<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Leah Howard on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Leah Howard on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@leahhoward?source=rss-5fbbf05f0f1b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:50:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@leahhoward/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lethality of Loneliness: Isolation Is Doing More Than Just Making Us Sad, It’s Killing Us]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leahhoward/the-lethality-of-loneliness-371a0d39a31f?source=rss-5fbbf05f0f1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/371a0d39a31f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[loneliness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[independence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Howard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Apr 2016 21:34:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-21T22:00:44.616Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DN20jV61tQAcn3gw2iANzw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>This post is written in response to an essay by Judith Shulevitz, <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/113176/science-loneliness-how-isolation-can-kill-you">The Lethality of Loneliness</a>. Full text featured below.</h4><p>In an age of individualism, independence seems to be a marker for success. Getting your own car, landing your first “real” job, moving into your own apartment… These are all signs that you’re well on your way to #adulting — a.k.a. paying bills, doing laundry, going to jury duty, etc.</p><p>We value these new responsibilities and privatized spaces and possessions as proof that we’re “making it on our own” — something we’re conditioned to do and to <em>want</em> to do.</p><p>But to what end are we actually helping ourselves? This pursuit of independence is, in turn, causing us to become dependent upon these things with little real value (job, money, car, apartment, etc.) while also causing us to become isolated from the things with true, lasting value (family, friends, community, faith, etc.).</p><p>According to everyone everywhere, the technological revolution has people more connected than ever before. But if that’s true, then why are so many of us still so lonely?</p><p>If you ask me (no one did but I’m telling you anyway), loneliness is Public Health Enemy #1. It is making us stressed, sad, sick, and riddling our bodies with disease. It isn’t just affecting our mental and emotional health, it’s affecting our physical health, too. Loneliness is reducing the quality of our life and actually <em>taking years off of it</em>. It’s not just affecting individual health but community health, too. How can we expect our communities to thrive if our citizens are sick, unhappy, and emotionally disconnected?</p><p>Loneliness is silently killing us and we’re sweeping it under the rug as a sorry little social problem. We focus on politics and mass tragedies — other “more important” issues. But I have to ask, what issues are more important than our own mental and physical health? More important than the mental and physical health of our families and our own communities?</p><p>This may sound selfish considering how many “more important” issues there are in the world. Loneliness sounds like child’s play compared to terrorist attacks and sex trafficking and Bernie losing to Hilary in the New York primary. But if we aren’t alive, healthy, and have our wits about us, what good can we do anyway?</p><p>It seems to me that there is a mass tragedy occurring right in front of us but we are blind to it. It’s like the lyme disease that will paralyze us before we get a chance to vote because we didn’t look down at our own skin while we were caught up in the political fire.</p><p>As much as I’d like to, I can’t change what’s going on in other parts of the world. I can’t change who’s running for president or who gets eleceted as delegates. I can’t change that Prince died today. But I can offer a space for people to connect. I can start a conversation around this issue, around this health crisis, and maybe, <em>just maybe</em>, start to do something about it.</p><h3><strong>The Lethality of Loneliness</strong></h3><h4>We now know how it can ravage our body and brain</h4><p>Sometime in the late ’50s, Frieda Fromm-Reichmann sat down to write an essay about a subject that had been mostly overlooked by other psychoanalysts up to that point. Even Freud had only touched on it in passing. She was not sure, she wrote, “what inner forces” made her struggle with the problem of loneliness, though she had a notion. It might have been the young female catatonic patient who began to communicate only when Fromm-Reichmann asked her how lonely she was. “She raised her hand with her thumb lifted, the other four fingers bent toward her palm,” Fromm-Reichmann wrote. The thumb stood alone, “isolated from the four hidden fingers.” Fromm-Reichmann responded gently, “That lonely?” And at that, the woman’s “facial expression loosened up as though in great relief and gratitude, and her fingers opened.”</p><p>Fromm-Reichmann would later become world-famous as the dumpy little therapist mistaken for a housekeeper by a new patient, a severely disturbed schizophrenic girl named Joanne Greenberg. Fromm-Reichmann cured Greenberg, who had been deemed incurable. Greenberg left the hospital, went to college, became a writer, and immortalized her beloved analyst as “Dr. Fried” in the best-selling autobiographical <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Never-Promised-You-Rose-Garden/dp/0312943598">novel</a> <em>I Never Promised You a Rose Garden</em> (later also a <a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0076172/">movie</a> and a pop <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-Bcl93lO1A">song</a>). Among analysts, Fromm-Reichmann, who had come to the United States from Germany to escape Hitler, was known for insisting that no patient was too sick to be healed through trust and intimacy. She figured that loneliness lay at the heart of nearly all mental illness and that the lonely person was just about the most terrifying spectacle in the world. She once chastised her fellow therapists for withdrawing from emotionally unreachable patients rather than risk being contaminated by them. The uncanny specter of loneliness “touches on our own possibility of loneliness,” she said. “We evade it and feel guilty.”</p><p>Her 1959 essay, “On Loneliness,” is considered a founding document in a fast-growing area of scientific research you might call loneliness studies. Over the past half-century, academic psychologists have largely abandoned psychoanalysis and made themselves over as biologists. And as they delve deeper into the workings of cells and nerves, they are confirming that loneliness is as monstrous as Fromm-Reichmann said it was. It has now been linked with a wide array of bodily ailments as well as the old mental ones.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*SPWCxRzCABSq8-i6." /></figure><p>In a way, these discoveries are as consequential as the germ theory of disease. Just as we once knew that infectious diseases killed, but didn’t know that germs spread them, we’ve known intuitively that loneliness hastens death, but haven’t been able to explain how. Psychobiologists can now show that loneliness sends misleading hormonal signals, rejiggers the molecules on genes that govern behavior, and wrenches a slew of other systems out of whack. They have proved that long-lasting loneliness not only makes you sick; it can kill you. Emotional isolation is ranked as high a risk factor for mortality as smoking. A partial list of the physical diseases thought to be caused or exacerbated by loneliness would include Alzheimer’s, obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, neurodegenerative diseases, and even cancer — tumors can metastasize faster in lonely people.</p><p>The psychological definition of loneliness hasn’t changed much since Fromm-Reichmann laid it out. “Real loneliness,” as she called it, is not what the philosopher Søren Kierkegaard characterized as the “shut-upness” and solitariness of the civilized. Nor is “real loneliness” the happy solitude of the productive artist or the passing irritation of being cooped up with the flu while all your friends go off on some adventure. It’s not being dissatisfied with your companion of the moment — your friend or lover or even spouse — unless you chronically find yourself in that situation, in which case you may in fact be a lonely person. Fromm-Reichmann even distinguished “real loneliness” from mourning, since the well-adjusted eventually get over that, and from depression, which may be a symptom of loneliness but is rarely the cause. Loneliness, she said — and this will surprise no one — is the want of intimacy.</p><p>Today’s psychologists accept Fromm-Reichmann’s inventory of all the things that loneliness isn’t and add a wrinkle she would surely have approved of. They insist that loneliness must be seen as an interior, subjective experience, not an external, objective condition. Loneliness “is not synonymous with being alone, nor does being with others guarantee protection from feelings of loneliness,” writes John Cacioppo, the leading psychologist on the subject. Cacioppo privileges the emotion over the social fact because — remarkably — he’s sure that it’s the <em>feeling</em> that wreaks havoc on the body and brain. Not everyone agrees with him, of course. Another school of thought insists that loneliness is a failure of social networks. The lonely get sicker than the non-lonely, because they don’t have people to take care of them; they don’t have social support.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*MuyLBbr6XwLD9JwQ." /></figure><p>To the degree that loneliness has been treated as a matter of public concern in the past, it has generally been seen as a social problem — the product of an excessively conformist culture or of a breakdown in social norms. Nowadays, though, loneliness is a public health crisis. The standard U.S. <a href="http://www.fetzer.org/sites/default/files/images/stories/pdf/selfmeasures/Self_Measures_for_Loneliness_and_Interpersonal_Problems_UCLA_LONELINESS.pdf">questionnaire</a>, the UCLA Loneliness Scale, asks 20 questions that run variations on the theme of closeness — “How often do you feel close to people?” and so on. As many as 30 percent of Americans don’t feel close to people at a given time.</p><p>Loneliness varies with age and poses a particular threat to the very old, quickening the rate at which their faculties decline and cutting their lives shorter. But even among the not-so-old, loneliness is pervasive. In a <a href="http://www.aarp.org/personal-growth/transitions/info-09-2010/loneliness_2010.html">survey published by the AARP</a> in 2010, slightly more than one out of three adults 45 and over reported being chronically lonely (meaning they’ve been lonely for a long time). A decade earlier, only one out of five said that. With baby-boomers reaching retirement age at a rate of 10,000 a day, the number of lonely Americans will surely spike.</p><p>Obviously, the sicker lonely people get, the more care they’ll need. This is true, and alarming, although as we learn more about loneliness, we’ll also be better able to treat it. But to me, what’s most momentous about the new biology of loneliness is that it offers concrete proof, obtained through the best empirical means, that the poets and bluesmen and movie directors who for centuries have deplored the ravages of lonesomeness on both body and soul were right all along. As W. H. Auden put it, “We must love one another or die.”</p><p>Who are the lonely? They’re the outsiders: not just the elderly, but also the poor, the bullied, the <em>different</em>. Surveys confirm that people who feel discriminated against are more likely to feel lonely than those who don’t, even when they don’t fall into the categories above. Women are lonelier than men (though unmarried men are lonelier than unmarried women). African Americans are lonelier than whites (though single African American women are less lonely than Hispanic and white women). The less educated are lonelier than the better educated. The unemployed and the retired are lonelier than the employed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*i58LZs7sI0EtpSn6." /></figure><p>A key part of feeling lonely is feeling rejected, and that, it turns out, is the most damaging part. Psychologists discovered this by, among other things, studying the experience of gay men during the first decade of the AIDS epidemic, when the condition was knocking out their immune systems, and, as it seemed at first, <em>only</em>theirs. The nation ignored the crisis for a while, then panicked. Soon, people all over the country were calling for gay men to be quarantined.</p><p>To psychologists trying to puzzle out how social experiences affect health, AIDS amounted to something of a natural experiment, the chance to observe the effects of conditions so extreme that no ethical person would knowingly subject another person to them. The disease came from a virus — HIV — that was neutralizing all the usual defenses of a discrete group of people who could be compared with each other and also with a control group of the uninfected. That allowed researchers in a lab at UCLA to take on one of life’s biggest questions, which had become even more urgent as the disease laid waste to thousands, then tens of thousands: Could social experiences explain why some people die faster than others?</p><p>In the mid-to late ’80s, the UCLA lab obtained access to a long-term study of gay men who enrolled without knowing whether they were infected with HIV. About half of them tested positive for the virus, and about a third of those agreed to let researchers put their lives under a microscope, answering extensive questions about drug use, sexual behavior, attitudes toward their own homosexuality, levels of emotional support, and so on. By 1993, around one-third of that group had developed full-blown AIDS, and slightly more than a quarter had died.</p><p>Steven Cole was a young postdoctoral student in the lab itching to move beyond his field’s mind-body split. At the time, he told me, psychology was only just beginning to grasp “how the physical world of our bodies gets remodeled by our psychic and conceptual worlds.” When the UCLA researchers started trying to figure out which social factors sped up the progress of the disease, they tested obvious ones like socioeconomic status and levels of support. Curiously, though, being poor or lacking family and friends didn’t much change the rate at which an infected man would die of AIDS (although being in mourning, as gay men often were those days, did seem to weaken an infected man’s immune system).</p><p>It eventually occurred to Cole to try to imagine the world from a gay man’s perspective. That wasn’t easy for him: “I’m a straight kid from the suburbs. I had stereotypes, but I didn’t really know the reality of these people’s lives.” Then he read a <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Stigma-Notes-Management-Spoiled-Identity/dp/0671622447">book</a>, Erving Goffman’s <em>Stigma: Notes on the Management of a Spoiled Identity</em>, that tallies in detail the difficulties of “passing” as someone else. He learned that the closeted man must police every piece of information known about him, live in constant terror of exposure or blackmail, and impose sharp limits on intimacy, or at least friendship. “It was like walking around with a time-bomb,” says Cole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*DQ2fthhZnNN4nO2S.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ariel Lee</p><p>Cole figured that a man who’d hide behind a false identity was probably more sensitive than others to the pain of rejection. His temperament would be more tightly wound, and his stress-response system would be the kind that “fires responses and fires ’em harder.” His heart would beat faster, stress hormones would flood his body, his tissues would swell up, and white blood cells would swarm out to protect him against assault. If this state of inflamed arousal subsided quickly, it would be harmless. But if the man stayed on high alert for years at a time, then his <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_pressure">blood pressure</a> would rise, and the part of his <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immune_system">immune system</a> that fends off smaller, subtler threats, like viruses, would not do its job.</p><p>And he was right. The social experience that most reliably predicted whether an HIV-positive gay man would die quickly, Cole found, was whether or not he was in the closet. Closeted men infected with HIV died an average of two to three years earlier than out men. When Cole dosed AIDS-infected white blood cells with norepinephrine, a stress hormone, the virus replicated itself three to ten times faster than it did in non-dosed cells. Cole mulled these results over for a long time, but couldn’t understand why we would have been built in such a way that loneliness would interfere with our ability to fend off disease: “Did God want us to die when we got stressed?”</p><p>The answer is no.</p><p>What He wanted is for us not to be alone. Or rather, natural selection favored people who needed people. Humans are vastly more social than most other mammals, even most primates, and to develop what neuroscientists call our social brain, we had to be good at cooperating. To raise our children, with their slow-maturing cerebral cortexes, we needed help from the tribe. To stoke the fires that cooked the meat that gave us the protein that sustained our calorically greedy gray matter, we had to organize night watches. But compared with our predators, we were small and weak. They came after us with swift strides. We ran in a comparative waddle.</p><p>“The very fact that [loneliness] can affect the genes like that — it’s huge,” Suomi says. “It changes the way one thinks about development.”</p><p>So what would happen if one of us wandered off from her little band, or got kicked out of it because she’d slacked off or been caught stealing? She’d find herself alone on the savanna, a fine treat for a bunch of lions. She’d be exposed to attacks from marauders. If her nervous system went into overdrive at perceiving her isolation, well, that would have just sent her scurrying home. Cacioppo thinks we’re hardwired to find life unpleasant outside the safety of trusted friends and family, just as we’re pre-programmed to find certain foods disgusting. “Why do you think you are ten thousand times more sensitive to foods that are bitter than to foods that are sweet?” Cacioppo asked me. “Because bitter’s dangerous!”</p><p>One of those alone-on-the-savanna moments in our modern lives occurs when we go off to college, because we have to make a whole new set of friends. Back in the mid-’90s, when Cacioppo was at Ohio State University (he is now at the University of Chicago), he and his colleagues sorted undergraduates into three groups — the non-lonely, the sort-of-sometimes lonely, and the lonely. The researchers then strapped blood- pressure cuffs, biosensors, and beepers onto the students. Nine times a day for seven days, they were beeped and had to fill out questionnaires. Cacioppo also kept them overnight in the university hospital with “nightcaps” on their heads, monitoring the length and quality of their rest. He took saliva samples to measure levels of cortisol, a hormone produced under stress.</p><p>As expected, he found the students with bodily symptoms of distress (poor sleep, high cortisol) were not the ones with too few acquaintances, but the ones who were unhappy about not having made close friends. These students also had higher than normal vascular resistance, which is caused by the arteries narrowing as their tissue becomes inflamed. High vascular resistance contributes to high blood pressure; it makes the heart work harder to pump blood and wears out the blood vessels. If it goes on for a long time, it can morph into heart disease. While Cole discovered that loneliness could hasten death in sick people, Cacioppo showed that it could make well people sick — and through the same method: by putting the body in fight-or-flight mode.</p><p>A famous experiment helps explain why rejection makes us flinch. It was conducted more than a decade ago by Naomi Eisenberger, a social psychologist at UCLA, along with her colleagues. People were brought one-by-one into the lab to play a multiplayer online game called “<em>Cyberball”</em> that involved tossing a ball back and forth with two other “people,” who weren’t actually people at all, but a computer program. “They” played nicely with the real person for a while, then proceeded to ignore her, throwing the ball only to each other. Functional magnetic resonance imaging scans showed that the experience of being snubbed lit up a part of the subjects’ brains (the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex) that also lights up when the body feels physical pain.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/0*tnD2PZvdzXiwvHg3." /></figure><p>I asked Eisenberger why, if the same part of our brain processes social insult and bodily injury, we don’t confuse the two. She explained that physical harm simultaneously lights up another neural region as well, one whose job is to locate the ache — on an arm or leg, inside the body, and so on. What the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex registers is the <em>emotional</em> fact that pain is distressing, be it social or physical. She calls this the “affective component” of pain. In operations performed to relieve chronic pain, doctors have lesioned, or disabled, the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex. After the surgery, the patients report that they can still sense where the trouble comes from, but, they add, it just doesn’t bother them anymore.</p><p>It’s tempting to say that the lonely were born that way — it’d let the rest of us off the hook. And, as it turns out, we’d be about half right, because loneliness is about half heritable. A longitudinal study of more than 8,000 identical Dutch twins found that, if one twin reported feeling lonely and unloved, the other twin would report the same thing 48 percent of the time. This figure held so steady across the pairs of twins — young or old, male or female, notwithstanding different upbringings — that researchers concluded that it had to reflect genetic, not environmental, influence. To understand what it means for a personality trait to have 48 percent heritability, consider that the influence of genes on a purely physical trait is 100 percent. Children get the color of their eyes from their parents, and that is that. But although genes may predispose children toward loneliness, they do not account for everything that makes them grow up lonely. Fifty-two percent of that comes from the world.</p><p>Evolutionary theory, which has a story for everything, has a story to illustrate how the human species might benefit from wide variations in temperament. A group that included different personality types would be more likely to survive a radical change in social conditions than a group in which everyone was exactly alike. Imagine that, after years in which a group had lived in peace, an army of strangers suddenly appeared on the horizon. The tribe in which some men stayed behind while the rest headed off on a month-long hunting expedition (the stay-at-homes may have been less adventurous, or they may just have been loners) had a better chance of repelling the invaders, or at least of saving the children, than the tribe whose men had all enthusiastically wandered off, confident that everything would be fine back home.</p><p>And yet loneliness is made as well as given, and at a very early age. Deprive us of the attention of a loving, reliable parent, and, if nothing happens to make up for that lack, we’ll tend toward loneliness for the rest of our lives. Not only that, but our loneliness will probably make us moody, self-doubting, angry, pessimistic, shy, and hypersensitive to criticism. Recently, it has become clear that some of these problems reflect how our brains are shaped from our first moments of life.</p><p>Proof that the early brain is molded by love comes, in part, from another notorious <a href="http://www.bucharestearlyinterventionproject.org/Publications.html">natural experiment</a>: the abandonment of tens of thousands of Romanian orphans born during the regime of Communist dictator Nicolae Ceauşescu, who had banned birth control. A great deal has been written about the heartbreaking emotional and educational difficulties of these children, who grew up 20 to a nurse in Dickensian orphanages. In the age of the brain scan, <a href="http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/6/2093.full">we now know</a> that those institutionalized children’s brains developed less “gray matter” — that is, fewer of the neurons that make up the bulk of the brain — and that, if those children never went on to be adopted, they’d sprout less “white matter,” too. White matter helps send signals from one part of the brain to another; think of it as the mind’s internal Internet. In the orphans’ case, the amygdala and the prefrontal cortex — which are involved in memory, emotions, decision-making, and social interaction — just weren’t connecting.</p><p>There’s a limit to how much we can poke around inside lonely humans, for obvious reasons. That’s why a great deal of research on the biological effects of a lonely childhood involves monkeys. Last year, I visited a monkey lab in the rolling farmland of rural Maryland run by a burly and affable psychologist-turned- primatologist named Steve Suomi. Suomi conducts his experiments on rhesus macaques, adorable little creatures sometimes called a “weed species,” because they, like humans, thrive in most environments they’re thrown into.</p><p>Suomi is building on research begun by his teacher and mentor, Harry Harlow, a psychologist at the University of Wisconsin notorious for experiments in the ’50s and ’60s. Harlow subjected newborn rhesus macaques to appalling isolation — months spent in cages in the company only of “surrogate mothers” made of wire with cartoonish monkey heads and bottles attached. Luckier monkeys had that and cloth-covered versions of the same thing to cuddle. (It is remarkable what a soft cloth can do to calm an anxious baby monkey down.) In the most extreme cases, the babies languished alone at the bottom of a V-shaped steel container. Cruel as these experiments were, Harlow proved that the absence of mothering destroyed the monkeys’ ability to mingle with other monkeys, though the “cloth mother” could mitigate the worst effects of isolation. Years of monkey therapy were required to integrate them into the troop. Harlow’s insights were not well received. Behaviorists, who reigned in U.S. psychology departments, held a blank-slate view of animal and human behavior. They scoffed at the notion that baby monkeys could be hard-wired for love, or at least for a certain quality of touch.</p><p>Times have changed, and Harlow’s conviction that nature demands nurture is now the common view. (Changing laws also mean that Suomi would have a harder time getting away with such experiments, which he’s not inclined to do anyway.) What Suomi has that Harlow did not have is technology. By shipping off monkey tissue to laboratories, such as Steve Cole’s, that have machines capable of seeing which genes are turned on and which are turned off, Suomi can show that loneliness transforms the brain and body. He can match the behavior of the lonely monkeys as they grow — what they act like, where they rank in dominance hierarchies when they’re introduced into a troop, whether they ever manage to reproduce — with the activity of genes that affect their brains and immune systems.</p><p>Suomi raises his monkeys in three groups, one group confined entirely to the company of peers (a chaotic, <em>Lord of the Flies</em> kind of childhood); another group left alone with terry-cloth mother-surrogates, except when released for a couple of hours a day to scamper with fellow babies; and the third raised by their mothers. What he found is that, in monkeys separated from their mothers in the first four months of life, some important immunity-related genes show a different pattern of expression. Among these were genes that help make the protein that inflames tissue and genes that tell the body to ward off viruses and other microbes.</p><p>Suomi was also excited about <a href="http://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/44/15626.full">results coming in</a> from peer-raised monkeys’ brain tissue: Thousands of little changes in genetic activity had been detected in their prefrontal cortexes. This region is sometimes called the “CEO” of the brain; it restrains violent impulses and inappropriate behavior. (In humans, faulty wiring in the prefrontal cortex has been associated with schizophrenia and ADHD.) Some of the aberrations were on genes that direct growth of the brain; modifications of those were bound to result in altered neural architecture. These findings eerily echoed the Romanian orphans’ brain scans and suggested that the lonely monkeys were going to be weirder than the others.</p><p>Emotional isolation is ranked as high a risk factor for mortality as smoking.</p><p>“The very fact that something outside the organism can affect the genes like that — it’s huge,” Suomi says. “It changes the way one thinks about development.” I didn’t need genetics, though, to see how defective the peer-raised monkeys’ development had been. Suomi took me outside to watch them. They huddled in nervous groups at the back of the cage, holding tight to each another. Sometimes, he said, they invite aggression by cowering; at other times, they fail to recognize and kowtow to the alpha monkeys, so they get picked on even more. The most perturbed monkeys might rock, clutch at themselves, and pull out their own hair, looking for all the world like children with severe autism.</p><p>Suomi added that good foster care could greatly improve the troubled macaques’ lives. He pointed out some who had been given over to foster grandmothers. Not only did they act more monkey-like, but, he told me, about half of their genetic deviations had vanished, too.</p><p>If we now know that loneliness, a social emotion, can reach into our bodies and rearrange our cells and genes, what should we do about it? We should change the way we think about health. James Heckman, a Nobel Prize–winning economist at the University of Chicago who tabulates the costs of early childhood deprivation, speaks bitterly of “silos” in health policy, meaning that we see crime and low educational achievement as distinct from medical problems like obesity or heart disease. As far as he’s concerned, these are, in too many cases, symptoms of the same social disorder: the failure to help families raise their children. Heckman believes that the life of a child at the lower end of the U.S. socioeconomic spectrum is starting to look more like the life of one of Suomi’s lonely macaques. As nearly half of all marriages continue to end in divorce, as marriage itself floats further out of reach for the undereducated and financially strapped, childhood has become a more solitary and chaotic experience. Single mothers don’t have a lot of time to spend with their children, nor, in most cases, money for emotionally enriching social activities.</p><p>“As inequality has increased, childhood inequality has increased,” Heckman said, “So has inequality of parenting.” For the first time in 30 years, mental health disabilities such as ADHD outrank physical ones among American children. Heckman doesn’t think that’s only because parents seek out attention-deficit diagnoses when their children don’t come home with A’s. He thinks it’s also because emotional impoverishment embeds itself in the body. “Mothers matter,” he says, “and mothering is in short supply.”</p><p>Heckman has been <a href="http://www.heckmanequation.org/content/resource/case-investing-disadvantaged-young-children">analyzing data</a> from two famous early-childhood intervention programs, the Abecedarian Project of the ’70s and the Perry Preschool project of the ’60s. Both have furnished ample evidence that, if you enroll very young children from poor families in programs that give both them and their parents an extra boost, then they grow up to be wealthier and healthier than their counterparts — less fat, less sick, better educated, and, for men, more likely to hold down a job. In the case of the Perry Preschool, Heckman estimated that each dollar invested yielded $7 to $12 in savings over the span of decades. One of the most effective economic and social policies, he told me, would be “supplementing the parenting environment of disadvantaged young children.”</p><p>If you can’t change society all at once, though, you can change it a few people at a time. Cacioppo and a colleague, Louise Hawkley, have been developing programs to teach lonely people to get along better with others. At one point, the psychologists thought of designing a mobile app, a sort of electronic nagging mother, to help people break bad social habits. (You’d check an item off the list, say, if you remembered to talk to anyone that day — a store clerk or a librarian.) But they didn’t get funding for the software, so now they’re focusing on a simpler and more low-tech fix. It’s a seminar with an instructor and a pointer and a screen in which students learn to read faces and interpret voices and also to stop making the assumption that lonely people seem prone to make, which is that every person they meet is judging or rebuffing them. What they’re learning, says Hawkley, is the art of “social cognition.” Her goal is to show people that they come at the world full of “assumptions about human nature, about social mores, that aren’t necessarily accurate.”</p><p>Cacioppo and Hawkley have been testing their social-cognition curriculum on Army bases, holding classes to hone soldiers’ social skills and teach platoon leaders to spot the lonely in their ranks and help them fit in better. The results aren’t in yet, U.S. Army psychologist Major Paul Lester told me, but he has been receiving reports that suggest that people who have gone through the training fall prey to post-traumatic stress disorder less often. Lester insisted that I add that the Army hadn’t agreed to spend $50 million a year for this experiment only because it’s worried about suicide and post-traumatic stress disorder — although if loneliness training brought down the number of suicidal and dysfunctional soldiers, so much the better. The Army sees the classes as essential training for coping with military life. The best fighting comes from soldiers who interact well with other soldiers, said Lester, and soldiers’ lives are full of social disruption — transfers from base to base and so on.</p><p>These are patch solutions, obviously, though it’s appealing to imagine a social-cognition program filtering down and replacing the vague platitudes usually taught to elementary- and middle-schoolers in their human growth and development classes. And it would completely transform a child’s world to have a teacher trained to identify the lonely kids in her classroom and to provide succor and support once she’d found them. Naomi Eisenberger pointed out to me that, while schools take physical pain very seriously, they usually trivialize social pain: “You cannot hit other students, but oftentimes, there are no rules about excluding another student,” she said.</p><p>Cole can imagine giving people medications to treat loneliness, particularly when it exacerbates chronic diseases such as diabetes and high blood pressure. These could be betablockers, which reduce the physical effects of stress; anti-inflammatory medicine; or even Tylenol — since physical and emotional pain overlap, it turns out that Tylenol can reduce the pain of heartbreak.</p><p>At a deeper level, though, loneliness research forces us to acknowledge our own extraordinary malleability in the face of social forces. This susceptibility is both terrifying and exhilarating. On the terrifying side is the unhappy fact that isolation, especially when it stems from the disenfranchisement of the underprivileged, creates a bodily limitation all too easily reproduced in each successive generation. Given that we have been scaling back the kinds of programs that could help people overcome such disadvantages and that many in Congress, mostly Republicans, have been trying to defund exactly the kind of behavioral science research that could yield even better programs, we have reason to be afraid. But there’s something awe-inspiring about our resilience, too. Put an orphan in foster care, and his brain will repair its missing connections. Teach a lonely person to respond to others without fear and paranoia, and over time, her body will make fewer stress hormones and get less sick from them. Care for a pet or start believing in a supernatural being and your score on the UCLA Loneliness Scale will go down. Even an act as simple as joining an athletic team or a church can lead to what Cole calls “molecular remodeling.” “One message I take away from this is, ‘Hey, it’s not just early life that counts,’ ” he says. “We have to choose our life well.”</p><p><em>Judith Shulevitz is the science editor of</em> The New Republic.</p><p>This essay originally featured on <em>newrepublic.com</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=371a0d39a31f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Transparency & Maintaining Authenticity On Social Media: The Week I Spent Volunteering At A Surf…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@leahhoward/transparency-maintaining-authenticity-on-social-media-the-week-i-spent-volunteering-at-a-surf-2f4ff3e0d81e?source=rss-5fbbf05f0f1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2f4ff3e0d81e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leah Howard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Apr 2016 21:13:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-19T19:22:45.857Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Transparency &amp; Maintaining Authenticity On Social Media: The Week I Spent Volunteering At A Surf Camp</h3><blockquote>“The moment that you feel, just possibly, you are walking down the street naked, exposing too much of your heart and your mind, and what exists on the inside, showing too much of yourself… That is the moment, you might be starting to get it right.” — <em>Neil Gaiman</em></blockquote><p>I arrived late on a Tuesday night.</p><p>The sweatshirt I had worn on the plane was sticking to my skin. A bead of sweat rolled down my chest and I felt the blood vessels in my hands dilate, swelling in the humidity. My rings were tight around my fingers.</p><p>Outside the airport where I was scheduled to be picked up, a crowd of Costa Rican men greeted me as they stood by the curb next to vacant vans, hollering things at me that I didn’t understand.</p><p>I looked for a sign with my name on it, or maybe with the name of the surf camp I was heading to. I didn’t see one. All of the men were staring at me, waiting for me to approach them. Avoiding their eyes, I searched the crowd, eagerly.</p><p>For forty-five minutes, I pretended I didn’t hear or see them as I paced through the empty corridors of the airport. With 1% battery left on my phone, no international cellular plan to call home for help, and no Spanish-speaking ability, I felt a quickly rising sense of impending doom from being stranded without the common comforts I’m used to. I didn’t know the address of the place I was going, I couldn’t find an outlet to charge my phone, and I had no way to communicate except with my hands.</p><p>Just as I had begun to accept that I had been abandoned, my driver arrived.</p><p>Relief.</p><p>He took me from the airport to the Northwest coast to the surf camp I was volunteering at. Bending and weaving through the rural farmlands, I held my face close to the window and watched the landscape pass through the tinted glass. Rolling hills and dense forests spotted with fresh fruit stands moved quickly through every frame. Like scenes from an old, poorly lit movie as you’re fast forwarding through it.</p><p>My driver stopped at the side of a quiet road in front of a cheap motel and turned off the car. I wondered how long it would take for anyone to realize I was gone if I was kidnapped there. It seemed a lot like the beginning of a ‘Taken’ sequel.</p><p>A few minutes later, a topless jeep pulled up with a dark, shirtless man in the front seat. “He’ll take you the rest of the way,” my driver said, and he opened the door of the van to let me out.</p><p>It was almost midnight when Jose, my new driver, turned down the dusty dirt path towards camp. He was friendly, at least from what I could tell through my extremely limited understanding of the language he was speaking. I’m almost certain he asked me my name… That was nice. I smiled.</p><p>I was greeted by another tanned, shirtless man — an employee — who jumped on the side of the jeep and hung on to the frame as it rolled down the path.</p><p>He checked me in and showed me to my sleeping quarters — a mattress on the floor of an old, broken down bus at the edge of the property. It was painted by two Canadian travelers who had stayed there in the past.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*Sg4xc5kJn3vgG9M3." /></figure><p>Before I left the states, I met a man building a tiny home for himself out of a van. I had been thinking about how cool it would be to live in one. I meant a van that actually <em>runs</em>, one that I could drive around the world, globetrotting like a real vagabond, living like a <em>true</em> minimalist. A van that I designed myself, that I filled with rustic furnishings and modern finishes.</p><p>But when I put my intention out into the universe, I never made these specifications.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*Sz_C2AO4PFFw258v." /></figure><p>I asked to live in a van, and that’s what I got.</p><p>I dropped my backpack onto the floor and collapsed onto the twin mattress, anticipating the week ahead.</p><p>I grew to find the space quite… Homey. In a “hey, at least I have a pillow” kind of way. I had five other bus-mates during the week I was there, one of which slept on the roof every night. Absorbing energy from the moon and the stars, he said. He was a fellow vegan and one of two resident yoga instructors working at the camp.</p><p>Our interactions were brief and sometimes hard to make sense of because of his thick Ukrainian accent. But his presence was energizing, and his light, child-like wonder and awe of the world was contagious.</p><p>I recall one morning when he and I woke up at 4 am to watch the sunrise. We hiked up a nearby hill and stood atop it, overlooking the ocean and the town of Tamarindo. “Pure magic,” he would say as he snapped photos of the clouds ribboning rainbows through the horizon.</p><p>As we made our way back down the hill to camp that morning for breakfast, he stopped and smelled the trunks of trees and kneeled down in the dirt to the smell flowers blooming along the path.</p><p>Although we didn’t spend much time interacting, he reflected back to me something in myself that I haven’t seen or felt in a while — something that I have been striving to reconnect with. A fascination with the complexity of nature, and a contentment with the simplicity of joy.</p><p>By Sunday, my legs were swollen with bug bites, each one nagging at me to itch.</p><p>I spent that night swaying in a hammock, covered in the sting of the sun’s kiss on my skin. Heat emanating from my body, keeping me warm as a cool breeze crept in with dusk. The hour cast shadows on the faces of people chatting about all the places they’d been, and all the places they’d go. Illuminated only by the Japanese lanterns hanging from the branches above.</p><p>My hair was stiff with salt from the ocean and there was sand slathered across my face and feet like I just stepped out of the break and onto the shore.</p><p>I was surrounded by spirited fellow travelers counting off the weeks they’d been exploring the country. We communed around a painted mango tree, draping our bodies across the deck beneath it and dangling our legs from the platform built around it.</p><p>A glorious treehouse! With a roof of unripened mangos. Like the one I dreamed of as a kid. One I would have slept in on summer nights with friends during slumber parties.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*ppgA5ZckCEKK2n2b." /></figure><p>I had been in Costa Rica a little less than a week, waking up to the sound of howler monkeys roaring through the valley like I did those months in Panama.</p><p>A few kilometers away, down a dusty dirt road, the city of Tamarindo unfolded onto the streets. Bars played loud latino music and poured heavy drinks for tourists thirsty for culture and something strong. I could have spent my nights dancing off the high of being in a foreign place again but I chose instead to rest in a hammock.</p><p>As I swayed, I had a strange feeling. Like I was a fifth-grader sitting on the sidelines at recess while kids were shooting hoops in the schoolyard. Like I was just watching them play, waiting desperately for the bell to ring so I could return to my doodles and daydreams.</p><p>The other volunteers stayed up late, laughing into the early morning over half-empty liters of beer, throwing ping-pong balls into plastic cups. They passed around a bowl, taking hearty hits and blowing out their leftover stresses with the smoke from their lungs.</p><p>They had spin-the-bottle dance-off’s during Reggae Night at a bar in town. But I didn’t go. Even though I love to dance.</p><p><em>Dammit, why didn’t I go?</em></p><p>I was in the middle of the jungle again, the place that seemed to awaken my soul and infuse me with a sense of purpose last time I visited. But this time I felt detached, like that fifth-grader, watching and waiting to return to a world of innocent, oblivious, unrepressed wonder.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong, every one was incredibly persistent in their requests for me to join them. It wasn’t at all for a lack of trying. The warmth and openness of complete strangers continues to move me.</p><p>Separated yet again from the stress of re-inhabiting my life back in the states, I became excruciatingly aware of the immense void since returning from Panama. A void that I was trying to fill with more culture shock, more confusion, more movement, more adventure — with things outside of myself.</p><p>It became clear to me that in doing this — in leaving my so-called ‘problems’ at home to travel and “find myself” — I was not seeking answers to questions about who I am, I was actually running from them.</p><p>In the context of such a social situation, you’re called to answer those questions. You’re called to tell your “story” — to express who it is that you understand yourself to be, and to create a narrative around that. There’s a crippling awareness that ensues with the realization that you don’t know how to answer those questions.</p><p>Before I left for Costa Rica, I came across an essay titled ‘On Tranquility of Mind’ by Seneca, a Roman Stoic philosopher. I had shoved it out of my mind in favor of high expectations and excitement, not wanting to acknowledge the very real possibility that maybe I was leaving again out of fear of confronting that void — that maybe I was running away from, rather than towards, myself.</p><blockquote><em>“Hence men travel far and wide, wandering along foreign shores and making trial by land and sea of their restlessness, which always hates what is around it. </em>‘Let’s now go to Campania.’<em> Then when they get bored with luxury — </em>‘Let’s visit uncultivated areas; let’s explore the woodlands of Bruttium and Lucania.’<em> And yet amid the wilds some delight is missing by which their pampered eyes can find relief from the tedious squalor of these unsightly regions. </em>‘Let’s go to Tarentum with its celebrated harbor and mild winters, an area prosperous enough for a large population even in antiquity.’ ‘Lets now make our way to the city’ <em>— too long have their ears missed the din of applause: now they long to enjoy even the sight of human blood.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>They make one journey after another and change spectacle for spectacle. As Lucretius says: </em>‘Thus each man flees himself.’ <em>But to what end if he does not escape himself? He pursues and dogs himself as his own most tedious companion. And so we must realize that our difficulty is not the fault of the places but of ourselves.”</em></blockquote><p>This quote tiptoed through my mind during every quiet moment at the camp. And there were <em>many</em> quiet moments.</p><p>Was I fleeing from myself?</p><p>The disconnect between who I am and what I was doing became unavoidable. Between who I am and what I was saying, what I was thinking, what I was choosing to put energy into.</p><p>I did a lot the few days I was there. I climbed a volcano and danced under a waterfall. I painted warm mud all over my body and soaked in a natural hot spring. I spent my days lounging on the beach and riding around in the bed of a truck filled with surfboards and people with fascinating stories.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*G02K_lTrPj4VhlIx." /></figure><p>I wanted so badly to tell everyone on Facebook and Instagram how great I felt while I was there — how much fun I was having and how I never wanted to leave.</p><p>I got so attached to the idea of travel that I started to identify myself with it. At one point I even edited my Bio on Instagram to cleverly say, “adventurer” next to my name. I liked how it sounded when I read it to myself. “Leah Howard, <em>adventurer.</em>” I deleted it after a few weeks because of how inaccurate it felt. What qualifies me to call myself an adventurer? Getting on a plane and flying to another country?</p><p>I received many messages from people saying things like, “You’re life looks so cool,” “I’m living vicariously through you,” and (my favorite) “I wanna be like you when I grow up.”</p><p>The attention from living such an attractive, adventurous life is powerful, almost more alluring than the adventure itself. This attention went to my head.</p><p>It’s human nature to want to keep doing the things that people respond positively to. The things that make us feel liked, “<em>cool</em>,” relevant, and valued.</p><p>I felt this nagging sense of guilt every time I posted a photo. I was sharing only a part of my experience and it was not entirely authentic. It seemed harmless, presenting the story in a way that made it seem exciting and glamorous. That is, until I realized it wasn’t just a fun little game but that it was actually affecting how I felt about everything.</p><p>I scrolled through my Instagram feed and couldn’t see myself anywhere in the photos. Even the selfies were faceless to me. It could have been <em>anyone’s</em> account. But I was getting more ‘likes’ than I ever had from pictures of my travels, so I kept at it.</p><p>I came across an article that resonated deeply with me: <a href="https://medium.com/@katikrause/facebook-s-mental-health-problem-9c48374c1bd8#.61l4k6dk3">Facebook’s Mental Health Problem</a>. The author, Kati Krause, writes:</p><blockquote><em>I took to my Facebook feed and the further I went back, the more jealous I felt </em>at my own life<em> as I had portrayed it.</em></blockquote><p>It looked like I was having a great time. How could I be in such an incredible place, surrounded by beautiful, interesting people, living a life that so many people dream of, and <em>still</em> feel unhappy?</p><p>My ego had been growing quietly beneath the veil of adventure and self-discovery, fiercely demanding attention and praise. It was the silent, stealthy driver behind my decision to travel, or rather, to flee.</p><p>I was fleeing from myself — from the gaping hole in my life where love and laughter and human connection once was — in pursuit of an unsubstantial and unsustainable self-image. I didn’t want anyone to know that I planned to stay six weeks but that I left after one.</p><p>I’ve been quite selective with the things I share on social media. I tell myself it’s because I know no one needs to or wants to read anything negative. We get enough of that already with politics, the media, and generally cranky people. But I think it’s mostly just because I want to protect myself.</p><p>There’s a really big part of me that wants more than anything to simply be a radiating beam of light that drives out darkness, that spreads love and lightness to every thing and every one around me.</p><p>It has been my hope that by choosing to share only the positive things on social media — the photos of the cool places I’ve been and the smiling selfies and the spiritually-minded quotes — that I am choosing that as my reality.</p><p>However, by only showing the light, I’ve failed to acknowledge the emotional, soulful, sensitive side of my being and it has left me feeling unseen and inauthentic.</p><p>As I strive to feel more connected, it is important for me to be honest with myself and with others about my experiences. To admit that <strong>the last four months have been really fucking hard</strong>. I’ve cried in my mother’s lap like a child as she rubbed my head on more than one occasion, and I’ve had frightening adult (?) temper tantrums that have resulted in me kicking walls and screaming into pillows. I’ve eaten breakfast, lunch, and dinner out of my lap with my hands in my car because I didn’t have anywhere to go, and I’ve gone to multiple doctors multiple times because I wanted an answer for what could possibly be making me feel everything so intensely. (Turns out, stress).</p><p>It’s important for me to admit that I am as much the darkness as I am the light. My humanity exists in the contrast between them — in the bending and stretching of the playful shadows created as they mingle.</p><p>I’m publishing this story almost two months later than when I started writing it because I wasn’t sure how to piece together all the jumbled bits. And because I’ve been afraid. Afraid of exposing too much.</p><p>I am not hollow. I am human and I experience happiness just as severely as I experience hurt. To deny one would be to deny my depth and complexity. I am learning to embrace each. To embrace the dimensions of my humanity, and to expose them, nakedly.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://amomentwithleah.com/2016/04/14/transparency-maintaining-authenticity-on-social-media-the-week-i-spent-volunteering-at-a-surf-camp/"><em>amomentwithleah.com</em></a><em> on April 14, 2016.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2f4ff3e0d81e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>