<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jeffery D. Long on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jeffery D. Long on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@longjd?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 16:46:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@longjd/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The World is One Family: Vedanta in the Thought of Mahatma Gandhi]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/the-world-is-one-family-vedanta-in-the-thought-of-mahatma-gandhi-53c83367c7fd?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/53c83367c7fd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[swami-vivekananda]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yoga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gandhi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Oct 2019 15:50:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-27T15:50:35.472Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Presented at the Vedanta Society of New York on October 20, 2019</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LiFcoMBrAhAHkS1MGEIIYg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Gandhi: Great Soul <em>and</em> Imperfect Human Being</strong></p><p>Today, I would like to speak about Vedanta in the thought of Mahatma Gandhi. I feel that this is an especially appropriate topic to discuss at this time, given that this month marks Gandhiji’s 150th birth anniversary (which occurred on October 2nd).</p><p>I would like to begin my remarks by noting that I am aware that Gandhi is a controversial figure for many, even today, more than seventy years after his assassination on the 30th of January, 1948. He is widely revered in the Western world, where he has inspired other admired figures like Martin Luther King, Jr. who similarly dedicated their lives to the causes of social justice and human dignity. He has recently become a controversial figure in South Africa, due to renewed scrutiny of his views on the relationship between the Indian community and the indigenous peoples of that country. And he has long been controversial in India, where, while being admired by many, he is also criticized for various decisions and pronouncements which he made, especially in connection with the Partition of India and Pakistan–an event which resulted in the deaths of possibly as many as two million people, and the displacement of fourteen million more (including, I would note, my mother-in-law and her family, as well as many of my friends and close acquaintances).</p><p>I do not intend to explore in my remarks today the areas in which Gandhi can be criticized. I would simply like to note at the outset that Gandhi was an imperfect human being: a claim with which he would no doubt be the first to agree, admitting quite openly, as he did in his writings, to a great variety of personal shortcomings, sometimes with a brutal honesty which sometimes makes for an uncomfortable reading experience. I have had the good fortune to get to know members of Gandhi’s family, who similarly attest both to his greatness and to his all-too-human fallibility.</p><p>The point I wish to make, here at the start, is precisely this: that Gandhi was <em>both</em> a great soul–a <em>mahātma</em> in the true sense–<em>and</em> an imperfect human being, subject to a range of criticisms. One can admire the genuine spiritual greatness in another person without having to believe that person was perfect and never made a mistake. Unfortunately, in our increasingly polarized world, if one utters even a word of criticism toward a beloved figure, one is immediately taken to be on the ‘other’ side (whatever that may mean), from that figure’s followers. And if one has admiration for a particular figure, it is assumed that one cannot tolerate any criticism of that figure whatsoever. All sense of nuance is being lost as humanity divides itself into warring ideological camps.</p><p>Even Nathuram Godse, the man who murdered Mahatma Gandhi, acknowledged the depths of Gandhi’s spiritual greatness, reverently touching his feet in an ancient Hindu gesture of respect before brutally assassinating him. The contradiction between these two, almost simultaneous acts, well illustrates the conflicted feelings that many in India have for this historically important figure.</p><p><strong>Vedanta in the Thought of Mahatma Gandhi</strong></p><p>The influence of Vedanta upon the thought of Mahatma Gandhi is extensive and profound. It is, of course, very understandable that this should be the case. He was a lifelong adherent of the Vaishnav tradition of Hinduism, growing up in a devout Gujarati Vaishnav family. He was also deeply pluralistic and open to influences from a variety of spiritual traditions, which is of course a trait of Indian culture tracing back to ancient times, to the teaching of the <em>Ṛg Veda</em>: <em>ekaṃ sat viprā bahuḍhā vadanti</em>. “The Real is One; the wise speak of it in many ways.”[1] In addition to Vaishnav Hinduism, he was deeply influenced by the Jain tradition–an influence to which we shall have an occasion to return shortly. Rājchandra Mehta, founder of the Jain Kavi Panth tradition, was a very dear friend of Gandhi’s. His influence on Gandhi was so profound that he is often referred to as ‘Gandhi’s guru.’ Later on in life, Gandhi would also be deeply moved by the New Testament, and by the Sermon on the Mount in particular (upon which Swami Prabhavananda, the founder of the Vedanta Society of Southern California, would eventually write a famous commentary, published under the title <em>The Sermon on the Mount According to Vedanta</em>).</p><p>The chief source, however, to which Gandhi refers again and again throughout his many writings is the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>. Gandhi called the <em>Gītā</em> his “dictionary of daily reference.”[2] The <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em> is of course a central Vaishnav text; but it is also a central source for Vedanta, as part of the <em>Prasthānatraya</em>, or ‘triple foundation’ of Vedanta, alongside the <em>Brahma Sūtras</em> and the <em>Upaniṣads</em>. Gandhi gave a series of lectures on this important Hindu text, which was published in 1946 as a book under the title <em>The Bhagavad Gītā According to Gandhi</em>.</p><p>In addition to the Vedantic influences he received from his upbringing, as well as his close and deep reading of the <em>Gītā</em>, Gandhi was also a great admirer of both Sri Ramakrishna and Swami Vivekananda. The imprint of the thought of both of these major figures and shapers of the modern Vedanta movement can be clearly discerned in his works. Indeed, Gandhi wrote the following of Sri Ramakrishna:</p><p>The story of Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa’s life is a story of religion in practice. His life enables us to see God face to face. No one can read the story of his life without being convinced that God alone is real and that all else is an illusion. [Sri] Ramakrishna was a living embodiment of godliness. His sayings are not those of a mere learned man but they are pages from the Book of Life. They are revelations of his own experiences. They therefore leave the reader an impression which he cannot resist. In this age of skepticism Ramakrishna represents an example of a bright and living faith which gives solace to thousands of men and women who would otherwise have remained without spiritual light. Ramakrishna’s life was an object-lesson in Ahimsa. His love knew no limits geographical or otherwise. May his divine love be an inspiration to all.[3]</p><p>Regarding Swami Vivekananda, Gandhi actually tried to visit Swamiji in 1902, when the Indian National Congress was holding its annual meeting in Calcutta. Gandhi was thirty-two years old at the time, while Swamiji, only thirty-nine, was, tragically, on his death bed and was unable to receive visitors.[4] One would very much like to have access to the alternative reality where these two figures met and managed to speak to one another. Were such a conversation to have occurred and to have been recorded, the resulting document would certainly be a source of enlightenment for the rest of humanity.</p><p>The Vedantic influences on Gandhi’s thought are so extensive that one could likely write a book enumerating and exploring them. I have found Gandhi’s thought echoing that of Thakur and Swamiji most clearly, though, in three particular areas: his commitment to serving the poor, his religious pluralism, and his rejection of prejudice based on birth-caste, or <em>jāti</em>.</p><p><strong>On Serving the Poor</strong></p><p>The idea of karma yoga involving <em>seva</em>, or selfless service, as a path to God-realization is one of the most distinctive elements emphasized by Swami Vivekananda throughout his life. This idea was first sparked in Swamiji’s mind when, as the young Narendranath Datta, and disciple of Sri Ramakrishna, he heard his Master make the statement, “<em>Jība Śiba</em>.” In other words, the jīvas, or living beings, are one with Śiva: with God. All souls are divine. Service to any living being is therefore service to God. <em>Daridra Narāyaṇ</em>, or God in the form of the Poor, thus became a central ideal for Vivekananda, who later wrote:</p><p>Blessed are they whose bodies get destroyed in the service of others. Wealth, and even life itself, the sage always holds ready for the service of others… ‘In this evanescent world, where every-thing is falling to pieces, we have to make the highest use of what time we have,’ says the Bhakta [or devotee]; and…the highest use of life is to hold it at the service of all beings.[5]</p><p>Swamiji also wrote, however, that one should, “Offer everything you have unto the service of the Lord.”[6] But there is no contradiction between these statements. Because of the all-pervasive presence of Brahman, dwelling within all beings–because the jīva is Śiva–a practitioner of Vedanta does not distinguish, according to Vivekananda, between “the service of the Lord” and “the service of others.” The service of the Lord <em>is</em> the service of others, and the service of others is the service of the Lord. In Swamiji’s words, “‘They worship Me best who worship My worshippers. These are all My children and your privilege is to serve them’ — is the teaching of Hindu scriptures.”[7]</p><p>Swami Vivekananda’s vision of seva is not a vision of charity. The ideal of charity tends to assume class distinctions among different groups of human beings based upon material wealth. It encourages the wealthy to aid the ‘less fortunate’ out of the goodness of their hearts: an act which can be done out of pride and with a sense of moral superiority based on the idea that one has earned one’s wealth, and that if others are not similarly fortunate, it must be due to some moral failing or flaw. This is something that Vivekananda strongly rejects. He says:</p><p>Do not stand on a high pedestal and take five cents in your hand and say, ‘Here, my poor man,’ but be grateful that the poor man is there, so that by making a gift to him you are able to help yourself. It is not the receiver that is blessed, but it is the giver. Be thankful that you are allowed to exercise your power of benevolence and mercy in the world, and thus become pure and perfect.[8]</p><p>The ‘less fortunate’ are God in human form, offering us an opportunity to serve, and thereby realize our own divine potential.</p><p>In terms of what kind of service, specifically, is most helpful to the poor, Swamiji offers, again, not a vision of charity, which tends to assume that contemporary disparities of wealth are a natural feature of society, and will always exist. Swamiji offers a more radical vision of enabling the self-empowerment of the poor, largely through education. He writes:</p><p>The only service to be done for our lower classes is to give them education, <em>to develop their lost individuality</em>. That is the great task between our people and princes. Up to now nothing has been done in that direction. Priest-power and foreign conquest have trodden them down for centuries, and at last the poor of India have forgotten that they are human beings. They are to be given ideas; their eyes are to be opened to what is going on in the world around them; and then they will work out their own salvation. Every nation, every man and every woman must work out their own salvation. Give them ideas — that is the only help they require, and then the rest must follow as the effect.[9]</p><p>This emphasis on self-empowerment, which Gandhi would convey with his concept of <em>swaraj</em>, or self-rule, is one of the strongest links between the thought of these two figures.</p><p>Seva, again, for Vivekananda is not subservient to–much less a diversion from–the spiritual path. It <em>is</em> the spiritual path, in a concrete manifestation that is no less valuable than the study of the scriptures, the practice of meditation, or devotional worship. And it is also an <em>expression</em> of spiritual liberation, not to be seen so much in a linear, cause-and-effect manner, but in a dialectical fashion, as both means and embodiment.[10] This is in keeping with the broader Vedantic ideal that the ethical virtues are, for those of us who are still on the path to realization, a means toward that realization; but for those who have attained realization, they are simply the spontaneous reflection of that realization. A <em>sādhak</em>, one who is on the spiritual path, serves in order to attain realization. A realized being serves for the sheer joy of serving.</p><p>The most obvious embodiment of Vivekananda’s ideal of seva, upon which he has had the clearest and most direct influence, is in the service work that is carried out by the <em>sannyāsīs</em> of the Ramakrishna Order and their lay supporters. I would like to argue, though, that there is also a direct line of continuity from Swami Vivekananda’s ideal and Gandhi’s constructive program–to the extent that Gandhi could well be regarded as a practical Vedantin of the Vivekananda school of thought.</p><p>The “Constructive Programme” is the title of an essay by Mahatma Gandhi which was first published in 1941, with a revised and enlarged edition appearing in 1945. In this essay, Gandhi defines the constructive program as the “construction of Poorna Swaraj or complete Independence by truthful and non-violent means.”[11] More than a mere political program for Indian independence from British rule, however, the constructive program, as Gandhi presents it, involves a complete transformation of Indian society, through peaceful means, into a just, or dharmic, social order that is characterized by independence, not only in a conventional political sense–although it includes such independence–but in a spiritual sense as well. It is a holistic program for the transformation of not only the nation, but of the communities and the individuals that constitute it. One can see Gandhi’s constructive program as an extension of Swamiji’s spiritual ideal, which is aimed mainly at the individual, to the whole of society.</p><p>True independence, according to Gandhi’s thought, “is never exclusive. It is, therefore, wholly compatible with interdependence within or without.”[12] As a spiritual ideal, it also cannot, at least at the societal level, be identified with any particular, concrete embodiment of it, but can only be approached asymptotically. In Gandhi’s words, “Practice will always fall short of the theory, even as the drawn line falls short of the theoretical line of Euclid. Therefore, Independence will be complete only to the extent of our approach in practice to truth and non-violence.”[13] These twin ideals of truth and nonviolence–<em>satya</em> and <em>ahiṃsā</em>–are indispensable to the goal and to one another.</p><p>This is very close in its sensibility to Swami Vivekananda’s teaching, in regard to karma yoga, that, “This world is like a dog’s curly tail, and people have been striving to straighten it out for hundreds of years; but when they let it go, it has curled up again.”[14]</p><p>This does not mean that specific, concrete goals are not to be achieved as part of the process of the unfoldment of the higher ideal. Indeed, Gandhi’s “Constructive Programme” essay consists largely of an outline of such concrete goals and practical suggestions for their achievement. The idea is that, even as specific problems are solved, it is in the nature of the material world that, so long as we inhabit it–so long as we inhabit <em>saṃsāra</em>, the cycle of birth, death, and rebirth–we will be involved in problem-solving. Problems exist in order to be solved, in order to give us spiritual exercise, as it were, that will enable us to realize our potential divinity. As Swamiji says:</p><p>The world is a grand moral gymnasium wherein we have all to take exercise so as to become stronger and stronger spiritually.[15]</p><p><strong>On Religious Pluralism</strong></p><p>The first concrete goal that Gandhi outlines is communal unity. Here we see a particularly strong resonance with the Vedantic teaching of both Sri Ramakrishna and Swami Vivekananda on the harmony of religions, or <em>dharma-samanvaya</em>. As Gandhi writes that:</p><p>Everybody is agreed about the necessity of this [communal] unity. But everybody does not know that unity does not mean political unity which may be imposed. It means an unbreakable heart unity. The first thing essential for achieving such unity is for every Congressman [or member of the independence party which Gandhi led], whatever his religion may be, to represent in his own person Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Zoroastrian, Jew, etc., shortly, every Hindu and non-Hindu. He has to feel his identity with every one of the millions of the inhabitants of Hindustan. In order to realize this, every Congressman will cultivate personal friendship with persons representing faiths other than his own. He should have the same regard for the other faiths as he has for his own…In such a happy state of things there would be no disgraceful cry at the stations such as ‘Hindu water’ and ‘Muslim water’ or ‘Hindu tea’ and ‘Muslim tea.’ [In Gandhi’s time, Hindus and Muslims drank from segregated wells and tea stalls.] There would be no separate rooms or spots for Hindus and non-Hindus in schools and colleges, no communal schools, colleges and hospitals…The beginning of such a revolution has to be made by Congressmen without any political motive behind the correct conduct. Political unity will be its natural fruit.[16]</p><p>It is significant that the communal unity that Gandhi advocates is not merely a political stance. It is not ‘vote bank politics.’ Gandhi’s ideal is, rather, a sincere embrace of the religious other, from which political unity would naturally flow. It is therefore not unlike the ideal that Vivekananda outlines in his various discourses on the world’s religions and to which he refers as “universal religion.” In the effort to realize this ideal, Vivekananda rejects superficial notions of mere tolerance in favor of the “unbreakable heart unity” of which Gandhi writes. For although tolerance is certainly preferable intolerance, it falls far short of the holistic Vedantic ideal. Swami Vivekananda, rejecting both tolerance and exclusion, writes:</p><p>Our watchword, then, will be acceptance, and not exclusion. Not only toleration, for so-called toleration is often blasphemy, and I do not believe in it. I believe in acceptance. Why should I tolerate? Toleration means that I think that you are wrong and I am just allowing you to live. Is it not a blasphemy to think that you and I are allowing others to live? I accept all religions that were in the past, and worship with them all; I worship God with every one of them, in whatever form they worship Him. I shall go to the mosque of the Mohammedan [that is, Muslim]; I shall enter the Christian’s church and kneel before the crucifix; I shall enter the Buddhist temple, where I shall take refuge in Buddha and in his Law. I shall go into the forest and sit down in meditation with the Hindu, who is trying to see the Light which enlightens the heart of everyone…Not only shall I do all these, but I shall keep my heart open for all that may come in the future. Is God’s book finished? Or is it still a continuous revelation going on? It is a marvelous book — these spiritual revelations of the world. The Bible, the Vedas, the Koran, and all other sacred books are but so many pages, and an infinite number of pages remain yet to be unfolded. I would leave it open for all of them. We stand in the present, but open ourselves to the infinite future. We take in all that has been in the past, enjoy the light of the present, and open every window of the heart for all that will come in the future. Salutation to all the prophets of the past, to all the great ones of the present, and to all that are to come in the future![17]</p><p>Gandhi, along similar lines, writes:</p><p>Religions are different roads converging upon the same point. What does it matter that we take different roads so long as we reach the same goal? In reality there are as many religions as there are individuals. I believe in the fundamental truth of all great religions of the world. I believe that they are all God-given, and I believe that they were necessary for the people to whom these religions were revealed. And I believe that, if only we could all of us read the scriptures of different faiths from the standpoint of the followers of those faiths we should find that they were at bottom all one and were all helpful to one another.[18]</p><p>And both Vivekananda and Gandhi are echoing the words of Sri Ramakrishna:</p><p>I have practiced all religions–Hinduism, Islam, Christianity–and I have also followed the paths of the different Hindu sects. I have found that it is the same God toward whom all are directing their steps, though along different paths. He who is called Krishna is also called Shiva, and bears the name of the Primal Energy, Jesus, and Allah as well–the same Rama with a thousand names.[19]</p><p>God can be realised through all paths. All religions are true. The important thing is to reach the roof. You can reach it by stone stairs or by wooden stairs or by bamboo steps or by a rope. You can also climb up a bamboo pole…Each religion is only a path leading to God, as rivers come from different directions and ultimately become one in the one ocean… All religions and all paths call upon their followers to pray to one and the same God. Therefore one should not show disrespect to any religion or religious opinion.[20]</p><p>Very much in the spirit of Ramakrishna, Gandhi’s pluralism was itself pluralistic: that is, in the very act of articulating his view that many religions and philosophies are able to express the truth and to take their sincere practitioners ever closer to the realization of their potential divinity, he drew upon multiple traditions. Specifically, he drew upon the Jain philosophy of <em>anekāntavāda</em> (which I mentioned in the presentation that I gave here in June, on Vedanta and Jainism).</p><p>While Gandhi did embrace, in many of his writings, Advaita philosophy, he also spoke and wrote frequently of a personal God–distinct from humanity and from the rest of the universe–and of the importance of discerning and behaving in accordance with this God’s will, and of the actions of God as an agent in human history–theistic concepts much more in line with Vaishnav Dvaita philosophy, or with Abrahamic monotheism, than with the ultimately impersonal and formless, or <em>nirguṇa</em> Brahman of Advaita Vedanta.</p><p>In early 1926 or late 1925, this apparent inconsistency in his thought was pointed out by a reader of Gandhi’s English-language newspaper, <em>Young India</em>, in a letter to the editor. Gandhi’s response to this letter, in the January 21, 1926 issue, reveals the debt of his thought to Jainism:</p><p>I am an <em>advaitist</em> and yet I can support <em>Dvaitism</em> (dualism). The world is changing every moment, and is therefore unreal, it has no permanent existence. But though it is constantly changing, it has a something about it which persists and it is therefore to that extent real. I have therefore no objection to calling it real and unreal, and thus being called an <em>Anekantavadi</em> or a <em>Syadvadi</em>. [Syādvāda is the Jain doctrine that claims are true <em>syāt</em>: that is, in a certain sense, or from a certain point of view, rather than being absolutely true or false.]</p><p>Gandhi continues:</p><p>But my <em>Syadvada</em> is not the <em>syadvada</em> of the learned, it is peculiarly my own. I cannot engage in a debate with them. It has been my experience that I am always true from my point of view, and am often wrong from the point of view of my honest critics. I know that we are both right from our respective points of view. And this knowledge saves me from attributing motives to my opponents or critics. The seven blind men who gave seven different descriptions of the elephant were all right from their respective points of view, and wrong from the point of view of one another, and right and wrong from the point of view of the man who knew the elephant. I very much like this doctrine of the manyness of reality. It is this doctrine that has taught me to judge a Musalman [a Muslim] from his own standpoint and a Christian from his. Formerly I used to resent the ignorance of my opponents. Today I can love them because I am gifted with the eye to see myself as others see me <em>and vice versa</em>. I want to take the whole world in the embrace of my love. My <em>anekantavad</em> is the result of the twin doctrine of <em>Satya</em> and <em>Ahimsa</em> [truth and nonviolence].[21]</p><p>For Gandhi, again, openness to the truths of others is not merely a matter of political expediency, or what we might today call ‘political correctness.’ It stems from the core nature of existence, and is an application of the ancient yogic values of truth and nonviolence.</p><p><strong>On Eliminating Casteism</strong></p><p>After communal unity, the second goal Gandhi outlines is the removal of untouchability–and by extension, of caste prejudice in general–which he calls a “blot and curse upon Hinduism.”[22] Here, again, he echoes Swami Vivekananda, who was quite clear, and characteristically blunt, in his rejection of caste and untouchability, which interfered with human beings’ ability to see God in one another. Swamiji fiercely ridiculed what he called the “Don’t-touchism” of the Hinduism of his time, deriding it as “kitchen religion” for its emphasis on rules regarding dining between the members of different castes:</p><p>The present religion of the Hindus is neither the path of Knowledge or Reason–it is “Don’t-touchism.”–“Don’t touch me.” “Don’t touch me.”–that exhausts its description. “Don’t-touchism” is a form of mental disease. Beware! All expansion is life, all contraction is death. All love is expansion, all selfishness is contraction. Love is therefore the only law of life. See that you do not lose your lives in this dire irreligion of “Don’t-touchism.” Must the teaching (<em>Atma-vat sarvabhuteshu</em>)–“Looking upon all beings as your own self”–be confined to books alone? How will they grant salvation who cannot feed a hungry mouth with a crumb of bread? How will those, who become impure at the mere breath of others, purify others?[23]</p><p>Finally, as we have already seen, Vivekananda viewed the most vital service that could be rendered to the poor of India as education, which could enable them to empower themselves–or, in his words, “work out their own salvation.” Here, too, there is a direct line of continuity between Gandhi’s thought and Swami Vivekananda’s. Recall that Swami Vivekananda specifically links education with making the poor aware of their situation of political oppression. The particular kind of education he has in mind is one which will allow them to “develop their lost individuality.” “Priest-power and foreign conquest have trodden them down for centuries, and at last the poor of India have forgotten that they are human beings. They are to be given ideas; their eyes are to be opened to what is going on in the world around them; and then they will work out their own salvation.”</p><p>Gandhi, again echoing Vivekananda, says that the education that he has in mind, although including “literary education”–or education in the conventional sense of the term–will consist primarily of liberating knowledge that will enable the people to under-stand their situation and lift themselves above it.</p><p>The villagers know nothing of foreign rule and its evils. What little knowledge they have picked up fills them with the awe the foreigner inspires. The result is the dread and hatred of the foreigner and his rule. They do not know how to get rid of it. They do not know that the foreigner’s presence is due to their own weaknesses and their ignorance of the power they possess to rid themselves of the foreign rule. My adult education means, therefore, first, true political education of the adult by word of mouth.[24]</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>In celebration of the one hundred fiftieth birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi, we ought to acknowledge the profound debt his thought process owes to Vedanta (and of course to Jainism and to various systems of thought upon which he drew, putting his spirit of pluralism into action). We began by acknowledging that Gandhi himself was an imperfect human being: as are we all, so long as we are in the process of unfolding our as-yet-unrealized divine potential. This ideal of a divine potential, realized by Sri Ramakrishna and proclaimed to the world by Swami Vivekananda, was the very ideal which Gandhi sought to manifest in the social and political realms. It is an ideal that we still seek to realize today, not in the utopian belief that the world–the curly of tail of the dog–can ever be made to conform fully to our limited ideas of perfection, but in the belief that, as Swamiji has taught, the very effort to do so may itself serve to draw us each individually nearer to the ideal, even as we resolve specific, concrete problems in the world, utilizing our problems like the exercise equipment in the grand moral gymnasium of life.</p><p>What Thakur, Swamiji, and Mahatma Gandhi all encourage us to do is to realize that, in the words of the <em>Mahā Upaniṣad</em>, <em>vasudhaiva kutumbakam</em>.[25] “The world is one family.” In other words, the world is a mirror of our own consciousness. We cannot transform the world without transforming our consciousness, and we cannot transform our consciousness without transforming the world. What we do to others, we do to ourselves. Let us therefore live lives of compassion, seeing ourselves in others, and others in ourselves. In the words of Swami Vivekananda, “Do not injure another. Love everyone as your own self, because the whole universe is one. In injuring another, I am injuring myself; in loving another, I am loving myself.”[26] This is the core message of Mahatma Gandhi, and the message of Vedanta.</p><p>[1] <em>Ṛg Veda</em> 1.164: 46c</p><p>[2] Mohandas K. Gandhi, <em>The Story of My Experiments with Truth</em> (1957), p. 265</p><p>[3] Cited in Satyam Roy Chowdhury, ed., <em>Ramakrishna for You</em></p><p>[4] Joseph Lelyveld, <em>Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi and His Struggle with India</em> (New York: Vintage Books, 2012), 50</p><p>[5] Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 3, “Para-Bhakti or Supreme Devotion: Universal Love and How It Leads to Self-Surrender,” pp. 81–84.</p><p>[6] Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 1, “Krishna,” pp. 437–445.</p><p>[7] Swami Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 4, “My Master,” pp. 154–187.</p><p>[8] Swami Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 1, <em>Karma Yoga</em>, p. 76.</p><p>[9] Swami Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 4, “Our Duty to the Masses,” pp. 361–364. Emphasis in the original.</p><p>[10] I owe this insight to Rita D. Sherma, personal communication.</p><p>[11] Gandhi, “Constructive Programme: Its Meaning and Place” (Ahmedabad: The Navajivan Trust, 1945), p. 7</p><p>[12] Ibid.</p><p>[13] Ibid.</p><p>[14] Swami Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 1, <em>Karma Yoga</em>, p. 79.</p><p>[15] Ibid, p. 80</p><p>[16] Gandhi, “Constructive Programme,” p. 8</p><p>[17] Swami Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 2, “The Way to the Realisation of a Universal Religion,” pp. 359–374.</p><p>[18] Glyn Richards, <em>A Sourcebook of Modern Hinduism</em>,<em> </em>p. 156, 157.</p><p>[19] Swami Nikhilananda, <em>The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna</em>, p. 60.</p><p>[20] Richards, p. 65.</p><p>[21] Gandhi, <em>Complete Works</em> (1981), p. 30.</p><p>[22] Gandhi, “Constructive Programme,” p. 10.</p><p>[23] Swami Vivekananda, <em>The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda</em>, Volume 6, pp. 319–320.</p><p>[24] Gandhi “Constructive Programme,” p. 17</p><p>[25] <em>Mahā Upaniṣad</em> 6:71–73.</p><p>[26] Vivekananda, <em>Complete Works</em>, Volume 1, p. 364.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=53c83367c7fd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ahiṃsā and the International Day of Peace (presented at the United Nations, 23 August, 2019)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/ahi%E1%B9%83s%C4%81-and-the-international-day-of-peace-presented-at-the-united-nations-23-august-2019-9deecbac74c4?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9deecbac74c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jainism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonviolence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Aug 2019 15:42:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-24T15:42:11.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4vki2RDkpTpWf9x9KKUU2Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Good afternoon, and Namaste! I am most grateful to be invited to speak at the United Nations to underscore the importance of the International Day of Peace. My topic for today is the yogic value of <em>ahiṃsā</em>, which is often translated as <em>nonviolence</em>, but which, as we shall see, has even more profound and far-reaching consequences than this humble translation suggests.</p><p>The centrality of <em>ahiṃsā</em>to the yogic traditions of India cannot be exaggerated. In at least three different systems of spiritual practice–Hindu, Jain, and Buddhist–it is listed first among the ethical virtues that a serious aspirant on the spiritual path must practice. Interestingly, these systems list <em>ahiṃsā</em>even before <em>satya</em>, or truth. This primacy of nonviolence suggests that, when faced with the choice to press forward with our own interpretation of truth or to be mindful of the well-being of others, we opt for the well-being of others. This is an important lesson for all of us who are committed to various belief systems and ideologies. We always like to win arguments; but our pursuit of truth must always take into account the feelings of others, that we not deliberately belittle or disrespect them in the name of making our point.</p><p>In the <em>Yoga Sūtra</em>of Patañjali, <em>ahiṃsā</em>is listed first amongst the <em>yamas</em>, or ethical restraints, which together make up the first of the eight limbs of Patañjali’s eight-limbed yoga system. Far from being merely a set of physical exercises, Patañjali’s yoga is a holistic approach to life, including an ethical system in which <em>ahiṃsā</em>is the foremost value. Also from the Hindu tradition, one finds in the <em>Mahābhārata</em>the teaching, <em>ahiṃsā paramo dharmaḥ</em>: “<em>Ahiṃsā</em>is the highest duty.”</p><p>In the Buddhist tradition, <em>ahiṃsā </em>is also the first of the five moral precepts taught by the Buddha. These five precepts overlap with Patañjali’s <em>yamas</em>, with four of the five precepts being identical to four of the <em>yamas</em>. <em>Ahiṃsā</em>in practice amounts to a life of compassion for all beings, which is a core Buddhist value, seeing the sufferings of others as the same as one’s own.</p><p>In the Jain tradition, <em>ahiṃsā</em>is also listed as the first of the five <em>vrats</em>, or vows, which observant Jains are enjoined to practice. The Jain vows are identical to Patañjali’s <em>yamas</em>. For lay Jain practitioners, or householders, they are called <em>anuvrats</em>, or ‘small vows.’ The lay Jain observes these vows, such as <em>ahiṃsā</em>, to the degree that is possible within the constraints of living an active life in the world, with worldly responsibilities. The Jain ascetic, on the other hand, observes a stricter version of these vows, called the <em>mahāvrats</em>, or ‘great vows.’ These involve observing <em>ahiṃsā</em>and the other practices to the highest degree humanly possible. This requires setting aside householder life and devoting oneself fully to this profound level of observance. To illustrate the difference between the small vows and the great vows, we can point out, for example, that a Jain layperson who is observing <em>ahiṃsā</em>will be strictly vegetarian, and will avoid any deliberate harm to small life forms in the environment. But she will nevertheless go about what most people would call a normal routine of activities. Jain ascetics observing <em>ahiṃsā</em>, though, will not wear shoes (to avoid accidentally treading upon small life forms). They carry a whisk to gently sweep the ground in front of them as they walk, and any surface on which they may be about to sit, also to protect small life forms. Some will wear a cloth mask, or mouth-shield, to avoid accidentally ingesting or inhaling small life forms. If they are unable to continue observing these strictures for reasons relating to health or old age, they will voluntarily give up all consumption of food, offering their lives as a sacrifice to the well-being of others.</p><p><em>Ahiṃsā</em>is not simply nonviolence. It is the absence of even the desire to let any living being come to harm. It is, in other words, nonviolence in thought, word, and deed. It does not refer simply to avoiding active harm against living beings, while otherwise remaining indifferent to them. <em>Ahiṃsā</em>is the desire to ensure that all living beings live happily and free from fear of injury. While it can be translated as nonviolence, it can also be translated as love, or compassion for all beings.</p><p>As a yogic value, the centrality of <em>ahiṃsā</em>to all these traditions can be seen in their lived practice and in the fact that it is consistently listed as the first of the moral virtues that form the essential foundation for spiritual progress. All of these traditions are unanimous in affirming, “First, do no harm.” Indeed, do not even <em>will</em>any harm, or speak in a harmful way. How different would our world be today if all our leaders were to observe this principle?</p><p>How can the virtue of <em>ahiṃsā</em>inform humanity’s collective aspiration for world peace, which the International Day of Peace affirms? How can we make every day an International Day of Peace? Clearly, the strictures observed by Jain ascetics are not accessible to the vast majority of human beings. This is something the Jain tradition itself affirms in making a distinction between the small vows and the great vows. The yogic traditions unanimously affirm that we are each at different points on the spiritual path. Expecting everyone to practice at the same level would be like expecting a grade school student, who is just learning to add, subtract, multiply, and divide, to solve sophisticated calculus equations. <em>Ahiṃsā</em>, as a value, is absolute, but its application will vary depending upon where we are in our spiritual journey.</p><p>Indeed, affirming the value of <em>ahiṃsā</em>is even consistent, for some, with defending themselves and their families with force if necessary. Even Mahatma Gandhi, the figure most widely associated with <em>ahiṃsā</em>in the modern world, affirmed the occasional necessity of force for self-defense; but he also said in this regard that if we are committed to <em>ahiṃsā</em>, “we have to choose the path of least violence.” He also strongly rejected cowardice, and affirmed that cowardice is even worse than violence.</p><p><em>Ahiṃsā</em>is not at all consistent, however, with the glorification of violence or war, or hatred toward any living being: even those who seek to do harm. Using force while being committed to <em>ahiṃsā </em>means using only that much force as is required to prevent even greater suffering. It also means maintaining compassion even toward those against whom one uses force. This noble ideal is expressed well by the Chinese sage Lao-tzu in his <em>Daodejing</em>:</p><p>The wise person enters a battle gravely,<br>with sorrow and with great compassion,<br>as if attending a funeral.</p><p>(<em>Daodejing </em>31)</p><p>It is expressed equally well by Jimmy Carter, who said, “War may sometimes be a necessary evil. But no matter how necessary, it is always an evil, never a good.”</p><p>On this International Day of Peace, in 2019, as nations continue to pour resources into weaponry and many of our leaders and fellow citizens see war not as an occasionally necessary evil, but as something to be pursued with enthusiasm, and with hatred for the enemy, affirming the value of <em>ahiṃsā</em>means taking a firm stand against all such glorification of violence. <em>Ahiṃsā</em>is rooted in the realization of the interconnectedness and ultimate oneness of all life. On World Peace Day, let us affirm the words of the <em>Mahā Upaniṣad</em>: <em>vasudhaiva kuṭumbakam</em>.Humanity is a single family. When we harm others, or even wish to harm others, or express our approval for harm being done to others, in reality, we harm ourselves. Similarly, when we work for peace, and for the well-being of all, we are, in reality, as Swami Vivekananda has affirmed, helping ourselves. I conclude with Swamiji’s words, “Do not injure another. Love everyone as your own self, because the whole universe is one. In injuring another, I am injuring myself; in loving another, I am loving myself.” (CW 1.364)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9deecbac74c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Comparative Study of Jain Philosophy and Vedanta]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/a-comparative-study-of-jain-philosophy-and-vedanta-d55bc519694c?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d55bc519694c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jainism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ramakrishna]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2019 01:03:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-20T01:03:42.713Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iOReiXg09CFDpXRT8Y7eFQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Presented at the Vedanta Society of New York on June 16, 2019</p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>Good morning! Namaste, Namaskār, and, to use the traditional Jain greeting, Jai Jinendra! It is my great honor to speak once again here at the Vedanta Society of New York, established by Swami Vivekananda himself in 1894. I would also like to wish everyone a Happy Guru Pūrṇima and a Happy Father’s Day. On this auspicious occasion, Swami Sarvapriyananda has asked me to speak to you about Jainism, a tradition that is certainly distinct from Vedānta, but that also has a great deal in common with it.</p><p>For those of you who do not know me, I have been a member of the Vedānta Society for a number of years now. My wife and I both took initiation from Swami Tyagananda, of the Boston Ramakrishna Vedanta Society, in 2005, although both of us have been drawn to Vedanta for much longer, going back to our respective childhoods. I have also, in the course of my career, done a fair amount of research on the Jain tradition, and wrote a textbook on this tradition titled <em>Jainism: An Introduction</em>, which was published in 2009. I am grateful to say that my work has been warmly received by the Jain community, and that <em>Jainism: An Introduction</em>is even used as a textbook in the International Summer School for Jain Studies, which is run every year by members of the Jain community in New Delhi, India. In just three more weeks, I am scheduled to speak at the annual convention of JAINA, the Jain Association in North America, which is to be held in Los Angeles, California, and last year, I had the honor of speaking at the Indian Consulate right here in New York on the occasion of Mahavir Jayanti, the holy day celebrating the birth and enlightenment of the great Jain sage, Mahāvīra.</p><p>Over the course of my career, I have been told by some scholars that my interpretation of Vedānta bears some resemblances to Jainism. I have also been told, by some other scholars, that my interpretation of Jainism sounds a great deal like Vedānta. My presentation today will perhaps prove that both of these groups have a point; for I shall argue that, while there are indeed significant differences between these two philosophies–Jainism and Vedānta–there is also an important sense in which they share a philosophical vision. This is particularly the case of Jainism and the Vedānta taught by Sri Ramakrishna and Swami Vivekananda–the Vedānta of the Vedanta Society.</p><p>I shall begin with a very broad overview of both Jainism and Vedānta, spending somewhat less time explicating Vedānta, on the assumption that most of you are already deeply familiar with it. I shall then speak briefly on what has drawn me to both traditions–to the practice of Vedānta and the study of Jainism–and then delve into the central point of my presentation, which is that the vision these two traditions share is one of pluralism, in which all worldviews are given respect and in which each is seen as capturing at least an aspect of the infinite truth. I see this vision as being of particularly urgent importance in our world today, which is characterized by deep suspicion and violence among communities based on differences of belief and practice.</p><p><strong>Jainism and Vedānta: A Broad Comparative Overview</strong></p><p>The obvious similarities between Jainism and Vedānta arise from their having originated in India. Adherents of these two traditions share the same basic cosmology that is shared across all Indic religious traditions: Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, and Sikh. Jains and Vedāntins both believe that the cosmos has always existed, there being no such thing as an absolute beginning of time, but that the realm of time, space, and causation goes through periodic cycles of arising, persistence, and destruction. Thus, this particular universe, the one we are inhabiting, had a beginning (which, according to modern science, occurred with the Big Bang roughly fourteen billion years ago–on a time scale quite compatible with the shared vision of the Indic traditions). It will also have an end, which is also quite far in the future. But this end will be followed by another beginning. A new cosmic cycle will start, and so on, and so on, to infinity. Similarly, our current universe was itself preceded by an earlier one, and another before that, and another before that, again, to infinity. The details of this process differ between the two traditions. According to the Vedāntic vision, creation, preservation, and destruction are presided over by a Supreme Being, a deity whose function is to ensure the smooth unfolding of the cosmic process. In the mode of creation, this deity is known as Brahmā, in the mode of preservation, as Viṣṇu, and in the mode of destruction for the sake of re-creation, as Śiva. Brahmā, Viṣṇu, and Śiva are each accompanied by a <em>śakti</em>, or a power, who makes possible their respective activities: Sarasvatī, Lakṣmī, and the Mother Goddess, variously known as Devī, Umā, Parvatī, Durgā, Kālī, or simply Śakti. According to the Jain vision, no such presiding deity is necessary to account for the smooth unfolding of the cosmic process, which can be explained fully by the workings of <em>karma</em>, the law of cause and effect that is affirmed by both Jains and Vedāntins, as well as by Buddhists and Sikhs.</p><p>According to Jainism and Vedānta–and again, all the Indic traditions–we living beings in the realm of time, space, and causation are undergoing a process of rebirth, a cycle which is known as <em>saṃsāra</em>. As individuals, this lifetime is not our only existence. Rather, as Lord Krishna says in the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>, “There was never a time when you and I did not exist, nor is there any time in the future when shall cease to be. Just as a person discards old and worn-out clothing and takes on a new set of clothing, thus does the embodied soul discard one body and take on another. The wise are not deluded by these changes.” Jains and Vedāntins thus share the reassuring view that, when we lose our loved ones, they have not ceased to exist. They have simply changed form, just as contemporary physics states that energy and matter (which are really the same thing) are never really destroyed. They simply change their state of being. Our loved ones carry on their existence in another form, and we shall do the same. We may even re-associate in the future. Similarly, it may well be that those who are near and dear to us today were our loved ones in former lives, and that we are now re-associating. And it may be that those with whom we have conflicts are souls with whom we have been in conflict in the past, and we still have yet to resolve our differences.</p><p>In both Jainism and Vedānta, though, the continuation of existence in a physical form, even though it is reassuring in the face of personal tragedy and loss, is not the ultimate aim of life. In fact, saṃsāra is seen in both traditions as a form of suffering (a teaching also found prominently in Buddhism). Our ultimate aim is to move from this time-bound, impermanent, and constantly shifting form of existence to the realm of the eternal: or in the words of the <em>Upaniṣads</em>, “from the unreal to the real, from darkness to light, from death to immortality.”</p><p>Our aim, in other words, according to both traditions, is <em>mokṣa</em>, or liberation from the cycle of rebirth.</p><p>According to both Jainism and Vedānta, we are bound to the cycle of rebirth by karma, the law of causation according to which each of our actions produces an effect. These effects must be experienced by their doer. As doers of action, we are therefore bound to experience the effects of our actions. This leads to rebirth, because, as we are constantly engaged in action, new effects are constantly being created for us to experience; so even at the moment of death, residual effects are still present which will pull us back into the cycle of rebirth, almost like a gravitational or magnetic pull being exerted on matter.</p><p>In regard to the details–the mechanics, if you will–of how karma works, and of how one becomes free from the karmic process, there are both similarities and differences between Jainism and Vedānta. I just mentioned the idea of karma as something akin to a gravitational or magnetic pull being exerted upon the soul, drawing it inexorably into the realm of rebirth after the death of the physical body. From a Jain point of view, this is precisely what is happening. According to Jain teaching, karma is not simply a law of causation (though it is that as well). It is also a type of matter or energy which adheres, in a very literal way, to the soul, causing it to experience karmic effects. The aim of Jain practice is to purify the soul of this karmic matter. This matter obscures the true nature of the soul, or <em>jīva</em>, and keeps it bound to a physical body. When the jīva is free of karma, it then manifests its true nature as infinite knowledge, infinite perception, infinite bliss, and infinite energy. It is then forever free, residing in a realm known as the <em>Siddhaloka</em>, the realm of the perfected ones. The ultimate aim of life is to realize, to fully manifest, the perfection that has always, already been the true nature of the soul: a nature that has been obscured by the presence of karmic matter.</p><p>According to Vedānta, we are all undergoing a similar process. Rather than literal, physical particles of karmic matter adhering to the soul and obscuring its true nature, Vedānta, particularly Advaita Vedānta, focuses upon our consciousness, our false belief that we are a body, a being that is characterized by the limitations of time, space, and causation. As in Jainism, it is taught in the Vedānta tradition that our true nature is not of this limited, physical nature. Rather, we are infinite being, infinite consciousness, and infinite bliss. In both traditions, our reality is one of infinity that has been limited by association with the finite. In Advaita Vedānta, this limitation is only apparent and is removed by the achievement of knowledge, or <em>jñāna</em>: the realization that we are, in fact, not limited beings, but that our true nature, or <em>ātman</em>, is identical with the infinite <em>Brahman</em>that is the foundation of all existence and the ground of all being. In Jainism, this limitation is not merely an apparent one, but is a function of energies that have become associated with the soul, from which the soul needs to disassociate itself. In Advaita Vedānta, our bondage is an effect of our ignorance, or of <em>māyā</em>, which makes reality appear to us other than as it truly is. In Jainism, our ignorance is an effect of our bondage, a consequence of the karmic energies adhering to the soul.</p><p>The difference between the two is a subtle one, and is obscured by the fact that a Vedāntin would certainly agree that our bondage, our experience of identifying with the body, has reinforced our ignorance: our mistaken sense that the body is really what we are; and a Jain would certainly agree that overcoming our ignorance, learning about the true nature of the soul and experiencing it through spiritual practice, is an essential component in freeing ourselves from our bondage. The difference thus must not be overstated. Both are about the same basic spiritual project of liberation.</p><p>The shared purpose of spiritual liberation and realization, the manifestation of our true self, also gives rise to shared values and practices. Jainism and Vedānta both, for example, teach that the acquisition of liberating spiritual knowledge is not simply a cognitive matter. It is not, in other words, simply a matter of reading books and listening to lectures and learning true things. It is a matter of direct realization, which must occur through practice. Both traditions teach that making the mind a suitable vehicle for realization requires moral training. Bad habits, or <em>saṃskāras</em>, that run contrary to the aims of the spiritual path must be replaced by good ones. Indeed, the five vows, or <em>vratas</em>, that define the basic teachings of Jain morality are identical to the five <em>yamas</em>found in the <em>Yoga Sūtra</em>of Patañjali, a text which has been adopted into the Vedānta tradition for centuries, even though the Yoga tradition was originally a school of thought distinct from Vedānta.</p><p>These five shared moral principles that ground the practices of both Jainism and Vedānta are, first of all, <em>ahiṃsā</em>, or nonviolence in thought, word, and deed. Ahiṃsā is not merely refraining from harming other living beings. It is being free even from the desire to see others come to harm. It is also not a state of indifference to the suffering of other living beings. Although it is phrased negatively, as the absence of the desire to do harm, ahiṃsā, in practice, really amounts to <em>dāyā</em>, or compassion: an active love and concern for the welfare of all beings. Secondly, there is <em>satya</em>, or truth, to which both traditions are absolutely committed. Thirdly, there is <em>asteya</em>, or not stealing, which is followed by <em>brahmacarya</em>, or chastity, and <em>aparigraha</em>, or detachment, both from material things and from thoughts and emotional states which distract us from the spiritual path: negativity, fear, and so on.</p><p>Jains also share a number of other practices with Vedāntins. Both traditions revere sages who have achieved realization and who have taught the spiritual path to others. In Jainism, these are, primarily, the <em>Tīrthaṅkaras</em>: twenty-four spiritual teachers who have found the path to freedom and re-established the Jain community over the course of our current cosmic cycle. The last such teacher to appear in our world, for this cosmic cycle, is Mahāvīra, the ‘Great Hero.’ Mahāvīra was a contemporary of the Buddha who lived roughly twenty-five hundred years ago in northern India. Like the Buddha, he was born to the royal class and, like the Buddha, renounced the world around the age of thirty in order to pursue spiritual liberation, for himself and for the benefit of all beings. Like the Buddha, he established a community of ascetics, and a wider community of lay followers. Similarly, in the Vedānta tradition, we have a community of male and female ascetics–of swamis and pravrajikas–and a wider community of householders. Just as the Jains revere the Tīrthaṅkaras, we in the Vedanta Society revere Sri Ramakrishna, the Holy Mother, and Swami Vivekananda, as adherents of the various traditions that make up Vedānta revere their founding figures: sages such as Śaṅkara, Rāmānuja, Nimbārka, Madhva, Vallabha, and so on. And while Jains do not affirm a need for a single supreme deity to preside over the cosmic process, they do affirm, like Vedāntins, the divinity of the soul. As Jainism scholar John Cort has pointed out, the Jain concept of divinity is a collective one. Jains do use terms such as <em>Dev</em>, <em>Bhagavān</em>, and the English word ‘God’ to refer to the sum total of liberated beings: those who have fully manifested the divinity that is inherent in all of us, in the form of the jīva, or living soul. This is the ‘Jinendra’ mentioned in the greeting ‘Jai Jinendra!’ <em>Jinendra</em>refers to all beings who have attained liberation, and who are <em>jitendriya</em>: that is, who have overcome attachment to the senses. And this is of course the goal of Vedānta as well. Finally, the Jains also revere various Hindu deities as beings capable of providing assistance in times of need, such as the Goddesses Lakṣmī and Sarasvatī, and Lord Gaṇeśa.</p><p>The difference mentioned earlier, though, between the basic vision of Vedānta and that of Jainism, does lead to a difference in emphasis between the two traditions. This difference, again, is that, from a Jain point of view it is our literal bondage to karmic energies that adhere to the soul that is the source of our ignorance, while, from the point of view of Vedānta, particularly Advaita Vedānta, it is our ignorance that gives rise to our bondage.</p><p>Because Jainism is focused on purifying the soul of karmic matter, there is a much greater emphasis in this tradition on a highly rigorous ascetic process aimed at not only mental, but also physical, purification. Jain ascetics seek to practice ahiṃsā, the non-harming of any living thing, to the greatest extent that is humanly possible, and even Jain laypersons go to great lengths in order to avoid harming any living being, cultivating a lifestyle of maximum nonviolence. This, indeed, is the thing for which Jains are known best: for practicing not only strict vegetarianism, but also for avoiding even certain vegetables, such as root vegetables, whose consumption involves killing of an entire plant. I have seen Jains at a religious gathering near Philadelphia clustered along the sidewalks near their temple in order to avoid stepping on the grass and harming not only the small life forms that might be crawling there, but also the very grass itself. Jain munis and sādhvīs, or ‘monks and nuns,’ depending on the particular Jain tradition to which they belong, will often wear a face-mask, or <em>muhpatti</em>, to avoid accidentally inhaling or ingesting small life forms like insects. Many carry a whisk or broom to sweep the ground in front of them to avoid accidentally stepping on an insect, and to sweep any space on which they might sit, also to avoid injuring small living things.</p><p>Because Vedānta is focused on the transformation of consciousness, on purifying the mind, the practice of Vedānta is focused more upon the cultivation of inner states than upon the outward impact that one might have upon the world. Three of the four yogas taught by Swami Vivekananda are aimed specifically at making the mind a fit vehicle for realization. Through jñāna yoga, the path of wisdom, one develops one’s discernment in order to differentiate between the real and the unreal, between Brahman and its appearance as māyā. Through bhakti yoga, one subordinates the ego completely to a personal form of Brahman, using the power of love to achieve realization, and submerging the ego completely into the divine beloved. Finally, through raja or dhyāna yoga, or meditation, one allows one’s consciousness to be absorbed completely in the contemplation of the divine self within: the state of <em>samādhi</em>. Even karma yoga, though, in which one dedicates oneself to the service of others, the focus is not so much on achieving results in the external world as on the effect this has upon our own consciousness, through overcoming the ego by subordinating it to the service of others. This is why Swami Vivekananda, when explicating karma yoga, explains “that in helping the world we help ourselves. The main effect of work done for others is to purify ourselves. By means of the constant effort to do good to others we are trying to forget ourselves; this forgetfulness of self [meaning ego] is the one great lesson we have to learn in life.” (<em>Complete Works</em>1:84) In order for such service to be effective in eradicating the ego and leading to liberation there must be complete detachment from its fruits. One must not worry about success or failure, but must simply dedicate oneself to the work, as it is good in its own right. And one must certainly not worry about receiving gratitude or recognition. If we do our work with these things in mind, then we simply receive the karmic result that is its outcome, rather than purifying the mind for the sake of liberation. The aim, again, is not the work itself, much less its outcome, but the overcoming of ego and the dawning of spiritual realization: the transformation of consciousness.</p><p>Again, the difference between Jainism and Vedānta in this regard is subtle, and should not be exaggerated. Certainly the Jain practice of ahiṃsā, while outwardly devoted to the protection of living beings, also issues in a transformation of consciousness. Indeed, Jain ascetics often say that they see their practice of nonviolence as a way of cultivating mindfulness. Similarly, it is not the case that Vedāntins do not care about the good of the world. Swami Vivekananda would not have made the long journey in 1893 to spread Vedāntic teaching in the West, nor would he have initiated the work of the Ramakrishna Mission, if he had were not motivated by deep compassion for the sufferings of others, both spiritual and physical. The difference in the metaphysical visions of these two traditions, though–the emphasis of one on material energies actually adhering to and impeding the vision of the soul, and of the other on a fundamental misconception of the nature of existence that needs correction on an existential level–could be seen to correspond to the greater strictness of the one in terms of the actual practice of nonviolence and the greater emphasis of the other on meditative and contemplative practice.</p><p><strong>My Interest in Vedānta and Jainism</strong></p><p>Turning now from a broad overview of the philosophies and practices of these traditions, I would now like to speak briefly to my own interest in them, which shall lead into a discussion of what I take to be one of the most important points of compatibility between Jainism and Vedānta: and specifically, the Vedānta of Sri Ramakrishna.</p><p>I am often asked how I came to have such a deep interest in these traditions. First, in regard to Vedānta, I have frequently told the story of how the loss of my father when I was a child led to an interest in, eventually culminating in a lifelong commitment to, Vedānta. I was brought up in the Roman Catholic tradition of Christianity. My family and I lived in a small town in Missouri called Montgomery City. I was my parents’ only child, but our extended family was quite large: aunts, uncles, cousins, and so on. When I was ten years old, my father was in a terrible accident that left him unable to live a normal life. Over the course of a year and a half, he was moved from hospital to hospital, and to various rehabilitation centers, and eventually came home to live with us. Our living room became a hospital room, dedicated to his care, and my mother’s full time job became looking after his health and well-being. When I was twelve, his despondency over what had happened to him led him to take his own life.</p><p>In the months that followed, I began to think deeply about philosophical questions such as the nature of the afterlife and the meaning of suffering. Why does God allow so much suffering in the world? Is there even a God? What, if anything, happens to us after we die? Is there such a thing as cosmic justice? Is it possible for us to know the answers to questions like this, and if so, how might we do so?</p><p>In the course of my questioning, I became inspired by a number of sources. I found a great deal of inspiration, and much wisdom, in the teachings of my Catholic faith. There were also some things, though, that did not entirely make sense to me. I especially began to question traditional Christian teaching about the afterlife. It seemed that, if there were such a thing as cosmic justice, then both heaven and hell, eternal joy and eternal suffering, were rather extreme options. It seemed more likely to me that our next life would be something like this one: a mix of joy and suffering, a set of experiences that would teach us and help us to evolve toward greater perfection.</p><p>I was convinced by my father’s experiences that we are not only this physical body. My father’s body had become a prison to him. If our body can be a prison to us, if it can turn against us, then it must be something distinct from the self. I believed that when my father took his own life, he had freed himself from this prison. I also, however, did not believe that he had attained to any kind of cosmic perfection. It seemed to me more likely that his journey would continue on in another form. I began to believe, essentially, in the idea of karma and rebirth.</p><p>I also began to get clues from popular culture. I know that my good friend, Phil Goldberg, spoke here last week on the influence of Vedānta on popular culture. In his book <em>American Veda</em>, he talks about the music of George Harrison, of the Beatles, and how Harrison’s journey continues to inspire many even today. Indeed, he mentions me in his book as a person not from the generation of the nineteen sixties who was inspired by Harrison. (I will also mention that, if you look in the acknowledgements page of <em>American Veda</em>, you will see the names of seven of my former students whom Phil hired to transcribe interviews for him as he was writing this book.) I was fascinated by the philosophy that Harrison expressed in his music and in the cover art of his albums: by his references to Krishna and to the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>. I also saw the film <em>Gandhi</em>at this time, and was similarly fascinated by Gandhi, and read everything I could find about him. In Gandhi’s writings, too, I found references to the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>. Finally, I came upon the <em>Gītā</em>itself at a flea market held in the parking lot of the local Methodist Church. Upon opening it, I came upon its teaching, mentioned earlier, of the immortality of the soul, and the reality of rebirth. In the <em>Gītā</em>, I found a philosophy that made perfect sense to me: that had answers to my questions that were both rational and intuitively appealing. Like many Westerners, I found in the philosophy of Vedānta a ‘middle path’ between Western religion, which makes appeals to faith, but is not always satisfying on the rational level, and Western science, which is rational, but does not always satisfy our need for a deeper meaning behind our experiences: our spiritual aspirations.</p><p>One of the teachings of the <em>Gītā</em>that I found appealing was its teaching that no person is condemned forever based on their religious practice. Lord Krishna says to Arjuna, “In whatsoever way living beings approach me, thus do I receive them. All paths lead to me.” (<em>BG </em>4:11) This is, of course, a verse quoted by Swami Vivekananda in his famous ‘Sisters and Brothers of America’ speech at the World Parliament of Religions in Chicago. Another book that I read early on in my search was Huston Smith’s <em>The Religions of Man</em>, which is where I first read about Ramakrishna. Ramakrishna’s teaching that all paths lead to God was deeply appealing to me: that the various names by which ultimate reality is known in the world’s traditions are but many different names for the same infinite One. As Ramakrishna teaches, just as people call water by many names, in their various languages, and draw it from many different sources, and it is nevertheless the same water, in the same way, people approach the Infinite from different perspectives, based on their cultural and religious backgrounds and prior philosophical assumptions, and call It by different names and conceive of it in different ways. Ramakrishna also cites the ancient Indian story, used by Hindus, Jains, and Buddhists alike, of the blind men and the elephant to illustrate this point. If we all seem to be talking about different things in our various traditions and systems of philosophy, it is not necessarily because only one of us is right and the rest are wrong, but that each of us has only one small piece of the total reality in our grasp, just as each blind man grasps only a portion of the elephant. To cite Pravrajika Vrajaprana, each religion is like a piece of a puzzle. Each piece is different from the rest, but each can fit together to form a larger vision of reality.</p><p>This made much more sense to me than the attitude that I encountered among many in my small Missouri town, where even being Roman Catholic was considered by some to be practicing a ‘wrong’ form of Christianity. In the heavily evangelical environment where I lived, I was told more than once that I was going to hell for being Catholic. And when my conversation partners found out that I was not only Catholic, but a Catholic who believed in reincarnation and read books about Hinduism and other religions, then they <em>knew</em>I was going to hell.</p><p>This whole idea of going to hell, though, especially for following the religion in which one had been brought up, and which one had as much reason to trust as the evangelicals had for trusting in their religion, seemed to me to be terribly unfair, and certainly unworthy of a God, in whom the evangelicals also claimed to believe, who was said to be a being of infinite love. It made much more sense, if God is a God of love, if the divine truths that one needed to know in order to draw nearer to God were distributed around the world, throughout time and space, and not dependent on the activity of missionaries to spread them. This would mean that sacred truths could be found in all religions and cultures. And this, indeed, was the thesis I discovered in the work of another Western Vedāntin, Aldous Huxley, in his class work, <em>The Perennial Philosophy</em>.</p><p>This also made sense, I felt, from what one might call a scientific perspective. If there is such a thing as objective reality–if the universe is a certain way–then it would make sense if smart people from around the world had all been able to perceive some of its central features, just as we can all agree, more or less, on the nature of the physical reality that we together inhabit. And, sure enough, one does find–even though there are significant differences among them, to be sure–that certain shared insights about the nature of reality, of mind, of self, and of morality, can be found in a variety of religions, philosophies, and cultures from around the world and throughout history.</p><p>As I grew older, I chose to pursue a career as a scholar of religion, precisely because these kinds of questions are so fascinating to me. Most scholars of religion are more interested in social and historical issues than metaphysical ones. While I have of course needed to learn–and have enjoyed learning–about these things as well, my primary interest has been in philosophy, and my primary training in graduate school was in the philosophy of religion.</p><p>The particular view that I came to hold regarding the presence of truth in many religions and philosophies is known in scholarly circles as <em>pluralism</em>. As I finished college and began my graduate studies in the early nineteen nineties, I found that pluralism had some strong advocates, such as John Hick, Paul F. Knitter, Wilfred Cantwell Smith, and Raimundo Panikkar (on whose work I wrote my undergraduate thesis). But I also found that it was a position under siege. On the one hand, conservative Christian theologians took exception to the pluralistic view that there was nothing unique, in any ultimate sense, about Christianity: that it was one more path to ultimate truth among many. On the other hand, philosophy and theology were themselves viewed, and are still viewed, with a good deal of suspicion by secular scholars. People such as Huston Smith, who affirmed a thread of truth running through many religious traditions were derided as ignoring the important differences among traditions, and the academy as a whole seemed to be moving in the direction of affirming difference over similarity, and viewing claims of similarity and sameness, again, with suspicion; for it is often the case that we project our own experience and understanding of reality onto the materials that we study, and it is certainly true that we need to be constantly on guard against engaging in projection of this kind. Of course, pluralism does not teach that religions are all <em>the same</em>. Puzzle pieces are not identical to one another. But they are mutually coherent.</p><p>I thus took arguing for this position as my chief mission as a philosopher of religion. At an early point in my graduate studies, I began an in-depth study of Indian philosophy. I had already read a good deal about Vedānta, and about Hinduism more broadly, as well as Buddhism and other religious and philosophical traditions. But this was largely private study, while my formal training in college had mainly been in the Western tradition (having pursued a double major in theology and the great books program, or Program of Libera Studies, at the University of Notre Dame). It was while reading a book by the late Bimal Krishna Matilal, <em>Logic, Language, and Reality</em>, that I came upon an account of Jain philosophy. And there, I believed I had found the secret to arguing for a logically rigorous philosophy of pluralism.</p><p><strong>Anekāntavāda: The Convergence of Jainism and the Vedānta of Sri Ramakrishna</strong></p><p>The central metaphysical doctrine of Jainism is a teaching called <em>anekāntavāda</em>: that is, the teaching of the complexity of existence. Reality, according to Jainism, is multi-faceted. There is that in reality which is permanent and stable. There is that in reality which is impermanent and is constantly changing. Vedānta and other systems of Hindu philosophy tend to emphasize the first aspect. Buddhism tends to emphasize the second. A complete understanding of reality, however, must be able to comprehend both. Differences in religious belief systems and philosophical world views arise based on which facet of reality one perceives to be fundamental–which part of the body of the elephant the blind man grasps, so to speak. In fact, however, reality encompasses a variety of aspects, each of which has its place in the larger cosmic picture. On the basis of this view, the Jain tradition develops <em>syādvāda</em>, which is an approach to truth based on the idea that all claims are, in one sense, true, in another sense, false, in another sense, both true and false, and in another sense, neither true nor false (or indescribable), and so on. The truth of our claims depends upon the perspective from which they are made: the facet of reality which serves as their basis. So the claim of Buddhists that ‘all is impermanent’ (sarvam anityam) is true. It describes one dimension of the nature of existence. But the Advaita claim that all that exists is one eternal entity, beyond the realm of time, space, and causation, is also true, describing, as it does, yet another dimension of existence.</p><p>In classical Indian philosophy, of course, adherents of Advaita Vedānta strongly rejected the Jain claim of the multi-faceted nature of existence, claiming that Brahman alone was real, and the world an illusion: <em>jagan mithya</em>. Other sysems of Vedānta, however, were much closer to the Jain perspective, affirming the reality, for example, of the distinction between God, or Īśvara, and the individual soul, or jīva, and amongst the jīvas themselves. The Dvaita, or dualistic system of Vedānta, indeed affirms difference, rather than non-duality, as its fundamental principle for the interpretation of the Vedic scriptures: the <em>Upaniṣads</em>,<em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>, and <em>Brahmā Sūtras</em>.</p><p>As another good friend of mine, Ayon Maharaj, however, has recently argued in his book <em>Infinite Paths to Infinite Reality</em>, and as I have similarly argued at various points, the approach of Sri Ramakrishna to these issues is distinct from those of earlier interpreters of Vedānta, and bears important similarities to the Jain approach of anekāntavāda and syādvāda. Ramakrishna takes a non-dogmatic approach to diverse paths, seeing the way each path conceives of reality as a function of which aspect of reality that path takes as fundamental, those he mentions most often being the impersonal Brahman, the Self within, or Bhagavān, the divine beloved.</p><p>Rather than seeing one of these as solely real and the others as false, or lesser, Ramakrishna sees each as simply different, and each as appropriate to those who practice a path to realization based upon it. For Ramakrishna, what is important is realization itself: following one’s path with complete and single-minded dedication. It is perhaps such dedication that can sometimes sound like dogmatic absolutism. If I am single-mindedly focused on realizing the impersonal Brahman, then perhaps I have no time for the personal God. Or if I am absorbed in bhakti, perhaps I have no time for an impersonal anything, or for any deity other than my own (hence the attitude of many evangelical Christians). But Sri Ramakrishna’s distinctive teaching–his message as the <em>Yugāvatar</em>, the divine teacher for our era–is that, even as we pursue our own path with complete devotion, we ought not to disrespect the paths of others. As Thakur himself said, we each think our own watch tells the correct time.</p><p>Much more can be, and should be, said on this topic. Time does not permit me to go into much greater depth in regard to the various dimensions of Jainism and Vedānta, or such topics as the thought of the Digambara Jain sage, Kundakunda, whose view of the role of consciousness in liberation is quite close to that of Advaita Vedānta. But the shared insight of these two traditions–and specifically, of the Jain teaching of <em>anekānta</em>and the Vedānta of Ramakrishna–is that reality can be approached in many ways, that there is truth to be found in many perspectives, and that it is essential to human advancement that all of these ways be respected, and that we learn to draw insight from one another through dialogue. Only then will our shared picture of the whole elephant–that is, all of reality–become more complete.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d55bc519694c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Idea of the Avatar: Ramakrishna, Buddha, Christ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/the-idea-of-the-avatar-ramakrishna-buddha-christ-94e69773a17?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/94e69773a17</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[avatar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ramakrishna]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2019 00:59:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-20T00:59:16.369Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bgSEZjfpcdmjOuEAUvtKdg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Presented at the Greater DC Vedanta Society, December 9, 2018</p><p>Namaste, Namaskar, and good morning! Today, I would like to explore the idea of the avatar–the divine incarnation, or more literally, divine ‘descent,’ if we are to be true to the original Sanskrit meaning of this term.</p><p>To my knowledge, the first appearance of this concept in Sanskrit literature is in the seventh verse of the fourth chapter of the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>. In this verse, Lord Krishna tells Arjuna, <em>yadā yadā hi dharmasya glanir bhavati Bharata, abhyutanam adharmasya tadātmānaṃ sṛjāmyaham</em>. “Whenever dharma, the moral order of the universe, declines, and adharma, or chaos, arises, then do I manifest myself.” In the verse which follows, Krishna explains that he manifests himself into the world in order to bring an end to chaos and evil and to restore dharma. Though the actual word <em>avatar</em>does not appear in the <em>Gītā</em>, it is clear from the context of the tradition that this is the idea to which Krishna is referring. In the <em>Bhāgavata Pūrāṇa</em>, and in other Hindu texts, the idea of the avatar is elaborated further, and lists of avatars are given. There are at least two lists of ten avatars, another list of twenty-four, and another of one hundred and eight. It is also said that there are, in reality, countless avatars. Given the infinite cycles of existence through which the universe passes according to Hindu teaching, as well as the existence of countless other universes, both as taught in Hindu texts and as postulated by contemporary physics, it stands to reason that the number of avatars would also be potentially infinite, with divine manifestations appearing in each and every age of each and every cosmic cycle, as well as on countless worlds: that is, wherever and whenever dharma declines and adharma arises. Perhaps there are realms and regions and eras of history in which this never occurs: in which dharma never declines and adharma never arises, and so there is no need for such divine manifestations. But these regions would certainly not be the region of the cosmos where we reside, nor would it reflect the nature of history as we know it in this world, as human beings.</p><p>The best way to understand the nature and function of the avatar is to examine the lives of such beings. The best known list of avatars is the list of ten which includes Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, as its ninth member. This seems to be a modification of an earlier list, which includes, instead of the Buddha, Bālarāma, the brother of Krishna. According to both lists, the first avatar is the Matsya, or Fish, avatar. Second is the Kurma, or Tortoise, avatar. Third is the Varaha, or boar, avatar. Fourth is the Narasimha, or Man-Lion, avatar. Fifth is the Vāmana, or Dwarf, avatar. Sixth is Paraśurāma, or Rāma with an axe, who is not to be confused with the seventh avatar, Rām, the hero of the <em>Rāmāyaṇa</em>, and possibly the most popular of the ten avatars, or Daśāvatāra.</p><p>The eighth avatar, according to the earlier list, is Bālarāma, the brother of Lord Krishna, who is followed by Lord Krishna himself, as the ninth. In the later list, the eighth avatar is Krishna and the ninth is the Buddha. Finally, the tenth avatar, Kālkī, is the avatar who is yet to come.</p><p>Although it is incomplete, given that the avatars are virtually infinite in number, the list of ten avatars, particularly in its second version, holds very deep spiritual significance. According to Sri Aurobindo, the list of ten avatars represents a condensed symbolic account of the evolution of consciousness in the material world. Aurobindo builds upon the work of Swami Vivekananda, in his teaching that what we call, from a materialistic perspective, the evolution of consciousness, is, from a spiritual perspective, the very same process as the descent or the <em>involution</em>of consciousness into the realm of matter. In other words, if we view the history of consciousness, from the most simple life forms to human beings and beyond, from a material point of view, we see increasingly complex manifestations of consciousness emerging from simpler forms. If limit ourselves to the material perspective, we are of course faced with the question of how it is that something as subtle and sophisticated as consciousness can have arisen from simple life forms–what Swamiji refers to as “protoplasm”–and even before that, from molecules and atoms. At least at our current stage of scientific knowledge, the answer we have is the rather unsatisfactory statement that this evolution has been the result of a series of fortuitous accidents. This is, perhaps, simply a way of saying that we do not know the answer to this question, or at least that no better answer has emerged that the scientific community has found persuasive. According to Vedanta, though, one can also view the process of evolution from the perspective of consciousness itself, taking consciousness, rather than the material world, as our starting point. From this perspective, what we have just been calling an evolutionary process is actually an <em>involutionary</em>process, in which consciousness descends, as it were, into the realm of matter, emerging first in simple forms, and then gradually manifesting its fuller potential in increasingly complex and subtle forms, culminating in the fully realized being, or liberated soul: the jivanmukta.</p><p>According to Sri Aurobindo, the ideal of the avatar, or divine descent, ultimately points to the descent or involvement of consciousness itself into the material world, where it manifests, from a material point of view, as the evolution of consciousness, starting with simple forms and moving to more complex ones. We begin then, with the Matsya avatar, for life on earth as we know it did emerge first in the oceans, with some fish gradually moving to land, first taking on an amphibious existence, and finally becoming the land dwelling creatures that we know today. Next comes the Tortoise avatar, and sure enough, the first animals to live fully on dry land were those that we now know as reptiles. Next comes the Boar avatar, Varāha, reflecting the fact that mammals have come after reptiles. Then, there is the Narasimha, the Man-Lion, for human beings have evolved from other animal forms, and the Man-Lion represents an intermediate stage between what we might see as an animal existence and a properly human existence.</p><p>The Vāmana, or Dwarf avatar, is sometimes compared to a child, due to his appearance. He would thus represent humanity in its infancy, with human consciousness just starting to appear in the world. Then, we have Paraśurāma, who is fully human, but who represents an earlier phase of civilization. This avatar is known for his great violence, slaying the entire warrior community when it has become corrupt. He thus represents an earlier, more violent phase of human evolution.</p><p>With Rām, we have humanity at its finest, living by the precepts of dharma and, while still engaged in violence, for the purpose of saving the world from the evil Rāvan, strongly tempering that violence with a deep sense of honor and fair play. Rām is the first avatar from this list who is aware of his divinity, though he only learns that he is a divine descent at the end of his story. For most of the <em>Rāmāyaṇa</em>, he is unaware of this fact. He could be said to represent the dawning of spiritual consciousness.</p><p>In the original list of ten avatars, Bālarāma, the brother of Lord Krishna, is next. Bālarāma would perhaps not represent an additional stage of evolution, but it is significant that Bālarāma and Lord Krishna both lived at the same time. This tells us that avatars do not necessarily need to appear in succession. Divinity can manifest itself in many places at the same time; for God is not limited to the laws of time, space, and causation as we experience them.</p><p>In the revised list, which Sri Aurobindo uses, Lord Krishna is next. Krishna is, unlike all of the previous avatars, fully aware of his divinity right from his infancy. He is therefore known as a <em>pūrṇāvatar</em>: that is, a ‘full,’ or absolute, avatar. Some of his most ardent devotees, in fact, say it is not proper to think of him as an avatar at all, but as the Supreme Being himself; for Krishna does not speak of himself as an incarnation or manifestation, but as the supreme reality, or supreme personality of Godhead. This seeming difference, though, can be resolved if we bear in mind that Krishna is a <em>full</em>avatar. The presence of the infinite is <em>fully</em>manifest in him. So to speak as though, in his case, the divine reality and its manifestation are two different things, is to quibble over minor details. True, Krishna had a body, which was born at a particular point in time, had human parents, and died when struck in the foot by a hunter’s arrow. But the spiritual essence of Krishna was the Paramātman itself, with no differentiation from the supreme being who maintains and upholds the cosmos. As Sri Ramakrishna has said, “Seeing an Incarnation of God is the same as seeing God Himself. God is born on earth as man in every age.” (<em>Gospel</em>, 186)</p><p>One might ask, “What is there beyond such an absolute manifestation of divinity? Why is any other avatar needed?” Next in the list, though, comes the Buddha, who, Sri Aurobindo tells us, deliberately forgets his divinity so that he can rediscover it, showing humanity the path to God-realization in the process. As a full avatar, Lord Krishna did not need to practice sādhana, as he was already the supreme being. His purpose on earth was different from that of the Buddha, and of the other avatars. The Buddha’s purpose, though, was to show human beings the way to freedom from suffering. In order to do this, he had to suffer himself, and then seek and find the solution to suffering. This required him to set aside his divine nature so it could manifest in his life and works.</p><p>This brings to mind several things. In 2012, I was privileged to hear a wonderful lecture by Swami Bhajanananda in which he described the non-dual realization, the realization of one’s own divinity, as the peak of spiritual experience. He went on, though, to say that if one has reached the peak, one has only reached the halfway point of one’s journey. If we climb to the top of the mountain, we are not finished with our task. We still need to climb back down the mountain and return home. This image reminded me of a Buddhist story, represented in the Zen tradition with ten pictures in which a man is searching for his ox. The ox represents enlightenment: the highest realization. Each of the ten pictures represents a phase in the search for enlightenment. The actual experience of enlightenment, though, is only the eighth of the ten phases. The journey is not over until the seeker returns to his village, riding on his ox, with open hands, ready to serve humanity. Returning to Swami Bhajanananda’s image, we need to come down from the mountain peak, the realization of our divinity, and share this realization with the rest of the world. The transition from the Krishna avatar to the Buddha avatar represents the move from the highest realization to the stage of sharing that realization with all beings; for, according to both Vedanta and Buddhism, we are all one, and our own realization is not complete if it is not shared with others, contributing to the realization of all. This is why, according to Mahayana Buddhism, some beings–those who are known as Bodhisattvas–do not leave the cycle of rebirth immediately upon attaining realization, but choose to stay and help other beings attain realization as well. And it is also why, according to the Vedanta tradition, the divine reality descends into the world again and again. Even liberated beings like Adi Shankaracharya chose to remain embodied and share their knowledge with others even after attaining realization, and the Buddha similarly remained embodied, sharing his dharma, his truth, with others for another forty-five years, long after attaining realization under the Bodhi tree at Bodh Gaya.</p><p>Finally, the Kālkī avatar, the avatar who is yet to come, can be seen to represent the fact that the process of divine involution is never complete, so long as we are in the realm of time and space and causation. Until we become liberated and there is, for us, no longer any realm of time, space, or causation, there will always be another avatar yet to come in the future.</p><p>Setting aside, for a moment, the evolutionary and involutionary aspect of the ten avatars, what else can we say about these beings, based on the information we have received about them in Hindu sacred writings?</p><p>If we look, again, to what Lord Krishna tells us in the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>, the supreme being manifests in the world whenever dharma declines and needs to be restored: whenever the moral order begins to collapse and chaos arises. Each of the ten avatars plays some role in restoring the good when it is threatened by evil. Most typically, this evil is represented by demonic beings: that is, beings who embody demonic qualities, such as arrogance, egotism, and a boundless desire for wealth, power, and sensory pleasure–qualities described in the sixteenth chapter of the <em>Gītā</em>.</p><p>The Matsya, or Fish avatar saves humanity from a natural disaster, in the form of a great flood. In an interesting contrast with the biblical flood, the flood from which the Fish avatar saves humanity is not sent as a punishment for sin. It’s just a great flood: a natural disaster. The divine role in the story is not to punish humanity, but to save humanity. One could argue, perhaps, that it must have been the karma of the people who perished in the flood that brought this disaster upon them. But we are also told, in the Vedanta tradition, that we must be careful about passing a moral judgment on others, based on their apparent bad karma. Sometimes, in fact, we suffer not so much because we have done something wrong, but in order to become stronger, and to gain in spiritual insight. As Swami Vivekananda says, “In studying the great characters the world has produced, I dare say, in the vast majority of cases, it would be found that it was misery that taught more than happiness, it was poverty that taught more than wealth, it was blows that brought out the inner fire more than praise.” (<em>Complete Works</em>1.27)</p><p>The Kurma, or Tortoise avatar allows himself to become the pivot that the devas and the āsuras use to churn the elixir of life, the <em>amṛta</em>, from the cosmic ocean. Here, too, we see an avatar manifesting for the purpose of bringing life into the world, of rescuing living beings from death.</p><p>The remaining avatars, though, engage directly in combat with demonic forces: either with demonic beings or with human beings who have given themselves over to demonic forces. In the case of the Boar avatar, Varāha, the demonic forces are represented by Hiranyaksha, who torments the earth itself. One can see an ecological message in this story as well, with the Mother Nature herself–the earth goddess, Bhūdevī–being in need of rescue from the forces of unbridled greed, in the form of Hiranyaksha’s desire to dominate her. The Narasimha, or Man-Lion, similarly fights with and destroys Hiranyakashipu, and Vāmana, the Dwarf, stands upon and crushes the demonic Mahābāli–whose name means “one with great power.” The power of delusion, of ego, is indeed great, and needs to be stamped down by the wisdom of the higher Self. We also see this theme in the iconography of Lord Shiva as Nataraj, Lord of the Cosmic Dance, who also stands on the ego and tramples it down, and in the stories of the Goddesses Durga and Kali, as they, too, conquer the demonic forces. Rām, too, the seventh avatar, destroys the demonic Rāvan, bringing an end to his reign.</p><p>Paraśurāma fights with and destroys human beings who have become consumed by lower forces: the corrupt warrior class. And finally, Lord Krishna defeats first his wicked uncle, Kāṃsa, and then the Kauravas, who have also become demonic through their greed and their dishonorable behavior.</p><p>The Buddha, we could say, while not a literal demon-slayer, teaches his followers the way to overcome the inner enemies of greed, hatred, and delusion–<em>raga-dvesha-moha</em>. These, as Lord Krishna tells Arjuna in the <em>Gītā</em>, are our true enemies, even more so than the mortal beings whom we encounter who are overcome by evil tendencies–tendencies to which we ourselves are subject.</p><p>I wish to turn now from a discussion of the Daśāvatāra, to a discussion of three avatars in particular, each of whom belongs to our era of recorded history, and each of whom stands at the origin point of a great spiritual tradition.</p><p>I will begin with the Buddha, whom I have already mentioned; for he is also one of the ten avatars listed in Hindu sacred texts. I have long seen the inclusion of the Buddha as an avatar, as I believe many of us have, as an example of the Vedantic teaching of the harmony of religions. It has certainly become this, as it has long been a mainstream view of many Hindus that the Buddha was a great spiritual teacher, and one certainly worthy of the honor of being proclaimed an avatar.</p><p>Interestingly, though, one of the earliest accounts of the Buddha avatar is part of an anti-Buddhist polemic. It is said that Lord Vishnu descended to the earth as the Buddha to deceive the demonic persons of his time into not performing Vedic rituals. Many Hindu stories refer to demons performing Vedic rituals, or performing tapasya, or asceticism, and thereby achieving great power. Rāvan, for example, received his immunity from attacks by all creatures except human beings due to an ascetic vow to Lord Shiva that he undertook and completed successfully. The Buddha avatar, it is said, deceives his demonic followers into not performing Vedic ritual, thereby making them vulnerable to destruction.</p><p>What should we make of this negative interpretation of Buddhism? As Sri Ramakrishna has said, “The scriptures contain a mixture of sand and sugar.” One finds, in many scriptures of the world’s great spiritual traditions, profound insight as well as evidence of jealousy and rivalry among sects. We always need to be wary of that within the scriptures which tends toward, in the words of Swami Vivekananda, “Sectarianism, bigotry, and its horrible descendant, fanaticism.” (<em>Complete Works</em>1.4) One always needs to be attentive to the complete context in which certain statements are found. Thus if one is attentive to the textual traditions of Hinduism as a whole, one finds far more positive statements about Buddha than negative ones. In Jayadeva’s<em>Gītagovinda</em>, for example, it is said that the Buddha avatar only taught his followers to avoid those Vedic rituals which caused harm to living beings: the animal sacrifices that have been enjoined in certain rituals in certain regions and during certain periods of history. Indeed, Swami Vivekananda taught that there was nothing in the Buddha’s doctrine contrary to the higher teachings of Vedanta, as found in the Upanishads, even as he rejected some aspects of the more ritualistic practice of the Vedas. According to Swami Vivekananda, “Buddha brought the Vedanta to light, gave it to the people, and saved India.” (<em>Complete Works</em>2.139)</p><p>To be sure, Buddhism itself, at least in all of its forms, does not teach that the Buddha was an avatar. He is seen, rather, as an extraordinary human being who achieved the highest possible state of spiritual awakening. In what is widely believed to be the oldest of the Buddhist traditions, the Theravada tradition predominant in countries like Sri Lanka, Myanmar, and Thailand, this is the case. The Buddha would thus be not an avatar, but the equivalent of a jivanmukta: one who has attained awakening and liberation. Indeed, this tradition does not speculate about the existence of a divine, supreme being, who might descend from time to time into the material world.</p><p>The Mahayana Buddhist tradition, though, comes very close to the teaching of Vedanta in regard to the nature of the Buddhas. Buddha Nature–the capacity for awakening–is present in all of us, according to this tradition. This is close to the potential divinity of all beings which Vedanta teaches. A Buddha is a being in whom this capacity has manifested fully. In fact, there are even Mahayana texts which speak of the infinite Buddha Nature taking on the form of a living being in order to teach and show other beings the path to awakening, and which also state that Śākyamuni, or Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha of history, was one such manifestation.</p><p>As Vedantins, we must show respect for the beliefs of others, and not insist to them that the sacred figure whom they revere as their teacher and guide is something other than what they take him to be. We can see, though, from our Vedantic point of view, the idea of the Buddha avatar as capturing an important truth: that divinity is capable of veiling itself and the fulness of its capacities in order to take on a mortal form, and through this form, in every other way exactly like our own, to show us, through a lived example, the path to God-realization.</p><p>As Christmas draws ever nearer, our sisters and brothers in the Christian tradition prepare to celebrate the manifestation in time, space, and history of a being whom they proclaim as divine, and who can also be seen, from a Vedantic perspective, as an avatar, or divine descent, who came with a mission, like that of the Buddha, of showing living beings the path to spiritual freedom.</p><p>Growing up, as I did, in the Christian tradition, I was taught from a very early age to regard Jesus Christ as divine. In the Roman Catholic tradition, in particular, in which I was raised, it is taught that Jesus is the second person of the Holy Trinity: God the Son. The Christian doctrine of the trinity is, in fact, akin, in many respects, to Hindu concepts of divinity. In both traditions, it can be said that divinity is both one and many: one supreme godhead with many forms or aspects. In the Hindu tradition, this of course takes the form of the Trimurti: God as simultaneously creator, or Brahma, preserver, or Vishnu, and the one who destroys the old in order to make way for the new, or Shiva, as well as the corresponding Shaktis, or Goddesses, who accompany each of these–Saraswati, or divine wisdom, Lakshmi, or divine mercy, and She who is variously known as Uma, Devi, Parvati, Durga, Kali, or, most fundamentally, Shakti, or divine power. Among these, it is Vishnu who manifests in the realm of time, space, and causation in the form of his many avatars, in order to do his work of preserving the cosmic order, or dharma, by bringing an end to the forces of chaos, or adharma. In the Christian tradition, one supreme godhead takes the form of the Father, or creator, the Son, through whom the world is made and by whom it is brought back into harmony with the Father, and the Holy Spirit, which is the divine presence in the world and in each one of us. To draw an absolute correlation between the persons of the Christian trinity and the deities of Hinduism is difficult, though some similarities can be seen. The Son of God, like Lord Vishnu, is the one who manifests into the world to reestablish the good and bring about an end to the demonic forces of chaos which always seek to undermine the cosmic order.</p><p>One important difference, perhaps <em>the</em>difference, between the Christian and Hindu visions of divine manifestation is that, at least for mainstream Christianity, Jesus Christ is the one and the only such manifestation: “the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6), faith in whom is a necessity for the attainment of salvation. This is in sharp contrast with the teaching of the <em>Gītā</em>, where Krishna proclaims that, “Whenever dharma, the moral order of the universe, declines, and adharma, or chaos, arises, then do I manifest myself.” That is, Krishna does not appear only once in the cosmos, but whenever his divine presence is needed. So there can be many divine manifestations, even while there is only one supreme divinity. Even if one sees Lord Krishna as a pūrṇāvatar, and so virtually identical with the godhead itself, this does not mean that other manifestations are to be rejected, or that those who place their faith in these manifestations are lost or misguided. Lord Krishna also tells us that, “In whatever way living beings approach me, thus do I receive them. All paths lead to me.” (<em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>4:11)</p><p>As I was growing up in the Christian tradition, its teaching of the necessity of faith in Jesus Christ alone disturbed me deeply. The heart of Jesus’ teaching, I felt, and was also told repeatedly, was that, “God is love, and whoever abides in love abides in God, and God in him.” (1 John 4:16) Many Christians, however, deduce from the teaching that faith in Jesus is necessary for salvation that all those who are not Christian are damned for eternity: that, after this life, they will suffer in eternal torment. Given that most people, quite naturally, adhere to the religious tradition in which they grew up, and that most people throughout history have not been Christian, with many never even hearing of Christianity, this would mean that most people are going to hell. And given that God is held to be the all-knowing creator of all beings, this also means that God created billions of people knowing that they would spend infinite time in eternal torment. Such a God, it seemed to me, was not only not loving, but was psychopathically cruel. If it is indeed necessary for God to appear to us in human form in order to reunite us with him, in order to close the gap between us and the divinity underlying all things, it seemed to me that God would appear many times, to many different people and in many different cultures and regions of the world, so that all beings would have the opportunity to learn the truth and reach salvation. And because I have always been a fan of science fiction, with a love for astronomy and physics, it seemed to me that, given the vastness of this universe, plus the extremely high likelihood that intelligent life forms are on many different worlds, God would also manifest on those worlds, in forms that those people could recognize and through whom they could reach God as well. Indeed, I thought, why should there not be divine manifestations for all species? In the words of Swamiji, “Suppose a cow were philosophical and had religion, it would have a cow universe and a cow solution to the problem, and it would not be possible that it should be our God. Suppose cats became philosophers, they would see a cat uni-verse and a cat solution to the problem, and a cat ruling it.” (<em>Complete Works</em>2.156) How, then, ought the Christian claim that Jesus is “the way, the truth, and the life” be understood?</p><p>We could again recall Sri Ramakrishna’s teaching that, “The scriptures contain a mixture of sand and sugar.” We would then conclude, perhaps, that the teaching that Jesus is the one divine manifestation is a pernicious dogma, inserted into the scripture at a time when the early Christians were contending with other traditions and competing for members. Indeed, this is precisely the view of some Christian scholars. I once had the good fortune to meet the New Testament scholar, Elaine Pagels, whose work I had read in college. It is her view that the more authentic teachings of Jesus are found in a work called the <em>Gospel of Thomas</em>, that is not a part of the New Testament canon, and that the <em>Gospel of John</em>, in which the verse about Jesus being “the way, the truth, and the life” appears, was written later, and as a reaction against the more universalist teaching of the earlier <em>Thomas</em>.</p><p>This is certainly a tempting view and a tempting interpretation to take, and I am not entirely averse to it. I am also, however, conscious of how central the teaching of the necessity of faith in Jesus alone is for many Christians. As mentioned earlier in connection with the Buddha avatar, as Vedantins, we must show respect for the beliefs of others, and not insist to them that the sacred figure whom they revere as their teacher and guide is something other than what they take him to be. At the same time, though, as Vedantins, and as rational, compassionate people, we must avoid the conclusion that the cosmos is ruled by a sadistic tyrant who creates living beings by the billions only to condemn them to eternal suffering.</p><p>I would suggest that another route is possible, which is drawn from the teaching of the next avatar we will consider: Sri Ramakrishna.</p><p>Looking ahead to the teaching of Sri Ramakrishna, when he was lying on his deathbed, he proclaimed his identity as an avatar to Swami Vivekananda–who was then still known by his birth name, Narendranath Datta, or Naren. His precise words, as translated by Swami Nikhilananda, were: “He who was Rama and Krishna is now in this body, Ramakrishna.”</p><p>According to Hindu tradition, while avatars are many in number, the divinity manifesting in these many forms is one and the same. Again, Lord Krishna says, “Whenever dharma declines and adharma arises, then do <em>I</em>manifest myself.” The <em>I</em>is singular, even if all the avatars collectively make up a multitude. And again, “In whatever way living beings approach me, thus do <em>I</em>receive them.” Krishna is here speaking as a pūrṇāvatar, and so as the godhead itself. In the same vein, he tells Arjuna, at the end of the <em>Gītā</em>, “Abandon all dharmas and take refuge in me alone; I shall free you from all evils.” (<em>Bhagavad Gītā </em>18:66) When he says, “take refuge in me alone,” this is not to be taken to mean that only he, in that particular form–as the son of Devakī and Vasudeva, a form which would perish due to a hunter’s misguided arrow–is the sole divine reality to whom we must go for refuge. He is speaking, rather, as the supreme being, who is fully manifested in and as that form–and in many other forms as well.</p><p>I would suggest that this is how we should interpret the words of Jesus, as recounted in the <em>Gospel of John</em>, as well: that the <em>I</em>who says, “I am the way, the truth, and the life, no one comes to the Father but through me,” is the same <em>I </em>who says, “In whatever way living beings approach me, thus do I receive them. All paths lead to me.” Jesus, like Krishna, is speaking as the supreme Self, the Paramātman, which is manifesting in and as Jesus, but which is not simply identical with any particular form. The singular being who manifests as many avatars is the way, the truth, and the life, without whom we cannot reach our potential divinity: the heavenly Father within. I think this is the only way we can reconcile this teaching, so central to Christianity, with a Vedantic view. We must otherwise reject it as sand, mixed in with the sugar of the authentic words of Jesus.</p><p>Finally, we come to Thakur: Sri Ramakrishna Paramahansa, the avatar of our contemporary age. The particular mission of this avatar, I believe, has been to show the harmony of religions by demonstrating, through his multi-religious sādhanas, the effectiveness of many paths in reaching God-realization.</p><p>A turning point in the life of Ramakrishna occurred when one of his gurus and mentors on his spiritual journey, a woman known as the Bhairavi Brahmani, came to believe that her disciple was an avatar. Hindu texts describe the attributes of an avatar, thus making it possible to determine if a particular individual might be one. Ramakrishna was filled at an early age with a longing to see God: to perceive God directly. This longing intensified after he became a priest at the temple of Kali at Dakshineshwar. After days of intense prayer and deep emotional turmoil, Ramakrishna experienced the Mother Goddess as a living reality, manifesting as “a limitless, infinite, effulgent Ocean of Consciousness.”[1] In the months that followed, he conceived a desire to experience the divinity in as many forms as possible, taking up the disciplines of various Vaishnava, Shaiva, and Shakta traditions of Hindu spiritual practice. It was in the course of these <em>sādhanas</em>, or spiritual disciplines, that the Bhairavi Brahmani became his guide:</p><p>Day after day she watched his ecstasy during the kirtan [singing of sacred hymns] and meditation, his samādhi [a profound state of meditative absorption which he was capable of entering spontaneously], his mad yearning; and she recognized in him a power to transmit spirituality to others. She came to the conclusion that such things were not possible for an ordinary devotee, not even for a highly developed soul. Only an incarnation of God was capable of such spiritual manifestations. She proclaimed openly that Sri Ramakrishna, like Sri Chaitanya [a great saint of Bengal also proclaimed to be an avatar] was an Incarnation of God.[2]</p><p>The Bhairavi Brahmani’s faith that Ramakrishna was an incarnation is widely held in our tradition. But our tradition has no dogma or creed to which we are all required to give our assent. Individuals in Vedanta are free to express skepticism about this, or any, teaching. One such skeptic was Swami Vivekananda. Though he would come to believe very deeply in his teacher’s divinity, he never insisted that adherents of Vedanta accept this idea, and discouraged others from insisting “too much” on it. (<em>Complete Works</em>5.81)</p><p>The idea with which the idea of the avatar rests in tension is the idea that all beings are divine. The ultimate aim of Vedanta is the realization of the divine potential in every being. One could suggest that an avatar is simply a person who has fully realized and manifested this divine potential. We will all someday be avatars, from this point of view.</p><p>There is a distinction, though, in Hindu traditions between one who <em>ascends</em>to the level of enlightenment and becomes God-realized–literally <em>jīvanmukta</em>, or liberated in this lifetime–and a <em>descent</em>, or <em>avatāra</em>, of the supreme being. Indeed, Sri Ramakrishna himself corrected the young Naren’s thinking in this regard, while on his deathbed. Narendranath, too, was thinking an avatar must be, essentially, a liberated soul: a jivanmukta, like the Buddha, or Adi Shankara. According to the <em>Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna</em>, as Ramakrishna’s body was wracked with cancer, “After one or two days Narendra said to himself, ‘Only if in the midst of this racking physical pain he declares his Godhead, then only shall I accept him as an Incarnation of God.’ It was a passing thought, but the Master smiled. Gathering his strength, he distinctly said, “He who was Rama and Krishna is now, in this body, Ramakrishna–but not in your Vedantic sense.’ Narendra was stricken with shame.”</p><p>There is, indeed, a sense in which we are all avatars. As Sri Aurobindo has shown, divine consciousness has ‘descended’–the literal meaning of <em>avatar</em>being ‘descent’–into this world of matter in the form of all our individual centers of awareness. It has become, to use Swamiji’s and Aurobindo’s term, ‘involved’ in the realm of time, space, and causation.</p><p>Our aim, in turn, is to ascend, to evolve, to the highest limit of our potential: to God-realization. The idea of the avatar, however, reassures us that we are not alone in this process. Just as we strive upward, to ascend to our highest ideal, the highest divinity also descends to meet us, with an outstretched hand to lift us from the ocean of rebirth–the torment of delusion and suffering–and raise us to the level of divinity that is our birthright. In the words of St. Athanasius, from the Christian tradition, “the Son of God became man so that we might become God”–so that we might manifest that divinity which resides in a potential state within each and every one of us.</p><p>[1]Swami Nikhilananda, <em>The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna</em>(New York: Ramakrishna Vivekananda Center, 1942), 14.</p><p>[2]Ibid, 19.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=94e69773a17" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections on a Culture of Peace]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/reflections-on-a-culture-of-peace-fe9df273a61a?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fe9df273a61a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yoga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jainism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2019 00:48:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-20T00:52:17.288Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ib7iqhFQPFwPoH_OLWtUQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The Role of Yogic Values in Promoting a Culture of Peace and Nonviolence (Presented at the United Nations, August 2nd, 2019)</strong></p><p>Good afternoon, and Namaste! It is truly an honor and a privilege to be invited to speak at the United Nations on the occasion of the twentieth anniversary of the <em>Declaration</em>and <em>Programme of Action on a Culture of Peace</em>. It is a particular honor to speak about the role of Yogic values in promoting a culture of peace and nonviolence. This is a topic to which I have dedicated much of my scholarship over the course of my career: a career which happens to coincide with the twenty-year period we are celebrating today.</p><p>Specifically, my work has focused on the role that the philosophies of India–philosophies such as Vedanta and Jainism–can play in rethinking how we human beings approach religious and cultural differences. All too often, such differences are used to justify the violence and dehumanization of the Other that continues to plague human life across the globe. If we can begin, as a species, to conceptualize religious, cultural, and philosophical difference, not as a threat to our own way of thinking and living, but as a source of wisdom that can supplement and deepen our own approach to truth, whatever it may be, then perhaps we can begin to view our neighbors not as rivals, or as people whose beliefs are false or dangerous, but as potential teachers who can share with us some part of the universal wisdom with which we are as yet unfamiliar, and with whom we can also share our own understanding of truth, not in an effort to proselytize or to convert, but to advance knowledge for the benefit of all. This is the vision found in the teaching of Sri Ramakrishna, when he says, <em>yato mat, tato path</em>–Each religion is a path to the Infinite–and in the famous teaching of the <em>Ṛg Veda</em>, <em>ekaṃ sat viprā bahuḍhā vadanti</em>: Truth is one; the wise speak of it in various ways. It is enshrined in the Jain doctrines of <em>anekānt</em>and <em>syādvāda</em>, and in the teaching of the Buddha’s skillful means, in which the way to enlightenment is presented in many ways, according to the needs of each spiritual seeker.</p><p>When we speak of Yogic values that might promote a culture of nonviolence and world peace, to what are we referring? One way to answer this question is to turn to the <em>Yoga Sūtras</em>of Patañjali. The values expressed in this text are clearly enumerated in the <em>yamas</em>and <em>niyamas</em>, or injunctions for Yogic living, which make up the first two of the eight limbs of the Yoga that Patañjali taught. These begin, not accidentally, with <em>ahiṃsā</em>, which is not simply nonviolence, but the absence of even the desire to let any living being come to harm. It is, in other words, nonviolence in thought, word, and deed. And it does not simply refer to avoiding active harm against living beings, while otherwise remaining indifferent to them. Ahiṃsā is the desire to ensure that all living beings live happily and free from fear of injury. Next comes <em>satya</em>, or truth. After the well-being of all, one who is committed to the Yogic path values truth above everything else. This value commits one to a spirit of open inquiry and to the scientific method, and to rejecting all forms of obfuscation or misdirection. After truth comes non-stealing. This value, like nonviolence and truth, commits one not only to avoiding thievery in the obvious sense, but also to taking only as much from the earth as it can sustain. Unbridled greed robs future generations of the resources they will need to survive, and is thus, itself, a form of violence. After non-stealing comes <em>brahmacharya</em>, or self-restraint, particularly in the realm of sexuality, which is followed by<em>aparigraha</em>, or non-possessiveness. Overall, the values one finds expressed in the <em>yamas</em>of Patañjali amount to a commitment to truth, and to not allowing one’s own selfish desires to impinge upon the well-being of others.</p><p>Similarly, in the <em>niyamas</em>, we find virtues expressed and practices cultivated that, if they were to be promoted globally, would certainly diminish our human tendency to impose our will on others and to do harm both to one another and to our physical environment. First, there is <em>śauca</em>, or self-purification. This refers to maintaining a clean environment, both inwardly and outwardly. Then there is <em>santośa</em>, or contentment. Contentment is followed by <em>tapas</em>, or self-discipline, which is in turn followed by <em>svadhyāya</em>, or self-study. Finally, there is <em>Īśvara praṇidhāna</em>, or ‘contemplation of the Lord.’ In our diverse world, of many religious belief systems, and of many philosophies which are non-religious in nature, ‘the Lord’ need not be taken to refer to any particular vision or concept of the Supreme Being. It can refer, rather, to whatever is of greatest value to us: the ideal which motivates us most deeply. This is the idea, also found in Patañjali’s text, of the <em>iṣṭa devata</em>, or ‘chosen deity.’The practice of <em>Īśvara praṇidhāna</em>invites us to ask ourselves, “Who or what is the lord of my life? What matters to me more than anything else?” Patañjali composed his <em>Yoga Sūtra</em>in the religiously pluralistic environment of ancient India, and his system of Yoga lends itself to being practiced by persons with a wide array of religious beliefs and commitments. For some, Īśvara might mean Lord Śiva. For others, it might mean Lord Viṣṇu. For others still, it could mean one of the many Buddhas or Jinas of the Buddhist or Jain traditions. For some today, it might mean any of these things, or it might refer to other concepts of divinity from other traditions, other ideas of God, or to an abstract ideal of truth. For some, it may refer to humanity itself.</p><p>The Yogic values enumerated by Patañjali are not simply ends in themselves. They are cultivated with the ultimate aim of achieving <em>samādhi</em>, or complete transcendence: a state of total absorption in the object of one’s contemplation. Some might well question the value of a practice aimed at transcendence for the improvement of life here and now, in the material world, where humanity struggles, and where the United Nations seeks to do its work of nurturing a culture of world peace. In response, I would cite Swami Vivekananda, one of the first historical figures to promote Yogic values on a global scale. In his lectures on Karma Yoga, the Yoga of Action, Vivekananda says that there is really nothing we can do to help the world. The world, he says, is like a dog’s curly tail. We can try to straighten it out all we like, but it will still return to its previous shape, despite all our efforts, the moment we let it go. This may not seem like an encouraging message for those of us who are committed to making the world a better place. But that is not all Vivekananda has to say on this subject. He goes on to say that the <em>effort </em>to make the world better, if pursued with an attitude not of arrogance, but of selfless service, is an ideal way to transform ourselves. He then says, “The world is a grand moral gymnasium, wherein we have all to take exercise so as to become stronger and stronger spiritually.” (CW 1:80) The problems of the world are exercise equipment. Through our attempts to solve them, we transform and improve ourselves. And indeed, it is not that there is any single problem in the world that is irresolvable. But with each problem we solve come new ones. This is the meaning of the image of the curly tail of the dog. Life itself, to quote Swami Atmarupananda, is problem-solving. Transcendence is to be found not in abandoning the world, but in facing its problems honestly, in a spirit of what we could paradoxically call passionate detachment: passionate in being fully engaged with addressing the problems at hand, but detached inasmuch as we rest assured in the confidence that no problem, however formidable, can destroy the spiritual essence of our being, which, the sages tell us, is infinite.</p><p>In what other ways can Yogic values inform our promotion of a culture of peace and nonviolence? If we can continue expanding our exploration of these values beyond the <em>Yoga Sūtras</em>, Yogic values are the values of the Hindu, Jain, and Buddhist traditions, as well as other traditions which have informed and been informed by the Yogic quest. Again, in the philosophies of all of these varied traditions can be found wisdom with the power to transform how we see one another. The Jain teaching of <em>anekānt</em>, or the complexity of truth, affirms that reality has many facets, and that many, seemingly contradictory visions of truth can be reconciled in a larger vision of reality, in which they are seen not as contradictory, but as complementary. This is the gist of the ancient Indian parable of the Blind Men and the Elephant. In the Vedāntic teaching of the <em>Upaniṣads</em>and the <em>Bhagavad Gītā</em>, we are taught that divinity is in all beings. We should treat others as we ourselves wish to be treated because, at the highest level, they <em>are</em>ourselves. This is the meaning of the traditional Indian greeting, <em>Namaste</em>: that I honor the divinity that resides within you. The <em>Gītā</em>also teaches that many paths can lead to realization of our divine nature. As Lord Krishna says, in words cited by Swami Vivekananda in his famous welcome speech at the 1893 Parliament of Religions, “In whatever ways living beings approach me, thus do I receive them. All paths lead to me.” (BG 4:11)</p><p>May the Yogic values of pluralism, of loving detachment, and of seeing the divinity in all continue to inform our efforts to cultivate a culture of peace and nonviolence everywhere in this world!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fe9df273a61a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No, Not All Hindus Are Indian]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/no-not-all-hindus-are-indian-718d2072e65d?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/718d2072e65d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tulsi-gabbard]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-presidential-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Feb 2019 15:16:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-09T20:44:51.778Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Calling Tulsi Gabbard a ‘Fake Hindu’ is Offensive and Misinformed</strong></p><p><strong>Jeffery D. Long</strong></p><p><strong>Professor of Religion and Asian Studies, Elizabethtown College</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*ADjnPzwhE5gnP0d1vE-WMg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sadly, but unsurprisingly, the candidacy of Tulsi Gabbard, the first Hindu American to run for President, has evoked a strong and rapid backlash of media attacks.<a href="/service/applewebdata://E3F9F77E-3F73-4F6C-BB09-173A2D7EB721#_ftn1">[1]</a> Of course, any person who runs for public office should, quite rightly, expect to be on the receiving end of extensive scrutiny. This is how we select our leaders in a democracy, at least ideally. It involves an extensive critical examination of the views and character of each candidate. In the end, hopefully, the public will become educated about the stances and qualities of the candidates and make an informed choice.</p><p>Recent attacks on Tulsi Gabbard, however, have strayed into the territory of interrogating her religious beliefs in ways that are both offensive and misinformed. The US Constitution clearly states that “no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States.” The religious views of a candidate for public office can certainly affect that candidate’s views on a variety of issues. But it is the views of the candidate on those issues, not the religious affiliation on which those views may or may not be based, that is relevant to the candidate’s suitability for office.</p><p>We, as Americans, have been through this before: when Alfred Smith, a Roman Catholic, ran for President in 1928, when John F. Kennedy, also a Roman Catholic, ran for President in 1960, and when Mitt Romney, a Mormon, ran for President in 2012. We have also been treated to the spectacle of a gossip campaign claiming that Barack Obama, a Protestant, was a Muslim, as though being Muslim could disqualify one for political office in America. Each time a candidate with a religious affiliation perceived to fall outside the American mainstream runs for office (or, in the case of Obama, who is even alleged to hold such an affiliation), questions about the effect of that affiliation on the candidate’s fitness for office are raised. Such questions are wholly inappropriate and are based on ignorance of constitutional principles.</p><p>One recent allegation, more often raised as an insinuation, against Tulsi Gabbard is that her self-identification as Hindu is somehow false or inauthentic: that she is a ‘fake Hindu’ because she is not of Indian descent. The assumption is that all Hindus are Indian: that one must be Indian, or of Indian descent, in order to be Hindu.</p><p>This is not, however, the case. Factually speaking, there are many self-identified Hindus from around the world who are not Indian or of Indian descent. And this is not merely a matter of self-identification. There are non-Indian Hindus who are accepted warmly, not only as Hindus, but as leaders and authoritative teachers of Hinduism, by the Hindu community at large. Many of the monks who publish the quarterly <em>Hinduism Today</em>, a journal widely read by Hindus globally and seen as a reliable and solid source of information about the tradition, are not of Indian descent. This includes the founder of the journal, the late Satguru Sivaya Subramuniyaswami, who was born Robert Hansen. Interestingly, these monks are based on the island of Kauai, in Hawaii, Tulsi Gabbard’s home state, though they represent a Hindu tradition distinct from the one to which Tulsi Gabbard is affiliated. (Hindu denominations are known as <em>sampradayas</em>.)</p><p>The Hindu denomination to which Tulsi Gabbard is affiliated is a branch of the ancient Gaudiya Vaishnava tradition of Hinduism, known in the western world as the Hare Krishna movement. To convince readers that Tulsi Gabbard is not a real Hindu, some have suggested that Hare Krishnas are not accepted by Hindus of Indian descent. This could not be further from the truth. A visit to any one of the dozens of Hare Krishna temples across the US where the teachings and tradition of Gaudiya Vaishnava Hinduism are practiced, provides an opportunity to see Hindus of all shades–Hindus of both Indian and non-Indian descent–worshiping and celebrating together as a single united community of devotees. Hare Krishna temples in India offer the same.</p><p>According to a 2015 Pew survey of ethnic diversity in American religious communities, 91 percent of Hindu Americans are of Asian descent (these being primarily South Asian, and these, in turn, being primarily Indian). Two percent are of ‘mixed’ ethnicity. This would include Tulsi Gabbard, who has an Irish American parent and a Samoan American parent. Four percent are white, two percent are African American, and one percent are Hispanic.<a href="/service/applewebdata://E3F9F77E-3F73-4F6C-BB09-173A2D7EB721#_ftn2">[2]</a> With roughly 2.23 million Hindus in the US, this means there are roughly 44,600 Hindu Americans of mixed ethnicity, 89,200 Hindu Americans who are white, 44,600 Hindu Americans who are African American, and 22,300 Hindu Americans who are Hispanic.</p><p>Calling Tulsi Gabbard a ‘fake Hindu,’ or even insinuating that her religious commitment and identity are in some way inauthentic, is therefore a slap in the face of nearly a quarter of a million Hindu Americans who are not of Indian descent. And even to think that her religious identity disqualifies her from being President of the United States is unconstitutional and un-American.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://E3F9F77E-3F73-4F6C-BB09-173A2D7EB721#_ftnref1">[1]</a>https://mauiindependent.org/the-ramped-up-smear-campaign-against-hawaiis-congresswoman-tulsi-gabbard/?fbclid=IwAR1MaUVo4svODPA1kIzHZ2NAxj5_oU6Y_qvkWmxOd7fgFX5gpJPCauPNDe8</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://E3F9F77E-3F73-4F6C-BB09-173A2D7EB721#_ftnref2">[2]</a>http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/07/27/the-most-and-least-racially-diverse-u-s-religious-groups/ft_15-07-23_religiondiversityindex-1/</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=718d2072e65d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Christianity Prepared Me for Hinduism (My Journey to Hindu Dharma, Part Two)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/how-christianity-prepared-me-for-hinduism-my-journey-to-hindu-dharma-part-two-154d8dc62c8e?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/154d8dc62c8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conversion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 May 2017 13:34:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-14T13:34:21.725Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Journey Begins: An Inquiring Childhood</strong></p><p>I was not born Hindu, unless one accepts the proposition that all of us are born within the <em>Sanatana Dharma</em>, the perennial and universal truth at the basis of all philosophies and religions, only gradually coming to identify with a particular culture and belief system as we grow up in a particular time and place.</p><p>I was born to a Christian family, of the Roman Catholic faith, and grew up in a very small town in Missouri. I had the privilege to be raised in a very loving family, free from abuse and full of encouragement for the intellectual interests that I displayed from an early age. It was not a wealthy family, but we never wanted for anything. My family was religious, but not fanatically so. What they valued most was a good moral life and hard work. As I was taught the basic worldview of Christianity, as understood by the Catholic Church, I was also deeply interested in science. My parents indulged my desire for books on outer space and dinosaurs. I was also an avid fan of science fiction, and it is probably fair to say that <em>Star Trek</em> and <em>Star Wars</em> had as much to do with developing my worldview as the teachings of Christianity.</p><p>I had an inquiring mind. My impulse was to believe that what I was taught was basically true, but also to make sense of it in terms that I found logical and compelling. I believed, for example, that God had created the universe and the life forms within it, as taught in the Bible. But I also understood the theory of evolution as explained in my books about science. I therefore concluded that God created the universe and its life forms by means of the natural processes revealed by science. Why should religion and science conflict? Could they not simply be different means of knowledge, illuminating different aspects of the problem? I did not yet know the Sanskrit philosophical term <em>pramana</em>, but this was, in its essence, what I had in mind.</p><p>We did not have a Catholic school in our town when I was growing up, so a group of nuns from near St. Louis came to us every summer for two weeks to give us instruction in the faith. At that point, I saw two very different faces of Christianity. One of the nuns was a very severe and strict lady. When she taught us in a question and answer format, it was expected that we would answer word-for-word from the text. Once, when I was called upon, rather than repeating the text word-for-word, I paraphrased it. I believed my answer was essentially correct. I was saying the same thing, just using slightly different words. She said, “That is incorrect.” Puzzled, I began to reply, “But I thought…” She cut me off before I could finish my sentence. “We are not teaching you to think!” True indeed!</p><p>Another one of the nuns, however, was extremely warm, kind, and grandmotherly. I felt comfortable asking her anything. One day, I took a question to her that had bothered me for some time. “Sister,” I asked, “Why is that when we pray to God, and talk to God, we do all of the talking? Why doesn’t God talk back to us?” I expected her to say that it was a test of our faith, or that it was a mystery and that we simply had to believe and keep on praying.</p><p>What I did not expect was the reply that she gave. After I asked her, “Why doesn’t God talk to us?” she said, “If you listen very carefully, He does!”</p><p>This answer moved me deeply, and excited my curiosity. It was a wonderful answer. It did not call for blind faith, but for experimentation. This was something that I could test. This was something I could try for myself and see if it worked! And that is what I did.</p><p>I began to develop the habit, after saying my prayers, of sitting and listening quietly. I would clear my mind of distractions and just listen. I did not know it at the time, but this was the beginning of my practice of meditation; for meditation is essentially an attentive state, not sleeping or daydreaming, and a state in which one calms one’s mind and clears it from distractions. It is, in the words of Patañjali’s <em>Yoga Sutra</em>, <em>chitta-vritti-nirodha</em>, the calming of the modifications of the mind.</p><p>The result, to paraphrase Gandhi, of this ‘experiment with truth,’ was that I began to have a strong sense of an indwelling presence, accompanying me at all times, watching over me in a kind, benevolent, and protective fashion, and observing my every thought, word, and deed with a kind of amused compassion. I was not sure if it was God or if it was what I would come to call my ‘higher self.’ Perhaps, I began to think, these were one and the same. A few years later, when I would read the <em>Upanishads</em>, I found this very insight to be confirmed.</p><p>When I would have a particular problem or question or concern that was troubling me, I would take it to God in prayer. I would phrase the prayer as a question, and then I would do my listening exercise. I never heard a booming voice from the sky, but what did begin to happen was that, sometimes immediately, sometimes later that day, and sometimes a few days later, the answer to the question would come. The mark of these answers that I have received through meditation, as opposed to answers that I come up with using my conscious mind and thought process, is that they always seem to be obvious when they arise, as if I had really already known the answer and had forgotten it. But paradoxically, they also do not have the feel of something that I could come up with on my own. They also have a particular tone that is distinctive to them: kindly but firm–a firmness rooted not in anger or a desire to have one’s authority respected, but in absolute certainty of the truth of what they state. More than firmness, this tone could perhaps be better described as supreme confidence. Finally, I will say that following the directions that have been given in these answers, whenever they have involved directions, has never led me astray and has always led to good results, and that ignoring them has been counterproductive. I generally do not ignore them!</p><p><strong>Looking Forward</strong></p><p>At the point at which the kindly nun gave me what I now regard as my first lesson in meditation, I was nine years old. I knew nothing at that point of Hindu Dharma, or even of any other religion outside of Christianity. One can see, however, that the foundation for my journey to Hindu Dharma was already being laid: a basic moral framework, belief in a higher reality that can be accessed through meditation, an intuition of the oneness of that higher reality and one’s own deepest self, and an inquiring mind, open to the spiritual realm, but not dogmatic in its approach to this realm.</p><p>People will often ask me how my family reacted to my eventual embrace of a Hindu path, and I am grateful to be able to say that, though they had their questions and doubts, my family has always been deeply supportive of my life choices.</p><p>How, then, did I actually encounter Hindu traditions? How did I first become aware of the teachings and practice of Hinduism? That will be the topic of the next installment in this series of autobiographical reflections.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=154d8dc62c8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hindu Theology Summit to Focus on Sustainability]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/hindu-theology-summit-to-focus-on-sustainability-d9207ccbf7c9?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9207ccbf7c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[berkeley]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Apr 2017 13:57:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-24T14:48:47.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Few, if any, issues are as urgent as the ecological crisis currently facing not only humanity, but all life on this planet. Contrary to widespread perceptions, religious people are not uniformly in denial of the realities of climate change. Indeed, many are seizing the opportunity provided by the current moment of crisis to rediscover the ecological wisdom at the heart of their traditions.</p><p>The Hindu community is no exception to this trend. India, the land that the vast majority of the world’s Hindus call home, is both at the forefront of the movement to develop sustainable sources of energy and on the front lines of the unfolding climate crisis, bearing the brunt of many of the problems to which this slow-motion disaster is giving rise: the drying up of rivers, the destruction of crops, flooding due to ocean rise, displacement of people (“climate refugees”), intolerable heat, as well as the needs of a rapidly growing economy to find sources of energy that will not worsen the situation.</p><p>Hinduism and the other Dharma traditions that have emerged in India, such as Jainism, Buddhism, and the Sikh tradition, have promoted ideals conducive to sustainability for hundreds of years. The virtue of <em>ahimsa</em>, of nonviolence in thought word and deed toward all living beings, is central to all of these traditions.<em> </em>In Hinduism, in particular, Mother Earth–Matri Bhumi–is a Goddess who has been revered in the subcontinent for thousands of years. But with the rise of modernity, these traditions of respect for the Earth have all too often been sidelined. The time has come now for thinkers operating from within Hindu intellectual spaces–Hindu theologians–to re-articulate this ancient Earth-centered ethos, especially as the world begins to look to these spiritual traditions to promote sustainability.</p><p>This work has already begun. The Hindu Declaration on Climate Change is just one example (and a very good one) of a statement of principles, rooted in Hindu traditions, that is addressed to the current crisis. You can read, and even add your voice in support of, this effort here:</p><p><a href="http://www.hinduclimatedeclaration2015.org/english">http://www.hinduclimatedeclaration2015.org/english</a></p><p>From Friday, April 28th to Saturday, April 29th, a gathering of Hindu theologians will meet at the Graduate Theological Union at Berkeley University to continue the process of reflection upon and giving voice to a Hindu ethos of sustainability. This event, titled <strong><em>Towards Sustainable Societies-Interreligious, Interdisciplinary Responses</em></strong>, will take place at the Flora Lamson Hewlett Library. One can register for this historic summit at <a href="https://gtu-sustainable-societies.eventbrite.com/">https://gtu-sustainable-societies.eventbrite.com/</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9207ccbf7c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Journey to Hindu Dharma (Part One: Setting the Scene)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/my-journey-to-hindu-dharma-part-one-setting-the-scene-7e5305511444?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e5305511444</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yoga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Apr 2017 17:25:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-07T17:25:10.765Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Who Cares?</strong></p><p>No matter how many times I present it in various venues, either in talks or in articles in books or on the internet, I find that there is an ongoing fascination with the story of how I came to identify myself as Hindu, and to be an active, participating member of the Hindu community in North America. I suspect this is because my story, while it is certainly not unique, is unusual. I also suspect it is because American culture is often perceived to be diametrically opposed to Hindu values–a perception that is both true and false, depending on which part of American culture and which part of Hindu Dharma one is comparing. There is also an assumption that most Americans are either Christian and antagonistic to all other faiths or paths, or materialist and antagonistic or indifferent to all spirituality. In reality, though, the situation is far more complex.</p><p><strong>My Story in Context</strong></p><p>A recent Pew research poll on the ethnic make-up of American religious communities<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> revealed that, while the vast majority of Hindus in America are of Asian heritage–mostly of Indian origin–a small but not insignificant number of those who identify as Hindu are from other ethnic backgrounds. Among the roughly 2.23 million Hindus in America, the study found that 91 percent are of Asian heritage. Of the remaining 9 percent, 2 percent self-identified as being of “mixed” heritage. 4 percent identified themselves as white, 2 percent as African American, and 1 percent as Hispanic. This means there are roughly 89,200 white American Hindus, 44,600 African American Hindus, and 22,300 Hispanic American Hindus.</p><p>These numbers are not insignificant. They suggest that non-Indian Hindus, while yet a small minority in the Hindu American community–and an absolutely tiny minority in the global Hindu community of almost one billion–are nevertheless a real, definite presence. Non-Indian Hindus are now, as many of my students would say, “a thing.” Indeed, our first Hindu representative to the US Congress, Tulsi Gabbard, is a Hindu; but she is not of Indian descent.</p><p>There have, of course, been non-Indian Hindus for many centuries. The Hindus of Bali, a remnant of what was once a much wider Hindu presence across Southeast Asia, have been around for a very long time. I am speaking here of Hindus in the West, and in the United States in particular, who are not part of the Indian Diaspora: Western Hindus.</p><p>Another poll, famously cited by Lisa Miller in her 2009 <em>Newsweek</em> essay, ‘We Are All Hindus Now,’<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> suggests that the influence of Hindu thought upon American attitudes and beliefs goes far beyond those who self-identify as Hindu. According to this information, a majority of Americans–65 percent–believe that “many religions can lead to eternal life.” This number includes a surprising 37 percent of white evangelical Christians. This survey also indicates that 24 percent of Americans believe in reincarnation, and that 30 percent–almost a third–self-identify as “spiritual but not religious.” And, of course, there are the vast numbers who practice some form or other of yoga, either as a type of exercise or as a total way of life.</p><p>It is in the context just described that my journey is best understood. Beginning with the coming of Swami Vivekananda to the US in 1893–or even before that, if one takes into account the Transcendentalists and Theosophists of the nineteenth century, and their deep fascination with both Hindu and Buddhist thought–the spiritual seeker who turns to India for inspiration has been a feature of American society. For some, this turning is a casual flirtation, an appropriation of a few ideas, and maybe even some practices, into a lifestyle that does not change in any fundamental way. It may even take the form of assimilating Hindu ideas or practices into a Christian spirituality–a phenomenon that some have called ‘digestion.’ For others, the experience is more profound and life changing, leading one to orient one’s whole existence around the wisdom that one has discovered, perhaps even to the point of identifying oneself religiously as Hindu. Finally, for a few, the experience is so profound that one goes, as it were, ‘all the way,’ and joins a monastic order, becoming a swami or a pravrajika and giving one’s life completely to the spiritual path.</p><p>I would locate myself in the middle group which I have just described: as one who has found Hindu thought and practice so compelling that it has defined the orientation of my life. I did not go to the point of joining a monastic order, though this is certainly a path I contemplated at one point. I did, however, marry into the tradition, though this is not how I first came to Hindu Dharma. I was already deeply immersed in Hindu thought and practice when my wife and I first met, now more than twenty years ago. My choice of a career was shaped by my spiritual journey, though. I became a professional scholar and teacher of Indian traditions–or Dharma traditions–precisely because I wanted to immerse myself in knowledge of all these paths.</p><p>The perspectives taken by scholars in an academic setting are, as is well known, not the same as those taken in a traditional setting. There is often tension–and sometimes even hostility–between the two. I believe, though, that one can learn from all perspectives, and that both the tradition and the academy can benefit from thoughtful and respectful mutual engagement. I have tried, in my own small way, to be a bridge between the two. But that is a story for another day.</p><p><strong>Who Is a Hindu?</strong></p><p>Some may argue that only one born into Hindu Dharma can rightfully claim to be Hindu. If that is the case, then we, the 156,000 or so non-Indian Hindus in the US, are deceiving ourselves. While I do not agree with this perspective, I want to conclude this particular essay by saying that I respect it. Indeed, I know others who have been deeply influenced by Hindu traditions–who even have a guru and practice their sadhana faithfully–but who do not identify themselves as Hindu precisely because they respect the tradition and are concerned not to give offense. Perhaps we should call ourselves something else: people inspired by Hinduism, or people who follow a Hindu philosophy or way of life. We can also identify, as many do, with the specific Hindu tradition to which we are affiliated: with ISKCON, or with Transcendental Meditation, or with Siddha Yoga, or with the Self-Realization Fellowship, or, in my case, with the Ramakrishna Mission (known in the US as the Vedanta Society). But when explaining our beliefs to our fellow Americans who are unfamiliar with these traditions, we inevitably end up using the word ‘Hindu.’ It is on this pragmatic basis that I so identify myself with this tradition that, for me, has changed everything.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/07/27/the-most-and-least-racially-diverse-u-s-religious-groups/ft_15-07-23_religiondiversityindex-1/">http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/07/27/the-most-and-least-racially-diverse-u-s-religious-groups/ft_15-07-23_religiondiversityindex-1/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Miller, Lisa. “We All Hindus Now” (<em>Newsweek</em>, August 31, 2009)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e5305511444" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Religion Scholars Object to Inaccuracies, Exoticism in First Episode of Reza Aslan’s ‘Believer’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@longjd/religion-scholars-object-to-inaccuracies-exoticism-in-first-episode-of-reza-aslans-believer-7e69643326ac?source=rss-701b18d1b5d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e69643326ac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cnn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeffery D. Long]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Mar 2017 15:44:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-31T01:29:18.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Celebrity religion scholar Reza Aslan recently debuted his CNN series, ‘Believer’ with an episode focused on a fascinating group of Hindu yogis known as the Aghoris. With a name which means “Fearless,” the Aghoris are worshipers of the deity Śiva and are known for their unconventional practices, which include meditating in cremation grounds and eating substances regarded in mainstream Hindu society as impure. All of this is done in the name of the philosophical ideal of non-duality: that divinity is present everywhere, even in places that “polite” society shuns.</p><p>An episode on the Aghoris, and on CNN no less, would have been a most welcome development. As a professor and scholar of Indian traditions, I was hoping it might even be something I could show to my students for educational purposes. Like many of my colleagues, I was horrified to find a piece riddled with factual errors and full of exoticization and sensationalism.</p><p>Finding this sentiment to be widely shared among experts in my field, I contacted a few of my colleagues and we crafted the following letter to Jeffrey Zucker, President of CNN, which was delivered to him this week:</p><p>March 24, 2017</p><p>Mr. Jeffrey Zucker</p><p>President, CNN</p><p>Dear Mr. Zucker,</p><p>We write this letter collectively as a group of scholars from a variety of academic disciplines to express serious concern with the first episode of the CNN Original series entitled <em>Believer</em>. Set in Varanasi, the debut features host Reza Aslan, widely described as a scholar of religion, roaming along the Ganga, interacting with self-proclaimed religious gurus, and participating in what can only be described as decontextualized shock-value rituals.</p><p>Setting aside the overtly sensationalist nature of the show and its promotional materials, what is most concerning to us as scholars are the factual errors and misinformation Aslan proffers about Hinduism throughout the episode. We understand that <em>Believer </em>does not aim to be an instructional film or documentary. However, a nonfiction program being broadcast on a globally renowned news network such as CNN is likely to be taken as presenting authoritative knowledge. It therefore demands far more in the way of fact-checking, depth, and, we daresay, consultation with actual experts on the traditions it covers.</p><p>Just a sampling of the misinformation includes:</p><ul><li>the number of cremation grounds in Varanasi being grossly overstated — Aslan claims 87, when in fact there are only two active cremation grounds</li><li>Aslan translates the Hindi word “ghat” as “cremation ground” — it actually means “flight of steps leading down to a river”</li><li>basic Hindu concepts explained incorrectly — Aslan’s description of karma and its inter-relatedness to reincarnation and the “caste system” reflects neither a Hindu understanding nor academic consensus</li><li>in some cases, scenes have clearly been staged in order to match the narration</li><li>deities Aslan talks about on camera are not the ones shown in the background</li></ul><p>These are only a few of the many errors that can be found throughout the episode.</p><p>In addition to its many factual errors, the episode is deeply insensitive to a variety of issues to which responsible scholars of South Asian religions are trained to be attentive. There is a strong air of orientalism–the deliberate exoticization of the Other in order, on some level, to control the Other–and neocolonialism about the entire presentation. We also share concerns which have been raised in the wider Hindu community that, in an era of growing violence against persons regarded as ‘Other,’ this episode could serve to fuel bigoted and racist attitudes and behaviors.</p><p>As educators, we know too well the knowledge gap on Hinduism amongst the American public. It is our view that the <em>Believer </em>episode on Hinduism has only served to compound religious illiteracy. It has, in fact, required some of us to do “damage control” with our students in order to correct the many misconceptions about Hindu traditions that can arise from a viewing of this episode. We are thus deeply concerned about the damaging effects that could arise from further airing of this episode. Some of us are willing to serve as consultants should a revised version of this episode, or future programming on Hinduism, be contemplated.</p><p>Sincerely,</p><p>1. Loriliai Biernacki, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Director of Graduate Studies, Religious Studies — University of Colorado Boulder</p><p>2. Christopher Chapple, Ph.D., Doshi Professor of Indic and Comparative Theology, and Director, Master of Arts in Yoga Studies, Bellarmine College of Liberal Arts — Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles</p><p>3. Abhishek Ghosh, Ph.D., Assistant Professor, Religious Studies and Liberal Studies — Grand Valley State University, Allendale, MI</p><p>4. Marcy Goldstein, Ph.D. Adjunct Lecturer, Department of Religious Studies, College of Liberal Arts &amp; Sciences — The University of North Carolina at Charlotte</p><p>5. Pankaj Jain, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy &amp; Religion, College of Liberal Arts &amp; Sciences — University of North Texas, Dallas, TX</p><p>6. Ramdas Lamb, Ph.D., Professor, Department of Religion — University of Hawai’i, Manoa, HI</p><p>7. Jeffery D. Long, Ph.D., Professor of Religion and Asian Studies — Elizabethtown College, Elizabethtown, PA</p><p>8. Vasudha Narayanan, Ph.D., Professor, Department of Religion, College of Liberal Arts &amp; Sciences — University of Florida, Gainesville, FL</p><p>9. Andrew Nicholson, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Department of Asian &amp; Asian American Studies — Stony Brook University, NY</p><p>10. Anantanand Rambachan, Ph.D., Professor of Religion — St. Olaf College, Northfield, MN</p><p>11. Nalini Rao, Ph.D., Professor of World Art — Soka University, Aliso Viejo, CA</p><p>12. Rita D. Sherma, Ph.D., Director and Associate Professor, The Mira and Ajay Shingal Center for Dharma Studies; Chair, Hindu Studies; Core Doctoral Faculty–Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley</p><p>13. Deepak Shimkhada, Ph.D., Adjunct Professor of Hindu Studies — Claremont School of Theology, Claremont, CA</p><p>14. Lavanya Vemsani, Ph.D., Professor of History, Department of Social Sciences — Shawnee State University, Portsmouth, OH</p><p>15. Richard Fox Young, Ph.D, Associate Professor, History of Religions–Princeton Theological Seminary, Princeton, NJ</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e69643326ac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>