<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Garske on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Garske on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kevingarske?source=rss-750e6c9dca89------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:38:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kevingarske/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seizing the Black Moment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevingarske/seizing-the-black-moment-d4671d800682?source=rss-750e6c9dca89------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d4671d800682</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-liberation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Garske]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jun 2020 19:31:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-04T19:31:33.403Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KavmQfkUFz7QxH9cu00ByQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Getty Images</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>And So it Begins</strong></p><p>Writing this has been spiritually liberating. I am an existentialist at bottom and a burgeoning black radical somewhere above that, so the opportunity to interrogate my own perspective and finally overcome my natural mode of self-doubt has been a gift. Ultimately, I wrote this for two audiences: the friends and family who asked me to, and myself. If you don’t fall into either of these categories, consider that I am not an organizer or an authority on the content herein. I am not a journalist and this has not been subjected to a fact-checking process. If I’m to be of any use to you here and ever after, it is as a synthesizer. I can speak only for myself while synthesizing, but trust that the energy and intent behind it comes from an aching, bluesy love for my fellow human beings.</p><p>Perhaps this is why the hardest part of writing this was knowing when to stop. It is long, so feel free to skim it or sit with it, whatever is appropriate to your practice. The following is my point of view on the events rapidly unfolding in cities all over America, on the kinds of framing and discourse that’s taking place, and inklings of where I hope it may lead.</p><h3><strong>Part I: The Material Moment</strong></h3><p>I spent the better part of a day refining an argument about looting, rioting, and the messier side of spontaneous protest movements. I want to be informative, and that seems to be on everybody’s minds. That being said, I had to betray my audience out of fidelity to a broader consideration and decided not to present it. Frankly, to discuss the morality of looting and rioting at the fringes of a spontaneous protest movement like this is to give in to a distraction rooted in our attraction to the spectacle of violence and our revulsion at the destruction of property. That’s not to say that the moral consideration is irrelevant, but the nexus of moral considerations at the heart of this movement should draw much, much more of our attention. That is my focus, and I hope if you’ve gotten this far, it is your focus as well. The bumper sticker version of the paragraphs I omitted goes as follows: Looting is Good, Looting is Bad, Looting is inevitable.</p><p>Be skeptical of news sources that are centering the spectacle of property destruction over the protest itself, or even holding them as phenomena of comparable significance. This is not simply a matter of the language used to discuss it, but also the airtime devoted to it. To hold looting and property destruction in <em>equal weight </em>to the aims and origins of the protests themselves is to unmask oneself as ignorant of a) how routine of an externality it is for protests, b) how outcries over rioting are a favored tool of repressive states to discredit protest movements in the eyes of the public (Hong Kong, France, Everywhere), and c) how disproportionate the coverage is when compared to all that good sisterly marching, chanting, standing with one’s hands up, sharing snacks and water, bandaging and holding and carrying each other, and so on. Note that these acts can be definitively attributed to the people of this movement, while the behaviors of looting and property damage are amorphous, clearly at times <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/02/tech/antifa-fake-twitter-account/index.html">sabotage</a> or <a href="https://www.insider.com/minneapolis-protesters-social-media-users-suspicious-of-umbrella-man-2020-5">infiltration</a>, and therefore are difficult to attribute to the movement or anyone in particular.</p><p>When we center arguments about visually stirring “bad behavior” from a minuscule proportion of protesters (or individuals using protesters as cover), we mystify that police are <a href="https://twitter.com/greg_doucette/status/1266752393556918273?s=20&amp;fbclid=IwAR2sEi7ej0hLuOoxAdGJVqY-1elPUfoLLiGd2cK1VDTKDZUtqxN1AA8tD_Y"><strong>overwhelmingly taking the initiative</strong> when it comes to violence</a>. This is one of the most striking parts of the on-the-ground experience of many activists and organizers, more so than I can recall in my lifetime. Journalists are being shot with rubber bullets and tear gassed. Medics from multiple cities providing neutral first aid on the streets report having their tents scuttled, their supplies crushed and stolen, and their bodies beaten (a war crime in combat zones, if I’m not mistaken). Protesters with their hands up are thrown to the ground and beaten savagely. People in a car were tased and dragged from their seats as their tires were slashed. Protesters won’t clear the roadway, so police simply run them over. Police threaten to tear gas crowds at the time of curfew, then start gassing 30 minutes before without provocation. People are <a href="https://twitter.com/nomoniker_/status/1267608918135640064?s=20">picked off the street at random for detention </a>and<a href="https://www.thedailybeast.com/nypd-officers-caught-beating-cyclist-with-batons-in-horrifying-viral-video"> beatings </a>regardless of their relationship to the protests. We should not presume they are mistaken when they signal to us that we, everyday people, pose the greatest threat to their power.</p><p>Thus, police are unwilling to wait for a pretext to start shedding blood. Awaiting justification to crack skulls is just too inefficient. That’s nothing to speak of the recent phenomena of National Guardsmen, and their behavior as military muscle. And let’s be clear: even the physical provocations from these protesters could never render the heightened violence the state has displayed acceptable.</p><p>The state expects us to accept that it is rightfully capable of distributing violence however it sees fit, and that people are required to receive this violence with open arms and warm hearts in order to receive recognition. Right or wrong, the people are overwhelmingly committed to peaceful resistance. There is no organized incentive to violence among the protesters beyond emergency self-defense. The vast majority of people do actually take this violence and respond to it with righteous anger, with love, with self preservation and protection of those around them. We have seen police<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jun/02/police-marching-with-protesters-george-floyd-reform"> join the protesters instead of opposing them in a handful of cities, and violence has been strikingly absent</a>. I don’t get the warm and fuzzies seeing police joining arms with protesters. The police are, in my view, <a href="https://www.wuwm.com/post/history-policing-america-starts-and-ends-protecting-private-property#stream/0">organs of class society that serve on the bleeding edge of state-sponsored racism</a>. They find their origins in <a href="https://lawenforcementmuseum.org/2019/07/10/slave-patrols-an-early-form-of-american-policing/">slave patrols</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-union_violence_in_the_United_States">union busters</a> — both expressions of their <strong>role’s</strong> primary concern with private property over human lives. The beliefs, hopes, experiences, ethnicities, and personalities of individual officers are immaterial to their overall legitimacy as an organ of the state. But the tranquility of these unopposed protests perfectly illustrates the true source of violence in the vast majority of other demonstrations. Somehow a march without police opposition remains a march, but a march chased and boxed in by belligerent police blockades invariably becomes someone’s riot.</p><p>If we must be sidetracked from the central thrust of protest, it would be far more ideal to discuss the merits of free mutual aid that is taking place on the ground. Spontaneous <a href="https://twitter.com/Omarisal/status/1268349682448650240?s=20">blossoms of human solidarity dot the landscape</a> of these protests, <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/157985/protest-medics-targeted-police-words">from trained medics</a> to <a href="https://www.instagram.com/tv/CA8uqCYBbBu/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link">hot food stations</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/PhxProtestLIVE/status/1268275909687042049?s=20">PPE provisions, hygiene packs</a>, and so on. Some organizations are sheltering people caught out after curfew, or giving safe haven to people running from advancing riot police. <a href="https://bailfunds.github.io/">Bail funds</a> and informal jail assistance networks are rooted in every active city, humming along independently of one another. Police are treating many of these blossoms as part of the protest itself — <a href="https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/nation/2020/06/03/asheville-north-carolina-police-seen-destroying-protesters-supplies/3135539001/">busting up tents, grabbing equipment,</a> issuing citations to local organizations for sheltering or feeding protesters.</p><p>Coverage of these extant phenomena is limited in mass media. Much of what we actually know from the protests is thanks to cell phone cameras, freelancers, and local media putting themselves and camera crews at risk. The resulting disparity between on-the-ground knowledge and mass media coverage is wide, and the police’s violent treatment of journalists of all stripes is assisting this disparity. But the revolutionary potential of people freely giving up their time, money, energy, and training to provide real material support in an action against state militias bears acknowledgment. You don’t have to be a radical to understand how promising this is; how fundamentally different this is from traditional forms of charity; how at-odds it is with capitalist framings of protest.</p><p><strong>— A Protest for Thee —</strong></p><p>The difficulty Americans have with understanding protests can be traced to recent coinciding trends. The Neoliberal turn, by which we mean (in brief) a shift in the political paradigm away from government as a steward of social welfare and redistribution, towards government as a sort of Public Venture Capital firm made up of credentialed, middle class managers. This required the kneecapping of the labor movement and the severing of the left’s ties to electoral politics. One side effect of this severance from populism was the recasting of protest from politics to a kind of agitation external to “proper” procedural politics.</p><p>Coinciding with this shift in the political terrain was the explosion of large media conglomerates in the context of war reporting. Protest is antithetical to a central tenet of Neoliberalism, which stipulates that the mechanism of progress is delegating authority to the correct, credentialed managers. Orphaned by electoral politics, protest was adopted by news media as another flavor of conflict journalism. It was the televising of Vietnam and later the Gulf War that laid the foundation for modern televised journalism in the West, and the protests of these wars were covered as part of an increasingly hostile national conversation.</p><p>In the aftermath of 9/11, as the country fell in line behind the war effort, the anti-war movements against the invasions of Afghanistan and then Iraq suddenly faced enormous opposition. The formula of protest coverage proposed and ratified by past wars was perfected here. News coverage was <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/media/2004/may/26/pressandpublishing.usnews">light on actual investigation</a> and anyone who violated this code in search of WMDs were marginalized. The overwhelming victory in the Gulf War left media consumers especially hungry for vengeance, and didn’t want complicating factors introduced to the narrative. Coverage by even the most respectable institutions fell <a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/irrefutable-evidence-and-_b_52470?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAJG-1gZZulwN0dMEFhKtRvVqDmiZDLaWASAC-hGdrU39rgbxysOsUGrIyTszyj_OTykdJEBM1Z2nP7tOMwMIFoavsGS8ZQmcaq75_zgeYeWOyfqTw87Ap68A-oyKj0imCIdf73x7SX9a9P3Biri6561MH80PE0w3hXAFCmDr6-cG">under the direct influence of White House staff</a>. Coverage of the anti-war movement in opposition to this righteous quest for American Justice triggered the same part of the American mind that turned against the counterculture in the late 60s and early 70s. Protest was now re-confirmed as “un-American”, and anomalous incidents of disruptive behavior was held up as proof.</p><p><strong>— Precious American Blood —</strong></p><p>This vulgar sketch of news media might inform another trend present on the American Right (including a good chunk of mostly older whiter liberals, who are unequivocally right wing) of a sort of patriotism that despises protests as violent, but will defend American violence abroad under any circumstance. These same people, who seek to discredit these undefined movements on the basis of them inevitably harboring small percentages of infiltrators, LARPers, and adventurists, are still happy to tell you about how the decades-long looting of Iraq was “protecting our freedoms.” When American infiltrators, LARPers, and adventurists surface in Afghanistan, Iraq, Nigeria, Uganda and so on behaving like Victorians on safari, these patriots are happy to explain how a few bad apples don’t spoil the war effort.</p><p>According to their formulation, you cannot discredit military occupation based on <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/05/10/torture-at-abu-ghraib">torture at Abu Ghraib</a>, or <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/apr/13/former-blackwater-guards-sentencing-baghdad-massacre">massacres of unarmed civilians by military contractors like Blackwater</a>, or the use of <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/iraq-records-huge-rise-in-birth-defects-8210444.html">Depleted Uranium Rounds in heavily populated civilian areas</a>, or frankly, the “collateral damage” of any given <a href="https://www.hrw.org/report/2003/12/11/target/conduct-war-and-civilian-casualties-iraq">clusterbomb airstrike in Basra or Fallujah</a>. Sucking the blood of innocent people, parceling out their resources and institutions to private contractors, looting their treasuries and resource-rich lands, <a href="https://fpif.org/just-much-paul-bremer-blamed-rise-islamic-state/">installing colonial leadership</a> to place a legal stamp on wholesale rape and mass murder — these are done in the name of our freedoms. They don’t discredit some higher imagined purpose to the absolute mayhem that follows the American Death Star.</p><p>While our looting and pillaging abroad is done in the name of American Freedom, breaking the windows of a Wells Fargo branch and stealing mid-market grilling equipment from Target, however, have become crimes against humanity. If you end up in a Target parking lot after police clashes and people around you leave with stolen Oxo brand serving spoons tucked in their bags, you don’t deserve to speak. If you break windows or spray paint “ACAB” on brick buildings, that is tantamount to violence. You must flatter our standards for what an American protagonist looks like on TV, or shut up.</p><p>Of course, disciplined peaceful protest is often unacceptable too. Whether it violates the sanctity of the holy Sunday Football sacrament, or temporarily disrupts freeway traffic, peaceful protest’s paltry demands of fellow citizens’ time and energy is always a bridge too far. These protests are suddenly the product of “entitlement” born out of jealousy towards the rich, lack of industriousness, or perpetual victimhood. In Black Power struggles, these are combined with racialized individual failings — want of a father figure, an alien sort of animalistic anger, or a peculiar attraction to shortcuts instead of hard work.</p><p>To find a protest that’s acceptable, you must always look to the distant past, or to marches that never functioned to challenge state authority in any way whatsoever. The Women’s March could be seen as acceptable, because gathering to uplift the mere idea of womanhood doesn’t demand anything of state authority. Never mind all of the concrete things that stands for — in practice, this march was formulated as a jab at Trump. Climate Change demonstrations are generally acceptable, so long as you don’t advocate for democratically reorganizing our unsustainable production. You are welcome to march for the mere concept of science.</p><p>Public mourning is fine as well. You’re more than welcome to grieve the killing of black people through candlelight vigils and stirring kumbayas. It must be Affect only — no demands, and no challenge. When grief is transmuted into anger, and anger into action, it becomes indefensible. In other words — if you want to be deemed an acceptable protest, you must first conceive of yourself as a marketing campaign. Sell me on the idea first — let me get comfy. How am I going to feel when I support this — what’s in it for me? Let me take this idea for a test drive, see if I can picture myself in the driver’s seat, rolling down I-5 with the wind in my hair.</p><p><strong>— Copaganda —</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/02/us/police-protesters-together/index.html">The police are certainly seeing the opportunity for marketing</a>. Pictures abound of police taking a knee, giving hugs, and shaking hands with black people, compassionate looks on their faces. But I must remind you again — an individual officer’s compassion is immaterial to their function. In the aforementioned cases of police marching with protesters, the immediate chief and/or mayors of those few cities made reform and de-escalation priorities long before this action. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2019/12/04/obama-administration-ordered-newark-fix-its-police-force-heres-what-has-hasnt-happened/?arc404=true">However, in some cases, their commitment to these policies and their efficacy remains in question</a>. And unless every rung on the chain of a given hierarchy is willing to wield their power leniently, compassionate police on the ground are still ripe to perpetrate abuse at the behest of their overseers. Perhaps more horrifying is the prospect, as appears most clearly in the case of the NYPD, that the police are not even responsive to the power mechanisms in the city government that give them authority, and instead act as an independent occupying force with an agenda all their own.</p><p>This reality is absent from these swatches of Heartwarming Content™. Some of those images show genuine moments where whole police departments are, by force or by choice, exempted from their usual business of controlling people. But most of those images were taken in cities like New York, Atlanta, and Los Angeles, where brutality is a normal tool of the State. <a href="https://twitter.com/search?q=kneeling%20and%20gassing&amp;src=typed_query">Some activists on the ground have claimed that cops knelt for momentary photo ops immediately before deploying tear gas</a>, flashbangs, batons, and the rest of it. <a href="https://www.alternet.org/2016/02/8-most-popular-types-copaganda-how-police-play-media/">There is an entire genre of media coverage devoted to distorting public opinion about police coined “copaganda”.</a> A black man in Louisville named David McAtee was gunned down by police on Sunday night and left dead in the street for 12 hours. He had regularly served cops for free at his barbecue restaurant, and was reportedly <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2020/06/01/david-mcatee-louisville-business-owner-killed-police-national-guard/5310854002/">a pillar of the community</a>. They left him dead in the street. All night.</p><p><strong>— Feels Like We Only Go Backwards —</strong></p><p>Then there are the protests of the distant past. The labor actions that got us the 40 hour work week, a minimum wage, the weekend, the outlawing of child labor — these all fail whatever purity test people might subject them to, were they to unfold before our eyes. Crucially, it seems they are retroactively acceptable because we, personally, enjoy their benefits. Or then, take the pathological fixation on Martin Luther King Jr., the long dead Civil Rights leader who <a href="https://theintercept.com/2018/01/15/martin-luther-king-jr-mlk-day-2018/">was hated in his time by the white public at large</a> and distrusted by most of his own people. Those protests were good because they had an identifiable male leader who gave orders — orders not to be mean to me or hurt me, as a white person or a propertied person. Orders to suffer the blows of police, the bites of dogs, bricks sailing through the air, bones snapping on the pavement. All of that appears as dust obscuring the thing in itself. The essence of the thing, the protest, to these critics, is the image of marchers linking arms, and a man at a podium articulating his vision. As the American mind views itself as the protagonist of reality, we can only accept and identify with actions that are far too disciplined and admirable for us to actually commit. For a protest to be good then, it must paradoxically be exceedingly better than me, and by extension, whomever I believe to be the average person. Protests too distant to affect me here and now, particularly ones which are pageants of immense suffering, are good to me now. Not back then, of course, but now!</p><p>Ejecting from this discussion of protest acceptability, it’s worth also noting that no two protests are the same. Every city has its own history, and every sub-community within that city has its own relationship with the government and local law enforcement. You can absolutely draw connections between these protests, but decontextualizing a local struggle to try to isolate and generalize national phenomena will generally fail. A protest organized by Anarchists (<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/made-by-history/wp/2018/01/11/anarchist-is-often-hurled-as-a-slur-but-can-anarchists-teach-us-something-about-democracy/">who are extremely wholesome people by the way, and not just destructive white guys, despite what quivering pundits will tell you</a>) in Seattle won’t have the same character as a protest organized by progressive church leaders in Birmingham.</p><p>The national character of the protest, if there is one, is a big tent revolt concerned with black lives — beyond that, it’s difficult to assign further coherence. We are all trying to make sense of what’s happening, and I would urge us all to view our own knowledge as incomplete. As angry as I’ve become with America over the past 10 years, I have to pinch myself every time I see pieces of this glorious rebellion in action. It makes sense that it’s happening, but I could have never expected this. Although the protest as a whole is still heterogeneous, a consistent lens around police violence and specifically black oppression is coalescing in the background. These shared values about black life are now more popular than I can remember in my lifetime.</p><h3><strong>Part II: Tactics? We Talkin’ About Tactics?</strong></h3><p>There are limitations to nonviolent acceptance, just as there are limitations to looting and rioting even at their best. If in reality the protests reflect a broad desire to discredit and disempower the police, and to afford black people some undefined ability to control their own destinies, we should evaluate tactics by their usefulness to these ends. Notwithstanding the morality of burning and looting, the practical limitations of destruction should be acknowledged if our goal transcends cathartic action. We also cannot understate the reality that riots have an extremely clear history of delivering substantive change, from <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/01/an-amazing-1969-account-of-the-stonewall-uprising/272467/">Stonewall </a>to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_assassination_riots">King Assassination Riots of ’68</a>. When people ask you about the morality of looting and present very real examples of local small businesses, understand that their appeals to reality are still packaged as a thought experiment.</p><p>This thought experiment is not irrelevant, but completing its task and developing a moral position on looting doesn’t have any practical bearing on the movement in its current form. Unless you radically alter its character to be top-down, disciplined, and exclusive, there is no way to mitigate anomalous actions. Making those changes not only takes enormous organizing power, but comes with enormous risks — and more to the point, it really isn’t up to any one person’s moral stance. If the protests were strictly or primarily purge-like riots with rioting itself as the overwhelming aim, that thought experiment would take on vital urgency and relevance. Since that is clearly not the case, and there is no practical application, developing the correct stance on looting to appease pearl-clutching sensibilities is irrelevant to our understanding or justification of the protest movement. The only way to ground this in the movement itself is to consider looting and rioting tactically, and understand their consequences and limitations. We have to return from our thought experiment back to the real world, or never leave the real world in the first place.</p><p><strong>— Dr. King is not a Meme —</strong></p><p>This bears a quick return to Dr. King, because he’s the favored dead horse to beat when it comes to discrediting black militancy. First of all, we cannot seriously ascribe civil rights legislation to the actions of King alone. An intricate network of black socialist, black nationalist, broad socialist, black philanthropist, black religious and broad labor organizations participated in what we call the Civil Rights Movement. That King is held up by textbooks and elected officials as the inheritor of the “progress” made during this period is no accident. His coalition was broader and marginally more congenial to power than that of his contemporaries, so elevating him is (well deserved as it may be) a part of a nationalistic reading of history that erases militancy and righteous opposition to the state from its pages. It also sustains the illusion that elected officials legislate based on emotional appeal, on conscience, rather than in service of competing concentrations of power. This illusion is beginning to wither back into the fertilizer of history as the mask on American power slips off, but it remains with us in many forms.</p><p>In truth, the greatest legislative gains of the civil rights struggle were surrendered out of deep fear and anxiety about black power’s effects on the Cold War, and about the Constitution’s waning legitimacy among black people. <a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/why-martin-luther-king-had-75-percent-disapproval-rating-year-he-died-180968664/">In truth, they were afraid of Dr. King as much as they were ever moved by him. </a>But they were in some ways more anxious about the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Action_Movement">Revolutionary Action Movement</a>, Nation of Islam, the Black Panthers and later their extant milita, the Black Liberation Army, SDS, and so on. These groups identified their struggles with those happening in Kwame Nkrumah’s Ghana, Mao’s China, and Castro’s Cuba. This alone was a terrifying prospect for strident Cold Warriors. Moreover, these groups demanded Earth-shaking change in the form of land redistribution, black sovereignty for a black nation, black ownership of the means of production — things which could be said to imply the destruction and remaking of America.</p><p>In this context, casting Dr. King as the sole hero and framing that heroism as peaceful affect allowed the state to create a two-fold lie — not only that congenial empathetic leaders are what get the goods, but that Dr. King was strictly congenial and empathetic, and not a radical in his own right. <a href="http://www.beacon.org/The-Radical-King-P1049.aspx">He was not only a radical</a>, but someone who deliberately collaborated with the labor movement and believed in reorganizing the economy around worker power. They’ve sanded his edges smooth so you can share that photo of brothers and sisters in humanity linking arms to change hearts and minds, when the central tenants of King’s plans included wealth and property redistribution that would require the building of the largest apparatus for Social Democracy known to man. It bears mentioning that despite a lifelong struggle through hierarchical, disciplined peaceful protest, the state never granted the most important hopes of Dr. King’s vision. Further, Dr. King was deepening his relationships with the black militant movement and the labor movement around the time he was assassinated. His nonviolent radical energy was in the process of reconciling with militant radical energy at the time of his death. Had this process reached completion, we might be living in a completely different country today. To say that peaceful protest is the only way is not only a fantasy, but a simple talking point sponsored by the natural enemies of protest in general. The Dr. King we know today is made of watercolors instead of flesh and bone.</p><p><strong>— In Space, No One Can Hear You Vote —</strong></p><p>Often coupled with appeals to the vaporous essence of Dr. King is the exhortation to vote. This is a common phenomena among well-meaning liberals who support some version of the protests, and intuit that protest alone does not translate directly into legislation. The natural assumption then is to redirect energy into electing the people who write legislation. I’ll spare you a full discussion of voting and instead offer some contextual observations.</p><p>The most striking irony of calling on protesters to vote is the conduct of elected Democrats since cities all over the country got down with Minneapolis. The most violent and punitive state reprisals we have seen across the country have all been issued or approved by cities and states led by Democrats. Liberal firebrand Gavin Newsome, who’s scored points for his handling of the pandemic and his criticisms of Trump, sent in the National Guard to occupy the city of Oakland and shack up in beds that were somehow unavailable to the homeless. Mayors Libby Schaaf of Oakland, London Breed of San Francisco, Eric Garcetti of Los Angeles, Laurie Lightfoot of Chicago, Keisha Bottoms of Atlanta, and Bill de Blasio of New York have allowed police to impose martial law-style curfews. Garcetti shut down Covid-19 testing sites, directly stating this was punishment for “burning police cars”. Lightfoot’s Chicago raised the bridge and trapped protesters until the curfew came around as a pretext to crack skulls and make mass arrests. Chicago announced it has shut down its school breakfast program, which has provided more than 12 million meals since the pandemic began, as punishment for protesting. This is to say nothing of the sadism their police departments have displayed with beatings, tear gas, and extensive use of rubber bullets without warning or excuse, or their neglectful treatment of arrestees awaiting processing and release.</p><p>Meanwhile, House Democrats are willing to pantomime black solidarity, but <a href="https://twitter.com/JStein_WaPo/status/1267253355530858496">legislative aides admit there are no substantive plans or willpower to roll out any proposals in response to public anger</a>. As Trump hurdles toward death with the competing wishes of taking us all with him, and putting his cartilaginous face back on TV for a little freestanding comedy, Biden sputters that <a href="https://www.complex.com/life/2020/06/joe-biden-proposes-police-shoot-assailants-leg-instead-of-heart?fbclid=IwAR0s1RUnWmw4uy3b6mDfERsYpLSjQzPv58jZYeRqRw0uMdte5WZo1yGsEkU">one viable response to the protest is training police to shoot at black people’s knees instead of center mass</a>. One wonders if Biden’s verbal macaroni art of late even merits a response. The spectacle of two angry, shallow, brain-dead old men slap-fighting over the controller to button-mash the final level of America is, perhaps, the logical endpoint of this experiment in white, patriarchal, bourgeois class rule. That’s not to say that this dispiriting state of affairs has no distinction, but the distinction lacks a key difference between the elected left and right: when you are out in the streets, you are as much a member of a restive insurgency to either of them as you are their constituents, and they will smother your movement in its cradle while demanding your votes.</p><p>I’m not here to discourage voting in general. If that lesser evil looks good enough, y’all go chase it. There are practical considerations for certain local and regional races all over that may now or someday be seen as useful for this movement. We have seen a sprinkling of reform experiments led by elected officials in smaller cities. But voting for Democrats in general is, I think, by and large unrelated to the problems of police terror and black liberation at this stage. Obama’s signature response to Ferguson was body cameras, a measure which has statistically had no effect on police brutality, and has received extremely little oversight. Activists at the time warned that body cameras were a head-fake that did nothing to protect black lives, and were met with “if you don’t like it, vote for legislators to pass reforms!” This inane rejoinder elides the deliberate narrowing of electoral choice, sponsored by the concentrated capital of the wealthy and powerful. It also elides its main proponents’ tendency to call the Green Party, PSL or anyone genuinely advocating these reforms (however impossible their victories) “Kremlin-Aligned” Ops intent on sewing chaos or outright electing Trump. The demand to vote is then unmasked as only half-sincere: your decision to vote should be aspirational, but your vote itself should be cast for practical considerations, according to what your ideological enemies deem acceptable opposition. Never mind that your position is likely practical in its own right but for the grace of Capital — we will dictate to you what is aspirational, and what is practical. This is the point at which the re-purposing of popular protest energy towards voting is directly beneficial to upholding what I believe we are attempting to destroy.</p><p>If the choice is between a Democrat mayor who will tweet #blacklivesmatter while gassing peaceful protesters, and a Republican mayor who is too senile to tweet while gassing peaceful protesters, you can forgive me if I don’t consider that choice a meaningful one for the movement. Local elections are definitely a meaningful distinction in service of other causes (think housing and homelessness, people), but I would urge people who take their cues from the Obamas and other election-focused Brand Marketers to be specific when connecting voting with the current struggle. Democrats have always beaten, abandoned, and murdered black people without notable distinction from their conservative counterparts.</p><p>If voting has a place when it comes to police terror and black liberation, it is an incidental stage borne from the task of people-centered politics. Which is to say, building our own institutions, funneling this temporary energy into something permanently organized, and coalescing around specific demands will open the “market” of politics to us. If we’re organized and mobilized, the political landscape may shift to produce better candidates who want to buy the less militant votes. We’ve seen this dynamic at play with organizing around Medicare for All producing a new crop of increasingly Progressive candidates. Voting is merely one of many eventualities of the most necessary efforts before us. It is a disposable tool that will naturally be used as a consequence of effective organizing — not the primary mechanism of change. Connecting our struggle to voting at this early stage is, frankly, a distraction that may serve our enemies, both present and hidden.</p><h3><strong>Part III: What is to be Done?</strong></h3><p>The words of Revolutionary agitator and maligned villain of history, Vladimir Lenin, hover in the atmosphere over this moment: “There are decades where nothing happens, and there are weeks when decades happen.” You don’t need to get into theoretical physics to visualize this phenomenon as a<strong> </strong>sort of<strong> </strong>curvature to time. To elaborate, what we broadly call “change” as it operates on history has a<strong> </strong>metabolism that is expressed in the intercourse between economic and political realities, and social life. Our experience of periods when that metabolism kicks into high gear seems to fold and compress time into itself, and our daily rhythms of 4:4 time slip into a more syncopated rhythm. Even non-participants can feel alternately energetic and exhausted by the mere knowledge of distant and uncertain forces, attempting to reach a kinetic threshold.</p><p>There is an understanding that we have to do something with the energy and possibility of this heightened state. The words “concrete demands” are starting to bounce around online already, and I am so grateful and excited to see this. The consensus is that something has to come next. For many that next step appears to be voting, but the strategic gulf between the early days of an insurrection and voting is wide at this point. It is bridgeable, but voting itself is just another tool in a series of tools, as we discussed.</p><p>For some, there is hope in the pathos of protest and the leadership of famous people and local leaders to reform the relationship between police in their communities, or to otherwise touch the hearts and minds of enough officers to change their conduct. In a different caste of mind, there is a general belief that the various protests must adopt some new form, either together or individually, that exerts more direct pressure on elected officials. Black radicals on the ground have also been salivating for this chance to <a href="https://www.hellablackpod.com/pbo">build out parallel organizations that directly serve the people</a> where The State has abandoned them.</p><p><strong>— Belief and Its Discontents —</strong></p><p>A basic conceptual framework for sorting these various proposals is the difference between Idealism, or the emphasis on altering ideas and beliefs in changing the world, or Materialism, the emphasis on changing the direct economic and political conditions to change the world.</p><p>My basic contention is that idealism in politics tends to confuse what power is, and how it works. This confusion then prescribes solutions that are overly individualistic, or incompatible with how power works. We can recognize this in certain cliches of liberal politics. For example, “Start a conversation”, “sharing pain”, “praying for healing”, “confronting bias”, “promoting understanding”, “stop making generalizations”, and so on. These tend to crop up in periods of racialized unrest as well, because there is a genuine need for education to make sense of events. The problem is that these phrases become the political ends and not the means, or are simply conceived as the natural precursor to voting correctly. As we have discussed, voting has a limited purview when it comes to addressing material conditions — not by definition, but by the constraints placed on it in a politics run by concentrated capital. The problem for the idealist then, is distinguishing basic pre-political social tools from actual politics. We would not say that having a dialogue about homelessness serves homeless people the same way that a municipal daily breakfast program and the building of free temporary housing would.</p><p>This is clear, but the confusion comes from an alchemical belief that enough discussion of homelessness can itself produce that breakfast program and that housing initiative. This assumption only stands up in a world where ideas are weighted according to their support among the people — in a world without concentrated power. In reality, power as it exists in a capitalist system must be challenged for that breakfast program and housing initiative, and it cannot be challenged merely through dialogue. Power can only be challenged on its own terms — resources, profit, self-sustenance. The idealist conceives of politics as conversation aimed at finding the right way forward. This inevitably means compromise in a historical process of competing ideas, all perfecting themselves or falling into disuse in a marketplace of competition. However, in a world where political mechanisms are incredibly warped by different forms of power, political ideas are therefore weighted according to power. In this picture, dialogue falls short, as does having command of the proper facts. We’re well acquainted with the era of “fake news” where facts as understood by politics are bought and sold out in the open. This dynamic has always been present where power was weighted disproportionately (so, everywhere, constantly, for a long time), but elites have decided it is safe and convenient to pull the curtain back. Belief in a fact is not the neutral relationship we’re taught it is — the truth value of that fact is mediated by context and yes — power, when that fact comes into contact with the real world. In this context, dialogue, understanding the facts, and broad participation can only shape politics <em>on their own</em> in a world where power is democratically distributed. And redistributing power, it turns out, requires far more powerful tools than the ability to vote.</p><p><strong>— A Note About Power —</strong></p><p>Let’s try now to be specific about these filters that mediate facts, that mediate the power of conversation, understanding, and common virtue. The roots of economic and hierarchical power are the story of humanity in its totality: who won wars, who plundered gold, who used the cheapest labor to harvest cotton and sugarcane, whose social fabric devoured another’s, whose geographic borders happen to contain vast natural resources, who industrialized and who stagnated, who donates the most money to campaigns, who has influence to trade for favors, and so on. In the case of material determinants for police departments we can pose: who owns property and who doesn’t, who lives in areas with adequate healthcare, food, water, utilities, and other resources, and who doesn’t, who is employed and who isn’t, who commits which crimes, how big is our budget, what actions expand our budget, what actions give us control over elected officials, who we are instructed to protect, what we are trained to do, who trains us, what metrics indicate success, and, of course, how can we maintain what power we have. These things are always in flux, responding to new crises and new sources of power as property changes hands; billionaires are made; people are laid off; wars start and end. Trying to apply concepts like “mutual understanding” and “respect” to the solution of material problems is like enlisting a phantom to arm wrestle The Rock.</p><p>In this way, we can dispense with the practicality of things like psychological reconditioning, emotional reconciliation, and mere conversation as the real solutions to political problems. Absent a political program, they are mere spirits to politics. Housed in political programs with specific demands and methodologies, they live and breathe. In terms of building movements, Conversation, Reconciliation, Healing, and so on are pure foundation. But the foundation only matters in politics insofar as it’s sturdy enough to support the actual structure it holds. The enemies of genuine, people-centered politics therefore invite you to build foundation forever. This is the recognizable dynamic of encouraging “thoughts and prayers” and exactly 0 action in the face of tragic mass shootings. Grieve, ponder, discuss — just don’t ask me for a goddamned thing.</p><p>What we need then, is to prioritize building something with concrete demands that targets material conditions as such. The exchange of ideas are a natural part of this building process rather than the ends in themselves. They are changed along the way through a social process of iteration and reiteration between material demands and lofty ideals. Nothing spiritually alters a person more profoundly than participating in the collective exercise of power. This speaks to voting’s allure to people who do not observe its shortcomings: the feeling of doing democracy is powerful, even if the wires between the action and the outcomes have been frayed and snipped.</p><p>To summarize, I reject things like pure dialogue, emotional appeals to police, and individualized behavior modification as <em>incomplete means and apolitical ends</em> in the scheme of people-centered politics. These things can emerge as important where power allows them to, as exemplified by the handful of mayors and police chiefs who take the initiative to reform, but they cannot alter the fundamental conditions of Black American life. I have covered an argument that treats traditional levers of political power with suspicion. We have our distinction between ideal and material. What then should be the demand of our movement? And how could this demand take shape? Here are a few examples that fall under the umbrella of Police Abolition — the systematic process by which we <a href="https://www.wbez.org/stories/how-much-do-we-need-the-police/3063239b-737a-4943-9b36-9dd9aa3923db?fbclid=IwAR2koqhh603P_QrlIgursuWtSptkeJVsHNVNL87j8a5hwM-6hdYkrlf0Dkc">strip police of their power, introduce democratic mechanisms of accountability, and redistribute portions of their mandate to nonviolent, non-repressive arms of the state.</a></p><p><strong>Defunding police departments is an absolute must.</strong> Crime in the aggregate has dropped significantly for the past two decades, yet dollars set aside for police continue to devour other public dollars, and in many places, expand independently of any discernible need. This coincides as well with cyclical cuts to most other local social services. This is a succinct illustration that the role of police is not strictly or even specifically about stopping crime. Stopping crime is why many earnest, individual officers join up, but the practice of crime management functions sort of like Pork-Barrel spending does for Congresspeople — it keeps constituents supportive. It is a means to uphold legitimacy and a much broader (and terrifying) concept called “Rule of Law”, which entails racism and the protection of property over moral concerns and protection of people. Defunding the police would reduce their mandate to harm black people, and reapportioning that money towards social services in underserved communities places a non-militarized institution between the poor and the police. <a href="https://www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/garcetti-agrees-to-reductions-in-lapds-share-of-city-funds/">We have already claimed small victories on this front in the short life of this movement.</a></p><p><strong>Restricting police access to firearms is another big deal.</strong> This is already the norm in many developed countries. Law enforcement do not need lethal force in most situations, period. If the concern is safety, departments are more than welcome to pay for better training to use the non-lethal resources at their disposal. Statistically, pizza delivery drivers still have more dangerous jobs than police officers. The de-escalation of violence in our streets must start with the state.</p><p><strong>Expanding Social Services to Take Over the Police</strong>. When people talk about police abolition outside of true believer activists circles, they naturally receive funny looks. Around older suburban folks, this is usually followed by a cold sweat and nervous questions like “what would we do about crime? What would be there instead of the police?” My personal position is that police abolition is a program with an end goal of rendering the modern paradigm of policing irrelevant through defunding, demilitarization, building more robust social safety nets, redistribution of resources and personnel to things like counseling, social work, child services, and much more. The approach is holistic and has no overnight expectations, just a goal based in justice and some tools for achieving it. The fact is, we shouldn’t need police for all of our emergencies. They are not well-trained for a variety situations that fall under their jurisdictions, from broad conflict resolution, to serving with homeless populations, to de-escalating mental health crises. Social workers and other services can take over these calls with better outcomes and without criminalizing people. In general people should be able to determine the means by which they stop and punish crime democratically.</p><p><strong>Consider also these additions, which may not fall under Abolition, but are critical for changing the material conditions of Black life.</strong></p><p><strong>Legalization of All Drugs.</strong> Drug enforcement is often used as a pretext for civil rights violations and confrontations with unarmed black people. It is also entirely dependent on the existence of a narcotics black market, sustained at the street level by statistically poorer people trying to make a living or protect themselves. Obviously, it is the lubricant for mass incarceration as well. The dangers of drugs is generally a problem of oversight — if people have proper information on when and how they can be used, when the purchase and selling can be regulated, when abuse and health concerns can be targeted rather than kept on the margins of the public square, and so on, we might see vast improvements overnight. Decriminalization has also been posed, but leaving the sale of drugs in the hands of the black market is problematic to our ends.</p><p><strong>Reparations.</strong> This word gets all kinds of hate and love without a unified understanding of what it means. Frankly, it is supposed to contain multitudes because its implications continue to evolve the further and further into history we go uncompensated for our terrorization. I therefore feel it unnecessary to elaborate beyond that when advocating for it, using the most expansive definition of the term is warranted and tactically sound. Demand more, get more.</p><h3><strong>Part IV: Method to the Madness</strong></h3><p>I’ll conclude with a note on methodology. I am not an organizer, so I am not an authority on how this work gets done at the atomic level — how organizations become permanent, how coalitions are built, how people are galvanized to consistent action. At a theoretical level however, I am aware that we need something we can all participate in, that will build solidarity, that will necessitate the formation of new black movements and organizations, and will attack the system in a language power speaks. I believe one possible final form of such a movement to be a General Strike for Black Lives.</p><p>This is not the only way forward, but I do think it is both possible and effective for a few reasons. The energy and appetite for strikes has been rising since the beginning of the Pandemic, as evinced by the actions of<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strikes_during_the_COVID-19_pandemic"> Amazon warehouse workers, Whole Foods employees, Instacart drivers, and more</a>. These limited strikes have not been able to move management in isolation. There is an understandable hesitancy to strike for too long as essential workers in economic precarity, and strikes in retail industries require broad public awareness and commitment to work. However, now that masses of people are prepared to be in the streets each day, there is a higher level of awareness and commitment than ever before in my lifetime. This is an opportunity to broaden the aims of both Black Power and Labor through collaboration.</p><p><strong>— Ligaments and Tendons —</strong></p><p>After all, these struggles are interlinked. Isn’t it curious that California’s major cities had beds a-plenty for National Guardsmen after filibustering on providing beds to even a fraction of their homeless? Isn’t it interesting how police have state of the art protective gear for the pandemic in addition to military supplies from the Pentagon, but nurses all over the country still have to wear trash bags in the emergency room as PPE? The linkages between austerity and policing are inextricable. After all, police budgets swell at the expense of other services. If the state hopes to continue cutting budgets and using taxpayer money on private contracts to cut corners; if the state intends to let wages remain flat, to let people lose their jobs without economic support, to force poor and unemployed people to pay rent and fend for themselves in the extreme conditions of a pandemic, it needs a robust law enforcement organ to quell the predictable fits of rage endemic to staggeringly hierarchical societies.</p><p>Discontent has been bubbling all across society. This explosion of rebellion on behalf of black lives has an incredible opportunity to formalize itself in about a million different ways. If we are talking about collaborating with labor, the coalition has to be broad. Historically, these kinds of coalitions needed to be built up long before a general strike was possible, and were sponsored by powerhouse labor organizations of the time like the AFL (Now AFL-CIO) and the IWW. The organizing power and time is immense. But as the state continues to fail us in deeper and deeper ways, linking black struggle with labor is a natural confluence. Communication is faster than ever, and the labor movement hasn’t really begun to benefit from this since Democrats shot it behind the barn at the height of the Cold War.</p><p>Now we’re in the woods of hypotheticals, which is likely a good place to stop. The sum of this essay is but a snapshot of my perspective on an incredibly dynamic situation, and speculating on what kinds of organizations could come into being out of these protests feels like jumping the gun. With the heightening brutality of police forces on full display, it is hard to say whether they will succeed in bottling up enough popular energy to isolate the radicals, or if we’ll rally to this cause and defy them with greater force. As time wears on, we will see a variety of demands bubble to the forefront of the movement to be debated and refined. That deliberative process is a great mechanism for building concrete, coordinating organizations.</p><p><strong>— Goodbye, and Good Luck —</strong></p><p>For now though, I’d like to consider something as coordinated and deadly as a general strike to be the North Star for the discontented public. We have to stand up for ourselves across the board. If support for the liberation of Black Americans carries with it the ability to kneecap economic activity with little notice, we can accomplish more than we’d dare hope today. If that links with Indigenous People’s struggles with Covid-19 and their fight for historical justice… I’m getting ahead of myself. But you can see how this turns from photography into finger painting rather quickly. If nothing more amounts from this than a few glorious weeks of revolt, so be it. The events are not in any single one of our hands, and being realistic and clear about our goals and limitations is far more radical than looking for extreme ways to vent frustration. I just want us to be clear — using this movement to build new organizations of local black solidarity, and connecting those struggles together, is realistic. Abolishing the police as they currently exist is realistic.</p><p>If I can leave you with anything it’s this: be prepared to support a movement that takes on a program and characteristics that you’ve never supported before. Be prepared for something new. Be adaptable and think long term. We are facing crushing defeats and winning stunning victories every day, but don’t let either sweep you off your feet. This moment is sobering, and it’s important to be patient among friends and comrades in this struggle. Through this struggle, we may discover new depths to the mere ideas we thought we understood — love, reflection, conversation, revelation. <strong>Bearing witness to suffering of others is the wellspring of radical politics.</strong> It may seem too improvisational to the unaccustomed, but the struggle for a new politics throughout history has always been grounded in a faith in human creativity. Without this, we will continue to wander this desert until we cease bargaining with injustice, and choose to strike it instead. Stay safe — you have my hope, faith, and solidarity.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d4671d800682" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>