<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Zancan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Josh Zancan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 03:47:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joshzancan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Rotten Tomatoes Explains One of the Biggest Problems in Public Discourse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/how-rotten-tomatoes-explains-one-of-the-biggest-problems-in-public-discourse-96685a132bbe?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/96685a132bbe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Feb 2023 21:51:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-23T21:53:02.682Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Don’t be so quick to trust a consensus.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XUwf_ph_aJj7WKuuGNGMsg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@quaritsch">Quaritsch</a></figcaption></figure><p>Here’s a hypothetical:</p><p>1,000 people go see a movie. 100 people really like it, 100 people really hate it, 100 people thought it kind of sucked, and 700 people though it was alright. Not great, not good — just alright. Pretty good at best. Good enough.</p><p>You read these reactions and come away with a pretty clear idea of how people feel about the movie: it’s nothing special. The majority of the people who reviewed it said as much, and the very vast majority wouldn’t even call it good. In fact, only 10% of the moviegoers would safely recommend it.</p><p>But…why does this movie have an 80% fresh score on Rotten Tomatoes?</p><p>In case you somehow don’t know, Rotten Tomatoes uses a binary scoring system. Thumbs up or thumbs down. Fresh or rotten, with the idea that this will balance out (sometimes it does!). But in this case, those 700 mildly positive reviews were positive enough to be put in the thumbs up column, and being that they’re in the majority, they have the greatest sway. This seems logical enough — majority rules and all — until you consider that <em>these reviews are the most indifferent,</em> equal only those who thought it kind of sucked (but since there was only 100 of those, they didn’t really matter).</p><p>What we see here is some sort of compounding approval. One person giving a mildly positive review is just a mildly positive review. But put a whole bunch of mildly positive reviews together and you get an overwhelmingly positive result.</p><p>80% is a good Rotten Tomatoes score. Movie studios will plaster that result on every piece of advertisement it can, and even if that Fresh number isn’t quite as high as they’d like, that’s okay too. They’ll slap that Fresh graphic on instead and leave the score off altogether. It doesn’t matter, because all you, the moviegoing public, needs to know, is that this film has been declared GOOD by a jury of your peers.</p><p>Even though…that’s just not the case.</p><p>But it shows how quickly a movie that people didn’t feel strongly about whatsoever can become a critical darling — or at least seem like one. And the reason marketing departments promote the Rotten Tomatoes score is because it signals to the audience that they (you) are supposed to like the movie too. That may seem too simple and dumb to actually make a difference, but studios keep doing it because it <em>works.</em> Most people want to fit in, and approving of the pre-approved pop culture is one of easiest ways to do that. You don’t even have to <em>see</em> the thing — you just have to Tweet about it.</p><p>So now what if <em>everyone</em> mildly approves of something? Or mildly disapproves? You’re looking at 100% and 0% scores, respectively, for movies that aren’t very good or bad and nobody actually really gives a shit about.</p><p>It’s like whispering in a room. One person is nothing, but 1,000 people is a roar. It’ll get so loud you won’t be able to make out the words and everyone will start talking over each other, louder and louder, until they’re all shouting.</p><p>Of course, you have the power to circumvent this type of forced-binary view of movies. Every Rotten Tomatoes page easily allows you to click on each individual review and engage with the greater nuances of the critic with the red fruit or green splotch next to their name, picture, and credential.</p><p>But how often do you really do that? And when (if) you do, how many of those reviews do you really read? Not all 50 or 100 or 250, certainly, and you can’t be expected to. There’s just too much to sift through to not simply look at the score and decide from there.</p><p>Because whether we want to or not, we <em>like</em> the binary. It’s <em>simple.</em> We can cover a lot of ground with very little effort, and there is nothing our stupid, lizard brains love more than efficiency. Maximum results, minimal effort.</p><p>Obviously I’m not talking about movies. But when studios benefit that much from manufactured binary assessments, imagine how hard politicians, pundits, and social media companies benefit from the same thing — and we’re not talking about movies and P&amp;L ratios. We’re talking about influencing and deciding the laws of the country. We’re talking about who decides how life goes for everyone. We’re talking about whipping up a frenzy, all from nothing.</p><p>And here’s the bad part. When it comes to politics, how many of us are watching the movie at all?</p><p>How many congressional sessions have you watched in their entirety in the past year? 5 years? 10? Your entire life?</p><p>I’m guessing the answer is approximately zero. And let me tell you, as someone who has done that, who has actually sat in the room and attended several, they are awful. They are horrible, tedious bullshit where grown adults play tit-for-tat like children and repeat the same thing ten different ways so they can pick which soundbite they like best for their next campaign commercial.</p><p>What about press conferences? How many have you watched in <em>their</em> entirety? A handful?</p><p>But you read about it online. Or rather, you read headlines, definitely, sometimes the first two paragraphs of the article, and every once in a while, the whole thing.</p><p>How many Tweets and Facebook statuses? I bet it’s much closer to a whole shit load.</p><p>In the end, the only thing that matters to a politician is getting your vote, and the only thing that matters to an activist is getting your support, so practically speaking, the binary makes sense. The end result of everything is which way you choose to go with it, and whether it’s movies or politics or anything else, it comes down to one question: do you approve or disapprove of the thing in front of you right now? It always, eventually becomes a binary choice, even though the binary metric <em>is not inherently reflective of reality whatsoever.</em> That’s troubling, considering we run our entire society based on it.</p><p>But when we take all this in, it feels like we know what’s going on, even though what we’re really seeing isn’t the movie. We’re seeing all the reactions and the reviews and then reactions and reviews to the reactions and reviews. It’s how someone will Tweet something stupid like “people are losing their minds over the [insert public figure] interview” but it’s really just a 30-second clip spliced together with smaller 5-second clips, and “losing their minds” is like 10 people being really mad while the rest of them are going “what a dumbass” and moving on with their lives.</p><p>But as this grows out, the perception is that people really <em>are</em> losing their minds.</p><p>The farther you get from the source, the more binary the assessment: simplified, sanded down, inaccurate. By the time it gets to you, it’s been filtered through so many summaries and framing devices and people just talking out of their ass, you might as well be engaging with a complete work of fiction. The middling reviews become an overstated Rotten Tomatoes score which becomes Great Movie. Or terrible movie, or movie you should be <em>furious</em> with.</p><p>And if you think people are losing their minds about something, and those people are on your side of the binary divide, then, like any good marketing team knows, you will receive — and likely accept — that you should be losing your mind too.</p><p>And you very likely will.</p><p>Then it won’t be a perception anymore. It will be a simple, demonstrable reality. We will be losing our minds, for no other reason than we think we’re supposed to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=96685a132bbe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Most Valuable (and Unexpected) Lesson I Learned in Alcoholics Anonymous]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/the-most-valuable-and-unexpected-lesson-i-learned-in-alcoholics-anonymous-8a8c711170f0?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a8c711170f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Jan 2023 20:04:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-19T20:04:34.953Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>One piece of advice taught me everything I needed to know about our responsibility towards others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RGYb5tkkVHxD64IhxcTSmA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@tinaflour">Kristina Flour</a></figcaption></figure><p>Alcoholics Anonymous has a weird place in our culture. It’s ubiquitous with substance abuse treatment, but for every proponent of the program, you’ll find just as many who are actively against it — and the latter group seems to be growing at a much faster rate than the former.</p><p>Personally, I worked the steps on my own because the meetings I went to usually had either one guy that was stark raving intense or one that was really into long, thorough hugs. Some meetings had both. One was trying to mend your broken wing while the other was trying to kick your ass out of the nest to teach you to fly. The thing they had in common — along with everybody else there — was a certain zeal for the program that I just couldn’t meet. But, I had been sober for about 25 hours at the time of my first meeting and I was terrified of where my life was heading, and I needed to be around people that understood that type of intense loneliness. So I went, and I’m glad I did. Not only did it help me feel less disfigured, but it brought me to a perspective I’m not sure I would have arrived at otherwise.</p><p>Every meeting had their personalities, but the first one I met was called Bob. I don’t need to use a fake name because, well, first names are allowed. But the thing about Bob was that he told me his last name too. He told <em>everybody</em> his last name. This dude did not give one damn about anonymity. He did everything in a big way. He was a big man, with a big smile and big movements and a big voice and he chewed his gum at about a billion decibels. If you wanted to feel welcome and cared for on the worst day of your life, you could do a whole lot worse than Bob.</p><p>He showed me around, paid for my handbook when he found out I didn’t have cash, and gave me his cell number in case I had any questions about the meetings or the process or if I was spiraling. Whatever I needed.</p><p>So it surprised me when, before my first meeting, this big, open man mentioned to me in a quiet voice in the corner of the room, “Hey just a heads up. Be careful what you share here.”</p><p>For a moment, I was disappointed. The whole reason I came here was so that I <em>didn’t</em> have to filter myself. That I could just present all my fucked-up-ness right out on a platter without repulsing anyone. And that’s about what I told him. I thought I was safe here to say anything and not be judged for it.</p><p>“Oh sure,” he said. “You can. You can say anything and nobody will judge you. But we’ve got a lot of women in this group, and generally speaking, most women who are alcoholics have been the victims of certain behaviors that a lot of male alcoholics have committed. You know what I’m saying?” I nodded. “And so they might not judge you personally. But hearing an account of a story like that can be triggering when you’ve been through what they have. They might not feel safe here anymore. And this is a safe place for everybody. So even though <em>you</em> can tell a story like that and be perfectly safe doing so, you’re doing it at the risk of other people not feeling safe. And that’s not what we do here. We don’t make people feel unsafe. So if you need to share a story like that, it’s best to do it at a mens-only meeting.”</p><p>The debate around safe spaces started in college campuses well over a decade ago and has spilled over into other areas. Work places, social media, comedy clubs. And the thing that seems to me to be at the heart of it all is defining what a safe space actually means. Is it the safety of being who you are — including saying what’s on your mind — and being accepted, or is it the safety to be there at all? Bob’s perspective was the first time I’d ever heard the two sides married with each other. That in order to be a safe space, you do have to be able to be who you are and speak true to yourself, but if it means someone else will no longer feel welcome, that you — not necessarily <em>can’t</em> — but <em>shouldn’t</em> conduct yourself in those ways.</p><p>Once you try to apply this to actual rules, such as the ongoing debates for social media, which has unfortunately become the de facto public square (even though it really isn’t and in my view, should be treated more like a club, with rules of conduct set accordingly), it gets a bit dicier. At some point, you have to zig or zag, either erring on the side of expression or erring on the side of welcomeness. And that’s where it all falls apart — considering the sensitivities of a group of 20 or 30 people all coming together in good faith to support each other over their struggles with addiction is a far simpler thing than applying that approach to society en masse.</p><p>But here’s the thing. <em>We already follow this approach every single day with almost every single thing we do.</em> We hold the door for the person behind us, we are cordial to the people who ring up our items at checkout and patient with servers at restaurants. Each of these little pieces, from civility to small social graces revolve around the same point: everything is fine. You are fine here. And if you don’t do these things, we generally come to a consensus: you’re an asshole. A Karen. You have small dick energy. All these insults built around the same conceit, that you are making the environment around you chaotic, tense, and threatening — not even the safety of it, necessarily — but the feeling and presumption of safety. We all agree to this implicitly. That’s the social contract. You don’t <em>have</em> to follow these rules. But you do.</p><p>So why was this ever really a debate at all?</p><p>I suppose it depends on the room. In a supermarket, the presumption of safety applies to everyone, for instance, while in the comedy club, the presumption errs on the side of the performer. That’s the deal for those spaces. Then you have social media, which, my god, who knows? It seems to apply to nobody, so…why even bother? I don’t know, but we do. Almost as if that’s our last battle ground. It’s No Man’s Land and everyone is trying to plant their safe zone flag in the ground and keep it there.</p><p>But that begs the next question: does everywhere have to be a safe space for everyone? Remember Bob’s recommendation: if you need to share a story that will make the women in the group feel unsafe, then consider sharing it at an all men’s group.</p><p>And it makes sense. Nobody’s recording your testimony. Women won’t be listening at the door.</p><p>But what would you do if you <em>were</em> being recorded? Because that’s the final big complex piece. It’s not like these online forums we’ve engaged in are locked behind a password with identities verified. It creates a world where men’s rights advocates can eavesdrop on feminists talking amongst themselves and even confront them directly. A complaint about race relations in America will be overrun with an onslaught of intense, almost cartoonish levels of racism and vitriol. Hell, I dare you to find a single Tweet sent out by the PlayStation account where half the responses aren’t “Xbox Better.”</p><p>The entire online experience is us peeking in on rooms that weren’t meant for us. Not only that, we award social clout to those who are the <em>most</em> disruptive to those rooms. We’ve gone the opposite direction.</p><p>It would seem the solution is to just not look. To refer back to the all male AA meeting, if women were listening at the door, it’s hardly the fault of men in the meeting at that point if they caused someone to feel unsafe. But I can’t say that applies online. The lure is too strong; not looking is simply not human nature.</p><p>And besides, at this point, everybody in all the respective online rooms are content to just scream at each other. Even private Facebook groups invariably become infiltrated by those just looking to disrupt (for better or worse, depending on where your sympathies lie in that moment).</p><p>I’m convinced we will never figure this out in full. The larger the room, the more impossible decorum will be, and the internet is one very, <em>very</em> big room. But I do think this sheds light on an important nuance often bemoaned and almost always misunderstood: tolerance and diversity.</p><p>You know how this goes. Someone does something deemed bigoted. People get upset. In defense of the alleged bigot, someone says “It seems you’re all mad at them for not being tolerant of others, but aren’t you the one being intolerant of their views/beliefs/opinions?” This is supposed to be a rhetorical gotcha, because as we all know, perceived hypocrisy is the biggest internet crime one can commit, and it is the only thing that matters, and it will automatically make one lose an argument. (I joke, but in practice, you’d really think this was true.)</p><p>But this is where we come full circle: that sentiment completely misses the point. A safe space, generally speaking, does not <em>strictly</em> mean that anything goes. It also means that everybody is welcome. Tolerance has never been the goal. It’s one tool to achieve it, but not the final result. And sometimes that’s going to mean you choosing to not say the thing. And if you do say the thing, and you keep saying the thing, well…I guess it depends on the room. But that’s just not something you have a lot of control over, and maybe don’t act so shocked and awed when the room starts to talk back.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a8c711170f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Resilience Almost Killed Me]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/resilience-almost-killed-me-e626b1242c6a?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e626b1242c6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[substance-abuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Feb 2022 22:09:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-22T22:09:52.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Relying too much on this one trait set me down a path that ended in substance abuse and debilitating mental health issues.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LCBTmvDqLaeVp9OyovW_1g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@sseeker">Stormseeker</a></figcaption></figure><p>This essay didn’t go the way I planned. I started writing it as the third and final installment of my series, “Our Obsession with Grit” — and to an extent, I still consider it to be — but while it follows all the same themes, I found my focus had shifted away from analysis and into something deeply personal. So personal that some of my own friends don’t know the things that I’ve written about here. In retrospect, this transition makes sense. The title “Our Obsession with Grit” never really sat right with me, because I knew what I was actually writing about all along, which was <em>my</em> obsession with grit.</p><p>Because I am obsessed with it. I’m obsessed, and I don’t want to be. I hate it.</p><p>I hate grit for the same reason one might come to resent religion or their job or their hometown or even the way they can’t stop picking their nails. It’s in the things I do, can’t stop doing, and don’t even know I’m doing until it’s too late. It’s inside of me and I can’t escape it.</p><p>Everything good in my life, I can attribute to some level of perseverance and resilience, but that goes for everything bad as well. That’s because for the majority of my life, sheer resilience was the only way I knew how to handle anything. When faced with a struggle or stuck in a bad situation, I fell back into the one thing that I felt gave me strength and stability. I told myself to just suck it up and get through it.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@joshzancan/our-obsession-with-grit-part-1-the-limitations-of-willpower-4abccc113e6b">I’ve mentioned before</a> that when we judge a person’s worth by what they are able to endure, we put no value in making things better. I was talking about society at large — and I do believe it applies there — but I was talking about myself as well. Because when you’re stuck in a shitty situation, the best thing to do is to realize that you aren’t actually stuck. You can leave that situation, you can change that situation. You don’t actually have to just deal with it, and choosing not to do so isn’t a sign of weakness, it’s not a sign that you’re giving up, and it’s not a failure.</p><p>That is, unless it’s the only thing you know how to do. When it’s the only place your instincts ever lead you and it’s the only thing that feels right and justifiable.</p><p>Bad relationships, bad jobs, bad habits. I spent years always in at least one of these things, pushing through them, struggling against them, doing everything except walking away or even addressing simple problems right in front of me, and it all goes back to the fact that I truly believed that not struggling meant I was weak. That I was not worthy. That I failed. All that, even though the only thing I ever really ended up struggling against was myself and my own self-preservation.</p><p>I can’t emphasize this enough. What a terrible existence it is, to believe that pursuing inner peace is the biggest proof of worthlessness. To believe that problems are not meant to be solved, but conquered through sheer force of will. To measure your own value by the trials you face and not know the reality of a life without an adversary, even if that means you have to make one up.</p><p>That’s not strength. It’s self-abuse. You end up keeping yourself miserable just to feel like life is worth living, or feel like you exist at all.</p><p>I chose the headline “Resilience Almost Killed Me” as a play on the adage, “What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.” Not as an endorsement of it, but a condemnation. It’s true we grow through experience, and experience includes hardships, but I am here to tell you, while those hardships have made me wiser, they have not made me stronger.</p><p>I am not stronger. I am broken.</p><p>My first job out of college, I was working a whole hell of a lot in a corporate office for not much money. It was a salary position, so there wasn’t overtime pay either. A slow week had me in the office for 50 hours, and during the busiest times of the year, I put in as many as 90, sometimes working as many as 21 days in a row. But I was okay with it, because I firmly held the belief that you just have to do what you have to do. I graduated in 2010, and two years into a massive economic recession, you took whatever you could get. So if that meant a demanding job where I was expected to be available 24/7 for no money and wasn’t able to have any life outside of the office, well…that’s what I was going to do.</p><p>In the beginning, I felt empowered. When you determine the value of everything you experience through the lens of how tough you need to be, taking a position like that is enough to make a 22 year old guy feel something like a real man. Sure it was challenging, but the sentiment was, <em>look at me world, I’m doing it anyway.</em></p><p>I don’t quite remember how long it took for things to change, but it seemed to happen slowly at first, and then all at once. I started getting a little fog-headed. Nothing alarming, and nothing that seemed unusual. I’d been putting in a lot of hours, I was having trouble sleeping, and I attributed it to that. Not long after, everything around me seemed different somehow. Nothing had changed in any physical sense, but the experience of it seemed otherworldly. There were even moments where the fog was so thick, I wondered if I was actually awake at all, or just dreaming. Life had that same sort of unreal feeling. In my more extreme moments, I’d go to our office supply closet under the guise of checking inventory as an excuse to feel the ridges in the wire shelving or the weight of a ream of paper in my hands, just to feel that they were really there. Because if they were, it meant I was too.</p><p>One night, the company was hosting customers for an event, and it was my job to essentially just hang around while everyone was there, clean up and lock up behind them. Another late night, but one of the easy ones, so I didn’t mind too much. Yet as I sat in the chair at my desk, I looked down to find that my body, my arms and hands, the chair itself, looked like it was 20 feet away. I was still attached to all of it, but following a twisted dream logic, it was me but not me at the same time. I knew that my breathing changed, because I saw my chest move more rapidly, but it didn’t feel any different to me. If asked, I’d have told you that I was perfectly calm. I don’t know how else to describe it other than that my mind had separated itself from my body, and as such, it wasn’t experiencing the same things as my body.</p><p>From somewhere distant, I heard a muffled sound, like I was underwater, and then suddenly everything returned to its proper place. One of the attendees was standing at the edge of my desk, saying my name. The room seemed brighter. Not like someone had turned up the lights, but as though everything had a sheen to it, like newly polished jewelry.</p><p>From this description, you’d be reasonable to think it was a dream, that I’d simply dozed off in my chair. I considered that myself, except I knew I was awake because unlike a dream, I remember the moment the experience began. Even when someone zones out, like with highway hypnosis, they can’t tell when the trance started; they don’t even realize they were in one until after it’s passed. This wasn’t that. I remember every detail: entering into it, existing in it, returning from it.</p><p>Then I started to lose time altogether.</p><p>It wasn’t necessarily a common occurrence and I never found a pattern to when it would happen. Technically, the first time was a couple years earlier when I was still in college, but I’d brushed that off as typical absentmindedness while driving, the kind we’ve all experienced at some point. I was at a stop light and then I blinked and I was at a different stoplight two miles past my house. I thought it was weird at the time because usually when your brain goes on autopilot while driving, you take the turn your muscle memory knows best. You don’t usually drive to a section of the city you’ve only been to once before. My therapist even said it sounded like I was just distracted, so maybe that really was the case. But when it started happening later in more non-typical situations, that day came to mind.</p><p>I always tried to look for and follow the most sensible explanation. Stuff like this happens to everyone, especially during moments of high stress or if you’re just busy as hell. That day driving: stressful. Another time at another company event: very busy <em>and</em> very stressful. These experiences weren’t nothing, but they could also be explained through more reasonable means than some deeper psychological issue. But one instance stands out in my mind.</p><p>We had a meeting with one of our vendors. It came and went and that was that. It was routine, practically nothing. But then later that day, in a follow-up conversation with the same vendor, he referred to something my boss had said. I didn’t recall it. Nothing unusual there though. One sentence in one somewhat long meeting isn’t exactly memorable. But then the vendor mentioned a suggestion <em>I</em> made. I didn’t recall that either. I figured it was another throwaway, easily forgettable statement, until I saw the look on his face. Apparently, we had discussed the suggestion at some length. More to the point, <em>I</em> had discussed it at length. It took up a significant portion of the meeting, and I had no recollection of it, even though it had only happened a mere three hours earlier.</p><p>Then he asked me, half jokingly, if I remembered anything about the meeting at all. And I didn’t. I remembered sitting down at the table and I remembered leaving the conference room, and that was it.</p><p>Mentally checking out during a meeting is one thing, but this seemed like an awful lot of cognitive function and critical thinking for someone who was just running on autopilot, so I asked him if I seemed weird or not like myself. I should mention, this was a guy that I had known for years, long before I worked at the company. He knew me very, very well, and he said I seemed perfectly ordinary. So something wasn’t right.</p><p>My official diagnosis was depersonalization disorder — DPD — which is known today as depersonalization-derealization disorder.</p><p>Depersonalization, in nutshell, is when someone feels as though they are detached from their own body. I referred to that earlier, sitting in my chair that late night at the office. Derealization is when a person feels as though they are detached from the world. And when I say detached, I don’t mean like when you were going through your teenage emo phase and felt like you didn’t fit in with society. I mean you feel as though the world is literally separate from you, as though you are watching everything on a television set, or through a thick pane of glass. You see it, and you know it’s there, but it’s just…not quite tangible. That’s what I was experiencing going into the supply closet just to feel the weight of physical objects. I was trying to connect with something physical outside of myself.</p><p>Both of these phenomena are classified as dissociation, and DPD (now DPDR) is listed in the DSM-5 as a dissociative disorder.</p><p>Here’s the kicker. Everyone experiences moments of dissociation every single day. Usually about five times on average. You may not notice it though, because it typically only happens for about a fraction of a second. It’s like a little reset button in your brain, like it just takes a quick break, and it is a wonderful and necessary defense mechanism.</p><p>But it’s meant for maintenance. It’s really, really not supposed to happen all day, every day, with varying intensities. But something about me and and my environment and the way I handled things made my brain learn to go, “Nope, fuck this. Fuck all of this, we’re getting out and we’re not going back.”</p><p>I did find my way back, of course. Eventually. It only took me about three or four years.</p><p>If you’ve ever been high, you know what dissociation feels like. That’s one of the reasons people use drugs in the first place. Now imagine being high all the time. At first glance, that might sound awesome, but I’m talking about being high minus any of the actual fun parts. The goofiness, the finding things funny, the way food is better and sex is better and all the good feelings in general. None of that stuff applies here. Just the thick, dense blanket of fog that you can never manage to get on the other side of.</p><p>Persistent dissociation is common in anxiety disorders too. Generalized anxiety disorder and DPD share many of the same symptoms, but there’s a major difference. A person with GAD dissociates when their anxiety is heightened to a certain level, which, if you have an anxiety disorder, can be often. With DPD, a person dissociates at the presence of pretty much <em>any</em> degree of anxiety.</p><p>I kind of laughed the first time my therapist brought it up. I told him I didn’t feel anxious. Then he kind of laughed, and said, “Yeah, that’s the whole point.”</p><p>It’d be disingenuous to say that an instinct towards resilience was my only problem, or that all of my problems were the result of this instinct. But the fact remains, everything I discussed in that therapist’s chair funneled into one functional result: I never truly confronted anything. Because when all you ever do is suck it up and push through any given struggle, it only <em>feels</em> like strength. From the outside, it may even look like it — we tend to value those who remain composed, unaffected, and stable — but that isn’t always the case. For me, it was anxiety, a total lack of coping skills, self-neglect, and sometimes just straight cowardice.</p><p>But here’s the bonkers thing. I wasn’t actually all that composed and unaffected. I could be, sure, but it’s just not sustainable. There’s a reason engineers build bridges to be flexible; if they were completely rigid, they’d crack into pieces under the weight of traffic and the force of the wind. The great irony here was that I couldn’t see that I was falling apart, even though it was pretty clear to everyone else, and painfully so to those close to me. I still felt stoic and strong.</p><p>At this point it might seem like what I’m describing is your garden variety bottled-up emotions, where all your anger and frustration brews under the surface until one day you just blow your top. This isn’t quite that. There were certainly elements of it at play, specific reoccurring stressors that, with each reemergence, did impact me more and more each time and eventually cause my emotions to boil over the brim. But more than that, with no ability to help or heal myself, or even the ability to recognize that I needed help or healing, my mental and emotional health deteriorated over time. This underlines the real danger of abandoning any sort of self-care or regard. It doesn’t just put your emotions under pressure until they burst; if let go long enough, it changes the way you think, the way you feel, and the way you view and interact with yourself and the world on a deep, primal level. Long periods of stress and struggle — internal or external — changes who you are as a person. It is a trauma in and of itself.</p><p>A bridge that never gives or sways with its environment is hazardous enough on its own. Now imagine how fucked up things can get when it has a raging drinking problem.</p><p>I could write multiple volumes on alcoholism, but the two relevant aspects here are 1) what drinking did for me, and 2) why I didn’t stop for nearly a decade even though I knew I had a problem almost immediately.</p><p>Moving away from the imagery of rigid, crumbling bridges, try to imagine that any time you’re in a situation where any sort of friction is present, you have to hold your breath. It’s beyond your control. Whenever you are doing most things, your diaphragm seizes up. Performing a task at work? Holding your breath. Someone gets in front of you too close on the road? Holding your breath. The sensation of basic human emotion? Lock it up.</p><p>That’s a draining experience. But then, you discover a wonderful potion, and as long as you have three or four doses of that inside you, you can breathe all you want. It doesn’t matter what’s going on. Someone could be wagging a gun in your face and you’d still stop to take a big lungful of the night air.</p><p>It was so profound that while most people I know spent the morning after a wild night nursing hangovers and cursing the gods, I never felt better. I woke up refreshed, even, like a massive weight had been lifted off my shoulders. Sure, I’d have a headache or be a little queasy (and yes, in a few cases, would need to stay in bed all day). And there were plenty of mornings where I needed to make apology phone calls for whatever behavior I exhibited the night before, which I always felt genuine remorse over. But that was nothing compared to the deep emotional relief. Even when I behaved badly and hated myself for doing so, outside of all that, the world simply felt lighter. It was amazing enough to far outweigh everything else. And when it got to a point where the hangover symptoms stopped altogether, that just made it all the sweeter.</p><p>The thing is, when you have to go around holding your breath most of the day, you sort of get used to it. Eventually, you barely notice. It just becomes something you do. That is, until you can finally breathe. Because sometimes you don’t know how bad you’re feeling until you really start to feel good.</p><p>Once you experience that type of relief, how could you possibly go back?</p><p>So…I didn’t. And it didn’t matter that I didn’t literally need alcohol to survive; what mattered is that it felt like I did. It was a need so deep that no matter what the consequences became, I always went back. And it wasn’t without trying. I must’ve told myself a couple dozen times that I was done with it, and with each attempt (except the most recent, of course), I never made it more than a week without some direct outside incentive. (I once went a month just to prove to my family and friends that I could, and another time for four months prior to an impending court date. But when it can be down to just me? Not a chance.)</p><p>And then of course, there was the resilience. The determination. The belief that no matter how bad things got, I was just going to hunker down and deal with it.</p><p>It might seem dumb to equate always pushing through and never quitting with never giving up alcohol, and that’s because it kind of is. There’s literally a joke about continuing to drink because “I’m no quitter,” but that’s pretty much the mindset I took. Each time I considered stopping, it felt like a loss. I’d been defeated. Booze and I were going toe-to-toe, and there I was, stepping out of the ring? It was a feeling I’d spent my whole life trying to avoid, so mix that in with the feeling of emotional freedom that alcohol gave me, I didn’t really stand a chance.</p><p>But even I couldn’t deny that it was causing problems, so it seemed to me at the time that I could do one of two things. I could admit defeat and give up the only thing that ever made me feel like a fully formed person, or I could just fix myself. And in my defense, it was the first time in my adult life that I considered the notion of psychological self-improvement in any meaningful way that didn’t involve self-medicating, so at least I was going in the right direction. Of course, I had no clue how to do that, so I did what I always did, which was try to just will myself to improve. I truly thought that if I simply told myself to be better, eventually I’d get there.</p><p>And so I didn’t get there. Of course I didn’t. Because grit and determination only go so far.</p><p>But there’s also the crazy notion at the center of all of this: that I needed to drink so badly, that I chose the hardest path. I chose self-criticism and self-loathing over sobriety. I chose to hate myself just so I could drink. Because if drinking was the problem, then it meant I lost, and if there’s one thing a person built on the foundation of resilience and perseverance does not do, it’s lose.</p><p>I’ve been in jail, I’ve nearly died, I’ve hurt myself and my loved ones, and I’ve let other people hurt me. I did this willingly for the sake of something that at the time I couldn’t name or place, which I now see as a pathological and irrational allegiance to resilience. And to this day, despite years of therapy and sobriety, I still have to conciously prevent myself from falling back into this pattern. I catch myself everyday still holding my breath to get by. Both emotionally, as in my previous analogy, but even literally as well. Constantly bracing for impact, ready to stand stone-like in the face of whatever life throws at me.</p><p>I started this off by saying I’m obsessed with grit, but maybe obsession isn’t the right word to describe it. Not for myself or culture in general. It’s a compulsion. It is an addiction. The first addiction.</p><p>I used to be grateful for all of this. My thought was, thank god I can’t give up anything. Thank god that I can’t help myself, that I can’t bring myself to just stop. And to be fair, when you’re a person who’s experienced periods of heavy suicidal ideation, the inability to quit is a decidedly good virtue to have. Despite the title of this essay, it literally kept me alive. But as I distance myself from all of this, I can’t shake the notion that if I didn’t rely so exclusively on resilience, if I had a grasp on any other coping mechanism besides a stiff upper lip, maybe I wouldn’t have had these issues in the first place. Resilience for me, then, was like alcohol or anxiety. The more I leaned on it, the more I needed it. My first addiction.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e626b1242c6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Obsession with Grit (Part 2) — Hollywood’s Big Lie About Perseverance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/our-obsession-with-grit-part-2-hollywoods-big-lie-about-perseverance-c0061db16b8?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0061db16b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[motivation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Jan 2022 01:56:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-02T03:33:37.846Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Hollywood’s portrayal of perseverance is unrealistic, especially when the stories are supposed to be true.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3YFougKYGCBWUqkPLZiGTg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mbrunacr">Miguel Bruna</a></figcaption></figure><p>Hollywood has always had a way of gussying up even the truest of stories to be something more than what they are, putting their own spin on things for the sake of dramatic flair or condensing certain details to fit as much as they can within a roughly two-hour runtime. I think everyone knows this, and we go into them prepared to get something ranging from “pretty much true” to “we kept the dude’s name and occupation, except now he can fly.” But who cares? It’s all a part of the movie magic. We don’t watch them necessarily to learn something, but for the same reason we watch any other movie. To be entertained or thrilled or inspired or touched in someway. Accuracy, then, is secondary to storytelling. Which is fine, because movies are just movies and when theater popcorn costs forty-five dollars, that shit better be <em>worth it.</em></p><p>Except…they aren’t just movies. Because despite all this, we still form expectations for ourselves, others, and how the world works based on what we see on the big screen. (Or small screen for that matter, as television shows can have the same effect.)</p><p>The reason that you might assume all smart people are nothing shy of chess grandmasters is because every smart person you’ve ever seen in a television show or movie can do some crazy shit like play a match blind over the phone while tracking the moves in their head.</p><p>Almost our entire idea of masculinity originated from John Wayne movies, even though John Wayne himself was just as much of a work of fiction as any of his characters. In real life and when out of the public eye, Wayne was significantly more feminine. (Director John Ford famously instructed him to walk properly and stop “skipping like a fairy.”)</p><p>The modern view of fraternities belongs solely to <em>Animal House</em>, which also instructed the behavior of fraternities from then on, and there’s a whole generation of people who are against the “snowflakes” of the world because they completely missed the point of <em>Fight Club.</em></p><p>I could go on and on. Almost everything in our culture, these ideas and aspects we take at face value, can be traced back to either originating or being severely enabled by Hollywood. And this is just as true when it comes to one of America’s favorite genres: the underdog story.</p><p>Stories of grit and determination and hard work that eventually always pays off in some grand and magnificent way. We take these as something to live up to even though, whether we know it or not, we never actually will, because we can’t. Because at the end of the day these are still movies and, true stories or not, they are no more reflective of the power of grit than hardcore porn is to real life sex.</p><p>Especially because many times, if not most of the time (almost all of the time), these true stories only achieve their emotional effect with the parts the filmmakers add in. The “true stories” that are just as true as anything else in Hollywood.</p><p>So let’s talk about a couple of them.</p><p>When I was growing up, there was one movie in particular that every person knew. It was drilled into all of us as not just an inspiring story in its own right, but an example of the way one should handle life itself. An incredible true story that showcased the power of perseverance and grit, where one man stood up in the face of everything stacked against him — and god there was a lot stacked against him — to achieve his dream. The tangible reward itself was relatively simple, but the reward wasn’t really the point. He did it because everyone told him he couldn’t, he did it out of pride and a dedication to himself, what he knew he was worth, and really just for the sake of <em>never giving up.</em> True grit and heart and determination because by god that’s the American Way. Hoo-fucking-rah.</p><p>And sure, Hollywood loves to stretch what it means for a story to be true, but even better, the guy this movie was based on claims that it is 92% accurate to what really happened, with only small liberties being taken for that beloved dramatic flair.</p><p>It’s a movie about a working class young man with a big heart, superhuman work ethic, and more perseverance and drive than any of us could imagine, who really, really, really wanted to play football for Notre Dame.</p><p>This movie was <em>Rudy</em>, and if you don’t want it ruined for you, just stop reading now.</p><p>See, that 92% figure comes from the real Daniel ‘Rudy’ Ruettiger, who’s career as a motivational speaker hinges solely on his reputation from this movie. He’s also known to have some other kind of far fetched anecdotes on his record.</p><p>According to pretty much everyone else though, yeah, some of the events in the movie technically happened…kind of.</p><p>Here are the only relevant details from the movie that were left entirely unchanged, with no fabrication or significant exaggeration:</p><p>Rudy went to Holy Cross College, and then he went to Notre Dame.</p><p>He gained a reputation on campus for being a very determined, hard worker.</p><p>He played football for Notre Dame.</p><p>He made it onto the field for precisely one play.</p><p>He sacked the quarterback on that play.</p><p>He was very short.</p><p>And that’s it. That is literally it.</p><p>The whole stadium chanting his name as he ran onto the field? An incredible movie moment, but are you trying to tell me that this kid worked so hard that an entire football stadium, largely filled with people who have no idea who he is, was that stoked for him to simply play one down?</p><p>Never happened, although a small group in the student section did chant his name after he sacked the quarterback.</p><p>But hey, that’s still pretty awesome!</p><p>The movie shows the team carrying him off the field, an honor, we’re told, never bestowed on another Notre Dame player before or since.</p><p>In reality, it was three guys, and they were doing it as a joke, the way you vote the nerdy kid prom king because you think it’ll be funny.</p><p>The whole team going to the coach to give up their spot on the game day roster for him? Not quite. According to the real Rudy, a few guys did go to the coach to talk about him playing, but another version is that he was <em>always </em>going to play because…</p><p>Contrary to what the film might tell you, the coach actually really liked Rudy! Of course he did. Have you ever met a football coach who was bothered by someone showing up to practice everyday and putting in 110%? This highlights probably the greatest revisionist offense the film has to offer:</p><p>The biggest struggle Movie Rudy faced, outside of being the size of a Cabbage Patch doll, was that nobody believed in him. Everyone told him he wasn’t good enough, strong enough, fast enough, or big enough. The coach hated him, his father dismissed him, and his older brother, by far his most brutal critic, all but told him he was a worthless piece of shit.</p><p>Actually, Rudy’s dad always supported his dream and was a source of encouragement. The coach admired Rudy’s work ethic. And as for his older brother…</p><p><em>He didn’t even fucking exist.</em></p><p>Sure, Rudy had his naysayers. Anyone who is loudly, comically scrappy and competitive is going to. But the fact is, Rudy received support from pretty much everyone who mattered, including two of the film’s three main antagonists, the third of whom was entirely fictional.</p><p>What’s interesting here is the groundskeeper who provided Movie Rudy with the majority of his encouragement was fictional as well. So all in all, filmmakers turned his support group into villains and then fabricated his mentor. This is a movie that is regularly cited as what could happen through the power of determination and perseverance — including literally how to win your emotionally stunted fathers’ love and approval — but they were only able to achieve that by presenting almost all of the relevant story details as the opposite of what actually happened in real life.</p><p>And these are only the big things that were wrong, because the filmmakers just couldn’t give this kid a break. They even had Rudy working so he could pay his way through college. Sure this was the 70s and tuition was way cheaper back then, but assuming most college students were making about minimum wage, Rudy would’ve had to be working almost full time all year round, and that doesn’t factor in any other expenses. How did he attend school, play NCAA football, box (oh yeah, Rudy was also a boxer, which is really where his reputation came from, not so much football), <em>and</em> work all these hours?</p><p>He didn’t. Rudy was in the Navy before college. The GI Bill payed for his education.</p><p>But <em>that’s</em> what we were telling kids to live up to for like a decade. That’s what we were striving for <em>ourselves</em>. It’s so unattainable that not even Rudy himself would’ve been able to do it. Using this movie as a model for the power of perseverance is like teaching a sex education class by showing Backdoor Bonanza Vol. 4.</p><p>But here’s the thing: the actual story of Rudy? It’s still really cool! You still have all the determination in there — again, he was a genuinely passionate, inspired, and determined guy — but it’s also a story about people appreciating and supporting those aspects of him. That’s a great lesson! But no. We love grit too much. We need things to be terrible so we have something to overcome, just like Rudy, so we can really show the magnitude of what we’re made of. Where even our own fathers won’t give us the least bit of leeway until we’ve literally been carried off the field in a hail of glory with thousands of people cheering our name.</p><p><em>Jesus.</em></p><p>With the movie broken down into pieces like that, I’m not even disappointed by how false it is. I’m mostly confused as to how we ever believed it was true to begin with, because this is some fairytale shit, more in line with a daydream Rudy would’ve had than anything even remotely plausible. They might as well have put his underwear on the outside of his pants and told him to go save Lois Lane.</p><p>Another film that rippled its way through my generation is the probably-less-popular but still very well know, <em>Cool Runnings</em>, the story of the first Jamaican Olympic bobsled team. To its credit,<em> Cool Runnings</em> didn’t quite wear its inspirational rah-rah angle on its sleeve, but even with a more comedic approach (“hey Sanka, you dead?” is seared into my memory), it still had its moments.</p><p>Like <em>Rudy </em>(and hell, any underdog story), the core character focus of <em>Cool Runnings</em> is all about determination and overcoming the odds. A track star whose Olympic dreams are dashed convinces a bobsled coach to train him and three others to make the Winter Olympics. The first obstacles were laid out early on by the tragically late John Candy: they don’t have snow, time to train, or a coach to train them.</p><p>They also had no money, but Candy’s character was kind enough not to rub that in their faces.</p><p>And then of course, once they overcame those odds, the winter athletes shunned the Jamaicans because I guess Jamaica being hot means Canada has never seen black people before. What better Hollywood adversary than the entire culture of the Olympics and the prejudices of their fellow athletes?</p><p>Now, if you thought <em>Rudy </em>took liberties with reality, buckle up, because the true story of the first Jamaican bobsled team was such a colossal work of fiction that not a single character in the movie existed. Every single one was invented for the film, including the team itself, and even the ones who have real-world counterparts were changed so much they might as well have been a formality.</p><p>As I did with <em>Rudy</em>, here is what the movie did not make up:</p><p>Jamaica had a first bobsled team.</p><p>They crashed on their final lap.</p><p>Seriously, this movie didn’t just take liberties; it is not a true story <em>at all.</em> In fact, unlike the real Rudy, who greatly over-exaggerated how little his movie exaggerated, our source for how full of shit <em>Cool Runnings</em> is comes from members of the actual first Jamaican bobsled team itself.</p><p>The reason filmmakers changed basically every single aspect of the story is ostensibly because the real story would come off more like a satire of how wealthy businessmen will try to do anything to make money, and it would be so on-the-nose that audiences would probably roll their eyes at the multitude of clichés present.</p><p>The summary of the real story is that some businessmen saw Jamaican pushcarting, and thought “Hey, that looks a lot like bobsledding! I bet we could put together a Jamaican bobsled team and make a fuck ton of money off the sheer novelty of it.”</p><p>They then approached the Jamaican track team to join them for their Winter Olympic dreams, and the track team didn’t even consider it.</p><p>Apparently, when you live on a sweltering island in the middle of the Caribbean, you tend to not like the idea of snow sports.</p><p>In fact, they couldn’t find <em>anyone</em> who was interested in competing. Some underdog story of grit and determination, huh?</p><p>The businessmen <em>were</em> determined though, because they ended up going to the Jamaican government, who then went to the Jamaican army, who sent it down the chain, picked four guys, and ordered them to be on the team.</p><p>And sure, those guys didn’t know what the fuck they were doing, so they got injured a good bit and had to push through those injuries, but that was less about the power of grit or determination or desire, and more that they had no choice. It was go bobsledding, or whatever the Jamaican version of a court marshall is. And that isn’t to say that soldiers in general don’t show grit just because they’re taking orders — I’d never diminish what armed forces have to go through— but having to march through the jungles of Vietnam for months at a time with leeches biting your pecker is leagues different than spraining your ankle in a sport where you’re mostly sitting in a big tampon tube while it glides down an ice chute.</p><p>A few more notes:</p><p>The Olympic committee and the other athletes were very warm and welcoming.</p><p>They didn’t carry their sled to the finish line at the end. That’d be stupid. They pushed it like anyone who can scrounge up a few brain cells would.</p><p>And obviously they were bankrolled by their investors. After all, it was a whole plan to make money. So no, nobody sold kisses and Jesus Christ could you imagine guys actually doing that? Kissing booths? The only visitors they’d get in real life would be from the police.</p><p>In the end, though, the Jamaicans triumphed. Despite their poor performance, they still earned the admiration and respect of their entire country. Because of course they did. It’s a movie. Having the characters return home and just go right back to their normal Army life would’ve been a fucking drag.</p><p>I want to make clear, I’m not shitting on these movies <em>as movies</em>. They were a huge part of my childhood, and I love both of them. I focus on them, though, because they not only exemplify our underdog worship, but they are the least subtle about the underlying subtext of why we love these movies to begin with (that is, they’re not subtle about it at all). The key message of each of these films is that determination equals glory. Rudy was carried off the field, being celebrated like he just single-handedly saved the championship game, and the team from <em>Cool Runnings</em> returned to Jamaica as heroes, even though the protagonists of either of these films didn’t actually make any incredible achievement. They were praised for their effort and initiative alone.</p><p>That in and of itself isn’t a terrible message, even if it is ironic that the generation who shits on participation trophies made whole films where the characters received immortal glory for trying their best and not succeeding at much of anything. But regardless, determination and hard work should absolutely be encouraged. Ultimately though, these movies aren’t about what you can <em>achieve</em> through these means. The moral of the story is that you should always work hard for the sake of it. That the hard work will equal glory, even if you’re only getting paid in sentimentality.</p><p>This is a value we see all throughout our culture, but it is a weirdly inefficient one. I mean, it’s great that Rudy reached his goal, but I can’t help but wonder what he would’ve achieved if he took all of his determination and grit and put it into something he was actually cut out for. It clearly wasn’t college football.</p><p>But this all makes sense. According to a Pew survey, 73% of Americans say hard work is important to getting ahead in life, significantly higher than the other 44 countries included in the same poll. It’s no wonder that we have the highest income inequality despite holding the most wealth, and half of us respond to that by saying poor people just need to get off their asses.</p><p>And if none of that hard work actually gets them anywhere? That’s fine. Hard work is the real reward after all, right? That’s why we don’t give a shit about paid leave, are the only country with widespread access to 24/7 stores, look down on people who like to sleep past nine, and, probably related to the last point, get less sleep than any other country. It’s why when we see people struggling, even on a mass scale, we see it as a flaw of character and a condemnation to their societal value rather than the value of the societal systems in place.</p><p>We also do more cocaine than anyone else. I’m pretty sure that’s by necessity.</p><p>And for what it’s worth, if you want a good underdog story that actually reflects real life success, I recommend <em>The Mighty Ducks</em>. That ragtag team of klutz’ didn’t beat the Hawks out of grit or determination or hard work. They got a coach who could provide basic focus and organization, one star player to rally around, and a goalie as wide as the net. They also poached the other team’s best player and recruited a guy who could fire a puck through a human skull. That’s less of an underdog story and more a movie about how to intelligently form a really good team with a lot of things going for it. And those are the ones who win.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c0061db16b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Obsession With Grit (Part 1) - The Limitations of Willpower]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/our-obsession-with-grit-part-1-the-limitations-of-willpower-4abccc113e6b?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4abccc113e6b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[willpower]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motivation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Jan 2022 02:38:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-05T07:36:07.533Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>It is counterproductive to measure a person’s value by what they are able to endure.</h4><p><em>You have to want it. And if you don’t have what it takes to see it through, then you didn’t want it bad enough.</em></p><p>Whatever <em>it </em>is. You’ve read the articles, you’ve heard the sports coaches (in real life or in movies), you’ve watched the motivational speakers, and hell, you probably learned this from your own upbringing. Desire, determination, will, willpower, grit, balls, resilience, heart.</p><p>To clear up any concerns right now, I am not about to say that any of those things are bad, because they aren’t bad. Determination is good. Resilience is vital. In my own life, I was taught this lesson and it has been reaffirmed time and time again: sometimes — many times, even — you really do just have it suck it up and get through it. It’s a huge part of the human experience and it always has been. So before you think I’m about to make the claim that we should drop these constructs, rest easy.</p><p>The claim that I am making, however, is that the relationship that we have given between a person’s will and their want is significantly more tenuous than we treat it to be, and most damagingly, how we associate those two things with worthiness is making our lives worse.</p><p>Yes, if a person wants something bad enough, they’ll keep working at it. Yes, if you see a person working at something diligently, they clearly want it pretty bad. There <em>is</em> a relationship there. And yes, that type of ambition is a very good trait to have. But not acknowledging all of the other elements at play is a misapplication of these values. This leads to a misreading of situations at hand, which leads to a society not operating in the most efficient way possible. And when you have a culture that is as gung-ho about efficiency as ours is, that seems like it would be a pretty big deal! Yet we end up handicapping ourselves based on principle, which suggests to me, it’s probably not a great principle (at least not when we apply it as universally as we do).</p><p>First, I need to hammer out some technicalities, because we have a lot of words, and we often use those words interchangeably, even when we shouldn’t. Determination, for example, and willpower do not mean the same thing. Perseverance gets tossed around too, but that’s also different. They’re closely related, they often rely on each other, but treating them as synonymous or mutually inclusive is one of the ways we got to this thinking in the first place. I know the political left has sort of co-opted the phrase “words matter” in a way that’ll make half the people reading this tune out, so let me make this distinction: the <em>definition</em> of words matter, and applying them correctly is necessary to parsing the finer specificity of our human experience.</p><p>Because we use these terms interchangeably, we often treat them as falling into one large conceptual umbrella. And to an extent, they do. Perseverance is aided by determination and willpower, sure, among an assortment of other things. It makes sense to lump them all together, but the ways in which they differ — more specifically, the roles in which they play — need to be respected. Perseverance is a behavior, determination is a mindset, willpower is a resource. These things make up a person’s…whatever you call it. Grit, heart, drive, etc. There may be times when I use these terms or concepts interchangeably myself (I already have), but I’m doing so only because that is how they are often understood. And also, yeah, depending on the context, they <em>can</em> mix together enough where they might as well be the same thing.</p><p>My key focus here, though, is willpower. Of all the things that go into our idea of what it means to be successful in an endeavor or even worthy as a person, willpower is the star of the show. It is the measure of strength, it is vital to our survival and momentum, and it is the first thing that will betray us. And that is because…</p><p>Willpower is a finite resource. While things like determination and perseverance and discipline are traits and attributes, part of our personality and identity, willpower is an active ability that commonly — but not always — manages those things. Think of it as the assist, keeping yourself in line, like bumpers on the side of a bowling alley. Your ball won’t always hit the side, but when it does, your willpower is there and it can keep you out of the gutter and on track. But when willpower goes, everything else is put in jeopardy.</p><p>Some have more willpower than others, some have less, but we all have an allotment of it that needs to be replenished, especially when it’s relied on too often. Willpower itself, however, is in no way an indicator of a person’s drive or desire (although choosing to never use it might be). Most of us know the feeling of just saying “fuck it” after a particularly tough day and going hog on a family size bag of potato chips even though we’re trying to drop 20 pounds by summer. But you’re not going to keep gorging when you wake up the next morning, because you no longer feel the need to. You’re still able to go to work even if you don’t want to because you rested and got some juice back. Maybe not all of it — if you’re constantly taking hits day after day you’ll need more than one nights rest to fully recharge — but generally speaking, that’s how the cycle goes. We burn some gas, we fill the tank. But just because someone’s tank runs dry doesn’t mean they’re weak or uncommitted or lacking in some area. It doesn’t mean they just couldn’t hack it or didn’t want to hack it. It means they’re a normal person with normal human limitations.</p><p>Any time you will yourself to do something you don’t want to do or resist something you do want, you use willpower. That’s literally what willpower is, and so there <em>is</em> a certain sensibility as to why we choose that for our focus. We know if a person wants something bad enough, they’re going to do what it takes to see it through, even when things get difficult. <em>When the going gets tough, the tough get going.</em> And since willpower is the thing that keeps us on track, we largely credit it for our success. Makes sense, right? But then we apply it to desire. Whether it’s losing weight, or getting off drugs, or any other arduous endeavor, we go around saying things like, “It’s just a matter of willpower. You’ve got to make the choice, how bad do you want it?”</p><p>But that’s antithetical to the entire concept. By definition, if it’s a matter of wanting it bad enough, you’d never need willpower in the first place. But desire and motivation are feelings, and feelings don’t go in a straight line like that. They are fickle and fleeting. Willpower is needed for when you explicitly <em>don’t</em> want it. (Or, in the case of junk food and drugs — when you crave the thing you’re trying to resist.)</p><p>It might seem like I’m just being picky and pedantic here, but there’s a real downside at stake. Namely, all of this suggests that we can simply grit our way through anything, through sheer force of determination, perseverance, willpower. If you <em>choose</em> to do so. If you really <em>want it.</em> Through this mindset, we begin to view failure as a choice as well as a result of not wanting to succeed bad enough. Success then, is also a choice, and a matter of achieving some vague pre-required level of desire. But how bad do you have to want success in order to achieve it? Seems to me the only answer anyone gives is “bad enough,” which is…pretty meaningless. How is anyone supposed to actually apply that advice in any sort of constructive manner?</p><p>Sure, maybe the sentiment works for motivation, when your football coach is trying to hype you up before a game or when you’re down by three touchdowns at halftime, but practically speaking, it might be one of the stupidest things I’ve ever heard. Actual success and failure looks nothing like that.</p><p>And here’s the wild part. <em>We know this.</em> We are fully aware of the amount of other stuff that goes into success. The knowledge, the planning, the organization, the diligence, the learning, the practice, the adaptation, the thought, the instinct, the circumstances. And we know that even if you do all of that stuff, you still might fail because you didn’t do it well enough, or someone else did it better than you or before you, or maybe you did everything perfectly and beyond expectation but things just didn’t break your way. Maybe your success was sheer dumb luck and maybe failure was too. Look around you, and you’ll see these things in action every day.</p><p>Yet we still stick to these platitudes, to the point where this is how we truly think of, and talk about, success, even when we know the reality is far more complex. And I’m not sure why. My best guess is that when we say these things we sound strong, we feel strong, and people will recognize us as strong. Maybe if we say them enough, we’ll actually <em>be</em> strong. And there’s value to that! A strong mindset and a confident self-image is an important part of handling any situation you find yourself in. But when we mistake motivational platitudes for real life procedures of success — that is, functional actions we take in order to reach our goals — we damn ourselves to failure. We associate success with willpower, even when it doesn’t apply. Determination? Sure. If you’re not motivated to do something you’ll never do it. Resilience? Yep. You gotta pick yourself back up and try again when things go wrong. But <em>willpower?</em></p><p>Okay, yes, sometimes willpower. But the thing is, a lot of things take a lot of willpower—more than the majority of us have the capacity for—and as such, it’s not something we can rely on. Think of it like anything else. You don’t blame the circuit breaker for blowing a fuse because you plugged twenty counter appliances into one kitchen outlet. You don’t blame your muscles for tearing into a hernia because you tried to lift a thousand pounds. And that’s probably because it’s all tangible. There’s a physical, observable cause and effect. Yet when it comes to our mental and emotional struggles—things that aren’t external or tangible—we just go “mind over matter,” like its fucking magic.</p><p>With this mindset, as well as our ability to conflate the finite resource of willpower with our level of determination, perseverance, and desire, it’s easy for us to look at failure or bad circumstances as an inherent fault of character. We can look at people like drug addicts and go, “This is their choice. They could stop if they just wanted to, but they don’t. They <em>want</em> to get high,” without ever considering what is actually, realistically, functionally needed for their successful recovery. We take for granted that if people deserve success, then they’ll get it, and if they don’t, they won’t.</p><p>For those who have never experienced withdrawal, consider hunger. Not that “oh I could use a little snack” bullshit. I’m talking about the deep, nauseating, feel-like-you’re-going-to-vomit hunger. It’s horrible, right? Now imagine feeling that in every cell in your body, each one screaming for relief. It’s a process that wrecks havoc on your system, both mentally and physically, and it doesn’t last for one training session. It’s not going to stop once you push out two more reps on the bench press. It can go on for days. It can be so intense that for some substances, stopping cold turkey risks killing you outright. And even when you get through that major hurdle, most addicts have been using for so long, they need to relearn how to interact and cope with the world — with life itself — with all the anxiety and poor functioning that aimlessness and helplessness can bring. That’s why it’s so easy to fall back into abuse. Heroin specifically is famous for making you feel better than you ever have or ever will, in a way that someone who’s never used it wouldn’t be able to imagine. And we expect people to just push through that? Most of us can’t even eat a fucking salad for lunch more than two days in a row.</p><p>If getting off drugs were simply a matter of willpower or personal strength or any of that, nobody would get clean. If getting off drugs were a matter of simply wanting to do so, almost every one would. “Suck it up and get it done” simply does not apply here. What you’re asking of people in this situation is Herculean. You might as well tell them to hold their breath until they die. That’s about what the recovery process feels like anyway.</p><p>Addiction and recovery is one example, but on a larger scale, this is a detriment to our society itself. When we measure worth and character by what a person is able to endure, we put no value in making things better. We’re actually incetivized to make things worse. The struggles of addiction, the struggles of poverty , the struggles of anything, really — we have the same answer to them all: Suck it up. Rise to the occasion. And if you can’t or don’t, then you weren’t worth a damn anyway.</p><p>That is <em>bonkers.</em></p><p>Personal willpower is only one necessary tool out of many at our disposal, and we need all of them to succeed. It doesn’t matter how hard you work or how much determination and willpower you display if effort is the only thing you have. This applies from the drug house all the way to corporate America.</p><p>It doesn’t matter how desperately you want to kick your addiction, if you don’t find an ironclad support system and adequate mental healthcare, you’re likely to relapse.</p><p>It doesn’t matter if you’re the most persistent cold-calling, fast-talking, businessman since Alec Baldwin introduced himself as “Fuck you,” in <em>Glengarry Glenn Ross</em>, your company will crash and burn if your business strategy doesn’t meet the needs of the market.</p><p>Those things won’t suddenly succeed because you <em>tried, tried, and tried again. </em>You’ll just keep spinning your tires, wondering why all your efforts refuse to pay off even though everyone said they were supposed to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4abccc113e6b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Aren’t in Control of Anything (Including Ourselves)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/we-arent-in-control-of-anything-including-ourselves-ff596110d0c7?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff596110d0c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-awareness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[determinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Dec 2021 17:09:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-12T19:14:19.226Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The belief that our future has many possibilities is based on a set of subjective assumptions.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DrUpxgQCi6JOAX0CiRBbdA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@photosantiago">Daniel Santiago</a></figcaption></figure><p>The subjective experience of people is, to say the least, incredibly strong. Not only that, it’s necessary to our survival as a species, so there’s really no getting around it. No matter how much we learn, no matter how much objectivity or logic or science points to one thing, our subjective experience will always win out. It’s baked in. I’m stating this to make clear that I don’t expect or intend to change your worldview with anything that follows this intro. I don’t think I can. Not with something like this, anyway. Hell, this is my own<em> </em>accepted logic and belief system we’re talking about here, and it’s still done absolutely nothing to alter my own subjective experience. That’s how remarkably strong our subjective experiences are.</p><p>Especially this one.</p><p>There are two things I think we can agree are absolute facts.</p><p>The first is that you have a definitive past. The things you have done and experienced are there and unexchangeable. Your recollection of those events may be imperfect, they may differ from someone else’s, but they are things that happened, and you have no power to go back and change them.</p><p>The second is that you have a definitive present. Right this very moment, you are reading these words. And every present moment you will have will also be definitive.</p><p>Yet for some reason, even though we have a definitive past and a definitive present, we don’t view the future that way. In fact, most modes of thought view the future as strictly non-definitive. Undetermined. We can choose to do anything. We can make our future whatever we want based on those choices.</p><p>Assuming you’re reading this on your phone, let’s look at some options for your future self: you can choose to keep reading, you can choose to switch to a different app, you can choose to throw your phone into the wall, or even just howl like a wolf. You — literally — can do anything you want with the next moment.</p><p>So.</p><p>What did you do?</p><p>Obviously if you got far enough to read that question, you’re still reading. (Admittedly, this isn’t the best format for that hypothetical.) Maybe you put the phone down to use the bathroom and then came back. Or you tossed the phone in the air just to be a smart ass (no judgment here, I personally would’ve howled).</p><p>Now here’s what I’d like to know. <em>Why </em>did you choose that? And more importantly, why didn’t you choose anything different? That’s assuming you chose anything at all. Maybe you did something completely by reflex — smiled or furrowed your brow or laughed or blurted out something mean about the idiot writing this stupid thing.</p><p>But even more importantly, could you envision yourself doing anything other than what you did?</p><p>I imagine the answer to that last, most important question, is a resounding yes. Maybe not in this case (if I’m reading something, I tend to keep reading it), but try this with other scenarios. I know it’s still a yes for me. I spend most of my life in some sort of internal conflict or state of indecision. I think too much, too carefully about most things I do. I spend too much energy on being measured and deliberate. So of course I can envision myself making different decisions. I nearly make a different one each time I have to.</p><p>But I don’t actually know that I would. It’s an assumption.</p><p>Since it’s impossible to go back and try out something different, you’ll never really know if you would have. It’s an experiment that can never be replicated. You might <em>wish</em> you could change things, if you end up doing something regrettable, but that’s only in hindsight. But all things being the same, in that exact moment, in that exact frame of mind, would you really do something different? And why would you? For sake of argument, let’s say that’s the case. If everything were precisely the same, what would cause the difference?</p><p>I parse this thought process to establish that the idea of an undetermined future is something we take for granted. But we don’t actually know that. We know we are individuals, we know we feel like we have free will, and we know we’re told, by pretty much everyone, that we are in charge of our life and we control our fate. We know that we’re told as kids that when we grow up, we can be whatever we want to be. And we believe it, because that’s how we experience it. We’re not just popping around like pinballs coming out of a chute. We know we make our own decisions.</p><p>When you add all that knowledge up, of course our future is undetermined. Of course it is in our control.</p><p>Hate to break it to you, but that is still an assumption. It’s an assumption based on information, true, and it’s not an unreasonable conclusion. But there’s a case to be made for the alternative that is rooted in a firmer logic. And it starts with what I implied earlier:</p><ol><li>A cause has an effect. If you do not change the cause, you cannot change the effect, and since the cause is our past, it cannot be changed.</li><li>You will only make one choice, and thus you can only have one future.</li></ol><p>To be clear, we do determine our future in the literal sense. What you do now will determine later, or at least influence it (or at least try to). You’ll never hear me say differently. The prepared person, generally speaking, has the most success. This isn’t about that. What this is really about is how we make decisions in our definitive present, or rather, how our decisions are determined enough that they are practically already made. How we would never do anything else, and how it was always going to be this way.</p><p>We aren’t born as blank slates. Each person in them has seeds of attributes, and from the beginning, some of those seeds have naturally sprouted, due to genetics as well as probably a whole nightmare of things that I’m grateful science has yet to uncover about things couples who are expecting a child should and shouldn’t do (the list is already anxiety inducing enough). This is our nature. Meanwhile, our environment — which includes everything: family, friends, neighborhood, socioeconomic status, the works — and life experiences decide which of the other seeds get watered and nurtured to bloom. If you’re especially lucky, all the bad seeds get left alone, and if you’re the luckiest, they’re absent altogether. (Most people, in my experience, are mildly lucky, but that’s neither here nor there.)</p><p>But this is where your individual pattern begins. In your very early childhood, before our higher minds take over, the naturally sprouted seeds really show off and direct how we behave in our environment. How we behave then influences how our environment responds to us (in coordination with the characteristics of the environment) which then determines which seeds get watered.</p><p>As we get older, some of the things we learn from our environment become conscious lessons, some become a part of our learned instincts. The ways these lessons combine to form the person we become have vast potential.</p><p>I’ve focused on overviewing the development of identity and personality for two reasons. The first is that external cause and effect is more readily apparent. We see it happen everyday. As a species, we’re generally good at picking up patterns, particularly after coming across them a few times. That ability is how our environments are able to influence and shape us in the first place. The second reason is that the biggest hang-up with the idea of determination is how it fits in with our subjective experience of control and autonomy; since many of us feel so staunchly like our behavior and choices are the result of our own selves, it’s important to understand that who you are as a person has very little to do with you at all. We are the result of our experiences, mixed with our nature. The way we feel, think, and behave are not of our own making.</p><p>This applies even if you are a person who does take control. Let’s say you went to therapy in order get help with harmful thoughts, feelings, or behaviors. In order to do that, you first had to be the type of person open to therapy, either by your nature or by an experience making you open to it — whether that be the way you were raised or something that happened later in life. You’ve surely heard of alcoholics who get sober only after they’ve hit their “rock bottom.” It wasn’t that they didn’t know they needed to get sober before then — I say this as a recovering alcoholic myself who has gone through all of this and sat in those meetings with many others — it’s that who they were as people were not capable of sobriety until they bottomed out. That experience was powerful enough to jar their thoughts, feelings, and behavior. (I should note just for the record: this is just one type of alcoholic/addict. Not all of them actually have to hit rock bottom before they are able to get clean and sober, not that “rock bottom” looks the same for everyone, anyway. Everyone has their own standard for it, and none are right or wrong.)</p><p>The process that a person goes through to be who they are, from their birth to their present moment, is complex, and when you factor in that this has happened with every single person, every single moment of every single life, and all those people are colliding with each other to create the external causes and effects that happen alongside the internal ones, it’s not something we can fully dissect. It’s a flow chart that we could never be able to make or, even if it was put in front of us, ever be able to track.</p><p>But we <em>can </em>create a small-scale model of it, in just one moment. (We could actually create a rather large model of it to really highlight how well this logic fits within all sorts of variables and complexities, but in the spirit of keeping this discussion within a reasonable length, let’s keep it simple).</p><p>So here it is:</p><p>You’re stuck in traffic, and you have a choice. Stay put and wait it out, or take the exit a quarter mile up to go the back way home. What do you do? If you had a shitty day, maybe the idea of being in a nice quiet car with nothing going on sounds like a nice reprieve, so you’ll stay. Or maybe, due to the way your seeds grew, having a shitty day means you get impatient and want to just get the fuck home. Or there’s something at home that will help you relax. Maybe your day was fine but you have to pee and need to hurry on ahead. Or, as a general principle, you’ll always pick the long way home when you can stay moving versus the route that still takes less time but means spending half your drive at a standstill.</p><p>While you have options at your disposal, who you are in this moment, and where your mind, body, and emotions are in this moment, will determine how you interact with this situation — with this environment — and you will ultimately take one real, definitive action, the result of every single one of these details present, even the ones you aren’t aware of, including everything about who you are in this moment, which was then shaped by all of your experiences leading up to this, from the seeds sprouted in you by nature, to the environments that nurtured the others, to the day you just had. This moment you are in right now is the only moment you will ever be here; it is the only moment that this exact, hyper-specific combination of details will be present at once. Everything has led up to this. It’s up to you. You either stay in traffic, or you take the back way home. (Or, I suppose, you could do anything else, too. You could lose your mind, slow traffic being the last straw to make you go berserk and strip naked, running and screaming through the street, but even then, my point will still stand, so again, let’s just keep it simple.)</p><p>You might look at this and say, “See, the future is not determined. It hasn’t happened yet, and I’m deciding it right now.”</p><p>This is where I’d like to point out that the choice you’re making is in a situation so wildly outside of your control that the thought of you having as much of a say over your future in the way we often feel like we do should be put right out to pasture. The wide magnitude of things that led to you being stuck in traffic on this very day alone could fill a whole book on their own, from the design of the road to the weather conditions to the economic demands and life patterns that led to the 9–5 work day to the psychology of driver efficiency (and why traffic jams happen at all on open highways with no discernible cause) to the behavior of the other drivers around you based on everything happening in their life in a pattern just as complex as yours. All these things, all far beyond the reach of your control.</p><p>But you do have a decision to make, and this one little decision is your sole contribution to your future. You’re going to decide, and you will have a reason for your decision. I know when people say “everything happens for a reason,” they are referring to either serendipity, or that there will be a future trade-off for whatever hard time you’re going through, but I prefer the other, opposite reading of that line, which is: nothing is random. It happened for a reason. There is always a cause to the effect.</p><p>And if nothing is causing you to stay, while everything is causing you to leave, then you will get off on the next exit. If you’re torn between the two options, because you have reasons for both, one of the reasons will win, and that’ll depend, again, on who you are in the moment. It’s a self-perpetuating cycle.</p><p>In order for your future to have more than one possibility, you would need for there to be more than one set of present details. And because that’s not possible, you will ultimately make the decision you were always going to make. Run the scenario a septillion times, unless you change one of the details, you will always get the same result. And it can take just one detail change. Just one tiny detail can absolutely make the difference. But not always. And also, it’s already happened. What’s done is done. There will never be an opportunity for a changed detail. You couldn’t change one even if you wanted to, because our brains are always one step behind. They are <em>always </em>responding to what just happened, even a split second in the past. But whether it’s ten milliseconds or ten years, the past is the past, and it is locked, definitive. There is no changing details without moving forward, yet another effect of a moment becoming another piece of the cause of the next. (On the surface, it may seem like the scientific method pushes back against this idea, considering that a large part of it is observing different effects with the same cause, but I disagree. The power of the scientific method is that it pinpoints specific cause and effect relationships, slowly but surely adding to that ever expanding flow chart and our understanding of existence.)</p><p>When this exact process is happening to every single person every single moment of their lives, it all looks random. But it isn’t.</p><p>It’s just that <em>precise</em>. Because randomness…doesn’t actually exist in your life. Not the way you think it does, in the practical sense.</p><p>Okay, so by definition, yes randomness exists. Random means something that is done, chosen etc., without method. Something that is not a deliberate, conscious decision. Something that does not follow any sort of discernible pattern, we also treat as random, even though that isn’t the explicitly correct usage. But that’s not true randomness in the scientific sense. In fact, there’s even a term used to describe things that appear random but actually aren’t. <em>Pseudorandom.</em></p><p>Things like rolling a dice, shuffling a deck of cards, drawing names out of a hat, flipping a coin, or using a random number generator are all pseudorandom. We only refer to them as random because they are the closest we can get to it, but true randomness, if it exists at all, only does so on the subatomic level. And I don’t think I need to tell you, but you’re not doing jack shit at the subatomic level. (Not consciously, anyway. There <em>is</em> quantum activity in our brain that shapes molecules and fires neurons, but what that means for us in terms of thoughts, feelings, behaviors, and cause and effect is, scientifically, a long way away. It’s obviously more complicated than this one sentence summary, but you can look it all up yourself like I had to before I wrote this, to make sure I wasn’t completely full of shit.)</p><p>Oddly enough, for as much as we feel in control of our lives, the idea of randomness comes into play pretty often. When we’re not telling people their future is what they make it, we’re hopping to the other side of the fence to say “anything could happen.” And yes, when you don’t know what’s coming next, anything really <em>could </em>happen. I’d even go so far as to say that’s one of the reasons we like the idea of randomness to begin with — to give us a break from all this control we have. To spice things up. <em>Anything could happen!</em> It keeps us on the edge of our seats during sporting events, it gives gamblers hope, and it basically helps us get through the day (when it’s not also contributing to an anxiety of the unknown).</p><p>Of course, this sentiment also implies that anything outside of our own actions is largely up to some cosmic role of the dice. We’re either in control, or it’s totally random. Anything, anything, <em>anything</em> could happen.</p><p>Except that’s an assumption too. If the causes are in the past, and the past is definitive, then, even assuming room for error, the effect must be, at the very least, severely limited. The effect can surprise us, excite us, and <em>feel</em> like a freak occurrence, but it’s not. Just because we can’t predict the future doesn’t mean it’s a game of chance and a matter of manipulating that chance through things like work ethic or sheer force of will. Yes, hard work can be the cause that influences the effect, but your work ethic is also an effect with a cause. It’s also far, far from the only relevant factor at hand.</p><p>We are so preoccupied with trying to crack the code of the future, we have a whole mathematical school of thought and an entire industry built around statistics. We track weather, we look at traffic reports, put disclaimers anywhere we can fit them, and we watch pregame shows so sports commentators can guess how games will go. We don’t like not knowing what’s coming, and we respond to that feeling in three unique (but not mutually exclusive) ways: we try to predict it, we try to influence it, or we throw our hands up and bank on faith that things will be okay. And on the whole, we’re pretty good at all three of those. Anything other than the idea that the future is just as definitive as our past or our present.</p><p>But…what if we <em>could</em> predict the future?</p><p>I’m not saying we can. That wasn’t a ramp up to some sales pitch. But it is a real question. What if we could predict the future? If you could go through life knowing exactly what was going to happen, what would you do? What choices would you make differently? What would you change?</p><p>The answer is absolutely nothing. You might try. Especially if your future was gruesome, then yes you definitely would. But it wouldn’t matter. Because that knowledge of the future is now a part of the cause that creates an effect that leads you to a moment. It will still lead you to where you were always going.</p><p>Let’s say you had a machine that showed you a vision of your future. Not your future in the abstract, but the definitive, one, true, eventual future. Not your current trajectory, not the most likely outcome. The Future.</p><p>You would do the exact same things and make the exact same decisions, no matter how seemingly in control of the outcome you might believe yourself to be.</p><p>Let’s say you used that machine while you were stuck in traffic, and it showed you that you’re going to get off on the next exit, come around the ramp, and there will be a deer in the road. You’ll swerve to avoid the deer, bounce over the guard rail, down into the embankment below, and you’ll die in a fiery blaze.</p><p>Sorry. That’s what’s going to happen. Because again, the machine didn’t show you a possibility of the future, it showed you your <em>definitive</em> future. And you can only have one. Eventually a decision is made, an action is taken. The future that feels open will become your definitive present. And that’s yours. Deer, swerve, embankment, torturous demise. Even if you know it will happen, when it will happen, and how it will happen.</p><p>So even knowing all that, why would it still happen? Why would you make all the same choices?</p><p><em>Why do you think it’s up to you at all?</em></p><p>Because it <em>feels </em>that way? So what?</p><p>The answer to these questions are as wide and varying as as there are people. Maybe the machine showed you what would happen and in a moment of hubris you said “nah fuck that machine, I’ll prepare for what’s coming,” and then you round the bend and panic grips you as you see the deer, causing you to reflexively jerk the wheel to the side. Maybe you thought you panicked in the vision the machine showed you because the deer scared you — turns out it was because you knew what the machine showed you was definitive and <em>that</em> sent you into a panic when confronting the moment. Or…well, anything else. Maybe you convinced yourself it was all bullshit and just went along as though you had no knowledge at all. Truthfully, I have no idea why it would still happen. This is a broad hypothetical. All I know is that you only have one eventual future and if you saw what it’s going be, you would still do everything exactly as shown.</p><p>So clearly, all of this shows with absolute proof, beyond a doubt, that our future is determined, right?</p><p>Well, no. Of course it doesn’t. Remember back to what I said near the beginning of this. The idea that we have control over our future is based on subjective assumptions while determination is rooted in a firmer logic. Here’s the key point: <em>firmer</em> logic. Not completely firm, though. I’m still making a couple of assumptions that I’d be dishonest not to highlight.</p><p>I mentioned before that the cause-and-effect pattern is something that we would not able to decipher. It is a flow chart that we could never make and even if it was presented to us we could never track. With something that expansive and complicated, it is highly likely (almost guaranteed) that there are workings at play beyond our awareness. I am assuming the properties of cause and effect can be applied because based on what we do know, logically, they should.</p><p>But I don’t know what I don’t know.</p><p>The second assumption involves the possibility of randomness on a subatomic, quantum level and how that affects us, if at all. I’m no expert, and even the people who know the most about this are still in relatively early stages of understanding the science and unlocking answers to how the universe works. Which is all to ask, does the true randomness that exists on the subatomic level impact our day to day lives in small indiscernible ways? Or does it bend the broad trajectory of our life or, even more broadly, the trajectory of human development? Are there large, sudden occurrences of randomness that shifts our paths in all new directions?</p><p>I don’t know, and best I can find, nobody else really does either. The consensus does seem to be that quantum randomness is truly random, but even then, there’s a school of thought that hypothesizes it isn’t. That even quantum activity follows a determinism we’ve yet to identify.</p><p>So yes, I’m still taking a few things for granted. However, the difference to note here is that the things I’m taking for granted are not the result of subjective assumptions, and as such, I don’t think they should be weighed quite as equally. The reason is that subjective assumptions are made to account only for the incredibly narrow view of our own personal experience, while the assumptions I’m making here account for things entirely outside of our personal experience and even science itself as we know it. That is, subjective assumptions treat our experience as everything, while the assumptions of determinism acknowledges things that not only do we not know, but may never be capable of knowing. They are assumptions which must be made, and being that they fit cleanly into our basic principles of logic, are notably safer than those of our subjective experience.</p><p>So what does all this mean to you? What’s the point of all this if, by my own admission, holding this belief has done nothing to change my subjective experience?</p><p>Let me elaborate on what I mean when I say my subjective experience has gone unchanged.</p><p>In short, I still fret about things. I still overthink most of the decisions in my life, I still get anxious over the unknown, I still work towards goals all in the hopes of influencing the possibilities of my eventual future to be a fortunate one even as I believe there is only one in the first place. My life and my future still very much needs to feel like there is order, and it’s very likely that this need has pushed me to consider the merits of determination, be more open to it, and even put value in it, the same way I imagine that the people who need to feel like everything is chaos and up for grabs will be the first to reject the notion.</p><p>I also spend a great deal of mental energy assessing all of the what-if scenarios of my life, which typically involves a significant amount of regret, because for some reason, this what-if train of thought never involves the <em>good</em> decisions I make, which might actually lead to gratitude (but hey, that’s anxiety for you).</p><p>Despite putting stock in the idea of determinism, I still do all of these things, even when intellectually, I don’t believe I need to. But that’s alright, too. Because it’s just who I am. It’s the way that I’m built, at the core of my being.</p><p>And besides, none of this is to say that self-reflection doesn’t have merit — in fact I think it’s one of the most important things a person can do — but maybe the larger point is that it’s alright to just give ourselves a break. Sure, maybe you fucked up in some scenario that keeps playing in your head over and over again, and it’d be good to learn from that, but also, take some comfort in the knowledge that, logically speaking, it was always going to go that way, and at worst, only a fraction of it was actually within your control. Still take responsibility, of course, still hold yourself accountable — that will always be important — but once you do that, move on.</p><p>That’s my big take away from it, at least. I don’t know what it’ll do for you, but maybe something. That’s up to you. In truth, it really doesn’t matter how I wrap this up. You’re going to do with it what you were always going to do anyway.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff596110d0c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Need For Consistency is Sabotaging Us]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joshzancan/our-need-for-consistency-is-sabotaging-us-639c7f60570c?source=rss-b5590684d17e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/639c7f60570c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Josh Zancan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Dec 2021 04:20:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-06T05:21:56.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The world is becoming exponentially more complex. It’s more than our minds know how to handle.</h4><p>If there’s one thing that binds us as humans, it’s…well, a lot of things. Most things, actually, at least on an internal level. Strip away all societal and socio-economic hangups, and we have pretty much everything in common, not the least of which is our instinct to focus on the ways in which we differ. The different ways we mix with the world. But there’s one bit I want to focus on, which seems to me to be one of the more defining traits of being human (perhaps even being a living organism at all), and that is we all pretty much want shit to stay exactly the same. Yes, even if you hate the way things are and yes, even if you’re striving for change. I know, it sounds stupid, but if this whole thing could be summed up in one sentence like that I wouldn’t even be writing this in the first place.</p><p>Also, right off the bat, I’m not talking about our taste for variety. Yes, there are the people who will go to the airport, buy a ticket for the first available flight and just go wherever it takes them, and that certainly shakes things up. It’s absolutely spontaneous and different, but I’d also bet my entire years salary that they’re only willing to do that because of…consistency. They know that whatever city they land in there will be a hotel for them to stay at. They’ll have access to most accommodations that they’re used to having, and even if they forget half the stuff they need for the trip, there’ll probably be a Target or Super Walmart within driving distance. And even if not, they will at least land in a place that, I presume, will have food and electricity.</p><p>So sure, spontaneous, but not inconsistent, in that it doesn’t threaten their understanding of how to meet their basic needs or even how to function.</p><p>The closest you could probably get is to go to a country without a plan or basic understanding of the language or culture, but I promise you, it’ll be a really miserable time. Fish out of water stories are only funny for the audience. The main character is usually pretty frustrated. Because nothing is consistent with how they know how to be.</p><p>We have such a deep mental and emotional need for consistency in our environment because it allows us to track whether or not our surroundings are safe, the way you can predict signs of trouble in your home by the out of place smell. You can only do that if you know what smell is supposed to be there. And even if our environment is unpleasant or hostile, as long as it’s consistent, we’ll know how to deal with the dangers. This type of reliability is one of the many reasons people give when they explain why they stayed in a bad (or even abusive) relationship. It isn’t that they just loved struggling to find fulfillment in a joyless partnership, its that no matter how bad things got, leaving it behind seemed worse. Even in instances of outright toxicity, they established a life and a routine and learned how to navigate those volatile waters, knowing exactly where their partner’s triggers were and carefully stepping around them. It’s horrifying and sad and they hated it, but at least they knew what to expect, unlike the moment it came time to step out the door into the huge unknown of whatever else life would bring. It can take <em>years</em> for people to will themselves to make that type of adjustment. <em>And that’s in response to something they actively despise. </em>So imagine how hard it can be with everything else.</p><p>You can see traces of this pretty much anywhere you find discontentment. There’s a whole industry and culture dealing with people who want to lose weight, and that wouldn’t happen if changing your diet were an easy long-term endeavor, but we have a habit of reverting back to…well, our habits. We’re so stuck on consistency, we’ll stay with the familiarly unhappy (or even dangerous) rather than whatever is on the outside of it, known or unknown, even when we know it will be a good thing.</p><p>But it’s not like we can just go around making absolutely no sense whatsoever like that. Our brain would cave in on itself. Because we don’t just need our environments to be consistent, we need us to be consistent as well. The only issue with that is, um…we’re not. Like, we are fucking terrible at it. As a result, we’ve developed a whole slew of psychological defense mechanisms that help us live with our own inconsistencies — often by preventing us from acknowledging them whatsoever. (Not, at least, without a LOT of mental effort, assuming the given individual is capable of doing so at all.)</p><p>You might figure, evolutionarily, it would be more advantageous if we just evolved to be the way we need to be and forgo all this stuff in the first place, but here’s the thing: if we did that, we’d have died — to use a very scientific term — almost fucking immediately. When you’re out there living off the land, where the latest human advancement is learning how to build a fire, being able to adapt your behavior on the fly is pretty important. Being able to do that without getting into a mental jam is hard, because, well, it’s easy to get hung up on the details.</p><p>Cognitive dissonance and the resulting defense mechanisms (rationalization, projection, denial, and all other forms of mental gymnastics) are probably best known nowadays as the things you bring up in an internet debate to drop the mic and deem another person’s worldview entirely invalid, but they’re actually pretty remarkable. If you, with your consistency-craving brain, had to make any adjustment within yourself to adapt to life, but were forced to do so without a psychologically built-in way to automatically reconcile any discrepancy in your thoughts or behavior (or more importantly, between your thoughts and behavior) how could you possibly cope with yourself? Your brain would be practically incapable of achieving the very thing it relies on. That’s like being a heroin addict who never stops needing a fix existing in a body that doesn’t respond to heroin. (Or, if drugs are outside of your purview, imagine having an insatiable need for the taste of chocolate without the ability to taste chocolate.) You would absolutely crumble, physically, mentally, and emotionally.</p><p>Or put another way, your defense mechanisms are literally responsible for not letting you view yourself with the same outside perspective you view the world, and it plays a massive role in your ability to function.</p><p>This suggests that three key factors in our survival as a species have been the ability to have a) a consistent external life (to keep things predictable, and thus safe), b) an inconsistent internal life (so we can adapt to any situation for any reason any time we need to no matter what), and c) a blind trust in whatever happens inside our own head (because doubt leads to hesitation which leads to a wild animal taking our leg home for dinner). And it seems to me that trying to balance this shit out has probably played a huge role in every problem we’ve ever had between people.</p><p>You may have noticed that these three things are in many ways at direct odds with each other. If your brain can let you adapt to any situation no matter what, why would you need all this consistency in your environment? Why would leaving that shitty relationship or changing your diet be so hard? And even if you do act on these things, how long is it until you’re texting your ex at 2 am to see if they’re still awake? How long until you’re back to eating French fries by the bag full, all fears of clogged arteries left by the wayside?</p><p>Your brain isn’t adapting so you can change. It’s adapting so you never have to, and it’s the whole reason you’re able to trust your thoughts, feelings, and instincts in the first place. You’ve proven yourself reliable, the cause and effect safe and predictable. Consistency!</p><p>So okay, that’s all well and good. I mean, it’s weird and wonky, and your brain is lying to you so you don’t go insane, but my alarmism aside, in your personal, everyday life, the process is probably serving you fine. It’s keeping you on track. When you do have conflict with someone, there’s usually a conversation to be had, something to work through, to explain perspectives, and you both can use the other to sort out your thoughts, maybe see where you might be wrong, maybe articulate a point to them, and most importantly, you’re probably doing this with someone you care about, someone you love and trust. The end result is two people coming together to reach the best outcome they can while also coexisting in a relationship (whether that be platonic, romantic, professional, etc., they all apply).</p><p>This works best on a smaller scale because that was its purpose, to benefit your everyday life and make sure you’re able to get to the next day. It’s when you zoom out to the broader world that things start to go haywire. Where the basic, mostly easy to navigate human hangups take on identities of their own, and these built-in psychological mechanisms that have kept us functioning for all these years are given a stress test. And unfortunately, I think they’re failing.</p><p>The easiest example of this is politics (but it could be any major social construct, especially the ones that exist on the internet), where your brain is working overtime to combat the inconsistencies of the world while protecting the inconsistencies of itself. If you’re conservative, those dumb liberals talk about “my body, my choice” when it comes to abortion but not vaccine mandates. If you’re liberal, those evil conservatives try to control women but when it comes to the vaccine all of a sudden they’re going, “my body, my choice, what happened to that?” The result is both sides bitching at each other for being hypocrites, and then…that’s it. The process just stalls, and it does so because we need consistency so bad, the conversation can’t move forward until the inconsistencies are resolved, like glitches in a software. Our brain doesn’t know what else to do with information it perceives as incompatible except reject it, so we just keep going back and forth over the same points trying to iron out the bugs each time. This is simple enough with your friends, but when the conversation is happening in a public forum, nothing moves forward, nothing is gained, everyone stays angry.</p><p>There are legitimate reasons why discrepancies happen. Inconsistencies can be accounted for. The world is complex, most things are messy, and these things don’t exist in a vacuum, but when it never goes beyond attack and defense, none of that matters. We create the vacuum. And therein lies the breakdown of our survival instincts and defense mechanisms happening on such a huge scale. The only way to move forward is to reconcile the inconsistencies, but the only way to work out the inconsistencies is to move the conversation forward.</p><p>Unfortunately, our defenses mechanisms are too good at what they do. Rejecting the information means pushing back against it, and convincing someone who doesn’t like you that their views and values are inconsistent is about as likely as someone strangling themselves to death with their own bare hands. We are mentally wired for both of those endeavors to not work. Bypassing our own defenses is a lofty enough goal; doing so in response to the threatening out-group is downright radical.</p><p>And while we call out the conflicting views around us and seek some form of reconciliation, within our own selves…we don’t. We don’t <em>need</em> to. And we don’t need to because (drumroll, please…) that’s just not how it works! We don’t need to do anything. We can think whatever we want and be whatever we want. And that’s not hubris, it’s a natural blind spot. No matter how ostensibly hypocritical or objectively and rhetorically inconsistent, our thoughts and feelings will always seem perfectly reasonable and fine to us for no real reason other than that’s just how it works. It’s automatic, built-in, free. Inner consistency achieved, the reality of that sentiment be damned.</p><p>But here’s the thing. It’s something that may put a lot of this into perspective, and it applies everywhere, from your personal relationships to Twitter to the presidential debate stage. The things that we talk about are very rarely the heart of the matter. We focus on ideals and values and virtues, and all of these things that exist in the abstract, so much so that you can often apply them almost wherever you like. Returning to the earlier example, if people were truly advocates for bodily autonomy as a principle — that is, if that were truly the value that influenced everything else — then the anti-mandate crowd would immediately become pro-choice and vice-versa. But…I get the sense that’s not going to happen anytime soon. Because it’s not about that. What it’s about is, one side wants you to have to get vaccinated and the other side doesn’t. One side wants you to be able to have an abortion and the other side doesn’t. Full stop. The ideals surrounding those positions, even if they start off in good faith, eventually become a means to an end to apply or ignore as required. We’ll believe them deeply for as long as they’re useful, drop them the second they’re not, and switch back and forth as often as we need to. (One could even say this is the mental adaptation that takes place so we don’t have to change. It’s much easier for our brain to adjust what our values mean to us and where they apply than go along with something we disagree with.) That may seem over-simplistic or reductionistic or even downright dumb, but that’s really all there is to it. Yes, every person has their own real, legitimate reasons for holding the views that they do. Compelling reasons, even. None of this is to say that there is no such thing as objective logic or constructive critical thought or processes of the higher mind, or even that ideals and values aren’t worth anything (they are!), only that once the lizard brain gets involved, it tends to win. People want what they want — usually because it’s the thing that makes them feel safe— and fuck off with anything that prevents them from getting it.</p><p>And this applies to <em>everything</em>. Gun laws, the war on drugs, the economy, religion, social issues, sports teams, movie franchises, whether or not a hot dog is a sandwich. If we really lived in a self-aware, self-honest world, everything would be yea, nay, or abstain, and we wouldn’t bother with rhetoric at all. But what people want, they really, really want, so if you have to believe that children being murdered in their classrooms is a government hoax to take your guns, well that’s just how it’s going to have to be. Especially when the alternative is <em>maybe that shooter shouldn’t have been able to have a gun.</em> But if that idea doesn’t mesh with who you are, then fuck that in favor of literally anything else.</p><p>As a result, it’s easy for our reasoning to start getting reverse engineered, the higher mind being manipulated by the lizard one, without us even realizing it. It starts with what you want and the rest gets tacked on later as needed (the standard of which being defined by the individual or group), until something else comes in and appeals directly to our inner-lizard. Then <em>that </em>becomes our new thing. New feeling, new belief, new rationale, conspiracy theory, whatever. Persuasion is not found in logic or reason, and rarely has been. It exists in the things that give the lizard what it needs. Need to feel safe? Strong? Seen? Smart? Like a proper REAL AMERICAN PATRIOT? There’s a reason politicians are the way they are, grabbing headlines with grandstanding histrionics and emotion-stirring rhetoric, instead of the boring nerds they probably should be.</p><p>This isn’t a judgment on anyone or any view, it’s literally human nature. Our entire existence has been reacting to survive then worrying about whether or not it was the right thing to do later (in case I need to reiterate: it almost always will be, according to you). A cop who shoots a fleeing suspect in the back may very likely believe that his life was in danger. Maybe he did in the moment too, maybe he didn’t, but either way, the odds are high that he truly believes it afterwards. He’s not lying, his brain just did what it’s supposed to do. It made sure his reality fit what he needed it to be (even if that meant altering it completely). That might sound terrifying, particularly in that specific context, but it becomes even more unsettling when you acknowledge that not only does everyone do this, but it is a huge reason why we made it this far as a species in the first place. When we were being chased through the wilderness by a sabertooth tiger we didn’t have time to think of the nuanced ramifications of our escape methods. If we had to decide whether that stranger outside our camp we’ve never seen, from a tribe we don’t know or trust, deserved to get pelted with a warning rock, there was never a concern about gaining some perspective on the moment. We had to just do what felt right and figure out why later. And usually “figuring it out” meant “well, I did the thing, so it must’ve been the right thing,” or “it must’ve been the thing I wanted to do all along.” If a guy tells a girl he’s dating that he is in love with her just to expedite the sex part of the relationship, don’t be surprised if he actually starts to develop those deeper feelings. If he can’t justify the lie to himself in his own mind, then his mind will make sure it is no longer a lie. “I said it, so it must be true, otherwise I’m a liar, which I’m not.” (He doesn’t actually say this to himself, the whole point is that this is a subconscious process.)</p><p>That’s how you get all of these strands of thought and ask why they apply to one thing and not to the other, or how people allow themselves to do those sorts of mental gymnastics. Because we will do almost anything to avoid confronting ourselves. Rationalization, intellectualization, projection, displacement, denial, repression — these are the big ones that get thrown around the most, but the full list of defense mechanisms is longer than you might think. We’ve had millions of years to develop and perfect all of these and we made good use of that time. But really we’re just people trying to justify our own instincts, impulses, feelings, and yes, even our own cognitive dissonance. We’re appealing our wild, inconsistent, dissonant inner selves to the outside world and getting angry when it’s just as inconsistent (and even as arbitrary) as we are. Because we need both. We need the world to be consistent, and we need to have the leeway to be inconsistent. But, as that god-awful song says…we <em>are</em> the world. So none of this was ever going to pan out the way we need it to.</p><p>This has nothing to do with intelligence, by the way. None of us have the mental or emotional resources to counteract this beyond isolated moments of effort. To do anything different would take up our entire lives and use up all of our brain power, not to mention that going against your own instincts is fucking <em>stressful</em>.</p><p>I focused on bodily autonomy as an example earlier because as I write this we’re on the second threatening variant of COVID-19 and abortion rights are returning to the Supreme Court after Texas all but outlawed them (the same state that sued the Biden administration over vaccine mandates), so its the freshest thing in my mind, but let’s put all that aside for a second. We could spend a book’s length going over individual examples and breaking each nuanced variation of this dynamic down into their own categories, but holy shit. <em>Why</em>? Why should that be possible? Even with everything I’ve discussed so far, which I think provides a pretty good answer, it’s still baffling that this dynamic remains so prevalent even when it serves no real functional benefit on a mass scale. Why are these things that have allowed us to thrive as a species for so long hindering us so severely? At this point, I’m surprised we haven’t died of starvation figuring out what to eat for dinner. The only other thing that stands out to me is…</p><p>I don’t think we’ve always had this problem. For the vast majority of human existence we lived on dirt and rock. We slept inside of dirt and rock. Or clay or straw or sticks or whatever. Point is, the complexities of our society were, compared to today, practically nonexistent. We didn’t have to navigate large governmental beaurcracues or make medical decisions that 99.99% of us will never be educated enough on the subject matter to fully understand. Hell, a huge portion of our lives are affected by taxes — they are at the forefront of every election we‘ve ever held — but unless you’re a tax accountant, I double dare you to explain to me even half the scope of how that system works.</p><p>The fact is that our lives run on massive and in many cases global systems that a very, very tiny minuscule of people fully grasp. And even among those who can and do, they are experts in their one particular chosen field, and even then, experts often disagree. (Or in some cases, the illusion of disagreement is sowed to increase tension, ratings, web traffic, user retention, etc.)</p><p>So I’m sorry, were you looking for consistency?</p><p>And then there are the rest of us, making decisions and reasoning and debating over fragments of the available information and a fraction of that in understanding. I hate to break it to you, but while I’m sure that 3 minute TikTok you watched explaining mRNA vaccines was very informative, you still don’t know shit. Watch a 3 hour video on it, and…well are you really going to do that? Even if you do, you’ve still just barely scratched the surface.</p><p>And yet we’re still here, still needing to engage, still needing to make informed decisions (“informed”), still very affected by the decisions of everyone around us based on the fragment of information they receive, still very, gravely, devastatingly concerned with the reliability of our perceived reality.</p><p>None of us fully get it, nor should we be expected to. We weren’t meant to process so much information, let alone a constant feed of it, presented in vastly varying and often exploitative manners, combined with the social pressures of our in-group. And not only did we not have to handle any of this, we also didn’t have to negotiate it with every other person on the planet all shouting into their own personal megaphones. Our survival instincts and basic cognitive functions were designed for things like “hey, when I hit that animal with this rock it dies faster,” or “when I eat those berries I shit nonstop for like a week.”</p><p>See what I mean when I say this quest for consistency is why we’re so fucked up? Of course we are. We’re so far out of our depth, how can we not be?</p><p>The really fucked up thing though, is that we don’t have a choice. We’re literally built this way.</p><p>Ask yourself why you do half the shit you do. Outside of the fact that most of us are going off deeply ingrained lessons that our parents handed down to us as kids when they were 25 years old (yes, odds are you are a grown adult still living life based on what someone almost half your age said and did decades ago), you’re doing what feels familiar, and you probably always will. Even if you’re one of the few who spends their life embracing the emphatically unfamiliar, I suspect even that has become a source of habit and routine — or you just have ADHD and are bouncing from one hyper fixation to the next, but this isn’t about that. (And for those of you who have embarked, or are currently embarking, on a journey outside your comfort zone, through the unfamiliar, congratulations! It takes a ton of work and discipline and overcoming fears, and I wish you the best.)</p><p>The idea that we need to respect our elders aligns with this. It’s not just some vanity thing the boomers go on about. It used to be that you needed your elders to let you know which berries were going to obliterate your large intestine. If someone made it to 80 years old, that was the person to listen to, because they had acquired the knowledge it took to live that long. And that’s because even though life was vastly more difficult than any of us could ever imagine, it was consistent. Eat this berry, not that one; dig the soil like this; surround the mammoth like that. Survive.</p><p>Notice the lack of ideology present there. It’s a matter of pure function. There’s no virtue signaling going on, no discussion on whether the mainstream media is biased against certain types of fruit. That thing over there is bad because it will kill you, this other thing is good because it will keep you alive. That was the only goal then, and our brains still think it’s the only goal now, even though that fight to the death you got in last night was actually on Reddit, and it was about whether or not Cyberpunk 2077 deserves all the criticism. Your higher mind knows it really doesn’t matter to your survival, but the lizard inside you doesn’t. A threat is a threat, and threats need to be destroyed.</p><p>The question that I can’t shake is what happens when this gets too complex. Because it’s not like we’re slowing down at all. 2,000 years ago (which is a blip in the lifespan of humanity), anyone could explain to you most things about how to survive by the standards of their time, even though they couldn’t even read or write. And that was because they actually had to do most of those things themselves. But we’re advancing as a society at an exponential rate. It took 4,000 years to transition from a chariot to a train, but only 190 to go from the most basic telegram to the most advanced smart phone. 60 years after the invention of the airplane, we put a man in space, and now 60 years after that, you can purchase a phone that contains a more advanced technology than we used to go to the moon with. And yet even with this miracle information device in our pocket, most of us couldn’t explain our own agricultural product supply line. You might be able to make an educated guess, but would you know for certain? And that’s just one single facet of a process <em>that we rely on for food. </em>Food! The most basic element of our survival! How do we get our food? The answer is not the grocery store. That’s just the only part most of us see.</p><p>We just take other people’s word for it, and take it for granted other people will make it happen. And that’s fine, because we sort of have to. I’m as guilty of all this as anyone. We used to cross oceans based on the stars, and now I need Apple Maps to get me to the closest Taco Bell.</p><p>But what will this look like in another thousand years? Hell, in another 100 years? The scenario in my head is that as things become more complex and require a more specialized and refined knowledge, the number of people who will have to take this monstrous system for granted will increase, while the number of people able understand it, execute it, and perhaps most importantly, troubleshoot it, will decrease, until eventually we’re doing things we don’t fully understand for no other reason than it’s how we’ve always done them — only this time our elders won’t know why either. We will be forced more and more to rely on our imperfect instincts that will be long out of time and, trapped inside our own state of defense, make reality into whatever we choose it to be even more than we already do.</p><p>I’m not saying this is how things will play out — this vision of the future is a broad concern, not an exact prediction — but what I do know is that this trajectory just isn’t sustainable. That’s not to say we’re fucked tomorrow, but hey, what if we took global warming seriously when we first realized it was happening? My point is, now might be a good time to really learn some things and deliberately try to not first filter them through your ego.</p><p>But! With such a massive system in place, with a total onslaught of information from every available source in every format, most of which contradicts other information, and some of that information being completely made up, the only chance we have for the consistency we need so much is within the small corner pocket of our lives. Get up, put the coffee on, go to work, go the grocery store to buy the food that is magically there, go home. Keep your head down. Once you introduce all the other stuff — that big stuff out there in the world (and, let’s face it, the internet), there’s only chaos for your brain to sift through. You have no other choice but to revert back down into your lizard self. The thing about all those survival instincts though is, unfortunately, we’ve outgrown some of them. They’ve started to betray us (repeat after me: you do not need to fight with people on the internet). They still help us cope moment to moment, of course they do. They always have. But we promoted ourselves to failure. We got too big. And because we can’t rely on anything, those cognitive errors and faulty defense mechanisms in our stupid animal brains are doing what they know how to do to keep us alive. They’re going to give us the basic lack of self-awareness to keep going however we think we need to, no matter what. We’re going to keep stumbling along, probably right off a cliff, and a bunch of people will be saying things like “No, I’m sure those berries are fine to eat, you’re just going to listen to some old guy?”</p><p>You might’ve noticed (and with how often I’ve mentioned it, how could you not), a lot of this correlates with the internet. There’s a common sentiment that the internet is not “real life,” and I both agree and disagree. It isn’t. People don’t go around in the real world behaving the way they do behind a username. But real people interact with it, and it drastically impacts us. Enough so that it’s the thing that amplifies all this stuff. I’d even go so far as to say that without it, I wouldn’t have a reason to write this at all. We’d be going about our lives still imperfectly human, but with the pros still far outweighing the cons.</p><p>So where does that leave us? What do you do when the psychological mechanisms you need to manage your personal, everyday life occur so rapidly and on such a huge scale, our own cognitive distortions twisting on themselves and amplifying across the world, rooting into place by sheer repetition and then uprooting and replanting and twisting all over again for every other new circumstance, issue, election cycle?</p><p>In short…I’ve got no fucking clue. I really don’t. Maybe an idea of a clue, but nothing remotely coming close to a list of procedures. Because you can’t expect people to just stop being people. You can’t expect years of evolutionary instinct to just go, “Whelp, this has been fun, I’m gonna head out.” Even if we do begin to evolve out of this, it’ll only occur over yet another four or five million years. So what about right now?</p><p>I suppose it’s just to be aware. We can’t control our own cognitive dissonance, defense mechanisms, knee jerk reactions, deeply ingrained feelings, or basic human instincts, but we can be aware of them. When you sit in a therapists office, that’s half the battle, identifying the problem. You may think you have nothing to say or solve at all and then fifteen minutes later you’re on a spiel about the pet hamster you had in third grade and how it relates to your current coworker who’s triggering some…something or other. Point is, most of us are actually pretty sharp, and once we know what the problem is — the actual problem — and what the root of it is, the solution is not so far out of reach.</p><p>Here’s the hard part. When human nature is the problem, the problem is us. And that means you.</p><p>That doesn’t mean to stop believing what you believe. It doesn’t mean to give up your convictions, your identity, or your personality, and it isn’t to suggest that the key to all our issues is to just realize that we’re all on the same team and need to hold hands and sing Kumbaya. We’re not on the same team. There are people who disagree with you and you, them. There are people who hate you and there are people you hate. There are good people in the world, bad people in the world, and everywhere in between, and we’re all going to have very different views on who falls into which of those categories. But if we allow ourselves to be aware of our own personal imperfect human nature, it’ll at least allow us to better appreciate when that is happening in others, which will probably make the experience of our disagreements a little less fucking insufferable, and life a little more enjoyable.</p><p>One more thing. Maybe this is relevant to this topic, maybe it’s not, but I’m going to say it here because I think it needs to be said more: don’t underestimate the value of gentleness, even (and especially) when it comes to those you are in conflict with.</p><p>And hell, even if nobody does that but you, well…fuck ‘em. Let them be miserable. You don’t have to let their misery touch you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=639c7f60570c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>