<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Lonnie Jay on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Lonnie Jay on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lonniejay?source=rss-1f4d2b8be7fa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 14:41:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lonniejay/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The death of the explorer and the rise of ‘ADHD kids’.]]></title>
            <link>https://lonniejay.medium.com/the-death-of-the-explorer-and-the-rise-of-adhd-kids-30e8d554bec5?source=rss-1f4d2b8be7fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/30e8d554bec5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[emotions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lonnie Jay]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Jan 2021 16:51:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-23T16:51:36.992Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hyperactivity. Impulsivity. Distractibility. We all know what ADHD looks like. ADHD kids can be chronically restless, have a hard time focusing and completing tasks, might interrupt people at inopportune times, and often show baffling lapses in judgement. ‘ADHD kids’ aren’t just impulsive and hyperactive, though — they often show other symptoms of emotional and behavioral dysregulation that puts them at higher risk for development of other psychiatric disorders. According to a national 2016 parent survey, 6 in 10 children with ADHD had at least one other mental, emotional, or behavioral disorder, with 5 in 10 children also presenting with a behavior or conduct problem (CDC, 2020).</p><p>Those who display these hyperactive and impulsive traits are also at a higher risk of developing a substance use disorder (SUD). Those formally diagnosed with ADHD have double the chances of developing a SUD. The risk quadruples when ADHD exists alongside a behavioral conduct disorder. (Wilens et al, 2014). Conduct disorders are disorders of behavior that include aggressiveness, deceitfulness, and a general disregard of other social norms and rules. There is a substantially higher likelihood of all manner of risk-taking behaviors in people that live with ADHD, which also includes a nearly-doubled risk of alcohol abuse and a 2.4x higher likelihood of cigarette smoking (CDC, 2020).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*Hj8_365vkVKUme-doTrWTg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Those with ADHD have a 64% chance of being diagnosed with any other mental, emotional, or behavioral disorder (CDC, 2020).</figcaption></figure><p>While a parent might lament receiving an ADHD diagnosis for their kid, there seems to be an evolutionary reason that some of us have these hyperactive and impulsive traits. There are different subtypes of ADHD and likely a wide range of genetic and epigenetic determinants for ADHD-related behaviors, but one of the more common subtypes of ADHD is the hyperactive and impulsive subtype, ADHD-HI, which we are discussing here, and not the inattentive type that often occurs with other learning disorders and can dramatically impact functionality. While those with ADHD-HI might display problems with attention and organizing information, those symptoms don’t present as severely as they do in the inattentive type, and many people with ADHD-HI go on to be very high-functioning people once they learn to adapt.</p><p>ADHD occurs at a high enough rate to suggest that some of the behavioral symptoms of the disorder may have been positively selected for in evolution, meaning these traits must provide some benefits for our society, or at least provided benefits for societies past. Indeed, there are certain genetic differences, like the seven-repeat allele of DRD4, which is related to dopamine function in the brain, that have been molecularly investigated and have been confirmed to be positively selected for in evolution, which means there exists the possibility that ADHD increases the reproductive fitness and survivability of the individual — or, crucially, for the social group as a whole (Taylor et al, 2006).</p><p>To illustrate this idea, let’s imagine a tribe of hunter-gatherer humans on the edge of a forest in a time long past. There are 100 humans in the tribe, but not enough food to feed all 100 humans. Some members of the tribe have to go out and explore the forest in order to forage for food and survive — but that exploration automatically carries immense risk with it.</p><p>If all 100 humans in the tribe are genetically wired to be highly judgmental, consistent, and make ‘safe’ decisions, nobody would feel a natural itch to get up and take the risks that are intrinsic in leaving a safe tribe to go explore and forage. Nobody has the exploratory itch, so nobody goes exploring. Food supply dwindles until all 100 humans die of starvation and none of their genetics are passed on.</p><p>On the contrary, if all 100 humans are wired for the hyperactivity and impulsivity that engenders a natural drive towards exploratory behavior, all 100 humans feel the itch to go foraging, and perhaps many die due to consuming unsafe berries, being bit by poisonous insects, being mauled by animals — some die, others are lost or injured, their tribe becomes a mess, and all 100 also wind up passing away, which marks the end of their genetic line, too.</p><p>ADHD occurs at a rate of 5–15% of the population, and at least one of the likely genetic predispositions for it show molecular evidence of recent positive selection (Taylor et al, 2006) which means that people that show these ADHD/exploratory traits allow for a group survival advantage that is most easily understood in this example: if 5–15 of those 100 members of the tribe have the hyperactive-impulsive exploratory itch, while the other 85–95 feel a drive to remain safe with the tribe, then we have a minority of the population that is wired to be deeply driven to forage despite the risks of exploring the unknown forest and the possible bodily harm that comes with it, while the majority can stay home and engage in other, safer, social group survival-related behaviors. In other words, having a minority — and only a minority — of the group wired to be restless and impulsive increases the survivability of the entire group.</p><p>Indeed, ‘ADHD kids’ that might have the aforementioned genetic predisposition (DRD4–7R) show higher tendencies towards novelty seeking, which has been shown to be inversely related to harm avoidance in these instances, meaning traits of high novelty seeking and low harm avoidance often go hand in hand. This makes sense, because DRD4 coding is related to functions like impulse control and attention (Bhatia, 2020).</p><p>This constellation of traits — hyperactivity, impulsivity, high novelty seeking, low harm avoidance, ‘jumpy’ attentional traits — makes ‘ADHD kids’ the perfect explorers. However, our society doesn’t have that perspective on these traits; hyperactivity and impulsivity are seen as characteristics of mental disorders that need to be treated, most often with medication. ADHD kids are the explorers in a society that rewards our ability to sit still and control all of our exploratory impulses, while punishing and pathologizing the behaviors that these hyperactive and impulsive traits give rise to.</p><p>As previously mentioned, people with these ADHD-like traits are at higher risks of developing all kinds of addictive and other mental-emotional disorders. The correlation between our society’s negative views towards hyperactive and impulsive behaviors and how they relate to the further development of other mental health issues has yet to be determined, but perhaps we can begin a paradigm shift in which we can start to discuss the benefits of having these ‘explorers’ around.</p><p>Beyond exploring a potentially dangerous forest and bringing back food for the rest of the tribe, as in the previous example, these people bring value in what is called ‘exploratory knowledge acquisition’. Beyond merely gathering up a few fruits for the tribe on a one-time basis, these exploratory-types were able to bring back priceless knowledge of where these new food sources could be found, enabling the entire group to benefit from the exploration.</p><p>Exploratory knowledge acquisition being limited to a minority, once again, bestows a survival advantage upon the rest of the tribe. In order for us to understand this on a practical, modern level, we must consider how all of our children benefit from having a few ADHD kids in the tribes of modern society.</p><p>Impulsivity means unpredictability and randomness; and our ADHD kids seem naturally driven to do random things they should not. They are the ones that touch the hot stove first. They eat the random berries and climb dangerously high trees. They do not focus on their classwork, which provides an opportunity for the teacher to show the rest of the kids what happens when children don’t focus on our classwork. ADHD kids see things differently; they break the rules in games, which is another teaching or learning opportunity for all of us and a way for flaws in our various systems to be exposed.</p><p>All these impulsive behaviors provide useful lessons for the majority of the kids, while only the minority of the ADHD-type kids put themselves into danger or trouble. Perhaps less often in modern society, but still very valuable, children with these hyperactive and impulsive exploratory traits might discover something advantageous that the more conservative children simply could not.</p><p>It’s no secret that our public education system isn’t conducive to the kinds of hyperactive, impulsive behaviors that lead to the exploratory knowledge that our ADHD kids are wired to forage and find. Rather than reframing their restless and impulsive behavior through the lens of understanding that every human has different genetic predispositions that cause them to behave differently, we say that they have an attention disorder. Rather than acknowledging that their innate genetic and emotional makeup drives them towards acts of novelty-seeking and risk-taking for this exploratory knowledge acquisition, we tend to kick them out of the classroom, which only increases their chances of getting into trouble in the real world.</p><p>We place a moral veneer over their behavior: little Johnny can’t sit still, and he has impulsive outbursts in class, so he’s misbehaving. God forbid he go from being labeled an ‘ADHD kid’ to being labeled a ‘bad kid’, which is the path towards suspension and expulsion from public school, which is often the beginning of further emotional and behavioral dysregulation and therefore a descent into even worse mental, emotional, and behavioral health. In order to turn ADHD kids into ‘good kids’ that can sit still for hours at a time without a single hyperactive knee-bounce or impulsive peep, we prescribe them drugs, most often stimulant drugs like Adderall.</p><p>Jaak Panksepp, who did exhaustive work into mammalian behavior, mammalian emotions, and the emotional circuits in mammalian brains that underly emotion and behavior, characterized the massive and highly influential dopamine-driven system in the brain as the SEEKING system. Most of us know the dopamine system as the ‘reward system’ and much of what we talk about when we talk about dopamine or the ‘reward system’ is in the context of addiction.</p><p>However, to call the dopamine system the ‘reward system’ is to grossly oversimplify it; dopamine has little to do with our experience of pleasure on the level of reward attainment. Dopamine doesn’t have as much to do with our brains saying ‘I like this’ as we previously thought; and dopamine is linked to much, much more than just ‘pleasure’ and ‘reward’.</p><p>Dopamine has 5 different receptor types. These dopamine receptors are linked to everything from generating the excited, euphoric emotional states that come from exploring and reward anticipation to higher-level cognition to impulse control to movement to learning and memory.</p><p>Dopamine signaling in the brain generates excitement at the prospect of a reward in the environment, it drives us to approach the possible reward, yet, crucially, it also inhibits the impulses that drive the consummation of the reward-related behavior — if and when all dopamine signaling is happening in a way that allows for impulse control, which might not be the case in our explorers.</p><p>Dopamine is also responsible for the adaptive learning that comes from attempted reward consummation, and even innervates the parts of the brain responsible for neurogenesis, a crucial process in allowing us to learn from our mistakes (Oertal et al, 2016). Clearly, natural differences in how we produce and process dopamine — like we see in the genetics of our ADHD kids — are major factors in whether we learn from our ‘mistakes’ or continue to make the same ‘reward prediction errors’ in the future.</p><p>This explains why ADHD kids can be so frustrating sometimes: why don’t they just learn from their mistakes like the rest of us? Maybe they don’t because humans would be extinct without them. Some of us have to make some mistakes and then continue to make similar mistakes after that; if all of us learned perfectly from every small painful mistake that we make, then none of us would ever take any risks.</p><p>Risk-taking would be snuffed from our genome, and all of us would sit in our chairs quietly for 10 hours a day and listen to our parents and our bosses and stay away from anything that could ever hurt us. We would never try to become Olympians or Hollywood stars or business magnates, because it would just be too risky. Then, hyperactivity and impulsivity would be bred out of our genome, and we would live in a world without Michael Phelps, Adam Levine, Ryan Gosling, Channing Tatum, Simone Biles, Jim Carrey, Richard Branson — the list goes on and on.</p><p>Hyperactivity and impulsivity should be viewed as the inherently neutral traits that they are. Michael Phelps, had he not had the opportunity to become a swimmer, might’ve found a more negative, maladaptive channel for his hyperactivity and impulsivity. Again, we must think of the clear link between ADHD, dopamine processing, and addictive disorders.</p><p>Again, dopamine-driven SEEKING is an emotional state of euphoric anticipatory excitement; it is pleasurable in a sense but not comparable to the pleasure of consummating a reward — for example, the pleasure and satisfaction we feel when we are eating a chocolate cake.</p><p>A great way to understand the difference between the enjoyment we feel when we are in a SEEKING emotional state and a more traditionally rewarding ‘pleasure’ like eating a chocolate cake is to classify these feelings differently: those who are deeply tuned into an emotional SEEKING state are enjoying the hunt for the sake of the hunt. Pleasure, as it relates to the enjoyment of ‘rewards’ like eating a chocolate cake, can be thought of as pleasures related to feasting. Hunting and feasting are two very different experiences of pleasure, and explorers are wired to hunt for the sake of the hunt and actually might not very much enjoy feasting at all. If Richard Branson was wired to feast, he would’ve stopped hunting after his first million dollars. Michael Phelps is naturally driven to SEEK and hunt, or else one gold medal would’ve been enough. For hunters, hunting in and of itself is enjoyable, regardless of any feast that they might partake in afterwards.</p><p>Michael Phelps and other ADHD kids/explorers are driven to greatness by their constant desire to hunt, which is a positive trait when their emotional SEEKING urges are appropriately channeled. However, had Phelps been denied a swimming pool and came across some oxycontin instead, perhaps his SEEKING urges would’ve turned him into a statistic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*7bB9WOx9koUjHa4X2RV7dQ.png" /><figcaption>‘ADHD kids’ are 2.6 times more likely to abuse or become dependent on illegal drugs.</figcaption></figure><p>I believe that our school system, and perhaps our entire culture in general, needs more time and space for allowing curiosity, exploration, and learning-related freedom and agency in our lives. We should recognize the natural SEEKING-related urge to explore that most kids have, accept that some kids will have more hyperactive and impulsive exploratory urges than others, and have programs in place for ADHD kids that just aren’t the best genetic fit for rote, dictated, classroom learning.</p><p>Perhaps we can begin to think of this subtype of ADHD as the explorer subtype, both to lessen stigma and provide these kids with another, more positive identity beyond that of an ‘ADHD kid’. We also need to emphasize the need for alternative educational programs for these children. This will also prevent the ADHD kids, who will likely struggle with behavioral and emotional dysregulation at some point in their lives, from becoming labeled ‘bad kids’ early on, which can lead to school suspensions and other punishments, which are the beginnings of societal expulsion and can be a death sentence in America.</p><p>The genetic differences that underlie ADHD will manifest behaviorally: ADHD kids are wired to pay more attention to novel and attention-grabbing stimuli, which might mean that they pay attention to everything except the book on their desk and the tone of the teacher, which the ADHD student might perceive as monotonous even if other students might not.</p><p>A natural overstimulation of this dopaminergic SEEKING system fills the bodies of our explorers with a restlessness that they just can’t quite put their finger on and certainly can’t control. It isn’t that they have difficulty understanding the content being presented in the classroom — on the contrary, many ADHD-HI kids are quite intelligent — they just might have difficulty truly and deeply comprehending why they have to sit there for 8 hours a day learning grammar and rote mathematics, no matter how often our teachers and parents explain to them that this is simply a necessary prerequisite to becoming members of high society.</p><p>Our explorers aren’t wired to sit there for 8 hours, and perhaps they even have a genetic makeup that makes them less likely to listen to their elders; they are wired to get up and SEEK novel information and exploratory rewards even if their parents tell them not to. Again, there’s a group survival advantage here; elders have brains that are more well connected. Our elders have fully-developed brains that often possess great judgement — but somebody still has to take the risk of disobeying them and taking on the potential harms that come with behaviors related to exploratory knowledge acquisition, or else we eventually stagnate and die.</p><p>We need our ADHD kids, and we need them to know they are more than just ADHD kids. I believe we need to start calling them explorers, playing to their strengths, finding a place for their behavioral and emotional dispositions, and trying to find a way to help them to thrive. There have been some compelling studies done on the link between ADHD and the self-employment associated with entrepreneurism, which makes sense given the constellation of aforementioned traits (Block et al, 2016). With this in mind, I am willing to bet there are more than a few explorers who would be more than happy to take on a fast-track to entrepreneurship if it were offered as a specialization at age 15. We must keep in mind that the differences in genetics and brain function that manifest as ‘ADHD’ and similar behaviors are here for a reason.</p><p>Thank you for reading thus far. For my next post, I will discuss the darker sides of ADHD, and go into more detail about how ‘ADHD kids’ become ‘bad kids’ that become ‘criminals’ and ‘addicts’, while also explaining how an overactive, under-inhibited SEEKING system can give rise to the mental and emotional disorders that we often see in our explorers, which can include narcissism, mania, bipolar disorder, and others.</p><p>Please check out my other articles about addictive disorders, follow along if you’re interested, and feel free to reach out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=30e8d554bec5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The SEEKING system, dopamine, and addictive disorders.]]></title>
            <link>https://lonniejay.medium.com/the-seeking-system-dopamine-and-addictive-disorders-c91436859331?source=rss-1f4d2b8be7fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c91436859331</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wellness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lonnie Jay]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Jan 2021 17:12:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T17:12:03.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Humans have a wide variety of natural emotional dispositions. Similarly, there are many factors in the development of an addiction — one person might learn to self-medicate for anxiety, depression, or the symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder while another addicted person is naturally born with an overactive dopamine-fueled SEEKING system. SEEKING is the first of the primary-process emotions (this is the third in a series of posts about the life-process learning disorder model of addiction, which takes an affective neuroscience perspective on addiction rather than the typical cognitive-behavioral perspective. For earlier posts, click <a href="https://lonniejay.medium.com/what-is-addiction-a-new-paradigm-355ffb3d993d">https://lonniejay.medium.com/what-is-addiction-a-new-paradigm-355ffb3d993d</a> and <a href="https://lonniejay.medium.com/emotions-come-first-an-affective-neuroscience-perspective-on-addiction-b8d793c2c009">https://lonniejay.medium.com/emotions-come-first-an-affective-neuroscience-perspective-on-addiction-b8d793c2c009</a>)</p><p>All animals, including humans, are emotionally driven to SEEK rewards in the environment, like food, sexual mates, and survival-bestowing plant medications. The SEEKING system is modulated by dopamine and is commonly called the ‘reward’ system, which is a misnomer based on an outdated understanding of the function that dopamine has in the brain.</p><p>When this dopamine-based ‘reward’/SEEKING system is stimulated electrically or chemically, mammals energetically engage with their environment in an exploratory manner; the dopaminergic SEEKING system fills us with euphoric excitement and anticipation of rewards in the environment — think of a dog excitedly bouncing around as we walk towards him with his food bowl in our hands.</p><p>Those of us who have studied addiction might have heard of experiments in which a rat sits in a cage with an electrical probe implanted in his brain and a lever in front of him. When the rat presses the lever, he triggers an electrical stimulation of the ‘reward’/SEEKING system via the probe. Rats will continuously press the lever to stimulate this dopamine system until they die.</p><p>When I first heard of this experiment, I pictured the rat sitting in his cage in a drug-like, electrically-stimulated stupor, completely ignoring his surroundings in favor of repeatedly stimulating the ‘reward’ system, high on pure pleasure from the constant dopamine release. On the contrary, rats don’t act doped up; they actually excitedly explore their environment while the ‘reward’/SEEKING system is being stimulated — they even seem to try to search behind the lever (Panksepp, 2012).</p><p>Although Panksepp’s work has been largely marginalized, and many of us have probably never heard the dopamine system called the SEEKING system, the rest of the neuroscientific community is coming around to the perspective of affective neuroscience, and it is now well accepted that the massive dopaminergic system that we previously called the ‘reward’ system is associated with an emotional-motivational state of ‘wanting’ and that entirely different, much smaller neural systems are involved in the actual feelings of pleasure that lead us to ‘liking’ (Berridge, 2016).</p><p>Panksepp postulated that animals self-stimulate the SEEKING system not because it feels pleasurable in the way that a wonderful meal is delightful, but because it promotes a powerful internal state of SEEKING that also produces a very special positive feeling that closely resembles how we humans feel when we are full of positive excitement about the good things that are around us in the environment.</p><p>Testing and experiments consistently indicate that the SEEKING system first gets mammals excited about newly found rewards, and then learns rapidly to anticipate further rewards, if more rewards are coming. Animals that are having their SEEKING systems stimulated simply do not behave as if they are consuming a delightful treat and experiencing a sensory-affective reward, like we would assume, given that some people still call this system the ‘reward’ system. There are other regions, including the septal region, that produce behavior that is closer to what we would expect from self-stimulation of a ‘reward’ system (Panksepp, 2012).</p><p>Thus, the old idea that addicted people are just dopamine junkies chasing the next ‘reward’ of a pleasurable high is rooted in a misunderstanding. We now understand why addictions can exist divorced of all pleasurable rewards, as they often do. Addictive disorders are rooted in a dysfunction of constant desire; addictive disorders are disorders of an emotional ‘wanting’ or SEEKING state that becomes all-encompassing, even when these emotional SEEKING states lead to behaviors that are negative or maladaptive.</p><p>Addictive disorders are disorders of desire, not disorders of consummatory pleasure. On some level, we know that addictive disorders aren’t disorders of pleasure, because addicted people often report being absolutely miserable. On a neuroscientific level, the problem isn’t that the addicted person ‘likes’ drugs too much; the problem is often that the person is in a constant state of deep, emotionally-driven wanting or SEEKING but doesn’t have anything much else that they ‘like’ — except, maybe, the escape from painful realities that drugs can bring, if we can even call that something that we can ‘like’. No one has illustrated this truth better than the quintessential ‘junky’ himself, William Burroughs:</p><p><strong>“</strong>The questions, of course, could be asked: Why did you ever try narcotics? Why did you continue using it long enough to become an addict? You become a narcotics addict because you do not have strong motivations in the other direction. Junk wins by default.<strong>”</strong></p><p>Addicted people might not have strong motivations towards things that they ‘like’, but as humans, they have no choice but to SEEK something. In other words, addictive disorders are disorders of pathological wanting; addicted people are on a treadmill of emotional SEEKING behaviors that lead to drug use, despite the fact that they might not even ‘like’ drugs anymore. The SEEKING system is extremely fundamental, and it energizes the other 6 primary-process emotional systems: FEAR, RAGE, LUST, CARE, GRIEF, and PLAY.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/1*FKR4LRTWMX6EzaxYD509Fg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The SEEKING system drives instinctual emotional behavior, controls learning, and extends into our thoughts.</figcaption></figure><p>In the case of FEAR, we can see how the dopamine-dependent SEEKING system would assist us in finding safety, by generating the energy we need to SEEK a comfortable environment. When we are SEEKING an environmental reward like food, and we are thwarted in some way, the RAGE system might be triggered, which would further engage the SEEKING system and drive us to overcome the barrier to food attainment, which would lead to reward attainment and therefore survival. Separation from loved ones will trigger the emotional GRIEF circuit, which will drive us to cry out in distress and also energize the SEEKING system, which will aid us in exploring the environment in order to re-connect to our social group, which, again, will allow us to survive, as mammals are highly social animals.</p><p>The SEEKING system, like all primary-process emotional systems, is a valuation system. Our emotions have evolved to get us to quickly assign values to various environmental risks and rewards, while also triggering behaviors that will get us away from the painful risks and close to the pleasurable rewards that can be found all around us. These primary-process emotional systems also drive the secondary-processes of learning and memory; in the case of addictive disorders, learning that self-medication can lead to feelings of emotional regulation and relief can become a deeply learned, highly-maladaptive behavioral trap for the dopamine system that powers our natural SEEKING urges.</p><p>This is how addicted people get stuck on the SEEKING treadmill; we are emotionally driven to SEEK the relief that we have learned can be found in the environment and that we remember as a reward due to our past experiences — despite the fact that, often, the ‘reward’ is no longer likable or pleasurable. The SEEKING system, when activated while a person is in a safe environment, will trigger feelings of euphoric expectancy that generate exploratory behaviors and anticipatory feelings of impending reward, but it also powerfully drives us to SEEK safety from pain, including personal, subjective emotional pain.</p><p>As previously mentioned, the SEEKING system also causes us to learn and remember our previous emotional survival-valuations. These learned behaviors can be thought of as a kind of subconscious software program. We place predictive emotional valuations upon different possible risks and rewards, and the pleasure or pain that results causes us to learn how to behave adaptively and ensure survival.</p><p>Thus, this dopamine-driven SEEKING system also has deeper components that trigger the learning and memory systems and seem evolutionarily designed to completely automate previous behaviors that led to the attainment of environmental reward and survival in the past. Ideally, the SEEKING system causes us to engage excitedly with our environment, it causes us to remember our previous emotional survival-valuations and whether they were accurate or not, and it causes us to seek previous rewards instinctively, impulsively, habitually, and eventually compulsively in order to streamline survival processes.</p><p>When a person is developing an addictive disorder, that person’s brain is learning to assign a high emotional survival-valuation to a specific drug or behavior. As addictive behavior progresses, the process of learning deepens, and the SEEKING behaviors that led to the attainment of previously highly-valued rewards begins to become automated, initially in a way that we might call impulsive, because impulsivity implies an estimation of pleasurable attainment, even if it turns out to be a mis-estimation that was made in poor judgement.</p><p>At the same time, these drugs or behaviors leave emotional voids behind when their ‘pleasurable’ feelings — which might just be the avoidance of even deeper emotional pain — inevitably slip away from us. So, it isn’t just that we deeply learn to subconsciously value these drugs or behaviors more than what they’re worth; we are also left in a negative emotional state when we find ourselves sitting alone and thinking to ourselves again.</p><p>Feelings of loneliness, pain, stress, or discomfort can energize the SEEKING system to get us away from the feelings of painful discomfort, and a brain is evolutionarily driven to get away from pain by attaining survival rewards. However, our perception of what is rewarding or pleasurable is based on past experiences, which means we might ‘remember’ that drugs feel good, even if they really don’t. Emotional dysregulation causes us to remember a mis-valued reward, faulty learned behaviors take over, and back on the addictive SEEKING treadmill we go.</p><p>It is worth noting that more natural and typical survival rewards like human connection, sex, and food pale in comparison to perceived hyper-rewards like externally-dosed opioids. Feeling driven to SEEK the reward of social connection in the form of a friend when we are lonely and feel GRIEF coming on is a process that happens naturally for many of us, but the ‘reward’ of the companionship of a friend pales in comparison to the ‘reward’ of a high dose of opioids in the brain.</p><p>These emotional circuits are mediated by chemicals that drive learning, and external opioids like oxycontin and fentanyl mimic the neurotransmitters that help us feel connected, safe, and secure, while also directly causing the secondary-process of learning. This causes us to deeply ‘mis-learn’ that external opioids are more valuable to us than social connections, which is maladaptive in and of itself, and explains why addicted people often behave the way that they do.</p><p>Chemical reactions in the brain cause us to feel specific emotions, these emotions drive the process of learning, and drugs release massive amounts of chemicals that cause us to feel powerful emotional states that automatically lead to the process of learning and can also lead to the eventual deep learning that drives compulsive behavior. This includes the deeply-learned automation of SEEKING behaviors that puts us on the proverbial treadmill of addictive disorders, which is characterized by impulsive and/or compulsive SEEKING behaviors related to reward attainment despite the negative consequences of engaging in such behavior.</p><p>The ‘rewards’ that we are wired to compulsively SEEK are mis-valued, and the behaviors that we learn to automate in order to attain the mis-valued rewards are maladaptive in the real world, so we are on safe ground when we say that addictive disorders are fundamentally disorders of emotional dysregulation, emotional mis-valuation, and finally, mis-learning.</p><p>Addicted people aren’t ‘hijacked’ by ‘evil’ drugs into a zombie-like chase for pleasure; these processes are completely natural. The process of developing an addiction is the natural process of deeply learning to automate behaviors that comes about as a result of our previous emotional survival-valuations. Learning and development go hand in hand; this is a natural process even if it has gone awry in addicted people. Addicted people are also capable of re-evaluating and re-learning these connections, which they do, every day.</p><p>We are mammals, and mammals are evolutionarily driven to deeply learn and automate the behaviors that led to us to feeling safe, connected, and alive in the past. This happens below the level of conscious awareness, and our sub-cortical, subconscious brain circuits cannot tell the difference between endogenous opioids released during a bout of laughter with a friend and externally-dosed opioids like oxycontin; we learn to place a high subconscious emotional value on these rewards all the same.</p><p>Pleasurable experiences trigger the release of a flurry of various neurotransmitters that cause powerful emotional feeling states that seem designed by Mother Nature to ‘imprint’ the reward and how to attain it into our memories. This powerful, emotionally-driven ‘imprint’ into our memory ensures that we never forget what gave us that pleasure and we never forget how to get it, which will help us in finding that pleasurable survival-reward again in the future.</p><p>It makes sense that we would evolve to deeply learn and eventually automate behaviors that allow us to attain the survival-related rewards that give us pleasure: if we have to take a complicated path to get to a hidden tree that is laden with delicious survival-bestowing fruit, the sooner and more deeply we can learn exactly how to get to that tree, the greater our chances for survival and the successful continuation of our genetics.</p><p>As primary-process SEEKING gives way to survival-reward attainment and the emotionally pleasurable feelings that come with it, our secondary-process associative learning expands. We learn to become impulsive: we see the fruit-laden tree and the process of neuroception kicks in. Neuroception refers to the process by which we constantly evaluate risks and rewards in the environment, which happens below the level of conscious awareness (Porges, 2011).</p><p>These are automatic evaluative processes that are undertaken in the deep brain structures that make up our emotional survival-valuation circuits; once we detect a potential risk or reward via neuroception, our physiological state shifts automatically to maximize our chances of survival.</p><p>We see the fruit tree — or the dope dealer — and our subconscious emotional survival-valuation systems kick into gear. Our primary-process emotional circuits are instantly triggered, which release chemicals that alter our physiology, which will drive us to approach what we have learned to perceive as a pleasurable survival-reward or drive us to avoid what we perceive to be a painful punishment based on past experience. However, as we can imagine, these emotional survival-valuation systems and the process of neuroception upon which they lie can be faulty, and we see this in people who have addictive disorders.</p><p>The impulsivity that characterizes mild addictive disorders implies a pleasure association, which implies an activation of our emotional SEEKING system upon neuroception of the environmental cue. Let’s say the environmental cue is a trigger for drug use, and the addicted person has previously learned to mis-value the drug reward that the cue signals.</p><p>Upon neuroception of the cue, the consciousness of the addicted person becomes colored with energetic anticipation, an affective ‘feeling-tone’ that is evolutionarily designed to drive approach behaviors on an extremely fundamental and powerful level. The addicted person feels an impulse to approach the cue, even if they ‘know better’. Impulsivity implies a pleasure association, though it also implies poor planning or judgement, which would be the perfect way to describe the behavior of a person that has developed a mild addictive disorder. Beyond impulsivity and mild brain disorder lies compulsion, which is what characterizes severe addictive disorders.</p><p>Once severe enough, our addictive disorders drive us to behavioral patterns that go beyond impulsive acts. Our ‘reward’ SEEKING behaviors become compulsive; they become an automated end in themselves, regardless of any experiences of pleasure in the past or pain in the present. Going beyond impulsivity and into compulsivity is underscored by observable changes in the connections of the motivational engine of the brain (striatum).</p><p>It’s worth noting that these automating functions of the SEEKING system are completely natural and not pathological or ‘diseased’ in and of themselves: animal brains survived, grew, developed, and evolved by quickly and deeply learning what is important for survival (sugar, fatty foods, sex, social connections, painkilling plant medicines) and automating the SEEKING behaviors that end with the attainment of these survival-bestowing rewards. It only makes sense that surviving feels good. If it didn’t, we wouldn’t be here.</p><p>Thanks for reading thus far. My next post will be about the evolutionary advantages of ADHD-HI, which is a subtype of ADHD that causes hyperactivity and impulsivity, and the links between ADHD-HI, SEEKING behaviors, substance use disorders, and other disorders of mental and emotional dysregulation.</p><p>Follow me on medium, and check out my book series, ‘epidemic’, which can be found on Amazon. Also, please reach out if you have something to add, contest, or contribute. I’m very passionate about updating our understanding of addictive disorders and revolutionizing the treatment of addictive and other mental health disorders.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c91436859331" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Emotions come first: an affective neuroscience perspective on addiction.]]></title>
            <link>https://lonniejay.medium.com/emotions-come-first-an-affective-neuroscience-perspective-on-addiction-b8d793c2c009?source=rss-1f4d2b8be7fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8d793c2c009</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lonnie Jay]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jan 2021 19:25:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T17:14:06.031Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*PTvxg7h4jJw4H4u_pz5XKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jaak Panksepp is best known for his work on laughter in animals.</figcaption></figure><p>Humans are mammals, and the very first primary-process emotional state that all mammals share is SEEKING (Panksepp, 2012). Although the idea that animals feel emotions is something that neuroscience has carefully avoided since the days of B.F. Skinner and behaviorism, Ivan Pavlov himself never discarded the idea that his dogs felt emotion, and even seemed convinced that his dogs contracted a form of PTSD when his lab was flooded. Behaviorism, which carefully avoided talking about the emotional state of animal subjects in any way, was succeeded by the cognitive revolution, which came about during the most recent technological revolution and appropriately likened the human brain to a kind of cognitive computer, with various brain structures functioning as ‘inputs’ and ‘outputs’. Many premier and influential neuroscientists still, to this day, believe that emotions are a uniquely human phenomenon; that emotions are somehow ‘read-out’ by higher cognitive centers in the brain and animals therefore do not feel true emotions (LeDoux, 2016).</p><p>We now know that the hard science simply doesn’t support this idea. As a result, some other powerful and influential neuroscientists like Antonio Damasio have even gone so far as to completely reverse their thinking and admit that the old ‘read-out’ theory of emotions was wrong and that emotions are generated by more evolutionarily ancient brain circuits (Damasio, 2010). What hard science has shown us — and what Jaak Panksepp had been saying for decades before his death — is that emotions are a fundamental property of animal life and an extremely basic, absolutely integral ingredient in any and all consciousness, including the ‘cognitive’ consciousness that underlies every single human thought.</p><p>Jaak Panksepp and his ‘affective neuroscience’ perspective takes the position opposite the behaviorists and the cognitivists that followed them; Panksepp has been stating that emotions are a fundamental property of all animal life for decades, even as his work was marginalized and largely ignored by the mainstream neuroscientific community, which continues to be awash in behavioral and cognitive models of thinking.</p><p>Despite Panksepp’s incredible marginalization and the fact that basically nobody ever talks about his work, many of his ideas are proving to be incredibly prophetic and far-sighted while also being anchored in the hard neuroscience that Freud and others craved but simply didn’t have the technology to access. Hard neuroscience has been largely missing from psychology and psychiatry, where psychoanalysis continues in the form of talk therapy, albeit alongside pharmacotherapy. While talk therapy and pharmacotherapy certainly have their uses, they also have their limits, and many of us feel there is much more to our mental and emotional lives that just seems to be slightly out of reach.</p><p>Panksepp’s invaluable contributions to the field, which are based in the hard neuroscientific work he did studying affective and emotional systems across mammalian species, have the potential to alleviate human suffering on an inconceivable scale, especially given the astounding rates of addiction, anxiety, depression, obesity, and other ‘mental disorders’ that we live with today, which might be better understood as emotional disorders given both the opaqueness of the term ‘mental disorder’ and the ever-mounting evidence that emotional processing and regulation are absolutely critical in our understanding and treatment of these disorders.</p><p>Panksepp, prescient in his identification of the neural circuits underlying social connection and grief among mammals, predicted that understanding and treating brain inflammation would be critical in our future understanding of depression. His prediction has been validated by the recent breakthroughs in psychoneuroimmunology that prove beyond any shadow of a doubt that inflammation in the brain is implicated in all kinds of mental and other disorders, including depression (Nakazawa, 2020). Panksepp also showed astounding foresight in his relatively early discussions of the importance of understanding how the environment affects our genetic expression — but we cannot afford to wait another decade for Panksepp to be proven right yet again. It is time to bring the absolute treasure trove of affective neuroscience to the forefront of the treatment of emotional and mental disorders, including addictive disorders.</p><p>Panksepp describes emotions as ancient survival-valuation systems that have both an affective, emotional, ‘feeling’ dimension and also engender specific actions, like seeking an escape when the FEAR circuit is stimulated. Panksepp did decades of homologous/cross-species mammalian research and testing of the various emotional circuits that he discovered existed deep in the ancient, evolutionarily pre-human, sub-cortical structures that exist in all mammalian brains as primitive forms of consciousness while also providing the support for higher cognitive ‘thinking’ consciousness. Panksepp used probes to electrically stimulate these various emotional circuits and observed the effects of the stimulation on various levels and among different structures in the various circuits, among his other extensive testing and research.</p><p>Panksepp determined that all mammals have 7 primary-process emotional survival-valuation systems. Humans have evolutionarily maintained these more ancient systems because they are the basis of survival, and because we wouldn’t be conscious at all without these systems.</p><p>The 7 primary-process emotional systems, in the order that they evolved, are as follows: SEEKING, RAGE, FEAR, LUST, CARE, GRIEF and PLAY. Panksepp stylizes the primary-process emotions in all caps in order to be extremely clear as to the functions of these fundamental systems, and I will do the same. Panksepp wanted to bring hard neuroscience to psychology, and he recognized that semantics and wordplay should be minimized the best they can.</p><p>While cognitive-behavioral understandings and treatments of mental disorders like addiction are still predominant, and cognitive-behavioral approaches to issues like obesity seem to be becoming even further popularized with applications like NOOM, even the most hardcore cognitive-behaviorists will benefit from discussion of the affective neuroscience approach. While there are plenty of cognitivists and behaviorists, the affectivists seem to be fewer in number. This seems backwards, as all of us can acknowledge the sheer power and influence our emotions have in our experiences of daily living. Indeed, Charles Darwin himself postulated that animals and humans share emotional traits (Darwin, 1872). Appropriately, some call Darwin’s ‘The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals’ Darwin’s forgotten masterpiece.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/492/1*q0MVq0nh_D-p5Eqx-7iKgQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>“the young and the old of widely different races, both with man and animals, express the same state of mind by the same movements” — Darwin, expressions.</figcaption></figure><p>Certainly, Darwin wouldn’t be surprised to learn that the ancient circuits that lie deep in the brain are inherently emotional in nature and more than just instrumental in underlying our conscious experience. Darwin wondered about the evolutionary importance of emotions and facial expressions in the quest for survival. Darwin deduced that animals and humans communicated their feelings of different emotional states with specific facial expressions as a means of adaptive behavior to enhance survival.</p><p>Critical to understanding the scientific truths in the theories of affective neuroscience, humans who are born without the most evolutionarily-recent neocortex still display the 7 primary-process emotions that all mammals display, which further proves that these emotions are both generated in the deeper parts of the brain and not dependent on the more ‘human’ neocortex for experience or expression. On the contrary, if the deeper structures that make up these emotional circuits develop lesions, we cease to display emotionality or meaningful consciousness (Panksepp, 2012).</p><p>Our emotions are survival-valuation systems; they are signals that let us know how we fare on the constant evolutionary quest to survive, thrive, and pass on our genetics. When stimulated electrically or chemically, these emotional circuits feel intrinsically ‘rewarding’ or ‘punishing’ on their own. Mammals don’t enjoy the FEAR that comes with a lack of safety and a threat to their survival — it is a fundamentally punishing signal that both colors our perceptions of the universe with underlying, affectively FEARFUL tones that we feel on a deep level and also gets us to take action to ensure our survival, whether that action be related to fleeing, fighting, or freezing.</p><p>This affect-action dual utility is inherent in each of the primary process emotions; there exists both the feeling-tones that come with a shift in our physiological state and add emotional ‘color’ to our worlds as well as predictable courses of action that the feeling states engender. Stimulation of FEAR means we both feel fear and run away; stimulation of RAGE means we both feel anger and fight, and so on. While the SEEKING system is central to understanding addictive disorders, further groundwork needs to be laid to help us understand these emotional-evaluation systems as a whole.</p><p>We continuously, automatically, and subconsciously evaluate our surroundings every second via a process that Stephen Porges, PhD calls ‘neuroception’. In the process of neuroception, we are evaluating environmental cues that trigger feelings that indicate risks, rewards, danger, and safety. Crucially, the process of neuroception happens at the subconscious level, below the level of our higher-level conscious awareness (Porges, 2011).</p><p>Our nervous systems are constantly evaluating the environment, subconsciously scanning the environment for cues of survival risks and rewards while simultaneously cross-checking these environmental informational cues against our learning/memory systems, all of which co-exist in the same circuits and work together to both generate emotions and allow us to adapt and act quickly to maintain survival based on past experiences. We can feel our physiological state shift automatically when we perceive cues that have an immediate bearing on our survival — like when we suddenly notice a gigantic spider or a $100 bill on the floor.</p><p>All of our emotions are ‘value indicators’ — they are signals that nudge (or shove) us into approaching or avoiding a person, place, or thing. In the case of human life, these primary-process emotions also become our higher-level thoughts, which are more clearly evaluative in nature and (should) aid us in making the decisions that will aid in the attainment of survival-related rewards and the avoiding of the painful experiences that have led to death in our ancestors.</p><p>We feel our bodies react quite differently to the smiling face of a friend at our front door and the cunning smile on the face of a stranger in a dark alley at night. This is due to the process of neuroception, which quickly and subconsciously determines survival-related emotional valuations, triggers the activation of the appropriate emotional circuit, and almost instantly alters our physiology, mobilizing us to act via the fight-flight stress response in the case of the stranger in the alley. Our interaction with the potentially-dangerous stranger might instantly cause overt emotional feelings of FEAR or RAGE depending on the details of the environmental situation — like whether we have someone to protect or not. The change in our physiological state — racing heart, a sudden surge of adrenaline and energy — and the emotional ‘feeling’ tones of the experience are one and the same.</p><p>In the case of the smiling friend at the front door, seeing their smile would trigger the release of dopamine, resulting in the pleasurable, anticipatory energetic anticipation of the SEEKING system as well as the further pleasurable neurochemical cascade that comes with the activation of positive emotional circuits such as CARE and PLAY.</p><p>These emotional survival-valuation systems, when triggered, alter our physiology and create powerful affective feelings that we naturally tend to perceive as rewarding or punishing. The alteration in our physiology further leads us to specific behaviors, and also intrinsically engages and ‘programs’ the learning/memory systems. In other words, our primary-process emotions automatically lead to the secondary-processes of learning and memory, which explains why.</p><p>Here is a fundamental and critical difference between the perspective of the behaviorists and the cognitivists and that of the affectivists. Behaviorists were not interested in the deeper neural nature of emotions and motivation — and besides, they didn’t have the technology to make those connections even if they were. Skinner was content to place the deeper, intrinsic, possibly-emotional processes of the organisms whose behavior they were attempting to understand and control into what he called a ‘black box’.</p><p>The black box of the mind was akin to the ‘black box’ of a DVR machine or modem to a plumber; we might be able to observe the inputs and the outputs, but who can make sense of all the wires and what they do? The brain is undeniably complex. Back then, nobody could seriously study the brain due to a lack of technology, and the mind/brain was indeed a ‘black box’. Behaviorists, and too often the cognitivists that have followed, considered only stimuli and responses as they were associated with rewards and punishments, along with a mysterious process called “reinforcement” that was supposed to glue them all together somewhere in the ‘black box’.</p><p>Back in Skinner’s day, we simply had to be content in saying that we knew the ‘inputs’ (stimuli) and we could observe the ‘outputs’ (behavioral response), which would allow us to say that this stimulus leads to this response, despite the indisputable fact that there is a complex organism in the middle of that stimulus-response equation.</p><p>Thus, the equation is always stimulus-organism-response, and the response of the organism depends on the physiological state of the organism, which depends upon a multitude of factors. The physiological state of the organism is massively impacted by the stimulation or lack of stimulation of various emotional circuits, and this physiology creates a ‘neural platform’ that affects the processes of learning and memory.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/242/1*kFATRqAdeeINiyaGGwnNKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture to illustrate the three processes and how they interact.</figcaption></figure><p>A good example of this is in fear conditioning, where organisms quickly (or sometimes slowly, depending on many factors including genetic predispositions and past stressors or trauma) learn to avoid places that their brains have learned to associate with the fearful, painful, punishing experiences of the past. The emotional state of FEAR is a great teacher sometimes, but so is the emotional state of PLAY.</p><p>In general, Panksepp found that the ‘affective tone’ of our experiences determines how much and how quickly we will learn from those experiences (Panksepp, 2012). Although this is nuanced and varies based on the individual, generally speaking, the stronger our emotions, the more deeply we learn and remember. We can sense this neuroscientific truth on an intuitive level.</p><p>The best teachers are the ones who teach with passion; the teachers who can be contagiously emotional and give rise to passion in their students. The most passionate, emotionally-driven students tend to be the best learners. Again, our ability to get organisms to respond to a stimulus, like the presentation of material for learning in a classroom, is dependent on their physiology, which goes hand in hand with our emotional states.</p><p>The relevance of these primary-process emotions and the secondary-process learning/memory mechanisms to the understanding and treatment of addictive disorders cannot be understated. Understanding various forms of emotional dysregulation and how they give rise to the deep learning of maladaptive addictive behavior is central to the life-process learning disorder model of addiction.</p><p>Sadly, much of our focus these days remains on the cognitive aspects of addictions, which, as we can see here, are actually tertiary-process. We often attempt to treat addictive disorders through the ‘top-down’ focus of traditional talk therapies rather than the ‘bottom-up’ rebalancing of primary-process emotional circuits. If we were to focus on rebalancing the underlying emotional dysregulation, the imbalances in emotional processing that lead to negative physiological states that lead to the maladaptive behaviors that serve as the defining symptoms of many mental disorders, including addictions of all kinds, would be able to be treated at the root of the problem.</p><p>People who develop addictive disorders often report a fundamental inability to regulate their own emotional states. We know that human beings that present with addictive disorders often have other mental disorders that are characterized by emotional dysregulation: PTSD, ADHD, anxiety, depression — these go hand in hand with addictive disorders.</p><p>Emotional states and physiology are intimately linked, and many drugs of abuse mimic chemicals that act directly upon these emotional circuits. A person who is addicted has found an external way to regulate their own physiology, which allows them to feel more in control of their negative emotions, which, feel ‘punishing’ in and of themselves.</p><p>The life-process learning disorder model of addiction takes an affective neuroscience approach in the recognition that addictive disorders develop as a learned response to a fundamental problem of emotional dysregulation. People who develop addictive disorders are not ‘addicts’ who need to ‘hit bottom’ in order to realize they are selfish and need God; they are people who are struggling with emotional dysregulation and have deeply learned to regulate their physiology and therefore emotional states through external sources like drugs.</p><p>A belief in God is a powerful way to cause changes to our own physiology. Prayer directly changes our physiology and therefore can allow us to better regulate our own emotional states, but developing a connection with God is the endgame of the human experience, and connecting with God is not the only way to develop the skills of emotional regulation, which we can also call self-regulation or self-control.</p><p>Talk therapy and other cognitive approaches deal with our thoughts, which are on the tertiary-process level of emotional processing. When talk therapy does work, much of it has to do with the fact that another person is there expressing CARE for us, which helps us to soothe negative emotional states. Stephen Porges, PhD refers to this as co-regulation of physiology: addicted peoples process their emotions with the help of a therapist or counselor. Co-regulation of physiology can lead to self-regulation of physiology, which is the end goal of therapy.</p><p>Co-regulation of emotional states, whether through the 12 step groups or a therapist, can lead to a feeling of safety, which down-regulates or turns down the volume on negative emotional circuits. This allows leads us to a kind of emotional ‘opening up’ through language. Our higher-thinking brain structures are an extension of our emotional structures; they allow us to further evaluate and judge risks and rewards through language. Language is what we use to express our emotions on the highest level; cognitive insights into our emotional states and emotional processing can lead to further cognitive control over our emotional states. These understandings illustrate the importance of a deeper re-balancing of these emotional states, circuits, and processes, which will continue to lead to problematic, maladaptive behavior when dysregulated, no matter how much we talk about ourselves and our problems.</p><p>The goal of talk therapy is often for a person to regain control over their ‘mind’; however, our ‘mind’ is powered by our emotions on an extremely fundamental level; our emotions are what moves us. Our emotions drive us. Our emotions create our motivations; emotions are both the engine of our consciousness and the color of the sky in the mental world that their energies generate.</p><p>Without our primary-process emotional circuits, we cease to be conscious. Without these emotional circuits, we don’t even eat. Therefore, it might be safe to say that talk therapy, when successful, succeeds due to a co-regulation over our thought processes that allows for a re-wiring and re-connection of our emotional-motivational engines to the higher-thinking frontal cortex and related structures. This co-regulation and assistance in re-wiring leads to a learning process that allows for an increase in ‘top-down’ self-regulation over emotional states and eventually cognitive processing, which leads to different emotional drives, different behavior, further learning, and the eventual establishment of new emotional and mental habits.</p><p>Understanding that addicted people are human beings that have fallen into a pattern of self-medication that is underscored by a fundamental dysregulation of emotional processing is crucial in ending the opioid epidemic. Understanding that these dysregulations in primary emotional processing and expression lead to further behavioral maladaptation in the secondary learning/memory systems that result in compulsive habits and addictions of all kinds will lead to breakthroughs in addiction treatment that don’t rely on cognitive, tertiary-process, ‘top-down’ talk therapies — though these therapies should not be dismissed out of hand.</p><p>Emotional processing is at the root of our addictions; it is time for us to discuss the kinds of ‘bottom-up’ treatments and strategies that will restore self-control and self-regulation to addicted people, of which no two are the same. We need more than just talk therapy and pharmacotherapy for these addicted people — we need neurofeedback and transcranial magnetic stimulation to become commonplace, first-line treatments for addictive disorders, among others.</p><p>This was a necessary introduction to Panksepp’s work and the ‘affective neuroscience’ perspective that informs the life-process learning disorder model of addictive disorders. In my next post, I discuss the primary-process emotional SEEKING system in more detail, which is crucial in understanding addictive disorders, along with other mental and emotional disorders of all kinds. The next post can be found here:</p><p><a href="https://lonniejay.medium.com/the-seeking-system-dopamine-and-addictive-disorders-c91436859331">https://lonniejay.medium.com/the-seeking-system-dopamine-and-addictive-disorders-c91436859331</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8d793c2c009" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is addiction? A new paradigm.]]></title>
            <link>https://lonniejay.medium.com/what-is-addiction-a-new-paradigm-355ffb3d993d?source=rss-1f4d2b8be7fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/355ffb3d993d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[addiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lonnie Jay]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Dec 2020 12:51:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-19T16:05:26.503Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What is addiction? Understanding the life-process learning disorder model.</h3><p>What is addiction? Is it a disease? If so, are we experiencing a pathological disease process when we become “addicted” to the naturally-rewarding endorphin release that comes with exercise? Are our addictions to the internet and coffee attributable to a ‘disease’ process too, or are those just habits, despite one (caffeine) having a basis on an actual, physical, chemical dependency?</p><p>When does a habit become an addiction — or an addiction become a disease — and how, exactly? Do various chemicals and drugs, themselves, cause a disease process in only THOSE specific addictions? Is gambling addiction a disease, even though there are no drugs involved? Does that make it a disorder as opposed to a disease? What’s the difference? Habit, addiction, disorder, disease — what do each of these words mean, and, more importantly, what do they look like in the brain?</p><p>As a result of the ongoing global pandemic, rates of alcohol and drug use, both pharmaceutical and otherwise, are skyrocketing, along with obesity. Against a backdrop of stress, fear, isolation, and actual or potential economic scarcity, more and more of us are developing maladaptive coping mechanisms like binge eating, binge drinking, and compulsive use of technology — even when we know that these actions will have adverse effects on our physical and mental health.</p><p>On top of these issues, many of us are succumbing to the depression and anxiety that so commonly co-occur with addictive disorders, and we might find that our bad habits accelerate and gain strength as our mental health deteriorates. Why is this so? What are the TRUE neural underpinnings of these experiences, divorced from any bought-and-sold biases? How can we use this knowledge to strengthen us?</p><p>It has never been more important for all of us to come to a collective understanding of exactly what addiction is, what is isn’t, how it happens, how we free ourselves from it, and how we can avoid it in the future or use our natural addictive tendencies to our advantage. Addiction exacts an almost incalculably high financial and human toll on us here in the United States, as the total economic cost to society is greater than all types of diabetes and all cancers combined. That’s a lot.</p><p>As our life situations complicate and our problems are exacerbated, we might feel that our survivability is at risk. The rampant stressors of 2020 have triggered emotions that are primordial valuation signals. Emotions are e-motive; they come from a Latin root that means ‘causing movement’. Our emotions are motivational. Emotions are evolutionary signals that are designed by nature to get us to assess how we fare on the daily road of survival and moderate our behavior accordingly. Fear is a primal emotion that is designed to get us to do something, NOW — but what can we really do right now?</p><p>As a result of evolution, we mammals are subconsciously wired on an extremely basic level to avoid the negative emotional stressors that often led to pain and death in our ancestors and seek the comforts and pleasures we intrinsically associate with survival. As a result of these ancient emotional valuation systems, stressors are a known trigger for comfort-seeking behavior. Hence, we are all at greater risk of falling into the kinds of impulsive, ritualized, and isolated routines of comfort-seeking despite negative consequences that define addictive disorders — which includes the binge eating that often leads to obesity, as Nora Volkow, the director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse, has so beautifully illustrated with her work.</p><p>The emotionally-driven, binge-style eating that has caused an average of 10–15 pounds of weight gain for Americans during the pandemic looks remarkably similar to drug addiction in the brain. Given the current obesity crisis in America, where the adult obesity rate stands at 42.4 percent, it is clear that our understanding of addiction, in every shape and form, is highly relevant to the health and lives of us all.</p><p>I will be referring to addiction through the lens of the life-process learning disorder model. I’m borrowing the term ‘life-process’ from the thinking and treatments of psychotherapist Stanton Peele, PhD. I’m borrowing the concept of addictive disorders as essentially disorders of learning from the idea that, of all the brain systems implicated in addictive disorders, the impact on the learning and memory functions seem to be the most far-reaching, longest-lasting, and most consequential. The idea that addictive disorders are best understood as disorders of learning are attributable to addiction specialist and author Maia Szalavitz and the incredible neuroscientist Marc Lewis, PhD.</p><p>The works of ‘affective neuroscience’ pioneer and revolutionary genius Jaak Panksepp, PhD are heavily influential in the life-process learning disorder model, as well. Emotions are crucial to understand clearly if we are to understand and best treat addictive disorders as well as the other mental disorders that co-occur with them. Understanding emotional dysregulation is as key to understanding addiction as the learning and memory processes of the brain, and they are deeply, deeply linked. Nobody has done deeper work into mammalian emotional processes than Jaak Panksepp, PhD, yet perhaps nobody has had their work more marginalized by the neuroscientific community.</p><p>The life-process learning disorder model proposes that addictive disorders be understood as occurring on the spectrum upon which they are diagnosed by medical professionals, which is of chief importance. There is a huge difference between mild cannabis use disorder, moderate problem gaming disorder, severe binge-eating disorder, and severe cocaine use disorder, and they should be viewed differently based on social-emotional life context and therefore treated on an individualized basis. The life-process learning disorder model, or LPLD for short, is based upon the idea that our addictions are deeply-learned habitual responses and sources of gratification and security that can be best understood in the context of our deepest and most emotional experiences, our social relationships, and the personal, subjective experiences that define our humanity.</p><p>Basically, it says that there are personal reasons for our addictive behavior that go beyond the simplified, impersonal explanation that the addiction-related behaviors are merely impersonal symptoms caused by the brain disorder that is observable when a person is in an addicted state — no matter what that person is addicted to. The LPLD model brings about much-needed reconciliation between the undeniable disorder-causing brain changes that occur in the cases of ALL addictions, including non-drug behavioral addictions, and the fact that the addicted person is a human being with a deeply nuanced and personal social-emotional background, which provides the invaluable context of life experience to their addiction(s).</p><p>To simplify addiction down to mere neurochemical processes gone awry, which we do by saying addiction is just the result of an impersonal ‘disease process’ is no longer sufficient given the accumulating recent, relevant, and revelatory neurological findings. Current paradigms of addiction, which focus on impersonal brains that we imagine to be interfaced like a computer, devalue life experience and social-emotional context, which is just as important — if not more important — than understanding the temporary underlying state of brain disorder that can be observed in brain scans.</p><p>In order to understand and address the temporary, impulsive or compulsive reward-seeking state that the disordered person becomes stuck in, we must understand that person and their social upbringing and what they’ve experienced in their lives and how that has affected them and stuck with them on an emotional level. At the same time, the LPLD model has room for the notion of relapsing chronicity and other ideas that come from what we currently call the ‘disease’ model of addiction, reserved for when severe addictive disorders overlap with each other and co-occur with other mental disorders.</p><p>Though outdated, I believe the concepts put forth by the disease model still have value, and I believe there’s some room for overlap. I also don’t want to do a disservice to the recovery community by zealously degrading the disease model, the 12 steps, or the total-abstinence approach that comes with them; it is very important to me that I pay respect and homage to the recovery community and the 12-steppers who have transformed their lives despite living without the deep and detailed scientific knowledge that we have now.</p><p>Despite being continuously prosecuted, misunderstood, ostracized, and discriminated against, many of those who have found understanding in the disease model and the peace that comes with personal recovery through the 12 steps have become anchors for their communities. They’ve also inevitably stumbled upon some deep and fascinating neuroscientific truths, which I will certainly post later on.</p><p>I propose that some of the ideas put forth in the disease model do fit with Bill Wilson’s original idea of a ‘spiritual malady’, that our new confirmed understanding of dopamine as being associated with ‘wanting’ rather than ‘liking’ provides a valuable perspective on severe addictions that incorporates the essence of the severe addiction as being beyond the temporary pleasures of the brain and instead existing in the deepest, most emotional, inextinguishable desires of the human mind or spirit. I also propose that the 12 steps are a solution of group spirit-power/willpower that can be explained in neuroscientific language when successful.</p><p>Before we go any further, though, we must answer the question: why do humans use drugs, in the first place, let alone get addicted? Can we stop people from using drugs, or has drug prohibition been doomed to fail from the start, just like alcohol prohibition?</p><p>The idea of severe addictions and alcoholism as being a disease is an ancient one, and one that can be traced back thousands of years and across oceans and societies. Humans have been self-medicating with the various plant medicines we have isolated, reduced into chemicals, and now call ‘drugs’ for thousands of years — since before we were even humans.</p><p>Humans share 98.8% of our DNA with chimpanzees, and chimpanzees are known to self-medicate for intestinal parasites by eating the Aspilia root, which they have been observed seeking out and consuming in nature when necessary. Otzi, a human whose frozen body was recovered near the alps in 1991, lived approx. 3000 years BC and carried in his pouch a travel pharmacy that included a polypore fungus with antibacterial and hemostatic properties, presumably for self-medication.</p><p>Indeed, humans, monkeys, elephants, mongoose, ants — so many species of animal life have been known to self-medicate — including with intoxicants — that entire books have been written about it, and medical professionals have a word for it: zoopharmacognosy, which comes from the greek roots “animal-medicine-knowing”. We know when we need medicine, and we medicate ourselves when we feel the need — or, these days, we call a doctor with the expectation of a filled prescription. To read more about this fascinating phenomenon, check out ‘Intoxication’ by Ronald K. Siegel, PhD.</p><p>If self-medication with plant and therefore chemical medicines is completely natural in all animal life, from an ant to an elephant, the question bears asking: when does self-medication, which is totally natural, become pathological or ‘diseased’? Roman physician Celsus claimed that physical dependence on intoxicating drink was a disease way back in approximately 200 A.D and was perhaps one of the first to delineate between natural self-medication and pathological physical dependence.</p><p>Dipsomania seems to be the first medical term we used for the idea of an addictive disease of addiction, which was coined in the 1800’s. Dipsomania, or ‘thirst-mania’, is characterized by uncontrollable cravings for alcohol and periodic, compulsive binges on alcohol. A dipsomaniac might abstain from alcohol for a while without too much trouble, but as soon as that innate desire for self-medication kicked in, an anti-reward stressor triggered a subconscious reward-seeking response, or the dipsomaniac tasted alcohol again, there seemed to be some kind of internal reaction that was different from that of a ‘normal’ person: uncontrollable cravings and compulsive use would again manifest themselves. Dipsomania was thought to be a chronic, lifelong, cyclical condition based essentially in uncontrollable cravings and alcohol-related compulsions that were unique to the dipsomaniac.</p><p>Nora Volkow is considered the pioneer of the current disease model of addiction, which includes these centuries-old fundamental criteria: uncontrollable cravings, compulsive addiction-related behaviors, and lifelong chronicity. The disease model, which 80% of addiction treatment centers in America use as their dominant paradigm, is based on the dopamine hypothesis, which is based on the idea that all addictions stem from a ‘hijacking’ of the mesolimbic dopaminergic ‘reward system,’ which is a fancy way of saying that all drug addictions are thought to share the same basic biochemical basis and characteristics, which include the progressive development of an initially-pleasurable habit into an addiction that manifests as a behavioral compulsiveness that is simply beyond conscious control and applies to all drugs. That made sense to me for a long time — these exchanges of dopamine occur deep in extremely primitive parts of the brain that are thought to be all but completely beyond our conscious control.</p><p>The disease model that we, as a society, subscribe to in the 21st century, brings with it these ancient ideas of compulsive use, uncontrollable craving, and lifelong chronicity: ‘once an addict, ALWAYS an addict’ is a harmful stereotype in the eyes of some formerly-addicted people but a helpful daily mantra for others. Again, this illustrates the desperate need for reconciliation between life-process and choice-related models of addiction with the disease model. If addiction is a disease, we cannot ignore the incredible rates of ‘spontaneous remission’. We cannot ignore the fact that statistics have shown that an addicted person has the same chance of recovering on their own as they do if they receive treatment, and we cannot ignore the simple fact that the single greatest predictor of relapse is belief in the disease model, itself (Lewis, 2016). These are statistical facts — they are controversial, but they are statistical facts that are easily confirmable with a google search.</p><p>One of the problems with the dopamine hypothesis is that it posits that addiction is a brain disease on a molecular basis yet offers no molecular confirmation, like a blood test that could confirm that one person has the brain disease while another doesn’t. Biomarkers that we might use to confirm the presence of a drug-induced addictive pathogen, like DeltaFosB, occur in the cases of ALL addictions — even behavioral addictions — and only confound us further.</p><p>The dopamine hypothesis postulates a disease process that looks something like this: initial use of a drug causes sensations of pleasure which feel different to a person that is genetically predisposed to ‘the disease of addiction’. Increased subjective experiences of pleasure, which might better be understood as ‘hyper-euphoria’ in those that are genetically predisposed, lead to repeated use of the drug, which leads to the loss of control that characterizes addiction. As we continue to use drugs, our addiction worsens. At some point, we have contracted a brain disease.</p><p>We call this a brain ‘hijack’ because the constant seeking of survival-related rewards like social connections and food are superseded by the ever-increasing drive to use drugs, which work on a neurochemical level to cause feelings of pleasure that are incomparably more euphoric than anything ‘natural’. The dopamine hypothesis for the disease model of addiction is based on the old idea that dopamine is directly and causally associated with pleasure. We now know that this isn’t the case; dopamine is more associated with feelings of ‘wanting’ than the more typical feelings of ‘liking’ that we used to associate with dopamine (Berridge et al, 2016).</p><p>Since the disease model is based on an outdated and disproven theory about the role of dopamine in the brain, it is obvious that the disease model — and, as an extension of this, our understanding of addiction as a whole — is in desperate need of a serious update. To start, calling the dopaminergic system the ‘reward system’ is based in a misunderstanding that dates back to the 1950’s.</p><p>To read about the tenets of ‘affective neuroscience’ and how the affective neuroscience approach differs from traditional cognitive-behavioral views of addictive disorders, click the link to read the next article in the series.</p><p><a href="https://lonniejay.medium.com/emotions-come-first-an-affective-neuroscience-perspective-on-addiction-b8d793c2c009">https://lonniejay.medium.com/emotions-come-first-an-affective-neuroscience-perspective-on-addiction-b8d793c2c009</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=355ffb3d993d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>