<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Kim Griest on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Kim Griest on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kimgriest?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 03:28:44 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Natural Superiority of Woman]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/the-natural-superiority-of-woman-9de10f139223?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9de10f139223</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[better-living]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[compassion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 19:53:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-06T19:53:57.320Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Many, if not most, people believe men are superior to women. Some</p><p>will admit this belief, while others will mouth equality, but</p><p>privately, or even unconsciously, believe men are better. However, a</p><p>little thought shows quite clearly that the opposite is, in fact, the</p><p>case. In the world today, women are superior. This article gives the</p><p>argument. While the argument is extremely simple and straightforward,</p><p>some time is spent making it, because most readers will have to fight</p><p>against their lifelong programming. Understanding the superiority of</p><p>women, or rather the superiority of the archetypically female</p><p>qualities, will be a step toward making the world a better place to</p><p>live. This world does not need more women taking on archetypically</p><p>male qualities; rather, value needs to be given to the archetypically</p><p>female qualities. Both men and women need to strive to become more</p><p>womanly.</p><p>For argument’s sake, consider people as having physical, mental, and</p><p>spiritual aspects. First consider the physical, which is the easiest</p><p>to understand, since the point of view described here is commonly</p><p>accepted. Are men physically superior to women? What does that mean?</p><p>Let me be precise. Consider a set of measures of the physical aspect</p><p>of humans; for example weight, strength, height, speed, performance</p><p>in sports, etc. Measure a large number of men and woman on all these</p><p>scales, and find the average of the men and the average of the women.</p><p>I think we can agree that on the majority of such scales, the average</p><p>score of the men will be higher than the average score of the women.</p><p>The average height of men is higher than the average height of women.</p><p>Men are, on average, taller than women, etc. In this precise sense,</p><p>one can then say that men are physically superior to women. Note</p><p>carefully what this statement does not mean. It does not mean that</p><p>all men are physically superior to all women. The tallest person in</p><p>the world may be a woman, and yet the average height of men is still</p><p>greater than the average height of women. Many exceptions can occur</p><p>and not change the conclusions. Anecdotal stories of aunts who are</p><p>incredibly strong do not change the fact that the average strength of</p><p>women is smaller than the average strength of men. Also there are</p><p>certainly some measures of physical capability at which women will</p><p>outrank men. For example, women can survive overboard in icy water</p><p>longer than men (on average). But I am specifically considering the</p><p>results from the majority of the measures of physical prowess. So</p><p>even if there are several ways in which the average woman outperforms</p><p>the average man physically, it will still be true that for the</p><p>majority of physical tests, the average man will rank higher than the</p><p>average woman. So, in this very narrow sense, we probably can agree</p><p>that men are physically superior to women.If you don’t understand the above, or don’t accept the conclusion,</p><p>you don’t need to read the rest of this article. That was the easy</p><p>part.</p><p>Next, consider the mental aspect. I will sidestep this complicated</p><p>issue by just saying that mentally, men and women are about equal.</p><p>ff There are certainly di erences in the way men and women think, but it</p><p>ff does not e ect the argument I am making here.</p><p>So, we turn to the spiritual aspect. By spiritual, I don’t mean</p><p>position in some church or formal religion, but rather the qualities</p><p>usually considered spiritual and associated with the saints, holy</p><p>people, and wise people of all spiritual traditions. These qualities</p><p>include compassion, kindness, empathy, wisdom, peacemaking, self-</p><p>sacrifice, devotion, humility, non-violence, understanding, service</p><p>to others, selflessness, etc. The qualities which indicate lack of</p><p>spiritual achievement include aggressiveness, cruelty, forcing ones</p><p>will over another, etc.</p><p>Now consider a set of such qualities and rank a large number of men</p><p>and women. Thinking over your mother and father, the mothers and</p><p>fathers of your friends, your relatives, the friends you know well, I</p><p>think it is clear that in the large majority of these spiritual</p><p>qualities, the average of the women would be higher than the average</p><p>of the men. And in the anti-spiritual qualities, it should be</p><p>obvious, that the average man would rank higher than the average</p><p>women. Thus, in the precise meaning defined above, one can therefore</p><p>claim that the average woman is spiritually superior to the average</p><p>man. Or in shorthand, that women are spiritually superior to men. A</p><p>moment’s thought should convince anyone with a relatively free mind</p><p>that this statement is no more remarkable than the statement than men</p><p>are stronger than women. As before, be clear that this does not mean</p><p>that all women are more spiritual than all men. It does not mean</p><p>there aren’t any cruel and aggressive women or that there are not</p><p>some men who are more spiritual than almost all women. As before, the</p><p>“most” spiritual person in the world could be a man. Just as in the</p><p>case where the tallest person in the world is a woman, all the</p><p>exceptions are included in the average, and therefore do not change</p><p>the conclusion. Likewise, if for some measures of spirituality, the</p><p>average man is superior, it is still true that for the majority of</p><p>such measures, women will outperform men, and therefore not change</p><p>the conclusion. Again, anecdotal evidence to the contrary does not</p><p>change the conclusion.</p><p>At this point most men and many women violently object. The</p><p>objections come in (at least) two main categories. First are the men</p><p>and women who object in principle to comparison along gender, race,etc. lines. I am, in fact, very sympathetic with these objections.</p><p>This type of comparison tends to polarize people and can lead to</p><p>prejudice, etc. My only justification is that this men vs. women</p><p>comparison is made constantly in our society, with it being</p><p>“understood” that men are superior. The realization that, in fact,</p><p>the opposite is true, may help people become aware of this unspoken</p><p>(and many times spoken) prejudice which pervades our society.</p><p>The other main objection comes from people who actually believe men</p><p>are superior. Many religions categorically state the superiority of</p><p>men, and it is the programming we were given since childhood. The</p><p>objection is raised that the great spiritual leaders have always been</p><p>men, and my answer is that it has always been men who needed</p><p>spiritual guidance and authoritarian leaders to tell them how to</p><p>live. The women instinctively understood the value of the spiritual</p><p>qualities, and while always comprising the majority of the faithful</p><p>in any religion, have never needed as much the dogmatic approach.</p><p>Also, until recently, women were treated as property by men, much as</p><p>slaves used to be treated and as animals are now treated. Also,</p><p>except for rare cases, the male dominated society prevented women</p><p>from taking the spiritual leadership roles they were naturally</p><p>qualified for. This is still, in large part, true today. But</p><p>unfortunately, a strong belief in the superiority of men can not be</p><p>removed by any argument. Many in the south never accepted that</p><p>slavery was wrong.</p><p>The final step in the argument is showing that in today’s world,</p><p>spiritual prowess is far more important than physical prowess. Thus,</p><p>while men may be physically superior, the spiritual superiority of</p><p>women, make them superior overall. So many of the problems of today</p><p>are caused by the anti-spiritual qualities of aggression, greed,</p><p>desire for power, etc. Physical prowess is almost worthless in</p><p>today’s society. Sports serve as an outlet for (mostly) men who need</p><p>to be rewarded for physical prowess (which is after all what they are</p><p>good at). Yet, sports contribute almost nothing to society except</p><p>perhaps an outlet for male anti-spiritual aggressiveness which</p><p>otherwise would turn to war and fighting. One might argue that a</p><p>remnant use of physical prowess is needed in defending one’s state</p><p>against outside armies, but in today’s world of guns and high tech</p><p>weapons even defense does not require great physical ability.</p><p>The lack of need for physical prowess is in stark contrast for the</p><p>need for empathy, kindness, and selfless service, qualities typified</p><p>by a mother raising children. If these spiritual qualities were not</p><p>considered “wimpy” and were given as much importance (and pay, power,</p><p>etc.) as aggressiveness is, the world would have to be a nicer place</p><p>to live. In the business world it is aggressiveness which is praised</p><p>and rewarded, not cooperation and work for the overall good. This isa remnant of a way of thinking which was perhaps appropriate</p><p>thousands of years ago, but today the world is too small to allow one</p><p>group of people to ride roughshod over another. Understanding,</p><p>compassion, and tolerance are the only way we can live together on</p><p>this planet with dwindling resources. Thus it is clear that we need</p><p>leaders, and people in general, to develop and value, what I call</p><p>spiritual qualities. Anti-spiritual qualities need to be quelled, and</p><p>the physical qualities are almost irrelevant.</p><h3>Discussion</h3><p>What is the use of such an argument? Does it make any sense? One simple-</p><p>minded approach is to look back to the evolutionary history of humans.</p><p>ff Thousands of years ago humans faced a di erent world. The male role of</p><p>protector and hunter probably required physical ability, while the</p><p>female role of raising family and maintaining the village life probably</p><p>required empathy, compassion, and the other spiritual qualities. In</p><p>those days the balance was probably reasonable. At some point, the</p><p>physical abilities became less important for the survival of family (as</p><p>farming became prevalent, and society became organized around larger</p><p>units). But the physical superiority of men allowed them to control</p><p>women physically. Being spiritually developed, women took it in stride,</p><p>and continued to raise children with love, kindness, and empathy. This</p><p>pattern was prevalent until the present century. The feminist movement</p><p>of the 20th century recognized how completely unfair the treatment of</p><p>women by men was. It was obvious to many that women were as much human</p><p>as men and should have the same rights as men. (To many men at the time</p><p>this was not obvious, and still is not accepted in many cultures.) This</p><p>recognition, along with many painful struggles, led to the right of</p><p>women to vote, and more recently to a modicum of equality in several</p><p>areas. Since men held (and still hold) almost all power in this world,</p><p>it was clear that gaining equality meant gaining power. The only way</p><p>open to women to gain power was to take on the archetypically male</p><p>characteristics of aggressiveness, competitiveness, heartlessness, etc.</p><p>Thus we see today, large numbers of women who have left their spiritual</p><p>instincts and behave like men. Margaret Thatcher is a good example. Of</p><p>course, similar examples have occurred throughout history, but never in</p><p>such large numbers. With so little value being given to the important</p><p>things in life such as kindness, compassion, and non-violence, it is not</p><p>surprising that modern societies are falling apart. A step toward a</p><p>better society is to realize the superiority of the spiritual qualities,</p><p>and for both men and women to strive to develop them. Accepting the</p><p>superiority of spiritual qualities, will necessarily mean accepting the</p><p>leading role women will have to play in the world. This cannot happen</p><p>while so many people believe men are better than women.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9de10f139223" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I predicted JD Vance as Republican VP pick six months before it happened]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/why-i-predicted-jd-vance-as-republican-vp-pick-six-months-before-it-happened-ced3840fba38?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ced3840fba38</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[libertarianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-2025]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jul 2024 20:09:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-24T20:09:13.659Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why I predicted JD Vance as Republican VP pick six months before it happened</p><p>24 July 2024</p><p>I read JD Vance’s memoir, Hillbilly Elegy, a couple of years ago. I had never heard of him, but as I read I became more and more suspicious of the honesty of the stories in it. By the end, I was convinced that Vance was a lying con-man whose “autobiography” was really just a self-serving political piece full of fabrications.</p><p>For example, the main point of the book is that Vance grew up in rural Appalachia as a poor white boy. He constantly tells stories of how poor Southern white boys like him are discriminated against by Northern Elites.</p><p>But Vance was not born in Kentucky, he was born in a middle class family in Ohio, which, bordering on Canada, is in the Midwest. Vance is definitely a Northerner, through throughout his book he pretends not to be.</p><p>Vance’s parents were also born and grew up in Ohio. Even Vance’s often talked about grandparents lived the vast majority of their lives in Ohio, moving there as young teenagers (his much talked about grandmother (mamaw) moved to Ohio at age 13 and his grandfather at age 16.)</p><p>Vance’s claim to be a a poor white boy from Appalachia comes from some summer vactions spent in Kentucky with cousins. I spent summer vactions with cousins who lived on a farm in rural Oregon. Does that make me a spokesman on the life of a rural farm boy from Oregon?</p><p>Vance went to elite colleges in the North and then moved to California, where he was a protoge of Peter Thiel. Peter Thiel is a conservative libertarian billionnaire who is trying hard to remove democracy in America. You can read about the libertarian billionnaire plans here: <a href="https://kimgriest.medium.com/yes-wealthy-libertarians-really-are-your-problem-46555278d883">https://kimgriest.medium.com/yes-wealthy-libertarians-really-are-your-problem-46555278d883</a></p><p>My favorite writing of Thiel is where he says, in the CATO Institute magazine, that many current problems in America can be traced back to giving women the right to vote in the 1920s. Yes, he really said that, and it is consistent with his and Vance’s goals for America. See the above article.</p><p>After reading Vances “memoir”, I predicted Vance would be picked by the conservative/libertarian billionnaires as a politician. He is an excellent performer, good at conning ordinary people into thinking his lies are genuine and that he one of them; that is, perfect for conservative/libertarian politics. In fact, more than six months before the Republican Convention, I predicted Vance would be chosen as Trump’s VP.</p><p>I didn’t think he would chosen by Trump. Trump is too far along in his dementia to be capable of any subtle strategies. I predicted that the wealthy libertarians who control the Republican party would pick Vance. In fact, many sources say that Vance was pushed hard by Trump’s large donors, especially Thiel, just as I predicted.</p><p>If Trump wins, I now predict that he is likely to become “incapaciated” before the end of his term, allowing Vance to take over. The wealthy liberatians/conservatives want someone who is easily controlled or already aligned with their program to turn the US into a autocracy. Vance has proved himself an excellent liar with a convincing story that can fool people into trusting him, and is also very aligned with project 2025 and the rest of the libertarian agenda described in my article above. For fooling the public, he is the perfect “down home” vice-president for the campaign trail, and when Trump is incapitated or dies, he will be the perfect tool for implementing the libertarian agenda.</p><p>You have been warned! Whether or not Trump wins, project 2025 is just the beginning of the libertarian plan for America. Read my article for more predictions of what is to come, and to see what we can do about it.</p><p><a href="https://kimgriest.medium.com/yes-wealthy-libertarians-really-are-your-problem-46555278d883">https://kimgriest.medium.com/yes-wealthy-libertarians-really-are-your-problem-46555278d883</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ced3840fba38" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Real Reason the American Middle Class is Disappearing]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-901cb78ababf?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/901cb78ababf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[taxes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jan 2024 22:41:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-04T22:41:41.744Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A brief exposition of the ideas in Thomas Piketty’s book, “Capital in the 21st Century”.</h4><p>Kim Griest, version 3: 5 February 2020</p><p>Many people I’ve met have concluded that it is getting harder to “make it” in America. When I was a kid in the 1970’s our neighbor worked as a butcher at a chain grocery store and was able to own a nice house, support his wife and two kids, and live a comfortable life, purely on the basis of wages he received. This was typical in my neighborhood; regular working people without advanced degrees could live well in America. Now, people who work 40 hours/week at a grocery store have no chance of buying a house on their own, and can barely afford rent. What happened?</p><p>Surprisingly, it is fairly well established what happened, and also pretty well understood what needs to be done to bring things back to the state of affairs that existed in the 1970’s and 1980’s. This article explains it.</p><p>Another way of saying, “it is harder to make it”, is that wealth of the middle class in America has shrunk. The cost of houses, cars, college, etc. has risen much more than the wages and wealth of the regular people who make up the middle class. So we need to discuss what determines the wealth of the middle class. It is important to note that throughout almost all of human history there was essentially no middle class. Under monarchy, the basic government system in place for all except the last couple hundred years, the richest 1% to 10% of the people owned basically everything and the bottom 90% of people owned basically nothing. This makes sense in monarchy where, before democracy, the nobility (top 1%-2%) were in complete control of everything and almost everyone else were peasants and serfs. Even during most of the 1800’s and up to eve of World War I, it was a fact that the bottom 90% of people owned almost nothing, and that there was essentially no middle class.</p><p>However, between the two world wars (1914 through 1945) shocks to the system caused the creation of a middle class for the first time in human history. There were many reasons for this, among the most important of which were that many large fortunes were destroyed by the wars and by the stock market crash of 1929, European nations lost their colonies, rebuilding from the wars and the introduction of new technology caused very high economic growth rates, and finally, for one of the few times in human history, extremely high taxes on the wealthy were imposed. Taken together these shocks to the system caused the fraction of wealth owned by the top 1% to drop by a large amount, meaning that the share of wealth owned by people in the middle class became significant for the first time in human history. After WWII, due to high economic growth and high taxes on the wealthy, the middle class wealth continued to increase in size until the 1980’s, when it began to shrink again.</p><h4>Figure 1: The Rise and Fall of the Middle Class</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KGNvnzzwJlM6Sx23DZlHYA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is shown in Figure 1 for the United States from 1962 until today (using data from the WID[1]). If you want to understand the decline in the middle class, it is important to understand this figure. The blue region shows the share of wealth owned by the middle class (defined as American individuals who own more than the 50% poorest Americans, but less than the top 10%, i.e., the middle 40% of America by wealth). In 1962 the middle class owned 28% of the total American wealth, where wealth is defined as the value of financial assets (stocks, etc.) plus non-financial assets (e.g. house and car), minus debts (e.g. mortgage, credit cards, student loans). The middle class share increased yearly, until 1985 when they owned 37% of the total wealth, the largest middle class in American history. Since 1985 the middle class has steadily shrunk, reaching again 28% by 2014 (the last year the WID data set describes).</p><p>This figure shows that our intuitive impression that it is getting harder to make it in America is backed up by hard data. Note, from this same plot, that total wealth of the top 1% (the rich), shown as the magenta region, was decreasing from 1962 until the 1980’s and then started to grow again in exactly the opposite behavior of the middle class. The total wealth of the top 10% excluding the top 1% (the well-off) shown in yellow, shrunk a little during this whole time, but stayed mostly the same. And, the bottom 50% of Americans (poor and/or lower middle class) shown by the red region owned very little in 1964, increasing their share up to 2% in 1985, but then losing even that, today owning less than nothing (meaning the poor/lower middle class have more debts than assets).</p><p>The change from an increasing middle class wealth to a shrinking middle class wealth happened between 1982 and 1988, and is marked by two vertical dashed lines. What happened during these years to make this change happen? Basically, under Reagan, the taxes on the wealthy were radically reduced. Lower taxes are a good thing, right? Nope, it depends on whose taxes are reduced.</p><p>There is an economic law that determines whether the middle class wealth is growing or shrinking. It is just the comparison of two numbers: g, the percentage yearly growth of the economy (very roughly the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) increase), and r, the yearly return on investment of capital (for example, think average yearly percentage yield of a stock market portfolio).</p><p>The law says that if r&lt;g, then the middle class will grow, and if r&gt;g, the middle class will shrink. This law is discussed extensively and shown to be true in Piketty’s book. What happened during and after the world wars caused r&lt;g, so the middle class grew (and the wealth of the rich shrunk). In the 1980’s changes in g and r meant that r&gt;g, so that since then the top 1% own an ever larger share of the wealth, meaning the middle class share of wealth is dropping.</p><p>Thomas Piketty wrote a 600 page book showing this economic law to be true, but it is fairly intuitive. Suppose the economy grows by 3% per year. For simplicity ignore the growth of population (this is covered in detail in Piketty’s book). In general then the total wealth of the country will grow by 3%, meaning on average everyone gets 3% richer; this is related to the famous Libertarian/Republican saying, “A rising tide lifts all boats”, an idea due to the economist Kuznets in the 1950s. This is half the story. But just because people are getting richer on average doesn’t mean that all or even most people are getting richer.</p><p>Next, consider r, and suppose that the after tax yearly return on investment is 7%. Almost all investments are owned by the richest Americans, so the top 1%(and some of the top 10%) get roughly 7% richer each year. If the average is increasing by 3%, but the wealthy get 7%, then each year the top 1% pull ahead of the average by more than 7%-3%=4%. So the SHARE of the total wealth owned by the top 1% will increase, and the share owned by the others will decrease. A relative gain of 4% may not seem like a lot, but if this continues for 28 years, the share owned by the rich will increase by a factor of 3, meaning everyone else’s share shrink by factor of 3. This intuitive argument is over simplified; Piketty’s book contains myriad caveats, uncertainties, other issues, and details, but the basic idea holds even after considering everything in detail.</p><p>From this perspective, it is easy to understand what is happening in Figure 1. The USA started income tax in 1914, and at various times had very large taxes on the wealthy. For example, in the 1940’s and 1950’s, under FDR and Eisenhower, the highest marginal tax rate was over 90% on income over $3 million. This tax rate was often changed but never dropped below 70% until Reagan’s tax cuts in the 1980s. If r was 7% before taxes, but the very wealthy paid 90% tax, that would reduce the real return on investment to less than 1%. Then we would have r&lt;g and the middle class would grow (at the expense of the rich). There are many things that happened between the 1950s and 1985, but this is the most important ingredient to explain why, in Figure 1, the middle class grew until 1985. In the 1980’s, under Reagan, the top tax brackets were removed, so the highest marginal tax rate dropped in 1982, 1987, and 1988, ending up at 28% on income over $62,000. The dates of the Reagan tax reductions are shown by dashed vertical lines and the effect of these changes are easy to see in Figure 1. I mark the changes in highest marginal tax rate in the figure, but other changes in tax law were also very important, e.g. changes in capital gains tax, inheritance tax, etc. all of which went into increasing r. In addition, the US total growth rate, g, which in America was quite high after WWII, dropped during the 1980’s. Without meaningful taxes on the richest Americans, this meant we switched from r&lt;g to r&gt;g, and the middle class started shrinking again back towards 0 (as it was in the 1800&#39;s).</p><p>Figure 1 has the major changes in highest marginal tax rate marked with arrows showing when the changes occurred, along with the president at the time. Note that decreases in top tax rate were made while Republicans were in power, and that the few attempts at increasing these tax rates were made by Democrats. Anyone who cares about preserving and/or increasing the middle class should take note of this fact. The persistent political drive to lower taxes on the wealthy is the main cause shrinking the middle class.</p><p>This economic analysis makes the future of the American middle class very clear. Unless tax rates on the wealthy are increased substantially, r will remain greater than g in the forseeable future. Thus the middle class will continue to shrink and it will be ever harder to “make it” in America.</p><p>Next we ask: “What is the future of the middle class?” History does show us several possibilities. Look at Figures 2 and 3, where five different possibilities are shown.</p><p>First, some people, when presented with the idea of describing the share of total wealth owned by different classes of society, think I am advocating a “true equality”, where everyone has same amount of wealth. This is not true. The left hand pie chart in Figure 2 shows what this would look like. If everybody owned the same amount, the top 1% would own only 1% of the total wealth, shown as the tiny blue portion of the left hand pie chart, and the bottom 50% would own half of everything (shown in purple). This kind of true wealth equality has never existed in human history and would mean that a normal economic market is not operating. It would not be a good idea. I know of no one who advocates true wealth equality, since it doesn’t make economic sense.</p><h4>FIGURE 2: Share of Wealth: What should the goal be?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*xpsJjl7aJJRdryThiquyNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>However, history does show us cases where people are happy, society works well, and capitalism is used in a way more equal than America today. Figure 2 also shows the wealth shares of Scandinavia in the 1970s and 1980s, perhaps the most egalitarian society in history. Here the top 1% and bottom 50% own roughly the same amount, 20% of the total. The middle class (middle 40%) owns roughly the average amount of the entire society (35%), and the top 10% to 1% own 28%. I believe this would be a reasonable goal. If we set up a tax system to make r&lt;g until this goal was met, it would be a large step forward for America. Next consider the USA’s actual past, present, and future as shown in Figure 3.</p><h4>FIGURE 3: Percentage Share of Total Weath: Past, Present, and Likely Future of US inequality.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*OeKLZDksxP5LhrSLyrf44g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The top left pie chart in Figure 3 shows America in 1985, when we had the largest middle class in US history. The size of the middle class then was about the same as the ideal of Figure 2. The biggest difference between the USA in 1985 and the ideal case is that in USA, even in 1985, the bottom 50% owned basically nothing, and the top 10% owned 61%, perhaps a little high.</p><p>The top right pie chart in Figure 3 shows the USA in 2014. We see how the middle class has shrunk and the top 1% have increased their share due to current economic policies (mainly low taxes on the wealthy). Finally the bottom pie chart in Figure 3 shows the USA future if we continue with the current economic policies and don’t raise taxes on the wealthy in order to get r&lt;g. If we continue on our current path, the USA will return to the inequality that existed in 1910, in the 1800’s, and in a typical monarchy, where the bottom 90% of people have nothing, and society is completely owned (and therefore controlled) by the top 10%, with the top 1% owning more than half of everything. The middle class will be gone, as can be seen as the tiny green and purple areas in the bottom pie chart. Continuing out the current trends seen in Figure 1 we could have arrive at this situation in only 20 to 40 years.</p><p>Note that in order to keep this article short and simple, I have left out many details and greatly oversimplified things. Piketty’s book, “Capital in the 21st Century” should be read if you are interested in these things. For example, I used the wage income tax brackets in the figures and discussion, but when considering r (the rate of return on capital), the tax on unearned income, is more important. The extremely wealthy have more unearned income (capital gains, dividends, rents, inheritances, etc.) than earned income (wages), and some of these incomes (e.g. capital gains and dividends) are currently taxed at the extremely low rate of 15% in the USA. Obviously to get r&lt;g, we will need to tax unearned income above a high threshold at the same high rates as wage income. Note that from the 1940’s until the 1970’s the tax rate on large inheritances was nearly 80%, explaining, in part, why the middle class grew, and also showing that large “death taxes” have been an important part of a strong capitalism in America in the past. These certainly should be reinstated.</p><p>Also, I didn’t include the effects of savings rate, spending rates, transfers such as welfare, social security, and unemployment insurance, as well as many, many other effects. There are also very large uncertainties in the data, especially for wealth, since the rich hide huge amounts of money in offshore tax haven accounts which are not included in data coming from public tax records. Again, see Piketty’s book for the size of these effects and much more careful discussion.</p><p>Piketty’s book also offers solutions other than making r&lt;g for the addressing the inequality problem. For instance, a annual progressive wealth tax, of say 1% on assets over $2 million, 2% on assets over $10 million and 3% on assets over $1 billion directly works to decrease the share of wealth owned by the 1%. Such a tax is completely consistent with market capitalism and could be used to reduce taxes for the bottom 99%, as well as pay for health care/education/environment/etc.</p><p>Finally, it should be clear why the information and discussion in this article is not well known. The people in the top 1% have a keen interest in making sure ordinary people in the bottom 99% do not understand that their policies are enriching themselves and shrinking the middle class. Many members of the top 1%, from the time of FDR, have strongly tried to reduce the top tax rates and roll back the New Deal (social security, unemployment insurance, Medicare, public schools, labor unions, etc.). Figure 1 shows why this makes sense: the growth of the middle class came directly from the wealth of the 1%. Since the wealthiest 1% own and control most large corporations, we see that “business friendly” really means policies that help the 1% at the expense of the middle class. Also, since almost all mass media are owned and controlled by the 1%, we almost never see meaningful discussion of these ideas in the mainstream press. So-called liberal media such as the New York Times, Washington Post, CNN, NBC in fact almost always ridicule these ideas as impractical, socialist or even communism, even though they were part of main stream American economic policy from the 1940s through the 1970s, and are a big part of what made America great after WWII. The supposedly liberal media are owned and controlled, of course, by large corporations and the extremely wealthy, so it is not surprising that, like all privately owned entities, they serve the needs of their owners. In my opinion the US mainstream media do a “good cop/bad cop” routine on the American public, with Fox and AM radio playing the bad cop and the “liberal media” playing the good cop, but both conspiring to not let these ideas out. As proof of this, note that in 2016, when Bernie Sanders started outlining some of these ideas, ALL the “liberal” main stream media ignored the ideas, instead focusing on personalities, etc. Fox and the right wing media did focus on the ideas, but only to distort and lie about them, knowing their audience was not very demanding of factual information.</p><p>So it will be a struggle to get these ideas out, and a further struggle to implement them. But, the existence of the middle class depends upon us winning this struggle.</p><h3>Frequently Asked Questions</h3><h4>1. What about people who say high taxes on the wealthy is unfair?</h4><p>There are some rather well educated and well paid people whose job seems to be to stop the ideas above from settling into public consciousness. They often use statistics to “prove” that these ideas are not true and/or unfair. One deceptive way of defending the destruction of the middle class is to use “fairness”, and to claim that the wealthy are already paying more than their share of taxes. They use (true) statistics, such as that the top 1% of American earners pay almost 40% of all federal income taxes, which is more than the entire bottom 90% pay. They then ask, “How can raising taxes on the wealthy be fair?” This is a deceptive trick to fool those who otherwise might be receptive to the arguments I made above. First, there are other taxes besides the federal income tax, and these should be included, and second the wealthy pay a large percentage of the taxes simply because they make a large percentage of the income. For example, including taxes besides federal income taxes, the top 1% pay 24% of total taxes, but get 21% of the total income. That doesn’t seem so unfair. It is even better to use wealth instead of income, in which case the top 1% pay 24% of taxes while owning 37% of the total wealth. This is certainly not unfavorable to the wealthy, especially if one considers disposable income and savings. The average person in the top 1% makes about $2 million dollars per year and has plenty of money to spare after subtracting food, shelter, taxes, and basic living expenses. Thus the wealthy can (and do) save a large fraction of their income, meaning that next year they are even richer. The poor and middle class spend a much larger fraction of their income just surviving and save much less, basically remaining in the same state of wealth. Taken together these facts means that each year the middle class owns a smaller percentage of the total wealth, while the rich get richer, i.e. the middle class wealth, as I defined it above, shrinks. As above, the obvious solution is to increase the tax rate on the wealthy until their share of the total wealth does not increase, or better yet, goes down to what it was in the 1980&#39;s.</p><h4>2. I’ve heard that the middle class is not shrinking, but actually growing and that middle class people are doing better than in the past.</h4><p>A second common deception seen in business pages are “official” reports that say that the middle class is not shrinking, or that if it is, it is actually a good thing. For example, in the Guardian newspaper (April 13, 2019, Richard Reeves) there was an article on an OECD report saying that, yes the middle class is shrinking, but it is because more people are moving into the wealthy class, therefore everyone should stop worrying about the shrinking middle class. The article uses lots of statistics, all of which, while true, have the purpose of fooling people into not seeing or understanding the shrinking of the middle class wealth. The main trick used in this article (and many other business analyses) is to use a seemingly reasonable but deceptive definition of the “middle class”. They define the “size” of the middle class as the fraction of people whose income is between 75% and 200% of the median income. This fraction of people says nothing about how much money these people have relative to the top 1%, so says almost nothing about the growth or shrinking of the wealth of the middle class. Note also that this definition pegs the middle class size to the median income, so even if the median income drops by a large factor, it may have little impact on the “size” of this middle class. For example, the article above states that in the 1980’s the “size” of the middle class was 64% of the total US population, while currently it is 61%, not a very big change. Then, to increase the deception, the article analyzes that small change and says that the 61% is smaller than the 64% because more people are above the 200% threshold than they were in the 1980’s, and thus are “richer”.</p><p>Note that for Piketty’s and our definition of the middle class, the fraction of people in the middle class doesn’t change; it is always the 40% of people who make more than the poorest 50%, but less than the richest 10%. Under our definition, the “size” of the middle class is meaningless. However, the wealth of the middle class dropped from 37% of the total wealth in 1980 to 27% in 2014, clearly shrinking in a bad way. The fraction of income earned by our middle class dropped from 50% in 1982 to 42% in 2014, also representing an important shrinking in middle class earnings. As an example of how bad the OECD definition of middle class is, consider an extreme case of a feudal system where the top 1% (the nobility) earn 95% of the total and the bottom 99% (serfs) earn 5%. One might also suppose in such a society that for the bottom 99%, debts outweigh assets, implying a total wealth of less than zero. In this (artificial) example there is clearly no middle class, since everyone except the top 1% earns and owns almost nothing. However, the size of the middle class by the deceptive definition above, could still be 61%, the same as it actually is today in the US. [Proof: Suppose a total population of 10 million people with a total income of 1 trillion dollars per year, so the top 1% consist of 100,000 people who earn a total of $950 billion per year and the bottom 99% are 9.9 million who earn a total of $50 billion. Thus the top 1% earn $9.5M each on average and the bottom 99% earn $5050 each on average. The OECD definition above uses median income, not average income, so suppose the incomes of the poorest 99% are distributed evenly between $100 and $10000, giving the correct average of $5050, and implying a median income of $5000. Thus members of this “middle class” have incomes between 0.75*5000=$3750 up to 2*5000= $10000. Thus we find the fraction of people in this “middle class” is 0.99(10000–3750)/(10000–100) = 62% of the total, basically the same as today. Thus, this definition says that the size of middle class does not change even if they go from earning roughly 42% of total income as they do today, to earning and owning almost nothing.]</p><p>In conclusion, this deceptive definition of the middle class should not be used. Anyone using it is probably trying to HIDE the actual shrinking of the middle class wealth.</p><h4>3. I thought union busting and shifting jobs to China is what weakened the middle class?</h4><p>Both destruction of unions in the US and transferring of manufacturing jobs overseas are included in the r&gt;g formula. When unions are destroyed workers make less money than when unions are in force. That money lost by workers goes into company profits which are returned to the company’s owners and management in the form of dividends, stock options, and increased stock prices, etc. Thus the return on capital investment, r, increases, meaning r&gt;g is more likely.</p><p>When manufacturing jobs are moved overseas, say to China, this also increases company profits, increasing r. In addition, the money that was going into the US economy now flows to the Chinese economy. Thus the growth that would have gone to the USA goes to China. Thus the American g goes down and the Chinese g goes up. Due to the huge number of jobs transferred to China, China has had g&gt;9% for decades, which has been very good for the Chinese middle class. Lowering g and increasing r, makes r&gt;g more likely and shrinks the US middle class.</p><p>It is possible to address the union busting and job transferring problems directly. In Germany, a law says that 50% of board of director members of large companies must be elected from the employees. The German electronics company, Siemens, could increase its profits by moving manufacturing to China, but when that proposal is brought to the board of directors, the employee members just vote no. So Germany has not lost as many manufacturing jobs as the USA. In addition laws that help destroy unions, such as the so-called “right to work” laws, common throughout the US South and Midwest, could be removed and stronger laws supporting unionization enacted. Alternatively, we could let the wealthy make more money and just tax that money more highly, returning it to ordinary people via socialized health care, expanded free public education including College, etc.</p><h4>4. Suppose the tax changes suggested are not made and middle class wealth continues to shrink. What will that look like?</h4><p>We have a long history of times with no middle class and there are many countries in the world today that have essentially no middle class. So we can see what it was like in those times and what it is like in these places and expect the US in the future to look like those times and places. Actually, finding historically accurate description of average (aka poor) people’s life in the past is difficult; only the wealthy were literate, and the stories were almost entirely written by and for the wealthy. So it is easier to look at third world countries today. In a typical third world country today there are gated areas where the wealthy live protected by guards. The streets are usually dirty and many people live in ramshackle “tiny houses” usually called slums. Most people do not own cars, attend school, have access to health care, clean water, good food, or even have regular jobs. Begging and menial labor are common. The best jobs available to regular (aka non-wealthy) people are as servants to the wealthy. The police are typically corrupt, protect only the wealthy (who buy them off) and prey upon the poor. The government may be a dictatorship or democracy, but corruption means that even in democracies the poor have little to no impact on the government, which serves only the wealthy.</p><p>This is what we should expect the US to be like in the future unless the middle class wealth is protected. Since the middle class shrinks only a few percent per year, we expect the US transition to 3rd world conditions to happen fairly slowly. In fact, this transition started in the 1980’s and is fairly obvious today to anyone paying attention.</p><p>To a middle class person living during the transition it just looks like everything becoming extremely expensive and therefore unaffordable. Technically it happens through inflation, where prices of everything go up faster than wages, and it gets harder and harder to find a good job. So, the current difficulty of affording rent, health care, a new car, paying for college, etc. is just evidence of the shrinking of middle class wealth since the 1980’s caused by r&gt;g. Today many people have to work overtime or several jobs to survive and still can’t afford rent. Expect more of this, more homelessness, more poverty, etc., until most people live in slums and can’t find good work.</p><p>[1] Note: the data from the figures come from the WID, Wealth Inequality Database [<a href="https://wid.world/">https://wid.world</a>] and [http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/capital21c]. The Figure starts in 1962 since that is the earliest data on the middle class listed in the WID, but the increase in wealth owned by the middle class was increasing through the 1940s and 1950s.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=901cb78ababf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[US National Debt: Republicans vs. Democrats]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/us-national-debt-republicans-vs-democrats-44ef6c7c0ec?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44ef6c7c0ec</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Sep 2023 21:07:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-04T20:06:18.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/792/1*Bnf4bzw-4yF2sFvd0Q-CTg.jpeg" /></figure><p>US National Debt: Republicans vs. Democrats</p><p>I keep getting annoyed when libertarians/conservatives say or imply that Republicans would do a better job than Democrats at dealing the US national debt. History shows this is patently false!</p><p>Of course, Republicans like to say this and somehow imply it’s true, but when it comes to economics what matters is not words, but numbers.</p><p>So, I did some calculations using the historical US National Debt numbers from investopedia.com. Starting in 1960, just before JFK was president, the National Debt went from $286 billion to $30.9 trillion at the end of fiscal year 2022. During that 62 years, there were 32 years with a Republican president and 30 years with a Democrat president. Looking at each year, I can calculate that during the 32 Republican years the National Debt increased by an average of 9.7% per year, while during the Democratic president years it increased by only 5.9% per year. Thus, Democrats are roughly twice as good as Republicans at not increasing the debt!</p><p>This, of course, makes complete economic sense. The US debt increases when government spending is larger than government income. Recently, Republicans, more than Democrats, have started/expanded expensive wars of choice (e.g. Iraq) increasing spending. And Republicans have often lowered the taxes on their extremely wealthy friends, thereby reducing government income. It is just common sense that Republicans are worse than Democrats regarding the US National Debt. This is shown in the Figure, where the debt caused by Reagan’s tax cuts stand out.</p><p>Now a yearly Republican increase of 9.7% compared to a Democrat increase of 5.9% might not sound like a big deal, but these numbers add up over 62 years. There are several ways to put this into perspective. The US debt under Republican presidents increased since 1960 by a factor of 19.4, while under Democrat presidents it increased by a factor of 5.6. This is a huge difference.</p><p>That is, if Republicans had been constantly in power since 1961, with their 9.71% yearly debt increase, then the US debt would now be $89 trillion, three times larger than our current $30.9 trillion debt. While if Democrats had been in power that whole time, the debt would be only $10 trillion, $20 trillion less than now! Actually, if Democrats had remained in power that whole time, the US debt might actually be zero, since they would not have lowered taxes on the wealthy so much. Those tax changes, mainly by Reagan (but also Bush and Trump), reduced government income permanently and therefore cause increases in the US debt for all presidents that follow.</p><p><strong>Conclusion:</strong> If you are someone who cares about reducing the US debt, always support Democrats for president, and never support a Republican.</p><p><strong>Frequently Asked Questions:</strong></p><p><strong>Question 1:</strong> Why start in 1960, isn’t that an arbitrary date?</p><p>Answer: I picked the time frame 1960 to present for a few reasons: Before 1914 there was no income tax and so funding the government was very different (mostly tariffs). The Great Depression and World War II were unique times and I wanted to avoid debts caused by those events. Starting in 1960 means I’m covering basically my whole life, and also gives an equal number of Republican and Democratic administrations. That makes comparisons easier and fairer. If one picks a small number of years, then one can get almost any answer you want by cherry picking the dates. So, I wanted a long, continuous (e.g. 62 year span) time span.</p><p><strong>Question 2:</strong> Congress “holds the purse strings”, so aren’t they the ones responsible for the budget and national debt?</p><p>Answer: The budget is always a 3-way compromise between the House, the Senate, and the president. Typically, the process starts with the president sending his requested budget to congress. Then the Senate and House pass their versions of the budget, which often do not agree. Then there is a Senate/House conference committee to work out a compromise. Since the president holds veto power over the budget, he is usually very involved in this compromise, and holds a great deal of power over the final budget.</p><p>I note also that people tend to give the president credit or blame for what happens during their administration. Almost everyone calls the tax cuts on the wealthy done during the Reagan administration, the “Reagan tax cuts”, even though the House and Senate wrote the bill.</p><p>There is also some reason for thinking that, of the three, the president has the most power:</p><p>1. He is a single person, and doesn’t have to find a compromise between 435 House members or 100 senators.</p><p>2. He has a better “bully pulpit”, meaning he can more effectively make his case to the American public.</p><p>3. When a compromise is not found and the budget is not passed it can cause a partial shutdown of the federal government. In the past 50 years this has happened around 11 times. It was usually a conflict between the president and congress. In 9 of those 11 times the president won and got what he wanted, that is, congress caved in to end the shutdown. This has happened under both Republican and Democratic presidents. In the two cases where the president didn’t get exactly what he wanted, it was a compromise in which he still got some of what he wanted. For example, a recent example of such a “non-win” for the president was the shutdown over Trump’s demand for $5.7 billion for his Mexico wall. Eventually congress gave $1.375 billion. Yes, that increased the deficit.</p><p><strong>Question 3: </strong>You mentioned that Republicans have lowered taxes for the wealthy more often than Democrats. I’ve heard that lowering taxes helps the economy, thereby increasing government income and more than paying for tax cuts.</p><p>Answer: This is common misconception often claimed by Republicans, libertarians, and conservatives. It is false. Recent careful research shows that tax cuts for the wealthy have no significant effect on the economy (as measured by the GDP), but do have the effect of transferring wealth from the middle class to the very wealthy (increasing economic inequality). One can see this easily in the Figure, where Reagan’s huge tax cuts for the wealthy in 1981 and 1986 were accompanied by the largest increases in the US National Debt of the past 70 years. This has been shown not only in the USA but in many other nations. For a careful discussion, calculation, and review, you can read the paper by Hope and Limberg, published by Oxford University Press: Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich: <a href="https://academic.oup.com/ser/article/20/2/539/6500315?login=false">https://academic.oup.com/ser/article/20/2/539/6500315?login=false</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44ef6c7c0ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Save the Middle Class]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/save-the-middle-class-914032456cd3?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/914032456cd3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taxation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Jun 2023 21:55:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-12T21:57:09.170Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Kim Griest, 11 June 2023</p><p>Me: The most important thing needed in America today is a huge increase in taxes on the rich.</p><p>Intelligent skeptic: I don’t believe that. First, it is not fair; the rich earned their money through hard work and deserve to keep it. And second what does it matter to me if some people have lots of money?</p><p>Me: The thing you are missing is that the huge amount of wealth that the rich control comes directly from the middle class; that is, as the rich get richer, you and I get poorer.</p><p>Skeptic: Why do you think that? What the rich earn does not affect what I have.</p><p>Me: Wrong! Think of all the stuff in America as a pie: all the houses, land, cars, etc. In normal economics, the share of the pie that anyone owns/controls is determined by their share of the wealth.</p><p>So, as the share owned by the rich increases, the share owned by the middle class must decrease, and if the middle class wants to increase its share, then the rich’s share must go down.</p><p>For the last 40 years, the share of wealth owned by the richest 1% has increased year by year, and the share owned by the middle class (and the entire bottom 90%) has shrunk. Why are those private equity firms buying up all the houses and putting the price of a house out of reach for most middle class people? Why do rents keep rising? Why is homelessness increasing, and why is everything getting more expensive? The amount of stuff is roughly fixed, but if one group has the majority of the money, then they will buy the majority of the stuff, and the rest of us will not be able to afford much.</p><p>Here is this story in a little more detail.</p><p>In the 1800’s and early 1900’s, the rich in America owned almost everything and there was no middle class; the bottom 90% of Americans owned less than 20% of the total wealth. Then, in the 1930s, FDR enacted the New Deal and raised the top tax rate on the wealthy from 25% to over 90% (and the inheritance tax to around 80% on large fortunes). The share of wealth of the richest 1% immediately started dropping.</p><p>Some numbers: The share of wealth owned by top 1% dropped from 44% in 1937 to 28% in 1964. In 1964, the share of wealth owned by the middle class[1] reached 28%, equaling the wealth of the top 1% for the first time in American history. Over time the tax rates on the wealthy were lowered somewhat but never dropped below 70% until the 1980s, and all that time the wealthy continued to lose their share due to high taxes, and the middle class continued to become more wealthy. Finally, in 1984, the top 1% dropped to a wealth share of 24%, and the middle class reached its highest ever wealth percentage of 35%.[2] This is the time many people fondly remember, since the middle class was at its peak, and the average person in America was able to buy a house and live well.</p><p>Skeptic: Why does the tax rate on the wealthy effect total wealth of the middle class so much?</p><p>It is simple economics. The extremely wealthy make most of their money from investments, and the stock market has risen at around 7% per year over the long run. Ordinary people don’t have substantial investments and so depend on wage increases, which are smaller. Think of the pie; if the top 1% get 7% richer each year, and the middle class get less than 7% richer, then the top 1% wealth fraction increases each year, meaning the middle class fraction decreases.</p><p>There are important caveats here, most importantly, the size of the pie can increase. The increase in the size of the pie is roughly measured by the increase of the GDP. If the GDP increases by 5% each year, then the pie gets bigger by around 5%. That means, on average, everyone gets richer by 5%. But if the return on investments is larger than the increase in GDP, then the rich still take a larger share each year. For example, if the top 1% get richer by 7%, then they pull ahead of the middle class by about 7%-5%=2%, and the wealth share of the middle class must shrink (by about 2% per year).</p><p>This logic changes due to taxes which reduce the net increase in wealth of everyone. A nice progressive income tax which taxes the wealthy at a much higher rate is what is needed. For example, if, as under Eisenhower, the tax on income over 3 million dollars is 90% (or 70% under Nixon), then the rich do not pull away, and, in fact, the middle class will gain ground.</p><p>This is exactly what happened between the 1930s and the 1980s. The high tax rate on the rich reduced the effective income of the top 1% and their fraction of the total wealth dropped by about 1.6% per year, while the middle class fraction of wealth increased by about 1% per year.</p><p>Thus, Americans in the early 1980s were the richest middle class in US history. Things changed in the 1980s when the Republicans, under Ronald Reagan, greatly reduced taxes on the wealthy; from 70% to 28%. Immediately, the top 1% started gaining wealth share and the middle class started losing share. Between 1984 and 2014, the top 1% went from owning 24% to owning 36% of the total wealth, and the middle class went from owning 35% to only 26%. That is, since 1984, the top 1% have increased their wealth share by about 1.4% per year, while the middle class share dropped by about 1% per year. America is nearly back to the huge wealth inequality that existed in the 1930s before the New Deal.</p><p>The worst news is that this yearly increase in inequality is continuing today and will continue into the future unless taxes on the wealthy are raised. In fact, it is accelerating since Republicans under Trump further reduced taxes on the wealthy.</p><p>Skeptic: A drop of wealth share by 1% per year does not seem like much to worry about.</p><p>It may not seem like much but if continued over the next 30 years, it means that that the middle class wealth share would shrink to below 20%, back to how it was in the 1920s, while the share of the top 1% would grow to above 50%, thereby bringing us back to the situation before the New Deal. If this happens, then the United States will no longer have a middle class, and the bottom 90% of Americans will basically own nothing.</p><p>Thus, if taxes are not greatly increased on the wealthy, we expect much more homelessness, much more inflation, many more poor people, etc. America is on its way to becoming a nation controlled by a small percentage of extremely rich people. It will be more like an old style feudal society run by a king and the nobility, than a democracy where ordinary people have some say in what happens. Even now, 3 extremely rich billionaires have more wealth than the poorest 50% of Americans[3], and due to that wealth, those 3 individuals have more influence on what happens in America than those other 160 million people. This is what is not fair and needs to be fixed.</p><p>We can look at poor 3rd world nations run by dictators to see what it will soon be like in America, unless taxes on the wealthy are soon increased to 90% (or at least 70%) as they were in the years between the 1940s and 1980s when the middle class was doing well.</p><p>[1] The “middle class” is being defined as the 40% of Americans who earn less than the richest 10% and more than the bottom 50%.</p><p>[2] The numbers given in this article can be mostly found in the World Inequality Database: <a href="https://wid.world/country/usa/">https://wid.world/country/usa/</a></p><p>[3] Wealth here is defined as total assets minus debts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=914032456cd3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Simple Solution to Homelessness and High Inflation: July 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/simple-solution-to-homelessness-and-high-inflation-july-2022-bef9f815c6fc?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bef9f815c6fc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[progressive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[homelessness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inflation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jul 2022 17:48:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-05T23:34:56.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Most people don’t know this, but homelessness and inflation come from the same source. Both come from the reduction in the wealth of the middle and lower classes that has been systematically occurring since the mid 1980s. This hollowing out of the middle class means more and more Americans are becoming poorer and poorer. Though conservatives like to speculate that homelessness is caused by mental illness, drug addiction, and laziness, all careful studies show it is mostly caused by expensive rents and poverty.</p><p>Inflation is normally quoted as the increase in prices as measured by the consumer price index (CPI), but what is important for average people is actually the difference between the increase in prices and the increase in wages. Over most of the years from the 1930s until the 1990s, wage inflation for middle class workers was larger than price inflation, meaning that a middle class person was able to buy more things and so felt richer year by year.</p><p>However, over the past three decades, this trend reversed and prices have risen faster than incomes, meaning that the purchasing power of the middle class has dropped. High price inflation is not so bad if ones wages increase faster, but high price inflation drives people into poverty when wages don’t increase. Thus more and more people can no longer afford their rents, and so become homeless.</p><p>It really is this simple. Here are more details.</p><p>From the 1930s until the late 1980s the middle class became richer year-by-year, then in the 1980s this trend reversed and the middle class wealth has been shrinking year-by-year. What caused this major shift to happen? Here is an article I wrote explaining it in great detail: <a href="https://kimgriest.medium.com/real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-901cb78ababf">https://kimgriest.medium.com/real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-901cb78ababf</a></p><p>In brief, the basic reason is that rich people make most of their money from investments, and when their after-tax return on investments is higher than the general growth of the economy, they take a larger share of the total wealth each year. That extra money going to the wealthy comes directly from the middle class, who then get poorer every year.</p><p>The total value of goods and services produced each year is given roughly by the GDP. If the GDP is not growing much, it means the total amount of wealth in the USA is roughly constant. With a constant size pie, when one group gets richer, some other group must get poorer. With a slowly growing GDP there is a roughly fixed amount of stuff to go around, and by simple economics, people get an amount of that stuff in proportion to the amount of wealth they have. Smaller share of total wealth means less stuff, eventually resulting in poverty and homelessness.</p><p>Americans blamed the great depression on the wealthy and elected FDR as president. The Democrats under FDR put a 90% tax on income over $3 million, and an 80% estate tax rate on large fortunes. That high tax rate reduced the after-tax income of the wealthy to below than the increase in GDP, so each year the total wealth share of the richest Americans fell. As a result, the total wealth share of the middle class increased. All that tax money was used to build the highways, electricity and water infrastructure, national parks, mental hospitals, public housing, libraries, the Food and Drug Administration, the National Science Foundation, etc. That is, that extra tax money was largely spent in ways that benefited the middle class. The wealthy hated this of course, and worked hard to change this tax structure, but even under Nixon, the tax rate on the wealthy never fell below 70%. Finally, the Republicans, under Reagan, got their way and reduced the highest tax rate to below 30%. With these lower taxes, the net return on rich people’s investments became larger than the increase in GDP. Thus, the share of the nation’s wealth owned by the wealthy started increasing year by year. And that meant the wealth of the middle class shrank year by year. Since the 1980s, the increase in GDP has been quite small, so with a roughly fixed amount of stuff, each middle class person gets relatively poorer each year.</p><p>The Republicans fool Americans into not knowing this and continue to lower the taxes on the wealthy; most recently Donald Trumps only legislative “accomplishment” was another lowering of taxes on the wealthy and the large corporations they own.</p><p>As long as this current tax structure continues, the middle class will continue to become poorer year-by-year. Thus, the people at the bottom of the middle class, will continue to move into poverty, and more and more of them will not be able to afford rent. When you can’t afford rent, you become homeless.</p><p>A lowering of the share of wealth of the middle class might sound like an abstract concept. How does this actually feel to a middle class person living through it? It feels like everything getting more expensive, i.e. it feels like high inflation.</p><p>Once you understand the above incontrovertible logic, the solution becomes obvious. All that needs to be done is to return to the tax rates that were in effect in the 1940s under FDR or even the 1970s under Nixon. Then the wealth of the wealthiest 1% will start decreasing year-by-year and the middle class share of wealth will again start increasing. To speed up the recovery of the middle class, one could also add in an actual tax on wealth over say 20 million dollars. Strong enforcement of such a wealth tax would also stop the wealthy from hiding their fortunes in tax havens like the Bahamas.</p><p>Now, many people and many groups offer many different “solutions” to the homeless and inflation problems. Unfortunately, unless those “solutions” increase the wealth of the middle class, they just won’t work. So, if we don’t change the tax structure back to FDR/Nixon rates, the situation will continue to get worse; that is, we can confidently predict that the number of homeless will increase year-by-year until America looks like a third world country, with huge numbers of people living in giant slums and a small plutocracy owning and controlling everything.</p><p>So, homelessness and inflation are simple problems with a simple solution. But the wealthy work very hard to ensure that ordinary people don’t understand this simplicity. Think about it, and don’t get fooled.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bef9f815c6fc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Are People So Weird?]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/why-are-people-so-weird-9e5ae241d2c6?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e5ae241d2c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jan 2022 05:38:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-10T05:38:20.136Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Why Are People So Weird? </strong>Steps Toward Understanding Humans and Their Societies Using Fantasy Bubble Theory, Part 1</h3><p><strong>Kim Griest: January 2022</strong></p><h4><strong>1. Introduction</strong></h4><p>Texas elects a person to its state board of education, who says President Barak Obama is a drug addicted homosexual prostitute. Roughly half of Americans don’t believe in the well proven theories of evolution and global warming. With very strong public support, the USA killed millions of Vietnamese and Iraqis for no apparent reason. People actually think it matters which football team wins the superbowl. For hundreds of years, Americans strongly supported slavery, child labor, and the beating of wives, but now they don’t support any of these things. Family gatherings degenerate into political yelling matches even though the family members clearly love one another. How can one understand these seemingly completely irrational behaviors and beliefs? Fantasy Bubble Theory (FBT) shows us how and why such strange behaviors and beliefs become acceptable and almost unavoidable. FBT shows us that beliefs such as those above naturally arise in human minds and human society, and also tells us what we can do to try and make more rational beliefs more common. In the context of FBT these solutions are easy to understand, but not so easy to implement. But first we need to understand the problem. To become free, one must first accept that one is in prison, and second, to study the cage in some detail.</p><p>The first thing we need is an understanding of how and why human minds come to believe things that are not consistent with reality or stated moral principles. I call this Fantasy Bubble Theory (FBT), though the basic ideas here have been discussed often before under many different names.</p><p>Then we need to understand some basic facts of survival including the food chain, which is a main organizing principle of all life forms, and gives rise to various social structures in human societies. I speculate on how evolution theory, the discovery of agriculture, plus the food chain gave rise to a Power Instability mechanism that explains the most common social structure that humans have used over the past 10,000 years: monarchy/dictatorship/patriarchy.</p><p>Fantasy Bubble Theory, along with the Power Instability, are the basic ingredients needed to understand most of the seemingly weird behavior, societies, and beliefs of humans. For example, I discuss politics, culture, economics, and religion.</p><p>I also discuss solutions to the problems above, and how to make a better society and a happier life.</p><p>In the next Section (2), we give the basic operating principles of Fantasy Bubble Theory, including why they are necessary for human society. In Section 3, we give several simple examples of Fantasy Bubble Theory, explaining why people support sports teams, why we have heroes, why slavery was once acceptable but now is not, and an example of Thanksgiving with the family. In Section 4, we return to the theory, discussing the importance and relevance of the Food Chain. In Section 5 we continue with the theory explaining the Power Instability and why humans tend to organize themselves as patriarchies. Finally in Section 6, we explain how two important human inventions: science and democracy, can counter the tendencies previously discussed: science can be used to improve defective Fantasy Bubbles, and democracy can be used to forcefully redistribute power to prevent patriarchal society organization.</p><h4><strong>2. Fantasy Bubble Theory</strong></h4><p>We all live inside Fantasy Bubbles (FBs). These are really just habits of thinking or stories that we use to organize our sensory inputs and decide how to behave in the world. When faced with any sensory input we interpret it using our habits of thoughts. We cannot see anything clearly because of this.</p><p>Some individuals cannot hear facts about global warming or evolution because of their fantasy bubbles. Racists really believe certain skin colors or nationalities are associated with inferior humans.</p><p>Fantasy bubbles are basically invisible from the inside. You can see another person’s fantasy bubble, especially when it is very different from your own. But it is difficult to believe that you yourself have a distorted view of reality. Pretty much everyone thinks they are a good person and thinks they act in good and reasonable ways. This includes political leaders such as Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin, or the American generals who ordered the killing of Native Americans; they almost certainly believed they were doing something good as they committed atrocities.</p><p>When two people have similar fantasy bubbles the fantasy bubbles easily merge into one larger bubble encompassing both people. People tend to like this, and since their habits of thoughts are similar, they tend to agree on things. This is the human herd nature. We group with people who have similar fantasy bubbles. In fact, the drive to harmonize fantasy bubbles is one of the most powerful human needs, determining much of human actions and culture.</p><p>Fantasy bubbles (FBs) are not fragile like soap bubbles. They are more like transparent protective shields and are nearly indestructible. They come in various degrees of flexibility. If the FB story differs from experienced facts, the bubble can distort a little, but will usually keep the basic world view intact.</p><p>Everyone thinks their world view is correct. This is a result of their FB. We have a drive for consistency in our ideas and thoughts because the world is consistent with itself. A model of the world (fantasy bubble) works better the closer it matches the actual world. Severe inconsistencies with facts can cause a person trouble. Someone whose bubble says the CIA is trying to kill them when they go outside has trouble doing well in this society. But the necessity of living in a FB means that inconvenient facts can be excluded from the FB. And convenient “facts” can easily be fabricated, e.g. Jews or Blacks are evil, the only good Indian is a dead Indian, tobacco does not cause cancer, humans are not causing global warming, etc.</p><p>It might be hard to accept that we all live in a delusion created by our fantasy bubble, but just think back to life in human society several hundred years ago. Slavery was accepted then; the Bible condones it and people throughout Europe and U.S. believed that Black Africans were not really human and so could be forced to be slaves with no moral consequences. The Europeans believed they were good people and lived in a fantasy story about themselves and the world that supported whites owning Africans. This bubble allowed conquering and committing genocide against the Native Americans and much of the less technologically sophisticated world. In those days, girls were not allowed to read and females were the possessions of the males. The fantasy bubble at that time was a story that women were incapable of being doctors, of voting, or holding any positions of power in the world. Pretty much everyone agreed with these stories. We now know that these ideas were false and complete fantasy. Humans also believed that blood-letting cured diseases and that the Sun orbited the Earth. The fantasy bubbles of the past are easy for us to see as such. So why is it hard to accept the societal fantasy bubbles of today? Does the military, the police, the media, and the corporations actually serve the average person or just the very wealthy? The answers to these questions are obvious but just as most people from several hundred years ago couldn’t see that Blacks and women were equally as human as white, male, property owners, most people today can’t see the equally obvious societal fantasy bubbles they live in today.</p><p>Note, that I am not saying that fantasy bubble theory explains all of the behavior of humans and their societies. There is a mountain of work in psychology, sociology, anthropology, philosophy, theology, etc. making models of humans and their society. Workers such as Maslow and Rosenberg have made exhaustive lists of human motivations, and societies in general are very complicated. In particular the “higher” human motivations such as self-actualization, transcendence, beauty, oneness with nature, freedom, and creativity are not obviously part of the simple theory I present here in this introduction. Also, many elements of fantasy bubble theory already exist in the literature of these fields, so it is not really new. I add fantasy bubble theory to these other theories because I’ve found it to be a useful way of organizing and understanding many of the weird things humans and their societies do.</p><h4><strong>2a. Why Fantasy Bubbles Are Necessary</strong></h4><p>Why do we have fantasy bubbles? Because our minds are simply not capable of accurately modeling the world. We have to simplify and approximate, that is, make up a story about the world. Each human being has a few pounds of meat inside their head with a few billion neurons trying to model the entire outside Universe. The Universe is much too complicated to allow a perfect model, or even a good model. It is not surprising to us that a dog or a snail can’t understand how electricity works. Humans’ brains are somewhat more complicated, but still have severe limitations that we are only dimly aware of. In general, our minds have only a few capabilities, and our entire world model must be made from these building blocks. Some fundamental building blocks include: 1) The story (i.e. causality): this causes that, which in turn causes something else. Such a remembered chain of events is a story and stories form the basis of all human reasoning and modeling. 2) Isolation of features: The world can be broken into discrete concepts: body, mind, tree, sky, country, race, etc. Then these pieces can be sewn together in a story. 3) Comparison: items of the same type can be compared for size, age, color, etc. Basically we have only the simplest a&gt;b&gt;c comparison (along with transitivity, etc.). To compare things we have to put then into the same category (i.e. use item 2 above). There are certainly other building blocks of our fantasy bubbles, but you get the idea. Thus, FBs are built entirely of thoughts, emotions, etc. which cannot possibly be completely correct.</p><p>These few building blocks are not sufficient to model the world, so all FBs are only approximate and therefore MUST be wrong in some ways. An obvious and incontrovertible example is the theory of quantum mechanics (QM), one of the most successful scientific theories of all time. In QM a single electron can be in two places simultaneously. No human can understand this intuitively. Things are either here or there. But QM says things are not what the world is made of; QM says the world is made of wave functions, which are in some sense the square root of a probability function. To “understand” QM one must use mathematics. The math that describes QM is not quantum mechanical; it is just symbols written on paper that are manipulated using very simple rules; to make a quantum prediction one writes a single symbol for each electron, then solves the equations mechanistically by rearranging the symbols using classical rules. While the manipulation of the symbols for the quantum wave functions is classical, the meaning is not. Thus we humans can accurately model the world using QM even without an intuitive understanding of it, and thereby create quantum devices such as lasers, superconductors, etc. The process of science has led humans to several realities that are beyond our direct, intuitive, brain-based understanding. Because of this, it seems reasonable that there are many other aspects of the world we live in that humans have difficultly modeling. What we do in these cases is use an approximate model. That approximate model is what I am calling a fantasy bubble. To paraphrase Murial Ruksyser, the world is not made of atoms, it is made of stories.</p><p>Now it should be obvious that some fantasy bubbles are better than others. A model of the world that is a better approximation will allow more accurate predictions of what is coming in the future. If one’s FB did not include the story that it will become cold in the winter, then there would be no storage of food or fuel for the future. Such a person or society would have trouble surviving, and evolution would eventually remove them from the gene pool. Likewise, FBs that more accurately predict the behaviors of the physical world and of other people are very useful. The mathematical theory of QM is part of the collective human fantasy bubble now and allowed the invention of the laser, etc. So, while it is true that all fantasy bubbles are false in some respects, it is also true that some FBs are more useful than others. Thus we turn to understanding what creates and modifies our FBs, and how they interact with each other.</p><h4><strong>2b. Operating Principles of Fantasy Bubbles</strong></h4><p>1.Everyone operates within a Fantasy Bubble (FB) and interprets the world through the distortion caused by their FB. One cannot interact with the world and with other people in the world free of one’s FB. Thus to understand why people act the way they do it is crucial to understand their FBs. A FB is simply a set of stories (thought patterns) that describe the world, one’s self, and one’s relationship to both.</p><p><strong>2.</strong>FBs are not delicate bubbles that easily pop, but are very tough, transparent, protective shields that are difficult and even painful to change. They can be changed, but it takes the right environment or extreme effort to do so. Usually a person’s FB includes the story that they themselves are a good person and that what they do is good. This belief is somewhat independent of an objective description of their behavior.</p><p><strong>3.</strong>People are much more comfortable when they interact with people who have FBs similar to their own. The more similar the FBs, the more comfortable, and the less similar, the less comfortable. Interaction with someone with a very different FB causes distress and can actually be painful.</p><p><strong>4.</strong>When dissimilar FBs interact (e.g. you are talking with someone with very different political opinions) there is a strong force that wants to make the FBs more similar. This is one of the main forces that drives much of human social interaction and human society. There are several ways this can happen as discussed below.</p><p><strong>4a. </strong>Change your fantasy bubble to agree with others. This is difficult because of Operating Principle 2. It is also fairly rare. It happens among scientists when the one scientist presents strong evidence that is more supportive of their FB (scientific theory). It also happens when many people you live among have a similar FB that differs from yours.</p><p><strong>4b. </strong>Try to change the other’s FB to agree with yours. This is also difficult. It happens among scientists and scientifically minded people when your evidence strongly supports your story. It happens when many people share your FB and the other person is somewhat isolated from people with similar FBs.</p><p><strong>4c. </strong>Place the person you disagree with into an “out-group”. A very common fantasy bubble story is the existence of in-groups and out-groups. You and your family, friends, sports teams, and social groups are members of your in-group. These are people you respect and trust and mainly treat well. Because of FB Operating Principle 3 above, the in-group people have large overlaps in their FB stories. One of the easiest modification to one’s FB, is to place certain other people (or objects) into an out-group, resulting in you not caring so much about what they think or what happens to them. This reduces the discomfort caused by the fact that their FB differs from yours. The FB story about out-group people typically is that they are less worthy of respect, somewhat inferior, or even evil. In the later case, your normal moral principles and actions are not necessary for out-group people or objects. Many, if not most, of the evils done by humans to other humans can be understood as being done by in-group people to out-group people.</p><h4><strong>3. Understanding Why People Are So Weird: Simple Examples of Fantasy Bubble Theory</strong></h4><p>Before turning to more theory we give several simple examples of understanding humans and their societies using FB theory.</p><p><strong>3a. Support for Sports Teams</strong></p><p>Many people really believe it is important that their sports team wins the championship. They get upset when their team loses and get angry at the opposing team and at the fans of the opposing team. We can understand these beliefs and behaviors using Fantasy Bubble Theory. Hard core sport fans have created a FB where their team is superior and it is very important that their team win. The FB they live in typically also says that those who support their team are members of an in-group and those that support the opposing team are an out-group. This FB creates a lack of empathy for the opposition team and its supporters and will result in strong emotions when the story of the FB proves false (e.g. their team loses). When their team loses, they think of (often false) reasons why their team lost, struggling to preserve a FB that is in contradiction with evidence. At times, fans of competing teams even get physically violent with each other.</p><p><strong>3b. Heroes of the Past</strong></p><p>Americans believed that Christopher Columbus was a great man for hundreds of years, even though all the best scholarship on the subject (including from his own journals) show that he committed genocide.</p><p>The colonial fantasy bubble was that Europeans were superior people whose destiny was to conquer and oversee the world. Thus Europeans were the in-group and the natives were the out-group and therefore not really human. Even though evidence showed that those FBs were false, almost all Europeans had these ideas as part of their FBs because it was so prevalent. Those Europeans who tried to correct the errors (e.g. the Quakers) were ignored or ostracized. In the late 20thcentury society started to allow the story that Columbus committed genocide and that Native Americans were people who deserved respect, i.e. not part of an out-group. Gradually society’s FB came to be a closer approximation to the historical truth and now it is acceptable to say Columbus committed genocide (though some groups of people in America still have the old FB about Columbus and the Native Americans).</p><p><strong>3c. Slavery</strong></p><p>Looking back at history, how can we understand that the institution of human slavery was accepted by most people throughout most of history, yet, from today’s point of view slavery is viewed as purely evil? Fantasy Bubble Theory explains this easily. Slaves were almost always taken from members of an out-group. The Hebrew Bible explicitly condones taking slaves from conquered peoples, which, almost by definition, would be members of an out-group and therefore not deserving of respect or basic human rights. Of course slave owners were very wealthy people who could use their influence over society to enforce the FB that slavery was acceptable and even good. After the U.S. civil war, slavery was ended and the strong financial motivation for the story that slavery was good also ended. Thus even in the American South, there was room for the FB to change to the obviously correct belief that African-Americans are people who deserve to be respected and have human rights. The resilience of FBs and the difficulty of changing them (FB Operating Principle 2) explains why It took generations for the current FB that African-Americans deserve respect to become dominant, and also why there are still some racists who continue to live in the old FB.</p><p><strong>3d. Thanksgiving with the Family</strong></p><p>Suppose a family gets together every Thanksgiving for a nice meal and visiting with relatives. Everyone enjoys each other’s company and catching up on family news. But at some point politics comes up and suddenly the liberals/Democrats and the conservatives/Republican/Libertarians are arguing loudly. The whole day seems about to be ruined as emotions continue to rise. Why are these people, who clearly love each other and care deeply about each other, suddenly so angry with each other?</p><p>Fantasy Bubble Theory explains this: The two groups live in different and incompatible fantasy bubbles (FBs).</p><p>The liberals/Democrats spend their year with other liberals and so live within a fantasy bubble in which the environment is important, women should have control over their own reproduction, taxes should serve the common good and not just the wealthy, climate change and evolution are real and well established science, etc. Since the people the liberals spend their time with agree, there is a similarity of FBs among all the liberals at Thanksgiving, and so it is comfortable for them to interact and talk politics with the other liberals.</p><p>On the other hand the conservatives/Republicans/Libertarians live inside a different fantasy bubble and spend their time with people who have similar FBs. Spending time of course includes TV, social media, etc. where specific FBs are strongly reinforced. Thus the conservatives think government environmental regulations hurt businesses, abortion is murder, taxes are too high, wealthy people deserve their wealth, climate change and evolution are myths perpetrated by dishonest scientists, etc.</p><p>When these two groups of people interact, their FBs conflict and the differences between these FBs cause discomfort for everyone who is paying attention (FB Operating Principle 3). Then FB Operating Principle 4 comes into play as each person tries to change the FBs that differ from their own. Sometimes, due to love, a liberal may accept a conservative FB story, or a conservative accept a liberal FB story, and this will often reduce the conflict and allow the family gathering to return to peace. However, many times this does not happen. Even worse, the in-group/out-group dynamic may have been operating during the year, causing liberals to have the story that conservatives are the cause of many problems and therefore are not really deserving of respect, and similarly the conservative’s FBs may tell them that the liberals are the source of their problems and not deserving of respect. This kind of FB story often leads to war among nations, and at Thanksgiving can lead to a terrible time being had by all.</p><p><strong>3e. What can be done about fantasy bubble differences?</strong></p><p>What can be done about the problems discussed above? It is not easy, since FBs are invisible to those who live inside them and very resistant to change (FB Operating Principle 2). So, first people must accept that they have a FB which is preventing them from seeing the other’s story. One can, using logic and empathy, explore another’s FB. By delineating the stories that make-up the other’s FB, one can find the source of the discomfort. One can “agree to disagree”, putting the other into a “partial out-group”, where one cares less about their opinion, but also tries to keep some respect/love for them.</p><p>Note, that accepting that someone has a different FB than you, does not mean accepting that their FB is equally good. Some FBs are clearly superior to others. For example, a Flat-earther who thinks the Apollo moon landings were faked clearly needs to change their FB. Making that change, however, will not be easy. Even more difficult to change are FBs that are not fact based, but are based upon perceived moral principles. For example, a racist white supremacist whose FB contains the story that African-Americans are an inferior sort of person clearly needs to change their FB, but in the not too distant past, such racist views were very common, making very strong FBs. However, now-a-days very few people admit to having such views. Society’s current FB, as enforced by TV, media, etc. has strongly pressured most people into having FBs that accept that all humans are basically the same and that racism is not acceptable. Currently most racists deny they are racists since society’s FB says racists are bad, and no one wants to think they are bad. Still remnants of those strong FBs of the past persist in many people.</p><p>Fantasy Bubble Theory operates at the level of individuals and family groups, but it also operates on the scale of large groups of people, such as religions, nations, cultures, and society as a whole. Before discussing these and other examples, there are two more important concepts to consider: The food chain and the power instability.</p><h4><strong>4. The Food Chain: Essential for Survival, but Brutal</strong></h4><p>To understand life on earth, one of the most important concepts is the food chain, also known as the food web. All living beings need energy to run their programs. We will call that needed energy their food. They also need to reproduce, which in most cases involves sex. So food and sex are the two most important ingredients of life, and it is not surprising that these things play outsized roles in the lives of pretty much all living beings.</p><p>The food chain is one of the most important and under-appreciated aspects of life. At the most basic level life consists of an individual that gets energy from somewhere outside itself and then uses that energy to run its “program”. This “program” is basically to survive and reproduce, but also includes everything that any living being is doing; for example, all of a given human’s activity is its “program”.</p><p>So, plants, at the base of the food chain, get energy from the Sun and through photosynthesis they turn sunlight (along with water, CO2, and minerals) into carbohydrates and cellulose, which are used to run their programs, that is to grow, build their bodies, and reproduce. The carbohydrates store chemical energy, and the plant bodies store carbon and other minerals, so animals eat plants in order to obtain that energy and those minerals and to run their programs (again to grow, move about, reproduce, etc.). Animals higher up the food chain, hunt and eat other animals to obtain the energy, minerals, and proteins they use to run their programs in turn. Mosquitoes suck the blood of mammals to get the energy to lay their eggs. Thus all living beings obtain the energy and materials to live on from outside themselves, and we call this process “eating”.</p><p>The idea can be extended to human beings. Humans certainly eat food to get energy to run their programs. They might find or grow plants or hunt animals, like other animals do. But in modern society they more likely have a job which gives them money which, in turn, is used to purchase those plants and animals for eating. Thus, money is a form of energy, and people getting money from other people can be said to be part of the food chain. Note humans also eat in order to grow and reproduce, but typically include many other activities in their “program”. For example acquiring stuff, gathering power, fame, wealth, status, etc.</p><p>The food chain is thus the basis for life and it controls who eats whom. In some sense the food chain should be considered “sacred”, since without it all life would cease. One doesn’t complain when a lion eats a deer, or when a bunny eats some grass, though in both cases eating involves killing another life form. The food chain is about killing. People like to put morality into killing and causing suffering for others, but somehow anything involved in the food chain is exempt from this morality. In this sense actions that are part of the food chain are “sacred”. One cannot understand life without accepting this brutality. Of course, we all do accept it at some level. When a lion kills a deer or a big fish eats a small fish, we may not want to watch, but we accept it. Thus the food chain must be respected.</p><p>In this way of looking at the food chain, humans trying to get money from other humans is the food chain in action. Money is not food, but is used to get food, and more importantly it is the energy needed to run each human’s “program”.</p><p>For most plants and animals the “program” run using the energy obtained from outside is set by their DNA. I guess the same is true for humans, but certainly there is a huge variety in the “programs” humans run. Grow, move around, eat, and reproduce suffices for many animals, but humans also seem to want to increase their power over other humans and the environment. They want fame and status among other humans. And they want wealth in amounts far more than they can really use. I guess other “pack” animals, such as wolves, bison, or crows also have “increasing status” as part of their programs, e.g. becoming the alpha member of a wolf pack.</p><p>In this way of looking at it, when a thief steals your money, it is part of the food chain. The thief is above you on the food chain, and you are the thief’s “food source”. The entire complex relation of economics in society can be viewed as part of the human food chain. This way of looking at things is helpful, since when a salesman is trying to get you to buy insurance or solar energy panels, you can realize that he is looking at you as a “food source”, and take appropriate action. When a deer sees a lion coming after it, it knows what to do: run like crazy. But much of what happens in human society is based upon deception, so the salesman tries to pretend that they are your friend, or the advertisement tries to make you think you will be happier if you give your money to the company. When you see the salesman and the advertisement as entities above you on the food chain, you know what to do. Run like crazy!</p><p>The food chain idea helps one understand human society and one’s place in it. Of course, animals like wolves hunt together in packs and then share the food they kill. Humans also do this. So it is not the case that all human actions are predator/prey relationships. But many are!</p><p>Given this, what should we think about a person who robs another person for their money? A person taking money from another is just getting energy to run their program, so in that sense it is part of that person’s food chain. But unlike a lion hunting a deer, a person usually has several choices on how to get the money to run their program, and also has choices about what program to run. Society creates rules (aka collective fantasy bubbles) about what energy a person is allowed to take. It is ok to take remuneration for working at a job, inheriting from a parent, or winning the lottery, but it is not ok to take money by robbing, counterfeiting, etc.</p><p>The essence of these modern “eating” rules seems to be to minimize suffering to the other humans. In the past it was ok to get money through slavery, war, etc., but luckily, now most believe these parts of the food chain are evil. Of course, some suffering is necessary; it takes work to grow food to eat, or to do a job you don’t like, so it is always a judgment call as to what means of obtaining the energy and minerals to run your program are acceptable. It is also a judgment call as to what “programs” are acceptable.</p><p>So, morality enters the food chain when there are choices or options on how to obtain the necessary energy. Cats must eat meat or they will suffer, so there is no option there, but humans are omnivores and have a choice. Thus many believe that eating plants rather than animals is morally superior. This reduces suffering, one of the main moral guidelines. But others believe differently; for instance that humans have always eaten meat and therefore should be grouped with mosquitoes and lions that cannot survive without getting energy from other animal’s flesh or blood.</p><p><strong>Status in the Social Hierarchy<br></strong>A main part of the “human program” aka “human food chain” is trying to obtain status in the social hierarchy. This is the human equivalent of bison or wolves fighting to be the alpha in a herd or pack.</p><p>Humans use all sorts of ways to move up the social hierarchy. The top of the hierarchy is the emperor or monarch or dictator or president or CEO, etc. depending on the organization under consideration. For almost all of the past 10,000 years (since the invention of agriculture and animal herding) the basic human power structure has been a patriarchy, with a single man at the top, and a group of nobles/advisors/board members below him, and some form of military/police entity to ensure continued power of the patriarch.</p><p>Why do humans organize themselves this way? How do these patriarchies come about and how are they then maintained? Fantasy Bubble Theory can explain it, but we need one more topic first: the power instability.</p><h4><strong>5. The Power Instability</strong></h4><p>It is important to recognize the power instability as a primary organizing principle in human societies. In any group of humans, some will have more power and wealth than others, and almost always they will use that power and wealth to maintain and gather more power and wealth. The original imbalance in power can come about in several ways: differences in physical, mental, or societal abilities, parentage, hard work, chance, etc. One might hope that those with more power would share it with others, but experience shows that humans with more power and wealth almost always want to keep that extra power and wealth and also to increase it. This desire seems to be a basic part of human nature, probably coming from our human pack nature operating in service of the food chain. Even if not every human has the desire for more power and wealth, as long as a few do and are willing to work hard to acquire it, then those who want it will end up with more.</p><p>Thus any excess of power and wealth, even if originally small, can be used to get more power and wealth, and then that extra power can be used to get even more. This continues until something stops it. If nothing stops it then eventually all the power and wealth ends up in the control of just one (or a few) humans in the group. We call that person the tribal chief, the warlord, the gang leader, the duke, the king, the dictator, the oligarch, the monarch, the communist party chairman, the CEO of the corporation, the president, etc. In science, this type of runaway situation is quite common and is called an <strong>exponential instability</strong>. For example, think of a pencil delicately balanced on its tip. An initially small imbalance is amplified into a larger imbalance, which causes even more imbalance, eventually reaching some end state, in this case the pencil falling over onto its side. In humans, I called this process, where an initial small difference in power/wealth becomes ever larger, the Power Instability. This tendency seems to always be present in a group of people and usually results in a hierarchical power structure in that group.</p><p>History shows that this hierarchical power/money structure is extremely common throughout human history, and it is quite stable. Anyone attempting to redistribute the money or power can usually be stopped by the superior money and power of the leader. However, even within such a power hierarchy the power instability is still operating. One king cannot be everywhere at all times and so must delegate authority to helpers. If these helpers have the chance they will try and take the power from the king. And these helpers must also delegate some of their power to nobility lower in the hierarchy, and so on. Thus assassination of kings, courtly drama, etc. is very common throughout history. Kings and nobility, of course, know this and try all sorts of ways to stop this and to keep their power. Fantasy bubbles have been a major player in this strategy throughout history. If the FBs of the people lower down in the hierarchy contain the belief that the king should be in power, they are more likely to resist their own belief in equality and support the king. Thus loyalty is an important part of many fantasy bubbles. In addition, if they think the king’s helpers and the nobility are somehow superior humans, they will again resist the natural power instability tendencies that make them want to take power away from the nobility.</p><p>Thus throughout human history we find that the main stories told in most societies are of the worthiness of kings and the nobility and the need to be loyal to them. The story the king would most like to have in the fantasy bubbles of his subjects is that he is divine. Thus the pharaohs of Ancient Egypt, the Mayan Kings, Gilgamesh in Sumeria, Rama and Krishna of the Hindus, were all considered divine beings. Next best would be a belief that the king that was divinely appointed by God, e.g. King David in the Hebrew Bible, King Author, Charlemagne, Louis XVII of France, and most kings throughout history, even through modern times. If society’s fantasy bubble says the king is God or is appointed by God, there is less chance someone will try and topple him. So nobility, throughout human history, worked very hard to create stories about how their “noble blood” was somehow superior. Even today, these stories are extremely popular in fiction, where certain bloodlines give a person special properties, i.e. make them a special in-group. Thus for thousands of years most societies demanded fantasy bubbles that included the story of the superiority of the king and the nobility. Given how difficult it is to change FBs, it is not surprising to see that such beliefs are still common today even though democracy has replaced simplistic patriarchy in many nations. It is also not surprising that many people, even in democracies, actually believe that certain people are superior.</p><p>Note that the power instability also operates on levels below the nation state. In any group, a small initial power difference will be magnified as the more powerful individuals use their power to increase their power. One can see this operating in almost any group of people, from teams at work, church groups, sports teams, non-profit organizations, etc.</p><h4><strong>6. Democracy and Science to the Rescue</strong></h4><p>The discussion of the near inevitability of patriarchal power structures due to the power instability and the food chain discussed above might leave one feeling discouraged. But humans have come up with possible solutions to both this problem and to the problem of bad fantasy bubbles in general. The main solution to the power instability is democracy, where societies periodically remove the power of the leader by force, returning it to the people via elections, who then pick a new leader. And the fundamental problem of horrible fantasy bubbles created by the food chain and power instability can be solved using the human invention of science. In science, fantasy bubbles (aka scientific theories) are compared with factual evidence and rejected when found lacking. Thus over time science causes society’s fantasy bubble to become a better and better approximation of reality.</p><p><strong>6a. Science: How To Improve Fantasy Bubbles</strong></p><p>Science is one of the most amazing human inventions of the past thousand years. Science is a method which can force the collective fantasy bubble into closer agreement with reality. Recall (FB Operating Principle 4) that there is an intrinsic psychological force in humans to coalesce their individual fantasy bubbles into a semi-coherent group FB. We discussed earlier that these collective FB are what we call religions, philosophies, and cultural norms. The variety of beliefs that human societies are capable of is truly amazing. History shows us that societies have many ways of enforcing this coalescence of FBs, from shaming, loss of status, banishment, laws, and even violence against non-believers.</p><p>As discussed, the collective FB gives rise to human society and the set of commonly accepted beliefs each society has. It is nearly impossible for an individual in a society to strongly contradict the collective FB. However, science has shown many times that it can contradict and, over time, shift the collective FB, even in the face of extreme opposition.</p><p>In science, a hypothesis is formed to explain some phenomena which happen repeatedly in the world. This hypothesis is called a “scientific theory”, aka a fantasy bubble. Then when the phenomena happen again, the prediction of the theory is compared to the actual measured evidence (aka facts). Then, if the facts disagree with the theory, the theory is said to be “proved false”, and must be rejected. That is, the hypothesis, aka FB, must be changed, and a new, modified theory proposed. When the phenomena happen yet again, yet again a comparison is made and yet again the FB is changed if there is disagreement. This cycle continues until the facts match the theory. This scientific theory then is NOT disproved and joins the body of knowledge called “science”. Note that a scientific theory can never be proved true, it can only not be disproved. This set of theories makes up the fantasy bubble of the scientists, and according to the scientists, is always subject to change if facts arise that don’t match the theory.</p><p>The method above of creating a scientific fantasy bubble is not written into law anywhere; the people contributing to the scientific endeavor just all “buy into” it, that is, live within a FB that includes the story above. The society of scientists hold the scientific procedure very dear and rejects anyone who doesn’t follow it. If a scientist tries to keep his theory, by say, distorting a few measurements, that scientist is publically shamed and will never again be trusted. Scientists live in fear of making a mistake and being accused of faking or distorting data. This strong scientist fantasy bubble is what holds the whole subject of science together. To publish a scientific result, other scientists must first check the work for distortions or dishonesty. It is a kind of democracy where all the scientists collectively ensure that the basic scientific method (FB) is obeyed. There is no central authority, though individuals who are successful in creating accurate scientific theories are held in greater regard and their opinions carry more weight.</p><p>The value of the scientific FB is that, once created, it will be a better approximation of reality than any other FB. No amount of argument, money, or force will be able to create a better FB. So, as long as the scientific community holds onto its values, the scientific FB will eventually win. This is true even in the face of strong opposition from powerful people and when the new scientific FB contradicts the current society FB.</p><p>Classic cases of this include the heliocentric astronomical system which went directly against the geocentric fantasy bubble of the time. The power holders of the day, including the main religious institutions, fought very strongly against this new “Earth goes around Sun” FB theory, even threatening Galileo with torture. But the new scientific theory agreed with the facts, and by the rules of science, theories can’t be changed just to agree with powerful men. So after around 100 years of battling (yes it took that long!), scientists won, and the collective FB of how the Solar System works became identical to the scientific FB, with even the Catholic Church FB changing.</p><p>Other examples include the germ theory of disease as opposed to the evil spirits or God’s wrath theory of disease. More recently the hundreds-of-year-old practice of smoking tobacco was shown by science to cause cancer. Powerful men, politicians, and large corporations fought aggressively against changing the then current fantasy bubble that smoking was cool and desirable. Again, it took 50 years, but because science is so persistent and because it agrees better with reality, eventually we arrived at the current fantasy bubble where almost everyone agrees cigarettes cause cancer.</p><p>Science’s forceful changing of collective FBs can still be seen in action today in many areas. For example, the theory of evolution is gradually taking over from the “God created us” theory in the face of incredible resistance from most of the major world religions. And in most of the world, the theory of human induced Global Warming has joined the collective FB, against the concerted efforts of many of the world’s most powerful corporations and richest men. We also see evidence based history gradually changing the traditional belief that colonialism was beneficial to the conquered natives, to a more accurate belief that it was mostly just genocide.</p><p>Note, that the creation of scientific FBs in no way says that scientists are somehow better or even different than other humans. Scientists strongly resist it when new theories challenge their old ones. There was tremendous resistance among scientists when Einstein’s theory of gravity said that the Newtonian theory was not completely correct and needed to be abandoned. Even stronger resistance was given to the new theory of quantum mechanics. But, in both cases, experiments showed the new theories agreed better with the evidence, and so over time the scientific community changed its fantasy bubble. The result of these newer, more accurate FBs was the amazing technology that resulted from the better theories: GPS, lasers, transistors, MRI, X-rays, etc.</p><p>One might ask, given the enormous power of the collective FB against new scientific theories, why has science not become like every other human endeavor and become susceptible to manipulation and “fashion” by the powerful men in science and in society? Why didn’t the normal power instability result in a few men coming into control of science and causing the science FB to lose its basic fact-matching methodology? The answer to this question is not clear to me. I am surprised how successful science has been and how over the past few hundred years it has changed so much of the collective FB.</p><p>Perhaps science’s success was just luck. The collective FBs that science changed might not have been that important to the rulers, compared to the powerful inventions the scientific FB enabled. For example, science gave humans radio, electronics, disease cures, atomic bombs, etc. Perhaps, the powerful men who ran society saw, through direct examples, the power of having a scientific FB that gave a more accurate description of reality and allowed manipulation of the physical world. The loss of the competing non-scientific FB was perhaps not too high a price to pay, since the science FB did not directly challenge their power. Note, that if this is the case, science may be abandoned by humans once it stops giving important inventions or does challenge actual power. For example, many don’t believe in human induced global warming because, unlike many scientific discoveries of the past, it does not help them make more money. Physicists note that society’s support for enormously expensive particle accelerators is dropping rapidly. Past support has been hypothesized to be because these same physicists invented the atomic bomb, and the rulers were afraid to stop supporting science and so perhaps miss the next such invention. As nuclear physics and particle physics becomes less relevant to everyday life, this hypothesis says that public (and private) support for fundamental science may drop. In which case, one might expect much of science to eventually be dropped by society and for society to revert to FBs that are far from reality (as humans often did in the past). The basic science needed to create useful machines would be retained in the collective FB, but research into subjects that are not useful for the powerful might be dropped and go unfunded. Alternatively, perhaps science’s success was not just due to luck; perhaps the answer is related to our next topic: democracy.</p><p><strong>6b. Democracy: The Forceful Redistribution of Power</strong></p><p>As discussed above, normal human nature gives rise to what I’ve called the power instability, which usually results in patriarchy, where almost all the power lies in the hands of a king, emperor, dictator, party chainman, etc. In this case, the majority of people live in substantially worse conditions than those with the money and power. This strikes the average person as unfair, and throughout history various attempts have been made to redistribute the power and money to make things more equitable. Apart from the last few centuries, these attempts were usually failures. The superior power of the nobility and patriarch was wielded to destroy any attempts at revolution, and when a revolution succeeded, the winners usually just established a new patriarchy with themselves as the rulers.</p><p>But, several times this attempt at power redistribution succeeded, and by far the most successful result has been the democratic form of government common throughout the world today. In a constitutional democracy, the rules of power transfer are written in a document, the constitution, which specifies that periodically the power of the leader is forcefully removed and given to the citizens in the form of an election for a new leader. Somehow, this piece of paper directly confronts and defuses the power instability described above. Karl Marx’s communism of the late 1800’s and early 1900’s had basically the same goal, but failed miserably at giving power to ordinary people. Why has democracy succeeded where no other system has? The answer is not clear to me, but here are several thoughts.</p><p>First, after a constitution is accepted, a very strong societal fantasy bubble is created that constitutional democracy is superior to monarchy, dictatorship, etc. People living in democracy believe that they should have rights and that the government should serve them, not just the wealthy and powerful. This fantasy bubble largely replaces the older FB where the nobility were superior to the commoners and so deserved to rule over everyone. Because of this strong FB, the people as a whole continually fight to ensure that no leader refuses to honor the constitution. Any leader wanting to take permanent power would need to confront this strong fantasy bubble. Of course, there are many of examples of leaders doing just this successfully and then taking power; Adolf Hitler winning public support by saying a strong leader is needed to fight the Jews, then winning elections, and then taking all the power, quickly comes to mind.</p><p>Second, in the USA and other democracies, a system of checks and balances is set up, so that at no time does the most powerful person (president or prime minister) hold all the power. In the USA, the Congress controls the money and writes the laws, while the Supreme Court enforces consistency with the Constitution.</p><p>However, it is important to remember that within all human societies, including both democracy and idealistic communism, the power/money instability still exists. The powerful and rich are always working to find ways to increase their power and wealth. Thus communist countries all became totalitarian dictatorships with the party chairman taking all the power. And many attempted democracies have reverted to dictatorships when democratically elected heads of state refuse to give up power, or when powerful people within the society manage a coup. Even within working democracies, the wealthy find ways to get more than their share of power. For example, while the U.S. and European nations have managed to avoid reverting to the natural human organization (dictatorship), the power/wealth instability is still strongly at work, with the richest 400 people in the U.S. having more wealth than the bottom 180 million. Thus the 1% richest of Americans have almost all the power. Actually it is the top 0.1% or 0.01% that really have a disproportionate amount of the money and power. We note that in almost all societies throughout all of human history the richest 1% constituted the “nobility” and controlled and owned almost everything. The “middle class” did not come into existence until around the 1940s due to unusual circumstances. For more discussion on this point, see my article: <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368</a> .</p><p>Given the pervasiveness of the power instability it is in fact remarkable that democracy was ever implemented, and that it continues in many nations today. Democracy was instituted in both America and France via revolutions where powerful groups of people overthrew and/or killed the current holders of power. George Washington was offered the position of King, but turned it down, an historically rare occurrence of someone not following the power instability. The creation of a democracy is almost always strongly resisted by the patriarchs in charge, but still today a fairly large fraction of the world is run by democracies at the national and state levels. Note, also that since power and money are very closely related, democracy, if it is working, also redistributes wealth.</p><p>Next consider that perhaps the same force that gave humans democracy also gave us science, and perhaps the continued existence of science depends upon the continued existence of democracy, and vice versa. Note that a huge increase in the pace of scientific discoveries correlated strongly with the rise of democracies in Europe and America. There were some scientific discoveries in the 1500’s and 1600’s before democracy really got under way, but these were dwarfed by the discoveries that started in the 1800’s, 1900’s, and 2000’s. Before democracy, scientists (called natural philosophers) worked for the Nobility. The great mathematician Carl Fredrich Gauss wasted much of his life calculating the orbits of minor planets. Why? Because that is what his nobleman sponsor wanted him to do. Independent, curiosity based research arose with the Age of Enlightenment (17th-19thcenturies), that same FB that gave rise to the democratic experiments in America and Europe.</p><p>One argument in favor of this view, is that it has been extremely important for scientific advancement that most scientists work at Universities. Universities are non-profit organizations that are largely not under control of either governments or corporations. They are, in most cases, democratic institutions run by their members. Currently science is almost entirely funded publically through democratic governments and the distribution of funding is almost entirely done through peer review, where the scientists themselves decide who gets the money. Publication of scientific results is also mostly out of control of the powerful (governments, the wealthy, and corporations) and again is peer reviewed. So perhaps as long as democracy survives, so will science. In this case, we then see that the basic idea of democracy (redistribution of power) is essential for the success of science. If tobacco companies had controlled scientific publication then we still wouldn’t have proof that smoking causes cancer. If this peer-review (i.e. democratic) structure of scientific research can be maintained, then perhaps science can continue to force collective FBs towards reality even when there is no obvious benefit to the powerful.</p><p>On the contrary, if the Power Instability somehow destroys democracy we might expect science to eventually also be lost. Note that Nazi Germany was very slow to develop Relativity (and the atomic bomb) because it was “Jewish science” (started by a Jew, Albert Einstein). Similar occurrences happened in the early years of the communist dictatorships. These restrictions on science were mostly dropped when it became apparent that science gives rise to powerful new weapons and powerful improvements in engineering and agriculture. However, almost all important scientific advances have come from the democracies, with dictatorships mostly just copying US and European science and then playing catch-up. As nations adopt democracy it is remarkable how quickly their scientist’s contributions increase.</p><p>If the science-created FB can continue to expand, this may bode well for humanity and for democracy. Physical Science started by addressing questions that only the powerful religious institutions were discussing, often inventing FBs that disagreed with those institutions’ FBs. Science won every one of these FB contests. Perhaps science will also start to address questions that are still only addressed by religion and cultural institutions. For example, is there a best way to raise children if you want happy, creative, and productive citizens? If economics is better understood using science, is there an economic system that maximizes the total happiness (i.e. utility) of everyone? Are there lifestyles that are better than others? Are there better ways to deal with criminals, drugs, the environment, etc.? Currently, these questions are answered by society’s collective FBs without strong regard to whether or not these theories are good approximations of reality. We know science is capable of forcing fantasy bubbles to come into closer agreement with reality, but we don’t know whether or not science can be applied to these questions. However, it is not obvious that science can’t be applied here and many other places.</p><p>As another example, consider the “social science” of history. The endeavor of modern history has its goal recording and explaining what happened in the past as accurately as possible. For most of human history, however, the subject of history was used to praise the powerful men who were running everything. The example of Columbus comes to mind; he was once considered a great man with many things named after him, but more recently he is also known for his genocide of native peoples. This change in the goal of the history profession seems directly attributable to historians wanting to be more “scientific”, and to the use of peer-reviewed (i.e. democratic) publication criteria.</p><p>Finally, just as democracy plays a key role in making science work, it is probably true that science plays a key role in maintaining democracy. In a society where the collective FB is far from reality the voters might chose in a very stupid way. In order to correctly choose leadership for their society, the average person needs to accurately know what those choices mean. Having a working science FB means that many people are used to checking the predictions of the collective FB with the actual observations. Thus if a politician says “I will double your wealth in the next 4 years”, but no increase in wealth occurs, the more scientifically oriented citizens will start to discard the statements of that politician as propaganda. On the contrary, if the ordinary citizens are continually fooled by false predictions, and never pause to check those predictions with observed reality, then a person with a strong ability to influence people’s FB may be elected, even if it leads to the end of democracy.</p><p>Thus we conclude that it is extremely important for humanity to continue with a collective fantasy bubble that includes the value of both science and democracy.</p><p><strong>Future Topics</strong></p><p>This concludes Part 1 of Fantasy Bubble Theory. Part 2 will give applications of the theory. For example, how to make a better society, how to understand religions and religious fanatics, how to change people’s opinions, and many other potential uses of FBT.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e5ae241d2c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Yes Wealthy Libertarians Really Are Your Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/yes-wealthy-libertarians-really-are-your-problem-46555278d883?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46555278d883</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[libertarianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy-in-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Dec 2021 04:38:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-05T22:39:40.696Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Kim Griest, 4 January 2022</strong></p><h4>Abstract</h4><p>There is a well organized plan being implemented to destroy the power and influence of the American Middle Class and return the control of the US to the extremely wealthy and the large corporations they control. This plan is being done mostly in secret since the majority of Americans would be against it if they knew it was happening. The essence of the plan is to undo the New Deal and the social systems that came along with it or were strengthened because of it: Social Security, Medicare, the FDA, public schools and universities, government funded science research, government regulation of the environment, public health, government funded national parks, forests, and beaches, and, in general, all democracy for the common good. Implementation of this destructive plan started in the 1950s, but got really well organized and financed starting in the 1980s. This paper gives a summary of how the plan came about, how it is being implemented, what the results will be if successful, and what we can do about it.</p><h4>1. Introduction</h4><p>We want to figure out what is going on here in America and the world. What are the real issues of importance? In order to understand this it is important to understand where the power lies and who the main players are. The basic struggle is between the people who control the world’s wealth and resources, and the “Middle Class”, i.e. the ordinary people just trying to make it through their lives in relative comfort.</p><p>The main problem for the Middle Class is that their wealth, comfort, and power has been decreasing for the past 35 years. Since it is happening gradually, it is not clear to most why this is happening, and it is also not clear to most what to do about it. There are many powerful groups and individuals who don’t want people to understand what is happening, so there has been a very concerted and organized effort put into fooling the bulk of the people as to the real causes of this gradual reduction in their standard of living and control over things. This article tries to explain what is going on and how to stop it.</p><p>Many facts and ideas in this article are taken from 4 books and this article is a kind of summary and retelling of these other authors’ research. Many more details and lots of documentation are contained in these books. The four books are:</p><p>1. “One Nation Under God: How Corporate America Created Christian America”, by Princeton historian, Kevin Kruse,</p><p>2. “Democracy in Chains; The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Stealth Plan for America”, by Duke University historian, Nancy MacClean (NOTE: Many of the detailed claims about James Buchanan, Charles Koch, and other prominent libertarians come from this book; after Buchanan’s death, MacClean obtained permission to enter and research Buchanan’s George Mason University office, which contained much of Buchanan’s private correspondence, including letters to and from Charles Koch and the many libertarians referred to in this paper),</p><p>3. “Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming”, by Harvard University sociologist Naomi Orestes and Erik Conway, and finally</p><p>4. “Capital in the 21st Century”, by well-known economist, Thomas Piketty.</p><p>Let’s start with the little known fact that before the 1900’s, there was almost no Middle Class anywhere in the world. Of course before democracy was invented society was run by monarchs and the nobility, who typically made up about 1% of the population of the countries they ruled. In those days, the bottom 90% of society had very little total net worth, and so there was basically no Middle Class. Perhaps surprisingly, even after the advent of democracy the wealthy kept their wealth (and power). For example, in France, where the best historical records on wealth exist, the richest 10% of the population owned more than 90% of the wealth even in 1910. Inequality was probably worse in England. The United States is tricky since records on wealth were not taken or kept in the 1800’s, blacks made up about 20% of the population and, being the property of whites, were legally not allowed to own anything, and the (unknown number of) Native Americans were not even counted. But by 1910, it was clear that even in the USA, the bottom 90% of Americans owned less than 20% of the total wealth. The New Deal changed everything, and by 1985, the Middle Class everyone nostalgically talks about had reached its zenith, with the bottom 90% owning nearly 60% of the total US wealth. What this means is that there was basically no Middle Class in the early 1900’s but by 1985 there was one.</p><p>Most people don’t know this because the many stories about life in the 1800s paint a romantic picture of hard-working, self-sufficient people which is for the most part false. The small time American farmer or the craftsman in a small town supporting their families in comfort was actually very uncommon. There are several reasons for the lack of knowledge of real history: 1. Public schools didn’t really exist in America before the 1850s, so only the children of the wealthy went to school. A large fraction of the Lower and Middle Class men (and basically all women, black people and Natives) were nearly illiterate. The romantic stories we read about these times were written by the wealthy for the wealthy. Their stories romanticized life, of course making out the wealthy to be mostly noble personages. In the US, it wasn’t until around 1920 that public education was made available to all white children, and not until later that public schools became open to all races. In addition, during the 1940s, 50s, and early 60s, most people alive today were fed romantic stories of early America for the political purposes discussed below.</p><p>This traditional order of plutocracy changed substantially due to shocks to the system caused by World War I, the Great Depression, and World War II. Many large fortunes were destroyed by the wars, and people in general blamed the Great Depression on the wealthy, thereby causing people like Franklin D Roosevelt to be elected. For the first time in US history people started using democracy to take away the wealth and power of the super-rich. The New Deal became law. This blaming of the wealthy allowed a huge change to take place in America. The tax rate on incomes greater than $3M/year became 93%, with inheritance taxes on large estates of nearly 80%. This huge new source of income allowed enormous investment to be made in the things the Middle Class wanted, public schools, public highways, national parks, the FDA, NASA, the EPA, etc. Europe followed FDR’s lead and also enacted large taxes on the wealthy thereby creating a European Middle Class for the first time. For more details see Piketty’s book or my article which summarizes it: <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368</a></p><p>In Section 2, we give the history of attempts to undo the New Deal starting in the 1940s. These mostly failed and resulted in a more organized plan described in section 3. Section 4 describes the development of the plan from 1952 until the 1980s, again mostly failures. Section 5 describes the transition to a stealthy plan in the 1980s and how that stealthy plan has been largely successful. The current status of the plan and the fact that US Democracy is in danger is discussed in Section 6, while Section 7 gives some ideas on what can be done to counter the plan and save US Democracy. Finally, in Section 8, we describe some current events in the context of the libertarian plan.</p><h4>2. Undoing the New Deal: First Try</h4><p>The mega-rich industrialists of the 1940s, such as Rockefeller, Carnegie, etc., were very upset when FDR’s New Deal was enacted by Congress. The New Deal included a tax rate of 93% on income over $3 million (in today’s dollars). Inheritance taxes were set at nearly 80% on large fortunes, and other taxes on the wealthy were created all of which were for paying for free public work projects, the interstate highway system, Social Security, and things that the wealthy just didn’t need or want.</p><p>What to do?</p><p>Their idea was, of course, to use their money to influence politics and undo the New Deal.</p><p>But Americans liked these things, and it just got worse for the millionaires under Harry Truman, who among other things, established the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) mortgage insurance, which redistributed the money from the high taxes on the wealthy to greatly facilitate home ownership by the Middle Class. The government also built huge public housing projects and started civil rights programs to help minorities, again reducing the power and influence of the wealthy.</p><p>Since straight out opposition to the New Deal wasn’t working, and Unions were giving more and more power to Middle Class workers, the millionaires tried various other tactics.</p><p>Prime among these was helping to create and support a new kind of Christian evangelism, which Princeton historian Kevin Kruse calls Christian Libertarianism. Prime examples of Christian libertarians include Billy Graham, Abraham Veriede, James Fifield, Norman Vincent Peale, etc. The speeches these preachers gave to very large crowds were as much about American “free enterprise” (free from minimum wage laws, environmental regulations, etc.), and anti-New Deal politics as about spiritual topics. Without directly saying so, their goal was to convince Americans that true Christians wanted the wealthy to again control the USA.</p><p>The Cold War was going and the anti-communism “red scare” was in full swing. Libertarian economist, Friedrich Hayek, along with many others, kept repeating that the New Deal was socialism and would lead straight to the US becoming a communist totalitarian dictatorship like the Soviet Union.</p><p>Many wealthy and famous Americans supported this Christian libertarianism and it’s goal to fight Truman and the New Deal; for example, Bing Crosby, Cecil B. DeMille, Walt Disney, Ronald Reagan, J. Howard Pew, Conrad Hilton (hotels), B. E. Hutchinson (Chrysler), James Kraft (foods), Hughston McBain (Marshall Fields), Ben Morell (Laughlin Steel), Eddie Rickenbacker (Eastern Airlines), Charles WIlson (General Motors), Harvey Firestone, E. F. Hutton, Fred Maytag, Henry Luce, J. C. Penny, and the heads of US Steel, Gulf Oil, Hughes Aircraft, United Airlines, as well as the presidents of the US Chamber of Commerce, and the National Association of Manufacturers.</p><p>Like much of corporate America, the advertising industry also discovered religion as a means of professional salvation in the aftermath of the New Deal. The New Deal represented the first ever real effort to regulate their work, as it empowered the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to fight false claims about food and drugs. Removing those false claims decreased their profit margins. The ad executives decided to use their power of advertising, via public service campaigns, to work against the New Deal economic system. The Advertising Council was the result. Disguised as public service, it promoted “free enterprise”, championing corporate interests. It’s “Religion in American Life” campaign strongly promoted the Christian Libertarian viewpoint, gathering money from General Motors, Union Carbide, etc. By 1956 over 9700 ads were running , covering Reader’s Digest, Ladies Home Journal, TV Guide, Sports Illustrated, etc. plus TV shows. Also more than 5000 billboards along major highways, 10,000 posters at bus and train stations, and 60,000 ad cards in public places were put up.</p><p>The wealthy Hollywood people also joined the effort to undo the New Deal. Cecil B. DeMille’s films were full of religious/anti-New Deal ideas. He hated Truman with a passion. He gave speeches and lots of money to his causes which worked to weaken labor unions throughout the country. His major film, “The 10 Commandments” was framed as Moses standing against the New Deal. He paid for and promoted putting stone “10 Commandments” statues throughout the country, in the end nearly 4000 of them were put up.</p><p>In, 1953, Dr. Fred Schwarz, started the CACC (Christian Anti-Communism Crusade). Originally focussed on international communism rather than the New Deal problem, the Christian Libertarians welcomed him. He worked with the House Un-American Activities Committee in making connections between communism, anti-Christians and the New Deal. As an example, the CACC widely distributed this false Khrushchev quote: “We cannot expect the American to jump from Capitalism to Communism, but we can assist their elected leaders in giving Americans small doses of Socialism, until they suddenly awake to find they have Communism”. Anti-communism schools were started at the Biltmore hotel in 1961, with the goal of undoing the New Deal. These were funded by Patrick Frawley (Paper Mate pens and Schick Safety Razors) and Richfield Oil, among others, and were strongly supported by Ronald Reagan, Edward Teller, Senator Dodd, Roy Rogers, Dale Evans, John Wayne, Pat Boone, and later also by Jimmy Stewart, Rock Hudson, Donna Reed, Ozzie and Hariet, Nat King Cole, Tex Ritter, Vincent Price, John Ford, Walt Disney, Jack Warner, and LIFE magazine. The biggest CACC event was “Hollywood’s Answer to Communism”. It, along with many CACC broadcasts, were extremely successful. A main sponsor was Roger Milliken, head of one of the world’s largest textile corporations, who was in the midst of a fight with unions and had just received a record fine from the National Labor Relations Board, a creation of the New Deal.</p><p>Something needed to be done, so the wealthy, represented by the National American Manufacturers organization (NAM), along with Billy Graham, and especially Texas oilman and America’s richest person, Sid Richardson, decided that Dwight Eisenhower, WWII general and a very Christian Republican, should run for president. Richardson was a primary funder of Eisenhower’s candidacy and worked hard to elect him.. All the Christian libertarian leaders endorsed Eisenhower, while the more progressive religious leaders endorsed Adali Stevenson.</p><p>These important movements in the 1940s and early 1950s — the prayer breakfast meetings of Abraham Vereide, which encompassed most Washington politicians and conservative business leaders, Billy Graham’s evangelical revivals, the McCarthy red scare, and the presidential campaign of Dwight D Eisenhower worked in lockstep to advance Christian libertarianism; effectively harnessing Cold War anxieties for an already established campaign to overturn FDR’s New Deal.</p><p>It worked! In 1952, Eisenhower was elected in a landslide,</p><p>the only states to vote against him were the solidly racist Democrats in the South. Eisenhower brought religion into American politics like it never had been before. It was at this time that “under God” was added to the pledge of allegiance, and the slogan “In God We Trust” added to printed money. The wealthy libertarians, libertarian Christians, and anti-communists celebrated.</p><p>But a serious problem soon developed. Eisenhower was an actual Christian, who believed in democracy for the common good and for a large government role in helping the less fortunate. His wealthy sponsors misread him; he was not a “libertarian Christian” who wanted a return to the unregulated free market capitalism and the oligarchies of the 19th century. Yikes, Eisenhower failed his sponsors.</p><p>Eisenhower supported New Deal ideals, promoting large government work programs, creating the interstate highway system, expanding Social Security, and kept the top marginal income and inheritance tax rates around 90% and 80% respectively.</p><p>What to do? Over the next 40 years, the wealthy never stopped trying to undo the New Deal, i.e. destroy Social Security, etc. but they encountered a major problem. The public liked the New Deal and the public liked how the Middle Class grew and grew. It really was the New Deal tax policies, along with the growing economy due to massive rebuilding of the world after WWII that led to the Middle Class growing and growing, and correspondingly the wealth share of the richest 1% dropping. The share of the top 1% went from 45% of total US wealth in 1920 to 23% in 1985, with much of this money going to the Middle Class. [See my article, “The real reason the Middle Class is shrinking”, for much more discussion on these points. <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368</a> ]</p><p>What were the wealthy going to do about this terrible inability to restore their money and power? Somehow they had to change the public’s mind about the New Deal and the progressive tax structure that made it possible. It seemed that all that hard work, all that advertising, all those famous actors, all those Hollywood movies, and all that Christian anti-communism had failed.</p><h4>3. Undoing the New Deal: Overview of the Goal and the Plan</h4><p>The wealthy conservative/libertarians and the large corporations they ran needed to get organized.</p><p>The goal of these individuals and the large corporations they controlled was fairly clear. They did not want to pay for things that wealthy people, such as themselves, for the most part did not need. They wanted to transfer as much money and resources as possible to themselves, taking it from average people and the environment. They did not want democratic government, representing average people, reducing their profits by stopping them from polluting rivers, lakes, and the atmosphere, or stopping them from selling cigarettes to kids. They wanted to maximize fossil fuel use, use poisonous asbestos in household products, clearcut the forests, etc. for short term profits. And they especially wanted to reduce their tax burdens to increase their share of the nation’s wealth, increase their power over government, and remove the “social giveaways” such as public schools and libraries, national parks, Social Security, Medicare, overtime pay, workplace safety rules, minimum wages, etc. that the Middle Class was enjoying and demanding.</p><p>While the goal was clear, the problem was that these goals only served the richest 1% of the population, and even then only those who were quite self-centered and didn’t care about the common good. In a democracy where everyone can vote, telling the truth about these goals would garner less than 1% of the vote; clearly not enough to elect politicians favorable to their goals. So somehow the wealthy had to get at least 50% of the population to get behind this program, that is, they had to get at least 50% of the population to vote against their own interests.</p><p>How to do this? Well the easiest people to get to vote against their own interests are the gullible, and the most gullible are the uneducated, prejudiced people of all sorts, conservative Christians, and single issue fanatics. Examples of single-issue-people are strong anti-abortionists or people fearful of losing their guns or people strongly afraid of blacks, immigrants, communists, etc.</p><p>What did these wealthy people say to convince Americans to vote against their own economic and health interests? Anything at all that seemed to work! There was no need for consistency or even logic, because remember the target audience were the gullible and/or single-issue Americans.</p><p>So the plan became obvious.</p><p><strong>1.</strong>Convince religious people that “true Christianity” is actually very libertarian, e.g. small government, no regulations, and self-centered (remember libertarian “saint”, Ayn Rand’s most famous non-fiction book was entitled “The Virtue of Selfishness”).</p><p><strong>2.</strong>Make “neo-liberalism” economics more popular, by convincing people that the wealthy people know what’s best for everyone, and if the wealthy get richer more will “trickle down” to the ordinary people. As we will see in the next section, the libertarian economists such as Friedrich Hayek, Milton Friedmann, and James Buchanan put forward these ideas and eventually became the intellectual leaders of the entire libertarian plan.</p><p><strong>3.</strong>Pack the courts with hand-picked libertarian “originalists”, who would undo the modern interpretation of the Constitution put in place by the Supreme Court of the 1940s-1960s, and who would increase the power of the wealthy and allow the conservative states to have their way.</p><p><strong>4.</strong>Increase the public’s distrust of people and organizations who could prevent this plan, namely 1) scientists, 2) experts (e.g. academics and Universities), 3) accurate, fact-based news reporting, and especially 4) the government in most of its forms except the military and police.</p><p><strong>5.</strong>Stoke racism, homophobia, sexism, anti-communism, etc. (anti-Semitism lost most of its traditional appeal after the defeat of the German Nazi’s.) and blame these “outgroups” for the problems caused by the destruction of the Middle Class.</p><p>Now, item 4 above was especially important since the only power regular people have to stand against the wealthy and the large corporations is a democratically elected government. The wealthy and corporations therefore needed to destroy these “suckers” trust in the government. So they told people that government was the problem. And whenever they got into power, usually as Republicans, they purposefully screwed up the government as much as possible to prove it was true! You might notice that almost everyone today distrusts “the government”. This is not a coincidence, but the result of a carefully executed propaganda campaign. In places like the Scandinavian nations, the public has very high trust in the government. And these nations are the most democratic in the world as well as being highly socialized.</p><p>This propaganda campaign also continued to work directly against the New Deal and especially against the public’s desire to expand the New Deal’s goals. They said universal public health care would lead to the USA becoming a communistic state, even though every advanced democracy in the world had already created such systems. They said the Democrats want to take your guns away and destroy Christianity, implement Sharira law, etc. They said that tax cuts for the wealthy helped average people, even though it is obvious (and proved by the data) that tax cuts for the wealthy actually reduce the wealth of the Middle Class and hurt everyone except the wealthy.</p><p>This large scale, very organized campaign against US democracy, the Middle Class, environmental regulation, and all things that increase the public good mostly failed throughout the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s. This was extremely frustrating to those leading these efforts. Finally in the 1980’s at the time of the Reagan administration, the libertarians began to succeed. They realized that they needed a secret, stealthy plan that did not seem to go directly against the interests of the majority of Americans. They got their tax cuts under Reagan, resulting in their wealth share increasing year by year. They purposefully blamed the resulting shrinking of the Middle Class wealth on other things.</p><p>4. How the Plan Developed: 1952–1980s</p><p>During the Eisenhower administration, 1952–1960, the strategy put in place earlier continued. Red scare McCarthyism continued until embarrassing itself out of existence in 1955. Christian libertarians continued to complain about the government programs that their congregations actually liked.</p><p>An important ingredient in all this democracy-for-the-common-good success was the fact that through the late 1940s and 1950s, almost the entire Supreme Court had been appointed by FDR and Truman. And even Eisenhower’s Supreme Court appointments voted with the liberals for the most part. Thus in 1954, the Supreme Court, in Brown vs. Board of Education, ruled that school segregation was unconstitutional. And in 1962, in Engel v. Vitale, state-sponsored prayer in schools was limited. These rulings, especially Brown v. Board of Education, energized the previously Democratic South like nothing else. “First the Feds forced blacks into our schools and then they forced Jesus out”, was a common refrain (though the word used was probably not “blacks”.) Southern states began a campaign of “massive resistance” against desegregation. At this same time, and largely because of this, a little known libertarian economist, James Buchanan, began his gradual rise to enormous power and eventual leadership of the entire plan to undo the New Deal.</p><p>The fight against desegregation enabled a renewal of the old pre-civil war libertarian idea that the federal government had no right to dictate how southern states like Virginia conduct its affairs. Newspaper columnist/editor, James Kilpatrick repeated endlessly this idea and added to it the old pro-slavery John Calhoun argument that state leaders had the right to “interpose” their authority between the residents and Washington. Many thought this argument was dead after the South lost the Civil War, but Brown vs. Board of Education brought it back in strength.</p><p>In 1956, James Buchanan wrote a letter to Colgate Darden, the president of the University of Virginia (UV), saying that forced desegregation would ruin Virginia. Darden funded Buchanan’s proposal to create a new school of political economy and social philosophy built on “individual liberty” (i.e. the freedom to keep blacks out of white schools) .</p><p>After Brown vs. Board of Education, Buchanan and his allies in the Virginia state government, realized they could use the inherent racism that drove the fight against school integration to train the racists to frame the question in “individual freedom” and “states rights” terms. It wasn’t about keeping the blacks out, it was about keeping the federal government out. Of course, this was the same libertarian argument John Calhoun was using in the 1800s in support of slavery and the Civil War. Buchanan realized that besides fighting desegregation, this issue could be used to end public education, something the libertarians fighting the New Deal greatly disliked. Buchanan recommended, and the state of Virginia agreed, to shut down any public school that attempted to end segregation. Most Southern States followed suit.</p><p>When the federal courts blocked that approach, he recommended that all public schools in Virginia be shut down (in a non-racial way) and invented school voucher programs that allowed people to give their tax money to private schools. In order to pay for these, Buchanan recommended that Virginia sell off all the public school buildings and properties, and Virginia proceeded to set up to do just that. Milton Friedman, the Nobel winning University of Chicago libertarian economist, wrote editorials supporting this sale of the public schools. While several counties started the sales, the Virginia State legislature balked, realizing that the fire sale of public schools to private operators would be political suicide. They wanted to stop racial integration, not get ejected from office.</p><p>Thus James Buchanan’s plan to preserve segregation failed. However, he thought carefully about why this failure occurred, and from this failure he formulated a more sophisticated plan that was implemented by the organizations he set up with the Koch brothers. This plan has been much more successful. Buchanan realized that the problem was democracy itself and especially majority rule and the public sector in general.</p><p>However, while the state did not sell off all its private schools, public schools in black areas in Prince Edward County were padlocked to prevent integration. Local black youth remained schoolless from 1959 until 1964 when a federal court intervened. Expect a return to situations like this if the current libertarian plan does succeed.</p><p>The wealthy libertarians became even more energized when the federal courts also started confronting the voter suppression system of the Southern States. These laws, such as the poll tax and literacy tests, were designed to keep poor blacks (and other poor people) from voting. In 1952 less than 15% of the black citizens of the South voted, largely because of these voter suppression laws. The poll tax for federal elections was ended in 1964 by the 24th Amendment, and for all state elections in 1966. The Supreme Court also ruled that census data could not be ignored in state representation. The libertarians viewed these rulings as an end to a long tradition: that (white) property rights were supposed to reign supreme over other rights. The FDR/Truman/Eisenhower Supreme Court was gradually removing this tradition, and the libertarians viewed this as “creeping socialism.”</p><p>The libertarians also realized that the “interpose” idea was useful because local governments were more responsive to the people who lived there and, for example, wanted public schools. This “interpose” idea to keep power at the State level is popular even today in the “red” states. We currently see Republican controlled states returning to the voter suppression techniques used in the Jim Crow South. Their goal is clearly to return to those pre WWII days when various means were used to keep the power in the hands of the wealthy. Thus it makes sense that the main plan to achieve this goal came from James Buchanan, an extremely intelligent Southerner whose family watched as civil rights legislation and a liberal Supreme Court forced Virginia to integrate and then continued to increase the power of democracy for the common good, and remove the privileges of the wealthy.</p><p>James Buchanan with his colleague Gordon Tullock took these lessons and created “public choice” political theory, for which Buchanan received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1986. This theory, along with their book: “The Calculus of Consent”, put forward ideas and justifications for protecting capitalism from democracy. Property rights needed to be protected over other rights. They worked with the Virginia government to spread the message that the federal government had been acting illegitimately since the 1930s and that the New Deal was based on the “misinterpretation” of the constitution “during the administration of Franklin Roosevelt”. Current Supreme Court justice Clarence Thomas, as well as many others on the right are strongly associated with these ideas. Ultimately 2 million pamphlets and books containing these ideas were distributed, for example to every state legislature and governor, every member of Congress, federal judges, chambers of commerce, town and law libraries, etc. In the UK, the conservative party under Margaret Thatcher was among those who adopted these ideas. An example is the school “choice” vouchers Buchanan created that could be used at private “whites only” schools. School vouchers, aka “school choice”, has always been a way of removing democracy from the public schools. The goal of the libertarian billionaires is to take control over what schools do away from the taxpayers, but force taxpayers to pay for them anyway. Private control of public money is always the libertarian goal.</p><p>Business men and economists (including famed libertarian economist Friedrich Hayek) argued that the New Deal was “nothing more or less than the Socialist doctrine called by another name”, and would undermine all freedom and usher in totalitarian states like the Nazis. They set up institutions to fight the New Deal: the University of Chicago economic department was one of these! The Mont Pelerin Society formed as a network of economists and business men to fight the New Deal. Buchanan’s school of economics worked to break the public’s trust in the government’s ability to offer economic solutions.</p><p>Of course much of Europe, and especially the Scandinavian nations such as Sweden, took the New Deal ideas and extended them exactly as the libertarians warned against. Even 70 years after Hayek’s predictions were made, none of Hayek’s or the libertarians’ predictions have come true, and exactly none of these nations became the totalitarian dictatorship the libertarians warned about. When one hears these same “totalitarian” scare tactics being used today, one can only laugh.</p><p>Democracy, especially as it became more inclusive, kept causing trouble for the men who wanted “economic liberty” — trouble that illuminates why they later adopted the strategy they did. For example, with huge effort these men got Barry Goldwater nominated as the Republican presidential nominee in 1964. Buchanan’s close colleague Warren Nutter wrote many of Goldwater’s speeches. But Goldwater’s ideas did not resonate with most Americans. He thought the Tennessee Valley Authority should sell off (privatize) its hydroelectric plants, and said that Social Security, the most popular New Deal program, should be made voluntary, a move he and many others knew would cripple, and in time end the program. In a speech in South Carolina, he strongly argued for the libertarian view of freedom, giving the example that Medicare was socialism. Most South Carolinians liked Medicare. Milton Friedman, William F. Buckley, Jr. and pretty much the whole right wing/libertarian community got on board with these ideas, for example strongly criticizing the Civil Rights Act of 1964, public school integration, etc. all in the name of liberty.</p><p>Goldwater lost the election in the worse showing in more than 100 years. The landslide election of LB Johnson along with a large majority in both houses of congress, was even worse for the libertarian’s goals: laws were passed such as the work-study program for college students, Medicare, Medicaid, a war on poverty, clean air and clean water laws, and especially the Voting Rights Act of 1965, designed to allow every American citizen, at last, to participate in the political process. These federal government laws all were aimed at increasing the power of ordinary citizens and reducing the power of the wealthy.</p><p>The student activism of the 1960s also hardened the resolve of the wealthy libertarians to reduce the power and promise of the public Universities, which were seen as enabling more power for ordinary citizens. Their programs to slash public University budgets, raise tuition, end need-based scholarships, reduce faculty governance of Universities, and undermine support for the liberal arts continues to this day, with the Koch funded project moving into high gear after 2010. They argued that the Universities should not be viewed as public resources, but as “corporations” which should be run by the rules of capitalism (only those who can afford paying full price (the wealthy) should be educated)).</p><p>By 1973, James Buchanan, relocated to Virginia Tech and heavily supported by the libertarian billionaire Scaife Foundation, had his plan ready. It required organization. He, and like minded associates, decided that individual voters “accept what they are told” by news sources they trust. So they needed to change what they were hearing and from whom. Buchanan’s vision was to start by converting people of power in domains that mattered: politics, business, the media, and the courts. They needed to transform “the way people think about government”. He called this the “Practical Strategy” and stressed that “conspiratorial secrecy is at all time essential”.</p><p>As part of the plan, Buchanan recruited Henry Manne to do in law what Buchanan was doing in economics. With massive funding from the libertarian Olin Foundation and several large corporations, centers for “Law and Economics” were created, starting with the University of Virginia. The goal was to train a cadre of libertarian lawyers who would eventually be placed on the courts, in order to fight the environmental and consumer rights sentiments that were occurring everywhere. This eventually resulted in the libertarian Federalist Society, founded in 1982 with funding by the wealthy libertarians, John Olin, Robert Mercer, the Scaife foundation, the Koch foundations, as well as Chevron Oil. This extreme libertarian organization now has chapters at 200 US law schools. It selects, trains, financially supports, and uses its networks to promote young lawyers with libertarian views. It basically has vetted all federal judges appointed by G. W. Bush and D. J. Trump, and is by far the most powerful force currently creating a conservative/libertarian judiciary in the US. It is hard to overestimate the importance of the Koch brothers in this effort.</p><p>Fred Koch, Charles’ and David’s father, was the founder of the John Birch Society in 1958. Charles took over Koch industries in 1967, and then inherited it. He turned the oil and chemical services company from a $60M/year business, when he inherited it, into a $110B/year business by 2014. The Koch’s were, and are, one of the wealthiest families in the world.</p><p>Over many decades, Charles Koch was the main source of funds for Buchanan’s plan to return control of America to the wealthy. Koch’s goals were in line with Buchanan’s ideas, being influenced in part by his mentor, F. A. Haper, a founding member of the Mont Pelerin Society. His basic beliefs included hatred of all the gains unions had given: pensions, health insurance, minimum wages, child labor laws, as well as mandatory schooling. He hated public education (aka “government schools”) which he thought contributed to “juvenile delinquency.” He believed that all these things were “the essence of communism-socialism”. He believed “The power to tax was the power to destroy”, and wanted to remove as much taxation of the wealthy as possible.</p><p>[Note all the quotes and most of the facts I give in this section come from MacLean’s book; the exact references can be found in the footnotes of that book.]</p><p>In Buchanan, Koch found the extreme right wing libertarian intellectual he had been looking for. Even libertarians such as Milton Friedman were “sellouts to the system”, because they sought “to make the government work more efficiently when the true libertarian should be tearing it out at the root”. Thus they really did want to bring the government down, and this was the plan they worked on implementing.</p><p>Koch started subsidizing several libertarian intellectuals, such as Murray Rothchild, who explained how a Lenin-like libertarian strategy might work; most importantly by creating a cadre of disciplined revolutionaries. Koch recruited Edward Crane II, a member of the Libertarian Party, formed in 1971, with the aim of ending public education, Social Security, Medicare, the U.S. Postal Service, minimum wage laws, child labor laws, foreign aid, the Environmental Protection Agency, and in time, the end of taxes and government regulation of any kind. Crane, Rothbard, and Koch insisted that the state power had to be overthrown. They thought the future belonged to the only “truly radical vision”: “repudiating state power” altogether. The organization they founded to create this revolution was the CATO Institute. MacLean says that “You cannot understand the influence of the stealth movement that is transforming America today without understanding this critical turning point”, that is the creation of the long term plan of the CATO Institute and other libertarian training organizations that followed. The Republican Party of 2008 is exhibit A of Koch’s success with this model. This “disciplined cadre” of libertarian intellectuals have completely turned the leaders of the Republican Party to their points-of-views.</p><p>While CATO advocated wide-ranging libertarian policies, another Koch-supported think tank, the Reason Foundation, made the case for selling off public property and outsourcing public services to private corporations. Ron Paul, libertarian member of Congress worked hard to do this. At the same time Buchanan was hired by another Koch-backed organization, the Liberty Fund, to run summer sessions to identify and train the needed intellectual cadre. Koch also backed the new Libertarian Party, which, while formed in 1971, at this time was attracting very little notice and very few votes. To get around the campaign finance laws of the time, Charles’ brother David Koch ran as vice president, funded largely by himself. That money was enough to get the Libertarian Party some press and gather 1% of the vote in the 1980 election. But gradually Koch and Buchanan were becoming disillusioned with democracy. In his book “Limits of Liberty” Buchanan comes to believe that democracy cannot be made to give the wealthy the control they want. He says, “Despotism may be the only organizational alternative”. The planning to destroy democracy had begun.</p><p>The libertarian economists got a real world chance to try out their ideas in 1979, in Chile, where democratically elected Chilean president Salvadore Allende had been overthrown in a military coup. The new dictator, Augusto Pinoche, and especially his economic advisor and minister of Labor, Jose Pinera, were devotees of Buchanan’s “Virginia School” of libertarian economic theory and were carefully following the advice given in one of Buchanan’s books. Between the coup in 1973 and 1979, Pinera/Pinoche had outlawed normal labor unions, privatized the Chilean social security system, privatized the previously socialized health care system, transformed the judiciary, forced the Universities to become self-financing (to ensure poor students could not attend), enforced K-12 school vouchers, and required voting supermajorities (2/3) to raise taxes or undo any of these changes, as well as other recommendations made by the libertarians. What was left was entrenching these changes into a new constitution to prevent subsequent governments from ever going down the democracy-for-the-common-good road of FDR, etc. The idea was to put “chains on democracy” to prevent the voters from ever getting control of the country again. Both James Buchanan and Milton Friedman spent time in Chile at the request of the dictatorship, giving huge input in the drafting of the new Chilean constitution. This constitution included many of Buchanan’s ideas, including a cunning electoral voting system, not in use anywhere else in the world and clearly the fruit of Buchanan’s counsel, which would permanently overrepresent the right-wing minority party. This constitution was adopted in a corrupt vote in 1980. Pinoche’s corrupt and anti-democratic regime is widely regarded as one of the worst in modern times, but his libertarian constitution continues until this day. The result of that constitution was Chile becoming the most unequal and one of poorest countries in South America, doubling the number of poor people from 23% in 1970 to 45% by 1987. This constitution continues to make meaningful changes in Chilean law difficult, yet the Chilean constitution is held up as exemplary and as resulting in an “economic miracle” by libertarian organizations such as the Koch funded CATO Institute, Heritage Foundation, etc.</p><p>If we want to see what the goal of the libertarian billionaires is for America, we can just look to Chile where it was implemented.</p><h4>5. The Need for Stealth: the Plan Starts to Succeed: the 1980s Until Today</h4><p>In 1982 Buchanan moved his group to George Mason University just across the Potomac River from Washington DC. Ronald Reagan’s election as president was seen by the libertarians as a huge victory for their cause. Buchanan was more skeptical than most that Reagan could accomplish his goal of defunding the government to such an extent that the power of the Middle Class and the majority of voters could be eliminated.</p><p>Reagan and Congress did accomplish one important long-term goal of the wealthy libertarians: the income tax on the wealthiest Americans was reduced by a huge amount, to 28% at the end of the Reagan administration. It had been 93% under FDR, reduced some to around 70% under Nixon, but had never dropped below 70% until Reagan. The estate tax on large estates was also greatly reduced, allowing the wealthy to establish fantastically powerful dynasties that are growing ever larger today. These changes to the tax codes reversed the 50 year-old trend where the Middle Class wealth increased year by year and where the wealth of the top 1% decreased year by year. Starting in the mid-1980s the wealth of Middle Class has decreased continually. Unless FDR/Nixon level taxes are reinstated, this trend will result in the demise of the Middle Class. See Piketty’s book or my summary paper for more details about this: <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/the-real-reason-the-american-middle-class-is-disappearing-e7700c593368</a></p><p>But while the taxes on the wealthy were reduced, the desired gigantic cuts in social services were not entirely implemented. The Reagan administration cut what it could, but found that the public liked many of the services the government provided and was forced to accept them and fund the hated services by increasing the US debt. By the time Reagan left office the deficit was 3 times larger than the one he inherited from Jimmy Carter.</p><p>So Buchanan proved correct, and this defeat of the conservative/libertarian program caused Buchanan and his funders to stop being honest with the public. Stealth would be required to achieve their ends. They decided to test this stealth approach on the “linchpin of the American welfare state”, Social Security. Social Security was the most popular New Deal reform, and they felt that if Social Security could be eliminated, or at least privatized, the rest of the New Deal programs would also fall. Detailed discussion of this plan was found by Duke University historian Nancy MacClean in letters between James Buchanan and Charles Koch, in Buchanan’s George Mason University office after Buchanan’s death.</p><p>Buchanan described the stealth approach that the Koch-funded think tanks, and the libertarian press, in general, should take:</p><p><strong>1</strong>. Undermine beneficiaries’ view of Social Security’s viability, because that would “make abandonment of the system look more attractive”. For example pay for TV ads showing older people with worried faces wondering if Social Security will be around when they need it.</p><p><strong>2</strong>. Divide and conquer:</p><p><strong>a.</strong>Those currently receiving Social Security (or those nearing that age) should be assured that their benefits would not be cut. These people would fight the hardest to preserve Social Security, and so getting them out of the fight was important.</p><p><strong>b.</strong>High earning people should be told they will be taxed at ever higher levels to preserve Social Security. These wealthy people need Social Security the least and also hold most of the power in the US, so getting them to support the ending of Social Security was important.</p><p><strong>c.</strong>Younger workers needed to be told that their payroll deductions were providing “a tremendous welfare subsidy” to the aged, and that the system probably won’t be there by the time they need it.</p><p><strong>d</strong>. Finally, Buchanan wrote “those who seek to undermine the support of the system (over the longer term) would do well to propose increases in the retirement age and increases in payroll taxes” so as to irritate recipients at all income levels, and increase distrust in the system.</p><p>This “patchwork pattern of ‘reforms’” (the quotation marks around “reforms” were added by Buchanan, to make sure the message was clear that reform was not really the endgame) could tear asunder groups that hitherto had been united in their support of Social Security. Better still, Buchanan noted, the member groups of the once unified coalition that protected it might be induced by such changes to fight one another. When that happened, the broad phalanx that had upheld the system for a half-century might finally fracture.</p><p>Buchanan did not go into who would benefit from the end of social security, but others at the Koch-funded Heritage Foundation did. All the money going into social security for old people’s pensions, would go into the financial industry. That had happened in Chile, and resulted in increased wealth for the wealthy. Currently the US Social Security Trust fund is worth about $3 trillion. Imagine how great it would be for Wall Street and the wealthy capitalists to get hold of that money?</p><p>While others focused on advancing the new stealth strategy, Buchanan realized that this was not enough. What was needed was a way to amend the Constitution so the public officials would be legally constrained from offering new social programs to the public or implementing regulation on their behalf. The real project must aim toward the practical “removal of the sacrosanct status assigned to majority rule”.</p><p>With lot of financial help from his libertarian sponsors, and the libertarian president of George Mason University, the GMU acquired a law school, put Henry Manne as Dean, fired almost all the existent faculty and hired bunches of “kindred spirits”. Manne’s school strongly took the side of corporations against “consumerism and environmentalism”, positions very attractive to conservative/libertarian donors. It was at this time that Charles Koch moved his hardcore libertarian think tank, the Institute for Humane Studies, from California to George Mason University. Around this time the Federalist Society came under the influence of Koch and Buchanan. This is the organization that has transformed the nations judiciary and law schools, including the US Supreme Court.</p><p>This GMU law center was an overwhelming success, with its summer legal programs that provided intensive training in applying free market economic (i.e. libertarian) analyses to legal decision-making for law professors and federal judges. It lured them to attend with luminaries and luxury accommodations. By 1990 more than 40% of sitting federal judges had participated in this program! These judges were gradually bending the legal system towards the libertarians’ goals. Buchanan’s and Koch’s updated goals were similar to the old ones: remove progressive taxation in favor of a “flat tax”, ending the government monopoly on schooling (i.e. public schools and Universities), fighting feminism, environmentalism, and the increase in voting by the poor and minorities due to the National Voter Registration Act of 1993. They decided to call all these goals and the actions needed to accomplish them, fighting “socialism”. They also worried that with the fall of the Soviet Union, even conservative heads of state such as George W. Bush and Margaret Thatcher no longer saw the need to devote vast sums to an arms race, which meant less money to the defense contractors, etc. and perhaps more money used for the common good (socialism).</p><h4>6. Current Status of the Plan: US Democracy in Danger</h4><p>The current libertarian practices contain an inherent self-contradiction. Libertarians constantly talk about “liberty” and “freedom” by which they mean that each individual, no matter how wealthy, has right to the control of his own wealth, even when the majority of the population thinks it might be put to better use serving the public interest. However extremely wealthy libertarians, e.g. Koch, have turned to coercion, including trickery, through deceiving trusting people about their real intentions in order to take them to a place where, on their own, given complete information, they probably would not go. The shear size of the wealth involved, and the funding of so many think tanks, politicians, media outlets, etc. also give a few individuals an amount of power inconsistent with democratic rule.</p><p>As Joseph Goebbels said, “If you tell a big lie and repeat it often enough, people will eventually come to believe it.” Today one big lie of the Koch-sponsored radical right is that society can be split into “makers” and “takers”. Read the output of the libertarians writers subsidized by wealthy donors and you will encounter endless complaints about the “moocher class”. These arguments have a deeper purpose: a compulsion to control others, to limit their freedoms, in the name of ensuring one’s own liberty. What will this look like? Tyler Cowen, who succeeded Buchanan at the Mercatus Center of George Mason University explains: Cutting Medicaid and all other government benefits for the poor, “recreating a Mexico-like or Brazil-like environment”, complete with “partial shantytowns” (i.e. Rio de Janeiro style ghettos). This includes elimination of programs for public healthcare (Medicare, Medicaid, Obamacare, basic public sanitation laws) and even the nation’s school lunch program, which House Budget Chair and libertarian Paul Ryan said, left poor children with “a full stomach — and an empty soul”. These libertarian efforts are having large effects, for example, in Flint Michigan, for 18 months 100,000 residents were exposed to toxic water. What happened in Flint was directly attributable to the Mackinac Center, a Koch-funded and Koch-staffed “think and do” tank associated with the SPN (State Policy Network). The center pushed hard for and got laws allowing the governor to take over all aspects of local governments facing a “financial emergency”. The resulting “financial managers” had vast authority to impose austerity measures, including abrogating collective bargaining agreements, selling off local resources, changing suppliers, etc. By 2009, more than half of Michigan’s economically troubled black voters were being governed by such state appointed emergency managers. The citizen’s had no say in what these managers did; this was the “interpose” idea in full force. To save money, Flint’s emergency manager switched the source of the city’s water supply to the polluted Flint River. The Mackinac Center laws made sure that these appointed managers were protected against lawsuits.</p><p>These same libertarians are currently the leading proponents of climate change denial and anti-environmental laws, having learned techniques from tobacco companies that for years sowed doubt about science to keep the public from connecting smoking and illness. The Koch-funded CATO Institute, and the Club of Growth, among many others lead these misinformation campaigns. The wealth and power of these Koch-funded organizations is why in 2014 only 8 of the 278 Republicans in Congress were willing to acknowledge that man-made climate change was real. The Koch funded Heartland Institute sent a misinformation book about climate change to every science teacher in the USA (I myself received one!). Backing up this chokehold on federal action on the environment is a secret alliance between “red state” attorneys general and fossil fuel corporations to litigate in federal courts to obstruct environmental and other regulatory efforts. This is the strategy advocated by Buchanan and inspired by Calhoun going all the way back to the fight again desegregation in Brown vs. Board of Education.</p><p>It is clear that if the Koch-network-funded academics and institutions were not in the conversation, the public would have little doubt that government action is needed to prevent further global warming.</p><p>A related catastrophe is under way in the nation’s public school system. State governments, under the sway of the libertarians, are radically cutting budgets to public schools and steering the money into private schools, many of which are held to no standards or even disclosure requirements. For example, a shocked superior court judge found that the North Carolina General Assembly had violated the state constitution in sending children with tax subsidies to “private schools that have no legal obligation to teach them anything”. His verdict was overruled by the state supreme court, which the Koch cadre had spent handsomely to control for just such eventualities. The new for-profit virtual charter schools, whose CEO personally earned $4 million in 2004, were found by one Stanford University research study to have left their enrolled students falling far behind their public school counterparts, equivalent to missing “72 days of learning in reading and 180 days of learning in math.”</p><p>Just as the radical right seeks to turn public education over to corporations, so it pushes for corporate prisons. These give perverse incentives for tougher sentencing (more profits) and create wealthy entities who give funding to politicians who want to further privatize public services. Judges have been convicted of taking kickbacks from private detention systems for sentencing thousands of children to their facilities. This exactly is what is expected when democracy is removed from important public services.</p><p>Economic inequality is also being purposefully pushed by these libertarians. Koch-funded organizations such as ALEC, the SPN, and Americans for Prosperity pushed hard and have succeeded in passing laws destroying worker’s ability to organize into unions and negotiate for better wages and conditions. A major example is Governor Scott Walker’s destruction of unions in Wisconsin. His laws followed carefully the methods described by Buchanan and implemented by him in Chile under Pinochet. The method worked and the number of public employees belonging to unions dropped by half in just five years after implementation.</p><p>Of course the Koch team lead by CATO are attacking Social Security, again using the Buchanan game plan he implemented in Chile under Pinochet. The slogans are “privatization” and “personal responsibility”, but the goal is clearly to kill the whole system by establishing a system of individual accounts. In Chile this proved a huge boon to financial corporations that received automatic deductions from workers’ paychecks. The companies achieved an annual profit rate of more than 50 percent, thanks to their taking between a quarter and a third of the workers’ contributions as fees. After the Pinochet dictatorship fell, Chileans demanded again a public (socialized) pension system, but of course most of their savings were already gone to the wealthy libertarians.</p><p>But it is important to note that the biggest goal of the libertarian’s stealth plan is the changing of the US Constitution itself to reduce democracy in America and give more power to the wealthy. This plan became very explicit when Charles Koch set up shop at George Mason University, with Tyler Cowen laying the ground work in a 1997 paper for the Mercatus Center, “Why Does Freedom Wax and Wane”, telling how they needed to eradicate the “restrictions on liberty” characteristic of 20th century democracies. One key finding was that by the 1920s “the expansion of the voter franchise” beyond “wealthy landowners” had produced the unfortunate result of enlarged public sectors. A key problem was that the elimination of poll taxes and literacy tests leads to higher voter turnout, clearly a problem. Using the libertarian definition of “freedom” he pointed out that “The freest countries have not generally been democratic”, with Pinochet’s Chilean dictatorship being “the most successful”. The problem, he said, in creating the desired controlled-by-the-wealthy society of the past was that such a transformation “finds little or no support” among the people. “The weakening of the checks and balances” in the American system “would increase the chance of a very good outcome.” He stated that a direct attack on the Constitution could prove “disastrous”, so it was better to take advantage whenever shocks to the system occurred (as exemplified by the Pinochet coup in Chile). Cowen explicitly states the need to enable “weakening of the checks and balances”, first by selecting judges and eventually through constitutional amendment.</p><p>The goal of this vast legal shift is to make it all but impossible for the government to respond to the will of the majority unless the very wealthiest Americans agree fully with every measure. The shift includes making Arbitration rather than legal trials the norm; here the wealthy and large corporations take control of the “judges” and take away citizens right to sue, even when flagrant violations of the law take place. This is a form of “Privatization of the Justice System”, in complete agreement with the libertarian philosophy. The plan articulated by the Mercatus Center included emphasis on shaping public opinion through the use of the media. Key ideas included focussing on men (rather than woman), using insights from cognitive science to harness the irrationality of the electorate to get voters to unwittingly enable an “unpopular” agenda. The attack on what their spokesmen, Rush Limbaugh, called the “four corners of deceit” (science, academia, accurate news reporting, and the government) went into high gear. They realized that the emerging internet “appears especially well suited for rumor, gossip, and talk of conspiracy”.</p><p>For example, the planned legal shift is called restoring the founders vision for America, but in reality it is quite the opposite. The libertarian donor network has pumped hitherto unheard-of sums into state judicial races. The Citizen’s United Supreme Court decision which allowed unlimited and secret amounts of money into elections opened the spigots to state races where huge numbers of judges supportive of the Koch constitutional changes are being put in place. On the federal level, the Koch-funded Federalist Society and the Scaife and Olin-funded Judicial Watch networks have been grooming, organizing, and providing lists of “originalist” (i.e. libertarian) activists who agree with the above agenda, to Republican presidents for appointment to the federal judiciary. The result has been a transformation of the Judiciary the impact of which has just begun to appear. A recent example is the Roberts court narrowing of the meaning of the Commerce Clause of Article I of the US Constitution, which gives the Congress the ability to regulate interstate trade and has long been used to increase federal oversight on what some consider strictly private or state matters. These rulings reduce the reach of Brown vs. Board of Education (which made segregation in public schools illegal).</p><p>It is of note that in 1935 the conservative Supreme Court of that time changed the long held meaning of the Commerce Clause so that the federal government could not put any restrictions on private organizations, effectively striking down most of the New Deal. After FDR threatened to increase the number of Supreme Court justices, that Supreme Court backed down, and over time the FDR, Truman, and Eisenhower appointed Supreme Court Justices increased the scope and power of the federal government to regulate State and private entities, by again allowing the Commerce Clause to be interpreted broadly. Clearly the current libertarian plan is to get back to that very narrow 1935 interpretation of the Commerce Clause.</p><p>Simultaneously, while trying to increase State power vs. the federal government, the Koch-funded ALEX and SPN are pushing (and passing) laws that allow the States to deny municipal governments the right to make their own policies on matters hitherto within their purview. Examples include state laws to prevent cities from enacting measures to raise the minimum wage, protect the environment, or increase voter participation among poor and minority citizens. These ALEC guided state laws have become very numerous and are very successful at achieving their purpose (taking power away from local government and concentrating it at the state level where the wealthy libertarians have decided their best chance at control lies.) This assessment is correct since, as shown by the nonpartisan Center for Public Integrity, virtually every state government kowtows to business and the wealthy, underrepresents citizens of lesser means, lacks transparency, and does a poor job of enforcing ethics laws. Thus the promotion of “states rights” over federal and local rights is a cold-eyed way to secure minority rule.</p><p>Another part of the plan has been the most audacious gerrymandering in US history, again with the purpose of ensuring underrepresentation of Americans viewed as troublesome by the libertarian cause, as well as overrepresentation of the more manageable. Project REDMAP, funded by the libertarian billionaires, has as its goal, “a veto-proof supermajority operating without majority support”.</p><p>In summary, the libertarian cause, from the time it first attracted wider support during the desegregation battles in the South, was never really about freedom as most people would define it. It was about creation of division among the people to stop any interference of those who held vast power over others. Its leaders enlisted white supremacy in order to achieve capital supremacy. And currently, knowing that the majority does not share its goals, their team of paid operatives seek to win by stealth. The goal is liberty for the few, the liberty to concentrate vast wealth, and to deny elementary fairness and freedom to the many.</p><h4>7. What Can We Do About It?</h4><p>If the story I’ve told above seems surprising or unlikely to you, that is to be expected. Many very powerful organizations have worked for decades to ensure that many people, especially Republicans, believe the opposite of this true story. However, this story is actually true and well documented. What can ordinary people do about this problem?</p><p>Of course, if there were “good” billionaires, who cared as much about protecting democracy-for-the-common-good as the libertarian billionaires care about destroying it, fixing things would be easy. Those “progressive” billionaires could match the billions spent by the wealthy libertarians and could copy the libertarian billionaire playbook, but with reverse intentions. They could create think tanks and super-progressive news outlets to convince the public of their goals. They could select and elect progressive politicians who understand and are prepared to fight against the libertarian plan. They could make and fund policies to increase democracy for the common good, etc.</p><p>However, there don’t seem to be any billionaires like this in the USA. Bill Gates fights against tax increases for the wealthy (see <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/tax-billionaires-out-of-existence-8ddb7ffa6d2f?sk=5ce6d8a1a060e5dadaa5232e1efdee04).">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/tax-billionaires-out-of-existence-8ddb7ffa6d2f?sk=5ce6d8a1a060e5dadaa5232e1efdee04).</a> Warren Buffett “says” taxes should be increased on the wealthy, but then doesn’t pay much himself. Tom Steyer, and the other well-known “liberal” billionaires don’t support politicians or groups that are pointing out and working on the problems described in this article. And no one is putting the needed multi-billion of dollars into countering the libertarian plan and forcing implementation of real solutions.</p><p>So, it is up to us! Here are some preliminary ideas about what could be done.</p><p>Since a working democracy is the main power average people have to confront the libertarian plan to remove our democracy, it is clear that we need to quickly use whatever democracy remains in the US system to stop the plan. Since the libertarians have almost completely captured the Republican party and also much of the “moderate” Democratic party, the most important need is to vote out of office all Republicans and most moderate Democrats. We need our elected representatives to understand and reverse the libertarian plan and goals; thus progressive politicians such Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. etc. need to be elected in large numbers. In order to do this we need the American people to change their attitudes towards these liberal politicians and causes. Several steps might help.</p><p><strong>First</strong>, we need to bring out in the open this secret plan to destroy Middle Class power and democracy for the common good. This entails several things:</p><p><strong>a.</strong>Recognize when science, academia, reliable news sources, and the government are being attacked. Let people know that these institutions are not the problem, but the solution.</p><p><strong>b</strong>. Continually point the blame towards the wealthy conservative/libertarians, their think tanks, and their news outlets. Expose and publicize their sneaky attempts to undermine democracy. FDR implemented the New Deal, in large part, by getting average Americans to blame the wealthy, and the large corporations they controlled and hid behind, for the Great Depression, for low wages, for pollution, and for most of the problems in society. Currently most people admire the wealthy and most of the press lionizes them. If we are to return to the needed high taxes on the wealthy and rein in their power, somehow this has to change. We have to counter the false argument that high taxes on the wealthy are somehow “unfair”.</p><p>When elements of their plan appear in the media, we need to point out the source and why they should not be trusted. We need to watch for and call out libertarian sources such as CATO institute, Hoover Institute, American Enterprise Institute, Heritage Foundation, Federalist Society, Judicial Watch, , Project Veritas, Pacific Research Institute, Heartland Institute, FreedomWorks, Americans for Prosperity, Family Research Council, Turning Point USA, US Chamber of Commerce, ALEC, Infowars, OAN, Newsmax, Daily Wire, Breitbart, Federalist, Fox News, and hundreds of others.</p><p><strong>c.</strong>Publicize the history and ideas contained in this paper. They will need to be repeated often before the general public will be able overcome the pervasive messaging of the libertarians who are trying to hide these ideas.</p><p><strong>Second</strong>, the tax system needs to be returned to how it was during the FDR administration (or at least the Nixon administration), that is, much higher taxes on the extremely wealthy. Furthermore, capital gains and inheritance taxes need to be greatly increased to stop, or better yet reverse, the decline of the Middle Class. A wealth tax should be instituted to reduce the wealth, and therefore the power, of the wealthy. Somehow the bulk of Americans must be educated to understand this need for higher taxes on the wealthy. If this is not done the average American (Middle Class) will soon be so poor as to have almost no ability to resist the wealthy.</p><p><strong>Third</strong>, strong laws stopping large corporations and the wealthy from dominating elections via massive donations need to be enacted. We need to have one person-one vote elections, not the current system of one dollar-one vote. Publically funded elections would help, as would getting as much private money as possible out of elections. Somehow the Citizen’s United Supreme Court decision must be countered.</p><p><strong>Fourth</strong>, we need to work hard for laws, programs, and policies that promote democracy for the common good: universal public health care, universal public education (including college), strong environmental laws, strong human rights laws, strong voter rights laws, etc.</p><p>Many other actions are also needed, too numerous to list here.</p><p>And besides the many problems discussed in this paper, somehow, the even larger problems of human induced climate change and environmental destruction, need to be addressed. All this will not be easy, but with patience and persistence I believe it possible get America and the entire world on track towards real democracy and to create a nation and a world that works for everyone and not the just wealthy.</p><h4>7. Appendix: Some Specific Examples</h4><p><strong>1a. Attacks on Science:</strong>Many attempts are being made to decrease the public’s trust in science. From cigarettes don’t cause cancer, to climate change denial, to anti-vaccination propaganda, libertarian organizations and media outlets constantly misrepresent science. Fact based science is a powerful weapon against the lies of the libertarians, so if the public can be made to distrust science, then environmental, food, and drug regulations can weakened. Since science obviously works, it is attacked selectively and indirectly. Science that hurts the conservative/libertarian agenda is made to seem more uncertain than it is, while parts of science that help the conservative/libertarian agenda are strongly supported to make it seem that the libertarian plan is NOT actually anti-science (e.g. new military weapons, computer and information technology, new drugs, and new chemicals.) This deliberate deception of the public needs to be repeatedly pointed out.</p><p><strong>1b. Attacks on Academia</strong>: Experts in history, social science, economics, etc., whose work adheres to high academic standards tend to speak facts that are supported by evidence. This can undermine much of the conservative/libertarian agenda. Experts at famous Universities are therefore disparaged and countered with privately funded “experts” from libertarian think tanks .The public is often fooled into thinking the opinions of both these sets of people are equally valid, while, of course, the privately funded pundits have no need to stick to the facts since their jobs depend on what their opinions are, and not whether or not their reasoning and facts are correct. Academics at universities are held to much higher standards.</p><p>An example of an attack on academia comes from Peter Thiel, the libertarian billionaire founder of Paypal and Palantir, famous for denigrating and trying to undermine the public university systems and public education. He repeatedly has said that higher education is a waste of time and ruins young people. He tried (and failed) to prove this by giving $100,000 to a very select group of students to drop out of college and start businesses. These “Thiel Fellows” have basically failed. The ones who succeeded did so mostly because of others (e.g. their parents created and ran their businesses using the Thiel money) and many of them have gone back to college to finish their education. Thiel falsely claims that universities indoctrinate people to be liberal, but actual research shows that college students actually become more tolerant of both conservatives and liberals because they interact with a more diverse group of people than they knew in high school. They also learn critical thinking skills that makes them more difficult to fool; this is a main reason the libertarian billionaires want to discredit academia and the universities. Also, university faculty write high quality papers and books based upon careful research and facts. These publications often go against the lies and propaganda the libertarian billionaires are trying to fool us with. Thiel also has given many millions of dollars to many dozens of extreme rightwing/libertarian politicians, including Donald Trump and many libertarian/conservative “think (propaganda) tanks” such as the “Club of Growth”. People like Thiel need to be exposed and confronted.</p><p><strong>1c. Attacks on accurate news reporting</strong>: An entire alternative fact media structure has been created to repeat the lies and propaganda helpful to the libertarian plan. Examples include billionaire Rupert Murdoch’s Fox News, billionaire Robert Mercer’s Breitbart and Infowars, the billionaire Wilk brother’s PragerU, the Kochs’ CATO and Heartland Institutes, OAN, Newsmax, along with hundreds of other sources and armies of paid social media influencers who work to counter the more fact based narrative that the main stream news ordinarily provides. These fake-news organizations need to be exposed and alternative (i.e. reliable) news sources recommended. For more on this see my article: <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/what-are-reliable-sources-of-information-5a7559bb42bb?sk=f5a5a0013748cd15270e3c1373f439a9">https://medium.com/@kimgriest/what-are-reliable-sources-of-information-5a7559bb42bb?sk=f5a5a0013748cd15270e3c1373f439a9</a></p><p><strong>1d. Attacks on government</strong>: A democratic government is pretty much the only force powerful enough to stand up to the oligarchic forces the billionaires and large corporations have orchestrated. Thus, a key component of the libertarian plan is that public should be made to distrust the government as much as possible. The Reagan slogan “The government is the problem” is endlessly repeated to convince people to vote against their own interests. We need to endlessly confront these efforts to fool people, and let people know that a more democratic government is the solution, not the problem.</p><p><strong>2. Stacking the Judiciary with libertarians: </strong>The Federalist Society, along with other groups, continue to select and train libertarian lawyers, to use the libertarian legal networks to get them into the best law schools, to obtain the best clerkships, and finally to pressure presidents and governors into placing them into federal and state judgeships, especially the Supreme Court. We need to expose these networks as the anti-democratic institutions they are. Recommendation by the Federalist Society should be looked at as disqualifying.</p><p><strong>3.Paving the way for getting rid of all government restraints on the power of the wealthy</strong>. The plan is no rules against lobbying or paying for politicians, no anti-trust regulations, no FDA to prevent corporations from selling snake oil, no FCC to prevent advertisers from lying, no banking regulation, etc. That is, complete control of the country by the wealthy and the large corporations they control. Billionaires Sheldon Adelson, Charles Koch, and the Walton Family, as well as the Coors, Olin, Scaife foundations, and many wealthy people and large corporations strongly support these goals. These plans need to be exposed and whenever the above billionaires are involved a red flag should be raised.</p><p><strong>5.Hundreds of other efforts at local, state, and federal levels are being made to implement the libertarian plan</strong>. We need to notice and confront each of these efforts. For example, the libertarians control the Republican party by the threat of well-funded primary challenges to force it’s elected officials to do their bidding or lose seats. They also push radical right laws in every state legislature through the extremely well organized American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). These laws are sold through the seemingly independent but centrally funded and operationally linked groups of the State Policy Network. These networks need to be exposed as the anti-democratic organizations they are.</p><p><strong>6. New examples appear in the newspapers every day.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46555278d883" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Liberals Hate America]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/why-liberals-hate-america-42447431016a?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42447431016a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[propaganda]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2020 21:53:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-05T22:33:42.202Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Liberals hate America because the corporate-sponsored right wing loudmouths need a dangerous enemy to rant about so that can they slip through laws and policies that are not in the interest of the majority of Americans. They used to blame the communists, but since the end of the cold war that doesn’t work as well. Liberals, foreign terrorists, and democratic socialists are now the needed outside enemy. Liberals, of course, actually are the ones who have given us most of the best things in America. Liberals ended slavery. Liberals gave women the right to vote, and before that the right to go to school. Liberals did away with child labor, sweat shops, indentured servitude, and debtor prisons. Liberals gave us U.S. senators elected by popular vote rather than appointed. Liberals gave Blacks the right to vote, laws to protect the environment and the consumer. Liberals gave us Social Security, Medicare, mental hospitals, public schools, and of course don’t forget the weekend. Conservative big corporations, the rich people who ran them, and their dupes, fought all these changes. [Note, the dupes include many groups of people, but especially conservative Christians, people with strong prejudices of all types, and gullible “fiscal conservatives”.] They made the same claims then against all these changes as they do now against the current liberal agenda. They said these changes cost too much and will ruin the economy. They said these changes were anti-American and against the Bible. That last claim was probably true since the Bible endorses slavery, says women and children are the property of men, and of course allows us only one day of rest.</p><p>The average person, of course, is happy that all the above changes made by liberals were made, and would certainly endorse the current liberal agenda if they actually thought about it. The current liberal agenda is really just a continuation of the 200 year tradition defined by the changes above: more freedom for individuals and more responsibility for corporations. Human health and happiness above tradition and above profit for the rich. Equal rights for all people, removal of special rights for the rich. Long term planning instead of short term profit. Thus the current liberal agenda includes stronger health and environmental laws and limits on destruction of forests and oceans. It includes removal of discrimination against the handicapped, gays, and women. It includes policies that promote fairness and peace in the world, rather than policies that increase the power of multi-national corporations.</p><p>Since to sneak in its anti-middle-class agenda requires falsely attacking some enemy, conservatives also are required to have much less regard for the truth. They need to build fear and prejudice, and the easiest way to do that is to distort facts and lie about their chosen targets of hatred. Liberals have a basic belief in honesty and truth, so are at a short term disadvantage. This is why distortion of scientific facts is a conservative policy: e.g. tobacco is not harmful to health, global warming is not happening, Saddaam Hussein was behind 9/11 and has nuclear weapons, etc.</p><p>So, it is just to keep us from thinking about the liberal agenda, that the right wing corporate controlled media keeps telling us that liberals hate America.</p><p>Liberals are and always have been the true Americans and our only hope. We have always been attacked by the powerful, but we always keep fighting. We may be delayed by the right-wing-Christian anti-middle-class agenda, but as the above list of accomplishments show, we always win in the end.</p><p>So next time someone asks why liberals hate America, you can tell them why.</p><p><strong>Frequently Asked Questions</strong></p><p><strong>Lincoln was a Republican, so how can you say liberals freed the slaves? And where did all these “liberal victory” examples come from anyway</strong>?</p><p>First, it is important to counter the false conservative narrative that today’s Republicans have anything to do with the liberal, big government party of Lincoln. It is well established by many careful historical analyses that, over time, the Republican party switched from liberal during Lincoln’s time to conservative today. (For a short description see: <a href="https://thecompletepilgrim.com/how-the-democrats-became-liberals-and-how-the-republicans-became-conservatives/">https://thecompletepilgrim.com/how-the-democrats-became-liberals-and-how-the-republicans-became-conservatives/</a> or even just read the wikipedia page on the Republican Party.)</p><p>Second, perhaps surprisingly, many of the examples I use of liberal victories are taken from my own family’s personal experience!</p><p>I come from a Quaker family on my Dad’s side; we’ve been in America since the 1600’s, and we’ve been liberals (and fought conservatives) that entire time!</p><p>My great-great-great grandfather published an abolishionist newspaper before the civil war, and wrote a book titled “The Fugitive Slaves”, where he describes his family’s use of the Griest homestead in Pennsylvania as part of the underground railroad helping fugitives slaves escape from the South. He fought in the civil war on the side of the North, even though many Quakers, including some of my relatives, were passivists. His book details the conflicts between the liberal Quakers and the extremely racist conservative Christians of that era.</p><p>My great-…-great aunt, Ann Preston, was a founder and dean of the first Medical College for Women in the US (still part of the U of Penn Medical School). When she finally won the right to bring her female students to observe surgeries at one of Philadelphia’s teaching hospitals, the male doctors and students gave her and her students catcalls and spitballs. The newspapers of the day disapproved of that, saying that was no way to treat women, but agreed that it was ridiculous for women to try and become doctors. Aren’t we all glad we liberals eventually won that battle?</p><p>My family was active in the suffragette movement. All you women who like to vote can thank us liberals for that. My grandfather worked with Linus Pauling on his Nobel Peace Prize winning “Ban the Bomb” movement (which gave us the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty of 1963), my uncle was head of the anti-war Peace Center at the University of Missouri, and my parents met just after WWII (in which my father fought) at the “Interracial Eating Co-op” at the University of Wisconsin; in those days just sitting down and eating with Black people was considered a radical act done only by Whites who were extreme liberals! I myself have taken in place in many liberal/environmental/social justice/anti-war causes, and I’ve watched as we liberals have improved America in so many ways (some of which are listed above).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42447431016a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Are Reliable Sources of Information?]]></title>
            <link>https://kimgriest.medium.com/what-are-reliable-sources-of-information-5a7559bb42bb?source=rss-77976fc4f86f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a7559bb42bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kim Griest]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2020 02:36:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-09T03:46:56.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Many have noticed a profusion of “fake news” and incorrect information circulating in the media. Is there any way to distinguish information that is strongly biased, distorted, or even fabricated from information more in line with reality? This article is an attempt to answer that question. The executive summary at the end of the article contains my ranked list of trustworthy and untrustworthy sources of information.</em></p><p><em>Kim Griest: July 2020</em></p><h3><strong>Introduction</strong></h3><p>First, note that as a scientist, I am convinced that not all information is equally correct. Some people think that all opinions are equally valid and it is OK to say: “My beliefs are true for me and yours can be true for you”. On topics of aesthetics or even morality, this may be true, e.g. Is Matisse or Picasso the better painter? But in many cases one “fact” or “theory” is true and the others are false. In the 17th century there were two popular theories about the relationship between the Sun and the Earth. Some thought the Sun circled the Earth and others thought the Earth circled the Sun. One theory was false and the other was true, though the argument went on for around 100 years before the true theory became accepted. In the same way, for around 50 years, wealthy people and tobacco companies stated that there was no proof that cigarettes caused cancer, while almost all scientists said, yes, the proof exists. One side was wrong and the other right. Currently most conservative/libertarian billionaires and politicians say that human burning of fossil fuels is not causing global warming/climate change. Scientists almost uniformly say it is. Again, one side is wrong and the other correct.</p><p>So, I start from the hypothesis that in many cases where there is disagreement on an issue with two or more sides, one side is right and the others are wrong, especially when the disagreement is about measurable things, facts of history, or scientific ideas. I also believe there are many cases that are purely matters of point of view, morality, or opinion. These can be vigorously argued as long as all sides of the debate stick to actual true information to support their views.</p><p>But how to tell whether to believe the tobacco and oil companies or the scientific community? That is the question we ask here.</p><p>The most important thing when questioning the reliability of information is to know the reputation of the source of the information. It’s just like with people; you trust people who have a reputation for honesty and a history of telling you the truth. And you distrust information coming from people who have lied to you in the past. Thus one should believe information coming from sources with a history of truth-telling and ignore information coming from sources with a history of distortion, or strong bias, or lying.</p><p>The second most important thing is probably the motivation of the source. If a media source is wholly owned by a person or corporation, it is very likely that no information that will harm that person or corporation will ever be published. If I owned a newspaper, it would never publish anything bad about me; it’s my newspaper, and that’s what ownership means. Wealthy people and corporations, of course, use their wealth to increase their wealth, so wariness is warranted when information from a given source might help or hurt the profits of that source.</p><p>Next, information coming from multiple, independent sources is more likely to be correct than information coming from a single source.</p><p>Finally, common sense is important. Remarkable claims require remarkable evidence, so awareness should be heightened when a claim is surprising, unusual, or contradicts other, well accepted, things.</p><p>So given the above what sources are most reliable? This is the question everyone should be asking! Please make a list for yourself of reliable and unreliable sources. Then follow it! Don’t read, click on, quote from, or repost ANY information coming from sources you have decided are unreliable.</p><p>Now, some argue that even unreliable sources sometimes give true and even important information. They claim you should read things from all sources, even unreliable ones, and then “decide for yourself”. In my opinion, this is a waste of time. A broken clock sometimes has the correct time (twice a day), but it can never be used to tell time, because you never know WHEN that is, without checking a working clock. In the same way, an unreliable source MAY give correct reporting or analysis, but you can’t know when that is without checking a reliable source. So with both a broken clock and an unreliable news source, just skip the unreliable source and go straight to a reliable source. If the topic interests you, you can try to find information on that topic from a source from your “reliable” list. If you can’t find it, then just assume the information is untrue and move on. If the information is true, trust that it will eventually come out from a reliable source.</p><h3><strong>Ranking Trustworthy Information Sources</strong></h3><p>So using source reputation, source ownership, multiple sourcing, and common sense, which information sources are the most reliable? In my opinion, number one in reliability are peer-reviewed papers in reputable scientific journals.</p><p>Scientists use a kind of democracy to ensure that the information they consume is true. Other reputable scientists read each submitted paper and send comments/questions to the author. Only if those other scientists are convinced that there was no exaggeration, deception, or mistakes, is the paper accepted for publication. Of course, mistakes are made and sometimes scientists fool other scientists and get bad information published. The scientific community has a way of correcting these errors however. When it is discovered that an author falsified data or made mistakes, other authors write papers correcting that mistake. If it is shown to be falsified data, then the falsifying author’s reputation is destroyed, and typically no other scientist will ever read or consider another paper by that person. Scientists live in fear of making mistakes and tarnishing their reputations. Scientists accused of fraud whose reputations are ruined are exiled and sometimes become bitter, turning against others in the field and even science itself. So one should be careful of scientists whose reputations are not good among others in their field.</p><p>Note, that only scientists with very good reputations are asked to referee papers (and also referee grant proposals), so science is a self-correcting, truth-finding system. Random errors and unlikely chances can also cause scientific results to be wrong, so for important results, the work is repeated several times until there is almost no chance of it being incorrect. This is the gold standard for information: Repeatedly checked, peer-reviewed theories and data.</p><p>Now some people complain that science changes and old theories are proved false and replaced by new ones. This is true. Sometimes what is considered true is proved false (or more likely not as accurate as some new data or theory), and science has to change. That is a good thing! It in no way undermines the fact that peer-reviewed articles in reputable journals are the most reliable sources of information we have, even if there can be wrong theories, mistakes, and out-of-date facts published in them. Note also, that scientists are less impressed with brand new results than the general public. It sometimes takes time to repeat an experiment or calculation or to discover mistakes. So science “news” is not the best source of reliable information. Probably the absolute best sources are “review papers”; usually famous scientists reviewing the entire scientific literature on a given subject and listing what is known with high confidence, what is known with some confidence, and what is still uncertain. One typically has to be an expert in the field to be able to read these high end review papers, so the general public has to rely on reputable science reporters who try and simplify things for the non-expert. Sometimes errors are made in the simplification, so again going to the experts with specific questions is often the best method. Thus one must distinguish between real science and “science news” where the problem of oversimplification is compounded with the problem of results not yet completely vetted and reproduced.</p><p>Some also say that scientists are only in it for their grant money and so can’t be trusted. While grants are very important to scientists, in democratic nations, grants are awarded competitively by panels of scientists themselves. Having sat on many such panels, I can attest that we award grants to the scientists who make the most interesting proposals and who we think are most capable of succeeding at making original, accurate, and transformative discoveries. Fame and prestige in science come from overthrowing a standard theory or from discovering something really new. Thus scientists are bad at defending the status quo merely for the sake tradition; we all want to be the one who starts a scientific revolution. And when someone else starts a scientific revolution, we want to be among the first to work in the exciting new field, where important discoveries are easier to make. Of course, science has a very tough standard of proof, and a really new discovery requires remarkably strong evidence, so mostly we end up just adding a small detail to the body of science, or proving that the standard theory is correct yet again.</p><p>So top of our list of reliable sources is <strong><em>Number 1: peer-reviewed scientific papers in reputable journals, with well-received review articles being the cream of this top category</em>.</strong>My entire list of reliable and unreliable sources is given in the Executive Summary at the end of the article.</p><p>Related to my top category of review papers are government reports that are supposed to be reviews of some topic. Examples included papers from NASA, the US CDC or Department of Energy and international reports from the World Health Organization (W.H.O.), the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), etc. We list these information sources as number 2 in reliability, somewhat below the refereed journal article category because of the “ownership” problem. Almost all reputable journals let scientists control what gets published. Many journals are published by the scientific organizations themselves and even for those that are privately owned (e.g. Elsevier), scientists are in complete control of the content. The fees that are charged by these privately owned publishers are independent of content, so there is no obvious advantage to the owners for publishing false information; especially since the journal’s reputation is of such importance. In some cases scientists themselves have patent rights to some drug or invention they publish, and the journals usually require disclosure of these “conflicts of interest”. However, still there are cases where scientists distort or fabricate things for their own financial benefit; after all, scientists are humans with human desires. One must always look carefully when financial interests are at stake, and lower one’s trust in any article where one suspects financial incentives. However, in general, especially in science areas where patents are not involved, the scientists themselves have no financial incentive to distort or lie. They are in it for pure curiosity, or fame, or promotions, and the fear of destroying their reputation by a mistake or distortion keeps the vast majority of scientists careful and honest.</p><p>So, information coming from government agencies where the reports are prepared by famous scientists is also usually very reliable for the same reasons; they are supposedly reviews of literature with no obvious advantage to authors for distorting or lying. However, this is only true for democracies and for international organizations where scientists themselves are in control, and where the line-of-command is clear. In dictatorships, such as China or Saudi Arabia, where free speech is not available, official reports should be viewed as political documents and treated with great caution. Examples include Saudi Arabia’s fabricated “official” reporting of their oil reserves, or China’s Covid-19 deaths and rates. Semi-democracies, such as Russia are also suspect since the government can easily control what is published. International documents such as the IPCC report on climate change caused by fossil fuel burning are quite reliable since scientists from many democracies write them, but still these reports do not reach the same level of trustworthiness as peer-reviewed review articles in reputable journals, since the content is subject to political review by the member nations. If the political interference is too great, then scientists, worried about their reputation, will resign, so the information can’t get too far from true. Again it is important to know the history and reputation of each publishing source. NASA and the CDC have sterling reputations and so are very trustworthy. Some review paper from an unknown source, is much more uncertain. And a review paper from a source known in the past to distort or fabricate (e.g. Saudi Arabia Oil Ministry) should never be trusted. In between we have organizations such as the W.H.O. who do have pressure placed upon them by various governments and have occasionally given in to that pressure.</p><p>Thus we list our 2nd and 3rd most reliable sources of information in the Executive Summary: <strong>Number 2. Official information coming from reputable places: NASA, CDC, US Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Department of Energy, major universities, etc</strong>. And <strong>Number 3. Government laboratories in nations with elected, democratic governments.</strong></p><p>After reputable organizations made up of reputable people, the next most trustworthy sources are articles or books published by individuals with good reputations. If you want to know the “facts” of history, a well-known historian from a high reputation university is a good bet. There are, of course, exceptions. So we have: <strong>Number 4. Published works by reputable academics from well-known universities.</strong></p><p>Of course, much information we are interested in is not published in scientific journals and is not scientific in nature. And usually “facts” make it into history articles and books long after they are current. How should we choose reliable information of this type (which is normally known as news)?</p><p>Again, reputation, source ownership, multiple sources, and common sense are important. Since Chomsky’s and Herman’s seminal book: Manufacturing Consent, in the 1980s, the topic of bias in news sources based on source ownership and the interests of the powerful has been studied deeply. We will not try to even recap that research here. For many topics, no regular news source is really accurate, and one must develop special sources for those topics. In the US almost all media is owned by wealthy people and/or large corporations, so one cannot expect to find information which is bad for business interests or the wealthy in any normal news source. For example, even the supposedly liberal New York Times repeated and strongly supported the lies of the G.W. Bush administration in the buildup to the Iraq invasion. Understanding the how and why of this is beyond the scope of this short article. However, here we are not writing for the sophisticated progressive, but for the average person who is confused by the contradictory “news” coming from their facebook friend’s posts. If you are interested in understanding the “why”, you might start with the most recent edition of Chomsky’s and Herman’s book, or look at my short article: <a href="https://medium.com/@kimgriest/why-so-much-pseudo-science-garbage-on-the-internet-b1ae2fb8cd5"><strong>https://medium.com/@kimgriest/why-so-much-pseudo-science-garbage-on-the-internet-b1ae2fb8cd5</strong></a></p><p>So, here, we will take a simplified approach toward ranking normal news sources. There are several groups that rank sources on media bias and fact reliability, and there are even courses at universities on this subject. I recommend relying on these rating groups until you develop your own list of trustworthy and untrustworthy sources.</p><p>The best rating website I’ve come across so far is <strong>adfontesmedia.com</strong>. This source is recommended by the Cornell University Library and is rated as very reliable and “least biased” by other rating websites such as <strong>mediabiasfactcheck.com</strong>. I like Ad Fontes (which means “to the sources” in Latin) because it rates news sources on both the “Information Quality” and the “Liberal vs. Conservative” scales. I am not very interested in the Liberal vs. Conservative rating, because these ratings are really just opinions: they use a panel of a conservative, a liberal, and a neutral judge to rate “Liberal” vs. “Conservative”. However, I am very interested in the information quality rating, which they calculate by reading and fact checking a sample of articles from each information source. Ad Fontes is trying to make money by subscriptions, so I find their current free charts a little hard to use, but here is a plot from a year or so ago.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iMqVcQJPyjlGSmYjLlNSiw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Media Bias Chart from Ad Fontes</figcaption></figure><p>Please spend some time with this figure, noting especially that the lower a source is listed on the figure, the more unreliable it is. I think it is important to use mainly sources from the Green and Yellow boxes, and to ignore sources from the Orange and Red boxes. The Green Box (<em>fact reporting</em>) and Yellow Box (<em>analysis and fair interpretations of the news</em>) include many well-known sources from both the left and right: e.g. AP, Reuters, NPR, Bloomberg, Christian Science Monitor, BBC, USA Today, Wall Street Journal, ABC News, CBS News, New York Times, Washington Post, Guardian, etc.</p><p>The Orange Box (<em>selective or incomplete stories with unfair interpretations of the news</em>) and Red Box (<em>inaccurate/fabricated information including nonsense damaging to public discourse</em>) include the Daily KOS, OAN, Drudge Report, Occupy Democrats, Daily Wire, National Enquirer, Infowars, and Fox News.</p><p>So, if you like conservative analysis, I recommend switching from FOX, Breitbart, etc. which are in the Red Box, and subscribing to the Wall Street Journal or The Hill which are in the Green Box. For a left wing/neutral viewpoint, most any of the well-known media sources are OK, with the most well- known being the highest quality. Also, note that local FOX news stations would be counted as “local news” which are listed in the “reliable” area of the figure. Of course, there are differences between different local media sources, and one should check for yourself the reliability of your own local news sources.</p><p>So, in conclusion, before clicking on a friend’s facebook post, check the source byline. If it is FOX news, or one of the other sources in the “Red Box”, then I recommend not clicking on it. Why fill your mind with information that is very likely false? Try to find information on that subject from a source with a good reputation. If the post is a video from someone on youtube, see if you can find the actual source. If you can’t, then be very suspicious and don’t trust anything you hear that sounds unlikely. Hope this helps.</p><h3><strong>Frequently Asked Question:</strong></h3><p>Question: Someone quotes results published in a scientific journal. Should I believe that result? Answer: From the list in the executive summary this seems like an easy question, but it is actually a tricky question! You need to ask (and answer) two questions first.</p><p>1. Is it a reputable journal? I have a colleague who couldn’t get his nutcase theory published in any reputable Physics Journal, so he started his own online journal! It is called “Journal of Cosmology”, which sounds very respectable. Of course it published his garbage papers. This journal is now known by normal scientists as a “fake journal” and no practicing scientist ever looks at or refers to anything published in it. But unless you are an expert in the field how would you know that? You have to ask an expert! Or do research on the reputation of that journal. Unfortunately there are thousands of such fake journals now, so be careful.</p><p>2. How recent is the paper and has the result been reproduced? Very recent results are always a little suspect. There is some review done by the paper’s referee(s), but that is usually only one or two people and could be the friend of the authors. Until other scientists have the chance to read, think about, and try to reproduce a given result, it is fine to be curious, or even excited about a new result, but one should hold onto some skepticism. If the result has been around a while, has been reproduced, has other papers making use of the results, etc. then the result is much more likely to be correct and can be believed. Of course, ALL scientific results are subject to change/revision/overthrow and scientists are aware of this. However, remarkable results require remarkable evidence, so if a result is unusual and out-of-line with past results, common knowledge, or common sense, then one should remain skeptical until very compelling data is at hand. Of course, many currently accepted theories went through this stage: Einstein’s Relativity, Quantum Mechanics, Plate Tectonics, etc. were very unusual and out-of-line with accepted conventions when they first appeared. It is always an exciting time in science when such revolutions happen, but such revolutions are fairly rare and really only experts in the relevant field can tell what is going on at such times.</p><h3><strong>Executive Summary</strong></h3><h4><strong>Trustworthy sources of information in ranked order, with number 1 being the most trustworthy.</strong></h4><p>1. Peer reviewed scientific papers in reputable journals, especially review articles by respected experts in the relevant field.</p><p>2. Official information coming from reputable places: NASA, CDC, US Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Department of Energy, major universities, etc.</p><p>3. Government laboratories in nations with elected, democratic governments.</p><p>4. Published papers and books by reputable academics at well-known universities.</p><p>5. Reputable news sources not owned by conservative/libertarian billionaires, large corporations, or non-democratic governments, for example, the BBC, NPR, the Guardian, Christian Science Monitor, etc.</p><p>6. News sources owned by the wealthy or large corporations, but which have shown they care about their reputation for accurate reporting: AP, Reuters, Bloomberg, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, LA Times, Financial Times, etc.</p><p><strong>[Note: Sources listed in items 7 and 8 should be considered untrustworthy and unreliable.]</strong></p><p>7. Sources owned by the wealthy, large corporations, or their followers, that have consistently been shown to distort, misinform, or lie: FOX news, OAN, Daily Express, many AM talk radio shows, Breitbart, Infowars, Daily Wire, Project Veritas, Judicial Watch, etc.</p><p>8. High quality, seemingly professionally produced, youtube videos by “disaffected insiders” that are designed to emotionally manipulate you into accepting some strange pseudo-science or conspiracy theory. (Who is paying for these videos anyway?)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a7559bb42bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>