontario]: Signal, 2015.</p><p>[7]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fn2H8wx1aBiQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dn2H8wx1aBiQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fn2H8wx1aBiQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b704db4d89130351e68a68f95d267b46/href">https://medium.com/media/b704db4d89130351e68a68f95d267b46/href</a></iframe><p>[8] “Facebook Unveils Facebook Ads.” <em>About Facebook</em>, 7 Nov. 2019, about.fb.com/news/2007/11/facebook-unveils-facebook-ads/.</p><p><a href="https://about.fb.com/news/2007/11/facebook-unveils-facebook-ads/">Facebook Unveils Facebook Ads - About Facebook</a></p><p>[9] Pichai, Sundar. “AI at Google: Our Principles.” <em>Google</em>, Google, 7 June 2018, <a href="http://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/.</a></p><p><a href="https://www.blog.google/technology/ai/ai-principles/">AI at Google: our principles</a></p><p>[10]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FM7Qm_UJML54%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DM7Qm_UJML54&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FM7Qm_UJML54%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7a6994840dfeb814bc46faf574171d52/href">https://medium.com/media/7a6994840dfeb814bc46faf574171d52/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f101fa084569" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>