<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Luke W. Henderson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Luke W. Henderson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 22:46:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Tale of Two Writers: When Michael Crichton & James Patterson Collided]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/a-tale-of-two-writers-when-michael-crichton-james-patterson-collided-8541751e82b3?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8541751e82b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-intellectualism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[michael-crichton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[james-patterson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writers-on-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Nov 2026 18:01:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-11T18:01:03.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3D0UfU7ASqwUZizgAIyMRQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Preface</h3><p>This is my fourth attempt to write and publish this essay. Most of my essays begin and end with a genuine love or curiosity about the topic, but this one was different. Each attempt left me feeling anxious and dreadful as negative emotions took over my body and my words. Eventually, I’d feel so bad that I would stop and promise to finish it later, but never did.</p><p>Over two years ago, I started researching James Patterson and Michael Crichton because I <em>had </em>to know how these two writers came together to finish the posthumously published <em>Eruption</em>. When I mentioned to my coworkers that Patterson had completed an unpublished Crichton manuscript, I got a lot of confusion and variations of “How does that make sense? They’re so different!”</p><p>I agreed. Something felt off, but there was no specific reason I could point toward. Middle school was the last time I’d read a Patterson book, so I didn’t know if this feeling had any justification.</p><p>Michael Crichton is one of my favorite authors. In college, I attempted to read all his books because I was so enamored with his stories. Ultimately, I never reached that goal, but his work has had a lasting impact on me. After rereading some of my favorites for research, his impact on my writing style cannot be denied.</p><p>Patterson, on the other hand, I was indifferent toward. He had a reputation for not <em>truly</em> writing his books and being a poor craftsman among my community, but it seemed to be mostly from secondhand information and vibes. The curious itch had to be scratched, so I decided to dive into his life and work.</p><p>But that curiosity was disingenuous. The more I learned, the more I grew to despise James Patterson.</p><p>After months of reading his interviews and books, I realized this disdain drove my first outlines. I was mad, and it consumed me. Had I continued down this path, the essay would have just been a long way of saying <em>James Patterson is an awful person; how dare he touch Crichton’s work? </em>It wasn’t until I watched two videos from some of my favorite creators that I started to chip away at this negativity.</p><p>In one of video essayist Abigail Thorn’s post-mortem livestreams, she said that she always tries to approach her topic with compassion and curiosity. Around the same time, I watched Crimson Ender’s “YouTube Negativity Death Spiral,” which details how he, like myself, had himself in a cycle of obsessively debunking one bad YouTube critic. These videos forced me to reconsider the “why” of this essay and of my writing.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhftrZ41GMo">Youtube Negativity Death Spiral</a></p><p>I concluded that I couldn’t publish a screed. That’s not what I like to write, and it wasn’t satisfying my heart or my curiosity. It made me actively feel worse. That’s why I stopped so many times: for my own sanity and to have something deeper to say than “I don’t like this and here’s why”. It would have been a poor tribute to Crichton, who doesn’t need me to fight this battle–no one does.</p><p>There are still interesting things to explore in how these two authors came together. I’ve let go of my anger, and I want to explore the coupling of Patterson and Crichton. They have such conflicting goals, personalities, and philosophies, and I think it’s valuable to explore what happens when these things collide. Plus, I don’t think I’ll truly get rid of this fixation until I put this essay into the world.</p><p>I wrote this prologue because I think it’s an important part of the story. Michael Crichton once said, “Can you ever describe a person and not be saying more about yourself?” I can’t completely remove my feelings from the “why” of this work. So, this essay might be a bit messy, a bit pointed in parts, and I will give my honest opinion on James Patterson and his work. However, I hope it translates as something born from curiosity and a love for craft, not negative feelings toward an author who I am, admittedly, not a fan.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>In early 2024, I got an email from BookBub that a new Michael Crichton book would soon be available. I am a huge Crichton fan and hadn’t heard about anything new until that moment, so it was a pleasant surprise. His posthumous works have been fine, for the most part, and my enthusiasm had waned over the years, but I was still excited.</p><p>So, I quickly clicked on the email and found that the book, <em>Eruption</em>, was co-written with James Patterson. Immediately, this seemed like an odd fit. When I told my coworkers about this collaboration, they likewise thought these two wouldn’t go together, one of them even going so far as to say, “Those are complete opposites”.</p><p>It seemed to be a common conception, one that I also held, that James Patterson didn’t really write his books, so his finishing a Crichton novel was odd. However, I hadn’t truly read any of Patterson’s books since middle school, when I was a fan of the<em> Maximum Ride</em> and <em>Daniel X</em> series. I don’t remember anything particularly egregious about these books, but the perception was still there.</p><p>Now, after much research and <em>a lot</em> of thought, I can safely say this is an odd fit. Even the initial title, <em>Eruption: The Big One</em>, seemed indicative of this. The first part is Crichton-esque as his books often have straightforward, single-word titles, but the second seems like what I call a Pattersonism, with <em>The Big One</em> emphasis existing to provoke a marketable curiosity.</p><p>It’s even curiouser when one considers <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2009/apr/06/michael-crichton-posthumous-novels">statements</a> from the Crichton estate and his publisher about how they carefully selected previous co-writers for his posthumous titles. His wife, Sherri Crichton, explained in interviews that she <a href="https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/michael-crichtons-widow-opens-up-andromeda-strain-sequel-i-cant-say-it-was-ever-a-slam-dunk-1253606/">wanted </a>people who were true fans of her husband and could honor his memory with quality writing.</p><p>“It was not an easy decision to touch one of Michael’s most iconic pieces of work. I was able to look past the potential criticism from naysayers and look at the bigger picture, which is that I don’t want Michael’s classic body of work to be forgotten.</p><blockquote>“I can’t say that [choosing the right writer] was ever a slam dunk. We were critical of what that story would be and how it would unfurl but Daniel [H. Wilson, author of <em>The Andromeda Evolution</em>] was remarkable to work with. He was truly inspired by Michael so we already had that under our belt.”</blockquote><p>With this ethos alone, James Patterson isn’t a logical choice, as he rarely mentioned Crichton before he was given the manuscript in 2021, outside of making simple logline comparisons. However, it’s in his character and philosophies where the contradictions with Crichton become stark. So, I want to explore where this disconnect occurs and how <em>Eruption</em> fared because of it.</p><h3>A Tale of Two Writers</h3><p><em>Who is Michael Crichton?</em></p><p>To begin this discussion, it’s essential to explain who these authors are as people because their personalities, philosophies, and writing are so entangled with one another. Their creative divergences are where the dissonance lies deepest.</p><p>Crichton was an intellectual’s intellectual. He enjoyed thinking deeply and thoroughly researching the topics and questions he found interesting, almost to a fault. In interviews, he was extremely hesitant to point to a specific event and claim it was the inspiration for his story because he couldn’t explain it logically or empirically.</p><p>In his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1a2-uGfssc8">mind</a>, “I don’t believe we know why we do what we do” and any attempt to explain why he felt compelled to craft a story outside “I wanted to do it” would be dishonest or rewriting history. Many people called Crichton incredibly humble, and I believe this practice stems from that humility. He very much rejected the idea of him being an enlightened artiste.</p><p>At the same time, Crichton was also very aware that he couldn’t truly separate himself from his writing. When speaking about his nonfiction book on artist Jasper Johns, he <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzoINx_2UWA">stated</a>:</p><blockquote>“When I was working on the Johns book, at a certain point, I really began to wonder whether the things that I was writing were descriptive of him or me. It’s an odd problem, it’s akin to the problem of whether or not you can write history that’s not contemporary history. Can you ever describe a person and not be saying more about yourself?”</blockquote><p>Writing seemed to be almost a spiritual experience for Crichton and something he did purely out of joy. He talked about stories as if they possessed him, <a href="https://www.bookbrowse.com/author_interviews/full/index.cfm/author_number/333/michael-crichton">claiming</a>, “I don’t usually feel as if I have a choice, or much control of what comes out. Often, I don’t want to be writing a particular book, but there I am, writing it anyway.”</p><p>He also claimed multiple times that he never wrote for any particular audience or person and often assumed no one would be interested in whatever he was writing. Again, it was simply a compulsion he couldn’t truly explain.</p><p>On top of this, he was incredibly meticulous and would sometimes take decades to research and write a book. His process was slow, consisting of him letting a story stew in his head for years, so it wasn’t unusual that <em>Eruption</em> was developed for 28 years before he passed. His wife tells stories of him not being entirely present during dinners and being absent for long periods as he figured out some aspect of a book. When Crichton did start plotting, he would write down scenes and ideas on note cards to be placed in a box. Once the box was full or his gut told him he had enough, he would then write the text.</p><p>This combination of humility and meticulousness is what made Crichton’s books great. He deeply cared about making something of quality that would convincingly whisk a reader away, even if only for a short time. One can see this care when examining Crichton’s craft. His sentences are near-poetry at times, having a delightful rhythm and sense of imagery:</p><blockquote>“People who imagined that life on earth consisted of animals moving against a green background seriously misunderstood what they were seeing. That green background was busily alive. Plants grew, moved, twisted, and turned, fighting for the sun…”</blockquote><ul><li><em>Jurassic Park</em>, Pg. 96</li></ul><p>His stories were intense, but not a continual onslaught of high-stakes moments. The thoughtful pacing allowed the reader moments to breathe, to understand scientific concepts or experience a quiet moment before being thrust back into action.</p><p>One of my favorite scenes in <em>Jurassic Park</em> is after Dr. Grant and the kids finally find shelter (via a shed) from every deadly dinosaur in the park. When Grant wakes up, he finds Lex feeding a baby triceratops–which she names Ralph–through the shelter’s bars. It’s a cute scene that takes a step away from fear and shows that the dinosaurs are more than hungry beasts.</p><p>His attention to detail also subtly weaves in advanced concepts while selling the premise of his stories. Take this passage from <em>The Andromeda Strain</em>:</p><blockquote>“This was a regulation of the recovery technique, as outlined in the Systems Rules Manual of Project Scoop. The SRM was a gray paperback that sat at one corner of Comroe’s desk, where he could refer to it easily. Comroe knew that conversation between van and base was taped, and later became part of the permanent file, but he never understood any good reason for this. In fact, it had always seemed to him a straightforward proposition; the van went out, got the capsule, and came back.”</blockquote><ul><li><em>The Andromeda Strain</em>, Pg. 8</li></ul><p>On the surface, this is exposition to explain the rules of an operation and Comroe’s disdain, but it also cleverly weaves in how this part of the story was recorded. <em>The Andromeda Strain</em> is written like it’s a report gathered from multiple sources, and this paragraph subtly demonstrates that, while making the reader think the recording is more important because it focuses on this character’s perspective about it.</p><p>Michael Crichton was a masterful writer because of what he valued. This becomes an issue for <em>Eruption</em> because James Patterson has completely opposing values.</p><p><em>Who is James Patterson?</em></p><p>While Crichton embodies intellectualism, Patterson does the same for anti-intellectualism. That word has a lot of negative connotations, but I use it as an observation of practice, not an insult. I don’t believe Patterson is unintelligent, merely that his words and actions promote a certain philosophy.</p><p>Anti-intellectualism, as argued by Richard Hofstader, comes in three flavors that can be separate or a delightful Neapolitan:</p><ol><li>Anti-rationalism, rejecting critical thought</li><li>Unreflective instrumentalism, preference for short-term payoffs regardless of later consequences</li><li>Anti-elitism, distrusting those who seem to have superior knowledge</li></ol><p>Patterson’s words and beliefs over the decades have touched upon all of these and it’s because he values being a brand more than a writer. He wants to be known more for himself than his writing and this is the purpose of a brand. As explained in multiple books by Naomi Klein, good brands are unchanging and consistent, never off message or pathos:</p><blockquote>“Good brands are immune to fundamental transformation.”</blockquote><ul><li><em>Doppleganger</em>, Naomi Klein</li></ul><p>Patterson’s brand rests on a foundation of anti-intellectualism, sprinkling rejection of critical thought, reflection, and supposed publishing elites into everything he claims to believe. This dedication to the brand makes parsing his interviews and memoir frustrating because there is little expansion or introspection on his stock answers, even with years separating them. It’s hard to discern what Patterson truly believes and what he’s saying to maintain an image, but for the purposes of this essay, his words will be taken at face value.</p><p>Early in Patterson’s career, he worked at an advertising agency. His boss there, Burt Manning, taught Patterson that “[the] audience [has] absolutely no interest in what you had to say” when writing about beer or shaving cream. While this makes sense for copywriting, it’s not necessarily true for fiction or other life matters, but Patterson adopted this as a motto for himself and others. In general, he rejects most standards with little critical thought, something displayed most in how he markets his books.</p><blockquote>“My tendency in any business — publishing, advertising, Hollywood — is to seriously question the rules. The rules in publishing were: You don’t do TV ads, you don’t cross genres, you don’t put out two books in a year. And I said, “I’m not sure that’s right.”</blockquote><ul><li>From an interview with the <a href="https://www.lapl.org/collections-resources/blogs/lapl/interview-author-james-patterson">Los Angeles Public Library</a></li></ul><p>While questioning accepted practices and norms isn’t a bad thing, Patterson does little to demonstrate that he thinks deeply, instead opting for a swift dismissal. Phrases like “I don’t think that’s true” are frequent in his interviews, but without expanding on why he believes it. His thought processes seem more directed by his anti-elitist tendencies (to be discussed more later) than a careful exploration of industry practice.</p><p>In addition, Patterson values being the best and having quick payoffs (for both, in life and fiction). This possibly stems from his parents’ high expectations of him in school. They were quite critical, and even a slight dip in his grades would earn a comment. Because of this, he learned “that my folks only cared about me as long as I was #1 in my class,” and held onto this well into middle age. This is also reflected in his writing. Patterson finds little value in something if it doesn’t maintain the reader’s attention, <a href="https://www.lapl.org/collections-resources/blogs/lapl/interview-author-james-patterson">explaining</a> that an idea shouldn’t be in a book unless “it heightens the drama, pulls at your heart, or turns your expectations upside down[…].”</p><p>Plot is king to Patterson; not sentence structures (which Patterson admits to being “bad at”), characters, quiet scenes, character reflection or unique metaphors. To Patterson, nothing matters as much as a solid, fast-paced plot. In fact, Patterson didn’t enjoy writing until he stopped worrying about his sentences and even <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/authorinterviews/7052581/James-Patterson-interview.html">claims</a>, “A lot of times, you know, good sentences get in the way of a good story.”</p><p>Extending from this, Patterson also realized that if he wrote a solid outline and didn’t worry too much about the sentences, essentially, he had a finished book. It’s through this method, and a gaggle of co-writers, that Patterson can push out books so quickly. By removing the critical engagement and play with syntax or meaningful metaphors, Patterson has found a way to make engaging, fast-selling works. In my opinion, it’s the biggest reason that he has become the highest-selling author of all time. However, it’s the third flavor of anti-intellectualism, anti-elitism, where Patterson focuses his rhetoric most. Truly, it’s the scoop of ice cream in his anti-intellectualism sundae.</p><p>He claims to have been a gifted student with a “goofy high IQ”, a competitive streak stemming from unsatisfied parents, and to be a reformed literary snob. He previously pursued a PhD in Literature but dropped out because he thought it would kill his love of reading. His life was changed when he read the novel <em>Mrs. Bridge</em> because of its simple, efficient style of writing. It was here he realized that books didn’t need to be flowery and dense to be enjoyable.</p><p>Patterson also seems to hold onto perceived slights, using them as fuel to motivate himself. One of the stories in his memoir concerns a friend and him not being selected for an elite Little League baseball team despite both being gifted players. This story is told from an older Patterson’s point of view (the typical “Voice of Experience” found in memoir writing), yet lacks any deeper commentary. When paired with the other stories of alleged rejections and then proving the rejectors wrong, a pattern of mythmaking emerges.</p><p>All of this amounts to what he calls his “colloquial” writing style. Patterson writes like he’s telling it to a friend: the plot might meander and not every sentence is the most beautiful ever. On its surface, there isn’t any problem with this type of writing, but it’s how he frames this style that leads me to argue he is anti-intellectual.</p><blockquote>“My writing style is colloquial, which is the way we talk to one another, right? Some might disagree, some might vehemently disagree, but I think colloquial storytelling is a valid form of expression. If you wrote down your favorite story to tell, there might not be any great sentences, but it can still be outstanding.”</blockquote><ul><li>From <em>James Patterson by James Patterson</em></li></ul><p>Notice how much of these three sentences is dedicated to justifying his colloquial style against a vague, antagonistic detractor. Through the vocabulary and structure of this passage, he’s priming his readers to think that there is some writing elite which he is fighting against. This is why Patterson focuses more on defending his style than explaining it.</p><p>Another example of this is in 2016 when Patterson described the launch of his Book Shots initiative. These were essentially novellas given an exciting title and targeted toward people who wanted to read but didn’t have the time. In a CBS <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-91hoy6S_s">interview</a>, he describes it as a “reading revolution” because books became something that were “crushing down” people due to their length. While not as explicit as the previous example, this rhetoric still broadly focuses on a supposedly out-of-touch publishing industry that makes its books too long. Patterson’s Book Shots promised not to be demanding, but “all thriller, no filler”.</p><p><em>Eruption</em> has two opposing forces behind its creation. James Patterson favors quickness in his process and books, while Crichton appreciated quiet contemplation and wrote at a glacial pace. Patterson creates mythology to codify his writing style, and Crichton constantly thought about his writing and embraced that he might never understand his compulsion.</p><p>One is a good brand, while the other is a good writer. Their goals are artistically and philosophically at odds. So, what happens when a rock and a hard place collide to write a book…?</p><h3>Eruption</h3><p>Coincidentally, I watched a playthrough of <em>Alan Wake II </em>while I read <em>Eruption,</em> and I couldn’t help but see similarities. For the unfamiliar, the world of <em>Alan Wake</em> follows a crime fiction author of the same name, who goes to a Pacific coast town named Bright Falls–home to an entity that feeds off artists called The Dark Presence. Through the Presence and its home, the Dark Place, Alan can rewrite reality with his words, but it comes at a price. In the second game, the world is once again being rewritten, but this time, The Dark Presence takes the form of Alan’s alleged doppelganger, Scratch.</p><p>Scratch writes a book titled <em>Return</em>, a horror story that foretells his arrival and flooding the world in nightmares. To stop Scratch, Alan takes a pen, crosses out portions of the manuscript, and rewrites it, and that’s where the trouble begins.</p><p>What results in <em>Alan Wake II</em> is that the game’s main protagonist, FBI agent Saga Anderson, exists in Bright Falls as two different people. The residents remember her past differently than she does; some claim that her daughter, Logan, drowned years ago, yet Saga knows she’s still alive. <em>Alan Wake</em> is a compelling game because of this dissonance. It’s intentionally hard to know what is true about the setting, characters, or autonomy of anybody.</p><p><em>Eruption</em> is a work made by two opposing forces like <em>Return</em>. There’s a push and pull that makes the events feel anxious and unstable. It has the same dissonance but, unfortunately, unlike <em>Alan Wake</em>, it is not nearly as compelling.</p><p><em>Eruption</em> is a novel that can’t decide its identity. It dances between a methodical, science-inspired thriller and a fast-paced action romp where one man tackles the forces of nature. Many typical Crichton drapings are there–a commentary on the hubris of man over nature, the situation escalating despite the protagonist’s best-laid plans–but there are also threads of Patterson’s style unharmoniously stitched throughout. Sometimes certain things are emphasized, and other times they are tossed aside to get to the next plot point. It leaves the reader unsure of what’s important and what can be ignored. This lack of cohesion can be seen best when considering the book’s main character, Dr. John “Mac” MacGregor.</p><p>The reader is first introduced to Mac giving surf lessons to a group of native Hawaiian youth. He is an accomplished surfer, but due to age, he had to trade in the sport for teaching it. One of his students, Lono, also happens to intern at the Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, so he has a fondness for the boy. This introduction gives the impression that Mac is patient, admired, and appreciates these little moments, but is also always aware of the looming threats that tower above the Big Island. In an hour, Mac is to give a press conference on the impending eruption of Mauna Loa, the islands’ largest active volcano, but before that he gets a phone call with troubling data from his colleague, Jenny, confirming what they already suspected: the largest eruption in history is days away. It’s in this press conference and the events following that the book’s identity crisis first appears.</p><p>During the press conference, Mac introduces himself:</p><blockquote>“Good afternoon. I’m John Macgregor, scientist in charge of the Hawaiian Volcano Observatory.”</blockquote><p>This dialogue immediately struck me as odd. Wouldn’t Mac say his field instead of just “scientist”? Even something like “lead scientist” would feel more appropriate than the vague “scientist in charge”. After a decent opener where Mac’s character is shown through an activity, this part seemed like a way to get from point A to point B. This shifting focus is present throughout <em>Eruption</em>. Sometimes, certain things feel important, and the writing takes its time to flesh out a concept or scene, but other times it gets breezed through. The reader doesn’t learn that Mac is a volcanologist until page 74, and then on page 83, Mac says he is a “geologist,” without explaining that volcanology falls under the umbrella of geology. Most readers will likely connect the dots, but it’s strange to not have this clearly written so that there is no confusion.</p><p>A more significant example is Mac’s general personality. Despite being established as a calm, considerate nature boy, Mac is also affectionately described by one of the characters as a “cowboy”. After the press conference, a private helicopter known to the characters flies a camera crew dangerously close to one of the lava-filled calderas, causing the craft to crash inside. Mac gets his own helicopter and rappels down to save the pilot and crew.</p><p>This section had me scratching my head because there was nothing to suggest that a volcanologist would have any experience doing a rescue mission inside a volcano. Mac wasn’t shown to be a former military member, an EMT, or anything that might have made this scene plausible. He’s simply an action hero in this moment because he’s the protagonist, and that’s what a protagonist does, right? This becomes a pattern as Mac constantly leaps between moments of slow contemplation and impulsive decision-making.</p><p>Even more stunning is that in the back half of the book, the writing seems to insist Mac isn’t the already established cowboy and that cowboys are actually a bad thing. A billionaire philanthropist character named J.P. Brett shows up and is framed as a sort of foil to Mac. Brett is the type of person to throw money at a problem, get quick results, and ask questions later. He says things like “Scientists take chances as only a last resort” and “chaos is my speciality” while accusing Mac of combating the impending eruption too slowly. After Brett’s actions get a cameraman killed (via falling out of a helicopter into lava), an Army General named Mark Rivers states, “You’re all a bunch of cowboys. I hate fucking cowboys.”</p><p>So, is Mac’s cowboyishness a good thing or a bad thing?</p><p>Mac’s characterization is indicative of <em>Eruption</em> as a whole. The plot rarely gets the time to build drama or allow the audience to be absorbed in the setting and characters, except for brief glimpses. In those moments, I found my hope refreshed a bit that this book would at least have a satisfying conclusion. A volcanic eruption potentially destroying a secret military base full of a deadly disease and spreading it worldwide via volcanic emissions is an exciting concept, so the conclusion should be equally enthralling. Sadly, this is not the case, and the ending made the whole experience feel like a Sisyphean exercise.</p><p>For about 50 pages of the ending, there is a tedious, nonstop string of scenes where people die from either the lava or the deadly disease that breached containment. The initial plan to redirect the lava doesn’t work, but Mac makes a last-ditch effort to drop bombs from a plane and save the day. The vog (volcanic fog that has glass particles in it) breaks the plane’s electronics and engines, so, with no options left, Mac decides that he and the fighter pilot he’s accompanying must crash their plane into the volcano. They hope this will create an explosion to relieve the lava pressure, stop its flow, and save whoever is left. Just before the fateful moment, Mac notices that the problem has fixed itself. The built-up, cooled lava of Mauna Kea, the neighboring volcano, acts as a natural wall and diverts the flow away from town.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>I struggled to manifest a thesis for this essay because I don’t know if there’s really any greater meaning to <em>Eruption</em>’s existence. But, there’s a line on page 271 that my thoughts have ebbed and flowed around since I finished the book:</p><blockquote>“This time both man and nature would lose…”</blockquote><p>It sticks in my mind because I think about the potential this story had. Many of Crichton’s stories have this resolve that man can never truly conquer nature. The scientists of <em>Jurassic Park</em> were foolish to bring back the dinosaurs, and the characters in <em>Prey</em> realize they’ve unleashed a new form of intelligence or life onto humanity. The characters don’t truly solve the problem they’ve created, but survive it, and through the plot and dialogue, a discussion is had on the core themes and philosophies underneath. With <em>Eruption</em>, it almost seems that Crichton wanted to write a story where man and nature are both in peril and have to work together to save both.</p><p>Perhaps, that’s why he worked on this book for <a href="https://www.jamespatterson.com/landing-page/eruption-timeline/">nearly 30 years</a>, and according to his wife, Sherri Crichton, “Michael rarely spoke of his ideas or projects, not even to his family or closest friends; however, he frequently spoke of his volcano project, and when we were traveling through Italy, we made a special excursion to Pompeii so that he could further research the story he set in Hawai’i.” <em>Eruption</em>, originally titled <em>The Black Zone</em>, was going to be a slight departure from his usual tale, and he wanted to get it right. I imagine an ending where the lava is redirected by pure chance is not a letdown, but the end of a long conversation about man and nature nurturing each other.</p><p>There was even potential for this Patterson/Crichton sandwich to be satisfying. While Crichton was the master of thoughtful plots, his characters always felt like cogs in a machine. They were never boring, but always had a specific purpose to move the plot forward. It’s largely why I think the film adaptations of <em>Jurassic Park</em> and <em>Twister</em> are superior to their written counterparts. The characters are people and go on emotional journeys as well as experience terrifying events.</p><p>In multiple interviews, he’s claimed he’s not terribly <a href="https://themillions.com/2013/03/jasper-johns-as-michael-crichton-knew-him.html">interested</a> in characters or human motivation, but this also sometimes seemed like an ascetic insistence required by his core philosophies. James Patterson can make interesting characters, and while I have issues with his <em>Alex Cross</em> novels, I can’t say the titular character is boring. Alex Cross is incredibly interesting, and I enjoyed reading <em>Along Came a Spider</em> as research for this essay, despite its flaws. In theory, Patterson could have strengthened a weakness of Crichton, but he didn’t.</p><p>In some ways, the plot of <em>Eruption</em> is strangely prophetic. A meticulous scientist (Crichton) collides with a billionaire loose cannon (Patterson), and what results is that nothing really matters in the end. Maybe that’s the metaphor of <em>Eruption</em>. Like the volcano Mauna Loa, the book just exists, and there’s not much more to say beyond that. Like Mac, my best-laid plan was also moot. I researched, wrote, revised, abandoned, readopted, and rewrote this for years, and what’s left is this essay and the journey it took to finish it. Hopefully, my conclusion and execution are satisfying.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8541751e82b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Ten Best Graphic Novels I Read In 2024]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/the-ten-best-graphic-novels-i-read-in-2024-77d77f5f25dd?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77d77f5f25dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comics-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graphic-novels]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[manga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[best-of]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Dec 2024 18:02:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-11T18:02:16.639Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What books made the cut this year?</p><figure><img alt="The book covers for Anais Nin: A Sea of Lies, These Savage Shores, 20th Century Men, Let Her Be Evil, When I Arrived at the Castle, Prokaryote Season, Mister Miracle, Paradise Kiss, Ambitious Failures &amp; Lavender Clouds is a collage style graphic." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*fO3DhPbdcml0mV0KWFEjvA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So… I’m not sure if I’m turning into more of a superhero fan or if I just happened to read good superhero graphic novels this year. There were way more considered than in previous years and three total (including the honorable mentions) made the cut, tying my list for 2022.</p><p>Other than catching a sudden case of cape-itis, the rest of these books seem to follow a similar theme: questioning one’s place in the world. Most of these comics focus on deeply emotional and reflective scenarios, some with characters that operate in grey areas. These characters’ questioning comes from all over as well; from places personal, relational, spiritual, and systemic.</p><p>It’s funny what I stumble on when reflecting on the stories that spoke to me this year. I feel like I say this annually, but I never intend for there to be themes when I pick my ten best graphic novels each year. It’s mostly a vibes-based decision, but reveals a lot about my mindset for this year. Beyond recent events that have me questioning a lot of things about the country I reside, I think I’m in a spot in my creative career where it’s time to take the next steps. I’ve been taking a broad approach to writing and rarely say no to opportunities, but I have been pondering where I want to go and what kind of writer/creator I want to be.</p><p>God, I feel like a recipe blogger bearing my soul (allegedly) for ad revenue. Let’s just get to the graphic novels.</p><h3>Anais Nin: A Sea of Lies by Leone Bischoff</h3><figure><img alt="Anais Nin: A Sea of Lies Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*97I9BG2chqlzCg_JDjVVXg.jpeg" /></figure><p>How many books have made you question your creativity?</p><p>This graphic retelling of erotic writer Anais Nin’s history explores what it means to create and have a muse as a woman as well as how those around a creative inform their creations. The titular character feels like every man in her life wants some piece of her writing, offering suggestions or flatly telling her she should be doing it as they do. But, she doesn’t want to write like a man, she wants to write like a woman, whatever that means. That questions shook me. So much of what is considered “good writing” is based on male experience, so as a nonbinary person, I found myself asking “how do I write as a nonbinary person?”</p><p>I still don’t have a concrete answer, but it’s something I never would have considered with Leonie Bischoff’s incredible story.</p><p>Her art is what truly makes this book. It’s mainly colored pencil art with occasional water colors and immediately shoves the reader into the emotional stakes of each scene. It’s far from photorealistic and instead focuses on the tone and message of each moment. Some pages are downright trippy, but incredibly effective and evocative. I’m a sucker for colored pencils (which is why Julia Delporte’s new book made the honorable mentions below). There’s a lightness to them but the ability to evolve beyond typical black-line art creates rich opportunities for emotional content.</p><h3>These Savage Shores by Ram V, Sumit Kumar, Vittorio Astone &amp; Aditya Bidikar</h3><figure><img alt="These Savage Shores Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*vbPAjJCdbzztHptaMkteGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This became one of my favorite horror books. It’s terrifying, heartbreaking, and eye-opening; a horror that makes one question their history and if things have really changed that much. There’s so much I could talk about with <em>These Savage Shores</em>, so much that I’m having trouble writing this portion succinctly. It’s about the stories people tell themselves to justify their actions, how marginalized people are forced into becoming the horrors of their oppressors, and the double standards of monstrosity. At the same time, it’s about the cosmic consequences that come from conceding to colonial powers.</p><p>Everything about this book is superb. The writing is tender at times and operatic at other moments. The art isn’t afraid to take several moments to establish a scene and set up the quiet before every storm. The creative team forced themselves to never stray from the confines of 3 x 3 grid paneling. Working together, these elements pace the story incredibly steadily and ensure the reader doesn’t miss a single word or detail.</p><p>This is the type of book that changes the perceptive reader. It’s not my place to speak on the bigotry experienced by India past or present, but I think I understand it a little better because of this story.</p><h3>20th Century Men by Deniz Camp, Stipan Morian &amp; Aditya Bidikar</h3><figure><img alt="20th Century Men Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*Xi7KTVYx0Gk9W0uuxqwyUQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In my notes on this book, I only had one quote saved:</p><p>“Tragic and absurd”.</p><p><em>20th Century Men</em> is about a lot of things, but these two words sum up what struck me most about it. The book is dense in narrative and art, but that is done intentionally.</p><p>Even summarizing this graphic novel is difficult. It’s essentially a speculative history where presidents have superpowers, the Soviet Union still exists and has super soldiers and the Middle East has been chosen as the stomping ground for World War III, but that still seems too simple to explain what happens. It lays bare the current state of the world and, in particular, the United States’ violent need to conquer in a way that only over-the-top pulpy comics can. The creative team doesn’t hold back their disgust, anger, or sadness in the slightest.</p><p>I don’t know if even 10 months removed from reading that I’ve fully digested everything in <em>20th Century Men</em>. It’s powerful like Art Spiegelman’s <em>Maus</em> and I know I’ll be returning to this book many times.</p><h3>Let Her Be Evil edited by Cassandra Jones</h3><figure><img alt="Let Her Be Evil Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*w_rspLY0KR7D1ZHghC5C9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Authors these days have had difficulty writing women. It’s a meme at this point where a “strong woman” is only physically strong or written as a man with long hair (boss babe alert), ignoring the experiences, nuances, and culture that inform a woman’s existence in modern society. I think these attempts come from a good place but sometimes fall flat. This has been particularly bad for woman villains who become the victims of overcorrection.</p><p>Attempts to make them nuanced have bloated the number of woman villains with tragic backstories and sympathetic motivations. While intentions may be pure, this plays into narratives of women always being victims and brushes against a failing Bechdel test. <em>Let Her Be Evil </em>does exactly what its title promises, presenting characters who do dirty deeds for any motivation that’s not tragic.</p><h3>When I Arrived at the Castle by E.M. Carroll</h3><figure><img alt="When I Arrived at the Castle Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*MITVh15m3tmFFsYRLXFDtw.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is one of the smoothest reads I’ve ever experienced. Instead of using typical gutters, Carroll lets everything flow into each other which makes the narration feel sing-songy which makes sense given the book’s themes on the power of stories. There’s so much I’d love to dig into with this graphic novel, but I fear I can’t without spoiling the twists, but trust me they are delightful.</p><p>Carroll’s minimalist style forces the reader to be present and let the words drift around their consciousness. Although only black, grey, white, and red are used, no page is boring and Carroll’s sense of composition and color is stellar. Plus, this is one of the few horror books I’ve read that has a few legitimate jump scares, something hard to accomplish in comics.</p><h3>Prokaryote Season by Leo Fox</h3><figure><img alt="Prokaryote Season Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*K6uelFrWnVQIqsU3rKCC7g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dear God is this book dark, but I also loved the crap out of it. It’s part coming-of-age story, part deconstruction of romance and friendship, and part trippy, angst-filled nonsense (the good kind). If one has ever felt that life was too complicated and it would be nice to just float in space with zero responsibilities, zero pesky feelings (like a single-celled organism), this book might be incredibly relatable.</p><p>Fox draws in a style reminiscent of the underground comix era and at times it’s not clear if something is meant to be read as a panel within the narrative, or flourishes to thrust the reader into these characters’ inner worlds. Considering the story revolves around the uncertainty of being in love, in friendship, or in horniness with one’s best friend, it feels completely appropriate. The reader will experience these swirling, confusing emotions with the characters. I’ve proudly stated I’m a Leo Fox stan now and this book is largely the reason why.</p><h3>Mister Miracle by Jack Kirby, Mike Royer &amp; Vince Colletta</h3><figure><img alt="Mister Miracle Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*HphqbD-BFeT7AYBjYCyL1Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ll be blunt here. I don’t like reading older Marvel and DC books. I find the overly expository writing hard to read and I like comics that leave room for the art to breathe (which a lot of older capes books do not). I can appreciate their place in comics history and I try to engage so I’m not ignorant of where some important techniques and tropes originated, but they’re not for me.</p><p>I decided to give Jack Kirby’s <em>Fourth World</em> books a try after they were discussed in a recent Thought Slime video essay. Like other older superhero books, I was prepared to slowly read through, learn what I wanted, and then shelve it, even if this was Kirby’s magnum opus. Color me shocked when I found myself loving these books, but I especially connected with Mister Miracle.</p><p>It’s rare for a superhero’s powers/gimmick to reflect his flaws. Superman’s powers represent the best person among us, Batman’s represents overcoming his fear and Captain America’s powers are a metaphor for his idealism. Mister Miracle’s abilities as an escape artist are intertwined with his story and his avoidance of conflict. He’s running from his past as a former soldier of Apokolips, from his emotions with Big Barda, and from his part in helping the New Gods.</p><p>Kirby does incredible work with this story, and I found myself relating to Mister Miracle more than most superheroes. All Mister Miracle desires is freedom from oppressive forces, but he learns the difference between freedom and escape.</p><h3>Paradise Kiss by Ai Yazawa</h3><figure><img alt="Paradise Kiss Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*AF2__Y3zTWgJuew_v6oaNw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I picked up this book when I was sampling some older romance comics to see where the genre had been and if I could draw any inspiration for future comics. I jumped into <em>Paradise Kiss</em> mostly blind and was not prepared for how much I loved this story. It is a romance, but it doesn’t hit the typical romance beats and that made it a true joy to read.</p><p>Unlike most romances where I know the two leads will be together by the end (which isn’t a criticism, this is why romance books are amazing comfort reads), this one left me guessing the entire time. I won’t spoil the ending, but I will say it ends in a happily ever after that readers won’t expect. There a some romance readers who will say that because of this book’s subversive ending, it’s not a romance, but I wholeheartedly disagree.</p><p>I think the heart of this story is when two people become inspired by each other, but it questions if that is the same as loving each other. Yukari is a failing student who meets an edgy group of fashion students headed by Joji (who prefers George) and is immediately smitten by him. Reciprocally, George sees Yukari as the perfect model for his upcoming school fashion show. The two make each other better people, but there’s also a lot of tension between them. This tension borders on negligence at times. The “will they/won’t they” of these two is intense, but that’s what makes their relationship incredibly intriguing and it leaves a lot to contemplate.</p><p>It’s not the fluffiest romance in the world, but it is a book that will linger in the reader’s mind.</p><h3>Ambitious Failures by Richard Fairgray</h3><figure><img alt="Ambitious Failures Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*Ffe3QQfiXEDxeD6kRmxjQg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ll flatly say it. If you’re not reading Richard’s books, you’re missing out on the best of indie comics. I was so eager to get <em>Ambitious Failures</em> that I was the second person to back its Kickstarter campaign. I love works that gut the creator and raze their demons regarding art, comics, and creativity. I feel confident saying that this book should be shelved among the likes of <em>Maus</em>, <em>Fun Home</em>, and <em>Ducks</em>, it’s that good.</p><p>For the uninitiated, Richard has a gift for weaving emotional narratives into the visuals of his work. He employs unorthodox layouts, lettering, and color schemes that perfectly match the narrative’s tone at any given time. In addition, his sense of time reminds me a lot of Will Eisner’s; thoughtfully considering how the page influences the reader’s speed of digestion, the dialogue, the art, everything. This tale about the anxious kiss of time grazing down one’s neck demanded this sort of attention to detail which makes the fact that the book was created in a short amount of time even more impressive. Again, this is a book I will revisit often.</p><h3>Lavender Clouds by Bex Ollerton</h3><figure><img alt="Lavender Clouds Cover" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*toJfQmox_xgn0WAsKZD3kg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I appreciate <em>Lavender Clouds</em> for its honesty and simplicity. The benefit of a comic strip format is that there is no room for extra baggage. The emotions are going to be raw and present. I think this is the type of media we need to explain mental health to the masses. Nuance and depth are great (and I’m not saying this book doesn’t have depth), but sometimes a bite-sized piece that flatly states “this shit hurts” is needed.</p><p>However, it’s not all doom and gloom in Ollerton’s work. There are also plenty of strips that highlight hope and celebrate the victories of accomplishing things even in the face of crippling negativity. I feel that too many characters with mental illness are shown as victims or quirky raccoons in human skin suits, which is needed, but the world also needs examples of people successfully coping and showing that thriving doesn’t have to follow a specific script. This book gives a little bit of both with a gorgeous color palette and a relate protagonist.</p><h3>Honorable Mentions</h3><p><em>Breaking Pointe</em> by S.T. Gillard, Renan Balmonte, Nicolas Faluotico &amp; Michael Eastop</p><p><em>Meanwhile… A Comics Shop Anthology</em> edited by Kevin Sharp &amp; Ryan Higgins</p><p><em>Earthdivers</em> by Stephen Graham Jones, Davide Gianfelice, Joana Lafuente &amp; Steve Wands</p><p><em>All-Star Superman</em> by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely, Jamie Grant, Phil Balsman &amp; Travis Lanham</p><p><em>Angela: Asgard’s Assassin</em> by Kieran Gillen, Marguerite Bennet, Stephanie Hans, Phil Jimenez, Tom Palmer, Le Beau Underwood, Scott Hanna, Robin Fajardo Jr. &amp; VC’s Clayton Cowles</p><p><em>Portrait of a Body</em> by Julia Delporte</p><p><em>Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End</em> by Kanehito Yamada &amp; Tsukasa Abe</p><p><em>I Kill Giants </em>by Joe Kelly &amp; JM Ken Nimura</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77d77f5f25dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Hazbin Hotel Hilariously Subverts The Secret Weapon Trope]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/how-hazbin-hotel-hilariously-subverts-the-secret-weapon-trope-5fa326709286?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5fa326709286</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hazbin-hotel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tropes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[secret-weapons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 May 2024 16:03:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-22T16:03:04.856Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hazbin Hotel is Great, but This Bit of Writing Shows Exactly Why</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/0*ZnX_A2q1bCtf2eBx" /></figure><p>Like many, I’m hooked on A24’s hell-larious (you’re welcome) animated show <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>. It’s got an amazing cast of loveable queer misfits (Vaggie is my favorite), incredibly well-written songs, and a story full of found family feel-good moments. Since <em>Owl House</em> was forced to abruptly end in 2023, there’s been a big, gay, fantasy-shaped hole in my heart that needed to be filled and this show delivered.</p><p>There are so many things I could dive into with this show; the clever wordplay of the lyrics, the interconnected stories of the characters, and the art design all deserve their own essays, but I want to hone in on something specific that probably went unnoticed and shows just how the writing is <em>so</em> good.</p><p>In true high fantasy fashion, <em>Hazbin Hotel</em> ended in an epic battle that largely hinged on that beloved trope: the secret weapon. But the show didn’t follow the usual format.</p><p>Whether because of the comedic nature of the writing, the limitations of short, animated episodes, or just great writing, the show, more specifically the final two installments, flipped this trope on its head in such a satisfying way.</p><h3>The Journey to the Secret Weapon</h3><p>This idea is so prevalent in fantasy, that it’s nearly cliche. The chosen hero thinks defeating the big bad guy is hopeless until they learn there might be one way to win; something that’s been forgotten or hidden.</p><p>First, the hero usually goes on a long and winding journey to find more information on this secret weapon. Perhaps they tromp through an abandoned town with ancient ruins that contain a legend leading them to the next clue, or they must track down a wise sage who is the last living being to know the location of an enchanted sword.</p><p>But of course, finding the thing is never easy and the hero has to traverse treacherous terrain, solve some riddles, or defeat an evil being to get it. Along the way, the hero grows and gains skills to beat the big bad guy.</p><p>As a final bit of twist, the big bad guy knew about the secret weapon all along, and while they’re a bit surprised, they aren’t unprepared. Through the skills they’ve gained, a bit of cunning, and maybe the power of love/friendship, the hero emerges victorious.</p><p>To simplify this, these motifs can be broken into three steps:</p><ol><li>Uncover the secret</li><li>Find the weapon</li><li>Beat the bad guy despite the weapon</li></ol><p><em>Hazbin Hotel</em> follows this general skeleton, but because of its raunchy, sarcastic nature, it pokes fun at this journey, sometimes throwing these steps off a cliff, but in other ways subverting them in stunning fashion.</p><h3>Uncovering the (Not so) Secret</h3><p><em>Hazbin Hotel</em> completely forgoes the adventure to find information that leads to the weapon. In fact, the show implies that it was an open secret all along.</p><p>For context, the show is set in a version of Hell where the angels of Heaven perform a yearly extermination of these sinners, and other demonic residents to balance Hell’s skyrocketing population. It’s a world where no one helps one another and is constantly looking to exploit their fellow damned, except for Charlie, the daughter of Lucifer, who opens the Hazbin Hotel as a means to redeem souls who desire it.</p><p>The angels can kill at will because they are invincible. No one in Hell has found a way to harm them and fight back. At least, that’s what everyone thought until the events of episode 7, “Hello Rosie!”.</p><p>Because Charlie’s efforts seem to make things worse and the angels refuse to believe that anyone in Hell can become good, she decides fighting back is the only option left. But, how can they do it when no one has hurt an angel?</p><p>At this point in the story, the audience learns that someone has killed an angel and only Alastor, the radio demon who runs the hotel with Charlie, knows who and exchanges the information for a future favor.</p><p>Except, that’s not quite true either. The Egg Bois, minions of the hotel’s slithery resident Sir Pentious, apparently knew this secret also, but because they often say “insane shit”, they were disregarded. So, the knowledge was not hard to find and the story suggests that many demons may have known.</p><p>One might ask “but, if everyone knew about it, then why didn’t Charlie know?”</p><p>It’s established multiple times that those in Hell are selfish and only care if they get a soul or some other bit of compensation for their knowledge. Alastor, in particular, rarely helps unless it benefits him, or, at the very least, allows him to avoid some annoyance like having to use video equipment (because he’s the radio demon, why would you dare insult him like that?).</p><p>This is also reinforced later in this episode when Charlie tries to motivate Cannibal Town to be her army against Heaven. While she’s promoting the travel opportunities and the good they will do, these demons only join the fray when Alastor mentions they can eat as much angel as they’d like.</p><p>This subversion of the secret weapon trope’s first step is hilarious and well-executed because of this fantastic worldbuilding. There is no trek-based or forced character growth because the obstacle to Charlie and the hotel isn’t personal, it’s because Hell is full of assholes. That these episodes are about 24 minutes long likely contributed to this decision, but because this part is written so well, it feels intentional.</p><h3>Finding the Weapon (the Characters had the Whole Time)</h3><p><em>Hazbin Hotel</em>’’s subversion of this step focuses less on humor and more on creative storytelling. Though it is a bit funny in the grand scheme of things, it’s more about the journey of Vaggie, Charlie’s spear-wielding girlfriend who, in a previous episode, had been outed as a disgraced angel.</p><p>Vaggie is a bit of a mama bear. She’s grumpy and places the protection of everyone else over herself. The revelation that she is an angel adds another dimension to this, for now, it’s clear that her protective instincts come from a deep sense of shame. She has to take care of these demons to make up for taking part in past exterminations.</p><p>Her secret leaves Charlie feeling betrayed and in a last effort to save their relationship, she asks Vaggie to talk to Carmilla, one of the overlords of Hell who has allegedly slain an angel. In a typical fantasy story, this part would entail some extreme test on the hero, usually a task or monster that symbolizes some obstacle that the hero must overcome to grow.</p><p>But Carmilla isn’t a monster and she explains fairly quickly that Vaggie has had the secret weapon all along. The ex-angel’s spear is made of angelic steel, the only thing that can harm Heaven’s exterminators. No one has made this connection until Carmilla because no one else has had the gumption (or desperation) to try and fight an angel mid-extermination.</p><p>So, with the weapon already revealed and gained, Vaggie has to overcome a different test: her own fear and shame.</p><p>The song featured in this part, “Out for Love,” explains this test well:</p><p><em>I know you’re thirstin’ for vengeance, Vaggie</em></p><p><em>You’re out for blood</em></p><p><em>But you’ll only stand a chance if you’re out for love</em></p><p>Vaggie’s monster is her hate for the angels and her lack of concern for her wellbeing. Through the magic of musical theater, Carmilla leads Vaggie through a journey of self-discovery (and dance fighting) without the usual heroic feats.</p><p>In a way, Carmilla combines aspects of the first and second steps. She is the wise sage who delivers information on the secret weapon, while also serving as the medium through which Vaggie undergoes an internal heroic tribulation.</p><p>It’s one of my favorite moments in the show because of its creative, emotional storytelling. Vaggie doesn’t slay her demons, but learns to dance with them and becomes who she needs to be to protect Charlie and herself.</p><h3>Beating the Bad Guy Despite the Weapon Because They’re Just the Worst</h3><p>As previously mentioned, the bad guy often knows about their secret weapon because why would they let a weakness go unnoticed? In some stories, this weapon is only a temporary advantage and the hero must swiftly rely on their talents and learned skills. And, of course, this happens, for they wouldn’t be a great bad guy if they weren’t cunning and ready for the worst…</p><p>…which is why <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>’s subversion of this moment is one of the funniest things in the show.</p><p>The show’s main antagonists, the angels, especially their leader Adam (the one from the Bible), are established in the story as incredibly egotistical and sadistic. They see the residents of Hell as less than and not worthy of any sort of humanity.</p><p>Adam, in particular, seems to delight in killing them since no one can, allegedly, fight back. He gleefully sings in the song “Hell is Forever” that “extermination is entertainment”.</p><p>In addition, they are hypocritical. They claim that none of Charlie’s hotel patrons are redeemable, but they can’t point to any specific reason why instead making an arbitrary list on the spot. Overall, they’re shown to simply think they can never be wrong, and never be hurt.</p><p>They’re so egotistical that when they realize they can be harmed, they almost seem offended by it. Adam responds to this revelation: “That’s how they can kill us? With our own weapons? Fucking weak dude.”</p><p>Like the usual fantasy fare, the weapon isn’t the ultimate decider of the battle, but instead of the heroes creatively pushing ahead, the angels’ arrogance becomes the true secret weapon. In the final moments, when Adam has Charlie by the throat and it looks like he will overcome this misfit bands’ hoard of weapons, he isn’t killed by a moment of brilliance by the characters, but by a random agent of chaos.</p><p>Nifty, the buglike cleaning lady of the hotel, stabs Adam from behind and saves the day. Later, it’s revealed it wasn’t a sneaky bit of ingenuity but simply because “Charlie told me to stab, so I did”. Nifty seemed unaware of the situation and was merely continuing her gleeful killing spree.</p><p>Because Adam looked down on the demons, he never imagined a random little bug with a knife would get him. He was a victim of his own arrogance and a bit of dumb luck, hilariously twisting the usual dramatic ending in this trope.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>There are many things regarding <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>’s writing that can be praised (and there <em>might</em> be more essays coming, stay tuned!), and this one aspect demonstrates where it all stems from. It would have been simple to flood the script with swear words and gore, then claim it’s comedy, but A24’s team did even better.</p><p>There’s still plenty of fucks, shits, drugs, sex, and violence, but the show’s subversion of the typical secret weapon narrative shows an incredible amount of thought and an adept eye for what makes something funny. Truly, it’s one of the best examples of hyping up the audience’s expectations and then creatively pulling out the rug.</p><p>Beyond the laughs, they also tie everything in with the more emotional side of the story. Vaggie’s and Charlie’s emotional growth seamlessly weave between absurdist situations and genuine reflection in the best way.</p><p>Comedy has long been linked with tragedy, going back to Aristotle, and while not every funny story has to have tragic elements, or vice versa, when the two are masterfully combined, it’s magical. This is largely why I enjoy Taika Watiti’s work because, like <em>Hazbin Hotel</em>, he handily blends the heart and the chuckle.</p><p>The secret weapon trope in <em>Hazbin Hotel</em> is an exemplary example of the show’s stunning craft and hopefully will continue for many years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5fa326709286" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Lukewarm Defense of I’m Just Ken]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/a-lukewarm-defense-of-im-just-ken-89324e9bed7f?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89324e9bed7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[barbie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[im-just-ken]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critics-choice-awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ryan-gosling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Jan 2024 22:24:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-20T22:24:51.594Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Responding to the Critic Choice Awards Reception</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*ULwADvqD4ZwnDGXTFpmEvg.png" /></figure><p><em>Note: If you consider yourself an anti-feminist or think like the person below, this essay ain’t for you. Kindly move on.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*1mrcxPkPg9K8DUKoGcGPjQ.png" /><figcaption>F**k this guy…</figcaption></figure><p>In mid-January, “I’m Just Ken” from Greta Gerwig’s <em>Barbie</em> won the Critics Choice Award for Best Song and many fans of the film were aghast. To these fans, it seemed like a film made by a woman director, that focused on women’s experiences and was celebratorily feminine in its presentation was being undermined because the male lead’s song was chosen over others by women artists.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*m1GbAvaUMZxxOe4FRIf5mw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*yACFta2_65nLc-J2m2kJBA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*XU6hEpvszBmeMsVuXfypww.png" /></figure><p>One TikToker called Kal (<a href="https://www.tiktok.com/@funkyfrogbait?_t=8jAoXF8jTsV&amp;_r=1">@funkyfrogbait</a>) even went so far as to <a href="https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPRc7nhmU/">say</a> in a comedic sketch depicting this frustration that “I’m Just Ken” is a “joke song that was essentially a satirical incel anthem”. In this scenario, they showed the award committee not understanding why that “might be a problem”.</p><p>The possibility that this award foreshadows a potential Oscar win for this song made things much worse. Even Billie Eilish’s “What Was I Made for?” <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3M8jf51VzD0">winning</a> the Golden Globe couldn’t sate the anxiety from this possibility, if anything, it made it more outrageous.</p><p>This backlash wasn’t unexpected. Ken (played by Ryan Gosling) and his many copies’ roles and amount of screen time in <em>Barbie</em> have been criticized since the movie’s release. Even Barbie experts <a href="https://www.vox.com/culture/2023/7/24/23805608/barbie-movie-explained-2023-ken-feminist-im-just-ken-ryan-gosling">felt</a> that Gosling’s character shouldn’t have had equal billing because Ken is an accessory to Barbie, and within the context of the dolls, has never had equal ambitions.</p><p>I don’t disagree with any of these feelings. The film industry has so many issues letting women tell their stories or be portrayed as anything but partners and support figures for male characters. <em>Barbie</em>’s Ken character does feel like a sort of security blanket for risk-averse studios who can’t imagine a story without a man being important in some way.</p><p>In addition, regressive YouTubers and right-wing talking heads (in all of their triggered glory) <a href="https://youtu.be/DtL2KY14QAc?si=C0jYkW0_hqDJ_Hvl">have</a> decried the movie as “anti-man” because they simply can’t imagine a male character being a supporting role or a punchline. But, even if this type of outrage comes from the fringes of society, it forces a feeling from fans to diligently defend <em>Barbie</em>, especially the parts that are pro-woman.</p><p>“I’m Just Ken” is also a strange song, in my opinion, and the other Critics Choice Awards nominees (Billie Eilish’s “What Was I Made For?” and Dua Lipa’s “Dance the Night”) are much better songs. So, I understand why it winning Best Song is concerning and I have misgivings as well.</p><p>However, I don’t think it should be completely dismissed.</p><p>While the meat of <em>Barbie</em> is women’s experiences, I think it’s also a story about how patriarchy negatively affects everyone, including men. I worry that the reactions to “I’m Just Ken” cause an unnecessary “us vs. them” conflict which dismisses the harm men face in this system and halts some quality discussion because it appears to take away from women.</p><p>A nuanced approach to this is desperately needed.</p><p>While the song and the story beat surrounding it are flawed, “I’m Just Ken” at least attempts to discuss the less-explored sex in feminism. I wouldn’t call myself a Ken fan (team Allan all the way) and I don’t particularly like this song, but I can see why others might identify with it.</p><p>So, here is a lukewarm defense of this semi-cringy song.</p><h3>The Meat of I’m Just Ken</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*oOhag_Hv0TF4DuEUbL_XPg.png" /></figure><p>What purpose does “I’m Just Ken” serve to <em>Barbie</em>?</p><p>It’s meant to be a culmination of Ken’s story arc. He feels disenfranchised by not being on equal footing with the Barbies in Barbieland. They get houses and personalities, while the Kens aren’t shown to live anywhere and, beyond different appearances, are all the same.</p><p>As the movie’s tagline explains: “She’s everything. He’s just Ken.”</p><p>This is why Ken so easily fell into the claws of patriarchy. Under that system, he is powerful, strong, and can explore his horse fantasies to his delight. He wants to be more than just another part of Barbie’s life, but at the same time, still wants her recognition. “I’m Just Ken” is meant to show this conflict that’s bubbling inside him.</p><p>The song’s co-writer, Mark Ronson, wanted this song to be a balance of serious and silly; campy, but also sincere. On acceptance of the Critics Choice Awards, he <a href="https://people.com/critics-choice-awards-2024-best-song-im-just-ken-barbie-ryan-gosling-mark-ronson-8425001">thanked</a> Greta Gerwig for “carv[ing] out 11 minutes for this prog-rock, power-ballad, dream-ballet, shred fest so the boys could cry and hold hands a little too […].”</p><p>And Ronson aimed for this sentiment at the song’s inception and through its creation. On Guy Raz’s <em>The Great Creators</em> podcast he <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1ycSxnjiTM">admits</a> that before coming up with even a single line “The Ken character had really sunk its hooks into me from the film because, you know, he does have it kind of tough”.</p><p>On top of this, Ryan Gosling initially didn’t want to sing in <em>Barbie</em>, but he <a href="https://www.nme.com/news/music/ryan-gosling-told-greta-gerwig-im-just-ken-speaks-to-him-very-deeply-3556373">reportedly</a> decided to do it because he had a deep connection with “I’m Just Ken”. The song seems to have a lot of heart and emotion behind it, a desire to demonstrate that it’s ok for men to express their pain under these patriarchal systems.</p><p>However, this wasn’t necessarily accomplished. While intentions may have been noble, the song comes across as confused, presented as a steak, but closer to a bacon slice.</p><p>The lyrics don’t do any favors for this goal.</p><blockquote>Doesn’t seem to matter what I do<br> I’m always number two<br> No one knows how hard I tried, oh-oh, I<br> I have feelings that I can’t explain<br> Drivin’ me insane<br> All my life, been so polite<br> But I’ll sleep alone tonight</blockquote><blockquote>’Cause I’m just Ken, anywhere else I’d be a ten<br> Is it my destiny to live and die a life of blonde fragility?<br> I’m just Ken<br> Where I see love, she sees a friend<br> What will it take for her to see the man behind the tan and fight for me?</blockquote><p>The words are fairly simple, focusing on shallow things like Ken’s appearance and don’t dig much deeper into his feelings of entitlement to love and attention. The majority of the song comes across as a generic “man feels bad” tune that partially points the blame at Barbie; not a great look for an award-winning song.</p><p>It’s frustrating because there are a few gems that could have used some breathing space.</p><blockquote>I have feelings that I can’t explain</blockquote><blockquote>Is it a crime? Am I not hot when I’m in my feelings?</blockquote><blockquote>I’m just Ken (and I’m enough)</blockquote><p>I like this focus on Ken not being able to name his feelings and that he can’t express himself because this is a reality for many men under patriarchy. They feel something is wrong, but have few, if any, outlets to explore why.</p><p>They are told to shove them down and place fault for these feelings on either themselves or, unfortunately, women. It’s a looping, self-degrading internal conflict that is either ignored or only displayed with problematic characters in today’s media.</p><p>“I’m Just Ken” attempts to demonstrate this kind of cycle through its structure. Instead of the typical verse-chorus, it jumps between starkly contrasting sections. Though this is most likely for choreography reasons, I would argue that it also is influenced by this idea of the swarming, contradictory feelings inside Ken. To me, this shows there was at least an attempt to make the song more than a “satirical incel anthem”.</p><p>But it feels unbalanced. The focus is definitely on Ken pining for Barbie’s recognition and how wrong it is for him to feel this. The concluding affirmation “And I’m enough” is great, but wasn’t earned with how the song currently exists. The journey is a repetitive emotional platitude that doesn’t lead Ken to this growth, making it feel less natural and less effective.</p><p>Sadly, there are few alternatives available that explore this, but Mark Ronson’s intentions and Ryan Gosling’s reaction seem to suggest there is a demand for this type of story. The LA Times even praised Ronson and his cowriter, Andrew Wyatt, for finding “emotional truth”, despite it being more of a grain (and truly is more of an example of men receiving praise for doing less than other groups).</p><p>But, for now, this is what we have. The song could be better, but it can still be useful and valuable.</p><h3>The Aftertaste of “I’m Just Ken”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*1GAoiKkY3PdjR85wq84Sqg.png" /></figure><p>Do I believe “I’m Just Ken” should have won the Critics Choice Award?</p><p>No.</p><p>Is it a shame it won over more women-centered songs?</p><p>Yes.</p><p>Do I believe there is still some merit to the song?</p><p>Absolutely.</p><p>While I too am worried about people missing the point of <em>Barbie</em> and rewarding the film’s most male-focused moment, I am more worried about the good conversations that will be dashed if the reactions to it remain this negative. It isn’t an either/or situation where either women win or they lose. The song can be a boon to discussions on male pain under patriarchy.</p><p>This idea is something that feminist author bell hooks explains better than I can in <em>The Will to Change</em>:</p><blockquote>“Men do oppress women. People are hurt by rigid sexist role patterns. These two realities coexist. Male oppression of women cannot be excused by the recognition that there are ways men are hurt by rigid sexist roles. Feminist activists should acknowledge that hurt, and work to change it — it exists. It does not erase or lessen male responsibility for supporting and perpetuating their power under patriarchy to exploit and oppress women in a manner far more grievous than the serious psychological stress and emotional pain caused by male conformity to rigid sexist role patterns.”</blockquote><p><em>Barbie</em> fans can take the good and bad without detracting from the amazing, talented women involved and their artistic achievements. I’d argue that to make a better world for all genders and orientations, it’s a must.</p><p>Ken definitely got more screen time than he deserved for a film about Barbie, but his role is still a valuable reflection on the state of men and their relationships with women.</p><p>For example, take this point from Vox Senior Correspondent Alex Abad-Santos in his <a href="https://www.vox.com/culture/2023/7/24/23805608/barbie-movie-explained-2023-ken-feminist-im-just-ken-ryan-gosling">article</a> “What does it mean to be ‘just Ken’?”:</p><blockquote>“Ken complements [Barbie’s] life, making it better in the only way he knows how, by being Ken.<strong> </strong>Like Barbie’s multiple jobs, her friends, her pets, her houses, and her vehicles, Ken is just one thing in her life rather than the only thing.”</blockquote><p>It’s this idea that sparked “I’m Just Ken”. The character is introduced to our “real” world where his misgivings, despite them being misguided, are valid. Sure, Ken would have more power under patriarchy, but he would never be happy as himself, as “just Ken”; a small part of Barbie’s world.</p><p>bell hooks also discusses this in the beforementioned book:</p><blockquote>“In patriarchal culture males are not allowed simply to be who they are and to glory in their unique identity. Their value is always determined by what they do. In an antipatriarchal culture males do not have to prove their value and worth. They know from birth that simply being gives them value, the right to be cherished and loved.”</blockquote><p>At the end of <em>Barbie</em>, the audience gets something close to this. Ken seems satisfied with being “Kenough” for himself and not being the main character. Simply him being a part of Barbie’s life is worth it. But, this is lost if this story is dismissed outright.</p><p>Even with its many, many flaws, “I’m Just Ken” is one of the few examples that grapples with these feminist ideas on men. I’d hate to see that thrown away and see fewer men able to envision their truest selves and how that comes from dismantling this oppressive system.</p><p>It’s not the fault of women, feminism, or feminists that this is the reaction to the Critics Choice Awards, but another example of patriarchy isolating all genders. “I’m Just Ken” has been made into a tool of dissent instead of a flawed piece of art worthy of discourse.</p><p>While I don’t necessarily want to defend it, the song, and we, deserve better than that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89324e9bed7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Craft an Anti-Trans Narrative with Deniability]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/how-to-craft-an-anti-trans-narrative-with-deniability-9b3f6b4204e7?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9b3f6b4204e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transphobia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-york-post]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bigotry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Dec 2023 17:30:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-27T17:30:26.676Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dissecting the <em>New York Post</em>’s Gross Article</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*c1YsQVI-bHOOcfNN2dljmw.png" /></figure><p>At the beginning of December, the <em>New York Post</em> published an <a href="https://nypost.com/2023/12/15/news/50-year-old-transgender-woman-shared-pool-locker-room-with-young-girls-at-race/">article</a> titled “50-year-old trans swimmer shared locker room while competing against teens: ‘The girls were terrified’”. Normally, I would ignore this type of news that is outrage bait, but the reporting and writing within was particularly egregious and, to me, a clear anti-trans narrative disguised as objective journalism.</p><p>The more I dug into this, the sicker I felt at how this “story” was framed and what details the <em>Post</em> decided to include and exclude. Drawing on my graduate education in communications and mass media, I knew I had to break down how this narrative was made with deniability as it’s something I see happening more and more. News outlets that lean towards transphobia report this way because it allows them to push their ideas while claiming deniability.</p><p>Unfortunately for these news outlets, these storytelling devices have long been studied and scholarly research can easily explain what’s happening. Through this, and a healthy dose of proper journalism, I will break down these techniques and show how they subtly construct their anti-trans narrative.</p><h3>Priming, Framing &amp; Word Choice</h3><p>The <em>New York Post</em>’s article begins with the following paragraphs:</p><p>“A 50-year-old transgender swimmer was allowed to compete against teenage girls at an event in Canada — with horrified parents building a makeshift tent out of towels to shield girls as young as 8 in the locker room.</p><p>Melody Wiseheart, who once competed under [her dead name], sparked outrage while competing during the Trojan Cup in Barrie, Ontario.”</p><p>In writing, but particularly news reporting, word choice is extremely important. Certain verbs have different connotations and can drastically change the meaning of a sentence.</p><p>Notice how in the first sentence, the writer of this article chooses “allowed to compete”. This term suggests that this might not have been allowed previously, or Wiseheart racing was a novel occurrence. What follows is that this “sparked outrage” and then the reader gets two negative quotes from parents about the girls being “confused” and “terrified”.</p><p>This is an excellent example of what’s called media-priming theory in communications literature. Introduced in 1987 by Iyengar and Kinder, this theory explains that certain words or visuals can activate associations one has with a certain topic or idea and then influence how one interprets something.</p><p>Since transgender athletes and whether they should be <em>allowed</em> to compete with cisgender ones is a hotly debated topic, most readers likely have vague opinions on it. The term “allowed” brings forth this idea by reminding them that it <em>is</em> something to be debated and that in some states many trans athletes are barred from competing as their identified gender.</p><p>Some of these readers may associate this with men “pretending to be women” to win at sports, or others may just associate trans athletes as a societal taboo. Regardless, in a single sentence, the <em>New York Post</em> has primed its audience to see this through a controversial lens.</p><p>What next occurs is another communications concept called <strong>framing. </strong>This idea was described in 1993 by media researcher Robert Entman as “select[ing] some aspects of a perceived reality and mak[ing] them more salient in a communicating text, in such a way as to promote a particular problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and/or treatment recommendation for the item described”</p><p>Words, phrases, or metaphors can all be used to frame an issue and emphasize what is important about it. Framing isn’t necessarily a negative thing, it can be helpful to streamline information for journalists, but in this case, it is used to highlight a false, disgusting narrative.</p><p>With the audience primed to think about this trans athlete as controversial, it’s easy to then frame this story as something negative and unusual. By including the phrase “horrified parents” in the introduction and then proceeding with strongly worded quotes, the New York Post frames Wiseheart’s competing as something allegedly morally corrupt or, at least, something to be concerned about.</p><p>The order of the paragraphs also plays a role in this. It isn’t until the seventh paragraph that the New York Post explains (incorrectly as I’ll show later) that Wiseheart has been competing with girls since 2019. By the time readers swim through this stream of primed novelty and strong, negative framing, this detail, which contradicts this frame, becomes less noticeable.</p><p>Even within this detail, the New York Post selectively uses the word “against girls” to frame her swimming as antagonistic. They could have said “competed with girls” or simply “swam in the girl’s division”, but that wouldn’t suggest an anti-trans narrative with a little escape hatch attached.</p><p>This pattern continues throughout the piece to dampen any reporting that might suggest these events aren’t as outrageous. After some more quotes from “concerned parents”, the closing paragraphs provide a statement from Swim Canada saying that:</p><p>“Swimming Canada and Swim Ontario believe swimming is for everyone … people of all shapes, sizes, genders, beliefs, and backgrounds should have the opportunity to swim to the best of their ability”</p><p>What comes after is a parent saying “This is crazy”. What should be a definitive statement that the swimming authorities of Canada aren’t against this, and therefore, this issue isn’t a big deal, gets sandwiched between a cycle of negative priming and framing.</p><p>By using certain words, priming the audience, and framing the “issue” in a certain light, the New York Post can claim to be “just reporting the facts” while subtly pushing a viewpoint into the writing. They hope that their readers will fill in the blanks so they can avoid accountability.</p><p>It gets even worse when one looks into the details that they chose to exclude or deemphasize.</p><h3>Omitting Details &amp; Strategic Ignorance</h3><p>The <em>New York Post</em> describes the event only as “The Trojan Cup” and then later an interviewed parent says “Some of [the girls] are hoping for scholarship”. These two decisions lead the reader to believe this is an important competition, one with an awe-inspiring name and possible financial implications.</p><p>In reality, the Trojan Cup is a community event hosted by the Barrie Trojan Swim Club. They are a private club that once <a href="https://www.gomotionapp.com/team/canbtsc/page/about-us">operated</a> out of a YMCA. Though some of the individual competitors may have been showing off for college recruiters, the event itself does not offer scholarships.</p><p>The event also hosts an open-age category where any person who is a member of a swim club could race. The New York Post doesn’t include any of this detail because it would force them to address details that dull the teeth of their narrative.</p><p>Along a similar vein, the Post also states:</p><p>“World Aquatics, the international governing body of the sport, effectively banned male-to-female transgender athletes from competing in women’s events last year after updating its policy to allow for only swimmers who transitioned before age 12 or in the early stages of puberty.”</p><p>What they fail to mention is that World Aquatics only governs over Olympic and World competitions, not private YMCA/Community Swim meets</p><p>Both of these are excellent examples of a communications concept called <strong>strategic ignorance.</strong></p><p>In a recent study done by Knudson and Kishik in <em>Social Epistemology</em>, they examined how Danish Agricultural agencies craftily maintained ignorance to avoid taking action during a disease outbreak among the country’s pig farms. Gaining knowledge on which farms had infected pigs and crafting a plan to address it would put the department in a difficult situation, so kept muddling the process by claiming they couldn’t proceed because of unknown variables or moving the goalpost on what the objectives of these investigations.</p><p>The New York Post likely was aware of the nature of this competition, for their original and <em>only</em> source, <em>The Toronto Sun</em>, wrote in their coverage:</p><p>“Parents confirmed that the person in question changed in and out of a swimsuit in the women’s locker room at the East Bayfield Community Centre during the Dec. 1 Trojan Cup.”</p><p>But, they likely didn’t seek out clarifying information because they didn’t want to and used strategic ignorance to avoid addressing it.</p><p>Knudson and Kishik use this case study to explain how “strategic ignorance is about avoiding, hiding, or rendering existing knowledge unreliable” and how carefully selecting how and what topics one communicates can produce and maintain ignorance.</p><p>Along with the Trojan Cup’s background, the New York Post fails to find out other details that could clarify this story like how long Wiseheart has been swimming, how long she’s been out as transgender, or her relationship with her community.</p><p>Googling her name, I found these answers quite easily. This leads me to believe that the New York Post didn’t look into these things to be strategically ignorant.</p><p>So, let’s answer some of these questions:</p><p>In regards to her swimming, it seems that Wiseheart has been <a href="https://www.swimming.ca/en/swimmer/5257113/">swimming</a> in the girl’s division since at least 2017 (her first recorded time is ironically a Trojan Cup), not 2019 like the Post claimed.</p><p>In 2012, her wife started a blog detailing their journey from being a heterosexual couple to a lesbian one. This suggests Wiseheart has been out for over 10 years, possibly more.</p><p>Wiseheart has been employed as a professor at York University for 18 years. Since professors tend to be involved in their communities and public figures, to a degree, it could be safely assumed she wasn’t a stranger.</p><p>Was this information hard to track down?</p><p>No.</p><p>As of publication, her wife’s blog can be found in the fifth result, and her Swimming Canada profile in the seventh when you google her name. She also has a public LinkedIn profile.</p><p>I can only assume the <em>New York Post</em> purposefully avoided this information like the Danish agricultural agencies for similar reasons: it would make this story a less effective anti-trans narrative, so they avoided looking it up.</p><p>It gets even more damning when one finds out where this story originally came from.</p><h3>Avoiding Troubling Associations</h3><p>This article includes a lot of quotes from unnamed parents making it seem like this outrage was a majority opinion, but that may not be the case. This may be another notch in a chain of fixation from conservative talking heads.</p><p>Though the <em>New York Post</em> credits the <em>Toronto Sun</em> as the original news source, this story originally broke in October from <em>Rebel News</em>, a website notorious for spreading misinformation and having reporters with ties to far-right and neo-fascist groups according to the Southern Poverty Law Center. Other conservative news outlets such as <em>Louder with Crowder</em> and <em>The Blaze</em> quickly latched onto this “story”, misgendering Wiseheart and placing her name in quotations.</p><p><em>Rebel News</em> claims to have gotten a tip from “concerned parents” about Wiseheart competing and allegedly were met with a lot of resistance when they went to investigate.</p><p>“First, organizers actually denied that [Wiseheart] swam at the meet, even though we provided them with a copy of the Friday schedule that indicated otherwise. Eventually, the organizers relented and admitted that [Wiseheart] did take part, but they didn’t want to get into a debate about gender and age.”</p><p>However, their video coverage, which the article is based on and is placed at the top of the page, paints a different picture. What they show is confused, contradictory, and frankly unprofessional reporting of this supposed travesty.</p><p>The event organizer they interviewed didn’t “relent” after pushing, but merely was mistaken about Wiseheart being registered for that race and admitted so. He also didn’t try to avoid a debate like <em>Rebel News</em> framed but explained that the standards on age and gender are governed by Swimming Canada and registration for races is based on that.</p><p>In the same video, they also claim that the meets were “segregated by sex and age”, but are later contradicted by one of their interviewees. The same interviewee explains that the meet is open-age and anyone can compete.</p><p>As a final nail in the coffin of this already unprofessional reporting, the site also claims that they couldn’t get any parents to speak to them because they were too afraid to be canceled but provided zero evidence; not even an anonymous source is quoted. Also, people give statements anonymously all the time, so this seems farfetched.</p><p>Since neither the <em>New York Post</em> nor the <em>Toronto Sun</em> credited <em>Rebel News</em>, it’s only speculation, but some signs point towards the <em>Post</em>, at minimum, trying to distance themselves and remain strategically ignorant.</p><p>The <em>Toronto Sun</em> has higher quality reporting than <em>Rebel News</em> and mostly sticks to facts, but the writer, Joe Warmington, can’t help but insert their opinion and be barefaced about their message.</p><p>“The whole thing is gross.”</p><p>“As difficult as the Lia Thomas situation was in the United States where a transgender female was competing against biological females, this one is even stranger in that it’s an adult pulling this stunt against kids.”</p><p>After a little digging, I also found that Warmington once <a href="https://pressprogress.ca/the-toronto-suns-joe-warmington-is-headlining-a-far-right-rebel-media-event-on-doug-ford/">headlined</a> an event sponsored by <em>Rebel Media</em>, the parent company of <em>Rebel News</em>, and <a href="https://twitter.com/joe_warmington/status/1728888018222846058">shared</a> their posts on Twitter as recently as November 2023. In my opinion, it’s highly likely that Warmington found out about Wiseheart’s racing through them and then pursued this “story”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*WScqRwa7KFr1c28jgsGC2w.png" /></figure><p>With all of that said, Warmington didn’t cite <em>Rebel News</em>’ coverage. Assumedly, it wouldn’t look good for the <em>Sun</em>, which has a <a href="https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/toronto-sun/">high</a> credibility rating, to base an article on a source with questionable journalistic ethics. Warmington’s article gives the <em>Post</em> a cushion of deniability by not being directly from the allegedly fascist news site.</p><p>This information was not hard to find, so I can only assume that the <em>New York Post</em> (which I must reiterate, used the <em>Toronto</em> <em>Sun </em>article as their <em>only</em> source with little to no additional information added) strategically avoided further information to maintain ignorance.</p><p>Through a kind of disgusting version of the telephone game, this story has gone from bluntly transphobic “news” by bigoted outlets to the now slyly written, and more digestible, article by the <em>New York Post</em>, but with the same conclusion: trans people shouldn’t be competing in sports.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>So, why did I just write over 2300 words (and counting) on a 500-word article?</p><p>It’s because this “story” got to the <em>New York Post</em>, one of the <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/272790/circulation-of-the-biggest-daily-newspapers-in-the-us/">biggest</a> circulating papers in the country. Had these events remained in the pits of conservative news hell, with their highly biased and often inaccurate reporting, I would have ignored this. Debunking them would have been easy and done little.</p><p>But, the <em>Post</em>’s name carries a 200-year-old legacy and is considered highly respectable by many. Their sphere of influence is much greater, making these sneakily-made anti-trans narratives extremely concerning.</p><p>Over 500 anti-transgender bills were <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/US/epidemic-anti-transgender-violence-highlighted-new-report/story?id=105036934">introduced</a> in 2023 and violence against the community is on the rise. Most of these bills are introduced under the guise of “protecting children” or “being against medical malpractice” because most politicians know it is not acceptable to flatly say “I want to outlaw transgender people”.</p><p>Likewise, the <em>New York Post</em> knows they can’t be upfront about their opinion. They hide it behind particular word choices and organization of information in attempts to prime their audience and frame the issue under a certain light, while also selectively pursuing certain details to claim ignorance and benevolence.</p><p>Further transgender hate won’t propagate through blatant calls for violence, but through words like these which quietly push an agenda. If the trans community, and more importantly allies, can learn to see these in news reporting, they can better defend themselves and their loved ones.</p><p>In other words, f^&amp;* off <em>New York Post</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9b3f6b4204e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The 10 Best Graphic Novels I Read In 2023]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/the-10-best-graphic-novels-i-read-in-2023-f2b38a91af92?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f2b38a91af92</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comics-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[year-in-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[best-of]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graphic-novels]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Dec 2023 17:22:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-20T17:31:50.785Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*Uv8TV8Z4nZNUICAxu95xgw.png" /></figure><p>This year was interesting in regards to reading. I discovered a love for poetry (more of a hyperfixation) and in general, spent less time reading comics than other forms of storytelling. I may crack 200 graphic novels read by the end of the year, but it’s a far cry from the over 300 I read last year.</p><p>The graphic novels I read tended to follow mini-projects for myself. I wanted to dive into particular creators, like Jeff Lemire or Art Spiegelman, read all of the nominees for GoodReads Choice Awards (I did not accomplish this), or read books from a single publisher (Hey Mad Cave Studios!). My reading wasn’t as varied or sporadic, but I think I learned a lot following my bliss in this way.</p><p>If there were any overarching themes to my favorite books this year, it’s the gays and finding one’s place in the world. A lot of these books deal with uncertainty in one’s desires and identity. How does one find their truest self when the past and people’s viewpoints say they’re something else? On reflection, this makes sense, but I’ll keep the reasons why to myself.</p><p>Anyway, to the list!</p><h3>Essex County by Jeff Lemire</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*o6lA3pLXYUsvYMmqCg7FVQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Essex County</em> is 15 years old at this point and, for many comics fans, doesn’t need a ton of introduction. I think this book could easily be called a classic and will be discussed in the annals of comics history for years to come.</p><p>For me, I think this book is an exemplary example of how story and art can mesh together so well that it feels like the two were made for each other. Jeff Lemire’s scrawling pencils, minimalist compositions, and thick inks are perfect for this rural setting with a story about loneliness, grief, and regret. The emotional weight conveyed in the simply designed faces is commendable and shows how comics art can display so much information into a tiny panel.</p><p>In the future, I’d love to write an essay that dives deeper into how this marriage of story and art creates a rich, depressing landscape and stunning visual metaphors. Lemire truly displayed the power of effective, thoughtful art.</p><h3>Squire by Nadia Shammas &amp; Sara Alfageeh</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*4Fh1OOoqlmfMTd-XrAG7XQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Squire</em> was one of my reads from the GoodReads Choice Award nominees. Nadi Shammas is a favorite writer of mine, so I knew this would be good, but it was so much better.</p><p>This book follows a young girl who must hide her identity as a member of the hated Ordu people so that she can enlist as a squire. By completing her training, she can become a knight and a full citizenship. Through her trials, she gains friends and learns that the history of her country isn’t what it seems. An underlying theme of the book is how stories and histories can be weaponized to turn people into bad guys and it’s done so well.</p><p>Shammas and Alfageeh draw a lot from their Arab heritage and create a gorgeous book that shows fantasy without the typical European aesthetics and narrative beats. I could easily get lost in the gorgeous architecture and landscapes, and this heightened an already emotional, thoughtful tale. Simply put, it’s a great book with a setting that deserves to be featured more.</p><h3>Mister Mammoth by Matt Kindt &amp; Jean-Denis Pendanx</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*wdvz9qIgZ4hqJ3JPW5Bg3g.png" /></figure><p>Matt Kindt is easily my favorite comic creator. When the opportunity came to <a href="https://www.comicbookyeti.com/post/i-m-always-joking-about-something-an-interview-with-writer-artist-matt-kindt">interview</a> him for Comic Book Yeti, I jumped on it. <em>Mister Mammoth</em> was one of the books I was given to by the publisher to prepare and I couldn’t put it down.</p><p>Mister Mammoth is one of the most interesting characters I’ve read and seen in a long time. On top of being the greatest detective with near-God-like foresight, he is hulking, scarred, and dresses like an old-school gangster; the type of guy who readers would expect to be violent and endlessly ambitious.</p><p>But, he’s the opposite of that. He’s a pacifist, refuses to defend himself, and refuses to accept lavish payments for his unbelievable skill. His only want is to find the answers to his past, which he can’t remember. His story is endlessly interesting and visually stunning, feeling both pulpy and high-concept simultaneously. I can’t recommend this enough.</p><h3>Project Nought by Chelsey Furedi</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*AYWAWg5CYPIYz7IPACaDdA.png" /></figure><p>I work at my local library and a lot of my graphic novel choices stem from impulsively requesting new books that come in. <em>Project Nought</em> was one of those. The synopsis alone had me hooked, and the number of queer characters sweetened it even further, but I was not prepared for this story to keep me guessing for over 300 pages.</p><p>This book revolves around a time-travel exchange program where people from the past are taken to the year 2122 to be interviewed and studied by that century’s college students. Ren Mittal, the story’s protagonist, is a listless young adult from the 1990s and isn’t sure how he feels about being forcefully grabbed from his time, even if his memory will be wiped after the program ends. Seeing a familiar face outside of the exchange students also sends him spiraling. Things are not as they seem.</p><p><em>Project Nought</em> was originally a webcomic on Tapas and converting these to print is always a challenge, but Furedi’s art masterfully adapts to the page. Had I not googled it, I’d have never known this was a webcomic. The layouts are densely packed, but never needlessly slow down the story. Readers truly get a chance to hang out with the characters because of it. GO READ THIS!</p><h3>Show’s End by Anthony Cleveland, Jeferson Sadzinski, Julian Gonzalez &amp; Justin Birch</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*SYM6bxaBcBIfY1Br9uuCBQ.png" /></figure><p>Have you ever just liked something, but weren’t sure why at first? Like an album by a new artist, you’ve never heard before that just scratches a certain itch in your core? That’s how I first experienced <em>Shows’s End</em>.</p><p>The book is part cosmic horror, part found family story concerning a freak show. In 1920s Georgia, a young, red-headed girl named Lorelei stumbles upon a traveling circus while fleeing gun-toting humans. She begs the ring leader to let her join, but they initially reject her for being “too ordinary”, but after befriending the group’s pinheaded girl, she is allowed inside. This story contains so many heart-wrenching twists and is an excellent first chapter.</p><p>On later reflection, I think what drew me to <em>Show’s End</em> was it being subtly queer. Lorelei has something inside her (no spoilers) that society has deemed evil causing her to lose her family and be hunted. She finds happiness through the freak show because they too are deemed vile by the rest and accept her true self. While the book doesn’t feature any openly queer characters, its themes of found family, acceptance, and a sort of “coming out” really resonated with me.</p><p>I love this book and can’t wait to get my hands on the next volume.</p><h3>Trick Pony by Greg Lockard, Anna David &amp; Lucas Gattoni</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*RjWe1lTxNmqdcnDiIyBdpQ.png" /></figure><p>Again, I had the pleasure of <a href="https://www.comicbookyeti.com/post/trick-pony-tpb">reviewing</a> this book for Comic Book Yeti and I knew right away it would make this list.</p><p>Rodeo star and party boy Jimmy finds himself injured and needs to return home after his mother calls and tells him his father is in the hospital. Saying much more than this would spoil a lot of the book, so I’ll keep it there.</p><p><em>Trick Pony </em>is a testament to how a story doesn’t need to be complex to be quality and meaningful. Jimmy’s journey is one-directional, but not boring in the slightest. He has a goal and some inner turmoil he has to address and his story makes its destination. It’s highly character-driven in the best way.</p><p>But allow me to gush about Anna David’s art. Like with <em>Essex County</em>, this story seemed made for her style. Her line art is thin, scraggly, and consistent with light compositions, leaving lots of space for the eye to focus on. Because of this, her coloring largely carries the load of contrast and focus in each scene and is some of the best I’ve ever seen. Colorists aren’t discussed nearly enough in comics and this book would be an excellent starting point on the necessity of deliberate color choices. This is the only book I’ve read where the line art takes a backseat and it’s so refreshing.</p><h3>The Moth Keeper by K. O’Neill</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*Dnzb5Djls_JXygieKHdAPw.png" /></figure><p>K. O’Neill was one of the comics creators whose catalog I devoured. Her <em>Tea Dragon Society</em> series is excellent, but <em>The Moth Keeper</em> quickly became my favorite book by her.</p><p>The story follows Anya who has been selected as her village’s newest moth keeper. The citizens of this world have adapted to living in the nighttime so that they may take advantage of the Night-Lily flower, which blooms only once a year with the moth’s assistance. It’s a lonely job, but Anya can handle it. However, she seems to be using the job as a way to avoid her problems.</p><p>O’Neill is a master of letting the art take the reins in her comics. Dialogue tends to be sparse and the reader is allowed long moments to appreciate the landscapes and characters. It’s my favorite kind of comics writing and her work has become highly influential on how I approach creating my own comics. Plus, the story is incredibly heartwarming, perfect for a cozy read this winter.</p><h3>Shubeik Lubeik by Deena Mohamed</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*CmaBEmJFdJ7ZLa27GITPrw.png" /></figure><p>Shout out to the website <a href="https://twitter.com/arablit">ArabLit</a> for turning me onto this book when I asked for recommendations on Twitter. I can safely say this book is a must-read for anyone wanting to broaden their horizons into the less-talked-about sphere of Middle Eastern comics.</p><p>In the world of <em>Shubeik Lubeik</em>, wish-granting genies exist but are tightly regulated by the Egyptian government, being separated into three classes based on their power. One middle-aged merchant sells three first-class wishes he inherited from his wish-hating father to three people, whose stories the book follows.</p><p>So much is explored in this graphic novel: class divisions, mental health, and the plights of Arab people, but I think the most heartbreaking theme is how one figures out their desires. Each character must tackle how best to use their wish, or even if they truly want them. It’s an amazing, reflective book that bravely asks “How do you know you’re happy and what if the thing you most desire can’t be achieved?”</p><p><em>Shubeik Lubeik</em> should be placed on the same shelf as works like <em>Maus</em> and <em>Persepolis</em>.</p><h3>Thoughtscape Comics by Matt Mair Lowery and a whole lot of super-talented artists and letterers who I don’t have room to list</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*2gyLw6mbRpf0fjMLM40N6g.png" /></figure><p>Yeah, yeah, yeah, I reviewed this book for Comic Book Yeti as well…</p><p>But here me out, because <em>Thoughtscape Comics</em> is one of the most creative series in comics. I would dare say it’s become a multimedia experience and stretched the limit of what is capable in this medium.</p><p>Each installment in this series is a collection of short comics and graphic art that is packaged as an employee orientation dossier from LifeTech, a fictional company that has harnessed the power of the Thoughtscape, the dimension where all thoughts and ideas live. Through this, the reader almost becomes a character in this universe; little bits of lore and facts about the company and the overarching story behind these short comics.</p><p>It’s a bit like <em>The Twilight Zone</em> meets <em>Five Nights at Freddy’s</em> if <em>FNAF</em> actually had thoughtful connections made between the easter eggs (no I won’t apologize for this X-P).</p><p>Though the stories inside are great, have a good variety and a bit of anti-capitalist satire, my favorite part is the extra bits outside of the book. In between the comics are fake advertisements, newsletters, and emails, some with QR codes that take the reader to additional content online. The only other comic series I know to do something like this is the <em>Radiant Black</em> universe, so this idea is still new and fun to play with.</p><p>The latest installment of this series comes to Kickstarter next <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/mattmlpdx/thoughtscape-comics-2024?ref=nav_search&amp;result=project&amp;term=thoughtscape">month</a>, so take advantage.</p><h3>In the Clear Moonlit Dusk by Mika Yamamori</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*4lASCBSZ-_-07HJPPvExbw.png" /></figure><p>This was another series that came through work and its premise seemed promising. I love works that play with gender roles and show that dysphoria is not a uniquely transgender experience. <em>In the Clear Moonlit Dusk</em> does this wonderfully.</p><p>This manga follows Yoi Takaguchi, who is a tall tomboy with a deep voice who everyone at her school labels “the Prince”. She doesn’t really like the nickname, but has accepted it and the inevitable truth that no one will see her as herself. However, an upperclassman boy, who also happens to be called a “Prince” begins showing interest in Yoi, which she initially rejects. After many conversations, the two decide to make a bargain and go through a trial period of dating. The first couple of volumes show both of these characters struggling to believe that the other truly sees them and is frustrating, but in that good way only romance stories seem to accomplish. It’s a great story that shows how deeply the expectations of society and friends can push someone away from their deepest desires.</p><p>While most manga art focuses on facial expressions, this series takes it up another notch. I love that the reader gets to see every little tick of emotion as Yoi struggles to accept that someone sees her as a girl and a desirable one at that. It also makes these books a nice, quick read while still packing in a lot of emotional content. I plan on collecting this series for my shelves as I imagine I’ll revisit it a lot.</p><h3>Honorable Mentions</h3><p><em>Ducks </em>by Kate Becton</p><p><em>One Soul</em> by Ray Fawkes</p><p><em>Poetry is Useless</em> by Anders Nilsen</p><p><em>Inside Mari</em> by Shuzo Oshimi</p><p><em>Palestine</em> by Joe Sacco</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f2b38a91af92" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your Children Deserve Nice Things: Home Alone & Why Kids Stories Can Be Good]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/your-children-deserve-nice-things-home-alone-why-kids-stories-can-be-good-8f3d25e44a6a?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8f3d25e44a6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[childrens-stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family-films]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[home-alone]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kids-stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas-movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Dec 2023 21:01:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-16T21:45:08.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let’s Stop Making Excuses For Poor Family Films</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*HsqNYpsdjMyOKzbsriqsnQ.png" /></figure><p>In the first week of the <em>Five Nights at Freddy’s</em> film’s release, there was a big divide between critical and audience reception. Audiences seem to generally find it entertaining and critics, myself <a href="https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/the-five-nights-at-freddys-film-is-disappointing-and-here-s-why-c60660f3066e">included</a>, found it disappointing. What struck me was the odd justifications for the film being poorly written.</p><p>Comments on critical articles claimed things like it was “for the fans”, but they also said the film was made for children as a defense. They claim that this is supposedly why the film was rated PG-13, so that FNAF’s young fandom would be able to see the movie without getting too scared.</p><p>But why does this mean the movie could be bad? Films like <em>Coraline</em> and <em>Spirited Away</em> manage to be creepy with PG ratings and good stories, so that can’t be the reason for <em>Freddy’s</em> lack of critical acclaim.</p><p>To me, the issue seems to be partially because of people’s previous affiliations with the video games, but also from a larger idea: these movies are for kids/family-friendly, so, of course, they aren’t as good as “adult” films.</p><p>I even experienced this recently with Disney’s latest animated film, <em>Wish</em>. Though I found the film fun, the story and songs didn’t get enough love in my opinion and I left the theatre dissatisfied. Despite this, I again saw the sentiment of it “being for kids”.</p><p>These comments seem to believe it’s not only acceptable for family movies to be bad, but inevitable. In my experience, this argument is built on two ideas:</p><p>1. Kids lack understanding and life experience, so they don’t have a frame of reference for “good” stories.</p><p>2. Kids care more about bright colors, loud music, and fun than they do about a good story.</p><p>Because of these two things, a kid’s film is bound to be bad.</p><p>As a parent, I find this a bit defeatist and pretentious. It says to me that children aren’t respected as consumers of art. Not only do my kids deserve to have good stories, a certain holiday favorite shows that a film for every age can be excellent:</p><p>Chris Columbus’ <em>Home Alone</em>.</p><h3>The Craft of Home Alone</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B9iNw5PMCzwf-p1P17I7Fg.jpeg" /></figure><p>At first glance, <em>Home Alone</em> is your typical family film. It has a colorful house for Kevin to concoct hilarious hijinks and a soundtrack that is fun and memorable. Who doesn’t love seeing him fool some burglars by rigging all of his family’s mannequins and cutouts as “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” plays?</p><p>What makes this movie great is that the well-crafted story and cinematography are very subtle. Most audience members wouldn’t realize that they are experiencing stunning character growth by the film’s writer, John Hughes, or subconsciously being shown the emotional beats through director Chris Columbus’ choice of visual metaphors.</p><p>Through these choices, the team behind this family-friendly movie demonstrates that this type of media can entertain the kids and give them a quality story. <em>Home Alone</em> manages to be incredibly meaningful because every piece of it is deeply deliberate and respects its child audience.</p><p>Let’s dig into how <em>Home Alone </em>accomplishes this.</p><h3>The Child Protagonist Is Treated Like A Person</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S44yfZc5RtE2Zq8QzxdHlw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most kid-centric films use young main characters to check off a box. They say “Kids like kid characters, so we need a kid character” without fleshing them out. Protagonists in these films tend to be comedic relief or something to be taken care of by other characters.</p><p>Unlike those films, <em>Home Alone</em>’s Kevin McCallister (played by McCauley Culkin) is the centerpiece of the story. Like his previous films, John Hughes respects Kevin as a character and gives him a fulfilling character arc.</p><p>In the beginning, Kevin dislikes his family for “crapping on him” all the time and even goes so far as to wish they would disappear. After this wish is allegedly granted, he irresponsibly seeks out everything denied to him, eating ice cream for dinner while watching a violent movie and running while screaming his head off through the house.</p><p>But he finds these things to be temporary fun and that the outside world is very scary.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/853/1*6FxcWUZzDlr8hc3qOMR08w.png" /></figure><p>Kevin continually runs away from his problems, physically and metaphorically. He refuses to go into his basement because the furnace is frightening. His first encounters with burglars Harry and Marv and his scary neighbor, Old Man Marley, result in him hiding under the bed and accidentally stealing a toothbrush as he flees.</p><p>At this point, Kevin is cowardly and more concerned about keeping the world away from him instead of facing it. Slowly, he gains his courage, first by telling the furnace to shut up and, in the end, allowing Harry and Marv to enter his home so he can fight back. He lets his fears inside his safe spaces and comes out victorious, more mature, and appreciative of what he has.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*ERkLl5UOZ3PmNkXyWQ0XwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Hughes treats his child protagonist like a person worthy of growth. <em>Home Alone</em> is not a morality tale where kids are told the lesson, they are shown the benefits of being brave and growing up through Kevin’s actions.</p><p>Truly, it’s a perfect example of how to write a story for kids. Respect for one’s young audience and characters is an essential step towards meaningful children’s media. When one adds the cinematography to this analysis, this film gets even better.</p><h3>The Adults are Placed on Equal Footing</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/792/1*PRDta9l0qPY9cZnlDh40kg.jpeg" /></figure><p>My favorite part of <em>Home Alone</em> is the parallels between Kevin and Marley, both visually and narratively. They are antagonistic towards each other, but conclude as friends and equals creating the film’s most meaningful moments. What’s even better is that their journey towards equal footing is largely shown through Chris Columbus’ chosen camera angles and visual metaphors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*oI4sYHNLuxv9hAA-y80ojw.jpeg" /></figure><p>When the audience is introduced to Marley, he is shown from above. Kevin and his brothers are physically and metaphorically looking down on him for his rumored killings. It shows that Kevin sees Marley as lowly, something to be feared. Right away, the audience is meant to see this old man as unpleasant.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*tu5i9c3a1CfRur90QXM6Ug.jpeg" /></figure><p>Marley is then shown from below in his next encounter with Kevin. The camera first focuses on his heavily bandaged hand and then shifts to his face from a worm’s eye view. He towers over Kevin and becomes even scarier because of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*HdmUpUPiyoch7qjW10SSOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The audience sees these two characters flip between high and low angles, visually creating a sense of conflict. Beautifully, the camera never allows Kevin and Marley to physically see eye-to-eye.</p><p>That all changes when <em>Home Alone</em> takes the audience to church. Here, the two characters are mostly shown together at the same camera angle. Both have come to this holy place because they’re “feeling bad” about themselves, though Marley doesn’t admit it initially, and they teach each other lessons.</p><p>Marley helps Kevin by putting his feelings into words:</p><blockquote>“How you feel about your family is a complicated thing. […] sometimes you can forget you love them.”</blockquote><p>Likewise, Kevin helps Marley by encouraging him to be brave and talk to his estranged son:</p><blockquote>“All this time I’ve been worrying about, but if you turn on the lights, it’s no big deal.”</blockquote><p>This is brilliant because it visually shows that these two have things to offer the other. They are no longer</p><p>flip-flopping between camera angles, they’re now on an equal plane.</p><p>Additionally, this interaction ends with a close-up of Kevin and Marley shaking hands, but this time, Marley’s wound is covered with a small band-aid. His hand is a subtle metaphor that the two are healing together; their pain can now be handled by something small. Simply put, it’s stunning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4qe_cfH_NZs02CB3PSZ7rQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>What other family film takes this much care to show adults and children as autonomous beings? It’s an uncommon practice, but adds so much. Once again, <em>Home Alone</em> demonstrates that a family film can be well-made, and perhaps, also that they should.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o1Sqd26ypv6L5-IugvUmaA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kid’s media has a lot stacked against it. This idea that it can’t be good creates a sort of circular logic where studios will take advantage to churn out less quality products that will do better at the box office.</p><p>In my opinion, this is partially why there are so many reboots and reimaginings of popular family-friendly films. Children simply aren’t respected as consumers of stories and are expected to only want entertainment.</p><p>But just because this is reality doesn’t mean it should be. The only reason I can discuss a 33-year-old film like <em>Home Alone</em> is because it was made with passion and pride. I think a lot of adults overlook that their favorite childhood films stick around for decades because they are quality works of art.</p><p>Children may have less experience and knowledge doesn’t mean that the pitfalls of their media should be dismissed. Kid’s media can absolutely be well-written and meaningful, but only if audiences stop making excuses for it.</p><p>Your kids deserve nice things.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8f3d25e44a6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Complicated Masculinity of Early Nickelback Songs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/the-complicated-masculinity-of-nickelback-songs-749feb9befb3?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/749feb9befb3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nickelback]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[song-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-roles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Nov 2023 18:02:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-24T14:43:04.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Good And Bad That Make The ‘Nickelback Mystique’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*SepSIbJv9WMvXH53QIrYaw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Note: This is a part of a zine called ‘Nickelback November’ which includes more essays and other Nickelback content. A copy of the zine can be found </em><a href="https://ko-fi.com/lukewhenderson/shop"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>One of the reasons I connected with Nickelback in the early 2000s was because of their heartfelt lyrics. Their music was heavy, but also vulnerable without the performative sadness used by other alternative bands.</p><p>‘How You Remind Me’ was a stark contrast from the masculine fame and fortune rock music of the past and, in my opinion, could have been another factor in why the band was hated so virulently.</p><p>The new millennium saw a rise in rock music that centered more on emotions, heartache, and suicidal thoughts. These musicians also wore eyeliner, fishnets, and androgynous hairstyles, the result being their music and personas being coded as feminine.</p><p>Despite this being a similar aesthetic to 1980s groups such as Motley Crue and Guns N’ Roses, these bands committed the cardinal sin of being popular primarily among teenage girls. Sadly, society has long had disdain for anything young women like and will accuse it of being inferior or silly.</p><p>And teens are extremely aware when this occurs, even today. A recent article by a Pennsylvania high school student <a href="https://theforeword.org/1240/editorials/society-hates-teen-girls/">revealed</a>:</p><p>“Throughout my youth, the things that I and many other girls enjoyed and consumed were often heavily critiqued by both men and other young women. I particularly remember during the peak of Justin Bieber’s popularity, when I was in elementary school, there was almost an equal amount of girls who’d make fun of other girls for liking him as there were actual fans of him.”</p><p>This quote also mirrors my experience. As a teen in the 2000s, it felt like a particularly hostile time for music, as bands like Fall Out Boy, My Chemical Romance, and Dashboard Confessional were constantly criticized or, shocker, called “gay”. I would secretly listen to these bands on my iPod, but then regrettably participate in the negative discourse to avoid suspicion (I really should have known I was nonbinary sooner, folks).</p><p>In the middle of everything was Nickelback, who were not emo and didn’t follow any of that culture’s aesthetics, but they did have similarly emotional music. With a criticism circuit already primed to hate depressing alternative rock, Nickelback likely got swept up into this wave and would eventually contribute to their reputation.</p><p>As I discussed in my essay on Nickelback hate, the band’s straying appearance was a focus of many criticisms, and their music dove into topics foreign to rock and roll, like emo bands. Them brushing against this certainly didn’t help.</p><p>But, that topic has been discussed to death, by me as well. Instead of discussing why gendered views contributed to Nickelback’s infamy, I want to explore the complicated picture painted by their first five albums.</p><p>Unlike the feminine presentation during this age of rock music, Nickelback took an interesting turn on masculinity.</p><h3>The Nickelback Mystique</h3><p>Unlike emo bands, Nickelback’s early successes were primarily masculine in topic, but it didn’t focus on superficial things like girls, cars, and money. These songs explored topics like responsibility, hopelessness, and inability to live up to expectations, more specifically the expectations associated with manhood.</p><p><em>From ‘Leader of Men’</em></p><p><em>I am not a leader of men<br> Since I prefer to follow<br> Do you think I could have a drink?<br> Since it’s so hard to swallow<br> Yeah, so hard to swallow</em></p><p><em>Turn your television off<br> And I will sing a song<br> And if you suddenly have the urge<br> You can sing along</em></p><p><em>From ‘Worthy to Say’</em></p><p><em>I’ll never do it again (No I won’t)<br> Let’s settle it (We don’t)<br> I can’t afford my life cause I’m spending it<br> Since you got just what you wanted</em></p><p>Overall, these songs are highly individualistic, using a lot of first-person narrative, and swims around the traits associated with men, but it’s also very raw. Chad’s voice delivers stories of inadequacy and wanting to be another face in the crowd instead of the man on the pedestal.</p><p>Their music, in most cases, lies somewhere between masculine and feminine. In many ways, Nickelback is a breath of fresh air for encouraging healthy masculinity, but they also fell short in others.</p><p>For the sake of jokes, I’ll call this nuanced blend the ‘Nickelback Mystique’. What building blocks make it? What is good about the band’s gender-defying display of emotions and what is a bit worrisome?</p><h3>The Good Kind</h3><p>Many boys are discouraged from tangling with their emotions and sitting down to process what they’re truly experiencing. Nickelback provides an excellent counter-discourse to his.</p><p>Despite accusations of being commercial drivel, their biggest hit, ‘How You Remind Me’, is one of the best examples of this. This song documents a journey of leaving a toxic relationship and the lyric’s protagonist questions “Are we having fun yet?”</p><p>The song is about feeling worthless and having a romantic partner that “reminds” them about that constantly. It’s in the chorus that this character takes all of these emotions and realizes they’ve “been wrong” and that the emotions they’re feeling are bad and this relationship has to stop.</p><p>And this style of songwriting isn’t limited to their smash hit. ‘Figured You Out’ and ‘Too Bad’ also follow a story of discovery and accepting one’s negative emotions. Nickelback doesn’t only write about deeper emotions often pushed aside by men, they show the necessity of working through them.</p><p>At the same time, the journey is hyper-focused on individual growth. The protagonist doesn’t reach out to family and friends to heal, they find their own medication and overcome it.</p><p>These tunes manage to feel masculine without falling into the trappings of blame and ignorance. To some listeners, I’m sure this came across as weak and girly, but having empathetic rock music during this time was a blessing for kids like me.</p><p>If this was the only facet of masculinity they explored, I would safely say Nickelback’s music is one of the best examples of positive masculinity and male vulnerability. Unfortunately, there is an aggressive, possessive side to some of their catalog.</p><h3>The Bad Kind</h3><p>There are a few concerning songs that interweave the darker sides of masculinity. None of these actively encourage abuse or anything close to it, but they are a huge contrast to their empathetic one.</p><p>A few of Nickelback’s songs express anger in fairly violent terms. While these are valid emotions, the response from the lyrics falls back onto the idea of men using their fists to right any wrongs.</p><p><em>From ‘Just For’</em></p><p><em>I want to take his eyes out<br> Just for looking at you<br> Yes I do<br> I want to take his hands off<br> Just for touching you<br> Yes I do<br> And I want to rip his heart out<br> Just for hurting you<br> And I want to break his mind down<br> Yes I do</em></p><p><em>From ‘Next Contestant’</em></p><p><em>I judge by what she’s wearing<br> Just how many heads I’m tearing<br> Off of assholes coming on to her<br> Each night seems like it’s getting worse<br> And I wish she’d take the night off<br> So I don’t have to fight off<br> Every asshole coming on to her<br> It happens every night she works</em></p><p>Even in one of their hit singles that explores domestic violence, ‘Never Again’, a bit of revenge fantasy leaks into the lyrics.</p><p><em>Father’s a name you haven’t earned yet<br> You’re just a child with a temper<br> Haven’t you heard “Don’t hit a lady”?<br> Kicking’ your ass would be a pleasure</em></p><p>Using aggression to punish domestic violence is contradictory to the message of this song. These are likely genuine emotions that Chad Kroeger felt about this subject, but it’s a sad departure from Nickelback’s other lyrics that show emotional depth.</p><p>While the band has no issue placing their deepest feelings onto the song sheet, they still cling to the idea of a man’s role as defender of women. The personal journey on display doesn’t seem to extend to other men if they’re hurting someone’s partner.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Nickelback’s themes of masculinity in their early work aren’t perfect, but that’s okay. They paint a realistic portrait of a man trying to grapple with intense emotions; a difficult journey with mistakes abound. Regardless, there’s still a lot to be gained through discussing these songs.</p><p>In a time when rock fans seemed divided between aggressive metal and allegedly feminine alternative, they sat somewhere in the middle and created something unique. In retrospect, Nickelback’s form of masculinity provided a touch of positive introspection for others to grow on.</p><p>Though it pains me to hear the occasional “I’m going to kick your ass”, I’m still thankful for their willingness to let their hearts bleed into their music.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=749feb9befb3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Photograph” Threatens Me Personally: The Deeper Reasons Behind Nickelback’s Notorious Reputation…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/photograph-threatens-me-personally-the-deeper-reasons-behind-nickelbacks-notorious-reputation-04b1e31b4954?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/04b1e31b4954</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[haters]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meme-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nickelback]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Nov 2023 18:01:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-15T18:01:11.864Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“Photograph” Threatens Me Personally: The Deeper Reasons Behind Nickelback’s Notorious Reputation and How it May Have Backfired</h3><p>Why The Nickelback Hate? Could It Have Some Deeper Meaning?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*yz2smzO9lnUsJIIO4Aax0g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Note: This is a part of a zine called ‘Nickelback November’ which includes more essays and other Nickelback content. A copy of the zine can be found </em><a href="https://ko-fi.com/lukewhenderson/shop"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>I was a proud Nickelback fan as a child, even though I was a minority opinion. This isn’t necessarily a flex, it was mostly a pre-teen/teen desire to stand out among my friends. I genuinely liked the band, but I can’t deny that it felt a bit countercultural as well.</p><p>Nickelback hate was always on my radar, but I truly wasn’t aware of how bad it had been over the years. I remember things like the Facebook page “Can This Pickle Get More Likes than Nickleback” existing, but not the more outlandish stunts.</p><p>I didn’t know that the band’s Wikipedia was constantly vandalized in 2009, that a petition was started to remove them from a Thanksgiving day NFL halftime show in 2011 (which I watched), or that the singer of the Black Keys, Patrick Carney, <a href="http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/the-rise-of-the-black-keys-20120119">claimed</a> in a 2012 Rolling Stone interview “Rock and roll is dying because people became O.K. with Nickelback being the biggest band in the world.”</p><p>Bluntly put, it was terrible and highly undeserved. Nickelback was not a group that ever should have generated this much vitriol, but they did.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Hating Nickelback is a meme on its last legs and this question isn’t new. There are dozens of YouTube videos and articles on the topic, but most of these focus on tangible, logical reasons, and a good number are written by people who don’t like Nickelback.</p><p>I want this essay to be an in-depth look from someone who is a legitimate fan of the band. I want to find out why people claim they hate Nickelback, what the actual reasons might be, and the impact of this decades-long trend while exploring this debate in a nuanced way that’s been severely lacking.</p><h3>How the Hate Started</h3><p>Upon the release of “How You Remind Me” on September 11, 2001 (ouch), Nickelback blew up rapidly. It was their first song to <a href="https://www.stereogum.com/2201620/the-number-ones-nickelbacks-how-you-remind-me/columns/the-number-ones/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CHow%20You%20Remind%20Me%E2%80%9D%20reached,hit%20of%20the%20entire%20&#39;00s.">make</a> the <em>Billboard Hot 100</em> and reached #1 by December. <em>Billboard</em> later named it the #1 single of 2002.</p><p>Adding to this, Chad Kroeger’s song “Hero” was selected as the anthem for Sam Raimi’s blockbuster <em>Spider-man</em> and became a top 5 hit. Just a year later, the group’s song “Someday” would become the #7 song in the nation. Within a short period, Nickelback was dominating the radio.</p><p>“[W]e write so many different kinds of music, I think that if you were listening to a radio station any time between 2000 and 2010, […] we were kind of tough to get away from. [I]f you didn’t wanna hear it and you changed to a different radio station, you’d probably hear it on there […].”</p><p>- Chad Kroeger via <a href="https://blabbermouth.net/news/chad-kroeger-explains-how-nickelback-became-one-of-the-most-hated-rock-bands-in-the-world">Blabbermouth</a></p><p>By the end of the decade, “How You Remind Me” would be played 1.2 million times (almost 330 times a day) making it the <a href="https://www.mtv.com/news/qf2ywy/eminem-is-the-best-selling-artist-of-the-decade">most-played song</a> of the decade. Couple this with the fact that critics such as <em>Rolling Stone</em> and <em>Entertainment Weekly</em> <a href="https://www.albumoftheyear.org/album/16258-nickelback-silver-side-up.php">rated</a> the album poorly, to many it seemed like a bad song was getting too much airplay. Later independent statistical work suggests that when comparing radio play to critical reception, this could be the case.</p><p>Some people <em>really</em> didn’t like this and turned towards aggressive jokes on the band’s inescapable songs. One of those was comedian Brian Posehn on Comedy Central’s <em>Tough Crowd with Colin Quinn</em> who, when discussing recent studies on music and violence, quipped “No one talks about the studies that show that bad music makes people violent, but listening to Nickelback makes me want to kill Nickelback.” This joke would later become part of an advertisement for the show.</p><p>Singer Chad Kroeger believes this is the true starting point. He <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ak6yi02i_Q8">explained</a> on the <em>Barstool Sports’</em> KFC Radio podcast:</p><p>“[It] played on Comedy Central for six months straight, this Nickelback joke. That starts this whole thing going. That’s where it really started, at that one moment. And then it started making its way into movies and we get all this stuff.”</p><p>This would make sense as there was a cable television boom in the early 2000s. According to the Los Angeles Times, 59% of households <a href="https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2003-apr-22-fi-comedy22-story.html">had</a> cable or satellite TV in 1990, but by the beginning of the millennium, 80% of them had it. Cable networks also saw their profits skyrocket from $2.5 billion to $14.5 billion.</p><p>Because of this, Comedy Central was acquired by Viacom in 2003 due to its cult-like following among the younger generation (which advertisers loved) and it being one of the only channels to regularly feature TV-MA-rated material. This was the era of hugely popular shows <em>The Chappelle Show</em>, <em>Reno 911,</em> and <em>Comedy Central Presents</em>, so six months of ads featuring Nickelback hate very likely had an impact.</p><p>However, no one with grievances against the band cites these advertisements as their reason for their negative feelings. While Colin Quinn may have sparked the idea, the reasons Nickelback haters claim move beyond it.</p><h3>The Alleged Why of the Hate</h3><p>Ask a Nickelback hater why they despise this band so much and one will receive a laundry list of reasons, but it can generally be reduced to two. Neither of these is the true, genuine reason, but should be addressed regardless.</p><p><em>They are bland, uninspired copycats</em></p><p>The first thing most claim is that Nickelback’s music is milquetoast and copies from better grunge and alternative acts without delivering something new. Some even claim that they copy their own material.</p><p>In the summer of 2007, flash videos playing Nickelback’s hit singles “How You Remind Me” and “Someday” side-by-side were shared widely claiming they were essentially the same song. In August of that year, a version of this titled ‘Nickelback Doesn’t Change’ was <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qs4tNeGyTyI">uploaded</a> to YouTube where it still receives comments from haters. This video is often cited as proof that Nickelback songs are bland and lazy copies of each other.</p><p>Unfortunately, for these people, I majored in music and am a music theory nerd. The conclusions from these comparisons are wrong for a variety of reasons, but for the sake of argument, I will approach this as a genuine piece of evidence.</p><p>When I took a closer look at the chord progressions here’s what I noticed (don’t worry if you don’t know music theory, I’ll explain):</p><p><em>How You Remind Me — Verse Chords</em></p><p>Cm — Fm — Bb — Eb</p><p>vi — ii — V — I</p><p><em>Someday — Verse Chords</em></p><p>Bm — G — A — D</p><p>vi — IV — V — I</p><p>Right away, there are some similarities between the two and if you’re a music theory nerd (which I doubt many of Nickelback’s critics are) you could argue these are the same chord progressions. The ‘ii’ chord and the ‘IV’ chord are often substituted for each other because they share two notes. The ‘ii’ is sometimes used because of its darker sound and adds a bit of flavor to a standard progression.</p><p>But, if one continues to the chorus this song begins to diverge.</p><p><em>How You Remind Me — Chorus Chords</em></p><p>Cm — Eb — Bb — Fm</p><p>vi — I — V — ii</p><p><em>Someday — Chorus Chords</em></p><p>G — D — A — D — G — A — B — A</p><p>IV — I — V — I — IV — V — vi — V</p><p>It should be clear without music theory knowledge that these aren’t the same. The progression in “How You Remind Me” is a simple four-chord one, while “Someday” is more complicated and moves around.</p><p>Even if they were the same, using similar chord progressions doesn’t make a song bad when compared to others. If this were the case, then most of Blink-182’s catalog would be bad and one would have to say Nirvana’s “Rape Me” is bad because it follows a similar progression to “Smells Like Teen Spirit”.</p><p>Songs have to be critiqued holistically. While the verses of these two songs are similar, these songs as a whole as very different. “How You Remind Me” concerns a toxic relationship where the protagonist is reminded how worthless they are by their partner and “Someday” is a song about hope and finding a way to forgive within a relationship.</p><p>They are near tonal opposites. This is why “How You Remind Me” relies on that ‘ii’ chord rather than the ‘IV’, it’s a sadder song and requires a minor sound.</p><p>Also, these two songs don’t represent the band’s entire catalog. Many detractors using this argument only seem to reference their radio hits, but not their entire albums. Nickelback has songs about drinking and partying, but also domestic abuse, long-distance relationships, and absentee fathers.</p><p>Nickelback may not have as much variety in tempo, rhythm, or lyrics as other bands, but that hasn’t caused people to decry Bruce Springsteen or AC/DC who similarly have less diversity in their compositions. Overall, this is a matter of taste that’s oddly being served as objective fact and just silly.</p><p><em>They got undeserved opportunities that better bands should have had</em></p><p>Another common argument is that Nickelback received more attention and funding than other deserving acts. Also, they were signed because of their ability to make radio-friendly hits that would rake in the cash. Except… that’s not quite true.</p><p>Nickelback signed to Roadrunner Records in 1999 at the tail end of a <a href="https://www.metalsucks.net/2022/04/25/the-burning-red-a-complete-history-of-roadrunner-records-pt-1-1981-2012/">massive expansion</a> outside of the label’s thrash and metal markets. This expansion and German music company called edel <a href="https://hitsdailydouble.com/news&amp;id=274672&amp;title=ROADRUNNER-LANDS-ATISLAND-DEF-JAM">phoning</a> in a $17 million debt would ultimately cause huge financial strains forcing them to sell a controlling stake to the Island Def Jam Music Group.</p><p>Roadrunner put the controlling stake on sale months into recording Nickelback’s <em>Silver Side Up</em> and it wasn’t bought until a month after they finished. Though comment from the band isn’t available on this situation, one can imagine it was extremely stressful. Would their label even have the money to release this album?</p><p>Before this, Roadrunner had been largely riding on the coattails of Slipknot, who was a platinum-selling group with great critic reviews and a cult following. Nickelback, on the other hand, was a hard rock band, entering a metal space, a group that took label A&amp;R man Ron Burman three months to <a href="https://rockitboy.com/nickelback-gets-signed-by-roadrunner-records-rock-it-boy-was-there-2/">convince</a> his bosses to sign them.</p><p>It seems like the label wasn’t enthusiastic about Nickelback and didn’t expect them to be a cash cow. Everything just kind of happened when ‘How You Remind Me’ blew up on the radio.</p><p>And even then, the wealth wasn’t shared with them at first. Kroeger’s then-attorney <a href="https://loudwire.com/chad-kroeger-nickelback-made-no-money-how-you-remind-me-silver-side-up/?utm_source=tsmclip&amp;utm_medium=referral">said</a> in an interview on the <em>Sticks and Stones</em> podcast “At the time, for us, I don’t think we’d made a ton of money. I don’t think that I’d seen a dollar from proceeds of “How You Remind Me” or the record sales of <em>Silverside Up</em>” with Kroeger adding “And any touring we were doing, we were probably just breaking even because you gotta pay for the bus, you gotta pay for the employees. At no point in time had we seen a check that was like, ‘Huh! What do you wanna buy?’ I just remember thinking, ‘I’m moving.’”</p><p>This story of Nickelback being a plug-and-play band for profit is goofy and incorrect. And if one is being truthful, if Nickelback hadn’t signed to Roadrunner Records, many bands on the label who were only cracking 100,000 sold per release (while Nickelback was selling millions) wouldn’t have had funding to continue. Nickelback’s success was unexpected and beneficial for heavy metal and rock music as a whole.</p><p>But as I said, these aren’t really the underlying issues that cause Nickelback hate. Further research suggests it is much more personal.</p><h3>The True Why</h3><p>What many Nickelback haters don’t realize, or don’t want to admit, is that their disdain for the band is more emotional than logical. It wasn’t because the band was too commercial, copycat songwriters, or a bunch of grizzly dudes with guitars thrown in a blender to poop out money.</p><p>It was that the band represented a threat to their identities as independent music fans with good taste or fans of anti-establishment music. This discomfort led them down a rabbit hole of near-conspiracy levels of justification for their hatred.</p><p>During the early 2000s, there was a weird culture of hating any music artist deemed too commercial, not being worthy, or stealing from coveted rock and alternative circles. While Nickelback was the poster child for this, other artists also had odd beliefs crafted to explain their popularity.</p><p>I distinctly remember rumors about Paris Hilton’s 2006 single “Stars are Blind” where she was accused of not actually singing the song and buying herself a radio hit for… reasons. Like Nickelback, she was accused of getting unearned or undeserved success.</p><p>This quote <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/hate-saved-nickelback#:~:text=And%20so%20the%20band&#39;s%20music,Nickelback%20was%20rock&#39;s%20black%20hole.">from</a> Ian Crouch writing for <em>The New Yorker</em> explains this idea fairly well:</p><p>“[Detractors believe] liking the band could not be the result of an active human decision: that everything about the band is, in effect, a default setting — sound blasted out by commercial radio run by robots. […] It <em>felt</em> true: it was hard to hear the band’s polished repetition as anything more than hard-rock background noise. And so, the band’s music was dangerous because of its very harmlessness; its success suggested that rock fans could be swindled or lulled into liking anything, meaning that the genre itself had been rendered obsolete.”</p><p>While rock and metal fans love a good contrarian, they also, contradictorily, have strict expectations of how a rockstar should be; Chad Kroeger and co. didn’t fit comfortably into any previous mold musically or physically. Though most describe the band as post-grunge, they weren’t quite grunge, not quite metal, country, or pop either.</p><p>According to a <a href="https://uefconnect.uef.fi/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Hypocritical_bullshit_performed_through.pdf">study</a> done by a Finnish Ph.D. student, critical feedback suggests a belief that the band’s music is “inter-contradictory” and contains “confusing combinations” to typical metal music. They were a blend of a lot of influences, which is cool, but to die-hard metalheads and grunge fans likely came across as cheap and copying their deeply respected heroes.</p><p>The band also didn’t follow any particular rock and roll aesthetic. For the most part, they looked like normal men with guitars which some saw as an awful disconnect.</p><p>Chad Kroeger, in particular, has been criticized for decades about his appearance. He was <a href="https://loudwire.com/nickelback-chad-kroeger-reason-cut-his-hair-short/">voted</a> the ugliest person in rock by readers of Kerrang in 2002, his hairstyle was constantly discussed, and many have called him “self-important” among other names because of his looks.</p><p>Even in 2016, well after the singer had cut his signature curly locks, people and critics were still talking about it:</p><p>“It’s not that Kroeger looks bad, it’s just that his <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2016/08/18/chad-kroeger-hair_n_11594088.html">goofy dyed-blonde hair</a> and cheesy goatee don’t match his grizzled rocker persona.”</p><p>Because the band didn’t match the sounds and flamboyant personas of rockers past, they became an easy target and eventually a symbol of everything these haters loathed: commercialism and inauthentic music. Sadly, this seems to reflect more on these fans than it does on the band.</p><p>Rock critics have long used boogiemen to justify that their music is more authentic than what’s on the radio. Unlike New Kids on the Block or Britney Spears, Nickelback happened to wear some of the dressings of rock and roll and be signed to a heavy metal label, therefore, they committed a deeper sin.</p><p>But the vitriol aimed at these villains isn’t a marker of universal taste, it is constructed to validate heavy metal fans as being independent and free from market forces. In the previously mentioned Finnish study, it concluded: “[Nickelback’s alleged] artificiality is highlighted so that the rest [of music] would seem more real, and to conceal the perception that all music is artificial.”</p><p>Nickelback represents what psychologists <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nyla-Branscombe/publication/254784791_The_context_and_content_of_social_identity_threat/links/54b57c3d0cf2318f0f99e342/The-context-and-content-of-social-identity-threat.pdf">call</a> a social identity threat. These can be broken down into four categories, but the one most relevant here is distinctiveness threat.</p><p>Studies have shown that having distinct identities (like being a metalhead) provides people with meaning and if they are threatened by comparison to another group (like Nickelback fans) they, sadly, turn to things such as discrimination to set themselves apart. Some studies suggest that having a strong, distinct identity may be more important than a positive identity when faced with a threat.</p><p>Hating Nickelback seems to be an overblown response to rock, metal, and alternative music gaining mass appeal and suddenly being compared to other types of music. What’s scary about this is how much this construction of Nickelback being the killers of rock and roll (or at least puppets to do so) is how much it overlaps with conspiracy theory thinking.</p><p>Video essayist Sophie from Mars explains in her <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZyIjBxxpTY">video</a>, <em>Conspiracy on the Left</em>, that conspiracy thinking, while presenting itself as logical, is actually “rooted in intuitive thinking, that is to say, emotional thinking” and often not the result of empirically-driven facts, but what others around these people think (normative similarities) and how well it fits with their knowledge of history (historical similarities). These emotional reactions also tend to be representative of inter-group conflicts between an ambiguous enemy and the believer’s in-group.</p><p>In my research, the line “How is Nickelback so popular, I don’t know anyone who actually listens to them” came up repeatedly suggesting that haters felt their point of view to be normative. They also expressed beliefs that these record labels copied their grunge and metal idols to make a quick buck because supposedly it’s happened in the past.</p><p>For Nickelback haters, these beliefs represent a continual fight between “true” music fans and shady record companies who pump out junk for profit on the radio. Hating Nickelback is merely a coping mechanism to make these haters feel better about themselves and signal that they can’t be bought like the masses.</p><p>In short, these haters want to be special little boys and Nickelback came too close to their special little boyhood. But was it worth it?</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Despite, and maybe because of, all of their reasons and justifications, Nickelback hater’s emotional posturing may have given this band a longevity they wouldn’t have acquired otherwise. Chad Kroeger even admitted this in 2014:</p><p>“If they had stopped writing all this stuff about us, there would be no controversy left in the band and we probably would have died out years ago.”</p><p>In one aspect, it seems to have motivated the band to do better. Kroeger confessed in 2007 that they were constantly told “We’ll never, ever have another big record like [<em>Silver Side Up</em>] again and our career would probably decline and then we’d probably just trail off and that would be the end of Nickelback. I didn’t want to accept that.”</p><p>What does a rock band do when they’re told they can’t do something? They say f — k you and create something. The years of hate likely kept Nickelback feeling like they had to prove themselves and were doing something truly rock and roll.</p><p>However, a young internet and the emergence of meme culture is likely what kept Nickelback in the public consciousness. The band’s archive on <em>Know Your Meme</em> sports nearly 400,000 images, some from this year. That’s nearly 50 memes a day from the time “How You Remind Me” blew up.</p><p>Logically, it would make sense for Nickelback to stay popular when the internet was bombarded as much with hate memes as the airwaves were with Nickelback singles. It has also been empirically demonstrated as early as 2020 that the memes boosted their fame.</p><p>In 2020, former president Trump tweeted a dated meme from the group’s music video for “Photograph” that was meant to show some alleged misdeeds or cover-ups by the Biden administration. Nickelback’s digital downloads <a href="https://www.distractify.com/p/what-happened-to-nickelback">saw</a> a 500% increase afterward.</p><p>Just think about how much this happened in the heyday of their hate. How many people stumbled on Nickelback or downloaded a song because they were curious about this band?</p><p>Hating Nickelback will likely never die out completely as a meme, and attempts to replace them as the most hated band have fallen flat (<a href="https://metalinjection.net/gossip/corey-taylor-says-imagine-dragons-are-the-new-nickelback#:~:text=Corey%20Taylor%20Says%20IMAGINE%20DRAGONS%20Are%20The%20New%20NICKELBACK,-Robert%20Pasbani&amp;text=Corey%20Taylor%20famously%20feuded%20with,to%20write%20a%20hit%20song.">sorry</a> Corey Taylor, Imagine Dragons will probably be fine). This phenomenon was, and kind of still is, the result of a lot of early internet culture and television media that is unique to a certain era. A mass dumping such as this may never be experienced again.</p><p>But this also means that ardent despisers will continue to lose the fight inside their heads and keep Nickelback relevant. As a fan of their music, that sounds good to me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=04b1e31b4954" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Figure You Out’ is Nickelback’s Best Song. Fight Me.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@lukewhenderson/figure-you-out-is-nickelback-s-best-song-fight-me-c23f99ac20c9?source=rss-a6deeb9c2e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c23f99ac20c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nickelback]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[denial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chad-kroeger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-long-road]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke W. Henderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Nov 2023 18:02:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-08T18:02:05.124Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How The Song Makes Clever Twists And Turns On The Theme Of Denial</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*rxgQKHhqFXisRbVCqC3YDw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Note: This is a part of a zine called ‘Nickelback November’ which includes more essays and other Nickelback content. A copy of the zine can be found </em><a href="https://ko-fi.com/lukewhenderson/shop"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Nickelback’s fourth album, <em>The Long Road</em>, is their best, in my opinion. It’s got an excellent mix of heavy hitters and laid-back tunes with lyrics that feel very grounded. Though ‘Someday’ became the star of the show, I’d argue that ‘Figure You Out’ is better because of its creative lyrical structure and how the music perfectly mimics the lyrics.</p><p>Allow me to demonstrate by starting at the beginning.</p><p>The song begins without introduction. Chad Kroeger’s vocals start before the guitars can even strum a note. Whatever the protagonist of this song has to say, they can’t wait, the words are spilling out.</p><p>Then the music enters with a catchy ostinato (fancy music speak for a repeating rhythm). The guitars play in octaves instead of typical power chords making everything feel lighter and more open.</p><p>At the same time, the chord progression seems to avoid a tonal center; it doesn’t fit neatly into a minor or major key. In a way, the music is a blank slate and the mood is a mystery. Without these sonic clues, the listener must turn to the lyrics.</p><p><em>I like your pants around your feet<br> And I like the dirt that’s on your knees<br> And I like the way you still say “Please”<br> While you’re looking up at me<br> You’re like my favorite damn disease</em></p><p><em>And I love the places that we go<br> And I love the people that you know<br> And I love the way you can’t say “No”<br> Too many long lines in a row<br> I love the powder on your nose</em></p><p>On the surface, these seem like happy love song lyrics but there are a few oddities. “I like” is paired with things like “dirt” and “disease”, things that are usually undesirable, but the protagonist claims these are their favorite parts. Here, the listener is still swimming in nebulousness.</p><p>This changes quickly in the second part of the verse. The ostinato becomes dirtier, the guitars unmuted and moving to familiar power chords with harmonics (pure notes made by lightly touching the strings) in-between the established rhythm. The protagonist switches to “I love” for each line, like their affections have become more intense, and fiercer.</p><p>Pair this with the previous lyrics and it seems that this song is about a protagonist who deeply loves their partner, makeup-covered warts and all. At this point, one has to take this at face value.</p><p>But things shake up when the chorus arrives:</p><p><em>And now I know who you are<br> It wasn’t that hard<br> Just to figure you out<br> (Now I did, you wonder why)<br> And now I know who you are<br> It wasn’t that hard<br> Just to figure you out<br> (Now I did, you wonder why)</em></p><p>What does the protagonist know? What changed in their relationship with this partner? If one listens to the music, it suggest things are getting complicated.</p><p>The chorus’ melody and chord progression finally suggest a major key. Most of the words fall within the I and V chord of B-flat major (these two chords <em>really</em> establish any key signature) and the melody outlines the notes within that B-flat chord. So, these first three lines are meant to be a happy moment.</p><p>But then that moment of joy is undercut by a single note outside of the key signature. An ‘E’ emerges on the word “out” and continues to invade during the line “Now I did, you wonder why”. Normally, E is an E-flat is this key.</p><p>This is interesting because it forms an interval us fancy music theory nerds call a tritone. It’s a crunchy, dissonant-sounding movement that jumps out at the listener. For centuries, this interval was <a href="https://www.npr.org/2017/10/31/560843189/the-unsettling-sound-of-tritones-the-devils-interval">called</a> “the devil’s interval” because of its ominous, unresolved sound.</p><p>Pair this with the quiet vocal distortion applied to Chad and Ryan’s voices and it’s apparent that something is unresolved and dark under the surface about this discovery.</p><p>Continuing, this alleged love between these two characters unravels more.</p><p><em>I like the freckles on your chest<br> And I like the way you like me best<br> And I like the way you’re not impressed<br> While you put me to the test<br> I like the white stains on your dress<br> And I love the way you pass the check<br> And I love the good times that you wreck<br> And I love your lack of self-respect<br> While you’re passed out on the deck<br> I love my hands around your neck</em></p><p>Wait, wait, wait, wait. This protagonist loves “the good times that [they] wreck” and their “lack of self-respect while you’re passed out on the deck”? Something is very wrong now. While the first verse could be interpreted as someone learning to adore another’s small flaws, these seem like major red flags. How can this character like these things?</p><p>When the chorus returns, another bit is tacked onto the tritone part, adding more darkness and mystery to the situation.</p><p><em>And now I know who you are<br> It wasn’t that hard<br> Just to figure you out<br> (Now I did, you wonder why)<br> And now I know who you are<br> It wasn’t that hard<br> Just to figure you out<br> (Now I did, you wonder why)<br> (Why not before, you never tried)<br> (Gone for good and this is it)</em></p><p>“Why not before, you never tried”? Who didn’t try? And “gone for good”? I thought these characters were in love despite everything.</p><p>And here’s where the real genius of Nickelback’s ‘Figure You Out’ is revealed.</p><p>The listener is given a repeat of the first verse but with muted guitars and minimalist drumming with short silences at the end of the phrase. The atmosphere is now intense; something is bubbling underneath the surface in this repetition.</p><p>Instead of flipping from “I like” to “I love”, it slams into “I hate”. Even though it’s nearly the same lyrics, their meaning has completely changed.</p><p><em>I like your pants around your feet<br> And I like the dirt that’s on your knees<br> And I like the way you still say “Please”<br> While you’re looking up at me<br> You’re like my favorite damn disease<br> And I hate the places that we go<br> And I hate the people that you know<br> And I hate the way you can’t say “No”<br> Too many long lines in a row<br> I hate the powder on your nose</em></p><p>The partner in this story is their “favorite damn disease” because they feel like something inescapable. Those “long lines” and “powder on your nose” weren’t little quirks or a bit of messy makeup, but likely a reference to drugs.</p><p>Because of everything that came before, this tiny change has completely changed the meaning of it’s lyrics. How many songs can claim to do that?</p><p>‘Figure You Out’ is a song about being in denial about a bad relationship. Its music and lyrics show this protagonist insisting, to themselves and everyone, they adore therse toxic behaviors. But, these feelings get harder and harder to push down until they finally burst forth.</p><p>This journey is why this song is Nickelback’s best. It manages to convey the mystery and inner turmoil of this situation through a marvelous marriage of music and words. Every choice, from melody and key signature to rhythm, perfectly encapsulates the idea and emotions of denial.</p><p>‘Figure You Out’ is a story where the listener is an active participant. They are squarely placed in the shoes of this character and get to feel every little crack in the façade until the big, crumbling twist.</p><p>At the same time, it isn’t obvious that one is listening to a tale of woe. There are no character names or places, just an experience. Though Nickelback with likely be immortalized for ‘How You Remind Me’ and other hits, it’s this little song, sitting in the background, that demonstrates the band’s true songwriting ability.</p><p>And if you don’t agree. Fight me (JK, please don’t).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c23f99ac20c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>