<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Keshav Parwal on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Keshav Parwal on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kparwal260?source=rss-f74d85abe6c9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 04:33:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kparwal260/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Progressive, Liberal Case Against UBI]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kparwal260/the-progressive-liberal-case-against-ubi-51a022690622?source=rss-f74d85abe6c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51a022690622</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universal-basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Keshav Parwal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Aug 2018 14:21:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-15T14:21:54.442Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/867/0*WUxC-kE0XplUU1cI" /><figcaption>Free money isn’t free</figcaption></figure><p>There’s been a lot of talk about the virtues of a European style of socialism and its ability to affect change for the poorest in society. A fringe few have even proposed a Universal Basic Income, a no-strings-attached government payout for simply being a citizen (a few even say it should be available for everyone, citizenship notwithstanding).</p><p>They run into an opposition they cannot fathom — an older generation that remembers the Red Scare and the horrors of communism. And the younger generation, a generation I am part of, would do well to listen. Even if the criticisms aren’t entirely applicable, it would be unwise to not listen at all.</p><p>As a young, liberal, progressive, child of immigrants, Indian-American person, I’ll try to reason out my stance against such measures, and I will also try to propose a possible alternative solution.</p><p>Let’s talk about UBI, Universal Basic Income.</p><p>Every legally recognized resident of the country, under the mainstream version of the plan, will receive a cash stipend each month, like a salary, from the central government. Simple and to the point, literally handing people money should stop the cycle of poverty. A smaller workforce who actually wants to be working would be accompanied with a rise in wages. Those who were working only for the money would simply drop out of the workforce. Right?</p><h3>Targeting</h3><p>The first problem with UBI is the lack of targeting. I grew up mostly lower middle-class, so I have no personal understanding of the welfare system. I cannot speak to the struggles of millions of Americans attempting to make ends meet, and running into walls because of the bloated welfare system. It is a seductive idea, simply scrapping all welfare for the sake of UBI.</p><p>But the central thesis of UBI is to give <em>everyone</em> the same cash handout. An elderly veteran pensioner receives and requires more benefits than I do. But under the UBI plan, we’d receive the same benefits. As would Bill Gates. From this standpoint, UBI feels reactionary — welfare isn’t “working”, so let’s scrap it for something simple. At best, it is an academic exercise and an experiment worth testing. At worst, it is demagoguery, pure and simple.</p><p>The current welfare system is plagued with problems that are too complex to fully go into here. I freely admit that. But for many, it also works. Nothing in reality is 100% effective. I don’t believe the current welfare is anywhere <em>near</em> an acceptable level of effectiveness, but it will also never be 100%. UBI will score even lower.</p><p>Welfare spends much of its bureaucratic overhead in targeting. And inefficient targeting creates secondary problems, like the “cliff”, a disincentive to work when at a certain income level when welfare suddenly vanishes. But that targeting is wildly important to the members of society who need it most — the elderly, veterans, the chronically infirm, the poor, and the oppressed. These groups would see a <em>lessening</em> in benefits and government outreach.</p><h3>Funding</h3><p>For now, I’ve been assuming that UBI would be funded through the wholesale cancellation of government welfare programs. This creates the massive targeting problem. The welfare infrastructure is a necessity, for now.</p><p>But what about other funding methods? Two come to mind. I’m going to admittedly ignore the numbers here, and just talk about the methods as if they would work out on paper.</p><p>The government could simply print new money. This is not unprecedented; rather, it is often times standard operating procedure. I defer to Greenspan on this one. Obviously, printing more money would simply increase inflation by an equal amount, rendering the population in the same boat as before, except wages haven’t had the time to rise to the occasion.</p><p>Cutbacks on costly foreign wars are a good start, but they are unlikely to improve the situation either. Downsizing the military is not only incredibly unpopular, but like it or not, America has held its supreme position in post-war world affairs because of this outsized and effective military. I’m all for <em>streamlining</em> the military, absolutely. But it alone could not fund UBI. A cutback on Navy operations would give pirates (yes, they are still a thing and are actually very dangerous) a bigger window to siphon off vital shipping lanes. Cutbacks on Army operations would result in a destabilization in many areas that would do the same thing. Prior, unwise decisions have forced our hand in this matter. It isn’t viable to simply “pull the troops home” en masse.</p><p>A tax on the superrich, the top .1% of the population income distribution, could fund the scheme. But these people have been shown to be a very wily lot, and they have many foreign holdings that represent a good portion of their net worth. Furthermore, the vast majority of their wealth is illiquid, so it would be an arms race (as it is today anyway) to figure out how to tax them. The problem is doubly hard with corporations, who can outlast governments in the waiting game. The largest corporations, infamous for finagling their way into incredibly low tax bills, can simply keep their cash in foreign states, waiting to repatriate it when tax conditions are more favorable.</p><p>That doesn’t mean we should not tax them — if anything, I’ll end this piece on the necessity for a tax overhaul. But taxing the wealthy and giving to the poor might still not work in terms of UBI. The core tenet of UBI is not nationalized, state-run health and wellness enterprises. It is providing the ability for citizens to pay their own way in the quagmire of private enterprises, and the money eventually would funnel its way back to the very same superrich stakeholders in the massive corporations.</p><h3>Government</h3><p>But let’s say we fund it. And we have not encountered the adverse targeting effects. We have managed, in an age of complete mistrust in the government, to give the government an ultimate, terrifying power. Where progressives decry the failure of government, we have responded with more government, rather than more <em>effective </em>government.</p><p>For UBI to work in any traditional sense, the government would first have to be able to track the actions of <em>every</em> single recipient. This government would wield a terrible power over it’s citizens.</p><p>Demagogues would fly in and out of public office with the promises of increasing the UBI, and either failing to do so or causing disastrous side effects in the process. The UBI of the US would resemble the grain-dole of the Late Roman Republic, a grim comparison.</p><p>Once we are dependent on UBI, the government would have a simple lever with which to control masses of the population — do what we want, or your money is gone. We already live in an era of effective mass surveillance. The leap, in theory, is not impossible. Difficult, sure. But not impossible.</p><p>These scenarios are hyperbolic, of course. But the citizens of the United States have a fairly lackadaisical attitude towards the dangers of a strengthening central government. Mistrust in the government hasn’t materialized into mistrust of government. There aren’t that many reasons that a totalitarian cannot start slowly ebbing away at checks and balances, just like what is happening in Turkey. A progressive strongman is just as dangerous as a conservative one. And one promising UBI is one to watch out for.</p><p>Solzhenitsyn’s <em>One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich</em> is one such warning. Don’t let it happen. It is not about a fictitious state like<em> 1984 </em>or <em>Brave New World. </em>It should horrify the reader because it is <strong>real.</strong></p><h3>Alternatives</h3><p>There are grave social problems in America. But I am confident that we can solve these problems. Slowly, to be sure. There is no such thing as a free lunch. But they can be solved. And new ones will crop up to take their place. Such is the nature of progress.</p><p>It would be ill-advised to compare the US with the often worshiped Northern European States. They are different countries. The culture is different. The history is different. The economy is different. They are smaller and more homogeneous. But that doesn’t mean we can’t learn from them.</p><p>A tax overhaul that helps to reduce inequity would be a great start. Streamlining the military, working down the disastrously large debt that eats up the budget with interest payments, and working to fix welfare are admirable, achievable, and important goals. Oppression and social inequity still ruin the lives of many in this country, and those should be eradicated as soon as possible.</p><p>But it is unlikely, with the past decisions made, that this is going to be an overnight process. The economic miracle of this age is one that is different — it will automate the jobs that have held this country steady for most of its history. As such, the education system is in an embarassing state of disrepair, and students emerge unready for the new direction of the economy. It will take decades to work down the federal debt. The military cannot scale back operations that quickly — the world is a tinderbox because of the past actions of large states, and right now there is not a lot holding it back, aside from the military presences of the developed, democratic world. And as expensive as long deployments and wars are, they don’t come close to the cost and devastation of full-scale global war.</p><p>Progressives must fight for social equality. Nothing less than total equality is acceptable. But they must also listen to other sources, including the past. A government over-empowered by well-intentioned progressives and revolutionaries is reminiscent of too many failed states of the past. We cannot let it happen again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51a022690622" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Best Anime to Watch if you Hate Anime]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kparwal260/the-best-anime-to-watch-if-you-hate-anime-bb546edb1f62?source=rss-f74d85abe6c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb546edb1f62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lists]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[recommendations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listicles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anime]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Keshav Parwal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Jun 2018 04:33:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-28T04:33:15.407Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*4nMCQknuG1TvIos3" /><figcaption>Your friends caught you watching anime, and now they hate you</figcaption></figure><p>I used to be an anime-hater. An anime-hater isn’t someone who hasn’t watched any anime, or doesn’t really have any interest in the medium — it’s for people who <em>actively </em>hate it, people who make anime fans “stay in the weeb-closet”, like I did for a number of years.</p><p>This list also doubles for older fans who have been left behind in the wake of the breakneck pace of the new anime medium, which was once a slow trickle of cult shows that would rarely get official dubbings. This list doesn’t have any high schoolers, memes, or seasonal “trash genre” shows (trash, once derogatory, has now more or less become it’s own strange genre).</p><p>This list is by no means definitive either — add your suggestions in the comments. This list is also 100% biased, obviously. I didn’t add anything I’ve not watched, and I clearly have a tendency to darker, grittier shows.</p><p>There are obviously some things missing as well. I’m not considering shows written for non-adults here, nor anything I’ve just never seen and can’t recommend in good faith, no matter how stellar the reviews (e.g. Grave of the Fireflies).</p><p>The order I’ve put them in isn’t a ranking, but instead a recommended watch order, from easiest to most difficult.</p><h3>1. Cowboy Bebop</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2GJADLBE7mI6bhK4.jpeg" /><figcaption>The motley crew of the <em>Bebop</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote>The bounty hunters, who are gathering in the spaceship “BEBOP”, will play freely without fear of risky things. They must create new dreams and films by breaking traditional styles. The work, which becomes a new genre itself, will be called… COWBOY BEBOP</blockquote><p>Yeah, yeah, everyone was expecting this one. But its 26-episode run is a legendary work of genius by Shinichiro Watanabe, and it rightfully takes it’s comfortable place at number 1 in this list.</p><p>A series of loosely connected episodes features a set of bounty hunters in the future of 2071 (as imagined when the series was created, so cut it some slack there). The solar system has been colonized, and space travel is commonplace. Each of the four characters is unique and interesting, with often competing personalities and overlapping themes. They struggle to deal with their respective pasts, and eventually they all must confront who they are (or aren’t), and the people that they’ve left behind.</p><p>Jet, a former police officer who grew disillusioned with his role in the world, set off to be a bounty hunter with his ship the eponymous<em> Bebop</em>. Faye, who seems like everything wrong with anime at first (fan-service male bait, to be exact) actually inverts the trope — she’s doing it on purpose, and it’s part of her character, which is by far the most nuanced in the show. Ed, the lunatic hacker who’s actually the only Earthling in the gang. And the main character, Spike Spiegel, an impossibly but subtly cool bounty hunter with a dark, sad past.</p><p>Cowboy Bebop starts off with action and a healthy dollop of goofiness, but make no mistake — this show deeply explores ennui, loneliness, despair, greed, and redemption in its characters. And like improvised jazz, upon which much of the show’s soul is based, the characters come together seemingly randomly, and don’t quite fit, but in the end they create a beautiful work of art, with the one of the most iconic endings in all of anime.</p><p>Combining deeply soulful jazz music, jaw dropping action and animation, and witty, succinct, but revealing writing all the same, Cowboy Bebop also nails all of its technical categories as well. Also, it’s got cool spaceships and fun action scenes. It’s considered the best English language dub <em>ever</em>, with most people rating the English version as <em>better </em>than the original Japanese, a feat which is exceedingly rare.</p><p>Also, while it flopped in Japan, it enjoyed the <em>longest</em> run on Toonami of <em>any</em> show, with only 26 episodes. I could go on and on — but you should just watch it. Also, the opening theme song is downright <em>awesome</em>.</p><h3>2. Monster</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wlJdy9fZCPmNZW8T.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>Tell me, what do you think is the ultimate fear? I really thought I’d already reached the darkest of the dark, but then, ahead of me, I beheld a darkness even greater still.</blockquote><p>Dr. Kenzo Tenma is a brilliant neurosurgeon in West Germany, pulling even the most extreme cases from the brink. He has everything — a beautiful fiancee (who is the daughter of the hospital director), a career on the rise, and a fulfilling job that he loves. As you’d expect by now, this doesn’t last very long.</p><p>One night, two patients needing brain surgery come in. One is a child, a young boy who’s parent’s were brutally murdered in a robbery, with a bullet wound in the head. The other is the mayor of the town. Tenma makes what he feels is the right choice, and he performs surgery on the child. He leaves the mayor, who came in slightly after the child, to other surgeons, but the mayor dies on the table. The child is saved by Tenma’s skilled hand, however.</p><p>The upper management is furious, blaming Tenma for the death of the mayor. His fiancee dumps him in dramatic fashion, and he is told his career is going nowhere. The director and his cronies begin to push Tenma out, who contemplates leaving Germany altogether.</p><p>Then, suddenly, the director and his cronies are found dead. The boy Tenma saved, along with his traumatized twin sister, go missing.</p><p>Nine years later, Tenma is the Chief of Surgery. Things are going well again, but the killings start again. And Tenma, as innocent as he is, is the only one to directly benefit from the crimes. And so he begins his quest to find the real killer, the little boy whose life he saved all those years ago.</p><p>Monster is a slow, dark, and downright creepy look at what happens when pure good meets pure evil, and how a twisted childhood can raise a heartless killer. Johan Liebert, the antagonist, is probably the most unsettling, hair-raising villain in the medium. This show isn’t for the impatient, or the faint of heart, but it is of the highest quality, and should be watched immediately. Warning, it’s long, clocking in at over seventy episodes, but it is worth it.</p><h3>3. Ghost in the Shell</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*IHOLdhHLctUCQFbC.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>Chief Nakamura: Nonsense! There’s no proof at all that you are a living, thinking life form!</blockquote><blockquote>Puppet Master: And can you offer me proof of your existence? How can you, when neither modern science nor philosophy can explain what life is?</blockquote><p>Originally a manga (Japanese comic) by Masamune Shirow from 1989, Ghost in the Shell (sometimes referred to as GitS) is a media franchise, and an icon of 90’s anime in general. The movie that followed the manga, <em>Ghost in the Shell</em>, is generally considered a critical success and a cult classic. It received overwhelming praise from critics, and the Wachowski brothers openly admit it as the direct inspiration for <em>The Matrix. </em>James Cameron also cites it as an inspiration for <em>Avatar</em>, which has a similar premise.</p><p>But don’t feel bad if you’ve never heard of it outside of that one Scarlett Johansson live-action remake — outside of the older anime circles, it’s widely unknown in the West. That’s the last I’ll mention of the live-action reboot — I haven’t een it, but it got a rather tepid reaction, so I’ll leave it be for now. What follows is a synopsis of the original 1995 movie.</p><p>Yeah, I am fibbing a little here, as it’s not <em>technically </em>a show, but a movie. Its spin-off shows are good too, so I’ll let it slide.</p><p>The year is 2029. Moore’s law remains unbroken, and humanity is on the verge of a Kurzweilian singularity. Cyberization — the practice of voluntarily replacing parts of yourself with advanced prosthetics — has offered humanity a leap forward. Now, even brains have become cyberbrains, electronic facsimiles of the natural human brain. The Internet is now inside our heads. Humans have enjoyed the advances in technology, but something is gravely wrong.</p><p>Motoko Kusanagi, working under the newly formed Section 9 of Public Safety, takes on the case of the mysterious “Puppet Master”, a hacker that commits crimes by hacking into the cyberbrains of others. Herself a master hacker, she and her team work to track down this hacker, and encounter questions about themselves and their own existence along the way. She’s joined by Batou, an old military comrade who provides even more muscle to the super-strong cyborg, and Togusa, an ex-cop who is one of the few remaining totally organic humans. He provides a different, traditional perspective, and in a world of uber-cool cyborgs, hit-men, and super soldiers, he’s just a family man with an old revolver.</p><p><em>Ghost in the Shell </em>is a deeply thought-provoking work that asks what the real definition of life is, and what constitutes a living being. It ponders the nature of existence, and in an age where the Internet was just starting to blossom, asks audiences to consider what the wider ramifications of interconnectedness really are.</p><p>Also, while it probably didn’t invent cyberpunk, it, along with the original <em>TRON</em>, made cyberpunk into what it is today. It’s not afraid to confuse you either — it requires your full attention, and it won’t slow down for you. It freely mixes politics, philosophy, technology, and other themes without hesitation.</p><p>The movie spawned multiple series, including the two Stand Alone Complex shows and the Arise reboots. They play fast and loose with self-consistency (read: don’t expect consistent backstories, or even consistent characters across series), but they’re all high quality for the most part.</p><h3>4. Neon Genesis Evangelion</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*x1B_1UQJHmormquM.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>“Man fears the darkness, and so he scrapes away at the edges of it with fire. He creates life by diminishing the Darkness.”</blockquote><blockquote>— <strong>Rei Ayanami</strong></blockquote><blockquote>“Evangelion is my life, and I have put everything I know into this work. This is my entire life. My life itself.”</blockquote><blockquote>— <strong>Hideaki Anno, The Director</strong></blockquote><p>Neon Genesis Evangelion (usually NGE or Evangelion, or sometimes just “Eva”) is widely considered the “final boss” of anime. It’s darker than Monster, more confusing than Ghost in the Shell, and more nuanced than Cowboy Bebop. It requires an understanding of the tropes of mecha (read: giant robots) as well as the story of the director itself.</p><p>This story takes place in the future (I’m beginning to notice a trend…), but honestly, that hardly matters. The actual content of the first six or seven episodes are actually a fairly normal show, with the standard tropes of any giant robot anime. That’s what it was supposed to be.</p><p>Hideaki Anno descended into a deep depression (among other mental illnesses, but he’s okay now) throughout the production of the original 26 episodes. What was supposed to be a normal action show (albeit <em>still</em> definitely not appropriate for kids to watch), transformed into something else. It became a case study in depression and psychosis, and not in a subtle manner like <em>BoJack Horseman</em>, but in a raw, brutal fashion that really doesn’t pull its punches.</p><p>The lore is confusing as hell, and that’s intentional. You’re as helpless as Shinji Ikari (the main character), trying to understand his confusing, terrifying world over which he has no control. You see him crumple under life-altering trauma that most other fictional characters just sort of shrug off, as if the author didn’t want to deal with it.</p><p>The characters all slowly crumble under the weight of their responsibility, and a conspiracy from within humanity’s highest echelons threatens to torpedo their efforts. All the while, terrifying, mind-bending aliens called “angels” (get ready for some pseudo-kabbalah-mysticism in this one) attack the already devastated Earth one by one. All the while, Gendo Ikari, Shinji’s estranged father, watches heartlessly as his son screams out in agony and fear while fighting the terrifying monsters.</p><p>And we haven’t even talked about the robots themselves. They’re a whole other can of worms that require a lot of spoilers to talk about, so I won’t.</p><p>The infamous final two episodes are a jumbled, borderline psychotic mess, a result of the complete breakdown of the director and the money for the show drying up. Afterwards, as the money poured in, <em>End of Evangelion </em>was produced, two feature length animations that provide what the actual end of the show was supposed to be. And it’s not for the faint of heart.</p><p>This show is also hard because it embraces the tropes that make anime-haters hate anime, but keep watching — it turns those tropes on their head, makes them look sad and ridiculous, and generally messes with your head. It knows what it’s doing. Probably.</p><p>There’s a reboot series of movies, which are a bit brighter in tone and a bit easier to understand, made years after the original. The story is somewhat different as well.</p><p>On the bright side, the opening theme song is <em>really </em>catchy.</p><p>There are plenty of other shows that belong on this list, and calling Cowboy Bebop <em>easy</em> is questionable at best — it’s just the “easiest” of this list for people who normally would never watch anime. It’s much more nuanced and dense than the average show.</p><p>But there are shows that you should watch that didn’t quite fit the criteria of this list (avoids anime stereotypes, written for an adult audience).</p><h3>Honorable Mentions</h3><ol><li><strong>Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood</strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V7ze5pm1-v_nRx3C.jpg" /></figure><p>This is actually a fantastic show, that only missed the list because of the criteria I set out at the beginning. Widely considered the “gateway drug” of anime, it’s appeal is universal. Bright and colorful characters in a diverse and fascinating world, with a thick but easy to follow plot. Also, along with Cowboy Bebop, it’s widely considered to be the other “good” dub, worth watching in English dubbing rather than subtitled. Also it has amazing opening songs, second only to the legendary Cowboy Bebop and Evangelion openings.</p><p>Sure, there’s politics, full-blown magic masquerading as pseudo-science, heartwrenching tragedies, and ancient evils and prophecies, but the show hinges on the axis of two brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric. I won’t say any more here, because this one should just be enjoyed without any other preconception. It has a confusing first episode, but it clears up after that.</p><p>The animation is stunning, the writing is a case-study for concise, neat, but still emotionally sound and connected story crafting, but the music is what seals the deal. Yes, it’s got its goofy (and sometimes a bit cringy) anime comedy moments, and yes, it was actually meant for people under the age of 18, but <em>please </em>don’t let it’s exclusion from the list above discourage you from watching it. It’s a true masterpiece of the medium, usually considered the overall best anime out there, and one of my personal favorites.</p><p>Just steer clear of the Netflix live-action movie, and remember that Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is actually the faithful manga adaptation. There was a series before it, just Fullmetal Alchemist, that halfway through begins to take some controversial liberties with the story.</p><p><strong>2. Death Note</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/0*0YlUmYIgG7OBXAIS.jpg" /></figure><p>A teenage genius, Light Yagami (cough symbolism cough), gets a hold of a notebook, a special notebook called the “Death Note”, once owned by a shinigami (Japanese Death God). Whoever’s name he writes in the book dies.</p><p>So, naturally, he loses his goddamn mind and begins cleansing the world. But he’s got to deal with an equally smart investigator, hell-bent on finding him out.</p><p>Cue the most intense game of cat and mouse since <em>Monster</em>. It’s a bit less serious than Monster, but it also takes the time to pose deep questions about morality and crime in general. In a really twisted way, what Light Yagami does isn’t a <em>bad </em>thing. But his descent into madness alongside his investigator’s unscrupulous techniques create a gray zone between the light and dark.</p><p>A thrilling watch, it does suffer from some less than perfect writing near the later parts of the show and has some tropes that bar it admission from the above list, but it is otherwise an intelligent, deep, and thrilling tour de force that is worth a watch by anyone.</p><p>Again, don’t watch the live-action movie on Netflix.</p><p><strong>3. Baccano!</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EJ-AvrCqvbEVdx8n.jpg" /></figure><p>A vastly underrated gem in anime, Baccano! is an impossible to define story with no definitive main character. It’s non-linear, and it starts off very confusing. But I promise, it’ll all make sense in the end.</p><p>A rare anime set in the good old US of A in the 1920s and 30s, it mostly takes place aboard a train, the Flying Pussyfoot, filled with colorful, vaudevillian characters, each on the train for a different reason. Then, people start dying, and things get interesting. The story jumps around to different arcs, but they are all strangely connected.</p><p>It’s goofy, raunchy, funny, but also very dark and gory, so definitely not meant for the faint of heart, but it is a very tightly-written tale that happens to nobody in particular, but to everyone all at once. It revels in great musical taste, stunning animation and action, and fascinating characters. It’s also got a jazzy opening to rival Bebop and Brotherhood, and is definitely deserving your attention, even though it didn’t quite fit the criteria of this list.</p><p>In the end, I can’t make you not hate anime. I can’t also stop the ever-increasing tidal wave of anime that reinforce the stereotypes of the genre as hopelessly weird, foreign, needlessly hyper-sexualized, and worst of all, childish. But I hope that you at least give a few of these an honest shot. Find some private time if you’re embarrassed, and don’t tell anyone if you don’t want to. Almost all of these are available on either Netflix, Hulu, or Crunchyroll.</p><p>You don’t need to dress up as anime characters, speak Japanese, understand complicated memes, or <em>only</em> watch anime. I watch all kinds of shows, read all kinds of books, and enjoy all kinds of music. I’m just asking you to keep an open mind.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb546edb1f62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game Theory for Dummies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kparwal260/game-theory-for-dummies-c68fe8f49de4?source=rss-f74d85abe6c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c68fe8f49de4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computer-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Keshav Parwal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 May 2018 21:21:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-11T21:21:18.331Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IU07VmNubejx5FUJhjbnHg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Game theory is the fascinating study of how people interact. It is the foundation for economics, law, politics, psychology, and artificial intelligence. Under the simple assumption of rationality (which is more reasonable than you might think), it’s possible to build models for behavior.</p><p>The simplest models don’t quite look right, in the same way the simplest physics problems ignore friction. But as they grow more complex, patterns of behavior, or “strategies”, emerge, and they grow more and more reasonable as copmlexity increases.</p><p>Many game theory concepts are directly applicable to our lives. Concepts like repeated games, the endgame problem, matching games, and more have direct correlations to our world. Let’s examine one simple game.</p><p>You’re Bonnie, and Clyde is your partner in crime. You’ve been caught by the police after robbing a bank, and now you’ve been stuck into an interrogation room with no escape and no way to get a message out.</p><p>You’re caught. But you won’t rat out Clyde. The interrogator presents you with an option. If you snitch on Clyde, they’ll go easy on you. Clyde is in another room, presented with the same option. What would you do?</p><p>If you’ve studied game theory before, you’ll immediately recognize this as the famous prisoner’s dilemma, one of the most important games. Let’s examine how to play the prisoner’s dilemma.</p><p>If neither of you snitch, you both get three years in prison. If one of you snitches, and the other doesn’t, then the one who didn’t snitch gets nine years, and the one who snitched gets off scot free. If you both snitch, then you both get six years.</p><p>From now on, to match game theory parlance, we’ll call snitching “competing” and not snitching “cooperating”. And we’ll call the “joint payoff” the negative sum total time you both spend in prison. If both cooperate, then the joint payoff is -6. If both compete, then the joint payoff is -12. Which is worse. If only one snitches, then the joint payoff is -9. If you both compete, you get the worst outcome! You should clearly both cooperate, you’ll both get the least possible amount of jail time.</p><p>But you’ll compete (snitch) every single time.</p><p>Go back to the interrogation room. Now imagine you have those individual and joint payoffs in front of you (or, the game is of perfect information), and you know that Clyde is making his decision at the exact same time as you (or, the game is static). You’re in a static game of perfect information. Remember, there is no communication at any time after your arrest.</p><p>You’re sitting there, the decision in front of you, and with the knowledge that Clyde is making the same decision. You know you should both cooperate. He knows that too. Let’s suppose you think he’ll cooperate. You could get -3 by cooperating. But you could get that sweet, sweet 0 by competing! Okay, let’s suppose you think he’ll compete. If you cooperate, you’re going to get a -9, but if you compete you could turn that into a -6! No matter how bad -6 is, it is better than -9.</p><p>No matter how Clyde acts, it is always in your best interest to compete!</p><p>The kicker is, Clyde has figured this out too. You two are tragically fated to compete with one another and make yourselves both worse off.</p><p>What we discovered there was a Nash equilibrium. There is never any reason for one player in the game to deviate from the compete-compete outcome, so the game has reached equilibrium — you’ll always compete. That’s the evil of the prisoner’s dilemma. It was designed to get you both to rat each other out. Without some way to change the payoffs of the game, even communication before you are arrested cannot change this outcome. Even if the game is made dynamic, where Clyde (or Bonnie) chooses first, and Bonnie (Clyde) is told what decision their partner made before making their decision, you will <strong>still</strong> always compete-compete.</p><p>People simply cannot be trusted, it seems.</p><p>This game, made more complex, becomes the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons">tragedy of the commons </a>— public resources will always be overutilized (there is also a tragedy of the anti-commons, where rightholders will exclude one another from using a resource, to the point it provides value to nobody).</p><p><em>A short side note, most formal literature on game theory will talk about socially efficient outcomes, Pareto efficient, or Kaldor-Hicks efficient, but these all essentially mean the “best” outcome — the one with the highest joint payoff. This isn’t necessarily the best outcome for you, but it’s the best outcome for everyone. It’s the same way that greedy algorithms find local optima, but almost always fail to find the global optima.</em></p><p>Now you probably feel pretty bad about this. Nobody can really, truly be trusted when it comes down to the wire. And nobody can trust you.</p><p>But this game could be slightly different.</p><p>Let’s imagine a new game. Let’s say you’re a construction company, and you have a client. Your client forwards you ten thousand dollars to build a shed.</p><p>You never signed a contract (more on this later!), so if you just walked away with his money, you could net yourself a neat ten thousand! Let’s call this action “breach” (contract parlance here, but for now let’s just ignore any legal ramifications). Or you could “perform”, and build his shed. This will net you about one thousand dollars in the end. Let’s say that the client values this shed at eleven thousand dollars, netting him one thousand dollars as well.</p><p>This is starting to look bad. There’s nothing to stop you from walking away with the money! And that’s exactly what would happen — if the game were played <em>once</em>.</p><p>But what if the game repeats? Do you still steal his money (and conversely, he may never give you the money to begin with!), or do you build his shed?</p><p>The answer depends on <em>how </em>the game repeats.</p><p>Let’s say this game is played ten times, and you both know this. Let’s say the first nine times, you play nice and build his shed, to make sure he’s giving you the money. But the tenth time, what’s to stop you from stealing his money?</p><p>This is the endgame problem, and it’s a real life problem for the people who are associated with someone near death. The dying person (barring any belief in judgment from a higher power), suddenly has no incentive to be nice to you, and instead will just take what they want. They have no long term, no reputation, to worry about.</p><p>But in our case with ten games, we can take this further. Since you and the client both know what’s going to happen the last game, it isn’t really a game at all — it’s a predetermined outcome. So there are only really nine games. But the ninth game is now the last game! That one is now predetermined as well! Inductively, this peels away all the games until we’re back where we started.</p><p>The world just sucks. Every game so far has ended in deceit. Deterministically repeated games of perfect information are just the same.</p><p>But there’s a hope on the horizon —<em> Stochastically </em>repeated games of perfect information!</p><p>Let’s say that instead of 10 games, each game has a 10% chance of being the last game. You only find out it is the last game after it is played (or before, it’s not all that important). On <em>average</em>, that’s ten games. But it could be seven, eleven, or just one.</p><p>All of a sudden, the game changes! Your client will always give you money, and you’ll always build the shed! Remember that one word, reputation?</p><p>You’ve gotta maintain that now. Because nobody knows when the game will end, it’s suddenly not in their benefit to cheat each other. To see this, imagine that the game extends infinitely. If you cheat the client the first time, they’ll never give you opportunities to build sheds ever again. You’ll make ten thousand the first time around, but after eleven games, you’d have been better off performing each time. You’ll never get a contract to build something from anyone ever again, and suddenly that ten thousand looks sort of small. You could have a potentially infinite payoff by performing every time, because you don’t know when the last game is!</p><p>This logic extends to our randomly ending game. You don’t know how many more games there will be, so you continue to perform because it could yield better opportunities in the future. In other words, you’ve begun to think long term.</p><p>Fascinatingly, this mirrors real-life. Any day, you have a (hopefully) miniscule chance of dying. It almost never informs your decisions (except during the endgame problem), so every interaction is unlikely to be the last. That’s why trust forms — you don’t know when you’ll need it again.</p><p>The magic of stochastic games also solves the prisoner’s dilemma — suspend reality for a moment, and try the stochastic repetition method on the Bonnie and Clyde scenario. Suddenly, instead of compete-compete, you’ll actually find a new equilibrium at cooperate-cooperate!</p><p>We saw what games are, and studied the bare basics of equilibria and strategies. But we haven’t even scratched the surface.</p><p>Each game has been about perfect information. But what about information asymmetry, like in buying a used car? Or in the job market? What about changing the payoffs by leveraging the judicial framework with contracts, remedies, and damages? What about criminal activity and deterrence?</p><p>Game theory is a fascinating way to examine your own decisions and the decisions of others. I’ll leave you with one other way to solve the prisoner’s dilemma.</p><p>What if the payoffs for ratting are lower? By not snitching, you incur the wrath of the police, but what if by snitching you incur the wrath of someone else, lowering your payoffs for snitching?</p><p>You know what they say. Snitches get stitches.</p><p>People have come up with their own solution, organically, to the prisoner’s dilemma. They’ve imbued a negative payoff into the very idea of ratting someone out. They call it tattling, snitching, and compare the action to being a rat. And if you do it? You’re going to need medical attention.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c68fe8f49de4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>