<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Leah Kiser on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Leah Kiser on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 09:20:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Perpetual Search for Truth]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-perpetual-search-for-truth-158f687b301f?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/158f687b301f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wonder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wisdom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Oct 2025 22:57:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-03T03:19:10.010Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Through Art &amp; Philosophy</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c1L7DZHPyQeQaLpYbhY1AQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Symbiosis” Painting by Leah Ode Kiser</figcaption></figure><p>The way artists so elegantly record what we see in the world has fascinated me for as long as I can remember. For decades, I have worked to gain the skills to draw and paint realistically. More than anything I wanted to do justice to the forms that I see. One lesson in particular helped me gain a greater ability to draw: to let go of my preconceived notions, and be as sensative as possible. With that lesson in mind, I begin to make marks and use those marks to triangulate and deduce where other marks should go. Through this process, if I do a good job of triangulating and weeding out the mistaken marks that don’t resemble what I am seeing, a likeness just appears.</p><p>Philosophy, as a form of truth seeking can be similar to drawing.</p><p>In college, as a philosophy and art major I read the writing of many philosophers which blew my mind wide open and helped me let go of many preconceived notions about the world. In my senior year, I attempted to write my own philosophy. I began to see parallels between writing philosophy and drawing realistically. But instead of expressing my understanding of reality with abstract marks like I do in the drawing process, in philosophy I expressed my understanding with beliefs/premises/statements. Attempting to carefully weed out mistaken beliefs when they no longer appeared to resemble the reality that I experienced. I’ve continued to work on the philosophy project that I started in college in 2005, the result of that work is in the articles that follow.</p><p>Whether its through words or paint, to observe someone else’s expressed findings about the world we experience together can be interesting and thought provoking. Below is an introduction to my philosophical writing that includes a comprehensive list of the articles I’ve written so far. Think of them as little art works to ponder, rather than proofs — because proofs, they definately are not. Considering them as “artwork” doesn’t mean you have to accept them or even like them— just think about them and if you want, leave a comment about what you think. I hope you find the ideas worthy of your time. If you are curious, you can view my painting on my website gallery at <a href="https://leahodekiser.com/Gallery">artifactfa.com</a>.</p><h3>Introduction to the Philosophy</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yEqn5xCWWdZRd-SH.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@qmikola?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Mikołaj</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/white-book-page-with-black-background-DCzpr09cTXY?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In my understanding and experience, philosophers seek <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">objective truth</a>, but they are (and<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f"> I am</a>) immersed in a subjective experience.</p><p>For this reason, I write in the first person about my subjective experience of what I will define as the “objective truth,” as Descartes did in his Meditations. But my philosophy has little else in common with his.</p><p>I cannot step outside of my subjective experience, but that does not necessarily mean that objective truth does not exist or that I have no access to it. It appears to me that objective truth does exist (at least to the degree that my body exists — truth, in my philosophy is made of molecules (or whatever molecules are made of), truth is not made of ideas or statements). I understand that will sound controversial to some, but it should become less controversial as the definitions that I am using are explained in the articles listed below.</p><h3>PART 1: The Components of My Experience</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">What is Truth</a>?</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/sensation-33308bad60a5">Sensation (&amp; Materialism vs Idealism</a>)</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">Cognition (&amp; Wonder, and Reason</a>)</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/attending-focus-14986a7bb72e">Attending(/Focus</a>)</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">Preference (&amp; Deliberation, and Free Will</a>)</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">What Am I</a>?</li><li>Aside: <a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/a-wonder-about-what-i-am-15f4d327bdc4">A Wonder about What I Am.</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-meaning-ca6d1b5facea?postPublishedType=initial">Meaning</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">Objectification</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">Scrutinization</a></li></ul><h3>An important lingering question:</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/does-truth-exist-26fddbe03de9">Does Truth Exist</a>?</li></ul><h3>PART 2: Navigating Immense Truth from a Tiny Limited Perspective with Much Room for Error:</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-feel-the-way-that-i-feel-0d02164787b8">Cognized Causes for Preference Sensations</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">What is Reasonable to Believe?</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a">Mistakes (&amp; Why do I Want to be Right/Accurate?)</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">Knowledge (&amp; What, if anything, is Justified True?)</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">What, if anything is a Reliable Source?</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">Actions/Behaviors</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">Intentions</a></li></ul><h3>PART 3: Summary</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/truth-seeking-ce3ae1915af4">Truth Seeking</a></li></ul><h3>PART 4: A Wonder about Morality</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/evidence-based-morality-ad0fc26e91b8">Evidence Based Morality</a></li></ul><h3>Supplemental Materials</h3><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">Cognitive Dissonance Theory</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/informal-fallacies-77784b04695f">Informal Fallacies</a></li><li><a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/formal-logic">Formal Fallacies</a> (this is a link to an encyclopedia Brittanica Article)</li></ul><h3>A Shorter Read:</h3><p>If the multi-article list above is too daunting. I’ve put together an article that ties together some of the most consequential points I’m trying to make. You can read it here:<a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/finding-common-ground-831b39c10108"> Finding Common Ground</a>.</p><p>What to expect:</p><p>I begin by calling this philosophy a language game, one in which “truth” is defined as “the common ground for all things” (The phrase “language game” is a reference to the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein). My objective is to seek the truth that I’ve defined (Common Ground for all things). I use this definition as the foundation for the rest of the philosophy. I use it to explore the definition of “myself” and the limitations of sensations. I devise an epistemological framework involving reason based upon a continuum (of believe←-wonder — -&gt;deny) instead of a true/false dichotomy. I then contemplate how our attention and actions are impacted by the way we categorize cognitions on that continuum and vice versa. Along the way, I ponder other philosophical topics such as existentialism, nihilism mind/self, and free will. Research conducted using the scientific method (a method in which ideas and evidence are heavily scrutinized) is referenced throughout the writing to support my thought process.</p><p>What is gained: Contemplating this definition of truth as the common ground for all things and clarifying my thoughts through writing has helped me seek common ground/truth in a way that appears to align more precisely with my experiences. It helps me relate better to others with whom I disagree and have more productive dialog with those whom I disagree with (or at the very least, understand the strong emotions that strike me when we cannot resolve our disagreements). And lastly, it gives me a new way to view the world that feels honest, meaningful, and valuable; in unexpected ways, it altered how I experience the world: what I attend to, how I think, and how I behave. Reading the philosophy and thinking out these ideas as a reader might lead to similar benefits.</p><p>I wrote this philosophy because the belief system that I grew up with was not focused on seeking common ground for all people. It was focused on a book, and making that book into a fabricated common ground by getting others to believe it’s contents. I realized, on the world stage, the strategy of focusing on man made fabricated content (the book) actually led to a lot of arguments. These arguments seemed tangential to reality, unnecessary, and unresolvable- they sometimes resulted in violence against people who used conflicting books or no book at all), and I sought a more common ground — one that it would be hard for anyone to deny — one that would be useful for making accurate predictions for our survival and thriving. In that search, I found what I call “the whole of all being.” Truth is the word that I use for that being, and it is made of what we call “molecules” and “atoms” (and whatever atoms and molecules are made of).</p><h4>Scientism Objection</h4><p>To some, this approach to truth seeking may look like “scientism” (an attempt to replace religious truths with scientific ones). But the distinct difference is that in my theories, “truth” isn’t something that humans express. “Truth” isn’t made of statements. Truth, in my theories, is made of “the whole of all being.” Due to its complexity and my limited sense abilities, it leaves a lot of room for observers to wonder and guess, but our wonders and guesses are not “truths.” Nor are the wonders and guesses of groups of scientists “truths”. I would say that inquirers aren’t developing “truths” through our research when we use the scientific method. We are observing the bits of truth (molecules) that we are sensitive to and developing our very best guesses about it. Those guesses aren’t true, at no point do they become justified as “true.” They merely appear to resemble truth/reality from the perspective that we are viewing it from (like a portrait resembles a person, it isn’t a person, but it bears a resemblance to what we see when we look at the person that was painted).</p><p>My definition of both “truth” and “knowledge” differ from that of traditional western science and philosophy. In my theories “truth is the common ground for all things.” Knowledge is “my best guess” and my best guesses about truth appear to be those grounded in the most heavily scrutinized evidence (that an individual accepts and is aware of — there is a lot of room for disagreement). The human experience of truth is incomplete (because of our limited energy, time, and sense abilities) and our descriptions are prone to flaws and overconfidence. It appears to me that humans are poor at judging dichotomous true/false. Knowledge is not “justified true belief” in my view (because we are guessers, not judges). Conflicting knowledge (conflicting guesses) is common and leads to a lot of heated arguments (especially if people define their knowledge as “justified true belief”), and in my philosophy I try to explain why those disagreements happen and offer some ideas about how to resolve those conflicts (if they can be resolved at all — I acknowledge that sometimes they can’t).</p><p>So, I am not calling scientific discoveries “truths” at all. I do place a great deal of emphasis on using sensory evidence as a way of seeking (as well as using tools that enhance our sensations). I believe that human truth seeking is incomplete and prone to flaws, because a great deal of evidence complied by scientists (who’ve shown their work — how the observations they’ve made led them to their conclusions, which we can check for ourselves) shows that this is the case. The scientific method appears to be a good scrutinization method that appears to help us arrive at “guesses”/knowledge that produce predictable outcomes, which are useful in making decisions about how to act (move molecules around) to produce our intended outcomes.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>I wrote all of this in search of common ground for humanity. Perhaps the search I’m expressing can help us attend to things that help us live lives more in harmony with other humans. Perhaps it can help us orient our attention, intentions, and actions to live more harmoniously with the rest of the living things whose lives we require for our own survival. Perhaps the philosophy can help us better cooperate with one another and collaborate against those who (the most heavily scrutinized sensory evidence shows) intend to harm or manipulate us away from seeking sensory based evidence and toward their own unsupported selfish objectives. It is a hope anyway.</p><p>I also hope you enjoy the language game/philosophy that I’ve written and find that it provides to you at the very least — entertainment.</p><p>There will be more to come eventually, but for now, I intend to take quite a long time off from writing to focus on my career as a fine art painter, but I will try to answer comments as they come in.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=158f687b301f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding Common Ground]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/original-philosophy/finding-common-ground-831b39c10108?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/831b39c10108</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Sep 2025 10:28:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T14:18:07.768Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Is this the philosophy that we need right now?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eUjks7xbFvHPAQfKAm5Njw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Throughout 2024, I posted a detailed and comprehensive philosophy that I’ve been cultivating for many years (I began writing it while finishing a philosophy degree in 2005). This submission is a condensed summary of the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">original writing</a> that explores three of the most consequential topics that I discuss:</p><ol><li>Common Ground/Whole of All Being Theory of Truth.</li><li>Rethinking the Western Definition of Knowledge.</li><li>Evidence-Based Morality.</li></ol><p>These three topics ponder the origins of disagreements and the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-meaning-ca6d1b5facea">meaning </a>of common ground/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>. By contemplating what is common to us all and what causes disagreements to occur, perhaps we can approach disagreements in a more honest and productive way.</p><p><strong>What will happen to our highly connected human civilization if we cannot learn to do that?</strong></p><h3>What do I mean by “truth?”</h3><p>I define truth as: The common ground for all beings</p><p>This is a categorization; it is not a premise or something that I’m trying to prove. I am connecting the word “truth” with “something” that I seek to observe. The “something” that I seek is “the common ground for all beings.”</p><h3>In this language game, what are “Beings,” and what is “Common Ground?”</h3><p><strong>“Beings”</strong></p><p>The word “being” is often used to mean a thing that is “alive” or “sentient.” That is not how I am using it.</p><p>A being, in this language game, is a thing that “is,” anything that exists independently of whether anyone senses, knows, or cognizes about it (I’ll discuss definitions for sensation and cognition in the next section). Things that we normally refer to as “physical things:” particles of matter, movements, waves… — things with mass that my body appears to be made of, things I bump into like walls and rocks, things I move through like water and gasses, and also particles and waves that don’t seem to have mass like electrons or particles that move at the speed of light (like photons and gluons).</p><p>Given the occasional discovery of new “beings,” over the course of human history that we didn’t previously recognize as existing (i.e. single celled organisms, UV light, and the Higgs Boson), it appears likely that there are many beings that are difficult or impossible for humans to observe through their naked sensory apparatuses. It also appears likely that there are beings that we haven’t yet discovered (like gravitons) that may become more apparent as we theorize, search, and fabricate apparatuses to make them detectable with our sensory apparatuses. Many beings are too small, too big, too fast, too slow, too far away, too bright, too dark for us to easily detect without special tools, but they are still beings if they can appear to exist outside of my cognition for other sentient beings to observe with their sensations and attempt to understand together. A being’s existence does not appear dependent upon my sensation or cognition; it appears to exist independently from my sensation and cognition (I realize this is a controversial topic and I’ll discuss more about realism vs. Idealism in the next section).</p><p>I use my sensory apparatuses to detect beings. Other sentient beings also appear to use their sensory apparatuses to detect beings. Our collective inability to detect a being does not appear to prevent it from being a being, but it <em>does </em>make the being appear not to “be” to <em>us </em>until we can find a way to detect it or detect signs of it with our sensory apparatuses.</p><p>I do not know the “medium” of beings. Are they what we call “matter” and/or “energy,” or is what we call “matter” and “energy” made of something that we don’t fully understand? I have no idea, but beings appear to be a medium that is distinct from my experience of sensations and cognitions, because sensations and cognitions are different from beings; when I sense an apple/being, it is not the case that the apple itself inputs into my cognition, it is a sensory representation of the apple brought on by my stimulated sensory apparatuses that enters into my cognition. I can recall the cognized apple as a memory. I cannot cognize/remember an apple and then eat my cognized/remembered apple to satisfy my hunger. A being that I can eat for sustenance appears to be made up of a distinct medium that differs from that of a sensed representation and remembered cognition of an apple that I cannot eat for sustenance. A cognition is not identical to a being — it is not a being. My sensations and cognitions are experienced inside of me (shielded from others) and they only become detectable to others when expressed in a way that others can observe. Cognitions and sensations aren’t common ground, like beings appear to be. They are subjective.</p><p><strong>“Common Ground”</strong></p><p>The common ground that I seek is a thing most common, most universal, for all beings.</p><p>What could that be?</p><p>The only thing that appears to be common to all beings is the whole of all being.</p><p>All beings that have awareness appear to be constantly aware of bits and pieces of the whole of all being whether they “believe” or “trust” in this awareness or not.</p><p>Anything less than the compilation of ALL beings is not common to all beings — because, by definition, it leaves some beings out. Anything less than the compilation of ALL beings does not fit the definition of truth that I am seeking.</p><p>There is nothing “more” than the compilation of all beings. There is nothing beyond it, because if there was, it would be “something:” it would be “a being,” and therefore, it would be part of the whole of all being.</p><p>The truth, the common ground for all beings, is the compilation of all beings — it is the single whole of all being.</p><p>The truth is inconceivably immense, rich, and complex. It is literally everything to me (including my body and every being I am made up of)– everything to all of us for all time, yet it appears to contain far more rich and complex information than I can sense or imagine. There are beings beyond my sensation or imagination that I am unaware of: a metaphysical portion of the whole of all being. Metaphysical in this sense is not a mystical fairy land (though admittedly, I don’t have awareness of what it is/is not), but rather it is the portion of the whole of all being that exists beyond human sensation. We know there are beings beyond our senses, because over the history of humanity, beings that humans had no awareness of have been discovered by our senses using invented apparatuses.</p><p>For example: the existence of molecules and the process of photosynthesis. My observation of molecules does not appear to be a necessary part of the workings of molecules. Plants eat, grow and thrive through the process of photosynthesis which entails photons slamming into water molecules (H2O) and carbon dioxide molecules (CO2), breaking molecular bonds, releasing oxygen (O2), and building different molecular bond to make carbohydrates. Plants eat, grow and thrive even though I’ve never personally observed photosynthesis occurring, and they ate, grew, and thrived before any scientist observed photosynthesis. Without my sensation, molecules and the way they interact appear to continue uninhibited because if they didn’t, it does not appear that plants would build carbohydrates or release oxygen molecules that animal life (like me) appear to need for survival. This is an example of how the metaphysical portion of the whole of all being becomes unveiled to us — how (new to us) evidence leads us to believe in theorized beings (that were there all along) that can now be used to make predictions about reality that appear reliably accurate.</p><p>A being does not need to be sensed in order to be part of the whole of all being, nor does it need my confirmation that it is a being. A being simply <em>is</em> whether I sense it (or acknowledge its being) or not. Beings do not appear to be static/unchanging either, beings appear to be constantly changing/moving from my perspective.</p><p>Clarifications</p><p>I am <em>not </em>referring to truth as “statements/cognitions that correspond to reality.” The truth I’m referring to <em>is</em> the whole of all being: the source of sensations, cognitions, and statements.</p><h3>SENSATION AND COGNITON</h3><p>I use the word <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/sensation-33308bad60a5">sensation </a>to mean “inputs”– sensation is the conversion of the parts of truth/beings (that I have receptors to receive) into a medium that I can internalize and cognize about. Any input is a sensation: light becomes sight, vibration becomes sound, chemicals become smells and tastes, pressure becomes touch, speed of molecules becomes temperature. Preference sensations (which I will discuss later) also appear to be brought on by the reception of chemical signaling molecules (Ligands, neurotransmitters, hormones) (source 2).</p><p>Sensation is the intake of information from truth into my inner experience. I call it an “inner” experience because it appears to only be experienced by me and not by anyone outside of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">what I consider myself to be</a>.</p><p>I will use the word <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognition </a>to mean the processing of sensory information — what I <em>do </em>with inputs/sensory information. Cognitions appear to also be inner experiences that I experience alone and are hidden from others until I express them.</p><p>One thing that I do with sensations when processing/cognizing them is categorize them (Source 1) — categorization is a “category of cognition.” Categorizations are a type of cognition that I use to put expressions and/or names to sensations (and cognitions). I also use them to put sensations (and cognitions) into named groups so I can familiarize myself with incoming sensory information more quickly and communicate with others about it. Categorizations are not truth; they are something I impose upon my sensations (and cognitions) of truth as a tool. The way that I categorize sensations and cognitions impacts how I understand them: what I pay attention to, and how I pay <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/attending-focus-14986a7bb72e">attention </a>to them. For instance, the categorization of “important information” vs “unimportant information” plays a big role in how I attend to the sensory and cognitive information that I put into those categories.</p><p>Making sure my categorizations are consistent with my observations of truth appears to help me accurately predict/guess future outcomes — For instance, if I categorize a cognition as unimportant when it <em>is</em> important, it can lead me to confidently make inaccurate predictions/guesses of future outcomes (using deductive reasoning) — For example, if I cognize that it is unimportant to breath oxygen to survive and I categorize that cognition as reasonable to believe, I may confidently swim deep underwater without giving myself enough time to get back to the surface for air and die of asphyxiation. This outcome contradicts my categorization of “reasonable to believe” for the cognition “I don’t need to breath oxygen to survive” because if it were reasonable to believe that I didn’t need to breath oxygen to survive, I wouldn’t constantly need to maintain a source of oxygen and I would be able to stay underwater without supplemental oxygen and not die of asphyxiation. (I’ll discuss more about reasonable belief in the epistemology section).</p><p>There are many other ways to categorize cognitions: sometimes they are dichotomous like true/false and sometimes they are on a continuum like hot ←warm →cold, and sometimes they are groups within groups like fruit: apple, orange, pear or vegetable: carrot, potato, turnip…</p><p>One way in which cognitions have been categorized by leading research psychologist Daniel Kahneman is fast/slow(Source 3). Fast cognitions are automatic intuitive cognitions (i.e. knee-jerk reactions or quick unthoughtful judgments) and slow cognitions are deliberate cognitions (i.e. careful deliberate scrutinized judgments). In this article, I am talking about truth seeking, which is a way of attending to my cognitions and sensations and attempting to process/categorize them accurately in a careful and deliberate way — I am talking about what Daniel Kahneman would categorize as “slow cognition” in this article.</p><p>In addition to categorizing sensations, I also wonder and guess about sensations and categorizations (Source 1). Wondering involves seeking more sensory information (and sifting through previously cognized information) in an attempt to make a more educated guess. Guessing involves jumping to a conclusion(Source 1); it could be a decision about putting a sensation or cognition into an established category or making a new category, or it could be making a prediction about what will happen in the future, and/or deciding upon an action to take. Jumping to conclusions/guessing quickly without question is an example of fast thinking, jumping to a tentative conclusion and maintaining a sense of wonder/questioning to scrutinize/check the conclusion and adapt the conclusion as more evidence comes in is an example of slow thinking.</p><p>I can <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize </a>my guesses by wondering more about them (I can seek more sensory information about how well my guesses correspond/contradict with more sensory experiences) and then I can adjust my guesses when a contradiction is detected, and the categorization/guess appears incorrect or incomplete. I can also wonder about my guesses by seeking more information about how my guesses correspond to one another — Do my guesses appear to align with one another or do they appear to contradict one another? I can use the answers to these questions along with more sensory experiences to help me weed out which contradictory cognitions appear to align most closely with truth and which ones do not. I do not have forever to decide however — I often must make quick decisions on the fly about my guesses to avoid threats that (I “guess”) might lead to my suffering and death, and to obtain/maintain homeostasis.</p><p>Below is a flow chart to visualize how I imagine the cognitive process may work. In the chart, you can see how one can choose to seek more information and attempt to keep perfecting their guesses (slow thinking) and conversely, how one can choose to maintain a first guess without seeking more information (fast thinking), and also how one can continue to maintain their first guess even as contradictions arise that should encourage a truth seeker to consider alternatives.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AZY1Wyla6r8AqpFbZt4KzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>(I devised my definition of cognition and this chart using what I’ve learned from reading a trusted secondary source — the writing of one of the world’s leading neuroscientists: Lisa Feldman Barrett. Feldman Barrett makes no mention of “wonder” in her writing. I’ve added it to represent incoming sensations that I don’t know what to do with — Wonders occur when we encounter ambiguous sensations that we don’t yet have enough information to place them definitively into a category. Though Feldman-Barrett makes no mention of “wonder,” in her lectures and books, she alludes to it when she shares a blobby incomprehensible picture and asks people to guess at what that blobby picture might be. When people accept her challenge, they enter what I would call a state of “wonder” from which they begin with open minded curiosity seeking to acquire more information from which to fabricate first guesses. To see Feldman Barret’s work and judge it for yourself, look at the source list at the end of this writing) — (I’ve also added into this model a reference to the findings of cognitive social scientist, Daniel Kahneman’s “Thinking Fast and Slow.” The bright green section signifies “fast thinking.” When thinking fast, a person guesses with their gut/intuition and doesn’t attempt to scrutinize their guess. Their trusted body of quick reference beliefs, denials, or wonders makes up their “intuition.” Intuited guesses are often “good enough” but are also often found to be incorrect when scrutinized with sensory evidence, especially when one’s body of beliefs is heavily dependent upon misinformation/disinformation that survived the original scrutinization phase of slow cognition. If a person is not careful to weed out misinformation/disinformation, their intuition becomes less reliable for making accurate predictions/guesses.)</figcaption></figure><h3>IDEALISM VS MATERIALISM</h3><p>It appears to me that truth/reality/”the common ground for all beings” is material and not ideal.</p><p>I cannot comprehend what my experience would be without sensory apparatuses that bring about my sensations(inputs). When a sensory apparatus is broken, it stops sending me information from truth. It leaves a gap in my ability to observe information that I previously had access to, and while my other sensations will attempt to compensate for a missing sensation (for instance when a person is blind they become better aware of their other sensitivities that don’t involve sight), the compensation does not completely fill in the gap, (a person who has always been totally blind their whole life does not appear to have the ability to observe visually or cognize what things look like).</p><p>If all of my sensory apparatuses were broken, what would that be like? If “I” were born with no sensory apparatuses, it seems that I would have no sensory experience and therefore no inputs to cognize/process. I don’t know that I could say that “I” even exist; how would I have a sense of myself? I also don’t know if I could say “I do not have any experience at all,” because living without sensation isn’t something I have any experience with (the idea is out of bounds for me). But, I’m drawing a blank on what such an experience would entail (if anything at all). I can wonder about it and guess about it, but I have no ability to check/scrutinize those guesses with my senses because I have no way of experiencing a senseless existence — My experience appears entirely brought on by my senses which are dependent upon my sensory apparatuses.</p><p>Even abstract concepts like mathematics appear meaningless without initial experiences of sensation. Numbers, symbols, or formulas are meaningless to me until I categorize — attach sensed information to those numbers, symbols and formulas. The notation 2+2=4 does not appear to mean anything to me (except sounds or marks on a page) without sensory experience that gives meaning to those values and symbols.</p><h3>Cognition Appears Dependent Upon Sensation</h3><p>My ability to cognize appears to require inputs. I <em>can</em>, think of a purple cat even though I don’t have experience with purple cats, because I can put two remembered beings that I’ve sensed together in my cognition, I have experience with cats and I have experience of the color purple, so I can guess at what a purple cat would look like and visualize that idea in my inner world or draw a picture of it. But it does not appear that I can cognize something that I have no experience with — I can’t cognize a cat that is a color that isn’t in my visual spectrum of light. Can you picture in your cognition a color that isn’t part of your visual light spectrum? It does not appear to me that I can. I do not appear to have any cognitions without first having sensory experiences that lead to those cognitions.</p><p><strong>The Matrix?</strong></p><p>My cognitions appear to me to be dependent upon the sensations I gather from truth and not the other way around. Truth does not appear to me to be dependent upon my sensation or cognition. However, there may be more to my sensory experience than the apparent sensation of physical beings. Is my sensory experience a holographic simulation? Am I living in a Matrix type situation where I am essentially a brain in a vat, and all of my sensations of beings (of molecules, photons, vibrations, organelles) are made up by some “ultimate reality computer programmer” and delivered to me through a cable that’s plugged into my cognition? Is there a metaphysical omnipotent God or “consciousness,” beyond my sense abilities, that builds and sends into my cognition the universe of information that I call truth that stimulates my sensory apparatuses? <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/does-truth-exist-26fddbe03de9">Is truth not ultimately real?</a></p><p>These are cognitions that cannot be confirmed by my sensations (because I don’t have any sensations of an ultimate reality computer programmer, an omnipotent God, or a “consciousness” beyond my sense abilities plugged into my brain), but that doesn’t mean they can’t exist in the metaphysical portion of truth beyond my awareness. It does appear to be the case that my sensitivity <em>is</em> limited and I am already aware that there are beings that I cannot sense — like colors beyond the visible light spectrum or things that, in earlier human history, were not even thought of as “existing” — like the Higgs Boson. It does appear that these cognitions about ultimate reality, God, and the Matrix are possibly true but it also appears that they are equally possibly false. I don’t have the means to observe the validity and confirm or disconfirm these cognitions with the sensory apparatuses that I have, because these potential “metaphysical things” are beyond sensation.</p><p>Does it matter if I’m living in the matrix or if there is an omnipotent God who delivers all of my experiences? I have no sensory awareness of those potential beings — I experience nothing about them that I am aware of. I can only confirm that they are in my cognition. Their existence/non existence appears to have no impact on my experience that I can point to and confirm: these are beings, not cognitions. I don’t bump into them, smell them, touch them, I cannot eat them for sustenance, there is no evidence gained from my cognition of them that reliably predicts future occurrences in the common ground truth.</p><p>Does it matter whether or not my sensations are a hologram? What alternative to sensory information might I use as a more reliable guide to navigate in my life? Whether they are “ultimately real” or not, sensations of “beings” that I have awareness of are what I experience; they appear to be what my cognitions are built upon. Sensations provide invaluable clues that I use as reliable guides to maintain my survival and relieve my suffering — they appear to help me make accurate predictions when I learn to interpret them effectively — predictions that I could not make without sensation, predictions that allow me to survive and alleviate suffering (like the prediction that I will always need oxygen to survive) –</p><p>Is it true or false that I exist? Is it true or false that truth exists? Is it true or false that the Matrix or an omnipotent god exists? I ask many questions (like these) for which I have no evidence to cognize an evidence-based guess. What do I do with those questions, and how do I categorize the answers to those questions as true/false? Let’s talk about Epistemology.</p><h3>MOTIVATON BEHIND EPISTEMOLOGY</h3><p>I’ll first discuss why I <em>want </em>to correctly categorize cognitions as true/false:</p><p>One apparent category of sensation/input that I experience are sensations of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference</a>. These sensations appear to me to be chemical sensations because of the way receptors inside my body receive chemical signaling molecules and there is a resulting experience of preference (Sources 1 &amp; 2). When particular molecules (i.e. dopamine, serotonin, and oxytocin) are received by receptors in my body I experience complex feelings that I call “pleasure/ease.” Other molecules (i.e. adrenaline, epinephrin and cortisol) appear to be involved in my feelings of suffering/dis-ease(Source 2). The chemicals are produced by my body(Source 2). They are the portions of truth that I receive through receptors, and ease/dis-ease becomes the resulting input/sensation that I cognize/process. This appears similar to the way that a vibration detected by hair cells in my ears results in the input/sensation of sound that I experience, or chemicals received inside my nose becomes an input/sensation of smells. Preference sensations are experienced as my personal feelings of ease/dis-ease and result in motivations for approach/maintain and avoidance actions(Sources 1&amp;2). (“Valence” appears to be the word that psychologists use for what I call “preference sensations”(Source 1)).</p><p>‌ Preference sensations appear to encourage and/or compel me to be more than just an observer. Actions that feel compelled are reflexive or habitual, like when I jump when startled, or I behave habitually like I do when I go through my morning tooth brushing. Actions that feel encouraged are actions that I can deliberate about and make a decision. When not compelled by my preference sensations, I may feel encouraged to think or “cognize” about the preference sensations that I am having (slow deliberate cognition).</p><p>Thinking/cognizing deliberately appears to entail wondering and guessing about what the preference sensations are telling me. Am I experiencing net ease or dis-ease? Why do I feel that way? What do I do/not do about it? How do I prefer to behave to achieve what I intend (attain net ease and/or pleasure and avoid net dis-ease and/or displeasure)? I wonder and guess about how to guide my behavior to approach preferred outcomes (<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">intentions</a>) that I predict/guess will promote sensations of net pleasure and/or ease (often survival, wellness/homeostasis/allostasis, gain…and also exhilaration and excitement). I also wonder and guess about how to guide my behavior to avoid unpreferred outcomes of net displeasure and/or disease (often trauma, death, starvation, loss… and also boredom and depression).</p><p>Negative preference sensations (sensations of dis-ease and/or displeasure) often alert me to what I call “problems;” problems that I feel the need to solve (I am experiencing preference sensations that feel intolerable, and I feel the need to end these feelings with some kind of change that requires action). But are those problems true/real (like starvation, injury, dehydration, the presence of predators…) or are they false/mistaken (like a nonexistent monster under the bed, phantom pain, or lies like “the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School was a hoax”)? Putting effort and attention into attempting to solve problems that turn out to be false is risky; it can result in net losses — I expend energy for potentially no gain or worse: my efforts can lead toward my demise or the demise of people or causes that I care about or intend to protect.</p><p>Not all negative preference sensations appear to be felt universally among all sentient beings (not everyone dislikes violence, risk, or pain all the time), but some negative preference sensations <em>do </em>appear to be felt universally under certain conditions. Universally, humans appear to prefer “homeostasis” — a balancing of “resources in” with “resources out.”(Source 1) Humans do not like/prefer to expend a lot of their limited time, hard earned energy, and other resources on efforts that lead to net loss for themselves and those they care about(Source 3)(like losing sleep over a nonexistent monster under the bed or harassing parents whose children were murdered in a tragic school shooting). Efforts like these that result in net losses appear to elicit universally negative preference sensations (dis-ease/displeasure) in humans like feelings we call intense disappointment, frustration, and disgust (when I acknowledge/categorize them as net losses anyway). It even appears that net losses elicit greater dis-ease/displeasure than net gains elicit pleasure(Source 7).</p><p>Net losses appear to be things humans all <em>very </em>much wish to avoid.</p><p>To avoid net losses, I can practice deliberately and carefully <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-feel-the-way-that-i-feel-0d02164787b8">interpreting the causes of my negative preference sensations</a>, and determining if the causes appear false so that I don’t expend energy on cognized problems that don’t exist. Additionally, to avoid net losses I need to align my beliefs with “true cognitions” and my denials with “false cognitions.” Beliefs are a category of cognition, cognitions that I trust. I listen to them (i.e. believing the cognition that I need oxygen to survive — this belief leads me to an intention to plan my actions around maintaining a constant source of oxygen). Denials are cognitions that I do not trust, I do not listen to them; instead, I ignore them (like denying the cognition that there is a monster under my bed — this denial leads me to tell myself that this monster is just in my head, and I intend to ignore/settle down the unpleasant feelings I’m having, stay calm, and get some sleep). Believing in true cognitions and denying false cognitions helps me avoid listening to misleading preference sensations from false causes and deduce accurate predictions that lead me toward actions that avoid predicted net loss and actions to obtain predicted net gain for myself and the people/causes I care about.</p><h4>Confirmation Bias and Cognitive Dissonance Theory</h4><p><strong>Motivation to Maintain False Beliefs</strong></p><p>I use my beliefs and denials to make statements that I use as premises in deductive reasoning to predict future outcomes. When the resulting predictions are reliably accurate, it appears to me that I correctly categorized my cognitions as true/false and believe/deny: they lead me toward behaviors that achieve my preferred outcomes, and lead me to avoid behaviors that lead to unpreferred outcomes (like net losses). But, just because a belief/denial appears correct, does not mean that it <em>is </em>correct.</p><p>Sometimes I get things wrong, and I sometimes don’t look for, ignore, or don’t see the signs that I am wrong, and only pay attention to the signs that I am correct. Not looking for, ignoring, or not seeing signs that I am wrong is a scientifically observed phenomenon called confirmation bias(Source 3). Confirmation bias is a universally common human behavior(Source 3).</p><p>Another common mental trick that humans use to preserve cognitions that misalign with observation/evidence is described in Leon Festinger’s Cognitive Dissonance Theory. When a belief is contradicted by new evidence, a person has some choices. They can change their belief to align with the evidence, they can ignore or destroy the evidence, or they can change the way they think about the evidence (say something like “the evidence isn’t relevant”). When a person has a strong preference for a belief to be true (they feel a “need” for it to be true), they become attached to the belief and will defend the belief even when the evidence clearly contradicts it (I call this <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">objectification</a>. I will discuss more about objectification later). Each time they defend the belief and deny the contradiction, the need for the belief to be true can get stronger. Admitting the belief was false means that all of the effort they put into defending the false belief was not advantageous, and they need the belief to be true even more. — They don’t want to admit that they exerted greater and greater amounts of effort for net loss, especially if their efforts would look detrimental to their character. For example, if they justified an action that others might consider unsavory or immoral in service of the false belief, such as gullibility, destroying evidence, lying, harassment, bullying, or murder(Source 5).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xuR4LzXtrclmBIoVFm50yg.jpeg" /><figcaption>(This visual aid depicting cognitive dissonance was modified to fit the vocabulary that I am using in this article. The original visual aid came from simply psychology.org (Source 6)).</figcaption></figure><p>Learning is inhibited by confirmation bias and mental tricks from Cognitive Dissonance Theory. When contradictions are detected (when my actions don’t result in the outcomes I’d planned and I notice/attend to the discrepancy), I can analyze what went wrong and try to avoid the same mistakes again. This appears to be how learning happens. But, if I won’t look at the evidence of mistakes; if I ignore the evidence that I’ve categorized a cognition incorrectly, these beliefs often lead me toward unpreferred outcomes of displeasure/dis-ease that could have been avoided had I recategorized my cognitions based upon the new evidence. If I deny cognitions that are true, they often lead me to ignore important information that could have helped me make a more accurate prediction more efficiently. As a result, I don’t see my mistakes, and I don’t learn from them.</p><p><strong>Conclusion for the Motivation Behind Epistemology</strong></p><p>Categorizing true/false accurately and aligning belief/denial with true/false appears useful in deductive reasoning to help me guess at/predict actual future happenings in truth, and home in on what outcomes certain actions may achieve. I can then assess those predicted outcomes as {desirable, approachable, safe} and/or {undesirable, something to avoid, dangerous}, and make an informed decision about potential net losses/gains and how I want to proceed with approach, maintain, or avoid actions. I no longer feel like I’m just guessing. I am learning, I’m making educated guesses. Guesses that appear informed by sensory evidence gathered from truth (the common ground); guesses that appear to have a higher likelihood of predicting future outcomes.</p><p>Checking the accuracy of my categorizations of cognitions and correcting my mistaken categorizations (learning) requires time and effort, but it appears to be worth it (when I have time and energy) especially when the risk of net loss is high(Source 3). Avoiding predictable and highly undesirable net losses(Source 3)and approaching/maintaining predictable and desirable net gains (approaching homeostasis)(Source 1) appear to be worthy motivations for putting effort into categorizing true/false accurately and aligning belief/denial with true/false. These motivations appear to align with my scrutinized cognitions about my experience, but the more difficult question is: How do I determine what is true and what is false?</p><h3>A DIFFERENT THEORY OF TRUTH &amp; A DIFFERENT DEFINITION FOR KNOWLEDGE</h3><p>In this section I will first emphasize how the “the common ground whole of all being” theory of truth that I have been using differs from other theories of truth. I will then discuss a revised definition for <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">knowledge</a>.</p><p>Other theories of truth attempt to define what makes a “statement” or “belief” true. The way that “the common ground whole of all being” theory of truth differs from other theories is that truth is not made up of “statements.” Truth, the common ground whole of all being, is not statements, but rather physical being. Truth appears rich and complex and appears to include elements beyond my comprehension, but I appear to gather clues about it through sensation.</p><p>It appears that I harvest clues about truth through my sensory apparatuses. My sensations are far from identical to truth (reflected light becomes sight, vibrations become sounds, chemicals become smells, tastes, preferences). Truth (the whole of all being) and sensations (the bits and pieces of experienced information that I gather from my sensory apparatuses) are two different things — Truth is the authority and my sensations are appearances that yield to that authority — My sensations do not have the authority to qualify/justify which cognitions/statements are “true” — they can only qualify what “<em>appears</em> true.” The cognitions that arise from my sensations are not truth either, nor are my statements which are expressed cognitions through language. Truth is true. My statements are expressed sensations, cognitions, and intuitions. When my statements appear accurate/true to me, it is because they appear to align with evidence gathered from my sensations when I carefully review them and scrutinize them with my sensations to double check their accuracy — But, sensations are just appearances, they cannot qualify/justify the “truthfulness” of my statements. My sensations are not “truth, the whole of all being.” Using sensations to qualify/justify sensations (or statements which are expressed cognitions that originate from sensations) as true appears to me to be a form of circular reasoning (I am not saying that knowledge and learning are not possible. I am saying that the way we traditionally define knowledge as “justified true belief” does not work in the language game that I am playing, and I need to revise the definition).</p><h4>Circular Reasoning in Justified True Belief</h4><p>Knowledge is traditionally defined as “justified true belief.” Using correspondence theory of truth, a belief or statement becomes justified when it aligns with “what is the case.” But, the only tools at my disposal for scrutinizing and confirming “what is the case” are my limited sensations, cognitions, and intuitions (and other sentient beings who may help me to scrutinize and confirm my sensations, cognitions, and intuitions are also using their limited sensations to justify their beliefs). Sensations, cognitions, and intuitions are not identical to “what is the case” (truth). Not one of us has access to what <em>is</em> the case (truth). I/we have access only to what <em>appears</em> to my/our sensations and cognitions to “be the case.” Not one of us, nor all of us has the means to confirm with absolute certainty “what is the case” for the whole of all being truth — what we experience through sensation is not identical to truth. It is circular to evaluate the validity of human sensations, cognitions, and intuitions about “what <em>is</em> the case” by using human sensations and cognitions about “what <em>appears</em> to be the case.”</p><p>Holding rigidly to my sensations, cognitions, and intuitions about truth/“what appears to be the case,” without acknowledging the deeper layer of truth/what <em>is</em> the case (beyond my awareness) is something that I call “objectification” (which I mentioned earlier in the cognitive dissonance section). This circular reasoning process of declaring a belief “justified true” leads to objectification. Objectification is problematic to the truth-seeking process, and I will discuss this problem more in depth after I offer an alternative definition for knowledge.</p><h4>Reasonableness and a Different Definition for Knowledge</h4><p>With the common ground whole of all being theory of truth that I am using, statements/cognitions are not evaluated on a true/false dichotomy. They are instead evaluated for “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">reasonableness</a>” using scrutinized sensory evidence, and placed on a continuum of:</p><p>Believe&lt; — Wonder →Deny (see table below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ky-ysSU_MpW5vFSouCKWxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image Created by the Author</figcaption></figure><p>When I speak matter-of-factly or say “I know” something, what I’m saying is that I believe it, and it appears reasonable to me to believe because the preponderance of sensory evidence that I’ve encountered so far leads me to believe it is true– I’m not implying that my belief is “justified true.”</p><p>A cognition/statement that is supported by a great deal of sensory evidence and has not yet been contradicted (like 2+2=4) appears very reasonable to believe and unreasonable to deny, it appears to approach “true belief” status, but it never gets there, because truth isn’t something I can confirm using the only tools at my disposal: my sensations, cognitions, and language. It isn’t blasphemous to wonder if a strong belief that appears very reasonable is absolutely true, it isn’t unacceptable to question a strong belief like 2+2=4 (though it may seem ridiculous). If the belief is worthy of its strong belief status, it will hold up to scrutiny, and if it doesn’t hold up to scrutiny, the wondering/questioning can help lead us to categorize our cognitions/statements in a way that appears even more reasonable (evidence-based — so long as the evidence is very well scrutinized). Playfully wondering about the validity of strong beliefs/denials is often where evidence-based corrections/paradigm shifts begin that help humanity course correct toward cognitions and statements that appear to better align to sensations harvested from “common ground whole of all being truth.” <em>But</em>, it can also lead people who aren’t carefully scrutinizing their evidence to be manipulated to believe/deny unsupported cognitions/statements, so truth seekers should heavily scrutinize evidence that encourages them to abandon beliefs/denials that are well supported by the greatest amounts of heavily scrutinized evidence, without contradiction, and lead to predictions that appear to produce consistently accurate outcomes (like mathematical and scientific proofs).</p><p>Truth is true, statements about truth are sensations, cognitions, and intuitions expressed through language, and whether they are reasonable statements/expressions (or not) depends upon the evidence at hand that supports the categorization that I’ve given to them. Reasonable statements correspond to sensory evidence from truth, but reasonable statements are not my very best guesses; I can also scrutinize my reasonable statements with a rigorous comparison between the statement and more sensory observation (my own or an expressed sensory observation from a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">secondary source who appears reasonable and reliable </a>because of their great deal of experience with the evidence on a subject, and ability to use such evidence to make accurate predictions). A statement and the evidentiary support for my categorization can always be more heavily scrutinized with more time and experience. There is no end to the amount of scrutinization a statement or a piece of evidence can receive. A statement can gain “reasonableness to believe” upon further scrutiny and supporting scrutinized evidence without contradiction, but it never becomes an unquestionable maxim/”self-evident truth” or “justified true belief.”</p><p>If I intend to be a “reasonable truth seeker” (using this theory of truth), I should believe cognitions when the available sensory evidence appears to support them, deny cognitions when the available sensory evidence appears to contradict them, and maintain a sense of wonder for cognitions when the available sensory evidence appears inconclusive or not available. (Each of us observes truth from a unique perspective and is using a different pool of sensory evidence, and often our vocabulary differs, so a statement that appears reasonable to me may not appear reasonable to someone else at first glance, especially if their experiences or vocabulary differ from mine. Contradictions and disagreements should be anticipated.)</p><p>Ranking cognitions and statements on a continuum based upon sensory evidence rather than using a dichotomous true/false determination seems more honest: more matched to my experience, more reasonable. It also seems more useful because it helps me to categorize, and converse with others, about less supported cognitions that don’t fit neatly into the true/false dichotomy. There is space for wonder, and some cognitions may stay in the wonder category perpetually, like the statement “the universe infinite.” We cannot confirm this statement. We have not found an end of the universe, but just because we haven’t found it does not mean that it <em>is</em> infinite(Source 14).</p><p>Knowledge, by my definition is not “justified true belief.” It is instead my best guess: Reasonable/evidence-based categorizations of guesses into the categories of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">belief/wonder/deny</a>. The categorizations are reasonable because the categorization is supported by scrutinized evidence and my “very best guesses” are those that are reasonable, scrutinized/checked, appear supported by observable evidence, do not appear to contradict observed evidence, and help me make reliably accurate predictions.</p><h4>The Trouble with Objectification</h4><p>Language, models, heuristics, categorizations and statements are expressed cognitions, and they are necessary tools for us to learn and communicate with one another about our sensations and cognitions, but it is important that we don’t confuse our language, models, heuristics, categorizations, and statements with truth — “what is the case.”</p><p>I’ve defined <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">objectification </a>as rigidly holding onto man-made cognitions/statements instead of letting the growing body of sensory evidence be the more authoritative guide for what to believe/wonder/deny about truth. Objectification derails my truth-seeking process, because I become prone to attending to the objectification/idea/cognition as “the truth” instead of attending to the ever-growing body of evidence gathered from sensations as clues to “the truth.” Using the common ground whole of all being theory of truth, there is only one truth, and it isn’t my sensation/statements/cognitions, it is the whole of all being. Holding rigidly to objectifications leads to cognitive dissonance and confirmation bias, and less curiosity about alternative possibilities and new evidence from truth that contradict conventionally accepted cognition categorizations.</p><p>When strongly held belief categorizations (objectifications) do not align with evidence, cognitive dissonance occurs: unpleasant feelings occur. Letting go of rigidly adhered to objectified versions of truth (strongly believed statements) feels like net loss for people who’ve come to rely upon them. It is often called “blasphemous.” The objectification might be a belief that the user built their entire body of beliefs upon: their way of life, their community, their sense of right and wrong, their knowledge. Without the objectification, it seems like everything will be lost, unguided: placed back in the wonder loop to be reconfigured. That feels like a net loss to the objectifying individual (Source 5), but ignoring the evidence often leads to greater net losses for the individual and for society:</p><p>Scientists who get stuck on objectifications miss out on new discoveries. Consider how Einstein’s theory of relativity led physicists to see beyond the standard models of physics (which was already showing signs of insufficiency). Those scientists who were unwilling to question the standard model of physics, missed out tremendously by not considering the validity of the theories that Einstein proposed. Also, consider how changing the 3 kingdom model of classification of life (a previous foundational model that included plants, animals, and fungi) to a 5 kingdom model (still a model, but slightly less objectified) helped scientists more easily theorize how organelles in eukaryotic cells (like mitochondria and chloroplasts) may have been independent living organisms that perhaps came together in a cell membrane to form symbiotic relationships that began what we now call plant and animal life (source 8). Evolution may not simply be “survival of the fittest” but also “survival of the cooperative.”</p><p>There are also countless examples throughout the history of human civilization in which objectification has led to great net loss. Examples of masses of people being encouraged to see “the other” (masses of different races, sexes, classes, religions…) as caricatures (objectified/stereotyped versions of people) rather than as complex human individuals (bits of truth) to be curious about and learn about. Objectifiers often feel justified in quickly categorizing “the other” as “bad,” “dumb,” “scary,” “immoral,” “less than”… and treating “the other” in a way that the objectifier would not want to be treated (lumped into a group and judged). Sometimes this leads the objectifier to experience and act upon misguided righteous indignation: discrimination, bullying and has even led to slavery and genocide historically… Objectification appears to lead to actions that would likely be considered unethical/immoral if the objectification wasn’t used; actions like intentionally inflicting harm on “innocent others” whose actions and intentions appear well-meaning (I’ll discuss more about this in the morality section).</p><p>Committing harm toward innocents feels like net loss. People who’ve committed harm toward innocents in service to objectifications, and then later abandon the objectification often express great remorse for their behavior. Objectifiers who do not let go of the objectification miss out on what cooperation with “the other” could have looked like: what “the other” could have offered society if they weren’t treated poorly for no apparent reason. They also continue to inflict harm on innocents unthinkingly because it’s just the way things are. What is the net benefit to society when well meaning, capable, and hard-working people are treated poorly because others misjudge them? What is the net benefit to society when large swaths of society are discriminated against and prevented from seeking the same gains as everyone else? There is a great deal of evidence for how objectification appears to lead to net loss for the greater whole of society.</p><p>The common ground whole of all being theory of truth differs slightly from other theories of truth because the authority for “what is the case” is the whole of all being. Truth (what is the case/the common ground whole of all being) isn’t made of words/statements or cognitions. The bits of sensory evidence gathered from truth are merely appearances, and statements about those appearances are evaluated for reasonableness based upon supporting sensory evidence. That slight difference of not calling knowledge “justified true” is crucial to avoiding objectifications — (confusing what <em>is</em> the case with what <em>appears</em> to be the case) which lead to overall net loss for individuals and society. Avoiding objectifications also leads to greater curiosity and opportunities for learning when contradictions to conventional models become evident and new evidence supported models become available. These instances appear to make evident the advantages of letting go of rigidly adhered to unfounded objectifications. It appears to be more reasonable and advantageous to adapt one’s belief/wonder/denial categorization to the ever-growing body of scrutinized evidence, rather than ignoring the evidence and rigidly clinging to less supported objectifications that maintain misalignment with scrutinized evidence, and lead to inaccurate predictions or unreliable predictions.</p><h4>Conflicting Knowledge:</h4><p>Using the common ground whole of all being theory of truth, truth is one thing. It is not relative. But, truth’s composition is constantly changing (from our limited spatial and temporal perspective) in ways that it appears that we can sometimes predict (reasonably well). Knowledge (each person’s body of best guesses about truth) <em>is</em> relative and malleable. What do we do when my knowledge contradicts with yours — how are disagreements resolved?</p><p>In the common ground whole of all being theory of truth, analyzing each of our categorizations/definitions/vocabulary as well as analyzing the evidence that supports a cognition categorization (of belief/wonder/denial) offers us an evidence-based understanding of why we disagree.</p><p>Contradictions are expected and considered with curiosity (so long as we can anticipate that initial negative preference sensations will likely occur under the pressure of cognitive dissonance when contradictions to strongly held beliefs arise (Source 5) and try to take a breath and relax as they arise). We can approach the contradiction with curiosity by acknowledging that there are other valid points of view and asking: Why do we disagree? Are there differences in our vocabulary? What evidence are we attending to? How does it differ? What level of scrutinization has the evidence endured? Is it possible that a difference of preference led to the disagreement? We can then investigate why <em>that</em> difference exists — Are our preferences different because of an unsupported cognition categorization, a faulty memory, a difference of evidence or experience that we can discuss and come to an understanding on? Or do our differing preferences appear more ingrained in our genetics (Source 15) and personality and not easily reconcilable? Or is it something else?</p><p>If I ask questions curiously and try to understand where our differences come from through dialog and interaction, we may not come to an agreement, but I will at least “know” or “have a reasonable evidence-based guess” about where we differ and why. In my experience, it’s unlikely that the other person appears “out of their mind” or appears deliberately trying to mislead me — though I can get a better feel for that possibility by having these kinds of curious conversations and questioning a person’s evidence, preference sensations, and cognitive processes, as well as considering their body language and non-verbal evidence. (I’m not discovering “the truth” about whether or not to trust someone by looking at this evidence, I’m just developing “my best guess” which can be constantly reassessed as I encounter new evidence, until a decision to trust/not trust needs to be made, but still I can always continue to reassess my guesses about a person’s trustworthiness on a topic after the initial guess is made, or not).</p><p>Adding the wonder category between belief and denial creates a space for reasonable contradictory statements — we might not be able to conclude whose “best guesses” appear more or less accurate (we might leave it up to wonder — agree to disagree).</p><p>Changing the definition of knowledge to “a best guess” and ranking guesses using supporting scrutinized evidence creates a hierarchy of knowledge. We can often resolve our differences with curiosity — figuring out whose evidence appears more scrutinized, accurate to observation, thorough and plentiful. This curiosity can result in learning from and understanding one another rather than attempting to brow beat one another with rhetoric or threats of violence.</p><p>A productive conversation may be impossible, however, if one’s cognition categorizations are heavily objectifying/not evidence-based. The connection to common ground truth becomes broken if one rigidly holds to objectifications– their attention isn’t on seeking truth, it’s on maintaining a statement/belief/objectification — They are on a tangent. There might be so much discord in how one person or both people rigidly categorize their cognitions without aligning them to scrutinized evidentiary support that finding common ground is not possible. When discussing cognition categorization with a person who shows evidence of using objectification/confirmation bias/mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory, and they are unwilling to consider that those tactics are unreasonable, then it appears likely that the conversation may be unproductive and not an exploration of varying perspectives of the common ground truth — it may become a non-listening expression of tangential caricatures of (each objectifier’s perspective) of the common ground truth.</p><h3>BELIEF CATEGORIZATION AND ACTION</h3><p>Categorizing beliefs/wonders/denials according to scrutinized evidence available appears useful in the cultivation of reasonable/evidence-based deliberate <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions</a>.</p><p>Preference sensations encourage actions. My categorization of beliefs/denials/wonders appear to help dictate which of my preference sensations I listen to and which preference sensations I discard. The relativity of our personal experiences and cognition categorizations may account for why one person’s preferences/actions might seem totally justified to themselves, and to another person they seem totally unjustified. Let’s discuss more about how beliefs/wonders/denials appear to me to lead to actions.</p><h4>Actions</h4><p>I will define an action as a thing that is done. It is what I do. It is what others do also. Actions have an impact on/move/change/modify bits of truth. They impact truth’s composition — they impact how bits of truth (photons, energy, atoms, protons, molecules…) are arranged. Our actions, because they are visible and impactful to others in the world of beings, are where thoughts/cognitions/inner-world medium are translated into observable things/happenings/“alterations of being medium” that can then be sensed and cognized by myself and others.</p><p>The arrangement of bits of truth (and my actions) are consequential to how truth appears to me and other sentient beings and how we feel about truth (and even whether or not our bodies can continue to survive and thrive in it). Not only am I a composer within truth, my body is also a part of the composition and through my bodily sensory apparatuses, I experience how the parts of truth (in my general vicinity) that I am sensitive to are composed at each moment.</p><p><strong>How Do Deliberate Actions Happen?</strong></p><p>In my understanding and experience, my deliberate actions/behaviors don’t seem to “just happen.” My deliberate actions appear cultivated. They appear to be a result of causes that I have some influence on. Deliberate actions do not appear to be completely pre-determined without “my” influence. They feel different from actions that are compelled (like when I jump from being startled).</p><p>The causes of my deliberate actions appear to be a direct result of my preference sensations (chemical changes inside my body that correspond with feelings of attraction/positive preference sensations and feelings of avoidance/negative preference sensations)(Source 1). I do not see how I become motivated to perform actions without the experience of preference sensations/feelings of attraction and avoidance. However, I am not saying that I have no free will. It appears to me that I do have some control over how some of my preference sensations impact my behavior. That control seems to be rooted in how I choose to categorize my cognitions as beliefs/wonders/denials and that categorization impacts how I receive (believe), proceed with caution (wonder), or reject (deny) the preference sensations that result from such belief, wonders, and denials. I’ll discuss more about that shortly.</p><p><strong>Cultivation of Deliberate Actions</strong></p><p>Sometimes I prefer/decide to carry out very deliberate actions, like when I’m working on a dangerous project where accuracy is crucial to the survival or safety of myself or others. Sometimes, I prefer to “feel my feelings” in a less controlled way and let them “move” me — like when I am at a concert or dancing, or when I’m really sad and let myself cry, or when I am furious I may let myself yell or break something (sadness and anger are emotion words that I use to describe more specifically my preference sensations).</p><p>I do appear to have the ability (in many instances) to decide/deliberate/choose when I will let myself indulge in preference sensations; when I will let them build up into stronger compelling sensations that impact my actions/choices. I can also choose to try to quiet those preference sensations and avoid letting them impact my choices/actions. I do that by “rationalizing” with myself: telling myself “this preference sensation isn’t worth listening to right now” perhaps because it doesn’t seem appropriate — I tell myself “people don’t behave freely in places like this” or perhaps because the preference sensation is from a cognition that does not appear to be rooted in evidence (like the cognition that there is a monster under my bed) — I can tell myself “there does not appear to be any truth to this cognition” and I will try not to allow preference sensations from that cognition to impact my behavior.</p><p>Deliberate actions don’t appear to just happen; they appear to me to be cultivated in part by how I’ve categorized cognitions into beliefs/wonders/denials about truth.</p><h4><strong>Belief/Wonder/Deny &amp; Preference Sensations &amp; Actions</strong></h4><p>Beliefs are cognitions that I categorize to be guesses that appear accurate to me. Reasonable beliefs are guesses that appear accurate because they appear to align with sensory evidence gathered from truth and don’t appear to contradict it. I take beliefs seriously. I use them to inform preference sensations that I trust to inform deliberate actions with minimal reservation. They can be strong to weak- I don’t often question my strong beliefs unless there is very strong evidence against them (and even then, I may be very skeptical of the evidence). When someone else disagrees with my strong beliefs, I will often feel strong negative preference sensations (How could someone not believe what seems to align with my scrutinized evidence? Why are they not feeling strong negative preference sensations about something that I’m feeling strong negative preference sensations about? — What is “wrong” with them?). But weak beliefs are closer to wonders. I more easily question and modify them. I get less upset when disagreements arise — I am more curious about their reactions, ask more questions, and feel less furious/defensive when weak beliefs are called into question.</p><p>Cognitive Dissonance Theory shows that we feel negative preference sensations when strong beliefs are thrown into question/wonder, and we may experience an aversion to recategorizing a strong belief as a wonder when it is called into question even when the evidence makes it highly reasonable to do so (Source 5). For this reason, it seems for the interests of truth seeking, we should only label a cognition as a “strong belief” if it is does not contradict evidence and is supported by a great deal of heavily scrutinized evidence that appears reliable, and even then, leave open the possibility that I might be missing something. A belief doesn’t become “justified true,” it approaches what appears true based upon the evidence I’m aware of.</p><p>Wonders are cognitions that I don’t know what to do with — I keep an open mind and seek more information in hopes of making a more informed decision in the future. I try not to get “too worked up” or “let my preference sensations from these cognitions compel me to act brashly” unless I must make a choice on what to do immediately (I often cannot vacillate forever even though I don’t have enough information). And, when I need to make a choice to act that I don’t totally believe in, I don’t do so confidently — I act, and I don’t take the results of my action for granted — I acknowledge that “I’m just winging it right now,” and then I seek to understand the result of my actions so that I can learn to home in on a more appropriate and evidence-based action for future occurrences (I take the result of my actions as evidence in the learning experience).</p><p>Denials are cognitions that I don’t think are accurate. I don’t take them seriously. I don’t use them to inform my actions. I often laugh at them because they seem so absurd. For instance, the cognition that I can fly unaided is a cognition that I have begrudgingly come to deny. When I have the idea/cognition that I would like to fly over the Grand Canyon unaided, I laugh at it, I don’t take it seriously, and I don’t try to fly over the Grand Canyon. I have never been able to fly unaided even though I really want to. There is also plenty of reliable evidence to show what happens to people when they step off the edge of the Grand Canyon; 100% of them do not fly to the other side. I can’t know for sure that I can’t fly without trying… but it doesn’t seem very reasonable to believe or even wonder if I can unless I do so playfully/not seriously.</p><h4>Actions Speak Louder Than Words</h4><p>Actions are much more telling than words when it comes to trying to understand what someone believes/wonders/denies. I can “tell” you that I categorize a cognition as a belief/wonder/denial, but that isn’t the whole story. What matters is how I treat the cognition: Do I appear to take the cognition seriously; do I confidently use it to inform my logical deductions and actions that I feel justified in taking (believe); do I appear to ignore or laugh off the cognition (deny), or do I appear to vacillate about it and use it to explore/experiment and try to seek more information and use the cognition cautiously (wonder)?</p><h4>Cognition, Cognition Categorization &amp; The Cultivation of Reasonable Actions</h4><p>Below is a model of how I imagine the components of {Cognition}and {Cognition Categorization/Belief, Denial &amp; Wonder} fit together to cultivate preference sensations and actions that a person will find reasonable, and how their preference sensations and the observation of their action outcomes cycle back into the pool of truth/reality to be sensed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qZMmZQ6A_GG-pIht8DI8FA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image Created by the Author</figcaption></figure><h4>Garbage in, Garbage out</h4><p>The provided illustration above adds to the story I’ve been building about intuition cultivation and how it impacts the cultivation of my preference sensations and deliberate as well as intuited actions (and possibly even compelled reactions).</p><p><strong>The Chain Reaction: </strong>How I categorize my cognitions as beliefs/wonders/denials appears to impact how I treat those cognitions and the preference sensations that they inspire. Preference sensations from beliefs that I trust often lead to actions. Preference sensations from denials that I don’t trust lead me to ignore them. Preference sensations from wonders that I’m not sure of often lead me to consider acting upon them, and if I choose to act, I proceed cautiously or experimentally.</p><p><strong>Doomed From the Start: </strong>The illustration also shows a couple of ways in which the cognitive process that I’ve described can lead me to accidentally fall into unreasonable beliefs/wonders/denials and unreasonable preference sensations, which result in unreasonable actions or inactions:</p><p>1.) Attending to/sensing misinformation — If I’m listening to a lot of sources that are misinforming me or deliberately disinforming (lying to) me, and I believe them, the actions I perform under the influence of this misinformation/disinformation appear reasonable to me, but can be found (with greater scrutiny of the evidence) to be unreasonable (contradicting sensory evidence).</p><p>2.) Making guesses about my sensations, not scrutinizing them, and treating them as “truths.” This is objectification and leads to confirmation bias: taking belief and denial categorizations too seriously and avoiding evidence of contradiction or not looking for evidence of contradiction.</p><p>These two problems often go hand in hand, because misinformation/disinformation is enticing; it often offers confirmation bias to help an individual ignore contradictions and avoid the discomfort of cognitive dissonance that would lead to learning (lead to modifying cognition categorizations to resemble sensory evidence harvested from truth more closely). Learning requires effort/(loss of energy) that could lead to gain (more accurate predictions that lead to less unfruitful efforts), but if a disinformer tells a person they don’t need to put in the effort (because their beliefs/objectifications are perfectly fine), they will be less likely to put in that effort to look at new inconvenient evidence and alter their cognition categorization.</p><p>Perhaps you’ve heard the term “garbage in, garbage out.” From the start, these two steps at the beginning of the cognitive process can lead to firmly held unreasonable categorizations of cognitions (garbage in), which have a domino effect into unreasonable preference sensations and actions/outputs (garbage out).</p><p>If I’m prone to jumping to conclusions (beliefs or denials), ignoring evidence that I’m wrong (confirmation bias), and seeking misinformation that supports my inaccurate beliefs/preference sensations/actions, I’ll struggle to maintain an evidential connection to truth the common ground whole of all being — I’ll believe unreasonable cognitions and feel unreasonable preference sensations, that lead me to feel justified in taking unreasonable actions. Though my actions and thoughts have minimal evidential connection to truth, I’ll feel like my actions are righteous and my thoughts are reasonable.</p><p>For the purpose of maintaining a mental connection to truth — cultivating reasonable/sensory evidence-based intuition, preference sensations, and actions, it appears vital that I attempt to avoid wholeheartedly trusting my intuition without leaving room for question: objectifications and misinformation from unscrutinized and unreliable sources. It also appears vital that I scrutinize my cognitions with sensations of truth and reliable sources and deny cognitions that appear to contradict scrutinized reliable evidence.</p><p><strong>Homeostasis</strong></p><p>Scrutinized truth seeking takes time and effort, and I also have food, water, shelter… collecting that I need to balance my time with (in order to avoid ever building negative preference sensations and eventual suffering and death). I don’t have endless time and effort for truth seeking. I must do my best to avoid net loss with the information and time available to me.</p><p>Incorrect/oversimplified guesses and actions are inevitable- I cannot make heavily scrutinized reasonable beliefs and denials (higher level knowledge by my definition) without a lot of experience and scrutinizing. I must use my intuition a lot. I can train my intuition to be more accurate by wondering and guess/checking a lot. This way I learn, and modify my guesses to I can arrive at intuitions that appear to resemble my sensory experiences that appear useful in predicting future action outcomes with minimal effort in the future.</p><p>I have to start somewhere — I have to make guesses. If I maintain at least a small sense of wonder for my guesses/cognitions (rather than considering them “true” unquestionable beliefs), I’m more apt to watch for what mistakes my actions cause and learn from them and adjust them for the future. I’m less apt to thoughtlessly repeat the same actions when an alternative method that might prevent more net loss is suggested.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion for Actions:</strong></h4><p>Deliberate actions appear to be cultivated; they appear to be cultivated in part by my choices. Preference sensations appear to play a big role in my choices to act by suggesting or compelling attraction and avoidance. However, I also appear to have a say in what preference sensations I take seriously and which ones I ignore as a result of cognition categorization.</p><p>How I categorize my cognitions as beliefs/wonders/denials appears to influence how I treat the preference sensations that my categorized cognitions inspire. The categorization also leads me to feel attracted to some cognitions about actions and repelled by others. Others, I’m not sure what to do with, so I continue to wonder about them until I must act, and when I do, I proceed cautiously.</p><p>My attention moves in a nonlinear way from one form of content to the next: preference sensations, sensations, cognitions, secondary sources, {beliefs, denials, and wonders.}…, preference sensations, results of my actions… The constant movement of my attention from one form of content to another and the way that I categorize content appears to build my ever-evolving reference library of guesses (body of knowledge) about the whole of all being. That library of guesses appears to help cultivate my deliberate actions and has an impact on my preference sensations and instinctual actions.</p><p>If I’ve allowed my reference library of guesses to be filled with disinformation or if I’m rigidly holding onto objectifications I’m likely to feel righteous and reasonable while avoiding evidence that could help me learn more about truth and avoid net loss. If I’m open to wonder about a cognition, after choosing a deliberate action, I can act and learn by watching the results of my actions: Do my actions appear to fulfill my intended goals/preferred outcomes? (did the effort applied appear to lead to net gain or net loss)? Was the result acceptable? Or do my actions appear to not fulfill my intended goals or even go against them? Do I need to change my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">actions </a>to better meet my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">intentions</a>? Or, do I need to change my intentions? These questions lead me to the next section: Evidence-Based Morality.</p><h3>EVIDENCE-BASED MORALITY</h3><p>To avoid talking past one another, effective discussions about morality must begin with a definition for the term “moral.” I will attempt to connect the word “moral” to something that we can observe together and discuss. From my understanding, from the way that people talk about morals, the term moral is more than simply a “right action” or an action that meets my intended goals. It has more to do with preference sensations: what I “want” to have happen -the intended goals themselves. Were my intentions “moral,” and did my actions meet those intentions? What are moral intentions, then? When people talk about morals, they appear to be talking about something greater than themselves — Not just intentions for themselves but intentions for others too, and not just any intention either, intentions for the “benefit” of that which is greater than themselves — “good” intentions for the greater community. What are good intentions?</p><p>I seek an evidence-based definition for what people <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-meaning-ca6d1b5facea">mean </a>by “good.” How can sensory evidence gathered from truth (the common ground) guide us toward this definition? “Good” appears to be a concept I have come to understand through my experience with preference sensations. As mentioned previously, people appear to have strong universal negative preference sensations for net loss(Source 7). and a universal desire for homeostasis: negative preference sensations guide me to behave in ways that lead me to fulfil needs which minimize my negative preference sensations, and when I don’t feel intolerable negative preference sensations anymore, I feel “good,” I want to maintain that feeling — that state of feeling “good” is called homeostasis(Source 1) and it is a fleeting feeling that I’m constantly chasing. Perhaps, when I behave morally, I act with consideration for the greater community; with intentions to avoid net loss for the greater community and intentions to home in on a communal version of “homeostasis” that I’ll discuss more about in a minute.</p><p>The experience of net loss appears to elicit greater negative preference sensations than net gains elicit positive preference sensations (Source 3), so it appears that avoiding the use of actions that cause net loss for greater society (for myself and others) ought to be a high priority in deciding what actions appear “not good.” I cannot innately feel the preference sensations of others — I have no ingrained sensations(interoceptions) that tell me (for certain) that I’m causing someone harm, but I <em>can</em> use my preference sensations as evidence for reasonable guesses (predictions) about how others probably do not want to be treated. In practice, this looks like: intending not to treat others in ways that I would not want to be treated under the circumstances without their (clear and uncoerced) consent (I can then use their verbal/facial expressions and body language as more evidence as to whether or not my behavior is causing them negative preference sensations). This is similar to the golden rule which is often considered a maxim in traditional religions. I would not call this a “self-evident maxim.” I would call this <em>my </em>best guess: a preference sensation evidence-based guess about moral (well meaning) intentions. It appears to work well given the way people respond to my behavior toward them when I use this intention. I find it reasonable to believe, but not unreasonable to continue to wonder more about if someone disagrees with me. The intention to not cause net loss appears to be a good/moral intention, and the intention to cause net loss to others appears to be a bad/immoral intention.</p><p>It appears that preference sensations are cultivated by many factors, and working out the specifics of which actions greater society members reasonably expect others in greater society to avoid regarding this good/moral intention requires a much more in-depth discussion than I can conduct on my own, or write about in this paper. Such a discussion is a truth-seeking endeavor that requires many voices from greater society, where everyone is attempting to avoid confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory to avoid universally unwanted net loss. It is also important to note that different cultures of people will come up with different norms/rules depending on what they are focusing on. They will also develop different facial cues and body language, so when a new person enters a new culture, misunderstandings and miscommunications are likely both on behalf of the new person evaluating a different culture and of those evaluating the new person. To understand what a person is feeling or how they do not want to be treated, and to communicate our own preferences effectively we really do have to spend time with one another and gather evidence of each other’s communication tendencies open mindedly, carefully, and cautiously (Source 13).</p><p>If everyone in greater society simply avoids the “immoral intentions” that I mentioned previously (not treating others in a way that I would not want to be treated), will that be enough to help a society find balance/homeostasis? It doesn’t appear to be enough. When a community of people are each trying to meet homeostasis using shared limited resources, they’re likely to experience situations where one person’s gain of resources to fulfill their personal homeostasis results in another person’s loss of resources leaving them unable to fulfill their personal homeostasis. Avoiding harm becomes much more difficult when resources are scarce. What do we do then?</p><h4>Challenging Objectification in Traditional Economics</h4><p>“Economics is the science which studies human behavior as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.”(Source 12) In traditional economics, it was assumed that humans were “self-interested.” Behavioral Economics challenged this assumption over decades collecting and analyzing data from hundreds of diverse studies (Source 7). According to this heavily scrutinized evidence, humans appear more cooperative than traditional economics gives them credit for. Factors like reciprocity, fairness, and social norms influence their behavior leading them to cooperate even when it’s not strictly in their immediate best interest (Source 7). These findings show that fairness <em>is</em> often a guiding interest for people. They often appear willing to experience hardships (struggle to meet homeostasis) if they know others are also experiencing hardship with them. And, so long as they are not experiencing intolerable hardship, they appear willing to make less money knowing those who make more are putting in more time and effort or have more training and expertise– they do not appear to universally want to get ahead at another harder working person’s expense(Source 7). Generally, people do appear to experience negative preference sensations of frustration and anger when they feel an action/intention/situation is “unfair” both for themselves or others(Source 7). Fairness, to a community, may be similar to homeostasis to a person.</p><p>How do we determine what is fair/balanced for a community? Since we cannot feel one another’s preference sensations innately, the next best way to discuss evidence about preference sensations appears to be: Conversations about fairness. We can express our feelings verbally and listen to each other to get a semblance of a feeling for what is going on in the greater community. Census data and polling information can also be informative (so long as it is collected in a careful scrutinized way that avoids objectification, confirmation bias, cognitive dissonance and contamination from sources that do not have good (fair and non harming) intentions for the community). Who appears to be suffering most/least and thriving most/least, and why? And does the balance appear “fair?” Are we okay with negligently letting hard working and well-meaning community members suffer prolonged negative preference? Or is our current societal system promoting that outcome, and are we okay with that? Leaders in the community can use available evidence to guess at resolutions that encourage fair distributions of resources, monitor the results of the resolutions, and adapt the resolutions to acquire a more fair/balanced action outcome over time. Representative Democracy may be an evidence-based method to ensure representatives are following their community’s wishes — the consequence for failure is that the community chooses someone else to lead. However, truth seeking on the part of both citizens and leadership are vital to the aim of fair/balanced outcomes. Lies/misunderstandings lead well intentioned citizens and leadership toward the opposite of their good intentions. Avoiding confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory are key. Meeting fairness/balance, like meeting homeostasis is challenging and fleeting, it appears to require a great deal of effort on the part of everyone with moral intentions (to not harm and seek fairness) to find and maintain.</p><p>Two priority moral (well-meaning) intentions appear to me to be: 1.) Intentions to not harm 2.) Intentions to find and maintain fairness/balance within the greater community with whom resources are shared. Immoral (ill-meaning) intentions appear to me to be those that deal deliberate net losses to individuals and the community and deliberate actions against finding/maintaining balance/fairness in the community.</p><p>It seems important to note that an individual’s homeostasis appears to always be at play — we can’t seem to get away from our preference sensations. We also don’t have unlimited energy and focus(Source 1). Even people who think of themselves as being extraordinarily moral are still trying to meet personal homeostasis, and multiple other priorities and that sometimes means being distracted from moral intentions toward others– that doesn’t mean they intend harm for others, but it may mean they are paying less attention to not harming anyone/everyone and more focused attention to their own needs. Some degree of moral negligence appears likely in our actions, and it is important that we avoid mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory, confirmation bias, and objectification that would prevent us from looking at the harm our negligent actions may cause, and acknowledging and offering apologies to those harmed when harm is done, and learning lessons that would help us avoid doing more accidental harm in the future.</p><h4>Consequences</h4><p>While balancing my intention to find my personal homeostasis and communal fairness, and my intention to not harm, how do I protect myself from people who do intend to harm me?</p><p>Theoretical models from Game Theory can be considered when answering that question. Game Theory is the study of mathematical models of strategic interaction. Game theory does not provide “maxims” about how to behave, nor does it provide sensory evidence, but it can provide theoretical predictions of how certain behavioral strategies “may” play out against one another in reality, and we can try those suggested strategies out in real life to see how predictive the models are under our personal circumstances and learn from them.</p><p>One game that offers insight into the effects of consequences for immoral actions is the Prisoner’s Dilemma. In this two-person game, each player has two options — cooperate or defect. For each round, the players choose one of the two options and points are distributed to the players based upon their choices. In the way the points are scored in this game, “cooperate” appears equivalent to “moral intent” and defect appears equivalent to “immoral intent” by the definitions I’m working with. “Points” could be considered “limited resources.” Here is how points/resources are scored/allocated: “If both players cooperate, they earn three points each {each player uses actions that would achieve moral intentions by my definition — intention to allocate resources fairly and not harm}; if both defect, they get just one point (neither player intends/hopes for this outcome). If one player defects and the other cooperates, the defector receives five points and the hapless cooperator gets nothing. {One player uses actions that would achieve moral intentions (a balance of resources between all players if the other player cooperates) and gets nothing, and the other player uses actions that would achieve immoral intentions (the player takes all the resources for himself and leaves the other with nothing as immorally intended by my definition)}” (Source 10)</p><p>“In 1980, Robert Axelrod, professor of political science at the University of Michigan, held a tournament of various strategies for the prisoner’s dilemma. He invited a number of well-known game theorists to submit strategies to be run by computers. In the tournament, programs played games against each other and themselves repeatedly. Each strategy specified whether to cooperate or defect based on the previous moves of both the strategy and its opponent… The winner of Axelrod’s tournament was the TIT FOR TAT strategy. The strategy cooperates on the first move, and then does whatever its opponent has done on the previous move. Thus, when matched against the all-defect strategy, TIT FOR TAT strategy always defects after the first move. When matched against the all-cooperate strategy, TIT FOR TAT always cooperates. This strategy has the benefit of both cooperating with a friendly opponent, getting the full benefits of cooperation, and of defecting when matched against an opponent who defects. When matched against itself, the TIT FOR TAT strategy always cooperates.” (Source 9)</p><p>From the hundreds of strategies submitted in the two years in which the tournament was held, strategies that were retaliatory (delivered consequences of non-cooperation in some version of TIT for TAT) ranked highest. Strategies that were retaliatory and also forgiving (attempting to cooperate again after several rounds of non-cooperation) were the strategies that racked up the most points. Importantly, “nasty strategies” — strategies in which the algorithm/participant defected first (TIT for no reason — not in response to their rivals defection) were rarely in the top ranks and were never the winners (Source 11). It is important to note, however, that “there is no best strategy” and a player must figure out their opponent’s strategy and then pick a strategy that is best suited for the situation. These results are not absolute — we must still pay attention to evidence in real life scenarios and learn what appears to work best for our situation on a case-by-case basis.</p><p>This simulation offers predictions that appear to work in theory, and I can consider their application in everyday life particularly when interacting with strangers whose intentions/strategies are mysterious to me. The findings may help me maintain the benefits of cooperation, and protect me from losing everything if I interact with someone acting on immoral intentions, and forgiveness may encourage them to switch strategies and cooperate with me so we can both receive the benefits of cooperation.</p><p>I’ll add these potentially useful tools to my strategy. I won’t simply cooperate with everyone no matter how they treat me all of the time. I’ll keep an eye out for defectors and deliver clearly communicated consequences of non-cooperation to avoid letting someone take everything from me, and I can use forgiveness to encourage them to cooperate again if it appears that they might — but go back to defecting if they deal more defections to me.</p><p>A missing element in this game theory model is that in real life it is hard to interpret “defecting.” I struggle to confirm when someone is defecting, negligent, or accidentally harming. If I ask a defector if they are defecting, they are unlikely to admit it, so a conversation with them will do no good. This becomes another careful “truth seeking” endeavor where I attempt to consider every bit of evidence available and attempt to avoid confirmation bias, mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory, and objectification to arrive at my best guess. I cannot vacillate forever however, and I should respond swiftly and clearly when it appears likely that someone is trying to take advantage of me.</p><p>TIT FOR TAT should be employed with caution. It can lead to great net loss when consequences are doled out unevenly. Several psychology studies have shown that people are likely to deal harsher and harsher punishments to their foes as TIT FOR TAT progresses due to self justification (Source 5). Minor infractions can lead people to feel “self justified” in dealing what they consider to be an equal TIT for TAT, but their punishment (when measured), is in fact, overly harsh. This often leads the original transgressor to feel justified in dealing an even harsher blow snowballing into greater and greater blows and unending escalating conflict.</p><p>An effective way to use TIT FOR TAT that does not appear to lead to escalation may be: simple and well communicated non-cooperation in response to the TAT. Instead of dealing one’s opponent a blow, one can communicate that they are not going to cooperate anymore and why (what was the perceived transgressor’s infraction) and then stop cooperating with the opponent until demands are met. It can be a very effective strategy when done on a mass scale — where a whole group of people chose to do a collective action of non-cooperation together. The act of non-cooperation does not look or feel “immoral” — it isn’t intended to physically harm. If the transgressor retaliates violently, they look as though they are being heavy handed, it requires the transgressor to think a little more about their retaliatory actions to the non-cooperation, and perhaps consider what the other side is trying to communicate. It also seems less likely that bystanders will see the non-cooperative action as unjustified and worthy of violent retaliation. If the transgressor does retaliate violently, then bystanders may see the transgressor as unjustified. Martin Luther King Jr. employed this strategy of non cooperation in response to transgressions in the United States during the civil rights movement, and Mahatma Gandhi used it in India’s struggle for independence from British rule.</p><h4>Consquences Conclusion</h4><p>It appears that scrutinizing cognitions about sensory evidence and avoiding confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory is key to maintaining a cooperative society that defects when the evidence shows it is necessary to keep well-meaning individuals and society safe from harmful action outcomes (whether the action outcomes were deliberate, negligent, or accidental). And, to dole out consequences to those bad actors that appear appropriate and effective (depending upon the evidence of their intentions and the severity of the harm that they appear to have caused — Consider the model below as an option).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8SWZGh8_k2sSm1gQSFlRMg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Moral Actions Conclusion</h4><p>There is a great deal more to say about evidence-based morality, communal laws, and justice, but I must save it for another time.</p><p>I’ve attempted to show in this submission that we can arrive at a definition for moral intentions using sensory evidence from preference sensations. When the definition is sensory evidence based, morality becomes something that we can have reasonable conversations about. When our preferences inevitably differ, we can discuss why they differ (in the same way that we can discuss other forms of conflicting knowledge). Very often our preferences differ because of a difference in belief categorization which is reliant on many other factors. When it appears to me that someone is “defecting,” or “acting immorally” it appears that way because of the evidence I attend to and the way I interpret the evidence. I am attempting to gain “knowledge — cognition categorizations of belief/wonder/deny that align with heavily scrutinized evidence” and make evidence-based guesses about how I ought to behave with a balance between my own needs and those of the greater community. I am watching the results of my actions and learning from the results. And when people disagree with me (when their guesses/cognitions about morals are different from mine) it isn’t necessarily because one of us has “immoral intentions” (though I’ll get a better understanding of what someone’s intention might be as more evidence is obtained and scrutinized). I can often resolve our differences with curiosity (that results in learning) rather than attempting to brow beat others with rhetoric, pushy arguments, or threats of violence.</p><p>Objectification can make these productive conversations impossible. Rigidly holding onto cognitions/statements instead of letting evidence be the guide leads to blind spots — spots where the evidence from common ground truth has no power to unite our understanding — Objectifiers won’t consider evidence that contradicts sacred cognitions/statements — even if the evidence shows that their objectification is less evidence-based than another person’s best guess; the objectification trumps the evidence. In these situations, when someone inadvertently behaves in a way that betrays the objectification, the strong believer feels unreasonable (not evidence-based) negative preference sensations that cultivate behaviors that go against evidence-based moral intentions. To those using a highly objectified moral strategy, I ask which strategy is likely to result in net loss: 1.) Ignoring sacred cognitions/statements so we can attend to complex sensory based evidence together open mindedly to assess the differences of our preferences, evidence, and belief categorization, or 2.) Ignoring the complexity of truth and one or both of us attending to rigid and conflicting sacred cognition categorizations that lead to rigidly conflicting preferences?</p><p>Which option is more likely to result in the net loss of endless conflict or of putting effort into dealing consequences to people who strive for net fairness in the greater community and whose intentions and action outcomes hurt no one? What net benefit to the greater community comes from defecting to people with intentions for non-harm and fairness?</p><h3>CONCLUSION FOR THIS SUBMISSION</h3><p>I used the goal of seeking truth and the definition of truth (as common ground) as the foundation for this language game. I’ve explored the topics of epistemology and the cultivation of moral actions.</p><p>Though I seek truth, knowledge — “my best guess” is the best I can do. It is my pool of most reasonable to believe (evidence-based and reliable secondary evidence-based) cognitions/statements that I can muster.</p><p>Whether my knowledge refers to sensations that lead to scientific discovery or actions/intentions I consider to be moral, at no point do my guesses: categorizations of cognitions into beliefs/wonders/denials become “justified true.”</p><p>There is a lot to wonder about when we disagree, and we can have productive conversations so long as neither of us are rigidly clinging to believed/denied cognitions not supported by evidence. Do my guesses align with the evidence from truth? Do others disagree with me? Why do they disagree with me? Are we using different vocabulary? What evidence are we paying attention to or not paying attention to that may lead to this dissonance? Does one of us have a belief that better aligns to the most scrutinized evidence? Some cognitions appear best kept squarely in the wonder category because “I just don’t know” no evidence is available to bring them toward confirmation or denial.</p><p>Truth is true (in the common ground whole of all being theory of truth) — it is one thing — the common ground for all things (and it is simultaneously made up of countless smaller things that compose it) — Truth is not cognitions or statements. If I categorize cognitions and statements as “truths,” then I use circular reasoning and lose sight of the single whole of all being truth. I objectify truth; I take the whole of all being that is unfathomably complex and in flux that belong to no particular perspective, and that holds all beings together by being the object of all sensations/perspectives, and I put a simplified and single man-made façade over top of it. I appear to hide truth from myself and potentially others if I’m rigidly telling everyone “I’m right and you are wrong!” without evidence to support my conclusions.</p><p>The traditional vocabulary for truth seeking: “justified true belief,” “self-evident maxims,” and dichotomous true/false — this vocabulary appears to encourage the building of this objectified façade and it robs the wonder category of its reasonable contents. The vocabulary creates a foundation on which to build more “façade” and call it “deducted truth.” Believing these guesses and deductions to be “truths,” can lead to objectification and leads to confirmation bias, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory. It appears to create blind spots where observable contradictions can hide.</p><p>Humans ask a lot of foundational questions that require accurate answers, but sometimes we don’t have access to evidence to move the needle to belief or denial: Is the universe infinite? What is existence? What is really real? What was the first cause? … for these questions, it appears reasonable to maintain a state of wonder without holding rigidly to cognized answers. It appears reasonable not to know the answer and admit it. It appears reasonable to think up elaborate answers, wonder aloud with others, and still set those unsupported cognitions aside as “fun/inspirational/entertaining ideas to keep wondering about.” It even appears reasonable to act on those wonders when decisions appear required; and keep thinking about whether or not that wonder should stay in the wonder category or be moved to the belief or denial category while watching the evidence and results of my actions unfold. It does not fit the definition of reasonable that I laid out to categorize them as strong beliefs/denials without evidence.</p><p>Is this philosophy that I’ve presented reasonable to believe? I’d like to enter it into the running as a “best guess” for others to consider. I have attempted to support it with scrutinized evidence from secondary truth seekers who appear reliable and I have attempted to avoid contradictions. I attempt to apply this philosophy to my life and find it useful in making predictions that appear accurate. It helps me have productive conversations with those whom I disagree. But this philosophy needs greater scrutiny. To gather more evidence for the accuracy/inaccuracy of this philosophy, readers can help assess. I look forward to hearing from them.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1.) Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2017). How Emotions Are Made. Pan Books Ltd.</p><p>2.) Pert, C. B. (2003). <em>Molecules of emotion</em>. Scribner.</p><p>3.) Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.</p><p>4.) (Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2020). Seven And A Half Lessons About The Brain. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.)</p><p>5.) Tavris, Carol, and Elliot Aronson. <em>Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me) Third Edition : Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts</em>. Boston, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2020.</p><p>6.) Mcleod, S. (2023, October 24). What Is Cognitive Dissonance Theory? Simply Psychology; Simply Psychology. <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html">https://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html</a></p><p>7.) Thaler, R. H. (2016). Misbehaving: the making of behavioral economics. W.W. Norton &amp; Company.</p><p>8.) Margulis, L. (1998). Symbiotic planet: A new look at evolution. Basic Books.</p><p>9.) Axelrod’s Tournament. (2019). Stanford.edu. <a href="https://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/courses/soco/projects/1998-99/game-theory/axelrod.html">https://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/courses/soco/projects/1998-99/game-theory/axelrod.html</a></p><p>‌10.) New Dilemmas for the Prisoner. (2017, February 6). American Scientist. <a href="https://www.americanscientist.org/article/new-dilemmas-for-the-prisoner">https://www.americanscientist.org/article/new-dilemmas-for-the-prisoner</a></p><p>11.) What Game Theory Reveals About Life, The Universe, and Everything. (n.d.). <a href="http://www.youtube.com./">Www.youtube.com.</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mScpHTIi-kM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mScpHTIi-kM</a></p><p>12.) Robbins, L. (1932). <em>AN ESSAY ON THE NATURE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF ECONOMIC SCIENCE</em>. <a href="https://cdn.mises.org/Essay%20on%20the%20Nature%20and%20Significance%20of%20Economic%20Science_2.pdf">https://cdn.mises.org/Essay%20on%20the%20Nature%20and%20Significance%20of%20Economic%20Science_2.pdf</a></p><p>13.) — -. ““How Emotions Are Made: The Secret Life of the Brain” — Dr Lisa Feldman Barrett.” <em>YouTube</em>, 13 Oct. 2020, <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KliAI9umFyY">www.youtube.com/watch?v=KliAI9umFyY</a>.</p><p>14.) Marcus du Sautoy. (2017). <em>The Great Unknown</em>. Penguin.</p><p>15.) <em>Breakthrough: The Trauma Tracer</em>. (n.d.). <a href="http://www.youtube.com./">Www.youtube.com.</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBkVx12yc2M">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBkVx12yc2M</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=831b39c10108" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/finding-common-ground-831b39c10108">Finding Common Ground</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy">Original Philosophy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evidence-Based Morality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/original-philosophy/evidence-based-morality-ad0fc26e91b8?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad0fc26e91b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Jul 2025 15:32:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-18T03:28:58.925Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Wonder About Evidence-Based Morality</h3><h4>Which moral strategy is likely to lead to conflict resolution?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*29VUvO7R73PZSO4P_pRLrg.jpeg" /></figure><p>To avoid talking past one another, discussions about morality that have any hope of establishing common ground must begin with an agreed upon definition for the term “moral.”</p><p>I am just one person, and morality involves not just me. It involves others: how I treat others, how they treat me, and how each of us “want” to be treated. What kind of behaviors do we want to have/not have in our society. Morality has a lot to do with what I have termed our internal “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference</a> sensations.”</p><p>I can’t inately feel someone elses prefereence sensations or how others want to be treated or what behaviors they feel are acceptable/unacceptable. This is why I categorize this article as a “wonder.” I attempt to define morality in an evidence-based way, but the only evidence I have about how others might want to be treated or what they deem acceptable/unacceptable is my own understanding of how <em>I</em> want to be treated — which <em>is </em>innate to me. In addition to these innate feelings, I also have the evidence of what others reveal to me in how I interpret their expressions when I treat them in ways they prefer or don’t prefer or when they witness behaviors that the prefer/don’t prefer — But these expressions that are offered, I still have to interpret them even when others try to be explicit with me.</p><p>In addition to the definition of morality, I also wonder about strategies that might lead to a more moral society (again using the definition of moral that I am working with, which is simply a categorization in the language game that I’m working with. Others might use a different definition, neither of us is wholly wrong/right- the words and definitions are tools, not truths).</p><h4>Morality Defined</h4><p>From my understanding, from the way that I hear people talk about morals, the term moral is more than simply a “right action” or an <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">action </a>that meets my intended goals. It has more to do with <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a>: what I “want” to have happen -the intended goals themselves. Were my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">intentions </a>“moral,” and did my actions meet those intentions?</p><p>What are moral intentions, then? When people talk about morals, they appear to be talking about something greater than themselves — Not just intentions for themselves but intentions for others too, and not just any intention either, intentions for the “benefit” of that which is greater than themselves — “good” intentions for the greater community.</p><p>What are good intentions? What is the greater community? I already discussed the meaning of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">intentions in a previous article</a>. First, I’ll tackle the meaning of the word “good” from personal experience, and then I’ll discuss its meaning in the context of the “greater community.”</p><h3>What is Good — from Personal Experience?</h3><p>I seek an evidence-based definition for what people mean by “good.” How can sensory evidence gathered from <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>(the common ground) guide us toward this definition? “Good” appears to be a concept I have come to understand through my experience with <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a>. As mentioned in a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a">previous post</a>, people appear to have strong <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a">universal negative preference sensations for net loss</a> (Thaler, R. H. (2016). Misbehaving: the making of behavioral economics) <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a">and a universal desire for homeostasis </a>(Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2017). How Emotions Are Made. Pan Books Ltd.): negative preference sensations “inspire” and sometimes “compel” me to act — to behave in ways that lead me to fulfil needs which minimize my negative preference sensations (when I am hungry, stressed, bored… I try to find ways to alleviate those sensations), and when I don’t feel intolerable negative preference sensations anymore, I feel “good,” I want to maintain that feeling — that state of feeling “good” is called homeostasis (and it is a fleeting feeling that I’m constantly chasing).</p><h3>What is Moral and Immoral- a guess about the perceptions of “good” and “bad” in the greater community</h3><p>Perhaps, when I behave morally, I act with consideration for the greater community; with intentions to <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a">avoid net loss</a> for the greater community and intentions to home in on a communal version of “homeostasis” that I’ll discuss more about in a minute.</p><p>More about the importance of avoiding Net Loss — The experience of net loss appears to elicit greater negative preference sensations than net gains elicit positive preference sensations (Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux) so it appears that avoiding actions that cause net loss for myself, others, and for greater society ought to be a high priority if we want to avoid looking like a “Bad Person.”</p><p>I cannot innately feel the preference sensations of others — I have no ingrained sensations(interoceptions) that tell me (for certain) that I’m causing someone harm, but I <em>can</em> use my preference sensations as evidence for reasonable guesses (predictions) about how others probably do <em>not </em>want to be treated. In practice, this looks like: <strong>intending not to treat others in ways that I would not want to be treated under the circumstances without their (clear and uncoerced) consent</strong>. This is similar to the golden rule (which is often considered a maxim in traditional religions) — but there is a significant difference with the emphasis on what kinds of action to avoid rather than guessing about ways <em>to</em> treat others. I would not call this a “self-evident maxim.” I would call this <em>my </em>best guess: a preference sensation evidence-based guess about how to guess about moral intentions. It appears to work well given the way people respond to my behavior toward them when I use this intention as a guide for my behavior.</p><h4>A Potential Objective Moral Heuristic</h4><p>I find the intention to “avoid treading others in ways that I would not want to be treated” as a reasonable rule of thumb (heuristic) to avoid causing others net loss and a reasonable heuristic for acting in a way that others will categorize as moral —It seems to me that a person who acts with good intentions for greater society would act with that intention. I draw a red line there — when a person appears to treat others in a way that I myself would not want to be treated under that circumstance, I get a negative preference sensation, and question the intentions and actions of that person. If I can gather my composure and attempt to understand whether or not I am missing evidence that would justify such behavior (has the apparent victim done something to deserve this treatment?) I can ask those kinds of questions. However, some actions toward others, just seem impossible to justify — rape, murder, sexual abuse — particularly of children, physical abuse… This is where, the idea of “objective moral truths” arises- because I think there are some actions that greater society (if given the most heavily scrutinized evidence of the case) would overwhelmingly agree are “bad actions,” actions that a healthy society cannot permit to continue to happen. However, these are preferences, and they aren’t objective and there isn’t any “truth” to them. Instead, they are preferences that must be discussed among the population to decipher which actions are acceptable in that population and which are not.</p><h4>Challenges with culture clashes</h4><p>It appears that preference sensations are<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-feel-the-way-that-i-feel-0d02164787b8"> cultivated by many factors (as I explained in a previous post)</a>, and working out the specifics of which actions greater society members reasonably expect others in greater society to avoid regarding this good/moral intention requires a much more in-depth discussion than I can conduct on my own, or write about in this paper. Such a discussion is a truth-seeking endeavor that requires many voices from greater society, where everyone is attempting to avoid confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory to avoid universally unwanted net loss. It is also important to note that different cultures of people will come up with different norms/rules depending on what they are focusing on. They will also develop different facial cues and body language, so when a new person enters a new culture, misunderstandings and miscommunications are likely both on behalf of the new person evaluating a different culture and of those evaluating the new person. To understand what a person is feeling or how they do not want to be treated, and to communicate our own preferences effectively we really do have to spend time with one another and gather evidence of each other’s communication tendencies open mindedly, carefully, and cautiously ( — -. ““How Emotions Are Made: The Secret Life of the Brain” — Dr Lisa Feldman Barrett.” <em>YouTube</em>, 13 Oct. 2020, <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KliAI9umFyY">www.youtube.com/watch?v=KliAI9umFyY</a>.).</p><h4>A Problem of Fairness Still Remains</h4><p>If everyone in greater society simply avoids the immoral intentions that I mentioned previously, will that be enough to help a society find balance/homeostasis? It doesn’t appear to be enough because when a community of people are each trying to meet homeostasis using shared limited resources, they’re likely to experience situations where one person’s gain of resources to fulfill their personal homeostasis results in another person’s loss of resources leaving them unable to fulfill their personal homeostasis. Avoiding harm becomes much more difficult when resources are scarce. What do we do then?</p><h3>Ideas from Behavioral Economics</h3><p>“Economics is the science which studies human behavior as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.”(Robbins, L. (1932). <em>AN ESSAY ON THE NATURE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF ECONOMIC SCIENCE</em>. <a href="https://cdn.mises.org/Essay%20on%20the%20Nature%20and%20Significance%20of%20Economic%20Science_2.pdf">https://cdn.mises.org/Essay%20on%20the%20Nature%20and%20Significance%20of%20Economic%20Science_2.pdf</a>)</p><p>In traditional economics, it was assumed that humans were “self-interested.” Behavioral Economics challenged this assumption over decades collecting and analyzing data from hundreds of diverse studies. (Thaler, R. H. (2016). Misbehaving: the making of behavioral economics. W.W. Norton &amp; Company.) According to this heavily scrutinized evidence, humans appear more cooperative than traditional economics gives them credit for. Factors like reciprocity, fairness, and social norms influence their behavior leading them to cooperate even when it’s not strictly in their immediate best interest (Thaler 2016). These findings show that fairness <em>is</em> often a guiding interest for people. They often appear willing to experience hardships (struggle to meet homeostasis) if they know others are also experiencing hardship with them. And, so long as they are not experiencing intolerable hardship, they appear willing to make less money knowing those who make more are putting in more time and effort or have more training and expertise– they do not appear to universally want to get ahead at another harder working person’s expense. (Thaler, 2016) Generally, people do appear to experience negative preference sensations of frustration and anger when they feel an action/intention/situation is “unfair” both for themselves or others (Thaler 2016). Fairness, to a community, may be similar to homeostasis to a person. Not everyone operates this way all the time, there are bad actors who are out for themselves most of the time, and there are circumstances when people resort to selfish behavior, but it appears (in the studies that have been conducted among various populations mostly in the United States) that a majority of people do attempt to balance their wants and needs with those of the greater community under a wide variety of circumstances even when resources are scarce.</p><h4>Fairness</h4><p>How do we determine what is fair/balanced for a community? Since we cannot feel one another’s preference sensations innately, the next best way to discuss evidence about preference sensations appears to me to be: Conversations about fairness.</p><p>We can express our feelings verbally and listen to each other to get a semblance of a feeling for what is going on in the greater community. Census data and polling information can also be informative (so long as it is collected in a careful scrutinized way that avoids objectification, confirmation bias, cognitive dissonance and contamination from sources that do not have good (fair and non harming) intentions for the community). Who appears to be suffering most/least and thriving most/least, and why? And does the balance appear “fair?” Are we okay with negligently letting hard working and well-meaning community members suffer prolonged negative preference sensations? Or is our current societal system promoting that outcome, and are we okay with that? Leaders in the community can use available evidence to guess at resolutions that encourage fair distributions of resources, monitor the results of the resolutions, and adapt the resolutions to acquire a more fair/balanced action outcome over time.</p><p>Representative Democracy may be an evidence-based method to ensure representatives are following their community’s wishes — the consequence for failure is that the community chooses someone else to lead. However, truth seeking on the part of both citizens and leadership are vital to the aim of fair/balanced outcomes. Lies/misunderstandings lead well intentioned citizens and leadership toward the opposite of their good intentions. Avoiding confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory are key. Meeting fairness/balance, like meeting homeostasis is challenging and fleeting, it appears to require a great deal of effort on the part of everyone with moral intentions (to not harm and seek fairness) to find and maintain.</p><p>Summarize: Two priority moral (well-meaning) intentions appear to me to be:</p><ol><li>Intentions to not harm oneself or others.</li><li>Intentions to find and maintain fairness/balance within the greater community with whom resources are shared.</li></ol><p>Immoral (ill-meaning) intentions appear to me to be:</p><ol><li>Those that deal deliberate net losses to myself or others in the community.</li><li>Deliberate actions against finding/maintaining balance/fairness in the community.</li></ol><p>It seems important to note that an individual’s homeostasis appears to always be at play — we can’t seem to get away from our preference sensations. We also don’t have unlimited energy and focus. (Lisa Feldman Barrett, 2017). Even people who think of themselves as being extraordinarily moral are still trying to meet personal homeostasis, and multiple other priorities and that sometimes means being distracted from moral intentions toward others– that doesn’t mean they intend harm for others, but it may mean they are paying less attention to not harming anyone/everyone and more focused attention to their own needs. Some degree of moral negligence appears likely in our actions, and it is important that we avoid mental tricks from <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">cognitive dissonance theory</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">confirmation bias</a>, and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">objectification</a> that would prevent us from looking at evidence for the harm our negligent actions may cause, and acknowledging and offering apologies to those harmed when harm is done, and learning lessons that would help us avoid doing more accidental harm (mistakes) in the future.</p><h4>Consequences</h4><p>While balancing my intention to find my personal homeostasis and communal fairness, and my intention to not harm, how do I protect myself from people who intend to harm me?</p><p>Theoretical models from Game Theory can be considered when answering that question. Game Theory is the study of mathematical models of strategic interaction. Game theory does not provide “maxims” about how to behave, nor does it provide sensory evidence, but it can provide theoretical predictions of how certain behavioral strategies “may” play out against one another in reality, and we can try those suggested strategies out in real life to see how predictive the models are under our personal circumstances and learn from them.</p><p>One game that offers insight into the effects of consequences for immoral actions is the Prisoner’s Dilemma. In this two-person game, each player has two options — cooperate or defect. For each round, the players choose one of the two options and points are distributed to the players based upon their choices. In the way the points are scored in this game, “cooperate” appears equivalent to “moral intent” and defect appears equivalent to “immoral intent” by the definitions I’m working with. “Points” could be considered “limited resources.” Here is how points/resources are scored/allocated: “If both players cooperate, they earn three points each {each player uses actions that would achieve moral intentions by my definition — intention to allocate resources fairly and not harm}; if both defect, they get just one point (neither player intends/hopes for this outcome). If one player defects and the other cooperates, the defector receives five points and the hapless cooperator gets nothing. {One player uses actions that would achieve moral intentions (a balance of resources between all players if the other player cooperates) and gets nothing, and the other player uses actions that would achieve immoral intentions (the player takes all the resources for himself and leaves the other with nothing as immorally intended by my definition)}” (New Dilemmas for the Prisoner. (2017, February 6). American Scientist. <a href="https://www.americanscientist.org/article/new-dilemmas-for-the-prisoner">https://www.americanscientist.org/article/new-dilemmas-for-the-prisoner</a>)</p><p>“In 1980, Robert Axelrod, professor of political science at the University of Michigan, held a tournament of various strategies for the prisoner’s dilemma. He invited a number of well-known game theorists to submit strategies to be run by computers. In the tournament, programs played games against each other and themselves repeatedly. Each strategy specified whether to cooperate or defect based on the previous moves of both the strategy and its opponent… The winner of Axelrod’s tournament was the TIT FOR TAT strategy. The strategy cooperates on the first move, and then does whatever its opponent has done on the previous move. Thus, when matched against the all-defect strategy, TIT FOR TAT strategy always defects after the first move. When matched against the all-cooperate strategy, TIT FOR TAT always cooperates. This strategy has the benefit of both cooperating with a friendly opponent, getting the full benefits of cooperation, and of defecting when matched against an opponent who defects. When matched against itself, the TIT FOR TAT strategy always cooperates.” (Axelrod’s Tournament. (2019). Stanford.edu. <a href="https://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/courses/soco/projects/1998-99/game-theory/axelrod.html">https://cs.stanford.edu/people/eroberts/courses/soco/projects/1998-99/game-theory/axelrod.html</a>)</p><p>From the hundreds of strategies submitted in the two years in which the tournament was held, strategies that were retaliatory (delivered consequences of non-cooperation in some version of TIT for TAT) ranked highest. Strategies that were retaliatory and also forgiving (attempting to cooperate again after several rounds of non-cooperation) were the strategies that racked up the most points. Importantly, “nasty strategies” — strategies in which the algorithm/participant defected first (TIT for no reason — not in response to their rivals defection) were rarely in the top ranks and were never the winners. (What Game Theory Reveals About Life, The Universe, and Everything. (n.d.). <a href="http://www.youtube.com./">Www.youtube.com.</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mScpHTIi-kM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mScpHTIi-kM</a>) It is important to note, however, that “there is no best strategy” and a player must figure out their opponent’s strategy and then pick a strategy that is best suited for the situation. These results are not absolute — we must still pay attention to evidence in real life scenarios and learn what appears to work best for our situation on a case-by-case basis.</p><p>This simulation offers predictions that appear to work in theory, and I can consider their application in everyday life particularly when interacting with strangers whose intentions/strategies are mysterious to me. The findings may help me maintain the benefits of cooperation, and protect me from losing everything if I interact with someone acting on immoral intentions, and forgiveness may encourage them to switch strategies and cooperate with me so we can both receive the benefits of cooperation.</p><p>I’ll add these potentially useful tools to my strategy. I won’t simply cooperate (seek fairness) with everyone no matter how they treat me all of the time. I’ll keep an eye out for defectors and deliver clearly communicated consequences of non-cooperation to avoid letting someone take everything from me, and I can use forgiveness to encourage them to cooperate again if it appears that they might — but go back to defecting if they deal more defections to me.</p><p>A missing element in this game theory model is that in real life it is hard to interpret “defecting.” I struggle to confirm when someone is defecting, negligent, or accidentally harming. If I ask a defector if they are defecting, they are unlikely to admit it, so a conversation with them will do no good. This becomes another careful “truth seeking” endeavor where I attempt to consider every bit of evidence available and attempt to avoid confirmation bias, mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory, and objectification to arrive at my best guess. I cannot vacillate forever however, and I should respond swiftly and clearly communicate when it appears likely that someone is trying to take advantage of me.</p><h4>Cautious Consequences</h4><p>TIT FOR TAT should be employed with caution. Consequences can lead to great net loss when they are mistakenly doled out to undeserving and well meaning people — decisions to act with consequences ought to be evidence based.</p><p>In addition to this, dolling out too strong of a consequence can lead to unending escalating consequences. Several psychology studies have shown that people are likely to deal harsher and harsher punishments to their foes as TIT FOR TAT progresses due to self justification (Tavris, Carol, and Elliot Aronson. <em>Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me)</em>). Minor infractions can lead people to feel “self justified” in dealing what they consider to be an equal TIT for TAT, but their punishment (when measured), is in fact, overly harsh. This often leads the original transgressor to feel justified in dealing an even harsher blow to the person delivering consequences, and snowballing into greater and greater blows and unending escalating conflict.</p><p>An effective way to use TIT FOR TAT that does not appear to lead to escalation may often be: simple and well communicated non-cooperation in response to the TAT. Instead of dealing one’s opponent a blow, one can communicate that they are not going to cooperate anymore and why (what was the perceived transgressor’s infraction) and then stop cooperating with the opponent until demands are met. It can be a very effective strategy when done on a mass scale — where a whole group of people chose to do a collective action of non-cooperation together. The act of non-cooperation does not look or feel “immoral” — it isn’t intended to physically harm. If the transgressor retaliates violently, they look as though they are being heavy handed, it requires the transgressor to think a little more about their retaliatory actions to the non-cooperation, and perhaps consider what the other side is trying to communicate. It also seems less likely that bystanders will see the non-cooperative action as unjustified and worthy of violent retaliation. If the transgressor does retaliate violently, then bystanders may see the transgressor as unjustified. Martin Luther King Jr. employed this strategy of non-cooperation in response to transgressions in the United States during the civil rights movement, and Mahatma Gandhi used it in India’s struggle for independence from British rule. Both men achieved for their minority “in group,” what seemed impossible — those in power to listened to them and attempted to change.</p><h4>Moral Actions Conclusion</h4><p>There is a great deal more to say about evidence-based morality, communal laws, and justice, but I must save it for another time.</p><p>I’ve attempted to show in this submission that we can arrive at a definition for moral intentions using sensory evidence from preference sensations. When the definition is sensory evidence based, morality becomes something that we can have reasonable conversations about. When our preferences inevitably differ, we can discuss why they differ (<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">in the same way that we can discuss other forms of conflicting knowledge</a>). Very often our preferences differ because of a difference in <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">belief categorization</a> which is reliant on many other factors. When it appears to me that someone is “defecting,” or “acting immorally” it appears that way because of the evidence I attend to and the way I interpret the evidence. I am attempting to gain “knowledge — correct cognition categorizations” and make evidence-based guesses about how I ought to behave with a balance between my own needs and those of the greater community. I am watching the results of my actions and learning from the results. And when people disagree with me (when their guesses/cognitions about morals are different from mine) it isn’t necessarily because one of us has “immoral intentions” (though I’ll get a better understanding of what someone’s intention might be as more evidence is obtained and scrutinized). I can often resolve our differences with curiosity (that results in learning) rather than attempting to brow beat others with rhetoric, pushy arguments, or threats of violence.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">Objectification </a>can make these productive conversations impossible. Rigidly holding onto cognitions/statements instead of letting evidence be the guide leads to blind spots — spots where the evidence from common ground truth has no power to unite our understanding.</p><p>Objectifiers won’t consider evidence that contradicts sacred cognitions/statements — even if the evidence shows that their objectification is less evidence-based than another person’s best guess (instead they play mental tricks described in <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">cognitive dissonance</a> theory); the objectification trumps the evidence. In these situations, when someone inadvertently behaves in a way that betrays the objectification, the strong believer feels unreasonable (not evidence-based) negative preference sensations that cultivate behaviors that go against evidence-based moral intentions. To those using a highly objectified moral strategy, I ask:</p><p>Which strategy is likely to lead to conflict resolution?</p><ol><li>Ignoring sacred cognitions/statements so we can attend to complex sensory based evidence together open mindedly to assess the differences of our preferences, evidence, and belief categorization. Then discuss why those differences occur and assess which preference sensations/actions appear most reasonable based upon the evidece.</li><li>Ignoring the complexity of truth and so we can attend to rigid and conflicting sacred cognition categorizations that lead to us to feel rigidly conflicting preferences from one another that lead us to think ill of those who come to a differing conclusion about which preference sensations/actions appear right/wrong?</li></ol><p>Which option is more likely to result in mistakenly dealing consequences to people who strive for net fairness in the greater community and whose intentions and action outcomes hurt no one?</p><p>What net benefit to the greater community comes from defecting or doling out consequences to people with those intentions?</p><p>It appears that scrutinizing cognitions about sensory evidence and avoiding confirmation bias, objectification, and mental tricks from cognitive dissonance theory is key to maintaining a cooperative society that defects when the evidence shows it is necessary to keep well-meaning individuals and society safe from harmful action outcomes (whether the action outcomes were deliberate, negligent, or accidental). And, to dole out consequences to those bad actors that appear appropriate and effective (depending upon the evidence of their intentions and the severity of the harm that they appear to have caused — Consider the model below as an optional guide).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8SWZGh8_k2sSm1gQSFlRMg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image Created by Author</figcaption></figure><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad0fc26e91b8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/evidence-based-morality-ad0fc26e91b8">Evidence-Based Morality</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy">Original Philosophy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mistakes & Why I Want to be Right…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-want-to-be-right-cbf15f6aa68a?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cbf15f6aa68a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motivation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bias]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Jul 2025 15:57:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-15T02:16:11.620Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zp7FNHIxpx8e8yvownmHmQ.png" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@garri?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Vladislav Babienko</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/man-standing-in-the-middle-of-woods-KTpSVEcU0XU?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In this post, I discuss why I <em>want </em>to correctly categorize cognitions as true/unknown/false (or believe/wonder/deny):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oEu1fdY64j3Q3rtl6I-Xrw.jpeg" /></figure><p>One apparent category of sensation/input that I experience are sensations of preference. These sensations appear to me to be chemical sensations because of the way receptors inside my body receive chemical signaling molecules and there is a resulting experience of preference also known as “valence”( Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2017). How Emotions Are Made. Pan Books Ltd.) &amp; (Pert, C. B. (2003). <em>Molecules of emotion</em>. Scribner.). When particular molecules (i.e. dopamine, serotonin, and oxytocin) are received by receptors in my body I experience complex feelings that I call “pleasure/ease.” Other molecules (i.e. adrenaline, epinephrin and cortisol) appear to be involved in my feelings of suffering/dis-ease. The chemicals are produced by my body. They are the portions of truth that I receive through receptors, and ease/dis-ease becomes the resulting input/sensation that I cognize/process. This appears similar to the way that a vibration detected by hair cells in my ears results in the input/sensation of sound that I experience, or chemicals received inside my nose becomes an input/sensation of smells. Preference sensations are experienced as my personal feelings of ease/dis-ease and result in motivations for approach/maintain and avoidance actions.</p><p>Preference sensations appear to encourage and/or compel me to be more than just an observer. Actions that feel compelled are reflexive or habitual, like when I jump when startled, or I behave habitually like I do when I go through my morning tooth brushing. Actions that feel encouraged are actions that I can deliberate about and make a decision. When not compelled by my preference sensations, I may feel encouraged to think or “cognize” about the preference sensations that I am having (slow deliberate cognition). This paper focuses on slow deliberate cognitions.</p><p>Thinking/cognizing deliberately appears to entail wondering and guessing about what the preference sensations are telling me. Am I experiencing net ease or dis-ease? Why do I feel that way? What do I do/not do about it? How do I prefer to behave to achieve what I intend (attain net ease and/or pleasure and avoid net dis-ease and/or displeasure)? I wonder and guess about how to guide my behavior to approach preferred outcomes (intentions) that I predict/guess will promote sensations of net pleasure and/or ease (often survival, wellness/homeostasis/allostasis, gain…and also exhilaration and excitement). I also wonder and guess about how to guide my behavior to avoid unpreferred outcomes of net displeasure and/or disease (often trauma, death, starvation, loss… and also boredom and depression).</p><p>Negative preference sensations (sensations of dis-ease and/or displeasure) often alert me to what I call “problems;” problems that I feel the need to solve (I am experiencing preference sensations that feel intolerable, and I feel the need to end these feelings with some kind of change that requires action). But are those problems true/real (like starvation, injury, dehydration, the presence of predators…) or are they false/mistaken (like a nonexistent monster under the bed, phantom pain, or lies like “the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School was a hoax”)? Putting effort and attention into attempting to solve problems that turn out to be false is risky; it can result in net losses — I expend energy for potentially no gain or worse: my efforts can lead toward my demise or the demise of people or causes that I care about or intend to protect.</p><p>Not all negative preference sensations appear to be felt universally among all sentient beings (not everyone dislikes violence, risk, or pain all the time), but some negative preference sensations <em>do </em>appear to be felt universally under certain conditions. Universally, humans appear to prefer “homeostasis” — a balancing of “resources in” with “resources out.” (Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2017). How Emotions Are Made.) Humans do not like/prefer to expend a lot of their limited time, hard earned energy, and other resources on efforts that lead to net loss for themselves and those they care about (Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow.) -like losing sleep over a nonexistent monster under the bed or harassing parents whose children were murdered in a tragic school shooting. Efforts like these that result in net losses appear to elicit universally negative preference sensations (dis-ease/displeasure) in humans like feelings we call intense disappointment, frustration, and disgust (when I acknowledge/categorize them as net losses anyway). It even appears that net losses elicit greater dis-ease/displeasure than net gains elicit pleasure.(Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow.).</p><p>Homeostasis appears to be a thing that humans seek universally.</p><p>Net losses appear to be things humans all <em>very </em>much wish to avoid universally.</p><p>To avoid net losses, I can practice deliberately and carefully interpreting the causes of my negative preference sensations, and determining if the causes appear false so that I don’t expend energy on cognized problems that don’t exist. Additionally, to avoid net losses I need to align my beliefs with “true cognitions” and my denials with “false cognitions.” Beliefs are a category of cognition, cognitions that I trust. I listen to them (i.e. believing the cognition that I need oxygen to survive — this belief leads me to an intention to plan my actions around maintaining a constant source of oxygen). Denials are cognitions that I do not trust, I do not listen to them; instead, I ignore them (like denying the cognition that there is a monster under my bed — this denial leads me to tell myself that this monster is just in my head, and I intend to ignore/settle down the unpleasant feelings I’m having, stay calm, and get some sleep). Believing in true cognitions and denying false cognitions helps me avoid listening to misleading preference sensations from false causes and deduce accurate predictions that lead me toward actions that avoid predicted net loss and actions to obtain predicted net gain for myself and the people/causes I care about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*82lBHVC_D9ZP_j92t5bGUg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Confirmation Bias and Cognitive Dissonance Theory</h3><h4>Motivation to Maintain False Beliefs</h4><p>I use my beliefs and denials to make statements that I use as premises in deductive reasoning to predict future outcomes. When the resulting predictions are reliably accurate, it appears to me that I correctly categorized my cognitions as true/false and believe/deny: they lead me toward behaviors that achieve my preferred outcomes, and lead me to avoid behaviors that lead to unpreferred outcomes (like net losses). But, just because a belief/denial appears correct, does not mean that it <em>is </em>correct.</p><p>Sometimes I get things wrong, and I sometimes don’t look for, ignore, or don’t see the signs that I am wrong, and only pay attention to the signs that I am correct. Not looking for, ignoring, or not seeing signs that I am wrong is a scientifically observed phenomenon called confirmation bias. (Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow.) Confirmation bias is a universally common human behavior (Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow.).</p><p>Another common mental trick that humans use to preserve cognitions that misalign with observation/evidence is described in Leon Festinger’s Cognitive Dissonance Theory. When a belief is contradicted by new evidence, a person has some choices. They can change their belief to align with the evidence, they can ignore or destroy the evidence, or they can change the way they think about the evidence (say something like “the evidence isn’t relevant”). When a person has a strong preference for a belief to be true (they feel a “need” for it to be true), they become attached to the belief and will defend the belief even when the evidence clearly contradicts it (I call this objectification. I will discuss more about objectification later). Each time they defend the belief and deny the contradiction, the need for the belief to be true can get stronger. Admitting the belief was false means that all of the effort they put into defending the false belief was not advantageous, and they need the belief to be true even more. — They don’t want to admit that they exerted greater and greater amounts of effort for net loss, especially if their efforts would look detrimental to their character. For example, if they justified an action that others might consider unsavory or immoral in service of the false belief, such as gullibility, destroying evidence, lying, harassment, bullying, or murder. (Tavris, Carol, and Elliot Aronson. <em>Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me) Third Edition : Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts</em>. Boston, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2020)‌</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xuR4LzXtrclmBIoVFm50yg.jpeg" /></figure><p>(This visual aid depicting cognitive dissonance was modified to fit the vocabulary that I am using in this article. The original visual aid came from simply psychology.org9)</p><p>Learning is inhibited by confirmation bias and mental tricks from Cognitive Dissonance Theory. When contradictions are detected (when my actions don’t result in the outcomes I’d planned and I notice/attend to the discrepancy), I can analyze what went wrong and try to avoid the same mistakes again. This appears to be how learning happens. But, if I won’t look at the evidence of mistakes; if I ignore the evidence that I’ve categorized a cognition incorrectly, these beliefs often lead me toward unpreferred outcomes of displeasure/dis-ease that could have been avoided had I recategorized my cognitions based upon the new evidence. If I deny cognitions that are true, they often lead me to ignore important information that could have helped me make a more accurate prediction more efficiently. As a result, I don’t see my mistakes, and I don’t learn from them.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Categorizing true/unknown/false accurately and aligning belief/wonder/denial with true/unknown/false appears useful in deductive reasoning to help me guess at/predict actual future happenings in truth, and home in on what outcomes certain actions may achieve. I can then assess those predicted outcomes as {desirable, approachable, safe} and/or {undesirable, something to avoid, dangerous}, and make an informed decision about potential net losses/gains and how I want to proceed with approach, maintain, or avoid actions. I no longer feel like I’m just guessing. I am learning, I’m making educated guesses. Guesses that appear informed by sensory evidence gathered from truth (the common ground); guesses that appear to have a higher likelihood of predicting future outcomes.</p><p>Checking the accuracy of my categorizations of cognitions and correcting my mistaken categorizations (learning) requires time and effort, but it appears to be worth it (when I have time and energy) especially when the risk of net loss is high. Avoiding predictable and highly undesirable net losses and approaching(Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow.)/maintaining predictable and desirable net gains (approaching homeostasis) (Lisa Feldman Barrett. (2017). How Emotions Are Made.) appear to be worthy motivations for putting effort into categorizing true/false accurately and aligning belief/denial with true/false. These motivations appear to align with my scrutinized cognitions about my experience, but the more difficult question is: How do I determine what is true and what is false?</p><p>That is the subject of the next section: <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">What is True?</a></p><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cbf15f6aa68a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Wonder About What I Am]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/original-philosophy/a-wonder-about-what-i-am-15f4d327bdc4?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/15f4d327bdc4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Mar 2025 12:47:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-29T15:20:01.860Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What am I? and Why am I?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XSDEybfN6NgJhKMIXp8mnw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@lapyrin?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Ivan Lapyrin</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/woman-with-blonde-hair-holding-her-face-wXYlJ8nQvhw?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Is the “I” that I sense and cognize myself to be a figment of my cognition developed by my brain and body, and was my brain, body, and conscious experience built by the life forms inside my body — not by chance — but rather as a means of their survival and thriving. Am “I” a homeostasis generator and maintainer for the smaller life forms that made me and depend upon me for everything they need?</p><p>My body is a physical being made up of other smaller beings — cells and molecules. Each cell’s design is coded by my DNA which resides in the nucleus of my cells. The various types of RNA molecules within my cells transcribe that code by transforming themselves and then they relay the transcription to ribosomes that form from ribosomal RNA and specialized proteins that build and rebuild my body throughout my lifetime.</p><p>My DNA and RNA were passed down to me from both of my parents (and I’ve also acquired RNA from viruses and other places). From my mother, I also received a microbiome — a community of microbes — in my digestive tract that break food down into nutrients that my cells can receive. Some of that food is glucose that my mitochondria convert into energy that my cells can use.</p><p>I also received mitochondria from my mother. Mitochondria are an essential part of each of my cells that replicates and has distinct DNA that is different from that of my cell’s nucleus. Mitochondria extract energy from the glucose molecules that my microbe biome produces. That energy powers functional RNAs and the organelles inside my cell so they can do their work which results in the constant flow of energy necessary for the survival of my body.</p><p>My microbiome is essential to feed my mitochondria. My mitochondria are essential to energize my RNA and organelles (which are also essential to “my” survival). The whole of my body, built using the code from my DNA, is also essential to the survival of my microbiome and mitochondria, RNA and DNA. The whole of my body provides to all of them: food, water, oxygen, warmth, mobility, protection… everything they need.</p><p>My microbiome, mitochondria, RNA and DNA appear to thrive in the environment of my body — a warm, iron rich, and salty environment, perhaps reminiscent of the iron ocean that existed before plants came about, started eating carbon dioxide and producing oxygen gas that cooled the planet dramatically. Perhaps this dramatic cooling transformed the planet into a space where the microbes that ended up inside my intestines could no longer survive and thrive outside of a body? Perhaps they had to find a way to cooperate (learn to live well together) with other life forms to survive, and the sentient body that I sense and cognize myself to be is the most current version of a solution to that predicament? (Perhaps mitochondria, RNA, and DNA experienced a similar event that caused it to require a cellular body?)</p><p>If the microbes in my microbiome are living well and in balance with everything they need, then my mitochondria can supply energy to my RNA so it can continue to do its work and my DNA and RNA can continue to replicate. As a result, “I” survive. And, I also continue to feed, warm, and protect them.</p><p>I wonder: Does the bacteria in my microbiome, and/or my mitochondria, and/or my RNA and DNA, lead me to sense and cognize that I am a collective “something” that is vital and important to itself so that I will protect them, feed them, keep them at a stable temperature, and go out in search of all of the nutrients that they need to survive and maintain this structure of my body that they’ve built to adapt and rebuild itself for generations?</p><p>It appears to be the case that some of the hormones that lead me to feel a sense of self are produced by the gut. <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7659911/#:~:text=Of%20the%20total%20serotonin%20in,brain%20(1%2C%202">https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7659911/#:~:text=Of%20the%20total%20serotonin%20in,brain%20(1%2C%202</a>).</p><p>If “I” am a figment of my cognition developed by the microbes in my biome and/or mitochondria and/or DNA and RNA, then they are not just taking advantage of me. They are also giving me the experience of my life -which I value more than just about anything (the exception being the lives of my children which are the next generation versions of my and my partner’s body (coded by DNA) to house the mitochondria and microbiome that I’ve passed onto them as their mother). I just wonder about it. Admittedly, I have no idea if the “I” that I sense and cognize myself to be is my body, or a cognition, or perhaps it is both, or neither?</p><p>(This article is an aside to my philosophical writing. You can find the rest of my writing here, including a whole article devoted to the question “What Am I?” )</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=15f4d327bdc4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/a-wonder-about-what-i-am-15f4d327bdc4">A Wonder About What I Am</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy">Original Philosophy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Truth Seeking]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/truth-seeking-ce3ae1915af4?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce3ae1915af4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Jan 2025 12:40:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-18T23:49:12.451Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Summary</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wuose_5VoDtrC07x-tiayA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@neom?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">NEOM</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/a-man-standing-in-a-cave-at-sunset-wTmGtmGQCjQ?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>A top priority in seeking any answer is to seek truthful answers. This way, I will attempt to avoid faulty cognitions that lead me to act in ways that lead me toward the opposite of my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8">intentions</a>.</p><p>Truth, as I have defined it from the beginning of this philosophy is the common ground for all being. It is the thing that we all appear to have in common. It appears to me that it is experienced as the “whole of all being” that we appear to observe through our sensory apparatuses. My sensations, harvested from truth, are the information available to my cognition that I wonder and guess about using the cognitive process. (I’ve documented my thoughts on all of these definitions throughout my writing, if you are curious about the way I’ve defined things, please read each article here: <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad</a>)</p><p>Truth also appears to be what others are sensing and cognizing (wondering and guessing about) — this appears to be the case because when two experienced realist artists draw a picture of a person, they come up with similar drawings. When we dance together, we move to the same beats. When a scientist attempts to redo a heavily scrutinized and consistently replicated experiment, they can do so and achieve identical results...</p><p>Seeking truthful/common ground answers sounds simple, but (as I have detailed in many previous posts) <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>appears extremely complex and immense. I don’t feel confident that I can verify the validity/truthfulness of my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>with the tools at my disposal: my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/sensation-33308bad60a5">sensations </a>and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions</a> (using sensations and cognitions to verify sensations and cognitions is circular). Secondary sources are available as well, but <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">secondary sources</a> come from other people who are also just using their <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/sensation-33308bad60a5">sensations </a>and cognitions to verify as well (circular again). No one is equipped to “justify a belief as true” for the whole of all being from their own tiny and limited subjective human perspective.</p><p>But, I don’t have the option to “not guess” my preference sensations require/compel me to act; if I do not, I will eventually suffer and die. Each action that I take (deliberate action or compelled) requires me (both the part of “me” that attends consciously or the part of me that acts habitually or instinctually) to make many guesses and act upon them. — I cannot get away from guessing — and I am not a perfect guesser — not one of us appears to be a perfect guesser, and those who think they are, ought to consider if they are under the spell of confirmation bias by seeking more evidence and heavily scrutinizing their guesses.</p><p>False Knowledge, or incorrect guesses that are incorrectly logged as correct guesses muddy my pool of information, they lead me to make more incorrect guesses that muddy my judgment and actions. I often have a hard time determining whether or not a guess is correct, because I only have guesses from sensations and cognitions to work with. It appears to me that “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">Justified True Beliefs</a>” (the definition of knowledge that Plato and Aristotle use) are not attainable, so instead, when I need a truthful answer, I seek my best guesses — heavily <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">scrutinized</a> <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">reasonable (evidence </a>based) be<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">liefs</a> as answers.</p><p>When I need a truthful answer, I seek heavily <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinized </a><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">reasonable (evidence based) beliefs</a> to answer serious questions by using elements that I’ve described in previous posts:</p><ol><li>Trying to keep my pool of information clean/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truthful</a> — I do this by using my own <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/sensation-33308bad60a5">sensations </a>of truth, and reliable and relevant <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinized </a><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">secondary sources</a> of information who do not appear to intend to deceive themselves or me. I explain tips on keeping my pool of information clean <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">here</a>.</li><li>Using the cognitive process that I explained <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">here</a> to guess and check (<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize</a>) my cognized guesses with observed truth over and over until I gain confidence in them and they start to form evidence based beliefs that appear to my senses to resemble my experiences.</li><li>Attempting to accurately categorize my guesses/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>as beliefs, denials, and wonders using evidence from my pool of information (which, again, I’m trying to keep clean) and maintain a sense of wonder when no evidence or not enough evidence is available. And, I attempt to use only those beliefs, denials, and wonders that appear reasonable to guide my deliberate actions (for beliefs)/inactions(for denials)/cautious actions or inactions (for wonders). I explained the categorization process <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">here</a>.</li><li>Checking/scrutinizing my categorizations of reasonable beliefs/denials/wonders, in an attempt to avoid confirmation bias. I explain the scrutinization process <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">here</a>. And in order to more heavily scrutinized my beliefs/denials/wonders, I should remain open to scrutinizing conversations with other truth seekers. I describe strategies for these conversations at the end of this post: W<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">hat is true?</a></li><li>Attempting to avoid mental tricks from <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">cognitive dissonance theory</a> that encourage me to ignore/deny evidence or make up evidence (muddying my pool of information) I may feel tempted to do this to avoid questioning beliefs that I hold sacred — Holding beliefs sacred hinders truth seeking. Questioning them when the evidence contradicts them encourages learning. Cognitive dissonance is explained <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">here</a>.</li><li>And, attempting to avoid objectification —objectification is a way of attending to sensations and cognitions in which I confuse my cognitions of truth with truth itself (valuing the stories I’ve told myself about truth above my observations of truth) which I explain <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a">here</a>. Plato’s definition of “knowledge” as “justified true belief” is an example of objectification that I explain <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">here</a>.</li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">Truth </a>seeking has many components and it involves a great deal of checking and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinizing </a>to arrive at <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinized </a>reasonable (evidence based) beliefs. It also requires practice, and I can get better at it and faster at it over time (as exemplified in how over the course of their lifetime an artist can get more precise and faster at making drawings of reality that look realistic to other humans). But, if I don’t work at it, I’ll accept a lot of beliefs that contradict evidence from truth, and those beliefs will muddy my pool of information and lead to poor predictions, that lead me to perform actions that output outcomes that oppose my intentions. In other words, I’ll make mistakes. Mistakes are a necessary part of learning. If I am willing to look at my mistaken predictions, and wonder/reassess my guesses to home in on more accurate predictions, I can learn from my mistakes. However, if I’m under the influence of confirmation bias and mental tricks shown in cognitive dissonance theory, I won’t recognize that my mistaken beliefs are leading to mistaken actions and I’ll go forth confidently repeating the same actions that lead to the same mistakes over and over again.</p><p>As some people in our midst spout disinformation and manipulative arguments about serious matters, this strategy might help us keep our pools of information clean, give us courage and motivation to question and call out those who deliberately disinform and/or manipulate, and help us maintain a steady footing while conversing with people with whom we disagree. It might help motivate us and others to stay sane and seeking so we don’t place undue trust in unsupported beliefs and run confidently in an unreasonable direction. It might give us pause so we don’t, like lemmings, run confidently off whichever extremist cliff might call to our unreasonable <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference</a> sensations (Unreasonable preference sensations are those preference sensations cultivated by beliefs that contradict observable evidence).</p><p>This post is part of a larger philosophy. You can read all of the articles here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce3ae1915af4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Objectification]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/objectification-3edeb7d51e0a?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3edeb7d51e0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[objectification]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Nov 2024 05:29:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T14:25:49.257Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IBUVib5QYAjgN3vQebBRmQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">Concepts/cognitions</a> are not <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>. Truth <em>is </em>truth.</p><p>In my philosophy, objectification <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-meaning-ca6d1b5facea">means </a>confusing beings/truth with my cognized representations of them — in other words, thinking that a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">concept/cognition</a> is true instead of seeing the being/truth as true (note, I have learned a new word that fits this concept better: reification — objectification is not quite right in how we use it in normal language, but it’s what I chose to use when I initially wrote this paper). In objectification concepts trump observations. In truth seeking, observations trump concepts.</p><p>Remember what was covered in the previous “What is meaning?” article. “Beings mean themselves.” This is a difficult concept to convey (especially to western thinkers who tend to think of meaning as “man-made” In this philosophy, categorizations are man-made, meanings are the beings that the categorizations are derived from). At their roots, true meanings are the beings themselves that define our words— true meanings aren’t concepts/cognitions — I can’t capture beings in their entirety in a concept. Beings/truth are too complex. We can instead seek to understand them perpetually through observation with curiosity.</p><p>This idea is central to the philosophy that I’m writing. The idea that our cognitions are not truths. And that truth/reality/the whole of all being is entirely meaning filled.</p><p>Truth is a common ground for us all to discover together through our sensations. It isn’t something that we can hold onto in our cognitions.</p><p>For instance the manikin pictured above is not a person, it is a representation of a person that we recognize as person-like, and that representation is a useful tool for us. If someone confuses a manikin for a person, it wouldn’t take them long to realize their mistake, because the manikin actually is an incredibly over simplified representation of a person.</p><p>Other mistakes are not so easy to recognize — Women and men are often objectified — people have concepts in their mind for what a woman or man “is” and how she/he is expected to look and behave as a woman or a man. We create boxes for people (manikin-like simplifications— concepts/cognitions that live in our minds as representations of man and woman) and when a person acts in a way that doesn’t fit into their male/female conceptual box, objectifiers often find that surprising, confusing, and even upsetting. They want to change the deviator and encourage them back into the box they’ve built rather than adjusting the box to include the deviator as a possibly harmless alternative to their concept of a woman/man.</p><p>The beings that the words “man” and “woman” represent aren’t concepts/cognitions, they are beings. Beings are simply beings, very often they cannot be adjusted to fit into conceptualized boxes, and why should they? Conceptualized boxes, however, can be easily adjusted to accommodate truth, and when we make these adjustments, our cognitions are corrected — they are more in line with truth, the common ground whole of all being.</p><p>People are beings. They are themselves. They are little portions of truth to be curious about and learn more about. (Though it is also important to be on the lookout for defectors to avoid being harmed ( Defectors are those who desire to cause harm or seek non fairness) — and protect oneself from such defectors — I will discuss the meaning of “defector” “harm” and “fairness seeking” in the article about <a href="https://medium.com/original-philosophy/evidence-based-morality-ad0fc26e91b8">evidence based morality</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*xtQKEKzS57nMqbyR1clFVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The thing pictured to the left is not an “apple” it is itself.</figcaption></figure><p>I can gather information about bits of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>and make rudimentary representations of them as evidenced in the way that I can paint a portrait of a woman with enough resemblance to her that another person could recognize the resemblance, but at no point does my painting become so real that it actually becomes the woman.</p><p>I seek truth. It is an aspiration, but I can’t “confirm” my beliefs about truth to be “true” (<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">I’ll explain in a future post</a>). Instead, I can see that my beliefs are useful in predicting future outcomes, and I can <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize </a>my beliefs and try to determine if they appear common to others who heavily <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize </a>their beliefs about the topic. But, even if we all agreed, the belief doesn’t “become true” because a lot of people believe it, it just becomes a more heavily scrutinized representation that appears accurate to all of us who agree (which gives it the appearance of being a more reliable and trustworthy belief).</p><p>My <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">categorizations, cognitions</a>, cognized boxes, and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-meaning-ca6d1b5facea">symbols </a>are not truth — beings and “truth, the whole of all being” is truth.</p><p>And, for truth seekers — truth, the common ground seems forever worthy to look upon with awe and curiosity and for us to seek to understand together. The boxes/concepts we impose onto beings are not; they are like manikins — over simplified and easy to dismiss.</p><p>As a realist painter, I’ve spent my lifetime learning how to paint realistically, and I’m still learning. The first step in any realist drawing is wondering — using light lines to try to map out what I’m seeing, and not making bold marks until patterns that resemble what I’m seeing start to appear. Letting go of my preconceived notions about a face allows me to capture a portrait more realistically. (I attempt with all my might to adjust the box to fit the person, not fit the person into a preconceived box).</p><p>If I was drawing in an objectified way, I wouldn’t need to look, I’d just draw what I think a person looks like — I might use a cannon of proportions, and I might come up with a nice drawing of what we’ve come to think of as a “person,” but it wouldn’t resemble a real person in the way that a realist painting does. It would appear more manikin like. Drawing in an objectified way is not a truth-seeking process, it’s an expressive process — an expression of simplified cognitions not expressions of sensitively and directly observed truth.</p><p>Both seeking and expressing appear to be useful human activities and they appear important to a person’s survival and thriving, but when we confuse our “expressions” with “truth,” — when we focus on our expressed understandings of reality and call them “true” instead of saying “appears true” and reserve the word “true” for truth — we run the risk of losing our connection to the common ground whole of all being. When we trust our expressions and stop looking for new information and adjusting the boxes to fit the truth, that is how irresolvable conflicts arise. (I’ll explain more of what I mean by this in the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-true-29c8b7c1f5b5">“What is True”</a> article).</p><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3edeb7d51e0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Intentions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/intentions-5ab2f0731ec8?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ab2f0731ec8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[intentions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Nov 2024 19:16:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-20T08:19:46.678Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HYcywnZ3LMd7KSnFTFuadg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jontyson?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Jon Tyson</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/a-person-standing-in-the-middle-of-a-street-PXB7yEM5LVs?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Intentions are the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> that <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">I</a> choose to let guide <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">my </a><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/attending-focus-14986a7bb72e">attention </a>and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions</a>. I choose which preference sensations to follow using the <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a> in which I wonder and guess and determine which guesses/cognitions I will believe, deny, or need to wonder more about.</p><p>Choosing happens only when preference sensations are not so strong that they cause compelled reactions. This post is about deliberate actions not compelled actions.</p><p>Here is a little reminder about how the choosing process seems to me to work I’m pulling this from a previous post about “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions</a>”—</p><ul><li>My preference sensations influence my attention: they encourage or compel to which sensations, and cognitions (how I’ve categorized beliefs, wonders, denials) my attention is attracted toward or repelled away from.</li><li>My sensations and cognitions (how I’ve categorized beliefs, wonders, and denials) then influence which preference sensations I attend to and how.</li><li>My preference sensations then influence my attention: which sensations and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, and denials) “I” attend to.</li><li>My sensations and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, denials) then influence which preference sensations I attend to and how&gt;&gt;.….</li><li>This cycle goes on and on so long as I have the ability to sense and cognize.</li></ul><p>All throughout this process, if I am truth seeking — I am <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">checking my beliefs/denials/wonders — (I am scrutiniz</a>ing them or deliberating about them). See my post about scrutinization to see how it appears to me that that process works. I often modify which <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>to move forward with as I take in new sensory evidence and cognize about it. The more I scrutinize my preference sensations, sensations, and cognitions, the more deliberate my intentions become, and the more deliberate my actions often become.</p><p>Deliberateness, in my philosophy, is a categorization on a continuum based on the level of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutiny/checking</a> I do during the <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a>:</p><p>Little <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinization </a>= less deliberate &amp; a lot of scrutinization = more deliberate. No scrutinization = Not deliberate.</p><h3>Deliberation</h3><p>Below is the model that I’ve been using to illustrate the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitive process</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b1NZqgj1qLuDSZ9b1bmLvA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image of a cognized model of the cognitive process create by the author</figcaption></figure><p>Below is an example of deliberation, so you can get a more accurate representation of how deliberate intentions and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>come to be (from my perspective).</p><p>Example:</p><ol><li>I feel (a preference sensation) that I want/need something— but what is it? (use <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a> — think, sense, wonder..)… guess</li><li>_(What I’ve guessed)_ appears to be what I want/need, and after <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinizing</a>/checking that guess (think, sense, wonder some more), I decide that = yes, I believe that I want/need _(what I’ve guessed)_.</li><li>My <strong>intention </strong>is now to get/keep _(what I’ve guessed)_.</li><li>How do I get/keep_(what I’ve guessed)_ without losing other things that I believe that want/need and without coming into contact with something else that I believe that I want/need to avoid (Use <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a> to wonder/guess about which <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>will work best to meet the intentions that I’ve chosen)…</li></ol><p>or in the case of negative preference sensations:</p><p>Example:</p><ol><li>I feel (a preference sensation) that I want/need to avoid something — but what is it? (use <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a> — think, sense, wonder..)… guess</li><li>_(What I’ve guessed)_ appears to be what I want/need to avoid, and after <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinizing</a>/checking that (think, sense, wonder some more), I decide that = yes, I believe that I want/need to avoid_(What I’ve guessed)_.</li><li>My <strong>intention </strong>is to avoid _(What I’ve guessed)_.</li><li>How do I avoid _(What I’ve guessed)_ without losing other things that I believe that I want/need and without coming into contact with something else that I believe that I want/need to avoid…(Use <a href="http://cognitive process">cognitive process</a> to wonder/guess about which <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>will work best to meet the intentions that I’ve chosen)…</li></ol><h3>Correct Action?</h3><p>To determine if an action was correct, I <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize</a> the result of the action with the intention.</p><p>Example: Did my action result as intended or better? Goal/intention achieved? Yes= cognition and/or action seems right. No= contradiction detected, cognition and/or action seems to need improvement.</p><p>As I correct/adapt my actions over time, I home in on more carefully rendered actions for a variety of situations that fulfill my intentions without causing unwanted effects. I learn. I get better and better at meeting my intentions without unwanted effects.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">Cognitive Dissonance Theory</a> is important to mention here. Humans appear to be pretty attached to some guesses/beliefs, and they have a tendency sometimes to ignore evidence that their guesses/beliefs are incorrect, especially when the beliefs are very strong or “sacred” to them. A sacred belief would be one in which a person fears they will be lost without the belief (they have strong negative preference sensations about the idea of wondering if it is incorrect — it <em>has </em>to be correct for them). They struggle to wonder about the potential that the belief might contradict reality. So, when a contradiction to the belief occurs, they often find ways to ignore the contradiction or explain it away rather than considering the evidence and wondering some more to change the belief.</p><p>Here is a visual of how we could apply cognitive dissonance theory to what I’m talking about:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xuR4LzXtrclmBIoVFm50yg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Correct Intention?</h3><p>If the action appears successful (the action had the <em>intended </em>result), but the result of the action appears to harm my health and well-being (or cause prolonged suffering and death/destruction of myself or others that I care about), then that is a sign that my intention may be incorrect and may be in need of revision.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">Preference sensations</a> appear to be geared toward leading me and those I care about toward homeostasis/fulfillment of basic needs and away from prolonged suffering and death.</p><p>If that seems controversial, I must ask: In cases when one thinks they prefer enduring prolonged suffering and death, and in cases where one thinks they prefer not to fulfil basic needs- in those instances, do those people end up with prolonged <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">negative preference sensations </a>until they change their ways? Do they feel nothing as a result? Do they have positive preference sensations as a result? It is my experience that prolonged negative preference sensations are the end result until a person changes their ways, but I am open to hearing other opinions.</p><p>When my intentions lead me toward prolonged suffering and death and away from my basic needs, it’s a pretty telling signal that my intentions are incorrect in accordance with what my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> are trying to tell me, and I should wonder about how I can improve upon my interpretation of them so that I can perform actions that lead to outcomes that do not include prolonged suffering and death.</p><h3>Apologies</h3><p>When my intentions and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>appear incorrect, and I hurt someone I didn’t intend to hurt. It appears important to acknowledge the harm and express what I will do to change (How I will change my actions to avoid harming in the future).</p><p>If I don’t acknowledge the harm— if I don’t express to those that I may have hurt that I see my errors and intend to change them, they may think that I deliberately meant to hurt them, and that I might continue to do it again (and I probably will do it again if I don’t see error in my actions and/or intentions and then change my actions and/or intentions). They might see me as an enemy and treat me as such. To avoid such outcomes, it is healthy/in my best interests to acknowledge/express faults and begin deliberation about changing intentions and actions to better serve myself and those around me.</p><p>I can deliberate about my intentions again and again to come up with new guesses that will lead toward more targeted intentions that achieve my goals without harming my health and well-being and without harming the health and well-being of my community (those who I intend to live well with).</p><p>Again, keep in mind <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">Cognitive Dissonance Theory</a> and the difficulty humans have in considering the incorrectness of their guesses. A person who harms themselves or others may convince themselves or others that they are overreacting to the harm — in this way, they change their perceptions of the experience of harm and permit themselves to continue to harm. They use a mental trick instead of acknowledging the harm and changing their ways.</p><p>One belief that people often appear to consider sacred is that the belief that “I am a good/well intentioned person” It may be hard for a person to admit fault if they cannot allow themselves to consider the evidence that their actions were harmful and in need of changing. In this way, their belief that “I am a good/well intentioned person” can actually prevent them from homing in on actions that would help them demonstrate that they are a good/well intentioned person.</p><h3>Without Deliberation</h3><p>My <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> lead me to believe that my top priority is to follow their lead, but I can’t understand what they are trying to tell me without <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognition</a>, and my cognition is just wondering and guessing about all of my sensations (and also my cognitions). By acting, and observing the outcomes of my actions, over time, I can home in on actions more preferrable outcomes (in a guess and check style of learning).</p><p>My guesses frequently contradict outcomes in <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth/reality</a>. If I’m not <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinizing </a>my cognitions and checking to see if my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> are rooted in evidence from truth and not the result of faulty cognitions/incorrect guesses, then I’ll use mistaken intentions to make mistaken <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>that lead me toward undesired results: toward results that will harm/kill me or others and away from results that will lead to fulfilling basic needs/well-being for myself and others in my community.</p><p>Also, if am not <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinizing </a>and checking to make sure that my guesses are correct about <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/why-do-i-feel-the-way-that-i-feel-0d02164787b8">cognized causes for preference sensations</a>, I will frequently misinterpret what my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> are trying to tell me. I will blindly follow incorrect cognitions about preference sensations and they will misguide my intentions and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions</a> toward undesirable results as well.</p><p>Deliberation/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinization </a>is an important part of the process when deciding what intentions and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77">actions </a>I should engage in.</p><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Intentions are the preference sensations that I choose to let guide my actions when I’m behaving in a deliberate way. They are what I want to have happen — what I intend to have happen. I attempt to act in such a way that will bring about the happenings/results that I intend.</p><p>This post is part of a larger philosophy. Read it here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ab2f0731ec8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Actions/Behaviors]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/actions-behaviors-aae640cb2c77?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aae640cb2c77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emotions]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Nov 2024 22:17:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-15T03:13:42.180Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mFjxIIIhB7S4GTpVd0xPCQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@aoddeh?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Ahmad Odeh</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/time-lapse-photography-of-man-dancing-ckm1yAe6jhU?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>An action is a thing that is done. It is what<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f"> I do</a>. It is what others do also. Another word that I use for action is behavior. Our actions, because they are visible and impactful to others in the world of beings, are where thoughts/cognitions/ inner world medium are translated into observable things/happenings/“alterations of being medium” that can then be sensed and cognized by myself and others.</p><p>Actions have an impact on/move/change/modify bits of truth. They impact truth’s composition — they impact how bits of truth (photons, energy, atoms, protons, neutrons, molecules, chemicals, matter and objects) are arranged.</p><p>The arrangement of those components appears to impact the current nature of truth — the arrangement of bits of truth is consequential to me. It appears consequential to how truth appears to my senses and how I feel about it (and even whether or not my body can continue to survive and thrive in it). The arrangement of bits of truth is also consequential to how truth appears to other sentient beings and how they feel about it (and even whether or not their bodies can continue to survive and thrive in it).</p><p>My actions are consequential to myself and other beings, and the actions of others are consequential to me.</p><h3>How Do Actions that “I” Perform Happen?</h3><p>In my understanding and experience, my actions/behaviors don’t seem to “just happen.” They appear cultivated. They appear to be a result of causes. But, as I explain throughout this post, they do not appear to be completely pre determined without “my” influence — “I” (the I that I sense and cognize myself to be) appear to play <em>some </em>role in the cultivation of “my” deliberate actions.</p><p>The causes of my actions appear to me to be a direct result of my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> (feelings of attraction/positive preference sensations and feelings of avoidance/negative preference sensations), which appear to be a direct result of the chemical signaling molecules being released inside of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">my body</a>. I do not see how I become motivated to perform actions without these chemical signals and without the experience of preference sensations/feelings of attraction and avoidance.</p><p>However, I am not saying that <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">“I”</a> have no free will. It appears to me that “I” do have some control over how some of my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> impact my behavior. That control seems to be rooted in how I choose to categorize my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>as <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs, wonders, and denials</a> and that categorization impacts how I receive (believe), proceed with caution (wonder), or reject (deny) the preference sensations that result from such belief, wonders, and denials. I’ll discuss more about that shortly.</p><p>In this post, I’ll discuss actions/behaviors in more detail, and I’ll also discuss how categorizing <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>into <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs, wonders, and denials</a> impacts what I “do” with them.</p><p>Because I’ve addressed already how some <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs, denials, and wonders</a> are <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">reasonable </a>and some are <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">unreasonable </a>— I’ll also discuss how reasonable and unreasonable beliefs and denials lead to reasonable and unreasonable <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> and actions.</p><h3>Categories of Actions</h3><h4>Compelled vs Deliberate Actions</h4><p>Compelled actions are those that happen as a result of strong <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> (lots of chemical signaling molecules binding to receptors all at once), like when I jump as a result of being startled by a loud unexpected noise. These are not the kinds of actions that I’m discussing in this post. I’m talking more about deliberate actions.</p><p>Deliberate actions are those that appear to occur as a result of a weaker <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensation</a> (a smaller more manageable trickle of chemicals binding to receptors over a period of time). Weaker preference sensations appear to allow me to think about how I feel, why I feel that way, and then decide what to “do” about those feelings — such as ignore them, make a plan and carry out actions to achieve a preferred outcome/goal, or use experimental actions to gather more evidence and wonder more about what goals or actions I should take seriously.</p><p>Sometimes I prefer to carry out deliberate actions, like when I’m working on a dangerous project where accuracy is crucial to the survival or safety of myself or others. Sometimes, I prefer to “feel my feelings” and let them “move” me — like when I am at a concert or dancing, or when I’m really sad and let myself cry, or when I am really angry and let myself yell or break something (sadness and anger are emotion words that I use to describe specific preference sensations).</p><p>I do appear to have the ability (in many instances) to decide/deliberate/choose when I will let myself indulge in my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a>; when I will let them build up into stronger compelling sensations that impact my actions/choices. I can also choose to try to quiet those preference sensations and avoid letting them impact my choices/actions. I do that by “rationalizing” with myself: telling myself “this preference sensation isn’t worth listening to right now” perhaps because it doesn’t seem appropriate — I tell myself “people don’t behave freely in places like this” or perhaps because the preference sensation is from a cognition that does not appear to be rooted in evidence (like the cognition that there is a monster under my bed) — I can tell myself “there does not appear to be any <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a> to this cognition and I will not allow the preference sensations from that cognitions to impact my behavior.”</p><h4>Outside of Me</h4><p>Some deliberate actions appear to take place outside of my body and are more visible to the outside world:</p><p>I seem to be able to decide to express my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preferences </a>outside of my body with carefully chosen words and body language in a very cooperative situation, or I seem to be able to decide to express with more relaxed words or movements to communicate with a more casual audience, or I seem to be able to decide to express with brash unthoughtful words and movements to show my anger and get people to fear my wrath. — The key word here is “decide.” I can often decide how to express my preferences and cognitions as actions.</p><h4>Inside of Me</h4><p>Some deliberate actions appear to happen inside of my body and are less visible to the outside world: the action of my attention changing from one sensation/cognition to another (like I am paying attention to the smell of those delicious cookies, but now my cat has used the litter box and there is a new smell in the air that I’m paying attention to) — other beings outside of my body may not be able to observe the action of my change of attention in this case — Unless my face changes, or I decide that I need to go clean the litter box.</p><h3>Cultivation of Actions</h3><p>As I mentioned before, deliberate actions don’t appear to just happen, they appear to me to be cultivated.</p><p>Part of this deliberative process appears to be dependent upon how I’ve categorized <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>into <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs, wonders, and denials </a>about <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>.</p><h4>Belief, Denial, &amp; Wonder and Preference Sensations &amp; Actions</h4><p><strong>Beliefs </strong>are <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>that I consider to be guesses that appear accurate in accordance with <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>. I take them seriously. I use them to inform preference sensations that I trust to inform deliberate actions with minimal reservation. They can be strong to weak- I don’t often question my strong beliefs unless there is very strong <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>against them. When someone else disagrees with my strong beliefs, I will often feel strong <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">negative preference sensation</a>s (How could someone not believe what seems so absolutely true to me? Why are they not feeling strong negative preference sensations about something that I’m feeling strong negative preference sensations about? — What is “wrong” with them?). But weak beliefs are closer to wonders that I will more easily question and modify and get less upset about if someone disagrees with me — I’ll be more curious about their reactions, ask more questions, and feel less furious/defensive.</p><p>C<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/cognitive-dissonance-bad644af2b6d">ognitive dissonance theory</a> shows that we feel <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">negative preference sensations</a> when strong beliefs are thrown into question/wonder, and we may experience an aversion to recategorizing a strong belief as a wonder when it is called into question even when the evidence makes it highly reasonable to do so. For this reason, it seems for the interests of truth seeking, we should avoid labeling a cognition as a “strong belief” only if it is supported by a great deal of heavily scrutinized <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence that appears reliable</a> and if the belief appears to yield observable and consistently reliable accurate predictions.</p><p><strong>Wonders </strong>are <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>that I don’t know what to do with — I’m keeping an open mind and seeking more information in hopes of making a more informed decision in the future. I try not to get “too worked up” or “let my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> from these cognitions compel me to act” unless I have to make a choice on what to do (I cannot vacillate forever sometimes). And, when I<em> do </em>need to make a choice to act that I don’t totally believe in, I don’t do so confidently — I act, and then seek to understand the result of my actions so that I can learn to hone in on a more appropriate and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence</a> based action in the future (I take the result of my actions as <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>in the learning experience).</p><p>Given that <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>is immense and complex and most of us do not have the time to <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb">scrutinize </a>our <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>into reliably reasonable beliefs, it seems reasonable to categorize a very large proportion of our cognitions with some degree of wonder. Categorizing cognitions with a degree of wonder creates a lot of learning experiences and helps me avoid getting carried away by and defending <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">strong preference sensations</a> and brash actions that turn out later to be unreasonable/not evidence based.</p><p><strong>Denials </strong>are <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>that I don’t think are accurate. I don’t take those cognitions seriously. I do not use them to inform my actions. For instance, the cognition that I can fly is a cognition that I have come to deny. When I have the idea/cognition that maybe I can fly over the Grand Canyon unaided if I just believe real hard, I laugh at it, I don’t take it seriously, and I don’t try to fly over the Grand Canyon using the power of my beliefs and cognitions. I have never been able to fly unaided even though I really really want to. There is also plenty of evidence to show what happens to people when they step off the edge of the Grand Canyon; 100% of them fall and are killed or severely injured (though I cannot verify whether or not the fault was in the lack of strength of their beliefs and cognitions, the idea of being able to fly unaided is quite appealing and as much as each human being may want to fly unaided, not one of us has demonstrated the ability to do it).</p><h4>Actions Speak Louder than Words</h4><p>Actions are much more telling than words when it comes to trying to understand what someone believes, wonders, and denies. I can “tell” you that I categorize a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognition </a>as a belief, wonder, or denial, but that isn’t the whole story. What matters is how I treat the cognition: Do I appear to take the cognition seriously and confidently use it to inform my logical deductions and actions that I feel justified in taking (believe), or do I appear to ignore or laugh off the cognition (deny) or do I appear to vacillate about it and try to seek more information and use the cognition cautiously (wonder)?</p><h4>Reasonable Belief, Denial, and Wonder</h4><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">Reasonable</a>, in my philosophy is another word for “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>based.” I shared the chart below in a previous post. I’m including it now in this post about actions as a quick review. I build upon this diagram later in this post:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SKoK-0QuVkjUh8zvbfdMCw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Belief, wonder, and deny are listed on one access of the diagram, and evidentiary support is listed on the other access.</p><p>See the diagonal line and the grey squares marked as “reasonable.” Also note the fuzzy borders between the squares of both of the accesses. Both accesses are continuum type categorizations where they bleed into one another (a weak belief is like a strong wonder, and a weak wonder is like a weak denial and there is a big difference between a strong belief and a strong denial.</p><p>If I’m being <strong>reasonable</strong>, I’ll use <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>from <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>to support my beliefs and denials and I will scrutinize/compare my evidence with my beliefs and denials with truth to avoid confirmation bias. My aim, when I am truth seeking, is to collect “heavily scrutinized and reasonable” beliefs and denials and maintain a sense of wonder for cognitions for which there is little to no evidentiary support from <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable sources</a>.</p><p>If I’m being reasonable, my categorizations will be rooted in <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>from our <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">common ground/truth</a> and should be useful in predicting some future outcomes because many of the elements/bits of truth (molecules, atoms, objects..) appear to behave in a fairly predictable way once I’ve learned to recognize and understand the patterns they follow.</p><p>Maintaining wonder for cognitions for which the evidence is inconclusive can help me keep an open mind when there isn’t enough evidence to show that my cognitions are useful in making reliable predictions. It can also encourage me to seek more evidence to make better informed decisions that could prevent me from making mistakes or help me proceed with caution and watch out for potential mistakes and learn from them.</p><h4>Cognition, Cognition Categorization &amp; The Cultivation of Reasonable Actions</h4><p>Below, I’ve put some of my previous visual aids together to show how the components of {<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">Cognition </a>}and {Cognition Categorization/Belief, Denial &amp; Wonder} fit together to cultivate <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> and actions that a person will find reasonable. If you have not seen these before, I explain the two illustrations in detail in these two posts:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">Cognition, Wonder, and Reason</a></p><p>R<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">easonable Belief, Denial, and Wonder</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TdJHuC7Qxm9CM84tokDxDg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Garbage in, Garbage out</h3><p>The illustration above gives a visual representation of my cognized model of the cultivation of actions. It adds to the story of belief, denial, and wonder, and how these categorizations appear to impact my preference sensations and actions.</p><h4>The Chain Reaction</h4><p>As I already explained in this post— How I categorize my cognitions as beliefs, denials, and wonders appears to impact how I treat those cognitions and the preference sensations that they inspire. Preference sensations that I trust/believe often lead to actions, preference sensations that I don’t trust/deny lead me to ignore them and not act upon them. Preference sensations that I’m not sure of/wonder about lead me to consider acting upon them, and if I choose to act, I proceed cautiously.</p><h4>Doomed From the Start</h4><p>The illustration also shows a couple of ways in which the cognitive process can lead to unreasonable (not evidence based) beliefs and actions or unreasonable denials and inactions:</p><ol><li>Attending to/sensing <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">misinformation</a></li><li>Making incorrect guesses and not scrutinizing them to observe their inaccuracy and/or not modifying/refining incorrect guesses.</li></ol><p>Perhaps you’ve heard the term “garbage in, garbage out.” From the start, these two steps at the beginning of the cognitive process can lead to inaccurate categorizations of cognitions about sensations/input (garbage in), which have a domino effect into my actions/output (garbage out):</p><p>If I’m prone to jumping to conclusions/beliefs or denials, ignoring evidence that I’m wrong, and seeking misinformation that supports my inaccurate claims, I’ll struggle to maintain an evidential connection to truth the whole of all being — I’ll believe unreasonable thoughts (cognitions) and feel unreasonable feelings (preference sensations), that lead me to feel justified in taking unreasonable (not reliable evidence based) actions.</p><p>I, “myself” will feel very reasonable (because I’m not checking my guesses to see that they are not evidence based and using faulty sources to back up my cognitions) even though I am out on a cognized tangent that bears little to no resemblance to “truth the whole of all being.” But, the preference sensations/intentions/attention are misguided and based upon inaccurate cognitions/misinformation/“not beings” that others can point to and show me. They can show me why my sources are not <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable </a>and not evidence based if I’m willing to look at their evidence (if they have reliable evidence). My misguided truth-seeking process appears to lead me to carry out unreasonable actions while thinking I’m totally reasonable.</p><p>For the purpose of cultivating reasonable/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">evidence </a>based preference sensations and actions/intentions/attention (reasonable/evidence based output), it is important that I attempt to avoid trusting misinformation from unscrutinized and unreliable secondary sources, and it is also important that I scrutinize my cognitions with sensations from truth and <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable secondary sources</a>, and deny cognitions that appear to contradict scrutinized reliable evidence. I should also continue to wonder open mindedly about cognitions for which there is no evidence for the purpose of cultivating reasonable/evidence based actions.</p><p>As I said before, however, that all takes time, and I also have food, water, shelter… collecting that I need to balance my time with. I don’t have endless time and effort for truth seeking. I’ll have to prepare for the future that I think might be coming (by using my sensory observations and cognitive process), and do my best not to die/become destitute, and hope to perform actions that align with my intentions. If I maintain at least a small sense of wonder for my cognitions, I’ll be more apt to watch for what mistakes my actions cause and learn from them so that I don’t ride them out when (from the outside observer’s perspective) they are clearly leading me away from my intentions.</p><p>Also, incorrect guesses and actions are inevitable- I cannot make heavily scrutinized reasonable beliefs and denials (knowledge by my definition) without a lot of experience and scrutinizing. I have to wonder and guess a lot, learn, and modify my guesses before I can arrive at cognitions that appear to resemble my experiences and are useful in predicting future outcomes. I have to start somewhere — For instance, I cannot make a drawing without starting with some guessed marks that may turn out the be inaccurate in the end. I also cannot learn to draw without making some pretty inaccurate drawings as a beginning artist. It is only with practice and scrutinizing that I can gain accuracy at seeing and expressing what I appear to see.</p><h4>The Challenge of Correct Categorization</h4><p>Even if I feel like I’m accurately cognizing: I am scrutinizing my cognitions with truth and<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62"> reliable sources</a> and correcting my incorrect cognitions to the best of my ability, the next potential issue I need to avoid is using false dichotomy to categorize my beliefs, denials, and wonders.</p><p>If I’ve scrutinized my evidence based beliefs, and I use Aristotle’s definition of knowledge, then I might feel like I have arrived at “the truth” or “justified true beliefs” But, as I discussed in the post “what is true” I don’t have the power to justify my beliefs as “truth.” I only have access to appearances/sensations of truth. Truth is true and my beliefs are just my best guesses. If my beliefs are based upon evidence that appears <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable</a>, then they are reasonabe. If they have been heavily scrutinized and appear to yield consistently accurate predictions, then they are heavily scrutinized and reasonable guesses (the best that I appear to be able to do), but at no point, do my guesses become “truth.”</p><p>It appears to me that there is a continuum between belief and denial with a big grey area in the middle for wonder.</p><p>We often encounter cognitions for which the evidence is inconclusive, and if we treat those cognitions like strong beliefs, we run the risk of confidently pushing ahead with the actions that feel correct in accordance with them even though they are not supported by evidence. We also run the risk of ignoring the potential that we might be incorrect (confirmation bias and mental tricks outlined in Leon Festinger’s cognitive dissonance theory).</p><p>If we treat cognitions for which the evidence appears inconclusive as though they are strong denials, we run the risk of ignoring or laughing off preference sensations that might be useful in keeping us safe or leading us to fulfill our intentions if we had considered more evidence and taken the time to wonder more about them (confirmation bias and mental tricks outlined in Leon Festinger’s cognitive dissonance theory).</p><p>Due to the vastness and complexity of truth and the apparent inadequacy of my sensation and cognition apparatuses for <em>sensing </em>and <em>making sense of</em> truth, the whole of all being — It seems as though cognitions for which the evidence appears inconclusive is actually a very large proportion of our cognitions.</p><p>It appears to me that to honor the complexity and vastness of truth, it is reasonable (or a reasonable idea) to leave a little tiny bit of room for wonder in each and every cognition, even those that I’ve categorized as very heavily scrutinized and reasonable beliefs and denials.</p><p>Keeping a little space open for wondering seems to help me avoid taking seriously <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">preference sensations</a> that are unreasonable/not evidence based, and avoid confidently repeating the same mistaken actions over and over again and defending them without evidence. It can also help me avoid getting so attached to beliefs and denials that I use confirmation bias and mental tricks outlined in cognitive dissonance theory to avoid considering other alternatives. It can help me be honest with myself about my own fallibility. It can help me be humble — be a more careful listener, be a more rigorous scrutinizer and (as I observe) become a more accurate truth seeker (going back to the portrait drawing analogy — if I observe and draw in a less confident/less judgmental way — if I observe and draw carefully in the beginning with “wondering” or “sketching” marks and scrutinize my sketching marks with reality, I’ll create a lot of mapping marks that cross reference one another and show me where the features of the face should likely go, and as I darken those marks for the facial features (more confidently), my drawing begins to show an accurate likeness, and I can keep going and learning about the face and add more details accurately. In contrast, the drawings of those who judge quickly without much attention to observation and scrutinization or cross referencing and do not modify their marks, they are unable to get a better likeness or map in more details accurately, because they haven’t done the work to show themselves where the facial features or details should go).</p><p>Stopping wonder prematurely by labeling a cognition as a strong unwavering belief or denial when the evidence isn’t there to support it, can lead to simplified cognitions of truth that never grow into more rich, more <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable evidence</a> filled, and more informed cognitions. It leads to objectification. It leads to brash unreasonable actions that I <em>think </em>are reasonable. It doesn’t help me seek more refined alternatives and keep honing in on more and more reasonable/evidence based understandings of the whole of all being. It doesn’t help me carry out actions in the future that honor the vastness and complexity of truth of which we are all a part, in which we all appear to exist together. Stopping wonder prematurely and labeling cognitions as strong unwavering truths/beliefs and fallacies/denials leads people out on tangents that seclude them from more evidence — seclude them from careful truth/evidence seekers.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Deliberate actions appear to be cultivated.</p><p>They appear to be cultivated in part by my choices. Preference sensations appear to play a big role in my choices by suggesting or compelling attraction and avoidance. However, “I” also appear to have a say in what preference sensations I take seriously and which ones I ignore as a result of sensation and cognition (belief, denial, wonder cultivation through my cognitive process that is informed by my sensations).</p><p>How I categorize my cognitions as beliefs, denials, and wonders appear to influence how I treat the preference sensations that my categorized cognitions inspire. There seems to be a constant cycle of preference sensations, sensations and cognitions influencing one another:</p><ul><li>My preference sensations influence my attention: which sensations, and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, denials) “I” attend to.</li><li>My sensations and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, denials) then influence which preference sensations I attend to and how.</li><li>My preference sensations then influence my attention: which sensations and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, and denials) “I” attend to.</li><li>My sensations and cognitions (beliefs, wonders, denials) then influence which preference sensations I attend to and how&gt;&gt;.…. in an endless cycle.</li></ul><p>The constant cycle appears to yield my ever-evolving mental map of the whole of all being. It also appears to yield the actions that I choose to take at a given moment in my truth experience. I can then learn from the results of my actions when I attend to the sensations of the results of my actions, which help me refine future actions toward results that I sense and cognize will lead me to fulfill my intentions.</p><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aae640cb2c77" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scrutinization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/scrutinization-7b4626e52afb?source=rss-204a1e4efa4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b4626e52afb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scrutiny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[truth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Kiser]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Nov 2024 22:03:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-29T00:14:29.116Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S67MqL2J-FEE9bcPtRFXUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@marilezhava?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">mari lezhava</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/grayscale-photo-of-man-using-magnifying-glass-q65bNe9fW-w?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>A “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">guess</a>”<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f"> </a>that appears accurate so far, is not necessarily accurate. It just appears accurate because I haven’t noticed anything wrong with it yet — I haven’t noticed any contradictions between the prediction/cognition and observations of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>. To believe it is true without further scrutiny leaves me vulnerable to “confirmation bias.”Confirmation bias happens when a person looks only for evidence that their belief is true and ignores evidence that their belief is false. Confirmation bias may lead me to believe that I am a very good guesser, but it is actually the case that I am not looking to see where I might be wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b1NZqgj1qLuDSZ9b1bmLvA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Above is a model of how the author understands cognition. A “guess” is a judgement using the available sensory information as well as one’s body of prior beliefs/denials/wonders. When I decide to put the guess to rest, it settles into my cognition as a belief, denial, or wonder (if I haven’t decided whether or not the guess seems accurate).</figcaption></figure><p>“Scrutinization” or (checking) is an important process in determining the reliability of a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognition</a>. Scrutinization entails checking to see if I’m wrong. I do this by comparing my most trusted cognitions (<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs</a>) to one another to see how they align with one another (to avoid contradictions in my belief system) as well as comparing my cognitions/belief system to observations of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>(to detect inconsistencies between both my beleif system and my observations). I can also compare my cognitions with the cognitions of other people whom I have deemed “<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-is-reliable-evidence-deee6f1d2b62">reliable</a>” I will discuss that qualification in a different post.</p><p>Personal Scrutinization is a complicated process — I’ll describe it as an analogy to the process of drawing a realist portrait:</p><h3>Realist Drawing Analogy</h3><p>A realist drawing is like a big bunch of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>(w<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">onders and guesses</a>) presented as marks on paper for all to see. We can look at the drawing and look at <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>and compare the two together by looking at them side by side to see how the <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">artist/cognizer </a>performed.</p><p>A realist drawing is like a theory that I can show others and say “does this seem right to you?” In the case of a theory, I’m not necessarily cognizing in a visual way like I do when I am drawing. I often use a different medium (usually words, numbers, or graphics) to describe my experiences of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>and then I can use those experiences (expressed as premises) to deduce other connections that I might not have noticed or been able to pinpoint otherwise.</p><p>If these deducted connections are later found to lead to consistently accurate predictions, I will believe they are true — they become observation-based <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">beliefs</a>. These deduced observation-based beliefs can then help me navigate through truth in a more informed way and make more precise predictions that I never could have made without the deducting process.</p><p>But, in order to deduct accurately I have to carefully scrutinize my expressed beliefs about truth. Incorrect expressed beliefs about truth will lead to inaccurate deductions and predictions. In order to see and correct them, I’ll have to express them somehow to in order to put them side by side and compare how the beliefs resemble my experiences (and the experiences of others).</p><p>Only when my beliefs are expressed and stabilized, can I then assess them — dissect my beliefs and try to figure out what appears accurate and where and how I went wrong, and try to resolve the inaccuracies.</p><h3>Getting Started:</h3><p>When I draw a portrait of a person in a realist style, I begin by making some rudimentary marks that relate to the face. I do it differently each time depending on the pose and the structure of the person’s face. I also do it without words, but for the sake of this example, I’ll talk it out:</p><p>I start by looking at the subject and recognizing “landmarks” and then I try to imagine how these landmarks connect using marks — often dots, lines and scribbles… “Landmarks” are points on the face that are easy to pinpoint — like the corners of the mouth eyes and nose…</p><p>To begin drawing, I have to start somewhere — somewhere on the face and somewhere on the page. Somewhere on the face has to correspond with a mark that I place on the page.</p><p>I can really start anywhere (on the page and the subject). Where I start on the page will impact where my drawing is located on the page. Where I start on the face will impact which landmark connections I will start paying attention to first. There are tons of landmarks and they are all important to the likeness of the drawing, but I cannot map them in all at once, I have to decide where I will start and branch out my connections from there.</p><p>The goal, in the end, is to get all of the positions of all of the landmarks of the face mapped in accurately with reference to one another and with reference to the face, and there are plenty of connections between landmarks that will help me locate the position of other smaller and less noticable landmarks later on.</p><p>In this instance, I’ll start with some lightly drawn mapping lines. My first line represents the vertical line of the center of the face where the center of the eyes, nose and lips align (see picture). The next line could be a horizontal line where the corners of the mouth align, and another line could be a diagonal line connecting the corner of the left side of my mouth to the outer part of the left side of the nose and another diagonal line will map in the other side of my mouth and nose. (see photo below)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/458/0*7xM8tZVg7k_l83Cd.jpeg" /></figure><p>Once I have these few lines mapped in I can scrutinize them carefully — do they appear accurate in relation to one another and in relation to the face I am drawing? If so, they become useful in helping me accurately locate on my page where other lines of the face should go. Can you see what other lines are more easily located now that I have this stable triangle mapped in? Maybe a line connecting the top of the eyebrows that intersects with the top of the triangle? Maybe the diagonal lines forming the point of the nose?</p><p>Though they don’t look like much now, the accurate mapping lines will help me get an accurate likeness. They are a technical foundation, and it works best if these lines are very accurate so that I don’t have to adjust them later. If I do have to change them, any other lines that I deduced from those original mapping lines will also be irrelevant to the new map.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/479/0*S1f4Xv4eWJGrF_2q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The original mapping lines make it possible for me to locate where other landmarks should be placed on the page.</figcaption></figure><p>The original mapping lines make it possible for me to locate where other landmarks should be placed on the page.</p><p>When I compare my drawing to my subject’s face, and I detect an inaccuracy, I get the feeling that it is wrong because the lines don’t appear to align with each other in a way that I am seeing on my subjects face. I am using my senses to see that there is a difference between the drawing (group of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions</a>) and my sensations of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>(my observation of the portion of truth that I am trying to draw -the person’s face).</p><p>It is hard to spot inaccuracies when I am a beginner at <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>seeking/drawing. It takes time and practice to get better at scrutinizing and seeing the inaccuracies as well as correcting the inaccuracies with precision. With time and practice I can get better it. With practice, I can also get better at placing the lines accurately the first time so the scrutinizing process becomes easier — but it does take time and practice.</p><p>Here is a video that talks about what I’ve described. You can watch the drawing and scrutinization process unfold as the artist discusses it while drawing.</p><p><a href="https://youtu.be/XHL5PhmglU4?si=rPSlYnsV6HFzT7Cg">https://youtu.be/XHL5PhmglU4?si=rPSlYnsV6HFzT7Cg</a></p><h3>Variations:</h3><p>Would everyone start drawing a face the way I did just now? No. I don’t even start every drawing the same way each time. I just get started, and wing it (I make my best guesses) for a while and try my best to correct my guesses as I go until a resemblance starts to appear.</p><p>This is similar to how I began this philosophical quest — I began with a goal of seeking <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth </a>and representing it with writing and concepts instead of marks. To do that, I noted the landmarks that appeared most prominently to me (truth, me, sensation, preference sensations, <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions</a>…), I categorized/defined them, and I’ve determined how they appear to relate to one another and to my experience of truth and I make corrections when I see/feel that my theory is not aligning accurately with my experience.</p><h3>Accuracy:</h3><p>The accuracy of my final drawing will be a direct result of the correctness of my initial mapping marks, and I cannot ensure my marks are correct without “scrutinizing” them — comparing the way the marks on the page align with one another and how the marks on the page align with the landmarks on my subject’s face that I’ve attempted to render on my page.</p><h3>False Knowledge</h3><p>If I don’t scrutinize — if I don’t strive very hard to make sure my mapping lines are correctly aligned with one another in relation to the landmarks on my subject’s face, they will lead to a skewed drawing that has a less accurate likeness or maybe even no recognizable likeness at all to my subject. This is because the incorrectly aligned mapping lines give me incorrect reference points, and since I’m using those lines to help me deduce where other lines should go and map in my subjects face, I’ll be off on a tangent and drawing lines that bears no resemblance to my subject. If I’m not paying attention to how the marks align with the model’s face, I won’t even realize that I’ve made a wrong mark.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*DK-VrNXpFVb9Qw87.jpeg" /><figcaption>If I am not checking how my mapping lines relate to one another, I may end up on a tangent creating deducted lines that are logically accurate (they eye is the right shape), but they don’t relate to the rest of my drawing (the eye is too small).</figcaption></figure><p>If I am not checking how my mapping lines relate to one another, I may end up on a tangent creating deducted lines that are logically accurate, but they don’t relate to the rest of my drawing.</p><p>This happens in philosophy too — if I jump to an unsupported conclusion (like I did when mapping in the eye above) or if I include even a single premise/guess that does not accurately depict reality, and I don’t detect it, I can reason myself out on a tangent and skew my theory to the point where it no longer resembles our common ground/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">truth</a>. The deducted cognitions that come from inaccurate premises will not help me make accurate predictions/guesses and navigate through truth in a more informed way — they will lead me to make inaccurate deductions and predictions/guesses that I “think” are supported by accurate premises (because I didn’t scrutinize carefully enough). I’ll have confidence in them (because I think I’ve supported them with accurate observations of truth) and maybe even feel strongly about them. But the guesses/cognitions are not grounded in truth — there is no substance to them and they are of no use for an accurate depiction of reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*CivxF4zgNmBXUHdV.jpeg" /></figure><p>Incorrectly aligned mapping lines do not help me put my future marks in the correct place. In fact, if I try to use them to help me put marks in the right place, they actually encourage me to put my marks in the wrong place.</p><p>Another word for this kind of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognition </a>is “False Knowledge” — Knowledge, as I define it in a future post, is heavily scrutinized reasonable belief. False knowledge is belief that I think is reasonable and heavily scrutinized, but it is not. False knowledge can originate from me if I make a mistake when building my personal set of heavily scrutinized reasonable beliefs, or it can come from another person as a source — if a source is mistaken, or if a source deliberately lies to me (deliberately tells me to put a line in a place where they know if should not go) and I believe/trust them, I’ll gain incorrect reference points that lead to skewed/unreasonable (not evidence based) philosophy.</p><h3>False Knowledge Causes Disagreements.</h3><p>This has a domino effect. Once I let incorrect beliefs/lines into my belief system, it leads to more unreasonable <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions</a>/beliefs &amp; denials that lead to unreasonable preference sensations that can lead to unreasonable compelled reactions, that can lead to disagreements between people — disagreement with those who are not following the same skewed philosophy that I am following.</p><p>Others who are carefully scrutinizing and reasoning will find me to be unreasonable if I believe cognitions that do not appear to them to be supported by evidence. If others show me evidence for why they disagree with me, and I hold rigidly onto unreasonable beliefs, it can lead to unending disagreements (people get a negative preference sensations from disagreements and if the preference sensation is a strong enough it can compel reactions that are sometimes violent).</p><h3>Accuracy and Common Ground</h3><p>When making a realist drawing, once I get a few mapping lines on my paper, there is only one correct place for the eyes of my subject to go, and I am trying to locate that place. There are infinite wrong/incorrect locations for them. When I put them in the wrong place, everyone who is using heavily scrutinized reasonable beliefs will disagree with me, and it is unlikely that someone else will use the exact same incorrect lines that I do.</p><p>People who are scrutinizing their marks and carefully truth seeking will end up with drawings that resemble the model and they will also resemble one another’s drawings. They’ve arrived at a common ground agreement without even looking at each other’s drawings or colluding with one another — they can find common ground by carefully and independently seeking truth.</p><p>People that are not scrutinizing will end up with wildly inaccurate drawings that do not resemble the model and do not resemble each other. They cannot find common ground that way — to find common ground, they may have to resort to a <a href="https://www.watch-me-paint.com/monday-morning-art-school-the-canon-of-human-proportion/?srsltid=AfmBOorGaVenRuVgKiDLGJwYJYOOc25S6e5Jea7o2HPz0n-l80bEGKIJ">canon of proportions</a> or rigid rules which result in agreement, but do not resemble truth nor honor it’s richness, complexity, and uniqueness.</p><p>This may also be the case in truth seeking with words (philosophy and science). If we all are carefully scrutinizing and rendering our beliefs, denials and wonders based upon evidence and correcting contradictory beliefs, denials, and wonders as we scrutinize, we may each find common ground with reality and with one another without need for a canon of proportions — without need for rigid rules that do not resemble truth.</p><h3>The Analogy Goes On Further</h3><p>Of course, when creating art, not every artist is looking to get an accurate depiction of their subject. Those artists, reasonably, do not consider themselves “realist” artists nor do they claim to be making more accurate drawings than an artist who is very carefully avoiding inaccurate marks.</p><p>However, if they did believe themselves to be drawing very accurately while making wildly inaccurate marks, this would be an unreasonable belief (a belief that is not supported by the evidence) there would be disagreement and perhaps an argument with people who care very strongly about realism.</p><p>If Pablo Picasso believed that his cubism paintings were realistic depictions of reality, this would be an inaccurate and unreasonable belief and people would be right to question his belief, and because of the evidence (how the marks on the painting look different from what we see in truth), treat his belief as though it is unreasonable, because he is being unreasonable on this topic, and everyone can see it with their own sensory evidence rooted in truth.</p><p><strong>I am not making a commentary on art/aesthetics here.</strong> I am not saying that it is “incorrect” to make art that isn’t realist, nor am I saying it is “incorrect” to feel a positive preference sensation for art that is not “realist art.” (I have not yet discussed a definition/categorization of “art”, and as an artist, I do have thoughts about it, but I’ll get to those another day). I am also not making a moral claim by saying that it is “good” to create realist drawings and “bad” to create drawings that aren’t realistic — the two types of drawings have different purposes — a realist drawing in my analogy is about finding truth/common ground without coercion. Drawings that are not for the purpose of finding truth/common ground, have a different purpose (often entertainment).</p><p>What I am saying is that categorizing “not realist expressions” as “realist expressions” is a miscategorization. If the miscategorization is done on purpose, it is a lie. If it is done accidentally, it is a mistake. In either case, the miscategorization can be detected by looking at the evidence the person posing for the portrait and making a comparison — does the drawing look like the person — if not, then it is not a realist drawing, if it does, then it is a realist drawing.</p><p>If all sides are reasonable (basing their beliefs and denials on scrutinized evidence) and scrutinize the belief (compare the belief to the scrutinized evidence), an agreement can be made.</p><p>If scrutinizeable evidence is not available (if the person isn’t around), it is only reasonable to leave the expression up to wonder and attempt to withhold belief/denial (and take a breath and calm my preference sensations).</p><h3>Scrutinization from Others</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">Truth seeking</a>/realist drawing is very challenging and a lifelong pursuit (I am constantly acquiring information through observation and perfecting my scrutinization skills in both drawing and philosophy). My observations are perpetually incomplete in relation to the vast amount of information from truth that is available to my senses, and my <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions </a>and expressions about my observations begin imperfectly and require constant scrutinization and tweaking. Others can help me detect imperfections in my expressions that I might not have noticed by expressing criticism.</p><p>If my expressed drawing/philosophy/theory does not resemble another person’s experience of our <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">common ground truth</a>, they will likely tell me — they will question or criticize my drawing/theories (especially if I’m parading around like I know what I’m talking about and they disagree with what I am saying).</p><p>If someone shows me that my drawing/philosophy/theory appears incorrect because the mapping lines/premises are wrong, then (if realism is important to me in my drawing/philosophy/theory) to be reasonable, I should adjust them. It is unlikely that my drawing/philosophy/theory appears incorrect to others because I’ve made a connection between landmarks that they cannot see or haven’t noticed yet. But, to be sure, I can retrace my steps and create a very detailed expression of how I came to a conclusion/found a landmark that they did not see. We can consider it together, and see what the other person thinks.</p><p>If I am open to listening to criticism, then I can attempt to understand the problems that others communicate to me, and I can use them to improve my theories/drawings (I can repeat what I hear from them back to them to scrutinize my understanding of their criticisms and make sure that our vocabulary matches so that we do not talk past one another), and after they agree that I understand their criticisms, I can then try to understand whether or not I can account for their concern or whether I am using false knowledge or missing something fundamental and need to make corrections, or just need to revert back to wondering because I don’t have enough reliable scrutinized evidence to deduce what I am trying to deduce.</p><p>As a realist artist and philosopher, <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/what-am-i-d0d0edfc501f">I</a> do have positive preference for avoiding false cognitions/marks, and I do have a positive preference for explaining myself in a way that clearly communicates my evidence and thought process for others to understand. I do not want to leave others in the dark about how I’ve come to my conclusions, so criticisms are very helpful for that, and I welcome them.</p><h3>We need each other’s help to see a broader view of Truth</h3><p>In a drawing session, the model stands in the middle of the room, and artists stand around them drawing — each from their own perspective. If each person is scrutinizing carefully as they draw and taking care to accurately represent the model, we will be able to tell that we are drawing the same person, and each person will represent the view of the model from their own perspective. I cannot see the model from all perspectives on my own — but together, we can draw a 365 degree picture of the person we are drawing.</p><h3>Harboring Incorrect Cognitions/Marks</h3><p>Even if I am doing my very best to scrutinize and correct, I likely still harbor incorrect marks/cognitions:</p><p>Here is why:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/a-foundation-for-truth-seeking-1b2335d2bd4a">Truth </a>is complex and it is not made of <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/imagination-0d1bbede675f">cognitions</a>/lines — I’m translating it from sensed being medium(sensations) to cognition medium to expressed being medium (marks/words/numbers…). Creating theories that resemble reality and reliably lead to correct guesses/predictions is very challenging and there is a lot of room for error.</li><li>Even when I attempt to scrutinize, I may not see that my marks/cognitions are grossly inaccurate because I’m focused in on a tangent that I didn’t notice — one part of my theory/drawing is based upon an inaccurate premise that I neglected to notice. If I step away and look with fresh eyes later, I may be able to see my flaws, or someone else may be able to look with fresh eyes and easily criticize or point out where I am wrong.</li><li>If I am really attached to an inaccurate mark/<a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">belief</a>, I may overlook that it is incorrect even after scrutinization. <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/reasonable-belief-denial-and-wonder-ed83ac3c87a9">Allostasis </a>(my body budget) may encourage me to keep a belief/mark that I’ve spent a lot of time using and building upon. Maybe I built my whole life — or my whole drawing process- around a belief that should have been categorized as a wonder. Maybe I’m attached to an inaccurate belief because my ancestors used the same miscategorizations and passed them down to me. But maybe those miscategorizations caused them to make inaccurate marks (mistakes) and overlook the same inaccurate marks (mistakes) over and over and over again — like using a <a href="https://www.watch-me-paint.com/monday-morning-art-school-the-canon-of-human-proportion/?srsltid=AfmBOorGaVenRuVgKiDLGJwYJYOOc25S6e5Jea7o2HPz0n-l80bEGKIJ">canon of proportions</a> instead of just trying to draw what I see. Maybe those inaccurate beliefs lead me to make the same mistakes too and I may pass them onto my children and lead them to feel obligated to preserve those inaccurate beliefs even though they are obviously inaccurate and causing the same repeated mistakes generation after generation.</li></ul><p>Whatever the case may be, I cannot get a correct or more correct likeness that depicts the common ground that we experience together if I don’t let go of incorrectly aligned marks/cognitions. AND I cannot see my inaccuracy if I do not keep checking.</p><p>Getting things wrong isn’t something I should be surprised by. Its a very likely scenario that I should anticipate and be mentally prepared for even when I am trying to be very careful. Doing so may help me avoid over reacting to a <a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/preferences-deliberation-free-will-962f2efed4c1">negative preference sensation</a> that will likely occur when someone points out the potential flaws in my beliefs and denials.</p><p>This post is part of a greater multipart philosophy. You can read it from beginning to end here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@leah.kiser3/introduction-to-a-philosophy-337ba65ee2ad">Introduction to a Philosophy by Leah Ode Kiser</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b4626e52afb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>