<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Luigi Pisano on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Luigi Pisano on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@luigipisano?source=rss-be6fe00849c1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 07:48:36 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@luigipisano/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Vehicle emissions control in the 1970s]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@luigipisano/vehicle-emissions-control-in-the-1970s-6663015edbf?source=rss-be6fe00849c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6663015edbf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luigi Pisano]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jul 2015 17:20:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-17T17:20:20.637Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The following article was published in 1976 in the Wall Street Journal. It is still extremely relevant today.</p><p>Being quite hard to find nowadays, I chose to reproduce it here, for the purpose of stimulating discussion on these topics.</p><h2>The Big Stick</h2><h4>California’s Air Board Breaks New Ground With Pollution Limits</h4><h4>It Lambasts Industry, Wins Environmentalist praise; National Ripple Effect?</h4><h4>Fines and Tongue-Lashings</h4><p>By A Richard Immel<br>Staff Reporter of the Wall Street Journal</p><p>SACRAMENTO — As California’s top air quality enforcer, Tom Quinn could hardly be accused of waging a quiet war against smog.</p><p>In the past year, the ex-newsman has issued sheaf after sheaf of blistering press releases directed against those who, in his view, are dirtying the state’s air. he has lambasted the federal government for an “insane, inept” energy policy that, he says, could cause thousands of premature deaths from smog in Los Angeles; blasted the oil industry as polluters who are “playing Russian roulette with the public’s health,” and accused the venerable Los Angeles Air Pollution Control District of failing to enforce its own regulations.</p><p>While such statements predictably have generated considerable controversy, the young man who made them is no paper tiger. Indeed, since taking over as chairman of Californa’s powerful Air Resources Board in January of last year, the 32-year-old Mr. Quinn has turned what was essentially a passive group under former Gov. Ronald Reagan into an environmentalist’s dream, a gough minded board that stands up to some of the biggest industries in the nation.</p><p>Working at a breakneck pace, the new three-member board has become what many regard as the most visible and aggressive public regulatory body in Gov. Edmund G. Brouwn Jr.’s administration. In the past 17 months it has, among other things,</p><p>- Established tough 1977 model-year auto-emission standards that auto makers had persuaded the federal government to postpone for the rest of the country,<br>- Ordered a phaseout of virtually all lead in California gasoline by 1980, and prepared a similar phaseout for sulphur;<br>- Set the first motorcycle emission standards in the US;<br>- Fined American Motors Corp. $4.2 million and Chrysler Corp $328,000 for selling cars in the state that didn’t meet California’s emission standards.</p><p>California, the place where photochemical smog was first identified, has long sperheaded air-pollution control efforts that have influenced national policies. For example, the antipollution catalysts now used in the exhaust systems of virtually all US passenger cars were first developed in the 1960s to meet California’s auto-emission standards.</p><p>Many of the board’s recent rulings are expected to have nationwide imact as well. Tom Austin, a former Environmental Protection Agency auto expert who joined the California staf last fall, says California’s tougher 1977 auto requirements are having a “significant” effect on EPA thinking. Manufacturers had claimed that these standards were impossible to meet without a significant decline in fuel economy. Yet according to the air board, latest tests show that gas mileage for cars meeting the state’s requirements will be only about 5% less than that for non-California cars. “With 10% of the new cars in the US meeting the standards, it means it’s not that difficult to achieve,” Mr. Austin says.</p><p><strong>Going After Smokestacks</strong></p><p>As new automobiles approach the desired emission limits, the board is shifting its attention to what it sees as the most deadly source of pollutants in the future: emissions from stationary sources, such as refinery and factory smokestacks. Even if automobile pollution diminishes markedly in coming years, California air quality experts foresee the total pollution worsening as a result of these smokestack emissions.</p><p>The board recently proposed strict guidelines on stationary sources that are to be adopted by local air-pollution districts. The rules would limit the amount of certain critical pollutants allowable from any new source to 250 pounds a day, a level that industry considers too stringent.</p><p>Reaction to the board’s actions has been predictable. “They’ve moved quickly on important issues that had been delayed for so long,” says Gladys Meade, air conservation director for the California Lung Association and a former board member herself. Even the militant, litigation-oriented Environmental Defense Fund approves. “I’ve been blasting the Brown people in a lot of areas, like water control and forestry, but I can’t fault them on air pollution,” says Tom Graff, regional counsel for EDF.</p><p>The board’s critics have been equally vehement. Los Angeles Air Pollution Control District officials have branded criticisms of their activities as “perverted and distorted.” The auto, oil and chemical industries, while acknowledging a grudging respect for the board as a worthy adversary, complain the agency has moved too far, too fast. They say that Californians are being unjustly penalized with higher-cost gasoline and poorer-running cars for what they say are marginal, and in some cases questionable, air-quality gains. “There ought to be a better way than one that costs California motorists million of dollars,” an oil executive complains.</p><p><strong>A Huge Auto Market</strong></p><p>So far, the decisions of this and previous California air boards have weighted most heavily upon the auto industry. Because of the state’s special air-quality problems, particularly in the smog-prone air basin surrounding Los Angeles, the federal government has allowed California to impose stricter emission controls than EPA requires elsewhere.</p><p>Because the state represents such a huge potential auto market — roughly a million cars — it can’t be ignored. That means auto makers must produce two kinds of cars, a “49-state,” or “federal,” car that meets EPA national standards and a “California” car that meets the tougher state requirements. Current-model autos here are equipped with extra devices and undergo special tests that add about $125 to the cost of making a California version. Car buyers in other states generally subsidize this expense. Chrysler, for example, estimates that only about half of the extra cost is charged directly to Californians.</p><p>Although observers say Mr. Quinn has mellowed during his short tenure on the job, a typical board meeting can still be a harrowing experience for an industry representative. The meetings, which under previous boards were relaxed and leisurely, now frequently turn into marathon sessions that may run past midnight and continue on Saturdays. There are few breaks, even for lunch. The gentlemanly give-and-take of the old days has given way to an inquisitional atmosphere where industry witnesses are questioned sharply.</p><p>At a recent session, for example, Mr. Quinn peers at his witnesses through large horn-rimmed glasses. “Make your point,” he snaps impatiently, as a Volkswagenwerk AG official starts to ramble. After dismissing him, the board next considers a plea from an official from Harley Davidson Motor Co., an AMF Inc. unit, for a delay in presenting motorcycle emissions-control data. The three board members are unimpressed by the technical reasons for the request and tongue-lash the man for his lack of preparation. Finally they agree to the extension, but only, they say, to avoid a legal challenge on the short notice given the company to appear at the hearing.</p><p>Created by legislative statute, the air board has sole responsibility for vehicle pollution control in California. It also oversees the activities of local-air pollution control districts, which are primarily responsible for the control of pollution from stationary sources. Traditionally, its members are appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the governor. Sometimes this pleasure wears thin. Former Gov. Reagan sacked most members of one board two years ago over a disagreement about a controversial board order to equip all older cars in the state with a $35 exhaust-control device.</p><p>The incident came back to haunt the Brown administration in early 1975, resulting in an embarrassing setback for the Quinn board. After the board had reinstated the order, the state legislature passed a bill overruling the board. “It was an inherited program, and we wanted to be forceful,” says former board member Robert Sawyer, who adds that Gov. Brown didn’t think it was worth risking the political confrontation that his veto of the bill would bring.</p><p>Board members come from different backgrounds, but they agree on two things: California’s air pollution problems are getting worse, and the only way to attack them is by taking action, even if it means “forcing technology” — requiring industry to meet standards for which it has no present technology.</p><p>Because it operates with a bare quorum (two seats are vacant), the board has been able to sail through a series of unanimous votes on complicated and controversial issues that often got bottled up in technical studies by previous boards. One member says the closest the group has come to a split vote was on the question of whether smoking should be banned at board meetings. The holdout was Mr. Quinn, a smoker, but he finally gave in.</p><p>“What makes this board such an interesting board is that Quinn has very little experience himself, but he recruited good technical people,” says environmentalist Graff. A recent appointee is 61-year-old Alvin S. Gordon, an engineering professor at the University of California at San Diego. A second member is Mary Nichols, a 29-year-old lawyer who specializes in environmental matters for a public-interest law firm in Los Angeles.</p><p>Catalyst for the group, however, is the politically savvy chairman, who asked for and got the job after managing Mr. Brown’s successful gubernatorial campaign. (He’s also the governor’s cabinet-level environmental adviser.) Why the air board? “I’ve always wanted to do something to get rid of that smog,” says the Los Angeles-raised Mr. Quinn.</p><p>The board also has a top-notch staff. Don Jensen, director of automotive emissions at Ford Motor Co. and former board member himself during the 1960s, calls it “probably the strongest technical staff of any air-pollution group in the US, including the EPA.”</p><p><strong>Watching for Contradictions</strong></p><p>That doesn’t mean the board is always able to outmatch industry, but it does have a big advantage: it can play company against company and industry against industry at its hearings, looking for discrepancies in what industry people say is technologically feasible. “You hope that if you get enough testimony from enough companies each will be a little different,” mr. Sawyer explains. “When you have a really competitive industry, that works well.” For example, he says, foreign auto makers sometimes contradict domestic auto makers’ assessment of which technological innovations can be implemented.</p><p>Industry has quarreled less with the board’s pro-environment stance than with its style, particularly Mr. Quinn’s fondness for poisonous press releases that seem designed to give companies a black eye.</p><p>A former broadcast newsman in Los Angeles before his association with Mr. Brown, Mr. Quinn is adept at showering the board’s actions in media limelight. On controversial actions he sometimes writes his own press releases before a hearing is adjourned, thus beating industry to the punch by getting his side of the news out first.</p><p>“We get on page five after the subject has been aired on page one,” complains Eneas Kane, vice president of research and environmental affairs for Standard Oil Co. of California. Mr. Kane is among those who question the accuracy of some of Mr. Quinn’s statements. His periodic outbursts “create the wrong atmosphere for cooperation,” Mr. Kane says.</p><p><strong>The AMC Debacle</strong></p><p>Similarly, announcements of the stiff American Motors fine (which the board said it would reduce by 75% if the company used the money to improve its test procedures) raised eyebrows in Detroit. To some, the money was less disturbing than public accusations that AMC may have deliberately falsified emissions test data, making AMC cars appear to be the cleanest in the US when they were, in fact, the dirtiest. AMC officials decline to discuss the matter, but they have told the board that the error was caused by malfunctioning test machinery.</p><p>Though the board has withdrawn charges of deliberate falsification, Mr. Quinn is still angry with the company’s handling of the problem. “The situation should never have occurred,” he says. “You can’t be a big corporation like that and have such gross negligence.”</p><p>AMC has challenged the legal basis for the fine, and the board has disputed its challenge. The board says if agreement isn’t reached soon, it will go to court to collect the fine.</p><p>Mr. Quinn shrugs off criticism of his aggressive tactics. “The more pressure you put on (companies), the better citizens they become,” he says. “I don’t think government friendship has accomplished much over the years. That’s the relationship they’re used to, and I think they miss it. When anyone says ill of them, they think you’re an enemy.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6663015edbf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>