<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Judith Johnson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Judith Johnson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@judithjohnson_14390?source=rss-397ed3597656------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 11:40:23 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@judithjohnson_14390/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Recognizing that free Will does not exist Matters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@judithjohnson_14390/recognizing-that-free-will-does-not-exist-matters-f1b6d3bf76bb?source=rss-397ed3597656------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f1b6d3bf76bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Judith Johnson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Feb 2018 14:15:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-12T14:15:07.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Recognizing that free Will does not exist Matters</strong></p><p><strong>1</strong>) Causality: the mystery of existence</p><p>Why does one thing lead to another? That is the real mystery of existence, a question I can’t begin to address. Experiments on preverbal infants show that that we are born looking for cause and effect. Human language assumes causality. Effects have multiple causes, eg. many votes elect a president, and causes have multiple effects eg. one person can infect a large population with a virus. Because of this interconnectedness all of reality consists of a complex web of causes and effects developing through time. Sometimes small causes have large effects at a distance. Large effects distant from small causes and multiple causes make prediction uncertain or even impossible for us much of the time. But we are successful at predicting events often enough to think we have some understanding of our world.</p><p>We can’t imagine a reality without causality, and if there is causality then the past determines the future from before we were born to after our death as effects follow causes through time. This is not a great leap; this conclusion has been reached many times by those who were willing to reach it and so it has many names: fate, predestination, determinism, predictable reality. There are subtle distinctions between these terms but they are close enough for this moment and I will bring out differences as necessary.</p><p>If I drew lines between the things that affect me (causes) and myself, then added lines for the effects I have, I would find myself at the centre of many radiating lines. If I added all possible lines between causes and effects I might fill all available space. I would be penetrated by and full of cause and effect lines many of which pass through me, leaving me with no distinct boundary.</p><p>My perceivable reality is a dense and massive web, a causality web, which simultaneously creates and imprisons all of us. This view of our reality as the only possible world is in opposition to the prevailing western Christian attitude that we have free will with which we freely create our future from many options. The conflict between these ideas has led me to question the idea of free will. I may as well say right now that free will looks like an illusion from where I am.</p><p>Where I am is agnostic on many issues. Although I attempt to practice Buddhism I do not believe or not believe in past or future lives, except as part of this life where my experience says myself, which defies definition, is continuously reborn as experience modifies self. Being agnostic is not a faith, nor is it a denial of the faith of others, it is realization and acceptance of my own ignorance. Saying “I don’t know” is an act of humility and realism that acknowledges the limits of my experience and ways of knowing. It involves giving up the idea that I was raised with that I should always have an opinion on everything.</p><p>I do however have an opinion on free will. In my opinion it is an illusion that we would be better off without. If I have faith it is that seeing clearly how we are created and held by causality will stop human beings judging self and other. I hope that this will expand our empathy and altruistic tendencies beyond our immediate family to include not just other people, but all sentient beings and the inanimate framework that supports our ecosystem. As far as I can see self interest rules every human institution from family to the UN but people need each other emotionally as well as physically, countries need each other, and we all need a functioning ecosystem. I can hope for. whole hearted cooperation on a large scale because it is always in everyone’s self interest to have that, doubly so in this age of genetic engineering, nuclear armament and human induced climate change.</p><p>Causality and the absence of free will may the the largest topic I could have chosen to address. All of human knowledge is relevant to it in some way. I have provided a short annotated bibliography with a list of authors whose publications I found useful while exploring and expressing thoughts about that. I have included my current favourite poet (1), many scientists (10–12, 15,16, 18–24) and buddhist writers (2, 5, 17) among others. Numbers in this text refer to that list.</p><p><strong>2</strong>) Choice and Unfree Will: enmeshment in the causality web</p><p>Throughout life we are aware of multiple potential actions and must choose. There is no way out of this compulsory experience as not choosing, not acting, or acting on habit are default choices. We often deliberately choose our actions with specific desired effects consciously in mind, i.e. we plan. It is the experience of conscious choice and planning that suggests to us that we have free will.</p><p>We feel we are free to choose from the options before us but our motivation has already been formed by the web of causes and effects that resulted in our conception and development. Being presented with a choice may result in agonizing inner conflict but there is only one action (or inaction) that we are most motivated to make, and we make that choice. The free will we experience is illusory as we can only decide to do what we are most motivated to do at each moment and that is dictated by past and present circumstances including what we have learned and brought to mind about causality and the way the choice is presented. Since our motivation (will) is not free, and much of it is not even conscious let alone freely chosen, the phenomenon called free will is named in a misleading way.</p><p>After we make a choice we learn from the combination of choice and perceived consequence. We may learn that we want to make different choices in future. That learning process occurs within and because of causality, not despite of or outside it.</p><p>Learning from experience in general forms a feedback loop in the causality web so it partly controls the web of which it is a part. The idea of feedback comes from systems theory but is easily understood by anyone who has used a household thermostat. A thermostat senses and controls temperature in the building that it is part of by turning the heating off when the required temperature is reached and back on if things cool down too much. The current temperature is detected and fed back to a decision making switch that turns the heat on or off. We set the desired temperature of the switching mechanism which is responsible for the temperature of its house, but not for its own design or setting. The loop that turns the heat off when it is too hot is negative feedback, it keeps the temperature stable although the heater has the capacity to exceed the set temperature. What it does is what it is responsible for. In the same way we are responsible for what we do, but not for being what we are, and not our “set temperature.”</p><p>Our set temperature is simply feeling good. We have built in ways of doing that, ways that support reproductive success in the environment in which our species evolved. Our feelings are like the temperature detector in the thermostat and our behaviour is the switching mechanism geared to keeping those feelings good. Because of natural selection what makes us feel good is meeting our physical and social needs including favouring kin and allies.</p><p>Learning by experience lets us modify our behaviour making our “switching mechanism” more effective. It adds a feedback loop as follows. Learning affects how we act, which affects what we learn next, which affects how we act, which affects what we learn, which affects how we act in a never ending process that lets us aim ever more effectively at desired consequences. This is a morally neutral process which can help us be better parents, better piano players, better warriors, better liars, better crusaders or better torturers depending on how genetics and experience have shaped our desires.</p><p>My intention in using a thermostat and switching mechanism to explain feedback in the above paragraphs is to highlight the difference between control and freedom. The thermostat that does its job and keeps a comfortable home is not a morally good thermostat. If it gets broken it is not bad. It most certainly does not have free will, yet it has a controlling function. We are complex and the choices we make are often influenced by thousands of genetic and environmental factors. Those choices have real effects in the causality web giving us some control over it. Complexity, control, and learning do not imply free will. Learning from experience provides increasingly effective methods for implementing the will that we have, which is an entirely different thing.</p><p>This gets complicated. We may be presented with choices that we know will affect our future motivation (will), although we don’t fully understand those changes until after they happen, if then. We may read up on determinism and free will. We may learn a new skill like art, music, math or a sport. We may learn how to make affirmations, how to pray, how to meditate, how to communicate better with others, how to take direction from scripture, religious authorities, ethicists, custom or law, or we may strive to be independent of external moral authority although that is difficult for such gregarious animals. Any of these choices can be expected to have profound effects on our motivation, but none of them allow us to pick our motivation from a position that is free of causality.</p><p>Although we can never arrive at absolute free will the quality of our illusory freedom matters to us. We act in accord with our will if we are not restrained physically and that feels freer than being physically restrained. We feel freer to act in accord with our desires if there are not too many painful consequences for doing so, otherwise our desire to avoid pain overrides other desires, molding our will.</p><p>Our desire to avoid emotional and physical pain gives our parents and community a powerful way to manipulate us. Parents and community condition us, rewarding behaviours that are acceptable in our society and disapproving of those that are not until we internalize the lessons and end up with a conscience. A conscience makes us feel bad when we do something we think is wrong and gives us a pleasant feeling when we do what we think is right. What we think of as right is what is expected of us in our society. If I was a pre European contact Polynesian chief and I sacrificed the life one of my least valuable children to placate an angry god and save my people I probably would not suffer pangs of conscience. Parents and community do their best to condition us so that our conscience reflects their values.</p><p>We learn to delay or refuse gratification if the anticipated consequences of indulgence are undesirable. A guilty conscience is definitely undesirable, right up there with an empty stomach or a crying child. No one wants regrets. Even my dog anticipates the future and has something like a conscience. He stays off the table and out of the garbage because he does not like the consequences of violating my expectations. Having a conscience is nothing to brag about. Eating garbage when wholesome food is provided is nothing to brag about either.</p><p>We shine compared to other animals with regard to anticipation of future consequences and long term planning but we have a surprising amount of difficulty accepting short term pain for long term gain even in simple things where the consequences are quite obvious. It is difficult for a child to stay out of the cookie jar for 5 unsupervised minutes. It is difficult for an adult to exercise the 24/7 self control needed to loose weight or stop smoking, even when our lives are at risk. Being generous with others is difficult if we are not secure about having enough for ourselves, even when we desire the benefits of having others as allies.</p><p>At times our own actions puzzle us because both conscious and unconscious motivation come into play. Saint Paul in Romans 7:15 describes the common human experience of subconscious motivation and strong desires overruling deliberate conscious decisions. “I do not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do.” Science, therapy and religion address our enmeshment in the causality web and our conflicting desires. They can all deepen our understanding of ourselves.</p><p><strong>3</strong>)	Understanding Ourselves: Science, Therapy and Religion</p><p>Understanding ourselves is a knotty problem because much of our motivation is not conscious and we are resistant to seeing our own unconscious motivation clearly. The principle of natural selection so well articulated by Darwin and Wallace cuts that knot. It can be applied to biological evolution and to the spread of ideas that cause cultural evolution. It is a stunningly simple principle: what both survives and reproduces in the present environment is perpetuated into the future. A biological lineage is perpetuated when births equal or outnumber deaths. Ideas are perpetuated when they spread from individual to individual faster than individuals die or change their minds.</p><p>Since genetics and the theory of biological evolution by natural selection have been used to justify forced eugenics and genocide many scientists are understandably afraid of how their work will be used. Realistic accounts of human development and behaviour may be attacked for a variety of political, ideological or religious reasons. In spite of the social hazards an increasing number of scientists are willing to stop equivocating and say outright that free will is an illusion (12) and that natural selection has shaped our psychology so that we are. predictable but only partly aware of our own motivation. The existence of unconscious motivation allows us to deceive others and/or ourselves when such deception is likely to promote reproductive success (21). Studies of the great apes, extant human hunter/gatherer bands, and people in modern nation states support these ideas (18, 23, 24).</p><p>Natural selection shaped life for billions of years starting before it was life. We have had less than 200 years in which to understand how it has shaped us but a coherent story is emerging rapidly. We are motivated to act in ways that promote the spread of our own genes by promoting reproductive success of our own children, siblings children and known useful allies more than we support others. We don’t need to be aware of underlying mechanisms for this to work. Lust will drive us to sexual behaviour even if we don’t know that sex causes pregnancy. We bond socially with those close to us without necessarily consciously relating this to anyones reproductive success. We want social status (7) long before we understand that it is the “alpha wolf” that has the pups. Since we need social contact and our personal survival is supported by the survival of our own group and by inter-group trading relationships we are capable of altruism beyond our immediate family, but priority usually goes to kin, and between adults reciprocal altruism i.e. trading favours, rather than unreciprocated gifting, is usual.</p><p>Even between parents and children reciprocal altruism and outright exploitation are common. In many settings throughout history maturing children have been a source of labour and they have at times been hired out, offered as hostages, soldiers or priests; or sold as brides or slaves. Although we often think of families as held together by unconditional love, history particularly history of royal families where the stakes are high, provides a fuller picture complete with betrayal and exploitation. Love is an umbrella term used to describe a variety of intense and complex feelings. The various forms of love are real enough but they are not the full story.</p><p>When self interest and the interests of others coincide, as when we are helping others within our family, we are least conflicted and most likely to have a subjective experience of deep and apparently selfless love. Usually we think of this as a good thing. The lengths to which a human mother will go to promote the wellbeing of her children is legendary. Parental love is held up as a model of divine love. But when resources are limited, and they generally are, this same powerful altruism comes at the expense of distant relatives and strangers, and favouring the child who has the best chance of helping our reproductive success may come at the expense of other children.</p><p>Favouring closer kin over more distant kin and allies over enemies sometimes, perhaps always, takes the form of honour among thieves. Example 1) a ruling class claims to own all the land and the peasants that farm it, forming and funding military and/or police to maintain their advantage. Example 2) I was a lookout when my partner held my sisters feet as she hung upside down inside a donation bin looting a bunch of discards rather than begging for free handouts or cutting into her children’s food budget for clothes and dishes. Example 3) Europeans colonized less populous and less technological areas of the globe enforcing laws that rob the indigenous of land, political power, dignity, and often of life.</p><p>Our genes did not evolve to make us happy or honest. They evolved to keep us moving in the direction of reproductive success. Discontent is built in, as soon as we gratify one desire another one manifests. If our basic needs are provided for we set about increasing future security and that usually takes priority over preventing deaths in other human populations. Post reproductive couples tend to support their descendants. Chocolate, coffee and RRSPs sell here while people starve elsewhere in spite of global communication being at an all time high. Goods are rarely given for free, handouts are usually paid for by loss of status.</p><p>When I think about winning the lottery I automatically think of improving my life and that of close relatives and friends. None of us are starving or homeless so lots of people need those hoped for millions way more than we do. Yet “that will feed a lot of hungry people” is not my first thought. The desire to use resources that others need more is an unpleasant aspect of myself, and of human beings in general. Along with a desire for comfort and high status for ourselves, favouring the comfort and status of kin and allies over the survival of others is a root cause of human induced pollution, climate change, famine and war all of which threaten our survival in the long term as well as promoting our reproductive success in the short to medium term.</p><p>Many of our current social and environmental problems including environmental degradation, high tech war, and new epidemic diseases are a result of our reproductive success. That success. has accelerated as a result of our ability to learn from experience and transmit that knowledge between individuals and across generations, which has benefitted from growing populations in a positive feedback loop. The more we learn about developing technology the more we develop technology and the more we develop technology the more we learn about developing technology so the more technology we develop. Technology benefits from large educated populations so increasing technology and increasing populations work together to create positive feedback which is not stable.</p><p>Positive feedback loops result in a change of state. A forest fire is a case of positive feedback while it is growing. The bigger it is the more the heat dries out vegetation and heats it, so the more the fire grows. If it does not rain the whole forest may burn changing the state of an entire forest. Child birth also occurs by way of positive feedback with birth itself being the change of state. Positive feedback and change are not good or bad in and of themselves.</p><p>We are concerned about the change of state accelerating population growth and technological change will bring. Will our technology eventually cause global famine, disease, flood, drought and pollution on a scale that vastly reduces our population? This sort of thing happens to other species and we are aware of climate change already moving us in that direction. Will we learn enough to create better group decision making methods that help us maintain a large well fed population? Will we make ourselves into cyborgs with telepathic computers accessing communal knowledge as if communal knowledge was stored with individual memories? What would happen to our individual nature, our social organization and our global ecosystem if we merged with our machines that way? We don’t know how it will end, but we are too dependent on technology to stop without disaster.</p><p>For now human nature is much as it always was, adapted for life in small groups that compete with, cooperate with, and interbreed with each other while individuals favour family and allies. The tendency to favour family and allies and the less than fully conscious tendency to repress negative aspects of ourselves means the concept of free will is applied selectively. It is easy for us to see free will, culpability, and necessity of vengeance against heinous acts of strangers while claiming pressure of circumstance for heinous acts of our own group members. This is a significant barrier to wider altruism. For example I have found people who excuse official participation in the 60s scoop and Indian residential schools because officials made the best choices they could make given their understanding at the time are often the same people who, when discussing “criminals”, emphasize free will and moral responsibility. They feel justified in punishing people they recognize as “criminals” but not in recognizing people who removed indigenous children from their communities as criminals. This is also behind the tendency of non-indigenous people to discuss “the Indian/aboriginal problem” rather than the “settler problem.” Failing to see moral equivalence here is a form of self deception that occurs quite naturally (21, 24) and is well explained by natural selection. We all do this sort of thing. Training ourselves away from this evolved tendency can only be done by using our evolved tendencies. We will stop doing this when we see that our self interest (which includes favouring relatives and allies) is best served by stopping.</p><p>Science does not have a monopoly on understanding. The desire to find meaning and purpose in our lives, and the use of religious faith to this end appear to be universals found in all human cultures. Even the least religious among us have experience of awe, humility, contrition, hope, love and a sense of good and evil. These are evolved tendencies strongly associated with religion. As Brazier (5), a zen priest and psychotherapist, put it “ Meaning is obtained by contextualization…Small things make sense in terms of the bigger things that they are part of. The bigger things are part of something bigger still. The biggest are inevitably out of sight and so become matters of faith. If faith is prohibited, everything becomes meaningless.” For me the causality web is the biggest thing conceivable, effectively infinite and powerful, a presence that quite literally both penetrates and creates me without being fully knowable. Causality can be explored scientifically, and by introspection which has traditionally been a domain of religious/spiritual practice.</p><p>Science relies on causality, if causality did not exist there would be no point in scientific investigation. Through the process of peer review, replication of critical experiments and testing of theoretical predictions science provides as much objectivity and veracity as humans can hope to arrive at. However the theoretical understanding science provides cannot replace the individual introspective process involved in contemplation, some types of prayer and some types of therapy. Just as monitoring activity in the visual centres of the brain, or measuring the wave length of light is no substitute for seeing a colour so there is no theoretical or knowledge based substitute for any variety of introspection.</p><p>It is introspection that shows me my basic motivation (purpose, will): stay out of pain including the pain of others, stay away from death, acquire status, and enjoy life including the excitement of a manageable degree of risk for as long as possible. Introspection allows us to experience more of the causality web than we usually see and feel, through a feeling of oneness, through moments of enhanced empathy, by being more directly aware of our own feelings and reactions including the things we habitually repress, or through experiences that are impossible to describe in words. For me experiences of smallness in vastness result from contemplating apparently infinite material reality and apparently infinite time and that has a religious feel to it.</p><p>I am a very poor practitioner of Buddhist methods yet practicing Buddhism made my own motives clearer to me. When I remember to introspect, to permit negative emotion to surface and be seen, and not to latch onto either negative or positive experience, then I enjoy life more and am less depressed than at any previous time in my life except very early childhood. There is/was a price. I found being confronted with myself was traumatic, and sometimes it still is when I badly want to deny some unpleasant aspect of myself like the desire to run from the pain of others, choosing pleasing others over truth, or the desire to pressure others to repress their pain so I can be more comfortable.</p><p>When I commented to a Buddhist monk that “we are just animals” his reply was, “yes, but we can realize it, they cannot.” At the time I could only realize it intellectually and that is not enough to increase self knowledge. Only by dropping the intellectual into the belly, into emotional appreciation, can I begin to “realize” anything. Modern psychology supports this, for example experiments show that appeals to emotion are far more powerful than appeals to logic when it comes to changing our beliefs and actions (11).</p><p>Being confronted with what we tend to keep subconscious including selfishness, status seeking and powerlessness over our place in the causality web can produce developmental crisis. Developmental crisis is provoked and handled differently by different religious traditions, and by many western self help gurus and therapists who seem to keep reinventing, renaming and claiming credit for the same “wheel.” For example Brown’s work (8) includes explication of truths that are recognizably Buddhist, without any reference to Buddhism. The concept of original sin in Christianity combined with repentance and the idea of a forgiving and accepting God seem to me to be a way of recognizing and accepting our deep selfishness, sneaky subconscious, and the demands of complex social organization. I could have identified Brown as using an almost Christian approach. Parables and rituals used in. religious settings are replaced in her work by stories about herself, stories about clients that she had therapeutic conversations with and specific suggestions for guided introspection and improved communication. She has made useful concepts accessible by spelling them out in the language of her contemporaries and they are by her own account legitimately grounded in her experience.</p><p>Religious practice can at times allow us to drop our self interest at least for a moment. Then we see as Gautama (Buddha) did that we are just a grain of sand on the beach, a tiny part of a vast universe, limited in our capacity for understanding and action. Brazier (5) writes of the function of religion with love as an example. He says “the love that we actually encounter in this world is always in some degree and in some manner conditional, yet from our experience of such love we intuitively conceive of unconditional love.” Conditional love is what natural selection predicts. The intuition of the abstract and extreme unconditional love is how our minds work. We always use abstract idealizations in our thought processes, these abstractions include infinity, the ideal table and chair, the perfect sphere, the idea of a mountain, and unconditional love. These abstractions are metaphysical according to Brazier, and according to him “Religion is about how we relate to such metaphysical fundamentals.” Religious practices then help us “to understand [metaphysical ideas] and keep them in mind and, most importantly, revere them.”</p><p>Brazier points out that “science” itself is a metaphysical idea, that the measurements it deals with are abstractions, that the metaphysical is an inescapable aspect of human thought. For Brazier spiritual life is forming “values (motivations) in the metaphysical domain and implementing them in the physical empirical domain” thus bridging between two ungraspable extremes. He says that we cannot turn off abstraction as thought is impossible without it, so we all have a spiritual life although we don’t all practice a religion and we are not all aware of how we use direct empirical experience and abstraction. I am not so sure that motivation arises in the metaphysical domain, having been motivated to scratch by an itch I find my motives strongly linked to the physical/empirical. Although the itch free state is surely a metaphysical abstraction that we yearn for, individual itches and scratches are not abstract and I’m not sure we always stop to think or even to mentally flash briefly to the abstract “itch” before acting to eliminate it. For values and motivations to be synonyms values have to be as unconscious as motivation and that leaves us having to distinguish between conscious declared values and unconscious values that influence action without being consciously accounted for. In spite of my reservations I find Brazier’s perspective helpful because he addresses the question of what exactly spirituality is as distinct from religiosity, and defines it in a way that makes sense of the universality of religious and spiritual activity in human culture.</p><p>Religion, science and therapy are embedded in the social structure. We are a species with a very flexible social structure, but we always end up with leaders and in that sense we are unwaveringly hierarchical. We may have a monarch or dictator with almost unlimited power, or we may have different leaders for different group tasks, often we have both. We are adapted to fit into a hierarchical social structure by being very suggestible and having a tendency to comply with authority. We sometimes alter our memories (19) and our judgement of social or even physical reality to comply with those of others, giving them the power to affect what we learn from experience. This often helps us by helping the social structure to work smoothly. We see this in very diverse settings from not parking on highways to groups of hunters acting quickly and silently under the direction of the best hunter. Compliance and suggestibility give cohesion to our ever more highly populated and complex social structures, but they have a dark side.</p><p>Following the Second World War the effect of authority on behaviour was explored by Milgram and others who wanted to know how the Nazis were able to perpetrate genocide. They found that individuals often abdicate from making their own choices when following orders or when influenced by an authority figure or a group. If the authority figure or group are murdering, warmongering, cheating, or polluting and subordinates go along with them we can end up with large scale destruction of human life. In less extreme situations we may find ourselves violating our own values or simply doing things we never thought we would do because those things are expected of us.</p><p>Since religion, science and therapy are organized into institutions with their own power structures, power struggles, authority figures and self serving interpretations of reality they are used for individual aggrandizement and political ends as well as for genuine deepening of understanding and widening of altruistic tendencies. While utilizing their tools it is wise to be aware of our huge capacity for self deception and compliance with authority as well as everyone’s natural bias toward their own group.</p><p>We have a unique capacity to record and learn from multigenerational information, using what we have learned to deliberately modify the causality web of which we are a part using innovative ideas and technology. Knowledge is communal (16, 20), not just individual, there are far more facts and concepts than can fit in a single human mind. Just as zoo animals are less bored and depressed when they have to search for their food so people do better with problems to think about and new things to learn. We value finding the solution to problems even at the expense of shattering cherished illusions like free will or the perfection of heroes, saints and teachers.</p><p>We need a purpose beyond staying out of pain and solving puzzles, usually looking out for relatives and allies provides that, but at times we take on improvement in the human condition in general advocating for causes like eliminating poverty, opening education to more people, ending cruelty to animals and so on. There is no shortage of projects that people use to fulfill their need for purposeful problem solving. But circumstances control how we formulate those projects. Our current understanding, interest and values, exposure to propaganda, suppression of information by media, governments, publishers and other “gatekeepers”, clever advertising and education all influence what we do and do not learn and therefore what we do.</p><p>Many impressive accomplishments have resulted from human problem solving. Some of those may be counted as successes, some as failures, likely we would not completely agree on which are which. Innovations include controlled fire, democracy, capitalism, socialism, communism, empire building, women’s rights, slavery, reducing slavery, paid employment, agriculture and accompanying new religions, founding the UN, bombing Hiroshima, avoiding nuclear war for over sixty years, extreme inequality with regard to resource distribution and freedom, not even talking about the long term effects of medical intervention which include increasing the frequency of harmful genes that no one wishes to inherit, genetic engineering.</p><p>Our tendency to deny things that are inconvenient or unpleasant is one facet of human nature. The repression of selected ideas by institutions from family to nation is another. A lot has been written about denial from therapeutic and religious perspectives and science has contributed here (11.) If we want to understand ourselves more than we want to avoid difficult truths we will keep looking in the places we want to avoid.</p><p>Investigating things we want to deny is important. So is understanding faith, hope and charity which are as universal as denial and self interest. When we give attention, understanding or something material we reward ourselves in the moment of giving. This is one level of the loaves and fishes story of Christianity and the stone soup story as well, nourishment that does not run out because people enjoy giving and inspire each other to give. Genetic variation and brain damage prevent this from being absolutely universal among humans. Kiehl makes it clear that this does not apply to psychopaths for example (15). But in general the tendencies to cooperation, trust, and trustworthiness are part of being human.</p><p>Conditional love and reciprocal altruism is what we expect given natural selection in a gregarious species. Hope ensures that we make an effort to survive. Generosity that is self rewarding helps individuals function in groups. Faith boils down to trust, which saves us from the dysfunctional craziness of paranoia. The almost universal human tendency to faith, hope and charity is not beyond science to explain although it might be better nurtured by religious or spiritual practices. I chose Buddhism as my spiritual practice because it embraces sceptical inquiry and does not require specific beliefs.</p><p>Tension between altruism and self interest appears to be bred into us. There are a variety of strategies for keeping that inner conflict to a minimum. Remaining in a small racially segregated group where we are fairly closely related to all group members is one such strategy. Extending our altruism to the broader family of humanity and beyond recognizing with some forms of spirituality/religiosity that all beings and all things are related is another. For poetic treatment of how frustrating our failure at this is read Sherman Alexie (1.) Usually we opt for an intermediate solution: favouring family and allies but cooperating in a reciprocal give and take with others as long as we do not feel a need to take their territory or they ours.</p><p>At the present time people in the fields of religion, science and therapy are engaged in mutual assessment, criticism and crossing boundaries to learn from each other. Ecumenical activity is widespread and religious practice is being reformulated in a secular context (2.) There are Buddhist teachers who are psychotherapists (5), neurobiologists that study the brain states of meditators, publications on the scientific study of morality and religion (23, 24, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion.) In the west the implications of new information is publicly explored (6.) There are many religious practitioners who see their calling as quite compatible with both science and therapeutic approaches since their goal is to help people live in harmony with themselves and each other in a realistic and honest way, appreciating both individuals and their place in the universe.</p><p>The current breakdown of interdisciplinary boundaries between science, therapy and religion seems to me similar to what happens individually when we stop thinking in a compartmentalized way. New connections are being made all the time. Human knowledge is opening up. It is possible to find religious leaders, therapists and scientists who acknowledge the illusory nature of free will and who balance between fatalism and arrogance.</p><p><strong>4</strong>)	The Razors Edge: Fatalism, Helplessness and Arrogance</p><p>Seeing that our reality is deterministic can undermine motivation if we think. “what will be will be so why make an effort?” This is the problem of fatalism. It is not trivial as motivation is not under direct conscious control. For us to stay motivated both conscious and unconscious mind (which are part of a whole mind and not without an intervening grey area) must be convinced of the value of effort.</p><p>The problem of fatalism has been raised by various western authors. In 2008 Vohs and Schooler (22) published an article entitled. “The value of believing in Free Will” showing that having subjects read material emphasizing determinism led to an increase in cheating compared to subjects reading neutral material. This result has been attributed to determinism reducing the effort that goes into self control. The same year Harrison (13) claimed in The Central Liberal Truth that in progress prone societies people are convinced of the power of their individualistic direction setting and blame themselves for their mistakes while in progress resistant societies people are more fatalistic. Four years later Hood (14) published The Self Illusion where he asserted that that belief in free will “predicts not only better job performance but also expected career success.” He suggested jokingly that we ignore the absence of intellectually defensible free will and believe in it anyway. That is ridiculous for several reasons:</p><p>1)	Once convinced of the absence of free will we can’t ignore our own conviction. Things we push into the subconscious affect our subconscious motivation and creep up on us.</p><p>2)	It is arrogant to think we can establish a chosen motive or belief outside the causality web.</p><p>3)	It is arrogant to think we understand consequences well enough to be in control of the causality web in the long term. Immediate benefits of progress are undeniable and include vaccination, antibiotics, machinery for heavy physical work, sanitation, longer average lifespans and freedom of movement. These benefits have come at a price which includes human induced climate change which will flood much farmland and wipe out low lying terrestrial hunting grounds, deaths related to pollution, poverty and overwork, the disruption of families by the ongoing forced removal of peasants and indigenous people from their land and by the demands of education and employment, industrial scale genocide and nuclear weapons. Progress has helped some and hurt some. Repressing our knowledge of determinism to promote progress will likely produce more of the same.</p><p>4)	It is impossible to hide causality and its implications. There will always be those who see it for themselves.</p><p>We can’t ignore fatalism. Experiments in learned helplessness. show that if we feel totally powerless we are so depressed we lack the motivation to do anything. Even the most obvious beneficial actions are impossible for very depressed individuals so demonstrating the efficacy of chosen actions is vital for human wellbeing. Yet we can only do what we are motivated to do and chosen actions often have unintended effects. Depressing though that reality is we face it or remain deluded.</p><p>Fatalism and arrogance are almost opposites: fatalism is due to feeling powerless in the grip of the causality web and arrogance is supported by the assumption that our will or motivation is independent of the causality web (which is what absolute free will would be.) A full appreciation of how we fit in the causality web includes recognizing the playing out of causality and the efficacy of learning and choosing. Such understanding may allow us to walk the razors edge between the arrogance of believing we are in control and depression resulting from learned helplessness.</p><p>Ancient stories of the playing out of fate exemplified by the Greek myth of Oedipus include a profound insight: it is our struggle to take control of our lives that brings our “fate” about. The societies that gave us Oedipus do not seem to me to be very “progress resistant”, they produced many ideas and social structures that still impress us. I’m not sure what Siddhartha Gautama (often called the Buddha) thought of free will, but the surviving teachings list long chains of cause and effect, and some buddhists are convinced of the absence of free will (17.) Although buddhists emphasize being free to be oneself, amongst other things accepting inner thoughts and conflicts for what they are, trainee monks and laypeople accept the discipline of sitting quietly with their own thoughts for long periods of time which requires a lot of self control. Science, from ecology to particle physics relies on experiments that can be replicated with predictable results. This only works if particular causes create particular effects in predictable ways so that our reality once in motion must follow natural physical and chemical laws, a view known as determinism which in my opinion is essentially the same as predestination.</p><p>Determinism says things are contingent on physical reality unfolding through time following definite and at least theoretically knowable laws. Predestination as used in theology refers to things predestined by God. If there is a God (or multidimensional aliens) who predestined certain outcomes for our causality web then those outcomes must be built into the physical laws that are demonstrably operating. This leaves little or no practical difference between predestination and determinism. Yet successful scientists who work within demonstrable physical reality and accept inviolable physical laws, and those who investigate predictable patterns of human behaviour, are some of the hardest working and at least in their role as scientists some of the most honest people in the world.</p><p>Looking at the ancient Greeks, Buddhists who see interconnectedness in a way that precludes individual free will, and at successful scientists who do not find it necessary or useful to believe in free will, we see people who accept the full implications of causality but are not suffering from depression or lack of self control. There is a way, maybe more than one way, to walk the razors edge.</p><p>I wanted to include Calvinism in the above sentence because Calvin integrated predestination into Christianity in a way that had Christians working very hard for predestined salvation. But to align with the bible Calvin reconciled free will with predestination by saying that we necessarily yet wilfully choose to sin. What this philosophical backflip ignores is that if our choice to sin is necessary enough that we all do it, then sin is not a free choice, it is built into who we are.</p><p>Sometimes people imagine that they are guardians of public morals and refrain from spreading the idea that we are not free agents. Darwin concluded in his private notes that human self interest (which aligns rather well with original sin) was an evolved characteristic, not something we can hold people responsible for. He was so worried about the effect of this information on public morality that he hesitated to publish until his own self self interest was threatened by Wallace having arrived at the idea of natural selection independently. (Robert Wright quotes Darwin’s unpublished notes on this issue.)</p><p>The philosopher Dennett (9) grudgingly admitted that there is a sense in which we could not have done other than we did (free will does not apply) and stated that learning and choosing are “all the free will worth wanting.” This looks like an effort to avoid falling into the trap of fatalism. By dodging the fatalism trap Dennett created an implied definition of free will as learning and choosing in a predetermined way, which is hardly free. He failed to address the issue head on.</p><p>Facing it head on we see that learning, choosing and illusory freedom are all we have, if we can’t value that we end up depressed. When we learn and choose more effectively then we feel freer. When we recognize the impossibility of perfection and settle down to do the best we can that is another kind of subjective, illusory, but valuable freedom. If we mistakenly believe that we are responsible for who we are then we place ourselves on a roller coaster of self praise and self blame which can make us truly miserable. Understanding that our will is not free does not stop us from refining our learning and choosing process and increasing our feelings of freedom. Not banging my head on the wall of causality feels pretty good.</p><p><strong>5</strong>) Clinging and Not Clinging to the idea of Free Will</p><p>I said that what we experience as free will is limited to the compulsory act of making inevitable choices. One common response is that “there is a point where you have to take responsibility for your actions”. These responders assume that seeing the illusory nature of free will provides an excuse for me to do what I want to do instead of what I should do. I always do what I want to do. There may be conflicting desires internally but I can’t help making the choice that I am most motivated to make, and neither can you. When we are getting along it is often because what I want to do corresponds with what you think I should do, and vice versa.</p><p>There are two powerful forces that motivate the “take responsibility” crowd to insist on the idea that I am morally responsible for my actions in the sense implied by a belief in free will. Both forces can be found in both secular and religious contexts. Neither of the following forces prevents the causality web from existing and developing deterministically as causes bring about effects.</p><p>1) The experience of efficacious choice is so powerful that the idea of illusory free will is counter intuitive. It is difficult to appreciate that it is the will that is not free and that efficacious choice is not the same as free choice. Western progress prone societies reinforce the idea that we have free will so it is quite difficult for us to appreciate on an emotional level that we are caught in a web not of our own making.</p><p>2) We seem to have evolved a sort of “vengeance instinct” that demands “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” in order to deter exploitation. A strong desire to get back at those who injure or insult us arises naturally and we justify it by denying the power of circumstance over those who insult or injure us. This denial leads to fear that theft, deception and violence will become common and acceptable if free will is widely recognized as an illusion and we can use the “my brain (or the causality web) made me do it” excuse.</p><p>Step back from this and it is laughable. We already confront and perpetrate theft, violence, and deception including self deception and accompanying hypocrisy on a daily basis. We can see it all around us even if we have been unable to see it in ourselves. The colonization of North America with military and police responses to indigenous objections, with breaking of treaties by colonizers and collusion of churches in cultural genocide is a now familiar example in Canada. At the same time that Canada attempts to intervene in genocide elsewhere in the world our governing bodies continue to force indigenous organizations to spend thousands of dollars defending treaty rights and human rights. The collective behaviours that allowed colonization and which continue to be problematic involve many individual deceptive, thieving and violent choices in spite of a professed belief in God given free will and a supposedly God given moral code. It is easy for me to see this until I remember that I have lived on stolen land that I worked and paid for, and then I become defensive.</p><p>Theft, deception and violence are often held to be acceptable, even laudable. We see this in the ancient Jews following the commands of a trickster God to defeat their enemies, in Israeli oppression of Palestinians, in suicide bombers, in Homer making a hero of Odysseus, and in Canadian history books which applaud John A McDonald who promoted cultural genocide, and which applaud colonization in general because to do otherwise would undermine national self image.</p><p>We can all come up with examples where most people today would say theft, deception and violence are laudable, including hiding Jews from nazis, protecting children from bullies, and Robin Hood behaviour. I have to applaud my late brother in law who stole meat for his children. Although that last item might not sit well with everyone it is obviously important that we retain the capacity for theft, deception and violence in extreme situations, mostly so we can protect ourselves from the theft deception and violence of other people. Unilateral disarmament is not always a practical option for people who want to survive.</p><p>Demanding that we “take responsibility” won’t change theft, deception and violence. It is only changes in motivation that affect behaviour. By giving everyone a stake in the smooth functioning of society we might align human motivation more closely with what our society considers to be right. Perhaps we will get closer to that by learning from experience and making more effective choices.</p><p>We often cling to the idea of free will in the hope that we can avoid pain and disaster. I suggest a different approach. Recognize and abandon the hubris involved in clinging to the idea of free will. A humble recognition that whatever morality we have is the result of the causality web and not a result of personal merit is a realistic place to begin. Then we need to value the ongoing and partly conscious feedback loop in which we choose, learn from consequences, choose in the next situation and learn more, which is how we actively participate in unfolding the causality web over time. This process does not give us free will, but it does increase our feelings of freedom and control.</p><p>The leaving of ultimate responsibility to forces larger than individuals or human societies is supported by science but is also a form of ancient wisdom exemplified by Buddhist recognition of interconnectedness, Christian “there but for the grace of God go I”, and by the even older idea of fate.</p><p><strong>6</strong>) Implications: Ending Judgemental Approaches to Social Order</p><p>As investigation into brain structure and function (10, 15) genetics, education, social science, biological and cultural evolution and related areas continues we understand more and more about what determines our motivation. The most important lesson may be that our behaviour is determined.</p><p>Recently discoveries in brain development and decision making have been popularized so free will as it pertains to education and justice is a hot topic (3.) Already western legal systems recognize insanity and neurological damage as removing moral responsibility. It is a small intellectual step from recognizing that abnormal brain structure and function destroy free will and remove moral responsibility to recognizing that normal brain structure and function determine the actions of normal people. There are those who oppose using abnormal brain structure as a legal defence because they see and fear this logical next step (Kiehl, 15.) If the legal system focussed on protection, restitution and rehabilitation rather than obsessing about culpability and free will there would be nothing to fear about taking biology in account.</p><p>From the perspective of biology I am no more to blame for being a sophisticated manipulative tool wielding monkey than a tiger is to blame for hunting its prey. The same applies to you. This view aligns well with the Christian injunction “judge not lest ye be judged”. We don’t have to believe in supernatural or divine judgement to see this play out. When we judge others we are at least unconsciously aware that our own failings are similar to theirs and we may in the long run doom ourselves to the hell of negative self judgement.</p><p>A nonjudgemental view of myself and others, based on accepting the compulsory and constrained nature of so called free will is liberating. There is no basis for blame. It is also disappointing as no matter how hard I work there is no reward that I can truly deserve. There are people I would like to emulate, none that I hero worship. Admiration and contempt are equally inappropriate if there is no free will. Of course I will still experience contempt and admiration. I may still use them to manipulate others. But a deep belief in justified contempt and admiration cannot survive appreciation of the illusory nature of free will.</p><p>No matter how badly a person wronged me or I them, they were doing what they had to do and so was I. With this view I no longer need to give and receive forgiveness as there is nothing to forgive. Since blame and anger arise automatically in my mind when I am hurt, and since feeling a need for forgiveness seems to be automatic as well it might be more realistic to recognize that that blame and anger arise in my mind and to get in the habit of automatically forgiving while dealing with whatever harm caused the blame and anger to arise. Either way, blame and desire for vengeance both fall away.</p><p>Realizing that pain inflicted on us is always an accident of circumstance even when it is deliberate relieves the anguish of angry reaction when we are hurt. If you believe in a creator god then you may accept that each particular pain is an act of divine providence (built into creation) with pretty much the same result. If we could remain aware of the causality web even when hurt we would never suffer angry reaction. Few of us will reach the level of Christ on the cross with his ‘they know not what they do,” or the level of a bodhisattva diving joyfully into the hell realms to rescue other beings. If we are lucky we have enough experience of cutting through self deception and arriving at an appreciation of our own motives and the needs of others to keep us going towards non judgement.</p><p>I was socialized by praise and blame, by the enjoyment of admiration and by the pain of contempt, by aspiring to emulate heroes and distancing myself from villains. These things guided me so that I could live with others. What works better is understanding human motives, mine and other people’s. As a westerner the language I grew up with works against me in this, tending towards value judgements that cut off understanding.</p><p>Although I obviously do not believe in anything close to absolute free will, maintaining a non judgemental attitude requires work on my part and I can’t do it all the time. The habit of judgement, which I may have been born with (4), is too strong for that. Sometimes I find myself labelling myself or others as good or bad, rather than seeing actions that are understandable. When I am nonjudgemental I see what is going on with myself better as self deception and repression are not needed to end negative self regard. To a lesser extent being non judgmental helps me see what is going on with others. I am more focussed on understanding when allocation of praise and blame is not an issue. A nonjudgemental attitude helps me learn.</p><p>If we always valued learning over judgement and vengeance there would be changes to our legal system (3.) For example, in a recent case of drunk driving where the driver was caught before they caused an accident the penalty was a temporarily suspended driving licence. In a different case in my area there was an accident where the drunk survived and others were killed. This driver received a severe jail sentence. The crime, risking someone. else’s life, was the same in each case. The second driver was punished more severely because he was unlucky, not because he did anything worse. If you think the punishment of the two drivers should be different you are still thinking in terms of vengeance balancing things which is impossible as the dead individuals cannot be returned to life. People who drive drunk often do so because they don’t think they are going to cause an accident. If we are going to remove dangerous offenders from the drivers seat then both drivers, including the lucky one who avoided an accident and is probably now overconfident about driving drunk, should loose their licences until they have learned not to drive drunk. If we are going to impose a jail sentence as a deterrent to drunk driving then both drivers should go to jail.</p><p>Dropping the idea of free will and not looking for vengeance does not mean dropping the idea of social control. When we are harmed by theft, deception and/or violence, even if we have lost the habit of blame we desire the restoration of what has been lost, and we want protection from future harm. Some features of our justice system may not change very much with or without the illusion of free will, but restorative justice and rehabilitation make more sense than retribution once we realize that free will is a misnomer. We don’t even have to believe in the total absence of free will to arrive at that conclusion, just recognizing the magnitude of genetic and environmental influences shrinks free will, should it exist, to minuscule size.</p><p>Human social control is inevitable because many human beings desire and work towards a society where trust and cooperation can be established, and because hierarchy in some form is always established. In a society where the majority trade favours honestly there is mutual trust. But in such a society a cheater does very well, so cheating spreads, either by biological natural selection or by cultural evolution. Cheating occurs within most social species including ours.</p><p>There are fish and squid species in which some males look and behave like females and are not chased off by stronger typical males. Males that mimic females enjoy reproductive success without having to be big and strong. If there are too many cheaters they have to compete with each other and the advantage disappears so natural selection maintains a small population of cheaters. In this case it is obvious that the cheaters are not “bad fish” they are just a different kind of fish.</p><p>Almost certainly genetics and experience are both factors in human cheating. Whatever the range of causes we all lie and cheat if circumstances motivate us enough, and none of us do if we are certain of being thwarted by getting caught. Starving people are more likely to steal. Those who will be punished for telling the truth, like gays and lesbians and members of persecuted ethnic groups are more likely to lie. Children who are punished for displays of emotion and for talking about unacceptable thoughts may learn to actively repress and mask their own psychology. These children may not be capable of honest communication until they learn to, and are rewarded for, seeking truth in themselves. Probably we are all these children although the areas where repression was required of us vary. Assisting and rewarding conscious recognition of subconscious motivation seems to me to be an important function of religion and therapeutic practice supported by science, although neither works consistently in this regard.</p><p>Repression of our own failings may not need to be taught. We may instinctively repress seeing how we fail to live the way we expect others to live. Then by believing we are as good as we think everyone should be, we easily project an image of a person with integrity, becoming hypocrites without realizing it. We all become more honest when honesty is rewarded, but cheating is part of our behavioural repertoire (21.)</p><p>Social control may be experienced in a completely different way by privileged and non-privileged members of a group. In nation states power, privilege and money are closely associated with the privileged receiving better protection from police, more lenient penalties for breaking the law, better education etc. Privilege comes in many forms (race, income, gender etc.) with the privileged forming cooperative groups separate from those of the disadvantaged. This may be openly and widely acknowledged by privileged and disadvantaged groups or, as here in Canada, it may be more covert. Either way those with the most privilege see them/ourselves as good, right and just. If they/we saw things any other way they/we would have to live with internal conflict or give up their/our privilege, and we all act in our own self interest even at the level of perception.</p><p>When we think of justice we generally think of getting what we deserve and deserving what we get. Given the causality web this is impossible. We are born a certain way and are governed by physical laws and built in psychological mechanisms that determine our development. There is no justice in this sense.</p><p>If we accept that free will is an illusion we may not believe justice is obtainable and we may no longer have a strong desire for vengeance but we still need to protect ourselves. We may still support the idea of deterring criminal acts by imposing penalties. But when we recognize that we are protecting ourselves, not administering just deserts, then there is no place for self righteous attitudes.</p><p>Some people say there are absolutely right and absolutely wrong ways of behaving. Establishing what is absolutely right and what is absolutely wrong is not possible. Most societies favour moral codes that support reproductive success and expand territory so the society is maintained or expanded. Those that don’t, don’t last long. The only example I know of is the Shakers, who no longer exist. So right and wrong are ultimately self serving concepts belonging to a community, as such they do not serve all individuals well. Slavery, extreme concentrations of wealth, torture, execution, human sacrifice, offering some people a choice between health destroying employment and extreme poverty are all examples of right behaviour somewhere, sometime, in human populations.</p><p>A practical approach to a harmonious society is found in the form of “the golden rule” which is “what you would not wish for yourself do not do to others” or “do as you would be done by.” We are very aware of how we absolutely would and absolutely would not like to be treated in our social group. Since other people seem to have the same preferences, and we tend to treat others the way we are treated, the golden rule provides a workable method for providing social order if only we all followed it, and followed it beyond our own group.</p><p>Kindness to strangers and non-judgement are taught in the Abrahamic and Buddhistic religious traditions, and increasingly they are taught in a secular context. Teaching the value of altruism beyond our own small group is necessary precisely because what comes naturally is kindness towards our own group tempered by self interest. Repeated xenophobic and genocidal behaviour of individuals and groups shows just how difficult it is to widen altruism as far as the entire human family.</p><p>The call to treat others as we would wish to be treated without looking for an immediate reward crops up in religious and secular teachings world wide. The earliest written record that I could find reference to was from ancient Egypt about 2,000BCE (Wikipedia entry for the Golden Rule). Recently (about 2000) Harris suggested we make a science of human wellbeing with a view to maximizing it, which amounts to a scientific attempt to intelligently implement the golden rule using national and international levels of organization as well as individual decision making.</p><p>History tells us that in spite of people having formulated and taught the golden rule in a variety of cultural settings for at least 4,000 years the peaceful, helpful, egalitarian and crime free society it promises is nowhere to be found. We can find theft, deception and violence in any human society. People are too self interested and hypocritical, too interested in our own status, too suspicious of others, to follow the golden rule consistently, so far.</p><p>Unless human nature changes we will always have to deal with self interested individuals capable of deception attempting to live in community. Some religions address this tension by encouraging us to discover the joy that giving can bring. Giving creates happiness by helping us feel good about ourselves, by surrounding us with happy people, and by establishing a base for reciprocal altruism it gives us some future security as well. But giving does not always work this way. It is easy to give to people that will give us something back, even if it is just gratitude or status. It is harder to give to people who are really needy because they resent the implied debt or status loss. In our own circle we may give things that we want to share instead of what others need. Sometimes others need us to give the gift of honesty and we go the easy way and flatter them instead. Sometimes we think we are giving honesty when we are using honesty as a weapon. Status seeking is served by largesse and volunteer work especially if it is given publicly. Sometimes we give by receiving gracefully so that someone else can experience the joy of giving. Sometimes we just accept what we want as if we were doing the donor a favour. The power and scope of self deception in this area is breathtaking.</p><p>It is possible that understanding the long term consequences of narrowly and more widely directed altruism will change our motivation by directing our self interested instincts toward planetary integrity. We already have international organizations that work, however imperfectly, at a more egalitarian distribution of the benefits of technological progress.</p><p>Making the subconscious conscious is a difficult individual journey. How much more difficult it is to do this at the national or international level with a population, leaders and organizations in many different states of self knowledge and self deception. Inadequate though truth and reconciliation processes are, the fact that this happens at all is encouraging. I am a product of the Roman invasion of Britain and the idea of the ancient Roman empire trying a truth and reconciliation process is so unlikely it strikes me as funny. Perhaps we have learned something since then, or perhaps recovery of colonized indigenous peoples has made a conciliatory attitude prudent.</p><p>Publicly acknowledging and legally accounting for the illusory nature of free will is bound to alter the way we deal with each other. As studies of determinants of human behaviour pile up we are poised to find out what shape that will take. If we don’t deny the causality web spread out before us human relationships will have a more realistic basis.</p><p><strong>7</strong>) Uncertainty and The Future</p><p>The causality web concept rests on causality, which is impossible to prove although we all experience it every day. We have to assume that the future resembles the past in order to have predictable causal relationships in the future. I am pretty sure that we live in a world with predictable causal relationships which preclude free will, but physicists say there are dimensions that are not physically accessible to us, some buddhists believe that there are other dimensions in which sentient beings exist, and such things are indeed beyond the reach of my mind. I don’t know if a fourth or eleventh, or 1000th dimensional being or beings might intervene in our reality. For all I know we have souls that hang out in another dimension. We might have been intentionally created, or not. When it comes down to it I cannot be certain about what is out there. If I was I would be an even worse student of reality than I am.</p><p>As a student of reality I have come to the conclusion that for practical purposes causality exists and free will is an illusion. I will hold that opinion unless it is convincingly refuted.</p><p>Our uninformed minds attempting to see where causality will take us next generate many possible futures. Usually the actual future differs from what we expected. We are curious about the future. We conduct experiments to help us predict it. We have plans and hopes. This is an integral part of the causality web.</p><p>We are using innovative technology to support larger and larger human populations as we are pushed by our most fundamental characteristics toward reproductive success. By improving our physical condition we have built ourselves a treadmill where we need new technology to counter the harmful effects of technology we depend on. This has had a strange effect on the concept and conditions of privacy.</p><p>In the small bands in our environment of evolution everyone knows everyone else and most of their business too. In this setting there is deception and secrecy, but nothing like our expectation of privacy or our liable laws. Technology is rapidly taking nation states back to this goldfish bowl existence. Small cameras and microphones are all but undetectable. Tiny undetected drones may fly over private areas. Personal data may be captured with consent or hacked. Massive amounts of information can be filtered and digested by artificial intelligence so mingling in a crowd is no guarantee of privacy. The actions of public servants especially police and military personnel is especially visible and may be recorded with or without their knowledge. Lack of privacy may make cheating more difficult, the accumulation and analysis of personal data makes self understanding through psychology easier and it can facilitate totalitarian government. It is unclear how this will play out.</p><p>Perhaps we will create a world that allows people and other beings to enjoy the fullness of life without permitting the destruction of others. The need for limits that stop destruction applies equally to psychopaths, wealthy self serving pillars of the community who deny others material wellbeing and status, and our own self serving tendencies. Accomplishing this would not be. justice (which does not exist), it would be an expression of human understanding.</p><p>Sweeping unpleasant or unwelcome facts about our lack of unconditional love, our lack of free will, our competitive, territorial, insecure and racist tendencies under the rug is not compassion, it is denial. If we cut through denial we may make increasingly well informed choices supporting the wellspring of faith, hope and charity written into the DNA of most humans.</p><p>In future humans may be using technology to learn faster to counter unwanted effects of technology. We may be drastically reducing the human population to reduce environmental impact and vulnerability to epidemics. We may enjoy a more egalitarian distribution of resources or experience a widening gap between rich and poor. We may use genetic repair to maintain a healthy population without the horrors of eugenics. We may allow environmental disaster to collapse our technology treadmill while we are busy fighting over resources and status, in that case we will collectively experience increased natural selection events as the apparently mindless and compassionless forces that have always shaped us increase: famine, war, pollution, pestilence, flood and drought.</p><p>Because of what we are what has already been set in motion will continue with our active participation as long as we exist. We do not know where unfree will is taking us. Time will tell.</p><p><strong>8</strong>) Annotated bibliography</p><p>Most of the ideas and information laid out above are located in many sources and I am not going to try and nail down the earliest origin of each. Instead I provide this idiosyncratic annotated bibliography to aid investigation of free will and associated issues.</p><p>1 <strong>Alexie</strong></p><p>Sherman Alexie is a poet, novelist and film producer who expresses the need for expanding altruism beyond family. He expresses this poetically in all his work. His new poem, Hymn, which I found on facebook addresses it quite explicitly.</p><p>2 <strong>Batchelor</strong></p><p>In After Buddhism (2015) Batchelor argues that Buddhism was originally about not living in a reactive way. This is a long and detailed read, worth the effort if you have an interest in examining the nature, extent and limitations of human freedom. Batchelor describes Buddhism as sliding from from pragmatic introspective psychology into a more traditionally religious framework. Batchelor has blazed a trail into secular Buddhism with his books.</p><p>3 <strong>Benforado</strong></p><p>In Unfair: the new science of criminal injustice (Reprint 2015) Adam Benforado explores the American justice system in light of new neuroscience.</p><p>4 <strong>Bloom</strong></p><p>In Just Babies (2014) Paul Bloom describes how babies attribute causality to the world around them, and how they seem to have the beginnings of a moral sense even before they can talk.</p><p>5 <strong>Brazier</strong></p><p>David Brazier is a psychotherapist and Zen priest practicing Zen therapy. He is the author of many books on Buddhism including Buddhism is a religion: you can believe it (2014) and Not everything is impermanent (2013). He presents an antithesis to secular Buddhism. My spiritual hunger has been for a something that sounds like an oxymoron, but perhaps is not, a secular religion with more formal ritual, awe/reverence, and emphasis on individual and collective discovery/creation of meaning in life than science provides. Brazier is particularly helpful when acknowledging that he struggles with interpretation of his own experiences from both Buddhist religious and scientific perspectives, and when he explores what distinguishes religious from secular practices.</p><p>6 <strong>Brooks</strong></p><p>In The Social Animal (2012) Brooks explores many areas of current research in psychology in the context of a particular couple’s development as individuals, as a couple, and in their roles at work and in society in general. It is an entertaining, sensitive and informative presentation although there are points where he makes unwarranted assumptions.</p><p>7 <strong>Botton</strong></p><p>Botton’s non fiction works How Proust can change your life (1998) and Status Anxiety (2005) are delightfully literate, articulate and readable investigations of the human condition. He maintains there is free will, but he does not really question it. I wonder what would happen if he did.</p><p>8 <strong>Brown</strong></p><p>Berne Brown has written a series of self help books including Rising Strong (2015) in these publications she shares the intimate details of her introspection, her therapeutic work, and the lessons she draws from those experiences.</p><p>9 <strong>Dennett</strong></p><p>In Consciousness Explained (1992) philosopher Danial Dennett suggests that consciousness is experienced when we build mental models of our own mind and body. In Freedom Evolves (2004) he grudgingly admits that free will leaves us with only one possible action per choice, but he is interested in the processes of learning and choosing which is all the free will “worth having”. Dennett is an important philosopher in the creationism versus evolution and the theist versus atheist controversies and has an interest in artificial intelligence which is an important current issue so I am a bit sad that his books are difficult for the uninitiated.</p><p>10 <strong>Feldman</strong> <strong>Barrett</strong></p><p>In How Emotions are Made: the secret life of the brain (2017) Lisa Feldman Barrett describes the use of fMRI to study how brain activity associated with emotion is distributed. She debunks the idea that emotion is generated by one or a few brain areas. According to her emotion arises as a pattern of brain activation distributed throughout the brain. The areas previously assigned as emotion centres may be critical for experiencing and/or acting on emotion, but they are not the whole story. She makes a good case for equating emotional and intellectual states with brain states. If this interests you you might also want to read Consciousness and the Brain: Deciphering how the Brain Codes Thoughts (Stanislas Dehaene 2014).</p><p>11 <strong>Gorman</strong> and <strong>Gorman</strong></p><p>In Denying to the Grave (2016) Gorman and Gorman explore why we deny scientific evidence that could be life saving. It turns out that appeals to emotion are far more persuasive than logic. In my opinion that is why the contributions of religion and therapy to human self knowledge are so important.</p><p>12 <strong>Harris</strong></p><p>A scientist with a conscience. In Free Will (2012) Harris investigates the issue of free will, which he says does not exist. In Lying (2013) he explores why it is in our best interest not to become habitual liars. In The Moral Landscape (2011) he talks about how science can develop our morality. He brings passion and intellect to his writing.</p><p>13 <strong>Harrison</strong></p><p>In the The Central Liberal Truth (2008) Harrison states that progress prone societies emphasize free will while progress resistant societies are more fatalistic.</p><p>14 <strong>Hood</strong></p><p>In The Self Illusion (2013) Hood explores the nature of self, touching on the problem of fatalism. In the last chapter he summarizes the self illusion, but here I have to disagree with an unsupported assertion. He says “Those who reject the notion of a self in control of destiny, lead sadder, less satisfying lives.” He does not explore the difference between embracing the illusion of self as reality and embracing the illusion of self as an illusion, and he does not fully explore the implications of what he says about illusory self. By addressing these things he would contribute to a deeper understanding of humanity by humanity.</p><p>15 <strong>Kiehl</strong></p><p>In the Psychopath Whisperer (2014) Dr Kent Kiehl describes decades of neurological work with psychopaths.</p><p>16 <strong>Mercier</strong></p><p>In The Enigma of Reason (2017) Mercier argues that reason evolved to facilitate transmission of knowledge, not to facilitate the endeavours of solitary geniuses. According to this interactionist. theory innovators can be understood best by seeing them in their social context.</p><p>17 <strong>Rasheta</strong></p><p>As of January 2018 Noah Rasheta is executive director of the Foundation for Mindful Living and hosts the Secular Buddhism podcast.</p><p>18 <strong>Sapolsky</strong></p><p>Behave: the biology of humans at our best and worst (2017) is what it sounds like, an overview of why we do what we do. He tackles free will and much, much more.</p><p>19 <strong>Shaw</strong></p><p>In The Memory Illusion Dr. Julia Shaw explores how memories change over time and how they are influenced by others.</p><p>20 <strong>Sloman</strong> and <strong>Fernbach</strong></p><p>The Knowledge Illusion (2017) A detailed look at the communal nature of knowledge.</p><p>21 <strong>Trivers</strong></p><p>In the The Folly of Fools (2011) Robert Trivers explores human deception and lying from the perspective of evolutionary biology.</p><p>22 <strong>Vohs</strong> and <strong>Schooler</strong></p><p>In 2008 Vohs and Schooler published an article in entitled. “The value of believing in free will”. An abstract and bibliography are available from Sage Journals on the world wide web.</p><p>23 <strong>De</strong> <strong>Waal</strong></p><p>In The Age of Empathy (2010) Frans de Waal looks at the behaviour of our close relatives, where we find some very human looking behaviours. I have not read The bonobo and the atheist: in search of humanism among the primates (2013) yet, but it looks promising.</p><p>24 <strong>Wright</strong></p><p>In The Moral Animal (1995) Wright explores human morality from an evolutionary biology perspective. He over generalizes about feminist views but otherwise this is a pretty balanced approach. Wright does not try and define good and bad, but looks for benefit and harm resulting from traits produced by natural selection and various social structures. He describes the theory of evolution of social behaviour in detail including relations between the sexes and reciprocal altruism with its accompanying feelings. His application of Darwinism to Darwins life is particularly apt. In Non Zero (2001) he explores human history and our progress toward world government. His latest book, the best seller Why Buddhism is True (2017) is a short pithy discussion of the principles of secular Buddhism. In The Evolution of God (2010) he describes. how spirituality and religion change with changing social structures.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f1b6d3bf76bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the (Un)Free Will issue Matters for Practical Purposes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@judithjohnson_14390/why-the-un-free-will-issue-matters-for-practical-purposes-f0971c1cbd7b?source=rss-397ed3597656------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0971c1cbd7b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Judith Johnson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Feb 2018 17:00:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-10T17:00:01.568Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why the (Un)Free Will issue Matters for Practical Purposes</p><p>1) Causality: the mystery of existence</p><p>Why does one thing lead to another? That is the real mystery of existence, a question I can’t begin to address. Experiments on preverbal infants show that that we are born looking for cause and effect. Human language assumes causality. Effects have multiple causes, eg. many votes elect a president, and causes have multiple effects eg. one person can infect a large population with a virus. Because of this interconnectedness all of reality consists of a complex web of causes and effects developing through time. Sometimes small causes have large effects at a distance. Large effects distant from small causes and multiple causes make prediction uncertain or even impossible for us much of the time. But we are successful at predicting events often enough to think we have some understanding of our world.</p><p>We can’t imagine a reality without causality, and if there is causality then the past determines the future from before we were born to after our death as effects follow causes through time. This is not a great leap; this conclusion has been reached many times by those who were willing to reach it and so it has many names: fate, predestination, determinism, predictable reality. There are subtle distinctions between these terms but they are close enough for this moment and I will bring out differences as necessary.</p><p>If I drew lines between the things that affect me (causes) and myself, then added lines for the effects I have, I would find myself at the centre of many radiating lines. If I added all possible lines between causes and effects I might fill all available space. I would be penetrated by and full of cause and effect lines many of which pass through me, leaving me with no distinct boundary.</p><p>My perceivable reality is a dense and massive web, a causality web, which simultaneously creates and imprisons all of us. This view of our reality as the only possible world is in opposition to the prevailing western Christian attitude that we have free will with which we freely create our future from many options. The conflict between these ideas has led me to question the idea of free will. I may as well say right now that free will looks like an illusion from where I am.</p><p>Where I am is agnostic on many issues. Although I attempt to practice Buddhism I do not believe or not believe in past or future lives, except as part of this life where my experience says myself, which defies definition, is continuously reborn as experience modifies self. Being agnostic is not a faith, nor is it a denial of the faith of others, it is realization and acceptance of my own ignorance. Saying “I don’t know” is an act of humility and realism that acknowledges the limits of my experience and ways of knowing. It involves giving up the idea that I was raised with that I should always have an opinion on everything.</p><p>I do however have an opinion on free will. In my opinion it is an illusion that we would be better off without. If I have faith it is that seeing clearly how we are created and held by causality will stop human beings judging self and other. I hope that this will expand our empathy and altruistic tendencies beyond our immediate family to include not just other people, but all sentient beings and the inanimate framework that supports our ecosystem. As far as I can see self interest rules every human institution from family to the UN but people need each other emotionally as well as physically, countries need each other, and we all need a functioning ecosystem. I can hope for. whole hearted cooperation on a large scale because it is always in everyone’s self interest to have that, doubly so in this age of genetic engineering, nuclear armament and human induced climate change.</p><p>Causality and the absence of free will may the the largest topic I could have chosen to address. All of human knowledge is relevant to it in some way. I have provided a short annotated bibliography with a list of authors whose publications I found useful while exploring and expressing thoughts about that. I have included my current favourite poet (1), many scientists (10–12, 15,16, 18–24) and buddhist writers (2, 5, 17) among others. Numbers in this text refer to that list.</p><p>2) Choice and Unfree Will: enmeshment in the causality web</p><p>Throughout life we are aware of multiple potential actions and must choose. There is no way out of this compulsory experience as not choosing, not acting, or acting on habit are default choices. We often deliberately choose our actions with specific desired effects consciously in mind, i.e. we plan. It is the experience of conscious choice and planning that suggests to us that we have free will.</p><p>We feel we are free to choose from the options before us but our motivation has already been formed by the web of causes and effects that resulted in our conception and development. Being presented with a choice may result in agonizing inner conflict but there is only one action (or inaction) that we are most motivated to make, and we make that choice. The free will we experience is illusory as we can only decide to do what we are most motivated to do at each moment and that is dictated by past and present circumstances including what we have learned and brought to mind about causality and the way the choice is presented. Since our motivation (will) is not free, and much of it is not even conscious let alone freely chosen, the phenomenon called free will is named in a misleading way.</p><p>After we make a choice we learn from the combination of choice and perceived consequence. We may learn that we want to make different choices in future. That learning process occurs within and because of causality, not despite of or outside it.</p><p>Learning from experience in general forms a feedback loop in the causality web so it partly controls the web of which it is a part. The idea of feedback comes from systems theory but is easily understood by anyone who has used a household thermostat. A thermostat senses and controls temperature in the building that it is part of by turning the heating off when the required temperature is reached and back on if things cool down too much. The current temperature is detected and fed back to a decision making switch that turns the heat on or off. We set the desired temperature of the switching mechanism which is responsible for the temperature of its house, but not for its own design or setting. The loop that turns the heat off when it is too hot is negative feedback, it keeps the temperature stable although the heater has the capacity to exceed the set temperature. What it does is what it is responsible for. In the same way we are responsible for what we do, but not for being what we are, and not our “set temperature.”</p><p>Our set temperature is simply feeling good. We have built in ways of doing that, ways that support reproductive success in the environment in which our species evolved. Our feelings are like the temperature detector in the thermostat and our behaviour is the switching mechanism geared to keeping those feelings good. Because of natural selection what makes us feel good is meeting our physical and social needs including favouring kin and allies.</p><p>Learning by experience lets us modify our behaviour making our “switching mechanism” more effective. It adds a feedback loop as follows. Learning affects how we act, which affects what we learn next, which affects how we act, which affects what we learn, which affects how we act in a never ending process that lets us aim ever more effectively at desired consequences. This is a morally neutral process which can help us be better parents, better piano players, better warriors, better liars, better crusaders or better torturers depending on how genetics and experience have shaped our desires.</p><p>My intention in using a thermostat and switching mechanism to explain feedback in the above paragraphs is to highlight the difference between control and freedom. The thermostat that does its job and keeps a comfortable home is not a morally good thermostat. If it gets broken it is not bad. It most certainly does not have free will, yet it has a controlling function. We are complex and the choices we make are often influenced by thousands of genetic and environmental factors. Those choices have real effects in the causality web giving us some control over it. Complexity, control, and learning do not imply free will. Learning from experience provides increasingly effective methods for implementing the will that we have, which is an entirely different thing.</p><p>This gets complicated. We may be presented with choices that we know will affect our future motivation (will), although we don’t fully understand those changes until after they happen, if then. We may read up on determinism and free will. We may learn a new skill like art, music, math or a sport. We may learn how to make affirmations, how to pray, how to meditate, how to communicate better with others, how to take direction from scripture, religious authorities, ethicists, custom or law, or we may strive to be independent of external moral authority although that is difficult for such gregarious animals. Any of these choices can be expected to have profound effects on our motivation, but none of them allow us to pick our motivation from a position that is free of causality.</p><p>Although we can never arrive at absolute free will the quality of our illusory freedom matters to us. We act in accord with our will if we are not restrained physically and that feels freer than being physically restrained. We feel freer to act in accord with our desires if there are not too many painful consequences for doing so, otherwise our desire to avoid pain overrides other desires, molding our will.</p><p>Our desire to avoid emotional and physical pain gives our parents and community a powerful way to manipulate us. Parents and community condition us, rewarding behaviours that are acceptable in our society and disapproving of those that are not until we internalize the lessons and end up with a conscience. A conscience makes us feel bad when we do something we think is wrong and gives us a pleasant feeling when we do what we think is right. What we think of as right is what is expected of us in our society. If I was a pre European contact Polynesian chief and I sacrificed the life one of my least valuable children to placate an angry god and save my people I probably would not suffer pangs of conscience. Parents and community do their best to condition us so that our conscience reflects their values.</p><p>We learn to delay or refuse gratification if the anticipated consequences of indulgence are undesirable. A guilty conscience is definitely undesirable, right up there with an empty stomach or a crying child. No one wants regrets. Even my dog anticipates the future and has something like a conscience. He stays off the table and out of the garbage because he does not like the consequences of violating my expectations. Having a conscience is nothing to brag about. Eating garbage when wholesome food is provided is nothing to brag about either.</p><p>We shine compared to other animals with regard to anticipation of future consequences and long term planning but we have a surprising amount of difficulty accepting short term pain for long term gain even in simple things where the consequences are quite obvious. It is difficult for a child to stay out of the cookie jar for 5 unsupervised minutes. It is difficult for an adult to exercise the 24/7 self control needed to loose weight or stop smoking, even when our lives are at risk. Being generous with others is difficult if we are not secure about having enough for ourselves, even when we desire the benefits of having others as allies.</p><p>At times our own actions puzzle us because both conscious and unconscious motivation come into play. Saint Paul in Romans 7:15 describes the common human experience of subconscious motivation and strong desires overruling deliberate conscious decisions. “I do not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do.” Science, therapy and religion address our enmeshment in the causality web and our conflicting desires. They can all deepen our understanding of ourselves.</p><p>3)	Understanding Ourselves: Science, Therapy and Religion</p><p>Understanding ourselves is a knotty problem because much of our motivation is not conscious and we are resistant to seeing our own unconscious motivation clearly. The principle of natural selection so well articulated by Darwin and Wallace cuts that knot. It can be applied to biological evolution and to the spread of ideas that cause cultural evolution. It is a stunningly simple principle: what both survives and reproduces in the present environment is perpetuated into the future. A biological lineage is perpetuated when births equal or outnumber deaths. Ideas are perpetuated when they spread from individual to individual faster than individuals die or change their minds.</p><p>Since genetics and the theory of biological evolution by natural selection have been used to justify forced eugenics and genocide many scientists are understandably afraid of how their work will be used. Realistic accounts of human development and behaviour may be attacked for a variety of political, ideological or religious reasons. In spite of the social hazards an increasing number of scientists are willing to stop equivocating and say outright that free will is an illusion (12) and that natural selection has shaped our psychology so that we are. predictable but only partly aware of our own motivation. The existence of unconscious motivation allows us to deceive others and/or ourselves when such deception is likely to promote reproductive success (21). Studies of the great apes, extant human hunter/gatherer bands, and people in modern nation states support these ideas (18, 23, 24).</p><p>Natural selection shaped life for billions of years starting before it was life. We have had less than 200 years in which to understand how it has shaped us but a coherent story is emerging rapidly. We are motivated to act in ways that promote the spread of our own genes by promoting reproductive success of our own children, siblings children and known useful allies more than we support others. We don’t need to be aware of underlying mechanisms for this to work. Lust will drive us to sexual behaviour even if we don’t know that sex causes pregnancy. We bond socially with those close to us without necessarily consciously relating this to anyones reproductive success. We want social status (7) long before we understand that it is the “alpha wolf” that has the pups. Since we need social contact and our personal survival is supported by the survival of our own group and by inter-group trading relationships we are capable of altruism beyond our immediate family, but priority usually goes to kin, and between adults reciprocal altruism i.e. trading favours, rather than unreciprocated gifting, is usual.</p><p>Even between parents and children reciprocal altruism and outright exploitation are common. In many settings throughout history maturing children have been a source of labour and they have at times been hired out, offered as hostages, soldiers or priests; or sold as brides or slaves. Although we often think of families as held together by unconditional love, history particularly history of royal families where the stakes are high, provides a fuller picture complete with betrayal and exploitation. Love is an umbrella term used to describe a variety of intense and complex feelings. The various forms of love are real enough but they are not the full story.</p><p>When self interest and the interests of others coincide, as when we are helping others within our family, we are least conflicted and most likely to have a subjective experience of deep and apparently selfless love. Usually we think of this as a good thing. The lengths to which a human mother will go to promote the wellbeing of her children is legendary. Parental love is held up as a model of divine love. But when resources are limited, and they generally are, this same powerful altruism comes at the expense of distant relatives and strangers, and favouring the child who has the best chance of helping our reproductive success may come at the expense of other children.</p><p>Favouring closer kin over more distant kin and allies over enemies sometimes, perhaps always, takes the form of honour among thieves. Example 1) a ruling class claims to own all the land and the peasants that farm it, forming and funding military and/or police to maintain their advantage. Example 2) I was a lookout when my partner held my sisters feet as she hung upside down inside a donation bin looting a bunch of discards rather than begging for free handouts or cutting into her children’s food budget for clothes and dishes. Example 3) Europeans colonized less populous and less technological areas of the globe enforcing laws that rob the indigenous of land, political power, dignity, and often of life.</p><p>Our genes did not evolve to make us happy or honest. They evolved to keep us moving in the direction of reproductive success. Discontent is built in, as soon as we gratify one desire another one manifests. If our basic needs are provided for we set about increasing future security and that usually takes priority over preventing deaths in other human populations. Post reproductive couples tend to support their descendants. Chocolate, coffee and RRSPs sell here while people starve elsewhere in spite of global communication being at an all time high. Goods are rarely given for free, handouts are usually paid for by loss of status.</p><p>When I think about winning the lottery I automatically think of improving my life and that of close relatives and friends. None of us are starving or homeless so lots of people need those hoped for millions way more than we do. Yet “that will feed a lot of hungry people” is not my first thought. The desire to use resources that others need more is an unpleasant aspect of myself, and of human beings in general. Along with a desire for comfort and high status for ourselves, favouring the comfort and status of kin and allies over the survival of others is a root cause of human induced pollution, climate change, famine and war all of which threaten our survival in the long term as well as promoting our reproductive success in the short to medium term.</p><p>Many of our current social and environmental problems including environmental degradation, high tech war, and new epidemic diseases are a result of our reproductive success. That success. has accelerated as a result of our ability to learn from experience and transmit that knowledge between individuals and across generations, which has benefitted from growing populations in a positive feedback loop. The more we learn about developing technology the more we develop technology and the more we develop technology the more we learn about developing technology so the more technology we develop. Technology benefits from large educated populations so increasing technology and increasing populations work together to create positive feedback which is not stable.</p><p>Positive feedback loops result in a change of state. A forest fire is a case of positive feedback while it is growing. The bigger it is the more the heat dries out vegetation and heats it, so the more the fire grows. If it does not rain the whole forest may burn changing the state of an entire forest. Child birth also occurs by way of positive feedback with birth itself being the change of state. Positive feedback and change are not good or bad in and of themselves.</p><p>We are concerned about the change of state accelerating population growth and technological change will bring. Will our technology eventually cause global famine, disease, flood, drought and pollution on a scale that vastly reduces our population? This sort of thing happens to other species and we are aware of climate change already moving us in that direction. Will we learn enough to create better group decision making methods that help us maintain a large well fed population? Will we make ourselves into cyborgs with telepathic computers accessing communal knowledge as if communal knowledge was stored with individual memories? What would happen to our individual nature, our social organization and our global ecosystem if we merged with our machines that way? We don’t know how it will end, but we are too dependent on technology to stop without disaster.</p><p>For now human nature is much as it always was, adapted for life in small groups that compete with, cooperate with, and interbreed with each other while individuals favour family and allies. The tendency to favour family and allies and the less than fully conscious tendency to repress negative aspects of ourselves means the concept of free will is applied selectively. It is easy for us to see free will, culpability, and necessity of vengeance against heinous acts of strangers while claiming pressure of circumstance for heinous acts of our own group members. This is a significant barrier to wider altruism. For example I have found people who excuse official participation in the 60s scoop and Indian residential schools because officials made the best choices they could make given their understanding at the time are often the same people who, when discussing “criminals”, emphasize free will and moral responsibility. They feel justified in punishing people they recognize as “criminals” but not in recognizing people who removed indigenous children from their communities as criminals. This is also behind the tendency of non-indigenous people to discuss “the Indian/aboriginal problem” rather than the “settler problem.” Failing to see moral equivalence here is a form of self deception that occurs quite naturally (21, 24) and is well explained by natural selection. We all do this sort of thing. Training ourselves away from this evolved tendency can only be done by using our evolved tendencies. We will stop doing this when we see that our self interest (which includes favouring relatives and allies) is best served by stopping.</p><p>Science does not have a monopoly on understanding. The desire to find meaning and purpose in our lives, and the use of religious faith to this end appear to be universals found in all human cultures. Even the least religious among us have experience of awe, humility, contrition, hope, love and a sense of good and evil. These are evolved tendencies strongly associated with religion. As Brazier (5), a zen priest and psychotherapist, put it “ Meaning is obtained by contextualization…Small things make sense in terms of the bigger things that they are part of. The bigger things are part of something bigger still. The biggest are inevitably out of sight and so become matters of faith. If faith is prohibited, everything becomes meaningless.” For me the causality web is the biggest thing conceivable, effectively infinite and powerful, a presence that quite literally both penetrates and creates me without being fully knowable. Causality can be explored scientifically, and by introspection which has traditionally been a domain of religious/spiritual practice.</p><p>Science relies on causality, if causality did not exist there would be no point in scientific investigation. Through the process of peer review, replication of critical experiments and testing of theoretical predictions science provides as much objectivity and veracity as humans can hope to arrive at. However the theoretical understanding science provides cannot replace the individual introspective process involved in contemplation, some types of prayer and some types of therapy. Just as monitoring activity in the visual centres of the brain, or measuring the wave length of light is no substitute for seeing a colour so there is no theoretical or knowledge based substitute for any variety of introspection.</p><p>It is introspection that shows me my basic motivation (purpose, will): stay out of pain including the pain of others, stay away from death, acquire status, and enjoy life including the excitement of a manageable degree of risk for as long as possible. Introspection allows us to experience more of the causality web than we usually see and feel, through a feeling of oneness, through moments of enhanced empathy, by being more directly aware of our own feelings and reactions including the things we habitually repress, or through experiences that are impossible to describe in words. For me experiences of smallness in vastness result from contemplating apparently infinite material reality and apparently infinite time and that has a religious feel to it.</p><p>I am a very poor practitioner of Buddhist methods yet practicing Buddhism made my own motives clearer to me. When I remember to introspect, to permit negative emotion to surface and be seen, and not to latch onto either negative or positive experience, then I enjoy life more and am less depressed than at any previous time in my life except very early childhood. There is/was a price. I found being confronted with myself was traumatic, and sometimes it still is when I badly want to deny some unpleasant aspect of myself like the desire to run from the pain of others, choosing pleasing others over truth, or the desire to pressure others to repress their pain so I can be more comfortable.</p><p>When I commented to a Buddhist monk that “we are just animals” his reply was, “yes, but we can realize it, they cannot.” At the time I could only realize it intellectually and that is not enough to increase self knowledge. Only by dropping the intellectual into the belly, into emotional appreciation, can I begin to “realize” anything. Modern psychology supports this, for example experiments show that appeals to emotion are far more powerful than appeals to logic when it comes to changing our beliefs and actions (11).</p><p>Being confronted with what we tend to keep subconscious including selfishness, status seeking and powerlessness over our place in the causality web can produce developmental crisis. Developmental crisis is provoked and handled differently by different religious traditions, and by many western self help gurus and therapists who seem to keep reinventing, renaming and claiming credit for the same “wheel.” For example Brown’s work (8) includes explication of truths that are recognizably Buddhist, without any reference to Buddhism. The concept of original sin in Christianity combined with repentance and the idea of a forgiving and accepting God seem to me to be a way of recognizing and accepting our deep selfishness, sneaky subconscious, and the demands of complex social organization. I could have identified Brown as using an almost Christian approach. Parables and rituals used in. religious settings are replaced in her work by stories about herself, stories about clients that she had therapeutic conversations with and specific suggestions for guided introspection and improved communication. She has made useful concepts accessible by spelling them out in the language of her contemporaries and they are by her own account legitimately grounded in her experience.</p><p>Religious practice can at times allow us to drop our self interest at least for a moment. Then we see as Gautama (Buddha) did that we are just a grain of sand on the beach, a tiny part of a vast universe, limited in our capacity for understanding and action. Brazier (5) writes of the function of religion with love as an example. He says “the love that we actually encounter in this world is always in some degree and in some manner conditional, yet from our experience of such love we intuitively conceive of unconditional love.” Conditional love is what natural selection predicts. The intuition of the abstract and extreme unconditional love is how our minds work. We always use abstract idealizations in our thought processes, these abstractions include infinity, the ideal table and chair, the perfect sphere, the idea of a mountain, and unconditional love. These abstractions are metaphysical according to Brazier, and according to him “Religion is about how we relate to such metaphysical fundamentals.” Religious practices then help us “to understand [metaphysical ideas] and keep them in mind and, most importantly, revere them.”</p><p>Brazier points out that “science” itself is a metaphysical idea, that the measurements it deals with are abstractions, that the metaphysical is an inescapable aspect of human thought. For Brazier spiritual life is forming “values (motivations) in the metaphysical domain and implementing them in the physical empirical domain” thus bridging between two ungraspable extremes. He says that we cannot turn off abstraction as thought is impossible without it, so we all have a spiritual life although we don’t all practice a religion and we are not all aware of how we use direct empirical experience and abstraction. I am not so sure that motivation arises in the metaphysical domain, having been motivated to scratch by an itch I find my motives strongly linked to the physical/empirical. Although the itch free state is surely a metaphysical abstraction that we yearn for, individual itches and scratches are not abstract and I’m not sure we always stop to think or even to mentally flash briefly to the abstract “itch” before acting to eliminate it. For values and motivations to be synonyms values have to be as unconscious as motivation and that leaves us having to distinguish between conscious declared values and unconscious values that influence action without being consciously accounted for. In spite of my reservations I find Brazier’s perspective helpful because he addresses the question of what exactly spirituality is as distinct from religiosity, and defines it in a way that makes sense of the universality of religious and spiritual activity in human culture.</p><p>Religion, science and therapy are embedded in the social structure. We are a species with a very flexible social structure, but we always end up with leaders and in that sense we are unwaveringly hierarchical. We may have a monarch or dictator with almost unlimited power, or we may have different leaders for different group tasks, often we have both. We are adapted to fit into a hierarchical social structure by being very suggestible and having a tendency to comply with authority. We sometimes alter our memories (19) and our judgement of social or even physical reality to comply with those of others, giving them the power to affect what we learn from experience. This often helps us by helping the social structure to work smoothly. We see this in very diverse settings from not parking on highways to groups of hunters acting quickly and silently under the direction of the best hunter. Compliance and suggestibility give cohesion to our ever more highly populated and complex social structures, but they have a dark side.</p><p>Following the Second World War the effect of authority on behaviour was explored by Milgram and others who wanted to know how the Nazis were able to perpetrate genocide. They found that individuals often abdicate from making their own choices when following orders or when influenced by an authority figure or a group. If the authority figure or group are murdering, warmongering, cheating, or polluting and subordinates go along with them we can end up with large scale destruction of human life. In less extreme situations we may find ourselves violating our own values or simply doing things we never thought we would do because those things are expected of us.</p><p>Since religion, science and therapy are organized into institutions with their own power structures, power struggles, authority figures and self serving interpretations of reality they are used for individual aggrandizement and political ends as well as for genuine deepening of understanding and widening of altruistic tendencies. While utilizing their tools it is wise to be aware of our huge capacity for self deception and compliance with authority as well as everyone’s natural bias toward their own group.</p><p>We have a unique capacity to record and learn from multigenerational information, using what we have learned to deliberately modify the causality web of which we are a part using innovative ideas and technology. Knowledge is communal (16, 20), not just individual, there are far more facts and concepts than can fit in a single human mind. Just as zoo animals are less bored and depressed when they have to search for their food so people do better with problems to think about and new things to learn. We value finding the solution to problems even at the expense of shattering cherished illusions like free will or the perfection of heroes, saints and teachers.</p><p>We need a purpose beyond staying out of pain and solving puzzles, usually looking out for relatives and allies provides that, but at times we take on improvement in the human condition in general advocating for causes like eliminating poverty, opening education to more people, ending cruelty to animals and so on. There is no shortage of projects that people use to fulfill their need for purposeful problem solving. But circumstances control how we formulate those projects. Our current understanding, interest and values, exposure to propaganda, suppression of information by media, governments, publishers and other “gatekeepers”, clever advertising and education all influence what we do and do not learn and therefore what we do.</p><p>Many impressive accomplishments have resulted from human problem solving. Some of those may be counted as successes, some as failures, likely we would not completely agree on which are which. Innovations include controlled fire, democracy, capitalism, socialism, communism, empire building, women’s rights, slavery, reducing slavery, paid employment, agriculture and accompanying new religions, founding the UN, bombing Hiroshima, avoiding nuclear war for over sixty years, extreme inequality with regard to resource distribution and freedom, not even talking about the long term effects of medical intervention which include increasing the frequency of harmful genes that no one wishes to inherit, genetic engineering.</p><p>Our tendency to deny things that are inconvenient or unpleasant is one facet of human nature. The repression of selected ideas by institutions from family to nation is another. A lot has been written about denial from therapeutic and religious perspectives and science has contributed here (11.) If we want to understand ourselves more than we want to avoid difficult truths we will keep looking in the places we want to avoid.</p><p>Investigating things we want to deny is important. So is understanding faith, hope and charity which are as universal as denial and self interest. When we give attention, understanding or something material we reward ourselves in the moment of giving. This is one level of the loaves and fishes story of Christianity and the stone soup story as well, nourishment that does not run out because people enjoy giving and inspire each other to give. Genetic variation and brain damage prevent this from being absolutely universal among humans. Kiehl makes it clear that this does not apply to psychopaths for example (15). But in general the tendencies to cooperation, trust, and trustworthiness are part of being human.</p><p>Conditional love and reciprocal altruism is what we expect given natural selection in a gregarious species. Hope ensures that we make an effort to survive. Generosity that is self rewarding helps individuals function in groups. Faith boils down to trust, which saves us from the dysfunctional craziness of paranoia. The almost universal human tendency to faith, hope and charity is not beyond science to explain although it might be better nurtured by religious or spiritual practices. I chose Buddhism as my spiritual practice because it embraces sceptical inquiry and does not require specific beliefs.</p><p>Tension between altruism and self interest appears to be bred into us. There are a variety of strategies for keeping that inner conflict to a minimum. Remaining in a small racially segregated group where we are fairly closely related to all group members is one such strategy. Extending our altruism to the broader family of humanity and beyond recognizing with some forms of spirituality/religiosity that all beings and all things are related is another. For poetic treatment of how frustrating our failure at this is read Sherman Alexie (1.) Usually we opt for an intermediate solution: favouring family and allies but cooperating in a reciprocal give and take with others as long as we do not feel a need to take their territory or they ours.</p><p>At the present time people in the fields of religion, science and therapy are engaged in mutual assessment, criticism and crossing boundaries to learn from each other. Ecumenical activity is widespread and religious practice is being reformulated in a secular context (2.) There are Buddhist teachers who are psychotherapists (5), neurobiologists that study the brain states of meditators, publications on the scientific study of morality and religion (23, 24, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion.) In the west the implications of new information is publicly explored (6.) There are many religious practitioners who see their calling as quite compatible with both science and therapeutic approaches since their goal is to help people live in harmony with themselves and each other in a realistic and honest way, appreciating both individuals and their place in the universe.</p><p>The current breakdown of interdisciplinary boundaries between science, therapy and religion seems to me similar to what happens individually when we stop thinking in a compartmentalized way. New connections are being made all the time. Human knowledge is opening up. It is possible to find religious leaders, therapists and scientists who acknowledge the illusory nature of free will and who balance between fatalism and arrogance.</p><p>4)	The Razors Edge: Fatalism, Helplessness and Arrogance</p><p>Seeing that our reality is deterministic can undermine motivation if we think. “what will be will be so why make an effort?” This is the problem of fatalism. It is not trivial as motivation is not under direct conscious control. For us to stay motivated both conscious and unconscious mind (which are part of a whole mind and not without an intervening grey area) must be convinced of the value of effort.</p><p>The problem of fatalism has been raised by various western authors. In 2008 Vohs and Schooler (22) published an article entitled. “The value of believing in Free Will” showing that having subjects read material emphasizing determinism led to an increase in cheating compared to subjects reading neutral material. This result has been attributed to determinism reducing the effort that goes into self control. The same year Harrison (13) claimed in The Central Liberal Truth that in progress prone societies people are convinced of the power of their individualistic direction setting and blame themselves for their mistakes while in progress resistant societies people are more fatalistic. Four years later Hood (14) published The Self Illusion where he asserted that that belief in free will “predicts not only better job performance but also expected career success.” He suggested jokingly that we ignore the absence of intellectually defensible free will and believe in it anyway. That is ridiculous for several reasons:</p><p>1)	Once convinced of the absence of free will we can’t ignore our own conviction. Things we push into the subconscious affect our subconscious motivation and creep up on us.</p><p>2)	It is arrogant to think we can establish a chosen motive or belief outside the causality web.</p><p>3)	It is arrogant to think we understand consequences well enough to be in control of the causality web in the long term. Immediate benefits of progress are undeniable and include vaccination, antibiotics, machinery for heavy physical work, sanitation, longer average lifespans and freedom of movement. These benefits have come at a price which includes human induced climate change which will flood much farmland and wipe out low lying terrestrial hunting grounds, deaths related to pollution, poverty and overwork, the disruption of families by the ongoing forced removal of peasants and indigenous people from their land and by the demands of education and employment, industrial scale genocide and nuclear weapons. Progress has helped some and hurt some. Repressing our knowledge of determinism to promote progress will likely produce more of the same.</p><p>4)	It is impossible to hide causality and its implications. There will always be those who see it for themselves.</p><p>We can’t ignore fatalism. Experiments in learned helplessness. show that if we feel totally powerless we are so depressed we lack the motivation to do anything. Even the most obvious beneficial actions are impossible for very depressed individuals so demonstrating the efficacy of chosen actions is vital for human wellbeing. Yet we can only do what we are motivated to do and chosen actions often have unintended effects. Depressing though that reality is we face it or remain deluded.</p><p>Fatalism and arrogance are almost opposites: fatalism is due to feeling powerless in the grip of the causality web and arrogance is supported by the assumption that our will or motivation is independent of the causality web (which is what absolute free will would be.) A full appreciation of how we fit in the causality web includes recognizing the playing out of causality and the efficacy of learning and choosing. Such understanding may allow us to walk the razors edge between the arrogance of believing we are in control and depression resulting from learned helplessness.</p><p>Ancient stories of the playing out of fate exemplified by the Greek myth of Oedipus include a profound insight: it is our struggle to take control of our lives that brings our “fate” about. The societies that gave us Oedipus do not seem to me to be very “progress resistant”, they produced many ideas and social structures that still impress us. I’m not sure what Siddhartha Gautama (often called the Buddha) thought of free will, but the surviving teachings list long chains of cause and effect, and some buddhists are convinced of the absence of free will (17.) Although buddhists emphasize being free to be oneself, amongst other things accepting inner thoughts and conflicts for what they are, trainee monks and laypeople accept the discipline of sitting quietly with their own thoughts for long periods of time which requires a lot of self control. Science, from ecology to particle physics relies on experiments that can be replicated with predictable results. This only works if particular causes create particular effects in predictable ways so that our reality once in motion must follow natural physical and chemical laws, a view known as determinism which in my opinion is essentially the same as predestination.</p><p>Determinism says things are contingent on physical reality unfolding through time following definite and at least theoretically knowable laws. Predestination as used in theology refers to things predestined by God. If there is a God (or multidimensional aliens) who predestined certain outcomes for our causality web then those outcomes must be built into the physical laws that are demonstrably operating. This leaves little or no practical difference between predestination and determinism. Yet successful scientists who work within demonstrable physical reality and accept inviolable physical laws, and those who investigate predictable patterns of human behaviour, are some of the hardest working and at least in their role as scientists some of the most honest people in the world.</p><p>Looking at the ancient Greeks, Buddhists who see interconnectedness in a way that precludes individual free will, and at successful scientists who do not find it necessary or useful to believe in free will, we see people who accept the full implications of causality but are not suffering from depression or lack of self control. There is a way, maybe more than one way, to walk the razors edge.</p><p>I wanted to include Calvinism in the above sentence because Calvin integrated predestination into Christianity in a way that had Christians working very hard for predestined salvation. But to align with the bible Calvin reconciled free will with predestination by saying that we necessarily yet wilfully choose to sin. What this philosophical backflip ignores is that if our choice to sin is necessary enough that we all do it, then sin is not a free choice, it is built into who we are.</p><p>Sometimes people imagine that they are guardians of public morals and refrain from spreading the idea that we are not free agents. Darwin concluded in his private notes that human self interest (which aligns rather well with original sin) was an evolved characteristic, not something we can hold people responsible for. He was so worried about the effect of this information on public morality that he hesitated to publish until his own self self interest was threatened by Wallace having arrived at the idea of natural selection independently. (Robert Wright quotes Darwin’s unpublished notes on this issue.)</p><p>The philosopher Dennett (9) grudgingly admitted that there is a sense in which we could not have done other than we did (free will does not apply) and stated that learning and choosing are “all the free will worth wanting.” This looks like an effort to avoid falling into the trap of fatalism. By dodging the fatalism trap Dennett created an implied definition of free will as learning and choosing in a predetermined way, which is hardly free. He failed to address the issue head on.</p><p>Facing it head on we see that learning, choosing and illusory freedom are all we have, if we can’t value that we end up depressed. When we learn and choose more effectively then we feel freer. When we recognize the impossibility of perfection and settle down to do the best we can that is another kind of subjective, illusory, but valuable freedom. If we mistakenly believe that we are responsible for who we are then we place ourselves on a roller coaster of self praise and self blame which can make us truly miserable. Understanding that our will is not free does not stop us from refining our learning and choosing process and increasing our feelings of freedom. Not banging my head on the wall of causality feels pretty good.</p><p>5) Clinging and Not Clinging to the idea of Free Will</p><p>I said that what we experience as free will is limited to the compulsory act of making inevitable choices. One common response is that “there is a point where you have to take responsibility for your actions”. These responders assume that seeing the illusory nature of free will provides an excuse for me to do what I want to do instead of what I should do. I always do what I want to do. There may be conflicting desires internally but I can’t help making the choice that I am most motivated to make, and neither can you. When we are getting along it is often because what I want to do corresponds with what you think I should do, and vice versa.</p><p>There are two powerful forces that motivate the “take responsibility” crowd to insist on the idea that I am morally responsible for my actions in the sense implied by a belief in free will. Both forces can be found in both secular and religious contexts. Neither of the following forces prevents the causality web from existing and developing deterministically as causes bring about effects.</p><p>1) The experience of efficacious choice is so powerful that the idea of illusory free will is counter intuitive. It is difficult to appreciate that it is the will that is not free and that efficacious choice is not the same as free choice. Western progress prone societies reinforce the idea that we have free will so it is quite difficult for us to appreciate on an emotional level that we are caught in a web not of our own making.</p><p>2) We seem to have evolved a sort of “vengeance instinct” that demands “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” in order to deter exploitation. A strong desire to get back at those who injure or insult us arises naturally and we justify it by denying the power of circumstance over those who insult or injure us. This denial leads to fear that theft, deception and violence will become common and acceptable if free will is widely recognized as an illusion and we can use the “my brain (or the causality web) made me do it” excuse.</p><p>Step back from this and it is laughable. We already confront and perpetrate theft, violence, and deception including self deception and accompanying hypocrisy on a daily basis. We can see it all around us even if we have been unable to see it in ourselves. The colonization of North America with military and police responses to indigenous objections, with breaking of treaties by colonizers and collusion of churches in cultural genocide is a now familiar example in Canada. At the same time that Canada attempts to intervene in genocide elsewhere in the world our governing bodies continue to force indigenous organizations to spend thousands of dollars defending treaty rights and human rights. The collective behaviours that allowed colonization and which continue to be problematic involve many individual deceptive, thieving and violent choices in spite of a professed belief in God given free will and a supposedly God given moral code. It is easy for me to see this until I remember that I have lived on stolen land that I worked and paid for, and then I become defensive.</p><p>Theft, deception and violence are often held to be acceptable, even laudable. We see this in the ancient Jews following the commands of a trickster God to defeat their enemies, in Israeli oppression of Palestinians, in suicide bombers, in Homer making a hero of Odysseus, and in Canadian history books which applaud John A McDonald who promoted cultural genocide, and which applaud colonization in general because to do otherwise would undermine national self image.</p><p>We can all come up with examples where most people today would say theft, deception and violence are laudable, including hiding Jews from nazis, protecting children from bullies, and Robin Hood behaviour. I have to applaud my late brother in law who stole meat for his children. Although that last item might not sit well with everyone it is obviously important that we retain the capacity for theft, deception and violence in extreme situations, mostly so we can protect ourselves from the theft deception and violence of other people. Unilateral disarmament is not always a practical option for people who want to survive.</p><p>Demanding that we “take responsibility” won’t change theft, deception and violence. It is only changes in motivation that affect behaviour. By giving everyone a stake in the smooth functioning of society we might align human motivation more closely with what our society considers to be right. Perhaps we will get closer to that by learning from experience and making more effective choices.</p><p>We often cling to the idea of free will in the hope that we can avoid pain and disaster. I suggest a different approach. Recognize and abandon the hubris involved in clinging to the idea of free will. A humble recognition that whatever morality we have is the result of the causality web and not a result of personal merit is a realistic place to begin. Then we need to value the ongoing and partly conscious feedback loop in which we choose, learn from consequences, choose in the next situation and learn more, which is how we actively participate in unfolding the causality web over time. This process does not give us free will, but it does increase our feelings of freedom and control.</p><p>The leaving of ultimate responsibility to forces larger than individuals or human societies is supported by science but is also a form of ancient wisdom exemplified by Buddhist recognition of interconnectedness, Christian “there but for the grace of God go I”, and by the even older idea of fate.</p><p>6) Implications: Ending Judgemental Approaches to Social Order</p><p>As investigation into brain structure and function (10, 15) genetics, education, social science, biological and cultural evolution and related areas continues we understand more and more about what determines our motivation. The most important lesson may be that our behaviour is determined.</p><p>Recently discoveries in brain development and decision making have been popularized so free will as it pertains to education and justice is a hot topic (3.) Already western legal systems recognize insanity and neurological damage as removing moral responsibility. It is a small intellectual step from recognizing that abnormal brain structure and function destroy free will and remove moral responsibility to recognizing that normal brain structure and function determine the actions of normal people. There are those who oppose using abnormal brain structure as a legal defence because they see and fear this logical next step (Kiehl, 15.) If the legal system focussed on protection, restitution and rehabilitation rather than obsessing about culpability and free will there would be nothing to fear about taking biology in account.</p><p>From the perspective of biology I am no more to blame for being a sophisticated manipulative tool wielding monkey than a tiger is to blame for hunting its prey. The same applies to you. This view aligns well with the Christian injunction “judge not lest ye be judged”. We don’t have to believe in supernatural or divine judgement to see this play out. When we judge others we are at least unconsciously aware that our own failings are similar to theirs and we may in the long run doom ourselves to the hell of negative self judgement.</p><p>A nonjudgemental view of myself and others, based on accepting the compulsory and constrained nature of so called free will is liberating. There is no basis for blame. It is also disappointing as no matter how hard I work there is no reward that I can truly deserve. There are people I would like to emulate, none that I hero worship. Admiration and contempt are equally inappropriate if there is no free will. Of course I will still experience contempt and admiration. I may still use them to manipulate others. But a deep belief in justified contempt and admiration cannot survive appreciation of the illusory nature of free will.</p><p>No matter how badly a person wronged me or I them, they were doing what they had to do and so was I. With this view I no longer need to give and receive forgiveness as there is nothing to forgive. Since blame and anger arise automatically in my mind when I am hurt, and since feeling a need for forgiveness seems to be automatic as well it might be more realistic to recognize that that blame and anger arise in my mind and to get in the habit of automatically forgiving while dealing with whatever harm caused the blame and anger to arise. Either way, blame and desire for vengeance both fall away.</p><p>Realizing that pain inflicted on us is always an accident of circumstance even when it is deliberate relieves the anguish of angry reaction when we are hurt. If you believe in a creator god then you may accept that each particular pain is an act of divine providence (built into creation) with pretty much the same result. If we could remain aware of the causality web even when hurt we would never suffer angry reaction. Few of us will reach the level of Christ on the cross with his ‘they know not what they do,” or the level of a bodhisattva diving joyfully into the hell realms to rescue other beings. If we are lucky we have enough experience of cutting through self deception and arriving at an appreciation of our own motives and the needs of others to keep us going towards non judgement.</p><p>I was socialized by praise and blame, by the enjoyment of admiration and by the pain of contempt, by aspiring to emulate heroes and distancing myself from villains. These things guided me so that I could live with others. What works better is understanding human motives, mine and other people’s. As a westerner the language I grew up with works against me in this, tending towards value judgements that cut off understanding.</p><p>Although I obviously do not believe in anything close to absolute free will, maintaining a non judgemental attitude requires work on my part and I can’t do it all the time. The habit of judgement, which I may have been born with (4), is too strong for that. Sometimes I find myself labelling myself or others as good or bad, rather than seeing actions that are understandable. When I am nonjudgemental I see what is going on with myself better as self deception and repression are not needed to end negative self regard. To a lesser extent being non judgmental helps me see what is going on with others. I am more focussed on understanding when allocation of praise and blame is not an issue. A nonjudgemental attitude helps me learn.</p><p>If we always valued learning over judgement and vengeance there would be changes to our legal system (3.) For example, in a recent case of drunk driving where the driver was caught before they caused an accident the penalty was a temporarily suspended driving licence. In a different case in my area there was an accident where the drunk survived and others were killed. This driver received a severe jail sentence. The crime, risking someone. else’s life, was the same in each case. The second driver was punished more severely because he was unlucky, not because he did anything worse. If you think the punishment of the two drivers should be different you are still thinking in terms of vengeance balancing things which is impossible as the dead individuals cannot be returned to life. People who drive drunk often do so because they don’t think they are going to cause an accident. If we are going to remove dangerous offenders from the drivers seat then both drivers, including the lucky one who avoided an accident and is probably now overconfident about driving drunk, should loose their licences until they have learned not to drive drunk. If we are going to impose a jail sentence as a deterrent to drunk driving then both drivers should go to jail.</p><p>Dropping the idea of free will and not looking for vengeance does not mean dropping the idea of social control. When we are harmed by theft, deception and/or violence, even if we have lost the habit of blame we desire the restoration of what has been lost, and we want protection from future harm. Some features of our justice system may not change very much with or without the illusion of free will, but restorative justice and rehabilitation make more sense than retribution once we realize that free will is a misnomer. We don’t even have to believe in the total absence of free will to arrive at that conclusion, just recognizing the magnitude of genetic and environmental influences shrinks free will, should it exist, to minuscule size.</p><p>Human social control is inevitable because many human beings desire and work towards a society where trust and cooperation can be established, and because hierarchy in some form is always established. In a society where the majority trade favours honestly there is mutual trust. But in such a society a cheater does very well, so cheating spreads, either by biological natural selection or by cultural evolution. Cheating occurs within most social species including ours.</p><p>There are fish and squid species in which some males look and behave like females and are not chased off by stronger typical males. Males that mimic females enjoy reproductive success without having to be big and strong. If there are too many cheaters they have to compete with each other and the advantage disappears so natural selection maintains a small population of cheaters. In this case it is obvious that the cheaters are not “bad fish” they are just a different kind of fish.</p><p>Almost certainly genetics and experience are both factors in human cheating. Whatever the range of causes we all lie and cheat if circumstances motivate us enough, and none of us do if we are certain of being thwarted by getting caught. Starving people are more likely to steal. Those who will be punished for telling the truth, like gays and lesbians and members of persecuted ethnic groups are more likely to lie. Children who are punished for displays of emotion and for talking about unacceptable thoughts may learn to actively repress and mask their own psychology. These children may not be capable of honest communication until they learn to, and are rewarded for, seeking truth in themselves. Probably we are all these children although the areas where repression was required of us vary. Assisting and rewarding conscious recognition of subconscious motivation seems to me to be an important function of religion and therapeutic practice supported by science, although neither works consistently in this regard.</p><p>Repression of our own failings may not need to be taught. We may instinctively repress seeing how we fail to live the way we expect others to live. Then by believing we are as good as we think everyone should be, we easily project an image of a person with integrity, becoming hypocrites without realizing it. We all become more honest when honesty is rewarded, but cheating is part of our behavioural repertoire (21.)</p><p>Social control may be experienced in a completely different way by privileged and non-privileged members of a group. In nation states power, privilege and money are closely associated with the privileged receiving better protection from police, more lenient penalties for breaking the law, better education etc. Privilege comes in many forms (race, income, gender etc.) with the privileged forming cooperative groups separate from those of the disadvantaged. This may be openly and widely acknowledged by privileged and disadvantaged groups or, as here in Canada, it may be more covert. Either way those with the most privilege see them/ourselves as good, right and just. If they/we saw things any other way they/we would have to live with internal conflict or give up their/our privilege, and we all act in our own self interest even at the level of perception.</p><p>When we think of justice we generally think of getting what we deserve and deserving what we get. Given the causality web this is impossible. We are born a certain way and are governed by physical laws and built in psychological mechanisms that determine our development. There is no justice in this sense.</p><p>If we accept that free will is an illusion we may not believe justice is obtainable and we may no longer have a strong desire for vengeance but we still need to protect ourselves. We may still support the idea of deterring criminal acts by imposing penalties. But when we recognize that we are protecting ourselves, not administering just deserts, then there is no place for self righteous attitudes.</p><p>Some people say there are absolutely right and absolutely wrong ways of behaving. Establishing what is absolutely right and what is absolutely wrong is not possible. Most societies favour moral codes that support reproductive success and expand territory so the society is maintained or expanded. Those that don’t, don’t last long. The only example I know of is the Shakers, who no longer exist. So right and wrong are ultimately self serving concepts belonging to a community, as such they do not serve all individuals well. Slavery, extreme concentrations of wealth, torture, execution, human sacrifice, offering some people a choice between health destroying employment and extreme poverty are all examples of right behaviour somewhere, sometime, in human populations.</p><p>A practical approach to a harmonious society is found in the form of “the golden rule” which is “what you would not wish for yourself do not do to others” or “do as you would be done by.” We are very aware of how we absolutely would and absolutely would not like to be treated in our social group. Since other people seem to have the same preferences, and we tend to treat others the way we are treated, the golden rule provides a workable method for providing social order if only we all followed it, and followed it beyond our own group.</p><p>Kindness to strangers and non-judgement are taught in the Abrahamic and Buddhistic religious traditions, and increasingly they are taught in a secular context. Teaching the value of altruism beyond our own small group is necessary precisely because what comes naturally is kindness towards our own group tempered by self interest. Repeated xenophobic and genocidal behaviour of individuals and groups shows just how difficult it is to widen altruism as far as the entire human family.</p><p>The call to treat others as we would wish to be treated without looking for an immediate reward crops up in religious and secular teachings world wide. The earliest written record that I could find reference to was from ancient Egypt about 2,000BCE (Wikipedia entry for the Golden Rule). Recently (about 2000) Harris suggested we make a science of human wellbeing with a view to maximizing it, which amounts to a scientific attempt to intelligently implement the golden rule using national and international levels of organization as well as individual decision making.</p><p>History tells us that in spite of people having formulated and taught the golden rule in a variety of cultural settings for at least 4,000 years the peaceful, helpful, egalitarian and crime free society it promises is nowhere to be found. We can find theft, deception and violence in any human society. People are too self interested and hypocritical, too interested in our own status, too suspicious of others, to follow the golden rule consistently, so far.</p><p>Unless human nature changes we will always have to deal with self interested individuals capable of deception attempting to live in community. Some religions address this tension by encouraging us to discover the joy that giving can bring. Giving creates happiness by helping us feel good about ourselves, by surrounding us with happy people, and by establishing a base for reciprocal altruism it gives us some future security as well. But giving does not always work this way. It is easy to give to people that will give us something back, even if it is just gratitude or status. It is harder to give to people who are really needy because they resent the implied debt or status loss. In our own circle we may give things that we want to share instead of what others need. Sometimes others need us to give the gift of honesty and we go the easy way and flatter them instead. Sometimes we think we are giving honesty when we are using honesty as a weapon. Status seeking is served by largesse and volunteer work especially if it is given publicly. Sometimes we give by receiving gracefully so that someone else can experience the joy of giving. Sometimes we just accept what we want as if we were doing the donor a favour. The power and scope of self deception in this area is breathtaking.</p><p>It is possible that understanding the long term consequences of narrowly and more widely directed altruism will change our motivation by directing our self interested instincts toward planetary integrity. We already have international organizations that work, however imperfectly, at a more egalitarian distribution of the benefits of technological progress.</p><p>Making the subconscious conscious is a difficult individual journey. How much more difficult it is to do this at the national or international level with a population, leaders and organizations in many different states of self knowledge and self deception. Inadequate though truth and reconciliation processes are, the fact that this happens at all is encouraging. I am a product of the Roman invasion of Britain and the idea of the ancient Roman empire trying a truth and reconciliation process is so unlikely it strikes me as funny. Perhaps we have learned something since then, or perhaps recovery of colonized indigenous peoples has made a conciliatory attitude prudent.</p><p>Publicly acknowledging and legally accounting for the illusory nature of free will is bound to alter the way we deal with each other. As studies of determinants of human behaviour pile up we are poised to find out what shape that will take. If we don’t deny the causality web spread out before us human relationships will have a more realistic basis.</p><p>7) Uncertainty and The Future</p><p>The causality web concept rests on causality, which is impossible to prove although we all experience it every day. We have to assume that the future resembles the past in order to have predictable causal relationships in the future. I am pretty sure that we live in a world with predictable causal relationships which preclude free will, but physicists say there are dimensions that are not physically accessible to us, some buddhists believe that there are other dimensions in which sentient beings exist, and such things are indeed beyond the reach of my mind. I don’t know if a fourth or eleventh, or 1000th dimensional being or beings might intervene in our reality. For all I know we have souls that hang out in another dimension. We might have been intentionally created, or not. When it comes down to it I cannot be certain about what is out there. If I was I would be an even worse student of reality than I am.</p><p>As a student of reality I have come to the conclusion that for practical purposes causality exists and free will is an illusion. I will hold that opinion unless it is convincingly refuted.</p><p>Our uninformed minds attempting to see where causality will take us next generate many possible futures. Usually the actual future differs from what we expected. We are curious about the future. We conduct experiments to help us predict it. We have plans and hopes. This is an integral part of the causality web.</p><p>We are using innovative technology to support larger and larger human populations as we are pushed by our most fundamental characteristics toward reproductive success. By improving our physical condition we have built ourselves a treadmill where we need new technology to counter the harmful effects of technology we depend on. This has had a strange effect on the concept and conditions of privacy.</p><p>In the small bands in our environment of evolution everyone knows everyone else and most of their business too. In this setting there is deception and secrecy, but nothing like our expectation of privacy or our liable laws. Technology is rapidly taking nation states back to this goldfish bowl existence. Small cameras and microphones are all but undetectable. Tiny undetected drones may fly over private areas. Personal data may be captured with consent or hacked. Massive amounts of information can be filtered and digested by artificial intelligence so mingling in a crowd is no guarantee of privacy. The actions of public servants especially police and military personnel is especially visible and may be recorded with or without their knowledge. Lack of privacy may make cheating more difficult, the accumulation and analysis of personal data makes self understanding through psychology easier and it can facilitate totalitarian government. It is unclear how this will play out.</p><p>Perhaps we will create a world that allows people and other beings to enjoy the fullness of life without permitting the destruction of others. The need for limits that stop destruction applies equally to psychopaths, wealthy self serving pillars of the community who deny others material wellbeing and status, and our own self serving tendencies. Accomplishing this would not be. justice (which does not exist), it would be an expression of human understanding.</p><p>Sweeping unpleasant or unwelcome facts about our lack of unconditional love, our lack of free will, our competitive, territorial, insecure and racist tendencies under the rug is not compassion, it is denial. If we cut through denial we may make increasingly well informed choices supporting the wellspring of faith, hope and charity written into the DNA of most humans.</p><p>In future humans may be using technology to learn faster to counter unwanted effects of technology. We may be drastically reducing the human population to reduce environmental impact and vulnerability to epidemics. We may enjoy a more egalitarian distribution of resources or experience a widening gap between rich and poor. We may use genetic repair to maintain a healthy population without the horrors of eugenics. We may allow environmental disaster to collapse our technology treadmill while we are busy fighting over resources and status, in that case we will collectively experience increased natural selection events as the apparently mindless and compassionless forces that have always shaped us increase: famine, war, pollution, pestilence, flood and drought.</p><p>Because of what we are what has already been set in motion will continue with our active participation as long as we exist. We do not know where unfree will is taking us. Time will tell.</p><p>8) Annotated bibliography</p><p>Most of the ideas and information laid out above are located in many sources and I am not going to try and nail down the earliest origin of each. Instead I provide this idiosyncratic annotated bibliography to aid investigation of free will and associated issues.</p><p>1 Alexie</p><p>Sherman Alexie is a poet, novelist and film producer who expresses the need for expanding altruism beyond family. He expresses this poetically in all his work. His new poem, Hymn, which I found on facebook addresses it quite explicitly.</p><p>2 Batchelor</p><p>In After Buddhism (2015) Batchelor argues that Buddhism was originally about not living in a reactive way. This is a long and detailed read, worth the effort if you have an interest in examining the nature, extent and limitations of human freedom. Batchelor describes Buddhism as sliding from from pragmatic introspective psychology into a more traditionally religious framework. Batchelor has blazed a trail into secular Buddhism with his books.</p><p>3 Benforado</p><p>In Unfair: the new science of criminal injustice (Reprint 2015) Adam Benforado explores the American justice system in light of new neuroscience.</p><p>4 Bloom</p><p>In Just Babies (2014) Paul Bloom describes how babies attribute causality to the world around them, and how they seem to have the beginnings of a moral sense even before they can talk.</p><p>5 Brazier</p><p>David Brazier is a psychotherapist and Zen priest practicing Zen therapy. He is the author of many books on Buddhism including Buddhism is a religion: you can believe it (2014) and Not everything is impermanent (2013). He presents an antithesis to secular Buddhism. My spiritual hunger has been for a something that sounds like an oxymoron, but perhaps is not, a secular religion with more formal ritual, awe/reverence, and emphasis on individual and collective discovery/creation of meaning in life than science provides. Brazier is particularly helpful when acknowledging that he struggles with interpretation of his own experiences from both Buddhist religious and scientific perspectives, and when he explores what distinguishes religious from secular practices.</p><p>6 Brooks</p><p>In The Social Animal (2012) Brooks explores many areas of current research in psychology in the context of a particular couple’s development as individuals, as a couple, and in their roles at work and in society in general. It is an entertaining, sensitive and informative presentation although there are points where he makes unwarranted assumptions.</p><p>7 Botton</p><p>Botton’s non fiction works How Proust can change your life (1998) and Status Anxiety (2005) are delightfully literate, articulate and readable investigations of the human condition. He maintains there is free will, but he does not really question it. I wonder what would happen if he did.</p><p>8 Brown</p><p>Berne Brown has written a series of self help books including Rising Strong (2015) in these publications she shares the intimate details of her introspection, her therapeutic work, and the lessons she draws from those experiences.</p><p>9 Dennett</p><p>In Consciousness Explained (1992) philosopher Danial Dennett suggests that consciousness is experienced when we build mental models of our own mind and body. In Freedom Evolves (2004) he grudgingly admits that free will leaves us with only one possible action per choice, but he is interested in the processes of learning and choosing which is all the free will “worth having”. Dennett is an important philosopher in the creationism versus evolution and the theist versus atheist controversies and has an interest in artificial intelligence which is an important current issue so I am a bit sad that his books are difficult for the uninitiated.</p><p>10 Feldman Barrett</p><p>In How Emotions are Made: the secret life of the brain (2017) Lisa Feldman Barrett describes the use of fMRI to study how brain activity associated with emotion is distributed. She debunks the idea that emotion is generated by one or a few brain areas. According to her emotion arises as a pattern of brain activation distributed throughout the brain. The areas previously assigned as emotion centres may be critical for experiencing and/or acting on emotion, but they are not the whole story. She makes a good case for equating emotional and intellectual states with brain states. If this interests you you might also want to read Consciousness and the Brain: Deciphering how the Brain Codes Thoughts (Stanislas Dehaene 2014).</p><p>11 Gorman and Gorman</p><p>In Denying to the Grave (2016) Gorman and Gorman explore why we deny scientific evidence that could be life saving. It turns out that appeals to emotion are far more persuasive than logic. In my opinion that is why the contributions of religion and therapy to human self knowledge are so important.</p><p>12 Harris</p><p>A scientist with a conscience. In Free Will (2012) Harris investigates the issue of free will, which he says does not exist. In Lying (2013) he explores why it is in our best interest not to become habitual liars. In The Moral Landscape (2011) he talks about how science can develop our morality. He brings passion and intellect to his writing.</p><p>13 Harrison</p><p>In the The Central Liberal Truth (2008) Harrison states that progress prone societies emphasize free will while progress resistant societies are more fatalistic.</p><p>14 Hood</p><p>In The Self Illusion (2013) Hood explores the nature of self, touching on the problem of fatalism. In the last chapter he summarizes the self illusion, but here I have to disagree with an unsupported assertion. He says “Those who reject the notion of a self in control of destiny, lead sadder, less satisfying lives.” He does not explore the difference between embracing the illusion of self as reality and embracing the illusion of self as an illusion, and he does not fully explore the implications of what he says about illusory self. By addressing these things he would contribute to a deeper understanding of humanity by humanity.</p><p>15 Kiehl</p><p>In the Psychopath Whisperer (2014) Dr Kent Kiehl describes decades of neurological work with psychopaths.</p><p>16 Mercier</p><p>In The Enigma of Reason (2017) Mercier argues that reason evolved to facilitate transmission of knowledge, not to facilitate the endeavours of solitary geniuses. According to this interactionist. theory innovators can be understood best by seeing them in their social context.</p><p>17 Rasheta</p><p>As of January 2018 Noah Rasheta is executive director of the Foundation for Mindful Living and hosts the Secular Buddhism podcast.</p><p>18 Sapolsky</p><p>Behave: the biology of humans at our best and worst (2017) is what it sounds like, an overview of why we do what we do. He tackles free will and much, much more.</p><p>19 Shaw</p><p>In The Memory Illusion Dr. Julia Shaw explores how memories change over time and how they are influenced by others.</p><p>20 Sloman and Fernbach</p><p>The Knowledge Illusion (2017) provides a detailed look at the communal nature of knowledge.</p><p>21 Trivers</p><p>In the The Folly of Fools (2011) Robert Trivers explores human deception and lying from the perspective of evolutionary biology.</p><p>22 Vohs and Schooler</p><p>In 2008 Vohs and Schooler published an article in entitled. “The value of believing in free will”. An abstract and bibliography are available from Sage Journals on the world wide web.</p><p>23 De Waal</p><p>In The Age of Empathy (2010) Frans de Waal looks at the behaviour of our close relatives where we find some very human looking behaviours. I have not read The bonobo and the atheist: in search of humanism among the primates (2013) yet, but it looks promising.</p><p>24 Wright</p><p>In The Moral Animal (1995) Wright explores human morality from an evolutionary biology perspective. He over generalizes about feminist views but otherwise this is a pretty balanced approach. Wright does not try and define good and bad, but looks for benefit and harm resulting from traits produced by natural selection and various social structures. He describes the theory of evolution of social behaviour in detail including relations between the sexes and reciprocal altruism with its accompanying feelings. His application of Darwinism to Darwins life is particularly apt. In Non Zero (2001) he explores human history and our progress toward world government. His latest book, the best seller Why Buddhism is True (2017) is a short pithy discussion of the principles of secular Buddhism. In The Evolution of God (2010) he describes. how spirituality and religion change with changing social structures.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0971c1cbd7b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wrong Time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@judithjohnson_14390/wrong-time-543297c5591c?source=rss-397ed3597656------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/543297c5591c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Judith Johnson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jan 2018 20:48:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-30T21:00:56.842Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Wrong Time</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wnF-982MPIXpQGnBn5aYBA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Just for that I should love you he said as I managed to tolerate a social handicap rather similar to my own. No, that’s not enough of a reason, for once I was not arrogant, love will do that anytime.</p><p>Until the time came when I could not tolerate the combination of stubborn weaknesses that he clung to, weaknesses that heaped too much weight on my shoulders, weaknesses that I as a human shared without knowing. I did not give up loving him, that was not possible.</p><p>Living with frustration generating constant anger was not possible although I missed him in prolonged absentia the reality of his presence became shackles chafing flesh. The verb to love devolved to self absorbed adjective, a storm of feeling blazing lightening, rumbling thunder, creating nothing.</p><p>I married someone else. He has a permanent dating relationship with another. Love persists painfully pulling into the worn groove of past embracing. Wrong time for intimacy, love respects that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=543297c5591c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>