<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by kentpalmer on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by kentpalmer on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 16:43:11 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[California Systems Dynamics Economic Pandemic Recovery Model]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/california-systems-dynamics-economic-pandemic-recovery-model-827f554d2a45?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/827f554d2a45</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[system-dynamics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[california]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Apr 2020 17:22:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-19T17:22:10.330Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is quite clear that the California Task Force on Business and Jobs Recovery chaired by Tom Steyer and Ann O’Leary should use Systems Dynamics Modeling to trade off policy positions that are being considered. This is because we are in a dynamic situation in which the Pandemic might return and it may be necessary to close down again after partially reopening. This dynamic situation in which there may be a resurgence in the viral load on the economy needs to be modeled in relation to the reopening strategies. Also, the goal should be future resilience and the model could help attempt to plan future strategies that will lead to greater resilience of the economy in the future against not just resurgence of Covid-19, but also against future pandemics.</p><p>So, the question needs to be asked what the form of such a California Systems Dynamics Economic Recovery Model should be like. How do we build such a model to support the work of the Task Force that will allow them to trade off different policy choices in relation to the dynamics of the possible pandemic resurgences that might cause the economy to retract again after opening? There clearly has to be a part of the model focused on the pandemic effects and possible contagion dynamics. On the other hand there needs to be a part of the model that focuses on different sectors of the economy. And another part of the model that is social and related to economic factors based on different behaviors of the public as they go back to work and start mixing again creating vulnerabilities for the continued spread of the virus. The right granularity of modeling must be picked based on the kinds of questions the task force has with regard to their policy recommendations to the Governor. Experts from various disciplines such as Economics, Sociology, Business Administration, Infectious Disease Experts and other disciplines need to have input into this model in order to make it robust enough. However, it cannot be too detailed to become unwieldy.</p><p>It is suggested that the place to start is with the Causal Loop diagrams that are fundamental to the way in which the dynamics in the economy and in the pandemic are understood. For us the rate of infection is unknown because of a lack of testing. Therefore, we only have a lagging indicator of the rate of hospitalization as the basis of our current modeling. Fortunately, we have been able to flatten the curve and to so far avoid the dire predictions that were first made with regard to the deaths from the pandemic. But the problem is that there is this fine line to be walked between opening up business and reinfection rates. And this is where good modeling could help policy makers attempt to understand different scenarios related to different policy choices in order to avoid unintended consequences. It is actually thrashing that has the most probability of causing harm to the economy. Thrashing means opening up then having to close down again quickly repeatedly. It is the dampening of this possible thrashing that Systems Dynamic Modeling might help us understand better before we make mistakes in our reopening policy recommendations.</p><p>My suggestion is that we divide up into teams that would create sub-models of the overall model. It is recommended that there be a generic economic sector model that is elaborated for each specific sector. And that there is a general economy model that represents that sector’s interaction with the whole economy. There needs to be a pandemic epidemiological sub-model hooked to various models of the pandemic itself and its dynamics. There needs to be a part of the model that represents government actions and then another part of the model that represents public response. The workforce needs to be represented and the relation between unemployment and reemployment. Companies and their supply chains also need to be represented in this model. In other words, it needs to be comprehensive with regard to the Pandemic situation we face but at a high enough level of abstraction so that it can actually help reflect the differences in policy choices that are considered by the task force. The model should be open to inspection by the public so that others might critique it and so we get maximum input into the model from experts in the various fields represented in the model. A public model would inspire more confidence in decisions based on the model than a private model. But this is of course a task force decision.</p><p>Here is the key to why such a model is useful in a situation like this. The model becomes a repository for your knowledge of the situation. It allows you to focus on what you need to know in order to make decisions which you can then build into the model. Then it gives you a place to plug in the relevant data as it is known in order to discover the impact as the situation evolves. It gives a way to focus on details as sub-systems within the overall model are considered by experts, but then there is an overall answer at the highest level of abstraction that can drive policy choice selection given different scenarios.</p><p>Systems Dynamics is a standard technique. There are many different experts in building these kinds of models who exist and can be recruited to help build it. It brings to the fore the dynamics one is concerned about which in this case is re-infection verses business functioning and the openness of the economy. This same approach could work for every state. There could be a shared model between states that is generic so that other states could benefit from the work on the California model.</p><p>I recommend that Systems Scientists in California and other experts who know how to build Systems Dynamics Models as well as disciplinary specialists cooperate to produce a model that Government and Business leaders can use to guide their policy recommendations and choices in these trying times.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/42787341/California_Systems_Dynamics_Economic_Pandemic_Recovery_Model_Part_1_Brief_Rationale">https://www.academia.edu/42787341/California_Systems_Dynamics_Economic_Pandemic_Recovery_Model_Part_1_Brief_Rationale</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=827f554d2a45" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Foundations of Systems Architecture Design]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/foundations-of-systems-architecture-design-ee295d4c1260?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee295d4c1260</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[software]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computer-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computer-science-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software-engineering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Mar 2018 22:47:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-24T01:03:23.779Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Series of papers on the Foundations of Systems Architectural Design: See <a href="https://independent.academia.edu/KentPalmer/Foundations-of-Systems-Architecture-Design">https://independent.academia.edu/KentPalmer/Foundations-of-Systems-Architecture-Design</a></p><ol><li><a href="https://www.academia.edu/31038671/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_01_Afoundational_Basis"><strong>Afoundational Basis</strong></a></li></ol><p><em>Using Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem to ground Systems Theory via Co-recursion based on Special Systems Theory. </em>— Abstract: A foundation for Systems Engineering is laid out based on Gödel’s Incompleteness theorem. This foundation gives the basis for Architectural Design of Systems including Software Systems. Systems Engineering has its roots in Systems Science. Systems Science propounds various General Systems Theories and all of them depend on Logic and Mathematics and their Foundations which have been brought into question by Gödel’s theorem. We use the Theorem of Gödel to provide the foundations for Systems Theory, and thus Systems Science via the Special Systems and Schemas Theory, which in turn ground Systems Engineering and thus Software Engineering Systems. These Systems are syntheses that are Designed using Architectural Design, the Afoundation discovered herein gives a basis for Emergent Design in general which leads to Architectural Design of Systems including Software Systems. Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Pascal Triangle, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory, Godel’s Incompleteness Theorem, Afoundationalism, Foundations, Meta-systems.</p><p>2. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36102821/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_02_Steps_toward_and_Ecology_of_Emergent_Design"><strong>Steps toward and Ecology of Emergent Design</strong></a></p><p><em>Differance that makes a difference</em> — Abstract: Bateson says that we need to explore the meta-levels of Learning in his Steps to an Ecology of the Mind. Here we explore the steps toward an ecology of Emergent Design. Notice we are not trying to found any specific Discipline directly. But instead we are trying to ground our specific designs that we produce as software systems architectures. In other words, it is concrete systematic structured compositions that we are grounding as dynamic syntheses. We do this by a fusion of Leibniz Characteristica Universalis as Symbolic Logic with his Analysis Situs the lost science of configurations of things which the mathematical contemporaries of Leibniz did not accept and therefore was only sketched by him. But this sketch is brought back into focus by our transformation of the proof of Gödel that gives a basis for Special Systems Theory. — Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory.</p><p>3. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36106255/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_03_On_Design_Synthesis"><strong>On Design Synthesis</strong></a></p><p><em>A Mysterious Synthesis or How a Miracle Occurs Here</em> — Abstract: This paper attacks the core problem with Design: What is a synthesis and how is it possible. We begin by asking why this Transdisciplinary approach to the problem of design synthesis is necessary and significant. — Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory.</p><p>4. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36120121/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_04_Convolution"><strong>Convolution</strong></a></p><p><em>A Prelude to the Comprehension of the Supra-Rationality of the Dagger Formation</em> — Abstract: The internal view of worlds seen in terms of the relations between pairs of schemas and pairs of Foundational Mathematical Categories which are convoluted and reflected as inward relations between Dagger Theory elements that are external and appear in the interstices between the worlds or realms as defined by Ken Lloyd based on the delineations of worlds by Penrose and Popper, with the addition of the social world. — Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory, Dagger Theory.</p><p>5. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36127848/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_05_Schematic_Nerves"><strong>Schematic Nerves</strong></a></p><p><em>Quiddity and Internal Relations in Schemas</em> Abstract: We define the names of the “essences” of each Schema. We call these nerves after the “Nerve Category” in Category Theory. Examples are Essence of Form, Structure of Pattern, Nucleus of System. We discuss the implications for the understanding of internal relations in Hegel from a schematic point of view. Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory, Dagger Theory, Essence, Nerve, Internal Relations.</p><p>6. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36134231/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_06_Essencing_Forth"><strong>Essencing Forth</strong></a></p><p><em>Essence as a Model of Internal Relations and Projective Geometry.</em> Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory, Dagger Theory, Essence, Nerve, Internal Relations.</p><p>7. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/36188930/Foundations_of_Systems_Architecture_Design_07_Microgenesis_of_Internal_Difference"><strong>Microgenesis of Internal Difference</strong></a></p><p><em>From Internal Relations of Hegel to Internal Differences of Deleuze</em> — Abstract: This paper explains the difference between internal difference of Deleuze and internal relations of Hegel. — Key Words: Systems, Architecture, Design, Special Systems, Systems Engineering, Software Engineering, Software Ontology, Formal Systems, Schemas Theory, Dagger Theory, Projective Geometry, Essence, Internal Relations</p><p>8. <strong>Nondual Difference </strong>(TBD)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee295d4c1260" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Comments on “Models, Science and Intersubjectivity” by Harald Wiltsche]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/comments-on-models-science-and-intersubjectivity-by-harald-wiltsche-8d49e969c56c?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d49e969c56c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[husserl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intersubjectivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phenomenology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heidegger]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Oct 2017 21:13:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-21T02:35:08.073Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Article at <a href="https://www.academia.edu/s/cf2f61f03d/models-science-and-intersubjectivity">Models, Science, and Intersubjectivity</a></p><p>I have been reading Mohanty, Jitendranath. Edmund Husserl’s Freiberg Years, 1916–1938. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2011). I was interested in it because it reviewed Genetic Phenomenology strand in Husserl’s thought. But it also reviews the Intersubjectivity strand much better than the Passive Synthesis strand.</p><p>His presentation makes it quite clear that Husserl was ultimately saying something like Transcendental Subjectivity is Intersubjectivity. In other words, he solves the problem ultimately by fiat which is really no solution. But the problem that Husserl has with solipsism is ultimately the problem that Western science itself has and the critique of Phenomenology by Science advocates is really a case of the pot calling the kettle black.</p><p>This is why Heidegger’s initiative in Being and Time is so important. Heidegger seizes on Husserl’s idea of the “monad” and makes that Dasein. He posits it as something prior to the arising of the dualism between Subject and Object. And this is a big step toward the solution of this problem. But this of course entails other problems to do with the unleashing of a regress in Meta-levels of Being. But Heidegger’s whole project is meant to solve multiple problems with Husserl’s Transcendental Phenomenology at the same time mostly by building off of the Genetic Phenomenology strand in Husserl courses. Of course we do not find that out until later.</p><p>Phenomenology is developed purely in a present-at-hand or Pure Being mode. Heidegger introduces a ready-to-hand or Process Being mode and gives Dasein an Existential basis seemingly outside ontology. This kicks off the development of Fundamental Ontology as a basic theme in Continental Philosophy. Another basic theme is Genetic Phenomenology taken up by Merleau-Ponty and Deleuze explicitly.</p><p>But the problem of Solipsism remains in Husserl’s thought despite claims to the contrary by him. Derrida uses these problems as the basis for his deconstruction of Husserl’s philosophy in Speech and Phenomena. If Husserl was convincing that Transcendental Subjectivity is Transcendental Intersubjectivity, that deconstruction of Derrida would be a moot point.</p><p>It seems to me that the real solution to the problem with intersubjectivity must be not just getting to a place prior to the arising of the subject/object split. But prior also to the mitsein/dasein split. And to do that it seems that we have to go all the way to the level of Wild Being as it is defined by Merleau-Ponty and taken up and developed by Deleuze as Transcendental Empiricism with respect to their version of Dasein and the Monad which is the Transcendental Field.</p><p>I try to show how this is possible in my recent article “<a href="https://www.academia.edu/34904546/Primordial_Sociality_and_Intersubjectivity_Exploring_the_Socius">Primordial Sociality and Intersubjectivity: Exploring the Socius</a>”. I try to show that we need to go all the way up the meta-levels of Being to Wild Being in order to get to a place prior to the division between dasein/mitsen and I also invoke Emergent Time as a resource for attempting to solve the problem of solipsism within the Husserlian context.</p><p>Phenomenology shows that Science itself has a problem of solipsism while claiming to have theories that are reproducible by a community of observers. The solipsism of science is seen in the exclusion of the subject and the claims of objectivity that cannot be sustained. Husserl is only delving into the common problem and attempting to find a way out. But the whole problem is set up and maintained by the subject/object duality that is the basis of science. Basically we need to go even further than Heidegger did when he concentrated on Dasein which was Husserl’s Monad as the basis of his philosophy and tried to make it something prior to the arising of the subject/object split. Merleau-Ponty went further and extended Phenomenology by developing further the idea of Dasein into the Transcendental Field that contains invisiblities interspersed in the visiblities. Deleuze goes even further down this road consolidating the moments of Genetic Phenomenology in Difference and Repetition to support our understanding of Wild Being and developing Transcendental Empiricism as an alternative to Phenomenology.</p><p>This problem of the solipsism (objectivity) of Science continues to be a fundamental problem that later phenomenologist have continued to work on as the advocates of science ignore the problem. But even with the developments of Genetic Phenomenology so far the solution to the problem of solipsism and intersubjectivity has been elusive. Hopefully by bringing to bear the resources of Emergent Time along with advances in Fundamental Ontology we can solve this problem. But that solution must in turn transform not just phenomenology but Science itself.</p><p>See <a href="https://www.academia.edu/13194091/Meta-levels_of_Being">Meta-levels of Being</a></p><p>See also <a href="https://www.academia.edu/12970172/Genetic_Phenomenology_and_Fundamental_Ontology_of_the_Meta-levels_of_Time">Genetic Phenomenology and Fundamental Ontology of the Meta-levels of Time</a></p><p><a href="http://kdp.me/">Kent Duane Palmer</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d49e969c56c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Schemas Theory Research — Personal Narrative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/schemas-theory-research-personal-narrative-784c0b784bc1?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/784c0b784bc1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[schema-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Oct 2017 19:18:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-20T19:18:41.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am going to give you a brief overview of my work so that you can decide if it is interesting to you.</p><p>I have been working as a Software Engineer and a Systems Engineer in my career.</p><p>I did a Ph.D. in Sociology/Philosophy of Science at LSE 1982: Structure of Theoretical Systems in relation to Emergence.</p><p>See <a href="http://etheses.lse.ac.uk/3174/">The structure of theoretical systems in relation to emergence</a></p><p>Working as a Software Engineer after studying Continental Philosophy I eventually saw that Computer Hardware embodies the first two meta-levels of Being: present-at-hand and ready-to-hand as defined by Heidegger in Being and Time.</p><p>That meant that software embodied Hyper Being or what Derrida calls Differance.</p><p>See <a href="https://www.academia.edu/19659239/What_differance_does_Derrida_make">What_differance_does_Derrida_make</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/13195805/Software_Metaphysics_01_A_Framework_for_Understanding_Software_Philosophically">Software_Metaphysics_01_A_Framework_for_Understanding_Software_Philosophically</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/6835869/Software_Ontology_old_">Software_Ontology</a></p><p>This realization that Continental Ontology directly related to Software as an technological artifact drove me to research Software Engineering especially Architectural Design of Software and then eventually Systems Design at the level of Systems Engineering, i.e. the whole system including Hardware.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/31797031/Software_Systems_Architectural_Design_Foundations_01_Introduction">Software_Systems_Architectural_Design_Foundations_01_Introduction</a></p><p>I wrote some papers and placed them on the internet and someone at <a href="http://incose.org/">Systems Engineering</a> saw them and invited me to speak about Schemas Theory <a href="http://schematheory.net/">http://schematheory.net</a> I formulated a set of schemas for that presentation and it has basically remained the set that I did my tutorial on for “INCOSE.org” <a href="http://incose.org/">Systems Engineering</a> and <a href="http://isss.org/">International Society for the Systems Sciences</a> Conferences.</p><p>Along the way as I developed Schema Theory I decided to do a Ph.D. in Systems Engineering, and my adviser asked me to apply Schemas Theory to something so I decided to apply it to design because that was my original interest that drove me to develop Schemas Theory.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/34831961/EMERGENT_DESIGN">EMERGENT_DESIGN</a></p><p>Over the years I have written quite a few papers on Schemas Theory and its implications some of which I have given at the “INCOSE.org” <a href="http://incose.org/">Systems Engineering</a>, CSER and <a href="http://isss.org/">ISSS.org</a> workshop meetings.</p><p>See <a href="https://www.academia.edu/34831626/General_Schemas_Theory">General_Schemas_Theory</a></p><p>As far as I know nothing like Schemas Theory has been developed before and it serves as a foundation for design, because all designs use schemas as their basic imaginary “material” “substance”, i.e. spacetime templates of intelligibility each with its own intrinsic order.</p><p>Schemas Theory is the next level of abstraction beyond Systems Theory</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/31086576/Systems_Philosophy_Questions_concerning_Schemas_Theory_Answered">Systems_Philosophy_Questions_concerning_Schemas_Theory_Answered</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/7993242/Beyond_Systems_Philosophy_From_Systems_Philosophy_to_a_Philosophy_of_Schemas">Beyond_Systems_Philosophy_From_Systems_Philosophy_to_a_Philosophy_of_Schemas</a></p><p>I have recently discovered the mathematical basis of Schemas Theory but have not published that paper yet.</p><p>Schemas Theory was developed in order to frame and make understandable the context of Special Systems Theory.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Special_Systems_Theory">Special_Systems_Theory</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/34804726/Reflexive_Autopoietic_Dissipative_Special_Systems_Theory">Reflexive_Autopoietic_Dissipative_Special_Systems_Theory</a></p><p>Since I have been not working I have devoted myself full time to my research and have gone back and reread everything that was significant in the development of the theory of the Meta-levels of Being in a Continental Philosophy Study group that is local.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/34810992/Groundless_Grounds_--_Continental_Philosophy_Reading_and_Study_Group">Groundless_Grounds_ — _Continental_Philosophy_Reading_and_Study_Group</a></p><p>In that I have discovered the thread of Genetic Phenomenology that I am studying intently now</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/12970172/Genetic_Phenomenology_and_Fundamental_Ontology_of_the_Meta-levels_of_Time">Genetic_Phenomenology_and_Fundamental_Ontology_of_the_Meta-levels_of_Time</a></p><p>I am also engaged in editing and publishing some of the papers I have written over the last year or so based on the readings I have done recently.</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/34467629/Dark_Entropy_and_Dark_Information">Dark_Entropy_and_Dark_Information</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/34370258/Adorno_with_Derrida_Deleuze_and_Zizek">Adorno_with_Derrida_Deleuze_and_Zizek</a></p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/31976900/Zizek_verses_Deleuze">Zizek_verses_Deleuze</a></p><p>If you are going to study Systems Theory as a basis for better understanding design I recommend the work of George Klir as a point of departure</p><p><a href="http://www.mediafire.com/view/gyjget4ea4a51bj/FormalStructuralSystem20150123kdp04b.pdf"><strong>Formal Structural Systems in relation to General Schemas Theory: On the Architecture of Problem Solving</strong></a></p><p><a href="http://www.mediafire.com/view/gyjget4ea4a51bj/FormalStructuralSystem20150123kdp04b.pdf">FormalStructuralSystem20150123kdp04b.pdf</a></p><p>This gives you a narrative to help you approach my work on Schemas Theory hopefully making it more accessible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=784c0b784bc1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Special Systems Theory is about . . . Life, Consciousness and the Social]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/what-special-systems-theory-is-about-life-consciousness-and-the-social-a89ca2380542?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a89ca2380542</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Dec 2016 19:26:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-05T19:26:45.281Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Special Systems Theory is a Mathematical Systems Theory concerning the necessary conditions for the possibility of anomalous phenomena like Life, Consciousness and Sociality which exist but are unexplained inadequately by contemporary scientific theory</p><p>The Summary of my research on Special Systems Theory is here:</p><p>See <a href="https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Special_Systems_Theory">https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Special_Systems_Theory</a></p><p>The idea of Special Systems Theory is to set the mathematically necessary conditions for the possibility of life, consciousness and the social, three very special anomalous phenomena. The necessary conditions are set by Mathematics which structure the possibility space in which anomalous emergent processes can occur as we see in Life, Consciousness, and Sociality which we have in ourselves and other life forms existential proof of their existence even though they cannot be explained by standard theories of Science yet. The whole idea of the meta-theory is to set the external limiting conditions that mathematics gives for understanding the phenomena. And those external conditions are in the form of mathematical anomalies that make ultra-efficacious phenomena like Life, Consciousness and Sociality possible. The bridge between the existential proof which we are as living conscious social beings and the mathematical possibility based on anomalous structures in mathematics is the meta-theory Special Systems Theory itself that is part of Systems Science and an addition to General Systems Theories within Systems Science. The relation between Systems and Special Systems are explained by Schemas Theory (<a href="http://schematheory.net/">http://schematheory.net</a>).</p><p>I take mathematical anomalies of different sorts that have basically the same structure and build a meta-theory that has a radically different structure than normal general systems theories. Then within the meta-theory are placed local theories that explain the phenomena of life, consciousness and the social very much along the lines of what <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Terrence_Deacon">Terrance Deacon</a> has envisaged in <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Incomplete_Nature">Incomplete Nature</a>, but he has not mathematics to back up his claims and he leaves out the social layer of emergence and only deals with life and consciousness. He however does the service of re-explaining basic scientific concepts in a way that makes Life and Consciousness plausible rather than the normal explanations that would render these phenomena improbable or impossible.</p><p>The concept is to use anomalies in mathematics as the basis for explaining the possible existence of anomalies in the physical world that would give us emergent features like life, consciousness, and the social. The meta-theory specifies the emergent differences between these phenomena and some of their very general properties. Then more specific theories related to each phenomena are substituted into the meta-theory to explain the phenomena in more detail in this case Prigogine’s theory of <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Dissipative_system">Dissipative Structures</a> augmented by the <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Constructal_law">Construal Flow</a> theory of Bejan, a modified form of the existential theory of life of Maturana and Varella called <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Autopoiesis">Autopoiesis</a>, and Reflexive Sociology to explain the social in more detail. We take the meta-theory as being fixed by mathematical anomalies that are related to each other by their general structure to specify the Special Systems Theory, then we allow the contained theories to be modified to better and better explain the link between the mathematics and the anomalous phenomena in question, be it life, consciousness or the social. The meta-theory explains the interaction between the Special Systems based on the structure of Hyper-complex algebras and other types of mathematics or some anomalous physical theories like the theory of Solitons, Breathers, and Instantatons, or Cooper pairs in super-conductivity or Bose-Einstein condensates. Thus there is a physical component to the theory based on specific physical phenomena that have the same structure as the mathematical anomalies.</p><p>Special Systems Theory has been constructed so that it as to be refutable by using different anomalies in mathematics to structure the special systems in order to give a very specific theoretical structure to the explanation offered. Unless we make our systems theories refutable there is no way to make progress. Special Systems Theory is meant to be an example of what a good theory of the phenomena might look like rather than the final answer. A good theory would be based in mathematics and testable, thus refutable.</p><p>Special Systems Theory was discovered through an analysis of the imaginary cities of Plato and then relating the anomalous structures of those cities to Anomalies in Mathematics. It was realized that these anomalous structures in mathematics which were all similar could be used to produce a general Systems Theory about these Special Systems. Then it was realized that Special Systems Theory could be used to set the limits of the necessary conditions of the possibility of anomalous phenomena like Life, Consciousness and the Social. The combination of mathematical anomalies and physical anomalies with the same basic structure makes it possible to explain things that normal Systems Theory cannot explain and thus its value in Systems Science and for other special sciences that need to explain anomalous phenomena with similar structures.</p><p>Other works on Special Systems Theory:</p><p><a href="https://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer/4/">https://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer/4/</a> Reflexive Autopoietic Dissipative Special Systems Theory</p><p><a href="https://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer/3/">https://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer/3/</a> Reflexive Autopoietic Systems Theory</p><p><a href="http://emergentdesign.net/">General Schemas Theory Research</a></p><p>For more see</p><p><a href="https://independent.academia.edu/KentPalmer">Kent Palmer — Academia.edu</a></p><p><a href="http://schematheory.net/">SchemaTheory.net</a></p><p><a href="http://nondual.net/">Nondual Science Institute</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a89ca2380542" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Schematic Nerves]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kentpalmer/schematic-nerves-81d067cd6f5c?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81d067cd6f5c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[schemas-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Oct 2016 02:33:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-27T02:33:13.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>What are the “nerves” of a schema?</strong></p><p><strong>An inquiry into Structures of Patterns, Essences of Forms, Nuclei of Systems, and Nexuses of Meta-systems.</strong></p><p>There is a concept in Chinese called LI. 理 <a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Li_(Neo-Confucianism)">Li (Neo-Confucianism) | Wikiwand</a></p><p>This term means both principle and pattern. The example of pattern is the exact configuration of content on the surface of a jade stone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/0*KwdNqGYnp1cS32dk." /></figure><p>Notice how the content of the stone has various colors which have particular qualities that appear as dark and light veins in the substance of the jade. This is Li as specific concrete pattern. The patterns are always unique.</p><p>Li also means Principle in which case it means how the unique patterns are generated. In other words, before the pattern appears there are constraints on what sort of pattern could possibly appear in the circumstances. You will notice that the pattern that does appear could have been slightly different in many ways but overall given the circumstances in the jade formation certain types of pattern are probable and among those one gets actualized.</p><p>Patterns that do appear take time to manifest, but the Principle of generation is there prior to the actual pattern appearing and the principle is embodied by the pattern that does appear. In different circumstances different types of LI apply, and thus there are myriad Li for every type of possible pattern.</p><p>The actual development of the pattern Li based on the principle Li is brought about by Chi which is the subtle energy by which the content is moved to its final configuration through the process of development. For instance, the growth of the living tree that produces the rings in a tree due to growth patterns in different seasons over the years.</p><p>We mostly understand these ideas based on Complexity Theory and Chaos Theory, as well Dynamics of various kinds. But our view tends to be abstracted from the concreteness of the patterns and principles at work in the Chinese perspective. To us Principle and Pattern are different things. But the Chinese saw them as two aspects of the same thing.</p><p>However, it seems to me that it is useful to think of Principles as generators of instances of schemas. Principles are always concepts for us which are abstracted from particular situations given a specific perspective. But concepts are understood in terms of exemplars and prototypes as well as abstractions. Thus we can think of the principles as being concepts, abstracted from a situation given a particular perspective in a specific domain that generate exemplars and prototypes that have in their concrete realization specific patterns of content. Content is monadic, i.e. bundles of qualia in concrete configurations. Those configurations are the patterns which are myriad and specific to the circumstance of their realization. But this content tends to be seen as something that fills the form, and thus gives a pattern of content that is exposed on the surface of the form.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/0*taNR7FFAbVh58UUb." /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/567/0*P24ctMpAk5-Kj1a2." /></figure><p><a href="http://www.loupignoletbowls.com/Pages/Examples.aspx">Amazing Wood Bowls from the North Shore of Lake Superior</a></p><p>The form is the overall shape of the thing, for instance a bowl made of a burl of wood. The content is determined by the substance, in this case burl maple wood that goes all the way through the bowl, but the content is exposed on the surface of the bowl to give patterns determined by the grain of the wood which exhibits the growth and force patterns that played out in the development of the tree to produce the burl that gives us its unique pattern of content. In this case the cellulose wood cells are the monads, that make up the content of the form, and produce a pattern on the surface of the form of the bowl.</p><p>Li is the specific pattern in this case that is the frozen result of the dynamics of Chi that produced the pattern during the growth of the tree.</p><p>But the underlying principle LI is what is behind the growth of the Burl on trees that produced that specific pattern.</p><p>The difference between Schemas and the Chinese concept is the level of abstraction. Schemas cover all instances of a particular dimensional configuration. There is just one pattern schema that can be either one or two dimensions. And that fits into a Form schema which is of two or three dimensions. Everything which is one or two dimensions can be seen as a pattern and everything that is two or three dimensions can be seen as a form. We see two dimensional pattern and form together in a watercolor painting for instance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/0*2pe4ilUN32jWcviT." /></figure><p><a href="http://fineartblogger.com/indian-watercolor-paintings/tree-watercolor-painting/">tree-watercolor-painting — Fine Art Blogger</a></p><p>The difference between Schemas and the Chinese concept of Li is that Pattern schemas are universals within specific dimensions covering all things within spacetime in that dimension as either one schema or another in a given dimension. Schemas are holonic in that they face two different schemas and they relate part to whole. They are templates of Understanding of spacetime configurations that are immediately intelligible. We look at the painting and we immediately see the patterning of colors within the outlines of the form of the branches. Every bit of color soaked into a particular spot on the paper are monadic qualia content, in the case of water color seen as mass effects.</p><p>Schemas are phenomenological in the sense that as you look out on the world — the schemas are the things you naturally see if you are brought up within the auspices of the Western worldview. Whether they are more general beyond our culture is an open question. But within our cultural tradition within the West they are well defined philosophically and historically within our tradition of aesthetic connoisseurship and artisan-ship.</p><p>See <a href="http://schematheory.net/">SchemaTheory.net</a></p><p>Once we realize that within our tradition there are a series of schemas … monad, pattern, form, system, … that nest and between which there are no gaps and are thus are well defined phenomenologically in practice, then it is possible to see what the term Software Pattern means, which is a <em>pattern of forms</em>. In other words, we can read the hierarchy of schemas in two directions. Normally we consider a pattern of monads as we have been considering. But we can also read the series in the other direction as Alexander did who created the <em>Pattern Language</em> in the context of his <em>Timeless way of Building</em> that produces a <em>quality with no name</em>. The <em>quality with no name</em> is what you are aiming for in each case if you are to build something aesthetically pleasing as a living environment for human beings. Engineers are inherently crippled in this respect as they have no idea at all concerning the quality with no name. The best they can do is sense<em> smells</em>. But that of course is merely a way to talk indirectly about Li. Primordial natural pattern generation by humans that give configurations that fit human beings in all possible ways as living environments that are not just aesthetically pleasing but brings the best out of the experience of life in terms of affordances within the lifeworld. Patterns Languages concern the patterns of forms that produce the quality with no name at various scales based on some amorphous undefined principles rooted in our inherent knowledge of human dwelling. [<a href="https://www.academia.edu/9965868/Living_Spaces">Living Spaces</a>] Alexander specifically told the software community that their use of his idea of ‘Pattern Languages’ did not capture its essence and were not what he was talking about in his books. But this reduction from what Alexander was indicating that goes beyond words to Software Pattern languages ends up being their reduction to patterns of forms which capture configurations of forms that turn up often and seem to work well in Architectural Design of Software Systems.</p><p>But what this alerts us to is the fact that we can have monads of patterns, and forms of systems, as well as patterns of forms. The reversal of the normal series of the schemas and their pairing lead to new ways of looking at things as Alexander discovered. The monad of the pattern is very much like the Chinese concept of Li. It is an irreducible pattern generator that is unique in terms of organization and quality [Grenander, Ulf, and Michael I. Miller. <em>Pattern Theory: From Representation to Inference</em>. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.]. The form of a system is more or less the kind of a system. That is to say one particular systemic configuration that is different from other systemic configurations. We might think of them as something along the lines of Isomorphies in Len Troncale’s sense.</p><p>Forms have essences traditionally. The essence is the constraints on the attributes of the form. Attributes are parameters that characterize the content of the form. The equivalent of the essence of forms at the pattern level could be called the Li, i.e. the principle by which the pattern is generated. In the West we do not have a general term for it. But instead we use the term “structure” which is static rather than dynamic. We consider the structure of a pattern the underlying rules or algorithm that constrains the generated pattern. Example is Mendeleev’s periodic table of elements.</p><p>Within our tradition generally we can say Essences are to Forms what Structures are to Patterns of content, i.e. Monads.</p><p>At this point we get to Hegel’s fundamental critique of Formalism in Kant, which is that if forms do not comprehend their contents then the contents are in themselves, but if forms comprehend their contents then the contents are for the other. i.e. the form. And forms cannot be for themselves unless the others are for them. Self-knowledge only comes through the mediation of the other. This critique was the beginning of taking seriously the need for structuralism within our tradition. If forms do not care about their contents and are blind to them then they lack understanding of their content and therefore they are not truly forms but some degenerate type of comprehension that exemplifies ignorance of what is contained in the form. Basically, Hegel was saying that for form to be for itself it needs to comprehend the structure of the content within it. Everything needs take into account for self, for other, in self and in other for full comprehension that can call itself self-conscious knowledge. If content is in itself, but not for form, and form is in itself and not for content, then this is not real knowledge. Only if the content is for the other of form, and the form is for the other of content, only then can content be through its structure for itself, and form through its essence be for itself. In other words the essence of form mediates the structure of content and the structure of contents mediates the essence of form to each other. That is self-conscious knowledge as opposed to mere consciousness. Only completely self-conscious knowledge can be fully rational.</p><p>The same is true for Systems and Forms. We don’t have a term for the equivalent of the essence of a system or the structure of a pattern. But in physics the inner structure of the atom composed of different fundamental particles which is stable is called the nucleus, so we could use that term for the core of the system. This is of course an analogy. Systems are gestalts, i.e. backgrounds on which forms appear, that background can be conceived as the boundary of the system, that contains several forms within it that each can be figures on the ground of the system for our inspection. The dual of the System is the Meta-system, i.e. what lies beyond the boundary to the horizon of the environment. Systems also have a dual which is the process with its meta-process. The duality of system and process is constrained by the nucleus of the system/process. Once we have a name corresponding to essence (form) or structure (pattern) in this case “nucleus” of the system/process as well as the meta-system/meta-process then it is possible to apply Hegel’s criteria to the relation of forms to system.</p><p><em>Nucleus</em> is to the System what Essence is to Form and Structure is to Pattern.</p><p>Therefore, forms within a system can be in themselves, for themselves, for others, or in others and the same thing is true of the system.</p><p>If a system does not comprehend its forms then the forms are in themselves, and the system is in itself. This state is called extension or what reigns is pure substitutability. But that means that the forms are blind to the system and the system is blind to the forms it contains. But this is a degenerate condition which lacks complete knowledge of both the forms and the system. Forms need to be understood by the system that contains them, just as systems need to comprehend the systems that contain them. Thus, the forms of the system need to be for the other (system), and the system also needs to be for the other (forms). And they do this through the essence and the nucleus. The nucleus of the system needs to comprehend the essences of the forms within them, and the essences of the form need to comprehend the nucleus of the system that contains them. If both sides do this then they are both for themselves by being for others. I.e. the System that has a nucleus that comprehends the essences of the forms in contains is for itself, i.e. self-conscious at the system level. And on the other hand, the Form needs to have an essence that comprehends the nucleus of the system that contains it in order to be for itself, i.e. self-conscious at the form level.</p><p>Notice that essence of form is a holon because it needs to comprehend the structure of its content looking down and the nucleus of its system, if it is in a system, looking up in the hierarchy of schematic containment. And it is this holonic nature of the essence that makes them like concrete universals, i.e. exhibiting internal relations between the contents it contains and the system that contains it as mediated by form through this essence.</p><p>With regard to the System level, which is a whole, then we get the internal relations between the parts of the system which is the way that the nucleus of the system manifests. Internal relations appear as negative information within the closure of the system.</p><p>But wholeness is not specific just to the System Schema as Hegel thought. Wholeness applies to every schema with regard to its closure and therefore negative information can appear at any schematic level, not just the system level as Hegel thought.</p><p>When we say that an essence is a constraint on attributes of a form, that constraint is negative information, i.e. a counterfactual. Similarly, when we talk about structure as a constraint on the characteristics of a pattern, that constraint is negative information, i.e. also a counterfactual. The same is true of the nucleus of the system that constraints the features of a system, the constraint is negative information and thus counterfactual. Counterfactuals appear at the level of hyper-intensional logics.</p><p>Essences to a certain extent are intensional in as much as they are like templates with slots for attributes that have variation, in which different elements that mean the same thing can be substituted, for instance red and green are both colors. Based on these intentional attributes and their substitutions we generate possible worlds. And thus possible worlds theory is the outgrowth of the problem of intensionality, i.e. that extensional substitution does not explain everything.</p><p>Counterfactuals are things that are not the case. We can define impossible worlds at the hyperintensional level that are totally based on counterfacturals. Worlds are schemas so in general there are counterfactual impossible schemas that need to be defined hyperintensionally. Belief is one of those hyperintensions. In hyperintensions we are substituting noesis rather than equivalent noema and thus getting differences.</p><p>[<a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Transparent_Intensional_Logic">Transparent Intensional Logic | Wikiwand</a>]</p><p>[<a href="https://www.academia.edu/7994695/Counterfactual_Reasoning">Counterfactual Reasoning</a>]</p><p>[<a href="http://substantialmatters.blogspot.com/2009/03/age-of-hyperintensionality.html">The Age of Hyperintensionality</a>]</p><p>Once we have seen that we need a concept related to a system that is equivalent but different from essence, i.e. unique to the emergent level of the system because it deals with features not attributes, that is to say the idea of the NUCLEUS of the System. Then we can recast the whole question in terms of these various types of schematic “essences” by asking what is the relation of structures of patterns, to essences of form, to nuclei of systems. The best example of a formal structural system that contains all these three schematic levels is <em>Architecture of Systems Problem Solving</em> by George Klir.</p><p>Klir bases his theory at the level of pattern and talks about configurations of variables, and he uses these configurations of variables to describe the level of forms and system. Thus in a sense he reduces form and system to pattern, the lowest common denominator. This makes his Systems Theory primarily structural. What if we don’t want to do this reduction but instead want each schematic level to stand by itself as well as to interrelate with the others in a nested fashion. Then we would have to complicate the picture given by Klir by introducing essences and nuclei of the system. Klir more of less assumes that variables can stand for any of these levels which is true but still this is a reductionistic account.</p><p>Structures organize all the possible characteristics within patterns. Essences organize all the possible combinations of attributes within forms. Nuclei organize all possible features of Systems. But organizing the characteristics, Structures allow all possible patterns of a certain sort to be generated. By organizing the attributes, Essences allow all possible forms to be generated. By organizing the features, nuclei allow all possible systems of a specific type to be generated.</p><p>This pretty well means that Principle, in the sense of Li can be thought of as the meta-structure of structure. And by analogy there may be a set of principles related to forms, that are quintessences, or meta-essences. And also there may be principles that are meta-nuclei of systems. These second order structures, essences or nuclei only have a name with respect to form which is quintessence, that is traditionally related to ether as opposed to the four normal Greek elements of earth, air, fire, water. In other words, it is though as a sublimation. Essentially these are meta-constraints on constraints which are rules that constrain rules that constrain characteristics, attributes or features. This sublimation at the higher degree of the structure, essence or feature has the right to be called a principle in all cases. Interestingly there is no general term for what is called here structure, essence and nucleus. But we can call them a “Nerve”. [<a href="https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Nerve_(category_theory)">Nerve (category theory) | Wikiwand</a>] So a principle governs a nerve which in turn governs the wholeness of the schema. This essentially gives us then the equivalent of the Chinese Li in our Western thought structures except for the fact that the Chinese work up from the concrete case to the abstraction rather than starting from the abstraction and working down.</p><p>Notice that these powers of the sublimation could go up several levels. These specifically are articulated in the design field in my second dissertation. See <a href="http://emergentdesign.net/">General Schemas Theory Research</a>. There is essentially a Cartesian cross of the Philosophical Principles and the Meta-levels of Being. But we can simplify this with regard to nerves by marking the level of their powers: Nerve^p. A lot of times in Science the Nerve³ level are called Laws, as in laws of nature. Laws are necessary, and in this sense the constraints are constrained by necessity.</p><p>Our point here is that All schemas have nerves, and that the nerves have powers. Nerve¹ is the nerve itself which organizes the content of the schema giving it structure, essence or a nucleus in the cases of pattern, form, and system. Nerve² are nerve related constraints of constraints called principles, and Nerve³ are constraints on constraints of constraints called Laws. All schemas have the equivalent of nerves, and the meta-levels of constraints up to the definition of contingency and necessity. A good source for this kind of model is Monod <em>Chance and Necessity</em>. Monod constricts a teleonomic system by interleaving layers of constraint and necessity which is how he thinks evolution works. But between contingency and necessity there is also conditionality which means that things are not random nor determined but conditional based on circumstances.</p><p>So let us extend this idea to the level of Meta-system (OpenScape). This schema is what exists from the boundary of the system to the horizon in the landscape in which the system exists. It is detotalized and disunified and a <em>general economy</em> rather than a <em>restricted economy</em> in the sense of Bataille. It is based on compementarities and is formally defined by the Universal Turing machine as opposed to the normal Turing machine. It can be described by rules just like the system, but the rules have to do with the allotment of resources and signaling using protocols between systems within the meta-system and also to the meta-system by the contained systems. Meta-systems a lot resources to Systems within their arena. Meta-systems are composed of source, horizon origin and arena. Systems and anti-systems appear from sources within the arena at origin points and they move through and interact with each other and their environment within the arena until they exit through anti-origins (sinks) and return to the source. Object Oriented programming systems are an example. The source is the object template. This object template gets instantiated and then is executed interacting with other objects within the system, until the various instances are killed off. The objects interact by calling each others methods with parameters which then allow the objects to change their state of internal data based on the interactions and call other objects. All the objects in the same application together are called a system. Our question is what is the nerve of the meta-system or open-scape. There is no name for it. In general meta-systems are invisible to us within our tradition. The only way we can see them is producing the inverse dual of the system realizing that the system is not self-dual. What is the non-self-dual dual of the System. We call it the Meta-system or OpenScape.</p><p>But the Meta-system schema’s nerve has no name, but we can call the nerve of this schema a “NEXUS” in the Meta-system or OpenScape. This is because the nexus of a meta-system is normally a constraint on complementary opposites that characterize the field of the arena within the meta-system. We will call what the nexus controls by its constraints field properties. In meta-systems these field properties are complementary like between electricity and magnetism. Once we have the name of the <em>nexus </em>that constrains the field properties then we can consider the relation of the meta-system to the systems that it contains in terms of Hegel’s critique. If the systems are in themselves and not for the other then we are merely conscious but not self-conscious of them. Thus we need to make the systems for the other of the meta-system and the meta-system for the other of the system. And if they are for each other then the system and the meta-system are for themselves rather than just in themselves. You can only be for yourself through the other, being either the contained or the container.</p><p>This plays out in an interesting way in relation to the system and meta-systems because either may be either emergent or de-emergent. Emergent Systems are wholes greater than the sum of their parts and they overflow supervenience, isomorphic relations between superstructure and base. De-emergent systems are taken apart by analysis and thus do not have their emergent properties that they would have if properly assembled. This is like the difference between a car taken apart or put together by the mechanic. But interestingly usually the meta-system is considered de-emergent, in other words it is the field or proto-gestalt within which the parts are arranged in relation to each other when taken apart, i.e. the floor of the garage on which the parts are strewn. To the mechanic this is a field in which the parts have dispositions to go back together to make the car work. To an ordinary person they are just junk thrown out on the floor with no implications with respect to each other. But there is a possibility of an Emergent Meta-system, i.e. a meta-systemic field with its own emergent properties. And this is produced by a combination of the special systems (that appear in the interstice between system and meta-system) along with the normal system which gives an Emergent Meta-system. We can characterize the difference between emergence and de-emergence in terms of the realization of inner relations between parts. Thus we can characterize the difference between in itself and for itself of Hegel, along with for others and in others as the means to distinguish emergence from de-emergence, or what we have known up till now as the blindness to content or the blindness of the content. So when the systems are in themselves and the meta-system is in itself then it is merely supervenitent. But if the system contents become for the other of the meta-system, and the meta-system becomes for the other of the system, then they escape supervenience. The system then becomes a whole greater than the sum of its parts, and the addition is what the system knows about its contents beyond the mere containment of them. We can use the term “knows” because the schemas are templates of intelligibility of spacetime configurations. Schemas are a kind of knowledge of things organized in spacetime. In other words the system schema, it knows and responds to the essence of its forms. And the same thing can be said of the meta-system except it is always a whole less than the sum of its parts. That means that what it knows of and responds to the nucleus of its constituent systems that is always less than the sum of its parts. But if the meta-system is emergent then it knows more despite having holes in the meta-system, i.e. niches for systems, and this appears as its own counter organization that complements the system. Now special systems are supervenient. And that means they have a special knowledge that balances for itself and for others, with in itself and in others, and this is called in-and-for-itself. Special Systems are in and for themselves. This makes them examples of Concrete Universals or in another terminology Holons.</p><p>See . . .</p><p><a href="http://archonic.net/rastnopY.pdf">http://archonic.net/rastnopY.pdf</a> <a href="https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Special_Systems_Theory">https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Special_Systems_Theory</a></p><p>In general we can say that it is important to identify the equivalent of the “essence of the form” for all the schemas. We have identified these as the ‘structure of the pattern’, the ‘nucleus of the system’, and the ‘nexus of the meta-system’. And once we have these various <em>nerves</em> defined then we have the ability to think about the knowledge that each of them has about the other, in other words does the contained know about the container and does the container know about the contained in each case. They know about each other by their response to the nerve of each. And these nerves can reach deep through their various levels of sublimation.</p><p>Patterns know about the content of its monads via the nerve of the monads that it contains.</p><p>Form knows about the content of its patterns of monads via the structure of the patterns of the monads.</p><p>System knows about the content of its forms of patterns via the essence of the forms of the patterned monads.</p><p>Meta-system knows about the content of its systems of its forms via nuclei of the systems of and the essences of the forms and the structures of the patterns of monads it contains.</p><p>Likewise Pattern knows about its form container through understanding and responding to the essence of the form that contains it.</p><p>Form knows about its system container through understanding and responding to the nucleus of the system that contains it.</p><p>System knows about its meta-system container through understanding and responding to the nexus of the meta-system that contains it.</p><p>Meta-system knows about its Domain container through understanding and responding to the nerve of the Domain that contains it.</p><p>In each case the relation between the nerves of the schemas make explicit the implicit internal relations between the elements at each schematic level to the other schematic level. These internal relations appear as negative information at each level within the whole of the schema. In this way we address the criticism of Kant and all purely formal systems by Hegel. Every schema has an internal set of constraints that govern its functioning. These internal constraints may function at different levels of sublimation. As we go up these levels they become less correlations and more like causes, less like principles and more like laws. Therefore, when we ask what is a principle or what is a pattern there is a wider framework given by Schemas Theory in which these questions can be answered. We do not just have to answer these questions a vacuum where principle and pattern stand in opposition to each other without considering anything else. Rather, it is much better to consider this question in a context where it can have an answer that is not arbitrary or just conventional. We live in a philosophical and scientific community that tends to be purely formal since B. Russell attempted to kill the idea of Bradley of Internal Relations taken from Hegel. But Hegel’s critique still stands as valid in relation to all kinds of formalists. But how does this apply when we recognize more types of schemas than merely form? We have to identify the nerve of every schema. We have identified nerves for Pattern (Structure), Form (Essence), System (Nucleus) and Meta-system (Nexus). Then we see that the understanding of one schema in relation to another means to come to terms with its nerve, i.e. to recognize it and respond to it coming to know it. Unless you understand the structure generating the patterns then you will never be able to account for it as a container form. And pattern unless it understands the essence of the form will never be able to respond to it properly within its context. So the connection of nerves of each schema to each other is their proper knowledge of the other, and it is only through knowledge of the other that it can have complete knowledge of itself. So basically a given schema is only in itself unless it comprehends and reacts to the nerves of its adjacent schemas, both those it contains and those it is contained by, its containers. But this is the same as having internal relations at each schematic level where each level is treated as a whole itself that is only really known through the other adjacent levels but not purely on its own as a formalism of a given schematic level.</p><p>See <a href="https://www.academia.edu/29403507/Schematic_Nerves">Schematic Nerves</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81d067cd6f5c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Note on the meaning of “complexity”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts/note-on-the-meaning-of-complexity-6362002fbd93?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6362002fbd93</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Feb 2014 20:33:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-02-11T20:33:04.052Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In an email discussion I am involved in the question was rasied if “Complexity” Theory was related to “Complex Numbers”.</p><p>Normally when the various books about complexity talk about it they are not specifically thinking about complex or imaginary numbers. They are talking about a determinate set of things which is not just complicated but complex. But “complexity” has the other meaning of imaginary numbers which is usually not meant.<br>Here is the problem. When “complex” or “imaginary” numbers were discovered they did not know what to do with them and so they just gave them random names that signified that they were hard to talk about and think about. They were “imaginary” rather than real. They were “complex” rather than just complicated or simple. But it turns out that these names although just meant to distinguish them from what we were used to in terms of mathematics were apropos in many ways to the nature of the numbers themselves and the fact that they were useful for describing physical phenomena meant we started thinking about the phenomena that they described along those lines such that there was a feed back loop between how we conceived them and what they ended up signifying and how we understood the phenomena to which they were applied.<br>If complexification means “complex or imaginary numbers” and phenomena that lends itself to being described by that kind of mathematics then this changes what is normally meant by complex dynamics or complex systems. Complex as it is used normally for systems means we don’t understand them and they are so difficult to understand that we will never untangle what is going on in the phenomena so we need to consider them as a whole rather than in pieces. While complicated means that it is like a mechanism but it is just a rather large and difficult to understand mechanism but ultimately it can be unentangled and understood determinately and discreetly if we were to take the time and effort to do so. Complexity means that we do not believe that there is enough time, effort, or computing power to understand the system discretely due to the entangled and enmeshed and ensnared nature of its relations.<br>Let me give an example I just learned about. Groupoids. 3-element groupoids have been completely determined <a href="http://www.math.uwaterloo.ca/~snburris/htdocs/gpd.html">3-ELEMENT GROUPOIDS</a>. But 4-element groupoids are seen as beyond the possibilities of computation. And what is more distrurbing is that there appears to be some of them which are themselves not finite at the 4 element level and so not only would it take too long to compute them given current computing power, even if we could there might be anomalous 4 element groupoids that themselves were nonfinite, which is very strange indeed. 2 elment groupoids are determinate. 3-groupoids are complicated but still discrete. 4 element groupoids are complex because even if we could compute them all, i.e. we had much faster computers, we would still find groupoids among them that were not determinate in the finitary sense. So given this mathematical example it becomes clear what the difference between determinateness, complicatedness and complexity is and the “imaginary or complex” numbers play no role here in this case.<br>However, if we take complexification to mean that we have somehow crossed the threshold into a phenomena that needs the “complex and imaginary” numbers to sort out and describe, then we have entered a whole different kind of complexity which is the realm that I call <a href="http://www.mediafire.com/?uuju8koj0cib513"><strong>Speical Systems Theory</strong></a><strong>.</strong><br>That is a realm in which the Hypercomplex Algebras provide the principle of organization. And I don’t believe that is what most people mean when they talk about complex systems, but it is definitely a variety of complexity but only one kind among others. It is an important kind because it is determinate but entangled in a way that cannot be unentangled. The entanglement is determined by the complex numbers and the higher hypercomplex numbers which are Quaternions and Octonions and even Sedenions. Basically what I have done in Special Systems Theory is work out the Systems Theoretic meaning of these mathematical structures for this kind of Complexity. For further information see my electronic book at<a href="http://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer">http://works.bepress.com/kent_palmer</a> on Reflexive Autopoietic Dissipative Special Systems Theory. I think there are many kinds of complexity and this is an important one which is actually based on complex numbers, but there are other types of indeterminacy, entanglement as well and I think that when people are thinking of complex systems they are not specifically thinking of systems driven by the hypercomplex numbers for their organization.</p><p>It is unfortunate that there is a confusion in the meanings of the word “complexity”. But it gives me a way to explain what I have been doing all these years, which is to explore the kind of complex system that is explicitly organized by hypercomplex algebras which is an esoteric type of complexity but I would argue a very important one because it is what makes Life, Consciousnes, and the Social possible. It is the kind of Complexity referred to by R. Rosen in Life Itself even though he did not realize it at the time. But the loops of entailment that he talks about as making biology possible as a science are a key part of the structure of hypercomplex algebras. Recently I presented my ideas on General Schemas Theory to the <a href="http://incose.org/">Page on incose.org</a> working group on Systems Science. Just let me within that context that Special Systems Theory is also a ‘schema’, however it is a special set of sub-schemas that is between the System and the Meta-system and is partially Systemic and partially Meta-systemic. General Schemas Theory is the background for the exploration of Special Systems which are Holonomic in the sense of the term coined by Koestler.</p><p>See <a href="http://holonomic.net/CSER2008paper125_PalmerKD_complexity_emergence_080204a.pdf"><strong>Emergence and Complexity in relation to General Schemas Theory</strong></a></p><p><a href="http://holonomic.net/CSER%202008%20Palmer%20080403kdp08a.ppt"><strong>Meta-systems, Complexity and Emergence .ppt</strong></a></p><p>For General Schemas Theory see <a href="http://holonomic.net/CSERbrief/CSER%20The%20Foundations%20of%20General%20Schemas%20Theory%20v13%20040414.ppt">Final thirteenth version for CSER Presentation</a>and <a href="http://holonomic.net/paper100_PalmerKD_Genera_Schemas_Theory040230e_final.doc">Final version E of General Schemas Theory short paper</a> and <a href="http://holonomic.net/General_Schemas_Theory_PALMER_060422kdp10.pdf">Longer Explanation of Research Program</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6362002fbd93" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts/note-on-the-meaning-of-complexity-6362002fbd93">Note on the meaning of “complexity”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts">Emergent Thoughts</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Foundations of Special Systems Theory]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts/the-foundations-of-special-systems-theory-88c1df243e50?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88c1df243e50</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Feb 2014 18:48:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-02-09T18:48:29.083Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/5767934/Foundations_of_Special_Systems_Theory_In_the_Name_of_the_Completion_of_Nature_Chapter_01_">Foundations of Special Systems Theory: In the Name of the Completion of Nature (Chapter 01 </a>)</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/5778546/Foundations_of_Special_Systems_Theory_C.S._Peirces_Name_taken_in_Vane_i.e._semiotically_Chapter_02_">Foundations of Special Systems Theory: C.S. Peirce’s Name taken in Vane , (i.e. semiotically) (Chapter 02</a>)</p><p><a href="https://www.academia.edu/5779531/Foundations_of_Special_Systems_Theory_Kantian_Categories_as_a_Model_of_the_Six_Core_Lacunae_as_the_Abstential_Eventities_of_Ententional_Phenomena_within_Autopoietic_Symbiotic_Systems_in_a_Reflexive_Social_Field_Chapter_03_">Foundations of Special Systems Theory: Kantian Categories as a Model of the Six Core Lacunae as the Abstential Eventities of Ententional Phenomena within Autopoietic Symbiotic Systems in a Reflexive Social Field (Chapter 03 </a>)</p><p>My reaction to the work of Terrence Deacon called Incomplete Nature based on <a href="https://www.academia.edu/3795281/Speical_Systems_Theory">Speical Systems Theory</a>.</p><p>Deacon’s work provides interesting foundations for Special Systems Theory by rethinking some basic ideas in Physics like information, entropy, thermodynamics and other concepts key to understanding life, and consciousness and the social and how there is a necessary gap between normal science and what is needed for these special topics that seem to violate normal physical science. Also of importance in this regard is Robert Rosen’s Life Itself which makes room for Biology in Physical Science though noting that complex entailment structures leave room for Life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88c1df243e50" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts/the-foundations-of-special-systems-theory-88c1df243e50">The Foundations of Special Systems Theory</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/emergent-thoughts">Emergent Thoughts</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why is Heidegger Significant?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/being-time/why-is-heidegger-significant-a91200628529?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a91200628529</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Nov 2013 08:33:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-11-05T08:33:46.324Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We can see from our critique of Zizek’s ahistorical presentation of Lacan one of the reasons that Heidegger is important. Heidegger sets off this whole progression. Without Heidegger there would have not been this progression. There would have been something else, something probably closer to Husserl, and thus nothing nearly as deep. The whole progression revolves around the transition to existentialism which was actually pioneered by Jaspers, but after the fact was associated with Kierkegaard, Dostoyevsky, and Nietzsche. But it was Heidegger that pushed Existentialism over the edge into its popularity by delving deeply into the facticity of life, i.e. the lifeworld, in the form of dasein as being-in-the-world. Heidegger established a new universe of discourse with a new terminology borrowed from Jaspers but deepened by a thorough analysis of dasein, i.e. what is before the difference between Subject and Object in the realm of meaning with respect to the facticity of life. Being and Time is a tour de force in every respect, especially when we understand it as Kisiel does in the context of the courses Heidegger taught beforehand. Heidegger in B&amp;T did something unprecedented, which was to push into a completely new territory for philosophy by going back to Aristotle and seeing that the kinds of knowledge that he described were actually wider than the modern concept of knowledge which had been narrowed to epiteme only. Heidegger then used the different types of knowledge identified by Aristotle to push back into techne and then into phronesis as ways of knowing that had been more or less abandoned by Philosophy, and gave them an ontological interpretation as ways of being-in-the-world. Phronesis is equivalent to Dasein, Techne to ready-to-hand and Episteme to present-at-hand which are equiprimordial kinds of Being, i.e. Pure and Process Being. Heidegger thus opened up the realm of the meta-levels of Being that Continental Philosophy has explored. These higher kinds of Being were known in antiquity, by Plato and in Myth and Epic but had been forgotten. Heidegger opened up the realm of the kinds of Being to be discovered again. French Continental Philosophy launched into that new realm and that produced a Renaissance of Thought of which Zizek and Badiou are the last vestiges. But what happened in France after the war for the last 60 years or so will be the basis for all significant philosophy for a long time to come. And it is all primarily Heideggarian in its impetus. It shows the slow and measured digestion of Heidegger’s philosophy that followed out the way that it had sketched discovering much more than Heidegger could ever have imagined. In fact Heidegger went completely the opposite way from the meta-levels of Being by discarding Ontological Difference and developing his ideas of Beyng (Seyn). He unleashed Pandora’s box and that scared him, he tried to put the genie back in the bottle. But by doing that he pushed to an even deeper level which has not yet been appreciated fully. How could it we are still coming to terms with Being and Time and its implications as played out in French Philosophy in the later part of the Twentieth Century. Our point is that if we take it as a whole it makes a lot of sense, especially when interpreted based on the Higher Logical Type theory of Russell as the disclosure of meta-levels of Being. Each thinker makes a discrete transform based on his understanding of Heidegger’s initial position in B&amp;T or in the later works. This series of transformations is like what we read in Phenomenology of Mind/Geist/Spirit, except it is a supplement or an appendix that goes beyond Hegel and thus Kant. They are positions with an inner logic which is being worked out. In the Phenomenology Hegel may describe more than two positions at a given stage in the unfolding of spirit. The dialectical working out of the relation of one stage to another can have multiple dialectical moments. What we are saying is that the French reception of Heidegger and Husserl has this type of inner logic which we can ultimately understand as being based on the meta-levels of Being. In other words there is a progressive process by which disclosure is disclosed. This is unlike anything described by Hegel in the Phenomenology. But this is because Heidegger broke through to the level at which disclosure revealed itself as fundamental. Of course, the French Philosophers had no idea where they were going. They were each performing their own analysis of the situation at each stage and reacting to what had been revealed previously by others. They were making moves in accord with the logic of the situation as it stood at each point along the way. But because each of them were in the new territory opened up by Heidegger, the basic impetus and understanding of the realm in which they were in has to be taken back to Heidegger’s B&amp;T for us to understand it.</p><p>Heidegger gives us the basic reference guide to the region he opened up which was being explored and elaborated beyond his expectations and dreams by others who sometimes understood the new territory better than he did. In fact, while they opened up the territory revealed by Ontological Difference he instead opened up a new territory which is its dual, that of Ontological Indifference, i.e. Beyng. And there is plenty of more room for this exploration to continue. There is a whole continent new to thought out there to be explored, claimed and settled. There are many French Colonies in this new territory but that does not mean that they will end up owning it ultimately. Sometimes colonies declare independence. But if they hardly have an overview of what has happened, what has been disclosed about disclosure, then how can we expect Americans to understand what is going on. The Americans are savaging for the most part the remains of what the French have achieved and have not gotten to the point where they themselves can contribute as yet. But there is a shift because we can see that Badiou and Zizek are the spent energy of the renaissance that occurred in France. The French are so desperate some of them have actually taken on the mantle of Analytic philosophers. Slowly, very late to the party American Universities are starting to produce Ph.D.s in Continental Philosophy. And with so many English Departments needing to have students who have viewpoints on literature to write about, the tide is turning toward Continental philosophy in Academia. Unfortunately, those in English Departments for the most part do not understand Continental Philosophy very well as yet. But when there are American Philosophers with a Continental bent to consult this will slowly change. We are right at the turning point where Continental Thought has not yet been corrupted completely by American interest as yet and when some of those who were alive during the heyday of the renaissance of Continental thought are still with us. That is we are right at the point where histories of the various French movements are starting to be released. And when Heidegger’s courses and other unpublished works are seeing the light of day. And most of the main streams that come out of Heidegger’s thought have been explored enough to see the big picture. So we are lucky to be living right at this time when philosophy has been renewed but has not yet reified completely. And at the center of this whole spectacle is the works of Heidegger which are amazing in their depth and their breadth. So lets take advantage of it to learn as much as we can about our worldview, now that this new perspective on it has opened up, before the door closes again. Reification is inevitable, especially when Academia in America gets into full swing digesting this new way of looking at the world. We need to pay attention to what has been disclosed before it is covered over again, with its own style of reification, like what happened with Deconstruction. As has been mentioned Deconstruction is an American phenomenon not a Continental phenomenon. It is the nihilistic outcome of the American adoption and interpretation of the work of Derrida mostly in English Departments. It is an imitation of Derrida’s style of thinking probably without understanding the fundamental impetus that led to it, i.e. the exploration of Hyper Being. And of course the Americans going to extremes in it has given Deconstruction a bad name, making it synonymous with Nihilism. Whether the later works of Derrida deserve this ignominy I do not know, but the early works were on to something very interesting, i.e. exploring for the first time Hyper Being which eventually was realized by Sallis to be the Third Kind of Being in Plato’s Timaeus, and thus justified as having a reserved but forgotten place within the tradition.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a91200628529" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/being-time/why-is-heidegger-significant-a91200628529">Why is Heidegger Significant?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/being-time">Being &amp; Time</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Placing Lacan Deeper in his Historical Context]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/being-time/placing-lacan-deeper-in-his-historical-context-166b8aa11270?source=rss-47ad7e09cbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/166b8aa11270</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kentpalmer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Nov 2013 07:02:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-11-05T07:02:44.563Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If we follow the hypothesis that Sartre is the vanishing mediator between Lacan and Heidegger then I think we can make some headway in understanding the relation between Lacan via Zizek in the context of Heidegger. But we need to step back and get some perspective by understanding the breakthrough that Heidegger made into the realm of Dasein, i.e. the realm prior to the distinction between Subject and Object, a realm not entered before in Western Philosophy. All the problems of the split between Subject and Object, or more personally between mind and body were most evident in the work of Husserl who tried to radicalize Kant’s philosophy by peering into the functioning of consciousness itself via the method of phenomenology. Heidegger set out to not just solve these problems but to radicalize phenomenology itself by looking at the factic life, i.e. life beneath not just the level of abstraction, but also beneath the level of essence perception as defined by Husserl which gives us the What of the object independently of our abstract representations of it. As Crowell points out Heidegger always stayed true to the project of phenomenology as a search for the realm of meaning. But for Heidegger as we learn from Kisiel the search for the understanding of life itself in its facticity was the ultimate aim of his phenomenology from the beginning. Heidegger was a very clever philosopher and brought to bear many innovations in order to move beyond Husserl’s phenomenology of essences into a phenomenology of religion which searches into the facticity of life. He develops the concept of the formal indication as a way at getting at the factic beyond the essences. The factic is the arena of the uniqueness of a given life prior to any kind of abstraction or generality. Heidegger approaches this through the work of Emil Lask as applied to Duns Scotus. Heidegger in his course work is seen to reinvent his terminology and approach to the material over and over again attempting to get closer to the facticity of life itself. Eventually Being and Time would be the result of this search for a way into the description of life as lived prior to the advent of the Subject/Object distinction. Heidegger starts off after the First World War in his first class with the idea that he is studying the Human Situation which is composed of the environment, the self-world and the with-world. Eventually the term Dasein (Being There) is developed as the formal indication of being-in-the-world situation prior to Subjects and Objects being distinguished. In B&amp;T Dasein and things within the world are distinguished by using completely different vocabularies to talk about Existenz-Existenitals-Existentiells human situations verses Ontos-Categories-Ontic things found in situations. Part of what Heidegger does is develop the modalities of dasein’s being-in-the-world that are divided into ready-to-hand (Process Being, essences, Heraclitus) and present-at-hand (Pure Being, abstractions, Parmenides). The key point is that these ways of dealing with things encountered in the world, are different from the ways of dealing with other dasein encountered in the with-world of mitsein. We can treat other dasein in these degenerate modes for instance in Aristotle’s ideas of friendship which has the degenerate modes of friendship based on pleasure and usefulness. But true friendship is between equals and is based on requiting the other with good not expecting anything in return.<br>For Lacan who was always interested in Surrealists works you can see how existentialism would be appealing, but it was only when he discovered Structuralism and Semiotics that he felt he had the tools to rethink Psychonanalysis given to him by Freud. We must be clear that in B&amp;T itself Structuralism of Dasein as a whole and Semiotics are combined with hermeneutics and phenomenology. This gave a clear interpretive framework of daseinanalysis which would unite the various strands that Lacan sought to use to reinterpret the Freudian vision of psychoanalysis in terms of existential phenomenology. But there is a problem which is for Heidegger the Subject has been abandoned due to all the philosophical problems it causes. But for the patients of Lacan there was still the struggle to be subjects, ultimately the struggle with madness or neurosis. So how do we look back at the subject from the position gained by Heidegger prior to the arising of Subject and Object, to understand Subjects and their Desire for Objects? Here enters Sartre who is the major interpreter of Heidegger in France, who produces from his reading of Heidegger a Humanist form of Existenitalism. Sartre’s descriptions of consciousness were always more intriguing than the descriptions of dasein which tend to seen inhuman even though they are mean to be more true to the human situation. And this is because we are expected to see ourselves as subjects by the big Other, i.e. the They (Das Mann). Sartre inverted Heidegger’s idea of Process Being (taken from Husserl) and produced the idea that consciousness was like a black hole and that not only was it nothing but it was a dynamic self negating nothingness, and things fell into the singularity of the black hole of consciousness on a regular basis. This view of consciousness as revolving around nothing and things falling into nothingness at the core of consciousness was very persuasive because it allowed us to use the terminology of Hegel to describe the activity of consciousness captured by phenomenology. Sartre talks about being-in-itself of objects in consciousness, and being-for-itself of self-consciousness, and being-in-and-for-itself in which through a dynamic negation of negation consciousness produces itself as a synthesis even though there is literally nothing there and that nothing is self-negating in its dynamics. Since it has been a long time since I read Being and Nothingness I don’t pretend that this is an accurate summary. But the key point is that Sartre’s vision can be used by Lacan to understand how the subject might look from the point of view of daseinanalysis and that gives a framework for reinterpreting Freud using Structuralism and Semiotics within the rubric of existential phenomenology as it was understand in France before and during the war as well as sometime after up until Letter on Humanism where Heidegger broke the spell of Sartre’s interpretation of Heidegger in France. Meanwhile there was the work of Merleau-Ponty which was truer to the work of both Husserl and Heidegger that was a counter point to the work of Sartre. Merleau-Ponty genuinely extended the kinds of Being that Heidegger had discovered, and added to them Hyper and Wild Being. Derrida worked on comprehending Hyper Being as Differance and later Deleuze worked on comprehending Wild Being. Lacan seems to have understood Derrida and used part of his work within his own work, while Deleuze coming later took parts of Lacan’s work as the basis for his own works. There was a lot of cross-fertilization going on in France through these years which was a renaissance in Philosophy. Basically French Continental Philosophy rediscovered the meta-levels of Being and explored them fully. Deleuze and Guattair used Wild Being as a basis to try to create an anti-Lacanian psychoanalysis called schizoanalysis. Derrida read texts and Lacan read people. But of the two Lacan was the most laconic and obscure. Derrida though difficult to read and understand was at least potentially understandable with the right type of background in Heidegger that comprehended the move that produced Heidegger’s Being (crossed out).<br>Zizek is quick to point out that we should forget Derrida and Deleuze. But Zizek has lost Sartre in Oblivion as far as I can see, and because of that it is very difficult to fit Lacan into the historical context that he deserves to be understood within. The reading of Lacan via Hegel and Hegel via Lacan is not all that helpful. It merely lends authority to Zizek’s interpretation without clarifying where Lacan stands himself, except that we learn that he was right about everything, just as Hegel was before him, and that Lacan was basically just saying what Hegel had said before in terms of psychoanalysis which we can apply to all kinds of cultural objects nowdays, especially to movies. Badiou gives us more of a model of Lacan’s thought. Where Lacan has the registers Real, Imaginary, and Symbolic, Badiou gives us Event, Multiple, and Set Ontology. In Lacan the Symbolic order is produced by the big Other. And the subject is basically a self-negation, hole within that order. The subject uses the Imaginary to fend off being overwhelmed by the Real. The key point is that the nothingness (negation of nothing) of Sartre is similar to the desire of desire of the Lacanian subject which finds its locus clasicus in the place where Heidegger talks about the nullifying of nullity that is at the core of Dasein. Instead of considering the Subject as a Form as Aristotle did in De Anima which has always been standard in the Western tradition, Lacan considers the subject structurally and based on semiotics both at the pattern level of the schemas below the form level. These more sophisticated methods allows Lacan to devour Freud using Hegel as the master template for understanding psychosis and neurosis, and reinterpreting everything in psychoanalyses on this new more modern basis.<br>What is interesting to us is that Lacan and Jung are very similar and not really at odds with each other. I understand that Lacan actually worked under Jung at some point in his career. Jung until Hillman’s deconstruction was getting really boring. But Hillman’s deconstruction of Jung is very dissatisfying, like deconstructionism in general due to its inherent nihilism. The mixture of Jung’s theory of Archetypes and the rooting of that theory in Alchemy gives a basis for understanding the psyche more deeply, in a similar way that Lacan’s structural semiosis does standard psychoanalysis. If we combine Jung and Lacan and understand Lacan within the context of daseinanalysis augmented by the antimony of nothingness developed by Sartre to the Process Being of Heidegger, then I think we have a much more interesting view of the possibilities of Psychoanalysis. Let me add to that a crucial point that we also need to consider the psychology of Nietzsche as being the dual of that of Jung. The influence of Nietzsche on Lacan is not so clear. Nietzsche’s psychology is Dionysian (Shiva) while that of Jung is Apollonian (Brahma) and we can see Heidegger’s Daseinanalysis as nondual between these because it abandons the idea of the distinction between subject and object, while all the various psychoanalysis programs cling to the subject because it is a well-established part of the big Other (They, Das Mann). And obviously patients also cling to the subject as well as they consider the functioning of subjectivity in terms of the ego’s coherence as normalcy. Heidegger did not develop his metontology that would explore the level of existentiells. So we don’t know what that would have been like. But Lacan provides a view of what it might be like as a field given the idea that the Subject is a gap or hole in Being, and the desiring of desire is a negative but reflexive process like nothingness in Sartre. I am thinking that Lacan is probably closer to Sartre than Hegel. And it is by the rooting of both Lacan and Sartre in Hegel that Zizek can make the case that Hegel is the source of Lacanian insight. There is a chance that Sartre is the closer source of that insight and that the Hegel connection is mediated by Kojeve and Sartre. Sartre however did not attend the Kojeve seminars on Hegel and so his access to Hegel was different from that of other contemporaries. As I said I think that perhaps Sartre is the vanishing mediator between Lacan and Hegel, and the connection is not at direct as Zizek makes out.<br>Our point is that if we understand Lacan in this historical context rather than merely in direct relation to Hegel, then we get a better picture of what Lacan might have been up to than we get through Zizek. Although I have to admit without Zizek I would not have come close to understanding Lacan at all. However, the co-reduction of Lacan to Hegel and Hegel to Lacan seems somewhat artificial. Going back to Hegel, reinterpreting him in relation to Lacan, then saying Lacan was really only interpreting Hegel all along . . . all this is not going to save Marxism from the dustbin of history. Rather if we want to save Marxism (I am not saying we do) then the route taken by Sartre in Critique of Dialectical Reason is better, i.e. rethink dialectics dialectically rather than mechanically as did Marxism. The Lacanian interpretation of the Ideological epiphenomena is interesting, but not fundamental. The irony is that Zizek is a lightweight compared to Sartre in Critique of Dialectical Reasonbut unfortunately no one reads that book by which Sartre tried to redeem himself after Being and Nothingness. But we are not sure that book needs to be redeemed. At a fundamental level Sartre was not a Nazi, or a collaborator, but a resistance fighter, and that demands our respect over and above the Nazism of Heidegger. Sartre was a Communist but he did not fall for Stalinism as did many others. Sartre is the very model of integrity in a philosopher. Bernard-Henri Levy attempts to give us a picture of what we should resuscitate Sartre instead of relegating him to Oblivion as Zizek seems to do.<br>By placing Lacan back in context and recognizing the other influences on him other than Hegel which is emphasized by Zizek, then we can begin to get a better picture of a road forward in our attempting to understand the relations between these various figures and the ways of thinking they championed. Lacan looked back from the place that Heidegger created prior to subject and object called daseinanalysis toward the Subject via the ideas of Sartre. In many ways like Foucault who admitted that he used Heidegger’s thought as a template for his own, substituting Power and Knowledge for Being, and by going back to Nietzsche’s idea of Genealogy we received many innovative works. We can see Lacan as secretly doing something similar but more complex. Once the way is opened up to Daseinanalysis that gives us a road to structuralism and semiotics which we can then combine with phenomenology and hermeneutics to produce a very powerful analytic regime that does not have the problems of Husserl’s phenomenology, and which has a bridge to Hegel. But Daseinanalysis without the promised but undelivered metontology is baren, and so Lacan probably used the existentialism of Sartre and its antinomic reversal of Process Being in Heidegger in order to look back on the Self as negating negation as a process, i.e. nothingness. This is hinted at in Heidegger as a possibility for understanding Dasein. Thus Heidegger’s attempt to distance himself from Humanism of Sartre’s interpretation is somewhat ingenuous. The difference is really that Sartre upheld the idea of freedom against all odds, while Heidegger believed in Fate, and also National Socialism. Sartre even as a communist rejected Stalinism. In other words when it came to standing by his principles when they became politically inconvenient he had the integrity to follow his own principles unlike Heidegger who capitulated to the Nazis and did their dirty work. Knowing about the They did not save his own Dasein, he and his thought became sullied by the association with Nazism. Lacan in later years distances himself from Heidegger, saying that his work is not essential to his own insights. I think this is wrong. Heidegger was essential for all the French Existentialists. It is just that what Heidegger was after was deeper than anyone imagined. We are still trying to come to terms with what he meant, after all this time. Being and Time has hardly yet been understood in spite of all the scholarly effort so far, and we have not even begun to scratch the surface of the later Heidegger’s unpublished works like Contributions. But Heidegger did something essential which was to define the origin prior to the split between subject and object as Dasein, and then shows that we can conceive of there being structure there and semiotics. Lacan seized that as the basis for his bringing structuralism and semiotics to bear on Freud’s texts and the practice of psychoanalysis. But to do that Lacan needed the subject still, but reinterpreted at the level of pattern rather than form, and it was via Sartre that he found a way to gain that perspective by making use of the idea of Nothingness as the desire of desire, i.e. the reflective process of desire by a subject who is merely a gap, hole, lacunae.<br>Once we understand this connection with Heidegger and Sartre then we can put the interpretations of Zizek into context and understand his elucidations of Lacan better. The fundamental dialectic is Sartrean and only by that mediation Hegelian. But Lacan is understanding Sartre based on Structuralism and Semiotics and reading Freud in this light. All the anomalies in Freud are then given a meaningful theoretical context. But in that reinterpretation of Freud via this hermeneutic Lacan moves closer to Jung than Freud. Hillman’s deconstruction of Jung is entirely negative. What is much more interesting is to consider the Lacanization of Jung’s archetypal psychology, especially now that we have the Red Book as a fundamental authentic basis for his practice, as it was expressed in relation to himself. And when we bring this into conjunction with the psychology of Nietzsche as the dual of Jung then we get an extremely interesting field of exploration. Where Jung is more influenced by Nietzsche than Freud, Lacan is more influenced and is a reader of Freud, correcting the errors and providing a structural and semiotic underpinning for psychoanalysis, even if it was somewhat eccentric and steeped in narcissism and arrogance. Jung is definitely the more human of the three and thus in many ways goes deeper. But archetypal psychology has become a genetically distinct island in which intellectual dwarfism has occurred. Basically Jungians only know Jung and no one else. But I suppose the same is true of Freudians and Lacanians. But at least Jung and Lacan knew the tradition and were not intellectual lightweights like Freud. And I think the fact that Lacan and Jung knew the tradition of their generations is what made their works deep. When we combine them with the even deeper Nietzsche in his role as psychologist of the world then we get some really interesting concepts that do not appear otherwise taking these thinkers separately, especially when we recognize the profound influence of Nietzsche on Jung as seen in the Red Book, his attempt to write something like Zarathustra. Zizek plays a key role in making Lacan accessible. But his playing down other influences than Hegel does not help us. Heidegger also plays a key role not only because of his influence on Lacan, but I think there is also an unacknowledged influence on Jung in terms of his idea of individuation. Lacan does not have a similar idea, he seems to have not taken seriously the idea of dasein attempting to become authentic and individualized from the They as a Self. But Jung does take that process seriously. Lacan is looking back at the subject from the viewpoint of Dasein, and seeing it in terms of Sartre’s nothingness. But Jung is looking at the idea of individuation in a way very similar to that of Heidegger, who has a deeper view of that process in many ways. But by appealing to archetypes and bringing in the idea of the collective unconscious Jung develops this individuation process in ways that Heidegger could not have imagined. And of course we have in Nietzsche the perfect example of someone who completely individuated within his time and culture and went deep into the ailments of the worldview. Jung tried to make the same journey in his Red Book, but does not reach the same depths as Nietzsche displays in Zarathustra. One interesting addition to the Archetypal Psychology camp is the work of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfgang_Giegerich">Wolfgang Giegerich</a>who is a Hegelian.<br>Our hermeneutic circle that considers these thinkers who have been mentioned, to which we should add Bataille and Plotnitski casts a wide net. But there is a lot of work to be done to come to terms with the various contributions of these thinkers concerning psychoanalysis. And to come to terms with them we need some idea of their relations to each other, which unfortunately Zizek obscures. There are really only three thinkers in his universe Lacan, Badiou, and Hegel. And that is unfortunate. But at least he makes Lacan make some sense. And for that we thank his interpretative efforts. But Zizek does not go far enough, he does not situate Lacan in his historical period and thus he forgets the influences of Structuralism and Semiotics on Lacan as well of that of Heidegger mediated by Sartre. Once we correct that difference then we can understand better where Lacan is coming from, in the sequence of the thinkers that contributed to the richness of Continental Philosophy. Really it was Deleuze that made Lacan great by taking his ideas seriously from a philosophical point of view. For all that Zizek would like us to forget Deleuze and Derrida, he does not measure up to them in terms of the innovation of thought. Zizek sees himself as a puppet that mouths the words of Hegel in the vernacular of Lacan based on the model developed by Badiou. All he claims for himself is the Anamorphic swerve.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=166b8aa11270" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/being-time/placing-lacan-deeper-in-his-historical-context-166b8aa11270">Placing Lacan Deeper in his Historical Context</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/being-time">Being &amp; Time</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>