<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Joshua Ananggadipa Haryono on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Joshua Ananggadipa Haryono on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joshuaharyono?source=rss-559330a493a3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:53:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joshuaharyono/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“God, It’s Brutal Out Here!”: The One Song about Fear, Anger, and Frustration Among Teenagers]]></title>
            <link>https://joshuaharyono.medium.com/god-its-brutal-out-here-the-one-song-about-fear-anger-and-frustration-among-teenagers-9f87c75f0051?source=rss-559330a493a3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f87c75f0051</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rant]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teenagers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Ananggadipa Haryono]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Feb 2022 08:43:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-01T08:44:19.066Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This article is purely based on my personal opinion and how the song itself reflected in my personal life. I’m open for any comments/stories regarding this article or the song itself.</em></p><p>In May 2021, Olivia Rodrigo released her debut album called “SOUR”. Anticipated by the fans, the album went straight to number one on Billboard 200 and music critics praised the album and called it “a solid debut album”. Critics noted how the album can describe the life of Gen Z, from love, anger, and everyday life. One song in particular grabs my attention and it is the opening track in this album and it’s called “Brutal”.</p><p>“Brutal”, written by Olivia Rodrigo and Dan Nigro, talks about the frustrations of the stardom that she experienced and how she talks about the feelings of fear and worry entering adulthood. The lyrics of this song are very straightforward plus the usage of pop punk genre also made the song really captures how the singer felt in her life right now. The way she presents the song is also interesting. In the verse, she just does casual talking and when the song gets to the chorus, the song gets really loud and she sings it with her heart out.</p><p>The song starts with Rodrigo saying <em>“I want it to be, like, messy” </em>then the instrumental gets loud, grabbing our attention to this song instantly. Yes, it is gonna get messy for the next part (in a good way). The second verse really hits me. Hard.</p><p><em>And I’m so sick of 17</em></p><p><em>Where’s my f*****g teenage dream?</em></p><p>This line truly reminded me of when I was 17 because I really was not really happy with my life. In school, in my family, everything is messy. On top of that, I am really struggling with my sexuality. All I can do is focus on my goal to do well in school. Seeing some people have happy life during high school, it truly makes me wonder “Why can’t I have that? WHERE’S MY F*****G TEENAGE DREAM??!?”</p><p><em>If someone tells me one more time</em></p><p><em>“Enjoy your youth, “ I’m gonna cry</em></p><p>Some people told me that their high school was the best years of their life. Well, good for them and I am also happy for them. But for me, Olivia perfectly captures how I feel back then and even now when remembering my high school years. How can I enjoy my youth when I don’t have much of a support system and almost everything in my life is messy (at that time)? Yes, crying sometimes can solve any problem and let out all the emotions.</p><p><em>And I don’t stick up for myself</em></p><p>This is the problem that I had during high school years. I always let the negative energy run through my life. I should’ve tried to defend myself more and try to be more confident. After I graduated high school, I started to feel more confident and as time went by, I was able to defend myself more. But, some people think that I’d be too confident and just be very egoistic at some point. The thing i wish i had back then and now i got it can come too strong apparently.</p><p><em>I’m anxious and nothing can help</em></p><p><em>And I wish I’d done this before</em></p><p>Who doesn’t feel anxious when you know that you are heading towards adulthood? I think we can all agree that when we enter that era, at some point we are feeling very anxious and we wish that we could have done this before. As an adult, I think the anxious itself is still there and still wondering how our future looks and whether we make the right choices for our life</p><p><em>And I wish people liked me more</em></p><p>Validation. Every person needs it and they do everything to get noticed and liked by more people. You are lying to yourself if you never do that at some point in your life. Apparently, it is just how life works. But is it wrong that we as a person can wish that people like us more? I am gonna leave it to you for the answers</p><p>Then the song gets to the chorus. This particular lyric is also grabs my attention</p><p><em>They say these are the golden years</em></p><p><em>But I wish I could disappear</em></p><p><em>Ego crush is so severe</em></p><p><em>God, it’s brutal out here</em></p><p>I lost count of how I wished that I could just disappear from this life during my high school years. The chorus itself ends with a perfect line <em>“God, it’s brutal out here!”. </em>That line is going to be my catch phrase every time I feel overwhelmed and just tired by what is happening in life.</p><p>Then the song gets to the third verse. Oh, and the lyrics get more relatable:</p><p><em>I feel like no one wants me</em></p><p><em>And I hate the way I’m perceived</em></p><p>This is the problem that i still have until now, even my therapist said that this is my biggest burden in my life. I am too overthink of what people thinks about me and feeling like people talk s**t about me all the time. Based on what my therapist said, this is also how my anxiety comes into my life. I still need to learn how to be more laid back and not overthink about life.</p><p><em>And lately, I’m a nervous wreck</em></p><p><em>’Cause I love people I don’t like</em></p><p>All I can do is laugh when I hear that line.</p><p>The first time I heard this song, it instantly hit me and became one of my favorite songs on the album. I just wished that this song was released when I was still in high school and this song definitely can be my anthem throughout the entire high school. The anger, the fear in this song, I can very relate to it and to think about how messy my high school life and how it is impacted my life right now. Even my therapist said that the way I still acted like a teenager now is because when I was in high school, my emotions were not perfectly built yet and skipped some important parts of my life during that time. This song is like a reflection and really slaps me, though I am almost 25 years old this year. But again, I really think that some parts of the song still resonate with adult life, not just me personally, but in general.</p><p>I know that this entire thing is just me ranting about my teenage years. But, I feel like I should make this article just to let out all my anger too and how “Brutal” can describe. So, I wanted to thank Olivia Rodrigo and Dan Nigro for making this song.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f87c75f0051" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“I’m Your Drama Queen, Tonight!”:]]></title>
            <link>https://joshuaharyono.medium.com/im-your-drama-queen-tonight-85e2c04ad8b7?source=rss-559330a493a3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85e2c04ad8b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[representation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eurovision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Ananggadipa Haryono]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jan 2021 08:07:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-15T08:07:17.865Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong><em>“I’m Your Drama Queen, Tonight!”</em>: Looking Back at the Journey of Queer Representation in Eurovision Song Contest</strong></h3><p><strong>Written By: Joshua Haryono</strong></p><p><em>This article is written as a Eurovision fan and solely based on observations around and outside the contest. I am very open for further discussions and other perspectives regarding this issue.</em></p><p>Over the years, the Eurovision Song Contest has grown in Europe and outside Europe to reach a bigger audience and become one of the most watched competitions in the world. Eurovision is also well-known for its inclusivity, especially regarding their entrants or the fans. The inclusivity itself is including the queer community to the contest. Eurovision is known for the large following from the queer fans and sometimes called it “a safe haven for the queer community”. For that, it is important to recognize all the artist, all the moments and the controversies surruonding the queer performers in the history of the contest.</p><p><strong>Eurovision on Becoming “Safe Haven” For the Queer Community</strong></p><p>Eurovision has always become the symbol of unity among the participating countries because of our love for music. Eurovision also a competition that takes the stage performances to a whole another new level. Flashing lights, dancing, LED projections, fireworks, just to name a few things that happen in the stage. Those performances can be called “extravagant”, “majestic” and even some called it “camp”. For this reason, Eurovision really fits in the box of another thing that resonates with the so-called “gay culture”. This imagery is very common for every person who just knew about the existence of the contest itself. Eurovision sometimes dubbed as the “gay Olympics” just by looking at the level of performances, the artist and the fanbase. But, for many times, Eurovision itself does not want to label as the “gay contest” rather as an “inclusive space for everyone that loves music, no matter what their sexualities, gender, race and everything”.</p><p>Eurovision throughout its history is seen as the “getaway” to just enjoying music and also having fun experiencing the series of events leading up to the Semi and Grand Finale night. Among the queer fans, especially those who already watched the contest since the 70s, Eurovision was really become the “getaway” for them to see something “extravagant” and “majestic” in their television. The “campy” and “queerness” appeal itself that draws them to Eurovision and makes Eurovision one of the shows that is starting to break the barriers to display a queerness appeal throughout Europe. Eurovision is also a place where they can enjoy being themselves and to feel being a part of a larger community that accepts them.</p><p>Some artist who get the chance to perform at Eurovision also making the contest to be one of the platform to voice about social issues, including equal rights for queer people. Even though some of the artist who identify themselves as the member of the queer community are not always bringing up their identity, they are aware that with their participation, they can increase the visibility of queer performer in Eurovision. Some artists also show how they are able to challenge the heternormative assumptions of gender and sexuality. The message of tolerance, inclusivity, acceptance, self-confidence, unity, and taking pride always comes up among these artists as their spirit when joining the competition and also to encourage their fans to be themselves and to be more open. Those messages are very relatable to the queer community and that is why some of the songs are considered as “queer anthem” and some of the artist dubbed as “queer icon” among fans.</p><p><strong>Recognizing Queer Performers and Acts in the Contest</strong></p><p><em>(For this part, i wrote all the queer performer that already out prior to the competition or after the competition and verified it with news articles)</em></p><p>The “visibility” era starts from the late 90s, where there is still rare depiction of queer artist in television. The first openly queer performer in the contest is <strong>Paul Oscar</strong> who represented Iceland back in the 1997 contest, with his self-penned song “<em>Minn hinsti dans</em>” (tr. My Final Dance). The song itself remains a classic among the fans and also considered ahead of its time. The performance itself is notable for having four women in latex accompanying Paul. It is controversial at that time due to the sexual imagery. The music composition is influenced by house and techno music, which was very rare in the competition at that time. He finished in 20th place out of 25 countries, and he got the most votes from the countries that implemented the televoting system for the first time.</p><p>In the 1998 contest, <strong>Dana International </strong>became the Israeli representative in Birmingham. Dana caused some controversy at that time because Dana is openly transgender. Dana represented Israel with her song “<em>Diva</em>”, a song that celebrates women empowerment. She won the competition, bringing the third win for Israel and also becoming the first transgender winner in Eurovision. This marks on how Eurovision become more inclusive for the queer community. Dana’s win is credited as one the most important moments that happened in the history of the contest. “<em>Diva</em>” also became one of the songs that frequently became fan favorites and regarded as a classic. Dana International also became the first winning act that was voted by the viewers as the televoting system is used to determine the winner. Dana came back to represent Israel in the 2011 contest, held in Düsseldorf with the song “<em>Ding Dong”. </em>But, she did not make it to the grand finale. She is the first winner to compete again and did not make it to the grand finale.</p><p>Drag acts also become prominent in the contest. In the 2002 contest in Tallinn, a drag group from Slovenia called <strong>Sestre</strong> had the chance to represent their country after they won the national selection (EMA) at the very close voting. They performed their song “<em>Samo ljubezen</em>” (tr. Only Love) and they dressed as flight attendants. They finished in 13th place out of 24 countries. They became the first drag act as the main performer in the contest. In 2007, Denmark sent a drag act called <strong>DQ</strong> as their representative to Helsinki, with the song called “<em>Drama Queen</em>”. DQ failed to qualify for the Grand Finale. In the same year, one drag act stole the show: <strong>Verka Serduchka</strong> from Ukraine. Verka’s performance stole the show with the song called <em>“Dancing Lasha Tumbai</em>” and the performance on the stage itself remembered for the silver dress that the performers were wearing on the stage. Verka was able to finish in 2nd place, just behind the eventual winner, Serbia, with 235 points. Since then, Verka has become one of the most recognizable and most campy acts from Eurovision. The song itself is also considered as classic and frequently mentioned as a fan favorite. In Copenhagen 2014, one drag act made headlines worldwide. Austria chose<strong> Conchita Wurst</strong>, a bearded drag queen, as their representative to the contest with the song titled “<em>Rise Like A Phoenix</em>”. Conchita stole the hearts of European people and she won the competition, making it the second win for Austria after 48 years since Udo Jürgens won in 1966. Conchita also became the first drag queen and openly gay performer to win Eurovision. Conchita’s appearance on the contest draws some criticism in Austria and outside Austria, but she is able to defend herself and many people in Europe support her.</p><p>After Conchita’s winning moment in 2014, more queer representation also graced the stage of Eurovision. They are more open with their identities, especially about their gender expression or sexual orientation. In 2016 contest, the Israeli representative, <strong>Hovi Star</strong>, identified as gay and known for his androgynous looks. He suffered some homophobic attacks at the time, one of them is when he arrived in Moscow to promote his Eurovision entry. Several police in the Moscow airport reportedly tore his passport and made fun of him. Also from 2016 contest, <strong>Douwe Bo</strong>b from the Netherlands, come out in March 2016 as bisexual. In 2018 contest, <strong>Saara Aalto</strong>, who identifies as lesbian, representing Finland with her song “<em>Monsters</em>”. Despite only finished in 25th place, the song become one of the fan favorites, especially among the gay fans. In 2019, France is represented by <strong>Bilal Hassani</strong>. Hassani already came out back in 2017 and identify as queer. Hassani represents their country with the song “<em>Roi</em>” (tr. King), which is seen as the “anthem of empowerment”. Another out performer in 2019 contest is <strong>Tom Hugo</strong>, part of the group<strong> Keiino</strong>, representing Norway, identify as gay. The eventual winner of 2019 contest, <strong>Duncan Laurence</strong>, the representative from The Netherlands, came out in 2018 on his personal Instagram as bisexual. Duncan brought the fifth win for The Netherlands and it is their latest win since 1975. Duncan also become the first openly bisexual performer to win Eurovision. Duncan is praised by the fans for being openly bisexual as he can be the role model for bisexual people and be proud for being bisexual. For some time, bisexuals has been discredited by many people and Duncan came at the right time to be the visible representation for the bisexual people. The 2020 and 2021 Dutch representative, <strong>Jeangu Macrooy </strong>is also very open about his sexuality. He identify as gay and he constantly talking about how important being a openly gay role model and have representation in the media for some people, especially he comes from Suriname where being gay is still a taboo subject.</p><p>However, some of the artists are still not publicly out while they become the representative of their respective countries. But, they become a media speculation when it comes to their personal life in their respective countries. <strong>Marija Šerifović</strong>, the first entrant from Serbia since becoming an independent county in 2006 and also the winner of 2007 contest, was coming out as lesbian in 2013 in her documentary. <strong>Harel Skaa</strong>t, representing Israel with his song “<em>Milim</em>” (tr. Words), came out as gay in October 2010, four months after he competed in Eurovision. The 2012 winner, <strong>Loreen</strong>, represent Sweden with her song “<em>Euphoria</em>”, came out as bisexual in February 2017.</p><p>Some non-queer performers also started to involving queer representation in the performance. In the 1986 contest in Bergen, the host country was represented by <strong>Ketil Stokkan</strong> with his song “Romeo”. On his stage performance, he was joined by a Norwegian drag group called <strong>Great Garlic Girls</strong> and they performed in 18th-century style clothing. It is the first drag act that ever graced the stage of Eurovision, although they are acting as the background dancers. They also remembered because of the choreography. <strong>Krista Siegfrieds</strong>, representing Finland in 2013. At the end of the performance, Siegfrieds kissed one of the backup singers. It is became the first <strong>same-sex kiss </strong>that depicted in the stage in Eurovision. In 2015, <strong>Monika Linkyte and Vaidas Baumila</strong> from Lithuania also involved a <strong>same-sex kiss</strong> in the performance where in the middle of the song. the back up dancers (two men and two women) are kissing their same sex. The same-sex depiction continues in 2018, where <strong>Ryan O’Shaughnessy</strong> from Ireland involves <strong>two male dancers (Alan McGrath and Kevin O’Dwyer)</strong> that are appeared in Ryan’s music video to perform in the main stage, accompanying his performances. This is marks the first ever depiction of same-sex couple in the history of the contest.</p><p><strong>Homophobia and Transphobia in the Contest</strong></p><p>Even though Eurovision is becoming more open to having queer performers, there is still a case for homophobia and transphobia, whether it came from the national broadcaster, the performer, the country’s policy or even from the fanbase. The early controversies surrounding queer representation in Eurovision happened back in 1998 when Dana International chosen as the representative for Israel. Dana become the subject of controversies because she is transgender. The religious groups in Israel condemned Dana and called her “a deviant”. She shut her critics and won the whole contest that year. But, the transphobia still continues after her winning moment and she also became a media sensation in Israel and other countries.</p><p>The homophobia continued to exist in the 2002 contest when Sestre, the Slovenian representative, was chosen. Not just about the controversy of the voting results in the national final, but also leads to an anti-gay protest that taking place in Ljubljana and this issue also raised in the Slovenian Parliament. The anti-gay protest itself also leads a debate in the European Parliament, especially when Slovenia still tries to join the European Union at that time. A Dutch MEP even said that Slovenia is not ready to join the EU due to the negative treatment of sexual minorities in their country. Another drag act that sparks some protests is Verka Serduchka from Ukraine, competing in 2007. Many Ukrainians expressed their disapproval of Verka as their representative to the contest, calling it a “grotesque” and “vulgar” act. Politicians also made some homophobic and transphobic remarks regarding Verka. Many believe it also could ruin Ukraine’s international reputation. Verka’s selection led to demonstrations and some Ukrainians demanded to pull out Verka’s participation in Eurovision that year.</p><p>When Conchita Wurst from Austria participated in the 2014 contest, homophobia and transphobia became more visible and broader. The moment when she was announced as the Austrian representative, there were already protests in Austria and outside Austria. A Facebook page was made and gained almost 40,000 likes to complain about Conchita’s participation in the contest. In Belarus, almost 2,000 people made a petition to ban the broadcast of Eurovision in the country, claiming it as “a hotbed of sodomy”. Similar moves also happened in Russia and Ukraine. Conchita also received criticism from fellow competitor, Aram MP3 from Armenia by calling her “lifestyle that is not natural”. Aram later apologized for his remarks. After Conchita won the competition, the criticism towards her continued, mostly from Eastern European part. Some politicians also started to speak up regarding Conchita’s win and seeing it as “the end of Europe” and “rejection of Christian values in Europe”. Conchita defended herself and gained public support across Europe. People revolted by attacking Russian representatives that year by booing their representative, Tolmachevy Sisters. This move seen as people’s rejection of Russia’s move for making anti-gay laws in 2013. Some called it “unnecessary” to booed Tolmachevy Sisters because they have nothing to do with the laws.</p><p>Irish entry in 2018 also became a major headline when Ryan O’Shaughnessy’s performances was reportedly censored in Mango TV from China due to depiction of gay couple in his performance. Rainbow flag also reported to be censored by the broadcaster. This resulted in termination of the Chinese broadcast rights later that year from the competition by the EBU because the station was not in line with the EBU’s value towards universality and inclusivity and also the tradition of celebrating diversity towards music.</p><p>From those cases we can see that queer representation itself still left some mixed attitudes in some countries and challenge the views on “European values”. Dana International can be regarded as the artist that made people start to talk about inclusivity in the contest, especially towards the queer performer. The transphobia that she faced also questioned Israel’s views on how they practiced the so-called “liberal view” on social issues. She also regarded as one of the transgender people that paved the way for a better depcition of transgender people in media. Dana’s participation also sees as the “coming out” moment of the queerness aspect of the contest and at the same time the contest itself starting to expand. Sestre and Verka Serduchka are also seen as “brave moves” by some people knowing how social attitudes towards queer people in their resepective countries are still concerning. This conversation got more broader when Conchita won the competition. Conchita’s participation proved to be a challenge to the so-called “Liberal European value” because Conchita’s participation at that time really made a border between “Western” and “Eastern’’ more clearer and can be seen as a cultural war, especially regarding values and norms that were attached to it. Many people also saw that sending Conchita to Eurovision is another way to show the symbol of tolerance and acceptance towards queer people. Some see it to be a political move, even though Eurovision has consistently claimed to be apolitical, but by talking about identities, especially queer identities itself already have a political tone to it. Observing the voting patterns for Conchita’s song could give another perspective of how European people’s attitudes towards Conchita. Dana’s and Conchita’s winning moment also sparks a debate whether the real quality song wins or people just doing a “sympathy votes” so that she can win the whole contest and makes a statement. Nevertheless, Dana’s and Conchita’s winning moment highlighted as one of the important moment for queer representation in general and taking another bigger steps when it comes to queer visibility in the contest.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Eurovision is indeed a place for everyone. It unites people all over Europe through music and can be seen as an “escape” and the time where they can enjoy themselves. The contest keeps growing and some people are demanding more representation, including queer representation. The reputation of Eurovision for being “the gay Olympics” is very common, looking at the whole competition itself. The queer representation in the contest are more visible over the years and it is also signaling on how the contest itself to be more inclusive towards the performers and also the audiences. At the same time, the rejection towards queer performer is also more common. This could be a challenge towards how we perceive the “European values” and how we can implement it in a song contest that is based on unity, tolerance and diversity. Despite some criticism towards queer aspect or queer performers in the competition, many fans are able to unite to shutting down those critics and more actively spreading the spirit of unity and tolerance. The queerness aspect of Eurovision can not be denied and it should be celebrated as the part of being inclusive. As Conchita said: <em>“We are unity and we are unstoppable!”</em></p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Baker, C. (2016). The ‘gay Olympics’? The Eurovision Song Contest and the politics of LGBT/European belonging. <em>European Journal of International Relations</em>, 23 (1), 97–121.</p><p>Banks, M. (2002, March 6). Transvestite Eurosong win sparks Slovenia accession doubts. Retrieved on January 15, 2021 from Politico.eu: <a href="https://www.politico.eu/article/transvestite-eurosong-win-sparks-slovenia-accession-doubts/">https://www.politico.eu/article/transvestite-eurosong-win-sparks-slovenia-accession-doubts/</a></p><p>Barlow, E. (2018, May 10). Viva la diva! How Eurovision’s Dana International made trans identity mainstream. Retrieved on January 14, 2021 from The Guardian: <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/music/2018/may/10/viva-la-diva-how-eurovisions-dana-international-made-trans-identity-mainstream">https://www.theguardian.com/music/2018/may/10/viva-la-diva-how-eurovisions-dana-international-made-trans-identity-mainstream</a></p><p>Bigg, C. (2013, October 31). Bearded Drag Queen Sparks Eurovision Uproar. Retrieved on January 15, 2021 from Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty: <a href="https://www.rferl.org/a/austria-belarus-eurovision/25153935.html">https://www.rferl.org/a/austria-belarus-eurovision/25153935.html</a></p><p>Carniel, J. (2015). Skirting the issue: Finding queer and geopolitical belonging at the Eurovision Song Contest. <em>Contemporary Southeastern Europe, </em>2(1), 136–154.</p><p>Denham, J. (2014, May 1). Eurovision 2014: Conchita Wurst faces transphobic backlash for “unnatural” lifestyle. Retrieved on January 15, 2021 from Independent.co.uk: <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/eurovision-2014-conchita-wurst-faces-transphobic-backlash-for-unnatural-lifestyle-9296690.html">https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/eurovision-2014-conchita-wurst-faces-transphobic-backlash-for-unnatural-lifestyle-9296690.html</a></p><p>Duffy, N. (2020, May 16). <em>14 of the biggest, brightest and most proudly queer performances in Eurovision history</em>. Retrieved on December 14, 2020 from PinkNews: <a href="https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/05/16/eurovision-2020-best-performers-gay-trans-lgbt-first-dana-international-conchita-wurst/">https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/05/16/eurovision-2020-best-performers-gay-trans-lgbt-first-dana-international-conchita-wurst/</a></p><p>Fawkes, H. (2007, April 2). Eurovision act angers Ukrainians. Retrieved on January 15, 2021 from BBC News: <a href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/6516927.stm">http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/6516927.stm</a></p><p>Grant, A. (2011, March 30). <em>Asked and Answered | Harel Skaat</em>. Retrieved on December 14, 2020 from The New York Times Style Magazine: <a href="https://tmagazine.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/30/asked-and-answered-harel-skaat/">https://tmagazine.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/30/asked-and-answered-harel-skaat/</a></p><p>Halliwell, J. (2018). ‘All Kinds of Everything’? Queer Visibility in Online and Offline Eurovision Fandom. <em>Westminster Papers in Communication and Culture</em>, 13(2), 113–120.</p><p>Haessler, S. (2015, May 22). <em>How Eurovision becocme a gay-friendly contest</em>. Retrieved on December 14, 2020 from France 24: <a href="https://www.france24.com/en/20150522-eurovision-gay-friendly-song-contest-lgbt-conchita-wurst">https://www.france24.com/en/20150522-eurovision-gay-friendly-song-contest-lgbt-conchita-wurst</a></p><p>Leighton-Dore, S. (2019, May 14). <em>Seven Times LGBTQI+ Artist Wowed At Eurovision. </em>Retrieved on December 14, 2020 from SBS.com.au: <a href="https://www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/agenda/article/2019/05/01/seven-times-lgbtiq-artists-wowed-eurovision/">https://www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/agenda/article/2019/05/01/seven-times-lgbtiq-artists-wowed-eurovision/</a></p><p>Morgan, M. (2017, February 6). <em>Eurovision winner Loreen comes out as bisexual</em>. Retrieved on January 14, 2021 from SBS.com.au: <a href="https://www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/fast-lane/article/2017/02/06/eurovision-winner-loreen-comes-out-bisexual">https://www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/fast-lane/article/2017/02/06/eurovision-winner-loreen-comes-out-bisexual</a></p><p>O’Reilly, B. (2018, May 11). ‘We were at that point at one stage’ — Europe’s closeted LGBT youth inspired by Ireland’s Eurovision performance. Retrieved on January 14, 2021 from Independent.ie: <a href="https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/music/we-were-at-that-point-at-one-stage-europes-closeted-lgbt-youth-inspired-by-irelands-eurovision-performance-36895791.html">https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/music/we-were-at-that-point-at-one-stage-europes-closeted-lgbt-youth-inspired-by-irelands-eurovision-performance-36895791.html</a></p><p>Reynolds, D. (2018, May 9). Ireland’s Gay Dance on Eurovision Shows World that “Love Is Love”. Retrieved on January 14, 2021 from Advocate.com: <a href="https://www.advocate.com/world/2018/5/09/irelands-gay-dance-eurovision-shows-world-love-love">https://www.advocate.com/world/2018/5/09/irelands-gay-dance-eurovision-shows-world-love-love</a></p><p>Tuhkanen, M. (2007). Introduction: Queer Eurovision, post-closet. <em>SQS–Suomen Queer-tutkimuksen Seuran lehti</em>, <em>2</em>(2), 8–11.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85e2c04ad8b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do They Need a New Member in the Group? : Evaluating the “Big Five” in Eurovision Song Contest]]></title>
            <link>https://joshuaharyono.medium.com/do-they-need-a-new-member-in-the-group-evaluating-the-big-five-in-eurovision-song-contest-ff49533a8d55?source=rss-559330a493a3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff49533a8d55</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[eurovision-song-contest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joshua Ananggadipa Haryono]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Oct 2020 05:00:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-03T06:40:29.254Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Do They Need a New Member in the Group? : Evaluating the “Big Five” in Eurovision Song Contest</strong></h3><p><strong>Written by: Alvarizi Daffaakbar, Dhany Iskandarsyah, and Joshua Haryono</strong></p><p><em>This article is merely written by us as Eurovision fans and solely based on our observations around and outside the contest. We are very welcome for further discussions and other perspectives regarding this issue.</em></p><p>It is not rare to see discussions about the existence of Big Five in the Eurovision Song Contest among the loyal fans. Some see it as unfair to the other participating countries, continuing the argument with narrations on whether the Big Five should be abolished or replaced with other countries that are “more deserving” than the current members. One particular country that are placing in the buzz is Sweden. But do we really need to change the game by adding a new member or reform the Big Five?</p><p><strong>Who are the Big Five and Why Does The Big Five Exist?</strong></p><p>For the past 64 years, the Eurovision Song Contest has entertained their audience with a variety of songs and more countries have participated over the years, especially after the fall of communism in Eastern Europe in the 1990s. This also prompted some changes over the years when it comes to the overall organization of the contest, especially on how the growing number of participating countries is managed. In 1993, seven countries participated in a pre-qualification round called “<em>Kvalifikacija za Millstreet</em>”, held to contest the last three spots for the year’s Eurovision in Millstreet, Ireland. The show, hosted by Radiotelevizija Slovenija (RTVSLO, broadcaster from Slovenia), decided that Bosnia and Herzegovina, Slovenia, and Croatia, would go on with the three tickets, while Hungary, Estonia, Slovakia, and Romania debuted only the next year. In 1996, the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) held a non-televised audio-only pre-qualification round in order to shorten the participating countries in the Grand Finale. Germany became one of the non-qualified countries. This came with a shock as Germany is considered one of the biggest financial contributors in the contest itself. Many believe that it is one of the main reasons why the Big Five is formed.</p><p>From 1997 through 2003, a system whereby the five countries with the lowest average scores from the past five years were forced to stay out of the contest for a year to return the year after, was put in place. Since the 2000 contest in Stockholm, four countries were granted immunity from such relegation. They became known as the “Big Four”. The Big Four consisted of France, Germany, Spain, and the United Kingdom. The Big Four merely exists because the countries, via their member broadcasters, are the largest financial contributors to EBU which organizes the annual contest together with the host broadcasters. The contributions are calculated on various criteria, such as the broadcaster’s turnover, size, as well as several other economic conditions in relation to each of the countries. The Big Four hence made large contributions to the production of the contest. The addition of Italy in the Big Four group itself was already addressed by Svante Stockselius, the then executive supervisor of the Eurovision Song Contest, back in 2007. He stated that should Italy return to the competition after a long-term withdrawal (then ongoing since 1997), Italy would join the Big Four and it will become the Big Five. Italy ultimately returned to the contest in 2011, ending a 14-year hiatus, and the promise was fulfilled (albeit under new executive supervisor Jon Ola Sand).</p><p><strong>Big Five Performances Over The Years</strong></p><p>The Big Five performed respectably pre-2000; France had already won five times, the United Kingdom and Germany consistently performed well (with the UK holding the record for most 2nd-place finishes), while Spain had mixed results, but with two victories in its back. Italy also already had two wins in its back (1964 and 1990) and was able to have one of the most iconic songs — “<em>Nel blu dipinto di blu</em>” sung by Domenico Modugno in 1958 — in the entire Eurovision history.</p><p>In the 2000s, the performance of the Big Four started declining. The United Kingdom, for the first time, achieved its worst placing in the 2003 contest held in Riga, finishing last place with the infamous <em>nul points</em>. In the 2005 contest in Kiev, the Big Four countries placed in the bottom four in the scoreboard, with Germany taking the last place. A number of reasons that can be cited for the declining performance of Big Five. This includes the expansion of participating countries, especially from the Eastern European countries. They also tend to take the contest more seriously (i.e. by sending “big”, regional artists and holding large national finals), and they also tend to have a more devoted fanbase. Exposure of the Big Five entries themselves is also a contributing factor; countries participating in the semi-final before qualifying for the final gets more screen time and exposure compared to the automatic qualifiers, and this disparity is said to have caused the aforementioned decline. EBU addressed this problem by allowing a small window in the semi-finals for the introduction of the automatic qualifiers since 2015, as well as broadcasting snippets of their rehearsal performances since 2016.</p><p>From the early 2010s, however, the Big Five countries’ performance has slightly improved. Germany secured their second win in the contest — also the first time since their reunification — with Lena in Oslo 2010. United Kingdom is “saved” by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Dianne Warren with their composition “<em>It’s My Time</em>”, sung by Jade Ewen in 2009 contest held in Moscow and UK able to finish in 5th place, their best placing since Jessica Garlick that placed 3rd in 2002 contest. UK’s entrants in the 2014 contest, Molly with her song “<em>Children of the Universe</em>”, became one of the fan favorites and predicted they could win the whole show. Amir, with his song “<em>J’ai cherché</em>” in 2016 also became one of the fan favorites and was able to finish at 6th place, one of the best placing France ever did since Patricia Kaas in 2009. Spain’s entrant in 2012, “<em>Quedate conmigo</em>” sung by Pastora Soler still consistently being the all-time favorites among the fans. In the 2011 contest in Dusseldorf, Italy returned to the competition after a 14 year hiatus, where they scored an impressive 2nd place. Since then, Italy has constantly had the best placement among other countries in the Big Five, with constant placing in Top 5 and Top 10 every year (with the exception of 2014 and 2016), and they were able to take the runner-up spot again in 2019. Italy’s entries also consistently became the fan favorites every year and many bookies also predicted Il Volo (2015) and Francesco Gabbani (2017) to be the contender for the grand prize at the time of their respective contest.</p><p>But, despite the slightly improved performances in the contest, most people are still questioning the credibility of the Big Five group. This started to occur when the United Kingdom finished last with <em>nul points </em>in the 2003 contest and UK did not relegated for the 2004 contest merely because UK is the member of (at that time) Big Four. People also started to question their song quality that they sent as their entrant to Eurovision, especially in the 2000s era. They are often foreshadowed by other countries and seen as not powerful as other countries. When Italy returned to the competition and was able to do well, Italy was dubbed as “the saviour of the Big Five group” and many fans called out the other members of Big Five to take the contest more seriously. But, Italy itself is not enough to save the Big Five from the criticisms around it. With the declining performance and quality, some people want other countries to replace the members of Big Five. One of the countries that consistently talked about replacing or added to the Big Five group is Sweden. But, why is Sweden consistently in the buzz to be a part of the Big Five?</p><p><strong>Sweden’s Emergence in Global Music Industry</strong></p><p>Sweden is no stranger when it comes to producing some of the well-known singers, bands, songwriters, and producers in the world music industry. Sweden had become an international music powerhouse from the 90s. Currently, there are still a lot of Swedish musicians who continue to do well internationally through certain genres. The biggest Swedish music export is in the pop music genre. The emergence of Swedish pop music was started back in the 70s. Blue Swede became the first artist from Sweden to reach the number one spot in the Billboard Hot 100, with their cover version of “<em>Hooked on a Feeling</em>” (later appeared in the 2014 feature film <em>Guardian of the Galaxy</em>). ABBA, the winner of Eurovision 1974, also became one the biggest Swedish exports in music. They produced some big hits in the 70s, such as “<em>Dancing Queen</em>”, “<em>Waterloo</em>”, “<em>The Winner Takes It All</em>” and they were able to become one of the best-selling groups of all time. In the late 80s, Roxette managed to top the charts in Billboard Hot 100 and other countries, producing some hits such as “<em>Listen To Your Heart</em>” and “<em>It Must Have Been Love</em>”. In the 90s, Ace of Base “opened up our eyes” and made some big hits like “<em>The Sign</em>”, “<em>Happy Nation</em>”, “<em>All That She Wants</em>” just to name a few. The Cardigans also made some anthem of the 90s, with “<em>Lovefool</em>” and “<em>My Favourite Game</em>”. In the late 90s, Swedes also produced some well-known pop artists such as Robyn and Meja.</p><p>When it comes to songwriting and producing hits, one of the biggest and famous names in the industry in pop music that came from Sweden is Max Martin. He is producing some of the biggest pop songs in the world in the late 90s, such as “<em>I Want It That Way</em>” by Backstreet Boys, “<em>Oops, I Did It Again</em>” by Britney Spears, “<em>Tearin’ Up My Heart</em>” by N*SYNC, “<em>Show Me Love</em>” by Robyn just to name a few. Until now, Max Martin is still writing and producing many pop songs. He worked with Taylor Swift, Katy Perry, Ariana Grande. Martin is also the songwriter with the third-most number-one singles in Billboard Hot 100, with 23 (as of September 29, 2020). In 2015, he won the Grammy Award for Producer of the Year, Non-Classical and Album of the Year for producing Taylor Swift’s “<em>1989</em>”. Max Martin frequent collaborators also come from Sweden, such as Shellback and Ilya Salmanzadeh. For this decade, it is still very common that the biggest pop songs are written and produced by Swedes, especially Max Martin. Music videos also played a big part in the music industry and some of the biggest music video directors came from Sweden, one of them is Jonas Arkelund. He has worked with some of the biggest names in the music industry since the late 90s. His works include <em>“Ray of Light</em>” by Madonna (won the Grammy Award for Best Short Form Music Video and MTV VMA for Video The Year), “<em>Praying</em>” by Kesha, “<em>Telephone</em>” by Lady Gaga and Beyonce. Many of the biggest pop songs are also recorded in Stockholm.</p><p>Not only pop music, Sweden also has contributions in other genres. One of them is electronic music, especially the electronic dance music (EDM). Sweden produced big names in the early 2010s in the EDM scene such as Avicii, Swedish House Mafia, Sebastian Ingrosso, Alesso, Axwell to name a few. They graced the charts and their songs became a hit all over the world throughout the 2010s. They also have some of the names that make it to the top DJ list in the world. Surprisingly, the other genres that Swedes are well known for is the heavy metal scene and Sweden became the second largest producer of heavy metal bands per capita just right behind Finland. Sweden’s most famous heavy metal scene includes Bathory (who is credited for helping to create “<em>black metal</em>”), Dissection, Opeth, Passenger.</p><p>It is undeniable to ignore Swedish artists contribution to the global music industry, especially the pop music industry and it has also had longevity up until now. The impact is passed along from generation to generation and we still hear all their songs on the radio or even become one of our favorite songs of all time. But, how does the impact of Sweden’s role in the Global Music Industry translate into their performances in the Eurovision Song Contest?</p><p><strong>Sweden in the Eurovision Song Contest</strong></p><p>Sweden made their Eurovision debut in 1958 when they sent Alice Babs with the song “<em>Lilla stjarna</em>”. She managed to finish in 4th place. Since its debut, Sweden has only missed three contests (1964, 1970, 1976). As of 2020, Sweden is one of the most successful competing nations in Eurovision, picking up six wins (ABBA — 1974, Herreys — 1984, Carola — 1991, Charlotte Nilsson — 1999, Loreen — 2012, Måns Zelmerlöw — 2015), achieved 25 top five results and has the most top five results in the 21st century, with 11. With its winning in 2012 and 2015, Sweden became one of only two countries (besides the United Kingdom) to win the contest in four different decades. Sweden also has the best track records among other Nordic countries. Despite all the achievements, Sweden’s presence in the contest started to decline in the mid-2000s as they were only able to reach the Top 20. In 2008, Charlotte Perreli (nee Nilson) almost did not make it to the Grand Finale, only placed 12th in the Semi-Final. But, she was saved by the jury votes and able to make it to the Grand Finale. In 2010, Sweden sent Anna Bergendahl, with her song “<em>This Is My Life</em>” to Oslo and she did not make it to the Grand Finale. This is the first time for Sweden since the introduction of the Semi-Final in 2004. Since 2011, Sweden came back stronger and able to pick up two wins over the course in just three years (Loreen in 2012 and Måns Zelmerlöw in 2015) and consistently finishing in the top five.</p><p>Sweden chose their entrants to Eurovision with a local national final called <em>Melodifestivalen</em> (tr. “The Melody Festival”) or simply known as Melfest or MF. Melfest is organized by Sveriges Television (SVT) and Sveriges Radio (SR) and has been organized since 1959. Melfest became one of the biggest television shows in Sweden and has been Sweden’s most watched TV show since 2000, thanks to the mastermind behind the revamp of Melfest, Svante Stockselius (who also became the Executive Supervisor for Eurovision from 2004 to 2010). Melfest also has grown some support from outside Sweden, as they include votes from other countries that participate in Eurovision, calling them as the “international jury” (usually 10 countries plus the host country in that particular year) to help choose their entries to Eurovision since 2010. Melfest also became one of the national finals that got the most attention from the fans and for that Melfest is sometimes dubbed as the “mini-version of Eurovision”.</p><p>Sweden’s influence on the contest for the past years has been very strong, starting from the song genres, the overall presentation in the contest has been influenced by the Swedes. Sweden is also well-known for sending and popularizing the <em>schlager </em>songs to the contest in the 80s. In the 2010s era, most of the songs that entered the Eurovision or in the national finals in some countries had been written by Swedes. They also help to popularize the newest trend in pop music. For that contribution, Sweden has a lot of support from other countries, especially their neighbouring countries as they give away points to each other every year. Since their debut in 2015, Australia also became Sweden’s newest “allies” in Eurovision as they give each other big points every year. Some Swedes are also credited for making big changes in the contest or helping to decide other countries’ acts that are worthy to be sent to the contest, for example Christer Björkman. Björkman already competed in the contest in 1992, finishing 22nd, Sweden’s worst results since 1977. He then became the show producer of Eurovision 2013, held in Malmö and the contest producer of Eurovision 2016, held in Stockholm. He also became the Head of Delegation for Sweden in 2015 and resulted in victory for Måns Zelmerlöw. He has acted as one of the members of international juries in several national finals, such as Destination Eurovision 2018 (France’s national finals). Since 2002, Björkman has been the producer of Melodifestivalen and he will step down in 2021. For that, Björkman is often regarded as one of the important figures in Melfest and Eurovision.</p><p><strong>Sweden’s Possibility in the Big Five</strong></p><p>As we can see, the Big Five is formed solely based on how big the financial contribution that the countries have to give to the EBU and for that, they have the privilege to have an automatic place in the Grand Finale. The urgency behind the formation of Big Five itself is quite slippery. Many fans started to see it as a “threat” to other countries, but it has been debunked as well. The so-called “speciality” itself has faded away — especially after the 2000 contest — the original four members have decent results in the competition. The addition of Italy to the elite group itself was also questioned by others. But, Italy proves that they are capable of sending strong entries and even become fan favorites almost every year. Fans also pointed out the other countries in the group to be more serious about choosing their entry and setting Italy as their standard and the Big Five can be taken more seriously.</p><p>From that, we can see that the Big Five is still judged equally as with the other countries that are competing in the contest. The status also puts some amount of pressure for the countries to finish relatively well, while at the end of the day you have to win the hearts of European people itself to win the whole contest. That being said, Big Five itself now sees as equal as other countries, but they have a bigger financial contribution to the EBU, which also be the part of the competition. But, why do many people want the Big Five to expand, becoming “Big Six” or replacing one of the members with another country that is so-called “more worthy” (in this case Sweden)?</p><p>We can already see that Sweden’s contribution in the contest itself is very big. It also affected how the other countries chose their entry every year to the contest and made Sweden “the sole standard” for them to get better results or even winning the whole contest. Sweden also sees as “the catalyst” in the competition because of the transformation that they already did in the competition or many people see it as the “breath of the fresh air” for the competition itself. People want Eurovision to grow and still become relevant for European people or people outside Europe despite the dynamics surrounding the organization of the contest itself. Arguably, the only country that can make it happen is Sweden. We saw the introduction of Semi-Final back in 2004 (inspired by the Melodifestivalen itself) under Svante Stockselius in order to accommodate the growing number of countries that wanted to be the participant for Eurovision. The introduction of the new voting system in 2016 (also cued from Melodifestivalen) where the contest took place in Stockholm could also be seen as an example of Sweden’s contribution in the contest; more than forty years after the 1975 contest in Sweden, as well, introduced the twelve points, one of the most defining elements of the contest. Not many countries can make bold moves to change the whole presentation of the competition as what Sweden has, not even the Big Five members. For that contribution, people started to think that Sweden can be more worthy to be one of the Big Five members.</p><p>Should the EBU sacrifice their one of biggest financial contributors and replace it with a country that also has, in their belt, a number of substantial contributions to the contest, organisational-wise? We do not know the answer for now. If the only reason for the existence of the Big Five in the first place is merely because of the financial contribution, maybe for now Sweden will not become the next member or replace one of the countries in the group. The <em>status quo </em>of Big Five itself also makes some fans argue to just leave it as it is. Besides, in the competition itself, the Big Five are also equal to the other participants. For now, EBU may continue to maintain the <em>status quo </em>regarding the Big Five group. Regardless of what happens in the future regarding the Big Five, the show must go on.</p><p><strong><em>References</em></strong></p><p>Bohlman, Philip V. (2013). Tempus Edax Rerum: Time and the Making of the Eurovision Song in D. Tragaki (ed.), <em>Empire of Song: Europe and Nation in Eurovision Song Contest</em> (pp. 35–56), Plymouth: The Scarecrow Press, Inc.</p><p>Feeney, N. (2013, October 29). <em>Why Is Sweden So Good at Pop Music? </em>Retrieved on September 29, 2020, from The Atlantic: <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/10/why-is-sweden-so-good-at-pop-music/280945/">https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/10/why-is-sweden-so-good-at-pop-music/280945/</a></p><p>Johansson, O. (2010). Beyond ABBA: The Globalization of Swedish Popular Music. <em>Focus on Geography</em>, 53(4), 134–141.</p><p>Michelsen, M. (2017). Ambassador, Merchant, and Masterminds: Swedish Popular Music Abroad. In A. Björnberg &amp; T. Bossius (ed.), <em>Made in Sweden: Studies in Popular Music </em>(pp. 211–221). New York; London: Routledge.</p><p>Pozzi, R. (n.d.). <em>Editorial: The cost of not having the ‘Big 4 / 5’ </em>Retrieved on October 3, 2020, from escdaily.com: <a href="https://www.escdaily.com/the-cost-of-not-having-the-big-45/">https://www.escdaily.com/the-cost-of-not-having-the-big-45/</a></p><p>Rosney, D. (2020, March 7). <em>Sweden’s Melfest: Why a national Eurovision show won global fans </em>Retrieved on September 29, 2020, from BBC News: <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-51749312">https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-51749312</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff49533a8d55" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>