<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Life Itself on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Life Itself on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lifeitself?source=rss-2fdf91aa0d21------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:42:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lifeitself/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Crypto: can these financial perpetual motion machines work?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lifeitself/crypto-can-these-financial-perpetual-motion-machines-work-a60d3d99df6?source=rss-2fdf91aa0d21------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a60d3d99df6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Life Itself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Mar 2023 13:52:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-15T13:52:22.654Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Does crypto technology “magic” allow it to transcend the principles of economics?</em></p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#update-november-2022">Update November 2022</a></h3><p>Since this post was written, FTX, one of the world&#39;s largest crypto exchanges, has controversially and spectacularly <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/post-ftx-collapse">collapsed</a>. This provides yet more compelling evidence that the crypto boom was the result of a financial bubble, rather than a magical perpetual motion machine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vfze_DyR7wXo150gG_unvw.jpeg" /></figure><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#introduction">Introduction</a></h3><p>The current crypto-economy is booming. A huge amount of money is circulating, and on the surface, it appears many are gaining huge returns on their crypto investments. As one now infamous piece of crypto popular culture puts it, the line just keeps going up. Much of the rhetoric in the crypto-sphere gives a sense of a perpetual motion machine, generating self-fuelled growth which will last forever. The key question is, can it?</p><p>This analysis will unpack the idea of crypto as a financial perpetual motion machine. Drawing on the downfall of TerraUSD as a case study it examines the dynamics and sustainability of the current crypto-economy, noting some worrying similarities to financial bubbles including the one which triggered the 2008 financial crisis. Finally, we consider the best-case scenario for the sustainability of a crypto-asset — widespread acceptance and diversification before the speculation bubble bursts — before laying out our prognosis as to whether the crypto-economy can continue to operate as a financial perpetual motion machine. We conclude that this is unlikely at best.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#contents">Contents</a></h3><ol><li><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#para1">What does it mean to call crypto a financial perpetual motion machine?</a></li><li><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#para2">TerraUSD: a case study in the impossibility of financial perpetual motion</a></li><li><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#para3">Similarities between the crypto economy and the pre-2008 financial bubble</a></li><li><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#para4">The best case scenario for crypto-assets: (1) Ponzi, (2) acceptance, (3) diversification, (4) permanence</a></li><li><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#para5">Conclusion: crypto isn’t a magic bullet for financial perpetual motion</a></li></ol><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#1-what-does-it-mean-to-call-crypto-a-financial-perpetual-motion-machine">1. What does it mean to call crypto a financial perpetual motion machine?</a></h3><p>A perpetual motion machine is a device that, once set in motion, continues to be in motion, with no requirement for any external source of energy to maintain it. The appeal of a perpetual motion machine is the reward of essentially limitless free energy (minus the cost of the initial input of energy to get it going). The first and second laws of thermodynamics have proven the existence of such machines to be impossible.</p><p>By analogy, we can think of a financial perpetual motion machine as something generating continuing economic returns, and perhaps even growth in returns, forever, “for free”. The term “free” here is not used as strictly as in the technical definition above; in the case of crypto, money is spent on inputs such as developer labor, and the energy used for activities such as mining. The important characteristic is that the value of any given asset increases without any economically productive activity taking place. On the understanding of the crypto-economy as a financial perpetual motion machine, my crypto-assets will keep growing in value perpetually without my doing anything (i.e. expending any inputs myself), and without this growth being attached to economically productive activity — understood as the production of goods and services which generate utility for people — as is the case with traditional investments such as stocks.</p><p>While the analogy is not perfect, the impossibility of true perpetual motion should give serious pause for thought as to the sustainability of this consistent and unproductive value growth. This skepticism can only be strengthened by observing the pattern played out time and again throughout economic history: financial perpetual motion invariably transpires to be little more than a bubble, grinding dramatically to a halt as spirits shift and the bubble bursts. Examining the dynamics of the crypto-economy in more detail, there are alarming similarities with both the pre-2008 financial system and bubbles further into the past. We will turn to this analysis in the following sections, beginning with an illustrative case study of the now-defunct stablecoin Terra and its staggeringly rapid crash.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#2-terrausd-a-case-study-in-the-impossibility-of-financial-perpetual-motion">2. TerraUSD: a case study in the impossibility of financial perpetual motion</a></h3><p>To explain why the crypto sphere is not a financial perpetual motion machine we are going to examine the mechanisms that enable the crypto market to churn out more value for investors than was deposited. We are going to use the stablecoin TerraUSD (UST) to demonstrate how these mechanisms operate and to explain why the system is unsustainable. UST is fitting to use as an example to demonstrate how all crypto-assets operate as they are fundamentally underpinned by the same mechanisms. We will explain how the crash suffered by UST is demonstrative of the systemic risk which runs throughout both DeFi and crypto-asset investments more broadly.</p><p>UST is an algorithmic stablecoin that is pegged to the US dollar. Whereas fiat- or crypto-collateralized stablecoins maintain their peg by having a reserve of fiat or cryptocurrency as collateral, algorithmic stablecoins such as UST maintain their peg through a system of algorithmic arbitrage. UST has a sister token, Luna. The system is designed so that each UST token is redeemable for $1 worth of Luna. Therefore, when UST is trading below $1, traders are incentivized to buy one UST and exchange it for $1 worth of Luna. As UST is burnt to mint Luna, the supply of UST is reduced and its price is pushed up. When UST is trading above $1, token holders are incentivized to exchange their Luna for UST. This increases the supply of UST, thereby reducing its price and keeping the value of UST stable at $1.</p><p>As an algorithmic stablecoin, untied from the volatility of other cryptocurrencies like bitcoin or ether, UST was presented as a safe and steady place to hold one’s money while still remaining within the crypto ecosystem. An additional motivation to potential investors of UST was the promise of staggering yields by holding their UST in a decentralized finance (DeFi) savings protocol called Anchor. The protocol, running on the Terra blockchain, promises 20% interest to those who deposit UST.</p><p>While Terra and Luna are often described as a financial engineering experiment, for a long time it looked as though the experiment was working. According to Coingecko, at its peak in early April, the market value of all Luna exceeded $41 billion placing it in the top 10 cryptocurrencies. 1</p><p>On May 7, 2022, UST deviated from its peg, seemingly as a result of massive withdrawals from Anchor. As billions of UST were removed from Anchor and dumped on the market, the price of Terra slipped, motivating more and more people to pull their money out of Anchor and get rid of their UST. While Luna tanked, the algorithm carried on doing what it was programmed to do: the system created more and more tokens to meet the demand of UST sellers who all remained entitled to a dollar’s worth of Luna. This caused the price to plunge even more, diluting the market with Luna. By May 13, one Luna was valued at $0.00001834 and the total supply of the coin was over 6.5 trillion. At the time of writing, UST is currently sitting at 10 cents.2 As described by Kevin Zhou, crypto hedge fund Galois Capital founder, Luna had suffered from “hyperinflation of hyperinflation”.3</p><p>Terra provides a stark case study of the dynamics of the crypto-economy not just because of its dramatic demise, but because the mechanism by which it sustained its growth and subsequently crashed pervades the whole of the crypto-sphere. The Terra system depended entirely on Luna, a manufactured token with no intrinsic or <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.us/concepts/use-value">use value</a>. Its value was a product of <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.us/concepts/artificial-demand">artificial demand</a> dynamics generated by overblown <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.us/claims/is-narrative-economics.md">narratives</a> and speculation. Almost all crypto projects share this characteristic: they are fuelled by demand for newly created tokens devoid of meaningful value beyond allowing one to participate in the project and make financial gains from speculation. The growth stemming from the sheer belief that these tokens will continue to increase in value bears all the hallmarks of <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.us/concepts/greater-fool-theory.md">greater fool theory</a> and of an economic bubble, as we outline below.</p><p>Even more worrying is the role of the Anchor platform in the case of Terra, the prevalence of yield farming, and the spate of complex financial derivatives which has sprung up around crypto-assets. As displayed by the impacts on Terra of large withdrawals from Anchor, this layering of ever more complex financial instruments on top of tokens whose value depends on belief alone builds an extremely high level of systemic risk into the system. Not only does this make it more likely that the <a href="https://web3.lifeitself.us/concepts/bubble">bubble</a> will pop, but the impacts will be all the direr when it does. As outlined in the next section, this bears a striking resemblance to the system which underpinned the 2008 financial crisis.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#3-similarities-between-the-crypto-economy-and-the-pre-2008-financial-bubble">3. Similarities between the crypto-economy and the pre-2008 financial bubble</a></h3><p>As noted above, the case of Terra is indicative of the bubble dynamics that pervade the entire crypto ecosystem. When we compare these more directly to economic bubbles throughout history, it is hard to avoid drawing parallels that bode ill for the prospect of crypto’s perpetual growth.</p><p>Economic bubbles are a market phenomenon that sees irrational pricing of an asset caused by herd mentality; people hear stories of others who bought in early and made big profits, and more and more people jump in, pushing the value of the asset up and up, exceeding the intrinsic value of the asset (if the asset even has any value), until one day the mania subsides and the value of the asset plummets.</p><p>Where such assets have complex financial instruments built on top, there is a risk of far-reaching systemic damage. The 2008 subprime crisis provides a demonstration of what happens when a range of complex financial products are completely dependent on the cash flows of a fundamentally unstable asset. Just as a fall in house prices caused mass mortgage defaults by borrowers in precarious financial positions, and in doing so brought down the entire financial system propped up by their repackaged debt, the cautionary tale of Terra shows the very same vulnerability throughout the system of decentralized finance (DeFi), which hinges on speculation-driven token value.</p><p>In her 2022 paper ‘DeFi: Shadow Banking 2.0?’ Prof. Hilary Allen warns that the current DeFi system risks emulating the “shadow banking” services (functional equivalents for banking products that operate outside the regulated banking sphere) which contributed to the 2008 banking crisis:</p><p>“<em>if DeFi is permitted to develop without any regulatory intervention, it will magnify the tendencies towards heightened leverage, rigidity, and runs that characterized Shadow Banking 1.0.</em>”4</p><p>Commentators have raised concerns about stablecoins in particular, describing them as analogous to the money market funds (MMF) at the heart of the 2008 crisis in their potential to cause runs. Prof. Allen explains:</p><p>“<em>If something were to shake confidence in stablecoins’ acceptance in the DeFi ecosystem (this ‘something’ could range from a hack to a problem with the reserve of assets backing a stablecoin, to a problem with the smart contracts managing the value of a decentralized stablecoin), we could then expect holders to exchange their stablecoins for fiat currency and exchanges to seek redemption, forcing stablecoin issuers to start liquidating the reserve of assets backing the stablecoin, depressing the market value of those assets, and cutting off credit for the corporations in which MMFs usually invest through the commercial paper market.</em>”5</p><p>This fragility and extreme vulnerability to the <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/animal-spirits.asp#:~:text=%22Animal%20spirits%22%20is%20a%20term,of%20economic%20stress%20or%20uncertainty.">animal spirits</a> of investors pervades the entire crypto-economy. The core mechanism — of minting tokens with no use value and whose market price is artificially driven by speculative hype — underpins almost the whole system (with the small exception of tokens that are in some way backed by real-world assets, whose value growth beyond the price of these assets still remains fuelled by speculation). What might appear as a recipe for perpetual growth and financial gain in fact appears highly likely to have created a speculation fuelled bubble, with the complex token derivatives which characterize DeFi akin to castles built on foundations of sand. If this analysis is correct then not only is crypto far from a financial perpetual motion machine but an economic time bomb.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#4-the-best-case-scenario-for-crypto-assets-1-ponzi-2-acceptance-3-diversification-4-permanence">4. The best case scenario for crypto-assets: (1) Ponzi, (2) acceptance, (3) diversification, (4) permanence</a></h3><p>The above paints a bleak outlook for the crypto-economy. So, what’s the best-case scenario? Is there any way that the machine can keep running and generating wealth?</p><p>The strongest case has been outlined in Bloomberg, although in a twist of irony, it focuses on Terra, just days before its crash. While the piece focuses on <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-19/the-stability-of-algorithmic-stablecoins">‘The Stability of Algorithmic Stablecoins’</a> it can perhaps be extended to other crypto projects also.</p><p>As the article notes, if you can keep your token-based Ponzi scheme going for long enough then you may be able to reach a point of widespread acceptance. Your stablecoin, despite having no intrinsic value, is just accepted as being worth, say $1. It is this common recognition embedded in the collective psyche of the system’s participants which maintains this value rather than a reliance on an algorithmic mechanism. This is to some extent akin to the collective belief that upholds the value of fiat money, although crucially without the power of a state to enforce it should this belief waver.</p><p>The next step would be to diversify the reserves backing the peg of your stablecoin, into other more embedded cryptocurrencies more embedded in the system such as bitcoin, and perhaps also non-blockchain-based assets such as gold and dollars. This diversification means that the project is no longer contingent just on investor belief in your own manufactured token’s value. If that spell breaks, there are assets deriving their market value from elsewhere which can be spent to return the value of your stablecoin to $1. More and more reserve assets are purchased until there are sufficient ‘real world’ tools ready to back up this zero-value, made-up asset. This ‘best case scenario’ can be summarized, then, as: “(1) Ponzi, (2) acceptance, (3) diversification, (4) permanence.”6</p><p>In theory, this process could be adapted to function for non-stablecoin projects also. The key is the transition from dependence on [speculative] belief in the value of the project’s manufactured token to other means of securing its value: economic norms and then external assets.</p><p>Even under this best-case scenario, however, the prospects for the perpetual growth of the crypto-economy as a whole remain slim. First, while this process could at least in theory work for specific crypto-assets, it cannot work for all of them. Not every crypto token can become so embedded that its value is simply accepted as a given, or become so big that it can fund the purchase of large amounts of external reserves.</p><p>Second, while other crypto-assets still make up a part of a token’s reserve assets, its value will still depend largely on the performance of the crypto-market as a whole. If, as appears plausible based on the above analysis, the great majority of this market is subject to the same speculation fuelled bubble dynamics, then vulnerabilities persist both at the level of individual projects and the broader market. This could be seen in the case of Terra, where a large proportion of initial Anchor withdrawals seemed to occur in response to general market downturns.</p><p>Third, pivoting to backing by real-world assets, arguably the most likely way to ensure a crypto token can retain its value, will fundamentally undermine the dynamics giving rise to a perception of financial perpetual motion in the first place. As soon as real-world assets enter the equation, so do the constraints of real-world economics. Growth will become a function of the real-world assets underpinning tokens, and this growth is far less likely to be propelled to dizzying rates by speculation.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#5-conclusion-crypto-isnt-a-magic-bullet-for-financial-perpetual-motion">5. Conclusion: crypto isn’t a magic bullet for financial perpetual motion</a></h3><p>The above examples provide strong reasons to believe that the crypto-economy cannot keep growing like this forever. The financial perpetual motion machine must at some point come to a halt, as the speculation-driven artificial demand for fundamentally valueless crypto-assets peters out. History is littered with examples of economic bubbles, all of which eventually burst. As the 2008 crash demonstrates, whole-system collapse is made both more likely and more disastrous when derivatives and other complex financial products spring up around bubble-driven asset prices. This same systemic risk pervades the ‘DeFi’ system, with the case of Terra being a warning of dynamics that have the potential to cause crashes at far larger scales.</p><p>The best-case scenario for individual crypto-assets — normalization and backup asset diversification — is unlikely and does little to secure the continuing growth of the entire crypto-economy. This system is occupying some of the world’s smartest minds, contributing massive carbon emissions to our atmosphere, and had, at its peak, over $3 trillion dollars invested into it. It is time we stepped back from the illusion of financial perpetual motion, before the inevitable crypto-asset crashes begin shaking the wider global economy.</p><h3><a href="https://web3.lifeitself.org/notes/financial-perpetual-motion-machine#notes-and-references">Notes and references</a></h3><ol><li>CoinGecko. ‘Terra Price, Luna Chart, and Market Cap’. Accessed 17 May 2022. <a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/terra-Luna">https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/terra-Luna</a>.</li><li>CoinMarketCap. ‘TerraUSD Price Today, UST to USD Live, Marketcap and Chart’. Accessed 18 May 2022. <a href="https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/terrausd/">https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/terrausd/</a>.</li><li>Weisenthal, Joe, and Tracy Alloway. ‘Meet the Hedge-Fund Manager Who Warned of Terra’s $60 Billion Implosion’. Bloomberg.Com, 15 May 2022. <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-05-15/Luna-crash-this-crypto-insider-warned-of-terra-ust-s-collapse">https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-05-15/Luna-crash-this-crypto-insider-warned-of-terra-ust-s-collapse</a>.</li><li>Allen, Hilary J. ‘DeFi: Shadow Banking 2.0?’ SSRN Electronic Journal, 2022. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4038788">https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4038788</a>.</li><li>Ibid.</li><li>Levine, Matt. ‘The Stability of Algorithmic Stablecoins’. Bloomberg.Com, 19 April 2022. <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-19/the-stability-of-algorithmic-stablecoins">https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-19/the-stability-of-algorithmic-stablecoins</a>.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a60d3d99df6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Collective blindspots]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/series/collective-blindspots-2bc9febeffc0?source=rss-2fdf91aa0d21------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2bc9febeffc0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Life Itself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jan 2020 16:22:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-06T16:22:07.459Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>An introduction to collective blindspots</strong></h3><h4><strong>Liam Kavanagh</strong></h4><p>Art Earth Tech is a community for a wiser world. You might ask how we see society getting wiser — we suggest that one of the main ways we can collectively become wiser is to look at our shared blind spots.</p><p>What are shared blind spots? You might think of them as collective versions of individual blind spots.</p><p><em>A very common blind spot develops when, for example, people do not recognize how their attachment to individual freedom impacts relationships with their families, partners, and children. The blind spot that results from the simultaneous desire for individual freedom and the inability to recognize the effects of this desire on relationships can lead to pain. We might notice our lack of connection but miss the role that our desire for freedom plays in our isolation, because such a conflict is painful to confront, and we wish to avoid giving up our attachment to freedom. Of course, we address this kind of conflict best when we become fully aware of the blind spots that make it possible, and this is also true on a large scale as people work together to mend a torn social fabric.</em></p><p>Many of the problems that cultures struggle to address are the consequences of shared blind spots. When everybody shares the same blind spot, it can be impossible to recognize, leading to ineffective solutions. This is a problem of culture, and of course human cultures can be as dysfunctional as families or individuals. So, in facing shared blind spots, we are at once seeking personal development and cultural activism.</p><p>Whether we are trying to transform ourselves or our society, we can move beyond feelings of guilt or shame about blind spots, and attend to them in a compassionate manner that opens the door to understanding. We believe that the best way to do this is collectively. At AET events, we gather a group of individuals who have already made a commitment to recognizing and transforming their personal suffering, whether through meditation or other forms of self-development, in order to create the conditions for transformational thinking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UmE2noviRrRHhF7m.jpg" /></figure><p>In our last AET gathering, we considered the following shared blind spots:</p><p>In our last AET gathering, we considered the following shared blind spots:</p><p><strong>Faith in Rationality and Progress.</strong> We are supposedly leaving behind the notion of progress — a belief in the steady and inevitable improvement of individuals and societies through developments in rational understanding and technology, or the equating of social progress with technological progress — yet it is still here with us. Do we put too much faith in our technology because of its dazzling past? Do we still overrate what science can do for us? Is it still something of a religion to believe in science and technology as the solutions to our problems? If these beliefs blind us, how do we actually let go of them?</p><p><strong>Belief in Individualism.</strong> We tend to define ourselves as unique individuals distinguished by essential personalities. Many of our ideas about ourselves and the world in which we live are based on that simple construct. And yet, how separate are we? How much of our identities, behaviors, sensibilities, and ideas are created purely through interaction with those around us? Our humor, our values, our ideals, and even our concept of ourselves as unique individuals are forged through our social engagement. What kind of blind spots do ideas about individualism create, and how to they prevent us from tapping into our greater collective intelligence to address global challenges?</p><p><strong>The Equality Complex.</strong> Westerners are highly attached to the idea of equality because it has done a great deal for us. At some point most of our ancestors were from “the lower classes” they were enslaved, or were peasants and surfs, and the transition over generations to more privileged positions has often been achieved with equality as a rallying cry. Along the way, our conceptions of equality have become near religious significance. But has this faith shaded into rigid dogmat. Equality as a social ideal is elusive; we often seem to confuse equality of status with sameness in talents. Has attachment to the idea of equality therefore impeded conversations around global and environmental justice? Is there an alternative way of thinking and feeling that allows us to preserve or even enhance the positive outcomes we associate with equality and avoid pitfalls?</p><p>My next three posts will discuss these three blind spots as they relate to what is probably the biggest issue of our time — the climate crisis.</p><p><a href="https://artearthtech.com/institute/blind-spots/"><em>Blind Spots</em></a><em> is our new series exploring the collective blind spots of our society. We invite you to check the previous blind spot events we organized </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/05/01/interview-roberto-unger/"><em>Blind Spots #1: The Knowledge Economy, the Progressive Project and the Future of Britain with Roberto Unger</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/04/17/blind-spots-2-returning-to-mystery/"><em>Blind Spots #2: Returning to Mystery, Saving Ourselves</em></a></p><h3><strong>Collective blind spot #1: faith in rationality and progress</strong></h3><h4><strong>Liam Kavanagh</strong></h4><p>As I watched reports of the Arctic wildfires this summer and witnessed the climate protests of the fall, I wondered: are we finally nearing that long-anticipated, long-dreaded point of collective reckoning? Will the world’s sights and sounds force our guts to feel what our intellect has long held in ghostly form? Humans have messed the earth up badly, and destruction is easier than healing, which is a truth basic enough to make it into nursery rhyme:</p><p><em>Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall,</em></p><p><em>Humpty Dumpty had a great fall;</em></p><p><em>All the king’s horses and all the king’s men</em></p><p><em>Couldn’t put Humpty together again.</em></p><p>At the personal level, many of us are stepping back and asking ourselves, “how did we get here?” I hope a collective version of this process begins very soon, which has got me thinking.</p><p>When I step back to look at my Western culture, which has created technological miracles but has also destroyed other cultures and seems to be on the brink of destroying itself, I’m struck by three shared cultural beliefs that we cling to: our extreme faith in analytical rationality, our strong ideas about individuality, and our obsession with equality (the last one is confronting, however bear with me on this: this is not about ignoring injustice or poverty). These beliefs all come out of the eighteenth-century Enlightenment era of which our culture is proud — but these particular ideas do not feel so enlightened these days. In this second post in our series on blind spots, I will look at our faith in rationality as it interacts with climate.</p><p>Is excessive faith in rationality a big part of our climate predicament? On the one hand, many might say “no,” given the number of people that seem determined to ignore science and dismiss the many scientists sounding alarms. However, this strange response is likely connected to the fact that our culture actually places too much faith in rationality and its famed products — technology, science, and profit-driven business.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*orED2tHSHZzMXNId.jpg" /></figure><p>Consider, just for starters, the most common objections to calls for</p><p>Consider, just for starters, the most common objections to calls for climate activism that claim that our concerns about the future are overblown because we actually don’t know for certain exactly how our weather systems will change, what the consequences will be, or how long the process will take. At the base of this objection is an extreme form of scientism, a belief that science should always provide us with exact answers. Scientism is an ideology fueled by the attachment to feelings of certainty and control that we humans enjoy while we pace around on the large island of order that, over millennia, our society has managed to dam off from the waters of chaos. And here I refer to our houses and computers and cars that travel on very flat roads and all the other things that function exactly like they’re supposed to almost all the time, down to perfect, red spherical tomatoes available at all times of the year.</p><p>It would be nice indeed if we could act now with total certainty about the future that we are seeking to avoid, but we just can’t. Climate science by its nature cannot be precise. In classic scientific experiments that result in neat and certain formulas, we are able to isolate and control one example out of a larger group of very similar entities (for example, a pure form of a particular substance, like carbon), and we can identify rules that apply to other similar entities out there in the world (such as the characteristics of carbon). Then we can use these rules to predict and control the many similar entities that are out there, waiting to be manipulated. Climate science does not rely on the results of experiments done within the artificial conditions of laboratories, and it describes only one very large, very messy thing, the Earth, which is itself a system that we are unable to isolate or to copy.</p><p>We can run experiments on this system, and we are certainly doing so with carbon emissions, but the experimental results that will tell us exactly what will happen to the Earth if we let it warm by 2 degrees Celsius will only come after the planet has warmed by 2 degrees Celsius — and by then, it will be too late. The idea that we can get a perfect scientific model before this all-too-real experiment runs its course seems to be a fantasy driven by our excessive faith in rationality.</p><p>The Earth is often likened to a single organism, so our situation is a bit like discovering a single exotic animal from the Amazon, one that we will never be able to replace, one that is unlike any other animal that we know of. We know the animal will stay healthy under certain conditions — the ones in which it has always thrived. But we run experiments on it and measure its internal processes by scraping a few pieces off of the animal and looking at them in the microscope. The results of our experiments, combined with our understanding of basic science, lead us to suspect that the creature will react badly if we change its conditions, but we persist in running the experiment, because we aren’t absolutely sure. We certainly recognize signs that the life form is not responding well to what we are doing, but, because we don’t know for sure yet exactly what will happen to the creature, we decide not to panic.</p><p>This example sounds insane, because it is. Obviously, if we wanted to preserve a life form in a healthy state, we would stop the experiments immediately. But we don’t always see this as clearly in life, because, in the case of climate change, the experiments that are being run on the Earth are highly pleasurable to humans.</p><p>Instead, we expect to be able to determine exactly when we will need to act to save the organism (the Earth), or how to cure it even after deeply damaging it, or how exactly we might attempt to replace it. Interest in such scientific knowledge is great, but expectation of or obsession with this kind of knowledge is off the mark. Sometimes you have to look at the big picture, sense the tradeoffs, accept your inevitable ignorance, and simply act based on your best judgement, which is frustratingly subjective. Plainly, we should have cut emissions long ago. We must do so drastically now.</p><p>There are many reasons why we cannot seem to act despite the consequences of inaction, but in the next two parts of this series, I will highlight two. One is an ideology of extreme individualism which has convinced us that we can and should live independently, ruling out collective action. And second, more controversially, we are utterly attached to a misguided definition of equality, which, although it has been effective in fighting oppression and inhumanity, is now in danger of becoming inflexible dogma. The attachment to certain beliefs about equality can sometimes translate into dangerous discord during any attempt to discuss the pressing social issues before us, including those of the climate debate.</p><p><a href="https://artearthtech.com/institute/blind-spots/"><em>Blind Spots</em></a><em> is our new series exploring the collective blind spots of our society. We invite you to read </em><a href="http://artearthtech.com/2019/10/25/introduction-to-our-collective-blind-spots/"><em>An introduction to our collective blind spots</em></a><em> and check the previous blind spot events we organized </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/05/01/interview-roberto-unger/"><em>Blind Spots #1: The Knowledge Economy, the Progressive Project and the Future of Britain with Roberto Unger</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/04/17/blind-spots-2-returning-to-mystery/"><em>Blind Spots #2: Returning to Mystery, Saving Ourselves</em></a>.</p><h3>Collective blind spot #2: individualism</h3><h4>Liam Kavanagh</h4><p>I started off this series of four blogs by first introducing the three major cultural attachments that Art Earth Tech has been taking as a theme this last year — rationality, individuality, and equality — and the blind spots that these attachments create. Next, I made the case that our religious faith in rationality stalls action on climate. Persistent faith that rational inquiry is <em>just about to</em> come up with a technological fix is one well known problem but just as important is the notion that <em>we can understand the climate crisis precisely</em>, and that very good models of the climate are possible and necessary for action. This leads to time wasted waiting for firmer scientific consensus and clearer answers, when really none are possible.</p><p>Though we have known it is “time for action” for decades, our culture of individualism has made political action almost impossible. Reducing carbon emissions is clearly technically possible, <em>there are straightforward ways of doing this — we could put a high price on carbon for example. But such measures have been politically impossible because they affect the individual’s ability to choose to buy what they want. We are allergic to this idea, because we have been told we can “do it my way” that there is a sphere of individual choice that is a natural and even sacred space.</em> The belief that we are entitled to live our own lives, doing our own thing, without interference from anybody, is quite dear to us. Libertarianism is basically this sentiment turned into a political creed; it claims to advance freedom by forbidding us to write laws.</p><p>Of course, this is silly. Humans share space and lives — as George Bernhard Shaw said, “A Smoker and a Non-Smoker do not have the same rights on train car” and so laws like banning smoking emissions make sense. Our choices interfere with other’s choices, and we avoid acceptance of this only through clinging to the dogmatic insistence that we live independent lives. The climate crisis is basically a global version of Shaw’s train car dilemma with carbon playing the role of smoke. But unlike in the train car, the greatest polluters are feeling the effects the least (scientific projections are that some homes mostly near the equator, will be uninhabitable within decades) and future generations’ choices are restricted by our choices — the second-hand smoke just builds up in the air for millennia.</p><p>It is worth noting that the US is the most famously and fiercely individualistic nation on earth, and it is the only place in which libertarianism is taken seriously. This is not a coincidence. By preventing the US from taking part in global solutions, political parties who are most rigidly built around ideas of individual freedom, especially US Republicans, have essentially stopped global action on climate. Their ideas are not foreign to the rest of us, they are just more extreme. The language of the collective “interfering” with the individuals only really makes sense if we assume that there is some natural state of freedom that individuals exist in. If there ever were such a state, it was as a hunter gatherer in a forest. Societies that are technically advanced like ours depend on governments and laws.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4QIrUZAtcXvmfWZX.jpg" /></figure><p>Libertarianism is the belief that, essentially, we don’t need a government because individuals acting on their own will solve problems. Libertarians, even more than others, promote technology (e.g. Bitcoin) as the solution to our problems because if individual inventors acting alone can solve our problems no government is necessary. If an inventor can, through a heroic act of brilliance, make clean energy cheaper than high-carbon energy then no government is necessary. And so libertarian individualists embrace technological solutions to collective problems.</p><p>Though enhancing the rights of the individual has done great things (I am quite happy to move where I want and be free of an arranged marriage) the climate crisis shows how this good idea has become a new and absurd faith.</p><p><em>*</em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/institute/blind-spots/"><em>Blind Spots</em></a><em> is our new series exploring the collective blind spots of our society. We invite you to read </em><a href="http://artearthtech.com/2019/10/25/introduction-to-our-collective-blind-spots/"><em>An introduction to our collective blind spots</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/11/04/blind-spot-1-faith-in-rationality-and-progress/"><em>Collective blind spot #1: faith in rationality and progress</em></a></p><p><em>Please also check the previous blind spot events we organized </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/05/01/interview-roberto-unger/"><em>Blind Spots #1: The Knowledge Economy, the Progressive Project and the Future of Britain with Roberto Unger</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://artearthtech.com/2019/04/17/blind-spots-2-returning-to-mystery/"><em>Blind Spots #2: Returning to Mystery, Saving Ourselves</em></a><em>*.</em></p><h3>Collective blind spot #3: the equality complex</h3><h4>Liam Kavanagh</h4><p>This blog series has focused on three revolutionary ideas that have slowly turned into dogmas: the faith in the power of rationality and scientific inquiry, individualism, and equality. I am asking whether these enlightenment ideas have become dogmas and how any rigidity creates collective blindnesses.</p><p>Equality is the hardest and least socially acceptable of these ideas to question. Historically, almost all people in Western society owe their social position to political movements that used ideals of equality as a rallying cry. Most of our ancestors were peasants and serfs or were enslaved, and they argued and fought for the rights we now have. Their tactic was often to point out the similarity between humans, even those on vastly different positions in the social hierarchy. It has been barely more than 100 years since women could vote, and non-white people have been denied the vote until very recently by people that called themselves democratic. It has been a historical eyeblink since anybody but King and nobles had a real say in any country on Earth. Ideas of equality have become very ingrained as we enjoy the effects that have come with the onset of democratic ideology.</p><p>So our attachment to equality is understandable. Another principle that we hold deeply is open mindedness and the notion that dogma always comes with costs. It is this principle, actually, that helped to open the door not that many generations ago, to questioning of extreme inequality between people. The right of Kings to rule was yesterday’s dogma.</p><p>In order to demonstrate that equality is something of a dogma, I will ask you to consider these statements:</p><blockquote>Money is not a source of suffering, but an obsession with money is.</blockquote><blockquote>Achievement is not a source of suffering, but an obsession with achievement is.</blockquote><blockquote>Being good looking is not a source of suffering, but an obsession with being good looking is.</blockquote><p>There are many things that do not cause suffering, but an obsession with anything is a source of suffering.</p><p>My experience is that most people would agree with these, but many get uncomfortable if I repeat:</p><blockquote><em>equality is not a source of suffering, but the equality complex (an obsession with it) is.</em></blockquote><p>This last statement is a quote from the Zen Master Thich Nhat Hanh. It is the only statement of his (that I know of) that reliably seems to raise people’s defences. There are good reasons for that defensiveness, but still I want to ask if it is a sign of dogma. If we think dogma has costs, then we should look more deeply to see what those are.</p><p>Or perhaps I should say: when Thich Nhat Hanh says the above quote, people are puzzled, but when I repeat it, they often say: <em>”…but we can’t just accept massive inequality!”</em></p><p>Now one <em>could </em>say that it should be obvious I am not saying that we should accept massive inequality. If I said, <em>“I think being obsessed with looking good causes me suffering”, </em>would it be reasonable to conclude that I mean, <em>“I am happy to look terrible.” </em>No.</p><p>But, of course, I am a white male Zen non-master, and am privileged in western society, which is privileged relative to the whole world. So some people that I have spoken to have reasonably suspected me of using Thich Nhat Hanh’s quote to preserve these privileges. As long as I am selfish (I have an ego) there will always be an element of that, I will be defensive and ignorant because not being conscious of how I am unfairly advantaged is the easiest way to keep my advantages. I think many white males would report that it would be nice if they could get through a day without being reminded of inequality in a way that makes them feel guilty, but if we try, we can understand why other people don’t sympathise with us that much.</p><p>The reality of equality is, however, that few people anywhere have shown the total belief in equality required to give away enough of their money to be equal in financial privileges to others. Speaking collectively, though we may have high ideals, these are not supported by deep convictions about equality in the West, or as a society we would be making plans to share our wealth. Foreign aid is less than one percent of most rich countries’ GDP and whether our foreign aid is well spent is a hotly debated issue.</p><p>At this point we can say that our ideals are bulls**t and commence hating ourselves and maybe even humans, generally. But to do this misses the point of ideals. Ideals are something to work towards, something to keep us honest, rather than standards that that we can strongly expect people to live up to.</p><p>Some people will resent me for saying this, because some people think accepting that we fall short of ideals opens a door to simply being nationalist or racist. But the door to these things has always been open — just not ‘officially’. As world politics shows despite decades of being taboo, these ideas are still here, and growing lately in their potency.</p><p>On the other hand, if we claim to actually live up to our ideals of equality, those of us who want the West to reckon with its historical legacies of colonialism and violence are easily dismissed as hypocrites. We are better served by the combination of high ideals and compassion for both ourselves and others that ancient wisdom traditions advocate, but which is absent from our current public discourse. If we have an obsession with equality, this translates into a lack of compassion and an acrimony that is stiffling a discourse which has to include six billion people.</p><p>The global warming crisis is going to make the shallowness of our interest in equality abundantly clear. We have to admit that we have not shown equal concern for our children as we do for ourselves, much less for people in other countries. We westerners are going to continue to be asked if we will let in refugees from abroad, and our proclamations that we deeply believe in the equal worth of all human lives will be put to the test. So far, the results are not very heartening.</p><p>The most necessary step to prepare ourselves at the emotional level is to act more consistently with our high ideals of equality is to accept that all egoic people, which in practice means all people, have a tendency towards selfishness and group identity that means we care more about ourselves than others. Habits like drinking too much or shoplifting, or telling lies are always easier to work with when we are honest with ourselves about their existence. Proclamations of belief in equality do little to change our passion-driven habits, and trying to hold onto or enforce these ideals with an iron grip turns into resentment, or an absurd twisting of the truth in order to escape guilt and shame. We can constantly be conscious of and try to transform our tendency to love ourselves more than our neighbour, but this tendency will not easily go away in white males within the west, or among the west as a whole as it relates to the rest of the world.</p><p>This is because of ego and power. Having power (as we usually define it) means that you don’t have to be equal if you don’t want to be. Having an ego means you don’t want to be equal.</p><p>None of this means that we shouldn’t aspire to fairness, we should. What it means is that, as long as there is power and selfishness, there will not be equality. If we expect their to be equality when there is not then we get hatred. When there is hatred, there is friction lies and no-communication, and all of these things get in the way of meaningful action.</p><p>So for purely pragmatic reasons, we will need to find a way to be less reactive when ideals of equality are violated. If the environmental movement hatefully says we must treat all others with complete equality, it risks undermining its own credibility, because only saints really achieve this. We have to be careful not to produce paralysis from fearful inaction, but also hateful action, both deepen an ecological disaster which is tragically unequal in its consequences. The climate crisis may be so brutal in the choices that it presents to the privileged and well-armed West that norms of equality and universalism themselves will be challenged. If we end up replacing these ideals themselves with a return to tribalism, that will be the greatest tragedy — it is a real possibility that we are still not seriously imagining mostly because we just don’t want to.</p><p>As hinted above, I think that re-integrating what wisdom traditions such the major religions and indigenous traditions have to teach us about love is the best way of really understanding, or even <em>moving beyond</em> our current ideals of equality. Love operates in a much different way than moralistic judgements about equality, but one which is hard to intellectualise, which is why love has found itself out of place in our rationalistic world. It is, however, something that seems to create social change more effectively than does our current heavy moralism, as the work of the greatest peacemakers of the twentieth century showed.</p><p>Future blog posts will discuss this point in the context of Art / Earth / Tech’s new initiative for <a href="http://artearthtech.com/2019/11/11/the-contemplative-activism-gathering/">contemplative activism</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2bc9febeffc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Contemplative Activism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/series/contemplative-activism-a66e5056a72e?source=rss-2fdf91aa0d21------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a66e5056a72e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Life Itself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jan 2020 16:19:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-06T16:19:21.453Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Contemplative Activism Gathering</h3><h4>Liam Kavanagh</h4><p>Art / Earth / Tech is pleased to team with Naresh Giangrande, co-founder of the <a href="https://transitionnetwork.org/">Transition Town movement</a> to put together the first gathering of a new initiative on contemplative activism.</p><p>Here, Naresh, my co-organiser, briefly explains it as: <em>“When a disappointment happens in the environmental movement, we often hear:</em></p><blockquote><em>‘It’s alright, eventually consciousness is going to change’,… but, can we do something about that?”</em></blockquote><p>A longer version is that many have remarked that the environmental issue that we face is really a spiritual issue. We are out of touch with what is larger than us, as a species and with capacities for wisdom. Joanna Macy famously has remarked on our conviction that we are separate from nature blinding ourselves to our awful effects on it and on ourselves. Martin Heidegger, Iain McGilchrist, Thich Nhat Hanh, Charles Eisenstein and Gail Bradbrook and a host of others have made related statements.</p><p>It is by now clear that these ideas are not going to spread themselves. The famous criticisms are as apt as ever, and climate chaos is upon us making it clearer every day that it is not just polar bears, but humans, that are in danger.</p><p>Activism is what we do with dreams, ideas, and perspectives. What are we doing to promote the awareness that the environmental crisis is based in a spiritual confusion? Are we being the change we want to see — are we acting as though, at base, the environmental issue is spiritual? What would that look like?</p><p>It is in this spirit that we are holding <a href="https://ti.to/art-earth-tech/contemplative-activism-gathering"><strong>our first gathering</strong></a> at <a href="https://www.westlexham.org/">West Lexham</a> Norfolk, U.K on <strong>Dececmber 14th - 17th</strong>.</p><p>So why will this gathering make a difference? We are gathering a very diverse and unusual group of leaders in their field, like you! Our intended outcomes (which are only a starting place) are the following: The formation of a group who is able to hold the turbulent, transitional time we find ourselves in as gracefully and compassionately as possible, providing a model for others.</p><p>For all of us as contemplative beings, to deepen understanding of what it means to be involved in activism in these chaotic times. That activists have access to tools of transformation that will change the way they are in themselves and the way they work.</p><h4>-Join us-</h4><p>Saturday 14th - Tuesday 17th December at West Lexham in Norfolk. For enquiries, please email: liam@artearthtech.com</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Xn6Ok0S0tHRsY8oy.jpg" /><figcaption>Wake Up London meditates at XR London — credit Noah Walton</figcaption></figure><h3>The Case for Contemplative Activism: why, why now, and what are we offering?</h3><h4>Naresh Giangrande &amp; Liam Kavanagh</h4><p>We are proposing that contemplative awareness, skills and practices can inform our responses to our collective cultural process of deep and lasting change. These changes are now being rapidly forced upon us. We are having to confront as a society, collectively and individually, the end of our way of life due to the breakdown in both the natural systems that have ensured the unbroken continuation of life on earth, and the concurrent breakdown of human social political, and economic systems. Contemplatives have, over millennia, faced death, ending, and change in ways most people have not. These gatherings aims to define a new relationship between activism and contemplation, create a sangha for holding this relationship, and inform and deepen activism in social change actors such as Extinction Rebellion.</p><p>These gatherings will inject something new into change and changing making in our societies. We need something new because we face challenges and changes which we are unprepared for. We need another way of considering the present and future- a present in which we are facing the loss of just about everything, despite staggering levels technical achievements and knowledge.</p><p>Since the ‘new thing’ we are proposing; collective cultivation of the contemplative mindset as a resource to develop better responses, is actually something that we (as a society) have effectively previously abandoned and stigmatized, it is worth deeply considering where the culture that undertook this abandonment has gotten itself. We are facing the loss of most of our culture, most of our way of life, and the certainties that we have lived with for all of our lives- and for many- generations past. The certainty of the continuation of life, and in particular our culture’s way of life, will almost certainly be unavailable to us and our children and grandchildren in the not too distant future.</p><p>Of course life on earth has always faced change and impermanence, sometimes swift and catastrophic, sometimes slow and inexorable. Weather catastrophes, (volcanoes, hurricanes, etc.) can and have wiped out whole tribes, and whole ways of life very quickly. Civilisations have come and gone. But we recover from those as a species. There is change, but the general flow of life remains. However the change that we are in the midst of is poised to change everything forever. ‘Catastrophists have always existed’, is a common reply to such statements, but when have these catastrophists comprised almost the entirety of the body of experts that we as a society have put in the best position to understand our situation?</p><p>To put our motivating intention succinctly, we believe that social conditions are ripe for determined group experimentation with holding our current situation within contemplative awareness so as to accept where we are with enough depth and solidity to see how to respond. To contribute to this process we will gather a group that combines contemplative awareness and experience with environmental, social and economic expertise with the premise that <em>how</em> we undertake conversation is as important as <em>what</em> we talk about. <em>How</em> we will discuss responding to the unravelling? It will be in a devotedly contemplative manner — with the conviction that the results of this process, which we don’t pretend to know, will be sufficiently valuable to motivate change and further larger-scale development of this process.</p><h4>The Situation as it is</h4><p>The destabilising of our climate means we can’t count on the ‘modern’ agriculture that our complex, industrial society depends on. Just think for a minute about where your food comes from and what it takes to get it to us, particularly those in cities who are utterly dependent on the continuous shipment of food and most other ‘stuff of life’.</p><p>Food is essential, as is clean water and clean air. But all of these are being threatened. We do not usually think about the essentials of life, those of us in the wealthy societies on earth and particularly in the well off sectors of that society. We take these for granted. We also take law and order, endorsement (however half-hearted) of universal sanctity of human life, free movement of goods and economic stability for granted.</p><p>But they are not a given.</p><h4>Changes to The ‘Fundamentals’</h4><p>We and any future generations will face the loss of many givens, crucial things we take for granted and lots more. Our climate is now shifting and destabilising from the end of the last glacial period; the Younger Dryas where it naturally shifted to the Holocene, which we now live in. The Holocene dating from approximately 11,600 before present is an interglacial period where we have had a stable and beneficial climate that is suited to growing crops and where all the known civilisations have developed and thrived. Ask any farmer what she needs to grow the crops, and she will reply certainty, and abundant sun, rain, and good, rich soil. And these are now no longer certain. The range of natural fluctuations have altered and will alter more until we can no longer adapt and the staple crops we rely on will no longer be viable.</p><p>Why is this important? Because this level of stability is required to enable us to year after year produce the kind of agricultural surpluses required to feed the 8 billion (and growing) human beings on the planet, and for a small number of us to produce this food while most of us, 97%+, to do other things (at least in the industrial food model). This enables the phenomenal complexity of our way of life, and it, in turn, is enabled by the energy we use, unfortunately still mostly in the form of fossil fuels. We are undermining our stable climate by the activity of our industrial civilisation. We are forcing our climate patterns out of the Holocene into what some have called the Anthropocene. It is a new and more extreme climate. We are also facing sea level rises which will make many of the world’s largest cities at least partly uninhabitable, and will inundate much of the worlds most fertile land.</p><p>While climate change is often referenced, we barely mention biodiversity loss, not because it is less important, but because it is less easy to understand. This mirrors the tendency of even scientists to avoid discussing negative and complex climate effects. Things that are complicated are easier to ignore than things which can be understood simply. But the future is going to be complicated, and we need to learn to look at it solidly regardless of whether it is pleasurable or painful, or at least we should if we there to be a future for humanity.</p><p>We are facing loss. And death; death of not just ourselves, but the death of our way of life. We must be prepared to contemplate that our civilisation is already dead and the only thing that matters now is what comes next. It is natural to fight to do everything we can to keep what we have, at least for the fortunate ones who so clearly benefit from the current way of life. But, as in all scales of life re-organisation, after collapse the remaining resources, the resources released by collapse, can reorganise into new forms of living and working and new forms of life. But if we use all available resources to prolong what is already dead there may not be enough left to support a reorganised system. A new climate regime, should the current trajectory be maintained, may also be unable to support all but the simplest forms of life. Therefore, any energy spent on keeping this particular civilisation alive will be wasted, and will prolong the agony of earth based cultures and other sentient beings.</p><p>The realisation that our civilisation or our way of life civilisation is dying which is essentially one of the key messages of ‘<a href="http://lifeworth.com/deepadaptation.pdf">Deep Adaptation</a>’, then begs the question what to keep from this civilisation if anything? And how to keep it? This is where our proposal, contemplative activism, become very important. The process we are in is death. We all have faced death and loss in some form or other, friends die, parents and grandparents die. As we grow older what one of us has not had to face loss or the threat of loss? Loss of friends, loss of our jobs, our marriages, or relationships, loss of our faculties, loss of our looks and youth. Life is about death and loss. And where has this been examined most clearly? In religion, spirituality or whatever you want to call it.</p><p>Stephen Bachelor in <em>Alone With Others</em> describes this very clearly,</p><blockquote>What is life? How are the potentials of life to be actualised? What is the purpose and meaning of life? These are all questions that gradually formulate themselves in this unstructured region (the region of being as opposed to having and doing) which is slowly disclosing itself to us[as we live our lives].</blockquote><p>In any case we are impelled to find a concrete framework which a set of satisfying answers is provided. The various religions of the world are in fact systematic formulations of the answers to these questions.</p><p>We are now in a time of cultural death. And coming to terms with that loss. This is because we have built a civilisation using lies, fabrications, and misunderstandings of the nature of what and how an Industrial Growth Society works. What we take as technological mastery is often just the exploitation of the abundant energy available to us from fossil fuels. The phenomenal growth of our economic sphere has been aided by both the enslavement of Africans and genocide in the Americas. We think we can grow food and exploit other renewable resources endlessly, but we can’t and we will soon come to a point where we must give up our stubborn hope that technological fixes can mend this vast brokenness. We can only write this as members of the elite class in the elite culture, the culture that has exploited many others and exploited the earth. Our culture is very busy destroying, seemingly unknowingly, the very basis of wealth and life.</p><p>The world’s most influential contemplative tradition, Buddhism, can bring much to times of ending and renewal. No society has more to benefit from understanding the second ‘noble truth’ — that attachment creates suffering.</p><p>Industrial society has given us perfectly red tomatoes at all times of the year and the ability to use the phrase ‘on demand’ commonly and un-ironically. We get most attached to predictable pleasure, and so the end of predictable opulence will create great suffering. Thoughts that imply suffering are the source of cognitive dissonance, which distorts our conclusions making them disjoined from reality. A society that has incredible levels of regularity and predictable consumptive pleasure will be attached- and have incredibly distorted and dissonant thoughts regarding potential threats to that pleasure. Releasing attachment can create subtlety and sensitivity, enable creativity and create the space for adaptation. We do not know what lies beyond these movements but have faith that it will be truer that what we experience now.</p><p>There is also the praxis of Buddhism in meditation, mindfulness, and other forms of authentically being with yourself. And there are the Buddhist practices based on non attachment that allow us to find the cracks in our ego structures, enabling creativity and the ability to just ‘be with’ without substituting story and shallow and frail human ideas for actuality.</p><p>Contemplation involves becoming unattached from our expectations and also our stories — authentically being with life itself. Being with what is without turning to ‘stories’ makes it possible to meet our reality and take our next steps in awareness and as consciously as possible. It will be especially important for those who are called to be leaders during the undoubtably violent and chaotic death throes of an unblissfully ignorant civilisation. We will need to stand in the fire and hold very difficult people, situations, and events, which, if mishandled. will leave us worse off. And on the positive side, there will also be enormous opportunities for change and collective growth.</p><p>We think that the imagining of the new will take clarity and tapping into states of consciousness regularly and reliably which none but the most devoted contemplatives are currently capable of, certainly we (the authors) are not. The notion of the sangha is therefore important, as communities of practice that artfully cultivate a consciousness that enable clarity and imagining beyond anything that currently exists. Releasing attachment creates cultural and personal malleability, which will necessitate the leaving behind of what has been and cultivating new and unexpected cultural forms and processes.</p><p>We will also be indebted to Buddhist practices based on gratitude, meditations on the interconnectivity and flow of life, loving kindness, healing pain of self and other, healing shenpa, letting go of self concern, and taking on board the concern of the welfare of others to name a few.</p><h4>The role of story and imagination</h4><p>Even though we can be outside them, story and imagination are crucial to our existence. The story of who we are as conscious beings, aware of our situation includes awareness of death. It includes the question that comes out of that — ‘what happens after death, if anything?‘ All religions have an answer to this question. They offer belief structures and practices that enable us to hold the anxiety of our certain death in order to live. However our patterns of identification, our notions of who we are usually extend beyond our essential being, what is sometimes called our true self, and into our status, achievements and so on. At death or when facing loss of these things, we suffer, as these are things which we cannot take with us, and which we will have to at some point relinquish. The pharaoh’s tombs held cornucopias of objects, many of which undoubtedly held deep meaning for them which they fully intended to take with them into the ‘afterlife’. We know that these objects remained on earth. And this will also be the case for us. Everything apart from our essential nature or spirit, cannot go through the gateway of death if you believe in something of us living on after physical death. Or at least this is the only credible explanation for what remains after bodily death. Of course we have no way of knowing this is true. But at least it’s plausible.</p><p>While this seems to be a religious question however that couldn’t be further from the truth. As a society we make up stories about who we are and make meaning for our lives, our suffering, our work, and what it means to be a part of whatever culture we are in.</p><h4>The story of our civilisation: the myth of progress</h4><p>We are a technological civilisation and as such we rely on our technical prowess to solve our problems. The temptation is to frame every problem into a technical one for which a technical solution can be found. While there are undoubtedly many technical problems to be solved; improved battery life, growing food with less fertiliser or water inputs, or cheaper, more energy efficient homes and buildings. However, there are many problems that are not technical. At the core of many of our problems; over exploitation of resources, obsession with short term economic growth, endless growth of our desires and wish for stuff lies a ‘being’ question or questions, rather than a ‘doing’ question. These questions cannot be solved with technology.</p><p>Questions like: What’s life about? What is the path of happiness or well being? What is real wealth? or How we can live in harmony with all of the ecosystems we are interdependent on? These are all being questions and cannot be solved by technology. These questions lie in the spiritual and cultural space, and transcend questions of doing. They are the questions which we will need to come to terms with if we are to create a new regenerative culture.</p><h4>Where are we going?</h4><p>There are many stories of where we are going. Two dominant cultural stories we have are the myth of unending progress and growth, and the realisation that our civilisation will crash and burn in the near future.</p><p><a href="https://healthyhumanculture.wordpress.com/2019/05/04/four-stories-of-the-future/">The 4 stories of the future</a> are an interesting and important statement of where we might be going, representing possible futures.</p><p>These stories are about to be tested in the end times of a culture that is reaching the end of its possibilities. And the reality of where we are at and what needs to happen now lead one to the unenviable conclusion that we will be increasingly facing a world of violence and suffering on a massive scale. And not just in the places of the world that are currently violent and are suffering, but in the places which up until now have been safe and secure. In other words, the world that you and me live in.</p><h4>One New Story to Consider</h4><p>We desperately need a new story to replace the old. One story for participants of this gathering to hold ever so lightly may be that we need a leadership who are not attached to any stories. This is the way of the mystic. We need people to live with what is without needing to turn it into a story or an explanation, or a thing of any sort. It is from that place of no-thing-ness, that peaceful and culturally generative actions and ways to be in the world can emerge.</p><p>This leadership does not have to conflict with ‘horizontality’ but to be outside of it, because it would be outside of status and value. Leaders are needed, but not in the conventional sense as being seen asÂ above those they lead, but playing a different role; of inspiring through the sheer quality of their presence. This role of leadership requires others who will listen to contemplative leaders. Contemplative leaders would hold this almost unholdable awareness along with the other aspects of non-duality and guide others to at least establish themselves in this awareness even if they do not always live in it. This is of course the sort of leadership contemplatives have always provided, but it can only work in a community in which the power of contemplation acknowledged. But for this we need not just contemplatives willing to lead but technical and political experts willing to be led.</p><p>The reason we propose this kind of leadership, is that it is only realistic to hope, we believe, for a very small minority to spend their lives in a mystical, or non dual presence. The habit of holding on to stories will die hard. A regenerative story of peace and living in harmony with earth processes is a much, much better than a story of technological progress and ruthless, and often consciously hidden exploitation. This is what we think. But of course one never knows. What we are saying is that it is unrealistic, we feel, for an entire culture to live entirely without a cultural story. Building a better story is therefore essential. However, if for those who it is possible, holding no stories will be an essential form of leadership and be most culturally generative.</p><p>There has been much talk over many years from people with a spiritual perspective on life that what we need is a ‘shift in consciousness’. The originator of Active Hope, Joanna Macy lists this as one of the three things that needs to happen to make a just and ecologically viable Transition. society-wide shift now seems vanishingly unlikely in the time scale we have to adapt and mitigate climate chaos and prevent species extinction. This kind of shift would probably require generations and a stable enough environment, but with enough tension with the current operating system to ensure evolution. None of these is available.</p><p>So a shift is possible, but it may be unwise to be attached to, or even hold the intention of, a total shift. Enough of a shift might allow us to grab onto a story with enough meaningful difference to the current cultural story and enough positive and negative dos and don’t to enable a culture to emerge that is in enough harmony with earth systems to allow life to continue amidst the chaos of the death of the existing paradigm and the birth of the new. And for this we need a very different kind of leadership. To harken back to tradition — we need a leadership that helps to craft a raft to cross to another shore. There are Buddhist teachings, expressed in dualisms, often simple ones like ‘nowhere to go, nothing to do’ that can help guide us.</p><p>Who or what will this leader be? Thich Nhat Hanh has said, the next enlightened being might be a Sangha. He said this with awareness that enlightened individuals were not going to develop within the culture of having and doing so a Sangha is necessary. A Sangha could become an enlightened subculture, or an enlightened enough of a subculture to make a real difference. We know of no greater aid to contemplative concentration than awareness of the environmental situation that we face, the fatal symptoms of our culture’s ill-being, its near total devotion to having and doing. We believe a contemplative sangha built around this fertile awareness may do great things for the art of presence in end times, it can help to build a raft to cross to another shore.</p><p>Those who can hold this form of leadership will often go unheralded and unrecognised just because the immensity of what is possible from a place of non attachment and authentically being with what is so far outside most people’s experience that they might as well be an alien. That is perfect, though, because recognition is the friend of ego, and ego is the enemy of awareness.</p><h4>Another Story to Consider</h4><p>What can we offer a society that is about to lose the way of life it knows? The simple fact is that people who have grown up in this culture, but turned towards the inner life know most deeply that none of the consumption is necessary and life itself is enough. They can say this with authenticity. As mentioned, deep awareness of this is alien, but some awareness of this is commonplace, even unavoidable.</p><p>Living life means some contact with simple pleasure, with the value of ‘life itself.‘ For example, visitors to the US, the epitome of consumerist culture, often are shocked if they are invited to Thanksgiving, one holiday where consumerism is still somewhat resisted. On that day even the most unashamed consumerists show the ability to at least touch gratitude even for a short while, even imperfectly, often without reflecting on the brutal history of their riches, or the story of what is at their table. Eating with friends, relaxing, and talking in a spirit of gratitude for having enough is still available if we could come anywhere near to realising how little enough really is. That is contemplative work, and so contemplative are best suited to helping to build a raft to cross to this shore.</p><p>The reality is that we could be far happier in the next decade, even while cutting our GDP drastically, which is what it will take to stop the irreparable damage to our home, the earth. The reality is also that on cultural level, a realistic calculation would probably show that we are too blind to see this, but contemplation is not about calculation, and any movement towards this is our best response to the current situation.</p><p>One of the key aspects of giving up or relinquishing, in the <a href="http://lifeworth.com/deepadaptation.pdf">Deep Adaptation frame proposed by Jim Bendell,</a> will be relinquishing deeply held beliefs and thoughts about who we are personally and as a culture. This inner letting go will enable outer relinquishment. This is because we are letting go of desires, beliefs and ideas about ourselves and our work that are simply not useful, and not important. If this is aligned to a sangha, a kind of vortex of change might be possible. One of us (Naresh) has seen this sort of thing occasionally manifest in Transition towns, although not reliably.</p><p>There is much to take on in these times, and much that will need to happen to allow a just and relatively less violent and traumatic end time for ourselves, our communities and our world. The retreat we are proposing will be a way to enable sanghas of personal change leading to the enabling of leadership in these times.</p><p>We cannot know the outcomes, much of what we are proposing and will propose has not been done before; and it never could have been done, because we are now facing historically unique times and unique circumstances. Of course every effort has been and will be made to learn from what does and has worked. We will be indebted to the millennia old practices and framing of the painful and anxiety ridden nature of our lives and our societies which can lead to transformation and the end of suffering.</p><p>We the holders of this gathering lay no claim to enlightenment, specialness, or mastery of ourselves and our lives. We are in the shit the same as anyone else. We hope that our combined practices, knowledge and experience will enable us to create the container to hold the energetic qualities that will allow something regenerative, solid, and durable to emerge. We obviously cannot give any guarantees. Active hope and possibility are however tangible and with us. We offer this gathering in utter humility and with a prayer for healing and peace for all beings.</p><h3>Contemplative Activism Primer: the pre-gathering read</h3><h4>Naresh Giangrande</h4><p>In our upcoming retreat we will explore how contemplative awareness, skills and practices can inform our responses to our collective cultural process of deep and lasting change.</p><p>I set out some initial ideas in a paper with Liam <a href="http://artearthtech.com/2019/11/29/the-case-for-contemplative-activism-why-why-now-and-what-are-we-offering/"><em>Contemplative Activism What it is and Why It’s Important</em></a>. Here I am exploring in more depth some of the ideas in that paper in an evolving enquiry into Contemplative Activism.</p><p>There are some ways in which contemplatives have engaged with the world that can inform how we live in difficult times. These ways might take the form of new cultural meta perspectives, which might then become the new common sense. For example, the ability to be with suffering, and the ability to embrace our suffering as a part of life rather than something that we feel we must avoid or prevent. It might take the form of realising that it is often our resistance to our suffering that is so painful, and that embracing suffering is the first step toward transforming that suffering into something else.</p><p>This is a key insight from contemplative traditions, such as Buddhism, that provides a real reason for suffering, a pathway out of suffering, and makes the possibility of a transcendent realignment of the self as a result of sitting with and allowing that suffering to be. Imagine a society where this was a common and accepted practice. Imagine collective rituals of embracing suffering. Imagine the possibility for collective action springing out of that kind of ritual space.</p><p>Contemplative Activism is really both a plea for a different way of thinking about and acting on our human predicament (which we are naming the climate and ecological emergency) , and is also a wish for a fundamental realignment with contemplative traditions in the context of our secular societies. This is of course written from a Western European perspective. As we see later, the context in which our response to the climate and ecological emergency we find ourselves in cannot be separated from the temporal place where we live.</p><p>Something is clearly missing from the way in which we frame, speak about, and act in all areas of collective life, but in particular in the emergency we are in. And a large bit of that missing piece can be found in the contemplative traditions; in our history of looking deeply into human experience, and experienced the full range of humanness. It is precisely the contemplative experiences that are missing from our collective discourse. This creates a serious hole where those experiences can and must inform our decision making and action.</p><p>An analogy might be <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_theory_(Ken_Wilber)">Ken Wilber’s four quadrant integral model</a>. Where for many there is a blind spot. The inner aspects of life are easily forgotten about, and as a result there is a lack of ability to discuss and frame let alone solve societal, or individual problems. An integral piece of the system is missing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/915/1*VHnLCb1HcHvd_HlAxkd_tQ.png" /></figure><p>The same is true of the missing contemplative piece, or, as it has been termed, a ‘God shaped hole’ in our civilisation. In a civilisation run by our collective personality or ego structures, we find ourselves abandoned (although it is us who have done the abandoning) and soulless. We are left with an extrinsically driven culture and set of values. As we approach the endgame of our collective ability to provide more, and meet human wants and needs with a purely material set of answers, there appears to be no way out of the collective cul de sac we find ourselves in other than positing, in all seriousness, colonising other planets as a solution.</p><p>Those of us taking part in the weekend are curious about what this missing piece of human existence means for the culture we are living in. We are equally curious about how the response to our climate and ecological emergency is affected by a lack of contemplative awareness.</p><p>Surely the ultimate expression of freedom is the freedom to be who we are and express and live as fully human lives as possible. In a culture that repeatedly attempts to narrowly define and thereby confine the human spirit in so many ways, anything but the fullest expression of our humanity is an unwelcome and possibly fatal civilisational flaw. We must not let be to be continued to be so narrowly defined. We must allow both the seen and the unseen, the mundane, the profane, and the transcendental to coexist and be in our hearts, minds, and awareness. Reducing ourselves to corporate sized entities to fit within the corporate consumerist, neoliberal evisceration of our collective identity is leading us to an apocalyptic end game. It is not just a question of freedom but ultimately of survival. What would a transcendental, contemplatively informed view of our humanity look like? I hope we can explore this in our gathering.</p><p>Of course one of the problems we face is that most of us do not see let alone practice the cultivation of the transcendental in our lives. What might some of these practices be? What are the most important one? If we developed a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Pattern_Language">pattern language</a> or transcendental practices for everyday life what might that be?</p><p>It is also clear that there are many individual ways to hold and be with ourselves that the contemplative life enables. One such way is nothing more than being with ‘what is’, rather than seeking to find ways to avoid or hide from ‘what is’. This being with rather than hiding from or avoiding is almost certainly one of the first steps in any contemplative life. It is probably the fundamental way as from this first step, a whole life’s worth of insights and competencies arise. It is the gateway to the mystery which we are both afraid of and so attracted to. Is this the case in all contemplative traditions, explicitly, or implicitly? Again I hope we can explore this.</p><h4>What does it mean: Holding our current situation within contemplative awareness so as to accept where we are with enough depth and solidity to see how to respond?</h4><p>As Thich Nhat Hanh writes in the opening lines of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Being-Peace-Thich-Nhat-Hanh/dp/188837540X"><em>Being Peace</em></a>,</p><blockquote>Life is filled with suffering, but it is also filled with many wonders, like the blue sky, the sunshine, and the eyes of a baby, life is both dreadful and wonderful. To practice meditation is to be in touch with both aspects.</blockquote><p>It is being able to hold without having to resolve contradictions and paradoxes.</p><p>It is being able to look at sets of beliefs for instance and find ways through them using for instance Byron Katie’s 4 questions:</p><ol><li>Is it true?</li><li>Can you absolutely know that it’s true?</li><li>How do you react when you believe that thought?</li><li>Who would you be without the thought?</li></ol><p>Contemplatives and spiritual teachers have come to the conclusion that it is not our objective situation that makes it hard to know where to go or how to act, but our beliefs around that situation or our thoughts and beliefs that limit our ability to respond.</p><p>In The Will to Meaning, Victor Frankl notes that logotherapy aims to unlock the will to meaning in life. That the lack of meaning in life often leads people to respond by adopting hedonistic pursuits, consumerism, power, hatred, boredom, compulsions or obsessions. And that meaning was found through deeds, the experience of values through some kind of medium (beauty through art, love through a relationship, etc.) or suffering.</p><p>Dr. Susanne C. Moser concludes,</p><blockquote>…the leaders of the future will face not just new, more difficult, and more pervasive environmental challenges than past and present leaders do, but will need to be adept in a range of psychological, social, and political skills to navigate the inevitable human crises that will precede, trigger, and follow environmental ones. Future leaders will need to be not just experts in climate change, or a particular environmental field, but be capable of holding that which is happening to and in our world. They will need to mentor, guide, and assist people in processing enormous losses, human distress, constant crises, and the seemingly endless need to remain engaged in the task of maintaining, restoring, and rebuilding — despite all setbacks — a viable planet, the only place the human species can call its home.</blockquote><p>This type of leadership which involves mentoring and holding people in their emotional turmoil is one which will come to the fore as it will be the most viable way to create the transformational civilisation that can allow for large scale collective intelligence to emerge from a ground of being firmly rooted in our social, political, and most importantly our ecological reality.</p><p>So contemplative awareness is about holding lightly ‘what is’ and questioning what is really true.</p><p>It is about developing this skill and making it a part of our life. It is also the ability to remain in that holding or questioning even when confronted with difficult or charged situations.</p><p>And then once we are able to hold ‘what is’ with enough grace and ease, there are clearly other steps which flow from this awareness. What are they and how can we define them?</p><h4>Preparing for the death of our way of life our civilisation:</h4><h4>How to go about doing this at a social scale?</h4><p>The first step in this process of coming to terms with the death of our civilisation might be to come to terms with the loss we personally feel, our personal experiences. If we can’t put our oxygen mask on first, we can’t help others with theirs.</p><p>In our Deep Dive into Deep Adaptation, it became clear that one of the first steps was to accept and acknowledge our privilege. For myself, I have lived in an enormously privileged position in life and in the society I live in. This helps me to local myself in a civilisational process. My experience in one of many and this helps me to be aware of the overall process, and not mistake my experience for the process. It helps me to accept the heterogeneity of this process of change. After all, we daily have access to information of how collapse is happening in different parts of the world. We know that many people are experiencing an uneven end to their societies ability to provide the basic necessities of life, let alone the bells and whistles. It is important to maintain that perspective</p><p>The main message of the Transition movement was that deep changes were needed, almost unthinkable changes, like a completely different economic system, and big, big personal lifestyle changes. And then, if we created an orderly energy descent (in ‘Western lifestyles’) we just might be able to retain some of our Western lifestyle. What was said, but unspoken, was that those of us living Western middle class lifestyles might, if we were lucky, retain at least some of the privileges we enjoy. This will be a controversial assessment to many, please forgive me. But, many have wondered why Transition was a middle class movement. At any rate this invitation was refused.</p><p>Now XR have come along with a much more unappealing proposition; completely change everything about our lives, very rapidly and unless we do that we face not just the end of our civilisation, but possible extinction. XR are saying this because this is what the science demands is saying. It may be politically difficult if not impossible, but as XR continually says we must act not on political possibility but physical reality. Science is all we have to rely on; it is the closest thing we have to collective truth. And we as yet have no evidence that this message is getting through to the degree and to create the scale of change needed. It may be, but we don’t know yet.</p><p>Are we not able to imagine a voluntary end to the capitalist system?</p><blockquote>…it is easier to imagine an end to the world than an end to capitalism,</blockquote><blockquote>- attributed to both Fredric Jameson and Slavoj Zizek.</blockquote><p>We in the Western world cannot come to terms with or see that giving up our privilege and power is necessary. We cannot imagine that at a mass scale. I am imagining that others not so privileged folks find imagining the end of the current system a lot easier, and the less privilege the easier it gets. The closer to the extractive ‘coal face’ of the industrial growth society, the easier it is.</p><p>But imagine it we must and at a mass scale. Our civilisation is dead. <a href="https://medium.com/@oliverwaters_76079/the-strange-necessity-of-infinite-economic-growth-ebc2e505cdf1">There are those who don’t agree of course</a>. But if we take this view, then there is much work to be done that contemplatives can help us with. As we said in our paper, Stephen Bachelor in <em>Alone With Others</em>describes this very clearly:</p><blockquote>What is life? How are the potentials of life to be actualised? What is the purpose and meaning of life? These are all questions that gradually formulate themselves in this unstructured region (the region of being as opposed to having and doing) which is slowly disclosing itself to us (as we live our lives)… In any case we are compelled to find a concrete framework where a set of satisfying answers is provided. The various religions of the world are in fact systematic formulations of the answers to these questions.</blockquote><p>Religions have traditionally provided us with answers to the fundamental and mysterious questions that frame our lives (and which most of us spend very little time contemplating or exploring). Life where we come from and after death, where we go to. And then how to live the bit in between.</p><p>So the first step it seems is to come to terms with death; our own and that of our civilisation. It is the practice of radical non attachment -giving up and letting go. It is the release of everything we can possibly let go of. Typically that conscious relinquishment was a preparation or a step in a phase of a journey to enlightenment. The giving up of everything that is not the true self or the self. All that which masquerades as the self but is not might be termed the personality structures, or the small self. These are pieces of ‘false self’ or ego structures which are nothing more than beliefs and thought constructions which are not us. The gaze of the larger or real self reveals them to be in fact non existent or not real (although in the paradox of humanness, in so far as we act as if they are real, they are. When in fact they are not). So in the process of relinquishment of the false self or our personality structures, which in the process of us identifying them we see them as the apparent self (unreal), we lose nothing and gain everything.</p><blockquote>For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for My sake will find it. —</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://biblehub.com/matthew/16-25.htm">Matthew 16:25</a> attributed to Jesus of Nazareth.</blockquote><p>If we take this as one aspect of a personal practice in a journey towards self realisation or attainment of oneness, how can we frame relinquishment in societal wide terms?</p><p>There has been a narrative in Transition towns that we can make, if we put our minds, hearts and souls to it, something infinitely better than what we have now for most people (except perhaps the 1%). If we invest all the creativity, skill and resources to making something beneficial and imaginative that we put into the fossil fuel economy, what might that look like? If we create an economic system for instance that is aligned around providing fulfilment, or happiness, or well being rather than profit maximisation, then we can do lots better. The framework of Manford Max-Neef is a compelling proposition that might go some way towards creating that kind of society. There is also Kate Raworth’s Donut economics, and the solidarity economy. There are many possibilities for change and reform which do not demand relinquishment, except for the clearly dysfunctional current system.</p><p>But what if we are going to have to relinquish our way of life, which unless we radically and swiftly change our way of life, which in itself will be relinquishment, we will lose. We will lose it one way or another. The only difference is that by voluntarily relinquishing our way of life we have the possibility of holding onto some vestige of civilisation of some sort. If we do not there is no hope that our social, economic, and political systems can cope with the scale of change and even the most technologically optimistic cannot begin to imagine the invention and rapid deployment of what we would need to continue on as life gets harder and harder for more and more, and with a steadily decreasing resource base to meet those needs. Yet this scale of change remains elusive.</p><p>What can contemplatives tell us at a civilisational scale of living about relinquishment? There are many stories of Native Americans who successfully enabled their culture to die and to be reborn in a new form. The process of cultural death and resurrection could hold many important insights for today’s changes, and process of loss and rebirth. I hope we can explore this further.</p><p>Loss of everything then begs the question: what to keep from this civilisation if anything? And how to keep it?</p><p>The earlier discussion on loss of personality and embrace of the true self or the self contains some important insights at a spiritual level. There is of course the material level which contemplatives might have much less to say. But on a spiritual level if we take the way of contemplatives as that we can only give away the personality and what remains cannot be taken from us. This is one of the understandings of Victor Frankl, as of course many others. We cannot lose our true self. An apparent loss is not loss. We lose what our personality structures, or the apparent reality that we construct from those structures.</p><p>When looked at from this way there almost certainly will be loss of technology and many other outer structures or social and technological structures and abilities, but what is essentially human cannot be lost. This seems to get us into the realms of absolute and relative truth. Or in Buddhist terms Satya, a genuine truth or reality and a provisional or conventional truth which describes (most of) our everyday reality. Or in Christian terms the revelation of truth which prophets are privy to.</p><p>There is a long debate amongst collapsologists over this question of what if anything we want to keep from our technology. There is of course a range of opinions from Richard Heinberg’s ‘lifeboat’ scenario where lifeboats encompassing the greatest amount of knowledge ranging from our understanding of what it means to be human, ontology and various epistemologies, to the technical knowledge embedded in our devices like computers and mobile phones which if lost could take decades if not millennia to recover. And then at the other end is a view often expressed by people like Derrick Jensen that our civilisation incorporates so much violence that it casts doubt that anything is of use at all. While I have some sympathy for Jensen’s views, if faced with a collapsing technosphere I can’t help but think a few solar panels and small scale grid might make life immeasurably better than not in my community.</p><p>What has been missing is the input of mystics into this space. What is the relationship of relative to absolute truth? What can we learn from this exploration? Or are they so far apart in terms of the areas of life they are describing that they don’t touch? It is reminiscent (or maybe it is the exact same debate?) of the debates about in the face of scientific knowledge whether God is dead.</p><h4>A brief exploration of contemplative practices and their relevance to Activism</h4><h4>Buddhism</h4><p>Meditation, mindfulness, and other forms of authentically being with yourself.</p><p>This almost goes without saying. The demands of being an activist make authentic being with yourself essential. This is because:</p><ul><li>Being an activist is demanding particularly emotionally. Being able to be with rather than avoid or fix uncomfortable emotions makes activism much more powerful. What we try to avoid or fix within ourselves, will also be our approach to outward problems or situations. Authentic action is more likely by being with rather than avoiding or fixing.</li><li>Burnout is often a problem. Under resourced and facing overwhelming problems day after day is not easy to be with. Mindfulness makes this easier or more possible.</li><li>Meditators are much more able to be in difficult group situations and develop the internal distance that is necessary to find ways to act with others.</li></ul><h4>Non attachment</h4><p>And there are the Buddhist practices based on non attachment that allow us to find the cracks in our ego structures, enabling creativity and the ability to just ‘be with’ without substituting story and shallow and frail human ideas for actuality. Releasing attachment can create subtlety and sensitivity, enable creativity and create the space for adaptation.</p><p>What has become clear to me as an activist is that letting go of all attachment to a specific outcome is essential to our current predicament. Letting go of what ultimately does not serve us is as important as letting go of specific outcomes once we have gone through the gateway of loss and change. We cannot know the pathways of change, how they will play out, the time sales and variations of ‘two steps forward and one back.’ We may need to take what appear to be detours. It is also clear to me that what ever comes next out of the metamorphosis will almost certainly be nothing we can have envisioned. We have taught visioning processes as part of the Transition model and process, and I wonder sometimes whether this is actually useful. We can vision a world of more silence, without cars or at least internal combustion engines, and more in tune with nature. However beyond this, what that looks like, what regenerative practices look like are only now being explored, and we have no idea of the scale of destruction we might have to be repairing, only that it will likely be high and perhaps insurmountable.</p><p>One of the key aspects of giving up or relinquishing, in the <a href="http://lifeworth.com/deepadaptation.pdf">Deep Adaptation frame proposed by Jim Bendell,</a> will be relinquishing deeply held beliefs and thoughts about who we are personally and as a culture. This inner letting go will enable outer relinquishment. This is because we are letting go of desires, beliefs and ideas about ourselves and our work that are simply not useful, and not important.</p><p>We do not know all that lies beyond these movements of letting go but, maybe need to have faith that it will be truer and more enlivening than how we are living now.</p><h4>Stories</h4><p>Being with ‘what is’ without turning to ‘stories’ makes it possible to meet our reality and take our next steps with awareness and as consciously as possible. Contemplation involves becoming unattached from our expectations and also our stories — authentically being with life itself. In fact it is essential.</p><p>It seems that all human societies rely on stories, fables, religious texts, myths, heroes, and legends to tell themselves who they are, what they stand for; the whys and hows of life. What’s life about? What is the path of happiness or well being? What is real wealth? How we can live in harmony with all of the ecosystems we are interdependent on? These are some of the questions that demand answers or at least stories that enable us to develop some beliefs that pass for answers.</p><p>Some think that human life becomes untenable without a story that explains pain and suffering, and birth (where do we come from) and death (where do we go to?), and what are the non material aspects of humanness like consciousness emotions and thoughts?</p><p>We can certainly ‘clean up’ the story and tell ourselves that we are one with earth and all living and non living entities. The reinterpretation of Genesis is often translated notion of dominion into stewardship and working with is more helpful than an understanding based on a Cartesian notion of linearity and control.</p><p>However, living without a story might be even more powerful.</p><blockquote>It’s not life that causes suffering, it’s our story about life — our interpretation — that causes so much distress. When we practice interrupting the story we’re telling ourselves, we can find a new freedom and flexibility in the face of uncertainty and change.</blockquote><blockquote>— Pema Chodron</blockquote><p>This is true on an individual level, but how might this work on a society scale level? Can we collectively free ourselves of the stories we tell ourselves? The stories we tell ourselves individually are generated by trauma, past experience, and the conclusions we have drawn from living. Many of these stories are based on childhood and other incomplete or outdated life history, and are embedded in our feelings of anxiety and fears. Hence we remain clouded in half truths that emerged often in our tender years, when we need protection and were able to develop only limited and provisional life stories, modes or being, and limited awareness. As such growing up, and the process of individuation means updating these complexes and ideas about who we are and how the world works to something with more freedom and allowing more possibility.</p><p>However the stories of our culture are something different. They interact with our personal stories but perform a different function. They are there to align us in collective action. Without these beliefs generated by the stories we tell ourselves about who we are we cannot act collectively. For instance unless we all agree that something printed on paper, or plastic with all sorts of magical symbols and holograms can be exchanged for a cup of tea and cake our money system does not work. And the economic story goes far, far beyond that into the reals of the myth of progress and makes it possible for us to operate <a href="https://www.ecoideaman.com/what-is-technosphere/">the technosphere</a> because those working in it need to have a story to make it possible to go to work in the morning because they are provided with a why along with the need to make money to live.</p><p>Exploring what it means to live without collective stories might well be an interesting and important way to create a group of people able to engage with and be with deep change of a kind we are unfamiliar with and beyond current imagining.</p><h4>Other practices</h4><p>Buddhist practices based on gratitude, meditations on the interconnectivity and flow of life, loving kindness, healing pain of self and other, healing shenpa, letting go of self concern, and taking on board the concern of the welfare of others to name a few.</p><h4>Contemplative leadership</h4><p>Contemplative leaders would hold this almost unholdable awareness of the nature of reality, life without stories, and the nature and scope of the climate and ecological emergency, along with the other aspects of non-duality and guide others to at least establish themselves in this awareness even if they do not always live in it. This is of course the sort of leadership contemplatives have always provided, but it can only work in a community in which the power of contemplation is acknowledged. But for this we need not just contemplatives willing to lead but technical and political experts willing to be led.</p><h4>Shift in consciousness</h4><blockquote>Nowhere to go, nothing to do</blockquote><p>This simple sentence crops up every once in a while in Plum Village. It encapsulates the awareness that there is a doing culture that demands action and a sense of there always being somewhere to go and something to do. It calls us into our essential self, and makes the awareness that this is actually the most important relationship we have with ourselves.</p><p>I hope we might have time to discuss what this shift in consciousness might mean, and how it might come about.</p><p>These are only a few ideas about what we might want to explore in our time together. It might not. These ideas are only offered as a range of possibilities that might or might not be useful in attempting to frame and inform our discussions. It is a starting point. We don’t really know where we are going or where we want to get to. I am purposely writing this primer in order to explore what contemplative activism might mean and how it can be useful. I am keen not to narrow our enquiry but to enable us to keep the enquiry open and alive.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a66e5056a72e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>