<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Joshua Foong on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Joshua Foong on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 07:08:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[This is not goodbye]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/this-is-not-goodbye-c14c0e7f94d2?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c14c0e7f94d2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jun 2024 13:31:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-10T13:31:04.163Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>First published in 2017.</em></p><p><strong>01</strong></p><p>He was the first person I met from Apostles.</p><p>We were gatekeepers at the pantry that day. I think Judy assigned him there since he had done the checklist thing before. Wasn’t too sure about me though; 2 hours later, I reckoned it had something to do with the Cantonese-speaking crowd lined up with the rest of the moms and dads. It’s funny because I do have Cantonese somewhere on my resume, but I don’t speak it very well at all.</p><p>Too many volunteers showed up. Most of them kept indoors, manning the squashes and canned goods and other kinds of groceries. And so it was just the 2 of us stationed at the front gates, keeping the hungry folks outside company, noting down their IDs for what reason I still do not know.</p><p>It was cold, of course. And so we began with that.</p><p>We talked about the blizzard 2 months back, about me being new to winter and the city that came with it, about what made us turn up at a halfway house doubling as a pantry on a freezing Saturday morning.</p><p>I got around to talking about my time in the city so far. It has been rough. The first week was terrible, the heater didn’t work, and the commute was incredibly annoying. But I’m surviving. It’s been alright, I said.</p><p>I learnt that he’s an architect. Or an aspiring one officially — he had some papers he had to pass before he would be certified to do what he already was doing for a while now. Evidently, he can’t wait to get them over and done with.</p><p>He was also the least-informed person on trending pop culture, a knowledge which evidently was better than my own.</p><p>An architect? That’s cool, I thought.</p><p>I would later learn about the adopted childhood, a long time after learning about the adopted eye. I would learn that he has been struggling with himself for a long while. He has tried coming to terms with both his past and his present, the former feeding into the now. He is still trying. But I’m surviving, he would later say. By the grace of God, I’m surviving.</p><p>He also hates mustard. What kind of person hates mustard?</p><p>He would become a close Christian brother. We would spend Sunday mornings setting up the church for service, and afternoons at a diner with a couple of other big guys, wiping breakfast food off our plates.</p><p>He left early that day. I can’t recall why; probably had to do with work or something. He gave me the name of his church, said it was just a few blocks away from here.</p><p>And then we said goodbye.</p><p>I would meet him next morning at Apostles. That was the day New York finally began.</p><p>***</p><p><strong>02</strong></p><p>“Omg, you like whisky too???”</p><p>I can’t remember the rest of the conversation to be honest. But that was plenty of material to start a friendship. After all, it’s not every day you meet somebody who knows how to enjoy some proper amber in a glass.</p><p>I met the lady from Seattle on a Second Sunday. It’s this thing where the church people go to a place called 67 Burgers when it’s not summer.</p><p>The lady from Seattle is kinda round and really, really sassy. These both probably have something to do with the fact that her dad’s Italian. Don’t tell her I said that.</p><p>But back to whisky. She likes them neat, but better in her cocktail.</p><p>“Seriously, a whisky cocktail? Aurghh. That sounds like an abomination.”</p><p>“Oh don’t be such a kid. I have SOO much to teach you.” That last sentence; I was gonna hear her say that over and over in the days to come. Like, over and over and over and over.</p><p>You couldn’t tell if you have just met her, but this lady runs a fair bit (again, don’t tell her I said that). Ok fine, I said fair bit but it’s really closer to a lot. She’s in this program where they pair the likes of her with the homeless and/or recovering addicts. And then they run as a group. In the morning. At freaking 5am. I know, right?</p><p>She went on about a marathon she was going to join sometime in November. No way, she can’t be serious.</p><p>The lady from Seattle came to the Big Apple 2 years ago searching for a fresh start. A new career, a break from relationships, a little breathing space to figure out what the next phase in her life has installed for her.</p><p>In the next 2 months, we drank more whisky cocktails and other kinds of abominations. She also tried to teach me how to cook, though lessons were mostly limited to conversations in the metro. “Not EVEN poached eggs? You are KILLING me here man; I have SOOO much to teach you.”</p><p>And then she was gone. 2 months after we first met, she was headed back for Seattle. Turns out, the fresh start she needed was home all along.</p><p>We said our goodbyes at a train station. I found that she’s not very good at that sort of thing. You know, the thing where you hug another person and say a few words and wave before not seeing them for a really long time.</p><p>I visited the lady in Seattle a few months later. She showed me Olympus Park near where the Indian territories are, and the Hal Mize sketch in her apartment. I think she liked the second one better.</p><p>We said our goodbyes again, this time at the airport. The lady in Seattle was still not very good at that sort of thing.</p><p>She ran her first marathon in November. She would complete the race with a busted ankle, 2 shoes full of blood, and (what was probably) a horrible timing.</p><p>But she finished it anyway.</p><p>***</p><p><strong>03</strong></p><p>“Eh, Panini Bro not working there any more sial.” “Yea, he said he moving to Virginia for uni.” “Wah sian. Then my fries how?”</p><p>Everyone in the house knew who Panini Bro was. He’s the tall, dorky-looking fella who spoke English with an odd droll, like the words were hanging down from his Adam’s apple and got stuck or something.</p><p>I mean, it’s really good English, considering English isn’t his native language. No I don’t think I’m being mean.</p><p>We called him Panini Bro because he worked at a panini place. Well, technically it was a pizza place, but I don’t think any of us ever ate a single slice from the oven. Besides, we could all do with more panini places in our lives.</p><p>Now this panini place was located in a Jewish neighborhood, and was operated by a short old man from Uzbekistan, making it one of only two non-Jewish food places on the main street. That is very important to note, since that Jewish neighborhood was where we lived, and the Jews shutter up their stores every Friday evening for Shabbat.</p><p>At the start of the weekend, the panini place would turn into a shining establishment on the street corridor, all other shop lights diminished.</p><p>(In case you’re wondering, the only other food place was a Chinese takeout. Obviously.)</p><p>Panini Bro made the best fries with the best panini. We don’t know what magic he did to the potatoes, but they came out exactly brown and exactly crispy. Which was amazing, considering he was just a part-time worker there. The other full-timers weren’t half as good as him.</p><p>He was also the only fella in the neighborhood who was vaguely interested in where we came from. “Sin Ga Pu? … No, I not know where is Sin Ga Pu. Maybe you show me?”</p><p>Panini Bro took free English classes in the day and flipped burgers at night. When flipping burgers, he talked to us about how long a week he was having with school and work, how he was saving up for his college education, how he needed the English classes before he could pass admissions. Then he would make us talk about Sin Ga Pu and the weather. The short old man would tell him to shut up, and Panini Bro would shout back a few words in Russian.</p><p>I think. I’m not really sure what they speak in Uzbekistan.</p><p>He also said that he has a twin brother in Virginia. He’s going to join his twin over there, and he would be pursuing Computer Science because “they say that is where you make big money.” I’m not sure if we believed him when he said that.</p><p>Panini Bro went to Virginia in the summer of 2016. We didn’t get to say goodbye at the shop, and I realized I did not ask for his name.</p><p>Later, the short old man sold the panini place to another owner; must have been sometime in November. I visited one Friday and saw an unfamiliar guy toasting the burger buns.</p><p>I ordered a chicken panini with fries.</p><p>They were the worst fries I have ever eaten in New York City.</p><p>***</p><p><strong>04</strong></p><p>I remember when the kid first got here. He was very friendly to all the co-workers that Monday, went right up to everyone and greeted them with a fist-bump or a chivalrous wave. And then he did it again the second day. And on his first week. And then his first month. That went on for quite a while.</p><p>The kid is one of the brightest and most hardworking dudes I know. He majors in computer engineering or something like that, and the stuff he made was brilliant. Brilliant to the likes of myself at least: he could design and code complicated circuit boards, or build a robot from scratch which he could then control remotely.</p><p>He fixed phones on the side for some quick cash and worked at a restaurant on weekends. I think he has got a couple of other small stuff going on, but I can’t remember what.</p><p>Between school, internship, side income, and bell-boy duties, he stretched himself to remain self-reliant. He hasn’t taken a single dime from his parents since he started college and intended to keep it that way.</p><p>Well, it wasn’t always ‘that way’ from the beginning.</p><p>The kid moved to the States from the Dominican Republic when he was 5. Growing up, he said he wasn’t much of a school kind of guy, even though he’s really smart; he just messed around with friends and girls and got up to all kinds of crap.</p><p>All kinds, but not drugs and cigs, “cos they fuck you up, and no way I’m gonna do that to myself”.</p><p>Kid knew what he was talking about. His family found themselves in the Bronx when they moved to the city in the late 1990s. He saw everything; the poverty, the discrimination, the disparity, the crime, and of course the drugs. The more he saw, the more he realized that he had too many things working against him already, so no way he was going to make it worse by working against himself.</p><p>After all, he was a Latino in the U S of A. “It’s tough just living in this city already. But if you brown or black? Damn.”</p><p>That’s when it finally came to him. He wanted to get out of the Bronx. He was going to find his own place and take care of his younger brother, and that wasn’t going to happen if he kept messing around. He has got to get his shit together; it wasn’t so hard once he put some juice into it.</p><p>Wasn’t so hard for school at least, went from passing classes in college to scoring ‘A’s almost overnight. But he learnt that the money part came tough. Making money meant working weekends, traveling 90 minutes from the Bronx to Brooklyn while others took half that time, and having to prove himself as a brown guy when he was capable of so much more.</p><p>“One day, I’m gonna say goodbye to that part of town and find someplace nice. No drugs, no shit, someplace I can make it on my own.”</p><p>He wants to build his own robots someday. The real deal, the kind they put on Mars and stuff.</p><p>Kid loves his younger brother to bits; bought him a bed on his 5th birthday. He said his brother looked up to him, and that he was like a second dad in the family.</p><p>“We’re all nothing without family man. Why do you think I work so hard for?”</p><p>***</p><p><strong>05</strong></p><p>20 miles an hour.</p><p>It’s not quite the speed of sound, but when you are rolling down a steep tar road in Manhattan at 20 miles, that’s quite enough for you to sense the mortality of such an endeavor right down to your bones.</p><p>But such an endeavor also offers you the most magnificent tour of the city you can ever possibly imagine. Imagine zigzagging between cars, lights on Times Square dissipating into a blur, pedestrians cheering you on and screaming something incomprehensible as the pack thunders past.</p><p>They call themselves the Wednesday Night Skate, a group of crazies who meet on Wednesday nights to, uh, skate. The shoe-on, inline variety, not the flat wooden boards that develop one leg disproportionately to the other.</p><p>Sometimes there were a handful, and sometimes there were close to a hundred of us from around the world wrecking havoc on the streets. Imagine a Russian lady on skates stopping traffic on Broadway. Once the party is up, we hit the bar on East 36th and get rowdy.</p><p>I did not talk to many in the group, and given that I was not very sociable to begin with I mostly kept to myself.</p><p>But there was one guy I did talk to on a number of occasions. Well, ‘talk’ is a tad off in this particular application. You see, this guy does not speak English.</p><p>40 skaters in a bar, and I meet the one guy whom I cannot have a conversation with — that was what I thought when he reached his hand over and cheerily blurted “coma esta amigo!”</p><p>He’s Colombian. They speak Spanish.</p><p>Over many beers that night and the Wednesdays after, I would learn more about the Colombian who spoke no English. He was an aspiring commercial photographer, an avid skater, a man new to the city like me.</p><p>He would attempt to teach me many words in his language, and I would return the favor with my own. We would fail miserably together. We continued employing the wonders of modern technology to facilitate our conversations (i.e. Google). I bought him a drink after our third meeting, and he would reciprocate the next time around.</p><p>Well, I did learn one new Spanish word from him — cerveza. Go Google it.</p><p>I gathered not much else from the Colombian. We became the type of friends who didn’t ask too much about the kind of lives we led when we did not have skates on our feet. Just a lot of punching each other on the shoulders, and him laughing at me when I looked spent trying to keep up with the rest of the pack. And then saying goodbye before it was Thursday.</p><p>It’s odd how the only friend I made there was a man with whom I could not even hold a conversation. And yet, on those wonderful evenings when the cars honked incessantly at us roadrunners, it felt just about right.</p><p>***</p><p><strong>06</strong></p><p>“Why did you have to show up at that pantry and join our CG? See, now all of us have gotta say goodbye to you.”</p><p>She was the really short Chinese girl from California. She loves to dance. Sometimes her body doesn’t allow her to, but that’s ok.</p><p>Her family lived in Vietnam for a while then settled in San Diego; she moved to New York a little over a year ago. She does not know if this is where she should be, but she is absolutely sure where she shouldn’t — California.</p><p>“Geez, you should have just stayed in Singapore man.”</p><p>And she’s joking of course. But she has a point too.</p><p>Imagine someone coming into your life for significant period of time. The only condition: this person will be leaving by the end of the year. You don’t know when you will meet this person again. How do you deal with such a presence? Don’t get too close and guard your circles? Break bread together and make a new friend anyway?</p><p>And if you do, how do you bid farewell?</p><p>I recall a conversation I had with her between 2 towering bridges, close to where I used to work. Here’s where you see the trains trudging along on the Manhattan bridge on your right, agonizingly loud and slow, almost as if they were doing their utmost to disrupt the pleasantry of the landscape in front of you.</p><p>We laughed at how cautiously the trains proceeded over the East River. The time was late, and still they dragged themselves across the bridge, shuttling between Manhattan and Brooklyn. This was a city that could never stop moving.</p><p>Kind of like its inhabitants themselves: always transient, always going somewhere. One day you are in Vietnam, then San Diego, and all of a sudden you find yourself in the Big Apple.</p><p>“Where’s next for you?”</p><p>“I don’t know. Maybe I’ll stay. Maybe I’ll find someplace else. I’ve only been here for a while, we’ll see.”</p><p>“So why did you leave?”</p><p>She left because there was little else for her back home, only unsavory memories and unmet expectations. Oh, I said, I know someone like that. That someone’s in Seattle now.</p><p>She showed me what the city looked like in the evenings. She loved it at night, for all the same reasons I first found it distasteful — dirty pizzerias, crowded bars, trains that never stopped running. We caught a lot of jazz acts, though it was just multiple outings to the same place over and over again.</p><p>“I like it here. The city lights, people up and about at 3am in the morning. Is Singapore like that?”</p><p>I in turn would show her bits and pieces from home. I would overemphasis the distinct Malay-ness of my country, mostly through our food. We are not just another Chinese community like Hong Kong or Taiwan. We are not just another ex-British colony. We are different.</p><p>“Well, everyone in this city is different, so what’s your point?”</p><p>A few months later, we went to a steep Tapas place in East Village. The year was almost up. She said this one’s on her, since she wouldn’t be able to make fun of me anymore once I leave.</p><p>Or maybe not.</p><p>“Now you are totally indebted to me after this meal. You had better feed me well when I visit you in Singapore.”</p><p>So back to the question. How do you bid farewell?</p><p>I suppose you don’t.</p><p>I suppose you find another place, another time,</p><p>and another excuse to break bread again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c14c0e7f94d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Two and Two is One]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/when-two-and-two-is-one-5c9621b46686?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c9621b46686</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jun 2024 13:11:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-10T13:11:52.699Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>First published in 2016.</em></p><p><strong>Part I — Basic and Other</strong></p><p>It has been 4 months since I arrived in New York. In that time, I have traded winter boots for bermudas, worked out the rhythm of my daily grind, and learnt what it means to miss your friends and family back home over and again. And ate bagels. Lots and lots of bagels.</p><p>The 4 months have also made me profoundly aware of myself, in particular, a side of me that I never had cause to muse over back home.</p><p>It begins as prejudice in my banter with strangers, a prejudice which (for reasons that cannot be explained) I invite wilfully. It repeats itself at every mealtime, at every purchasing decision, when working with my colleagues. It is, however, felt most acutely in the idle moments both ephemeral and prolonged, when the absence of a familiar presence somehow accentuates the person that I am.</p><p>I have never quite realized that I am an Asian until now. More specifically, I am Chinese with a capital C. Yes, I do feel incredibly weird typing that previous sentence. No, I am not writing about racial profiling and/or other social injustices. My life here thus far has been splendidly devoid of that sort of thing, thank you very much.</p><p>But I am that which I said I am. Chinese. I am fluent in Mandarin, I struggle with Cantonese, and I take my rice very seriously. This is not an instance of the outside looking in; this is me undertaking a conscious effort to identify myself as such. In the past four months, I have begun an earnest exercise to discern my heritage, in a sea of New Yorkers hailing from every corner of this good Earth.</p><p>Why am I doing this?</p><p>I was at a gathering recently where those in attendance were largely Asian of the Eastern variety. Most have been born and raised in the States, or have spent a significant number of years growing up here. I do not know how they choose to identify themselves. I am pretty confident though, that they all shared similar childhood experiences under a brand of parenting that had its origins from the other side of the Pacific.</p><p>Somewhere in the chatter and blabber, an exchange struck me as particularly odd.</p><p>“I didn’t know you were from Taiwan! I always thought of you as just Chinese. I can’t really tell the difference.”</p><p>“Yea, no I’m not like, basic Chinese.”</p><p>Cue laughter.</p><p>The differentiation between ‘Chinese’ and ‘other Chinese’ comes intuitively any one that is, well, Chinese. It is a concept shaped by the natural migrations of a civilization, as well as political ideologies that force topographical elements to mean something they are not.</p><p>I never imagined I would find myself flinching at that exchange. I have heard that one before; why does it mean so different now?</p><p><strong>Part II — Say No to Soylent</strong></p><p>I grew up Singaporean, where Chinese means “must plus one Malay and one Indian in government advertisement then got racial harmony”. Ethnicity is an explicit identity on your NRIC and an apparatus for nation-building. Being a locally-educated Chinese who served out his service to his country also means I have the distinct privilege of differentiating myself from the Ah Tiongs, also known as mainland Chinese. That this distinction exists never bothered me much; I was too busy juggling my intellectual pursuits in institutions that are predominantly Chinese-populated, while feeding my localism in the company of Malay and Indian brothers (or abangs), most of whom I befriended from my time in the Force.</p><p>But that distinction exists. We are Chinese-Singaporeans, not Chinese-Chinese, without the “heavily accented English and questionable hygiene standards and spicy hotpot” and a host of other conceivable racist stereotypes.</p><p>Fast-forward back to the present. Laughter at the gathering dies down; chatter resumes. I continue to participate in the awkward procession of small talk, but hereon with furrowed eyebrows. Wow, I thought, here I am a Chinese in a non-Chinese world. There and then, I stumbled upon the realization that I have to redefine the person that I am. The same person has to contend with parts of himself that he never once thought anything of, like a sick man asking the doctor, “Oh, I have a spleen? What on earth is that?”</p><p>Being Chinese is a vague endeavor. It is not at all a difficult one though. There are many things that distinguishes the different groups, clans, dialects, and nationalities from one another. There are many things that we share in common too.</p><p>It begins with drawing towards that which is most familiar. The first month here saw very little of bagels for breakfast and tacos with salsa. It was Hong Kong restaurants, soba, and rice vermicelli, grocery shopping in Chinatown (not Trader Joe’s). Milo here is hardly Milo back home, but I’ll take it any day over soylent or Starbucks coffee.</p><p>Then there is the spoken word. I find myself in a city that speaks my first language, yet it is conversations in Mandarin that I anticipate, even though my linguistic proficiency makes it more inconvenient than efficient. I pretend to keep up. Not doing so was clearly inappropriate; obvious only to me, of course, because my upbringing suggests that I was taught to hold my own in Mandarin. Choosing otherwise meant feigning ignorance and rejecting the qualities of my other self.</p><p>Still, why am I doing this? I am in New York, where all in sight is cosmopolitan and colorful, where cultures, foods, and social stratifications bleed into one another. Why am I only embracing that which has always been me, when I have traveled an ocean to be liberated from it?</p><p>I don’t know. What I do know is that I inexplicably find myself in the company of other Asians very, very often. It’s comfortable. I am not confronted with my ignorance of Americanism, because even when it happens, I readily forgive myself in a coalition of people I assume familiarity with. Here, the conversation gravitates towards chopsticks, Asian habits, and tough family love.</p><p>I tried to convince myself that it is not the ethnic kinship that I am drawn to, but a system of beliefs entrenched in my consciousness ever since I was brought forth from the womb. I was determined to disregard cultural paraphernalia and focus my attention on the originating philosophies behind so-called “Chinese” habits.</p><p>Richard Nisbett’s ‘The Geography of Thought’ provided an intellectual sanctuary for that. The book spells out psychological differences between how the East and West approach language, conversation, intelligence, and conduct. He proposed that Asians are hardwired to prefer a holistic understanding of a situation over the empirical, deterministic practices of the West. Trains running late? Don’t just blame the train operator; consider the hundreds of New Yorkers tossing trash on the tracks every day. Enrolled in an Ivy school? You could be pretty damn smart, but being smart is made possible by orchestrating a thousand different events to work in your favor.</p><p>It’s tempting to stop there: being Chinese is to be hardwired as such. That’s your answer, move along now, nothing else to see here. Only that would have been stupid. How can social thought embark on such a linear progression without being diluted by exogenous factors? Where is the role of history in this picture? Whatever happened to individual agency?</p><p>Nisbett himself admits that habits can be unhinged, and for those exposed to both cultures, practical philosophies are interchangeable. We can switch out of either at will; his research showed that this is especially so for Asian Americans, Singaporeans, and Hong Kongers. Why then do I still consider myself one over the neither?</p><p>The answers do not lie in a philosophical narrative, but genealogical one. It begins with the story of two men, both of whom I know of but barely knew.</p><p><strong>Part III — Two + Two</strong></p><p>My paternal grandfather (also Ah Gong) passed away before I could even walk. I do not know how old I was when that happened, but what I heard about him I heard from my Dad. As a young man from Guangdong, he traveled across the South China Sea to Nanyang, also known as Southeast Asia to the modern geographer. I believed he was fleeing the effects of Communism on his home, a detail my Dad could not confirm. He was lowly educated, so the jobs that he could secure were often laborious and never permanent. I have heard of the term ‘coolie’ in Social Studies classes in primary school; I never thought that my Ah Gong was one himself. My Dad spoke of how the family lived in a kampong while he was still a child (i.e. a village), how they survived on a diet of rice with soy sauce and home-grown sweet potatoes, how the sweet potato crops were destroyed when the government evicted the villagers when confiscating state land, how a family of 8 people relocated to a tiny rental apartment that came without a bedroom.</p><p>If Ah Gong’s life is epitomized by poverty and mediocrity, my maternal grandfather’s life could not have been more different. We called him Gong Gong (usually reserved for paternal grandfathers), not Wai Gong (which is the accurate term, but which translates into “outside grandfather”). The story of how he came to be in Singapore was a fascinating one. A middle-class, highly-educated man with what I imagined was a bright future ahead of him, the three-way fight between the Kuomintang, the Communist Party, and the Japanese would change the entire course of his life. He would be conscripted and promoted in time to become a ‘low-level general’ (his words, not mine). He would lose the civil war, flee to Taiwan, and eventually find his way to Malaysia, where he taught in Chinese schools and later met his wife. His second wife, that is; he left behind his first family when he fled the mainland. Given his role in the war, he was a highly respected man by his peers, affiliated with numerous Chinese clans, and lived on a considerable property with three sons and three daughters when he finally settled down in Singapore.</p><p>As life would have it, both men would spend their final years up against the same backdrop: a modest government flat, seated in front of the television on an old and dusty sofa.</p><p>God sure has a brooding sense of humor.</p><p>Both my parents bore little love for their fathers. Growing up, my Dad had to be constantly treated for his ailments. On more than one occasion, he has spoken of how his mother struggled to raise the family and worked when jobs came her way, while attending intimately to his sickly condition. That he remained muted about Ah Gong’s role told me as much about what my Dad thought of his father, I am sure of it.</p><p>My Mom was mistreated. She was a girl; he wanted a boy. While the eldest son was lavished with love, the only love my mom saw came lashing from a belt. In another Asian family, the treatment would not have been out of place, but favoritism turned an act of parenting into a cruel childhood.</p><p>These are stories I had always known, recited to me while growing up. But they never meant much to me until here; they mostly just incited a cool nod from my brother and me during the rare occasions we sat down as a family at the dining table. Why did we need to know this? Is this my parents trying to rant at our sense of self-entitlement again? Probably yes; that was what I thought every time I had to ignore the sermons.</p><p>Then New York happened.</p><p>I played out those stories often and again while here. I thought of why I find it hard to affect the same cordialness I was used to from others with my Singaporean mannerisms. I thought of what made me the way I am, and if I am more a consequence of someone else’s actions than my own.</p><p>Before New York, I was simply Singaporean, and being Singaporean is about a present state. Not transient, but present. I always thought of it as a tattoo you are born with. You can remove it. You don’t.</p><p>But being Chinese.</p><p>That was a whole other something else I had to deal with. There is a quality of permanency about it that goes beyond genetics and language and color and government policy. Sure, being Chinese is about the things you choose. Hailing the waiter in Cantonese. Opting for noodles instead of fries. Feeling all nostalgic when the CNY draws near. Going for the discount while splurging on showmanship.</p><p>Being Chinese is also about the things you don’t get to choose. It is about Ah Gong and Gong Gong, who had no choice but to flee mainland. Dad, who had no choice but to live on sweet potatoes. Mom, who had no choice on how a girl was to be treated in her family. Me, accepting that I have no choice about the family that largely defined the person that I am, even if I lie about those sentiments outwardly.</p><p>And History. The Cultural Revolution of 1966, which in one fell swoop came to outline and split the entire body of Chinese people, purging all distinction between groups of Chinese in pursuit of “ideological purity”. The fracture that tore an entire civilization apart became that which draws us all towards each other.</p><p>Here we have on the one hand the irreversible history of the 20th century; on the other, an imagined narrative of what could have been. One exists as an imposition from all quarters, not just the East but the West especially. The other exists in the collective consciousness of a dispersed civilization, whether we acknowledge it or otherwise.</p><p>We all live and breathe the dual destiny that manifested in the people before us, and therefore, us.</p><p>I do apologize for digressing.</p><p>I am a product of a somewhere I knew next to nothing about. That I knew next to nothing was my own fault, and I never had reason to realize that until now. Because being Chinese means having a story to tell; basic or other, local or Ah Tiong, in poverty or dignity, with love or otherwise. You are not the protagonist, but it is your own story nonetheless.</p><p>As with all stories, you get to write your own.</p><p>***</p><p><em>What inspired this essay was an article in the New Yorker by Tash Aw, the author of The Harmony Silk Factory (an incredibly gripping novel and one of my absolute favorites). I confess to borrowing heavily from the themes expressed in his article, but only because everything he wrote resonated completely with what I believe to be myself.</em></p><p><em>That essay can be found here: </em><a href="http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-stranger-at-the-family-table?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTAAAR2G_eKnjNjArhGW_VT_Y1RlZCFqlbzRaKUkUx3lTxJliNZA_fwfqCrzPdc_aem_AS-hl-t4irpBKozbiHgvkDzAtp9iW-21JPXvuvqSOztL53dU_2ky39mzUp3xzGXKeY_TvkyapxIRAOKsaKqmRcgG"><em>http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-stranger-at-the-family-table</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c9621b46686" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Donning the Blue]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/donning-the-blue-ab18822d4cec?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab18822d4cec</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jun 2024 12:54:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-10T12:54:14.433Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>First published in 2013.</em></p><p>The dark blue of the police uniform had always struck me as something incredibly deliberate. Evolved from the khaki brown and grey of earlier generations of police officers, it was distinct from the blue of the civil defence, the auxiliary forces, and the other home team agencies. It’s so dark that it’s almost the color of the night itself. One could tell that this was not just any shade of dark blue, but a particularly imposing and dignified choice of hue.</p><p>Those thoughts raced through my head as I prepared to tuck my bush jacket into its dust cover and store it away for good. I cannot help but stare long and hard at it. There was still one question I had not been able to answer completely despite the past 23 months in the SPF.</p><p>For a long time now, I’ve been asking myself: what does it mean to be a police officer?</p><p>I know I have it somewhere. 23 months ought to leave me with some impressions, and I know I can’t live with the regret of not finding out the answer. I started to write.</p><p><strong>Part 1 – Perception</strong></p><p>It starts with the bus I took to work for the good part of my NS stint. The 172 service passes through major bases of all 3 uniformed organizations in the west: there’s the Tengah Air Base, Keat Hong Camp, Home Team Academy, Civil Defence Academy, and Jurong Police Division (where I work). You’ll see scores of NS boys pack the bus every day at 5pm, their attire clearly identifying themselves as either an Army or CD serviceman.</p><p>What you’ll never find though, is a police officer dressed in his uniform taking the bus home.</p><p>Neither will you ever see a uniformed cop at a coffee shop sipping kopi. Or sitting below void decks on the familiar blue stone benches. Why?</p><p>Or rather, why not? Officers are expected to bring packaged food back to the station to consume when there are good reasons for us to take it at the coffee shop itself. We cannot rest our legs in public, but are only allowed to catch a break while hiding in our office. Wouldn’t it make more sense to have policemen linger around in an open area where their presence can be felt, rather than trap them in an enclosed space and have no eyes and ears on the ground?</p><p>Of course, I know the reason why, and it’s more than just putting on a show of professionalism. Each time an officer dons the blue, it’s like pinning a target board on himself. The moment he steps out of his police vehicle, eyes follow. They study his face, his rank, his name tag, almost as if they are trying to identify and bookmark the person for some form of future reference — which is perfectly alright, because you would like to know the police officer patrolling your neighborhood, no? Except that one of these pairs of eyes might belong to someone with an agenda (i.e. a subject in hiding, a wanted criminal, or a “citizen journalist” who usually posts very criminal things on STOMP). Then it’s suddenly not-so-alright.</p><p>Unfortunately, this means that public perception towards us has become pretty harsh as a result. To think that cops once roamed the streets in carefree and domineering fashion before the turn of the millennium. Things are very different today. I once bought bubble tea from a neighborhood, non air-conditioned shopping center in my uniform. As I stepped out of the shop and started slurping, a group of teenagers passing by exclaimed in Mandarin, “walao, policemen can drink bubble tea one meh?” in a tone that suggested the only thing I was entitled to is tap water (they weren’t the only ones that day to shoot me condescending looks either). And every day when my office bunch goes out for lunch, it has become routine for us to change out of the number 3 into civilian attire. It’s troublesome stuff. More starkly, it’s a daily reminder of our inability to behave freely in our uniforms.</p><p>Little wonder why everyone in my office would not change into their uniforms at work whenever they can get away with it.</p><p>Nevertheless, it remains necessary for us to avoid being identified as policemen as far as possible. Ours is no longer an organization where one can wear his uniform and strut freely in public after all.</p><p>But there’s more. SPF does not just make it a point that their off-duty police officers remain undistinguishable from the members of public. They made it pretty hard to differentiate one cop from another as well. Just compare our working attire to the army number 4. It isn’t just the IPPT badge and marksman tab that’s missing; there are no arms badges, no formation patches, no fancy berets to be worn anywhere. Beyond the rank epaulettes, service ribbons, and the rare appearance of a skill badge, the uniform gives nothing else away about the officer.</p><p>Even the term “officer” bears significance in this aspect. Cast away the notion that a cop is either a “man, specialist, or officer”: there is no such thing as a 3-tiered hierarchy in the police force. Every cop is an “officer” by virtue of his occupation, and is to be addressed as “Sir” by his charges. To add to that, policemen are rarely named in the media. Officers working on an ongoing case will never be screened on the news for security reasons (besides the official spokesperson from Public Affairs, who usually isn’t even named). Neither will they be publicly recognized after the successful solvency of the crime. In an age of rampant online social networking, we remain anonymous.</p><p>All these, because being marked differently from a fellow officer can be a hindrance to our operational effectiveness. It can even be dangerous. Just ask every frontline cop how many times they have come across complainants or subjects insisting on “speaking only to the higher-ranking officer”, thereby prolonging engagement time at the scene and jeopardizing our operational capacity to attend to other crimes.</p><p>I’ve also come to realize that this show of singularity isn’t just a front either; it has imbued itself into the dynamics and relationships between officers as well. The working atmosphere is often a jovial, brotherly one, very unlike what I initially expected coming into a police divisional headquarters. Nobody addresses me as “Sir”, and if they do, I always insist they drop it. During major deployments, A Staff Sergeant with full knowledge of the terrain often takes charge of the situation and readily disagrees with a much higher-ranking Sector I/C with less expertise on the subject. Rank matters little as opposed to our respective designations, that much is for sure.</p><p>Over time, I came to realize that the police uniform is our greatest leveler all along. Doesn’t matter whether you’re an NSF or regular, senior or junior officer, shift work cop, or office hour staff; we all wear the same blue.</p><p><strong>Part 2 – Operation</strong></p><p>However, perception alone does not complete our identity as police officers. What is perceived is no doubt the result of the work we do as men in blue, which means I have to dwell on the stuff I had been up to at my desk space.</p><p>Every day at approximately 9am, I would receive briefing notes on all the reported cases that occurred in the 24-hour period during the earlier shift (which resets itself at 8am) in my inbox. Throughout the day, cases of interest (COIs) that are still fresh will pop up in my mail as well. On a weekly and monthly basis, all these cases are compiled and analyzed at a meeting chaired by the Commander or his/her deputy, and attended by all the key frontline officers in the division.</p><p>One key component of my job is to staff these meetings. Not only am I well-read on the crime cases that occur on a daily basis, I was exposed to information detailing the statistics, crime trends, hotspots, and other numerical crime indicators within my divisional jurisdiction every month. COIs are flashed up on the projector for discussion, often retold in explicit and graphic manner. Operational and investigative methods are reviewed over and over again. Penal Code statutes and crime classifications are thrown back and forth like a beach ball. On a bad day, such meetings can be bloody exhausting stuff.</p><p>I’ve also clocked in my fair share of ops hours. I’ve attended cases, apprehended subjects, laid ambushes, tailed illegal immigrants, patrolled dilapidated foreign dormitories, even witnessed prostitutes being apprehended from forested areas (I now know that Singapore is a very different city after midnight).</p><p>These, amongst many other policing duties I’ve come across, have led me to conclude one thing: there is no pride in our work as law enforcers.</p><p>As policemen, we don’t just deal with crime: we deal with the failings of our humanity. We deal with debt-crippled individuals, broken families, desperate situations, suicidal behavior, rape victims, and the occasional decomposed body of a lonely, neglected elderly person. We deal with the everyday affairs man could not resolve peacefully or competently amongst themselves, or the inner demon man we fight so hard not to succumb to. We deal with the things no one wants to deal with.</p><p>And we enforce the consequences of their failure. Ask yourself: have you never failed in your life up till now? No doubt we all had at some point, but it’s in understanding that these criminals have failed too, only differently, that you realize how similar we are to them.</p><p>Crime could happen to any one of us, sure, but what we often don’t realize is that we can be easily guilty of it too. When life deals you a forced hand, you become vulnerable to failure. Criminals are not crazy, not delirious, not without some kind of friends or family. Not unlike everyone else. The moment we believe that the inner convictions of another man have got nothing to do with us, we become estranged from one another. If deep down inside, we are not convinced that we are pretty much the same, there would be no such thing as society.</p><p>And if man is not prone to these shortcomings, we wouldn’t even have police officers. What pride is there to be had then, knowing that we exist as a result of this?</p><p>It’s no wonder nobody likes police officers. It’s an institution that reminds us of how our natural inclinations can go against our morality and therefore wrought harm or loss unto another. Not exactly a happy thought.</p><p>But I am not so cynical to think that policing does not carry an ounce of pride at all. It’s simply measured differently.</p><p>Our pride is measured in a very peculiar kind of hope. It’s the belief that maybe someday, people can solve their own problems, and police intervention won’t even be necessary. It’s something we’ve been working on for quite a while now.</p><p>Crime prevention has become a key focus of the Home Team in recent years. It is imbeded in the police mission statement, spawned so many anti-crime advisories and publicity campaigns, and has even become an organized crime-fighting entity with the introduction of COPS (Community Policing System). We have spent so much time formulating civilian policing groups like Citizens-on-Patrol and Neighbourhood Watch Groups. We liaised with large corporations and grassroots organizations, Members of Parliament, engaged foreign workers, and domestic maids. We even drove up north, knocked on the front doors of the Royal Malaysia Police, and insisted that a joint crime prevention pamphlet between the two forces be introduced. All this is done not just to curb the rise of an already impossibly low crime rate. It’s to allow the community to guide itself, and through it, reduce its dependency on an artificial law-enforcement agency like the police.</p><p>That, to us, is what we can hope for.</p><p><strong>Part 3 – Reflection</strong></p><p>So what then, does it mean to be a police officer? My understanding and attitude towards the force is hardly ubiquitous amongst the other 10,000 cops serving under the same name, but I guess my takeaways still count as an answer.</p><p>In Max Weber’s theory on the monopoly of violence, he puts forth that “[the] state is a human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory”. “Use of physical force” here is hence extended only to those working in two particular professions: the soldier and the law-enforcer.</p><p>I have had the fortune (or misfortune, subject to varying interpretations) of being both. Before my police calling, I was a newly minted private in the army. But while my army rifle was meant to shoot (hypothetical) enemy soldiers, my police revolver was meant for something very different.</p><p>The first time I loaded my revolver and stepped outside of the police station, the Taurus suddenly felt twice as heavy as it did during the practice rounds at the shooting range. The fact that it was meant to be pointed at a civilian when I was surrounded by them made me uneasy (no matter how hypothetical I made them out to be). Surely nobody wants to be put in this position.</p><p>And that, I realized, was my answer: being a police officer means being what nobody wants to be, and being who nobody wants around (especially at their doorsteps). It means carrying a revolver that must not be fired, but should it be unavoidable, it must be you and no one else that pulls the trigger (touchwoodtouchwoodtouchwood).</p><p>It proves to us that none of us are perfect, because our common humanity ultimately points towards our susceptibility towards failure. It shows us that while nobody is born a criminal, we are all capable of behaving criminally against another. It also reminds us while no two versions of morality are perfectly compatible, just as no single version of morality is universal, a universal code of conduct is still necessary for our coexistence.</p><p>And yet, it is also about hoping that crime will show itself no longer, and hence nobody else will be victimized as a result. It’s like that paradoxical phase you always find in war movies: we fight so that we don’t have to fight (crime) anymore.</p><p>And in the process, we become invisible. Being a cop means having no chance at heroism (at least not here in Singapore) because you must never stand out from the rest. In your uniform, you don’t only look like your colleague; you are one and the same. Without it, you blend into the commuting crowd making their way back home on the bus. What pride we earn can never be worn outright on our sleeves, but only pinned unto the deep recesses of our hearts.</p><p>We are nobodies. We are a group of faceless, silent law enforcers hidden behind the flag of our organization. We are the dark blue of the police uniform.</p><p>Almost the color of the night itself.</p><p>I tucked my bush jacket into its dust cover and stored it away for good.</p><p>***</p><p><em>This note is dedicated to the good men and women watching over our streets at night, both past and present. I really wish wholeheartedly that they could read this, but that would be ill-advised for reasons only I believe to be valid. Nevertheless, this still has to be written somewhere: my time in the force has affected me tremendously, has taught me how powerful it can be to hold true to one’s purpose, and completely remolded me to become the person I am today. All this is possible only because of the officers I have met, laughed with, and toiled alongside before we went our separate ways. To these Sirs and M’dms, thank you for everything.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab18822d4cec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ubin (2013)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/ubin-2013-0356b8aac0e4?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0356b8aac0e4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jun 2024 12:17:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-10T12:17:15.101Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>First published in 2013.</em></p><p>I have, for the longest time, tried coming to terms with my pencil art. Many assume my ability to be a talent, a God-given gift, a biological advantage I inherited that merits being labeled as “creative”, “artistically inclined”, something along those lines.</p><p>I hated it.</p><p>Alot of people don’t understand that creating what you call “art” is often a highly masochistic process. It involves closing yourself off in a room at the back of your mind, struggling incessantly for indefinite answers. It consists of hours, days, weeks surviving on emergency rations of inspiration as it runs dry. You find yourself questioning the entire purpose of the piece you are trying to create, desperately finding a reason to drive you forward.</p><p>Some take to it more easily than others. Heck, some even relish it enough to take it on as a profession. Not me. And yet, it’s an innate part of my identity I had to grow up with, and I can’t quite figure out if I would rather possess this supposed gift or trade it with God for something else. Each time I tried to shake it off, a pencil miraculously appeared in my hand and I compulsively etched a few lines on a piece of paper. Unable to leave my work unfinished as they come back to haunt me, I stumbled through the rest of it, all while procrastinating like a child. The work finally completed, I escaped from this self-induced suffocation and critically examined my flawed creation. Lather, rinse, repeat.</p><p>It gets even more frustrating when others approach me and go, “HEY JOSHUA! You’re the artsy guy right? Mind helping us draw up something nice on this birthday card for blah blah blah?” Somewhere inside is a guy who turns absolutely livid at the suggestion that my “talents” for some reason oblige me to create some artistic at a whim. But I comply anyway, because hey, aren’t we all just part of this larger social mechanism where everyone is supposed to fulfill some kind of role, and you have every right to judge me disdainfully should I adamantly refuse?</p><p>I told myself that perhaps by pursuing art as an academic subject, I could loosen up a bit. You know, finally figuring out what I could do with my pencilling skills, surround myself with like-minded folks, stop feeling so lost about myself, that kind of stuff. I was right about points 1 and 2. I created more than I ever did in my life. Working alongside a company of nutcases was incredible. I lost track of time during those 2 years in the art studio, and I could not stop drawing.</p><p>But therein laid the problem: drawing. I just didn’t want to do anything else. I felt utterly alien with a brush in hand and canvas to fill. Or when I was sculpting a clay mold, or dabbling with installation art. While others used their pencils to sketch out studies for their coursework, I was subconsciously channeling my efforts towards these sketches and neglecting my main piece. Worse still, I did myself the cruellest favour by convincing myself to be an architectural buff, therefore severely limiting my curiosity for anything else. In the end, I did poorly compared to my classmates, and walked away from those 2 years feeling more lost than ever.</p><p>It was a couple more years before I discovered a reason to draw again.</p><p>In my first year of NS, I attempted something I had surprisingly never done before: gifting a drawing to a close friend. For some reason, I relinquished this piece more than anything I have done in a long time. There was a particular draw to the idea of giving your art away which got me hooked, but there was a more compelling quality to this whole thing that was missing in all my previous sketches. I found myself trying to capture something more than the picture itself, almost a form of meaning in the midst of penciling out the piece. Almost as if I was trying to grasp some hidden essence, or a very distant shadow.</p><p>I was so very close to figuring out what made this drawing so special. Then all of a sudden, I completed the damn thing, sent it to my friend, and the question dissipated into thin air. I couldn’t draw anything for a long while after that. Realizing that the current underlying inspiration differed entirely from everything that came before, I stopped and pondered for a long while. The blackout lasted 2 years.</p><p>At the start of 2013, I tried picking up the pencil again. There was an old picture that caught my attention, one I found on the internet for my project work back in the first year of JC. Something in there struck me. The whole photo was shrouded in an incredibly thick cloud of loneliness, but there and then I felt a connection that blew the cloud right off it. It was saying something about myself I couldn’t quite put a finger to at that point in time, but I took a shot at it anyway. Predictably, it was an agonizing process that I constantly tried to put off, all the while berating myself for my itchy-finger tendencies and for starting work on this damn thing. I frequently had to resist the urge to tear up my work during droughts of inspiration when I thought I was going bonkers.</p><p>I was however convinced that this one was different from everything else I’ve worked on previously. I just knew it. Still, a badly needed break was necessary, and work on it went on hiatus for a bit.</p><p>A few months later, I hopped on a plane to America. It was a life-changing experience.</p><p>I had set out before my travels to leave behind a little trace of myself in the form of a sketch. The drawings were not only meant to thank my hosts whom I probably will never ever visit again, but also for myself as a form of escape from life in Singapore. Every bit of each piece was to be completed on American soil and never to follow me back home. Before I took the flight across the Pacific, I would never have thought I would accomplish so much more than just that.</p><p>At my first stop in Chicago, I started out sketching the Lyric Opera of Chicago in order to ease into the whole idea of penciling on the road. The building was a favorite of the friend and his plus-one who were hosting me, and its location in the middle of the Chicago metropolitan area felt appropriate. Unfortunately, I didn’t finish it. The one-week deadline I set myself just seemed too impossible to meet (everything I did previously needed at least two). It was so exhausting that I spent my time in Boston mentally recuperating from the whole thing.</p><p>Yet that experience didn’t set me back at all; this time, I took on a novel approach with this first piece I did. Rather than holing myself in a room to rush out the drawing, I went out into the city and went walking and walking and walking around. I didn’t do the touristy thing of taking pictures of everything I found along the way, just the ones that documented snippets of inspiration. Back at the dorm, I translated those moments into my drawing.</p><p>The Lyric Opera sketch therefore became a reflection of my trip in the United States thus far. And like the sketch, my trip was far from complete.</p><p>The return trip from Boston brought me back to the Windy City. This time round, I was bent on finishing off what I had started. On a fresh piece of paper, I wandered out of the city center in search of the perfect picture to capture these last few days in America. It wasn’t long before I stumbled upon the rails at Wicker Park.</p><p>My time in America was largely spent clocking ridiculous number of miles on foot, travelling around Chicago, Evanston, Boston, Medford, wherever the road ahead brought me to. When I ran out of places I could trek, I took my friend’s bike and peddled around Chicago just for the heck of it. Those journeys took me to amazing places that wouldn’t fascinate anyone but me, and watching the landscape transform one step at a time was breathtaking. I would be in the middle of a suburb, transport myself to a ballpark, then an ethnic enclave, the beachfront, a black neighborhood, the CBD, college campuses, outer cities, then back in a suburb again. You brush shoulders with people from all walks of life, from the kids who inherited their privilege from their parents, to the penniless folks living under the bridge.</p><p>The rails at Wicker Park mirrored my 28 days spent in the US. The rails, the walls, the van in the dead centre of the picture all stretched endlessly into the unfamiliar. The less-than-dignified choice of subject matter hints at a path less traveled, far from the glimmer and glamour of city life. Your everyday Chicagoan wouldn’t even shoot a look in its direction on any given day, but as a stranger to the city, it was fascinating.</p><p>Even more fascinating, though, was how the sum of my journeys accumulated into a single piece of paper. I had somehow captured every moment I wished to capture, every conversation with friend or stranger, every step of my long arduous walk around the city into this.</p><p>It was the essence of a memory, the shadow of a friend.</p><p>I parted ways with that friend 28 days later; silently transformed by the time I spent alone with what was once a stranger to me. Stepping out into the familiar-looking Changi Airport, I felt my old self rushing back to my senses as I vehemently tried to reject it. “That’s alright”, I said to no one in particular. “We’ve got plenty of time to work this out.”</p><p>Reaching home and revisiting the half-done pencil art I left behind was very hard for me. Telling myself to pick up where I left off was even harder. I was home again, and the urge to rip up my drawing was once again overwhelming. I resisted. BREATHE, Josh, breathe, and try to remember what you realized was missing from all this, and what you found during your time there.</p><p>And then it dawned on me. I needed a story.</p><p>I picked up my pencil and started to write.</p><p>***</p><p>Ubin is about a wooden house in the middle of a forest, imprisoned by the dense vegetation around it but ironically isolated from its surroundings. Juxtaposed against the greenery, it is a thing of beauty, and yet it looks trapped in the middle of nowhere. Its dweller wanted out. It’s leaky, unfurnished, too exhausting to preserve, and so humble a home it’s embarrassing. Maybe the house does have its charms (that’s what he has been told, at least), but if he could trade it off for another dwelling place, he would.</p><p>He hated it.</p><p>Yet he understood that he was just as lost without it as he was with it. He was completely helpless beyond his wooden shelter. It was the only life he had ever known, and each time he ventured out determined to seek out something different, he gave up and rounded back home.</p><p>Quietly, he resigned himself to his fate. Perhaps he just needed a rethink of his present situation. Or perhaps he was afraid that no one else would look after his dwelling place should he leave. Maybe he didn’t want to forsake it after all.</p><p>In time, he found solace in his solitude. Reluctantly, he realized that he needed the house as much as it needed him.</p><p>He still struggles with the upkeep of the place. It remains leaky, unfurnished, embarrassingly humble. The urge to run away continues to pervade his thoughts every so often. But every time he falters, he would utter this line.</p><p>“That’s alright”, he would say to no one in particular. “We’ve got plenty of time to work this out.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*eZo_JakSi-_2bIK59FjF4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ubin, pencil on paper, 2013</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0356b8aac0e4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Payoffs of Panic-Buying]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/the-payoffs-of-panic-buying-ec47281057f8?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec47281057f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[panicbuying]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2020 14:56:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-03T15:11:23.809Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>WARNING: super long post on panic-buying and Game Theory ahead.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bZl0YAAjitaCNC94OUB8hw.jpeg" /></figure><p>To everyone doing their best to advise Singaporeans not to panic-buy, I first want to state that I am 100% with you guys on this and that I have also tried my best to discourage this behaviour from those around me.</p><p>However, here’s why our advice has been persistently futile, and will continue to be so in the coming weeks. More importantly, it’s only in examining and empathising with actual people on the ground that we can get a sense of why panic-buying at this stage is longer an irresponsible action based on irrational fears, but a calculated decision based on repeated experiences.</p><p><strong>And this has all to do with Game Theory.</strong> I’ll try my best to explain this as plainly and accurately as I can, using a lone figure to illustrate my point: my Mom.</p><p>***</p><p>Let’s begin from 2 months ago. On the day Dorscon was raised from Yellow to Orange (which was a Friday), several families began panic-buying. My Mom was not one of them; she decided to skip the panic-buying crowds and buy her groceries the next day instead. When she arrived at the supermarket on Saturday, she found certain items on her grocery list missing from the shelves. Flustered, she decided to buy the missing items the following week when the shelves are restocked. She probably thought: <em>“there are still some groceries left at home, or I can just da-bao from the kopitiam. Can tahan another week lah.”</em></p><p>With that, we conclude Week 1.</p><p><strong>At the beginning of the story, there were two strategies my Mom could have chosen: Strategy A — to panic-buy, or Strategy B — not to panic-buy. </strong>By selecting Strategy B when others chose Strategy A, she received a negative payoff (ie not being able to get her groceries on time), while the panic-buyers rode off happily into the sunset.</p><p>Note that in this game of grocery shopping, we can assume one thing: a person will always get a lower payoff with Strategy B when the “opponent” chooses Strategy A over B.</p><p>Grocery shopping is an iterative game with thousands of players each time, but these players all fall broadly into two groups: those who are immune from the panic-buying actions of others (ie can tahan), and those who have lost that immunity (ie cannot tahan already). As of Week 1, my Mom still falls into the former group (I call them Group Immune, or Group I).</p><p>But let’s hypothetically assume that my Mom is in the other group (let’s call them Group Vulnerable, or Group V): she is a working single-parent from a low-income family with little time to go grocery shopping, or an elderly person who finds it hard to make trips down to NTUC and has run out of food at home. Her negative payoffs from not panic-buying on that fateful Friday were MUCH higher than if she was in Group I instead. <strong>For her, the issue is no longer about not getting her groceries on time: she faces a real problem of going hungry.</strong></p><p>So what does she do? Going into Week 2, she rationally avoids Strategy B at all cost and opts to panic-buy instead. This does two things: it temporarily shifts her from Group V to Group I in the coming weeks (assume she can now wait out a whole month), but it also means someone who couldn’t get their groceries is displaced from Group I to Group V.</p><p>Meanwhile, the economy continues its downward spiral under the worsening COVID situation. <strong>More and more people lose their jobs and also displaced into Group V</strong> — these people may have groceries at home, but with no income, dwindling savings, and no idea when they can start working again, stocking up on $0.50 instant noodles sounds like a pretty solid plan.</p><p>Other factors increase the vulnerability of grocery buyers: the possibility of being struck by a Stay-Home Notice or Quarantine Order, which means no more grocery runs for you. Sure, online grocery delivery is an available option — assuming you can afford the higher costs and that you know how to do it (I know my Mom sure does not). So too is getting someone else to help — assuming there is someone available to help you.</p><p>And so as Week 2 commences with more people in Group V, the trend of panic-buying persists or increases. As a result, people continue to get negative payoffs for choosing not to panic-buy; <strong>in fact, the negative payoffs for both Groups have even increased over time due to persistent shortages and longer queues!</strong> Cue more panic-buyers the following week, with even more Group V members, and poorer and poorer payoffs for Strategy B. Over time, everyone defaults into full zombie apocalypse mode and starts shoving items into their trolleys.</p><p>***</p><p>It is now Week 8 of Dorscon Orange. My Mom feels completely frustrated — the queues have grown longer, the shelves emptier, and she has gone on more than 4 failed grocery runs so far. The high costs and unfamiliar processes of online delivery continue to deter her even with my best attempts to help. Despite her best faith in the Singapore government, she nests a growing concern that supplies from overseas will run into a shortage if the COVID situation stays on its present trajectory.</p><p><strong><em>She decides she has had enough — it’s time to go with Strategy A.</em></strong></p><p>***</p><p>It’s easy to shame the actions of panic-buyers. For those who did not need to stock up but chose to do so at the beginning of this crisis, their actions were certainly selfish and contemptible.</p><p>But what about now? As more people lose their jobs, as initially-cooperative homemakers find their shelves repeatedly swept clean, as everyone stops dining out — it has become increasingly irrational to adhere to a losing strategy just because it is “the right thing to do”. When we also consider how some people experience larger repercussions than others, <strong>it becomes apparent that our advice of “PLEASE DO NOT PANIC BUY” is simply an empty statement that offers no clear alternative solutions.</strong></p><p>What we need now, therefore, is to create the conditions that allow for successful cooperative games (another Game Theory concept). In other words, introduce different sticks and carrots to recalibrate the payoffs for both strategies that ultimately creates a Nash equilibrium in Strategy B.</p><p>We have already seen limitations on grocery items purchasable at our supermarkets; I would argue that this is almost completely ineffective as it is now given the worsening situation. Perhaps I will go in-depth at another time as to why I think so, and what national policies should be in place to complement the limitations.</p><p>In the meantime, here’s my call-to-action: don’t just throw out an angry FB post telling people to cease panic-buying and then walk away. Ask yourself what you can do to alleviate the very real concerns that people are facing, and then take action to help.</p><p>For those who have become vulnerable to grocery shortages, <a href="https://www.giving.sg/childrens-wishing-well/groceries_for_all_sgunited">actions such as sponsoring food or being grocery runners for them</a> can make a big impact with enough people chipping in. For those who are less tech-savvy, we can train them in online grocery deliveries, or order on their behalf.</p><p>Regardless of what we do, let us recognise that we are past the point of judgement and the time to help is now. Many of us are suffering to different extents, but for those who can give just a little more, <strong>I am certain that the positive difference you make will outshine the marginal sacrifices along the way.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec47281057f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[bantu in the Press!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bantulife/bantu-in-the-press-19e92c4dfc5?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19e92c4dfc5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[public-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[singapore]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[press]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[news-articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-enterprise]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Oct 2018 05:07:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-15T19:20:44.204Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Check out this space for exciting updates regarding our latest PR.</h4><h3>The Straits Times</h3><h4>16 July 2018: From Normal (Tech) to an honours degree, techie realises dream after 20 years</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YHWb0XvNA5SOxF5-HlZLRg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Read article on The Straits Times <a href="https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/education/techie-takes-long-road-to-an-honours-degree">here</a></figcaption></figure><h4>17 March 2019: End of streaming in schools: Former: EM3 and Normal student carves out tech path</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BcJOmiDnHJKutpjPMWgcbg.png" /></figure><h3>联合早报</h3><h4>20 June 2018: 两电子平台为义工与慈善机构配对</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K_G2xd0R3pDRhcN7guHqVQ.png" /><figcaption>Story link <a href="https://www.zaobao.com.sg/news/singapore/story20180620-868539">here</a>.</figcaption></figure><h3>The New Paper</h3><h4>10 May 2018: Platform makes managing volunteers easier</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0ihys8n9YsUXd34-UcrF8w.png" /><figcaption>Check out the article <a href="https://www.tnp.sg/news/singapore/platform-makes-managing-volunteers-easier">here</a>!</figcaption></figure><h3>Capital 95.8FM</h3><h4>6 October 2017: Radio Interview: <a href="https://soundcloud.com/capital958/06-10-2017?in=capital958/sets/bbzz">步步追踪 — 学生创业的苦与乐</a></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*FvaMX83luzz57Kgd.jpg" /><figcaption>Listen to the podcast <a href="https://soundcloud.com/capital958/06-10-2017?in=capital958/sets/bbzz">here</a>.</figcaption></figure><h3>Other Features:</h3><ul><li><strong>14 June 2018: </strong>NUS Enterprise Sparks — “<a href="https://medium.com/enterprise-sparks/joshua-foong-co-founder-of-bantu-solving-one-problem-at-a-time-c64b410b524">Joshua Foong, Co-Founder of bantu — Solving One Problem at a Time</a>”</li><li><strong>18 February 2019</strong>: Successpedia Asia — “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmF0INrn07Q">Did you know Bantu means “To help” in Malay language?</a>”</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19e92c4dfc5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bantulife/bantu-in-the-press-19e92c4dfc5">bantu in the Press!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bantulife">bantu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Regardless of _____.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshua.m.foong/regardless-of-9e4c37d6944b?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e4c37d6944b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[raffle]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Oct 2018 02:21:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-01T10:52:53.499Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9EYNACDeb-zXcFl08gfBJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was a December day in 2004. A day just like any other, only that I was 12, and the PSLE results were announced a week ago.</p><p>That afternoon, I was playing street soccer with some ex-classmates from primary school. Our moms were present. No prizes for guessing what the adults were talking about.</p><p>When we left, Ma had this very grave look on her face that came out of nowhere. Which was straight-up frightening, considering that she was just smiling and waving goodbyes to all my friends’ moms a second ago. Ma glanced in my direction.</p><p>Oh crap, what did I do now.</p><p><strong>“恩凯, 你想好要去哪一间学校了吗?”</strong></p><p><em>(En Kai, have you decided which secondary school you want to go?)</em></p><p><strong>“Huh? 为什么 leh?”</strong></p><p><em>(Huh? Why leh?)</em></p><p><strong>“Rob 的妈妈说我们不像他们有钱, 没有钱就不应该读莱佛士.”</strong></p><p><em>(Rob’s mom said that we shouldn’t put you in Raffles since we don’t have the money to afford it, unlike them.)</em></p><p>That year, I scored really, really well for my PSLE. Everyone was incredibly surprised, shocked even; no one saw this coming, least of all me.</p><p>I did so well that I qualified for the school with the second highest entry score across Singapore. The only reason I couldn’t make it to the school with the highest cut-off had nothing to do with my grades — it was a girls’ school.</p><p>The conversation went silent for a minute. I wasn’t sure how to respond. Then Ma said:</p><p><strong>“你不可以因为比别人没钱, 就让别人拿走你应得的东西. 你要记住.”</strong></p><p><em>(Don’t let others take away what you deserve just because you have less money than them. You must remember this.)</em></p><p>***</p><p>That conversation frustrated me for many years. It turned out Rob’s mom had a point: my less-than-affluent upbringing did affect the way I perceived myself against my schoolmates and teachers in school.</p><p>The material comparisons were the plainest. My classmates often raved about the latest computer/console game they acquired, while I never once owned a console. When the first iPhones were released in Secondary 3, I got to see my classmates parade them around campus while I was still wrapping my head around the word “Apple” (what kind of name is “Apple”?) I was also trying to wrap my head around the pervading presence of iPhones in school: why would a 15-year-old own something like this?</p><p>Such material comparisons with my classmates subsequently became the lens through which I perceived myself. <strong>What started out as “I have less than my classmates” morphed into something else with time — “I am less than my classmates.”</strong></p><p>You see, I had always been one of the weaker students at Raffles since day one. Which is hardly a travesty; I mean, its fucking Raffles.</p><p>The problem was when I started believing I did not deserve any better.</p><p>I remember a particular incident in Secondary 2. I was forced to sit through this international Maths olympiad thing, which was made compulsory for everyone in my cohort. When my Maths teacher announced the results, only two students in class scored a high distinction. The first was one of the usual suspects — Pat.</p><p>And then I heard my name.</p><p>Everyone had this incredulous look on their faces, but only for a second. “He definitely cheated.” “No way he could have gotten that.” “You looked at Pat’s answers right, walao.”</p><p><strong>“Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha”</strong></p><p>Of course I did not cheat. But as I tried to defend myself, I felt a huge lump in my throat instead. I turned to my Maths teacher, hoping she would do something, anything.</p><p>She gave me the very same incredulous look and said absolutely nothing.</p><p>It was a look that said this: you came from a neighbourhood primary school, from a below-average family, with no expectation of even getting into a school like this. That was why you do not deserve to do better than those kids who had a gifted primary education and who were chauffeured to school every single day.</p><p>Maybe you do not deserve to be here at all.</p><p>***</p><p>Before the 2008 financial crisis, Pa brought home less than $3000 after CPF. During the crisis, Pa received a pay cut, then a retrenchment letter. Since then, he was briefly re-hired, retrenched again, went on to work as a security guard, then as a fridge technician, and now in condominium management — still bringing home less than $3000 after CPF.</p><p>Ma was a housewife for more than 15 years. She is presently a gardener, but not before she took on odd-jobs at an army canteen and a hawker store.</p><p>At Raffles, my parent’s income often felt like a handicap. The longer I stayed, the lower I regarded my own position vis-à-vis others around me.</p><p>Yet I wanted to keep up with my peers — if not academically, then perhaps materially. And so in the six years at Raffles, I was going out to restaurants and cafes with friends who can actually afford it (unlike myself), willfully oblivious to how hard things were back home.</p><p>Those six years felt like a contradiction: I was a boy from a below-average family of four, making friends with classmates who overwhelmingly made up the top 20 percent. <strong>School was a bubble, and I was living inside and outside of it.</strong></p><p>It was a bubble that popped the moment I was commissioned as a police officer.</p><p>***</p><p>Growing up in Raffles had led me to believe that I was worse off than everyone else around me. There were days where I bore deep resentment against my circumstances at school and at home, often telling myself “if only I hadn’t scored so well for PSLE.”</p><p><strong>The moment I stepped out for good, my resentment was replaced by a huge sense of guilt and relief immediately. </strong>Since then, I have learnt that my economic circumstance was the dominant narrative for most Singaporeans.</p><p>Much of that transformation had to do with my time in the police force, where my eyes were pried open to the world outside of that bubble.</p><p>As a freshly minted officer, I was particularly drawn towards the police reports that were sent to my divisional Commander every morning. The reports aggregated all the key incidents in the past 24 hours (72 hours on Mondays) from 7 different neighbourhoods — 50 on a good day, 100 on a busy one.</p><p>The Commander’s staff assistant would print these every morning next to my desk. In my first month of work, I took the liberty of reading the reports cover to cover before the assistant took them away, diving into the world that surrounded our air-conditioned office building.</p><p>It was a world that made my own look like a fairy tale. Life at the bottom aint pretty —<strong> </strong>I entered a perverse reality in which your options are joblessness, cheating spouse, loan sharks, grandma with stroke, drugs, abusive step-dad, petty crime, friends in gangs, teenage pregnancies, younger brother who passed away from leukaemia, no electricity for a week, and depression. Pick one, and pray really, really hard that the rest don’t tag along.</p><p>In comparison — sure, money was still hard to come by at home, <strong>but while I did not have all the material enablers of a middle/ upper-class family, my education certainly compensated for that.</strong></p><p>Like, really compensated: I got to visit China and India in my secondary years, of which more than 70 percent of the expenses were covered by the school. My trip to China was my first time on an airplane, and I was barely 13.</p><p>But more important than the material enablers was the lack of social inhibitors. My parents never separated, I lived in a great neighbourhood, we never had the electricity cut, and I had Church to keep out of trouble for the most part (unless when it was me causing trouble in Church — long story for another time).</p><p>So while I wasn’t exactly being fast-tracked to upper class, I did not have anything going against me either.</p><p><strong>And that is a form of privilege too.</strong></p><p>Damn, I think my life is a fairytale after all.</p><p>***</p><p>The subject of “class” is something that I experienced growing up, not something that was taught to me. It started out with an odd conversation at 12, overwhelmed much of my six years at Raffles, went through a period of redefinition during National Service, and finally introduced itself properly when I began undergraduate life at FASS.</p><p>My time in New York then led me to witness a different set of privileges and tribulations that are unlike any I encountered in Singapore. My vocabulary on social classes expanded tremendously as I volunteered, first in Brooklyn, then back home with youths from at-risk backgrounds.</p><p>In total, I have learnt exactly one thing.</p><p><strong>I learnt that social class is not just about an income level.</strong> It is about having options in your pursuits, about how you perceive yourself and others, about breeding a sense of belonging, about the way we speak and dress and work and sip overpriced coffees at the most inaccessible all-day breakfast cafes.</p><p>Neither is it a complex formula of weighted variables and probabilities that spits out an elegant number.</p><p>Take me for example: I am currently surviving on a salary of less than $1000 — by choice. As a university graduate, I have the ability and opportunity to move out of my present economic position any time I want to. By starting my own social enterprise, I have chosen the long route to move up the ladder. However, this is a position could change in a matter of weeks, should I choose to quit and get a regular job like most of my peers.</p><p>What’s my class?</p><p>I then factor in various historical variables into my present situation (such as past and present household income + debt + education attainment in my family + race &amp; ethnicity), as well as other evolving probabilities (such as risk of illness + exposure to financial and/or natural disaster + legal rights + foreign relations + access to basic amenities).</p><p>What’s my class?</p><p>So if social class isn’t just a singular, linear, quantifiable measure, how then are we differentiated from our betters? Why do we make this differentiation and enforce it, either silently in our heads or explicitly in our remonstrations towards the other?</p><p>What’s my class?</p><p>***</p><p>While that question had once preoccupied me endlessly, it has a much-diminished role in how I perceive myself today.</p><p>I recently returned to Raffles for the 10-year reunion of my secondary school graduation. Remarkably little has changed: everyone was huddled in their respective cliques, the cheeky ones were still making mild innuendos, and our former teachers somehow hardly aged a day. It was like recess all over again: only that everyone was better dressed, and the food was free-flowing. I also spotted a couple of chubbier faces.</p><p>Meanwhile, I am still exactly where I was economically vis-à-vis my former classmates. Many are starting out as doctors, lawyers, bankers, and civil servants. As for me… you already know how much I’m making.</p><p>And yet, staring at all those familiar faces, a very unfamiliar feeling tided me through the proceedings — I didn’t care. <strong>While I was once incessantly concerned about keeping up with my peers, I have shrugged off the envy and resentment.</strong></p><p>I went to the reunion afraid that there were still unvanquished demons at the back of my head. I went away feeling pretty zen with myself.</p><p>***</p><p>Ma once told me that that I shouldn’t deserve any less than others just because I have less money than them.</p><p>I’m pretty sure she hadn’t meant that I should start my own social enterprise. But hey, I think the same rule applies (read: starting a business should not only be for rich people).</p><p>bantu came about because my co-founders and I believe that we have a lot to give to the larger community. In that sense, we deserve a chance to make a real difference in the lives of others, change on such a grand scale that it will be absolutely disproportionate to the team itself.</p><p>I know I’m not where I want to be — of course I don’t want to be stuck where I am now.</p><p>But I think I have earned a chance to make it there on my own terms, in a way that can change our communities for the better. That change is going to take a long while, but I want to give it a real shot before I absolutely have to throw in the towel.</p><p>I deserve that shot.</p><p><strong>And so do many, many others around us today.</strong></p><p>In the end, I think Ma was right after all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e4c37d6944b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Can I collect NRIC numbers of my volunteers?”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bantulife/can-i-collect-nric-numbers-of-my-volunteers-997bef81afb5?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/997bef81afb5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nonprofit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pdpa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resources]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[volunteering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Sep 2018 16:56:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-22T09:12:57.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>With the updated Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) guidelines on NRIC collection, we’re here to answer some FAQs you may have.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q5mIFJBGMMx1KJ-32cux0g.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/">Photo Credits: PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION COMMISSION</a></figcaption></figure><p>Over the past few weeks, there has been a couple of major updates regarding the collection of NRICs by organisations. To help non-profits understand these changes, we have put together a couple of common questions that have been buzzing around the social sector!</p><h4>1. Am I allowed to collect a volunteer’s NRIC number?</h4><p>This will depend on the activity that your volunteer is engaged in. In general, you will have cause to collect NRIC under the following scenarios:</p><ul><li>When a volunteer will be interacting directly with high-risk beneficiaries, such as children and seniors.</li><li>When your activity is conducted in a facility that requires volunteers to produce NRIC for prior clearance (eg Changi Prison).</li><li>When the collection of NRIC is required by law for the activity you are running.</li></ul><p><strong>You should not be collecting NRIC of a volunteer if he/she is only engaged in the following capacity:</strong></p><ul><li>Conducting talks, roadshows, or any other forms of volunteering that do not involve beneficiaries directly.</li></ul><p>By and large, you must have a clear reason as to why you need to identify your volunteers to a high level of fidelity for the activity that they will be engaged in, and this reason should be stated clearly to the volunteers.</p><h4>2. Can I get volunteers to produce their NRICs for identification purposes when they report for volunteering?</h4><p>Suppose you have the name of a volunteer, but not their NRIC. That volunteer shows up for the first time, and you wish to ascertain that he/she is indeed the same person as indicated in your name list. You can definitely request the volunteer to produce a photo ID to verify his/her identity. Just make sure you do not keep a copy of any information on the ID that you do not have the right to collect, such as NRIC, driver license number etc.</p><p>TL;DR: you can get volunteers to cite their NRIC, but you cannot record it (unless you have permission to do so).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p3uPYdlCif5pM8JtY9Pceg.png" /><figcaption>If you really want to read the loooooong version instead… you can read it <a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/-/media/Files/PDPC/PDF-Files/Advisory-Guidelines/Advisory-Guidelines-for-NRIC-Numbers---310818.pdf">here</a>.</figcaption></figure><h4>3. If I am allowed to collect NRIC for a project, can I do so through applications such as <strong>Giving</strong>.sg, the SG Cares portal, or bantu’s volunteering portal?</h4><p>Yes you can. Sites such as <a href="http://www.bantu.life/">www.bantu.life</a> and <a href="http://www.giving.sg/">www.giving.sg</a> are known as data intermediaries. They allow you to collect information of volunteers when they sign up, and such information is also encrypted when hosted on the server.</p><p>It is <strong><em>the data intermediary’s responsibility</em></strong> to ensure that any data collected through the platform is sufficiently secured from malicious attacks, as well as accessible only by specified accounts within each non-profit.</p><p>This is why sharing administrator accounts is strongly discouraged, since two persons sharing the same account may have different rights to view the same piece of information.</p><p>It is <strong><em>your responsibility as a non-profit</em></strong> to:</p><ul><li>(1) ensure that you have the right to record volunteers’ NRIC for a project,</li><li>(2) inform volunteers of the reason(s) why you are doing so, and</li><li>(3) control and track which of your staff is given access to the volunteer’s information.</li></ul><p><strong>If there are some projects in your non-profit that requires NRIC while others do not, you should revise your project sign-up process.</strong></p><h4>4. Where can I go to find out more about how PDPA applies to non-profits?</h4><p>You’re in luck! The Personal Data Protection Commission is offer non-profits (like yourselves) DP Advisory session for FREE. Find out more at the link <a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/Organisations/Help-for-Organisations/DP-Advisory">here</a>!</p><p>Besides that, there are plenty of resources on the PDPC website which you can access. Here are some useful links below:</p><p><a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/-/media/Files/PDPC/PDF-Files/Legislation-and-Guidelines/Finalised-Social-Service-Guidelines_31Aug2018-v2.pdf">Specific guidelines for the Social Sector</a></p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SGg8RX7QSZQx3N5jy9qDHPmKpDLEAc8Z/view">Infographics on the updated guidelines</a></p><p><a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/-/media/Files/PDPC/PDF-Files/Resource-for-Organisation/Template-Notice-for-Collection-of-NRIC-Numbers-(310818).pdf">Template notice on the collection of NRIC numbers and phase-out period</a></p><p><a href="https://www.pdpc.gov.sg/-/media/Files/PDPC/PDF-Files/Advisory-Guidelines/Advisory-Guidelines-for-NRIC-Numbers---310818.pdf">Full updated guidelines regarding NRIC collection (31 Aug 2018)</a></p><p><a href="https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/collecting-nric-numbers-and-making-copies-of-the-identity-card-will-be-illegal-from-sept-1">News report on updated guidelines regarding NRICs</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D4tqCAXG9NEiWOx3LkGnoA.png" /><figcaption>And if all else fails… just ask Jamie ;)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=997bef81afb5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bantulife/can-i-collect-nric-numbers-of-my-volunteers-997bef81afb5">“Can I collect NRIC numbers of my volunteers?”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bantulife">bantu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“How can I get my volunteers to keep coming back?”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bantulife/how-can-i-get-my-volunteers-to-keep-coming-back-d741a5cc0ad?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d741a5cc0ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tuban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonprofit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[volunteering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Aug 2018 04:06:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-15T04:06:01.053Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Here’s how you can solve your volunteer management woes once and for all — using data.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*62zf779YjVfSHl6OCCleMA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Volunteers help to run more than 80% of programmes in the social sector.</figcaption></figure><p>Volunteers are the lifeblood of a non-profit. They help to relief much of the work in a non-profit (e.g. data entry, event planning), provide critical services to beneficiaries (e.g. subject tutoring, medical services, legal advisory, food delivery), and provide critical manpower at events. Since more than 80% of programmes in the social sector are delivered by volunteers, it is suffice to say that it is impossible for a non-profit to function without its volunteers.</p><p>Here’s the problem: volunteers don’t stick around forever. In fact, many volunteers leave before their stint is up, and this obviously creates problems for the non-profit. How do they recruit volunteers to fill the gap left behind by those who left, without wasting precious time and resources? More importantly, how do they prevent the problem from happening again and again?</p><p>While there are always a couple of bad apples, most volunteers start out genuinely committed when they step forward to sacrifice time and energy for your cause. What we need to realise is that non-profits are part of the problem too: to solve volunteer attrition, many teams must do more to improve the way they manage and engage volunteers!</p><p>So if you’re working in the social sector presently, here’s some good news for you: bantu is here to help.</p><p><strong>We have released a research to understand critical volunteer management issues in the social sector today. </strong>Bringing together data from 62 non-profits across Singapore, we derived an empirically-driven approach to unlock the causes underlying poor volunteer retention and engagement today. Feel free to download a copy of it <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=1TcEDJw1qR4yAJd7i3hN_LOTxIX4FTj4U">here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1008/1*4BIfUD5C9O745jABvqAqVA.png" /><figcaption>Our research on volunteer management is finally out <a href="https://drive.google.com/open?id=1TcEDJw1qR4yAJd7i3hN_LOTxIX4FTj4U">now</a>!</figcaption></figure><p>Here are three findings we want to share with you:</p><h4>1. Communicate with your volunteers.</h4><p>Our results showed that <strong>organisations facing issues communicating with their volunteers have a 29% higher chance of reporting a problem with volunteer attrition.</strong> In other words, if you cannot get through to your volunteers, then chances are, you’re not going to see them around much longer.</p><p>With so many communication tools at our disposable (think of the 101 different messaging apps we have today), nothing beats meeting your volunteers face-to-face and building up rapport in person. At the end of the day, building up trust and aligning expectations early on will solve many problems for you later down the road.</p><p>In addition, sending out timely reminders and clear instructions to volunteers is very critical to the success of your programmes as well. If there are too many messages to send to your volunteers, you should consider automating the admin-related communications in your organisation, either via SMS or email.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Eorp4_KUWHQpwoxsnMkR9w.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://mailchimp.com/">Mailchimp</a> is a good place to start if you are considering free email automations.</figcaption></figure><h4>2. Skills are important.</h4><p>The most important finding we uncovered is that <strong>non-profits that deploy volunteers based on their skills are much less likely to report an issue with volunteer attrition: 38% less likely, in fact.</strong></p><p>This means that your organisation should consider changing the way you recruit and engage volunteers. Instead of casting a wide net for volunteers, you can select volunteers with specific skill sets to deploy for your programmes instead. Alternatively, you can redesign your programmes around the capabilities of your volunteers: for example, you set up a calligraphy class for the beneficiaries if you have a volunteer who is particularly skilled at it.</p><p>Alternatively, you can consider developing the skill set of your volunteers instead. Just like employees, volunteers can also learn to become better at their roles, but only if you provide them training and guidance along the way. For example, a youth befriender can go on to become a life mentor or programmes planner in an organisation, once they are adequately trained in that particular capacity by your team.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hqMs48Y6gxvrgywjXCc6_w.png" /><figcaption>There are many organisations that can help you put together your skill-based volunteering programmes, such as <a href="https://www.empact.sg/">Empact</a> and <a href="https://www.nvpc.org.sg/">NVPC</a>.</figcaption></figure><h4>3. Acknowledge the work that they do.</h4><p>Volunteers aren’t just grunts in your organisations. They want to do good for your organisation because they believe in your cause, and perhaps feel strongly about your non-profit specifically. Therefore, it is important that you find time to appreciate your volunteers, and acknowledge them as part of your team (and not just as resources).</p><p>However, we at bantu recognise that appreciation is not easy work at all: our results indicated that <strong>those who run volunteer appreciation events are 38% more likely to report an issue with administration. </strong>This may seem like a curious and unconvincing relationship: how can having dinner with your volunteers possibly influence your administrative processes?</p><p>There is actually a key element tying these two variables together: calculating volunteering hours. Knowing which volunteers to appreciate (especially in a large organisation) means knowing how much your volunteers have contributed, and this can be a very admin-intensive task. Since a significant amount of time is required to capture such data, your team should consider processes and platforms that can reduce the level of repetition required for this objective. Volunteer management systems (VMS) are particularly useful for automating much of the work in such instances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VmB89P2SAdDHfDG-eM1KEg.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://workspace.bantu.life/">bantu’s Workspace VMS</a> can help you tackle your volunteer admin problems, and start appreciate your volunteers right!</figcaption></figure><h4>So…. what next?</h4><p>Getting your volunteer management process right not only means fixing issues with volunteer admin and retention, it creates plenty of positive externalities too: better programmes, more donors, lower instances of staff-burnout… the list goes on.</p><p>We believe our findings will be a useful first step in helping your non-profit engage your volunteers more meaningfully. There is a growing amount of resources on volunteer management too: for a start, the National Council of Social Services (a.k.a. NCSS) has put together a concise list of localised materials on optimising the social good from volunteering, which you should certainly check out <a href="https://www.ncss.gov.sg/GatewayPages/Donate-Volunteer/Volunteer/Volunteer-Resources">here</a>. You should also check out volunteerism-related courses from the <a href="https://www.ssi.sg/Training/Short-Courses/Volunteer-Programmes">Social Service Institute (SSI)</a>, or volunteer-related consultancy from <a href="http://emmaus.sg/public/">Emmaus Strategies</a>.</p><p>And of course, if you ever need the right technology to improve your volunteer management process, <a href="https://workspace.bantu.life/">bantu’s here to help</a>.</p><p>So what are you waiting for? It’s time to win your volunteers back!</p><p>***</p><p><em>We hope that this paper can help you or the agencies that you work with to address the volunteer management issues in this space, as well as validate and improve processes in your organisation.</em></p><p><em>Please let us know what are your thoughts on our research. We have also used this research to build out bantu’s VMS solution to solve such critical issues more effectively, and we would love to share our know-hows and resources with you or your networks.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d741a5cc0ad" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bantulife/how-can-i-get-my-volunteers-to-keep-coming-back-d741a5cc0ad">“How can I get my volunteers to keep coming back?”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bantulife">bantu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introducing: bantu Workspace!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bantulife/introducing-bantu-workspace-7efa05e3477?source=rss-82f026ca1af2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7efa05e3477</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nonprofit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[volunteering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[volunteer-management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Foong]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Apr 2018 14:15:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-23T11:07:59.566Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>More than just a volunteer management system, Workspace is here to change the way we do good.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MSS5u7Af0REDXD-Bzs4aOA.png" /></figure><h4><strong>The bantu team is so excited to officially launch our volunteer management platform: the </strong><a href="https://workspace.bantu.life/"><strong><em>bantu Workspace</em></strong></a><strong>!</strong></h4><blockquote>bantu Workspace is an intelligent &amp; user-friendly volunteer management &amp; engagement platform for the modern non-profit.</blockquote><p><em>Workspace</em> is truly the cumulation of bantu’s journey thus far. Since coming together as a team back in 2016, we have been applying all that we have learnt from the social sector and building out a new platform that can radically improve the work of non-profits all around the world. This long road of validation with over 20 different non-profits has both inspired and instructed the work we do at bantu every day.</p><h4>So what is <a href="https://workspace.bantu.life/"><em>bantu Workspace</em></a>?</h4><p>For the uninitiated, <em>Workspace</em> is a cloud-based solution that allows non-profits to manage their volunteers and processes, all in one place. For volunteer managers who have been working on multiple disparate platforms to manage information and communications, <em>Workspace</em> is a game-changer.</p><p>There are many tangible ways in which our platform can help non-profits, such as automating menial tasks, scrapping hours off data entry work, scheduling messages to volunteers, and aggregating volunteer data intelligently.</p><p>And then there are the intangibles.</p><p>Our automations help to free time and resources for non-profits, which means they can now engage volunteers more effectively and design better programmes. Our data helps managers to work more intelligently, which means they can now develop and appreciate volunteers the right way.</p><p>And let’s not forget our incredible team, who are always here to lend a helping hand to our non-profit partners on all things tech.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EY8LjOZwgeSAK02tiBp1Iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The 4 of us at the bantu <em>Workspace</em> launch last Friday!</figcaption></figure><h4>But our launch not just about our volunteer management platform.</h4><blockquote><strong>bantu is not a technology: it is a movement.</strong></blockquote><p>Our latest launch is a part of something much larger. You see, bantu is not a technology: it is a movement. We want to start a new movement about how we can use technology for social good, and more importantly, how we can do it differently from how the world is doing it right now.</p><p>Technology as we know it has been built around the profit sector. A sector that is hardwired to maximise outputs, extract greater margins, and transact with clients. But the social sector don’t deal with such things: they deal with helping beneficiaries, gathering donations, engaging volunteers, and creating better communities. This is why so much of these technologies do not work for non-profits.</p><blockquote>We want to build new technologies around the social sector.</blockquote><p>Today, we see the social sector building their work around the technology we have now. We at bantu want to flip that relationship upside down: to build new technologies around the social sector instead.</p><p>We are incredibly fortunate for the tremendous support we have received along the way. To our families and friends, mentors both here in Singapore and abroad from New York and Silicon Valley, non-profits and governing bodies, school staff, corporates affiliates, our start-up counterparts: thank you for believing in us all this time.</p><p>We are so excited for the journey ahead. Whoever you are, thank you for reading, and we truly hope you would join us in the bantu movement.</p><p>Yours sincerely,<br><strong>The bantu team</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7efa05e3477" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bantulife/introducing-bantu-workspace-7efa05e3477">Introducing: bantu Workspace!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bantulife">bantu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>