<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by zoha batool khan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by zoha batool khan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@khoonsurat?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:10:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@khoonsurat/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There’s No Way You Don’t Already Know Students Hate Groupwork But Just in Case, Here’s Why.]]></title>
            <link>https://khoonsurat.medium.com/theres-no-way-you-don-t-already-know-students-hate-groupwork-but-just-in-case-here-s-why-63516319cbb8?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63516319cbb8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classroom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[students]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[group-dynamics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zoha batool khan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Nov 2020 12:10:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-28T06:17:21.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>There’s No Way You Don’t Already Know That Students Hate Groupwork But Just in Case, Here’s Why.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*rS-Mc-gbQ9jbonQmYhtyfA.png" /></figure><p>We studied Daniz Kandiyoti’s conceptualization of ‘classic patriarchy’ back in Fall 2019 and I have kept coming back to it since. Her analysis was a succinct description of everything I had observed already so it made perfect sense on the very first read. For that text, Kandiyoti analyzed patriarchy in South Asia. Her understanding of the family was Marxist, so it saw the unit as a site of conflict between the powerful (the patriarch) who extracted labor from the powerless (the women). Of course, there were ways to ascend the hierarchy. You could start out an oppressed wife and work your way up the ladder by having sons who will bring in wives that you can exploit.</p><p>I keep coming back to this reading because it’s relieving to have someone with credentials tell me I’m not imagining things.</p><p>With the lockdown, education went online. Professors who were already too fond of group-work saw that it was their time to shine. Thanks to the Zoom breakout room feature (which allowed students to be split into separate private rooms within a meeting), group class discussion became a graded feature in most of the courses offered. Many courses started having daily group discussions which often made up half the class itself.</p><p>I have an important clarification to add here: I am not entirely blaming professors for having to resort to this. It is unrealistic to expect them to speak themselves hoarse to a largely unresponsive class two hours a day. For teachers with multiple classes, this becomes impossible to do on a daily basis. It is natural to expect that students will feel more comfortable interacting with other students. It is natural to resort to Zoom breakout rooms to have <em>any </em>activity.</p><p>However, because they implemented this measure, they should be ready and willing to hear any complaints from students when they enforce it. The professors should anticipate potential conflicts and have ready solutions. What happens if a student is a freeloader? What happens when someone tries to play leader? What happens when one student is working ten times harder because they need the grade and everyone else is coasting on their work?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/0*1LByoZoZk-o0v8zP" /></figure><h3>Calling Thing Good Doesn’t Make Thing Good (Surprise)</h3><p>In my three and a half years, I’ve only been part of one group that didn’t make me want to stab a bitch. The group was from SDSB (finding camaraderie in the business school, of all places), which meant it was outside my school (humanities). My problem starts here. It starts with professors insisting that group-work is inherently a benign thing, that it teaches us collaboration and compromise simply by virtue of being group-work. To that, I say: bullshit. Students don’t magically shed their socioeconomic identities when they enter a classroom. Their personalities are not erased; the habits formed from a lifetime of privilege are not undone for the greater good.</p><p>Unsurprisingly, a Zoom breakout room often replicates pre-existing social dynamics, apart from making miscommunication much worse because everything keeps getting cut off. Men who don’t take their education seriously know that there will be one desperate woman in the group they will compel to pick up their slack the way they have compelled every woman in their life. The woman — who is probably trying to ‘earn’ education by overachieving to show her parents that she’s smart enough to be allowed to study and to be given the same opportunities as her brothers — will suffer in silence, as she is taught to.</p><p>A financially constrained student who is either on aid/scholarship or is seeking one in the future will carry the rich kids on their back to the finish line, because they depend on the grade to get the seat the rich kids can just throw money at. The disabled and neurodivergent students will burn themselves out, trying to manage their symptoms, because the able-bodied and neurotypical kids (and professor) don’t understand or they don’t care, because no corporation or postgrad university cut them some slack for having lower grades on account of their conditions.</p><blockquote>What a stroke of luck to fall in all 3 mentioned categories of the overworked student. Maybe that will explain the rage that underscores this piece.</blockquote><p>There are hundreds of these dynamics at play. I am obviously not denying that there aren’t students in class who need help and would benefit from group activities. Many socio-economically powerless kids could find someone understanding and kind enough to assist them. But the professors already tokenize them enough to prove their point about group work being the best thing since sliced bread for me to not need to explain that point in detail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JKTCysy0X6g3SBkY.jpg" /></figure><p>This is for people who lose out in this setup and are not attended to, who are often accused of being selfish for complaining about a group that is exploiting them. There is a unique fury you become familiar with only when you’re in a university that prides itself on treating its students like adults when it’s time to punish them for drug usage or substance abuse because they’re ‘old enough to know better’, but is quick to turn on them when they have complaints, overruling their real problems by telling them<em> they</em> know better.</p><h3>The Blame Game</h3><p>One of the most patronizing responses from professors is to hear that ‘this is real life’. You mean the world will exploit my labor without due compensation and tell me to stop complaining about it? Gee, you don’t say. Many of us come from conflict-ridden homes where we have to work overtime to manage the fallout we weren’t even responsible for. We have lived real life plenty. To hear social sciences and humanities professors respond with this, that we should become numb to the inevitability of our suffering at the earliest opportunity, is hilarious. Instead of teaching their students solutions that they can take with them into the workplace if they are faced with unfair labor practices, these professors do the work for the capitalist and train the future workers to be compliant, to <em>expect </em>theft and dismissiveness.</p><p>Many of these professors — if not all — are also the type of people to split the class up and then detach themselves from the groups (re: the whole ‘you’re an adult’ thing). Others try to justify this by telling students they chose their group so they should deal with it ‘like adults’. Never mind that a sizable bunch of students just sign up for a random group. If you bring this up, you are then criticized for ‘failing’ to make friends in so long (very curious about what professors think happens when they teach 4-month classes where they barely learn half the students’ names themselves).</p><p>Either way, this means they have little to no knowledge of the inner workings of any group, so when the time comes to arbitrate a conflict that’s erupted, they have no clue what to do. They don’t even attempt to be fair. They just opt for the easiest fastest solution that will gloss over the very real resentment, uncaring of a student losing faith in them because they can console themselves by saying they tried their best.</p><p>At this point in the semester, I am dictating points to a group member to speak on the group’s behalf because I can’t go represent the group too often. I have stopped complaining to teachers because I know what I look like: the grade-obsessed uncooperative bitch who’s too intellectually arrogant to suffer anyone else’s stupidity. Fair enough. I’m all of those things. I see no reason why I should work my ass off in getting both an A <em>and</em> in teaching my wealthy peers for free, when I need to be earning to cover my own expenses and need to reserve my strength for another rich kid’s stupidity who’s at least reimbursing me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wMAjRMdNNBTEcTH9.jpg" /></figure><p>I understand that teachers can’t explain everything in one-on-one interactions with students because they have 4 months to drag everyone through the curriculum. I get it; we’re all trapped in a broken system that fails everyone sooner or later.</p><p>But of course, I have questions. If my teachers are really that invested in cooperation, why don’t they reward efforts to help with extra credit? Why not adopt an absolute grading scheme so students aren’t competing with each other and see one person’s comprehension as a threat to their own progress? Why not tack on extra 5% to someone’s grade for explaining concepts to a peer? I understand even the destructive need to grade group assignments.</p><blockquote>Professors think it will compel students to work. This is based on the false premise that students care enough about their grade to magically start caring about learning. After seeing this come from instructors with years of teaching under their belt, I can only ascribe that belief to a delusion. I have no idea how a teacher’s years of experience haven’t torn that delusion apart yet; I can only surmise that it’s wilful stupidity.</blockquote><p>Students who genuinely care about learning will be free to learn because they won’t be pressured to score. Students who slack off will slack off <em>either way</em>. They can slack off in ungraded assignments and not drag anyone down with them or they can slack off and force other kids to scramble to cover up for them. Even students who may usually slack off might perk up at a fun ungraded discussion. These dismissed ‘slackers’ often only seem careless because they are actually terrified of failure. They prefer to not try than to fail, a phenomenon widely documented in educational psychology.</p><p><em>Ungraded assignments allow both paranoid overachievers and immobilized slackers to meet someplace where neither is driven by their fear, so they can actually learn instead of being reactive or shutting down.</em></p><p>Despite popular belief, most students don’t enjoy reporting their peers, so the solution to just report the freeloaders is an empty gesture. It’s especially the powerless kids who are sympathetic to the people behind their exploitation. They cover up for other kids because they understand what it’s like to be overburdened. Many have lifetime habits of compensating for others which they will not unlearn in one class just to lodge a complaint. Take it from the resident bitch: nobody enjoys <em>being</em> the bitch. Even at their most frustrated, most students do not want to assume malintent from their peers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/810/0*V2Iwt9RnRLVp84qY.png" /></figure><h3>It’s All About the Psychosocial, Baby</h3><p>Just as students can’t shrug off their socioeconomic identities so they are easier to teach, they can’t dump their traumas at the door either. Of course, this sounds like a stretch — until it’s your trauma being triggered. Then it makes perfect sense.</p><p>Many students have their own baggage with conflict, often because of abusive families. Their history means they are very familiar with suffering silently and cleaning up the mess neglectful or destructive parents leave behind because they know there’s no authority figure who could actually help. Group work often replicates those dynamics, where you’re lumped in with people that you don’t have any connection with outside of this space. You have to keep putting up with their bullshit until you can be free of the course, trying to contain the damage they’re inflicting on your future. It feels like your hard work doesn’t matter, because you can’t outwork ruin of this capacity, especially when all of you are graded collectively. Your needs and your circumstances don’t matter. Even if you try reporting them, the authority figures say they’re helpless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*tjMCrm-psF2QD_6X.jpg" /></figure><p>This is infuriating enough on its own but when it triggers decades of family trauma, it becomes too much for any student to bear, especially for 2–3 months in one go. Many students simply shelve and forget because there’s no time in a semester to reflect on the injury you’ve sustained. It’s only a reminder of your powerlessness, of the instructors who say they care but dismiss your concerns when you work up the nerve to voice them. It’s better to hold onto the illusion that they care, than to find out you put your faith in someone who disparages you. Your list of untrustworthy instructors is already too long to make you feel safe in your institution.</p><p>People are not stupid when they keep trudging. They are tired. They are exhausted from trying. By third year, you just learn to keep your head down, assuring yourself that graduation is just on the horizon and you’ll be out of here soon enough.</p><h3>Just Do the Bare Minimum</h3><p>Instructors, please don’t start something you can’t preside over. Please don’t do this just because you don’t want to check 40-something final papers. Don’t make group work such a massive part of the grade; that only upsets the trapped students even more. They can at least hope to recover from a 10% component. The administration has failed you, so don’t take it out on the students. Don’t deflect responsibility by feeding them false promises about how it’s just one grade and it doesn’t matter and we’ll forget it in postgrad anyway.</p><blockquote>We may forget the grade but the feeling of betrayal and helplessness stays with us. It makes students afraid of collaboration. They become so accustomed to compromising and to lack of oversight that they start staying away from group projects in general.</blockquote><p>Just because you had to deal with it growing up doesn’t mean we should too. Stop passing this shit on. Practice the pedagogy you love bringing up in class so much. You learn how to teach from us, just as we learn how to learn from you. It’s our responses that are half of this exchange (and yes, I called it an exchange for a reason). If you’re irritated by the tone of this piece, that’s part of the problem. Your students get to be upset from years of not being heard and you don’t get to dismiss concerns just because you think they sound too aggressive.</p><p><strong>Education is not a dictatorship where you lay down the terms and we accept them because there’s no other option. It’s a process and we’re equal contributors.</strong></p><p>P.S. the abundance of memes I found on this alone should tell you just how many people hate groupwork. Listen to your students. Listen to the studies conducted on students complaining about groupwork. Stop acting like you don’t know exactly what you’re putting your students through.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63516319cbb8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I Wish Someone Had Told Me About LUMS — Junior (Third-Year) Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://khoonsurat.medium.com/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-about-lums-junior-third-year-edition-6292a1027c2a?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6292a1027c2a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[students]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zoha batool khan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2020 10:44:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-10T10:56:51.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Things I Wish Someone Had Told Me About LUMS — Junior (Third-Year) Edition</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*8XG3gm4mqs2jH-ggHe3ing.jpeg" /></figure><p>Freshie edition: <a href="https://medium.com/@khoonsurat/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-before-lums-started-37bc317d3d10">https://medium.com/@khoonsurat/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-before-lums-started-37bc317d3d10</a></p><p>Soph edition: <a href="https://medium.com/@khoonsurat/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-about-lums-sophomore-edition-372950125801">https://medium.com/@khoonsurat/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-about-lums-sophomore-edition-372950125801</a></p><p>As always, a disclaimer: I’m from HSS (humanities) and I’m a socio/anthro senior (rising). LUMS has changed a lot since I started, so all the advice may not apply. For instance, the recommendation to have taken a math course may already have been met for first-years joining the university from 2019 onward, who must take one course from the STEM bucket. Those first-years (and others incoming) must adhere to a bucket system for first year, which involves taking one course each from the STEM bucket, the Social and Behavioral Sciences bucket (think Psych, Anthro, Socio), and the Arts and Humanities bucket (think Philosophy, CLCS, etc). In your second year, you’ll have an assorted bucket of various 200-level courses from within your own school; you HAVE to choose one to study or you’ll be force-enrolled.</p><p>This is why it’s important for students to create their own tips and tricks for their peers each year. The more people doing this, the better, because each major has its own challenges.</p><p>A second disclaimer: the list is never truly complete. I’ll probably recall something later and come back to add it. You can also message me your queries or hit me up on Twitter.</p><p>***</p><p>It’s junior year! December of junior year also marked my first year in therapy so I’m gonna sound like a real hippie in this. I have learned a lot about myself and that has altered the conclusions I come to, thus affecting the advice I dispense. This is why I want to clarify that everyone has different goals and priorities, which is why it’s important to seek out advice from people who have what you want or have come from similar circumstances. Asking a professor who comes from generational wealth whether academia is a good idea for you, a girl who wants to run away from home, isn’t going to get you anywhere. You need to find someone who is closer to your age, who is coming of age in the drastically different economy of 2020 (as compared to 20 years ago, which is when your professor probably graduated), and can tell you the trends they see in the workplace (if income matters to you). Ask someone who’s leading a life of your choice for advice.</p><p>Getting a therapist in my second year of uni was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made. It was the reason I was able to have a 20 CH course load in my 5th semester and a 19 CH in my 6th semester, with a TA-ship in each and two tutoring gigs always running. Go to the LUMS counselor if you’re struggling. Hit up Hafsa Yaseen’s Waqfiyaat for pro-bono services. Care about yourself enough to get help. The sooner you reach out, the better. Most kids in LUMS are struggling with mental health, even if it doesn’t show; they’ll tell you which faculty is friendly enough to be approached with these concerns.</p><p>******</p><p>Larger goal 1: you need to look at junior year as the year to bulk up your imaginary LinkedIn profile. Heads-up: a lot of your peers will be talking about corporate internships and multi-national companies and networking this semester. Don’t let that freak you out, especially as an HSS kid who’s wondering if they should participate in a L’Oréal drive just for their CV.</p><p>Some people pursue corporate achievements because they plan on going into the corporate sector after graduation. If you want a more creative path for a career, your journey will be less predictable. For instance, if you’re looking into journalism, this may be the year to start writing and pitching pieces to LUMS publications and then to local newspapers. You can also repurpose your academic essays for zines or write about your experiences researching a certain topic, share any insight you couldn’t put into your essay but felt like valuable information. If you’re an artist, this may be the year to start building your social media presence, seeking commissions, refining an interactive platform to gain followers, etc. Once you’ve done that, you could enter art competitions, send your pieces for publication. It’s also perfectly okay to not want to let the world have access to your creative output. It doesn’t mean your work is worth any less. I’m only giving these ideas because unis are corrupt institutions that care about awards and shit.</p><p>If you’re nervous, consider putting it up under a pseudonym so no one can recognize you.</p><p>Even these creative pursuits can be coupled with professional experience. Writers can find journalism or copywriting/copyediting work. Artists can find graphic design/illustrating work. Tbh, I can already tell you that online skills are becoming much more important and impressive to have, so save up for a secondhand tablet (or crowdfund; there’s no shame in asking) and start learning Photoshop, Illustrator, Canva, etc., during the summer break.</p><p>You can do an internship for the experience in freshie/soph year and use that to make your resume more competitive for that postgrad/future-career relevant internship in a firm or an industry you can see yourself work in. Junior and senior year internships matter a lot more because firms are looking for young grads to hire straight out of uni or to keep in mind. When you come back after graduation to apply, they’ll be pulling up the work you did during your internship. So you can get a soph internship that you don’t particularly care about to learn the ropes. Your junior/senior year internship should preferably be more seriously handled; you want to do a good job to network with your colleagues (who will recommend you to other recruiters) and with your bosses (who might hire you after graduation).</p><p>I know that freelance work pays much better than even the best internships in Pakistan, which is unfair. A lot of kids don’t get internships because it’s a waste of time, and a lot of recruiters just don’t respect freelance work as much as internship experience, unless you’re a celebrity freelancer on Fiverr with 5 years of rave reviews (most of these people delegate the work to others, pocket most of the pay and benefit from the reviews when all the hard work is done by newbies). Freelancers who get most of their work through word-of-mouth recommendations often don’t have much to show for their hard work; the burden is entirely on recruiters to change the ways in which they evaluate ability.</p><p>It’s okay to feel nervous when you hear business kids talking about Nestle. You may not have the same path but when so many people are all repeating the same strategy for success and postgrad, you start feeling like you didn’t get the memo and are neglecting some invisible looming deadline. That’s a normal fear to have but I can tell you that it’s not the be-all end-all of success. Does it make the path easier? I can’t lie: it does. Most people are impressed by MNC work experience because that’s the capitalist world we live in. But that doesn’t mean there’s no chance for you.</p><p>Alternatively, HSS kids often end up feeling like there’s nothing they can do with their degree except academia. Apart from the fall of the tenured faculty due to COVID-19 and the global teacher layoffs, it’s easy to feel lost if you don’t want to become a professor.</p><p>That’s where shamelessly emailing professionals in the field of your choice comes in handy. Talk to your seniors about life after graduation to find out about their experiences. Those people will be able to tell you what skill-sets are in demand (so many wish they had taken some data analysis courses and learned to use the software because of how in-demand they are), whether the field will still be relevant by the time you graduate (a pandemic does funny things to the economy), how tough it was in the beginning (so you don’t feel like the only person in the world who struggles after graduation). Spread your email far and wide because many people are too busy to respond. The wider your reach, the better the chances of a response. For me, my therapist has provided me with great insight on what being an adult in your mid-twenties feels like.</p><p>Here’s the advice most of them gave me: master software because most jobs require some form of quantitative expertise. They said pol sci/socio degree programs were woefully inadequate because they didn’t teach kids Excel, R, Stata, etc. If you can’t take a course at LUMS (unsurprising, given the terrible planning), teach yourself by watching tutorials and downloading it for free. Even the best courses will only teach you the basics. You will need to teach yourself the rest. You can structure this by taking MATH 101 (Calculus) first because it’s a pre-req to some of the courses I’m about to mention next (like econometrics and SDA).</p><p>The other courses you can choose from are: Econ 230 (Statistical and Data Analysis — SDA), Econ 330, DISC 203, Math 230 (Cal 1) + Math 231 (Cal 2). You need to take at least one of these courses to qualify for Econometrics.</p><p>You can also take DISC 321, but take Probability and Statistics first because it’s a pre-req.</p><p>The majority of corporate jobs require some form of data analysis expertise but if you’re a qualitative kid, that’s fine. If you’re also attached to your GPA and bad at math, you can try teaching yourself. Some kids just do better when they have a structured course and a teacher. Some people prefer to learn on their own without the pressure of timed tests.</p><p>Employers have been employing people long enough to know that one handful of uni courses doesn’t ensure expertise. You will have to demonstrate your abilities in front of them anyway, so you don’t need to worry much on the job front.</p><p>This only becomes a hurdle when you’re looking for a postgrad program. Some degree programs may require you to have taken a math course per semester for a year. Some may only want one course. Some may want some introductory science courses that are the equivalent of theirs (like by covering the same topics).</p><p>This brings me to my second point: you need to start figuring out where you wanna go and what you wanna study in your junior year, so you have 1.5–2 years to take the courses your dream program wants.</p><p>Larger goal 2: you need to start looking into your postgrad plans, if you can afford to. There are several caveats: many kids need to jump straight into earning, because they’re their family’s main breadwinner. Some kids are fleeing parents trying to coerce them into early marriage, so they go for the first and/or the easiest program they can find. I will be honest: Pakistan’s economy is severely exploitative and pays for the stamp on your degree, which means students from public universities end up with 30k as their first salary, while private universities (such as IBA, Habib and LUMS) often end up in the 60k-70k bracket. Men will be paid more than women. English speakers with an accent will be paid more.</p><p>Some pigs will try to justify it because they think they spent a lot on their degree, without bothering to think about the theft and tax fraud their parents engaged in so they could pay the fee. The point is to highlight that even in an economy that loves to drain young people of their strength and ideas while paying them pennies, kids from LUMS get the most pennies. The least we can do is to point out this injustice in our workplaces and help other employees negotiate for a higher pay.</p><p>However, if you only have an undergrad degree, your pay will stagnate very quickly. Promotion is only possible up until a point. That’s why many people recommend that you work for a year or two and then leave for higher ed. Even some scholarships, like DAAD or Chevening, require a couple of years of work experience (2 for DAAD). It makes your application more competitive too, because work experience is a valuable contribution. It gives you insight as a student, making you a good candidate.</p><p>It also gives you a break from studying (if you’re looking for one). Lastly, it teaches you what skills are valued in the workplace — or, at least, a very specific segment of the Pakistani workplace that you’ve experienced. I’m adding this because people often think their experience is a blueprint for every workplace environment ever. However, some people want to go straight for higher ed, and that’s fine too. The popular way to do something is not necessarily the right way to do it. Your needs will be very different from your peers’.</p><p>So, do you want to pursue higher education? Is it going to be a Master’s or a PhD? This is the time to grill your seniors and your faculty advisor for advice. Go to professors who did work you’re interested in (many of them have probably done this part-time or know someone in the field). For me, personally, the questions went in this order. First, do I want a Master’s or a PhD? I want a Master’s because academia is crumbling right now and postgraduate students are running out of funding, striking to be paid more and training for an industry that’s killing tenure, so their chances of employment are pretty low. In fact, many TAs are being put under even more pressure, because their unis are expecting them to take over for the fired professors and teach their classes. Do I want to go someplace where my living stipend is tied to my TA job? Nope. Do I want to spend some of my best years researching, cooped up in a building? Do I want to go back to an environment that’s made me feel unseen and unheard and bind myself to it for 5–7 years? Resounding no.</p><p>Then, what program do I want to apply to? A Master’s is only a step-up from your undergrad, so I was under way less pressure to decide. I wasn’t stressed out about spending 5–7 years (my entire youth) in a field only to find out that I hated it. Then I had to find a university that would let me do a Master’s in my field because many universities allow a Master’s only if you’re planning to do a PhD right after with them.</p><p>This is a lengthy process, which is why you need to start early. You can go about it two ways.</p><p>Either you can do it uni-first. In this process, you choose a dream university you want to attend and a list of backups (with the right program ofc). You make a list by focusing on certain characteristics like: if it has a student union (a requirement for me after the shit LUMS pulled on its students), if the faculty are to your liking. You can check the climate if you can’t stand extreme heat or extreme cold, because you’re going to be living there for two years. I personally look into statistics of sexual assault, racial violence, class discrimination, etc. Many care about accommodation and the facilities.</p><p>That approach works better if you have the money for higher ed. If you need a scholarship to attend, you need the scholarship-first method. First, you choose the degree program you’re interested in. Then, you look for scholarships that cover that area of interest. Let’s say you want to pursue South Asian studies and realize that both Fulbright and Rhodes offer funding for this. You’ll apply to those scholarships. For this category, the money is more important than the uni you’re placed. I’m not saying this because you need to settle for a mediocre university or something to just get done with your degree. Many of these scholarships are partnered with phenomenal institutions. It’s just an idea of where your priorities lie, because for this group, securing funding is of utmost importance. If your dream university doesn’t offer funding, you simply can’t attend.</p><p>Some of us only look into scholarships because we can’t attend without funding, so we go where the aid takes us. By summer break, you should have a list of universities and/or scholarships you’ll be applying to.</p><p>Whenever I talk to my friends, I predict we’re about to have an intellectual shift from the US to Europe, the same one that pulled the center from the UK to the US (that’s why so much of your older faculty is educated in England). The USA’s visa, migration and deportation policies are making it for students to attend universities, let alone settle there (which is why so many people go graduate from there in the first place). Europe is an affordable option with a much longer history of scholarship and prestige. A significant portion of the Global South will soon be pursuing education in Europe (many already study in Germany).</p><p>Larger goal 3: those of you applying for the US need to start studying for your GREs (for postgrad and if the university/scholarship you’re applying to needs the scores) so you can sit for the exam in the summer break before senior year. Some of you will need to save up the money; some of you can crowdfund it. The GREs costs $190 for those outside the US for, which is PKR 32000 (last I checked), so you will need to save up during the year or find a sponsor to afford the exam. There’s also the cost of actually sending those test score reports to the universities you’re applying to — a whopping $27 per recipient. Let’s add the application fee per university to this, which vary but often average around $150. There are waivers but I don’t know how easily they’re available.</p><p>The preparation itself takes 1–2 months (that’s what I’ve heard), so don’t risk your grades by ditching your studies for something you can learn during June and July. However, that depends on your own abilities. If you’re weak at Eng/math, you may want to practice slowly all year.</p><p>Others will need TOEFL/IELTS (PKR 24k in Peshawar, Abbottabad, Quetta, PKR 27k in Khi and Hyd, PKR 28k in Isl, Lhr, Fsl, Sargodha, Multan, Bahawalpur, Sialkot and Gujrat, as per the British Council website) scores.</p><p>IELTS: <a href="https://www.britishcouncil.pk/exam/ielts/which-test/academic#:~:text=the%20provincial%20government).-,Rs.,levied%20by%20the%20provincial%20government).">https://www.britishcouncil.pk/exam/ielts/which-test/academic#:~:text=the%20provincial%20government).-,Rs.,levied%20by%20the%20provincial%20government).</a></p><p>TOEFL costs $195: <a href="https://www.usefpakistan.org/Testing/TOEFL.cfm?Tab=Testing#:~:text=You%20can%20register%20for%20TOEFL,States%20Educational%20Foundation%20in%20Pakistan%22.">https://www.usefpakistan.org/Testing/TOEFL.cfm?Tab=Testing#:~:text=You%20can%20register%20for%20TOEFL,States%20Educational%20Foundation%20in%20Pakistan%22.</a></p><p>As you can see, standardized testing is a racket and we’re all being duped. But every university doesn’t require these tests. They’re just harder to find but I promise, they’re out there.</p><p>Larger goal 4: pre-COVID, students must submit a proposal for their senior year project by April of junior year and start meeting with their chosen supervisors. The project itself is not mandatory but it’s useful as a writing sample and as a demonstration of your research skills when you apply for postgrad. Just remember: it’s 10k words and 6–8 CHS, so you can’t half-ass it. That’s why I suggest that you start thinking right now. For a good SPROJ, it’s important to find an instructor who has either done research in the field you’ll be exploring or is a good mentor to you and understands your priorities (preferably both). Find an instructor whose teaching style gels with your learning style. For instance, if you’re doing an SPROJ in education, you’ll need an instructor who can recommend literature, connect you to relevant people, possesses the know-how because they’ve been working in the field long enough, is willing to hear your feedback about their guidance so they can work with you better, etc.</p><p>You will also need all this time to choose the topic itself. Are you conducting research in your hometown or Lahore? Is it feasible, accessible (women aren’t allowed access to a lot of places), affordable? Is the research even possible? Does it require some skill you don’t possess (such as translation)? Why not team up with a partner? The idea of research is exciting, and we often get carried away and set unrealistic goals. Use junior year to take courses that encourage independent research. It might be hectic but it will answer a lot of questions. Am I built for sweating in the heat in marketplaces for 5 hours a day? Am I better suited to primary research or secondary? Have I developed my ability to converse enough to do an ethnography?</p><p>Who knows? You might start a project in those courses that might intrigue you enough to flesh it out as an sproj. Just remember, it’s a 30-page project. You want to make sure you pick up something with enough data (quantitative or qualitative).</p><p>In my year, we were emailed that anth/soc majors (at least) needed a 3.2 CGPA and to have taken Qualitative Research Methods (because Quant hadn’t been offered for a couple of years but Qual had been offered consecutively) to take an SPROJ. They clarified that exceptions would be made if deemed fit, but it’s better to be safe.</p><p>Here, I want to transition into smaller goals. Speaking of converting a course project into an sproj, you can always do a Directed Research Project (2 CH) or Independent Research (1 CH) with the instructor you’d like to have as your supervisor. Try doing this in your fall semester, because you may need to finalize an idea and submit the proposal during spring. This DRP is only pass/fail so it’s much safer and lets you check for compatibility. You can even do a version of the sproj idea you’re considering to test the waters.</p><p>However, be careful. Your sproj should be your passion project, because it will require hard work and lots of reading. Some professors might try to use you to do their grunt work. They may suggest a topic you’re not particularly excited by but one they want to explore for themselves, because they want to use your data for their own research without crediting you as a co-author. The best of us still want to please authority figures, so we don’t have the necessary conversations about how our teachers can sometimes exploit us for free labor and make senior year miserable. No matter how much we love a teacher, the power dynamics don’t go away. Make sure you choose someone that is worth your time, attention and insight. Choose someone who understands your expectations of yourself and guides you towards meeting them, instead of someone imposing their own standards of excellence on you.</p><p>In university, intellect is capital. Ideas and experiences are currency. Do not underestimate what you bring to the table, the importance of your unique perspective. The instructor also benefits from being your sproj supervisor (it gets added to their resume), so you’re not burdening them.</p><p>*******</p><p>Smaller goals:</p><p>2. Frankly, ECAs are the least important part of your CV anywhere. If you want to bulk up your ECAs, apply to be a PAL or an O-week coach (I’d recommend PAL because it pays 10k a semester for a year and some of us need the money). Keep your eyes peeled for the application from May onwards. Careful: you’ll have to show up at least ten days before LUMS actually opens. The dorms were not cleaned up or fumigated or fixed in 2019 (and it appears to be a pattern of neglect). You’ll be doing a lot of sweeping and wiping on your own.</p><p>This is also useful because your PAL work can count as work experience. The same goes for your society, so don’t be afraid. Apply for that executive level position without any fear. You’ll know you tried. It’s better to get into smaller societies because you’ll have more control and way less bullying. No corporation or postgrad uni will care about the scale of your society anyway. The idol worship will wear off after graduation, so just pick someplace that’s hospitable to you and hears you out, instead of the Music Society or LAS.</p><p>3. This is the time to land an RA-ship, if you’re looking for a career in research, thinktanks, etc. Obviously if LUMS has slashed its budget (because it’s too busy decorating 😊), it’ll be much harder to get a spot. Put your feelers out and ask professors to recommend you to those conducting research (be they local or international). LUMS has multiple grants and they are refreshed after a certain amount of time has elapsed. Approvals are sent out during late Sept and early Oct, late Oct, winter break, etc. This is the time to ask around.</p><p>Hunting for an RA-ship will teach you a valuable thing that it’s never too early to learn: if you want something, you need to ask for it. Tell all your professors that you’re looking for an RA-ship and if they’re conducting research, you’d like to be considered. Tell them if their peers or their international colleagues are conducting research, you’d like to be recommended. I went to Sir Naseer-ud-Din to ask who had received the grant so I could go talk to the relevant people (people I had studied with or were in my dept).</p><p>Merit is a myth. Very few teachers, if any, will come up to you and drop an opportunity in your lap out of nowhere. It’s not enough to stand out to your teachers; you need to tell them you’d like to be an RA. Try following up politely and asking for an answer because they’re likely to forget. This is by no means encouragement to go harangue them. Just don’t give up because there are multiple cycles for grants (Sept-Oct, Jan-Feb, etc.).</p><p>A 10–15 hour (per week) RA-ship pays 30k per month but it will take up your weekends. It will be harder to manage — or get — an RA-ship with a packed schedule that keeps you busy from 10 am to 6 pm because most libraries and archives close after 5 pm. If, like me, you’ve also taken on 20 credits during junior year (my condolences), you may have to wait until senior year to bag an RA-ship. Again, many people overhype a LUMS RA-ship. You will not be regretting not getting an RA-ship for very long, especially because many of them don’t teach you much beyond what being an errand-runner entails.</p><p>Being a TA will impact your chances for an RA-ship though. A LUMS student is allowed to put in a limited number of work hours per week, so choose wisely. Many full-time TAs are straight-up denied the chance to do a full-time RA-ship alongside.</p><p>If you don’t get an RA-ship, that’s okay. Get a research internship during the summer. There are many, but the ratio of unpaid to paid is skewed highly in the former’s favor, so that might be a deterrent. Another fun fact: many internships favor junior and senior year students because they’re hoping to find potential employees, which is why this is a good time to start applying.</p><p>4. It’s also the time to land a TA-ship. All TA-ships are not built equally. A 30–40 student TA-ship pays 42k per semester (full TA-ship, 20 hours a week). A 20–30 student TA-ship pays 31k per semester. A 10–20 student TA-ship pays 20k per semester. Writing and Communication pays 42k no matter the class size. My experiences taught me very quickly that only the 30–40 one comes close to reimbursing you for the exhaustion of TA-ing. This may be breezy for people who are not juggling a full course load and off-campus jobs though. The workload also depends on the instructor you’re working with. Some don’t quiz their students, so you won’t have to check the papers.</p><p>Some people will make you feel like you need to email professors or talk to them personally to TA a course. Sure, if a professor has been that impactful for you and if you’ve loved their course, go ahead. But TA-ships will open automatically in the third or fourth week of August for you to apply. You just need to be a junior and have a GPA of 3.0+ to apply.</p><p>Your TA cheque is split into two. The first half is halfway through the semester (Oct: fall, March: spring). The other half arrives at the end of the semester. This can be Jan for fall and June for spring. The end is much less structured. Do not base all your expenses around the TA cheque; you aren’t issued one every month.</p><p>Random tip: whoever is the best speaker (and has the strongest understanding of the concepts) in your presentation group, make sure they do either the introduction or the conclusion (the latter is preferred). They can mention everything everyone else might have missed out and strengthen all the links anyone might have neglected to establish.</p><p>5. Jbtw, the admin is untrustworthy, so if you’re filling out a fridge/heater registration form for the dorm, make sure you keep the receipt AND GET A SCANNED COPY. Take a picture and save it in your CamScanner app (or whatever your phone’s default scanner app is). If there’s a random check (and they email you in advance to warn you) and they find an unregistered appliance in your room that you did register but they have no record, you’ll have to show your receipt to be taken seriously.</p><p>6. This is the time to start asking questions about life after graduation, because of how quickly it’s approaching. Ask your fresh graduates about living expenses, commute, food, etc. Ask them what they wish they had known. Take careful notes of the job postings on the Facebook group and remember what skills they usually look for. You’ll see that graphic design and social media management are taking off, usually as a combo deal. This is the time to start learning the necessary software like Adobe Illustrator, Photoshop, etc. Excel is usually a must.</p><p>7. A lot of people right now are doing courses on Coursera for their future jobs but frankly, I think employers have browsed the catalog too and know exactly the kind of actual learning being imparted through those courses. Sure, a certificate is always nice but that qualification alone is not enough. It takes one slip-up for the level of skill to show. Regardless of whether you’re taking those courses, see if you can set aside time even once every two weeks to brush up on the software and keep learning (after downloading it for free, of course, because those prices are exploitative).</p><p>I just want to remind people that if they’re not doing Coursera round the clock, that’s fine. You don’t need to be amassing achievements 24/7 to be secure in your work or your ambitions That’s just a problem I and other people have. You could ask your seniors for interview advice instead, because that matters more.</p><p>8. I know I’ve said your first year is the most important in terms of GPA and that’s true. The GPA in your first semester weighs the most, so play it safe. You’ll already be learning a whole new way of life, so stick to what you know and ease it into foreign territory araam se. But for postgrad, the letter GRADES from your last two years matter the most. Postgrad unis give more importance to those grades when reviewing candidates.</p><p>Lastly, there will always be things no amount of advice could have prepared you for (like studying during a global pandemic). That’s fine. The point of this isn’t to test how prepared you are but how well you can adapt, how well you can take a hit and keep going. There’s not a lot to learn in junior year. You’ve already figured most of uni out. Now you’re preparing more for postgrad education/a job than for your uni. Just remember to finish your out-groups asap because you will be turned down the older you get. Always take your 200 level courses first. If there’s a course that intrigues you, take it now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6292a1027c2a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I wish someone had told me about LUMS — Sophomore Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://khoonsurat.medium.com/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-about-lums-sophomore-edition-372950125801?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/372950125801</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[junior]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[university]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zoha batool khan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jul 2019 14:22:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-07T18:15:15.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Things I wish someone had told me about LUMS — Sophomore Edition</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4ziwqq7vDUi76zAwFnN_cg.jpeg" /><figcaption>LUMS in the rain, from the F5 entrance (srsly get an umbrella). Image courtesy of instagram.com/khoonsurat</figcaption></figure><ol><li>You’re going to start looking for work/internships now (‘now’ should start from May, btw). If you want to stand a chance, always make sure you spend at least half an hour researching the company and the department you’ve applied to, because they *will* ask you if you know anything about their background. Research also prepares you for the ‘suppose you don’t get the position you want. What back-up positions/departments do you have in mind?’ It makes them think you’re smart, prepared, all those other SDSB buzzwords business kids throw around because that’s their entire vocabulary.</li><li>This also reminds me: popular and competitive internship applications usually open in March (corporate internships schedule their tests mainly in March, such as Unilever, P&amp;G, etc) and peak in late April, so you better start scouring the internet and applying uss waqt. Don’t wait for summer break to actually start, because the big and famous (and especially the paid ones) organizations are full by then.</li><li>Don’t just get internships based on the money/availability. Think about the skills you lack and need to develop (no clue about marketing? Apply for that position), the postgrad program you want to pursue and need to demonstrate expertise in (LUMS only offers a psych minor but you want to do a Masters in it? Work for an organization that deals with mental health, write about the issues, do fieldwork in it). Have variety in your internships. Don’t stick to just one field (only small start-ups or only multi-nationals or only not-for-profits). Show that you’ve learned everything and now, you’ve chosen this thing, that you bring great range to the table.</li><li>Start with an internship with a big and prestigious company, like Dawn. It gets you into more exclusive places because of the pull of the name, teaches you how corporate environments work, and it’s always easier to work your way from big to small, than the other way around. At smaller places, you can lead your own campaigns, get more personal recommendations, become memorable enough to have a job ready for you after graduation, etc.</li><li>Always refrigerate your bread (if you haven’t learned this already). Switch to multi-grain. It lasts a lot longer. Refrigerate your veggies and your fruits. Have one rule in mind when you’re buying anything perishable: will I use this in a week? If the answer isn’t a resounding yes, put it back. Do not overstock, thinking ‘oh, this will save me careem fare.’ No, it will go bad. Things might last during the winter but they’ll rot before your very eyes when it gets hot.</li><li>If you want to cut down on transport costs, switch to bykea, careem or uber bike (from my experience, uber bike is the cheapest out of the three). Apart from that, download department-store apps to help you grocery shop, like Carrefour Pakistan, Metro Online, Grocer App, etc. Have multiple grocery apps so you get the maximum amount of things in your list. If paying that 150/200 delivery charge kills you, there’s always the bike to your nearest department store instead (and a rickshaw wapsi mein because you can’t carry that much on a bike).</li><li>Tbh, fruit at a mandi and mart outside is much cheaper and fresher than Carrefour and LUMS Super Store fruit. It’s worth the once-a-week trip if you like your fruit to be nutritional and not just decorative.</li><li>I haven’t personally tried Airlift yet but it’s a bus service with fixed routes and times that are constantly expanding and covering more areas that you can try, if you’d like. I’ll update this list with my experiences when I’ve tried it.</li><li>Have all important conversations with your instructors over email, so you have proof later in case anything happens. Same applies to Financial Aid. Document your every interaction.</li><li>Get yourself a therapist. Do whatever it takes but get yourself a therapist and do everything possible to make sure you don’t miss the sessions. This is the time for mental illness to peak, especially personality disorders. Instead of resorting to harmful coping mechanisms that range from substance abuse to isolation, seek help. Post on LDF; there are a lot of alumni now practicing as psychologists who will inbox you or students who will post numbers of their own therapists, many of whom offer student discounts. Post anonymously on help@lums (a facebook group) if doing it publicly is an issue. This stress is only going to build from here and you need to learn how to start coping with it. And do not expect instant results. You understand more with every session; there’s no magical breakthrough that fixes everything. Healing is not linear. There will be plenty of relapses but therapy will teach you how to deal with them. Even if you aren’t crying everyday, get a therapist, like you’d go to the dentist even if you aren’t losing teeth. If you’ve lost hope, if your life seems meaningless, if your connections feel empty, if a person displaying shitty behavior reminds you of someone you knew a lifetime ago and you feel yourself withdraw to protect yourself, go see a therapist — and stick to it. I can’t stress this enough: it will be the best decision you will ever make. And like everything else, you won’t immediately click with a therapist. You’re allowed to switch to someone else (has every single doctor you’ve met understood what you needed?). You’e allowed to outgrow therapists and need someone new to understand your new set of priorities. But keep going to therapy (maybe not as often anymore but keep going). Think of it as improving yourself instead of fixing yourself; everyone has room for improvement.</li><li>Save paper. Make notes in your google docs during class. It makes it easily accessible and you can always press Ctrl+F to ‘find’ a word in any document, on any page, article, Word Document, etc. Press those keys simultaneously. A blank search bar will drop down from the URL bar. Type the phrase/word you’re looking for and it will highlight every instance of that appearance in the entire thing. That lets you go through your notes, skim read, etc. I thought it was a basic shortcut everyone knew but I learned this year that I was wrong.</li><li>Take Quantitative Research Methods (I’v heard pol and socio offer it). It looks great on your resume for both postgrad and job applications. Even if you suck at math, grit your teeth together and take it. Convert it to pass/fail and just get through it (but only if you think you’ll score above a C, because below is Fail that wastes valuable credit hours and impacts your GPA and transcript).</li><li>Junior year is when you should take your GRE — especially if you’re applying for Fulbright. That means you need to start preparing the summer right before your junior year. Clear out your schedule so you can use those 3 months to study like your life depends on it. Also use that time to compile a list of the postgrad unis you’re considering (if you are).</li><li>Use sophomore (and junior) year to see which teachers you gel with, to not only decide which teachers you’d like as future advisors but also the supervisor for your SPROJ. Please ask your seniors for their experiences, and don’t just pick a teacher based on their cult of personality, how much you worship them, how much other people rave about them or want them, how exclusive you think they are so it makes you feel super validated when they favor you, etc. Pick someone who understands what you want to do, who understands how you need to improve and what direction you need to be nudged in but still lets you explore ON YOUR OWN, and treats you like the soon-to-be adult you are. Pick a teacher who meets you halfway, not someone you want to emulate, become, someone you’re projecting your issues onto, or someone you need to bend over backwards for. This is one of the most important achievements of your undergrad. Do not allow room for regret.</li><li>Get a tutoring job. Start looking for them in August and have a couple of opportunities lined up in September (keep your options open because koi na koi masla hojata hai). It’s very important to have back-ups because a shit ton of people will try to make you work five days a week for 10k all the way in Johar Town, which is not the kind of money LUMS tutors make. These people exploit new tutors and their ignorance of the market rate. If someone says anything over 12k is too much, they’re trying to fleece you. Not only will the constant commute take up time and strength, it’s also be a drain on your budget because of the careem fare. Always state a figure and then tell the employer to either provide transport or give you a transport allowance (state it as an add-on). If the student is difficult to teach for whatever reason, point it out and ask for more money. Have different rates for the number of DAYS asked of you, not hours (because that will take up more careem fare — teaching two hours for five days is a lot more expensive than teaching three hours for three days). Open your careem app and check the fare from your place to theirs casually, and multiply it by the days and then double it (back and forth); that should be your careem conveyance. Feel free to explain to your employer that your subject doesn’t have many tutors, that the kid has no prior familiarity with the subject and is starting from scratch, that you’ve been a TA in your A-Levels or in LUMS, that you have your own notes, etc. // Most importantly, <strong>ask for half your pay every two weeks</strong> (a month has four weeks). Explain this system to your employer as ‘I need to cover my expenses too and can’t wait a whole month for the money. Also, it helps you because you don’t have to raise as much money at once.’ If they refuse to understand, it’s because they’re playing dumb and are hoping to cut corners with the regular ‘first of every month’ bullshit. It tides you over and helps prevent scams (employers often get a month’s work out of you before informing you that they can’t pay you because your rates are too high, and then they try to coerce you into lowering them or threaten to fire you). At max, allow 2–3 days ki delay. Stop showing up if they don’t give you the money, no matter how legitimate the excuse sounds, because people are not above exploiting personal/family tragedy to cut costs. It also makes sure you get paid for the exact amount of work you put in, because a lot of people try to withhold payment entirely or pay only half in December/May, when you taught for three weeks at the very least, just because you weren’t there for the whole month. Keep track in a calendar for both when the payment is due, and when you actually received it, so you don’t get tricked out of the money you’re owed. Do not expect honesty from anyone. //</li><li>Save up your job money and buy yourself a laptop if you don’t have one or yours is unpredictable and decrepit. I can promise you it’s an investment that’s a hundred times smarter than money blown on expensive places with bad food. Woh baad mein bhi hosakat hai. Go to Carrefour and look at their range. Ask broke and geeky CS majors for recommendation and tell them what you’re looking for.</li><li>Save up job money preemptively for emergency medical bills, because I can assure you: they will cost a kidney. You should always have a back-up fund for emergencies. LUMS Insurance is useless for anything except an overnight stay. Chughtai Medical is reliable, right at Lalik Jan Chowk and gives a 15% discount to LUMS students on tests if they show their ID card (and seeing as how much they cost, that’s a sizable dent). Chughtai also has a free consultant sitting there 10 am — 4 pm Monday to Thursday that you can go to, and they have a free medical camp (swing by and ask when) where a bunch of different doctors sit (dermas, gynes). Make sure you go as early as you can because a shit ton of people show up when they get off from work, and you’ll end up waiting a long time.</li><li>Save up for therapy expenses. Have that set aside as your do-not-touch money to make sure you don’t borrow from it and need to skip a session because you couldn’t replace it in time. Always save ahead so in case you’re temporarily out of work, you don’t have to skip therapy to cover your other expenses. Money is best spent in a structured way. Splurges are for special occasions only.</li><li>All tutor agencies should want max 50% of your first month’s pay and then leave you alone (if that’s the one you’ve found work through). If it’s higher than half and/or deducts something from your pay for eternity, do not opt for it, no matter how good the pay sounds. Do not comply if they ask you to lie about your grades to land the work. People in Lahore’s DHA have a whole facebook group and if you’re found out, they’ll probably post about you on that group and alert others. Additionally, if you have DHA relatives, don’t ask them to post for you and find you work. Do not reveal any association with them to employers because if they want to harangue you, they’ll threaten to not just shame you but your family as well (for the bad recommendation). If you have a nice family who’ll defend you, great. You don’t need to worry. If your family values their reputation more than helping you, this one’s for you. Pretend you know no one in Lahore.</li><li>An sproj (senior year project) per semester counts as a 200 level elective, so don’t bulk up on that many 200 level courses for your major and miss out on fulfilling other requirements (two 4-CH sproj sections basically count as 2 electives). Use your soph year to figure out if you want to minor in something because that’s a whole other nightmare (take the intro course if you’re curious; you can file it away for some other requirement if you reconsider). Try taking one 300 level course in the spring semester (at least) so you know what’s coming up ahead. Use this year to get done with any in-school and out-school requirements you have, because you’ll have to beg for 100-level courses as a junior/senior (and most of your requirements are intro courses open only to freshies/sophs). Take that MGMT and PLS and ILR course and put it behind you.</li><li>Most importantly, if you have DHL dreams, the cut-off is 3.59 AT THE END. Don’t freak out about your semester ka GPA. Use your soph year to play it smart and stabilize your GPA because junior year will be the toughest year in undergrad. Go to Eilya Mohsin and ask her what grades you need in how many courses to ensure you end up on the DHL by the end of soph year. Be frank about your ambitions.</li><li>If you have Student Council aspirations, start campaigning and building your base rn. Post more frequently on LDF, participate in your classes, take part in society activities. Let people know your face and your name. And don’t just capitalize on random issues to make your platform cool and relatable. People might vote you in abhi but trust me, if you don’t deliver, they will notice and lose faith in you. Apart from it being an ethically shitty and terrible thing to do, there are consequences for it.</li><li>Speaking of society activities, start being present in the societies you’ve joined. At the end of soph year, forms will be circulated and interviews conducted to appoint new president, executives, directors, etc., and you can only aim realistically to be selected for those positions if you’ve been working (or your current heads are from your A-Level college/city and think like a flock of sheep/pack of wolves and will pick you just because of an arbitrary similarity instead of actual merit).</li><li>Invest in a planner. Get a notebook split into weeks and days (I got mine from MINISO), and write down every deadline in advance (your essays, exams, presentations, sab). If that’s tedious and/or expensive (personally, I use a pencil because I’m a stingy bitch who’ll erase the dates until the paper rips), put a desk calendar on your, well, desk and write down everything in its tiny squares. If that isn’t your thing either (finding a desk calendar often proves impossible), put alerts on your calendar app. You can even customize them to start popping up in advance. I had a presentation due on 23rd April, so I set the notifications to start pinging two weeks prior, so I’d remember to get done with the research and to visit the sites in question. After that, I had a notification going off every day from 17th April, just to make sure I never forgot to prepare. Plan ahead of your procrastination, so you can engage in it anyway. Your brain is a circus animal and it’s your job to trick it.</li><li>If your essay is 3k words, as it will be often in soph year, PLEASE brainstorm, structure and discuss with your advisor <strong>at least a week in advance</strong>. Forcing yourself to adhere to that deadline, even when it’s not a graded part of your essay (like it usually is in W&amp;C), will make sure your instructor can poke holes in your argument and prevent a situation that ends in you sitting in front of the computer six hours before the deadline, realizing your data doesn’t prove any of your claims. Please show them all the resources you’ve collected so they can go through them and point out potential problems and so you actually look up stuff and start refining your points, instead of running frantic Google searches at 10 pm. Force yourself to stick to this routine. Schedule an appointment with your instructor pehley se so you HAVE to show up or risk upsetting them and wasting their time. I don’t know about anyone else but most HSS instructors (sans econ) are wonderful and want you to come to them and talk to them about your ideas in their office hours. They’d love to tell you what’s doable and what isn’t, to tweak how you conduct research and prepare you for grad school. If you disagree with their methods, say it in a civil manner. If you’re anything like me, you’ll realize they saw a lot more nuance and balanced the contradictions better you could, at that age. You’ll realize they were right and you’ll regret snapping like that. Ofc, I’ve only experienced easily the most aware and conscientious instructors LUMS had during my time, so idk what other schools’ instructors are like. My advice is about history, socio, and anthro instructors (heart eyes only please).</li><li>A lot of difficult lessons were learned during soph year and at the end of it. Chief among them was that LUMS is unpredictable with its aid. You might not get any next year, even if you have it now. Don’t bank on signing a loan with them if you don’t get anything; they only provide that option to kids who’ve been accepted for aid. You might want to start looking into external sources of funding from now. Always have a back-up plan for everything and I mean everything. I’m compiling a list and will be posting it in a separate blog post soon.</li><li>Everyone will try to spook you about F4 for some reason. I just spent a year there. The lift is working 97% of the time (just one of the two though). It’s just that the storage room sucks ass. It’s just one regular-sized room so your boxes might have other boxes piled on top of them, so either don’t put anything fragile in there or leave the things with a trustworthy friend/relative when you leave at the year-end (OR take things back home in the winter and spring break). I lived on the top floor. The bathrooms were usually clean, the coolers usually working, the common room usually seemed full because of the mattresses being everywhere but it was mostly just my roommate and me. The only complaints I had was that there would be hundreds of mosquitoes that would dart into my room if I opened the door just to get in, and no amount of coil-burning or sprays could kill them. Keep your door closed after it gets dark, even if it means dying of heat (or you can die of dengue; it’s your funeral). When/if you get a heater, make sure it doubles as those cooler fan things so you can prevent yourself from experiencing the misery I did in spring semester.</li><li>When everyone is graduating, be on the lookout for posts selling heaters, fans, fridges, mattresses, etc., on LDF. You just need these things for two years max (hopefully). Get them secondhand and save money. They’re usually in good condition. Have no shame about wanting to see/test them before buying them.</li><li>Please buy cartons for packing for the summer break at least two months in advance (because stuff will come up and you will pakka end up delaying it by at least 3 weeks). Put them on top of the shelf drilled into the wall in your room. They won’t get in the way, and you won’t be running to H-block market when you should be studying for your finals (only to find out they’re out). Trust me, people will make a business out of your misery and desperation and charge you 150 for a piece of cardboard that should have cost 10. I’ve said this in my last post but I need to reiterate just to be safe (also, because I forgot to take my own advice and suffered).</li><li>And of course, if you have more suggestions, comment them or tweet me at twitter.com/khoonsurat_ so I can plug them in. Any and all feedback is appreciated. I’ll keep updating this list as I think of more things.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=372950125801" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I wish someone had told me about LUMS — freshie year]]></title>
            <link>https://khoonsurat.medium.com/things-i-wish-someone-had-told-me-before-lums-started-37bc317d3d10?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37bc317d3d10</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[listicles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hostel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lists]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zoha batool khan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Aug 2018 16:24:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-08T12:44:12.343Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m writing from the perspective of a broke hostelite from Karachi who was not prepared at all for what a new city would be like.</p><p>This list will increase (started typing it up randomly at 7 pm) as I remember more things and if others remind me of more. If you have questions, comment them below or reach out to me. Good luck!</p><ol><li>I know everyone says you should start sticking to a budget immediately, to develop the habit. And it’s true: you <em>should</em> start from the very first day. But your first month is going to be ridiculously expensive anyway, despite your best efforts, because a) you need to make a lot of one-time investments like masalas, utensils (btw, have more than one of each in the cutlery dept — re: #16), etc., and b) you live in a family so you have no idea how to buy and prepare meals for one, which means you’re going to be throwing out a lot of food because you over-estimated (a lot). You can be the most conscientious thrifty little kid in your neighborhood back home but — trust me on this; I found out the hard way — you have no idea how fast tomatoes rot in your fridge or that cucumbers can grow fungus. Never buy anything perishable if you won’t immediately eat it. You’ll tell yourself that you’ll need it two days from now but I promise, you’ll forget about it until you gag from the stench in your fridge because it decayed in the back. Mourn the death and then toss it out. It’s okay; in two months, you’ll be much wiser about this. In the meantime, you can give away all your extra food to the domestic help in your dorms. Ask them what the procedure is and they’ll tell you.</li><li>Start learning to cook the basics right now. PDC’s food is so bland, the water left over from boiling chicken is spicier than their salan. Even the basics go a long way. Unless you’re rich, because then you can afford to order. If your budget is anything below 20k per month, forget about being able to eat out. Forget convenience. That was a luxury you could afford only back home.</li><li>You’re charged for any ‘damages’ to your hostel room. So get a plastic cover for your desk, and find tape that doesn’t leave a mark if you want to put anything up on the walls. Don’t let your shoes or laptop scrape against the wall because it’ll leave a long black streak. Don’t put too much weight on your bed or try to jump on it, because the mattress is supported by a big thin wooden board, which doesn’t take much to break (but you’ll be billed for the replacement). Don’t lose your keys because you’ll need to pay for an extra copy (if you lost your room keys, borrow your roommate’s and get a copy made for way cheaper).</li><li>Another reason the first month of a semester is the most expensive: you’ll need to buy course-packs. Some teachers upload their notes online so you can just read them there but most compile them into books, which will be selling in a little shop in LUMS, above the grocery store. You’ll pay 1k for a stack of papers you will never touch again after these four months. So either start looking for buyers towards the end, or buy discounted notes from your seniors (a lot of them give them away for free).</li><li>In my experience, the LUMS Super Store usually inflates prices, so if you want anything (and it isn’t an emergency), make a list of everything and go buy groceries at the beginning of every month. Carpool with a friend to cut down on transport costs — or make yourself a nice Lahori friend who’s generous with their car.</li><li>Use one of the drawers under your bed to make a basic First Aid supply kit, with Dettol, saniplasts, Burnol, cough drops, cough syrup, painkillers, a brace, Moov, Vicks, a proper smog mask (should cost 300 something) instead of just that weird surgeon thing, etc. Because you’re going to be falling sick.</li><li>Continuing from #6: if you’re from any city where the winter lasts two weeks (*cough* Karachi *cough*), you and your 96% lawn ki wardrobe are not ready for Lahore’s winter. At all. You need to get a shit ton more winter clothes made — personally, fake fur jackets work like magic — or you’re going to fall horribly sick in December, which is when finals start. I’m talking throwing-up, congested-chest levels of sick which force you to skip your exams, because the LUMS doctor will not back your request for a sick leave unless you have a burning fever exactly when you meet her, and without that, no teacher will excuse you, and will give you a zero on quite possibly the biggest part of your grade.</li><li>Talk to your roommate to get the room swept once a week; split the bill evenly. Tip heavily, because the domestic help cleaning up after you is trying to make a living too, and if uni should teach you anything, it’s that if your one meal costs 200, theirs doesn’t magically cost only 50. Tipping should done according to realistic expenses, not to dispose of whatever chillar you have.</li><li>Your classes might be terrible and soulless (Islamiat) but you want to attend them for the attendance grade — and by extension, the class participation grade. Combined, they can make the difference of a letter grade (which impacts your GPA and then your TA-ship chances down the line). This obviously means you will need your sleep, so if you want to do tumblr shit like watch the sun come up (whyyy), save that for the weekends. If you want to one-up that, avoid 8am sections like the plague (which they are), and arrange your schedule to have Friday off to do more useless things. But be careful — one slip and your entire sleep schedule will be fucked beyond belief, and can take weeks to reset, during which your grades will drop because you can’t pay attention for shit and everything hurts — if you’re actually taking challenging courses. (I personally stocked a lot of black tea so, every morning, I would always boil a mug with two tea-bags, sugar and cinnamon, and then pour it into a bottle to chug through my three back-to-back classes)</li><li>Save drastic haircuts for the breaks because a) someone you trust will be supervising while you get it done by a professional and b) if it’s bad, you can wait a month (minimum) at home while you grow it out.</li><li>If life is just a struggle with money for you too, you will be travelling by train. If your parents prefer that you travel in a cabin with trusted friends and associates, you will want to start looking for a group six weeks in advance, because it will take you at least two weeks to assemble one. You will then want to book your tickets in advance as well (four weeks), because those things sell out <em>fast, </em>especially if you’re looking for an empty cabin’s worth.</li><li>If you’re one of those types who’s super excited about learning, this is for you: give yourself a couple of days to go through your pick of courses so you can make an evenly balanced schedule. Try going for 3 new courses that cover totally new territory, and 2 that elaborate on stuff you already have a grasp of (because of your previous education).</li><li>If you’re gunning for the Dean’s Honor List before you’ve stepped foot on campus: you need a minimum of 16 credit hours <strong>per semester</strong> to start. After that, you need a GPA of 3.6 per semester. If you get it in only one, don’t worry. You don’t get on the DHL but you do get a special mention on your transcript.</li><li>Get an umbrella. The first thing you need to buy when you get to Lahore is an umbrella. It might look sunny but do not be fooled (I was). The first week of my classes, it rained everyday. You couldn’t even think of running because you’d slip and fall flat on your face. Even if you tried, you got soaked anyway, so you would be shivering in class because they’d be blasting the AC full force.</li><li>If you want to stop spending money, stop carrying it with you. Leave your wallet in your room when you go out (this actually helps because your friends are also too broke to loan you anything).</li><li>Theft is a thing in LUMS. Lock your door when you sleep because people sneak into your room to steal your devices (yes, this has happened to hundreds). Don’t leave your keys in the vent because everyone does this (also, it’s against the rules so it’ll be confiscated).</li><li>Get a mini fridge for your room. Secondhand is cheaper. Appliance charges are 1k per month, which is a lot more than you’ll lose from your food going missing from the communal fridge (re: #16). You’ll need to clean it out a handful of times during the year, but it’s an investment that’s worth it (also re: #1).</li><li>Join LUMS Discussion Forum. It’s a Facebook group where a lot of useful shit is posted, like course packs for sale, honest teacher reviews, turnitin accounts you can use for your essays, etc.</li><li>You’ll be assigned an O-week orientation group. If you like it, great. If you don’t, feel free to completely ignore them after the first day. It’s not the end of your friend-making opportunities. You can also join societies but if you’d like to settle in before you take on more responsibilities, that’s cool too. There’s no limit. Also, a better reason would be so you have more stuff to brag about on your resume (eyes on the prize).</li><li>Don’t lose your ID card and don’t break it. That shit costs 1500 to replace.To get a new smart card made — copied from a super helpful LDF post:</li></ol><p>· E-mail vigilance</p><p>· They send you a fee voucher that you have to pay at MCB (can be paid off at the LUMS MCB Booth). It costs Rs 1500/-</p><p>· Take the depositor’s copy of the fee voucher to the Security Office</p><p>· Get your smart card the very next evening</p><p>Edited: In case you want to get your picture changed as well, at Step (3) let the security office know your request. They’ll ask you to send out an e-mail to vigilance with your presentable picture.</p><p>21. If you’re a kid who is on or wants to get on financial aid, you want to start preparing your documents in November, because that’s when application time starts. It usually ends in the last week of January but trust me when I tell you that things will be way too crazy to get it done at the last minute.</p><p>22. Get yourself a massive suitcase, the biggest you can get your hands on. This will be important when the year ends because you’ll be expected to clear your whole room out (anything you leave behind becomes LUMS property) and you’re allowed to stow away only the belongings you can fit into your one cardboard box downstairs in the storage. So start posting your things home at least one month in advance, or find Lahori friends who are generous enough to lend you space in their storage.</p><p>23. On a tangent from #22, you will find your cardboard boxes (for packing) from all the department stores and malls nearby. Even though there are many such buildings in your vicinity, you want to go box-hunting at least one week in advance because everyone from LUMS will descend like a horde of furies last minute, just like you, so you’ll find nothing, except maybe shoe-boxes.</p><p>24. Btw, LUMS’ hostel kitchens contain a big communal fridge, two microwaves, two stove tops, two toasters, and one water filter. Everything else is to be brought by you (and stashed in your room or it’ll be stolen). I brought a blender to make milkshakes and coffee in. It also helps with garlic paste.</p><p>25. That 300k per semester figure you see on the website? That’s false. For the first year, at least, you’ll have a minimum of roughly 70k as admission fees. There’s also 50k extra for hostels, 5k extra for appliance charges, yearly fake hostel room damages, a price hike in the fees as you move up, the travel costs between cities/countries (because you have to go back home during the break), the budget every month just to feed yourself (15k is a minimum if you don’t want to be starving by the last week) etc. There are a lot of hidden costs when it comes to LUMS. You might want to start looking for a job about halfway into freshie year, to help your parent(s) offset your growing uni costs. That gives you enough time to settle in and find your groove.</p><p>26. In the first week of uni, you’ll get a handbook. There’s a PDF available on the LUMS portal if you ever lose your hard copy but try not to, because — believe it or not — that thing is actually important. What I found about a month before freshie year would end was that there are a bunch of pages in there that tell you what kind of courses you need to take for your degree. You can’t just go around studying whatever you like (the dream); you have to cover a certain number of courses pertaining to your major (some of them above 300 level and some below), and then a number within your school but not of your major, and then a number regarding your minor (btw, you can do a double minor) which can’t overlap with the first two categories (one course can only fulfill one category’s requirements), and then a number from outside your school. Surprisingly, that’s a lot to cover in just four years, especially if you’re in HSS where there are never enough courses to go around. If you don’t entirely understand how it all works, that’s okay. You can book an appointment with counselors (in your first year, you’re assigned one and if they suck, you can go to Eliya Mohsin to report their incompetence; after that, you can pick one that’s actually relevant to your major). As long as you’ve read the pages, you’ll know what questions to ask, instead of just showing up at their office and waste their time by demanding they explain everything to you (which they won’t, because their job isn’t to spoonfeed you).</p><p>27. If you’re ever struggling to pay your fees for whatever reason, you can ask for an extension. Download the form off the LUMS Portal and print it out to fill. If you’re significantly ahead of time, you can print out the copies of the documents they want and then TCS them. But if that isn’t an option, scan and attach everything to an email meant for the RO. Just make sure you do it a day before the actual deadline, before 3 pm ( yeah, they have a deadline for submission… for a deadline extension).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37bc317d3d10" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Zainab and the Hierarchy of Rape Culture]]></title>
            <link>https://khoonsurat.medium.com/zainab-and-the-hierarchy-of-rape-culture-e760bf3dc4fe?source=rss-21aa8c572b7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e760bf3dc4fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-sexual-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zainab]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zoha batool khan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jan 2018 04:32:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-18T05:53:31.977Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On 5th January, 2018, in Kasur, Pakistan, a missing-persons FIR was filed for Zainab by her paternal uncle, a day after she had gone missing. She had been living with her maternal aunt while her parents were away on Umrah in Saudi Arabia and had left for a madrassah in the Road Kot area near her house on 4th Jan. Footage was soon received by the family that depicted her walking with a stranger near Peerowala Road.</p><p>On 8th January, the police recovered her body from where it had been left in a rubbish heap (different articles state <a href="https://www.samaa.tv/pakistan/2018/01/zainab-incident-violent-protest-continues-in-kasur/">different</a> <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1382022">locations</a>). An <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1382243/6-year-old-zainabs-autopsy-suggests-child-endured-rape-captivity-before-murder">autopsy report</a> showed she had been killed two to three days earlier, sexually assaulted, tortured and strangled to death, the details of which are still being investigated. The body was buried on Wednesday when the parents returned, the funeral prayers led by Pakistani Awami Tehreek’s chief, <a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/who-is-islamic-cleric-dr-tahir-ul-qadri-and-why-should-pakistan-care-8454230.html">Tahirul Qadri</a>, whom Zainab’s father supports.</p><p>This has not been <a href="https://tribune.com.pk/story/1605145/1-kasur-timeline-tears-shed-lives-lost-years/">the first time</a> Kasur has featured in headlines due to violence against children. Last year, two men were imprisoned for <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1382596">a pedophilia ring</a> consisting of multiple children abused all over Punjab over a number of years by a wealthy family that would force the children to perform sexual acts on tape and then use it to <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1201633">extort money</a> from parents. Then too, the state looked the other way and insisted it was a land dispute.</p><p>As the news spread, protests erupted not only in Kasur but all over the country; in major cities such as <a href="https://www.samaa.tv/pakistan/2018/01/sexual-abuse-awareness-karachi-zainab/">Karachi</a>, Islamabad and Lahore, there were protests at press clubs . #JusticeForZainab started trending, attracting coverage from <a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-trending-42646151">BBC</a>, <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-pakistan-sexcrimes-children/celebrities-call-for-justiceforzainab-to-end-girls-rape-and-murder-in-pakistan-idUSKBN1F02EC">Reuters</a>, <a href="http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/01/pakistanis-protest-police-search-girl-killer-180111173226500.html">Al-Jazeera</a>, among countless others.</p><p>While the fact that this didn’t just go underground as one of the countless cases of violence against women but gained global attention is remarkable on its own, the focus has shifted entirely to catching the rapist and hanging him publicly to act as a deterrent to other rapists and child molesters. <a href="https://www.change.org/p/supreme-court-of-pakistan-hang-the-rapists-of-zainab-publicly">Petitions demanding punishment</a> have cropped up and are quickly gaining lakhs of signatures, citing <a href="https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/10/28/womens-rights-iran">Iran</a>’s Atena Aslani case as inspiration, the same country <a href="https://www.huffingtonpost.com/kaveh-taheri/iranian-women-still-denie_b_9607430.html">whose soccer team’s captain was barred from playing in Malaysia in 2015 because of Sharia law</a>, whose <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2015/03/24/middleeast/sanei-iran-treatment-of-women/">leader deems gender equality incompatible with the Islamic Republic</a>. Cries for punishing the rapist as per Sharia are echoing throughout Pakistan, when it was under the same <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1261054">mantle of Sharia</a> that the landmark Violence Against Women bill was <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-pakistan-women/top-pakistani-religious-body-rules-womens-protection-law-un-islamic-idUSKCN0W51O9">criticized and deemed unIslamic </a>by Pakistan’s Council of Islamic Ideology, the same council that insisted DNA couldn’t be primary evidence in a rape case, termed the changing of women’s minimum marriageable age from 16 to 18 <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1092571">‘blasphemous</a>’, going so far as to declare <a href="https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/2014/03/15/coucil-of-islamic-ideology-declares-womens-existence-anti-islamic/">women themselves anti-Islamic</a>, among a host of other misogynistic stances.</p><p>Apart from the erroneous focus on Sharia methods for punishment, the problem is, in fact, the focus on punishment itself. The under-reported crimes in Pakistan alone show that this is a serious, systemic problem and punishing one individual will not fix the system in place that fosters the attitudes that lead to this. The punishment should be doled out, that much is certain, but it can’t be our main goal. It should be on making sure no victim needs to fear a situation like this in the first place. Even in our focus on punishment, we’re making mistakes by not revising what we know of rape and justice, and why, why there’s only one type of victim and one type of rapist, by not fixing the flaws in the system that allow only some crimes to be punished.</p><ul><li><em>The misconceptions surrounding rape itself</em>: We should be looking at a multi-faceted reform of the system that makes certain bodies more vulnerable to violence and why it’s mostly men inflicting it, what entitles them to this. No, it’s not because of mental illness. Many mentally ill people are not abusive, which counters the idea that illness makes one inherently prone to abuse; this explanation just perpetuates ableism and stigmatizes mental illness further. It also serves as an excuse, where the blame for rape is shifted from the individual onto the illness. Rapists know perfectly well what they’re doing. They choose it because they think they’re entitled to other people’s bodies, regardless of bodies. The problem is taught, not a result of sickness.</li></ul><p>No, it’s not about lust, a pervasive misconception that we can’t seem to shake off despite multiple research studies. For one, the elderly and children often make up significant chunks of assault victims. It’s simply about dominance, about exerting control over a victim to teach them ‘who’s boss.’ Rape has been historically used as a tool of subjugation globally, often as an explicit command issued out to soldiers to ‘<a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/689976">pollute’ bloodlines and honor</a>, used to perpetuate every crime from religious to caste-based to class because all conflicts are gendered. Panchayats or arbitration courts think it’s completely logical to punish the women in a family when the men are convicted of a crime; the men of the accuser’s family then proceed to <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1083887">rape the women</a> with the full approval of the village elders. They also sanction <a href="https://tribune.com.pk/story/1467157/17-year-old-raped-panchayats-orders-muzaffarabad/">‘revenge rape’</a>, a concept blatantly misogynistic, horrible and twisted beyond belief. Even <a href="https://www.geo.tv/latest/174125-panchayat-members-repeatedly-rape-newly-married-woman">marriage of one’s choice</a> is apparently asking for it.We should be asking why certain bodies are battles zones to engage in warfare on, why they’re used like land to ambush the foe on, treated like property and discarded when defiled, no identity of their own except how they can be used against those in actual power, as liability. It’s this sort of social reform that must be carried out to prevent any blocking of progressive bills.</p><ul><li><em>Why only some victims are defended:</em> We should be questioning why only selective types of victims get sympathy, those we can turn into martyrs, those we could see as our own or ourselves. Why are women like Qandeel Baloch seen as deserving of their fate? We all know why: it’s because they owned their sexuality and refused to abide by chaste-victim norms, refused to be subordinate and modest, and we believe that if someone doesn’t play by our rules, they deserve what’s coming to them, even when our rules haven’t protected those who obeyed either.</li></ul><p>Why are some bodies considered public property, disposable, particularly <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1360805">trans people</a> and sex workers, so when they’re violated, it isn’t considered rape? Because they were never seen as people, and beyond that, as people with autonomy, whose consent matters as much as an upper-class cis woman’s. Why has state-sanctioned violence against the trans community gone unprotested? How was Zainab not asking for it but Muskan was? In our society, some bodies have been sexualized beyond the point of requiring consent, of basic rights, and we just watch when that’s reinforced everyday in every sphere. We only sigh in relief that today, it wasn’t our body chosen.</p><p>Why was the body of an 8-month-old Ahmadi girl, Kainat, burned in Gujranwala while a mob danced? Are only Sunni Muslim girls worth protecting, because Sunni Muslim honor resides in them? Maybe that’s why Zainab’s father was insistent that the committee to investigate Zainab’s murder and rape shouldn’t be headed by an Ahmadi. After all, what would they know of <a href="http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2016/12/bigotry-ahmadis-constant-pakistan-161218113353263.html">violence</a>, right?</p><p>Why can your abuse only be abuse if you fit the damaging, restrictive mould of what a good, defendable victim is supposed to be? Only a dead victim is worth lauding, and it’s evident in how countless girls Zainab’s age, of all ages, are going through <a href="https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/opinion/blog/marital-rape-is-it-criminalized-in-pakistan/">the same thing</a>, through <a href="https://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/24020/i-was-raped-hundreds-of-times-by-the-man-i-was-married-to/">marital assault</a> and rape, just under the sham of a marriage, and no one cares; no one will mourn them and their current-tense suffering because it’s too painful and requires actual work to undo, something more than grabbing onto one perpetrator and making a ceremony out of the punishment, something too close to home. it’s easier to mourn someone dead: they can’t make any more demands of you, ask you to do something more than perform.</p><ul><li><em>Why only some rapists are prosecuted:</em> On the other end of this equation, why are some rapists easier to vilify while others walk free? There has been no national protest against the <a href="https://tribune.com.pk/story/1564321/9-madrassas-allegedly-infested-sexual-abuse-minors/">sexual abuse going on in madrassahs</a>, because they are either connected to militant groups who threaten the family into dropping charges or because the social prestige from being a religious clerk protects them. One’s profession can influence how people see them and what they’re capable of; just as sex workers are unduly stripped of autonomy by virtue of what they are mostly trafficked into, <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/pakistan/islamic-schools-in-pakistan-plagued-by-sex-abuse-of-children/articleshow/61748488.cms">molvis</a> are given undeserved saintly status for what they chose. It is in this thread that parents’ complicity in abuse also comes under investigation, where many cover up their own children’s abuse because they blame the child for being the victim, are in denial, or refuse to believe this happened because they somehow consider it blasphemous, completely under the spell of their priests.</li></ul><p>Apart than the focus on punishment, there were numerous ‘tips’ all across social media on how to prevent child abuse, arguing this was only realistic because we couldn’t do anything about the abusers. These mostly assumed the abuser would be a qari, a driver, house help. It neglects to consider two scenarios: someone from the immediate family is the abuser, making it a case of incest (statistics show that in most of the cases, it was <a href="https://www.rainn.org/statistics/perpetrators-sexual-violence">someone the victim was close to</a>), or that the parents, if not the abusers themselves, would want to cover it up for various reasons that include but are not limited to: the family’s honor being at stake, the religious beliefs that insist men working for God can’t do this, financial or societal pressure, etc. It is not only unrealistic to expect the parents to be guarding the children 24/7, blaming them when something goes awry when they have other responsibilities to attend to and are prone to lapses in judgment and trust, but also dangerous because they might be the ones<a href="https://www.sbs.com.au/news/dateline/article/2017/05/31/child-trafficking-china-often-starts-parents-selling-their-own-kids"> trafficking their children</a> into this for money, etc., to begin with. This line of argument can not only endanger the child by entrusting them to the perpetrators but also deflects from the problem by pretending that we can solve this if we’re just alert enough for it to never happen.</p><p>It is parents pulling their daughters out of school early and forcing them into <a href="https://tribune.com.pk/story/1020355/of-child-marriages-and-medieval-mindsets/">child marriage</a>, selling their daughters off to <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5201613/Police-rescue-child-bride-10-sold-mother-man-50.html">pay loans incurred back home</a>. How can you trust a parent to stand up for what’s right in a country where a <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1308798">mother kills her own daughter</a> for honor? How can you entrust a child’s safety to a parent when so many are fleeing abusive households?</p><p>Children are the most defenseless in our society. Zainab’s intersection of sex, class and age all contributed to her being an easier target. This needs to be <a href="http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/01/pakistani-activist-rape-victim-blaming-180113115520779.html">a wake-up call</a> to Pakistan to improve its child protective services program (which is, frankly, in shambles), to help and free the victims still alive, not wait for them to die before validating their suffering, to change the culture and mindset that says you’re either your father’s property or your husband’s which means you’re just passed from abuser to abuser, creating a scenario in which too many girls are either forced into marriage or jump into it to flee abusive households and end up being trapped in another one. We can’t focus simply on punishing Zainab’s rapist because she’s not the only victim. There are countless others whose lives remain unaffected by this hanging. For their sake, the change needs to go deeper. It needs to be a social change, with classes about sex education that normalize sex and stop making it so taboo that it <a href="https://images.dawn.com/news/1175342">prevents abuse from being talked about</a>, to explain the importance of consent and respecting autonomy, of how a no means no, how abuse works and how it’s wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/208/1*mr6qESzdbGuayziT_uBCDQ.png" /></figure><p>We need a legislative reform that criminalizes all forms of harassment and implements punishments effectively, that is, importantly, pro-trans and pro-sex worker, segments of population that are disproportionately targeted, that <a href="http://thehill.com/opinion/civil-rights/356512-decriminalize-sex-work-to-bring-trafficking-victims-out-of-the-shadows">decriminalizes sex work</a> to <a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/sex-workers-decriminalisation-of-prostitution-new-zealand-new-law-works-research-proves-sex-workers-a7761426.html">allow them workplace protection</a> and recognizes that they too can be abused. As per Ambedkar, social reform needs to happen to effect political change but as per Humeira Iqtidar, secularism as a state policy (a facet of it here as pro-child and pro-woman legislation that markedly deviates from all aspects of Sharia, progressive as they seem), needs to be implemented to facilitate secularization, the social process, opens up conversations about abuse, incentivizes better treatment of victims.</p><p>We cannot afford to involve Sharia, whether in punishment or legal, social reform. We’re using the palatable bits to fix the problems caused by the other version which is a self-defeating process because it doesn’t change anything about the root of the issue. Using it as support inevitably leads to misuse and problems tomorrow. The #JusticeForZainab movement needs to center the voices and experiences of victims, instead of marginalizing them all over again, making props out of them to push for more religious involvement. This requires unlearning how all of us have been complicit in upholding this system, even victims who prioritize our own definitions and experiences and force them onto other victims, discrediting theirs under the assumption that they don’t know well enough (as we’re seeing victims insist that <a href="https://babe.net/2018/01/13/aziz-ansari-28355">Grace</a> is faking it). And as a victim, I say this needs to be a reckoning for the whole country, for the rapists and all the bystanders who assisted through silence. May there be no more of us or of them after today, and if we do this right, we can ensure a world like that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e760bf3dc4fe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>