<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Journal of Beautiful Business on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Journal of Beautiful Business on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@journalofbeautifulbusiness?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 15:10:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@journalofbeautifulbusiness/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Humans 3.0—Where To Now?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/humans-3-0-where-to-now-a8aa3782c31f?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8aa3782c31f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Nov 2022 13:51:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-28T13:52:12.546Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Closing Town Hall</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oMe3P6fa27qXFxMAZSgbaA.png" /></figure><p>Unbelievably, our 20-long asynchronous conference has come to an end. And to celebrate the fantastic contributions and participation we have witnessed along the way, we have gathered together one last time, with some of our participants, contributors, team members, and members of the audience.</p><p>To start, we aimed to quickly summarize the key aspects of exploring Beautiful Business in Web3 discerned throughout these past 4,5 months:</p><ul><li><strong>The metaverse seen as a parallel reality</strong> that creates new opportunities for interaction, and brand-consumer engagement, like team members from Journee, argodesign, Aglet and Journey have shown us.</li><li><strong>The narrative of</strong> <strong>decentralization</strong> — and democratization — of the internet, wherein platforms no longer exist based on data that’s being capitalized by Big Tech’s oligarchs, the historical context for this narrative as well as its feasibility.</li><li><strong>Increased</strong> <strong>representation</strong> in Web3 and an overview of new models of <strong>participation</strong>, with the advent of DAOs and incentivization driven with tokens.</li></ul><p>Speaking of which, we heard specific examples of such initiatives that drive positive social impact through token-driven incentivization from our <strong>hackathon participants, Sofia Ambrosioni </strong>and <strong>Katia Poenigk. </strong>Their projects—using <strong>umbrella tokens</strong> as an incentive for companies acting in the blockchain environment to be 100% inclusive with their products and services, and allowing citizens to become <strong>better ancestors</strong> through purchase impact tokens to decide on their city’s natural sources used for the common good and the future generations—were imagined in just under 72 hours!</p><p>This recap was followed by Monika Jiang, head of curation and community at the House of Beautiful Business, in conversation with <strong>Kevin Dulaney</strong>, executive vice president of technology and innovation at Hotwire, based in NYC. They about whether the Web3 hype is myth-making; reflected on the image of a “tech messiah;” discussed Mastodon; and touched upon the measures that need to be taken to shift the current platform economy.</p><p>A “<strong>centralized decentralized” music performance </strong>from our musical director <strong>Mark Aanderud</strong> and composer <strong>Warren Walker</strong> that followed next paved way into the last part of the town hall.</p><p>Having gathered some of the contributors to the program, we asked them to shortly answer the same question:</p><h4><strong>How can we make the dream of Beautiful Business in Web3 real?</strong></h4><p>The responses were diverse and reflective.</p><p>“Having more joint conversations like this one, and making room for representation of all kinds of people,” <strong>Joana Lacerda</strong> said.</p><p>“Having the power in our hands to create organizations as we set up Facebook groups today, and developing data ownership and accountability through progressive decentralization,” <strong>Nishant Bhaskar </strong>said.</p><p>“Using these new tools while remembering to think about the real world, driving real-life impact,” <strong>Rica Amaral</strong> said.</p><p>“By building places that are beautiful that we can emotionally connect with as humans, and that will slow us down, and by creating global accessibility and simple onboarding processes,” <strong>Ida Kymmer </strong>said.</p><p>“By demystifying and showing users that Web3 isn’t unattainable and that this new world isn’t so far out of reach,” <strong>Kevin Dulaney</strong> said.</p><p>“By not falling into the trap of ‘the next big thing.’ By not necessarily using scale as a driver of something beautiful we’re trying to create, and by accepting that it’s not a failure if we don’t reach that scale,” Greg Sherwin said.</p><p>We couldn’t think of better words to close these 20 weeks of communal reflection, discussion, experiment, and learning. And, even if our conference came to an end, this Discord channel remains open for you to have further discussions and continued access to all talks and material from these 20 weeks—including the <a href="https://vimeo.com/showcase/9657805/video/773414085">full recording</a> of our closing town hall.</p><p>Just sign up <a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>here</strong></a><strong> </strong>at any moment.</p><p>Thank you all so much for your beautiful presence, energy, readership, participation, curiosity, and trust. We really hope it has been insightful and helpful, and inspiring for you — it certainly was for us.</p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> is the first community-run, asynchronous conference on the future of humanity, technology, and business in a decentralized world. It is run by the House of Beautiful Business in partnership with <a href="https://hotwireglobal.com/">Hotwire</a>, a global PR and communications consultancy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8aa3782c31f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/humans-3-0-where-to-now-a8aa3782c31f">Humans 3.0—Where To Now?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The post-platform economy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-post-platform-economy-50623796a3a7?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/50623796a3a7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Nov 2022 10:19:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-10T10:19:22.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Returning to basics with Juergen Geuter, alias tante</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6jw0cC0Qw42jFNJoRFXl1Q.png" /></figure><p>We are slowly approaching the end of our asynchronous conference. After hearing so many voices and stories during these weeks, we thought we’d go back to essentials, like discerning the very infrastructure of the promised Web3 and its foundation, decentralization. To explore if there is a possibility of a post-platform economy, Monika Jiang, our head of curation and community, spoke with Juergen Geuter, alias tante, who is an independent theorist working on the intersection of technology, politics, philosophy, and the social.</p><p>Tante scans new technologies for whether they are relevant for business propositions, and de-evangelizes them, meaning that he takes these narratives and ideas of the future, whether Web3, AI, or blockchain, and sees if they hold up to scrutiny. In the process he tries to explain and contextualize technical knowledge to make it accessible to all and help all readers and users have an opinion on things.</p><p>During this conversation, tante shared some of that analysis with us. First of all, it’s important to understand that decentralization isn’t the silver bullet to solving all kinds of problems, he said. Just slapping “open code” and “decentralization” on something is tech solutionism — and it’s easy to fall into that trap.</p><p>Secondly, the transition from Web2 to Web3 isn’t a done deal, in tante’s opinion, and even something we shouldn’t be pursuing. How so?</p><blockquote><em>The answer is not to find someone who’ll shatter all familiar structures and run the software for us, but maybe to keep the centralized infrastructure intact and find other ways of running it.</em></blockquote><p>Decentralization is mostly used when we talk about a place where decisions are being taken. A centralized technology means: having a server, putting software on it, and inviting users. Then there is the idea of distributed systems—with a bunch of servers that are still a controlling entity. And decentralized technology means: not having just one server, but many different instances of server and software—with every operating group able to make decisions. Brought to the extreme, this model holds everyone on their own, running their own software, communicating with others through defined protocols. This absolute decentralization means you never have to trust anyone; the software is under your control, and you make the decisions for yourself and no one else.</p><p>Decentralizing the web would call for deplatformizing the whole infrastructure. But would that lead to a more democratized way to engage with the digital space?</p><p>“Decentralization and democratization are at best very loosely connected,” tante says. You don’t need democratization to build decentralized systems—those latter ones can also be built in plutocracy. And, on the other hand, centralized systems aren’t, by definition, undemocratic; once again, it’s about making decisions. If it’s a privately-owned server, it’s the owner who makes the decisions. But if the server is owned by a collective, and it has defined political processes of how to make decisions, it qualitifies as a democratic system, while also being centralized.</p><p>“Many of the problems that we have with digital democracies get exponentially harder when they try to become decentralized,” tante says. The idea of not having one entity controlling everything sounds very democratic, but in democracy we also have the ability to enforce things (for example, enforce the principle “one person—one vote”)—and that option doesn’t hold with decentralization.</p><p>There are also certain advantages in centralization when it comes to building trust: you know everyone’s being in the same space and rule set, the same governing principles, so it’s sometimes easier to build efficient kinds of communications.</p><p>So how can trust be created within a centralized technology? Some platforms, like Signal, use encryptions for that purpose. And yet, in tante’s opinion, both decentralization and encryption are “tech fixers” that are a little too simplistic for the social problem they’re trying to solve. They tackle the issue of trust from a highly technical perspective, with math and protocols—but trust is a social and psychological thing, tante says. It’s built on knowing people, having shared history and shared values. And in Signal’s case, trust is first and foremost based on the reputation of its founder, Moxie Marlinspike.</p><p>And what are some alternative scenarios to the wishful decentralization? Tante refers to Ben Tarnoff’s most recent book <a href="https://www.versobooks.com/books/3927-internet-for-the-people)"><em>Internet for the People</em></a><em>: </em>certainly, these big centralized systems can be problematic, especially if they belong to companies whose goals don’t usually align to the goals of the users. Should this be reorganized geopolitically? Having one government running a service used globally isn’t an option, either—different countries have very different moral and legal code. What if we brought the scale down? Tarnoff argues for smaller platforms connected by protocol, so that you have access to a service maintained and supported by, say, your city. The people on the platform would be familiar to you, as well—they would be your neighbors, so you’d already have trust relationships with them.</p><blockquote>“Maybe we can leverage existing trust and governance relationships, processes and institutions to build a space where we can analyze and understand: what works in a global governance hierarchy, and what doesn’t, and figure out the things that don’t work in politics. Maybe they can be fixed in the decentralized people-governed social networks better than in existing governance structures. In the end goal, we should have an infrastructure that we can control. We should have the right to vote on the laws and the processes of the platforms we use, and veto certain things—it’s a fundamental human right we should enforce in the digital space. The core functionality and the core data should be governed by entities that we have influence over—and that means they need to be run by coops that are funded by tax money, but run independent of the government.”</blockquote><p>Curious to hear more? Listen to tante and Monika’s full conversation <a href="https://soundcloud.com/houseofbeautifulbusiness/tante">here</a>!</p><p>And join us for the last stretch, including a final townhall next Wednesday, featuring many of our speakers!</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> is the first community-run, asynchronous conference on the future of humanity, technology, and business in a decentralized world. It is run by the House of Beautiful Business in partnership with <a href="https://hotwireglobal.com/">Hotwire</a>, a global PR and communications consultancy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=50623796a3a7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-post-platform-economy-50623796a3a7">The post-platform economy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Umbrella Tokens, Better Ancestors, and the Future of Moments]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/acceptably-sustainable-or-climate-positive-too-c4358493d699?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4358493d699</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Nov 2022 09:11:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-04T12:03:17.291Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Dispatch from Wine3 — The Happy Hour Web3 hackathon</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HWVuRV7sON9InpcFPkzWjg.gif" /></figure><p>Well, this was a first for us. Last week, we witnessed a real mini-hackathon. Hosted by <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/annabelle-low/?originalSubdomain=sg"><strong>Annabelle Low</strong></a>, venture builder and director of strategic development at Project Ark, and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ricaa/?originalSubdomain=de"><strong>Ricardo Amaral</strong></a>, co-founder of Positiveblockchain.io, it was a four-session crash course on the practical applications for making Web3 impactful, sustainable, and beautiful.</p><p>Now, we’re currently sitting in a tricky spot. Since 1970 69% of earth’s species have been lost. And to avoid a climate disaster, we have to reduce 30billion tons of emissions per year. Inevitably, we find ourselves in the business of rethinking how we live—and Web3 can help us drive this change. It’s crucial, however, to remember that Web3 is a tool, but not a solution in itself. Technology is not the main driver of social social change, it’s just an element in a complex system of social, cultural economic process.”</p><p>So Rica and Belle contextualized this moment, from Web1 (as a library, a web where we can read) to Web2 (as a platform, a web where we can read and write) towards Web3 (where we are the web; we can read, write, and execute—the user is empowered). How can we push the existing structures of Web3 to do public social good?</p><p>To better understand how to use these technologies, we went through the basic vocabulary, the main “buzzwords”—blockchain (the underlying infrastructure), tokens and NFTs (ways to make transactions happen, the currency and assets), DAOs (the community using these technologies), and the metaverse (the interface). And the coordinators behind using these for social impact? The ReFi, Regenerative Finance movement, used to build systems for human thriving and plurality—because, just like <strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal </strong>was saying last week, there’s not just one internet, or one Web3; there’ no <em>one </em>way of doing things.</p><p>We glanced into the tokenomics: how do tokens create value, how do they incentivize positive behaviour? What are deflationary and inflationary tokens? How do proof of impact tokens attach to sustainable product? (Check out GainForest, a decentralized fund using AI to measure and reward sustainable nature stewardship). What is proof of humanity and Soulbound token—and how does it correlate with the Sybil proof list of humans through the trusted web?</p><p>To explain the workings of Web3 projects seeking to drive positive social impact, Rica and Belle gave<strong> examples of such projects</strong>, like their own <a href="https://www.project-ark.co/">Project Ark</a>. Through their own experience, they have learned a lot about using NFTs for fundraising, positioning the project, educating through PR and marketing, investing into a community around the project, responding to concerns about environmental aspects of using this technology, and so on. How can creating a digital twin and using NFTs and proof of impact tokens help drive sustainable initiatives, like ecotourism and conservation activities? What is the preserve-to-earn method? (Check out The <a href="https://www.greenverse.world/">Greenverse</a> Suriname project). How can we use NFTs and the metaverse for inclusivity? (Check out the Unhidden, for people with disabilities). How does a non-profit philanthropic DAO work? (Check out <a href="https://dao.biggreen.org/">Big Green DAO</a>). How can DAOs drive regenerative design? (Check out <a href="https://traditionaldreamfactory.com/">Traditional Dream Factory DAO</a>). How can you support local causes, artists, and changemakers, as well as education initiatives through NFTs and the metaverse? (Check out <a href="https://www.africarare.io/">AfricaRare</a> and <a href="https://www.kolektivo.network/">Kolektivo</a>). How does proof of humanity work? What are some criteria to select a green chain to build on? And other examples, which you can check out in the recording.</p><p>To be able practice this received knowledge, and turn it into a real hackathon, the participants worked together in 3 groups, aiming to come up with a project responding to one of the two main challenges: <strong>tokenizing beautiful business</strong>, so seeing how organizations can leverage digital assets for the common good, and <strong>decentralizing beautiful business</strong>, or imagining setting up a decentralized organization to leverage Web3 for creating positive externalities.</p><p>In the spirit of learning together, the criteria by which the groups were judged were: identification of the problem, the strength of solution, creativity, feasibility, and the clarity of the presentation. Our judges were <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/gregsherwin/?originalSubdomain=pt">Greg Sherwin</a>, senior principal engineer at Farfetch and contributor to our asynchronous conference (during <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/a-new-promised-land-ee0475fb9911">Week 2</a>), <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/alexdumitrescu/?originalSubdomain=ro">Alexandra Dumitrescu</a>, catalyst of partnerships for innovation at WWF, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonposullivan?originalSubdomain=ca">Jon O’Sullivan</a>, director of business development and partnerships at Project Ark, and Belle and Rica.</p><p><strong>And these were three fantastic projects presented.</strong></p><p>Are the new systems we are learning to use accessible to everyone? There are more than 350 million colorblind people in the world today—and there are so many other common disabilities around us. Does “everyone” really mean “everyone?”</p><p>So the first team (Sofia Lopez Ambrosioni, Rute Sousa, and Petra Ronzani) presented <strong>umbrella tokens</strong> as an incentive for companies acting in the blockchain environment to be 100% inclusive with their products and services. In other words, it’s an accessibility rating tool of businesses’ blockchain platforms, measuring things like contrast of color, user interactivity, presentation of information, etc, that grants the tokens using smart contracts. And for the users, companies’ umbrella tokens work as a kind of filter so that they can choose the platforms that best fit their needs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V4BpFqwhmW4cf2F9g30HDA.png" /></figure><p>Second group (Katja Pönigk, Anna Sundukova, and Mariana Westphalen) wants to become <strong>better ancestors</strong>. City dwellers often feel disconnected from municipal officials who take care of natural resources—the parks, the rivers, the forests, the air, and so on. How could they be a part of those decisions, as well? As suggested by this project, they could access platforms where local organizations and municipal officials are represented, and purchase impact tokens to decide on their city’s natural sources used for the common good and the future generations. Through smart contracts, organizations would have to prove the realization of their initiatives. Citizens could also go into a virtual representation of the city and see the “live” results of their actions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_RuUIw7cJ-ztPxoHdvoXBA.png" /></figure><p>And the third group (Micael Lopes, Su Sakarya, Alexandre Ayoub) presented us with a problem, known to many of us, globally: we take way too many photos and videos, we post them on social networks, and we share fake images and spread fake news. And there’s a lot of duplication: per day, we are looking at around 8 billion pictures sent on WhatsApp alone. And our global data is expected to double within the next three years. So the solution this group proposed is to create a platform where every single picture and video only exists once—and it would be stored and authenticated in time and geolocation. It would bring about an <strong>authentic digital world</strong> based on real life events and moments through revolutionizing how we store and share pictures and videos. It could later be used for proof of creation and proof of preservation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C1rtin4nWsmnL_r2d_Wz8g.png" /></figure><p>After tough consideration, the judges announces the winning team, and the second group, that of <strong>the</strong> <strong>good ancestors</strong> received a 100 ton CO2 offset by <a href="https://www.project-ark.co/">Project Ark</a> under the team’s name (that’s an equivalent of roughly 100 trips from Paris to New York—or, the <strong>average yearly carbon footprint of someone living in Berlin</strong>). It’s a <strong>100 Climate CRED token</strong> that verifies that carbon has been removed from the atmosphere and serves as proof-of-removal.</p><p><strong>Congratulations to the winning team and to all the wonderful participants, hosts, and judges!</strong></p><p><em>Additional information and links:</em></p><p>A lot of the information covered in the hackathon was quoted from the book by one of the founders of Gitcoin, Kevin Owocki, called <br><a href="https://greenpill.party/#book"><em>Greenpilled: How Crypto Can Regenerate the World</em></a></p><p>And here are the recordings of all the four sessions:</p><p><a href="https://vimeo.com/766731330">Day 1</a><br><a href="https://vimeo.com/766734165">Day 2</a><br><a href="https://vimeo.com/766735585">Day 3</a><br><a href="https://vimeo.com/766840192">Day 4</a></p><p>They are also available in the #library section on our Discord. Want to join our journey? There’s still time!</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> is the first community-run, asynchronous conference on the future of humanity, technology, and business in a decentralized world. It is run by the House of Beautiful Business in partnership with <a href="https://hotwireglobal.com/">Hotwire</a>, a global PR and communications consultancy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4358493d699" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/acceptably-sustainable-or-climate-positive-too-c4358493d699">Umbrella Tokens, Better Ancestors, and the Future of Moments</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[But Is There Still Time to Make It More Ethical?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/but-is-there-still-time-to-make-it-more-ethical-bbc8d282dd7e?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbc8d282dd7e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Oct 2022 09:56:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-27T09:56:56.004Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Learning about an ethically conscious Web3 from Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal and Micaela Mantegna</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_mnfx-fnJAn2VJDSd3HJaQ.gif" /></figure><p>They say history repeats itself, and yet, there’s cause for optimism, that we’ll learn from the mistakes and false promises of Web2. How do we go about that? How do we address the issues that are ingrained in the current infrastructure, that mirror the inequalities, the injustices, and shortcomings of the societies that we live in? What are the policies needed for an ethically conscious, sustainable shift built for inclusion and intersectionality?</p><p>Big words, big dreams. To tackle these, <strong>Monika Jiang</strong>, head of Curation and Community at the House of Beautiful Business spoke with <strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal</strong>, philosopher, computer scientist, and research associate at the Technical University of Berlin, and <strong>Micaela Mantegna</strong>, video game lawyer, TED Fellow and affiliate at the Berkman Kline Institute for Internet and Society at Harvard University based in Buenos Aires. Read the transcript of their conversation below.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Hello, my name is Monika, I’m the head of curation and community at the House of Beautiful Business.</p><p>Jess and Mica, first of all, thank you for being here and for taking the time to join us! I would love to start with learning a little bit about you. So do you both remember the first interaction that you’ve ever had with the web, the internet? When was that? How was it? How did you feel about it?</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>Yes, sure! I was kind of privileged, because my dad was actually a nerd. So he really wanted to install the internet as soon as it was available. I experienced it as a teenager — I think I was 11 or 12 years old. And it was this time where you had to buy the internet by hours. And the first time I used it, it was to chat with my best friend from school whom I was seeing basically every day, and it was limited to 15 minutes by my parents. I remember that I was really impressed to be able to talk with my friend, but at the same time, I was wondering: what is the purpose of that? Because when you’re 11 years old, you can’t really type fast, so we were taking ages to have a conversation of 15 minutes. I had this weird feeling of being extremely impressed, but at the same time, not being able to figure out the purpose of this new thing.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Love this! What about you, Mica?</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>I was laughing, because when you’re telling this, it’s like you’re giving away your age. I don’t remember the first interaction, but I remember the feeling of <em>not having </em>internet. I was born and raised in Patagonia in Argentina, so my access to knowledge and culture was really limited to the books you had in the library, or the books that you could borrow from a friend. I was 15 years old or so, and I couldn’t order a book online. So for me, this sensation was like the world opening up. And the access to the internet was really slow and not so common. My parents actually sent me to “learn the internet” — as you would send a child to ballet classes, or, I don’t know, other activities; but they sent me “to the internet”. And the best thing about that place is that I had unlimited access to it after the courses, so I could stay the whole afternoon, browsing the web. For me, accessing knowledge — and, as a copyright lawyer, I shouldn’t be saying this — but downloading books was the best thing for me! And that’s why I kind of became an internet activist, because we should defend this access to culture, to knowledge, and open up the worlds of little girls around the world.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>I love that! Thank you both for sharing. And I was thinking about that as well, because both of my parents studied computer science, and the internet was very much “a thing,” as were computers! And I remembered entering all of these random chat rooms and thinking: “What is this! I can just talk with people?” It was so much fun, like this Harry Potter themed chat world, and I thought, “Oh, my God, they’re all like me; but who are they?” And then there were definitely some weird moments, when you’d start exchanging photos, and you’d realize: ok, that’s definitely a real person. And you exchange a lot, but you don’t know them…Anyway: odd! We’ll talk about the evolution of that, I guess, which is the metaverse now.</p><p>I want to bring us to this moment of Web3, and the conversations around it. You both work in the field of research around tech policy intersecting with larger questions of society and culture. So I’m wondering, in this conversation that we’re witnessing, that you are following and shaping, what are the most significant misconceptions that you are coming across right now?</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>I think the biggest misconception that I see is not even related specifically to Web3, but to what we call “the” internet. It gives the impression that we experience the fundamentals of the internet all in the same way, because, technically, it makes sense to speak about one internet, but then we have very different experiences. Depending where you are in the world, you don’t have the same speed of access, the same reliability, and even the same interface. We have a very different experience of “the” internet. That’s why I think it’s a bit misleading to make it singular.</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>I totally agree with that. Back in the days the internet was like the information highway, the World Wide Web… It hasn’t yet been set what the internet was, or what the internet could do. I think right now some people are overlapping the metaverse with Web3, and thinking about them as the same thing. And that, for me, is a huge misconception. Another one that I particularly fight a lot is the commercial narrative about the metaverse. I come from the internet governance space, and I see the same debate that we’ve already had in those spaces. We are kind of converting to this new space, but at the same time everyone is talking about the metaverse as <em>Meta’s</em> metaverse. We are not talking about open metaverses, about the possibility of public metaverses, or different versions that don’t have to do with scarcity — which, for me, as a Star Trek fan, is core to my ethical beliefs. How can we create a society that is not based on scarcity? If you are in the physical world, everything has a cost to replicate. And that is tied up to supply chains, to how much everything costs. But when you are in the digital space, the cost is really different, because once you produce something, you can replicate to the infinite, and everyone can have a copy of that. So why are we talking about NFTs, and scarcity, and creating artificial means, when we need to shift the paradigm and start thinking about a post-scarcity world? One where, once you produce something, you can replicate it, and a lot of people can have access to that. So for me that’s the biggest kind of misconception: everyone’s talking about the metaverse as Meta, and the commercial metaverse.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Jess, you are a philosopher and a computer scientist, right? Just so explain to us a little bit how these two things go together, and how you bring them together through your work.</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>I used to work as a computer scientist. At this time I was doing very boring things. It was called “big data” by marketing people. We were just crushing a lot of data to optimize the price of plane tickets, which is ethically concerning too, I think. And then I switched to AI. I got very interested in machine learning, and I tried to build my startup twice, and it failed, twice. I learned a lot through that. My biggest learning was that when you are a software engineer, you are a bit naive, because you create digital worlds the way <em>you</em> want it. You have all these big ideas, and you really think that you’re gonna change the world. And then you are confronted with investors who do their job, so they have to make the product profitable. And it’s not always compatible with your big, ethical ideals. So after these two failures, which were mainly related to that to different conception of what the technology should do, I decided to stop that and to, to help technologists to do more ethical work, and also help policymakers regulate these things, and really do the work that I wish would have been done when I was trying to launch my own startups. And so my computer skills helped me to read computer science papers, to understand it. I think it’s very important and sometimes lacking in philosophy. And then, of course, the philosophy allowed me to understand these bigger structures, and to try to think how we can make it more ethical. I also think we focus a bit too much on ethics, but we should actually look at political philosophy. That’s what I’m trying to bring to the topic. Because a lot of these problems are actually political problems, rather than ethical matters.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>And Mica, you’re a video game lawyer, amongst other things. What does that mean?</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>I have been doing different work, and I came to this area from different things. People tend to think that being a video game lawyer is something weird, but in fact, it’s a very specific field of law that you need to have a really good grasp of in the video game industry. Let’s be honest, I started because I’m a gamer at heart, I’m a geek, I’m a nerd, and I wanted to kind of transition my profession into that. But what I discovered was a fantastic world. I was super bored, as Jess was saying, with the legal work that I was doing, I felt that it wasn’t meaningful. I’m prone to creativity, and I found this intersection, when you have creative products on the one side and copyright law on the other, which protects and regulates creativity. So that’s when it started to make sense. I started working with beginning developers, helping them understand some of the legal aspects related to intellectual property. In my research, the first approach was related to internet governance. I have a background in understanding checks and balances of internet policy works, something that is unregulated, or semi-regulated around the world.</p><p>Talking about freedom of speech, that kind of emotionalisation is not only about the liberal ideologies, but also the gender, because the people that are making Web3 are a particular set of people. And yet again we are replicating the lack of access, the technical barriers that minorities have, to create this world. So we are seeing these crypto spaces dominated by male (a particular subset of male!). Sorry for the digression…</p><p>And the other moving piece in my career was my interest in ethics of AI. About seven years ago I received a fellowship in Google, so I started to develop a framework to talk about AI ethics and think about ways artificial intelligence impacts society. And the conversation tends to go to many places very quickly, which is why my framework tries to explain it as a sequence, from how you go from being aware that these systems are in place around you, to how they end up impacting equality, fairness, and inclusion in society. It’s gradient: you go from being aware that these systems are there, which means you cannot opt out of these systems. Being aware of the bias, the lack of transparency, and the particular obfuscation, not only technical, but also legal, because you have intellectual property devices that can obscure how this technology works, and can obscure the access for researchers to know how this technology works. And this is connected with the video game copyright, and from there everything gets converted into the metaverse.</p><p>It might sound a bit convoluted, but this is my head 100% of the time. I’m super curious. I’m doing different kinds of research. In my current research, I’m thinking about ways brain computer interfaces are going to be implemented in devices that are going to allow you to access the metaverse, and the future of interfaces, and how it’s going to impact privacy, and, of course, self-determination. So that’s the bigger picture. And the last bit of it is: I have been doing research for the past four years on artificial creativity. And that’s my book on artificial creativity that’s launching next month, hopefully. (Unfortunately, it’s in Spanish.) But it talks about the intersection of computer creativity, copyright, and its future.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Amazing! Wow, I definitely want to also learn more about those interfaces! But first, let’s come to the question and the statement that you just made, Jess, that we talk a little bit too much about ethics and are focused only on that, but that many of the reasons of how the current Internet is being built and how we want to move forward is a question of political aspects and political philosophy. So what does that exactly mean? Can you help unpack that a little bit, specifically for the context of Web3?</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>Yes, that’s a bit what I meant when I was talking about these values of liberalism. I agree with you that it’s this particular demographic, Mica, who are building it and probably ruling it. I think that’s also compatible with these liberal values. When we talk about liberalism, of course there are values, and political theory, and liberalism as a political ideology. But it also has a materiality when it’s entering society, and when we look at the US, which is probably the paradigm example, but in the European countries it’s all the same, the people who are actually benefiting the most from this liberal system are white men with an initial capital above average, etc. And the metaverse looks like it’s produced by this system, because, as we mentioned, there is a problem of freedom of speech, that’s clear. They bring this anonymity as one as the value of Web3, but we don’t necessarily want people to be anonymous and have no censorship, because then the groups who are the most threatened have no protection, and this is what we see on Twitter, for example, with black women being harassed, having to shut down their accounts, not being able to speak in this on the space — these kinds of things are gonna reproduce in the Web3 space even more, if we have this anonymity possibility.</p><p>And what about DAOs, decentralized autonomous organizations? I mean, of course, decentralization sounds great: to not have one boss, but then who protects minorities, what happens to the antidiscrimination laws? From what I understood, Web3 wants to replace those who have the decision power with those who have coins, but then what is it? It’s, once again, the people who have more capital. It will not necessarily be economical capital, but like we saw with Bitcoin. Who became rich from Bitcoin? People who were tech savvy, who had some initial investment to do mining. But all the minorities, or people who are not as tech savvy, even if it’s not in terms of financial capital, they will be left behind again. So that’s what that’s what I mean: for me it’s more of a political problem. Ethics, it’s about thinking is a good life. And we have a tendency sometimes to think about technological artifacts as agents. And then it’s true that when you have this conception of an agent, you want the agent to behave morally. And that’s what ethics is about: to find the action that’s good, the action that’s bad. But it’s not really the case with these technologies. They are not acting by themselves. They are made by humans, for humans. It’s a complex web of interconnection. And I think it’s a bit misleading to believe that you can have these universal good ethical values that you can build Web3 with. I think it’s more a question of politics, in the sense that the people should be deciding how this thing will be organized, how DAOs or Web3 should be implemented and function. Because if not, it’s going to be minorities who are going to be the most left out. That’s what I mean when I say that it’s a reproduction of liberalism. But I’m not saying that we should throw liberalism away. I’m just a bit concerned that it seems to be the only ideology reproduced in this digital space. I think we really need the diversity of political ideologies to build this new form of the Web.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Mica, would you maybe like to respond or build on that? What I hear you saying is basically, that the idea of the metaverse as it exists now and as it’s being dominated, and, again, monopolized, in a way, is the first version of replicating all of the patterns and structures that you’ve just listed, Jess?</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>This is fascinating. For me, this is about geopolitical concerns — as in, when you’re thinking about the annexation of Taiwan and local politics. And we’re seeing the rise of different regimes that are based on an extremism of liberal principles: the rise of Trump, the rise of Bolsonaro… And in Argentina we are going to have elections, and one of the candidates is being dismissed, which is concerning for me, because he has a huge vote, and resonates with the kind of person that is building Web3. For me, it’s interesting to see how politics are connected to the issues we are discussing. But at the same time, even though we cannot agree on different moral philosophies about ethics, and can’t create “the correct” course of action, we already have an internet history, and some of the questions that have been posed along that history of the internet are popping up again now, because we haven’t solved them on Web2. So, for example, when we are talking about anonymity, this is a huge debate on Web2. When we are talking about access to Facebook, we are talking about net neutrality, and those who will have the power to give out access to not only internet connection, but also manufactured hardware. How are we going to access the metaverse or Web3? Particularly when we’re talking about the metaverse, if we see the metaverse as a virtual reality (which is another subset of discussion, because people think that could be AR and VR, or they’re seeing it as just VR.)</p><p>Imagine you are working for a company that provides you with a headset, but it’s kind of a lower quality. So it gives you headaches, nausea, which women are particularly more prone to. And on the other side of the spectrum, there are people from other parts of the world that have access to the same technology, and can access the same meeting that you’re in with different headsets. They are more comfortable, of better quality. So yet again, all the things lead to<strong> </strong>replicating inequalities. But there is a common ground we can build upon and it’s human right. We have the human rights framework. There is almost a common set of principles that we need to preserve. If we think about this as something completely new, we’ll risk losing all the things we have learned from the past history of the internet. So if we think of the metaverse and Web3 as something completely new, and we start debating about anonymity with a liberal mindset that encourages going the full route of unregulated freedom of speech, we’ll end up having the same problems, but enhanced. We’ll lose the safeguards that we already built in — and it took a lot of time to build those safeguards for the internet.</p><p>And the problem with unregulated internet is, it’s different jurisdictions, nobody has real power. In terms of legal power, the best framework for that was the data protection regulations. If you regulate access to data, you regulate the access to the field of the digital economy. So maybe we cannot regulate the internet, but we can cut access, and that can also create another huge problem of internet governance today, which is fragmentation. Because one thing that I foresee could be risky for Web3 is creating different silos and different kinds of subsets, where, if you want to access this, you need this token or that token. Fragmentation begins. Then there are websites like Reddit or 4chan, with new subsets of people and their own narrative, and algorithms can replicate it, and exacerbate that kind of thought. All in all, you end up going down the rabbit hole quickly. So it’s a really complex problem that we didn’t solve in Web3, and it’s coming back to bite us in Web3.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>I want to follow up on the whole commercialization part. This is something that we’ve touched on here and there, since the theme overall is <strong>Beautiful Business in Web3</strong>. So I’m curious to hear, you know, what that triggers in you, what you’re seeing currently, if people are benefiting off of this new-and-old, or, rather, something-in-between technology, both in positive and negative ways.</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>For me it’s that we can see different business models. I’m super excited to see what DAOs can provide, because for me it could be the evolution of business models towards those based on crowdsourcing, which could be more fair and hold the concentration of power in a central entity. It’s like thinking about small business in Web3. For me DAOs could be like that bridge. The things I hate about the commercialization that we are seeing today are also poisoning the spirit of Web3. It’s like Budweiser entering the space selling NFTs, and people are spending a lot of money…And you have seen what happened with the <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/04/13/jack-dorseys-first-tweet-nft-went-on-sale-for-48m-it-ended-with-a-top-bid-of-just-280/">first tweet in history</a> that was sold for $3 million and now it’s worth $40 million, or something like that. I hate that kind of spirit, that I think is poisoning what people are trying to do. For me the hope relies on DAOs and businesses can interact more closely with their actual audience through those mechanisms.</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>Yeah, I share your enthusiasm about DAOs. Of course, it may look naive — I remember, when Bitcoin arrived, I was really seduced by the idea. I thought, Oh my God, all the big banks are going to collapse. But it didn’t happen and came with a lot of problems — like environmental problems. At the end of the day, I see the people who earned the most from that, apart from some early nerds, were big investors who came just at the right time — and left just at the right time. So this kind of example makes me worried about commercialization. But of course, it’s a bigger problem, not just a digital problem. It’s the way capitalism works nowadays. It’s a very unregulated version of capitalism, with its core principles like tax redistribution, unfortunately, not functioning. And I think because of that, when you look specifically at the digital, it has strong impacts. When you look at the way that we build technology nowadays is very different from what you had in the 80s, or even before in the 50s, 60s. At this time, mainly academics were building technology. The very first steps of AI were an attempt to replicate the human brain, to understand how human intelligence functions. Now we are very far from that. AI decides if humans will get a job or not. We are not at all trying to understand how the brain is working, we are in commercial applications, and we save you the cost of an HR department telling you that the software knows better. And it’s these kinds of things. And with Web3 we risk having the same problem. The products are so complex nowadays… By yourself, even if you are a very gifted developer, you are not going to do much. You need a full team: you need someone to do the interface, the beautiful design, you need someone to take care of your database, you need blockchain engineers, etc. It’s always going to become more costly, more difficult to take part in Web3. And it will be a strong advantage for these tech giants that were supposed to disintegrate. I’m not so convinced about that narrative.</p><p>And another consequence of capitalism, in which Web3 is totally embedded, like the world nowadays, is that we don’t have a diversity of actors, and I find that very concerning, as well. Because now academics are totally out of the game, I don’t think that’s a mystery for anyone. If you just follow the academic Twitter, you can see all the academics leaving for all the tech giants, and I totally understand my colleagues, because it’s really tough. And when you see what you have, outside, it’s difficult to remain. So we definitely don’t have academics anymore. And like for small organizations, NGOs, it’s extremely difficult to come to this space, because the costs are enormous. That’s why I think that this commercialization has contaminated the space, just like you said. The space doesn’t have a possibility to open up communities that are a bit more ethically oriented, value oriented. Even these communities are not diverse, because the code is not accessible to most people. So that’s why I think that it’s a larger problem, and this lack of diversity is concerning for the building of Web3.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Let me ask you both a closing question: diversity of actors. Whom do we need to bring into the space more in order to build this in a way that is actually more ethical and sustainable as well? We didn’t even touch on the environmental aspects of all of this, which is also very much conflated with the capitalistic system that we live in, and so forth. Whom do we need to bring to the space to actually create a more beautiful future of the Internet?</p><p><strong>Micaela Mantegna:</strong></p><p>That’s a tough one! I would say we should have every representation of people. So you can bring your own set of values, you can bring your own cultural context to this, to how these products are designed. But it’s really tough because it’s rooted in inequalities that we see in this world of transition. And we spoke about this the first time we met with the House of Beautiful Business: not everyone is born equal into Web3. It’s not like we are magically doing the transition, and the axis is completely different.</p><p>And another thing: I like to talk about this as like capitalism of cognitive surveillance, that is a perfected form of capitalism. And this is something we haven’t touched upon today, but it’s going to mean the end of ownership, even in the case of NFTs, and ways to move content around Web3, and ways intellectual property will work there. Digital products are different from tangible products, so it’s going to create a separate layer of capitalism, when you can control how your consumer is going to use these and how your consumer is going to kind of remix this content. So it’s a really tough conversation. And I strongly agree with what Jess was saying about how it’s always going to lead back to centralization, because these middlemen are already taking positions. I didn’t want to end on a sad note, but this is concerning.</p><p><strong>Jess de Jesus de Pinho Pinhal:</strong></p><p>Yeah, I totally agree. I think the answer is everyone, obviously. But we come back to the same problem that you were rightly highlighting, Mica: we haven’t solved any of the issues with Web2. And I would go further as to say: we haven’t solved the issue of Web1, and Web0. We are coming back to what we were saying at the beginning: to me, the first layer is this infrastructure problem. We cannot speak about removing inequalities in the web, when you have people who have to get internet through these undersea cables, while you have the US with a fiber optics network that is blocked, that is just reserved for them. This kind of materiality of the Web is already based on very strong inequalities. And then you have the other layer of the big tech giants, and those who control the data etc. And then of course, in Web3 all of that will intensify, but also because the diverse digital divides that we have are just getting wider. We have done nothing to reduce the material digital divide of the infrastructure, but also the digital divide of being tech savvy, of being able to code, of growing technologies, etc. We haven’t solved that at all. I think we are just widening that up, and now we also have the capital, which will heavily contribute to widening these gaps, because it becomes more and more costly. So I really want to say: we need everyone, but I think the reality of Web3 is that we will leave even more people behind, if we don’t do something to bridge this digital device.</p><p><strong>Monika Jiang:</strong></p><p>Thank you both so much for all of your time, your perspective, all of the really crucial questions that we need to ask ourselves now, and also stick with them, and try to solve them from the back, rather than already being so excited about the future that we become lost in the reason and the purpose of why and how we ended up here. Thank you both. I think there’s a lot of overlap in your work, you’re both embodying the personas and the critical thinking that I would love to see more of. So thank you again! I hope to see you soon.</p><p><em>This is a transcript of a conversation that happened on Discord. You can listen to it </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/houseofbeautifulbusiness/web3-ethical"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><h4>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h4><p>There couldn’t be a better moment to do so! This week we opened up the stage to our participants, who are rocking it with their own wisdom: Shakespearean avatars, crypto for financial freedom, matching with gamers, and the manifolds of the metaverse, among other topics. Tune in at any moment to hear their contributions!</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbc8d282dd7e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/but-is-there-still-time-to-make-it-more-ethical-bbc8d282dd7e">But Is There Still Time to Make It More Ethical?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Shakespearean avatars, crypto remittance, and matching with gamers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/shakespearean-avatars-crypto-remittance-and-matching-with-gamers-db9db4fac8f6?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db9db4fac8f6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Oct 2022 17:55:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-18T17:55:05.720Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A crowdsources program from our participants</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qu8MRnA90uLmqbuCSHQLhw.png" /></figure><p>Last week’s format was a mystery to us, the organizers of this 20-week long asynchronous conference, as we asked our participants, members of the Discord community, to run the program for a week and share their wisdom with us. And so they did, via a series of beautiful talks and presentations. We couldn’t feel more grateful for their unique contributions to our program!</p><p>We started by getting our creative juices flowing, and played the <strong>analogy game </strong>with <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/meredith-lewis-6518a7145/?originalSubdomain=au"><strong>Meredith Lewis</strong></a><strong>, </strong>writer and facilitator. Could you compare yourself to a place? And if Web3 were a place, what would it be? What if it were a film or a TV show? One participant saw it “as a fascinating blend of creative non-fiction and drama,” the other as horror. Meredith quoted Leo Tolstoy who had said, “With great literature, it boils down to one or two stories: either a man goes on a journey, or a stranger comes to town.” So which narrative is it for you, regarding Web3? Of whose stories do you find yourself a part? “I’m looking to be a part of someone’s story being told,” one participants resumed beautifully.</p><p>And speaking of analogies and literary devices, storyteller <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/megandavisstoryteller/?originalSubdomain=au"><strong>Megan Davis</strong></a><strong> </strong>brought a fascinating one, to focus on the stories we tell that end up making up our culture. If today we can play around with our representations, we owe it to Shakespeare, Megan said, and how he’d revolutionized the ways we identify with personalities and characters. Before Shakespeare there was fate (i.e. a path laid out for everyone), and characters had to behave in accordance to their role and path, without deviation (i.e. King and Queen). But Shakespeare had said: “No, people are messy, contradictory; they’ll say one thing and do another; they’ll change what they believe, their goals, and what motivates them.” And it’s thanks to him that today we value flaws and see them as representations of personality.</p><p>So Megan prompted us to think: when moving into a community, what sides of yourself can you show? Rather than showing what is perfect, maybe you can highlight what’s not so perfect? What makes you memorable? How can we expand our 2D into 3D thinking? In Web3, what will your avatar be?</p><p>“In order to get to the truth, a lot of people have to be antagonistic,” one participant said, “The truth doesn’t just present itself on a silver platter”.</p><p>And what are some of the best ways we can create social impact in the Web3 space? We heard from <strong>Craig Schuster, </strong>the founder of <a href="https://remittdao.io/">RemittDAO</a>.</p><p>RemittDAO focuses on international remittance payments from people groups in developing nations or from unbanked and undocumented migrant workers in host cities that are sending remittances on a daily basis back home to their families. Sure, there is WesternUnion, and it is deeply engrained into the societies in these developing countries—but it’s quite archaic (170 years old!), still dependent on the physical offices, closed during holidays and national disasters (significant in places like the Philippines). And there are other remittance services, predatory towards migrant workers. And Craig thinks that the new technological possibilities we have today can really change the picture.</p><p>During the Ethereal Conference in 2017 Joseph Lubin, co-founder of Ethereum and CEO of ConsenSys, said: “An excess of two billion people don’t have banking relationships, and similar numbers don’t have a state issued ID. Though while they may be able to transact in their local context, this renders them non-citizens in the larger regional and global economies.”</p><p>So why does the Web3 not address this problem? Because the Web3 world got caught up in what’s “cutting edge,” Craig thinks. “It’s all about: let’s invent the next tool, the community around something new. As if everyone’s forgotten about this use case scenario.” In Craig’s opinion, the bigger picture here is: to change the societal attitude towards migrant workers who keep the economy rolling. The way to do that is through education—and the tools are already there. RemittDAO’s mission is to educate migrant worker families and refugees about the benefit, safety and logistics of digital remittance tools. Craig and his team want to host classes in Hong Kong, Singapore, and other host cities, where migrant workers could learn about the digital remittance tools they can use to build wealth in their families. To make it sustainable, they will be taught how to teach these workshops themselves, and help the ecosystem grow.</p><p>Futurist, founder and CEO of <a href="https://reddingfutures.com/">Redding Futures</a>, <strong>Neil Redding </strong>spoke about the ecosystem paradigm of the metaverse and the aspects of decentralization, connectedness, and presence as the key tools for building a beautiful metaverse.</p><p>The world is made up of ecosystems nested inside each other (i.e. a person, an apple, a business, a society). Take mushrooms, and mycelium networks, that, in turn, resemble the internet. The more we study ways of mycelium and the ways it connects through the forest ecosystem, the more we will discover patterns that will help us consciously evolve collective behaviors that create ever greater health and capabilities, Neil claims. And in the Web3 world, we can practice building these patterns into the smart contracts in DAOs.</p><p>“What if we saw the world as connected instead of seeing it as a bunch of separated things?” Neil asks, “Connectedness is what’s left when our programming in the paradigm of distinction is stripped away.” Our ego takes years to become formed, and the constant, mostly automatic reinforcement requires of us to feel and think of ourselves as distinct — but through various experience, a profound sense of connectedness seems to be the default. “The tipping point is our awakening into intentional active participation in the ecosystems that we already inhabit,” Neil says, “And this is what will make the metaverse work.”</p><p>As we’ve seen over the last 15 years or so, the very nature of engagement via maximized socialization, of everything digital, is to disrupt our experience of connectedness with each other, and even with ourselves. But Web3 is a promise of a different kind of communication. “The guiding principles of distributed ownership and participation are our best hope for creating an immersive world that’s aligned with the things that ultimately matter most to us, humans: self-determination, connection with each other, and the freedom to pursue what fulfils us,” Neil says.</p><p>Using these tools as guiding principles can provide powerful lenses for unlocking opportunities of evolving our business models for greater resilience and greater resistance to disruption. And more broadly, these principles are essential for greater alignment with the greater ecosystem of the planet. As the physical and the digital converge, becoming expert in discovering and activating potential connections across all domaines is ever more important.</p><p>For <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/lilysnyder/"><strong>Lily Snyder</strong></a>, <a href="https://journey.world/">Journey</a>’s head of metaverse research, “One of the foundations of the metaverse is gaming, and the other is community,” and with her talk she looked to give tools to analalyze the Web3 experience and being empowered to make a good decision. Videogames contribute to creating the virtual world that is often thought of as the metaverse. And what makes a game a game? Each game has goals, rules, and feedback loops; and there’s an instant sense of gratification when we figure one of them out. A game is a problem to be solved, and gamers are volunteers who want to solve it. That means, a game can create visible results, and can be used for that purpose in the Web3 community.</p><p>And what about community? There’s a saying: “metaverse is the people’s movement.” A community comes together around a common belief or cause. Similarly to a game, through feedback loops, data and tools, it refines its goal. Using the minds and the collective power, it is unleashed, and is able to come up with the community owned solution. Whether through your contribution to building the metaverse, or NFTs, think whether your experience meets the standards we’re all aiming for: decentralization, possibilities of co-creation and collaboration, a sense of authorship and ownership.</p><p><a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=elyssa+goldberg&amp;oq=elyssa+goldberg&amp;aqs=chrome.0.0i512j0i22i30j0i390l2.4735j0j7&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8"><strong>Elyssa Goldberg</strong></a>, head of growth at <a href="https://powder.gg/">Powder</a>, also spoke about Web3 and gaming, in particular blockchain gaming. Its emerging popularity has to do with the mechanics of gaming that permit people to have some ownership over assets they have been collecting, Elyssa claims, including the interoperable avatars. Additionally, there is economic utility, meaning that it’s possible to resell the items accrued during a prolonged period of gaming. But at this point, most gamers are intimidated by Web3 gaming, including setting up a wallet, learning about exchange rates, and so on. And most studios believe that Web3 games marketing is labor intensive — one has to spend hours on Twitter and Discord — and impractical compared to Web3 practices.</p><p>At the same time a lot of games have to rethink their marketing stack, taking the community aspect in. There are adjustments, and Elyssa has taken us through the various examples of these, describing Powder’s first-hand experience in making Web3 games they work with approachable and fun.</p><p>Thank you to all our wonderful contributors. And to all our readers: join us, it’s never too late!</p><h4>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h4><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> is the first community-run, asynchronous conference on the future of humanity, technology, and business in a decentralized world. It is run by the House of Beautiful Business in partnership with <a href="https://hotwireglobal.com/">Hotwire</a>, a global PR and communications consultancy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db9db4fac8f6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/shakespearean-avatars-crypto-remittance-and-matching-with-gamers-db9db4fac8f6">Shakespearean avatars, crypto remittance, and matching with gamers</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The End of Hierarchy: DAOs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-end-of-hierarchy-daos-eaf9cb88089?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eaf9cb88089</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Oct 2022 15:07:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-12T15:07:33.090Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Learning about DAOs with Marlene Ronstedt and Nishant Bhaskar</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OXspDDwMoxssFUYDHUo1Mw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“To me the idea of DAOs is so beautiful and powerful that I believe: if humans are a species with inherent regenerative tendencies, then DAOs will enable the best of what humanity could be” — Nishant Bhaskar</blockquote><p>For <a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=nishant+bhaskar&amp;oq=nishant+bhaskar&amp;aqs=chrome.0.69i59j0i512l3j0i22i30j69i60l3.4668j0j7&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8">Nishant Bhaskar</a>, co-founder and CEO of <a href="https://lomads.xyz/">Lomads DAO</a>, as for one of our very first speakers on this asynchronous conference, David Mattin, the ability of humans to coordinate at scale makes us truly unique as species. So why not strive to achieve even more because of it? DAOs have come to mean a new kind of world, one for freelancers, moveable, multi-specialized professionals, and contributors. And they can also help us overcome some of the challenges we’re facing in Web2 today, like data ownership.</p><p>We’ve all heard before that one of the weak spots of Web2 is the handling of users’ data, right? We’ve got almost no ownership, no control over it. It’s quite freaky.</p><p>But what are some concrete ways to address this problem, starting now? Enter <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/marlene-ronstedt-a61383141/?originalSubdomain=de">Marlene Ronstedt</a>, our last week’s speaker and the ​​co-founder of <a href="https://dataunions.org/">Data Union DAO</a>, where data ownership is revised. The idea behind Data Union is for people to be able to choose what kind of data they would like to contribute, do it, and get remunerated for the value of their contribution.</p><p>So imagine you choose something, like your data from Spotify, the liked tracks, favourite artists, and the record of your listening patterns. Imagine you partner up with a thousand other Spotify listeners. Based on your collective aggregated contribution, a data product is being contributed, and that creates impact. A data buyer can then buy that data set, or subscribe to a real-time version of that data, whereas you and other participants get paid for your data in crypto. And we’re talking about things already happening now. The biggest data union in this ecosystem, <a href="https://swashapp.io/">Swash</a>, has 400 000 members today.</p><p>So, DAOs, huh. Quite a mouthful, as Marlene says! There are many understandings and definitions of it, but perhaps to start, here <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1494244523983081475">are a few types</a> of them. There are <strong>Autonomous DAOs</strong> that operate through smart contracts and automatic execution of decisions. <strong>Bureaucratic DAOs</strong> constitute a messier model where joining is easier, through having the token, and decisions have to be implemented by its members. And then there are <strong>CEO DAOs</strong>, closest to Web2 models, where the decentralization aspect is manifested in the project being open-sourced and its code being on the chain, the teams being decentralized, and DAOs having numerous token holders.</p><p>The pendulum of “(de)centralization” is swinging hard from super classical structures of Web2 to completely novel forms of governance and collaboration in Web3. “But there is nothing wrong with progressive decentralization,” Nishant says. Going for a DAO structure doesn’t mean we’re forsaking other business models. It’s more of a gradual transition to these new models that use elements of our traditional structures in new ways.</p><p>So there are <strong>a few governance models </strong>among DAOs that Nishant spoke to us about. For example, the classical DeFi model, where the more financial skin in the game you have, the more voting power you’ve got. Another model does deals not only with the amount of finance put into the capital pool, but also the organization’s reputation, revenue growth, etc. And there are some others, with creators and their supporters, and the voting rights distributed among them.</p><p>What’s crucial is <strong>designing the incentives</strong>: tokens, benefits, discounts, ranking, points, quest boards, bounty boards, among others. Why so? Because “<strong>in DAOs people contribute if they receive the value</strong>,” Nishant says, so the aspects that matter are value, behaviour, and objective. How do you want people to participate and behave? It’s about rewarding these behaviours and penalizing the ones you don’t want reproduced.</p><p>Marlene and her teammates from Data Unions DAO are currently working on creating and staking their own governance token to build a community around it, vote on funding proposals. And the toughest part, she says, is making it secure and legal for everyone. Like, to avoid community members <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/03/business/kim-kardashian-sec-crypto.html">being fined for $1.26 million</a> for crypto promotion by the S.E.C., like Kim Kardashian. Staking, in particular, is what makes a DAO trustworthy. “It’s what aligns the ecosystem,” Marlene concludes.</p><p>Tokens can be independently affiliated, they can be security or utility oriented. But being a DAO doesn’t necessarily mean you need to have a token, Nishant says; DAOs can be used for voting on Discord, for example. “It’s all about finding the right balance of what’s at stake.”</p><p>As Marlene says, the adoption of these technologies depends on the cultural attitude towards processes like data sharing (which is not widely popular in Europe). The process takes time; but both our speakers agree that it’s quite alright. For Nishant, organizations are following growth patterns, like humans—there’s childhood, then adolescence, then early adulthood, and so on. The whole process is like moving from an early adopters’ market, to early majority market. But don’t worry about having to discover too much all at once. “Initially you don’t need governance models or tokens: just find a small team and experiment with this novel kind of work structure,” Nishant recommends. The basics are: you need to attract people, have a well-defined cause, and have a clear path to value. And Nishant and his team from Lomads DAO will be there to help you simplify things and help you with the most basic tools to get started.</p><h3>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h3><p>There couldn’t be a better moment to do so! This week we opened up the stage to our participants, who are rocking it with their own wisdom: Shakespearean avatars, crypto for financial freedom, matching with gamers, and the manifolds of the metaverse, among other topics. Tune in at any moment to hear their contributions!</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eaf9cb88089" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-end-of-hierarchy-daos-eaf9cb88089">The End of Hierarchy: DAOs</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reimagining collaboration with Web3]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/reimagining-collaboration-with-web3-84cc57c6db14?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84cc57c6db14</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Oct 2022 10:05:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-05T10:49:03.204Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Talking about <strong>decentralized collaboration </strong>with <strong>Kerem Alper</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CVtoWzK69iniYbJGxu6XYg.gif" /></figure><p>“What is the problem with current models of collaboration?” <a href="https://kyu.com/about/kerem-alper"><strong>Kerem Alper</strong></a> asks. He is the co-founder of <a href="https://www.atolye.io/en/home/">ATÖLYE</a>, a community-powered creative services organization, and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/3276605426/">Neol</a>, a decentralized collaboration platform targeting design and creative professionals, as well as corporate innovation managers.</p><p>The problem seems to be: people doing things internally, behind closed doors and thick walls. The team behind ATÖLYE strives to build a community system around a wide group of innovators, designers, technologists, and thinkers with whom they can collaborate openly, and at scale. At Neol, a more recent platform, Kerem and his team want to push the boundaries farther and think: What would be a truly decentralized version of creating a platform where companies could find teams to collaborate with, where individuals could engage in powerful learning journeys?</p><p>“Learning is an incredibly tool for collaboration and community building,” he says, “Through such experiences and networks companies work on some of their toughest challenges, and by having access to inspiring organizations they become better versions of themselves.”</p><p>Neol is a decentralized, soon-to-be-tokenized platform which aims to think about collaboration among individuals and companies through a timely lens that aims to take current paradigm shifts into account. Overall, the world is becoming more complex, and the challenges companies and working individuals face today are redefined, so new approaches need to constantly be discovered.</p><blockquote>“We need to tap into different pockets of wisdom from people of different backgrounds, parts of the world, cultures and experiences”</blockquote><p>Today’s trends such as the Great Resignation and the gig economy are also shifting a global vision of talent. Individuals identify as multi-dimensional, and don’t want to be categorized strictly under one role, like “strategists”, “graphic designers”, or “business developers.” But organizations are often surrounded by thick walls, and that often makes them not suitable enough for the challenge presented. “Creators and innovators need to look for new ways of coming together, breaking away from the same old echo chambers,” Kerem concludes. His goals is to find new ways of empowering the individual in alternative work settings, and create support mechanisms, structures, and so on.</p><blockquote>“Imagine all the know-how that exists within a structure! The question is, how do we create models where it’s shared more extensively from within? How do you tie that to internal incentive mechanisms?”</blockquote><h4><strong>Empowerment of the individual through Web3</strong></h4><p>For Kerem, Web3 is very collaborative in and of itself, with users constantly sharing white papers on their experience — and that creates an openness that hasn’t really existed before. At ATÖLYE and Neol Web3 is primarily practiced as a mode of thinking and a way of discovering desired behaviours that need to happen in a system. It allows to pose such questions: How can value be created and can it be tracked? What are intrinsic and extrinsic motivations of individuals? Can we create a transparent and equitable system? “Web3 can shift mindsets, and the world of consultancies and education is ripe for this transformation,” Kerem says. “The dangerous thing is to be obsessed by the token mechanism, and hope that that mechanism will solve all the problems. Tokens are simply a method, a tool that can only be used as long as there’s value.”</p><p>At Neol, Kerem and his team are creating the suitable environment for collaboration to happen, then tuning into epicenters of value creation, and shifting the mindset of traditional investment towards a true participation and new ways of investing into the system. Web3, with the use of tokens and tools, gives individuals a chance to invest in content creation, and be the first supporters of lecturers, artists, innovators. And Kerem’s goal is to bring that model to the world of education.</p><p>Many legacy organizations will need to transform themselves to be able to better engage with these new systems by changing their procurement, legal, and operational processes. But Kerem believes: we are looking at a shift from a consumer-client user mindset to an initiator-believer-investor one. And at both companies, Kerem and his teams combine aspects of Web2 and Web3, “starting Web2” in the way value is created and distributed, and look for ways to apply the Web3 innovation.</p><p>To hear more about the new systems and models of collaboration, DAOs, mechanisms of incentivization from within, and so on, <a href="https://vimeo.com/753756296">watch</a> <strong>Kerem Alper</strong> in conversation with <strong>Till Grusche</strong>, the co-founder of the <strong>House of Beautiful Business</strong>.</p><h3>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h3><p>This week we’re discussing DAOs, decentralized power, governance, and decision-making with <a href="https://ronstedt.space/"><strong>Marlene Ronstedt</strong></a>, co-founder of Data Union DAO, and <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/nishantbhaskar/?originalSubdomain=fr"><strong>Nishant Bhaskar</strong></a>, co-founder and CEO of Lomads.</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84cc57c6db14" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/reimagining-collaboration-with-web3-84cc57c6db14">Reimagining collaboration with Web3</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Real-life impact, one NFT at a time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/real-life-impact-one-nft-at-a-time-8100fdb7bfee?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8100fdb7bfee</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Sep 2022 08:57:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-04T16:09:51.534Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Laura François</strong>, founder of Actually People, talks about creating positive social impact</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hhm50Ke8UlOc3sYF3qnLaQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Laura’s interest in social impact sprouts from the years she spent living in South Asia, working in the domain of human rights, and looking at fashion as its storytelling tool. That work made her see the interconnection between human rights and environmental rights, and apprehend their interconnectivity. With the aim of moving the narrative forward, she began exploring human migration patterns—and with that, Web3, with concepts like <em>proof of identification. </em>Today, she is still exploring<em> </em>new ways to leverage this new world and find appreciation for it, while pushing the same narrative:</p><p><em>How do we make sure that social and environmental rights are promoted through technology, storytelling, and art?</em></p><p>To her, the Web3 space seemed to provide empathetic ways for human connection, a really wholesome and kind one—and that was enough to draw her in, open up a <a href="https://www.actuallypeople.com/">community</a> for building empathy and curiosity for humans, to serve as a reminder that we are all <strong><em>Actually People</em></strong>.</p><p>This project began through a collab with a non-profit, <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/arthelps/"><strong>Art Helps</strong></a>, that builds tangible art projects in high-conflict areas as a way to provide second aid for communities who really need space to feel freedom and creativity. Laura wanted to help them fund projects using Web3 and a <strong>decentralized fundraising</strong>, but as soon as she received the green light, war in Ukraine broke out. Together, Actually People and Art Helps quickly adapted their collaboration model and decided to build a physical space for creating art backed by a digital community of like-minded people.</p><p>Laura’s entire career has been focused on measuring impact—but impact is never just good or bad, it’s always both, she says. And for her, using Web3 technology is a very interesting way to get very tangible about the impact of their organization in real life.</p><blockquote>“Using NFTs is a way to design positive impact to occur from the get-go, to inherently architect it within the paradigm of what we’re building.”</blockquote><p>Laura sees a decentralized funding through the NFTs as a win-win: a chance to create an architecture for this to happen in perpetuity, and build a community project that holds financial value for the community holders as well as fund the non-profit. The non-profit, in this case Art Helps, can thus focus on what they do best: delivering art workshops. Such funding also allows people to contribute to a common “bank” of a physical space that will be based either in Ukraine or Iraq (they’re deciding on it as you read this). Their goal is to build a creative space that will exist within these refugee communities they’re working with. So every time someone purchases an NFT, a little bit more of that building space can exist. As a bonus, buyers have access to Actually People’s shopping list, and can see where the funding from the purchase of that NFT goes to, be it wall paint, light bulbs, or anything else. It builds a lot of trust, but that also means they have to get everything right. “It’s kind of like meeting someone for the first time and showing all your cards — there’s no room for failure,” Laura says.</p><p>The first NFT collection was Actually People’s co-creation with the Art Helps and a community of around 50 children from Ukraine, Syria, Egypt who had relocated to Germany. During the workshop they explored a few concepts alongside various artists and created a set of characters that embody a person’s creative spark. “You know that feeling that you get not just when you’re ‘writing a novel’ or painting, but making a sandwich, or getting dressed,” Laura describes, “That feeling that you’re communicating something you’re feeling.”</p><p>The result of this collaboration was a set of characters that embody a person’s creative spark, turned into a series of NFTs called <a href="https://mobile.twitter.com/creativeonesnft"><em>The Creative Ones</em></a>, impersonations of those sparks. Any time someone mints the NFT, they input the answers to a few questions — “kind of like pulling a tarot card” — and their<em> creative one</em> becomes a representation of who they are, and a personification of that spark — “a visionary”, “a destructive creative”, etc.</p><p>When doing something impactful, you want to be able to be sure of the positive income — but in the Web3 space one needs to accept the uncertainty, Laura says. Of course the co-existence of the digital project and real-life impact can be intimidating, too. Decentralized funding needs to work “today” to be able to bring people in a bus from Ukraine, or cater to other urgent needs. These are real tangible necessities, and Laura is still learning her way around it.</p><blockquote>“We have to embrace experimentation as this acknowledgement that we don’t have all the answers, we’re just in this liminal space where the solutions, the processes and the community are still being built. The rules aren’t there yet, and that feels both scary and liberating. We all need a dose of insanity and bravery to even be thinking about Web3”.</blockquote><h3>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h3><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8100fdb7bfee" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/real-life-impact-one-nft-at-a-time-8100fdb7bfee">Real-life impact, one NFT at a time</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Value of Art, the Art of Value]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-value-of-art-the-art-of-value-66be1e4aee58?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/66be1e4aee58</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Sep 2022 13:18:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-21T13:18:41.185Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Learning about decentralization through art that reflects on global tipping points with Chow and Lin, an art-duo from Beijing</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tUi2mXW4C8-t0LWjdePh4A.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are still millions of people who live below the poverty line today. In the realm of photography, poverty is often expressed through the portraits of the poor. It comes to a point when one gets exposed to one too many of these images, and the society that consumes this media becomes desensitized to the whole idea of what poverty is. So <strong>Chow and Lin, an artistic duo from Beijing</strong>, decided to bring attention to this overlooked issue of market economy in an alternative way—and use art and blockchain to reinforce their argument.</p><p>Stefen Chow and Hui-Yi Lin both grew up in Singapore. “We were both born with silver spoons in our mouths, in middle-class families” Stefen says, “But before we were of school age, both of our families have actually lost everything.” Stefen is a trained photographer, and Lin used to work in the Singapore government, where she would see how policies would affect people on the ground. Their experiences were very different, but they shared a personal relation to poverty.</p><p>With the help of Lin, a trained economist, they started studying poverty as an economic term, and broke poverty into an amount of food a poor person can have in a single day. Their intention was to show that poverty does not equate to homelessness; at the poverty line, people <em>do </em>have income, it’s just not enough to have a decent level of living. Back in 2010 the poverty line in China was drawn at around 50 cents US. For that value, a person could get some vegetables, rice, or one single chicken breast at the market. Armed with data, Chow and Lin dove into this experiment. They took pictures of the food bought with the daily quota on top of newspapers, because of how universally affordable and familiar it is as an object, no matter the political system. For the next ten years Chow and Lin took pictures of the food bought at the poverty line in different countries. The resulting project is called <a href="https://www.chowandlin.com/thepovertyline"><em>The Poverty Line</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>They were looking at such food staples around the world: China, India, Norway, Denmark, France, Germany, and so on, then turned their attention to a Chinese mantou bun, a “tasteless bagel” that’s very filling and easy to carry. Over the years the cost of a mantou rose to 1 renminbi, a coin similar to a one euro coin. Simultaneously over the same period of time cash as a form of exchange has virtually disappeared in China, giving way to digital wallets and cryptocurrencies. With that, the whole understanding and role of money, as well as the notion of stability, has changed. Only the poor still had cash.</p><p>Through looking at the nature of an exchange that has evolved with the disappearance of cash, Chow and Lin realized that food, a necessity for life, is heavily subsidized in many countries, with food staples taken for granted. Through an experimentation with the concept of exchange, Chow and Lin’s project <strong><em>Decentralized Value Systems</em></strong> was born. They would play with extracting the shared aspect of money from a pair of apples equaling 1200 mantous. Turning the different foods into a mosaic on the floor, they asked: does it still have value, or is it wasted? Shown lying on the floor, it would seem essential; but when food was equated to money instead of other foods, somehow it wasn’t worth that much anymore. Throughout the process, <strong>Chow and Lin wanted to question our logic of what the value is.</strong></p><p>Eventually the project became an <a href="https://opensea.io/collection/decentralizedvaluesystems01">NFT series sold of Opensea</a>, making a point about the volatility of value even seen through the means of cryptocurrency. “What systems are we operating in?”, Chow and Lin ask, “What systems are bound to stay or change? Food is available as long as the systems are stable, but our supply chains are changing due to global warming and political events. And with this fragility <em>essential food</em> becomes <em>expensive</em>.</p><p>A few years back Chow and Lin visited a UNHCR refugee camp in Kakuma, Kenya, and witnessed the power of the systems that divide us. This visit made them see that the world does not consist of people with money and without, but those with status and without it, the have and the have-nots. The power that the systems have of destabilizing such essential aspects of living as food or status is at the core of Chow and Lin’s art.</p><h3>Check this out</h3><ul><li>Wach my conversation with Stefen Chow (and please forgive the dreadful echo!)</li><li>Chow and Lin’s projects <a href="https://www.chowandlin.com/thepovertyline"><em>The Poverty Line</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.decentralizedvaluesystems.com/"><em>Decentralized Value Systems</em></a></li></ul><p>And join us this week! We are hosting a conversation with <strong>Laura François</strong>, founder of Actually People and the Creative Ones NFT project who looks at art as a method of communication and ecosystem empowerment. We’ll hear about her experience with alternative decentralized funding mechanisms for social good, and building physical social impact spaces through digital communities.</p><h3>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h3><p>This week we’re talking about the value of art and the art of value with a Beijing-based art duo <a href="https://www.chowandlin.com/">Chow and Lin</a>. We speak about merging art with market economics, bringing attention to the global tipping points of our times, like the poverty line, and using Web3 technology to challenge the question of value in art and social issues.</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=66be1e4aee58" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/the-value-of-art-the-art-of-value-66be1e4aee58">The Value of Art, the Art of Value</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NFTs That Diversify Power and Decolonize Knowledge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/nfts-that-diversify-power-and-decolonize-knowledge-562600ea3e9?source=rss-35a56c9f9717------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/562600ea3e9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Journal of Beautiful Business]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Sep 2022 08:13:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-14T08:13:31.550Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Speaking on diversity, inclusion, and education with Maliha Abidi, Joana Lacerda, and Paff Evara</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*KUqwZ-JqkYVTJfiiKcX-SQ.gif" /><figcaption>Art: Maliha Abidi ©</figcaption></figure><p>During the last week of our asynchronous conference we heard from <strong>Maliha Abidi</strong>, Pakistani-American artist and activist, founder of NFT community <a href="https://womenrise.art/">Women Rise </a>and author of <em>Rise: Extraordinary Women of Colour who Changed the World </em>and <em>Pakistan for Women; </em><strong>Joana Lacerda</strong>, Portuguese entrepreneur, founder of <a href="https://www.womenweb3.org/">WomenWeb3</a>, and creative director of Women Labs, which “represents the bold and unpolished women of Web3;” and <strong>Paff Evara</strong>, co-founder of <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/takeupspace/">Take Up Space</a>, an online platform and community for the next generation of diverse change-makers.</p><p>Maliha and Joana use art to bring awareness to issues close to their heart: empowerment, diversity, inclusion, and education. They strongly believe that Web3 can greatly help us build stronger communities and achieve increased representation.</p><p>“How can art enable the actors in the system to really promote better living for everyone?” Joana asks.</p><p>For Maliha, art became her personal way of coping with the isolation, the culture shock, and confronting the issues that affected her as a woman of color and a Muslim after moving to the US at the age of 14. Ten years later, she uses art as a tool for storytelling, to celebrate and represent women. Maliha’s project, <a href="https://womenrise.art/"><strong>WomenRise</strong></a>, comprises 10,000 NFTs that represent women from all over the world. She sees Web3 is a way to encourage women, people of color, and other underrepresented groups to take up space which was inaccessible to them for so long.</p><p>Not coincidentally, <strong>Take Up Space </strong>is the name of a community and platform founded by <strong>Paff Evara</strong> and her partner for LQBTQ and BIPOC change-makers, aimed to empower, onboard, and educate these people in Web3 to become the next generation of diverse leaders.</p><blockquote>“We’re all about empowering the individual, and focusing on underrepresented people. It’s no doubt that Web3 has a bit of an image problem, and,<strong> I think we could all agree, it is a little bit pale, male, and stale</strong>.”</blockquote><p>Paff quotes Patrice Palmer, a doctoral candidate in the School of Education at Baylor University: “It’s one thing to say, all people are welcome, and it’s another thing to say, I had you in mind.”</p><p>The changemaker curriculum at Take Up Space consists of a three-phased approach to personal growth, and it’s all about healing, removing limiting beliefs, building network, and leading. “Myself being black, queer, and neurodivergent, I wanted to create a community that I wished that I had when I was just starting my career,” Paff says.</p><p>But you can’t expect the individual to bring all the change—there’s systemic, organizational change that needs to happen, so the other part of Take Up Space is called Make Space. It’s a DEI consultancy that partners with brands. Through working with this consultancy brands are able to get real insights from different communities, understand lived experiences, and make sure they are using the right language, terminology, etc.</p><p>“We want to help people take up space in Web3 and help brands make space for underrepresented communities in Web3 and beyond,” Paff summarizes.</p><p><strong>Joana Lacerda </strong>has considered herself a changemaker from day one. If Maliha used painting as a way to bring attention to such matters as inclusion and diversity, Joana used architecture as a way to promote human rights and speak for the underrepresented people.</p><p>Today, it’s all about building the new spaces for Joana. She names some numbers: about 73% of crypto owners are men and only 60% of women understand what an NFT is. She believes there’s a drastic need for change. Her space WomenWeb3 was born out of the need to scream to the world: <strong>There should be more women involved in this!</strong></p><p>She also believes Web3 should be built from scratch, and not be made by a transition from Web2. “The only way to change the system is by changing the story and not to “transition” it”, she tells Monika Jiang. And the way to bring that change is through better education.</p><p><strong>Maliha, Joana, and Paff</strong>, each in her own way, all see Web3 as a way to increase and normalize education around the world. Maliha wants to make Web3 accessible and create educational initiatives using this space for 129 million of women and girls around the world who have not had access to education.</p><p>On the other hand, the mindset and ethos of educators is also crucial here, says Joana, who works a lot with the European commissions. Systems like the European Commission are still very self-centered, she says, and that needs to shift. There is no openness to the approach of co-creation there, but decolonizing knowledge and creating diversity is the key to changing our reality.</p><blockquote><strong>We are all, including from the business side perspective, are co-creators of the systems and products that will be there for us. </strong>We need to unlearn and build from scratch. <strong>We are the wild ones thinking about rewriting the systems.</strong></blockquote><h4><strong>Check this out</strong></h4><ul><li><a href="https://soundcloud.com/houseofbeautifulbusiness/joana-lacerda-nfts-that-represent-and-empower-everyone">Listen</a> to Joana Lacerda in conversation with Monika Jiang</li><li>Watch my conversation with <strong>Maliha Abidi</strong> <a href="https://vimeo.com/736847370">here</a></li><li><a href="https://soundcloud.com/houseofbeautifulbusiness/paff-evara">Listen</a> to Paff Evara’s voice note</li></ul><h4>Some recommended sources from Joana</h4><p>Here are some initiatives recommended in our #houseverse by Joana Lacerda where you can learn more:</p><ul><li>Metaschool: <a href="https://metaschool.so/courses">hands-on Web3 learning</a></li><li>A <a href="https://www.mybff.com/">community</a> for the crypto curious</li><li>A “<a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ObiFHmmZnWmX5alar-O81QwkAHFERKUFDDo2AcEDPZg/edit">bible of content</a>” around key topics on the web3</li><li>A <a href="https://docs.celo.org/">mobile-first blockchain</a> with a mission is to build a financial system that creates the conditions for prosperity for everyone</li><li>A <a href="https://codegreen.earth/">decentralized non-profit</a> with a mission to help the crypto and NFT community to have a positive impact on our planet</li></ul><h4>Want to learn more and join our 20-week-long learning journey?</h4><p>This week we’re talking about the value of art and the art of value with a Beijing-based art duo <a href="https://www.chowandlin.com/">Chow and Lin</a>. We speak about merging art with market economics, bringing attention to the global tipping points of our times, like the poverty line, and using Web3 technology to challenge the question of value in art and social issues.</p><p><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><strong>Sign up for free here</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><p><em>Katia Zoritch, writer at the House of Beautiful Business</em></p><p><em>The House of Beautiful Business is a global community with the mission to make business more beautiful. Learn more about our Beautiful Business Trip, in partnership with global PR and communications consultancy Hotwire </em><a href="https://houseofbeautifulbusiness.com/beautiful-business-web3"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=562600ea3e9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3/nfts-that-diversify-power-and-decolonize-knowledge-562600ea3e9">NFTs That Diversify Power and Decolonize Knowledge</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/beautiful-business-in-web3">Beautiful Business in Web3</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>