<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Goodman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Goodman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@josh-goodman?source=rss-b8dc6092928e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:02:16 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@josh-goodman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Analysis of the Starladder Major Berlin 2019 Quarterfinals: Astralis vs. Liquid]]></title>
            <link>https://josh-goodman.medium.com/analysis-of-the-starladder-major-berlin-2019-quarterfinals-astralis-vs-liquid-8590bfbd4130?source=rss-b8dc6092928e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8590bfbd4130</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[csgo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[counterstike]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Feb 2021 20:07:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-27T14:56:25.194Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>By Joshua Goodman</h4><h3>Introduction</h3><p>“It’s a shocking defeat for a team that has had an otherwise stellar 2019” were the words that came out of commentator Jason “Moses” O’Toole. The number 1 team in the world and clear favorites to win the Fall Major for 2019 in Counter-Strike:Global Offensive, the American side of Team Liquid, had just been stunned in a 2-0 loss to their long-time rivals from Denmark, Astralis. Before the remainder of the playoffs even continued most were calling this match the true final of the tournament, even though it occurred in the quarterfinals. Team Liquid were ranked #1 and were on a 6 event win streak where they had won 24 straight Best of 3/5 matches, the best any team had done in over 5 years. For them to do anything but win this Major would be a disappointment. Astralis, on the other hand, had suffered a dip in form during 2019. The 2-time reigning Major champions had started 2019 off with a bang winning the first Major of the year in convincing style, showing the world they were still at their peak. However, directly following their victory they would go on a cold streak, unable to repeat their unprecedented success from 2018 and took many months off for mental health and burnout reasons throughout the year. Going into this Major they were a large unknown to many experts. Which Astralis would show up?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KUJ2MzWfY7zZU2t2Ns68Yg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This paper will examine an economic analysis of this quarterfinal between Astralis and Liquid. Topics that will be addressed include tournament theory, a look at league governance for Counter-Strike:Global offensive and how it compares and contrasts to “traditional” sports, and finally a deep dive into the game theory and strategy behind the map selection process before the match, specifically Astralis’s decision to pick Vertigo as the first map. As most are unfamiliar with the game of Counter-Strike:Global Offensive (CSGO) an executive summary is directly below for some basic insights into the scoring and outline of the match.</p><h3>CSGO Summary</h3><p>CSGO is a First Person Shooter game from Valve Software. It is a 5v5 game with no substitutions. The game is a Best-of-30 rounds with each team being either the Terrorists or Counter-Terrorists. After Round 15 the teams switch sides and prepare for the second half. A team becomes victorious if they reach 16 rounds won during regulation. Should a tie of 15-15 occur, an overtime would begin with shortened, 3-round halves. If a team wins 4 out of these 6 rounds they will win the map, if the overtime ends in 3-3 split another overtime will commence. This continues until a team has won as there are no draws in CSGO. A typical playoff match in a CSGO tournament is a Best-of-3. This is akin to Tennis in some regards. For a team to win a match they must win enough rounds to win the map, and win 2 out of 3 maps to win the match. For professional play there are 7 possible maps that can be played in a series. The teams conduct a pick-ban selection process before the match to decide the maps that the match will unfold on.</p><h3>Tournament Theory</h3><p>To start any conversation on tournament theory it is important to understand the Principle-Agent Dilemma and who the principals and agents are in this competition. The Principle-Agent problem occurs because a principal cannot effectively monitor an agent at all times to ensure 100% effort and quality by the agent. Therefore, the agent has the opportunity to make mistakes or act against the principal&#39;s best interests and in their own self-interest instead. A way to attempt to solve this dilemma is for the principal and agent to enter into a contract which aligns the agent’s incentives with the interests of the principal. This gives direct motivation for the agent to perform to the best of their abilities and enact the principal’s vision. In professional CSGO the principal is the ownership group of the team and the agents are the 5 players competing in a team. When looking at this specific match there are 10 agents, the 5 players on Liquid (Elige, Nitro, Stewie, Twistz, Naf) and the 5 players on Astralis (Device, Dupreeh, Glaive, Magisk, Xyp9x). For Liquid the principals are the co-CEO’s of the team, Steve Arhancet and Victor Goossens. For Astralis the principals are their co-CEO’s, Nikolaj Nyholm and Anders Hørsholt. However, it’s important to keep in mind that for both teams the CEO’s are also agents with the shareholders being their principals who put their trust in the CEO’s to enact their vision for the company. Team Liquid is a private company with many investors including NBA legend Magic Johnson, Steve Case, and others. Astralis on the other hand is a public company traded on Nasdaq’s First Growth Market Denmark.</p><p>To properly incite effort the environment needs to allow for effort to directly impact productivity. In CSGO, this is the case. The more hours spent aim training or studying opponents past matches, the greater the performance in game tends to be. Another big factor in inducing effort is the difference between winning and losing a competition. In this match the losing side would leave with only $35,000 while the winners would secure at least $70,000 and play to win a total of $500,000 should they come in first place. This is a minimum 100% increase in prize money. In a 2 party competition with higher payouts for the winner, the incentive to win is higher which will lead to a higher investment of effort by the parties to maximize their probability of winning the competition (Lazaer &amp; Rozen, 1981). In addition to this, it has been shown that the bigger the spread between winning and losing, the larger the investment by the players. This effect is amplified even higher as a competition moves towards the final few matches or days (Ehrenberg &amp; Bognanno, 1990). The matchup in question was an elimination match in the quarterfinals of one of the largest monetary events on the professional CSGO calendar, meaning that not only was there a large monetary difference for winning or losing, but that the contest was in its later stages with even more incentive to exude more effort. Something unique to esports and CSGO in particular is how player’s contracts are incentivized. Not only do top level players have salaries between $20,000-$50,000 a month, but it’s commonplace for the players to get 100% of all prize money won, split evenly between all players (possibly a smaller share going to the team’s coach if they have one). Therefore in this situation the players are even more incentivized to win more prize money as they will keep all of it without any split to their organization.</p><p>In addition to the $1,000,000 prize pool the 8 teams that make the playoffs in CSGO Majors are automatically invited to the next Major as long as the retain 3/5 of their current roster. This invite is akin to the PGA Tour “exempt list” on a much smaller scale. With the PGA, players who have won any major tournament within the last 8-10 years were eligible to enter any tournament they pleased (Ehrenberg &amp; Bognanno, 1990). Since CSGO Majors are the pinnacle achievement in the scene, instant invitation is worth its weight in gold and therefore further incentivizes teams to reach the playoffs. Furthermore, by securing an invite to the next Major, each player on the roster has greatly increased their own bargaining power. Since teams must retain 3 out 5 current players, each player on the team has become exponentially more valuable and the risk of being cut and becoming a free agent drastically decreases with the securement of an invitation to compete at the next Major.</p><p>Another element of tournament theory is the need to sort through all possible players to have only those with the best skills to reach the top teams. In CSGO there are no minor leagues or farm systems that allow players to truly work their way up and ensure they are talented enough to compete against the best teams. Instead, the rise of young talent is done in one of 2 main ways. The first and more common is where players rise through the ranks of pick up game ladders and attract the attention of top teams. These games are not professional play but more akin to playing 5-on-5 pickup basketball and live streaming it to grow one’s brand. The more marketable and well known these players can become, the higher chance they have to create connections with current top level players, who have large influence over their team’s roster decisions. The second way to get to the top is to win your way there. Since CSGO is completely open-circuit, it is possible for any group of 5 players to band together and win any tournament in the circuit. This is less common as the best talent from up and coming teams are usually poached by larger organizations before they can reach this point. However, this open circuit allows for self-selection of the best talent as the only way to reach these high level events is to field top teams. Since there are no franchised spots, a team that decides to spend less on talent and field a lesser team will no longer qualify for events and be resigned to play smaller events against worse competition, out of the spotlight that top events have. Similarly, because there are next to no trade deadlines or contract restrictions, player’s are incentivized to put in their maximum effort throughout the year as they can quickly be replaced from an ever-growing talent pool. This job insecurity coupled with the monetary motivation of winning guarantees that top level professional players that want to keep their spot on a team will consistently be putting in the required hours to train and invest in their skills to constantly perform at the best of their abilities.</p><p>The organizer of this contest, Starladder, wants the best matchups between the best teams to occur later in the tournament in order to maximize viewership. To increase the chance of having the best teams competing in the playoffs Starladder modified the Swiss System group stage from chess and added in an elo rating system created by Arpad Elo, after which the playoffs would be played in single-elimination Best-of-3 matches. In this format teams are initially seeded by their average world ranking over the past 5 months according to the CSGO news website HLTV.org. The first round matchups between the 16 teams are based on these seedings, so #1 team played the #16 team, the #2 vs #15 and so on. Using an elo rating system based on the strength of the opponent all the teams have their ranking slightly adjusted due to their victory or defeat. Subsequent rounds following the initial rounds are “power-matched” where teams can only face each other if they have the same record (Hua, 2017). So after the first round in this contest 8 teams are 1-0 and the other 8 are 0-1. Now the highest ranked 1-0 team will play the lowest ranked 1-0 team, the highest ranked 0-1 team will play the lowest ranked 0-1 team. In addition, a team cannot play the same team more than once in the swiss system (Ólafsson 1990). This format continues for every team until they have either won 3 matches and advance to the playoffs or lose 3 matches and are eliminated from the tournament. Finally, to ensure the best teams would advance and the worst would be eliminated, all elimination and promotion matches were played in Best-of-3 format, which is typically reserved for the playoffs. This was so that if a team got a bad draw early on and went down 0-2, they could show they were superior in the Best-of-3’s and have a chance to win 3 straight matches and qualify for playoffs. Likewise, this made it so no team could make it to the playoffs without winning at least 1 Best-of-3 series. These series induce different efforts from the players at different points. It was found that in tennis matches the winner of the first set exerts more effort than their opponent, on average, during the second set and if the match goes to a third set, both competitors exert equal effort (Malueg &amp; Yates, 2010). In this group stage, 8/13 Best-of-3’s ended 2-0, meaning the winner of the first map carried the momentum into the second for a sweep, following Malueg &amp; Yates’ findings.</p><p>For Astralis and Liquid, who came into the tournament seeded #1 and #2 respectively (although Astralis had been slumping while Liquid was the clear favorite, Astralis had dominated the rankings in the first half of the year due to previous results and as such did not leave the #1 spot on the world rankings until May when Liquid dethroned them and began their own win streak), neither escaped the group stage with a perfect 3-0 record. Liquid was defeated by North-American rival NRG in the second round 1-0 matchups, falling to 1-1. There, they were shocked in overtime by huge underdogs AVANGAR from Kazakhstan, who came into the tournament ranked 14th out of the 16 teams competing. Now down to 1-2, Liquid were fighting for their tournament life and were able to claw out of the hole following back to back 2-0 victories against Danish side North and international squad Mousesports. Importantly, due to these losses and the structure of re-seeding teams after each round, Liquid entered the playoffs ranked #6 out of the 8 remaining teams, which meant they would face the #3 seed in the quarterfinals.</p><p>Astralis was able to avoid the early struggles that plagued their rivals in Liquid and reached the promotion 2-0 match without much issue. They did take a loss in this round against NRG but bounced back with a 2-1 win vs the Serbian team CR4ZY to advance to the playoffs with a 3-1 record. Due to this 1 loss Astralis were based on the elo seedings and were slated into the #3 spot, setting up a date with Liquid in the quarterfinals. It is vital to understand this information as the unique format of this tournament is what allowed the #1 and #2 ranked teams to face each other early on in the playoffs, a matchup that most spectators would have hoped to be the grand final.</p><h3>League Governance</h3><h4>Traditional Sports</h4><p>In traditional sports the league organizer aims to have the best product to sell to consumers and therefore are incentivized to have exciting matchups and more parity than dominance in a league. The greater the competition, the greater the profits are for the league and the teams in it in the long-run. This goes against a typical firm’s goals to achieve a monopoly to maximize profits due to the Louis-Schmelling Paradox, whereby it is in the best interests of the teams to create a cartel as sheer dominance by one team will lead to burnout of their audience and decreasing interest in each game (Neale, 1964). Teams can become dominant and become exciting but if their reign lasts too long without contest, fans will lose interest in their games and the league. Sports leagues take strides to achieve this parity thought competitive balance acts. These include salary caps, drafts, revenue sharing, and more. The end goal for all parties is to have their league be entertaining enough to fill stadiums throughout the year and garner large television audiences for every broadcast. Teams benefit from this via gate receipts from their home and away games, while the league itself massively benefits from large network television contracts to the rights of the league.</p><p>To achieve this goal, the competitive balancing measures must allow the league to be uncertain. In order to reach higher levels of uncertainty the league must have an equal distribution of top talent throughout the league (Rottenburg, 1956). As teams move towards being homogeneously talented, the uncertainty of each matchup increases up until it is a 50/50 tossup of who will win any single game. This is more hypothetical as Rottenburg mentions how there will always be teams with larger home markets or revenue and they can afford to pay top talent more than small market teams, leaving true uncertainty out of reach. In professional sports leagues across North America and Europe, competitive balance is enforced by an overarching governing body. For European Football this body is UEFA, which in turn is just one part of FIFA which governs all of international soccer. For closed franchise leagues such as the MLB, the MLB itself is the governing body which enters into a collective bargaining agreement with the MLB Players Association in order to effectively control the league. In these agreements both players and teams must agree to guidelines on topics such as revenue splits, free agency rules, contract minimums, salary cap, and more.</p><p>In North American sports the market for players has many constraints. For a team to acquire another player they either draft them, win the bidding war during free agency, or make a trade to acquire the play from another team. In soccer there is also the ability to purchase a player directly from another team for a set buyout price determined in their contract. Player’s rights have generally increased in sports throughout the late 20th century into today and have come a long way from the reserve clause of the early MLB where they were fully at the whim of their owners.</p><p>The market for CSGO players is based on that of soccer with some major differences. Just like soccer, CSGO has a large market for buyouts where a larger team will purchase the rights to a talented player to enhance their team. However, in CSGO, there is no union that has reached a CBA with the leagues running the events. This is due to many factors including top organizations acting as a cartel, the large pool of players willing to take cheaper salary for the opportunity to play, and the divided nature of esports with teams based across North and South America, Europe, Asia, and Australia. Experts believe that as time goes on and esports continues to grow a player’s union will rise and collective bargaining agreements will be formed and esports will start to mature (Ridenhour, 2020). But for now, CSGO players are unprotected and their leagues remain unbalanced. And without this CBA there exists no competitive balancing mechanisms such as a salary cap, draft, or any real governing force to balance the teams to create parity. Teams with enough capital can purchase the top players from all other teams if they wanted to and this has happened in the past. This had led to the HHI for CSGO Majors to be above 1500 as will be shown later.</p><p>While European Soccer is more of an open circuit than the franchised leagues of North America, CSGO embodies a much more pure iteration of the open circuit ideals. The developer and publisher of CSGO is Valve, who own the game. Unlike any other professional sports league, this company owns the IP of the entire sport. This means that if they wished to have unilateral control across the globe with no restrictions, they could do so. However, Valve is very famously laissez-faire about esports and controlling the circuit for their own games. Valve has stated that no company needs a license to host and operate a CSGO tournament with any teams in the world. This allows for a free market to operate for tournament organizers who want to enter the scene. The only event that Valve directly controls are the Majors. The Major was introduced by Valve in 2013 in order to reinvigorate attention around CSGO. Valve themselves funded the prize pool for the first Major, at a then impressive $250,000, and have done so for each of the subsequent 14 Majors that have occurred. In addition to giving out this prize money Valve have also created in-game cosmetics for all the teams and players competing in each Major. These include virtual stickers of team logos and player signatures that can be used in game, of which a percentage of each sale is given directly to the player or team that the item belongs to. For the Starladder Major Berlin 2019 Valve paid out over $11 million to players and teams from these cosmetics alone. Valve themselves do not organize the event though, instead they award complete control to independent organizers from a number of pitches. Similar to how FIFA awards the World Cup, these pitches are judged by country location, prior tournament organization experience, and scale. The company that wins this pitch is given near full control of the Major. They are able to sell the broadcast rights, receive 100% of ticket sales, as well as sell sponsorships for segments of the event and even a title/presenting sponsor. The Fall Major 2019 was awarded to Starladder, a Ukrainian company founded in 2001 which is predominately known for its events in the CIS (Commomwealth of Independent States) area. Starladder had already hosted over 20 top tier CSGO tournaments with great success. The distribution of which company receives the chance to host and run a Major is another issue to competitive balance. The organizer who runs the Major is given control over the most important segment of the CSGO competitive calendar and as such could purposely schedule qualifiers for the Major over their competitors event dates to increase their own market share.</p><p>When looking at how balanced CSGO is there is an important distinction that needs to be made from traditional sports, the idea of a team. In traditional sports the organization is the ownership and brand that pays the players, but in CSGO it is more common to associate the “core” of a team’s players as the team. For instance, in 2016 an upstart group of 5 Brazilian players won both Majors in a show of dominance. However, after their first victory they gained massive leverage to look for better contracts and the entire team of 5 was purchased by a different company which they competed under. The players were the same, the fans followed the players and not the organization. So when looking at competitive results it makes sense to consider 2 groups the same “team” if they share 3 out of 5 players in common. Now, dissecting competitive balance is slightly harder in CSGO as we cannot really look at win% as due to the open nature of the scene, a team can have a really large win percentage but play only a few top teams. Instead we will look at HHI of the Major championships to understand the parity in competitive CSGO. Table 2.0 below showcases both the HHI for the winners of each Major and also the tournament organizer who was chosen to host. Teams that played under different organizations but we consider the same “team” are numbered by their Core.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/733/1*HjlziduJunkHdppD5ZOK8g.png" /></figure><p>From this table we can see that the market for Major winners is slightly unbalanced but not towards a complete monopoly with an HHI of 1639. This shows that within the free market of CSGO, the Majors (which are the equivalent to a sports world championship), are not dominated by a few players and have more parity than some major sports. The more startling number is the HHI of organizers who have been chosen to host the Majors at 3954 which would be considered a highly concentrated market. The biggest player in this space is MTG (Modern Times Group) which owns 2 different tournament organizers, Dreamhack and ESL. This is concerning as MTG has hosted 60% of all Majors ever which means they have a strong market dominance over the CSGO competitive calendar.</p><p>Other organizer’s have tried to chip away at MTG’s hold on CSGO to little success. In 2020 3 different organizers have started to create revenue shares with the team’s competing in their leagues to incentive certain organizations to prioritize their events over their competitors. In February 2020 MTG met with the top teams across the globe in Paris in order to come to an agreement on how they can organize their event structure to the teams and players needs and requirements. Titled the “Louvre Agreement”, the meeting outlined that top teams have the ability to become partnered with MTG. Being an MTG partner entails automatic invites to every MTG event on the calendar with the requirement that they attend a certain amount each year to ensure each event has a high level of competition. These partner teams also gain power over the leagues that MTG operates with any new partner teams requiring 2/3rds approval from existing partners before being admitted.</p><p>With this agreement, partner teams will split 25% of operating revenue from MTG leagues before expenses, representing the first time that competitive CSGO has moved towards competitive balancing measures and structure of more traditional sports leagues. In addition these revenue shares are not equal and instead each partner’s individual revenue share is based on the number of events attended, competitive results and viewership. This provides further incentive for organizations to field highly competitive and marketable players to maximize their potential profits from MTG leagues.</p><p>Finally, the players for these top teams have come together to form a proto-players union called the Counter-Strike Professional Players&#39; Association (CSPPA). The CSPPA was present during the Louvre Agreement, giving the player’s a seat at the table for the first time in CSGO history. Through this new agency players are now entitled to receive 15% of the partner’s revenue share for MTG events. Now CSGO players are not only increasing their payouts by winning prize money but also from the event they are attending reaching higher viewership and driving more revenue. This in turn motivates the teams and players to exert more effort during media days and other obligations while attending the event.</p><p>The Louvre Agreement represents the dawn of a new era in competitive CSGO. As esports continues to grow every year, CSGO needs to adapt to the new attention that has been shined into their world. With this agreement teams, players, and organizers have created mutually beneficial relationships that motivate all parties to cooperate in order to maximize their own profits (Louvre Agreement. 2020).</p><h4>Other Esports</h4><p>It is important to note that other esports leagues have been ahead of the curve on CSGO in terms of moving towards traditional sports models. Other large publishers such as Activision-Blizzard or Riot Games take a more hands on approach and have franchised many of their own games with a slot costing upwards of $40 million for one team. As esports has grown globally these publishers and other tournament organizers are looking to transition to a more traditional competitive model based on that of the North American franchised leagues. This allows the publisher to increase revenue by charging franchise fees in the millions to enter their closed league as opposed to having a free market that operated before. This also appeals to the larger esports organizations who can afford to purchase these franchised spots as they no longer have to worry about qualifying to events or needing a top ranked team to maintain relevance. Since their business model is based on sponsorships, having their team getting guaranteed air time and viewership is preferred to needing a winning team to get air time.</p><p>These leagues also include collective bargaining agreements which in theory should increase the leverage and power for players in the league. However, the player’s union that represents all professional players in each of 3 current franchised esports leagues (Overwatch, Call of Duty, and League of Legends) is also owned and operated by the publisher who is running the league itself (Melrose, 2018). Esports is ripe with conflicts of interest and clearly the players in these leagues have not yet created a coordinated effort to make their own union and instead are now at the complete control of the publisher.</p><p>Valve have made it clear they have no interest in going down this route and want CSGO to maintain an open circuit with any organizer able to host a tournament should they have the capabilities. They have fought against circuit exclusivity by issuing statements like the following as a warning to those who wish to restrict a team&#39;s ability to play in their competitors events, “At this time we are not interested in providing licenses for events that restrict participating teams from attending other events” (Valve, 2019). With this in mind the future of the competitive Counter-Strike events will be a battle to take control of the tournament market with MTG currently controlling over 60% of the calendar and no other organizer being able to compete on the same scale and volume.</p><h3>Strategy</h3><p>There are many different ways to analyze the strategy of a CSGO match. From Counter-terrorist side setups, to full site executes, fake executes, clutches, flashes, and more. But for this particular match arguably the most important strategy took place before the players even entered the server with the map selection process.</p><p>In CSGO there are 7 competitive maps in the pool at any one time. This means that in any match you could potentially play any of the 7 maps. Each team has strengths and weaknesses on every map and can have extremely varying win rates for each map. During the Starladder Major Berlin 2019 the 7 maps in the playing pool were: Dust2, Inferno, Mirage, Nuke, Overpass, Train, and Vertigo. Liquid and Astralis’s respective win rates and stats for each map factored into the map veto preparation.</p><p>The map selection process for a competitive CSGO Best-of-3 is a 6 step pick/ban process whereby 3 maps are chosen to be played in the series. Before the selection, one team is assigned to be “Team A” and the other “Team B” this can be decided by coin flip or possibly by whoever is the higher seed in the tournament. This typically doesn’t have a huge impact but does change which team goes first in the selection process. For the Majors the veto process goes in the following order.</p><ol><li>Team A bans a map</li><li>Team B bans a map</li><li>Team A picks a map, Team B picks which side to start on</li><li>Team B picks a map, Team A picks which side to start on</li><li>Team B bans a map</li><li>Team A bans a map and the leftover map is made the decider if necessary</li></ol><p>Liquid’s map pool statistics up to their Starladder Major quarterfinal faceoff with Astralis are shown in Table 3.0 below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/722/1*TplcFqAKGvmHcJNWnu5sRQ.png" /></figure><p>These stats reflect Liquid’s incredible dominance over the Spring and Summer of 2019 in CSGO. Their worst map, Nuke, had a win rate of 64.3% and they had won their last 5 matches on Nuke coming into the Major. The only map they don’t play is Train and due to the format of the map selection, they can have Train as the “permaban” to ensure it never comes into play. This left 6 maps at an elite level of play and had won their last 6 tournaments, which led to them having a 24 Best-of-3/5 winning streak, one of the longest in CSGO history. Their other active winstrikes included 13 in a row on Mirage, 9 in a row on Inferno, and the 100% win rate on the 5 matches they’ve played on Vertigo. In the last 55 maps Liquid had played up to this match, they had only lost 9 maps.</p><p>For Astralis, who were not as active in the Spring and Summer months of 2019, their map pool statistics for the 4 months leading up to their matchup with Liquid are represented in Table 3.1</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/737/1*47qnP_i3g5DGQH78TO0LoQ.png" /></figure><p>From these statistics it is clear why Liquid was favored going into their quarterfinal matchup. Similar to Liquid’s permaban of Train, Astralis had a permaban of Mirage which they would ban in their first decision during the veto process. Astralis’s few strong maps were also strong maps for Liquid. This meant that even if they got a map veto to end up in their 3 highest win percentage maps being played, Liquid would still be favored to win. However, these statistics are against any team, to get a much better picture it’s important to look at the last time Astralis and Liquid played each other and how the map selection process unfolded.</p><p>On June 19th 2019, in the quarterfinals of the ESL Pro League Season 9 Finals, Astralis and Liquid faced off in a Best-of-3 series where Liquid won in a closely contested 2–1 victory. The map veto for this series went as follows:</p><ol><li>Liquid ban Train</li><li>Astralis ban Mirage</li><li>Liquid pick Overpass</li><li>Astralis pick Inferno</li><li>Astralis ban Dust2</li><li>Liquid ban Nuke, Vertigo is the decider</li></ol><p>The results for this series were an Astralis victory on Overpass (16–12), a Liquid victory on Inferno (16–6) and a Liquid victory on Vertigo (16–13) to take the series. Based on this previous map veto the idea of dominated strategies starts to take shape for both teams. Astralis and Liquid each have a map that they believe they are so weak on that if they play it, they will lose. As such these maps represent a teams dominated strategy and we can therefore simplify the game tree by using the Iterated Elimination of Strictly Dominated Strategies. A strategy is considered strictly dominated if there exists another strategy whereby the payoffs are strictly better than the previous strategy for all outcomes (Dutta 1999). For these teams the dominated strategy would be picking their permanently banned maps, or leaving them for other teams to pick against them. Liquid’s dominated strategy is not banning Train and it is dominated by removing it during their first ban phase. Similarly, Astralis’s dominated strategy is not banning Mirage and it is dominated by removing it during their first ban phase. Now the game is simplified by removing the first 2 bans as they both are the removal of the dominated maps for each team. The new map veto process after elimination consists of 5 maps (Dust2, Inferno, Nuke, Overpass, Vertigo) and 4 steps:</p><ol><li>Team A picks a map</li><li>Team B picks a map</li><li>Team B bans a map</li><li>Team A bans a map and the last map is made the decider</li></ol><p>On September 6th, 2019, when Astralis and Liquid faced off in Berlin in front of a sold out Mercedes-Benz Arena, the greatest shock came during the map selection process. Astralis was the higher seed so they were Team A while Liquid became Team B. The full veto process went as follows:</p><ol><li>Astralis ban Mirage</li><li>Liquid ban Train</li><li>Astralis pick Vertigo</li><li>Liquid pick Overpass</li><li>Liquid ban Nuke</li><li>Astralis ban Dust2, Inferno is the decider map</li></ol><p>Looking at this game in extensive-form after removing the dominated strategies is visualized in Graph 3.2:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*13AvXBf-uWpfXLxN" /><figcaption>The green lines represent a team’s pick options while the red lines represent their ban options</figcaption></figure><p>This veto results in the same 3 maps being played as the last matchup between the 2 teams with Overpass, Inferno, and Vertigo, however in this game they appear in a different order and this drastically impacted the outcome of the game. The most interesting decision made in this selection process was the surprise pick of Vertigo by Astralis. A dissection of this choice is illustrated in Graph 3.3</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZuDedWt2Be2aPeIi" /></figure><p>Based on these win percentages conventional knowledge and experts predictions believed that Astralis would pick into Inferno as a safety pick as it was currently their most successful map even though Liquid beat them on it the last time they played. Or they would pick Nuke as a show of confidence, a map where they had previously won 31 straight and for a long time was considered the “home map” of Astralis. However, Astralis did neither and instead picked Vertigo where they had won 2 out of 3 with the sole loss being a 16–13 defeat to Liquid, who were an undefeated 5–0 on the map since its release. The live reaction to this pick was deafening, the crowd roared, the analysts claimed that this picked showed that Astralis thought they were an underdog and needed a curveball in order to have a chance to win, and Liquid themselves had a look of bewilderment at the confusing pick in front of them.</p><p>Looking further into the potential payouts for each of the 5 options Astralis faced it becomes clear why Vertigo was the optimal choice for them. The best choice for Astralis is the map where they have the best chance to win vs Liquid. On Dust2, Inferno, and Nuke, their current form was poor or worse than that of Liquid. Also, Astralis was expected to pick one of either Inferno or Nuke, meaning that Liquid would be able to prepare against this pick in preparation, which would lower Astralis’s chance to win even further. Down to Vertigo and Overpass as the remaining 2 options it would seem that Astralis would want to play Overpass as it is the only map where their past win percentage is higher than that of Liquid. However, the format of this game is considered a sequential move game with <em>imperfect information</em>. In this disparity of information lies the deciding factor that led Astralis to pick Vertigo.</p><p>The true reason behind the confusion was the information difference between the 2 teams. Liquid believed they knew Astralis’s strengths, weaknesses, and current form but it had been over 3 months since the 2 sides last faced off. Astralis had taken this time to secretly prepare a completely new game plan on Vertigo in anticipation of this very moment in order to pull out the victory. Part of this secret strategy was maintaining it’s secrecy and purposely avoiding playing Vertigo much in the months leading up to the Major and even when playing it, never picking it but instead having it be the decider. Astralis’ coach, zonic, had this to say when asked about the surprise Vertigo pick after the match, “When I was looking at Liquid’s win streak on different maps, it was kind of like ‘what to pick?…We kind of wanted to catch them off-guard. We’ve been really good in practice on Vertigo, extremely good playing against all different teams, so it was also a case of not falling into old habits…It was about going a different route this time and then winning the mind game” (HLTV.org, 2019).</p><p>Liquid on the other hand, were completely caught off guard and had not prepared to play Vertigo against Astralis in this match. Had Liquid known Astralis’s prowess on Vertigo they would have instead chosen to ban it instead of Train. However, since teams are naturally risk averse, the risk of potentially playing their worst map in Train outweighed any other possibility Liquid thought they could face. They played it safe and Astralis took advantage of this unequal information between the teams. Due to the large disparity in preparation spent for Vertigo, the chance of Astralis winning this match heavily swung towards the Danish side. And since Astralis had banked on this pick being a surprise, they knew they were going to play a wild card and hoped to take the momentum from this pick and steamroll into a full match victory on the second map of Overpass. Following along the ideas mentioned in Malueg &amp; Yates this is exactly what unfolded. After shocking the world with their Vertigo pick, Astralis was able to win with a convincing scoreline of 16–8. Moving towards Overpass, Astralis had all the momentum having just broken Liquid’s undefeated streak on Vertigo. With this added momentum their effort exerted was most likely higher than that of the now slightly demoralized Liquid and this led Astralis to taking the map victory, 16–13. With this Astralis won the quarterfinal 2–0, with the entire victory stemming from their decision to pick Vertigo during the map veto.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Counter-Strike: Global Offensive’s Starladder Major Berlin 2019 quarterfinals between Astralis and Liquid represents the essence of competitive Counter-Strike. Astralis’s surprise victory propelled them to their 3rd straight Major victory and their 4th overall while Liquid’s failure to perform on the world’s biggest stage remains a talking point with this match as the prime example.</p><p>This match elicited large interest from fans across the world, both in person at the sold out 17,000 person arena in Berlin and the hundreds of thousands watching live on the internet. CSGO still has a long way to go before it can be considered in the same sentence as traditional sports leagues such as the NFL, MLB, UEFA, and others, but all the pieces necessary to build a league that scales over time are there.</p><p>Valve Software has created a tournament structure where effort is correlated to success and more importantly, effort is rewarded with increased payoffs for winning. Although no large-scale competitive balancing has taken place, the Louvre Agreement signed by top teams and MTG signifies the start of stricter league governance and more balancing to create a more competitive scene that is not dominated by organizations with the most money to spend.</p><p>Finally, it is clear that decisions matter in Counter-Strike. In this quarterfinal the most crucial choice was made before the 10 players even entered the server. Astralis’s ability to understand their opponent and base their decisions on this information is what led to their eventual victory and Major championship run.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Dutta, P. K. (1999). Strategies and Games: Theory and Practice. Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxeSXHD37Bt5TlI5VHpyNEFPa28/view">https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxeSXHD37Bt5TlI5VHpyNEFPa28/view</a></p><p>Ehrenberg, R. G. &amp; Bognanno, M. L. (1990). Do tournaments have incentive effects? <em>Journal of Political Economy</em> 98(6), 1307–1324.</p><p>HLTV.org. (2020). Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://www.hltv.org/">https://www.hltv.org/</a></p><p>Hua, C. (2017). The Swiss Tournament Model. <em>University of Pennsylvania Scholars Commons</em>. Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://repository.upenn.edu/wharton_research_scholars/149/">https://repository.upenn.edu/wharton_research_scholars/149/.</a></p><p>Lazear, E. P., &amp;amp; Rosen, S. (1981). Rank-Order Tournaments as Optimum Labor Contracts. <em>Journal of Political Economy</em>, 89(5), 841–864. doi:10.1086/261010</p><p>Louvre Agreement. (2020, February 18). Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://pro.eslgaming.com/csgo/proleague/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Louvre-Agreement.pdf">https://pro.eslgaming.com/csgo/proleague/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Louvre-Agreement.pdf</a></p><p>Malueg, D., &amp; Yates, A. (2010). TESTING CONTEST THEORY: EVIDENCE FROM BEST-OF-THREE TENNIS MATCHES. <em>The Review of Economics and Statistics,</em> <em>92</em>(3), 689–692.</p><p>Melrose, A. (2018, April 20). Legal Analysis of the Overwatch League Structure and the Code of Condu. Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://www.lawsofesports.com/single-post/2018/04/07/Legal-Analysis-of-the-Overwatch-League-Structure-and-the-Code-of-Conduct-A-Comparison-Study">https://www.lawsofesports.com/single-post/2018/04/07/Legal-Analysis-of-the-Overwatch-League-Structure-and-the-Code-of-Conduct-A-Comparison-Study</a></p><p>Neale, W. C. (1964). The Peculiar Economics of Professional Sports: A Contribution to the Theory of the Firm in Sporting Competition and in Market Competition. <em>The Quarterly</em></p><p><em>Journal of Economics</em>, 78(1), 1. doi:10.2307/1880543</p><p>Olafsson, S. (1990). Weighted Matching in Chess Tournaments. <em>Journal of the Operational Research Society,</em> <em>41</em>(1), 17–24. doi:10.1057/jors.1990.3</p><p>Ridenhour, K. F. (2020). Traditional Sports and Esports: The Path to Collective Bargaining. <em>Iowa Law Review,</em> 105(4), 1857–1897.</p><p>Rottenberg, S. (1956). The Baseball Player’s; Labor Market. <em>Journal of Political Economy</em>, 64(3), 242–258. doi:10.1086/257790</p><p>Valve. (2019, September 18). Keeping Things Competitive. Retrieved November, 2020, from <a href="https://blog.counter-strike.net/index.php/2019/09/25557/">https://blog.counter-strike.net/index.php/2019/09/25557/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8590bfbd4130" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Always a bridesmaid, never a bride: Datto and the elusive World’s First title]]></title>
            <link>https://josh-goodman.medium.com/always-a-bridesmaid-never-a-bride-datto-and-the-elusive-worlds-first-title-587e7cf113d5?source=rss-b8dc6092928e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/587e7cf113d5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[datto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[destiny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[raiders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 May 2019 16:52:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-19T23:35:22.402Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Throughout Destiny’s lifespan, the race to complete the new raids first has been the pinnacle PvE achievement that all high-end players strive for. In the over 4 years since Destiny’s release on September 9th, 2014 there have been 16 World’s First races, 9 full raids, and 7 hard or prestige mode raid versions. Some of these come with more weight than others, due to difficulty or lack of hype/excitement. Usually the normal release of a raid is considered more difficult as a fireteam has to go in blind and figure out all the mechanics, while a hard mode or prestige mode only has slight changes, or in the case of the Prestige Eater of World’s and Spire of Stars, no mechanical changes at all. From the very beginning, community figure <a href="https://twitter.com/dattosdestiny?lang=en">Datto</a> has been at the forefront of these World’s First races. And yet, after so many attempts and so many close finishes, he remains title-less as the one crowning achievement that has escaped him thus far. No single figure has consistently been in the top placings of Destiny’s World’s First races more than Datto.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*YJ5vjVg0BmOvkMgUizDdkA.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the very start with the release of Destiny’s first raid, Vault of Glass, Datto finished the grueling race second, placing behind his own clan mates in <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/511972115776425984">PrimeGuard who defeated Atheon </a>after a 14-hour battle and emerged from the Vault victorious. Then just a week later Datto was second fiddle once again, this time to InvigorateGaming who claimed the World’s First title for the Hard Mode of Vault of Glass. Back to back second place finishes is nothing to scoff at but Datto put it best when <a href="https://twitter.com/DattosDestiny/status/503965862781788160">he said,</a><em> “I have plenty of goals and all of those goals can be practiced; only 1 world first.” </em>There is only 1 World first, one team that can achieve greatness for that particular raid, and although high placings are impressive, we remember the victors and not those who came up short.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n6cWgwT_Fz9Jh2FvoEMVpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Vault of Glass (VoG) was Destiny’s first raid</figcaption></figure><p>History would seem to repeat itself once again as Datto placed <a href="https://www.bungie.net/en/News/Article/12465">third </a>in the race for Destiny’s 3rd title in Crota’s End on January 21st, 2015, with <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/542368300529750016">InvigorateGaming becoming the first team to get consecutive titles</a> and the only to hold 2 World’s First titles until Prestige Leviathan in Destiny 2. 3 raids, 3 top 3 finishes, and still no crown to claim for Datto. His consistency was unrivaled at the time and wouldn’t go anywhere anytime soon…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KYqGWHcLDtXsRsLO7ZbIFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Datto cemented his consistency at the top of World’s First races after he achieved top 3 once again in Crota’s End</figcaption></figure><p>For the next race he would have to wait, a full 9 months, when on September 18th, 2015 King’s Fall was released as part of The Taken King expansion. Datto was unable to keep up his prefect record of very top placings but did still manage a 19th place finish after a exhausting 11 hour fight to complete the raid. <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/645022733126864897">KingGothalion, and his fireteam consisting of many other top Destiny streamers,</a> emerged from the darkness as the first team to conquer this new raid, while Datto once again had to settle for something other than a title. In the follow up hard mode release of King’s Fall, Datto once again slipped slightly further down the rankings, completing the race in 26th place. While a large fall from his past performances, Datto was still maintaining top 30 finishes despite his struggles, and staying competitive in nearly every race until the end.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3JaQeI7qZ5SL_gEc1CuCAA.jpeg" /><figcaption>While Datto didn’t perform as well as he did during the previous raid races, he was still a top finisher for Destiny’s 3rd full raid, King’s Fall</figcaption></figure><p>There would be a large gap between raid releases as no new expansions were released until Rise of Iron and its raid, Wrath of the Machine on September 23rd, 2016. Datto would slightly bounce back as he claimed 14th place as <a href="https://twitter.com/bungie/status/779399992859504640?lang=en">Clan Redeem would grab their first World’s First title</a>, with now familiar names such as ModernTryhard, Fleshcrunch, and Ehroar, as well as speedrunner turned Fortnite pro Tfue. 3 weeks later in the hard mode release Datto fell down to 29th place in one of the fastest races to date with only a 20 minute gap between 6th and 32nd place. For the first time an unknown team called Clan Die Busfahrer or, The Bus Drivers, crossed the finish line first to earn their title.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*hnb8QwMgAqZr4QaaGc3U2A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wrath of the Machine would see a significant drop off for Datto in its 2 WF races</figcaption></figure><p>Once again raiders would have to wait to test their strength as there wouldn’t be another raid until the launch of the second iteration in the Destiny franchise with Destiny 2 and the raid that came with it, The Leviathan on September 13, 2017. A new game meant a new start for all players who had hopes of ascending to the throne of first in the world to conquer a new activity but it was a familiar face to the Destiny community that would be the first to grow fat from strength and defeat Calus on the Leviathan. After 5 and a half hours hardcore PvE streamer<a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/908099898838368256"> sc_Slayerage and his team, The Legend Himself</a> achieved greatness and got their first WF title under their belts. Datto ended up in 9th place, once again breaking the top 10 barrier and establishing that even in a new version of the game, he was not going anywhere in these races. In the drama-filled Prestige mode, Destiny 2&#39;s version of hard mode raids, Datto placed a respectable 14th in a race that is still a subject of contention. The Leviathan was an opportunity for Datto to shred his past of coming up short in all previous World First races, however he once again showed his consistency and ability to keep up with the very best in the world while still just shy of beating them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QIfGcU5Ca6-PJYs7RvW6fw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Destiny 2’s “The Leviathan” offered a fresh start to the raiders of Destiny old and new</figcaption></figure><p>Bungie took a different direction with Destiny 2 and instead of releasing full length raids in the first year of its release, they decided to release one raid and 2 raid <em>lairs, </em>or just smaller and shorter versions than a full sized raid would entail. The first of these was called Eater of Worlds and was released December 8, 2017 and once again Datto would have a respectable yet disappointing finish: <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/939223332381011969">Placing 18th behind a surprising LFG team taking first. </a>Once again a top 20 ranking is nothing to be scoffed at but it seemed to be that Datto was cursed, forever destined to be within striking distance of the pinnacle PvE achievement but always coming up just shy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m0hDnD2qujD0p8USOFJMug.jpeg" /></figure><p>The next raid lair, Spire of Stars released in May 11, 2018, didn’t bode much better for Datto and Co. as he once again had to settle for a top <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/995088059996688384">placing behind Clan Redeem</a> as he came in at 11th. Now, in July 2018 Bungie released the Prestige versions of both raid lairs but importantly there were no mechanical differences, and as such I have decided not to include those races in my judgement of Datto and his placements as I as well as others do not believe these races had the same weight as the others before it. The next true raid race would have to wait until September 2018, when the race of a lifetime would take place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LvkXQM5uNd-_XZld-38J1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>In Fall 2018 Bungie released the Forsaken expansion for Destiny 2 and with it, Last Wish, Destiny’s newest and biggest raid to date. It was announced that the winners of this raid race would receive real life championship belts commemorating their victory as well as any team to finish the raid within 24 hours would be rewarded with an in-game emblem otherwise unobtainable. Remember that second part carefully. To say that this race had people excited is an understatement; thus far in Destiny’s history no other race except perhaps the original Vault of Glass could compare to the hype and excitement Bungie had built around Last Wish. Everyone was praying that the raid itself would live up to expectations put around it…and what a race it was.</p><p>After almost 19 debilitating hours of fighting a team emerged from the Dreaming City as champions, but it wasn’t Datto and the rest of his Math Class ensemble. Instead Destiny saw <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/1040933057857908736">Clan Redeem claim yet another title</a> after the longest race Destiny has, and possibly ever will, see to claim World’s First. But Datto was still in the raid hoping to conquer this new raid before his 24 hours were up. At 22 hours a second team finished, Gigz and the rest of Tier1 claimed their emblems with not much time to spare. And in the final hour Datto seemed like it was meant to be; his team was clicking and it looked like there was time left to still finish this raid within a day. And as they finally crossed the finish line and checked their clocks, their hearts sank. Datto and Math Class had completed the new raid in a very impressive and intensive 3rd place, but more importantly and disappointing, in 24 hours and 2 minutes. Not only did Datto once again secure a top placing but fail to take that sought after trophy, he was painfully close to being 1 of 3 fireteams to even complete said raid in under 1 day. The 24:02 memes still persist to this day and it seems that coming so close after such a hard fought competition against the darkness will haunt those players until the end of time. Another race, another close call, another heartbreak as the pattern continued for Datto.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KPBOi3T38_MOvuZFdv3Qlw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Riven artwork by <a href="https://twitter.com/Paji__">@Paji__</a> of Clan Redeem’s fireteam conquering the raid</figcaption></figure><p>That brings us to the most recent Destiny raid at the time of writing, Scourge of the Past, released December 7th 2018 as part of the Black Armory content drop. In one of the shortest normal mode races, Insurrection Prime was bested in under <a href="https://twitter.com/Bungie/status/1071115566365065216">2 hours by Gigz and Tier1, </a>finally defeating their own curse of always coming close to the championship without being able to close. Datto would stumble in this short race as he finished in just over 3 hours in 20th place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R2RWZmIb3fHbsVZm48Rzsg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Throughout all these races the worst placement Datto has ever achieved was 29th while having 4 Top 3’s and a multitude of Top 10’s, a testament to his consistency not just in ranking but also in his presence throughout Destiny’s life. Very few players can say they have raided on Day 1 for every raid, less can say they finished, and even fewer can say they were in the running for being the first to finish. Datto can say all that and more and it would still be an understatement. No one, from streaming champion KingGothalion, to multiple title holder Clan Redeem, to any other raider in Destiny’s history can match Datto’s constant performance. Even comparing who he has raided with over the years, from that very first 2nd place finish in Vault of Glass almost 5 years ago to now, almost none of the names have persisted throughout Destiny’s history. Not only has Datto stayed around he has been a threat in nearly every race he’s participated in. Many top streamers and raiders even have said that if their own fireteam was unable to claim victory for themselves, they want to see Datto finally claim the title that has eluded him thus far.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/1*pKLMNvw3vE12Jr8R3FHFIQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>So where does that leave us today? It is near the end of May 2019 and the next raid, Crown of Sorrow, is set to be launched on June 4th. Bungie has recently announced that for this raid race there will be a new mode called <a href="https://www.bungie.net/en/Explore/Detail/News/47832">Contest</a> in play. While Contest is active, a period of the first 24 hours after the raid goes live, player Power level will be capped to even the playing field among players. This will be Datto’s 10th normal mode World First race, a feat on its own, and only time will tell if the curse will be continue or if Datto will break free of what has haunted him throughout Destiny’s history and be the first to complete this new challenge brought forth and claim his first title.</p><p>No matter what unfolds on June 4th Datto has something to be proud of; a legacy of incredible performances throughout all of Destiny’s raids and top placements unrivaled by anyone else in the community. All that remains is for a championship belt to sit atop his mantle, a sign that he finally accomplished what he set out to do long ago in 2014: Become legend and achieve World First status.</p><p><em>Written by Josh Goodman</em></p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/joshigoods"><em>Twitter</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshua-goodman/"><em>LinkedIn</em></a></p><p>Thank you to /u/<a href="https://old.reddit.com/user/dweezil22">dweezil22</a> of <a href="https://www.d2checklist.com/home">DestinyChecklist.net</a> for helping me recover WF raid rankings I previously had thought were lost in the past</p><p><strong>Disclaimer: </strong>For transparency with regards to their mention in this article, I am affiliated with <a href="http://twitter.com/ClanRedeem">Clan Redeem</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=587e7cf113d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The birth of the most dominant PvE clan in Destiny and the unlikely figure who made it all possible]]></title>
            <link>https://josh-goodman.medium.com/the-birth-of-the-most-dominant-pve-clan-in-destiny-and-the-unlikely-figure-who-made-it-all-possible-a16d4ee4cf81?source=rss-b8dc6092928e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a16d4ee4cf81</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[destiny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[destiny-2]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Jun 2018 15:35:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-28T15:35:32.913Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Bungie’s <em>Destiny, </em>the online FPS MMO, has a storied history of PvE (or Player vs Environment) clans and players being at the forefront of the title. From the very first clan to gain the status of World’s First with PrimeGuard in Destiny’s first raid, “Vault of Glass”, to the extremely popular clan “My Dad is Bungie” containing streamers such as KingGothalion and ProfessorBroman, achieving World’s First in “King’s Fall”, PvE members have been leading the community.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5LMchD3Kjdmb8U4atiquiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you’ve played <em>Destiny</em> you might have heard of a PvE clan called Redeem. They&#39;ve accumulated 3 <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqcsFkVKRe8">World’s First</a> titles across both <em>Destiny </em>iterations, completed some of the most difficult <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnewjGsfTyE">solos</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnewjGsfTyE">challenges</a> and their name has rang through the upper echelons of PvE for a majority of Destiny’s history. But the story behind the rise to success for Redeem is anything but normal and according to some, can be traced back to a streamer called “TheHM05”, whose rise and fall led to the powerhouse we know today as Clan Redeem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pEGXyZYl1R9-21Kq4pjoXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>TheHM05 attempting one of his signature Crota challenges</figcaption></figure><p>TheHM05 was a hardcore Destiny PvE streamer that was well known for his solo Crota challenges during Year 1 of Destiny. He also ran a clan of his own known as “Hidden Machine” that had multiple speedrun records and was formed with the intent to attain World’s First for the next raid, “King’s Fall”. During this time Redeem Clan was a small speedrunning clan that constantly competed against Hidden Machine, but both clans were not well known to the larger community. When asked how he was originally recruited to Hidden Machine, clan member Ehroar said that “<em>HM recruited me back when speedrunning really was becoming a thing in Destiny. There was a nightfall one week that was very good for speedrunning, it had really good modifiers and was a short strike. I decided to try to finish it the fastest I could solo because I enjoyed playing it. At the time speedruns were recorded by destinytracker that used API times. Without really knowing it HM05 was also speedrunning it with a full fireteam. It ended up that my solo time was faster than their fireteam times. They noticed this on destinytracker and messaged me leading to my recruitment.” </em>Another talented member of this roster, Fleshcrunch had this to say about Hidden Machine. <em>“I was a moderator in HM’s stream for a long time and when I saw he was recruiting for his clan I tried out and made it to the roster. HM was not that involved in the clan and the rest of us really bonded together as clan mates during this period.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M0ess2n7t3sV75zJ9TJa9A.png" /><figcaption>Hidden Machine members regularly ran speedruns and challenges without HM05 during this time</figcaption></figure><p>When asked what he thought about Redeem at the time Flesh says, “<em>I thought they were shitters because HM told me so. They were our main rivals in speedruns every week and we had a constant flow of banter between the two clans</em>.” Outside of TheHM05 himself, who was 21 at the time, most of the Hidden Machine clan was made up of high school aged players who looked up to the older and more popular streamer. He was their talismanic figure who, although distant at times, led them in spirit and experience.</p><p>The average playtime of his clan mates in the month leading up to the next raid was over 120 hours while HM05 only played around 30 hours in the same month, leading to some disagreements and unrest within the group about a commitment to the clan and what the future held for its members if one day HM05 decided he was done.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3JaQeI7qZ5SL_gEc1CuCAA.jpeg" /></figure><p>September 18th 2015 rolls around, Destiny’s third raid, “King’s Fall”, has released and the race for World’s First has once again begun. Hidden Machine and Redeem are both off to the races, hopeful that the teams they’ve assembled can take home the trophy and be the first team to decimate Oryx. The pressure was on and Hidden Machine fractured under the stress. Although they made it to the final phase of the raid in line with other top teams, they crumbled and stalled where others thrived. After many painful and grinding hours, KingGothalion and the rest of My Dad is Bungie were confirmed to be the first fireteam to walk out of the darkness and complete the trials they faced in “King’s Fall”.</p><p>Directly after hearing this news TheHM05 told his teammates he was quitting, not just this raid, but Destiny as a whole and he proceeded to log out. The remainder of Hidden Machine’s fireteam was in shock, their leader abandoned them in the most important moment in their young Destiny careers. When asked what went through their minds when their captain left Ehroar mentioned, “<em>It was my first world’s first attempt and I was already so lost and overwhelmed to begin with and when he [HM05] left I knew it was over. Looking back it was a huge learning experience. To see your own leader turn his back on you in the middle of the attempts made me realize that it can only go up from here in the future.</em>” The remnants of the clan remained as a pack and soon reformed in a temporary clan called “Lit Nation” while they figured out their next steps.</p><p>Following the dismantling of their old clan, FleshCrunch and Ehroar started to work on a new challenge, attempting a solo run of Oryx, the final boss in “King’s Fall”. It was during this theory crafting and testing phase that the current Clan Redeem roster and the now Lit Nation members started to interact more and move past their days as rivals. Soon, they were collaborating on strategies and playing together as friends, each side bringing strengths that the previous had lacked. The ex-Hidden Machine players brought over discipline and structure led by Ehroar’s mechanical and calculated approach to the game supported by his co-leader in FleshCrunch’s way of developing younger players into reaching their potential. Redeem provided raw talent and a hunger to become the worlds best; players such as Tfue, ModernTryhard and MagneticRubber were heralded as some of the most mechanically gifted PvE players but were lacking that one extra piece to push them to the very top. When asked about this uniting of clans, Clan Redeem founding member ModernTryhard told us, <em>“</em>[We] <em>wanted to get players that were really good at the game and that were willing to play without leaving the team name behind because I love the word Redeem and just how nice it rolls of the tongue and easy to remember.”</em> Finally what had seemed evident to both parties happened, a merger was formed. The players formally under the guidance and leadership of TheHM05 were absorbed by Clan Redeem, and thus the first steps to greatness began.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pjmKLtBP6RFzRFySvmNAkw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A-Y1PfK6ETYDEr28TlmzBA.png" /></figure><p>The pressure was on now for this newly formed Clan Redeem; they had all the pieces of the puzzle to achieve the goal that all high level PvE players strive towards, a World’s First title. Unfortunately they had to wait to get their chance, the next World’s First race would not be until September 2016, when Bungie’s fourth raid, “Wrath of the Machine” was released during <em>Destiny: Rise of Iron. </em>But when they finally got their opportunity, Clan Redeem delivered. They completed the newest raid in just under 2 hours and thus getting their hands on the elusive World’s First title for the first time, but they didn’t stop there, they had tasted the thrill of victory and wanted to ride this wave into the future. When looking back at this feat, Ehroar claims, <em>“Getting world’s first WoTM was a moment where I/we all realized we had a place in Destiny PvE history. Before this point we had a lot of speedrun records from things like strikes, missions, and even raids but nothing that was really “mainstream.” The entire point of merging Hidden Machine and Redeem was to form a team that could do everything and compete for world’s first raids also. WoTM being our first attempt as a newly formed team and achieving world’s first was something we all dreamed about. From then on we knew we could do anything we set our minds to.”</em></p><p>When the hard mode for “Wrath of the Machine” came out, Redeem wanted to go back to back and secure another title. It started out well, with Redeem leading the race through the Siege Engine encounter, until disaster struck.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HiuNVhBcRzypRB_vrxO6Jw.png" /></figure><p>A bug in the raid had caused the entire Clan Redeem roster to die, causing a wipe and adding 6 minutes onto their run. In the end Redeem finished 3rd by a margin of just 4 minutes. Many claimed they were robbed, many others thought all was fair in the race, but the Redeem members themselves shrugged it off and kept on going. They didn’t let this get to their heads and instead kept grinding for the coming months, completing numerous challenges and setting record speedruns in this time. Clan Redeem wanted to prove that their World’s First was not a fluke and that they had the ability to repeat their successes in the future. But to do so they had to wait, the next raid would not be released until Destiny 2 in September of 2017.</p><p>When the time finally came and “The Leviathan” went live, Redeem were unable to gain any traction and fell short of the World’s First title. After this failure the clan decided to shift the roster around for the world’s first team in the future, removing some of the old guard and once again bringing in newer talents and prospects. The next opportunity for a title would come during the Prestige Mode version of “The Leviathan”, and although they would find success once again, it would not come without controversy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/587/1*sHbFg4ldUGR-PsTWj0smFg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4LGujIs-d9j_JBgOLEjygQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Once again Redeem would claim the title of World’s First raid team but it was discovered that members of this team used an exploit known as “Coil Glitching” to get more ammo during the raid. Many members of the community believed this to be cheating and asked Bungie themselves to strip the accolades from Redeem. However it was found that most if not all other top 20 teams to finish the raid had also used the same exact exploit. The community still was upset and Clan Redeem members were on the back foot, believing that they did nothing wrong. <em>“I think the controversy around Prestige Leviathan was mostly people looking for things to be mad about when the game was failing at the time. No matter what Bungie was doing around this time — CoO </em>[<em>Curse of Osiris, Destiny 2’s first expansion] it would be dissected and turned into fuel for the discontent the community had with the game. And, with our run just the word “glitch” was enough for this treatment from the community. I truly believe that 99% was misinformed, misguided hate. And the 1% that truly thought we cheated, we showed them…” </em>This mentality by Redeem showed their resilience and their will to prove those who doubted them wrong. And the world didn’t have to wait long before Redeem rose to the top once again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AOzZfBxMRC5FLNx5zSfgdg.png" /></figure><p>On May 11th 2018 Clan Redeem made history by being the first Clan to achieve 3 World’s First titles when they conquered the newest raid lair “Spire of Stars”. No controversy, no glitches, no bugs, no doubts, Redeem was #1 once again. Only one other clan has ever claimed 2 titles (Invigorate emerged victorious in Destiny 1 when they won the race for both hard mode “Vault of Glass” and normal mode “Crota’s End”) and no other clan has a World’s First title across both Destiny iterations. Redeem has established themselves as the clan to beat in every World’s First race, the final boss of the PvE community.</p><p>While only one founding member of Redeem remains, in ModernTryhard, new names have come to bear the [RDM] tag and strive for greatness everyday. To the outside it may seem like just a group who plays video games together but to ModernTryhard and many others, it’s always been more than that. “<em>I’m always proud of what everyone does and what happens, love everyone in Redeem see them all as family, brothers across the country and seas”</em></p><p>Clan Redeem stands alone on the cusp of Destiny’s first true PvE dynasty, and TheHM05 can watch from the sidelines with the knowledge that his triumphs and mistakes made it all possible.</p><p><em>Written by Josh Goodman</em></p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/joshigoods"><em>Twitter</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshua-goodman/"><em>LinkedIn</em></a></p><p><em>Thank you to all of </em><a href="https://twitter.com/Clan_Redeem"><em>Clan Redeem</em></a><em> for your time and candor during these interviews</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a16d4ee4cf81" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>