<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Stoddard Nathan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Stoddard Nathan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 14:51:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Food Not Bombs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/food-not-bombs-ecb723d78e4f?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ecb723d78e4f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 May 2019 15:40:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-14T15:40:17.649Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This article was originally published in the November/December 2016 issue of the Honest Weight Food Co-op’s Coop Scoop. You can read the article as originally formatted </em><a href="https://issuu.com/honestweightfoodcoop/docs/novdec2016coopscoop_for_web_1/6"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Every Monday at 5 p.m. in Albany’s Townsend Park, a narrow triangle between Central and Washington Avenues, a sandwich-board sign promises something dubious: “FREE FOOD.” An arrow points to a row of folding tables, crowded with bowls of vegan fare: roasted okra, stringbeans, and squash; veggie burgers; potato-leek soup; pasta; corn-tomato salsa; baked tofu; garlic bread; mashed potatoes; stir-fry with peanut sauce; big apple pies; small apple pies; fruit salad; and fruit pudding. “It sounds weird, but it’s good,” Jay Toraty, 24, said of the last dessert, which he made by mixing soy milk with mashed peaches, bananas, and pears.</p><p>“That’s a pretty good spread,” said Nickleson Cook, 31, as three dozen diners queued up for a free meal one Monday in September — no money down, questions asked, or sermons suffered. Hours earlier, Cook, who is front-end floor manager at Honest Weight, squeezed fifteen boxes of culled produce and baked goods from the Slingerlands ShopRite into his Honda Fit, dropped the haul at another volunteer’s apartment on Elm Street in the Mansion Area, and, after a short recess, convened with several others at the Albany Free School a little after 2 p.m. to cook the food. (Honest Weight also donates provisions to the cause.)</p><p>The alternative school’s commercial kitchen makes improvisational cooking, at scale, feasible. “I think all of us have things that we’re familiar with that we feel comfortable making…It’s a great [place] to just practice,” said Mei-Yee Yau, 26, of Rensselaer, while chopping vegetables for a to-be-determined soup. I asked if the process was stressful. “Once everybody is cooking a dish and the oven and the stove are, like, completely hot — that’s when the chaos starts happening,” she said.</p><p>The chaos started just after 4 p.m., heralded by the arrival of Keith Chan, a professor in the School of Social Welfare at SUNY Albany and the operation’s designated food transporter. “What’s on the menu?” Chan asked.</p><p>“The judge is here!” Cook announced in a mock-seigneurial tone.</p><p>“Panic time,” Yau said quietly. The grassroots, volunteer-supported, unincorporated association — an everchanging coterie of about twenty people — is known as Food Not Bombs of Albany. It is one of an estimated 500 independent chapters worldwide, united and governed by a commitment to three principles, according to Cook: 1) free vegan or vegetarian meals for all, 2) nonviolent, direct action — the group’s distribution of food is not charity, according to its website, but rather “a way of protesting war and poverty” — and 3) consensus-based decisionmaking.</p><p>Chan, who was once homeless as a college student in the early ’90s, brought the dishes to the Albany Social Justice Center on Central Avenue, which holds some of the group’s supplies and hosts indoor Food Not Bombs events in winter and inclement weather. Cook and I carried metal chairs across the four-lane state highway from the SJC to the park, which has lacked benches since 2009, when they were removed due to complaints about “unruly crowds,” according to the Times Union.</p><p>Diners gave positive reviews. Rose Sebastino, 56, of Albany, enjoyed the potato-leek soup — one of the only items she could eat, she told me, because she did not have any upper teeth. Her husband Anthony, 61, liked the soup, too, though he thought it needed more “spices and seasonings.” (He planned to bring his own special dish — eggplant parmigiana — next Monday.) The couple shared an origin story too uncanny to omit: They dated as children in Albany, lost touch, then reconnected by chance in 2014 on Lovelinks, a phone chatline service, while Anthony was imprisoned. They married one month before his release last year. On the day of her husband’s release, Rose fell and fractured her spine. She is now disabled. “He does everything for me,” she said meal at Townsend Park on Monday, September 19th, 2016. with reverence. “When we were kids he upward. His and his wife’s combined she drives, she pulls over to rest every used to buy me candy.”</p><p>Even after I explained that I was only a journalist, not a volunteer, Carlo Patino, 67, an Argentinian immigrant, would not stop shaking my hand. “I’m not homeless,” he whispered, smiling as he held up two loaves of ShopRite bread. Patino moved to Albany six months from Queens, where he worked as a housekeeper at Jamaica Hospital Medical Center, “because the rent”—here he stopped talking and let his hands spiral upward. His and his wife’s combined monthly income is $1,800; their rent in Albany, at $850, is nearly $400 less than what they paid downstate. (According to the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, families “who pay more than 30 percent of their income for housing are considered cost burdened.”) “New York City—it’s impossible,” he said.</p><p>Around 7 p.m., as the event wrapped up, I met Karen LaDuke, 44, of Clifton Park, who held two tupperware containers half-filled with the last of the soup. LaDuke lost her job in a medical office in June. The next month she sustained a concussion in a car crash that left her cognitively impaired. She cannot afford her monthly mortgage payment of $1,150, and her home will soon be foreclosed. “It’s getting impossible for me to get groceries,” she said, despite visiting “pretty much every [food] pantry” in the Capital District throughout the week. She is prescribed anti-anxiety, -seizure, -nausea, and -headache medications—all related to the concussion—though she’s wary of taking any of them. When she drives, she pulls over to rest every fifteen minutes, which means she is often late to pick up her 11-year-old daughter from various functions.</p><p>That Food Not Bombs needs to exist at all, in a country of extraordinary private wealth, is disheartening. The Albany chapter is in its fourth iteration in about a decade, and though Cook is ideating an expansion to the South End, history suggests that the present effort will eventually peter out, too. That’s not a dig at the dogged efforts of the cooks and gofers and coordinators involved, but a recognition of the limits of volunteerism in a capitalist economy. Food Not Bombs of Albany, an elaborate orchestration, feeds about fifty people once a week in a downtown pocket park. What else could be done? “If we had ten percent of people in Albany donating their time towards [Food Not Bombs],” Cook told me, “we could feed so many people. There’s no shortage of food to take from grocery stores.” There’s also, evidently, no shortage of hungry people. Whether those plain facts will move policymakers and citizens alike to do something, or do more, to further food justice remains to be seen.</p><p>###</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ecb723d78e4f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Renewal is All Wrong]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/when-renewal-is-all-wrong-ee26caac3392?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee26caac3392</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-planning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 May 2019 15:18:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-14T15:42:20.806Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This piece was originally published in the January/February 2017 issue (“Renewal”) of the Honest Weight Food Co-op’s Coop Scoop. You can read it as originally formatted </em><a href="https://issuu.com/honestweightfoodcoop/docs/january_february_2017_coop_scoop_fo/10"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>“The new mid-town arterial,” the Times Union editorial board gushed in 1968, “is only one link in the lacy network which will bisect and encircle the city in graceful but practical ribbons.” Endorsed by Governor Rockefeller and Mayor Corning, the proposed $112.5 million highway featured “twin 1,600-foot-long ventilated tunnels, each of which would carry two lanes of traffic under the eastern edge of Washington Park” — and called for the destruction of 351 buildings and the displacement of 741 families, according to other reports.</p><p>The T.U. editorial’s title, “The City of the Future,” offers a clue as to how people — who, presumably, had seen highways — could find them beautiful. (“At first glance it looks like modern art,” a Knickerbocker News caption says of the Patroon Island Bridge interchange.) Boosters forecast Albany as an Epcotian tomorrowland. “It is unfortunate that the dreams of future Albany cannot be realized with a mere snap of the fingers,” the newspaper lamented, though it curbed its impatience by imagining future generations’ gratitude. When “all of today’s planned construction and perhaps more is in place,” it predicted, “the citizens who are still around will look back [on] the 1965–1975 decade as one marked by things being torn down, and carted away, and built up again in vast new forms and shapes.” This was prescient — except today, such recollections are tinged with pained incredulity, in light of the disproportionate impact urban renewal has had on marginalized communities nationwide.</p><p>Fortunately, the midtown arterial never despoiled Washington Park. Neighborhood resistance killed the proposal — as, a decade earlier, a similar effort in a similarly named square scotched Robert Moses’ dream of a highway through Greenwich Village. Jane Jacobs, the urban theorist best known for The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961), led that charge, and her work popularized the sort of human-scale, pedestrian-friendly ethos behind the now-common belief among Albanians that the “lacy network” corseting the capital is a fatal encumbrance.</p><p>The “long-delayed Riverfront Arterial,” as the Times Union was calling I-787 by 1966 (not completed for another half-decade), is the tightest stricture. Albany’s current comprehensive plan basically says so. The six-lane superhighway, which serves 80,000 automobiles a day, “represents a visual and physical barrier between the City and its waterfront,” the planning document states. “Replacing the elevated highway with an urban arterial at or below grade would have a dramatic impact on the visual attractiveness of the City of Albany, walkability, and potentially create additional developable land.” A $320,000 study on how to do something along those lines, funded largely by the state Department of Transportation, is expected to be completed this summer.</p><p>The planners and politicians maybe meant well. After all, once upon a time, the Hudson River was “just the smelly sewer that [ran] through the middle of town,” city historian Tony Opalka told me, when I browsed the Pruyn Collection of local history at the Albany Public Library. “When I was growing up, you wouldn’t go near it,” he added.</p><p>The highways augured, in theory, an influx of shoppers — a boon to business. “The task for Albany is to make itself so attractive in every way, including commercially, as to ensure two-way traffic on those arterials, with people pouring into the city rather than only fleeing it,” Knickerbocker News wrote. Many chose the second option, though the glut of highways and parking lots made visits convenient.</p><p>At the Pruyn Collection, the contents of two thick manila folders — tagged “Albany Highways” and “Urban Renewal,” respectively — constitute not just priceless records of thoughts and actions, but monuments to the fallibility of planners, politicians, and journalists alike. Everyone was so certain, and so wrong.</p><p>I’ll temper that: a few were right. In 1966, at a public hearing in the Assembly parlor, Virginia Malone, speaking on behalf of her neighborhood association, urged the Joint Legislative Committee on Motor Vehicles, Traffic and Highway Safety to “shift this country to a different gear,” according to the Times Union. Cars are fine, Malone conceded, but “there is also a need for trains and buses and for the matter, bicycles — to get from one place to another.”</p><p>“Far more than this,” she added, referring to the Washington Park arterial, “we need cities in which people can walk to work if they choose.” How did that one go over? An Automobile Club of New York representative could not let it slide. “The fact is,” he declared, “no vehicle [has] yet been developed or [is] even in prospect that equal[s] the automobile for speed, comfort, privacy, economy, and other qualities that people value.”</p><p>Donald Walsh, an attorney with the New York Conference of Mayors, clapped back. “We submit that city traffic problems cannot be resolved by tearing down the city and laying more and more concrete,” he said.</p><p>Nice sentiment, Walsh — but it was already too late. In early 1961, Knickerbocker News reported, “Roman Catholic priest and urban renewal expert” Rev. Robert G. Howes spoke to hundreds of officials — including Mayor Corning and the city’s planning consultants — about the perils of their exuberance. Howes warned of “over-idealism and spectacularism … which focuses on plazas and modern architecture and neglects ordinary people.”</p><p>One year later, the state claimed 98 acres in downtown Albany, the future site of the South Mall.</p><p>###</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee26caac3392" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who is RensCo DA Mary Pat Donnelly?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/who-is-rensco-da-mary-pat-donnelly-6df647c8ef0e?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6df647c8ef0e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rensselaer-county]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Apr 2019 17:10:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-11T17:10:00.327Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This story, with a different headline, was originally published by </em><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/business/article/The-Alt-newsweekly-shutting-down-13196558.php"><em>The Alt</em></a><em> on May 7, 2018. The Alt’s website is defunct, and this story was not captured by the Internet Archive before its disappearance, so I’m republishing it here, for posterity.</em></p><p>Jack Conway, now town supervisor of East Greenbush, met Mary Pat Donnelly at a zoning board hearing a little over a decade ago, when she served as the board’s attorney. After the hearing, Conway’s feet “froze” — he has a gout problem — and so he sat there, somewhat immobilized, as many attendees walked past him.</p><p>Donnelly noticed. She lent Conway her cell phone to call his wife, sat with him until she arrived, and helped him into the car. They’ve been friends ever since.</p><p>“I have no objectivity on this — she’s one of my favorite people,” Conway told <em>The Alt </em>in a recent interview. On the bench — Donnelly served as town justice from 2012 until last month, when she resigned after being <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Democratic-candidate-for-Rensselaer-DA-resigns-12851935.php">picked</a> by Rensselaer County Democrats to run for district attorney — Donnelly has the “perfect judicial temperament,” a blend of compassion and toughness, Conway said.</p><p>As the county’s top prosecutor, she’d strike that same balance, Conway predicted: “a law-and-order district attorney who never loses sight of the concept of justice.”</p><p>In interviews with <em>The Alt</em>, local defense attorneys who have represented clients in Donnelly’s court also rated her highly.</p><p>“Fair and impartial,” Andrew Safranko said of the town judge. She “holds [prosecutors’] feet to the fire if they don’t have the elements to prove their case,” and “has set appropriate bail” when prosecutors ask for something beyond that, he said.</p><p>She’s “just courteous, which is sorely lacking in a lot of town judgeships,” said veteran Albany defense lawyer James Long. Some judges want to rush cases to clear their calendar, Long added, but Donnelly is patient and “even-keeled.”</p><p>Donnelly, 44, may face a more polarizing incumbent who, according to state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, has flouted the law.</p><p>Joel Abelove, a Republican <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Abelove-is-winner-of-DA-s-race-5888555.php">narrowly</a> elected four years ago, was charged in December with official misconduct and perjury related to his handling of the fatal police shooting of Edson Thevenin, an African-American man who had fled a DWI stop in his vehicle. A trial is set for June, though Abelove, who pleaded not guilty and maintains his innocence, has <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/04/09/abelove-seeks-indictment-dismissal/">moved to dismiss the indictment</a> filed by state prosecutors.</p><p>Abelove has not said publicly whether he intends to seek reelection. (The county Republican committee didn’t return a phone call, and the prosecutor’s campaign didn’t return a message sent through <a href="http://www.joelabelove.com/">its website</a> last week.)</p><p>In a phone interview Friday, Donnelly declined to say whether she believes Abelove should have resigned, as the <em>New York Times</em> editorial board <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/13/opinion/abelove-district-attorney.html">suggested</a> and Democratic county legislators <a href="http://www.troyrecord.com/article/TR/20171204/NEWS/171209920">demanded</a>, when charges were filed against him.</p><p>She also, perhaps more notably, would not say outright that she agrees with Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s 2015 executive order appointing Attorney General Eric Schneiderman as special prosecutor in cases where cops have killed unarmed civilians, though she said she’d obey it. (Abelove, after he’d already convened a grand jury that opted not to indict the cop who killed Thevenin, was sued into compliance by Schneiderman.)</p><p>“I can understand why law enforcement…may not appreciate [the executive order], but I do think that it can be a good thing,” she said. “An independent body that does not have ties to the law enforcement agency in question could only seek to get the truth out and perhaps bring honor back to everyone.”</p><p>Donnelly has considerable ties to law enforcement. Her husband is an Albany police officer, <a href="http://www.legacy.com/obituaries/timesunion-albany/obituary.aspx?n=timothy-joseph-murphy&amp;pid=14740466&amp;fhid=5016">as was her late father</a>, Timothy Murphy, who died in 2005. Her mother, Toni Murphy, the East Greenbush tax collector, also <a href="https://esd.ny.gov/sites/default/files/08302017_TechValleySecurity_RecommendedOrder.pdf">owns Tech Valley Security</a>, a consulting firm established by her husband two years before his death and long led by a former Albany police chief.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xQyT9XPcrzlvoaK7Mk5ZeA.jpeg" /><figcaption>East Greenbush Town Hall (5/7/18)</figcaption></figure><p>In her only <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Outside-Troy-more-party-lines-mattered-4017898.php">competitive race</a>, in 2012, Donnelly’s largest donation, of $2,500, came from <a href="http://www.elections.ny.gov:8080/reports/rwservlet?cmdkey=efs_sch_report+p_filer_id=C87901+p_e_year=2012+p_freport_id=E+p_transaction_code=B">Council 82</a>, a law enforcement officers’ union.</p><p>When we asked Donnelly what she would say to progressives who might be wary of her familial links to police, she said she had “thought a lot about this” but then spoke about how “isolated cases cause a stain on all of the wonderful men and women that do this job.”</p><p>“I live the life of a police officer, and I have my entire life,” she said. “I know the sacrifices, I know the pain, and I know how…much it hurts to be painted with a broad brush.”</p><p>Donnelly took fairly moderate positions on the policy-related questions we asked. She believes all police officers should be fitted with body-worn cameras (“It could only protect the ones that are doing their job correctly, which is the bulk of them”). She’s “in favor of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/07/nyregion/defendants-kept-in-the-dark-about-evidence-until-its-too-late.html">open discovery</a>,” or requiring prosecutors to turn over evidence to the defense with ample time before trial, as long as no one’s safety is jeopardized.</p><p>She called LEAD — Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion, a program that allows police officers to refer people suspected of certain low-level crimes to social workers in lieu of arrest and prosecution — “wonderful,” and said she’d prioritize implementing it in Rensselaer County if she had the opportunity. (The program was <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Albany-launches-LEAD-diversion-program-7219908.php">brought to Albany</a> in 2016.)</p><p>She declined to make a blanket commitment to not prosecute marijuana possession cases. While she said she appreciates the trend toward legalization, and acknowledged that “a solitary charge of marijuana” is “probably not a valuable use of resources,” she maintained that “there can be a function to a low-level marijuana charge — depending on if it’s linked to something else, depending on if it is an individual who may have a bigger problem.” The charge could present “an opportunity to maybe get them in front of a body that can provide them with some sort of support or treatment,” Donnelly said.</p><p>She emphasizes, correctly, that the statutory purpose of bail is to ensure defendants return to court, not to serve as preemptive punishment. But she does not support Gov. Cuomo’s proposal to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/02/nyregion/cuomo-ending-cash-bail-state-of-the-state.html">end cash bail for misdemeanors and some felonies</a> because “bail has its place in certain circumstances,” she said.</p><p>She declined to say whether she thought Sheriff Patrick Russo should withdraw from <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/20/nyregion/new-york-rensselaer-county-ice-jails.html">his office’s partnership with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement</a>, as Democratic county lawmakers have urged.</p><p>Notwithstanding the rather middle-of-the-road posture her opinions evince, Donnelly is seeking the Working Families Party’s endorsement. Anita Thayer, secretary of the WFP’s Capital District chapter, told us the endorsement process for the race is still unfolding, though Donnelly is the lone applicant.</p><p>Donnelly has spent the bulk of her career as a court attorney in Albany City Court, assisting judges with drafting decisions and researching law. Before taking that job, she spent a year as a state’s attorney in Vermont, which is equivalent to an assistant district attorney in New York. She has also volunteered for an array of local causes, <a href="http://egedfoundation.org/hall%20of%20fame%20bios/Donnelly.pdf">according to an East Greenbush Education Foundation biography from 2015</a>.</p><p>It remains to be seen if Donnelly’s blend of legal expertise, centrism, and amiability — she’s “built for” knocking on doors, Conway, the town supervisor, said — will help her win her first countywide election.</p><p>She may also expect support from law enforcement, considering her background and potential opponent. The <em>Times Union</em> has <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/local/article/felony-cases-linger-in-rensselear-county-12398856.php">reported</a> that, under the current administration, cops in Rensselaer County “are not happy” about the number of felony cases that have been dismissed by courts for not being presented to a grand jury in a timely manner.</p><p>While she alluded to the speedy-trial issue in an <a href="http://www.troyrecord.com/article/TR/20180428/NEWS/180429795">interview with the Troy Record</a>, for now, Donnelly seems somewhat loath to critique her prospective opponent in detail, at least at this early stage of the campaign.</p><p>If she sharpens her rhetoric, don’t expect her to sound like <a href="https://theintercept.com/2018/03/20/larry-krasner-philadelphia-da/">Larry Krasner</a>, a Philadelphia civil rights lawyer elected district attorney last year while promising radical criminal justice reforms.</p><p>For instance, Donnelly takes issue with Abelove’s alleged attempt at circumventing the Cuomo executive order, but at least partly because she thinks it may have denied Sgt. Randall French, the officer who killed Thevenin, the chance of a “clean exoneration.”</p><p>“The attorney general came to the same conclusion, essentially, as the grand jury,” Donnelly said. “I think, and I would hope, that if there had been cooperation with the executive order, that the [AG’s] conclusion would have had a less tragic effect on so many people.”</p><p>In its <a href="https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/oag_report_-_edson_thevenin.pdf">report on the matter</a>, the AG’s office said it could not disprove that French’s use of force was justified, since a forensic analysis could not rule out the possibility that Thevenin’s car was moving toward the officer when the first shot was fired.</p><p>The report did conclude, however, that French’s (and the police department’s) claim that Thevenin’s car “pinned him before he started shooting” was untrue. Even if Abelove had cooperated promptly with the AG, was a cloud-free absolution ever really possible?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6df647c8ef0e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Links to My (Archived) Stories for The Alt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/links-to-my-archived-stories-for-the-alt-c4cd747202f?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4cd747202f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Apr 2019 15:05:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-13T20:09:26.920Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Shortly after </em><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/business/article/The-Alt-newsweekly-shutting-down-13196558.php"><em>The Alt shut down in Sept. 2018</em></a><em>, its website also vanished. Fortunately, many, though not all, of my stories for the outlet were preserved by the Internet Archive. Below, I have compiled links to the archived stories I’ve found. <br>- LSN 4/10/19</em></p><p><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708212942/http://thealt.com:80/2016/11/22/no-shelter-here/">No Shelter Here</a> (11/22/16)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20161209192843/http://thealt.com:80/2016/11/29/nimby-versus-affordable-housing-saratoga-springs/">NIMBY versus affordable housing in Saratoga Springs</a> (11/29/16)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170107220853/http://thealt.com:80/2017/01/02/searching-troy-cans-hope-election-night/">Searching Troy for cans and hope on election night</a> (1/2/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180703061829/http://thealt.com:80/2017/02/27/departed-suny-poly-execs-not-resign-personnel-records-show/">Departed SUNY Poly execs did not resign, personnel records show</a> (2/27/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180705001030/http://thealt.com:80/2017/03/13/mysterious-big-poles-cause-controversy-troy/">Mysterious big poles cause controversy in Troy</a> (3/13/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170724054012/http://thealt.com:80/2017/03/16/trumps-funding-cuts-end-local-housing-programs-homeless-aid-services/">Trump’s budget cuts could end local housing programs, homeless aid, other services</a> (3/16/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180216090942/http://thealt.com:80/2017/04/11/sunys-many-affiliates-revealed/">SUNY’s many affiliates revealed</a> (4/11/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620215621/http://thealt.com:80/2017/05/04/momentive-will-pay-1-25-million-settle-environmental-claims/">Momentive will pay $1.25 million to settle environmental claims</a> (5/4/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170712213814/http://thealt.com/2017/05/15/troys-telecom-skirmish-sign-national-shift/">Is Troy’s telecom skirmish a sign of national shift?</a> (5/15/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170610110145/http://thealt.com/2017/06/05/troys-public-housing-authority-pursues-private-funding/">Troy’s public housing authority pursues private funding</a> (6/5/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170624175837/http://thealt.com:80/2017/06/15/private-investigators-buffalo-billion-probe-contract-worth-1-million-finally-approved-comptroller/">Private investigator’s Buffalo Billion probe contract — worth more than $1 million — finally approved by comptroller</a> (6/15/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180228044226/http://thealt.com:80/2017/06/19/5649/">Ex-lobbyist Todd Howe got a new job in Idaho, attorneys say</a> (6/19/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180705002818/http://thealt.com:80/2017/06/21/troy-ethics-commission-hasnt-met-year/">Troy ethics commission hasn’t met this year</a> (6/21/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170731183604/http://thealt.com:80/2017/07/28/6433/">After eight-month wait, SUNY Poly releases emails Kaloyeros received on day of arrest</a> (7/28/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708212221/http://thealt.com:80/2017/08/03/schwartz-probe-announcement-research-foundation-hired-outside-counsel/">After Schwartz probe announcement, Research Foundation hired outside counsel</a> (8/3/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170812184626/http://thealt.com:80/2017/08/09/6585/">Public defender highlights importance of Albany City Court election</a> (8/9/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170816201541/http://thealt.com:80/2017/08/11/new-filings-mayor-kathy-sheehan-loaned-campaign-162000-july/">New filings: Mayor Kathy Sheehan loaned her campaign $162,000 in July</a> (8/11/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708212226/http://thealt.com:80/2017/08/29/6991/">SUNY shares contract with deletable redactions</a> (8/29/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170903203524/http://thealt.com/2017/08/30/outside-fray-mclaughlin-follows-people-oriented-approach/">Outside the fray, McLaughlin follows people-oriented approach</a> (8/30/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180607213840/http://thealt.com:80/2017/09/25/new-suny-foundation-already-strayed-mission/">Has a new SUNY foundation already strayed from its mission?</a> (9/25/17) <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170928194801/http://thealt.com/2017/09/25/7478/">SUNY Research Foundation conceals info about bad debt</a> (9/25/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180526175829/http://thealt.com:80/2017/10/16/whats-next-troys-one-monument-square/">What’s next for Troy’s One Monument Square?</a> (10/16/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180704181344/http://thealt.com:80/2017/10/26/interview-guy-ladouceur-pecks-arcade-tavern-bar/">Interview: Guy Ladouceur, Peck’s Arcade &amp; Tavern Bar</a> (10/26/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181106214050/http://thealt.com/2017/11/02/feds-percoco-threatened/">Feds: Percoco “threatened at least four” state employees</a> (11/2/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181112034230/http://thealt.com/2017/11/09/8298/">Newly released sheriff’s video shows airport foam incident</a> (11/9/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180418051402/http://thealt.com:80/2017/11/10/six-state-agencies-retain-outside-counsel-worth-1-9-million-federal-probe/">Six state agencies retained outside counsel worth $1.9 million for federal probe</a> (11/10/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181112032719/http://thealt.com/2017/11/13/complaint-suny-new-paltz-cops-slept-on-job-falsified-timesheets/">Complaint: SUNY New Paltz cops slept on job, falsified timesheets</a> (11/13/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181112071119/http://thealt.com/2017/11/15/state-ag-suny-poly-didnt-produce-emails-responsive-subpoena/">Fuller Road counsel challenges accuracy of AG affidavit</a> (11/15/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171226122428/http://thealt.com:80/2017/11/22/rosenblum-companies-eyes-new-project-downtown-troy/">The Rosenblum Companies eyes new potential project in downtown Troy</a> (11/22/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180203132911/http://thealt.com:80/2017/11/22/nearly-three-dozen-properties-close-to-rpi-sell-for-9-5-million/">Nearly three dozen properties close to RPI sell for $9.5 million</a> (11/22/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171204073009/http://thealt.com:80/2017/12/01/cuomo-counsel-considers-potential-next-steps-regarding-rensco-da/">Cuomo considers ‘potential next steps’ regarding Rensco DA</a> (12/1/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180208121547/http://thealt.com:80/2017/12/04/suny-claims-foundation-donor-names-are-trade-secrets/">SUNY claims foundation donor names are ‘trade secrets’</a> (12/4/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180428204113/http://thealt.com:80/2017/12/07/rensco-legislature-will-ask-sheriff-present-ice-partnership-plans-publicly/">RensCo legislature will ask sheriff to present ICE partnership plans publicly</a> (12/7/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620045416/http://thealt.com:80/2017/12/12/help-capital-regions-homeless-population-winter/">How to help the Capital Region’s homeless population this winter</a> (12/12/17)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620215633/http://thealt.com:80/2017/12/12/county-property-transactions-troy-put-hold/">County property transactions in Troy put on hold</a> (12/12/17) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180315154501/http://thealt.com/2018/01/10/percoco-trial-primer/">The Percoco trial: a primer</a> (1/10/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180116081651/http://thealt.com:80/2018/01/11/state-public-authorities-hired-law-firm-bharara-probe/">State public authorities also hired law firm for Bharara probe</a> (1/11/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180526184154/http://thealt.com:80/2018/01/19/bryce-takes-cdta-to-court/">Bryce takes CDTA to court</a> (1/19/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180628130418/http://thealt.com:80/2018/01/19/one-year-later-cities-adapt-zombie-property-legislation/">One year in, cities adapt to ‘zombie’ property law</a> (1/19/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180705001011/http://thealt.com:80/2018/01/31/internal-suny-probe-found-fraud-misconduct-buff-state-program/">Internal SUNY probe ‘found fraud and misconduct’ in Buff State program</a> (1/31/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180517190213/http://thealt.com:80/2018/02/02/trustees-question-suny-foundations-related-party-deals/">Trustees question SUNY foundations’ related-party deals</a> (2/2/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180212131802/http://thealt.com/2018/02/06/former-trojan-hotel-auctioned-for-196k-but-questions-linger/">Former Trojan Hotel sells for $196K</a> (2/6/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180211074425/http://thealt.com:80/2018/02/07/soares-named-special-prosecutor-troy-pba-ex-prez-case/">Soares named special prosecutor in Troy PBA ex-prez case</a> (2/7/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180705144831/http://thealt.com:80/2018/02/09/bryce-petition-cdta-adds-detail-eminent-domain-docs/">CDTA adds detail to eminent domain docs amid Bryce’s challenge</a> (2/9/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180705143907/http://thealt.com:80/2018/02/23/courtwatching-deposit-no-longer-prerequisite-rent-abatement-hearing-troy/">Courtwatching: Deposits no longer required for rent abatement hearings in Troy</a> (2/23/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180511185659/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/06/irish-mist-building-near-troy-canal-sells-brooklyn-company/">Former Irish Mist building near Troy canal sells to Brooklyn company</a> (3/6/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180515083529/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/10/courtwatching-meet-city-marshal/">Courtwatching: Meet a Troy city marshal</a> (3/10/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180315170244/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/13/yesfolk-eyes-sustainable-growth/">Yesfolk eyes sustainable growth</a> (3/13/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180418065953/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/14/police-officer-allegedly-assaulted-downtown-troy/">Troy police officer allegedly assaulted, injured</a> (3/14/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180528143604/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/19/cdtas-ridership-declining/">Why is CDTA’s ridership declining?</a> (3/19/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180323210848/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/20/10340/">SUNY foundation ‘created its own version’ of standard vetting form</a> (3/20/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180526183951/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/21/troy-ldc-sues-enforce-casale-settlement-agreement/">Troy LDC sues to enforce Casale settlement agreement</a> (3/21/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180601045636/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/26/courtwatching-bail-gets-set/">Courtwatching: How bail gets set</a> (3/26/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180604214231/http://thealt.com:80/2018/03/30/state-found-issues-saratoga-county-jail-last-year/">State found issues at Saratoga County jail last year</a> (3/30/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708213120/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/02/former-albany-police-chief-supports-bail-reform/">Former Albany police chief supports bail reform</a> (4/2/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180420011151/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/09/abelove-seeks-indictment-dismissal/">Abelove seeks indictment’s dismissal</a> (4/9/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180622220704/http://thealt.com/2018/04/12/bill-would-repeal-ny-loitering/">Bill would repeal New York’s prostitution loitering law</a> (4/12/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180624213449/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/17/will-massachusetts-pot-shops-lure-new-york-tourists/">Will Massachusetts’ pot shops lure New York tourists?</a> (4/17/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180421100807/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/19/reforms-needed-justice-courts-state-bar/">Reforms needed in justice courts, state bar association says</a> (4/19/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180704005355/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/24/ldc-casale-disbursing-not-removing-debris-south-troy-site/">LDC: Casale was disbursing, not removing, debris at South Troy site</a> (4/24/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180704005205/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/25/troy-real-estate-developer-files-claim-city-de-facto-taking/">Troy developer files claim against city over sewer installation</a> (4/25/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180630215536/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/26/rosenblum-closes-deal-for-former-keybank-site-in-downtown-troy/">Rosenblum closes deal for former KeyBank site in downtown Troy</a> (4/26/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180701194334/http://thealt.com:80/2018/04/27/theres-halfpipe-collar-city-bridge-now/">There’s a halfpipe under the Collar City Bridge</a> (4/27/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180707071933/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/01/exclusive-redburns-unsuccessful-proposal-1-monument-square-revealed/">Exclusive: Redburn’s unsuccessful proposal for 1 Monument Square, revealed</a> (5/1/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180616014548/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/11/bonacio-redburn-eye-hudson-waterfront-parcel-as-basilica-founders-call-for-mindful-development/">Bonacio, Redburn eye Hudson waterfront parcel as Basilica founders call for ‘mindful development’</a> (5/11/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620043318/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/11/troy-police-chief-body-worn-camera-policy-may-released-two-months/">Troy police chief: Body-worn camera policy may be released in two months</a> (5/11/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620045148/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/16/instagram-account-captures-amazing-parking-efforts-in-troy/">Instagram account captures ‘amazing’ parking efforts in Troy</a> (5/16/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180529232128/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/21/man-was-savagely-beaten-by-troy-cops-defense-attorney-says/">Man was ‘savagely beaten’ by Troy cops, defense attorney says</a> (5/21/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180530233544/http://thealt.com/2018/05/24/rosenblum-gets-site-plan-approval-for-ex-keybank-project-in-troy/">Rosenblum gets site plan approval for ex-KeyBank project in Troy</a> (5/24/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180628121300/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/24/ex-porn-theater-project-in-troy-not-moribund/">Ex-porn theater project in Troy still possible</a> (5/24/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180628123412/http://thealt.com:80/2018/05/24/cdta-will-bring-trolleys-to-albany/">CDTA will bring trolleys to Albany</a> (5/24/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180601045033/http://thealt.com/2018/05/25/big-parcel-sale-not-game-over-for-troy-nature-trails-proponents-say/">Big parcel sale not game over for Troy nature trails, proponents say</a> (5/25/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180602040802/http://thealt.com/2018/05/29/community-builders-eyes-site-near-troy-canal">Affordable housing developer eyes site near Troy canal</a> (5/29/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180602034557/http://thealt.com/2018/05/29/local-leaders-want-a-rensselaer-troy-bike-path/">Local leaders want a Rensselaer-Troy bike path</a> (5/29/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180602235700/http://thealt.com/2018/05/30/judge-development-may-start-mccarthy-building-renovations-soon/">Judge Development may start McCarthy Building renovations soon</a> (5/30/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180603034745/http://thealt.com/2018/05/31/troys-state-st-parking-garage-staircase-partly-closed/">Troy’s State St. parking garage staircase partly closed</a> (5/31/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180607040211/http://thealt.com/2018/06/01/troys-bike-path-extension-still-under-construction/">Troy’s bike path extension ‘still under construction’</a> (6/1/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180609041745/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/04/chinese-restaurant-said-to-be-slated-for-ex-minissales-building/">Chinese restaurant slated for ex-Minissale’s building</a> (6/4/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180609132533/http://thealt.com/2018/06/06/rensselaer-albany-gondola-project-will-seek-state-funding-again/">Rensselaer-Albany gondola project will seek state funding again</a> (6/6/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180609132538/http://thealt.com/2018/06/07/11700/">O’Briens Pub in Troy closes</a> (6/7/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180613131215/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/11/troy-to-study-hoosick-street-again/">Troy to study Hoosick Street (again)</a> (6/11/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180613130938/http://thealt.com/2018/06/11/state-plans-first-overall-rehab-of-collar-city-bridge/">State plans ‘first overall’ rehab of Collar City Bridge</a> (6/11/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180617112102/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/12/troy-farmers-market-again-eyes-1msq-as-permanent-home-space/">Troy farmers market again eyes 1MSQ as ‘permanent home space’</a> (6/12/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620120222/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/13/jonathan-nasrallah-on-troy/">Jonathan Nasrallah of Casual Decay on Troy’s eclectic music scene</a> (6/13/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180617130419/http://thealt.com/2018/06/14/a-non-exhaustive-list-of-peoples-wishes-for-1msq/">A non-exhaustive list of people’s purported wishes for 1MSQ</a> (6/14/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180620191608/http://thealt.com/2018/06/15/number-of-cdphp-cycle-bikes-in-circulation-to-double-soon/">Number of CDPHP Cycle! bikes to double soon</a> (6/15/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180621205800/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/15/national-grid-to-perform-minor-work-at-troys-king-fuels-site/">National Grid to perform minor work at Troy’s King Fuels site</a> (6/15/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708130644/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/27/azura-keahi-of-collard-city-growers-on-planting-fruit-trees-in-troy/">Azura Keahi of Collard City Growers on harvesting Troy’s fruit</a> (6/27/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180624025629/http://thealt.com/2018/06/19/troy-teases-potential-digital-innovation-district-at-1msq-workshop/">Troy teases potential ‘Digital Innovation District’ at 1MSQ workshop</a> (6/19/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180626064210/http://thealt.com:80/2018/06/21/city-councilperson-sees-ex-masonic-temple-as-troys-future-city-hall/">City councilperson sees ex-Masonic Temple as Troy’s future city hall</a> (6/21/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180626133520/http://thealt.com/2018/06/22/bonacio-questions-competitors-prospective-tax-breaks/">Bonacio questions competitor’s prospective tax breaks</a> (6/22/18) <br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708130544/http://thealt.com/2018/07/02/troy-property-said-to-be-spitting-bricks-marked-for-demolition/">Troy property, said to be ‘spitting bricks,’ marked for demolition</a> (7/2/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708130714/http://thealt.com:80/2018/07/03/cdta-in-talks-to-extend-service-to-montgomery-county/">CDTA considers bringing service to Montgomery County</a> (7/3/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180708130600/http://thealt.com:80/2018/07/05/loportos-owner-to-buy-part-of-troy-italian-community-center/">LoPorto’s owner to buy part of Troy Italian Community Center</a> (7/5/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180716035641/http://thealt.com:80/2018/07/13/new-troy-parking-agreement-may-impact-sex-shop/">New Troy parking agreement may impact sex shop</a> (7/13/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180716030830/http://thealt.com:80/2018/07/13/troy-is-selling-these-99-properties/">Troy is selling these 99 properties</a> (7/13/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180721080515/http://thealt.com:80/2018/07/17/judge-troy-man-cant-withdraw-guilty-plea/">Judge: Troy man can’t withdraw guilty plea</a> (7/17/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180822035600/http://thealt.com/2018/07/27/troy-land-bank-to-bid-on-three-city-owned-properties/">Troy land bank to bid on three city-owned properties</a> (7/27/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180822042852/http://thealt.com/2018/07/31/media-alliance-solicits-input-for-science-center-in-north-central-troy/">Media Alliance solicits input for science center in North Central Troy</a> (7/31/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181013221124/http://thealt.com:80/2018/08/10/troy-salt-pile-may-be-relocated/">Troy salt pile may be relocated</a> (8/10/18)<br><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20180927015944/http://thealt.com:80/2018/08/16/standard-manufacturing-building-salt-pile-relocation-on-troy-planning-board-agenda/">Standard Manufacturing building, salt pile relocation on Troy planning board agenda</a> (8/16/18)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4cd747202f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A review of the Troy LDC’s Facade Improvement Grant Program]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/a-review-of-the-troy-ldcs-facade-improvement-grant-program-c4006c474340?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4006c474340</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[troy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Apr 2019 14:40:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-10T14:40:36.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This story was originally published by </em><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/business/article/The-Alt-newsweekly-shutting-down-13196558.php"><em>The Alt</em></a><em> on April 5, 2017. The Alt’s website is no longer active, and this story was not captured by the Internet Archive before its disappearance, so I’m republishing it here, for posterity.</em></p><p>In May 2013, the Troy Local Development Corporation (LDC), an agency controlled by a five-person, majority mayor-appointed board, launched its own façade improvement grant program. Structured to incentivize private investment, the program offered up to $5,000 in matching funds to any Troy property owner who undertook exterior renovations “<a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Libraries/Economic_Development_-_TLDC/FA%C3%87ADE_IMPROVEMENT_GRANT_FAQ.sflb.ashx">visible to the traveling public</a>,” like re-pointing brickwork, repairing cornices, or replacing windows. After initial board approval, applicants had one year to finish their projects, and were reimbursed upon completion.</p><p>Cities across the United States <a href="http://plannersweb.com/2013/10/how-facade-improvement-programs">have long deployed similar programs</a> to spruce up storefronts and preserve historic edifices. The Troy LDC itself had administered grants of this type before, but these involved state or federal funds with certain reporting requirements. This new iteration was wholly the prerogative of the Troy LDC.</p><p>The agency generates revenue from interest on loans to local businesses — borrowers include popular establishments like Rare Form Brewery and Troy Kitchen — and from the occasional sale of property, like 444 River Street, a large historic warehouse the LDC acquired at auction in 2012. While it does not draw directly from city coffers to execute its modest economic development agenda, the agency is <a href="http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/guest-column/2017/03/12/guest-essay-government-smokescreens-hide-accountability/98909988/">effectively an arm of the government</a>. Three current board members — Steven Strichman (commissioner of planning and economic development), Monica Kurzejeski (deputy mayor), and John Donohue (city council member) — are also city officials, and the LDC intermittently funds governmental endeavors. For instance, <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Libraries/TLDC_2016/minutes042216.sflb.ashx">in April of last year</a>, to meet a “funding shortage,” the LDC awarded $97,000 to Urban Strategies, a Canadian consulting firm the city had tapped to produce a new comprehensive plan.</p><p><a href="http://troyny.gov/Libraries/TLDC_2013/Minutes041213.sflb.ashx">Minutes show</a> that in 2013, some LDC board members worried that the façade improvement grant program would not generate revenue for the entity, a perennial concern for what is essentially a lender of last resort. Nonetheless, <a href="http://troyny.gov/Libraries/TLDC_2013/TLDC_Meeting_Minutes_05-10-13.sflb.ashx">the initiative was approved</a> soon after it was pitched by Kurzejeski, then the city’s economic development coordinator, and quickly attracted applicants.</p><p>From May 2013 through Sept. 2016, the Troy LDC approved 110 façade improvement grants, a potential expenditure — if all grants were redeemed at their maximum value — of $547,000.</p><p>Some applicants, however, did not carry out their projects, and others approved last year have yet to complete them. Unutilized and pending projects notwithstanding, by the end of 2016 the LDC had already paid out just under one-third of a million dollars in façade improvement grants, meaning that, given the program’s matching structure, at least this amount of additional, private funds have been invested in Troy’s neighborhoods over the past three years.</p><p>If all 20 projects pending at the end of last year are eventually redeemed at their maximum value, the LDC will have spent just under $433,000 on the program during this period.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Flukestoddardnathan.carto.com%2Fviz%2Fe65eb3e8-029c-11e7-a338-0ee66e2c9693%2Fembed_map&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Flukestoddardnathan.carto.com%2Fbuilder%2Fe65eb3e8-029c-11e7-a338-0ee66e2c9693%2Fembed&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fcartocdn-gusc.global.ssl.fastly.net%2Flukestoddardnathan%2Fapi%2Fv1%2Fmap%2Fstatic%2Fnamed%2Ftpl_e65eb3e8_029c_11e7_a338_0ee66e2c9693%2F1200%2F630.png&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=carto" width="800" height="600" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/855805ed0182a77e6561a67557e62bcf/href">https://medium.com/media/855805ed0182a77e6561a67557e62bcf/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Foolish not to do it</strong></p><p>Interviews with more than a half dozen grant recipients revealed widespread satisfaction with the program.</p><p>“You’ve got to be a fool not to do it,” said Daniel Marchese, the owner of a used car dealership, who received almost $3,000 after replacing his Lansingburgh two-family house’s rotted trim work with a decay-resistant variety, among other improvements. The prospect of matching funds, Marchese said, “was the thing that pushed [him] over the edge” to perform long-deferred maintenance. “I definitely got comments from neighbors that it looked a lot better,” he added.</p><p>Beverly Traa, who has owned and lived in a downtown brownstone on Fifth Avenue since 2003, steadily making piecemeal improvements, was similarly spurred to more comprehensive action by the funding opportunity. Her project, completed by Andrea Daley of <a href="http://diyrestoreit.com/">DIY Restore It</a>, a local restoration specialist, included resetting an ornamental iron railing, repainting window sills, and restoring the home’s front door and doorway.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YKw279hWcGdoxw3H0FE0Bg.jpeg" /></figure><p>“If you don’t do it in a timely manner, things deteriorate to such an extent that you can’t afford to do it, and then…your neighborhood deteriorates,” Traa said. Though she conceded that she eventually would have made the improvements with or without the financial assistance, she “got to it…sooner as a result of the grant program, which enhanced my neighborhood,” she explained.</p><p>Along with homeowners, many businesses throughout the city obtained façade improvement grants, including Twenty-Two Second St. Wine Co., River Street Cafe, <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/@42.7284455,-73.6909021,3a,75y,100.86h,88.97t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1snYX0I7rVkGFHuuC6gcIKVg!2e0!5s20110701T000000!7i13312!8i6656">The Ruck</a>, Superior Merchandise Co., and The Cookie Factory. Over half of the properties approved for façade improvement grants contained at least one commercial unit.</p><p>Sue Scaccia of <a href="https://www.facebook.com/Alpha-Lanes-115457045223902/">Alpha Lanes</a>, a bowling alley in Lansingburgh, found the whole process “very simple” and straightforward. Her husband Joe learned of the program after calling city hall to inquire about available grants for businesses. “This building has been here forever — I think it’s like 90 years old,” said Scaccia. One section of the long brick façade was starting to bow. “They took all the brick right out and relaid it,” she explained. “They did a beautiful job.”</p><p>In the fall of 2014, Thomas Rossi, a principal of Redburn Development, obtained two façade grants, one of which was for a building on Fourth Street that had been “completely trashed by a hoarder,” Rossi said in an email. “Before we bought it from a bank out of foreclosure, they had to call a hazmat team to remove the trash where multiple dead animals were found inside.” The building also had significant structural issues, the developer added.</p><p>“A lot of Troy’s buildings are in an historic district or historic in [nature] which requires specific renovations and improvements to the façade,” Rossi explained. “These improvements are almost always more expensive, but critical to keeping Troy’s character. The program is meant offset some of those costs where there is a cheaper but not necessarily historically appropriate option.”</p><p>Adam Siemiginowski, who owns <a href="https://www.thehillatmuza.com/">The Hill at Muza</a>, a European-style beer garden just east of Prospect Park, used LDC funds to improve a pair of buildings on Congress Street; one abuts his popular, partly outdoor establishment.</p><p>“We have [around] 14,200 people driving past that building each day, connecting downtown to the East Side,” Siemiginowski wrote in an email. “It was an eyesore. The cedar shake siding and window capping cost [around] $18,000 in the end, with additional painting to be completed this spring once the weather warms up. $5,000 to help fund that…was very much appreciated.”</p><p>“I find this grant a helpful investment of public funds as it raises all local property values, and brings pride to the community, which is a recursive benefit to us all,” he wrote, before adding, “Flip side: I do see the potential to pour those funds into more service critical uses — if they legally can be.”</p><p><strong>For the “little guy”?</strong></p><p>At least for now, the façade improvement grant program is on hold, pending future discussions on funding and execution. The agency’s balance sheet is hamstrung by the <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/@42.7026497,-73.7004432,3a,75y,21.48h,84.6t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1suPVUIFs_UkoVzWPpFZnJVw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656!6m1!1e1">contaminated King Fuels site in South Troy</a>, a subject of consternation and sometimes friction at board meetings.</p><p>“I’d like us to revisit the façade [improvement] grant program in some way, to some extent,” chairman Kevin O’Bryan said at the LDC’s Jan. meeting this year. “It’s money out the door, it’s not coming back, it’s not like loans, but it’s effective, it’s popular. It’s a little guy thing, and we don’t do a lot of little guy things.”</p><p>Troy’s commissioner of planning and economic development, Steven Strichman, who is also executive director and a board member of the LDC, said at the same meeting that he’d be inclined to support a “more commercial” version of the façade improvement grant program, citing similar ventures he oversaw as a planning official in Schenectady. (Strichman assumed his position in Troy last year.) “Whether that business fails or not,” he explained, “you’ve got an investment in a building that continues there and goes on to the next tenant.”</p><p>While the structure of the matching grant program ensures that administrators can justify it as a dollar-for-dollar inducer of private investment toward purported public goods — the beauty of the city’s streetscape, the boosting of property values — it also means that applicants must have ample cash on hand or access to credit to embark on a project.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*295zFQdsmSxiuNz1a_Sj1Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>“Nothing’s for free,” one grant recipient said with a laugh when asked if the matching structure precluded certain homeowners from participating. Neither Strichman nor Kurzejeski responded to an emailed summary report of this story’s findings, along with a list of questions that included this topic. Former Troy LDC executive director Bill Dunne, who left the position in early 2016, declined to comment.</p><p>Although many owner-occupants, small-scale landlords, and small business owners did obtain façade improvement grants, some individuals and entities received grants for multiple properties, which was permitted under the program’s terms. One entity received additional funding from the LDC for a separate, non-façade-related project around the same time period.</p><p>Tai Ventures LLC, owned by Lolly Tai, a professor of landscape architecture at Temple University, and her brother Luther Tai, a lawyer and engineer on the board of the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Foundation, received three façade improvement grants from the LDC worth $15,000 total for two historic buildings on First Street in 2014 and for the <a href="http://www.timesunion.com/business/article/New-owners-may-restore-spires-edifice-lost-to-fire-6476947.php">Rice Building</a>, an extraordinary flatiron-shaped landmark, in 2015. Between the time the former and latter grants were approved, the LDC awarded Lolly Tai a $10,000 grant to produce a book with her senior Temple University students titled <a href="https://issuu.com/templeuniversity/docs/2016118_troy_issuu_optimized"><em>Troy: Designing a Historic Waterfront</em></a>. Troy LDC executive director Steven Strichman confirmed in an email that the agency received 45 copies of the book, as per the agreement, which “were distributed to assist in concepts for the Comprehensive Plan and other developments along the waterfront.” (Lolly Tai did not respond to an emailed request for comment.)</p><p>Of the 90 total applicants who obtained initial approvals during this time period, 13 were approved for multiple façade improvement grants, and may yet receive a little over $143,000 total in LDC façade funds. That figure represents roughly one-third of the total funds the LDC may end up paying out for this era’s façade improvement grants, though applicants approved for multiple grants constitute just under one-sixth of the applicant pool.</p><p><strong>Disparities by neighborhood, city council district</strong></p><p>While the grants’ popularity and potential multiplier effect are evident, their geographical distribution raises questions about equitability.</p><p>When sorted by neighborhood, for instance, <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Residents/Neighborhoods.aspx">based on a map posted on the city’s website</a>, over half of all initial approvals — 68, with more than $200,000 in funds redeemed — pertain to properties located downtown or in neighboring South Central, which encompasses the private Washington Park and Little Italy. In contrast, North Central received just five initial approvals, at least two of which were not redeemed.</p><p>Sorted by city council district, similar disparities are apparent — 82 initial approvals pertained to parcels in district four or five. District six, which lies directly south of district five and roughly corresponds to South Troy, received just three initial approvals.</p><p>In <a href="http://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-invests-in-neighborhood-facades-6195221.php">April</a> and <a href="http://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-issues-record-56-800-in-facade-grants-6324765.php">June</a> of 2015, the <em>Times Union</em> reported on the Troy LDC’s designation of three “target” areas, two of which — segments of Second Avenue in Lansingburgh and Pawling Avenue on the Eastside — were far from the city center. (The third was Fourth Street in Little Italy.) The LDC earmarked $50,000 for each of the three target areas, which eventually yielded about a dozen initial approvals in total. Yet demand in other areas eclipsed demand within the targets, prompting the LDC in Sept. 2015 to move $75,000 from target area funds into the general façade grant fund.</p><p>According to minutes, the LDC approved all façade improvement grant applications that it brought to a vote. The geographical disparities appear to stem from who applied in the first place — but what, precisely, determined that?</p><p>Factors shaping the applicant pool may have included marketing, underlying economic inequalities, variations in types of housing stock and land-use regulations, or an amalgam of some or all of these. Downtown and South Central, for instance, overlap with <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Libraries/Planning/2015historicdistrictmap.sflb.ashx">locally and nationally designated historic districts</a>, over which the local planning commission may exert <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Departments/PlanningZoning/HistoricDistrict/guidelines.aspx">more stringent exterior-work-related standards</a> than elsewhere. Costs incurred from the added hurdles might increase the allure of the grant program.</p><p>In some of the city’s relatively well-to-do neighborhoods, grants may not have been sought because, simply put, they were not needed. In 2010, <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1f4Fq1ZXSCeo7oXiGzD7wM_NwSOnihfm32z2aA1VZB7Q/pubhtml">according to Census data</a> that divides Troy into 14 tracts, those that intersect portions of The Hill (tract 413), Sycaway (413), Eastside (412), and South Troy (411) had among the highest owner-occupancy rates per housing unit and the <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/Libraries/Consolidated_Plan/COT_Census_Map_2014.sflb.ashx">lowest concentrations of low- to moderate-income residents</a>. Those neighborhoods obtained relatively few façade improvement grants compared to downtown and South Central, which appeared at the opposite end of both categories.</p><p>Downtown’s census tract (407) also has the highest number of housing units and likely commands a preponderance of the city’s commercial activity. All told, it is perhaps not surprising that the city center garnered such a high percentage of façade improvement grants. And while it is difficult to assess the extent to which downtown has benefitted further from separate city-sponsored publicity or development efforts, it is also true that neighborhoods underrepresented in the façade grant tally have benefitted from other, far larger grants in recent years.</p><p><strong>“Economic catalyst”?</strong></p><p>Each year in recent memory, Troy has received about $1.6 million through the federal Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program, which permits a broad array of potential activities, so long as 70 percent of funds benefit low- and moderate-income residents.</p><p>By the end of the present decade, <a href="http://thealt.com/2017/03/16/trumps-funding-cuts-end-local-housing-programs-homeless-aid-services/">if the program is not scrapped at the Trump administration’s behest</a>, Troy will have directed at least $10 million total in CDBG funds to blocks within South Troy (tracts 409 and 410), North Central (404), and Lansingburgh (402) for sidewalk, streetscape, and other infrastructure-related improvements.</p><p>The city also enabled the creation of the Troy Community Land Bank (TCLB), a public authority that acquires vacant properties for stabilization or demolition. TCLB has trained its focus on North Central, and since its inception has garnered roughly $2 million in funding from the state attorney general’s office to carry out its mission.</p><p>Notwithstanding these sizable investments, there remains at least a perception among some residents that city leaders have prioritized the revitalization of Troy’s urban core over its peripheral neighborhoods. The distribution of the LDC’s façade improvement grants, along with recent budget cuts that entail the closure of public pools in South Troy and Lansingburgh and the <a href="http://news10.com/2016/12/21/layoffs-continue-in-troy-budget-battle/">layoff of a part-time employee responsible for organizing events at Powers Park</a>, lend some credence to that impression.</p><p>“The downtown is an economic catalyst for the City as a whole,” the city stated in a <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3491311-Troy-N-Y-Grant-Applications-May-2016-Dec-2016.html#document/p9">grant application</a> submitted this fall to Empire State Development, the state’s chief economic development agency, seeking funds for the restoration of a long-defunct movie theater on River Street. Due “to the project being an anchor,” the city wrote, “[positive] impacts would ripple beyond this commercial corridor as part of the City-wide revitalization.”</p><p>The grant application was successful, and the theater, which figures in <a href="http://alloveralbany.com/archive/2017/03/01/1-monument-square-movie-theater-plan">the larger Monument Square redevelopment project</a>, will likely be enjoyed by residents from every census tract. Whether a downtown-first strategy can and will catalyze development in other areas of the city, however, remains to be seen.</p><p><strong>Amid economic development efforts, foreclosures continue unabated</strong></p><p>Within the same period the 110 façade improvement grants were green lighted — May 10, 2013 to Sept. 23, 2016 — there were 411 tax- and mortgage-related foreclosures in Troy, excluding another five dozen vacant-parcel foreclosures, according to an analysis by <em>The Alt </em>of Rensselaer County records.</p><p>This volume of foreclosures is likely not uncommon for an upstate city of Troy’s size, though detailed foreclosure statistics are surprisingly rare or at least cloistered in county record rooms. According to <a href="http://www.empirejustice.org/assets/pdf/policy-advocacy/fc-prevention-materials--public/protect-ny-homes-fact-sheet.pdf">a fact sheet distributed by the Empire Justice Center</a>, a nonprofit legal advocacy group, there were “nearly 34,000 new filings…and 72,000 pending foreclosure cases” last year in New York’s courts. It is unclear what fraction of those proceedings will ultimately result in judgments. Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, who since 2012 has directed $20 million annually in mortgage-crisis-related settlement funds to foreclosure prevention services, recently extended the five-year arrangement for one year, <a href="https://therealdeal.com/2017/03/30/schneiderman-keeps-foreclosure-prevention-program-afloat-with-10m-infusion/">but at half the amount of funding</a>.</p><p>To raise the specter of foreclosures is not to suggest that instead of attending to frontages, the Troy LDC ought to have used its limited funds to keep residents in their homes; even if the agency had done so, it is unclear if such an intervention would have made much of a difference. Ideally, cities would not have to choose between, say, helping the elderly navigate “<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/09/your-money/reverse-mortgage-lenders-fined-for-ads-that-tricked-older-borrowers.html">reverse mortgage</a>” proceedings and preserving critical architecture.</p><p>But by plotting initial façade improvement grant approvals and foreclosures together on a map — the former in green, the latter in red — one is afforded an almost visceral sense of the challenges facing any well-meaning administrator in a small upstate city. Local economic development initiatives may sometimes feel Sisyphean amid broader trends and the vagaries of larger governmental bodies and financial institutions.</p><p>Downtown was the only neighborhood where initial approvals of façade improvement grants outnumbered foreclosures. Lansingburgh saw more than 150 foreclosures within this timeframe.</p><p>For every vacant property reclaimed by an upstart developer, for every historic structure salvaged, how many more fell into disrepair?</p><p><em>Review public datasets compiled for this story </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1m2S6GJApObbKI0zZmd_ShevqqZzbL533FMrSQm7tq6c/edit?usp=sharing"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4006c474340" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[TL9: Do Not Overstructure]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/tl9-do-not-overstructure-c33cce946c4?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c33cce946c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[newsletter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[troy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Nov 2018 14:57:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-10T14:57:34.518Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*Z-TuS_gSlAU6J82o.png" /><figcaption><em>Hello, Collar City! This is Issue 9, dated Nov. 9, 2018.</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>[Note: I am publishing this issue today, Nov. 10, on Medium because it’s been </em><a href="https://twitter.com/lukestdnathan/status/1061021883817189377"><em>held up by TinyLetter for reasons not entirely clear to me</em></a><em>.]</em></p><p><strong>Hello!</strong> I don’t love the idea of raising the prospect of next year’s elections after another fairly fatiguing election cycle just ended — ICYMI, <a href="https://www.troyrecord.com/news/donnelly-wins-rensselaer-county-district-attorney-seat/article_856fefae-e24f-11e8-b39f-07aff86520f9.html">Donnelly</a> and <a href="https://www.troyrecord.com/news/elections/weaver-wins-district-rensselaer-county-legislature-seat/article_4590d704-e254-11e8-8397-b7a7f4c1a845.html">Weaver</a> won — but I think it’s worth mentioning that next year’s will likely be a bit livelier locally, since the mayor and city council will be up for election. (The county sheriff, too.) And so, please be advised that it’s not too early to let me know, if you know, who’s running and who’s not (or who <em>should</em> run and who shouldn’t).</p><p>This week’s TL has lots of Troy police-related stuff, ideas from a farmers market public workshop, and other assorted items. Enjoy, and, as always, feel free to email me if you have questions or opinions.</p><h3>TPD’s 2019</h3><p>Last night, Troy Police Department Chief Brian Owens appeared before the city council’s public safety committee to answer questions about the department’s $20.2 million budget for next year. Here are the highlights.</p><p><strong>Body-worn cameras</strong>. The department intends to have a body-worn camera program fully in place within the next few months, Chief Owens said. A <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/05/11/troy-police-chief-body-worn-camera-policy-may-released-two-months/">draft policy</a> has been completed. The department hasn’t received a final answer from the state attorney general’s office regarding its application for a grant through the <a href="https://ag.ny.gov/cams-program">CAMS program</a>, “but they did request additional information,” Owens said.</p><p>The grant, which requires a 25 percent local cash match, wouldn’t pay for the entire program but would offset some costs. Assemblymember John McDonald has told the mayor that he will attempt to secure state funding to help pay for part of the program, too, Mayor Patrick Madden told the council.</p><p>In January, the department will finalize its selection of a vendor and begin a pilot program for a month or two, rotating different units through the program. The department would then finalize its policy and fully implement the program.</p><p>Later this month, the city council finance committee <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/CCFinanceAgenda112918DRAFT.pdf">will consider a resolution</a> to authorize the issuance of bonds worth $250K to pay for BWCs and storage.</p><p>Next year’s budget includes a new, $44,190-a-year video clerk, who will handle the BWC footage.</p><p><strong>Other grants</strong>. Owens said that the department will continue to pursue the various grants it has secured in past years, as well as look for new ones. But “the grants have always been very competitive,” Owens said. “It seems now that the total funding available for grants, just looking at the ones that I used to work on, the funding has decreased.” Capt. John Becker is now the department’s grant writer, the chief said.</p><p><strong>More vehicles</strong>. At the aforementioned finance committee meeting later this month, the council will also consider bonding to pay for 14 police vehicles: six patrol SUVs, four unmarked SUVs, three sedans, and one van. (The general practice of bonding for vehicles was discussed in <a href="https://tinyletter.com/troy_letter/letters/tl8-snack-size">TL8</a>.)</p><p>“We do have an aging fleet,” Chief Owens said last night. “Right now we have main patrol cars, in zones, that have over 160–180,000 miles. In years past, we never kept them that long.” He acknowledged that vehicles last longer these days, but maintenance costs increase with age. Used police vehicles tend to be passed on to other city departments, like code enforcement or public works, “so you still get continued use after we’re done” with them, the chief said.</p><p>The department currently has an estimated 70 total vehicles in service across all units, the chief said.</p><p><strong>Facility improvements</strong>. Now that a remediation of the impound lot at the north side of the police station has been completed, the department intends to build a steel structure there for evidence processing and long-term storage, Owens said. (Currently, vehicles are processed for evidence at a sally port at the station that is also used by law enforcement to bring prisoners to and from city court.) The 36&#39; x 90&#39;, “minimally insulated” structure will cost an estimated $120K to build.</p><p><strong>OT increase</strong>. Projected police department overtime costs will increase by $100K from the current year’s budget, from $850K to $950K. Councilmember Anasha Cummings asked the chief about the extent to which OT costs are driven by staffing levels versus an uptick in big cases. “Anecdotally, I think most of it is staffing-driven,” the chief said. The recent settlement of the PBA contract also contributed to the projected OT cost increase, the city’s deputy comptroller said.</p><p><strong>Department size.</strong> The proposed budget includes an additional police officer, bringing the department’s total of sworn officers to 131. The department currently has six vacancies, a figure Owens expects to see increase soon. Council President Carmella Mantello asked the mayor if there has been any movement on a <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-poised-to-study-increasing-number-of-police-12819533.php">potential study on increasing the total size the police force</a>.</p><p>“There was no statement that there would be a study,” the mayor said. “There was, I think, at best, a rumination, wondering whether the police force is appropriately sized for what we’re trying to do. We’ve had some discussion around that in weekly meetings with the chiefs, but we’ve not gone further than discussions at this point.”</p><p><strong>Drug unit revival.</strong> “Our plan going forward is to restore” the department’s drug unit, said Owens, who <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-commits-to-community-policing-under-12806772.php">disbanded the unit earlier this year</a>. Last month, two former members of that unit pleaded guilty to misdemeanors in connection with a <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-cops-plead-guilty-in-illegal-search-case-13311215.php">warrantless search they carried out in 2017</a>.</p><p>TPD members have been serving on a drug task force with federal agencies, but those partners “tend to focus on the larger drug connections,” Owens said. “And what we see is a lot of nuisance-level drug dealing that’s certainly very disruptive to people in the neighborhood. It also leads to violence, potentially. So we need to have our own unit.”</p><p>Owens told the council that the department wants to make sure that “everyone has solid trust in that unit” following “prior incidents that might be fresh in people’s minds.” I followed up on this with Owens after his appearance before the council, asking how the department would restore this trust. He said:</p><blockquote><em>One of the things we want to do is make sure that we staff it properly, make sure that everyone is properly trained, given the resources that they need, just to make sure that the conduct of that unit is above reproach. I can’t get into any particulars on how I would do that because I really don’t know yet. It’s just a matter of making sure that we do it right, that there’s sound policy in place, that there’s training in place, and there’s supervision in place. And I’m not speaking particular to that last incident, but I just want to make sure, going forward, that there’s no question as to any of those.</em></blockquote><p>Councilmember Mark McGrath told me after the meeting that, at least right now, he wouldn’t support the revival of the unit. “I don’t think there’s a lot of trust there,” he said.</p><p><strong>Comitale’s comments</strong>. I also asked the chief if there was anything he’d like to tell Troy residents who might’ve been alarmed by <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Little-League-official-sues-Troy-over-Comitale-13364135.php">comments made by Officer Dominick Comitale to North Greenbush police</a>. Here’s what he said:</p><blockquote><em>I’ll say this: At the time of the incident — when we became aware of the incident — we opened an internal affairs investigation at that time. That’s still ongoing. We expect that to be completed very soon, the end of this week or potentially next week. And then we’ll move forward based on our investigation.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Comments that are inappropriate or inflammatory are not acceptable. And we’ll look into that, as we have been doing. Unfortunately, I can’t get into the particulars of a personnel matter, but we do take those allegations very seriously.</em></blockquote><h3>Farmers Market Future</h3><p>The nonprofit Troy Waterfront Farmers Market held a public meeting Wednesday night at Franklin Plaza to solicit input from patrons, vendors, and other interested parties on the popular, once-a-week market’s future.</p><p>The meeting was led by the <a href="https://www.pps.org/">Project for Public Spaces</a>, a nonprofit that the market has hired as a consultant. PPS devoted a substantial chunk of the two-hour session to a presentation on farmers markets in other cities and what one of its team members called their “chain of evolution,” which ranges from open-air markets (least evolved) to <a href="http://easternmarket-dc.org/">market districts</a> (most evolved). The consultants also talked about markets’ benefits (creates active public space, promotes public health, etc.) and ingredients of successful ones.</p><p>Then, for the finale, the dozens of attendees were encouraged to answer four questions, each written on easel pad sheets, by writing their responses on sticky notes and affixing them to the appropriate sheet. At the event’s end, I photographed each sheet and have reproduced all the answers (with minimal editing/consolidating) below. There were no small group breakout sessions that sometimes happen at these sort of events, so I thought by transcribing these sheets you’d at least get a sense of what attendees were thinking.</p><p><strong>What are the market’s goals?</strong></p><ul><li>Fresh food from local farmers</li><li>Bring in people to Troy / local sales</li><li>Support for healthy local food 1st</li><li>Quality foods / Support local farms / connect people in a vibrant space</li><li>Long term financial viability, growth with the city, [indiscernible] differentiation from competing markets in Saratoga &amp; Schenectady</li><li>Be a food bridge / farm -&gt; city / nutritional privileged -&gt; less so</li><li>Can the market support Fri/Sat or Sat/Sun from 5/31–9/30?</li><li>Incubating new enterprises</li><li>Permanent year-round location with shelter from elements AND open air feel</li><li>Needs to support itself so it can pay for the space(s)</li><li>Remember that there are many supports to other values in city not accounted in “paying for the space</li><li>[other sticky note overlapped] a village-scale economic revitalization (depends on establishing satellite markets)</li><li>Vendor profitability</li><li>Grow and change slowly enough that failure is difficult</li><li>Be a heart of the city</li><li>Add space for public/private functions</li><li>Expand to include more exhibits / children’s activities</li><li>Ideally — an indoor/outdoor location as pictured</li><li>Increased quality of life for Troy residents, downtown businesses, and vendors + farmers</li><li>Attract visitors and residents to the city — encourage livability</li></ul><p><strong>Who are the market’s potential partners[*] and how can they help?</strong></p><p>[*Obviously, anyone could write any entity down here, so it doesn’t mean the entity has actually signed on to help out.]</p><ul><li>The city, obviously. After all, part of our current renewal is due to the market.</li><li><a href="https://www.nybdc.com/">NYBDC</a> / ENYA [?] / <a href="https://esd.ny.gov/">ESD</a></li><li>RPI Environmental Studies / Science — agriculture &amp; global influence</li><li>RPI School of Architecture — vendor/street layout, circulation, &amp; student impact</li><li>Local Architects — Mosaic Associates, 3tarchitects, architecture+ — design &amp; spatial analysis</li><li>Rensselaer County Historical Society</li><li>The Arts Center of the Capital Region — shows/sales, craft market, classes</li><li>Other downtown vendors</li><li>Local medical — walk w/ a doc, yoga, healthy food [indiscernible]</li><li><a href="https://www.capitalroots.org/">Capital Roots</a> — healthy community, outreach to assist food insecure population</li><li>Owners of unused spaces (eg: a few of Troy’s many unused churches) could be donated for this purpose)</li><li>CDTA</li><li>Russell Sage</li><li>Private/Public Partnerships will make the most sense</li><li><a href="https://www.mediasanctuary.org/initiatives/collardcitygrowers/">Collard City Growers</a></li><li>Unity House</li><li>Rensselaer County</li><li><a href="https://www.agriculture.ny.gov/">NYS Ag &amp; Markets</a></li><li><a href="https://www.agstewardship.org/">Agricultural Stewardship Association</a></li><li>Could the city of Troy run the trolley during the market to promote shopping in the city?</li><li>MVP or CDPHP? Marketing or financial support</li><li>Local businesses within the market footprint</li></ul><p><strong>What are your concerns &amp; issues for the Troy Waterfront Farmers Market?</strong></p><ul><li>Parking &amp; Access</li><li>Make “food” vendors permanent members of the 501(c)(3) organization</li><li>Keep it on River Street</li><li>We have the best market in the region. Don’t mess it up.</li><li>Maintain the festive, diverse, urban market environment of the current market on River Street, while working [?] on growth and a “permanent” market</li><li>I love the “[indiscernible]” I go to once a week. I’m terrified it will become a grocery store that is ignorable.</li><li>Recycling/composting efforts.</li><li>Must keep dog friendly</li><li>Also, dog control!</li><li>Not enough cost sharing among vendors. Need common fund for infrastructure.</li><li>Integrate move with nonprofits in the city.</li><li>Keep simple &amp; basic.</li><li>Priority for local food.</li><li>Easy in &amp; [overlapped, but looks like it says “out”] for customers &amp; vendors</li><li>Emergency vehicles access within market footprint</li><li>I worry it will build [indiscernible] that puts it out of business.</li><li>Don’t ruin a great thing.</li><li>Change State Street to two-way traffic the whole length of it (to improve access to lower River St.)</li><li>Diversity — include more craft people</li><li>Public transit access</li><li>Improve utilities for vendors</li><li>Leaving footprint for growth of vendor count, a leading driver of market health and customer turnout</li><li>Public restroom</li><li>More space between vendors so it’s not congested</li><li>[re: dogs] loan &amp; require 4&#39; leashes. Ban thin cord retractable leashes.</li><li>A permanent home should not remove the market from River St.</li><li>Downtown location is key…on nice weather days.</li><li>Maintaining an architectural motif consistent with downtown Troy’s historic buildings</li><li>Farmers’ market not be overwhelmed by other markets</li><li>Change of location twice a year (indoor/outdoor) causes confusion for shoppers who don’t know</li><li>What if dramatically changing economic realities (due to peak oil, climate change, etc.) obviate prior experience?</li><li>A location on the river would be nice</li><li>Love outside</li><li>Where are the brown, the black, &amp; the poor people?</li><li>How can a city that is broke be of any help with this project? What other sources are available?</li><li>Inclusive of entire downtown small businesses?</li><li>Blocking traffic to lower river Street</li><li>The majority of Trojans are too poor to shop at the market in its current form</li><li>Permanent location so customers can plan</li><li>I hope the market will always, or at least partially, remain sited on street space due to the unique and pleasant transformation of car-space.</li><li>Sustainability — don’t over-build, don’t reach beyond grasp</li><li>Allow traffic to drive around Rice Building</li><li>Wish it reflected more of the whole city + its citizens</li></ul><p><strong>What are your hopes &amp; wishes for the Troy Waterfront Farmers Market?</strong></p><ul><li>To be bookended by the Uncle Sam Garage &amp; State St. Garage</li><li>Drive &amp; leave trucks &amp; equipment [?]</li><li>Same location summer/winter</li><li>Have we had a market wedding yet? (Sounds like a marketing (sic) opportunity!)</li><li>More than 1 day/week</li><li>Add an additional weekday market</li><li>Book market &amp; library component</li><li>Hoping it stays out on the street in summer/spring/fall &amp; not inside a building</li><li>Encourage people’s link to waterfront via access to boat tours, kayak rentals, etc.</li><li>A few spaces kept for local nonprofits on rotation</li><li>Fri &amp; Sat — indoor &amp; outdoor place</li><li>Space for kids — the waterfront water sprout area is wonderful!</li><li>Keep it a working market. Not a yuppie or hipster paradise or “destination” [lol]</li><li>That it doesn’t lose its focus — to try to be everything to everyone. Local food first.</li><li>Keep the great attitude — fun/friends over bags of $$</li><li>Space for socializing &amp; chairs</li><li>Reconfigure Atrium (remove central stair?) to make it more adaptable for market and other uses</li><li>That the market could appeal to the average (lower income) shopper</li><li>That they stay outside in the street</li><li>Keep growing / indoor/outdoor space / Connect with River St, river, park</li><li>Integrate with waterfront / Develop boat-based “booths” for outdoor season</li><li>Tai Chi / Qi Gong for kids and for 50–90</li><li>Expansion</li><li>A solar panel shed roof parking lot used as a market on weekends</li><li>Do not overstructure</li><li>Continue to focus on local food</li><li>To integrate smoothly w/ the future of 1 Monument Square as a central civic space</li><li>Wherever the vendors are best served for their needs. I’ll find them &amp; buy</li><li>I would like to see multiple neighborhood markets. I hope they would stimulate economic revitalization on a village scale, therefore lead to less dependence on fossil fuels</li><li>I hope the market REMAINS CROWDED!</li><li>Market is too crowded!</li><li>I hope it grows. Inter-vendor competition is vital to this. Allowing more similar vendors may even lead to TFM as being known for something unique.</li><li>Continue outdoor musicians and add to tables for eating.</li><li>Many businesses are blocked off from traffic on Saturday</li></ul><p>Whew! I’m not sure if all this points in any decisive direction, but I suppose it’s PPS’s responsibility to figure that out. I asked the market’s interim operations manager, Steve Ridler, about next steps, and he sent me this statement: “The Market will be working with PPS to review what they heard from the community workshop and other meetings and site visits. There will be follow up discussions with community groups and vendors to examine opportunities and issues that were identified.”</p><p>“The Market looks forward to hearing back from PPS as to how it should evolve successfully in the future,” the statement concluded.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*QY3LiCOE-SzGcgp-.jpg" /></figure><p>This past summer, the market made a <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/06/12/troy-farmers-market-again-eyes-1msq-as-permanent-home-space/">very public push</a> to secure a place in the newest iteration of 1MSQ. It now seems that, while that option remains possible, the market is open to alternative ideas, too.</p><h3>Other News</h3><p><strong>Brookses buy row house from Sage.</strong> Russ and Jody Brooks, who also own 155 River St., <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4946434-Troy-DRI-THREE.html#document/p66/a458429">the future site of a long-planned boutique hotel</a>, have purchased 37 First St. from The Sage Colleges for $560K, according to a deed filed with the county clerk’s office this month. “Jody and I are very pleased to be finally moving to Troy and living at 37 First,” Russ Brooks said in an email.</p><p>In a statement, the president of Sage, Christopher Ames, said the building was not currently being used by the college and that a “survey of our facilities identified it as a surplus property not contiguous to campus that would be better transferred to a performing asset.”</p><p><strong>What changed in 1MSQ vision? </strong>I missed Monday’s meeting on the future of 1MSQ — this was separate and apart from the farmers market meeting discussed above — but I <a href="http://alloveralbany.com/archive/2018/11/06/heres-the-new-concept-plan-for-1-monument-square-i">recommend reading All Over Albany’s writeup</a>. We still don’t have any firm projections on cost or completion date. The renderings look <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/06/27/what-you-missed-at-troys-1msq-charrette-last-week/">very similar to what we were shown this past summer</a> at the end of the three-day workshop. I asked Margaret Irwin, a member of the consultant team, to specify exactly what changed between then and now:</p><blockquote><em>Lots of minor refinements and adding floors to the main building and making the restaurant a bit bigger based on developer feedback that they’d need more SF [square feet] to make a project work. Given that the public likes the size of the plaza any additional sf would need to be vertical […] We did not have a negative comment (expressed publicly at least) regarding the height ([eight] stories or about 15 feet higher than the apartment building across the street, lower than the monument and much lower than icons like the TSB [Troy Savings Bank Music Hall].) we consider that a maximum height.</em></blockquote><p><strong>There are four projects on </strong><a href="http://www.troyny.gov/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/ZBAgenda111318.pdf"><strong>next Tuesday night’s ZBA agenda</strong></a>, all of which are fairly minor.</p><p><strong>FYI: Troy City School District BoE meeting videos are posted </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCG7Ow0-wpxUDAYJMkfxPh1g/videos"><strong>here</strong></a>. This seems like another area of undercovered city news, one that I intend to keep an eye on going forward.</p><h3>Links</h3><p><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/local/article/Churchill-Troy-s-mistake-could-be-a-market-13360880.php">Churchill: Troy’s mistake could be a market opportunity</a> (TU, 11/4). Next year is the Atrium’s 40th anniversary.<br><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Little-League-official-sues-Troy-over-Comitale-13364135.php">Recording: Troy cop disparages N. Greenbush chief, female witnesses</a> (TU, 11/5)<br><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Ren-Co-chairman-blames-vandalism-on-weak-minded-13367608.php">RensCo GOP chairman blames vandalism on politics</a> (TU, 11/6)<br><a href="http://alloveralbany.com/archive/2018/11/06/heres-the-new-concept-plan-for-1-monument-square-i">Here’s the new concept plan for 1 Monument Square in downtown Troy</a> (AOA, 11/6)<br><a href="https://www.troyrecord.com/news/local-news/sage-college-s-new-strategic-plan-to-re-vision-its/article_d8c83318-e142-11e8-b253-434d1fd8e804.html">Sage College’s new strategic plan to re-vision its identify</a> (TR, 11/6). <a href="https://sp.sage.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Strategic-Plan-Rationale.pdf">Here’s the college’s rationale</a> for the plan, which essentially calls for Sage to become a single, coed institution, albeit one with two campuses. Among the purported benefits of this approach? “Increased housing occupancy in Troy,” per the rationale.<br><a href="http://www.rensco.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/G18.html">Rensselaer County Unofficial Election Results</a> (RensCo BoE, 11/6)<br><a href="https://www.bizjournals.com/albany/news/2018/11/07/for-developers-devil-is-in-the-details-of-one.html">For developers, ‘devil is in the details’ of One Monument Square</a> [$] (ABR, 11/7). This features interviews with Sam Judge and Sonny Bonacio.<br><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Rensselaer-County-DA-elect-to-consider-office-13372429.php">Rensselaer County DA-elect to consider office staffing</a> (TU, 11/7)</p><p>Also, I wrote about <a href="https://www.chronogram.com/hudsonvalley/caffeinated-politics-democracy-coffee-raises-money-for-campaign-finance-reform/Content?oid=6649344">a coffee operation that uses its proceeds to promote publicly financed elections</a> for this month’s issue of Chronogram, a Hudson Valley magazine.</p><h3>Events</h3><p>See a Belle-Skinner / Girl Blue / Zan Strumfeld show <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/1850190755088951/">tonight at SMCo</a>. Alternatively, <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/253723052166068/">barhop with your downtown councilmember</a> or <a href="http://www.facebook.com/events/551739561920463/">celebrate</a> Lucas Confectionery’s sixth anniversary. Tomorrow night: <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/1942371882736049/">see jazz in North Central</a>.</p><p>(Monday is Veterans Day, and <a href="http://www.troyny.gov/city-hall-closed-for-election-day-veterans-day/">city hall is closed</a>.) Tuesday night, <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/190451928514206/">tell stories at the Ale House</a>. Watch a documentary on NYPD whistleblowers <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/320109805202537/">Wednesday night</a> at the Sanctuary. Or <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/294929327788741/">swap clothes at Psychedelicatessen</a>. Thursday and Friday (11/16), see <a href="http://empac.rpi.edu/events/2018/fall/descent">DESCENT at EMPAC</a>.</p><p><em>The end. Have a wonderful weekend. Reply to this email and speak your mind, if you’d like. Old, stale TL issues are always kept </em><a href="https://tinyletter.com/troy_letter/archive"><em>here</em></a><em>, for your continued sampling. Talk soon — LSN.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c33cce946c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Troy, NY Meeting Diary: 9/3–9/7/18]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/troy-ny-meeting-diary-9-3-9-7-18-86bc0cb8345b?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86bc0cb8345b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[troy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Sep 2018 16:49:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-10T16:54:16.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Hi! </em><a href="https://www.timesunion.com/business/article/The-Alt-newsweekly-shutting-down-13196558.php"><em>Until recently</em></a><em> I was news editor of The Alt (RIP). For the last few months I’ve been covering Troy, where I live, pretty extensively. While I plan my next steps, I thought I’d continue to at least attend major city meetings and blog about them once a week (this is the first one). If you’ve got tips/comments/thoughts feel free to email me: luke.s.nathan@gmail.com.</em></p><h4>Troy City Council Finance Committee, 9/6</h4><p><strong>Land bank update. </strong>The finance committee (and, later the same night, the council) approved a new memorandum of understanding between the city and the Troy Community Land Bank, a quasi-governmental entity largely funded by the state attorney general’s office.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p178">MOU itself</a> is rather uninteresting—it basically formalizes a partnership that has existed since TCLB’s creation several years ago—and councilmembers didn’t delve into its particulars. But they did take the opportunity to discuss TCLB’s accomplishments and plans with its director Tony Tozzi, who was in attendance.</p><p>Tozzi seemed particularly proud of TCLB’s ongoing partnership with Habitat for Humanity Capital District, which is currently overhauling two properties on Fifth Ave. between 101st and 102nd streets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wkX7-n0cnX0adQyydtPZuw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.troycommunitylandbank.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/2018-TCLB-Annual-Presentation-Power-Point.pdf">Source</a>: TCLB’s March 2018 annual meeting presentation</figcaption></figure><p>According to Tozzi, TCLB is “in the process of selling so many of our properties”—all but two—“that we’re running out of inventory.” He attributed the bump in demand to the efforts of Greg Tobin of Coldwell Banker Prime Properties, whose real-estate listing services TCLB procured <a href="http://www.troycommunitylandbank.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/02.2018-Land-Bank-Agenda.pdf">earlier this year</a>.</p><p>That said, it seems TCLB is now charting what Tozzi described as a “new path.” In the past, TCLB has pursued two primary courses of action for the dilapidated properties it acquires from the city (or occasionally from banks as donations) before selling them: demolition or “stabilization,” which you might define as attending to a building’s structural issues but not really doing much beyond that.</p><p>Now, Tozzi said Thursday, TCLB is poised to perform more extensive renovations at 791 and 899 River St., using the buildings “to introduce alternative rehab designs” that might inspire people—future buyers and renovators, perhaps—to “think outside the box.” The latter property, a rather “tired-looking,” vinyl-sided home, will be refashioned as an “urban cottage,” Tozzi said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*spRvzaNxVf3gIvfSvpOVaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>899 River St. (June 2018)</figcaption></figure><p>It seems the general idea behind TCLB opting to renovate, rather than stabilize, its properties is to attract a broader pool of buyers.</p><p>In other news, two buildings in what was once envisioned as a four-parcel assemblage for a <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/03/02/land-bank-plans-transit-oriented-development-north-central-troy/">future transit-oriented development</a> likely will be demolished by mid-November. But the privately owned building at 871 River St. is tied up in a bankruptcy proceeding, which poses a challenge for acquisition, Tozzi said.</p><p>TCLB is applying for nearly $1.8 million in new funding from the AG’s office. In its proposal, which deputy mayor Monica Kurzejeski said would be submitted on Friday (9/7), TCLB details plans to expand its efforts into Lansingburgh. To date, it has focused largely, though not exclusively, on North Central.</p><p><strong>Reverter madness.</strong> Almost 50 years ago, the city sold a large parcel of land off of Oakwood Ave. to Beltrone Construction of Colonie for $3,500. The deed contained the following provision:</p><blockquote>This conveyance is made subject to the condition that a building shall be erected of such type of construction as to conform with building, housing and fire prevention codes within one (1) year after the date of the deed. If the purchaser, its successor, or assigns shall fail to comply with this [condition] the City of Troy has a right to re-enter the property without refunding the purchase price.</blockquote><p>This building was not built within that one-year time frame, or ever. The property has since changed hands, and it is now poised to change hands yet again: Yonna Realty intends to sell it to an entity related to the Troy Housing Authority, which would use the still-undeveloped land for its <a href="http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:H5Cu4KE9H4EJ:www.troyrecord.com/article/TR/20180607/NEWS/180609842+&amp;cd=11&amp;hl=en&amp;ct=clnk&amp;gl=us">Martin Luther King Apartments revitalization project</a>.</p><p>Mayor Patrick Madden’s administration asked the city council to authorize him to release the reverter clause. The city’s corporation counsel, James Caruso, cast this as something like a formality, since a <a href="https://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=1097">laches defense</a> would likely stymie any attempt by the city, after a half-century of doing nothing, to take back the property.</p><p>And anyway, the city probably wouldn’t want to take back the property, because, councilmembers agreed on Thursday, this affordable housing project seems beneficial for the city.</p><p>But after councilmember Mark McGrath questioned whether the council has the authority to authorize the mayor to release the reverter, it agreed to table the resolution, pending future communications between the city’s corporation counsel and the development team’s title company.</p><p>The discussion was contentious and sort of hard to follow, but apparently the mayor did not want to sign off on the reverter release without first obtaining council approval, at least in part because code enforcement, which typically inspects properties to verify that work outlined in the buyer’s proposal has been completed before approving the release, could not, in this instance, say that the work had been done.</p><p>A member of the development team in attendance said a delay of a few weeks wouldn’t necessarily harm the project’s prospects.</p><p><strong>Opioid lawsuit. </strong>The finance committee and the council at its regular meeting authorized the mayor to <a href="https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4840102/Opioid-Lawsuit.pdf">hire the law firm of Dreyer Boyajian LLP</a> “to investigate the viability of claims against the manufacturers and/or distributors of prescription opiates and, if appropriate, commence litigation” against them.</p><p>Dreyer Boyajian already represents Albany, Schenectady, and Plattsburgh in similar efforts. It will work for Troy via a contingency fee arrangement, taking a quarter of the city’s final winnings (if there are any).</p><h4>Troy City Council Regular Meeting, 9/6</h4><p><strong>Property sales. </strong>The council approved the sale of <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p21">more than two dozen, city-owned properties</a>.</p><p>The only modification to that linked-to list is that the sale of 403 Third St. was tabled. The recommended winner, John DeBonis Jr., had <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p56">proposed</a> to purchase the two-family home for $7,000 and spend another $11,000 on assorted improvements. He would have lived in one unit and rented out the other one, per his application.</p><p>Sid Fleisher and Charles Conroy, both of whom live near the long-vacant property, which is just south of Monroe St., appeared at the Aug. 23 finance committee meeting—when the bundle of prospective sales was advanced to this month’s regular meeting—and again at this meeting to question, if not advocate against, DeBonis’s plan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*otbB71mxkDcYfDCpXSF-WA.jpeg" /><figcaption>403 Third St. (July 2018)</figcaption></figure><p>The two neighborhood residents had partnered on an unsuccessful proposal for the same property this round that involved demolishing the house by hand and creating green space. At the previous meeting, Fleisher expressed concern that DeBonis’s project would be a bare-minimum kind of effort, judging from his proposal. (DeBonis did not speak at either meeting.)</p><p>The city council minority also tried to change the winner of 231 Hill St. from Gunnafly LLC to Varton Jerian, who bid substantially more money but proposed an arguably less interesting use (an HQ for his real-estate management company), but the amendment failed.</p><p>According to its <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p75">application</a>, Gunnafly intends to spend $70,000 converting the structure into light-industrial and office space, then lease it to <a href="https://www.varasafety.com/">Vara Corporation</a>, an RPI-linked, firearm safety startup.</p><p>Other winners of interest: The Troy Community Land Bank (11 Winnie Ave., 3278 Sixth Ave.—$250 each); <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/08/21/price-chopper-eyes-future-development-in-lansingburgh/">Clark Trading</a> (867 Second Ave., $52,500); Priam LLC, a <a href="https://www.bizjournals.com/albany/print-edition/2016/03/25/never-heard-of-north-central-troy-let-these-people.html">Brian McCandless</a>-owned entity (17 102nd St., 47 Ingalls Ave.); and Colie Collen of Flower Scout (423 Second St.), who intends to use the lot as a second flower garden.</p><p><strong>Lots of Hope.</strong> The city council approved the acquisition of <a href="http://thealt.com/2018/07/11/troy-may-acquire-lots-of-hope-lot-in-osgood-neighborhood/">409 Second St.</a> from the Troy Community Land Bank for $1. The once-vacant lot will become a “passive park,” according to the <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p95">ordinance</a>.</p><p><strong>New pipes. </strong>The council approved the issuance of <a href="https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Troy-weighs-40-million-replacement-of-pipes-from-13177249.php">up to $40 million in bonds</a> to reconstruct the water transmission line from the Tomhannock Reservoir to the city’s water plant.</p><p><strong>Application processing restriction law.</strong> The council <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4839927-CCRegularAgenda090618.html/#p97">amended</a> the city code to prohibit the issuance of any sort of permit to any property owner behind on their real-estate taxes or similar fines/fees.</p><p>Corporation counsel James Caruso, responding to a question from the council, opined that the law is enforceable.</p><p><em>Say hi: luke.s.nathan@gmail.com</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86bc0cb8345b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[With Armstrong, Did The Postal Service Get Its Money’s Worth?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/with-armstrong-did-the-postal-service-get-its-moneys-worth-ff0f1874f6a?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff0f1874f6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lance-armstrong]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sponsorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cycling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Oct 2016 14:17:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-26T00:45:50.524Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/929/1*vHFg9Vr6f1KvTtpjHimTFQ.png" /></figure><p>In 1996, the United States Postal Service sponsored an American cycling team, owned by a sports marketing company best known as Tailwind Sports, for $1 million. It increased this subsidy each year thereafter: $2 million in 1997, $2.5 million in ’98, $3.5 million in ’99 (enter Lance Armstrong), $4.3 million in ’00, $6.3 million in ’01, $7.9 million in ’02, $8.1 million in ’03, and, in 2004, its final year as title sponsor, $8.9 million. The post office re-upped on an annual basis until the end of the 2000 season, when Armstrong’s second consecutive Tour de France victory incited Gail Sonnenberg, then senior vice president of sales at USPS, to push for a four-year contract extension.</p><p>Sonnenberg, who did not respond to a Facebook message concerning this article, later testified that when she became the de facto USPS liaison to the cycling team in 1998, her “primary duty was to try and build new revenue from the relationship.” The chief marketing officer at the time, Allen Kane, had said to her, in her telling, “I’m not sure why we have this [sponsorship], but I would like you to take it and see if you can make a business case for having it.” Sonnenberg and her staff set about attempting to sell mail-related services to the team’s other sponsors.</p><p>In 1998, the third year of the USPS sponsorship and the team’s second consecutive invitation to the race — still <em>avant</em> Armstrong — the Tour de France blew up. Three days before the start, Willy Voet, an employee of the French team Festina, was stopped by customs officials at the border of France and Belgium. Officials found in his vehicle a cache of steroids, EPO (a red-blood-cell booster), human growth hormone, testosterone, amphetamines, and other goodies. The entire Festina team eventually withdrew from the race, as did five other teams. Riders staged two sit-down protests during the three-week race, in reaction to perceived overreaches by French police. The USPS team escaped scandal; none of its riders were directly implicated during the race. (A USPS team masseuse, Emma O’Reilly, later <a href="http://d3epuodzu3wuis.cloudfront.net/OReilly,+Emma+Affidavit.pdf">testified</a> that she convinced customs agents in Dublin, where the race began that year, not to search USPS team vehicles arriving on a Belgian ferry the same day as Voet’s arrest. Had she not intervened— well, that might have complicated Armstrong’s entrée the ensuing year. He later returned the favor by suing O’Reilly for libel and calling her a whore under oath, though they’ve since <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2014/jul/02/emma-o-reilly-lance-armstrong-cyclist-doping">reportedly</a> patched things up.)</p><p>In ‘99, Armstrong won the Tour. Then he won again. For the Postal Service, everything changed after the second win. “When the world is watching the Postal Service Cycling Team and its hero win the Tour de France two years in a row,” Sonnenberg testified, “someone who has recovered from cancer, someone who fought back against all odds…all of the positive parts of that, became, I think, bigger than whether you were going to make [sales of] $40 million in the minds of senior management.” She recalled the Postmaster General, Bill Henderson, “coming into my office and telling me that we were no longer going to need to [worry] about using the sponsorship to develop new business, that this had become more valuable on its own.”</p><p>Throughout the nine-year arrangement — during both the “Invest” and “Harvest” periods, as a late 2003 “exit strategy” slideshow termed the pre- and post-1999 periods, respectively — Sonnenberg and her cohorts adduced various data and studies to prove to the agency’s Board of Governors and civilian watchdogs that the sponsorship, to quote one talking-point memo from 2003, was “one of the most effective public relations ventures the Postal Service — and for that matter, any other global service organization — has ever undertaken.” Some of these statistics, Sonnenberg has stated, were “soft numbers,” yet given the ubiquity of this sweet-deal defense in now-public post office documents, the figures would be difficult to disavow wholesale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r6wLeJeLYxg3f0PdlBVOnA.png" /></figure><p>In 2010, former teammate Floyd Landis sued Armstrong in federal court under provisions of the False Claims Act. The government joined the suit in 2013. It seeks to recoup more than $30 million — or up to triple that amount, actually, a chunk of which Landis would receive for whistleblowing — from Armstrong and his associates for defrauding the government by doping (thereby breaching his contracts) to win the Tour de France. It also claims the fallout from the doping revelations damaged the USPS brand — in other words, that the Postal Service did not get its money’s worth.</p><p>Trouble is, his attorneys have noted, Armstrong never signed a contract with the Postal Service; his contract was with Tailwind Sports, a point the Postal Service once raised in defense of the sponsorship (“The Postal Service does not pay Lance’s salary,” read a stock letter to a skeptical newspaper editor, in the agency’s 2004 communications plan). In an April filing for summary judgment, Armstrong’s counsel furnished a chart, sourced from USPS documents and public statements, that pegged the sponsorship’s quantified benefits to the post office, from 1996 to 2004, at $163.8 million, not including the also-touted boon to employee morale.</p><p>There is no evidence that any USPS employee knew, during the years of the sponsorship, that Armstrong used performance-enhancing drugs — but the agency braced for the possibility. The four-year contract extension, at the behest of Sonnenberg, included a moral turpitude clause. “I don’t know that I thought through the get-back-the-money-that-we-had-already-paid part,” she said of the clause during her deposition last year. “I was more concerned with being able to sever ties if we ever needed to.”</p><p>In November 2000, French newspapers reported on an ongoing investigation of the USPS cycling team. A French TV crew had witnessed a team doctor and chiropractor dispose of medical waste, which included one-hundred syringes and empty vials of the Norwegian drug Actovegin, the latter not banned at the time but believed to increase oxygen uptake. Later that month, Sonnenberg faxed Deputy Postmaster General John Nolan, “It has been two weeks since the story came out and, as of today, our team management has heard nothing from the French courts regarding an inquiry, nor do they expect to hear anything. They believe this story was manufactured by the French press. Also, there has been little additional media coverage.”</p><p>In February 2001, USPS contracting officer Lynda Zelnick wrote to a representative of DFP Cycling (a.k.a. Tailwind Sports) regarding plans to correct the negative publicity “and its concomitant impact on the value of our sponsorship.” Zelnick informed Tailwind Sports that the Postal Service had retained Manning Selvage &amp; Lee, a Chicago-based public relations firm, for $50,000, and would reimburse itself from sponsorship funds.</p><p>The same month, USPS employees drafted a contingency plan, which outlined “five possible drug testing results scenarios and [recommended] appropriate action steps and messaging.” If a team member tested positive in an EPO urine test, the report advised, the team manager would issue an “immediate statement challenging the validity of EPO urine tests.” If a team member tested positive in an EPO blood test, “[a]ssuming the tests were performed fairly, the offending rider should be removed from the team. Fighting the more reliable EPO blood tests would put USPS team in an untenable position.” If test results proved inconclusive, the team would “[i]ssue [a] statement that supports testing, but questions process.” The statement would include the message that “[i]nconclusive tests at this late date simply confirm that USPS team is drug free; conclusive evidence would have appeared long ago.” At the next racing event — “anywhere but France” — the team would hold a press conference that included “supportive cycling authorities and testing experts.” Team officials would be sure to “[p]oint out timeline — this process has gone on for nearly a year.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KMbCvE8efRq_OmpTmbcKeQ.png" /></figure><p>For her part, in late November 2000, Sonnenberg flew to Austin to meet with Armstrong at the Four Seasons Hotel for breakfast. She believed that Armstrong was responding to too many press inquiries himself. She told him that the “story only has legs because you continue to respond to it. And any reporter can get you to call back. And if you could just not do that, and let Mark [Gorski, general manager of Tailwind Sports] handle the press…I think maybe this story would not continue to grow.” She suggested that Lance and the USPS team “get together with some of the more reputable cycling teams and have a joint proclamation or commitment to zero tolerance, publicly.” Armstrong, she said, didn’t think much of the idea.</p><p>Having been assured so many times by Tailwind’s manager “that there is no way Lance would use drugs after what he had been through with cancer,” Sonnenberg never asked Armstrong if he had ever used them. Not even, Armstrong’s attorney Elliot Peters asked at the end of her deposition, when she “sat down with him at breakfast one-on-one” at the Four Seasons?</p><p>“No, I did not,” said Sonnenberg. “I had no reason to.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff0f1874f6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Blake Mills’ Alt-Americana: An Appreciation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/blake-mills-alt-americana-an-appreciation-f5f8758572a8?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5f8758572a8</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Feb 2015 06:03:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-05-29T05:48:46.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/1*rKLluGJC9kIyF3e77NqbFg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Look between the garish yellow block letters (<em>HEIGH HO</em>)<em> </em>pasted over the cover photograph and you’ll spy an introvert. LA-based singer/songwriter Blake Mills sits slumped over a capo-laden guitar — so slumped that his fretting arm rests on his thigh. Eyes closed, lips parted, he wills his instrument to speak. At live performances, again chair-bound by choice, he sinks into the same bent posture. When he sings, his neck contracts and his head pitches back in a pseudo-startle reflex.</p><p>“I hate shows,” he mumbles in a 2012 <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIYUShdzLlE">Red Bull-produced YouTube short</a>.</p><p>For the fall tour supporting <em>Heigh Ho</em>’s September release, he asked ballroom-style venues to set up chairs and close their bars. He consigned his first album, 2010’s <em>Break Mirrors</em>, to cassette tapes sold in a Venice Beach surf shop. The lyrics felt too introspective and revealing, he said, to be broadcast to a wider audience. But before and after that album’s soft release he worked as a session guitarist for artists like Andrew Bird and Kid Rock, toured with Lucinda Williams and Band of Horses, and produced records for Jesca Hoop and Nickel Creek’s Sara Watkins. In light of this prolificacy and collaborative zeal, one hesitates to typecast him — brooding in public, ebullient in private — as the next eremitic genius of popular music.</p><p>In the Red Bull documentary, Kid Rock says he once asked Mills, “What’s with all the weird stuff, man?” He was referring, I think, to <em>Break Mirrors</em>’ glut of lo-fi sonic frills — all the squeaks, amplifier hum, manipulated and doubled drums, and asymmetrical accompaniments from unfamiliarized instruments. The record sounds like an exhibit of Hurricane Sandy-damaged pop art. As a producer Mills delights in inventing and blending tones. Enumerating my favorite parts of <em>Break Mirrors — </em>here’s two: the odd clomping effect applied to the kick drum on the back half of “Hiroshima” and the tenuous growl of the right-panned guitar in the uptempo coda of “Wintersong”— would result in a litany of timestamped rattles and squawks. The lyrics are wry and cryptic. “Hey Lover,” a catchy, two-chord romp written for then-girlfriend, now-pop star Danielle Haim, has lines like, <em>I’ll never tell her when she plays a song I never heard / because I always learn the music and forget the words. </em>Like many talented instrumentalists who also write songs, he’s endowed with music-first, lyrics-last instincts. But his hunger for originality in harmonies and figures and sounds extends to words, too, and often these elements combine to achieve levels of expressivity and irony seldom heard in latter-day folk-rock.</p><p>On <em>Break Mirrors</em>’ second track, “It’ll All Work Out,” Mills plucks an ostinato bass while shifting between a C# chord and a C# chord marred with a raised fifth and a minor seventh. The shifting dissonances swathe the verse in a dismal, ambiguous tonality. He keeps time with forceful right-hand slaps on nylon strings. The lyrics offer a bleak or at least unromantic portrait of his parents’ parenting:</p><blockquote>He’d say, “Go to college, get your knowledge straightened out,”<br>With an air of desperation in the way it sounded,<br>Like he’d bet on it, and now it seemed his odds were down.</blockquote><p>As Mills reaches that third line, the tonality slides into D, leading to the chorus’ titular bromide over a cheery I-IV change, complete with a first-position D chord flourish familiar to anyone who’s had a handful of guitar lessons and knows some AC/DC. The effect is unsettling and a little bit comic. No one, least of all Mills, believes it’ll all work out. (On a recent WNYC <em>Soundcheck </em>performance of the song, above hushed accompaniment, Mills channels Leonard Cohen in an eerie <em>fil di voce.</em>)</p><p><em>Break Mirrors </em>suffers at times from a surfeit of originality, as if Mills, leaden with all the songs he’s written in the interstices of other artists’ tours and recording sessions, and perhaps wanting to divest himself of gripes tied to his upbringing and early adulthood, was understandably jazzed to get it all out. Though only a few full-on guitar solos appear on the record — a blast of bottleneck on “Hiroshima,” some atonal noodlery toward the end of “Under the Underground” — one could argue that this kind of knowingly reserved guitar playing is its own cliché. He knows every obvious guitar move and avoids them all. He’s internalized the less-is-more credo — but wants to make sure we know it. “There’s an obsession with the unusual turn of phrase, and an aversion to saying anything that might be considered banal or mannered or extraneous,” author George Saunders wrote in <em>New York Times Magazine </em>about re-reading his debut short story collection.</p><p>These are, I’ll own, quibbles that inevitably arise when one listens to an album entirely too much — though, at this point, I’ve listened to <em>Heigh Ho </em>more than <em>Break Mirrors</em>, and really I have only good things to say about it. I wonder what Kid Rock thinks of the new record. In the Red Bull interview, he seems to object to the weirding-up of Mills’ Americana sensibility. “[He’s] such a great blues player,” Rock says with a goateed moue.</p><p>Mills’ slide guitar playing, which on <em>Heigh Ho </em>features most prominently at the end of “Don’t Tell Our Friends About Me” — twin leads stutter in a synchronous, ascending riff (mimicking a seemingly tossed-off lick in the second chorus) before they dip, diverge and converge, rip into high-register peals and stereophonic burbles, swell via volume-knob massage and coast to a sweet and satisfying end — owes much to Derek Trucks, the resident reticent bottleneck wunderkind of the aughts.</p><p>Trucks, 35, completed his service in October to the now-disbanded Allman Brothers Band and will continue to spread his brand of soul revivalism with the Tedeschi Trucks Band, which he leads with his wife, blues and soul musician Susan Tedeschi. Eric Clapton heard Mills’ slidework on a <em>Grey’s Anatomy </em>episode and mistook the guitarist for Trucks, who had collaborated and toured with Slowhand in the mid aughts, and called his friend to congratulate him on the spot. Trucks referred Clapton to his emulator, and this referral earned Mills a spot at the 2014 iteration of the Crossroads Guitar Festival, which benefits the Crossroads Centre, Clapton’s drug rehabilitation clinic in Antigua. I attended the second Crossroads Guitar Festival in Dallas with my mom in the summer of 2004 as a rising high-school freshman (in my view the latest permissible age to attend a guitar festival or convention). Given its charitable ends, I feel obliged to say I am glad the six-string fetish fête exists, despite the preponderance of bad haircuts and black t-shirts embossed with chord charts and cartoon women.</p><p>“I became a big fan of Derek Trucks’ playing, and in reading about him I found that he wasn’t so focused on the pantheon of guitar players as much as he was other instrumentalists,” Mills said in a recent interview with <em>MusicRadar. </em>“He was coming from a gospel and soul side simultaneously with a Middle Eastern influence, and I thought, ‘Finally, here’s a musician who is showing me that these influences don’t have to be partitioned off.’”</p><p>Trucks’ distinctive style, once likened by John Mayer to “a female singer from the ‘50s or ‘60s just belting it out” — an amalgam of Indian classical, sacred steel, and Duane Allman — has been sufficiently rhapsodized elsewhere. When pressed, Mills will cite Trucks as an influence, as a guitarist who has transcended the instrument, but he’s more inclined to talk about Nina Simone. (“I Wish I Knew How it Would Feel to Be Free,” incidentally, was a staple of The Derek Trucks Band’s live set for years.) I don’t doubt that vocalists and non-guitar instrumentalists have had a strong influence on Mills; I regret that the word <em>eclectic </em>has been worn out by music critics, since Mills’ tastes seem genuinely, implausibly broad. I believe he’d rather listen to <em>Le Mystère des Voix Bulgares </em>than Stevie Ray Vaughan (though perhaps he belongs to the elite class of melomaniacs and highly-commissioned Eastman graduates for whom my and other amusic, album-less critics’ obsession with ranking records and scrutinizing styles with adjectives feels inimical to the appreciation of music — I might agree), and I know that at an early age Mills took lessons from world-music maven Bob Brozman, but I’ve always found this playing up of one’s non-guitar influences supercilious. Trucks did it too, always talking about Coltrane and Ali Akbar Khan. True, Trucks’ runs often sound like they’re blown by a Hindu saxist, and Mills’ habit of playing very, very quietly on very loud settings of very powerful amplifiers reminds me of the scarily resonant Simone in certain <em>piano </em>moments. A middling guitarist myself, I’ve gravitated toward the pariahs — Jeff Beck, Bill Frisell, Blake Mills — who tout woodwind- and brass-players over other guitarists. I’m repulsed by guitar-centric anything. I skip the sections in interviews where Mills discusses his “rig” — slang for his amplifiers and pedals and cables (of course the existence of these interviews undermines my argument about Mills’ guitar phobia). Guitarists are infamous for our lack of musical literacy and cloistered, idiomatic approach to mastery. Mills himself weighs in on this in a <em>VICE-</em>produced series on popular guitarists:</p><blockquote><em>One of my favorite things to do and one of the things that keeps me interested in guitar is coming up with ways to get it to sound like other instruments. I think a common trap that a lot of players fall into is that they pick their favorite guitar players and they grow up and they study those styles and they unlock whatever those secrets are, but it ends up kind of stunting the advancement of the instrument. What people don’t often pick out from [Jimi Hendrix’s] playing, for example, is that it seems like he was listening to horn players … It’s the guys that tend to figure out a way to not get the guitar to sound like Jimmy Page or get it to sound like Elmore James […] Those things have been discovered, and it’s beautiful to hear somebody play like that […] But the guys that really seem to make big steps and advancements are the ones who seem to be obsessed with wind players, with Middle-Eastern instruments.</em></blockquote><p>He goes on to imitate — convincingly — a sitar. “This is like palm to forehead territory for dudes who actually play the sitar, but it’s great for guitar players,” he says.</p><p>Host Matt Sweeney (credited with a co-write on <em>Heigh Ho</em>’s “Gold Coast Sinkin’” and “Before It Fell”) agrees. “The great thing about guitar is — ”</p><p>“Nobody takes it seriously,” Mills cuts in.</p><p>“Yeah, it’s just an instrument for assholes.”</p><p>“It’s like the Green Party for instruments,” says Mills. They laugh.</p><p>Sweeney gets to the crux of the matter: “The guitar is a cool thing where you can just do a really cheap, shitty version of something beautiful like a horn part or a sitar part […] and it sounds cool. You’re doing such a grave disservice to what you’re ripping off, and you sound awesome.”</p><p>They’re joking, partly, so it’s hard to object to Sweeney’s perhaps accidental description of horn or sitar parts as eo ipso beautiful without seeming like a pedant. But then this long diversion, prompted by a Kid Rock jab, into a talented guitarist’s (<em>most </em>talented guitarists’, I’d wager) anxieties about seeming too guitar-centric has already outed me as a nitpicker. I just find Mills a bit obscurant in these interviews for not big-upping more guitarists, for implicitly characterizing the guitar tradition as bloated, derivative, and onerous, one that demands constant elusion, rather than a rich lineage to mix up and milk and pilfer from. One can hear many canonical riffs refracted in Mills’ playing. Of course when I drop the elder statesman of the instrument schtick, <em>bloated, derivative, and onerous </em>seems an apt description of the guitar tradition. Chiding a stylistically-adventurous guitarist for liking <em>chorinho </em>or choral music amounts to instrument jingoism. And I <em>have </em>seen Mills cite guitarists, like rock and roll pioneer Ritchie Valens, Cuban legend Manuel Galbán, session whiz Ry Cooder (whose playing, along with that of Derek Trucks and perhaps John Scofield, Mills owes the most to), and Julian Lage, a boy wonder in the jazz scene who, now 27, has crossed into bluegrass and roots music with dazzling results. Who could blame Mills for touting extracurricular influences? Playing the Guitar Hero card might get you a spot on <em>Rolling Stone</em>’s next list of the best 100 guitarists, but it also invites hordes of rich teen boys and Telecaster Dads to the front rows of your shows to leer at your fretboard.</p><p>That said, he wasn’t above premiering “Shed Your Head,” an eight-minute improvisation with overdubs, by far the most guitar-centric song on <em>Heigh Ho</em>, really a jam, on <em>Guitar World </em>in August.</p><p>In late 2000 an Amazon reviewer, “Blake Mills” from Malibu, California, left a five-star review of The Derek Trucks Band’s second studio album, <em>Out of the Madness</em>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/0*oKWKzp7yLKmh08bD." /></figure><p>Mills was 14 at the time. The fourth track on <em>Out of the Madness </em>is a cover of Howlin’ Wolf’s “Forty Four” (first recorded by boogie-woogie piano man Roosevelt Sykes in 1929, though Wolf’s 1954 version features major alterations to the lyrics and music). Fronted by guest vocalist and guitarist Warren Haynes, The Derek Trucks Band performs a serviceable rendition of the song. I mean, it’s <em>fine — </em>an unremarkable cover cluttered with showcase slide guitar, recorded when Trucks was still a teenager and had not yet perfected his cosmopolitan, voice-like style (best captured, IMHO, on 2004’s <em>Live at Georgia Theatre).</em></p><p>I include Mills’ review not just because it’s funny or because it underscores how often seemingly unconventional musical maxims (space between the notes, etc.) are parroted by eighth graders, but because this song, “Forty Four,” by Mills’ own admission, is the kernel of the first song on <em>Heigh Ho</em>, “If I’m Unworthy.”</p><p>I imagine Kid Rock, at least at first, will be pleased when he plays “If I’m Unworthy.” With an overdriven, down-and-open-tuned Telecaster, Mills adapts “Forty-Four” — piano, drums, guitar, and all — by sporadically accenting swung eighth notes with a tireless right hand above a familiar bass figure. When the tune diverges from the anticipated twelve-bar form with jazzy passing chords and a leisured turnaround, Rock might still be hair-whipping along, though perhaps miffed by the absence of drums as we move into the second verse.</p><p>Indeed, where are the drums? One wants them on every big <em>one. </em>When they still don’t drop on the third verse — though there’s a ramp-up of bass and guitar and vocal energy — all listeners have noticed the absence of percussion and are wondering what this might mean. First we’re denied a twelve-bar blues, now we’re denied drums in our not-twelve-bar blues. Mills delivers the song’s refrain once more:</p><blockquote>What if I’m unworthy of<br>The power I hold<br>Over you?</blockquote><p>Maybe in interpersonal relationships he’s ambivalent about agency, but on the record, as singer/songwriter/producer/guitarist, Mills wields the power we grant him — in the form of our expectations, our collective musical intuition’s well-worn grooves — to challenge and surprise us. He’s exuberant, irreverent. Not long after that third refrain, an overdriven squall, like a commercial-grade lawn mower sputtering out, introduces a slide guitar solo. At first Mills matches the bass part with delicate harmonics. You realize that he’s playing very quietly and that his guitar is still quite audible, front-and-center in the mix, which means — yup — another huge squall, this time slapped with tape delay. For a spell the solo completely overwhelms the mix, as if it’s 1951 and Elmore James has just stepped closer to the studio’s lone microphone. Mills slashes some more, doused in nasty high frequencies. A burst of strings, arranged by Rob Moose of the indie-classical group yMusic, lends the bluesy track some fleeting Dixieland flavor for two bars before a sudden diminuendo. Mills croons a final, subdued verse. Still no drums.</p><p>They eventually come, courtesy of septuagenarian studio legend Jim Keltner (Bob Dylan, Elvis, etc.), in a quasi coda, the sort of vamp you’d expect to go on for several minutes at the end of a cut like this one on a hackneyed blues-rock album. Now that the pretense of a song has been dealt with, we expect the guitarist to show us all the new licks he’s learned since his last album. But the song dissolves after three measures, just shy of the five-minute mark. Some friends I’ve shared this record with are left feeling that nothing revelatory has transpired — on this track or on this record. Maybe I’m eminently discerning; maybe you need to have been mired in lukewarm, guitar-centric blues-rock for the duration of your adolescence to appreciate Mills’ innovations; maybe I’m inclined to find his work inspiring — when in reality it’s insipid — because his guitar playing is unimpeachable. For me the album’s accretion of tiny, unexpected decisions; its sawtooth dynamics; its Van Dyke Parksian orchestrations; and its subtle-but-stubborn defiance of tropes, all constructed atop a stratum of technical mastery, make <em>Heigh Ho </em>something more than a solid roots-rock record. It’s Americana made strange.</p><p>What a transformation of “Forty-Four”! It’s neither blues-by-rote nor an artful dodge of obvious influences. Rather, it’s a wonderful contemporary warping of a tradition I’ve tired of admiring that evinces a songwriter’s commitment to all parts of his product — the chord structure, the lyrics, the instrumentation, the sound. It’s tender and snarling, stricken with doubt and tension until the very last bars.</p><p>And yes, the album <em>sounds </em>really, really good. Mills might love sound more than he loves music. Each guitar tone — gorgeous, as expected — perfectly blends with its respective song’s gestalt. Mills’ thumbstrokes on bright nylon complement the brush-struck snare on “Don’t Tell Our Friends About Me.” The more muted plucks and strums of “Cry to Laugh” meld with the double bass’ buzz. No shade at the former, the album’s clear standout track, but the latter, clocking in at 2:47, is a mini-masterpiece. Its verses comprise a restless quarter-note motif, little jabs of three-note chords, and a jarring modulation before the progression bends toward resolution as the bass ascends. Sometimes the bass slips to suggest a shuffle beneath the guitar’s stiff beat. Mills plays the part of a hapless, endearing loser. “I tried but I cried to laugh,” he shrugs as the first verse completes its loop. An electric guitar soon joins the mix to make plain the song’s latent honky-tonkiness before the chorus arrives:</p><blockquote>I tried believing that I could be your leadin’ man.<br>You just wanna do as you always have done but you can’t.</blockquote><p>Mills holds a lovely vibrato on “man.” His singing voice, vaguely Southern and sneering, reminds me of Randy Newman’s, only more intimate and breathy, more dynamic, more vulnerable. In a live-streamed interview with <em>Fretboard Journal</em>, Mills credited the piano playing of that acerb absurdist as inspiration for the guitar part’s economical shape-shifting. I like “Cry to Laugh” for the faith Mills exhibits in its academic choppiness, its subtle swing (which subverts what might seem a classical guitar study in a kind of <em>trompe l’oreille)</em>, and for the sheer liveliness of the tiple-dappled mix, teeming with twangs and moans of every timbre, each sound vibrating together and apart, wide like the vista the luckless woodsman in the first verse might encounter “on the hunt to feed all [his] little pains.”</p><p>The recording space itself — the “B” room of the famous Ocean Way studios in Hollywood — seems as big a player as any of the album’s all-star musicians, a truth I think Mills underscores with the bits of studio chatter and miscellaneous noises left between many of the tracks. The thumb-swept acoustic strings of “Three Weeks In Havana” I find synesthetically lush, as if each stroke is a daub on a sun-drenched canvas. Keltner’s brushwork sounds like the ocean. I’m so enveloped by the song’s pleasant clime, the guitars’ chromatic and colorful plashes, that I don’t object to the one-note guitar solo that appears toward the end, a hushed syncopation that gives us more time and space to savor the balmy ambience. It feels like a statement, another exhortation to enjoy the music as a whole.</p><p>On a good stereo, the low-end resonance of the drums and double bass on “Just Out of View” is almost unbearably voluptuous. (On Instagram Mills recommended listening to the album on CD rather than vinyl: “so much of this record has to do with extreme bottom end and detail in the top or ‘air.’ When you master to vinyl you immediately sacrifice those two areas.”) The song itself is one of the weaker tunes on the album — too clearly constructed around one cool, surf-infused guitar riff — but the lyrics have an abrupt sardonicism I’ve come to enjoy in a lot of Mills’ work:</p><blockquote>The young one finds the doorman quite good looking.<br>He considers me<br>A fag,<br>Because he’s the judge of “all that.”<br>He and maybe a dozen bros<br>That have been unloved by their dads.</blockquote><p>To set this barb in a dream-like sonic environment, when one so reflexively expects boilerplate about dreams (or worse, drugs), seems to me another sign of Mills’ disinclination toward the familiar, as well as an invitation to engage in attentive listening. Measure to measure, verse to verse, song to song Mills exhibits a commitment to the creation of new sounds to capture old feelings — without ever tipping too far toward the academic or avant-garde. He is unafraid to dance with American traditions; “Seven,” a duet with Fiona Apple, is steeped in a county-fairground aesthetic — echoic vocals, calliope-like organ, a dollop of delicious, bluesy vamping. But it is the somewhat subliminal layer of what I <em>think </em>is a filthily-distorted keyboard, one that pretty much hews to the foregrounded slidework but occasionally drones outside the lines, that coats the song in dread. (The cattywampus carnival vibe is abetted, too, by spectral percussion work, particularly the unruly bells that pitch the song toward its midpoint crescendo.)</p><p><a href="http://instagram.com/p/tqCbxQRTv6/?modal=true">Blake Mills and Fiona Apple</a></p><p>“Curable Disease” concludes the album with a bitter goodbye to, presumably, an ex-fling who’s become a big pop star. The postscript to “Hey Lover,” perhaps. Propelled by the guitar’s restive eighth-note syncopations and a chain of sour imperatives, the song throbs with a tropical melancholy.</p><blockquote>Go on and taste your dreams.<br>Leave me with the bill.<br>Miss me half as much as you say you will.<br>You can make me believe that you need me still.<br>Love may be a curable disease.<br>Those dreams, they are like pills.</blockquote><p>Like <em>Break Mirrors</em>, then, <em>Heigh Ho </em>ends on a pained, ruminative note (“History of My Life” caps off the former record with the refrain, “Oh God, couldn’t I just change the history of my life sometimes?”). In the four years between the two releases, Mills has built an exhaustive list of star clients and collaborators, has played <em>out </em>quite a bit, while concurrently honing a modus operandi at once meditative, retiring, and cheeky. In concert a favorite trick of his is, while soloing, to imperceptibly roll down the volume knob on his guitar until he is playing wholly unamplified. It has never failed, in the times I’ve witnessed it, to make listeners lean forward in their chairs and realize, once the thin twang familiar to anyone who has spent time in a college dorm room has ceased, that they have held their breath in an unconscious attempt to avoid the obtrusion of every last sound wave.</p><p>I want to mention again the stellar orchestrations of Rob Moose — especially the Latin brass ornamentations that entwine the triple meters of “Before It Fell” and the oneiric swells that sustain “Half Asleep,” two songs that may in fact be the best on the album. But they will be and have been invariably overlooked by “Don’t Tell Our Friends About Me” (north of 1.5 million listens on Spotify, as of this writing). I’ve already mentioned the delicate, dyadic slidework at the end of the track and the impeccably-matched sounds of Mills’ thumbstrokes and the drummer’s brushstrokes — and feel somewhat contrite about this piecemeal, left-brainy dissection of what is such a fiercely emotive song. Gushing about its production might undersell its overall wallop. (I’ll go with this line of thought for the purposes of this overdue conclusion, but in actuality I think, at least for Mills, how a song is produced cannot be extricated from the song itself.) I read somewhere that for this record Mills had tried to write more character-based work à la Newman but ultimately couldn’t shake his compulsion to confess. Be that as it may, the narrator of “Don’t Tell Our Friends About Me” is paranoid and overbearing and comic in his despair, reminiscent of Newman’s troupe of Nabokovian solipsists and brutes. “I know I fucked up, I know I fucked up,” Mills incants in the perhaps misguided belief that forgiveness can be bought by bludgeoning the offended party with admissions of guilt. Fiona Apple makes another cameo to harmonize the chorus. Later she delivers a counterpoint that further underscores the narrator’s madness. “I’m not friends with his friends anyway,” she remarks.</p><p>Sorry to be such a miniaturist, a goofy scruplist, but I must mention one more tiny moment that for me eclipses everything else, much as I’d like to foster in myself a more thoroughgoing appreciation for the song’s complete emotional course. It happens just before the second chorus. “Frankly, I don’t know what else I can confess to you,” Mills sings over a sudden effusion of tiple, the Colombian ukulele. There’s a low-end bending, C to D, which heralds the arrival of the V chord (F) — the last in a mostly-descending, five-chord progression spangled with the shimmering drones of Mills’ tweaked top two strings (retuned from B and E to Bb and F, respectively; 2/3 of the tonic chord) — and teases our imminent return to the I (Bb) for the chorus. Had it happened just once, I likely would not have noticed. But now as we linger on the V, and Mills delivers another line (“Lovers may quarrel and spar sometimes, but…”) that will bleed into the chorus, twice more — this time with greater force and irresponsibility — he womps on that C-D one-two as the song teeters between verse and chorus. Oh, these are exquisite womps! Definitive womps! <em>The </em>womps! They add a tension that unjustifiably amplifies the pleasure I get as we spill into the entreating refrain. They’re akin to Jonny Greenwood’s celebrated dead-noise womps on “Creep” (which, like these womps, sit at the precipice of the chorus), only half as abrasive and even more fucking special — because they happen only once. Yes, just once, like much of the album’s fancywork. If these sorts of flourishes happen twice, we know they’re the products of careful deliberation, split-testing, &amp;c. Nothing wrong with that! I welcome such exertion on my behalf. It was with this kind of meticulosity Mills doubtless assembled <em>Heigh Ho. </em>I’ve tried to show how much thought and craft went into the collage. The title itself invokes the daily grind. Moments of supposed happenstance or improvisation (though this term for me suggests a Berklee-bred modal fluency and the attendant music that, perhaps due to my desultory musical education and unskilled cilia, leaves me unmoved) can be regarded as the product of Mills’ two decades of listening to and making music.</p><p>And still, listening to <em>Heigh Ho — </em>listening to it nearly six months after its release — I feel as if at any moment anything could happen. Lots of stuff feels left up to chance; the record’s aforesaid asymmetricities and lurid granularity give it the sparkle of live performance.</p><p>“I was listening to Elmore James on the way over here,” Mills says to Matt Sweeney in a video for D’Addario strings, “and I hadn’t realized how many times in the span of one song his voice completely breaks and cracks. There are these things going on on his records that would never make the cut today — they would be fixed, or there would be another take.”</p><p>To me Mills is like an eminently fashionable friend whose ambitious stylistic choices invite attention whenever we go. I’ve known him and his wardrobe long enough to find the praise a bit much — I know all his tricks and am allergic to the obvious joy he finds in his dandyism — and yet not infrequently I see him and think, man, <em>the motherfucker looks good. </em>He has raked the fabric of <em>Heigh Ho </em>with high-grit sandpaper to yield an altogether pleasing, “distressed” look. Oh, that song? Just something he found in his grandfather’s closet. <em>This</em>? A thrift-store curio, ’tis all. I’m well aware of all the work that goes into his look, so it’s doubly impressive that it always feels fresh.</p><p>“That secondary sound thing,” Mills goes on, speaking of James’ voice breaks, “becomes the thing that people are in the studio ten years later trying to replicate.” If on <em>Heigh Ho </em>Mills has replicated the lovely mistakes of past recording artists, I can’t tell. There are no obvious transpositions. There are influences, there is a recombining of styles, sure, but the record really just sounds like itself. I can’t wait to hear which of Mills’ tics are picked up by his acolytes ten years hence. Somewhere some stripling is writing an effusive, somewhat-embarrassing review of <em>Heigh Ho </em>on Amazon (<em>Blake Mills has mind-melting chops, but I love how he just holds back…</em>)<em>. </em>I’d place this panegyric in that same, gushy league.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5f8758572a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hello Internet]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukestdnathan/hello-internet-78aae09349b2?source=rss-e3fe8bdc0306------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78aae09349b2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Stoddard Nathan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Oct 2014 20:49:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-31T20:36:04.094Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“First of all,” says C.G.P. Grey, whose fact-dense YouTube videos on oft-Googled topics like copyright law and daylight saving time have garnered over 100 million views, “I think that this podcast is a place where I’m going to be wrong quite a lot.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*Ae1Ii5O3vvwC_hDvgOFuSw.png" /><figcaption>The logo of <em>Hello Internet</em>, a podcast produced by veteran YouTubers C.G.P. Grey and Brady Haran</figcaption></figure><p>“That’s a really positive note to start on,” says co-host Brady Haran, a video journalist best known for his Numberphile channel, where he has enlisted academics to explain the optimal way to cut a birthday cake or choose a Port-a-John at a music festival.</p><p>A one-bar burst of two-tone semiquavers — call it a theme sound — interrupts the banter, like an SMS alert a smidgen too long and too gaudy to pass without comment. I’m thankful that the ditty, part of the suite of desiderata endemic to podcasts at large, is short and monophonic. I’ll endure highbrow programs’ self-consciously eclectic scores, but if a show selects a 30-second snippet of a Thin Lizzy tune as its permanent jingle, I won’t linger long enough to nab the Squarespace offer code. UX oversights and slights merit swift unsubscribing. Implicit in podcast shopping is a prognosis: Can I bear the hosts’ tics and tropes, the show’s foibles of form, for thirty hours?</p><p>In the case of <em>Hello Internet </em>(the above-quoted exchange marks the start of episode one) the answer is yes. The podcast, now in its third season, is designed for the long-term listener. Potential vexation points are limited. Scant sonic trimmings comprise the theme sound and the xylophonic blips that bookend the two advertisements, always rendered anew in Grey’s “syrupy” voice (Brady’s descriptor). Though I don’t aspire to create an exceptional website and find audiobooks autocratic — why surrender my power over pacing? — I rarely thumb my listening app’s “thirty-seconds forward” button. Grey imparts the copy with sponsor-approved gusto without defaulting to hyperbole. When I rake through potential subscriptions, my eye elides podcasts that clutter their allotted pixels with text and graphics. <em>Hello Internet</em>’s logo offers an expedient greeting: “HI” in big white block letters on a charcoal backdrop.</p><p>Vital adornments default to frippery if the bulk of the product — in this case, conversation — is substandard. True to Grey’s forecast, wrongness abounds, though most mistakes are minor. He starts the second episode by correcting a misnomer in the first: <em>The Economist </em>is a weekly newspaper, not a magazine. After he atones for the error (and after Brady asks if anyone’s still listening), Grey proffers a suspicion that future episodes will consist entirely of the hosts responding to listeners’ feedback.</p><p>A podcast in which a perfectionist and his friend rehash mistakes made in past episodes? Not quite what I pine for while planted in others’ armpits on the L train. But I ignored the sign of coming boredom and listened to the rest of the episode (on copyright law) and the next one (on work-life balance). The first three episodes, each under an hour in length, were recorded before the pilot, “Being Wrong on The Internet,” went public in January. Grey, ostensibly concerned they might run out of broadcast fodder, billed the podcast as a ten-episode “experiment.” His conservative estimate of the podcast’s lifespan rhymes the show’s cautious start. In contrast to the improvisational tenor of later episodes, a conspicuous effort is made to stick to predetermined topics. Tangents are curtailed as Grey leads cogent arguments to their conclusions.</p><p>From the start, though, Grey and Brady eschew formal introductions — another unbearable convention forgone. An orotund American voice holds court with a heap of reasoned opinions, while a sweeter, more sibilant Australian asks questions and argues for intangibles. Bios emerge: both live in England and support themselves with ad revenue from YouTube videos. C.G.P. Grey (a pseudonym; he has not publicly revealed his identity) grew up somewhere in New York state and, in a past professional life, taught physics at a British secondary school. He also ran a time-management business. Brady Haran hails from Adelaide. For seven years he worked as a video journalist at the BBC. Today he juggles myriad science-centric YouTube channels, some of which were commissioned by the University of Nottingham and Google.</p><p>Grey’s videos feature unadorned animations with dense, meticulous scripts declaimed at radio-addendum speed. Each one entails 50 to 100 hours of work. He’s published about 100 since starting his channel in 2010. Within a week of publication, a video’s views must eclipse his channel’s total number of subscribers (about 1.5 million) for Grey to consider the project a success. SocialBlade, a YouTube analytics tool, estimates that this primary channel brings in $2.2K to $17.3K per month in advertising revenue. Grey also solicits contributions on crowdfunding sites <a href="https://subbable.com/">Subbable</a> and <a href="http://www.patreon.com/">Patreon</a>, which allow fans to make recurring donations of any dollar amount, a courtesy he equates in his video pitch with “buy[ing] a stranger Internet coffee.”</p><p>Brady doesn’t afford his YouTube productions lengthy incubation periods. He’s adopted the jellyfish model of parental investment, often releasing several videos in a day across an indeterminable number of channels. Some videos sport seven-figure view counts; others have gone viral. Tall tales concerning Haran’s sundry channels and Grey’s work hours per video have become part of the show’s folklore. On the <a href="http://www.reddit.com/r/cgpgrey">C.G.P. Grey reddit</a>, new <em>Hello Internet </em>episode threads regularly amass over five hundred comments. One fan discovered that the theme sound’s 16-note sequence, when converted to bits and placed in an ASCII binary-to-text converter, spells “HI.” Another shared a single-serve site he built that tells visitors the number of videos Haran has released since the date of Grey’s last published work. Though grounded in good fun, the comparison, as Haran has noted, undersells the talents and efforts of both creators, casting one as a prolific peddler of shlock and the other as a luftmensch.</p><p>The title of the fourth episode, “Feedback on Feedback,” evokes the playful indulgence typical of the show. Highly-optimized autodidacts beholden to podcasts for actionable facts; young creatives spellbound by their idols’ bland habits; flagging commuters sustained by brave, fresh storytelling: all might be miffed by <em>Hello Internet</em>’s insular chitchat and flippant debates. I’ve lost my taste for <em>Radiolab </em>and <em>This American Life — </em>the grating polyphony, the precious adventures. On those shows, when an interviewee drops a telling turn of phrase, I hear the producer’s intercostals contract, his grip tighten on the shotgun mic. I hear him brace for a chance at a followup probe as he mentally cues a trip-hop sonata to move us into the next segment. Of course I recognize and sometimes marvel at the skill with which Ira &amp; co. splice stories into edifying hours of radio. Maybe, like Sam Lipsyte <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/this-week-in-fiction-sam-lipsyte">in this interview</a> with the <em>New Yorker</em>, I’m just sick of <em>storytelling — </em>storytelling as the secret for striking Big Business Deals<em>— </em>especially when I am aware that it is happening to or near me:</p><blockquote>[W]ith some of the increasing vagueness in job definitions, people have come to rely on storytelling or the idea of creating narratives as a catchall. My dentist is a storyteller, weaving a narrative from my bloody gums. My accountant uses numbers to tell a story about my debts and the threat of ruin. Sadly, my barber doesn’t say squat. I’d welcome a story from him. But it’s also an intrinsic part of sales these days. You don’t just buy some jam or a loaf of bread or a chair or a car. You have to hear a whole story about how the product came about, often a tedious tale about how somebody quit the rat race (after making a mint in advertising or data mining or manufacturing weapons) and discovered an old family recipe and then made friends with local farmers and woodsmen. Or a team of engineers got together and asked themselves one simple question. It’s always one simple question. Never a series of complicated questions. The jam is usually great and the chair well crafted. The car is a gleaming wonder. But the narrative angle gets annoying after a while. I prefer the closed course, a professional driver, and an indie rock song that used to be important to me pumping through the speakers.</blockquote><p>“Feedback on Feedback” clocks in at over ninety minutes, a comfortable length that allows the hosts not so much to delve deeper into topics as skate across them. Never listen to a podcast without also doing something else. It’s a slapdash art form best enjoyed absentmindedly. Wash dishes, drive your children to soccer practice, have sex. Allow your attention to perk up for the best bits as you busy yourself doing other things, as you would while listening to a baseball broadcast or a Wagner opus. Even the perfunctory <em>Hello Internet </em>listener soon gleans the show’s prime gambit: Grey is efficient, and Brady is not.</p><p>“The more we do these podcasts the more … I realize how different we are,” says Grey at the start of episode six. One redditor draws amusing cartoons that depict Grey as a one-wheeled robot with glasses and Brady as a caveman. Grey’s ideal home is “as empty and spartan as possible” — he loathes clutter — while Brady welcomes the steady accumulation of tchotchkes. Another time, Brady begins to tell Grey about a dream he had the previous night, but censors himself when he senses Grey’s impending censure. “I judge people very harshly if they’re the kind of people who want to tell you about their dreams,” says Grey. It seems he’s run cost-benefit analyses on all his opinions (“I try to be very consistent and very evidence-based in my thinking”). He plugs business books like <em>Getting Things Done </em>and <em>So Good They Can</em>’<em>t Ignore You </em>and <em>The Checklist Manifesto. </em>He has a “Not To Do” list, at the top of which is “Learn a Foreign Language.” In one episode, “Sorry, Language Teachers,” he argues that foreign language classes should not be required in high schools because they rarely lead to fluency. Brady’s response to this hard stance is characteristically ambivalent, affable, and unconvincing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B92r-GnGMwbnRNdNRN_0-Q.png" /><figcaption>Image created by reddit user <a href="http://www.reddit.com/user/TuncJH">TuncJH</a></figcaption></figure><p>The best bits arise in “followup,” the segment at the start of each show in which Grey and Brady give personal- and work-related updates and respond to reddit comments. Redditors’ insights sometimes incite funny exchanges between the hosts that highlight their disparate dispositions and (in)efficiencies:</p><blockquote>GREY: Someone asked if you were a hunt-and-peck typist. Is that the case, Brady? I’m guessing that they thought so based on that little moment [in the previous episode] where we could hear you typing.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Ah, see, I thought they were just casting aspersions on me that I would just be that type of person, but they were basing it on evidence.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: And as soon as I saw that question I thought, you know, it did take him a long time to type whatever he was typing. Are you a hunt-and-peck typist?</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: What do you think — like, from what you know of me?</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: Here’s the problem: I always just assume that everyone can touch type. And I’m always surprised to discover people who cannot touch type. So I would just assume that you could. But I feel a strong moment of doubt here that you are not a touch typist. But you would have to be since you worked at a newspaper and you had to write quickly. So … my emotions are thinking maybe you’re not a touch typist, but my logical guess would be that you are. Which half of me is wrong here?</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Grey, you should always trust your feelings. [<em>both laugh</em>]</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: God, how do you survive in the world? … Now every time we instant message back and forth I’m going to have to feel sorry for you. “Oh, he’s there, trying to find the letter ‘s’ on the keyboard.”</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: I know where it is! I know where the ‘s’ is. It’s up in the — I know the general area. And then once my hand’s moving in the general direction — you know, light travels very fast.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: So you’re looking at the keyboard when you’re typing.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: [<em>pensively</em>] That’s sad.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Why, what are you doing, reading a book or something?</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: I’m looking at the screen while I’m typing.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Oh, I know what’s on the screen … It’s the buttons I’m pressing down on the keyboard.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: When you say it like that it’s hard to argue with. [<em>Long pause</em>] Interesting, learned something new about you today.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: Yeah, you just think that little bit less of me. I am gradually eroding [<em>Grey laughs</em>]. I’m definitely eroding quicker than I’m building, I noticed that.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: I am slightly disappointed, I must admit.</blockquote><p>Their divergent email-checking strategies, discussed at length in episode six, underscore the same efficiency divide. Both receive about a hundred emails a day that, at least ideally, merit a response. Grey, guided by Merlin Mann’s “Inbox Zero” talk at Google in 2007, has developed a system to minimize the amount of time he spends sifting through his inbox, which he checks no more than twice a day. He reads the first line of the first paragraph and the first line of the second paragraph. That takes him “an absolute max” of three seconds. By that time he has deleted the email, flagged it for a later response, or responded immediately.</p><p>What if you misjudge a message? Brady wonders. What if the emailer buries the lede and you miss out on a great business opportunity? While he accepts the risk of overlooking worthy propositions, Grey believes that the longer an email is, the less likely it is to be valuable. Emailing a busy person is an empathic exercise, and from all the bad pitches he receives on daily basis — emails longer than his computer screen spell Instant Deletion — Grey has refined his own pleas to VIPs. Three paragraphs, two sentences each. Introduce yourself last — the VIP first wants to know what you want from her (if interested she’ll check your credentials). Grey boasts of “very high response rates for the emails I send other busy people who don’t know who I am.”</p><p>Brady endorses a less-streamlined system of email management:</p><blockquote>BRADY: I check my email once every 15–20 minutes at least.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: That is literally a dopamine addiction.</blockquote><blockquote>BRADY: I’ve got to a point now where sometimes I take it out of my task bar on the Mac because even if its closed I will just instinctively go down and open it. Like even if I don’t want to open it, I’ll just go down and click on it and open it and be like, “Ah, I’ve opened it.” I didn’t even want to open it but I’ve gone and done it like a reflex.</blockquote><blockquote>GREY: You gotta break that dopamine addiction, buddy.</blockquote><p>Grey doesn’t respond to fan mail. Brady sometimes does. “If I think they’ve written something from the heart, I will write something,” he says. “I will say thanks and then I’ll make sure there is one sentence or one phrase in there that proves that I’ve read the email.” The hosts spend a lot of time considering how to manage their emails, “but should both of us be thinking about what [the fan] will get from us taking five seconds to reply?” Brady asks.</p><p>“I actually got the most valuable thing in my life from email … which is my wife,” says Grey. “I met my wife through email from an earlier Internet project that I was running that she liked and she sent me an email just as a random person on the Internet and that eventually led to us meeting and getting married. And her first email was very good. It was an email that indicated that she actually knew who I was and [that] we had common interests.”</p><p>“Have you kept that email?” asks Brady.</p><p>Grey says yes, of course.</p><p>“I knew you were sentimental somewhere. It’s an e-possession, though.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtQ7_vbNEDEk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtQ7_vbNEDEk&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtQ7_vbNEDEk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e54ab03527d125101f7dba08e772d804/href">https://medium.com/media/e54ab03527d125101f7dba08e772d804/href</a></iframe><p>Try as they might to amplify their differences for podcast theater, Grey and Brady are still white men in their thirties who share an unusual career and an interest in science and tech. Grey refers to the podcast’s genre as “Two Dudes Talking.” He’s logged thousands of hours listening to a range of podcasts and likes this format best, even when he doesn’t understand or care about the subject matter. The intuition he’s built from listening to all this material helps him to avoid other shows’ aural clutter and throat clearing. Podcast theme songs are annoying, ads shouldn’t be recycled, it’s okay for follow-up to consume the whole show — these are revelations of an attentive listener and student of design. (Grey thinks a lot about what makes things look good. He’s spoken about kerning, the undeserved lampooning of Comic Sans, and 99<em>% Invisible</em>, a podcast about design.) The fun part of following a podcast from the beginning is that you get to hear games and in-jokes unfold. Grey calls it an “evolving conversation.” Mutations like Brady’s Plane Crash Corner (inspired by his habit of reading NTSB reports) and Brady’s Paper Cuts (in which Haran airs minor complaints about the world) distinguish the show in the bloated “Two Dudes Talking” niche.</p><p>Grey is not a heartless robot. “I’m keenly aware of the sad, sad limitations of my own mammal-monkey brain,” he says in episode seven.</p><blockquote>I think I’m this clever, rational person, but I have a monkey brain in my skull just like every other human does. And that monkey brain is easily distracted and it doesn’t want to pay attention and it engages in all this horrible, self-destructive behavior. Being productive is learning to deal with the monkey in your head who just wants to sit in the sunshine and eat bananas or go run around.</blockquote><p>Mostly I believe he’s human because of his ardent complaints. He mourns the missed opportunities of <em>The Hobbit </em>films and Spike Jonze’s <em>Her. </em>He rants about the Kindle Paperwhite, in his estimation the best e-book reader available, which only compounds his frustration. (A vehement digiphile, Grey calls physical volumes “books made of paper.”) The Paperwhite lacks the option to left-justify text (“an abomination in the eyes of the typographic gods”) and sullies the I-just-finished-a-book afterglow with crass upsells. Brady makes a crack about Grey having inserted his emotion chip. Faced with his flights of indignation and strategic soul-searching, one never doubts Grey’s ability to pass the Turing Test.</p><p>Midway through the second season, Grey asserts that they are getting worse at doing the show, evidenced by the ballooning preamble. Longtime lurkers know he’s kidding. With experience the hosts have become more comfortable with never getting to the point. Free from the chore of retaining key points or tracing narratives, I listen to enjoy the play of Grey and Brady’s personalities, even if they’re more similar than they’d like to admit. Almost by accident I accrue token knowledge of net neutrality and the design flaws of U.S. state flags. As Grey might explain, each day we’re allotted finite amounts of intellectual energy. <em>Hello Internet </em>is an inefficient conduit for facts and wisdom and plot, but the organic exchange makes it palatable for commutes and workday interludes. Stories are tucked in the folds of discursive discussion rather than presented with the goal of blowing the listener’s mind. More deliberately-constructed podcasts, with their glut of ambition and craft, are too filling. I’ll opt for lighter fare.</p><p><em>HI </em>is hard to summarize succinctly. When, in response to my unsolicited endorsement, friends ask what the show’s about, I muster something hazy about the Internet and technology. In episode 11 (“Stream of Irrelevancy”) the hosts float a new tagline, “It’s not waffling, it’s an amazing amount of content” — tongue-and-cheek but also a clue that they have not totally shaken the compulsion to be pragmatic. The joke evinces an anxiety that #content is only useful when it supplies life tips and information.</p><p>Recently stirred by the worry that I had deleted my attention span and kinesthesia thanks to untold chair-bound hours online, I pared down my Internet use. I sought out a few sources like <em>Hello Internet </em>to serve as representative samples of digital culture. How to head off the loss of Internet fluency? I worried I’d tout outmoded trends, memes, argots, idioms. I’d jump into an Internet debate and suffer reproof. But a fear of never getting anything done now trumped the fear of Being Wrong On (Or About) The Internet. No one would care about my digital illiteracy if I had no pieces to my name. Forgoing creative work to track kyphotic firebrands’ hashtags seemed a poor long-term career strategy.</p><p>I scuttled the plan once I realized I could get work done without rehabbing my web habits. Grey stresses the importance of having systems in your life that force you to make good decisions. Don’t trust resolutions and willpower — they fluctuate with mood. “I try to be very consistent and very evidence-based in my thinking in my life,” he says in an early episode. In my inconstancy I’ve so enjoyed the steady presence of <em>Hello Internet</em>, its consistent breeziness and robust inefficiency, that I’m hostile to the prospect of another trip to the iTunes podcast page. Acclimating to new hosts, new music, new pacing, new segments — oh, horrible! I’ve made it well past the thirty-hour benchmark with my betrothed and don’t wish to start over. The day Brady and Grey run out of things to talk about is the day I quit the Internet, though unless I introduce some sort of accountability to my wild resolutions, I can’t really believe this vow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78aae09349b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>