<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Louis on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Louis on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:41:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@louismendee/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Museum Feeling]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/i-remember-being-in-the-old-museum-in-liverpool-as-a-kid-and-feeling-so-reassured-by-the-familiar-3363502371d?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3363502371d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caravaggio]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Aug 2019 15:23:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-01T08:46:48.818Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vzGGkPDFMHcqOUs928TmfA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nZobLxE38rU3yHKaLYlB9A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VcBlQIfGKvGy05ohoVtVCQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-FuCPhUQvYsYskG-ajK0Og.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Church of San Luigi dei Francesi, Contarelli Chapel.</strong> <em>The Calling of Saint Matthew</em>, <em>The Inspiration of Saint Matthew, and The Martyrdom of Saint Matthew</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tbneyZSSOfT-dDuxwHM4vg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Church of Sant’Agostino, Cavalletti Chapel. </strong><em>The Madonna of Loreto</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zkSar7dah412FUjENJZdkw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tpRDy-dmS62OZD5fdzJysQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Church of Santa Maria del Popolo, Cerasi Chapel. </strong><em>The Crucifixion of Saint Peter, The Conversion on the Way to Damascus</em></figcaption></figure><p>I remember being in the old museum in Liverpool as a kid and feeling reassured. I don’t know if I was even interested in learning about anything; for me it may have been more about the feeling of being within a set of walls that seemed impervious to the effects of time. I’ve definitely always had a fascination with Natural History, but I think even more than that I loved the assurance that came with knowing that everything would be there the next time I went, and the time after that. In that way, seeing these objects became more of a ritual than anything else; a way of confirming that everything was as it should be. The same old, dark carpet winding through mazes of taxidermied animals, through ice and through forest, and then desert, but always staying close to home in memory. A layout not subject to change. Still.</p><p>I associate Caravaggio with the same. Not that his Art is boring in a dusty museum kind of way, but in the way it elicits a familiar sense of warmth: nostalgia without kitsch. Sentimental, but not sad. When I saw these paintings for the first time it was almost as though I had seen them before, a long time ago, and was recalling a memory that was somehow lost.</p><p>Caravaggio is an artist made eternal by the city, Rome. It immortalises everything it touches. The Midas of cities, except it is time that is crystalised here as well as gold. <br>Churches like the Church of Sant’Agostino were built to express an essential truth about the cosmos; they say something of the eternal harmony of heaven and earth, of a universal balance. In the corner of the church inside the Cavalletti Chapel, the <em>Madonna of Loreto</em> speaks to a similar immemorial notion, and yet, importantly, she is painted in a way that is intrusively honest. With the exception of the unassuming halo that sits atop her head, Madonna is unabashedly <em>ordinary. </em>Barefoot, she appears in uncomfortably close proximity not only to the two pilgrims before her, but to us, the religious viewer. There is no separation. We inhabit the same space as the Virgin, close enough to touch her, and the absence of supernaturalism includes us into a scene that looks and feels real. The frame of the painting is an open door leading to an adjoining room, and we peer through, tentatively, lucky to be in the right place and the right time. Never before in the History of Art had the viewer been given so much access to a divine subject.</p><p>Berger writes how Caravaggio was <em>condemned as a ‘naturalist’ — invasive. intimate. Anti-tradition, intense, no protective space, no proper distance. </em>He spent his short-lived career perfecting the art of painting <em>people</em> as they are — ugly, imperfect and utterly flawed. To him, the contrived, Raphaelesque notions of beauty were tedious. Instead, he used art to express truth.</p><blockquote>“He was the first painter of life as experienced by the popolaccio, the people of the backstreets, les sans-culottes, the lumpen-proletariat, the lower orders, those of the lower depths, the underworld.” — John Berger</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aIFBT_w_FmKjKTgbxFkchg.jpeg" /></figure><p>But truth was considered a coarse substitute while Caravaggio was alive. His art was considered way too direct, if not disrespectful, in its treatment of biblical themes. The viewer is a participant in an intimate congregation, not an audience member to a carefully staged <em>scene, a</em>nd this removed element of detachment is what made Caravaggio so controversial. The fleshy realism contradicts the easeful, idealised grace of classical Renaissance art that was mainstreamed by Raphael and propelled by his followers — the Caraccis and Possins and then the French neoclassicists — who would dictate the artistic agenda throughout much of the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries. The world was not ready for Caravaggio.</p><p>In fact, the only reason the above painting belongs in the National Gallery is that its original owner had failed to sell it at auction. There simply wasn’t a market for these paintings, which Ruskin claimed to represent “<em>horror and ugliness, and filthiness of sin</em>”. The art critic went further in his disdain for Caravaggism, lamenting that the style is “<em>distinguished only by [Caravaggio’s] preference for candlelight and reinforcement of villainy</em>”.</p><p>But Ruskin was wrong on this. Horror, ugliness, and filth are not concocted for some perverse aesthetic value. They are elements of Caravaggio’s own life that he is translating onto canvas. Ruskin may have thought these details to be unnecessarily vulgar, but Caravaggio was merely being honest, breaking down the fourth wall in paint. I doubt he could have stomached to do anything but this.</p><p>Whereas Raphael dined with popes and indulged in all of the fineries of Roman life, Caravaggio spent much of his career on the run for murder. He didn’t live his life in Palazzo reception rooms or in the art studios of the Vatican, but in the darkness of the Roman underworld alongside petty criminals, drunkards and thieves. His life <em>was </em>ugly, so why wouldn’t his art be. He was able to paint the broken, loathsome and sordid with humility because he really did <em>see </em>these people, but more than that, he <em>was </em>them. Berger, again, comments that “<em>[many painters over the centuries following Caravaggio] painted pictures of the same social milieu. But all of them — however great — were genre pictures, painted in order to show other how the less fortunate or the more dangerous lived. With Caravaggio, however, it was not a question of presenting scenes but of seeing itself.”</em></p><p>The frivolity of Rococo and the dreamy idealism of 18th-century picturesque art squandered much of the visual (and emotional) honesty that he, I think, wanted to convey. He wanted to make something human; something recognizable; something permanent. <br>Cezanne remarked that he himself wanted to ‘<em>make of Impressionism something solid and durable like the art of museums</em>’, and every time I hear this quote, I instantly remember the feeling that he is articulating — the feeling of the Liverpool World Museum; and the art of Caravaggio</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3363502371d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mind your Manners]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/mind-your-manners-42e9768eaf6b?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42e9768eaf6b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[painting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renaissance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Jun 2019 18:23:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-21T07:49:12.768Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Uneasy Transitions</h4><blockquote>“…I can say confidently that art has achieved everything possible in the imitation of nature and has progressed so far that it has more reason to fear slipping back than to expect ever to make further advances” — Vasari</blockquote><p>The term ‘Renaissance’ as a historical time stamp is vague, but it does serve to describe a certain ‘rejigging’ of Western thought. I read somewhere that it would have actually occurred to the well-educated humanists at the time that they were inhabiting a peculiar, exciting age of rediscovery and reinvention. What they could not have understood, however, is that they were concocting the precursory foundations of what future centuries would perceive to be ‘Western culture’, creating the methods by which subsequent generations would relate to and narrate history.</p><p>One of these people is still known to us today as Giorgio Vasari. He bears the title ‘Founder of Art History’, which is quite the impressive feat. It is not that others before had never viewed Art as a note-worthy discipline, but it may be true that they had never attempted to explain the phenomenon of Art using historical methods or formulate the specific criteria to assess it. <br> <br> A student of Michelangelo, Vasari saw the Renaissance as a three-stage rediscovery of the artistic excellence of antiquity. For him, changes in artistic output from the 14th century onwards could be seen as an up-hill progression starting from humble beginnings through to the dizzying heights of the High-Renaissance — the age of Michelangelo. Although Vasari used naturalism as a measuring stick to determine the merits of visual art, he spoke of the work of Michelangelo, Raphael and Leonardo as transcending mere ‘imitation of nature’. In reaching perfection, these three men had surpassed the flawed, imperfect natural world to create an art that was more beautiful than nature; an art that was unparalleled in all of history; an art that was, simply, <em>perfect.</em></p><p>“The three fine arts have been brought to a state of complete perfection”, Vasari claimed in the <em>Lives of the Artists </em>(1568). How, then, was an artist living near the tail-end of the 16th century supposed to contribute, if all that could be achieved in Art had already been achieved, and to devastating effect? The answer(s) to this question was born out of what Gombrich calls the ‘Crisis of Art’, in which artists anxiously pondered what progress looked like in a post-Michelangelo world, and <em>Mannerism </em>was one such answer. I have already written about how the Mannerists<em> </em>have not been well favoured by history — about how their search to replicate and even out-do the work of Michelangelo led historians to decry what they saw to be jittery, strained attempts to compete with the old master. But modern art audiences are more empathetic. We can relate to the feeling of being at the end of the road, with no real sense of what could, or <em>should</em>, come next. We can understand why an artist would feel pressured to be inventive, to seek out ways to shock and push boundaries; in fact, these are things that we automatically associate with art practice in the 21st century.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Zn_V6XAQEo5jdB1wm9ntYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The purification of the Temple, 1580, Jacopo Bassano.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RKbljgDwol2_att2mM3RQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Christ washes the feet of the Disciples, 1575–80, Tintoretto</strong>. Gombrich wrote about how critics of Tintoretto complained that his art was “…so crude that his pencil strokes show more force than judgement and seem to have been made by chance” He explains, “[this] is a reproach which from that time onwards has often been made against modern artists…for these great innovators in art have often concentrated on the essential things and refused to worry about technical perfection in the usual sense. In periods like that of Tintoretto, technical excellence had reached such a high standard that anyone with some mechanical aptitude could master some of its tricks. A man like Tintoretto wanted to show things in a new light, he wanted to explore new ways of representing the legends and myths of the past.”</figcaption></figure><p>A static energy exudes from these paintings, and mystery transpires not only through the use of dark hews and tense lighting. Without any knowledge of the biblical story being told, the viewer is immediately aware that trouble of some sort is afoot. There is a distinct feeling that a storm is brewing; an uneasiness fills the room. The figures are enclosed within an interior space and yet the slithered openings to the outside world make them seem vulnerable. But to what?</p><p>The cleansing of the temple recounts a biblical episode in which Christ, whip in hand, expels the merchants and traders occupying the Temple of Jerusalem.</p><blockquote><em>And making a whip of cords, he drove them all out of the temple, with the sheep and oxen. And he poured out the coins of the money-changers and overturned their tables. And he told those who sold the pigeons, “Take these things away; do not make my Father’s house a house of trade.” </em><strong><em>John, New Testament</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the money changers, and the seats of them that sold doves, And said unto them, It is written, My house shall be called the house of prayer; but ye have made it a den of thieves. </em><strong><em>Matthew, New Testament</em></strong></blockquote><p>Although his halo is dimmed, Christ carries an authority that screams from left to right. His rage is amplified by the red drapery that billows from the ceiling like an angry cloud of lighting, and there is a fearful tone that is encapsulated perfectly by the frantic gestures of a child, who is surprisingly the central component of the work. The emotional charge of this painting is undeniable; this is a significant departure from the Art of still, composed harmonies. There is something of Raphael&#39;s <em>Transfiguration </em>about it; unsettled, perhaps even <em>unsure</em>.</p><p>Although I don’t know whether these paintings can altogether be described as ‘Mannerist’, they definitely draw on similar tools, especially in the dramatic use of light effects, the atypical compositions and the effective suggestion of movement — qualities that infuse the work of Greek-born El Greco, who more obviously embodies the hallmarks of the genre (but in an uncomparably unique way).</p><p>The TATE describes Mannerism as <em>a style of art and design characterised by artificiality, elegance and sensuous distortion of the human figure.</em> Artists of this time exaggerated the Renaissance tendency for idealisation in a way that sacrificed naturalism, balance, and rationality. By adhering less to the laws of representation, they allowed themselves to think more — arguably in a strained, perhaps forced, way — about <em>style, </em>and about techniques that could enhance the overall effect of a painting. They found that by having a looser relationship to observable reality, they could experiment with ideals of beauty and grandeur while developing an ability to startle and evoke.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hKGiUAAAfYQx-BIPpA_fFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Christ driving the Traders from the Temple, 1600, El Greco.</figcaption></figure><p>Art historians, however, decried what they perceived to be overly stylised, frustrated paintings that were too preoccupied with trying to outdo the previous generation of artists. I can kind of see why some of the criticism is justified, but to me, the work of El Greco is far more interesting, and far more memorable, than a lot of the artists who preceded him. Yes, El Greco’s interpretation of <em>Christ driving</em> <em>the Traders from the Temple </em>is kind of ridiculous — figures tumble, twist and bend around Christ like dancers on a stage in this unnatural scene, which is only made tenser by the vividness of colour, the business of the composition, and the electric light effects that shock through the paint — but it is nevertheless an incredibly powerful image that baffles and amazes in equal measure.</p><p><em>“Only after the first world war, when modern artists had taught us not to apply the same standards of ‘correctness’ to all works of art, was El Greco’s art rediscovered and understood”, </em>Gombrich says, which makes sense to me: El Greco’s paintings look more ‘modern’ than the neoclassical masterpieces of artists that came over 200 years later, and they certainly look out of place here in the National Gallery, where they sit alongside works by Titian and Veronese. In fact, the difficulty in contextualising his work is the principle reason why El Greco is one of my favourite artists of all time: originality and individuality are qualities that most of us now look for in great artists, even if it makes them difficult to box in to a particular movement or school, and El Greco had both of these in spades. <em>“You must study the Masters but guard the original style that beats within your soul and put to sword those who would try to steal it”</em>, he boldly asserted. And his Art makes you believe that he meant it: there are few, if any, artists of the 16th century who developed such a confident and unique style that broke with tradition so boldly.</p><p>The History of Art would have undoubtedly turned out very differently if the critics of El Greco’s time had been more receptive to his work. But, alas, the Mannerist Period came out of favour relatively quickly. In its stead was born a more robust movement made up of artists who followed in the footsteps of Caravaggio — the man who would bring the art of the High-Renaissance through to a stark and decisive end. The Baroque era transformed painting, sculpture and architecture to an extent not seen since the early Renaissance, but this time it would be Rome, not Florence, firmly at the centre of this change. But to understand this period it is also vital to comprehend the political and religious upheavals of the 16th century that made it necessary; because as we know, Art does not exist in a vacuum, and it can arguably be understood on the basis of the sociological and environmental conditions in which it was created. In understanding the work of this period, I, therefore, want to look more into how society-at-large was changing in the early 1500s — or more specifically, post-1517, when people in Western Europe began to witness one of this most important cultural changes of the last 1000 years, which would change the course of History, and therefore our story of art, forever: the rise of Protestantism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42e9768eaf6b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[More than meets the eye]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/more-than-meets-the-eye-91e26c3a1253?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91e26c3a1253</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[veronese]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[painting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 May 2019 21:48:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-30T07:50:12.266Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Digging deep</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_S8yVEdzfsY7maW5PT6vIw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Think about the number of faces that a painting must have met in its lifetime. About the walls from which it hung; the countries it has visited – the miles travelled by sea, plane, or perhaps even foot. Think about the times it may have been rescued from war, vandalism, or from ageing. About the changes in value, the different currencies exchanged, and the reasons for purchase. The biography of an object is often more intriguing than the object itself, and yet it is the thing that is most often ignored when we come to look at a painting in a gallery.</p><p>Take the Rokeby Venus for example. It is one of Velasquez’s most famous paintings and remains one of the most well studied paintings in the history of art. There is much to be said about the artistic merit of the painting, but its biography is just as impressive: it was effectively stolen by a British art dealer, who decided to take advantage of Napoleon’s Spanish invasion by ‘acquiring’ expensive artworks that he could sell back home.“<em>In troubled waters we can catch the best fish</em>”, Buchanan wrote in his memoirs, years after his employees smuggled the masterpiece out of Spain and flogged it for £500 to John Morritt of Rokeby Hall. Morritt, in turn, sold it to the National Gallery in 1913, and 5 years later, the painting was attacked with a meat cleaver by notorious ‘Slasher Mary’, a suffragette who would later lead the women’s branch of Mosley’s British Union of Fascists. “<em>I have tried to destroy the picture of the most beautiful woman in mythological history as a protest against the Government for destroying Mrs. Pankhurst, who is the most beautiful character in modern history</em>,” she wrote after her arrest. None of this information is essential knowledge to appreciate the aesthetic of this painting, but it certainly helps you to understand that its past forms a small part of an interconnected web of distinct but inextricably linked histories. It helps you to situate the painting into a broader, historical context of colonialism, capitalism, and even feminism, which are phenomena that inadvertently but inevitably become infused with the life of an artwork.</p><p>Even the most unassuming of paintings take on a new life when they are seen in conjunction with their biography. I found this out for myself a few weeks ago when I arrived in room 11 of the National Gallery, which houses Veronese’s ‘Four Allegories of Love’. I’ve got to be honest: <em>The Allegories </em>aren’t the easiest of paintings to engage with; a considerable amount of classical knowledge is required to understand the meaning behind the work and the intention of the artist. <em>Challenging </em>pieces like this served an essential purpose in art history by re-affirming the perceived superiority of an elite, wealthy class of patrons. They were bought as a status symbol by people who wanted to prove their humanist credentials, and an ability to ‘decode’ the cryptic clues planted in works such as <em>The Allegories</em> allowed buyers to impress important visitors by demonstrating connoisseurship and intellect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jiReHdVtuug7XzKa7dbHFg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Happy Union, Veronese. </strong>The names of all 4 of these paintings have been made up over the years, we don’t know when they were painted, and we don’t know who they were painted for. We can, however, make certain inferences about the paintings based on the presence of certain art historical themes. Here, a semi-naked woman hands another woman a crown of leaves, while a fully naked baby tugs impatiently on her robes. What any of this means is debatable, but art historians have elucidated some of it: a crown of leaves signifies virtuous love, so it would make sense for the lady holding it to be Venus, goddess of love. The naked child could, then, be Cupid, with the dog representing marital fidelity, the olive branch representing concord, and the horn of plenty representing prosperity.</figcaption></figure><p>The allegorical details depicted in the 4 paintings are not what I want to write about today. Instead, what is of more immediate interest to me is their history, or at least the history that is currently hypothesised.</p><p>I often have to remind myself that the paintings in the gallery have not always resided here. Some may have been family heirlooms — passed down to younger generations over centuries before being sold — whereas others have only ever been owned by the state, whether it be in the UK or elsewhere in Europe. Some of the paintings may have only ever known the confines of a gallery, but others will have adorned the walls of country homes, villas, castles, palaces and churches across the world. Some, importantly, would have even been created with these particular spatial contexts in mind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7lxcksgvK_TR4Ix7m2UJJA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Scorn, Veronese.</strong> This one is a little easier to interpret; Cupid bludgeons a man with his bow, presumably for making an inappropriate advance to the lady on the left with her boobs out.</figcaption></figure><p><em>The Allegories </em>were first documented in the castle of Prague in an inventory of the imperial collections, but nobody knows how Emperor Rudolf II acquired them. For a while, it was assumed that the 4 paintings were made for a ceiling, and the oblique perspective of each (i.e, the figures seem to be at the top of a slope that comes down towards the viewer) certainly supports this theory. But alternative hypotheses have arisen since the discovery of a preparatory sketch that Veronese himself created.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qvNy1p8nbCkbRPxtbEPWDw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Respect, Veronese. </strong>Cupid makes another appearance in this one, but this time he seems to be leading a soldier towards a naked sleeping woman. He ‘respectfully’ resists temptation.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*LHp_D2E0NOiRSIjSnHHB9w.png" /><figcaption>This study can be found in The Met, New York. Happy Union, Unfaithfulness and Respect are sketched down the right-hand side. Scorn can be identified in the top left quarter.</figcaption></figure><p>The letters have faded slightly, but you can just make out the letters G, B, A, C and F arranged almost like an isosceles triangle above the <em>Respect</em> sketch. It’s still up for debate what the letters stand for — it might even be that they have no relation whatsoever to the <em>Allegories </em>series — but the letters have nevertheless caused huge amounts of speculation. It has been argued that they represent the positioning of the individual paintings relative to each other on a ceiling, with A, C, G &amp; F indicating <em>Happy Union</em>, <em>Unfaithfulness</em>, <em>Scorn </em>and <em>Respect, </em>respectively. What ‘B’ would stand for in this scenario, however, is a mystery, and why letters D &amp; E are missing is also a question with no convincing answer: perhaps they represent paintings by other artists working in collaboration with Veronese, or compositions that were still in the planning stage, or maybe, just maybe, we’re thinking too much about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/762/1*ZIzLMifCAhJV_a8ZG3sRTw.png" /><figcaption>Maybe Veronese was just innocently leaving himself a little abbreviated shopping list, without realising that he was creating an unsolvable puzzle that future historians would desperately attempt to solve.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iRDM12kiTdNAcTLl4H-GQg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Unfaithfulness, Veronese. </strong>This one is similarly ambiguous. The nude woman holds a letter (presumably a love letter) in her left hand, which she is about to give — or has just received — from one of the suitors. The raised, central position that she occupies has been argued to be a rare suggestion of feminine strength, but this may just be an example of well-intending modern revisionism.</figcaption></figure><p>Another, more recent, theory postulates that the letters don’t indicate the spatial arrangement of paintings, but rooms of a Veneitan residence. This would make sense, because the typical renaissance home in Venice followed a specific plan in which a long, central <em>portego</em> (the main living space) was symmetrically flanked on both sides by adjoining rooms. A, C, and F could indicate three rooms to the right of the central <em>portego </em>(B) containing three of the paintings, whereas G could represent a room — across from room A — that contained the fourth. Regardless of whether this is true or not, it seems to be widely accepted that the paintings would have been made as a result of a private commission for an intimate setting, perhaps in the villa of a newlywed couple.</p><p>And when you picture them within this setting, you immediately realise how limiting the space of a gallery is: art intended for dimly lit churches, extravagant royal residences or, in this case, light, open-plan villas are stripped of the spatial context that enables them to really <em>work</em>. Of course, we can try and imagine how they would have looked in their original setting, but this is only as good as imagining the presence of mozarella when eating a slice of pizza — it will never be as good as the real thing, but it is probably better than nothing. A Caravaggio painting, for example, is going to look pretty good regardless of where it is shown, but it is never going to compete with an original masterpiece that remains <em>in situ </em>in a church, where the artist would have paid close attention to the precise entrance of light in order to maximise the effect of shadow and countour. And the same could surely be said of <em>The Allegories.</em> Deciphering the mystery of Veronese’s scribbles may seem like a futile exercise — and is probably impossible — but experts will continue to try in the hope that one day it will allow people to enjoy the paintings even more, in a way that (at least partially) satisfies the original intention of Veronese and his commisioner(s).</p><p>But whether or not galleries choose to engage with the complex histories of their art is a separate question altogether. For example, it’s understandable that the National Gallery does not loudly advertise that the Rokeby Venus is essentially a looted object. Greece’s claim to the Elgin Marbles has opened a can of worms, and British museums are being forced to wrestle the history of the British Empire and the theft of priceless artefacts from indigenous communities across the world. Indeed, facing up to history is often a precarious act for institutions such as the National Gallery (which is why they often don’t bother to do it), but that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t encourage them to do so: a culture of transparency about the real history of our museums’ objects could stimulate interesting and constructive conversations about the way that we relate to art and the cultural narratives that shape our lives, and I personally think it could do a lot to reverse the dwindling visitor numbers that many galleries are currently contending with.<br> <br> It’s easy to recognize museums as places of stagnant permeance, but by deeply engaging with the dynamic, convoluted histories of the objects they contain, they could be transformed into progressive centres of social influence — places where we are encouraged to challenge preconceived norms and think objectively and critically about the society we inhabit. Say what you want about Slasher Mary, but by vandalising one of the country’s most prized paintings, she provoked engaging conversation about the objectification of women in Art and in society-at-large — conversations that the gallery itself could have had a role in initiating if it had dared to dig a little deeper.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/465/0*9j2PvbGlofRS7ZXO.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91e26c3a1253" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is Art Racist?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/is-art-racist-14d0bcb0cea4?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14d0bcb0cea4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sculpture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Apr 2019 17:24:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-14T22:01:12.805Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>White is Right</h4><p>I know a lot of people who like art but are intimidated by spaces like the National Gallery. There is a lot of pressure when you walk into a place as grandiose as the National, and you suddenly feel unequipped to perform in the ‘correct’ way. How are you supposed to look at a painting? How long for? Do I like? And am I wrong for liking it? There can be a lot of insecurity when it comes to engagement with pre-modern art because we can assume that there are certain keys to understanding that we are not privy to. My friend Hidigo thinks the art here is ‘bougie’, and she’s essentially right: most of the paintings here were created by aristocrats for other aristocrats, who had clear motives for keeping the discipline of art as elitist as possible.</p><p>The commodification and academicization of art enabled the bourgeoisie to reaffirm their sense of elitism, and this co-option of art by a wealthy, European cabal resulted in a barrier of access in terms of both money and education. An appreciation of art is therefore not merely an exercise of aesthetic judgement: it is a status symbol like any other — an indicator of refined taste, sophistication, and wealth. Of course, much of the modern art of the 20th century came a long way to challenging some of this, and big steps were made to make art more accessible: in Russia, there was the rise of constructivism and, later, socialist realism, and in the US, edgier post-war movements sought to take art out of the gallery and into the gritty streets of New York. Street art was a radical subversion to ‘high-art’, and the rise of artists such as Basquiat — a young black man from Brooklyn with no wealth— was a confusing hit to an art establishment that seemed to be losing more and more control.</p><p>The power of Basquiat as a historical figure cannot be overstated enough in my opinion. His art is powerful and soul-shattering, and what I enjoy so much about his work is the way that the exhibition setting can enhance and give meaning to that power: Basquiat’s life work has been exhibited in the best galleries across the world — in London, New York, Paris, and Rome — and the very act of having his paintings displayed in these exclusionary and, yes, white spaces is an empowering thing. I saw his work displayed at the Louis Vuitton institute in Paris and I couldn’t help but smile throughout the entire exhibition; brash and unfiltered, it bursts out from the lifeless white of the wall and asserts itself forcefully in the eye of the viewer. A lot of his art is boldly enthused with the trauma of racism, and as it hangs unapologetically before me, I can’t help but be struck by how invasive it is — how invasive he is — in a space that has such a strong historical pretext of elitism. This feeling of infiltration and the contrast between the painting and the wall that it occupies is jarring.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1EhbAODaqG6TvmGRjKQUuQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The root of this tension, though, originates in the formulation of what we perceive as ‘high culture’. Classical art, music, and opera all occupy an elevated position in the Western ranking of art forms for reasons that are deeply problematic. My personal pet peeve relating to this is how the University Challenge music round is ALWAYS on classical music, as if it is culturally superior to more-accessible genres. Why should Bach be favoured over Beyonce in the pantheon of musical greatness lol? And while you’re at it, name a Bach song that is better than Me, Myself and I… I’ll wait…</p><p>Seriously though, the pervasive nature by which we sanctify classicism in the arts is actually quite dangerous and has resulted in our historical institutions being inaccessible places that many do not feel comfortable in. And it’s not just about classism. Western obsession with antique art has a racial component that is often deliberately ignored by our public museums and galleries. Indeed, the marble statues that we are so used to seeing in the biggest and best museums across the world played a big role in formulating a construct of whiteness during the 18th and 19th centuries; art critics and historians used the artistic produce of the Graeco-Roman world in order to develop a false history of the West, in which the ‘aesthetic perfection’ of works such as <em>The Apollo Belvedere </em>became linked to notions of racial purity and racist standards of beauty. The white of marble became synonymous with ideals of purity, civility and enlightenment, and our public museums helped to cultivate a belief that the ‘high-art’ of the ancient West was above the colourful, garish, primitive art of Africa and the East.</p><p>Johann Joachim Winckelmann was one of the most influential figures in perpetuating an illusion of antiquity that was centred around the idealization of whiteness. Around the same time, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe talked about how <strong>“</strong>savage nations, uneducated people, and children have a great predilection for vivid colors” while “people of refinement avoid vivid colors in their dress and the objects that are about them”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*El9l0jriIAtgpsODKy6ddA.jpeg" /><figcaption>This is a neo-classical statue of the Greek goddess Hebe from an exhibition in the Hermitage, Amsterdam. The neoclassicists sought to replicate the graceful beauty of ancient sculpture, but contrastingly, the white aesthetic was paramount to their work.</figcaption></figure><p>The funny thing is, though, is that their celebration of white marble was massively erroneous. It’s still not widely talked about by most museums that Greek and Roman artists actually painted the statues that we now celebrate for being pristinely white. That’s right, the fetishization of white stone by modern society is based on a fallacy that ancient craftsman purposely created sculpture without colour. But in reality, the pigments have actually just faded over the millennia, leaving us with bare, naked figures that years ago would have been brimming with colours.</p><p>Now, this was quite the gag for our Victorian ancestors, who by the time of this discovery had become accustomed to the significance that classical sculpture denoted. Because the art had become entwined with ideas around self, identity and superiority, many revolted against the new evidence and agonised over what it could mean. “I feel it <em>here</em> that they were never coloured”, Rodin was supposed to have said, demonstrating how viscerally the white, western mindset was connected to the manufactured connotations of classical history. Even into the 20th century, the establishment sought to continue with the delusion and refused to come to terms with this horrifying truth; and in the 1930s, the British Museum scrubbed the Elgin Marbles until they gleamed and glistened, their colourful past wilfully forgotten.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EvzKMXyjwdZv7Ig0SMv5ZA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rodin was greatly inspired by the Parthenon and its creator, Phidias. “No artist will ever surpass Pheidias,” he said. “The greatest of the sculptors, who appeared at the time when the entire human dream could be contained in the pediment of a temple, will never be equalled.”</figcaption></figure><p>But why is it so difficult for us to accept that we have been lied to — to accept that Western adoration of antique art is a symptom of environmental conditioning? <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/10/29/the-myth-of-whiteness-in-classical-sculpture">In this amazing Margaret Talbot’s article</a>, Mark Abbe suggests that we need to ask ourselves “Who benefits?” He states, “If we weren’t benefitting, we wouldn’t be so invested in it. We benefit from a whole range of assumptions about cultural, ethnic, and racial superiority. We benefit in terms of the core identity of Western civilization, that sense of the West as more rational — the Greek miracle and all that. And I’m not saying there’s no truth to the idea that something singular happened in Greece and Rome, but we can do better and see the ancient past on a broader cultural horizon.”</p><p>The point is, that this is not <em>just</em> about art. There are real consequences to the peddling of false, historical narratives; <em>The Apollo Belvedere</em> is famous not only because of it’s artistic merit, but because it has been a focal point for racists throughout the centuries. 18th-century scholars obsessed over it and believed that they could derive the formula for beauty from its ‘perfect’ facial ratios. This pseudo-science manifested into the Cephalic Index and the taxonomizaiton of human beings into distinct categories of race, in which whiteness — and the phenotypic features of white people — were held supreme. Later on in 1930s Germany, this science was legitimized in order to justify the supremacy of the Aryan race.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/0*oEPHdJGeErB9gS8E.jpg" /><figcaption>Rolf Michael Schneider of Ludwig Maximilian University: “Without the classical tradition, the Nazi visual ideology would have been rather different.” … “The perfect Aryan body, the white color [of the marble], the beautiful, ideal white male: to put it very bluntly, it became a kind of image of the <em>Herrenrasse </em>or ‘master race’ — that’s what the Nazis called themselves and the Germans.”</figcaption></figure><p>Hitler and Mussolini’s affection for classical sculpture — and loathing for the ‘degenerate’ art of the modern era — was born out of a deeply distorted, white-washed interpretation of European history. Even today, neo-nazi group Identity Evrope utilizes this art to signify their movement. They wrongly assume that they are the ancestral descendants of a superior people. They believe that they are the products of an unblemished Caucasian lineage that is strong and unbroken, and above all, white as marble. Clean and colourless, they think of their imagined heritage as being isolated from the rest of sullied humankind, and they revel in historical fallacies as a way to claim a stake in the world.</p><blockquote>“Who are we? We aren’t just white. White is a checkbox on a census form. We are part of the peoples, history, and spirit of Europe. This legacy stands in front of us as a gift and a challenge. For what our ancestors took for granted we must discover and we must renew.” Richard Spencer, 2017.</blockquote><p>The manufacturing of false histories is surely one of the most singularly damaging human specialities, which is why the role of our museums and galleries in fostering a healthy relationship with the past is so crucially important. The way we relate to our history — to art — is what makes our society, so it is imperative that we use public institutions as a way to dispel detrimental myths, and to cultivate spaces that help us to contextualise our lived experiences. Part of this must include a real effort by places like the National Gallery to explore the reasons for such a lack of diversity, and to explain, for example, why people of colour are all but erased in the ‘story of Western art’ — not only as artists, but also within the paintings themselves, where black people are more than often depicted as slaves or servants. It must include an active attempt by the British Museum, as well, to reconcile its colonial past — yes, by repatriating the Elgin Marbles, but also by demonstrating how our relationship with historical narratives can transcend the walls of a mere museum. This might be a big ask: challenging ingrained assumptions is a rebellious thing to do, but it is necessary in order to make our perceived history a little less white.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14d0bcb0cea4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tide is Turning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/tide-is-turning-33f3d8c4bf84?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33f3d8c4bf84</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[impressionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renaissance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[titian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[painting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Apr 2019 17:44:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-06T17:45:40.356Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reflections on Society</h4><p>I’m not in the Gallery this week. I’m on a beach on the south coast of Lanzarote, watching how light and water twirl and tumble in unison. Ripples of moving shadows oscillate as light peppers the outer crest of waves; there is a constant flurry of movement and activity. Hold your gaze at a single viewpoint and you can see how the little explosions of light flicker on and off like pixels on a moving blue screen. A blue that dances with the sun to create variations of azure and sapphire, retreating further back into cobalt, deep into navy, touching the pastel of the sky and the plush powder blue of the clouds overhead. Nature’s canvas is solid and formless all at once, made amorphously resolute by rays of gold as though it were lava, as if it exudes energy, electricity. These reflective tricks played by water are hypnotic to my eyes that are bored by the dull of London and invigorate everything else around me. How lush, for example, is the green of the distant palm leaf, up there on the coast? It drips into the palette of the ocean like a pen into ink, bursting with colour.</p><p>To depict light in pigment is something artists have contended with for centuries. Think of Van Gogh’s starry night and the swirling tendrils of moonlight; of Monet’s waterlilies, floating peacefully on a late summers day; and of Caravaggio, whose use of shadowy contours provided a spotlight-of-sorts for his subjects to perform under.</p><p>An understanding of the workings of light, and colour, evolved in 16th century Venice while a compulsion for design emerged in Florence. It’s hard to say why or when these distinct practices started to diverge, but I like to think of it romantically: could it be that the City of Canals gifted its artists with an acute sensitivity to how colour acts with a fickle changeability in the eye? The distorted image of a grand city in water, a liquid impression of reality, rippling down below like a molten mirror. Could it have pushed the Venetians towards an art that was equally as beguiling, equally as responsive to the trickery of light?</p><p>Whatever the reasons, artists from Venice grew to see colour as a more fundamental constituent of visual art, an integral fixture of equal if not more importance to the overall design itself. We’ve already seen this dichotomy at its earliest stage with Bellini and Mantegna, but this polarisation would later expand into two distinct lineages of art practice that would derive importance from differing qualities, creating a novel series of questions for humanists of the new age to think about: is the goal of art more important than its method, or are some practices inherently more valuable than others? Why? And what is the key to creating paintings that look even more like reality? Is there a way of transferring what I see onto canvas? How?</p><p>For the Venetians following in the footsteps of Bellini, answering these questions meant approaching art in a different way. The evolution of a distinct Venetian style was of course helped by Venice being the most significant maritime trading city of the Western world. And as Europe’s link with the East, it exported and imported a vast wealth of precious material, including pigments that were sourced from places as far away as Afghanistan, China and India. Venetian artists were introduced to Ultramarine for the first time — an intense blue ground from lapis lazul — and were fascinated by the rich tones, hews and exotic contrasts that surrounded them in market stalls around the city.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fiDdmMw5caT-RJSN_K_C-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Bacchus and Ariadne, 1520–1523, Titian. </strong>Ultramarine blue was the most expensive blue pigment that could be bought. This painting would have been a clear show of wealth that — in combination with mythological references that only elite intellectuals would have caught — proved the owner’s high status.</figcaption></figure><p>On a technical level as well, artists such as Titian came to reject the Roman insistence on vigorous design, often working directly on canvas and layering colours as they built up the composition from scratch. Abandoning lines used to define clear parameters of form, Titian painted in a more spontaneous way and worked with loose, impulsive brushstrokes that are more easily characterised as <em>expressive</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aaNsSvNnDzpqOtsBQoa-WQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The Death of Actaeon, 1559–75, Titian</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Take this painting of Diana and Actaeon. It’s unlike anything we have seen thus far but looks much, much more familiar. The casual, improvised way in which white paint has been used to highlight the stream; the softened imprecise outlines of subjects; and the wild, interwoven mesh of tangled browns, greens, and oranges — it all serves (despite the very traditionally Renaissance subject matter) to remind the modern observer of the style we are accustomed to and hold dearly. Specifically, the art of French Impressionism.</p><p>And this is why Titian is such an interesting case study for me. The fact that I feel more of an immediate affinity for his work over that of Raphael or even Michelangelo is surely indicative of how influential the art of the late 20th century has been on modern sensibilities. Monet, Pissarro, Degas, and co. transformed our creative ideals and invented a new set of standards by which art is evaluated, and the modernists of the 20th and 21st centuries have done little to discourage our appreciation of their goals and aesthetic. My guess would be that most people who consider themselves to be marginally interested in Art would prefer the works of Titian over Michelangelo, not due to an inexpiable magnetism but because Titian’s paintings align more with our prevailing artistic culture, which I would surmise is still heavily shaped by the Impressionists and their dutiful search for honesty.</p><p>Michelangelo, however, would be appalled by the Impressionists. He pioneered an art of intense definition that focused on well-designed human forms and would have looked at a painting such as <em>Impression Sunrise </em>in complete bafflement, not only because of the subject matter, but because of its vague incoherence, the looseness of the brushstrokes and the ambiguity of physical form. In comparison though, I can’t help but think that Titian would have felt more at ease. The female models depicted in Renoir’s <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b5/Pierre-Auguste_Renoir_-_Torse%2C_effet_de_soleil.jpg">N<em>ude in the Sunlight</em></a><em> </em>and Titian’s <a href="https://cdn.kastatic.org/ka-perseus-images/0e19fe51ace26b9b5cfd9d02729d1425b9c34c0b.jpg"><em>Pastoral </em></a><em>Concert, </em>for example, are separated by over 300 years of history and yet there is no denying their relation: there is a clear inheritance of a more intuitive looser style of painting that, importantly, is enthusiastic about capturing the effects of light on flesh to convey a ‘truer’, albeit more sensuous, account of reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WvgLdYXLCek7hLgLw7tTKw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Afternoon at the Beach in Valencia, 1904, Joaquín Sorolla. </strong>Sorolla was heralded by none other than Monet as the ‘Master of Light’. He continued in a similar vein to the Impressionists but with a more acute interest in the varied effects of light — a post-impressionist style often known as Luminism.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0vMDbfupqertcf2f1OR5QQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The white boat, Javea, 1905, Joaquín Sorolla. </strong>Sorolla was such a great artist because he was able to separate his previously conceived notions of what something should look like from the reality in front of his eyes. He painted what he saw. Not an unusual concept for us now, but it would have been in the Renaissance. Titian was one of the first artists to start the shift towards a more naturalist form of art, and one way he did so was by paying more attention to light, even adding ground up bits of glass to his pigment to make it more reflective.</figcaption></figure><p>The reason for me making these comparisons I guess is to verbalise the feeling that I have at this point on the tour, where the artist’s intention is starting to make more and more <em>sense </em>to me while I’m simultaneously challenged by the inescapable fact that my aesthetic judgements are bound to the societal standards of the day. In the 16th century, for example, Michelangelo was said to have commented on what a great painter Titian would have been ‘if only he had been taught to draw properly’, which was a highly common judgement one could make during the period of <em>designo </em>supremacy where draftsmanship as an art form was lauded above all others. Today, however, our priorities are entirely different: Matisse, Picasso, Cezanne are incredibly acclaimed artists but none are celebrated chiefly for their ability to draw — instead, we celebrate their unique perspective (quite literally in the case of the latter two) or perhaps their ability to convey meaningful sentiment with colour and form — their drawing capability is largely irrelevant to their merit.</p><p>The great thing about the National Gallery having such an expansive collection is that you’re encouraged to think about how trends and tastes have come and gone throughout the centuries. When I look at Titian’s work, I think of the groundbreaking paintings of the romantic period — of Delacroix and Turner — and the subsequent earthquake of Impressionism. But being privy to this influence while picking out the elements of his work that have endured the capricious tendencies of art criticism causes me to engage with it in a way that I’m sceptical of. Is a reason to like a work of art because it seems more relevant to your modern tastes, and is therefore more easily understood? I’m not really sure if I’m honest, and it might not even matter anymore in the current artistic climate, which is fundamentally liberated from doctrinal laws. But when exploring art that is <em>this old, </em>I think its probably worth trying to recognize how our environment (and its relation to history) shapes the way in which we view things, even aesthetically. In fact, a failure to do so has resulted in incredibly problematic myths that have the effect of perpetuating harmful — even racist — beliefs about the world; so next week, I’m going to try and think about how politics, history, and art have intersected in institutions such as the National Gallery to create a ‘story’ that may not be altogether true.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33f3d8c4bf84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Life After Death]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/at-what-point-does-influence-end-and-plagiarism-begin-e4318dd96d44?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e4318dd96d44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renaissance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[raphael]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michelangelo]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Mar 2019 10:43:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-26T07:07:03.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>2 of Rome’z Most Wanted</h4><p>At what point does influence end and plagiarism begin? Artist’s must ask themselves this question all the time. How can any idea be purely original when everything we perceive, feel, and judge has some basis in the cultural environment that surrounds us; when our artistic choices are unconsciously informed by the enduring influence of past creators, who were in turn brought up in the cultural milieu in part constructed by their predecessors, etc, etc.</p><p>But if originality is so elusive, then why is it the marker by which society has chosen to evaluate art, and why is it even an attractive attribute anyway? It’s an interesting point, and one that was put to an audience of ageing communists by Art writer Chrstine Lidney at a SCRSS event last week: “why must everything be original?!”, she asked us with a tone of weary exasperation in her voice. Christine spoke to us about the avant-garde art of the early 20th century that resulted from the utopian fervour of the 1917 Russian revolution and, later, the enforced application of Socialist Realism by Stalin. Although radically abstract art was initially seen as compatible with the political and technological advancements of the new age, the function that Art would play in Soviet society began to change, and therefore so did its aesthetic; Stalin cared little for originality of thought and instead prescribed an art that was productive and easily accessible/understood by the ‘common man’ — an art that was made by the people for the people — unlike the ‘selfish’, ‘soulless’ works of the modern age, with all of its pseudo-intellectualism, celebrity and <em>originality</em>.</p><p>Most 20th century historians insisted that Art suffered as a result of Stalin’s suffocation of modernism; which is probably why I agree with them. It seems obvious to my generation that any good artwork must be infused with a touch of the artist’s idiosyncrasy, as though a work of art should be viewed almost like a Rorschach test, a looking glass into the inner-workings of an artist’s mind. But as I keep trying to remind myself, the ways in which society has discerned greatness in art has changed a lot since the time of Leondardo da Vinci, for example, and we need to keep that in mind as we continue our way out of the period known to us as the Renaissance.</p><p>I’m basically saying all of that to say this: I hate Raphael’s art. Well, maybe hate is too strong a word, but I’m definitely not the biggest fan. The reason for this — despite being incredibly cliche and almost certainly very ignorant — is because Raphael was involved in the most impact rivalry ever featured in the story of Art, and, frankly, it is difficult not to pick sides, especially when traditional interpretations of Art history insist that we <em>must … </em>anyway, it was 1504 … and interestingly, this story of competition began as the story of an older, more underrated competition approached its end.</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p>On one end of The Palazzo Vecchio hall, da Vinci began work on a new invention that would aid in the artistic process. A sort of wooden elevator, he would use it to peruse his fresco with ease, and it would also help to make his opponent, on the other side of the hall, venomously jealous. Michelangelo scowled over at Leonardo with his stupid face and stupid ladder thing and brewed with resentment over the fact that this wizard man — an eccentric freak — was being positioned by the elites of Florence as HIS equal, a ‘worthy opponent’ they said?! LOL. He would show them.</p><p>While Leonardo was commissioned to depict the historical Battle of Anghiari, Michelangelo opted for the equally patriotic depiction of the Battle of Cascina. Both would battle it out for the crown of Florence in what would turn into the Renaissance equivalent of the Lil Kim vs Foxy Brown saga, with aspiring artists flocking into Tuscany from far and wide as though it were a new Mecca. One such artist named Raffaello Sanzio da Urbino, later called Raphael, made the journey westwards into Tuscany to see the spectacle for himself, and although neither of the paintings were finished (we spoke about da Vinci’s notorious unreliability last week, and in that regard Michelangelo wasn’t much better), the artistic occasion did result in the exposure of new and dynamic art forms to the young Raphael — who was amazed by the achievements of both Leonardo and Michelangelo and would become <em>heavily</em> influenced by both in his own work.</p><p>For Michelangelo, however, his most-favourable contemporaries heralded him as a prophet — <em>Il Divino </em>(the divine one) — influenced purely by the sublimity of God himself. In some ways, he thought of himself as an artistic apostle and carried out his work in a strictly pious way: famously, he turned down payment for the construction of St Peters Basicilca while he slaved away day in and day out, refusing company and sleeping in a make-shift room on the construction site. Indeed, all accounts attest to the fact that he was deeply serious about the profundity of his art, which was created in a deeply personal and emotionally expressive way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DwTYShv78GfIOEDQ8ZfLBg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Michelangelo, The Entombment (or Christ being carried to his Tomb), 1500–1 (Unfinished).</figcaption></figure><p>It’s no wonder then that Raphael was captivated. And he wasn&#39;t the only one: the primary reason why Michelangelo abandoned his fresco in The Palazzo Vecchio was because Pope Julius II had requested his services in Rome. And here he would begin the arduous task of constructing a monumental tomb for the ageing Julius, which began with a 6-month excursion around the quarries of Carrara in search of the perfect blocks of marble. And this is one of the most important qualities to note about Michelangelo: by his own admission, he was a sculptor — not a painter — and most of his long career was spent in an attempt to raise the status of sculpture, and later architecture, as respectable art forms. In fact, it was this seemingly up-hill battle to change the perception of these ‘lower arts’ that resulted in Michelangelo being pitted against Raphael, as each fought to assert their respective specialities in what would form a crucial part of an overarching cultural debate on the most important, fundamental quality of art.</p><p>As part of this <em>Paragone</em> debate, which we touched on in <a href="https://medium.com/@louismendee/the-story-of-western-art-starting-in-florence-is-a-story-of-liberation-both-of-the-artist-and-of-8d659f6d8c12">Bellini week</a>, the relative importance of <em>designo</em> (the quintessentially Florentine focus on draughtsmanship, line, mathematical perspective, and design) and <em>colorito </em>(epitomised by the great Venetian artists of the Renaissance who viewed colour as a central part of a painting, not a secondary concern) was argued over. Michelangelo was considered the supreme in the former element and, as such, was held in very high-esteem throughout his career. So well regarded was Michelengelo that when he stormed back to Florence in a rage from Rome, Julius pleaded with the authorities to send him back in order to take on a new commission. The pope had snubbed Michelangelo by growing bored by the tomb idea in favour of a new plan to build a Basilica named after Saint Peter, and the sensitive, and perhaps paranoid, artist sensed that this was part of a plot by the upstart Raphael to defame him.<br>Dutifully complying with the Pope’s wishes, however, Michelangelo returned back to Rome in 1508 to see what the ageing Julius had in mind, and to his horror, he found out that he was to be commissioned to paint the 12 apostles on the vault of the Sistine Chapel. Michelangelo refused at first; he was a sculptor, not a painter, and he would not take artistic direction from anyone other than God himself — not even God’s representative. But luckily for us, Julius was able to compromise and gave Michelangelo the freedom to choose his own subjects. This is why the nine scenes from the Book of Genesis exist today on the most famous ceiling in the world.</p><p>It took Michelangelo 4 years of hard, relentless labour, spent hunched over in isolation to finish it. Refusing company, he would lock the doors every night, forbidding even the Pope from having a sneak peek of his masterpiece. According to Vasari, when Michelangelo was out of the city to take a break from his fresco, Bramante (the architect whose design for St Pauls basilica was chosen by the Pope in 1508) let Raphael into the chapel to ‘understand’ Michelangelo’s painting methods. And so the rivalry began — legend has it — as what Raphael saw was unlike anything he had ever seen. He was struck by the magnitude of Michelangelo’s figures and the way in which their bones and flesh and limbs seemed to spin with unbridled intensity. da Vinci had mocked Michelangelo for his portrayal of the male nude as a “sack of walnuts”, but even he, like Raphael, could see that the sculptor-come-painter had achieved something immense in his ability to convey raw, powerful expression through the human form. Indeed, once the doors to the chapel were opened, Michelangelo cemented his position as the greatest artist alive. For the time being.</p><p>Raphael came to the Vatican in 1508, and (v. conveniently for the narrative of this story) was everything that the bad-tempered Michelangelo was not. Charming, well-dressed, young, and sociable, Raphael was quick to make a lot of important, well-connected friends in the city and was soon at the centre of an elite milieu of academics, humanists, and artists in the Papal court. <br>Before coming to Rome, however, Raphael experienced the art of both Michelangelo and da Vinci in their home city of Florence. Gaining access to some of the preliminary works of Leonardo, he learned to perfect the <em>sfumato </em>method as well as the glances and gestures that assist with the overall sense of naturalism, and he was pushed to instil in his subjects with a potency that was emblematic of the style of Michelangelo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C0MOtV8ruzme9Wj_qG5TNg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Raphael, The Virgin and Child with an Angel, the Archangel Raphael with Tobias and the Archangel Michael, 1496–1500. Leonardo’s influence isclearly seen in this interpretation of the Madonna and child.</figcaption></figure><p>Despite being undeniably influenced by the great artists of his time, he succeeded in creating his own unique style that came to represent the style of the High-Renaissance at its finest. In fact, this period is traditionally said to have ended when Raphael did, in 1520. Raphael’s early death was most likely considered a blessing by Michelangelo, who by this point had almost given up painting entirely, embittered by the fame and glory that the young man from Urbino had accrued in his short career. Talking about Raphael, Michelangelo was claimed to have said “everything he knew about art he got from me”, but aside from the alleged plagiarism (and there is much to read on this), the rivalry became a lot more complex, even philosophical, than this alone.</p><p>Interestingly, the National Gallery contains one of the best paintings there is to understand this, and even more interestingly, it&#39;s not even by Raphael of Michelangelo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g1YUAtXakKjmnPpHUGzWZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sebastiano del piombo, The Raising of Lazarus, 1517–1519. This masterpiece ended up as part of the London banker Angerstein’s art collection, which was bought by the National Gallery in 1824. Catalogued as NG1, it is the gallery’s first ever painting.</figcaption></figure><p>This painting was made by Sebastiano del Piombo, a Venetian painter who trained under the tutelage of the greats Bellini and Giorgione (more on the Venetian masters next week), and it depicts the biblical story of the <em>Raising of Lazarus </em>in which Christ undertakes the miracle of resurrection. Nothing about this painting seems particularly strange, but if you look intently enough at each of the figures in turn and note their differences, you will most likely be drawn to Lazarus and sense that something is not quite right; I came to the gallery with my nan this week and she also isolated Lazarus as being particularly <em>different</em> from the rest of the painting, a little bit too distinctive.<br>Indeed, you might have even guessed already that this twisting, strained, figure, in all of his vascular muscularity, <a href="https://www.google.com/search?biw=1440&amp;bih=789&amp;tbm=isch&amp;sa=1&amp;ei=VIuWXIHDMtmf1fAPgJao4A4&amp;q=michelangelo+male+nudes&amp;oq=michelangelo+male+nudes&amp;gs_l=img.3...10653.12004..12063...0.0..0.90.629.8......1....1..gws-wiz-img.......0j0i30j0i8i30j0i24.q5pEG8KSvTA">could have only really been drawn by Michelangelo</a>. But how could this be?</p><p>By the time he had finished the Sistine Chapel, Michelangelo was pretty much over the whole painting thing. People were now beginning to talk of Raphael as “the Prince of Painters” after the completion of <em>The School of Athens </em>in the papal apartments, and many believed that Michelangelo was a one-trick-painting-pony who could only achieve mastery of the human form. Writing in <em>The Lives</em>, Vasari said:</p><blockquote>Raphael of Urbino had risen into great credit as a painter, and his friends and adherents maintained that his works were more strictly in accordance with the rules of art than Michelangelo, affirming that they were graceful in coloring, of beautiful invention, admirable in expression, and of characteristic design; while those of Michelangelo, it was averred, had none of those qualities with the exception of the design. For these reasons, Raphael was judged, by those who thus opined, to be fully equal, if not superior, to Michelangelo in painting generally and… decidedly superior to him regarding coloring in particular… these ideas… found favour among those who preferred the grace of Raphael to the profundity of Michelangelo.</blockquote><p>And to be fair to them, their point was maybe kind of valid. By his own admission, painting was not Michelangelo’s favoured art form, and he struggled with the new advancements, pioneered by the Venetians, that had been made with colour. He preferred the simplicity of fresco over the newer medium of oil, which had allowed more ambitious painters to experiment with the softness, transparency, and depth of colour. Raphael was one such artist who dared to study the Venetian method of <em>colorito</em>, and his biggest fans also claimed that he was superior to Michelangelo in painting pretty much everything other than nudes. In many instances, his style is the polar opposite of Michelangelo’s: soft, elegant, restrained, and reposeful, Raphael’s harmonious compositions and subjects were renowned for their simple and easeful beauty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ALsvYru7mreKRlTScVrGvw@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Raphael, The Garvagh Madonna, 1509–10. The soft, ordered grace of this painting is indicative of Raphael&#39;s ‘Apollonian’ style. There was a joke at the time that Michelangelo created porters (burly, coarse, and vigorous) whereas Raphael created gentleman, and I think it’s fair to say that the former did not find it very funny at all.</figcaption></figure><p>Michelangelo’s abstention from painting, however, did not completely deter him from pursuing competition with Raphael. He wanted to demonstrate that Raphael could be defeated, not only on the basis of <em>designo </em>(which Michelangelo had already proven himself to be supreme), but also on the young artist’s own turf — colour, composition, and conformity. But to do this, he would need help. We’ve already established that Michelangelo primarily considered himself a sculptor and struggled with the <em>colorito</em> end of the <a href="https://medium.com/@louismendee/the-story-of-western-art-starting-in-florence-is-a-story-of-liberation-both-of-the-artist-and-of-8d659f6d8c12"><em>designo — colorito </em>binary</a>, so by his logic, in order to depose Raphael’s apparent supremacy in the pictorial arts he would need to enlist an accomplice; somebody who could make up for Michelangelo’s ambivalence to colour; somebody who he could assemble with, like some kind of Renaissance Transformer, to out-power the reigning champ. This person was Sebastiano del Piombo.</p><p>As Art Historian Costanza Barbieri says: <em>Michelangelo’s manipulative behaviour had to rely on a painter whose talent — as to the rules of painting — was comparable, if not superior, to that of Raphael, thus representing a real threat for the painter of Urbino. </em>And Sebastiano had talent in spades; trained in the Venetian tradition, his primacy in colour (in oil too) surpassed Raphael’s, and, living in Rome he learned to develop a refined Florentinesque style that was more palatable to central-Italian taste. At some point in the years after the completion of the Sistine Chapel ceiling, the idea was born that Michelangelo and Sebastiano could work together — “in a synthesis of sculptural qualities and coloristic value” (Barbieri) — to create inimitable masterpieces. Jumping at the chance to work with the eminent Michelangelo, Sebastiano wrote to him that together they “could accomplish the revenge of the one and the other all at once, and demonstrate to the malevolents that there were demigods other than Raphael from Urbino and his <em>garzoni</em>”. It was basically all very Game of Thrones, just with more paint and less sex … although, actually, some of Sebastiano’s letters to his idol are a little bit too intense to be platonic imo, and it’s a well-known fact at this point that Michelangelo was into men, so who knows.</p><p>Anyway, for a while in the 1510s, Michelangelo took a bit of a back seat and pulled some strings behind the scenes, providing Sebastiano with advice, ideas, and even preparatory sketches for paintings. Because of this, Sebastiano’s fame rose quickly, and he was soon in competition with Raphael for important commissions across the capital. In 1516, Cardinal Giulio de’Medici, cousin of the new pope Leo X, commissioned two paintings for the cathedral of Narbonne: <em>The Transfiguration of Christ</em> and <em>The Raising of Lazarus. </em>Rumour now has it that the situation was engineered and manipulated by Michelangelo so that Raphael was chosen to depict the former and Sebastiano the latter, in a competition that mirrored his own rivalry with Raphael in the Vatican a decade earlier.</p><p>Raphael was furious, and according to Leonardo Sellaio (who wrote to Michelangelo in January 1517), he “turned the world upside down to prevent Sebastiano from painting it, because he does not want any comparison”. Michelangelo, however, relished the opportunity to put his new artistic combo to the test and immediately got to work providing Sebastiano with the drawing designs he would need to win (s<a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cf/Michelangelo%2C_lazaro%2C_per_pala_sebastiano_del_piombo.gif">ome of which now exist in the British Museum</a>). The result was seamless and displayed a variety of favourable Renaissance elements: the beautiful natural landscape; the skilful application of light, which interacts with expertly coloured drapery; and the detail paid to outlining the physical form of Lazarus, all make this an iconic masterpiece of the High-Renaissance. It is no wonder that Raphael was scared; he likely received intel on the painting as it was being made and altered his own painting in response.</p><p>But to be fair to him, the <em>Transfiguration </em>is equally as powerful a piece. Pressured to go beyond the realms of what he was used to, Raphael was forced to be more radical in his approach and experiment with different techniques. Indeed, what he produced was unlike anything he had ever created before: unsettled and ominously atmospheric, the Transfiguration incorporates much of Michelangelo’s resolve. Going even further though, the tense, turbulent, and restless, nature of the dramatic light effects and <em>affetti </em>(passion and feelings expressed through gesture) seen in this painting foreshadows the Art that would emerge after Raphael’s own death. <br>It would therefore seem that a bit of healthy competition can sometimes pay off when it comes to the creation of masterpieces … with ‘healthy’ probably not being the best choice of word, as Raphael would not actually live the 6 days required to see his project exhibited alongside Sebastiano’s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*54PkaClSPdpg5gmGmM0tvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Raphael, The Transfiguration, 1516–20. This painting stayed in Rome while Sebastiano’s was taken to Narbonne.</figcaption></figure><p>In terms of who won though, there was never really ever a clear winner. I personally prefer Raphael’s because of its novel ingenuity, but at the time — or at least for Michelangelo — it was irrelevant. With Raphael dead, he was now indisputably the greatest artist alive, and with that came huge ramifications not only for the artist himself but for the trajectory of Western Art into the 17th century and beyond. <br>When Michelangelo unveiled his new fresco <em>The Last Judgment </em>in the Sistine Chapel in 1541, the aesthetic of Renaissance art was already starting to look very different as a result of the political upheavals in the 1520s/30s — the rise of Lutheranism in the North, and the sacking of Rome in 1527— as well as the creative block that had arisen out of the oppressive, dominating shadows of Michelangelo and Raphael. The achievement of these two artists was considered so absolute that it caused a ‘crisis in Art’ in which creative progress seemed impossible, and even Michelangelo had to content with the apparent ‘perfection’ of his own work, adopting a style that was symbolic of the agitated insecurity of the time, which was only intensified by the growing threat placed on the Catholic Church.</p><p>The next generation of artist’s had nowhere to go. If the limits of what was capable with Art had been reached, what more was there to do? The majority decided that the best course of action was to create an Art of imitation, <em>in the manner of</em> Michelangelo. This era of ‘Mannerism’ was now ushered in as a hasty, unsure extension of the Renaissance in which artists did all they could to convey the passion and rawness of the great sculptors work, sometimes even breaking into his house to steal drawings and sketches — anything that would help them learn. Revisionist Art historians now look back on this era as hopelessly try-hard and a bit pathetic: there’s an undertone of desperation in much of Mannerist art that makes it difficult to engage with. The ease of Raphael and the effortless dynamism associated with Michelangelo was lost as artists laboured to reproduce greatness, with their work becoming more forced. But, of course, let&#39;s make our own minds up on this when we get to it in a couple of weeks.</p><p>In the short term, then, Michelango’s legacy was by far more influential than Raphael’s, and by all intents and purposes, the <em>designo </em>vs <em>colorito</em> debate was over. Michelangelo, the icon of the <em>designo</em> side, believed that the illusion of relief was the goal of painting and that a painting only succeeded as long as it resembled sculpture, and this viewpoint was largely unchallenged until way into the 19th century when modern artists began to develop new (or perhaps old, Venetian-inspired) ideas about how movement and emotion could be conveyed by utilizing a more fluid approach to design and a more audacious use of colour.</p><p>But Michelangelo contributed more than superb draughtsmanship. He showed that Art could be a medium through which to communicate intense emotional feeling, primarily through the use of the human nude. It is this quality of his work that I am most fascinated by — there is an almost unexplainable energy that courses through Michelangelo&#39;s subjects in a way this is so at odds to the refined, serene compositions of Raphael. With a crude revisionism, it is reasonable to suggest that this polarity continued way after the deaths of the two artists and became an essential tension that existed in all visual art. Nietzche would describe this in <em>The Birth of Tragedy</em>, in which he spoke of a balance of sorts between Apollonian — restrained, rational, ordered and dignified — and Dionysian — instinctive, wild, emotive, and disorderly — tendencies of all Art. Following the high-renaissance, cultural tastes ebbed and flowed between these two tendencies, coming in and out of fashion. And although the Apollonian legacy influence of Raphael was overshadowed for much of the late 16th century, it enjoyed several renaissances later down the line with Poussin in the 17th century and with the Neoclassicists of the 18th/19th centuries (Kauffman, David, Ingres, etc.). As for Dionysus, the expressive vitality of Michelangelo lived on in his immediate aftermath, through Rubens (17th C) and the Baroque, and made a more-recent resurgence in the romantic movement (of the Victorian age), which in turn set the scene for the modern era of Impressionists.</p><p>But importantly, the <em>methods</em> by which artists expressed this emotive sentiment in their work drifted away from Michelangelo’s <em>designo</em>, and as traces of Mannerism and Baroque started to fade away in the 18th century, artists sought different ways to paint that would enable expressiveness. For this end, they looked away from Florence and towards Venice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Boc2Lsvje3oC5wAHB3DV6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Michelangelo, The Sistine Chapel ceiling, 1512.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e4318dd96d44" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Polymath Procrastinator]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/the-polymath-procrastinator-353d00ef282f?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/353d00ef282f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[drawing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renaissance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leonardo-da-vinci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-gallery]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Mar 2019 15:55:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-09T20:55:54.731Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Who shot ya?</h4><p>At the peak of summer in 1987, Robert Cambridge finally made up his mind. Drunk, depressed and alone, he traipsed aimlessly from tube to gallery, to gallery, until one evening he found himself in room 7 of the National. It is one of the darkest, smallest rooms here, and when you get the rare chance to be alone, face-to-face with <em>The Virgin and Child with St Anne and St John the Baptist, </em>you are gently encouraged to feel at peace … and I wonder whether Robert Cambridge felt the same, or maybe thought twice before he looked up at Mary, lifted the sawn-off shotgun out of his coat pocket, and pulled the trigger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u6Xv2EzfO5sIdT9N51Wizw.png" /></figure><p>The cartoon was protected by reinforced glass, but the inner layer had shattered and smashed into the cartoon, striking the Virgin Mary in the heart and tearing the paper in multiple locations. The National Gallery, which lacked expertise in paper conservation, called upon a range of experts from the British Museum, V&amp;A, Albert Museum, Tate Gallery, and the Royal Library at Winsor to attempt a restoration, and they wasted absolutely no time. The importance of this undertaking could not be overstated: the drawing was bought in 1962 as a result of one of the largest nationwide fundraising appeals in the country&#39;s history (in which the British public donated millions of pounds), and having this work of art, even if it was <em>only </em>a cartoon, affirmed the National Gallery’s place as one of the top artistic institutions in the world.</p><p>The months that conservators spent salvaging this 500-year-old drawing, made of nothing but charcoal and chalk, is a testament to the astronomical importance of Leonardo da Vinci in the story of Art. It is funny to think that <em>The Bullington Cartoon </em>may never have been intended for exhibition and was perhaps only a rough preliminary drawing for a painting that was never made, and yet it remains one of the most prized objects to exist in any British museum or gallery. In fact, such is the enormity of <em>Leondardo da Vinci</em>, that his notebook drawings and sketches that form part of Her Majesty’s collection have been said by some critics to constitute <em>the</em> greatest works of art in Britain. It would, indeed, not be a stretch to say that no other artist is held in such high regard in modern Western society; although the reasons for this undoubtedly go way beyond the sphere of Art.</p><p>As the first great, High-Renaissance artist, Leonardo created new parameters for what was possible with painting. Before him, Masaccio had studied the shapes, lines and contortions of the human body and Jan van Eyck scrutinized and recorded every minute detail of his subject; but neither truly ever succeeded in capturing the extent of a living, breathing human subject on canvas. Not only was Leonardo the first artist to do this in a meaningful way, but in doing so he laid the foundations for a modern scientific process based on observation. Indeed, part of the reason why Leonardo was able to instil so much life into his subjects was because he really <em>knew </em>them: during the course of his life, he dissected dozens of corpses, and at times stayed overnight in hospital morgues and mortuaries in order to understand everything that he could about human anatomy and the way in which skin, muscles and nerves collaborate to generate gestures and expression. He understood that in order to really understand the world, he had to scrutinize it himself and not rely on medieval superstition or Churchly assumptions about the mechanics of life. <br>It was this Renaissance mentality — of individual empowerment and creativity — that brought Western civilisation out of the middle ages and closer to the era of Enlightenment, and Leonardo played a fundamental role in this transition while also finding the time to create the two most famous artworks of all time. Your fave could literally never.</p><p>What is important to know about Leonardo is that his art was never a means to an end, and in many ways his collective artistic output can be viewed as the creative by-product of an existence indentured to truth. He once said that a good painter “has two chief objectives to paint — man and the intention of his soul”, and when looking at his art you understand what he means: with every line that he makes, Leonardo seeks to unlock truth from human form, conveying not only the physical representation of his subjects but their spirit, and soul.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f_0VDeMYR9xs_d-bAlDIkg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Think back to the week on Massaccio, where his relentless use of perspective and anatomical detail resulted in figures that were powerfully imposing but always slightly rigid, unmoving and statuesque. This was the sacrifice that early renaissance painters had to make: in order to achieve a high level of likeness, figures were made to look static and the artist’s ability to express movement or dynamism was lost. Leonardo, however, made it possible to have both, and he did so by paying close attention to the properties of light. <br>The technique that he is credited with is called <em>sfumato</em>, and it refers to the way in which Leonardo would slightly blur his outlines so that his colours and shades flowed easily and smoothly from one another, creating a sort of hazy atmosphere in which forms disappear softly into shadow and some of the detail is left to the viewers imagination. The result is ethereal and provides the basis for Leonardo’s ability to depict something so deeply human with apparent effortlessness; and yet don’t be fooled — every glance, gesture, and angle is carefully chosen in accordance with the emotional undertone that Leonardo is trying to communicate, and his attention to exquisite anatomical detail only heightens this visual experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YPTdrJjIRQj_InNfyysFbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The muscles of the upper spine. Leonardo did not actually contribute much to the field of anatomy as he never published his findings, but studies such as this show that he was way before his time in this field, as he was in many others.</figcaption></figure><p>This year is the 500-year anniversary of his death, and to mark the occasion the Royal Collection Trust has loaned-out its expansive collection of da Vinci drawings to 12 locations across the country. I went home to Liverpool this past weekend and was lucky enough to see one such exhibition in the Walker Art Gallery.</p><p>One thought that I have kept coming back to since, is the question of whether these drawings can really be described as Art at all, in the sense that <a href="https://medium.com/@louismendee/trying-to-come-up-with-a-water-tight-definition-for-what-art-is-is-damn-near-impossible-in-the-5ab0c2a43c06">I spoke about a few weeks ago</a>. These drawings are studies by a person who is desperately trying to work through and understand complex, scientific phenomena, and I’m not altogether convinced that he would have considered himself to be acting as an artist when he created them. Nevertheless, his drawings are truly awe-inspiring and give insight into just how varied and extensive his talents were; as indeed, Art was one of many disciplines in which Leonardo excelled during his lifetime, and painting was never the single priority during his varied and insanely productive career.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*81MSFmPFqXoYBle5XquzEQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>These loose sketches of horses were made in preparation for a painting that — shock — was never completed. Leonardo’s respect for accurate anatomical detail reminds me of the 18th century artist George Stubbs, who is best known for his horse paintings. Like da Vinci, Stubbs was an artist whose work was a product of dedicated observation. He would suspend horse carcasses from the ceiling in order to record them in excruciating detail. Spending months on any one carcass, he would peel back the layers of skin as the carcass rotted, observing the muscle/tissue structure underneath so that he could build up a more fundamental understanding of the horse’s physicality.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*atWfZzwboyKq1jy-EAP73A.jpeg" /><figcaption>On the other side of a drawing, Leonardo takes some notes on astronomy. They read: “If you want to prove why the moon appears larger when it reaches the horizon, take a lens which is convex on one surface and concave on the opposite, and place the concave side next to the eye, and look at the object beyond the convex surface; by this means you will have produced an exact imitation of the atmosphere included between the sphere of fire and that of water; for this atmosphere is concave on the side next to the earth and convex towards the fire”.</figcaption></figure><p>You get a sense that he was frenzied in his wonderment of the natural world. In this notebooks, he would frantically move from equine anatomy on one page to lunar calculations on the next. You might be thinking that between astronomy, anatomy, topography, engineering, architecture — the list goes on — it is a wonder how he managed an artistic career at all. But in fairness, he never really did. His polymathic abilities meant that he just did not have enough time to produce as many artworks as his contemporaries, and he was notoriously unreliable, abandoning many, many paintings, which are now lost or unfinished. This reputation meant that during the peak of the High-Renaissance, the Pope was reluctant to award large-scale commissions to Leonardo, presumably due to fear of him leaving halfway through to focus on something absurd like a flying machine, or a metal knight, or maybe even an underwater breathing apparatus. It’s probably fair to say that if you were a wealthy patron of the arts in 1512 Rome, Leonardo da Vinci was a bit of a liability, although a frustratingly talented one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LpvlYejBGzz1SnUs-ms_hQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Here, Leonardo observes how a stream of water reacts to impediment. He was incredibly interested in the nature of water and spent a lot of time working in the study of hydraulics. At one point in his career, he attempted to create plans for a series of canals, locks, and dams, that would divert the course of the river Arno from Pisa — Florence’s enemy — to Florence.</figcaption></figure><p>Leonardo is definitely an anomaly in the story of Art in that the discipline of Art was perhaps not even his first, second or even third priority, and yet he is still considered one of the greatest artists of all time. When you think of the most famous paintings ever, it is likely that the Mona Lisa and The Last Supper are very high if not at the top of your list, and for many, including the celebrated Art Historian Ernst Gombrich, “ The Last Supper remains one of the greatest miracles wrought by human genius”. We will never know the extent of the artistic influence that Leonardo could have had, though, if he had chosen to focus solely on the arts. There are only about 15 attributed paintings by Leonardo — partly due to the difficulty he had actually finishing anything, but also because of his insistence on experimenting with new and unproven painting techniques, which resulted in many of his works rapidly deteriorating — but imagine if there were 60, or even 100; how many of these could have shaped and influenced the trajectory of Art to the same extent as the Mona Lisa? <br>It is not clear; but I think it is fair to say that by not being completely focused on his artistic output (and thank god he was not), he became eclipsed by others who were; for while Leonardo pottered around the gardens of the Vatican honing his botanical skills (and neglecting the art studio that Pope Leo X had given him in the naive hope that he would actually use it), two other artists were hard at work on the inside of the palace — one in the Sistine Chapel, and the other in The <em>Stanze</em>. They battled fervently, and often bitterly, for the artistic soul of Rome while the rest of the Western world watched in awe, and in doing they rose to heights that no artist had achieved before or has achieved since. Next week, we meet <strong>Raphael</strong> and <strong>Michaelangelo</strong>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=353d00ef282f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Honesty is the best policy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/honesty-is-the-best-policy-84db74f02113?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84db74f02113</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[national-gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artblogchallenge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netherlands]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renaissance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Feb 2019 23:26:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-01T10:18:05.879Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Telling the truth in oil</h4><blockquote>“The Italians, having before their eyes the treasures of ancient statuary, were able to acquire the purity and correctness of the drawing quickly. They have learned to give their figures this suppleness and elegance of pose, and to clothe them with artistically arranged draperies. The Germans, on the contrary, had only one model: nature. Also if their poses have some stiffness, so their heads are almost all portraits, they great charm and delicious naiveté in expression. In a way, they are closer to the truth.” — <em>Albrecht Dürer</em></blockquote><p><strong>Rooms 62–65</strong></p><p>As the National Gallery’s collection was being built during the first half of the 19th century, English taste was still very much concerned with masterpieces of the High-Renaissance and the spectacle of classical, Italian works of art. Within 30 minutes of walking around the National, it becomes evident that the allure of antiquity lingered for much of the story of art (with momentary peaks and troughs) and became a defining feature of Art’s constitution. This was especially the case in the early 1800s, when classism faced yet another resurgence in the public interest.</p><p>Even today, the ancient charm of Greece and Rome remains a hallmark of ‘good taste’ in elitist circles, and Classics<em> </em>can still be studied as an independent discipline at most of the UK’s top academic institutions. The renaissance of all-things antique had an unparalleled effect in shaping the aesthetic, philosophical and political realms of Western society, and the art produced during this time is undoubtedly among the most influential ever created. The sheer magnitude of the Italian ‘greats’ has, in my opinion, stifled and obscured other historical areas of creativity — both in Europe and outside of it — and you only need to look at the buildings in which our prized art collections reside to realise the extent of classicism’s infringement on the post-industrial world.</p><p>It’s a case of ‘History is always written by the winners’, and in comparing Northern European vs Italian Renaissance art, it really is no contest. Although names such as Dürer, Brugel, and Jan van Eyck, are much more infamous now, German and Netherlandish art is nowhere near as well documented or studied as Italian, which has created somewhat of a gulf in Art theory and practice that I suspect still exists today.</p><p>The Renaissance did not, however, confine itself within the borders of the Italian peninsula but rapidly moved throughout Europe where it manifested in different ways. Without the ancestral nostalgia for Rome, or a desire to resurrect the Greco-Roman world, artists in other parts of Europe were able to utilize the Renaissance to explore different arenas of creativity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JW-XPZqKwKekJstCKJl2sA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Jan van Eyck, The Arnolfini Portrain, 1434. </strong>Jan van Eyck applies exquisite detail to every component of the composition, and the painting differs vastly from the Italian painters who came later — e.g, Mantegna and Massacio — in terms of subject matter, medium, and style. On the Netherlandish vs Italian divide, Gombrich said the following: “it is a fair guess to say that any work which excels in the representation of the beautiful surface of things, of flowers, jewels or fabric, will be by a northern artists, most probably by an artist from the Netherlands; while a painting with bold outlines, clear perspective and a sure mastery of the beautiful human body, will be Italian”.</figcaption></figure><p>Some artists such as the great Jan van Eyck saw their duty as artists to faithfully reproduce nature <em>as it really exists. </em>In this masterpiece, the idealised, sometimes surreal aspects of the Italian Renaissance have been abandoned by van Eyck in favour of total attention to detail. I almost feel bad uploading this photo: <em>The Arnolfini Portrait </em>is a painting that deserves to be looked at in the flesh; every single brush stroke is placed with immaculate precision, and you can see that van Eyck has earnestly laboured over every crease, fold, and hair, while paying remarkable attention not only to the varied effects of light but also to the reflection of the scene in a convex mirror.</p><p>Now, there is an entire saga of mystery that surrounds this painting, and an amazing amount of literature has been made in reference to it over the past few centuries. The fascination with The Arnolfini Portrait stems from the subjects: Who are they? Why are they greeting the viewer? Or are they engaging in a secret marriage…because she’s pregnant? And is that the painter himself that you can see reflected in the mirror? Is that why he is there, to act as a witness to the marriage? And is that why <em>Johannes de eyck fuit hic 1434</em> (<em>Jan van Eyck was here 1434) </em>is inscribed above the mirror?</p><p>The painting is riddled with hidden meanings, and it is an incredibly interesting work of art to try and decode. Whatever the answers are, what immediately interests me about this painting is how strongly the presence of the artist is felt, whether it be suggestive or physical. The mirror on the back wall is surely a little joke: it challenges our fundamental understanding of ‘art-as-a-window’ and pushes us to think about whether we are viewing the scene through our own eyes or through the eyes of the artist — <em>Johannes de eyck</em> — who transforms the otherwise simplistic parameters of the scene by boldly asserting himself into it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OcpY1u-xwtbE8zqJw1bYTQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Jan van Eyck, Portrait of a Man (Self Portrait?), 1433</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Part of the reason why Jan van Eyck’s paintings were, and still are, so captivating is because he was the first artist to use oil painting to achieve such realism, long before the Venetians caught on. By using layer upon layer of oils and glazes, van Eyck was able to create smooth, glossy finishes in which colours could be expertly blended and transitioned. This medium of painting would prove to be far more flexible than egg tempera, which was a staple in the early Italian Renaissance, and it would dominate as the primary painting method for centuries to come.</p><p>For all that is said about the innovations of Renaissance art, it is perhaps a shame that Jan van Eyck is not regarded in the same light as the great Italian masters; he was the first artist to seek a sense of <em>truth</em> in his work, and is the ultimate artistic descendant of Rembrandt, Vermeer and perhaps even the Impressionists, who each sought to convey more than idealism in their dutifully honest depictions of the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GbOz4CUmm_zqij1RC-t-Og.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Dürer, 1497.</strong> Dürer is considered to be the first artist to really legitimise the genre of portraiture (self-portraiture, specifically). In this respect, he would have no equal until Rembrandt.</figcaption></figure><p>Dürer is another artist of the Northern renaissance who perhaps does not get his just due. While the Italians pioneered painting and sculpture, Germans excelled in the field of prints: woodcut, engraving, and etching. With the invention of the printing press in Germany circa 1450, artists such as Dürer were able to create mechanically reproducible, mass-produced, portable artworks that could be easily disseminated and acquired relatively cheaply. From Nuremberg, Dürer was the archetypal German renaissance artist and excelled in this German tradition; however, he was equally in awe of what the Italians were doing, which is no surprise given that Da Vinci was his contemporary, an artist who shared Dürer’s almost scientific approach to documenting nature.</p><blockquote>The more precisely the forms in your work are compatible with life, the better it will appear. That is the truth. So never imagine that you can or should attempt to make something better than God has allowed his created nature to be. For your ability is impotent compared to God’s creativity — <em>Dürer</em></blockquote><blockquote>That painting is the most to be praised which agrees most exactly with the thing imitated — <em>Leonarda Da Vinci</em></blockquote><p>Dürer frequently travelled to Italy, which allowed him to create a style that was uniquely his own yet undoubtedly infused with the style of the Italian Renaissance. He was familiar with many of the great artists of the time and likely even met a few of them, including Bellini, who Dürer remarked “is very old, but in painting still the best.” Returning to Germany with a new found appreciation for geometry and mathematical perspective, Dürer set about trying to achieve <em>Kounterfei, </em>a German word that emphasises ‘likeness’ or ‘making exactly like’. And by looking closely at this face of Dürer’s father in the portrait above, it is clear that Dürer went above and beyond the precedent that was set by van Eyck in capturing truth to nature, and this is supported by Dürer’s <a href="https://www.thecultureconcept.com/albrecht-durer-observing-nature">studies on plant life and animals</a>, which — like Da Vinci’s — are recorded with microscopic accuracy and a scientific curiosity that was indicative of the Renaissance.</p><blockquote><em>“Nature holds the beautiful, for the artist who has the insight to extract it. Thus, beauty lies even in humble, perhaps ugly things, and the ideal, which bypasses or improves on nature, may not be truly beautiful in the end”. — D</em>ü<em>rer</em></blockquote><p>These scientific notions of objectivity and <em>truth</em> were not uniquely artistic ones but developed as part of a broader cultural change that provided the scaffolding on which future scientific endeavour would rest. Importantly, this sentiment that man was master of his own domain and could scrutinise and measure the physical world around him did not begin antagonistically to religion, but did ultimately lead to the fundamental crisis of Christianity that saw the weakening of the Catholic church and the demotion of Rome as an influential centre. The rise of Protestantism throughout Northen Europe and the subsequent counter-reformation in Rome exacerbated and entrenched the geographical artistic divides discussed. In the North, secular art — especially portraiture, genre-painting and still-life (all of which we’ll get to later) — became incredibly important, and artworks that focused on moralistic, humble accounts of everyday life became the new normal. The modesty of this style of art was fiercely rebuked in the south however, where the counter-reformation fed into a highly extravagant style of art that would seek to revive the Catholic supremacy by utilizing the compelling intensity of the <em>Baroque.</em> Art would be stuck in this spiritual tug-of-war for centuries to come.</p><p>The iconoclasm of this period, as well as the propaganda that was created, show just how powerful art had become in the Western imagination, which we should never forget when viewing these paintings (indeed, the word ‘propaganda’ has its roots in the creation of the <em>Congregatio de Propaganda Fide</em> (the Congregation for Propagating the Faith)<em>, </em>the administrative body of the Catholic church that oversaw the counter-reformation). From humble beginnings in the middle ages, art began to enter the realm of politics, laying the groundwork for the politically oriented art of the 19th and 20th centuries. The Artist was now a political actor who could wield a tremendous amount of power, and such was the importance of art as a persuasive tool that leaders across the continent would covet artists to serve in their retinue and pay great sums of money for their work. Gone were the days when artists were mere craftsmen; they now took centre stage.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84db74f02113" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Beauty is in the eye of the beholder]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/trying-to-come-up-with-a-water-tight-definition-for-what-art-is-is-damn-near-impossible-in-the-5ab0c2a43c06?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ab0c2a43c06</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artblogchallenge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aesthetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conceptual-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Feb 2019 22:31:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-12T09:14:51.832Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Shovel Girl…is an artist?</h4><p>Trying to come up with a water-tight definition for what Art is is damn-near impossible in the 21st century. Being ill this past week, I’ve been transferring my garbled thoughts on to Google, as you do, and stumbled into a world of literature and philosophy that questions the essence of aesthetic, taste, and Art. It turns out that it’s actually all insanely complicated — and falling from rabbit hole to rabbit hole, I’ve found that Kant, Hume, Aristotle and even Plato all contended with the mind-bending properties of art and collectively failed to reach a resolution that wholly resonates with today’s paradigm. Part of the problem surely is that art refuses to just chill and allow us to pin it down. It is constantly moving and changing, defying our reasoning and understanding.</p><p>For this reason, my notebook this week is basically the equivalent of the math lady meme. Lots of big angry question marks and capital letters; all blended together with really long arrows and sentences that I can no longer read but can just about pick out ‘ART’ and ‘WHY’ — and is that a smiley face next to ‘DREAM WORLD’? Suffice to say, these are not thoughts that have an ounce of merit — I am essentially clueless — but I do want to write them down in a semi-coherent way nevertheless to help me process them. Northern European art can wait until next week.</p><p>I think I’ve gathered so far in my journeying of the National Gallery that earlier art can be described as an arrangement* of colours, lines, shapes, forms and materials, fashioned into a visual representation of objects** that exist in reality. <br>* The arrangement of these elements is unfixed and has changed throughout the course of art history through various movements that prioritise certain techniques or styles. **Objects in focus are prone to change: humans, the natural world, imagined divine beings, everyday scenes etc.</p><p>The purpose of a work of art is also something that has changed. Between the 1500s — 1900s, something being ‘art’ was contingent on its purpose, which was either to encourage religious devotion; act as a status symbol; (e.g., courtly or royal art, which acted to legitimize autocratic rule, and Bourgeouis art, which served as an indicator of wealth and social position); or to act as an aesthetic object to be enjoyed. Moving into modernism, purpose becomes more difficult; perhaps it is to evoke emotion from the viewer, or to challenge them in some way and make them think. Going beyond this, I would postulate that the purpose of most post-modern art is simply to be looked at.</p><p>But regardless, the purpose of art is presumably quite irrelevant to how you define it. If purpose <em>is</em> a factor when judging what is or isn’t art, then what happens if barriers prevent a work of art from fulfilling that purpose? i.e, does art require a human viewer to be considered as art, or does an artwork exist regardless of whether it is seen or not? I lean strongly towards the latter; if we accept that art is something that exists, then it must do independently of any other extraneous factors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/758/1*A_pkP2-_oAGVY_XkqLad-g.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Cezanne, 1897.</strong> The origins of Cubism can be seen in paintings like this. Critics at the time thought that Cezanne was mad, he is now considered as one of the greatest artists to have ever lived.</figcaption></figure><p>When exactly the lurch into modernity happened is debatable depending on how far back you want to draw influencers, but for all intents and purposes, it was Cezanne who was the first to create something we would now consider to be modern. The transformation was fundamental. Cezanne re-examined the essential properties of both art and the visual world around us, and in doing so created an art that was self-referential: the aspects of form, line and colour that constructed the work were as, if not more, important than the illusion itself. A viewer becomes more aware of the two dimensional surface of the canvas, which no longer served as a window into a picturesque world but as an arena for the experimentation of form, line, and colour, which become a focus in their own right, liberated from the task of representation. This was the most radical departure from consensus in the history of art and “<em>would start a landslide…” </em>(Gombrich) from which there was no return.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*cNDbznLAPybEB9S06l9RHg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Lucio Fontana, 1960. </strong>In the 20th century, there was a ‘realisation’ that the medium, surface, and even the act of painting itself could form primary components of an artwork.</figcaption></figure><p>The journey into abstraction poses distinct problems for the definition I outlined earlier, namely the idea that art must convey a visual representation. This seemingly solid definition of art, which holds up in explaining much of Western Art pre-1900, was destroyed by the artists who pioneered the first, truly <a href="https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artists/kazimir-malevich-1561/five-ways-look-malevichs-black-square">non-objecvtive art</a>. Perhaps then, the definition can thus be shortened to just read: <em>an arrangement of colours, lines, shapes, forms and materials.</em></p><p>But even this is thwarted with problems … what happens if somebody goes out one day, buys a urinal, and then submits it to a prestigious art association — is that art? There is no colour, line, or form to speak of; in fact, the only act that has been taken by the artist has been to 1) conceive of the idea and 2) purchase the urinal. When Duchamp did this, as I recalled last week, it initiated yet another Cezannesque crisis that threatened to destroy the constituting parameters of art completely. Previously, the abstractions carried out by Picasso, Kandinsky and even Pollock and Rothko could be rationalised by a definition of art that — in addition to my previous criteria of form, line, etc. — requires the presence of a ‘creative act’ that uses certain media, but where does that leave an ‘artwork’ such as <em>A Prelude to a Broken Arm</em>?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/435/1*-lIZ56rq3dXRBl1ycXsr6A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Duchamp, 1915.</strong> Duchamp was decades before his time, which is quite something when you consider he produced art at the same time as Picasso. It wouldn’t be until the era of conceptual art in the 1960s that his true genius could be appreciated.</figcaption></figure><p>Is it a work of art, just a shovel, or both? Did it used to be just a shovel before Duchamp magically turned it into a work of art — or did the <em>viewer</em> turn it into a work of art? These questions led to infinitely more, which is why art theory and the philosophy surrounding it is so dense, and why I now have a sore head.</p><p>In thinking about some of these questions, there’s a useful, real-life analogy that I think is helpful. You might remember the controversy in 2011 when wildlife photographer David Slater left his camera lying around somewhere in a forest in Indonesia, and a very naughty monkey called Naruto grabbed it and (accidentally?) took a <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4e/Macaca_nigra_self-portrait_large.jpg">picture of himself</a>. The gag is, that David was denied copyright of the image on the basis that he didn’t actually take it, and to make things even weirder, PETA then filed a lawsuit ON BEHALF of the monkey (a very normal and respectable use of money), arguing that “the monkey owns the rights and any profits ought to go to him”. David, in turn, stated that he “was the artist and Naruto was simply part of the medium used to create the art”.</p><p>So who is right? Can the selfie in question even be described as art? Is it art without an artist? Like with the Duchamp dilemma, answering this question requires that you confront the fundamental principle of what art is; and for me, any definition of art must include the caveat of <em>intent</em>. If the thing in question was created — or even bought — consciously in the belief that an artistic act has taken place, then it is art. A refusal to accept this means that accidental art must be a possibility or even that art can be made in retrospect. This, of course, would mean that anything and everything could be art, which would in turn make the term redundant and obsolete. As a social construct, art relies on a collective belief if it is to exist. Unlike physical, natural components of our world, which exist independently of humans, constructions of race, gender, money, and art are things that exist only as long as we will them to, and so retaining art as part of a human fabric requires an acceptance that a non-physical element — intent, and the self-aware action of creating — is an essential, and arguably the only, constitution of art. In short, the shovel wasn’t art, and then it was.</p><p>OK, so now we’re closer to understanding what art is (lol imagine), the next step is surely getting to grips with what makes <em>good</em> or <em>bad</em> works of art. I went to a panel talk at the Whitechapel Gallery last week called <a href="https://www.whitechapelgallery.org/events/what-it-means-to-write-about-art/">What it Means to Write About Art</a>, which was incredibly interesting but didn’t do much to convince me that there is much benefit at all in the practice or art ‘criticism’. Surely, art is subjective, and what is heartbreakingly touching to one person can be dull as concrete to another? My feeling throughout the talk was that if we accept that some art is inherently good and others are bad, then we accept that there are certain criteria (whether they be technical, emotional, or otherwise) by which art can be judged. This has been the case historically of course, but the way we quantify the success of a work of art has clearly become more ambiguous, being based more around the feelings of the viewer than anything, and the emotional or spiritual connection that the artist is able to form with them.</p><p>So if this is the case, then how is it possible to conceive of an artwork that is inherently better than another? After hours of trawling through the Stanford Encylopedia of Philosophy and listening to nerdy professors talk about the subject, I’m happy to say that I have no idea — I am literally none the wiser. Kant’s <em>Critique of the Power of Judgment </em>places aesthetic judgement at a very confusing midpoint of <em>subjective universality </em>between subjective judgements and objective, empirical judgements. Kant says that a judgement about the beauty of a thing is not the same as a judgement of “goodness” or “agreeableness” (‘niceness’ and ‘nastiness’), because it is disinterested; that is, it is a pleasure that does not involve desire. When we see something that is beautiful, the judgement is free of motive, it is completely <em>pure</em>. <br>According to Kant, it therefore follows that our judgements of taste/beauty are universally valid in the same way that empirical judgements are, as we feel as though everyone <em>ought</em> to feel the same of us (due to the disinterested nature of our feelings). Unlike empirical judgements, however, they are made as a result of a subjective response.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2iCyCmpH1GvvDb7e.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Gerhard Richter, 1990</strong>. The idea that a painting could be appreciated solely for its aesthetic is a modern concept that would have been met with derision and confusion in pre-modern times.</figcaption></figure><p>So for Kant at least, the idea that a judgement of art is completely relative is not really the case … I’m personally not so sure about this, but what is easier for me to contend with is the idea that deducing the best <em>type </em>of art is essentially meaningless. Applying modern tastes when viewing a Rococo or Baroque painting, for example, is a pointless exercise, as it fails to take into account the historical and sociological factors that enable the painting to make sense, and also fails to judge the painting based on the values of the time (i.e, when paintings were not painted purely for aesthetic purposes).</p><p>My feeling is that your judgement of a painting is made objectively stronger by having a better understanding of the context in which it was created, which is part of the reason I decided to embark on this year-long journey around the National Gallery. Trying to derive <em>only</em> an aesthetic response from a painting in this place would be at odds with the work’s intended purpose, which I feel should be factored into the viewing experience. Doing otherwise would be like judging a spaghetti bolognese without tasting it or judging a car without driving it — it’s just a bit of a miss. With that being said, my detour into whatever this is has come to an awkward end, and I’ll be (fingers-crossed) picking up where I left off next week in <strong>Germany, Rooms 62 &amp; 65.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a13TnAMpjC3wumehcyO8nA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ab0c2a43c06" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s (art) beef?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@louismendee/the-story-of-western-art-starting-in-florence-is-a-story-of-liberation-both-of-the-artist-and-of-8d659f6d8c12?source=rss-e754ca390ac0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d659f6d8c12</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[national-gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artblogchallenge]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Louis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Feb 2019 17:37:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-04T11:52:54.484Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“The Sun is God”, <em>J. M. W. Turner</em></blockquote><h3>What’s (art) beef?</h3><p>The story of Western Art starting in Florence is a story of liberation, both of the artist and of their work. For the artist, liberation has meant that the rigid tastes, prejudices and control of the consumer have lessened, while art has been freed of purpose and the shackles of role and expectation. The autonomy of Art means that it has no obvious explanation: art can be meaningless, meaningful, everything or nothing; it can be visual or invisible; physical or imagined. Artists have knocked down the socially constructed walls of art, and their success continues to bestow more and more possibility; <a href="https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/duchamp-fountain-t07573">Duchamp’s fountain</a> was, yes, a bit of a joke, but it perhaps did more than any Poussin or Gainsborough painting (all tea, all shade) to reinvent the parameters of art. Reinvention and rebellion were uniquely 20th century phenomena, which do not necessarily make <em>fountain </em>any ‘better’ than 17th-19th century masterpieces (which were also products of a particular environment), but if your interest in art is due in part to an interest in <em>change, </em>which I think it is for me, then there is much to be said about the artists who challenged a status quo and refused to subordinate to prevailing norms.</p><p>There were plenty of such artists during the 20th century, but things were easier for them: unlike Mantegna, Picasso was not expected to fulfil a pre-defined function in his art; his artistic ability was not something that could simply be learned in an academy or workshop — individual ingenuity of thought was revered as much as the product or materials of labour, so high was the status of the 20th century artist; and his artistic direction was neither influenced by a tiny elite of patrons/commissioners nor a highly religious, conservative market of consumers.</p><p>Despite the barriers imposed on Renaissance artists, varying schools and styles of art were still able to thrive, and the first major beef we encounter is that of Florentine vs Venetian art. <br>As we’ve seen already, the Renaissance was as much about an intellectual and cultural revival as an artistic one; in establishing a new way of engaging with the modern world around them, humanist Florentines pushed for an art that was naturalistic, ordered and harmonious, where each element of the design was carefully calculated and arranged, almost like how an architect would plan a blueprint. Skilled draftsmanship formed the basis of all successful paintings, and immense detail was applied to preparatory sketches and cartoons way before an artist would even begin to think of secondary concerns such as colour, or light. In prioritising <em>designo</em> over all else, Florence formulated an art of fortitude, where forms were created with precision, sureness and an immaculate sense of clarity (we are yet to get to the works of three greats of the High Renaissance who practised this style most successfully: Raphael, Michaelangelo and Leonardo Da Vinci).</p><p>The art of Venice developed in a subtly different way, however, due to sociological, technological and geographical reasons that I want to write more about when we get to the golden age of Venetian painting (epitomised by Titian); but in essence, the Venetians favoured <em>colorito </em>over <em>designo</em>. That is to say, where the art of Florence used colour as a descriptive tool to embellish designs, the Venetians saw it as a fundamental, inseparable component of the design — as important, if not more important, for creating form than drawn outlines or shapes. While Florentine artists like Micaelangelo would spend months preparing charcoal sketches for eventual transfer onto a painted surface, the Venetian style was a lot more spontaneous: often applying coloured brush strokes directly to canvas, they built the composition as they went, working through problems as and when they were encountered, using looser preliminary sketches (or ‘impressions’, you can see <a href="https://www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/i/impressionism">where this is going</a>) for guidance. The absence of severe form and line led many to criticize the Venetians for a supposed inability to draw, which was, and still kind of is I guess, seen as the ultimate attribute of an artist. But by sacrificing exactness, Venetians were able to explore a role of colour in creating not only a sense of depth, but a realistic interpretation of how light, shadow and forms interact to create atmospheric and even sensuous settings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lnAwl3P4JMAIaAfeQKKK9A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Bellini, 1459–65.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The father of the Venetian tradition of painting is Geovanni Bellini, who I mentioned last week was the brother-in-law of the great Paduan artist Mantegna. They respected each other hugely, which is very evident when comparing their respective catalogues (the recent <a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=mantegna+and+bellini+exhibition&amp;oq=mantegna+and+bellini+exhibition&amp;aqs=chrome.0.0l4.4986j0j7&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8">National Gallery exhibition</a> did this in fact, to mixed acclaim!), but nevertheless chose to go in very different directions with their art despite often choosing identical subjects, themes, and biblical episodes in an ongoing (friendly) rivalry that fuelled their artistic imaginations.</p><p>Bellini’s version of <em>Agony in the Garden </em>was painted at an early point in his career when he was most influenced by the Florentine school pioneered by his brother-in-law. Comparing it to Mantegna’s from last week, there are clear similarities that are self-evident, but what interest’s me is that even at this stage we are able to detect subtle differences that in time will manifest into totally different styles. There’s a smoothness to Bellini’s version that contradicts the severity of Mantegna’s; the figures are more fused within an overarching landscape that is not reduced to theatre backdrop; and look at the sky — light collects in the bottom layer of cumulus cloud and blends with a background haze to create the beautiful red of dawn. Whether the intention is to foreshadow death or even hope is up to grabs in my opinion, but the point is that the landscape itself is being used to convey emotion and make us <em>feel</em>. Without this painting or others like them in the 15th century, I don’t think it is possible to conceive of Turner, or Monet — artists who were in love with the effects of light, and could evoke powerful emotion in landscape alone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KEGQl-aDEmjva_6ic_lxPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Giovanni Battista Cima da Conegliano, 1500</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In room 57, Giovanni Battista Cima da Conegliano’s depiction of Saint Sebastian shows none of the startling anatomical detail of Mantegna’s version (also from last week), and although the figure is purposefully statuesque, the flesh is soft and almost translucent (this may be due to the painting being unfinished though?) and the arrows go through his skin like pins through a cushion. Look also how the artist has experimented with shadow and light by tilting the right side of the model’s body towards the sun. There are no severe contours or demarcations, and instead, the artist has opted for gradual tonal shifts and colour blends; it’s pretty impressive how human-like the figure is without a laboured use of line.</p><p>There is a similar simplicity to Antonello da Messina’s crucifixion, which is my favourite interpretation of the scene that I have seen so far.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M5O8ABqiAQBnabAS4F2BBw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Antonello da Messina, 1475</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Jesus is central to the piece, but this is not a crude crude over-dramatisation. The vastness of the sky, which takes up more than half of the composition, is not intended to intimidate but to reflect the quiet stillness in the aftermath of death, which I think it does in a really modest and touching way. You can almost feel the silence of this painting, which seems to compel a state of contemplation, if not meditation. Looking at this, I can truly understand the power of landscape to conjure emotion in a way that isn’t very easily explained or rationalised, there is a mystery to it that I find intriguing and beautiful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UK7JN28Qf357zVsGUxqOuQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Carlo Crivelli, 1486</strong>. Yes, there were differences in approach, but Venetians were still overcome with the Florentine invention of linear perspective; in this painting, the artist is zealous in his application of perspective, and he has used staircases, an adjoining room, and even a courgette and apple duo (?) to test his skill.</figcaption></figure><p>It’s probably clear already where my preference lies on the <em>colorito </em>vs <em>designo</em> divide, but we’ve only just begun to see how these two branches of Renaissance art develop and offshoot over the centuries. The polarity of Bellini &amp; Mantegna is also seen with Caracci &amp; Caravaggio in the late 16th century, Poussin &amp; Rubens in the 17th century, and Ingres &amp; Delacroix in the early 19th. Of course, these dichotomies are not always useful, arguably do not hold up, and go way beyond the simple <em>colore — designo </em>binary, but they do show that total consensus is something that has rarely existed in the art world since the Renaissance, and that opposing schools of art have driven change and energised artists for centuries.</p><p>The differences between Venice and Florence in the late 15th century, however, seem minute when comparing the collective art of Italy to the rest of the continent at this time. Next week I’ll finally be saying arrivederci and heading North temporarily to see what the rest of Europe was doing while the Italians were having the glow-up of a lifetime.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d659f6d8c12" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>