<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Schmader on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Schmader on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joshschmader?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 10:14:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joshschmader/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Modern Myth-Making: Furiosa]]></title>
            <link>https://joshschmader.medium.com/modern-myth-making-furiosa-efaef6372bea?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efaef6372bea</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[furiosa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[furiosa-a-mad-max-saga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mad-max]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Schmader]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Jun 2024 02:19:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-24T17:47:45.643Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reflecting on the creation and experience of ‘The Darkest of Angels’</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lqfX3H0q_vPNOUCGa_cB5w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anya Taylor-Joy as Furiosa in Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024)</figcaption></figure><p>*Contains spoilers for<em> Mad Max: Fury Road </em>and<em> Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga*</em></p><h4>1. The Birthing of a Myth</h4><p>Technically speaking, George Miller’s <em>Fury Road </em>from 2015 reintroduced some to the world of <em>Mad Max. </em>For the majority of others, including myself, <em>Fury Road </em>was our first introduction to such a world.</p><p>When I see <em>Fury Road </em>referenced these days, I see it praised for the exceptional action sequences and set pieces, the comedic or “camp” nature of the character’s names and viking + metal aesthetic, and the character of Furiosa. In fact, if you were to search “Mad Max Fury Road” on any social media platform, the first photos you are bound to see are that of Tom Hardy as Max being mounted on the front a pursuit car, then, not too far behind, follows a still of Charlize Theron’s iconic scream as Furiosa. More coming on that scream later.</p><p>What is so fascinating about the <em>Fury Road </em>is that George Miller has said in numerous interviews that he had written every character and their backstory before he wrote the plot. This means that Furiosa’s story, along with all of other characters, are already alive, breathing, and embedded in the DNA of <em>Fury Road. </em>The events, places, and people referenced in the film do have a central and concrete purpose in their place in the world of <em>Mad Max.</em> These are not cheap throwaway references or easter eggs, like those our culture has become accustomed from franchises like <em>Star Wars, Marvel, </em>and<em> Harry Potter</em>. Rather, each object and character that we see on screen has a rooted and intentional purpose in the world and story we are witnessing. Miller’s level intentionality in his storytelling is so strong that it trickles down to the way that he directs actors performances. The stars whom have worked with Miller have all described him as being “excruciatingly detailed” and “intentional”. He is a committed storyteller, not someone who is interested to creating new references to sell as toys (like <em>Star Wars’ </em>marketing strategy) or drop references that could be turned into another soul-devoid project later on (<em>Marvel’</em>s strategy in the last several years<em>).</em></p><p>The way that this meticulous writing process impacts character-driven storytelling is curious to me. Let us reflect on <em>Star Wars </em>once more, considering how this is a franchise who’s prequels were written retroactively. Darth Vader was conceived of and written before the character of Anakin Skywalker. The character of “Anakin” is obviously referenced in the Original Trilogy, sure, but the actual roots or ‘building blocks’ of that character are not crafted until many years later.</p><p>Irregardless of the nuances within this, all of the characters in the <em>Mad Max </em>universe are not written this way. Everyone already has a backstory — they just haven’t been told yet. The functionality that results is that <em>Fury Road</em> creates a skeletal framework for the myth of each of it’s individual characters. To illustrate further, consider <em>Fury Road</em> through language of generic archetypes. The events of <em>Fury Road</em> take place over a three day period, telling the story of a revolution or “armageddon”. It is the story of a world, in this case a society, that is destroyed and given the chance to arise anew: healthier, equitable, and more just. The narrative is fairly straightforward, and we have all seen this archetype before. We already know this story, we are familiar with the movements of villains like Immortan Joe, and we know that good will defeat evil in the end.</p><p>While the symbolic and archetypal language is familiar, Miller adds just a hint of newness, sprinkling in a sense of unfamiliarity. We are not given a detailed introduction into what the world of <em>Mad Max</em> is. We are provided with a short summary of the nuclear war that created “the wasteland”, but we are not given an explanation of how this civilization has come to be.</p><p>How did Immortan Joe gain power? What is the religion that he seems to rule by? What are the intricacies of the belief system of this religion? Who is Max? Why is he alone, and how is he able to survive alone in a wasteland with so many violent factions trying to preserve themselves? Who is this mysterious Furiosa? Why is she heading home? What is this home?</p><p><em>Fury Road </em>is not interested in answering any of these questions. It only cares about telling the revolution/armageddon. At best, <em>Fury Road</em> hints at some answers, while others are not addressed at all. The significance of this is that it creates a <em>buffer of understanding</em> between the audience and the fictional world that they are placed in. This world, how it functions and is inhabited, is vaguely familiar to us, yet we are shown repeatedly that we do not know it.</p><p>Miller is candid about not wanting to tell story through dialogue. If he were, we may have gotten an introduction to the world of <em>Mad Max</em> in the same way that we were introduced to the world of <em>Dune</em>: full of exposition giving literal descriptions of how the world works<em>. </em>This method of story telling destroys that buffer of understanding between audience and the ficitonal world. We now know how everything works, leaving little room imagine, less material to “chew” on when we leave the experience.</p><p>Instead, Miller prefers to use the strength of the medium to tell his stories: moving pictures. In other words, we are informed about Miller’s fictional world through the character’s interactions with and within it, behaviors and gestures that don’t provide the clearest of picture of what’s happening. The result is that buffer of understanding remains intact. There is more for us to wonder and dream about, beyond this story of revolution, when we leave the experience.</p><p>When you add a prequel to this kind of story, the formula of storytelling leads to something very different from other prequels. As many positive reviews have praised <em>Furiosa </em>for, the two films have a reciprocal relationship: <em>Furiosa</em> is enriches <em>Fury Road</em>, and <em>Fury Road </em>enriches <em>Furiosa</em>. Each film gives the viewer questions to ponder, some that may be answered in the other, while other questions remain unanswered and wondered about<em>. </em>I, for one, cannot name another sequel that can say that they have a reciprocal relationship in this way with their prequels.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FXJMuhwVlca4%3Fstart%3D2%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D2&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DXJMuhwVlca4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FXJMuhwVlca4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0ebf64f7af2011b273872cb11fe855df/href">https://medium.com/media/0ebf64f7af2011b273872cb11fe855df/href</a></iframe><h4>2. Mad Myths</h4><p>Before we dive into the myth-building of Furiosa, it would be responsible of us to investigate: What is a myth? The “official” definition of a myth is a story, possibly supernatural or divine in nature, that explains social or natural pheonema. All cultures throughout human history have had their own myths to explain the workings of the earth or human behavior.</p><p>When we think of stories like these, we may first think about ancient tales from fallen societies that tell of heroic journeys or personified tales of how our world works. Consider Greek myths like that of Zeus, Poseidon, Sisyphus, or Medusa. We, as humans, cannot possibly understand the worlds that these characters exist in. There is a veil of mysticism and magic that covers these stories, causing them to elude our comprehension, beckoning awe and wonder.</p><p>In our modern culture, it seems that we hardly consider the stories we tell to be “mythic” in nature anymore. Our stories, or at least those made for adult audiences, instead feel much more “grounded”. The scope narrower in focus, choosing to stick to human’s experience in the world as we know it and the various relationships we may find ourselves in. These stories are every bit as emotional and entertaining, but the way that we consume these stories is one based in a literalness. We experience the story as it as told to us, and, in some cases, the story is explained to us through dialogue and expostion as we experience it. The result is that we leave the experience with nothing to chew on, nothing to dream or wonder. “That was good, pretty entertaining,” we may say, as we return to our regular routines.</p><p>Is this a product of our faculty of reason and rationality, the same faculty that is the catalyst for our major developments in science and technology? We now have scientific descriptions of how just about everything in the world external of us works, and the field of psychology is similarly describing in scientific terms what the brain is, how it functions, how it produces consciousness, emotions, and the like. What is the use of wondering about mythology and mysticism anymore, stories that make us consider spirituality or the cosmic, if everything in our modern life can easily be explained away by reason and science?</p><p>Despite the scientific explanations that we seek and continuously create, we never stop making mystical myths. They are not stories reserved for ancient civilizations, but a creation by the meaning-making human being, no matter the year or era, no matter how much science is able to describe the world and our experience of it in the most literal of terms. Characters are conceived, their stories told, and those tales resonate in a myriad of ways with the audience who witnesses them. This is the true function of myths: a story that creates that <em>buffer of understanding, </em>using it to turn the viewer inward to introspect, inviting us to ask which parts of ourselves are being touched by the narrative and to be changed by it.</p><h4>3. The Inevitability of Subjectivity</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x6T6qEhRxnL7p4GNuL4lzg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Charlize Theron as Furiosa, Mad Max: Fury Road (2015)</figcaption></figure><p>I rewatched <em>Fury Road </em>with my mom a week or so before writing this. In her first viewing, she made the astute observation that Furiosa, played by Charlize Theron in 2015, always looks as if she is on the verge of tears. I had never noticed this detail before, and she is right. Furiosa’s eyes in <em>Fury Road</em> frequently have this glaze over them, moist with a rage and grief that we viewers are made aware of, but <em>Fury Road</em> never grants us full understanding of how those emotions have come to be.</p><p>I responded to my mom’s observation with an affirmative nod. Having seen <em>Furiosa</em>, I had understood the roots of that rage and grief.</p><p>The mystique yet emotional heaviness that exists within the Furiosa character made me wonder how each of the actresses who play her were able to tap into that psychology. What was their experience of this character like? Did it resonate deeply with them, just as deeply as it had for viewers that love Furiosa?</p><p>What I discovered is that both Charlize and Anya Taylor-Joy both had significant input in how the character was portrayed on screen. Remember Charlize’s scream, depicted in the photo above? That scream was not George Miller’s idea — it was Charlize’s. In an interview, she recounts:</p><blockquote><em>So [the scream] was never in the storyboard. The scene was always supposed to end on her realization that the Green Place was gone, and the camera would start spinning around her while she was just in utter shock. I said to George, “I feel like we need to have a moment where she’s completely lost, completely vulnerable. We’ve seen this woman be so capable and driven, so we need to have a moment where she’s none of those things.” I felt very strongly that we had to take her to her rock bottom. Imagine the disappointment of doing all this to get to a place that doesn’t exist anymore, to have spent all this time thinking this thing would fix everything for you and then it doesn’t fix anything? It’s a character at the cusp of, “I think I’m done,” and that was an important moment to me because then the stakes of her turning around and going back feel so much higher.</em></blockquote><p><a href="https://collider.com/mad-max-fury-road-charlize-theron-scream-scene-inspiration-revealed/">Charlize Theron Came Up with Her Iconic Fury Road Scream Moment</a></p><p>Similarly, Anya’s interviews about her time as Furiosa tell how she was also impacted by taking on the character, and how she also advocated for her character’s expression of rage. She speaks of a scream in <em>Furiosa </em>that she had to fight for for “three months”, and George Miller finally gave her that moment.</p><p><a href="https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/anya-taylor-joy-fights-female-rage-on-screen-1235906843/">Anya Taylor-Joy on Why She Fights for &quot;Female Rage&quot; to Be Depicted on Screen</a></p><p>These moments are worthy of highlighting because they show how the myth-building happens. Myths are a co-created phenomenon, given meaning by various creators and the audience who observes them. In Furiosa’s case, both Charlize and Anya were active contributors in the telling of this character’s story, the emotions that the character is feeling, and how those emotions are expressed. As mentioned earlier, Charlize’s scream is one of the most remembered moments of <em>Fury Road</em>. Without she and Anya’s insistence that the character have these moments of expression, we would be left with a story about a presumably female-identified character being told through the gaze of a man. How differently this character would be thought of and remembered if these moments had not been fought for…</p><p>Returning to Anya for a moment, she speaks candidly in a recent interview with the New York Times about how psychologically difficult it was to become Furiosa. This article is unfortunately behind NYT’s paywall, but I will emphasize the important sentiments. Anya speaks of the emotions and trauma that she was forced to act in, through, and out of, and how embodying this subjectivity brought some of her own experiences to the forefront of her psyche. In one part of the interview, she speaks on how the only version of the movie that she has seen herself was a black-and-white cut, prior to any of the special effects being added in.</p><p>Anya states: “I’m curious, once I watch it, if I’ll ever be able to watch it again. Two minutes in and I’m sobbing. I adored a person that I could not protect. There were forces greater than me.” She continues to speak on how she carries Furiosa with her, carrying on lessons that the character taught her. “I think being able to advocate for myself more. Some of the protection and love I felt towards her, I’ve carried into my actual life.”</p><p>The dialectic power of mythology, and storytelling overall, is revealed in Anya’s words here. She was an active participant in bringing the character to life, bringing her own experiences to fill empty frame of the idea: “Furiosa”. She then witnessed that character in the same flesh and blood that she contributed, informing her own life and experiences beyond Furiosa’s story. Although experiencing this dialectic power in different ways and likely to different degrees, the audience does all the same as Anya. We are always projecting our own experiences and beliefs to stories and myths, then leaving the myth with a new understanding of ourselves once we see those projections played out in a narrative that is not our own.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/12/movies/anya-taylor-joy-furiosa.html">Anya Taylor-Joy Still Can&#39;t Make Sense of What She Went Through</a></p><h4>4. The Darkest of Angels</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sVqtcDvB2XoTm-wvN96gcA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anya Taylor-Joy as Furiosa, <em>Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Nine years after the initial introduction to the character of Furiosa comes her time to take center stage. George Miller’s trademark storytelling through cinematic action is still present like in <em>Fury Road</em>, but, while <em>Fury Road</em>’s spectacle lies in the size, scale, and pace of it’s action, it’s prequel’s spectacle lies in the emotional intimacy and mythical nature of it’s story as we experience 18 formative years alongside our protagonist. In other words, where 2015’s <em>Fury Road</em> is a high octane character-driven-epic tracking 3 days of events, <em>Furiosa </em>is the witnessing of the birth and development of a character who we, as the audience, are already familiar with and (most likely) already have an affinity for.</p><p><em>Furiosa</em>’s intention to explore the psychology of one of the saga’s more iconic characters is evident in it’s slower pace, deliberately building up tension throughout until the final climax. And, like any story that is truly committed to explore the phenomenology of vengeance, that climax is not grand and sensational, but narrowly focused: intimate, personal, emotionally raw, impure, almost diabolical.</p><p>It is this film, <em>Furiosa</em>, that has caused me to fall in love with Miller. Amidst all of the action sets, loud music, and colorful shots is a subtlety that is left for the viewer to discover, to make meaning of and relate to, for themselves. In fact, the composer for Furiosa, Tom Holkenborg has confirmed that all of the music that is in the film is meant to convey Furiosa’s internal state. If she is present in a scene, we are given music to convey how we are to feel based on her feeling. This is the making of a true character study.</p><p>The exploration of how <em>Furiosa</em> creates it’s mythical <em>buffer of understanding</em> can be exemplified by Furiosa’s celestial tattoo on her left forearm. We are told that the tattoo is a map to her birthplace, while also being a symbol of guidance and commitment to the promise she made to her late mother to return home. However, there is a third layer of meaning to this tattoo, as it has a mystical nature that the audience is not given an explanation for. The stars are referenced as being spiritual, even religous, to the The Many Mothers or Vuvalini culture (the name of the culture that Furiosa is from). The spiritual significance of the stars is never expanded on further, providing a magical buffer between the audience and the Garden of Eden-like origins that Furiosa has been stolen from.</p><p>Now, anyone who has seen Fury Road or knows about the character of Furiosa at all, knows that she eventually has a prosthetic left arm. With this foresight and careful observation, the viewer can easily infer that she is going to lose the arm that holds this mystical tattoo. The grief is spelled out for the viewer before the event even happens. Similar prequels has encountered this dilemma, and history seems to tell us that this will likely not pay off. In fact, it may even single handedly describe while Furiosa struggled in the box office. For me, the question that arises for prequels is: If the viewer already has the “<em>effect</em>” of what is to happen without knowing the “<em>cause</em>” of that effect, what emotional “<em>affect</em>” is there for the viewer? How can we be expected to feel any emotion for something that we already expect to happen, even if we don’t know how it happens?</p><p>However, <em>Furiosa </em>ends up creatively playing with this common trope.</p><p>Furiosa has her tattooed arm significantly damaged during a chase with Dementus, but she does not lose her arm here. Not yet. She is then caught by Dementus immediately after having this arm damaged, and he orders her to be hung from this arm in a form of deliberate torture. After a brief time-skip sequence, it is discovered that Furiosa has escaped, amputating her own arm — the same arm that carried the tattoo of the celestial map that could lead her back home. This act of self-mutilation is shocking and subversive, the score revving to a crescendo as the camera lingers on the severed arm. And so the chase begins again, Dementus on the hunt for his prisoner who continues to be on the run.</p><p>Curiously, Furiosa is not even given a moment to process or grieve the loss of neither her arm, nor her tattoo. The film makes no acknowledgment of the significance of Furiosa severing her own arm, or the loss of a sacred symbol and map that contains so much meaning for her.</p><p><strong><em>Why?</em></strong></p><p><em>Furiosa</em> maintains its commitment to the phenomenology of vengeance, therein providing the embedded answer. In her hatred and vengeance, Furiosa amputates her own arm to escape, thereby revealing the core of the emotional phenomenon of vengeance: it is destructive and corrosive in nature, ignorant to anything worth preservation. It desires to annihilate the subject at which it is aimed at. Anything and everything that falls outside of that narrow periphery can be sacrificed for this cause, and done so without hesitation.</p><p>But again, the film doesn’t gesture at this at all. We are shown the tattoo multiple times throughout the movie up until this point, but it is never acknowledged that the tattoo was damaged then amputated, and the weight of that loss is for Furiosa. The arm is literally left there in a single shot, hanging in the dust of the wasteland, for you to witness, grieve, and make meaning of yourself.</p><h4>5. A Language for the Ineffable</h4><p>This post is long enough, and you have been reading my puny words for too long. I am going to close by centering George Miller himself, the passionate auteur who admits to being inspired by the works of Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell’s that speak of the importance of myths and the collective unconscious. George has an undeniable passion and gift for storytelling, and the masses owe it to him to continue to show his creations love through interactivity.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FWXGwEYaliM0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DWXGwEYaliM0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FWXGwEYaliM0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f8ed00b16d6413c3b3bdd201c4258a1e/href">https://medium.com/media/f8ed00b16d6413c3b3bdd201c4258a1e/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FCiTysspD-jU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DCiTysspD-jU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FCiTysspD-jU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/590d515ed3b9b61eb2858938db22c0ae/href">https://medium.com/media/590d515ed3b9b61eb2858938db22c0ae/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efaef6372bea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Hauntology of Decision to Leave]]></title>
            <link>https://joshschmader.medium.com/the-hauntology-of-decision-to-leave-46907ef5d784?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46907ef5d784</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Schmader]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Jan 2023 13:02:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-15T15:12:02.999Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>When Transcendental Desire is halted by the Social/Cultural</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JTnSuNQRo9-Y2ZsS_VT8kA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Decision to Leave is one of the top films of 2022, but this here writing is not here to tell why nor how. This is not a film review, nor an experiential reflection on the many things that this film does so well. This is a meditation on Decision to Leave’s exploration of a unique form of hauntology: when love is halted by seemingly impermeable social and cultural boundaries.</p><p><strong>*SPOILER WARNING*</strong>: There are spoilers<strong> </strong>ahead for Decision to Leave. If you are interested in this premise, and the film by proxy, I strongly encourage you to close this article and watch the film for yourself before returning to read. If you are unbothered by this warning, or your sole interest is in the premise, by all means continue. I welcome all thoughts and comments on the film and/or the premise.</p><p>Before beginning the musings, I must highlight the definitive haunting moment of the film. Without exploring this moment, the following musings would ring empty.</p><p>At the 43 minute mark, ‘Decision to Leave’ features our two central character’s crossing a definitive social boundary: Hae-joon’s (the talented detective in an unhappy marriage) hosts Seo-rae (his only current suspect for Seo-rae’s husband’s murder) for dinner. During this dinner, Seo-rae surveys Hae-joon’ wall of unresolved cases and asks about the killings of San-O, a murderer that has evaded arrest for some time. Seo-rae’s <strong>playfulness</strong> and <strong>curiosity</strong> during this scene is highlighted by her frequent attentive questions about the cases, a disposition further emphasized by the “<strong>happy</strong>” and “<strong>bumpy</strong>” violins that play in the film’s soundtrack during this scene.</p><p>Seo-rae asks about San-O’s relationship with one particular woman. Hae-joon answers, explaining that the criminal killed another man after suspecting that the man was messing around with the criminal’s girlfriend at the time. Seo-rae remarks, “So, he loves the woman more than death…”, then points to a picture of the aforementioned girlfriend of the criminal. Hae-joon confidently dismisses her wondering, responding “Oh, [her]?”. Immediately, the film cuts away to a few days forward in the story, when Hae-joon and his partner move forward to arrest this very criminal he is discussing with Seo-rae. Those <strong>“happy”</strong> and <strong>“bumpy” </strong>violins that I previously mentioned, those which highlighted the playful curiosity of Seo-rae? They startlingly morph and deepen into roaring cellos, the only time the instrument appears in the film’s score. The viewer has just been severed from the ‘Buddy Cop’ and ‘Budding Romance/Fling’ of Act 1, and has now been introduced to a much different Act 2. The tone is now darker, far more serious, signifying that this film is not here to be fun or flirtatious. “We are here to sit with something deeply unsettling, something ineffable,” I could hear the film almost whispering to me.</p><p>As the cellos continue to roar, we watch as Hae-joon’s partner is attacked by the criminal as the duo of police officers are moving in for the arrest. The criminal flees, and Hae-joon gives chase. The film cuts back to Hae-joon and Seo-rae during their dinner. Hae-joon explaining that the girlfriend of the criminal that Seo-rae is asking about lives “far away” and that she had since gotten married to someone else, essentially dismissing Seo-rae’s suggestion that to find the criminal you only need find his love. Seo-rae sighs, shoots a look of disappointment at the naive Hae-joon, then giggles as she looks at her hands.</p><p>The cellos fade. The score quiets to a few subtle chimes.</p><p>It is here where the film reveals its soul, the very conflict it suggests the viewer to sit with, all within one sentence of dialogue from Seo-rae. She looks back up at Hae-joon, and, with impregnable poise, poses a question:</p><h3>“In Korea, if a person you love gets married, does the love cease?”</h3><p>As the film explains to us in myriad of different ways, the <strong>answer</strong> to Seo-rae’s question<strong> </strong>is “no”, love does not cease when a person you love gets married. The film’s meditation on both this <strong>question</strong> and <strong>answer </strong>becomes its own exploration of the phenomenological structure for love, and one that brought me right back to Lévinas’ reflections on the emotion:</p><blockquote>“Love remains a relation with the Other that turns into need, transcendent exteriority of the other, of the beloved. But love goes beyond the beloved… The possibility of the Other appearing as an object of a need while retaining his alterity, or again, the possibility of enjoying the Other… this simultaneity of need and desire, or concupiscence and transcendence,… constitutes the originality of the erotic which, in this sense, is the equivocal par excellence.” <br>―<em> </em><strong><em>Emmanuel Lévinas, Totality and Infinity: An Essay on Exteriority</em></strong></blockquote><p>To quickly summarize, Lévinas describes <strong>love </strong>as having<strong> </strong>multidirectional<strong> </strong>movement: a <strong>desire</strong> and <strong>need </strong>that moves <strong>towards </strong>the other, but also <strong>beyond </strong>in a <strong>transcendent </strong>motion. Love is a movement towards the other in terms of “needing” to be with, to share physical and/or mental space. At the same time, there is a transcendental movement, where the self is moved from itself and pulled out of itself in its desire to join with the other, an other whom is infinite, ever-expanding, and always unknowable. The intricacies and specificities of these philosophical notions are not of this writing’s concern. Rather, the concern is the transcendental movement of <strong>love</strong> itself, how Seo-rae and Han-joon make these movements, and what happens when this transcendental movement is forbidden or prohibited from coming to fruition.</p><p>Seo-rae and Han-joon use their situatedness in their social/cultural roles as “suspect” and “detective” to continually <strong>move toward </strong>each other in <strong>desire</strong>. For Hae-joon, this is the care he places in observing Seo-rae, or how he eventually lets her into his home after his partner *trashes her apartment. For Seo-rae, she returns to Hae-joon’s home to help him sleep and burn photos. The glaring caveat that the film presents as a ‘given’ from the beginning is the obvious: the romantic relationship between the two <strong>cannot</strong> <strong>ever</strong> happen. It is almost socially forbidden. Hae-joon is investigating Seo-rae and Hae-joon is also married. To seek a life with Seo-rae would mean for Hae-joon to ruin his career and his marriage. Although the two individuals are equals, their social and cultural positions have created a boundary. This is a boundary that a transcendental movement <strong>could</strong> leap over and love to see itself manifest, but not without involving consequences in the relational and professional spheres for each of the individuals involved.</p><h3>In effect, ‘Decision to Leave’ invites the viewer to sit with this unique ‘hauntology’: what happens — what does one do — when transcendental love (between two equals or peers) is stomped out by social, cultural, and logistical boundaries?</h3><p>Decision to Leave is wonderful and flawless work of fictional cinema, naturally entailing that its story is taken to the highest degree of risk in the name of entertainment. All the while, the haunt of this phenomenological dilemma is recognizable in everyday life: when love painfully persists even after one is married to someone else, when the relationship is separated by physical distance, when the two’s social positions are organized in such a way that it is made clear that the relationship <strong>cannot </strong>manifest<strong> without </strong>harming another social or culture agreement — common example coming to my mind being dating in the workplace, or when one peer is in a professional position of power over another peer.</p><p>This is haunting that I sat with throughout the film, and the haunting that I continue to sit with when I think about this story. To be sure, the film’s tragic ending only amplifies the intensity of this experience, this particular mourning of interpersonal connection that is incapable of seeing itself through. Chan-wook is a mastermind in his ability to convey this romantic tragedy using the sea and the mountain metaphor. As the omnipresent imagery throughout the film suggests, the sea and mountains can never explore or be with each other. For one to exist naturally entails that the other must be pushed away, the two eternally separated by the physical properties that allow them each to exist on their own.</p><p>Unless, what if there were to be a mountain submerged under the sea? Have we then solved this phenomenological dilemma? Or, perhaps there is a separate geographical term that names this feature of the Earth, and I am merely resistant to accepting that there is no possible universe where Hae-joon and Seo-rae can continue to share time together.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46907ef5d784" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science, Overthinking, and Humanity’s Endangered Relationship with Dasein]]></title>
            <link>https://joshschmader.medium.com/science-overthinking-and-humanitys-endangered-relationship-with-dasein-31cef398b26c?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31cef398b26c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Schmader]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Apr 2018 17:54:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-30T17:54:53.951Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/1*DqELXy3OnEGfhiaIc25XiA.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Limits of Reason” by Paul Klee</figcaption></figure><p>Modern society is a remarkable phenomena, a product of human qualities such as creativity and wonder, innovation and problem solving. These traits have led to technological developments once only achieved in dreams, new scientific discoveries about ourselves and our universe, and even the ability to cure ourselves of disease and illnesses, allowing us to live longer than ever before. These incredible feats may encourage one to seek the common catalyst that facilitated them. I will attribute the catalyst of human creativity and wonder to “Dasein,” Heidegger’s German word that can be translated to an existence that is present here now in time. The catalyst of innovation and problem solving can be attributed to reason, logic, and thinking. The combination of these two aspects of humanity alone have allowed human existence to embark on tremendous adventures and unveil life-altering discoveries. Our entire existence has entailed the spawning of questions that result from our anxiety ridden awareness of our finite temporality. What is the history of the Earth that we call home? What are these other animals around us? What is out there in space? Throughout human history, we have used our creativity and wonder to ask such questions, only to then attempt to solve them with our thinking and reason.</p><p>However, there is a question that reason cannot reach or solve: Why are there beings instead of Nothing? The only beings that can ask such a profound question are Dasein, Heidegger’s German word for Being. This question seems foreign to some, and this foreignness is no accident. With the effects of globalization and population increase, much more emphasis is placed on the faculty of reason. Reason appears to be the most necessary faculty when dealing with such a great number of humans at one time, for the right choice is often the most efficient one. The affect of this dominant preference for an efficient and rational perspective on the world and existence is a strain on the relationship between humans and Dasein and the ability to ask the question about why they are here.</p><p>As Heidegger explains in his <em>Introduction to Metaphysics</em>, it is important for humans to maintain connection with their Dasein. This relationship is fragile, for once the species loses its spirituality and forgets how to ask the question about being, they can never return to that state again. While this connection has gotten weaker and weaker throughout history because of the development of sciences and thinking, Heidegger explains how we can attempt to restrengthen our connection to Dasein. One of these ways is turning towards anxiety and boredom, which are states that prompt us to ask direct questions about what we are. Art, poetry, and philosophy are also mediums that can unveil these emotions and states in us that may have been lost over time in a society that champions reason and scientific pursuits. A rumination over Heidegger’s <em>Metaphysics </em>can reveal how modern society’s growing obsession with scientific thinking has resulted in the tendency for humanity to overthink and classify existence, therefore causing significant damage to its connection with Dasein.</p><p>Heidegger begins his <em>Introduction to Metaphysics </em>by explicitly asking the ultimate question of existence: “Why are there beings at all instead of nothing?” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 1). To him, this “why” question is the first most important for human existence. It is the question. While he admits it may not be the first chronologically, he believes that it is among the top in rank, for it delves into the foundation of our experience and attempts to discover the answers for why we are where we are. Such a question is only capable of being asked by humans, who are the only beings that possess awareness of its finite life. Heidegger explains, however, that we are not able to ask this question on demand, but instead we can only encounter it through a range of different experiences. The three most important experiences are those of profound joy, boredom, and anxiety. When we experience true heartfelt joy, Heidegger (2014) believes that we perceive things for what could be the first time, for we are seeing them as they truly are (p. 2). Similarly, we may come across the question once more when we experience boredom. When we feel indifference in our lives because of our monotonous daily routines, or what Heidegger (2014) describes as the point in which we are “equal distance from despair and joy,” we aimlessly wonder why it is that beings exist instead of nothing at all (p. 2). And lastly, Heidegger explains that we encounter the question when we experience anxiety. However, Heidegger’s description of “anxiety” is of existential proportions, which is not comparable to the anxiety one experiences when preparing for a presentation or worrying about being late for an appointment. This existential anxiety is experienced specifically when encountering Nothing, the antithesis of being. In many ways, the experience of this Nothing through existential anxiety is the true manifestation of the question of beings. As we will see later in Heidegger’s definition of Dasein, this state leaves one to experience existence in the midst of Nothing, and the opportunity to question why this is the case.</p><p>Despite these different profound experiences through which we can encounter the question of why there are beings instead of nothing, Heidegger explains that it is not always a guarantee that supposed question will necessarily follow. He elaborates that the question is so daunting and carries so much weight that merely reading or uttering it may not convey the true significance of the question. Heidegger writes,</p><p>Many never run into this question at all, if running into the question means not only hearing and reading the interrogative sentence uttered, but asking the question, that is, taking a stand on it, posing it, compelling oneself into the state of this questioning. (Heidegger, 2014, p. 1).</p><p>His insistence that encountering this question is so rare that some may not encounter it even once further attests to how important the question is.</p><p>The philosophical exploration of the question of why there are beings instead of nothing involves a plethora of Heideggarian terms that require their own definitions and analyzes. For starters, perhaps the most important term that Heidegger uses when discussing the question about beings is the term “Dasein”. The term is so significant because of its meaning in Heidegger’s text that it is almost always left untranslated. The term sometimes appears with a hyphen as “Da-sein,” literally translating as “being-here”. In Fried and Polt’s (2014) introduction to <em>Introduction to Metaphysics, </em>they define “Dasein” as “being for whom Being itself is at issue, for whom Being (especially its own Being) is in question” (p. xi). While Dasein does refer to human beings, it is not a complete correlation to human beings. Specifically, Dasein is human beings in direct relation to the question and issue concerning beings. This means that Dasein is not referring to a living biological thing or object, but rather a condition of questioning that can only be experienced universally by humans, though each individual human has its own individual Dasein. In this sense, Dasein literally refers to a meaningful appearance or existence that occupies a specific moment in time, which goes both forwards and backwards (Fried, 2014, p. xi).</p><p>To return to Dasein’s question, “Why are there beings at all instead of nothing?”, Heidegger explains that we must closely examine the terms utilized in order to determine what it is that the question is actually asking. First, when we are talking about “beings,” we are really asking about everything that exists. The opposite of this would then be the “nothing,” in so far as the opposite of existence is just that, nothing. However, Heidegger explains that we are incapable of engaging with what we mean when we talk about Nothing. For when we talk about nothing, we make it into a something, which is the opposite of Nothing. “Whoever talks about Nothing does not know what he is doing… By speaking this way, [they] speak against what they mean” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 26). Heidegger (2014) reflects that because Nothing is the opposite of Being, meaning that it cannot be observed or calculated, in order to even attempt to articulate Nothing one “must necessarily become unscientific” (p. 29). In fact, because the Nothing cannot be observed and obtained, only specific mediums are capable of exploring its meaning. These mediums are philosophy, poetry, and other arts. We will discuss these mediums and their relation to the question later.</p><p>Because of the contradictory nature that comes with talking about Nothing, Heidegger (2014) explains that we must eliminate the entire clause from our question. In doing this, we can dedicate our full attention to “Why are there beings at all?”, focusing on items that actually do exist (p. 27). Heidegger uses the example of a piece of chalk to illustrate the definition of being. Its stability, grayish-white color, dusty nature, and its purpose to be used as a writing utensil are all part the chalk’s possibility, which all belong to itself. Without either of these characteristics, which belong completely to the piece of chalk, the object of chalk would not exist and would otherwise be Nothing. Because the piece of chalk possesses all of these qualities in itself and for itself, it emerges as Being, thereby overcoming the possibility of Not-Being (Heidegger, 2014, p. 34).</p><p>It is clear that a distinction must be made when asking any question about being, for the term can generate some confusion because of its representation of two things at the same time. The lower case “being,” for Heidegger, is essentially all of the qualities that compose of the being at hand. In this instance of a piece of chalk, its being is its grayish-white color, dusty nature, and ability to be used as a writing utensil. “The first meaning of “being” names the things themselves that are in being, either individually or as a whole, but always with reference to these things and not their beingness” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 35).</p><p>Heidegger investigates the distinction between being and Being. If beings are everywhere and everything, where is Being to be found? What is Being? He revisits the question at hand, “Why are there beings at all instead of nothing?” By using the lowercase “being,” what we are really asking about is the superficial or materialistic appearances of beings, which does not really get to the core of their meaning or existence (Heidegger, 2014, p. 36). What we should really mean when we ask the question is what the foundation of being is, or as Heidegger says “We are asking at bottom about Being… We are asking about the Being of beings” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 36). This capitalized “Being” is what Heidegger refers to as an “emerging sway,” or wavering. Therefore, when we mention lowercase beings, we only refer to their properties that make up their existence. However, the capitalized Being refers to an aspect of their existence that goes far beyond how they are presented in this moment. It refers to <em>why </em>they exist in the first place, while not collapsing into Not-Being or Nothing. It is because of the possibility of collapsing into Nothing that Being begins to sway and waver throughout its limited existence. “The oscillation of this wavering reaches out into the most extreme and sharpest counterpossibility of beings, into Not-Being and Nothing” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 32). Therefore, only the universal and individual Dasein is responsible for investigating the question of Being, working to establish the ground, or foundation, that separates it from Nothing. Heidegger (2014) cites his own <em>Being and Time, </em>stating that “the understanding of Being belongs to Dasein” (p. 32).</p><p>So, what exactly is the Being of beings? Heidegger (2014) explains that, “…we are not able to lay hold of the <em>Being </em>of beings directly or expressly, neither by way of beings, nor in beings, nor anywhere else at all” (p. 37). He uses the example of a high school to help explain this point. By merely looking at a high school building, we can observe its being. We see its qualities and its purpose, but these qualities do not possess or reveal its Being. Heidegger examines other examples, such as a church and a Van Gogh painting. With each example we fail to identify its Being, or the foundation of its existence. This failure to identify Being prompts Heidegger (2014) to ask whether it is an “empty word,” or whether it is ultimately undiscoverable just like Nothing (p. 39).</p><p>Here we have reached the root of our problem. Why is it that we are only able to observe the material properties of being, without being able to accurately determine what or where the foundational Being is? Is Being really just an empty term? Heidegger makes a startling proposition, explaining that Being is not an empty concept, but humans have just begun to fall out of Being, meaning that they have begun to lose their connection to Dasein and also their ability to ask the question about Being (Heidegger, 2014, p. 41). He goes on to suggest that it is not our fault individually, but rather it is a fate of the West that we lose our connection to Dasein and relationship with Being.</p><p>“What if it were possible that human beings, that peoples in their greatest machinations and exploits, have a connection to beings but have long since fallen out of Being, without knowing it, and what if this were the innermost and most powerful ground of their decline (as cited in Heidegger, 2014, p. 41).</p><p>Heidegger refers to Russia and the United States as evidence for this claim, explaining how they have both become incredible powers and, as a result, have resorted to science, reason, and logic in order to organize their massive populations and power. Because of this “unchained technology” and “rootless organization of the average man,” Heidegger (2014) explains that humanity is experiencing a spiritual decline, where all news, locations, and events can be experienced whenever you like through the incredible power of technology(p. 42). He hypothesizes that if we stay on this track, we will lose the very little spiritual strength that we have left, therefore, losing our connection to Dasein and Being forever.</p><p>But how exactly does science, rational organization, and technology damage our spirituality and relationship with Dasein? First, Heidegger explains how deceptive Being can be. We may believe that we have experienced Being, or in other words we have complete understanding of something’s existence, but this is only Being as ‘seeming’. This seeming is only the appearance, or instance, of Being, for it does not tell the whole story or reveal the depths of Being. Consider media coverage of a news story. The news story is told by reporters, who have gathered the details of the story from various witnesses. The true “Being” of the story that occurred can never be obtained. Thus, the best we can do is create a surface level representation of it, to share the story of what appears to have happened. The reporter represents Being as seeming, for it is the only way to share the story.</p><p>In our modern society, full of technology, news stories, and instantaneous online interactions, Being is always misrepresented as seeming. Heidegger (2014) explains that appearance and seeming are “thus necessarily and constantly, in the possibility of a look that precisely covers over and conceals what beings are in truth, that is, unconcealment” (p. 114). The “truth” that Heidegger is referring to is true Being. In this sense, every Being must appear as seeming, but this does not mean that Being is fully grasped and understood. This point is where modern society stops. We no longer seek to ask about the true nature of Being, because we believe that we have found it already. But, what we have found is merely a representation of Being as seeming. It is only an appearance of Being, like a news story about an event. We take it for granted, therefore we misrepresent Being as only seeming.</p><p>A major reason for our society’s assumption that Being is only seeming is due to our emphasis on thinking, logic, and science. All human faculties, which are feeling, willing, desiring, and finally thinking, are what enable us to relate to all other beings (Heidegger, 2014, p. 131). I will argue that thinking is the most dangerous of these faculties, for it is the faculty that is responsible for creating all scientific disciplines, organizations, and labels of man. As Heidegger reflected earlier, once a country or societal power becomes too great, thinking becomes utilized in excess amounts. This faculty is necessary in such situations, for it is the only faculty that can maintain order and efficiency across a massive population.</p><p>Heidegger explains how the faculty of thinking functions. In order for thinking to function, it brings an object to focus upon in order to process it. “Thinking brings something before us, <em>represents </em>it… we think upon and think through what is represented by analyzing it, by laying it out and reassembling it (Heidegger, 2014, p. 131). Heidegger explains that while this rational thinking process is taking place, we are also attempting to find a way to experience the thing that we are thinking about (Heidgger, 2014, p. 131). We do this in order to find the universal of the thing, that way we are certain that we understand it in the fullest way possible.</p><p>By observing this rational process of thinking, we can already see how the concept of Being may be affected. When we think about Being, we are required to bring it before us in order to begin to rationalize with it. Through rationalizing in this way, we are convinced that we have found and defined Being. However, this is not the case. “Thinking sets itself against Being in such a way that Being is re-presented to thinking, and consequently stands against thinking like an object” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 128). Representing Being as an object places a false definition on a foundation of beings that cannot be found, discovered, or observed. In other words, the definition that is obtained is a misrepresentation of Being. Thinking is only capable of misrepresenting Being as seeming.</p><p>Examples of this can be found in any of the sciences or politics, fields where various definitive labels are used to define human beings. The labels are taken as the truth, the ultimate descriptor of the being that is observed. Ask a psychologist what a human is and they will attempt to define its Being through psychological terms and mental processes. Similarly, a biologist will define a human’s Being using biological terms, and so on. These descriptions only represent Being as seeming. Heidegger explains that even if such a science were to publish a book on the question “<em>What is a human?”,</em> the question about Being is not asked, for it is just “letters on the book’s cover” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 158). For Heidegger, the question about Being is never asked. Such a metaphysical question is answered with another question, not an answer like science and thinking are constantly attempting to provide. These answers are products of overthinking, over rationalization, and science. We humans begin to think that our thinking is powerful enough to answer every question and discover every object in the universe, without fully acknowledging our limitations. Heidegger explains that this is the spirit of the West, to represent and answer everything through thinking and rationalization. Our naivety and emphasis on thinking has only resulted in damaging our relationship to Dasein, and asking the true question about Being.</p><p>While this scientific thinking and over-rationalization are present in today’s society, something must be said about the rapid technological progress that we have seen in the past decades, not technology in the sense of science and scientific discovery, but in the sense of technology used for pure entertainment. This technology is not something that Heidegger had foreseen, technology that’s purpose is not to discover or create something new, but rather technology that’s sole purpose is to distract from the question. Phones are large captivating screens, allowing access to social media and communication with people and places at any moment desired. Abilities such as this numb us to the anxiety and boredom that can bring the question before us. While Heidegger could have never predicted technology having this distracting affect, he would surely agree that it is significantly contributing to the decay of our connection to Dasein and the question about Being.</p><p>In an era where technology is always evolving and science is continuing to classify and label, is there any way to strengthen our culture’s spirituality, therefore, maintaining our connection to Dasein and asking the question about Being? Heidegger says that there is a way, through art, poetry, and philosophy. Let us return back to the topic of Nothing, where art, poetry, and philosophy are capable of having some insight. Just like Being, thinking cannot make sense of Nothing, simply because it is not a something. In this sense, thinking could never hope to address Dasein or the question of why there are beings instead of nothing. Art, poetry, and philosophy, however, are capable of reaching such depths that the limits of reason could never reach. This is where Heidegger draws a distinction between different types of thinking. Thinking, in the rational and logical sense, refers to the sciences that we have defined. However, the thinking that is involved in art and poetry is a philosophical thinking. In this line of thinking, every topic is thought through as if it were the first time experiencing it. Heidegger (2014) recognizes “an essential superiority of spirit holds sway in poetry,” compared to that of science (p. 29).</p><p>With this distinction, between scientific thinking and philosophical thinking, we can begin to see the ways in which thinking can be used to strengthen our spirit and connection with Dasein. What Heidegger (2014) calls for is the revival of original thinking, for only it is capable of overcoming this “misuse” and “misinterpreted” thinking (p. 135). “In order to provide a new foundation for such thinking, we must above all else return to the question of the essential connection of thinking to Being — but this means unfolding the question of Being as such” (Heidegger, 2014, p. 135). The philosophical thinking, or original thinking, that Heidegger is calling for can be stimulated by art, poetry, and philosophy. These mediums have the potential to provoke the feelings and emotions necessary to enable one to ask why there are beings at all instead of nothing. It is through these mediums that one can experience an aspect of Nothing, or existential anxiety, where one can feel their Being as an emergence within this finite world of chaos. This moment may only last for a fleeting instant, but the question was still asked, provoked in a manner that scientific thinking could never hope to provoke.</p><p>Heidegger makes it clear that art, poetry, and philosophy are essential to society, for they are the only mediums that are capable of eliciting emotions and feelings that connect us with our spiritual Dasein. There is still a significant presence of TV shows and films that emulate this effect, namely HBO’s <em>Westworld </em>series<em> </em>and the recent Blade Runner sequel. Both visual works force the viewer to question their reality and what it means to be a human. In both cases, answers are never given to this question, but rather it leaves you asking more questions about Being, therefore, reinforcing your connection with Dasein. If Heidegger were alive today, I’m sure that he would celebrate this sort of TV and cinema, as well as the other art and philosophy that is fighting to maintain our spiritual Dasein. As long as these forces are still present in our society, there is still hope that we can maintain a healthy balance between philosophical thinking and rational thinking, thus preventing ourselves from losing our connection with Dasein and the question about Being forever.</p><p>References</p><p>Heidegger, M., Fried, G., &amp; Polt, R. (2014). <em>An Introduction to Metaphysics</em>. New Haven: Yale University Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31cef398b26c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Westworld through De Beauvoir’s Existential Ethics]]></title>
            <link>https://joshschmader.medium.com/westworld-through-de-beauvoirs-existential-ethics-8ce1eb2ddeef?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ce1eb2ddeef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[westworld]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Schmader]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Apr 2018 17:48:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-30T17:48:34.207Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>*The following analysis was written during Season 1 of HBO’s Westworld*</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*qrTNhmfrrMwzmA-YM6pbPA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In HBO’s <em>Westworld </em>a clear dichotomy begins to form between the two main characters, both of whom are women. After the first few episodes, Delores and Maeve find themselves in very similar situations. They both go about their “lives” in the park living out their continuous loops. After some time, however, they both begin to experience glitches that suggest that there is a bigger meaning to their lives than what they are immediately aware of. The ways in which the two women handle these glitches varies tremendously. Delores seems to represent the “complicit” women that De Beauvoir references. Meanwhile, Maeve represents the opposite. She seeks to embody the “existential ethics” that De Beauvoir suggests, seeking to transcend above her programmed existence within an artificial park to become not just a “real” woman, but to transcend that as well to become an authentic human being.</p><p>Delores represents the “complicit” woman that De Beauvoir describes. Arguably, the most important character in <em>Westworld, </em>much of the series is told from Delores’ perspective, allowing the viewer to experience all of the glitches as they happen to her. One of the reasons that she develops such a strong initial relationship with the viewer is because of her naivety, from the viewer’s perception, towards her life and situations that inevitably get her into trouble within her loop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EGBTPi6RHQpt_l-5k5Zuew.png" /></figure><p>The programmers appear to have programmed Delores to operate as a “damsel,” or in De Beauvoirian terms, an inessential object in relation to the essential, which is the man (De Beauvoir, The Second Sex, p. xliv). Delores’ loop involves her being at a constant risk of being raped and murdered, only capable of being saved if a “guest,” who will most likely be a male who is seeking sex, comes along and saves her and her family from the bandits who are looped to attack them. In fact, Delores’ only purpose in her loop is to be saved from the bandits, so that she can runaway with her hero.</p><p>Delores is complicit in her oppression by remaining in her loop as an immanent object even after she experiences glitches that suggest to her this immanence. By remaining in her loop and choosing not to seek answers, she allows herself to be acted upon by men and is incapable of making any decisions or movements for herself that would allow her to rise above her current status. By listening to Delores’ dialogue, we can also gather that she “loves” the world in which she lives. She looks forward to finding a man to protect her, to build her life with, and make her choices for her. Thus, Delores’ naivety can be assimilated with De Beauvoir’s “complicity”. She is so complacent with being “the Other,” that she is described as being “incapable of hurting even a fly”. As De Beauvoir would say, “she is often very well pleased with her role as the <em>Other” </em>(De Beauvoir<em>, </em>The Second Sex, p. l). It is because of this complicity that Delores does not seek answers to her glitches right away, but rather chooses to remain in a state of immanence in a world run by men.</p><p>Maeve, on the other hand, is the opposite of Delores. Where Delores is a complacent and innocent damsel, Maeve acts with her skepticism and calculative emotional intelligence to transcend her existence within the park. From the start, Maeve is already capable of manipulating men, being that she is the leader of the town’s brothel. In that sense, she already has the potential to manipulate the world which is owned and run by men. Still, Maeve complicit at first just like Delores. It is not until Maeve discovered that her reality is a meaningless loop that she begins to transcend her being. It is through the following actions that Maeve represents De Beauvoir’s “existential ethics”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*WBIuXaEeyo_9USwx66S7kQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>After Maeve realizes that the park world that she lives in isn’t real, she begins to make the movement De Beauvoir describes. “To decline to be the Other, to refuse to be a party to the deal — this would be for women to renounce all the advantages conferred upon them by their alliance with the superior caste” (De Beauvoir, The Second Sex, p. l). Renouncing all of the benefits that she receives from men within the park, Maeve begins to manipulate the world within the park so that she can “die” in order to interact with the park technicians. Maeve tells them that they will help her “transcend” into the real world. To this, the technicians, whom are men, tell her that she will never get out and that she will always remain in the park. Maeve then threatens to kill them if they do not help her, showing her capacity for violence. This threat shows that she has already rejected being the “complicit” Other that the male technicians are hoping she will accept. De Beauvoir perfectly describes this scene:</p><p>Now, what peculiarly signalizes the situation of woman is that she — a free and autonomous being like all human creatures — nevertheless finds herself living in a world where men compel her to assume the status of the Other. They propose to stabilize her as object and to doom her to immanence since her transcendence is to be overshadowed and forever transcended by another ego which is essential and sovereign. (De Beauvoir, The Second Sex, p. lix)</p><p>Maeve is already breaking out of the immanence of being a passive object. She is transcending into something more than a just a woman, but a living human being in the real world. Maeve is on her way to becoming free from men imposing immanence on her. Soon, she will be in charge of her own destiny and free to make her own choices. This freedom to transcend is the meaning of De Beauvoir’s “existential ethics”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ce1eb2ddeef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hegelian Light Amidst the Abyss]]></title>
            <link>https://joshschmader.medium.com/hegelian-light-amidst-the-abyss-ddb01669d38f?source=rss-d55909c3d53f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ddb01669d38f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existential-crises]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wonder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existential]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hegel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Schmader]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Dec 2017 17:12:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-28T17:12:29.730Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*hRicgHu1BV-zYUpQOsgcSA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was a normal cold overcast Wednesday when I decided to take my trip to the local Museum of Natural History and Art. I was dreading the visit to this museum, which I was required to go to because of a general Earth science course. My initial plan was to get in, complete the assignment, and continue on with my day. What resulted, however, was a much more extended stay than originally planned.</p><p>My assignment was complete at the conclusion of the dinosaurs’ exhibit, but I felt as if there was so much more to see in the museum. Despite the primary goal being to finish the assignment, I decided that I should stay awhile longer and have a look at what else the museum had to offer. I made my way up to the second floor to an exhibit showcasing mammals and other modern animals from all of the different climates, such as the amazon, safari, and the rainforest. I felt an overwhelming sense of peace looking at these fake reconstructions of nature. It occurred to me just how pure nature was at its core, it being a unity of all different kinds of vegetation and wildlife functioning together in perfect harmony.</p><p>After the modern animals’ exhibit, I went up to the third floor, where I found myself alone in a long dark hallway. When I reached the door to the next exhibit and stepped inside, my peaceful transcendental experience vanished. Almost instantly, existential anxiety took its place. This exhibit was not about a particular species or ancient time period, but of humans and modern culture. The exhibit communicated the rift in the relationship between humanity and nature, displaying all of the destruction that the human race is causing. Issues such as pollution, overpopulation, mass production, and extinction were plastered all over the walls. The small square exhibit made sure that you were aware that you were a part of this destruction, that you were responsible for the torture and suffering of your own home and all of your neighbors in nature, the very same nature that was depicted in the past exhibits that I had just visited. There was no escaping this feeling of failure and the seemingly inevitable demise of all forms of life as a result of the selfishness of humanity.</p><p>As I continued my way through the museum and my existential angst, I entered an exhibit that covered native peoples and the early ways of life. One portion featured interviews with Native Americans. These interviews highlighted how the Native Americans would pray to their gods and thank them for the meal that they had hunted or for the timber that they collected for their fire. To me, this seemed like the most honest way to live as a human, to give thanks to what nature has given you. I began to feel reassured that the human race wasn’t all destructive, and that it was possible for us to coexist with nature. All that we needed to do was to simply give thanks and treat it with respect as the living breathing thing that it is.</p><p>But, not even the natives were as pure as I had hoped them to be. Part of the interviews explained the native peoples’ love for war, even considering it to be a cornerstone of their identity to become a “warrior”. This mindset was in play as recent as World War II, as Native Americans reflected that they could not wait to reclaim their identity as a warrior through killing and destruction. My perception of their purity vanished. Where they treated nature with kindness and respect, they met any opposing humanity with hostility and violence. This violence was so important to them that the native peoples considered this conflict with “others” to be an essential part of their identity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4y6dFoq5DqaLeVbxkld2wg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I was appalled by the museum’s depiction of the human race. To me, it is clear that we have an inclination to “other,” that is, to neglect and negate other beings that are not us, considering them to be inessential and inferior. This “othering” is all that I found myself surrounded by that day in the Natural History Museum. From the desire for warfare and killing, to the neglect of nature and the environment, this “othering” is present in every issue that is currently haunting humanity. Is it possible to bridge the void between us and what we consider to be “other,” to reach common ground instead of destruction? What are we to make of ourselves if it is a necessary part of our essence to go to war with and kill members of our own species just as the native peoples thought? What will become of all of nature if we continue to think that we as humans are more essential than all other forms of life? Is it possible for humanity to come together at all, to realize that no individual or group really possesses the truth? This was my existential crisis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UohCuP42f6h_M0qv2eTgaw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Desperately searching for any sort of light to guide me through this abyss, I turned to one of the legendary works that phenomenologically navigates the interactions between two subjects, Hegel’s <em>Phenomenology of Spirit</em>. Serving as the foundation of all phenomenology, Hegel’s dialectic explains how all of history, beings, and nature come together in the form of “Absolute Knowing”. His theory begins by explaining the basic manner in which we perceive the world, building up and developing to the idea that each subject is a historical developing being. Therefore, all beings are always in the constant state of discovery, alienation, and becoming. By applying this dialectic, which he calls “The Notion,” to the crisis detailed above, we can both come to understand Hegel’s theory, while also come to a realization of what this theory suggests as the resolution between humanity and its tendency to “other” itself and nature.</p><p>Hegel begins the <em>Phenomenology of Spirit </em>with the explanation of “sense certainty”. He explains that sense certainty is the beginning of all knowledge. “The knowledge or knowing which is at the start or is immediately our object cannot be anything else but immediate knowledge itself, a knowledge of the immediate or of what simply <em>is” </em>(Hegel<em>, </em>1977<em> </em>pg. 58). Hegel explains that we must remain attentive to the object as it presents itself, not getting caught in trying “comprehend” it, but rather “apprehend” (Hegel<em>,</em> 1977,<em> </em>pg. 58). Take how we sense a tree for instance. In my observation of this tree, I see mostly every part that constitutes its being, from its branches, to its leaves, to the trunk that protrudes from the roots that I can see on the surface of the ground beneath it. In the most basic sense, Hegel is speaking of our limited sensation of a particular object, allowing the object to show us directly what it is. It seems as though this basic form of sensing should communicate various truths. For example, I believe that I know everything about the tree that I am observing. “But,” Hegel states, “in the event, this very <em>certainty</em> proves itself to be the most abstract and poorest <em>truth (</em>Hegel, 1977, pg. 58). If we pay closer attention, the object that we believed to be showing its purest form of itself, is actually only a shallow representation. As Hegel says, “An actual sense-certainty is not merely this pure immediacy, but an <em>instance </em>of it” (1977, pg. 59). He goes on to explain that in this encounter with this “instance,” there are two “Thises.” One of the “Thises” is the object, the other is the “I” that is perceiving. Both of these “Thises” are not fully present when they encounter each other; but rather, they are only mediated forms that conceal other aspects of themselves.</p><p>There are two ways to go about making sense of this encounter between the two “Thises”. One of which is the realist position. The realist asserts that the knowledge of the object is not all that important. The only thing that matters is that the object and its essence still exist. Whether or not it can be actually known and understood does not matter. To put it simply, the object is the essential component in the realist’s self-certainty. Hegel points out that there are issues with the realist’s perspective when it comes to pointing to what it is that we are sensing. Because we are only observing a specific instance of an object, is there any way to accurately convey what it is that we see? Hegel doesn’t think so. When we wish to identify or label something that we see, we label it with a universal term, such as me telling you that I see this tree. Hegel explains that because language is nothing but universals, “…it is just not possible for us ever to say, or express in words, a sensuous being that we <em>mean</em>” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 60). When I tell you about this tree that I am perceiving, you still have no idea what tree it is that I am referring to. The universal term, “tree,” could be referring to any type of tree. This shows the limitation of language when it comes to identifying what it is that we mean when we speak.</p><p>The other way to interpret the sense-certainty encounter between the two “Thises” is the idealist position. Where the realists believe the object to be the essential component and the knowing inessential, the idealist believes the opposite to be the case. The idealist recognizes the knowing as the essential and the object as inessential. In the case of me observing a tree, I, the knower, is what holds the tree into place because it is “I” that knows the object as I see it. But, for the same reason that universals do not work for the realist, they also do not work for the idealist. If I instruct someone to look at “this” tree “here,” those words are in reference to my interpretation of “this” and “here”. To another person, those universals may indicate an entirely different object. This misunderstanding is why Hegel asserts that it is the idealist that is correct and not the realist. Despite there being many different perceptions of what the “this” or “here” is, “What does not disappear in all this is the ‘I’ as <em>universal…” </em>(Hegel, 1977, pg. 62). But this means that like “this” and “here,” “I” is also a universal. This means that every “I” that is perceiving holds truths that cannot be communicated through universals. Hegel asserts that inability to escape universals is the limit of sense-certainty. In order for me to tell you about the particular tree that I am perceiving, I must go further than sense-certainty.</p><p>It must be noted that the universal, “Now,” that Hegel discusses leads into what he refers to as “The Notion”. The particular universal is when we point to something and assert that it is “Now.” As soon as we assert this “Now,” the moment in time has already passed, and it has become a new “Now”. For instance, as I observe this tree and tell you to look at it “Now,” the instant that I point to the moment it has already fleeted and become something new. I could then negate the “Now” that has passed and assert a new “Now”; but that moment also passes, and it becomes a new “Now”. Hegel acknowledges that the “Now” can be a reference to seconds, minutes, hours, weeks, or any sort of time period (Hegel, 1977, pg. 62). Regardless of what measurement of time we are speaking of, the “Now” always passes and becomes a new “Now”. The multiple meanings of “Now” reveal its universality.</p><p>However, there is another aspect of the “Now” that Hegel takes interest in. In realizing that the movement is an assertion of the immediate “Now,” negation of that “Now,” and then negation of that negation by asserting a new “Now” in its place, I realize that the history of all of the “Nows” actually synchronize together to form a comprehensive history of “Nows”. For example, a day is composed of seconds, minutes, and hours, which are various degrees of “Nows”. But a day is also considered a “Now,” and it is part of the composition of a week, month, year and so on (Hegel, 1977, pg. 63). This never ending <em>supersession</em> is what Hegel refers to as “<em>Aufhebung” </em>in German, translated as sublation. It is mostly recognized as “The Notion”. He attributes this movement to natural consciousness, as it learns the truth from experience, forgets it, and then performs the movement again in search for the truth. The combination of consciousnesses experiencing and forgetting is what makes the consciousness. This is its never-ending historical becoming.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/241/1*yziqZ37eN-wRC1O3v_oEgg.png" /></figure><p>It is clear that sense-certainty is incapable of providing the information necessary to distinguish which tree it is that I am attempting to literally point out to you. As Hegel showed us, we lose ourselves in asserting different universals, all of the while still unable to accurately pin down the same object. Hegel explains, “Immediate certainty does not take over the truth, for its truth is the universal, whereas certainty wants to apprehend the This. Perception, on the other hand, takes what is present to it as a universal” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 67). Perception analyzes the object more thoroughly than sense-certainty, examining each property of the object and how those individual properties are both separate from each other but also make up the whole of the object. When we think of an object in this way, we can see that it is a product of <em>supersession</em> as previously explained. The object is a product of “The Notion,” both negating its properties and preserving them all at once (Hegel, 1977, pg. 68).</p><p>To make this movement of Perception more explicit, Hegel uses the example of a cube of salt. If we are to observe this cube of salt, we assert universals through sense-certainty by saying that it is “this” cube of salt. However, when we move further to use Perception, we can see that in “this” cube of salt, there is a collection of different properties that make up the particular cube of salt that we are speaking of. For instance, “this” cube of salt is white, tart, and in the shape of a cube. Here, we can observe how the universal “this” not only represents the cube of salt, but also all of the properties that make up that cube of salt and make it whole. “All these many properties are in a single simple ‘Here’, in which, therefore, they interpenetrate; none has a different Here from the others, but each is everywhere, in the same Here in which the others are” (Hegel, 1997, pg. 68). These qualities make up the “Here” that is the cube of salt, although they are also universals in of themselves. As Hegel mentioned, these properties, the whiteness, tartness, and cubeness, interpenetrate each other to form the cube of salt, but do not directly affect each other. As Hegel describes, the whiteness does not affect the tartness, and neither of those properties affect the cubeness. This manner in which the properties coexist with each other is referred to as the “Also”. For instance, the cube of salt is white, and “Also” in the shape of the cube, and “Also” tart.</p><p>Through this movement of perception, we see how the object that we are observing is both a <em>One </em>and a <em>Unity. </em>It is simultaneously the collection of properties that make up the whole, the <em>One,</em> and the product of individual and separate properties, forming the <em>Unity.</em> However, when we complete this analysis of the object and observe each of the properties that it is composed of, we realize that we, the observers, are the ones that hold these properties together in their unity. Therefore, we are known at the “<em>universal medium” </em>of the object. “So in point of the fact, the Thing is white only to <em>our eyes, also </em>tart to <em>our </em>tongue, <em>also </em>cubical to <em>our</em> touch, and so on” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 72). The essence of these properties come not from the object, but from us, for we are the ones who hold these together to create the objects’ <em>unity</em>. But, this then creates a contradiction. These properties that come together to form the <em>unity </em>of the object, though held together by us acting as <em>universal medium</em>, do indeed exist together to make up the <em>One </em>that is the object. The cube of salt <em>is </em>white, tart, and cubical, not because I perceive with my senses that it is so, but because these are the actual qualities that make up the cube of salt.</p><p>It can be observed that there is a process of acknowledging the <em>One </em>of the object and then breaking it down as a <em>Unity </em>of its properties. It is through this constant cycle of movements, the breaking down into universal properties and then reassembling them as a whole, that is the object itself. “The Thing is a One, reflected into itself; it is <em>for itself</em>, but it is also <em>for an other</em>; and, moreover, it is an <em>other </em>on its own account, just <em>because</em> it is another (Hegel, 1977, pg. 74). The object, therefore, exists for me to perceive and interact with, but it also exists in and for itself. The object both exists in my direct perception of it and its qualities, but also outside of my perception with its universal properties that compose it. Therefore, the very object that we are observing <em>is</em> this entire process.</p><p>This is the establishment of Hegel’s 4-way dialectic. As we have explored, our consciousness can become lazy and only experience the object through sense certainty. It is only when consciousness goes further, to perception, that it is more capable of experiencing this object and its individual properties. However, rather than perception only concerning my relation of the object and its properties, it also reveals that the object exists independently of me based on the constant interaction and distinction done by the properties that make it up. Thus, our entire experience is a continuing cycle of engaging with objects as they exist for us, but then reassessing as those objects continue existing for themselves, distinguishing themselves from other objects with its particular properties, while those properties are only existing for distinguishing themselves amongst each other. To put it simply, it is an always occurring dialectic between the object and I, and also the object and its properties. It is through this process that the object and its properties cycle through asserting and negating its identity.</p><p>To Hegel, this is the manner in which every consciousness experiences and makes sense of the world around us. Every consciousness serves as the universal medium for all objects and experiences they encounter. That being said, this also means that each perception that one has is merely their subjective truth. Therefore, the only way in which the true objective nature of an object can be discovered, or any potential objective truth for that matter, is if many perspectives and universal mediums come together to communicate their experience. This ties in with Hegel’s overarching theme that the truth is the whole through the Notion, or sublation. Take my perception of the tree. My observation of this particular tree and all of its properties are very different from your observation of the tree. I cannot take my observation and assume it to be the objective truth, for that would just be going back to consciousness’ laziness in sense certainty. I must recognize that I, just by being the universal medium, cannot truly know the object by myself. The object can only truly be known if many perspectives are combined with each other, co-constructing the whole of the object.</p><p>By breaking down the function of consciousness and how it perceives, Hegel is also illustrating phenomenologically how consciousness is constantly rediscovering its own identity and knowledge of the world through experience. But, this knowledge of self and the world cannot be obtained by consciousness all by itself. It must communicate with other perspectives in order to get that much closer to the ever evolving whole that is the truth. So, to return to my crisis in the Natural History Museum, it appears that the solution is simple. If humanity is destroying and killing itself through war, then it should be obvious that the solution is that all of humanity should come together to combine their perspectives to get closer to this forever expanding truth.</p><p>However, Hegel shows us how communication may not be that simple. In his explanation of the relationship between the Lord and the Bondsman, Hegel shows the immense problems that can arise when two consciousnesses meet for the first time. First, Hegel explains that self-consciousness can only exist in itself when it is acknowledged by another (Hegel, 1977, pg. 111). Considering that we have only been considering consciousness as a perceiver of object thus far, this is quite a crucial moment for the development of consciousness. Consciousness’ realization of itself, self consciousness, is possible only through recognition by another self consciousness.</p><p>Hegel explains how the two consciousnesses should operate in the dialectical manner, however, the two self-consciousnesses wish only to prove that they are the all-knowing essential consciousness. This laziness within self-certainty results in a fight to the death between the two self-consciousnesses. “They must engage in this struggle, for they must raise their certainty of being <em>for themselves </em>to truth, both in the case of the other and in their own case” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 114). Self-consciousnesses feels threatened by the other’s presence, therefore, feeling that it must destroy the other to prove that it exists for itself and not the other. Thus, self-consciousness will do anything to assert itself as the essential being. It sees itself as the only thing that matters because it is the one perceiving, judging, and knowing. Therefore, it deems any opposing self-consciousness as inessential. This is the phenomenological moment of “othering”. Hegel refers to the consciousness “that exists <em>for itself</em>” as the “Lord”. The other self-consciousness, who has been either killed or at risk of being killed, is forced into submission by the Lord, is the Bondsman. The Bondsman, having lost the fight to the lord, finds its own existence completely dependent upon the victor, for they are no more than a thing in relation to the essential consciousness.</p><p>One does not have to strain too hard to find evidence of this “fight to the death” throughout the course of human history; it is littered with it. From war, to slavery, to genocide, this process of “othering” is considered amongst the worst of evils. In modern society, “othering” processes such as racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, xenophobia are more prevalent than ever. All of these examples, historical and contemporary, began when one consciousness, or group of consciousnesses, considered themselves to be the essential. All of the “others” were considered to be inessential. Whether we are observing the current hostility between two opposing sides in the political climate within the United States, or the Native Americans and their desire to live out their lives as warriors, it seems like humans cannot help but to consider their own individual consciousness essential over everything else. Are humans capable of overcoming our tendency to rely heavily on the inaccuracy of sense certainty? Will humanity ever reach the point of realization that they do not know everything, and that they must actively perform the “The Notion” to take them further?</p><p>In an attempt to reconcile with this failed relationship between the Lord and the Bondsman, the two turn towards skepticism and stoicism (Hegel, 1977, pg. 119). The stoic retreats into itself, thereby asserting that the only truth that can be discovered is its pure thought. In making this movement of retreat, the stoic becomes an inward thinking subjectivity, thus dissociating itself from all outward experience. Therefore, the Bondsman, having been defeated by the Lord and now dependent on them, can become “free” by retreating into their own pure thought. Hegel explains the Bondsman’s retreat into thought to become free by stating, “In thinking, I <em>am free</em>, because I am not in an <em>other</em>, but remain simply and solely in communication with myself, and the object, which is for me the <em>essential</em> being… and my activity in conceptual thinking is a moment within myself” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 120). The Lord can also realize its freedom through the same manner. Through the stoicism, the Lord could realize that the truth lies not in its relationship with the Bondsman, but in its retreat to into its own pure thought. No matter the identity of the individual, the key aspect of stoicism is that, “Freedom in thought has only <em>pure thought </em>as its truth…” (Hegel, 1997, pg. 122).</p><p>It is easy to spot issues with the stoic’s position. The most glaring issue is the principle that one can only live free by claiming that their subjectivity and thought is essential, leaving every instance of “other” still inessential. The only difference between the stoic retreating into thought and the Lord who rules over the Bondsman, is that the stoic does not even wish to interact with other forms of consciousness. Why should it interact with the “other” when the truth lies in its own thought? “Its principle is that consciousness is a being that <em>thinks</em>, and that consciousness holds something to be essentially important, or true and good only in so far as it <em>thinks </em>it to be such (Hegel, 1977, pg. 121). It is out of this precise reason that the skeptic develops. Unlike the stoic, the skeptic sees that the “otherness” is what is essential. The skeptic illuminates the contradiction within the stoic’s perspective by questioning how the stoic can assert that its subjective purity of thought is essential and “others’” thought are not. The stoic and its pure freedom in thought is not possible. Each time that the stoic would interact with reality, its pure thought and freedom would fall apart because of the randomness that exists within the world, such as truths put forth by other consciousnesses and objects. Despite this valid criticism form the sceptic, they too fail to find a viable answer. The skeptic, seeing the “other” as essential, finds itself in a world that lacks stability. Each “other” that it encounters imposes its own subjective truth, which then gets opposed and contradicted by the another’s subjective truth. Therefore, the skeptic can never find solid footing in a world where the essential is full of the variety of ever-changing “others”.</p><p>Hegel explains how the stoic and the sceptic come together to form the “Unhappy Consciousness”. The tension between these two philosophical positions manifests within one consciousness as it attempts to unite its inward pure thought with the external randomness of the “other” and the world. It is very easy to relate to what Hegel means by the “Unhappy Consciousness”. If we examine humanity as a species, we can find that it naturally turns inward to thought and considers itself to be essential, then facing the inevitable conflict that comes from establishing their truths against the truths asserted by the “other”. This thought process then organizes itself with like-minded individuals within a group, whether it be taking a side in politics, nationality, gender, ethnicity, sexuality, family, or taking the side of human against nature. It is within these groups that we consider ourselves to be the essential. Therefore, according to us, all opposing “others” are false and inessential. The natural “Unhappy Consciousness” of the human race is this tension of living within one’s group with their own set of truths, whilst facing the opposition of the various “others” who are also asserting their own truths. Therefore, all of reality is constructed through the conflict of these different groups, located on different scales and magnitudes, attempting to assert their respective truths over each other.</p><p>“Spirit” is the solution to the “Unhappy Consciousness’” tension. “Reason is Spirit when its certainty of being all reality has been raised to truth, and it is conscious of itself as its own world, and of the world as itself” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 263). Spirit realizes that the world that comes from its pure thought is equally essential as the various worlds of the “other,” whether it be another consciousness or nature. Hegel explains how all of the movements made thus far make up the Spirit. “Spirit is thus self-supporting, absolute, real being. All previous shapes of consciousness are abstract forms of it. They result from Spirit analyzing itself, distinguishing its moments, and dwelling for awhile in each” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 264). Thus, sense-certainty, perception, understanding, stoicism, skepticism (among others not discussed here), all come together by way of The Notion and exist within the one true being of Spirit. One of these aspects cannot exist without the others, going back to Hegel’s overarching claim that the truth is always the whole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*CNd0W3LvzXnHGI5QB9BVnQ.png" /></figure><p>If we go back to analyze the different ways in which humanity “others,” we begin to see that we are gradually working towards the unity that the Spirit establishes in certain answers. In issues such as racism and sexism, although there is certainly still a significant amount of “othering” occurring within these populations, it has shown signs of improvement over past decades through civil rights and social justice. This improvement displays the development of Spirit, although this development is occurring at a very slow pace.</p><p>Despite the majority of humanity failing in the development of Spirit by still choosing to “other”, there is yet another step that lies beyond it, “Absolute Knowing”. This is the moment that Hegel has been building up to all along. Hegel explains that the Spirit, which formerly appeared to be the solution to our Unhappy Consciousness, is also only a form of “picture thinking,” meaning that it is just another form of self-certainty (Hegel, 1977, pg. 479). Thus, in order to reach the next step, all that Spirit has to do is to perform the Notion to supersede itself. This supersession takes place through the Spirit externalizing its self-consciousness, viewing itself as an object and “other” for the first time. Hegel states, “…for in this externalization it posits <em>itself</em> as object, or the object as itself, in virtue of the indivisible unity of <em>being-for-self</em>” (Hegel, 1977, pg. 479). Hegel continues to say that self-consciousness then takes this externalization back into itself, creating a unity between its self and its “otherness”. This unity is, once more, the totality of all of consciousness movements thus far. Through the Notion, consciousness realizes that it is both a thing, a self, and an “othering,” and that all other instances of consciousness that it encounters are the exact same combination. If the totality of humanity were to ever reach “Absolute Knowing,” it would finally be aware of its tendency to “other” the rest of humanity that is not it. Therefore, all humanity would finally realize the harm that it was causing itself through war, racism, sexism, and all of the rest of instances of “othering” that divide humanity. Humanity would realize that all of its individual consciousnesses, each with their own subjective truths and perspectives, are all equally valuable and essential in forming the truth that is the whole.</p><p>Hegel asserts that the process is still incomplete, for nature has still failed to be considered (Hegel, 1977, pg. 492). It is this unity between humanity and nature that is one of the final moments of “Absolute Knowing”. The self-certainty in this case is that humanity knows itself, therefore, “othering” nature and considering it to be inessential. But this is not true, for humanity is a part of nature. Thus, humanity allows itself to go through the process of the Notion and realizes that it is in unison with Nature, for the truth is that the entirety of both of them are equally essential to each other. They are one and the same, a unity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/1*WI7_c921r5GNzT6q_U2t_A.png" /></figure><p>Lost amidst the abyss that was my existential crisis of what humanity is to do with their tendency to “other,” I used Hegel’s dialectic as my guiding light, just as I have done here. Through the Notion, Hegel phenomenologically breaks down our entire existence, starting with one consciousness’ laziness self-certainty and ending with consciousness realizing that it is a constant becoming amongst other consciousnesses who are doing the same thing. It is this complacency within self-certainty that consciousness is overcoming through the Notion, again and again, each time learning and discovering something new about the history and being of itself. If the Notion tells us anything, it is that humans must address their tendency to “other” through this self-certainty. Hegel has shown just how lazy that consciousness can become, as it sometimes wishes to remain in self-certainty and not to fully engage with the “other” that lies before it, whether it be another object, a person, or nature. It assumes itself to be the essential and completely disregards what the “other” has to offer. If humanity wishes to resolve all of the instances in which it “others,” it must be willing to explore this “otherness”. In doing so, the species can finally see the value that lies in making the movement of that first negation, the first step in the unfolding of The Notion and sublation. This is the only way that nature and humanity can avoid its destruction: the unification of consciousness and object, consciousness and consciousness, humanity and nature, continually coming together in discover the ever changing and evolving truth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/785/1*cYi423RB2VBG6awmJgsuuw.jpeg" /></figure><p>References</p><p>Hegel, G. (1977). <em>Phenomenology of Spirit</em> (A. Miller, Trans.). Oxford University Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ddb01669d38f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>