<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Reuben Poling on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Reuben Poling on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy?source=rss-18f286e62243------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 18:44:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOTD S01E02–03: Breaking the Silence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy/hotd-s01e02-03-breaking-the-silence-36027e256707?source=rss-18f286e62243------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36027e256707</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Reuben Poling]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Sep 2022 04:46:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-15T04:46:41.886Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*l48YZwvUz0At2niy.jpg" /></figure><p>I hadn’t initially planned to review these two episodes together, but a long internet outage and a COVID scare put me way behind schedule. And in a happy piece of kismet, “The Rogue Prince” and “Second of His Name” have a great deal in common in terms of tone and structure. These are two drawn-out, almost lethargic episodes, where our characters soak in long, excruciating silences and make a tremendous effort to talk about anything except their real problems, until Daemon Targaryen comes crashing into the narrative to fuck up everyone’s day. In his edged-weapon wake, unspeakable things come pouring out.</p><p>The fun part about taking these two episodes in tandem is their contrast, best illustrated by King Viserys, who’s pretty well fixed as the heart of the story thus far. In “Prince” he’s moping in brittle silence, and everyone around him is using high style and stilted formality to pad the impact when their wants and needs brush up against one another, lest something crack; by the time of “Second,” he’s moved on to decay, starting from his infected, rotting fingers and spreading around him in distended excess, and his court is feasting on the meat while it lasts. Paddy Considine controls the screen in “Prince” with a sort of anti-magnetism — mourning his wife and his own idea of himself as a good man, finding comfort in his family history, his extremely normal and cool midnight chat sessions with his teenage daughter’s best friend, and most of all in the illusion of stillness, an insensate and unmoving Iron Throne that can’t hurt anyone but him.</p><p>But by the time of “Second” he’s replaced his books with wine, and his midnight sessions with Alicent have become something else entirely. Nobody comes off particularly well in the story of the king’s second marriage — not Viserys, nor that piece of shit Otto Hightower, nor his rivals in marriage, Lord Corlys and Princess Rhaenys, whose status as sympathetic figures is undercut by their stark embrace of Weserosi realpolitik. (The shots of Viserys’s walk with 12-year old Laena, emphasizing their height difference, are among the most painful to watch of anything in our first three episodes). Even Alicent gets a collar-tugging moment when she reassures Rhaenyra that pregnancy isn’t anything to be worried about, just begging for a response like <em>Remind me again why my father was single? </em>But it’s Viserys who has the closest thing to control over the situation, and Viserys who, when forced into action, blunders forward into the worst possible choice. No wonder that a few years later, he’s doing everything he can do to do nothing.</p><p>Is it any wonder that the self-styled men of action find an excuse to be elsewhere? Balked at his attempt at political maneuvering, Corlys Velaryon finds a straighter, cleaner path to power and influence at sword’s point. He’s joined by Prince Daemon, whose role we’ll come back to later, and their wartakes up the back half of “Second” with its conclusion. This is some of the most <em>Game of Thrones</em>-ish material in the series so far, for its depiction of battle as an extension of character, where the results depend on the decisions and development of the key figures the audience cares about. There are some nods to tactics and strategy — the declining morale and supplies of the Velaryon army, the Triarchy’s use of the terrain as a force multiplier — but fundamentally, the war for the Stepstones ends here because Daemon has become desperate enough to win on his own that he’s willing to risk it all, and the Velaryons roll the dice with him. It pays off in a sequence that frankly depicts medieval archery pretty realistically (no matter what Ramsay Bolton told you, it’s extremely hard to hit a single moving target with a bow) and serves up our third dragon, Seasmoke, the bright blue mount of Laenor Velaryon — who, miraculously, appears to be having the appropriate amount of fun zipping around on a dragon absolutely wrecking shop.</p><p>The gruesome demise of the Crabfeeder and the Triarchy’s bloody defeat comes off as a relief, and not just because we know the characters involved (who have nearly all done something already to give the audience second thoughts about being overly sympathetic, except perhaps for Laenor, who again, is having a <em>great</em> time out there). It’s because in two episodes of sluggish tension, the final battle for the Stepstones provides some kind of emotional payoff, matched only perhaps by Rhaenyra’s boar-slaying earlier in the episode. That whole sequence, from Viserys’s reluctant, half-assed execution of the bound hart, through Rhaenya’s desperate fight to the death, all the way up through her triumphal entry into camp soaked in blood and dragging her trophy, is one of the strongest in either episode.</p><p>Rhaenyra presents an interesting challenge for <em>House of the Dragon</em>, as a character who could very easily fit into a plucky-princess mold that feels out of place in the lane this show is occupying. But against a backdrop of dour scheming and explosive gore, her habits of speaking out of turn, leaping into action, and finding logical excuses to do what she wants feel energetic and compelling rather than cliche. Compared to the source material, which portrays the would-be queen as spoiled, grasping, and cruel (albeit as a result of an in-universe misogynist bias that George RR Martin is not above beating his readers about the head with), HOTD’s Rhaenyra shows several signs of imminent fitness to rule. We’ll see what the coming episodes hold in that regard.</p><p>One of those signs comes earlier, in “The Rogue Prince,” when she defuses a standoff that’s within a few harsh words of erupting into civil war. It’s tempting to write off that climactic scene at Dragonstone as a dick-measuring contest between two proud men who loathe each other, but that does a disservice to the writers’ room for how they’ve crafted both Otto Hightower and Daemon Targaryen. The Hand of the King is perfectly suited to the fragile court of that episode, hearing whatever he needs to in the excruciating silence and adeptly finding the weak points to make anyone crack and shatter. Seeing an opportunity to provoke Daemon into an irrevocable break with his brother, Otto seizes on it immediately, and his only mistake is to underestimate just how quickly Daemon will leap from petulance to the maximum applicable amount of violence. But then, maybe I’m giving Otto short shrift — he might be more willing to die than to admit he was wrong.</p><p>As for Daemon, is anyone in Westeros more brittle? He’s all sharp edges and sinew to look at him, a thing made to harm — but weapons break just as easily as anything else, and Daemon’s fragility makes him even more dangerous. In his role as Royal Shit-Disturber, he breaks half a year of silence and the wary peace at court with a theft that turns out to be nothing more than a plea for his brother’s attention. He risks his own life and the hard-earned freedom and safety of his lover Mysaria to demand that Viserys not only notice him, but <em>acknowledge </em>him — if not as his heir, or his Hand, or just his blood-flecked attack dog, then as his enemy. And when Otto Hightower’s machinations deny Daemon even that, starting a civil war in a spurt of dragonfire seems preferable to further irrelevance.</p><p>That underlying desire for recognition chases the prince all the way to the Stepstones, sustains him through three years of increasingly frustrating war, and finally drives him to a fit of brutality and bloody gamble. I have a feeling that we’re not even close to peak Matt Smith in this show, so I’ll just single out his way of contrasting his body language with everyone around him. He’s easy and casual when everyone around him is taut and afraid — sidling back to a war council like he’s home from the grocery store, practically making an And-1 mixtape with his stolen dragon’s egg. But when the Velaryon forces relax at the word of help on the way, Daemon tenses up, practically vibrating with shame and failure, as miserable among celebrants as he was in the brothel orgy in “Heirs of the Dragon.” It’s a great contrast to Viserys’s captivating mopery, both brothers commanding the screen with a bit of that unearthly Targaryen charisma. Daemon just gets a lot more done in the process.</p><p>And he gets it done in “Second of his Name,” winning the war for the Stepstones without his big brother’s help. It comes off as small and petty when you put it like that, and maybe it ought to. Daemon’s goals are intensely personal, the product of a dangerously fragile man with all the accouterments and expectations of power but no real portion of his own. Westeros produces thousands like him, all going crazy in peacetime like captive predators gnawing at their own legs, but Daemon is too big to leash. The kingdom was lucky he was someone else’s problem for a few years. Now, one presumes, he’ll be coming home again. Imagine the joy.</p><p><strong>Quick Hits:</strong></p><ul><li>Beginning to see the way the show will handle the Rashomon history of <em>Fire &amp; Blood</em> — showing certain events happening without being explicit about the motivation or awareness of the characters involved. A great small example is Alicent’s declaration to the king in “Rogue Prince” that “she will open herself to you, if approached kindly.” It’s a double entendre worthy of Westerosi Pornhub, but the way it’s presented, we don’t know if Alicent is aware of her implications. In a largely unsubtle show, where characters find every excuse for exposition and the camera knits together an episode’s themes and parallels, those moments of doubt are clear signposts for the audience to start asking questions.</li><li>Let’s talk about Alicent quickly! These episodes give her some well-deserved shading as a pawn beginning to explore her rare diagonal opportunities. Her friendship with Rhaenyra and affection for the king both read as genuine, but so do her loyalty to her father and her acceptance of her “proper station” as a noblewoman — that is, a game piece for alliances and a factory for male babies. Alicent’s self-harm oddly mirrors Daemon, of all people. Both of them are compelled to reject the desirability and power of their own highborn bodies, but where Daemon has opportunities to turn his violence outwards Alicent is only equipped to inflict it on herself.</li><li>Great moment in the confrontation in Dragonstone — one of the many times Otto refers to Mysaria as “your whore,” Daemon takes a moment to showily look around in confusion, as if to say <em>no, Otto, I didn’t bring any sex workers today. This is my fiancée, we’re at a work thing, it’d be weird.</em></li><li>“Second of His Name” was a great showing for the supporting cast. The Lannister twins played by Jefferson Hall were very distinct flavors of pain in everyone’s ass, and Criston Cole demonstrated a lot about his whole deal by dutifully sticking to Rhaenyra’s side, performing heroics in her defense, and answering her questions about marriage by taking pains to point out that he <em>definitely</em> fucked, a lot. And Lyonel Strong, meanwhile, developed as perhaps the only reasonable and trustworthy human being in the Red Keep, and we were introduced to his sons as two men who can both say a great deal with a single look.</li><li>For the record, Larys’s look said <em>I am committing every detail of this conversation to memory while I eat this muffin</em>, and Harwin’s said <em>Oh yeah, I’ll eat a muffin all right.</em></li><li>I sympathize with the desire to learn more about the Crabfeeder, a truly compelling-looking guy, and I do hope that future seasons of HOTD explore the Free Cities as something other than a source of colorful and vaguely ethnic menace. But the whole War for the Stepstones took up about two paragraphs of <em>Fire and Blood</em>, so giving it half an episode seems about fair. RIP, Craghas Drahar, I’m sure someone will write you a very cool fan-fiction backstory.</li><li>If there’s one thing this show needs to get a handle on, it’s dialogue. On the balance I vastly prefer HOTD’s affected high-style to the anachronistic dick-jokery of GoT’s later seasons, but it seems sometimes that the writing doesn’t quite trust the audience to understand things delivered in a more formal tone. So far the dialogue is at its best when it’s poetic or allusive, leaving some ambiguity and letting the actors fill it in with delivery and body language…or not fill it in, sometimes. This is a story with a lot of unanswered questions, and it’s alright to let some of them linger.</li><li>If you’re reading this you’ve probably already seen Episode 4. Most of this review was written before it dropped, so I’ll get that reviewed over the weekend and we’ll get back to a regular cadence soon, as long as I don’t lose my internet again. Thanks for bearing with me!</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36027e256707" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOTD S01E01: The Machine Wants Blood]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy/hotd-s01e01-the-machine-wants-blood-d301cb68ba9f?source=rss-18f286e62243------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d301cb68ba9f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Reuben Poling]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Aug 2022 17:02:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-24T17:03:24.661Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*snsabDPqFmIrsXGITFzCvg.jpeg" /></figure><p>If a pilot episode is a thesis statement for the show to come, then the statement made by “The Heirs of the Dragon” is that <em>House of the Dragon </em>takes place in a world constructed by violence. Westeros in 112 AC might not be at open war, but its peace is a sham, compelled by power and an attendant threat of force. The kingdom of the Targaryens is a machine that runs on bodies and blood. Men’s bodies are used as instruments of violence, women’s of propagation, both as currency for alliance. The heights of medical knowledge on display range from burning shut an open wound without diagnosing what caused it to declaring a woman in labor already dead as a pretext for her murder. The cocktail of precedent, whim, and expediency referred to as “law” is both communicated and enforced by a campaign of violence. This machine is currently outputting prestige and wealth for the ruling class, and relative safety and prosperity for the commons, but it’s always one bad turn of the gears away from delivering something very different.</p><p>At the center of the Targaryen machine is the hangdog King Viserys. Surrounded by more openly dangerous figures — his mercurial, violent brother, young but strong-willed daughter, and ambitious chief counselor (a real piece of shit!) — the king evokes pop-culture depictions of the well-meaning, hapless Tsar Nicholas II, a genial country squire with his hand on the tiller of empire. (This of course leaves aside the obsessive bigotry and bloody absolutism of the real Nicky, a man who richly deserved his fate.) But Viserys’s affability and good intentions are worth precisely jack shit when the machine requires his wife Aemma’s life and autonomy as a sacrifice; he doesn’t have the kindness to refuse it, or even the courage to tell her that he’s having her murdered for a chance to salvage a male heir from the bloody mess.</p><p>This medically administered execution isn’t comfortable to watch, but neither is it careless or blasé. Compared to <em>Game of Thrones</em>, the violence on display in the first hour of HOTD is by turns more extravagant and far more intimate, particularly the episode’s signature sequence in which Queen Aemma Arryn’s involuntary C-section is intercut with a pointless duel between her sore loser brother-in-law and an upstart tourney prodigy. The queen lives in a body made for making new Targaryens, and the machine requires a new Targaryen, so she must make one; the knights live in bodies made for violence, but the machine doesn’t need any violence right now, so they’re going to make some of their own. The difference, of course, is that the knights can stop any time they want, and do so (that time, anyway — not so lucky for previous competitors). There is no such mercy for Aemma.</p><p>Subtle, it is not, but fantasy at its best using an imagined world to mirror and heighten the real one, both past and present. The City Watch’s sloppy crackdown on King’s Landing — judgment meted out by way of “I’m pretty sure that guy’s a criminal”, open-air beatings and maimings, a severed penis as punctuation mark — quickly illustrates the red truth of King Viserys’s benign rule, and calls into question what kind of peaceful order would require this much violence to maintain it. The fountaining blood and crushed skulls of the tourney ought to raise similar uncomfortable thoughts about a state that trains people to inflict violence and sets them loose to use that toolkit as they like. And Aemma Arryn’s fate, inflicted on her by a husband with words of love on his lips and doctors who don’t even bother to tell her what’s going on when the knives come out, is a frank reckoning with the horror at the heart of any society that prizes a womb’s reproductive capacity above the will of the person in whom that womb resides.</p><p>Of course, there’d be little reason to hang around in this world of grinding cruelty and florid brutality for an hour, let alone 10 or more, if there wasn’t something compelling us to care. The characters come first; like <em>Thrones</em>, HOTD will ultimately go as far as they can take it. “Heirs of the Dragon” introduces us to our principal cast and a character sketch for each — Princess Rhaenyra, our strong-willed and generous protagonist, was born into power and expects to set her own rules, while her dear friend Alicent follows them stringently as a safety rail against the horrors beyond and beneath. Alicent’s dad Otto Hightower, Hand of the King, is competent, ambitious, and a real piece of shit, willing to dress his teenage daughter in her dead mother’s clothes and try to pimp her out to his grieving monarch; he’s opposed by the magnetic but stoic Lord Corlys Velaryon (a guy who I hope gets a chance to open up a little bit in the pending episodes) and his unflappable wife Princess Rhaenys, unique among Targaryens for her apparent emotional stability and loving marriage.</p><p>Weaving through this ensemble with blood dripping from his fangs is Prince Daemon, chosen by the vicissitudes of Targaryen genealogy to be this generation’s unfettered id. In a show dedicated to giving all of its leads their own goals and motivations, the role of principal antagonist goes by default to the source of greatest conflict, and that’s Daemon to a tee; the primary issue set up in our first hour of TV is that Daemon is the de facto heir to the throne, if not precisely de jure, and nobody wants that. It’s very easy to see why. The Prince of the City shows himself brutal, callous, and volatile, but also something of a dilettante, whose exercises of power are limited more by boredom than mercy or restraint. His campaign of wanton police brutality is, in the eyes of king and council, a set of jingling keys to distract him from doing something worse.</p><p>But like all Targaryens, Daemon is just human enough to be compelling. It shows in his half-chastened defiance of his fellow councilors, his wounded disbelief at Viserys’s rage, and most of all his silences. Twice in the episode, Daemon’s celebration of apparent triumphs (the new City Watch’s bloody debut and his near-confirmation as heir) finds him wordless and hunched, his posture and expression conveying a self-loathing that borders on dysmorphic — a rejection of his flagrant public persona, of his various offices and roles, and of the esteemed body he inhabits, whose royal blood is the only reason his excesses are tolerated. There’s worse yet to come from Daemon, and it’ll be a challenge for HOTD to balance his misdeeds with his watchability and keep him out of the Ramsay Bolton zone where many viewers have gotten the point and would just like someone to kindly kill this motherfucker.</p><p>The richest bait “Heirs” offers viewers to stay tuned in is aesthetic, and that’s where I think HOTD has a chance to really outdo its predecessor. Unencumbered by either the budgetary limitations of Thrones’s early seasons, or the faintly embarrassed angle with which its showrunners always approached the fantasy genre, House of the Dragon is free to exult in the trappings of medievalism. King’s Landing is a riot of color, with the tourney knights bedecked in decorative armor and heraldry and the spectators showing off the elaborate and occasionally bizarre flourishes of a range of medieval and fantastic fashion. There’s even a variety of headwear, something Thrones largely eschewed except as a comic prop, like the coif-wearing hillbilly Freys. It’s a kingdom at its height, as opposed to the Westeros of nearly 200 years later after centuries of decline capped off by Robert Baratheon’s bloody-minded determination to erase all marks of Targaryen power and general disinterest in replacing them with anything that would require him to work.</p><p>Little touches like the Small Council’s attendance marbles and Viserys’s scale model of the Valyrian Freehold fill in the details of the setting without demanding explanation. Meanwhile, the vast scale and oddly yonic design of the King’s Landing tourney grounds, Criston Cole’s spectacularly impractical mace-and-chain, and the orgy at Mysaria’s brothel for the benefit of her pouting prince all serve to make HOTD’s Westeros feel appropriately fantastical. Historical accuracy is both a canard and a moving target — what’s needed is verisimilitude, a sense of the invented world’s faithfulness to its own conditions. In its medievalist aesthetic, “Heirs” evokes a recognizable past and present to do just that.</p><p>And then, of course, there’s the dragons. We only get a close look at two, but they’re bright and distinctive, with wildly different body types and facial constructions. Rhaenyra’s Syrax is something of a “dragon classic,” expressive and even cute when called to perform her duties at Queen Aemma’s funeral, while Daemon’s Caraxes is as sinuous and uncanny a predator as the prince himself. The dragons are beautiful creatures, whose power can be used not just to construct a machine for ruling the world, but destroy it or perhaps even escape it. If you want to talk thesis statements, starting the story proper by showing us the clouds pierced by a dragon, a princess on her back, is as clear a marker of scale and scope as we could hope for. The Targaryens are trapped in the heart of the machine they’ve built, and it must have an heir — but at the start of our story, Rhaenyra is as free as anyone could ever hope to be.</p><p><strong>Quick Hits</strong></p><ul><li>I don’t know if I’m actually gonna keep up reviews for the whole season, but I’m sure as hell going to try! It beats endless twitter threads.</li><li>I spent a lot of this review talking about the things that worked and, more importantly to me, <em>how</em> they worked; sort of my own personal pilot episode/thesis statement for what I think this show is going for and the lens through which I’ll be viewing it. For future episodes I’ll probably be talking more about scenes and choices that measured up or fell short, but it was important to me to establish table stakes for my analysis. And, you know, I very much liked the episode and don’t have a lot of bad to say!</li><li>A touch I loved was the quick turnaround of the jousting scenes, with each tilt proceeding directly into the next and the competitors grabbing their next lance and getting back into the lists ready or not. Compared to the usual “stopped clock” depictions of medieval tournaments, where every tilt ends with the knights going to their corner for a breather and a pep talk, this twist gave the jousting a propulsive feel that really brought me into the excitement of the crowd and the danger of the sport.</li><li>Not sure about the other big feature of tournaments in 112 AC, that being “sometimes a tilt just turns into a live-steel fight to the death.” It’s thematically consistent and gave Eve Best as Rhaenys some nice material to work with, but it raises some eyebrows — isn’t jousting dangerous enough without a sore loser just getting to escalate it to revenge killing? And would Westeros’s prickly and succession-obsessed noble class really write off the purposeful deaths of some heirs and spares as the cost of a good time? I guess one interpretation is that it all went down after Viserys had left to go have his wife medically murdered, and these things only happen when Dad isn’t watching the kids.</li><li>Matt Smith gives a great performance as Daemon, but he also just has a perfect face for the role. I fundamentally believe that Targaryens should all look like weird little guys, reminding you that they’re not quite the same kind of human as everyone else, and Smith inhabits that with every tilt of his chin and thin-lipped smile. (As great a job as Emilia Clarke did, I kind of want to peek into the alternate universe where Tamzin Merchant kept her role and lent her uncanny beauty to the story of Daenerys Targaryen).</li><li>Using the old “water cooler conversation” metric, the breakout star of the first episode appears to be the 33% visible portion of the Eleventh Doctor’s dick. Your move, David Tennant.</li><li>I couldn’t fit this anywhere else, but I wanted to keep it. During Viserys’s critical conversation with his daughter, he states “The idea we control the dragons is an illusion,” but he doesn’t go so far as to say it’s the other way around. Maybe we’re meant to take “the dragons control us” as implied, but I don’t think so; I think Viserys is saying there that neither the Targaryens nor their dragons are in control, that there’s ultimately nobody in charge of all this power, which is a pretty good punchline to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpL6Fwu0wkw">Varys’s iconic riddle</a>.</li><li>From the perspective of ASOIAF fans, the big revelation in “Heirs of the Dragon” was Viserys’s disclosure of a Targaryen prophecy about the Long Night threatening the world, Aegon the Conqueror’s motivation to install himself and his heirs as overlords of Westeros in order to fulfill the prophecy and hold back the darkness. There’s some wiggle room there; <a href="https://www.insider.com/house-of-the-dragon-asoiaf-prophecy-reveal-came-from-george-rr-martin-2022-8">per Miguel Sapochnik and Ryan Condal</a>, George told them that Aegon was personally aware of the prophecy via his own dreams and those of his ancestors, and it was the showrunners’ call to spin it into a Targaryen legacy passed down from monarch to monarch. So as tempting as it is to speculate about where precisely the Targaryens lost the prophecy, how and where they regained it, and whose actions were motivated by what parts of it, I think we may be a bit ahead of ourselves in terms of what’s represented in book canon. Don’t let that stop you from theorizing, of course! It’s not like we have anything else to do.</li><li>What I will say is that Aegon’s being motivated by the Song of Ice and Fire (hey, look, it’s the name of the thing!) is, to me, an enrichment of the story. ASOIAF is not simply a statement that realpolitik and human foibles trump mystic prophecy and heroic motivations, but an exploration of where these things meet. For a man in possession in one hand of a prophecy foretelling the end of the world and how humanity can unite to avert it, and in the other of three flying, fire-breathing, semi-autonomous biological superweapons, to enforce his dominion over an empire in the name of saving the world rather than attempt to build a coalition of the like-minded and trust that people are capable of saving themselves — well, that sounds like some extremely George R.R. Martin shit to me.</li><li>For more critical analysis of HotD, particularly as a piece of prestige television in its own right, read <a href="https://t.co/100bkdHDjF">Sean T. Collins</a>, <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/70853478?pr=true">Gretchen Felker-Martin</a> ($), and <a href="https://thatshelf.com/house-of-the-dragon-review/">Akash Singh</a>. For a very good perspective on the Aemma Arryn scene, <a href="https://twitter.com/MaesterMerry/status/1562158871015202816">read this thread</a> by Merry of the Westerosi Bar Association. You can also listen to the WBA <a href="https://www.buzzsprout.com/958693/11189352-hands-on-hotd-episode-1-heirs-of-the-dragon">discuss the episode in podcast form</a>, and get more HOTD in pod form from <a href="https://notacastasoiaf.podbean.com/e/house-of-the-dragon-season-1-episode-1/">Manu and Emmett at the NotACast pod…cast</a>, and from <a href="https://girlsgonecanon.podbean.com/e/house-of-the-dragon-s1e1-the-heirs-of-the-dragon/">Chloe and Eliana at Girls Gone Canon</a>.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d301cb68ba9f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Two New Yorkers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy/two-new-yorkers-923606000f51?source=rss-18f286e62243------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/923606000f51</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[new-york]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Reuben Poling]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Sep 2016 14:36:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-29T14:36:40.094Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m not exactly sure why I thought of this during the first Clinton-Trump debate. I think it was Donald Trump’s voice and accent, reminding me of person who to me has always meant <em>New York</em>, who has personified the place and the idea ever since my first flight to JFK. In any case, at some point during that meandering clown-show, it occurred to me how often and how thoroughly my grandfather Al would have absolutely blown his stack over this election.</p><p>Al was a loud, boisterous native New Yorker, a showman by nature and sometimes by trade. His parents, immigrants from Europe, named him Israel Alperstein, but like many of his generation he Anglicized his name to have an easier time assimilating. He worked in advertising, which suited his ability to talk for weeks on end. He had a plentiful archive of stories and embellished them shamelessly, so they grew more exaggerated (and more entertaining) with each telling. He fell asleep with the television on, pronounced “beautiful” with five or six syllables, and put ketchup on everything he ate.</p><p>Al was born in the Bronx and grew up during the Depression, helping his family keep their grocery store running. He never finished high school, though he did study stage design, being temperamentally unsuited to the family business. He fought in World War 2, from North Africa into Italy — and how I wish I could elaborate on this, but he refused to talk about his experiences at war. (Though he stage-managed USO shows in Puerto Rico, and he would happily talk about that.) After the war he met, courted, and married my grandma Mattie; they raised three kids, bought a big house in Long Island, filled it with beautiful (“bay-YOU-ti-fu-hul”) things, mostly the pre-Columbian and traditional African art that was Al’s passion. And eventually they sold the house, and most of the collection, to move to San Francisco so they could be near their daughters and grandchildren.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oC5OC9Qpla_kvRTdCNauag.jpeg" /><figcaption>Al’s dog tag. There’s now a church at that address, which prominently advertises itself as a food bank.</figcaption></figure><p>Al was the kindest person I’ve ever known. I suspect that more than his other qualities, his eloquence or imagination or talent for exaggeration, it was his empathy that helped him succeed — the idea, swiftly becoming certainty, that the big man with the booming voice and the arching eagle’s-beak nose was <em>on your side</em>. He had a keen eye for art — stuff that would appreciate in value, maybe, but he never brought home anything he wouldn’t be just as happy to keep and look at every day. He treasured his family, and knew full well how adrift and helpless he would have been without Mattie. She and my mother have joked that Al, a contemporary of Don Draper et al. (separated only by the porous boundary of fiction), would have been the most boring character on <em>Mad Men; </em>he didn’t drink, didn’t smoke, didn’t cheat on his wife, cheat on his taxes, or do anything more dubious than exaggerate his friendship with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_Mostel">Zero Mostel</a>. The only times I can remember hearing him curse in English were in reference to George W. Bush or Richard Nixon. (And really, Yiddish was so much more fitting for those schmucks, those goniffs, those fakakta crooks.)</p><p><em>A sidebar: when my sister from graduated elementary school, the principal proudly read a letter, in praise of the school’s academic achievements, from recently sworn-in President George W. Bush. The response from the crowd of San Franciscan parents and families was a glacial, fragile silence, shattered when Al, from the back row, said “Boo.” Two </em>o<em>s, a period and not an exclamation point — that was how he said it. Everyone heard him. Everyone laughed.</em></p><p>Al’s only son Ricky died at 30, the age I am now, of a heart defect nobody suspected. I never met my uncle, who I’m named in honor of, but I’m told Ricky resembled Al in many respects — a creative, a dreamer, a bit of a ditherer, who spent his youth and early adulthood figuring out how to loose the numinous things in his head and heart on the world around him. Al never really got over Ricky’s death, which is wondrous to me, because I think about the grandfather I knew — his voluble humor, his expansive warmth — and wonder <em>my god, what was he like</em> before<em> he lost Ricky?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/895/1*8D0BpyfiF5Bjqh3v62HxNA.png" /><figcaption>I don’t look a lot like Al, but we have a very similar creative process.</figcaption></figure><p>This is a lot, I know. I drew you this picture because it’s the only way I can introduce you to Al, and I needed to introduce you to Al because I’ve been thinking about him and Donald Trump. Because I’ve been imagining what Al might have to say about this <em>other </em>blustering Manhattan showman, this <em>other</em> garrulous descendant of immigrants. The one who surrounds himself with pretty women, but reduces them to set-dressing and humiliates them at every turn; the one whose idea of beauty isn’t the art and culture of distant lands, but the filigree of his own name. The former Bronx resident who has never known hardship or want, but mocks those who have; the New Yorker who sees loss and grief not as a way to build rapport, but an occasion for mockery of the <em>losers </em>— and think about that word when you hear it, for it means <em>the people who have suffered loss</em>. What would Al say of him? — this shmegegge, this bulvon, this chozzer who didn’t travel to fight fascism, but invited it to camp on his doorstep.</p><p>I wish I could ask Al what he thought of that man; wish I could sit in the den watching debates or cable news with him, occasionally prodding him when he fell asleep in his chair. I wish I could hear his reactions to “Not paying taxes makes me smart,” or “Go over there and beat the hell out of them,” or a refusal to reject the endorsement of the real, actual Ku Klux Klan, or any of the countless pieces of invective hurled at women whose insistent, intrusive humanity encroached on Donald Trump’s personal reality.</p><p>I don’t know exactly how these conversations would go, but I figure at the very least, I’d learn some more Yiddish.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=923606000f51" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Notes from Worldcon 74]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@liesandperfidy/notes-from-worldcon-74-5323ff738ea8?source=rss-18f286e62243------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5323ff738ea8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hugo-awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Reuben Poling]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Aug 2016 22:51:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-23T15:59:36.179Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have a longer blog post in the works that actually contains, like, meaningful content and deep thoughts (or paragraphs masquerading as such.) But in the meanwhile, I can contribute the collected thoughts of other people! I took notes on every panel I attended, either live-tweeting or, in rooms with worse wi-fi signal, making notes &amp; screenshotting them.</p><p>(Side note: someone greeted me on Sunday with “So you’re the guy who’s been tweeting everything!” This is true of me both at Worldcon and as a general summation of my life. <a href="https://twitter.com/dril/status/247222360309121024?lang=en">I will never log off.</a> But it was both gratifying to be recognized and <em>weird</em> to be recognized for my conscientious note-taking, which is not a skill I’ve cultivated in my life until very recently. Never let them say social media can’t do anything for you.)</p><p>Anyway, I’d planned to Storify the various threads, but it turns out Storify doesn’t have a built-in advantage for threaded tweets so it’ll be easier to just compile and link directly. So: here are the panels I went to, the panelists of each, a quick summary, and the notes I took.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766308050810445824"><strong>“Have At You!” — Writing a Great Fight Scene</strong></a><strong>:</strong> <em>Eva Elasigue, Dr. Claire McCague, Kathryn Sullivane, Jeffe Kennedy, Steven Gould</em></p><p>My first panel of the con, so my notes were very short as I sorta found my level. Something that didn’t make it into the notes: pacing is so important for a fight scene, and probably the most important thing. Even just down to the length of sentences. Get punchy. Make an impact.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766334524309458944"><strong>“As You Know, Bob…” — The Fine Art of Exposition</strong></a><strong>:</strong> <em>Matthew S. Rotundo, Stanley Schmidt, Eric James Stone, Tamora Pierce, Kevin J. Anderson, Teresa Nielsen Hayden</em></p><p>This panel was probably the best one I attended in terms of pure craft advice, the nitty-gritty of making some words what do a good story. Also, Tamora Pierce is an anarchist who will burn down the world.</p><p><strong>Mythology as the Basis For Speculative Fiction: </strong><em>Sheila Finch, Katie Daniels, Jeffrey Cook, David Farnell, Ada Palmer </em>(<a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766374091280351232">Screenshots 1</a>; <a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766374382474100736">Screenshots 2</a>)</p><p>When I was at 4th St. Fantasy earlier this year, a ton of people were talking about <em>Too Like the Lightning </em>by Ada Palmer, and I was like “huh, I should read that book.” Now that I’ve seen Ada on a few panels…no, <em>really, </em>I should read that book. This panel also contained one of the most interesting observations about the Lovecraft mythos that I’ve ever heard, courtesy of David Farnell.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766378939568693248"><strong>SF As Protest Literature:</strong></a><strong> </strong><em>Alex Jablokow, Dr. Bradford Lyau, Mark Oshiro, Jo Walton, Ann Leckie</em> (<a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766390103363072000">Second small tweet thread</a>)</p><p><strong>This was the best panel I attended at Worldcon. </strong>The subject matter was great, each panelist brought an interesting perspective, and the moments where they intersected threw big CGI spaceship-crafting sparks into the air. (It was also the only one of Ann Leckie’s events I managed to attend, because I am a failure). I would gladly have listened to three hours of this.</p><p>About halfway through, the guy sitting directly in front of me flipped open his laptop and I couldn’t help glancing at the screen while he logged in. “Huh!” I thought to myself. “That guy’s user name is Cory Doctorow’! That’s a funny user name to <em>oh shit</em>.”</p><p><strong>It’s Not Torture If It’s the Good Guys: </strong><em>Scott Lynch, Seth Dickinson, John Wiswell, Marc Zicree </em>(<a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766668873366024192">Screenshots 1</a>; <a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766669007617335296">Screenshots 2</a>)</p><p>I wish I’d taken better notes on this, because it was great. It’s a subject near and dear to my creative heart and it was particularly interesting to hear Scott talk about one of my favorite scenes in fantasy (you know the one; this was a panel about torture) as its <em>very conflicted</em> author. The panel also said a lot of critical things about the American military and intelligence services, so basically, this was my catnip.</p><p>Also, holy shit you guys, Marc Zicree wrote “Far Beyond the Stars” for <em>Deep Space Nine</em>! He wrote “IT’S ALL REAL!” Worldcon is so cool.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766697372109778944"><strong>Action and Sex Scenes — Is There a Difference?</strong></a><strong>:</strong> <em>ElizaBeth Giligan, Fonda Lee, Rob Chilson, Dr. Claire McCague</em></p><p>Lotta craft focus in this one, unsurprisingly. I think it’s a mark of my development as a writer and adult human being that I didn’t giggle like Butthead at any point during this panel. I was definitely thinking it, though, because I’m still Butthead. <em>Huhuhuhuhu, narrative tension.</em></p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766710714702573569"><strong>A Cast of Thousands and A Unity of Plots</strong></a><strong>:</strong> <em>Ginjer Buchanan, Charlaine Harris, Scott Lynch, Kate Elliott, Robert Silverberg</em></p><p>I have to admit, this panel was shorter on actionable advice than I might have hoped, but it made up for it with entertainment value. Here’s how it went: four extremely accomplished authors took turns admitting that they were actually really disorganized, and then Bob Silverberg remembered another amazing story. Repeat. There was certainly some useful stuff, especially of the “dirty author tricks” nature, but it took second prize to the Silverberg Stories.</p><p>This was Bob’s 65th Worldcon. If he’d had a baby shortly before going to Worldcon for the first time, <em>that baby would now be retiring.</em></p><p><strong>Nifty Narrative Tricks: </strong><em>Elizabeth Bear, Steven Gould, Mary Robinette Kowal, Jo Walton, James Patrick Kelly</em> (<a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766756151983640577">Screenshots 1</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766756275300347904">Screenshots 2</a>)</p><p>I think I lied earlier. I actually went to a lot of really good craft panels. This one had some super actionable advice. Looking at my notes, I think there’s an implication that Mary Robinette Kowal did something obscene with a shoe being used as a puppet. This didn’t happen! It was just a really good bit of silent physical comedy. Mary’s gotten in enough trouble already.</p><p>Also, I would like to propose a new annual Worldcon panel called “Jo Walton talks about whatever she would like to talk about.” You see, it’s an event in which Jo Walton just talks, and we listen, and she gets to keep going for as long as she wants. I think it has a lot of potential.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766756574991745024"><strong>The Evolution of Epic Fantasy</strong></a>: <em>Kate Elliott, Sarah Beth Durst, Tessa Gratton, Stina Leicht, Anna Kashina</em></p><p>I mischaracterized the topic of this panel when I started transcribing; I thought it was going to be about how epic fantasy informs urban fantasy and vice versa. It was just about high fantasy! Now I’m wondering if I subconsciously misread the description because, you know, a panel of all women authors <em>had </em>to be about urban fantasy, not high fantasy. That’s some bad braining right there, and I apologize for it. The panel was awesome, especially <a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/766762224463454209">this part.</a></p><p>(At this point, Friday programming complete,, I embarked on an evening journey involving enormous heaps of meat, Malort, absinthe, picklebacks, and the Terrible Fate of the Finnish Tango King. For some reason, my notes deteriorated in quantity and quality in the following day.)</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/767104143638994944"><strong>Dialog in <em>Game of Thrones</em> — Great Storytelling through Ordinary Conversations</strong></a><strong> </strong><em>(Erin Underwood, David McDonald, Charlaine Harris, Toni Kelner)</em></p><p>This panel was a little fluffy — you know, “let’s geek out about our favorite stuff in front of an audience” — which was fine. Listening to Charlaine Harris talk about her favorite HBO adaption and throw the <em>subtlest shade</em> at HBO in the process was a delight. I actually feel that the dialog in<em> GoT</em>, while one of the show’s strengths, has some real tin-ear moments, and talking about <em>why</em> those don’t work when others do would have been interesting…but that wasn’t really this panel. I still enjoyed it.</p><p>If you’re wondering how George R.R. Martin’s career is going: there was a panel specifically devoted to his work, at a convention that he was attending, and he was too busy to attend the panel. That’s a Secret Hugo Award.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/767119007166062592"><strong>Giving Constructive Criticism</strong></a> (<em>Walt Boyes, Terrence Miltner, Lauren M. Roy, Vivian Trask, Stephen Leigh, Rick Wilber</em>)</p><p>This was actually a super fucking cool panel because the advice was useful at every level — giving &amp; receiving feedback, working professionally and with friends. I don’t have much else to say about it that my notes didn’t say — though, regarding “beta reading isn’t copy editing,” the continually rad Shveta Thrakar did have <a href="https://twitter.com/ShvetaThakrar/status/767125307040141312">this important addendum</a>.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/liesandperfidy/status/767391011974762496"><strong>Oh, Goddess!</strong><em> </em></a><em>(Frederick Turner, Tessa Gratton, Dr. Mary Anne Mohanraj, Ada Palmer, Symantha Reagor)</em></p><p>I’ll be honest: when I saw a panel on goddesses in spec-fic composed of four women being moderated by an older man, my guts churned a little. We’ve all heard those horror stories (yes, including <em>that</em> one; I’ll have stuff to say about it another time). But I think Mr. Turner did a fine job as both a panelist and a moderator. Anyway, this was a really fucking cool panel that went all over space and time; it ended up being more focused on real-world mythological history than crafting your own spec-fic goddesses, but that was just as informative. There were probably six different things I wanted to hear like another half hour about.</p><p>Symantha Reagor brought up the pantheon from <em>Guild Wars</em>, specifically the trickster goddess Lissa. I loved hearing, in the middle of this very academic discussion on thousands of years of religion &amp; myth, a shout-out to an MMORPG. She was right, too!</p><p>So: that was my programming experience. I also went to a couple readings, one of which (GRRM) I annotated. I’m going to clean that up and post it at some point. Let me know if there are any issues with my Twitter compilations and I’ll try to fix them. I may yet Storify them for future convenience if I can figure out a convenient way to handle threading.</p><p>Thanks for reading! More on Worldcon-in-general later.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5323ff738ea8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>