<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by kabogle on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by kabogle on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 21:14:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kabogle/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE GREAT REFORM AND HILDEGARD OF BINGEN]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-great-reform-and-hildegard-of-bingen-47f58b76262c?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/47f58b76262c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scivias]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anne-h-king-lensmeier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernard-mcginn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-great-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hildegard-of-bingen]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2026 17:34:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-26T17:34:57.297Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>And a reeking fog enveloped the whole mountain, which wrapped the head in such filth that the people who stood by were terrified.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KbeIz4oodT0Ca16l84vgQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Today we get to delve into Hildegard of Bingen a little bit. She was an amazing woman, and probably the first to really stand out since Apostolic times. Her music is wonderful and well worth your time. She was also very well known for her visions, and we’ll be looking at one today. Dreams and visions have been questioned in Christianity since the beginning; the major, and really only, requirement is that they must agree with the Bible, and this one certainly does.</p><p>Here’s what Bernard McGinn has to say about Hildegard in VISIONS OF THE END:</p><p><em>“The events of the Great Reform also played a role in the speculations of the visionary and prophetess Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179), one of the most remarkable religious leaders of the time. Hildegard’s striking visions mark her as one of the most original apocalyptic thinkers since the intertestamental period. Her writings display a wide variety of themes both cosmological and historical. The central production, the SCIVIAS completed in 1151, shows this Benedictine abbess as conservative and monastic in outlook, and primarily moralizing in intent. Hildegard was not particularly papalist; indeed, she predicted that both the universal powers of Christendom, the empire and the papacy, would fail as the age of crisis unfolded. According to her thought, this time of trouble…began at the end of the eleventh century with the attacks of Henry IV upon the Church. Although the German abbess tends to be less concerned with the details of the great controversy than some of her contemporaries, it is obvious that her view of history can only be understood within the context of the Great Reform movement.”</em></p><p>I find his conclusions about Hildegard to be somewhat dismissive, particularly because she was not that <em>“concerned”</em> about the <em>“great controversy.”</em> For myself, I find that refreshing about her. Her focus was on the next world rather than the foibles of this one. And her writing is fully understandable without knowing a thing about the <em>“Great Reform.”</em></p><p>I am very unhappy with Mr. McGinn’s translation of a portion of Hilegard’s SCIVIAS, a book describing 26 of her visions. His translation was less than lyrical, but much worse was his attempt to use modern anatomical terms in the descriptions of the youth and the woman. I found a better translation in the book HILDEGARD OF BINGEN: AN INTEGRATED VISION by Anne H. King-Lenzmeier, though she doesn’t go as far into it as Mr. McGinn, so we will be picking up his translation at the end.</p><p><em>“Then I looked to the North, and behold! five beasts stood there. One was like a dog, fiery but not burning; another like a yellow lion; another was like a pale horse; another like a black pig; and the last like a grey wolf, and they were facing the west. In the West, before them, a hill with five peaks appeared; so from the mouth of each beast one rope stretched to one of the peaks of the hill and the ropes were black, except for the one from the mouth of the wolf which was partly black and partly white.”</em></p><p>According to King-Lenzmeier, the allegorical meanings of the animals are representative of types of people, as follows:</p><p>The dog — <em>“people of a ‘biting temperament’”</em></p><p>The lion — <em>“warlike persons”</em></p><p>The pale horse — <em>“those who sink themselves in sin”</em></p><p>The pig — <em>“impure”</em> persons</p><p>The wolf — <em>“robbers and cunning deceivers”</em></p><p>King-Lenzmeier goes on to say: <em>“They are there to show dissension in the final days of the world. They face the West because they will vanish as the sun sets.”</em></p><p>Back to Hildegard:</p><p><em>“And behold! in the East I saw again that youth, whom I had first seen on the corner of the wall of the building where the shining and stone parts come together, wearing a tunic of purple. I now saw him on the same corner, but now I could see him from the waist down. And from the waist down to the place where a man is discerned he shone like the dawn and there was a lyre in his lap lying with its strings across his body; and from there to the width of two fingers above his heel he was in shadow, but from there down to his feet he was whiter than milk.”</em></p><p>King-Lenzmeier identifies the youth as Christ <em>“appearing in the last days of the old times.” </em>She identifies the building as <em>“being under construction until now and is nearing completion.”</em></p><p>Hildegard continues:</p><p><em>“And I saw again the figure of the woman whom I had previously seen in front of the altar, which stands before the eyes of God; she stood in the same place, but now I saw her from the waist down. And from her waist to the place where a woman is discerned, she had various scaly blemishes; and in that latter place was a black and monstrous head. It had fiery eyes, and ears like to an ass, nostrils and mouth like a lion’s; it opened wide its jowls and terribly clashed its horrible iron-colored teeth.</em></p><p><em>“And from this head down to her knees, the figure was white and red as if bruised by beatings repeatedly. From her knees to her tendons where they joined her heels, which seemed white, she was covered in blood. And lo! That monstrous head moved from its place with such a great shock that the figure of the woman was shaken through all her limbs. And a great mass of excrement adhered to the head; and it raised itself up upon a mountain, trying to climb the heights of Heaven. And behold, there came a thunderbolt striking this head with such force that it fell from the mountain and sent its spirit into death. And a reeking fog enveloped the whole mountain, which wrapped the head in such filth that the people who stood by were terrified. And that fog remained around the mountain for a while longer. The people who stood there, seeing this, where shaken with great fright and said to one another: ‘Alas! Alas! what is this? what do you think that was? wretches that we are, who will help us and deliver us? unfortunate as we are? For we do not know how we were deceived. O Almighty God, have mercy on us! Let us return, turn back; let us hasten to the Gospel of Christ. For ah, ah, ah, we have been bitterly deceived!’ and lo, the the feet of the the figure of the woman glowed white, shining with a splendor greater than the sun’s.”</em></p><p>King-Lenzmeier identifies the woman as the Church because <em>“she appears </em>[in Hildegard’s woodcut illustration]<em> as is customary above the waist entirely in gold and crowned as usual.”</em> But she also identifies the woman as <em>“the most gruesome part of the whole picture…scarred and bleeding, with the head of the Antichrist where the genitals would be…the placement seems to have multiple meanings: the figure of Christ has harmony where the genitals should be (the lyre); when he joins his true spouse the monstrous aberration will leave her, torn away by the power of God embracing the bride…” </em>To me, this says that the parts of the Church that are not following the Gospel will not be part of the Rapture; and that the Rapture is the <em>“embracing”</em> of the bride.</p><p>King-Lenzmeier continues: “<em>The placement here could also mean that the human failings of those inside the Church help to give birth to the Antichrist, leaving the true Church maimed, beaten, and bleeding…”</em></p><p>This is frightening, but also makes sense. The Church feels <em>“maimed, beaten, and bleeding”</em> right now.</p><p>King-Lenzmeier goes on: “<em>The commentary stands as a warning also to Christians to beware the Day of Judgment because one does not know when it will come. Like the people in the vision, many will cry out about how they have been deceived, fooled until the end.” </em>This goes directly against Adso’s idea that people will have time to repent after having gone along with the Antichrist. Of course, Revelation itself says that those who take the mark of the beast are lost, but it’s interesting to see it repeated in Hildegard’s vision.</p><p>Back to King-Lenzmeier: <em>“Hildegard also warns about the mother of the Antichrist as steeped in sin and who will teach the Antichrist the false ways of magic and power.”</em> In the last 200 years or so, the idea of teaching <em>“magic and power”</em> would have seemed a bit foreign and unlikely for someone in western culture. But the current world has brought back much of the <em>“magic and power”</em> from the days of old, so that, in my opinion, it is not so unlikely anymore.</p><p>Returning to Hildegard:</p><p><em>“And again I heard a voice from Heaven speak to me:” </em>[the continuation is now from VISIONS OF THE END] “<em>’Even though all things on earth are tending toward their end, so that the world with all its powers now weakened and oppressed by many hardships and calamities is bowed down to its End, nevertheless, the Spouse of my Son, though much weakened in her children, will never be destroyed either by the heralds of the Son of Perdition or by the Destroyer himself, however much she will be attacked by them. At the End of time she will arise more powerful and more secure; she will appear more beautiful and shining so that she may go forth in this way more sweetly and more agreeably to the embrace of her Beloved. The vision which you saw signifies all this in mystic fashion’”</em></p><p>This last bit is pretty interesting. I have been noticing that Christians have been sorting themselves out quite a bit. There are those who are totally devoted to Christ, who may or may not be attending services (depending on the sincerity of the services available), but are finding others of the same devotion with which to study and have fellowship. There are those who still attend church, and maybe even attend bible studies, but rarely think of Christ beyond those times. And, there are those who were relieved to have the churches closed during the ‘pandemic’, and have moved on. The “embrace” is coming, one has to wonder who will be receiving it…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=47f58b76262c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE GREAT REFORM AND GERHOH OF REICHERSBERG]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-great-reform-and-gerhoh-of-reichersberg-6ddb6efde7ae?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ddb6efde7ae</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[antichrist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[frederick-i]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regnum-vs-sacerdotium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-great-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gerhoh-of-reichersberg]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2026 18:48:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-17T18:48:19.247Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>THE GREAT REFORM AND GERHOH OF REICHERSBERG</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cqEtFQQbYp8FDMrLHfLqnQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We’re continuing with Germany during the Great Reform.</p><p>Emperor<strong> </strong>Frederick Barbarossa had his own run-in with papal authority, but it came after the death of Otto of Freising. Being his uncle, Otto had been a biographer for Frederick I in the early part of his reign: Frederick was crowned Emperor in 1152, and Otto died in 1158 at the age of 48.</p><p>In terms of apocalyptic thought, the mantle moves to Gerhoh of Reichersberg. Gerhoh was one of the leading theologians of his time, but was not well loved. It seems he was anti-imperial, and was certainly banned from the court of Frederick I. But he was also in favor of reform based on Gregory VII’s ideas, which fell out of favor as time went on, making him persona non grata with the popes following Eugene III. He was even accused of heresy at one point. [Info from Wikipedia and Oxford Reference.]</p><p>Here’s what Bernard McGinn has to say about him in VISIONS OF THE END:</p><p>“<em>The writer for whom the struggle between the </em><strong><em>regnum</em></strong> [the royal element]<em> and </em><strong><em>sacerdotium</em></strong><em> </em>[the priestly element] <em>played the most important role as a key to the course of history was the bellicose Bavarian canon, Gerhoh of Reichersberg (1093–1169). Unlike…Otto, whose writings he knew, Gerhoh survived to witness the second major clash between the papacy and the empire, the long schism of 1159–1177 between Frederick Barbarossa and </em>[Pope]<em> Alexander III. The reformer’s reflections upon these events strengthened his deep sense of opposition to the empire and convinced him that the career of the Antichrist named Henry IV had begun the final catastrophic age of history. Gerhoh’s first major apocalyptic work written during the schism was entitled ON THE INVESTIGATION OF THE ANTICHRIST. The treatise is notable for its highly spiritualistic view of the Antichrist as the collectivity of all who have opposed the Church since the time of Cain. R. Manselli has suggested that by his break with the fantastic and legendary accounts of the Final Enemy, Gerhoh opened up the way for a more immediate application of antichrist language to current events.”</em></p><p>I find it hard to think of the idea that Cain and other people of the Old Testament were opposing “the Church” as anything except <em>“fantastic and legendary.”</em> More than that, second century Church Fathers had no trouble applying antichrist language to their current events, and, as we shall see, Gerhoh seems to have agreed with them.</p><p>Here’s the first excerpt from THE INVESTIGATION OF THE ANTICHRIST:</p><p><em>Many of the faithful and prudent believed that what was thus prophesied in the Revelation of John was fulfilled or began to be fulfilled from that time. ‘When the thousand years have been completed, Satan will be loosed from his prison and will go forth and lead astray many nations that are at the four corners of the world, Gog and Magog’ (Rev. 20:7).”</em></p><p>Gerhoh seems to be promoting the idea that one of the Roman Emperors was, indeed, the antichrist; and that the first millennium after Christ was The Millennium. Perhaps he also saw The Church as Christ’s regent ruling on earth. And Satan was safely locked away for 1000 years, only to be let out at 1000 A.D. These two ideas don’t make a lot of sense together: the Antichrist appears in Roman times, but Satan is locked up while Antichrist is appearing. Let’s follow this further:</p><p><em>“Until that time, as we have said before, the same Satan had been bound through the Angel of Great Counsel in the abyss of the hearts of the very evil and by the huge chain of his deep malice.”</em></p><p>So, it wasn’t <em>really</em> a chain and an abyss. Satan was bound by his own <em>“deep malice”</em>, in the hearts of the <em>“very evil.”</em> Does that mean he could still affect the people of the earth? Was it a long chain, as J. Vernon McGee reports that his post-millennial professor said it was?</p><p><em>“He was enclosed and ‘sealed over for a thousand years so that he might not seduce the nations any more until the thousand years be finished.’ “</em></p><p>The answer to the question about affecting the earth seems to be ‘no,’ though I’m not clear why. Being <em>“sealed”</em> in mortals, no matter how evil, doesn’t seem very secure.</p><p><em>“For ‘after this,’ as the same passage says, ‘it is necessary that he be released for a brief time’ (Rev. 20:1–3). At that very time at which the devil was freed as it were through King Henry (of whom we have spoke and will speak again), a thousand years had already passed from the Passion, when the devil was put in prison and sealed over. The devil, when truly free, began to rule as a tyrant. From that time began the split in the papacy and the conflict between sacerdotium and regnum which surely contributed to the loosing of Satan.”</em></p><p>The convolution moves into high gear. First of all, a good question from Revelation is: why does Satan need to be released? If a prophesy has been fulfilled, then we should have a realization and understanding of what was said about it: so he should be able to tell us why that was necessary; yet he doesn’t.</p><p>The second question is: how did King Henry free Satan <em>“as it were”</em>? There is an implication here that Henry was the Antichrist, yet that can’t be right because he’s already implied that one of the Roman Emperors was the Antichrist. Unless, the Roman emperor was only the beginning of fulfillment, followed by more fulfillment with Henry (and all the other people labeled ‘antichrist’ by the Church between the Roman emperor and King Henry, while Satan was bound). In modern times we speak of antichrist as an archetype. We label men who were/are responsible for the deaths of many people, like Napoleon and Hitler, as a ‘type’ of antichrist, reserving the title Antichrist for the final emperor. But I’m not sure that King Henry actually meets even the definition of ‘type’ of antichrist. He was against the Church due to the Church’s usurpation of power; he instigated some fighting, but it doesn’t sound like a lot of people were killed: mostly the Church’s men withdrew and/or surrendered before King Henry’s men. It certainly looks like the Church, in her worldly power, was deciding who would be excommunicated and who would be labeled ‘antichrist’ based on who she disagreed with and who stepped on her toes.</p><p><em>“For as long as the priesthood remained strong, shining and burning through unity and devotion to religion, and as long as kingship with the cooperation of the priesthood was strong in good fear of evil works and not fear of good ones, Satan and evil men, his ministers, were bound in their lairs by these luminaries, like beasts, far from the presence of God. From the time when these two luminaries were moved against each other and failed in their devotion to religion, Satan was loosed.”</em></p><p>So, it’s not God who keeps Satan bound, but the restrainer is the good will and cooperation between the clergy and the king. Really, it’s apparently all just a metaphor for how men are behaving, or not.</p><p>The last line is a bit telling. Gerhoh is saying that the disputes of the “two luminaries,” or that they<em>“failed in their devotion to religion,”</em> are what led to Satan being loosed, i.e. he was loosed <em>after</em> they moved against each other. But he can’t quite go there with his hero Gregory, so he says they <em>“were moved against each other;”</em> I’d like to know: who moved them?</p><p><em>“From that time one pope stood against another, the one attempting to loose what the other would bind and vice versa. From that time the priesthood was made like a smoking cloth through the evil of simony and the wickedness of incontinence so that in many it was evident as a fear not of evil works but of good ones. The rare bishop who wished to correct his clergy did not dare to do so through fear of the Roman curia, with whom even the wicked could find judgment for a price.”</em></p><p>This provides the early echos of the Reformation of Martin Luther, and meanwhile the Catholic Church went even further down this road of worldly power and wealth.</p><p><em>“Then ‘it was night’ in which ‘all the beasts of the forest wandered about, the whelps of the lions roaring to lay waste and to seek their meat from God’ (Ps. 103:20–21). Under a disguise of piety they hid their purpose, so that what they did in an evil and bestial manner might seem to be done at God’s inspiration, that is, ‘to seek their meat from God.’</em></p><p>Let’s start by looking at Psalm 103:20–21:</p><p><strong><em>Bless the Lord, ye his angels, that excel in strength, that do his commandments, hearkening unto the voice of his word. Bless ye the Lord, all ye his hosts; ye ministers of his, that do his pleasure. (Psalm 103: 20–21; KJV)</em></strong></p><p>This is obviously not the Psalm that was quoted. Here is the one that was:</p><p><strong><em>Thou makes darkness, and it is night: wherein all the beasts of the forest do creep forth. The young lions roar after their prey, and seek their meat from God. (Psalm 104:20–21; KJV)</em></strong></p><p>I double and triple-checked myself, and it was not my typo. I’m not sure whose it was.</p><p>Now let’s look at the whole thought in Psalm 104:</p><p><strong><em>16 The trees of the Lord are full of sap; the cedars of Lebanon, which he hath planted; 17 Where the birds make their nests: as for the stork, the fir trees are her house. 18 The high hills are a refuge for the wild goats; and the rocks for the conies. 19 He appointed the moon for seasons: the sun knoweth his going down. 20 Thou makes darkness, and it is night: wherein all the beasts of the forest do creep forth. 21 The young lions roar after their prey, and seek their meat from God. 22 The sun ariseth, they gather themselves together, and lay them down in their dens. 23 Man goeth forth unto his work and to his labour until the evening. 24 O Lord, how manifold are thy works! In wisdom hast thou made them all: the earth is full of thy riches. (Psalm 104: 16–24; KJV)</em></strong></p><p>Psalm 104 is a song of praise to God. To take an isolated phrase from this beautiful, poetic verse and turn it into a metaphor for evil just makes me feel ill. There’s a saying that you can twist statistics to prove anything you want…well, the same is true of the Bible. Unless it’s read in context, looking at the original meanings, and with the help of the Spirit, it can be twisted to mean whatever a wayward, or even corrupt, mind wants it to mean. I just can’t accept this kind of use in a serious Christian discussion.</p><p>That’s all for today, and if the end is too much of a downer, then please reread the quote from Psalm 104 to be uplifted!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ddb6efde7ae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE GREAT REFORM AND OTTO OF FREISING]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-great-reform-and-otto-of-freising-ef437e9efae6?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef437e9efae6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[12th-c-catholic-church]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pope-antipope-clement-iii]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pope-gregory-vii]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-great-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[otto-of-freising]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 May 2026 15:48:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-11T15:48:32.697Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“The Church smote the kingdom in its weak spot when the Church decided not to reverence the king of the Clay as lord of the earth but to strike him with the sword of excommunication as being by his human condition made of clay.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4jppJyb3DnGG3tr3WICyvA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We are now in the High Middle Ages. At this time a lot was happening in Germany, so we will be looking at the views of three religious Germans who were active during the Great Reform. Because this is running long, we will look at them one at a time.</p><p>We are still in the book VISIONS OF THE END by Bernard McGinn. He has a good synopsis of the Great Reform:</p><p><em>“The central event of the late eleventh and early twelfth centuries was the prolonged struggle between the popes and emperors over the leadership of Christian society. From about 1050 a group of reform-minded prelates gathered around a succession of popes and attempted to purify the Church from the evils of the time: the corrupt life of the clergy, simony (the buying of ecclesiastical offices), and especially lay investiture (the investing of a churchman with the symbols of office by a secular ruler). In 1073, the monk Hildebrand, one of the most vehement of the reformers, was elected pope as Gregory VII. By 1075 he was locked in a mighty struggle with Henry IV, a struggle which N. F. Cantor has described as one of the great world revolutions.</em></p><p><em>“It is not my purpose to detail the history of this encounter nor the battle of the books that accompanied it. The struggle proper was ended by the compromise reached at the Concordat of Worms in 1122 and confirmed by the First Lateran Council the following year; its ramifications were to be felt for centuries. The Great Reform engendered by the investiture controversy brought about the most far-reaching political changes that Latin Christendom had seen since the conversion of the Roman Empire. It called into question not only the theocratic dream of the Christian emperors, both East and West…but also challenged the theory of history and version of the apocalyptic scenario connected with it. The success of the reformers in elevating the papacy to a position of truly effective universal authority in the Western Church could not help but provoke a serious reconsideration of traditional eschatology and apocalypticism. Schemes of history based upon the succession of empires and the view of the End that stressed the role of the Last Emperor as the predecessor of Christ were called into question in an age when the sacrality of both empire and emperor was challenged by many. The rise to power of the papacy made it possible to begin to wonder what role the popes would play in the last times.”</em></p><p><em>T</em>he Church had obviously gone down a wrong road, and unfortunately, the Great Reform really didn’t set it right. The wrong road was the road of earthly power. It was no wonder that the secular leaders were seeking to stick their noses into the doings of the Church, the Church had been doing the same thing to them. The <em>“rise to power of the papacy”</em> began to put a decidedly sinister spin on the Church.</p><p>The next excerpt refers to Guibert of Revenna without explaining who he was. Henry IV was the Holy Roman Emperor, and in that capacity he was appointing bishops and archbishops without consulting the Church (the Investiture Controversy). Gregory VII and his group struck back at Henry IV by supporting a rival claimant to the imperial throne and excommunicating Henry IV. Those on Henry’s side retaliated by electing the Archbishop of Revenna, Guibert, to be pope (Clement III) in opposition to Gregory VII, as well as against three successive anti-imperial popes after Gregory (Victor III, Urban II, and Paschal II). Apparently, after his death, Guibert was hailed as a saint by his followers, but Paschal II and his party declared a ‘condemnation of memory” against him, had him dug up, and threw his remains into the Tiber river. The Catholic Church still considers him an AntiPope.</p><p><em>“Gregory VII made heavy use of Antichrist rhetoric in the course of his struggles. Guibert, the archbishop of Revenna and imperial Antipope, is called ‘Antichrist and archheretic;’ other opponents are spoken of as precursors, heralds, members, or limbs of the Antichrist. But this kind of language was by no means novel — all of these uses appear in previous authors, though perhaps not in the profusion present in Gregory. The pope is also more inclined than most of his predecessors to provide a concrete political interpretation to the opposition between the followers of Christ and the servants of the Antichrist, but he does not seem to have held that the End itself was at hand. The closest Gregory comes to an imminent sense of the Last Things is found in a remark he made to explain the conflict his views had brought forth: ‘the nearer the day of Antichrist approaches, the harder he fights to crush out the Christian faith.’ This is a familiar eschatological </em>[theme]<em>, not necessarily a real apocalyptic one.”</em></p><p>So, Gregory VII not only had designs on world power, but was also willing to use the words of Revelation against his political enemies. Just think, if Henry IV had gone along with him as the Antichrist to Gregory’s False Prophet, that would have been a different tale! But it wasn’t time yet.</p><p>Now we get into our first theologian, Otto of Freising.</p><p><em>“Otto of Freising (c.1110–1158), monk and bishop, reformer and imperial propagandist, Scholastic and symbolist, is one of the more complex figures of the twelfth century. Born into the highest levels of German nobility…he was no simple imperialist. His major work, THE TWO CITIES…is unique in the Middle Ages in combining a profound Neo-Augustinian theology of history with a skillful and critical analysis of recent events. Otto’s universal history does give over its eighth and final book to the consideration of the events of the End, but there is little originality in the treatment. His profound historical pessimism, evident in the reflections he gives on the investiture controversy…are more cogent proofs of his apocalyptic interests.”</em></p><p>The following quote comes from Otto’s THE TWO CITIES, written about 1146. The first paragraph is a summary of his current events, it’s interesting so I’m leaving it in:</p><p><em>“In the one thousand and sixty-sixth year from the incarnation of the Lord, a star of the sort that is called a comet is said to have been seen and failed not to have its effect. In the same year William, count of Normandy, conquered Greater Britain, which is now called England, killing Harold, its king, and, after reducing the entire population to slavery and settling the Normans there, ruled there himself as king. In the following year the emperor took to wife Bertha, the daughter of the Italian margrave Otto, celebrating the wedding at Tribur. The Roman pontiff excommunicated the emperor after frequently summoning him to appear before him to do penance, and upon the pontiff’s advice and authority (so tradition says) Rudolf, duke of Alemannia, was made emperor by certain nobles. Not long afterwards Rudolf was killed in open and public war and Herman, prince of Lorraine, was chosen in his stead, he too was killed not long afterwards by loyal supporters of the emperor. I have read and reread the history of the Roman kings and emperors, but I nowhere find that anyone of them was excommunicated by a Roman pontiff or deprived of his kingdom before this emperor — unless perchance one is to consider as equivalent to excommunication the fact that Philip was for a short time placed among the penitents by the bishop of Rome and that Theodosius was barred by the blessed Ambrose from the portals of the church on account of a bloody and murderous deed.”</em></p><p>We see a little pomposity in this last excerpt, and it only gets worse in the next. I have split this concluding paragraph into sections to make it easier to comment on it.</p><p><em>“At this point I think I ought to relate </em>[about what]<em> I postponed, the fact that the Roman empire — compared in Daniel to iron — had feet ‘part of iron and part of clay’ (Dan. 2:33) till that it was struck and broken to pieces by a stone cut of the mountain without hands. For, without the prejudgment of a better interpretation, how can I interpret ‘the stone cut out without hands’ (Dan. 2:34) as anything other than the Church, the body of its Head, a body that was conceived by the Holy Spirit without carnal admixture, was born of a virgin and reborn of the Spirit and of water — a rebirth in which mortal man had no part….”</em></p><p>Today we see the <em>“stone cut without hands”</em> as being Christ, not the Church. And worse, Otto attributes the Immaculate Conception to the Church (the <em>“body”</em>) rather than to Christ! So now we have the <em>“head”</em> of the Church being the pope, who is said to be Christ’s representative on earth, and we have the Church itself being <em>“conceived by the Holy Spirit” </em>and <em>“born of a Virgin”</em>, etc. Apparently, Christ is in heaven, so we must carry on here without Him. The Church at this point seems to have only a tenuous hold on its purpose and reason for being.</p><p><em>“It was clearly the Church that smote the kingdom near its end (that is the meaning of ‘the feet’). The kingdom was of iron on account of its wars and of clay on account of its condition. The Church smote the kingdom in its weak spot when the Church decided not to reverence the king of the Clay as lord of the earth but to strike him with the sword of excommunication as being by his human condition made of clay.”</em></p><p>Here Otto is making Bible prophecy about the Church, rather than about Christ. His statement <em>“The kingdom was of iron on account of its wars and of clay on account of its condition” </em>is rather vague: what condition is he referring to? Later he refers <em>to the “king” </em>being<em> “human”</em> and thus <em>“made of clay.”</em> So is the <em>“condition”</em> the <em>“human condition”</em>? And if so, was the original Roman Empire (made of iron) not human?</p><p>Then there is the <em>“Church [smiting] the kingdom in its weak spot.”</em> Did Gregory VII and Otto both forget what Paul said in Romans?</p><p><strong>Let every soul be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and the authorities that exist are appointed by God. Therefore, whoever resists the authority resists the ordinance of God, and those who resist will bring judgment on themselves. (Romans 13:1–2; NKJV)</strong></p><p>More than that, Gregory IV went far beyond <em>“decid[ing] not to reverence the king of the Clay as lord of the earth.”</em> He backed his own choice for king! And, why wouldn’t <em>“the king of the Clay”</em> be the perfect person to rule the earth (clay)? Finally, how does excommunication get to be used against a person, not as an individual, but as a secular leader? I understand that Henry IV was doing things that the pope did not agree with, and that it was interfering with the Church. But would Christ have seen that as a sin? I’m not sure that Christ would have even recognized the Church at this point.</p><p><em>“All can now see to what a mountainous height the Church, at one time small and lowly, has grown. What great calamities, how many wars and perils of wars followed in consequence of the weakness of the kingdom; how often unhappy Rome was besieged, captured, laid waste; and how pope was placed over pope even as king over king, it is weariness to record. In a word, the turbulence of this period carried with it so many disasters, so many schisms, so many dangers of soul and of body that it alone would suffice to prove the unhappy lot of our human wretchedness by reason of the cruelty of the persecution and its long duration.”</em></p><p>Did Christ prepare a <em>“mountainous height”</em> for Himself to stand upon? Did Christ encourage wars? Then there is the statement <em>“so many dangers of soul and of body that it alone would suffice to prove the unhappy lot of our human wretchedness by reason of the cruelty of the persecution.”</em> There was no persecution against Christians during this time, he is undoubtedly referring to his perceived persecution of the <em>Church</em>. So, not only Christ, but also Christians are not important: only the Church.</p><p><em>“The aforesaid Pope Gregory was driven out of the City by the emperor and Guibert, archbishop of Ravenna, was thrust into his place. Gregory abode at Salerno and, as the time of his summons drew near, he is said to have remarked, ‘I have loved righteousness and hated wickedness; therefore I am dying in exile’ (Ps. 45:7).”</em></p><p>This so misleading. By saying <em>“as the time of his summons drew near,”</em> it is implied that he was being summoned to his death at the hands of Henry IV or perhaps Guibert/Clement III. And then it’s followed by Gregory’s epitaph from Psalms about dying in exile…which isn’t exactly right:</p><p><strong><em>Thou loves righteousness, and hates wickedness: therefore God, thy God, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness above they fellows. (Psalm 45:7; KJV)</em></strong></p><p>This combination makes it sound like Gregory was put to death. Nothing could be further from the truth. Henry marched into Rome, despite Gregory’s military supporters, and Rome surrendered to him. Gregory retired from Rome, and refused to meet with or crown Henry, even when Henry offered to bring him Guibert as a prisoner. Gregory was able to convene a few of the bishops and again excommunicated Henry. Henry marched back into Rome and saw to it that Guibert was installed as Pope Clement III, and was then crowned by him. Gregory formed an alliance with some Normans and they retook Rome. But the Roman people were fed up with Gregory and his Normans, so they had to withdraw. Gregory lived out the rest of his life in exile in the castle of Salerno by the sea. [This was from Wikipedia, which I used because it’s very concise and avoids a whole rabbit trail.]</p><p><em>“Not only, then, was the kingdom severely smitten in the case of its emperor, who had been cut off by the Church, but the Church also suffered no little sorrow in being bereft of so great a shepherd, who had been notable among all the priests and bishops of Rome for his zeal and force of character. With so great a transformation, as the times were passing from perfection to overthrow, let us put an end to the sixth book that, with God’s guidance, we may hasten on to the seventh and to that rest of souls which follows the wretchedness of this present life.”</em></p><p>Otto is trying hard to be conciliatory here, describing the reasons for sorrow on both sides. And then destroys it with <em>“as the times were passing from perfection to overthrow,” </em>implying <em>“perfection”</em> when Gregory was winning, and <em>“overthrow”</em> when Henry won. In the end, of course, Pope Urban II retook Rome (Victor III died only 2 years after being elected), and AntiPope Clement III died in 1100, in exile, during Pope Pascal II’s reign. And the biggest insult was that a new pope took the name Clement III in 1130.</p><p>An interesting fact is that Otto of Freising was only 10 years old when AntiPope Clement III died. Yet Otto’s writing makes it sound like he was actually involved in a partisan way on the side of Gregory. A second interesting fact, Otto was Henry IV’s grandson!</p><p>Otto was related to most of the German royalty. He was the uncle of Frederick Barbarossa, who became the next big Holy Roman Emperor. After Henry IV, followed by the last of his line, Henry V, the German princes had had enough of powerful emperors and so for the next 25 years they stripped the crown of power and the big, important families took turns providing an emperor figurehead.</p><p>We’ll leave Otto here, and we’ll take up with Gerhoh of Reichersber next time, another man on the side of Pope Gregory.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef437e9efae6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE PEOPLE OF THE YEAR 1000, AND THE PEOPLE OF THE CRUSADES]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-people-of-the-year-1000-and-the-people-of-the-crusades-af8a7d838771?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af8a7d838771</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rodulfus-glaber]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-crusade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ekkehard-of-aura]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abbo-of-fleury]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[benzo-of-alba]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Apr 2026 15:57:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-20T15:57:58.023Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“After the sign in the sun that had been foretold was seen, many portents appeared in the sky as well as on the earth and excited not a few who were previously indifferent to the Crusade.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EPIIP74F3KfIP--Jkoe28w.jpeg" /></figure><p>We’re moving from the tenth to the twelfth century, and things are beginning to change. The first millennium after Christ’s death is passing and the world isn’t coming to an end. We are going to see some cynicism, some mysticism, and the start of the Crusades. We are still in VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES by Bernard McGinn from 1979, and will be a bit longer.</p><p>Here is Mr. McGinn’s summary of the eleventh century:</p><p><em>“The eleventh century has frequently been seen as an age of strong apocalyptic expectations. Basing themselves upon two wide-spread historical myths, the legend of the year 1000 and the claim for the apocalyptic motivation of the crusading movement, many accounts, both old and new, stress the revival of apocalypticism at this time. Both myths contain germs of truth, but in the forms in which they have generally been presented they are more misleading than helpful. The eleventh century did not produce anything new in the history of apocalypticism, and in comparison with the following centuries it should not be singled out as an era of especially fervent hopes of the End of the World.”</em></p><p>McGinn goes on to throw more cold water on the idea that people were really thinking the world would end at the turn of the millennium. He thinks that because the theologians since Augustine were not treating the Millennium literally, that people really wouldn’t get that worked up about the year 1000. But let’s take a minute to think about how people reacted to the year 2000. Despite our technology and supposed sophistication, there was quite a bit of excitement and fear around the start of the second millennium.</p><p>The people approaching the year 1000 were very subtle in their thinking, and they were deep thinkers. It made sense to them that if Christ had said He was coming back “soon,” and He hadn’t come back during the first thousand years, then coming back at the turn of the millennium was a distinct possibility…even a probability. So, while the people of that time were not crazy enough to throw themselves off of cliffs or commit mass suicide at the approach of the new millennium, I have no doubt at all that there was a rise in anticipation and perhaps some anxiety. There was enough anxiety, for example, that a large amount of land was donated to the Cluny monastery by the local aristocrats from 980 and into the 1030’s. Obviously something was worrying them!</p><p>When Christ didn’t arrive, there’s a good chance that the let-down was palpable. The faith of many probably waned some, but Western culture was very wrapped up in the Church at that time, so most probably they didn’t fall away completely. But of course they temporarily lost some interest in apocalypticism, and no longer looked for the imminent End of the World, at least for a while. If this topic interests you, there is a great paper from 2011 called FEAR OF AN APOCALYPTIC YEAR 1000 (<a href="https://www.bu.edu/history/files/2011/10/11.Fear-of-an-Apocalyptic-Year-1000-Speculum.pdf">https://www.bu.edu/history/files/2011/10/11.Fear-of-an-Apocalyptic-Year-1000-Speculum.pdf</a>). Briefly, scholars in the mid-19th century believed that people <em>were</em> affected by fear of the year 1000. But, those in the 19th century went a bit overboard with their dramatic imaginations, as they often did, leading to a complete reversal of thought around 1900. Since 1900 it’s been generally believed that the year 1000 was “just another year,” and this has been academically accepted with very little thought or scholarship. The author, Richard Landes, goes into a lot of aspects about this topic looking at them realistically and with scholarship.</p><p>Moving on, let’s look at what McGinn has to say about the Great Crusade:</p><p><em>“The Great Crusade was fundamentally a papal plan for the reestablishment of the Mediterranean Christian empire under the leadership of the pope. Insofar as it formed a part of Gregory VII’s plans for the realization of an ideal world order, it might be described as having important eschatological, but not directly apocalyptic, implications. As a major form of organized lay piety, the crusade was not so much the result of apocalypticism as it was a notable stimulus to the revival of apocalyptic ideal, and changes that affected the political situation of the city were bound to suggest apocalyptic implications after 1100.”</em></p><p>Notice that Pope Gregory VII was going for a ‘world order.’ Where do we see reference to that in Bible? Of course Daniel refers to the world systems, but it’s Revelation that heavily alludes to a one-world order. I have to wonder if the Pope was trying to push forward the end times, or if he actually thought that he could ‘improve’ on the Bible and achieve a ‘world order’ that was ‘good’? This rabbit hole leads to some pretty confusing thoughts!</p><p>Let’s look at the representative works from the late 10th to early 12th centuries. We’ll begin with an excerpt from Abbo of Fleury who was a monk and abbot of a Benedictine monastery in France. He was one of the great scholars of his time, and interestingly he was killed with a lance in his side while trying to quell a riot of monks! Apparently he was trying to change how they did things, and they weren’t happy about it.</p><p>The excerpt is from his APOLOGETIC WORK, written in 995:</p><p><em>“When I was a young man I heard a sermon about the End of the world preached before the people in the cathedral of Paris. According to this, as soon as the number of a thousand years was completed, the Antichrist would come and the Last Judgment would follow in a brief time. I opposed this sermon with what force I could from passages in the Gospels, Revelation, and the Book of Daniel. Finally my abbot of blessed memory, Richard, wisely overthrew an error which had grown up about the End of the world after he received letters from the Lotharingians </em>[a narrow, short-lived, post-Carolingian kingdom, extending from the North Sea to the Mediterranean, located between West Francia (known earlier as the Aquitaine, or roughly France) and East Francia (known earlier as Saxony, or roughly Germany/Austria)] <em>which he bade me answer. The rumor had filled almost the whole world that when the feast of the Annunciation coincided with Good Friday without any doubt the End of the world would occur.”</em></p><p>One of Abbo’s listed achievements is the calming of fears about the coming change of millennium, and he refers to that activity here. This quote only strengthens my point of view that the millennium was more influential than McGinn seems to think. If this was not a widespread idea, then why would Abbo need to fight against it? And, Abbo was right, by the way: the 1000-year concept before the appearance of the Antichrist was not really Biblical.</p><p>Next we meet Rodulfus Glaber. He is sometimes referred to as ‘Ralph Glaber,’ and he was also known as Rodulfus the Bald (Glaber being Latin for ‘bald’). He was a French monk who had a reputation for being “unruly;” I’m getting the idea that French monks of this time were pretty feisty. Rodulfus probably had trouble submitting to monastic rules as evidenced by the fact that he was kicked out of his first monastery for disobedience. But, maybe he just liked traveling, because he wandered quite a bit and, while he stayed in various monasteries, it doesn’t look like he stayed very long in each one. He is known as a chronicler and for writing his five volume HISTORIAE. However, HISTORIAE was so poorly done (the words used to describe it are: “lacking critical sense and order”) that it was ignored for a very long time. In modern times it is considered valuable as historical documents, probably not so much for interpreting his times, as rather just providing names, dates and places.</p><p>The excerpt is from his HISTORIAE, which was completed around 1040:</p><p><em>“When some of the more truthful of that time were asked by many what might be the meaning of such a great flocking together of people to Jerusalem, unheard of in previous centuries, they cautiously responded that it presaged nothing else but the coming of the Lost One, the Antichrist, who according to divine authority stands ready to come at the End of the age. Then the road to the eastern region from which he was to come was opened to all nations, so that all might go forth to meet him without delay. Truly that prophecy of the Lord will be fulfilled which says: ‘Then even the elect, if it be possible, will fall into temptation (Matt. 24:24).’”</em></p><p>This is an interesting quote, and, again, suggests that people were disturbed by the approaching millennial change. There is a certain smugness about this quote, particularly how it ends. Rodulfus would have been about 15 (and already in monastery from the age of 12) at the turn of the millennium. He probably remembered the hype, but at 15 he may not have thought about it too deeply, and thus may have thought himself free of the “temptation.”</p><p>What is really interesting though is his reference to all the people “flocking” to Jerusalem. This is well before the first crusade, and I hadn’t thought about it before, but it makes sense that this was happening. Attacks on Christian pilgrims (who were most often the rich and powerful of Europe) to the Holy Land was one of the stated reasons for the crusades in the first place. Muslims had taken over Jerusalem in the 7th century, and over the years did a lot to destroy the Christian presence there. Different caliphates had differing attitudes towards Jews and Christians, some more tolerant that others. There was a lot of skirmishing and warfare as different Muslim groups took or lost control. The next to the last group in control was a war-like group of ‘Turkman’ tribes, who killed each other and many of the populace pretty regularly for about 20 years. As the crusaders approached, the Fatimid caliphate was able to regain control of Jerusalem (a somewhat more tolerant and stable group) until the crusaders freed Jerusalem from Islamic control. Interestingly, the Jews fought on the side of the Fatimid caliphate, which was used against them by Christians. But it must be remembered that the Christians were quite anti-Semitic already, and the Fatimid caliphate probably looked more tolerant at that moment.</p><p>Meanwhile, back in Europe, Pope Gregory VII had his ‘one world’ plans, but King Henry IV of Germany was standing in his way. I’m not going to go deep down this rabbit hole, but it needed to be mentioned because: remember the ‘mysticism’ I said we would see? Well, this next quote is about as airy-fairy as it gets. It’s from PANEGYRIKUS by Benzo of Alba, an Italian bishop, and was written in 1086:</p><p><em>“For a long road still remains to him [Henry IV] as the prophecy of the Sibyl testified…Then he will lead an expedition to Jerusalem and having rescued the Sepulcher and the other sanctuaries of the Lord he will be crowned to the praise and glory of the One who lives forever and ever. Babylon in amazement will come to Sion desiring to lick the dust of his feet. Then will be fulfilled what is written: ‘And his sepulcher will be glorious’ (Isa. 11:10). Caesar, why do you wonder about this? He who created you has decided without you what he will do in your case. You should say: ‘O Lord, my God, you have done many wonders; in your deep thoughts there is none like you’ (Ps. 39:6)…These things will take place as the song of the Sibyl foretells. You, fellow priests of the emperor’s ear, do not think the Sibyl’s words the voice of a screeching crow! Where you hear that the sea is to be crossed, you should think upon deep things. If you are doubtful in any way ‘…ask in Abel…’ and when the veil has been rent those things that were hidden will be clear.”</em></p><p>Today we would hardly recognize this as having been written by a Christian. Benzo apparently did a lot of fawning over the leaders of Europe that he approved of. Even female leaders, though he made it very clear that they were still beneath the male leaders. The line <em>“You, fellow priests of the emperor’s ear”</em> sounds distinctly pagan, as if they are the priests of Henry rather than Christ.</p><p>Unfortunately, Henry did not live up to Benzo’s flattery.</p><p>Now we’ll look at the references to the crusades. Again, I don’t want to go too deeply into this because there is just too much and we’ll never get to Revelation. I will just say that there are multiple sides to any issue, and that there were/are as many people who were grateful for the crusaders as there were those who hated them, despite their many blunders. And there were probably as many reasons for going on crusade as there were crusaders. There will be more about the crusades, but only in regard to Revelation and apocalypticism.</p><p>We’ll look at two crusade excerpts; the first is from Ekkehard of Aura, a German bishop who, as a young man, went on crusade in 1101. He wrote JERUSALEM JOURNEY in 1105:</p><p><em>“After the sign in the sun that had been foretold was seen, many portents appeared in the sky as well as on the earth and excited not a few who were previously indifferent to the Crusade. We thought that some of these signs could be usefully inserted here: to give all of them would be very tedious. About the fifth of October we saw a comet in the south, its tail extending sideways like a sword. In the third year after these events, on February 24, we saw another star in the east changing its position by leaps and bounds after a long interval. We and many witnesses attest to have seen blood-red clouds rising from the west as well as the east and rushing together in the center of the sky, as well as brilliant fires from the north in the middle of the night, and frequently even sparks flying through the air. Not many years before, a priest of venerable life by the name of Siger one day at about three in the afternoon saw two knights charging against each other in the sky and fighting for a long time. The one was carrying a good-sized cross with which he struck the other turned out the victor. At the same time the priest G. (now a monk with us…) was walking in the woods with two companions about noon. He saw a sword of marvelous length, arising from an unknown source, borne off into the heavens in a whirlwind. Until the distance hid it, he heard its din and saw its steel. Others who kept watch feeding horses reported that they saw the likeness of a city in the air and that they beheld various crowds hurrying to it from different places both on horseback and on foot. Some showed the sign of the cross stamped by divine influence on their foreheads or clothes or on some part of their body, and by that mark they believed themselves to be ordained for the army of God. Others who were converted by a sudden change of heart or instructed by a vision in the night sold their manors and household possessions and sewed the sign of mortification on their clothes. In the midst of all of this, more people than can be believed ran to the churches in crowds, and the priests blessed and handed out swords, clubs, and pilgrim wallets in a new ritual. Why should I report that at that time a woman, pregnant for two years, gave birth to a son already speaking when her womb finally opened? Why should I speak of the infant born with two members in all parts, or of another with two heads, or of the lambs with two heads, or the foals who at birth put forth the large teeth which are commonly called ‘equine,’ and which nature grants only to three-year-olds?”</em></p><p>So first I have to tell you about a book I read a number of years ago called EIFELHEIM by Michael Flynn. It’s a novel that explores the idea of an alien space craft crashing near a small German town in the 14th century. What would they think? What would they do? It’s a fascinating story, but I wondered how Flynn came up with this idea. And now, go back and read this passage again with the thought: that the comet and/or star was a space ship, the weird clouds and fires were it crashing, the sword in the whirlwind was it taking off again, and all those birth defects were from the radiation. Freak you out much? I can’t help but wonder if Michael Flynn read this quote…</p><p>The main reason I included this excerpt is, of course, that it shows what people were thinking. They thought all these things were omens and signs about the End of the world. So of course they needed to go crusading and save Jerusalem from the pagans.</p><p>The last excerpt is basically a call to arms for the crusades. It is from a book called THE DEEDS OF GOD THROUGH THE FRANKS by Guibert of Nogent. Guibert was a French abbot who never crusaded himself, but knew many French crusaders and used their stories to write this history of the crusades in 1108.</p><p><em>“You ought to consider with deep deliberation whether, as a result of your pains, with God acting through you, it should happen that the mother church of all churches begins to bloom again to the Christian religion. You ought also consider whether perhaps he may not wish other parts of the East restored to the faith against the approaching times of the Antichrist. For it is clear that Antichrist will not wage war against Jews and pagans, but, according to the etymology of his name, he will attack Christians. If he finds no Christians there (as today there are scarcely any), there will be no one to oppose him or whom he may legally overcome. According to Daniel and his interpreter Jerome, he will fix his tents on the Mount of Olives, and it is certain, as the Apostle teaches, that at Jerusalem he will sit ‘in the Temple of God, as if he were God’ (2 Thess. 2:4)…Lo, the Gospel calls out: ‘Jerusalem is to be trodden down by the nations until the times of the nations are fulfilled’ (Luke 21:24). ‘The times of the nations’ can be understood in two ways. First, either because the nations have dominated the Christians at will, and for the satisfaction of their passions have chased after the sloughs of every shamefulness and found no obstacle. (For they who have everything at their pleasure are said to have their time,’ as the text: ‘My time is not yet come, but your time is always ready’ (John 7:6), and as we say to voluptuaries, ‘You’re having your time!’) Or second, ‘the times of the nations’ are the fullness of those nations that will steal in before Israel will be saved. Dearly beloved, these times will now perhaps be fulfilled while you repel the pagan powers with God’s cooperation. The End of the world is already near, even if the pagans are no longer being converted to God, for as the Apostle says, there must first come a falling-away from the faith (2 Thess 2:3). According to prophecies, before the coming of the Antichrist it is first necessary that the Christian empire be renewed in those parts, either through you or through those whom God pleases, so that the head of all evil who will have his imperial throne there may find some nourishment of faith against which he may fight. Think then that the Almighty has perhaps prepared you to rescue Jerusalem from such subjugation! I ask you to consider what hearts could conceive the joys when you have seen the Holy City raised up by your aid, and the prophetic, nay divine, oracles fulfilled in our times!”</em></p><p>First of all, just because the Son of Perdition is sometimes called the Antichrist does not mean that Christians are the only peoples he will strive against. They are probably the <em>main</em> people he will go up against, but I doubt they will be the only ones. And certainly, there are no <em>“legal”</em> bonds on him to only fight against Christians.</p><p>The statement: <em>“According to Daniel and his interpreter Jerome, he will fix his tents on the Mount of Olives”</em> was interesting. Remember when I said I didn’t know where they got the idea that the Antichrist was on the Mount of Olives? Well, here it is, it came from Jerome.</p><p>Then he mentions the <em>“falling away,”</em> as if this falling away is to be characterized by pagans <em>“no longer being converted.”</em> He apparently cannot conceive of Christians actually <em>“falling away.”</em> Then, in the next breath, he talks about the necessity of the Christian empire <em>“being renewed” </em>before the Antichrist comes (of course, followed by Christ). That was a not-so-clever twist to lead us to believe that we must improve the world for Christ to consider returning. Propaganda is a very old art.</p><p>I will leave it here for today.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af8a7d838771" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ADSO ON THE ANTICHRIST]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/adso-on-the-antichrist-ebc15d766cb1?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ebc15d766cb1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[holy-roman-empire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antichrist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-age]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adso]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-of-revelation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2026 15:09:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-03T15:09:45.470Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IxjFOY1kuB1wCK2ihr1QwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We are still in the Middle Ages, and the material is still coming from VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES by Bernard McGinn from 1979.</p><p>We are in the middle of the Middle Ages at this point, about 600 years before the Renaissance. The Carolingian period is mentioned in several excerpts; it takes its name from Charlemagne who began ruling as king of the Franks in 741. In 800 the Roman Pope crowned him emperor, and he then considered himself king of the Holy Roman Empire (which was thought of as the continuation of Rome and extended at that point from France to eastern Europe and northern Italy). The Carolingian period ended in 888, though the title of Holy Roman Emperor lingered on as the Catholic Church in Rome strove to hold on to power, and the Carolingian family continued to rule part of France with the last Carolingian descendant dying in 1122. In Europe, the middle ages is considered to have begun with Charlemagne’s reign.</p><p>Meanwhile, in the East, they were identifying themselves as the continuation of Rome under what became known as the Byzantine Empire. While the Holy Roman Empire was conducting official business in Latin, the Byzantines were doing that in Greek. The Byzantines were also much less consolidated, which is why there are multiple Orthodox Churches, i.e. Greek Orthodox, Russian Orthodox, etc. Both the East and West, of course, started out with similar beliefs, but gradually moved apart, and in 1054 they each officially declared the other to be heretical in what is known as the East-West Schism.</p><p>So with that historical background, the first excerpt gives a small overview on the thoughts about the Antichrist over the previous 400 years:</p><p><em>“…speculation on the Antichrist had remained popular both in the East and the West during the centuries from A.D. 500 to 900. The corporate interpretation of the Last Enemy was common, with the Antichrist usually being identified with heretics or sometimes with the Jews. Belief in a final individual Antichrist was also known. The new life given to learning, education and theology in the Carolingian period inspired Agobard of Lyons in a letter to Louis the Pious in 826 to suggest that someone should compose a treatise summarizing traditional teaching on the Son of Perdition.”</em></p><p>This time period, and perhaps much of our own, was fascinated with the Antichrist. It often seems like more people are interested in when the Antichrist will show up, and who he is, than in when Christ will return! But, I will try to give them the benefit of the doubt by thinking that perhaps they are interested in the Antichrist because they know that the rise of the Antichrist will herald the coming of Christ.</p><p>So now we will read a bit about Adso’s life. If you are hungry for more, go borrow McGinn’s book on Internet Archive, there is much more in there about who has been determined to have influenced Adso and what Adso’s influence on culture was.</p><p><em>“The hope </em>[for a treatise on Antichrist]<em> was not fulfilled for over a century. Adso was born about 910 and entered the monastic life during the time of the great reforms associated with the houses of Cluny and Gorze </em>[these two houses reformed to the rule of St. Benedict and started what we know of as the Benedictines)<em>. He became abbot of the reformed monastery of Montier-en-Der and died in 992 while on pilgrimage to the Holy Land. A noted hagiographer </em>[someone who writes about the lives of saints]<em> and confidant of the West Frankish royal family </em>[i.e. the Carolingians]<em>, Adso composed his LETTER ON THE ORIGIN AND LIFE OF THE ANTICHRIST about 950. It was dedicated to Gerberga, the sister of Otto the Saxon, the future renewer of the empire, and wife of the young Louis IV (ruled </em>[France]<em> from 936 to 954), one of the last descendants of the Carolingians…The monk was a learned man for his day, but in the tenth century even scholars traveled with light academic baggage. It is certain that Adso depends ultimately upon patristic </em>[Church fathers]<em> teaching on the Antichrist, though his access to this material seems to have been largely through summaries dating from the eighth and the ninth centuries…Relying on his background as a hagiographer…the monk modeled his account of the Antichrist on a typical saint’s life.”</em></p><p>The next excerpt talks about something that I was wondering about. Think about Nebuchadnezzar’s dream that Daniel interpreted, the one with the image that had a golden head, silver torso, iron legs, and feet made of clay and iron. And then remember that many think that Daniel prophesied that the Antichrist would come from the last great kingdom, i.e., Rome. I was imagining living during the end of the Roman Empire: They thought that the world would end when Rome fell, because hey, the Antichrist had to come from Rome, and, they were also equating Rome’s power with the ‘restrainer’. But then, what did the people after that think? Today we look back and see that Rome influenced a large swath of land, and that influence remains today, both geographically, culturally and linguistically, so we consider that Rome is still present in many ways. But the people living after Rome fell mostly saw it as the end of Rome and beginning of great upheaval. But after a period of time, the Holy Roman and the Byzantine Empires began to see themselves as a continuation of the Roman Empire as it existed in the 4th century. The following excerpt provides some hints as to how these things were being thought about at that time:</p><p><em>“…the notion of the endurance of Rome to the End of time as the last of the four world empires was also a subject for speculation. There appear to have been two attitudes to this complex of apocalyptic ideas in the Carolingian age — one jettisoned the traditional exegesis which identified Rome with the restraining power of 2 These. 2; the other attempted to update the traditional teaching by showing how the reality of Roman rule had passed from East to West during the course of history. Adso is among the most influential exponents of the latter option in early medieval thought.”</em></p><p><strong><em>For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work; only He who now restrains will do so until He is taken out of the way. (2 Thessalonians 2:7; NKJV)</em></strong></p><p>Now let’s look at the introductory passage from THE ORIGIN OF THE ANTICHRIST section of Adso’s LETTER:</p><p><em>“Since you want to know about the Antichrist, the first thing to observe is why he is so named. It is because he will be contrary to Christ in all things and will work deeds against Christ. Christ came in humble fashion; he will come as a proud man. Christ came to raise up the humble, to justify sinners; he, on the other hand, will cast out the humble, magnify sinners, exalt the wicked and always teach the vices contrary to virtues. He will destroy the Law of the Gospel, call the worship of demons back into the world, seek his own glory, and call himself almighty God. This Antichrist will have many ministers of his evil: many of them have already gone forth into the world, such as Antiochus, Nero, and Domitian. In our own time we know there are many Antichrists. Any layman, cleric, or monk who lives in a way contrary to justice, who attacks the rule of his order of life, and blasphemes the good, he is an Antichrist, a minister of Satan.”</em></p><p>Adso mentions that he got the information about Antichrist from other sources that he had “diligently studied.” This is good for us because it means that what he writes about it was agreed upon by at least some contemporary, and somewhat earlier, sources. This gives us a better idea of what people were thinking about the Antichrist and the End Times in the mid-tenth century.</p><p><em>“As our authorities say, Antichrist will be born from the Jews, namely, from the tribe of Dan, as the prophet says: ‘Let Dan be a snake on the wayside, an adder in the path.’ He will sit like a serpent on the wayside, and in the path to wound those who walk on the paths of justice and to kill them with the venom of his malice. He will be born from the union of a father and mother, just as other men are born, and not, as some say, from a virgin alone. Nevertheless, he will be conceived wholly in sin, generated in sin, born in sin. The devil will enter the womb of his mother at the very instant of his conception. He will be fostered by the power of the devil and protected in his mother’s womb. The power of the devil will always be with him. Just as the Holy Spirit came into the Mother of Our Lord Jesus Christ, overshadowed her with his power, and filled her with divinity, so that she conceived of the Holy Spirit and what was born of her would be divine and holy, so too the devil will descend into the mother of the Antichrist and completely fill her, surround her completely, possess her completely both inside and out, so that she will conceive through a man with the cooperation of the devil, and what will be born will be totally inimical, evil, and lost….”</em></p><p>There are those who still hold to many of these ideas, including the focus on justice, though the New Testament focus is on mercy rather than justice. We will continue to run into these ideas as we go through the Revelation commentaries. I don’t really agree with most of it, but the part that bothers me the most is the idea that the mother of the Antichrist will be in-dwelt by Satan before conception, and that the child will be in-dwelt upon conception. First of all, Satan cannot read the future, so he cannot be sure of the timing in which he would need to perform this deed (and it is questionable that he could perform this deed in this way). And secondly, if Satan has done this for every antichrist character through time, then he has been kept too busy to do much else.</p><p>My third issue is: while I’m sure that there are women enough out there who have embraced evil to the point of allowing themselves to be in-dwelt by demons, a child at conception is a different thing. We are all born with original sin, but I don’t believe that alone gives Satan the right or cause to indwell an individual. Just as there are plenty of evil women out there, there are also plenty of evil men. The Antichrist will be a man who has earned being in-dwelt by Satan, not a poor schmuck who was in-dwelt before knowing good from evil.</p><p>The last issue revolves around sin and free choice. As I said above, we are all born in sin because of original sin. For Adso, or his “authorities,” to think that the circumstances of the Antichrist’s birth must have compounded evil upon evil for this all to work is naive at best, and completely misguided at worst. To me this attitude suggests the idea that people are inherently ‘good’ (i.e., sinless at birth), and would therefore need significant input from evil forces to ‘turn bad’.</p><p>We have only to look around us to see the harvest of evil and its origin. The people being drawn into sin may have been tempted by Satan, but they have the free will to decide whose side they will take. And in choosing to turn from God, they default to the side of Satan, and this allows Satan far more leeway in their lives. All of them started out as ‘innocent’ babes, young children loved by God, unable to tell good from evil and thus not personally responsible, but tainted by the sin of Adam nonetheless; and Antichrist will start out the same way. Choices made through free will, once the knowledge of good and evil is achieved, mark out a path for the individual. It is not marked out by anyone else, or any outside power, i.e. free will. God, in His infinite Love and Goodness, does provide <em>through Jesus</em> that anyone may turn from the evil path to Him at any time <em>until death</em>. Even the Antichrist will have this option open to him, but he will not take it, as many of his followers will not. And one more point: if mankind is inherently ‘good’, and yet Satan can take us over at will, then we are only powerless pawns, suggesting that this life is nothing more than a chess game between God and Satan. It may sometimes feel like this is the case, but this is wrong on many levels. We are not powerless. We cannot save ourselves through our own deeds, but we have the power to turn to Christ and have faith in Him. That is all we need. Once we do that, Satan can tempt us, but he cannot indwell us. If we turn away from Christ, then we are on our own, and we are weak before Satan. And while we are weak before Satan, Satan is weak before God…it is not an even match.</p><p>I will leave the argument here. We’ll return to Adso:</p><p><em>“The Apostle Paul discloses the time when the Antichrist will come and when the Day of Judgment will begin to appear in his Epistle to the Thessalonians where he says: ‘I ask you through the coming of Our Lord Jesus Christ…,’ down to ‘…unless the falling away first comes and the Man of Sin and Son of Perdition be revealed.’ (2 These. 2:1–3). We know that after the Greek empire and even after the Persian empire, each of which in its day throve in great glory and flourished in very great strength, finally, after all the others, began the Roman empire, which was the strongest of all and had the whole world under its sway. All nations were subject to the Romans and served them as tributaries. Hence the Apostle Paul says that Antichrist will not come into the world unless first comes the falling-away, i.e., unless first all kingdoms fall away from the Roman empire to which they were long subject. This time has not yet come, because, though we see the Roman empire destroyed in great part, nevertheless as long as the kings of the Franks who hold the empire by right shall last, the dignity of the Roman empire will not totally perish, because it will endure in its kings.”</em></p><p>This is an interesting take on ‘falling away.’ It goes to show that Rome was a huge influence on culture, even after she fell. This letter was written around 950; by then the Carolingian period was over and the Frankish kings were ruling smaller and smaller areas, while other family lines were actually ruling the empire. Adso, being a friend to the Carolingian court in France, obvious believed that they had the right to the throne of the empire.</p><p>It’s amazing that Adso would still believe that the falling away had anything to do with Rome. But he goes further:</p><p><em>“Some of our learned men say that one of the kings of the Franks who will come in the last time will possess anew the Roman empire. He will come at the last time and will be the last and the greatest of all rulers. After he has successfully governed his empire, at last he will come to Jerusalem and will put off his scepter and crown on the Mount of Olives. This will be the end and the consummation of the Roman and Christian empire. Immediately…they say that the Antichrist will be at hand. Then the ‘Man of Sin’ will be revealed, Antichrist who, although he is a man, will nonetheless be the source of all sin, and the ‘Son of Perdition,’ that is, the son of the devil, not through nature but through imitation, because he will fulfill the devil’s will in all things, and because the fullness of diabolical power and of every evil disposition will dwell bodily in him in whom will be hidden all the treasures of malice and iniquity.”</em></p><p>Today, this ‘last ruler of the Roman empire’ is seen as being the Antichrist himself. And he won’t be laying down his scepter and crown on the Mount of Olives. I’m not sure where they came up with this scenario on the Mount of Olives either. But, Adso goes on:</p><p><em>“This Antichrist, the son of the devil and the totally wicked agent of all evil, for three and a half years will torment the whole world with a great persecution and torture the whole people of God with various punishments, as foretold. After he has killed Elijah and Enoch and has crowned with martyrdom those holding fast in the faith, finally the judgment of God will come upon him, as St. Paul writes: ‘The Lord Jesus will slay him with the breath of his mouth’ (2 Thess. 2:8). Whether the Lord Jesus will kill him by the power of his might, or whether the Archangel Michael will slay him, he will be killed through the power of Our Lord Jesus Christ…The learned say that Antichrist will be killed on the Mount of Olives in his pavilion and on his throne, opposite the place where the Lord ascended to heaven…You should know that after the Antichrist has been slain the Day of Judgment will not come right away, nor will God immediately come to judge; but, as we understand from the Book of Daniel, the Lord will grant forty days to the elect to do penance because they were led astray by the Antichrist…”</em></p><p>The ‘learned’ seem to be obsessed with the Mount of Olives, but the Bible says nothing about the Antichrist hanging out there. According to Revelation, the Antichrist is <em>captured</em> by Christ at Armageddon and subsequently thrown <em>alive</em> into the lake of fire. The Thessalonian quote seems to depend on the translation. Here it is per King James:</p><p><strong><em>And then shall that Wicked be revealed, whom the Lord shall consume with the spirit of his mouth, and shall destroy with the brightness of his coming: Even him, whose coming is after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders (Thessalonians 2:8–9; KJV)</em></strong></p><p>Paul does not make it clear just what happens to the Antichrist or what, exactly the time frame is, but just that he loses and dies eventually at Christ’s hand.</p><p>Revelation does say that the judgment occurs after the millennium. But, the 40 days for <em>“the elect to do penance because they were led astray by the Antichrist”</em> is doubtful. The pertinent part of Daniel says:</p><p><strong><em>And from the time that the daily sacrifice shall be taken away, and the abomination that taketh desolation set up, there shall be a thousand two hundred and ninety days. Blessed is he that waiteth, and cometh to the thousand three hundred and five and thirty days</em></strong>. (<strong><em>Daniel 12:11–12; NKJV)</em></strong></p><p>Subtract 1290 from 1335 and you get 45 days (I’ll try to keep the math to a minimum…), not 40. And why would those who were <em>“led astray by the Antichrist”</em> be considered <em>“blessed”</em>? More than that, why would anyone who is the <em>“elect”</em> even be able to be <em>“led astray”</em>? This whole idea is very antithetical to Bible teachings. It sounds like something written by either someone who had not experienced persecution, and was afraid that he might not be able to stand up to it, or, perhaps someone who was afraid that he might not be able to discern the lies of Satan…and has no faith that Christ will allow that discernment. It’s a trap door, an escape hatch that is an illusion.</p><p>Here’s the last theological point for the day: While repentance is a necessary part of salvation, penance is not. Christians do not have a ‘get out of jail free’ card, so that they can go sin at will and then do penance to be forgiven; this, unfortunately, is where the Catholic Church went and was one of the things that brought on the Reformation. Once you call on Jesus and repent, your sins are forgiven…all of them, and you no longer willfully sin because it is anathema to you. Are you perfect at that point? Of course not, you will continue to be a sinner, but you will mourn and repent each time you sin. Do saved Christians ‘fall away’? Yes, of course they do. But if they were truly saved, they come back. Is this what Adso is referring to, time in which come back? No, because ‘penance’ is not part of that return. Consequences can be part of it…if a Christian ‘falls away’ and robs a bank, he will have to suffer the consequences of having robbed that bank, even if he returns to Christ. But he does not need to do specific penance to ‘make up’ for his sins. Christ already did that, totally and completely, past/present/future.</p><p>I have given you a lot of theological points today. They are mine, not in an original sense, but they reflect how I have understood the Bible and the many pastors I have chosen to listen to. I freely admit that not all Christians or pastors will agree with me. But to stand and say that this is right and that is wrong, you need a piece of real estate to plant your feet upon. I am defining my piece of real estate. You may read things differently and stand in a different spot. If that’s the case, then me defining my stand, my understanding of the truth, should help you solidify yours by giving you something to push against.</p><p>This is not to say that I have a different ‘truth’ than you do: the Truth is solid and immovable. But what is coming from the huge and incomprehensible mind of God we must explain to ourselves with our microscopic minds. It’s entirely possible that in God’s mind these concepts include <em>all</em> of our interpretations <em>simultaneously, </em>plus much more. But meanwhile, we are stuck in our microscopic minds and must come up with ways of understanding those specks of information that God has bestowed upon us; and while those specks can feel overwhelming at times, they are what God requires that we sort through to understand some basic knowledge of Him and His Plans. If your understanding is different that than mine, feel free to share, and of course, I could be wrong.</p><p>That’s it for now. Thanks for being there.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ebc15d766cb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[EPHRAEM AND BEATUS]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/ephraem-and-beatus-f3d30d9f459b?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3d30d9f459b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bernard-mcginn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ephraem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-age]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[early-church-fathers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[beatu]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Mar 2026 18:22:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-28T18:22:03.991Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>There are evil deeds among the ministers, adulteries in the aged, wantonness in the youths — in mature women false faces, in virgins dangerous traces! In the midst of all this there are the wars with the Persians…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ABfU5EGz4LKWLx3BCz3tdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>We’ll start today with more excerpts from the 1979 book VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES by Bernard McGinn. Ephraem the Syrian is the first writer we’ll look at starting with a short biography and speculation about the dating of the writings:</p><p><em>“Ephraem was born in Nisibis </em>[Nisibis was a trade center located on the road between Assyria and Syria]<em> about 306 and fled to Edessa </em>[a city on the frontier of the Syrian desert] <em>when his native city was conquered by the Persians in 363. The final ten years of his life at Edessa established the city as the intellectual center of the Syrian Church. Ephraem is the most important and prolific of the Syrian Church Fathers, though there is still a good deal of uncertainty regarding the authenticity of much that has been ascribed to him…According to E. Beck, the Syriac apocalyptic sermon ascribed to Ephraem dates to the second half of the seventh century…There is a Latin ‘Sermon on the End of the World’ found in three eighth-century mss. under the name of Ephraem…W. Bousset thought that portions of the source of this work, though not by Ephraem, could be dated to near the time of his death; but most scholars have sided with the editor, C. Caspari, who though he admits the use of a document from the late fourth century, assigned the original composition to the Byzantine period between 565 and 628. The Sermon…is an important witness to the transmission of Eastern apocalyptic materials to the Frankish West.”</em></p><p>And now an excerpt from the SERMON ON THE END OF THE WORLD:</p><p><em>“Dearly beloved brothers, believe the Holy Spirit who speaks in us. We have already told you that the End of the world is near, the consummation remains. Has not faith withered away among mankind? How many foolish things are seen among youths, how many crimes among prelates, how many lies among priests, how many perjuries among deacons? There are evil deeds among the ministers, adulteries in the aged, wantonness in the youths — in mature women false faces, in virgins dangerous traces! In the midst of all this there are the wars with the Persians, and we see struggles with diverse nations threatening and ‘kingdom rising against kingdom’ (Matt 24:7). When the Roman empire begins to be consumed by the sword, the coming of the Evil One is at hand. It is necessary that the world come to an end at the completion of the Roman empire.”</em></p><p>If you substituted “the United States” for “the Roman empire” this could be read in a pulpit today and people would be nodding in agreement. Whether this was written by Ephraem or not, I suspect is was indeed written in the 4th century (though perhaps copied and reused/revised at a later date.). By the 6th or 7th century the Roman Empire was history and no longer relevant in the way that is written about here. When I read this piece, I recognize the underlying feelings because it describes what’s happening today as well. If I had read this 30 years ago, I might have thought to myself “yes, we are starting down this same road,” but I don’t think it would have resonated as strongly as it does now. And someone in the 6th or 7th century would be hard pressed to write something so present, yet emotionally restrained, about an earlier time in history. I think someone imagining that time would over-blow the emotional content without realizing that a person living through it cannot afford to do that if they are to survive. Something we should be thinking about…</p><p>The sermon goes on to do a very brief synopsis of what’s described in Revelation:</p><p><em>“In those days two brothers will come to the Roman empire who will rule with one mind; but because one will surpass the other, there will be a schism between them. And so the Adversary will be loosed and will stir up hatred between the Persian and Roman empires. In those days many will rise up against Rome; the Jewish people will be her adversaries. there will be stirrings of nations and evil reports, pestilences, famines, and earthquakes in various places. All nations will receive captives; there will be wars and rumors of wars. From the rising to the setting of the sun the sword will devour much. The times will be so dangerous that in fear and trembling they will not permit thought of better things, because many will be the oppressions and desolations of regions that are to come.”</em></p><p>This piece is also very restrained. The writer is anticipating this happening in his lifetime, and he’s not expecting a rapture. I’m especially struck by the phrase: <em>“The times will be so dangerous that in fear and trembling they will not permit thought of better things.”</em> I have a very dear friend who was a child in Bremerhaven, Germany during World War II. She credits her mother’s <em>constant prayer and meditation on the Bible</em> with getting the family through the war alive, including her father who was in a Russian prison camp. Her story brings home to me very firmly that the more dangerous the time is, the more fear and trembling the times create, <em>the more we need “thoughts of better things”</em>…the more we need God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit. Looking ahead at the coming times, it can be very difficult to realize how much we will need those <em>“thoughts of better things,”</em> and how much we imagine surviving, or not, on our own resources. I see this in this paragraph, he is imagining himself in the future experiencing these things, and thinking only of his own resources.</p><p>Next we will look at Beatus of Liebana, from another time and another place:</p><p><em>“Among the most important conveyors of tradition during these centuries was the Spanish monk Beatus of Liebana (~750–798). From Visigothic times the church in Spain had had close ties with North African Christianity, and as in Africa, the Book of Revelation was paid particular reverence.”</em></p><p>If you’ve ever wondered why Spain was attacked by the “Moors”, i.e. Muslims, then this information should provide a hint.</p><p>We will end with an excerpt from THE COMMENTARY OF BEATUS, which includes a timeline. If you compare, you’ll notice that it mostly follows Eusebius’ timeline, but with some differences.</p><p><em>“For the first age was from Adam to Noah and occupied 2,242 years; the second, from Noah to Abraham, was 942 years. The third, from Abraham to Moses, was 505 years, and the fourth, from the departure of the sons of Israel from Egypt until their entrance into the promised land, was 40 years. From the entrance into the promised land to Saul, the first king, the Israelites had Judges for 355 years. Saul reigned 40 years, and from David to the beginning of the Temple there were 43 years. The fifth age, from the first building of the Temple to the Babylonian captivity, took 446 years. There were 70 years in which the people were captive and the Temple desolate. The Temple was restored by Zorobabel in 4 years, and from the restoration until the Incarnation of Christ there were 540 years.</em></p><p><em>“The whole time from Adam to Christ makes 5,227 years, and from the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ to the present Spanish era of 824, there are 786 years. Therefore, compute the time from Adam to the present Spanish era and you will find 5,986. There are then only 14 years left in the sixth millennium, and the sixth age will end in the Spanish era 838.</em></p><p><em>“The time remaining to the world is uncertain to human investigation. Our Lord Jesus Christ rejected every kind of question on this matter when he said: ‘It does not belong to you to know the times or the moments which the Father has put in his own power’ (Acts 1:7); or again ‘No one knows the day nor the hour — neither the angels of heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father’ (Mark 13:32). Because he said ‘day and hour,’ sometimes they are to be taken for general time spans, sometimes to be understood directly. You should know in truth that the world will end in 6,000 years; but whether these years are to be completed or to be shortened is known only to God…One thousand is said as a manner of speaking, just as that passage which reads, ‘That which he commanded for a thousand generations’ (Ps. 104:8) is to be understood not as a thousand but openly signifying the whole. Therefore do not listen to those who say that from the Nativity of the Lord to his Second Coming there are a thousand years — they think the same as the heretic Cerinthus. Nor should we listen to those who say that all the baptized and all those who die without penance will not be judged guilty of sin or offense because they remained in the faith, or if they be buried in Hell, after a thousand years they shall be freed. These do not understand that the Lord will say to sinners, ‘Go into everlasting fire’ (Matt. 25:41), since it has no end…”</em></p><p>Beatus not only says that the end comes in 838 A.D., but also addresses the idea that there would be 1,000 years between the First Coming and the Second Coming. Many people viewed 1000 A.D. with dread as they thought the world was going to end. It was actually much worse than Y2K for mass panic!</p><p>We also see in Beatus’ writing the Catholic Church idea that dying <em>“without penance”</em> leads to Hell. This is one of the beliefs that was let go in the Reformation: the idea that salvation is up to us and our actions. The Reformation brought Paul’s writings about ‘faith alone’ to the forefront, providing relief to countless believers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3d30d9f459b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE CHRONOLOGY OF THE BIBLE, part 2]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-chronology-of-the-bible-part-2-51155fdada74?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51155fdada74</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bible-chronology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clement-of-alexandria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jack-finegan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tertullian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Mar 2026 16:22:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-06T16:22:42.014Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Pzd5C4B0-DmPebO4RZ-OWQ.png" /></figure><p>(As some of you may have noticed, there has been a long hiatus between the last post and this one. A series of life events, involving a train trip, an injury, a new job, and a change of residence got in the way of my writing. Beginning to pick up the pieces…)</p><p>We’re looking at Jack Finegan’s HANDBOOK OF BIBLICAL CHRONOLOGY today. Half the book describes the problems with and the details of dating things in the Bible. We will be studying a few of those things.</p><p>First, let’s look at Abraham:</p><p><em>“…In the Bible record the entry of Abraham into Canaan appears to be put by the figures in the Hebrew text at about 1921 B.C. (Ussher), by the figures of the Septuagint at around 1700 B.C. Historically it is at least possible that the Amraphel of Gen 14:1 is to be identified with King Hammurabi of Babylon, and the latter is now probably to be dated about 1728–1686 B.C.</em></p><p><strong><em>And it came to pass in the days of Amraphel king of Shinar, Arioch king of Eliasar, Chedorlaomer king of Elam, and Tidal king of nations; (Genesis 14:1; KJV)</em></strong></p><p><em>“Archeologically, conditions in the Negev in general and at Gerar in particular appear to be such as are presupposed in the biblical narrative concerning Abraham either in the period known as Middle Bronze I (21st to 19th centuries B.C.) or in Middle Bronze II (19th to 16th centuries B.C.), perhaps the latter.”</em></p><p>A lot of ‘probables.’ It looks like a ballpark has been established, but it’s not definitive at all. It’s very hard to pinpoint events in such a remote age, even the dates for Hammurabi’s rule have changed since 1964 to 1792–1750 B.C. And Wikipedia, that all-knowing website, puts Abraham’s dates as ~2150 B.C. to ~1975 B.C.</p><p>Let’s look at Exodus next:</p><p><em>“The statement in I K 6:1 that it was in the four hundred and eightieth year after the people came out of Egypt that Solomon began, in the fourth year of his reign, to build the Temple, appears to provide a relatively precise date for the exodus.</em></p><p><strong><em>And it came to pass in the four hundred and eightieth year after the children of Israel were come out of Egypt, in the fourth year of Solomon’s reign over Israel, in the month Zif, which is the second month, that he began to build the house of the LORD. (1 Kings 6:1; KJV)</em></strong></p><p><em>“Computation on this basis leads to dates for the exodus from 1491 (Ussher) to 1446 B.C. The statement of Ex 1:11 that the Israelites built for Pharaoh the store cities of Pithom and Raamses seems to require, however, that the enslavement immediately prior to the exodus be placed under the famous Pharaoh Ramses II.</em></p><p><strong><em>Therefore they did set over them taskmasters to afflict them with their burdens. And they built for Pharaoh treasure cities, Pithom and Raamses. (Exodus 1:11; KJV)</em></strong></p><p><em>“According to the best information presently available</em> [1964] <em>the reign of Ramses II is probably to be dated 1304–1237 B.C., and a date of the exodus not too long after 1300 B.C. seems more probable”</em></p><p>A couple things stick out to me in these excerpts. First of all, who came up with the 1446 B.C. date? Secondly, the author states that the Exodus was probably under Ramses II, which I’ve read in multiple other places. I’m not sure though, why he thinks that the Exodus was early in Ramses’ reign.</p><p>But now let’s dig a little deeper. Let’s look at the reign of Ramses II. The author’s best information was 1304–1237 B.C. On <a href="http://www.worldhistory.org/">www.worldhistory.org</a> the dates for his reign are currently listed as 1279 to 1213 B.C., and <a href="http://www.britannica.com/">www.britannica.com</a> agrees. Not a big difference, but still a difference. And as more time and archaeology goes by, it may change again.</p><p>Modern archaeology has more to say on the subject. The city of Pithom, or Per-Atum, or Per Tum, was identified with the modern city of Tall al-Maskhutah in the 19th century. It was thought to be from the period of Ramses II due to statues of him found there. But, excavations have shown that the earliest habitation layers do not predate the 7th century A.D., and it’s been guessed that the statuary was transported there around the 4th century (from <a href="http://britannica.com/">britannica.com</a>).</p><p>In an article from the Journal of Near Eastern Studies in 1968 by E.P. Uphill called PITHOM AND RAAMSES: THEIR LOCATION AND SIGNIFICANCE, there are many other reasons cited for the unlikeliness of Tall al-Maskhutah being Pithom, providing several plausible alternatives, and then concluding that Heliopolis was the most likely. As for Raamses, the article gave a number of possibilities, but without being able to recommend any of them. On the other hand, an article in the journal Vestus Testamentum called RAAMSES, PITHOM, AND THE EXODUS: A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF EX 1:11 by Bernd Ulrich Schipper from 2015 seems to accept the 19th century point of view as the “classical” point of view, and then goes on to push the idea that ‘Raamses’ mentioned in Exodus 1:11 was not referring to a town, but to the Pharaoh himself! So you can see, this is far from cut and dried.</p><p>Let’s move on to the New Testament. I’m going to give you an abbreviated version of Mr. Finegan’s look at the date of Christ’s birth. He goes into excruciating detail figuring out the reign of Augustus in Rome, starting with the death of Julius Ceasar, and the reign of Augustus in Egypt, starting with the death of Cleopatra. He makes multiple tables. Please look at this if you are interested. And for sheer scholarship, all of that would be necessary. But I decided to skip to the part where he looks at the statements made by the early Church Fathers, which he backs up with information about Augustus’ reign. Again, this is a rabbit hole, and I just want to give you a flavor of how the dating is done. And remember, this was written in 1964. I know that they are still arguing about the date of Christ’s birth even today, so it’s still not settled.</p><p>First we’ll hear about Clement of Alexandria:</p><p><em>“In the STROMATA, written about A.D. 194, Clement of Alexandria says: ‘And our Lord was born in the twenty-eighth year…in the reign of Augustus.’ In the same passage he also says very precisely: ‘From the birth of Christ…to the death of Commodius are, in all, a hundred and ninety-four years, one month, thirteen days.’ The emperor Commodius was murdered Dec 31, A.D. 192. From Jan 1, 2 B.C., to Dec 31, A.D. 192, are one hundred and ninety-four years. One month before Jan 1, 2 B.C., is Dec 1, 3 B.C. Thirteen days before that is Nov 18, 3 B.C. This is Clement’s date for the birth of Christ. This date was in the twenty-eighth year of the Egyptian reign of Augustus…”</em></p><p>Next we’ll get Tertullian’s take on it:</p><p><em>“In AN ANSWER TO THE JEWS, written about A.D. 198, Tertullian makes these statements: ‘After Cleopatra, Augustus reigned forty-three years. All the years of the empire of Augustus were fifty-six years. In the forty-first year of the empire of Augustus, when he has been reigning for twenty-eight years after the death of Cleopatra, the Christ is born. And the same Augustus survived, after Christ is born, fifteen years.’ After the death of Cleopatra Augustus reigned almost exactly forty-three factual years in Egypt…In Rome, after the part year in which Julius Ceasar died and before the part year in which he himself died, Augustus reigned fifty-six full calendar years…By the reckoning just indicated…the forty-first year of Augustus was the year 3 B.C.; the twenty-eighth Egyptian year…was 3/2 B.C. After the year 3 B.C…there were fifteen full years of reign remaining, namely…2 B.C. — A.D. 13 inclusive…”</em></p><p>Now, Julius Africanus, who we haven’t heard from previously, and Hippolytus who we have:</p><p><em>“In his CHRONOGRAPHIES Julius Africanus (A.D. c.170 — c.240) placed the birth of Christ in…3/2 B.C., as established above. His contemporary, Hippolytus of Rome ( A.D. c.170–236) also indicates in his CHRONICLE the same date of 3/2 B.C.” </em>[Mr. Finegan points out here that Julius Africanus had Christ’s birth as 5500 years from Adam, and Hippolytus had it as 5502 years from Adam.]</p><p>Origen is next, but only to say that he has the same figures as Tertullian. As an aside, I have talked to people who just can’t understand that people in ancient times got around and talked to each other, or that those hand-copied books got around for people to read….they did, and they did.</p><p>The next Church Father is Eusebius:</p><p><em>“Eusebius of Caesarea (A.D. c.325) says in the CHURCH HISTORY: ‘It was, then, the forty-second year of the reign of Augustus, and the twenty-eighth year after the submission of Egypt and the death of Anthony and Cleopatra…when our Savior and Lord Jesus Christ…was born.’ By both factual…and accession-year calendar…reckonings, the twenty-eighth Egyptian year of Augustus extends from August of 3 B.C. to August of 2 B.C….Likewise in the Macedonian calendar in Syria according to the accession-year system the forty-second year of Augustus extends from Oct 1, 3 B.C. to Sep 30, 2 B.C…In the CHRONICLE as translated by Jerome Eusebius says that Augustus reigned fifty-six years and six months, and places the birth of Jesus in the forty-second year. It has already been established…that this probably indicates the same year, 3/2 B.C.”</em></p><p>Epiphanius of Salamis is next:</p><p><em>“Epiphanius (A.D. c.315–403) was born in Palestine and became bishop of Salamis or Constantia on the island of Cyprus in A.D. 357. In his PANARION or ‘medicine chest’ for the healing of all heresies, he states, like Eusebius…that Augustus reigned fifty-six years and six months, and that Jesus was born in his forty-second year. He also says, however, that this was the year when the consuls were Octavian for the thirteenth time and Silvanus. This indicates, therefore, the year 2 B.C., when the consul listing is: </em><strong><em>Augusto XIII et Silvano</em></strong><em>…Epiphanius also mentions a different date for the birth of Christ which he says was given by the Alogi. The Alogi, as he calls them, were a group in Asia Minor around A.D. 180 who were opposed to the Montanists. Because the Montanists used the Johannine writings to support their doctrines of the Spirit, this group also opposed the books of John. Epiphanius explains the name he gives them: ‘They reject the books of John. Accordingly since they do not receive the Logos proclaimed by John they shall be called Alogi” According to the Alogi, Christ was born around the fortieth year of Augustus. Assuming the equation by Epiphanius of the forty-second year of Augustus with the year 2 B.C., the fortieth year must have been the year 4 B.C. In the same passage, however, he says that the Alogi put the birth of Christ under the consuls S. Camerinus and B. Pompeianus. Assuming that the latter name means Poppaeus Sabinus, these were the consuls of A.D. 9…</em><strong><em>Camerino et Sabino.</em></strong>”</p><p>It’s interesting that the Alogi are way off of everyone else’s dates. We don’t know who the Alogi were really, but we do know that some of the Church Fathers were only 3 or 4 generations away from the Apostles, and in a direct line of teaching. To me, that makes their information more believable.</p><p>Mr. Finegan concludes:</p><p><em>“…Even the earliest preserved dates which we interpret to indicate 4 and 4/3 B.C., however, seem hardly early enough to be acceptable. In the CHRONICLE Eusebius equates the forty-second year of Augustus, in which he places the birth of Jesus, with the thirty-second year of Herod the Great. In the PANARION Epiphanius equates the forty-second year of Augustus, in which he also puts the birth of Jesus, with the thirty-third year of Herod. Both equations seem impossible… [when considering] the dates of the reign of Herod the Great, but both show a recognition of the fact that the birth of Jesus must be placed within the reign of Herod…and it appears that it can be satisfied only by a date of 4 B.C. or probably earlier.”</em></p><p>Confused yet? I could go on, but I think I’ve made my point: working out chronology from so long ago, Biblical or not, is very difficult and fraught with problems.</p><p>Next time we’ll be back on track with one or two more commentators from the Middle Ages.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51155fdada74" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE CHRONOLOGY OF THE BIBLE, PART 1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-chronology-of-the-bible-part-1-8cbebed638d4?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8cbebed638d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[age-of-the-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eusebius]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bishop-ussher]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[johann-albrecht-bengel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jack-finegan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Jul 2025 15:59:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-27T15:59:13.947Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7FgIhF-P7d6QpzwpJzNWtw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Today we’re going to look at Bible chronology. We’ve mentioned that some of the early Church Fathers tried to predict the End of the world, and we’ve already noticed some problems with that. With a cursory inspection, the Bible appears to be pretty straight forward in terms of time, because there are so many lists of ‘begats’ and many, many mentions of things that appear to provide an actual date, such as “in the fifteenth year of Tiberius”, or “at the end of the reign of Domitian.” Unfortunately, it’s not that easy. As an example, Sir Isaac Newton wrote 4500 pages on Bible chronology, and still couldn’t nail it down. He did a whole chronology of the secular world as well, with somewhat better results. I think I read that his interest in astronomy started with trying to use reported astronomical events to provide dates for far distant historical events (he was only partially successful in doing that). And he was an undisputed genius.</p><p>I’ll start by saying that an assumption was made, early on, that the Second Coming, and thus the End of the World, would be on the 6,000th year. Then, the end of the millennium would be the 7,000th year. This deduction was based on the 7 days of creation. The assumption is that God would plan it out that way, and the problem for them became: When did the 6,000 years start?</p><p>You’ve probably noticed in your own life, as I’ve noticed in mine, that God doesn’t usually do things by the numbers. For example, Daniel received a prophecy that the Anointed one would arrive (enter Jerusalem) 483 years after the word goes out to restore and rebuild Jerusalem. Why 483 years? Why not 480 years? Or an even 500 years? Or why not have a really clear pattern of numbers ticking off the important prophetic events of history? We humans love to find patterns in things; I’m not saying God doesn’t like patterns, but His patterns are far beyond our understanding without His help. And besides, if everything was neatly laid out and perfectly visible, we would know when everything was going to occur, and that’s not really part of the plan.</p><p>The 6,000 years idea is interesting, but hardly realistic. Yet, it continues to crop up even today. It has morphed into “a Christian thing” to assume that the world is only 6,000 years old, even though Eusebius figured out from the Bible that it was 5270 years from Adam to the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 A.D. That would make the world at least 7,295 years old this year.</p><p>I wanted to find the numbers for how several of the people who have predicted the End of the world have calculated it, but that turned out to be very difficult. I searched for 3 days and was able to find 3 examples. There are plenty of people who have made predictions, and you can find lists online of what year (and often what day!) they predicted, but not how they got there. The 3 I found tell me why that’s probably the case: the calculations are VERY convoluted. People are so ingenuous! As this is a rabbit-hole, and not our main topic, I decided to change my plan.</p><p>I found a book I could borrow on Internet Archive that delves into how time has been perceived and calculated throughout the Bible. It’s by Jack Finegan and called HANDBOOK OF BIBLICAL CHRONOLOGY, published in 1964. I’ll be using this book, combined with a couple other online sources, to give you an idea of just how difficult it is to pin down the chronology of the Bible. Even in 1964, there was enough more discovered about the Holy Land and the ancient peoples that lived there to cast serious doubts on anyone’s calculations.</p><p>Let’s start with the numbers I did find, and first up is Eusebius, cleaned up by St. Jerome. This is from the HANDBOOK, and Mr. Finegan only takes it to the destruction of Jerusalem. This will give you an idea of some of the events that are used to provide dates and relationships. I’ll just give you the number of years, with, in parentheses, dates and number of years from Adam specific to the listed, underlined event.</p><p>Adam (5200 B.C., 0 years from Adam) to the Flood (2958 B.C., 2242 years from Adam)- 2242 years</p><p>First year after the Flood to the Birth of Abraham (2017 B.C., 3184 years from Adam) — 942 years</p><p>First year of Abraham to the last year of servitude in Egypt (1512 B.C., 3689 years from Adam) — 505 years</p><p>First year in the wilderness to the Foundation of the Temple in the 4th year of Solomon (1033 B.C., 4168 years from Adam) — 479 years</p><p>Fifth year of Solomon to the Destruction of the Temple in the 11th year of Zedekiah (591 B.C., 4610 years from Adam) — 442 years</p><p>First year of Captivity to the 70th year of the Captivity (521 B.C., 4680 years from Adam) — 70 years</p><p>Rebuilding of the Temple in the 2nd year of Darius (520 B.C., 4681 years from Adam) to the Birth of Jesus in the 42nd year of Augustus (2 B.C., 5199 years from Adam) — 519 years</p><p>43rd year of Augustus to the Beginning of the Public Ministry of Jesus in the 15th year of Tiberius (28 A.D., 5228 years from Adam) — 29 years</p><p>16th year of Tiberius to the Death of Jesus in the 18th year of Tiberius (31 A.D., 5231 years from Adam )- 3 years</p><p>19th year of Tiberius to the Final Destruction of Jerusalem in the 2nd year of Vespasian (70 A.D., 5270 years from Adam) — 39 years</p><p>Let’s look at Bishop Ussher (d. 1656) and his ideas next. He started by adding the ages of the 21 generations of the Old Testament, commencing with Adam and Eve, while subtracting the life span reached after the carrier of the next generation was born. This took him to the first destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem during the reign of Nebuchadnezzar (totaling 3442 years). He then turned to Greek and Roman history to establish the date of Nebuchadnezzar’s death as 562 B.C. Next he added 562 to 3442 to get 4004, which he took to be the year when the earth was created; or rather, the evening of October 22, 4004 B.C. Apparently he decided on the actual day by assuming that God would create the sun at a cardinal point. And then he thought about Adam and Eve with all that ripe fruit….it must be autumn! The date itself was then found on the calendar worked out for 4004 B.C. This is only a small part of the Bishop’s calculations.</p><p>Ussher probably used a very similar technique to what Eusebius used to get to the first destruction of the Temple, but got different results….3442 years instead of 4679 years. Usher dated the fall of Jerusalem to 588 B.C., and Eusebius dated it to 591 B.C., and there are probably a number of other discrepancies in their dates.</p><p>I found information on one more person’s calculations, and that was Johann Albrecht Bengel. He based his calculations on the number 666. He wrote:</p><blockquote><em>“It is impossible for me to withhold from you a disclosure, which, however, I must request you keep entirely to yourself. By the help of the Lord I have found the number of the Beast [Inveni numerum Bestiae, Domino dante!]. It is 666 years, from A.D. 1143 to A.D. 1809 [i.e., ‘the period of papal domination’]. This key to the Apocalypse is of importance, and even a consolation to me, with respect to the repeated losses of my infant children; for those who are born in this generation are entering into troubling times. You, also, my friend, may well make ready to meet such times; for wisdom will be greatly needed. But “Blessed be He that cometh! (Psalm 26; Luke 13:35).”</em></blockquote><p>In Rev. 13:18, it says “let him calculate”, which Bengel took to be literal. To do that you need 2 numbers, so Bengel decided that John intended a distinction between ‘common time’ and ‘prophetic time’. He divided 666 years, the ‘common time’, by the 42 months of ‘prophetic time’ and concluded that a prophetic month was equal to 15.8571428 (or 15 6/7) common time years. From that he determined that Daniel’s ‘time’ equaled 222.22222 (or 222 2/9) common years. Think about this for a moment….this means that the Tribulation would last for 1111.11111… years. The Antichrist would have to have an Old Testament life span. But no, Bengel was a total preterist: he believed that everything had happened already.</p><p>Here’s an abbreviated form of Gerhard Krodel’s reportage of Bengel’s calendar based on his calculations. This abbreviated form comes from a 2010 article in Journal of Unification Studies by Mark D. Isaacs, entitled THE END-TIME CALCULATION OF JOHANN ALBRECHT BENGEL. I’ve added some of the Bible passages that were referenced so we can see if they really fit.</p><blockquote><em>96 A.D. the Book of Revelation is written and the future is disclosed.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>97–98 A.D. the seals are opened as promised in Revelation 6 and the “chronos” is indicated in the fifth seal (Rev. 6:11).</em></blockquote><p><strong>And white robes were given unto every one of them, and it was said unto them, that they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellow servants also and their brethren, that should be killed as they were, should be fulfilled. (Revelation 6:11; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>The second, third, fourth, and fifth centuries are filled with the blasts of the first four trumpets (Rev. 8:6–13); the second century is marked by, the scattering of the Jews by the Roman Emperor Hadrian (Rev. 8:7); the third century sees the invasion of the barbarians (Rev. 8:8); and the fourth century witnesses the Arian heresy (Rev. 8:10).</em></blockquote><p><strong>7The first angel sounded, and there followed hail and fire mingled with blood, and they were cast upon the earth: and the third part of trees was burnt up, and all green grass was burnt up. 8And the second angel sounded, and as it were a great mountain burning with fire was cast into the sea: and the third part of the sea became blood…10And the third angel sounded, and there fell a great star from heaven, burning as it were a lamp, and it fell upon the third part of the rivers, and upon the fountains of waters (Revelation 8:7; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote>Through the fifth trumpet the Roman Empire in the West comes to an end in 410 A.D. (Rev. 8:12).</blockquote><p><strong>And the fourth angel sounded and the third part of the sun was smitten, and the third part of the moon, and the third part of the stars; so as the third part of them was darkened, and the day shone not for a third part of it, and the night likewise. (Revelation 8:12; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>The “first woe” (Rev. 8:13; 9:12) is dated between 510 and 589 A.D. and comprises the tribulation of the Jews in Persia (Rev. 9:1).</em></blockquote><p><strong>1And I beheld, and heard an angel flying through the midst of heaven, saying with a loud voice, Woe, woe, woe, to the inhabiters of the earth by reason of the other voices of the trumpet of the three angles, which are yet to sound! (Revelation 8:13; KJV)</strong></p><p><strong>1And the fifth angel sounded, and I saw a star fall from heaven unto the earth: and to him was given the key of the bottomless pit…12One woe is past; and, behold, there come two woes more hereafter. (Revelation 9:1,12; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>From 589 to 634 A.D. is the interval between the first and the second woe.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The second woe lasts from 634 to 847 A.D. (Rev. 9:13–19) and is filled with murder perpetrated by the Islamic Saracens (Rev. 9:13) as well as with the unsuccessful struggle against idolatrous images (Rev. 9:20) in the East. [e.g., Mohammad (c.571–632 A.D.) to the Battle of Tours (732 A.D.)]</em></blockquote><p><strong>13And the sixth angel sounded, and I heard a voice from the four horns of the golden altar which is before God. 14Saying to the sixth angel which had the trumpet, Loose the four angels which are bound in the great river Euphrates. 15And the four angels were loosed, which were prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year, for to slay the third part of men. 16And the number of the army of the horsemen were two hundred thousand thousand: and I heard the number of them. 17And thus I saw the horses in the vision, and them that sat on them, having breastplates of fire, and of jacinth, and brimstone: and the heads of the horses were as the heads of lions; and out of their mouths issued fire and smoke and brimstone. 18By these three was the third part of men killed, by the fire, and by the smoke, and by the brimstone, which issued out of their mouths. 19For their power is in their mouth, and in their tails: for their tails were like unto serpents, and had heads, and with them they do hurt. 20And the rest of the men which were not killed by these plagues yet repented not of the works of their hands, that they should not worship devils, and idols of gold, and silver, and brass, and stone, and of wood: which neither can see, nor hear, nor walk (Revelation 13–20; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>December 25, 800 A.D. begins the “non-chronos” of Rev. 10:6 with the coronation of Holy Roman Emperor Charlemagne (742–814 A.D.), followed by a line of many “kings” (Rev. 10:11).</em></blockquote><p><strong>6And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and the earth, and the things that therein are, and the sea, and the things which are therein, that there should be time no longer…11And he said unto me, Thou must prophesy again before many peoples, and nations, and tongues, and kings. (Revelation 10:6,11; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>847–947 A.D. is the interval between the second and the third woe. The third woe lasts from 947 to 1836 (Rev. 12:12).</em></blockquote><p><strong>Therefore rejoice, ye heavens, and ye that dwell in them. Woe to the inhabiters of the earth and of the seal for the devil is come down unto you, having great wrath, because he knoweth that he hath but a short time. (Revelation 12:12; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>940–1617 A.D. comprises the 1,260 days of the woman (Rev. 12:6).</em></blockquote><p><strong>And the woman fled into the wilderness, where she hath a place prepared of God, that they should feed her there a thousand two hundred and threescore days. (Revelation 12:6; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>1058–1836 A.D. is the “time and times and a half time” of Rev. 12:14.</em></blockquote><p><strong>And to the woman were given two wings of a great eagle, that she might fly into the wilderness into her place, where she is nourished for a time, and times, and half a time, from the face of the serpent. (Revelation 12:14; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>In 1614 “the angel with the eternal gospel appears” (Rev. 14:6), i.e., Johann Arndt (1555–1621), the father of Lutheran Pietism.</em></blockquote><p><strong>And I saw another angel fly in the midst of heaven, having the everlasting gospel to preach unto them that dwell on the earth; and to every nation, and kindred, and tongue, and people (Revelation 14:6; KJV)</strong></p><blockquote><em>June 18, 1836 A.D., will see the beginning of the thousand-year imprisonment of Satan and the destruction of Antichrist (Rev. 19:11–20:3).</em></blockquote><p>I don’t think I need to add the long Bible quote of Rev. 19:11–20:3. If the world ended and Satan was chained in 1836 I couldn’t prove it by history. And if the Millennium has already come and gone, I’d say we’re in big trouble.</p><p>To force these Bible passages to “fit” the historical “equivalents” would take some major fast talking. I’m sure there is symbolism involved in the explanation, but, for example, Revelation 10:11 is pretty straight forward….John is told that he will <em>prophesy again before many peoples, and nations, and tongues, and kings. </em>This could refer to what he did after Patmos, or it could refer to how his Revelation has been read around the world. It seems far less likely that it would mean that Charlemagne was <em>followed by a line of many “kings.”</em></p><p>Also, there is a lot of Revelation left out here. It’s possible that Bengel actually did a line by line explanation, but the preterists that I’ve read so far seem to avoid that. They prefer to do what was done here: pick and choose the “likeliest” passages to fit the history that they have in mind.</p><p>Regarding the ‘first woe’, I was intrigued by the bit of history that Bengel chose. Of course I knew that the Jews lived in Babylon during the captivity, and I knew that probably not all of them left when they were released. But I didn’t know if they were there continually or for how long. Bengel is saying that they were there between 510 and 589 A.D., and by identifying that time and place as the ‘first woe’, I would expect to be hearing about some pretty horrific things happening at that time. Even if the falling star, poisoned waters, and the sun and moon being dimmed were all symbols, they would have to be symbolizing something pretty bad. But, notice that the Bible verses referred to completely avoid any of those things (and that’s hard to do in that part of Revelation). So I looked up that time and place and did not find a lot of entries. But, the online Jewish Encyclopedia [<a href="https://www.studylight.org/encyclopedias/eng/tje/b/bahram-gor.html">https://www.studylight.org/encyclopedias/eng/tje/b/bahram-gor.html</a>] has this to say about that time period in Persia:</p><blockquote><em>“The opening of the reign of Bahram V., who is generally known as “Bahram Gor,” from his fondness for hunting the wild ass (“gor”), was signalized by a victory over the White Huns…but was later darkened by the defeat he sustained in war with the Byzantine Empire, which compelled Persia to accept terms of peace with her traditional foe (421 C.E.)…In their religious attitudes towards other beliefs, however, the Sassanids were often very intolerant, as is shown by their persecution, at different times, of the Jews, Christians, and the followers of the sects of Mani and Mazdak. The Jews suffered especially under Ormazd IV. (578–590)…”</em></blockquote><p>This sounds much like other times and places for both Christians and Jews, hardly a special time of ‘woe’. At the bottom is a quote from Curzon’s PERSIA describing how the Jews lived in Persia during that time. It doesn’t sound great, but it wasn’t unique either for the times or the place:</p><blockquote><em>“Usually compelled to live apart in a ghetto, or separate quarter of the towns, they have from time immemorial suffered from disabilities of occupation, dress, and habits which have marked them out as social pariahs from their fellow creatures. The majority of Jews in Persia are engaged in trade, in jewellery, in wine and opium manufacture, as musicians, dancers, scavengers, pedlars, and in other professions to which is attached no great respect. They rarely attain to a leading mercantile position. In Isfahan, where there are said to be 3,700, and where they occupy a relatively better status than elsewhere in Persia, they are not permitted to wear the kolah or Persian head-dress, to have shops in the bazaar, to build the walls of their houses as high as a Moslem neighbour’s, or to ride in the streets. In Teheran and Kashan they are also to be found in large numbers and enjoying a fair position. In Shiraz they are very badly off. At Bushire they are prosperous and free from persecution. As soon, however, as any outburst of bigotry takes place in Persia and elsewhere the Jews are apt to be the first victims.”</em></blockquote><p>On the whole, Bengel’s list sounds 19th-century-centric and doesn’t really explain Revelation well at all.</p><p>That’s enough for today. The next part will go a bit deeper into the HANDBOOK’s discussion of some of the problems in actually dating parts of the Bible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8cbebed638d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[JEROME, SEVERUS, AND HILARIANUS]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/jerome-severus-and-hilarianus-8bcdee557f17?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8bcdee557f17</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[martin-of-tours]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[st-jerome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernard-mcginn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hilarianus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-fall-of-rome]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Jun 2025 16:08:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-20T16:08:45.060Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iKph5Vm0feQJdbdoTbNUng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Owls at dawn</figcaption></figure><p>We’re going deeper into the 1979 book VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES by Bernard McGinn over the next few posts. McGinn has provided some translations of medieval pieces that I haven’t seen elsewhere…at least yet. He also provides some fairly decent analysis of the beliefs of the time.</p><p>The first excerpt refers to a “<em>scheme of history</em>” that predicts the timing of the end of the world. These schemes apparently started very early, and we will look at a couple of them in more detail a little later.</p><p>Here’s the first excerpt:</p><p><em>“The six-thousand-year scheme of history as revised by Hippolytus indicated that the End of the world would come about the year 500. Barbarian onslaughts and the partial collapse of Roman governmental structure, especially in the West, seemed to confirm this in the eyes of many writers of the late fourth and early fifth centuries. When Rome, ‘the restraining force,’ was dissolving before men’s eyes, could the final enemy be far off?”</em></p><p>I’m stopping here to add some quotations from St. Jerome (347–420); these are from the Preface of his book THE COMMENTARY OF EZEKIEL, written between 410 and 414; there were 14 volumes.</p><p>From the Preface of Book 1:</p><p><em>“…but alas! intelligence was suddenly brought me of the death of Pammachius and Marcella, the siege of Rome, and the falling asleep of many of my brethren and sisters. I was so stupefied and dismayed that day and night I could think of nothing but the welfare of the community; it seemed as though I was sharing the captivity of the saints, and I could not open my lips until I knew something more definite; and all the while, full of anxiety, I was wavering between hope and despair, and was torturing myself with the misfortunes of other people. But when the bright light of all the world was put out, or, rather, when the Roman Empire was decapitated, and, to speak more correctly, the whole world perished in one city. ‘I became dumb and humbled myself, and kept silence from good words, but my grief broke out afresh, my heart glowed within me, and while I meditated the fire was kindled;’[Ps. 39:34] and I thought I ought not to disregard the saying, ‘An untimely story is like music in a time of grief.’ [Ecclus. 22:6]…since opportunity has been given me which I ought to use…for devoting myself to the exposition of Scripture, I will resume my work upon the prophet Ezekiel.”</em></p><p>Then, Book 3 includes the following preface:</p><p><em>“Who would believe that Rome, built up by the conquest of the whole world, had collapsed, that the mother of nations had become also their tomb; that the shores of the whole East, of Egypt, of Africa, which once belonged to the imperial city, were filled with the hosts of her men-servants, that we should every day be receiving in this holy Bethlehem men and women who once were noble and abounding in every kind of wealth, but are now reduced to poverty? We cannot relieve these sufferers: all we can do is to sympathize with them, and unite our tears with theirs. The burden of this holy work was as much as we could carry; the sight of the wanderers, coming in crowds, caused us deep pain; and we therefore abandoned the exposition of Ezekiel, and almost all study, and were filled with a longing to turn the words of Scripture into actions, and not to say holy things but to do them…”</em></p><p>Time and his work go on, until the Preface of Book 7:</p><p><em>“There is not a single hour, nor a single moment, in which we are not relieving crowds of brethren, and the quiet of the monastery has been changed into the bustle of a guest house. And so much is this the case that we must either close our doors, or abandon</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>the study of the Scriptures on which we depend for keeping the doors open. And so, turning to profit, or rather stealing the hours of the nights, which, now that winter is approaching, begin to lengthen somewhat, I am endeavoring by the light of the lamp to dictate these comments, whatever they maybe worth, and am trying to mitigate with exposition the weariness of a mind which is a stranger to rest. I am not boasting, as some perhaps suspect, of the welcome given to the brethren, but I am simply confessing the causes of the delay. Who could boast when the flight of the people of the West, and the holy places, crowded as they are with penniless fugitives, naked and wounded, plainly reveal the ravages of the Barbarians? We cannot see what has occurred, without tears and moans. Who would have believed that mighty Rome, with its careless security of wealth, would be reduced to such extremities as to need shelter, food, and clothing? And yet, some are so hard-hearted and cruel that, instead of showing compassion, they tear up the rags and bundles of the captives, and expect to find gold about those who are nothing but prisoners. In addition to this hindrance to my dictating, my eyes are growing dim with age and to some extent I share the suffering of the saintly Isaac: I am quite unable to go through the Hebrew books with such light as I have at night, for even in the full light of day they are hidden from my eyes owing to the smallness of the letters. In fact, it is only the voice of the brethren which enables me to master the commentaries of Greek writers.“</em></p><p>The remaining 7 volumes contain no further thoughts about what was happening, yet chances are that the repercussions of the fall of Rome lasted for some time, and it is no wonder that people thought the end was near. My heart cries out every time I read those passages. And when St. Jerome speaks of the “careless security of wealth”, I can’t help but think of America, and how we too, some day, possibly soon, may be in similar straits.</p><p>McGinn refers to Rome as ‘the restraining force’, and in one sense that was true: Rome’s might restrained the barbarians at the gate. But that is probably not the sense that Paul meant when he wrote:</p><p><strong>For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work; only He who now restrains will do so until He is removed.(2 Thessalonians 2:7; NASB).</strong></p><p>Now, back to VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES:</p><p><em>“Sulpitius Serverus (d. c.430) was the friend and biographer of Martin of Tours, the Father of Western monasticism. His popular LIFE OF ST. MARTIN was written shortly after the saint’s death in 397. Within a few years he supplemented LIFE with a mass of material about Martin, partly legendary, in three letters and two books of DIALOGUES. Whether or not the teaching on the Antichrist at the end of the first DIALOGUE goes back to the saint himself, its omission from later copies indicates that such views were popular enough to be considered dangerous by Church authorities in the later fifth century.”</em></p><p>[Exceprt from Supicius Severus’ DIALOGUES] <em>“When we asked him</em> [Martin of Tours] <em>about the End of the world, he told us that Nero and the Antichrist were to come first. Nero will rule in the western region after subduing the ten kings. He will conduct a persecution to compel worship of the pagan idols. Antichrist will first seize the Eastern empire and will have Jerusalem as the seat and capital of his kingdom. He will rebuild the city and the Temple. His persecution will be to compel denial that Christ is God rather setting himself up as the Anointed One. He will order all circumcized according to the Law. Then Nero himself will be destroyed by the Antichrist so that the whole world and all nations may be drawn under his power until that wicked one is destroyed by the coming of Christ. There is no doubt that Antichrist, conceived by an evil spirit, has already been born. He is now a child and will take on the empire when he comes of age. We heard all this from him </em>[Martin]<em> seven years ago. Ponder how close these coming fearful events are!”</em></p><p>It’s interesting that even in the early 400’s people were still expecting Nero to show up. It was believed that when Nero reportedly committed suicide in 68 A.D., that he was either not really dead, or was raised from the dead (or saved from death) like the Antichrist in Revelation. People watched for his return for a very long time, yet 300+ years seems a bit excessive, so perhaps Martin meant that Nero would come back in the same way that Enoch and Elijah would return. If that’s the case, then I have to take exception here: God has the power to return anyone He chooses to life, Satan does not.</p><p>There are also a number of details in Severus’ account that are not specifically from the Bible: the ruling of the ‘western region’ vs. the ‘eastern empire’, the rebuilding of Jerusalem and the temple, ordering universal circumcision, and the conception of the Antichrist by ‘an evil spirit’. These details are interesting because they hint at the things that worried the people of that time. Also, as to the temple, people today believe that the temple will be rebuilt based on Revelation mentioning that the Antichrist will stop the daily sacrifices: but it does not say explicitly that it will be rebuilt. Of all the things that Severus believed would happen, the temple being rebuilt is the most likely, but it’s still an interpretation.</p><p>We return to Mr. McGinn:</p><p>“Quintus Julius Hilarianus, an African bishop, composed two chronographical works in 397. One of these, THE PROGRESS OF TIME, shows a strong adhesion to the Hipplytan tradition and gives evidence of the strength of chiliasm at the end of the fourth century.”</p><p><em>[From THE PROGRESS OF TIME] “…There remain 101 years to complete the six thousand. The six thousand years will not be completed before the ten kings first go forth into the world near the End and remove from the midst of the world the daughter of Babylon who now stands firm. Immediately the One who has power over them will march against them; he is called the Dragon in Revelation. He will gain power over the ten kings — some he will destroy, others will remain under his control. ‘Then the impious one will be revealed, the Son of Perdition, who is lifted up against all that is called God or worshiped as God, so that sitting in the Temple he will show himself as though he were God’ (2 Thess. 2:8,4). This is the true Antichrist. The very powerful Dragon to whom the ten kings yielded will give over his power and might to him, and all men will be in awe of him. The times of the Antichrist will be necessarily deadly, like the times when Antiochus tried to make one people commit apostasy under his reign. The Antichrist will attempt to do what Antiochus could not, since he had not the time. When he comes, he will come for the destruction of the faithful. His time will be harsh and evil, ‘he whom the Lord Christ will slay with the breath of his mouth and destroy by his coming’ (2 These. 2:4).</em></p><p><em>“When the Antichrist has been overcome and killed at the completion of the six thousand years, the resurrection of all the saints will take place while the world still stands. . . .To the saints the resurrection will be one day, but this day of the saints will be prolonged so much that to the evil who will be living with pain in the world it will number a thousand years. This is the seventh day, the eternal and true Sabbath whose image and figure was that temporal Sabbath written in the Law of Moses, as was said to the Jews: ‘Six days do the works of the world, but on the seventh day which is called the Sabbath rest from your works’ (Exod. 23: 12). So when the six days, i.e., the six thousand years of labor and pain for the saints, have passed, the seventh day, the true Sabbath, will come for all of them who have existed from the beginning of the world… After the seven-thousandth year, Satan will be loosed from his prison and will go forth to seduce the nations of Gog and Magog. He will bring them together as if ready to fight at the Camp of the Saints. Fire will descend from heaven and all men will be consumed, and then will be the second resurrection for all flesh and all will be judged by the just judgment of God because they have not believed, but have done justice pleasing to themselves.”</em></p><p>The name <em>Hilarianus</em> is like a tickle to the brain, I love it. But I don’t love what he wrote. First of all, the world did not end in 498. Next, I’m not clear who he is referring to when he says “<em>the daughter</em> of Babylon.” I don’t think this term is used in Revelation; it comes from Isaiah 47:</p><p><strong>1“Come down and sit in the dust, virgin daughter of Babylon; sit on the ground without a throne, daughter of the Chaldeans! For you will no longer be called tender and delicate…3Your nakedness will be uncovered, your share will also be exposed; I will take vengeance and will not spare anyone.”…5”Sit silently, and go into darkness, daughter of the Chaldeans; for you will not longer be called the queen of kingdoms. (Isaiah 47:1,3,5; NASB)</strong></p><p>In Isaiah 47 it becomes pretty clear that he is talking about God’s wrath being poured out on the original Babylon, so again, it’s not clear who Hilarianus is referring to.</p><p>He goes on pretty well then for a short time, until he says: <em>“The Antichrist will attempt to do what Antiochus could not, since he had not the time.”</em> Antiochus Epiphanes was in power for 12 years, the Antichrist only gets 7. Time is not the advantage that Antichrist has over Antiochus. I would venture to guess that Antichrist’s advantages will be charm, charisma, wealth, technology, and the power of Satan. Antiochus was always running short on funds, and appears to have had very little charm…from BibleGateway:</p><p><em>“…he assumed the title Theos Epiphanes meaning ‘the manifest God’ but some of his enemies called him Epimanes (which requires only one letter change in the Greek spelling…) meaning ‘mad man’ or ‘insane’.”</em></p><p>The last paragraph of Hilarianus is very problematic. It states that Antichrist is ‘killed’; that’s not what happens in Revelation:</p><p><strong>15From His mouth comes a sharp sword, so that with it He may strike down the nations, and He will rule them with a rod of iron; and He treads the wine press of the fierce wrath of God, the Almighty.…20And the beast was seized, and with him the false prophet who performed the signs in his presence, by which he deceived those who had received the mark of the beast and those who worshiped his image; these two were thrown alive into the lake of fire, which burns with brimstone. (Revelation 19:15,20; NASB)</strong></p><p>The sharp sword was for smiting the nations. The beast was taken alive.</p><p>The remainder of the paragraph is based on six thousand years from Adam, with the millennium being the seventh thousand years. It fit together so nicely, too bad it wasn’t true (i.e., the world didn’t end in 498). Also, the statement: “<em>To the saints the resurrection will be one day, but this day of the saints will be prolonged so much that to the evil who will be living with pain in the world it will number a thousand years” </em>is not in sync with Revelation at all. Revelation is very clear that the millennium is reigned over by Jesus and the saints, and it has nothing to do with ‘the evil’ living in the world in pain. The last bit about Satan comes straight from Revelation.</p><p>That’s enough for today. We’ll continue on with the Middle Ages, but first, we’ll take a detour into the rabbit hole of Bible chronology and the schemes of the end times in the next two posts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8bcdee557f17" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE APOCALYPSE IN THE MIDDLE AGES]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kabogle/the-apocalypse-in-the-middle-ages-a31d4e1f2199?source=rss-b6b719c39d71------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a31d4e1f2199</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bernard-mcginn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[1-thessalonians]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-middle-ages]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apocalyptic-tradition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revelation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kabogle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Jun 2025 17:06:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-09T17:06:42.942Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rkwa53yM-J6-NHqpUnebxA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve been finding a number of pieces from the Middle Ages, both commentary-type pieces as well as writings that mention the Apocalypse. Most of these will be used when we go through Revelation line by line.</p><p>In looking at all these early Church Fathers I found the dating difficult to keep in my head, so I made a table with the dates. Here’s what I have so far:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/372/1*_XKbqNUxPUCnRtxWmmQ4Ew.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/372/1*r6Ve_-qrN2zuMJUnbsyBgg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/372/1*TNAp9df8wgJ1ykRd7frhoA.png" /></figure><p>We’ve seen some of these writers already, and most of the others will appear here at one time or another.</p><p>Today I want to start with a small amount of basic information about apocalyptic literature in general. This is from a book called VISIONS OF THE END: APOCALYPTIC TRADITIONS IN THE MIDDLE AGES by Bernard McGinn. It was published in 1979 (see source list), and my excerpts today are from the Introduction.</p><p><em>“Apocalyptic texts from various religious backgrounds and different ages display family resemblances in key areas that include: first, a sense of the unity and structure of history conceived as a divinely predetermined totality; second, pessimism about the present and conviction of its imminent crisis; and third, belief in the proximate judgment of evil and triumph of the good, the element of vindication. This vindication can take many forms — this-worldly or other-worldly, individual or collective, temporary or definitive, or a combination of some or all of these elements. I should not like to say that any of these areas is more central than another, and I admit that my election of them is that of a medievalist seeking to find sufficient continuity between the Jewish apocalypses and their later influence to allow us to speak of an apocalyptic tradition; but these three characteristics do seem to provide a way to conceive of the unity of the apocalypse tradition in all its changing variety.</em></p><p><em>“The problem of the unity of apocalyptic traditions becomes more complex when we reflect upon the relation of the earliest Christian apocalypticism to its Jewish heritage. Christianity was born apocalyptic and has remained so, not in the sense that apocalyptic hopes exhaust the meaning of Christian belief, but because they have never been absent from it…”</em></p><p>I wanted to include this information, not because I think it’s terribly important, but because this is how some people study Revelation. They do not think it has any meaning beyond “<em>pessimism about current times</em>” and feelings of “<em>imminent crisis</em>.” In other words, these apocalypses are the writings of more primitive peoples who sought to control their feelings of “<em>imminent crisis</em>’’ by writing pieces that indicate that history is a fore-gone conclusion and we, the ‘good guys’, always win in the end. In this sense, many, if not all religions are apocalyptic in origin, though most that have survived down through the ages have left apocalypticism behind. In fact, modern Christianity as currently practiced is mostly non-apocalyptic. Thus the idea that it’s only the early, more primitive peoples that believed that, as well as the more crazy of modern Christians. But, I will put it to you now: if people read Nostradamus and/or other psychics, believe in alien space ships coming to save us, avidly follow political pundits that believe as they do (and literally <em>hate</em> the ones believing opposite things), or read their horoscope, then those people have more than a little feelings of “<em>imminent crisis</em>” and apocalyptic ideas. Even in the placid 1950’s there was a feeling of “<em>imminent crisis</em>”.</p><p>The description of apocalyptic literature given by Mr. McGinn fits many modern movies and books, so as we go on, just bear that in mind. He continues:</p><p><em>“The Revelation of John is so closely tied to the meaning of the entire Christian apocalyptic tradition that any simple characterization is impossible. The book is at once a summary of preceding literature, an appropriation of the genre on a new level, and the point of departure for much subsequent commentary and expansion…”</em></p><p>Considering that Revelation is the only piece of self-identifying Christian apocalyptic literature in the Bible, it’s interesting that he speaks of “<em>Christian apocalyptic tradition</em>”, and “<em>appropriation of the genre</em>”(and we’ll see later that he and his ilk identify other New Testament pieces as “<em>apocalyptic</em>”). Obviously, he is including the Apocrypha in the “<em>tradition</em>.”</p><p>Earlier, he summarizes the debate about who wrote Revelation, and he also states that John was “<em>eschewing the traditional pseudonymity of apocalyptic writers</em>”, which implies that he believes that the author was John the Apostle, though he doesn’t say it. There were a number of apocalyptic writers in the early Christian era, and they all used the names of an apostle or other famous person as a pseudonym (they did not use the name of an unknown person). I’ve looked at a few of the apocryphal apocalypses and found them quite different in character from Revelation, and disagreeing with scripture quite a bit. As mentioned in the quote, the <em>“book is…a summary of preceding literature”</em>, meaning that it summarizes and agrees with preceding scripture. To me, that implies that the Revelation of Jesus Christ is not in the category that Mr. McGinn has so neatly laid out. The genre may have been “<em>appropriated</em>”, but it was done by Jesus, not John.</p><p>I have trouble with Mr. McGinn’s characterizations of Christianity as he doesn’t seem to have a deep understanding of it, especially for a Medievalist. The Church was a BIG player during the Middle Ages. To not understand it on a deeper level would imply that he would miss some of the deeper, more subtle meanings of the writings of that time. And make no mistake, the people of the Middle Ages were very subtle, intricate and detailed thinkers. They loved intrigue; their royal courts were full of intrigue and conspiracy. You can see the intricacy of writing even starting in the New Testament. That complexity continued through the Middle Ages, and probably deepened.</p><p>Here’s another quote from the Introduction that I want you to see because it tells a lot about Mr. McGinn’s view of Christianity:</p><p><em>“The earliest datable witness to Christianity that we possess, the First Epistle of Paul to the Thessalonians (probably A.D. 51), is not an apocalypse in form but contains apocalyptic teaching of importance in 4:13 to 5:11, showing how strong expectation of the End was in the first Christian communities. The specific literary form created by early Christianity, the Gospel, had intimate relations with apocalyptic, both in form and in content. Norman Perrin has shown how the earliest Gospel, that of Mark, occasioned by the crisis of the Jewish Wars and the fall of Jerusalem and written shortly after A.D. 70, is organized according to a three-act apocalyptic drama. The innovation of the first evangelist was to make use of realistic descriptions to convey his message.”</em></p><p>First of all, if the Gospels had “<em>intimate relations with apocalyptic</em>,” it was because the <em>story</em> of Jesus had the “<em>form</em>” of the apocalyptic: there was strife, He was killed, He won by returning from the dead. But in my humble opinion, to focus on the “<em>apocalyptic</em>” reduces the impact of the true message of the Gospels: that of salvation through the death and resurrection of Christ.</p><p>Of course the biggest problem with the above quote is the reporting of Mr. Perrin’s ideas as if they are settled fact. Again, there is the total avoidance of the idea that Jesus’ story is the reason for the “form” of the Gospel. But more importantly, for Mr. Perrin to suggest that Mark was written after the fall of Jerusalem, indicating a date of “shortly after A.D. 70” for the Gospel of Mark, means that he does not believe Jesus did, or could, prophecy that event. He’s suggesting that Mark added that prophecy after the fact.</p><p>So, briefly, this assumption of Mr. Perrin’s that the Gospel of Mark was written after A.D. 70 is based solely on his basic assumption that Jesus could not have prophesied the future. This makes Jesus out to be, at best, the foil in Mark’s story, or, at worst, a liar. All the other evidence points to Mark being written in the 50’s, just 20 years after Jesus’ resurrection. We will be looking at this in great detail at some point in the future.</p><p>One more comment on the above passage: regarding the last line “<em>The innovation of the first evangelist was to make use of realistic descriptions to convey his message.”</em> There are many Old Testament passages that include “<em>realistic descriptions</em>,” and the Gospels fit into those patterns pretty well. And, the message being conveyed was not Mark’s message, but Jesus’, or at least Peter’s. If you look at the evidence for the timing of the writing of Mark’s Gospel, you’ll see that Mark wrote Peter’s reminiscences of what Jesus said and did. To state that it was the “evangelist’s” message implies that it all was from Mark’s head and he wrote it to “evangelize” others. (Notice, I didn’t even mention that the Scriptures are God-breathed.)</p><p>Mr. McGinn continues:</p><p><em>“The Gospels are books of the nascent church. They can tell us much about the apocalyptic beliefs of the early Christians, and even perhaps about the apocalyptic elements in the preaching of Jesus. The most important apocalyptic text ascribed to Jesus by the synoptics is the so-called Little Apocalypse or Apocalyptic Discourse of Mark 13, Matthew 24–25, and Luke 21. The theory that a written source, specifically a brief Jewish apocalypse, lies behind Mark 13 and its parallels was first advanced in 1864. (Such a theory implies that the Little Apocalypse has nothing to do with the actual preaching of Jesus.) An extensive controversial literature has developed on the problem of the Little Apocalypse…”</em></p><p>He goes on to describe yet another theory that suggests that the Gospels were written to a “form” and were not reporting the words of Jesus. He ends the thought by admitting that<em> “there is at present a strong tendency among many Scripture scholars to minimize the extent of apocalyptic influence detectable in what they hold to be the probably authentic fragments of the preaching of Jesus contained in the Gospels.”</em> He footnoted this line, so the implication is that he didn’t think of it himself, but he agrees with it. And I have to admit, the words “<em>probably authentic fragments</em>” really irk me.</p><p>This excursion into secular research regarding the Revelation has been interesting and informative. It makes me really appreciate the commentaries written by men (and a few women) of God. It also points out how difficult it is to have a meaningful understanding of Scripture without admitting the underlying beliefs, such as Jesus was the Christ, the Son of God. As I came to Christianity late in life, I can remember when I read the Bible cover to cover as a non-believer, and could understand only the basic things, like the resurrection, as being important. It all read like a history to me (or perhaps like an “apocalypse” for Mr. McGinn), with the deeper meanings totally missing. After accepting Christ into my life I was amazed at how differently the Bible read.</p><p>I will be reading further to see if there is anything more we want to say about the Middle Ages before we dive into the Renaissance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a31d4e1f2199" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>