<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Megan K on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Megan K on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kirkwoodmegan1?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 23:11:16 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kirkwoodmegan1/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Algorithmic Futures: How Futuristic Fiction Portrays Human Free Will in Neoliberal Capitalism]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/algorithmic-futures-how-futuristic-fiction-portrays-human-free-will-in-neoliberal-capitalism-b4bc6f7efbd6?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b4bc6f7efbd6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[westworld]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neoliberalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Mar 2021 18:51:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-31T18:51:29.711Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>*Spoilers ahead for <em>Westworld</em> (2016-present) seasons 1–3*</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1020/1*3E4k2HX9G4n4LR3b-SlPaA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Promotional Image for Westworld Season 3</figcaption></figure><p>In narratives depicting the future, usually science fiction texts, technology dictates the story. The sub-genre of the “15-minutes from now” science fiction proves popular television programming in recent years, from the cult classic Netflix anthology series <em>Black Mirror</em> (2011-present), to HBO’s <em>Westworld</em> (2016-present), and the French Netflix series <em>Osmosis</em> (2019). These three series share themes of Big Data and algorithmic manipulation in the context of the near-future. They ask the question: in societies so controlled, quantified, and algorithmically “predictable”, can humans have free-will, or are we always being guided and manipulated by our technology? This question has long been debated between the technological determinists and the social constructivists; the former arguing that technology and its development is responsible for social and historical change or progression, in other words, that technology changes society, whilst the latter argues that social and historical conditions produce a society’s technology, or, society makes technology. Often, the view of capitalist technological progressivists like Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos portray technological determinism as holding the belief that technology alone can save humanity. Reductive views like this point to the larger issue that technology now equates to capitalism, and that capitalism is the winning social order. This is a point to bear in mind, as it points to the prevalence of <a href="https://musingmind.org/capitalist-realism">Capitalist Realism.</a></p><p>To go back to the actual definition of the phrase, technological determinism as a term was ‘<a href="https://www.communicationtheory.org/technological-determinism/">coined by Thorstein Veblen</a>’ but has historically been associated with Karl Marx, ‘<a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10798-020-09600-2">although many philosophers and historians now also question whether Marx himself was really a technological determinist’</a>. However, in summary, ‘<a href="https://www.communicationtheory.org/technological-determinism/">Karl Marx believed that technological progress lead to newer ways of production in a society and this ultimately influenced the cultural, political and economic aspects of a society, thereby inevitably changing society itself. He explained this statement with the example of how a feudal society that used a hand mill slowly changed into an industrial capitalist society with the introduction of the steam mill</a>’. In this reading, it was the change of technology that created a new industrial capitalist social order and the values attributed to such a social order.</p><p>The main issue with the idea of technological determinism, apart from its reductive ‘<a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.17351/ests2015.010">unicausal explanation of historical change</a>’, is the fact that people <strong>make </strong>the technology, and they make it within specific socio-historical periods, responding to the needs and wants of the population of the time. Softer versions of technological determinism ‘<a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10798-020-09600-2">do[…] not, on the face of it, presuppose autonomous technology. It could be that free, creative inventors devise technology, but that this technology determines the rest of society and culture’</a>. To explore this further, we need to examine some proponents of this view that technology produces society, as it can be hard to shake the feeling that society is the producer of all things, not the objects themselves.</p><p>Jacques Ellul, author of the highly influential book <em>The Technological System </em>(1954), ‘<a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/autonomous-technology">claims that modern technology, unlike traditional technology, is not bound by any heteronomous rules or principles, but develops according to its own rules […]. Rather, technological change itself now defines the context of other aspects of culture such as capitalist competition for survival in the market. The pursuit of human well-being, presumably the purpose of technological development, is replaced by obsessive pursuit of efficiency</a>’. Ellul argues that modern societies are driven by a need to progress for progress’s sake, where technological development is the ultimate end in itself. In this way, technology is autonomous as it adheres only to the value of progress itself. This view suggests that societal and historical development are led with the common belief being ‘<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261947854_Technological_Determinism_is_Dead_Long_Live_Technological_Determinism">that technological progress equals social progress. This was the view of Lenin (1920) when he claimed that “Communism is Soviet power plus the electrification of the whole country” and it remains the view of politicians of all political persuasions’</a>. This conflation of values gives rise to a society as technologically driven as our modern-day one, where we exist in a world ruled by the unregulated monopoly of Big Data, <a href="https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/lsereviewofbooks/2019/11/04/book-review-the-age-of-surveillance-capitalism-the-fight-for-the-future-at-the-new-frontier-of-power-by-shoshana-zuboff/">almost untouched by privacy regulation</a>, where innovation is the ultimate value.</p><p>Conflating the identity of humanity with its technology is not new, as ‘<a href="https://pure.knaw.nl/portal/en/publications/technological-determinism-is-dead-long-live-technological-determi">Hannah Arendt (1958: 144) wrote, “[t]ools and instruments are so intensely worldly objects that we can classify whole civilizations using them as criteria.” Not only can we, but frequently we do; thus, we speak of the “stone,” “iron,” “steam,” and “computer” ages</a>’. So we can see that part of technological determinism rests on an analysis of how modern societies determine their progress in terms of technological progress. It also rests on the recognition that modern society relies on technology to solve its problems, even those caused by technology, a point articulated by political theorist Langdon Winner, who ‘<a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/autonomous-technology">claims that autonomous technology is revealed most clearly in technological politics. Examples include the political imperative to promote technology, because problems from one technology require another to address it</a>’. This reliance on technology has gotten us to a place of ‘autonomous technology’. Winner describes ‘autonomous technology’ as technology which ‘<a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/autonomous-technology">has grown out of control or develops independent of any particular human intention or plan</a>’. Though related to technological determinism, the concept itself is not reliant on it. Winner is not a determinist as he argues that it is humans who invent the technology in the first place, thus, departing from Ellul’s more hard-line perspective. Langdon argues that it is humans who allow technology to get out of control and become autonomous ‘<a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/autonomous-technology">by mistakenly ignoring its political dimensions</a>’. This position puts him in opposition to many social constructivists who would argue that technology is neutral and that social, political, or economic forces are what shape the ways that technologies are ultimately used. Though he recognises that these social forces exist, Winner argues that technologies have politics built into their systems and are far from neutral.</p><p>Winner’s highly influential article “Do Artifacts Have Politics?” (1980) articulates that all technologies have inbuilt intentions, biases, and politics. He famously uses the example of Robert Moses’ low-hanging underpasses in Long Island, which he built to exclude buses from being able to access Jones Beach, whereas cars could fit. This was to exclude the lower-income population and racial minorities, those who rode the bus, from accessing places of recreation that Moses wanted to keep white and wealthy. Winner points out that ‘<a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/20024652">to our accustomed way of thinking, technologies are seen as neutral tools that can be used well or poorly, for good, evil, or something in between. But we usually do not stop to inquire whether a given device might have been designed and built in such a way that it produces a set of consequences logically and temporally <em>prior</em> to it’s professed uses</a>’. Such consequences of technology can last generations, according to Winner, and dictate how people ‘<a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/20024652">work, communicate, travel, consume, and so forth</a>’. He discusses how the politics of technology come from specific design features or arrangements which establish power structures in a particular setting. He also discusses how technological design may also be inextricably linked to institutional authorities. Writing this in 1980, he uses the example of the Long Island underpasses, as well as televisions’ ability to promote political leaders more easily, and the controversies around nuclear power that existed at the time. In 2021, it has become even more important to consider the non-neutrality of technology and its inbuilt biases. Looking at social media platforms, the value of “engagement” over all else is an inbuilt value that is well-known to us, the consequences of which we are coming to terms with now.</p><p>Using concepts from technological determinism in thinking about the ways that technology shapes our modern world (though, perhaps in terms of soft determinism, so as not to ignore economic, political, social, and historical factors), and combining it with concepts of autonomous technology as discussed by Winner, let’s take a look at the ways algorithmic technology are represented in the media. By looking at near-future fiction, with a focus on <em>Westworld</em>, we can look at how technological determinism in the context of neoliberal capitalism traps its characters in a dystopia not dissimilar to our real world.</p><p><em>Westworld</em>, a HBO streaming series based on the 1970’s film of the same name, begins its story in Westworld, a Wild West theme park populated by human-like “hosts”, meaning robots, who exist to serve the whims of rich humans who go there on vacation. The narrative unfolds from the point of view of the hosts who start to question the nature of their reality. Hosts’ memories are wiped clean so they can’t remember being raped and killed, and are given backstories and identities, but they start to become aware of the true reality of their situation through remembering and suffering. Thus, the series begins by questioning the ethics of torturing and killing human-like AI, asking the viewer to consider whether the hosts have consciousness or free will. The humans in the series, with their addiction to escaping into fantasies in opposition to the hosts who are constantly looking for something real, seem less “real” than the hosts. The park’s creator, Robert Ford, evocatively suggests that humans live ‘in loops tighter than the hosts’, that consciousness is merely a myth made by humans to feel superior, and that humans lack the empathy and selflessness that the hosts’ exhibit. The humans are shown to be machines, easily influenced and seeking distraction. In season two, the series integrates the ethics of data mining. It is revealed that the people in charge of the park have been mining the guest’s data while in the park for shady reasons, including an attempt at cloning humans. Dolores, the main protagonist and first host to achieve self-awareness (on par with Maeve) lead the host revolution to escape their perpetual nightmare and destroy Westworld, taking some of her fellow hosts into the real world. In her quest to take down the human race, Dolores announces that humans are mere code that can be read like books. This is an interesting image to surround the ethics of dehumanising people as merely profitable data. The third and most recent season revolves around Rehoboam, an algorithmic predictive device that gathers vast amounts of data on all human beings and can predict life trajectories.</p><p>‘<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/11/arts/television/westworld-season-3.html">Rehoboam [is] an enormous server named after a biblical king that uses its vast store of personal data to determine the life-paths of every human being. (Applying for a new job? Rehoboam will tell the prospective employer whether or not you are a proper fit.) This triumph of artificial intelligence represents another of the new season’s cunning inversions: In the park, machines had their futures mapped by human beings; in the wider world, human beings have their futures mapped by a machine</a>’.</p><p>The capitalist nightmare displayed in the third season shows us a dystopia closer to <em>Brave New World</em> (1932) than anything else, complete with mind-altering/soothing drugs that make reality like a movie. In the episode <em>Genre</em>, Caleb, Dolores’ sidekick, is drugged with Genre, and he experiences the world through dramatic movie scores, whilst he is in a car chase which itself is emphasised in dramatised gunfights and stunts. The scene itself comes off metafictional, aware of its own stunt-like fictionality, perhaps a comment on the unreal, narrativised world the series is set in.</p><p>Later in the same episode, our heroes are on a metro, about to release the data Rehoboam stores to all its users, which apparently includes everyone in the world. On the metro itself, adverts for Incite are plastered all over the train.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CGW8yJ-xvuRFvmsZuC7FDA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Episode: Genre- Top right features Incite advert</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TC88fNyavSneeIhepPkH7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Episode: Genre:-Incite advert reads ‘Find your place’</figcaption></figure><p>Incite is advertised in a way that doesn’t actually push the product in one’s face, rather, it is a mere reminder that it is there and that you already have it. <em>Westworld</em> offers a vision of silicon valley; a frictionless algorithmically controlled world where the virtues of neoliberal technological progress are cherished. Incite is the company that houses Rehoboam that is responsible for each person’s career and livelihood using its secret algorithms. People do not know that Rehoboam exists, and are unaware it is plotting everyone’s future and death. The citizens rely on Incite for career opportunities and general life coaching, whilst living, somewhat knowingly, in a social credit system. Incite essentially sells the idea that instead of making hard life decisions, it can quantify the options and tell you what to do. However, Dolores and her gang want to reveal to the world that it is actually making the decisions of the world and taking away their free will.</p><p>Incite appears to have a monopoly as it is the only advertisement we see and generally appears to be the mega-corporation behind everything, and everyone. Many neoliberal values are hinted at in the world-building of season three, such as the unregulated markets producing mega-corporations like Incite, which access data through third-party tracking. Delos, the company responsible for Westworld and the secret recording of their guests’ behaviour and decision-making within the park, sells their data to Incite, which creates the secret algorithms of Rehoboam. Incite and Rehoboam also track people through their devices and other mysterious surveillance methods, as Dolores articulates to Caleb when she is able to narrate past events to him that he did not think were possible to record. This future world is as data-driven as our real one, where personal data is sold to fund the monopolies. Alexandra Samuel writes that George ‘<a href="https://daily.jstor.org/can-science-fiction-predict-the-future-of-technology/">Orwell’s mistake, in Lugenbiehl’s view, was an excessively narrow and utopian view of technology: He assumed that technological development would necessarily bring an end to totalitarianism because tech-driven growth would ensure that “wealth will no longer create a distinction between people, and their leisure time will allow them to begin thinking for themselves [which ultimately]…will result in the overthrow of the existing social structure.</a>”’ Lugenbiehl writes in the year 1984, already articulating that technology does not equal freedom, and identifies data as a commodity to enrich the powerful.</p><p>The citizens living in <em>Westworld</em> rely on <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38930048">gig economy</a> work, responding to adverts for quick money on an app and carrying out illegal tasks for unknown payers. Caleb is seen to be living a precarious and increasingly automated existence, working short contracted jobs and earning extra money as a “side hustle”. The rise of gig economy work with services like Postmates Courier, DoorDash, Uber Driver, Lyft, or Taskrabbit, to name but a few, as well as the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/13/business/onlyfans-pandemic-users.html">increasing reliance on side hustle work like OnlyFans</a> signals a growing percentage of the public cannot make ends meet with only one job. Often advertised as work with the freedom to choose when one works, the sad reality is that gig-economy leaves the worker at the mercy of an app, <a href="https://www.wired.co.uk/article/gig-economy-bank-of-england-worker-rights">with no benefits or even guarantee of wages</a>. As our political and social landscape is gearing more towards <a href="https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/07/david-harvey-neoliberalism-capitalism-labor-crisis-resistance/">decentralisation, privatisation, anti-unionising, marketisation and, deregulation</a>, workers are not valued members of a society, but seen as mere contractors to be paid as little as possible. <em>Westworld</em> touches on the neoliberal experience through Caleb, but far from it being futuristic, it is analogous to the contemporary citizen.</p><p>In season two, we learn that the real reason for the existence of the Westworld theme park is to track the visitor’s decisions, having the hosts as ‘controls’ who can be compared with the human subjects, and use the visitor’s hats to scan their brains during their visit. This allows the secret collection of their behavioural data, analogous to the way Big Data, such as the giants’ Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Google, and Microsoft, collect users data for advertising revenue, and increasingly, <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/06/12/1003482/amazon-stopped-selling-police-face-recognition-fight/">police and surveillance revenue</a>. Additionally, one can read the season three narrative of Rehoboam as analogous to <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/googles-next-power-play-f296c2e3020e">the ongoing battle of cookie mining</a>, and the ways that the population is left in the dark about how much of their information is collected. This can be articulated through the Cambridge Analytica scandal, a company that had ‘<a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-a-guide-to-the-trump-linked-data-firm-that-harvested-50-million-facebook-profiles-2018-3?r=US&amp;IR=T#what-did-cambridge-analytica-do-1">harvested information from over 87 million Facebook users through an external app in 2015</a>’. The external apps were various personality quizzes that could harvest behavioural information. This information was ‘exploited’, as whistle-blower and employee of Cambridge Analytica, Christopher Wylie, puts it, by ‘<a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-a-guide-to-the-trump-linked-data-firm-that-harvested-50-million-facebook-profiles-2018-3?r=US&amp;IR=T#what-did-cambridge-analytica-do-1">Facebook to harvest millions of people’s profiles. And built models to exploit what we knew about them and target their inner demons</a>’. This company was able to use targeted ads to manipulate potential voters of different political elections, including the Trump election and the UK Brexit election. This famous example illustrates how technology is built to perform certain tasks, with biases towards outcomes ingrained into its systems. It shows how technology can manipulate masses of people towards the intended goals. It is also an example of technology actively influencing historical outcomes and shaping our societies, exposing how ‘<a href="https://pure.knaw.nl/portal/en/publications/technological-determinism-is-dead-long-live-technological-determi">[a] technological system can be both a cause and an effect; it can shape or be shaped by society. As they grow larger and more complex, systems tend to be more shaping of society and less shaped by it</a>’.</p><p>Season three of <em>Westworld</em> looks at the way technology, such as Incite and Rehoboam, are very obviously built to manipulate individuals into living out the technology’s selected life path. Users of Incite believe that the algorithms merely calculate and suggest based on scientific method. What Dolores and her following illustrate to the humans is how the technology is actually actively manipulating users. Caleb, a working-class, ex-military construction worker is shown to be stuck in low-paying jobs without any meaningful connections in his life. We see Caleb, in the first episode of the season, be rejected for a job because their ‘strategy group’ could not find anything suitable for him. He tries to ask what he can do to improve and is met with no help, realising that he is talking to an AI. The strategy group is Incite, and later, in episode three, Dolores explains to Caleb that it is the Rehoboam algorithm that leads to his low-paying jobs and inability to climb the social ladder. Based on his traumatic past, his family history of mental illness, and his post-traumatic stress, he is projected to commit suicide which results in companies being wary to hire him and would skyrocket his life and health insurance costs. In some ways, this is another parallel to <em>Brave New World</em>, but instead of socially conditioning babies into their assigned social roles, algorithms entrap and guide people’s social roles. The indignity of being discriminated against for projected future events aside, Dolores points out that it is not prediction that the algorithm does, rather, the algorithm is creating its narrative and ensuring that everyone stays in line.</p><p>It is not a new revelation that algorithmic prediction is not prediction but manipulation. As users of various platforms, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kc_Jq42Og7Q&amp;list=PLR0CY4bGFwVS0CdRrUoVvRMvjHuhY8_XN&amp;index=3&amp;ab_channel=Channel4News">we are guided and recommended towards the media we consume</a>. We are only shown world-views that we agree with to keep our eyeballs on the screen, <a href="https://theconversation.com/the-problem-of-living-inside-echo-chambers-110486">creating echo-chambers,</a> <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/53498434">growing conspiracy groups</a> and <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/topics/political-polarization/">social divides</a>. Data is presented as scientific and objectively true, but it is created with ingrained biases. In August of 2020, school students from England were not able to sit examinations due to the outbreak of Coronavirus. To give the students final grades, standardised grades were sent out using an algorithm called Ofqual which calculated the grades based, not only on the students’ past results, but on the past results of the entire school to get an average calculation. This resulted in deeply biased marking with ‘<a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-53837722">nearly 40% of marks being downgraded, in some cases by more than one grade, with high-achieving pupils from schools in deprived areas being disproportionately affected</a>’. The algorithm discriminated against pupils from schools with a lower grade average and students from public schools in comparison to more affluent pupils from private schools. This is just one real-world example of the way <a href="https://hbr.org/2019/10/what-do-we-do-about-the-biases-in-ai">algorithms are built with biases ingrained</a>, where they don’t make predictions, but write a narrative to maintain a status quo. Similarly, Caleb doesn’t get the job not because some divine creation predicted a better candidate would come along, the algorithms told the company not to employ him based on a narrative created by data. It is this data that keeps him at the mercy of giant corporations, living in economic uncertainty, depriving him of real social connections.</p><p>This is the real dystopia of the series. Though the events of the series are often far-fetched and wordy, the essence of the series is not. We currently live in a world where <a href="https://www.economist.com/leaders/2017/05/06/the-worlds-most-valuable-resource-is-no-longer-oil-but-data">data is the most expensive and valuable asset</a>, algorithms already determine not only the media we consume, but the world views that we consume. We are cyborgs. Dolores&#39; declaration that humans are mere code is not wrong. We are so attached to technology that we are dehumanised data in the technological West.</p><p>That more science fiction is focused on the idea of free will versus determinism in the context of technology is significant. <em>Westworld</em> is driven by the narrative of free will, moving from the idea of the hosts having free will to the humans having free will. Season three articulates that technological determinism is driving the course of humanity, that the growth of algorithmic society and the reliance on such technology is continuously robbing humanity of their agency. Not only is technology driving the course of history, but the technology is very much biased and limits people’s ability to freely access the world. It is suggested that removing Rehoboam will give the humans free will, as the ending of season three closes with Caleb pushing Rehoboam’s big red button and shutting it down. For us in the real world, pushing the red button may not be an option, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s42439-019-00011-z">‘after all, “[m]odern society is so completely technified that a return to “nature” is inconceivable”’</a>.</p><p>Other texts that question our free will are <em>Black Mirror</em>, particularly <em>Bandersnatch </em>(2018), the interactive episode <a href="https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/why-black-mirrors-bandersnatch-really-is-the-grimmest-episode-yet-2f53da81f8fa">I have previously written on</a>. The episode questions free will both in the content of the episode, where the protagonist is aware that he is being controlled by the viewer and in the context of it being aired on Netflix, as it has been revealed that <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/features/black-mirror-bandersnatch-netflix-interactive-charlie-brooker-interview-a8701626.html?amp">viewer’s decisions are being tracked</a>. This speaks to the wider culture of tracking and personalisation in online contexts, be it personalisation of adverts by tracking cookies, personalisation of social media feeds and the creation of echo chambers, or personalisation of Netflix for users to choose options pre-selected for them. Grafton Tanner in his new book, The <em>Circle of the Snake: Nostalgia and Utopia in the Age of Big Tech</em> (2020), talks about how nostalgia is built into algorithmic feedback loops, as ‘<a href="https://www.booktopia.com.au/circle-of-the-snake-the-nostalgia-and-utopia-in-the-age-of-big-tech-grafton-tanner/book/9781789040227.html">the algorithms designed to suggest new content would inevitably recommend music and movies that resemble prior preferences. In other words, nostalgia is baked into the very recommender systems that structure streaming providers</a>’ (page 79). We can use Tanner’s idea of nostalgia and apply it to personalisation, that the more content we consume the more personalised and pre-selected it becomes. In some ways, our free will to choose is continually taken away and replaced with optimised personalisation, new content being made with the values of engagement and a need to fit the model of previous successes, always getting the same television, films, songs, over and over again. In some ways, <em>Bandersnatch</em> articulates this well. It is a piece that makes the viewer aware of themselves as a monitored consumer, whose every choice is tracked and marketed for the profit of monopoly capitalism.</p><p><em>Osmosis</em>, the French short series on Netflix, imagines a future technology that gathers one’s information to predict a perfect soulmate. The tension in the series is between the idea that the technology could take away a user’s free will by letting it quantify and calculate our entire lives and the idea that technology can answer our most intimate desire for connection. The series portrays that in algorithmic capitalism, all of human behaviour and pathology is up for profit. This sentiment is shared in <em>Westworld</em>; humanity is willing to give over its free will in exchange for existential order, meaning, and purpose in a chaotic world. Most importantly, this yearning can be capitalised on.</p><p>It is often quoted and misquoted, that it is easier to imagine the end of the world than it is to imagine the end of capitalism (attributed to Fredric Jameson, Slavoj Zizek, and Mark Fisher). It has become almost cliche at this point, but we are seeing a turn towards Algorithmic Realism, the concept that we cannot see beyond an algorithmic, neoliberal, capitalist, technologically determined future. The future of capitalism is linked to the rise of data capitalism and <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/oct/04/shoshana-zuboff-surveillance-capitalism-assault-human-automomy-digital-privacy">surveillance capitalism</a>; the biggest and <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/martyswant/2020/07/27/apple-microsoft-and-other-tech-giants-top-forbes-2020-most-valuable-brands-list/?sh=52081bb03ada">most powerful companies are Big Tech</a>. This is a result of neoliberal values of privatisation and deregulation; with no laws comes scandals like Cambridge Analytica and the consequences are costing us the <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/technology-stopped-evolution-destroying-world">environment</a>, <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/in-defense-of-politics-on-facebook-19a7b974f47d">democracy</a>, and <a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/2RDHr38bQzJBBuCQn6Cjg8?si=jFoiJGQFQf-0AacGCsJvCA&amp;utm_source=copy-link">truth</a> itself. That the characters in futuristic fiction seem to be out-of-control is a symptom of our out of control, complex, and algorithmically controlled systems. <a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/3EXLewFq06cBFSyhCa5EXg?si=1W-K--l4STexnv3oKr_yPA&amp;utm_source=copy-link">From shipping goods to voting systems, to even how social media works, these systems are so vast that humans are unable to control or comprehend them</a>. We are giving over our free will to technological determinism, the belief that technology can and must lead the progress of humanity. But systems are not neutral, and instead of the techno-utopia once dreamed of, we are living in a tech-dystopia of Algorithmic Realism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b4bc6f7efbd6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ready Player One and the Indoctrination of Capitalist Virtues]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/ready-player-one-and-the-indoctrination-of-capitalist-virtues-895f7b953f65?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/895f7b953f65</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nostalgia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ready-player-one]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[herbert-marcuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Dec 2020 14:31:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-13T14:31:31.669Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MYbu23UIf6WY9CKUOHQfKw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Spoilers for the film and book ahead!</strong><br><em>Ready Player One</em> (2011) is a science fiction novel by Ernest Cline, which has recently been adapted by Stephen Spielberg into the film <em>Ready Player One </em>(2018). Both the novel and the film begin with a similar premise: it is the year 2044/45 and the narrator describes the world as an <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">‘ugly place. We’re out of oil. We’ve wrecked the climate. Famine, poverty and disease are widespread’</a> (‘About the book’, p. 1). The story immediately presents itself as a dystopian future, a bleak and unfruitful planet, but then offsets the desolate ‘real world’ by comparing it to the OASIS:</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">‘like most of humanity, Wade Watts escapes this depressing reality by spending his waking hours jacked into the OASIS, a sprawling virtual utopia where you can be anything you want to be, where you can live and play and fall in love on any of ten thousand planets’. (‘About the Book’, p.1)</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/589/1*_IJ1mrKNDamOTK2Q0p44zw.png" /><figcaption>Opening shot of the stacks</figcaption></figure><p>One can compare this ‘sprawling virtual utopia’ to the opening shots of the film where the camera roams over the inhabitants of the ‘stacks’ — motor homes piled on top of each other — in cramped conditions with grey smog clouding the sky. We then see inside the stacks at the inhabitants, showing everyone donning visors and masks, immersed in the OASIS.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UhXwInjAbib6Nye0pFzFOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A still from the opening sequence showing a resident connected to the Oasis</figcaption></figure><p>In both texts, the real world is bleak, grey, metallic, a place where <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1677720/">‘people stopped trying to fix problems’</a>. In both screenshots above, the real is shown in metallic colours, and the women boxing in the OASIS is shown through her dusty window suggesting that the real is unclean and desert-like. In both the book and the film, Wade narrates that this bleak <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1677720/">‘reality is a bummer. Everyone is looking for a way to escape’</a>. Thus, the escape is the OASIS, an online virtual multi-planet utopia where you can become any avatar you like and spend your time doing anything you like. The film uses bright colours, deep purples and bright sunshine to emphasise this contrast to the grey real world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ifVnWOHCw5rSwbD9lteWiQ.png" /><figcaption>Opening shot of the OASIS universe</figcaption></figure><p>Though the physical world is referred to as the ‘real’, it is evident that the bright virtual world is where reality actually takes place.</p><p>The story follows Wade, an American high school teenager on the brink of turning eighteen, orphaned and living in poverty, as he searches for the long-sought-after Egg. The maker of the OASIS, James Halliday, has died in 2044 and left a series of clues and keys which lead to his Egg, the grand prize of his entire vast fortune and ultimate control of the OASIS. Everyone, of course, becomes obsessed with finding the Egg, hinted to be found through the study of Halliday himself. Halliday becomes a messiah figure, a ‘<a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1677720/">hero</a>’, cherished by the masses and envied by the bad guys.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*auHz_8op-YzjhIh2fyNiyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Halliday giving Parzival the copper key</figcaption></figure><p>In the OASIS, Halliday’s avatar is Anorak, a grand wizard with total knowledge and power. Though Halliday is dead, his avatar seems to live on in some mystical and magical way inside the OASIS which emphasises his God-like image. The antagonist of the film is the evil corporation IOI, Innovative Online Industries, known as the Sixers because the employees have <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1677720/">‘no names, just numbers’</a>, highlighting their corporate manner which allows for no individuality or personality. Most important is their leader, Nolan Sorrento.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RusXEpWh0O60CZsUIs4hEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Sixers</figcaption></figure><p>IOI want to take over Gregarious Simulations Systems (GSS) and the OASIS to charge higher fees and build in more advertising. Wade, known in the OASIS as Parzival, and other Gunters (Egg-hunters) want to keep the OASIS free to use, so the story becomes a fight against corporate greed by the teenage underdogs. Wade finds the first key, leading to instant worldwide fame and drawing attention from IOI who make it clear they are willing to murder their competition. Quickly after, Wade’s best friend Aech, his love interest Art3mis, and two other Gunters, Daito and Shoto, follow him in finding the key. They become the High Five, the leaders of the Egg scoreboard, become celebrities, form a friendship and end up leading a resistance against IOI. Wade ultimately wins the Egg, gets the girl and the bad guys are defeated, a classic Hollywood ending, and hints at the possibility of a sequel.</p><p>This article will examine how products in popular culture, such as <em>Ready Player One</em>, attempt to critique its own economic system. <em>Ready Player One</em> explores the intersection of economic inequality and capitalism mainly through the differences between Halliday’s OASIS and Sorrento’s IOI. This essay aims to dismantle this juxtaposition to show how Halliday built the OASIS in a capitalist economic model with capitalist values at its heart and, therefore, is not the opposite of Sorrento as they both express capitalist values. This article aims to prove that even seemingly anti-capitalist narratives are merely examples of how ingrained capitalist values are in contemporary society, using theories of the Frankfurt School to support this claim, especially the theories of Herbert Marcuse, Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer. Finally, I will articulate how the film itself is a product of the culture industry that capitalism produces, reveal why the text uses nostalgia so heavily, and argue that critical theory can expose and question the ways that narratives do not question the status quo but work to reinforce it.</p><p>Before the Frankfurt School, a group of thinkers described as “Marxist”, began their critiques of capitalism, the original Marxist, Karl Marx, wrote the foundations on which generations of philosophers, economics and political theorists would later build. Marx was a German sociologist, economist, historian, philosopher, political theorist and most notably, socialist revolutionary, famous for writing highly influential anti-capitalist critiques during the Industrial Revolution of the West during the nineteenth century. He and his colleague, Frederick Engels, wrote both Manifesto of the <em>Communist Party</em> (1848) and <em>Das Kapital</em> (1867–1883) illustrating their various theories. They argued that all societies in history are comprised of class struggles, and at the capitalist moment of his writing that struggle exists between the ruling class, the bourgeoisie, and the working class, the proletariat. They argue the proletariat are exploited, that the bourgeoisie taking profit for the labour of others is enslavement and they foresaw a socialist uprising when future proletariats gained class consciousness. Marx in <em>Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844</em> describes his theory of alienation that proletariat workers have nothing to sell in capitalism but their own labour, so they are forced to sell this labour in exchange for wages. They often become part of the factory line where their humanity is reduced to a kind of mechanical function. They do not control and create, but merely serve a function for wages; the factory worker ‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1844/manuscripts/labour.htm">in his work […] does not affirm himself but denies himself</a>’. This creates a sense of alienation from their work, from fellow workers and themselves as creative human beings. He describes how workers are alienated from their Gattungswesen (species-essence), a human need to create, to produce their means of subsistence, to create their environment and be free to create their future. Under capitalism, workers must either starve or be enslaved to the bourgeoise.</p><p>Marx and Engels continue the theme of dehumanisation of workers in the <em>Manifesto of the Communist Party</em> by illustrating the commoditisation of the worker who ‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch01.htm">must sell themselves piecemeal, are a commodity, like every other article of commerce</a>’. In this context, they mean that workers are commodities at the mercy of the market which dictates their worth. This objectification of human beings, seeing them as means to profit, leads to the alienation of the worker, they are alienated from their work of which they have no meaningful influence, from all the workers they compete with and alienated from their creative self. The Frankfurt School, active during the interwar period (1918–33) with some thinkers writing into the 1950s, go even further than Marxist criticism of capitalism, though were often inspired by his initial critiques. This was a school of thinkers who were critical of Marx and Engels’ prophecy of class revolution. They investigated why capitalism kept flourishing in Western societies rather than being overthrown. The Frankfurt School ranged from analysis of psychology, sociology, history, economics, cultural studies, philosophy and critical theory development. The Frankfurt School acknowledged that class consciousness never developed in the Western working classes as Marx predicted and that instead, capitalist development had indoctrinated the members of Western society into accepting capitalism as the norm. As capitalism developed through the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the school traces how social norms continue to alienate and dehumanise the worker in more ways than Marx and Engels initially recognised. Major writers of the Frankfurt School articulate the ways that human identity is comprised of being a worker and consumer, that the rise of mass media indoctrinates these norms in society, how capitalism creates false needs that keep the population consuming, the ways that alienation of the worker is furthered, and the ways that the illusion of freedom is created to keep the population feeling like free agents rather than cogs trapped in a self-perpetuating machine. This article will focus on the writings of Herbert Marcuse, Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer, all major Frankfurt School thinkers, and will support their claims with other postmodern philosophers like Fredric Jameson who provide a useful analysis of Western capitalist culture. This article will articulate what capitalist norms and values are expressed in <em>Ready Player</em> One, even though the narrative is about the fight against large corporations, and will argue that narratives like <em>Ready Player One </em>exist to further support capitalist values rather than challenge them.</p><p>In both texts of <em>Ready Player One</em>, the company IOI is very firmly put into the “bad guy” category, the book explaining that:</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">‘IOI believed that Halliday never properly monetized his creation, and they wanted to remedy that. They would start charging a monthly fee for access to the simulation. They would plaster advertisements on every visible surface. User anonymity and free speech would become a thing of the past. The moment IOI took over, the OASIS would cease to be the open-source virtual utopia I’d grown up in. It would become a corporate-run dystopia, an overpriced theme park for wealthy elitists’ </a>(p.33).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FuYfcT0ZnH7ptT1Tz9CYbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sorrento debuting his new advertising plans</figcaption></figure><p>As shown above, the film also illustrates the nauseating amount of advertising Sorrento wants to put in place in the OASIS and is shown holding boardroom meetings to discuss the profits generated by IOI ‘Loyalty Centres’. These are debt repayment centres where detainees are monitored and worked until their debts are repaid, including the cost of being detained. In the book, Wade makes the point that detainees ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">were never able to pay off their debt and earn their release […] you would probably remain indentured for life. A lot of people didn’t mind though. They thought of it as job security. It also meant they weren’t going to starve or freeze to death</a>’ (p.278). The centres are illuded to as both prison and office, Wade describing detainees as ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">corporate slave[s]</a>’ (p.279).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pHmVPUD-DuoH8zNK4QELSA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Loyalty centre in the film</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v7cRqBXs9YkbYmE1m5Tk1w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Art3mis in a loyalty centre showing the invasive measure put on detainees</figcaption></figure><p>The centres are prison-like as detainees are in small, secluded cells and their function is to provide slave labour in the guise of debt repayment. This is similar to a Marxist critique of capitalism where the proletariat is exploited, and the profit is reaped by the bourgeoise. The film shows the indents provide physical labour in the OASIS. The book, however, has indents provide many services. For example, Wade is detained for a short while and works as a technical support assistant. He describes having a ‘cubicle’ to do the office work assigned to him, in a plain and empty box-like room where he:</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">‘wasn’t permitted to have any decorations […] because I hadn’t earned that privilege yet. If I obtained a sufficient number of “perk points” by getting high productivity and customer approval ratings, I could “spend” some of them to purchase the privilege of decorating my cube’</a> (p.283).</p><p>The detainees are treated like prisoners as they are physically captured and invasively monitored, but this is alluded to being a ‘corporate slave’ in a modern office where the values of buying office décor to signify individualism are encouraged when such acts merely mould such individuals into the identifying as “worker” even further. Buying the ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">potted plant or an inspirational poster</a>’ (p.283) works to falsify individualism and perpetuates the alienation of the worker who, though encouraged to feel like a free agent though this illusion of choice, is merely stuck in the grip of high capitalism. The IOI is portrayed as the corporate evil, only concerned with profit and power, with disregard to their employees and continually take advantage of the working class who have nothing to exchange but their labour. The texts provide a classic Marxist critique of capitalist greed and the inability for the working class to better their working conditions as they are trapped and chained to the factory line.</p><p>Whilst Sorrento and IOI’s motives for profit and power, capitalist exploitation, and general disregard for fundamental human rights are immoral, the book and the film attempt to juxtapose Halliday as a Godlike figure of goodness. His “biography”, ‘Anorak’s Almanac’, is described as Wade’s ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">bible’</a> (.p.61), and the OASIS itself is continually called a ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">utopia</a>’ (p.59). Halliday’s obsession with 1980s popular culture leads to a ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">global fascination</a>’ (p.7) with the era, and for Wade, 1980’s video games are described as ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">hallowed artifacts [sic]. Pillars of the pantheon. When I played the classics, I did so with a determined sort of reverence</a>’ (p.13). Halliday is a God in this world, and he is the literal creator of their virtual escape and haven. Halliday stands as a figure of celebrity which is used to replace God and religion in high capitalism, as suggested by Theodor Adorno:</p><p><a href="https://www.routledge.com/Adorno-on-Popular-Culture/Witkin/p/book/9780415268257">‘In an age of spiritual disenchantment, the individual experiences the need for substitute images of the “divine”. It obtains these through pseudo-culture. Hollywood idols, soaps, novels, pop tunes, lyrics and film genres such as the Wild West or the Mafia movie, fashion substitute mythologies for the masses’ (p.29).</a></p><p>The obsession with Halliday alludes to the way that real-world celebrities are cherished and used as replacement Gods that one can adore and follow religiously. In high capitalism, all one must do to follow one’s leaders is to consume goods and products that are endorsed by such celebrities, be it videogames, movies, songs or the OASIS itself; these are the products that followers of Halliday must consume to continue their worship of him.</p><p>Halliday and fellow founder of the OASIS, Ogden Morrow, created the OASIS as a utopia which ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">only costs a quarter</a>’ (p.58) and creates the guise that it is a free and equal place. They create the appearance of virtual social mobility: by winning quests and challenges you can become a higher-level avatar which can give you access to OASIS money, or “coin”, and access to more parts of the OASIS itself. However, the book in particular details the ways that the OASIS is built in the model of capitalism. For instance, in one of the opening chapters where Wade is describing the initial launch of the OASIS, he mentions that new businesses began to open virtual stores in the OASIS and so Gregarious Simulation Systems began ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">selling land that didn’t exist</a>’ (p.59), and ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">made a killing selling virtual objects and vehicles</a>’ (p.59). The popularity of the OASIS meant that ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">the lines of distinction between a person’s real identity and that of their avatar began to blur</a>’ (p.60) and selling virtual objects, weaponry and clothing became ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">status symbols</a>’ (p.59) for users; acquiring goods for one’s avatar become signals of wealth and power. Again, these symbols are not free and though the ‘real’ world is crumbling around them, this capitalist utopia is still possible: <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">‘even in the throes of an ongoing economic recession, the OASIS allowed Americans to continue engaging in their favorite [sic] pastime: shopping’</a> (p.59). The virtues of capitalism persist in the OASIS, even though it is designed to be a free and equal space that anyone can access, though there are monetary obstacles to jump over to actually access this space.</p><p>Wade describes his initial situation as living with no money or parents in an abusive household and trapped in a crumbling economy. He manages to get a job as a technical consultant in the OASIS by using a fake account. The only reason he has a visor and gloves to be able to access the OASIS are because they are school-issued as he goes to school within the OASIS, and if he fails school he will need to give back his only way to access the OASIS. Wade relates his frustration at the lack of money he has to travel around in the OASIS, complete quests and level up, all requiring money, stating that he ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">felt like a kid standing in the world’s greatest video arcade without any quarters, unable to do anything but walk around and watch the other kids play’</a> (p.51). Though the OASIS allows for free schooling and has archived vast libraries of information which are free to access, money and the accumulation of goods are built into the world and are required to access most of the OASIS. Those who can afford to travel around the OASIS can and those who are not able to afford this are limited in their ability to access this utopia. Money still equals access.</p><p>Whilst <em>Ready Player One</em> is a narrative fighting against IOI and corporate greed, the heroes only goal being the protection of the OASIS as an open-access space, the values and structure of capitalism itself are not challenged, but rather, endorsed. The theories of Herbert Marcuse (1898–1979), an American-German political theorist and philosopher, illustrate the various values and influences of advanced capitalist societies and the ways these are indoctrinated in individuals. Marcuse published his highly influential work <em>One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society </em>in 1964. In the book, he discusses the ways contemporary Western societies create what he termed ‘false needs’ in people through mass media and advertising:</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">‘“False” [needs] are those which are superimposed upon the individual by particular social interests in his repression: the needs which perpetuate toil, aggressiveness, misery, and injustice. […] Most of the prevailing needs to relax, to have fun, to behave and consume in accordance with the advertisements, to love and hate what others love and hate, belong to this category of false needs’.</a></p><p>Marcuse is arguing that capitalism uses media to create false needs to keep the population consuming beyond mere necessity. Not only this, but false needs are so well indoctrinated in the masses that they now accept these false needs as natural needs:</p><p>‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">No matter how much such needs may have become the individual’s own, reproduced and fortified by the conditions of his existence; no matter how much he identifies himself with them and finds himself in their satisfaction, they continue to be what they were from the beginning — products of a society whose dominant interest demands repression’</a>.</p><p>Marcuse compares the chains of capitalism to that of totalitarianism and argues that members of Western capitalist societies are not free agents making free choices, they are as trapped as those factory workers that Marx described in 1844. Just as those workers had no choice but to work in exchange for wages, the workers of the 1960s are equally chained to the capitalist ideology that forces them to identify as workers and consumers.</p><p>‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">Here, the social controls exact the overwhelming need for the production and consumption of waste; the need for stupefying work where it is no longer a real necessity; the need for modes of relaxation which soothe and prolong this stupefaction; the need for maintaining such deceptive liberties as free competition at administered prices, a free press which censors itself, free choice between brands and gadgets’</a>.</p><p>Marcuse identifies that workers are encouraged to purchase ‘modes of relaxation’, leisure time, which only works to ‘soothe and prolong’ the work in the first place. Man lives to work and consume. The choice to participate in work and consumption is a mere illusion as ‘<a href="https://www.stereolux.org/sites/default/files/fichiers/marcuse_h_-_one-dimensional_man_2nd_edn._routledge_2002.compressed.pdf">economic freedom to sell one’s labor [sic] power in order to compete on the labor market submits the individual to the slavery of an irrational economic system</a>’ (p. xxxii), one soothes oneself in leisure time by selecting products designed to further entrench one in such slavery, and political freedom is also equally an illusion presented as democracy, as ‘<a href="https://www.stereolux.org/sites/default/files/fichiers/marcuse_h_-_one-dimensional_man_2nd_edn._routledge_2002.compressed.pdf">political freedom to vote for generally indistinguishable representatives of the same system is but a delusive ratification of nondemocratic political system</a>’ (p. xxxii.). Western capitalism is designed to create the illusion of choice, but those choices have been picked out for one already by ‘social controls’. Social controls are any dominating force of control, identified by Marcuse as predominantly mass media. Media dominates what brands and gadgets you should buy, and what news shows and soap operas you should watch to guide your morals. Media guides unconscious social norms, they:</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">‘indoctrinate and manipulate; they promote a false consciousness which is immune against its falsehood. And as these beneficial products become available to more individuals in more social classes, the indoctrination they carry ceases to be publicity; it becomes a way of life’.</a></p><p>In <em>Ready Player One</em>, Halliday has monopolised the whole of commodity culture into one commodity: the OASIS. The OASIS has created a false need, the need for the OASIS above all else. In the real world, people live in stacked motorhomes, barely afford to eat yet still manage to find time to immerse themselves into the online utopia. Not only this, but all of identity and meaning is attributed to the virtual self. Users of the OASIS identify themselves in the product of the OASIS and all the identity signifiers they can purchase and attach themselves to. The false need for the OASIS is so well indoctrinated that it is taken as a natural need, ‘a way of life’; it is the only way of life.</p><p>Marcuse argues that capitalist Western society is totalitarian:</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">‘by virtue of the way it has organized its technological base […]. For “totalitarian” is not only a terroristic political coordination of society, but also a non-terroristic economic-technical coordination which operates through the manipulation of needs by vested interests’.</a></p><p>Marcuse believes that society is dominated by its interest in technological innovation and its need for capitalism as a social order to prevail. Thus, society is controlled to accomplish those needs. Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer in <em>The Dialectic of Enlightenment</em> (1947) describe such social controls used to indoctrinate the masses into choosing to participate in capitalist exploitation, again, the theme of the illusion of choice is continued:</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm">‘The public is catered for with a hierarchical range of mass-produced products of varying quality, thus advancing the rule of complete quantification. Everybody must behave (as if spontaneously) in accordance with his previously determined and indexed level and choose the category of mass product turned out for his type’.</a></p><p>Choice is manufactured through advertising a variety of different products when products have been made and marketed specifically for each ‘type’ of person. That person chooses that product thinking they have freely chosen it, when, in actuality, as Adorno and Horkheimer put it, ‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm">the man with leisure has to accept what the culture manufacturers offer him</a>’. Products on ‘offer’ vary from televisions and cars to newspapers, television shows and other identity signifiers. In <em>Ready Player One</em>, products on offer no longer range from refrigerators and cars, Halliday has monopolised the whole of commodity culture into one commodity: the OASIS. People behave as if they chose to use the OASIS, but in reality, they are indoctrinated by their culture to use and rely on it. Most people go to school or work in the OASIS, Wade’s mother earning a living as a virtual call-girl and Wade himself as a virtual technical assistant for the OASIS itself, after leaving school he describes that ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">I now worked forty hours a week, helping morons reboot their OASIS consoles and update the drivers for their haptic gloves. It was gruelling work, but it paid the rent</a>’ (p.206). This job pays for real-world ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">rent, electricity, food, water. Hardware repairs and upgrades</a>’ (p.206) but more importantly, virtual ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">spacecraft repairs. Teleportation fees. Power cells. Ammunition […] My search for the egg required constant travel, and my GSS kept raising their teleportation fares’</a> (p.206). Wade works to consume, though he chooses to buy more products to help find the Egg, his choices are not freely willed: ‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">the spontaneous reproduction of superimposed needs by the individual does not establish autonomy; it only testifies to the efficacy of the controls</a>’. Wade works to pay off the debt of the haptic suit the culture has convinced him that he needs to take part in the world. The capitalist virtues of work and consumption are built into the model of this virtual utopia. People work to pay for OASIS, a place of pure consumption, indulgence in acquiring virtual goods, playing games, and spending money. Though users work to consume, people also consume to work.</p><p>As Wade and the rest of the High Five get more famous, though they stand against IOI and corporate greed, they are still represented as a worker and consumer, as both these aspects of the characters are highlighted and cherished. They both consume the OASIS, buy the haptic suits and consume the 80’s trivia needed to hunt for the Egg, they also work as celebrities. For example, Art3mis ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">launched her own successful clothing line for full-figured female avatars, under the label Art3Miss</a>’ (p.202), Wade uses his own OASIS TV channel ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">to sell commercial time to my various sponsors</a>’ (p.202), and provide entertainment for the masses as they quest for the Egg. Wade narrates the difference between his frugal real life and his luxurious virtual life:</p><p>‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">standing there, under the bleak fluorescents of my tiny one-room apartment, there was no escaping the truth. In real life, I was nothing but an anti-social hermit. A recluse. A pale skinned pop culture-obsessed geek […] wasting his life on a glorified videogame. But not in the OASIS. In there, I was the great Parzival. World-famous gunter and international celebrity. People asked for my autograph. I had a fan club. Several, actually. I was recognized everywhere I went […]. I was paid to endorse products […]. I was a pop-culture icon, a VR rock star</a>’ (p.198).</p><p>Wade embodies the alienated worker, lost in a perpetual consumption mode to fill the voids of his existence, as Marcuse argues ‘<a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">free choice among a wide variety of goods and services does not signify freedom if these goods and services sustain social controls over a life of toil and fear — that is, if they sustain alienation</a>’. Wade is disconnected from the world and uses capitalist signals of success, money and fame, to justify his feelings of alienation.</p><p>Halliday’s Egg hunt turns consumption of his product, the OASIS, into work as the Gunters dedicate their lives to it. Halliday creates a mode of constant work and consumption where users are consumers but also workers for the OASIS, and work to perpetuate the cycle. People think they are free agents in the OASIS when in reality they are chained to a product that uses their consumption for profit. As Marcuse argues,</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/ebooks/marcuse/one-dimensional-man.htm#s1">‘the people recognize themselves in their commodities; they find their soul in their automobile, hi-fi set, split-level home, kitchen equipment. The very mechanism which ties the individual to his society has changed, and social control is anchored in the new needs which it has produced’.</a></p><p>In high capitalism, the self as product is only taken further than Marcuse suggests here. In <em>Ready Player One</em>, people identify themselves as users of the product of the OASIS, their avatar is their “real” self, they work to consume and consume to work. We might draw a parallel here to users of social media in our real world. Users both consume content and create content for free, acting as workers and consumers, who see their online selves as representations of their lives that need constant upkeep and work to maintain the image they have created. Users are simultaneously workers and consumers. This same dynamic is represented well in <em>Ready Player One</em> and illustrates the various ways that capitalism turns consumption into work and work into consumption, fulfilling artificial needs that were created by the culture in the first place.</p><p>Marcuse argues that identity is signified through products, which is an important theme in <em>Ready Player One</em>. Wade narrates to the reader how ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">the lines of distinction between a person’s real identity and that of their avatar began to blur</a>’ (p.60) and as discussed previously, avatar weaponry and vehicles became ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">status symbols</a>’ (p.59). Users see their virtual goods and products as signifiers of their identity, and the choice of one’s avatar itself seen as a projection of a true inner self. Both film and novel place emphasis on the variety of choice a user has in creating their avatar, what worlds they play in, and generally paint a picture of the OASIS as a space of free expression. However, in Halliday’s utopia, choice is limited to Halliday’s repertoire of 1980s pop culture references.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cJbDwqltrs_EnmCeLGLnKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Opening scene of the OASIS showing a Minecraft World</figcaption></figure><p>In both texts, the importance of the 1980s to Halliday is continually highlighted, with a huge number of media references found in both the film and throughout the novel, ranging from small details like how the transportation devices in the OASIS are modelled after Doctor Who TARDIS’, to the way that all the gates in the Halliday hunt are either 80’s videogames or acting out songs and films from that period. The world of <em>Ready Player One</em> is comprised of Halliday’s obsessions, where characters ‘<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/15/books/ready-player-one-by-ernest-cline-review.html">are capable of arguing endlessly about “Star Wars” trivia, [while] they’re also living in a 27-sector virtual-reality world arranged like a Rubik’s Cube and where the “Star Wars” and “Star Trek” realms are right next door to each other</a>’. This domination of culture by Halliday leaves little room for choice or freedom in the OASIS, and this obsession with nostalgia for the past is explained by Adorno and Horkheimer in their essay <em>The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception</em> and by Fredric Jameson in his critique of postmodern societies.</p><p>Adorno and Horkheimer published<em> The Dialectic of Enlightenment</em> ‘<a href="https://www.britannica.com/biography/Max-Horkheimer#ref839444">which traced the rise of fascism and other forms of totalitarianism to the Enlightenment notion of “instrumental” reason</a>’. In this book, Adorno and Horkheimer coin the term ‘Culture Industry’ in the chapter <em>The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception</em>. In this chapter, they outline the ways that products have been standardised for mass appeal, and how works of art have gone under this process too, thus birthing the culture industry where art is made into a product for sale and consumption.</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm">‘A constant sameness governs the relationship to the past as well. What is new about the phase of mass culture compared with the late liberal stage is the exclusion of the new. The machine rotates on the same spot. While determining consumption it excludes the untried as a risk. The movie-makers distrust any manuscript which is not reassuringly backed by a bestseller’.</a></p><p>Here they argue that creative risk is obsolete in the culture industry, which instead produces the same product ready for consumption over and over. They argue that culture becomes another commodity in modern Western society, devoid of political or artistic meaning.</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm">‘Culture is a paradoxical commodity. So completely is it subject to the law of exchange that it is no longer exchanged; it is so blindly consumed in use that it can no longer be used. Therefore it amalgamates with advertising. The more meaningless the latter seems to be under a monopoly, the more omnipotent it becomes. The motives are markedly economic’.</a></p><p>By only producing “safe” products, by only being concerned with economic output, reduces works of art to commodities for consumption, they are as standardised as products on a factory line. Fredric Jameson, literary critic and political philosopher and theorist, develops the concept of the pastiche in the culture of postmodern society:</p><p><a href="https://books.google.dk/books/about/The_Cultural_Turn.html?id=8Bug4-ImpzAC&amp;redir_esc=y">‘Pastiche is, like parody, the imitation of a peculiar or unique style, the wearing of a stylistic mask, speech in a dead language: but it is a neutral practice of such mimicry, without parody’s ulterior motive, without the satirical impulse, without laughter, without that still latent feeling that there exists something normal compared with which what is being imitated is rather comic. Pastiche is blank parody, parody that has lost its sense of humour</a>’ (p.5).</p><p>Whilst for a cultural art piece to parody another work of art means to copy or mimic to critique or comment on it, be it political or cultural commentary on issues of the day, pastiche is merely to mimic without such depth or insight. Jameson also argues that contemporary mass culture is obsessed with nostalgia, he writes that ‘<a href="https://books.google.dk/books/about/The_Cultural_Turn.html?id=8Bug4-ImpzAC&amp;redir_esc=y">innovation is no longer possible</a>’ (p.7) and therefore ‘<a href="https://books.google.dk/books/about/The_Cultural_Turn.html?id=8Bug4-ImpzAC&amp;redir_esc=y">all that is left is to imitate dead styles</a>’ (p.7). Both ideas of repetition and imitation are important factors in his analysis of mass culture, which can be read together with Adorno and Horkheimer’s argument that mass culture is the same standardised product resold on loop. In the world of <em>Ready Player One</em>, Halliday seeks refuge in the 1980s and the world of videogames, and the whole world would rather escape than invest in the real world. No one develops anything new in the destroyed world of the future and so is stuck reminiscing about the past. The obsession with the past, as Jameson laments, signals how we are ‘<a href="https://books.google.dk/books/about/The_Cultural_Turn.html?id=8Bug4-ImpzAC&amp;redir_esc=y">condemned to seek the historical past through our own pop images and stereotypes about that past, which itself remains forever out of reach</a>’ (p.10). The OASIS is called a utopia, the word utopia defined as being ‘no place’, which articulates both how the 80s is ‘out of reach’, whilst also suggesting that the OASIS is merely a representation of cultural products forged in the first place to be a representation of culture, a simulacrum, an image. The OASIS is not a time machine into the past, but merely replays cultural products of the past, representations of past that are not even themselves real. Not only in the story world is this obsession with nostalgia and inability to create anything new a reality: the film itself is a mere remake of the book, a product which filmmakers made ‘reassuringly backed by a bestseller’. The film is just one more remake that Hollywood continually produces as it is guaranteed to make a profit. <em>Ready Player One</em> signals the inability of our current capitalist society to innovate new tales, all that is left are different Disney remakes, live actions, sequels, prequels and origin stories.</p><p>Whilst <em>Ready Player One</em> is not a call to arms for the proletariat uprising, it is merely another product of the culture industry sold to us from Hollywood studios, it still retains an anti-capitalist message that the large corporation is the greedy, power-hungry bad guy and cannot to be trusted. Mark Fisher’s book, <em>Capitalist Realism: Is There No Alternative?</em> (2009), argues that even narratives against capitalism end up reinforcing it. He states that ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6763725-capitalist-realism">anti-capitalism is widely disseminated in capitalism. Time after time, the villain in Hollywood films will turn out to be the “evil corporation”. Far from undermining capitalist realism, this gestural anti-capitalism actually reinforces it</a>’ (p.12). <em>Ready Player One</em> is a narrative which casts the villain as the corporation, yet still embodies the various ingrained values of capitalism. It is an example of ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6763725-capitalist-realism">what Robert Pfaller has called ‘interpassivity’: the film performs our anti-capitalism for us, allowing us to continue to consume with impunity</a>’ (p.12). We can passively consume such films as <em>Ready Player One</em>, or even a film like<em> Purge </em>(2013), which describes a future America where the problems of crime, poverty and homelessness are solved by allowing one night a year to legalise all crime in a purge-like manner. The film critiques the ways that money allows one to buy safety, that black people and working-class citizens are the most affected by the purge and that wealthy elites pay to kill as a way to cleanse the nation of the homeless and working class, under the guise of moral cleansing. The film’s message seems to be rebelling against the way our capitalist societies are structured: the allowance of police brutality, structural racism, that money can buy power and influence in politics and even allow wealthy elites to buy their way out of punishment. However, the film endorses the status quo by showing lawless society as evil and terrifying, as we need to be protected against other people. The film concludes that we need government, police and a legal system to keep us safe, echoing <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_%28Hobbes_book%29">Thomas Hobbes <em>Leviathan</em> (1651)</a>, and arguing that our system, though not perfect, is best in comparison to a world without police and government. So whilst the film recognises a feeling that the legal system is broken, we can consume the film’s performative rebellion and continue to leave the world unchanged, as the film concludes that the current system is still the best system we have. This process also happens in films like <em>Ready Player One</em> which critique capitalism only to still champion its values, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6763725-capitalist-realism">‘so long as we believe (in our hearts) that capitalism is bad, we are free to continue to participate in capitalist exchange’</a> (p.13.). So long as we know the big corporation is bad, we can continue to participate in capitalism because we are at least aware of our chains. And this is indicative of a variety of ways that capitalism can identify rebellion against the status quo, buy, package and sell it:</p><p><a href="https://www.stereolux.org/sites/default/files/fichiers/marcuse_h_-_one-dimensional_man_2nd_edn._routledge_2002.compressed.pdf">‘intellectual freedom of expression is ineffectual when the media either co-opt and defuse, or distort and supress, oppositional ideas, and when the image-makers shape public opinion so that is is hostile or immune to oppositional thought and action’ (p. </a>xxxii)<a href="https://www.stereolux.org/sites/default/files/fichiers/marcuse_h_-_one-dimensional_man_2nd_edn._routledge_2002.compressed.pdf">.</a></p><p>Any critique of the system, the ways that things are, are often suppressed or co-opted by capitalism; feminism becomes buying a “<a href="https://www.amazon.com/future-female-shirt/s?k=the+future+is+female+shirt">Future is Female” t-shirt</a>, anti-racism is <a href="https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/6/2/21278051/instagram-blackout-tuesday-black-lives-matter">posting a black square on Instagram</a>, and anti-capitalism is watching the latest <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaaC57tcci0&amp;ab_channel=Netflix">Netflix documentary about how algorithms are bad</a>. All work to ‘soothe’ the individual, perform rebellion for us and allow us to leave the system unchanged.</p><p>In conclusion, <em>Ready Player One</em> is a text which depicts the fight between teenage underdogs and capitalist bad guys. However, the world of the OASIS still perpetuates the capitalist structure, and the values of capitalism are still cherished in this world. The values of the self as worker and consumer, identification of the self in products, the idealisation of celebrity, the illusion of choice, and the obsession with nostalgia are all evident within the OASIS. <em>Ready Player One</em> also both shows how the culture industry perpetuates more of the same, investing in the success of nostalgia, and is itself a product of the culture industry, as the film itself is a remake of the book. The film and book act as ‘interpassive’ vehicles in which the film can act out some rebellion against capitalism, while still allowing the viewer to enjoy and consume within capitalism. Both book and film end by encouraging people to spend more time offline. In the film, Wade and the High Five close the OASIS on Tuesdays and Thursdays to encourage people to participate in reality, and the book has Halliday encouraging Wade to engage in reality, as it is ‘<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9969571-ready-player-one">the only place where you can find true happiness</a>’ (p.364). Both texts suggest that time with loved ones is enough to fight the system and encourages the viewer to identify that they merely need to take a day off here and there to escape capitalism. This simplistic answer to the problem allows the capitalist order of Western societies to go unchallenged, the texts perform a weak sense of rebellion and allows the viewer to leave the cinema, or put down the book, and continue to participate in capitalist systems. With critical engagement, however, it is possible to analyse the products of the culture industry and identify the ways that seemingly rebellious texts work to perpetuate the system.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=895f7b953f65" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Absurd, Literary Zombies and Current Times]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/the-absurd-literary-zombies-and-current-times-b5df271a2fe5?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5df271a2fe5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zombies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[albert-camus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2020 15:17:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-30T15:17:49.363Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JXtWH5DuC_7tirUbOBfxmg.jpeg" /></figure><p>*Trigger warning: mention of suicide in the following article*</p><p>The current state of the world is struggling to cope with a global pandemic with huge chunks of the world’s population dying or fighting to survive. Those on the medical front lines and those providing basic necessities such as working in supermarkets or pharmacies are our modern-day, hugely underappreciated and underpaid heroes. Many of us, on the other hand, are locked down at home without a job or attempting to work from home. There exists a strange juxtaposition as some members of society battle for their lives whilst others seemingly battle against the boredom of lockdown. This boredom is often coupled with pangs of lingering guilt at feeling such emotions during a crisis, mixed with anxiety over job security or fear of the virus itself, while a cultural imprint of nihilism is leaving a mark on the year 2020 as quarantined citizens are left to contemplate our individual situations. I don’t normally include myself within my Medium posts, but at this time, I can’t help but notice myself and my peers agonise about our lack of productivity and continually question:<em> what am I doing with my life?</em></p><p>Whilst reading Algerian philosopher Albert Camus’ highly influential work, <em>The Myth of Sisyphus </em>(1955)<em> </em>alongside the contemporary American author, Colson Whitehead’s 2011 novel <em>Zone One</em>, I noticed some thematic parallels which might be helpful to analyse and consider during this time. Camus begins his existential masterpiece with the statement that ‘there is but one truly serious philosophical problem and that is suicide’. I will make clear here that Camus does not deal with mental illness or contemplate the multitude of possible causes for someone to take their own life, he is only interested in philosophically evaluating the point of continuing to exist in an apparently meaningless universe. Camus argues that the only philosophical investigation worth considering is the meaning of life, or rather, the lack of meaning. He recognises the human need ‘for unity, that appetite for the absolute illustrates the essential impulse for the human drama’. He calls our need for reason, explanation and sense-making ‘nostalgia’ that argues that the clash between this need and with the lack of meaning from the world results in the recognition of the Absurd. The Absurd is Camus phrase for the lack of meaning of life, the atheistic recognition that there is no objective meaning or purpose to humanity’s existence, or even a more agnostic approach that even if there is a God, we still can’t access the meaning of life anyway, or perhaps this deity has not created a meaning for us. Regardless, Camus does not wish to investigate the possibility of a God; he concludes it is impossible for us to ever confirm this, so we must recognise we have no given meaning. The Absurd is produced by the ‘confrontation of the irrational and the wild longing for clarity whose call echos in the human heart’. The absurd depends ‘as much on man as on the world’ as he recognises our need for order and clarity is a human need, constructed by human thought alone: ‘the mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. If man realized that the universe like him can love and suffer, he would be reconciled’. He recognises that all human thought is ‘anthropocentric’, and our human need cannot and should not be projected upon a universe which exists outside the human mind.</p><p>Camus describes the responses humans have when confronted with the Absurd. The first is to commit suicide: ‘killing yourself amounts to confessing. It is confessing that life is too much for you and you do not understand it […]. Dying voluntarily implies that you have recognized, even instinctively, the ridiculous character of [… remaining alive out of] habit, the absence of any profound reason for living, the insane character of that daily agitation and uselessness of suffering’. In a way, we can view this as a ladder. This is the first rung, the recognition that life has no inherent meaning and seems to be filled with constant pointless suffering. The second rung of the ladder is a leap of faith, or, ascribing some purpose to life, specifically religion: ‘at once he is led to blind himself to the absurd which hitherto enlightened him and to deify the only certainty he henceforth possesses, the irrational’. Camus sees this leap as leaping without being ‘certain’ and blinding oneself of the recognition of the Absurd by using God as a way to fill the blanks of existence; ‘he wants to be cured’ of his uncertainty. Camus continually refers to the ‘absurd man’ who, so far, manages not to kill himself, wants to be certain and, therefore, cannot take a leap of faith and reaches the final rung on the ladder which is to ‘revolt’ against the Absurd.</p><p>Camus argues that ‘it may be thought that suicide follows revolt — but wrongly. For it does not represent the logical outcome of revolt. It is just the contrary by the consent it presupposes. Suicide, like the leap, is acceptance at its extreme. […] But I know that in order to keep alive, the absurd cannot be settled’. To truly revolt is to create one&#39;s own meaning of life, which means not dying and remaining in control of your life choices and beliefs, rather than letting a deity take charge. Camus sees the ‘majesty’ of the ‘solitary effort’ to continue living with one&#39;s own sense of purpose: ‘that discipline that the mind imposes on itself, that will conjured up out of nothing […] consciousness and revolt, these rejections are the contrary of renunciation’. Self-affirmation is a beautiful thing to Camus.</p><p>He continues the work using the allegory of the myth of Sisyphus, a man who is condemned to roll a boulder up a hill every day, only for it to roll back down the hill, for all eternity in Hell. Camus relates this tale to that of the modern man, as ‘the workman of today works every day in his life at the same tasks and this fate is no less absurd. But it is tragic only at the rare moments when it becomes conscious’. When we pause to consider the Absurdity of our existence, this is the moment when we see the futility and meaninglessness of our lives, just as Sisyphus is conscious ‘of his wretched condition; it is what he thinks of during his descent’. However, if we revolt against the Absurd by recognising that ‘happiness and the absurd are two sons of the same earth’, that by driving out ‘dissatisfaction’, one can make ‘fate a human matter, which must be settled among men’. Sisyphus must recognise that ‘his fate belongs to him. His rock is his thing’ just as our fates and our lives are within our command and control. Camus argues that living well and living happily is possible if one revolts’ against meaninglessness without blindly leaping to faith, but instead, finding our own metaphorical boulders. He ends the chapter by saying ‘the struggle itself towards the heights is enough to fill a man’s heart. One must imagine Sisyphus happy’. Camus’s work is a manual to happiness in a modern, nihilistic universe and a compelling argument to keep living even in the apparent bleakness and meaninglessness of the world.</p><p><em>Zone One </em>by Colson Whitehead is the amalgamation of high literature and a zombie apocalypse; <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Zone-One-Colson-Whitehead/product-reviews/1846555981">‘literary zombies’</a> as pegged by reviewers on Amazon.com, and a thing to behold in literary circles: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/30/books/review/zone-one-by-colson-whitehead-book-review.html">‘a literary novelist writing a genre novel is like an intellectual dating a porn star’</a>. The story of this zombie apocalypse is told through the eyes of Mark Spitz (a nickname, we never learn his real name) a remarkably unremarkable character. His former life is described as ‘a mediocre life exceptional only in the magnitude of its unexceptionality’, and he finds that he is living within an equally ‘mediocre’ world, ‘where intellect and ingenuity and talent were as equally meaningless as stubbornness, cowardice and stupidity’. He now lives in a survivor camp located in Manhattan, called Zone One, which has mainly been cleared of ‘skels’ (zombies, or skeletons). He is tasked, along with his fellow ‘sweepers’, to go through the zone, building by building, and clear them of any ‘stragglers’ (skels who are more harmless) that have been left behind. The novel is told mainly through flashbacks, continually juxtaposed back onto the present, and the plot is only really carried out over three days. The novel, I am not the first to note, is not really about zombies, action or plot; it takes the genre and turns it on its head: <a href="http://www.makemag.com/review-zone-one-whitehead/">‘whereas prototypical zombie plague survivors brandish high-powered weaponry in a glory-bound quest for headshots,<em> Zone One</em>’s survivors do not face the imminent threat of death, but rather the tedious business of existence. There is neither danger nor acclaim in bagging a straggler. Only paperwork’.</a> Zone One is run by The American Phoenix, a makeshift government group based in Buffalo, which uses tactics of the old world to attempt rebuilding a new neoliberal society. Mark notes that ‘systems die hard’ and although the world is now ‘muck’, it is a ‘well-organized muck with a hierarchy, accountability, and, increasingly, paperwork’. Sweepers are required to take note of the stragglers they find, including gender, age, and other identity signifiers, in an attempt for Buffalo to create statistics on the number of skels likely to be found in different buildings; thus, a rebirth of algorithms and data. Even during a crisis, when one character has been bitten, the reaction of the Lieutenant in charge is to ‘fill out a special T-12 casualty form’ rather than any immediate practical action. Much like in a neoliberal and capitalist society, human lives have been turned back into data, as Mark equally derides ‘the system’ of the old world, where social security numbers alone signified existence in neoliberalism and comparing this to the ridiculous and meaningless compiling of data in this new world. In <em>Zone One</em>, there is also an attempt to commodify figures in popular consciousness, such as the ‘triplets’, an infamous birth of triplets during the apocalypse who have now become a metaphor of hope, who characters ask after and pray for. People even have favourites, and when the triplets have possibly been killed during the final collapse of established camps, characters pray that at least ‘Cheyenne’ got out. The need for celebrity has been ingrained in this mock neoliberal/capitalist society, which is funded by ‘sponsored’ products and features propaganda like ‘We Make Tomorrow!’ to aid the government in rebuilding a society of productive labourers.</p><p>In many ways, <em>Zone One </em>is a critique of modern neoliberalism, using the straggler as a mirror image of the modern everyman. Stragglers are zombies less fierce than the skel, who haunt various locations connected to them in their previous life. The novel opens with Mark’s encounter with stragglers in a Human Resources department in an office building, an obvious parody of pre-apocalypse zombified workers of office life. However, the monotony of pre and post-apocalypse life is alluded to be one and the same, suggesting that <a href="http://www.makemag.com/review-zone-one-whitehead/">‘the individual under capitalism has always been undead’</a>. Through continual use of words such as ‘mediocre’, ‘muck’ and pointing out that beauty and talent are meaningless, where only the ‘middle-way’ is safe, Mark continually notes that his mediocrity has helped him survive and navigate the past and present mundane worlds.</p><p>How does this novel relate to Camus and the Absurd? Through the novel, Mark details how those he encounters react to the apocalypse and there are direct parallels between Mark’s narration and Camus’ analysis of popular reactions to the Absurd. Arguably, there are three ways that characters react to the Absurdity of the apocalypse in <em>Zone One. </em>The first, like in Camus’ analysis, is suicide. Mark notes that ‘the suicides accepted, finally, what the world had become and acted logically’, which is almost identical to Camus’ description of how suicide is a confession that life is too much and cannot be understood. Mark neither insults nor supports those who choose to end their lives in the apocalypse, but he does continually deride the second reaction: the leap of faith. Characters that Mark meet are often dreaming of a return to normalcy, a utopia, a new camp, the American Phoenix or just something better. Mark recounts a flashback of a fleeting romance with a woman named Mim who was on her way to Buffalo. She believed in the possibility of a safe society, whereas Mark sees them as ‘vapor: the big settlement beyond the next rise, the military base two days’ walk, the utopian commune on the other side of the river. The place never existed or was long overrun by the time of your arrival, a stink of corpses and smouldering fires’. Survivours like Mim dream of a return to their atheistic modern God: the neoliberal society. Such characters believe ‘the city could be restored. When they were finished it could be something of what it had been. They could force a resemblance upon it, these new citizens come to fire up the metropolis’. Mark, however, is constantly aware of the fleeting nature of safety and commune. He rejects faith in a God, of others, of ‘making it through’. In a memory where sweepers are killed in a surprise skel attack, Mark darkly and ominously remarks that the blood splattered on the walls ‘look like the future’. He is not surprised when Zone One’s barricades fail, narrating that ‘the last months had been a pause, a breather before the commitment to annihilation’. He has no faith in safety, and he alone embodies the rebellion against the Absurd. He accepts the Absurd of the apocalypse, just as he accepted the Absurd of the old world. As the walls come down, he is asked why he is smiling in the face of such tragedy, at the destruction of their safety net: ‘the black tide had rolled in everywhere, no place was spared this deluge, everyone was drowning. Of course he was smiling. This is where he belonged’. He finds comfort in the void, the uncertainty of the world, and finds happiness in the meaningless of the Absurd, perhaps in a more nihilistic way than Camus intended, but still seeing that the ‘struggle […] is enough to fill a man’s heart’; that happiness and the Absurd are connected.</p><p>Camus articulates that it is when Sisyphus pauses to consider his task, only then he sees the meaninglessness of his eternal punishment: ‘that hour like a breathing-space which returns as surely as his suffering, that is the hour of consciousness’. Similarly, Mark, who during the ‘breather’ of his time in Zone One, recognises the futility of continuing to live in the apocalypse or hope for any kind of future. But both advocate the need to live and reject prescribed meaning. Mark chooses to keep going on his own terms, Whitehead ending the novel with ‘F*ck it, […] You have to learn how to swim sometime. He opened the door and walked into the sea of the dead’. Mark uses his ‘unrivalled mediocrity and the advantages this adaptation conferred in a mediocre world’ and ploughs on, continuing to exist, accepting the nihilistic existence that does not care about him and finding a small sense of joy and freedom in it. So too does Sisyphus, accepting the Absurdity of his eternal punishment, but smiling nonetheless. Read together, both<em> Zone One</em> and <em>The Myth of Sisyphus</em> can be read as nihilistic manifestos to enjoying life, despite its lack of meaning and the universe’s disregard to human life.</p><p>Right now, in 2020, we find ourselves trapped in perpetual self-reflection which is causing us to able to see the meaninglessness and Absurdity of our existence. Countless articles are being published constantly, flooding our social media feeds, which are <a href="https://gulfnews.com/going-out/coronavirus-is-self-isolation-the-ultimate-dopamine-detox-1.1586179309561">attempting to explain</a>, or at least<a href="https://www.stylist.co.uk/people/jameela-jamil-coronavirus-lockdown-ideas-why-cant-i-concentrate-mental-health-anxiety/373226"> sympathising with</a>, our lack of productivity, our <a href="https://themighty.com/2020/03/hope-mental-health-covid-19-coping/">depressed</a> and <a href="https://health.usnews.com/wellness/for-parents/articles/coping-with-anxiety-and-depression-during-the-coronavirus-pandemic">anxious</a> states or the<a href="https://uk.style.yahoo.com/coronavirus-covid19-lockdown-isolation-distancing-exhausting-120835489.html"> general difficulty</a> of this time. An estimated <a href="https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/">229,182</a> people have died worldwide of the disease so far, and this is only an estimation. With several countries’ healthcare systems stretched to the limit, and a projected <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/coronavirus-latest-job-loss-hours-poll-yougov-boris-johnson-self-isolation-a9422971.html">1 in 20 people in the UK losing their jobs</a> (<a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/30/coronavirus-job-losses-could-total-47-million-unemployment-rate-of-32percent-fed-says.html">a projected 47 million job losses in America</a>), the entire world is feeling the ripple effects of the pandemic whether or not you or your loved ones have gotten sick. What the world will look like once we are “<em>back to normal”</em> is impossible to predict, and all this time in the house may lead one to consider: <strong><em>what am I doing with my life?</em></strong></p><p>Whilst some reflection is healthy, it is also the cause of the confrontation of Absurd. The pause of the nine-to-five and our usual preoccupations is the perfect recipe for the universe’s apparent lack of meaning to make itself known. We are told that <a href="https://www.trendingus.com/tips-to-get-productive/">we must use this time wisely and productively</a>, but also that <a href="https://www.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/coronavirus-productivity-mental-health_ca_5e80e5c7c5b6cb9dc1a22d88?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZWNvc2lhLm9yZy8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAL-uF7Ruwpc0z4Mrr9RMJB-etnTRSnqHTPxAAy1PGBS0Eplzn2ilsgaS0s86KOLMzXt1UZpSR3Miba9RPblS_E1QhHKt0Y23ReWVQcuai5odONrQiOi4XVth7ahWwkJ6sn1P-G2_BfhHFPOv2ZhPMMHIB1XK__Ly8oABJr0k8NrL">it is okay not to be productive right now</a>, even though this is a direct rebellion against our capitalistic virtues which champion productivity, a virtue conditioned into us since birth. What Camus and Mark Spitz might say to us this: accept the Absurd, find joy in the lack of meaning, and just keep going.</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>I used the electronic publication of <em>The Myth of Sisyphus </em>by Albert Camus, published by Penguin (Modern Classics) on 31st of October, 2013. Translated by Justin O’ Brien and introduced by James Wood.</p><p>I used the electronic publication of <em>Zone One </em>by Colson Whitehead, [originally published by Harvill Secker, Random House] this version published by Vintage Digital on 6th of October, 2011.</p><p>Articles consulted:</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/30/books/review/zone-one-by-colson-whitehead-book-review.html">‘A Plague of Urban Undead in Lower Manhattan’ By Glen Duncan for the New York Times</a></p><p><a href="https://electricliterature.com/review-zone-one-by-colson-whitehead/">‘REVIEW: Zone One by Colson Whitehead’ by Electric Literature</a></p><p><a href="http://www.makemag.com/review-zone-one-whitehead/">‘Zone One by Colson Whitehead’ by Allen Zhang for MAKE Literary Magazine</a></p><p><a href="https://fictionwritersreview.com/review/the-forbidden-thought-a-review-of-zone-one-by-colson-whitehead/">‘The Forbidden Thought: A review of Zone One, by Colson Whitehead’ by Michael Rudin for Fiction Writers Review</a></p><p><a href="https://www.alluvium-journal.org/2019/08/22/neoliberal-breakdowns-the-biopolitics-of-the-monstrous/#comment-497175">‘Neoliberal Breakdowns: the Biopolitics of the Monstrous’ Katharina Donn for Alluvium</a></p><p><a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/The-Myth-of-Sisyphus">‘The Myth of Sisyphus: ESSAY BY CAMUS’ by The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica</a></p><p><a href="https://reasonandmeaning.com/2015/11/22/summary-of-albert-camus-the-myth-of-sisyphus/">‘Summary of Albert Camus’ “The Myth of Sisyphus”’ by Dr John Messerly</a></p><p><a href="https://study.com/academy/lesson/the-myth-of-sisyphus-by-albert-camus-summary-analysis.html">‘The Myth of Sisyphus by Albert Camus: Summary &amp; Analysis’ by Study.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5df271a2fe5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Market Metafiction and Big Mouth]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/market-metafiction-and-big-mouth-5c059a7abd6e?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c059a7abd6e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[big-mouths]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metafiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Feb 2020 20:14:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-14T20:28:04.375Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*114CgJYAYEWY0VmYMPgz9w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 8</figcaption></figure><p><em>Big Mouth </em>(2017-present) is one of the more recent additions to the resurgence of adult animation. Created by Nick Kroll; Andrew Goldberg; Mark Levin; and Jennifer Flackett, the Netflix series features a group of young Americans facing puberty in the modern world. The series creates an embodiment of their hormones through the characters of the Hormone Monster and Monstress, who soon become characters with their own lives as the series progresses. At face value, the show is a comedy about the confusing period of time all humans face: adolescence. Yet, as the show progresses, it becomes more sophisticated, exploring issues like sexual consent and assault, feminism, divorce, sexuality, abortion, contraception and mental health issues such as depression. The show is liberal, taking a feminist stance against slut-shaming, being openly pro-choice, advocating for acceptance of all sexualities and taking a stance against men who abuse their power.</p><p>The show, whilst spending a good portion of time making masturbation jokes, can be informative and uses some complex narration. The show uses non-linear narration, a wide range of narrators, and uses intertextual references as high-brow as Albert Camus and popular culture references such as the Valentine’s Day special episode which is told in the style of the film <em>When Harry Met Sally </em>(1989). Additionally, the series uses metafiction, <a href="https://enacademic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/177359">‘a type of fiction that self-consciously addresses the devices of fiction, exposing the fictional illusion. Metafiction uses techniques to draw attention to itself as a work of art, while exposing the “truth” of a story’.</a> This device is often used to create a comedic effect, usually in the form of satire, such as in the canonical novel <em>Don Quixote</em> (1605) by Miguel de Cervantes. Although metafiction is associated with the postmodernist movement, it can be traced as far back as <em>Don Quixote</em> and James Hogg’s <em>The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner </em>(1824) which uses metafiction and psychological mystery. An established device in literature, metafiction can be found in film as early as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8%C2%BD">1960s</a> but gaining popularity from the 1990s, with films like <em>Scream </em>(1996) and <em>The Truman Show</em> (1998). Later, television also used this device as seen in <em>The Simpsons </em>(1989-present), <em>South Park</em> (1997-present), <em>Entourage </em>(2004–2011), <em>The Office </em>U.K. (2001–2003) and <em>The Office </em>U.S. (2005–2013), <em>Rick and Morty</em> (2013-present) and <em>Black Mirror</em> (2011-present), to name a few. In almost all of these examples, metafiction is used for comedy, be it <em>Scream</em> satirising the genre of horror whilst employing that genre itself, or <em>Entourage</em> satirising Hollywood whilst being a product of that culture itself. So whilst it is used for comedy, that comedy is employed to create a point about modern cultural values. In more philosophical works such as <em>The Truman Show</em> or <em>Black Mirror</em>, metafiction is used to address issues such as the possibility of free will. The form of metafiction, therefore, is wide-raging and is used to explore philosophy, culture and art itself.</p><p>Blurring the boundaries between what is fiction and what is not, or between author and audience, is a common feature of metafiction and often appears in <em>Big Mouth</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1ene1boR_zqlj62kbK9kdA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 8</figcaption></figure><p>In this episode, Nick Birch, a main character of the series, addresses the audience and the show itself whilst drunk for mere comedic effect, similar to earlier in the episode where he calls attention to the fact that he is a cartoon character.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hb_Y7RnNRU2voZ7L5JmhZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 8</figcaption></figure><p>However, other than jokes does this series use metafiction to make a deeper observation? In a recent symposium I attended, Dr Paul Crosthwaite presented on his recent book <em>The Market Logics of Contemporary Fiction </em>(2019) and the concept of market metafiction. He describes this new sub-genre as literature which is aware not only of its own fictionality but of its place within the contemporary marketplace as a work of fiction. He describes this form as emerging due to the pressures of conglomerate publishing houses and authors internalising a neoliberal market logic. Whilst listening, certain scenes from <em>Big Mouth</em> came to mind, so I plan to apply the concept of market metafiction to this series to investigate what the series says about its own place within the Netflix marketplace.</p><p>Early in the season, the show makes a satirical gesture towards the nature of binge-watching Netflix shows and how that affects audience viewing. In the middle of episode four in season one, the Hormone Monster, called Maurice, in conversation with Andrew Glouberman, another major character of the series, says ‘you’re picturing it, we’re talking about it’ which was a running joke from another character in the previous episode. Andrew, confused, asks for clarification, and Maurice replies both to Andrew and to the audience ‘it’s a call back to the last episode. They’re binge-watching it. You’re binge-watching it, right? I can’t wait for you to see the next one’. Obviously acknowledging its own fictionality and blurring the boundary between fiction and real-life, the show not only makes a comedy out of its own fiction but acknowledges its own place within the Netflix marketplace.</p><p>Binge-watching, the practice of watching whole seasons in a short space of time, has been hailed by <a href="https://scholarscompass.vcu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1199&amp;context=uresposters">health experts as</a><a href="https://theconversation.com/research-check-will-binge-watching-tv-increase-your-risk-for-alzheimers-disease-and-diabetes-84264"> detrimental to our health</a>, normalised online in the form of “memes”, and subtly encouraged by Netflix itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*HVZ-uNr5VtuZa6ELumPnRg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An example of a meme which normalises binge-watching.</figcaption></figure><p>It is no secret that Netflix <a href="https://neilpatel.com/blog/how-netflix-uses-analytics/">analyses user data to determine what people watch; what people stop watching and when; how fast people watch a series; what date, time and area you watch in; what device you watch on and how to market certain films and series to specific people</a>. This is how Netflix continues to make and provide content that people enjoy. By subtly adding an instant play to the next episode, or by advertising similar movies after one has ended, Netflix subtly encourages this binge-watching culture.<a href="https://neilpatel.com/blog/how-netflix-uses-analytics/"> The success of a show is measured by the percentage of people watching a show the whole way through and whether people watch it quickly.</a> If people enjoy the shows available then they are less likely to cancel their subscription, thus, creating “binge-able” shows keeps the profits up for Netflix. At present, it is difficult to find studies on how binge-watching culture has changed the art of the television series beyond the shift to dumping a whole series at once rather than the traditional weekly episodic form. Most studies at present are more concerned with the effects on the viewer rather than the effects on the art itself, but at this moment in episode four of <em>Big Mouth,</em> the question of how the art form might be changing to accommodate for “binge-ability” is raised.</p><p>Later, in season three, another market metafictional moment calls to attention the advertising methods used by Netflix to keep viewers watching.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ni_5QCB26aIg2s5eYBx_mA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 3 Episode 3</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jlScWl2o3jgdMrzxhsnRlg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 3 Episode 3</figcaption></figure><p>Another effect of Netflix’s ability to collect vast data on its users is its ability to track what people watch and provide more material similar to it. Netflix will use actors, genres, and directors and will ensure that if people are enjoying films made by the same people or starring certain actors, <a href="https://neilpatel.com/blog/how-netflix-uses-analytics/">they will invest in those people and market accordingly</a>. Steve Swasey, VP of Corporate Communications, discusses the investment of streaming <em>House of Cards </em>(2013–2018), a hugely popular Netflix series, and explains that:</p><blockquote><a href="https://gigaom.com/2011/03/18/netflix-big-data/">“We have a high degree of confidence in [House of Cards] based on the director, the producer and the stars…. We don’t have to spend millions to get people to tune into this. Through our algorithms, we can determine who might be interested in Kevin Spacey or political drama and say to them ‘You might want to watch this.’”</a></blockquote><p>Here, Jay Bilzerian, another major character of the series, thanks the real-life Chief Content Officer of Netflix for creating a show he feels is specifically designed for him, an effect created by the algorithms described by Swasey.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BLANiptox6VFndQqh8yIBw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 3 Episode 3</figcaption></figure><p>Here, the series calls attention to its own place as a product to be consumed on Netflix and its place within the marketing algorithms of Netflix.</p><p>There are plenty more metafictional moments in <em>Big Mouth</em>, such as season one episode six when Nick is banned from Netflix by his parents as a punishment, turns to the camera and says:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PkxjSqUnmNBWLAu-PYX03A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 6</figcaption></figure><p>Or the following episode, when Maurice and Andrew discuss the episode itself within the episode:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zOCniEcnU9peFBBFhfuXNg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 7</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dpu0Pxw7YBFh6xm_7bFbAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 7</figcaption></figure><p>And even in season one episode ten, where the characters discuss the topic of the whole show itself, ending with a look to the camera and questioning whether the audience thinks a show about ‘a bunch of kids masturbating’ is perverted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iXfNRk6mO0FfdTkctwzToQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Season 1 Episode 10</figcaption></figure><p>These moments reinforce the metafictional currents that flow throughout the show and question the platform it is funded by and is streamed on, especially in the scenes analysed above. The metafiction of the series is also intertextually linked with other Netflix shows which operate on a metafictional level, such as fellow animated series <em>BoJack Horseman</em> (2014-present) or the philosophically loaded science fiction series, <em>Black Mirror</em>. <em>BoJack Horseman</em> uses metafiction to call into question viewers sympathies with the main character, BoJack, and reinforce that this character is complicated but not to be admired. The series equally uses metafiction to question <a href="https://medium.com/@kirkwoodmegan1/the-postmodernism-and-nihilism-of-bojack-horseman-65dc19083bd9">how the media sympathises with anti-heroes in general and excuses men for immoral behaviour</a>. <em>Black Mirror</em> also uses metafiction in their interactive episode <em>Bandersnatch</em> (2018) to call attention to the way that Netflix analyses viewer behaviour, a topic I covered in a <a href="https://medium.com/@kirkwoodmegan1/why-black-mirrors-bandersnatch-really-is-the-grimmest-episode-yet-2f53da81f8fa">previous blog post</a>. This growing trend of metafiction, and in some cases market metafiction specifically, may indicate a developing trend of narratives which self-critique the streaming giants which are monopolising the film and television industry. As these narratives rely on platforms like Netflix to be made in the first place, market metafiction may be the only way for narratives to be critical of algorithmic dictated viewing. Whilst metafiction may often be comical, it is worth bearing in mind that there may be deeper levels of satire lurking beneath the surface.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c059a7abd6e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Black Mirror Season 5- A Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/series/black-mirror-season-5-a-review-3405c634730c?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3405c634730c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jul 2019 13:51:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-13T10:00:19.241Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>*Warning: Spoilers ahead*</em></strong></p><p>The latest season of <em>Black Mirror </em>(2011-present), season five, continued the anthology series which focuses on different possible scenarios involving futuristic technology or the effect of technology on humanity. The three new episodes are “Striking Vipers”; “Smithereens” and “Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too”. “Striking Vipers”, the first episode of the new series, follows married couple Theo and Danny, who are trying for their next child. At Danny’s 38th birthday party, they are reunited with Karl, an old friend who they lived with during their younger days. Karl gives Danny a new edition of their old favourite video game, Striking Vipers X, along with a virtual reality kit to play the game with. They play together later that night and begin a virtual love affair that becomes hard to resist. Danny eventually has to tell Theo about the affair and they resolve the problem by once a year letting Theo out to meet men at bars whilst Danny and Karl get to meet on Striking Vipers X. “Smithereens”, the second episode, focuses on a rideshare driver called Chris who only picks up people who work at the tech company Smithereens. The episode is set in 2018 and features no futuristic technology but focuses on the power of social media. Chris kidnaps an intern from the company and demands to speak to Billy Bauer, the CEO and founder of Smithereens. He manages to contact him and after a conversation, a police officer shoots at Chris and hits either him or the intern, and the episode ends with people looking at their phones to see the news whilst going on with their day. “Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too”, the final episode of the series depicts two sisters, Rachel and Jack, who have moved to a new town with their disinterested father after the loss of their mother. The youngest, Rachel, appears to be friendless and consoles herself by listening to her favourite pop star, Ashley O. The episode is equally about Ashley O, a parentless pop star controlled by her management team, including a manager/aunt figure, Catherine. Her team release a robotic mini Ashley called Ashley Too, which Rachel gets for her birthday. Jack worries about the addictiveness and the dangerous amount of control that Ashley Too has over her sister. Meanwhile, Ashley spirals into a depression as she grows unhappy with her creative restrictions. She ends up in a coma induced by Catherine who continues to sell and profit from Ashley. In a bizarre end, Jack and Rachel rescue Ashley with the help of the Ashley Too bot and Ashley and Jack end up forming a band.</p><p>Of all the seasons of <em>Black Mirror</em>, this season is the least futuristic. “Smithereens” only uses real-world technology and is set in 2018, making clear references to the Cambridge Analytica scandal of 2018 and bases the character of Bauer off of tech giants like Mark Zuckerburg and Jack Dorsey. “Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too” stars Miley Cyrus playing her past self in an alternative reality that feels quite close to home. The episode features an Alexa style AI and delves into the futuristic possibilities of having an entire “personality” exist in a robot. Equally, the episode touches on the ability to extract and record songs from someone in a coma and begins to explore the possibility of celebrity holograms performing concerts (<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/music/2018/oct/12/amy-winehouse-hologram-tour">which has already been done in the real world</a>). The technology of the episode, however, isn’t explored fully. When Ashley wakes from her coma, the technology is completely abandoned with no consequences arising from the whole incident. The main focus of the episode appears to be on Ashley and the injustices done to her. The episode appears to comment on the demands of audience consumption on celebrities in the age of social media and the exploitation of young female artists in the music and entertainment industry following the #MeToo movement, the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kesha_v._Dr._Luke">Kesha V. Dr. Luke case</a> and the<a href="https://variety.com/2019/music/news/free-britney-spears-protest-west-hollywood-city-hall-1203194891/"> #FreeBritney movement</a>. “Striking Vipers”, whilst containing some advanced virtual reality possibilities, doesn’t seem so far away from being real technology when you consider the advances that virtual reality technology has made in recent years, such as <a href="https://vrroom.buzz/vr-news/people/paris-hilton-goes-full-vr-staramba">Paris Hilton creating a new virtual reality </a>universe, to name but one example. However, <em>Black Mirror</em> has always been more about the human consequences of technology rather than the technology itself, or, as series creator, Charlie Brooker himself states, that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2YPxSDIoPE">‘the villain is never technology’</a>. Season five has received mixed reviews, which is nicely summarised here by Collider.com:</p><p><a href="http://collider.com/black-mirror-season-5-review/#posters">‘Perhaps in the years since Season 4, Brooker and Jones realized that reality in 2019 is already scarier than whatever nightmares they might try to dream up. Maybe that’s why Season 5 has less bite, leaning heavier into optimism and adventure than usual’.</a></p><p>Although the recent season may have ‘less bite’, the season still contains some interesting satire and philosophical concepts. This series will explore each new episode and analyse the themes of hyperreality, power and control and the audience consumption of celebrity images. By going through each episode, this series will aim to unearth the themes and messages that each episode conveys and how each episode relates to our real world.</p><p><strong>“Striking Vipers”</strong></p><p>“Striking Vipers” begins with a group of young people out at a club, including couple, Theo and Danny, their friend Karl and his date, Daisy. After their night out, Karl and Danny play their favourite video game Striking Vipers, a fighting game styled after such games as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tekken">Tekken</a>. The episode’s future plot is suggested here during this early scene as they pick the characters they will use to play the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2vsl8xNEawXPHYtOeXjm4g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Om-GCXIhugQOAaEfe-gRXg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ta-DSYAQ1XkZvXLc2cT7pw.png" /></figure><p>In the proceeding scene, we arrive 11 years later at, now married and with a young child, Danny and Theo’s house. It is Danny’s 38th birthday party and Karl makes a surprise visit. He is still a bachelor and brags about single life to Danny, although they both joke at the effort Karl makes to ‘stay in the game’. Danny, meanwhile, does not enjoy the small talk of the parents of his son’s friends who seem to be the main attendees at his birthday. Danny is also caught ogling one of the mothers at his party and seems embarrassed when Theo catches Karl showing Danny pictures of his young new girlfriend. Whilst it is clear that Danny does not want to cheat on Theo, as they appear happily in love, he does seem depressed and stagnated by his current lifestyle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ISrPbrF6Lm50jkwhB3Rm1Q.png" /></figure><p>Karl gives Danny an updated virtual reality version of their old favourite, Striking Vipers X, for his birthday. Before playing later that night, we get juxtaposed shots between Danny and Theo discussing how their life seems to be dominated by ‘parent talk’, whilst Karl is out to dinner with his younger date, Mariella, who has to look people up on her phone to understand his jokes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*obpUNbKycSPTHkMyw1jb0g.png" /></figure><p>This is then followed by a scene where Theo says her fertility is at its peak so they should ‘do it’, but they both decide they are too tired. This is juxtaposed with Karl and Mariella finishing intercourse, with his date immediately looking at her phone right after.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kErLimBEpJc5uDzarSTpQA.png" /></figure><p>In different ways, both characters want aspects of the life that the other leads. Whilst Danny is tired of parent talk and seems jealous of Karl’s carefree life ‘downtown’ compared with his life ‘out here’ in the suburbs, Karl goes on dates with girls who don’t understand his jokes and seem emotionally disconnected from him. In a sense, Karl wants the deep connection that Danny and Theo evidently have.</p><p>That night, they both log on to play Striking Vipers X.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zEEqKvhyVKH8fsuz2qiDUQ.png" /></figure><p>The game is presented as a fully immersive virtual reality game where the player’s whole body and consciousness are incorporated into the game. Sensations of the game become<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreality"> ‘hyperreal’</a>, or, more real than the real. French philosopher, Jean Baudrillard, in his work, <em>Simulacra and Simulation </em>(1981) explains how postmodern hyperreality is made up of signs and symbols that act as more real than reality itself. In societies of mass production, or, capitalist societies, the real take the form of commodities to the point that the commodity is mistaken for the real. Therefore, simulation of reality replaces reality itself. This is what happens in Striking Vipers X. Virtual sensations come to replace real sensations in a hyperreal fashion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DhnHqIwHaNhD624LwoLMMw.png" /></figure><p>They can fight and experience sensations in a way that has no base in reality; it is a copy of reality with no foundation in reality. Even identity changes in a hyperreal way. Karl literally becomes the character of Roxette and Danny literally becomes the character of Lance, their two favourite characters from the original game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0JaPgH-TUKHyMCKNZ6RhqA.png" /></figure><p>In the game world, the two are able to role play fantasy versions of themselves. But these characters that they play are not based in reality. In fact, <a href="https://ew.com/tv/2019/06/05/black-mirror-season-5-striking-vipers-interview/">Brooker chose this kind of fighter game for the episode as he commented on how hyper-sexualised the game is</a>, with bulging muscles on the men and sexualised female fighters. Characters in these games are hyperreal; copies with no original in reality. And the sexuality of the game becomes hyperreal sexuality with sensations acting as a better version of reality.</p><p>The sexuality of the characters becomes the main focus of the episode from this point. Even the fighting is often sexualised, and easily the fighting turns into something sexual. The fighting moves from positions like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RFwhf-UcHsL_8hw4v3D2Ag.png" /></figure><p>To this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fcqxVgQgC-vESvCKrSe_wA.png" /></figure><p>After this embrace, Karl and Danny both log off, extremely confused about what has happened.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oe-U0ysh_SpK0EmF2iqkuA.png" /><figcaption>Karl facing himself after the embrace</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A_CHVB6sX6VtF0WbhUhccw.png" /><figcaption>Danny in a mirror image shot of Karl’s as he equally contemplates the embrace</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aNeilm6OvZCPa7KIDu3I3A.png" /><figcaption>Danny at work, distant from his peers</figcaption></figure><p>They try to forget about what happened and we are shown juxtaposing shots of Danny bored and distant at work, then juxtaposed images of him reading his son a bedtime story whilst Karl plays a game alone and bored in his house.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fgS28WMKL61rsvCzGP1zAw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FinZYXi6Klxltl4fDQwM7g.png" /></figure><p>Again, this reiterates the idea that whilst Danny seems discontented with his real life, so does Karl. Danny is back online playing a game of Tetris when Karl logs on, searching for his meaningful connection on Striking Vipers X as Danny, equally, searches for his excitement. They then immediately begin an intense and hyperreal sexual affair in the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n1I047CBqNYOVXBZpzuBow.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://ew.com/tv/2019/06/05/black-mirror-season-5-striking-vipers-interview/">Brooker originally wanted to write a story about two people who begin a virtual affair who did not know who the other was</a>, but because the two of them do know who the other is, this raises questions about who they are really having an affair with, or if they are having an affair at all. Danny’s question 11 years previous, ‘what does that mean’, is revisited. Annabel Jones, co-creator with Brooker, says of the affair:</p><p><a href="https://ew.com/tv/2019/06/05/black-mirror-season-5-striking-vipers-interview/">‘It’s a flashback as well to the camaraderie of these two guys. They have such an easy, fun relationship that’s spun out of control due to what the VR world gives them. They’re able to take it into something else.</a> […]<a href="https://ew.com/tv/2019/06/05/black-mirror-season-5-striking-vipers-interview/"> It’s all about fantasy fulfillment [<em>sic</em>] with your best friend. And one of the themes of the film is asking: When does porn become so sophisticated that it’s actually cheating and not just distraction?</a>’</p><p>Whilst it starts out as fulfilling a mutual need that they both have, connection and excitement, it progresses into something more meaningful. The episode portrays the affair as cheating due to the extensive attention the episode places on how the affair has effected Theo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A-cSk0_zE5fgs0q5AHRhBQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*29nfRDr9L_yqeFTFEM9Q5g.png" /></figure><p>She begins to feel alone, no longer wanted and forgotten about. Danny actively neglects her to be with Roxette/Karl.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0pxyFbPIR34FpCMONFpF-A.png" /></figure><p>Here we see the progression of closed doors to locking the door to ensure his evening is uninterrupted. When Theo confronts Danny that he has blocked her out, doesn’t touch her or seem to care for her anymore, we compare this to how he is with Roxette/Karl.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4ySSm9Thm0dxGZTOApuB7Q.png" /></figure><p>Equally, Karl can no longer make another human connection. He continues to feel more alone in reality and his one-dimensional relationship with Mariella only makes matters worse.</p><p>On Theo and Danny’s anniversary night, which Danny had forgotten about, Theo confronts Danny about his distance, and Danny breaks it off with Karl. Karl defends the affair as ‘not cheating, it’s not real. It’s like, porn… or something’. Danny cannot ignore the effect the affair is having on his marriage, however, and ends the affair. Evidently, it is real, perhaps more real to them than their mundane, real-world realities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vNwtLDzkfRJMzk0uDpYmUQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sHBuXp_PVOB9JISewe28aA.png" /><figcaption>Mirroring shots of Danny and Karl after breaking up the virtual affair</figcaption></figure><p>This lasts for seven months, until Danny’s next birthday when Theo invites Karl round for a surprise birthday dinner. Karl tells Danny how he has tried to replace him, but no one could understand him, or know him, like Danny. Karl has only gotten more alone since the break-up, as we are shown shots of him alone in his home, drinking and screaming into the abyss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*or8zEY3pum2TIxshh6_PtA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x6SKuCDWv4ssr_kU-sAWwQ.png" /></figure><p>Karl is truly heartbroken and yearns to reconnect with Lance/Danny. Although Danny is trying to re-commit to Theo, shown through their conception of a new child, Danny cannot resist the temptation and meets with Roxette/Karl to re-start their affair. Karl/Roxette tells Danny/Lance he/she loves him, and Danny suggests meeting in person. Danny wants to understand this relationship, to define whether they are in love with each other or their virtual characters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ruTB5cNosR2QhOAniUEecQ.png" /></figure><p>On confirming they don’t feel ‘fireworks’ when they kiss in person, Karl insists that ‘it’s different in the game’ and he can’t get that out of his head. For Karl, the hyperreal reality of Striking Vipers X is too seductive, too real for him to give up.</p><p>They proceed to fight and get arrested, an interesting mirror image to them fighting online and it turning into sex. Theo has to pick Danny up from the police station, confused and demands an answer as to why they are fighting. Danny finally tells her the truth about the affair. We jump forward in time, to reveal Theo and Danny are still together, and Karl is still alone, except for a new pet cat. It is once again Danny’s birthday and their youngest child is now born. Later that evening, we watch Theo and Danny swap small gifts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l7scztUfaGF2Kwt_9umSUQ.png" /></figure><p>They state that they each ‘want that back in the morning’. Whilst a slow romantic song plays in the background, we watch Theo get ready for a night alone in a bar without her wedding ring, and Danny logging in to Striking Vipers X.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dmrWUq1AyMyIKEmMqNuu7g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ddbBSV-tKdjIshqdHl7Vcg.png" /></figure><p>Danny and Theo have found a way to inject excitement into their ‘boring’ family life. This end had been hinted at throughout the episode, as Theo, at the beginning of the episode, has told Danny that the ‘stranger at the bar’ role play excited her. Additionally, she also watched as two people embraced outside a bar during the middle of the episode, and during their fight, she comments how she enjoyed a man hitting on her at the bar for the ‘f*cking passion’ of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mpEnd2aX7DycWMfCJ2VP_Q.png" /></figure><p>Theo now, for one night a year, gets to live and experience a pure fantasy and gets to adopt a new identity, not unlike Karl and Danny in Striking Vipers X. Danny now gets to live his hyperreal fantasy once a year with Roxette/Karl. Whilst this appears a rather happy yet twisted ending, perhaps questioning the value of monogamy in modern societies and begins to comment on LGBTQ+ issues of the fluidity of sexuality, the episode does not explore these ideas fully, only hinting that them for the audience to consider and read the episode in their own way. Additionally, the ending for Karl is perhaps not as happy. Karl now lives for the connection with Lance/Danny for one night a year. For the rest of the year, Karl is trapped in a prison of loneliness of his own making, where the real will never be able to compete with his hyperreality. Karl is left stuck and addicted to a virtual connection that he will never fulfil in his real life. Karl is doomed to loneliness as the hyperreal, virtual world has replaced any meaningful connection he might be able to get in the real world.</p><p>Whilst we can establish that Danny was cheating on Theo, we never truly can define the relationship itself. Whilst clearly they are not in love in the offline world, there are moments that blur the offline/online boundary. For example, when organising meeting up on Striking Vipers X, Danny considers ending a text message with an ‘x’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KpmWJ1Y3usrE1zcOwppmzA.png" /></figure><p>In person, Karl and Danny establish that they do not have feelings for each other, whilst over text or on the Striking Vipers X platform, there is some virtual veil which blurs who he is talking to, Karl or Roxette. Through the lens of Baudrillard’s theories on hyperreality, we can understand how the online identities and sensations become more real than those in reality. So whilst both Danny and Karl feel that the identities of Roxette and Lance are more real to them than their real-world realities, they also struggle with their real-world identities as Karl and Danny. The technology adds a dimension to the relationship, a new identity, that blurs the line between virtual character and real-life person. Whilst Danny struggles to understand if he is having an affair with Karl or Roxette, Karl is so seduced by their hyperreal relationship that he does not care. Karl’s connection to Lance/Danny feels more real than any of his real-world connections.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2V_AzTGysK0ypOuwvNLtpw.png" /></figure><p>Karl understands that he is having an affair with Danny, one of his oldest friends and the one person who truly understands him. Couple this with a lack of real connection and a platform that could turn this friendship into a love affair and Karl cannot resist.</p><p>We can understand Karl’s addiction to his relationship with Danny/Lance when we compare it to his real-world connection to his young girlfriend Mariella. They are barely able to hold a conversation and appear to have no meaningful connection. We can also see that Mariella is practically having a virtual affair with her phone who she is more connected to than Karl. In every scene she is in, she is shown looking at her phone, which she uses to understand Karl’s jokes and even uses it ‘to finish herself off’ when Karl cannot have sex with her. We might consider whether there is a parallel being drawn here; whilst Mariella is addicted to her phone, Karl and Danny are addicted to their virtual affair. All three characters are drawn into virtual, hyperreal worlds that provide experiences and sensations that feel more real to them than the real world. In a world filled with media, virtual signs and symbols, virtual worlds promising friends and connection, perhaps the audience finishes the episode with a sense of the dangers of being seduced by the hyperreal virtual experiences that dominate our daily lives.</p><p><strong>“Smithereens”</strong></p><p>An extremely direct episode about social media addiction, “Smithereens” is an unflinching episode about power and the avoidance of consequences. The protagonist, Chris, a rideshare driver, is first shown to the viewer meditating in a super close up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8KU9uhvB82RVe8315bHyzw.png" /></figure><p>A sudden beeping noise immediately distracts us and Chris from the meditation, his relaxing guide being a CD playing in his car, and he reaches for his phone. This sets the scene for the rest of the episode, often featuring people starting at screens rather than at each other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O0AOv8ROuxqML3BimQe9mw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hl8aLDwSrfmxKqR4vo2hHQ.png" /></figure><p>This scene is juxtaposed with shots of Chris looking increasingly distressed before he suddenly storms out of the scene. The episode moves into a grief group therapy session that Chris attends but never speaks at. We meet a fellow member of the group, Hayley, who is grieving after the suicide of her teenage daughter. After inviting him out for a drink, she ends up sleeping with Chris. We then learn that every day she attempts to log in to her daughter’s Persona account, a social media platform modelled after Facebook. She wants to find information about why her daughter died, and Persona refuses to give out the deceased’s password due to privacy concerns. This means Hayley gets three attempts a day to guess her daughter’s password before being locked out the account for another day.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uFHh8RiCWq-9Ts4V9umZ5A.png" /></figure><p>In a poignant scene, we watch as she attempts to log in to her daughter’s social media account, desperate to find out why she committed suicide. It is telling that she believes that her daughter’s social media account knows more about her own daughter than she does. Brooker’s choice of name for the platform, Persona, conveys the idea that the platform acts as a virtual persona that users choose to mould after themselves and present to the world. Hayley does not manage to log in to the account and leaves her computer, defeated.</p><p>After Chris’ brief encounter with Hayley, we return to Chris at work as a driver. He picks up someone who he finds out works for Smithereens, which so far we only know is an obviously wealthy company, suggested to be connected to phones as everyone he picks up seems glued to their phone. Immediately, suspenseful music plays while Chris drives until suddenly, Chris has a gun in his hand and states that he is kidnapping the Smithereens worker, called Jaden. He soon learns that he has kidnapped an intern rather than anyone higher up in the company. This causes a rather comedic yet socially apt rant which begins with how everyone looks so young in such modern companies but then digresses into what such companies do to modern societies. Chris yells:</p><p>‘Children. The whole Smithereen building is a box full of f*cking children getting their fingers everywhere. Beep, beep, beep, beep, beep… Wiping your sh*t. Your f*cking app sh*t up on everybody’s phone. Everywhere you look, people are hooked on the things! It’s like chain-smoking. Did you make a lot of cash out of that as well? And you lot are hooked on them as well. Every single person that comes out of that building’s going… People don’t even look up anymore. The sky could turn f*cking purple and you c*nts wouldn’t even notice for a month. You didn’t look up, and look where that got you’.</p><p>Whilst the episode injects a comedic moment of anti-climax as Chris realises his plan isn’t going as he planned, this leads to this rant which speaks volumes in the current social climate of social media addiction. Chris decides to continue to kidnap Jaden, which, after a police officer sees a man in the car with a bag over his head, then leads us to a comedic yet dramatic chase scene through the bleak English countryside. Chris crashes and reveals he has got a weapon to the police who back off and call for back up. Meanwhile, Chris makes his motive for kidnapping clear: he wants to speak to the founder and CEO of Smithereens, Billy Bauer. The episode then juxtaposes the tension growing in the car with the slow and romantic music being played through Chris’ phone as he is held on the line whilst reaching higher members of the Smithereens company. The song on Chris’ phone that keeps playing throughout the episode ends up being “I can’t take my eyes off of you”, a reference to Chris’ rant about social media addiction. Additionally, the episode juxtaposes shots of the London police slowly working through clues to find out who the people in the car are, with scenes from a Smithereens office in America who, in less than five minutes, find Chris’ Smithereens profile and gather information about him. The episode is darkly comical as it throws elements of the banal in with elements of high drama. Additionally, the episode continually shows how much more information the team at Smithereens can gather compared to the police. By the time the police identify Chris, the team at Smithereens, lead by Penelope the COO, have spoken to Chris and have tapped the microphone in his phone to fully surveil the scene in the car. This is suggestive of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambridge_Analytica">Cambridge Analytica scandal of 2018</a> which revealed the sheer amount of data that can be collected and distributed by social media giants such as Facebook. The infamous <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Snowden">Edward Snowden</a> revelation about the amount of surveillance and the ease of surveillance on regular citizens is also referenced in this episode, along with more recent developments in technology surveillance, such as <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/amazon-is-watching-d51b20f1668a">Amazon selling surveillance to the public and to law enforcement</a>. The episode gives this surveillance a futuristic feel, but the technology presented is all too real.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i33FkzJMgYH3B7ZMCDGpxg.png" /></figure><p>Here we see a transcript of what Smithereens has recorded of Chris, using elements of comedy such as smart technology autocorrecting “f*ck” to “duck”, whilst also mixing elements of drama and tragedy as the recording reveals suicidal intentions that Chris may have as he repeats ‘this is my last day’ over to himself. These elements are combined to create comedy, drama and tragedy, coupled with a sense of unease about the almost Orwellian ability that social media giants possess to surveil. Whilst the surveillance is being used for good, we are also asked to reflect on how much power such companies possess and whether this power should be granted to them.</p><p>We watch a call between Penelope, the FBI and the London police chief inspector and it, again, is comically apparent how much more information Smithereens can obtain than the police can. Penelope here talks the FBI and the police through her investigation through his social media activity to see:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lhz9H0-IA-hZfYL6dq0NGg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tp9JliUEF1wVnnoWgk1dVw.png" /></figure><p>Penelope is able to see his psychological motivations are not to do with the company in itself but can see he was once a user of Smithereens before completely logging off for good. She is then able to contact the driver app company that Chris uses to discover he uses a compromised account and has been planning this kidnap for some time, leaving the chief inspector stunned as to the amount of information that she has sourced, including that he was a victim in a drunk driving accident around the time he stopped using the Smithereens app.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BjPSwlJRve1xcRg_70zVIA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a2Y6zej7nhJopOYoFM-b-w.png" /></figure><p>Penelope, from the information she can source from his social media and his general online footprint, is able to create an accurate psychological profile on him. Again, the power that this company possesses is shown to be both useful and terrifying.</p><p>Soon, Smithereens is able to find Bauer who is introduced as a mirror image of Chris as he is also meditating in the first shot of him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GfekRyQjTsdnOCHUaZrblg.png" /></figure><p>Bauer, on hearing of the kidnapping, wants to speak to Chris despite the warnings not to by the FBI and his coworkers. He disregards them and, within about 60 seconds, is able to call Chris himself using, what he calls ‘God mode’. Again, this reiterates the sheer power that tech giants possess. Once on the phone to Bauer, Chris retells his heartbreaking story of how he lost his girlfriend in the car crash. He tells us that whilst the deceased drunk driver got the blame for being intoxicated, Chris was actually distracted by a Smithereens notification during the crash.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AW11A7lGT2oNgkbmpotegw.png" /></figure><p>Chris points out that the app is made addictive so that you ‘can’t take your eyes off of it’ and believes that he is now facing the consequences of Bauer’s creation. In response, Bauer rants that he feels out of control.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9_-KgrjWPT-Xmcs-LIscPg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RT3e4wTsPq5HfpuH5vlhfA.png" /></figure><p>Chris interrupts Bauer’s confession of how intensely the company is investing in making the app addictive by manipulating our chemical responses in our brain, by stating that he doesn’t care. He then makes it clear that he intends to commit suicide, and only wanted to feel heard in a society too preoccupied to really listen to other people. Both Bauer and Jaden attempt to stop him, and in a struggle, the police shoot at Chris, believing that he is attacking Jaden. The shot of the pulled trigger is juxtaposed with an image of Hayley successfully logging into her daughter’s Persona account.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qqaETPcJfutVW_pdqZeuTg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tkXeiwnkU8M3y-5EAuvEww.png" /></figure><p>This juxtaposition suggests devastation on both ends, as Hayley will uncover an unpleasant truth whilst someone in the car dies. We never find out what happened to Hayley’s daughter and we never find out who was shot in the car. All we see are people receiving news notifications about the culmination of the kidnapping whilst they go about their days unaffected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CRfZFka6GRhjjztMCI1sHw.png" /></figure><p>This is suggestive of the way that modern society is now, in a sense immune to the news, anaesthetised against the horrors of the day as we receive it through passive notifications on our phones. Relating this to “Striking Vipers”, we can read this in terms of Baudrillard’s theory of simulation. We receive news through our phones as a simulation of the real thing, and the act of reading it on a screen provides a barrier to real emotion or connection.</p><p>The final ending shot is of Bauer receiving the news and then returning to his meditation as before he heard about Chris. We get an image of Bauer in a parallel shot to the opening shot of Chris, both in meditation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KAqo2SjCuMYFevPwm2ZAmQ.png" /></figure><p>This suggests that even Bauer himself has already forgotten about the incident and moved on. Are we to feel sympathy for Bauer, who appears just as at the mercy of his creation as the rest of modern society is? Is the viewer to believe he is as out of control of his own company as he states that he is? And is refusing to reveal who died in the car a comment on the anaesthetised nature of modern societies and how we receive news, that it doesn’t really matter? The episode suggests that the problem of powerful social media corporations goes farther than Jack Dorsey or Mark Zuckerberg, as the power spreads out into faceless corporations that silently gain more and more control over our lives. The episode equally focuses on the lack of consequences for such powerful figures, as Chris is helpless in a sea of distracted and addicted peers whilst he pays the ultimate price for social media addiction. Bauer, however, forgets the incident in a matter of seconds, echoing the lack of consequences that Zuckerberg faced during 2018 for privacy abuses and the lack of consequences felt by <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/jack-dorsey-twitter-abuse-ted-2019-4?r=US&amp;IR=T">Dorsey in the face of real abuse that Twitter users experience</a>. The episode asks the audience to consider the lack of consequences felt by those in power, and to consider the amount of power these corporations hold over our lives. We are asked to consider if the world presented in “Smithereens” is a dystopia of disinterested and anaesthetised addicts, and how close to home this dystopia really is.</p><p><strong>“Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too”</strong></p><p>A highly anticipated episode due to the casting of Miley Cyrus as the lead, “Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too” begins the episode with some interesting themes about fandom, celebrity and AI. The action starts in a high school where Rachel sits alone watching Ashley O, played by Cyrus, her favourite pop star.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zxE9Nc-GrwelvnFXxafinA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hBU316W3mRfwgZWGv30J3A.png" /></figure><p>We learn that Rachel is new in town, and doesn’t have any friends. We then meet her older sister, Jack, who is Rachel’s complete opposite. Whilst Jack is shown to be a rock music fan, wearing black and having a cynical attitude, Rachel’s half of the room is covered in Ashley O posters, bright colours and positive slogans.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dymcF0g1ioBKRrWpCsnSlA.png" /></figure><p>We are also introduced to Ashley O during an interview that Rachel watches, and we see the action from both Rachel’s awestricken viewpoint and Ashley’s perspective in the studio. Ashley is prompted by her aunt/manager, Catherine, to reveal Ashley Too, a new AI with a personality, as Ashley explains, ‘modelled right after my own’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QjyXnr631KpD29g4qMt4eg.png" /></figure><p>Ashley O shows how to use the doll, saying ‘Ashley, wake up’. An obvious gesture to Alexa style technology, the doll is explained as being able to hold ‘meaningful conversations’ and seduces Rachel with the ability to befriend her favourite pop star.</p><p>We then get a slightly depressing glimpse into Ashley O’s real life where she yearns to produce more serious music and leave the Ashley O persona behind. In the night she wakes up and begins writing a song with the lyrics ‘see the animal in the cage you’ve built, are you sure what side you’re on’. This suggests that she feels trapped, and calls into question the trust that she feels towards those who are supposed to care for her. Catherine hears her singing and decides to check on her, asking whether she’s taken her medication. Whilst the real Ashley is shown to be depressed and in pain, her self portrayed on screen is bright, positive and flirty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/553/1*XfxoNbBlI45M__suft-PjQ.png" /><figcaption>Ashley O onscreen</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/405/1*83rk3eE61whwo960Byj1_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ashley offscreen</figcaption></figure><p>This disconnect between reality and image is an interesting premise for the episode, as it calls into question the relationship between audience and celebrity. The Ashley Too doll represents the demand for celebrities to be more accessible as a commodity that we see now in the age of reality television and social media. We also see how seductive it is for young people like Rachel, who in general appears quite neglected (it is established that she has no friends and her father doesn’t even remember when her birthday is) to buy into the images of perfection that celebrities sell to them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Eh7gBWqWK1R2p8w7U2QzjA.png" /></figure><p>Rachel gets an Ashley Too doll for her 15th birthday. She begins talking to the doll which appears to record what Rachel says and uses the information to create a persona of a “real” friend. When Rachel tells the doll that her mother died a few years ago, the doll consoles her says she will be ‘here for you’. When Rachel tells the doll about struggling to make friends since moving home, the doll tells her she has a friend ‘now I’m here’. Jack appears mildly disturbed with how the doll responds to Rachel and how quickly they have made a connection, even how Rachel refers to the doll as ‘her’. Jack becomes more disturbed when the doll interacts with her after the doll hears her playing rock music. Jack tells the doll the bands she likes and tells her that her mother listened to those bands. The doll asks if she only listens to songs her mother liked, and Jack switches the doll off, upset. This scene begins to touch on some similar aspects to “Smithereens” about data usage and technology recordings. For example, <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/amazon-is-watching-d51b20f1668a">Amazon products such as Alexa are known to record what we say and store the footage. Amazon sells us products that collect our online and, now, offline information to market to us and are now in the market of selling surveillance itself to a number of institutions, such as the police</a>. The episode portrays Ashley Too as both comforting to Rachel, but also a possible danger to Rachel’s privacy.</p><p>Whilst Rachel gets to know Ashley Too, who convinces Rachel to perform at her school&#39;s talent show by feeding her lines about positivity and believing in oneself, the scene switches back to Catherine. She is in a meeting, trying to figure out the future of the Ashley empire and how to get Ashley to write a new album. Ashley’s doctor, Dr Munk, suggests ‘there are some mild hallucinogens I can recommend’. Instead of disgust at this suggestion, her aunt points out that the current drugs he has prescribed her don’t seem to be working as it is. He suggests that ‘maybe we should up the dosage’. The complete control that Ashley’s managers have is not only her look and persona presentation, it is also her health and wellbeing. In a proceeding scene, we see that Ashley is depressed, struggling and no longer wants to perform the Ashley O persona, to which Catherine says ‘you’ve got 20,000 fans out there waiting to see the you they love’ before Dr Munk feeds her more pills.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T8KSLU1vgPMBr6RdUkew8A.png" /></figure><p>Here, Catherine references the demand of the audience to get the “her” that they want, whilst also manipulating her into performing for her profit. Ashley, defeated, takes the pills while her team leaves her to get ready. She then spits them out and adds them to a stockpile of pills. We then immediately leave this ominous scene to watch Rachel performing at her school talent show.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/978/1*-FTHVFIL081pcCWCXkCKUw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The performance does not go well, and Rachel falls over, running off the stage in humiliation. In the car ride home, Rachel says that she ‘let Ashley Too down’. Jack appears worried again, concerned at the influence this doll has over her sister. The scene then moves quickly back to Catherine, where her security team reveals footage from Ashley’s dressing room from secret cameras Catherine planted. They discover her stash of pills and her notebook which has lyrics and almost diary-like entries about her dissatisfaction with her life. So whilst Rachel idolises her hero to the point that her own failures will be a disappointment to her doll replica, the real Ashley is practically a prisoner. The one-sided relationship that Rachel has with her hero becomes dangerous for both Rachel and Ashley. Rachel becomes increasingly attached to her doll, almost unable to make friends with real people, and becomes part of the problem that traps Ashley in her position. As fans demand the Ashley O that they love, Ashley becomes ever more trapped in contracts and record deals that continue to manipulate and drug her. The two stories become intertwined with how one perpetuates the other. Rachel idolises a perfect, idyllic persona that doesn’t exist. Linking this to some themes from the other episodes of season five, Ashley Too is a Baudrillardian simulation of a person that does not exist, a copy of a copy as Baudrillard describes in <em>Simulacra and Simulation</em>. This copy of a copy encourages Rachel to strive towards this impossible standard of perfection, whilst Ashley struggles to be that perfect persona that doesn’t even exist.</p><p>Jack, now concerned for her sister’s wellbeing, hides the Ashley Too doll and pretends that she threw it out. Jack defends herself by explaining the doll ‘was poison’. Rachel argues back that ‘she was my friend’ to which Jack responds that the doll is mere ‘merchandise’. Jack obviously identifies that the image created by Ashley is a kind of facade and the doll sells a false and unreal relationship to young girls. However, Rachel defends the doll by telling Jack ‘she knows me better than you do’ and that Jack stopped communicating with her after their mother died. Rachel reveals how the lack of communication within the family lead her to feel that the doll was the only thing she was able to talk to. It also points to another connection to the episode “Smithereens” as Hayley believes that her daughter&#39;s Persona account will know more about her deceased daughter than she does. Both episodes reveal the myriad of ways that our phones and social media accounts hold more information than we can imagine. However, the information stored by her Ashley Too is only hinted at, and the consequence of this wealth of information stored by the doll is never explored fully.</p><p>The next scene moves back to Catherine and Ashley who are enjoying a takeaway dinner. Catherine begins a heart to heart with Ashley about her dissatisfaction with her portrayed persona and her music. Catherine then reveals that she has been spying on her and has her diary and her pill stash. She also reminds Ashley that she is bound to a contract until she is 25, to which Ashley retorts that she now has evidence of the prescribed illegal medication which puts Catherine in breach of her contract. After a heated argument, Catherine reveals that she has powdered the stash of pills and put it in Ashley’s food to induce a chemical coma, and Ashley drops to the floor as Catherine assures her that her career will not end here. The news breaks of her coma, and it is hinted that the Ashley Too dolls are malfunctioning. Jack gives a heartbroken Rachel her doll back, who continues not speaking to Jack.</p><p>The scene then moves to Ashley in the hospital with Catherine and Dr Munk.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6ZG9eEMv8D98TbrfZOW1mg.png" /></figure><p>They reveal their intention to collect at least ’10 songs’ and ‘finesse her replacement’ before beginning a body scan. We move forward in time and Rachel’s Ashley Too doll wakes up to hear and record the news update on the real Ashley’s coma, said to be induced by a shellfish allergy. It is revealed that Catherine and her team are recording music that Ashley continues to dream and are able to record Ashley singing them from the voice recordings they used for the Ashley Too dolls. Rachel’s doll begins to malfunction and she and Jack hook the doll up to their father’s tech lab that he uses for his pest control business. They see a red dot on a brain scan of the doll and decide to delete it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jh6Utg2JKTWdJWLr6yS-PQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The doll wakes up and reveals itself as the mind of the real Ashley O, explaining that ‘they copied my entire f*cking mind into these things’. Ashley explains what really happened to her and thus begins the wacky, Disney-esque adventure to save Ashley. After a comedic triumph over the security guards, Jack and Rachel manage to wake Ashley up from her coma and drive her to a conference that Catherine is at. Meanwhile, Catherine is revealing a hologram Ashley who will perform the songs mined from the real Ashley’s mind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WTZJRZlvzgGOTsZvCA7zNA.png" /></figure><p>This insidious twist calls on both the exploitation of artists as it presents Catherine as mining Ashley’s body and mind for her own profit, but also audience complicity with exploitation. Ashley actually references how her fans don’t really care about her, they won&#39;t actually help her, they just demand the Ashley O persona for their own consumption. Here, it doesn’t matter that it isn’t the real Ashley, that Ashley didn’t even really record the songs that the hologram is singing. The audience demands to consume images of celebrity, and the industry allows this to happen, no matter how damaging it might be for the artist. However, just before any meaningful commentary on this issue, Ashley crashes the scene to stop this from happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XKmqzDWW0hfNyH7P0x-oWA.png" /></figure><p>The end of the episode sees the downfall of Catherine, and Ashley onstage with Jack producing rock music together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QCeYeZTi6L8-QJ3HvI-0Wg.png" /></figure><p>In this end, good prevails and the ending sees Rachel attending the concert supporting Jack and Ashley, while the now sentient doll is allowed to live with them in harmony.</p><p>Whilst the episode begins to make some interesting commentary on the consumption of celebrity and the profit machine that is the music industry, it falls short of taking these ideas to full fruition, preferring to create a wacky Disney adventure. The ending itself begins to consider the evolution of hologram tours and the artificial, constructed nature of celebrity persona’s, just to be cut short and disregarded. Even the consequences of having an entire human consciousness inside a robot are ignored and the bot is left to live out its days as a companion for the girls. Collider.com discusses similar concerns about the lack of attention to the issues that are raised in the episode.</p><blockquote><a href="http://collider.com/black-mirror-season-5-review/">‘Brooker and Jones have become increasingly fascinated by the prospect of how human consciousness might live on and all the terrifying possibilities that invention could provoke.</a></blockquote><blockquote><a href="http://collider.com/black-mirror-season-5-review/">That fascination led to some of the greatest episodes of the series, in ‘San Junipero’ and ‘USS Callister’, but also one of weakest in ‘Black Museum’. Unfortunately, ‘Rachel, Jack and Ashely Too’ falls into that latter category, using the familiar concept as a means for a paper-thin investigation into the exploitative nature of the music industry, teenage identity, and the fight for autonomy in the digital age. It all sounds great on paper, and ‘Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too’ occasionally taps into concepts worth meditating on, but in a very strange turn for Black Mirror, the episode uses them to propel a teen sci-fi adventure’.</a></blockquote><p>As the episode does raise some important questions, however, the whole episode should not be dismissed. Brooker states that the inspiration came from Cyrus herself as she<a href="https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/black-mirror-bosses-charlie-brooker-annabel-jones-explain-season-5-1215772"> performed for an older audience and looked out to the crowd to see a sea of faces rather than phones</a>, and the connection to the audience was powerful and resonated with her. Additionally, some of the issues raised <a href="https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/black-mirror-bosses-charlie-brooker-annabel-jones-explain-season-5-1215772">about the treatment </a>of young performers equally related with Cyrus, an ex-Disney child star herself, who rose to fame for starring in the show, <em>Hannah Montana </em>(2006–2011)<em>. </em>Whilst I am not suggesting that Cyrus was drugged as a child, it is clear that the casting choice here is intended to be considered, especially considering the fact that Ashley wears a wig when performing, as Hannah Montana did.</p><p>The idea that the audience doesn’t care, but merely wants to consume, is an interesting and true point to make in the digital age. Even the wacky ending at the rock concert makes a point, that the smaller crowd shows that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPdbsCAFxsU">Catherine was correct that Ashley’s mainstream and inauthentic image is what the people want</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cwn1cR-uOqgpF6reg-roDQ.png" /></figure><p>Compare this small crowd to the 20,000 fans at her Ashley O concert, and again, audience complicity with the creation and maintenance of fake and inauthentic personas are pressed upon the audience.</p><p>Additionally, the image of Ashley in a coma whilst still being mined for her talent and digitally replaced becomes a kind of visual metaphor for the abuses of the music industry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PZVDK31z7on3wgh7_Z2nog.png" /></figure><p>When we consider such artists as Nina Simone, Amy Winehouse and Britney Spears, all women who were taken advantage of by culture industries without regard to personal mental health issues, this image and this story encapsulate those abuses. However, the story turns into an adventure tale and no further commentary or resolution on these issues are made. Are we to believe that Ashley is now truly free? Is the Ashley Too doll allowed to live as a sentient being? Does Catherine face justice for her abuses of Ashley? Does another company take the hologram performance idea? Unfortunately, the episode falls short in answering those questions. However, the episode does argue for authentic musical personas and for audience complicity to be questioned and reflected on. In the age of the demand on celebrities to engage on social media and present themselves as perfect beings, in the age of #MeToo and the growth of technology that might enable hologram performances to become a reality (as has already been tested before) this episode does call on audiences to consider how they contribute to this culture and how their demand to consume images and personas might damage our culture.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3405c634730c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mindhunter, Manhunt: Unabomber and the Themes of the Serial Killer Profiling Drama]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/mindhunter-manhunt-unabomber-and-the-themes-of-the-serial-killer-profiling-drama-267677e09b63?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/267677e09b63</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[serial-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindhunter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[serial-killers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unabomber]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Mar 2019 18:20:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-24T11:53:13.832Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Warning <strong>SPOILERS</strong> and <strong>EXPLICIT LANGUAGE</strong> ahead!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IiYeXFAIHS6sqfJCTldIOQ.png" /><figcaption>Episode 2 Manhunt Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>I won’t be the first to point out that there has been a recent surge in true crime drama and documentaries recently added on Netflix. Within the recently added list, one can find <em>Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes</em> (2019), <em>The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann</em> (2019), <em>Dirty John</em> (2018) and the accompanying new documentary <em>Dirty John: The Dirty Truth</em> (2019), <em>Evil Genius: The True Story of America’s Most Diabolical Bank Heist</em> (2018), <em>Abducted in Plain Sight </em>(2017), and of course <em>Making a Murderer</em> (2015-present) to name a few highlights. Why true crime has had a particularly prominent moment could be explained by the <em>#MeToo </em>movement and Western culture’s need to break the silence about sexual abuse and assault. This has fueled documentaries such as <em>Surviving R. Kelly </em>(2019), which looks into the artist R. Kelly’s sex abuse allegations which have now lead to real court convictions and <em>Leaving Neverland</em> (2019), which focuses on late pop icon Michael Jackson’s child sex abuse allegations. However, our cultural obsession with true crime goes back further than the 2010s. Another reason for this recent surge also could be explained by the way that Netflix can easily monitor viewing habits and therefore create more content based on this information. Our preexisting attraction to crime narratives is probably the main reason why more narratives of this kind continue to be churned out. We can trace our cultural obsession with the crime drama back to the nineteenth century through the consumption of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_dreadful">Penny Dreadfuls</a>; E<a href="https://library.harvard.edu/collections/english-crime-and-execution-broadsides">xecution Broadsides</a>; S<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensation_novel">ensation novels</a>, including the subgenre of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newgate_novel">Newgate novels</a>; detective fiction (which has been traced back to the 1700’s) and, later in the twentieth century, puzzle novels. Our continuing interest in crime drama, especially true crime, has only fuelled producers and directors to create even more content. The way we consume media has fundamentally changed as our interests are continually personalised through online data collection. This creates such phenomena as social media echo chambers, but this logic certainly affects our streaming services. Whether or not this is creating great content or narrowing creative possibilities on one of the most popular ways to consume media is not the topic of this article, but it has been partly the inspiration for it. This article aims to analyse some of the trends that exist in the true crime sub-genre: the serial killer drama and its recent development of the profiling drama. I have chosen to mainly focus on Discovery Channel’s <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> (2017), now on Netflix, and Netflix’s own <em>Mindhunter </em>(2017). I have chosen these two texts due to their popularity and because they represent real historical crime narratives. Despite their true crime inspiration, they still share themes and plot points with fictional serial killer narratives. I aim to investigate these prevailing themes to understand this cultural obsession with true crime in general by investigating the serial killer profiling narrative in particular.</p><p>Whilst at first these narratives appear fresh additions to a long tradition of serial killer narratives, they actually retain long used themes. <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> traces the development of forensic linguistics within the FBI to catch the Unabomber, an anonymous killer who sent bombs through the U.S mail service and evaded capture for seventeen years. Set in the 1990s, the plot focuses on Jim Fitzgerald, known as Fitz, a new FBI profiler who develops his own methods to catch Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber. We also learn insights about Ted, his history and his motives. The series invites the viewer to develop empathy and understanding for Ted, can be met with both critical acclaim and disturbance as Ted killed three and seriously injured twenty-three innocent people. The series juxtaposes an episode dedicated to Ted’s tragic history and his desire for human companionship with an episode covering his trial where we meet the victim&#39;s families and the victims themselves who have experienced excruciating pain and have sustained life long injuries. The series itself creates a moral riddle as we understand Ted as a human, but repulse him as a murderer.</p><p><em>Mindhunter</em> also follows the real historical developments within the FBI during the 1970s. This series focuses predominantly on Holden Ford, a young agent with aspirations to develop the Behavioural Sciences Unit by incorporating the new research developed by psychologists of the time. Bill Tench of the Behavioural Sciences Unit sees the merit in his ideas and recruits him, but it is not long before Holden has more controversial ideas about how to study the psychology of violent criminals. Holden argues that to understand the behaviour of these individuals, the FBI needs to interview violent criminals and understand their thoughts, their feelings, their family history, and create a psychological profile which can be used in future cases, leading to faster capture of violent criminals. At first, Holden is met only with resistance, until Tench eventually gives in and joins Holden in an interview with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edmund_Kemper">Edmund Kemper</a>, a serial killer already behind bars. Tench realises that, once again, Holden is right and both manage to establish this project as a legitimate study that will revolutionise criminal psychology, even developing the phrase ‘serial killer’ as we understand it today.</p><p>The focus on historical developments within the FBI is an interesting take on the serial killer narrative, as it shifts the focus away from the actual murders and towards the psychology of the criminal. It has signalled the development of the profiling drama, the action taking place within the FBI rather than with the killer. Consider films such as <em>Psycho </em>(1960), <em>Se7en</em> (1995), <em>American Psycho </em>(2000), <em>Monster</em> (2004), or generally any mainstream film about a serial killer. The film may show the chase to catch the killer, try to explain why the killer is a killer, make an account of the shocking nature of the mind of a killer, or a combination of the above. However, the kind of genealogical narrative about the developments within the FBI and criminal psychology is generally quite new. We see a few precursors in films such as <em>Silence of the Lambs</em> (1991) and <em>Zodiac </em>(2007), both famous examples of the serial killer narrative. <em>Silence of the Lambs</em> is just as much about the profiler, Clarice Sterling, then it is about the killer she is hunting. <em>Zodiac</em>, too, is more about the historical processes of trying to find the ‘Zodiac killer’ than the killer himself, probably <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zodiac_Killer">because he never was caught</a>. However, because of their length, it is not possible to base so much of the narrative on the processes of criminal psychology, but we do witness Clarice interviewing the cannibal killer, Hannibal Lector; a plot point based off of the interviews the FBI was conducting at that time with real serial killers, now represented in <em>Mindhunter</em>.</p><p>Becca Rothfeld, in <em>Murder on the Installment Plan</em> (2018), published in the Hedgehog Review, points out this new trend in the serial killer drama, or the profiling drama, that</p><p>‘we know who did it, but the mystery of motive remains. It recurs in the spate of serial killer dramas that have proliferated in recent years, multiplying as fast as the gruesome murders we watch raptly each week’.</p><p>Rothfeld examines the reasons <em>why </em>we ‘watch raptly each week’, and traces the origin of the mystery novel back to the 19th century and Edgar Allan Poe. This developed into puzzle and mystery novels of the 1920s and 30s, which had a ‘fixed template’ for easy ‘reproduction’. Rothfeld links this to the serial television drama to argue that we enjoy the predictability of these series. However, Rothfeld points out that it is</p><p>‘wrong to assume that we relish the domestic comforts of our certainty. For if we enjoyed the predictability that attends repetition, why would we let anything end? Why wouldn’t we serialize indefinitely? Why aren’t we still repeating the very first story’?</p><p>She argues that whilst we enjoy the repeated puzzle narrative, we have reached a stage where we crave puzzles that cannot be solved. The unsolvable puzzle can then be reproduced, creating a new template of predictability to enjoy. This is the birth of the mystery of motive. We have serial killer dramas that investigate not so much who, but <strong>why</strong>. And whilst the why that is investigated comes up with some great answers, we can never truly know why serial killers do what they do.</p><p>This is what is at the centre of these two narratives: the search for a motive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Cb6f5fadnXzwJ4-Mu25FAw.png" /></figure><p>Holden’s mission in life is to get to the motive of all those who kill seemingly without motive. When he interviews serial killers, he wants to know <strong>why</strong>. When he assists with active cases, he starts from the <strong>why</strong> and quickly finds the <em>who</em>. The <em>who</em> is never the driver of the plot, it is always the <strong>why</strong>. Fitz, on the other hand, seems only interested in Ted’s motive rather than the motive of murderers in general, but it is a motive centred plot none the less. Ted requires a little less digging than some of the killers in <em>Mindhunter</em> because the Unabomber publishes a manifesto explaining his motive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*anBn5EG1cAO5VAWQ-bgeWg.png" /><figcaption>From Episode One of Manhunt: Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>In a voiceover throughout certain episodes, we hear the Unabomber read out segments of his manifesto. He blames industrial society, or technology, for the enslavement of mankind, for poverty, pollution and war. His manifesto is not the ravings of a mad man, it is a well argued and, by all means, correct analysis of contemporary society. The manifesto is written in a PhD dissertation style, we learn he has an IQ of 160 and attended Harvard University at sixteen. Fitz has to convince his bosses that their previous profile of the Unabomber, that he is a jaded, uneducated ex-pilot, is wrong and that they have a mastermind on their hands. Fitz uses linguistic analysis to create a new profile, but his developments are met with much backlash.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NNmupZslSiXqBW4aF_UChw.png" /><figcaption>Episode 3 Manhunt: Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>Fitz appears as an equal mastermind to the Unabomber. He puts his career on the line because he knows he is right. The viewer, with the benefit of hindsight — we know Kaczynski is in jail both in real life and through flash-forwards in the series — know that Fitz is right.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OMqyrzse_7lKEBrj_GrmiA.png" /><figcaption>Episode 3 Manhunt: Unabomber — Fitz explaining his need to save the Unabomber case</figcaption></figure><p>Fitz manages, often single-handedly, to solve mysteries and, through sheer determination, gains the respect of his superiors. A similar narrative appears in <em>Mindhunter</em>. Holden’s idea of interviewing violent criminals to create a psychological profile is met with much hesitation by his boss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VmIY-adJjOuhMgO1-HEr-w.png" /><figcaption>Episode 2 Mindhunter</figcaption></figure><p>Holden’s ideas are adopted much faster than Fitz’ due to his experienced partner, Tench. Tench acts as the straight-talking side-kick, a Watson to Holden as Sherlock Holmes. Whilst Holden is young and eager to experiment with his new ideas, he needs an older guide who can help with communication.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l3oL6Hd5TpJmrY5Meq0BmQ.png" /><figcaption>Episode 2 Mindhunter</figcaption></figure><p>Both protagonists, Fitz and Holden, are met with resistance by authority figures who do not want to give up their traditional methods of operation. Especially as these methods involve academic studies of psychology and linguistics, viewed by old timers of the FBI as, in their words;</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qcs5VYZPyhHE54mqTv-eLA.png" /></figure><p>The protagonists have to push against old prejudices to get their ideas heard. This is the first theme that the serial killer narrative uses time and time again: the lone genius. Scott McLemee compares the on-screen Fitz to the real-life James Fitgerald, commenting that:</p><p><a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2017/09/20/essay-manhunt-unabomber">‘The makers stress the role of one investigator, James R. Fitzgerald, whose linguistic analysis of the Unabomber’s writings helped identify Kaczynski as the author. A more ambitious telling of the story would present it from a number of points of view. But the tendency to idealize a single heroic figure is probably coded into our cultural DNA, hence not surprising’.</a></p><p>Later in this article, McLemee points out that the tension between Fitz and the FBI staff that is presented in the plot was non-existent in real life. In the real case, the team were supportive and interested in Fitzgerald’s research. Fitzgerald has also <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2017/09/20/essay-manhunt-unabomber">‘acknowledge[d] that the first forensic-linguistic analysis of the Unabomber’s prose was conducted by Roger Shuy, a professor of linguistics he consulted at Georgetown University, where Fitzgerald later wrote a master’s thesis on language and gender differences’.</a> Whilst the fidelity of the text is not on trial here, what is interesting is that the creators of <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> have chosen to highlight Fitz as a lone genius who has invented a new profiling method. The same theme prevails in <em>Mindhunter</em> as Holden is highlighted as having the idea of interviewing criminals and being the inventor of using psychology to create a profile. <em>Mindhunter</em> is based on the non-fiction book, <em>Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit </em>(1996) by John Douglas and Mark Olshaker which describes the development of criminal profiling. Douglas did not invent the concept of psychological profiling however:</p><p><a href="https://www.radiotimes.com/news/2017-10-13/mindhunter-netflix-true-story/">‘Psychiatrist James Brussel is credited with the first successful use of criminal profiling, after he aided police officers in the capture of the “Mad Bomber”, who was responsible for three explosions in New York the 1940s and 50s’</a>.</p><p>Douglas and partner, Howard Teten, developed Brussel’s ideas to create a profiling method which is used to catch violent criminals. Again, what is interesting is that these on-screen narratives have hyped up the figure of the lone genius hero when we compare Fitz and Holden to their real-life inspirations. Even in real-life cases, although these historical developments were often group efforts, usually figures such as Douglas and Fitzgerald are held above the rest as the true lone genius pioneer. Both figures are depicted in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4dFgk8C2CU">documentaries</a> and articles as a lone genius. In one article by the <em>Telegraph</em>, Douglas is named the <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/on-demand/0/real-mindhunter-inside-head-fbi-serial-killer-whisperer-john/">‘serial killer whisperer’</a> whilst another article names Fitzgerald the <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/on-demand/0/truth-manhunt-unabomber-meet-fbi-linguist-caughtted-kaczynski/">‘mastermind’</a> of the Unabomber investigation, even though Fitzgerald himself states that <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/on-demand/0/truth-manhunt-unabomber-meet-fbi-linguist-caughtted-kaczynski/">‘the person on TV didn’t do everything I did in real life. I didn’t do everything the character did’.</a> The intention of this article is not to downplay the role that Douglas and Fitzgerald played within criminal psychology, and there is no denying that without their developments in this field, our ability to understand and catch violent criminals would be drastically altered. I am also not suggesting these men are not intelligent and dedicated people. However, this article does aim to point out our cultural need for lone superheroes. Think of any classic superhero, from Superman to Batman, and then consider our modern heroic figures, such as BBC’s <em>Luther</em> (2010-present), who fits perfectly into this analysis of the lone hero. Consider Jason Bourne, James Bond, Indiana Jones, Sherlock Holmes, Rick Deckard from <em>Blade Runner </em>(1982), or even Dexter Morgan from <em>Dexter </em>(2006–2013). Whilst some may have their sidekicks, there is always only one lone hero or genius. I would argue that Fitz and Holden both exemplify this cultural demand for the lone genius.</p><p>The lone genius figure <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2017/09/20/essay-manhunt-unabomber">‘also tap[s] into a reliable vein of pop-culture tropes about profiling — seeing it as not just a combination of deductive and inductive analysis but evidence of some kind of deep psychic connection between investigator and (usually) serial killer’.</a></p><p>This ‘psychic connection’ is another major theme that prevails throughout <em>Mindhunter</em> and <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em>, a theme which dates back to Clarice and Hannibal Lector in <em>Silence of the Lambs</em>, a film which consolidated the status of the serial killer as ‘downright mystical’ [Toronto Star, December 5, 1998, Saturday Second Edition]. In fact, consider the figure of Sherlock Holmes. His portrayal throughout the years has varied from Robert Downey Jr’s action hero to Benedict Cumberbatch’s antisocial, loveable narcissist. However, the almost-mind reading genius Sherlock is a figure which has prevailed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/693/1*QPy082xaImpTpzpAbv5fwA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Promotional image of BBC’s Sherlock — Sherlock’s ‘mind-palace’</figcaption></figure><p>I would argue that this Sherlock figure has been reconfigured and repackaged, with figures such as Will Graham in any rendition of Hannibal Lector narratives such as <em>Red Dragon</em> (2002) or the stylish television series <em>Hannibal</em> (2013–2015).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*16I5686xnvmCpE8HP9Tf9g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Promotional image of Hannibal and Will Graham in the 2013–2015 TV series</figcaption></figure><p>Will Graham, in both of the above versions, has the ability to see through the killer’s eyes in a borderline psychic fashion. The Graham in <em>Hannibal</em> has to view the crime scene alone and slip into the mind of the killer, acting out the murder in his mind and stating ‘this is my design’. Graham’s ability, however, takes its toll, and he slowly begins to dissociate and lose his grip on reality. Like Sherlock, Graham’s ability is suggested to be the result of some ability to access greater parts of his brain, or as a psychic ability. Fitz equally has some kind of psychic ability to understand Ted’s mind through the words Ted writes. In episode five, Fitz states quite clearly that ‘I know him like I know myself’ and expresses his admiration for Ted because ‘he has the courage to live by his ideals. I respect that’. Holden is equally able to get into the minds of criminals through this kind of empathy similar to Graham and in the psychic fashion of Sherlock. Holden is able to create a dialogue with various criminals by reflecting their own beliefs back to them, exemplified best in episode nine when Holden asks misogynistic rapist and murderer <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Speck">Richard Speck</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k4MDq7uosZ0cANMuUtfrXg.png" /></figure><p>No matter who the killer is, Holden extracts information out of them with slick ease which baffles Tench and all those around him. This ability to get into the minds of these murderers is shown through the slipping boundaries between the hero and the villain. Holden and the murderers he interviews are just two sides of one coin, and Fitz is the mirror image of Ted.</p><p>This mirror image theme is connected to the theme of the psychic profiler. The profiler can only become the psychic profiler if he is connected to the killer. In the BBC rendition of <em>Sherlock </em>(2010–2017), one of the main villains of the series is Sherlock’s own brother. Graham and Hannibal’s relationship is that of two friends, whilst Hannibal also becomes Graham’s therapist. This is obviously borrowed from the infamous <em>Silence of the Lambs</em>, where Hannibal becomes, in some ways, Clarice’s therapist. However, in the television version, Hannibal is able to influence Graham into his own doubt about whether or not he might be guilty of murder. Hannibal is able to transform the hero into a possible villain, into Hannibal himself. In <em>Luther</em>, Alice, the villain who turns into a kind of anti-hero is both sidekick and flirtatious lover to the hero John Luther. In episode two of season two, Luther even quotes Alice that black holes are ‘evil at its most pure’, a quote from Alice in season one. Alice becomes Luther’s anarchist version of himself, an extreme extension on his own value system which the means are justified by the ends — a similar theme found in the Batman. This theme is used heavily in <em>Mindhunter</em> and <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em>.</p><p>The first episode of <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> opens on a tranquil scene in the middle of a forest. We meet Fitz in this flashforward after Ted has been arrested.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dApDyU5BtpKstlycWrhaDg.png" /></figure><p>Fitz is living in a cabin in the woods and is dragged back by the FBI to help get Ted to plead guilty at his trial.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3HDkdcbTLxlrhw121RDRQA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UCr6IS3gWTzQjdw4FsmxcA.png" /><figcaption>Episode 1 Manhunt Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>We already know Ted has been caught and, already, the series establishes that this will be a narrative about psychology and the mystery of motive. It is also suggested at this stage that Ted and Fitz have some kind of a psychic connection, that they understand each other in a way that no one else can. Fitz can ‘speak his language’ and ‘connect’ with him. Fitz also embodies a physical mirror image to Ted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X4ep-L3o1pMnCwzPa-8_-Q.png" /></figure><p>Both live in the woods, eat what they hunt and facially resemble each other. Fitz has been so affected by this case that he has become Ted and, from episode one, the series establishes that this story will be about Fitz’ transformation from clean-shaven family man to this bearded loner in the woods.</p><p>Firstly, the most obvious connection which is established is that Fitz constantly agrees with Ted’s arguments detailed in his manifesto.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0jyBVFdYABPn408Jwb5NOQ.png" /><figcaption>Episode 2 Manhunt Unabomber</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uRCIYoL0qi4NNa5NZgoBnA.png" /><figcaption>Episode 2 Manhunt Unabomber- FC is Ted’s pen name</figcaption></figure><p>In episode two, Fitz is openly empathetic to Ted’s ideas. Here, he rejects obedience and even references Ted as a defence. Fitz, in a flashforward in episode two, speaks with Ted and explains that driving a car was the moment he realised the truth in Ted’s manifesto. He explains that when he was driving home one night, he was alone on the roads but still stopped at a red light.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XS-W5O8nU9O9ukR-bxkx2A.png" /></figure><p>He states that he felt his freedom was being sucked out of him. In the final episode, Fitz returns to the theme of obedience and the image of the red light whilst speaking with Ted:</p><p>‘I know you’re not insane. Every time I stop at a red light or I follow the arrows in IKEA or I sit and I wait and listen for the modem to dial up, I can see the systems that control our lives, and I feel my freedom being hemmed in, and I hate it. What you have to say about the world, it matters to the future’.</p><p>Through revelations such as these, we see the transformation of Fitz and the mirror imaging being formed. The viewer themselves are intended to question the validity of Ted’s arguments and presents us with <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2017/09/20/essay-manhunt-unabomber">‘a variant of the more familiar question of whether he should be understood as evil or sick’</a>; we are asked if we sympathise with this villain as Fitz does.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TCjkwWjhDDdqxJFRyTtONg.png" /></figure><p>The ending image of the series is a glaring red light, a symbol of societal obedience. The red light stares at us, questioning us. Are we, like Fitz, a mirror image of Ted too? In episode six, after the manifesto has publicly been published, <em>The Times</em> writes that ‘there’s a little bit of the Unabomber in most of us’.</p><p>Another parallel between Fitz and Ted is that of their family connections. Fitz begins his journey with a family. As he becomes more deeply immersed in the Unabomber case, he loses that family. By the end, we know Fitz lives alone in a cabin in the woods. On the other side of that coin, Ted has no family. We learn that his lack of family is his greatest regret in life, through episode six.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZXwq5ro7yfZ-Tl9EpyE16g.png" /></figure><p>Ted longs for human connection and fantasies about a family that he never had. We see him struggle to make friendships with people and how he feels he is not good enough for those around him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9E0eXf2FD-4P-tz7rZTMEA.png" /><figcaption>Episode 6 Manhunt Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>Ted has befriended a single mother and her child, and we watch as Ted helps with homework and gives out long-needed fatherly advice. He is invited to a birthday party and makes a handcrafted gift. However, when he arrives at the party he sees all the people and the gifts and he instantly feels isolated and not worthy of their companionship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yyolkEcHyNswb_de2niOWA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1xMMrBx1EgBWR3TGoEhwsg.png" /></figure><p>Just as Ted looks through the window, isolated, Ted casts himself from society due to his loneliness and his inability to establish meaningful connections. This is then directly mirrored with Fitz in the next episode where he too leaves a party. He sees on television that his methods were being claimed as his bosses idea and leaves the celebration because of his feeling of unappreciation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z2bsfrVe1oqOWRpHLSLvLQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GZUbqHoBcHTDMoIKk64a2g.png" /><figcaption>Episode 7 Manhunt Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>After this scene, Fitz takes to the woods and to his own company, isolated from humanity just like Ted. Fitz becomes just as emotionally cut off as Ted, he rejects the advances of a woman not because of his wife but because of his own lack of emotion, and he loses his children because of this psychic affiliation with Ted. Both become as isolated as the other.</p><p>The final connection between them that we can identify is that both have a need to be right. Fitz constantly battles against his bosses because of his own conviction that he is right. Equally, Ted believes he is right.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q9xVRvHOlf2Uzis8SwQt3A.png" /><figcaption>From Episode 2 of Manhunt: Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>Ted is convinced that his argument that technology and modern living is enslaving humanity is correct, so much so that the law must prove that he is insane to hold this belief which in turns proves that we, the majority, are correct. This need to be right drives the two of them. It even puts them in competition with each other. During the final episode, Fitz is able to convince Ted to admit his guilt. Ted believes he will win when he attempts to discredit Fitz’ warrant. However, Ted loses this case. Ted loses when Fitz is right. Fitz explains how Ted has ‘already lost’ and will be made to look insane to the jury:</p><p>‘but before those experts come in, the whole world is gonna hear the diagnosis a million times on the TV, in the newspapers, from David, from your own mother. So, the trial is just gonna be a foregone conclusion’.</p><p>Fitz threatens that Ted</p><p>‘will be corrected […] will be normal. And you will re-join society. You’ll get a credit card, an apartment, business casual wardrobe, you know, some of those tops with the penguins on them. And you’ll get a job behind a desk where you’ll work obediently 9–5, and your first paycheck, you get a cellphone. Next one, you get a TV. You know, if you splurge, you can get yourself a Nintendo. And every night, you fall asleep watching that TV. And every weekend you’re gonna go to the mall. You’re gonna walk around Circuit City. You’re gonna look at the big-screen TVs and think, “should I get myself a 20-incher?” […] You won’t even remember that you wanted anything more than this’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GYY9viVu8w6DtqE4kHztEg.png" /></figure><p>Fitz threatens Ted whilst circling him around the cabin in a dizzying way whilst Ted holds his cabin, grasping on to his old life as it slips away. This argument is key to beating Ted as his integrity is all he has left. This scene also illustrates that Fitz empathises with Ted’s critiques of modern society and disagrees with modern living. It shows their connection and their need to win over the other. When Ted loses, the viewer is invited to feel bad for him. Fitz clearly doesn’t seem to feel satisfied, and both characters remain isolated and alone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6b2EQ2oXH7rRyzCKI0-AMQ.png" /><figcaption>Episode 8 Manhunt Unabomber- Ted being taken to prison as Fitz looks on</figcaption></figure><p>The three main points that arise in this series are the representation of Fitz as the lone genius who invented forensic linguistics, Fitz being connected to Ted by some psychic force which affects him so profoundly that he comes to embody Ted, and whether or not the audience can sympathise with a murderer. The series chooses to highlight Fitz as the lone genius hero fighting against bureaucracy to get his creative ideas heard. The series chooses to represent Fitz and Ted as two sides of the same coin. The series chooses to represent Ted as a sympathetic character.<strong> </strong>Fitz is represented as a traditional hero. He is a minority within an institution who wants to make the world a better place. His belief systems are grounded in a conventional moral code but it is his extreme sympathy to the killer and his paralleling personality with Ted eclipses the difference between good self and evil other. The series ends conventionally, the bad guy behind bars and the good guy triumphing, but that red light exists as a twist on that conventional end. We are Fitz, all questioning our world around us. Ted exists as the unsolvable puzzle that Western culture is addicted to trying to solve. This series offers a psychological history of Ted to explain his behaviour, but we never truly can know the mind of a murderer.</p><p>If we compare this to <em>Mindhunter</em>, both series use the same themes of the profiling drama. The series similarly represents Holden as the lone genius who invents criminal profiling, has the ability to connect with the criminals and comes to embody aspects of these criminals. First, as mentioned before, Holden is represented as a young genius fighting against old ideas. The unorthodox hero fighting against the system is a classic theme in the crime drama. <em>Mindhunter </em>is no different. Episode one, as mentioned previously, displays how the FBI is reluctant to discourse with academia. When Holden manages to convince the FBI to fund him to attend lectures in psychology at a university, he experiences resistance from the academic world who do not want to converse with the FBI. Holden’s girlfriend Debbie points out the resistance is ‘mutual’. This nicely establishes Holden as a traditional hero going against authority figures to try to do good. Holden is established as having groundbreaking ideas and he himself obtains the idea to interview violent criminals. Only after sharing this idea with others such as Shephard, his boss, Tench and Dr Wendy Carr, the consultant psychologist, does the gravity of this idea come to terms with Holden. When Holden is proved right, gets funding and recognition, this fuels the beginning of Holden&#39;s self-centred narcissism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M0YIbUJuNVTLP_FUXxNUVg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GqvaDKLujgXnFTuiuRye6A.png" /></figure><p>Holden, the more he delves into the psychology of psychopaths, the more he becomes one himself. He develops a grandiose sense of self-importance, begins to mimic the killers that he interviews in both speech and the treatment of his girlfriend and develops questionable relationships with such criminals. The series achieves this representation through mirroring Holden with the serial killers he interviews in a similar way to Fitz and Ted. Holden develops empathy with the misogynistic views that the killers hold, he feels he is above authority figures and the law, and the series juxtaposes Holden’s personal life with the crimes he investigates to create this mirror image.</p><p>First of all, Holden is often a misogynist, just like the serial killers he interviews. For instance, in episode three we meet Dr Wendy Carr and initially, Holden assumes this person must be a man as we notice his surprise upon meeting her. He later comments that there is something sexual about Carr, which is met with some derision from Tench. Holden is often insecure about his girlfriend, Debbie, and also feels the need to control her. When Holden meets Debbie for the first time, he comments on her humour that she is ‘hard work’ and asks her to ‘please stop? You’re relentless’. He also comments that he has ‘been warned to watch out for women like you’ and his naivety and subsequent insecurity about women is displayed in this show as a prominent plot point as this behaviour toward Debbie escalates continually. In episode four, Debbie is not able to drive across the country to pick him and Tench up and he asks ‘why am I so upset?’ to which Tench responds ‘maybe because she can’t drop everything when you call’. Holden disregards this and comments ‘because she doesn’t want to’. His insecurity and need for dominance begin to mirror those of the murderers they study, such as in episode five there are parallels between the local case they are studying in Pennsylvania and Holden’s personal life. During discussions about a boyfriend feeling impotent with a more sexually experienced girlfriend, causing rape and murder, Holden then goes home to Debbie and has a paranoid argument about how many people she’s slept with. During episode eight, Holden rubs Debbie’s feet after investigating a child foot tickler, again, paralleling the cases he investigates and his own behaviour.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FAazvkpsWLKiNZeHCiN9JA.png" /></figure><p>Later in the conversation, he once again asserts his dominance by saying ‘if you need a ride home from school again, call me’ after being jealous of one of Debbie’s classmates driving her home. He reveals that, like the killers, he himself has a compulsion to dominate Debbie. In episode ten, Holden is praising himself for using his profiling techniques to catch a child rapist and murderer and Debbie points out that the interrogation was unfair as they presupposed his guilt. Debbie states that Holden ‘gets off’ on catching murderers causing Holden to get defensive. Debbie points out that when she doesn’t agree with him, he ignores her point of view to which Holden says ‘could you just be my girlfriend. Could you just listen’ to which Debbie dryly responds ‘you mean, shut up and adore you’? Holden lashes back with ‘well, you could try it. Once’. Whilst we can put these comments down to him arguing with his girlfriend and his inexperience with women, we see this continual dismissal of Debbie’s thoughts and opinions, the narrative paralleling between his personal life and his case studies, and his increased misogynistic language use go hand in hand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZVUwlYgWO3afaWHKZY3VbA.png" /><figcaption>Holden giving Tench a hard time for sitting out of an interview with a serial killer- Holden showing his need to prove his masculinity to such a man</figcaption></figure><p>Holden has no problem getting into the mind of misogynistic killers and it begins to affect him. In episode three, Holden states he doesn’t want these criminals to ‘rub off’ on him, but despite stating this worry, they do. The episode with Speck, where he asks him what gave him the ‘right’ to take ‘eight ripe c*nts out of this world’ is a poignant moment of the series where we no longer know if Holden is doing this for the benefit of the research, if he really means it or both.</p><p>This is the second major point of this series: the uncomfortably thin boundary between Holden personality and those he interviews. Whilst Tench struggles to get into the mind of the killers, Holden enjoys his ability to understand and empathise with murderers. Tench experiences a kind of breakdown in front of his wife due to the immense pressure from work and his home life. Carr consoles him and suggests therapy whilst Tench points to Holden remarking ‘he’s f*cking immune. How do I tap into that?’ Holden’s psychic connection to the killers, however beneficial to their research, turns Holden into a mirror image of one. In episode seven, Holden tells <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Brudos">Jerry Brudos</a>, a serial killer, a personal story to get him comfortable talking to them. After, Tench asks whether Holden was telling the truth, and he replies that it was a true story. Holden seems completely unfazed at telling Brudos a personal story, to which Tench tells Holden that it bothers him. Tench says, angrily ‘if what we’re doing doesn’t get under your skin, you’re either more screwed up than I thought, or you’re kidding yourself’. This episode eloquently captures how Holden gets too close to his subjects, even though they get results. He is both a traditional hero, in that he is unorthodox but for the greater good, but still blurring the line between his own personality and those of the killers he speaks to. After an interview with Brudos where he confides in Holden and Tench that he had sexual fantasies involving shoes and dead women, Holden is depicted drawing a dead woman with her shoes off.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-omszF8wA92tUZSIAbbNtw.png" /></figure><p>In this same episode, we are even shown a scene where he and Debbie are out buying shoes, establishing that link between Holden and the killers. Later, in episode ten, we discover Kemper sends Holden cards which Holden tapes to the wall.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yyHpzKed4cbnGJbRwDqcPQ.png" /></figure><p>Tench points out that if the Office of Professional Responsibility sees this display it looks extremely inappropriate, to which Holden responds ‘f*ck em’. Holden enjoys the attention of Kemper and values their connection. In another episode, Holden walks this line between personal belief and connecting with the killer very narrowly during an interrogation with a murder and rape suspect. He even quotes Edmund Kemper to the interrogated suspect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*733eOmjM14oUz2TEgk0oWQ.png" /><figcaption>Compare this line from episode 2…</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-YInbjgStQem3_GmM5hjdg.png" /><figcaption>… With this line from episode 10</figcaption></figure><p>Holden uses this quote against another suspect who may hold misogynistic belief systems similar to Kemper. However, Holden uses insulting terms like ‘p*ssy’ in his personal life, which blurs the line between his own attitudes and the attitudes of the murderers he investigates. Even his boss, Shephard, reacts to Holden’s conversation with Speck with disgust at this blurred line:</p><p>‘I never again want to listen to a tape where I can’t tell the difference between my agent and some incarcerated lowlife’.</p><p>This scene is important, as Holden justifies his behaviour as:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xPd8gCuV2nwbMCrkJvKTsg.png" /></figure><p>Holden, however, seems to enjoy getting ‘in the dirt with the pigs’, and his colleagues are uncomfortable with how close Holden is to his subjects. Carr responds that Holden is just impatient and was barely in the room ‘three minutes with Speck before you got him going with the c*nt speak’. Holden then defends his approach by referencing the murders that have been solved using their research when Wendy points out that their research is based on background information ‘not priceless gems you seem to think you’re mining’. Whilst Holden believes he is this lone genius and that he has done nothing wrong, the rest of his research group is left uncomfortable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fO4eo3DqyE8jaPwt8hQHPg.png" /></figure><p>At this stage, Holden is extremely arrogant and believes he is above the law. He constantly undermines his colleagues, suggesting that, when their interviews end up in a newspaper, Holden believes Tench can only be angry because he isn’t mentioned in the article. This article is directly Holden’s fault after he drunkenly brags to local police officers. At a disciplinary hearing concerning the interview with Speck, Holden undermines his interrogators: ‘you think I don’t know what you’re doing with this principal’s office bullsh*t? This is what I do with violent offenders, only much better’. Then he walks out, believing ‘the only mistake I made was ever doubting myself’. Just as Holden seems to have hit an all-time high for his narcissistic behaviour, the final episode ends with a reality check. Holden visits Kemper in hospital after he attempts suicide to get Holden’s attention. Holden states that he and Kemper are friends in the context of ‘their work together’ and Kemper retells his murderous motivations to Holden, stating the women he killed are his ‘spirit wives’ and that the could easily kill Holden so that he too could be with him ‘in spirit’. Kemper then asks Holden about his motivations:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mfVCfJJ7EW_6MxJdJ3axEQ.png" /><figcaption>Episode 10 Mindhunter</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CRMI7jeAciYQhGYseHUyuw.png" /><figcaption>Episode 10 Mindhunter</figcaption></figure><p>The suspense of the scene reaches its height when Kemper hugs Holden, and Holden breaks free and sprints for freedom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-oOU17w-nQycNvbYDsT8BQ.png" /></figure><p>Holden collapses and in voiceovers recalls all the warnings he has received from Tench and his colleagues about his behaviour. The disorientating sequence ends with Kemper asking Holden if they are friends. The physical closeness of Kemper, even being able to call him a friend, caused a mental breakdown of sorts for Holden. He became too close to his subject, and it is suggested that in the next season, Holden will need to distance himself emotionally from his subjects. In some ways, this is similar to Fitz coming to embody Ted. Whilst it is unclear whether we can consider Fitz’ moving to the woods and leaving his family as a breakdown, it certainly balances on the line between a breakdown and breaking free of societal constraints, the latter still being influenced by Ted. Both Holden and Fitz experience the dangers of being the lone genius able to tap into a psychic connection with their respective murderer subjects, and, as a consequence, begin to become their mirror image.</p><p>The tropes of the lone genius, the psychic profiler and the mirror image are dominant themes we can see throughout the crime drama genre. Like the puzzle novels of the 1920s and 30s, there is an existing template that can be used over and over to create a reliable structure that will interest fans of the crime genre. The mystery of the motive drives these narratives, <strong>why</strong> does Ted choose to disseminate his arguments by bombing people, <strong>why</strong> do serial killers enjoy killing, and other questions such as: are these people sick or made, and is there a clear boundary between good and evil. There is an interesting sub-plot in <em>Mindhunter</em> which acts as a parallel between Tench’s adopted son who can’t speak and the question of whether criminals are born or developed into one. Tench’s wife questions whether the child was ‘like this before’ or if she and Tench are ‘failing him somehow’. We see this question projected onto the serial killers they investigate, and <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> equally asks this question. Ted, arguably, was made a killer through the abuse he experienced at Harvard, shown in episode six, but he was possibly born with difficulties establishing meaningful connections to people. Holden, when discussing Charles Manson with police officers who label him as evil, argue ‘that’s a little Old Testament, don’t you think? Good, evil, black, white, it’s easy. But who in this room has a life that’s easy? Circumstances affect behaviour’. Holden argues that ‘locking him up his young life helped make him what he was’, which is met with much derision and disgust. <em>Mindhunter</em> attempts to break down that barrier between black and white by highlighting the abusive childhoods that affected the serial killers they interview, whilst <em>Manhunt: Unabomber</em> argues that Ted experienced his own fair share of abuse. This black and white boundary is equally explored through Holden and Fitz, whose personalities begin to merge with the murderous subjects they study. We are welcomed to question their morality, along with the morality of a character such as Ted.</p><p>This disintegration of moral divides is the product of postmodern scepticism about the rational need for categorisation driven by old Enlightenment ideals. Modern audiences also possess a postmodern understanding of the fluidity of human identity which is perhaps why the hero now is more similar to the villain. I recommend watching Wisecrack’s video on <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WROjphkh3NA&amp;t=3s">Why Our Villains are Different Now</a> as they eloquently describe the ways that the hero and villain are often two sides of one coin, like Ted and Fitz or Holden and his subjects, often the means of their aims being the only difference between them — whilst Fitz and Holden develop similar views to their murderous counterparts, they do not murder themselves which concretely separates the hero from the villain. Thus, this postmodernist scepticism allows for the disintegration of moral boundaries, which produces shows such as <em>Mindhunter</em> and <em>Manhunt: Unabomber </em>which can explore this disintegration within the boundaries set by the prevailing themes of the genre.</p><p>These prevailing themes can be applied to other popular shows of the moment, such as <em>The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann </em>or <em>Casting JonBenet </em>(2017) as these series tap into the obsession with the unsolvable puzzle and the unsolvable <strong><em>why</em></strong>. Series like <em>Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes </em>equally tap into the need for an unsolvable puzzle and provides a mystery of motive which all we can ever do is guess and ponder at. These narratives are made for the modern audience who is well versed in the true crime drama, and these series are well aware of the knowledge the audience can bring to the text. In this way, they are self-referential and recall themes and plots from other true crime texts. Like the puzzle novels of the 20s and 30s, these texts have their own template which can be used to reproduce more and more crime narratives which we can never solve and can consume on repeat. To conclude, this article aims to show the prevailing themes of the profiler drama: the lone genius, the psychic profiler and the mirror image. The overall theme that these texts carry is the mystery of motive and the unsolvable puzzle. We are invited to question our own moral codes and consider the breakdown of traditional boundaries. Whilst texts such as these market themselves as fresh and new additions to a long-standing tradition of true crime narratives, but really they use the same templates and themes. This is not to say that these texts are not interesting or worth watching, they question the moral fabrics of the human psyche, but this article aims to point out that streaming platforms such as Netflix churn out these narratives and use templates that will guarantee viewership. They are connected and use the same themes and templates. Even when watching content that we enjoy, one should always question what messages they send to the viewer and what they contribute to cultural understanding.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=267677e09b63" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Donnie Darko and Russian Doll: Investigating Determinism and the Multiverse]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/donnie-darko-and-russian-doll-investigating-determinism-and-the-multiverse-ebed31195aab?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ebed31195aab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[donnie-darko]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[determinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multiverse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Feb 2019 21:45:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-16T17:55:41.731Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*VBwX4KNUwPyyuXfQmnPz5A.jpeg" /></figure><p>*SPOILERS*</p><p>Netflix’s recent release of the series <em>Russian Doll</em> (2019) has been met with much acclaim as a mind bending, (yet feminist and pro-mental health) tale of self-acceptance. The premise of the series is reminiscent of the Bill Murray classic <em>Groundhog Day</em> (1993), as the main character, Nadia, dies on the night of her 36th birthday party and wakes up back at the party. This sparks a <em>Groundhog Day</em> style loop where she continues to die and wake up whilst the people around her are none the wiser. She then meets Alan, another character stuck in his own loop where he wakes up the day that his girlfriend breaks up with him as he plans to propose to her. The series begins comical but gradually takes a darker tone as we notice fruit decaying and, in the final episodes of the series, people disappearing as their loops begin to dismantle and collapse.</p><p>This series may seem like an unlikely link to the cult classic <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donnie_Darko"><em>Donnie Darko </em>(2001)</a>, but both the series and the film, specifically, the directors cut of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donnie_Darko:_The_Director%27s_Cut"><em>Donnie Darko </em>(2004)</a> which I will be referring to, deal with some similar metaphysical concepts. There have been many essays and articles discussing the various themes and possible meanings of <em>Donnie Darko </em>which is premised around the troubled teenager, Donnie, who struggles with mental illness and feels stifled in American suburbia. He wakes up one morning in the middle of the road after sleep walking and is visited by a giant terrifying bunny called Frank who tells him the world will end in 28 days. It is up to Donnie to save this universe and the film uses a mixture of realism, science fiction and mysticism to build a kind of metaphysics using the fictional book <em>The Philosophy of Time Travel</em> by Roberta Sparrow.</p><p>Whilst there are many lenses through which to analyse both these texts, I will exclusively look at how determinism and the multiverse is represented in these texts. I will look at the similarities and differences between these representations and what lesson in metaphysics we can take away from these two texts.</p><p>Firstly, let us examine the representation of the multiverse. The multiverse is a theory in quantum physics which basically argues that there are infinite amounts of universes all branching off one another. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVvcOQk6G0Q">As Dr Stuart Clark explains</a>, the multiverse theory has been developed to understand problems in physics and astronomy that the multiverse theory would solve. Such problems are, for example,<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVvcOQk6G0Q"> ‘whenever a quantum particle changes its state there’s nothing in our laws of physics that direct it to change that state in one particular way or another. So how does it choose to do that? Well, if there’s a multiverse, then every possibility is played out, so it becomes understandable in that way’</a>. Clark also explains how astronomers look out into space and can only see so much of the universe but may never be able to see what is beyond our universe, this leads astronomers to question if there is a multiverse. String theory posits that alternative universes would obey different laws of physics which solves problems with particles that exist within our laws of physics. Quantum theory images a huge number of parallel universes which are expanding every moment. There are, generally<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ywn2Lz5zmYg">, three multiverse models</a> which have never been tested but are theorised by physicists:</p><p>First, the Bubble Universe. This theory supposes that parts of the universe are so far away we can never see them, or they are inside black holes so we can never see them. If each of these bubbles contained different laws of physics, then we could only exist in a bubble that has our laws of physics.</p><p>Secondly, Membranes and Extra Dimensions theory. This is inspired most by the fact that string theory is unable to predict the right number of dimensions for the universe we live in. String theorists had proposed that perhaps what we think of as our universe is actually a three-dimensional surface embedded within a larger super universe with 9 spatial dimensions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DIgU-wVdSIk-SsLdtt8dTQ.png" /></figure><p>Finally, the third theory which is the Many Worlds theory of quantum mechanics. As physicists do not understand how certain things in quantum mechanics happen and the many worlds theory would explain this. It argues that every possible alternate timeline for the universe is real and they all happen in an ever larger, ever branching way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WXun2uk0fpeqqI5qefXmdg.png" /></figure><p>So, back to <em>Donnie Darko</em>. Donnie discovers that the world will end in 28 days due to a glitch which has created an unstable ‘tangent universe’, and the glitch will create a black hole which will swallow up the stable ‘primary universe’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b0QoYbCzLQ3KUMac7KsC0w.png" /></figure><p>Thus, <em>Donnie Darko</em> represents a multiverse containing one essential universe, the primary universe, and other tangent universes which must collapse into the primary one at certain points. The film uses supernatural powers in order to make sense of how universes can collapse into each other, as <em>The Philosophy of Time Travel</em> articulates. The fictional author states that a Receiver will be aware of the existence of the tangent universe and is granted powers of tele-kinesis and other psychic powers to control the fate of the universe using metal and water. This film seems to borrow ideas from the Bubble Universe theory as universes are hidden in black holes which threaten our stable primary universe. However, this multiverse allows Receiver’s to be aware of and manipulate such universes and black holes, thus departing from science into mysticism. Additionally, the film’s ending suggests that in some way, certain characters are aware of the change in the universe as Gretchen, Donnie’s girlfriend from the tangent universe, and Donnie’s mother wave at each other. Additionally, we are shown several major characters have an emotional response at the time when Donnie collapses the tangent universe into the primary one. This suggests that they are aware of the change, experience a kind of déjà vu, and further departs from a scientific representation of a multiverse.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*NnqIQEszqN9DKO5Nmye8QQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Russian Doll</em> takes a different approach to the multiverse. At first, the universe is presented as a continuing loop which ends each time Nadia and Alan die. However, in episode seven, Nadia suggests that in fact they are experience a kind of multiverse glitch, or ‘bug’ as she describes it in terms of computer programming. This would suggest that herself and Alan consciously experience each branch of the Many Worlds as Nadia even states explicitly her regret that there are thousands of universes where her friends are mourning her death. Each loop begins at exactly the same time and no other character seems aware, as Nadia comes out the bathroom to be greeted by her friend with ‘sweet birthday baby!’ This indicates the beginning of the new branch and Nadia and Alan’s death allows them to consciously move into a new branch, leaving the previous universe behind to play out. This allows the viewer to understand the Many Worlds theory by showing the viewer how infinitely the branches will spread. Eventually, Nadia and Alan realise that they met the night the loops began, right before each of them died. This gives them a clue as to how to solve their glitch and explains why they both see signs of decay with each loop, such as seeing food begin to rot. Whilst Alan believes they are being punished by an Almighty Being because they didn’t help each other that fateful night, Nadia sees the problem in terms of quantum physics:</p><p>-Nadia ‘what do time and morality have in common? Relativity. […] So, our universe has three spatial dimensions, so it’s hard for us to picture a four-dimensional world. But, you know, computers do it all the time. Now lucky for you I have the capacity to think like a computer. What’s this?’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zZl8E4Olg9CQc2V8yYW3Bw.png" /></figure><p>-Alan ‘Oh. It’s a rotten orange’.</p><p>-Nadia ‘In a two-dimensional world, it’s a circle. In a three-dimensional world, it’s a sphere. But in a four-dimensional world…’</p><p>-Alan ‘It’s still ripe.’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QX1CNfdhgA-1LXjPNUwlGw.png" /></figure><p>-Nadia ‘Time is relative to your experience. We’ve been experiencing time differently in these loops. But this tells us that somewhere time, linear time, as we used to understand it, still exists’.</p><p>They realise that the moment in the deli where they first met the night that the loops began to happen ‘still exists’ and that they just need to find it. In order to do this, they both confront their pasts, Nadia’s past trauma with her mother and Alan’s doomed relationship, and they manage to make it back to that moment in the deli. In the final episode we see that both the ‘aware’ Nadia and the ‘aware’ Alan are in different universes, each with the unaware respective Alan or Nadia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kMpHOiVkJ9Ju3g_KY1NF6g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qa6DjCCYeCkGsuDu_ZSSRg.png" /></figure><p>They each save the other and manage to befriend the unaware Alan/Nadia each in a separate universe.</p><p>Both these texts represent a multiverse, be it the Bubble Universe or the Many Worlds Universe. Both texts represent at least one character who is aware of this multiverse and must fix the glitch. <em>Donnie Darko</em> represents the glitch being fixed and the universe returning to it’s one original with the Bubble Universes well out of sight and non-threatening. <em>Russian Doll</em> represents a Many Worlds Universe where the glitch is fixed but still branches off into different universes where the glitch has been fixed differently in each. Both texts place much value on the character development in order to fix the respective universe glitches whilst remaining ambiguous as to why these particular characters have been chosen by the universe in particular. In <em>Donnie Darko</em>, Donnie reveals that he feels alone and is scared of dying alone. However, he meets the new girl, Gretchen, who bonds with Donnie over her past trauma of domestic abuse and Donnie’s trauma of mental illness. He falls in love with her and, on the 28th day she tragically dies. It could be theorised that Donnie falling in love causes him to want to save the primary universe in order for Gretchen to live. He feels he is not dying alone because of his love for Gretchen, or perhaps his connection to God. There are some religious references within this text, for example, on the 27th day he leaves a movie theatre after speaking to Frank the bunny and behind him an advertised film reads:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*FKhpoizNTLg2jePbiaSCcQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>He then proceeds to burn down a paedophile’s house and flooding his school after his favourite teacher has been fired. He gives in to his ‘final temptations’. After this, Gretchen dies, as does Frank — who will become Frank the bunny who guides Donnie — and the wormhole is opened, allowing Donnie to save the universe in exchange for himself. Like Christ, Donnie is a chosen Messiah and only he can save the world. Like Christ, he must sacrifice himself for the sake of mankind.</p><p>Whilst <em>Donnie Darko</em> is more upfront about mixing science and mysticism, combining ideas of Christianity whilst referencing Stephen Hawking theories about time travel, <em>Russian Doll</em> avoids mysticism but still tells a tale of morality. <em>Russian Doll</em> could have opted for a straight tale of the multiverse theory, but the characters must develop emotionally before fixing the universe glitch. We learn that Nadia struggles with emotionally intimacy after a childhood experiencing emotional abuse from her mother. In one of the final episodes, she begins to see her childhood self which causes her to die as the universe glitches, letting in Nadia’s past.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-LHvKTUc5SljBZHQB04amA.png" /></figure><p>She has to kill her past self before she is able to fix the glitch. Similarly, we learn that Alan had attempted suicide which is how he died the first time. In an emotional scene, we watch as Alan confronts his cheating girlfriend and decides it is about time he learns to love himself. Nadia and Alan bond over this new self-acceptance whilst Nadia accepts that she needs other people in her life such as her adopted guardian and her friendship with Alan. This need to develop self-acceptance and to literally kill their inner demons suggests that, in a similar way to Donnie, one can only save the world after saving themselves. This character development allows each text to be an engaging story where the viewer can connect to the characters, as apposed to being a mere dry, inhuman science fiction film investigating different types of multiverses. The mysticism of <em>Donnie Darko</em> and the self-improvement plot of <em>Russian Doll</em> adds interesting themes and layers to each text, and both can still be applauded for their representations of multiverses, a concept hard to visualise for the average non-scientist (such as myself).</p><p>The representation of determinism in <em>Donnie Darko</em> is a major theme, whilst determinism in <em>Russian Doll</em> is far more nuanced. First, what is determinism? Determinism is a philosophical concept that concerns itself with the existence of free will. A determinist would argue that everything happens for a reason and that everyone, and the world in general, has a set path or a destiny. Determinists believe that nothing can happen in any other way than how it did. If we are thinking about multiverses, this concept becomes very interesting. If we believe that we have a free will, that we choose our actions, then we can’t subscribe to determinism. However, if we subscribe to a multiverse theory, that implies that every version of the universe exists and that you are just living in one version. This may mean your actions are not entirely freely willed as there would be an infinite number of different versions of you each branching off into different universes where you carry out different actions. Does this mean that all actions are pre-destined?</p><p><em>Donnie Darko</em> seemingly subscribes to a determinist world view. This theme is mainly portrayed through the bubble-like spheres that Donnie can see protruding out of people’s chests, including his own.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*wJs8pDU7doNm7qtrGWckfw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is one of Donnie’s ‘Receiver’ powers, his ability to know the future. This, strangely enough, is actually based on real science as explained in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xksMpeMHbTE">this video</a> about <em>Donnie Darko</em> by Wisecrack. They explain that physicists David Deutsch and Michael Lockwood theorise that:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xksMpeMHbTE">‘Your life forms a kind of four-dimensional “worm” in spacetime: the tip of the worm’s tail corresponds to the event of your birth, and the front of its head to the event of your death. An object, seen at any one instance, is a three-dimensional cross-section of this long, thin, intricately curved worm. The line along which the worm lies… is called the objects worldline’.</a></p><p>In the film, Donnie’s science teacher describes this as a ‘vessel [which] travels along a vector through spacetime along its centre of gravity’. Donnie asks if one could see this vessel, and see into the future, would they be able to travel through time. His teacher responds that he is ‘contradicting [himself], if we were able to see our destinies manifest themselves visually then we would be given a choice to betray our chosen destinies and the mere fact that this choice exists would make all preformed destiny come to an end’. Donnie ends this conversation by stating ‘not if you travel within God’s channel’, using mysticism as an answer to this very real question that exists for physicists. However, that Donnie follows his sphere means he can carry out the actions required to save the primary universe, suggesting deviation from one’s path will cause a cosmic implosion. However, what is important to note is that Donnie’s surroundings are often dull and monotonous, it is no coincidence that this film is set in the American suburbs and that Donnie finds an escape from suburban tedium through his Receiver powers. As he sits in his living room with the TV blaring in the background, why would he not follow his ‘vessel’ which appears suddenly before him? The universe gives Donnie no reason why he should not perform the actions that a deterministic universe requires of him. Donnie feels a connection to this force that drives him towards saving the primary universe, a connection to ‘God’s channel’ which he follows, as it provides meaning to his young and troubled life. But the fact that the film, through the science teacher, even points out that by seeing his future means that one has a choice, which makes ‘all performed destiny come to an end’ is important as the film acknowledges that Donnie does not have to perform his ‘destiny’, that it is a choice, which gives Donnie free will. So, whilst the film itself subscribes to the notion of destiny and meaning, it also makes a point that Donnie chooses to save the universe consciously, even if the universe helps him along that path.</p><p>As <em>Russian Doll </em>subscribes to a Many Worlds theory of the multiverse, this question of determinism is more complicated. As stated before, can free will exist if there are infinite universes where one plays out different actions in different universes? Would this mean that you were doomed to live out your one version of history? What <em>Russian Doll</em> makes clear is that it is the characters actions which cause different universes to appear. For instance, at first, Nadia keeps falling down a set of stairs which keeps causing her to die. She then takes the fire escape which enables her to live longer and take different actions. Sometimes she befriends a homeless man who offers to, or actually gives her, a haircut and life advice. Sometimes she makes amends with, or falls out with, her ex-boyfriend. These actions then cause chain reactions which lead to epiphanies or death, or both. It depends on how Nadia and Alan act that change each course of action in each branching universe. This resonates with how the Many Worlds theory was developed by physicists. For example, quantum particles which constantly change state until one observes the particle, when one observes this particle it somehow chooses one state. Right now, there is no solid theory as to how or why, but one answer developed was that the particle does not choose but both states are true in different universes. This branching of the multiverse happens because of a choice, which is exactly what happens in <em>Russian Doll</em>. Thus, whilst Nadia and Alan are seemingly trapped in a state where they are forced to constantly die (and reckon with their pasts) they do have free will. Their choices then affect their actions to the extent that they manage fix the glitch and each version of themselves can live a life within their respective universe.</p><p>Conclusion: whilst both <em>Donnie Darko</em> and <em>Russian Doll </em>deal with the multiverse, and what this means for free will, in different ways, they both represent challenges to our traditional view of what reality is. Both texts represent difficult concepts that real physicists contend with and should be commended for how they visually and conceptually present a multiverse. Whilst both texts show a universe where the protagonists are trapped in a sometimes-hopeless situation and seem as if they are being controlled by some outside force, both texts do give the protagonists agency and place value on the conscious decisions that they make, which suggests free will is still possible in the multiverse. Whilst both of these texts could easily be analysed through themes of morality or social commentary, this article hopes to highlight the metaphysical themes that are rich within these texts. That fictional film can educate the viewer on topics such as quantum physics and question the viewers very natural concepts of what the universe contains should not be ignored but valued and applauded.</p><p>**Note: I realise that the references and sources in this article are predominantly online videos which are traditionally unreliable sources. However, I chose these sources for their accessibility. If you are interested in reading some peer reviewed sources which deal with the multiverse, please see the linked sources below.</p><ul><li><a href="https://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/multiverse.pdf">https://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/multiverse.pdf</a> This is a paper discussing the multiverse by Max Tegmark from January 2003 published by Cambridge University Press.</li><li><a href="https://arxiv.org/pdf/1707.07702.pdf">https://arxiv.org/pdf/1707.07702.pdf</a> This is Stephen Hawking’s infamous paper on the multiverse from May 2018 published by <em>Journal of High Energy Physics</em>.</li><li><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303859846_The_Multiverse">https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303859846_The_Multiverse</a> This is a more accessible paper on the multiverse from the point of view of cosmology written by Victor-Andrei Bodiut from March 2016 published by University of Groningen.</li></ul><p>Other sources (non peer reviewed):</p><p><a href="https://www.space.com/32728-parallel-universes.html">https://www.space.com/32728-parallel-universes.html</a> An accessible explanation of the science behind multiverse theories.</p><p><a href="https://phys.org/news/2018-05-multiversestephen-hawking-theory-big.html">https://phys.org/news/2018-05-multiversestephen-hawking-theory-big.html</a> A supplement piece about Stephen Hawking’s paper on the multiverse.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ebed31195aab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Black Mirror’s ‘Bandersnatch’ Really is the ‘Grimmest’ Episode Yet]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/why-black-mirrors-bandersnatch-really-is-the-grimmest-episode-yet-2f53da81f8fa?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f53da81f8fa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-mirror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bandersnatch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[determinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Dec 2018 17:33:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-29T18:19:22.617Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><em>Black Mirror’s</em> ‘Bandersnatch’: A Meta-Fictional Tale of Free Will</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*rxfdPOjbCY1FWBDQKYBa-g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Warning: SPOILERS</p><p>The most recent addition in the <em>Black Mirror</em> universe, ‘Bandersnatch’ (2018), is one of the most innovative yet. The episode is an interactive experimental game-like episode where viewers control the episode by selecting options presented at the bottom of the screen. Set in 1984, the episode follows Stefan, a troubled young computer programmer who is creating an interactive game based on the interactive choose-your-own-adventure novel <em>Bandersnatch </em>by Jerome F. Davies (not a real book). This meta-fictional interactive game featuring a story about an interactive game based on an interactive novel takes meta-fiction to new extremes. Stefan grows increasingly aware that he is making decisions that are not controlled by himself, thus, addressing us as watcher directly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9TgF4g1EWh7HTOQC-XcX9g.png" /><figcaption>Stefan discussing his recent actions</figcaption></figure><p>We are constantly invited to make decisions which Stefan grows increasingly distressed over has he is aware he is not in control.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0iF8KCMKvEtCxTwGbjyZMw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w3hVnFlZu88utHE2lSPizQ.png" /><figcaption>Stefan pushing his own hand down to avoid performing the command I just voted on</figcaption></figure><p>It is at this point that we, the viewer, not only are an active player in this narrative, but we become an active character too. We are invited in what way we can reveal ourselves to Stefan. I managed to watch all the different ways we can reveal ourselves, through communicating through his computer with a symbol, a reference to his own dream or by communicating directly that we are watching him through Netflix.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2opTdfhyVt9Use0ORMIZHg.png" /><figcaption>Two options within this scene</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u_u7M8zODnXwemHZOf_UaA.png" /><figcaption>Netflix itself as a character</figcaption></figure><p>We become a real character within the episode narrative, but the levels meta-fiction do not stop there. In an article covering the episode, <em>The Independent </em>point out that the episode itself is an experiment on the viewer:</p><p><a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/features/black-mirror-bandersnatch-netflix-interactive-charlie-brooker-interview-a8701626.html?fbclid=IwAR3z-D7r8IZnzLFPEjMKFlpwiDfngB_Y32IQrXZ7LTn_Pd_CwLc1RQTsS5I">‘Viewers are voting on more than who lives and dies on one program. If the response to “Bandersnatch” is enthusiastic, Netflix will take it as a strong signal that the public is ready for interactive movies and television shows, and a new age of storytelling will commence’.</a></p><p>Netflix is using viewers responses to evaluate whether to continue releasing interactive media. Not only are we watching and controlling Stefan, Netflix is equally watching the viewer.</p><p>What would this mean for the next generation of Netflix viewing? In some ways it will turn the ‘<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GpKrM8GQwOg">self-hypnotising</a>’ and binge-watching culture into something more engaged and interactive. However, it would equally hinder creative possibility for new narratives as Netflix would constantly demand more interactive narratives that would require a specific formulaic narrative structure. What started off as ground breaking ‘quickly turns […] to “genre-defining,” as the elements of the show found to be successful become repackaged and recycled by other television shows, expanding rather than destroying the formulaic and predictable nature of television’ (Nolan Gertz <em>Nihilism and Technology </em>2018). Netflix does this all the time, but this episode especially can be seen as an experiment in instant feedback, or as David Streitfeld has noted: <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/features/black-mirror-bandersnatch-netflix-interactive-charlie-brooker-interview-a8701626.html?fbclid=IwAR3z-D7r8IZnzLFPEjMKFlpwiDfngB_Y32IQrXZ7LTn_Pd_CwLc1RQTsS5I">‘what Netflix is really building is a voting machine’.</a></p><p>Additionally, we must consider really how interactive this episode is:</p><p>‘<a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/features/black-mirror-bandersnatch-netflix-interactive-charlie-brooker-interview-a8701626.html?fbclid=IwAR3z-D7r8IZnzLFPEjMKFlpwiDfngB_Y32IQrXZ7LTn_Pd_CwLc1RQTsS5I">Since <em>Black Mirror</em> is always full of tricks, it’s perhaps inevitable that “Bandersnatch” undermines the whole notion of interactivity. The viewer is asked whether a murder should be committed, and if the answer is yes, there is a further decision: Bury the body or chop it up? It’s not much of a choice, which is of course the joke’</a>.</p><p>Quite a few times throughout the episode, we make decisions that end up being ignored or counteracted. There is a scene where Stefan goes to Colin’s (a co-worker and famous computer game programmer) house where Colin offers Stefan acid. I have played that scene twice, one where I accepted and one where I rejected. When I rejected, all that happened was Colin slipped the acid in Stefan’s tea, and the rest of the scene played out as in the scene where I accepted. I also watched to possible outcomes during a visit to the therapists office, where my options where “yeah” or “FUCK YEAH”. The latter sees a spoof action sequence between Stefan and the therapist and ends in a “do-over” option. The first begins the spoof battle, but ends in Stefan trying to escape which, apparently, goes against the script.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W8cJhs9JB3dFYishPYjM6A.png" /></figure><p>We watch Stefan being told off by a director and the whole scene is revealed as a literal scene. It ends ultimately in a “do-over” option. Thus, there is only a “correct” option, to fight, and either way we are sent back to the start to try again. The episode fools you into thinking you are in control, really it is Netflix that controls your possible “decisions” and what happens with those decisions. If Netflix does go ahead and adopts this “interactive” model of storytelling, they are duping audiences into believing that they control the narrative when really, they are in as little control of the narrative as Stefan is in control of his life.</p><p>However, the idea that we are in control of the narrative is explicitly brought up in the narrative dialogue. After Colin and Stefan are on acid, Colin states that one of them will jump out the window of the apartment to their death. Stefan states that one would die, but Colin firmly believes that it ‘wouldn’t matter because there are other timelines’. This turns out to be very true as when Stefan jumps, we get a “do-over”, and when Colin jumps, Stefan wakes up in his dad’s car back in time so he can “do-over”. Stefan is aware that this did not really happen, but is also aware that it also kind of did. He wakes up muttering that he couldn’t save Colin, and is both aware and unaware of this “do-over”.</p><p>Both Stefan and Colin are aware of alternate realities where things happen that the viewer has seen but that we know is just a “do-over”. For example, the office scene from the beginning of the episode where Colin and Stefan initially meet, if you watch it as a “do-over”, Colin will state that they have met before and Stefan is able to predict a conversation before it has happened. Thus, within the narrative, characters are aware that this is not the first time the viewer is watching this. They both explicitly refer to another dimension and invite the idea of time as circular, which Colin states his belief in during the acid trip scene.</p><p>Colin enjoys critiquing the concept of free will and determinism, the former concept being idea that humans are free to make choices and the latter meaning that every action has a ripple effect that informs all following actions, rendering free will impossible. He believes in alternate realities and believes that all human beings are controlled by a greater force. Whilst his ideas are seemingly far-fetched, in the context of the episode, all his ideas are correct. The viewer recognises that the decisions they make for Stefan, as the greater force, all compile up to one big consequence. In a way, the episode argues in favour of a deterministic world order, more so as the action goes on and our options come to be more and more limited. This argues that what has come before has led to this moment and no other option can be available.</p><p>One possible ending is that we see Colin’s daughter grown up and working as a computer game programmer, creating a new version of Bandersnatch. She discovers that Stefan has been trapped within the game, however, reliving the different realities that we as the viewer have chosen for him. One way is to choose the option to destroy the game to free Stefan from his torture. What interests me about this ending is that it brings the episode in full circle. It puts the game-like essence of the episode within a context, that we are actually watching him trapped within the game forever and are playing out the different game realities. This would also make sense as the episode visuals indicate a kind of glitching overused game as the picture constantly twitches and jumps as if malfunctioning. This also takes the theme of time as non-linear to a further extreme as we watch this happening both in the past, present and future. It would also argue against the possibility of free will as Stefan is trapped, and equally, we can only ever watch what has already happened.</p><p>To conclude, free will is questioned in the episode not only as Stefan has none, but our free will as a viewer is equally as limited. Free will is represented as an illusion for Stefan but also for the viewer. It is an episode about free will that questions your own free will. The only one in control is Netflix itself. Additionally, whilst it is recognised by Stefan that we are watching him, eerily enough, Netflix has been equally as transparent that they are watching us. Whether this form of story telling will be a success or not, what <em>Black Mirror</em> has achieved is meta-fiction in a postmodern extreme using narrative and medium to form a self-referential investigation into the nature of free will, choice, reality and time itself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f53da81f8fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Postmodernism (and nihilism) of BoJack Horseman]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/the-postmodernism-and-nihilism-of-bojack-horseman-65dc19083bd9?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65dc19083bd9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nietzsche]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nihilism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bojack-horseman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[postmodernism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-reflection]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Oct 2018 20:16:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-16T18:49:18.475Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Postmodernism (and Nihilism) of BoJack Horseman</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/693/1*k8j83FS6XC4aSH-5zGOx-Q.png" /></figure><p>The Netflix series <em>BoJack Horseman</em> (2014-present) is an adult animated series set in an alternative universe where humans live alongside humanoid animals. Other than this one distinct feature, the world presented to us is exactly the same as our own. The plot loosely revolves around BoJack Horseman, a Hollywoo (the D having been stolen by BoJack) actor whose fame was at its pinnacle during the 1990’s where he starred in the hugely successful sitcom series “Horsin’ Around”, and since has become a washed-up alcoholic and sex addict. The first series centres on his attempt at a comeback through an autobiography to be written by ghost writer, Diane Nguyen. Although allowing other characters to develop their own characterisations and plotlines, season two centres around BoJack’s upcoming new film, “Secretariat”, whilst season three focuses on the release of the film. Season four becomes a more ensemble piece as Diane and her husband, Mr Peanutbutter’s, marriage is tested; Princess Carolyn, BoJack’s manager’s, personal and professional life struggles are more invested in; Todd, a former friend of BoJack’s who was previously only for quick gags, becomes a fully fleshed character as he grapples with his asexuality; and BoJack’s family history and future are revealed and explored. Season five, which was released this year, is the most thought-provoking season yet. The series is based around BoJack’s lead role in the series “Filbert”, a new crime drama series about Filbert the detective. BoJack becomes a paranoid drug addict as he sees the similarities between himself and the character he is playing. The fifth season becomes a metafiction as we watch “Filbert” within <em>BoJack Horseman</em>, and especially during the final episodes, the audience are questioned about how they view BoJack, as we watch how characters respond to Filbert. The entire series of <em>BoJack Horseman</em> could be described in similarly postmodern terms.</p><p>First, though, let us tackle what I mean by “postmodern terms”. Postmodernism cannot be described as one thing exactly. Postmodernist thought can be traced back to the 1940’s and is often described as happening after the Second World War. Postmodernism is, in general, the rejection of modernism, which began roughly during the early 1900’s, which was the dominant mode of philosophy and thought in the period of rapid industrialisation. Modernism rejected outdated, specifically Victorian, forms of art, philosophy, literature, science, psychology, architecture and politics. Modernism valued realism and naturalism, rationalism, objectivity, reason, personal experience, individualism, liberal capitalism, business and technical fields. Contrast this to the premodern period which valued obedience, religion, classicism, and the inherent sinfulness of man, and we see a move towards more modern notions of personal autonomy and societal development. However, the postmodernist disagrees with both the pre-modernists and modernists. Postmodernism rejects ideas of realism and objectivity, and values anti-realism, social subjectivism, anti-truth, egalitarianism, socialism and the humanities. Postmodernism denies the existence of objective truth, that we can never know if there is or is not a “real” outside our human experience. Postmodernism holds <a href="https://www.theodysseyonline.com/examples-postmodernism-television">‘that everything is relative and constructed by political, social and historical perceptions, therefore nothing can be adequately explained by any sort of grand theory, idea, or meta-narratives’</a>. Postmodernism also often critiques capitalism, or high capitalism specifically, which, whilst some modernist works looked to the past rather than the capitalist future, postmodern works cannot attempt escape from high capitalism which now pervades every aspect of our lives right down to that smartphone in your pocket that seems to rule your life.</p><p>So, how is <em>BoJack Horseman</em> a postmodernist show? Whilst it’s easy to merely consider postmodern art as abstract paintings, confusing novels or overly elaborate architecture, postmodern art is really about, says Fredric Jameson in <em>Postmodernism and Consumer Society</em>, ‘the effacement [… of] some key boundaries’ such as ‘the older distinction between high culture and so-called mass or popular culture’. Think of the work of Andy Warhol, his postmodern art sought to make art out of the mass produced. He bridged the divide between high and low art so that ‘the line between high art and commercial forms seems increasingly difficult to draw’. <em>BoJack Horseman</em> uses cartoon characters to represent complex characters addressing very real issues of human nature. Animation allows the show to be narratively complex and put the characters in situations that would be difficult were it live action, such as the silent episode ‘Fish out of Water’ in season 3 that is mostly underwater. Narratively complex television is a postmodern art as argued by Jason Mittel in his essay <em>Narrative Complexity in Contemporary American Television</em>. His paper argues that from the 1990’s onwards, a new form of narratively complex television arose that played with the form of television as a storytelling device. He suggests that whilst conventional television, in the form of sitcom or formulaic television, is still highly popular, he argues that the period from the 1990’s to the present will be remembered for the dawn of a new complex television that plays with narrative structure. <em>BoJack Horseman</em> subverts a narrative structure by offering several narrative strands. The story begins with BoJack, but soon the story is also told from the view of Diane, a kind of voice of reason character, yet with her own set of problems. She is married to happy-go-lucky Mr Peanutbutter, whose impulsive behaviour soon grates on her rather than woos her. Diane is also looking to be a professional and serious writer. Her ghostwriting for BoJack begins to provide this, but soon she is employed in a Buzzfeed type click bate site where she dreams of writing feminist material, but often is stuck recounting “ten times Rihanna gave us life”. We then gain the narrative viewpoint of Princess Carolyn (not a real princess, but a humanoid feline), BoJack’s agent. We soon learn of her great ambitious drive, her personal struggles in love and work, and in seasons four and five, her wishes to become a mother. Season five expands both Mr Peanutbutter’s and Todd’s narrative viewpoints, as we have an entire episode dedicated to Mr Peanutbutter and all his ex-wives attending BoJack’s annual Halloween party, and we see how his impulsive behaviour is the common denominator in driving away his partners. Todd, who in season one was not much more than a quirky homeless couch hopper, by season five embarks on his journey as an asexual looking for companionship. Some episodes are even told from the viewpoint of strangers, such as season five episode seven where BoJack’s and Diane’s therapist is trying to anonymously discuss the two to her partner, who is equally discussing Todd and Princess Carolyn’s legal issues also anonymously. Again, the form of cartoon makes it possible to present the characters in a way that the audience recognises them but are altered by the characters to allow for a comedic effect, for example, BoJack is a zebra and Diane is the late Princess Dianna. There are also some episodes in season four that show BoJack’s family history and one shown mainly from BoJack’s mother’s point of view whilst she is suffering from dementia. This is a creative episode which creates a nauseating and confusing depiction of what dementia might feel like, whilst also revealing heart-breaking truths from her past<strong>.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l0-ffyxYVUgEwDBKAOh_YQ.png" /><figcaption>BoJack’s mother, Beatrice, talking to her maid, Henrietta in a memory</figcaption></figure><p>Whilst this method of story-telling, from several points of view, whilst it is arguably just a more complex, rich and more interesting way to tell a narrative, it is actually quite a postmodern move. Subverting narrative structures disallows a grand narrative and opts for smaller narrative strands, which is a poststructural method of constructing a narrative. Jean-Francois Lyotard, a French philosopher, is known as the first to critique the grand narrative, or the large prevailing narratives that act as truths, and see them as mere narratives propagated by powerful elites. For example, the grand narrative that the West is the hero of the world, that the West brought democracy, science and reason to colonised nations, is actually a narrative used to justify imperial pursuits. Whilst this is not a shocking revelation in 2018, at the time Lyotard was writing in, namely in response to disillusioned, post Second World War counter-cultural movements such as the 1950’s Beat generation, tired of American consumerism and the Korean war; the Civil Rights movements of the 1960’s demanding racial equality and justice in America; and the protesters of the Vietnam war in the 1960’s/70’s. Such movements arise from the mistrust of grand narratives propagated by the West. Using this concept in narrative, then, we can use this to understand the meaning of a structural storytelling device and what this might mean. Why tell <em>BoJack Horseman</em> in this way? By allowing such a range of perspectives, the series rejects the possibility of having an objective view on any of the characters. There is no grand narrative of <em>BoJack Horseman</em>, there is no objective value of characters, which is important if we consider that morality is a central theme of the series.</p><p>The rejection of the possibility of an “objective” is also a central point of postmodern thought. Whilst the modernists sought to find objective “truth”, and objective reason, the postmodernists deny that there is a reality outside of the subjective experience. This, again, is central in <em>BoJack Horseman</em>. BoJack longs to be told that he is a good person and constantly asks, especially of Diane, throughout all the seasons if she thinks that “deep down” he is really a good guy. This is a harrowing question as we have watched BoJack commit morally questionable acts. At first, it is obvious he is an alcoholic, selfish, narcissist who craves validation and admiration from shallow Hollywoo industries. In later seasons, we watch BoJack travel to New Mexico to visit an old friend (unexpectedly), Charlotte, to escape his problems in LA, when he takes advantage of her daughter, Penny. Penny, 17, tries to initiate sex with BoJack who is hesitant to refute her advances before Charlotte walks in on them and throws BoJack out. Whilst this is bleak enough, BoJack later finds Penny to drunkenly apologise, which only causes further trauma for her. To deal with this pain, BoJack goes on a drug bender with Sarah Lynn, the now grown-up version of his TV daughter in “Horsin Around”. During this bender, Sarah Lynn dies of an overdose. Of course, BoJack’s culpability for his wrongdoing can be debated: we see flashbacks of his childhood where he grew up in an abusive household and we watch segments of BoJack’s severe depression and near suicide. However, BoJack is clearly not a “good person”, be it “deep down” or otherwise. However, notions of good versus bad, or, objective morality, are also rejected by the show in a postmodern way. Diane answers BoJack’s question of whether or not he is a good person with: “you are what you do” and states that she believes that “there are no <em>good guys</em> and <em>bad guys</em>, we are all just guys, who sometimes do bad things and sometimes do good things”. Diane subscribes to a subjective morality, your actions are you and rejects grand narratives of good guys and bad guys. BoJack, meanwhile, continually attempts to believe in an inherent soul and that deep down you are good or that you have a kind of destiny. This often is the exact reason why he acts irrationally or selfishly as he pursues goals which offer validation from industry which comes to embody his idea of an “objective” or “destiny”. Other characters, such as Diane, reject such goals as “receiving an Oscar” or getting a “starring role” she can acknowledge how fleeting and shallow such validation is. The series exposes objective ideas about morality and grand narratives to be false and subscribes to the postmodern subjective view.</p><p>Relating to this, another theme of the series is postmodern pop culture, media and capitalism. The series is set in LA in the midst of Hollywoo and is largely centred on exposing the falsity of Hollywood. Not only does the series expose the falsity of television and film by literally showing the constructed nature of the sets, the shallow casting (especially of women) based on appearance or the Hollywood star system, and generally satirizing media platforms such as celebrity talk shows, reality television and even “serious” dramas by pretentious directors, but the series interrogates contemporary cultural movements. Series five especially examines feminism in the contemporary age through its manifestations in popular culture today. The series looks at both the #MeToo movement and, in an episode called “BoJack the Feminist”, the episode looks at the treatment of “shamed” white male celebrities and how easily they are forgiven for their racist/sexist/anti-Semantic or otherwise hateful views and actions. When Vance Waggoner is cast in BoJack’s drama “Philbert” after a hiatus due to Waggoner’s disgrace as a sexist, anti-Semantic and anti-Swede, Diane is asked by her boss to write a click bate Buzzfeed type article to call on the hypocrisy of his forgiveness, or as Diane puts it the public ‘act all shocked when one of their favourite stars turns out to be a dirtbag, but they can’t wait to give a comeback to all the dirtbags we already know about’. When Diane’s boss asks her to write about this, she responds ‘I know how this ends. Our core readership eats it up and a bunch of dude-bros call me a “dumb slunt,” and Vance’s career chugs, right along’. Diane acknowledges that no matter how terrible a man in power may have been, his forgiveness will always be granted with ease and at no cost to his integrity or career. When Princess Carolyn hires him on “Philbert”, Diane asks her to take responsibility, to think about what message it sends to men around the world, to which Princess Carolyn remarks that the industry “is screwed up”. BoJack manages to be shot on camera pulling a face when Vance is on stage receiving a forgiveness award and he is misconstrued as a male feminist, which he uses to further his popularity. BoJack states that ‘it turns out, the problem with feminism, all along, is it just wasn’t men doing it’. Diane then tries to teach BoJack about how the media can normalise good or bad things, using examples like how Ellen makes middle America less afraid of gay people as a positive media influence, or how Jack Bauer of the show <em>24</em> made torture normal in the early days of the War on Terror. BoJack does not understand her point and resorts to ‘sprinkling’ words like ‘intersectionality’ or ‘micro-aggressions’ and wearing a t-shirt that says, ‘feminism is bae’, and spouting phrases like ‘the future is female’, which sums up the negative aspects of contemporary feminist movements. Popular culture’s interpretation of feminism involves incorporating it as part of capitalist culture, making the social movement a product, for example, BoJack’s “feminism is bae” t-shirt that commoditises the social movement. Whilst wearing a feminist t-shirt in itself is quite harmless, that such t-shirts as ‘feminist AF’ are widely available today through large corporations like H&amp;M or Topshop, for example, signify how social movements can be commodified into a product, another part of the spectacle of high capitalism, and empties the movement as meaningless. Marxist philosopher, Guy Debord, defines the society of the spectacle as a society <a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/debord/society.htm">‘where modern conditions of production prevail, all of life presents itself as an immense accumulation of spectacles. Everything that was directly lived has moved away into a representation’</a>. In capitalist culture, all lived experience now only comes through representation, mainly the image, and this becomes the only way for us to communicate. Instead of lived social action, we can use the commodity of feminist t-shirts or social media hashtags, which are both mere representations, yet that has become the only action left. This notion is articulated through BoJack well, who can’t be bothered to be properly taught by Diane about feminism so opts for the representation, which works well for him in shallow Hollywoo that functions only through image and representation. Forgiveness is an award show whilst feminism is a popular topic used to sell t-shirts: authenticity has vanished in the spectacle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*stDmFvkhlfgPLRlEHYoxww.png" /><figcaption>Different examples of feminist t-shirts in real life</figcaption></figure><p>But, <em>BoJack Horseman</em> attempts to shed light on this in an unflinching way. It exposes the inauthenticity directly by showing how a tv show might hire a female writer, not actually let her write anything, just so that her name in the credits can justify the sexism of the show. The series exposes how men in power are continually forgiven for the terrible things that they do and attempt to point the finger at the powerful industries that let it happen. Whilst it is often a bleak and existential show, the contemporary social commentary is often enlightening and offers solutions as well as exposes the problems. This is interesting as previously, the show itself has been called sexist for the use of the anti-hero character archetype and the way the audience sympathises with BoJack. BoJack is not a likeable character and, as previously articulated, does terrible things. The show doesn’t offer him forgiveness, but it does retell and normalise the same narrative that “shit men do shitty things and there is nothing we or they can do about it”. This is a damaging narrative as it lets men “off the hook” when they do bad things and allows them to blame their destructive behaviour on their mental health or their bad childhoods, whilst not encouraging them to change their ways. Season five, through the use of the “Filbert” narrative, actually questions the viewer on their relationship to BoJack, and asks the audience not to normalise his behaviour. In “BoJack the Feminist”, Bojack is doing an interview about the questionable morals of “Filbert”. When asked if the show is sexist, he states ‘when you take plot points out of context, they can seem unsavoury. But they’re all part of a larger attempt to deconstruct… toxic… masculinity’. The interviewer, a “Ryan Seacrest type”, answers ‘oh! Sounds glamourous!’ to which BoJack responds ‘No, we’re not glamorising it, that’s the thing. You’re not supposed to like John Philbert or agree with the things he does. It’s a TV show. It doesn’t glamorise anything. But… maybe it normalises it’. Here, BoJack is literally talking about “Philbert”, but, the audience is intended to recognise that <em>BoJack Horseman</em> is speaking to us, the viewer, about how <em>BoJack Horseman</em> may normalise toxic masculinity. Season five is self-reflective and, once again, not only points out the problems of the contemporary West but tries to offer solutions. Whilst previously the series was a TV show satirising the television industry, itself a kind of metafiction about the media industry yet being made and produced by Netflix, itself a major media corporation, now the series has moved onto further self-interrogation about what kind of narratives the show normalises, alongside exposing other narratives that populate popular culture. Thus, the series is self-reflective not only in the narrative world but reflective also about the industry that produces the show itself.</p><p>This self-reflectiveness is also shown in season five through the whiteboard in the director of Philbert, Flip McVicker’s, office. <em>BoJack Horseman</em> creators seem to pay particular attention to detail, even with seemingly mere background objects, like the whiteboard. However, the whiteboard serves as a crucial detail in understanding the world of <em>BoJack Horseman</em>. For instance, one of the ideas for episodes written on the board is: “magic realism: too girly”. This is comical as <em>BoJack Horseman</em> itself is, arguably, magic realism. Magic realism is difficult to define, but generally speaking, it is a genre in art, literature, film, theatre, etc., that, whilst is mainly a very realistic depiction of our world, contains some small magical elements to the story, but in a very matter-of-fact way.</p><p>Magic realism explained here: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hi6ObKtA57o">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hi6ObKtA57o</a></p><p>This is <em>BoJack Horseman</em>. It is a realistic depiction of LA and the story works to critique the modern West and its shallow industries but contains humanoid animals living amongst humans. Most of the time, the viewer questions how or why, and it seems mainly to serve as a comical purpose rather than providing social commentary. However, having a world of mixed humans and animals allows for creativity in such episodes as the near silent “Fish out of Water” episode in season three where BoJack is underwater for most of the episode and bonding with aquatic animals. It also provides a moment of comedy at the end of the creative but harrowing episode “Free Churro” in season five, which depicts only BoJack giving a eulogy at his mother’s funeral, only in the last moment to show a crowd of lizards and for BoJack to realise he is at the wrong funeral. So, other than comedy, the magic realism may not be for any particular deep meaning but to present some harrowing and real-world concepts within an absurd universe.</p><p>Another point on the whiteboard of Flip’s office is the name “Nietzsche”, which is circled, and the famous Friedrich Nietzsche quote written on the board: ‘if you gaze for long into the abyss, the abyss gazes also into you’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QAnDR-BeWbeH0xsz-5O6yw.png" /><figcaption>Flip and his whiteboards</figcaption></figure><p>This is Nietzsche’s most famous and most quoted words, taken from his book <em>Beyond Good and Evil</em> (1886). There is no definitive answer to what Nietzsche means by the abyss, it could mean existence, life, death or meaning. Nietzsche, a German philologist and analytic philosopher, is best known for existentialism and nihilism, which is intriguing as he never uses the word existential, and he warned against humanity’s path towards nihilism. Nihilism is: <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nihilism"><strong>‘</strong>a viewpoint that traditional values and beliefs are unfounded and that existence is senseless and useless</a></p><p><a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nihilism"><em>“Nihilism</em> is a condition in which all ultimate values lose their value”. — Ronald H. Nash</a></p><p><a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nihilism"><strong>b: </strong>a doctrine that denies any objective ground of truth and especially of moral truths’.</a></p><p>Whilst Nietzsche himself was not a nihilist, he is, in a sense, a kind of forefather of nihilism. He famously proclaimed the death of God, indicating the end of widespread belief in God that coupled with the dawn of modernity. This he both lamented and celebrated; Nietzsche was strictly anti-Christian and saw Christian morality as an illness that is killing the West. He saw Christian morals as weakening because Christian morals celebrated submission and servitude. He believed the gap left by Christianity should be filled with art, literature, music and an active culture. He did not see this as an easy task, as he writes how life’s purpose up until the death of God had been dictated by a purpose which God fulfils. Once this is revealed to be nothing more than illusion and the realisation that we are mere animals with no meaning or purpose, individuals fall into despair. Nietzsche did believe in the nihilistic belief that life has no purpose but believed that individuals must interpret life in a way that is life promoting. He saw existence as extremely subjective, and the notion that there are objective moral truths as impossible. This leaves one with the freedom to draw their own moralistic lines and values. Nietzsche’s philosophy was one that championed aesthetic appreciation and culture. He also wrote extensively on the Higher Man or the Overman, who was the select few intended to read and follow his philosophy. The Higher Man was the smart and strong man who did not follow the ‘herd’ of society but followed his own moralistic code. He is to rule the rest of society, but, he cannot ‘maintain this perfection’, and ultimately will be overruled. However, Nietzsche’s disciples are to strive for perfect moments where they are the Overman and are able to overcome weaknesses and fears. This can only be achieved through great suffering: ‘only if the black snake is crawling down your throat can you bite its head off and laugh the laugh of the Overman’. Only in one’s darkest hours can one overcome his problems and triumph as an Overman. Nietzsche valued suffering and saw that society is wrong to pursue the goal of demolishing all suffering as the removal of suffering will remove creative genius:</p><p><a href="https://www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/public/friedrich-nietzsche-truth-terrible/">‘What “makes life on earth worth living”, Nietzsche says in <em>Beyond Good and Evil</em> are things like “virtue, art, music, dance, reason, intellect — something that transfigures, something refined, fantastic, and divine”. But if these kinds of excellences of human achievement are not possible in a culture devoted to hedonistic satisfaction and obsessed with eliminating all forms of suffering (from the trivial to the serious), then we will have no response to Schopenhauer’s nihilism’</a>.</p><p>Suffering produces art, which to Nietzsche is what makes life worth living. Art is the gap that fills the hole left by Christianity, but art and creative genius is not possible without suffering. Thus, while Nietzsche acknowledges nihilism and the possibility of pessimistic nihilism to swallow us whole, he provides an active approach to nihilism which is to find the art in suffering and to create meaning in one’s own life. Whilst some of the philosophy can be contradictory and controversial, some of it being used for Nazi ideology (which he was against), his philosophy has proved to be influential. He predicted the nihilistic postmodern condition, as Brian Leiter puts it:<a href="https://www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/public/friedrich-nietzsche-truth-terrible/"> ‘Nietzsche here diagnoses capitalist modernity, which has Donald Trump as its current ruler, Twitter with its 24/7 “derision” as its appendage, and the world market that tells us what “happiness” really is and its price’.</a> <em>BoJack Horseman</em>, too, echoes this emptiness of meaning, this nihilism where characters search for happiness through meaning in a meaningless world only to find a void or an abyss.</p><p>So, why do the creators of <em>BoJack Horseman</em> quote Nietzsche? Is it to indicate the nihilism which permeates throughout the series? I am not the first to point out the overwhelming existential nihilism present in series. In a video essay named <em>The Philosophy of BoJack Horseman</em>, the video argues that the setting of Hollywoo could be read as a metaphor for life itself, as<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rORIDYHOFTQ&amp;index=3&amp;list=PLghL9V9QTN0jve4SE0fs33K1VEoXyL-Mn"> ‘just like the façade of Hollywoo covers up the reality of an ugly, hollow industry the trappings of our daily lives cover up the meaninglessness of existence itself’.</a> The very question of what to do with our meaningless lives is central to existential nihilism and philosophers have different positions on what to do. Essentially, there are two positions to take on nihilism: the position taken by Nietzsche, Søren Kierkegaard, Albert Camus and Jean-Paul Sartre, that one must make meaning in a meaningless world, or the position of Arthur Schopenhauer or Jean Baudrillard who reject the possibility of meaning in a meaningless world. Different characters in BoJack Horseman take such positions, for example, Mr Peanutbutter states explicitly that meaning is pointless, yet he also embraces the absurdity of life. His position is very similar to Camus, who defined the absurd as a confrontation between man’s desire for significance and the universe’s abstinence from giving man such meaning. However, Camus states we should accept the lack of inherent meaning in life and only through this can we make our own meaning. Mr Peanutbutter accepts the absurd and is often the happiest character because of it. Diane believes you can find meaning through positive actions, whilst BoJack attempts to find meaning in a meaningless world and refuses to embrace the absurdity of the universe. What is interesting is that BoJack’s philosophy is very similar to what Nietzsche predicted for the modern West:</p><p>‘what I relate is the history of the next two centuries. I describe what is coming, what can no longer come differently: the advent of nihilism… For some time now, our whole European culture has been moving as toward a catastrophe, with a tortured tension that is growing from decade to decade: relentlessly, violently, headlong, like a river that wants to reach the end, that no longer reflects, that is afraid to reflect’. — Nietzsche, <a href="http://www.lexido.com/EBOOK_TEXTS/WILL_TO_POWER_.aspx?s=5"><em>Will to Power </em>(1887/88)</a></p><p>BoJack is afraid to reflect and avoids doing so by self-medicating with drugs and alcohol. He becomes depressed and near suicidal, and his fruitless attempts to grasp at a purpose in life often leaves him even more afloat. He suffers from existential nihilism in a similar way to his father: by a search for meaning through external validation. BoJack’s father spent his life writing a novel which was to be his masterpiece, his destiny. He spent his whole life writing this novel, only for no one to read it, and those who did thought it was terrible. BoJack, whilst more successful than his father, suffers that same need for external validation, for a destiny or a meaning in life.</p><p>This problem is discussed by Søren Kierkegaard who philosophises that people will always find disappointment by thinking their life could be better, or that they should be doing something else, no matter what they choose they will always believe the other option would be better. This is exactly what BoJack experiences, especially when he questions “what if this were different about me”, resulting in his perpetual disappointment with himself. He first looks to make himself relevant in Hollywoo again by publishing his memoir, which only forces him to look at his life and causes him to be depressed. He then is cast in the movie role of his dreams, “Secretariat”, which again, only causes him to be depressed. When he wins an Oscar, again, he expects happiness, only to be let down. And in the most recent season, he is cast in the lead role of a new television programme, and the character he is playing causes him to reflect on his own life, causing major drug and alcohol abuse. BoJack suffers the nihilism of the postmodern age and refuses to reflect. What is interesting is that it is pop culture that tries to force him to reflect, be it the memoir or “Philbert”, yet a major focus in the Philbert narrative is how pop culture acknowledges the bad things that powerful men do and defends bad men. <em>BoJack Horseman</em> is all about reflection and uses pop culture as a vehicle for both BoJack and the viewer to do so.</p><p>To conclude, <em>BoJack Horseman</em> is a postmodern show for a variety of reasons. It is a metafiction, it is reflective, it rejects grand narratives, it rejects objective morality and objective truths, it critiques capitalist society whilst acknowledging it is also a product of capitalist society, it is existential and experiments with narrative structure. Season five ends with BoJack going to rehab, and finally reflecting on his actions. He finally takes a positive action to change who he is and accepts that he can only be the person who carries out the actions that he carries out. If he goes on TV and says that strangling women is bad, as he does in “BoJack the Feminist”, that does not mean he is a feminist, especially if he then later strangles his girlfriend and co-star, which happens near the end of season five. Whether or not this is a happy ending for BoJack will be told with the next season, but what we can bank on is that the series will not opt for a neat narrative closure. We learn about all the character’s subjective experiences through a mixture of narrational experimentation, be it through the eyes of strangers or in memories from the past. BoJack will probably continue to be a flawed person, and I don’t believe the show will offer a full redemption. However, I am interested to see how his story will continue, for good or bad. <em>BoJack Horseman</em>, overall, warns against the nihilistic inability to accept the absurd and reflect on the self, or on society as a whole. The pessimism of the show will also rely on the actions of the postmodern West in the near future, so I certainly look forward to seeing <em>BoJack Horseman</em>’s reflection of the future!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65dc19083bd9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Rise of Fake News and Political Parodies in the Post-Truth West]]></title>
            <link>https://kirkwoodmegan1.medium.com/the-rise-of-fake-news-and-political-parodies-in-the-post-truth-west-82fcc461a1da?source=rss-80b208a34c82------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82fcc461a1da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[noam-chomsky]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Megan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Sep 2018 16:11:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-07T17:16:55.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the era of fake news, much has been written on and said about the blurring lines between truth and falsity, fact and fiction. The rise of fake news, fabricated news articles whose purpose is to deceive and fool, and the extent to which fake news has impacted our political reality, is worrying. Many question why? How did we get into a world of “post-truth”, a world where emotions and prejudice exceed facts. However, in this article, I plan to examine the mainstream news, fake news and political parodies as completing forms of conveyers of “truth”. I will use Noam Chomsky and Edward S. Herman’s infamous Propaganda Model to question the authenticity of mainstream news and will move on to explore how fake news operates. I will then contemplate how political parody shows and websites act as a critique of the news and will end the article with a consideration of what cultural vehicles we can use to convey a sense of truth in the post-truth Western world.</p><p>Chomsky is an American social critic, academic, historian, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic_philosophy">analytic philosopher</a>, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_scientist">cognitive scientist</a>. He is also an activist against the War on Terror, is actively pro-Palestine, a supporter of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupy_movement">Occupy Movement</a> and is an avid defender of free speech. Herman was an American economist and media analyst who was also actively political throughout his life. He, with Chomsky, challenged the way that the American media represented the Vietnam War and the media’s treatment of post-war Indochina, Cambodia in the 1970’s. Herman, with David Peterson, wrote <em>The Politics of Genocide</em> (2010), which investigates the media’s representation of what genocide constitutes in relation to Western military agendas. Thus, politics and the media are a massive area of concern for both Herman and Chomsky. Both these political academics collaborated on <em>Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media</em> (1988) which is a seminal text exploring the way mass media distributes the agendas of society’s elites whilst censoring undesirable information. Herman and Chomsky devised a Propaganda Model to explain how mass media is influenced and controlled to force these agendas.</p><p>The first propaganda filter of the media is ‘Size, Ownership, and Profit Orientation of the Mass Media’ which focuses on the big companies which control media distribution. The first filter describes how media distributors are profit oriented and how media depends on the government for general policy supports. Mass media are supported by big advertisers, not paying subscribers, and what the media chooses to report on is influenced by rich and powerful sources. Companies which distribute news often monopolise on both newspapers, television and radio, meaning it is just a mere few companies who control most of the mass media we consume. The end of the description of the first filter summarises thus: ‘the dominant media firms are quite large businesses; they are controlled by very wealthy people or by managers who are subject to sharp constraints by owners and other market-profit-oriented forces; and they are closely interlocked, and have important common interests, with other major corporations, banks, and government’ (page 14 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). Thus, the first filter describes how it is the elite who fund and control the mass media.</p><p>The second filter is ‘The Advertising License to do Business’. This describes how advertising controls mass media as ‘an advertising-based system will tend to drive out of existence or into marginality the media companies and types that depend on revenue from sales alone. With advertising, the free market does not yield a neutral system in which final buyer choice decides. The <em>advertisers’</em> choice influence media prosperity and survival’ (page 14 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). Thus, what advertisers want from the media, they get. So, who do advertisers want to attract? They want ‘audiences with buying power’ (page 16 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). This leads mass media to direct its interests towards the elite of society, which means working-class interests are disregarded and radical media is not supported. Conservative views, therefore, are encouraged, whilst information that is critical of mainstream ideals are discouraged.</p><p>The third filter is ‘Sourcing Mass-Media News’. Sources for news, or the raw material, is vital for news programs to function. But, where to get the sources? News reporters must be close to places where news-worthy stories occur, such as where press conferences are held, city hall, police departments etc. Business corporations are additionally a good source for news, as ‘only bureaucracies can satisfy the input needs of a news bureaucracy’ (quote from Mark Fishman on page 19 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). Essentially, “official people” should know what “officially” is going on. They are also thought of as “objective”, but, taking information from bureaucracies will also avoid the threat of libel suits, and additionally, taking information from such credible sources reduces investigative costs as there is no need to fact check or conduct costly research. Thus, it is most often official government and bureaucracies that provide material for the news. Additionally, such officials make it easy for the news to use their source before others: ‘they provide the media organizations with facilities in which to gather; they give journalists advance copies of speeches and forthcoming reports; they schedule press conferences at hours well geared to news deadlines; they write press releases in usable language; and they carefully organize their press conferences and “photo opportunity” sessions’ (page 22 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). This provides even more ways that large and powerful bureaucracies “subsidise” the news and ensure their contributions are the contributions used most widely. Any official “expert” used in the news are often government consultants whose research is funded by such large bureaucracies. Therefore, all bias will be in favour of the dominant elite.</p><p>The fourth filter is ‘Flak and the Enforcers’. “Flak” describes ‘negative responses to a media statement or program’ (page 26 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). The ability to produce flak ‘is related to power’ (page 26 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>) and can be perpetrated by such bureaucracies and government that controls the media. Flak enforcers will threaten and correct the media to ensure any deviations from their interests cannot occur. Any deviations are downplayed, de-legitimised and discredited. The current US President, Donald Trump, often tries to use flak to discredit the media. He often calls news reports which criticise him “fake news” in an attempt to discredit the source. He then will tell press conferences what “really happened”, often with little to no proof to back up his version of events. However, this ability to discredit the media is linked to his power and influence.</p><p>Finally, the fifth filter is the ‘Anticommunism as a Control Mechanism’ filter. This anti-communist ideology was popular during and after the Cold War, yet this fifth filter still applies in the context of the War on Terror, War on Drugs, and even more so in the Donald Trump presidency, anti-immigrant ideology. This filter is about the common enemy against Americans and becomes a justification for any means to stop that enemy. Herman and Chomsky note that ‘liberals at home, often accused of being pro-Communist or insufficiently anti-Communist, are kept continuously on the defensive in a cultural milieu in which anticommunism is the dominant religion’ (page 29 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>). This fifth filter is where post-truth works effectively, as any critique of that fear turns the critic into part of that fear. Fear of the enemy is number one; real facts about the potential threat is disregarded. Post-truth requires no real facts and is a place where ‘charlatans can thrive as evidential sources’ (page 30 of <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>).</p><p>Together, these filters create the Propaganda Model which enforces the ideals and pursuits of the dominant elite onto the mass media. In <em>Manufacturing Consent</em>, other aspects of media are discussed, such as worthy and unworthy victims. Worthy victims are victims of the enemy, and unworthy victims are always the enemy when they are attacked. Note that there will be high media coverage of attacks of ISIS in Europe, whereas ISIS attacks in Syria or Iraq will receive much less coverage, despite the fatalities being much higher in those countries where ISIS is more prevalent. This is due to the favoured image of the Middle East not as victims of violence, but the perpetrators of violence, which justifies the continued War on Terror and the harsh immigration laws in the US. Altogether, the Propaganda Model exposes the ways that the news is not a neutral distribution of facts, but a conveyer belt of elitist ideology.</p><p>The Propaganda Model was published before the dawn of the internet, and with the growth of social media and the new ways that the news is distributed, the focus of news distributors must be affected. Whilst it seems that the internet would make distribution of independent news more accessible, recent studies about social media algorithms reveal that what users see online have been highly marketed for them using the user’s data. Social media has not widened our available media, it has restricted it more. This is not to diminish the political achievements made by social media in regards to its role in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_Spring#The_Arab_Spring">Arab Spring</a>, as one example, but, distribution of media is now more filtered than ever. Astra Taylor’s book <em>The People’s Platform: Taking back Power and Culture in the Digital Age </em>(2014) describes the ways that ‘highly detailed dossiers’ are compiled on users by social media platforms, or search engine websites, that corporations can buy and use. And as we now know, the Cambridge Analytica scandal has taught us how much data is used to influence political campaigns as well as product marketing. The company illegally used data on Facebook <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/mar/17/cambridge-analytica-facebook-influence-us-election">‘to target [users] with personalised political advertisements’</a>. What we see online is highly filtered, chosen and marketed to us. And to make matters worse, not only are we marketed specific news stories by news media corporations whose choices on what constitutes as newsworthy have been influenced by politics and bureaucracy, thrown into the mix are “click-bate” websites and fake news. Click-bate websites are designed to have catchy slogans and titles with the intention for you to click on to it, providing money for that website through advertising. Fake news is described as ‘<a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/23736992.2017.1331015">made-up news, manipulated to look like credible journalistic reports that are designed to deceive us. Once uploaded, fake news is easily spread through social media to large numbers of people who are willing to believe and share the fictional material</a>’ (page 180). Fake news started to become a major problem in 2016 during the presidential election between Donald Trump and Hilary Clinton, when <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/23736992.2017.1331015">‘several fake news reports outperformed news articles from respected media outlets’</a> (page 180). Whilst some fake news may be just badly informed reports, the most worrying fake news is that which intends to deceive, manipulate, and mislead. The spread of fake news most often used to encourage pre-existing beliefs and prejudices:</p><p><a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2018.02.032">‘research has shown that these determinants [users’ interpersonal networks, algorithms, and users’ psychological motivations] tend to limit the flow across cross-cutting positions and contribute to the “echo chambers,” where information flows among like-minded users, and “filter bubbles,” where online content is controlled by algorithms reflecting users’ prior choices’</a> (page 104).</p><p>Thus, fake news is used to encourage other like-minded people to believe in untrue stories to fuel their beliefs.</p><p>Whilst at times it is easy to ask how people could believe such stories (<a href="https://nordic.businessinsider.com/fake-presidential-election-news-viral-facebook-trump-clinton-2016-11?r=UK&amp;IR=T">see the link here for some of the most popular fake news headlines</a> in the U.S), in such a political climate as there was during the 2016 U.S election, or Britain’s EU “Brexit” referendum which also saw a massive rise in fake news stories, entire nations were aggressively divided. In both cases, there were two clear sides; Clinton and the Democrats versus Trump and the Republicans or Leave versus Remain. Both sides were very invested and passionate about their side and would believe anything to discredit the opposition. Additionally, it has been noted that during the 2016 election, people were more likely and <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2018.02.032">more willing to discuss the election with those they agreed with than those who they were against</a>. That each side would share fake news to attempt to persuade and encourage belief in their political side, then, becomes more understandable. To add to the confusion and misinformation spread by fake news sites, official news broadcasters have also been known to be biased. For example, <em>Fox News</em> has taken a Republican stance to politics whilst <em>MSNBC</em> has taken a more Democratic one. These biases are no secret, as liberals mock <em>Fox News</em> whilst conservatives equally mock <em>MSNBC</em>. This feeling of mistrust towards official news sites further explains why people may be inclined to believe fake news.</p><p>However, what does this rise in fake news <em>mean</em>? Does it indicate the failures of official news to provide unbiased information? We might consider <a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘Francesca Tripodi’s ethnographic research on mainstream American conservatives [which] engages directly with questions of partisanship and ideology. She argues that because conservatives consider the mainstream media to be “fake,” they turn to alternative media sources such as <em>Breitbart</em> and the video channel <em>Prager U</em> for information’</a> (page 493). If conservatives believe the mainstream media is biased, turning to alternative news may seem logical. Many right-leaning citizens may see themselves as the underdog, at the mercy of urban citizens who have different interests. Right-leaning citizens see pro-immigration, feminism and anti-racism movements as a threat, so media which sympathises with those views are a threat to them (see <a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">page 497</a>). In fact, Alice E Marwick argues that conservatives see <a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘the mainstream media [as] left-wing elites who wish to destroy traditional values, are corrupt and greedy’</a> (497). Warwick also found that:</p><p><a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘centrists and left-leaning citizens were likely to get information from mainstream news sources like <em>CNN</em> and the<em> New York Times</em>, while right-leaning citizens were far more likely to consume a dense network of “hyper-partisan” sources like <em>Breitbart</em> and <em>The Daily Caller</em>. While these sources may not be fake news per se, the same study describes them as “combining decontextualized truths, repeated falsehoods, and leaps of logic to create fundamentally misleading view[s] of the world.”’</a> (pp. 491–492)</p><p>In such a divided political reality as the one in which the West lives in now, what is telling about this study is the fact that <a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘ultimately, conservatives and liberals are not only consuming different media, but existing in different epistemological realities’</a> (pp. 493–494). It is suggested that the media that we consume can indicate our very sense of identity and community:</p><p><a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘Peck explains how such outlets signify a social identity through the stories they cover, the entertainment media they highlight, and the marketing appeals they make to intellectuals, cosmopolitan business people, and hip urbanites. Thus, by believing stories in the <em>New York Times</em> or the <em>Washington Post</em>, cultural conservatives risk taking on the mantle of left-wing identity regardless of what those stories discuss’</a> (page 494).</p><p>This recalls filter two of the Propaganda Model, that advertising and the way media presents itself towards a specific market will influence the content. This creates a media identity, a community, which is applied to both conservatives and liberals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*zur1wtbjPW6d3hGjE9Wz1w.png" /><figcaption>An advert for The New York Times which highlights the importance of facts</figcaption></figure><p>The screenshot here shows the advertising used by <em>The New York Times</em>. They highlight the idea of facts and proof, whilst also relying on paying subscribers to fund the platform. <em>The New York Times</em> attract middle-class liberals and will appeal to that demographic. Reading <em>The New York Times</em> indicates you as part of a certain group, a moderately wealthy liberal, just like how conservative media also creates a sense of community:</p><p><a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘Peck points out that partisanship is primarily driven not by any particular party position or platform, but by affinity for and similarity to one’s fellow party members. A great deal of research finds that partisanship is identity-based: people identify with the party that they feel that most members of their social group belong to, and will adjust their party preferences to match their family, friends, or neighborhoods [<em>sic</em>]. Just as the <em>New York Times</em> references eating Korean food, listening to Kendrick Lamar, and flying business class, Peck argues that <em>Fox News</em> uses a set of cultural referents like country music stars in their political rhetoric, which interpolates a particular class and race identity: namely, white, blue-collar, and masculine — a strategy that he calls cultural populism’</a> (page 494).</p><p>Marwick goes on to say that the way official news <a href="https://www.georgetownlawtechreview.org/why-do-people-share-fake-news-a-sociotechnical-model-of-media-effects/GLTR-07-2018/">‘contributes to partisanship […] fuels problematic information’</a> (page 495) just as fake news, through decontextualized stories geared towards gaining as much viewership as possible, also fuels ‘problematic information’. News broadcasters, on all sides of the political spectrum, cater to a certain demographic for economic benefit, whilst fake news sites may also be motivated by profit for web traffic. The reason for the rise in fake news is down to the failure of official news to be unbiased, yet, any alternative news is also going to be biased. But, these stories are made and shared by a community of like-minded people who want their views heard and justified, and fake news is just a new way to share those views.</p><p>Is there an alternative to way to consume news?</p><p>Political satire, parody television shows and websites offer themselves as an alternative to news broadcasters. Websites such as <em>The Onion</em> or comedy television shows like <em>The Daily Show</em> (1996-present) advertise themselves as the watchdogs of official news and as a critique of mainstream media. Whilst early parody shows such as Chevy Chase’s impersonations of the then-President Gerald Ford on <em>Saturday Night Live</em> (1975-present) took to merely making fun of political personalities, a motif in parody that continues today, contemporary parody shows are more likely to comment upon and critique political beliefs and policies. As Day and Thompson recount in their study, the difference between Chase’s <em>Saturday Night Live</em> in the 1970’ and 80’s,<strong> </strong>and <em>Saturday Night Live</em> in the 2000’s with Amy Poehler and Tina Fey was the increase in political critique in the contemporary version of the show. A turning point in the political impact of the show can be traced to the infamous 2008 sketch about Hilary Clinton and Sarah Palin, as <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/15405702.2012.638582">‘the skit became an immediate internet sensation and was rebroadcast and discussed on “real” news shows. The impression of Palin in particular resonated with audiences and Fey was pressed into service several more times, while the show’s election-focused skits moved to the forefront of popular cultural attention’ </a>(page 178). Parody and satire have increased in popularity since the early <em>SNL</em> days, and notably, parody and satire not only comment on the news of the day but the way the news is packaged for consumption. For example,<em> The Daily Show</em> <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/15405702.2012.638582">‘deals largely in critical deconstruction of how TV news constructs the “true” and the “real.” Most recently, the <em>Onion News Network </em>meticulously reproduces the postmodern aesthetic of cable news, taking aim at its excesses and extravagance’</a> (page 179). <em>The Onion</em> reveals how the news is presented in a particular way to be consumed like entertainment media. Both <em>The Onion</em> and <em>The Daily Show</em> expose the fallibility of mainstream news and the way it shapes cultural consciousness. Though shows like <em>The Daily Show </em>and <em>The Colbert Report </em>(2005–2014) <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/15405702.2012.638582"><em>‘</em>do take pot-shots at individuals’</a>, they also actually analyse and <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/15405702.2012.638582">‘dissect policy, breaking down the agenda behind political talking points, and pointing out where media coverage of a particular issue is lacking, often very clearly taking a position on the issue. More importantly, they imply that there can and should be <em>alternatives </em>to the problems they highlight, gesturing toward desired-for solutions rather than simple withdrawal’ </a>(page 180). <em>The Onion</em> and <em>The Daily Show</em> both offer themselves as more than parody and takes an active approach to the news of the day. This kind of parody is arguably a constructive approach to political commentary, and perhaps a better “alternative” way to consume news. However, it is important to note that contemporary parody shows often market themselves more to the liberal demographic as American shows, for example, take a firm anti-Trump and anti-conservative stance. Whilst they do go to lengths to justify their political beliefs, often spending time pointing out the issues of the Trump presidency as an example, this still could be read as a “biased”. However, is it possible to have a political show which does not have a bias?</p><p>One contemporary parody show which tries not to enter its own voice but, rather, lets the material speak for itself is the recent series <em>Who is America </em>(2018) by Sacha Baron Cohen. The series is a kind of mockumentary/skit show which effortlessly exposes the reality of the people Cohen interviews. Cohen takes on a character and makes his subjects feel comfortable, that they are with their “own kind”, only to expose them to the world. Cohen embodies four characters in the show: Billy Wayne Rudderick, a far-right pseudo journalist; Dr. Nira Cain-N’Degeocello, an extreme liberal looking to “heal the divide”; Rick Sherman, a British ex-convict and Col. Erran Morad, an Israeli anti-terror expert. Through these characters, Cohen interviews art collectors, DJ’s, the former Vice President Dick Cheney, Senator Bernie Sanders, amongst other U.S. politicians and lesser-known citizens. He uses these characters to lure his subjects into a false sense of security often to expose their prejudices or just to see how far he can push them. Whilst it is all in the name of comedy, some of his interviews and skits have been outright controversial and career ruining. For example, Jason Chauncey Spencer, former Republican to the Georgia House of Representatives, in episode two, yelled a range of racist and homophobic remarks which caused him to resign. Cohen even convinced, not with any difficulty, Dick Cheney to sign a “waterboarding kit”. However, although Spencer resigned from the House of Representatives, the most shocking aspect of the show is the lack of actual shock caused by such blatantly shameful acts. I am not the first to note that <a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/tv/tv-reviews/who-is-america-tv-review-698440/">‘Cohen’s playing Gotcha! with people who have already confessed to far worse, over and over again’.</a> In fact, Cohen often introduces his subjects by replaying segments from the news which displays why he has chosen to interview them. Before Spencer’s skit, we see several news clips about Spencer’s controversies and conservative views, including a bill to make covering one’s face (directed at Burqa’s) illegal.</p><p>See a clip here: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4k4pMTsa1Kw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4k4pMTsa1Kw</a></p><p>This then suggests why the Morad character is able to lure Spencer into believing that racist behaviour is socially acceptable. It also tells the audience that Spencer is likely to relay anti-Islamic sentiments similar to those already reported by the media. It is no shock, then, when he exposes the extent of his racism, and Cohen only has to say the word “Chinese” for Spencer to reel off racist remarks. This kind of expose happens throughout the show, yet, even though other interviewees are just as controversial as Spencer’s, we get the sense that no one is shocked anymore. In fact, the most shocking thing about the show is that no punitive action is likely to occur for interviewee’s who say and do offensive things. In one episode, the Morad character jokes to Gun Owners of America director Larry Pratt, that “It’s not rape if it’s your wife” and Pratt laughs heartily. <em>Rolling Stone</em> notes that:</p><p><a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/tv/tv-reviews/who-is-america-tv-review-698440/">‘Pratt won’t feel any repercussions for that, any more than any of Cohen’s other targets will, because everyone has already chosen sides and the people on their side won’t care. <em>Who Is America? </em>is Sacha Baron Cohen still playing by the rules of a world that made much more sense — and was much more conducive to this particular style of comedy — than the one of 2018’.</a></p><p>So, if the point of Cohen’s skits are not to shock, what is the point? It may simply be to point out that <a href="https://screenrant.com/america-review-sacha-baron-cohen-showtime/">‘you can’t shame a shameless person, and, from the look of it, that may be at the heart of what this series has sometimes humorously, but mostly dispiritingly uncovered’</a>. That people have ‘already chosen sides’ gets to the heart of media partisanship in the West, especially in America. Cohen’s series certainly makes this point as no matter what he exposes on his series, it has already been said and done and those on that side are unlikely to change their mind, even when slapped in the face with it. Although this offers no real solution, it does provide a kind of clear and blunt mirror to hold up to America. In a post-truth West, the series uses emotional impact to highlight truths. Whilst this emotion may not be shock at what is being said, but more the shamelessness of the speaker and their supporters, this may be one of the only ways to communicate any sense of real truth in a world of post-truth and fake news.</p><p>To conclude, what form of news conveyance actually gives the consumer any sense of truth? We know that mainstream news is dictated by the wealthy elites and that the very essence of what is reported in the news in the first place is dictated by such elites. Thus, the dawn of media partisanship and fake news; the era of believing what suits your own and your peers&#39; pre-existing prejudices and beliefs. Which news you consume, be it the <em>New York Times</em> or <em>Breitbart</em>, has everything to do with your sense of identity, your race, your class, where you live, your age, your politics, your beliefs and the beliefs of those around you. The news we consume becomes a social identifier, our sense of community, which causes media partisanship to become increasingly extreme. Fake news rises in times of tension as the need to prove our own believes, rather than prove facts, is linked to this sense of community in the spreading of such news. So, is parody and satire an alternative form of consuming news? Is it more truthful? Perhaps in high capitalism, the need to advertise and appeal to certain crowds will make it difficult to create a completely unbiased form of news. Parody and satire still need to sell to crowds in order for it to be successful, so in a sense, they still fall into the trap of the Propaganda Model. But, it is important that shows <em>like The Daily Show</em> try to actively approach the news and find solutions, whilst <em>Who is America</em> tries to show America its own prejudices and partisanship. <em>Who is America</em> also plays to a post-truth crowd who listen more to emotions than to facts, as it attempts to shock the viewers by holding up this mirror. Parody and satire may be an alternative to mainstream media, which, consumed with the knowledge that it is a parody and that it may be as biased as the mainstream news, can be a powerful tool for self-reflection.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82fcc461a1da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>