<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jennifer Trainor on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jennifer Trainor on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 02:31:34 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jstrainor/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does Helicopter Parenting Harm Kids’ Ability to Think for Themselves?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/lythcott-haims-book-led-me-to-terry-castle-s-2012-essay-about-helicopter-parenting-an-essay-that-5732281d6ce1?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5732281d6ce1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Mar 2016 20:39:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T17:16:15.316Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*qz8tlgu-30TBbTf42RkPcQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="http://chronicle.com/article/The-Case-for-Breaking-Up-With/131760/">Terry Castle’s 2012 essay about helicopter parenting</a> goes way beyond decrying pushy parents or worrying about over-scheduled, constantly monitored kids, to the philosophic, psychological, and moral dimensions of parent-child relationships in general. For Castle, these relationships are essentially about the individual’s relationship to authority, and she argues that it is every person’s right and responsibility to break with authority in order to become a free-thinking adult:</p><blockquote>it is indeed the self-conscious abrogation of one’s inheritance, the “making strange” of received ideas, the cultivation of a willingness to defy, debunk, or just plain old disappoint one’s parents, that is the absolute precondition, now more than ever, for intellectual and emotional freedom.</blockquote><p>Castle goes on to argue that metaphoric orphanhood — think Harry Potter, Jane Eyre, Huck Finn — is a primary trope of Western fiction since the Enlightenment, and that metaphoric orphanhood is what made the Englightenment, with its emphasis on individual rights and freedom, possible. In essence, we all have to break with authority to be free-thinking individuals capable of democracy, and the first authority we have to break with is our parents, with a close second being our teachers. Today’s young people, both Castle and Haims (and a host of others) insist, have not broken with their parents and hence don’t know how to think for themselves. Indeed, she cites as an example employers who hire recent college grads, only to find that they can’t work unless tasks are spelled out for them in lists of directions and steps. They can’t take a problem and run with it, in ways that bosses often want their employees to do.</p><p>But true adulthood, Castle argues, requires taking responsibility and assuming the innate expertise to solve, think, design, create, vote, and live. We can’t depend on experts all the time (we can’t always expect a list of directions or steps) and indeed, progress depends on our learning to think critically about and move past the expertise and authority embodied in the previous generation.</p><p>But here’s where Castle gets really interesting: before the Enlightenment, she writes, humans did not aim to become autonomous individuals capable of thinking on their own, free from authority and parents and custom and tradition. In fact, the opposite was true (and is still true in many parts of the world): one was born into and expected to remain ensconced within a set of traditions where elders and authorities had the answers and our role was to follow and live those answers.</p><p>So what if, Castle muses, the rise of helicopter parenting combined with the connectedness brought about by the digital age (today’s undergraduates apparently text their parents several times a day) are ushering in a new cultural understanding of the individual and authority? What if we’re exiting the Age of the Individual and entering the Age of the Community, where novices don’t break from experts but rather work side-by-side with them? What if we are moving away from individualism and autonomy (with its requirements that we push away from our parents, rebel against the establishment and its institutions, like school) and entering a much more connected, inter-dependence?</p><p>Although I can see how this would not necessarily be a bad thing (and indeed, I just saw a story in Slate this weekend about the isolation and loneliness many professionals feel, having moved away from home and family to pursue promising creative, professional and artistic paths), I also really sympathize with Castle’s belief in the importance of autonomy and critical thinking. It’s disturbing to see undergraduates who don’t embrace freedom, and who seem to want to be told how to complete every intellectual task. It’s disturbing to see assignments with every step laid out for the student; grading rubrics that speak from on-high about what “good” writing is; detailed syllabi that read more like legal contracts than invitations to think, create, and explore.</p><p>But Castle’s point — that our belief in the importance of critical and independent thinking may be tied to a waning political era, and my realization that whatever new era is dawning (the age of the expert? the age of connectedness? Interdependence?) may not be all bad — is reshaping how I think about parenting and teaching. I have been worried about how I can foster independence and critical thinking in my kids and my students. I have wanted to wean them from dependence on my expertise and authority, and I have believed, especially with students, that their dependence on my authority can only be negative — critical thinking must be accomplished by separating from and interrogating authority, not acquiescing to it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*ht81zk4WIwD3yY_edNZnYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>But what if in this age of easy connections and easy access to information, the relationship between authority/expert and novice is not one of struggle for power and control, but one of collaboration? Collaboration between teacher and student, and between parent and kid? So those detailed step-by-step assignments are new artifacts in the age of sharing and connection between those who know and those who are learning. Those college kids who text their parents three times a day (and my kids will probably be among them some day — true confession: my 11 year old Facetimed me the other day so I could help him figure out how to lace his new basketball shoes) are forging new identities for all of us based on connection, support, and collaboration.</p><p>So, college-aged readers: does this ring true for you? have you rebelled against or intellectually separated from your parents and teachers or are you dependent in the ways Castle and Haims fear? Or is there a more hopeful view, as I’ve tried to articulate here?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5732281d6ce1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Helicopter Teachers: Assignment Designs that Misunderstand Development and Hinder Learning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/i-m-reading-julie-lythcott-haims-how-to-raise-an-adult-143cde03d48e?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/143cde03d48e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Mar 2016 03:23:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T16:40:38.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m reading Julie Lythcott-Haims’<a href="http://www.howtoraiseanadult.com/"> How to Raise an Adult.</a> My review so far (I’m only 40 pages in): it’s not telling me anything I didn’t already know, but it is exceptionally well-written and the examples themselves are worth the price of the book. Haims writes of parents who insist that their teenagers text them every hour that they are away from home or school, who track their college-age kids via GPS, who try to escort their elementary-age kids all the way into the classroom (rather than dropping them in front of the school, allowing them to walk/ride or take the bus), who carry backpacks and water bottles for their kids and who check their kids’ academic progress online every day. In one of the most ludicrous, but metaphorically resonant and troubling examples, Haims cites a product that allows anxious parents to control the brakes on their kids’ bikes via remote control!</p><p>One of my big questions is how such parental surveillance and desire for control connects to, or overlaps with, or influences teachers and classrooms. In some ways the connections are easy to imagine. If parents expect to control the kid’s bicycle brakes, they probably also expect to control her experience in math class. No bike accidents (because Mom’s in charge of the brakes!) and no failed math tests (because Mom’s in charge of school too!). Parents who want to shield their child from the risks that accompany pedaling a small bike on a big street probably also hope to shield him/her from the confusion and messiness that accompanies learning challenging material. They are going to want that material rendered “safe.”</p><p>But going a bit deeper, I think there are parallel misunderstandings about the nature of learning that govern helicopter parenting and modern-day education. Teachers, it should be said, like the parents with the remote control, are acting with the best of intentions: we want to protect students, to facilitate their success, to pave the way. But like the parent with the remote in hand, we risk depriving our students of important learning opportunities, and sometimes turn them off to learning in the process (I imagine that the fun of cycling is lost if every time a hovering adult thought you were going too fast, you were forced to slow down. The same can be said of learning and writing: how much fun is writing when every sentence feels dictated by an authority figure?).</p><p>This morning, I was looking at writing assignments from across the disciplines, and they reminded me strongly of bicycles with parent-controls.</p><p>Buried in all of the assignments I looked at were exciting intellectual projects and rich learning experiences for students. But layered over the top were tables and grids, bullet points and paragraphs instructing the student in what MUST be done, and what NOT to do: “Forecast your main idea,” “Do not list your sources on a separate page,” “Your essay should be at least three pages long but no more than five pages long.” Some assignments provided a confusing mix of freedom and restriction (that remote controlled bicycle again): “You do not have to include every bullet item, but you do need to include all six major sections (and it’s up to you whether or not you use section headings in your paper).”</p><p>As a teacher, I definitely understand the impetus behind these instructions — much in the same way that as a parent, I understand the impulse to slow my kids down on their bikes. I know that learning does require some support — scaffolding — in the beginning (training wheels, perhaps, or those low-to-the-ground, easy-to-maneuver balance bikes — as well as safe, wide streets with plenty of room for error. We don’t, after all, send 8 year olds to cycle on narrow mountain roads, for obvious reasons). This is where both parenting and teaching are at their trickiest — where the importance of guidance and structure meets the imperative of exploration, discovery, freedom, and yes, risk. When should we guide and instruct and control, and when do we turn students loose? An <a href="http://compositionforum.com/issue/14.2/wilner-assignment-design.php">article </a>by Arlene Willner, an expert on writing assignments and learning, helps explain this tricky question.</p><p>On the one hand, Willner writes, students struggle with writing assignments because they don’t understand the big picture. They don’t understand the assumptions and taken-for-granted knowledge of their teachers. Recognizing this lack of understanding, teachers put in place rules and regulations to guide students toward what is obvious to the teacher but opaque to students. But these regulations, ironically, obscure more than they reveal for students, who take from them the mistaken idea that the teacher wants them to follow the rules. The teacher hopes students to learn from the rules the big-picture ideas that the assignment is intended to illuminate. The student sees only the rules, and perhaps something else as well: he/she sees an exercise of authority by an expert, an exercise whose implicit message is: you can’t do this on your own. It’s the remote-controlled brakes all over again: the parent says “I’m helping you achieve the goal of safe cycling.” The child, on some level, hears: this is too dangerous or hard for you to manage on your own.</p><p>I might be stretching the bicycle-brakes metaphor here, but if the big idea at stake in learning to ride a bike is something unpredictable, and messy, like “when to use brakes to ensure safety and fun” then putting parents in charge of braking is destined to fail. It will teach kids that parents know best, it will free kids from the responsibility of safety, but it will not encourage them to explore risk and safety themselves. Bike-riding, it turns out, is a wicked problem, of the sort I mentioned in my last blog post. And a wicked problem, as Willner, quoting Donald Schon, writes, requires:</p><blockquote>a holistic skill. In an important sense, one must grasp [the problem] as a whole in order to grasp it at all. Therefore, one cannot learn it in a molecular way, by learning first to carry out smaller units of activity and then to string those units together in a whole design process; for the pieces tend to interact with one another and to derive their meanings and characters from the whole process in which they are embedded. (158).</blockquote><p>I think there is a lot of stuff going on with parents who control the brakes on their kids bikes (anxiety and fear and a misplaced sense of a parent’s role and a misplaced need for control). But I also think Haims’ example of parent-controlled biking says a lot about our misunderstanding of how people learn. You don’t control the pedals, and then the handle bars, and then the brakes, in order to learn to ride a bike safely. You don’t learn about the importance of slowing down by having someone else do it for you, and you don’t learn it without falling a few times.</p><p>Similarly, students won’t learn the purpose and context of academic writing by following teacher-mandated rules about format and structure. They can’t learn it, as Schon says, “in a molecular way.” There has to be corners taken too fast, skid marks on the driveway, the occasional tumble over the handle bars. There has to be a way to dive in, doing it all at once and one thing at a time at the same time. As Wilner writes,</p><blockquote>research suggests that the complex moves required to relate parts to a whole are considered essential to learning theory. In studies of expert vs. novice problem-solving, cognitive scientists have noted the importance of patterns, “big ideas,” or conceptual understanding in enabling effective solutions: the knowledge of experts “is organized around core concepts or ‘big ideas’ that guide their thinking about their domains” [ <em>How People Learn</em> 24].</blockquote><p>How do we engage students in the “big ideas” that guide intellectual life? The same way we teach kids to ride a bike: by holding on, providing a space safe, and then letting go.</p><p>Schon, Donald A. <em>Educating the Reflective Practitioner</em>. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1990.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=143cde03d48e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Teaching Students to Tackle Wicked Problems]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/when-it-comes-to-education-i-have-some-ideas-that-are-let-s-just-say-a-bit-outside-the-40dc6ecd46d5?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40dc6ecd46d5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Feb 2016 18:54:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-30T16:24:22.135Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BJWShuL4pLqsl5Z4SlHcsQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>When it comes to education, I have some ideas that are, let’s just say, a bit outside the mainstream. I think <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/primaryeducation/12038625/Reading-writing-and-mud-the-growth-of-Forest-Schools.html">preschoolers should go to school in the forest,</a> for example. I’m opposed to <a href="http://www.alfiekohn.org/article/case-grades/">grading</a>, which I believe undermines intrinsic motivation. I think education is more <a href="http://www.wesjones.com/gatto1.htm">indoctrinating </a>than we like to believe. I’m convinced that lists of student learning outcomes — those ubiquitous and weirdly coercive statements about what “students will be able to do” at the end of a semester — and tools such as grading rubrics send students the wrong message about learning and about writing.</p><p>Most of these beliefs can be backed up by scholarship, as the links in the above paragraph attest to. But I always thought my irritation with rubrics and learning outcomes was personal, not principled, and so for many years, I dutifully listed outcomes on my syllabus and tried to make my feedback to student writers conform to standardized rubrics. I assumed my inability to use these tools in a meaningful way was evidence of some lack in me as a teacher. Why was I unable to make complex ideas clear and accessible to students via outcomes or a rubric? Why did I insist on making everything messy and complicated all the time?</p><p>Gert Biesta and Alfie Kohn are among the scholars who challenge the tools of standardized education, including rubrics and student learning outcomes (SLOs). Biesta argues that rubrics and SLO’s aren’t neutral tools, in the way a chalkboard, for example, is neutral. Instead, these tools are designed for standardization and efficiency, as much as for learning. She shows how these tools negate the principles of student-centered learning that many of us value: they shave off the messy edges of teaching and learning, giving everyone (students and teachers) the wrong impression that uncertainties have been vanquished, complexity has been tamed, and the unmeasurable has been measured, objectified, and brought under control. Taken together, Biesta and Kohn suggest that as educators we need to rethink our assumptions about the value of rubrics and SLOs because these tools disable critical thinking, rather than support student learning.</p><p>Let’s start with those seemingly innocuous list of outcomes attached to every syllabus and assignment. have pointed to several problems with outcomes. <a href="http://www.gertbiesta.com/">Biesta</a> critiques the standards movement in education for, among other things, failing to capture the moral, philosophic, and ethical dimensions of teaching and learning. To sum up what I learned from reading her: Most things worth learning fall under the category of what designers call “wicked” problems. Wicked problems are those that don’t have one solution or an agreed upon outcome, or clear-cut methods. Designing a bridge is not a wicked problem. Figuring out how to get cars across the river without disrupting traffic flow on the East End, and while paying attention to the new baseball field being built at the base of the bridge and while juggling the results from the environmental impact study which shows that bridges tend to cause pollution and while figuring out a way to keep costs low because the tax bond measure that was supposed to pay for the bridge didn’t get enough votes —<strong> that’s</strong> a wicked problem.</p><p>SLOs and rubrics reduce the complexity that goes into real-life bridge-building, and assume that the only aspect of bridge-building worth teaching or measuring is the quantifiable calculations needed to figure out the bridge’s construction. In this way, rubrics and SLOs favor a technical model of education where the only questions to ask are about effectiveness and measurable results. For Biesta, wicked problem-solving is moral and ethical, philosophic, rhetorical, and strategic, not, or not only, technical and rationale. And so, she argues, our teaching needs to reflect the messiness inherent in wicked problems, rather than reducing all problems to something falsely manageable (and hence teachable).</p><p>Like Biesta, Alfie Kohn, also critiques the tools of standardization in education. And like Biesta, Kohn believes that rubrics, in particular, fail on moral and practical grounds. As he writes, in his essay <a href="http://www.alfiekohn.org/article/trouble-rubrics/">The Trouble with Rubrics:</a></p><blockquote>Now some observers criticize rubrics because they can never deliver the promised precision; judgments ultimately turn on adjectives that are murky and end up being left to the teacher’s discretion. But I worry more about the success of rubrics than their failure. Just as it’s possible to raise standardized test scores as long as you’re willing to gut the curriculum and turn the school into a test-preparation factory, so it’s possible to get a bunch of people to agree on what rating to give an assignment as long as they’re willing to accept and apply someone else’s narrow criteria for what merits that rating. Once we check our judgment at the door, we can all learn to give a 4 to exactly the same things.</blockquote><blockquote>This attempt to deny the subjectivity of human judgment is objectionable in its own right. But it’s also harmful in a very practical sense. In an important article published in 1999, Linda Mabry, now at Washington State University, pointed out that rubrics “are designed to function as scoring guidelines, but they also serve as arbiters of quality and agents of control” over what is taught and valued. Because “agreement among scorers is more easily achieved with regard to such matters as spelling and organization,” these are the characteristics that will likely find favor in a rubricized classroom. Mabry cites research showing that “compliance with the rubric tended to yield higher scores but produced ‘vacuous’ writing.”</blockquote><p>For Kohn, rubrics may work but only because they ask us to “check our judgement at the door” when we respond to and assess student writing, and only because students learn to produce “vacuous” writing that meets quantifiable measures of success but misses everything else.</p><p>I’ve largely abandoned teaching guided by learning outcomes this semester, and I’m using a simplified grading system that gives students control over their writing and their revision process. I’ve focused my grades on the “big-picture” aspects of writing — critical thinking, persuasion — and I’ve tried to link the work we are doing in class to the kind of work I hope students do out in the real world as change agents who are able to grapple with complexity and solve wicked problems.</p><p>Skeptics tell me that my approach deprives students of needed skills, or promotes an “anything goes” climate in the classroom. They argue that open-ended teaching is too overwhelming for students, who need “scaffolding” to accomplish tasks. This, however, creates a false binary. As Arlene Willner has argued, true inquiry-based learning has boundaries and scaffolding built in; the classroom, including assignments and assessments, are carefully designed so that students acquire skill, and are supported by scaffolding, as a natural part of working toward an authentic goal or working with authentic inquiry.</p><p>Biesta and Kohn make a compelling case for abandoning the tools of standardized education in favor of a more student-centered, organic approach. Their arguments have liberated me from my dutiful compliance with SLO’s and rubrics. As I continue to read and think about these issues, I’m hopeful that the tide is turning toward an educational approach that puts wicked problems at the center and that encourages teachers to carefully design classroom spaces to support students’ work.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40dc6ecd46d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Self-Discovery in the Classroom and Beyond]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/this-quote-from-jean-piaget-nicely-sums-up-two-articles-i-read-recently-one-about-parenting-the-90c5a36f2ad?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/90c5a36f2ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Feb 2016 03:12:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-30T15:57:42.931Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/580/1*oQIZ7BIjHtzuL2_cI8ieSA.png" /></figure><p>This quote from Jean Piaget sums up two articles I read recently, one about parenting, the other about teaching. The first is a long essay by Hanna Rosin called “The Overprotected Kid.” Like me, Rosin is interested in the changes from the free-range childhoods many adults remember to the over-regulated experiences of today’s kids. But Rosin then links this comparison to research on the importance of risk-taking and autonomy in human development. She suggests that because kids are deprived the chance to take risks and experience freedom from adult supervision, they are more depressed, fearful, and conventional as adults:</p><p><em>[Young people are ]less emotionally expressive, less energetic, less talkative and verbally expressive, less humorous, less imaginative, less unconventional, less lively and passionate, less perceptive, less apt to connect seemingly irrelevant things, less synthesizing, and less likely to see things from a different angle.</em></p><p>Rosin does raise troubling questions for educators. For example: what is the connection between the development of creativity and opportunities for robust exploration in childhood? If the latter is constricted, will the former wither? Rosin asks whether shielding children from risks disables their decision-making and ability to manage difference and risk later (qualities that are central to critical thinking) in life. Citing research that suggests that children need to face risks in their play in order to avoid developing phobias such as a fear of heights or water, she writes:</p><blockquote>Children are born with the instinct to take risks in play, because historically, learning to negotiate risk has been crucial to survival; in another era, they would have had to learn to run from some danger, defend themselves from others, be independent. Even today, growing up is a process of managing fears and learning to arrive at sound decisions. By engaging in risky play, children are effectively subjecting themselves to a form of exposure therapy, in which they force themselves to do the thing they’re afraid of in order to overcome their fear. But if they never go through that process, the fear can turn into a phobia. Paradoxically, Sandseter writes, “our fear of children being harmed,” mostly in minor ways, “may result in more fearful children and increased levels of psychopathology.” She cites a study showing that children who injured themselves falling from heights when they were between 5 and 9 years old are less likely to be afraid of heights at age 18. “Risky play with great heights will provide a desensitizing or habituating experience,” she writes.</blockquote><p>In other words, letting children experience risk and exploration on their own helps them adjust to life’s risks and risk-taking possibilities later.</p><p>Parents, unfortunately, aren’t the only ones guilty of depriving kids of risk-taking opportunities, exploration and discovery. Teachers can also get in the way, as Ed Yong makes clear in <a href="http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2011/01/18/when-teaching-restrains-discovery/#.VsUEVPkrLIV">this</a> Discovery Magazine article. Yong summarizes a study conducted by <a href="http://cocosci.berkeley.edu/Liz/index.html">Elizabeth Bonowitz</a>. Bonowitz gave two groups of children a toy. One group of children sat down with an adult teacher who showed them how the toy worked. The second group of kids were handed the toy with no explanation from an adult. Bonowitz found that the second group played with the toy for longer and discovered new ways to use the toy. As Yong sums it up:</p><blockquote>“teaching can be a “double-edge sword”. When teachers provided specific instructions about a new toy, children learned how to play with it more efficiently. But the lessons also curtailed their exploratory streak. They were less likely to play with the toy in new ways. Ultimately, they failed to find all of its secrets.”</blockquote><p>This isn’t to say that we should just turn students loose and provide no instruction or guidance. Yong implies that teachers have a role to play as guides and mentors. He notes that in another version of Bonowitz’ experiment, teachers presented possibilities about the toy to the children and then left the room. In this version of the experiment, the children discovered even more of the toy’s abilities. In other words, a teacher who provided some guidance about the toy and then stepped back increased the children’s learning while also promoting discovery and invention.</p><p>As teachers, I believe we need to think seriously about the perspectives offered in Rosin and Yong’s articles. We need what Arlene Wilner calls “bounded openness” — tasks that are at least somewhat authentic, and that are presented with guidance but little direct instruction in how to accomplish them. Rather than a list of instructions or assessment criteria, we need to make clear to students that there are multiple routes to success (many ways to play with the toy!). Traditional writing assignments, which are often crowded with information, regulations, rules, lists of “how to’s” and tips on “what to avoid,” encourage students to behave as some of the kids in Bonowitz’ study did — they encourage students to follow instruction but not to discover their own voice and ideas as writers.</p><p>As Piaget says: when we tell them how to do it, we take away their opportunities to learn for themselves. As a teacher and parent, these are words to live by.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=90c5a36f2ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Childhood Then and Now]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/during-the-summers-of-my-11th-12th-and-13th-years-i-had-a-full-time-job-c1e89e4525e8?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1e89e4525e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Feb 2016 06:15:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T16:31:02.024Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*9dxOfR04oNMjx9OMcQ80HA.jpeg" /></figure><p>During the summers of my 11th, 12th, and 13th years, I had a full-time job. I worked as a babysitter for three kids, who were barely younger than I was (the first summer, they were 9, 7, and 5 years old). I rode my bike to my job every day at 7:45. The mom left for work when I got there. I watched TV till the kids got up. I poured everyone bowls of cereal and we watched episodes of Leave it To Beaver and I Dream of Jeannie. At noon, I made grilled cheese sandwiches or put frozen potpies in the oven. At 1:00pm, we all got on our bikes (including the five year old) and rode a couple of miles across town to the public swimming pool. My young charges swam with their friends, and I with mine, and I didn’t see them again till 4:30, when we rode home. The mom came home at 5pm and I pedaled back to my house for dinner. I earned $1 per hour, and bought all of my school clothes in August with my earnings.</p><p>We didn’t wear bike helmets.</p><p>We didn’t worry about pool safety (there were teenage lifeguards on duty).</p><p>We didn’t wear sunscreen.</p><p>We didn’t have summer enrichment classes or summer tutoring or summer homework or summer reading lists.</p><p>My parents had no idea how I spent my summer days. I mostly talked on the phone, went to the pool, got lost in a book, or watched TV.</p><p>The childhood I’m describing isn’t a relic of a bygone age; it was the norm in the US as recently as 25 years ago. Most of the adults I know feel deeply nostalgic for it, even as we buckle our children tightly in their bike helmets, hover over their nightly homework (a word I was basically unfamiliar with until I got to college and even then I did very little), and carefully manage their complicated schedules: dance, music, art classes, playdates, competitive sports practice, etc.</p><p>Indeed, much as been written on the changes between then and now (see Julie Lythcott-Haims, Denise Pope and the work of Challenge Success, Hanna Rosin, Lenore Skenzay, and a host of others). Most agree: the rise of helicopter parents and the check-listed childhood are net-negatives for children and for our society. Children are less resilient, more depressed, less able to solve problems independently, more entitled, less confident.</p><p>But one question that nags at me in all our discussions and hand-wringing over childhood is the parallels between helicopter parenting and the damage it does, and school, which I think has followed a similar path.</p><p>Let me continue with my trip down memory lane: In third grade, I read comic books all day after completing my worksheets. In sixth grade, I wrote a report on WWII and the teacher misplaced it before she could give me feedback or a grade. In seventh grade, the music teacher was senile, but somehow we managed to send a couple of trios and an ensemble to the state music contest; my trio won second place. In 8th grade, a bird-loving science teacher required us to memorize 150 different types of birds before we could go on a field trip. I read romance novels through science class and never memorized the list. He let me go anyway. In high school most of my teachers were benignly indifferent. A few tried to inspire us to think for ourselves. One teacher put us in groups and assigned short films that were to be created in response to the classic books we had (mostly not) read. Another openly mocked the conventions of education and said nothing good ever came from slavish attention to following the rules. When I didn’t turn in the final essay, he told me he had been looking forward to reading it, but he understood: I was busy with other things. He did not notify my parents or grade me down (or maybe he did but I didn’t worry about it) or write a lengthy assessment of my skills, abilities and attitudes.</p><p>I got a few A’s, a lot of B’s, a couple of C’s, and almost didn’t make it through algebra my junior year. I drove myself around town, got a job as a waitress, hung out with my friends, read a lot, went to rock concerts and Santa Cruz and county fairs on my own with friends. No seat belts. No sunscreen. No bike helmets. I went to a college that looked fun and interesting. It was unbelievably cheap and I didn’t have to do much to get in. I took the classes I was supposed to, got a lot of B’s, a few C’s, a few A’s in subjects I liked. I drove up and down the coast of California, to my boyfriend’s campus, in a old, decrepit VW bug I bought myself. I made the trip whenever I wanted, with no cell phone to text my mom when I arrived and again, no seat belts. I majored in English because I liked it, without a thought about what career it would lead to. I had never heard of a learning outcome or a grading rubric.</p><p>The free-form education I managed to cobble together — mediocre grades and a parental and pedagogical system that seemed to be predicated on the educational equivalent of “don’t ask/don’t tell” — was also fairly typical for my generation. My parents rarely involved themselves in my schooling, never emailed a teacher, didn’t check my assessments online, and never hectored me about my GPA; my teachers never emailed parents, didn’t give assessments and so didn’t enter them online, and no one worried about whether our test scores were higher than those in Finland or China. There was no federal No Child Left Behind, very little standardized testing, and no arms race of competitive college admissions.</p><p>But compare this to education now. The number of hours students spend preparing for and taking standardized tests has sky-rocketed. The number of hours even small children spend on homework has sky-rocketed. Teachers face increasing pressure to create fool-proof assignments that lead students through every step of the thinking process. They are required to fit all learning into lists of outcomes, and it is not uncommon to hear that one cannot teach what can’t be assessed (measured). I am fascinated by, and also worried about, how much has changed between then and now. How have we gotten here? What have we lost and what have we gained in the change?</p><p>I’ve done a lot of reading and thinking about this, and I can offer a preliminary answer to the question of what we have lost. My answer begins with a favorite quote, from Leonard Cohen: “Forget your perfect offerings / There’s a crack in everything / That’s what lets the light in.” From my perspective, we have lost sight of the meaning in these lines: we have become convinced that we can perfect the “outcomes” of our children’s lives, that we control and dictate the “outcomes” of every pedagogical encounter our students experience in our classrooms. We try to engineer our children and our students, with the “<a href="http://time.com/3910020/the-over-parenting-trap-how-to-avoid-checklisted-childhoods-and-raise-adults/">checklisted childhood</a>” and the lists of standards that “students will be able to” master by the end of every unit or term. But in patching up every possible crack, we shut out the light. Humans aren’t machines whose settings and functions we control, program, or fix.</p><p>I’ve created this blog as a place to review books and articles on the parallels between the problem of helicopter parenting and the problem — much less understood — with helicopter classrooms. I hope this will be a place to explore my own experiences as a teacher and parent. I want to read and review some of the new books that have come out recently on this topic (for example, Julie Lythcott-Haims’ “<a href="http://www.amazon.com/How-Raise-Adult-Overparenting-Prepare/dp/1627791779">How To Raise An Adult”</a>) and to try to make sense of all the articles on education and parenting that are regularly featured in the Washington Post, HuffPo, the Atlantic and similar magazines. But more specifically, I want to look at how critiques of helicopter parents also apply to the current climate in education, where kids face increasing pressure (homework, standardized tests, competitive college and grad school admissions), and where beliefs about good teaching seem to echo cultural norms surrounding parenting: good teachers/parents constantly monitor, they engineer desirable outcomes, they determine the outcomes in advance. I’m interested in exploring some of the arguments scholars, educators, and parenting experts have about these issues: should grade school children have homework? Are learning outcomes and standards-based educational methods effective and if so at what cost (to creativity, critical thinking, etc)? Should we change college admissions practices? If so, how?</p><p>As I hope is clear by now, the changes from my<a href="http://www.freerangekids.com/"> free-range</a> childhood to my own children’s highly controlled and scripted lives are both puzzling and worrying. I hope to use this blog to learn more about these changes, so that we can discover the best ways to help young people reach their fullest potential.</p><p>�l�t�T</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1e89e4525e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor is a Professor of English at San Francisco State University.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jstrainor/jennifer-trainor-is-a-professor-of-english-at-san-francisco-state-university-939abe7a961c?source=rss-4f56ddef84d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/939abe7a961c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[san-francisco]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jennifer Trainor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Feb 2016 22:40:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-10T16:15:17.980Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Jennifer Trainor is a Professor of English at San Francisco State University. She has worked as a parent educator in the Silicon Valley and is the parent of two children. She is interested in academic engagement, learning theory, modern parenting and schooling.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=939abe7a961c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>