<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Karen Zilberstein on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Karen Zilberstein on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@kzilberstein?source=rss-54ef4c6cdf88------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 20:35:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@kzilberstein/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What I Learned from Ana: It Is Not Just What Parents Do That Make the Difference, But What They…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kzilberstein/what-i-learned-from-ana-it-is-not-just-what-parents-do-that-make-the-difference-but-what-they-2684460ef93e?source=rss-54ef4c6cdf88------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2684460ef93e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mothers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karen Zilberstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Feb 2020 14:23:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-03T14:25:59.814Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>What I Learned from Ana: It Is Not Just What Parents Do That Make the Difference, But What They Have</strong></p><p>I prided myself on being a good mother, until I met Ana. As a psychotherapist working with children and families, I had steeped myself in child development, and applied its lessons. I attended to my children’s feelings, soothed their distresses, and helped them problem-solve their dilemmas. I provided plenty of stimulation, even if a bit too much transpired via television and video games. For the most part, I ensured my children ate a well-rounded diet, generously doused in ketchup and strawberry jam, which, according to Reagan era proposals, count as fruits and vegetables. Like other parents, I also indulged in my share of unsavory temper tantrums, miscommunications, and preoccupations. But, in the spirit of psychoanalyst D.W. Winnicott, who coined the phrase “good enough mother,” it seemed to suffice.</p><p>Ana was not a perfect parent, either. But she performed remarkably well, given the challenges stacking the odds against her.</p><p>I met Ana through her lawyer, the introduction coming through email. It read, “I represent a twenty-two-year-old mom. She had a difficult past, but has turned it around. DCF (Department of Children and Families) has custody of her children, and the goal is adoption. She’s a good mother. Visits go well. HELP! Please.” HELP meant get to know her, glimpse life as she lived it, and make recommendations to the court.</p><p>The all-caps pulled me in. It felt good to stretch my professional muscles, test their power, and drape myself in an expert’s mantle. So, I diligently collected what I knew about parenting and child development and, leaving my office behind, lugged it into Ana’s terrain. I sat in her apartment, strolled through her neighborhood, talked to her friends and family, and attended visits and meetings at DCF. I never walked in her shoes, but I trailed her footsteps as best I could, trying to keep pace while encumbered by the trappings of my experience and training.</p><p>My first meeting with Ana was held in her sparsely furnished apartment. Apart from a bed, television, couch, clothes, and kitchen utensils, the rooms held few possessions. The building, itself, appeared derelict. The stairs creaked, the hallways begged for paint, and the intercom system had long since stopped functioning.</p><p>I half expected Ana to look as defeated and run-down as her surroundings, and was surprised when greeted by a young woman with a healthy complexion, wide smile, and mixture of hope and sadness streaming from her eyes. Explaining my role, I warned her about the intrusive questions and scrutiny I would put her through. I was probably just the latest in a long line of professionals who had run her through a similar gauntlet.</p><p>“That’s okay,” she replied, before launching into her story, “my lawyer is the best and she said you can help me.”</p><p>Ana held modest goals: to raise her children and watch them graduate high school. But the shallow banks of her life could barely contain its cascading unpredictability. Her past contained culprits typical to DCF involvement: low-income, trauma, out of home placement, high school drop-out, teen pregnancy, and getting mixed up with the wrong man, who stalked and abused her. After she left him, he tracked her down and brutally beat her. It was then that DCF removed their three young children, now aged two, three and five.</p><p>Her present was also precarious. She worked a series of low-income jobs, her latest gig paying eleven dollars an hour, more than minimum wage, of which she felt proud. The salary barely stretched to pay the bills, causing trouble when she missed work and pay because of sickness or appointments or when faced with unexpected expenses. A few months like that and eviction loomed. In the past, when she lost an apartment, she would spend up to half a year camped on family members’ floors, until she could save enough for a security deposit. Now, however, with DCF scanning her every move, judging whether she and her residence were fit for children, she could not afford that option.</p><p>My life differed substantially. My partner and I earned advanced degrees before raising three children in a solidly middle-class community of comfortable houses, decent schools, and low crime. We owned a house and reliable cars and our nest contained sufficient padding to sustain us in an emergency. Life’s goals centered on professional advancement and the welfare of our children, whom we expected to graduate college. Stability was the norm, not the exception, although at times plans veered off course. When a bus crumpled the front of my car or a child collapsed with a sports injury, my heart quickened and my body quaked. But I never feared losing my home, a child, or my own life for a sustained time.</p><p>Ana faced the prospect of all three. A lot of the time. She could not avoid the frequent reminders, which poked through her softly armored exterior, causing her to teeter between optimism and despair.</p><p>“It’s too much,” she’d say, when the strains accumulated, “I spent last week in the hospital because my apartment has mold and it made me really sick. Plus, my children’s father just got out of jail, which stresses me out. DCF told me that with everything going on, I need to go back into therapy, but I don’t have time or a way to get there. Nothing is ever enough for them.”</p><p>When my life faltered on the brink of chaos, I tried to keep a firm grasp on my priorities, shedding some tasks while concentrating on others. I had choices: cut back on commitments, hire help, retreat from people who caused angst. My parenting also rested on a sense that both myself and my children could influence our fates, as long as we exercised self-understanding, emotional regulation, and rational decision-making. But Ana could count on no such foundation. When she and I discussed her options, few arose. She spent much of her time in activities crucial to her physical wellbeing, or mandated by DCF. Cutting back or parceling out was not an alternative.</p><p>Ana did not let accumulating strains sink her for long.</p><p>“Look at these cute sheets and blankets I bought for my kids,” she told me one day, as we sat in her apartment. “I am getting their room ready, buying things little by little. I want to save so I can live in a better place when they come home. A better neighborhood. I’m doing good. I can make it work.”</p><p>I had to admit that the sheets were cute, and helped brighten the drab surroundings. But I silently questioned why she bought them, when saving and moving seemed more important. Of course, I had also purchased child-friendly sheets when my children were young, hoping they would infuse sleep with comfort and security. I could afford the luxury; the bedding I purchased hardly dented my monthly budget.</p><p>“What made you decide to buy them rather than something else?” I asked.</p><p>“I want them to feel safe and happy when they come home,” she answered. “I’ll never be able to afford a really nice place in a great neighborhood, but if home is bright and cozy, they will know I love them and that I am looking out for them.” She had saved up, sacrificed for the sheets. What first appeared a waste of money now looked like a generous gift.</p><p>Ana’s brightest moments occurred during visitation with her children. Visits were held at the local DCF office, in a bare room without carpeting or color. A DCF worker sat in the doorway, notebook in hand, recording every step and misstep. Ana would arrive promptly each week, her arms laden with gifts, toys, and food. She read, colored, and played games with her children. She asked about their weeks, and gently received their answers. They leaned into her, and she cuddled them back. When they hit one another, or bumped their heads, she responded mildly, offering comfort or correction, showing no signs of anger, anxiety, or impatience.</p><p>Once she arrived to the visit with sagging eyes and a body that drooped. She engaged notably less with her children, initiating little and muttering responses.</p><p>“Are you okay?” I asked, worried that something had happened.</p><p>“I haven’t slept,” she said. “I worked the night shift, and then went to a medical appointment. The bus runs only once an hour, so the whole thing took forever.”</p><p>I hoped there were better options for her, and ran through a couple ideas in my head. What would I do, if I did not have a car. Uber? Probably too expensive. Friends? In her low-income community, few had cars, extra gas money, or flexibility. Call a family member? How alone was she?</p><p>“Is there anyone who can help?” I asked.</p><p>“My mom does, but she wasn’t free. Plus, I need to be able to show I can do it myself, so, I can’t rely too much on others.”</p><p>I thought I could offer assistance on that point. Although I could not give her a car or other resources, I had plenty of advice about help. The psychological literature lauded the benefits of social supports. Even in my well-off community, we aided each other in a pinch. My neighbor had looked after my children for a full day when I needed to leave town suddenly for a family emergency.</p><p>“Everyone relies on others,” I said, “Friends, family, neighbors. That’s how it works.”</p><p>“Tell that to DCF,” she said.</p><p>DCF acknowledged that visits generally went well, but the worker had concerns. One day, she wrote up Ana for letting her three-year-old run a few steps ahead while they walked between McDonalds and the office. He stopped when she called out, but DCF thought she should have held his hand the whole time. Another time, Ana left her daughter’s drink on the floor, where it promptly got knocked over, and its contents spilled. The worker told her she needed to do a better job anticipating. Then, her son put crayons in his mouth. Ana told him not to and took the crayon from him, but a few minutes later, he grabbed another. When, after the third offense, Ana did not remove the box, DCF told her she needed to learn effective discipline.</p><p>Ana took the suggestions calmly, until she left the building.</p><p>“They never say anything good about me,” she raged. “They make me into this bad mom, and I’m not. They are never going to give me a chance.”</p><p>Her outrage burned for a few minutes, before turning to anguish. I watched her struggle against feelings of powerlessness, not wanting to succumb. As her predicament seeped through me, I acceded that she had a point. I could recall accidents and oversights in my parenting, as well, some worse than she displayed, but nobody, thank goodness, wrote me up. If they had, it would likely have turned me into an anxious wreck, hypervigilant about mistakes, hardly able to muster the calm, positive interactions considered the bulwark of good parenting.</p><p>Good enough parenting was beginning to look like a phantom idea, existing in the eye of the beholder. While Ana’s nurturing qualities impressed me most, her DCF worker cared more about discipline and self-sufficiency. Perhaps I was missing something, minimizing. Maybe what worked best for families ensconced in privilege and safe neighborhoods counted as mere luxury for those in poorer circumstances. So, I queried her worker about DCF’s concerns.</p><p>The worker conceded that she had no concerns about the care Ana provided. She had never harmed her children. Drug or alcohol use was also not a problem. But she labelled a few other risks.</p><p>“She has had more than one abusive partner,” she said, “and we feel it is likely that she will eventually hook up with another. She won’t tell us, of course, so we won’t know until it is too late. She’s also been evicted more than once. So, we worry that she cannot sustain appropriate housing. Also, she sometimes gets depressed. She has a trauma history. So, there are mental health issues.”</p><p>“Sometimes, she gets depressed?” I thought, impressed by the infrequency suggested by the phrase. Depression, sometimes, pestered me, as well, dragging me through the day, and dampening enjoyment and attention. Stress, disappointment, and loss were the main instigators, although none of them visited me with the regularity or amplitude that Ana experienced. I wondered how my mood would fare if bombarded with the assaults and indignities she bore. I was pretty sure it would fall lower than hers.</p><p>But DCF also had a point. There were risks: financial strains, limited supports, health concerns, neighborhoods with hazards. Each peril derived from a common factor: poverty. Pluck her from her circumstances and give her stable work and housing, and I felt confident that she and her kids would be fine. Place me in hers, and I was not sure how I or my children would fare. She was a good parent. More than good enough.</p><p>I told that to the court.</p><p>The day after the judge awarded Ana custody of her children, her lawyer and I sat down to talk.</p><p>“What does she need to succeed?” she asked.</p><p>“$40,000 per year,” I said, “give her that, and she’ll do alright.”</p><p>We let the thought hang in the air until it dissipated into sadness. $40,000 a year was a lot less than my family lived on, and well under what I thought we needed to be comfortable and achieve our goals. But Ana, I knew, expected less for herself and her children than I. We maneuvered on vastly different playing fields, whose turfs were far from even.</p><p>Later that year, when my son walked across the stage to receive his college degree, I felt extremely proud of his accomplishment. But I no longer patted myself firmly on the back for helping him get there. Good enough parenting does not materialize in a vacuum, nor was it the only ingredient in his success. It was not until I encountered Ana that I realized how fully the accoutrements of a middle-class life, which my family passed down from generation to generation — a working car, sufficient income, flexible work, stable housing, safe neighborhoods, community supports, status and control, and stressors that did not threaten to knock us over — allowed me to be a decent mom and he a gifted student. The wind blew at our backs, and as long as we steered in a reasonably competent way, desired destinations were in reach. Ana, however, found herself fighting gales head on, which stunted forward progress, no matter what her effort and skills.</p><p>When she and I said a final good-bye, my biggest hope was that the gusts would diminish.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2684460ef93e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Forget the science, this is parenting]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@kzilberstein/forget-the-science-this-is-parenting-62c6db06874c?source=rss-54ef4c6cdf88------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62c6db06874c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Karen Zilberstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Mar 2018 14:30:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-03T16:32:07.067Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Throughout my 24 years as a parent, I have been both eager consumer and perennial skeptic of parenting advice. Eager because, like most parents, I want to do best by my children. Skeptic, because parenting has never been a one-size-fits-all endeavor that conforms easily to experts’ ever-changing prescriptions.</p><p>When my youngest children were born, Penelope Leach and T. Berry Brazelton monopolized the parenting airwaves, spattering recommendations across books and television shows. One click of the remote and I could watch them pitch their brands of childrearing and the benefits of professional guidance.</p><p>“I wish that every new parent had a chance to share their new baby with someone who could interpret him for them,” Brazelton said during an interview, speaking in a warm, soft, hypnotic tone that could make a true believer out of anyone. “It makes a significant difference in a baby’s self-esteem, and readiness to pick up on learning — all the things we dream about wanting.” Yes, I wanted and dreamed about all of that. He had me hooked. I bought the books and watched the shows. It was the least I could do to safeguard my children’s futures.</p><p>Brazelton and Leach had a lot to say about feeding, sleep, crying, aggression, and the parent-child relationship. But their overall messages boiled down to a key principal: listen to and accept children unconditionally. The more attentive and responsive the parent, the more resilient and flourishing the child.</p><p>So, a few years later, when my six-year-old son spawned a family crisis by announcing that he would wed our neighbor, I felt armed and ready.</p><p>“No,” my four-year-daughter insisted in response, “you are going to marry me.”</p><p>“I can’t marry you,” he replied, “brothers don’t marry sisters.”</p><p>She shed tears. Could not sleep.</p><p>As I tried to comfort her, I could not help flashing forward to the teenage years, wondering whether I would be consoling her the same way then. I pictured her grief flung throughout the house after a romance gone awry. I felt the fragility of the protections I could offer, my inability to shield her from life’s shocks and tremors. I badly wanted to inoculate her against future pains, and give her the inner strength to withstand its assaults. So, channeling the mantra of unconditional acceptance, I reassured her that she was dearly loved by all.</p><p>“Yes,” she moaned, “everybody loves me, but no-one will marry me.” At her age, she could not imagine parting from her family.</p><p>Attending and responding was harder than it sounded. Especially when it required disentangling parental anxiety from the child’s feelings. I still liked Leach and Brazelton, but their advice worked better in theory than practice.</p><p>In the eighteen years since that incident, I have watched the parent guidance industry become more complex and omnipresent. The World Wide Web proliferates opinions and recommendations, promising to deliver answers with one touch of a keyboard. A quick search of “parenting advice book” returns 56,978<strong> </strong>results on Amazon and “parenting advice blog” shows 13,600,000 Internet entries. (Both have already increased since this writing.) With that volume, the experts and opinionators should cover just about every dilemma of childrearing. But try googling “what to say when a preschooler worries about marriage,” and nothing of relevance appears. Even if it did, it is unlikely that a book, or the Internet, would have been able to guide me through that moment, whispering to me that my daughter was not concerned about love, but about separation.</p><p>Despite their limitations, the advice gurus continued their magnetic pull, promising to turn myself and my children into the best possible versions of ourselves. Along with them, I encountered ubiquitous warnings of harm and maladjustment, which stoked my determination to stay abreast and be well-prepared.</p><p>The morning newspapers featured stories about teens who attempted suicide after being strung on and then rejected by online romances. The evening news reported the ways modern culture stunts children’s development. Hidden poisons lurked in food and cleansing products. Parents deprived children’s intellect by speaking too few words per day. Youth were plugged in and tuned out, turning their lives into breeding grounds for ADHD. Problem after potential problem flashed across the screen. Expert after expert expounded solutions. Brazelton and Leach’s “listen to and nurture your child” was updated with haunting proof that children need protection. What was a modern parent to do?</p><p>A Google search scored plenty of suggestions. Monitor your children: keep tabs on their social contacts and activities, check their social media usage, search their rooms.</p><p>Other sites warned against too much oversight. Children need privacy. Hovering parents damage self-esteem. America is faced with a tsunami of overprotective parents breeding youngsters who will never be able to cope with life’s demands. Let children struggle and learn from their own mistakes.</p><p>Then came research that struck fear in my parental heart. Stress is lethal. A single event can destroy neurons in the brain, interfering with memory and learning. Chronic stress is even worse, reducing brain volume and causing emotional and cognitive impairment. It had been proven in mice, which surely resemble little kids.</p><p>What type of stress the research referred to, I could not discover. Penelope Leach said that when babies cry vigorously, cortisol swishes through their brains and stymies development. I could remember numerous, sustained episodes of vigorous crying in my children’s infancy: when my son tumbled down the stairs, when I left my daughter at day care, when fevers broke out in their small bodies. With better monitoring, maybe I could have avoided some of those incidents. Clearly, I was failing on all fronts. I was neither vigilant nor responsive enough.</p><p>Just how much I fell short and what modern parenthood really demanded soon became apparent. In her 2006 tome, <em>The Science of Parenting, </em>Margot Sunderland synthesizes parental practices and neurological development. She explains that by responding sensitively to children’s feelings, parents can tame the emotional centers of their children’s brains, keeping cortisol dispersion at bay. It was killing two birds with one stone; by being responsive, parents could build in biological protections. That sounded like a good deal, almost too good to be true.</p><p>“Consistent emotional regulation is challenging,” I read, “if you have two or more children under five, you may find that meeting their every need can feel relentless at times; a young child has an emotional regulatory need every 20 seconds.”</p><p>Sunderland thinks parents should get help from other adults, share the regulatory burden, but not skimp on it. Others emphasize the grueling demands mean parents should make time for self-care. Surely self-care is hard to fit into that kind of schedule.</p><p>Edward Tronick, a Harvard psychologist, claims that the average mother responsively attunes to her child only about 30 percent of the time. He thinks it is good enough. That would knock Sunderland’s estimate down to one regulatory reply per minute. Even with the lowered bar, I knew I failed the test. Once a minute hardly left time for meal prep, adult conversation, or a trip to the bathroom. Although maybe I could sneak in a couple of deep, refreshing breaths for self-care.</p><p>I gave parenting my best shot for many years, but following the experts’ advice proved challenging. I tried to attend and respond, but could not always muster interest in my children’s concerns. Did it matter whether, during four-square games, my son’s friends cheated and called balls out that were really in, or if the homework his teacher assigned was “a stupid waste of time”?</p><p>“Fine,” I would say, “if it’s that bad, don’t play four-square or do your homework.”</p><p>“What kind of mother tells her kid not to do homework?” he replied.</p><p>I made a few half-hearted attempts to monitor social media and activities before deciding the effort was not worth the ensuing resentment or the way it interfered with unconditional acceptance. I snooped only if I noticed suspicious or irresponsible behavior. Even with that hands-off approach, I got accused of over-protectiveness.</p><p>“What are you doing tonight?” I would ask my teenagers.</p><p>“Why do you always need to know everything?” they would respond.</p><p>“When are you finishing your history project?</p><p>“I don’t know, it depends when I have time. It’s really annoying when you keep asking what we are doing and when.” That is not to say that parenting did not have its magic moments, when understanding and action coalesced, and the experts and I fell into step. Sometimes a kiss could magically cure a scraped knee or a bandage hide it from consciousness. Sometimes a well-timed comment lifted a sour mood. But, at other times, life’s bumps and bruises left marks. Most healed. Some probably remain as scars.</p><p>I am sure my bumbled responses are indelibly imprinted somewhere in my children’s young adult brains, but they do not seem to mind. It turns out that they did not want me to be a scientific or studied parent, or to pepper everyday interactions with too much responsiveness. They did not mind if I did not always listen or sometimes misunderstood, or if they ended up with brains or lives that were not perfectly regulated. What they wanted most was for me just to be their mom, interested in them, and willing to help when needed. Their bar, thank goodness, was relatively low.</p><p>In the meantime, the news, Internet, and bookshelves continue to bombard with the latest findings, promising to make parenthood more and more scientific, and daily life less and less feasible. While curiosity allows the hints and tips to continue to sneak into my inbox, I try to divorce myself from their grasp. No matter how devoted or well-read I become, I can never give myself or my family immunity to the difficulties of being human.</p><p>“I love you. I am going to miss you,” said my daughter, giving me a big hug as she bounded out the door to return to college, moments after expressing irritation at my questions.</p><p>“Even though you find me annoying?” I asked.</p><p>“Yes, you are annoying,” she said. “So, what?”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62c6db06874c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>