<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by kgro on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by kgro on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kgro?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 16:07:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kgro/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cyberpunk’s golden arcades of Hong Kong]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/cyberpunks-golden-arcades-of-hong-kong-150c7af4f306?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/150c7af4f306</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[antropologia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hong-kong]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 May 2025 01:48:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-18T01:48:38.359Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lcMVfgKKQ3YUUoIC" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@optimux?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Raymond Yeung</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Hong Kong, by many accounts, is the blueprint for cyberpunk aesthetics. After all GHOST IN THE SHELL was modelled on Hong Kong — not Tokyo. And since then, most cyberpunk cityscapes have been modelled on Ghost in the Shell.</p><p>The most obvious epicentre for the cyberpunk liminality is the Golden Computer Arcade in Sham Shui Po. It’s a high density area, with market stalls on every street, cars, delivery vans, weirdness tourists, value expats, locals, and punters. Major retail chains confined to small storefronts, offloading their soon-to-be-obsolete tech to the mainlanders and occasional clients from the depths of the New Territories, the innumerable “massage parlours” and brothels in the <em>indescript</em> walk-ups. The random food, always local focused, completely incomprehensible to the outsiders, since they are clearly not the target audience. And all this is just the outside.</p><p>Once inside we have the multi-level, maze-like claustrophobic corridors, that require multiple deep exploratory missions just to understand the layout. The class division between (semi-) branded electronics on the higher floors and the absolute unlicensed not — even — gray imports, straight from the factories in Shenzhen, with no licensing, certifications, and very dubious safety standards. The haggling in Mandarin. The geeks, otakus, cosplayers, and aspiring influencers, all sifting through technological detritus for gear.</p><p>The truly profound cyberpunk feeling deepens as you leave Sham Shui Po by car and go towards Shatin/Kwun Tung, on the Tai Po Road. The road takes the car up on the ramp, continuously rising, to seemingly head-spinning heights. Higher than a dinky two-lane ramp has the right to climb. Yet time into climb, still among the same central floors of the pen-like buildings. The ramp must be following the contours of the ever-rising hill. Maybe. But the continuous ride up, with barely any changes in the dilapidated buildings, caged basketball courts on the roof tops, and weirdly-unremarkable utility buildings with no windows make the atmosphere exceptionally eery and ominously oppressive. You know there are powers to be, and you know that there is no way you’ll ever find out. At least you pray that you won’t. That overpass never ends.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=150c7af4f306" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Japanese existentialism of Osamu Dazai — No Longer Human]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/japanese-existentialism-of-osamu-dazai-no-longer-human-edd9baa33cc7?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edd9baa33cc7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[japanese-literature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Mar 2025 13:45:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-03T13:45:54.397Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Japanese existentialism of Osamu Dazai — No Longer Human</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*bjqz1sHcOEBgCM8KV-7k2A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I clearly have a thing for <a href="https://medium.com/Japanese%20literature">Japanese literature</a>, hence I had to familiarise myself with the genesis of the existential ideas, that many Japanese acquire during their teenage years. Dazai is truly is considered by them (considering the age and limited experience) a Japanese Dostoyevski.</p><p>The novel is a simple one, a pure introspection in the epistolary form presented as multiple notebooks. Unlike anything Dostoyevski has done, these pages are pure stream of consciousness, that involves only the <em>self</em>, and very little of the influence from the outside, towards which the narrator is radically compliant. It is unclear when each notebook was written, and the logistics of them transforming from being passed down form the original author to the point of being published is vague to the point of being opaque. The complete lack of context, both narrative and logistical, as well as the linear form of the narrative and complete lack of any unexpected narrative turns, forces the readers’ attention fully on the content and away from the form.</p><p>The protagonist is deeply engaged in his own extreme alienation, to the point of partial disassociation from the community routines and the logic of society. The rejection, no, the complete lack of traction with the common rituals of the society, despite plentiful of opportunities, makes the character a sympathetic one, rather than a bored spoiled rich kid. Then again, perhaps this is my perception, and there would be some readers who would think otherwise, and this is precisely why I like this book.</p><p>While I understand that the novel is placed as a starting point for a multiplicity of discussions, from the role of women, to social definition of human or <em>less</em>, or to the changing society of pre-WWII Japan, in this reading I have focused on the experience of reading. I tend to involve multiple lenses in my readings, with Hegelian and Marxist being my favourite, but this novel with its decievingly simplistic structure has forced me, as the reader, to rely almost entirely on phenomenology.</p><p>Nothing much is happening in terms of his own development, as protagonist’s alienation, being his primary character trait, is not sufficient to build any sort of character development. As he matures, he engages in more mature acts of the very same defiance of expectations, which in the best Dostoyevski traditions, are manifested by increasingly self-destructive behaviour. Of course, closer to the end, as the protagonist inevitably becomes a philosopher (around the time when he would add excerpts from <em>Rubáiyát</em> to his pornographic comics), the nature of his actions shifts from Dostoyevski to Erofeev. Around the same time the great Russian existentialist (Dostoyevski that is) is also mentioned explicitly. As much as I enjoy structural mimesis in my literature, the exact opposite presents a novel read (ironically making a <em>mimetic structure of lacking the complexity to the highest degree</em>), and I am glad for the opportunity for having enjoyed this romantically-naive ideas distilled to the purest form 🤡</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edd9baa33cc7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Welcome to the Factory: Where Your Soul Goes to Die (A Review of Hiroko Oyamada’s Novel)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/welcome-to-the-factory-where-your-soul-goes-to-die-a-review-of-hiroko-oyamadas-novel-6c577bb635b3?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c577bb635b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[japanese-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Nov 2024 00:07:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-11T00:07:43.175Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*23NGcj5A5lz-yEb_hkAPMA.png" /></figure><p>The Factory is an uncanny and unsettling novel, which demonstrates the absolute desensitisation to radical conformity of the modern Japanese workforce. It is not only the characters, but the entire genre the book represents, that demonstrate the massive intellectual and creative vacuum in the texts as the literary device. The text is practically devoid of any emotions, both on the side of the characters and on the side of the reader. This is partially due to the complete detachment of the character in what is happening around them, and partially due to lack of contextual details in the novel’s universe.</p><h3>Structural semantics</h3><p>The novel comprises three-piece homodiegetic narrations from three quite different characters that have found themselves becoming a part of the Factory. The novel is split into chapter-like sections with no markings (and no index), with each section being a narrative perspective of one of the character without any indication which of the character we are reading. In fact the author makes an effort to mislead the reader about who is the narrator, only slowly giving the details of the narrator that contradicts the initial reader’s assumptions. This is a powerful way to show the homogeneity of the experience of seemingly different characters, who are ultimately distinguished only by their tasks, seemingly arbitrarily assigned by the Factory.</p><p>Chapters often contain unprompted glitch-like shifts in events and time. The temporal shifts within the same chapter, or even within the same paragraph can span from minutes to years, and invoke complete change of environment and participants, with only the chapter’s narrator being the constant. Occasionally the text begins to fundamentally break down, sometimes with textual bleeding transforming the narrative into near-gibberish, mirroring the general break down in the narrative process, which defines the novel.</p><p>“From my second day on the job, barring the occasional jam, I never had to use a single brain cell” — this admission of intellectual void contrasted with the fetishised form of the narrative is crux of the novel. <em>Structural mimesis</em> prioritises the form over the empty content, pushing the reader’s experience into the similar monotony and and dehumanised experience of the characters within the Factory. The unmarked fluid structure, temporal discontinuity, the glitches, and structural <em>cul-de-sacs</em>, with extremely low density content, creates the profound sense of disorientation and topographic loss, mirroring the vacant inner lives of the characters. This is arguably the most unique feature of the novel, which sets it apart from many other representatives of the genre.</p><h3>The Philosophical Lens</h3><p><em>Kant, Hegel, Foucault, Mbembe, Kafka</em><br>Within the larger context of the Factory as a system of power, this palimpsest effect demonstrates the crushing indifference of the system toward individual persons, ideas, and even its own ontology.</p><p>The breakdown mirrors how most employees lack any understanding of their purpose within the system. The Factory emerges as an almost infinite elephant, with intellectually blind employees’ futile attempts to understand it through touch alone. Unlike the original Sufi tale’s seekers of truth, these employees aren’t even interested in truly comprehending the whole; they merely grope in darkness to locate their own position within its monstrous topography. The Factory is the Geist — a conscious entity, fed by the employees subconscious compliance and complacency, engaged in its own monstrous logic which transcends the comprehension of both people on place, and the reader, confined by the limitations of narrators’ faculties — Kantian Transcendental Idealism is a fair game when we start talking Hegel.</p><p>The necropolitical dimension of the novel further emphasises the system, that functions to the interests of the unknown. The, presumably, metaphorical metamorphosis of one of the characters into one of the Factory-specific fauna members — the black bird: the undead creature, with no communication skills, no migratory instinct, and no purpose, is a horrifying reality of soulless large scale system, stripping these individuals of their humanity, agency, and ultimately, their lives as individuals, reducing them to the instrument of the system. The ominous mention, more than once, that the Factory has every possible facility, except the graveyard, further displays extend of the power the system holds over the individuals — they are all but the mute creatures.</p><h3>The Japanese Lens</h3><p>Since the novel is Japanese, it would be unfair to consider the most visible critique vector — the all-encompassing Japanese corporate culture of 会社 (kaisha). It is represented in the novel with all its important hallmarks. The lifetime employment — 終身雇用 (shūshin koyō), is clearly manifested by the undead black birds and the mystical metamorphosis of the employees into those birds — the corporate livestock — 社畜 (shachiku), which, ironically isn’t even that useful on its own. The metamorphosis is perhaps metaphorical, but it certainly turns the novel not only into a display of corporate horror, but also the existential one. The individuals are stuck in the rigid opaque structure, that transcends the interpersonal ties within the organisation, and consumes the very soul of the subject into the philosophical corporate realm — 企業精神 (kigyō seishin).</p><h3>The Limbus Lens</h3><p>The almost industrial gothic view of the Factory yields itself to the horror-centric analysis, where the Factory space, not the identity, could be viewed as a liminal space akin to <em>limbo</em>, as envisioned by Dante in his <em>La Comedia</em>. The organisational structure and topography fits the analogy — both the limbo and the Factory grounds are infinite dull spaces with no purpose, reserved for people with equally unremarkable virtues, to be cast there for the eternity. Unless. Unless, they are ferried across the river Acheron by Charon, which in the novel’s case the invitation of the <em>Captain</em> from the Print Service Department to see the Factory’s own river and cross the bridge, which he has “crossed it many times”.</p><p>Expanding on this notion, Goto, the single person of responsibility, truly the only person we see to dispatch the tasks and responsibilities upon his subjects, seems to have surprisingly little agency of his own. Staying with Dante’s theme it would be very fitting to have him mapped as the devil, who instead of being punished in the 9th circle of hell, has been cast to a mid-level managerial position. This is both ironic and poignant, as Goto’s position is ironically set as the contemporary form of damnation.</p><h3>The Complex Systems Epistemologies</h3><p>Despite all the absurdities described above, the Factory exists. It exists as the Geist, but it also exists as the employer. This is a liminal space, but also a work place. It is an oppressive organism, but also a manufacturing space. Saying that the space is absurd purely from the extremely narrow perspective of individuals who clearly do not possess neither the knowledge, nor the vision of the Factory, would be absurd. Judging the efficiencies based on the inefficiencies of the small cogs would be denying the entropy, a crucial element in the dynamics of Complex Systems, which invokes the fundamental laws of physics. The Factory here represents the bitter truth of our epistemic deficiency, and is truly applicable to all of our lives, the cosmos, the reality. I am pretty sure the author did not mean to to on this tangent, but I do, by the powers wested in me by the Knight of Post-structuralism himself — Roland Barthes. With it I declare the book a both an existential and noumenal reminder of our futility to understand the complex system just by looking at its individual components. Ultimately, the great elephant is there, we simply have no means to comprehend it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c577bb635b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Darkness, Reductive Eroticism, and the Pursuit of Terminal Liberty in Han Kang’s ‘The Vegetarian’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/darkness-reductive-eroticism-and-the-pursuit-of-terminal-liberty-in-han-kangs-the-vegetarian-262eb9478914?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/262eb9478914</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reading]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Oct 2024 05:53:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-23T05:53:35.669Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Nobel Prize for Literature has been a good indicator of something big, worthy. Elfrede Jelinek, Kazuo Ishiguro, Jean-Paul Sartre (though he didn’t show up) — were the subject of some of my deepest literary analyses. So, when I’ve been recommended this book by a friend, with whom we share the interest in morbid and fucked up literature, I have put my hopes up. The synopsis seemed right, the relatively small page count of 206 pages makes it a short commitment piece, and this would definetely make a good change from the poetically-cynical couple of books on perfumery that I’ve just gone though.</p><h3>The Narrative arc focus and seppuku</h3><p>In the times of feudal Japan the truly honourable way to redeem a major transgression for the samurai was the seppuku. The important, and often overlooked fact about seppuku is that it was not done just in a straight line — at the end of that horizontal line the samurai would turn his <em>wakizashi</em> (a type of short sword) upwards and continues cutting up, so in the end the shape would resemble the letter “L”. This is the focus of the narrative arc in this novel — we open with the interior monologue of an unreliable narrator, delivering his singular perspective, just to disappear from the novel right by the end of “his” chapter. The next chapter is taking a drastic narrative turn, but is told us by a more sensual character. Finally the last chapter is taken up by the unlikely hero — the sister.</p><p>The book makes use of a unique minimalist narrative strategies. The literary craft is absolutely minimal, with deceivingly simple mechanics and language, which at the same time creates a bare platform for the reader to freely observe multiple positions on the matter of social compliance, body autonomy, eroticism, duty, and dignity, mostly expressed though a discourse of deeply flawed individuals. The spirit of the writing is reminiscent of Yukio Mishima (the last high-profile official seppuku in Japan), perhaps of not only due to stylistic minimalism, but also the because of the focus on the body and the latent erotic.</p><h3>1. The Vegetarian — The Horizontal of Darkness</h3><blockquote>I caught the darkness<br>Drinking from your cup<br>I said: Is this contagious?<br>You said: Just drink it up</blockquote><p><em>The Darkness, Leonard Cohen</em></p><p>A chapter-long interior monologue of a dull, unimaginative, and spineless egotist about his family life, manifesting in his dissatisfaction with his wife. This relationship between husband and wife within the context of the traditional patriarchal expectations in the Korean society, lends itself very well for Hegelian reading, particularly as master-slave dialectic. Husband, as the head of household expects his position as the master to be acknowledged on the basis of patriarchical mythologies — a man and the breadwinner in the family. However, there’s clearly a lack of acknowledgment from his wife, because he perceives her as an inferiour, thus the validation carries little weight. The wife, for reasons of her own is unable or unwilling to privode the validation in any case, which challenges both his self-perception and his standing in the eyes of society. Of course he also fails to recognise any moral and emotional core in his wife, largely due to the absence of such depth in his own character (the author has done an excellent job writing a character with serious <a href="https://medium.com/@kgro/epistemic%20deficiency">epistemic deficiency</a>. This lack of core is crucial. It prevents him from seeing his wife as an equal, making it impossible for him to value her validation as their relationship progresses. The irony here is palpable — the very patriarchal structure that should affirm his dominance is ultimately undermining his sense of self-worth.</p><p>This epistemic deficiency is not an exclusive trait of the husband, but it seems to be the norm in the society in which the protagonist is situated. The dissonance between the societal expectations and protagonist’s vision leads to the insane level of cruelty by the society, and is shown to be based, again, on ignorance, lack of perspective, and lack of sensibilities. The malicious acts are done out of “duty”, “social position”, or “for the greater good” — the banality of vicious attacks are very reminiscent of Hannah Arendt — The Banality of Evil.</p><p>As the wife further distances herself not only from her husband but also from her prescribed roles as homemaker, wife, and, quite radically, member of the society, the husband’s position becomes increasingly precarious. Her rejection of these roles, symbolised by her decision to become vegetarian (perceived as anathema in their social circle), leaves him unable to consider her as part of the matrimonial equation at all. He finds himself abandoned and unacknowledged, leading him to see himself as the victim — a sentiment he explicitly voices at the end of the chapter: “Anyone can see that I’m the real victim here”.</p><p>It’s easy for the reader to dismiss this notion of victimhood, given how unsympathetically the husband is portrayed, paired with his lack of introspection and personal dishonesty. Yet, if we view this relationship through the Hegelian lens and consider the crushing weight of patriarchal expectations based on his epistemic reality, he is, ironically, a victim. Not one I’d sympathise with, mind you, but a victim nevertheless of a system that he is a functional part of.</p><h3>2. Mongolian Mark — Vertical of Reductive Eroticism</h3><p>This chapter is a deep dive into a phenomenon of reductive eroticism. Intensely erotic without being erotic. Narrated in third-person limited, this is a personal erotic journey from a perspective of brother-in-law — an artist, sensual and emotional. The erotic process prevents him from functioning. The obsessive focus with his subject of desire completely takes him over with the scenarios and details, trying to repurpose the sexual drive into the meaning. The narrator is essentially writing his own emotional porno, and in the process reducing the enactment to the absolutely essential parts, that do not include sex. The extreme reductionist version of personal erotic buildup reveals the complexity of individual’s ideas of sensuality, sensibility and eroticism.</p><p>Despite the narrator this time being sensual and with much wider emotional bandwidth than in the last chapter, his obsessions drive him into anti-social territory. He betrays the family arrangement, neglects his own child’s safety and breaks the status quo on the social agreement between his artistic peers. It would be too easy to write off the transgressions on the obsessions, if not for the overarching style of the book. Is our narrator so different from the essentially impotent husband? His conduct shows him as impotent, even if his motivations are driven by the higher ideals, at least in his mind. The actions of both men lead to the same result for the protagonist — attempted suicide and psychiatric ward.</p><h4>Impotence</h4><p>When I talk about the impotence of the characters, I mean of course this in the metaphoric sense. However, the metaphors spread on multiple layers — for the husband that would be emotional and social impotence, for the brother-in-law it’s the artistic impotence. The unifying factor for both of them is the symbolic sexual impotence. Neither of them can have sex with their respective wives <em>properly</em>. While the husband resorts to raping his wife and providing weak excuse such as “man’s needs”, the brother-in-law does not engage in the sexual relationship with the subject of his desire initially, because his true desire is externalised, and as fetish in its classic understanding — disconnected from the person. This perhaps explains the quite direct objectification of her body by turning it into a canvas, of which the sole purpose is to create a new meaning for the somewhat unusually belated mongolian mark. However, the failure of <em>ersatz</em> has placed him with the choice, and the choices he’s made, the attempt to act as an ersatz replacement, had detrimental consequences.</p><p>The final touch of sublime is the failure of the brother-in-law to commit suicide — the symbolic seppuku with all its difficulty and risk (jumping from the third floor veranda requires a very purposeful and deliberate fall on the head in order to achieve the certain death), as the realisation of his irredeemable transgressions has set in.</p><p><em>Note Bene: Initially I have written the brother-in-law character as an artist, since his art has been the driving force for the second chapter events. However, I have decided to rescind this title, retitling him back as brother-in-law, because his position within the novel is first and foremost a gendered family member. His art, while a major motivator, is in itself in no way sufficiently expressed to allow him the honour.</em></p><h3>3. Flaming Trees — The Kaishaku for Terminal Liberty</h3><p>Many overlook that seppuku comprises two acts: the agonising self-disembowelment and the swift, merciful decapitation by the <em>kaishakunin</em>. This <em>kaishaku</em> ensures a “good death,” preserving honour. The final chapter of “The Vegetarian” offers a similar, albeit metaphorical, <em>kaishaku</em> for the reader. It delivers a final, decisive blow, shattering our emotional equilibrium while simultaneously offering a tragic, almost cathartic understanding. It ties together the threads of female suffering woven throughout the novel: the domestic violence, the matrimonial rape, the coerced attempts at happiness. The two sisters, In-hye and Yeong-hye, navigate their shared predicament in starkly different ways. Yet, their deep emotional connection, forged in shared trauma, makes In-hye’s eventual mirroring of her sister’s radical escape feel tragically inevitable. For years, In-hye struggles to “save” Yeong-hye from her self-destructive path, only to realise in the final moments that her own conformity was merely another form of escape — a failed attempt to navigate the cruelties of the system that ultimately consumes them both. For the helpless and hoopeless, perhaps the final, unified act of transformation — a “good death” on their own terms — is all that remains.</p><p>In a way, the ending is implicitly discreet — the decisions have been made, priorities set, arrangements made. In-hye’s failure at suicide in the forest is but an insignificant setback. The trees refused her then, when her sister — imagining herself as one of them — was still alive. Once Yeong-hye is dead, which is truly a matter of days, if not hours now, nothing will stand in In-hye’s way.</p><h3>Supplemental thoughts, mostly around the first chapter</h3><h4>아메리칸 사이코</h4><p>In the first chapter the extreme juxtaposition of the monotonous unimaginative monologue of the husband and the violent and surreal dreams of the wife opening up the possibilities of narrative uncertainties. Is any of this happening, or is the narrative a part of someone’s headspace — a sort of a Korean re-imagination of the American Psycho (by the way, the constant descriptions of of clothing, irrelevant to the plot, seems like the nod to Bret Easton Ellis) in the Asian post-consumerist reality, the Seoul-style corporate oppression that has hollowed out any sense and sensuality out of the compliant citizens, leaving those left in the state of psychosis.</p><p>It is interesting that Korean texts (literature, film or TV) seem to be using, if not overusing, the extreme violence and dissonance as a standard measure for retaining audience attention. Both as a result of American cultural colonisation, as well as turbulent political and economic past and present of South Korea, the violence clearly plays a big part of the artistic expression and entertainment values that the Seolites consume casually. The small peek that we get to see into the art of the single creative character, has too exposed the prevalent imagery of the violence and its aftermath. But while I take the liberty to dismiss the quality of the art of the “artist” (yet another nod to American Psycho, where the meticolously described meals are barley edible, and detailed description of outfits hits at the wearers to be looking ridiculous), I hold the book to a different standard. With it the question stays — what is the purpose of the violence in the book. Is it the marketability, familiarity, or is this the genuine exploration of the darkness. Who is the intended audience of the book?</p><p>As for me personally, I feel that the author truly touches the personal darkness, with its unglorified, unabridged honesty. The ugly, the disturbing, the one we suppress and try to never ever ever look it in the eyes.</p><h4>Redemption</h4><p>Just like Dante’s <em>La Comedia</em> is most famous for its Purgatorio — the space of true darkness, the hell, it seem the first chapter creates the biggest impact on the first reading. I have read that the reason Purgatorio is so popular, is because of both, the violence, and relatability of the predicament of the inhabitants. Deep inside we know that we are the sinners, and our only chance of redemption is the Grace. No human power or will is able to take us though the life of no sin. Similarly here, placed in the perspective of arguably the most morally bankrupt character in the novel, we can’t help but feel, to our own horror, relatability in a perverse way. The artist in the second chapter has had an entire history of addressing social issues though his art, and absolutely no-one thought much of it. Including himself. His entire world felt relieved when he’s changed his style. This is not about the truth, this is not about empathy, this is about the redemption. It’s not about others, it’s about ourselves.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>On the surface, the novel seems deceptively simple — straightforward language, uncomplicated events. Yes, they’re a bit fucked up, but nothing overtly complex. Yet, see beyond the deceptive simplicity, the narrative turns inside out, revealing layers of meaning. This hidden complexities and the openness to multiple interpretations is a testament to the novel’s depth. It’s this complexity, lurking beneath the surface, that begins to illuminate why this book, and Han Kang as an author, merits the Nobel Prize in Literature.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=262eb9478914" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disappointment in Black and White]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/disappointment-in-black-and-white-e13e3be7d72a?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e13e3be7d72a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ripley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-talented-mr-ripley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patricia-highsmith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Sep 2024 09:46:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-17T09:46:25.536Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am a huge fan of Patricia Highsmith’s prose and her <em>Talented Mr. Ripley</em> series for me represents an intoxicating blend of adventure, hustle, and artistic sensibility, with a protagonist as charming as he is daring. Surprisingly the cinematic adaptation of 1999, starring Matt Damon and Jude Law, truly captured this essence. I was in fact so content with both the book and the series, that I had absolutely no plans to see the new Netflix adaptation. What drove me to see it, was the feeling of cultural understanding of the next generation, who would be exposed to this text as their first Ripley. Unfortunatley I couldn’t push beyond two episodes, as the new series simply fails to embody the spirit of Highsmith’s creation.</p><p>From the beginning, this Tom Ripley is a far cry from the lovable schwindler I know. Older, not charming, and completely devoid of grand ambitions, he’s reduced to a desperate man chasing for a quick cash. Gone is the romantic idealist who saw Italy as a canvas for reinvention. Instead, we’re presented with a schmuck stumbling through luck, making for an undignified viewing experience.</p><p>The series’ aesthetic is visually striking with cinematography reminiscent of Jim Jarmush films and Escher-esque Italian townscapes and seem to serve not only to emphasise Tom’s discomfort and alienation, but also bring the viewer into the same experience. The constant presence of liturgical imagery feels oppressive rather than culturally observant, foreshadowing doom rather than possibility. This is the stark departure from the romanticism of the original.</p><p>The series’ treatment of sexuality — one of the main tenets of most Highsmith’s works — is particularly disappointing. Homoerotism is an integral part to Ripley’s narrative, has been turned from the driver to a chore. Rather than bold exploration of desire present in the original, we are presented with Tom, who is uncomfortable in his own skin and in his interactions with Dickie. This neutering of Tom’s sexuality turns what once was a defining characteristic into a handicap, further distancing the adaptation from the original spirit of Highsmith’s creation that I personally have found so compelling.</p><p>It is pretty evident that our Tom has changed from the great romantic who would go to Italy above anything else, to a sad low level crook, for whom Italy is a manifestation nothing short of torture. He suffers every moment there and is not able to hide it. His complete lack of enthusiasm is painful to watch, because that fresh idealsim is exactly what I have enjoyed when reading Highsmith’s Ripley. The creators have taken a lot of liberties working with the novel, and wether the new Ripley was worth it remains to be seen in the next episodes.</p><p>The show’s approach to character development and symbolism is frustratingly direct. Dickie’s poor painting skills directly mirror his lack of self-awareness. Tom’s struggle with the town’s stairs becomes a heavy-handed metaphor for his feelings about Italy. Even Tom’s basic manipulations of Dickie are presented without subtlety, suggesting a lack of faith in the audience’s ability to interpret nuance. What am I to think of the creators, who feel the phrase “You and he couldn’t be more unalike” is supposed to be perceived by the audience as some sort of clever discovery?</p><p>I have had always ambivalent feelings towards the character of Freddie Miles. Philip Seymour Hoffman’s performance has somewhat made it more compelling, at least as a plot driver. The character played by Eliot Summers has absolutely elevated the character to the most, if not the only interesting one in the series. Sadly even this was not enough to salvage the series for me. Alone the stark contrast between Sumner’s extravagant, androgynous Artful Dodger and Andrew Scott’s dour, Goebbels-like Tom feels too direct and lacks the depth of character interaction found in Highsmith’s work.</p><p>Ultimately, this adaptation of “The Talented Mr. Ripley” seems tailored for an audience that prefers unambiguous characters and situations, sacrificing the richness and complexity of the source material. It trades the romantic allure of a charming con artist for a tale of alienation and despair, losing the very essence that made Highsmith’s Ripley so captivating. If I want to see a depressing story of an alienated individual, there are plenty of films that serve the purpose without bastardising a great piece of fiction for no good reason, losing the entire raison d’etre of the work in the process — the romantic escapism.</p><p>Perhaps there would be some development further, but two episodes in and with the decision to assume Dickie’s identity, I don’t expect it to go back to Highsmigh.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e13e3be7d72a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cosmicomics Conundrum: A Journey from Confusion to Clarity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/cosmicomics-conundrum-a-journey-from-confusion-to-clarity-7f37597c6b11?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f37597c6b11</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[italo-calvino]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scifi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Sep 2024 12:12:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-17T09:58:21.273Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/252/1*EzW9VDR9i3EUVMBqACeRRw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Distance of the Moon</h3><p>I love Calvino, but what an actual fuck was that? An unreliable narrator spews nonsense of the magnitude that I am ashamed of putting the synopsis in writing. This must be either a pisstake on the romantics with moon and unrequited love, or develops into some larger idea in the context of the greater text, as I would expect from the author. So far I am merely confused, and only very mildly amused.</p><p>The initial, almost visceral reaction to the first story is reminiscent of a common first reaction to avant-garde perfumes (another small hobby of mine at the moment) — the confusion, combined with a splash of negative emotions. It’s a struggle that reader seems to take personally, possibly feeling that their senses and intellect are being attacked, challenged. I suppose this is where people start to differ — some outright reject, while others try to change their perception. I know where I stand. Carrying on reading the book with the hopes of any of this to start making sense.</p><h3>At Daybreak</h3><p>Octavio Paz talks about poetry concerning itself mostly with the language. Calvino’s Cosmicomics are the opposite of that: it it is irreverent towards it, turns it into a tool of senseless blabbering of some bullshitting noumenal entity. Our protagonist not as much as showing off, but boomer-flexing, making everyone listening to his old stories that are mostly retelling of some mundane details of his life just because they happened (or didn’t, we don’t know — he is pretty unreliable) to be back in the old times around Genesis. And yet, mundane, uninteresting domestic shit, though which he tries to relive his youth, as to stall the idea that his life was mostly meaningless. Even his most interesting moments where he is a hero in his own eyes sound stupid.</p><p>Of course the irony lies in the fact that as a piece of literature, it is fun to imagine the phenomenological component of these times, and the author makes sure to deliver, fully aware of the meta-nature of the way this narrative is to be consumed by the reader. Calvino is the master of that. This, along with heavy self-referential jokes make the writing typical to the early postmodernist works of the 60s, if not genre-defining. I wonder if <em>Hichhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy</em> was influenced by this in any way. If it wasn’t, there must have been a certain zeitgeist amongst the selected few literary minds, that have managed to create a pastiche of SciFi, postmodernism and comedy very successfully indeed.</p><p>A complete mockery of science, literature, and old-folks-tales. Formation of a nickel as the first solidity event in nebula after an eternity in limbo of entropic state is pretty funny as is, adding the fact that it is all told as “when I was young” makes it a comedy. Having this written in over 60 stories on 400 pages makes it literature.</p><h3>A Sign in Space</h3><p>We are only at the third story now, but reader’s relation with Qfwfq are starting to change. First there is an implication that the protagonist is describing his experience as a matter, of which we are also a part. In that sense he may be describing our experience way before the beginning of our existence in our current form.</p><p>Another take that the story introduces is the idea that is fundamental to structuralism — binary opposites and the notion that anything is defined not by what it is, but by what it isn’t in the relationship to itself. To do away with any doubts that we are referencing de Saussure here directly — the topic of the conversation is <em>signs</em>. Sign is the most fundamental element of Saussurean linguistics, and our protagonist’s attempt at defining the first ever sign with the great difficulty is the testament to Saussure’s genius, and Calvino’s incredible sensibilities (also being a writer of high profile, clearly has deep understanding of the Structural Linguistics, helps). True to the subject, the author expands the topic on the idea of how signs are instrumental in our identity, the perception of the reality, as well the recursive nature of the signs. In short — Calvino gives us a humorous, concise <em>Course in General Linguistics</em>.</p><blockquote><em>… it was clear that, independent of signs, space didn’t exist and perhaps had never existed.</em></blockquote><p>p. 63</p><h3>All at One Point, Without Colours, etc…</h3><p>As the collection progresses, two things become clear:</p><ol><li>The books concern themselves with the questions of ontology, epistemology, identity and ethics from the day to day perspective.</li><li>Like many people, I too have been asking myself these questions. This was quite a long time ago, and it seems I am a bit too old for this.</li></ol><p>After only 5 chapters or so the themes have become predictable and the literary, philosophical and intellectual novelty, that has captured me initially have worn thin. The diminishing returns have made it difficult to continue reading the book. I will continue reading for a bit still, purely to make sure I am correct about my assumptions. With the correct methodology — for instance reading first, middle and last chapter in each sub-book, I can ensure the degree of objectivity.</p><p>With all above, the book does seem like a great fit for the intellectually curious young adults.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f37597c6b11" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Memetic Mazes and Missed Opportunities: A Critical Look at qntm’s There Is No Antimemetics Division]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/memetic-mazes-and-missed-opportunities-a-critical-look-at-qntms-there-is-no-antimemetics-division-8d33868addbc?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d33868addbc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scifi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Sep 2024 13:18:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-12T13:18:51.649Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/938/1*27n6_RfG7ziZfmkTOyDgjg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The book with a very clever plot and underlying ideas for the world that reaches beyond faculties of humans perception. A 5-dimensional metastasised anti-mimetic entity, the fatal parasite that feeds on ideas, with human ideas being merely a small gulp to this monstrous creation from beyond visible space, sounds like a very compelling antagonist.</p><p>The mechanics of the narrative is very clever indeed. Aside from the non-linear use of <em>chronotopes</em>, the user is also forced to negotiate with <em>memetopes</em>. In this instance I understand under memetope a current state of memories of a character in description. Since the primary object of the novel is the mimesis and the war based on those, the subjects continuously change their own memories and perceptions and those of others. This memetic instability, and instead of narrative unreality we reach a number radical shifts of the narrative, even when the reader is aware of alternative conditions. Just like the characters are scrambling to collect a coherence of their reality, so is the reader, and knowing the alternatives somehow isn’t making it easier. Each new memetope situates the reader <em>in media res</em> with all existing assumptions as they are, making it hard to instantly understand which sections of memory are available to the character and which are not. Additionally the external powers, such as Foundation organisation may or may not possess additional information about the induced topical memetope, to the point of running the character though the loop of assumptions on the same conditions.</p><p>The memories are not only erased or extended and amplified, but the perception is also gets twisted to the point that it seems some characters have managed to die in multiple different ways. Additionally to that, with the extreme advancement of the antagonistic anomaly in the memetic war against human civilisation, the reader, and the characters, are exposed to omniverse, in which each universe becomes a <em>heterotopia</em>. Each one, including the one based on purely memetic matter (Heaven), has its own physical properties and life-and-death consequences.</p><p>One very powerful moment in the book is closing to the end, a moment when the newly appeared unlikely hero, at the beginning of his journey, and seemingly in the implied <em>population 1</em> scenario, realises the gravity of <em>too late</em>. Too late by significant amount, with no hope for recourse, human civilisation already fully destroyed, the planet earth fully taken over and repurposed to the life of the new master. And his process, his beginning of the hero journey begins there, with no hope, no reason, but purlely because of <em>pietas</em>, <em>dharma</em>, or whatever other reasons beyond human comprehension could be applied here.</p><p>With all said above, the book is an excellent example of when extremely clever and engaging novel is still not guaranteed to be a Great piece of literature. The text is very busy with cross-meme motions to engage with fundamental ideas of human condition. Considering SciFi has been traditionally the platform of choice setting this discourse on the basis of <em>what if</em> scenario, this is where the book falls short. Additionally, despite the all looping in the memetic perception, the anti-memetic changes and drug-induced partial memories recoveries for the sake of a slow and painful progress forward with “100 steps forward, 99 steps back”, the fact that there is only one character, experiencing a range of emotions is exactly what is wrong with the writing.</p><p>One of the most annoying aspects of the premises, is the singular-view of the evil, which the ultimate antagonist represents. While I understand that we are perceiving the narrative from human perspective, a bit of an ambiguity would make it a great way to set up an effective villain. Instead we are stuck with a massive anthropomorphic entity covered in spiders</p><p>A lot of effort went into description of its terrifying stature, no doubt heavily inspired by H.P.Lovecraft and I think it isn’t unreasonable to feel disappointment when reading about a memetic alien form we end up still in a full anthropocentric perspective. This easily could have been avoided simply by not describing the antagonist, and absolutely nothing of the book would have been lost.</p><p>In conclusion, the book is clever, albeit too clever for its own good. It fails to address the most obvious themes of ontology and ethics as they are really laid out bare right before us. Essentially the book has missed grand ideas, while ironically writing about ideas.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d33868addbc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Temporal ontology of cartoon characters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/temporal-ontology-of-cartoon-characters-59da68b9b952?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59da68b9b952</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[doraemon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ontology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Aug 2024 05:14:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-22T05:14:46.435Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LnVh32w-FpPN5UN6" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@binkore?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Bin Jaleel Almanza</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Today I was asked by my wife of my opinion on the development of cartoon characters, say Doraemon and his universe, and whether they grow — they retain the same age, so are they growing up or down.</p><p>Recently I have been thinking about <a href="https://medium.com/@kgro/chronotope-centric-weltanschaung-fa935bdc379d">chronotopes</a> and determinism a lot, and so this question is very welcoming — at last someone wants to listen to my random musings. Also, this is just for fun, ok?</p><p>There are two takes on this topic in my point of view:</p><h3>Take one — literary (Bakhtin):</h3><p>These characters neither grow up nor down. Their timeline is non-linear, and their temporal space can be imagined like a slice. Imagine a bamboo shoot, that we are constantly slicing at the same length — it retains the same height, but the slice evolves, it is constantly different. It neither grows up, nor down. We can consider each episode a fresh slice to the same stalk.</p><p>Essentially the characters are situated in their own chronotope string, which is different from and incompatible with ours, which we perceive as linear and progressing. Also, while their chronotope appears indeterministic from within their universe, it is ironically deterministic from our perspective, since we know their universe to be scripted by us.</p><h3>Take two — relativist (Einstein / Kierkegaard):</h3><p>From the perspective of these characters they grow just fine. In their universe Nobita Nobi is always 5, it is us who would not fit their reality — getting born, growing and dying. Because of the permanence of their universe, it is unlikely they could notice us, due to the ephemeral nature of our ontological existence. On the other hand, their universe with its seemingly unchanging time slice appears to have diegetic evolution — cultural and contextual changes within their story world. The subtle change of the characters, their growth from one episode to the other, while still being in the same slice, is antithetic to our view of progressive temporal flow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59da68b9b952" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reading notes: Italo Calvino — If on a Winter’s Night a Traveller]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/reading-notes-italo-calvino-if-on-a-winters-night-a-traveller-75798c663bc3?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75798c663bc3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reading-notes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[avant-garde]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Aug 2024 05:50:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-14T05:50:28.626Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Reading notes: Italo Calvino — If on a Winter’s Night a Traveller</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vc5FEzyEBYRCG_ZIEqFCHQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are many amazing things in Calvino’s novel. The meta nature of the work, the detailed explanation of the literary tricks the author is using in delivering the narrative, the economics of the reading and writing, where the narrative is delivered by way of explained mechanisms, rather than making the reader to experience it by themselves — this does take an extra effort for sure. But one of the most amazing part of the novel — is that it gives me a bunch of other novels, just the beginning, the tedious intro that leads into the exciting set of events, just to abruptly end. It would be hard to admit in most other circumstances, but reading just the beginning is what I am doing to many books. The “Traveller” also has shown me that in fact it’s not the juicy part that I am looking for mostly, but indeed the move from tedious part to the exciting, the understanding, or at least the glimpse of the literary universe that I am exposed to, the initial work, just as I am about to collect the fruits of my labour, no, patience, this is the part I seem to enjoy more than anything else. I did this to Kudera’s “Lightness” and to the “White Hotel” amongst the most recent cases. I’ve tried but couldn’t do this to “Remainders of the Days Past” but then had to force myself to write a lengthly analysis, applying Hegelian lens (using ChatGPT to fix my awkward grammar, of course). There are countless books that have been essentially deflowered and left by me, by having revealed its universe to me, as the reader, just to be promptly abandoned. What’s worse, is that I am boasting about having had experienced those books. I don’t, of course, tell anyone that my familiarity with them is cursory, not more than couple of chapters, one third of the book at most. No-one will find out too, because I have sensed the main idea, I have touched that universe, I have seen the story naked, exposed. I just didn’t consummate the book-reader relationship as expected by the reading community and as hoped by the author.</p><p>Now the “Traveller” has released me from this stigma by essentially dipping me into a literary orgy of unknown titles, unknown stories, each giving just the beginning, just enough to get into it, only to switch to the new one right after. The anonymity, even the understanding that there is nothing beyond that — those stories, novels don’t exist beyond the point of where it ends, at the beginning. My stigma, shame is wiped away by the revelation that this is all thre is.</p><p>Was this the author’s intention to give the reader the freedom? Or did he try to make us feel stressed? Hungry? Incomplete by withdrawing the catharsis right from our noses? Well, as far as I am concerned I don’t actually care. The author is (theoretically) dead. Why should I care about author’s intentions? This is not an exercise in deontological ethics. I am absolutely thankful to the author for giving me this freedom, dipping me into all of these stories with no guilt of not willing to go into further research and finish those books, that I have started, seen their most intimate, and abandoned right there just to dip into the next story.</p><h3>Chapter 4</h3><p>It is an interesting move on Calvino’s part, that he suddenly starts to provoke some sort of emotions in the reader regarding the unfinished books. Does this mean I don’t fit his motives of arouse the reader just to withdraw the catharsis? Or am I missing something? Perhaps the fact that I am thinking about all this is exactly what he wanted? Or perhaps, as a great post-modernist, he didn’t actually want anything, and just did what he does best, which is writing amazing fiction… In fact I don’t care to know — this is not my job to know the intention of the author, as much as it is not author’s job to make me feel the way he wants to.</p><h3>Without the fear of wind or vertigo</h3><p>The narrative is starting to take a more traditional form of an avant-garde writing of the 70s — awkward dialogues, Lacanian / Freudian eroticism, political upheaval whis directly reflects in personal turmoils, far less meta form than before, at least no more invitation for reader’s participation, but a mere mention of skipped paragraphs. We also are seeing somewhat almost defined temporal and geographic location. I can’t say I have enjoyed this chapter — too much cliche, especially with the ending, and generally just trying too hard to be unpredictable. Weak allusions, though I did enjoy the notion of emptiness beyond the text, that somehow were to become the basis for the transformation of the characters, didn’t work for me.</p><p>Providing the reader with the grasp of the stories is counterproductive since the book is not about those ephemeral incomplete stories, but specifically about the meta-centric nature of the relationship of the author and the reader. In that way the approach betrays the purpose of the book. Like the sudden metanarative within a relatively coherent story shocks the reader and snaps them from the universe narrative has created, so did the actual avant-garde story has shocked the reader by driving them into an uncomplicated complete story. It’s like the author has abandoned the reader and fully focused on the story, leaving the reader treading alone in that universe the author is busy creating. Was this the purpose or am I reading too much into it now?</p><h3>Chapter 5</h3><p>Back to the overarching narrative, the discussions of the previous story is mostly revolving around juxtaposing the phenomenological and analytical approaches of reading a book, and with it implying a sharp critique of academic, economic, historic, and political realities and how they destroy the book. Particularly harshly was the publishing business criticised. It was demonstrated as a soulless, soul-sucking machine, devoid of any order, a chaos, that consumes authors and employees alike. The chapter also serves also some fun cross-intertextualities with the previous chapters. One of which is where the protagonist is being coerced in doing something by a lady (visit the publisher now, and acquire a jail-escaping aid in the story). Another one was the the offhand critique of the chapter I actually have criticised before (the author knew! He did it on purpose!). With all things said, I still feel that the novel is slipping from the shape that has excited me so much in the beginning — the meta-narrative has become a mere mean to the goal of telling the story, rather than an experiment, that challenges the relationship between the author and the reader.</p><h3>Looks down in the gathering shadow</h3><p>We’ve come full circle with a roman noir, mysterious, morally ambiguous. The protagonist is possibly engaged in the acts, that are dictated by the circumstances beyond his control, and not for his personal satisfaction. Femme fatale is also present, thought this time she is dominating, and is assisting the situational change, rather than being remotley involved in such. A single instance of direct conversation with the reader, discussing the virtues of fractal-like weaved stories, that permit the author to avoid providing thick context to the primary storyline. An interesting allusion to the past as a tapeworm, followed by scatalogically-themed descriptions of attempts to resolve the past. The dramatic ending. This is starting to get boring.</p><h3>Chapter 6</h3><p>This chapter deals with the book as a whole, the single indivisible unit. The value of the complete book is elevated far above the sum of its parts, and the context, the intertextual considerations are shown as preventive measures from seeing the whole. They are put up as some sort of bizarre masquerade, unworthy of the content. Ironically the mechanics of writing, the literary methodology is viewed in the same way, while the actual book is essentially the highest form of representation of those methodologies. The fact that “Traveller” is a raw mechanics of storytelling has been lightly dressed by mediocre, and let’s not forget, incomplete stories makes it fairly obvious how the mechanics has been cheated into the narrative, rather than the other way around.</p><p>Suddenly more temporal hints — the implicit collapse of the financial industry (implied by the deserted buildings of Wall Street), the reference to AI writing (not exactly in those terms, as the novel is dating back to the end of 70s, but still). We had very ambiguous temporal placement, and now it is ambiguous still, but somehow tomorrow(?). So, a slightly more defined time is even more ambiguous then? Amazing.</p><p>After pages and pages of pointless details, describing only, what I could imagine, one of the character’s chaotic nature of relationship with the publisher (institutional — bohemian dichotomy?) we’ve finally hit the catharsis — the exactly the structure the character proposes, akin to 1001 Nights, where the story never ends because a new one is rudimentary inserted to continue indefinetely. We are in this very same predicament, already knowing that whatever we are reading will not have the ending. The method of delivery is kind of fun — us, the reader, on the assignment to the femme fatale to the publisher, are learning about the circumstances from the editor by letters written by their contact — a quite distinct unreliable narrator, who retells his conversation with a mysterious Sultan. Absolutely none of this gives us any sort of confidence of being even remotely true, which in turn, is the whole basis for fiction to begin with. Are we dissatisfied that we are being served exactly what we’ve been looking for? The never-ending cycle of consumption (even cultural consumption that is), provided by people we know are lying?</p><p>Well, now we are presented with yet another dichotomy — the soulless over-analysis by the analytical reading with the complete disregard to the content, and the mindless consumption by the phenomenological one. Nether are actually looking great in the grand scheme of the book. What has began as a critique of academia, has shown the readers as consumers with very little self control. It’s only expected that the few references to the authors made in the book, don’t make them look great either — mostly frauds or sellouts, or simply casualties of some political games left relatively insignificant in the history. The chapter also throws a bunch of senseless dichotomies — Wing of Light vs Wing of Darkness, Machine of Counterfeits vs Father of Stories. The final blow is that only by the end of the chapter have I realised Marana is a woman. In general the chapter seems quite pivotal, both by the radical transformation of the protagonist (as he was forewarned) to the establishment of the general qualities of that elusive universe. The boundaries are vague, but that’s also their exact definition. The extreme binary approach and overemphasis on books as the single object of thought and value in the universe sets it as a very imagined world, clearly having nothing to do with reality we are in, despite lively details that have been taken perfectly from our world and not a single note of mysticism. Bravo maestro!</p><p>[2023–08–27]</p><h3>In the network of lines that enlace</h3><p>The chapter stars with the meta-narrative just like the first chapter, trying to explain to the reader how they should be feeling about things that would have been written, without actually writing what would be making us feeling like that. The explanations are in the best post-structuralist traditions, touching the ideas I’ve read some time ago in the book on quantum mechanics (Rovelli), that was explaining that the space (and time, of course) is not a thing, but merely a relation between objects and events, thus space in fact does not exist, but is a merely a construct. This, along with repeating reimagining of the space or events where the author may find himself to convey the emotions the reader should be feeling when reading the passages that were never written in the first place. And he is really good at it, the anxiety, the loneliness, the isolation, the senselessness of it all, and the deep existential dread — we feel it by reading the ersatz of the text, served to us by the very same author. By the guy, who has been writing in the previous chapters about the frauds, who have been confusing the books, titles and authors for their own personal gain or out of ignorance, or just pressed by circumstances. And this has been only couple of pages in to the chapter. What a ride!</p><p>On a personal note, this repeated reimagining of the scenarios evokes my childhood memories. I am sure I am not the only one who would imagine how things would happen, by attempting to create a universe around myself, and whenever I would get stuck in some logical limbo, or perhaps take things in the wrong direction, I would abruptly stop the development of the said universe and immediately start a new one. This could go on for a while with the universes being shut down at the very preliminary stages, with very little development to them if any at all. All it takes is the thought “Or better what if …”. I imagine now, what if these universes would truly have conciseness? Imagine a child, casually creating and destroying them. Just like us, being in space and time that may get simply interrupted at the will of, for the lack of better words of it right now, a god, who is just a child with a little too much time on it’s hands and not enough cognitive powers to pull though a simple story with itself being a hero in it. Someone with the full creative powers, but still failing to create a universe that serves it, and ceters it, as the child desires? This would be a pretty painful idea to the theists, since this challenges their entire assumption that ultimate power somehow comes together with ultimate wisdom. Unlike in my childhood experiences, the author in this chapter does lose control over his universe.</p><h3>7</h3><p>The entire chapter, while having the dramatic development of the relationship between the protagonist and his Other, is in fact an exploration of the relationship between the reader, narrator, author, between the readers and those in auxiliary positions to reading. The promised, and totally expected, big bang, including some major narrative twists I have found to serve more of a decorative role to the actual exploration. From my perspective as a reader I can confidently state that the narrative twists have created some sort of light annoyance to me, and rather than enamouring me into the mysteries of personas and events, I was merely looking forward to the structural parts. The book is akin Centre Pompidou in Paris — in a way the most interesting part about it is the structure that has been exposed and decorated. This prime example of bowelist architecture is mostly famous specifically for showing what multiple generations of architects have been putting all their efforts to hide. To many seeing the Centre from the outside is pretty much the complete experience. This is how I see this novel, thus any big twists I find distracting. Also, Ermes Marana is a man now!</p><h3>In a network of lines that intersect</h3><p>Bad prose. This book is starting to test my patience. It all has started on the high note of experimentation, close to symbolically rejective the narrative, yet here we are — a love triangle, and the grand mirror parable. I am split between wanting this to go somewhere, to justify me reading this, or to be entirely dropped, so I don’t remember this shameful part of the book.</p><h3>8</h3><p>The book crescendoing, from the seemingly banal dichotomy between the two writers, or the writer’s ambitions and reality, to be more precise, though the post-structuralist musings on the nature of the writing, and the agent of control over the writing process and meaning formation, we come full circle to meet the entire cast. Classic Calvino’s temporal mix-ups and shifts: Ludmila meets the author for the first time on her revisit, as it was made clear in the previous chapters. The writer is experiencing jealousy towards the Reader, while the Reader is struggling to overcome his jealousy towards the writer — all this in regards to Ludmila and her free-spirited nature. The meeting of the grand faker, the UFO cultists, none of this makes sense. I am ready to forgive Derrida-esque grammatology bullshit, because the author is going all-in exposing the inner working, torments and desires of the writer, while very consciously stating that none of the things he writes should be taken at face value. Analysis is futile — that would be merely counting words and believing you have accessed the meaning. Feeling is futile, because the author can’t even decide on his ideal scenario of the outcome. Rejecting the author is futile, because he doesn’t care about the reader’s rejection, and rejects everyone anyway, with a slim exception of his “ideal” reader. Accepting is futile, since the author can’t accept himself, and is looking for a refuge behind anonymity of the multiple personas that fake his writings. The author cares about writing, as the process. The reader cares about writer’s physical process of writing — and these things are close, but not the same.</p><p>[2023–08–28]</p><h3>On the carpet of leaves illuminated by the moon + 9</h3><p>This is the second instance of a really bad prose. This time it is coming from the Japanese source, implying that this is a machine-produced book. The entire piece reads as the pink literature with the sexual resolution being the sole goal and purpose of the piece. The follow up is equally mechanised piece, but now by tempo. The fakeness is put in the overdrive, into senseless text, that is devoid of purpose, sense or taste. The erotic resolution, mirroring from the previous chapter is the most logical conclusion. While I appreciate bad text as art, it most certainly does not provide the reading pleasure. Clearly the intention of the author, it is a very cruel device to make the reader contemplate on the nature of authenticity, and control amongst other things.</p><h3>Around the empty grave</h3><p>One of the rare pieces that actually has a direct reference to the actual content of the story. A dream-like spaghetti western. In fact the huge chunk of the story is the structure of the book — the unfinished story, distrust between the author and reader, inconsistent space and time, and of course the metanarrative right smack in the middle of the story with no prompt or of adieu. I can’t say that this was a great story, and it was rather predictable too. In that respect it is quite different from the first one. But is it different, and more predictable because we’ve come already such a long way together with the author? Have we been riding along the waterfall next to each other to the point of knowing what each one of us could be doing? Is this too meta now?</p><p>I guess at this point, as we are coming close to the end of the book, I am becoming more restless about the fear that the whole book is just a collection of ideas and experiments that Calvino is throwing at us. As the reader I should expect a sort of body of work of deep contemplation, that without the book would be either intellectually or artistically unattainable, or simply extremely difficult to achieve, hence the purpose to read the book. In that spirit I don’t think many readers would be in just for the ride, and would probably also hope to rub off some of that extra intellectual powers of the author.</p><h3>10</h3><p>Possibly the last chapter that works within established structure from early in the book is essentially contemplation on foucauldian power in regards of bureaucracy, information dissemination, access. Because universe in the book is so book-centric, the view on lateral power is a bit simplistic. However, the demonstration how behind the soulless machine of bureaucracy, be it censorship, state-sponsored ideology apparatus or anything else, there are real people, who in fact do have connection with and appreciation for books and reading, even if their motivation may be simply the exercise of their power and exclusive access to the content. But by now we have already established the many types of readers, so this is just one of them.</p><p>[2023–08–30]</p><h3>Issue with dichotomy</h3><p>One of the hallmarks of Calvino’s writing is the extensive use of dichotomies. Dichotomies are used both as the narrative drivers, and as the intellectual tools. While I am very much interested intellectual exercises, it is precisely for this reason I dislike dichotomies, as I see them as simplified views of the infinite range of possibilities that represent our reality/realities. I associate binary way of thinking with intellectual laziness or deceit (though the use of false dichotomies, for instance, as a polemic tool). In that respect I wish Calvino would have chosen a more sophisticated instrument to be able to work with the nuanced ideas that he presents to his readers.</p><p>On the other hand, had Calvino employed, say, approach of dialectic discourse, the tensions would become dynamic, evolving into synthesis, and this could make the book infinitely more complex, completely obfuscating the playfulness the author has created. And let’s be honest, not many readers have an advanced degree in Literature Studies or Philosophy to read a book, hence the compromise, that has prevented the creation of the book that nobody really would want to read.</p><h3>Issue with the book-focus</h3><p>I appreciate the writer being absolutely committed to his art, but a universe where everything revolves around a specific subject, books in this case, seems forced. Yes, I accept the alt universes, but this is really dumbing down the universe towards a fetishised object that, while culturally important, also has become completely reduced to few functions, that haven’t even been well defined, and the universe has been reduced to essentially cater to that object. I like books like the next guy, but this obsessive book focus turns that universe into a simulactum.</p><h3>In the search for ideal reader</h3><p>Author serves several archetypes of the readers, each representing almost a stereotype: The Reader: active, inquisitive, hungry and alive Ludmila: also a reader, but passive, critical, consumer. Her focus is almost exclusively the emotional charge of the book, which doesn’t make a very balanced reading Lotaria: the opposite of Ludmila. Active, analytical, academic. Dissects the text and analyses them, at the expense of the spirit of book. Both Ludmila and Lotaria are representative of academia, critics etc. Translator: probably the most negative character, faker, deceiver, castrated and lost. Author doesn’t mince the words to express his disdain towards this character Editor: betrayer of his own dreams, stuck between the commercial and artistic side. A sad casualty of capitalism Artist: anti-reader, sees books as objects, or even subjects, which does not bode well with the author Bureaucrat: also a reader, but possibly accessing the text because of exclusivity, rather than the content</p><p>[2023–09–03]</p><h3>Ending</h3><p>The final chapters may have been interesting in themselves and there certainly was a thought behind them, I feel the fact that these were the last chapters of a complex book means we, as readers, are allowed to haste a little bit and try to see the overall meaning, the big picture of the book, rather than delving into the details of the final chapters. The ending was absolutely predictable, and that’s a good thing. With it’s established structure and the rhythm I would feel betrayed if it didn’t end with unfinished ending. The chapter 12 was a banality, seemingly serving as a soothing element after a turbulent journey, which is also appreciated. Overall it was a real delight to read this book, to go though the emotional rollercoaster and to see the work of the great master of literature.</p><p>[2024–08–07]</p><h3>The role of this reader within the novel</h3><p>I find it hard not to situate myself under Calvino’s authorial gaze. While the reductionist logic of his simplified universe can’t be directly mapped to my reality, I can still evaluate this reading as a blend of his established archetypes:</p><p>The Reader: Purely by virtue of reading, we are all readers.</p><p>Ludmila: The purpose of this particular reading hasn’t been the search for emotional components, so I align with her to a lesser degree.</p><p>Lotaria: Ironically, dissection is the spirit of this book, which makes Lotaria its ideal reader. With my notes, reviews, and close readings, I can attest that the work’s spirit isn’t robbed. It’s true that such reading sessions might ignore authorial intentions — case in point: I read “Destroy, She Said” through a Marxist and Hegelian lens rather than psychologically. The work didn’t suffer; I still found the prose rich and inventive.</p><p>Translator: I understand Calvino is revolting against institutions here, but I can’t help thinking how reading itself is a process of translation. It’s inevitable in writerly reading. How does Calvino feel about this? As an avant-garde writer, he can’t ignore that many readers adhere to reader-response methodology. Is he silently shaming us for not being true to his hidden intentions?</p><p>Artist: Anyone with more unread books than they can read (there’s a succinct Japanese term for this: tsundoku) is an artist.</p><p>Bureaucrat: In a way, everyone fills this role. Whether we read the newest bestseller or recluse ourselves to experimental literature niches, collect first editions or pile megabytes on e-readers — the admin part of selection is at play. Does Calvino mean any of this? Probably not. Does this prevent me from ignoring his intentions? Of course not. But having selected this book, regardless of criteria, I can pat myself on the back for the right choice. It’s an absolute pleasure to read, write about, and now have as part of my mind.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75798c663bc3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reading notes: Edwin A Abbott — Flatland]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kgro/reading-notes-edwin-a-abbott-flatland-ea0dc40237e3?source=rss-1c84c13a3ede------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea0dc40237e3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[euclidean-geometry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reading-notes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[kgro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Aug 2024 05:45:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-14T05:46:34.673Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Reading notes: Edwin A Abbott — Flatland</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*_fswsDjSEgHaYWiZLsOOfQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Reading motivation</h3><p>Like an amuse-bouche, the first 5–10 pages of a book can reveal much, if not about the book itself, then about the author’s state of mind when they began writing. This isn’t to say the rest of the book will maintain the same quality — quite the opposite, actually. Often, the author’s mindset changes as they write, especially for longer works, and not always for the better. This is wonderful in itself for those who enjoy the journey. Sometimes it’s like riding Charon’s boat, with your attention as the fare. With all this, the first pages, our figurative amuse-bouche, offer insight into the author’s motivation, that final kick that pushed them to start writing. It’s a subtle touch, and like an amuse-bouche, it often goes unnoticed by less discerning readers.</p><p>Since childhood, I’ve wondered what life in 2-dimensional (or 1-dimensional, 30-dimensional, etc.) space would be like. It was a sort of introspective thought about how our 3-dimensional world might appear to those of higher dimensions (since it would be largely invisible to lower-dimensional worlds), if at all. It seemed obvious we wouldn’t treat a 2-dimensional world like we do ants in their glass colonies — firstly because that world might be more advanced than ours, but more importantly because its z-dimension equals zero. Hence, the seemingly lower dimension is simply inaccessible to us, much like, or even more than, a higher-dimensional world. I never expected to share these thoughts with others, let alone read a bona fide novel on the topic. Yet here I am, ready to soak in musings on the same subject written in the Victorian era, of all times.</p><p>2024-07-17</p><h3>Initial impressions (chapters 1–4):</h3><p>I was half-expecting this to turn into a sort of sequel to the Three-Body Problem trilogy, where low-entropy civilisations almost mindlessly destroy the universe based on past fears, transforming into mindless protocols of self-preservation with the meanings of preservation lost in rigid processes. In a way, it is, and the fact that it was written in and about Victorian England well over a century before Cixin Liu’s great work of modern sci-fi makes for a very nice ironic meta-commentary on what we consider “progress” based on a society’s temporal existence.</p><p>Overall, the didactic narrative creates a Brechtian distancing effect, allowing for a nuanced examination of the narrator’s evolving perspective on his society and himself within it.</p><p>In fact, the main narrator has almost immediately situated himself within the society, not without a certain pride, giving full justification to the existing social system. Ironically, from his own description, it becomes obvious that his character is a second-generation nobility — a mere square. This yields additional flexibility to the narrator’s position as a source of societal critique both up and down the social hierarchy.</p><p>The existing society is described from the beginning as authoritarian, with strong class stratification, and with women basically treated as almost subhuman. In fact, the treatment of women, justified as deeds “for their own safety,” is painfully reminiscent of many current societies where women’s bodies and agency are controlled by patriarchal structures. In that respect, the initial thought that pops into the reader’s mind is that the settings are quite modern, only to be hit with the realisation of how archaic these oppressive gender structures are, and how we find them “normal” and even relevant to our times.</p><p>This irony in the radical suppression of women in the 2D world lies in the fact that the attempts at suppressing women are futile and women do let the men know their own opinions regardless of the class, sometimes even with the use of extreme violence. Considering this almost a century away from Second Wave feminism, the notions of the women’s conditions and resistance in the book are quite progressive.</p><p>The social structure of the 2D world is oppressive not only towards women but also the lower classes — the Isosceles. The automatic advancements in status of all classes except the lowest ones both continuously devalue the simpler shapes and widen the division between the lower and middle-cum-upper classes even further, despite the rare possibilities of vertical social mobility for those lower classes to become equilateral triangles. Furthermore, any possible upward social mobility is followed by complete and total isolation of the “evolved” character from their lower origins for fear of possible hereditary regression. It is clear that very little has changed from the Victorian era, besides the terminology we use.</p><p>Quite like in the Spacelands (our domain) the upper classes are very much worried about the possible uprising of the proletariat, and are actively working to undermine the revolts, by co-opting the revolt leaders, as well as by instilling cultural hegemony, as per Gramsci and Marx. In that respect, I wouldn’t be surprised if the author has read, or has been a part of discussions on, the works of Marx and Engels, as the theme of class struggle is very evident in the first several chapters.</p><p>Finally, early in the story, we get a glimpse of the epistemological shift, possibly fuelled by the power structure, through the explanation of attempts to find the source of light and the act of suppressing knowledge-seeking activities, not only by legal means but also by labelling the knowledge-seekers as insane in the best Foucauldian tradition of the social construction of madness.</p><p>2024-07-20</p><h3>Chapter 7</h3><p>Chapter 7 is talking about Regularity and Equality of Angles. It is ironic that the term Equality is used as a measure and justification for rejection, opression and destruction non-conforming entities. This is of course done in the name of convenience and safety of the majority. This rhetoric has not changed much since the Victorian England and is still actively used by those, who are willing to deny the equal rights to minorities, LGBTIQ+ or anyone who does not conform to the arbitrary standards set by the society.</p><p>2024-07-21</p><h3>Chromatistes</h3><p>The narrator’s account of the colour reform — a measure that would ostensibly render the society more egalitarian — serves as a potent illustration of ideological manipulation by the ruling class. This episode vividly demonstrates the reinforcement of hegemonic cultural norms and values, effectively manufacturing consent among the Isosceles. These chapters present a rudimentary yet accurate depiction of cultural hegemony, remarkably predating Gramsci’s Prison Notebooks by some four decades. The narrative thus offers a prescient critique of power structures and social control mechanisms that would later be formally articulated in critical theory.</p><p>Of course the last part of the chapter that has described the ruthless suppression of the uprising by extreme and prolonged violence, the anti-colour terror, is especially noteworthy. Only 30 years later Russian Czar has attempted to violently suppress protests (Bloody Sunday), which led to further protests (including Potemkin Mutiny), which eventually led to the Red(!) Revolution. The status of aristocracy has changed forever after that.</p><p>The later chapter brings up the notion of the higher classes treading the matters of personal relationships, traditions and marriage with far lower care than the middle ones, not only ignoring the history of their chosen women’s lineage, but even specifically opting for the ones with deficiencies in the recent history, choosing them on the account of their immediate attractiveness. Our narrator seems to be oblivious to the fact upper class hypocrisy towards morality — it is merely the arbitrary set of rules specifically made for the middle classes in order to keep them in line. This is valid in 2D world, in Victorian England, and today anywhere.</p><p>2024-07-22</p><h3>Lineland king</h3><p>The interaction between the Square and the Line king is both clever and hilarious. The attempts at communication between beings of different dimensional levels produce some truly memorable expressions, such as:</p><blockquote><em>excess of approximation</em></blockquote><p>Aside from all the cleverness I am not sure why the protagonist didn’t explain to the Lineland king his universe in king’s own terms, as an infinite number of lines adjoined to each other creating plane.</p><p>Finally, I’ve found it funny how the protagonist is flexing that he can <strong>infer</strong> shapes, while we, the readers, can actually see shapes. Moreover, the fact that we are <strong>reading</strong> this text, i.e. seeing shapes makes it particularly ironic.</p><h3>Spaceland and conclusion</h3><p>The last third of the book a starts showing a clear decline in the quality of writing. Over-flowery monologues with no purpose, predictable outcomes, weak motivations, it feels like the author was rushing to finish the book, while still ditching the last attempt to make it not as short as it turned out to be (the book is just over 100 pages). The change of the dialogue format to speaker-labeled form serves no purpose and breaks stylistic continuity. Additionally the quality of the narrative has deteriorated. Gone are the strong social systemic commentaries, replaced with implausible focus on individuals as a narrative drivers. Gone is the vivid description of the society and how their 2-dimensional existence affects it. Most of the very interesting themes stayed unresolved. The piece has failed to fulfill its full potential, and has transformed an exciting (for the time) topic into arguably entertaining school material that explains some abstract basics in epistolary form — the conclusion certainly does not deliver on the full potential of the subject. 6/10</p><h3>Inaccuracies</h3><p>With all the mathematical precision and very novel at the time social commentary, I am bothered immensely by the fact that the 2D characters’s visual perception of each other and their world is described as seeing lines, black with gradient (with sufficient training) or coloured during the Chromatistes era. These are volumetric expressions, that are ontologically impossible in the universe with no z-dimension. The same issue is, of course stands in the 1D universe — the Lineland. Even if the inhabitants of those universes would <em>perceive</em> each other somehow (I think the author was quite careful as to hint that some terminology the 2D narrator is using is borrowed from 3D world, but it does not necessarily mean exactly the same thing in their universe), it would be quite impossible for the representatives of the higher dimension to see them. This means the Sphere would not be able to see the Triangle, and the Triangle would not be able to see the Line, and of course neither of them could see the Point — an entity of a single dimension, a mere positional indicator, rather than an entity, with no width, height or length.</p><p>The author, clearly fluent in Euclidian geometry, seems to have compromised quite a bit of mathematical sense for the sake of a fun story. Was the sacrifice of accuracy worth the convenience of the narrative?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea0dc40237e3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>