<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Mackenzie on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Kevin Mackenzie on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kmziekm1?source=rss-34aa424466ab------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:06:01 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kmziekm1/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Between Worlds: Navigating the Liminal Spaces of Immigration]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kmziekm1/between-worlds-navigating-the-liminal-spaces-of-immigration-f207203a7500?source=rss-34aa424466ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f207203a7500</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigartion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Mackenzie]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Apr 2025 20:36:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-18T18:57:19.297Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*txxCSqnEd2uwaFRzdSHpQA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction -</strong></p><p>Immigration isn’t a linear story. It’s a kaleidoscopic adventure into another world. A process and experience that defies a simple narrative. For this reason, I have chosen to share elements of my American immigration experience not as a seamless and coherent arc but as a series of fragmentary observations.</p><p>The deliberate use of the third person throughout much of this essay is not detachment but a chosen and perhaps necessary perspective. The immigrant experience requires a certain dual consciousness, an ability to observe oneself navigating unfamiliar terrain.</p><p>What follows are not chronological chapters but thematic explorations, each a lens through which to examine different dimensions of both America and becoming an American. Think of them as liminal field notes on discovery, sense, and identity making, where what you were meets what you are becoming.</p><p><strong>Immigration is hard to explain -</strong></p><p>The arc of the story is one of adventure. A consensual agreement with your former self to curate a new life and identity. It’s a bold bet taken with too little information. Its process pulls out of you new skills, insights, comprehensions, perceptions all while re-engineering your emotional, psychological and intellectual scaffolding. You become what you weren’t.</p><p>It’s a paradoxical process. A sudden and slow reset. A hard landing and a long taxi. A phase transition. An external integration and an internal reformation. An existential discovery. A process, task and informational re-engineering. It’s a sudden and emergent realization of how much change you need to navigate. A seismic rupture from what you know and understand. It shines an immediate spotlight on what you took for granted or ran on autopilot. You lived in a context-rich environment where small gestures and sayings captured whole concepts in a single utterance. You knew which brands to buy, commuting shortcuts, riding routes, morning routines, news outlets, school sports (that you understood), your Dr, dentist and physio, bike shop, how the seasons felt, social decorum, your primary and high school locations, sports teams, holiday locations, etc. Importantly, you had a Rolodex. A group of friends and associates that mutually lubricated, facilitated, and interacted in generative connect the dots ways. You also had cash flow. A work-to-revenue model primed over years of investing, working, and networking. Said differently, you had momentum.</p><p><strong>Inefficient, time heavy, and energy depleted -</strong></p><p>You arrive exhausted from the selling and packing process and drained from saying goodbye to people who have played an integral part in your life. You are hardly primed for what you are about to experience. New architecture, roads, accents, supermarkets, brands, people, food, routines, sports, TV stations, ways of being, etc., that while novel consume large amounts of energy. It’s a cold start (excuse the Chicago pun). You have a green card but no bank accounts, no vehicle, no credit, no cell phones, no affiliations, no friends and, importantly, no network. You have yourself and your family. All 3 of you are trying to orientate, adapt, and establish some reliable routines that offer familiarity, safety and a practical path to daily living. You get tripped up by the unfamiliar. Making beds, sweeping the floors, packing dishes, doing washing, folding clothes, dumping trash, scrubbing bathrooms, booking parking, pumping gas…. You’re inefficient, time heavy, and energy depleted. You have family scraps sourced from new causes. You’re figuring shite out. You slowly start to get a sense of direction, a feel for the rhythm of the city and its hidden order. You become less reliant on Google Maps, figure out where stuff is in the supermarket, what coffee you like, how to navigate school drop off and pick up congestion and how to sequence home chores.</p><p><strong>Becoming aware -</strong></p><p>The subtler stuff takes longer to notice. The ways of being, thinking, talking, socializing, and interfacing. I was immediately struck by the peculiarities of American language. English is very versatile. Just because you speak it doesn’t mean you speak American English, ahyite!</p><p>Novel word combinations abound, either bringing a smile to your face or befuddle your understanding. Slept hard, studied up, fix’n to, boondoggling (wasting time and energy on an unnecessary, inefficient, or unproductive project/activity), acclimating, gussied up (looking smart), kitty-corner (diagonally opposite) are good examples. You comprehend what is being said, but you would never have said it that way. You are reminded of your newness and that you haven’t swum in these waters. You need to concentrate just a little bit harder. I recall trying to explain to a waitress what a serviette was. Small losses in translation that just make you aware enough of your difference, your peculiarity, and that you lack American edges.</p><p>You start to realize that American culture is everywhere but nowhere. It’s in the architecture, streets grids, restaurant menus, Starbuck order combinations (Venti Green Tea Frappuccino with 12 scoops of matcha, soy milk, vanilla bean, skinny mocha, and no foam), food packaging, ad content, product positioning, school rituals and rules, sports, their teams and rivalries, TV commentary, nonstop pharmaceutical ads (where the side effects disclosures seem more dangerous than the disease being treated), driving decorum, fashion, shopping hours, meat cuts, the yellow school bus, political rhetoric, pre-game national anthems, slang, wearing slippers and carrying a Starbucks drink to school etc. It’s the stuff you can point to, photograph, or order off a menu.</p><p><strong>Noticing the invisible -</strong></p><p>It’s also curiously invisible. Maddingly intangible. A ghostly layer of mental models, assumptions, habits, and ways of talking that are so foundational that they hide in plain sight. A set of deeply engrained values and principles (liberty, freedom, and the pursuit of happiness) that inform autocued responses, language, and civil expectations. You notice it just enough to be aware of its existence, but you can’t quite describe it. It hides in language and the ideas it&#39;s expressing. Phrases like the “homeland”, over-served (it’s the barman’s fault that you are drunk), I’m good, game changer, living the dream, tough it out etc., hide discordant ideas that contradict and fight each other simultaneously — The ruggedized individual and the targeted victim. You are responsible for your successes but the system for your failures. Personal freedoms that deflect blame. An insistence on liberty and litigation. Starbucks customization as an expression of unfettered choice, masking or normalizing excess. The ritualized tendency to noise, activity, and achieving all while feeling anxious and depressed. Supersized portions and rising obesity. Freedom, success, and happiness coupled with overwork and debt. Your sense-making apparatus slowly starts to tune into more stations. Things become less opaque. You feel like you are starting to figure this out.</p><p><strong>Self-Sabotage -</strong></p><p>When you first arrive in the US, you feel like a guest. You don’t take your green card and the rights it bestows on you for granted. You make a big effort to fit in and keep your head below the parapet. You feel like an apprentice but without a boss. You appreciate the opportunity but less the discomfort of having to learn the American way. You feel like a taker of the status quo and less a maker. As an apprentice, you have no voice, but more importantly, you don’t have the right to one. You haven’t served your time. You’re under-assimilated and haven’t earned your stripes. The result is that you are more accepting and less assertive when that’s what’s required. You feel that pushing back carries too much risk. You don’t know enough, which directly impacts your self-perceived option set. This curtails the size of your thoughts and ambitions, allowing you to undermine your own agency. You are grateful for the few friends you have, your kid is in school, is playing in a team, and neighbours. This approach manifests in subtle ways — you accept vague teacher feedback, bad parent and player behavior at a sports game, criticism at work, being overlooked for work, not being greeted, teenage rudeness, and discourteous drivers. This results in low-grade anger and ever-present anxiety. A feeling of being under-tooled or having a knife at a gun fight. The options seem more binary than they actually are. Your inner voice explains that if you don’t like it here then leave. You decided to immigrate so suck it up. This happens until you finally realize it’s happening. You start to notice how your ‘guesthood” has fueled your fear and self-sabotaged your process. In the words of Mother Cabrini, you realize that “unless you are bold in America, you die”. This changes your mindset from defensive to offensive. You expect more from yourself, family, and community. You act with more conviction and with greater expectation.</p><p><strong>Lost in Transition -</strong></p><p>You start your process as a South African in America. Your decision requires another decision. How much of your SA mind do you retain? Do you follow the news, sports teams, political developments, and to what end? Doing so robs you of time spent getting to understand America. I felt I had to let it go. Square it off as a previous life. Remember South Africa as I had lived it. I also realized that by leaving it I had lost the right to criticize it. Our decision to immigrate was as much about its failings, our decision not to try and be part of the solution as it was wanting a life adventure. 5 years in, you are a South African American. Not sure what that is. You have citizenship and all the rights and obligations that go with it, but still talk, act, and engage like you used to. You have American friends, understand American history, have views on American politics, understand American sports (to some degree), but still feel alienized. You can’t talk about your college experience, are a fan but not a “die-hard fan” of a sports team, still walk to the wrong side of the car, feel emotional when watching the Springboks play, talk about cricket with immigrant Indians, and serve South African dishes at dinner parties. You’re a hydroid, an in-betweener! An in-process assimilation and American work-in-progress.</p><p><strong>Imperfection everywhere -</strong></p><p>When you live in a country for a while, you get to better understand its past, its current grievances, tensions, and contradictions. You also start to understand that a country never escapes its history. Like a shadow or echo that refuses to dissipate, it provides endless fuel and energy in the here and now. You also realize how ideas are infinitely transportable across time, nations, and cultures. One of the things that struck me about America was both the amount of internal grievance and the similarity to South African criticisms. An archetypical set of core problems and solution sets all couched in well-rehearsed language that just travel through time. A baton handed from one generation and country to the next. Perhaps it was simply the US political climate at the time, but a never-ending set of “complaints” propagated by media, activists, and civic organizations. Claims that America is systemically racist, misogynistic, homophobic, transphobic, unequal, non-inclusive, too capitalistic, corrupt, Islamophobic, monopolistic…. Its foundational nature deeply compromised, insufficiently reconciled, and made right. A set of conditions so grievous that all hands needed to be on the make this right deck. This not in the organic or evolutionary sense but in a fast-tracked, radical interventionist way. Failure to see this or fully agree with this casts you into the dim, intolerant, privileged, insensitive, and out-of-touch bucket. A cohort of Americans that needed to be changed and despised. This resulted in a low-grade tension just waiting to erupt. The spark that did it was George Floyd. I recall watching BLM riots, property destruction, looting, street battles, defunding police rallies, and an abandonment of civil behavior. I saw shop fronts getting boarded up, buildings set alight, and groups vandalizing properties. I started to see America’s dark underbelly and its ability to blame its failings on the very things that it had made it prosperous — individual freedoms, industriousness, personal agency, hard work, risk taking, and systems that coordinated and mediated daily interactions. I started to rehear all the South Africanisms but with a twist or American flavor — systemic racism, injustice, and inequality, racial bias, white privilege, and the need to actively reengineer the system. A constant focus on everything that is wrong with America. This perhaps neatly divided down Democrat-Republican lines and well supported by media outlets aligned to either side. A never-ending stream of us vs them, well packaged and honed in divisive rhetoric. The adversary was other Americans. An enemy within. Fellow citizens that needed to be despised and systemically changed and held to account. The external social tension firmly asked, “where do you personally sit” on these issues? How do you tacitly signal your alliance with the “right side”, take a stance, and adopt an externally scripted identity or not.</p><p><strong>Building a new identity -</strong></p><p>Identities are interesting things. They are internal mooring and external projection devices. They are the composite of your job title, marriage status, where you live, what university you went to, the people you hang out with, the schools your kids go to, and your reputation, to name a few. In South Africa, your identity has been built over years and is relatively well-established. You had a well-chiseled sense for who you were and what you did. When you arrive in the US, you possess only your endo-identity. Your exo-identity doesn’t exist outside of the fact that you are South African and an immigrant. A proxy and highly condensed version of who you are. Outside of that partially interesting fact no one gives a shite. You have walked into a narrative discontinuity or dislocation. There is no one who can vouch for your character, competencies, or past contributions. They exist in your memory and what you can explain within a CV, social media or LinkedIn page. Particularly hard hit, if not obliterated, are the social and professional elements of your identity. In my case, these were both cold starts made worse by the fact that we arrived just as COVID-19 was kicking off. Summoned to your basement office, you have almost zero interaction with the outside world. Your external identity-building process being restricted to your digital avatar and once again a one-step and well-curated proxy of who you are. A small immaterial vessel sending out a daily proof of life ping all while bobbing in a vast ocean of digital equivalents. You join online content groups to see and hear real faces and voices as much as to orientate and figure out how your thinking and style of being works in your new world. While an improvement, you are still one step removed from the “real America”. The one where you meet, talk, and, as an entrepreneur, start getting a sense of what problems might exist and how one might go about solving them. The process leaves you feeling alienated, hollowed out, and somewhat internally focused. Starved of external signal, how do you assimilate and find a way to build an integrated and robust American identity?</p><p>All while you are figuring this out, your internal identity is getting re-smelted. Isolation infused with situational unfamiliarity forces upon you an uncomfortable confrontation: Stripped back, who am I in most uncut form? How do you show up, what skills do you actually have, what do you really care for, how can you be useful, what self-delusions have you consumed, how do you deal with pressure, what’s your default coping mechanism, what are your next best steps, how do you know, and what unwavering anchoring or orientation process can you rely on and why. It’s like having root canal without an anesthetic. An unpleasant and unabating internal exploration of your character and its working parts. The answers emerge slowly and quietly. They whisper, which at the time is bloody inconvenient. The upside is that you start to construct an identity on your terms and from the inside out. A more deliberate process less inherited or shaped by externalities or life’s previous momentum. An emergent discovery of what really matters and a rejection of what you thought did. Your ego doesn’t enjoy the procedure. It feels disempowered by a process that wrestles back active control, de-positioning it to the role of spectator. What’s left is the authentic but not yet fully formed “you”.</p><p><strong>Finding your people -</strong></p><p>Building friendships is hard at the best of times. Finding your people in America is made harder by the way in which a large chunk of Americans engage the world. On the whole, Americans are friendly, courteous, and easily engageable. They are, however, not overly curious. Their ratio of questions received to questions asked is uncannily lopsided. I recall going to dinner with two baseball parents, and not once did they ask a bunch of rudimentary questions: how long have you been in the US, why did you come, how have you found the experience, how different is it to South Africa? I recall wondering if it was just disinterest or whether the thought of asking the questions just never entered their minds. I remain undecided. Another curious phenomenon is something referred to as Midwest nice. A puzzling polite interested disinterest. A transactional sincerity undertaken at a distance or with reserve. A tendency to small talk and avoidance of expressing strong opinions in casual interactions. An evasion to longer term interactions or deeper conversations. As a result, you establish a set of acquaintanceships but very few friendships. Perhaps it&#39;s insufficient common ground, a cultural preponderance, or that your personal interface is just off-putting or difficult to engage. You talk with an accent and just haven’t accumulated enough American cultural subtleties to notice the conversational cues or to engage in the conversational dance. Even worse, perhaps you are just not interesting enough. The friendships you do kindle matter. They are real connection points that affirm your slow integration and offer up a welcome reprieve from the do-it-aloneness. People to explore ideas with, share notes and experiences, introduce you to American pastimes, and explain the subtleties you are not quite getting. People that make you feel a little more connected to your new world.</p><p><strong>What America does well -</strong></p><p>America does lots of stuff well; that’s not to say it’s always right. First to mind are how well-honed rituals and celebrations are. From the Super Bowl to Thanksgiving, Presidential inaugurations to Fourth of July celebrations, little league to college football games. These pastimes, events, and ceremonies create cultural touchstones that transcend regional and political divides, offering moments of collective identity in a diverse nation. They are software that bind American culture. They are adorned by and propagated through national anthems, flags, regalia, speeches, food, and dress.</p><p>America does scale at scale well. Whether skyscrapers, stadiums, 6 lane freeways, ports, logistics, strip malls, food assortment, national parks, sports and entertainment complexes, consumer sales, parking garages, city management, government and bureaucracy, etc., it happens at XXL.</p><p>America does tertiary education well. There are approximately. 6000 colleges in the US, with the largest ones having enrolments that exceed 60,000 students. Colleges are deeply woven into the fabric of American society, serving as cultural touchstones, social network builders, and identity markers. There is a surprising weight placed on where someone went to college, what they studied, and the experiences they had there. “Where did you go to college?” is a front-loaded question in many initial conversations. Getting into colleges has spawned a massive ecosystem of consultants, counselors, test prep companies (estimated value of $4.5B), and a bunch of college guides spanning admissions, rankings, campus life, and higher education trends.</p><p>America has honed hero worship to a fine art. Past presidents, sportsmen and woman, musicians, actors and actresses, soldiers, civil rights champions, etc. exist in rare air. America is less about quiet competence and more about spectacular success, the perfect conditions for the hero to take on mythical status. At its core, the US runs on the idea that anyone can rise from nothing to greatness through hard work, dogged determination, and talent. Anyone who personifies this becomes the face of the rugged individual, the lone genius, the maverick, the athletic freak. Michael Jordan, Tom Brady, Steve Jobs, Drake, Babe Ruth, Martin Luther King Jr., Neil Armstrong, Oprah Winfrey, and Serena Williams are kings and queens lorded with qualities that the media magnifies and reinforces. I seem to think that hero worship is a coping mechanism, a giver of hope, and a cultural engine that fills a collective existential gap. It reminds Americans that the “system” still works.</p><p><strong>Advice to my immigrating self -</strong></p><p>What advice would I give my about to immigrate self?</p><p>Be bolder from day one. Take on your apprenticeship with more intention and expectation and be more deliberate in your actions. Be endlessly curious about everything you see and hear, asking why more often. Accept less and probe more. While the answers may not be forthcoming, the act of noticing starts the slow recasting of your mental models.</p><p>Enjoy the process despite its discomfort. Fear and anxiety have a way of robbing us of the present and small things that are worth noticing and celebrating. Be kinder to yourself and less critical of your rate of progress, momentum, and success. Journal every day. Find words to explain your day, how you spend your time, and how you feel about the process. Witness your new life in an honest, balanced, and grateful way.</p><p>Actively read about American history. Who were the founding fathers, what did they believe in, what concerns did they have, what principles guided their decision making, and why is the constitution what it is. This will moor you to the core of the American idea and help you orientate in a more foundational way. As an aside, it will get you to understand American axioms or postulates better than most Americans. It will help you make more sense of why America thinks and behaves like it does.</p><p>Travel outside your State as often as you can and preferably by car. Get a sense for the vastness of America, its busyness, sameness, and difference. Drive through the small towns and notice the architecture, churches, schools, cars, and people. Try and figure out what happens here, what daily life might be like, and what’s propelling the economic engine. It’s how you get to “feel” America in its rawest form.</p><p>Be more intentional about making friends. Friendships matter in the new world. They are connective tissue that bind you to the real American social body. Their stories, perspectives, and lived experiences dock you into real-world America and give you and your adventure a deeper sense of meaning. If you meet someone that you resonate with, reach out to them. Americans are, on the whole, too busy and have functioning friendship groups with a lower need than you to make new friends. The onus is on you.</p><p>Pick a team to support. Become a real fan. It not only teaches you about the sport but forces you to integrate into something deeply American. You become less of a passive spectator and more a connected citizen.</p><p>Trust your story, your views, and your principles more. The South African transformation is a case study in what and how national potential can be scalped through bad ideas, actors, and a willingness of the core populus to consume and adhere to the mimetically prescribed politically correct, socially astute, and personally less risky behavioral decorum, all facilitated through its well-crafted language. National prosperity is not a guarantee. Countries get eroded from the inside as much as from the changing outer macro conditions in which they co-exist and create. America is your new home and life. Be active, be heard, be courageous, be unpopular (if required), and be committed to what you think is true in an attempt to shape it in some tiny way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f207203a7500" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Valueball — Thoughts and lessons on what baseball can teach us about value.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kmziekm1/valueball-thoughts-and-lessons-on-what-baseball-can-teach-us-about-value-d5774b45e5b9?source=rss-34aa424466ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d5774b45e5b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[competitive-advantage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[value-creation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kevin Mackenzie]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Sep 2023 17:54:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-19T17:54:18.200Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Valueball — Thoughts and lessons on what baseball can teach us about value.</h3><h3>Baseball is an American institution and has been played since the mid 1800’s. Part sport, theatre and business it’s a trove for understanding value-based thinking in its eternal search for competitive advantage.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/1*qwXlTufXVLGp9ra7fvIIAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Graphic — Lorie Shaull</figcaption></figure><p>The concept of value is synonymous with business. In the one word value, we convey both long term intent &amp; daily action. Business’ continuously attempt to create, capture and extract value for customers and themselves. While the primacy of value is never questioned, asking a c-suite, functional, product or support team to detail what value they are solving for and how they go about it often offers up an array of fuzzy answers. Furthermore, the collective rationale, methods and outcomes are hard to coherently and simply account for. Value as a definable and demonstrable phenomena remains vague best understood as some kind of benefit. It seems to be wrapped up in their strategy, business model, customer journeys, need states, and product benefits. This raises the question how can businesses solve for outcomes they find hard to clearly define?</p><p>Like any business, professional baseball teams have to create, capture and extract value on a sustained basis. This as a requirement to keep the composite baseball offering competitive vis a via alternative entertainment offerings but also as teams within the industry. But what is this value, in what states does it exist, and how do teams and players manifest it? What are teams trying to solve for and what mechanisms are they most focused on? What specific business takeouts can we glean and port from a baseball teams thinking, processes, and desired outcomes?</p><p>In exploring these topics it’s noted that teams and players are but two of the game’s value creators. (This done for simplification). Also, unlike business, baseball as a game has clear physical bounds, terminating conditions, and defined rules. That said, baseball offers up some interesting business strategy insights and use-cases. Specifically, how do search for, identify, and execute on marginal advantages when all competitors:</p><p>1. Have access to the same asset performance data.</p><p>2. Have equal access to asset markets.</p><p>3. Comply with the same in-game, trade, salary cap, recruitment rules and roster limits.</p><p>4. Utilise identical or sufficiently similar front and back office functions and processes.</p><p>Advantages need to found within a fewer and constrained set of influenceable parameters. As a result, teams are battling for marginal strategy, skill and fit differences that in the composite provide some form of competitive edge.</p><p><strong>The gateway to value.</strong></p><p>An obvious but key factor is that baseball is a team game. Games are won and lost in and by the collective. That “third thing” that emerges from the sum total of many contributing interactions — individual player performance, strategy, umpire decisions, team dynamics, luck etc. There are many ways for teams to win. There is no one winning formula. Each team builds around it’s unique take on what skills if accumulated give them more formula options. Be that offensively or defensively driven, some approach that if consistently executed upon puts the team in a winning position more often. I call this their how to win theory. That unique to them logic coupled with how a combined set of in game skills will enable value.</p><p>At its simplest, a baseball franchise’ objective is to win as many games as possible. That said, winning isn’t the value. It’s an outcome that opens the portal to a bunch of value pools.</p><p>1. Ticket sales.</p><p>2. Merchandise sales.</p><p>3. Concession contributions.</p><p>4. Broadcast fees.</p><p>5. Trade values.</p><p>6. Fan loyalty.</p><p>7. Brand recognition.</p><p>8. Sponsorships.</p><p>9. Talent attraction and retention.</p><p>The more the team wins the greater the potential within in each pool. The economics of how each pool can be maximised is beyond the scope of this article. While each value pool is distinct it operates within a relational and self-reinforcing whole. Greater fan loyalty drives ticket and merchandise sales creating cash for talent acquisition etc.</p><p><strong>In search of advantage.</strong></p><p>Where might the potential for competitive advantages reside with the baseball? This article argues that outside of player skill, it emerges from how small differences in similar practices are perceived, valued and executed upon. These fall into four broad buckets:</p><p>1. The derivation and working logic of a winning formula. A unique-to-team approach that they believe maximizes run production and prevention.</p><p>2. Roster development and management — the ability to identify, acquire, ingest and grow players that best fit the requirements of the winning formula.</p><p>3. Enabling a generative team dynamic that gets the most out of each players abilities and for the benefit of the collective outcome.</p><p>4. On field strategy and gaming tactics that best adapt and respond to contextual and situational requirements.</p><p>Importantly, these constructs are not standalone but rather co-dependent inputs and co-creators of a dynamic and complex performance system. Change any one of the variables and you change the behaviour of the system and the outcomes its creates. Also having an advantage in one area may offer little composite advantage. This best illustrated by teams who have quantifiably stronger rosters being outperformed by teams with shallower rosters.</p><p>In this regard a team like the Tampa Bay Rays is an interesting case. How does a team with the third lowest salary budget remain competitive? How do they think about and practically integrate these buckets in ways that other teams don’t or can’t. What hidden or hard to understand practices enable their above weight class outcomes? What portable business lessons or at least principles can be gleaned?</p><p><strong>Team performance and the uniqueness imperative.</strong></p><p>Team performance in baseball is an intricate tapestry woven by the interplay of numerous factors — roster depth, player skills, personalities, umpire calls, expectations, decision making, coaching, motivation, batting order etc, Each player’s unique skills and attributes interact dynamically with the strategies employed by coaches, the chemistry among teammates, and the external factors influencing the game. The emergent nature of team performance reminds us that value cannot be solely attributed to individual players but requires an appreciation for how their behavioural interactions contribute to the success of the team as a whole. Factoring and working with this emergent dynamic is hard. Really hard!</p><p>In doing this, teams attempt to control or at least influence as much as they can. Most notably the composition of their how-to-win theory coupled with short and long term makeup of the player roster. Acquiring, developing and combining the best set of positional skills that potentially afford some kind of win rate advantage. This achieved by analysing and assessing a combination of qualitative and quantitative player performance metrics. Proxies they believe best explain and predict the value of a player and their ability to deliver or support their formula. This is part science and part art.</p><p>In business, exceptional returns are typically rewards for/on scarcity i.e. the ability for a business to find a match between what you are good at and available assets that competitors value less or cannot access. Firms create value when they obtain assets at a discount to their future deployed use (1). This presents three challenges:</p><p>1. Knowing what you are good at.</p><p>2. Discovering under-priced assets.</p><p>3. Figuring how to apply your uniqueness.</p><p>Teams enable value generation by identifying what they are uniquely good at, establishing a competitive theory (winning formula), discovering under-valued assets that fit their strengths and theory, and figure how to combine existing and new assets over time.</p><p><strong>Valuing, acquiring and developing skills.</strong></p><p>Individual player skills and their collective contribution are critical inputs into any winning formula. Players are the primary asset class. The process of developing a theory on what attributes best predict the “performance potential” of these assets is pivotal to long term win rates. Like any business, teams are looking to invest in assets that offer the highest ROI potential. Asset identification, selection, integration, development and dis-investment are thus key value enabling processes. Teams bring their unique-to-them view on what potential positional skills look like. This attested by the differing trade value teams assign to the same asset. Teams are looking for assets they believe that within their stable, emersed within their uniqueness, will perform as well or better than competitive alternatives.</p><p>Because of this, baseball has gone to great lengths to capture a swath of quantitative player and team stats over a long period of time. These include hits, strike outs, walks, home runs, runs earned etc. These measures give teams a useful retrospective and “relative to” view of how individual players have performed against a range of offensive and defensive markers.</p><p>These markers are the quantitative footprints of what a player has achieved, seems to be good at, if they are in form, what you can reasonably expect from them, and importantly what value they may offer and thus be worth to a team.</p><p><strong>Valuing player’s</strong></p><p>Value, as a concept, is often hard to define or describe. As a basis for understanding I argue that value is an experienced, net positive outcome, attributed worth. Logically this requires something distinct (a unique player), that can make or produce a difference (execute on some play) that will have some perceivable impact (e.g. scores more runs, gets more outs or reduces runs scored) within a certain context. (2). One could argue within baseball the net positive outcome is more wins experienced by the team i.e. the team is the recipient of the value.</p><p>How might this generic frame be particularized for baseball? The field of Sabermetrics has continued to grapple with this challenge, refining and combining available simple counting statistics into varying “uber algorithms” that attempt to predict a players value-to-desired outcome ratio, in ever finer levels of detail.</p><p>Baseball has given lots of thought to how wining formulas can be gleaned from identifiable skill types and combinations. Said differently, if winning is delivered through maximizing run production and prevention, what elements of the game if optimized via specified skills will increase your win-loss ratio.</p><p>In order to explore player value we need a baseline value definition to anchor our thinking. One potential player value definition:</p><p><em>A player’s value is his contributions to his team based upon his on-field performance (hitting, running, fielding and pitching) in a neutral context. A player’s value is essentially an average team’s runs or wins with that player, minus their runs or wins without that player (3).</em></p><p>The value definition tries to square off how some <em>distinct</em> player makes an<em> impactful </em>and quantifiable <em>difference</em> to a desired outcome. In so doing, baseball recognizes four important things:</p><p>1. It’s what the player produces that’s valuable.</p><p>2. What’s being valued needs to be specified.</p><p>3. How you contribute to the wins needs to be quantified.</p><p>4. Player value needs to be anchored in a clear collective outcome.</p><p>Sabermetrics manages these subtleties by introducing an “above replacement” idea. This thinking proposes that a distinct player must be quantifiably better than the next best alternative. This captured in a family of differing metrics including — Wins Above Replacement (WAR), Value Over Replacement Player (VORP), Runs Above Replacement (RAR). Each measures something different using the same core idea delivered via a single number.</p><p>Exploring their detailed formula, statistical and predictive logic is beyond the scope of this article. That said, if winning is the desired outcome, they all attempt to predict how specified player contributions, either directly or indirectly, deliver on this objective. What’s important is that they are underpinned by some foundational and coherent value logic.</p><p>The word replacement represents a hypothetical next best same position player that the team could utilize. A player with a WAR of 4 suggests that he produces 4 more wins than his next best replacement. RAR measures how a distinct player produces and prevents runs being scored, this as a proxy for wins. This a combination of hits, base advances and runs prevented in the field. This allows trade-offs between offensive and defensive skill combinations to be made. A great hitter that doesn’t steal bases and/or who is defensively weak could be valued less that a great baserunner and run preventing fielder.</p><p><strong>Potential value observations and takeouts</strong></p><p>What generalizable value lessons, insights and principles can be extracted from these practices?</p><p>1. Marginal Value:</p><p>A players value is measured in net-positive impact or what marginal difference a distinct players offers. In commercial terms, how a specific asset doing a particularized job contributes to an outcome that another asset or combination cannot. This incorporates how this asset, within your business model, is more valuable within your value creation and capture theory.</p><p>2. Value Trade-Offs:</p><p>Baseball value metrics illustrate the inherent trade-offs between different player skills. Teams need to be clear as to what drives these trade-off decisions. If you cannot afford a top rate hitter how else can you produce/prevent runs? What does their how-to-win theory require and what assets are they best at developing. This is particularly important when the industries dominant logic values certain asset types higher than others. Trade-offs need to always be mediated by their effect on the collective outcome.</p><p>3. Contextual Factors:</p><p>Baseball value metrics acknowledge that performance should be evaluated in light of contextual factors, such as park effects, league strength, positional scarcity and the state of the game when the stat creating event occurs. This in recognition that value is always context sensitive. The same product experienced within a different context will elicit differing value attributions. Teams need to square off both what a specific player is good at but also when he best at it. This lies at the heart of value proposition design. Customer needs are always activity centric. Figuring out which activity settings make your offering most needed, useful and why are often nuanced calls. This is particularly hard to incorporate into quantitative numbers and current statistical approaches used within baseball. They tell you what happened (a player got to base) but less how they did it.</p><p>4. Player development</p><p>Value emerges when teams get more out of a combination of players than competitors can. The marginal or above neutral performance gain is grounded in firstly discovering and recognizing unique-to-the-team potential and secondly coaching, leading and developing players using unique-to-the-team skills. This affirms how value creation emerges through unique actions curated by a how-to-win theory. Change the theory and/or the development approach and asset performance changes. More subtly, asset utility and financial value is always mediated by and in service of your how-to-win theory.</p><p>5. Refining and interpreting what you measure.</p><p>Baseball value metrics undergo constant refinement, incorporating new data sources, advanced statistical techniques, and evolving methodologies. This commitment to continuous improvement ensures that value assessments remain both relevant and reliable. The downside is that all teams have access to the same data. Advantage can only be gleaned from the theory you apply and the qualitative overlays you use to interpret the data with. This as distinct to mining incumbent rationale and data in greater detail. Contrarian or novel beliefs inform and highlight a new or previously unexplored set of observations. Data is neutral. Its value is in the questions our theory asks of it.</p><p><strong>Principles and lessons to be gleaned.</strong></p><p>The rule based nature of the game coupled with a freely traded and well quantified asset market has forced teams to find increasingly nuanced insights into how advantage can be gained. How do distinct asset combinations, following or attempting to execute on a theorized how-to-win formula, win more games than their competitors. This makes for interesting value theory, strategy, investment and asset development insights.</p><p>Teams have had to develop a clear sense for what they deem as valuable and find increasingly nuanced ways to notice and deliver on small advantages. Most importantly, they have to have a specified and particularized theory on what they are uniquely good at and how they wish to play or approach the game.</p><p><strong>A list of potential business lessons include:</strong></p><p>1. Develop a clear and unique to you how-to-win-theory. Your best imagined and logically coherent explanation and prediction for why a certain set of assets and actions within a given context will produce some advantage. Your theory will guide your strategy and its asset accumulation and configuration.</p><p>2. Value is always created and solved for in the collective. It’s the “whole” product that wins and not specific discrete features and functions — Pricing, positioning, quality, channel, packaging, service, and support in the composite shape your competitive potential.</p><p>3. Make your value outcomes explicit. Both what you want the customer to experience and how your asset configurations produce the effect. The more specified and particularized the better. You can’t easily solve for what you can’t define or describe in a pragmatic way.</p><p>4. Make the parameters of the market order you wish to compete in clear. What are the implied rules, constraints and dominant practices and what affordances do they give you access to? In highly competitive markets common functions operated more effectively or differently offer a string of marginal advantages.</p><p>5. Value typically emerges as a second order effect. What does winning look like for your company and what value pools does that offer you?</p><p>6. Environments are never passive. Different settings, skill development approaches, &amp; team dynamics have a direct impact on discrete asset performance.</p><p>7. What are you uniquely good at. Why will a certain set of openly available assets be more valuable under your custodianship than that of competitors?</p><p>8. Particularize the expectations you have of specific assets types and the attributes they need to possess. This allows you to spot value potential where other don’t.</p><p>9. What new beliefs and hypothesis can you bring to existing industry logic, data and stats that will allow you to see things that competitors don’t? When all competitors have access to the same data it’s the questions you ask of it that offer up potential for novel insights.</p><p>10. Asset combinations are always imbued with some performance trade-off. Make them clear.</p><p>Interpret and apply these lessons as principles or frames for thinking.</p><p>References:</p><p>(1) Beyond Competitive Advantage, Todd Zenger, Chapter 2</p><p>(2) An adaption of Malcolm Ryder’s original semantic definition of value</p><p>(3) The Hardball Times; How to measure a player’s value (Part 1 and Part 2), by Colin Wyers; Jan 2009</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d5774b45e5b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>