<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by lizzy rosa on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by lizzy rosa on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lizzyrosa?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 03:29:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lizzyrosa/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Traditions can become laws if allowed]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/traditions-can-become-laws-if-allowed-38f1689b6334?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38f1689b6334</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Nov 2023 11:19:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-08T11:19:23.239Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The psychological inclination to adhere to tradition stems from a deep-seated human need for stability, predictability, and a sense of belonging. Traditions provide a framework that satisfies these needs by offering a continuous link to the past, which can be comforting in a world of change. This comfort, however, can lead to a collective inertia where traditions are upheld not for their current utility but for their historical significance.</p><p>Take, for instance, the progression from respecting the office of the vice president to a monarchical system. Initially, the tradition that the vice president assumes the presidency in the event of the president&#39;s inability to serve is practical; it provides a clear protocol for maintaining government stability. Over time, this practical measure can subtly evolve into an expectation that the vice president is the heir apparent to the presidency. This expectation arises not from a consciously designed system of succession but from a psychological ease with the familiar; it&#39;s simpler and less unsettling for people to support what they know than to explore new options.</p><p>As this expectation becomes ingrained, the tradition may further evolve into the president selecting their successor, akin to anointing a new leader. At this stage, the tradition has subsumed the democratic process, with the psychological comfort of a known successor overshadowing the civic principle of elected leadership. The final step toward monarchy is not a deliberate choice but the end result of a series of small psychological concessions to tradition, each compounding until the system is transformed entirely.</p><p>In journalism, the tradition of not questioning the president stems from a respect for the sanctity of the office and can serve to uphold the decorum of political discourse. However, this tradition, when overemphasized, can extend to a general reticence to question authority figures, solidifying a culture of deference in place of critical inquiry.</p><p>This deference arises from the same psychological trend: abstract concepts like the respect for the office become more important than the accountability of the individuals occupying those offices.</p><p>In both cases, the abstractions of tradition and the office hold sway over individual agency and opinion, reflecting a societal trend where structures and abstract concepts gain primacy over individuals. This is the result of a psychological ease with the familiar and a reluctance to embrace the discomfort that comes with challenging long-standing norms. It demonstrates a preference for the certainty of tradition over the uncertainty of change, a preference that can be manipulated by those in power to maintain and solidify hierarchical structures.</p><p>To counter this trend, it&#39;s critical to foster a societal mindset that values individuals and their agency over the abstractions of tradition and office. This involves cultivating critical thinking and adaptability as cultural virtues, promoting the idea that traditions should serve the people, not the other way around.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38f1689b6334" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Capitalism created monogamy]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/capitalism-created-monogamy-5bf6305b8670?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5bf6305b8670</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Nov 2023 13:04:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-06T13:04:53.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the nascent stages of agricultural society, the generation of surplus presented a fork in the road, leading to a range of social possibilities. Rather than a communal boon, this surplus often catalyzed a shift towards capitalist-ish individualism. Wealth began to be amassed by individuals or families, and this accumulation became a powerful force in shaping societal norms and structures, including those related to familial and romantic relationships.</p><p>Monogamous unions became advantageous within this capitalist-ish framework. They provided a clear and uncomplicated structure for managing wealth and ensuring that property stayed within a given lineage. It’s not that monogamy was the only natural outcome but that it aligned with the environmental pressures of an economy that was beginning to echo capitalist-ish values.</p><p>This relationship between environment and social structure is reminiscent of observations in the animal kingdom. Consider how wolves in captivity exhibit alpha and beta dynamics — a hierarchy not commonly observed in the wild, where resources are less constrained. The captive environment induces a survival mode, leading to the development of rigid hierarchies. Similarly, the artificial environment created by property ownership can warp human relationships, leading to social structures like monogamy, which can be seen as a response to the capitalist-ish imperative to ensure the welfare of one’s progeny within a competitive and uncertain economic landscape.</p><p>In a community-oriented society that values mutual aid and communal stewardship, the social fabric is fundamentally different. With the community at the heart of child-rearing and resource distribution, the pressure to accumulate and pass on individual wealth is greatly diminished, if not rendered obsolete. Property, laws, and the infrastructure of trade and money act as a cultural prison of sorts, reinforcing social structures that are not inherently natural but rather responses to these manufactured pressures. If one were to remove these capitalist-ish pressures — much like returning captive wolves to the wild — one might see a dissolution of the artificially maintained social structures, including monogamy, as community-based practices take precedence, ensuring the survival and well-being of all members, including the progeny, through collective support and responsibility.</p><p>This perspective challenges us to consider how much of our current social fabric is a product of our environment and to imagine how different our relationships and family structures might be in a society free from the capitalist-ish imperatives that shape our choices today.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5bf6305b8670" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Totally Unrecalled: Occupy]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/totally-unrecalled-occupy-16d0ee8b2248?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16d0ee8b2248</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[china]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[occupy-movement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taiwan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Sep 2023 14:58:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-06T15:00:33.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The corporate-owned and monopolized news media industry in the United States plays a significant role in shaping public perception and discourse. When covering current events and foreign affairs, corporate interests consistently take precedence over those of the working class. For instance, we are meant to remember the Occupy movement as a failure, if at all, and are encouraged to limit our view to less radical forms of activism.</p><p>In the USA, the treatment of civil activism and whistleblowing reflects a corporation-first approach to civic participation rather than a people-first one. In the USA, corporately funded lobbyists pass policies written by corporate think tanks to politicians, who often have strong corporate ties. This process is how the majority of the policies are generated, and when whistleblowers and activists demand transparency and accountability from these policy makers they don’t get treated as an ally by the state. The Occupy movement was one of the more radical forms of activism in the USA, tell me again why it has been removed from the activism toolkit?</p><p>Today, when we hear about Taiwan, it’s usually in the context of its relationship with China and is used to portray China’s foreign policy as undemocratic. Taiwan is often depicted as a democracy, and China as a dictatorship, creating a narrative that we should support democratic Taiwan against autocratic China. However, Taiwan’s democracy is treated merely as a token, as delving into the details of their democracy may not align with the corporation-first worldview. We are encouraged to accept them as a symbol of democracy but not to pay attention to aspects such as the success of the Occupy movement there and how their government embodies democratic principles.</p><p>The narratives presented by the corporate news media industry are fragile constructions, carefully manufactured. Our perspective is tightly controlled, with facts selectively promoted to fit a particular narrative, rather than being valued for their intrinsic significance. These facts are often shoehorned into existing narratives when they should be standalone narratives in their own right.</p><p>Taiwan stands out for its commitment to transparent governance principles. Citizens actively participate in policy-making, and government spending is open to public scrutiny. What’s particularly remarkable is that Taiwan has embraced its harshest critics and activists from the Occupy movement, offering them a seat at the decision-making table. The Occupy movement in Taiwan serves as a testament to the country’s dedication to democratic principles. Notably, some of the most prominent activists from the Occupy movement have transitioned into ministerial roles within the government, showcasing Taiwan’s belief in the people’s right to make demands of the government and hold it accountable.</p><p>In the USA, the most prominent activists and whistleblowers are treated as threats (for eg. Chelsea Manning, Edward Snowden, and Julian Assange) who face persecution by the USA government. In contrast, Taiwan’s government has not only listened but also implemented structural changes aligned with the Occupy movement’s goals and invited Audrey Tang into a government role to facilitate doing so. Maybe the real story should revolve around how we can learn from them to become more transparent and accountable, rather than Taiwan merely being a token on a battleground in a propaganda proxy war against China. Examining the governing model of Taiwan would reveal the the success of the Occupy movement and add occupations back into the civil activism toolkit. An outcome which would be great for the working class but not so great for corporate-first organizations.</p><p>Through this corporate self-censorship, they’re stuck between a rock and a hard place. They need to cover the relevant current news which might span any number of topics, and yet they’re unable to cover any topics that criticize their role in society at a depth that would reveal those realities. As a result, for as long as the narrative that the Occupy movement is a failed strategy is accepted by the audience… there’s no way the corporate news industry would open the pandora’s box of reintroducing it as a viable tactic to the zeitgeist by highlighting the its success in Taiwan. And thus they are forced to cover the topic as it pertains to current events be censor themselves from going into too much details about the very topics they’re covering.</p><p>In our own activism, it’s essential to challenge the mainstream narrative and recognize that Occupy movements, far from being failures, hold the potential to disrupt established power dynamics and promote a more equitable future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16d0ee8b2248" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is consciousness?]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/what-is-consciousness-b372221edebc?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b372221edebc</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Oct 2020 10:24:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-01T10:27:17.169Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What is consciousness?</p><p>Consciousness is an instrument, where concepts are chords, thoughts are notes and neurons are the strings.</p><p>This also applies to multiple person consciousness, if all of you are tuned to the same scale and play as one instrument the thoughts come out in one key but if you have multiple sub-instruments they could have different tuning or play different chords at the same time.</p><p>So singular consciousness is just having all of the sub-instruments so well in harmony that they&#39;re indistinguishable from each other.</p><p>It&#39;s possible for one instrument to play multiple chords at the same time too (like multitasking or having two thoughts at once as a singular consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b372221edebc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An argument for a more intuitive understanding of collectivism and individualism]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/an-argument-for-a-more-intuitive-understanding-of-collectivism-and-individualism-6425a0a5e357?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6425a0a5e357</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Aug 2020 23:44:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-26T23:44:59.077Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>An argument for a more intuitive understanding of collectivism and individualism</p><p>People already have definitions for individualism and collectivism but are these definitions actually helpful, do they really represent the words they&#39;re attached to, or like &quot;communist Russia&quot; or &quot;libertarian capitalists&quot; have the definitions become the opposite of what the labels imply.</p><p>Just as how no state could ever be communist (because communism is a classless and stateless society), and just how capitalism is the least libertarian economic model humanity has ever devised (being forced to serve others or die isn&#39;t freedom), so too I would suggest that the current usage of collectivism and individualism are entirely opposite of what those names aspires to. The traditional usage of these terms is counter intuitive, and it need not be so.</p><p>In my opinion collectivism should be an ideology where the collective is at its best, the most healthy and strong state a collective could possibly be. A collectivist collective should be the most enjoyable collective to participate in, it should have perfected the art of coming together. It should be self improving, constantly evolving to embrace the things that would make it a better collective to be a part of, and getting rid of ideas that hold the collective back. And most importantly, not a collective where an individual can exercise domination or authority over another individual, what kind of collective would that be, why would anyone want to be part of that kind of collective unless dominating other individuals is what they want to do.</p><p>And as for individualism, well it can&#39;t also be about collectivism, it can&#39;t be an ideology aimed at creating the best collective possible because if it were then it would make more sense to call it collectivism not individualism. No, the most fitting society to be called individualist would be one were individuals can individually pursue their goals without considering if their actions are harming or helping a collective. Individualism should describe an ideology where people live as islands disconnected from each other so that they don&#39;t have to take responsibility for the health of the collective or participate in collective decision making. The more insulated people are from each other the more individualist the society would be.</p><p>And so in my opinion it makes no sense to call something like a state or any hierarchal organization collectivist, doing so would imply that hierarchy is the strongest form a collective could take, which is absurd, how could a society where some individuals dominate others be the best possible configuration for a collective to be in.</p><p>Similarly it makes no sense to call any kind of anarchism individualist, anarchism makes no room for any individual to dominate another within its collectives, it doesn&#39;t aim for a society of silos where the weak are not the concern of the strong. No anarchism sees the best possible form for individuals to be one where they are connected to each other, where collective decision making is specifically desired so that none among us are vulnerable to domination because seeing others dominated is abhorrent to us. We don&#39;t want to tolerate domination, we don&#39;t see domination as strong nor healthy, but rather we see it as a flaw and disease. We see some individuals being able to harm others as a failure of the collective it occurs in and a collective which allows it to be less h healthy, less strong, and less desirable than one that doesn&#39;t.</p><p>No, there&#39;s nothing individualist about anarchism, and anarchists have no need to avoid the label collectivism. Because collectivism, if we use it to refer to the optimization of collective arrangements already gives the individuals within it maximum agency and minimum domination. An optimized collective is the strongest form for a collective to exist in and normalized domination is a suboptimal arrangement for a collective have.</p><p>I would suggest that capitalism fat better suits the label of individualism. Under capitalism the collective only exists to allow some individuals to dominate other individuals, it welcomes hierarchy because it gives individuals justification not to consider the health of the collective but rather where they personally fit in it&#39;s hierarchy. And so long as you&#39;re on an upward trajectory within that hierarchy you&#39;re seen as successful. Under capitalism an individual rising in power with respect to their peers is considered praiseworthy. And if you are born or get near to the top of the hierarchy you&#39;ll even be worshipped for it, you&#39;ll become a celebrity, and be given even more riches and be considered an example of individual excellence no matter how much help from the collective it took to get their nor how many other individuals you pushed down on your way up. Individuals under capitalism are empowered at the expense of the collective good. Quite a good fit for the term individualism in my opinion.</p><p>But what about authoritarian ideologies which denounce the excesses of capitalism, are they actually collectivist as they claim to be. Is &quot;the collective&quot; (state/cause) really placed above the individual or is that just the farce they like to entertain. And if they were telling the truth why would the individual being subjugate to the collective actually be considered a good form of collectivism. If optimizing for collective health were really their concern they would have to evolve into a non-authoritarian arrangement because doing so would make the collective stronger and healthier. There would be no reason to hold on to hierarchy when it harms the collective health.</p><p>No, we don&#39;t live in a world where abstract concepts come to life and enforce their will on us. If &quot;the collective&quot; is subjugating an individual there&#39;s no incorporeal force dominating them, rather it is other individuals doing the domination. While they may claim to act on behalf of the abstraction we know that it&#39;s still their own choice to make the domination occur. If there were no individuals willing to act as avatars of the abstraction the abstraction would not have any effect on anyone. And so it really is just a charade, individuals choosing to dominate other individuals using the abstraction of the collective as their weapon, not the other way around. And those welding the power to dominate other individuals are still considered successful, the individuals who are leaders of these hierarchies are still treated as celebrities, if not gods.</p><p>And so in those societies it&#39;s actually the collective who serves individuals not the other way around as they claim. And whichever individuals have wormed their way to the top of the hierarchy and into positions of authority get to decide what&#39;s best for the collective. And they dedicate themselves to ensuring that the hierarchy persists so that they don&#39;t lose that ability to dominate others. Despite it being harmful to the collective they require loyalty to the hierarchy they&#39;ve climbed to the to of, not because the hierarchy is good for the collective, on the contrary it weakens the collective, but because they individually benefit from it.</p><p>It&#39;s just individualism all over again. But instead of the physical bank accounts determing which individuals get to be the dominators it&#39;s the social capital of the individuals who have gotten rich in the esteem (or fear) of others that get to be the dominators. In those cases the collective arrangement serves merely as a front to enable those powerful individuals within them to oppress the weak individuals, even at the expense of the collective health, a suboptimal arrangement if you cared about the strength of the collective.</p><p>So in conclusion, hierarchy is undoubtedly the core foundation of individualism, and non-hierarchy the core foundation of collectivism. And by trying to use those words the other way around you only increases confusion and cognitive dissonance for those who want to understand these phenoma,even if the traditional use of those words did so. This world is an absolute mess and loyalty to the pre-existing framing and usage of words is partly to blame for how we got here. If we want to improve society we should also declutter our language, instead of calling ourselves individualists because our favorite authors have been called that we should use definitions that are intuitive and simple to parse, and be unafraid to point out that our predecessors were not wording things three best way. And we certainly shouldn&#39;t give a term like collectivism over to the people who clearly just want to use it to further their own individual goals at the expense of the collective. Our own individual goals as anarchists should be to optimize for collective arrangements and to oppose all hierarchies and the individual on individual violence they exists to facilitate.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6425a0a5e357" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[what is means to be left wing]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/what-is-means-to-be-left-wing-d0653e93815f?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0653e93815f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Aug 2020 15:34:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-25T15:39:18.243Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>what it means to be left wing</h3><p>Unfortunately (for me) my opinions seem to be quite unpopular, but I don’t hold them absently, and so I’d like to explain and argue them if anyone’s interested. If you want to know where I’m coming from, my favourite authors are stirner, kropokin, and saul newman, now, let me get to the point…</p><p>It’s my belief that the left/right dichotomy can be helpful, but only if there’s a meaningful distinction between the two, if we’re going to say things like “such and such is left wing” and “such and such is right wing” then those things need to be dissimilar to their opposite label, for example, if we are going to say that capitalism is right wing, then we need to also say that nothing capitalist is left wing, because if something can be both capitalist and left wing then what’s the point of calling capitalism right wing. So it’s fairly easy to then categorize something like social democracy or state capitalism as right wing, they both have a state, they both have capitalism in some form or another, and while they might be closer to “center right” than to “far right” (and so be left in comparison to say neoliberalism or open fascism) it doesn’t make them actually left wing.</p><p>Similarly it’s fairly easy then to say that socialism is left wing, but then the socialism we’re talking about must also not be capitalist in nature, because if you are calling something capitalist in nature socialism then what is the point of calling it socialism, why imply it’s something entirely different when it’s just capitalism repackaged, so no, social democracy and state capitalism are not socialism, no matter how many times they proclaim themselves to be such, they simply cannot be, not if we want the word to indicate something apart from capitalism, either socialism is anti-capitalist or it’s not, i’d argue it makes no sense at all to call socialism pro-capitalist, so politics that still contain within them the core principles of capitalism cannot also be socialist.</p><p>Socialism must be anti-capitalist, and so it must not be social democracy or state capitalism. Of course defenders of social democracy or state capitalism might take offense to being called right wing, in their minds neoliberalism and open fascism are right wing, how dare we lump them into the same box. Of course, lumping them into the same box is actually a good thing, because it helps us to differentiate them from other ideologies, their economic models are fully compatible with capitalism, that’s why a social democratic country, or a state capitalism country, can both have international trade with a fascist state or a neoliberal state, their economies are so compatible they can literally transact with each other as part of one larger global economy. A socialist economy would be thoroughly incompatible with a capitalist economy, you wouldn’t be able to trade with each other, you would entirely different value systems, entirely different motivations for production.</p><p>So far all I’ve said is quite ordinary, I’ve come across many people who share those views, I wouldn’t call it controversial at all, so if you’ve already found yourself outraged then please don’t read any more as I’m about to offend you even further. Now my insistence that socialism and capitalism be so different from each other as to be incompatible with each other gives us an easy way to separate left from right, left being socialist and anti-capitalist in nature, and right being capitalist and anti-socialist in nature.</p><p>But what is this “nature” of capitalism or anti-capitalism, it’s not just an appeal to nature but a shorthand for describing the emergent patterns that arise from an entirely different mode of operation, the environment that’s created when a certain way of engaging in economic activity is performed in massive scales. And the mode of operation is most clearly distinguished when it comes to production, in other words, the mode of production, this comes to what each individual person’s motivations are for production, what is that triggers their choice to take an economic action, when it comes to capitalism the motivation is exchange, you are producing goods or services to exchange them for either other goods or services or for some kind of value proxy (like money, IOUs, vouchers etc), and so this predetermines the mode of distribution and consumption as well, because after being produced a good or service must be distributed in such a way that there is such an exchange, and consumption must also be gatekept behind some kind of exchange, so that the value chain can come back to the producer and they get compensation for the thing they produced. It all fits together and self-reinforces, a producer within an economy based on exchange mode production cannot go off and start producing things and NOT get anything in exchange, how will they then be able to get the things they need, everywhere else they go will be expecting an exchange for goods, so if they did not get any exchange for their own goods they’ve got nothing to trade / exchange, if they chose to produce without exchange they wouldn’t be able to exchange for new raw materials too, and so their productive capacity will come grinding to a halt.</p><p>likewise no distributor / retailer can decide on a whim to no longer offer their goods for exchange but rather to give them away exchange-free, while we might applaud their altruism once they run out of stock they will need to close down as they won’t be able to replenish their stock without anything to exchange for it, all the producers will be demanding exchange and they won’t have anything to exchange for. They are just as locked into the exchange mode as the producer.</p><p>And this is where things get rather controversial, because if you identify the exchange mode as the fundamental principle underlying capitalism, then any other economic model which relies on the exchange mode of production / distribution cannot be said to be different enough from capitalism as to be anti-capitalist, thus also not being socialist, and thus also not being left wing. And that means an ideology (for example mutualism), or any other ideology which proposes an economy with markets, must be considered both capitalist in nature and right wing. This also means primitivists who want to perhaps abolish currency, maybe even markets, are still not free from exchange, sure you have less institutional power behind your exchange economy, but people still wake up in the morning and decide to go to work because they envision for themselves being able to trade (read EXCHANGE) something they produce to get something else they don’t have, the driving force of even a primitve trade based economy is still exchange, is still going to exclude the potential of other modes of production.</p><p>So if we’re going to call anything leftist, socialist, or anarchist for that matter, there must be a new NON-EXCHANGE mode of production accompanying it. This is not my idea by the way, and the proposed mode of production under socialism has been called “production for use” by other philosophers. But that doesn’t really clarify things because people still consider something they exchanged to obtain useful. So if we are going to call this alternative mode of production “for use” it needs to be understood that the “for use” is implying “ONLY for use” or to be more specific “for use and NOT for exchange”.</p><p>And just like how the exchange mode of production is self-reinforcing and makes no room for any other mode of production or distribution, so the for-use production mode has no room for exchange, exchange undermines it at the retail end and is obsolete at the production end. The producer can only produce “for use” if the retailers are also distributing “for use”, because when you produce something without getting anything in exchange for it, you’ll need your own needs, the things you want to consume, to be given to you without exchange as well. And that way the value chain from start to finish contains no exchange anywhere along it. So any raw materials you might need to keep production going are given to you without exchange, enabling you to continue producing things, that you then can give away without exchange as well because when you go to the store to get your own needs met there is no exchange demanded of you either. And if one producer within a for-use economy tries to gatekeep their production behind exchange people will simply go to a different producer who isn’t doing that, knowing that the raw materials were given without exchange you identify the producer trying to profit as a bad faith actor, and if one retailer tries to gatekeep distribution behind exchange, knowing that everything they recieved was given for free without any need for exchange, you would just go to a different retailer, and identify the profiteer as a bad faith actor. An entirely self-reinforcing economic mode of production.</p><p>And could these economies ever interact with each other? Absolutely not. The capitalist exchange-mode economy demanding an exchange for trade will be parasitic to the socialist for-use-mode economy, as the for-use economy will only know how to offer things for free and the for-exchange economy will only know how to offer things for exchange, and if you engaged in trade you would simply be a free resource for the capitalist economy to exploit. So, a socialist economy, a left wing economy, cannot have markets, cannot have currency, and cannot even have trade (as an economic action, you can still trade pokemon cards with your friend — just not sell them or trade on a market).</p><p>It’s my personal opinion that this distinction needs to be emphasized far more, how are we meant to build support for a socialist for-use economy if half the people we allow to call themselves socialist are advocating for some kind of for-exchange economy (like social democrats, state capitalists, or mutualists), we can admit that they are closer to socialism than neoliberalism or neofeudalism, but being closer to something doesn’t make you that thing, and the dividing line needs to be much more distinct, so that the concept of socialism becomes tied to for-use economics, we need to reappropriate the term socialism from those advocating for markets or states, and reappropriate the term left from those advocating for a society where you go to work to get paid, instead of because you want to give back to society for free.</p><p>If you’d like to read this same basic argument but made from an entirely different perspective (a historical one, mind you), the following article served as my inspiration for coming to these conclusions, feel free to debate with me but I’d appreciate if people don’t make personal attacks simply because my opinions are outrageous to them, despite me going to great lengths to spell things out simply enough, if you’re outraged then channel that anger into an attack on my points, not me as a person. thank you for coming to me ted talk. <a href="https://libcom.org/library/how-socialism-can-organise-production-without-money-adam-buick-pieter-lawrence">https://libcom.org/library/how-socialism-can-organise-production-without-money-adam-buick-pieter-lawrence</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0653e93815f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[an open letter to Biden supporters]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/an-open-letter-to-biden-supporters-1e98a9a91cf7?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e98a9a91cf7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 May 2020 14:05:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-25T14:05:15.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>the problem with your narrative is that it’s very short-sighted, which means the capitalist class who are playing the long con can keep you from rebelling against the whole game, it’s not self defense to vote for Biden because Biden is just the good cop in the good cop, bad cop routine, either way you’re getting screwed, what would be self-defense would be to get away from the 2 party system, while Biden might be “short term harm reduction” he represents a long term increase in harm. Now voting for trump would be even worse, and not voting would also be useless, but, you should definitely vote for a 3rd party if you care about harm reduction, don’t let the short-sighted analysis scope of only one election lead you, think longer term, if you vote 3rd party now yes you will lose to Trump, but you will take a step towards a third option. Wanting Trump to lose isn’t going to make it happen, Biden will likely lose to Trump even if people try to hold their nose and vote for Biden because Biden is just way too repulsive to way too many people, calling people non-black if they have any questions about him, telling people that they are fools if they believe women, he literally cannot win, and the oligarchs are scripting it all, this whole video is playing their game, Biden’s script is “virtue signal but lose due to your corrupt record” and Trump’s script is “anti-virtue signal and win by fake news”, that’s why we had Russiagate, the intelligence agencies put out false information to get liberals to think Russia interfered in the election so that they didn’t have to own up to the fact that Hillary (and Biden’s) ideology is why she lost, they want to make sure people didn’t learn so they could push another candidate with all her same flaws, so that new candidate will lose again. So talking about harm reduction without also talking about how it plays in to the long term, that over many many years of “voting the lesser of two evils” your new “normal” is extremely more evil than it was at the start and you only have more and more evil ahead of you, they give people the opportunity to slow the deteriation down so that they don’t try to stop it entirely, it’s a classic manipulation / abuse tactic and it works, that’s why the cops have a whole routine about it, it’s designed to get people to deny their long term best interests to stop short term abuse, and being “more heavily effected” by Trump’s policies doesn’t give people a free pass to ignore what voting the lesser evil does in the long term, every election you wait before breaking that paradigm is 4 more years IN TOTAL that you live in dystopian hellscape, you’re giving yourself a small amount of breathing room in order to stay trapped in a sunken ship instead of swimming to the surface. If Biden wins it would be even worse because it would then normalize his policies, like, vetoing universal policies including m4a, student loan debt, etc. which is designed to make those policies fail in the long run, where’s Trump would make those alternatives much more likely to be fought for. Now, I’m not saying vote for Trump because that is also chaining you to the two party paradigm, but for the love of the future of our species, vote for a 3rd party. Start to build a movement outside of the democratic party or you’ll continually see it sacrificed to the gods of lesser evilism. if you think Trump is the worse it gets, buckle up your seatbelt, especially if Biden wins, if Biden wins you’ll get Trump 2.0 next, because Biden architected all the policies that got us Trump 1.0 (crime bill, wall st getting all the power etc), and Trump 2.0 will be competent, maybe even have a clean record, and will offer people things like m4a but with the compromise of nationalism, and people will go for it en masse, so really, voting for Biden is like being a lamb getting led to the slaughter, 4 more years of Trump will be hell, but you still have options, for starters, you can impeach the f* out of him, and impeach Pence too, keep impeaching until you get someone who isn’t super corrupt and fascist, you can take to the streets (pulse riots) and make sure it happens, but you won’t because you’ve bought into the lie that only elections can change leadership, and so you rob yourself of any other strategy. no. vote 3rd party, and then STILL try to beat Trump, through promoting the 3rd party, through strikes, through a movement to impeach. The reality is you can’t do that, because you don’t have enough support for social justice to actually get Trump out, because it’s easier to whine and pick the lesser bully than to stand up and fight back.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e98a9a91cf7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[the future of south africa]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/the-future-of-south-africa-622c1ee08eed?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/622c1ee08eed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Mar 2019 20:27:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-27T20:27:22.986Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t-FvOtfBn89HXzsktEoY9g.jpeg" /><figcaption>wakanda (but imagine it in south africa for a moment please)</figcaption></figure><p>Our future does depend on what we do now, very cliche, but still very true.</p><p>But let’s be honest, even if we did everything right and achieved a libertarian socialist society it would not last very long unless the global climate were tolerant enough for it.</p><p>If you’re like me your mind is swimming in grandiose dreams of living your best life free from all oppression, to imagine what the world would be like if state and capitalism were a thing of the passed. And i believe having these dreams is actually a necessary ingredient in achieving that goal it’s not enough on it’s own.</p><p>Now we can’t exactly hold back either, we should be compelled by the suffering we see around us to strive for it to end as soon as possible.</p><p>And so that’s why I think we need to always remember the position we are in when it comes to global imperialism because it is an antidote to nationalism. We just aren’t a big enough fish for anything we do here to last if the imperial states do not approve of it. Forgetting this can cause people to preach those grandiose dreams as if they can be achieved here in isolation. It’s sobering to consider that your life may hang by a thread that is held by people on the other side of the planet, in a place where you can’t participate in elections and have very little ability to effect change.</p><p>The way I see it the best way to approach this would be for us to get as close as we can to the boundary of their approval first, and then choose which things we cross that boundary on very strategically so as not to provoke a retaliation before our movement can become our popular culture which has at least some permanence.</p><p>So if I’m going to suggest that there is some position where we could move to and still be safe from imperial punishment what would that be?</p><p>Well, for starters, anything that has popular support in the imperial states is automatically safe for us because it would be a pretty bad look if they punished us for doing things that they already do or are very close to doing, perhaps something like universal national healthcare would be an example of that.</p><p>What about electoral reform, moving beyond elections is going to be treated as hostile immediately, but strengthening how we do our democracy is not going to cause a stir. Many countries have already done this and not had any trouble about it. So what kinds of electoral reforms can we do, well we can have public campaign financing, as in each person gets a R100 voucher to give to any party they want (they cant spend it themselves) and then parties are not allowed to take donations in any other way. We could have ranked choice voting where you vote for your top 3 in order and what this does is if your first pick gets way too few votes to win they will instead choose your second pick, same story, then third pick, and so what this lets you do is put 2 very small parties first and then the main vote you would normally have placed for strategic reasons third, and this gives those smaller parties a much better chance of winning and will boost their numbers as you can release the stats of how many of their votes were first pick, second, third etc. Just make elections more democratic.</p><p>We can do publicly funded education.</p><p>We can do universal basic income (it pays for itself, they did the maths).</p><p>We can do land reform if the land is not taken from private citizens, if it is then this is going to trigger punishment, it is still absolutely justified in the right situations but it is important to note that this is not something the imperial powers have traditionally tolerated.</p><p>We can do renewable energy and address our carbon emissions.</p><p>We can industrialise, become more of a manufacturing and tech based economy than an export economy.</p><p>Tax reforms that ease up on the poor but make it way harder for the rich to hide from paying their taxes. Close as many loop holes as you can.</p><p>We can have very strong unions.</p><p>We can legalise all drugs.</p><p>We can do prison reform.</p><p>We can have laws that protect net neutrality and against state surveillance.</p><p>We should have the freedom to criticise the state and report on anything the state or corporations do, all journalists, reporters and news sites should be non-profit organisations, it’s 2019 are we still going to pretend profit and journalism are a good combination? There is never a good reason to try to monetise what to report. Perhaps each community should have a journalist election along with their municipal election and whoever wins the journalist election gets a respectable income from the state as part of our civil apparatus. This will allow us to have as many journalists as there are municipalities plus whoever else does it out of charity, at the expense of 1 salary per municipality, an investment that is so small we would be foolish not to make it. Lets see the politicians and corporations try to get up to their tricks when there’s a reporter in every place they go.</p><p>We can make it a lot harder to do corruption by advocating for a more transparent system, one that comes to mind is Taiwan&#39;s under the architecture of Audrey Tang they have an open source government platform that handles open data as well as open social media interactions about policy ideas before those ideas are even considered for legislation (the people become the lobbyists through this platform), whenever a term ends and someone is leaving a position and someone else is taking it over, there is no handover between them because all of the relevant information for their job is present in the platform, nothing can be done in secret, and the data is open to the public. This kind of system would have made state capture impossible. And we can implement it here. It’s already existing and working in Taiwan. Google Audrey Tang and watch one of her talks. She is one of my favourite anarchists, yep, anarchists can be members of the executive cabinet of a state.</p><p>We can regulate environmental and health impacts of corporations to clean up our air, water, oceans, land, towns, cities, schools, communities, putting the life and health of the environment and its inhabitants above that of reckless corporate behaviour.</p><p>Now these are all things that imperial states have tolerated. I think it is foolish to fight for things that will trigger a punitive response from them if we haven’t even done the things they will permit. So, that can be our official platform, if we were to be running a party on lets fix as much as we can without pissing off mom and dad.</p><p>Now we don’t have to run our own party, we could, it might make some of our favourite authors turn in their grave, but it is probably a lot easier to form a specific organisation of anarchists (look up especifismo anarchism) that can advocate for that platform openly, perhaps run in elections just for advertising but not to win.</p><p>Now of course the problems are far bigger than what these things can solve, and it is not good enough to treat it as the goal, however, our path towards the goal should cross through these lands if we want to optimise the relief we can give people without being treated like Venezuela.</p><p>But it’s worth mentioning what comes next, where does the path lead after it’s won all the victories it can without challenging the imperial states to an ideological war?</p><p>There’s a few things I think we can advocate for that will both bring us even closer to a libertarian socialist society but also make it harder for the ground to be lost should an imperial punishment come our way.</p><p>For example…</p><p>With a strengthened electoral system we could go further, give communities more and more say over the laws that govern them, who enforces those laws, how they enforce them and what the punishment is, without allowing them to do worse than is done now of course, but to build community autonomy while ensuring criminal justice reform in said communities.</p><p>We can give legal protections and even things like tax incentives or grants to people who want to produce for use instead of for exchange. What that means is people who are not making things at their job so that those things can be sold for money, but they are making them to be distributed directly to people who need them. While I think it’s important that those things be done by communities choosing to cooperate and pool their resources rather than being funded by the state which allows the state to maintain a say in it, but the state can certainly encourage them to flourish through tax exemption or similar policies.</p><p>We can push for more worker control of the means of production, giving people the tools they need to make things or provide services themselves or themselves and their colleagues rather than for a boss. Boosting union power and democratising of their government as you forge them together into a syndicate.</p><p>We can build architecture that facilitates community building, freedom of movement, utility and invest in infrastructure like public transport so that opportunities open up for people.</p><p>Now these are all politics at the national scale, and this stuff is very important, it’s important to educate the public on why these things are needed, how they would work, how we could implement them here, it is gonna take a lot of figuring out by people before it’s something the public can grasp, there’s a lot of work to do comrades, and we aren’t going to live those fantastic dreams unless we do the work, things go our way globally, AND we also have a lot to do locally around us in our communities. And we need all of these things to happen at the same time, global tolerance of socialism, national popular support for it, and local implementation of it.</p><p>So what is local implementation of socialism, what does that mean, how can socialism happen at a scale smaller than national you may be wondering?</p><p>Well, there was an idea i alluded to earlier of how a journalist who isnt reporting for profit allows them to call out corruption and so actually give us a way of catching them in the act and this both exposes the fallibility of the state and allows for some amount of harm reduction as there can be some justice and reparations sought.</p><p>In a similar way someone who is providing a service or producing a product if they had their salary taken care of by a community fund for example, let’s say 1% of all your municipal taxes goes into funding as many people as you can afford to with that, and that’s how many seats people can elect others onto to earn this funding, with the stipulation that they stay non-profit to continue receiving it. This would allow them to use their labour, skill, knowledge, and time, to offer their services or products to the community. If communities want to vote for a co-op they could elect everyone in the co-op and have the whole co-op working for the community, you might have bylaws like that a co-op needs at least 3 members to gain additional funding for the co-op itself, perhaps allowing it to use surplus community funds to pay for running costs so that the co-op can fully dedicate itself to the community instead of needing to also work for commercial income to keep afloat. And so if you hire a fencing co-op one year but everyone has a new fence already the next year maybe you vote for a construction crew who can build you a new library using extra community funds to pay for the resources, and with those who got elected bearing responsibility in the eyes of the public so if they do not serve the community faithfully they are also tarnishing their reputation in that community going forward so this should incentive real effort. You might also have people donating via charity to workers or co-ops who are providing free services but were not elected if they want to increase what services or products they can have access to. This empowers the communities because they get to decide what they want done, who does it, and the cost of it is coming from their own taxes (that should not be raised for this). And when this model, of people’s needs being met allowing them to enrich their community so much more catches on, people may be far more receptive to an entire economy based on these actions and relying on the networking between ourselves to cover each other’s needs. So this is a start towards the very thing we are trying to end at and this practice can become beloved by communities such that even an imperial retaliation wouldn&#39;t convince them it’s a bad idea.</p><p>Once you have enough people offering serices or goods for free in this manner and they are networking together, you might achieve a point of self-sufficiency, if you can achieve this protect it, like starting a fire, you now have the smallest flame, if protected and fed it could burn the entire forrest of oppression down. As it grows it moves people out of capitalism.</p><p>I think when you look at just how many things may need to be done before an entire society was ready to go libertarian socialist, I think any talk of immediate revolution aught to be strongly opposed, yes we yearn to break our chains but we are first adopters of this new technology called socialism, and overcome with love for it we might forget that to others it is still foreign, not understood or experienced, you could hype up your platform to such a degree that the populace impulsively chooses to abandon their better judgements and hand control to people promising to do these things, but those things never materialise fast enough if it all, because they are in opposition to the accumulation of political, social, and material capital. So when the fervour wears off and people notice things aren’t what they were promised they’ll be eager to devote themselves to the next champion offering to rewind things back to how they were. “Better the evil you know” in their hearts. What we want is for people to be so thoroughly convinced with not only the validity of these policies but the practical possibilities of them, that they will be the ones demanding to be taken forward not backward, the politicians will lag behind the public when the public actually wants these things, and until they want these things our job should be teaching them and showing them these things so that they become familiar with them, understand them, and then are actually able to appreciate them. We are not marketers, we are educators.</p><p>Someone who was marketed into revolution can be marketed into counter-revolution, but people who are educated will never stop trying to achieve it, there will be no counter-revolution if you got to where you are because your society is so thoroughly aware of the specific reasons why that it benefits them.</p><p>However, before I finish I also want to mention that even as educators we will face opposition. The conservatism, fascism, and social dominance that many powerful people have will cause them to oppose even these non-violent stages of revolution. We should be providing people a counter narrative to their smearing. And our counter narrative should be based on factual evidence not fake news. Let the people who are pulling the fake news be exposed because we are putting the real news out there. And when it comes to countering their attacks, they will often be ideological or attempting to gaslight people. We should become masters of calling their bullshit, but that means we need to be masters at calling our own bullshit first. We need to work at getting rid of every kind of prejudice, because this society we are working towards that is classless is going to require everybody to do that work and expel their harmful values, beliefs, intolerances, prejudices or loyalties as much as they can so that we aren’t constantly in conflict with everyone over everything as soon as we gain our freedom. Sometimes the best way to resolve these conflicts of interest between ethics and a loyalty is to redefine the thing we are being loyal too. For example, if you are currently someone who eats animals and are very attached to doing that forever more, now this is not ok because animals have feelings and shouldn&#39;t exist just to die for us, but it might be an easier way to resolve the conflict if we invest in vegan friendly meat alternatives and switch over all our consumption to that, get it good enough, and move passed killing billions of animals just to meet our hunger. But similar loopholes might be found in your own beliefs, for example your religion, that allow you to keep both your commitment to ethical interactions and your religion. For example if a christian were to understand Jesus’s teaching about loving others to mean doing the things that will help others and show them love through practical means, then accepting queer and LGBT people as they are is the easiest call in the universe, they are no different from the straights and accepting them as they want to be accepted is what Jesus would do. We need a transformation of our traditions.</p><p>So I guess the bottom line is, there is a lot of work to do, and I wouldn’t be writing this unless I thought that the effort would be worth it. In fact I believe that every step we take in this direction is a net positive for pretty much the entire universe.</p><p><em>thanks for reading, make sure you check out my youtube if you liked this: </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/erincollective">https://www.youtube.com/c/erincollective</a></p><p><em>if you want to read something else i wrote </em><a href="https://medium.com/@erincollective/genre-gender-what-is-it-eda9a6d5460a"><em>try this post on gender</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=622c1ee08eed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[socialism and capitalism, a comparison]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/socialism-and-capitalism-a-comparison-ab2f44f690bb?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab2f44f690bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[production-for-use]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Jun 2018 06:44:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-11T06:44:14.405Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>many things have been said about economies, capitalist, socialist, other, most of them lies. some of them ideological positions, some definitions or imaginings of what socialism or capitalism is. some of it is correct though, however the correct things aren’t said as often. but what i want to do is take an almost anecdotal approach to capitalism where instead of trying to describe it based on the ideas or descriptions that others use i’m just going to describe it the way it looks to me. if that happens to be the same as what someone else thinks that’s great.</p><p>currently most of the world operates within the context of capitalism, there would be much less reason to discuss this stuff if capitalism worked, but it’s my opinion that it doesn’t work. as far as i can tell the system that would work is called socialism. but because everybody has a different idea of what those things are (including people with PHDs etc… wow) i’m just going to re-explain them so that even if what i’m describing isn’t actually capitalism or socialism at least you’ll understand what it is about the current system that i think should be different in a future and better system.</p><p>again as most of the world operates under capitalism we all have some idea of what it is, so let me begin by explaining socialism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w0FpNZju5eh4XvT4EuKISA.png" /></figure><h3>socialism</h3><p>when talking about politics the term socialism implies that the driving force of the economy is social, in contrast to capitalism which has a driving force of capital. but what does it mean for an economy to have a driving force of that’s social? if you’re anything like me that isn’t something you can necessarily imagine, i mean i wasn’t able to no matter how hard i tried. it was only when i came across <a href="https://libcom.org/library/how-socialism-can-organise-production-without-money-adam-buick-pieter-lawrence">this article</a> that i realized what it meant. however that article is pretty intense and it took me a lot of time and effort trying to learn about this stuff before i was able to make sense of it. i’ll try to describe it for you as best i can.</p><p>so on trying to come up with what a “socially” driven economy would look like many people have come up with ideas that kinda sorta fit the description and some of those ideas when put into practice were fairly problematic. so i think the important thing should be to agree on what this future model actually is before we implement any of the existing proposals. in my opinion the best proposal is for the economy to continue to be supply and demand based but that all of the supply be done voluntarily without any exchange or trade, simply done because there is a need.</p><p>how does that result in an economy that is socially driven? well, let’s take a look at the diagram above but this time as a production line from raw material to end consumer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1IaJpsP_GGiBCrHwrBlcHA.png" /></figure><p>so let’s start off with the person holding a basket all the way on the right, there’s some or other good they want from the store, maybe they’re looking for a sodi pop. so in order for there to be any chance of a sodi pop actually being there someone would have needed to put it there. and for someone to put it there someone would have needed to make it. and whoever made it needed to get their ingredients from someone who harvested them. and ultimately everything we can make comes from the planet we live on.</p><p>so, in a society where people don’t care about sodi pops or advanced medical technology, or advanced electronics, or more ecological manufacturing processes this model makes no sense. why would people put in all that effort if they’re not getting anything out of it. but socialism isn’t for people who are happy with the current state of affairs nor is it for people who want things to regress into lower levels of human ability / welfare. socialism is for people who want to have nice things, they want to get medical treatment when they’re ill, they want to be able to get an education, and to contribute positively to society, to be rewarded for their labor and to enjoy the labor of others. if you have a society that wants that, then you socialism becomes an option and a tempting one at that.</p><p>the phrase that has been used to describe this is “to each according to their need / desire, from each according to their ability / will”, while some versions of that phrase omit the “desire” and “will”, i’ve included them because we are discussing a society which sees value in this arrangement and so there will be a desire and will to meet people’s needs with your abilities. there isn’t some magic trick that will make people go to work under socialism, it’s simply a society that has chosen to go to work if they’re able in order to enrich everyone’s lives overall through the abundance we can create. it is a society that has chosen to cooperate instead of compete.</p><p>people want the (1) items to take place because it results in a comfortable and enjoyable society, so they choose to contribute (4) for free, and then the existence of (1) itself is the reward for that. of course they could also produce things for themselves and that too is rewarding.</p><p>we also want (2) to be used responsibly so that future generations enjoy similar comforts so we should have some people (3) making sure that our use of resources is sustainable and eventually fully renewable.</p><p>there are many other benefits to this kind of society, for starters you don’t need bosses or governments, there is no poverty and thus most likely no crime, you never have to pay for anything ever again. you can retire whenever you want or change careers entirely and won’t risk losing your ability to meet your needs in the process.</p><p>the reason this system does not already exist is because many people don’t understand or agree with it, and many others prefer to live in a competitive environment, or they are afraid of challenging the current powers who are ensuring that the current system is adhered to. it isn’t something that is going to happen by accident, those factories there, the land that the resources are gathered from, the store, all of those things are currently under control and protection of corporate and state agents. while we can agree that is is superior that doesn’t make it any easier to achieve.</p><p>however, the things that we can do need to be as effective as possible and so agreeing on what it is we are working towards should increase the ability we have to try and reach it. but in order to understand why the current system is being so violently enforced we should have a look at it and what it is trying to accomplish. if socialism is trying to create a society where the social needs determine what we make (including your own of course) then what does it really mean that capitalism is trying to create a society where capital drives the economy, and where is it being driven to? a social need once met no longer exists but capital once earned must go somewhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*koga7In5PtpBSdXBu25HDg.png" /></figure><h3>capitalism</h3><p>similar to socialism, capitalism is a supply and demand economy, however instead of the demand being fulfilled free of cost or obligation the demand is only supplied to those who have enough of a certain currency (agreed to be valuable thing) to exchange for it. in other words instead of creating things because they’re needed people are creating things in order to exchange them. this moves the focus away from what can i do to help towards what can i do to get more for myself.</p><p>the problem with such a society is that if someone were for some reason unable to obtain any of the valuable products or currency they would not be able to get their needs met. in other words, a result of making everything require an exchange is that people who have nothing can get nothing and this often leads to them dying or needing to be supported by someone who couldn&#39;t bear to let that happen. this is essentially dividing society into haves and have nots because no matter how badly you need something you can only get it if you have enough of the right thing to trade for it. the reason people have to charge for their goods and services however is because everyone else is charging. if nobody charged nobody would have to charge.</p><p>so what is it that really benefits people about this model, about being able to charge, if it is resulting in death and suffering what is it providing in exchange for that?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IWTv6XoxbwCmX8b0BN0niA.png" /></figure><ol><li>the real driving force in a capitalist economy is the capitalists themselves</li><li>the profits from production are given to</li><li>things are made according to potential profit not actual demand</li><li>unable to participate in exchange the planet’s needs are not met</li><li>profit is sought from all interactions instead of them being cooperative</li><li>in order to meet your needs you <strong>must </strong>have capital to exchange</li><li>those who have capital to give hire those without any to produce for them</li><li>people rent themselves out in order to get capital to meet their needs</li><li>some people are unable to find hire and are ignored by the system</li></ol><p>capitalism exists to extract as much “value” from the environment as possible by the rich, without putting anything back, and keeping an army of people who can’t afford not to work to pull off this robbery for them.</p><p>when there is suffering under capitalism it is not a sign of the system being broken, it is the pollution of the system that is operating as intended. in order to have a “broken” capitalism it would be one where the rich lost their wealth and the poor got their needs met. however socialism already does that without the extra burden of exchange accounting and competition so you don’t want a broken capitalism, you either want a working capitalism which includes that suffering or a working socialism that doesn’t. capitalism is working correctly as long as the rich continue to benefit from the expropriation of resources from people and the environment. that is the only reason for having capital (in a society that want to cooperate anyway).</p><h3>comparison</h3><p>capitalism can’t create in people a desire to cooperate, but what capitalism can do is create a system of bribery and coercion where people who do not desire to cooperate will do so because they are trying to get something out of it. if a society has many people who do not want to cooperate then this can create some kind of cooperation. however, if your society does want to cooperate then it is attempting to fix a problem that doesn’t exist and instead causes new problems. socialism is the system that works and is healthy for people when they do want to cooperate. it is an infinitely better system, we just need everyone to agree that cooperation is mutually beneficial.</p><p>supply and demand but without a market or trade or money or profit or debt. just what are the things we need, who can make them, lets do it, now life is better for everyone what else is needed. and the things we don’t like making, well there’s a need for automation that needs to be met so it gets attention too. this will radically change the way we think about our actions, each other, and the things we make and use.</p><p>no more making gold plated toilets for rich assholes, you want a gold plated toilet you go find someone to make one for you for free, oh you can’t? you can go make it yourself, oh nobody wants to give you gold, well you could try and mine some yourself. the things that exist will be the things we agree need to exist and overproduction and useless junk will be a thing of history. the things that are most critical at solving will be the things that society collectively decides to solve.</p><p>when things are decided by price it’s essentially just a proxy for decided by the rich, and the rich don’t care about the poor, but when you remove the ability to be rich by removing money from society you remove the previous architects of society (those with the money) and the new architects (those with the abilities who no longer have to answer to those with the money) will be able to address the most critical issues immediately.</p><p>how we get all of society to agree to cooperate instead of compete is beyond the scope of this text, if a small minority choose to withold the things we need to produce (the means of production) from the rest who have chosen to cooperate should they be allowed to hold the rest of the planet at ransom for their own greed? these are questions i won’t answer right now but worth mentioning nonetheless. but there is a fairly good chance that people will choose to withold the means of production because they are currently the benefactors of the capitalist way of doing things, and doing things in a socialist way kind of makes them obsolete.</p><p>if we could as a society agree to produce things based on need and remove capital and its mechanisms then how to make that transition could be figured out with billions of people working together on it. for now what we need is for people to start popularizing the existence of this better model and the ability for people to ignore all of the noise about fixing things from within via voting or trying to implement things via a shortcut.</p><h3>conclusion</h3><p>socialism is clearly a far more beneficial way of running the economy and so we should be attempting to get popular support for it.</p><p>however should people have more immediate solutions to their material conditions then whatever they do might not be socialism at that time, they shouldn’t call it socialism like some have before, but they should be openly attempting to attain actual socialism and the things they do should be in attempts to achieve it.</p><p>for example a capitalist state might ban all forms of corporate structure except for equal ownership of all workers making coops the only way of running a business, while this isn’t socialism it is far closer to it the model, it can be something that once achieved can then have completely capital-free mutual aid networks established within it. what will not move us closer is any system that concentrates power in a few voices, no matter how contrite or elected.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab2f44f690bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[is [actual] socialism even possible?]]></title>
            <link>https://lizzyrosa.medium.com/is-actual-socialism-even-possible-850eb8d8c40a?source=rss-329c79cda2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/850eb8d8c40a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intersectionality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[lizzy rosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 May 2018 00:03:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-30T00:03:31.808Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>spoiler alert: yes.</p><h3>disclaimer</h3><p>it’s possible, but i think it’s a lot harder than people usually make it out to be. what i want to do is make some observations about the nature of societal paradigm shifts, no doubt this kind of thing is highly hypothetical and to some degree unproveable, i’m going to make these observations anyway, i’m just admitting that they’re conjecture up front so you don’t assume there’s more than intuition behind these points.</p><p>the reason i am giving this disclaimer is so that i don’t have to try and make actual references to research and quote sources and know that the idea i’m having has a specific name i should be using etc. i want to just sit here with my computer and vomit out the stuff in my brain onto a page. fuck academia. fuck high barriers to entry on people giving their opinions on stuff. let’s have a discussion and let’s use the words and imagery and conclusions that work for us. i try to immerse myself in theory when i’m not writing so that i’ve got a more helpful opinion when i do, but i don’t want my writing to be a manifesto or thesis i want it to be a platform for me to put my ideas out into the open and see how they fare.</p><h3>shut up about that noise and start talking politics</h3><p>so, let’s say we want an egalitarian society, we want to find a comfortable balance between cooperation and mutual aid and personal liberties, where personal freedom is maximized and amount of input required is minimized. once we’re operating under those mechanisms as a society our collective ability and desire to supply our own demand for these parameters to be optimized will eventually (but in our lifetimes) lead to a zero input required and maximum personal liberty society, in other words an utopia.</p><h3>zero input society (input = work)</h3><p>how would you achieve zero input? well, the input i’m talking about here refers to labour, so you might still input something like what you want for dinner but you won’t have to do any work or give back in any other way in order for that request to be honored. now if you like cooking then that’s not what i mean when i say work, when i say work i’m talking about commitments to perform labour. so, doing a favour for someone else isn’t work because although it took labour it wasn’t previously committed to. community service, or provision of labour to the economy that you do because you want the system to function but would prefer not to do if it were possible . and that is essentially a fully automated society. where everything that we don’t want to do ourselves is done automatically. and if that were one of the two main mechanisms driving society we would achieve it through our technological progress.</p><h3>maximum liberty society</h3><p>so what about a maximum liberty society, how would that be achieved? well, part of achieving it would be getting everyone to agree on what it means. but that’s not necessarily impossible, all we need is to find a definition of liberty we can all agree on. while getting people to all agree on something arbitrary might still be impossible, getting them to agree to something they have some personal reference point for wouldn’t. so this means the things we define as being liberatory need to be liberatory for everybody because if they liberated some people but not others then that would by definition not be the maximum amount of liberty possible.</p><p>some people argue that true liberty means being able to do whatever you want to and then include things like being violent or harmful to others, but the problem with that is all you would need is one single person who isn’t happy with being harmed for it to no longer be a universal freedom. i think it’s safe to say that a universal freedom is always going to overrule a less universal freedom that contradicts it because universal freedom is by definition more freedom than non-universal freedom. however if one universal freedom overruled multiple lesser freedoms then perhaps things will be a bit harder to judge. but perhaps in that case a universal freedom that provided those lesser freedoms would be better than including those lesser freedoms and so absent such a dilemma we can assume that non-universal freedoms are disqualified from the optimized version of the mechanic of maximizing personal liberty.</p><p>so, as we’ve mentioned violence already, and how the freedom to commit violence contradicts a universal (potentially) desire to not be the victim of violence we can say that non-violence is a universal freedom. people may disagree on what the definition of violence is so in the context of a universal freedom it would be defined as advocating for or carrying out harm against another person. now i’m not suggesting that a society will exist where nobody ever harms another person, but what i’m suggesting is that when they do it should be considered a breach of the recipients freedom and liberty and our society will be continually optimizing itself o maximize freedom and so it would be attempting to reduce the amount of harm people do to each other.</p><p>while that may be an ongoing struggle it’s possible that we can achieve a society where macro-aggressions have stopped and only micro-aggressions occur and so they may require some social interactions with intent on restorative justice but the amount of harm done should be low enough not to cause new trauma. in order to further optimize away harm we will need to find ways of reducing even micro-aggressions.</p><p>one options for this is for us to have a commonly used cybernetic implant or wearable device that has a way of determining your emotional state, we could then have a wireless network which these devices can communicate between each other on. coupled with this would need to be some way of recieving feedback from the software on the device, so a small speaker in the ear, a contact lense or glasses with a display in them, a sort of morse code of vibrations, but some way of getting signals. we could then program our personal privacy settings, like whether we like to be approached by a stranger or not, whether we are happy for someone else to make physical contact with us, and so on, and then our devices would pick up on our emotions and the other persons and facilitate a warning when a person is not comfortable with the situation or whether they want to be talked to or left alone etc.</p><p>although a perfect solution would be for us to have some kind of telepathic connectivity where our consent negotiation api can understand the thoughts we’re having and let us know if the other person would be down for that or not before we even ask it, or if a joke would be offensive to someone before we say it.</p><p>whatever it is we come up with, we need things that help us avoid harming each other, technology that could give us a person’s pronouns as we looked at them for example, there are a lot of ways we can improve this and possibly eventually reach a place where we are legit all just getting along fine.</p><p>so really, if you think about it, that is the only real universal freedom you need to reach maximum liberty, because if you’ve reduced all the harm people do to each other to zero by giving them access to enough information etc then you’ve given them the tools to not limit anyone elses liberty, and in the process as nobody else is limiting yours you can do anything you want, as long as it’s not harming others. we definitely need some way of facilitating the communication regarding what is or isn’t harmful to people but given that it is not actually a difficult thing to achieve.</p><h3>but that’s just a technicality</h3><p>while technically possible for us to achieve a maximum liberty with minimum work society, there are things that are not strictly speaking technical which may be obstacles preventing us from implementing it.</p><p>there are two main examples of non-technical obstacles that are blocking our path towards utopia: desire for competition instead of cooperation, and prejudice towards certain expressions of humanity.</p><h3>desire for competition instead of cooperation</h3><p>to begin with, the part there that says “desire for” is very important. now, when most people think of desire for something they think of the emotion or the longing or the obsession for a thing, i know many people do feel that way towards competition, but i’m actually referring to what people consider to be in their own best interest. so, while people may prefer and feel emotional desire for cooperation they may conduct their day to day lives with behavior that is competitive because they have determined that to be in their best interest.</p><p>it wouldn’t be too difficult to prove that cooperation would benefit people more than competition does. but, that proof won’t really mean much if the person assesses it and concludes that competition is still in their own personal best interest. this is why capitalism has not been abandoned by now, because capitalism arranges people in society in such a way that each of them will benefit more from competing than from cooperating. so for example someone at work is getting yelled at by the boss and you think they may about to get fired, you could speak up in their defense but it’s possible that this would further provoke the boss and get you both fired. in that immediate moment cooperation risks your own ability to survive.</p><p>now cooperation could achieve more security for people’s jobs by creating a security in numbers, which is what unions attempt to do, but even when you have a union the corporation itself exists in an environment of competition and that will continually put pressure on them to try and dissolve the cooperative organizing that has begun to insulate the workers there from the competitive arena. now if every workplace in the world were unionized and every union cooperated in a global and permanent strike we may be getting somewhere but that isn’t actually possible in my opinion because there is too much incentive under capitalism for people to compete that some will use the fact that the competitive market rewards competition to market themselves as competitive instead of cooperative and so cooperation for cooperation sake isn’t going to happen any time soon if unionization is all we have to make it happen.</p><p>the problem is we are living in a society that is attempting to optimize for maximum accumulation of exchange value (eg. money), and so it heavily rewards those who accumulate a lot of it and heavily harms those who run out of it. capitalism is like the facebook algorithm of optimizing it’s settings to keep you contributing towards the accumulation of exchange value (eg. money). if every 2nd day the food in the shops was free, well you would simply go and get your groceries on the even days and avoid the shops on the odd days, this would result in a loss of exchange value for the grocer (the groceries could have been exchanged for money) and a reduction in the spending of exchange value for the customer.</p><p>in fact, would you even need to keep going to work if you could get free food every second day? i wouldn’t. lol. but if someone stopped going to work then sure there’s a little less loss of exchange value by the corporation paying them, but a much larger loss in exchange value for them in output, (spoiler alert: whatever you were doing is worth more than they were paying you for or they’d not make as much or any profit). so the net loss in exchange value being created would be catastrophic, especially if the corporation couldn’t find anyone to replace the person who quit because they were all hanging out on the beach eating their free food.</p><p>so how much of the time can you keep the grocery stores open for free before it begins to destabilize the entire economy. well, let’s take a low but not impossibly low estimate of 15 minutes. you could go lower than that sure but let’s be honest, at that point why are you even bothering, you’re just trying to create stampedes and it’s probably not safe. but lets say 15 minutes a week, so almost nothing compared to the full week right.</p><p>week 1: a few hundred people in the community have been chatting and they think they’ve come up with quite a great plan, so, strangely enough this week they’re not going for any food or household items, nope, they’re all going in and grabbing wheel barrows, ladders, big bags, ropes, wheels, planks, sheets of wood, canvas. well, that stuff wasn’t going to sell anytime soon so the capitalists decide to give this another week.</p><p>week 2: a thousand people show up with makeshift trolleys and platforms, the doors open and the go in and methodically clean out the entire shop of all of its items.</p><p>the end.</p><p>like it wouldn’t last two weeks even with such a small amount of time where things are free for the entire viability of that store to disappear and for the community to not need to buy anything for a few weeks. this is a tremendous amount of exchange value loss and is quite destabilizing for the local economy, however for the people in the community this is the best thing that has ever happened to them.</p><p>curious system isn’t it, when even 15 minutes a week of compromising on the whole exchange value system and it breaks in less than two weeks (it’s like 8 days or something). and if you don’t believe me that people will organize that kind of cooperation in a short space of time why don’t you give it a try and let me know :) (spoiler alert: you won’t, you know it’s possible). my point is, that little pockets of cooperation instead of competition are a threat to the whole competitive environment. they are a destabilizing effect. a few of those experiments gone wrong would cause the entire economy to take a tumble from the banker’s perspective. and so this environment of competition is going to self-optimize to eliminate threats in order to continue existing and will work towards eliminating any kind of cooperation based system that tries to exist within it (they’ll oppose unionization even if they claim they don’t).</p><p>so, in order to go from a competition centric system to a cooperation centric system what we would call this in software development is a “breaking change”. software developers try to avoid “breaking changes” if at all possible because they imply that two different versions of the software are not compatible with each other. so, let’s say you were programming a game and you were saving the player’s progress in a file with a certain format. later on you realize that you want to change the format, but if you do then people who have a save game with an older version of the game wouldn’t be able to load that save game in the new version of the game. it would break their save and so it’s called a “breaking change”. but how and what breaks what might be different from app to app.</p><p>but let’s use that analogy of a save game format and explore why i call this a breaking change. so, let’s say we were to save everybody’s progress in the competitive environment called capitalism to file. this is the capitalism game we’re playing here so it means we need to save how much money you have, what things you have legal ownership of, what contracts you’re bound to, debts, criminal record maybe, health insurance number if you have one, id doc from a state if you can get one and need one. like we’ll take you the same person you are now and load a different game than capitalism so we don’t need to save your personality etc. just the bits that let us reload your place in capitalism later.</p><p>so we’ll load up a cooperative centric game now, let’s call it socialism, and oh wow socialism has a different save format. hmm. so, i guess you lose all your stuff… but then nobody in this game is trying to steal your stuff or evict you so maybe you keep your stuff but you lose your money. but that’s ok because you don’t need money to get what you need. ok cool, you can keep playing, it sorta worked. ok but now let’s try and take a save game from the new socialism save format and load it back into capitalism.</p><p>well, actually now you did lose all your stuff because socialism didn’t save any money or legal ownerships, you were just kinda left to stay where you stayed and help how you could help, get the things you needed when you needed them. it saved your name, your pronouns, a link to your profile on some decentralized open source social network that doesn’t exist in this game called capitalism. so that sucks i guess if you wanted to go back. but. the point kinda is that you can’t go back and so that’s why it’s a breaking change. the things that capitalism wanted to record were only important when you were playing capitalism and unless you had a backup of your old save somewhere you wouldn’t be able to go back to how you were before. and so even though this is a competitive environment and we all like to tell each other how much cooperation is better than competition, we’re still choosing not to load the new game called socialism because we were keeping score to be honest and not so keen about losing it, and you know, what if socialism fails and you can’t go back to your save on capitalism and it’s all ruined.</p><p>socialism isn’t the USSR or China by the way, it’s people producing things so that others can use them instead of to exchange for something else of value like money. if there’s money, or a state, or trading it’s not socialism even if there’s a big banner saying “this is socialism” hanging over it.</p><p>but for some people this isn’t a bug, it’s a feature. for the developers of the socialism system it’s definitely a feature. because once you have erased the mechanism for optimizing society for maximum accumulation of exchange value you can switch it to maximum personal liberty by removing barriers to movement and occupation and minimum work through cooperation and automation. what i’m suggesting isn’t that some perfect model for society be figured out and put into practice everywhere, rather what i’m talking about is removing the things that have been preventing us from cooperating all along. we are a cooperative species and this is why we have such an affinity for it and yet for most of us we live in a society that is antithetical to it and it’s a pretty wild ride.</p><p>the things that prevent cooperation are the things that allow some people to hold something ransom from other people to get them to do as they wish or to get them to bring you something in exchange for it. like the capitalists who hold the products that are made under their dominion ransom from everyone except those who can give them something of value in exchange. so we remove the ability for any one person to take ownership of our means of production. all our factories and manufacturies are no longer owned by anyone in particular but are kept in operation by the community and workers who rely on it’s existence or the contribution it makes to the cooperative economy that in return provides you with the things you rely on for your existence.</p><p>how about the landlords who hold ransom their “property” in order to receive something of value in exchange for “permission” to live there? easy, of course yes, no more ownership of accomodations, people get to stay where they are or move somewhere unoccupied but they no longer have to give anything to anyone to do so. and of course, all the grocery stores provide everything for free instead of holding those things ransom in exchange for something valueable.</p><p><em>“ok but if everything’s free people will just hoard and there will be nothing left for anyone.”</em></p><p>yeah, when you’re in a competitive environment sure, but not in a cooperative one, let me explain using the internet.</p><p>if you have a small data cap and you want to watch a tv show what do you do, well you wait until the last day of your cap and whatever you have left you use to download some (legally right? :P ) files and then you can watch those offline and hope they last you until the end of the next month where you can do another batch. same thing with making stuff free but only temporarily, you need to hoard so when it goes back to not free you have extra.</p><p>now what if you had super uncapped internet and if you were to watch streaming tv for a full month solid you would still not run out of cap. please be honest, you’re not going to batch download stuff on the last day of the month. you might download high res versions as soon as they’re released, you might stream stuff straight from a streaming site. but you’re not worried about batching your downloads unless there’s some kind of restriction on your usage. now the same is true for socialist grocery stores, my suggestion would be for them to stay shut at the beginning and have a few people taking orders and going in and grabbing things and giving them to people because it’s gonna be a bit weird at the beginning let’s be honest. but like you’ll need people working the stores to keep track of whats being taken so you can order more, and you know you can remind people that there’s been a breaking change so they don’t need to worry about things going back to capitalism and so they don’t need to hoard.</p><p>that awkwardness of figuring out how to get people what they need but without causing a panic will need to be something done in a cooperative manner by people, as part of the switch over, the breaking change, they will need to be on board with that and willing to cooperate. but when people have gotten into the groove of things they’re not going to need any help remembering because they will have lived weeks, then months, then years with important things not running out and no hint of capitalism in sight. how will we go weeks, months and years without things running out? we will cooperate to make sure that doesn’t happen. both before the switch during the planning phases and after the switch when we will have to manage the needs of the community and build the solutions to the problems they’re having. we will need to contribute what we can, learn what we can, adapt, cooperate, but we’ll figure it out and optimize it. and it will be less labour intensive than what we’re already doing today. less work.</p><p>why would it be less work? well, we’ll be producing what is needed for usage rather than to try and exchange it for some or other currency, so immediately all the work that goes into economic calculations is eliminated. technical calculations will still be needed though so those who have experience in economic calculations can contribute there and reduce the work of those who’re doing all the technical calculations now. entire industries that are focused on the management of currency will disappear which means no more insurance, no more banking, no more stock exchange no more payroll and many office workers can help out with other industries from that. industries which exist to generate exchange value but don’t add anything of value to actual users will evaporate like advertising, but those skills will come in use with creating educational or recreational content so that will help. mass production will shift towards longevity and quality of production instead of mass production for repeated replacement so production will be reduced overall to meet demand. everyone who works within the “intellectual property” industries will be able to open source all their contributions allowing for much less duplication of efforts.</p><p>essentially we can keep our current standard of living while working a bunch less and never have to worry about money again with this one trick called socialism. and by trick i don’t mean it’s going to be magic, it’s going to take a bunch of work, and a lot of the problems that we were never able to solve under capitalism will now be solveable so to begin with it’s going to be bunch of hard work, but we’ll do it because we value cooperation and we want everyone to be a part of our global society and have their basic needs met.</p><h3>prejudice towards certain expressions of humanity</h3><p>the second large obstacle that is blocking our path towards utopia and that is one of prejudices. what is a prejudice? well, as we discussed earlier regarding freedoms, we’re talking about freedoms that aren’t harming others. so in that regard prejudice is the belief that some people deserve more freedom than others. while that’s certainly an opinion many people have, they’re wrong, and it’s an opinion that is an obstacle along the path to utopia.</p><p>when talking about freedoms here it’s within the context of people who have been peaceful, if someone does harm to someone else then there may need to be some kinds of assistance there for them to figure out why they messed up and how to not do it again and we should expect everyone to find that person in their life not any kind of institution, a community may have things that they could do to restore their standing with the community. for the more nasty acts a community is going to have to figure out how it wants to go forward with that, they have every right to choose not to keep someone who’s been violent around but this kinda thing needs to be figured out by each community not someone else’s opinion being imported, but by all means share ideas, look at the research with regards to what is most effective etc.</p><p>so we can, and will, talk about some of the specific prejudices, but i think to some degree once you’ve gotten one you’ve gotten spoiled the whole personality. like sure you might have internalized some that you’re still trying to deprogram and keep at that, no shame in turning things around, but when they come up you start to fix them, that’s one thing, but it’s another thing entirely to actively think some people are less deserving of the same freedoms as you. like i’m actually at the point where i’m ready to call anyone who has a single prejudice a fascist, but i’m not going to do that because people don’t like when you use that word or something, pretty phantastic stuff but let’s not dwell there…</p><p>anyway, my point is, you have one prejudice you have them all, you’ll use whatever one is around if it gets you what you need, even if all you need is to vilify someone different to you for your own failings, you’re perspective on humanity is completely worthless. like, if it’s legal i suppose, but look into some kinda mind altering experiences that might jolt you out of your broken logic loop because the only opinion you’re allowed to have is that we are all equally deserving of freedom. you see, when we’re talking about moving towards a society that has no law we kinda need everyone to be on board with the everyone is deserving of equal freedom train. once there is enough of us on board that train we are going to leave the station and we won’t be sharing all of our things with you because you are untrustworthy by the fact that you think some people should have more freedom than others.</p><p>i lied i’m not going to go into the specifics, but what i will say is, in every single specific instance the way that i think we will make progress is develop a dual wing approach, where on the one side you have the struggle for freedom from that particular prejudice, and on the other side you have the struggle for freedom from ALL prejudices. you need to be calling for both, like in every activist meme or podcast or protest board where you’re saying “freedom from prejudice X” i personally think you should also be saying “freedom from all prejudices”, and this is why, we need everyone to be called out, like constantly, because the cognitive dissonance they get when they are getting called out is going to force them to change, and they’ll quickly learn that changing for the worse doesn’t quite reduce the problem.</p><p>now i’m not into call out culture so when i say calling them out i don’t mean like “hey you, self-crit or die” what i mean is any way you want to communicate for equal freedom for everyone take it. like, when you’re fighting the struggle for one prejudice you’re learning about how all the other prejudices happen, like they look different but they have the same pattern, they all try to gaslight you, they all differ from what science tells us, they all try to get you to not speak up. try to make you invisible. try to forget you exist. and you gotta keep reminding them. because if you let those fuckers forget they’re gonna start thinking that’s the way things aught to be and now you got yourself so real life fascists to fuck with. if you do have those species-traitors around i’m not the right person to ask, but the rest of this stuff can still help avoid more of them from coming up.</p><p>so yeah, we need more feminist representation in media, we need way more queer representation in the media, like it should be unavoidable, like everything that makes up a prejudiced person’s culture needs to be appropriated by queer people and they need to see the queer version more often than they see their shitty version. talk to people who are super super old and they’re all like “oh well, guess my era is over”, they know there’s no coming back from this now, i want cishet tears to be raising the oceans faster than climate change if that’s what it takes for them to let go of that ridiculous notion that biology determines your gender. imagine every shop and restaurant with “no cis / hets allowed”, i mean it’s not like you can test for it can you? but you can totally have signs like that because there is no such thing as a gender binary so being cis or het is lie.</p><p>unfortunately there are some nefarious tricksters who go around telling people that if you had a specific bing bong when you born then you can only be trans if you would prefer to have a different shammy wammy or the casually internalised transphobia of “afab’s cant identify as both trans and women”. sorry to melt your candles bethany but a person is trans if they identify differently to the gender they were assigned at birth. i didn’t come up with that definition but i do understand it’s significance. if you were assigned a binary gender but you prefer a not-binary version of that same gender that’s still a different gender to what you were assigned, it’s a different version, that’s like in the definition, it can’t possibly be the same, so how could that then still make you cis? unless somehow we bring biology back into things and in that case i’m gonna let you know that i’ve already permanently noped you, sorry, not sorry, bye.</p><p>i don’t think we need to be chill with trolls, like, if someone claims to be trans and then acts cis af all the time and hates trans people nope them to hecc, but dont nope someone who’s like “i don’t feel like what everyone else says is this gender but i don’t know if i’m something different either”, being trans is awesome, it’s authentic, it’s the only way to do authentic human gender tbh, but it can’t be faked, you need to deprogram the binary first, and that takes time. and some people have started to realize that they have been programmed and aren’t sure what those feelings mean and they 100% belong in the community and allowed to identify as whatever feels comfortable.</p><p>there’s no such thing as being trans enough. like we’re talking about how once you have one prejudice the whole batch of personality is ruined, well if you have one fibre of queerness in you the whole batch gets a little bit more beautiful. why would i say that, am i cisphobic? yes, i am cisphobic, because there were hundreds of thousands of people studied in thousands of research papers and there was strong evidence in favour of the conclusion that a person’s gender is unique, that there is no gender binary, that a person’s anatomy does not correlate to any specific developmental pattern in those people’s brain scans. the binary is literally just not understanding that gender is unique and so unassignable.</p><p>but that’s just one prejudice, and the more you are a victim of the worse your treatment and prospects are. with ableism there’s shit like equating the desire to harm others as a mental illness despite studies showing that people with mental disabilities are much more likely to be the victims of violence and a fair amount less likely to be the perpetrator people have a prejudice against those who have disabilities and they’ll throw us under the bus if it lets them pretend the problem isn’t closely intertwined with capitalism and the patriarchy itself. and even people who are usually totally supportive of those with disabilities will jump on board the ableist train, some times out of naivety but mostly because it’s support until they have to actually do something / make an correction to their opinions, or acknowledge the validity of your existence.</p><p>those are the struggles i’m fighting, but whatever it is you’re fighting you know best what it’s like, and you know how things could be made right, and you need to let people know what those things are. but at the same time, we have this obstacle in our way towards utopia and we need all prejudices to get rekt and that message is a unifying message. the call out needs to be like a double barrelled shotgun, a person with a prejudice isn’t just a person with a prejudice, they’re a person who thinks it’s ok to have a prejudice, so my point is that both the prejudice itself and the idea that having one at all is ok need to be combatted before we get there and they synergize with each other because you have a banner that covers everyone who is willing to get passed that obstacle and you can challenge people who aren’t getting behind you.</p><p>so it’s like, transphobia get rekt because we’re on our way to zero oppression utopia and you’re blocking the path, instead of transphobia get rekt cuz you are there near me and i’m not going anywhere but i want you not to be there. ableism get rekt because you’re blocking the path to utopia. racism get rekt because you’re blocking the path to utopia. sexism get rekt. xenophobia get rekt. etc. does having this approach mean you might lose some people who would otherwise have fought the struggle with you because they have some or other prejudice then that’s a feature not a bug, the trash it literally taking itself out and this is somehow a problem? automatic garbage collection please.</p><p>not even one prejudice. thank you very much.</p><h3>so if we have a desire for a cooperation based society that has no concept of money or exchange value or markets, but is quite adept at supply and demand and takes care of the ecology, and we have a desire for a zero tolerance stance on the existence of prejudice what does that actually help</h3><p>right? how does simply wanting this help at all?</p><p>well, how many people exist on earth, take the number one, to represent yourself, divide it by the number of people alive right now or as close as you can get to a good guess and the result is how much of the total number of people needed to want this for it to actually become a reality and leed to utopia. it’s a pretty small number like like nine 0’s in the decimal or something but if you are able to get someone else to want this too then you’ve doubled your contribution. to be fair, we only need like 80% of the population to be on board for the rest of them to give up or go into open opposition but what do i know.</p><p>this is not an impossible quest it’s just very very difficult. but if you want utopia this is how you get there. you don’t get there through a “socialist state”, you don’t get there through a “free market capitalism”, and you won’t get there through whatever brand of authoritarian capitalism they’re selling these days. those systems are designed to not ever lead to utopias, they may claim to be able to deliver them but their design betrays this false advertising. inspect the quality of their arguments rather than the flashy marketing gimmicks. if capitalism is really that great solve poverty right now, like instantly, do it now capitalism, oh, what’s that, you can’t? socialism would have done it three times since the first time i asked you to. capitalism is weak af when it comes to ending inequality and thus poverty because equality is a threat to it’s existence.</p><p>quite correctly i believe the capitalists fear that if an alternative to capitalism were to be successful that it would spell the end of their reign.</p><p>now, the question i’ve been building up to is this…</p><h3>which comes first, the dismantling of capitalism or the dismantling of prejudice?</h3><p>and the answer is neither / both, they need to happen at the same time and here’s why…</p><p>capitalism is a breeding ground for prejudices, as soon as you limit people’s freedoms based on their ability to produce socially needed labour you’ve done the prejudice of ableism, capitalism itself is inherently ableist as it actively minimizes the access and experiences of those with disabilities. so people are in favour it have already tainted their souls with prejudice, or allowed a prejudicial thought pattern to embed itself in their brain’s nueron structure, or they’ve proven that they don’t believe everyone deserves equal freedoms, however you want to phrase it. and so adding more on top of that is relatively easy. i guess it’s kinda like getting a tattoo, and once you’ve got the “i ❤ capitalism” tattoo on your forehead you’re way more likely to tattoo “white pride” on your arm as you’ve already communicated to other people that you’re the worst trash humanity has been able to poop out by your condoning of capitalism.</p><p>but capitalism is also a tool with which prejudices can be acted upon. so if you were to try and remove it the people with prejudices wouldn’t be too happy about that as you’re removing their ability to oppress. we can’t remove the prejudices first because capitalism is making us hate each other, and you can’t get rid of capitalism first because we need it to keep hating each other. a mutually beneficial logic loop in two parts unless there were more than two options.</p><p>what if you did both at the same time.</p><p>how do you do both at the same time?<br>how do you do one of them? <br>do that but with all of them at the same time?</p><p>i dunno lol, but what i know is that there is a future society where maximum personal liberty with minimum work and these two bolders are leaning against each other so when you try to move one out of the way the other one holds it in place.</p><p>maybe we can treat capitalism as “the tool of prejudices” and add it to the “equal freedoms” initiative and get people to ditch it in their plans on how this new society needs to be structured. spoiler alert: decentralized socialist anarchism with federated mutual aid communities, no money or trade, it’s all free, and if you hate someone because they’re a different way to be human than you, you can get into the ocean and leave.</p><p>in my mind i picture those movies where they have a nuke and you have to turn two keys in two different key holes at the same time in order to arm it, and it’s like, that’s what needs to happen when we try to reforge our society. we need the key of intolerance to prejudice to turn making prejudice no longer acceptable, and at the same time we need the key of socialism to replace capitalism and for production to be done for use instead of for exchange. now both of these keys are like multi-decades long struggles, but maybe it’s time we brought them together and made them a joint struggle.</p><p>not one or the other, but both, not the end of one prejudice but all, not the end of just capitalism or just prejudice but the end of both and the birth of a new society from those ashes. one where every problem becomes a technical problem instead of an economic or political problem and then a technical problem on top of that. if you’re like me you didn’t ask for this shitshow, you woke up in a place where capitalism was accepted as legitimate and prejudice for other people was common practice. but we have developed in our technological capacity, in our scientific understanding, we’ve improved our social analysis, and we have everything we need to make a utopia happen.</p><p>and the plagues of war, climate destruction, and poverty that capitalism has brought upon us, the myriad of prejudices that people try to use to tear us apart, these things need not be permanent, i can get 1/[people on earth] there all on my own, and so can you, and if we try hard we can make that more, and it might end up being enough. but let’s go all the way to utopia, none of these multi-stage decades long trips in circles, none of these “debates” on if capitalism is better than socialism or not, war, climate destruction, poverty, i just said it, lol, that’s worse than socialism, yes, a lot worse.</p><p>and i encourage you to think about this, and to consider making your activist struggle a dual struggle, for both socialism and the end to tolerance of prejudices with the utopian future in mind, rather than only to fight the thing immediately in front of you with no further goal in mind than a slightly less shitty version of what you’re currently living rather than a radically different and free society.</p><p>thank you for lending me your attention ❤</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=850eb8d8c40a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>