<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Khristian Vanier on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Khristian Vanier on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 12:32:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Meaningful Changes for Eradicating Violence Towards Women]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/meaningful-changes-for-eradicating-violence-towards-women-e84bf8f7a952?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e84bf8f7a952</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rape-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[domestic-violence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-enforcement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Dec 2018 03:19:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-06T03:19:17.660Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>KEY CHANGE 1: ELIMINATION OF THE MARITAL EXCEPTION TO SPOUSAL RAPE</strong></p><p>One important key change to the scope of violence towards women is eliminating the marital exemption to spousal rape (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). In the past, marital exemption to spousal rape did not exist. “The issue of sexual assault of married parties had never been widely addressed” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). “Many legislatures tried to limit the ability of police… from turning severe assaults against intimates into simple misdemeanors” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). Dropping charges related to domestic violence, including sexual assault, to simple misdemeanors encourages the widespread belief that violence in the home, and specifically, violence towards women is not a serious matter worth prosecuting to the full extent of the law.</p><p>Understanding the magnitude of spousal rape requires “setting violence in the context of coercive control meant to complement the emphasis on trauma by highlighting how stalking, isolation, and control tactics also harm a victim’s rights and liberties as well as their sense of physical or sexual autonomy and safety” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). Spousal rape in the scope of domestic violence is important to recognize as part of the control cycle that exists in an abusive relationship. “We use the term ‘domestic violence’ to encompass a broad range of maltreatment by intimates. We include (a) physical violence…; (b) sexual violence; © threats of physical and sexual violence; (d) severe emotional or psychological abuse, including behaviors designed to isolate or control victims; (e) economic violence…; and (f) stalking by present or former intimates for the express purpose of committing domestic violence” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). It is vital to recognize the weight that spousal sexual violence carries when considering the broad scope of domestic violence and what external forces keep women in abusive relationships, even after recognizing levels of violence and threatened violence increasing. Spousal rape extends the pressure of control over the victim, and can happen as a regular occurrence until the victim leaves or attempts to get help from outside forces (law enforcement, safe houses, programs for battered women). “Stark (2007)…insists that by incorporating the range of coercive acts into the definition of abuse, alongside tactics like depriving women of money, transport, or other necessities of daily life, we enhance the harms caused and overcome the current tendency to trivialize or ignore case in which victims are not seriously injured” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017).</p><p>Previously, when spousal rape did extend a marital exception, this normalized the notion that a person cannot be sexually assaulted or raped by a romantic partner. This incorrect notion contributes to society’s views of battered women, typically that a husband cannot be abusive to his own wife (or a boyfriend to a girlfriend), and that sex between two people in a relationship can never be coerced or otherwise nonconsensual by nature. Including spousal rape, and contending that the marital exception is incorrect, extends the scope of understanding interpersonal violence and why people stay in abusive relationships.</p><p><strong>STRENGTHS, LIMITATIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS</strong></p><p>Recognizing spousal rape and eliminating marital exemptions to spousal rape laws shows that regardless of relation to one another, rape is rape. The state courts’ decisions to remove this exemption can help contribute to understanding interpersonal violence by recognizing that people we are in formal or informal relationships with can (and more often, statistically) abuse women.</p><p>The limitations to this are that it is a very small step towards eliminating violence from the home. While this exception is removed, we must first address the understanding that rape as a whole is entirely underreported to law enforcement. This means that for this decision to have meaningful effect, this would assume women report spousal rape more often. Underreporting exists because victims fear reprisal from their partner for reporting, mainly. This can very potentially be a part of a domestic violence scenario where a victim feels powerless and submissive.</p><p>Spousal rape and assault was not explored or researched in the past. It is vital to recognize the dynamic of power that can prevent leaving. States should extend this notion, silently proclaimed in the dissolution of the marital exemption, that sexual violence and otherwise that occurs between romantic partners is criminal in nature and should be punishable to the full extent of the law. This reasoning should set ideas forward that also abhor sexual violence and other forms of interpersonal violence to a romantic partner.</p><p><strong>KEY CHANGE 2: INCREASED MANDATES TO REQUIRE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE TRAINING FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT</strong></p><p>The increased mandate to train key officials in domestic violence to enhance their awareness of domestic violence, and thus assist them in making more educated decisions when it comes to exercising discretion in domestic violence calls. These mandates make sure that domestic violence training is “not left to individual departments’ discretion” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). Police officers maintain a very high level of discretion in the criminal justice system, and it is more than even the prosecutor’s level of discretion allowed. “An officer might develop an internal matrix… governing whether to make an arrest in any particular circumstance” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017).</p><p>Educating law enforcement and other response staff that are present during domestic violence calls and in the proceedings following is important to ensure they are making informed decisions when deciding how to handle domestic violence calls, i.e., to make an arrest or not, to arrest both victim and perpetrator, and so on. “By the early 1980s there was widespread disillusionment with classic patterns of police noninvolvement in cases of domestic violence” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017).</p><p><strong>STRENGTHS, LIMITATIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS</strong></p><p>There is strength in mandating education to increase domestic violence awareness in law enforcement sectors. Education is mandated, as in, not optional. Departments will somehow be sanctioned for failure to ensure all staff and especially police officers attend classes.</p><p>Limitations to this are clear; we will have to hope that sanctions imposed are threatening enough to prevent nonattendance to mandatory domestic violence classes. Small monetary fines will not be enough to dissuade nonparticipation by police departments. The burden should be on the law enforcement officials individually, with the department providing the classes at times that everyone can attend. This may require classes held several times on a regular basis. Since the burden will be on the individual, the individual will be held accountable for not attending classes as mandated.</p><p>Further, statutes make different recommendations state to state, district to district, department to department. There is no uniform standard to hold all responders and law enforcement officials to when it comes to adequate and sufficient domestic violence training. Another limitation is that only a “small minority of states… require continuing training” (Buzawa, Buzawa, &amp; Stark, 2017). Finally, Under-reporting and the wide amount of discretion police officers carry limits the ability of sanctioning agencies to determine the true magnitude of how domestic violence cases are handled.</p><h4>Bibliography</h4><p>Buzawa, E. S., Buzawa, C. G., &amp; Stark, E. D. (2017). <em>Responding to Domestic Violence: The Integration of Criminal Justice and Human Services</em> (5th ed.). Los Angeles: Sage.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e84bf8f7a952" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE METAMORPHOSIS OF JUVENILE JUSTICE: HISTORY, EFFECTIVENESS, AND PROPOSED CHANGES]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/the-metamorphosis-of-juvenile-justice-history-effectiveness-and-proposed-changes-2d8c362a671d?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d8c362a671d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[juvenile-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prison-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[juvenile-delinquency]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Apr 2018 18:10:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-18T18:10:07.689Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The juvenile justice system is complex in its operations and how it processes our nation’s youth when they are faced with neglect, abuse, or delinquency. As Anthony M. Platt stated in The Child Savers, “The juvenile court system was part of a general movement directed toward removing adolescents from the criminal law process and creating special programs for delinquent, dependent, and neglected children” (Platt, 2009).</p><h3>HISTORY OF THE JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM</h3><p>Prior to an established juvenile court system, the United States treated juveniles the same as adults when it came to criminal acts. Children were jailed alongside adults, no matter the crime committed by either. The Puritan Period, which lasted from the mid-1600s to the early 1800s, displayed the most primitive forms of juvenile justice. Children were considered inherently evil, and laws were passed that criminalized normal displays of childhood development. The Massachusetts Stubborn Child Law permitted parents to testify against their own child in the court of law if their child was deemed unruly (Hess, 2013). The child could be put to death if they were sixteen or older. This era can be considered the pre-juvenile justice era. The laws at this time criminalized children acting out or disobeying their parents, incarcerating these children alongside adults in prisons.</p><p>Following the Puritan Period came an era of the first major reform in the realm of juvenile justice: the Refuge Period (Hess, 2013). The thought of this era was almost opposite that of the Puritan era: children were considered inherently good, and must be protected from the criminals of the world (Hess, 2013). During this period, many believed there should be established “separate institutions for youths such as houses of refuge, reform schools and foster homes” (Hess, 2013). Before this time, any child removed from their home despite the reason why, was sheltered in jail cells or prisons with adults and juvenile offenders. The Refuge Period, however, changed that. The New York House of Refuge was established in 1824 (Hess, 2013).</p><p>During the Refuge period emerged the Child Savers, a group of predominantly white, middle-class women who believed that children are inherently good, and “that children’s environments could make them ‘bad’” (Hess, 2013). During the Refuge Period, the YMCA and YWCA both emerged (Hess, 2013).</p><p>With these drastic changes to how the system treated juveniles, it was inevitable that juveniles would soon enjoy their completely exclusive system. And thus emerged the Juvenile Court Period. The first juvenile court was established in 1899 in Cook County, Illinois under the Juvenile Court Act (Hess, 2013). It did not take long for other states to catch on, and “by 1917 juvenile court legislation had been passed in all but three states” (Platt, 2009).</p><p>The road to pass laws to make the juvenile court system make more sense was extensive. Many landmark cases have paved the way for the juvenile court system to make it what we know it as today. In re Gault (1967) established due process for juveniles. The Juvenile Delinquency and Control Act of 1974 removed juveniles officially from adult prisons and granted them separate detention centers. Roper v. Simmons (2005) was the landmark case that led the Supreme Court to abolish the death penalty for juvenile offenders.</p><p>Public opinion has also helped shape how we treat juvenile offenders. Crime rates jumped up in the 1980s, sparking a “get tough on crime” attitude that shifted a mainly-rehabilitative system to a punitive one that came in the form of harsher sentencing for juveniles and more juveniles being tried as adults.</p><h3>WHAT WORKS?</h3><p>When it comes to how we approach juvenile delinquency, it is important to remember that environmental factors, such as living conditions and immediate family members, play an important role in shaping how a child differentiates between right and wrong. Very few people are natural-born killers; most often, a child who has committed a violent act has never had someone teach him or her otherwise. It is because of this sociological standpoint that many methods of juvenile corrections involve some sort of juvenile rehabilitation. Rehabilitation has proven very effective when it comes to preventing juveniles from continuing down a path of criminal behavior.</p><p>Prevention is possibly the most effective method of reducing juvenile recidivism and juvenile delinquency. Preventing a child’s exposure to risk factors and creating positive factors in a child’s life is possibly the most effective way to prevent the child from acting out or mimicking negative or antisocial behavior in the future. Parents who serve as positive role models, and who maintain a safe living space, are vital. When parents know who their child spends time with, they can have a chance at preventing their child from being exposed to potentially dangerous situations. If parents do come under the suspicion that their child is being exposed to drugs, gangs, violence, or other risk factors outside the home, families can intervene and have a chance at preventing future offending.</p><p>Early intervention in the juvenile court system is another effective way to manage and control juvenile delinquency. Edward Humes discussed a variety of cases he witnessed in Southern California in his book, There Are No Children Here. The most successful stories were ones where a child was entered into the juvenile justice system early enough in their development that they were successfully deterred from criminal behavior following some form of rehabilitation (Humes, 1996). Effective early rehabilitation can include mental health services and educational opportunities while detained. Facilitators should search for the reasoning behind a juvenile’s behavior, and seek appropriate treatment methods. Rehabilitation can also be found in group meetings or group therapy, such as the one Carly was a part of during her detention (Humes, 1996). One juvenile detention facility in Washington state provides group therapy and discussion for female offenders who wish to get help with anger management.</p><h3>WHAT DOES NOT WORK?</h3><p>The most prominent example of ineffectiveness in order to reduce recidivism and juvenile delinquency lies in juvenile incarceration. Mandatory sentencing guidelines are causing many juveniles to serve life sentences in harsh prisons. Some juveniles get transferred to adult prisons, many of which are rife with assault, rape, and gang activity. Exposure to this environment typically leads the juvenile to a permanent criminal lifestyle they never give up. For many, gang membership is the only way to get protection in violent territory.</p><p>Lax recommendations, such as unsupervised probation, are ineffective as well. In one case, a juvenile told his probation officer he was in school and making good grades. The probation officer never made an effort to verify the claims. The juvenile was arrested again, and in court is where the probation officer learned the juvenile had not been to school in months (Humes, 1996). In some cases, juvenile offenders were punished more harshly if a judge noticed they had gotten slack probation sentences. Even worse is to do nothing when the juvenile is referred to juvenile court.</p><h3>CAN THERE BE CHANGE?</h3><p>I have several feasible recommendations for change within the juvenile justice system. The budget needs to increase in order to expand staffing, renovate juvenile justice halls and courts, and create more rehabilitative programs. By placing more juveniles in rehabilitative programs, camps, or hospitals to receive appropriate treatment, less juveniles will be placed in detention halls. By limiting juveniles’ exposure to detention facilities can help prevent the juvenile from accepting a negative label established by “doing time.” An extended budget can help expand mental health resources for juveniles, including those who are victims of neglect, abuse, and assault, as well as juveniles who are suffering from mental disorders.</p><p>Another change I propose is to house juvenile victims separately from juvenile offenders. I believe a separate system should be established for juvenile victims to limit exposure to juvenile offenders, but government spending is very limited across the board, so for now I propose simply housing victims separately. Victims should not be lost in the system and should be protected to prevent future delinquency and to promote a positive future.</p><p>Juvenile detention should be based around education, and the primary goal for every juvenile to earn a GED or diploma. Because many juvenile delinquents do not have education extending beyond the 8th grade level, it is important to give these juveniles the tools they will need to succeed after detention (Humes, 1996). The detention environment should shift from one resembling jail to one resembling a school or university in order to prevent labeling juveniles and to promote an academic atmosphere.</p><p>Finally, I believe the foster care system needs to increase the screening process for foster parent applicants. Many juveniles who later committed acts of delinquency had negative experiences within the foster system. Drug addict foster parents as well as neglectful foster parents are far too common. Also, parents found guilty of child endangerment, neglect, access to drugs or drug paraphernalia, abuse, or assault should be punished under harsher sentences. We owe all children a fair chance at life, and children are denied that chance when they have to endure abusive or neglectful parents.</p><p>Our children are our future. Children have a right to justice as well as due process. And while it is important to teach children right from wrong, it is not necessary to punish a child as if he or she were an adult. Because the brain develops until the age of 25, it does not make sense to attempt to punish a child with adult sentences. This does not work. The causes of juvenile delinquency and criminality need to be sought and dealt with on a case-by-case scenario. Humans are not one-size-fits-all, and each juvenile requires a different treatment plan, even those who commit violent acts. There is a reason for nearly all juvenile offending, whether it be a lack of nurturing parents or a history of abuse. It is our job to seek out these reasons, treat them, and allow for these children to flourish into adults who understand right from wrong.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Hess, Karen M., Christine Hess Orthman, and John Paul Wright. <em>Juvenile Justice</em>. 6th ed. Belmont: Wadsworth, 2013. Print.</p><p>Humes, Edward. <em>No Matter How Loud I Shout</em>. New York: Touchstone, 1996. Print.</p><p>Kotlowitz, Alex. <em>There Are No Children Here</em>. New York: Anchor, 1991. Print.</p><p>Platt, Anthony M. <em>The Child Savers: The Invention of Delinquency</em>. 40th</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d8c362a671d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The era of mandatory sentencing, brought to life by the War on Drugs established in the 1970s, has…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/the-era-of-mandatory-sentencing-brought-to-life-by-the-war-on-drugs-established-in-the-1970s-has-24828301da9c?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24828301da9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[opioids]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heroin-epidemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war-on-drugs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Apr 2018 18:03:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-18T18:03:38.939Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The era of mandatory sentencing, brought to life by the War on Drugs established in the 1970s, has done very little to control the drug epidemic in America. The War on Drugs, however, has managed to create a system of mass incarceration, epitomizing the application of disparate treatment for people of color.</p><h3>THE WAR ON DRUGS</h3><p>The War on Drugs was established in the 1970s and sought to administer harsh penalties to those who bought, sold, or used illicit drugs in the United States.</p><p>New York City’s heroin epidemic was fought by the criminal justice system and came as a response to what was seen as an ineffective period where rehabilitation was the primary focus when it came to handling drug addicts (<em>Heroin</em>, 2015). New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller, previously “a champion of drug rehabilitation,” shifted gears in the opposite direction amid public fear and outrage regarding the rampant heroin problem (Mann, 2013). In 1973, the Rockefeller Drug Laws were enacted. These laws created minimum sentencing standards for drug sales, use, and possession.</p><p>Washington, DC, was also clamoring for respite as its population fell to heroin’s grasp. Washington, DC and its policymakers introduced methadone, a synthetic opioid that could reduce withdrawals in heroin addicts. The Department of Corrections began using methadone in treatment programs, treating over 15,000 heroin users during this time (<em>Heroin</em>, 2015). The use of methadone clinics in Washington, DC, brought great success: the crime rate was cut in half during this time (<em>Heroin</em>, 2015). This success, however, was overshadowed by the public’s desire to crack down on drug dealers and users.</p><p>The AIDS crisis of the 1980s only added fuel to the fire. To prevent the further transmission of HIV and AIDS, free needle exchange sites were set up to give heroin addicts access to free, clean hypodermic needles for intravenous use. This program was criticized widely, as the public and some officials deemed heroin addicts as criminals, rather than embracing an effective clinical approach to controlling the spread of AIDS and HIV.</p><p>The War on Drugs exacerbated issues within the inner city. Mass incarceration of drug dealers and users only perpetuates poverty and addiction; by not treating the addiction, the offender will recidivate to support their habit. Also, employment is difficult to obtain when you have a felony drug charge- or have been in prison for an extended period of time.</p><h3>RACIAL DISPARITY IN MASS INCARCERATION OF DRUG OFFENDERS</h3><p>The War on Drugs birthed an age of mandatory sentencing and enhanced sentences for drug offenses. New York’s Rockefeller Drug Laws of 1973 established a mandatory sentence of 15 years to life for the sale or possession of 2 ounces of of illegal drugs including marijuana, heroin, and crack cocaine (Mann, 2013). Many states followed suit and have created their own mandatory sentencing guidelines and three-strike laws, which further punish those with prior convictions.</p><p>It is also important to recognize the effects that sentence enhancements carry. Sentence enhancements automatically increase the mandatory minimum sentence when a crime is committed with specific items or in specific areas. When a crime is committed while the offender is also in possession of a weapon, for example, some states will enhance the sentence, adding more time to be served. Also, if the crime is committed on or near public property (such as a school), more time can be added to the sentence. Prior convictions can also result in additional time served when charged with a new offense.</p><p>Mandatory sentencing and enhanced sentence policies have a racially disparate effect. Sentence enhancements and mandatory terms “increase punishments for traits that Black people are more likely to have or behaviors they are more likely to engage in” (Schlesinger, 2011). Public housing, which houses predominantly Black people, tends to be close to other public buildings, such as schools. This means that offenses committed near public housing are subject to extended time served upon conviction. Also, Black offenders are more likely to commit a crime while also in possession of a weapon. Black offenders are more likely than White offenders to be admitted on weapons charges: 1 in 35 Black offenders are admitted on weapons charges, while 1 in 50 White offenders are admitted on weapons charges (Schlesinger, 2011).</p><p>Mandatory sentencing and sentencing enhancements overall increase the prison population by extending the average time served. Overall, Black and Latino/a offenders are more likely to have mandatory minimum sentences applied than are White offenders with similar convictions (Schlesinger, 2011).</p><p>Mandatory sentencing in regards to drug offenses varies, and the variance can also be attributed to the racial disparity that exists in the mass-incarceration of drug offenders. Mandatory sentencing can vary based on the type of drug involved in the offense. Crack cocaine and powdered cocaine share the same chemical makeup but have a major difference in the mandatory sentencing guidelines. Crack cocaine’s minimum sentencing is much harsher than the sentencing for powdered cocaine. Crack cocaine is primarily used by Black people, while powdered cocaine is primarily used by White people. However, many more Black people are incarcerated on charges related to crack cocaine possession or sales than Whites are for powdered cocaine possession or sales.</p><h3>THE MODERN HEROIN EPIDEMIC, A SHIFTING DEMOGRAPHIC, AND POLICY ALTERATIONS</h3><p>A shift in the demographic of drug addiction has been noted in modern times. Whereas the Black, impoverished population of the 1980s was afflicted with addictions to crack cocaine, the United States has witnessed the reemergence of heroin, predominantly in White, middle-class populations.</p><p>In the 1970s, the criminal justice system tackled the widespread drug epidemic with harsh punishments, extended sentences under mandatory sentencing mandates, and policies that have resulted in the mass incarceration of people of color. Black and Latino/a drug offenders are punished with longer sentences, increased likelihood of pre-trial detention, and an increased likelihood of recidivism following a prison sentence.</p><p>The criminal justice system, faced with a new drug-addicted demographic, has started to implement more rehabilitative measures in order to control heroin’s reemergence in suburban and rural White communities. Many police officers are equipped with and trained to use Narcan, a drug that is used to stop an overdose (<em>Heroin</em>, 2015). More needle exchange sites are being set up by local officials to prevent the spread of HIV and AIDS through intravenous heroin use. In prisons and rehabilitation facilities, heroin addicts are treated with monthly injections of naltrexone. Naltrexone, also known as Vivitrol, is a synthetic opioid that blocks the effects of alcohol or heroin, as well as other opioids.</p><p>Some policymakers claim that a shift from a primarily punitive style of criminal justice to one focused on a more clinical, rehabilitative standpoint is simply because policymakers do not want to make the same mistakes made in the past in regards to drug sentencing. Increased length of drug-related sentences, three strikes laws, and mandatory minimum sentencing has only led to disparate incarceration of people of color, primarily Latino/a and Black populations. Extended sentences for drug-related offenses have also only taken up more space in already-overcrowded prisons.</p><p>Washington, DC, established the positive outcomes that resulted from rehabilitative measures (<em>Heroin</em>, 2015). The criminal justice system should continue to fight drug addiction primarily to combat drugs as a whole. Drug crimes primarily affect low-level users who tend to sell drugs to support their own habit. By reducing addiction, we can begin to get drugs off the street for good. States should begin to see the drug epidemic from a public health perspective, treating it as a disease. Mandatory sentencing should be altered so it does not target specific populations.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Haberman, C. (2015, November 22). Heroin, survivor of War on Drugs, returns with new face. <em>New York Times</em>, pp. 1–5.</p><p><em>Heroin and the War on Drugs</em> [Video file]. (2015). Retrieved from <br> <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000004052651/heroin-and-the-war-on-drugs.html?action=click&amp;gtype=vhs&amp;version=vhs-heading&amp;module=vhs&amp;region=title-area">http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000004052651/heroin-and-the-war-on-drugs.html?action=click&amp;gtype=vhs&amp;version=vhs-heading&amp;module=vhs&amp;region=title-area</a></p><p>Mann, B. (2013, February 14). <em>The drug laws that changed how we punish</em> [Audio file]. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.npr.org/2013/02/14/171822608/the-drug-laws-that-changed-how-we-punish">http://www.npr.org/2013/02/14/171822608/the-drug-laws-that-changed-how-we-punish</a></p><p>Mauer, M. (2009). The changing racial dynamics of the War on Drugs. <em>The Sentencing Project</em>, 1–20.</p><p>Schlesinger, T. (2011). The failure of race neutral policies: How mandatory terms and sentencing enhancements contribute to mass racialized incarceration. <em>Crime and Delinquency</em>, 56–81.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24828301da9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Families of the Forest: Family Planning in the Peruvian Amazon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/families-of-the-forest-family-planning-in-the-peruvian-amazon-3fce4813dea4?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3fce4813dea4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Apr 2018 19:52:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-16T19:52:04.660Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>OVERVIEW</p><p>The Matsigenka of Shimaa are a family level society in that each nuclear family operates without a larger community attachment. A typical single-family home is composed of about 7 or 8 people. The Matsigenka are “reasonably happy” and “well-adapted” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). The Matsigenka’s preference for living apart from a larger community aspect is a symbol of the Matsigenka’s adaptability and resilience. “One adaptive aspect of the family level is that it has to some extent helped them avoid enemies and exploiters” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). The Matsigenka are not heavily interested in being a community and prefer to live as individual, nuclear families (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). This individualist sense “appears to violate the anthropological assumption that ‘individualism’ is a Western cultural bias…” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>The region’s populations living outside the Matsigenka community regard the Matsigenka as violent and deadly (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). The region of rainforest in which they live is referred to widely as Green Hell, insinuating the negative notions held toward the region and its people. The ethnographer reports, “…I kept asking myself what in the name of God I thought I was doing here in the first place” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>When it comes to directions, the Matsigenka do not use cardinal directions such as north and south, but use geographical landmarks for navigation purposes. This methodology of direction is referred to as an “everyday compass,” where the Matsigenka use important landmarks to their daily tasks as points of direction (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>NEEDS AND RESOURCES ASSESSMENT</p><p>The Matsigenka are considered well-adapted and resilient. However, family planning methods within the Matsigenka community is lackluster. The Matsigenka do believe that sexual intercourse can result in a pregnancy. Further, the Matsigenka believe that a single instance of sexual intercourse is “sufficient to cause pregnancy” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). The widely held belief is that if a woman does not wish to become pregnant, then she should abstain from sexual intercourse. However, “whether or not a woman feels ready for the pregnancy, everyone knows that each pregnancy puts her life at risk” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>Family planning aside from abstinence is not formally practiced. There exists an herb, inchapari, that is believed to eliminate any future pregnancies and therefore diminish a woman’s fertility (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). Further, “one or two in ten pregnancies are unwelcomed,” and “one in ten contemplate infanticide” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). A variety of herbs are made into teas or compresses to terminate pregnancies (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>The attitudes towards newborns intertwine with superstition. If a newborn resembles a “demon” at birth, the newborn is killed (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). The Matsigenka also believe that bathing a newborn after birth in near-scalding water prepares the newborn “for the hard life ahead” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999). While many may balk at this idea, consider that Western societies spank newborn babies to “strengthen their lungs” (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>Taking into consideration the understanding that sexual intercourse results in pregnancy, and the 10–20% of Matsigenka women considering infanticide or abortion, one cannot ignore the glaring need for more access to family planning education and resources. Because the Matsigenka have a wide cultural acceptance of individualism and a woman’s choice to control her body, family planning and birth control methods could be administered among Matsigenka women without worrying about a sexual partner, i.e., a husband, urging her to conceive or keep the infant after birth (<em>Families of the Forest</em>, 1999).</p><p>FAMILY PLANNING FOR THE MATSIGENKA</p><p>I propose a family planning program is introduced to the Matsigenka of Shimaa in order to eradicate the need to commit infanticide as a method of family planning. Because there is a wide acceptance of a woman’s body autonomy, that all pregnancies are risky to a woman’s life while carrying the baby and in childbirth, and that it is relatively common and accepted to not want to keep a baby after birth, I have reason to believe family planning methods will be accepted to some extent. “Women in developing countries continue to report an unmet need for family planning” (Townsend, et al, 2010). According to the NIH, “barriers to family planning acceptance include 1) high illiteracy rates, 2) high infant mortality rates, 3) the high economic and social value placed on children in developing countries, and 4) religious beliefs” (Harriman, 1984).</p><p>I propose that family planning be introduced to the Matsigenka through hormonal contraceptives, including long-term methods like hormonal implants that can be effective for up to five years. “A number of processes have profoundly affected the procurement and use of hormonal contraceptive methods in developing countries: a supportive policy environment, evidence-based practice and an increasing diversity of delivery strategies play a significant part in increasing number of contraceptive users and the demand for hormonal contraception” (Townsend, et. al, 2010). Further, “the Millennium Development Goal target of universal access to reproductive health reaffirms the need for contraceptive options as well as access to other key reproductive health services, including safe abortion, to reduce maternal mortality and achieve gender equity” (Townsend, et. al, 2010). Offering contraceptive options to the Matsigenka will help reduce death during childbirth and pregnancy and will offer safe options for terminating unwanted pregnancies.</p><p>FUNDING SOURCES</p><p><em>USAID</em></p><p>“USAID operates family planning and reproductive health programs in more than 30 countries, with a focused effort in 24 priority countries that are mostly in Africa and Southern Asia” (<em>The U.S. Government and International Family Planning &amp; Reproductive Health Efforts</em>, 2017). USAID’s goal is to increase access to un-coerced family planning and reproductive health services worldwide, with many interventions offered including sexual health education and training medical and health workers.</p><p><em>United Nations Population Fund</em></p><p>The UNPF recognizes that women in developing nations who do not wish to conceive lack access to information and services related to family planning. Currently, the UNPF ensures “a steady, reliable supply of quality contraceptives” (Family Planning, 2017). The UNPF is already working on improving women’s access to contraceptives and family planning information as well as offering other resources such as funding assistance and technical assistance to developing countries. The UNPF is the largest purchaser and distributor of contraceptives worldwide, currently.</p><p><em>FHI360</em></p><p>Formerly known as Family Health International, “FHI 360 research and programs enable women, men and youth to make informed decisions about their reproductive and sexual health” (<em>Health</em>, 2017). FHI360 has several health-related initiatives, one of which is called the Contraceptive Technology Innovation Initiative. FHI360 recognizes that over 214 million women in developing countries do not wish to become pregnant but lack the access to effective contraceptive methods. This initiative helps increase access and reduce costs of contraception for women living in developing countries where access is low to nonexistent.</p><p><em>The Bill &amp; Melinda Gates Foundation</em></p><p>“The Bill &amp; Melinda Gates Foundation’s Family Planning program is working to bring access to contraceptive information, services, and supplies to an additional 120 million women and girls in the poorest countries by 2020 without coercion or discrimination, with the longer-term goal of universal access to voluntary family planning” (<em>Family Planning: Strategy Overview</em>, 2017). In general, many women do not use contraceptives due to a lack of available resources or the cost. The Bill &amp; Melinda Gates Foundation seeks to increase access and reduce costs of contraception by supporting the innovation and development of accessible contraceptives.</p><p>WORKS CITED</p><p><em>Families of the Forest: A Psycho-ecological Study of the Matsigenka of the </em><br> <em>Peruvian Amazon</em>. 1999, <a href="http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/anthro/faculty/johnson/">www.sscnet.ucla.edu/anthro/faculty/johnson/</a> <br> ethnography.html. Accessed 4 Dec. 2017.</p><p>“Family Planning.” <em>United Nations Population Fund</em>, 2017, <a href="http://www.unfpa.org/">www.unfpa.org/</a> <br> family-planning. Accessed 14 Dec. 2017.</p><p>“Family Planning: Strategy Overview.” <em>Bill &amp; Melinda Gates Foundation</em>, 2017, <br> <a href="http://www.gatesfoundation.org/What-We-Do/Global-Development/Family-Planning.">www.gatesfoundation.org/What-We-Do/Global-Development/FamilyPlanning.</a> Accessed 10 Dec. 2017.</p><p>Harriman L. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12339668">Family planning in developing nations: a global concern, our concern.</a> J Home Econ. 1984 Spring;76(1):8–12. PubMed PMID: 12339668.</p><p>“Health.” <em>FHI360</em>, 2017, <a href="http://www.fhi360.org/health.">www.fhi360.org/health.</a> Accessed 10 Dec. 2017.</p><p>“The U.S. Government and International Family Planning &amp; Reproductive Health Efforts.” <em>Kaiser Family Foundation</em>, 10 July 2017, <a href="http://www.kff.org/">www.kff.org/</a>global-health-policy/fact-sheet/the-u-s-government-and-international-family-planning-reproductive-health-efforts/ Accessed 14 Dec. 2017.</p><p>Townsend JW, Sitruk-Ware R, Williams K, Askew I, Brill K. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21477681">New strategies for providing hormonal contraception in developing countries.</a> Contraception. 2011 May;83(5):405–9. doi: 10.1016/j.contraception.2010.08.015. Epub 2010 Oct 12. Review. PubMed PMID: 21477681.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3fce4813dea4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Missoula’s Key Players in the Justice System and Ethical Issues]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/missoulas-key-players-in-the-justice-system-and-ethical-issues-f04f0b48483e?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f04f0b48483e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[utilitarianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-rawls]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Apr 2018 01:21:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-16T01:21:44.741Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>INTRODUCTION</p><p>Ethical issues exist at every turn in the criminal justice system, from the very first interaction with police officers who respond to a call and regularly have to make the discretionary decision on whether or not to take action, to the detective who has the decision to investigate a case and recommend the case to the prosecutor, to the prosecutor’s decision to charge someone with a crime and take them to court, to the judge who is faced with a decision of how to rule a case based on the facts and evidence presented at trial. In <em>Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in a College Town</em>, we see the many faces of main actors working to solve cases and, at times, bring assailants to court. But what is more apparent than discretionary decisions are the moral or ethical code each actor personally holds and applies to each situation.</p><p>At face value, the decisions key actors need to make pertaining to ethical theories may seem clean-cut. It may seem that all ethical actions will have similar, if not the same outcomes; after all, aren’t ethical codes derived from similar moral codes? Not exactly. In <em>Missoula</em>, we see Immanuel Kant’s moral code applied by Kirsten Pabst, to the dismay of rape victims and their families, and we see utilitarianism, i.e. consequentialism, applied by the detectives, also to the disapproval of these families and to the offense of the victims reporting heinous crimes. We see Frank Van Valkenburg apply John Rawls’ theory of social justice to attempt to mediate on behalf of not just the rape victims before him but rape victims in college towns across the country, while we see Charles Couture apply Carol Gilligan’s ethics of care for the rape victims attending the school he oversees to attempt to show a side of the justice system that operates outside of the formal criminal justice system.</p><p>In this paper, I will offer a brief explanation of each of the above-mentioned ethical theories, and then I will describe how each of the four main actors in <em>Missoula</em> applied these ethical theories according to their personal moral codes to better understand and evaluate the decisions that were made in the face of the sexual assault issues that plague college campuses across the United States in a society that tends to perpetuate rape culture and the overbearing theme that if one is successful, one can get away with a serious crime with minimal, if any, punishment. Evaluating the ethical codes applied by each key actor is important to help us to understand that even if we do not agree with the decisions and actions made, there is a reason why each actor did what they each felt was the best decision in the face of rampant moral dilemmas.</p><p>THEORIES OF ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE</p><p><em>Immanuel Kant</em></p><p>Immanuel Kant’s theory in relation to criminal justice is one of pure duty as a moral code, as opposed to morality surrounding the greater good. Kant “argued that morality depends on following absolute rules,” regardless of the situation or its outcome (Banks, 2017). This means that when faced with a decision, we are to follow our personal duty above all else; if, for example, we are required to lie in order to get money for medicine that would prevent us from dying, this is immoral. Kant “takes no account of the consequences” (Banks, 2017). Kant lays out a categorical imperative, which means we should “be helpful to people regardless of your particular wants and desires” (Banks, 2017). The categorical imperative is not taking into account any “reference to goodness” and “does not advocate promoting the good of anyone”; according to Kant, a moral action is one that comes from our personal sense of duty and rules and suggested actions involved in that duty (Banks, 2017).</p><p>Kant upholds respect from human dignity regardless of crimes committed. Kant posits that in a situation where we are faced with an aggressor, that we hope the aggressor makes the decision to retreat and learns from his or her own actions and eventually can re-enter society. From a criminal justice standpoint, “respect for human dignity is… signified by fair trials and access to legal advice, ensuring processes of appeal, taking into account mitigating circumstances, and creating prison conditions that do not degrade the individual who has received the just punishment of society already in the form of deprivation of liberty” (Banks, 2017). From this perspective, it can be said that Kant believes that both the victim and the assailant are treated fairly and as humans, and both are respectively given a fair chance at both remediation and rehabilitation, because society already punishes the aggressor through social ostracization and imprisonment.</p><p>Kant’s theory also insists that no matter what, the truth should be told. The truth should not be bent, even if this means that someone who has been harmed will only encounter remediation through altering the truth or the confines of the criminal justice process. No matter the severity of the wrong or the crime committed by one or more assailants, humans should be treated with dignity through fair trials, being given access to fair justice, and treating the accused with “dignity, compassion, and humanity” (Banks, 2017).</p><p><em>Utilitarianism</em></p><p>Utilitarianism is vastly different from the theories of Kant, as it argues we should take into account all the harms and all the benefits to decide what is the most moral action. Utilitarianism, also known as consequentialism, refers to this as the Greatest Happiness Principle. Under utilitarianism, the criminal justice system should seek the outcome that most vastly benefits everyone: the victim, the accused, their respective families, the community, and all others involved in any given situation. The Greatest Happiness Principle “stats that if we have a choice about which action or social policy to follow, we ought to choose the one that will give the best overall consequences for all concerned” (Banks, 2017).</p><p>Under utilitarianism, we can calculate the amount of pleasure and the amount of pain to determine if the action was morally sound through a method Bentham referred to as “hedonistic calculus” (Banks, 2017). Hedonistic calculus takes into account seven elements, which Bentham argues can be given numerical values, which include factors such as the intensity of pain and the duration of the pain and pleasure involved (Banks, 2017). Utilitarianism requires us to “extend our concern to encompass the good effects on all those people affected by our actions” and that we should “try to bring about the greatest balance of good over bad that we can for all people” involved (Banks, 2017).</p><p>There are three major utilitarian propositions to consider. First, right actions produce the greatest amount of good or positive consequences. We take into account the virtue of the consequences and weigh the good actions against the bad. Second, everything, including our personal duties, are irrelevant; we are only accounting for positive and negative consequences of an action. Third, when we calculate positive and negative consequences, “each person’s welfare is equally important, and right actions are those that produce the greatest possible balance of happiness over unhappiness, taking into account each person affected” (Banks, 2017).</p><p><em>John Rawls’ Social Justice</em></p><p>John Rawls has several important theories that relate to ethics in criminal justice and are relevant to <em>Missoula</em>. One is Rawls’ veil of ignorance principle, which contends that each person acts as if they have no standing in society. This means that one “ensures that no one will gain an advantage or suffer a disadvantage because of his or her particular circumstances in society” (Banks, 2017). Rawls has also set forth a group of principles that are referred to as principles of social justice. The two principles are as follows: first, each person has an equal right to basic liberties that are related to that which others enjoy, and second, each person’s inequalities are reasonably expected and open to every person regardless of their position or office (Banks, 2017).</p><p>According to Rawls, a moral person is one who operates beneath the veil of ignorance and seeks to make each person’s position in society one that is as equal to others as possible, with all advantages and disadvantages equally accessible, regardless of a person’s background, situation, position in office, or other standing that may affect a person’s ability or disability. For example, Rawls sees “the inclusion of the Bill of Rights within the United States Constitution as one significant way in which the first principle of justice could be institutionalized in a given society” (Banks, 2017).</p><p><em>Carol Gilligan’s Ethics of Care</em></p><p>Carol Gilligan’s theory of ethics of care is considered a feminist theory that states that women take into account the totality of the circumstances in a given situation and are concerned with maintaining relationships in ethical dilemmas and see each situation case by case, as opposed to men who apply rules fairly and in an “Across-the-board” manner that is impartial (Banks, 2017). According to Gilligan, “women focus on relationships and interdependence and on feelings of empathy and compassion” (Banks, 2017).</p><p>Gilligan’s theory takes into account three levels of developing moral appreciation. The first level is where one sees individual survival as the paramount factor in decision-making, and “moral considerations are relevant only when one’s own needs are in conflict” (Banks, 2017). The second level sees goodness as self-sacrifice, meaning that for one to be considered a good person, one takes care of other people at the sacrifice of oneself. The third level views care of others and the self as universal, and while we do not engage in self-sacrifice, we keep our own best interests in mind along with the best interests and care of those who are in our familial and social groups (Banks, 2017).</p><p>The challenge to the ethic of caring comes with how we care for others, and to what extent, at our own expense. While Noddings argues that caring for starving children in Africa would be unethical under the Ethic of Care because the person’s family would then lack the care in the caregiver’s absence, Held argues that relationships held with everyone, including starving children in Africa can exist and one can remain ethical, and states that not caring for those starving in Africa is itself unethical (Banks, 2017).</p><p>KEY PLAYERS IN <em>MISSOULA</em></p><p><em>Kirsten Pabst</em></p><p>In Missoula, Chief Deputy County Attorney Kirsten Pabst declined to prosecute the case involving Calvin Smith sexually assaulting Kaitlyn Kelly, a fellow student, at University of Montana due to her belief that there was not enough evidence to trigger the probable cause she believed to be required to take the case to trial (Krakauer, 2015). This decision to not prosecute the case can be steeped in the ethical code of Kant, who states that duty trumps personal emotion and to act outside of that purpose of duty is immoral. Pabst did not take into account her position as a woman who could have just the same been a victim of sexual assault when she attended school, or elsewhere in the United States in any given situation and at any given time, given the statistics on sexual assault and rape in the U.S. Pabst also declined to evoke thoughts of how much this may negatively impact either the accused Smith and his family, or Kelly and her family. Pabst acted purely in the line of her own duty to fairly prosecute cases that had probable cause in a jury trial. The duty as prosecutor is to act on behalf of the state and its best interests, and she believed that the state would not win a case that, in her eyes, lacked enough evidence to take to court. In this situation, I can understand Pabst’s ethical decision.</p><p>I, however, cannot stand by Pabst’s decision to act as a character witness for Smith before the University of Montana’s tribunal to decide whether Smith would be expelled for sexually assaulting a Kelly as she slept. This action itself is unethical, because it did not involve her duty as a prosecutor and took her personal time to present herself before the University of Montana staff to describe her personal relationship with Smith and how she did not believe that he committed the act due to a lack of evidence (Krakauer, 2015). Pabst could just as easily not make any appearance and display herself as otherwise impartial to the outcome, as her duty as an actor on behalf of the state of Montana should dictate.</p><p><em>Charles Couture</em></p><p>Charles Couture, Dean of University of Montana, chose to take action as best as he could on Kaitlyn Kelly’s behalf after learning there would be no legal action against Calvin Smith. Couture sent Calvin a letter to notify him that he was engaging in an investigation after learning of the sexual assault that happened at University of Montana, which is a violation of Section V.A. 18 of the University of Montana Student Conduct Code (Krakauer, 2015). Couture decided to work to the maximum of his authority as Dean and arranged a hearing at the school to allow a jury to decide if Smith should at least be expelled from the University of Montana. Further, Couture “disapproved of the county prosecutor’s advocacy on Calvin Smith’s behalf” (Krakauer, 2015).</p><p>Couture operated under Gilligan’s Ethics of Care, despite not himself identifying as female- as Gilligan described her ethical theory. Couture took into account how this would affect his own family and took his own time to seek justice for Kelly after learning she would not see any form of restitution or security that would have been instigated if Pabst took the case to trial for a jury to decide. Couture exhibited caring outside of his family as a moral response to a situation he felt was unjust. According to West, “if a caring response is a moral response, then public life and public decision-making should also include this virtue” (Banks, 2017). “West sees the ethic of care as a morality that should be followed in the judicial system so that justice, compassion, and care go hand in hand” and “expands the boundaries set by Gilligan and others beyond the personal and into the field of public administration, law, and dispute settlement” (Banks, 2017).</p><p><em>Fred Van Valkenburg</em></p><p>Missoula County Attorney Fred Van Valkenburg did not initially operate in a way that served the victims a sense of justice, but by the time the trial for the case of Beau Donaldson came around, he worked on behalf of the state to seek justice for Allison Huguet (Krakauer, 2015). Van Valkenburg questioned the witnesses and Donaldson effectively to seek the maximum of thirty years’ imprisonment at Deer Lodge (Krakauer, 2015). Van Valkenburg was able to question another victim of Donaldson via video chat in the court of law to determine that Donaldson was a repeat offender that could not be rationally believed to change his actions and not rape others without the intervention of the criminal justice system (Krakauer, 2015).</p><p>Van Valkenburg acted under Rawls’ theory of social justice. Rawls theory offers an alternative to utilitarian ideology. The theory that “the business of moral theory” is “to establish fundamental principles that would govern a morally good society” (Banks, 2017). The key point of Rawls’ theory is that society should be served by our actions to be deemed moral. Van Valkenburg eventually took the position to work to have Donaldson tried and sentenced in order to not only gain justice on behalf of his victims but to also prevent future assaults he may commit, especially after Donaldson met with two separate clinical psychologists who maintained that Donaldson claimed his sexual relations were consensual, despite having already pled guilty and admitting guilt (Krakauer, 2015).</p><p>Rawls’ principles state that every person is to have an equal right to basic liberties that mimics that of others, and Van Valkenburg displayed this through offering Donaldson his day in court that all the accused are thus offered in the U.S. Donaldson, being a star football player for a decent collegiate football team that is typically surrounded by fans initially gave Donaldson an advantage not enjoyed by his victims, and Rawls theorizes these advantages should be enjoyed by all, or not by anyone (Banks, 2017). Van Valkenburg questioning Donaldson in the court of law stripped Donaldson once and for all of his heightened status, allowing Huguet and McLaughlin an even chance at finally getting justice for his heinous crimes (Krakauer, 2015).</p><p><em>Detectives of Missoula Police Department: Jamie Maryfield, Connie Brueckner, Guy Baker</em></p><p>The detective of the Missoula Police Department each acted independently when it came to how they handled the accused and the accusers. They each acted under the theory of utilitarianism, however. Detective Brueckner did not take the accounts seriously, because she believed there was not enough evidence to tarnish the accused’s lives in a negative way. She took into account how little evidence there was available in each case brought to her attention and related it to the potential impact it could have on a person’s life, especially considering the small town of Missoula and the media stories that could develop if it was learned that a football player or a freshman out-of-towner was accused of rape by a fellow student. Further, Detective Brueckner considered how the accused’s families would be negatively affected, and ultimately chose not to investigate the cases further based on her personal belief that the accusers were not being truthful.</p><p>On the other hand, Detective Baker also acted as a utilitarian, but felt the benefits of taking the accused to court, even with shaky evidence, outweighed any negatives that could be experienced by the accusing party, Allison Huguet. To Detective Baker, he took into account also the negative impact that could affect the accusers, along with their respective families. Detective Baker also worked to help Huguet feel the strength necessary to take the stand and to follow through with her case through trial, despite the negative experiences she was experiencing socially. This is because he felt that the ends would justify the means- and they did.</p><p><em>Final Thoughts</em></p><p>Reading Missoula was very difficult for me, as a college student, a rape victim, as a mother, and as a person majoring in criminal justice. The criminal justice system is filled with instances at every turn that challenge each actor’s personal beliefs, ideologies, and moral code at all levels, from police officer to the Supreme Court. At first, it was difficult for me to understand the rationale of a prosecutor like Kirsten Pabst to not move forward and prosecute cases, nor did I understand some of the police officers’ or detectives’ decisions not to take the reports seriously and recommend them to the prosecutor for review.</p><p>However, when I apply these ethical principles and codes of morality to each actor, it makes more logical sense as to why they acted as they did. Some instances I will never understand, like Kirsten Pabst’s decision to not prosecute a rape case while also offering herself to serve as an accused’s character witness, or also to leave the state to be a defense attorney for someone accused of rape who in fact admitted his crime. However, this paper was very vital for me personally to wrap my head around what happened to me, while also understanding a feeling of hope knowing that the criminal justice system in the U.S., while far from perfect, operates under typically well-founded discretion and moral codes of many types.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Banks, C. (2017). <em>Criminal Justice Ethics: Theory and Practice.</em> Los Angeles: Sage.</p><p>Krakauer, J. (2015). <em>Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in a College Town.</em> New York: First Anchor.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f04f0b48483e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FOUNDATIONAL PRINCIPLES OF REALISM AND LIBERALISM]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@khristian.vanier/foundational-principles-of-realism-and-liberalism-e090e8198544?source=rss-998cddf6d70a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e090e8198544</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[realism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Khristian Vanier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Apr 2018 01:19:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-18T21:26:29.628Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>While at first it may seem simple to differentiate between realism and liberalism, once we get through the basic foundational principles of each, we see often these guiding ideologies overlapping. Realism is “the view that world politics is driven by competitive self-interest” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 16). Realism assumes human nature itself is competitive; the decisive dynamic among countries is a struggle for power in an effort to preserve, or improve, its military, security, and economic welfare in competition with other countries (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 16). Classic realism states that humans are not rational and have an inherent dark side, so therefore political struggle among humans is an inevitable truth. According to Morgenthau, humans naturally possess a “lust for power” as “ubiquitous empirical fact” and so are destined for conflict with each other as political actors on a global scale (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 16).</p><p>Realists believe it foolish to “trust other countries and their people” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 17). In Leviathan, Hobbes declared that humans have an inherent urge to dominate, which often causes them to “become enemies and…[to] endeavor to destroy or subdue one another” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 17).</p><p>Another fundamental principle of realism is the “zero-sum game,” which means that gain for one state is a loss for other countries. This is because the realist theory suggests states are in competition with one another, so if one gains, the others virtually cannot enjoy the spoils. Further, realism advocates for a realpolitik approach to foreign policy, which is composed of several key components: secure your country’s interests before moving to assisting other countries; achieve an equilibrium in the global power dynamic to prevent a single dominating power from rising up; and keep a mighty defense, because other countries cannot be trusted (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 18). Finally, according to the realpolitik approach, realists believe that countries should not aspire towards endeavors they cannot afford. “A country should never waste its power on peripheral goals, not pursue goals that it does not have the power to achieve” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 18). For example, Morgenthau expressed that the war in Vietnam was an enormous waste of resources “in a tangential area” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 19). Many realist scholars opposed the United States’ invasion of Iraq in 2003, arguing Iraq was not an immediate threat and was peripheral and unnecessary (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 19).</p><p>Liberalism, on the other hand, is an ideology rooted in cooperation, rejecting realists’ contention that politics is inherently a power struggle (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 19). Liberals do not completely dismiss the existence of a power dynamic among humans and between countries, but they add in concepts such as morality, ideology, emotions, habits of cooperation, and altruism as factors that influence behavior of national leaders and global politics as a whole (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 20). Classic liberalism frames humans in an optimistic light in contrast to realists. Rather than believe humans are inherently power-driven and competitive, liberalism believes in a cooperative, altruistic human nature that extends into foreign policy decisions. Contemporary liberals argue that people and their countries can better their existence by joining together to build a cooperative society (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 20).</p><p>The world currently seems at odds with itself, where the United States acts like a realist with neoliberal tendencies; a mostly-realist United States operates with neoliberal policies to connect with other countries to eventually further its own interests. Cooperation exists, but is not altruistic but rather a strategy to secure allies and deals internationally. This combines with the classical realist theory that states work in competition with each other, especially states not involved in allied partnerships cross-globally. What we have in modern times is a global stage, where allied groups of states compete with international governments who in turn also compete with individual states, with each faction seeking different endpoints.</p><p><strong>A.</strong> <strong>Define neorealism and neoliberalism. List three points of difference between them.</strong></p><p>Neorealism, like classic realism, “also portrays politics as a struggle for power, but believes the cause of conflict in the international system is its anarchic structure” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 17). Anarchy in this case refers to the organization of states on a global plane that lacks structure or order. Anarchy exists because the international system is made up of sovereign states with no higher governing power, and differences in issuing authority (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 17). Neorealism assumes states are actually rational actors who can be trusted to act in a predicable way that is similar to power realities in a given situation regardless of who is in office (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 17).</p><p>Neoliberalism surprisingly has some similarities to neorealism, and is how realism and liberalism can overlap. Neoliberalism agrees with neorealism that competition among sovereign states causes conflict. Neoliberals and neorealists agree that the anarchic nature of the international system can be blamed on the fact that the global stage is made up of sovereign actors and no overreaching law or governing body to keep order. The difference that exists in neoliberalism is that scholars contend the system is not as anarchical as neorealists recommend, but is simply “marked by ‘complex interdependence’” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 19). Countries are tied together via trade, social and economic exchanges; both of which increase cooperation and limit conflict (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 20). Complex interdependence promotes increased use of international law and increased international organizations to handle international dealings.</p><p>Neoliberalism and neorealism disagree on the level of anarchy that exists between states in global politics, thus causing a difference also in policy priorities. Neorealists prioritize state security measures while assuming human nature, and therefore political nature, is to achieve power and act competitively. This means that neorealists do not agree with the neoliberal idealist approach that cooperation is desirable, sustainable, and attainable in today’s world. Neorealists contend a zero-sum mindset where the state seeks to gain more than its competitor states.</p><p>Neoliberals believe that human nature is to act cooperatively, and anarchism between states is not as extreme and other states can be trusted to form alliance with the goal of creating an international governing body to diminish said anarchy as countries become more interconnected via trade and other exchanges. This interdependence, to neoliberals, means we can expect humans will behave in a way that promotes cooperation and thus limits conflict. Neoliberal goals are primarily environmental and economic in nature.</p><p><strong>B.</strong> <strong>How does world politics change the environment?</strong></p><p>World politics affects air quality, water quality, the environment, and pressure on resources due to population growth. It took 100,000 years for humans to bring Earth’s population to 1 billion, but only another 200 years to bring the population to 6.6 billion people (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 10). World politics dictates who gets what and how much, but not all states are equal in population, in needs, in environment. World politics essentially decides who will lose out and who will benefit. World politics also can pressure states to heavily industrialize, as we have seen in India’s industrial revolution for example. This intense pressure on production rapidly created several dire environmental issues for India, including rising sea levels and irreparable deforestation.</p><p><strong>C.</strong> <strong>How has war changed over the past century?</strong></p><p>“War, terrorist, and other forms of transnational political violence are in many ways more threatening today than ever before” (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 11). After the 20th century, civilian deaths increased drastically as foreign operations targeted civilians more and more regularly. As many civilians as soldiers were killed during World War II; now, more civilians than soldiers are killed. 85% of everyone killed during wars in the 1980s and 1990s were civilians, according to the United Nations (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 11).</p><p>The 21st century has also rendered more inclusivity in the military ranks, as females become accepted into almost all positions, including previously barred combat roles. The inclusion of more women in more dangerous roles in military operations means service-related deaths of women have and will continue to increase over the next century (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 11). 200,000 women are currently on active duty in the United States, and 61 women have been killed in service in Iraq as of 2006 (Rourke &amp; Boyer, 11).</p><p><strong>SOURCE</strong></p><p>Rourke, John T., and Mark A. Boyer. <em>International Politics: On the World Stage</em>. McGraw-Hill,<br> 2010.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e090e8198544" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>