<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Lizbeth Varieswildly on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Lizbeth Varieswildly on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lizbethvarieswildly?source=rss-557ecc2fb15c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 02:04:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lizbethvarieswildly/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I’m sure no one will read this, as TMI, but I’m going to tell you a story.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lizbethvarieswildly/im-sure-no-one-will-read-this-as-tmi-but-i-m-going-to-tell-you-a-story-923bb164e6c2?source=rss-557ecc2fb15c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/923bb164e6c2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lizbeth Varieswildly]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Sep 2020 13:22:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-15T13:22:10.602Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m sure no one will read this, as TMI, but I’m going to tell you a story. It’s personal. And now, in retrospect of current pandemic, it’s important. It’s why I’ve been so anal about masking and serious risk management. Lots of others share similar stories of trigger events.</p><p>I feel if I can share what happened to me, maybe there is a teeny chance someone will read to the end and save their ass, especially if they are feeling a bit tired or laissez faire about pandemic. Please do NOT let Covid 🦠 fatigueget to you. Stay vigilant.</p><p>In 2006 right after my mother was killed, 4 months after, I was completely overwhelmed, brain not functioning, grieving hard, having incredible vivid and violent flashbacks and terrible dread/anxiety. Plus I was working 12 hours per day in my own Investment Management practice I had spent 18 gruelling tough months building from scratch to success. I had left my clinical pathology position with further 18 months of cramming brutal post grad / licensing study to become a reg. Investment Advisor/ Pension. Manager/ Ethical Stockbroker etc.</p><p>My mother( was killed) my own investment practice secretary 😢Chip( ex Vietnam vet with PTSD shot himself in head the following weekend on a logging road) , my sisters recent ex boyfriend( age 23, medical student , also shot himself in head💔😢) all died brutally the same horrific week. My step sister also gave birth to a baby as well who suffered non stop respiratory arrest in NICU. That week.</p><p>Frozen with grief, I couldn’t mentally function nor manage my multimillion dollar practice alone while in absolute shock. I was frozen at my screen and suddenly couldn’t open mail, or read emails. Crying non stop. I was flattened and terrified. It felt like my brain cells were popping. I was given 3 days off from firm to arrange just my mother’s funeral. Of 600 people.🤯💔plus coroner, police, forensics, family, estate etc. Plus the grief of Chips girlfriend who had reported him missing, my poor sister…plus my kids at home..partner…too much. Unbearable.</p><p>So on a whim, I packed off my beautiful corner office downtown Victoria, I worked my ass off to get, grabbed all my client files and gave everything to another broker and quit. I was too stressed to even comprehend taking sick leave, mental health i never really. struggled with before out of the norm, I didn’t know how to even put it into words. I just couldn’t function , period. So up and quit.</p><p>I booked a flight to Bangkok same day and informed my partner I was going to a Buddhist type yoga retreat the next day for a month to sort my head.</p><p>He looked after the kids, bless him 💓</p><p>Anyhow, at the time, 2006, in my 30’s, super physically fit, vegan, raw vegan at times, 48 kg, hadn’t had even a cold in 2 years, which was incredible for me. Super bloody healthy.</p><p>I got my flight first to Hong Kong ,and I was thrilled to have a window row alone to stretch out and sleep on the 13 hour flight. This was 3 years after SARS was reported over. However flights to Hong Kong usually did temperature checks, and offered masks. Not this flight.</p><p>An older man from China got on flight and was visibly very sick. He was coughing badly, sputtering, sneezing, sweating. No mask. I complained to flight attendant that it’s only been 3 years since SARS, why didn’t they screen an unwell passenger like before? Or at least give him a mask?</p><p>Anyhow I was nervous about that flight, as I went through SARS hell in 2002/3 for a few months working at the hospital stuck in full PPE terrified of getting it.It played on my mind a few years later as I was sure it didn’t just vanish overnight. Boom. It’s over. This was just before FB and social media really started. 2006.</p><p>Three days later in Thailand I was getting a cold. I thought bad jet lag. Then it morphed into a horrible respiratory flu. I was at a Detox,Yoga Juice fasting retreat so I thought drinking juices, fasting, steam saunas, ocean swimming, broths would kill virus. Wrong. I wanted to ride it out as I convinced myself a virus will takes its course and unless I’m spitting green , I don’t need a doctor or antibiotics unless for secondary infection. Wrong. I was trying holistic measures. I got a bit better for a week or so. I flew home, and it body slammed me again. This time it was in the lungs. I couldn’t breathe. I felt like an elephant was on my chest with a pillow on my face suffocating me. I couldn’t take a breath. A deep breath. It was terrifying. It still scares me badly to think about it.</p><p>But I was diagnosed with panic disorder,PTSD. and panic attacks. 🤯😳truth, but not the real whole picture. Then given heavy drugs for that. Well, that made it ,breathing, 10x worse. Panic attacks don’t last 24 hours, they are transient. I really wasn’t able to breathe. My breathing got so bad I laid awake for 10 days on the sofa terrified to sleep counting my breaths, worried if eyes closed, I’d die. Anyhow, my oxygen kept dropping and I ended up in A&amp;E with a heart rate near 200, unable to breathe, and numbness down my arms and face. I thought I was having a stroke. My right face froze, and my mouth was not working on one side. I was having a reaction that was perplexing doctors. They gave me blood pressure meds, prednisone, and more anxiety medication.</p><p>A few days later my oxygen dropped to 82% my peak flow at 170</p><p>( 400 normal) and I was nearing respiratory arrest. I was admitted again to hospital and given IV steroids, oxygen, inhaled ventolin…. My lungs were cloudy. But they also pushed it was anxiety related due to grief. Sure, truth in that, but they genuinely missed the mark. This was about 12 weeks of extreme lung issues and inability to take a breath without feeling like I was 100% suffocating. This is torture.</p><p>After the steroids and more anxiety meds, I lost normal vision. I saw three of everything. I couldn’t walk across a room anymore without severe breathlessness and crushing suffocating chest tightness that only lifted if I was really sedated, but I woke with it. I had an O2 machine, and nebuliser come home with me.</p><p>Anyhow, long story short, I got a bad virus when I was still grieving, and run down. it was an unusual infection in my lungs stumping doctors, I had bronchoscopy, ct scan and there was a strange lung abnormality cavitation/ vessel problems may have needed sudden surgery. Anyhow, the infection raged before they got lung aspiration cultures back and had already hit my sinuses, then my brain . I started getting encephalitis and had emergency surgery on my sinuses to drain, cut out bacteria damaged tissue and remove polyps. My lungs improved after sinus surgery. But I was on such heavy medications by then I was a zombie of horrible side effects. Vision loss, hearing problems, no smell,stomach pain, searing headaches, sudden big weight gain from huge steroid doses,and now anti depressants to control anxiety from not being able to breathe and horrible vivid flashbacks.</p><p>Anyhow, that was 2006/7. I didn’t get a semblance of real recovery until 2017. I had Chronic Fatigue and post viral syndrome very badly. Plus other health issues hit, like old injuries deteriorating leaving me in severe pain, immobile at times, then autoimmune disease attacked my joints and tendons etc, I had clot risks too. Steroid damage. 7 more surgeries. It was a total nightmare. But by 2018, I was seeing a bit of light. 11 years later. 😳😳😳But I didn’t recognise my body anymore. It was traumatising to lose control like that, esp as an orthorexic health freak.</p><p>This decade of severe illness, with if lucky, 4 weeks per year of a bit of reprieve, totally demolished my career. I returned to work as Private Banker and W. Canada manager for new firm in late 2007 still super sick,but. pushing hard for wellness.</p><p>But, still, in late 2007–2009 was having scary mini strokes non stop. Small vessels were playing up from viral damage. I was completely off work for 2 years after that and I was super ill. It’s been a roller coaster since of self employment, little income, tiny disability pension, and loads of extreme stress/ illness. My body paid very dearly, so did my income, relationship, security. I lost my house, 2 investment properties,and cashed in my only retirement fund to live on. By my late 30’s. I left my partner, moved back to the U.K. eventually,lost my retirement. Fun. Nothing left, flat broke, still ill. Body, gone.</p><p>I can tell you , without a shadow of a doubt, if you got very ill, and there are gaps in your CV, and you hit 40, especially as a woman, a divorced single parent, you won’t get hired, anywhere. Not as a post grad licenced professional on your normal level. Not even below your level. Not even with stunning references like I had.</p><p>I’m not joking, they see risk, high level qualifications , and refuse. Too much risk for dodgy sick person forced by income loss return, even if you minimise the health issues. You can have a PhD and Starbucks won’t touch you if ill. It’s not only soul destroying, but it is very deeply humiliating to not get hired, esp after a high level, successful career with awesome references and long term career stability and top tier success record, nope. Jobs become very hard to reach, so self employment kicks in.</p><p>I still have chronic infection issues now, but I’m 60% better. I don’t struggle with crushing fatigue and severe brain fog anymore.</p><p>So, moral of story, even if young, fit, healthy, you get this virus badly, you’re next decade might be completely shot. You might lose absolutely everything, including your extremely expensive 7 year bout of post secondary education you only finished paying off loans on, or have 5 figure loans hanging, still.</p><p>Chronic illness is very real. Autoimmune disease loves a virus like Covid to trigger it.</p><p>Anyhow, as I look back on that decade + from hell, with my symptoms, it sure looked like a checklist of SARS that may have been lingering in Hong Kong.No where did I get virus pcr testing when so sick. Sadly. Even if not SARS the lung , organ, and small vessel damage lingers. It may improve, it may not. I had gotten confirmed Klebsiella bacterial pneumonia eventually that spread to other areas. This has been the shits. They will also try to write off severe infection under *mental health* if anything else in life happens to be stressful. And esp if female. Thats really not helpful when things get complex, even if mental health suffers as a result of virus. It’s lazy. Especially with no history of mental health issues/ disorders. Lots of people who have post viral or infection damage know this too well. It’s very patronising. You can’t mediate or yoga away organ damage. Anti depressants don’t cure it.They help anxiety about it though.</p><p>Wear a mask, dont for a moment remove it indoors with others ( except house) and don’t risk everything,please. Life’s short, have patience, be careful. Don’t drop your guard for even. a half second. Don’t be cocky, and stay humble to the magnitude of potential life damage until known treatment happens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=923bb164e6c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Rojava-100 Questions from a Western Observer on the Left]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lizbethvarieswildly/on-rojava-100-questions-from-a-western-observer-d566848bec01?source=rss-557ecc2fb15c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d566848bec01</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lizbeth Varieswildly]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Nov 2019 18:24:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-10T21:02:55.768Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>On Rojava-100 Questions from a Western Observer on the Left</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/564/1*kz0z7A8KV_fegNXkLI_VPg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>The recent devastation of the Turkish invasion into Rojava or Northern Syria , has brutally revealed the growing chasm of serious ideological conflict amoung the so called Western left.</p><p>It’s been simmering all along, a given, and Afrin was a primer to a greater fracture test,but now we have genuinely hit peak discord amoung Syrian solidarity networks.</p><p>The main issue or argument has been the sudden brutal amplification of double standards and significant triggering on all sides when it comes to the Syrian opposition be it the revolutionary opposition , the Kurds, the Jihadi extremists, and apologists of the regime. It has demonstrably shown that Syria really has become the symbolic crux of a global left collapse. The pinnacle in terms of what extreme identity political support has done. It’s caused a massive implosion.</p><p>How did this all start?</p><p>Those of us horrified by the war jumped in by showing solidarity the best we could in these horrific circumstances.Supporting fleeing Syrians in our own countries, or on the horrendous journey towards safety was within our control.We couldn’t stop the war, but we could help on a practical and political level.Some of us naively, jumped into the well funded and organised anti war lobby, only later to find out it was laced with a robust lobby of supporters of Assad leaving quite a few of us genuinely aghast at tacit support of a genocidal maniac.</p><p>A few of us also welcomed many Syrians into our own homes and lives for a period ,helping with sponsorship and also helping integrate into new communities. On top of a few of us trying to stay acutely aware of what’s still happening there, it was the best we could offer.</p><p>Most who support both sides, Kurdish and Arab equally against brute oppression , can only explain in simple terms now itʼs about the civilians. Against Autocrats. We just canʼt go there.</p><p>Originally in 2011 we only saw Syrians. How things evolved in a sectarian manner was often linked to our wanting deeper understanding or committing to solidarity on a political front aligned with our own European democratic ideology. Our values.</p><p>Or in many cases, often accidentally, we forged close personal relationships with many Syrians:Kurds, Arabs , etc and that tilted us to bias perhaps. Their deep personal grievances and experiences became ours, or our cause. Most often it led to deep personal connections to their families, friends and allies still stuck in Syria , and their daily struggles.</p><p>For myself, exactly equally, I became close to revolutionary Arabs, Kurds, Druze, Yazidis, Atheists of all stripes,Syrian Palestinians , a Damascan Jew remarkably, many LGBTQ , artists, performers,and quite a few happy to ditch politics altogether, forget the nightmare of war and live a new clean slate elsewhere.</p><p>Having supported all revolutionary democratic minded Syrians, being placed in a spot of being pushed into the toxic blend of propaganda coming from all sides is really, really hard. I am in well over my head.</p><p>By defending any side here, I will lose friends, surely. I despise the sick genocidal , tyrannical Assad regime and its allies , I despise DAESH, Al Qaeda et al- any hardline Islamist terror group. Thatʼs it. So best thing is to not speak. Or is that even more arrogant?</p><p>Sudden silence when allied voices are needed more than ever seems disingenuous.</p><p>So Iʼll carry on and risk it.</p><p>Some questions just donʼt easily get answered in one of the most complex wars of this century. The one that has stood out as an enigma for the West however is Rojava.</p><p>Northern Syria, known in popular as Rojava, is now hotly contested amoung the left. Since the Turkish invasion, some have now relished in accusing the Rojava ‘revolution ‘ as being verified regime cronyism and a selfish nationalist project that betrayed the original revolutionary solidarity in Syria.</p><p>The evidence was recently amplified, when the YPG / PYD was forced an alliance with Assad. That or extermination by Turkey. No choice.</p><p>But,</p><p>The final days of Rojava seemed to be ,curiously, well engineered from the top. A basic shoe-in for Assad vis a vis Russia. It was discussed in detail in Astana on how this would all play out.</p><p>By giving the Turkish permission to do what they wish in the Orwellian sounding</p><p>“Operation Peace Spring”, and by advising Trump to betray his old Kurdish allies for the NATO outlier, Turkey could also finally get to grips with their grievances with the PKK.</p><p>This deal would pave the territory to send back their Syrian refugees to these Turkish backed and newly cleansed “ buffer zones “.</p><p>Turkish public sentiment has radically changed from 2012 over hosting 3 million Syrians for the duration of the war. Most Turks felt it was time to send them back, as far right nativist groups have deeply taken hold of public opinion.</p><p>This invasion will ultimately throw victory to Assad by pushing the Kurdish and allied forces to their knees to capitulate with no choice, hence by default allowing the regime to reclaim lost Kurdish territory in the border deal with Turkey. Also **very importantly**allow Turkey/ NATO to absorb the associated “costs” of the Turkish invasion of the perimeters by coordinating with Putin and Assad in the re engineering of the region by agreement, and regional influence.</p><p>The invasion worked. Kurdish troops acquiesced to Assad for protection under the horrific Turkish air strikes and Turkish backed ground militias committing immediate atrocities and displacement. Kurdish strikes over the border into Turkish civilian areas were further impetus. These moves helped bring the large Kurdish held territory’s almost immediately back under Assad’s or Assad’s proxy control. The US was or would have been the only major force present able to keep all the other dark forces at bay and guarantee some form of autonomy for the Kurds and allies in the region.</p><p>So it really is a big win for Russia by exploiting NATO on costs via new close ally,Turkey, huge win for Turkey on PKK grievances with bonus expanded territory and regional influence of Sunni majority areas, but all of these manoeuvrings would be the biggest, most triumphant win for Assad.Assad can finally demolish the Kurdish autonomy project after very usefully exploiting them, and their Western Allies to fight the Islamic State,saving the regime and its backers a lot of financial and military resources as the common enemy was shared. The regime was always a deep foe and deep oppressor of the Kurds,but allowing autonomy to flourish , knowing the West would jump in to help, was looking like just another calculated,murderous, exploitative betrayal.</p><p>Win Win Win on all sides. Putin Assad and Erdogan. The Kingmakers. Let’s not forget Iran either.</p><p>Those who lost always have been the genuine grass roots revolutionaries and 100% of the time, innocent civilians.</p><p>As for the US ,Trump pulled his troops out largely to appease to his powerful inner circle of cynical, anti interventionist ,far right Libertarians. Not by any advice of any regional commanders or senior military personnel who had themselves been in the region and had years of experience and intelligence on what the best plan would be.Trump refused to listen.</p><p>By cruelly ,simplistically, and stupidly denouncing all “foreign war”, this was an astounding,nightmarish betrayal of important loyal allies in Kurdish areas and against all rational advice.</p><p>Trump was acting in full accordance with Putin’s plan to either demolish or usefully exploit NATO for financial reasons, and to appease his US pro Kremlin lobby.Trump showed his true colours,as his deep admiration of autocrat strongman despots is never a secret.</p><p>The real benefactor from the definite chaos of the US troops leaving and resource pulling of Kurdish and Allied forces back to the front against Turkish air strikes and ground militias, would be DAESH POWs.They would no longer have the people available to man the camps of Islamic State fighters/family’s security. Trump gifted these prisoners to Turkey.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/184/1*_S-fb7KsmaL0RRleZnX0fA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anyhow, back to Rojava and why the most popular revolution of this century suddenly ,and devastatingly, became to be seen as a very sudden pariah state amoung so many Anti Assad Revolutionary Syrians and their supporters.</p><p>What happened exactly? I have a thousand questions here, however based on my observations over the years and superficial knowledge, perhaps just slightly more attuned than the average person, I will share my thoughts.</p><p>Itʼs really hard to fall out of love with a movement that seemed to give so much hope. Many people felt **incredibly skeptical** of any negative publicity of Rojava. It was elevated by pop culture even to an idealised world far ahead of us in the West even. Finally a real eco feminist Anarchist revolution not seen since the days of the Spanish Civil War. The CNT and their period of autonomy in Barcelona in 1936 became the holy grail of what could be. Anarchism in full practical,beautiful ,community driven application .The most important reference to silence cynics that Anarchism was an improbable, lofty, naieve idea. They had proof it could work. Just not long term.</p><p>So many on the left have been holding hope for another revolution like this one day. Much like the second coming of Christ to many Westerners, miraculously , Rojava happened. In the most conflict riddled ,extremely conservative area of the world , it made its radical juxtaposition to these societies a hopeful miracle.</p><p>Immediately commodified by Alt pop culture mongers, by exploiting the imagery of beautiful emancipated women fighters triumphant over the sickening regional patriarchy , and demolishers of The Islamic State, made Rojava suddenly appear to be very much one the most progressive zones in the world. Through the ability to destroy enemies with incredible ferocity and enable radical democratic change very quickly, simultaneously,many wanted to jump on board.</p><p>This first happened largely through Vice media forays into the region years ago looking at the training camps of the all female militias, the YPJ. This set off a frenzy of media portraying the incredible heroics, open mindedness,grit strength and modesty of the YPJ. They were the real deal, the uncorrupted,noble forces defending all humanity against the world’s pre eminent threat of the Islamic State.The most poignant thing of all was knowing every time a female soldier killed an Islamic State member, it would cancel their 70 virgins and head them straight to Hell. This delighted everyone , left or right, that being killed by a woman was the worst humiliation possible for these extremists.This was the tipping point for radical Western support for these women.</p><p>This was also the perfect place for Westerners to jump in , go off to join their ranks, to project their longings and desires for this kind of revolution to go global. They would also fight to the death for this revolution.</p><p>This was appealing to both devoted anarchists, thrill seekers, feminists and mercenaries to run off to Syria, to both build a plural eco feminist revolutionary utopia on the left, and fight the sadistic evils of the Islamic state on the right and left equally. This commodification and deification of a serious political movement in a horrific conflict took many idealists by the skin off their back, or in fact, took their life.</p><p>People, especially feminists , moderate leftists, some even on the centre right- radically defended Rojava from anything possibly tainting the movement as the stakes felt very high. Especially for women. More especially for the Yazidi women still held captive amoung DAESH and radical Islamist militias.</p><p>The sex slavery market of Yazidis was and is still sickeningly rife. These women, and their children desperately needed to be found. Their only hope it seemed were the Syrian Kurdish and allied forces. As far as I know, the other revolutionary forces such as the broadly coined FSA, did not take on the Yazidi plight with such priority and fervour as the Kurdish and allied forces did.The FSA did not stand out in media as the noble force **also** demolishing patriarchy for equality or standing in protection of all minorities. We saw little to no presence of women in the FSA ranks. They were hidden, often in civil society. Their voices not publicly amplified like the Kurdish women’s voices.It’s main, emergency priority was to fight the regime.</p><p>The FSA also did not, in its many collection of militias, or even in established Syrian Opposition parties in exile, seen to have a cohesive, unified,documented post conflict ideology or manifesto, other than removing Assad and proceeding with democracy. What would this democracy look like? Was it a human rights and full equality based inclusive bottom up democracy? We didn’t know the exact roadmap for the FSA and allies if success happened. What this would actually look like?</p><p>However we supported them in taking on the brutal regime , as the only heroic defenders of the innocent civilians. The Kurds had a very clear, direct democracy, equality based manifesto that was repeated time and time again in media, that we didn’t see from the FSA. Or the unified voices of Syrian opposition parties in media presenting their organised post conflict manifesto. It was noticeably absent in the Western Press. The Western press only focussed on the heroics of the Western backed White Helmets , the FSA initially, and the extreme regime atrocities. Little to nothing portrayed what post conflict success would look like. Success was seen in crude terms of the physical destruction of the Assad dynasty. Then what? What about the innocent civilians stuck on the Assad side living in fear of both?Or Assad supporters? The military apparatus? The practical governance? There seemed no one in charge in the media working on the immediate aftermath of success. This was a big risk for Western Government backers to not know what would actually happen. So I was told by several politicians that really wanted to see the end of Assad, it was too vague on the practical,governance front. There had been too much exposed corruption in the opposition held areas when government funds became available to help train local police. This put many governments off from going further. It would be a PR disaster if tax payer funds were stolen by radical Islamist armed groups, or stolen by thieves. Who would step in to help? If the West did they’d be branded imperialists and meddlers, citing the disaster of Iraq and Libya.The public or voters had no appetite for it, at least in the U.K.</p><p>For many in the West, the lack of a structured detailed plan mapped out in the mainstream press seemed curious. The West needed something to struggle for, in greater detail, not just against. Democracy is too broad a term,look at Iraq, Libya. These were not functioning democracies in a Western sense at all. They were a chaotic, sectarian, unclear ruse.</p><p>Throwing negativity</p><p>towards the Syrian Kurds and allies then from a practical,human rights centred democratic Western point of view would be wrong then, as they had a very ,clear and distinct plan.A plan in rapid action. Something to get behind to push forward with clarity that ticked all the right, progressive boxes.They also regularly denounced corruption and elitism for equality. Their ideology alone was reassuring their funding would reach the masses, not just a few who would pocket and leave. Or so we are assured anyhow.</p><p>Also any scathing criticism fit too obviously into a radical Islamist, or misogynist propaganda narrative. The Kurds and allies are incredibly smart and sophisticated in their clarity of message. They know backers need this over emotive or dreamy rhetoric.</p><p>DAESH had an incredible , sophisticated propaganda machine. They are experts at it. So is the Muslim Brotherhood or any allied type of radical Islamist organisation disguised as “moderates” even. They have huge funding streams behind them. So, all bad press directed at Kurds was also seen as a direct attack on freeing the Yazidis trapped in the dungeons of the Islamic state and their close allies, or indeed, a falsified set of grievances set up by the Islamic State and their cronies. All plausible.</p><p>But recently things began to change, when reasonable, respected trusted Syrian scholars, writers and even secular feminist intellectuals on the Syrian Revolution side started to cast a shadow on this movement. I couldnʼt believe it. I had and still have a hard time with it in fact, this was because I became very close to the displaced Yazidi community in Iraq who lost women, children, and so many men in the most grotesque fashion to sex slavery , torture and genocide.</p><p>I could not turn on them. They had no one on their side in the region, just the Syrian Kurdish and allied forces. Protecting them, the women and children still missing was priority number one, along with seeing the Islamic State surgically demolished and burned to Hell.</p><p>When the decision to ally with Assad came up as the “no choice” solution it jarred me. I had heard too many murmurings of Kurdish PYD complicity with Assad. This was radically disconcerting. Bizarre even.</p><p>My thoughts were initially, “Why on earth would genuine Kurdish Nationalists or real plural revolutionaries acquiesce to such a tyrannical ,horrific Fascist regime force that murdered both their own and 1000ʼs of innocent Syrian children and other revolutionaries, intellectuals, students, in utter grotesquely genocidal cold blood? “ the evidence of oppression , torture and murder is astonishing and goes back decades of brute actions against Kurds by the regime. How could this be?It goes completely against their plural and rights based ideology.</p><p>I think the answer lies in who *ultimately* controlled or forced the PYD/ YPG.The alliance with the regime seemed so way off, yet understood in the choice against a definitive destruction by Turkey. Itʼs so much more complex now. I had to press further.</p><p>One thing I had to consider was why the YPG / PYD was the dominant political force in the SDF. The SDF included a full suite of internationalists as well as Arab, Assyrian and Christian Militias.It was evidenced it was fully plural and inclusive of all ethnic groups in the region, despite regional Kurd population dominance.Many, many civilians from local Arab tribes were part of the SDF.</p><p>I also knew of many varied opposition parties in Syria in the Kurdish region, but I never saw their voices amplified in international media however. None in fact. Another blind spot politically. Like the alliance of previous described Syrian opposition being a media blind spot.</p><p>When I talk to expat Syrian Kurd friends I know in Europe , males mainly, many ran from conscription. I assumed it was just the murderous regime, but no, also the PYD. Conscription by force?? The YPG?! What!?Anarchists? I was clearly naieve on a lot of what was really happening. Obviously any media was highly curated, and returning Western Voices were quieter, or exhausted, but still, defiantly supportive.</p><p>I thought enough foreign volunteers and Western special forces were filling the gaps of soldiers being lost on the front. I was taken aback by this, but Iʼm clearly naive. Anti Fascist Anarchist inspired forces would never seek to dominate and force an individual resisting military service through threats and coercion. Itʼs counter to basic ideology!!</p><p>You join as you feel impassioned ,dedicated , emotionally and physically able. This wasnʼt the case,I was told internally, and a big reason a lot of guys left and kept a low profile in European Kurdish centres as a result. Was this Turkey pressuring them and families to stay quiet because of the ones who fled Syria now resided in Turkey? Relatives still there?</p><p>I didnʼt understand why the hesitation on supporting the PYD if they were espousing their general progressive ideas anyhow. Most friends I know were too tired to explain, and wanted out of politics and war. They needed time to heal from serious trauma. I never pushed. I respected the space they needed to heal.</p><p>The conscription issue kept coming up though.Stories also circulated on brute force and family extortion if a person didnʼt willingly submit. I didnʼt dismiss it, but it was percolating in the back of my mind. It sounded more PKK than YPG. Strange. I knew the PKK were rhetorically described by Turkey and pro Turkish allies as hardline violent Stalinists bent on revenge and civilian destruction if need be, and Turkey suffered incredibly under them. Kurds as well due to the resulting purges and destruction of Kurdish towns by Turkish forces seeking out PKK terror cells. They were terrorists in the most basic terms, according to Turks. Their tactics did not resonate well with the average Turkish or Kurdish working class person Iʼm told, they caused too much fear and resulting destruction.</p><p>However, according to media, to counter this narrative , there was a historical ceasefire in place in Turkey and Ocalanʼs political stance changed to fully repudiating terror and aggressive violence, for diplomacy, and a new philosophy inspired by American anarchist, Murray Bookchin.</p><p>This is a radical departure from hardline Stalinism the PKK are accused of, with the exception of active ultra violent PKK offshoot TAK.It seems on appearances TAK and the PKK have very different, yet converging roles on Kurdish liberation. Much like the ultra violent ‘Real IRA’ from the IRA who uncoupled broadly from SinnFein, but share a similar end goal of Republicanism.</p><p>It is still debated whether TAK is actually linked to the PKK, despite leadership declaring they are not. TAK operate on the surface as independent extremist guerrilla cells responsible for the most horrific series of serial terror attacks in Turkey, including on innocent foreigners and civilians. These attacks have been horrific and utterly terrifying for their total civilian disregard. Rightly, this has left Turkey living in absolute fear with ample justification for self defence.</p><p>However, TAK uses Ocalan’s unjust imprisonment as an inspiration for their terror. This is very suspect and problematic. It goes completely against Ocalans contemporary desire and declarations of a ceasefire. Only defensive force could be used in an invasion by Turkey.</p><p>Regardless, the cult of Ocalan, and his personality or even exploitation, as he’s in prison, has given him a status of a nearly infallible leader. This type of absolute leader impunity is uncharacteristic of democratic Anarchist movement’s. There is a regard for multiple leaders,deep respect for martyrs, but philosophically it’s opposed to unquestioning submission to any one authority.</p><p>However, it’s a cultural shift that hasn’t happened quite as broadly in the Middle East as it has in the West.So the flags of Ocalan remain flying highest.</p><p>I was told the Syrian PYD/ YPG had nothing to do with the PKK, Ocalan was their leader too, but instead of ‘Stalinismʼ type tactics, they embraced Bookchin instead. Again their interests did converge on the wishes of an autonomous homeland. I personally saw them as separate entities entirely. The PKK has or at least did have a very dangerous reputation globally and are allegedly involved in mass organised crime, protection rackets, drugs, money laundering to fund their activities.Again, often these allegations are stemming from Turkish state media, however, anyone familiar with Kurdish gangs or cartels in Europe, know their brute tactics.</p><p>Some Syrian academic Kurds I know have a belief the PKK, especially TAK, are not really who they say they are and instead, a covert apparatus of a racist Turkish state or covertly by opposition Kemalists. Filled with PKK traitors or naïve disaffected nihilistic youth, they are used as an excuse to sow terror, to justify ethnically cleansing Kurds and turn the public against them even more.</p><p>Anyhow, itʼs complicated well beyond most analysts attempts to draw linear conclusions , as Kurds have enough historical grievances and genocides behind them to need a real protection force. Perhaps not one like this that makes it worse for everyone. Diplomacy and political solutions were the best route, only if Turkey remained democratic however.</p><p>Its not been looking good since 2016 though. Post coup the country has clamped down on all dissent, period. A Facebook post by a naive tourist critical of Turkey, to a teacher accused of Gulenism, or any and all genuine opposition leaders, mass incarceration. Brutal crackdowns continue, true democracy has been compromised or even destroyed , especially since the last referendum.The crackdowns have had a sinister global reach even. A friend of a friend or a relative displaying any criticism of the Turkish state now, especially on social media, could result in family of friends back in Turkey facing incarceration unless they repudiated these connections entirely.</p><p>Back to Western support of the PYD/ YPG. People took great care to not confuse them with the PKK.</p><p>Here is largely what enticed Westerners to Ocalanʼs contemporary ideology dominant in Rojava mentioned earlier:Womenʼs Equality, the brave all female YPJ militia, and radically equal city and village councils with equal participation of women, Arab and all other minorities. Grass roots direct democracy councils .This was why. Direct Democracy ,from the bottom up. Full representation.</p><p>The idealised form of municipal confederalism taking root in localism movements across the globe. It was a revolution that was holistic and profound in nature. Nobody got excluded, everyone had an important voice.For this to flourish under a nation oppressed by dictatorships for time immemorial, this was the radical change needed for full emancipation of all, not just a ruling class.</p><p>Westerner activists mourning the days of the occupy movementʼs fading, and the destruction of these radical community direct democracy councils in the squares they took over, someone needed to carry the torch. In this case it was the Kurdish supporters of Ocalan who ran with it and seemed to perfect the model according to the news we would receive from Rojava.</p><p>After very bravely retaking Kobane and then ultimately reclaiming all areas from the Islamic State, to build stability and security again was really impressive. Seeing towns like Manbij flourish under this model, everyone saw this as incredible triumph over the worst adversity ever.</p><p>All this with the added critical aspect of a deep respect for ecology, based on Murray Bookchin’s laudable eco anarchism. Fully plural, fully inclusive, fully amazing sounding. Who thinks of ecology in war? Very few. War is one of the worst forces of the degradation of humans for generations and for our vulnerable planet. We are currently hurling towards extinction if we donʼt drastically change fast. This aspect made it all the more urgent and compelling from the outside looking in. This was a very relatable revolution.</p><p>Support in Western left activist circles grew even greater, and enthusiastically on a fiery ,almost religious level regarding the pureness,bravery and sanctity of the Rojava revolution.It was becoming beyond criticism.The right also threw their weight behind their Anti Islamist and Islamic State fighting heroics. It became an intersection of left and right against Islamic extremism.</p><p>They became immune to critics in foreign activist eyes. An army of defenders would shout down anyone taking pot shots as fascists or DAESH supporters.The YPG/J PYD and allied forces were, after all, the main menace towards and eternal solution to the worlds very darkest force, DAESH. It was really black and white, genuine good versus tyrannical sadistic evil, in most eyes.</p><p>Back to the Yazidi genocide, no human who witnessed it could forget the moment the Kurdish forces of the YPG/ J rescuing the Yazidis on Mt.Sinjar from total genocide on that hideous ,searing, scorched August day in 2014. This was a heroic act of ultimate bravery in many eyes. This was their status as the plural minded force of ultimate good, consolidated and proven now.</p><p>No one can forget the terror , the sick psychic imprint of the slaughter of the innocent Yazidi. Or 3000+ women, girls, children kidnapped by the caliphate missing, perhaps still in reach. No one single force bravely took control of this nightmare of genocide and sexual slavery, but the YPG/J and allied forces did. They stood up and saved the Yazidis they could and hunted DAESH with such ferocity and vengeance we were left looking like moral lepers.</p><p>Moral Leper’s.</p><p>Our broad Western forces did nothing.</p><p>They ignored. For feminists and activists, this was beyond reprehensible. We owed them a debt of eternal gratitude.</p><p>However, very importantly, who stood firmly by the civilians during the brutal bombings and sieges of Aleppo? Or Eastern Ghouta? The worst mass slaughters and gas attacks by the regime? Who stood shoulder to shoulder in deep solidarity to the survivors and torture victims of Assadʼs prison regime? Who stood for the missing? The innocent women and female revolutionary activists brutalised and raped in such sickening ways in prison? The children in prison and the one 12 year old child who had his genitals severed by the regime and chucked back to his family, dead and defaced so disgustingly for participating in peaceful protests?</p><p>The silence of a lot of the left on Assad, but who were incredible supporters of Rojava was *extremely* strange. Mind boggling. I don’t think it was just because the FSA/ opposition didn’t have a cohesive post conflict plan or manifesto. There were other reasons. Much darker reasons.</p><p>In fact, statistically, documented by many organisations , the crimes of the regime exceeded the crimes of DAESH by sheer numbers. The fascist sick violence was ultimately the same. Assad had the upper hand of controlling airspace, one that DAESH did not. The regime and DAESH were the same in my eyes. The **only** difference is the regime did not have a global mandate of domination, DAESH did. But any internationalist would be accused of grotesque double standards and zero moral principle if they did not condemn both of them equally.</p><p>Sadly a portion of the Rojava supporting left became seduced by regime apologists declaring all supposed , and verified atrocities committed by the regime was Western Imperialist propaganda. All lies. All of it created by Islamists and Zionists. Of course. The Zionists at it again. “Western meddling” “ regime change “ For some reason those trigger words are like chloroform to old guard leftist brains. Hypnotic chloroform. This was not Latin America, Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, it was a uniquely new situation in a country where an old lefty ally/ brutal dictator was slaughtering en masse. Unchallenged. This needed immediate humanitarian intervention, not the reverse.</p><p>I was staggered people bought this utter shit propaganda.It was lazy, stubborn and myopic.. But it was rife in the U.K. Labour Party even. Anyhow, much to my utter disgust, the roots of this comes from the Stalinist inspired mainstream anti war movements or,predictably,The Socialist Workers Party and global Neo Stalinist/ Anti “Western Imperialist “ movementʼs everywhere.</p><p>Other brute imperialists forces, like Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas etc get a free pass though. I call them Red Brown Fascists who are linked to the far right and many racist, nationalist fronts. The leadership there use the language of the left to appeal to old lefties, but their agenda is far right in nature. La Rouchian maybe as well. They are Nationalist Socialists really, it seems. As long as the word ‘ Socialist ‘ remains.</p><p>Baathism was rather inspired by Nazism and united by anti semitism.In fact Assad Sr had sheltered ex Nazis fleeing war crimes tribunals and used their expertise in building his Nationalist Socialist state, and more importantly his extermination chambers, his prisons. Assad was also seen as the heroic bulwark in the region of the equally aggressive Israeli state. To me they are the relatively the same, or mirror images of each other. Supremacist regimes supportive of ethnopluralism . I try to see things from the top down. Israel had far more claim to democracy however amoung Jews and allies, with thriving , open oppositions, and a modern semi free, critical press and level of free expression and gender equality unknown in Syria. However the treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank is a testimony of supremacist tyranny in action. But anyhow,large segments of the left *only*see things in terms of Israel and “Western Imperialist” Zionist crony states, like America.Anyone an arch enemy of Israel, is a true friend. Like Iran, like Iraq under Hussein, and especially Syria. Assad is their man. They will whitewash all his regime crimes , along with other bff Iran , or the crimes of Hezbollah, and group favourite, Hamas, because they share a common enemy.Israel.</p><p>If this is not cognitive dissonance and selective solidarity on the highest level , I donʼt know what it is.</p><p>If they can excuse such hideous crimes , mass slaughter, siege, brutal barrel bombs and air strikes against civilians and even hospitals,and gloss over the verified gas attacks etc , for the sake of “anti Israel forces” and “anti Zionist” solidarity , then they are truly sick in the head.</p><p>Big time. How is this different from political Neo Nazism? I donʼt genuinely know. They share a lot of friends. They also never seemed too bothered about the extreme repression and brutal murders of stateless Palestinians in Syria however. That got a free pass too.</p><p>These people were also some vocal supporters of Rojava. It was getting really, really dissonant and disturbing now. What was wrong with peoples brains? Thereʼs a saying that nails it on their locked in Anti West, Anti Zionist , and of course, “ Anti Soros” “enemigo number one “ mentality.</p><p>“A person who is guided by his principle will stand up to his allies, and side with his “opponents” if truth and morality dictates it.</p><p>A person driven by bias will go to war against reality in order to defend the identity of the herd”</p><p>Not as many who jumped onto Rojava bothered to look much at the other factions of democratic revolutionary resistance in individual and Syrian opposition voices independent of the few or unknown political opposition parties in exile. Voices at the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights were very clear on their support of progressive democracy in Syria, and were/ are very objective in their reporting of war crimes and atrocities against all civilians. The best they can be given the conditions.The SOHR is the best example of what Syrian democratic ,unified solidarity could be, in press and human rights documentation anyhow.</p><p>For pro regime left , just seeing what appeared to be ‘Sunni Islamist’ militias scared them off point blank. They brushed them all off as Al Qaeda. Western meddling. Ridiculous to not understand the complexity of the armed opposition and the 1000’s of militias fighting under the banner of FSA.</p><p>They didnʼt think to take the time seek to understand the revolutionary civilians there, or their brutal, multi sided oppression. Or the fact many Arab Sunni civilians and activists despised these radical jihadi Islamist criminal groups but had guns to their heads to maintain silence. Peak Islamophobia , really. Rojava activists failed to look. Not all, but most. They began looking quasi regime. The split began.</p><p>But the split got ever worse when Western solidarity left wing activists blind to the Kurds, perhaps for personal reasons or connections more to brutally oppressed Arab Sunni communities, began uncritically supporting any opposition to Assad without any due diligence. Just sloganeering. As long as it hated Assad, it was an ally. Including Al Qaeda proxies, or extremist militias. Exactly mirroring the bias behaviour of their hardline anti Zionist foes sharing the space of the “left”.</p><p>Soon though, these anti regime Western activists began a vocal campaign against the Kurdish, namely Rojava. It really peaked after the fall of Raqqa. Particularly as documented atrocities by some YPG forces came out against Arab civilians. It started more robustly when Turkey and Turkish backed militias invaded Afrin. Despite the plethora of horrific war crimes in Afrin, Western solidarity activists were by then equating Kurdish and ally fighters as the same as DAESH themselves, or becoming vaguely DAESH apologists at the extreme end. What on Earth happened? They became uncritical supporters of Turkey and especially Erdogan. He became a type of folk hero.</p><p>What sort of crazy propaganda pill did they swallow to fully abandon their democratic supposed non racist values? What was going on? What was I missing here ? During Afrin they supported the Turkish Militias as the Grey Wolves and condemned and seriously threatened critics who brought up war crimes by the FSA and Turkish or Turkish backed Syrian militias. Erdogan became God. Had everyone lost the plot now? Turkey just chucked pretty much everyone opposing their own regime in the clink. The biggest anti democratic NATO member purge in modern days of innocent critics. How could I support or any Westerner support a man looking more and more exactly like Assad?!</p><p>People like myself became shocked and saddened at what was (considered now an umbrella term of a collection of opposition militias)FSA atrocities, and I refused to support them broadly anymore, after Afrin. They already were getting a bad reputation for being ruthless ,murderous, rogue thugs. They were a cacophony of 1000 militias under that umbrella and no longer the coherent, disciplined perhaps unified resistance that they were in 2012. However pockets of good , brave soldiers of course existed,but they were eclipsed by militia faction in fighting chaos that’s hard to understand unless on a very local level.</p><p>Afrin changed everything. I trusted no broad militias anymore. Except hoping the SDF and YPJ women’s militias were still staying in convention?</p><p>Maybe it was sexist, but I kept that faint hope in the nobility of the womenʼs movement and that it stayed loyal to ideology and didnʼt stoop to war crimes.I admit a bit of a gender and ideology bias here in their outward feminist ideology ,although women in the Islamic State were also equal to males in their support or executions of extreme brutality. I and many. Yazidi solidarity activists needed to hold fast to the rescue of Yazidis and the destruction of DAESH in their corner.</p><p>I did find it odd the retreat from Afrin was so hasty on the YPG side,despite rhetoric, but such is war. I can’t criticise well what I don’t really know, if it’s not clear what happened, or it hadn’t been explained to me by sources that were there.</p><p>The Syrian Kurdish template for feminist ,plural Rojava still boldly stood in stark contrast to these all these Male ultra violent militias and even to the deeply patriarchal, nepotic ,capitalist, tribal Kurdistan Regional Government in Iraq.</p><p>Hope needed to be held somewhere, that some were still good, noble, opposition forces. I just didn’t know where they all were now. I just knew lots of soldiers on all sides were still very good, loyal to the cause and stuck to conventions of war by not touching civilians, or committing war crimes.</p><p>The differences in the political and cultural leanings of Iraqi Kurdistan vs Syrian Kurdistan were marked, in my observations of friends from both regions. Despite sharing the obvious language, history and ethnicity of their immediate neighbours, things were very different.</p><p>According to the Iraqi Yazidis stranded on Mt. Sinjar, the Kurdish Peshmerga absolutely abandoned them to DAESH, whereas the YPG/J liberated them.The Iraqi Peshmerga also herald women in their military ranks, however few of these women sit on the front line. There are still massive barriers to gender or political equality in the KRG region.</p><p>With the KRG as America’s biggest ally in the region, and DAESH fighting force in Iraq, holding a positive diplomatic position with Turkey is a big ideological clash for the also Western backed SDF/YPG/PYD, especially united under US support of their military.The Turkish diplomatic issue was incredibly tough to rectify.</p><p>So then, considering the above situation, how effective was the Rojava Revolution forces in yielding *real* power in direct line with their ideology? What was behind the *real* power? What did the financiers demand?</p><p>Still, more critical questions again. Especially around the US relationship with Rojava. That was terribly odd, but optimistically seen as a possible ? Obama inspired progressive stance and that the US was evolving to be more progressive? Still it didn’t make much sense, considering how Obama abandoned the Syrian people at the front of the revolution to slaughter when they needed him to intervene.He had horrible foreign policies.</p><p>Letʼs look at that.</p><p>Why on earth would the US support an Anarcho ECO Feminist Plural project ideologically? Do you see US Federal money going into support Black Disabled Single Mother Trans Lesbian Jewish womenʼs grass roots organisations in say Detroit?</p><p>A bit odd?They definitely donʼt do it at home. Just see what would happen if a bunch of Anarcho feminists of colour take over Wall Street? Well in 2011, they had a good run of venting at the 1%. But everything got way worse in America following OWS. Look at the last 8 years and the rise of the far right and increased tolerance and extremist terror of violent white supremacy.</p><p>So Iʼm thinking tone correct optics and carrot stick PR on the Rojava Revolution perhaps was meant to lure broad Liberal Western Support and lobbying ,initially, in very good faith.</p><p>But any real power here in terms of ultimate end strategy ?</p><p>America was unlikely to stick around.</p><p>Fighting DAESH and exploiting the Kurdish and allied forces was the primary reason, as was securing the oil in the region that DAESH had taken , and the Kurds/ Allies had liberated. They didn’t give a shit about the “ideology” of the Rojavan revolution, but individual US soldiers definitely did, and some even stuck around or came back after tours to support the revolution as independent volunteers and anti DAESH fighters. They stayed shoulder to shoulder with their Kurdish comrades now, they wouldn’t betray them.</p><p>If it was ‘a ‘realʼ “sustainable” popular revolution , conservative America would destroy it. Fully. Their history is all about squashing genuine democratic egalitarian movements unless they had blank cheque access to their natural resources . So itʼs very strange bedfellows . Someone knew it was something it was not.That cynicism proved correct as of last week when Trump declared the oil patches now secured and guarded by US forces. This was his moment to abandon the Kurds and keep the oil , as it were.</p><p>This murderous betrayal by Trump to Turkish forces was a bold clue of the “exploitation or sinister dismantling “ of what sounded like a very good,noble, US supported revolution from afar.</p><p>Of course it was a brilliant use by America , now traitorous abuse, of their DAESH fighting skills,loyalty to the core, and intelligence.The Rojava movement was likely riddled with traitors top down keenly exploiting the grass roots benevolence and big trust of Syrians in the region. And Western supporters. Internationalists.The US led forces that superficially supported the movement , only if it worked in their interests, would by design ,inevitably cause the brutal destruction of the Kurds and allies of N Syria . Their homes and lives destroyed once again when Turkey invaded. Just like Afrin. Maybe worse. The region around Manbij was the jewel in the crown of the success of the Rojava Revolution and offered the last year or so a bit of stability and a small boom in economy. The revolution seemed to work well there.</p><p>Again, this gives us an idea of who was possibly the arch controller of this movement that possibly contributed to pushing it off a cliff. There were glaring ideological inconsistencies from questionable supporters, or financiers, particularly the Americans. On the simplest level, maybe the Kurdish and allied forces really did trust, and trust hard. The evidence was in Iraq, and in the commitment and support of the troops themselves independent of Trump. Lots of bottom up loyalty. There was not much other choice out there as most Western NATO troops stayed largely out ,except for some small special forces troops and of course NATO outlier, Turkey.</p><p>To address the fever pitch conflict in current anti regime international Leftist Syria solidarity circles who condemn the Rojava project, I am trying to still piece together why they have such a particular and passionate disdain for it and often take on almost verbatim the Turkish narrative that this movement in absolute is the PKK, who is in turn the TAK. All are the same. Who are either as bad as DAESH, which is incredibly bizarre to hear from these circles, or are equal to or a direct apparatus of the genocidal Syrian regime granted special favours.</p><p>But why this state being the Pariah almost more than the concern of Nusra controlling Idlib? I’ll try to dig into some reasons that would at least be better than straight up propaganda..</p><p>From: The Kurdish Para State in Rojava chapter, from “Rojava, Revolution, War and The Future Of Syriaʼs Kurds” by Thomas Schmidinger- an Austrian Kurdish Scholar</p><p>On Womenʼs councils in Rojava:</p><p>“ The principle of Co Chairmanship, that is, all councils are always jointly led by a Male and female. Moreover, in addition, there are also autonomous womenʼs councils , which reflects the importance of feminism in the ideology of the PYD and the PKK.</p><p>In “theory “ * this creates a council system based on based on direct democracy, but which is, however, in fact dominated by the supporters of the PYD and the latter ‘frontʼ organisations. Moreover, just like other historic systems such as in the former Soviet Union, the question is Who is really in the possession of political power?:</p><p>Is it, in the end, really “all power to the councils”, or is it , after all “all power to the party” Or even to the army, in this case the YPG?</p><p>How significant the council system is actually to the real power structures in Rojava is controversial”</p><p>T. Schmidinger.</p><p>So, what I see here from what the author has written is on one side , an attempt at exploiting egalitarian movements on a cosmetic “front” level by convincing local Kurds and other citizens in its councils its bottom up effectiveness, ,and making good PR for the Liberal, progressive West and expat Kurds looking for hope in one of the worst totalitarian regimes around.</p><p>We desperately needed a story of hope in Syria, somewhere needed a just ending of Liberation and democracy right? As Westerners in general we have this optimism bias. Perhaps itʼs our privilege talking. Or our faith and hope in spiritual justice after great awful sacrifice.</p><p>On the idea it is a genuine heartfelt attempt at a very good thing, yet unknown to most, perhaps the military stifled it, rogue traitors infiltrated it, regime or the arch financiers ultimately had the last say.Or America flat out ruined it.</p><p>Perhaps critics of Rojava were silenced too often at important inconsistencies. Lots went off piste apparently ,according to critics. Maybe the Rojava movement was partly too trusting and tolerant of bad apples. Or maybe the submission to the ideology of their financial backers controlled them ultimately?The regime playing them too on the highest level?</p><p>Did financing streams corrupt this movement in desperate times? Everything requires compromise and guarantors on some level, but not to the extent of serious counter revolution activities / war crime allegations. Thatʼs way too off piste on professed ideology.This is the type of stuff alleged by the anti regime supporters.</p><p>I know a lot of very good people here. The ones who went to “Rojava “ They laid down their lives to fight DAESH.</p><p>Often getting slammed by anti regime cynics as phoney self serving Anarchist wanker thrill seekers, when they were absolutely not .In fact a grave insult to so many who fought and died with the noblest of intentions.Maybe some wankers, of course. So Iʼve heard,but they didnʼt last. They would get sent off or refused at the front.</p><p>Nor were these International volunteers Stalinist frauds, phonies , regime cronies. or ideologically corrupt.</p><p>In simple terms. They went to fight DAESH. And join a global movement that looked optimistic.Be the change. Simple.</p><p>For others to learn from what sounded like a beautiful revolution happening, it encouraged more people. Normal working class people joined to fight for a revolution against evil that would surpass even the West in progressive values. Eco Feminist anti DAESH Utopia. Straightforward on the outside.</p><p>Many did run there, and left families with incredible heartbreak. Others went in and fought as inexperienced soldiers even, but succumbed to PTSD and a few tragically took their young lives on return back to the West .Unable to cope with re entry to society outside the deep comradery of war, the brutal deaths and loss of powerful friends in the collective struggle was too much to bear. Too much guilt and little collective support on the outside. Never mind being charged and convicted by various governments for running off to Syria to join the Anti DAESH forces. These volunteers were treated as locals there ,embraced into a culture and big extended family totally unknown to most Western Europeanʼs or Westerners in general. This is incredibly powerful to feel so included and valuable. As one.</p><p>Very Good People with sound ethics and huge hearts.</p><p>They went in with good intention of revolutionary egalitarian solidarity.</p><p>The good people who ran perhaps naively and open hearted to Rojava would not stray from their egalitarian , Feminist and respect for life ideology.</p><p>They only targeted DAESH.</p><p>Now they are on the defensive to Turkish backed militias. Lots of women came deeply supporting womenʼs struggleʼs in one of the most oppressive places on the planet for women. Now they are supporting civilians and comrades in the current Turkish invasion.</p><p>But, back to arguments on leftist double standards.</p><p>How come Westerners sharing such radically enthusiastic democratic ideology did not run to join the FSA in the beginning with the same enthusiasm as for Rojava?</p><p>I think Rojava had a better campaign of outreach simply, one Westerners can relate to.Particularly with emphasis on gender equality. Seeing female fighters side by side with men wasnʼt seen in the FSA. This would be a deterrent for Western female internationalists. Too many men and where are the women exactly?</p><p>But in theory , both movements were sharing similar ideology in the beginning. Both “professed” pluralism? Did they really ? What happened? The FSA eventually had financiers from Qatar, Turkey etc that demanded a religious , pious front in return for cash. Likely the Muslim Brotherhood got the upper hand.</p><p>This is after the West let them down, Qatar, Saudi etc filled the vacuum, funds for loyalty and piety. Hence the ideological shift with FSA, as opposed to Kurdish outward facing secularism,gender equality and pluralism. The seeds of revolutionary solidarity between groups was no more, now militias were proxy fronts beholden to financiers directions . There was no choice. Point of no return as proxy or sure death by regime. Someone needed to keep innocents and the idea of the Revolution alive and fight the worst domestic cold blooded monster mass slaughterer of all, the regime.</p><p>Intention is whatʼs important here. International volunteers lured in by Rojava, could not be the broad force also fighting the regime as the battle against DAESH was too intense. But if their ideology was sound, they would fight the evil regime with equal vigour. But in war you follow orders. As a foreigner, follow orders. Trust the locals to lead, you follow. Fight DAESH,help in reconstruction etc.</p><p>Remember, the Syrian revolutionary forces as the original incarnation of the FSA, fought DAESH with the same vigour and sacrifice for a Democratic Grass Roots Revolution.</p><p>So all fronts fought DAESH in theory, FSA, Nusra et al, Assad, they all professed to fighting DAESH together. But you cannot say the FSA and Assad were allies sharing a common enemy as DAESH right? No one is exploiting that line, calling them an alliance.</p><p>What happened to solidarity between Kurdish, minority and Sunni Arab groups?</p><p>All groups wanting grass roots democratic revolution shared common enemies, the regime, and DAESH et al, in simple terms. What went so wrong that historical grievance , racism, and cynicism took over?The biggest targets of genocide by regime was Sunni Syrians. Kurds are also a Sunni majority. What happened to a sense of Ummah between Sunniʼs being targeted? Clearly ideology.Culture too.</p><p>On the other groups of Westerners compelled to join the Syrian Revolution, It was the foreign Jihadis joining DAESH and Nusra etc to fulfil Jihad .They wanted the realisation of a caliphate in complete opposition to any plural equality based democracy.This was transparent.</p><p>But all Western Volunteers can be lumped as idealists and opportunists hoping to see the dream realised, save a country from stupid sectarianism, and plant trees , build schools and be good solid dedicated internationalists or Jihadis. Much like the Internationalist Brigades to Spain during civil war or the Muhajideen in Bosnia. Radically opposite beliefs, but same compelling lure from the clarion call of brothers and sisters in the struggle. Brilliant propaganda, power luring campaigns inspired crudely and very astonishingly by gaming for certain young males.They wanted to go next level.They were some of the most vulnerable to joining propaganda.Thats a whole other essay.</p><p>Back to Rojava and women.</p><p>Was it also Men tokenising and exploiting womenʼs struggles again? Let them have what looks like liberation, give them a good taste to get fierce loyalty after being oppressed for so long, but still hold the key to their cell? Like Saudi Women drivers? It seems the good people and ideas got subverted somewhere? Did they?</p><p>Or as witnessed by Thomas Schmidinger above, “upper” management of the YPG dominated and over rode grassroots council decisions.Who were they really?</p><p>Breaking from ideology radically, why did rogue or aggressive alleged revenge style actions of the YPG seem to mimic the regimes crimes ?</p><p>This was brought up in critically Important Arab grievances such from the liberation of Deir Ezzor.</p><p>The YPG/ PYD response to allegations hasnʼt been totally clear. Beyond the gross war crimes atrocities of bombing campaigns and crude aerial strikes by Western Forces on DAESH enclaves, ground force civilian victims grievances are deafening now, as many Sunni Syrian Arabs are backing Erdoganʼs “Peace Spring” Invasion.</p><p>There is a feeling of intense anger amoung many voices, of Sunni Syrian Arabs especially, and feeling of betrayal by the Kurdish movement. This anger eclipses, bizarrely ,the actual serious racism , betrayal and xenophobia fuelling the Turkish political campaign against all Syrians, especially refugees in Turkey.</p><p>Kurds and Kurdish progressives will always be enemy number one though for a Turkey. The Syrian Sunni Arab backing of Erdogan feels like an act of irrational self hatred, naiveté, or its based on threats of violence in places where Arabs are living amoung Nationalist Turks. Used to living under dictatorship, the capitulation or even Stockholm syndrome towards threatening autocratic leaders is very real. Towing the line for survival. Or theyʼve sold their loyalty and soul to the Muslim Brothers, or are Islamists at heart.Or they have been direct victims of Kurdish forces atrocities . Who knows?</p><p>It was reported that the YPG launched rockets over the border in revenge on Turkish civilians.</p><p>Why were missiles fired aggressively on civilian areas over the border on Turkey? Why follow the extremism of the PKK and horrific history of killing civilians when Ocalanʼ clearly and apparently condemned and demanded an end to?Thats not justifiable self defence.Thatʼs cynical and counter revolutionary. Again, we can see this is a questionable “non monogamous” ideology, especially Coming from a movement preaching pluralism and respect for minorities on all levels in a radical way!</p><p>That laudable, compelling revolutionary front a token gesture? Optics? Was it high level infiltration? Rogue traitors sent to discredit? Who knows? So many permutations. Or a combination of everything. For purists supporting the supposed peaceful ideology from afar, this is off. Way off.</p><p>Not all Sunni Arabs in the DAESH held regions were DAESH , of course ! Its a beyond absurd thought, most were civilian victims stuck in horror under DAESH.Sure some DAESH hid in sleeper cells using human shields.</p><p>On hearing complaints and grievances on the YPG personally, its not been explained well, or critically of what happened there exactly. There has to be an explanation, because revenge attacks on civilians is a huge credibility destroyer. What is the story there?</p><p>Back to the democratic councils in Rojava, if they voted, but then were subject to the decision being actively,unilaterally vetoed by the military? How is that compliant?That is not democratic. Itʼs cosmetic. What happened?</p><p>It tells me higher powers pulled the strings on critical fronts, and the citizens were not really respected from the grass roots? Who ordered attacks on civilians ? Or to push for displacement and looting in civilian Arab areas? Or Arab victims of Islamic State. I understand the difficulty in identifying sleeper cells though, disguised as civilians. It’s very complicated.</p><p>No one seems to give a direct answer, or they are still working it out for themselves on rogue factions.</p><p>Perhaps slightly similar to what FARC did in Columbia , the idea was to exploit the womenʼs movement to get lefty Western support , on social justice optics, but actually remain a male dominated corrupt brute drug cartel Stalinist death cult, or grim proxy for financiers partisan exploitation?</p><p>In N Syria, the history of complex opposition parties exists massively in the area. Many with different ideologies, but one party, the PYD, dominated the discourse. Why was that system so successful in getting backing from foreign, ideological opponents?</p><p>There have been many Kurdish political parties in the region over time,many with a socialist or left wing ideology, or some running in closer alliance with Kurdistan Regional Government in Iraq.</p><p>Kurdish Democratic Political Union.</p><p>Kurdish Democratic Progressive Party.</p><p>Kurdish Future Movement in Syria.</p><p>Kurdish National Alliance in Syria.</p><p>Kurdish National Council.</p><p>Kurdistan Democratic Party of Syria.</p><p>Opposition and especially Turkish Propaganda tends to always assert the PKK , is ascribed to pretty much all the Syrian Kurds or most Kurds in the immediate region. This conflicts all evidence pointing to incredible political diversity.</p><p>There are AKP party supporting Kurds in Turkey which adds to the fallacy of stereotypes. Much like the incredible political diversity of Arabs globally, pushing stereotypes is cynical , dangerous and wrong.Why do people insist on doing it? Itʼs lazy, dangerous and keeps end of the world is nigh nihilists rather happy.</p><p>Iʼm no scholar , but it raises a lot of questions on why such a popular movement among Westerners , with huge international support would capitulate to Fascist cold blooded murderer Assad in the end?It was rumoured for a long time. No one wanted to believe it.</p><p>I know itʼs survival, but as fervent Nationalists fighting to the end of time , it would be kicking, screaming, demonstrating across Europe condemning Assad, alongside Turkey and resisting out loud with incredible might to resist falling back under the Fascist dictator who badly oppressed them right?Like they do with Turkey?</p><p>I’ve still not seen a picture on a placard of Assad with blood on his face at Kurdish PYD dominated demonstrations, like I have in other Syrian Revolution solidarity demonstrations I’ve been to. I’ve never seen the two groups demonstrate visibly together, united against Assad in London anyhow. I’ve not seen the Anti Assad supporters demonstrate against the Turkish invasion and subsequent displacement of more civilians. The sectarian lines are still massive.</p><p>Much of the last bastion of civilian, roots resistance to the regime is in Idlib, defending itself loudly from the tyrant to its last breath despite its HTS and Turkish backed Islamist overlords.</p><p>Resistance and civil society lives in Idlib.Much as it lives with fervour in N Syria. Resistance lives under all brute oppression.Often totally silenced.The problem in Idlib is the outward voices on social media of democratic resistance are exploited by the militias, to resist them being labelled extremists. However, evidence is becoming ever more grave that Idlib is the hotbed of multiple controlling extremists. Al Baghdadi, case in point. Hiding in plain sight, under protection. Civilian democratic revolutionaries caught under this have zero ability to be honest in these conditions,as it’s too risky. The line must be towed , the one hammered down by overlords. The overlords are the only form of protection from outright genocide in this kettled ,intense area. A hideous dilemma, much like in N Syria being forced back to the tyranny of the regime.Idlib is still being pounded brutally daily by regime and Russian Airstrikes, hitting hospitals and civilian areas. It just doesn’t stop. This has faded from media and even Western Government eyes now, where Turkey has taken the spotlight in addressing this.</p><p>As for-many westerners jumping in , DAESH is the worst existential , “global” menace we have seen in recent history, and massive credit to Kurdish and allied anti DAESH Forces, they are the most experienced, brilliant forces at demolishing this global threat at the root. In this sense we must lay our gratitude for our own safety as a result of the pure hearted martyrs fighting them on all sides. Dying to protect our humanity, all humanity.</p><p>This alone is a powerful act of loyalty and care. For this monumental struggle ,respect and loyalty is more than due.</p><p>For the credibility of the heroism of the collective forces that smashed DAESH, the ones caught alive, they very importantly treated them as prisoners of war, rather than using straight up execution. This says a hell of a lot too on ethics on the surface.Assad would not have done this. I’m certain. The Kurdish and allied forces in Rojava sought justice via what appears as democratic means.</p><p>Pushing for fair attempts at trials. This was a huge undertaking that exhausted resources, and the West did little to help when they should have repatriated their own Jihadis.</p><p>But the risk of POWS can also be a handy weaponised revenge force again.Assad proved this in 2012 by releasing extremist jihadis from prison into Iraq. So for the West or all nations to not take their fighters back pronto, we realised they could be used again, so whose side is the majority West really on then?</p><p>Regardless of good intentions everywhere , the big tragedy in this war is that all sides have been cynically exploited.However the salacious and hideous ,hidden ,covert details we might never really know . Only hypothesise. Crudely.</p><p>But we canʼt forget the heroes, allies and internationalists who fought to the death for all of us from the menace of DAESH and against Assad. All this for the Syrian Revolution, and for the true glimmer of hopeful , plural , peaceful, rights based modern democracy , one day.</p><p>However, as for comrades on the “so called Western Left” it’s correct to say the Syrian war has been the ultimate litmus test and fine filter to see who are ,by extreme ideological inconsistencies,the far right traitors amoung us at worst, or the simply lazy,chauvenistic, seemingly earnest , or kind jam making Granny activists refusing to leave comfortable old rhetoric. It’s the path of least resistance.</p><p>After Syria, amplified by Brexit in the U.K., the ascension of the Assad allied and especially anti Semitic Far Right and Far Left, I don’t see much hope in bridging these multiple divergent and perplexing sides of the left together ever again. The recent impossible U.K. election pit principled left leaning Syrian solidarity activists in the worst position ever, vote for desperately needed end to a decade of class war and social murder in the Labour Party, who have too many Assad supporters, even Srebrenica genocide deniers and genuine anti Semites in the ranks, for socialism needed domestically? Or vote for the isolationist Brexit party that has killed over 130,000 vulnerable British via austerity? The Conservatives had a superficial Anti Assad position, but again did little to nothing to stop the war from carrying on for years, slaughtering 1000’s, or even preventing a mass refugee crisis via early intervention, none of it. As cynical as the Labour Party leadership.</p><p>Its fair to say that we really have entered the era of the mainstreaming of Third Positionism. Red Brown alliances that have already swept Europe by massive force. The Syrian war has changed Europe from a bastion of supposed human rights and liberalism, amplified its brute hypocrisy, and inadvertently spurred on the refugee crisis that provided the tragic trigger for the incredulous rise of the Far Right.The so called ‘Leftist’ Anti interventionist powerful lobby did a lot to disrupt or stop a desperate needed humanitarian intervention in 2012 by NATO backed forces or the UN , because they were too busy citing the disaster of Iraq and Western Imperialism as an example. This very powerful, so called,lefty anti war movement played a huge role in politically stepping in to allow this humanitarian disaster that’s gone on for 8 years now. They do have a tremendous amount of blood on their hands. They have a very powerful PR lobby. To me this is not Left. Anti intervention uses ‘pacifism’ as a cloak to allow atrocities to carry on against individuals by dictators or rogue militias . They are not pacifists. The cynical bystander effect is the polar opposite of the ‘good Samaritan’. Pacifists who support diplomacy instead of war, yes, we understand, however most people support diplomacy before war. It’s not a uniquely noble position. You cannot control violent ideological thugs with ‘Give Peace A Chance’. That’s a lazy platitude to get well meaners off the hook from paying attention to humanitarian intervention or genocide prevention.</p><p>The biggest tragedy is really the loss of a glimmer of hope things will change positively soon and we will again see liberal, secular roots democracy still flourishing in Europe and growing in the Middle East.</p><p>For now, we can only pin our hopes and aspirations on Revolutionary Syrians in exile, the ones left struggling and resisting bravely under oppressive lethal forces, to bring back plural democratic revolution. Perhaps revolutionary Lebanon will succeed in its youthful candour and optimism , and pave the way. We can only hope.</p><p>For the Left, nothing will ever be the same again. Syrian solidarity and the sides in the Syrian war those on the left took, was the ultimate litmus test. The biggest contemporary reveal of darker forces at play.</p><p>The few that did remain on the left who were nuanced, well researched, open minded, flexible and critically aware of bias, or old loyalties suddenly becoming or revealing themselves to become toxic, and counter revolutionary, are the minority these days. Few like to exist in the complex and nuanced grey area of remaining very firm to basic principles or without even a selfish or relativist bias. The few who know conditions change all the time, and how effective propaganda can be. The few are also the first ones to admit being wrong if our supporting sides took a wrong turn, we believe in accountability. Constructive criticism and important discourse for growth. This is a very tough,uncomfortable space to inhabit. However we must keep pushing, because seeing old allies of the left ending up extremely intertwined with far right figures as the leader of the KKK, and autocrats using ‘lefty language/rhetoric ‘ is extremely worrying.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/1*QA_TduHyKU2Tgfj2wW7EMQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*IQJOhvPtDlOFFTvHxsCTQw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/692/1*R374iFnbei4M34w8Upcxbw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/747/1*BKpHn2WeNoeZ7OZZthwjpQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/743/1*wKN6NwdUqGE57PX1GtJPmA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d566848bec01" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>