<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Libertine on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Libertine on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@libertinewomen?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:49:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@libertinewomen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do you see what I’m saying? The link between visual culture and empathy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/do-you-see-what-i-m-saying-the-link-between-visual-culture-and-empathy-e6ed0291e8ca?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6ed0291e8ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emoticons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Jun 2015 14:21:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-16T14:22:24.568Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Visual expressions of emotion online both amplify and simplify our emotional literacy — communication barriers are lowered, but is there a risk that we’re just saying less to more people?</blockquote><p>Last month, it was revealed that emoji (picture messaging) is the fastest growing language in the UK, fuelled by the global adoption of smartphones and instant messaging services like What’s App. While it can sometimes feel hard to keep up — or perhaps precisely because of this — it’s clear that pictures &gt; words on the internet. At a broader level, a tacit understanding of ‘pictures or it didn’t happen’ has led to frantic biographical documentation — with visual social networks like Instagram, Pinterest and Tumblr gladly springing up to accommodate. There have been no fewer than three emoji-only social networks –<a href="http://emojicate.com/"><strong>emojicate</strong></a>, <a href="http://emoj.li/"><strong>emoj.li</strong></a> and Steven, which is no longer available. This is a shame as it sounds the most interesting, creating an ‘<a href="http://techcrunch.com/2014/09/04/former-twitter-chief-scientist-launches-steven-an-emoji-based-social-app/"><strong>ambient awareness</strong></a>’ of what you’re doing by tracking your activity or location and logging it in picture format (a cup of coffee if it knows you’re in a coffee shop, or a briefcase if you’re in the office). In theory, this allows your connections to have a more realistic sense of your life activities without you having to tell them, or them having to ask.</p><p>According to Swyft Media, around <a href="http://www.adweek.com/news/advertising-branding/here-s-why-your-favorite-brands-are-making-their-own-emoticons-163325"><strong>6 billion smileys</strong></a> are sent around the world every day. There are 300 million emojis shared daily on Facebook. Businesses are taking notice: Mentos and Coca Cola have released their own branded sets — in the case of Mentos, accompanied by an expensive campaign that sets out the different personality of each ‘ementicon’ (*shudder*) in an attempt to spark some affinity with their target audience. This is a way of infiltrating natural, everyday communication on the brand’s part, but it also demonstrates just how much the use of visual messaging has skyrocketed.</p><p><a href="http://liberti.ne/libertine-100-user/?member_number=70"><strong>Tiffany Watt-Smith</strong></a>, who researches and has written a forthcoming book about the history of emotions, concedes that there is a long history of visually representing emotional states. Even the earliest human language started out in image form, first as pictograms — literal representations of objects — before evolving into ideograms, which communicated more abstract contexts. Their online evolution seems to be tracing a similar path. The first emoticon — <a href="http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/mbj/smiley/smiley.html"><strong>a simple smiley</strong></a> — was used as a cue for how the message should be interpreted (not seriously) rather than being message itself. Today, we’ve got animated emojis to illustrate an increasingly diverse set of situations and even translated versions of literary classics, such as <a href="http://www.emojidick.com/"><strong>Emoji Dick</strong></a>, which raised funding on Kickstarter in 2013.</p><h4>Controlled communication</h4><p>There is no set of guidelines for emoji use, and they have no official names beyond those granted by their users. The language is still evolving — in spite of attempts by the Unicode Consortium, who control which emoticons go into our standard smartphone keyboards, to<a href="http://www.wired.com/2015/05/using-emoji-wrong/"><strong>impose some consistency</strong></a> in their use. Google have patented a text-to-branded-emoji translator which, if successful, would introduce a worrying bias into everyday conversation. Emoticons are also being taken seriously at the highest levels of the law. Sally Bercow’s *innocent face* tweet about Lord McAlpine’s sexual proclivities led to a landmark ruling that emoticons and other symbolic expressions of imagery could be as defamatory as words on their own.</p><p>But Watt-Smith doesn’t understand their appeal. “I’ve never used an emoticon and I don’t imagine myself ever using them. To me they seem incredibly reductive and limiting. It seems strange that people would find them a useful tool for communication.” I know what she means — or I did when I started researching this piece. For a start, you need to know where to find the images you’re looking for before you can type them into a message, which takes away from the fluency of communication altogether. And interpreting other people’s is an even bigger challenge — one missed word or symbol can change the received meaning entirely. You couldn’t (yet) have a reasoned debate in emoji. Burger lips building. What?</p><p>But more experienced emoji users have told me that this does get easier with practice. Like learning a language. And the ability to decipher a message is improved by understanding the sender — their sense of humour, their communication style, their personality. What’s implied is as important as what’s visible. Addie Wagenknecht, co-creator of the <a href="http://www.fastcolabs.com/3024664/under-the-hood-of-the-all-emoji-programming-language"><strong>Emojinal coding language</strong></a>, says that emojis’ limitations may well be where their power lies. Perhaps this is because their lack of precision enables them to do what one journalist called “emotional heavy lifting” in a difficult online exchange. Even if you’re not sure what someone is trying to say to you, a picture can give you a sense of how they’re feeling about it and make you aware that they’re trying to forge some kind of connection through the wires and tubes.</p><h4>Show not tell</h4><p>As we’ve seen, people who are actively engaged in social media — and young people in particular — are constantly aware of their audience and their role as entertainers. Images leave much unsaid and open to interpretation, so their meaning and intention can be defended in line with audience feedback and the threat of social shame. They’re also useful in projecting an aspirational persona, again carefully curated. From one (less flattering) angle, however, this could be seen as a lack of clearly defined personality. With the broadest imaginable pool of influences at their fingertips, people can be everything at once, and this has made them less of any one thing.</p><p>Chris Christodoulou, a media theory and music professor at Westminster who has extensively studied various musical subcultures, has seen this non-commital, pick ’n’ mix approach to identity play reflected in his students’ choice of clothing. Whether it’s a Kid’n’Play haircut blended with grungey trousers, “there’s no distinction between subcultures anymore.” This isn’t surprising when you consider the huge, ahistorical pool of imagery they’re bombarded with online — retro gifs, pins, picture memes, Facebook stickers, vintage-style Instagram shots. They can dip into and play with it without needing to commit to an opinion or statement about what any of it means.</p><p>Chris has also noticed, anecdotally, that some of the most wildly dressed on campus have the least clearly defined personalities when you speak to them; conversely, I wonder whether the blank canvas of ‘<a href="http://www.vice.com/en_ca/read/normcore-is-the-first-brilliant-meme-of-2014"><strong>normcore</strong></a>’ clothing is a direct reaction against this. The more boring you look, the theory goes, the more interesting you are. There’s a parallel to this online, summed up in the reference to having “<a href="http://www.slate.com/blogs/lexicon_valley/2015/01/29/all_of_the_feels_how_we_distance_ourselves_from_emotion_on_the_internet.html"><strong>all the feels</strong></a>”. Writer Katy Waldman describes the emergence of an emotion economy — an OTT spectacle of sentiment influenced by reality TV culture. Being seen to care or feel deeply about something adds to your personal brand value. Hence the outpouring of grief whenever a well-respected celebrity or activist dies — are you really feeling those feels, or just needing to express something? There’s an inverse correlation between actual emotional sentiment and its expression. ‘Feels’ are a way of actually distancing yourself from emotion online. In a lot of cases, the more you say you feel, the less real emotion you’re likely to be experiencing.</p><h4>Cultural difference vs universal meaning</h4><p>It will come as no surprise to anyone that East Asian countries dominate emoji use, partly because they’ve had them for longer and have therefore got more adept and creative at using them. Even simpler emoticons have more creative iterations, such as the ‘angry table flip’ using Kanji characters. A quantitative, big data analysis of emoticon use in 2014 found that more individualistic cultures favoured horizontal and mouth-oriented emoticons, whereas collectivist cultures tend to use vertical and eye-oriented smileys. An interesting nugget-in-a-vacuum, this, as it doesn’t get us any closer towards understanding empathy and visual expression.</p><p>Regardless of any cultural differences or nuances in communication — Spanish-speaking Americans are the heaviest users of the sad face, according to keyboard app <a href="http://swiftkey.com/en/blog/americans-love-skulls-brazilians-love-cats-swiftkey-emoji-meanings-report/"><strong>Swift Key’s recent analysis</strong></a> — there are roughly two main camps, positive and negative. Over 70% of messages in were positive, perhaps unsurprising when you consider the preoccupation with appearing a certain way to your audience. The only <a href="http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1111/jcc4.12063/asset/jcc412063.pdf;jsessionid=8262B9A39385106E9B9670C3A2811291.f01t02?v=1&amp;t=iao3v4mh&amp;s=b36fbaf4ea1da3aef34c2f0e6007b997d80c5985"><strong>work-related study</strong></a> I managed to find, of remote customer service and telesales workers in Scandinavia, found no instances of the frowning face at all in messages exchanged, a fact the researchers attribute to wanting to demonstrate a positive attitude to co-workers and management.</p><p>The universal meaning of the sad and happy face has made them powerfully persuasive when designing for certain behaviours, such as more efficient energy use around the home. More recently, Cambridge University researchers found that putting emoticons on food labels yielded stronger effects on perceptions of taste and healthiness than the colour-coded labels currently being debated by the EC. I refer you again at this point to Google’s branded emoji-translator patent, which gets more disturbing given the potential impact on purchasing decisions.</p><h4>Empathy and ambient attention</h4><p>But while it creates a positive feedback loop in a ‘nudge’ situation, choosing between two binary emotions presents challenges for more nuanced reflection or communication. Perhaps we just don’t yet have the words to fit the varied and complex emotional responses represented by the hundreds of available Facebook stickers. And that’s before you include custom emoji; services like <a href="http://www.imojiapp.com/"><strong>Imoji</strong></a> allow you to turn any image on your phone into a custom sticker.</p><blockquote>Any erosion in language barriers will need to contend with the incessant drive for individualism as self-defining groups of individuals carve out private spaces of secret meaning.</blockquote><p>Reaction gifs are an indicator of this — the Jean Luc Picard facepalm clip both communicates a well-known expression for one broad audience yet carries within it a second layer of knowing for Star Trek fans.</p><p>But perhaps the most significant aspect of the shift to pictorial communication is that it offers up potential for exploring what <a href="http://liberti.ne/libertine-100-user/?member_number=62"><strong>Amber Case</strong></a> calls ‘calm technology’. We process images much faster than text (one commonly quoted stat reckons 60,000 times faster), perhaps we don’t really need to focus on them to understand them. They could be background notifications, at the periphery of our vision but no less powerful, as we saw with the now-defunct Steven app and its quiet but persistent emoji life logging.</p><p>In an age of chaos and constant noise, there’s value in gentle unobtrusive communication — and visual languages could be one possible avenue for this. As Jenna Wortham writes <a href="http://issuu.com/lindseyweber5/docs/emoji_by_womanzine"><strong>in praise of her favourite emoji</strong></a>, picture messages offer “a way to be present when there’s nothing to say at all”.</p><p><em>This piece originally appeared on </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/editions/do-you-see-what-im-saying-the-link-between-visual-culture-and-empathy/"><em>Libertine</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6ed0291e8ca" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/do-you-see-what-i-m-saying-the-link-between-visual-culture-and-empathy-e6ed0291e8ca">Do you see what I’m saying? The link between visual culture and empathy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Empathy tech: solving problems through perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/empathy-tech-solving-problems-through-perspective-5d05110215b0?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d05110215b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[empathy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jun 2015 19:32:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-08T19:32:01.795Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Empathy is a designer’s best friend when thinking about which problems to solve</blockquote><p>Lurking behind every technical product is a problem; a problem designers are attempting to solve through engineering. This fundamental principle has brought us everything from plastic cups that fit snugly in the water cooler dispenser to the lines of code that automatically sync your flight confirmation email with your Google calendar.</p><p>But there’s a meta-problem behind all the challenges which give rise to the objects and widgets adorning our lives: how do designers and engineers know which problems are worth solving?</p><p>One strategy is to take a self-reflexive approach: solve an issue that’s meaningful to you. Software developer Paul Ford designed <a href="http://anxietybox.com/"><strong>Anxiety Box</strong></a> to periodically email himself sentence fragments relating to his personal anxieties. As he describes in<a href="http://gimletmedia.com/episode/the-anxiety-box/"><strong> episode 8 of <em>Reply All</em></strong></a>, trying to repress his internal monologue of anxious thoughts only made it more powerful, so he hoped that externalising it would help him view them objectively. The spam-like formatting of the Anxiety Box’s messages made it easier not to take his negative thoughts so seriously; it helped him reframe his negative self-beliefs into much more manageable (and “ridiculous”) chunks.</p><h4>App therapy</h4><p>Though related to the principles of cognitive behavioural therapy, in which people try to recognise and reframe their negative thought patterns, Anxiety Box was never intended to be a clinical therapeutic treatment for large populations. But some designers are teaming up with scientists to do just that.</p><p>Creative director of Playlab London Simon Fox drew on his experiences with panic attacks to design the game <a href="http://www.flowygame.com/"><strong><em>Flowy,</em></strong></a> which helps players control their breathing. In a talk at London’s<a href="http://www.meetup.com/ThinkDrinkDo/events/213999442/"><strong>Think Drink Do</strong></a> meetup series last year, Simon spoke about the app’s use of gamification to create behavioural change.</p><p>Playlab’s goal is to get <em>Flowy</em> adopted as a clinically recognised therapy by pairing up with researchers at King’s College London and the NHS to conduct controlled trials that can determine its clinical value. Simon Fox believes it’s essential for PlayLab to work with the pace of academic and clinical research — even though it’s at odds with the current trend in software design to release products in quick cycles of rapid change. It means development of <em>Flowy</em> may take longer, but they want to create a more lasting impact through robust product design.</p><h4>The empathy machine</h4><p>For the interdisciplinary team behind <a href="http://www.themachinetobeanother.org/"><strong>The Machine to Be Another</strong></a>, the problem is more existential: how can a person know what it’s like to be someone else?</p><p><a href="http://www.themachinetobeanother.org/?page_id=764"><strong>Their solution</strong></a> “offers users the possibility of interacting with a piece of another person’s life story by seeing themselves in the body of this person and listening to his/her thoughts inside their mind.” Through a combination of VR headsets and a controlled performance environment, the Machine allows one person — the user — to interact with the performance space while another person — the performer — voices an internal monologue and mimics the user’s movements in the VR headset, giving the illusion that the user <em>is </em>the performer.</p><p>The aim is to confront personal biases and promote empathy in personal interactions by literally looking at the world through a new set of eyes. As described <a href="http://www.themachinetobeanother.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/THE_MACHINE_TO_BE_ANOTHER_PAPER_2014.pdf"><strong>in their white paper</strong></a>, the researchers hope that their discoveries around embodied empathy could lead to advancements in conflict mediation, body dysmorphia treatment, accessibility design and more.</p><h4>A sociology toolkit</h4><p>The Empathy Machine is an open-source project that anyone with the technology and the know-how can reproduce. But it operates at an individual level: only one person can experience another person’s story at any given time. For mediating the disjuncture between ‘self’ and ‘other’ on a macro level, the techniques of anthropology, social psychology, and sociology form a useful toolkit.</p><p>Genevieve Bell, user experience strategist at Intel, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/16/technology/intels-sharp-eyed-social-scientist.html"><strong>describes her role</strong></a> as “bring[ing] the stories of everyone outside the building inside the building — and mak[ing] them count.” Including a mechanism in the design process for assessing the needs of consumers is vital, and sometimes it opens up surprising findings: for example, despite the perception that technical innovation is being driven by a young male consumer base, <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/11/why-people-really-love-technology-an-interview-with-genevieve-bell/265596/"><strong>Bell’s data suggests</strong></a>that <a href="http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2012/06/19/genevieve_bell_on_women_and_tech_this_is_not_a_man_s_world.html"><strong>women spend more time online</strong></a>, particularly engaging with social networking. <a href="http://www.techrepublic.com/article/the-state-of-women-in-technology-15-data-points-you-should-know/"><strong>While the tech industry remains predominantly staffed by men</strong></a>, one challenge the industry will continue to face is designing for its largely female consumer base.</p><p>Whether through self-reflexive processes, machine-assisted experiential reframing, or cultural research outcomes, empathy is a key element in assessing which problems have true meaning and urgency in people’s lives. An engineer’s coda to the well-known Socratic principle that the unexamined life is not worth living could be that the un-empathetic product is not worth designing.</p><p><em>Caitlin E McDonald is an anthropologist. </em><a href="https://twitter.com/caitiewrites"><strong><em>@caitiewrites</em></strong></a></p><p><em>Image credit: CC </em><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/meddygarnet/3636225279/"><strong><em>Morgan</em></strong></a></p><p><em>This piece originally appeared on </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/editions/empathy-tech-solving-problems-through-perspective/"><em>Libertine</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d05110215b0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/empathy-tech-solving-problems-through-perspective-5d05110215b0">Empathy tech: solving problems through perspective</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The power of glamour]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/the-power-of-glamour-39c87739bd3a?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39c87739bd3a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2015 08:45:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-30T08:45:54.049Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Glamour is powerful because it’s an illusion — one that tells the truth about who we are and who we want to be</blockquote><p>When we hear the word ‘glamour’, we envision beautiful movie stars in designer gowns or sleek sports cars and the dashing men who drive them. For a moment, we project ourselves into the world they represent, a place in which we, too, are beautiful, admired, graceful, accomplished, powerful, wealthy, or at ease. Glamour lifts us out of everyday experience and makes our desires seem attainable. It creates a distinctive sensation of projection and longing.</p><p>What we find glamorous, like what we find funny, varies with personality and culture. But all glamour promises transformation and escape. In the image of a rising jet or a speeding convertible, a runway model or a martial arts hero, we experience the same dream: that we might soar beyond present constraints to become better, more accomplished, admired, respected and desired versions of ourselves. Glamour lets us project ourselves into new identities, imagining the ideal in the half-known.</p><p>As a result, glamour can be as powerful as it is pleasurable. By focusing previously inchoate yearnings, it motivates not just momentary fantasies but real-world action, from buying holidays and high heels to moving to new cities and pursuing new careers.</p><p>In fact, more than we like to admit, glamour influences our answers to the question “What do you want to be when you grow up?”</p><h4>Stars of their own show</h4><p>For young children, to whom the very idea of adulthood is alluring and exotic, the responses are almost always pure glamour: movie star, athlete, fireman, model, pilot, dancer, and, especially for the preschool set, princess or superhero. Children, their answers tell us, long for lives of power, excitement, beauty, fame, and significance.</p><p>So do adults. Whether experienced as children or young adults, the idealised professions we glimpse through books, movies, and TV shows often determine grown-up career choices — most of which have nothing to do with the stereotypically ‘glamorous’ trades of fashion or show business.</p><p>Longings for beauty or fame aren’t the only desires glamour can serve. “In Michael Herr’s<em>Dispatches</em> he says something about each of us starring in our own movie, picking up cues on how we should act in a given situation from every movie on the subject we’ve seen,’ observes aerospace engineer Dan Hollenbaugh, reflecting on the glamour that shaped his own career choices. “Every man wants to be like Cary Grant. I’d guess that a lot of us choose our life’s work based on the images (written and visual) we pick up from our parents and culture as children.”</p><h4>The appeal of a cool career</h4><p>In the mid-20th century, when Hollenbaugh was young, aerospace was intensely glamorous, just as aviation had been earlier. (RAF pilots were known as ‘glamour boys’ between the wars, a phrase that was both a tribute to the knights of the air and a jab from their Earth-bound comrades.) In the 1950s and 60s, the power and promise of space exploration and supersonic flight featured prominently in popular culture.</p><p>“I’m an aerospace engineer,” says Hollenbaugh, who works on air defense programmes for the US Army, “because of my father’s stories about the US Army Air Force in World War II, because of the war film <em>Twelve O’Clock High</em>, because of the original seven astronauts and the Mercury/Gemini/Apollo programmes when I was a boy, because Fred MacMurray looked so cool playing Steve Douglas, the aero engineer father in the sitcom <em>My Three Sons</em>, with his sleeves rolled up, perched over a drawing board.”</p><p>Howard Roark, the uncompromising hero of Ayn Rand’s <em>The Fountainhead</em>, has similarly inspired countless architects and designers. A generation of American reporters went into journalism because of the glamorous portrayal of Woodward and Bernstein in <em>All the President’s Men</em>. In a tribute to their ongoing allure, the Danish TV drama <em>Borgen</em> includes a poster from the movie starring Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman on the back of its hard-driving young reporter’s apartment door.</p><h4>Glossing over the flaws</h4><p>As a teenager, the economist Paul Krugman — now better known for his fiercely partisan<em>New York Times</em> columns than for the scholarship that won him a Nobel Prize — read Isaac Asimov’s <em>Foundation</em> trilogy. These science fiction classics feature a planned society that is managed using a perfectly predictive science of human behaviour called psychohistory. The idea of “saving civilization through the mathematics of human behaviour” entranced the young Krugman. “I wanted to be a psychohistorian when I grew up,” he writes, “and economics was as close as I could get.”</p><p>In the 1990s American law school applications shot up as the TV show <em>L.A. Law</em> made the lives of litigators seem impossibly glamorous. Writing in the <em>American Bar Association Journal</em>, a critic complained that “in a typical day in La-La Land, beautiful lawyers drive beautiful cars to the beautiful office, discuss sex with twins at a firm meeting, leave for court to win a case that is not only on the ‘right side’ but very lucrative, then go to a beautiful dinner with tonight’s beautiful sexual conquest.” More recently, university forensic science programmes identified the ‘<em>CSI Effect</em>’, as students flocked to a career made suddenly glamorous by crime dramas highlighting the importance of the work and hiding its tedium.</p><h4>The truth in the illusion</h4><p>The word ‘glamour’ originally meant a literal magic spell, and it always contains an element of illusion. Societies aren’t as easily reduced to equations as Isaac Asimov or the young Paul Krugman imagined. Real-life criminalists wait for days or weeks, not hours, for lab results. Aerospace engineers live with endless bureaucratic frustration. Designers and architects can’t simply ignore what clients want. Most reporters never get near the White House.</p><p>But glamour is an illusion that tells the truth about who we are and who we want to be. When LinkedIn surveyed 8,000 members around the world, around a third said they now have either their childhood dream job or a career related to it. Those dreams weren’t just fantasies — they were inspirations.</p><p>Writing in <em>Elle</em>, essayist Emma Rosenblum recalls her college days watching <em>Sex and the City</em>: “Here was a thrilling glimpse of grown-up New York, a place where you could have guiltless sex, wear crazy-stylish clothes, and sip Cosmos with your BFFs without flashing a fake ID.” That glamorous vision was largely an illusion, but it wasn’t entirely false. “Like young Carrie,” Rosenblum writes, “I once dreamed of a life awash in glamour, romance, and pink Martinis. And now I’m a writer in New York. To some extent, you could say I got it.”</p><h4>Eyes on the (fictional) prize</h4><p>Taken as a guide rather than the literal truth, even improbable forms of glamour can channel desire into personal fulfilment. As an impoverished and abused teenager, Oprah Winfrey found her version of career glamour in the TV newsroom of <em>The Mary Tyler Moore Show</em>, a hit sitcom in the 1970s featuring the eponymous actress as a smart and stylish, if sometimes awkward, reporter.</p><p>“I wanted to be Mary,” says Winfrey. “I wanted to live where Mary lived. I wanted Mr Grant [Mary’s newsroom boss] in my life. I wanted my boss to be like that.” A series whose comedy was largely based on embarrassing situations, the show wasn’t intended to be glamorous. But the right audience can always edit away the flaws.</p><p>For Winfrey, the show provided an alluring portrait of friendship, collegiality, meaningful work, personal safety and economic independence. Despite their quirks and sometimes ridiculous failings, the characters lived interesting, fun-filled lives without significant hardship. The setting — the idea and ideal of the characters’ lives — was far more important than the details of any particular plot.</p><p>Following Mary’s example, Winfrey pursued a career in television news. Although she struggled as a news anchor, she soon found her calling as a talk show host. One of the highlights of her triumph as a TV star in her own right was re-creating <em>The Mary Tyler Moore Show’</em>s opening credit sequence, with herself in the leading role. It ends with her tossing her hat joyfully in the air, just like Mary does. “Whenever I’m having a down day,” she told her audience in 1997, “I just pop that recording in. I love that!” She had projected herself into a glamorous fiction and, with a few adjustments, made it come true.</p><h4>It’s not all ideas and dinner parties</h4><p>I also found life-changing glamour in something meant to be anything but glamorous: the portrayal of New York intellectual life in a memoir by Norman Podhoretz, the long-time editor of the magazine <em>Commentary</em>. Published in 1967, <em>Making It</em> was actually something of an exposé, revealing the ruthless ambition and careerist jockeying of people who presumed they were above all such petty concerns. Ambition, Podhoretz argued, was “the prime dirty little secret of the well-educated American soul.” The book was supposed to deglamourise intellectual life.</p><p>But reading it in around 1980 as a college student with nothing against ambition, I found the book’s picture of people arguing about politics and literature over dinner — and making a decent living editing journals of ideas — entrancing. I decided that was what I wanted to do when I grew up. I forgot that New York, crime-ridden, filthy, and expensive, was the last place I wanted to live or that I had absolutely no competence at throwing dinner parties. Glamour always depends on hiding, or in my case ignoring, the flaws.</p><p>Nonetheless, like Oprah, I managed anyway. I’ve never lived in New York and I’m still no good at the dinner thing. But I spent the 1990s doing the exact job I aspired to in college: editing <em>Commentary</em>’s classical-liberal equivalent, <em>Reason</em>, a magazine congenially based in Los Angeles, not New York. The job wasn’t exactly what I imagined, but it was close enough and in some ways better. And now I get to write books on weighty topics like glamour.</p><p><em>Virginia Postrel is the author of </em>The Power of Glamour: Longing and the Art of Visual Persuasion<em> (Simon &amp; Schuster). She is also a columnist for Bloomberg View and </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/libertine-100-user/?member_number=69"><em>a member of the Libertine100</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Join us at The Trouble Club, London, on June 30th for some enchanting ideas with one of the US’s foremost literary and cultural critics. Virginia</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>will take us through the aesthetics of persuasion, from the golden age of Hollywood to Revlon’s striding woman. More information </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/product/libertine-live-the-power-of-glamour/"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39c87739bd3a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/the-power-of-glamour-39c87739bd3a">The power of glamour</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pink vacuum politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/pink-vacuum-politics-93ac53a24d2f?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93ac53a24d2f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Apr 2015 08:43:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-28T08:46:04.966Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>There’s a fine line between creating space for women in politics and ghettoising them. Attempts to tackle “women’s issues” must be inclusive, not exclusive</blockquote><p>I am not a mother. I do not care for an elderly relative. Fortunately, I do not suffer from domestic violence. These topics still interest me in a general way, and I recognise that women are disproportionately affected by many related issues. I am also, whilst happening to be a woman, interested in the economy, the environment, welfare, foreign policy… the list goes on. I am not alone.</p><p>When Harriet Harman listed the former as among the topics the now infamous Pink Bus would include in its attempts to engage women, it was the exclusion of the latter from the list that really alienated me. Perhaps some of the 9 million women who didn’t vote in the last election, the women who are now being targeted by such schemes, feel the same way. Perhaps, just perhaps, some of the 9 million women who didn’t vote last time around have the same motivations and concerns as some of the 8 million men who didn’t vote.</p><h4>The kitchen vs the boardroom table</h4><p>The most damning moment for the Pink Bus was the description from Lucy Powell, general election co-ordinator, claiming Labour wanted to “have a conversation about the kitchen table, and around the kitchen table” not an “economy that just reaches the boardroom table”.</p><p>This polarisation is toxic. It’s retro sexism of the highest degree, but it’s also a first rate example of the problems which can arise when women’s participation and what are described as “women’s topics” are boxed separately from the larger spectrum of political issues. Household economy and the boardroom are not mutually exclusive interests, nor are they unrelated.</p><p>Fortunately, as I spend exactly zero time at school gates and more time at work than loitering in shopping centres (although when I do, please don’t zone in to talk childcare at me whilst I’m elbowing my way down the sale rack) I’m unlikely to be approached by the Pink Bus in my natural habitat.</p><blockquote>I’m a moving target, like lots of women, unable to be pinned down by out-of-date ideas on what I’m thinking.</blockquote><h4>“Women’s issues”</h4><p>It’s been observed that when women talking politics stray too far from anything considered a “pink” topic, the opposition, and at times abuse, becomes louder and more dismissive, from politics to sports to video game journalism. Declaring the boundaries of what constitutes women’s interests excludes an awful lot of topics that affect them equally as much, or even more. Misguided schemes like this, and attempts to dismiss or attack women’s contributions have some thoughts in common.</p><p>As a feminist, I’m heartened that more and more men feel able to take on the role of primary caregiver in their families. Women still shoulder the vast majority of childcare, but stay at home fathers have been on the sharp increase for the last decade. This happens for two primary reasons: a cultural shift in attitudes towards family roles, and because of a growth in female breadwinners. In this context too, and for “women’s issues”, what happens in the boardroom is relevant to the kitchen table.</p><h4>Engaging with the wider picture</h4><p>Because women are still underrepresented in politics across the spectrum, from elected posts to discussion panel appearances, creating space for a greater number of women to engage with politics is an important strategy in tackling inequality. The concerns, and importantly, voices, of those who really do care first and foremost about childcare and the kitchen budget shouldn’t and don’t exist in a pink vacuum. Attempts to specifically engage with women work when the focus is to welcome women into the wider political arena as a whole, and to empower and encourage women to discuss foreign policy as well as domestic abuse. Grassroots campaign group <a href="http://www.womenforindependence.org/"><strong>Women For Independence</strong></a> recently ran seminars on introductory economics, an example of a practical way to encourage women to engage with the wider picture.</p><p>These things work when women’s voices aren’t segregated to the kitchen. And they work when domestic abuse, sexual assault, childcare and so on aren’t seen as just women’s issues, separate from the bigger picture, but part of it, and tackled within it. Inclusive, not exclusive.</p><p><em>Laura Waddell is an Edinburgh-based literary assistant, writer, and freelance digital marketing strategist. </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/editions/pink-vacuum-politics/@lauraewaddell"><strong><em>@lauraewaddell</em></strong></a><em>. Image credit: </em><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/3943074133/in/photolist-71rhyM-722Wdy-6ZJmjk-6ZJmb2-7QpsVw-7iqUDU-9whuTR-7oe4o3-7oe4xw-8iLTn9-7m66Qd-7QDVo9-7mwHUX-6ZNmp3-71rhtP-7mABBL-7VQP51-7izu9v-7iDs1q-8j1AkG-7jB8Gt-7iDrmC-7oe4HW-7jFnZu-8hkKxa-7iF9FB-6XVG8G-7oa9Wk-7LMNa3-7KvAzg-7hTgAX-7STqt4-7oa9YB-7VtQKt-8h5dns-7WoyQj-7oanwT-8hp14w-7in4ha-7iRf8d-8iLTtb-7mXptF-7L8aqL-7kTN2f-7Qm8PZ-7hTgHc-7h9t2c-71vgxw-7myfCU-7khLgz"><strong><em>James Vaughan</em></strong></a></p><p><em>This piece originally appeared on </em><a href="http://liberti.ne/editions/pink-vacuum-politics/"><em>Libertine</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93ac53a24d2f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/pink-vacuum-politics-93ac53a24d2f">Pink vacuum politics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FAKE IT ’TIL YOU MAKE IT]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/fake-it-til-you-make-it-aefcb3ab8bf3?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aefcb3ab8bf3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2015 22:41:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T22:41:35.127Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Fake it ‘till you make it</h2><blockquote>There’s a complex and often comedic dance of imitation, improvement and innovation between East and West, spanning hundreds of years. Can counterfeit products ever be good for business?</blockquote><p>Say the words ‘copy’ and ‘China’ to Westerners today and most will think of Silk Alley counterfeits, Shenzhen knock-off factories, Guangdong sweatshops, or Nanjing’s legendary fake mall with its frontage of entirely bogus outlets such as <em>Haagon-Bozs</em>, <em>Pizza Huh</em>,<em>Buckstar Coffee</em>, <em>KFG </em>and <em>McDnoalds</em>: the brainchild of a property developer who wanted to create buzz around his new development.</p><p>Not quite so amused by the knock-offs are the businesses, mostly in the West, who are losing money as a result of the estimated US$600 billion worth of fakes produced every year. Most are made in China, currently the world’s leading counterfeiting superpower. What manufacturers would prefer to keep a lid on, is that at least one in ten of the goods you buy — from luxury brands to smartphones — is a fake.</p><p>But is it a zero-sum game: are counterfeits as good news for the faker as they are bad news for the faked, or can copying actually be good for business? Can imitation help to create industry and benefit the economy?</p><h4>There’s a reason it’s called China</h4><p>A glimpse into the past suggests it often does. A mere three hundred years ago the current roles were reversed: only China had the technology to be able to make that most desired of luxury goods — porcelain, and the West were desperate to develop, copy or hack the secret of its manufacture.</p><p>Known as ‘white gold’ by kings and nobles (incidentally the only ones who could afford its exorbitant price), porcelain is still called ‘china’, a direct result of the 1000-year hold the Middle Kingdom had over the secrets of this exquisite pure white ceramic.</p><p>Hugely prized, yet seemingly impossible for anyone, other than the Chinese to make, porcelain was translucent to the light, gave out a clear melodious ‘ting’ when tapped, was thin walled yet diamond-hard, and most of all was easy to distinguish from the rough, mud-coloured, earthenware pottery made for everyday use. It was perfect for conspicuous consumption.</p><h4>Flaunting the family crest</h4><p>Both nobles and the new rich (mostly moneyed merchants) in Europe began to send instructions and designs for customised porcelain to the Imperial Workshops at Jingdezhen. By the early 1700s, the really smart show-off thing was to have a made-to-order dinner service with your coat of arms hand-painted onto each piece.</p><blockquote>21st century celebrities may flaunt other peoples’ logos but the ultimate in 18th century bling was to flaunt your own.</blockquote><p>The services were vast collections, numbering up to two or three hundred pieces: plates, serving dishes, tureens, soup bowls, ewers, mustard jars, washing jugs — even chamber pots; the last word in matchy-matchy homeware. The more important the family, the more bombastic the arms blazed across their tables and displayed in their rooms.</p><p>Around 1715, one Sir Edward Harrison, who had made a fortune during a spell in India, ordered a porcelain service from China. At the centre of each piece, on a single shield, was to be Harrison’s and his wife’s coats of arms side-by-side: a blue (‘<em>azure</em>’ in the old French used for heraldic colours) cross on a silver- white (‘<em>argent</em>’) background, next to three bird’s claws on a yellow gold (‘<em>or</em>’) ground with a black (‘sable’) chevron.</p><p>The instructions were on a pencil drawing of the family coats of arms complete with little arrows to indicate which bits should be filled in which colour. The service took around two years to make, and when the porcelain finally arrived back in England it was an occasion of great excitement. The chests were broken open to reveal that the Chinese craftsmen had rendered the design faithfully.</p><p>Rather too faithfully, in fact: every piece had carefully painted onto it a perfect facsimile of the pencilled coat of arms from the instructions. There were no colours, but each detail had been immaculately copied by the Jingdezhen artists, right down to the little arrows and scrawled directions indicating ‘<em>sable </em>here’ and ‘<em>argent</em> there’.</p><h4>A blurred line between faker and maker</h4><p>Amusement aside, we don’t really like unauthorised imitation. We call unofficial copies ‘fakes’ or ‘counterfeits’: our words for replicas we haven’t asked for. Once you commission the copies, they become legitimate.</p><p>No longer ‘fakes’, we say instead that we subcontracted the manufacture or franchised the outlets. A copy that has our blessing cannot be a fake. We also have a convention that you can’t fake yourself, so if a designer makes a cheaper version of their fashion brand, it’s not a knock-off but a ‘diffusion line’ or an ‘entry level range’.</p><blockquote>It doesn’t excuse forgers to point out that ‘original’ and ‘fake’ are complex concepts, sometimes depending more on the intention or permission behind a product than the innovation and creativity of the maker, or to point out that originators sometimes copy, and imitators frequently innovate.</blockquote><p>The ebb and flow of ideas is the lifeblood of business; designs are disseminated along with the ocean currents of trade. Often, imitation is simply the first step towards innovation.</p><h4>Shanzai and “virtuous banditry”</h4><p>China is currently in the grip of an epidemic of innovation, the result of the extraordinary rise of ‘Shanzai’ culture. Although the word <em>Shanzai</em> is now used as shorthand for imitation or pirated goods, it comes from the word for a mountain village or stronghold that is far away from official control.</p><p>From there it crept into Cantonese slang where it was used metaphorically to describe bandits or outlaws: folk-hero Robin Hood types who broke the law to get around a system that was itself corrupt. Over the past ten years, as small family firms set up unregulated factories and workshops making cheap knockoffs and imitations of Western products, these too became known as <em>Shanzai</em>.</p><p>Western companies, such as Nokia and Apple, had set up factories in China, but their goods were too expensive for the local market. <em>Shanzai</em> products — seen as a kind of virtuous banditry — were lower quality and borderline illegal, but at least they were sold at prices Chinese consumers could afford.</p><p>By the mid to late noughties production, clustered around Shenzhen and the Pearl River Delta, was booming with tens of thousands of companies producing their own versions of desirable consumer goods. The market exploded with the rise of the cell phone. <em>Shanzai </em>handsets cost a similar amount to manufacture as the real thing, around $US20, but knock-off versions of the iPhone such as the <em>HiPhone </em>and the <em>SciPhone</em>, and the splendidly anagrammed <em>iOrgane</em>, (‘iOrange’) sold for just $US100–150.</p><h4>When the original’s no longer best</h4><p>By 2007, <em>Shanzai</em> phone sales were 1.5 million a year, a tenth of the world total. Within four years the percentage had risen to <em>a quarter</em> of global cell phone sales. The outlaws were on a roll, but something even more extraordinary was happening. Freed from the dead hand of Chinese government regulation, the near impossibility of being granted permission to become an official cell phone manufacturer and, it must be admitted, free from any concern about IPR and copyright law, the <em>Shanzai</em> phone makers began to innovate and improve on the original products.</p><p>They tried combinations Western manufacturers hadn’t thought of. Why have just one sim card when you can have two, and use the second to roam around and find the cheapest rates? Why not combine a phone with a UV detector light to spot counterfeit notes — a nice example of a fake being used to detect a fake? Or make phone chargers that run on solar power?</p><p>The manufacturers used humour and topicality to drive up sales. For the Kenyan market during the 2008 US presidential election, the <em>Obomophone </em>(sic) with a picture of the man on the back and sporting the motto “Yes We can” was a bestseller. Mainstream manufacturers began to copy <em>Shanzai</em> ideas, and by 2010 Samsung and LG had produced multi-sim card phones.</p><p>When BYD, a Shenzen electric car manufacturer with a suspiciously familiar logo and an inspiring name — BYD stands for ‘Build Your Dreams’ — joined forces with a company that had developed a longlife battery to produce eco-friendly <em>Shanzai</em> electric cars that sold for just US$2–3000 dollars each, no less than the Sage of Omaha himself, investor Warren Buffett, paid US$230million for a 10% stake in the company.</p><h4>Counterfeit culture</h4><p>By this time, the Chinese were also using the word <em>Shanzai</em> for cultural piracy. Establishment events, ones where ordinary people had no input, were being spoofed by grassroots versions. There was a<em> Shanzai</em> ‘Nobel Prize’ and a <em>Shanzai</em> ‘Olympic Torch Relay’. Cumbersome Chinese state TV spectaculars such as the National Spring Gala were <em>Shanzai</em>’d; even state TV channels such as China Central TV (CCTV) was aped on the internet by the super low cost ‘CCSTV’ (China Countryside TV).</p><p>Meaning was beginning to shift. <em>Shanzai</em> was coming to mean less ‘bandit’ and more ‘by the people for the people’. Less ‘poor quality pirate goods’; rather goods made with a special sort of Chinese ingenuity and imbued with a peasant pride. The outlaw had become mainstream.</p><p>The West took note. Influential <em>Wired</em> editor, David Rowan, was an early enthusiast for <em>Shanzai</em>-style innovation, if not for their buccaneering ways with intellectual property rights.</p><blockquote>Earlier this year, observing the shift in meaning, <em>The Economist</em> wrote that <em>Shanzai</em> “used to mean pirated electronic goods but now stands for open source manufacturing.” Imitation had morphed into innovation.</blockquote><h4>The imitation game</h4><p>History frequently repeats itself but never in quite the same way: the patterns are familiar; the names change. If Country A has a proprietary technology and profitable captive markets, this encourages copyists in Countries B, C, D, E and possibly F.</p><p>At first, they can only manage cheap second rate imitations, but even these are good for trade as there are plenty of consumers in Country A who can’t or won’t buy the top class stuff, but are happy to buy the cut-price version.</p><p>On the back of this trade, the countries build new industries, learning about export markets as they do so. Eventually the proprietary technology secrets of Country A are bought, borrowed, stolen or reinvented by the most enterprising of Countries B to F, and the creative ferment begins, and genuinely new and innovative ideas are developed.</p><p>Three decades ago, the West was Country A, and the East in the form of the Japanese were mocked as industrial copycats much as the Chinese are today. But then Toyota revolutionised carmaking; SONY gave us miracles of miniaturisation including that grandfather of the iPod, the Walkman; there were digital cameras and copiers; Nintendo machines and super-noodles; LCD screens and hybrid cars, and gradually the world began to acknowledge that although Japan hadn’t invented these industries, it had come to dominate them.</p><p>Three hundred years ago, the roles of East and West were reversed. China was the country with proprietary porcelain technology; the West the would-be imitators. Whilst the Chinese guarded the precious secret of their ‘white gold’ the West tried, with limited success, to mimic the distinctive mix of kaolin and minerals, the high temperature kiln-firing that vitrifies — quite literally turning into glass — the particles of clay in the mix to give the pure white luminously beautiful, nail-hard porcelain.</p><p>But the Europeans could never get the sheen quite right: their mixes were full of gritty impurities; their clay was too spongy and, with anything other than simplest shapes, the soft paste buckled and bulged out of shape in the kiln. At the peak of the fever to discover the secret of porcelain and break the Chinese hold on the trade, Emperor Augustus the Strong of Saxony employed an alchemist called Böttger to work on the formula, keeping both him and the workers at the Meissen factory as virtual prisoners.</p><p>Böttger is usually credited as being the first to have experimentally discovered how to make porcelain, but around the same time, Chinese manufacturing secrets were being stolen by a most unlikely hacker.</p><h4>The mischievious missionary</h4><p>In 1712 a French Jesuit priest, Francois Xavier d’Entrecolles, wrote a letter from Jaochow [Jao-chou] to a fellow priest in Paris. D’Entrecolles notes that while staying in Jingdezhen [Ching-tê-chên] “to administer to the spiritual necessities of my converts”, he became interested in the manufacture of porcelain. He then writes, somewhat disingenuously: ‘Nothing but my curiosity could ever have prompted me to such researches, but it appears to me that a minute description of all that concerns this kind of work might, somehow, be useful in Europe.’</p><p>Really? Nothing but ‘curiosity’? Would just ‘curiosity’ warrant ‘a minute description of all that concerns this kind of work’? At what point does curiosity become spying? It seems that Father D’Entrecolles, in between ministering to his flock, took time to question closely those congregants who worked in one particular trade and even do a little reading himself. As he continues: ‘I believe I have obtained a pretty exact knowledge of all that concerns this beautiful art’.</p><p>In what today would be regarded as flagrant industrial espionage, D’Entrecolles published the details of Chinese porcelain manufacture in two letters in 1712 and 1722. In the decades following publication, transcripts turned up in places as far apart as Josiah Wedgewood’s<em>Commonplace</em> book and Diderot’s <em>Encyclopedie</em>; new potteries were set up in France and Britain. Chinese exports shrank markedly, much as Western trade suffers today from Chinese imitations.</p><h4>A Western retelling</h4><p>But there was also a flourishing exchange of ideas between China and the West that led to the 18th century mania for Chinoiserie in art, architecture, interiors and gardens. The master ceramicists of China developed new styles, shapes and decoration in order to appeal to changing western tastes.</p><p>The dazzling late Ming-inspired <em>famille verte</em> combined a luminous palette of translucent enamels, dominated by shades of green, with accents of yellow blue and red that coincided with the early 18th century appetite for baroque. The exquisite <em>famille rose,</em> with its rococo emphasis on flowers painted with a gold-based rose enamel, and the later monochrome pieces known as <em>encre de chine: </em>delicate fine-line painting in black ink to resemble engravings or book illustrations.</p><p>Ideas travelled in both directions. Chinese-style Willow pattern china first became popular in England in the late 18th century and 200 years later is still in use. When I was at school we ate our lunch off a rather chunky earthenware version, and I was entranced by the legend of the star-crossed lovers told by the pattern on the plate: the beautiful Koong-se falls in love with her father’s servant and defies her parent’s plans to marry her off to a Duke by running away with him; the pair are captured and killed but subsequently turned into doves by Gods moved by their plight.</p><p>What I didn’t know was that the story was invented by the 18th century English porcelain manufacturer, Thomas Minton, in order to promote sales of his blue and white chinaware. Some components of the legend do turn up in genuine Chinese folklore, but Thomas Minton’s version is a Shanzai’d story that makes Chinese who hear about it smile at its comical misinterpretation, much as Westerners smile at ‘Dolce &amp; Banana’.</p><h4>Faking things up</h4><p>Luxury markets evolve. Today’s novelty item is tomorrow’s ‘must have’. If the West hadn’t craved and copied the Chinese ‘White Gold’, there would be no Sevres or Spode, no Wedgewood or Meissen. If China hadn’t been adept at incorporating — or faking as it would be called centuries later — foreign influences into its products, the fissile exchange of East-West design would have been much the poorer.</p><p>Without <em>Shanzai</em> manufacture, millions of people in the developing world would not be able to afford mobile phones, laptops and other modern essentials. To imitate is to begin to climb the slopes of invention; copies are just the baby-steps of creativity. By standing on the shoulders of others, new ideas can reach the light.</p><blockquote>The phrase ‘intellectual property’ was only coined a hundred years ago, the concept of copyright is barely three centuries old, but the succession pattern of imitation, creation and innovation goes back to the dawn of time. You don’t invent out of thin air, you build on and make something new out of what went before or, as business jargon has it, you ‘add value’.</blockquote><p>Adding value is what China is busy doing now. The first wave, the boom years, were export driven fuelled by cheap manufacturing, cheap money, open foreign markets — and yes, ‘borrowed’ ideas and technology. But times move on. There are newer, cheaper manufacturers on the block, such as Vietnam and India.</p><p>China is becoming a creator: it’s the country that files more intellectual property applications than any other. As with the porcelain wars, a turning point has been reached and soon the West will be looking at China with different eyes. Perhaps they should be a little less worried about knock-offs from the East and more worried about being left behind on key technologies, markets, insights and designs.</p><p>And what of Sir Edward Harrison and his consignment of unusable porcelain? Pieces with the pencilled instructions for the coat of arms are still in existence and in good condition, possibly because they were hidden away in a cupboard and never used. But we do know that Sir Edward put the unfortunate episode down to experience, and that the Chinese learned from their mistake, for Sir Edward ordered no fewer than six more sets of ‘armorial’ porcelain — and this time he got them all in the right colours.</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aefcb3ab8bf3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/fake-it-til-you-make-it-aefcb3ab8bf3">FAKE IT ’TIL YOU MAKE IT</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Turning vaginas into pop stars]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/turning-vaginas-into-pop-stars-352d2953c34a?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/352d2953c34a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2015 22:40:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T22:40:58.686Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Art modelled on vaginas isn’t obscene — it’s empowering, says Japanese artist Megumi Igarashi</blockquote><p>Artist and <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">Libertine 100</a> member <a href="http://liberti.ne/libertine-100-user/?member_number=39"><strong>Megumi Igarashi </strong></a>was arrested last year for making a 3D printed kayak which she dubbed her “pussy boat”. Thanks to an online petition, she was released — only to be arrested again in November 2014 on fresh obscenity charges.</p><p>Megumi, who goes by the name Rokudenashiko (‘good-for-nothing kid’ or ‘reprobate child’), now faces up to two years in prison. We caught up with the artist about gender politics and freedom of expression in Japan — and what if anything those across the globe can do to help.</p><p><strong>You’ve said that you want to make vaginas “casual and pop.” Could you tell us more about your artwork’s message?<br></strong>The vagina has been despised in Japanese culture for centuries, and it has always been a taboo word. Even when it was portrayed artistically, it was sexualised, and from a male perspective. In Japan, where traditional (male) culture dominates, there’s a subculture called <em>Kawaii</em> (meaning “cute” in Japanese) in which women were able to create for themselves. An artist called Kyray Pamyu Pamyu uses <em>Kawaii</em> subculture as a vehicle for fame. Similarly, I want to use kawaii culture to make vagina imagery more shareable and fun.</p><p><strong>Considering Japan has a penis festival, what do you think makes your vagina-inspired artwork “obscene”?</strong><br>In Japan it’s acceptable for men to talk about their penis and how horny they are but it’s a completely different story when it comes to women. It is absurd but it is almost thought that women don’t have any sexual desires.</p><p><strong>Japan is notorious across the world for its fetish pornography. Campaigners have been calling for tougher laws on child pornography for a long time. But despite this seemingly lenient attitude, an image of an actual, anatomically correct vagina gets censored. Why do you think this is?</strong><br>Japanese laws are made around heterosexual men and still full of prejudice.</p><p>I’m going to continue to create my art. The police don’t like it and I’m sure I’ll get caught again, but that won’t stop me.</p><p><strong>Do you have many supporters in Japan?</strong><br>Yes, my fanbase has recently increased but societal attitudes mean that not many people really understand what i’m trying to do.</p><p><strong>In an interview, you spoke about how you previously underwent vaginal rejuvenation surgery because you felt ashamed of your body. Do you think other women feel this way about their genitalia in Japan?</strong><br>I think most women are insecure about their vagina, and with good reason. As a child if you start talking about it, your mother would tell you to “be quiet! That’s a very embarrassing thing to talk about”.</p><p><strong>On your website, you describe your “Decoman Workshops”, where women make moulds of their vaginas and decorate them. What did the women get out of these workshops?</strong><br>Most women are too embarrassed to look at their own vaginas. If you actually make a model of it you realise it’s not that frightening. It’s a great opportunity to become friends with it, for starters. I think the experience has given many women the power to start questioning their values in life, the importance to start thinking for themselves, and to become more creative.</p><p><strong>Is your arrest indicative of a wider culture of sexism and censorship in Japan?</strong><br>Absolutely yes. It’s a big, deep-rooted problem.</p><p><strong>What can people in the UK and across the world do to help you now?</strong><br>Japan is very timid against foreign pressures, and I think the best way to help is to cause a big stir worldwide. My court hearing will start in February or March, so I would love for the media to cause a big fuss.</p><p>I will also be selling Vagina character goods on <a href="http://ganka.buyshop.jp/"><strong>my website</strong></a> (pictured), and the profits will be put towards the court fees. If you can’t read Japanese please <a href="/service/mailto:info@gankagarou.com"><strong>send an email</strong></a> and we will sort you out.</p><p><strong>Do you think art has the power to change people’s attitudes towards women for the better? Do you think your art can make a difference?</strong><br>It’s such a small step, but since my incident I am happy to hear that some women are able to think positively about their body. This double standard that Japanese society had been ignoring has now come to light. Finally I am delighted to it’s also fired up online debate about freedom of expression.</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=352d2953c34a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/turning-vaginas-into-pop-stars-352d2953c34a">Turning vaginas into pop stars</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The seven steps of being in beta]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/the-seven-steps-of-being-in-beta-2d2e2a07a957?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d2e2a07a957</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2015 22:40:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T22:40:14.444Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>We learn by testing and making mistakes — find out how to take a beta approach to life and business.</blockquote><p>My friend Angela’s restaurant was one of the first Detroit-style pizzerias in the south. The deep-dish, sauce-on-top pie garnered stellar reviews, and spawned a loyal fan base.</p><p>But there was a problem: people kept trying to order thin crust. This was around the time low-carb diets were all the rage, and not everyone was thrilled by the inch-thick layer of dough beneath their toppings.</p><p>After the buzz of opening night died down, customers dwindled, and Angela began to worry. She weighed her options. She could stay the course, serving the best Detroit-style pizza in Austin, and hoping the rest of the city would catch up to the trend. Or she could rethink her concept and expand the menu.</p><p>She went with the second option. The next night for dinner, she placed three paper-thin pizzas on the dinner. “Boys,” she said. “Eat up. You’re gonna help me develop the best thin-crust in the city.”</p><p>Fifteen years later, Angela has three pizzerias, proudly serving Detroit-style, thin-crust, and a handful of heavenly baked pasta dishes. Reviewers often refer to Angela as a “triple threat” of casual Italian cuisine.</p><h4>Beta is better</h4><p>I asked my friend how she felt during that first, dicey year in business. “It was scary. Most of our life savings were in that restaurant. But I never let myself feel defeated. I stayed in Beta.”</p><p><em>Being in Beta</em> was a phrase she had picked up from her husband, the computer geek. In programming speak, <em>Beta</em> refers to the first phase of testing open to a public audience. Beta versions are usually crude and unattractive, but they get the job done. Many times, the Beta version will reveal design flaws and quirks. That’s the whole point — to try something, to see if it fails, and if it does, to try again.</p><p>I asked Angela to expand, and she outlined the seven steps of Beta:</p><ol><li>Knowing your goal. (“I’m going to open the best Detroit-style pizza in Austin.”)</li><li>Failure. (“Oh no! Not everyone likes Detroit-style pizza.”)</li><li>Overcoming Perfection (“It’s okay that not everyone likes this pizza. We’ll expand the menu.”)</li><li>Testing (“Boys, try these three varieties of thin-crust, and tell me what you think.”)</li><li>Using Resources (“Mom, the sauce is gross, but the crust is great.”)</li><li>Listening (“I’ll keep the crust, ditch the sauce.”)</li><li>Constant Improvement (“Boys, here are three more pizzas. What do you think?”)</li></ol><h4>Making room for improvement</h4><p>Think about your own life. Are you in beta? Do you set clear goals for yourself? Are you hungry for improvement? Do you surround yourself with friends and colleagues who are pushing to be better, or is your social circle full of people who are always <em>talking </em>about doing something but never seem to get anything done?</p><p>I used to work with a guy who would send an email to all his co-workers at the end of the month. He would ask how he could improve in certain areas of his work. This guy was always in Beta, always improving. Before long, the trend caught on.</p><p>Soon we were all exchanging emails and meeting in small groups. We would set individual and collective goals. Then we’d pick each other’s brains, determining how far we had come. If we fell short, we learned from our mistakes and tried a new strategy. If we succeeded with flying colours, we’d set our sights higher.</p><p>There’s a lot of talk about “being the best version of yourself.” That’s a pretty tall order, isn’t it? Get over perfection paralysis. Forget about being the best version of yourself, and start being the <em>beta</em> version of yourself.</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d2e2a07a957" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/the-seven-steps-of-being-in-beta-2d2e2a07a957">The seven steps of being in beta</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social justice on a comet]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/social-justice-on-a-comet-4a76c794f70f?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a76c794f70f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2015 22:39:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T22:39:43.838Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Must we choose between fundamental research and social justice? No. The two go hand in hand, says <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">Libertine 100</a> member Anais Rassat</blockquote><p>In these tough economic times, would money spent on blue-skies research — <a href="http://xkcd.com/1446/"><strong>like the recent comet landing</strong></a> — be better spent on urgent humanitarian and societal problems?</p><p>In 1970, just after the moon landing, the great <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/05/gil-scott-herons-poem-whitey-on-the-moon/239622/#disqus_thread"><strong>Gil Scott Heron released a song called “Whitey on the Moon” which lamented</strong></a>:</p><p>“I can’t pay no doctor bills<br>But Whitey’s on the moon.”</p><p>The song contrasted the reality of African-Americans’ everyday life with the scientific and technological advances of the cold war space race.</p><p>The question was laid out: can one think about the cosmos — and spend precious money trying to understand it — when so many inequalities still need to be addressed?</p><p>I strongly believe that we need not choose between fundamental research on one side and social justice on the other. In fact we <em>cannot</em> choose.</p><p>Throughout history, <a href="http://anaisrassat.tumblr.com/post/99041370836/its-friday-let-me-tell-you-about-einsteins"><strong>fundamental research, technological and societal advances have continuously advanced side by side</strong></a>. Scientific research in quantum mechanics in the early 20th century brought us the information age, which has revolutionised so many aspects of the world we live in today. Today’s technology and economy are inherently linked to those early scientific advances. Society and the way people interact, communicate and inform themselves have all been profoundly transformed too.</p><p>Historically, there are many more examples of these inherent links between science, technology and society. The study of genetics <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/mar/01/racism-science-human-genomes-darwin"><strong>contributed to understanding race</strong></a> as a <a href="http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/is-race-a-social-construct-the-natural-history-museum-investigates-30957654/?no-ist"><strong>social construct</strong></a>. Studies in neurobiology showed that <a href="http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2013/05/25/les-hommes-et-les-femmes-ont-ils-des-cerveaux-differents_3174565_3224.html"><strong>differences between female and male brains were due to environmental effects</strong></a> (link in French). Even simple technological advances had a major societal impact, for example with the <a href="https://www.experienceplus.com/blog/?p=207"><strong>popularity of the bicycle contributing to the women’s rights movement</strong></a>.</p><p>Can we therefore choose between fundamental research and social justice? No. The two go hand in hand and should be pursued in parallel.</p><h4>Social justice in the lab</h4><p>One battleground for social justice is within science labs themselves, where <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/higher-education-network/2014/nov/18/-sp-white-males-monopolise-highest-paid-jobs-uk-universities"><strong>white males are over-represented in the higher paying, higher echelons which offer stable permanent contracts</strong></a>, and where women and minorities are more likely to be offered some of the numerous short-term and precarious positions that now constitute the bulk of the academic workforce. This is problematic because it suggests that public money is not always used meritocratically. Social injustice has many faces and the position of women and minorities in science is one of them that should be addressed by science policy makers. Without concrete proactive policies, <a href="http://ec.europa.eu/research/science-society/document_library/pdf_06/she_figures_2009_en.pdf"><strong>the European Commission report on gender equality in science concluded that the gap would take decades to close</strong></a>.</p><p>Policy makers should take note that in order to truly inspire, science should not only be at the cutting edge of fundamental research and technological advances, but also at the forefront of social progress.</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a76c794f70f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/social-justice-on-a-comet-4a76c794f70f">Social justice on a comet</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Standing up for crowdfunding]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/standing-up-for-crowdfunding-da774950dcea?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da774950dcea</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2015 22:39:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T22:39:08.254Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Does crowdfunding offer up an unfair shortcut to success? No — here’s why.</blockquote><p>I get pretty annoyed when I see people criticising technological advances without any foundation. For the most part it’s born out of fear of the unknown, or an unwillingness to welcome change and progress into their comfortable lives. But when a newspaper trash-talks innovation and ingenuity, like this <em>Metro</em> <a href="http://metro.co.uk/2014/09/15/crowd-funding-the-answer-to-students-prayers-or-vaguely-unethical-4845730/"><strong>article</strong></a> slamming a science undergraduate for having the audacity to crowdfund her education, it can have a negative impact on the world.</p><p>The journalist’s objection was that Emily-Rose Eastop was getting ‘something almost totally free’ instead of having to work a part-time job or tap into the ‘bank of mum and dad’ like everyone else. For starters, as someone who is still fulfilling the campaign promises for my own <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/katerussell/mostly-harmless-an-elite-dangerous-novel-working-t"><strong>successful Kickstarter</strong></a> 18 months ago (to write a sci-fi novel, <a href="http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00KUXT3DC/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&amp;camp=1634&amp;creative=6738&amp;creativeASIN=B00KUXT3DC&amp;linkCode=as2&amp;tag=worktheclou-21"><strong><em>Elite: Mostly Harmless</em></strong></a>, which is out now on Amazon, thanks for asking!), I can tell you it is a long way from getting something for nothing.</p><h4>Use it or lose it</h4><p>On reward-based platforms, backers are essentially paying in advance for whatever you’re selling. This helps many truly innovative products and services come to market when traditional finance avenues — like banks and investors — might not be open to them because the market is yet to be proved.</p><p>There are equity based-platforms too, where backers are rewarded with shares like any normal investor, and for charity work platforms like Just Giving are available. But in Emily-Rose’s <a href="https://hubbub.net/p/get-ER-to-oxford/"><strong>campaign on Hubbub</strong></a>, she is actually committing to writing and publishing regular content based on her degree course, and her backers, familiar with her dedication and writing abilities because of her existing (unpaid!) work running a <a href="https://www.facebook.com/hatepseudoscience"><strong>Facebook page that debunks science myths</strong></a>, are happy to pay for it.</p><p>So where exactly is the sin in this? Emily-Rose <em>could</em> play by the rules of the system; get a job at Wetherspoons and rack up tens of thousands of pounds worth of debt she will spend years paying back (with interest) once she graduates. But instead she decided to see if her writing skills could provide an income.</p><p>Despite the fact I’m willing to bet there isn’t a publisher on the planet that would have given her a £26k advance, she now has a job — producing content from her master’s degree to share with her readers. And who knows, without the yoke of debt around her neck maybe Emily-Rose will go on to do something really important with her education. Or she might inspire the next Nobel Prize winner with her science blogging.</p><h4>The wisdom of the crowd</h4><p>I believe that crowdfunding represents an opportunity for us to take back control of the entertainment content we are served. The highest funded project in any<em> </em>category right now is video game <a href="https://robertsspaceindustries.com/"><strong>Star Citizen</strong></a>, which has so far made more than $53m against an original goal of $2m.</p><p>The campaign still runs independently on the game developer’s website and is earning additional pledges of between $1.3m and $3.7m each month. When you look at movies, there are currently over <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/discover/advanced?category_id=11&amp;sort=most_funded"><strong>800 projects</strong></a> live just on Kickstarter alone. The highest funded so far was <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/559914737/the-veronica-mars-movie-project?ref=category_most_funded"><strong>The <em>Veronica Mars</em> Movie project</strong></a>, which made nearly $6m against a goal of $2m.</p><p>Music is also well represented. Amanda Palmer <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/amandapalmer/amanda-palmer-the-new-record-art-book-and-tour?ref=nav_search"><strong>crowdfunded her tour and album</strong></a> and made over a $1m against a goal of just $100k. Not so much crowdfunding, but crowdsourcing an audience: Welsh high school student Beth Reekles was 17-years-old when she got a <a href="http://www.thewire.com/entertainment/2013/04/beth-reekles-kissing-booth/64016/"><strong>three-book publishing deal</strong></a> in the US last year after getting more than 19 million views when she posted her first novel, <a href="http://www.wattpad.com/story/203382-the-kissing-booth-sample-entire-book-available-now"><strong><em>The Kissing Booth</em></strong></a>, online at the story-sharing site Wattpad.</p><p>In many ways crowdfunding is a return to Shakespeare’s days of patronage, only the patron is fragmented into hundreds, perhaps even thousands or millions of backers on the internet. The artist sets a target — the lowest amount they want to be paid for their time — and anything over that is a bonus.</p><p>In the case of the above examples, they knew they had hits; achieving earnings in the millions during the period of their campaigns. That’s not common — but then neither is earning millions as an artist under today’s system of copyright. For others, like Beth Reekles, great success might come after the completion of the campaign, with the content taking off across the world once people get the chance to experience it. For some, like me, success will most likely be moderate. Very many more people will never achieve their crowdfunding goals at all and fade into obscurity despite their creative ambitions… so a lot like it is today all round, really.</p><p>If we embrace crowdfunding, I believe we have the potential to bring the power of choice over what we watch, listen to and read back into the hands of the people, instead of it being something that is decided by a soulless financial algorithm designed to assess the potential return on an investment.</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da774950dcea" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/standing-up-for-crowdfunding-da774950dcea">Standing up for crowdfunding</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lightening up about death]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/libertine-collection/lightening-up-about-death-5240c489c1fb?source=rss-2938d2a11664------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5240c489c1fb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Libertine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Oct 2014 16:02:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-11T17:42:37.017Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Modern medicine is keeping us alive for longer than ever — but is it longevity we should be focusing on?</h4><p>This is the idea put forward in Atul Gawande’s new book <a href="http://atulgawande.com/book/being-mortal/"><em>Being Mortal</em></a><em>, </em>released on October 7 and reviewed across the literary press<em>. </em>Gawande, who is a practising surgeon and staff writer at <em>The New Yorker</em>, is critical of the medical profession’s approach to death. Instead of focusing all our efforts on putting off the inevitable, he asks, shouldn’t we also be trying to come to terms with it?</p><p>As late as 1880, approximately 20% of all children born in Western society died before their first birthday, and another 20% before their fifth. Global average life expectancy at birth was around 30 years. No one even got around to considering death from natural causes. Thanks to advances in public health and modern medicine, the average lifespan in the West is now 78 years, and this average increases by two years every decade. But a culture that grows old pushes the subject of death to the periphery. Death and dying are relegated to hospitals and care facilities.</p><p>While we might, as Philip Larkin said, have a ‘real talent’ for ignoring death, it’s always been a big topic in literature. Tennyson goes on about it for 700 stanzas (<em>In Memoriam). </em>What’s different about Gawande’s treatise is that it takes what has been a fairly popular cultural debate around the notion of a good death into the clinical domain. Of course, palliative care specialists have been doing this since Cicely Saunders pioneered the concept in the sixties. But the medical profession and culture at large have been fairly slow in following suit.</p><h4>Coming to terms with the body</h4><p>Accessible healthcare is one of the many privileges of 21st century living in the West, but leaving everything up to the professionals has contributed to the sanitisation of what is in reality less a sudden event than a bodily process, and a messy one at that.</p><p>“The thing people really have trouble with is the body”, Poppy Mardall, funeral director and founder of <a href="http://www.poppysfunerals.co.uk/">Poppy’s Funerals</a>, tells me. If someone wants to see the body and it’s not in good condition, the undertaker will put you off. “They’re scared about how you’ll react,” she says. “Deceased, leakage, loved ones — these are phrases that aren’t very helpful or direct.”</p><p>The practice of embalming developed to make people look more lifelike for family viewings. Most people are, however, unaware of the aggressiveness of the procedure. Fluids are removed and replaced by chemicals; gums are stitched to keep jaws shut; the formaldehyde is “bad for the environment and for the people doing it”, Poppy says. “I don’t believe in this whole perfect memorial picture bollocks. Just let the person be.”</p><p>The BBC recently commissioned ‘<a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04lp4kb">Body of Essays</a>’, a radio series in which five writers explore an organ of their choosing. Naomi Alderman considers the intestines, citing Ernest Becker’s Pulitzer-prize winning <em>The Denial of Death</em>: at one end lies the mouth, and at the other the anus, which represents the fate of all that is physical: decay and death. It seems that speaking about poo and farts doesn’t just offend our manners; it’s a threat to our existence. But this is our lot, and it’s important to remember that, “whatever ecstasy we find, we are also, essentially and at all times, full of shit.”</p><h4>Kill or cure</h4><p>Calico, the Google-backed experiment that wants to ‘cure death’, announced in September its <a href="http://www.theverge.com/2014/9/3/6102377/google-calico-cure-death-1-5-billion-research-abbvie">plans to partner with Big Pharma to fund a $1.5 billion</a> research centre. But Gawande is critical of the medical approach to death as a problem that needs to be solved.</p><p>“We need to recognise that people have priorities that they need us to serve besides just living longer’, he writes in the <em>New York Times. </em>Gawande spoke to over 200 hospital workers, palliative care patients and geriatricians about their priorities in managing mortality. Above all, people wanted to share memories and connect with loved ones. Prolonging life through aggressive medical intervention often precludes this. A mother in the UK recently made legal history after she won a High Court case to end the life of her severely disabled 12-year-old daughter. Could this signal a re-evaluation of the country’s euthanasia laws?</p><p>We also appear to be confronting our mortality outside of the medical and professional contexts in which the subject tends to be confined. Unless you’re comedian Eddie Izzard, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMMHUzm22oE">cake and death</a> make strange bedfellows. With one, you celebrate life. The other ends it. But on a visit to Hampstead’s Cafe Rouge last May, psychotherapist Josefine Speyer walked in with a slice of cake lit by a single candle: <a href="http://deathcafe.com/">the Death Cafe</a>, at which we were congregated, was celebrating its first birthday.</p><p>Inspired by the cafe mortels pioneered by Swiss sociologist Bernard Crettaz, the first UK Death Cafe was opened by former council worker Jon Underwood in 2011. Josefine’s Hampstead branch is just one of the many that have opened since. They aren’t therapy sessions, although people find them therapeutic. They aren’t exclusively for the bereaved, although many who attend have experienced loss. We’re told that a café regular, who was terminally ill, died last month.</p><p>As I observe the gathering, strangers make small talk. I hear the words ‘euthanasia’ and ‘cremation.’ “It’s a social conversation”, Josefine says.</p><p>The average visitor at the Death Cafe is 60 years old, suggesting that it’s not until we get closer to death that we start trying to understand it. Various efforts have been made to get people talking about it sooner. As well as the death cafes, there’s <a href="http://deathsalon.org/">Death Salons</a>. We’ve also got <a href="http://deathdrawing.com/">death drawing</a>, hosted by Nikki Shail. In 2009, the National Council for Palliative Care set up <a href="http://www.dyingmatters.org/">Dying Matters</a> to help people talk more openly about dying, death and bereavement. <em>Atlantic </em>correspondent Erika Hayasaki regularly writes about the ‘death movement’; her recent book tells the story of Dr. Norma Bowe, a nurse who decided to teach ‘The Death Class’ at a college in New Jersey. Bowe believed that death education is as important, if not more, than sex education, “since not everyone has sex.” It is quite literally in fashion: <em>Death Becomes Her: A Century of Mourning Attire</em>, has just opened at New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art.</p><h4>Thoroughly modern loss</h4><p>One of the best ways of striking up a conversation nowadays is, of course, through virtual means. Which is exactly what New Yorkers Rebecca Soffer and Gabi Birkner have done with <a href="http://modernloss.com/">Modern Loss</a>, an online community for ‘candid conversations about grief’ that launched last November.</p><p>“I’m totally not an expert on anything. I’m just somebody that had life happen to them”, Rebecca tells me. Like Josefine, whose husband died in a car accident, Gabi and Rebecca both experienced sudden and untimely deaths. Gabi’s father and stepmother were murdered by a methamphetamine addict in a home invasion. Rebecca’s mother was killed in a car accident when she was 30, and four years later her father died of a heart attack while on a cruise to the Bahamas (‘lucky him, unlucky everyone else’, she writes.) “I really felt like the onus was on me to make everybody else feel better,” she says.</p><blockquote><strong>“There’s a reason they say you don’t talk about death or taxes at a party, but I feel like it’s definitely more acceptable to talk about taxes over death, right?!”</strong></blockquote><p>Modern Loss is a repository of resources and ‘how-tos’ offering advice on everything from getting your dead relatives offline to job hunting while grieving. Its mission is chiefly, “to not be a depressing project.” And it isn’t — because, like Rebecca and Gabi, it’s very funny. As its name implies, the site is about creating a space for 20–40-year-olds to talk about death in their own words, which are both direct and warm, light-hearted and heartfelt.</p><p>The essays on the site are mundane, in the best possible way. “It’s those little moments and those specific angles of people’s experiences with loss that we’re trying to highlight”, Gabi says. “It might draw people out of their isolation if they can identify themselves in those stories.” One contributor writes that it’s not necessarily at big moments, like weddings and births, that she misses her mum the most. It’s when she’s watching <em>The Kardashians.</em></p><h4>But i’m totally fine with death on TV</h4><p>Talking about death online ties into the ongoing furore about the ways that media are shaping our interpersonal lives. We’re exposed to death constantly, whether it’s on the internet, through the news or within pretty much any scene from <em>Game of Thrones. </em>But awareness of a subject doesn’t necessarily equate to acceptance or understanding. In a 2014 University of Minnesota study, students watched ten episodes of <em>Six Feet Under </em>over five weeks. On completing the ‘Death Attitude Profile-Revised’ test, the students showed a higher fear of death, a decrease in neutral acceptance of death, and a higher level of death avoidance.</p><p>What we have, then, is a no-holds barred, transgressive discourse playing out across our screens that runs parallel to a society constantly attacked for its real-life reticence. And this split can make our behaviour seem inauthentic, especially when it comes to dealing with difficult subjects over social media. We’ve all cringed at that person who overshares on Facebook, that celebrity who tweets an RIP followed by some first world problem that makes them appear to have the memory and depth of a goldfish. Our various media have the power to both provoke and desensitise, to (in psychologist Sherry Turkle’s words) “sacrifice conversation for mere connection”. How meaningful can a tweet actually be? What’s the emotional value of a Facebook comment?</p><p>Some of the sharing over social media is facile. But, it also allows for support when real life is not enough. “When you experience loss, it helps — in my opinion — to be connected to a community of people who ‘get it,’ no questions asked,’ Gabi says.</p><p>Ultimately there is no one way to grieve. While some need the comfort of others, others value the detachment afforded by the internet. We live in a society that seems to have redefined intimacy to include virtual communication. People use apps to communicate purely using emojis and even simply the word ‘yo’; subtle systems of implicit, passive attention rather than the strenuous focused kind. ‘Twitter therapy’ is on the rise, with cancer patients tweeting through chemotherapy; a simple, 140 character message can make a big difference. Should some people’s views on what’s truly meaningful delimit the experiences of others – especially a generation for whom traditional outlets provide little comfort, and social media, for better or for worse, is an intrinsic part of their lives?</p><p>The ideal scenario is that some of that openness will translate IRL. With people updating their Facebook statuses when a family member dies, news travels quickly. “It could really be a jumping off point for people to do more”, Gabi says. “like sending a card, like making a visit, like asking the person, ‘What can I do?’”</p><h4>Putting the fun in funerals</h4><p>There was a time when funerary rites were less about honouring the dead than protecting the living. The Saxons would cut off the dead person’s feet to prevent any post-mortem rambles; some aboriginal tribes used to decapitate bodies so their spirits would be too busy searching for their heads to go about haunting people.</p><p>The Pope might have granted exorcism legal recognition in July, but dealing with dead spirits is no longer at the top of Western society’s agenda. Modern funerals are about celebrating the deceased — in frequently weird and wonderful ways. <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/22/us/its-not-the-living-dead-just-a-funeral-with-flair.html">One service in New Orleans</a> will display the body of the dead person amidst the backdrop of your choosing. They’ve posed a paramedic behind the wheel of his ambulance, and a woman with a can of beer in one hand and a cigarette in the other, “just as she had spent a good number of her living days”.</p><p>There’s also the premium end of the market. For a starting price of £2,500, LifeGem Memorials will turn human remains into a diamond (fun fact: the average person has enough carbon in them to produce <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2002/sep/22/burhanwazir.theobserver">between 50 and 100 diamonds</a>). In China, the funeral business is booming, and increasing numbers of people are splashing out on <a href="http://qz.com/155846/chinas-largest-funeral-provider-is-trying-to-make-death-a-luxury-event/">elaborate ceremonies</a>. One flush businessman spent 5 million yuan (roughly £500,000) honouring his dead mother with gold-plated canons and a motorcade of Lincoln limousines.</p><p>Some might call these extravagant send-offs sweet, others might say they were gaudy, materialistic and, like the criticism levied at social media, lacking in substance. But most of the anger surrounding the commodification of death is reserved for the funeral industry.</p><p>The fact that a funeral is a physical ceremony means there will always be a problematic issue of quantifying loss, which is, in turn, something that can be exploited in the wrong hands. A 2013 survey found that the average cost of dying in the UK, including death-related costs such as probate, headstones and flowers in addition to the basic cost of a funeral, stood at £7,622 — although this figure is disputed in research by the National Association for Funeral Directors. Researchers at the University of Bath estimate that one in five families experience a shortfall when it comes to paying for funeral costs.</p><p>“The truth is there are affordable options out there, they’re just not signposted very well”, Poppy tells me. “Families go in, meet a funeral director and they’re told what they should do. They don’t realise that a lot of that is about being sold stuff.”</p><p>After a series of cancer scares in the family, Poppy was dispatched to investigate funeral services but couldn’t find any without the traditional trimmings. “We’re not a Bohemian family, but it also wouldn’t be appropriate for us to be driven around in black limos. It’s not how we roll,’ she says.</p><p>So Poppy left her job at Sotheby’s auctions to train as a funeral director and set up Poppy’s Funerals. The simple eco-friendly service covers Greater London and beyond. The website is bright and colourful, with an upbeat tagline : ‘The freedom to do it your way.’ Like the coffee-house chatter of the death cafe and the informality of Modern Loss, it’s accessible without being superficial. “It’s a deep change’, Poppy says. ‘It’s about the way we view the dead, and the way we communicate with families.”</p><p>Something Poppy hears a lot is, ‘I don’t want to take up any space, I just want to disappear off into the ether.’ Cremation, which was illegal just over 100 years ago, now accounts for 75% of funerals in the UK. There’s natural burial too, which involves placing the dead person in a simple cardboard coffin or a bamboo shroud and burying them — in the case of ‘Poppy’s Funerals’ — in Clandon Wood.</p><p>Personalising a funeral doesn’t necessarily entail elaborate gestures, gold canons and cavalcades. “It’s not about the crazy, it’s about the tiny things that mean stuff to people”, Poppy tells me. Like carrying the coffin — but being too afraid to ask. “We talk [relatives] through it”, she says. “After the funeral they’ll say, I’ll never forget what it was like to have my dad in my hands. That was the last thing I could do for him, and I did it.”</p><p>Josefine used to hold death education workshops, where she’d ask: ‘what would be your ideal death?’. One woman imagined linen sheets and beeswax candles. Another woman, who had no children and whose partner had died, wanted to die alone in the Arctic looking up at the Northern Lights.</p><p>Death might be the great equaliser, but each of us goes through it individually — and each of us has our own idea about what a good death might entail. As Being Mortal suggests, endings matter beyond their timing; we need to invest in treating both physical and emotional needs. Even if the latter are a bit harder to measure in clinical terms.</p><p>Opening up the conversation about death also makes it easier to cope with loss. “It’s going to happen to everybody, it’s just a wider turn for other people than it is for some,” Rebecca says. “Why not make it more acceptable to say, ‘Hey, I lost my mum, it totally sucks’; ‘I lost somebody, hopefully my healthcare will cover the therapy’; ‘I lost somebody, and I think I need to take a couple of weeks off work instead of just three days’.”</p><p>About Libertine:</p><p>The <a href="http://liberti.ne/">Libertine community</a> is made up of diverse, eclectic and global thinkers with an insatiable curiosity for ideas, a sense of fun and adventure, and a ruthless commitment to getting shit done.</p><p>The new Libertine platform is a conduit to connecting around the ideas you’re interested in, driven by a virtual panel of brilliant minds — <a href="http://liberti.ne/the-libertine-100/">the Libertine 100</a>.</p><p>Sign up to our <a href="http://interestedwomen.us8.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=027870218601bae54f9e57922&amp;id=f856bb75f3">newsletter</a> or follow us on <a href="https://twitter.com/libertinewomen">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5240c489c1fb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection/lightening-up-about-death-5240c489c1fb">Lightening up about death</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/libertine-collection">Libertine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>