<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Nathalie Ventilation on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Nathalie Ventilation on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:59:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sophie Doesn’t Need to Understand Voc Sensors but knows When to Open the Window]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/sophie-doesnt-need-to-understand-voc-sensors-but-know-when-to-open-the-window-14da0202fa34?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14da0202fa34</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-ga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-quality-monitoring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[voc-sensor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tvoc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2026 20:07:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-13T20:15:16.763Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/825/1*HI3YSSU5U7BBkcHyh1161g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Why the conversation around low-cost gas monitoring needs to move from sensor limitations to useful action</strong></p><p>Sophie is sitting in her living room when she notices something strange on her air quality monitor. The VOC Index, usually low, has climbed to 300.</p><p>She doesn’t know what a MOx sensor is. She doesn’t know how its baseline adapts, what cross-sensitivity means, or how the algorithm behind the number works.</p><p>She knows only one thing: the number has gone up. A lot.</p><p>So what should she do?</p><p>Open a window? Turn on the kitchen or bathroom exhaust fan? Look around for something that might be releasing gases? Or do nothing because low-cost VOC sensors are imperfect and the number may be difficult to interpret?</p><p>This is the question I think we’re not asking often enough when we talk about low-cost gas monitoring.</p><p>In <em>The Forgotten Air We Breathe</em>, I wrote about what I called the “poor cousin” of indoor air quality: gases. We pay increasing attention to CO₂ and particulate matter in our homes, while gases often remain invisible, not only physically, but in the way we think about indoor air.<br> The Forgotten Air We Breathe. <em>Indoor gases: the blind spot of a public-health blind spot. </em><a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-forgotten-air-we-breathe-ccafbd7d785b">https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-forgotten-air-we-breathe-ccafbd7d785b</a></p><p>This article is, in a way, the next chapter of that reflection.</p><p>Because even when we do monitor gases, I’ve noticed another problem. We spend a remarkable amount of time explaining what inexpensive gas sensors cannot do. And those limitations matter. But sometimes we become so focused on the limitations of the measurement that we forget the reason for measuring in the first place.</p><p>Sophie doesn’t need perfect information. She needs enough information to make a better decision about the air she’s breathing right now.</p><p>And that requires something more than measurement. It requires helping people move from measurement, to understanding, to action.</p><p><strong>Are We Blinded by Science?</strong></p><p>I’ve noticed a strange ambiguity around low-cost gas monitoring.</p><p>I see it on Reddit, on X, and in articles and discussions about indoor air quality. Gases already receive far less attention than particulate matter or CO₂. But even when we do monitor them, there often seems to be a hesitation to really believe that the information can be useful.</p><p>The conversation quickly turns to everything these sensors cannot do.</p><p>They aren’t precise enough. They can’t identify individual compounds. They respond to multiple gases. Their baselines move. They have cross-sensitivities. A VOC Index isn’t a concentration. One monitor can’t necessarily be compared directly with another.</p><p>All of that matters. I don’t want less science. I want good science.</p><p>But I sometimes wonder whether we’re becoming so preoccupied with explaining the limitations of these sensors that we’re losing sight of why we put them in people’s homes in the first place.</p><p>We measure because we want the measurement to help us make a decision and ultimately, to breathe better air.</p><p>A recent experience with AirGradient brought this ambiguity into focus for me.</p><p>AirGradient is actually an interesting example precisely because it isn’t dismissive of gas monitoring. Quite the opposite. The AirGradient ONE measures VOCs and NOx alongside PM and CO₂. In that sense, they’re among the “good students” in the room: they believe gases matter enough to put sensors for them in a consumer indoor air quality monitor.</p><p>And yet, when I had a question about the VOC readings from my brand-new ONE, I encountered a way of talking about gas sensors that felt very familiar.</p><p>My AirGradient was reporting a very high VOC Index while four other monitors sitting right beside it were all indicating low VOC levels. Two of them (the Temtop M10+ and Qingping Pro 2) also report a VOC Index. The other two (the Temtop M10 and Temtop LKC-1000S) report TVOC in mg/m³.</p><p>I wanted to understand the discrepancy.</p><p>But the response brought me almost immediately back to the limitations of low-cost VOC sensors and the difficulty of comparing them.</p><p>And that’s where the ambiguity becomes interesting to me.</p><p>We believe in gas monitoring enough to measure it. But do we believe in it enough to investigate what the measurement is telling us, and to help Sophie (or Nathalie) use it?</p><p>Imagine that Sophie has two perfectly legitimate consumer monitors sitting in her living room. One is essentially showing her a red light: VOCs are high. The other is showing her a green light: VOCs are low. What should we tell her? Don’t compare them? Accept that VOC sensors are imperfect? Read more about how MOx sensors work?</p><p>Or should we help her investigate why two instruments designed to give her information about the same air are telling her two very different stories?</p><p>Because Sophie isn’t trying to publish a paper on MOx sensors. She is trying to manage the air in her home.</p><p>Maybe she already owned four VOC monitors and decided to buy a fifth because she wanted more information. Instead, on her first days with the new monitor, she got more questions than answers.</p><p>That’s not necessarily a failure of the sensor. Contradictory measurements can themselves be useful information. One sensor may be responding to something the others aren’t. A baseline may still be adapting. The instruments may behave differently for reasons worth understanding.</p><p>But shouldn’t our response be curiosity rather than resignation?</p><p>If one legitimate monitor says VOCs are high and another legitimate monitor says they’re low, surely the interesting question is why.</p><p>And while Sophie investigates that question, she still has another one:</p><p>What should I do with my air right now?</p><p>The material I was referred to by AirGradient’s customer support helped explain why VOC monitoring is complicated. But it didn’t answer either of those questions for me.</p><p>And that’s the contradiction I can’t quite get past. If we’re going to put gas sensors in people’s homes, show them the numbers, color-code the results and encourage them to monitor their air, then when those measurements become confusing, we can’t simply retreat behind the limitations of the technology.</p><p>Otherwise, what are we measuring for?</p><p>That’s the gap I want to explore.</p><p><strong>Are We Answering the User’s Question?</strong></p><p>This brings me to a broader question: when we explain low-cost gas monitoring to consumers, are we answering the questions they actually have?</p><p>AirGradient’s article on the VOC Index explains what VOCs are, how MOx sensors work, why they cannot identify individual compounds, why readings should be interpreted qualitatively, and how the VOC Index uses an adaptive baseline.</p><p>(Altaïr Sheikh. January 6, 2026. <em>Explaining VOCs, TVOC and the VOC Index</em>. AirGradient Blog. <a href="https://www.airgradient.com/blog/explaining-voc-tvoc-and-voc-index/">https://www.airgradient.com/blog/explaining-voc-tvoc-and-voc-index/</a>)</p><p>This is useful information. But it mainly answers the question:</p><p>How does this technology work, and what are its limitations?</p><p>That’s not necessarily the question the person looking at the monitor is asking.</p><p>Sophie is asking:</p><p>What does this change in my air mean for me, and what should I do about it?</p><p>If the number suddenly rises, should she investigate what changed in the room? Should she stop using a product? Turn on an exhaust fan? Open a window if outdoor conditions are good? Should she wait and see whether the reading comes back down?</p><p>And if two monitors disagree dramatically, should she simply accept that these instruments are difficult to compare, or should she try to understand why they are telling her two different stories?</p><p>These are not questions about sensor engineering. They are user questions.</p><p>And I think that’s where an important gap appears in the way we sometimes communicate about gas monitoring. We provide increasingly sophisticated explanations of the measurement without always completing the journey from measurement to meaning to action for ordinary people.</p><p>The technical information isn’t the problem. It’s valuable. The problem comes when we teach level two without teaching level one.</p><p>A person shouldn’t have to understand MOx technology, adaptive baselines, gain algorithms and cross-sensitivity before being able to make sensible use of a consumer air quality monitor.</p><p>Sophie can learn something much simpler first.</p><p>If the gas indicator turns red while she’s cooking, she can turn on the kitchen exhaust fan. If it rises after a shower, she can use the bathroom exhaust fan. If she’s cleaning the floor or doing laundry and the level rises, she can ventilate if outdoor conditions allow.<br>And if the level suddenly climbs for no obvious reason, she doesn’t necessarily have to identify the gas before doing anything. She can reduce her exposure first, perhaps by ventilating, watch what happens to the reading, and then try to understand what caused the increase.</p><p>That’s level one.</p><p>Level two is understanding why the sensor behaves the way it does: what a MOx sensor actually measures, why its baseline moves, why different sensors may respond differently to the same air, and why a VOC Index cannot tell us which compounds are present.</p><p>That knowledge matters. It can make Sophie a more informed user. But it shouldn’t be the entrance exam she has to pass before the information on her monitor becomes useful.</p><p>The ultimate goal isn’t to pass a university exam on indoor air quality. It’s to breathe better air here and now.</p><p>Technical sophistication should support simple action, not be a prerequisite for it</p><p><strong>Three Ways of Talking About the Same Imperfect Sensor</strong></p><p>The same limitations of low-cost gas sensing can be communicated in very different ways.</p><p>Three documents provide an interesting example.</p><p>The AirGradient article I was referred to focuses largely on understanding VOCs, the technology behind the measurement, and its limitations. It explains why low-cost sensors cannot identify individual compounds, why their readings require context, and how an adaptive baseline affects the VOC Index.</p><p>Now consider a technical note from Sensirion explaining its VOC Index.</p><p>It too explains the relative nature of the index and its moving baseline. But it also explicitly connects the measurement to action. Sensirion gives the example of mapping a VOC Index value to an action a device should execute, such as triggering an air purifier above a certain threshold.</p><p>( Sensirion. What is Sensirion’s VOC Index?<br> <a href="https://sensirion.com/media/documents/02232963/6294E043/Info_Note_VOC_Index.pdf">https://sensirion.com/media/documents/02232963/6294E043/Info_Note_VOC_Index.pdf</a>)</p><p>An air purifier is generally not the most appropriate response to elevated gases. Source control or ventilation usually makes more sense. But what is interesting here is the underlying idea:</p><p>The measurement is connected to something we can do. Sensirion gives us an action threshold.</p><p>A VisiblAir article makes that connection even more explicit.</p><p>The article explains many of the same complications: the adaptive baseline, the fact that the index isn’t a concentration, the inability to identify individual compounds, and the importance of looking at patterns rather than isolated readings.</p><p>But it also translates those limitations into practical guidance. A table connects reading or pattern → possible context → interpretation → practical action.</p><p>A brief rise can prompt the user to identify what activity may have caused it, use local exhaust or ventilate if outdoor conditions allow, and then watch for recovery. A sustained or repeated rise can prompt a search for the source, source control when practical, ventilation, and continued observation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*EKfzI9vosQSG4TQIjNUxJQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Source: VisiblAir, VOC Index Meaning: Scale, Baseline and Actions</em></figcaption></figure><p>(VisiblAir. Reviewed and updated August 3, 2026. VOC Index Meaning: Scale, Baseline and Actions. <a href="https://visiblair.com/products/what-does-the-tvoc-value-represent-on-model-e-and-e-lite/">https://visiblair.com/products/what-does-the-tvoc-value-represent-on-model-e-and-e-lite/</a>)</p><p>Put these three documents side by side, and an interesting difference appears.</p><p>All three help explain an imperfect measurement. But they place different amounts of emphasis on the final step: what the person looking at that measurement can actually do with it.</p><p>We don’t have to choose between scientific rigor and practical guidance. We can have both.</p><p>Explain the limitations. Explain the science. Explain what the number cannot tell us.</p><p>And then finish the sentence.</p><p>Tell Sophie what she can reasonably do with the information.</p><p><strong>From Measurement to Action</strong></p><p>Low-cost gas sensors are imperfect. They will become better. Their algorithms will improve, independent validation will improve, and perhaps one day affordable home monitors will tell us much more about the individual gases in our homes.</p><p>But we don’t have to wait for perfect sensors to make better use of the ones we have today.</p><p>The challenge is not only to improve the measurement. It is also to become better at translating imperfect measurements into reasonable actions.</p><p>That doesn’t mean treating every VOC spike as an emergency, or pretending that a low-cost sensor knows more than it does. It means helping people understand what the information can reasonably tell them, and what they can reasonably do with it.</p><p>A meaningful rise can be a reason to pay attention. What changed? Is there an obvious source? Can that source be stopped or removed? Would local exhaust help? Would ventilation be appropriate? Does the reading fall after taking action? Does the same pattern happen again?</p><p>None of these questions requires the monitor to identify every molecule in the room.</p><p>In fact, the uncertainty is part of the information. If a sensor tells us that the gas environment has changed significantly but cannot tell us exactly which gases caused that change, the sensible response isn’t necessarily to dismiss the signal. It can be to investigate it, reduce the source or exposure when practical, and see how the measurement responds.</p><p>This is where I think the conversation around low-cost gas monitoring needs to go next.</p><p>Better sensors, yes. Better validation, absolutely. Better understanding of their limitations, of course.</p><p>But also better guidance about what we can do with the information we already have.</p><p>The monitor doesn’t have to give Sophie a chemical analysis of her living room.</p><p>It has to help her make a better decision about the air she’s breathing.</p><p><strong>The Person on the Other Side of the Sensor</strong></p><p>Somewhere, Sophie is still standing in her living room, looking at that number on her monitor.</p><p>There will always be more to learn about the science behind the measurement. But that science should bring us closer to the person using the sensor, not further away.</p><p>Sophie didn’t buy an air quality monitor to understand a sensor.</p><p>She bought it to help herself and her family breathe better air.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14da0202fa34" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Forgotten Air We Breathe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-forgotten-air-we-breathe-ccafbd7d785b?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccafbd7d785b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wildfire-smoke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-monitoring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home-ventilation-system]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2026 20:57:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-31T12:33:21.218Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Indoor gases: the blind spot of a public-health blind spot</em></strong></p><p><em>We worry about what is coming into our homes. We should also worry about what is building up inside them.</em></p><p>Indoor air quality is the poor cousin of public health. And gases may be the poor cousin of indoor air quality.</p><p>When wildfire smoke blankets a city, the message is simple: <em>stay indoors, close your windows, keep the pollution outside.</em></p><p>But what happens to the pollution already inside?</p><p>Our homes are not boxes filled with clean air. They continuously release and generate gase, and, taken as a whole, gaseous pollution is generally higher indoors than outdoors. Yet gases remain largely absent from the public conversation about air quality, including during major smoke events.</p><p>Some people barely think about them. Others know enough about outdoor pollutants to become afraid of outdoor air itself. Different paths, same result: we close the windows and assume we are safer.</p><p>But a closed window is not an air-quality strategy.</p><p>We need to stop thinking in ORs. Outdoor pollution or indoor pollution. Particles or gases. Closing the building or ventilating it.</p><p>The challenge is to do both: protect ourselves from particles AND prevent gases from accumulating indoors.</p><p>That is what this article is about.</p><p><strong>TL;DR:</strong> Indoor air quality remains a neglected area of public health, and gaseous pollution is perhaps its most neglected component. Public messaging during wildfire smoke focuses heavily on outdoor PM2.5, staying indoors, and closing windows, while paying far less attention to the gases already present inside our homes.</p><p>Wildfire smoke does increase gaseous pollution outdoors, but unless a home is so close to the fire that evacuation is necessary, total VOC levels are still likely to be higher indoors than outdoors. Homes contain many sources of potentially dangerous gases, including formaldehyde, and these pollutants continue to accumulate when outdoor air ventilation is reduced. Particle filters remove particles, not gases. Activated carbon can capture some gases, but its effectiveness varies and it does not replace ventilation. Outdoor air is therefore always needed to dilute indoor gaseous pollution, even when wildfire conditions require that this air be carefully controlled and filtered.</p><p>Buildings also behave differently. A very leaky home may allow more outdoor PM2.5 to enter through cracks and gaps, but this uncontrolled air exchange may also provide greater dilution of indoor gases. A tightly sealed home may offer better protection against particle infiltration, but if the windows remain closed and mechanical ventilation is insufficient, gaseous pollutants can accumulate. Negative pressure creates another problem. When more air is mechanically exhausted than intentionally supplied, replacement air is pulled inward through cracks and gaps, allowing outdoor PM2.5 to enter without filtration.</p><p>A complete strategy must address both particles and gases. This means sealing uncontrolled leakage pathways, bringing outdoor air in through controlled ventilation, filtering the particles from that incoming air, maintaining slight positive pressure when possible, preserving enough ventilation to dilute indoor gases, and using sufficient portable particle air cleaners indoors. During severe wildfire smoke, outdoor air intake may need to be reduced, but it should not necessarily be eliminated.</p><p>Monitoring allows this strategy to be fine tuned according to actual conditions. Indoor and outdoor PM2.5 measurements can show whether particles are entering and whether filtration is sufficient. Low cost TVOC sensors, despite their limitations, can show whether gaseous pollution rises or falls as ventilation changes. When in doubt, indoor and outdoor TVOC readings can be compared, although the vast majority of the time they are likely to confirm the usual pattern, with higher levels indoors than outdoors.</p><p>Indoor air should not remain a public health blind spot, and gases should not remain the blind spot within that blind spot. The goal is to protect against particles, dilute gases, measure what is actually happening, and adjust accordingly. We can and should do both.</p><p><strong><em>A note before you dive in</em></strong></p><p><em>This article turned out to be much longer than I originally expected. The deeper I went into the subject, the more I realized how many pieces needed to be brought together.</em></p><p><em>So don’t feel you need to read everything from beginning to end. I’ve included a table of contents below — feel free to browse, skip around, or go directly to the sections that interest you most.</em></p><p><strong><em>Table of Contents</em></strong></p><p><em>The Gases We Breathe Indoors</em></p><p>A propos des purificateurs avec filtre de carbone</p><p><em>VOC Levels Are Consistently Higher Indoors Than Outdoors</em></p><p>The Dilemma of Fresh Air: Why We Cannot Do Without Ventilation</p><p>Stay Indoors” Is Not an Indoor-Air-Quality Strategy</p><p><em>The Pressure Problem: When Your Home Becomes a Vacuum</em></p><p><em>When Outdoor Air Becomes the Enemy</em></p><p><em>Seal AND Ventilate: Resolving the Apparent Contradiction</em></p><p>What ASHRAE Actually Recommends During Wildfire Smoke</p><p>It’s Better to Measure Than to Guess</p><p><em>The Information Gap: Searching for Culprits, Missing the Basics</em></p><p>Conclusion. The Forgotten Half of the Air We Breathe</p><p><strong><em>The Gases We Breathe Indoors</em></strong></p><p>When we talk about gases in indoor air, VOCs are an important part of the picture. VOCs — volatile organic compounds — are a large family of organic compounds that can evaporate into the air. But VOCs are not the whole story. There are other gaseous pollutants as well, such as carbon monoxide and radon, and some PAHs can also be present in the gas phase.</p><p>Not every gas is dangerous. But many gaseous pollutants can affect our health, and indoor-air chemistry makes the picture even more complex. A compound that may not seem particularly concerning by itself can interact with another compound and create new pollutants.</p><p>Limonene is a good example. Limonene is a naturally occurring, sweet-smelling compound found in oranges and commonly added to household cleaners and other products for its pleasant scent. But when limonene reacts with ozone, which is primarily an outdoor pollutant but can enter our homes. the reaction can generate formaldehyde and particles.</p><p>Allen and Macomber give this example in <em>Healthy Buildings</em> while describing just how many ordinary sources of VOCs surround us at home. VOCs can come from laundry detergent, dryer sheets, couches and soaps. They can be emitted by personal-care products such as perfume, lotion, hand sanitizer, shampoo and deodorant. Building materials and furnishings can also be sources.</p><p>Formaldehyde, a known human carcinogen, can be emitted by some manufactured wood products used in cabinetry, furniture and laminate flooring.</p><p>And consider benzene, another known human carcinogen. We may instinctively associate benzene with traffic and outdoor air pollution, but benzene also has important indoor sources. These include environmental tobacco smoke, stored fuels, paint supplies, and automobile emissions entering from attached garages. In other words, knowing that a dangerous gas exists outdoors does not mean that closing ourselves inside automatically removes our exposure to it. The indoor environment has sources of its own.</p><p>(And if you think tobacco smoke does not concern you because you don’t smoke, think again if you live in a multi-unit building: air — and the pollutants it carries — can travel between units, meaning your neighbors’ smoke can become part of the air you breathe.)</p><p>So the gases in our homes do not simply come from some mysterious source of “pollution” outside. They are emitted by many of the materials, products and activities that are part of ordinary daily life. And once they are in the air, some compounds can react with others and create additional pollutants.</p><p>This matters for health.</p><p>As the American Lung Association explains, VOC exposure can produce a range of health effects, with the respiratory system being particularly vulnerable. Short-term exposure can cause eye, nose and throat irritation, headaches and dizziness. Prolonged or repeated exposure to high VOC concentrations may contribute to more serious health problems, particularly for people who already have lung disease. People with asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) may experience worsening symptoms when exposed to VOCs. VOC exposure may also contribute to allergies and sensitivities, particularly in children.</p><p>And some VOCs pose much more serious risks. Formaldehyde and benzene, for example, can cause cancer.</p><p>Some people are also more vulnerable to these exposures than others. The American Lung Association identifies children, older adults and people with respiratory conditions as being at greater risk of health problems associated with VOC exposure. Children breathe more air relative to their body size, which means that their exposure relative to body size can be greater. Older adults may have reduced respiratory function and immune defenses, making them more susceptible to the effects of air pollution.</p><p>So when I use the word “gases” throughout this article, I am deliberately talking about something broader than VOCs alone. I am not suggesting that every gas in indoor air is dangerous, or that every gaseous pollutant carries the same level of risk.</p><p>What matters is the mixture we actually breathe: VOCs and other gaseous pollutants, some relatively harmless, some irritating, some toxic or carcinogenic, and some capable of reacting with other compounds in the air to produce new pollutants.</p><p>And this mixture is not static. It is constantly changing as products are used, people carry out everyday activities, materials continue to off-gas, outdoor air enters the building, and chemical reactions take place indoors.</p><p>References :</p><p>American Lung Association. 2023. Volatile Organic Compounds in the Home. <a href="https://www.lung.org/blog/volatile-organic-compounds-at-home">https://www.lung.org/blog/volatile-organic-compounds-at-home</a></p><p>Joseph G. Allen &amp; John D. Macomber. Healthy Buildings: How Indoor Spaces Drive Performance and Productivity</p><p><strong>What About Air Purifiers with Carbon Filters?</strong></p><p>Activated-carbon filters can be useful for removing some gaseous pollutants, but their effectiveness varies considerably from one gas to another.</p><p>Some important indoor gases are difficult to remove effectively with activated carbon. Carbon monoxide, radon and CO₂ are particularly poor candidates, while formaldehyde is also relatively difficult to adsorb. Other gases, such as ozone, are much more readily removed.</p><p>And even for VOCs that activated carbon can capture effectively, performance depends on many factors: the particular compounds involved, the type and amount of carbon, airflow through the media, contact time, environmental conditions and how saturated the carbon has become.</p><p>As Joseph Allen and John Macomber explain in <em>Healthy Buildings</em>:</p><p>“These can be expensive, and they require some skill and expertise to use well because carbon filters can saturate. When a particle filter gets dirty, it performs better because there is more physical junk in the way of the air stream, but when a carbon filter saturates, VOCs pass right through. So having it in place may give a false sense of security. Not to mention that carbon filters also preferentially bind certain VOCs. There is an art to using carbon filters, but they can be effective when done right.”</p><p>Carbon filtration can therefore be a useful tool. But it does not replace outdoor-air ventilation.</p><p>I ran a small exploratory experiment at home using a simple, minimal protocol. My goal was to compare the ability to reduce TVOC levels of outdoor-air ventilation through an 84 × 12-inch window opening with three different activated-carbon air purifiers: one commercial unit and two DIY units.</p><p>I used a control phase and timed experimental phases, generating TVOCs in the same way for each condition. The purpose was simply to get a preliminary sense of how the different approaches compared under the same basic setup.</p><p>The difference was striking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*10ydUQWzMjRcPl2M0NJf2A.png" /></figure><p>Under the conditions of this preliminary experiment, opening the window produced by far the largest reduction in TVOC levels — close to 50%. The MegaVOC DIY carbon purifier produced a reduction of about 10%, while the TruSens Noctua produced a smaller reduction of roughly 4%. The AirFanta carbon filter showed only a very small effect at 5 V and almost no measurable effect at its maximum setting.</p><p>In this particular setup, outdoor-air ventilation reduced TVOCs roughly five times more than the best-performing carbon purifier I tested.</p><p>And the window was only partially open. It is 84 inches high and can open as far as 29 inches in my home; for this experiment, I opened it by only 12 inches.</p><p>These results should not be generalized beyond this experiment. The protocol was deliberately minimal, and performance would be expected to vary with the VOC mixture, amount and type of activated carbon, airflow, room conditions, ventilation rate and other factors.</p><p>But the experiment offered me a useful preliminary comparison: carbon filtration did reduce TVOCs, particularly with the larger MegaVOC unit, but outdoor-air ventilation produced a much larger reduction under the same basic test conditions.</p><p>The result put things into perspective for me.</p><p>Carbon filtration can help, but it should not create a false sense of security or distract from the much more fundamental role of ventilation.</p><p>When outdoor air is cleaner in terms of gaseous pollution, why try to capture individual gases one by one if sufficient outdoor-air ventilation can dilute the gaseous pollutants in indoor air much more broadly?</p><p>Personally, I don’t currently use activated-carbon air purifiers in my home. Under my usual conditions, ventilation is sufficient to keep my TVOC and formaldehyde readings low, so adding carbon filtration would mean additional cost, noise, space and maintenance without an obvious need.</p><p>I would reconsider that trade-off if outdoor gaseous pollution became unusually high and ventilation were no longer as useful for reducing indoor levels. In that situation, activated carbon could become another useful tool in the toolbox.</p><p>Références</p><p>Joseph G. Allen &amp; John D. Macomber. Healthy Buildings: How Indoor Spaces Drive Performance and Productivity</p><p><strong><em>VOC Levels Are Consistently Higher Indoors Than Outdoors</em></strong></p><p>There is a basic fact about indoor air pollution that is surprisingly absent from most public conversations about air quality: VOC concentrations are generally higher indoors than outdoors.</p><p>The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency states that concentrations of many VOCs are consistently higher indoors (up to ten times higher) than outdoors. The American Lung Association reports the same general pattern.</p><p>This is important to keep in mind because when we hear about air pollution, our attention is usually directed outside: traffic, industry, wildfire smoke, gas stations, highways. We tend to think of pollution as something that comes into our homes from outdoors. Yet when it comes to VOCs, the baseline reality is generally the opposite: indoor concentrations tend to be higher.</p><p>This is consistent with what we have already seen about the many sources of VOCs inside ordinary homes: building materials, furniture, cleaning products, personal-care products, fragrances, paints, solvents, stored fuels and everyday human activities.</p><p>A recent Canadian study provides a useful real-world example.</p><p>In 2025, Amirashkan Askari and Arthur W. H. Chan studied a 110-unit residential building in downtown Toronto. They analyzed the gas-phase composition of the air entering and leaving the building through its mechanical ventilation system.</p><p>The comparison was quite clear. VOCs were more prevalent and more concentrated in the exhaust air than in the incoming air, and total VOC concentrations were significantly higher in the exhaust stream. Of the compounds they quantified, 37 out of 47 were detected in at least 90% of exhaust samples, compared with 27 out of 42 in the incoming-air samples.</p><p>This study is not the basis for the broader claim that VOC concentrations are generally higher indoors — the phenomenon was already well documented. But it provides a recent Canadian residential example consistent with that established pattern.</p><p><strong>But What About Wildfire Smoke?</strong></p><p>This is probably where some readers will immediately pause.</p><p>What happens during a major wildfire-smoke event? Surely there are gases coming from the fire outside. Doesn’t that change the picture?</p><p>It may. Wildfire smoke contains gaseous pollutants as well as particles, and concentrations of particular gases outdoors can increase.</p><p>But that fact alone does not answer the indoor-versus-outdoor question at a particular home.</p><p>The presence of hazardous gases outdoors does not automatically establish that TVOC concentrations, or gaseous pollution more broadly,are higher outdoors than indoors.</p><p>And the indoor sources we have just discussed do not disappear when wildfire smoke arrives. Building materials continue to off-gas. Furniture continues to off-gas. Household and personal-care products remain sources. Human activities continue to generate pollutants.</p><p>There is another important difference that we will return to later: gases and fine particles do not behave identically in the atmosphere. PM2.5 from wildfire smoke can travel hundreds or even thousands of kilometres. Many gaseous compounds are diluted, transformed or removed as a smoke plume travels and ages. How much of any particular gas reaches a particular location depends on the compound, distance, atmospheric chemistry, weather conditions and other factors.</p><p>So simply knowing that a wildfire is producing gases somewhere does not tell us what the indoor-versus-outdoor balance is where we are actually breathing.</p><p>And here the scientific evidence is surprisingly limited. To my knowledge, we do not have studies that give us a general indoor/outdoor comparison of TVOCs — or overall gaseous pollution — in occupied homes located far from a wildfire during a smoke event.</p><p>The limited research we do have, however, is interesting.</p><p>Two studies examined gas-phase PAHs indoors and outdoors during wildfire events. PAHs are not TVOCs as a whole, and these studies therefore cannot answer the broader question of whether total gaseous pollution is higher indoors or outdoors.</p><p>Still, their findings are worth considering.</p><p>Messier et al. measured 63 PAHs using paired indoor and outdoor samples at six residential sites during wildfire conditions. They found that indoor gas-phase PAH concentrations were consistently equal to or greater than outdoor concentrations. The authors concluded that the household indoor environment could actually be worse for gas-phase PAH exposure than outdoors and questioned wildfire recommendations based entirely on particulate-matter exposure. (<a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7039657">PubMed Central (PMC)</a>)</p><p>A larger study by Ghetu et al. produced a more nuanced picture. Across sampling periods, indoor PAH concentrations were higher in 77% of samples. Even during wildfires, 58% of sampled locations still had higher PAH concentrations indoors. Under more severe smoke conditions, however, the balance could change: when AQI exceeded approximately 140, outdoor PAH concentrations became similar to or higher than indoor concentrations. (<a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9301925">PubMed Central (PMC)</a>)</p><p>Again, these studies measured PAHs, not TVOCs or gaseous pollution as a whole. They do not establish that gases are generally higher indoors during wildfire smoke.</p><p>But neither do they support the assumption that wildfire smoke outside = gaseous pollution must be higher outside.</p><p>The reality appears to be more complicated.</p><p>I will come back to this question later. For now, the important point is the baseline we already know: under ordinary conditions, concentrations of many VOCs (and overall VOC levels) tend to be higher indoors than outdoors.</p><p>That is an important fact to remember before we start deciding which side of the window we should be more afraid of.</p><p>References<br> American Lung Association (2023). <em>Volatile Organic Compounds in the Home.<br></em><a href="https://www.lung.org/blog/volatile-organic-compounds-at-home">https://www.lung.org/blog/volatile-organic-compounds-at-home</a></p><p>U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. <em>Volatile Organic Compounds’ Impact on Indoor Air Quality.</em> <a href="https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/volatile-organic-compounds-impact-indoor-air-quality"><em>https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/volatile-organic-compounds-impact-indoor-air-quality</em></a></p><p>Askari, A. &amp; Chan, A. W. H. (2025). <em>Volatile organic compound emissions from a multi-unit residential building to ambient air</em>. <em>Environmental Science: Processes &amp; Impacts</em>.</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=%22Messier%20KP%22%5bAuthor%5d">KP Messier</a> &amp; al. 2020 Feb 24. Indoor versus Outdoor Air Quality during Wildfires. Environ Sci Technol .<a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7039657/">https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7039657/</a></p><p>Christine C. Ghetu &amp; al. Juillet 2022. Wildfire Impact on Indoor and Outdoor PAH Air Quality. <a href="https://pubs.acs.org/journal/esthag?ref=breadcrumb">Environmental Science &amp; Technology</a>. <a href="https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/acs.est.2c00619?ref=article_openPDF">https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/acs.est.2c00619?ref=article_openPDF</a></p><p><strong>The Dilemma of Fresh Air: Why We Cannot Do Without Ventilation</strong></p><p>If gases concentrations are generally higher indoors than outdoors, and if carbon filters have limited effectiveness at removing the full spectrum of indoor gases, the logical conclusion is inescapable: if we want good indoor air quality, we need an adequate supply of outdoor air to dilute indoor gaseous pollution.</p><p>And that is precisely where things get complicated.</p><p>Because that very same outdoor air we desperately need to flush out gases is sometimes heavily loaded with fine particles (</p><p>) during smog episodes or wildfire smoke events.</p><p>How do we resolve this contradiction? We will come back to that in detail later, supported by ASHRAE guidelines for wildfires. But before moving on, let us keep one truth firmly in mind: fresh air is essential for diluting our indoor pollutants.</p><p>In the upcoming sections, we will explore why simply “staying indoors” by battening down the hatches does not constitute a viable long-term strategy.</p><p>Forgotten Baselines: ASHRAE and AHAM Standards</p><p>To structure our approach, formal guidelines already exist. Yet they face a major hurdle from the start: they are frequently ignored.</p><p>It is crucial to repeat this: ASHRAE recommendations for ventilation and AHAM recommendations for indoor purification are absolute minimums. They are floors, never ceilings of excellence. And despite that, in many households, even this bare minimum is not met.</p><ul><li>The Ventilation Minimum (ASHRAE 62.2):</li></ul><p>Under ordinary conditions, the minimum outdoor air ventilation rate for a residential dwelling is roughly calculated as:</p><p>Minimum CFM = (0.03 x square footage) + (7.5 CFM per person).</p><p>Concrete example: A 500 sq ft apartment occupied by 2 people requires a continuous MINIMUM of about 30 CFM. In the book “Healthy Buildings,” the authors recommend a minimum of 30 CFM per person, which seems better — and even that might not be enough in a lot of situations. In our example, that would mean a minimum of 60 CFM. This just goes to show how ASHRAE 62 is a bare minimum of a bare minimum, and one that’s often not even met.</p><p>Added to this is a frequently neglected necessity: effective source extraction in kitchens and bathrooms. Too often, residential range hoods are absent, undersized, or rely merely on indoor recirculation rather than true outdoor exhaust.</p><p>The Purification Minimum (AHAM):</p><p>On the air cleaning side, AHAM recommends a Clean Air Delivery Rate (CADR) in CFM equivalent to at least two-thirds of the room’s area in square feet.</p><p><em>Concrete example:</em> For a 240 sq ft room, a minimum CADR of 180 CFM is required (roughly equivalent to 4.8 air changes per hour).</p><p>During smog or smoke events, this baseline is stepped up: the recommendation is a CADR in CFM at least equivalent to the room’s area in square feet (so a 240 sq ft room requires 240 CFM).</p><p>These numbers are not luxury options. They are minimal thresholds that remain insufficient on their own, yet are routinely missed in a vast majority of homes.</p><p>Reference</p><p>Ashrae. Standards 62.1 &amp; 62.2</p><p><a href="https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/standards-62-1-62-2">https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/standards-62-1-62-2</a></p><p>AHAM. Follow the 2/3 Rule <a href="https://ahamverifide.org/ahams-air-filtration-standards/">https://ahamverifide.org/ahams-air-filtration-standards/</a></p><p><strong><em>“Stay Indoors” Is Not an Indoor-Air-Quality Strategy</em></strong></p><p>During wildfire smoke events, we all know the refrain:</p><p>Stay indoors. Close your windows and doors.</p><p>The advice is given to virtually everyone.</p><p>For a moment, let’s even play along with an extremely simplified version of the problem. Forget everything I have said so far about gases. Let’s pretend particles are the only pollutant that matters and that our only objective is to shut ourselves inside a box and keep outdoor PM2.5 out.</p><p>There is already a major problem: not all boxes are alike.</p><p>Homes vary enormously in how tightly they are sealed. A very tight newer home may have extremely little uncontrolled air exchange. At the other end of the spectrum, a very leaky home can exchange its indoor air with outdoor air at a much higher rate through cracks, gaps and other openings. And of course, there is everything in between.</p><p>Allen and Macomber point to another useful way of understanding this in <em>Healthy Buildings</em>. Reviewing studies of particle infiltration into homes, they write:</p><p>“A review of different infiltration factors in homes shows that a stable median estimate for infiltration in homes is ~50 percent.”</p><p>Think about what that means during a wildfire-smoke event. As a median estimate, roughly half of the outdoor particles may end up contributing to indoor particle concentrations even when people have followed the instruction to stay inside.</p><p>And that is only infiltration from outdoors.</p><p>It doesn’t include the particles we generate inside our homes: cooking, cigarette smoke — including smoke migrating from a neighbor’s unit in a multi-unit building — ultrasonic humidifiers, hair dryers, essential-oil diffusers, renovation and DIY work, and many other ordinary indoor activities.</p><p><strong>What I saw during the 2023 wildfire smoke</strong></p><p>I had an opportunity to see just how dramatically indoor particle concentrations can vary during the massive Canadian wildfire-smoke events of 2023.</p><p>On June 25, 2023, during an extreme smoke episode in the Montreal region, Montreal was ranked by IQAir as having the worst air quality among major cities in the world.</p><p>I took my Temtop M10 with me and measured PM2.5 in the corridors of two residential buildings — my own and another one — as well as inside a McDonald’s, a shopping mall and a supermarket. I compared those readings with outdoor PM2.5 at approximately the same time.</p><p><strong>The indoor readings ranged from roughly 40–50% to about 95% of the outdoor concentrations.</strong></p><p>The most striking measurement was right outside my apartment door. In the building corridor, my monitor measured approximately <strong>235 µg/m³ of PM2.5</strong>, while outdoors at approximately the same time I measured <strong>245 µg/m³</strong>.</p><p>That corridor was therefore at roughly <strong>95% of the outdoor concentration</strong>.</p><p>Inside my own apartment, by contrast, PM2.5 remained at much safer levels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*bgOLa4bQpw9V62VMF_6QPQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*msHJ8VZiC-ohK0V8DZ3gKg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*upS-VpANBgB6P0qHwdcnXQ.png" /></figure><p>Very different indoor air.</p><p>And this is the fundamental problem with treating <em>“stay indoors”</em> as though <em>indoors</em> were itself an air-quality intervention.</p><p>Three homes, one recommendation</p><p>Imagine outdoor PM2.5 is 100 µg/m³.</p><p>House A is very well sealed, has little particle-generating activity indoors, and manages to maintain PM2.5 around 10 µg/m³.</p><p>House B has roughly 50% particle infiltration and ends up around 50 µg/m³, before even accounting for particles generated indoors.</p><p>House C is very leaky. People are cooking. Perhaps someone smokes inside — or smoke is entering from another unit. Indoor PM2.5 reaches 150 µg/m³.</p><p>All three households followed the same public-health instruction:</p><p>They stayed indoors and closed the windows.</p><p>Now make the wildfire episode much worse.</p><p>Outdoor PM2.5 reaches 300 µg/m³.</p><p>House A maintains approximately 30 µg/m³.</p><p>House B reaches 150 µg/m³.</p><p>House C, combining very high infiltration with indoor particle sources, reaches 450 µg/m³.</p><p>Yet according to the simplest interpretation of the public message, everyone has done the “safe” thing.</p><p>They’re indoors. Windows closed. Mission accomplished.</p><p>Except, obviously, it isn’t.</p><p>These numbers are simplified hypothetical examples, not predictions of what any particular home will measure. The point is that the same outdoor concentration and the same behavioral instruction can produce radically different indoor exposures depending on the building and what is happening inside it.</p><p>This is why telling people simply to <em>stay indoors and close the windows</em> is not precise enough.</p><p>People also need to understand the importance of particle filtration — something useful throughout the year, but especially important during wildfire-smoke events. Yet the public message often amounts to little more than: stay inside, close your windows, and wear a mask if you have to go outside.</p><p>And there is a second side to leakage.</p><p>So far, I have deliberately talked only about particles.</p><p>But remember everything we established earlier about indoor gases.</p><p>When a building leaks, air can enter through cracks and gaps — but air can also leave.</p><p>What is bad news for particles during wildfire smoke can therefore have another side: a leaky building may allow more outdoor particles in, while at the same time providing more uncontrolled dilution and removal of pollutants generated indoors (gases and pm).</p><p>The reverse problem can occur in a very tight home.</p><p>A well-sealed building can be much better protected against uncontrolled particle infiltration. But if we close the windows and drastically reduce outdoor-air ventilation, the same tight envelope that helps keep particles out can also help keep indoor-generated gases in.</p><p>One home (the leaky one) may therefore have a bigger particle problem.</p><p>Another (the new well sealed home) may have a bigger accumulation problem for indoor-generated gases .</p><p>Calling both simply “indoors” tells us remarkably little about the air the people inside are actually breathing.</p><p>And wildfire smoke is not a problem we can treat as a rare historical anomaly. Smoke episodes are expected to remain a recurring air-quality challenge, and in many regions climate change is increasing wildfire risk and the likelihood of severe smoke exposure.</p><p>We need something more useful than:</p><p>Stay indoors. Close the windows.</p><p>It is not, by itself, a plan to protect the public health in case of mega smog.</p><p>And there is another variable we haven’t even considered yet.</p><p>A house doesn’t have to passively leak outdoor air through its cracks. Pressure differences can actively drive air through them. Many homes can become depressurized, effectively turning the building into a giant, imperfect vacuum cleaner pulling outdoor air through every available leakage path.</p><p>So next we need to talk about pressure.</p><p><strong><em>The Pressure Problem: When Your Home Becomes a Vacuum</em></strong></p><p>There is another major variable that the usual <em>“stay indoors and close your windows”</em> advice rarely addresses: air pressure.</p><p>A home or apartment can be under negative pressure, neutral pressure, or positive pressure relative to the spaces surrounding it.</p><p>The basic principle is surprisingly simple. Negative pressure occurs when more air is being exhausted from a home than is being supplied to it. Air is leaving faster than it is being intentionally brought in.</p><p>But a home cannot simply keep losing air. The missing air has to be replaced.</p><p>So where does it come from?</p><p>From outside the home, but not necessarily from outdoors.</p><p>In a detached house, much of that replacement air may come directly from outdoors. In a multi-unit building, however, it can also come from corridors, neighboring apartments, wall cavities, common spaces, or other parts of the building.</p><p>When a home is depressurized, the pressure difference pulls air toward the lower-pressure space wherever it can find a pathway: cracks around windows and doors, gaps in the building envelope, electrical and plumbing penetrations, openings between apartments, and countless other leakage paths.</p><p>This distinction matters. The air being pulled into your apartment can carry whatever pollutants exist on the other side of those leakage paths — wildfire particles from outdoors, for example, but also cigarette smoke, VOCs, cooking emissions, particles or other pollutants originating elsewhere in a multi-unit building.</p><p>So during a wildfire-smoke event, closing the windows does not necessarily mean that you have stopped polluted air from entering your home. If your home is under negative pressure, it may be actively pulling air — and whatever that air contains — from the spaces surrounding it.</p><p>Closing the windows is only part of the equation</p><p>It isn’t only:</p><p>How leaky is the building?</p><p>It is also:</p><p>What pressure is driving air through those leaks — and where is that replacement air coming from?</p><p>A negatively pressurized home can behave almost like a giant, imperfect vacuum cleaner, pulling air through every available leakage pathway.</p><p>In a detached house, that may mean primarily outdoor air. In an apartment, the picture can be considerably more complicated: some air may come from outdoors, some from the corridor, some from neighboring units, and some through hidden pathways within the building.</p><p>This matters during wildfire smoke, but it matters year-round as well. You can dutifully close every window and door and still have pollutants entering your living space — not because you failed to follow the advice, but because air moves according to pressure differences, not according to whether we consider a door or window “closed.”</p><p>The opposite occurs with positive pressure. If slightly more appropriately filtered outdoor air is intentionally supplied to a home than is mechanically exhausted, the indoor pressure can be kept slightly higher relative to surrounding spaces. Air then tends to move outward through leakage paths rather than being pulled inward through them.</p><p><strong><em>When Outdoor Air Becomes the Enemy</em></strong></p><p>We talk about outdoor air quality all the time.</p><p>It is in our weather apps. It is reported on the news. We see outdoor AQI maps, outdoor pollution forecasts and outdoor air-quality alerts. And when a major smog episode arrives — particularly one caused by wildfire smoke — we hear the familiar message:</p><p>Stay indoors. Close your windows and doors.</p><p>There is an important nuance here.</p><p>Public-health agencies do have more sophisticated recommendations about indoor air quality. Organizations such as Health Canada, the EPA, the CDC and lung associations provide year-round information about ventilation, source control and air purification. As we have already seen, organizations such as ASHRAE and AHAM also provide recommendations concerning indoor air and filtration.</p><p>So the problem is not that nobody recommends ventilation or air purification.</p><p>The problem is that these pieces of information are not put together when the public needs them most.</p><p>Even under ordinary conditions, far too many homes are insufficiently ventilated and inadequately filtered. Many people do not own adequate air purifiers, do not use sufficiently effective HVAC filtration, or simply do not know much about the pollutants generated inside their homes.</p><p>A major wildfire-smoke event should therefore be an opportunity to reinforce the basics of good indoor air quality:</p><p>If air purification is important year-round, it becomes even more important now.</p><p>Outdoor particle concentrations may suddenly be many times higher than usual. More particles can infiltrate the building. The filtration capacity that may have been adequate yesterday may no longer be enough today. Depending on the building and outdoor concentrations, people may need more filtration than usual, not simply closed windows.</p><p>Yet that is rarely the message that reaches people’s ears through radio reports, newspaper headlines and short public warnings.</p><p>What gets repeated is much simpler:</p><p>The air outside is polluted. Stay inside. Close your windows.</p><p>And most of the discussion is about particles.</p><p>The missing half of the gas story</p><p>There is an additional problem when we turn from particles to gases.</p><p>Most of the time, gases are simply absent from the public conversation.</p><p>We hear about PM2.5. We see AQI numbers. We are told that wildfire smoke is unhealthy and that closing our windows will help keep the smoke outside.</p><p>When gases <em>are</em> mentioned, it is often to explain that wildfire smoke does not contain particles alone: it also contains VOCs and other potentially harmful gases.</p><p>That information is true.</p><p>But without the other half of the story, it can create a profoundly incomplete picture.</p><p>We are warned that there are dangerous gases outside, in wildfire smoke.</p><p>We are told to close our homes to protect ourselves from what is outside.</p><p>But what is absent from that same message is something we established earlier in this article: our homes contain gaseous pollutants every day. Building materials and furniture off-gas. Cleaning and personal-care products emit VOCs. Cooking and other human activities generate pollutants. Formaldehyde and other compounds can accumulate indoors.</p><p>And concentrations of many VOCs are generally higher indoors than outdoors.</p><p>That is not some obscure reason to ventilate. It is one of the fundamental reasons we need ventilation in the first place.</p><p>Yet when wildfire smoke arrives and people are specifically instructed to reduce outdoor-air exchange, this side of the equation disappears from the public message.</p><p>The gases already inside the home have not disappeared because there is smoke outside.</p><p>Their sources have not stopped emitting.</p><p>If anything, when we close the building and reduce air exchange, we have changed one of the mechanisms that normally helps dilute and remove them.</p><p>So the problem is not that telling people about gases in wildfire smoke is wrong.</p><p>The problem is that the message is incomplete.</p><p>If you tell people repeatedly that dangerous gases are coming from outside, while saying nothing at that moment about the gaseous pollutants already inside their homes and the continuing need to manage them, what mental picture should we expect people to develop?</p><p>Something like this:</p><p>Pollution is outside.</p><p>Outside air is dangerous.</p><p>My home protects me from it.</p><p>Opening the window lets the danger in.</p><p>And after hearing versions of this message repeatedly, it should hardly surprise us if that mental model survives long after the smoke is gone.</p><p>The fear doesn’t necessarily disappear with the smog</p><p>I see the same way of thinking even among people who are much more knowledgeable about indoor air quality.</p><p>Some monitor CO₂ or PM2.5 in their homes. They own good air purifiers. They understand filtration. They may know about VOCs.</p><p>And yet they can still be afraid to let outdoor air in.</p><p>There is a highway nearby.</p><p>There is a busy road outside.</p><p>There is a gas station close to the house or the school.</p><p>There is ozone outdoors.</p><p>There is benzene in vehicle emissions.</p><p>Perhaps there was wildfire smoke in the region recently.</p><p>These are not imaginary pollutants. Outdoor pollution is real, and there are circumstances in which outdoor air can absolutely be hazardous.</p><p>The mistake is something different.</p><p>It is looking carefully at every pollutant that might exist outside the window, while failing to make the same inventory on our side of the window.</p><p>Because the relevant comparison isn’t:</p><p>polluted outdoor air versus perfectly clean indoor air.</p><p>That perfectly clean indoor air doesn’t exist.</p><p>The relevant comparison is:</p><p>actual outdoor air versus actual indoor air.</p><p>And we have already established an important baseline for making that comparison: under ordinary conditions, concentrations of many VOCs are consistently higher indoors than outdoors.</p><p>This is where our perception of risk can become strangely inverted.</p><p>We can become frightened of the monster outside while sleeping with the monster already inside the house.</p><p>That doesn’t mean the monster outside can never be real. During severe outdoor pollution events, it certainly can be.</p><p>It means we need to stop assuming that the location of a pollutant tells us which exposure is greater.</p><p>“Outdoor” is not a pollutant.</p><p>And “indoor” is not a synonym for clean air.</p><p>What matters is the air we are actually breathing.</p><p>Later, we will look at what ASHRAE recommends specifically during wildfire-smoke events. Those recommendations are much more nuanced than the message that usually reaches the public. They recognize that protecting indoor air requires an actual building strategy — not simply shutting the windows and assuming that whatever remains inside is safe.</p><p>And that distinction matters.</p><p>Because “stay indoors” describes where you are. It does not tell you what you are breathing</p><p><strong><em>Seal AND Ventilate: Resolving the Apparent Contradiction</em></strong></p><p>At first glance, we seem to have a contradiction.</p><p>During a major wildfire-smoke event, outdoor air can contain extremely high concentrations of PM2.5. The public-health message is familiar:</p><p>Stay indoors. Close your windows and doors.</p><p>But as we have already seen, closing the windows does not mean that a building is sealed. In a leaky home, substantial amounts of outdoor air — and the particles it carries — can still enter through cracks, gaps and other uncontrolled pathways.</p><p>So if we really want to reduce particle infiltration, we need to go beyond simply closing the windows.</p><p>We need to reduce uncontrolled leakage.</p><p>At the same time, we have another problem: indoor-generated gases continue to accumulate and need dilution.</p><p>This is where the apparent contradiction begins:</p><p>How do we keep outdoor particles out while still bringing in enough outdoor air to dilute indoor gases?</p><p>The answer is not to choose between sealing and ventilation.</p><p>It is to seal uncontrolled pathways and ventilate intentionally.</p><p>Cracks, gaps and other leaks in a building envelope allow air to enter without our deciding where it comes from, how much enters, or whether it has been filtered.</p><p>The goal, then, is not to keep outdoor air out at all costs. The goal is to control how outdoor air enters the building.</p><p>In a well-designed approach, uncontrolled leakage is reduced by improving the building envelope. Outdoor air is then brought in intentionally through mechanical ventilation, where it can pass through an efficient particle filter — MERV 13 or higher, when the system can accommodate it — before entering the living space.</p><p>If the ventilation system also maintains the home at slight positive pressure, we gain another important advantage. Remember what we saw in the previous section: under negative pressure, cracks and gaps become uncontrolled inlets, pulling air and pollutants into the home. With slight positive pressure, the direction tends to reverse. The remaining cracks and gaps become primarily exit pathways: air tends to leak out rather than polluted air being pulled in.</p><p>Put these elements together and we have something very different from simply closing the windows:</p><p>Seal the uncontrolled pathways. Bring outdoor air in through a controlled pathway. Filter its particles. Maintain slight positive pressure.</p><p>Now the outdoor air entering the home is no longer simply whatever happens to seep through the building envelope. We have much greater control over how much comes in, where it comes in, and what happens to it before we breathe it.</p><p>And we can add another layer of protection with portable HEPA air purifiers inside the home. They continuously remove particles that still make their way indoors, as well as particles generated inside.</p><p>This is how the apparent contradiction begins to disappear.</p><p>We don’t have to choose between protecting ourselves from outdoor particles and ventilating our homes to dilute indoor gases.</p><p>We can do both.</p><p>Seal AND ventilate. Filter the air coming in. Keep the indoor space slightly positively pressurized. And supplement with portable particle air cleaners.</p><p>The objective is not an airtight box with no outdoor air. It is a building in which air exchange is intentional rather than accidental.</p><p>And interestingly, this is not merely a theoretical solution to the dilemma we have constructed. When we turn to detailed building-science guidance for wildfire smoke, this is essentially the direction ASHRAE takes.</p><p>So let’s look at what ASHRAE actually recommends.</p><p>The previous section presented a way of resolving what initially looks like a contradiction.</p><p>During wildfire smoke, outdoor PM2.5 can be extremely high, so we want to prevent those particles from entering our homes. At the same time, indoor gases still need to be diluted through ventilation.</p><p>The solution is not simply to choose between sealing and ventilating.</p><p>It is to reduce uncontrolled infiltration, bring outdoor air in through a controlled pathway, filter the particles it carries, and use pressure to help control the direction in which air moves through the remaining leaks.</p><p>This is where ASHRAE’s wildfire guidance becomes particularly interesting.<br> (source ASHRAE Guideline 44–2024, Protecting Building Occupants from Smoke During Wildfire and Prescribed Burn Events. <a href="https://www.ashrae.org/file%20library/about/government%20affairs/public%20policy%20resources/guideline-44-2024-fact-sheet.pdf">https://www.ashrae.org/file%20library/about/government%20affairs/public%20policy%20resources/guideline-44-2024-fact-sheet.pdf</a>)</p><p><em>What Guideline 44 Recommends</em></p><p>In 2024, ASHRAE published Guideline 44, <em>Protecting Building Occupants from Smoke During Wildfire and Prescribed Burn Events</em>.</p><p>Its building-design recommendations include sealing leaks in the building envelope, using MERV 13 filtration in HVAC systems, and integrating air-cleaning technologies, including portable air cleaners.</p><p>During a wildfire-smoke event, the operational recommendations include reducing outdoor airflow while maintaining positive building pressure and using air-cleaning technologies to maintain indoor air quality.</p><p>Those recommendations are worth considering together.</p><p>ASHRAE is not simply saying: <em>outdoor air is polluted, so eliminate outdoor air.</em></p><p>Instead, the strategy combines several tools:</p><p>Reduce uncontrolled infiltration.</p><p>Filter incoming air.</p><p>Use additional particle air cleaning.</p><p>Reduce outdoor airflow during severe smoke conditions.</p><p>Maintain positive pressure.</p><p>This last point is particularly important in light of the pressure problem discussed earlier. A negatively pressurized building can pull polluted air inward through cracks and gaps. Positive pressure tends to reverse that direction, making the remaining leakage paths more likely to become pathways out of the building rather than uncontrolled pathways into it.</p><p>The objective is therefore not simply to close the building.</p><p>It is to control how air moves through it.</p><p><em>What a Guideline 44 Committee Member Explains</em></p><p>The written guideline tells us what ASHRAE recommends. An ASHRAE Journal podcast provides additional insight into the reasoning behind some of those recommendations.</p><p>In the podcast <em>How to Mitigate the Effects of Wildfire Smoke</em>, Abdel Darwich, a voting member of the Guideline 44 committee, discusses the principles behind the guideline.<br> (source Ashrae Journal Podcast. <em>IAQ 46. How to Mitigate the Effects of Wildfire smoke.</em><strong> </strong><a href="https://www.ashrae.org/news/ashraejournal/ashrae-journal-podcast-episode-46"><strong>https://www.ashrae.org/news/ashraejournal/ashrae-journal-podcast-episode-46</strong></a>)</p><p>One of the first principles he emphasizes is measurement.</p><p>Darwich explains that the guideline recommends PM2.5 sensors outside and inside the building so that it is possible to see how smoke is actually migrating indoors. He also discusses pressure sensors and airflow monitoring.</p><p>His explanation of pressure is particularly straightforward. If outdoor-air supply exceeds exhaust, the building tends toward positive pressure. If the building becomes negative, it can begin pulling smoke through uncontrolled leakage pathways — what Darwich describes as effectively vacuuming the smoke inside.</p><p>This reinforces an important point made earlier in this article:</p><p>Closed windows do not tell us how air is actually moving through a building.</p><p>Pressure, leakage, ventilation and filtration do.</p><p><em>Why Not Shut Outdoor Air Off Completely?</em></p><p>The podcast also provides an important explanation of ASHRAE’s decision to recommend reducing, rather than completely eliminating, outdoor airflow during wildfire smoke.</p><p>Darwich says:</p><p><em>“We did not recommend completely shutting down outside air because we felt that if you do that, you may have buildup of contaminant inside the building, which may become more harmful than the smoke.”</em></p><p>This distinction is fundamental.</p><p>During severe wildfire smoke, reducing outdoor airflow reduces the particle load entering through the ventilation system.</p><p>But completely shutting down outdoor air creates another problem: pollutants generated inside the building continue to accumulate.</p><p>So ASHRAE’s approach is not based on the idea that outdoor air is inherently safe or inherently dangerous.</p><p>It is a balancing problem.</p><p>Too much polluted outdoor air without sufficient filtration can increase indoor PM2.5.</p><p>Too little ventilation can allow indoor contaminants to accumulate.</p><p>The goal is to manage both.</p><p><em>A General Recommendation Is Necessarily a Compromise</em></p><p>There are limits to how finely an organization such as ASHRAE can tailor a recommendation.</p><p>Guideline 44 has to apply across buildings with enormously different envelopes, ventilation systems, filtration capacities, air-cleaning capacity, occupancy and outdoor smoke concentrations.</p><p>A broad recommendation therefore needs a margin of safety.</p><p>Reducing outdoor airflow during severe wildfire smoke is a sensible general compromise: it reduces the amount of outdoor particles the building’s filtration system must handle without eliminating ventilation altogether.</p><p>But that does not mean that every building necessarily needs to reduce ventilation by the same amount — or that reducing it is automatically beneficial when indoor PM2.5 is already being successfully controlled.</p><p>Consider two buildings exposed to the same outdoor smoke.</p><p>One has limited filtration and insufficient portable air-cleaning capacity. Maintaining its normal outdoor-air ventilation rate may cause indoor PM2.5 to rise substantially. Reducing ventilation makes sense.</p><p>Another is well sealed, filters its incoming outdoor air effectively, has sufficient additional particle air-cleaning capacity, and is able to maintain very low indoor PM2.5 despite keeping the same ventilation flow as ordinary time.</p><p>The problem is different.</p><p>If filtration and air cleaning are successfully compensating for the additional particle load, maintaining more ventilation may be possible without sacrificing protection from PM2.5.</p><p>And maintaining that ventilation preserves something particle filtration cannot provide:</p><p>dilution of indoor gases.</p><p>This is where measurement allows considerably more nuance than a general recommendation can provide.</p><p>If indoor PM2.5 rises, that is evidence that the current combination of ventilation and filtration is not adequately controlling the outdoor particle load.</p><p>If indoor PM2.5 remains low, the filtration strategy is doing its job.</p><p>And if reducing ventilation is accompanied by rising indoor gaseous pollution, that is information too.</p><p>The appropriate balance therefore does not have to be guessed solely from the fact that there is wildfire smoke outside. It can be informed by what is actually happening inside the building.</p><p>That brings us naturally to the next part of the problem.</p><p>ASHRAE’s wildfire guidance gives considerable attention to measuring particles.</p><p>But particles are only one part of the air we breathe.</p><p>What about measuring gases?</p><p><strong>It’s Better to Measure Than to Guess</strong></p><p>There is a striking asymmetry in the way we approach particles and gases.</p><p>ASHRAE Guideline 44 recommends installing PM2.5 sensors both outside and inside the building to monitor the effectiveness of wildfire-smoke management strategies.</p><p>That makes perfect sense.</p><p>Instead of assuming that closing the windows has protected the indoor environment, measure PM2.5 outside. Measure it inside. See how much is getting in. See whether filtration and air cleaning are keeping indoor concentrations low. Adjust accordingly.</p><p>But there is no equivalent recommendation in Guideline 44 to monitor TVOCs or formaldehyde indoors and outdoors.</p><p>To be clear, ASHRAE does not say <em>not</em> to monitor gases. It simply does not make the equivalent recommendation here.</p><p>And this matters because, as we have seen throughout this article, particles are only part of the air-quality problem.</p><p>If the decision to reduce ventilation is partly based on the possibility that gaseous pollution is higher outdoors during wildfire smoke, an obvious question follows:</p><p>How do we know whether it actually is?</p><p>Without measurement, we don’t.</p><p>We know that wildfire smoke contains gases. We know that traffic and industry emit gases. But we also know that homes contain many sources of gaseous pollutants and that VOC concentrations are generally higher indoors than outdoors under ordinary conditions.</p><p>Knowing that a source exists outside does not tell us which side of the wall currently has the higher gaseous-pollution burden.</p><p><em>The Same Blind Spot in Healthy Buildings</em></p><p>This hesitation around consumer gas monitoring is not unique to ASHRAE.</p><p>In <em>Healthy Buildings</em>, Joseph Allen and John Macomber strongly recommend continuous real-time monitoring of indoor air quality:</p><p>“Air quality in a building can change frequently […] so we strongly recommend continuously monitoring air quality in real time, supplemented with more traditional ‘industrial hygiene’ assessment methods.”</p><p>But look at the parameters they specifically recommend monitoring continuously:</p><p>“This includes carbon dioxide, temperature, relative humidity, and particles…”</p><p>TVOCs and formaldehyde are not included.</p><p>Again, the authors do not tell readers not to monitor them continuously. They simply do not recommend it. For VOCs, they instead point toward periodic professional sampling using validated methods capable of identifying and measuring specific compounds.</p><p>There are good scientific reasons for that caution.</p><p>Low-cost gas sensors have important limitations. They cannot identify the hundreds of individual gases that may be present in indoor air. Their absolute readings may be inaccurate. They can suffer from cross-sensitivities. A TVOC number should certainly not be confused with a laboratory analysis telling us exactly which compounds are present and at what concentrations.</p><p>But this leaves an important practical gap.</p><p>Professional testing can provide much better information about what is in the air.</p><p>It cannot realistically tell most people, hour by hour, whether opening a window right now is causing their overall gaseous-pollution indicator to rise or fall.</p><p>And that is a different question.</p><p><em>A Suggestion of My Own</em></p><p>So here I am going one step beyond what these sources explicitly recommend.</p><p>This is not an ASHRAE recommendation. I am not an indoor-air-quality professional. It is my own proposal: use inexpensive TVOC and formaldehyde sensors as additional information, while understanding their limitations.</p><p>Not as laboratory instruments.</p><p>Not to determine precisely which gases are present.</p><p>Not to establish an exact health risk from a particular reading.</p><p>But as real-time indicators that can help reveal changes and guide cautious action.</p><p>Suppose there is wildfire smoke hundreds or thousands of kilometres away and the question is whether gaseous pollution is currently higher outdoors or indoors.</p><p>Without any measurement, one can only assume.</p><p>With low-cost sensors, the information is imperfect — but at least there is information.</p><p>The relevant question may not always be:</p><p>“Is this TVOC measurement exactly correct?”</p><p>Sometimes the more practical question is:</p><p>“What happens to the reading when outdoor air enters the house?”</p><p>Does it rise?</p><p>Does it fall?</p><p>What happens when ventilation is increased?</p><p>What happens when it is reduced?</p><p>And how does that compare with what PM2.5 is doing at the same time?</p><p>For many day-to-day decisions, direction and trend may be more useful than knowing the exact concentration of every compound in the air.</p><p><strong><em>Low-Cost Gas Sensors: Imperfect Information Is Still Information</em></strong></p><p>The obvious objection is that inexpensive gas sensors are imperfect.</p><p>They are.</p><p>But imperfect does not necessarily mean useless.</p><p>Maria Justo Alonso et al. evaluated the low-cost DART formaldehyde WZ-S sensor against a reference instrument. Both the low-cost sensor and the reference sensor showed cross-sensitivities to some VOCs released by the tested sources, and the low-cost sensor sometimes overestimated and sometimes underestimated concentrations relative to the reference sensor.</p><p>Yet something interesting happened.</p><p>The two instruments showed very similar dynamic responses.</p><p>In other words, despite its limitations in determining the exact concentration, the low-cost sensor was able to detect changes.</p><p>The researchers concluded that these sensors have the potential to be used in indoor environments as Tier III supplemental monitoring, particularly for triggering appropriate controls.</p><p>That distinction is extremely important.</p><p>A sensor can be poor at answering:</p><p>“Exactly how many micrograms per cubic metre of formaldehyde are in this room?”</p><p>while still providing useful information about:</p><p>“Something has changed.”</p><p>or:</p><p>“The reading is rising.”</p><p>or:</p><p>“When ventilation increases, the reading falls rapidly.”</p><p>That is a very different standard of usefulness.</p><p><em>What Are We Doing While We Wait?</em></p><p>As is often the case in science, the conclusion of the DART study is appropriately cautious: the technology <em>has potential</em>. Better accuracy is desirable. More research is needed.</p><p>Of course it is.</p><p>But there is another question that deserves attention:</p><p>What are we doing while we wait?</p><p>There is a tendency to place the burden of proof on action. Before recommending an imperfect sensor, we want evidence that it is sufficiently accurate and beneficial.</p><p>But we do not necessarily place the same burden of proof on inaction.</p><p>Yet doing nothing is also a choice.</p><p>The relevant comparison is therefore not necessarily:</p><p>Is this low-cost sensor perfectly accurate?</p><p>It may instead be:</p><p>Given what we currently know, are we better off having imperfect real-time information and acting cautiously on it — or having no real-time information about gases at all?</p><p>We already know that VOCs and formaldehyde can represent real indoor-air-quality concerns. The uncertainty is not whether gaseous indoor pollution exists. The uncertainty is how accurately inexpensive consumer sensors can quantify it.</p><p>And waiting for laboratory-quality consumer sensors has a cost too.</p><p>Without any gaseous monitoring, a person deciding whether to ventilate during an outdoor pollution event may be making that decision largely blind.</p><p><em>The Cost of Being Wrong Goes Both Ways</em></p><p>Of course, acting on an imperfect sensor can produce false positives.</p><p>A reading may cause someone to ventilate when it was not necessary. That may increase heating or air-conditioning costs. It may temporarily make the home warmer or colder. And during an outdoor particle-pollution event, additional ventilation may introduce PM2.5 that then has to be removed through filtration and air cleaning.</p><p>Those are real trade-offs.</p><p>But there is also a cost to the opposite error.</p><p>If gaseous pollution is accumulating indoors and we assume the outdoor air is more dangerous simply because wildfire smoke, traffic or another outdoor source exists, we may reduce ventilation precisely when outdoor air could be diluting those indoor pollutants.</p><p>So uncertainty exists in both directions.</p><p>This is why measuring indoor and outdoor conditions can be useful.</p><p>Not because a $100 sensor suddenly turns a home into an analytical chemistry laboratory.</p><p>Because it gives us another piece of information with which to make a decision.</p><p><em>A Sensor Can Trigger Action Without Explaining Everything</em></p><p>There is another benefit to thinking of these devices as action-triggering instruments rather than laboratory instruments.</p><p>If a TVOC or formaldehyde indicator rises substantially, ventilation can be increased and the response observed.</p><p>If the reading falls rapidly, that is useful information.</p><p>At the same time, PM2.5 can be monitored independently and sufficient particle filtration used to keep particle concentrations low.</p><p>The two problems do not have to be confused.</p><p>And increasing ventilation in response to elevated gaseous pollution does not dilute only whatever VOC happens to be triggering the sensor.</p><p>Outdoor-air ventilation also dilutes other indoor-generated pollutants the sensor may not detect at all, including radon and many other gases.</p><p>That is an important point.</p><p>The sensor does not need to see everything to help trigger an intervention that affects much more than what the sensor can see.</p><p>This is essentially a pragmatic application of the precautionary principle: use the best information currently available, understand its limitations, and act conservatively when the intervention itself has acceptable costs.</p><p>A low-cost sensor is not the final word on indoor gaseous pollution.</p><p>It is an instrument.</p><p>And sometimes an imperfect instrument is more useful than flying blind.</p><p><strong><em>The Information Gap: Searching for Culprits, Missing the Basics</em></strong></p><p>People who care deeply about indoor air quality are often among the most informed people in the room. They monitor particles, buy air purifiers, read about pollution and try hard to reduce their exposure.</p><p>Yet in online air-quality communities, I repeatedly see another pattern.</p><p>Someone notices an odor and becomes worried about what mysterious chemical might be causing it. Someone else tries to determine which particular gas might be affecting them or their child. Others worry about traffic, wildfire smoke, a nearby gas station, an industrial facility or some other potential outdoor source.</p><p>The questions become increasingly specific:</p><p>What gas could this be? Where is it coming from? Is it benzene? Formaldehyde? Ozone? Something else?</p><p>Meanwhile, a much more basic question is sometimes missing:</p><p>What is the overall air quality in the home, and is the home being adequately ventilated?</p><p>Sometimes people describe staying inside with the windows closed while trying to identify the source of an odor. They may have excellent particle filtration, yet say nothing about outdoor-air ventilation, CO₂ or gaseous-pollution monitoring.</p><p>This is not surprising.</p><p>We have spent years teaching people to worry about outdoor air pollution. During wildfire smoke, the message becomes even stronger: stay indoors and close the windows.</p><p>At the same time, PM2.5 monitoring has become inexpensive, more widely discussed and increasingly recommended. But inexpensive monitoring of gaseous pollution remains largely absent from mainstream guidance, or treated so cautiously that many people are left with no practical information at all.</p><p>The result can be a strange situation:</p><p>We worry about gases we cannot identify while not measuring the gaseous pollution we can at least observe.</p><p>And we start playing detective. And guessing.</p><p>Of course, identifying and eliminating a specific source is valuable whenever possible. If there is a known source of formaldehyde, benzene or another harmful pollutant in the home, removing that source is better than continuously diluting its emissions.</p><p>But when the source is unknown, or when hundreds of different gaseous compounds may be present, trying to identify every molecule before taking action can become a distraction from the fundamentals.</p><p>Ventilation does not need to know the name of the gas.</p><p>It dilutes and removes indoor-generated gaseous pollutants regardless of whether we have identified them.</p><p>Think of a glass of water that we know is contaminated. Suppose we discover that it contains ten different pollutants. Then someone tells us there is an eleventh one.</p><p>Does that necessarily change what we need to do?</p><p>If our strategy is to empty the contaminated water and replace it with clean water, the eleventh pollutant does not require an eleventh solution. It leaves with the contaminated water, just like the others.</p><p>Ventilation works on the same basic principle. We don’t need to identify every gas in indoor air before ventilation can dilute and remove it. The outgoing air carries whatever pollutants it contains: VOCs we know about, gases we haven’t identified, radon, particles and pollutants our sensors may not even detect.</p><p>Of course, a home is not literally a glass of water. Pollutants continue to be generated indoors, outdoor air can introduce pollutants of its own, and ventilation continuously mixes and dilutes the air rather than emptying a room all at once. What matters is whether cleaner air is being supplied at a sufficient rate relative to the pollutants being generated or introduced.</p><p>But the basic principle remains: discovering one more pollutant in the air does not necessarily create one more problem to solve individually.</p><p>Sometimes the solution is not to become a better detective. It is to replace enough of the polluted air with cleaner air.</p><p>Sometimes the solution is not to become a better detective. It is to replace enough of the polluted air with cleaner air.</p><p>And before fine-tuning anything, there are basics.</p><p>ASHRAE and AHAM already provide minimum recommendations for ventilation and particle removal. Yet many homes do not even meet those basic recommendations.</p><p>That distinction matters. Monitoring is not a substitute for the basics. It is what can help us verify and fine-tune once the basics are in place.</p><p>If tomorrow morning every home suddenly had adequate baseline ventilation and sufficient particle filtration or air cleaning — even without a single TVOC monitor — we would already have made an enormous improvement in the air people breathe and, consequently, in public health.</p><p>This is where the contrast I see in online discussions can be striking. People sometimes search for increasingly specific explanations — <em>Which gas is this? Could this particular chemical explain my symptoms? Is there an obscure source somewhere in my home or neighborhood?</em> — while their posts suggest that the basic recommendations for ventilation and particle removal may not yet be in place.</p><p>There is nothing wrong with wanting to go further. If the fundamentals are covered and someone wants to investigate a particular pollutant, identify additional sources, or optimize an already well-controlled indoor environment, that is fine-tuning.</p><p>The problem is when fine-tuning comes before the fundamentals.</p><p>Monitoring does not solve everything either. A low-cost TVOC sensor cannot tell us exactly what we are breathing.</p><p>But it can give us another piece of information about what the air is doing.</p><p>And perhaps that is a healthier way to approach indoor air quality: start with the fundamentals, then measure, observe and fine-tune — less fear of individual invisible pollutants, less guessing about what might be there, and more attention to the basic conditions we can actually observe and control.</p><p>Ventilate. Filter. Measure. Then fine-tune.</p><p><strong>Conclusion — The Forgotten Half of the Air We Breathe</strong></p><p>Indoor air quality is still too often the forgotten child of public health. And within indoor air quality, gaseous pollutants may be the forgotten child of the forgotten child.</p><p>Air-quality monitoring, smog alerts and public-health messaging remain heavily focused on outdoor pollution and, during wildfire events, on fine particles.</p><p>Particles deserve that attention. PM2.5 can travel enormous distances, infiltrate buildings and cause serious harm. We have increasingly good tools to measure it and increasingly effective ways to remove it from indoor air.</p><p>But particles are not all we breathe.</p><p>Every day, our homes continuously generate gaseous pollutants from building materials, furniture, cooking, cleaning products, personal-care products, combustion and countless other sources. Many of these pollutants cannot be effectively removed by ordinary particle filtration, and carbon filtration has important limitations.</p><p>For gases, ventilation remains fundamental.</p><p>And this is where the apparent contradiction at the heart of this article disappears.</p><p>We do not have to choose between protecting ourselves from outdoor particles and protecting ourselves from indoor gaseous pollution.</p><p>It is not particles OR gases. It is particles AND gases.</p><p>Seal uncontrolled leaks. Bring outdoor air in through controlled ventilation. Filter that incoming air when necessary. Use sufficient particle filtration and portable air cleaners. Avoid negative pressure and, when possible, maintain positive pressure during severe outdoor pollution events. Reduce outdoor-air intake when conditions truly require it — but remember what may be accumulating indoors.</p><p>And measure what we reasonably can.</p><p>ASHRAE already recommends indoor and outdoor PM2.5 monitoring during wildfire-smoke events. Low-cost monitoring of gaseous pollution remains much less established and much less discussed. The instruments are imperfect. They cannot tell us exactly what mixture of gases we are breathing.</p><p>But uncertainty is not a reason to replace measurement with assumption.</p><p>Six years after Messier and colleagues called for gas-phase pollutants to be included in air-pollution risk assessment, this blind spot remains.</p><p>And it matters increasingly.</p><p>Wildfire-smoke events are not a problem we can afford to think about only when the sky turns orange. Preparing buildings to handle outdoor pollution while maintaining healthy indoor air requires thinking about ventilation, filtration, airtightness, pressure and monitoring before the crisis arrives.</p><p>The minimum recommendations already exist. If more homes simply met basic ventilation and particle-removal recommendations, the air people breathe would already be substantially better. Monitoring can then help us verify, adjust and fine-tune.</p><p>What we need is not fear of outdoor air, nor complacency about indoor air.</p><p>We need to stop thinking of one side of the wall as <em>polluted</em> and the other as <em>safe</em>.</p><p>The relevant comparison is actual outdoor air versus actual indoor air.</p><p>Conditions change. Sources change. Wildfire smoke comes and goes. Cooking happens. Products are used. Buildings breathe — or fail to breathe. No single assumption can tell us which air is cleaner at every moment.</p><p>Our lungs do not distinguish between the pollutants that receive public attention and the ones that don’t.</p><p>The gases may be the forgotten half of the air we breathe. But our lungs breathe them anyway.</p><p>And perhaps that is the simplest message of this article:</p><p>Ventilate. Filter. Measure. Adjust.</p><p>Protect against particles. Dilute gases.</p><p>We can, and should, do both.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccafbd7d785b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wildfire Smog: Is “Close the Windows” Always the Right Advice?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/wildfire-smog-is-close-the-windows-always-the-right-advice-b6231d11f458?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6231d11f458</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[air-monitoring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-pollution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wildfire-smoke]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Jul 2026 02:49:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-23T02:49:09.426Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/812/1*ynuNW4QAlPVwAL4wYO1ViQ.png" /></figure><p>Every time wildfire smoke rolls in, we hear the same advice: close the windows and stay inside.</p><p>It gets repeated so often that it has almost become automatic. Smoke outside means windows closed. End of story.</p><p>But I don’t think it should be that simple.</p><p>What worries me is the image of families trying to protect themselves by sealing the house completely, without having any idea what the air is already like inside.</p><p>Imagine a newer home that is fairly airtight, with very little natural air coming in through cracks. A family with two children is cooking dinner. They cook often, without a range hood. Meat, oil, high heat, maybe an older nonstick pan that was never really meant to be used that way.</p><p>Nothing dramatic. Nothing unusual. Just a normal evening.</p><p>By the time dinner is over, indoor PM2.5 has reached 200 µg/m³.</p><p>Nobody knows.</p><p>Like most people, they don’t monitor the air inside their home.</p><p>Then the wildfire smoke alert comes in. Outdoor PM2.5 is at 100 µg/m³.</p><p>The parents look at their children, close every window, and decide to stay inside because they believe the indoor air must be safer.</p><p>But in this case, the particle level inside is already twice as high as it is outside.</p><p>That is the part we rarely talk about.</p><p>The house may also already have elevated VOC levels from cooking, cleaning products, furniture, flooring, carpets or other materials. CO₂ may be climbing too, especially in a small, airtight home with several people inside.</p><p>Now the family seals everything up even more.</p><p>They are trying to do the right thing. They are following the advice they were given. But without knowing what is happening indoors, they may actually be making part of the problem worse.</p><p>How airtight is your home?</p><p>Very airtight? Moderately airtight? A little leaky? Extremely leaky?</p><p>Most people have no idea.</p><p>And yet that matters a lot.</p><p>When a radio host or public health announcement tells everyone to stay inside and close the windows, it has no way of knowing what the air is like in your particular house.</p><p>For particle pollution, there are a few different possibilities.</p><p>In a leaky home, a large amount of outdoor smoke may still get inside even when the windows are closed. Depending on the building, more than half of the outdoor particles may eventually infiltrate.</p><p>Then you add what is being produced indoors: cooking, cigarette smoke, candles, essential oil diffusers, certain appliances, a neighbour’s smoke, and other everyday sources.</p><p>In some homes, indoor PM2.5 may end up higher than outdoor PM2.5.</p><p>The only way to really know is to measure both. Fortunately, affordable air quality monitors are now within reach for most households.</p><p>Ideally, you would use the same monitor, compare indoor and outdoor readings, and check them around the same time.</p><p>But particles are only one part of indoor air quality.</p><p>Good indoor air is not just air with low PM2.5.</p><p>You also want CO₂ and VOC levels to stay reasonably low. And for that, at some point, you need outdoor air coming in.</p><p>Outdoor air usually contains fewer VOCs than indoor air, unless you are very close to an active fire or another major pollution source. In most homes, VOCs are being produced indoors all day long.</p><p>Cooking. Cleaning products. Fragrances. Furniture. Paint. Flooring. Personal care products. Building materials.</p><p>When the house stays closed for hours or days, those gases can build up.</p><p>Anyone who uses a TVOC monitor has probably seen this. You cook, clean, shower, use a scented product, or simply keep the house closed for a long time, and the numbers rise.</p><p>The same is true for CO₂. In an occupied home with little ventilation, it can climb well above 1,000 ppm and sometimes beyond 3,000 ppm. At those levels, people may feel tired, foggy or headachy.</p><p>This is why the message “close your windows and stay inside” is incomplete.</p><p>Closing the windows for a short period during the worst smoke conditions may reduce the amount of particles entering your home.</p><p>But what happens when the smoke lasts for a week?</p><p>Or two weeks?</p><p>Or even longer?</p><p>Is the plan really to keep millions of people sealed inside their homes for that entire time?</p><p>Because Indoor VOCs don’t stop accumulating.</p><p>And neither do all the pollutants we generate ourselves by simply living in our homes.</p><p>Closing the windows isn’t a strategy.</p><p>It’s only one piece of a much bigger problem.</p><p>Wildfire smoke is no longer a rare event in many places. With climate change, these episodes are becoming more frequent, more intense and sometimes longer-lasting.</p><p>We need a strategy that works for days and weeks, not just for a few hours.</p><p>Air purifiers can play an important role. Properly sized for the room, they are very effective at removing fine particles and can help keep indoor PM2.5 low.</p><p>But particles are only part of the picture.</p><p>Outdoor air is not necessarily cleaner than indoor air. It may contain more PM2.5 during a wildfire, but it contains far less CO₂ and usually far fewer indoor-generated VOCs. That is why ventilation and filtration are complementary, not competing, strategies.</p><p>The goal is not simply to keep smoke out.</p><p>The goal is to achieve the best overall indoor air quality.</p><p>Sometimes, keeping the windows closed will be the better decision.</p><p>Sometimes, bringing in outdoor air will be the better decision.</p><p>The point is not to assume that one choice is always better than the other.</p><p>The point is to compare indoor and outdoor air quality, then choose the option that gives you the healthiest indoor environment overall.</p><p>That is why monitoring matters.</p><p>Low-cost air quality monitors have improved dramatically in recent years. It is now possible to monitor PM2.5, CO₂ and TVOCs at home without spending a fortune.</p><p>We already think it is normal to own a thermometer.</p><p>One day, it will feel just as normal to know the PM2.5 and CO₂ levels in your home.</p><p>Once you have those numbers, your decisions become much more informed.</p><p>Maybe you need to run an air purifier.</p><p>Maybe you need to bring in outdoor air.</p><p>Maybe you need to close the windows.</p><p>Maybe you need to do more than one of those things.</p><p>The measurements, not a universal rule, should guide your decisions.</p><p>Homes are different.</p><p>Buildings are different.</p><p>Families are different.</p><p>Indoor pollution is different.</p><p>Outdoor pollution is different.</p><p>So why should every household receive exactly the same advice?</p><p>Closing the windows may sometimes be the right decision.</p><p>But it should never become a mantra.</p><p>Measure first. Decide second.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6231d11f458" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Single-Hose Portable ACs: The Overlooked Problem
 How a DIY FantaMix, bringing in filtered fresh…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/single-hose-portable-acs-the-overlooked-problem-how-a-diy-fantamix-bringing-in-filtered-fresh-02707fc01015?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/02707fc01015</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[portable-air-conditioner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home-ventilation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy-projects]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[single-hose-ac]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jun 2026 02:08:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-29T00:57:07.845Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Single-Hose Portable ACs: The Overlooked Problem<br> How a DIY FantaMix, bringing in filtered fresh air, can be adapted to help</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PLjCZ24PrDXU_pFvW2UgTA.png" /></figure><p>You bought a single-hose portable air conditioner, or you’re thinking about it. It cools, it was affordable, and it was easy to set up.</p><p>But do you know what it’s doing to the air in your home while it runs?</p><p>To cool, this type of unit pushes air out of your home. And that air has to be replaced, so your home pulls it back in through every crack and gap, unfiltered, straight from outside.</p><p>Most of us think about cooling, noise, or price. Far less about this quiet effect on the air we breathe.</p><p>And it matters most at the worst moment: during a smog or wildfire event, when the air being sucked in is exactly what you don’t want inside.</p><p>The good news: there’s a simple, DIY way to regain some control.</p><p><strong>How a Single-Hose Portable AC Works</strong></p><p>A single-hose portable air conditioner sits inside your room, with one flexible hose running to a window.</p><p>It draws in air from the room, cools it, and blows it back out into the room. To get rid of the heat it removes, it uses some of that indoor air to carry the heat away, then pushes it outside through the hose.</p><p>That’s the key point: air is constantly being expelled from your home, but nothing is brought back in through the unit to replace it.</p><p>So your home has to make up for the air that’s leaving. It does this the only way it can: by pulling air in from outside through any opening it can find, cracks around windows and doors, vents, gaps in the structure.</p><p>This imbalance is called negative pressure. In the next section, we’ll look at what it actually does to your indoor air.</p><p><strong>The Problem With Excessive Negative Pressure</strong></p><p>So why does this matter?</p><p>The real issue is control. The air pulled in through the cracks is air you have no control over. You don’t choose where it comes from, you don’t choose what’s in it, and you don’t choose its temperature.</p><p>Compare this with a controlled ventilation system. An HRV, for example, brings in outdoor air in a controlled way, and tempers it through heat recovery so it doesn’t enter at full outdoor temperature. A recirculating AC (window, mini-split, or dual-hose) can be paired with mechanical ventilation, or a simple DIY setup, to achieve something similar: controlled, filtered air.</p><p>(If you have one of those other AC types, <a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/what-your-air-conditioner-does-to-your-homes-air-quality-a-guide-to-making-an-informed-choice-74a373ff18ba">this article</a> looks at what each one does to your indoor air, and how to ventilate alongside it.</p><p>A single-hose AC is different. It already ventilates, in a sense, but in the worst possible way: under negative pressure, pulling air in through gaps. That air is uncontrolled on every front. It isn’t filtered, so during smog it carries fine particles (PM2.5) straight inside. And it isn’t tempered, so it enters at full outdoor temperature.</p><p>That’s the heart of it: the very moment you most want control over the air entering your home, a single-hose AC gives you none.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*lWlOYWom2PSazDGzVnRCGQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Negative pressure pulls air into the home from outside and neighboring units</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>A Possible Approach: Compensating for Negative Pressure</strong></p><p>If the problem is uncontrolled air being pulled in under negative pressure, then the logical response is to take back at least part of that control, by giving your home a deliberate source of filtered air to draw from.</p><p>The key word is <em>part</em>. You won’t fully cancel out the negative pressure created by a single-hose AC, those units move a lot of air. And this isn’t heat recovery: the air you bring in isn’t recovering energy. But you can compensate for some of the negative pressure, and above all, you can filter the air you bring in on purpose, instead of letting it seep in unfiltered through the cracks.</p><p>Every bit of filtered air you bring in deliberately is air your home doesn’t have to pull in blindly through the gaps. During a smog event, that means fewer particles getting inside.</p><p>This is where a DIY FantaMix can come in. It’s not the only way to bring in filtered air, and it isn’t the perfect solution, it has its own strengths and trade-offs compared to other options. But it’s accessible, affordable, and well suited to this particular situation. Let’s look at why.</p><p><strong>How a FantaMix Can Help</strong></p><p>The FantaMix was introduced in detail in the <a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/fantamix-review-983bc64a1344">FantaMix Review</a>.</p><p>In short, the FantaMix is a compact, DIY ventilation system released under an <a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/building-the-fantamix-fresh-filtered-air-at-home-no-exhaust-under-200-13242b9ac323">open-source license</a>. It consists of an indoor unit connected to a short duct installed in a window. It draws in a mix of fresh outdoor air and stale indoor air (without active exhaust), then filters this mixture through an H11 HEPA filter. It is a hybrid device: both a source of fresh air and an indoor air purifier.</p><p>So how does this fit the single-hose AC situation?</p><p>The FantaMix brings air <em>into</em> the home, in positive pressure. A single-hose AC pushes air <em>out</em>, creating negative pressure. The two work in opposite directions, and that’s exactly the point: the FantaMix pushes back against the depressurization the AC creates.</p><p>It helps in two ways here.</p><p>First, it compensates for part of the negative pressure. Every cubic foot of air the FantaMix delivers is air your home no longer has to pull in through the cracks. You won’t fully neutralize a single-hose AC this way, but you reduce how hard your home is sucking air in through every gap.</p><p>Second, the FantaMix filters air through a HEPA H11 filter, and it does so in two ways at once. It filters the fresh outdoor air it brings in. And because it also recirculates a portion of indoor air through that same HEPA filter, it works partly as an air purifier. This second function matters a lot in this situation: since a single-hose AC will keep pulling some unfiltered air in through the cracks, bringing fine particles (PM2.5) with it, the FantaMix can capture part of those particles as it recirculates and cleans the indoor air. It doesn’t stop the infiltration, but it offsets some of it by filtering the air on the inside.</p><p>The result isn’t perfect balance, but it’s a meaningful shift: less uncontrolled infiltration, and some of the particles that do get in are filtered back out.</p><p><strong>How Is This Different From a Fan in the Window?</strong></p><p>You may already know the popular trick of putting a fan in a window, sometimes with a filter attached, even a HEPA one. Thousands of people around the world use this approach, especially during wildfire smoke events. It works, and it’s a great low-cost idea. On filtration alone, a window fan fitted with a good HEPA filter does much the same job as a FantaMix.</p><p>So where does the FantaMix differ?</p><p>The difference comes down to how the window is handled. A fan placed <em>in</em> the open window can’t safely stay there through changing weather: rain is a real problem, both for fire and electrical-shock risk. To avoid that, some people instead set the fan <em>near</em> the window rather than in it. That solves the rain issue and can be left in place, but it creates another: the window has to stay open for the air to pass, and an open window can’t be sealed. So unfiltered outdoor air, and the particles it carries during smog, keeps coming in around the fan.</p><p>The FantaMix is designed to close that gap, literally. It connects to the outside through a sealed duct passing through a fitted window panel, so the rest of the window opening is properly closed off. You get a setup that can stay in place through the season, without rain risk, and without leaving the window open to uncontrolled, unfiltered air.</p><p>None of this makes the simple window-fan approaches wrong. They’re solid, accessible options. The FantaMix simply handles the window itself more tightly, which is exactly what helps during a smog event.</p><p><strong>A Specific Case: Monica</strong></p><p>Monica is 70. She lives alone in a 600-square-foot, two-bedroom apartment in a rental building.</p><p>Money is tight, and her health is fragile: she has COPD and cardiac issues, which makes her especially sensitive to air pollution, and leaves her with limited physical energy.</p><p>For cooling, she uses a 5,000 BTU single-hose portable AC, installed in her bedroom. It was the practical choice. A relative helps her, and a portable unit is simpler to set up than a window AC. It also takes up less of the window and blocks less of the view, which matters to her.</p><p>Recently, a friend gave her a low-cost PM2.5 monitor, and she started keeping an eye on her readings. She was puzzled to see that fine-particle levels were sometimes high indoors, even with all her windows closed. What she didn’t know was that her single-hose AC was creating negative pressure in her apartment, pulling unfiltered outdoor air, and its particles, in through every gap. That negative pressure was part of the explanation for those puzzling indoor spikes.</p><p>At medium, her AC pulls roughly 180 CFM of air out of the apartment (an approximate figure). To push back against that, Monica sets up two FantaMix units, with help from a friend: one in her bedroom, and one in the second bedroom she uses for storage.</p><p>Fitting both hoses in the same bedroom window took a bit of planning. Her window is 38 inches high. Monica made a panel of polystyrene covered in aluminum foil, 8 inches wide and 38 inches tall, to fit the opening. The FantaMix duct (6 inches across) passes through the lower part of the panel, while the AC hose exits near the top of the window. Placing the AC hose up high also makes sense because hot air rises: the heat it pushes out tends to move upward, away from the FantaMix intake below. That leaves at least 20 inches between the two, and the FantaMix duct is angled downward as well. Keeping them far apart matters: it limits the chance of the FantaMix drawing in the hot air the AC has just pushed out.</p><p>She runs them like this: the FantaMix in the storage room stays at maximum (68 CFM, 47 dBA). The one in her bedroom runs at low at night (27 CFM, 37 dBA), quiet enough for sleep, and at maximum during the day (68 CFM, 47 dBA). That gives her about 95 CFM of filtered outdoor air at night, and 136 CFM during the day.</p><p>This doesn’t fully cancel the negative pressure from her AC, which still pulls more air than the two FantaMix units bring in. But it compensates for a good part of it. Less air is now being sucked in uncontrolled through the cracks, and a meaningful share of the air entering her home is HEPA-filtered instead.</p><p>On top of that, both FantaMix units continuously recirculate and clean some of her indoor air. Each one has a measured CADR of about 52 CFM at maximum, so during the day, with both at full power, that’s roughly 104 CFM of purification working inside her home. At night it’s lower, since her bedroom unit runs at low, but the storage-room unit alone still adds at least 52 CFM.</p><p>As for noise, what matters is what’s running in the same room as her. The storage-room unit is far enough away that she barely hears it. In her bedroom, the AC is already the louder machine, and at night her FantaMix is set lower than the AC anyway, so it doesn’t add meaningfully to the sound she lives with</p><p>For Monica, this isn’t about achieving perfect balance. It’s about taking back some control: fewer uncontrolled particles coming in, cleaner air in the rooms where she spends her time, and a setup she can manage despite limited energy and a tight budget.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*ciPiSwzSYgNzKc1K7N95YA.png" /><figcaption><em>FantaMix Spec Sheet — Performance at Level 3/9 and Maximum</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Taking Back Some Control From Your Single-Hose AC</strong></p><p>A single-hose portable air conditioner cools, and for many people it’s the simplest, most affordable way to get through a heat wave. But it comes with a hidden cost: by pushing air out of your home, it pulls unfiltered outdoor air back in through every crack, and during a smog or wildfire event, that means outdoor particles getting inside exactly when you want them out.</p><p>A FantaMix doesn’t make that problem disappear. It won’t fully balance the pressure a single-hose AC creates. But it shifts things in the right direction: it compensates for part of the negative pressure, it brings in air that’s HEPA-filtered on purpose, and it cleans some of the indoor air as it runs. For someone already using a single-hose AC, that’s a realistic way to take back some control over what they’re breathing.</p><p>With heat waves intensifying and smoke events becoming more frequent, more people are reaching for portable air conditioners. Knowing what they do to your indoor air, and what you can do about it, is worth the effort. A FantaMix is one accessible, DIY way to make a single-hose AC a little easier to live with.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=02707fc01015" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Room Size Illusion: 
 When Air Purifier Claims Hide the ACH]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-room-size-illusion-when-air-purifier-claims-hide-the-ach-a45d8296b757?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a45d8296b757</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[consumer-protection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-purifier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jun 2026 21:39:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-07T21:39:49.149Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*dEO4BlLYpefJmGo_nXZg8g.png" /></figure><p><em>Have you ever shopped for an air purifier and compared room size claims?</em></p><p><em>Perhaps one model claimed to clean 3,100 square feet, while another claimed only 645 square feet. Faced with those numbers, most people would naturally assume that the first machine is far more powerful.</em></p><p><em>But what if the difference has less to do with the machine itself and more to do with a hidden assumption?</em></p><p><em>That assumption is called the Air Changes per Hour (ACH) rate. The lower the ACH used in the calculation, the larger the advertised room size will appear.</em></p><p><em>This article explores how room size claims can be inflated by using lower ACH values, why that matters, and why room size ratings should always be accompanied by the ACH used to calculate them. It also argues that, by default, room size claims should be based on the approximately 4.8 ACH benchmark used by AHAM, one of the most influential organizations in the air purifier industry.</em></p><p><strong>The Air Purifier Jungle: When Room Size Claims Hide the ACH</strong></p><p>The air purifier and ventilation market can be a jungle for consumers. Marketing claims and specification sheets are often incomplete, confusing, or sometimes even misleading.</p><p>As a result, comparing products and selecting the one that best meets our needs can feel like navigating an obstacle course.</p><p>This article is the third in a series on specification sheet clarity and transparency.</p><p>The first article examined the practice of advertising CADR at maximum speed while pairing it with noise levels measured at minimum speed — a combination that provides little useful information about real-world performance.<em> <br> </em><a href="https://medium.com/its-airborne/the-challenge-of-finding-clear-and-honest-specs-on-air-purifiers-and-air-exchangers-acf10c0cc4bb"><em>Unclear Specs on Air Cleaners Useful information can be challenging to find</em></a></p><p>The second article explored the confusion created when some manufacturers display CADR in m³/h while others use CFM, making product comparisons unnecessarily difficult.<br> <a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/consumers-shouldnt-need-a-conversion-calculator-to-compare-air-purifiers-91581c9ff0e2"><em>Consumers Shouldn’t Need a Conversion Calculator to Compare Air Purifiers: Why Air Purifier CADR Should Be Reported in CFM</em></a></p><p>This third article focuses on what I call the room size illusion.</p><p>Room size is often presented as a simple and intuitive metric. Yet in practice, it may create more confusion than clarity. Depending on the manufacturer, the advertised room size may be calculated using very different Air Changes per Hour (ACH) assumptions — and the ACH used is often not disclosed.</p><p>The examples presented in this article range from 1 ACH for the AirFanta 3Pro, to 2 ACH for the Medify MA-112, 3.5 ACH for Smart Air, and 4.8 ACH for the Levoit Core® 300S-P.</p><p>The lower the ACH used in the calculation, the larger the advertised room size becomes. As a result, room size claims are often not directly comparable from one manufacturer to another.</p><p>In practice, manufacturers are often deciding for consumers what level of air cleaning is “good enough” without clearly disclosing that choice. Yet organizations such as AHAM and the CDC recommend approximately 4.8 to 5 ACH.</p><p>If a manufacturer believes that a lower ACH is sufficient, that position can certainly be discussed. The problem is that consumers are often not told that the advertised room size is based on a lower ACH in the first place.</p><p>The result is a marketplace where larger room size claims can create the impression of superior performance, even when the difference is largely explained by the ACH used in the calculation. Consumers may end up making decisions based on room size figures that are not directly comparable, while manufacturers using lower ACH assumptions gain a competitive advantage over those using higher standards.</p><p><strong>Why ACH Matters</strong></p><p>Before discussing room size claims, it is important to understand the concept of Air Changes per Hour (ACH).</p><p>ACH represents the number of times the air in a room is cleaned or replaced each hour. For air purifiers, ACH is determined by the amount of clean air delivered to a room relative to the room’s volume.</p><p>In simple terms, a room receiving 5 ACH will have its air cleaned five times per hour, while a room receiving only 1 ACH will have its air cleaned once per hour.</p><p>Why Is 5 ACH Often Used as a Reference?</p><p>There is no single universal standard, but a broad consensus has emerged around approximately 5 ACH as a reasonable target for air cleaning.</p><p>One important reference is the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM). AHAM’s Verifide certification program bases its room size recommendations on approximately 4.8 ACH.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*YGOgqHIUwU4akeCqpZr3xw.png" /><figcaption><em>AHAM Verifide certification for the Levoit Core 300S air purifier. <br> The suggested room size of 219 sq ft is based on 4.8 air changes per hour (ACH)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Source : <a href="https://ahamverifide.org/directory-of-air-cleaners/">AHAM Verifide Directory</a></p><p>Another widely respected reference is the Harvard Healthy Buildings Program. Harvard’s guidance is even more ambitious, identifying 5–6 ACH as excellent and 6 ACH as ideal. While Harvard’s recommendations include both outdoor air and air cleaning, they still point toward a target in the same general range as AHAM.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*UpJBfSMbSCI_lvsm20AVkg.png" /><figcaption><em>Harvard Healthy Buildings Program — Recommended total ACH targets (fresh air + eACH from portable air cleaners)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Source Harvard. Healthy Buildings. <em>Portable Air Cleaner Sizing Tool.</em></p><p><a href="https://healthybuildings.hsph.harvard.edu/tools/air-cleaner-calculator/">https://healthybuildings.hsph.harvard.edu/tools/air-cleaner-calculator/</a></p><p>The exact number is less important than the overall observation: respected organizations generally converge toward approximately 5 ACH, not 1 ACH.</p><p>Why 1 ACH Is Generally Insufficient</p><p>The purpose of ventilation and air cleaning is to remove pollutants from indoor air.</p><p>If pollutants are being generated continuously within a space — whether from occupants, activities, outdoor infiltration, or other sources — the rate at which clean air is supplied must be sufficient to keep pollutant concentrations under control.</p><p>A room receiving only 1 ACH is receiving much less clean air than a room receiving 5 ACH. As a result, pollutant concentrations will generally remain higher, which is why organizations such as AHAM, Harvard Healthy Buildings, and many other experts recommend substantially higher air exchange rates.</p><p>This distinction is critical because the room size advertised by a manufacturer depends directly on the ACH selected for the calculation. A room size based on 1 ACH does not provide the same level of air cleaning as a room size based on approximately 5 ACH.</p><p>The mathematics behind ACH, CADR, and room size will be presented later in this article. For readers who wish to verify the calculations themselves, the formulas and calculators used in this article are also provided.For now, the key point is that room-size claims depend directly on the ACH used in the calculation.</p><p><strong>The Math Behind the Claims</strong></p><p>For readers who prefer understanding the calculations behind room size claims rather than relying solely on manufacturer specifications, the following formulas may be useful.</p><p>In the formulas below:</p><ul><li>CADR is expressed in CFM.</li><li>Room Volume is expressed in cubic feet (ft³).</li><li>Room Size is expressed in square feet (ft²).</li></ul><p>ACH Formula</p><p>ACH = CADR × 60 / Room Volume</p><p>Room Volume Formula</p><p>Room Volume = CADR × 60 / ACH</p><p>Room Size Formula</p><p>Room Size (ft²) = CADR × 7.5 / ACH</p><p><em>Note: These formulas assume an 8-foot ceiling. If the ceiling height is different, replace 7.5 in the room size formula with “60 ÷ ceiling height (in feet)”.</em></p><p>For readers who prefer calculators rather than performing the calculations manually, several options are available.</p><p><a href="https://healthybuildings.hsph.harvard.edu/tools/air-cleaner-calculator/">Harvard. Healthy Buildings. Portable Air Cleaner Sizing Tool</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*hua6BpYGlHax0HUiggZpdw.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://housefresh.com/cadr-calculator/">HouseFresh CADR calculator</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*Ok1xuEipK1MrWhVvwnDHQw.png" /></figure><p>Excel personal CADR-ACH Calculator web link:</p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kfRT-UhQ4H5QrNdpekTWjKZsB7vvK3Xz/edit?gid=618508704#gid=618508704">CADR-ACH-Calculator</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*dq34iqmJMB9RbVTtdmvW9A.png" /><figcaption><em>Personal Excel CADR-ACH Calculator used for air purifier analyses and comparisons. The calculator estimates room size and ACH from CADR, room dimensions, and ventilation inputs</em></figcaption></figure><p>Unlike the Harvard Healthy Buildings and HouseFresh online calculators, this is a personal Excel spreadsheet that I use in my own analyses and comparisons. It is included here as an Excel-based alternative.</p><p>Whether you prefer an online calculator, a spreadsheet, or a simple calculator, all three approaches lead to the same result.</p><p><strong>The Room Size Illusion</strong></p><p>At first glance, room size appears to be a simple and intuitive specification.</p><p>A larger room size seems to indicate a more powerful air purifier. A smaller room size seems to indicate a less powerful one.</p><p>The problem is that room size is not a direct measurement of an air purifier’s performance.</p><p>Unlike CADR, which measures the amount of clean air delivered by a machine, room size is a calculated value. As shown in the previous section, room size depends on both CADR and the ACH used in the calculation.</p><p>This creates an important consequence: for a given CADR, lowering the ACH increases the room size.</p><p>To illustrate this, consider a hypothetical air purifier with a CADR of 300 CFM.</p><p>Using the formula presented earlier:</p><p>Room Size = CADR × 7.5 / ACH</p><p>The same 300 CFM air purifier would be associated with the following room sizes:</p><ul><li>469 ft² at 4.8 ACH</li><li>643 ft² at 3.5 ACH</li><li>1,125 ft² at 2 ACH</li><li>2,250 ft² at 1 ACH</li></ul><p>Nothing about the machine has changed.</p><p>The CADR has not changed.</p><p>The airflow has not changed.</p><p>The amount of clean air delivered has not changed.</p><p>Only the ACH used in the calculation has changed.</p><p>Yet the advertised room size increases from 469 ft² to 2,250 ft².</p><p>This is the room size illusion.</p><p>A larger room size is not necessarily the result of a more powerful air purifier. Room size depends directly on the ACH used in the calculation.</p><p>Under the AHAM Verifide program, room size claims are consistently based on 4.8 ACH. Outside of AHAM certification, however, manufacturers may choose different ACH assumptions. The lower the ACH selected, the larger the resulting room size claim will be.</p><p>As a result, room size ratings from different manufacturers are often not directly comparable.</p><p><strong>Real-World Examples</strong></p><p>The room size illusion is not merely theoretical. The following examples illustrate different approaches currently found in the air purifier market. The goal is not to single out particular manufacturers, but to show how room-size claims can vary depending on the ACH used — or implied — in the calculation.</p><p><a href="https://air-fanta.com/products/airfanta-3pro?srsltid=AfmBOoobmO_3A9ZT7dmkDQ3y9ECODLVca7j7bp6v7JUy5TSxWfk5c8UR">AirFanta 3Pro</a></p><ul><li>Advertised room size: 3,100 ft².</li><li>ACH not disclosed.</li><li>Based on the published specifications, the claim corresponds to approximately 1 ACH.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*8w7n4PkDBHYb1tKp3NfGrw.png" /><figcaption><em>Personal Excel CADR-ACH Calculator showing that the AirFanta 3Pro’s published CADR of 413 CFM and advertised room size of 3,100 ft² correspond to1 ACH</em></figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://medifyair.com/products/ma-112?variant=31240021180483">Medify MA-112</a></p><ul><li>CADR: 1,009 m³/h (594 CFM).</li><li>Advertised as cleaning 2,228 ft² in 30 minutes.</li><li>This approach is different again, as the specification is based on a cleaning time rather than a stated ACH.</li><li>Using the formulas presented earlier, the claim corresponds to approximately 2 ACH.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*VQi5VFgWCnBgELY96zWZ6A.png" /><figcaption><em>Personal Excel CADR-ACH Calculator showing that the Medify MA-112’s published CADR of 594 CFM and advertised room size of 2228 ft² correspond to 2 ACH</em></figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://smartairfilters.com/en/product/sa-600-large-room-air-purifier/?srsltid=AfmBOopcvgqC4n6hz5taRTes2W0qzOTsKoeZ3fc_zMqgZ6KGtU76iVew">SmartAir SA-600</a></p><ul><li>CADR: 508 m³/h (299 CFM).</li><li>Published room-size claim corresponds to approximately 3.5 ACH.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*MrB8Nf1wM50uNzcCIzjaZg.png" /><figcaption><em>Personal Excel CADR-ACH Calculator showing that the Smart Air SA-600’s published CADR of 299 CFM and advertised room size of 645.9 ft² correspond to 3,5 ACH</em></figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://levoit.com/products/core-300s-p-smart-air-purifier?srsltid=AfmBOoqt2YU0l3Lf76QoEZdCtIQZ138mcmXBRg0yx2c-qum1451Ku3aZ">Levoit Core® 300S-P</a></p><ul><li>Displays both 1 ACH and 4.8 ACH room-size ratings.</li><li>Explicitly states the ACH associated with each room-size claim.</li><li>Allows direct comparison and informed decision-making.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*q8rE8A6HToqOWg0rjsdOLg.png" /><figcaption><em>Personal Excel CADR-ACH Calculator showing that the Levoit Core 300S-P’s published CADR of 141 CFM and advertised room size of 219 ft² correspond to 4,8 ACH</em></figcaption></figure><p>Among the four examples discussed above, only the Levoit Core® 300S-P aligns with AHAM’s approximately 4.8 ACH benchmark for room-size claims.</p><p>Another useful reference comes from the Harvard Healthy Buildings Program. The figure below places each air purifier on Harvard’s ACH scale using the ACH associated with its advertised room-size claim, whether explicitly stated or derived from the published specifications.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*gd4fSZZZ0BqxI6RSP48meg.png" /><figcaption><em>Comparison of the ACH associated with the advertised room-size claims of four air purifiers against the Harvard Healthy Buildings recommended ACH targets</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Why This Matters for Consumers</strong></p><p>Most consumers naturally assume that room-size claims can be compared directly from one manufacturer to another. After all, room size appears to be a simple and intuitive specification. A purifier advertised for 3,100 ft² appears more powerful than one advertised for 645 ft².</p><p>The problem is that these numbers are often based on very different ACH assumptions. A room-size claim calculated using 1 ACH does not provide the same level of air cleaning as a room-size claim calculated using approximately 4.8 ACH. Yet this crucial piece of information is often absent from specification sheets.</p><p>When a manufacturer provides a room-size claim based on 1 ACH, it is effectively deciding on the consumer’s behalf that 1 ACH is sufficient. Consumers are rarely told that this assumption is being made, nor are they told that it is approximately five times lower than AHAM’s 4.8 ACH benchmark.</p><p>If a manufacturer believes that 1 ACH is sufficient, that position can certainly be defended and debated. The problem is not the existence of a different opinion. The problem is that the ACH used to calculate the room size is often not disclosed, leaving consumers unable to make an informed comparison.</p><p>As a result, consumers may believe they are comparing equivalent room-size ratings when they are not. Two products may appear dramatically different on paper even though much of the difference is explained by the ACH chosen for the calculation.</p><p>For consumers trying to make informed decisions about air cleaning, room size without the associated ACH can be more confusing than informative.</p><p><strong>Why This Matters for Competition</strong></p><p>The consequences extend beyond consumer confusion.</p><p>Manufacturers compete for attention in a crowded marketplace, and larger numbers tend to attract attention. Because lowering the ACH increases the advertised room size without increasing the CADR, room-size claims can become larger without any improvement in air-cleaning performance.</p><p>This creates an uneven playing field. Manufacturers that use AHAM’s approximately 4.8 ACH benchmark may appear less competitive simply because they are using a more demanding standard. Meanwhile, manufacturers using lower ACH assumptions can advertise substantially larger room sizes for air purifiers with similar CADR values.</p><p>All else being equal, many consumers will naturally gravitate toward the product displaying the largest room-size claim. This creates a competitive advantage for manufacturers using lower ACH assumptions, while manufacturers providing a higher level of air cleaning may appear less attractive on paper.</p><p>The result is a market incentive that rewards larger room-size claims rather than greater transparency. Such an incentive may help generate sales, but it does little to help consumers understand the level of air cleaning they are actually purchasing and may ultimately contribute to poorer indoor air quality decisions.</p><p><strong>Transparent Specifications Are a Public Health Issue</strong></p><p>Specification-sheet transparency may seem like a technical concern. It is not.</p><p>In <a href="https://seetheair.org/2026/05/06/book-review-the-time-thief-by-simon-jones/"><em>The Time Thief book</em>,</a> Simon Jones cites Dr. Joseph Allen of Harvard’s Healthy Buildings Program, who argues that facility managers often have a greater impact on our daily health than our doctors. While the quote refers to building ventilation, the underlying idea applies more broadly to indoor air quality.</p><p>Air purifiers are not decorative products. They are purchased to reduce exposure to pollutants and improve indoor air quality. The decisions consumers make when selecting these products therefore have consequences that extend beyond convenience, marketing, or product preference.</p><p>Indoor air quality is increasingly recognized as an important factor influencing health, well-being, productivity, and long-term outcomes. When people are trying to improve the air they breathe, clear and transparent information becomes more than a consumer-protection issue.</p><p>That is why this series focuses on specification-sheet clarity and transparency. Whether the topic is CADR, noise levels, units of measurement, or room-size claims, the objective is always the same: helping people understand what they are buying and what level of air cleaning they can reasonably expect.</p><p>Better information does not guarantee better decisions. But transparent, informed decisions are impossible when essential information is missing from the specification sheet.</p><p><strong>Room Size Claims Should Include ACH</strong></p><p>The solution proposed here is remarkably simple.</p><p>Whenever a room-size claim is displayed, the ACH used to calculate that room size should also be displayed. This would allow consumers to understand what level of air cleaning the claim actually represents and make meaningful comparisons between products.</p><p>Ideally, room-size claims would be based on approximately 4.8 ACH, consistent with the benchmark used by the AHAM Verifide program. When a different ACH is used, that ACH should be clearly disclosed alongside the room-size claim.</p><p>Manufacturers may have valid reasons for using different ACH assumptions. The issue is not the use of a particular ACH value. The issue is whether that value is disclosed.</p><p>A room-size claim without the associated ACH is incomplete information. A room-size claim accompanied by the ACH used in the calculation is transparent information.</p><p>This is not a complicated technical problem. In many cases, it requires only a few additional characters on a specification sheet.</p><p>Small improvements in transparency can make product comparisons easier, encourage informed decisions, and help consumers better understand the level of air cleaning they are purchasing.</p><p><strong>Indoor Air Quality: A Greater Impact on Health Than Our Doctors</strong></p><p>This article is the third in a series examining the transparency of air purifier specification sheets.</p><p>The first explored the practice of pairing CADR measured at maximum speed with noise measured at minimum speed — a combination that says little about real-world performance. The second examined the confusion created by the coexistence of m³/h and CFM. This article focused on the room-size illusion and the often-hidden role of ACH in determining those claims.</p><p>Other topics remain to be explored. The “True HEPA” mantra is one of them. CADR values presented without particle-size information is another. At first glance, these subjects may appear technical. In reality, they all revolve around the same question: does the public have access to the information needed to make informed decisions about the air they breathe?</p><p>Air purifiers are not purchased for their specifications. They are purchased because people want cleaner air.</p><p>And cleaner air is ultimately about health.</p><p>Much attention is given to doctors, medications, hospitals, and treatments. Yet the quality of the air people breathe every day may influence their health long before medical care ever becomes necessary.</p><p>That is why complete and transparent specification sheets matter.</p><p>Not because consumers need more numbers.</p><p>Not because technical specifications are interesting in themselves.</p><p>But because better information can help people choose the right product, achieve better air quality, and make decisions that may benefit their health for years to come.</p><p>Some health problems require a doctor.</p><p>Others may be prevented long before a doctor is ever needed.</p><p>The air people breathe every day belongs in that conversation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a45d8296b757" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Consumers Shouldn’t Need a Conversion Calculator to Compare Air Purifiers: Why Air Purifier CADR…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/consumers-shouldnt-need-a-conversion-calculator-to-compare-air-purifiers-91581c9ff0e2?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91581c9ff0e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consumer-protection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transparency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cadr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-purifier]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jun 2026 16:42:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-07T15:48:34.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Consumers Shouldn’t Need a Conversion Calculator to Compare Air Purifiers: Why Air Purifier CADR Should Be Reported in CFM</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*6yxyI7bDyzMOQewASooZog.png" /></figure><p><em>“When it comes to buying air purifiers or air exchangers, navigating through the technical datasheets can feel like an obstacle course. The real challenge is in the lack of transparency and consistency of the data provided, which makes it difficult for consumers to make informed decisions.”</em></p><p>I wrote that in a <a href="https://medium.com/its-airborne/the-challenge-of-finding-clear-and-honest-specs-on-air-purifiers-and-air-exchangers-acf10c0cc4bb">previous article.</a> Today I want to add one more obstacle to the list — one that doesn’t require any bad intent from manufacturers to cause real harm: reporting CADR in m³/h instead of — or without — CFM.</p><p>This is something I’ve been thinking about for a while. I know how to convert m³/h to CFM, and I think it’s worth learning. But not everyone does — and manufacturers could easily help by providing both units, or by defaulting to the one the public already relies on.</p><p>To be clear: m³/h is a perfectly valid unit. The issue is not that CFM is better than m³/h. The issue is that the most widely used metric in the certified air purifier world — AHAM, Energy Star, HouseFresh — is CFM. Reporting in m³/h alone creates confusion for a public that is already navigating a lot.</p><p>To illustrate this with a concrete example, I’ll use the SA600 by Smart Air. Why Smart Air? Because they are widely regarded as one of the most transparent and education-focused actors in the industry. Which is exactly why I hope they will reconsider this practice.</p><p>Someone unfamiliar with units might assume 508 m³/h and 508 CFM are equivalent. They are not. 508 m³/h = 299 CFM.</p><p>And someone who doesn’t yet know that CADR is the metric that matters (and not the “true hepa mantra”) is probably also not someone who knows how to convert m³/h to CFM.</p><p><strong>CFM: The Reference Unit in the Certified Air Purifier World</strong></p><p>CADR reported in CFM (cubic feet per minute) is the primary standard used by AHAM, Energy Star, Intertek, and the well-known independent tester HouseFresh.</p><p>Reporting in m³/h is equally precise and informative — but only for those who know how to use it. For everyone else, it means pulling out a calculator just to compare two purifiers. Without that step, you’re comparing apples and oranges.</p><p>My position is simple: reporting in m³/h is fine, as long as CFM is also provided. And if only one unit is shown, it should be CFM — the unit used by hundreds of certified purifiers worldwide, the one consumers and references already rely on. Let’s help consumers navigate, not add to the confusion they’re already facing.</p><p>There is also something worth naming directly: reporting in m³/h offers a numerical advantage. Since 1 CFM = 1.7 m³/h, a purifier’s CADR will always appear as a larger number in m³/h. For an uninformed consumer comparing two purifiers side by side, that larger number can be the deciding factor — even when the actual performance is lower. Everyone loses in that scenario, except the manufacturer who chose that unit. Even informed consumers — and I count myself among them — are forced to do extra math just to make a fair comparison. Math that adds no value whatsoever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*yNFRd1y1sbNwCFAiM-f3cQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Energy Star specification sheet for the Levoit LAP-C341S-WUSZ air purifier</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/725/1*qNo_yPxrSnRjt-llKma3Jw.png" /><figcaption><em>AHAM certification sheet for the Medify Air-MA-112 Pro air purifier</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Unit Confusion That Could Leave You <br> Breathing Dirty Air : <em>m³/h and CFM are not the same number</em></strong></p><p>The <a href="https://smartairfilters.com/en/product/sa-600-large-room-air-purifier/?srsltid=AfmBOoqrl8mARn8WPnD4dfiBMOSsMGbubjaXIYdooF1M2TjRNboFfRAk">Smart Air SA600</a> lists a CADR of 508 m³/h — without providing the CFM equivalent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*-xDOOYdbsi7tGnamxKt7LA.png" /><figcaption><em>Smart Air SA-600 specification sheet</em></figcaption></figure><p>That number, 508, looks impressive. And here’s the problem: most people never look past the number itself. The unit right after it — m³/h or CFM — is easy to miss, especially when you don’t know there’s a difference to look for. Many consumers assume that 508 is 508, whatever the label says.</p><p>It isn’t. 508 m³/h = 299 CFM.</p><p>That’s not a rounding error. That’s a 41% gap — and it only shows up if you know to look for it, and if you’re willing to pull out a calculator. (For the record: 1 m³/h = 0.59 CFM, and 1 CFM = 1.7 m³/h.)</p><p>If you need a CADR of 500 CFM and you buy a purifier listed at “508” — not realizing it’s 508 m³/h, not CFM — you walk away with 299 CFM. Not zero. Not useless. Just not what you needed.</p><p>And that gap matters, because we buy air purifiers for a reason: cleaner air, better health, meeting the standards that actually protect us. When the number you relied on wasn’t the number you think it was, you may never reach that threshold — without ever knowing you missed it.</p><p><strong>A Daycare, an Asthmatic Child, and a Number That Looked Right</strong></p><p>Let’s make this concrete with a hypothetical — but entirely plausible — scenario.</p><p>A couple of parents has a child with severe asthma. The child attends a daycare in a 750 ft² room, in one of the most polluted cities in the world, where PM2.5 levels regularly exceed 50 µg/m³. The parents ask the daycare director if they can bring in an air purifier — at their own expense. The director agrees, on one condition: the unit must be quiet and not too bulky.</p><p>They did their homework. They find AHAM’s 2/3 rule: choose a purifier with a tobacco smoke CADR at least ⅔ of the room’s square footage.</p><p>(Source: <a href="https://ahamverifide.org/directory-of-air-cleaners/">AHAM Verifide Directory</a>)</p><p>For 750 ft², that means a minimum of 500 CFM.</p><p>Run the numbers:</p><p>ACH = (CADR × 60) / room volume,</p><p>and that translates to 4.8 air changes per hour of clean air, which is what that rule is designed to deliver.</p><p>They find the Smart Air SA600. The spec sheet says 508. They don’t notice the m³/h. They see 508, they need 500, they buy it.</p><p>The purifier delivers 299 CFM — not 508.</p><p>Instead of 4.8 air changes per hour, the room gets roughly 3.</p><p>Not useless. But below the minimum standard — the one that was already a floor, not a ceiling.</p><p>The parents think the job is done. The child keeps breathing air that still carries more particles than it should. And nobody in that room knows the difference</p><p><strong>Spec Sheets Should Help the Public Make Informed Decisions:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Clean air isn’t a luxury. Neither is the truth about what you’re buying</em></strong></p><p>At the end of the day, air purifiers exist for one reason: cleaner air. Cleaner air means better health — for our children, our families, our communities. And better decisions start with honest, readable information.</p><p>Reporting CADR in m³/h alone — without the CFM equivalent — makes that harder. Not necessarily out of bad intent. But the effect is the same: a number that looks bigger than it is, a purifier that looks more powerful than it is, and a consumer who walks away thinking they bought something they didn’t. Meanwhile, the manufacturer who chose the larger-looking unit gets the sale.</p><p>Manufacturers have the power to change this tomorrow. Report both units. Or default to CFM — the standard used by AHAM, Energy Star, and every major certification body in the industry. It may cost some of them a competitive advantage they never should have had in the first place.</p><p>Consumers deserve spec sheets that are clear, complete, and readable without a calculator. Most people trust the number on the spec sheet — and they should be able to. The status quo needs to change. And it will — the more we demand transparency, the more pressure builds on manufacturers to deliver it. That’s how the future gets made.</p><p><strong>This Is Just the Beginning : The Spec Sheet Rabbit Hole Goes Deep</strong></p><p>Spec sheets in the air purifier industry are a Pandora’s box — and I intend to keep opening it. This article is the second in what will likely be a longer series. <a href="https://medium.com/its-airborne/the-challenge-of-finding-clear-and-honest-specs-on-air-purifiers-and-air-exchangers-acf10c0cc4bb">The first</a> covered CADR at max speed paired with noise at minimum — a combination that tells you nothing useful about real-world performance. This one covers the m³/h vs CFM confusion.</p><p>There is no shortage of topics still on my radar:</p><ul><li><strong>Room size claims that ignore the 4.8 ACH standard</strong> — and never mention how many air changes per hour that room size actually delivers</li><li><strong>The “True HEPA” mantra</strong> — and why 200 CFM through a True HEPA filter is exactly the same as 200 CFM through a MERV-13. CADR is what moves the needle, not the filter label</li><li><strong>CADR without particle size</strong> — and why reporting pollen CADR instead of smoke CADR inflates the number, misleads the consumer, and penalizes the honest manufacturer</li><li><strong>Bad faith in the industry</strong> — manufacturers attacking competitors on irrelevant grounds, or hiding behind the language of science to discredit rather than genuinely debate — whoever the target may be.</li></ul><p>Every topic on this list has the same thing at stake: the public’s ability to make truly informed decisions about their air quality and their health.</p><p><strong>Update June 7, 2026</strong></p><p>After publishing this article, I came across a good example worth mentioning.</p><p>The <a href="https://levoit.com/products/core-300s-p-smart-air-purifier?srsltid=AfmBOoqt2YU0l3Lf76QoEZdCtIQZ138mcmXBRg0yx2c-qum1451Ku3aZ">Levoit Core® 300S-P</a> specification sheet displays both CADR units: 141 CFM / 240 m³/h. This simple addition makes comparisons easier for consumers and demonstrates that greater transparency is possible without adding significant complexity to a specification sheet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/869/1*3RiGF0kKx4kXR5XUCafCog.png" /><figcaption>Levoit Core® 300S-P specification sheet showing CADR in both imperial and metric units: 141 CFM / 240 m³/h</figcaption></figure><p>Interestingly, some of the discussions generated by this article suggest that not everyone agrees that both units should be displayed. Some argue that consumers should simply learn the conversion or use a calculator. Others go further and argue that CFM should disappear altogether, describing it as a relic of the past that should be replaced everywhere by m³/h.</p><p>At times, the debate seems to extend beyond practicality and consumer information. For some, the issue appears to carry a cultural or symbolic dimension related to the continued use of imperial units. Whether that is the case or not, the focus of this article is much simpler: helping consumers make informed decisions.</p><p>While debates about units continue, ordinary consumers are trying to choose air purifiers that will provide the level of air cleaning they expect. If the information is difficult to compare or requires additional calculations, some may end up purchasing a unit that delivers less clean air than they thought they were getting. This is ultimately a matter of consumer protection, public information, and public health.</p><p>Perfect solutions can take years. Small improvements can start today.</p><p>A small step for the manufacturer, but a meaningful step for the public.</p><p><strong>Second Update –june 7 2026.</strong></p><p>Even trained healthcare professionals — pharmacists, nurses, and doctors — frequently make medication dosing errors because both pounds (lbs) and kilograms (kg) remain in use. Official reports document hundreds of such incidents, some leading to overdoses.</p><p>A 2023 Radio-Canada article also showed that Canadian retailers often display prices per pound first (e.g. $16.99/lb vs $37.46/kg for the same product). Consumers focus more on the number than the unit, perceiving the imperial price as cheaper and sometimes misjudging the real cost.</p><p>If professionals who know that kg and lbs are different units — and whose job is to protect patients — still make mistakes, and everyday shoppers who also know these two units exist still get confused, imagine the situation with air purifiers. Here the public is at a different level: many people simply do not know that CADR can be expressed in different units, let alone how to compare or convert them. They simply compare raw numbers — apples to oranges — which undermines truly informed choices and public health prevention.</p><p><strong>Clearly displaying both units would be a major advancement that would help thousands of consumers make better decisions.</strong></p><p>References</p><p>Emergency nurse association. Position Statement. Weighing All Patients in Kilograms. <a href="https://media.emscimprovement.center/documents/Weighing_All_Patients_in_Kilograms_ENA_Position_Statement.pdf">https://media.emscimprovement.center/documents/Weighing_All_Patients_in_Kilograms_ENA_Position_Statement.pdf</a></p><p>Radio-Canada. November 19, 2023. <em>Des prix à la livre et au kilo qui alimentent la confusion.</em></p><p><a href="https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2027696/prix-fruits-legumes-viande-livre-imperial-kilo-metrique-confusion">https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2027696/prix-fruits-legumes-viande-livre-imperial-kilo-metrique-confusion</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91581c9ff0e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Prettiest Hum in a Loud, Dirty Room: 
 Why Sound Color Is the Last Thing to Consider When…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-prettiest-hum-in-a-loud-dirty-room-why-sound-color-is-the-last-thing-to-consider-when-3ca2ae60b313?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ca2ae60b313</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cadr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pink-noise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-purifier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brown-noise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-noise]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 May 2026 22:53:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-14T22:53:20.579Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Prettiest Hum in a Loud, Dirty Room: <br> <em>Why Sound Color Is the Last Thing to Consider When Choosing an Air Purifier</em></strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/461/1*ZWnjUJQ2sLrNLpbdJ1nemQ.png" /></figure><p><em>You’ve spent hours researching air purifiers. Commercial models, DIY builds, HEPA filters, fan speeds. The market alone is a jungle — hundreds of models, misleading specs, and manufacturers who advertise maximum airflow at minimum noise, as if the two ever go together. Just finding a purifier that genuinely cleans your air quietly is already an enormous challenge.</em></p><p><em>And then, somewhere along the way, someone mentions it: sound color. That this purifier hums with a harsh, irritating tone. That this other one produces a smooth, almost hypnotic noise — closer to a waterfall than a machine. Suddenly you have a third thing to optimize for, on top of an already overwhelming list.</em></p><p><em>Before you know it, you’re watching noise comparison videos at midnight, trying to hear the difference between white noise and brown noise, forgetting entirely why you started this journey in the first place: you wanted cleaner air.</em></p><p><em>Here’s the thing. Sound color is real, it matters, and it’s worth considering — but only after you’ve nailed two more fundamental things: how much air your purifier actually cleans (CADR), and how loud it actually runs (dBA). Get those wrong, and the prettiest hum in the world won’t save you from a loud room, a dirty room, or both.</em></p><p><strong><em>CADR first. dBA second. Sound color third. In that order.</em></strong></p><p><strong>CADR and the Two-Thirds Rule: Your First Compass</strong></p><p>So let’s start with the first metric: CADR, or Clean Air Delivery Rate. It measures how much purified air a device delivers per minute, and it is your single most important number when choosing an air purifier.</p><p>CADR is actually measured for three types of particles: dust, pollen, and smoke. In most discussions about air purifiers — and throughout this article — smoke CADR is the reference, as it covers the smallest particles and is the most commonly used benchmark for comparison.</p><p>But not all CADR numbers are created equal. Before applying any rule, make sure the CADR you’re looking at comes from an independent, certified source — such as <a href="https://ahamverifide.org/directory-of-air-cleaners/">AHAM</a> and <a href="https://www.energystar.gov/productfinder/product/certified-room-air-cleaners/results">Energy Star</a>. Manufacturers self-reporting their own CADR figures is common, and those numbers are frequently optimistic. A certified CADR is tested in a controlled chamber, following a precise protocol. An uncertified one is just a claim on a box.</p><p>Once you have a verified CADR, the rule is simple: choose a device whose smoke CADR — expressed in CFM, or cubic feet per minute — is at least two-thirds of your room’s square footage. For a 120 sq ft room, that means targeting a purifier with a smoke CADR of at least 80 CFM. Follow that rule and you’re guaranteed roughly five air changes per hour — the baseline for meaningful air purification.</p><p>In higher-pollution situations — a busy kitchen, a wildfire smoke event outside — you may want to aim for a CADR closer to your full square footage rather than two-thirds. But for most people, most of the time, the two-thirds rule is a solid, tested starting point.</p><p>A certified CADR is your compass. Everything else follows from there.</p><p><strong>Compass in the Jungle: The Double Target (When CADR and dBA Must Align)</strong></p><p>Here is where it gets complicated and the jungle begins.</p><p>There are dozens of air purifiers with certified CADR ratings available through AHAM and Energy Star. If you need a device with a smoke CADR of 100 CFM, you’ll find plenty of candidates. That part is relatively straightforward.</p><p>The problem is noise.</p><p>Certified CADR ratings are measured at maximum speed — and at maximum speed, the vast majority of purifiers are simply too loud for everyday use. Most devices have lower speed settings, of course, but at those quieter settings, the CADR is unknown. You remember the rule: CADR first. But at low speed, you don’t have a CADR anymore. You have a guess.</p><p>And noise is not just a comfort issue. A purifier that runs too loud can disrupt sleep, reduce concentration — especially for children in schools — and over time, contribute to cardiovascular stress. The goal is clean air without creating a new problem. In many situations, a total noise level of 45 dBA is the upper limit people can tolerate. For sensitive individuals, that target drops to 35 or 40 dBA.</p><p>The trouble is that very few devices publish — let alone certify — their CADR at low speed settings. And marketing tactics often make things worse: a manufacturer might display a certified CADR of 100 CFM alongside a noise level of 30 dBA, without mentioning that the two numbers come from completely different speed settings. A consumer could reasonably — and wrongly — conclude that the device delivers 100 CFM at 30 dBA. It doesn’t.</p><p>Welcome to the air purifier jungle market.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*iKPvkrRkKJl47fS-hZ1tmg.png" /></figure><p>Fortunately, independent testers like<a href="https://housefresh.com/"> HouseFresh</a> provide more honest data. And databases like Clean Air Stars have made a genuine effort to pair CADR and noise levels at specific speed settings — though testing methods vary and are not yet standardized. It’s imperfect, but it’s more than most manufacturers offer.</p><p>The bottom line: finding a purifier that is both genuinely quiet and genuinely effective is already a significant challenge. You’ll likely end up with a handful of options, not dozens.</p><p>And now, just as you’re navigating all of this, a new concept enters the conversation: sound color. Pink noise. Brown noise. White noise. Suddenly the jungle gets even denser.</p><p>In the next section, let’s look at what sound color actually is.</p><p><strong>What Is Sound Color, Exactly?</strong></p><p>Noise has become a market. Millions of people listen to white, pink, or brown noise to sleep, focus, or mask their surroundings. There are apps, entire YouTube channels, and some debates on forums and air purifier communities.</p><p>Increasingly, you’ll hear comments like: “That fan has an annoying sound” or “I prefer this one — it just sounds nicer.” These reactions are real — but keep in mind that what people describe as “annoying” is often a mix of two very different things: how loud a sound is, and what kind of sound it is. Sound color is about the second part only.</p><p>Sound color is the framework that describes exactly that — how sonic energy is distributed across frequencies — bass, midrange, and treble — much like colors of light form a spectrum. It can be measured objectively, and research suggests that certain profiles, like pink or brown noise, tend to be perceived as more pleasant by most people.</p><p>Here are the main types:</p><ul><li><strong>White noise:</strong> Equal energy across all frequencies. It sounds bright and artificial because the high frequencies are just as loud as the lows. Think of a TV static hiss.</li><li><strong>Pink noise:</strong> Softer and more natural. It has more energy in the low and mid frequencies, and less in the highs. Think of a waterfall or heavy rain.</li><li><strong>Brown noise</strong> (also called red noise): Even richer in bass frequencies. Deep, rumbling, and soothing — like a distant thunderstorm or the hum of an engine.</li><li><strong>Blue / violet noise:</strong> The opposite — very rich in high frequencies, sharp and hissing.</li></ul><p>To get a personal sense of what you prefer, here are a few examples worth listening to:</p><p>Brown Noise → <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t9uWUyuMUc">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t9uWUyuMUc</a></p><p>Pink Noise → <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezwIrxOFFqw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezwIrxOFFqw</a></p><p>White Noise → <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSZaNwRU-MA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSZaNwRU-MA</a></p><p><strong>When Sound Color Adds Noise: Why the Order of Priorities Matters</strong></p><p>Let’s pause and restate the rule clearly, because everything that follows depends on it.</p><p>CADR first. dBA second. Sound color third.</p><p>The reason dBA comes before sound color is simple: noise is noise. A purifier running at 45 dBA is doing physiological damage regardless of whether its frequency profile is pink, brown, or white. Sound color cannot undo the harm of excessive volume. So you set your dBA target first — your personal ceiling, the level above which you will not go — and only once you have a shortlist of machines that meet both your CADR and your dBA targets do you ask: among these options, which one sounds the most pleasant?</p><p>Doing things in reverse — chasing a beautiful sound color before confirming CADR and dBA — is how you end up with the prettiest hum in a loud, dirty room.</p><p>Now, sound color is increasingly part of the conversation — in DIY communities, air purifier forums, Reddit threads. And that’s not a bad thing. The concept is real and relevant. But introduced without a clear framework, it can make an already complex decision even harder.</p><p>When someone says “that fan sounds annoying” without having compared fans at equal volume levels, without having tested the fan inside an actual build with filters, and without accounting for the fact that a fan’s sonic signature changes significantly with rotation speed — that comment, however sincere, adds confusion more than clarity.</p><p>This can lead to two traps. The first is analysis paralysis: people feel even more lost in the jungle, unable to decide. The second is misplaced focus: prioritizing a subjective sonic impression over the two metrics that actually determine whether a purifier is effective and safe.</p><p>There is also a data problem. Studies on white and pink noise point in different directions — we don’t yet have a clear, consistent picture of what sound color does or doesn’t do for health and wellbeing. And verified, objective sound color data for specific air purifiers is almost nonexistent. What we have are scattered subjective impressions, often made under uncontrolled conditions.</p><p>A few common pitfalls worth naming:</p><ul><li><strong>Intensity and color are not the same thing.</strong> If you don’t control for volume, you can’t know whether a fan sounds better because of its frequency profile or simply because it happened to be running quieter. The two variables must be isolated.</li><li><strong>Always compare at equal dBA, not equal airflow.</strong> When evaluating sound color, the only fair comparison is between machines running at the same volume level. Matching airflow is irrelevant here — you are comparing a listening experience, and that experience has two variables: intensity and color. If you don’t control for intensity, you are not comparing sound color. You are comparing two different sounds altogether.</li><li><strong>A fan tested in open air at full speed tells you almost nothing</strong> about how it will sound inside a real build with filters, at the speed you’ll actually run it. Too many variables change.</li></ul><p>The bottom line: if you accept 5 extra dBA to get a “prettier” sound color, or settle for a lower CADR to get the fan with the more pleasant hum, you have traded one problem for another. Even if the color is pink or brown — exactly what you were looking for — the benefit will be cancelled out by the added volume or the reduced purification.</p><p>Sound color becomes genuinely useful only once CADR and dBA are already solved. Used out of order, it doesn’t add clarity. It adds noise.</p><p><strong>Sara’s Story: When Three Targets Meet the Real World</strong></p><p>Meet Sara. She lives in an apartment building in Canada. She’s allergic to dust, sensitive to noise, and her neighbors smoke — she can smell cigarettes directly in her bedroom. She decides it’s time to buy an air purifier for her 150 sq ft bedroom.</p><p>She starts with the first target: CADR. Following the two-thirds rule, she needs a minimum smoke CADR of 100 CFM — ideally closer to 150 CFM given the cigarette smoke situation. That’s her floor, non-negotiable.</p><p>Then comes the second target: dBA. Using a sound level meter app, Sara measures her bedroom at night: 33 dBA of background noise. She knows she cannot tolerate more than 40 dBA total. That leaves room for a purifier running at no more than 39 dBA — her personal ceiling.</p><p>Already, finding a machine that genuinely meets both targets — 100 CFM minimum and 39 dBA maximum, verified, not just claimed on a box — is a serious challenge. But Sara does her research. After consulting <a href="https://filters.cleanairstars.com/">Clean Air Stars</a>, she finds a shortlist of options that credibly meet both criteria:</p><ul><li><strong>LEVOIT Core 600S</strong> — 136 CFM at 36 dBA</li><li><strong>SmartAir Blast Mini</strong> — 200 CFM at 36 dBA</li><li><strong>Tempest with AAF Flanders filter and Arctic P14 fan</strong> — 169 CFM at 35 dBA</li></ul><p>Three options. Not dozens — three. That’s the reality of the double target.</p><p>Now Sara reads that the Arctic P14 fan, used in the Tempest build, has been described as annoying by some users. Someone recommends Noctua fans instead for their smoother, more pleasant sound. Sara starts wondering: should she factor in sound color? Is the P14 really that bad?</p><p>Here is the problem. The comments about the P14 were made by people listening to the fan in open air, at full speed, under uncontrolled conditions — not inside a Tempest build with filters, at the low speed Sara would actually run it.</p><p>Should Sara make her decision based on scattered subjective impressions, potentially ending up with a lower CADR or a higher noise level, in pursuit of a sound color that may or may not be noticeably different in her actual setup?</p><p>The answer is no. Sara has three solid options that meet her two fundamental targets. If sound color data becomes available for any of them — measured properly, at equal dBA — that would be a genuine tiebreaker. Until then, CADR and dBA have done their job. Sound color is a bonus, not a basis.</p><p>Think of it like buying a mattress. You start with the essentials: the right support for your back, the right size, the right price. If two mattresses check all those boxes equally, then yes — choose the one with the softer fabric. That’s a legitimate tiebreaker. But you wouldn’t choose a mattress that hurts your back just because it feels pleasant to the touch.</p><p>Choosing an air purifier works the same way. CADR is the back support — non-negotiable. dBA is the price you pay in comfort and health. And sound color is the fabric: genuinely worth considering, but only once the fundamentals are solid, and never at the cost of adding decibels or losing purification power.</p><p><strong>A Manifesto for Future Spec Sheets: Sound Color as a Standard</strong></p><p>Let me be clear: sound color matters. At equal dBA, choosing a machine with a more pleasant frequency profile is a legitimate and worthwhile preference. The problem is not the concept — it’s the data. Or rather, the lack of it.</p><p>We are already in a jungle when it comes to CADR and dBA at low speed settings. Adding sound color to the equation without reliable, standardized data only deepens the confusion. But the solution is not to ignore sound color — it’s to demand better data.</p><p>I dream of the day when reading spec sheets like this will be ordinary:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/925/1*eNhoL_RbyHcuygCLM3_yhw.png" /></figure><p>Imagine you’re looking for a purifier in the 120–150 CFM range, at 40–42 dBA, with a preference for brown noise. Suddenly the decision becomes real and informed. Model A is the quietest but produces white noise, not brown. Model B delivers brown noise but exceeds your dBA target. Model C hits your sound color and stays within your noise ceiling — but asks you to accept a lower CADR.</p><p>That’s a genuine tradeoff you can reason through. That’s a free and informed decision.</p><p>Add to that the physical dimensions, wall-mount compatibility, aesthetics, and price — and you have everything a consumer actually needs to choose confidently, without guessing.</p><p>We’re not there yet. But independent databases like <a href="https://filters.cleanairstars.com/">Clean Air Stars</a> have already shown it’s possible to pair CADR with honest noise data at specific speed settings. <a href="https://housefresh.com/">HouseFresh</a> goes further, testing machines at quiet settings around 45 dBA. And in the DIY community, independent testers — myself included — are doing the same work at low noise levels, one build at a time.</p><p>The jungle won’t clear itself. But with the right data, we can draw a map.</p><p><strong>In the Meantime: Imperfect Data Is Better Than No Data</strong></p><p>We’re not going to wake up tomorrow with certified sound color spec sheets. So what do we do in the meantime?</p><p>In science, you work with the best available data. And right now, the best available data on sound color is imperfect, subjective, and scattered — but it’s not worthless.</p><p>Imagine if, alongside a verified CADR and a dBA measurement at a specific speed setting, users started sharing a simple pleasantness rating — say, a score out of 10. Nothing certified, nothing standardized. Just honest impressions from real people who have lived with a machine. A bit like Google reviews for a restaurant: subjective, yes, but when ten different people independently say the same thing, it starts to mean something.</p><p>The key condition — and this cannot be stressed enough — is that any subjective sound rating must come paired with a dBA level and a CADR. Without those two anchors, a pleasantness score is just noise added to noise. With them, it becomes a genuine data point.</p><p>This is exactly what I tried to explore in my earlier article<a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/sound-color-and-air-purifiers-the-conversation-is-just-beginning-9a2caf184968">, <em>Sound Color and Air Purifiers — The Conversation Is Just Beginning</em></a> — an attempt to pave the way, to invite the DIY community, independent testers, and everyday users to start building this data together, however imperfectly. Because it’s only by accumulating data points, one honest review at a time, that sound color can eventually become a useful tool for everyone.</p><p>But how do we actually collect and centralize this data? A shared spreadsheet like Clean Air Stars did for CADR and dBA? A dedicated section on existing forums? A rating system embedded in a database? I don’t have the answer yet — and I’d love to think about it together. <strong>If you have ideas, or if you’ve already started collecting this kind of data, feel free to leave a comment or reach out directly by email.</strong></p><p>The pieces are falling into place. We are slowly getting better at the basics — more certified CADR data, more honest noise measurements at low speeds. That progress is real. And as the foundation solidifies, sound color is the natural next frontier. Not a distraction. A refinement. The day we can reliably choose clean, quiet air and a pleasant sound profile will be a genuinely better day for everyone who breathes indoors — which is all of us.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: The Prettiest Hum Is Worth Chasing — In the Right Order</strong></p><p>Let’s come back to where we started. You set out looking for cleaner air. Somewhere along the way, you found yourself deep in noise comparison videos at midnight, trying to choose between pink and brown.</p><p>That detour makes sense. Sound color is real, it matters, and it will become increasingly relevant as the field evolves. But the hierarchy of priorities should stay clear.</p><p>Start with what actually cleans the air: choose a purifier with a certified CADR that matches the size of your space. Then protect your peace: make sure it stays within a noise level you can live with, day after day. Only then — once those two foundations are solid — pick the one whose hum feels the most pleasant to you.</p><p>A beautifully sounding purifier that fails to clean your air or forces you to live with irritating volume hasn’t solved the problem. It has simply redecorated it.</p><p>CADR gives you clean air. dBA gives you livable comfort. Sound color, when it finally fits, gives you joy.</p><p>That’s not a limitation. It’s a clear framework that lets you make decisions you won’t regret.</p><p>The conversation around sound color is only beginning. One day, spec sheets will include it, independent testers will measure it, and communities will rate it. Until then, we already have enough to choose wisely.</p><p>The prettiest hum is absolutely worth chasing — but only after you’ve made sure the air is truly clean and the room stays quiet.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ca2ae60b313" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sound Color and Air Purifiers — 
 The Conversation Is Just Beginning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/sound-color-and-air-purifiers-the-conversation-is-just-beginning-9a2caf184968?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9a2caf184968</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pc-fan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home-air-purifiers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-noise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brown-noise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy-air-purifier]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 May 2026 15:08:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-10T15:08:58.201Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/662/1*ikCRaUgRFjthsZj1Vu0f4w.png" /></figure><p>The sound color of air purifiers is becoming a real conversation. We can all measure dBA with a low cost sound meter. Spectral analysis is another story. And yet people confidently say certain PC fans sound “annoying” — without always asking: at what speed? at what dBA? compared to what exactly?</p><p><strong>My subjective ratings at 36 dBA</strong></p><p>In my subjective experience, I compared several PC fans at equal (or near-equal) dBA levels and rated their sound pleasantness. This is a follow-up to my first article: <a href="https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-sound-color-of-5-pc-fans-my-subjective-noise-test-d358dbc7490e">The Sound Color of 5 PC Fans — My Subjective Noise Test</a></p><p>At 36 dBA, my ratings are:</p><ul><li>Silverstone 184i PRO: 9.5/10</li><li>Arctic P14 Max: 9.2/10</li><li>Noctua NF-A12x25 G2 PWM: 8.7/10</li><li>Noctua iPPC 3000 &amp; Cooler Master SickleFlow 120: 8.5/10</li></ul><p>Arctic P14 Pro PST: 8.2/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/685/1*vTnOFA74U7FJRBFFGAvwRw.png" /></figure><p><strong>About the Youtube video “The Ultimate 140mm Fan Test”</strong></p><p>This video is genuinely useful if you’re shopping for a PC fan to cool your computer and want to know how each fan sounds at 25%, 50%, 75%, and maximum speed. For that purpose, knowing both the dBA level and the sound character at each speed is valuable.</p><p>The video lets you hear each fan and judge pleasantness for yourself — which is valuable. The limitation is that except for the first segment (38 dBA for both fans), the other three segments don’t compare at equal dBA levels. So what you’re hearing is fans at different intensities, which makes it difficult to isolate sound color from loudness. To compare sound character fairly, equal dBA is needed first.</p><p>Also worth noting: the video tests the P14 Pro, not the P14 Max. These are two different fans with measurably different sound profiles, as my own subjective test shows: 8.2/10 vs 9.2/10 at 36 dBA.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FLAVfS2ANPDA%3Fstart%3D3%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D3&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DLAVfS2ANPDA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FLAVfS2ANPDA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d5478dc671260650818738fe51c8ebfe/href">https://medium.com/media/d5478dc671260650818738fe51c8ebfe/href</a></iframe><p><strong>When PC fans are used in air purifiers</strong></p><p>Some people use PC fans in a different context: DIY air purifiers (and some commercial ones). In that case, the relevant comparison shifts. When evaluating a fan for an air purifier, you want to compare sound pleasantness at equal dBA levels — because what matters is how the purifier sounds at your target noise level, not at maximum speed.</p><p>And even then, sound pleasantness is only part of the equation. You also need to factor in CADR (Clean Air Delivery Rate). If fan A sounds slightly more pleasant at equal dBA but delivers 50% less CADR, you either get insufficient air quality, or you compensate with another machine — which brings its own noise. Sound comfort has two variables: intensity (dBA) and frequency spectrum. Both matter. So does CADR.</p><p><strong>The fan inside a box sounds different</strong></p><p>There’s another layer to this. A fan inside a box with a filter — or inside an air exchanger — doesn’t necessarily produce the same sound spectrum as the same fan in open air. The enclosure, the filter resistance, the airflow path all shape the sound.</p><p>I discovered this with my DIY HRV AccordFlow, built with Arctic P14 Max fans. Inside the unit with a MERV 13 filter, the sound is more pleasant than the same fan in open air — even when tested at a slightly higher dBA level. The sound resembles brown noise: deeper, steadier, more calming. My partner likes it too. It’s been running 24/7 for 18 months.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/565/1*M7Kj8EVYeB62O8LPjglVCA.png" /></figure><p>Listen what brown noise sounds like: <br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t9uWUyuMUc">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t9uWUyuMUc</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*G5bOw0McBxstuduPes-sVA.png" /></figure><p>For reference: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezwIrxOFFqw">Pink Noise</a> — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSZaNwRU-MA">White Noise</a> — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0iGdLDeyeso">Gray Noise</a></p><p><strong>The devil — or the sonic paradise — is in the details</strong></p><p>This is just the beginning of the conversation. We need to avoid generalizing results across different speeds, different models, and different contexts. A fan that sounds great in open air may sound even better — or worse — inside a specific build.</p><p>We need more subjective data from more people, combined with objective measurements. One day, I hope air purifiers will include sound color information in their spec sheets — something like a “brown noise certified” or “white noise profile” label.</p><p>Giving a subjective rating is an invitation for others to share theirs — not to close a discussion, but to open one.</p><p><em>If you have comments or questions, feel free to share them below.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9a2caf184968" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Sound Color of 5 PC Fans — My Subjective Noise Test]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/the-sound-color-of-5-pc-fans-my-subjective-noise-test-d358dbc7490e?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d358dbc7490e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diy-projects]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pc-fan-air-filter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-noise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[air-purifier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pink-noise]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Apr 2026 13:44:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-26T14:06:41.736Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*EG7payda6viuaSUv-h2ZPw.png" /></figure><p><strong>When we talk about the noise level of air purifiers or PC fans, we usually think in terms of decibels. But loudness alone doesn’t tell the whole story — the <em>color</em> of the noise matters too. The distribution of frequencies shapes how pleasant or harsh a fan sounds to the ear.</strong></p><p><strong>With that idea in mind, I decided to run a small experiment to compare the subjective noise character of five PC fans.</strong></p><p>On April 19, 2026, a quiet Sunday morning, I decided to compare the subjective noise quality of five PC fans. Using a <a href="https://www.amazon.ca/-/fr/BAFX-Products-D%C3%A9cibelm%C3%A8tre-pression-acoustique/dp/B00ECCZWWI">BAFX decibel meter</a>, placed exactly 39.4 inches (1 meter) from each fan, I adjusted their speeds so that each produced roughly 36 dBA of sound pressure.<br> Background noise was carefully minimized to 33.6 dBA by shutting windows and nearby machines.</p><p>Setup:</p><ul><li>Fans tested: Silverstone Air Penetrator 184i PRO, Arctic P14 Max, Noctua NF-A12x25 G2 PWM, Noctua iPPC 3000, and Cooler Master SickleFlow 120.</li><li>Power supply equipment: <strong>DC female Plug to 3 x 4 Pin female Adapter Cable </strong><a href="https://www.amazon.ca/PNGKNYOCN-5-5x2-1mm-Computer-Splitter-Adapter/dp/B09HSZKHMV"><strong>(</strong>PNGKNYOCN</a>)<strong> </strong>+ adjustable AC/DC 12V 5A power supply (<a href="https://www.amazon.ca/Universal-Adjustable-Switching-100-240V-Converter/dp/B083GG2H6R?th=1">Facmogu</a>).</li></ul><p>Note The Noctua iPPC 3000 couldn’t drop below 5.18 V without stopping, so it measured slightly higher at 37.8 dBA.</p><p>After matching levels, I rated each fan’s pleasantness of sound from 1 to 10. Personally, I prefer lower-frequency, more uniform sound profiles; sharp or irregular tones feel harsher to me.</p><p>Results:</p><ul><li>Silverstone Air Penetrator 184i PRO — <em>9.5/10</em></li><li>Arctic P14 Max — <em>9.2/10</em></li><li>Noctua NF‑A12x25 G2 PWM — <em>8.7/10</em></li><li>Noctua iPPC 3000 &amp; Cooler Master SickleFlow 120<em>–8.5/10</em></li></ul><p>The Silverstone stood out immediately — even when I first tested it last year, I remember being struck by how smooth and “soft” it sounded. My measurements this time confirmed that impression.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/577/1*iH7rbL4e6-Vnnh86L2D2gg.png" /><figcaption><em>Comparison of five PC fans — Silverstone Air Penetrator 184i PRO, Arctic P14 Max, Noctua NF‑A12x25 G2 PWM, Noctua iPPC 3000, and Cooler Master SickleFlow 120 — rated for subjective sound pleasantnes</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/515/1*7lFBxebrI7-D4rIqzEW1pw.png" /></figure><blockquote>This small experiment was a way to explore how we perceive the “character” of fan noise — beyond the decibel reading. Even when two fans measure the same sound pressure, their sound can feel completely different depending on frequency balance and tonal texture.</blockquote><blockquote>The question of how we experience noise feels increasingly relevant — in computers, air purifiers, and everyday machines that share our living spaces.</blockquote><blockquote>It’s a fascinating area to explore, and one day it would be interesting to measure the actual <em>color</em> of noise produced by an air purifier — at different settings (low, medium, and max) — using a tool that captures its frequency spectrum.</blockquote><p>Update April 26th 2026</p><p>I recently bought some Arctic P14 Pro PST fans for a project, so I added them to the list. The comparison between the P14 Max and the P14 Pro is really striking to me: 8.2/10 vs 9.2/10 It’s very subjective, of course. What sounds pleasant to one person can be tiring to another. But at an equal noise level of 36 dBA, I clearly prefer the sound of the P14 Max . <br> Have you ever compared the sound quality / pleasantness of different fans at the same dBA level? Share you experience in the comments section.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*Ayw5ClH4c42egzVoRHC2Ow.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*aYdVRxwxLp6p0907gslNRA.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d358dbc7490e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Far-UVC Research: 
 Aligning with Existing Air Quality Standards for Particles and Gases]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@levangelistedelaventilation/rethinking-far-uvc-research-aligning-with-existing-air-quality-standards-for-particles-and-gases-85eca55e761f?source=rss-bbd0016264be------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85eca55e761f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indoor-air-quality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ashrae-241]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ventilation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uv-disinfection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Nathalie Ventilation]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Apr 2026 18:18:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-12T20:02:52.943Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/668/1*i0XTzpDijBmhxaExdhYzsQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Far-UVC is gaining attention as a promising tool to reduce airborne infections. But how we study it matters just as much as the technology itself.</strong></p><p><strong>Indoor air is a system. Beyond viruses, we already manage well-documented risks from PM2.5, CO₂, VOCs, ozone, radon, and mold — with existing standards designed to reduce them.</strong></p><p><strong>If we want to evaluate Far-UVC seriously, we need to study it accordingly: not in isolation, and not below these standards, but as part of a complete air quality strategy.</strong></p><p><strong>Toward a More Complete Approach to Studying UVC Disinfection</strong></p><p>We are entering a new phase in the control of airborne infections, where technologies like Far-UVC are being actively explored as part of the solution. The interest is growing, and so is the body of research evaluating both its effectiveness and its safety.</p><p>But there is a fundamental question that remains largely unaddressed: under what conditions are we studying these technologies?</p><p>Indoor air is not defined by a single risk. It is a system. Alongside airborne pathogens, we are already dealing with well-established health risks associated with fine particles (PM2.5) ans gases (VOC’s) such as formaldehyde. For these, guidelines and standards already exist.</p><p>Yet in practice, these standards are very often not met. Ventilation is frequently insufficient, and air purification is rarely deployed at the levels recommended to reduce known health risks.</p><p>If Far-UVC is to be seriously evaluated, it should not be studied in already degraded conditions that fall below existing standards. It should be assessed in environments that meet these standards first, and then evaluated as part of a complete air quality strategy — alongside ventilation and filtration.</p><p>This article is a call to move beyond simplified or underperforming scenarios and toward field studies that reflect what we should be aiming for: indoor environments that already meet established air quality standards, and where additional technologies like Far-UVC can be properly evaluated for both effectiveness and safety.</p><p>This does not mean that studies should ignore the reality that many indoor environments do not meet existing standards. On the contrary, this reality should also be studied.</p><p>In many settings, achieving recommended levels of ventilation and air purification is difficult due to cost, noise, infrastructure limitations, or building constraints. As a result, a large portion of the population is exposed to suboptimal air quality.</p><p>In these contexts, an important question emerges: can Far-UVC contribute to reducing infection risk without worsening other aspects of air quality?</p><p>This opens the door to a second type of study — not as a replacement, but as a complement. Alongside studies conducted under optimal conditions, we should also evaluate scenarios where ventilation and filtration are below recommended levels, and assess whether combinations of partial solutions — such as moderate air purification and UV disinfection — can provide meaningful benefits while remaining within acceptable limits for pollutants like ozone, PM, and VOCs.</p><p>In other words, the goal is not to choose between ideal conditions and real-world constraints, but to study both — and understand what works across this spectrum.</p><p><strong>Far-UVC: Why It’s Worth Considering</strong></p><p>Far-UVC is being explored because it offers something current strategies struggle with: a high capacity to inactivate airborne pathogens without relying solely on airflow.</p><p>We already know that ventilation and air purification can reduce the transmission of infections. In fact, improving air quality alone has the potential to prevent outbreaks — and possibly even reduce the impact of future pandemics.</p><p>One of the most ambitious frameworks in this area is ASHRAE 241, which sets some of the highest targets currently proposed for controlling airborne infections through indoor air. But reaching these levels is not trivial.</p><p>In real-world settings like classrooms and restaurants, achieving the necessary air changes per hour (ACH) is challenging. Space is limited. Noise becomes a major constraint. Cost is another barrier. Even when technically feasible, these constraints make full implementation difficult.</p><p>This is where Far-UVC becomes particularly interesting.</p><p>Unlike ventilation or filtration, it does not rely on moving large volumes of air. It directly inactivates viruses, bacteria, and fungi in the air. In that sense, it offers a complementary pathway to reduce infection risk.</p><p>However, it is important to be clear about what it does and does not do. Far-UVC does not remove particles. It does not remove gases. It targets biological agents in the air.</p><p>And like any intervention, it comes with trade-offs.</p><p><strong>The Trade-Off of Far-UVC</strong></p><p>There are different types of UV technologies, but much of the current attention is focused on Far-UVC at 222 nm. One of the main reasons is its relative safety for eyes and skin at short exposure distances. So far, studies tend to support this safety profile.</p><p>But this is only part of the picture.</p><p>Far-UVC can generate ozone, which can in turn trigger a cascade of chemical reactions in indoor air. These reactions can lead to the formation of additional gases (TVOCs) and secondary particles.</p><p>This concern is not hypothetical. It has been explicitly raised in the scientific literature.</p><p>As noted by Linsey C. Marr and Jonathan M. Samet in a 2024 publication:</p><p>“One concern is that UV light can result in the formation of secondary air pollutants that have adverse health effects, such as ozone, particulate matter, and other compounds… A more complete characterization of risks is needed for this new technology.”</p><p>This highlights an important gap: while the effectiveness of Far-UVC against pathogens is promising, its broader impact on indoor air quality still requires careful study.</p><p>In the next section, we will look at a recent study published in March 2026 that attempts to address some of these questions.</p><p><em>Source :</em></p><p><a href="https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878#con1">Linsey C. Marr</a> and <a href="https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878#con2">Jonathan M. Samet</a>. 10 may 2024.<em> Reducing Transmission of Airborne Respiratory Pathogens: A New Beginning as the COVID-19 Emergency Ends. </em>Environmental Health Perspectives. <a href="https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878">https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878</a></p><p><strong>A Recent Study on Far-UVC and Indoor Air Pollution</strong></p><p>A recent study published in March 2026 in <em>Environmental Science &amp; Technology</em> explores the trade-offs associated with germicidal UV (GUV), including Far-UVC at 222 nm.</p><p>Using a modeling approach, the authors evaluated wavelengths between 185 and 310 nm to assess both disinfection performance and the potential for indoor air pollution. Their results suggest that shorter wavelengths, including 222 nm (far uv), may generate significantly more secondary pollutants — including ozone, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and particulate matter — primarily through ozone formation and subsequent chemical reactions in indoor air.</p><p>The authors conclude that there is no single optimal wavelength that simultaneously maximizes disinfection efficiency, safety, and air quality. They also note that the use of Far-UVC may require the addition of air cleaning strategies to mitigate secondary pollution.</p><p>Source :</p><p>Zhe Peng, Ben Ma, Daven K. Henze, Shelly L. Miller,Joost A. de Gouw &amp; Jose L. Jimenez. March 2026. <em>Is There an Optimal Wavelength for Germicidal Ultraviolet Air Disinfection?</em> Environ. Sci. Technol. <a href="https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.6c02001">https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.6c02001</a></p><p><strong>Modeling vs Real-World Evidence</strong></p><p>The study presented above is based on modeling.</p><p>Modeling is useful to explore mechanisms and generate hypotheses. In science, these hypotheses are meant to be tested.</p><p>It can also help define what to test and how to design the next steps.</p><p>But by definition, modeling relies on assumptions.</p><p>What ultimately matters is how these hypotheses hold in real environments — with actual ventilation, real occupants, and real sources of pollution.</p><p>This is where field studies become essential</p><p><strong>Study Conditions Below Existing Standards (The 1 ACH Issue)</strong></p><p>In the study presented above, the authors model a baseline scenario with 1 air change per hour (ACH) of fresh air and no air purification.</p><p>This choice is justified by the fact that such conditions are commonly observed in buildings. But this raises an important issue.</p><p>These conditions are not aligned with existing standards.</p><p>Ventilation is already widely documented as being below recommended levels in many buildings. Standards such as ASHRAE 62.1 typically require higher levels of fresh air — for example, around 2 ACH in settings like classrooms. In parallel, organizations such as the EPA and Health Canada recommend air purification levels equivalent to about 5 ACH to reduce risks associated with fine particles (PM2.5).</p><p>In other words, the baseline used in the study reflects a degraded environment — one that does not meet the standards already recognized to protect health.</p><p>This matters, because the study evaluates the impact of UVC in this context.</p><p>The authors show that UVC can generate secondary pollutants, including gases and particles. But particles can be effectively removed through air purification, and gases can be diluted through sufficient ventilation. These are not unknown solutions — they are already part of existing recommendations.</p><p>This raises a fundamental question: what are we trying to study?</p><p>If the goal is to improve indoor air and reduce risk, then studying a technology in conditions that fall below existing standards may lead to misleading conclusions. It becomes difficult to distinguish the effects of the technology itself from the effects of an already insufficient baseline.</p><p>An analogy can help illustrate this.</p><p>Studying the side effects of a medication in participants who are given only 300 mL of water per day would likely exaggerate negative outcomes. The issue would not be the medication alone, but the context in which it is tested. What should be tested instead is the medication under normal conditions — where participants follow basic health recommendations.</p><p>The same logic applies here.</p><p>Interestingly, the authors themselves note that UVC may need to be combined with air purification to mitigate secondary pollution. But this combined approach is not explored in their modeling.</p><p>This represents a missed opportunity: rather than testing UVC within a system that already meets established standards, the study evaluates it in isolation, in conditions that are already suboptimal.</p><p>This is precisely the broader perspective emphasized by authors such as Linsey C. Marr and Jonathan M. Samet. As they note:</p><p>“Respiratory pathogens are not the only contaminant of concern in indoor air. Many gaseous and particulate pollutants are known to be harmful to our health, and, as a co-benefit, their concentrations would also be reduced with greater attention to indoor air… Thus, we expect that efforts to improve management of indoor air for the purpose of infection resilience will have co-benefits for our health and well-being.”</p><p>Their point is clear: improving indoor air should not be approached in silos. Efforts to reduce infection risk should also account for other well-established health risks — not ignore them.</p><p>Source :</p><p><a href="https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878#con1">Linsey C. Marr</a> and <a href="https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/full/10.1289/EHP13878#con2">Jonathan M. Samet</a>. 10 may 2024. <em>Reducing Transmission of Airborne Respiratory Pathogens: A New Beginning as the COVID-19 Emergency Ends</em>. Environmental Health Perspectives <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11086747/">https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11086747/</a></p><p><strong>Missing Lamp Type: Not All Far-UVC Is the Same</strong></p><p>The study does not specify the type of lamp used in its modeling.</p><p>Ozone generation at 222 nm is not solely a function of the wavelength. It depends strongly on the design of the lamp and how it is implemented.</p><p>Some lamp technologies, such as Kr-Cl excimer lamps, have been identified as preferable in indoor environments because they are designed to limit ozone production.</p><p>This represents a missed opportunity. The study could have included scenarios using lamp technologies specifically designed to minimize ozone formation.</p><p>If the goal is to evaluate Far-UVC as a potential solution, then it should be assessed under conditions that reflect its best available implementations — not only generic or unspecified ones.</p><p>Leow et al. (2024), citing an earlier study, report that ozone generation at 222 nm depends on lamp design, power, and operating conditions, and that Kr-Cl excimer lamps generate less ozone and are therefore preferable in indoor environments where ozone formation is a concern.</p><p>Source : Chee Huan Leow, Lip Huat Saw, Foon Siang Low. Nov 2024. <em>Investigations of the UVC 222 NM air cleaning system in an air-conditioned room</em>. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/building-and-environment">Building and Environment</a>. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0360132324008321">https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0360132324008321</a></p><p><strong>Toward a More Useful Approach: From Problems to Solutions</strong></p><p>Science is iterative.</p><p>It does not move forward by stopping at potential risks, but by testing, adjusting, and improving solutions in real conditions. The goal is not only to identify what could go wrong, but to understand how things can work.</p><p>A tool is not inherently good or bad. A hammer can build or destroy. The real question is how to use it properly — and under what conditions it becomes useful.</p><p>This is the perspective I propose we use when studying technologies like Far-UVC..</p><p>We already know a great deal about indoor air and health.</p><p>Fine particles (PM2.5) and gases such as formaldehyde, ozone, and radon are well-documented risks associated with disease, hospitalization, and death. Mold is also a significant concern in indoor environments, contributing to respiratory and other health issue. Elevated CO₂, while not a direct cause of mortality at typical indoor levels, has been associated with impacts on cognitive function, sleep, and overall well-being.</p><p>To address these risks, ventilation and air filtration are not new ideas — they are established tools with clear health benefits when properly implemented.</p><p>Standards already exist:</p><ul><li>ASHRAE 62.1 and 62.2 for ventilation (Fresh Air, mostly for CO2 and gases)</li><li>EPA, Health Canada, and AHAM recommendations for air purification (≈5 ACH for particles)</li><li>ASHRAE 241 for infection control</li></ul><p>We are not starting from scratch.</p><p>The problem is that these standards are often not met in practice. Indoor air quality is frequently below recommended levels, which already exposes people to known and preventable risks.</p><p>This context matters.</p><p>If we want to evaluate Far-UVC seriously, we should prioritize studying it in environments that meet existing standards — as a baseline that reflects what we know already works to reduce risks from particles and gases.</p><p>This means:</p><ul><li>adequate ventilation in fresh air (typically 1–5 ACH depending on the setting)</li><li>sufficient air purification (≈5 ACH)</li></ul><p>Together, these already form a strong foundation for reducing health risks.</p><p>From there, Far-UVC can be evaluated as an additional layer — not as a standalone solution.</p><p>The real question is not whether UV is “good” or “bad,” but under what conditions it becomes useful and safe.</p><p>This requires studying combinations:</p><ul><li>UV disinfection (dose, eACH)</li><li>ventilation (ACH)</li><li>filtration (CADR)</li></ul><p>And doing so in real environments.</p><p>What is needed are field studies — not only modeling — conducted in places such as schools, restaurants, and homes, where air is monitored in real time (PM2.5, CO₂, TVOCs, ozone).</p><p>The objective should be simple:</p><p>Which combination works best, here and now, while staying within acceptable health thresholds?</p><p>We should not aim to demonstrate that every solution has flaws.</p><p>We should aim to understand how to make them work together.</p><p>Because while we debate imperfect solutions, exposure to known risks continues. And in this context, taking action — even imperfect — remains better than inaction.</p><p><em>Note: Ventilation alone is not sufficient to address all indoor air risks. Mold requires source removal, and radon may require mitigation measures such as sub-slab depressurization. However, improved ventilation can help reduce concentrations and associated risks in both cases</em></p><p><strong>What an Interesting Study Could Look Like</strong></p><p>Building on the approach outlined above, the next step is to translate it into a concrete study design.</p><p>The objective is to evaluate UV disinfection as part of a complete system, not in isolation. Both control and experimental groups would start from a baseline that already reflects existing recommendations for ventilation and air purification. From there, ASHRAE 241 provides the total equivalent air cleaning target, and UV is used to complete what is missing. In this framework, UV does not replace purification — it complements it.</p><p>ASHRAE 241 allows this flexibility: air can be cleaned through a combination of fresh air, filtration, and disinfection, as long as the total meets the required target.</p><p><strong>A Concrete Scenario: High School Classroom</strong></p><p>Let’s take a concrete case.</p><p>Consider a high school classroom of 1000 ft² with 26 occupants (25 students and one teacher). According to ASHRAE 241, this type of space requires approximately 9.3 equivalent air changes per hour (eACH) .</p><p>Using ASHRAE 62.1 for ventilation, with 10 cfm per person, this corresponds to approximately 2 ACH of fresh air in this scenario. For air purification, recommendations from EPA, Health Canada, and AHAM suggest approximately 5 eACH to reduce risks associated with fine particles.</p><p>This gives a baseline of 7 eACH (2 fresh air + 5 purified). To reach the ASHRAE 241 target, an additional 2.3 eACH is required. This remaining portion can be provided by UV disinfection.</p><p>Note : ACH is calculated as (cfm × 60) ÷ room volume (ft³); here, 10 cfm/person × 26 = 260 cfm, which corresponds to approximately 2 ACH in a 1000 ft² classroom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/671/1*GQGogblk6oHmVrNE1pV8jQ.png" /><figcaption><em>This table is taken from Joey Fox, Equivalent Clean Airflow Rates<br> from ASHRAE 241 — Control of Infectious Aerosols (Part 2).</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*7gALDYDkYYUGHym1OrSxMQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure assembled from ASHRAE 62.1 (Ventilation and Acceptable Indoor Air Quality), showing 10 cfm per person for classrooms (age 9+).</figcaption></figure><p>References</p><p>Joey Fox. July 2023. <em>Equivalent Clean Airflow Rates from ASHRAE 241 Control of Infectious Aerosols (Part 2).</em> It’s Airborne. <a href="https://medium.com/its-airborne/ashrae-241-control-of-infectious-aerosols-part-2-equivalent-clean-airflow-rates-76a511769d4d">https://medium.com/its-airborne/ashrae-241-control-of-infectious-aerosols-part-2-equivalent-clean-airflow-rates-76a511769d4d</a></p><p>Ashrae. Juin 2023. ASHRAE Approves Groundbreaking Standard to Reduce the Risk of Disease Transmission in Indoor Spaces<strong>.</strong><a href="https://www.ashrae.org/about/news/2023/ashrae-approves-groundbreaking-standard-to-reduce-the-risk-of-disease-transmission-in-indoor-spaces">https://www.ashrae.org/about/news/2023/ashrae-approves-groundbreaking-standard-to-reduce-the-risk-of-disease-transmission-in-indoor-spaces</a></p><p>EPA. Guide to Air Cleaners in the Home . <a href="https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/guide-air-cleaners-home">https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/guide-air-cleaners-home</a></p><p>Ashrae. Standards 62.1 &amp; 62.2 . The Standards for Ventilation and Indoor Air Quality<br> <a href="https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/standards-62-1-62-2">https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/standards-62-1-62-2</a></p><p><strong>Study Design</strong></p><p>The study would be conducted in real conditions, with real occupants and continuous monitoring of indoor air quality. Parameters would include PM2.5, CO₂, formaldehyde, TVOCs, and ozone.</p><p>Two scenarios would be compared. The control group would operate with the baseline system only (2 ACH fresh air and 5 eACH purification, for a total of 7 eACH). The experimental group would use the same baseline, with the addition of 2.3 eACH of UV disinfection, reaching approximately 9.3 eACH.</p><p><strong>What We Evaluate</strong></p><p>The study would assess overall air quality. This includes PM2.5, ozone levels, TVOCs, formaldehyde, and other secondary pollutants.</p><p>The objective is to determine whether the system remains safe once UV disinfection is introduced.</p><p>Results should then be evaluated against established health-based standards. For PM2.5, this includes guidelines such as those from the WHO (e.g., ~5 µg/m³ annual average). For ozone, TVOCs, and formaldehyde, existing indoor air quality guidelines provide reference thresholds.</p><p>The key point is not to compare relative increases (e.g., “20× more”), but to determine whether concentrations remain within acceptable limits for health.</p><p><strong>A Different Ratio</strong></p><p>This approach leads to a very different balance than the study discussed earlier.</p><p>In that study, UV disinfection is used at levels of 5 to 20 eACH, with only 1 ACH of fresh air and no air purification. This corresponds to a UV-to-ventilation ratio of 5 to 20.</p><p>In contrast, the approach proposed here relies on a much stronger baseline of ventilation and filtration. With approximately 2.3 eACH of UV over 7 eACH of ventilation and purification, the ratio is about 0.3.</p><p>This is not just a technical difference — it is a fundamentally different way of designing the system</p><p>It reflects how much ventilation and filtration are available to compensate for potential byproducts of UV disinfection. A higher ratio means that UV plays a dominant role, with limited capacity to dilute or remove secondary pollutants. A lower ratio, as in the scenario proposed here, maintains ventilation and filtration as the primary mechanisms, with UV acting as a complementary layer.</p><p><strong>An Iterative Approach</strong></p><p>A school setting provides a useful starting point when existing recommendations are applied. In the classroom example presented here, following ASHRAE 62.1 for fresh air (≈2 ACH) and EPA / Health Canada / AHAM guidance for air purification (≈5 eACH) already provides about 7 eACH of baseline air cleaning. Under these conditions, only a limited amount of additional disinfection is needed to reach the ASHRAE 241 target.</p><p>This makes it a relevant context to evaluate safety under realistic conditions.</p><p>If results are favorable, studies can then be extended to more demanding environments, such as restaurants, where higher targets require different trade-offs between ventilation, filtration, and UV disinfection.</p><p>Progress can then happen through iteration — starting from conditions where systems are already strong, and gradually moving toward more constrained or demanding environments.</p><p><strong>Alternative “Compromise” Scenarios</strong></p><p>At the same time, it is important to acknowledge that many real-world environments do not meet existing standards. In such cases, it can also be useful to study scenarios where ventilation and purification are below recommended levels.</p><p>For example, instead of targeting ASHRAE 241 levels, a study could aim for a total of 5 eACH, accepting that risks associated with PM2.5, CO₂, and VOCs may not be fully controlled.</p><p>In a school setting, this could look like the following:</p><p>The control group operates with 1 ACH of fresh air. The experimental group uses 1 ACH of fresh air, combined with 2 ACH of air purification and 2 eACH of UV disinfection, for a total of 5 eACH.</p><p>These scenarios do not represent optimal conditions, but they reflect real constraints and can help identify what remains possible in less favorable environments.</p><p><strong>Important Clarification</strong></p><p>In the school scenario, the additional disinfection required to meet ASHRAE 241 is relatively limited (≈2.3 eACH), while ventilation and filtration already provide a strong baseline.</p><p>This makes it a relevant context to evaluate both effectiveness and safety under conditions where UV is used as a complement rather than a dominant mechanism.</p><p>A reasonable hypothesis is that, in such conditions — particularly when using lamp designs optimized to limit ozone generation — UV disinfection can be implemented without exceeding established air quality thresholds.</p><p><strong>Looking Forward</strong></p><p>If initial studies are promising, this approach opens the door to a wide range of future research across different environments — including schools, restaurants, healthcare settings, and community spaces.</p><p>Over time, accumulating results could allow for broader synthesis and stronger conclusions.</p><p>At this stage, however, the field is still in its early phases. There is not yet enough evidence to consider the question settled.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85eca55e761f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>