<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:33:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strategic Reviews Are Like Rearranging the Deck Chairs on the Titanic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/strategic-reviews-are-like-rearranging-the-deck-chairs-on-the-titanic-dab2980c4043?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dab2980c4043</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategic-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[value-logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conditions-for-success]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Feb 2025 20:15:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-08T20:15:03.500Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Revising Strategy Conversations: Better Business Strategy IV</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WNlFEihfK5xfAF65P90V1g.png" /></figure><p>In the world of Business Strategy, the parallel to Sir Humphrey’s ‘government enquiry’ is typically called a Strategic Review, a one-off, focused and intensive response to major performance issues. Like ‘government enquiries’, Strategic Reviews are often more about organizational politics and assigning blame for problems than about improving performance. And they’re more about justifying changes that have already been decided rather than finding new opportunities.</p><p>The precursor to a Strategic Review is often the termination of the CEO — who leaves quietly with a ‘bag of gold’. This change is usually driven by a board of directors with their own ideas about the performance issues and the strategies that should be in place to address them. Next a new CEO is appointed and a Strategic Review is announced. It usually involves months of analyses to justify and flesh out the strategies that have already been decided, followed by cost cutting, asset sales, terminations, reorganization etc etc. But the problem is</p><blockquote><strong>Most Strategic Reviews hinge on the misguided notion that planning and strategy are the same thing</strong></blockquote><p>Strategic Reviews are typically ‘poor performance’ driven episodes of Strategic Planning (as opposed to calendar driven). They involve all the problems I’ve talked about previously in the <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice</em> (<em>SCIP)</em> series (see <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/disappointed-with-strategic-planning-there-is-a-better-way-try-strategy-conversations-in-practice-32c7bfd6baf8">Disappointed with Strategic Planning, Try Strategy Conversations Instead</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">Where is the Business Model in Strategic Plans</a>). In particular, their output is typically a laundry list of fragmented threads of activities mislabeled as strategies and aimed at creating value for the firm itself rather than for its Customers.</p><p>To make matters worse these so-called ‘strategies’ are overlaid with cognitive biases on the part of those who initiated the Review. Their focus is usually on shareholder value and on keeping their well-paid jobs.</p><p>Finally, Strategic Reviews are reactive. By the time a Review is completed, it’s usually too late. The horse has already bolted!! A Strategic Review might keep a firm alive in the short term, but it is not surprising that the cycle usually repeats itself a couple of years later.</p><p>So, what’s the alternative? In <em>SCIP</em>, I argue that strategy is a focused, coherent and integrated set of Customer and Organization Value Creation choices that are continuously reconfigured through a learning loop of four distinct but interconnected, iterative, and reflective Strategy Conversations. Revising Strategy Conversations are the fourth stage in this loop. The other stages are <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a">here</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/designing-strategy-conversations-and-business-model-innovation-14566b4e9d76">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/better-business-strategy-iii-making-strategy-happen-df5ac0b2b84d">here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/1*YQvna6vIJK8T3ozo4fuKkA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Revising Strategy Conversations</strong> involve continuously assessing:</p><p>- Conditions for Success.</p><p>- Customer and Organization Value Creation performance relative to expectations.</p><p>- Progress with the Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 Business Model Innovation Projects initiated in <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/better-business-strategy-iii-making-strategy-happen-df5ac0b2b84d">Making Things Happen Conversations</a>.</p><p><strong>Conditions for Success, </strong>or <strong>What Would Have To Be True (</strong><a href="https://rogermartin.medium.com/what-would-have-to-be-true-83dac5bd2189">Roger Martin</a>) are the conditions that must be in place for a Business Model to successfully deliver Customer and Organization Value expectations. Conditions for Success are reverse designed from the prototype Business Models developed in the <strong>Designing Strategy Conversations</strong> stage. They include macro environment, industry, market and competitive factors as well as factors specific to a firm’s Business Model.</p><p>Once specified, these ‘conditions’ should be continuously compared with what is happening in the real world. The aim is to identify key differences as they emerge and synthesize insights into potential changes to the firm’s Business Model.</p><p><strong>Customer and Organization Value</strong> <strong>Creation</strong> expectations are also developed in the Designing Strategy Conversations<em> </em>stage and refined in the Making Things Happen Conversations<em> </em>stage. A Revising Strategy Conversation starts with actual outcomes versus those expectations and asks if and why there are gaps. This Conversation uses the Business Model View to frame the Who, What, Why and How of Value Creation choices that have been made and assesses the actual firm performance against those choices.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/688/1*cv3Owdh2elKzToPkSPQGYA.png" /></figure><p>Typical questions that should be asked on a <strong>continuous basis</strong> in Revising Strategy Conversations include:</p><p>- <strong>Primary Customers:</strong> Are we gaining/losing/maintaining those Customers we targeted?</p><p>- <strong>Value Proposition:</strong> Are we excelling in the chosen dimensions of Customer Value? Are we meeting Table Stakes in others?</p><p>- <strong>Organization Value:</strong> Are we meeting expectations in terms of the key financial and non-financial value dimensions?</p><p>- <strong>How:</strong> Are we focused on, investing in and continuously improving the Capabilities and Resources needed to deliver the ‘excel’ value dimensions? Are we maintaining the Capabilities and Resources needed to deliver Table Stakes value dimensions. Are we wasting investment, time and effort in areas that don’t matter?</p><p>- <strong>Value Logic:</strong> Is it clear, concise and dominant? Or, are we trying to be all things to all Customers?</p><p>Again, the aim is to identify areas of divergence from Customer and Organization Value expectations and synthesize insights into potential changes to the firm’s Business Model.</p><p><strong>Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 Business 2 Business Model Innovation Projects: </strong>Typical questions include are we meeting the targets and milestones set in each project’s Business Case? If not, why and what are the implications? Are we successfully integrating business as usual with these projects?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*IsgDkeJ6GfqgMT8OkQT2NA.png" /></figure><p>The aim at this point in a Revising Strategy Conversation is to gain insight into the changes that need to be made to the project portfolio and/or the projects themselves.</p><blockquote><strong>Change the Business Strategy……Change the Strategy Projects?</strong></blockquote><p>If any of the Conditions for Success are not true or they’re not heading that way, if Value Creation results are well below expectations, then the firm’s Business Strategy needs to change. It’s time to move into a new <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a">Making Sense Conversation </a>aimed at developing a new Business Model.</p><p>If the Conditions for Success are heading in the expected direction, if Value Creation results are meeting expectations, then the firm’s Business Strategy is on the right course. But this doesn’t mean the firm stands still. Rather, it means it’s time to improve the current Business Model by looking for opportunities to refresh the portfolio, implementation and integration of Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 Business Model Innovation projects</p><p>How often should firms hold <strong>Revising Strategy Conversations?</strong><em> </em>They should not be an annual ritual like Strategic Planning! The reality of today’s business world is that firms need to be prepared to continuously reconfigure their value creation choices.</p><blockquote><strong>Firms that stick their heads in the sand will get their butts kicked</strong></blockquote><p>Holding <strong>Revising Strategy Conversations</strong><em> </em>often should be a habit in all organizations. They don’t have to be intense and time consuming like Strategic Reviews. A continuous routine of reflecting on Conditions for Success, on Customer and Organization Value Creation performance relative to expectations, and on progress with the Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 Business Model Innovation Projects initiated in <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/better-business-strategy-iii-making-strategy-happen-df5ac0b2b84d">Making Things Happen Conversations</a> is one key. Another is the mind set to learn from these reflections to change the Business Model and/or change the Strategy Projects?</p><p>To paraphrase a quote often incorrectly attributed to Winston Churchhill:</p><p><strong><em>However beautiful the strategy, you should always look at the results and be prepared to learn from them……not once a year, not once a quarter….but continuously.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dab2980c4043" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Better Business Strategy III: Making Strategy Happen]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/better-business-strategy-iii-making-strategy-happen-df5ac0b2b84d?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df5ac0b2b84d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[project-managing-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy-is-execution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-model-view]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Nov 2024 01:58:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-08T01:58:30.226Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Execution Is Strategy………and Strategy is Execution</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*wjQU1NU3t_SrZSLt.jpeg" /></figure><p>Strategic Planning has a lot to answer for. One of its <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/disappointed-with-strategic-planning-there-is-a-better-way-try-strategy-conversations-in-practice-32c7bfd6baf8">major flaws</a> is the notion that formulating strategy and executing strategy are conceptually and practically distinct activities, that senior managers analyse and plan and then hand down that plan to those lower in the organization who are meant to implement it exactly as planned.</p><p>This thinking has led to hundreds, maybe thousands of posts, articles and books over the last 25 years on how to prospectively ‘close the strategy — execution gap’, the <em>potential</em> shortfall between a firm’s actual results and its expected results. Common ‘recipes’ to address this potential shortfall draw on topics such as alignment, resourcing, communication, culture, agility, organisational structure, leadership, training, capabilities, performance reviews, setting better targets………and the list goes on…….and on….and on!!</p><p>Distinguishing between strategy and execution is a convenient way for senior executives to shift blame down the ranks when their ‘good’ ideas fail to deliver the expected results. And it’s certainly a rain maker for consultants but, as <a href="https://rogermartin.medium.com/why-execution-is-a-bankrupt-management-concept-211f77c1fc75">Roger Martin</a> has argued many times, it doesn’t make sense. Many of the recipes for what is called ‘good strategy execution’ actually involve strategy formulation so how can they be conceptually and practically different??</p><p>In <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice (SCIP) </em>there is no distinction between strategy formulation and strategy execution. <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/disappointed-with-strategic-planning-there-is-a-better-way-try-strategy-conversations-in-practice-32c7bfd6baf8">Strategy</a> is defined as the pattern realized in the choices a firm makes in aiming to creating value for its Customers and for itself. Strategy is framed in terms of choices on Customer Value, Organization Value and How these ‘buckets’ of value are created, and expressed in the form of a coherent, integrated, cause and effect <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">Business Model View</a> that is unique to the firm in question. At the center of this Business Model View is a clear and concise <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/an-unbalanced-value-logic-is-the-key-to-better-business-strategy-ee9316526cde">Value Logic</a> that integrates each of the components.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DgwTuw3L-OdP2-jj.jpeg" /></figure><p>This Business Model View represents strategy in action, not a plan and definitely not the ‘laundry lists’ of activities so commonly seen in Strategic Planning. The underlying premise is that strategy is what firms do, not what they say. <strong>A firm’s Business Model represents its strategy and its execution.</strong></p><p>To put it another way, <strong>in <em>SCIP</em> execution is strategy….and strategy is execution.</strong> The strategy process in <em>SCIP </em>involves a continuous learning loop of four distinct but interconnected, iterative, and reflective <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/the-strategy-conversations-framework-better-strategy-better-results-bb60319a2340">Conversations</a> with the Business Model View at the core of the loop, as a touchstone for each Conversation and the collective output of all four Conversations. Strategy choices are made in each of these Conversations and are continuously revised as an organization moves through the loop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/756/0*89HBj4CRZDyFHLFH.jpeg" /></figure><p>So far in the Better Business Strategy series I’ve written about strategy choices in <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a">Making Sense</a> and in <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/designing-strategy-conversations-and-business-model-innovation-14566b4e9d76">Designing</a> Strategy Conversations. In this Post I will draw on the principles of Project Management to write about strategy choices in the Making Things Happen stage of <em>SCIP.</em></p><p><strong>Making Things Happen Strategy Conversations </strong>focus on moving from a firm’s existing Business Model towards a new Business Model prototype(s). The major challenge in Making Things Happen is to ensure that this integration is a positive sum exercise. In other words, gains in Customer and Organization Value Creation from integrating new ideas into the existing Business Model exceed any declines in performance by that model.</p><p>Two steps are critical in this stage of <em>SCIP</em>:</p><ul><li>Developing a Strategy Narrative in parallel with a Business Model View for a future in which select Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model Innovation Ideas (from the Designing Conversations stage) are integrated with the existing Business Model.</li><li>Project Managing these Horizon 1 and 2 Ideas — framing them as Strategy Projects, and then planning, refining and integrating them with the existing Business Model to the point where the proposed (future) Business Model is realized in practice.</li></ul><p><strong>Strategy Narrative: </strong>A Strategy Narrative <strong>is not</strong> another fluffy Vision or Mission statement, it’s not a goal statement, and it’s certainly not a ‘laundry list’ of loosely connected activities that have little to do with Customer Value Creation. Nor is it a huge slide deck prepared by a team of consultants and delivered by the CEO in a ‘dog and pony show’ to employees, analysts and other stakeholders.</p><p>A Strategy Narrative is a short story, a clear and concise statement that explains in plain English, without buzz words and fluffy hyperbole, an organization’s proposed Business Model. It is a ‘word picture’ that complements an organization’s Business Model View.</p><p>A Strategy Narrative is intended primarily for internal use. It should spell out the Who, What, How &amp; Why of Customer and Organization Value that the firm is aiming to create. It should also guide the choices people within the organization routinely make each day — what to do, what not to do — and link these choices back to the organization’s proposed Customer Value and Organization Value Creation.</p><p>Most importantly, a Strategy Narrative spells out, either implicitly or explicitly, in the context of the firm in question, the dominant <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">Value Logic</a> that underpins its proposed Business Model.</p><p><strong>Project Management of Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model Innovation Ideas: </strong>As I mentioned earlier, the challenge in Making Things Happen <em>Strategy Conversations </em>is to ensure that integration of Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 ideas into a firm’s existing Business Model is a positive sum exercise. In <em>SCIP, </em>I frame Business Model Innovation ideas as Strategy Projects and use Project Management disciplines to facilitate the integration process.</p><p>In <em>SCIP</em> Strategy Projects represent new choices. They are pockets of work aimed at improving Customer and Organization Value Creation. Horizon 1 and 2 Strategy Projects are conceptualised in Designing Strategy Conversations, and then planned, refined and integrated with the existing Business Model in Making Things Happen Conversations.</p><p>Strategy Project Planning involves all the typical steps — resourcing, accountability, milestones, risk assessment, outcomes etc all wrapped up into a Business Case for each project. Horizon 1 and 2 projects are typically led by operational managers. Why? Because they’re at the coal face, they’re implementing the current Business Model, and they will know best how to make changes to that model to create value in practice.</p><p>Operational managers should have the freedom to experiment with and refine Strategy Projects as they evolve or even to send them back into the Designing Conversations stage if appropriate. It’s also important to recognize that operational managers must constantly juggle business as usual activities with their work on Strategy Projects. This has implications for workloads, performance assessments and rewards.</p><p>Senior management, and/or the board’s role in Making Things Happen Conversations is to oversee the portfolio of Strategy Projects, to establish priorities and allocate resource in line with value creation opportunities, and especially to choose which Projects to continue with and which ones to drop. Getting the timing right is also a critical consideration. I’ll write more about the board’s role in Strategy Projects in a future post.</p><p>Consider Bunnings as a retrospective example of what these two steps might look like. To reiterate, Bunnings is a business unit of Wesfarmers, a publicly listed Australian conglomerate renowned for its financial discipline and management of its portfolio of business units. Bunnings currently operates around 400 ‘big box’ retail outlets in Australia with annual revenue more than $A18 billion and a CAGR over the last 25 years of around 15%. Bunnings’ earnings have grown even faster in that period. It is a highly successful business!</p><p>This is my take on the Bunnings Business Model that has evolved over the last 5 years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/0*5VxXWWjdC6K_QIjR.jpeg" /></figure><p>And this is my take on the Strategy Narrative that has guided Bunnings over that 5 year period.</p><p><em>Our Primary Customers are DIY households, tradies and small contractors. We help them to maintain, renovate, decorate, protect and enjoy homes and gardens. We offer the lowest prices, widest range and best experience in a constantly evolving suite of products and allied services. Our scale in stores and digital footprint, our operating efficiencies, our suppliers’ partnerships, our investment in technology and innovation, our investment in attracting, training and retaining people with DIY and trade expertise, and our focus on supporting local communities are critical in maintaining and growing our business.</em></p><p>The application of Strategy Project Management to Business Model Innovation is best understood through a practical example in Bunnings. In the 2023 Strategy Briefing to analysts Bunnings talked about their track record of growth by expanding their ‘addressable markets’ while at the same time delivering projects aimed at transforming the existing Business Model. The slide below titled ‘While Delivering Transformational Projects Over Past 5 Years’ is taken from that briefing.</p><p>Note that Bunnings have implemented only 22 projects over 5 years. Bunnings knows how to focus. I’ve seen many examples from firms stuck in the Strategic Planning paradigm with 50+ projects on their ‘laundry list’ each year. It’s no wonder they don’t get anything done.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/0*uCqpGxpf79lxSSeb.png" /></figure><p>I’ve reverse engineered these ‘transformational projects’ into Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model Innovation:</p><p>- <strong>Horizon 1:</strong> 15 Projects in total. Some examples include ‘Launched Click and Collect/Deliver’; ‘Launched Drive and Collect’; ‘Opened Laverton Fulfilment Centre’; ‘Implemented Enterprise Data Platform’; ‘ERP to Cloud’. Each of these Projects aimed to deliver lower total cost to Customers (especially convenience) and increased volume/lower costs for Bunnings.</p><p>- <strong>Horizon 2: </strong>7 Projects in total, all aimed at expanding into adjacent markets. Two of these were acquisitions — Adelaide Tools &amp; Beaumont Tiles, and one was a rebranding exercise — Tool Kit Depot. Four were product range expansions or new product ranges — Garage Storage, Moving Home, Frame &amp; Truss, Pet Care.</p><p>It’s worthwhile mentioning the approach that Bunnings has taken with Adelaide Tools, a specialty tools chain aimed at “tradies and hardcore-DIY-ers” acquired in one state in 2019. The value proposition is more about expert advice and high-end tools than widest range — lowest prices. So, instead of folding it into the Bunnings business, Adelaide Tools was initially maintained as a separate entity, and after testing out new concepts in one store, it was rebranded as Tool Kit Depot and new stores rolled out. The stated aim is to expand to 75 stores nationally, but the staging is deliberately slow and geographically focused to recognize the different ‘Who and What’ Value Proposition compared to the core Bunnings business.</p><p>Making Things Happen Strategy Conversations are not solely about strategy execution. The notion that strategy formulation and strategy execution are conceptually and practically distinct activities is one of the fairy tales of Strategic Planning. In the real world Strategy is what firms do to create value. Strategy is not a plan nor is it a ‘laundry list’ of activities. Strategy in is a firm’s Business Model, one that is continuously evolving. Strategy is execution and execution is strategy.</p><p>Making Things Happen Strategy Conversations<strong> </strong>focus on moving from the existing Business Model towards a new Business Model prototype(s). These Conversations involve planning, refining and integrating a portfolio of Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model Innovation ideas with the existing Business Model. Framing these Business Model changes as ‘projects’ and using Project Management disciplines to ‘make them happen’ is critical.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df5ac0b2b84d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Better Strategy II: Lessons on Strategy Design from a Dog Sled]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/designing-strategy-conversations-and-business-model-innovation-14566b4e9d76?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14566b4e9d76</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conditions-for-success]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-as-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-model-innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jul 2024 02:05:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-08T04:34:21.229Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Strategy as Design in Value Creation</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/490/1*aElQ7BB9A3JbrcTKhCoBmw.png" /></figure><p><em>Understanding a business model requires not only knowing the compositional elements, but also grasping the interdependencies between elements. This is easier to express visually than through words. This is even more true when several elements and relationships are involved.</em></p><p><em>The world is so full of ambiguity and uncertainty that the design attitude of exploring and prototyping multiple possibilities is most likely to lead to a powerful new business model.</em></p><p>Alexander Osterwalder 2010</p><p>What’s wrong in this scene? The aim is for the kid and the dog to have fun. Dogs love to run in the snow, kids love to ride sleds in the snow. All the components are in place………..snow, sled, kid, dog, harness, park…….. The problem is that the scene is not configured correctly. It needs some ‘Design Thinking’. The same is true for strategy.</p><p>Design Thinking has become something of a fad in the business world in recent years. Not surprisingly, it has various definitions. I see it as a holistic, intuitive, Customer focused approach to creating value. <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice</em> (<em>SCIP) </em>is a design journey covering four stages — Making Sense, Designing, Making Things Happen and Making Revisions. Elements of Design Thinking are important in each stage. The Business Model View at the core of <em>SCIP </em>is the output of applying a Design Thinking lens to Business Strategy, one that involves configuring choices about the ‘Who, Why, What, and How’ of Customer Value and Organization Value Creation into a holistic system.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uSCV8c2dYXo3BBShrfN_DQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Four Stages of the Strategy as Design Journey</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Designing Strategy Conversations </strong>involve elaborating the Horizon 1, 2 and 3 Ideas inherent in the Alternative Futures developed during the <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a">Making Sense Strategy Conversations</a> stage. In Designing Conversations each Alternative Future is framed in terms of its Value Logic and its unique configuration of Customer Value, Organization Value and How. In other words, this stage involves designing a new, prototype Business Model for each Alternative Future. From there, each prototype is iteratively tested and refined based on its potential to create Customer and Organization Value. The final step is to make choices on which prototypes to drop and which ones to take into the Making Things Happen Conversations stage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/1*4wb9i7vGDi17y-OSJdtUsQ.png" /><figcaption>Business Model Innovation</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Horizon 1 Business Model prototypes </strong>represent ‘tweaks’ to the existing Business Model. They aim to deliver additional Customer and Organization Value by incremental gains in efficiency and effectiveness driven by improved capabilities and resources. They’re add ons to the existing Business Model so are relatively easy to design and test.</p><p><strong>Horizon 2 Business Model prototypes</strong> represent transformations of the existing Business Model. They aim to deliver substantial gains in Customer and Organization Value by focusing on adjacent markets, offering new ‘Who &amp; What’ combinations as well as new capabilities and resources to enable those combinations. They’re more complicated to design and test.</p><p><strong>Testing Horizon 1 and Horizon 2 Business Model Prototypes:</strong> There are five fundamental questions to answer:</p><p>1. What are the Value Creation expectations — Customer and/or Organization — of this prototype?</p><p>2. Is the prototype coherent? Is it logical, concise and consistent with the theory of value creation (<a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">the Value Logic</a>) that underpins the existing Business Model?</p><p>3. Is the prototype <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">integrated</a> (? Do the components fit together into a mutually reinforcing and interdependent system of value creation activities?</p><p>4. How does the prototype improve on or leverage the existing Business Model?</p><p>5. What are the conditions that must be in place for this prototype to successfully deliver Customer and Organization Value Creation expectations?</p><p>Before talking about these questions, it’s important to recognize that they’re a complement to rather than a substitute for financial modelling and quantitative testing. Choices between modelling and testing methodologies need to be tailored to the prototype Business Model in question. There is a wealth of literature on this subject so I will not dwell on it here.</p><p>But I do want to make two brief comments on the use of assumptions in financial modelling. First, assumptions usually involve extrapolating the past and using it to predict the future. At best it’s an unreliable methodology. At worst, it’s a recipe for failure.</p><blockquote><strong>It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future……Yogi Berra</strong></blockquote><p>Second, the temptation to ‘game’ assumptions to make the financials look better for whatever case the proponent is trying to make is always there……I’ve fallen into it and so have a lot of other managers!!!</p><p>Coming back to the five questions, the application of 1, 2 and 3 has been covered in earlier Posts in the <em>SCIP</em> series (see <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6">Customer Value</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793">Organization Value</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/how-to-create-customer-and-organization-value-simultaneously-b91d6f4a145a">How</a>). However, Question 4 deserves special, especially in the context of Horizon 2 Business Model prototypes .</p><p>History tells us that firms sometimes get seduced by their Horizon 1 success, by overconfidence in their own expertise and by the perceived potential in adjacent markets. They make the mistake of thinking Horizon 2 opportunities are easy tp capture. Consider two Australian examples in the hardware/DIY/home renovations arenas.</p><blockquote><strong>Never test the depth of the river with both feet</strong></blockquote><p>In 2011, Woolworths, one of two dominant retailers in the grocery supermarket business in Australia and with a significant presence in discount department stores and liquor retailing was so confident in its retailing capabilities that it entered a joint venture with Lowes from the U.S. and launched Masters in competition with Bunnings. If you’re not familiar with Bunnings, it is the Australian version of Home Depot. Bunnings was well established at the time, highly profitable and growing strongly. I talked about <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a">Bunnings</a> in the Making Sense Strategy Conversations Post.</p><p>In late 2016, five years after the first Masters’ store opened, the chain was closed down with accumulated losses for Woolworths of over $A3 billion. Despite Woolworths proven expertise in grocery retailing Masters failed to tick the boxes in all five questions. They focused on the number of store openings but missed the critical importance of store locations; they ignored key Customer segments and their value expectations; and the Business Model was neither coherent nor integrated. It was an unmitigated disaster that led to wholesale departures at board and management levels and a serious erosion of market value.</p><p>Ironically, around the same time, Wesfarmers (Bunnings parent company) announced the $A705 mill acquisition of Homebase, a struggling UK home improvement chain. This was Bunnings first big move offshore. The Homebase Business Model was quite different to Bunnings in terms of Customers; the product/service range; the stores and their locations; and the supply chain. The expectation was that installing Bunnings management and expertise would turn Homebase around. But instead of developing and testing changes to the Homebase Business Model the newly installed management swamped it with the Bunnings Business Model. Two years later, Wesfarmers announced the sale of Homebase with accumulated losses and write-downs around $A1.7 bill.</p><p>There was a lot of talk in the media about the old chestnut — <strong>good strategy, poor execution — </strong>with Masters and Homebase. But I don’t buy that. I’ll write more about both disasters in a future Post (The Execution Myth). The key point at this stage is that Horizon 1 expertise and prior performance, no matter how strong, do not necessarily lead to success in Horizon 2 markets.</p><p>Question 5 also deserves special mention — what are the conditions that must be in place for this prototype to successfully deliver Customer and Organization Value Creation expectations? In concept this is very similar to Roger Martin’s <a href="https://rogermartin.medium.com/what-would-have-to-be-true-83dac5bd2189">‘What Would Have To Be True’</a> question.</p><p>Conditions for Success can be reverse designed from the prototype Business Models. They can include macro environment, industry, market and competitive factors as well as those specific to the prototype under consideration. The test involves positing why a prototype will work rather than finding reasons why it won’t, which is a particularly useful approach to combat the negative thinking that often comes into play in firms when the status quo is challenged.</p><p>Once Conditions for Success have been identified they can be evaluated based on how likely they are to be true. This is a subjective test but nonetheless it provides an assessment of risk which informs choices between prototype Business Models. Identifying the Conditions for Success also highlights potential barriers to success that may need to be addressed in Making Things Happen Conversations. Finally, it enables these Conditions to be tracked and linked to firm performance in Revising Strategy Conversations.</p><p>As an example, Bunnings recently announced its “biggest ever category expansion” — the launch of around 1000 pet care products into 270 of its 400 retail outlets. One obvious Condition for Success for this Horizon 2 idea would be that Bunnings Customers will change from their current Petcare provider to Bunnings. In Australia it’s normal practice for most retail outlets to allow only assistance dogs inside. But Bunnings have allowed dogs inside their outlets for several years now. It’s common to see little Ellie May or even big Hank sitting up in a shopping cart while their owner wanders through the aisles. It’s even become trendy. There is now a Facebook page for the Dogs of Bunnings (<a href="https://www.facebook.com/dogsbunnings/">https://www.facebook.com/dogsbunnings/</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/362/1*KSgxSz2ixaD5AZO9CPNkWQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dogs of Bunnings</figcaption></figure><p>Was this prescience on the part of Bunnings? Was the firm establishing a pattern of Customer behaviour in advance of their Pet Care category expansion, one that was intended to foster a Condition to Success? I suspect yes. And next time I go to Bunnings I expect to see Ellie May, Hank and numerous other fluffy dogs sitting in their carts beside a tin of paint, some BBQ tools, other household paraphernalia, a dozen tins of dog food, and a new dog bowl………….</p><p><strong>Who participates in designing new Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model prototypes? </strong>Ideally design and testing of ideas should be a co-creation effort between Business Development executives and senior operational managers. The former should provide not only overall co-ordination but also a perspective outside the existing Business Model, one that is consistent with the Alternative Futures developed in the Making Sense Conversations. The latter should provide an ‘on the ground perspective’ of the potential Customer and Organization Value Creation associated with specific ideas and on how the existing Business Model might be modified to deliver this value.</p><p><strong>Designing and Testing Horizon 3 Ideas: </strong>By definition, a Horizon 3 idea involves addressing an unmet Customer need. The idea might stem from science and technology, from changing market forces, societal trends, government regulation and so on. Regardless, it is <strong>an idea in search of a Business Model.</strong> Designing and testing a Business Model to commercialize that idea is very different to the process for Horizon 1 and 2 ideas. It proceeds through an iterative and messy cycle of Customer Discovery, Customer Validation and Business Model Discovery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*i3VBkhBhdxgJ4IqbVOAlSw.png" /><figcaption>An Idea in Search of a Business Model</figcaption></figure><p>I’ll cover this process in more detail in a future Post but for now it’s important to recognize two key points. First, designing and testing Horizon 1 and 2 Business Model prototypes is about answering the five questions previously posed. However, designing and testing Horizon 3 prototypes is quite different. In the words of Clay Christensen:</p><blockquote><strong>The language that is characteristic of this stage is the language of questions, not of answers</strong></blockquote><p>Second, Horizon 3 ideas are typically managed outside the existing business. Why? Because Horizon 3 ideas will usually involve a different Value Logic to the existing business and so will require a completely different set of Business Model exploration capabilites. Some businesses set up corporate incubators, separate business units that operate at arm’s length to the core business and are dedicated to the development of Horizon 3 ideas. Some, like big Pharma companies, contract out much of the work on Discovery and Validation.</p><p>Like Making Sense Strategy Conversations, Designing Strategy Conversations are not linear. They’re iterative and messy. The more you practice them, the better your strategy is likely to be.</p><p><em>Questions or comments are always welcome.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14566b4e9d76" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Better Strategy I: It’s About Insight, Not Plans]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/want-better-strategy-start-with-making-sense-strategy-conversations-c2bb19b6b83a?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2bb19b6b83a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy-insight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alternative-futures]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[better-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[making-sense-of-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 May 2024 22:47:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-26T22:19:15.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How to make sense of what really matters for Value Creation.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*17P7Wns3JjW7yAPRkZTfnw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by janoon 028 on Freepik</figcaption></figure><p><em>I</em><strong><em>t’s not what you look at that matters, it’s what you see………Henry David Thoreau</em></strong></p><p>The notion that Strategic Planning is the pathway to Strategy is still widely held in many organizations. The problem is that Strategic Planning is typically long on analyses but short on insight and creativity.</p><p>Strategic Planning typically involves weeks or months of analytical pre-work using a myriad of Strategic Management tools and frameworks, all of which goes into Strategic Planning’s ‘black box’. Then, almost by magic, out of the box pops 3-to-5-year predictions, a set of firm specific objectives and a ‘laundry list’ of fragmented threads of activity, typically called strategies, intended to achieve those objectives. But, there is no overarching logic that underpins these so called strategies and that links them to Customer and Organization Value Creation.</p><p>To the extent that there is an algorithm in the ‘box’ it is usually extrapolation of history overlaid with corporate politics and decision biases. To paraphrase Thoreau, Strategic Planning looks at lots of things but doesn’t see what really matters for Customer and Organization Value Creation (see <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/disappointed-with-strategic-planning-there-is-a-better-way-try-strategy-conversations-in-practice-32c7bfd6baf8">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">here</a> ).</p><p>Is there a better way? Yes — <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice (SCIP). </em>In<em> SCIP, </em>a<em> </em>Making Sense<em> </em>Strategy Conversation<em> </em>is the first in a learning loop of four distinct but interconnected, iterative, and reflective ‘Conversations’. The Business Model View sits at the core of the loop, as a touchstone for each Conversation and the collective output of all four Conversations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CH1nCitzoFMvTl1-5KL1uw.png" /></figure><p>In <em>SCIP </em>I define Business Strategy as <strong><em>the system or pattern realized in the choices — what to do, what not to do — an organization makes in creating value for its Customers, for itself and for its stakeholder. </em>I<em> </em></strong>use the Business Model View to describe this system or pattern.</p><p>Making Sense Strategy Conversations focus on using this Business Model View to describe the Value Creation choices a firm has already made— it’s existing or <strong>What Is Strategy — </strong>and to develop what these choices might look like in the future — it’s <strong>What Might Be Strategy</strong>. Insight into what really matters for Value Creation is critical in the ‘What Is’ stage while insight and creativity are critical in the ‘What Might Be’ stage</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lZjYt1Kv6tC2iT_dePYihQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>‘</strong>What<strong> Is’ — the Existing Strategy</strong></h4><p>Step 1 in describing <strong>‘</strong>What Is<strong>’</strong> involves understanding a firm’s performance and context. What are the firm’s performance expectations in terms of creating Customer and Organization Value and is it meeting those expectations? How does the firm’s context, its industry, markets and/or competitors affect its ability to meet those expectations?</p><p>The <strong>selective</strong> use of some of the analytical tools of Strategic Management is important in Step 1. I say ‘selective’ to distinguish Step 1 from the preparatory work in Strategic Planning which often takes weeks or months. In a Making Sense Conversation, Step 1 should only take a day or two.</p><p>Step 2 in describing ‘What Is’ involves understanding the Business Model choices that underpin those expectations and how those choices affect the firm’s ability to meet performance expectations? Step 2 involves the use of Strategy as Design concepts (see <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/the-strategy-conversations-framework-better-strategy-better-results-bb60319a2340">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">here</a>) to reverse design the existing Business Model. Step 3 involves synthesizing the information from 1 and 2 to gain insight into the unique strategy opportunity, problem or question the firm faces.</p><p><strong>Reverse designing a Business Model </strong>in <em>SCIP</em> is analgous to reverse engineering in that it involves ‘deconstructing’ the firm’s existing strategy and then ‘reconstructing’ it using the Business Model View as the framework.</p><p><strong>‘Deconstructing’ a firm’s existing strategy focuses on its actions (what it does and doesn’t do now) not its plans.</strong> The process groups these actions into Customer Value Creation, Organization Value Creation, and How the Value is created. The ‘deconstructing’ steps have been covered in detail in earlier Posts in the <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice (SCIP)</em> series (refer to <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6">here</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141">here</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793">here</a>, and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/how-to-create-customer-and-organization-value-simultaneously-b91d6f4a145a">here</a> ).</p><p>Typically, the questions asked at this stage might include:</p><p><strong>Who are our Primary Customers ?</strong> What is their Job to be Done?Why do they buy our product or service? Which Customer Value dimensions do we excel in? Which dimensions do we meet table stakes in? Which dimensions do we not even bother about? How do our excel, table stakes, and not bother dimensions of Customer Value compare to competitive offerings?</p><p><strong>Who are our current stakeholders?</strong> What dimensions of Organization Value — Economic, Social and Environmental — are important to them? Why? Which of these dimensions do we excel in, meet table stakes in, not bother about?</p><p><strong>How do we create these dimensions of Customer and Organization Value? </strong>What are the Capabilities and Resources that we excel in, that we meet table stakes in, and that we ignore?</p><p>‘Reconstructing’ a firm’s strategy involves visually combining these components, usually on a big whiteboard, into a holistic Business Model specific to the firm. Whenever I’ve gone through the ‘reconstruction’ process with firms or watched others do it for the first time in Executive Education classes , the ‘reconstructed’ Business Model often looks more like spaghetti thrown at the whiteboard than a Business Model. That’s OK. This is where synthesis comes in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Jz_lMYm4VaZ_DTK_sfvA7w.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Synthesis is About Asking Better Questions</strong></blockquote><p>Step 3, the process of ‘synthesis’ in Making Sense Strategy Conversations iterates between questions and ‘reconstruction’ until Business Model clarity starts to emerge from the ‘spaghetti’. Synthesis involves developing hypotheses for the Value Logic that underpins this Business Model and testing the choices made within each component of the Model for focus, coherence and integration relative to this Value Logic ( see <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9">here</a> ).</p><blockquote><strong><em>Focus </em></strong>— <em>Do we excel in one clear and dominant Value Logic? What is it? Is it supported by table stakes performance in the other two Value Logics? Are we following it consistently? If not, where are we falling down and why? Are we stuck in the Zone of Mediocrity? Why? What can we stop doing?</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Coherence:</em></strong><em> Is there a logical, consistent and concise cause and effect pathway from what the firm does (How) to the Customer and Organization Value it creates. Is this pathway consistent with the Value Logic? Are there activities that we can stop doing?</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Integration:</em></strong><em> Do all the components fit together into a mutually reinforcing system of Value Creation? Are there activities that are not integrated? What can we stop doing?</em></blockquote><p>Two other questions round out the synthesis stage.</p><p><strong>What external circumstances</strong> (economic, technology, culture, health, industry, regulatory, competitors etc) are likely to change in the future. What are the implications for our current Business Model?</p><p><strong>Are Customer and Organization Value expectations likely to change</strong> in the future? Why and in what way? What are the implications for our current Business Model?</p><p>The findings from these questions are then abstracted up to identify the major strategy problem, opportunity or question the firm faces. This is where insight is critical. Insight is a skill. Steps 2 and 3 are iterative and often messy. The more times you go back and forth between them the better will be your insight.</p><h4>‘What Might Be’ Strategy</h4><blockquote><strong>Creating Alternative Futures is very different to trying to predict the future</strong></blockquote><p>The final step in Making Sense Strategy Conversations involves drawing on the concepts and tools of Strategy as Innovation to imagine a firm’s ‘Alternative Futures’ in which the problem, opportunity or question is resolved. An ‘Alternative Future’ is not a fluffy Vision or Mission statement. Nor is it a goal or an objective. Rather, it’s a different way to see the firm, one that can be framed in terms of Business Model choices.</p><p>For example, way back in 2010 Dominos Pizza in Australia saw a ‘Digital Future’ for the business and started to invest in technology aimed at easier ordering , delivery tracking, faster make and delivery times for Customers and lower operating costs for the organization itself (see the Post <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141">Doing Everything Is Not Strategy</a>). They started slowly but by 2013 the results were so strong that the CEO, Don Meij, excitedly announced that Dominos had moved <em>from a pizza business to an online digital business that sells pizzas……..we are best in class for digital sales, marketing and execution……..</em></p><p>Maybe he was being a little over the top but there is no doubt that insight proved to be a game changer for the Dominos business in Australia.</p><p>Interestingly, in a 2022 interview about the turnaround efforts currently underway in Pizza Hut Australia, the CEO at the time said that his <em>main focus has been reshaping what was a restaurant-based operation into a delivery business by using digital technology.</em> A little late??</p><p>Strategy as Innovation starts with the reverse designed Business Model and then searches for ways to ‘Exploit’ that Business Model and ‘Explore’ new Business Models simultaneously.</p><p><strong>Exploitation</strong> focuses on continuously enhancing the current Business Model, on refreshing the current Value Proposition and improving ‘How’ to deliver that Value Proposition.</p><p><strong>‘Exploration’</strong> focuses on discovering and validating adjacent and/or completely new Customers, their Jobs to be Done, alternative Value Propositions, and new Business Model discovery, iterative testing and subsequent scale up.</p><p>This process of Exploitation and Exploration is typically called Business Model Innovation. It relies on a number of creative thinking tools, too many to discuss in this Post (there will be a future Post on this topic) but two excellent books on the subject stand out — Business Model Generation (Alex Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur) and Seizing The White Space: Business Model Innovation For Growth and Renewal (Mark Johnson).</p><p>A major problem firms often run into when trying to develop ‘Alternative Futures’ is that they end up with another ‘laundry list’ of ideas that may not fit with the Value Logic of the existing business and may not have natural owners within the existing business. <em>SCIP</em> uses a modified version of the 3 Horizons of Growth developed by McKinsey in 2000 to make sense of these ideas, to translate them into a portfolio of Alternative Futures described in terms of Business Model choices. This portfolio is the output of Making Sense Strategy Conversations. It’s important for two main reasons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DpbQF5OcNPwUTvW9W51Rhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Making Sense of Alternative Futures</figcaption></figure><p>First, identifying a portfolio in this way enables the ideas to be screened, prioritized and management responsibilities allocated. Horizon 1 ideas are an extension of the existing business. They should be relatively simple to validate and implement and provide a clear and quick boost to performance. Horizon 1 ideas should always be the province of existing managers.</p><p>Horizon 2 ideas leverage the existing business but go a step further into new ‘Who &amp; What’ Value Creation combinations. They explore emerging opportunities that leverage Horizon 1, follow an iterative development path and have the potential to drive a step change in performance. Horizon 2 ideas may be the province of existing managers or may involve specialist project teams outside the existing business. Regardless, successful Horizon 2 ideas always move into the existing (Horizon 1) business in time.</p><p>Horizon 3 ideas usually require a leap of faith in their potential and follow a slow, iterative and messy (think Newman’s Design Squiggle) development path. They should always be the province of specialist project teams (or business units) operating outside the existing business.</p><p>As a rule of thumb and provided there are no ‘burning platform’ issues with the existing business, Horizon 1 ideas should occupy 70% of the time and effort in a Making Sense Strategy Conversation, with 20% devoted to Horizon 2 and 10% to Horizon 3.</p><p>Second, Horizons 1, 2 and 3 ideas in the portfolio must be progressed in parallel, not sequentially. Rapid advances in technology, especially digital, mean that the development time for Business Model Innovation has shortened considerably. When you add in increasing competition, it becomes clear that firms need a view across all three Horizons contemporaneously and a sense of urgency around continuously creating their own future.</p><p>Let’s take a brief look at how a Making Sense Conversation can be retrospectively applied to Bunnings’ Business Strategy over recent years. Bunnings is the Australian equivalent of Home Depot. It is a large ($A18 bill revenue) and very profitable ($A2.2 bill earnings) business unit of Wesfarmers. The first Bunnings ‘big box’ store opened in 1995. Its Value Logic was and still is Operations Leadership and its Customer Value Proposition ‘Lowest Prices, Widest Range, Best Experience’.</p><p>Between 1995 and 2023 Bunnings sales and earnings grew at around 15% CAGR and 18% CAGR respectively. The key insight that ignited this growth and has underpinned it ever since was the realization that Bunnings had opportunities in what they call ‘Addressable Markets’ (adjacent markets in the Three Horizons model) outside the traditional hardware market. Bunnings Business Strategy has been to progressively expand into carefully selected segments of these ‘Addressable Markets’ by leveraging the existing Business Model. Most of these Horizon 2 ideas were rolled out in the existing stores and, by virtue of the increased volume, contributed to improved effectiveness and efficiency in those stores, a Horizon 1 effect.</p><p>Bunnings ‘Addressable Markets’ show a progression from traditional hardware to Home Improvement, to Home Improvement and Outdoor Living, to Home and Lifestyle + Commercial, to Interconnected Home and Lifestlye + Commercial. Within each of these markets sub-segments were identified and products or services launched.</p><p>A recent example of a Lifestyle subsegment is Pet Care. Pet ownership in Australia exploded during the pandemic. Given this opportunity, Bunnings are slowly rolling out their biggest ever new category with up to 1000 Pet Care products to be added to the range.</p><p>Bunnings has also implemented a number of Horizon 2 ideas aimed at moving from a part-time focus on ‘tradies’ as Customers within their consumer-oriented stores to dedicated ‘tradie’ offerings. A recent example was the acquisition of Tool Kit Depot, a small, localised group of stores that retail and hire high-end power tools, specialised woodworking equipment and other commercial grade products. Tool Kit Depot’s Business Model is related to Bunnings core business, but it is also very different in terms of the product range, knowledge and service that are essential in this market segment. For Bunnings it’s an ‘emerging’ Business Model that will be scaled up and expanded geographically but managed as a separate business unit while management ‘learns’ how it works.</p><p>Making Sense Strategy Conversations set the overall direction for the firm so they should be the province of senior managers and board directors. They are not a once p.a. exercise and they’re not part of the budget cycle. Rather, Making Sense Conversations should happen when there are signs that Customer Value and/or Organization Value expectations are not being met, when there are unexpected changes in a firm’s environment, when the conditions for success (Roger Martin’s <a href="https://rogermartin.medium.com/what-would-have-to-be-true-83dac5bd2189">What Would Have To Be True</a>) of the Business Strategy are in doubt or don’t eventuate. The timing of Making Sense Strategy Conversations is a judgment call, not a calendar call.</p><p>Making Sense Strategy Conversations are not linear. The arrows go one way in the visual for simplicity of presentation. But the reality is that Making Sense Strategy Conversations involve an iterative and messy process. However, the more you practice them, the better your insight becomes. And the better your insight becomes, the more likely you are to develop a creative strategy that will set your firm apart from the crowd (who are stuck in Strategic Planning mode).</p><p>Finally, at their core, Making Sense Strategy Conversations are ‘damn good arguments’ (vigorous but constructive debate to be more polite), seen through the Business Model View, about a firm’s existing Strategy and what changes need to be made for <strong>Better Strategy</strong>.</p><p><strong><em>Questions or comments are welcome. That’s what Strategy Conversations are all about.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2bb19b6b83a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where is the Business Model in Strategic Plans?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/where-is-the-business-model-in-strategic-plans-4f4a5b86d2a9?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f4a5b86d2a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-models]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategic-planning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 May 2024 21:28:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-29T20:22:07.677Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>It’s definitely not in the laundry list of activities that Strategic Planning loves!!</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/0*c79f9GvrdpcR2AxH.png" /></figure><p>In my first Post in the <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice</em> <em>(SCIP)</em> series I argued that Strategy has lost its way. Rather than providing focused direction, strategy has become over complicated, fragmented, and confusing. The main culprit — Strategic Planning.</p><p>While Strategic Planning has become institutionalised in the business world, I agree with Henry Mintzberg. Strategic Planning is an oxymoron. You cannot plan Strategy because planning is primarily about analysis while Strategy is primarily about synthesis, about developing insight into what really matters. I also agree with Roger Martin — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iuYlGRnC7J8">a Plan is not a Strategy</a>. A Plan involves programming activities in an organization while a Strategy involves developing a focused, coherent and integrated theory of value creation.</p><p>The output of Strategic Planning is typically a ‘laundry list’ of fragmented threads of activity, usually called strategies, that are grounded in an internal perspective of the firm and aimed primarily at creating value for the firm itself rather than for its Customers. Strategic Plans rarely have an overall ‘logic’, an overarching ‘theory of the business’ that integrates these so-called strategies and guides choices and trade-offs between them, what to do and what not to do. Instead, Strategic Plans try to do everything which is, at best, a recipe for mediocrity ( <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141">Doing Everything Is Not Strategy</a>).</p><p>This is where the Business Model View and the Value Logic concept used in <em>SCIP </em>come in. In earlier Posts I’ve covered <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6">Customer Value</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793">Organization Value</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/how-to-create-customer-and-organization-value-simultaneously-b91d6f4a145a">How</a> each are created but have only touched on the Value Logic concept. The Value Logic at the core of the Business Model View is a generic theory of Strategy as contemporaneous Customer and Organization Value Creation that informs the choices about each component of the Business Model and explains the interdependencies between them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/926/0*KAP1HQsHNbCZnw9P.png" /></figure><p>The Value Logic concept in <em>SCIP</em> is derived from the Value Disciplines described by Michael Treacy and Fred Wiersema in their book, <em>The Discipline of Market Leaders</em>. These authors argued that firms outperform their competitors by carefully choosing their target Customers, and focusing tightly on delivering, at a level their competitors cannot match, the dimensions of value those Customers expect and will pay for. They posed three different ‘Value Disciplines’ as generic theories of value creation.</p><p>In <em>SCIP</em>, I’ve adapted these ‘Value Disciplines’ and relabelled them as Value Logics — Operations Leadership, Product/Service Leadership, and Customization Leadership (Table). The key premise underlying the Value Logic concepts is that different Customers will prefer different dimensions of Value. In creating these different dimensions of Customer Value, firms will capture different dimensions of Organization Value. Not surprisingly, the How of Value Creation will also be different for each Value Logic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*O6m_Iq3FQBzYHPIr.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793">*For dimensions of Social and Environmental Value see the Post Organization Value — Economic, Social, Environmental</a></p><p><strong>Implications for Business Model Design</strong></p><p>It is important to recognize that, while each Value Logic involves different, albeit generic perspectives on Customer Value, Organization Value and How, Business Model design involves translating these generic perspectives to form a Model that is <strong>specific </strong>to the firm in question. It is also important to recognize that the three Value Logics are not mutually exclusive.</p><p>In practice, these two insights mean that many different Business Models are possible even within the same industry by configuring choices on Value Logic, Customer Value, Organization Value and How differently.</p><p><strong>Implications for Value Creation</strong></p><p>The potential for a Business Model to create Customer and Organization Value depends on three factors — Focus, Coherence and Integration.</p><p><strong>Focus: </strong>There must be one <strong>Dominant Value Logic</strong> in which the firm excels supported by Table Stakes performance in the other two. When a firm chooses its Primary Customers and the Value Proposition to offer those Customers, it automatically sets its Dominant Value Logic which then shapes the other Business Model choices — Organization Value and How. In practice, this plays out as excelling in carefully selected Value Dimensions, meeting either competitive parity or internal standards (Table Stakes) in some other Value Dimensions and ignoring others.</p><p>For example, firms whose Dominant Value Logic is Product/Service Leadership or Customization Leadership cannot ignore cost. If their product/service costs rise faster than their ability to raise prices, then margins will be eroded. Thisusually leads to expenditure reductions elsewhere in the business (R&amp;D, capex, people, technology) which often lead to a downward spiral in revenue and profits. One way to protect against this is to maintain a secondary focus on Operations Leadership, to constantly look for ways to take cost out of the business without adversely affecting revenue and/or the firm’s ability to continue to offer a high level of unique functionality or customization value dimensions.</p><p>Similarly, firms whose Dominant Value Logic is Operations Leadership cannot ignore product/service innovation. They must be able to meet Table Stakes standards in terms of functionality or they will lose volume.</p><p><strong>Coherence: </strong>To effectively create Customer and Organization Value, a firm’s Business Model must be coherent. It must demonstrate a cogent, consistent and concise pathway from what the firm does (How) to the Customer and Organization Value it creates. There must be a clear cause and effect model whereby every step is consistent with the Dominant Value Logic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/926/0*DfSB6Vq_jM0qDJxZ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Integration: </strong>To effectively create Customer and Organization Value, a firm’s Business Model must be integrated. The components must all fit together and must be mutually reinforcing. How often do you see organizations that operate in silos? Instead of being integrated, they each go their own way, creating problems within the organization and outside it for their Customers. Banks, airlines and insurance companies are classic examples.</p><p><strong>Summary: </strong>A firm’s Value Logic is its theory of Strategy as contemporaneous Customer and Organization Value Creation. There are three different, but not mutually exclusive Value Logics — Operations Leadership, Product/Service Leadership and Customization Leadership. Each Value Logic involves different, albeit generic perspectives on Customer Value, Organization Value and How. Business Model design involves translating these generic perspectives to form a Model that is specific to the firm in question. The potential for a Business Model to create Customer and Organization Value depends on three factors: <strong>(1)</strong> <strong>Focus</strong> — the Business Model must be based on one clearly dominant Value Logic supported by Table Stakes in one of the other two; <strong>(2) Coherence</strong> — the Business Model must demonstrate a cogent, consistent and concise pathway from what the firm does (How) to the Customer and Organization Value it creates; and <strong>(3) Integration</strong> — the components of the Business Model must all fit together and must be mutually reinforcing.</p><p><em>Your feedback is important to me. If you have questions or comments please let me know via the Response button</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/tag/value-logic?source=post_page-----c5e33aa6a87f---------------value_logic-----------------">Value Logic</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/tag/theory-of-strategy?source=post_page-----c5e33aa6a87f---------------theory_of_strategy-----------------">Theory Of Strategy</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/tag/business-model-view?source=post_page-----c5e33aa6a87f---------------business_model_view-----------------">Business Model View</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f4a5b86d2a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strategy: Choose Where to Excel, Where to Meet Table Stakes, Where to Not Bother]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/how-to-create-customer-and-organization-value-simultaneously-b91d6f4a145a?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b91d6f4a145a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[what-not-to-do]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[choices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[what-to-do]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jan 2024 19:42:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-26T22:15:17.790Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Use the Business Model View to Design a Coherent and Integrated Capabilities + Resources System</strong></h4><p><strong><em>Different customers buy different kinds of value. You can’t hope to be the best in all dimensions, so you choose your customers and narrow your value focus…………… provide the best offering in the marketplace by excelling in a specific dimension of value……………maintain threshold standards in other dimensions of value….</em></strong></p><p>Michael Treacy and Fred Wiersema in <em>The Discipline of Market Leaders</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/1*7Bs8gn_geKha78_jsgxaLg.png" /><figcaption>How to Design a Coherent &amp; Integrated Capabilities &amp; Resources System</figcaption></figure><p>In previous Posts I’ve covered the Who, What and Why of Customer Value (<a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6">Being Customer Centric Is Not Strategy</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141">Doing Everything Is Not Strategy</a>), and Organization Value (<a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793">Organization Value — Economic, Social, Environmental</a>) in the context of a firm’s Business Model View and its underlying Value Logic. In this Post I cover <strong>How </strong>to create Customer and Organization Value by focusing on the system of Capabilities + Resources that needs to be in place.</p><p>In using the <em>Strategy Conversations In Practice </em>framework in an existing organization the first step is to reverse design the existing Business Model. While this is an iterative process it starts with understanding the Primary Customers, their Job to be Done, the Value created for those Customers (specified in terms of Excel and Table Stakes Dimensions), the underlying Value Logic and the Organization Value created as a result. The process goes on to understand <strong>How</strong> the firm currently creates value for those Customers, for itself and for its stakeholders.</p><p>In this Post I will first discuss the ‘How’ of Value Creation as a stand-alone component and then discuss its interdependencies with Customer and Organization Value.</p><p><strong>Capabilities + Resources System</strong> <strong>= How</strong></p><p>There are multiple ways to conceive of ‘How’ in the Business Model View, most of which are too complex. I prefer to keep it simple by thinking about ‘How’ in terms of a system of coherent and integrated Capabilities and Resources.</p><p>When I ask practitioners about their organization’s Capabilities and Resources, they often answer in terms of its structure and functions. But Capabilities and Resources are more than that. Capabilities are cross-functional business processes or activities that enable value creation. For example, a logistics capability in a consumer products business might integrate functions such as order processing, invoicing, inventory control, distribution, customer follow up and returns management with the aim being to deliver low total cost to its Customers and cost efficiencies to itself.</p><p>Resources enable capabilities to be exercised and improved. Resources might be physical (plant, equipment, infrastructure, land), intellectual (technologies, brands, information systems), people (knowledge, skills, experience, relationships) and organizational (management systems or routines, culture, alliances, networks, reputation).</p><p>It’s the coherence and integration of Capabilities and Resources in the context of a firm’s Business Model that enable it to create value, not only for Customers but also for the organization itself and its stakeholders.</p><p><strong>The Customer Value Proposition Determines the Capabilities + Resources System</strong></p><p>In <em>SCIP, </em>when a firm chooses its Primary Customers and the Value Proposition it offers to those Customers it automatically determines it’s dominant, albeit generic ‘Value Logic’, which in turn broadly informs choices on Organization Value and on the generic Capabilities + Resources system that must be in place.</p><p>The relationship between generic ‘Excel’ dimensions of Customer and Organization Value and ‘Excel’ Capabilities and Resources is summarized in the table below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*KF__do5aSnWpUviTvHU5YQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>More specifically:</p><p><strong>‘Excel’</strong> Capabilities + Resources are those that really matter. They are key differentiators and demand a disproportionate share of management focus and investment, as well as continuous innovation.</p><p><strong>‘Table stakes’</strong> Capabilities + Resources must be maintained and updated from time to time in line with changes in Customer and stakeholder expectations. They cannot be ignored, and they become critical if a firm falls behind minimum expected standards.</p><p><strong>‘Don’t Bother’</strong> Capabilities + Resources mean just that. Stop funding them, stop doing them. Unfortunately, this is one of the hardest choices for many organizations to make. It’s the ‘status quo bias’ in action. Firms and people struggle to stop doing what they’ve always done.</p><p>In <em>SCIP </em>there are three important implications for practitioners when making choices about the firm specific Capabilities + Resources system in their Business Model.</p><blockquote><strong>Choosing Capabilities + Resources is an Iterative, not a Linear Process</strong></blockquote><p>The Table shown previously oversimplifies the process through which these choices are made. The progression from Customer Value to Organization Value to the Capabilities + Resources System is not linear and nor is it a simple process. Rather, it’s a design process that is better represented by the Business Model View in the figure below. This View demonstrates a holistic pattern of interdependent Value Creation choices that must be considered simultaneously and iteratively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/1*a29pioh-wGX01n5oP8Atzw.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1 Expanded Business Model View</figcaption></figure><p>The practical implication of this iterative process is that having chosen the Primary Customers and the Value Proposition to be offered to those Customers, if the appropriate mix of Excel and Table Stakes Capabilities + Resources does not already exist, cannot be developed internally or readily acquired from outside the organization, then it’s time to start over again. Primary Customers, the Value Proposition, the expected Organization Value, and the Capabilities + Resources System all need to be reconsidered until they come together into a Business Model with a dominant Value Logic that demonstrates:</p><p><strong>Coherence: </strong>It must make sense, it must demonstrate a logical, consistent and concise pathway from How to the Who, What and Why of Customer and Organization Value Creation.</p><p><strong>Integration: </strong>The components must all fit together and must be mutually reinforcing.</p><blockquote><strong>Maintain Existing Value Creation While Integrating Business Model Innovation Ideas</strong></blockquote><p>As I previously mentioned, in an existing business, <em>SCIP </em>starts with reverse designing the existing Business Model. <em>SCIP </em>goes on to identifying opportunities to innovate that Business Model to improve Value Creation. The ‘Strategy Challenge’ at this stage is to keep the existing Business Model ticking along while, at the same time, integrating Business Model Innovation ideas that have the potential to realize additional, sustainable Value Creation.</p><p>Balancing the ‘new’ with the ‘existing’ is always difficult, especially in larger organizations. Some people embrace change. They go all in on the new ideas and pay little attention to the existing business. Others are resistant, preferring to stick with what they’ve always done in the past.</p><p>So, in <em>SCIP, </em>I frame Business Model Innovation ideas as Strategy Projects that overlay the existing Business Model and use Project Management concepts and tools to manage the transition from the existing Business Model to the new Business Model.</p><p>There are three important benefits to this approach. First, it maintains focus on the existing business, which is, after all, the major source of revenue and profits. Second, by establishing appropriate Project Teams to manage and integrate Business Model innovation ideas, support and momentum for the relevant changes can be built across an organization. Third, senior executives can use Project Management tools to track progress, to ensure an appropriate balance is kept between the existing and the new and to make revisions where appropriate.</p><blockquote><strong>Look for What Not To Do</strong></blockquote><p>What falls out of identifying the Excel and the Table Stakes Capabilities and Resources is usually activities that can be stopped, products or services that can be phased out, assets that can be divested. But, as I mentioned previously, people often struggle to stop doing what they’ve always done. Again, Project Management can play an important role as a mechanism to manage ‘what not to do’ in the same way that it does with ‘what to do’.</p><p><strong>Summary: </strong>The ‘<strong>How’</strong> component of the Business Model View is the system of Capabilities + Resources that a firm uses to create Customer and Organization Value. <strong>‘How’</strong> is first described generically using the Value Logic typology. From there, ‘How’ is designed in the context of the firm’s Business Model by identifying the specific Capabilities and Resources needed to deliver those Dimensions of Customer Value where the firm chooses to Excel and those where it chooses to meet Table Stakes.</p><p>The challenge is to keep the existing Business Model ticking along while, at the same time, integrating Business Model Innovation ideas that have the potential to realize new and sustainable value creation. The concepts and tools of Project Management are critical, not only to integrating new ideas but also to phasing out activities, products and services that no longer create value.</p><p><em>Your feedback is important. If you like this Post please give it a ‘clap’. If you have questions or comments please let me know via the Response button.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b91d6f4a145a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Maximizing Shareholder Value — A Legitimate Goal of Business Strategy or the Dumbest Idea in the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/maximizing-shareholder-value-a-legitimate-goal-of-business-strategy-or-the-dumbest-idea-in-the-3c15f9953972?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c15f9953972</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stakeholder-capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shareholder-primacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shareholder-value]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Nov 2023 08:01:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-27T08:38:17.910Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Maximizing Shareholder Value — A Legitimate Goal of Business Strategy or the Dumbest Idea in the World?</strong></h3><h4><strong>How Qantas Got Into A Tailspin</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/726/1*qa1ON198gL1VEKfUUE7N1g.png" /></figure><p><em>….if a farsighted capitalist had been present at Kitty Hawk, he would have done his successors a huge favor by shooting Orville down.</em></p><p>Warren Buffett in his 2007 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders</p><p><strong>From Managerial Capitalism to Shareholder Primacy</strong></p><p>For most of the 20th century firms were managed according to a philosophy called ‘managerial capitalism’. In this philosophy boards of directors and managers called the shots and made decisions not only for the benefit of shareholders but also for Customers, suppliers, employees, and the community. During this era, shareholders were widely dispersed and played a passive role.</p><p>But this started to change in 1970 when Milton Friedman, an Economist, published an essay in the New York Times forcefully arguing that there was only one proper purpose for a business — to maximize profits for its owners (who Freidman assumed to be its shareholders) while conforming to the basic rules of society.</p><p>Friedman’s proposition got a strong boost in 1976 when Michael Jensen and Dean Meckling published their famous article on Agency Theory. In a nutshell, Agency Theory argues that directors and managers are inherently self-interested, and that controls and incentives need to be put in place to ensure they maximize owners’ (shareholders) wealth. This was the start of equity-based compensation for executives.</p><p>By the early 1980s, the notion that corporations should be managed solely for the benefit of their shareholders was up and running. In 1990 Jensen wrote another article that gave equity-based compensation a further push, arguing that CEOs should be paid with significant amounts of shares so that their interests would be aligned with shareholders. Equity based compensation subsequently exploded in its application, if not in beneficial effects over the next 30 years.</p><p>By the time the year 2000 came around there was widespread support in the Anglo-American business world for what became known as Shareholder Primacy, the notion that public corporations are owned by their shareholders, that Shareholder Value should take precedence over the interests of all other corporate stakeholders such as society and the environment in general, specific communities, suppliers, employees and even the organization itself, and that the primary responsibility of boards and management (even the ‘purpose’) of publicly listed corporations is to maximize a corporation’s share price for the benefit of current shareholders.</p><p><strong>Maximizing Shareholder Value is a Choice, not a Legal Obligation</strong></p><p>Maximizing Shareholder Value (MSV) involves a single-minded focus on short-term profits as the perceived driver of share price, on doing whatever it takes to boost profits this quarter, and to repeat the cycle next quarter, and the next, and the next…….. A related perspective involves maximizing Total Shareholder Return which factors in gains or losses in share price plus dividends, again in the short term.</p><p>But this is a doctrine that has attracted escalating criticism since the early 2000s when the accounting scandals associated with Enron, WorldCom, Tyco, Global Crossing and others began to emerge. Serious questions have been increasingly raised about the legal basis for Shareholder Primacy, especially the idea that shareholders are the ‘owners’ of corporations.</p><p>While this ownership question is still under debate it has become clear in recent years that <strong>Maximizing Shareholder Value is a managerial choice, not a legal obligation.</strong> And it’s a choice that can involve accountability problems and dubious, if not illegal, managerial behavior.</p><p>McKinsey politely describes this dubious behavior as using ‘accounting or financial gimmicks’ while The Economist calls it ‘shenanigans’. Steve Denning, writing in Forbes 2016, cuts to the chase by calling it ‘institutionalized selfishness’ whereby some managers, boards of directors, shareholders and institutional investors look after their own interests at the expense of all other stakeholders.</p><p>Some examples of this behavior include ‘managing’ (manipulating might be a better term) short term earnings to meet analysts’ expectations and/or to look better than they actually are by cutting R &amp; D and other long-term growth investments; squeezing workers and suppliers; avoiding taxes; relying on exorbitant but short-term equity based pay incentives for executives; share buybacks at the expense of reinvesting in the business; using share options to lock employees in; ‘greenwashing’; pursuing risky acquisitions, joint ventures or projects that lead to a ‘sugar hit’ in the share price but fail to create long term value…..and the playbook goes on!</p><p>Back in 2009, Jack Welch, a former CEO of GE from 1981 to 2001 and former champion of MSV during that period made, rather ironically, an important observation:</p><p><em>On the face of it, shareholder value is the dumbest idea in the world. Shareholder value is a result, not a strategy…………your main constituencies are your employees, your customers and your products. Managers and investors should not set share price increases as their overarching goal………Short-term profits should be allied with an increase in the long term-term value of a company….</em></p><p>In the following decade there were many articles and publications condemning MSV. If you want to read a few of these, Google Steve Denning in Forbes.</p><p><strong>A Shift in Thinking to Sustained Value Creation for All Stakeholders</strong></p><p>By 2019 a quantum shift in thinking had occurred. That year the Business Round Table (BRT), the peak body for corporate CEOs in the U.S. which had endorsed MSV as the sole purpose of public companies for the previous 22 years, released a new statement on the purpose of a corporation saying that:</p><p><em>……….companies should serve not only their shareholders, but also deliver value to their customers, invest in employees, deal fairly with suppliers and support the communities in which they operate.</em></p><p>Interestingly, the five commitments made by the BRT had <em>delivering value to customers </em>at the very top and <em>generating long-term value for shareholders, who provide the capital that allows companies to invest, grow and innovate </em>at the bottom.</p><p>The Davos Manifesto 2020 was very similar:</p><p><em>The purpose of a company is to engage all its stakeholders in shared and sustained value creation. In creating such value, a company serves not only its shareholders, but all its stakeholders — employees, customers, suppliers, local communities and society at large.</em></p><p>So, how do this quantum shift in thinking inform the question posed in the headline to this story?</p><p><strong>Business Strategy and Shareholder Value</strong></p><p>My perspective has long been that Shareholder Value, measured by share price, is not a legitimate nor even a sensible goal of Business Strategy. In <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice (SCIP), </em>I deliberately exclude share price as a dimension of Organization Value Creation. Why?</p><p>First, share price is an outcome of the Business Model choices a firm makes, the <em>Strategy Conversations</em> it goes through in continuously innovating this Business Model, and its performance in creating sustainable Customer and Organization Value, all in the context of its competitive, industry and macro environments including government policies, technology changes, regulatory and competitive changes to name just a few.</p><p>Second, share price is a subjective valuation. It’s part science, part art, and part ‘smoke and mirrors’ on the part of corporations themselves and the financial institutions that value them. In the words of Warren Buffett in his 2023 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders:</p><p><em>It’s crucial to understand that stocks often trade at truly foolish prices, both high and low. “Efficient” markets exist only in textbooks. In truth, marketable stocks and bonds are baffling, their behavior usually understandable only in retrospect.</em></p><p>There is no empirical evidence to support the argument that Shareholder Primacy generates superior business results in the longer term. Trying to ‘predict’ share price goals based on Business Strategy is an exercise in making ‘fortune tellers’ look good.</p><p>Third, MSV, whether measured by share price gains or TSR, is an exercise in extracting value from corporations to benefit only one group of stakeholders — current shareholders — at the expense of all other stakeholders. It’s contrary to the concept of Strategy as the pattern realized in the choices an organization makes in creating sustainable value for its Customers, for itself and for its stakeholders.</p><p>Finally, Maximizing Shareholder Value is an invitation for shenanigans as history has already shown. If you want a more entertaining perspective on this point, watch Damien Lewis as Bobby Axelrod in Billions. I know it’s meant to be fiction but how much is true?? How many parallels have there been in the corporate world? One of my favourite quotes from Bobby is:</p><blockquote><strong>What Have I Done Wrong? Really? Except Make Money And Succeed</strong></blockquote><p>The good news is that we’re seeing increasing momentum in the swing away from the doctrine of Shareholder Primacy and MSV to a broader stakeholder perspective, one that recognizes the importance of sustainable value creation for Customers, for the organization itself and for all stakeholders, with reasonable returns for shareholders as a guardrail. The bad news is that many firms have been slow in accepting this swing.</p><p><strong>Qantas in a Tailspin</strong></p><p>Qantas, the Australian flag carrier, the Flying Kangaroo, the Spirit of Australia, is one example. Qantas has the good fortune to operate in a cosy oligopoly. Qantas announced, on 24th August, an underlying profit before tax of $A2.5 bill for the year ending June 2023 — a record financial result — and Total Shareholder Return for the year of 39%.</p><p>Sounds great on the surface, especially since Qantas had been the most complained about company in Australia for each of the two years prior. The complaints covered almost all elements of the ‘customer experience’ — ticket prices, flight delays, lost baggage, long queues in terminals, problems in redeeming $570 million in flights credits from the Covid era, lack of availability of flights for frequent flyer redemptions, unanswered phone calls…….</p><p>But, on the 31st of August, the Australian Consumer and Competition Commission (ACCC) launched action in the Federal Court alleging that Qantas had engaged in false, misleading or deceptive conduct between May and July 2022 by continuing to sell seats on more than 8000 ‘ghost flights’ that had already been cancelled. According to the ACCC, many of these cancellations were made for reasons that were within Qantas’s control.</p><p>On 5th September, Alan Joyce, the controversial Qantas CEO since 2008 who was due to retire in November, announced his immediate resignation. That move sparked intensive inquiry and hundreds of articles in the business press. Roger Montgomery, writing in The Australian on 8th September summed up the situation clearly. It’s the <a href="https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/wealth/profits-over-reputation-and-an-old-fleet-the-joyce-legacy-qantas-board-may-rue/news-story/d5de4b8bbaed7fb4ad7796f6b2304080">Maximizing Shareholder Value question</a>.</p><p><em>While whispers revolve around Joyce’s sudden retirement and its implications on the board’s autonomy, a more pressing issue demands attention. Specifically, did the board, under the shadow of short-term profitability objectives, potentiallycompromise the airline’s long-term brand and value?……..Did the board possibly prioritise immediate profits, those that might coincide with the retirement of a CEO, over Qantas’ enduring reputation and value?</em></p><p>Trust in Qantas has plummeted to an all-time low. Robert Gottliebsen, a highly respected business journalist, has labelled the current situation in Qantas as one of the worst failures of corporate governance in Australia. The significance of this claim is underscored by Qantas’ 61% share of the domestic travel market. Qantas is not just another airline with poor Customer performance and overpaid executives. A healthy Qantas is crucial to the Australian economy. But Maximizing Shareholder Value is not a sign of a healthy Qantas.</p><p><strong>Qantas has been Maximizing Shareholder Value for a long time</strong></p><p>There are four inter-related signs of the dominance of MSV thinking in Qantas’s history over the last 15 years.</p><p>First, Qantas engaged in nine share buybacks over the period from 2008 to 2023. Roger Montgomery estimated the disbursement to participating shareholders as approximately $A2.2 billion ($A1 billion of which was in the 2022/23 year alone) with another $1.6 billion in dividends to shareholders. Montgomery noted that Qantas reported a net loss of $116 million over the period and speculated that the $3.8 billion to shareholders was funded by an increase of $A1 billion in debt since 2008 plus $A2.7 billion in taxpayer money provided to Qantas during the Covid years.</p><p>Second, Qantas began cancelling and deferring orders for new aircraft in 2011. In 2014 the average age of the Qantas fleet was 7.7 years. In 2023 it is 16.4 years. Qantas is facing an estimated cost of $A6 billion to rejuvenate its fleet over the next three years. Many people have questioned the wisdom of the share buybacks and argue that, in recent years, Qantas should have been raising share capital instead to assist in funding the new aircraft and to reduce the risk associated with relying on $A5 billion in Customers’ pre-payments for flights (including those that were cancelled and not yet refunded) for working capital.</p><p>Third, Qantas has treated its Customers very poorly. The firm has openly admitted this. Vanessa Hudson, who took over the CEO’s role on 6th September from Alan Joyce, issued a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7c8Qpnu8z28">public apology</a> on 22nd September. However, it’s stunning to hear a newly appointed CEO, one who was the CFO for four years prior and had been with Qantas since 1994, apologize for poor service and then ask Customers to judge her on her actions going forward. It’s almost as if she wasn’t part of the previous senior executive team that got Qantas into the tailspin in the first place.</p><p>Fourth, there is Alan Joyce’s compensation package. Joyce sold $17.1million in shares into the buyback in June 2023, with the board’s permission and before the 22/23 results were announced. Joyce’s total pay outcome for 22/23 was $21.4million (Annual Report). After a very strong institutional investor pushback and a lot of adverse press coverage, $14.4million of this is now subject to ‘claw back’ by the board but the final decision is still pending. Ironically, it’s been suggested by more than one financial journalist that Joyce’s pay over his 15 years tenure was more than Qantas’ total profit for the same period!!</p><p>Qantas insiders will undoubtedly talk about a long list of other matters that contributed to the current tailspin, most of which fit into the MSV playbook. They include drip feeding capacity increases to allow higher pricing; attempts to reduce operating costs through ongoing conflicts with unions and illegal terminations; failed joint ventures in Asia; the price war with Virgin; inappropriate influence over Federal Government decisions on international competitors’ access to Australia; the failed attempt to cancel, effective 31st December 2023, $570 million in consumer flight credits outstanding from the Covid era and others.</p><p>But when you manage a corporation to maximize value for current shareholders you make short term choices for the wrong reasons. The goal of Business Strategy is to create sustainable value for Customers, which enables the corporation itself and its stakeholders to share in that value. Shareholder value in itself may not be the ‘dumbest idea in the world’ but the doctrine of Maximizing Shareholder Value certainly is.</p><p><strong>Summary: </strong>Shareholder Value, measured by share price, is not a legitimate nor even a sensible goal of Business Strategy. It’s an outcome of Business Strategy, subjectively arrived at through a combination of art, science and smoke and mirrors. Shareholder Primacy, the notion that public corporations are owned by their shareholders and that Shareholder Value should take precedence over the interests of all other corporate stakeholders, is a flawed doctrine.<strong> </strong>Maximizing Shareholder Value is a managerial choice, not a legal obligation. And it’s a choice that can involve accountability problems and dubious, if not illegal, managerial behavior. The goal of Business Strategy is for a firm to create sustainable value for its Customers, and to share in that value for itself and all its stakeholders — employees, suppliers, communities, environments, and society in general.</p><p><em>I welcome feedback on this Post. Please share your thoughts or questions in the comments or click on the ‘clap’ symbol if you find it useful.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c15f9953972" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Organizational Value — Economic, Social, Environmental]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/organizational-value-economic-social-environmental-076c5d9a1793?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/076c5d9a1793</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organization-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-models]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environmental-values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy-choices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-value]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Nov 2023 21:41:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-17T21:41:42.977Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Organizational Value — Economic, Social, Environmental</h3><h4>Balancing Choices on a Barbed Wire Fence</h4><p><em>Businesses have rarely approached societal issues from a value perspective but have treated them as peripheral issues.</em></p><p>Michael Porter and Mark Kramer in <em>Creating Shared Value</em> 2011</p><p><em>Balancing and integrating choices on Customer Value and Organizational Value is like running along a barbed wire fence with one foot on either side……it’s not very comfortable.</em></p><p>With apologies to Joh Bjelke-Petersen, a former Australian politician</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vGIYE5XryOW26NbC0CQsLA.png" /><figcaption>Balancing Organizational Value Choices on a Barbed Wire Fence</figcaption></figure><p>Joh Bjelke-Petersen, a former and eccentric (and that’s putting it very mildly) State Premier in Australia once described his job as<em> like running along a barbed wire fence with a foot on either side……. it’s not very comfortable…… </em>It’s an apt way to describe the strategy choices that need to be made in balancing Organization and Customer Value Creation.</p><p>In <em>Strategy Conversations In Practice (SCIP) </em>I define Organization Value as the benefits that accrue to a firm itself and its stakeholders from creating Value for its Customers. Organization Value has three interdependent dimensions — Economic Value, Social Value and Environmental Value.</p><p>Most firms have considerable discretion when it comes to choices about the ‘Who, What and Why’ of Customer Value (see the Posts <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6"><em>Being Customer Centric Is Not Strategy</em></a><em> </em>and<em> </em><a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141"><em>Doing Everything Is Not Strategy</em></a><em>).</em> However, when it comes to choices about Organizational Value, this discretion is complicated, especially in large firms, by competing expectations of multiple stakeholders such as employees, suppliers, communities, environments, and shareholders. Firms must make choices that are integrated and balanced relative to these stakeholder expectations. The higher and more diverse the expectations (the metaphorical barbed wire fence), the more difficult the choices.</p><p>Michael Porter and Mark Kramer posed the concept of <a href="https://hbr.org/2011/01/the-big-idea-creating-shared-value"><em>shared value creation</em></a><em> </em>as a way to integrate competing expectations in a 2011 Harvard Business Review article. It involves making choices that simultaneously connect and improve firm economic performance and societal progress. It’s a principle that has gained considerable traction over the last 12 years.</p><p>Boards and management teams are looking more closely at social and environmental issues that have specific relevance to their firms’ economic performance. And there is increasing support for the argument that, to move these social and environmental issues from the periphery to the core, they must be woven into a firm’s Business Strategy and contribute to Customer Value Creation as well as improve overall firm performance.</p><blockquote><strong>ESG Activities………Woke Capitalism? Virtue Signalling?</strong></blockquote><p>This aim has been partially addressed by the investment community in recent years using ESG data (Environmental, Social and Governance). While the ESG movement has its critics — some call it naïve, a version of ‘woke capitalism’ — it also has its cheerleaders. Many investors now incorporate ESG data into their fundamental analyses. Activist investors use ESG data to encourage changes in strategy in the firms they’re invested in.</p><p>However, I argue that ESG scores have limited utility to Business Strategy practitioners. Why? First, ESG scores are subjective constructs derived by external parties using a range of inconsistent methodologies. While these scores may provide a small window into a firm’s Environmental and Social performance, it’s still a view from the sidelines. In many cases the focus is more on reporting, on ‘virtue signaling’ than on real value creation. In particular, the link between ESG scores and firm economic performance remains to be established.</p><p>Second, and more importantly, ESG scores don’t provide a logic for integrating the complexity in choices and for balancing the inevitable trade-offs that strategy practitioners routinely face in today’s organizations.</p><blockquote><strong>Strategic Planning ………..A Longer Laundry List</strong></blockquote><p>To go a step further, I argue that the main hurdle to integrating the management of social and environmental issues into Business Strategy is not so much the limitations of ESG scores but rather the fact that many firms are still stuck in the Strategic Planning paradigm. Strategic Planning, with its linear process, its internal focus, its predilection for setting fragmented objectives and loosely related threads of activity to achieve those objectives, doesn’t have a mechanism to integrate complex and interdependent choices about Customer, Economic, Social and Environmental Value.</p><p>Instead, Strategic Planning just adds Social and Environmental considerations to its ‘laundry list’, a few more things to do which means it is more likely to further entrench the ‘peripheral issues’ problem that Porter and Kramer identified back in 2011. Firms that rely on Strategic Planning to address social and environmental issues are more likely to default to ‘box ticking’ than to make integrated and balanced choices that simultaneously drive both Customer and all three dimensions of Organization Value Creation in a manner that is proportionate to the firm’s context.</p><p><strong>Doing Well and Doing Good — Business Model View</strong></p><p>The Business Model View at the centre of <em>SCIP </em>provides an ideal framework to balance and integrate choices about Customer Value Creation and all three dimensions of Organization Value Creation into a holistic Business Strategy. Why? Two reasons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cqWvZrDh1DZSTPT1y7Havw.jpeg" /></figure><p>First, the same ‘Who, What and Why’ questions that are applied to Customer Value can also be applied to the dimensions of Organization Value. More specifically, who are the relevant stakeholders? What dimensions of Economic, Social and Environmental Value really matter to these stakeholders. What are their expectations in terms of the levels of value for each dimension? What choices will the organization make as a result — which dimensions of Social and Environmental Value will it aim to excel in, which will it aim to meet competitive or table stakes expectations in, and which will it not even bother about?</p><p>Second, when it comes to balancing and integrating Economic, Social and Environmental Value Creation choices, the key to simultaneously moving them into the core of Business Strategy is to ensure that they’re consistent with and leverage the dominant Value Logic underpinning Customer Value Creation (see the Post <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/an-unbalanced-value-logic-is-the-key-to-better-business-strategy-ee9316526cde"><em>An Unbalanced Value Logic Is the Key to Better Business Strategy</em></a>).</p><p>This argument is best understood by looking at some examples for each Value Logic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wjoyMx8FAbi-eAOimELEuA.png" /><figcaption>Some ‘Excel’ examples of Social and Environmental Value Creation in each Value Logic</figcaption></figure><p>There are numerous opportunities for firms with Operations Leadership as their dominant Value Logic to weave Customer and firm Economic Value Creation together with Environmental and Social Value Creation. Consider Wal-Mart and Amazon. By leveraging volume to reduce packaging components and optimize distribution facilities and delivery routes, costs can be lowered. This creates Economic Value for the firm while at the same time lowering carbon emissions.</p><p><a href="https://investors.dominos.com.au/">Domino’s Pizza</a> in Australia is another example of the Operations Leadership Value Logic in action to create Environmental and Social Value. Domino’s Environmental Value Creation efforts are focused on stores and operations, the food served and the way that food is produced. Not surprisingly, Domino’s aims to reduce emissions by expanding the use of electric vehicles and optimising its store network. But Domino’s is also working with the dairy industry to reduce one of the largest sources of emissions in pizza production — cheese — without compromising on Customers’ taste preferences.</p><p><a href="https://streat.com.au/">STREAT</a>, an Australian social enterprise operating in the hospitality industry, has successfully integrated Economic and Social Value creation into its dominant Operations Leadership Value Logic. STREAT operates street front cafes, corporate cafes (inside corporate offices), a catering business and a specialty coffee beans business. These businesses provide an opportunity for employment of homeless and disadvantaged youths and fund vocational (hospitality industry) and life skills training plus specialty support services for these youths. STREAT’s Customer, Economic and Social Value Creation is best summed up by their own numbers:</p><p><em>Four million ‘conscious consumers’ have enjoyed the delicious fare from our 12 social enterprises and enabled us to provide over 3100 amazing young people with a safe space to belong and over 240,000 hours of support and training as their recipe for building a healthy life.</em></p><p><a href="https://www.csl.com/">CSL</a> is a global biotechnology leader with its headquarters in Australia and a listing on the Australian Securities Exchange. The dominant Value Logic in CSL is Product Leadership. The firm has chosen to excel in innovative, plasma derived protein therapeutics for immunology, haematology, cardiovascular, metabolic, respiratory and transplant diseases as well as in differentiated vaccine products (primarily influenza). CSL has a secondary, but still important, focus on Operations Leadership in its plasma collections operations.</p><p>CSL creates Customer Value by saving and improving lives of patients with diseases in these therapeutic areas and by preventing the spread of influenza in the general population. There is an obvious and very significant flow on to Social Value Creation in terms of improved longevity and quality of life for patients, improved public health, lower hospitalization costs, and lower cost burdens on government. CSL enhances this Social Value Creation by supporting specific patient communities and collaborating with medical and scientific organizations.</p><p>CSL creates Environmental Value through responsible and efficient use of natural resources such as water and energy. However, CSL is not targeting zero emissions by 2030 but rather a 40% reduction in emissions based on the 2019 to 2021 levels. The rationale, as outlined by the CFO in the Australian press, is to set goals that “balance its business objectives with what was genuinely achievable”.</p><p>Clearly, Environmental Value Creation in CSL is not integrated into its Business Strategy to the same extent as Customer Value and Social Value. Rather, it’s a dimension where CSL chooses to meet acceptable (table stakes) standards. This is not meant to be a criticism of CSL but rather a commonsense reflection of its strategy.</p><p>Another good example is <a href="https://www.monashivfgroup.com.au/">Monash IVF Group</a>, an Australian publicly listed company that provides human fertility and assisted reproductive services in Australia and some Southeast Asia markets. Monash IVF’s dominant Value Logic is Customization Leadership. The Value Proposition is to help patients achieve their dream of having a family by providing a range of services from pre-conception health assessments to genetic testing, counselling, fertility treatment options and women’s ultrasound diagnostics tailored to each patient.</p><p>Monash IVF creates Economic Value through its fee for services approach. The firm creates Social Value for the broader community by virtue of a flow on effect from conception to happy families, local population growth and subsequent economic growth. Monash IVF also creates Social Value directly via its research activities and its collaboration with the scientific community. In this way the firm contributes to the medical and scientific communities’ knowledge base in reproductive healthcare while at the same time building its own capabilities in delivering patient services.</p><blockquote><strong><em>What about Shareholder Value?</em></strong></blockquote><p>One obvious question that many people ask is where does Shareholder Value Creation fit into Business Strategy? This is a tricky subject, so I’ve devoted the next Post in this series to <em>Maximizing Shareholder Value — A Legitimate Goal of Business Strategy or the Dumbest Idea in the World?</em></p><p><strong>Summary: </strong>Businesses are under increasing pressure to better integrate Social and Environmental considerations into their mainstream Customer and Organization Value Creation activities, to <em>do well and do good</em> simultaneously. Neither Strategic Planning nor the ESG movement provide an adequate framework for integrating the complex choices involved or for balancing the trade-offs that these choices present to strategy practitioners. But the Business Model View at the core of <em>SCIP </em>provides an ideal framework to address both challenges.</p><p>It addresses the three dimensions of Organization Value — Economic, Social and Environmental — with the same ‘Who, What and Why’ questions that are applied to Customer Value. More specifically, who are the relevant stakeholders? What dimensions of Economic, Social and Environmental Value really matter to these stakeholders. What are their expectations in terms of the levels of value for each dimension? What choices will the organization make as a result — where will it aim to excel, to meet competitive or table stakes expectations, and to not even bother?</p><p>Plus, the Business Model View balances and integrates Economic, Social and Environmental Value Creation choices by ensuring that they’re consistent with and leverage the dominant Value Logic underpinning the firm’s Customer Value Creation.</p><p><strong><em>I welcome feedback on this Post. Please share your thoughts or questions in the comments or click on the ‘clap’ symbol if you find it useful.</em></strong></p><p><em>Footnote: My thinking on SCIP has been influenced by the work of Roger Martin, Donald Sull, and numerous other strategy writers. I am especially grateful to John Steen who I co-taught the Strategy in Action course with at the University of Qld Business School. My thanks also go to the many strategy practitioners I’ve worked with and those I’ve taught at UQ and the Australian Institute of Company Directors. They’ve driven my strategy learning loop.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=076c5d9a1793" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Doing Everything Is Not Strategy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/doing-everything-is-not-strategy-07bcef7f2141?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/07bcef7f2141</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[choices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[value-dimensions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs-to-be-done]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Nov 2023 21:18:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-05T21:18:43.558Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Who, What and Why of Customer Value Part II</strong></p><p><em>We want this! And that! We demand a share in that, and most of that, some of this, and f**king all of that! Less of that, and more of this, and f**king plenty of this! And another thing, we want it now! I want it yesterday, I want f**king more tomorrow, and the demands will all be changed then so f**king stay awake!</em></p><p>Sir Billy Connolly, Scottish Comedian</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*io_BeNXrP6amlEiSRK8WZg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Have you ever seen Billy Connolly’s video on <a href="https://vimeo.com/235412480">Demands</a>? It reminds me of some of the Customers I dealt with in my corporate life. And it especially reminds me many of the Strategic Plans I’ve seen. ‘Laundry lists’ of ‘this and that’ objectives and fragmented threads of activity, typically called strategies, intended to achieve them. The attention is on internal activities and measures, especially costs, but they’re only integrated on paper. There are loads of KPIs. They’re not integrated either, and they make as much sense as Billy’s demands. The Plan says a great deal about the business but very little about really matters. Instead, everything is important. And critically, the pathway to Customer Value Creation is buried somewhere deep in the mix. The problem:</p><blockquote><strong>Businesses are from Mars, Customers are from Venus</strong></blockquote><p>The <em>Strategy Conversations In Practice</em> (<em>SCIP</em>) framework follows a different approach. <em>SCIP </em>is grounded in the principle that firms must first create Customer Value before they can share in that value. <em>SCIP</em> recognizes that different Customers buy different dimensions of value and that it is impossible for firms to offer the best in all value dimensions. In <em>SCIP</em> firms choose their Customers carefully and choose to provide those Customers with the best offering in <strong>only some</strong> dimensions of value; they choose to meet competitive parity or threshold expectations (table stakes) in other dimensions of value, and they choose to ignore still other dimensions of value.</p><p>In existing firms, <em>SCIP </em>starts with understanding the firm’s current Customer Value offering in terms of ‘Who, What and Why’. I talked about ‘Who’ in my prior Post, <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6">Being Customer Centric Is Not Strategy</a>. In this Post, I’ll focus on the ‘What and Why’ of Customer Value. I’ll also talk about integrating ‘What and Why’ into a clear and compelling Value Proposition that guides Business Strategy.</p><p>I emphasize that, while I’m separating ‘Who, What and Why’ for the purposes of writing bite-size Posts, in practice, these choices must always be considered together.</p><p><strong>What and Why Customers Buy — Jobs to be Done</strong></p><blockquote><strong>The customer rarely buys what the company thinks it sells him.</strong></blockquote><p>This is one of those great Peter Drucker quotes that has stood the test of time. Clayton Christensen recognized this situation in developing his <a href="https://hbr.org/2016/09/know-your-customers-jobs-to-be-done">Jobs to be Done theory</a> . Christensen argued that firms might know a lot about Customer demographics and characteristics but that these provide little insight into why Customers buy. Christensen also argued that Customers ‘hire’ products or services to do ‘Jobs’ for them and that understanding those ‘Jobs’ provides insight not only into what and why they buy but also into how to make a firm’s innovation efforts more successful.</p><p>As a simple example of this ‘Jobs’ concept, consider Ted Levitt’s famous quote about a customer who wants to buy a drill bit.</p><blockquote><strong>People don’t want a quarter-inch drill, they want a quarter-inch hole.</strong></blockquote><p>The ’What’ (Job to be Done) is a hole in the wall and the ‘Why’ is most likely to hang a picture. But you could argue that this ‘What and Why’ has changed over the years. A more nuanced perspective today could be that their Job to be Done is hanging an object without marking the wall at all. The point is, a Customer’s Job to be Done is always context dependent. Just as the ‘Who’ of Customer Value is not static so too is the ‘What and Why’.</p><p>While this is a good example it’s important to recognize that Jobs to be Done are rarely just about function. They can have, in Christensen’s words, ‘powerful social and emotional dimensions’<em>.</em> Understanding ‘Jobs’ requires that they be unpacked into their different Value Dimensions.</p><p><strong>Unpacking Jobs to be Done — Value Dimensions</strong></p><p>One frequently used approach to understanding the ‘What and Why’ of value creation is to ask Customers, usually in focus groups and/or some form of quantitative survey, why they purchase a certain product or service. However, these are blunt approaches that provide limited insight into Customers’ problems and potential solutions. A quote that is often wrongly attributed to Henry Ford is:</p><blockquote><strong>If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.</strong></blockquote><p>Regardless of whether Ford said it or not, the point is valid. Customers might know what their problem is but their perceived solutions are often framed ‘within’ rather than ‘outside’ the box, limiting the potential for innovation.</p><p>A better approach to understanding ‘What and Why’ Customers buy is to get much closer to Customers by conducting one-on-one, semi-structured interviews asking each Customer questions such as “what are you trying to do and why, how do you currently do this, what frustrates you, and what might be better?” The aim is to establish a more granular understanding of a Customer’s Job to be Done by using generic Customer Value categories to explore the relevance and application of different dimensions of value to that Job.</p><p>In B2C markets I use five generic Customer Value categories as a preliminary framework to better understand a Customer’s Job to be Done:</p><ul><li><strong>Cost:</strong> Asking price and all the other elements of cost that Customers may incur e.g. convenience, warranty, availability, repairs, maintenance.</li><li><strong>Utility:</strong> Performance of specific tasks e.g. taste, ease of use, speed.</li><li><strong>Social:</strong> Being perceived in a favourable way by others e.g. status, brand image or contributing to broader societal value e.g. community support, environmental effects (or lack of).</li><li><strong>Personal:</strong> Achieving a specific individual goal e.g. title, financial security.</li><li><strong>Engagement:</strong> Customer experience in the context of purchasing and consuming e.g. service, co-creation of value.</li></ul><p>Generic Customer Value categories can also be identified for B2B markets:</p><ul><li><strong>Compliance: </strong>With regulatory or voluntary standards, with product or service specifications, with community expectations.</li><li><strong>Utility: </strong>Performance of specific tasks, productivity gains, cost reductions.</li><li><strong>Ease of Doing Business: </strong>Improved access to resources, better supply chain management, risk reduction.</li><li><strong>People: </strong>Knowledge and skills, career development, networks, health and lifestyle benefits.</li><li><strong>Purpose: </strong>Environmental, Social, and Governance<strong> </strong>expectations.</li></ul><p>In identifying Value Dimensions it is important not to use constructs. For example, value for money is a construct of dimensions such as price, payment terms, warranties, delivery fees etc. Insights come form unpacking Customer Value categories, not re-bundling them.</p><blockquote><strong>Nothing beats talking to actual Customers.</strong></blockquote><p>To unpack Customers’ Value Dimensions, it’s critical that strategists themselves talk to actual (or potential) Customers in the first instance. Commissioning market researchers may come in later, but strategists must first get close to Customers. I cannot emphasise this point enough. There has been a lot written about ‘talking to Customers’ but if you want a good starting point, read Tim Kastelle’s Post — <a href="https://timkastelle.org/blog/2016/01/the-how-and-why-of-customer-development/#more-9035"><em>The How and Why of Customer Development</em></a>.</p><p>Another way to get close to Customers is to observe them making purchasing decisions and using products or services in their ’natural habitat’. Again there has been a lot written about this subject but a good place to start is Christian Madsbjerg’s Harvard Business Review article <a href="https://hbr.org/2014/03/an-anthropologist-walks-into-a-bar"><em>An Anthropologist Walks into a Bar</em></a><em> </em>.</p><p><strong>Integrating What and Why into a Value Proposition</strong></p><p>A clear, concise and compelling Value Proposition is critical in Business Strategy. Why? Because it guides Business Model choices on what to do, and what not to do in creating value for Customers, for the organization itself and for its stakeholders. In articulating a firm’s Value Proposition, it is important to avoid the temptation, especially in B2C markets, to lapse into ‘advertising speak’ hyperbole. This does not help Business Model design.</p><p><em>Avoid the glittering generalities, the fluff and the hyperbole.</em></p><p>Why? First, everyone within the firm needs to understand what activities really matter for Customer Value creation — where to excel, where to meet threshold expectations, where to not even bother — and the links between the choices they routinely make each day and these activities. A fluffy Value Proposition risks subjective interpretations which can lead to sub-optimal resource allocation and conflicting activities rather than coherent and integrated Business Model choices.</p><p>For a good example look at the Post on <a href="https://medium.com/p/a4a180fdc998">Who Gives A Crap</a>. The Value Proposition in ‘advertising speak’ is ‘<em>Good for your bum. Great for the world’. </em>My take on it as a Strategist is: Toilet paper that is guaranteed to make you feel good or your money back — it’s environmentally friendly and at the same time, soft and comfy, with colorful and quirky packaging, an irreverent sense of humor, reliably supplied direct to the home and most importantly, it builds toilets and improves water safety for people in need’. Which version do you think will better guide Business Model design?</p><p>Second, a clear and concise Value Proposition determines the dominant Value Logic that should underpin a firm’s Business Model. A fluffy Value Proposition means a fluffy Value Logic, which leads to problems in saying no. That’s when Business Strategy defaults to a laundry list of loosely related activities where direction is vague, people try to excel at everything and end up excelling at nothing. It’s a recipe for mediocrity at best.</p><p><strong>From Customer Value to Business Model Choices to Better Results — Dominos Pizza Australia</strong></p><p><em>………from a pizza business to an online digital business that sells pizzas……..we are best in class for digital sales, marketing and execution……..</em></p><p>Don Meij, the long serving Dominos CEO made this comment in the 2013 Annual Report. It still holds true today. A little bit of background information will help in understanding it’s relevance to this discussion about Customer Value.</p><p>A major Customer segment for Dominos is families with school age children. My take on their Job to be Done is ‘a freshly cooked meal for the whole family that is a special treat, available quickly and easily at a low price’.</p><p>Dominos doesn’t claim to provide the best tasting takeaway/home delivery pizza in Australia. For Dominos, taste is a ‘table stakes’ value dimension. So too are dimensions such as range and sides (drinks &amp; desserts). Dominos Value Proposition, where it chooses to excel, is ‘a hotter, fresher pizza, at a low price’. The dominant Value Logic underpinning Dominos Business Model has always been Operations Leadership (see the Post <a href="https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/an-unbalanced-value-logic-is-the-key-to-better-business-strategy-ee9316526cde"><em>An Unbalanced Value Logic is the Key to Better Business Strategy</em></a><em>).</em></p><p>But things were different in 2010. The industry standard delivery time for a pizza was 45 minutes. Not surprisingly ‘hot and fresh’ was a promise that was often not met. That year, Dominos recognized the potential for digital technology to (1) improve on the ‘cost’ and ‘utility’ value offerings to Customers by enabling easier ordering and delivery tracking along with faster make and delivery times; and (2) lower operating costs.</p><p>Dominos invested in digital capabilities and the effect was so quick and so spectacular that Don Meij made his excited comment in 2013 about the transformation in the business.</p><p>Fast forward to the 2023 Annual Report where Don Meij talks about two key components to Dominos strategy — opening more stores closer to Customers, and digital technology — both of which are key enablers of the ‘hotter, fresher’ Value Proposition. These insights have proven to be game changers in the takeaway &amp; home delivery pizza market. They enabled a virtuous cycle of growth in sales volume, franchise outlets, revenue and profits for Dominos with results that were unheard of in the pizza industry beforehand.</p><p>Pizza Hut is still struggling to catch up more than ten years later. In a 2022 interview about the turnaround efforts currently underway in Pizza Hut Australia, the CEO said that his “main focus has been reshaping what was a restaurant-based operation into a delivery business by using digital technology.”</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong> <em>Strategy Conversations In Practice</em> recognize that Customers buy products or services to address a Job that they want done or a Problem that they want solved. Firms need to clearly understand this Job or Problem in terms of its discrete Value Dimensions, and choose which Dimensions it will address, where it will excel, where it will deliver competitive parity or threshold standards, and where it will not even bother. These choices should be integrated into a clear and compelling Customer Value Proposition, one that is expressed in concise and unambiguous terms that everyone within the organization can understand and use to guide the choices they make in their everyday activities — what to do, what not to do.</p><p><strong><em>Question:</em></strong><em> What is the Job to be Done for your firm’s Customers? What insights does this understanding enable? What gaps or problems are there in the current Strategy?</em></p><p><strong>What’s Next:</strong> The next Post in this series on Customer Value will be <em>How Customer Value Drives Business Strategy.</em></p><p><em>Footnote: My thinking on SCIP has been influenced by the work of Roger Martin, Donald Sull, John Steen who I co-taught the Strategy in Action course with at the University of Qld Business School for many years. My thanks also go to the many strategy practitioners I’ve worked with and those I’ve taught at UQ and the Australian Institute of Company Directors. They’ve driven my strategy learning loop!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=07bcef7f2141" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Being Customer Centric Is Not Strategy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kevinhendry1/being-customer-centric-is-not-strategy-be338269c1d6?source=rss-91b07426f4e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/be338269c1d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-models]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-value]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Hendry  Strategy Conversations in Practice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Oct 2023 03:13:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-24T03:13:15.030Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Who, What and Why of Customer Value— Part I</strong></p><p><em>Our highest priority is satisfying our customers………except when it is hard……..or unprofitable………or we’re busy.</em></p><p>Dilbert</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/538/1*fEUrT2dLfQ0r9GnIhJ8P2A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Every time I see or hear the words ‘strategy’ and ‘customer centric’ linked together my BS barometer goes off. Some (many?) businesses love to talk about being ‘Customer centric’ but don’t act that way. These firms are usually caught up in the Strategic Planning paradigm. They focus on what they can control, which is generally internal activities and measures. They know lots about their costs but nowhere near as much about their revenue. Revenue is driven by Customers and Strategic Planning is poor when it comes to understanding Customers. So, they rely on platitudes like being ‘customer centric’ to get across the message that they care about Customers. They even have Customer Care departments, but their actions suggest otherwise. Maybe they should change the name?</p><blockquote><strong>You’ve reached the Customer Don’t Care call centre…….</strong></blockquote><p>Airlines are a classic example. Not so long ago, I had a problem with Air Canada. To cut a long story short, Air Canada changed the flight reservations I had made months earlier. The airline advised the details via email and gave me an international phone number to ring if I was not happy with the new flights. After a week of trying at all hours of the day and night with no answer I gave up and rang the local (Australian) agent for Air Canada. They couldn’t help because I had booked on the internet.</p><p>But they gave me an email address for the Customer Care department, so I contacted them and explained the problem. They responded via email to the effect that Customer Care looked after problems after flights were taken, Reservations looked after problems before flights were taken. “But Reservations don’t answer the phone” I said, more than a little frustrated. Anyway, it took another four emails before Customer Care finally fixed the problem. When I told a friend in Canada about it, he laughed and said “Don’t you know Air Canada’s motto……”</p><blockquote><strong>We’re not happy until you’re not happy.</strong></blockquote><p>Qantas, the Australian flag carrier, the Flying Kangaroo, makes Air Canada look like ‘Customer centricity’ experts. Qantas has long traded on its image as the Spirit of Australia with great advertising campaigns such as <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2sMMbOg8pk"><em>I Still Call Australia Home</em></a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Vlv0NL6Cog"><em>Feels Like Home</em></a><em>. </em>They’re warm and fuzzy and make you think that Qantas will treat you like a king.</p><p>Qantas announced a record profit of $A2.5 bill for the year ending June 2023!! But in March 2023, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) announced that Qantas was the most complained about company in Australia in the prior year. Despite the excellent financial results, Customers were, and still are, not happy about ticket prices, flight delays, lost baggage, long queues in terminals, problems in redeeming flights credits from the Covid era, the lack of availability of flights for frequent flyer redemptions, unanswered phone calls…….</p><p>Qantas is also in trouble on other fronts ranging from unions, employees, a High Court decision about unfairly firing workers, executive compensation, corporate arrogance, anti-competitive matters, and political influence. But these are matters for another story about Organization Value.</p><p>This story is about Customer Value and the latest issue for Qantas is the announcement on 31st August that the <a href="https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/accc-takes-court-action-alleging-qantas-advertised-flights-it-had-already-cancelled">ACCC launched action in the Federal Court</a> alleging that:</p><p><em>……. for more than 8,000 flights scheduled to depart between May and July 2022, Qantas kept selling tickets on its website for an average of more than two weeks, and in some cases for up to 47 days, after the cancellation of the flights…….</em></p><p>While it’s only an allegation at this stage, this announcement, coming on the back of the earlier problems, triggered a fire storm of criticism. On 5th September, Alan Joyce, the Qantas CEO for 15 years, who was due to retire in November, announced his immediate retirement. Joyce’s designated replacement, Vanessa Hudson (an internal promotion), began on the 6th September and issued a <a href="https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-09-22/qantas-ceo-vanessa-hudson-apologises-video-message/102888746">video apology</a> to all Customers on 22nd September This is an excerpt from it:</p><p><em>………We understand we need to earn your trust back, not with what we say but what we do and how we behave. This is going to take time and I ask for your patience. The work is already underway: we’re putting more people in our call centres to help solve problems faster, we’re adding more frequent flyer seats, we’re reviewing all of our customer policies to make sure they’re fair and we’re giving our frontline teams more flexibility to better help you when things don’t go to plan.</em></p><p>While Hudson didn’t use the words this looks suspiciously like a small step towards being more Customer Centric. But is it strategy? Or is it an attempt to put out spot fires while a major bush fire is just over the hill?</p><h4><strong>Being Customer Centric Is Not Strategy</strong></h4><p>Why do I say this? Being Customer Centric is an important but generic principle underlying all three Value Logics in <em>Strategy Conversations in Practice (SCIP). </em>It’s application will vary across the three Value Logics but it’s a principle that, as Roger Martin has argued, to do otherwise <a href="https://rogermartin.medium.com/is-the-opposite-of-your-choice-stupid-on-its-face-5b247ffd7f94">‘would be stupid on its face’</a>.</p><p>Being Customer Centric is not strategy because it says nothing about what value a firm aims to create and who for, nothing about how the firm creates that value, and nothing about the interdependencies between Customer Value and Organization Value. These are all must have requirements for Business Strategy as defined in <em>Strategy Conversations In Practice (SCIP):</em></p><blockquote><strong>Business Strategy is the system or pattern realized in the choices- what to do, what not to do — an organization makes in creating value for its Customers, for itself and for its stakeholders.</strong></blockquote><p>The Business Model View at the core of <em>SCIP </em>describes these choices and the way they’re configured into a system or pattern. All four are interdependent choices, they must always be considered together in practice. And they’re not static choices, they must be continuously reconfigured in line with changes in a firm’s context and performance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/556/1*xrgbndI8YWpVPLL5HzkcTw.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Who, What and Why Of Customer Value</strong></h4><p>Identifying the ‘Who, What and Why’ of Customer Value is the first step in understanding a firm’s Business Strategy by reverse designing it’s Business Model. While ‘Who, What and Why’ are interdependent choices and must always be considered together in practice, for the purposes of writing bite-sized Posts, I will artificially separate them for now. The remainder of this Post will focus on ‘Who’ while Part II will focus on ‘What and Why’.</p><p>Understanding and making choices about ‘Who’ starts with clarity on the organization’s external context, its Arenas. These are the industry sectors, geographies, socio-economic segments, technologies, value chain stages and product/market segments that might represent an opportunity for an organization’s products or services. Potential Customers are those segments within the specified Arenas who may, under the right circumstances, buy the product or service. <strong>Primary Customers</strong> are those Customer segments that the organization <strong>chooses</strong> to focus its value creation activities on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*7D3BORDjQivOlc9vcJrT8Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Who Customers are not</strong></p><p>How does an organization clarify who its Primary Customers are? It requires some tough choices, so let’s start with some <strong>guidelines on ‘who Customers are not’</strong>. Customers are <strong>not internal</strong> to the organization in question. Rather, people and departments/functions within a firm are partners in a ‘whole of business system’, each with different roles, but each working together to create value for external Customers.</p><p>I sometimes get pushback on this point with examples of firms that have successfully broken up a large bureaucracy into small independent cells that contract with each other in a supplier — customer relationship. I argue that this approach might work in some rare situations but only if there is a very clear, shared understanding and acceptance of ‘Who’ the external Customers are and what the Value Proposition to those Customers is.</p><p>Customers are <strong>not shareholders or other stakeholders</strong>, nor are they enablers such as donors, funding bodies or regulators. These groups figure in Business Model design, and they’re linked to Customer Value creation, but in <em>SCIP</em>, they’re addressed in choices about Organization Value creation.</p><p>Most importantly, Customers are <strong>not ‘average’</strong>. Firms that rely only on demographic segmentation understand their Customers in ‘average’ terms and usually default to offering a list of all the benefits of a product/service to all potential Customers. It’s a shotgun approach with low odds of success.</p><p><strong>Who Customers are</strong></p><p>Customers provide, or have the potential to provide revenue, either directly to organizations through transactional engagement or indirectly through enabling activities. For example, the Customers of prescription Pharma companies are the doctors who prescribe their products and enable a revenue flow to the company from a third-party payer (government, insurance company, consumer).</p><p>Customers can be end-users or beneficiaries of a product or service, intermediaries in a value chain or partners in a platform Business Model. For example, Amazon operates a digital platform that links four different Customer groups to each other — consumers, sellers, enterprises and content creators.</p><p><strong>From Potential Customers to Primary Customers</strong></p><p>In refining potential Customers into Primary Customers — those that really matter — there are several considerations. First, as I mentioned earlier, it is critical to realize that the ‘Who’ of Customer Value creation cannot be understood independently of the ‘What’. Both choices are inextricably linked — there must be a match between the dimensions of value that are important to a chosen Customer segment (because these are indicative of likely behaviour) and the firm’s current or potential offerings.</p><p>Second, Primary Customers may be current Customers and/or new Customers but they’re never static for long. The ‘Who’ of Customer Value will always evolve as a firm’s environment changes.</p><p>Third, the Organization Value creation potential (Economic, Social and Environmental), both short and long term, associated with the choice of Primary Customers is critical. Organization Value and Customer Value are interdependent choices. You cannot make a choice about one without reference to the other. There will always be trade-offs relative to Organization Value creation in deciding which group of Customers to focus on.</p><p>Fourth, there are the risks associated with either supplying or not supplying a certain Customer segment.<strong> </strong>This is a complex and multi-factorial area. To name a few examples, there are market factors such as exposing the firm to the buying power of a large Customer, or the threat posed by competitive players. There are also internal factors such as the nature and level of the required investment in capabilities and resources to service certain Customers. In addition, there are risks associated with sourcing, currency, technology, government, regulation and so on associated with certain Customers.</p><blockquote><strong>Not everyone is your Customer. Beware the Zone of Mediocrity</strong></blockquote><p>Finally, it’s critical to realize that <strong>not everyone is your Customer. </strong>If everyone in a given market is your Customer then you will default to offering all things to all people. You will be stuck in the Zone of Mediocrity.</p><p>There is a famous story about Herb Kelleher, the former CEO and co-founder of Southwest Airlines, and a woman who wrote a complaint every time she flew Southwest. There were so many complaints and so many attempts to appease her that someone finally bumped the most recent complaint ‘upstairs’ to Herb. He supposedly responded with a very simple letter that said:</p><blockquote><strong>Dear Mrs………. We will miss you. Love, Herb</strong></blockquote><p>The moral of the story — your odds of success will be better if you choose your Primary Customers carefully, not everyone is your Customer.</p><p><strong>Summary: </strong>Being Customer Centric is not strategy. It’s common sense. The end goal of Business Strategy is to create Customer Value. Business Strategy begins with clear choices on the ‘Who, What and Why’ of Customer Value. These are interdependent choices that must always be considered together in practice. Choosing ‘Who’ your Primary Customers are depends on the match between their value expectations, your offering (or potential offering), the potential for Organization Value creation this match provides and your appetite for risk. And not everyone is your Customer……that’s a recipe for mediocrity.</p><p><strong>Question: How does your organization choose its Primary Customers?</strong></p><p><strong>What’s Next:</strong> The ‘What and Why of Customer Value’ is covered in Post II on <em>Customer Value: Choose Where To Excel, Meet Table Stakes, Not Even Bother.</em></p><p><em>Footnote: My thinking on SCIP has been influenced by the work of Roger Martin, Donald Sull, John Steen who I co-taught the Strategy in Action course with at the University of Qld Business School for many years. My thanks also go to the many strategy practitioners I’ve worked with and those I’ve taught at UQ and the Australian Institute of Company Directors. They’ve driven my strategy learning loop!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=be338269c1d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>