<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Karah Sutton on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Karah Sutton on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:16:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social media for traditionally published authors]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/social-media-for-traditionally-published-authors-9844334e5e8e?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9844334e5e8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karah Sutton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Sep 2023 00:37:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-06T00:37:39.352Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AemJi21swaUcyBAKJLjj2g.jpeg" /><figcaption>[An image of a phone screen showing social media icons. Visible are Facebook, Instagram, Quora, Pinterest, Twitter, and Snapchat. They all have notification icons.]</figcaption></figure><p>Please find the <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/marketing-your-debut-novel-a-multi-part-guide-from-someone-with-a-decades-marketing-experience-453ff3267955">intro of this series on Marketing for Authors</a> here.</p><p>The social media landscape has changed a lot in recent years. Twitter is now X. Authors left X in droves. Hive became a thing. Mastodon became a thing. Threads became a thing. Bluesky became a thing. And TikTok definitely became a thing.</p><p>Social media is one of those areas that authors feel tremendous pressure about. As publishers have downsized, authors feel an increasing expectation to undertake their own marketing. And more often than not, the outcome of this is authors posting a lot on social media.</p><p>This can feel a little like shouting into a void. The pressure to create content and amass followers, then the disappointment that inevitably follows when a social media post doesn’t result in dozens of books sold, is a topic frequently raised in author groups.</p><p>In order to help navigate this social sea, I’ve written out some questions I’d like you to consider.</p><p><em>[I’ll caveat this by saying that, if you look at my own author social profiles, you will be unimpressed. I personally don’t do a great job at following my own advice. But I’m qualified to give that advice because I’ve been working in social media in the entertainment industry for 10 years, and in that time I’ve learned a lot of things from people smarter than me. Now, on to the questions!]</em></p><ol><li><strong>Who are you speaking to?</strong></li></ol><p>This is a question with a lot of different answers, so I’m not here to tell you the “right way.” But I do want you to think about different approaches, and what their effects might be.</p><p>On Twitter, I see a lot of authors following other authors. This is great, but it isn’t the only way to use social media. Are you also following librarians? Booksellers? Teachers? If you’re following influencers, are you only following those with huge followings, or are you following people with smaller followings but who are more likely to interact with you directly? Are you looking for crumbs of validation from people you admire, or are you forming actual meaningful relationships?</p><p>Ask yourself: “who are the people most likely to buy my books?” The real answer is: people who care about me, who like what I do, and who want to support me. Is that other authors? Very possibly, yes. But there are others who are ready to become your fan, if you engage with them.</p><p><strong>2. How often do you engage with other people’s content?</strong></p><p>Are you commenting on other people’s posts, or are you mostly posting yourself? And when you comment, are you doing so in a way that actually forges relationships? Are you interacting with others in ways that offers something in addition to requesting something?</p><p>Be generous with people (not with money, but with your care and attention). Think of your followers like your family and friends — they’re the ones who are likely to actually buy your book when you ask it. But don’t be the friend who only ever talks about themself, be the friend who gives as well as takes. Find the people most likely to act like your exuberant aunt who comments all over Facebook about your book. Then show that person that you’re interested in what they have to say.</p><p><strong>3. What is your goal?</strong></p><p>You’re probably rolling your eyes right now. “My goal is to sell books!”</p><p><em>Is it?</em></p><p>Because a lot of the content I see authors make is at odds with this goal. If you aren’t speaking to people who are likely to buy your book, if you aren’t forming relationships with them, you aren’t likely to sell books (except on TikTok — more on that in a minute). People might follow you because they like your pretty photos, or they enjoy your sassy takes, but that doesn’t mean they will resonate with your fiction.</p><p>Here’s your real goal: to build a community. By building a community, you will reap so much more than just books sold. You’ll gain people’s support in a variety of ways, whether they’re requesting your library purchase a copy of your book, or leaving reviews on Amazon, or just being an ear to listen to your triumphs and frustrations.</p><p><strong>4. What platforms are you on?</strong></p><p>Here’s my obligatory reminder that you don’t need to be on every platform. Save your sanity. Preserve that time for actually writing books.</p><p>So what platforms should you choose? The answer is based on two things: the kinds of content you enjoy making, and where your readers are.</p><p>TikTok is particularly great for romance and YA/Adult fantasy. There are people who manage to make picture books work, but the audience for picture books on TikTok is not as ravenous as BookTok. TikTok is the rare social media platform that is less about building community and more about being the right type of book for the audience, with the right kind of hook. To be honest, TikTok also evolves so rapidly that I’m reluctant to offer any more advice on it (it’s possible my information above is already out of date). If you’re interested in TikTok, <a href="https://www.facebook.com/groups/4984960078203132">seek out groups</a> where you can learn from those having success with it. They’re generous with their time.</p><p>It’s possible that the communities you are speaking to use a number of different platforms, so that’s where your content comes in. Photos and videos will lead you toward TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube. Writing will lead you toward Reddit or one of the Twitter replacements, or — hear me out — writing a newsletter. Yes, I consider having a newsletter as part of your social media strategy. Because a newsletter follows the same principles of working to build a community, and working to give as much as you take. Bet you weren’t expecting that one! (Also: podcasts fit in this category too, by the way).</p><p>Go where you are naturally inclined to go, and make what you are naturally inclined to make. If it becomes too much of a chore, you won’t invest the time needed to actually make the most out of the platform. It’ll be hard work regardless, but hopefully you’ll dread it less.</p><p><strong>In conclusion. . .</strong></p><p>All of the above means something that’s very important, something I hope you’ll remember even if you forget everything else: <em>it is better to have a small but passionate following than a large but disengaged following</em>. So don’t feel pressured about follower numbers — those won’t stop a publisher from buying your book. Form communities. And remember that those communities want to read your books.</p><p>If you find any of this useful, please consider sharing, or check out my books <a href="https://bookshop.org/search?keywords=karah+sutton"><em>A Wolf for a Spell </em>and <em>The Song of the Swan</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9844334e5e8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Amazon Ads for Traditionally Published Authors]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/amazon-ads-for-traditionally-published-authors-5a933d75e547?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a933d75e547</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[advertising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[amazon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books-and-authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing-industry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karah Sutton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Oct 2022 00:48:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-06T00:42:20.588Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Back when I first started experimenting with running online ads for my book, Amazon did not allow traditionally published authors to run ads on their platform.</p><p>This made running digital ads very ill-advised for traditionally published authors (you can <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/facebook-and-google-ads-for-authors-10f52e0624b2">read more about why I thought so here</a>). TLDR on why: you shouldn’t run ads unless you can see dollar for dollar what you’re earning from what you’re spending. Because Facebook/Instagram/Google don’t have purchase information, you’re stuck with sending people towards a purchase page and hoping for the best, totally in the dark as to whether you’ve made an impact or are just throwing money down a hole (unless you set up your own e-shop, which is a whole other thing). You are paying for people to click on the ad, but those people might or might not buy your book.</p><p>Well now, Amazon has opened up ads to traditionally published authors. And it… changes things…</p><p><strong>First let’s talk about advertising strategy</strong></p><p>(I recommend you read my <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/facebook-and-google-ads-for-authors-10f52e0624b2">previous article on digital ads</a> for a more thorough breakdown of how online advertising works.)</p><p>I’ve been in digital marketing for 10 years. And the thing that is important to understand about how companies run ads is understanding the idea of Return on Ad Spend (ROAS). You spend $100 so that you get $100. You do not spend $100 to get $50. You aim to tweak and improve your ads so that your ROAS is 100%: you are earning back every dollar you spend.</p><p>Before, a traditionally published author couldn’t see revenue resulting from ad spend, making calculating this ROAS impossible. With Amazon, you can now see that revenue data. And this is very powerful.</p><p><strong>Let’s look at a campaign I ran</strong></p><p>My book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0593121651"><em>A Wolf for a Spell</em></a> has wolves and witches in it. Since it’s October, I decided to run some campaigns. I made an <a href="https://author.amazon.com/">author account</a> and claimed my book, and then navigated to the Ads Console from the Marketing section.</p><ul><li>I selected a Sponsored Product campaign type</li><li>I chose both my hardcover and my paperback as the sponsored products. (If you only have hardcover because you’re wanting to run ads for your publication day, this is actually fine. Because hardcovers have a higher price, they’re actually better for running ads because you earn more revenue)</li><li>I chose Automatic Targeting (I have done Manual Targeting as well in past experiments, and to be honest I don’t recommend it because it’s inefficient, requires skill to perfect, and gets expensive)</li><li>I set a default bid of somewhere between $0.30-$0.55 (I messed around with this a bit as I went along). The general rule of thumb is the higher the bid, the more likely your ad will be seen in prominent places, but with the obvious repercussion of having spent more money. You’re looking for a balance of keeping the bid low enough to keep campaigns profitable, but high enough to actually be seen. The range above seems to hit that balance for me.</li><li>The only negative keyword I put is the name of my own book. Basically negative keywords are a chance to list types of searches where your ad might show but you don’t want it to. One reason you do this is to avoid having to pay for clicks made by a person who is unlikely to purchase your book. Maybe they’ve searched for graphic novels, see my book listed so they think my book is a graphic novel, so they click on the product page, explore further, realize it’s not a graphic novel, and leave. Now I’ve paid for a click from a person who was looking for a book that is totally different from my book. The reason I include my book name as a negative keyword is related, but different: I want to avoid paying for a click for someone who was specifically looking for my book and was likely to purchase anyway. There are ways in the dashboard to find out what searches are leading to clicks but not purchases, so ideally you start your campaign with limited Negative Keywords and then add them over time as your campaigns gather data. I also left negative product targeting blank.</li><li>I left it on Dynamic Bids for simplicity.</li><li>Here’s the text I used:</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yDvkUF333q7MUOYP" /></figure><p>Results:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*G0NXRaCg1_5Kpf1Y" /></figure><p>What does it all mean?</p><ul><li>For spending $200, I sold $460 worth of books, or 44 books in total. I actually consider this a good result, when I think of all the ways I might spend $200 (on a social media or blog tour, on a Goodreads giveaway, printing bookmarks, or traveling to a conference) and would probably sell fewer books.</li><li>0.83% CTR (the number of people who saw my ad and then clicked on it) is quite good. Advice I can find online says anything below 0.3% is poor, anything above 0.5% is good. Some of the CTR is going to be outside my control (it’ll be hugely affected by my cover and my title), but I can play with the text to try to improve it. I had other text that had lower CTRs, so this text was effective for me.</li><li>This result does <em>not</em> warrant me spending money to run ads all the time. I haven’t earned out my advance, so any money I spend is money that will take years (if ever) to show up in my bank account as money earned. If I were earning royalties, this is still running unprofitably, because I’m only earning 10% of that revenue from my publisher, so I’m actually spending $200 to earn $46 (not good enough).</li><li>My conclusion is that, if there’s a period of time where I’d like to give my book an extra push and have some money to do it, then this is an effective option. Since my book is autumnal/wintery and has witches and snow, I’ll likely do a yearly cadence of running ads in October or November and that’s it.</li></ul><p><strong><em>Your results may vary!</em></strong> As always, do not ever spend money on ads that you aren’t prepared to lose entirely. Your book’s cover, title, topic, genre will all affect how many people click on your ads or purchase your book. It won’t be a great option for every book type.</p><p><strong>Update November 2022:</strong></p><p>I ran another month’s worth of campaigns, using different text. Have a look and see what an immense difference an identical campaign set-up but with different text can have!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/1*4d6U2IHbukl0nHagQsEndg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V_dm_fmNFcsz70KRx2UcmA.png" /></figure><p><em>[Note that I played around with increasing and decreasing the daily budget, which is why there’s that spike in spending on Nov 20, and why there’s no spend on 23–24 Nov.]</em></p><p>My observations on the above:</p><ul><li>You’ll notice the impressions are much lower for virtually the same spend. This is because the click-through rate (the percentage of people who saw the ad and clicked on it) was so much higher. I capped my daily budget at $8, so if I dug further into the data you would see the same number of clicks per day.</li><li>The CTR in this set-up was actually so high that I was burning through my daily budget in a matter of hours. If I had more funds that I could spend on ads (and if the revenue were in my favor), I could have increased the budget to probably $50 a day and the ads would still be earning much more than that spend.</li></ul><p>This brings me to . . .</p><p><strong>My plea to traditional publishers:</strong></p><p>I am sending this into the void in the hopes that someone might see it. I know that you have too few marketing people for a backlist of hundreds of thousands of books, and that you need to prioritise. And prioritising means running ads for only your frontlist. New releases, big name authors. I’ve looked at your Facebook ads library; I’ve seen which books you’re running ads for. And I get it. There just isn’t enough time in the day. And also Amazon isn’t your favorite company to work with.</p><p>But my experiment above shows that running ads for backlist books is not a silly idea. I don’t know all your costs, so I can’t say whether the campaign above would be profitable for you. But with improvements, it could be cost neutral, or even marginally profitable. And when you factor in word-of-mouth… I don’t know. Maybe. It’s certainly more profitable for you than it is for me, since it’s money in your pocket, and marketing is a big part of what you do.</p><p>There are millions of e-commerce companies running billions of ads. And traditional publishing seems to run remarkably few digital ads for the size of the industry. This feels like something that could benefit from more investment, and who knows, it might result in some of those midlist titles breaking through.</p><p>The next article in this series on marketing for authors is on social media. You can <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/social-media-for-traditionally-published-authors-9844334e5e8e">read that here</a>.</p><p>If you find any of this useful, please consider sharing, or check out my book <a href="https://bookshop.org/search?keywords=karah+sutton"><em>A Wolf for a Spell</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a933d75e547" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Facebook and Google Ads for Authors]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/facebook-and-google-ads-for-authors-10f52e0624b2?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10f52e0624b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[advertising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karah Sutton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Nov 2021 05:10:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-24T01:28:38.694Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Please find the <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/marketing-your-debut-novel-a-multi-part-guide-from-someone-with-a-decades-marketing-experience-453ff3267955">intro of this series on Marketing for Authors</a> here.</p><p>Whenever I mention that I work in Marketing to an author, usually the first question I’m asked is “how do I run ads for my book?”</p><p>I am happy to give advice on setting these up, because I know that’s the answer to the question they’ve asked. But there’s an unasked question, one that I try to answer as well by providing as much context and information around the world of digital advertising as I can.</p><p>That question is: <em>Should</em> I run ads for my book?</p><p>The answer, if you’re a traditionally published author, is very like <em>No</em>. No, you should not. (Update Oct 2022: I’ve changed my answer to “Maybe”. You can read more on why <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/amazon-ads-for-traditionally-published-authors-5a933d75e547">here</a>)</p><p>To understand why, let’s start with how online advertising works and the strategies employed by companies that use it successfully, then we should think of that in the context of being an author who receives a royalty via a publishing contract.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*XjTywC5yMhCxVvjlkxd2yg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>How does digital advertising work?</strong></p><p>The benefit of digital advertising is that you can see direct causation. I ran an ad, I can see the number of clicks it got, and then the number of purchases that occurred as a result. This is something that TV and radio ads always tried to achieve (quote “SALE2021 when you purchase today!”), but digital ads mastered. It means that people can see exactly how much money they earned for the amount that they spent.</p><p>Facebook and Google then take that purchase data, analyse aggregated metrics about the people who purchased (what other things have they expressed an interest in? Do they follow any similar pages or click on other ads?), then update the targeting of the campaign based on those similarities. This means the longer a campaign runs and the more people who purchase, the more it learns how to show ads only to the people who are most likely to find your ad of interest. This is what it means when you hear the phrase “Interest-Based Targeting”.</p><p>[Something I’m not going to delve into in-depth in this post is the ethics around said interest-based targeted ads. This is another reason why I caution people away from digital ads, because there is so much legislation, policy, and personal comfort levels at play here that it becomes extremely complex. The short answer is that there are ways to do this ethically, and there are ways to do this unethically. Interest-based targeting, when done anonymously, in aggregate, targeting adults who have given permission, can be done ethically. For the most part, following the prompts in the advertising dashboard will help you from straying into running ads in a problematic way, because more parameters and regulations have been put in place in recent years. In the end you have to decide for yourself whether you’re comfortable with using advertising platforms that have been used for unethical behaviours. This paragraph has been edited based on feedback in the hopes of making it clearer to read.]</p><p>The thing is though: when you’re traditionally published, the ads don’t work that way, because you don’t get purchase data. You can see clicks, but unless you are selling the book yourself, you have no way of seeing whether your ad successfully led to someone purchasing a book. So already you are working with less data, and the campaigns themselves are unable to optimise. I could optimise my campaign to get more clicks by using some click-bait headline, but that doesn’t mean people will purchase. Or maybe it does? Who knows, without the ability to see that?</p><p><strong>Imagine a company that is successfully running digital ads…</strong></p><p>A company that is successfully running digital ads will have a budget purely for running those ads. Let’s say this budget is $10,000 per month (sorry, I know you probably just fainted. Bear with me, as it’s easier to explain things using larger numbers).</p><p>For that $10,000 per month, we will get a certain number of impressions. Meaning, the number of times your ad is seen (<em>not</em> the number of people who have seen it!). A percentage of those impressions turn into clicks, and then a percentage of those clicks turn into purchases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*o4zkwYw4yfHdMWsO6T9QAA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>NUMBERS STUFF</strong></p><p><strong><em>For those who get overwhelmed by numbers, jargon, and formulas, feel free to skip this section.</em></strong></p><p>The number of impressions you get for your $10,000 monthly spend is calculated based on what’s called an eCPM (estimated cost per mille). An average eCPM might be $10 for 1000 impressions. This means for your $10K per month, you are getting 1,000,000 impressions per month based on this formula:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/227/0*q-s2VxgKzn_mqJmK" /></figure><p>A million impressions sounds great, right?</p><p>Not so fast.</p><p>Because the percentage of people who click on that ad <a href="https://www.wordstream.com/blog/ws/2017/02/28/facebook-advertising-benchmarks">is around 1%</a>. This is known as a Click Through Rate, or CTR. Now your 1,000,000 impressions has become 10,000 clicks.</p><p>Still sounds pretty good though! Surely people wouldn’t click on an ad unless they intend to buy the book. If those 10,000 people each spend $10 on a book, that’s $100,000 on a $10,000 investment. Amazing! No wonder everyone’s talking about running ads!</p><p>Except that your click to purchase rate is <a href="https://www.smartinsights.com/ecommerce/ecommerce-analytics/ecommerce-conversion-rates/">also around 1%</a>.</p><p>In this scenario, that is 100 books. Multiply that by the $10 purchase price, and you’ve now earned $1000 when you’ve spent $10,000.</p><p>Except… you haven’t actually earned $1000. If you’re a traditionally published author, you’ve only earned a 10% royalty on that $1000, meaning you’ve earned $100 for the $10,000 you spent.</p><p><strong><em>Hang on. This all sounds very gloom and doom. If the numbers were this bad, no one would ever run ads!</em></strong></p><p>You’re right! I’ll admit, I did tweak the numbers to keep the percentages clean (1% instead of 1.5%, for example, or a $10 eCPM instead of a $4.50 eCPM). If you mush those numbers around, you will find variations where they work out. Those numbers are averages only.</p><p>Here are some reasons why people are able to run ads profitably:</p><ol><li>They earn the majority of the revenue. This is where self-published authors can find success running ads, because they’re earning a higher percentage than a 10% royalty.</li><li>Their click rates are much higher than average, due to especially appealing images/videos and good audience targeting. This is where having an appealing cover becomes incredibly valuable.</li><li>Their click to purchase rate is above average. Maybe the book is on sale for a limited time and the person feels compelled to purchase right away. Maybe the topic of the book is trendy. Maybe it just has a great hook. [This part can be difficult to shift, and would be almost impossible for someone traditionally published as it will depend a lot on things determined by the publisher such as the description, the review quotes, and the cover].</li><li>Their campaigns optimise better due to more data. If the campaigns can track the % of purchasers, they can target more effectively and that 1% purchase rate might shoot up to more like 10%.</li><li>They have greater volume, which means… even more data. Some companies will spend upwards of $100,000, even $1,000,000 on ads <strong>per month</strong>. More volume means the algorithms are optimising based on 10,000 purchases instead of 100. The ads are less likely to find patterns that might make the campaigns do weird things. 4 people in that group of 100 loving welding is much easier for a computer to assume a pattern than 4 people in a group of 10,000. By spending more, campaigns get more data and the campaigns don’t suddenly start accidentally targeting welders for your unicorn picture book. [NOTE: I am <strong>not</strong> saying you should spend thousands of dollars on ads. I’m just using this example to illustrate how those ad platforms interpret data]</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/0*FpW6ylaPRbeWL4Xz.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>END OF NUMBERS STUFF</strong></p><p>The summary of all of the above is that when you combine earning a royalty percentage of a sale, not being able to see purchase data, and running on smaller budgets, it is impossible for your advertising campaign to earn you back what you’ve spent on it.</p><p>This is a problem, because “breaking even” is how these tools are built to run. A company selling t-shirts isn’t just pouring $10,000 per month into ads for the fun of it. They will have $10,000 set aside every month, and then optimise those ads to earn back $10,000 every month.</p><p><em>But why only earn back $10,000? Shouldn’t they want to earn back more? Where is the profit?</em></p><p>Well, yes. Ideally. But the reason it’s done this way is that more copies sold benefits word of mouth. So there’s an assumption that if you get 10,000 tracked sales, you might see another 1000 that aren’t tracked from your campaigns. And those 1000 are your profit. So instead of spending $8000 and earning $9000, they decide that it’s better to continue investing that additional money into ads because it results in more sales and profit in the long run. For those companies it’s better to keep the volume higher, as it works out better for them. This is, of course, out of reach for a single self-employed author trying to earn a living.</p><p>In the end though, whether spending $20 per month or $1,000 per month, the point is that as a traditionally published author you are not going to earn your money back.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/430/0*pxpR0sbtwijqrWRP.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>I get it. Don’t run ads. What if I still want to run ads anyway?</strong></p><p>If the above didn’t deter you, that’s fine. I’ve actually run ads for my own book. I wrote out all the above so that you are going into this with your eyes open. But don’t say I didn’t warn you, and don’t try to lay at my feet that you didn’t earn back the money you poured into ads. Proceed at your own risk.</p><p>One final thing I would like to mention is that these websites and dashboards are constantly changing (like, seriously, one of the challenges of the digital advertising industry is that just when you get used to doing something a certain way it changes completely). For that reason I’ve kept my guidance below slightly more general, rather than giving specific step-by-step instructions with screenshots. If that causes challenges, please leave a comment and I can try to update this to make the information more useful.</p><p>Here are some key things to know and think about:</p><ol><li>If you know you’re going to lose money, then strategize and budget accordingly. Don’t plunge $500 into this that you can’t afford to lose entirely.</li><li>Keep the steps that it requires for someone to buy your book as minimal as possible. Don’t send them to your author home page where they then need to scroll around or navigate to find your book, then they have to click through to a different site before they’re able to purchase. Send them somewhere that enables them to purchase directly and immediately, like your <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/a-wolf-for-a-spell/9780593121658">Bookshop.org</a> product page. The harder you make it for people to figure out what to do next, the more likely it is that they’ll just close the page and leave.</li><li>Keep in mind that the percentages I mention above (click through rate and purchase/conversion rate) mean that spending $100 on ads likely means you won’t see a single purchase, or if you do it will be limited to 1 or 2, which is very difficult to measure. What this means is you should run ads without any expectation of observable results. Any sales that come from ads will be indistinguishable from your usual sales.</li><li>Consider where your audience congregates. If you’re writing for a 20-something audience, choose a social media platform that is used by 20-something people. If you write books for children though, your audience is actually their parents and grandparents, so keep that in mind. <strong>Do not target ads at people under 18</strong>. This isn’t just an ethics thing, it’s a keeping-you-out-of-a-legal-quagmire thing.</li><li>As of 2021, Amazon doesn’t let traditionally published authors run ads (I still find this a baffling choice on their part, but whatever)[Update Dec 2022: You can now run ads via Amazon if you’re a traditionally published author. Read about my experience <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/amazon-ads-for-traditionally-published-authors-5a933d75e547">here</a>]. Facebook and Google, for worse or for worse, are the kings of this industry and tend to have the best results. Instagram ads are run via Facebook. As of 2021, TikTok only lets you run ads if you’re a registered business, and being self-employed isn’t sufficient (I tried). Pinterest ads have an interesting benefit in that the images from the ads remain on the website even after you turn the ads off (they just don’t get promoted). So you might see a residual click here and there months after you’ve stopped spending money.</li><li>On Facebook, videos do better than static images. The carousel of images does better than a single image.</li><li>Keep text very short and to-the-point. People spend a fraction of a second skimming past an ad; they are not going to read a giant wall of text. Research <a href="https://www.facebook.com/business/news/ad-copy-cheat-sheet">how to write effective ad copy</a>. (Summary: keep it short and have a single clear call-to-action like “Buy now!”)</li></ol><p><strong>Setting up ads on Google</strong></p><p>Running ads on Google is simple compared to Facebook because it’s more straightforward to set up and you have less granularity in what you can target and tweak, so I usually recommend this as a starting place.</p><ul><li>Go to <a href="https://ads.google.com/">ads.google.com</a>, go through any sign-up stuff that you need to do until you get to the point where you can click “Create New Campaign”.</li><li>Select that you want to direct people to a website since you most likely aren’t wanting to direct people to a physical location or get phone calls.</li><li>The website you direct them to should be a store page where people can purchase your book directly, like your <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/a-wolf-for-a-spell/9780593121658">Bookshop.org</a> product page.</li><li>From here you can write your copy, which you want to keep short and clear. Practice flicking your eyes over the words for a fraction of a second to gauge how difficult it might be for someone to absorb what you’ve written.</li><li>Images are super important and have a huge impact, so make sure you upload some! Use websites like Canva and BookBrush, which have attractive templates that you can use.</li><li>The main targeting that Google offers is keywords. This can get tricky, knowing what to select, so I recommend experimenting and seeing what makes your click-through rates go up or down. By tweaking my keywords and also my text and images, I managed to increase my click-through rate from 1% to 4%.</li><li>Think about what it is that people might be searching for and try to address that in your keywords and your copy. Maybe they’re looking for “Best books with dragons” or “Books about mountain climbing”. Maybe it’s “Books with boy characters” or “Queer fairy tale retellings”. Put yourself in the shoes of a person who is looking for the exact type of book that you’ve written.</li><li>If your book might have more appeal in a certain region, consider restricting the ads to show only in that region.</li></ul><p><strong>Setting up ads on Facebook:</strong></p><ul><li>You will need <a href="https://www.facebook.com/pages/create">a Page</a> (not a Profile) to run the ads. Consider whether you want that page to be your author name or a more generalised brand around books. Think about what would prompt you to click on an ad, and what image you’re comfortable having show up in random people’s news feeds. Don’t pretend to be someone you’re not.</li><li>Choose your campaign type. Things like “awareness” are going to maximise views/impressions based on your budget, but this means you might see reduced click through rates. Things like Conversions aren’t an option unless you are sending them to your own store. “Traffic” optimises towards a Click, so this is what I usually do.</li><li>You can click through the part where it tells you to name the Ad Set and stuff and edit this later. The name doesn’t matter too much — it’s more so that people who run lots of campaigns can keep things organised.</li><li>A/B test means that Facebook will show two different images that you upload to a portion of the audience and then tell you which image results in more people clicking. You can do this with your ad copy/text also.</li><li>The Ad Set is where you define your audience, ie: the list of people who will see your ads. If you have an audience already, via newsletter subscribers, content that has had a lot of engagement, a page that people follow, or an Instagram, Facebook can create an audience that resembles those people if you click “Create new” in the “Custom Audiences” section and then click “Lookalike Audience”. Note that you will not be able to see any personal info about the people Facebook finds to include in your new audience. If you don’t have those things, you can target your ad based on certain interests under the “Detailed Targeting” section. You can select people within a certain age range, people who like a movie that is comparable to your book, and people who are frequent online shoppers. Browse through and select anything that seems relevant. Again, you won’t be able to see any specific information around who the people are who will be seeing your ads.</li><li>Since you are presumably working with a limited budget, keep an eye on the Audience Definition gauge at the top, and try to keep it leaning towards “Specific” rather than “Broad”.</li></ul><p>Once you have set your ads live, keep an eye on them in the coming days. Running ads is all about experimentation, so try different images, different text, and different audiences. Try to tailor the images/text to the audience that you’ve selected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/395/0*EIEuG4V9h1KdpbG6.png" /></figure><p><strong>To wrap up…</strong></p><p>Marketing yourself as an author is challenging and often scary. Digital ads provide a certain level of comfort, because they don’t require you to pitch or email strangers or beg people to follow you. Despite all their complexities, there’s something straightforward about turning on a campaign and watching numbers tick up.</p><p>But running ads is still a complex beast that is constantly evolving, and as I’ve outlined above, with limited odds of you being able to measure any increase in sales from running them. But if this is an experiment that you are interested in trying, I hope the advice above is helpful.</p><p>Best of luck!</p><p>Read my follow-up article on running ads on Amazon <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/amazon-ads-for-traditionally-published-authors-5a933d75e547">here</a>.</p><p>Please <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton">follow on Medium</a> or <a href="https://twitter.com/Karahdactyl">on Twitter</a> to be notified when I post new articles.</p><p>If you find any of this useful, please consider sharing, or check out my book <a href="https://bookshop.org/search?keywords=karah+sutton"><em>A Wolf for a Spell</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10f52e0624b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marketing your debut novel: A multi-part guide from someone with a decade’s marketing experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/marketing-your-debut-novel-a-multi-part-guide-from-someone-with-a-decades-marketing-experience-453ff3267955?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/453ff3267955</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-employed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karah Sutton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Nov 2021 04:55:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-03T05:12:19.823Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*ZVqzmzGfLe6iPh-ewwOb0w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I remember receiving that fated phone call from my agent. I happened to take the day off work and woke to the phone ringing. I wasn’t supposed to hear from her for another week at least; we had made arrangements that we would have check-ins every two weeks while the manuscript was on submission to publishers.</p><p>But that morning, more than a week before our scheduled check in, she called to say that a publisher had offered to publish my book, the book that would become <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/a-wolf-for-a-spell/9780593121658"><em>A Wolf for a Spell</em></a>.</p><p>I burst into tears.</p><p>In the months that followed I went through the intense revision process that all debut authors go through: developmental edits, line edits, copy edits, pass pages. . .</p><p>Throughout all of this, lurking in the back of my mind, were thoughts about the book’s marketing. Not because I didn’t trust my publisher, but because as someone with nearly a decade’s experience in marketing, I was excited to see what the future held.</p><p>Typically, marketing is one of the reasons why an author chooses to pursue traditional publishing (having a publisher print and distribute the book and then give the author a royalty) versus self-publishing. In self-publishing, an author gets ultimate control over the book as a final product, including the cover, the price point, any illustrations, the font and formatting, even the title — all things that can and do get changed by publishers in the interest of selling more books (though hopefully in consultation with the author). With this freedom also comes the pressure of selling books. The marketing, press, store and library outreach, awards applications, all of it falls on the shoulders of a self-published author.</p><p>This gets especially tricky for authors of children’s books, like myself. Schools and children’s librarians are often hesitant to purchase self-published children’s books, using the publisher’s brand and reputation as a way of vetting books for quality. Given how busy teachers and librarians are, this is understandable, even if the unfortunate result is that some excellent self-published books are overlooked.</p><p>For me, this meant that my goal was to be traditionally published, even as someone who loves marketing and would happily do the work of marketing my own book.</p><p>Whoops, I did a bunch of marketing experiments anyway!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r641xB26nQ7jltBcrmsfGw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the months leading up to my publication day and the year since, I have built up a list of things that I’ve tried. Some failed tests, some never intended to be more than experiments. I wanted to begin noting down what I’d done in preparation for my second book. Since I’m noting down all of this anyway, I’d like to share it with other authors, in case there’s anything useful.</p><p>Before we begin, a few caveats:</p><ul><li>First, I am a middle grade author, so much of my experience is focused on books for children. There will be more relevance for picture book and young adult authors than adult, perhaps, though I tried to call out things that I think are relevant for authors of all age groups.</li><li>Second. As mentioned, I was traditionally published, so some of this advice is probably less relevant to self-published authors. I have a lot of admiration for what self-published authors are able to do in marketing for their books, and I’ll admit that my advice probably falls far short of the incredible advice that already exists for self-publishing.</li><li>Third, in listing all of these things I am in no way saying that you <em>should</em> do all of them. In fact, I think that is probably impossible. Most authors are juggling writing as well as full-time jobs and family obligations. Trying to be a full-time marketer on top of that is not a good use of your time. You are better off writing more books, which earns you more money and also markets your back-catalogue of already-published work. My hope though is I might be able to help you prioritize, and decide which things you feel more able to succeed at doing.</li><li>Finally, while I am someone with a lot of marketing experience, I can’t say that my own marketing for my books is flawless. I know there are many areas in which my own marketing and my past marketing elsewhere in the entertainment industry could have been improved, but my experience does make me more aware of industry best practices and norms so I feel comfortable speaking to many of these things, even if they are things that I personally am not very good at.</li></ul><p>There is enough content here that I think it should be spread across multiple articles so I will theme each article over a subset of activities, which are usually considered as part of a marketing plan. These are:</p><ul><li>Advertising: This can include both traditional advertising (newspapers, billboards, the side of a bus), but most people who ask me questions about advertising are usually referring to digital advertising (running ads on Facebook, Google, and elsewhere). I’ll go into more depth as to why I think traditional authors <em>should not </em>run digital ads, but I will also give some tips on how to do it if it’s something you want to experiment with.</li><li>Social media: We all have heard the phrase “building a platform.” I’ll talk more about different channels, how their audiences differ, and why it’s better to have an excellent presence on one platform than a mediocre one on several. Once you think about the reasons behind building a social media presence, it might also have you rethink things that feel very different but actually serve a similar purpose, such as email newsletters and podcasts.</li><li>Press: If you’re traditionally published, you will hopefully have a publicist. But it’s still super valuable to understand how pitching works and what materials are useful to have in your back pocket, and why you will get a lot further if you do the research into the publications you’re pitching to and the kinds of content they like (what does that remind you of? Oh, that’s right, it’s a lot like querying). I tend to include influencers in this group because the processes are pretty similar.</li><li>Sales: I’ll be honest, this is the area that I don’t really cover in my day job, so it’s more of a mystery to me than the others. But what I basically mean by this for individual authors (instead of a Sales Department) is the work a lot of authors consider the hardest and most terrifying, which is speaking to individuals and asking them (or convincing them) to buy your book.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*XjTywC5yMhCxVvjlkxd2yg.jpeg" /></figure><p>But beyond these things, there are a lot of other activities that a marketing/PR/sales department at a company might be responsible for, which you can consider as part of your marketing presence and plan. Some examples:</p><ul><li>Your author website</li><li>Your presence on other websites, such as GoodReads</li><li>Giveaways</li><li>Conference talks and panels</li><li>Book Clubs</li><li>School Visits</li><li>Book Crates</li><li>Awards (yes, they are a marketing tool)</li></ul><p>That’s a lot to cover!</p><p>There is a reality that even traditionally-published authors still need to do a lot of their own marketing work. Hopefully I can help demystify some of that, and also help you avoid sinking too much time into things that might not be strategically sound. Some of the confusion and stress for authors comes from authors being uncertain. <em>What marketing is handled by my publisher and what is my responsibility? </em>I’m hoping this will provide some clarity.</p><p>Let’s get started!</p><p>You will find the next article, <a href="https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/facebook-and-google-ads-for-authors-10f52e0624b2">‘Facebook and Google Ads for Authors’ here</a>.</p><p>If you find any of this useful, please consider sharing, or check out my book <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/a-wolf-for-a-spell/9780593121658"><em>A Wolf for a Spell</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=453ff3267955" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Game Design Taught Me About Story Structure]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@karah.sutton/what-game-design-taught-me-about-story-structure-ccb7f7dc968e?source=rss-8119a984fe34------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccb7f7dc968e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[screenwriting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karah Sutton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Oct 2018 00:33:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-31T00:33:28.065Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9a8KpQlNUFcddUh_cNbNYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I once made a comment on Twitter about how Quidditch is a poorly designed game, because the Snitch being worth 150 points throws the balancing off. A writer friend responded to me saying that Quidditch was perfectly designed from a story standpoint because it allows Harry to be a hero in his first game.</p><p>She was right, but as our conversation continued, I realized that she didn’t understand what I meant by “game design.” Or “balancing,” for that matter.</p><p>“Balancing” is a game design term that refers to how the different moving parts of a game fit together and fine-tuning them so that they work cohesively. If one choice is especially difficult, it’s worth more points to make up for it. If another option is easier to come by, it needs to have other restrictions placed on it. This makes it so that players can form different strategies, and no single strategy is a sure-bet for winning. A straightforward example of this is Scrabble: the number of points each letter is worth has to be balanced, and a game designer goes through a careful analysis to ensure that it is. They have to check how common certain letters are, how easy they are to use, whether they need to be paired with other letters, and assign more or less points based on this. Thus you get Q worth 10 points and there are only 2 of them while E is worth 1 point and there are 24 available.</p><p>Quidditch, as a game, is not balanced. The majority of the game design is similar to soccer: get the ball into a guarded area and get points. The Beaters add an interesting extra level in making it more difficult for the Chasers to do their job. But the Seeker… well, the Seeker throws the balancing off. None of what any of the other players are doing matters if the Seeker can suddenly catch the Snitch and not only earn 150 points, but also end the game! Were a game designer balancing this, they would probably either assign the 150 points ability but not the endgame ability (meaning a good Seeker can help a team immensely, but can still be overpowered by good Chasers on the opposition), or the endgame ability but not the 150 points (meaning the Seeker’s role becomes more strategic: they have to prevent the other team’s Seeker from catching the Snitch when it benefits the opposition, and in turn try to catch the Snitch if and only if their team is ahead).</p><p>I never used to think much about game design. I was a writer, an aspiring novelist and screenwriter. I constantly analyzed plot, character, and story structure. But when I started working at a game studio in 2013, I began to learn how games are designed. And to my surprise, I found that many of those principles can be applied to storytelling as well.</p><p>[I should caveat that I don’t work as a game designer, I only work for a studio. So a lot of these elements are things I’ve learned through osmosis. If I misuse any terms, I’d love to be corrected.]</p><ol><li><strong>There are rules governing people’s actions and behavior</strong></li></ol><p>You don’t need to work in game development to know that games have rules. They’re more obvious in board games, but video games have them too. The rules determine what choices you’re able to make and what restrictions are placed on you (will you die if you don’t collect food? Do you have to be at a certain location within a set period?). When players break the rules (either on purpose or by accident), it can lead to a game feeling unfun or unfair, and no one wants that.</p><p>Stories have rules too! We sense them, even if they aren’t declared outright.</p><p>Let’s start with characters. Characters often have rules that they obey, usually related to either what they treasure, or what they fear. Captain America will always elect to save Bucky, no matter what else is going on. He just will. Stories get interesting when plot tries to force a character to break their personal rules, or pits their rules against each other. What happens when Indiana Jones’ determination to acquire artifacts for a museum conflicts with his fear of snakes? Conflict! Tension! Story!</p><p>My favorite example of this is the film <em>There Will Be Blood</em>. Daniel Plainview will always seek wealth and personal gain above all else. So the story throws everything at him that would normally lead a person to have a crisis of conscience and abandon that trajectory. What happens if he has to take care of a son? What happens if he’s confronted with religion? What happens if a long-lost family member tracks him down? If you haven’t seen it, can you guess what happens?</p><p>In many stories, a character transforms in the end when they break their rules. It signifies personal growth. In <em>The Emperor’s New Groove</em>, Kuzco has to break his rule of always putting himself first when he makes the choice at the end to save Pacha instead of reaching for the vial that will make him a human again. However, if a character breaks their rules in any other circumstances, this can feel misleading and wrong. What would happen to the story if Kuzco was repeatedly putting others before himself? It would break the rules of the story, which would weaken Kuzco’s transformation at the end. While we see him display small signs of growth through the film, foreshadowing his transition, we don’t see him do anything that is truly counter to his own needs until the end.</p><p>The other way that we see rules is in worldbuilding. My favorite example of this is in <em>Star Wars</em>, and what makes it so fascinating is how much everyone disagrees on how the rules work. In <em>A New Hope</em>, it’s not clear whether the Force is learned or inherited, because Luke never showed signs of the Force until he enters the tutelage of Obi Wan, but he is also the son of strong-with-the-Force Anakin Skywalker. But in <em>The Phantom Menace</em>, we learn about midi-chlorians (and that Anakin was an immaculate conception?), which codifies the rule in this world that strength in the Force is predetermined. Yet <em>The Last Jedi</em> breaks this rule in stating that the Force exists in everyone and belongs to no one (which was clearly an intentional choice… many people disagreed with the rule as stated in <em>Phantom Menace</em>). It goes one step further to state outright that Rey has not inherited any special abilities; she’s a nobody from nowhere. So what are the rules? How many arguments have broken out because one fan believes strength in Force is inherited, while another believes anyone can become a Jedi?</p><p>Knowing what the rules are for both your characters and your world can make for an altogether more satisfying experience.</p><p>2. <strong>A little randomness and luck can be good, too much leads to frustration</strong></p><p>Somewhere in a room with white walls and brushed steel countertops there is a rat in a cage. In the corner of the cage is a lever, and if the rat presses on it with a paw, a food pellet drops in front of her.</p><p>If a food pellet is given to the rat every time she presses on the lever, then the rat will only press on the lever when she’s hungry. She knows she can get food whenever she wants it. But what happens if the food only appears sometimes? Say, half the time there’s no food, and it’s unpredictable when the food will appear?</p><p>You can probably imagine. The rat presses the lever over and over and over. Even when she has plenty of food, she wants to stockpile for the times when she might not get it. The pleasure centers in her brain skyrocket. She experiences a thrill each time the food does appear, and she keeps pressing the lever in seeking that thrill.</p><p>Casinos know that this is how chance makes people feel, and take full advantage of it. In regular games, a little bit of luck or randomness can feel good. Drawing a card in the hopes of getting what you need, rolling dice to get extra points, opening a chest in the hopes of finding that special sword. If you have too much randomness, it can feel awful. Take a look at <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com.au/monopoly-rules-everyone-gets-wrong-2017-12">how the actual rules of Monopoly work</a>, then compare them to the rules most people play where you circle the board endlessly hoping that you will luckily land on the space you need. On the opposite end of the spectrum, if you take away all randomness, you have a game that is purely strategic like chess. This is great and serves a very important purpose, but sometimes just a little bit of randomness or luck can feel good and satisfying.</p><p>In stories, this little bit of chance often has to do with moments when two characters happen to be in the same place at the same time. Strider happened to overhear Frodo using his real name in Bree. Ilsa happens to stumble into Rick’s gin joint in <em>Casablanca</em>. Marty McFly happens to go back to a date in 1955 just before his parents would have had their meet-cute and also just before he knows lightning will strike the clock tower.</p><p>There’s a phrase often used that if something bad happens by chance, then that’s plot, but if something good happens by chance, then that’s cheating. I think there’s room for some good things to happen by chance. After all, it’s good that Harry Potter happens to stumble into the room containing the Mirror of Erised and learns how it works. This doesn’t ruin the plot, and it doesn’t feel like cheating. It’s just information that happens to come in handy later. But what does feel like cheating is when too many things happen by chance in a single story. To use <em>Harry Potter</em> again, when Harry happens to make every single choice that will allow Barty Crouch Jr.’s wicked plot to come to fruition. When that happens, it’s more like you’re playing a casino game, and you can’t help but wonder if you’re being cheated.</p><p><strong>3. There must be choices, and those choices must come at a risk</strong></p><p>Let’s go back to the topic of balancing. Games are all about choices. You can choose to move your pawn or your knight. You can choose to pass the ball to your teammate or you can try to run for a touchdown. What makes these choices interesting in games goes back to the design of the game and also the balancing. In basketball, you are taking a greater risk by aiming for a three-pointer, but that risk can pay off in the additional point as a reward. And if there is additional pressure such as a team being 3 points down with only 2 seconds left on the clock, then that risk carries even more weight.</p><p>This is the core of stories as well. If you’re querying a novel, you will often see advice that your query must include the phrase “If [character] chooses X, then [stakes]. If [character] chooses Y, then [other stakes].” If Katniss loses the Hunger Games, she will die. But to win the Hunger Games, she will have to kill Peeta. If Woody gets rid of Buzz, he’ll be Andy’s favorite toy again, but he will have lost the respect of Andy’s other toys. If he stops to help Buzz, he might miss the moving truck and they both lose Andy forever.</p><p>Choice is what stories are built on, but without risk, those choices are meaningless.</p><p>Oftentimes you will see a character make a third choice. “I have either poisoned my goblet or yours. Just kidding, I actually poisoned both.” This can be a really fun way to twist the rules and subvert expectations. You often see this is scenes where a villain says “Join me or die.” Neville chooses a third option in killing Nagini. Luke jumps off the platform instead of joining or being killed by Darth Vader. It’s good to give players multiple choices, and it’s fun for readers if that third choice feels like it still fits within the rules of the game.</p><p><strong>Finding the core experience</strong></p><p>You often hear in a game design studio the question “is it fun?” It feels strange discussing this, because it’s so subjective. I had fun, did you have fun? This part was fun, but this other part was tedious. But it’s nice having that simple question at the heart of what we’re doing. A game can be tense, or challenging, or frightening, or heartbreaking, but those emotions are all fun to experience.</p><p>This is an overly simplistic question to ask when it comes to books or movies, and it doesn’t even apply to all games either. Stories that deal with extremely challenging subject matter wouldn’t be considered “fun.” But it is worth considering what your core experience is. When the story is over, do you want the reader or audience to feel satisfied? Exhilarated? Heart-warmed? Asking that question at various stages can help hone in on what serves the core purpose and what is excess.</p><p><strong>And in the end,</strong> it didn’t matter if the balancing of Quidditch was off. Harry needed to be the hero in his first Quidditch match and earn the admiration of the school. By weakening the role Harry played in the sport, it might have weakened the sense of achievement in his winning the game single-handed. A choice was made to prioritize one aspect over another.</p><p>Just like characters, writers make choices too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccb7f7dc968e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>