<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by llull on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by llull on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@llull?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:05:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@llull/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dromomania: Reading Paul Virilio]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/dromomania-reading-paul-virilio-5764f4bf0cfa?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5764f4bf0cfa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dromology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[speed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paul-virilio]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acceleration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virilio]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2020 00:14:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-19T00:55:27.321Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Paul Virilio, L&#39;insécurité du territoire" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/313/1*dp_1ClnJxkRhAlzr_Ux49A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Daniel L Potter</p><p>Culture Industry Conference, Cornell University, 1987</p><p>I.</p><p>Reading Paul Virilio on an airplane: contagious process, invasion, virus, illuminating contours of the now, hurtling through the medium of the message. <em>Contour </em>though lacks the quality of motion that Virilio wants to give to spatial terms and categories. What he reveals is not precisely the contours of our world, but its tendencies, contours leaning or even taking off in a certain direction: contours in motion, as aerial vehicles are houses in motion. <em>Tendencies </em>are vectoral viruses probed by a new science — dromology. It is, literally, the study of the race (<em>dromos </em>referring to the Spartan race course); dromology produces readings of configurations of speed, it pinpoints a tightly enmeshed network of global problems related to velocity. Its space is also a time and vice versa, because speed always involves bizarre forms of intimacy between the two.</p><p>Tendencies are the prey of dromology because the method and the results involved in Virilio’s studies goes directly against the grain of a “scientific” language that would situate an object in a prone, defined, vivisected, cornered position. Virilio does not seek to situate or exhaust, but rather to set writing itself in motion, send it on a trajectory that itself lacks a precise itinerary. As he says in the interviews with Sylvère Lotringer entitled Pure War:</p><p><em>“I don’t believe in explanations. I believe in suggestion, in the obvious quality of the implicit. Being an urbanist and architect, I am too used to constructing clear systems, machines that work well. I don’t believe it’s writing’s job to do the same thing. . . . I work in staircases . . . .</em></p><p><em>Developments are the episodes. I try to reach the tendency. Tendency is the change of level.” [38–39].</em></p><p>Paul Virilio was born in Paris in 1932, directed the École Speciale d’Architecture in the early seventies, has been on the editorial boards of a number of French journals, was in the French army before becoming a gonzo philosopher, and considers himself an “urbanist.” His first major works, <em>Bunker Archéologie </em>and <em>L’Insécurité du territoire</em>, testify to his ability to make use of various disciplines, various ways of seeing — seeing by means of war and the military, seeing through the optic of the city, seeing as a citizen of an advanced capitalist nation in the twentieth century.</p><p>Responding to a question posed by Lotringer regarding misunderstandings of his work, Virilio sketches where he’s coming from:</p><p><em>To be interested in technology through war already makes people suspicious: war is generally considered a negative phenomenon, and technology a positive one. So to say that the positive phenomenon of technology came in large part from the arsenal and war economy is already hard for people to accept. They are forced to reject me. Thus I’m either grouped in with a mystifying, mystical logic — defrocked priest — or with a military logic — defrocked officer. They can’t recognize the situation as I present it.</em></p><p><em>This has to do with what I said at the beginning of the interview: if war is the source of the city, then, being an urban planner, I’m for war. If I say that war is the source of technology, I reinforce what I said for the city. I reinforce the idea that I’m a strategist, a man of the war-machine, and thus someone who shouldn’t be trusted. As people don’t accept that war, and not commerce, is the source of the city, as they don’t accept the negativity in technology (the negative tendency in technology), they push that negativity back onto the person who says it — me, as it turns out. And since, to boot, I don’t have a career in the social sciences — sociology of war, history of technology, etc. — to back me up, people have their doubts about me. They say: how did he get where he is? And I answer: by living. As a child, I was terrorized by war. As I say in my preface to L’Insécurité du territoire, war was my father and my mother. I didn’t do it on purpose; one doesn’t choose one’s parents. Later I fought in the Algerian War, as a draftee. I’m not bragging about it; quite the contrary, it’s tragic. But both these wars initiated me into a profound understanding of the military phenomenon. War was my University.” (Pure War, 24)</em></p><p>In <em>Bunker Archeologie</em>, his preoccupation was with reconstructing the spatial dimension of the second world war, what he calls the “European fortress.” Like Walter Benjamin, another urbanist both in his writings and his life, Virilio began writing from the perspective of catastrophe, by digging around in the remains of a type of city, the sedentary and imposing constructions left by the war machine.</p><p><em>L’Insécurité du territoire </em>attempts a much more global project and comprehends a whole series of tendencies that mark the postwar world. This horizon, the twentieth century’s negative horizon, or to quote Alexander Kluge, “the assault of the present on the rest of time,” continued to inform his subsequent books — <em>Vitesse et politique, L’Horizon négatif, L’Espace critique</em>, and several others, as well as his frequent contributions to the journal <em>Traverses</em>. Gilles Deleuze has provided a summary of <em>L’Insecurite du territoire </em>in a piece called “Politics”:</p><p><em>Paul Virilio has sketched the outlines of the World State such as it appears today: a State of absolute peace more terrifying still than one of total war, having fully realized its identification with the abstract machine, where the equilibrium of spheres of influence and the great segments communicate with a ‘secret capillarity,’ where the illuminated and totally cross-sectioned city now provides shelter only for nocturnal troglodytes, each one buried in his black hole, the ‘social swamp.’ (“Politics,” On the Line, 99)</em></p><p>Or, following a formulation of Deleuze and Guattari’s: “The administration of a grand organized molar security has for its corollary a micro-management of small fears, a molecular and permanent insecurity. “ (<em>Mille Plateaux</em>: 263)</p><p>II.</p><p>What is required of thought in view of and inside the world exposed (or overexposed) by Virilio’s wakeful gaze? Paranoia, nearsightedness, the pressing of the issue, the pursuit of tendencies instead of happiness.</p><p>Virilio’s writing, his manner, and his topic display a resistance that systematically rejects the unconscious will-to-apocalypse that theory has tended at times to encourage, in favor of a detective’s eye view. The detective’s job, in this case, is to keep his eyes open and to wander around in the scenes of the crime, the crime being Pure War, which is to say the inconceivable, always deferred potentiality of nuclear exchange. Its scenes are our cities, our airports, our missile sites, and movie theaters,</p><p>and the victims are spread out all over the globe, in the first, second, third, and fourth worlds. Cognizant of the diffuse nature of an analysis that attempts to portray the present moment from a global perspective of emergency, Virilio makes of this very diffuseness a virtue.</p><p>Speed is found in information exchange, in the “world vision” of television and film, in travel, in every instance where humans hook up with and are saturated by technologies. Speed is also at the heart of the manipulation of wealth. Indeed, his idea is that speed precedes wealth, that power always grows out of the possession of the means of velocity. He describes this claim in his talk with Lotringer:</p><p><em>Speed is the unknown side of politics, and has been since the beginning: this is nothing new. The wealth aspect in politics was spotlighted a long time ago. it was a mistake . . . to forget that wealth is an aspect of speed. . . .</em></p><p><em>People forget the dromological dimension of power: its ability to inveigle, whether by taxes, conquest, etc. Every society is founded on a relation to speed. Every society is dromocratic. We have two sides of the regulation of speed and wealth. Up until the nineteenth century, society was founded on the brake. Means of furthering speed were very scant. You had ships, but sailing ships evolved very little between Antiquity and Napoleon’s time; the horse even less; and of course there were carrier pigeons. The only machine to use speed with any sophistication was the optical telegraph, then the electric telegraph. In general, up until the nineteenth century, there was no production of speed. They could produce brakes by means of ramparts, the law, rules, interdictions, etc. They could brake using all kinds of obstacles. [Pure War, 44–45]</em></p><p>The dromocratic revolution is Virilio’s name for the Industrial Revolution; the key to the steam engine and the combustion engine was the fabrication of speed. He goes on:</p><p><em>And so they can pass from the age of brakes to the age of the accelerator. In other words, power will be invested in acceleration itself. We know that the army has always been the place where pure speed is used, whether it be in the cavalry — the best horses, of course, were army horses — the artillery, etc. Still today, the army uses the most pertinent speeds — whether it be in missiles or planes. . . .</em></p><p><em>There is no political power that can regulate the multinationals or the armed forces, which have greater and greater autonomy. There is no power superior to theirs. Therefore, either we wait for the coming of a hypothetical universal State, with I don’t know what Primate at its head, or else we finally understand that what is at the center is no longer a monarch by divine right, an absolute monarch, but an absolute weapon . The center is no longer occupied by a political power, but by a capacity for absolute destruction.” (45–46)</em></p><p>Closely related to the notion of speed is that of the vector, the grid formation and formulation of the earth, of perception and power. Recalling Montaigne’s style of indirection, Virilio’s project tracks down within the mobile and resourceful form of the essay an immense number of grid formations. Recalling Deleuze and Guattari, the discourse here on territoriality considers space relations in the optic of power, in the panopticonflict. In the contemporary situation, there is no assurance of a “natural” space to which one might return. The nuclear horizon eliminates the possibility of noble savagery while giving rise to generalized savagery in all sorts of local conflicts. As Adorno knew, thought has no Archimedean detachment but must proceed nonetheless according to the logic of the end. The trapped subject becomes the most observant of the system of imprisonment. She or he or it, the replicant on the run, is ready to seize the juncture of escape not only by confrontation but also by disguise and mimicry.</p><p>In fact, the mode of escape by vigilance conveys something of the trajectory of Virilio’s writings, his incessant translation of the point into the line. The <em>ligne de fuite </em>becomes for him, without being overtly claimed as such, a kind of radical obverse to the dictatorship of speed.</p><p>Speed can function as a sixth sense, be turned into a defense mechanism as well as suffered as tyrannical. The goal of the meditation on technology is not to freeze, to extract a still from the film that is constantly running, to retreat into the slowness of writing, but rather to bring writing up to speed. In this aim, whose success or failure is indeterminate as yet, the analysis of tendencies is turned into the deployment of counter-strategies.</p><p>Is it possible that thought must take on for this task a more mimetic behavior toward the “new technologies” in order not to be hopelessly confined to the archive, to lapidarian existence in the era of telecommunications? If so, the seat of knowledge must give way to a <em>pensée du dehors</em>, a nomad thought. This externalization of thought recalls Nietzsche’s invective against the <em>Sitzfleisch</em>, which he called the “true sin against the holy ghost,” opting instead for thinking while walking outdoors, or thinking as dancing. What Virilio resists is the sedentary path of science, that seeks to exhaust its subject and succeeds often in exhausting itself. At the same time, he pays closer attention to what the “hard sciences” have meant in their incessant interventions in the social sphere, attempting for instance to comprehend the mentality of the military technocrat, and the logic of his products.</p><p>Virilio’s books are written in the form of essays. They are dense and circular, sometimes repetitive; arguments repeat themselves, but always to go off in unexpected directions, rather than repeat the same genealogy. The essay form allows him to pursue the interdisciplinary vocation of global detective, pursuing tendencies, taking evidence. But the note-taking is not primarily manifested as a textual operation. It involves sifting through books, but also and more notably the traversing of contemporary landscapes. Nor is it leisurely.</p><p>Lotringer puts it this way:</p><p><em>“What seduced me from the beginning is precisely that a book on speed should be so rapid. We’ve gotten too used to seeing ‘the end of the book’ proclaimed in books that are themselves interminable. Your work is not voluminous because it is itself ‘vehicular.’” (41).</em></p><p>III.</p><p>Call technology by its secret name, know its passwords: this perspective makes Virilio’s enterprise a perilous one. The stakes are increased, which means both the risks and the rewards are accelerated when writing treats itself to speed. One of the risks, as he notes in a passage quoted above, is not to be trusted, another is to desire the abstract machine. The rewards are tactical maps of the interpenetrations of various forms of technology, or more precisely human-machine</p><p>symbiosis slash metempsychosis. That inventions play on each other, that machines rely on certain previous machines while making others obsolete, is not exactly news, but certainly bears further examination in the light shed by this type of analysis. Four of the great blocks of activity where speed organizes itself are the military (the business of war), business (the manipulation of wealth), travel (the violence of projection), and entertainment (the culture industry).</p><p>These blocks cannot be seen apart from each other — they all preserve the division of labor even as speed preserves them, keeping them not merely running but accelerating.</p><p>Acceleration is the movement of movement and is essential in the current production and maintenance of power and knowledge in all these areas. Each builds on the knowledge forged by the others; they all enjoy both parasitical and hegemonic existences, and the postwar global situation witnesses various grotesque couplings of the spheres of work and play, confrontation, and leisure. A quick glance at new devices shows not how firm the commodity structure is but its reckless trajectory, which comes to look more and more like a death drive. England’s dream is a shopping scheme, as Johnny Rotten knew.</p><p>Pershing and MX missiles, CD players and dub decks, speed metal and hardcore, metros, walk things, moving sidewalks, microwaves, private helicopters, ready tellers, modems: all function by accelerating flows, and by creating multiple interfaces between hysterical bodies and hyperactive machines.</p><p>IV.</p><p>Dromology may not be a philosophy per se, but it is a return to philosophy’s beginnings. As a meditation on the formal constraints of life, it provides perhaps a further chapter in Adorno’s <em>Minima Moralia</em>, which was subtitled “Reflections from Damaged Life.” Damaged life is life spent under the negative horizon, in the confines first of the European fortress during WWII, then in the aftermath(s), which Virilio sees as the reign of Total Peace under nuclear dictatorship — war pursued by other means.</p><p>Subjectivity is not depth or interiority, but the “unable body” subjugated within the prosthesis, hurtling forward in time and space, circulating but never arriving.</p><p>Unlike Adorno, Virilio doesn’t seem to retain much old-world nostalgia. His — and ours even more extremely — is a quite different generation. He does, however, preserve an intimate connection between lived experience (reified or not, <em>Erlebnis </em>or <em>Erfahrung </em>) and writing. He begins his books <em>Bunker Archéologie</em>, <em>L’Insécurité du territoire </em>and <em>L’Horizon négatif </em>with observations on his personal relationship to some external event, situation, or representational problem. In the first of these books, he remembers discovering after the postwar liberation of the coast of France the hugeness of the beach’s horizon, and the presence of a bunker, full of hidden signification. In the second, it is Nantes at the end of the war, the terror he experiences in relation to the sky, occupied by planes. In the third, he recalls his efforts to paint in a new</p><p>manner, concentrating on the spaces between objects, to combat fabricated objects with the study of “antiforms.” He writes: “The eclipse of anti-forms seemed to me like the consequence of a sort of imperialism of apprehension.” (22). In each case, a curiosity about space leads to reflections on its territorializations.</p><p>Subjectivity in these conditions necessitates a vigilant observation and creative appropriation of what he calls the “field of vision.” Its deformed character is a result of the violence of speed, of technologization and formalization, the narrowing of Borges’ bifurcating paths to rigid vectors of delivery. The price enacted from the body doesn’t have to be characterized in the language of hermeneutic depth or that of reification; although he doesn’t rule out these ways of gaining access to subjectivity, Virilio prefers to investigate concrete situations involving the harnessing of machines, where the subject becomes a “voyeur-voyageur.”</p><p>The term projection can be introduced here; it is apt due to its overlapping of the registers of television/film and transportation. The seat of subjectivity is henceforth a spectral one, a hurtling through space in the surroundings of immobility, otherwise known as comfort. Virilio’s discussion in <em>L’Horizon négatif </em>of the <em>monture</em>* focuses on the situation of immobility. He traces man’s self-harnessing to animals (the horse as the first machine of war). His analysis moves from a nomadic configuration in which women served as the means of transport for the man, to the later use of the horse as a seat of power and velocity which would dominate the exercise of war.</p><p>Later forms of <em>monture</em> become so many facts (or facticities) of daily existence; Virilio details the “violence of speed” in the development of vectors of transport, evaluating not simply the specifics of the comfort-immobility syndrome, but travel as a form of logistics.** Space and then time undergo transformations that turn them into grids. With the development of technologies of transport from the early <em>chemin de fer </em>to the Concorde, time itself becomes habitable. One takes up residence in speed when traveling. This residence, the Grand Hotel Abyss of our times, is characterized at its extreme by continual motion around the globe. One example offered is the case of the homeless PLO terrorist whose field of action is the airplane and the airport, places of speed and circulation, of continual transit. The violence of terrorism situates itself within and mimics in a complicated way the “violence of displacement” that constitutes air travel.</p><p>Integral to this way of pinpointing the violence in the machine are considerations relating to the inertia of the passenger.</p><p>For Virilio, the politics of travel must go beyond discussions of the need for increases of security via seat belts and surveillance and treat instead the whole procedure of harnessing, the problematic subject whose trajectory displays very little choice, whose choices have been made for her or him on a pervasive scale and yet give off the surface glow of normality, i.e. invisibility. This happens in relation to consciousness in the time frame of always- already, as what Adorno calls a “prehistorical surgical intervention.” The political unconscious is a militarized one.</p><p>The medium is a massage. Not only in the one- way communication of television is this true; travel and communications and world-vision technologies all share an origin in the deployment of an economy of war. For Virilio, the massage of entertainment forms the flipside of the state of emergency, although individual productions can help illustrate and work on the situation in crucial ways. The era of nuclear deterrence is also an era of the deterrence of the nomadic or meandering path in favor of the vector. The connections here are perhaps obvious, as grids have become a recurring fantasy in the cartesian-goyesque sleep of reason. But Virilio succeeds at lending a convincing background to their articulation. His book <em>Guerre et cinéma: Logistique de la perception</em>, tackles the utilization of filming techniques in conjunction with air missions in WWII. The crossbreeding of technologies appears to be the true terrain of Virilio’s new science (or anti-science) of observation. <em>Bunker Archéologie </em>used an archeological method to discuss the profound connection of the military and a specific architecture that would house its lookouts and strongholds; <em>Logistique de la perception </em>pursues another constellation of technical knowledges, that of war and cinema.</p><p>The thesis is that arms are a means of perception and that cinema is an armament. Cameras mounted on reconnaissance planes provide an exemplary chapter in the colonialization of space/time in the name of knowledge of and for destruction. This constellation of machines also hastens the connection between imperialism of the gaze and war as penetration, the production of information and territoriality. This is, of course, war in the old sense, or rather in a recent or previous sense. The end of the Second World War was also the inauguration of Pure War.</p><p>Virilio ascribes the term “state delinquencies” to the range of armed conflicts since Hiroshima. Global insecurity henceforth constitutes the planet’s atmosphere, while Pure War is conducted hypothetically from command centers staffed by immobile bodies. In Speed and Politics, Virilio details the strategies of tension that color every aspect of political economy but extend as well into the immense machine of culture exemplified but by no means exhausted by Hollywood.</p><p>Speed is the <em>ground </em>of current first-world culture, and this culture is still and always imperialistic, tending to spread its vectors around the globe, exporting and replicating itself in insidious, digestible bits. Speed is the form, content, and apotheosis of culture. It reaches its millenarian stage with music video, which deterritorializes perception by a flux of images and noise, but reterritorializes it without fail as commodity. “Overaccelerated speed renders us unconscious,” he says. Speed sells, speed can be packaged, but it also takes the senses over a certain apperceptive threshold, and points in the process to a sort of cannibalistic enterprise; speed eats the body because the senses start having a hard time “keeping up.” Perhaps we are entering a final stage in the cult of sensation, in which our bodies are unable to enjoy the extreme pleasures that have been prepared for them with frenetic excess.</p><p>Here are two quotes, the first from Adorno’s <em>Minima Moralia</em>, the second from Virilio. Adorno writes in 1946:</p><p><em>Human dignity insisted on the right to walk, a rhythm not extorted from the body by command or terror. The walk, the stroll, were private ways of passing time, the heritage of the feudal promenade in the nineteenth century. . . .</em></p><p><em>Perhaps the cult of technical speed as of sport conceals an impulse to master the terror of running by deflecting it from one’s body and at the same time effortlessly surpassing it. The triumph of mounting mileage ritually appeases the fear of the fugitive. [162]</em></p><p>Virilio counters in 1983:</p><p><em>Movement is now only a handicap — a double handicap that we know only too well. A motor-handicap: a man in a car piloted by a driver (until such time as cars are completely automatic, which won’t take long) is motor- handicapped. In his own way, he is just as bed-ridden as Howard Hughes. The man sitting before his television watching the soccer championship live from Santiago in Chile is seeing-handicapped. For example, to be — as we are now — sitting in well-stuffed chairs is a postural comfort. Our muscles are relatively relaxed. They aren’t being called upon. It’s a postural comfort with respect to the body and to physiological materialness. Now, the prostheses of automotive-audio-visual movement create a subliminal comfort. Subliminal, meaning beyond consciousness. They allow a kind of visual — thus physical — hallucination, which tends to strip us of our consciousness. Subliminal comfort multiplies the speed of consciousness — the speed of the vivacity of reflection. This multiplication can be pleasant in relative acceleration, that is, within the boundaries of my consciousness; but these boundaries are very narrow, and if, as in certain cases of ‘invasion of privacy,’ someone should use speed to go beyond this, I am conditioned. This in fact what is called subliminal advertising and, of course, propaganda directed at entire populations. You see an image of which you are not at all conscious, it imposes itself on you without your being able to detect it because it goes too fast. The prosthesis is completely alienating. (74–5)</em></p><p>We have come a long way since Adorno’s memory of human dignity.</p><p>Without tackling here the full breadth of the connections made by both of these thinkers, or contemplating for too long the abyss that separates Adorno’s culture industry from ours, let me note that Virilio’s analyses of the war machine are fruitfully transplanted to the study of film, at least at what Lotringer calls the episto-technical level. But to pose the operation as one of transplantation is perhaps unfair to his vision. Culture itself in its massive form, its American form, its first-world form, its commodity form, its industrial form, grows out of war in innumerable ways. Just as Dada transposed the shock of the Great War onto language, the shock of Pure War is seen in current Hollywood productions, especially in their budgets. This type of cinema comes into its own as the most advanced dream machine in the era of war carried on by other means.</p><p>The clue that video offers the detective of these connections can be uncovered by drawing a parallel to the point of Virilio’s about the status of the body under what he calls “dromocracy.” He discusses the significance of air force pilots being equipped with whole head computers, visual mediators that process the raw data of trajectories, speed, horizon, target, etc., slowing down and simplifying the transmitted information. The body is outgrown by the technology it still fits into anachronistically. Examples of this type of operation can be multiplied and will no doubt continue to multiply. Donna Haraway has spoken of the cyborg (human body equipped with bits of machine) in a more positive light, that of feminist intervention, the possible freeing of the subjugated female body. In Virilio’s eyes, it remains at the services of a repressive regime of surveillance, engaged in the disciplining of territory, but also the further refinement of the obsolete body.</p><p>* Monture: animal for riding, mount; mounting, setting, frame, support, socket . . .</p><p>** Logistics: branch of military science involving the procuring, maintaining and transporting of materiel, personnel and facilities . . .</p><p>Daniel L Potter, Cornell University, 1987</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5764f4bf0cfa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dedication of the Perfect Park Peace Monument]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/dedication-of-the-perfect-park-peace-monument-8b614ccc91f8?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b614ccc91f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peacemovement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[1960s]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[isla-vista]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monuments]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Oct 2020 23:02:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-18T23:37:05.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://bobpotter.org/">Bob Potter</a> (1934–2010)</p><p>June 10, 2003</p><figure><img alt="Bank of Amerika Burning Check Poster Isla Vista" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9eDU1r3XpuByvKxNYI02rg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A third of a century ago, our forefathers … and foremothers — and fore-motherfuckers — hippies and yippies; speed freaks and Jesus freaks; Students radicalized by their professors; Professors radicalized by their students; Anarchists, Pacifists and Registered Republicans; Flower Children, Franciscan Friars and pissed-off Football Players; Marxist-Leninists and Proto-Feminists; Surfers, Sorority Sisters and Sexual Revolutionaries; Space Cadets and Vietnam Vets; the Hare Krishna and the Woodstock Nation; Visionaries in all colors and Mindblown lead guitarists of non-existent bands; not to mention winos, transients, alcoholics Anonymous and Otherwise, the Chairman of the Sociology Department and ordinary college students caught up in the pure adrenalin of the moment —</p><p>All of these people, and indescribable hundreds more, made history with their asses, by sitting down on them here in Perfect Park, in violation of a Police Curfew Order, linking arms to defend their community.</p><p>What could have brought so many unlikely people — including more than a few still alive here in this audience — to that outlandish act of defiance? Tonight, exactly 33 years later, it is worth looking back briefly, and as unsentimentally as possible under the circumstances, to remember what a hell of a mess things had gotten into.</p><p>To begin with, there was the <strong>Vietnam Crisis</strong>. By early 1968, with the February Tet Offensive, the American public had begun to wise up to the fact it had been lied to (does that sound familiar?) and that the Vietnam War had become unwinnable, though young Americans continued to be drafted and killed in action by the thousands. This quickly brought on a <strong>Political Crisis</strong>, as President Lyndon B. Johnson was driven from the race in that Presidential Election Year by antiwar activists led by Eugene McCarthy and later Bobby Kennedy — whose assassination after the California primary in June brought chaos and deceit in its wake, a tumultuously rigged Democratic Convention and a bloody police riot in the streets of Chicago. And this coincided with a perilous turning point in the <strong>Racial Crisis</strong> in America. The non-violent insurgence of the Civil Rights movement to overturn segregation ended in calamity, with the murder of Martin Luther King on April 4, 1968, touching off catastrophic urban riots across the country, and calls for Armed Struggle. The backlash from all of this brought the election in November of Richard Nixon as President of the United States.</p><p>It was in the long shadow of these events that activism — violent and non-violent — came to the sunny shores of Santa Barbara. Thanks to the EOP program, an early example of Affirmative Action, the previously lily-white UCSB campus was integrated — though the Black students who arrived were unhappy enough with their treatment by campus bureaucracy and local law enforcement that one day they took over North Hall — the campus Computer Center! That every bit of the campus’ computing went on in one small building tells you how long ago that was. The peaceful settlement worked out by the UCSB administration, brought the promise of more minority faculty and students, and new Black Studies and Chicano Studies Departments — but triggered a vicious denunciation from Governor Ronald Reagan, who had won his job in the first place by attacking student demonstrators at Berkeley, an ongoing <strong>Educational Crisis</strong>.</p><p>Concurrently an <strong>Environmental Crisis</strong> had erupted, with the Santa Barbara Oil Spill of January 1968, the single worst ecological disaster of our times, and the opening gun in a war of attrition between developers and environmentalists that continues along this coast to this very day. The oil-soaked dead birds on the beach turned surfers and ordinary beachgoers overnight into radical activists.</p><p>Meanwhile, thanks to the baby boom, UCSB had doubled its enrollment between 1954 and 58, doubled it again by 1963, and again by 1967. Too busy building classrooms to bother with dormitories, the University solved its problems by steering this avalanche of students into substandard overcrowded apartment houses thrown up overnight by private land speculators and slum landlords, creating a demographic dystopia called Isla Vista, and precipitating a <strong>Housing Crisis</strong> (well, there’s always a Housing Crisis in Isla Vista).</p><p>And all of this, let’s remember, was unfolding generationally in the throbbing context of the <strong>Countercultural Crisis</strong> of the 1960s, that sexually-pioneering, musically-energized, chemically-induced metaphysical vision quest and psychedelic light show. Oh, you should have been here!</p><p>But if you were, you’ll remember the pain and disillusion of it too. Woodstock led on to Altamont. Repression and violence were as American as Apple Pie, as Black militant H. Rap Brown pointed out. There were signs of trouble locally as early as 1969, with the arrest of 7 Black student leaders by the Santa Barbara Sheriffs on the pretext of an eviction notice, bringing student demonstrators out by the thousands. And April of that year brought the first death, when a bomb set off in the Faculty Club killed an innocent custodian, named Dover Sharp — a senseless, violent crime still unsolved.</p><p>In the fall came news of the firing of a popular (and decidedly countercultural) Anthropology professor. The <strong>Bill Allen Crisis</strong>, which culminated in massive demonstrations and a petition signed by 7,776 students demanding an open hearing on his personnel case, was at once a carnivalesque assault on academic pomposity and a serious protest against the ivory tower obliviousness of much of the faculty, at a time when the world seemed literally to be coming apart. Bill Allen had the temerity to speak to students about what was on (and in) their minds, and it seemed he had been fired precisely for doing so.</p><p>And speaking of injustice, there were nightly TV news clips of the bizarre show trial of the Chicago Seven, with Judge Julius Hoffman railroading criminal Conspiracy charges against antiwar activists who barely knew one another, with Black leader Bobby Seale gagged and bound in the courtroom. At the year’s end, as Tom Hayden, one of the defendants, came to speak on campus, a <strong>Crisis of Justice</strong> was palpable across America. Could we trust our traditional institutions, or were they in the process of failing us, precipitating anarchy and revolution — or maybe fascism?</p><p>It was in such incendiary times that <strong>Isla Vista</strong> burst into flames 33 years ago, putting this most improbable trouble spot on the world map forever after. In the first few months of 1970, there were to be three major civil disorders.</p><p>In January came huge campus protests against the firing of Bill Allen, and the calling of Santa Barbara Sheriffs to clear the Administration Building of protestors, with Captain Joel Honey, the loose cannon of the Sheriffs Tactical Squad, leading the charge. As Allen’s appeal for an open hearing was turned down, with the arrest of 19 student leaders, matters careened off-campus and out of control. On February 26, after a rousing speech by William Kunstler, the lawyer for the Chicago Seven, and the beating of student leader Rich Underwood by police, crowds gathered in the Isla Vista streets and attacked Realty Offices and the Bank of America, seen as the prime local symbol of the Establishment. Later that night, having chased off the police presence, the crowd set a fire in the lobby of the bank and then watched in amazement as the place burned to the ground.</p><figure><img alt="Perfect Park Peace Monument, Isla Vista near UCSB" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/693/1*DxooeclGwDqVFwrG9HI1yQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Perfect Park Peace Monument, Isla Vista, California</figcaption></figure><p>The ashes of the bank were still smoldering the next day as Governor Ronald Reagan arrived in town to vilify the bank burners as “cowardly little bums” and call in the National Guard. The Bank of America took out nationwide full-page advertisements offering a $25,000 reward for the arrest of the arsonists, vowing to rebuild the bank. Reagan’s call for a campus crackdown seemed to be heeded shortly afterward, when Chancellor Vernon Cheadle banned Chicago Seven defendant Jerry Rubin from speaking on campus, saying it would “seriously threaten the welfare of the University.” Unappeased, Reagan made a speech to a Growers Convention on April 7, in which he made the following infamous statement about campus disorders: “If it’s to be a bloodbath, let it be now.”</p><p>It seemed he didn’t have long to wait. On April 16, after a campus speech by Berkeley radical Stu Albert calling on students to “rip off the pigs,” there was an angry rally in Perfect Park, then a vacant lot at the end of the Embarcadero loop that had become an informal community gathering place. As night fell the new temporary bank was attacked, as were realty offices; other students — protesting the violence — defended the bank and extinguished fires. The police waded into the middle of this melee, firing tear gas and birdshot into the crowd indiscriminately, from dump trucks specially outfitted for the occasion — an action that was dubbed “Operation Wagontrain”. The next night the violence (and the resistance against it) resumed — with tragic consequences. As police arrived in riot gear, amid reports of sniper fire, anti-violence students were attempting to defend the temporary bank from assault. One of them, Kevin Moran, was shot and killed.</p><p>KCSB the campus radio station was covering these events live, with reporters in the field, as they had previous demonstrations. Fearing that the reports were giving away police tactics and deployments, Sheriff James Webster demanded that the University authorities close down the station — an order with which Vice-Chancellor Steven Goodspeed complied. So it was that the only recorded silencing of a radio station by government order in American history took place, right over there on the UCSB campus. The death of Moran was attributed to snipers, and a dawn-to-dusk curfew was imposed, with heavy police patrols and reports of beatings and apartments broken into. On April 20, as Governor Reagan made a speech blaming Moran’s killing on those who “take the law into their own hands,” it was revealed that a Santa Barbara policeman had admitted that his rifle had “accidentally” discharged at the time of Moran’s shooting. In a subsequent Coroner’s inquest, held with little public scrutiny, the shooting of Kevin Moran would be ruled to be accidental, and the policeman, Officer David Gosselin, exonerated and returned to duty.</p><p>Less than two weeks later President Nixon astonished the world, escalating the Vietnam War by invading Cambodia. The resulting firestorm of protest spread from coast to coast. At Kent State, Ohio National Guard troops fired into a crowd of protesting students, killing 4 of them. UCSB students occupied and closed the Santa Barbara airport, and surged onto the 101 Freeway, blocking it for many hours. As Universities across the country began to close down, the UCSB faculty was energized, at last, moving quickly and effectively to keep our community together, by offering special “national crisis” courses focusing on the circumstances of the times.</p><p>It seemed that the school year might end quietly, but events intervened once again. On June 3 news leaked out that 17 people — student leaders and activists, the “usual” suspects — had secretly been indicted, accused of burning down the Bank of America. One of those indicted had in fact been in jail the night of the bank burning. The resulting outrage led to further street and campus demonstrations, including attempts to torch the temporary bank. With disorder in Isla Vista once again, State officials, apparently acting on instructions from Governor Reagan’s office, ordered the Los Angeles County Sheriffs to dispatch their Special Enforcement Branch to restore order. Instead, this notoriously violent paramilitary outfit, which had cracked heads in many urban riots, brought a reign of terror into Isla Vista. On June 8 and 9, enforcing a dusk-to-dawn curfew, the LA Sheriffs, accompanied by local law enforcement units, kicked down doors, dragged Isla Vistans from their houses, beat them bloody with their nightsticks, sexually harassed and intimidated, destroyed vehicles and personal property, sprayed mace and threw tear gas canisters into private yards and dwellings, threatening to shoot to kill.</p><p>At this very dark moment came Isla Vista’s finest hour. With their streets under siege the next day, June 10, a group of faculty, student, and community leaders met in the Methodist to seek a collective strategy. They decided to organize a sit-in in Perfect Park that night, to protest the police repression. By the time of the 7:30 curfew, a quiet and determined crowd of some 700 had gathered, including UCSB faculty and staff and students of all social and political persuasions. When the police began arresting them for curfew violations, they reacted with calm, non-violent acceptance in the tradition of Gandhi and Martin Luther King. At 9:20, with nearly 300 arrested, police ordered the remaining crowd to disperse. When no one moved, the police sprayed pepper gas from a machine directly into the crowd. Then, as the Santa Barbara News-Press described it the next day, “gas-masked deputies swarmed into the crowd, flailing their nightsticks in all directions.” Those arrested were hauled away to the still-unfinished New County Jail where many were subjected to further beatings, denied bail, abused, stripped naked, sprayed with mace, and thrown into solitary confinement.</p><p>But a crucial moral point had been made. Judge Joseph Lodge ordered charges dismissed against all those arrested and, faced with an ultimatum from University officials, Governor Reagan agreed to end the curfew and withdraw the L.A. Sheriffs. Peace returned to the streets of Isla Vista. The promised bloodbath had been averted, and the task of creating new institutions for the Isla Vista community had begun.</p><p>In the aftermath of the 1970 riots, a whole array of community institutions came into being in Isla Vista. The IV Recreation and Park District would go on to become a dynamic force in the establishment of parks and other public venues for the first time, along with the dream of cityhood (with or without Goleta). The University began to provide funds and pay belated if sporadic attention to its unruly stepchild; one tangible result was the IV Foot Patrol, putting officers into direct daily contact with the community. Also established were the IV Credit Union, the IV Medical Clinic (bringing the inimitable Dr. Dave Bearman to town), the Isla Vista Youth Projects, and the IV Food Co-op which remain vital and highly-value institutions to this day. In short, a true community was born, out of the courage and solidarity of the Perfect Park sit-in.</p><p>It was in an effort to commemorate that event and in a larger sense the spirit of peaceful protest that is the most important legacy of the Vietnam era, that some visionaries set out in the early 1990s to create a Monument in Perfect Park. They had to begin by saving the Park itself!</p><p>Perfect Park had been purchased in the 1970s by a Santa Monica doctor who wanted to build a Safeway Supermarket. Only the long Goleta Water moratorium prevented him from doing so. In 1992 — eleven years ago! — Isla Vista voters approved a referendum saving Perfect Park from the developers, and two years later the Park District bought the property. Carmen Lodise, the historian and unofficial <em>Alcalde</em> of Isla Vista, was probably the first to propose building a monument to the anti-war movement on the site. That Carmen was proposing it guaranteed that certain other people would oppose it — and so indeed they did. Critics denounced the whole idea as an attempt to glorify bank-burners and bomb-throwers, waste taxpayers’ money, and enrich unspecified cronies.</p><p>In 1995 — eight years ago! — the IV Park District decided to appoint a committee to study the issue, including both proponents and opponents. Against my better judgment (I had, after all, co-authored a book on the IV Riots) I applied to join it. Despite our disagreements, we held some useful public forums and learned that the IV community generally liked the idea. Most thought it should be a positive symbol for Peace, to unite rather than divide the community.</p><p>When the committee was reconstituted in 1996, we adopted a mission statement that made clear our commitment to honoring peaceful protest. We further decided that the monument should be built with private donations rather than public funds — a noble idea, though easier said than done. And as for what the thing should look like, there were dozens of conflicting strong opinions. A consultation with the County Art Commission yielded the bright idea of a national design competition, which of course we couldn’t afford to finance. Here the amazing people at the Fund For Santa Barbara came to our rescue in 1997, funding a $3,800 grant, which enabled us to reach artists all over the country.</p><p>To vet the entries, we appointed a Selection Committee of arts professionals and community representatives (including John Muir, a combat veteran of the Vietnam war, who is here today). In June 1998 — five years ago! — the committee picked 6 finalists, who were given $500 grants to build models of their proposed monument designs. The following year, as fundraising began with a goal of $20,000, we held three public exhibitions of the models, on campus and in IV, gathering input and reactions to the designs; Santa Barbara artist Colin Gray’s design for a cluster of arches proved to be the public favorite. In May 1999 — four years ago! — our committee voted to recommend Colin’s design be built, and the IV Park District Board accepted the recommendation, authorizing the monument to be built on Park District land here in Perfect Park. Now, all we had to do was raise $20,000.</p><p>Thanks to a flock of small donations, and a few large ones (thank you, Michael Douglas, and Richard and Tekla Sanford, for your $1,000 checks!) plus two generous grants of $2,500 from the IV Community Relations Council of the UCSB Associated Students, we had by June of 2001 — two years ago! — raised some $13,000.</p><p>They say that everything changed after September 11, 2001. That was indeed the case with our project. Suddenly, with the war in Afghanistan, a Peace Monument began to seem like a timely idea, rather than an exercise in nostalgia. People who had written us off as a bunch of aging hippies began to understand what we were up to and pay attention. In January Congresswoman Lois Capps lent her name and support to our effort, speaking at a campus gathering where Colin’s model was displayed, with television coverage from KEYT. In May 2002 — just a year ago! — filmmaker and film critic Peter Biskind came to town to show his infamous documentary <em>Don’t Bank on Amerika</em> and help us raise over $2,000, and someone found a stash of old Burning Bank Check Posters and donated them to the cause.</p><p>As the Bush administration began its push toward war with Iraq, our small Peace project rode the wave of public outrage and protest as the Peace movement came alive all across the globe. Daniel Ellsberg came to town and joined our honorary board of advisors, which by then included Dick Flacks, David Krieger, Tom Hayden, Marc McGinnis, David Smith and Terence Hallinan In February of this year, as the war clouds gathered, the L.A. Times ran a prominent feature story on our project.</p><p>That same week, — less than four months ago! — still $9,000 shy of our new goal of $25.000, I picked up the telephone to find that I was speaking with someone who wanted the Perfect Park Peace Monument to be built — and had the courage and the money to make it happen. Thanks to that visionary donor — who has insisted on remaining anonymous! — we received an astonishing pledge of $9,000 and broke ground in April.</p><p>So thanks to all the hundreds of people who made this possible — Diane Conn, Dave Bearman and Carmen Lodise still on the committee, and all the others who served time on it, including Mitch Stockton, Karl Brunner, Brent Foster, Dave Fortson, Leila Salazar, Ariana Katovich and untold others. And let’s not forget someone whose reckless and disastrous actions put our initiative back on page one and turned the Peace movement from a distant memory to an international necessity — President George W. Bush!</p><p>But finally, our thanks must go to the people who, 33 years ago tonight, made a commitment to non-violence and kept it so memorably, who took a beating unflinchingly, looked repression in the face, and pepper gas in the eye — the people who made this ground historic when they put their asses on the line.</p><p>Bob Potter</p><p><em>Professor Bob Potter, poet, playwright, UCSB professor, and political activist. Potter was a Fulbright Scholar at the University of Bristol who joined the UCSB Department of English faculty in 1966. He went on to join the UCSB Drama Department in 1972 and was head of the Playwriting Program until 2001. At UCSB, Potter was deeply affected by the student anti-Vietnam War protests and the subsequent riots in Isla Vista. With economist Jim Sullivan, Bob proudly co-authored “The Campus by the Sea Where the Bank Burned Down” for the Presidential Commission on Campus Unrest.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b614ccc91f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[She and It]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/she-and-it-bb7d77cda2ec?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb7d77cda2ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ecriture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Aug 2020 23:58:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-15T23:58:02.456Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h5heQgvYh6-TkRGs4Q3-Gg.jpeg" /></figure><p>To come to an understanding of the predicament, there is much to be unearthed, and much to be washed away. Running into these persons who would not have been encountered in any other way, the intuition stepped in and led you there. There were signals, gestures of the universe opened to you, there to be read and responded to, there beyond the feeble hand and tongue, untranslatable except simply as here. Shooting into the light.</p><p>Here, listening to Kate Bush with no other intention than to do some preliminary work of sorting out my life. This is the work that needs to be done before I am to proceed further. Without this, all is a muddle, and cannot proceed. There has been a long hiatus from self, evident in the activities of erosion, entrance into worlds of others where one does not belong, far-flung internally corrosive intentions that the unconscious works at against the grain of the intuition. The intuitive method must return, must come back into play, as it is needed. We all need each other, and these persistent ones who seem to value the brother who has dropped by the wayside and may never be heard of again.</p><p>With her, there is a warning away from relationship of the ruinous kind. She seeks a dropping away of the game and weaves herself back down to zero. She is totally there; she is two eyes of the ultimate. She extends herself to us as a new friend, and there is the euphoria of the first day between us, as we wheel around like absurdity itself, the fool for a day who cares nothing for the reactions of the backdrop people.</p><p>From here it is backward, as her words point. Backward toward a simpler design, a more workable plan, a modesty that still will not give up on ecstasy. Let’s wipe, sweep, and rampage that bullshit away. Let’s erase some of the years, some of the murderous instances. Let’s give but not be taken. We are the Fool, but we are no fools. One honest eyeful, one new breath, one gasp of an extraterrestrial sincerity that might be held in damaged lungs a lifetime long and nourish. Back then to the clean surface, the few words, the grace which accompanies every birth. With this music, I’ll be there, now and at the end of time. They will find their way out of this zone; they will migrate without a plan but with all the love that flows through their limbs. Unfortunately, the scars cannot be removed, but they can be caressed, tattooed, and laughed at.</p><p>Thanks also to her, who calls as a voice of belief and who is similarly beyond the beyond and who yet possesses a heart, and always will. Let’s gather our notes from the beyond. Thanks to she who encourages shorter saner projects and who would encourage him to go to Berlin in the winter, to put something major behind him and to tap at the future, or just sit dumbfounded in the presence, but of nothing and what matter. And to the sisters who are aglow. Who don’t seem to know this demon, who do not seek to awaken the slumbering beast. What did it, and how far back does that ricocheting crime lie? Wake or drown, the boat is loaded with disease and patience has been worn thin.</p><p>Remember how you did it in the past. Remember that you are meant to fall into the arms of the longed for. Remember your dreams before you reach for the coffee.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb7d77cda2ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Happy *day Chris Marker :: 2015]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/happy-day-chris-marker-2015-5e950e9234e8?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e950e9234e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Mar 2018 03:51:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-22T03:51:41.419Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*8A3tWZl5EHQ4ig9P.jpg" /></figure><p>Bon anniversaire Chris!</p><p>What else is there to say? Everything’s been said. Birth and death like an oroborous, the legendary snake eating its tail, where the date July 29, 1921 superimposes itself on another date, July 29, 2012. The two dates merge in an origami fold. Inside the fold is an extraordinary life and a wealth of extraordinary works. Inside is a cat, stretching its paws to the sound emanating from the speakers, a cat reclining on a keyboard. Inside is a love affair with cinema, and a Japanese bow to Kurosawa, Tarkovsky and Hitchcock. Inside is a spiral, a tree trunk, the madness of time. Inside are thousands of photographs, each emanating the gaze of the master spectator, the man behind the camera and very rarely in front of it. Inside the fold are memories and a system of memories, strongholds against the onslaught of history’s wounds, erasures, distortions. Inside the fold is the Zone, a place where images mutate and take on disguises, where seekers wander in search of lost time, where stray dogs pace and owls sit with observant eyes, recording. The birth and the death touch like this, like the creation of Adam. The original breath of the baby, the last breath of the old man, still working, always working. The tears of friends and lovers, innumerable fans for the most famous of the unknowns. A loss is felt, because we care for the visions given to us by a man of vision. We care for the traces, relics, breadcrumbs left as a puzzle for our minds but also our hearts. Mysteries of time and remembrance, tastes of the futures fractal in the micro/macro, traces of the places he traveled. The dogs are crazy on the island of Sal, and all the other islands. “I found my dogs pretty nervous tonight; they were playing with the sea as I had never seen them before. Listening to Radio Hong Kong later on I understood: today was the first day of the lunar new year, and for the first time in sixty years the sign of the dog met the sign of water.” He was an island but also a continent, unfindable on any map. There be dragons. There be mysteries. There be celebration, rueful meditation and admiration.</p><p>Originally: <a href="https://chrismarker.org/happy-birthday-chris-marker-2/">https://chrismarker.org/happy-birthday-chris-marker-2/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e950e9234e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fate of Salt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/fate-of-salt-89ca43475469?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89ca43475469</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ancestors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persian-rugs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[salt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poem]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Mar 2018 01:29:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-10T01:29:49.608Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Saltshakers everywhere<br>In slow motion<br>Fall off a table<br>All salt once tears<br>Disappears</p><p>Ancestors<br>In gemstone homes<br>Reunite bare-footed<br>Walk on sand floors<br>In nirvanic stupor</p><p>Each pauses to hug <br>An ether being<br>On a Persian rug</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89ca43475469" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wounded Time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/wounded-time-on-sans-soleil-bbb59990c6b5?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbb59990c6b5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[essay-film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sans-soleil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chris-marker]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 22:32:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-18T02:38:20.989Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b_nWyyvRddQzTQq7CZzKcA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Chris Marker, Sans Soleil</figcaption></figure><h4>Notes on Sans Soleil</h4><p>Daniel L Potter</p><p><em>Originally published on </em><a href="http://chrismarker.org/chris-marker-2/wounded-time/"><em>chrismarker.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><blockquote><em>Rien ne distingue les souvenirs des autres moments: ce n’est que plus tard qu’ils se font reconnaître, à leurs cicatrices.” — Chris Marker, </em>La Jetée</blockquote><blockquote><em>“History is essentially longitudinal, memory essentially vertical. History essentially consists of passing along the event. Being inside the event, memory essentially and above all consists of not leaving it, staying in it and going back through it from within.” — Gilles Deleuze, </em>Cinema II</blockquote><h4>Time Travel</h4><p>This viewing, the sixth or seventh, I decided not to take notes, but to let the film wash over me, and the friend and friend of a friend who had shown up.</p><ul><li>The city as theater of memories — everything in its place upon the return to Tokyo. The film as art of memory — every sight and sound “placed” in an architecture of remembering, in which the recording device doubles and begins to erode unaided memory.</li><li>Memory versus history: the personal wound against the onset of global oblivion.</li></ul><p>The protagonist, photographer, letter-writer, veiled self-portrait of Chris Marker, returns “home” to the 15,000,000 inhabitants of Tokyo: returning home to a huge, anonymous, and still familiar foreign city, rather than to the home, family, or nation of residence. Nomadic belonging substitutes for the “maison” as palace of memory. There is a transcendental homelessness to <em>Sans Soleil</em>, and it represents one of the most poignant aspects of this masterpiece, as expressed for instance in the two sequences from Iceland, one by Marker of three blond children walking on a country road, one filmed a year later by Harun Tazieff, footage of the volcano eruption which covers the town where Marker lived and filmed, and where his memory is entrapped.</p><p>Tazieff’s footage includes a shot of the black cat with white paws which the fictional i/eye of the narration claims to recognize from 1965. There is a gap in time, the expulsion of the remembering subject into a non-memory, an anti-memory and beyond into a kind of active forgetting which is still the privilege of the human being in the era “before memory was perfected.”</p><p>We are within an exploration of nonlinear or shamanic time. The healer comes from the future: 4001, the “era of full employment of memory.” This journey back, paralleling the unforgettable story of <em>La Jetée</em>, invokes a complex philosophy of time, a focus on the idea of compassion, and a counterpoint, as Marker says, to “all the stories of men who have lost their memories” — this one treating “a man who has lost forgetting.”</p><p>This whole science fiction speculation is accompanied by a suite of images of the city of San Francisco, Iceland, etc. and seems to offer a view from 4001, a selective fanning through time-images: “sheets of past,” as Deleuze phrases this ability of film narration. The music, the ebbs and flows of the montage, the sense of synchronicity which begins to surge as we enter further into the film — these facets of <em>Sunless</em> link directly, indirectly, and obliquely with <em>La Jetée</em>, Marker’s famous time-travel film of 1962.</p><p>There is, in fact, a similar gap between scene one of Iceland and the volcanic reversal (history forgetting itself and leaving a wound, as the figure runs in another section of <em>Sans Soleil</em>) as exists between Marker’s two films — approximately twenty years. We see another filmic gap in the English version of <em>Le Fond de l’air est rouge</em>, <em>Cat Without a Grin</em>, which adds a new ending dialectically reflecting on the gap between 1977, the year of the completion of the first, and 1988, when the film was translated and re-edited for showing on British television.</p><p>The same melancholy of the temporal gap and of memory’s associative reappraisal comes into play: akin to Benjamin’s concept of history from the present, a present which views micrologically that which is a prehistory of itself, but suffers a separation from it by the immense gravity of ruin, decay, collapse.</p><p>This is the gap of the sunless world — a wound, or rather a constellation of wounds which infect the memory, and which find themselves occasionally transcribed into other media having lost none of their power. The image is perhaps fragmented, but salvaged by a word; words and images seek each other like two halves of a desiring equation, like one of the images of love in Plato’s <em>Symposium</em>.</p><p>This formation is a kind of antidote to the agonistic portrayal of the components of the emblem, a portrayal which commands Lessing’s <em>Laokoon</em>, newspaper practice, and the pitfalls of a major slice of modern documentary film practice.</p><p><em>La Jetée</em> is even, as I see it this time, directly referred to in the section on Hitchcock’s <em>Vertigo</em> and San(s) Francisco. Kim Novak points to the tree calendar, to the death of a tree which transforms it into a kind of reference point for the relativity of perspective etched into both Marker films, a radical concept of time which offers us the prospect of its nonlinear traversal.</p><p>Marker says: this scene occurs in Hitchcock’s film “and in another film.” The reference to <em>La Jetée</em> is quickly executed; in this, it points to a fundamental reduction of the self-portrait or authorial signature into interstitial moments which are nods, hints, brief unveilings within a greater obscurity of agency and self-reference.</p><p>Like Benjamin, Marker finds it difficult to speak in the first person and often opts out of this scenario of direct communication; neither, however, reject the I; in fact, the whole work of construction, arrangement, composition, architectonics concurrently take on the signature and even aspects of a theoretical and sensual desire.</p><p>One of the bases of this desire is the act of traversing, traveling, expanding the self through an immense and ongoing encounter with experience in the guise of material detail, which an exacting intelligence then goes over with the care of a painter.</p><p>This travel is not metaphorical, but practiced, and it involves a literal descent into the archive, of two types: the dust of the library, and the fragments of memory. Both are types of time-travel, and trace the engravings of time, legible, half-legible, and illegible.</p><p>It is no wonder that the dominant atmosphere in Benjamin and Marker is melancholia, the scent that of the collector wiping the dust off the foreign, and never returning home. Memory is a collection of images, and has been slowly externalized, into the apparatus of writing and recording, into the “electronic bible” which <em>Sans Soleil</em> evokes. “How did humans remember before they taped, filmed, photographed?” Marker asks himself this question as a veiled and retrospective autobiographical self-interrogation.</p><p>The film, as memory itself, submits to the distortions of the fallible, and accedes to the colorized and abstracted images of Hayao’s Zone, “homage to Tarkovsky,” who in turn is revealed as a major presence in Marker’s spiritualization.</p><p>The spiritual turn is brought out in the focus on ceremonies and in the commentary’s obsession with the partition between life and death. This strain of the film is akin on some levels to an orientalist discourse on Japan as other, but the clichés are couched in quotation marks, and the visual detail given minute attention.</p><p>Essaistic conclusions are provisional; they brush at the truth but contain a good dose of humor, and offer many outlets, resonances, chain reactions of thought in their wake. They do not claim to solve the hermeneutic intricacies of the visual image, but can on the other hand go so far as to hint at the mystery of the conjoining of the ear and the eye.</p><p>There are, in other words, moments of an intense and fervent meta-commentary in <em>Sans Soleil</em>; these moments are like epiphanies, and hit one unawares, always in or near to the gesture of self-effacement. The willingness to erase translates as a capacity for speed, for the blurred image which registers only subliminally in the sensory system of the spectator.</p><p>Such indeed is the situation of the tourist, whose journey is from ignorance and groping, unseeing movement through a foreign social space, towards a secret knowledge of the place, a place such as Tokyo.</p><p>Places abound in this film: one focus is the interstitial — shots in the beginning of Japanese asleep on a ferry are echoed by Tokyo commuters sleeping in the train. The story of transportation and the odd connections with the medium of film are told allegorically, in a tale of traveling, sleeping, dreaming, drifting off into imaginary worlds which are themselves like small films, pulling in as they do fragments of the experienced real, of television, of mythological image, comic, city street — all the phantasmagoria.</p><p>This may be a “cinema of the real” but it is no longer strictly documentary; the real expands to enclose the irreal, imagined, hallucinated. Marker documents and then splices in his projection of the dreamstate barely hidden behind every appearance. But for him, to document is to already transform into a lived dream, to bring out the singular aspects of subjects and objects, and their perverse relations.</p><p>The objects look back (“les objects m’aperçoivent”), as Klee said, and they also infiltrate every corner of the world. Department store steps are musical instruments, image and advertisement are everywhere. Marker finds in Tokyo a living cinema, a city on display constantly and basking in the proliferation of the image and the media landscape (as in a scene of a few poor men watching a huge bank of TV screens displaying a major sumo wrestling match).</p><p>There is a surveillance of the viewer by Japanese television — the eyes of prostrate women look straight into ours. The gaze is male, and murderous — filming is murder, as it preserves but also kills memory, and Marker cannot circumnavigate desire in his filming — a visual adulation of women, in short, a voyeurism, suffuses the film.</p><p>They are the other within the societies he traverses and records, and he from the outside; a syllogism is offered to the viewer, the site of an identification which is realized when Marker remarks of the Bissau women: “Women have always possessed a grain of indestructibility, and it has been man’s task to make her realize this as late as possible. But after seeing these African women [in the market], I wouldn’t bet on the men.” T</p><p>here is then the corresponding, earlier, shot of the women who skirts the camera with her eye as it is focused directly upon her for what might be taken as an uncomfortable length. Finally she gazes directly into the camera; this moment is clocked at 1/24 of a second, the length, as we are informed, of a single film frame.</p><p>Marker’s veiled commentary takes this into a critique of the rule in filmmaking to avoid direct eye contact with the camera; <em>Sans Soleil</em> strives for the perpendicular focus on the human face — this occurs in the train sequence in a kind of eerie eavesdropping on the sleeping, still upright passengers, each of whose portraits is taken. (Photos of the same subject matter appear in Marker’s photoessay books <em>Le Dépays</em> and <em>Staring Back</em>).</p><h4>Film at the Limits of the Visible</h4><p>Magic which is to be filmed leaves the residue of an enigma beneath the surface of the visually recorded/transcribed. One of the roles of commentary in film-magic is to reveal what the image as such leaves obscure; montage can perform this same function because it enables a play of analogies or correspondences which serve to suggest and imply the beyond-the-visible.</p><p>Such is the case with the train sequences of <em>Sans Soleil</em> in which Japanese passengers, having fallen asleep, are supplied in the montage with dream images spliced into shots of them with eyes closed, drifting off.</p><p>We go from the documented exterior to the imagined or projected interior in accord with Marker’s speculation earlier in the commentary about the dream nature of the whole of Tokyo, condensed in the long hypnotic shot of small tickets being given up to enter the subway. These tickets (in this scene preceding the train-dream sequence) are re-figured as entrance slips to the dream city, a kind of collective phantasmagoria which is the “ultimate film.”</p><p>This ultimate film resonates with Marker’s idea of the perfection of memory in the “magnetic Bible” of the future; together they provide an important moment of metaphysical auto-commentary: a limit situation which film as a memory system confronts, consisting of related notions of simultaneity, full memory, and the slippage of exhaustive documentation into dreamscape, cinema of the invisible, beyond the thin partition which separates life from death (as a related thematic of Marker’s discourse on Japan explores).</p><p>Proximate to full memory is the threat of a grand oblivion, and this proximity is treated explicitly as well. Memory, we hear early in the film, is not the obverse of forgetting but its “lining.”</p><p>Memory and forgetting are trails on a singular moebius strip which frustrates or undermines their differentiation, philosophic and cinematic. Marker translates this membrane, this lining, into one of the <em>fils conducteurs</em> (conducting threads) of <em>Sans Soleil</em>; it is not left intact, but found to be violated — the wound becomes the one survival, the one locus of continuity in history and memory, because the “progress” of each is seen to be a violent one.</p><p>History and memory are nonetheless incompatible; the one is the wound of the other. The loss of individual life is figured multiply: in the quotation of a farewell letter of a kamikaze pilot who dreams of a free Japan and who confesses that his mission relegates him to becoming a machine (or man-machine), entirely expendable in the greater war — memory obliterated by history.</p><p>There is also a key sequence of the death, or rather murder, of a giraffe, which forms one of the most painful moments of spectation; we hear the gunshot and see blood spurting from twin holes on either side of the giraffe’s long neck. We see it stumble and its legs give out, and are then witness to the vultures which descend on the helpless, awkward creature.</p><p>Marker creates here a quite singular and personal version of Eisenstein’s symbolic film, with its layers of effects, its woven patterns of space and time, its conceptual basis. The homage to Eisenstein which opens <em>Le Fond de l’air est rouge</em>, in the form of an essay on the Odessa steps, returns here more structurally and more subtly, in the direction of what can only be described as a set of interrelated thematics with moments of climax in a symbol which condenses what has been seen or is to be seen in a knot, a nexus of intensity or metaphoric takeover.</p><p>This sequence encodes Marker’s profound compassion for animals, which suffuses all of <em>Sans Soleil</em> and many other of his films as well, and it takes on the weight of visual allegory for his verbal speculations on “survival.”</p><p>Early on, Africa and Japan are introduced as the explicit topics (literally, places of discourse, sites of memory and seats of arguments as in rhetorical tradition); they are named the “two extreme poles of survival.”</p><p>Africa and Japan are linked through visual and philosophic means, visually through sequences of public celebrations — Carnival in Bissau (borrowed footage), a parade/dance in Tokyo, Shinjuko youth culture dances, African women in a marketplace, a military medal awarding ceremony conducted by Amilcar Cabral, as well as diverse ceremonies of acknowledging and commemorating death.</p><p>Apart from and before the giraffe, we are shown several dead animals in the sub-Sahara, laid out in what might have been a pond whose water has been absorbed and whose oval indentation in the earth is cracked, parched, the animal dead, dehydrated, and recorded mutely by the camera without commentary.</p><p>There is a very similar scene in Trinh T. Minh-ha’s first film, <em>Reassemblage</em>. Both are filmic gateways to Africa, and attempts to transcend tourist (and even ethnographer) status. Marker’s essaistic technique of utilizing threaded association (or the <em>fil conducteur</em>, as he mentioned in person in connection with his film <em>Le dernier Bolchevik</em> — in which he tells the history of the Soviet Union through the story of filmmaker Alexander Medvedkin), is nowhere more evident than in the way he weaves various topics, themes, visual and musical combinations, which are cross-stitched, delay-echoed, textured.</p><p><em>Sans Soleil</em> is a film about animals, but also about political struggle; about memory and space-time travel, but also about Hitchcock, poverty, guerilla struggle, dreams . . . . Both spaces and times (past present and future) are woven together, and if the whole seems to contain notable sections and a segmented architectural plan, this model coexists with multiple strategies of erasure of the perpendicularity of the cut.</p><p>Montage is put in the service of weaving, and this weaving is equally that of a fabric as of a magic spell or the multiple return of memories to the surface-screen of the mind.</p><p>Part of this weaving evolves in the vein of self-portraiture, a reflection on the journey of the self and its senses through space and time (we are the “third worlders of time,” returning to the past with the gaze but also the ears of compassion). Each scene as it finds its place in the structure/texture of the whole marks a lived moment — lived but mediated by the recording apparatus, and thus perhaps not fully lived but rather cut off by the intervention of the machine between the sense-body and the exterior.</p><p>The final film effects perhaps a redress of the transgressions of this mediation — of the intrusions of film recording between the subject and the world, and of the appropriation of individual subjects through eavesdropping, surveillance, imperialist salvation.</p><p>This redress takes place within a melancholic, confessional discourse which is simultaneously one of erasure and self-erasure.</p><p>The “Zone” images abundantly attest to a kind of will to erasure of the real through technological transformation. It is as if the distortion of form, color, sequence, and (not least, as we will see) sound, delineate a response of fatalism — pushing to the limit of a tendency, instead of backing away from the its consequences toward a previous, less mediated stage.</p><p>Technology, far from abandoned, is launched into the imaginary, and begins interpretation again from the perspective of an artificial intelligence.</p><p>One of the moments of the self-portrait here is in the subtle return to <em>La Jetée</em>, Marker’s film of 1962. Twenty years later this film finds its <em>Aufhebung</em>, its preservation and destruction, memorization and active forgetting.</p><p>In between, Marker’s nomadic itinerary has taken him all over the world, and he has become indeed the character of the earlier film, “projected” through the temporal-spatial continuum.</p><p><em>Sans Soleil</em> is a reprise also of the political themes of <em>Le Fond de l’air est rouge</em>, whose discourse revolves around struggle — armed, ideological, discursive, and of class and gender. This palinodic aspect makes of the later film a kind of sequel, but one in a different mood or modality, with what one might categorize as the subjective underside of events in the “objective” political and technological world which <em>Le Fond de l’air</em> revolved around.</p><p>In fact it would be useful to compare in detail these differences in perspective, mood or modality in order to pinpoint the mutation of documentary into essay filmmaking with its higher quotient of self-portraiture, allegory and the de-realization of the real.</p><p>The parallels come out in the commentary which accompanies the images of a demonstration at Narita, the long-protested Japanese airport outside of Tokyo. Everything is the same ten years later, Marker says with irony, except precisely the addition of the airport itself, “with its one fenced-in runway, more besieged than victorious.”</p><p>He goes on to speak of the politicization of students, peasants, and workers in the 1960s, and to note that the sense of community formed through the movements transcends the failure of their explicit goals. Marker pinpoints the paradox of success and failure whose mediating and transcending term is experience; experience can be relegated to neither of these categories but draws of necessity from both of them.</p><p>Experience is the category of the wit and atmosphere of <em>Sans Soleil</em>: irony and cynicism tempered with knowledge, poetry and compassion. Both extremes seem to proliferate exponentially and even fuel each other, taking on the aura of a method, a hermeneutic, a way of looking through a kind of filter which doubles the mediating, intervening role of the recording apparatus.</p><p>What melancholy, cynicism and compassion have in common is a departure from the evidence of the real, from the acceptation of the <em>bloß Seiende</em> (“merely existing”) which is the epistemological common denominator of superficial “objective” forms of documentary.</p><p>Here the essay film again departs markedly from this implicit standard. To pursue “critical documentary” is not enough; nor was it apparently an end in itself for Marker to film strikes and workers’ struggles in the sixties or, as the founding member of S.L.O.N. (<em>Société pour le lancement des oeuvres nouvelles</em>, but also the Russian word for elephant), to hand over the equipment to these workers themselves so that they could make their own images of struggle and protest.</p><p>Marker returns in the post-S.L.O.N. period (with his new company ISKRA) to a profound irony which his earliest films had known. <em>Lettre de Sibérie</em>, for example, exploits the humorous and ideological possibilities of the renowned Kuleshov effect by showing how the documentary image, in its virginal, soundless state, contained a myriad of possible elaborations/distortions, effected by its radical ambiguity and by its possible interfaces with commentary.</p><p>Commentary often takes the form of the joke in Marker, but his humor is not without a sly compassion, as <em>Sans Soleil</em> makes abundantly clear.</p><p>In his irreverence and wealth of knowledge and cultural reference (Henri Michaux was once quoted as stating: “Ecraser la Sorbonne, et mettre Marker à la place.” — “Tear down the Sorbonne, and put Marker in its place.”), Marker recalls two other contemporary filmmakers — Godard and Kluge.</p><p>The works of all three are informed and traversed by Marxist discourse, but never to the point of an orthodox, hard-lined ideology which has purged all humor from its critical gaze at the real. Instead, the imaginary and the phantasmagoric facets of the real come to the fore and are drawn out by the paradoxes which spring from the dialectical and proximate potencies of the meeting of word and image.</p><p>The emblem is the basic form of this paradox and essay film reveals itself as what might be phrased a “weaving of hieroglyphs.”</p><blockquote><em>Il enregistre plus qu’il ne réagit. Il est livré à une vision, poursuivi par elle ou la poursuivant, plutôt qu’engagé dans une action. Deleuze, Cinéma II: L’Image-temps</em></blockquote><p>Daniel L Potter aka @llull</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CE8l9W57tGPBObf7UmXEiQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbb59990c6b5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Flipsides of Western Speed: Abjection, Rust & Rain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/flipsides-of-western-speed-abjection-rust-rain-ee3108ae6a84?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee3108ae6a84</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2015 15:59:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-31T05:28:40.426Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ta7dzLG1zr3uumR1fWYxyg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Bela Tarr, Sátántangó</figcaption></figure><p><em>Daniel L Potter, Berlin 1994</em></p><p>Returning to Berlin after the wall, after the fall of the GDR, flying through time and space to reach the destination of more travels, film journeys through the wealth of images, imaginaries and sound gardens that only an international film festival can offer. . . To see Berlin again after leaving in July of 1989 is to discover the palimpsest of history, the threads of events that are laid down in the time of absence. What is exciting about the Berlinale, of which this year (Feb. 10–21) presents its 44th incarnation, are the perceptual distortions and depth of memory experienced in attending this festival. One is treated to the whole spectrum of filmmaking from Hollywood to 5 minute experimental films, and to a schedule so impossible as to force one to construct an individual compendium, to develop a tactical spectatorship, and to discern patterns in this subjective passage through hours and hours of audio-visual material.</p><p>For those who seek out young and independent cinema, the “Forum” section offers the most comprehensive selection in the world, accompanied by a catalogue composed of in-depth, erudite notes, interviews and filmographies. This is where we — Adrian Chan and I — focused our energies over the 10 day period in Berlin, choosing to steer a path around the competition films, as many will no doubt appear in the States eventually, and as the mainstream press and festival hoopla was already so focused upon these high budget productions. Our goal was to check out smaller productions, new editing patterns, to gain information from documentary productions about the state of Europe in the era of the wars in ex-Yugoslavia, to learn something about the Zeitgeist in Germany, Eastern Europe and Russia, to find films which, transgressing genre boundaries, became essays, poems, dreams or letters.</p><p>In Berlin one is also exposed to the sheer energy of the historical city, even in the midst of a bitter Winter, as it continues to mutate approaching the end of the century. We found it enlarged to a sublime degree, what we had known as two cities put together suddenly and incomprehensibly. I traveled with Chan, my co-researcher and multimedia talent. We decided at a late stage to attend the Berlinale; the multiple reasons for the trip, as the possibility dawned on us, were convincing. We had both studied in West Berlin in the late eighties and had many reasons to return — to jog the memory, to see old friends long since not visited, to discover the state of the art in Europe, to meet filmmakers and try to encourage Bay Area venues to show certain films, to find out about the impact of multimedia in Europe, to videotape and record sounds and interviews ourselves, to write articles. We came, in other words, with goals of both consumption and production. We wanted a little project, or rather several little and interrelated projects, to emerge from the hallucinatory surfeit of images, both real and cinematic. In fact, the real, when one approaches it with a video camera and DAT recorder, becomes cinematic, and the cinematic, when one sits through its mazes for six to ten hours a day, becomes ever more self-evident — a fabric whose threads begin unavoidably to appear in widely differing productions, encouraging the flow of mental associations. Montage exists not only within individual films but also, within the denser viewing experience of a festival, between the films themselves, as if they are all communicating cells, perspectives which add up to a hugely heterogeneous databank of expressions, and to the paranoid tendency to perceive in their far-flung worlds the metalanguage of a great Auteur, the weaver. The curators take on this role in the absence of a Film God — Gregor Ulrich, for example, who heads the Forum selection committee and conducts post-screening discussions with filmmakers at the Delphi.</p><p>The festival spreads out its wealths over the landscape of Berlin’s central areas: the Zoo and the Kudamm, Charlottenburg, Tiergarten, Alexanderplatz, whose thin phallic and futuristic radio tower, a legacy of when Berlin was “Hauptstadt der DDR”, dominates the sky. Spectators shuttle between the Zoo Palast, the Delphi, the Akademie der Künste, the small but important Arsenal (somewhat the equivalent in Berlin of the Pacific Film Archive or New York’s Anthology Film Archives), the Astor (where retrospectives on Erich von Strohheim and Sophia Loren took place), the Filmpalast, East Berlin’s International, a dilapidated eastern version of the west’s Zoo Palace where the main competition took place, and the Urania, a kind of cultural center where, among other things, the Children’s Film Festival took place. In a sense, the Berlinale unites the city more than the wall’s demolition and the economic annexation has. There is without doubt something here for everyone, including children and speakers of every major language of the world. Everyone seems to find a pathway, a flowchart, through the chaos of times and offerings, through the sheer simultaneity of the screenings, which gives the Berlinale a carnival-like atmosphere of movement, intersections, hurry, intersecting trajectories and accidental encounters. The space between films is punctuated with rides on the U-Bahns and S-Bahns, coffee, beer, minipizzas, brief but dense conversations, exchanges of cards, and the always failing attempt to digest what one has just incorporated in the viewing experience.</p><p>Some of the montage cuts established by exiting one film and entering another are inappropriate and disturbing, flinging one in emotionally opposite directions: from a long documentary on the history of politics and bloodshed in Croatia, Testament L.Z. by Lordan Zafronovic, to Mika Kaurismaki’s Tigrero, an amusing meditation on distance in time and space that has Sam Fuller and Jim Jarmush traveling to an obscure part of Brazil to locate the traces of Fuller’s “film that was never made,” as the subtitle runs. Impressive films began to line up for me in two extreme and opposed sub-categories: humorous and absurd films which create an affective release, and dark meditations on the human condition in German documentaries and Eastern European features in the aftermath of the Soviet empire. In the first category, but not without a large dose of black humor — perhaps the link of these two categories — were for example the Polish film Rejs, (a 1970 production resuscitated by the Forum because it was effectively banned in Poland for two decades), or the Bavarian parodist and madman Herbert Achternbusch’s Ab nach Tibet! (Off to Tibet!), or to a slapstick, high gag-per-second ratio Hong Kong James Bond/Kung Fu/Pink Panther/Hollywood musical parody called The Legendary La Rose Noire (Jeff Lau), whose midnight screening at the Delphi was attended by more Chinese than anyone ever imagined lived in Berlin.</p><p>The other category: Tarkovski-esque films from Eastern Europe and Russia: slow moving, melancholic, spiritual-yet-desolate or desolate-yet-spiritual worlds unto themselves with magical realist and apocalyptic visions. Among these were films which mesmerized me so strongly that I am still under their spell: Alexander Sokurov’s Whispering Pages, Artur Aristakisjan’s Ladoni (Palms), and finally and most monumentally the Hungarian Béla Tarr’s seven and a half hour Sátántango. Walking out into the lobby of the Akademie der Künste at its conclusion, I learned that it had won the top prize of the Forum, and that Ladoni had captured the Staudte prize given out by the Berlin daily newspaper Tagesspiegel. On our way out of the lobby toward the S-Bahn, I saw Aristakisjan and shook his hand, experiencing firsthand the title and philosophy of his film — that knowledge of a person proceeds most deeply through the medium of the hand surface. His touch was very light; he bowed to Adrian and I and did not seem to understand the simple word we had for him: “congratulations.”</p><p>Ladoni is a film that gets under one’s skin, and under the skin of its own black and white images. It presents a complex montage of documentary footage of beggars in a Russian town — half of whom are now dead, as Aristakisjan stated during the award acceptance — whom he lived among and came to know intimately over a period of several years. There is no original synchronized tone provided; this has been replaced, copied over, with a first person commentary consisting of journal entries which reflect and refract the beggars life stories — indirect discourse and poetic license. The thread through their different life experiences, anti-Bildungsroman narratives of demise and falling outside the “system”, is love (as the filmmaker repeatedly insisted in a post-screening discussion); love, A. claims, has brought them to where they are, and he perceives purity of heart directly alongside, even in causal connection to, destitution and physical deformity. Each character receives his or her own chapter; the pages of their lives are flung open by the attendant camera. One of the paradoxes of the film is the obtrusiveness and concurrent invisibility of this camera. For these subjects, the apparatus which documents their lives, although not shown within the frame, comes to resemble the crutches, skateboards, carts, etc. which serve as beggar prostheses. A filmmaker, as we know, is a beggar of a special kind. One man, said to be a king and descend from an alien race, races around on a board with wheels, a type of skateboard which replaces or extends his missing legs. His speed on this device is phenomenal, and it sets him apart from the abjection exhibited by those who beg from a solitary, unmoving position. As each of the characters in A’s film are marked by tragedy, this king is no exception: he is said to be the last of his kind, a sort of post-historical Ishi speeding around the streets of the ex-Soviet Union.</p><p>Another chapter follows a boy who is blind and who begs to support his parents; he too demonstrates a supernatural mobility. We see him in his tactile, metonymic drift, going from one person to the next in a central square, intuitionally aware of each person’s presence, unable to take no for an answer, successfully gathering a small horde of coins. The commentary describes him as someone who believes that all humans are women, and that he is the only representative of the male gender, and thus crippled. There is a poetic logic to these commentaries, which carry the spectator far from the actual picture, or rather deeper into it so that its surface is broken and a hidden, personal and cosmic images emerge, touching on realms that a documentary image on its own would have a difficult time accessing. The words we hear veer from poetic extrapolations on each character and the stories behind his/her home- and systemlessness, to addresses from the auteur to an invisible, apparently as yet unborn son, heavily weighted with a apocalyptic Christianity. The child is told to skip life, in particular the lives of work and sex — production and reproduction — to proceed directly to the afterlife, in an attempt to make language triumph over time, and love over hardship. With every sentence we feel a profound Russian melancholy, as if the end of the Soviet state opened the gate to a revival not only of orthodox belief but also to an end of the world variety that recalls both Dostoevsky and Tarkovski. One of A’s characters is an old man who lives with and talks to birds; they have opened to him the secrets of their language, and he is shown with white and black doves perched on his knees, caressing his cheek, engaged with him in an almost grotesque intimacy. This man’s other idiosyncrasy is a compassion offered prostitutes and girls whose sex has been sold by their alcoholic parents; being the only character in this film with a place to live, he lets them stay in his attic room — they and the birds. He dies before the film is completed, and the commentary’s eulogy states that when the police came to his room after his death, a woman clutching a white bird under her coat hurled herself from the window to the pavement below. Out of her clothes appeared a red-stained white bird which flew off. It is these details of language, which correspond to no filmed image but which extend the images into a metaphysical or magical-realist realm, which supplement the documentary evidence of poverty. And, rich as the images are, the poverty of the documentary image: but A’s images do not strive to be objective; his camera, as he himself, is communal with those he films, and he has been implicitly accepted into their world. The commentary-supplement introduces lyrical flourishes which cannot be double-checked for truth content, for which there is, finally, no need.</p><p>As a footnote on the impulse towards this acceptance and merging with the documented group, is is useful to briefly suggest a comparison of Ladoni with Vitali Kanjewski’s Nous, les enfants du vingtième siècle, a Russian documentary with a French title in the cinéma vérité style. This film, which was also screened in the Forum section, succeeds as an informative and energetic documentary, but ultimately discovers the limitations of its larger aim, which is to pass the camera and the personality of the filmmaker without friction into the hidden world of a subculture. This film seeks to get inside the world of runaway street kid criminals in St. Petersburg; in the discussion after the screening, Kanjewski said that he owed his upfront, familiar (even guerilla) interview technique to the fact that he shared this type of reckless, itinerant childhood with the children depicted in his film. Kanjewski brought to his subject group sympathy and strategy, playing for instance on the desire of these kids to become stars and crafting the interview language toward street slang, insider talk. With the very young children, he succeeds wonderfully, but when he tries to gain the confidence of some older raketeri who work the black market and conduct bizarre baptismal rituals on a yacht, he is rebuffed, and the camera must film from an unsatisfying distance.</p><p>Still experiencing jetlag several days into the festival, we went to the last and midnight showing of Whispering Pages in East Berlin on one of the coldest nights, apparently, of the whole cold season. It felt like traveling to Siberia. Sokurov’s film opens with a monumental shot of the side of a huge industrial concrete building. This shot strips the viewer of perspective, which comes on slowly as the camera begins a slow pan to reveal water at the base of this massive architecture, and later what look like towers of a nuclear plant. People seem to live here; the camera follows then down corridors, snakelike, slowly, insidiously, like a sentient machine equipped with a concealed intent — neutral, malevolent, revelatory by turns. Sokurov’s style, and that of his cinematographer, immediately recalls Tarkovski; in this and several other eastern European productions, it becomes clear the extent to which Tarkovski (who died in 1986) has given other artists the taste for enigma, for details of erosion or traces of past human activity in the object world, for the invisible which can only be revealed through an exaggerated slowness of motion and thought. Whispering Pages’ opening credits add to the title what is either a subtitle or a brief motto serving as a clue to its enigmatic images: “Motifs taken from works of 19th century Russian literature.” Throughout the film, as we follow the protagonist through the caves of these dwellings, we are on our guard to find parallels to Gogol, Dostoevsky, Tolstoi, Turgenev, et al. The scenes, then, are like stitched together half-memories of fragments of lengthy novels; filmed quotations; amalgamations of authors; subtle reflections on genre (novel v. film). More than anything, they seem to offer evidence that the future will slip back into the past, into squalor, metaphysics, and deceleration, that the 21st century may resemble the 19th more than the current century. One motif that stands in the center of the film is spiritual desolation and the death of god. Innocence v. experience, good and evil — all the good old 19th century questions, still unsolved, blurred here to indistinction as we situate ourselves near the millennial threshold.</p><p>But what of the plot? The man has committed a crime, killed someone, but not with intention. The dead one is a relative of a young girl, a girl who seems fully innocent but at one point hints that she too has sinned; embodying the fall of the child into adulthood, she is both exceedingly soft and hardened already by the suicidal, millennia society living around her in the nuclear environs; the result is a brittle fragility and unspoken knowledge, which are masterfully brought out by the director. Many of the other girl-women, such as her sister, are already prostitutes, and they hang around the corridors squealing just out of camera range, trying to pull the man into their end of the century orgy. He continues on, and seems to embody an observing eye, already on the other side of life (analogous to the deliberate, patient camera). Further, as we are led ever so slowly past this scene of excess, we reach a railing from which we look down into a bizarre pool or reflection, a kind of gateway into another realm (an image of magical realism). As the man watches, several persons in succession climb the railing in slow motion and hurl themselves off as if diving off cliffs at a resort. These are not artistic dives but acts of an ecstatic desperation — serial suicides which propel them through the mirror, beyond which we cannot see. Earlier, we saw the man being roughed and beaten up by a large swarthy man; later we encounter with him the Bureaucrat: the protagonist slips from Crime and Punishment into Dead Souls, traversing the motifs of 19th c. Russian prose. The latter scene depicts a visit to a clerk of the court, in which the man must fill out some document, a testament or a confession (?). Entering this room is like beginning to breath dust, and feeling the weight on the clerks withered features of a tedious and insurmountable bureaucracy. Gogol, we must remember, is one of Kafka’s precursors. The clerk, speaking from a distant, archival space, insists on readability, penmanship; the man, in his one moment of anger throughout the film, is insulted and eventually, painstakingly, leaves the suffocating enclosure. He sees the girl for the second time, in her bare room. Their interaction — several brief but loaded sentences punctuated by long, charged silences — is filmed with a hypnotizing and languid eroticism, in takes long enough to enable one to memorize the exact posture of her arms and hands — she is a Schiele or a Munch, thin, intense and angular, with pale and absolutely smooth skin.</p><p>The man leaves her too, after revealing his culpability but asserting that, in the void of a disappeared god, culpability is nonexistent. His nihilism and her belief mirror, in their tension, the sexual tension that infuses the scene. The film pursues its denouement without untying anything or giving us any new information; rather, we simply perceive how the man wanders slowly to a different complex of the edifice, to where a huge stone lion of superhuman proportions sits eternally; he kisses its teat and recedes within it, becoming invisible and drifting off into a sleep (as I was on the verge of doing, momentarily entering equally surreal dreams to wake suddenly to a slightly jumpcut eventlessness). The effects serve, as in Tarkovski, only to increase the enigmas — not to solve anything, not to provide any real ending, much less a happy one, but rather to establish an emotion whose veil it will henceforth be difficult if not impossible to tear.</p><p>This effect of a film living on inside of us is not new, but for me it was amplified with Sokurov’s film, and even more so with Sátántángo, which is over four times the length of Whispering Pages. Living through Sátántángo is like being thrown into a dimension diametrically opposite that of MTV, with its velocity and its hyperbolic stimulation of the nervous system. Tarr’s film, based on a novel by László Krasnahorkai, evokes with equally explicitness the experience of duration — the “time-image” — found in Tarkovski’s films. Tarr takes his time with each scene, with each chapter of the “Dance Order” in which the film is organized. The dance of death, with earth already hell, is the governing metaphor, joined by another powerful one: that of the spider’s web, and the intrication in it of victims (both characters and spectators, undoubtedly). The Dance Order runs as follows:</p><pre>Part One<br>    I. The News That They are Coming<br>    II. We are Resurrected<br>    III. Knowing Something<br>    IV. The Work of the Spider (1)</pre><pre>    Reclining Eight</pre><pre>    V. The Net Tears<br>    VI. The Work of the Spider (2)</pre><pre>    Devil&#39;s Seat, Satan&#39;s Tango</pre><pre>    Part Two<br>    VI. Irimiás Speaks<br>    V. The Perspective, When from the Front<br>    IV. Ascension, Feverdream?<br>    III. The Perspective, When from Behind<br>    II. Nothing but Worries, Nothing but Work<br>    I. The Circle Closes</pre><pre>&quot;History is not at an end, nothing is at an end, we can no longer deceive ourselves that anything with us has come to an end; something continues and is retained.&quot; — Lászlo Krasznahorkai on Sátántángo</pre><p>Sátántángo concerns a small town whose factory, its sole economy, has closed, where alcohol dominates everyone’s lives, where everyone distrusts each other, where every material thing, building, piece of clothing, gives off the air of dilapidation and impending death, while pure existence and its unendurable duration continues on, and drags the relics of humans and objects with it. If that weren’t enough, the rainy season has begun and will continue for months without a single letup. Only two people hold on, however slightly, to semblance of distance and independence: the Doctor and Irimiás, a false prophet who returns, after declaring himself dead, to lead the human remnants into a new era. Both turn out to be informants, linked to the corrupt and capricious power of a state surveillance apparatus. Both practice the art of writing.</p><p>For the Doctor, writing is a form of self-defense against the general demise, as well as a ritual of inscription and surveillance which coexists alongside rituals of self-destruction — these take the form of continuously drinking a clear alcohol and occasionally shooting up. The ritual of alcohol is precisely formulated by Tarr: a kind of game of transference in which it is poured from a large wicker-glass jug into a smaller carafe, and from there into a small glass. Water is poured from a pitcher into a slightly larger glass. These two glasses are then poured simultaneously into a slightly larger glass, which is then downed in one painful swallow. The precision of the alcohol ritual mirrors itself in that of the inscription-surveillance ritual: a board is pulled out of the desk drawer, notebooks, one for each town inhabitant, are pulled out when new information needs to be added; otherwise they are arranged in a private, dirty little archive. Pens are periodically adjusted to line up straight. Throughout it all, the Doctor is half muttering, half clearing his throat in an inscrutable commentary on his own actions.</p><p>A small catastrophe happens in the midst of these rituals: the alcohol runs out, forcing the Doctor to enter the external world, as he has not for some time. Coming home from his errand, which is followed with extreme precision in the excruciating “real time” of the filming, the Doctor collapses. He is found by a man who loads him onto a truck and takes him (as we later find out) to a hospital, where he recovers for fourteen days. When we next see him, he is returning home and recommences his two rituals. But in the meantime, those he has been spying on have been led away to the city by the false prophet. Finally realizing this, any further concern with the external world having been eliminated, he begins to board up the window that his desk looks out on. The screen becomes black: we are finally at the end of the film. But we have yet to learn how we got there.</p><p>In the deathly everyday life of this decaying village, we can read a global economic moment: that of industrial burnout, factory settings no longer filled with work of any sort, already exquisitely rusted and coming apart at the seams. Prostitution, embezzling, informing become so many new partial models of a substitute economy. One wonders why there is even money still (it is counted out exaggeratedly in an early scene and forms a recurring motif or subplot). There seems to be no food, only beer and vodka. The present is diagnosed by being stripped of its historical markers, and it winds up appearing both futuristic and archaic. The results of this technique hold true in many films which seek to reduce visual information to a minimum; in direct relation to the degree of paucity of such markers, the allegory of historical process finds itself enlarged. The film leans toward a paradoxical affirmation of both Christian and satanic interpretations of its allegories. Apocalyptic religious themes run parallel and are imbedded in the economic and political allegories; the indictment of Hungary’s demise is a visual spectacle of profound ugliness, as long-takes continuously reemphasize the material and psychic reality of the collapse of a whole infrastructure. The images are emptied by two gravitational forces: the past which has fallen away, and the future which has not yet begun. The allegory is also epistemological, as Tarr and Krasnahorkai lead us to imagine a treachery behind the pastoral act, i.e. to impute a falsity to the prophet Irimiás which hollows out his mission of salvation, revealing it as a grandiose swindle of money and spirit — if there is any left in these people in their state of alcoholic demise, faithlessness, mutual cruelty, promiscuity.</p><p>There is, in the end, no one who remains outside the system of trickery and falling apart; even the young girl Estike (Evening) whose suicide with rat poison might, from one perspective, make her a martyr or sacrificial lamb who takes the sins of the community onto herself, even she is portrayed as yet another relay point in a sadomasochistic economy. On the one hand, she watches inertly as her mother earns money prostituting herself out of their home, and we witness how she is ripped off by her brother, who convinces her to put all her stray coins in a handkerchief and bury it in order to grow a money tree (he later digs it up and steals it). On the other hand, she is the agent of what must be the most horrific and unwatchable scene. Preceding her own self-poisoning, Estike takes all of her accumulated loathing out on her cat — the one object of her love, the one creature weaker than she — rolling around in the dirt with it pinned maliciously between her hands, imprisoning it in a net from which it hangs (concretizing the metaphor of the spider’s web as an image of power) as she steals milk and rat poison from her home. She walks around with the pet in a state of rigor mortis underneath her arm, in a daze, crossing paths with the Doctor just before his collapse, and becoming a substitute spectator to the excessive scene of all-night drinking and dancing (to an accordion which culminates the evening with a satanic tango). This reveling reaches a grotesque frenzy before everyone passes out, completely drunk and strewn over the benches of the bar.</p><p>The bar scene is one of several which are returned to a second time from an altered perspective. The film seems to loop around on itself, retracing its minimal diegesis, multiplying its enigmas with multiplied points of view whose lack of moral perspective somehow correlates with an omniscient and neutral camera. Tarr seems to have built in to these revisited scenes hallucinations and phantasms, in the form of new information: the scenes are not repetitions but behavioral investigations of the spectator. The prismatic effect remains a disunited constellation of fragments, just as alcohol, which unites everyone in the deformations it enacts on their failing minds and bodies, fails to bring anyone closer, fails to collapse the enormous, cosmic distance between individuals. It only inaugurates a temporary and wretched forgetting. Tarr’s film is the memory of such forgetfulness, a prismatic constellation of lies and distances; as an eye which refuses to turn away, it represents, thinly, something other than what it shows — a faint difference brought to light by immense effort. That the film was completed and exists at all seems like a miracle of sorts after we have endured its duration — a miracle which tends to undermine Sátántángo’s systematic undermining of every miracle, economic or theological, leaving one with an enormous positive balance. We leave seven and a half hours later reconfigured.</p><p>Daniel L Potter</p><p>Webliography:</p><ol><li>Evocative article on Whispering Pages on the Alexander Sokurov website. Retrieved 7.13,2014<a href="http://www.sokurov.spb.ru/isle">http://www.sokurov.spb.ru/isle</a><em>en/feature</em>films.html?num=65</li><li>“Bela Tarr’s Satantango” on Cinemaparallel.com.<a href="http://www.cinemaparallel.com/CP.tarr.html">http://www.cinemaparallel.com/CP.tarr.html</a></li><li>“A Place in the Pantheon: Films by Bela Tarr,” by Jonathan Rosenbaum. Retrieved 7.13.2014<a href="http://www.jonathanrosenbaum.net/1996/05/a-place-in-the-pantheon/">http://www.jonathanrosenbaum.net/1996/05/a-place-in-the-pantheon/</a></li><li>The Elusive Hitler A Dialogue on Sokurov’s Moloch. Retrieved 7.13.2014 <a href="http://www.ce-review.org/00/3/kinoeye3_halligan.html">http://www.ce-review.org/00/3/kinoeye3_halligan.html</a></li><li>Filmfestivals.com article on Sokurov’s Moloch.</li><li>An interview with Tarr Béla: “Sit down, Shut up and Watch…with your Heart”</li><li>“Pathologies of Time: Sátántangó” by Andréa Picard.</li><li>K I N O E Y E Archive: Director Index</li><li>Madness and Civilization: The very strange fictions of László Krasnahorkai, New Yorker, 7.4.2011<a href="http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2011/07/04/110704crat">http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2011/07/04/110704crat</a><em>atlarge</em>wood</li><li>Satantango’s French translation: Tango de Satan by Laszlo Krasznahorkai (available at amazon.fr). [Since translated into English]</li><li>Alexandr Sokurov Tikhiye stranitsy<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol4aeC6czUs">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol4aeC6czUs</a></li><li>Redesigning Satantango <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wA2APi0cTYY">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wA2APi0cTYY</a></li><li>Bela Tarr, I Used to Be a Filmmaker<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KRZ9D_6Zypk">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KRZ9D_6Zypk</a></li><li>Critics Explain Their Love for Bela Tarr: A Round-Up. Retrieved 7.13.2014 <a href="http://www.ce-review.org/00/3/kinoeye3_halligan.html">http://www.ce-review.org/00/3/kinoeye3_halligan.html</a></li><li>Palms “Ladoni” 1994 IMDb<a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0168845/">http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0168845/</a></li><li>Daniel L Potter, Reflection on Ladoni / Palms<a href="http://windwater.tumblr.com/post/76485854762/ladoni-palms-artur-aristakisyan-inspiring">http://windwater.tumblr.com/post/76485854762/ladoni-palms-artur-aristakisyan-inspiring</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee3108ae6a84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sudden Peace]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@llull/sudden-peace-34192bf6dbba?source=rss-69842bb214ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/34192bf6dbba</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[llull]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 May 2015 19:11:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-28T19:11:23.002Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>for mm</em></p><p>naxos they gather at the nexus<br>when the bar<br>spills them out on the street<br>of island number two<br>already it is over<br>poignant he is smitten and must<br>let her go off with another<br>after days of skin her aroma her rose<br>between two dreams<br>walking his way<br>he gestures the acceptance<br>of femme fatality<br>he is leaving the next morning<br>on the ferry (she remaining)<br>stage one<br>of the return to berlin<br>and longs for her<br>eyes upon the restless<br>mediterranean where all voyages<br>are round trips<br>while she weaves and unweaves<br>till time moves neither<br>forward nor back<br>and his home subtly morphed<br>under the accumulation<br>of days<br>the weight of absence<br>sex impatience</p><p>her clothes are scattered<br>on every surface bath<br>bed and balcony<br>and he gathers them<br>like grammarless words<br>into a duffel bag dictionary<br>deposited with the clueless<br>concierge<br>for eventual retrieval</p><p>“eine deutsche frau<br>hat nicht<br>so lange haare”<br>- a german woman does not have<br>such long hair —<br>first words upon acquaintance<br>echo the black beaches<br>of santorini<br>island number one<br>cornrow styled<br>with extensions<br>already his lense zoomed<br>on her exclusive<br>full focus on the ferry<br>anonymous promise</p><p>and you anton<br>anubis identified<br>she showered for us both<br>one otherwise eventless afternoon<br>enveloped amid<br>a week wondering if we’re<br>still drunk or already<br>hungover<br>and for me<br>throughout<br>the german cold from hell</p><p>a man smashing octopus<br>against the rock</p><p>that nasty german cold<br>that won’t quit<br>acquired<br>specifically suspiciously<br>in schoenefeld<br>paradoxical port of berlin ost<br>hungarian airlines malev<br>having somehow three syllables</p><p>strip search<br>in the narrow passage<br>toward a vacation<br>their citizens denied</p><p>he comes up<br>on the computers<br>their bureaucrats denied<br>once they photocopied<br>the pandemonium of his journal<br>marginless black scrawl<br>once upon a watercolor<br>ideogram<br>and grew suspicion in the soil<br>of his full flowering german<br>and healthy wealthy stipend</p><p>sore throats for the cia<br>a trick up the sleeve<br>of the dullest of gray<br>uniforms</p><p>silver rings for the smallest finger<br>a shop he will forever wish<br>to find again<br>around mazecurves<br>of the old town naxos<br>self sufficient island<br>needing no imports</p><p>both back in deutschland<br>she sends pictures<br>none of her<br>two of him<br>of which in one<br>his hand encircles<br>a big black stone<br>homeless ribcage dogs lurk<br>just beyond<br>the rectangle of her eye<br>the imprint of her film<br>the lapse of her image<br>the loss of her lips</p><p>on a balinese futon<br>in a soft coal fueled room<br>in the booklined avenue<br>in charlottenburg her<br>fishbone t-shirt arrives<br>it becomes his<br>outfit for dreamtime<br>until one day it vanishes<br>in one of twenty moves</p><p>letting her be just who she is<br>time number two<br>her hair all different<br>who could have known but<br>it was the last year<br>of west berlin<br>island number three</p><p>letting her be<br>‘cause the judge is crazy<br>said judy</p><p>letting her beyond<br>up to the razor’s edge<br>of nearly letting go<br>just so he<br>touches her in a place<br>beyond the easy opening<br>of sex to strangers<br>I know<br>she still remembers<br>how she ran most oblique<br>with luck<br>into love</p><p>on the ubahn<br>on a mission<br>to score hash she says<br>“du bist ein poet”<br>after she brought the british punk<br>chinese cook<br>small time auto crook<br>met the night before<br>with her on her visit<br>again he sends her off<br>to sleep with another<br>his heart in knots<br>this too weaves them<br>tighter together<br>makes possible<br>a finale still hovering<br>in the neighborhood<br>of happy ever after</p><p>flash forward to frankfurt flughafen<br>she meets his plane<br>they have half an hour<br>for one whole kiss<br>interrupted only<br>by reckless swallows<br>of still chilled champagne<br>consumed on the spot<br>for<br>mad laughter has waited<br>a lifetime</p><p>right up to the<br>mad dash to the gate<br>dizzy with her</p><p>her plan may have been born<br>on the phone<br>as she says<br>just days before<br>“… trauig, dass du den Kontinent<br>verlässt…” sad that you are leaving the continent<br>another string of words<br>sculpted like a rose<br>etched indelible<br>even to today</p><p>Daniel L Potter</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=34192bf6dbba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>