<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Maija Haavisto on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Maija Haavisto on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 02:23:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Myth of Personality Disorders Leads to Enormous Harm]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/the-myth-of-personality-disorders-leads-to-enormous-harm-0b503a65851d?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0b503a65851d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shame]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personality-disorders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychiatry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2026 13:23:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-10T13:25:24.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Trauma Keeps Us Using the Violent Label (Mostly as an Euphemism)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ss6IsuLhsG875DKk_wvUdA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Spenser H @ Unsplash.com</figcaption></figure><p>One of the most stigmatized diagnoses in psychiatry are the purported personality disorders. This is particularly heartbreaking considering they are nothing but a problematic label for fully healable <a href="https://www.openaccessjournals.com/articles/exploring-the-connection-between-trauma-and-personality-disorders.pdf">trauma responses</a>. Ironically, even the term itself arises from the trauma of the mental health system. Shame and dissociation play a major role in its perpetuation.</p><p>Though I explore some new perspectives and points here that I have not seen anywhere else, criticism of the concept of personality disorders is nothing new, it’s widespread from a variety of angles from feminist to psychodynamic. One of the most prominent voices has been Judith Lewis Herman, whose groundbreaking book <em>Trauma and Recovery</em> was published in 1992. I cite it at various points of this article.</p><p>While that book is outdated now, the notion of personality disorders is much more so. The standard DSM-5-TR classification for “mental disorders” recognizes ten different personality disorders,. The categorization has been largely unchanged since 1980 and predates our current understanding of trauma by decades.</p><p>The term “personality disorder” posits that the symptoms are enduring, likely permanent, and more intimately related to <em>personality</em> than those of other mental health issues. Much of current research <a href="https://psyche.co/ideas/theres-a-growing-case-for-renaming-personality-disorders">disagrees with those claims</a>.</p><p>Personality disorders are also a staggeringly ableist idea, based on the norm that people should exist in a certain way and any deviation from that must be pathological. Suggesting someone has a “disordered personality” because their trauma manifests in less socially acceptable ways than the trauma responses of others is deeply p<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/360939741_Death_By_A_Thousand_Cuts_Report_into_the_Tees_Esk_and_Wear_Valleys_NHS_Foundation_Trust_BPD_Protocol">roblematic and harmful</a>.</p><h4><strong>About This Article</strong></h4><p>A trauma therapist and disability activist, I’m also the author of multiple books on trauma, which illuminate its neglected societal dimensions, as well. Between 2006 and 2013, I wrote several scientific books on chronic illnesses in a wider sense. Several of those also explore societal aspects of the subject, such as stigma, marginalization, problematic nomenclature, medical gaslighting and misogyny, ignorance of scientific research and how these contribute to iatrogenic harm.</p><p>Large parts of this article are based on my free book <a href="https://lovingawakening.net/"><em>Shattered White-Out: How Trauma and Dissociation Mold the World, Your Relationships and You</em></a>. In it, I delve into many concepts introduced here in much more detail (also with many more citations).</p><p>For brevity reasons, I primarily focus on three of the purported personality disorders. Alas, it’s not possible to fully flesh out all my arguments in the limited space, as this article is already very lengthy. With the exception of book citations, I utilize more web-friendly inline citations rather than an academic endnote format, but most references are still academic sources.</p><p>Also, this piece handles many subjects and perspectives that can be highly triggering, including for mental health professionals. If you suddenly begin feeling upset or angry while reading, it could be helpful to tune inside to see what is really going on.</p><h4><strong>Parts of the Mind</strong></h4><p>An approach I often use for elucidating the intricacies of human mind is <em>parts</em>, originating from <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">Internal Family Systems</a>. A psychotherapeutic modality developed by family therapist Richard Schwartz in the 1980s, IFS is based on systems theory. Besides therapy, it can be used to explore the origins of feelings, behavior and interpersonal dynamics.</p><p>The key concept of IFS is that our minds are made up of parts, kinds of subpersonalities, which make us the incredibly complex and fascinating beings we are. Parts are why we sometimes act in ways “uncharacteristic” to us, why we may find ourselves doing things we don’t want to do (as with addictions or bad habits) or don’t do the things we want to do (like going to the gym or expressing our boundaries).</p><blockquote><em>“</em>There is a seemingly endless parade of sub-personalities within our total personality, all ready to take the stage and play their allotted roles. If one of these possible characters within us is denied his rightful prominence in the drama which is ourself he may stage a take-over or irruption.<em>”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>– Joseph Redfearn</em></blockquote><p>Parts may be linked to major traumas, or more minor issues that have been dubbed <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/contemporary-psychoanalysis-in-action/201506/micro-traumas-can-undermine-our-emotional-health">“microtrauma” or “small t trauma”</a>, though those also shape the personality to a surprising extent. Many parts correspond to trauma reactions correlated with autonomic nervous system responses such as fight, flight, freeze and fawn (people-pleasing). Though outside the scope of this piece, knowledge about the ANS also greatly facilitates understanding of different manifestations of trauma.</p><p>Our parts are in constant interaction with those of others. They are also what forms our <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/attachment-style-parts-and-internal-family-systems-3058f93bf72b">attachment style</a>. It’s not always helpful to reduce its complexity into a single label, but attachment trauma is closely connected with the kinds of presentations that get labeled as PDs. This goes especially for the turbulent and confusing <em>disorganized attachment</em>, where apparent clinginess alternates with severe dissociation and a strong urge to withdraw.</p><h4><strong>Parts Help Explain Different Types of Trauma Responses</strong></h4><p>IFS didn’t invent the notion of parts. Several other therapeutic modalities utilize them in a similar fashion, though most are less concerned with a systemic perspective. Carl Jung discussed complexes, archetypes and subpersonalities and the concept of Inner Child also originates from him. In IFS there is no one inner child, however, but rather one’s system tends to be full of parts stuck in childhood.</p><p>In the Internal Family Systems model, parts can be divided into three types. <em>Exiles</em> carry pain from past wounds and are guarded by protector parts, <em>managers</em> and <em>firefighters</em>, which try hard to stop the pain from coming to your attention. Managers have more rational approaches to this, while firefighters fight fire with fire and may escape into addictions or even self-harm.</p><p>In practice, this taxonomy tends to be too simplistic. I rarely use it in my work with therapy clients, but it can be helpful to illustrate trauma responses. For example, in people branded as “borderline”, you tend to see many firefighters, but also exiles at play. Our manager-led society gets very triggered by witnessing exiles in action, hence the stigma of BPD. Some other “PDs” are all about rigid managers.</p><p>In IFS, <em>blending</em> with parts refers to being constrained into the perspective of a particular part. For example, someone frequently annoyed by a behavior from their partner might have a part that resents them. While entirely normal, this can become problematic when you blend with such a belief, forgetting that your typical experience is very different. Developmental trauma can lead to persistent blending with child parts.</p><p>Another IFS concept highly relevant for this article is <em>polarizations</em> between parts. They are why someone wants to go to the gym yet somehow doesn’t or can’t decide whether to stay with their partner.</p><p>An alcoholic does not just have one part that wants to drink. It’s more like a power struggle between firefighter parts driven towards that urge to cope with trauma and parts attempting to interfere, as well as parts experiencing crushing shame about the whole thing.</p><p>Similarly, there is no “borderline part”, “histrionic” or “schizoid part”, but a complex constellation of trauma responses polarized with each other. I will come back to both polarizations and shame later.</p><p>Ultimately, trauma is about feeling unsafe. The best way to explain the vast majority of human behavior is by parts<em> trying to attain more safety</em>, whether it’s by e.g. dissociating, fawning, avoidance, seeking proximity or reassurance or seeking to control. Most of these are also common trauma reactions utilized by mental health professionals in their work.</p><h4><strong>Dissociation as the Guard of Trauma</strong></h4><p>Dissociation refers to two somewhat different yet typically connected trauma responses that help keep unbearable emotions at a distance. One is “zoning out” (which may also come off as derealization, confusion, numbness, tiredness or fogginess), sometimes called detachment. The other is fragmentation or compartmentalization (also known as <em>structural dissociation</em>), which is less likely to be noticed consciously.</p><p>In structural dissociation, trauma is “split off” from consciousness so as not to become overwhelming. This provides a vital survival mechanism particularly in situations of continuing maltreatment. Complex developmental trauma may leave the entire personality fragmented. Parts are walled off from each other, which also tends to make them more extreme and polarized.</p><p>Many times, dissociation gets discussed specifically in the context of childhood sexual abuse, despite its strong association with <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medicine/article/abs/dissociation-in-victims-of-childhood-abuse-or-neglect-a-metaanalytic-review/4175C6041A35F8E1901434B57873E487">all types of developmental trauma</a> (in my book I explore the idea it’s really a ubiquitous <em>societal survival mechanism</em>). Much of the critique of personality disorders also centers on the concern that CSA survivors may get inappropriately misdiagnosed with a PD, even though the same goes for other types of childhood abuse and neglect, as well.</p><p>Dissociation is almost like an “anti-symptom”, in that it can conceal other symptoms and patterns while itself remaining hidden. Some facets of it are easy to notice and others may be much trickier to spot. Screening tests have their own limitations, which I discuss in my book. Studying such elusive phenomena can be challenging, too, such as whether someone’s empathetic capacity is fully intact and only veiled by dissociation.</p><p>It’s curious to me that dissociation was already well-known by psychiatrists in the 19th century and was considered a significant contributor to serious psychiatric ailments.<a href="#_58">1</a> The idea just fell out of fashion for decades.</p><h4><strong>Splitting: A Fancy Name For Dissociation</strong></h4><p>With regard to BPD, the term “splitting” is used to refer to profoundly polarized thinking: the person may alternate between idolizing and demonizing a loved one. Rather than a specific symptom, black-and-white thinking is almost a defining feature of child parts. This is similar to how a real four-year-old child might switch from “you are the worst mom ever” to “you are the best mom ever” within minutes depending on whether they get candy or not.</p><p>Most people harbor these kinds of dynamics, even if often masked by manager parts. Such thinking can also manifest in trauma-based beliefs in ideas like “psychopathology”, “clinical populations” or “personality disorders”.</p><p>Dissociation is at the core of all ostensible personality disorders. As an example, antisocial and schizoid PD are particularly manager-led dissociative conditions. Narcissistic trauma responses tend to involve heavy splitting, but manager parts are often able to conceal it, at least until things blow up.</p><p>This is one heartbreaking depiction of dissociation in narcissism from “Mr. B”, in a famous <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20120509062923/http://internationalpsychoanalysis.net/wp-content/uploads/2007/07/libbeypaper.pdf">article by Mary Libbey</a>:</p><blockquote><em>“</em>I feel I am always in the gap between two or more selves, and there is a nothingness in that gap. What I feel is blankness… an in-between… a splitting apart… in the cracks between things. That doesn’t seem like a feeling. It seems like a lack. A place. I am in that place most of the time… I exist in the cracks between possible selves…<em>”</em></blockquote><h4><strong>Borderline Personality Disorder, Trauma and Marginalization</strong></h4><p>Uniquely stigmatized is the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder (BPD), originally regarded as residing on the “borderline” between neurosis and psychosis. The purported symptoms include volatility of mood and emotions, difficulties with emotional regulation, lack of a clear self-identity, feelings of emptiness, black-and-white thinking, impulsivity and fear of abandonment. There may also be suicidal thoughts, anger and short-term psychosis.</p><p>All of these are classical, highly prevalent trauma symptoms and not surprisingly, BPD is also strongly connected with disorganized attachment. The PD conceptualization denies the etiology and that such patterns were created adaptively in response to maltreatment.</p><p>As one <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/247749672_I_Women_at_the_Margins_A_Critique_of_the_Diagnosis_of_Borderline_Personality_Disorder">critique</a> put it: “<em>Both anger and fear of abandonment can be — and frequently are — judged to be inappropriate, as opposed to being understandable in the context of a person’s history of being violated or abandoned</em>.”</p><p>This diagnosis is mainly given to women, commonly viewed as an example of medical sexism and a <a href="https://crownschool.uchicago.edu/student-life/advocates-forum/power-selfhood-and-identity-feminist-critique-borderline-personality">modern label for hysteria</a>. In my experience, men demonstrate similar patterns at least as often, but tend to <em>dissociate them more thoroughly</em> and are more likely to evade the label. LGBTQ individuals are <a href="https://survivorsvoices.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/New-Ways-of-Supporting-Child-Abuse-and-Sexual-Violence-Survivors-FINAL-MANDATE.pdf">particularly prone</a> to receive a designation of a PD if their identity and potential struggles with it are interpreted in a pathologizing way.</p><p>Neurodivergent people are also at risk of getting such a label, especially BPD, rather than having their neurodiversity recognized. Multiple studies have reported this to <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11816473/">cause significant harm</a>. Curiously, a Finnish study found that ADHD medications were associated with <a href="https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2805752">a lower risk of suicide</a> in those with a BPD diagnosis, while most classes of psychiatric drugs were linked to an increased risk.</p><p>Our understanding of neurodiversity is still quite recent. While there are reports of ADHD-like presentations since the 18th century, the term originates from 1987. The now-defunct label Asperger’s syndrome was introduced in 1994 to describe supposedly “higher-functioning” forms of autism (both AS and “high-functioning” are considered problematic terms, but outside the scope of this article.)</p><p>In ICD-10, the term BPD gave way to <em>emotionally unstable personality disorder</em> (EUPD), a name still occasionally used in Europe despite ICD-11 changing to a different categorization again. (The term borderline was supposed to be scrapped from ICD-11, but in the end <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/01410768231164780">powerful lobbies allegedly got their wish</a>.)</p><h4><strong>The Stigma of the Borderline Label</strong></h4><p>BPD is viewed as highly challenging to treat or even refractory to treatment. Those diagnosed with it are commonly told as much, rather than being informed about how well these struggles respond to trauma therapy. (There is, however, a treatment developed specifically for BPD, called dialectical behavioral therapy, but DBT has grave problems, which I will address a bit later on.)</p><p>This kind of “psychoeducation” can greatly <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bjpsych-international/article/epistemic-injustice-of-borderline-personality-disorder/010CBB826061A040F6537B8B8A738A41">contribute to distress</a>. Imagine suffering tremendously, having a low self-esteem and potentially feeling suicidal and then being told that your personality is defective and you will never get better!</p><p>BPD symptoms are as reversible as any other trauma, with several studies finding <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16274279/">high rates of “lasting remission”</a> even with generally suboptimal treatment. (Importantly, “remission” is a concept not actually applicable to trauma, introduced to claim personality disorders as “enduring” against evidence. Rather than remitting, trauma is healed, or in some cases, better obfuscated with dissociation.)</p><p>Judith Lewis Herman quotes a trauma survivor named Tani about “BPD”: “<em>Having that diagnosis resulted in my getting treated exactly the way I was treated at home. The minute I got that diagnosis people stopped treating me as though what I was doing had a reason. All that psychiatric treatment was just as destructive as what happened before</em>.”<a href="#_60">2</a></p><p>One of the most stigmatized aspects of BPD is its frequent link with self-harm and suicidal thoughts, often deemed manipulative. (Antisocial personality disorder is also commonly associated with suicidal behavior, but is much less maligned for that.) BPD can also be regarded as a way of pathologizing <em>a particular type</em> of self-harm urges.</p><p>Contrary to othering narratives, there is no clear distinction between self-harming behaviors and choosing normalized actions that lead to pain, discomfort, risks to health or other harm.<a href="#_62">3</a> I would even argue that many ubiquitous people-pleasing responses can be classified as self-harm (which I explore in my book). In her <a href="https://crownschool.uchicago.edu/student-life/advocates-forum/power-selfhood-and-identity-feminist-critique-borderline-personality">critique</a> of the concept of BPD, Bria Berger writes:</p><blockquote><em>“</em>Some types of self-harm — such as overworking at one’s place of employment to the point of causing physical ailments, neglect of interpersonal relationships, and loss of sleep — are not seen as pathological because these acts resonate with cultural values, such as self-sacrifice for a greater goal. But because the self-directed nature of self-injury cannot be reconciled with other cultural norms, self-injury is seen as a manifestation of severe pathology; the person must be viewed as disordered for such an action to make sense.<em>”</em></blockquote><p>I have long argued that demonizing self-harm and suicidal feelings is based on projection, a common dissociative response. It’s less distressing to imagine that someone is manipulating you rather than suffering so intensely that they would resort to cutting themselves or desire to end their life.</p><h4><strong>Antisocial Personality Disorder and Psychopathy</strong></h4><p>Another infamous label is the one of antisocial personality disorder. The name should not be confused with being <em>asocial</em>, which refers to aversion of social engagements, while the “anti” is more about behavior that goes <em>against</em> society.</p><p>ASPD is commonly used synonymously with psychopathy (technically not a psychiatric diagnosis), while many sources stress that not all with ASPD are psychopaths. On the other hand, some authors consider ASPD more synonymous with the non-clinical term <em>sociopath</em>.</p><p>Sometimes ASPD is regarded as more descriptive of antisocial <em>conduct</em>, such as aggression, impulsivity and disregard of rules, while psychopathy is more about the inner <em>experience</em>, such as shallow affect, lack of guilt and putative lack of empathy. Research has suggested, however, that it’s not about lacking the capacity for empathy, but <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/251878760_Reduced_spontaneous_but_relatively_normal_deliberate_vicarious_representations_in_psychopathy">turning it off</a>. This fits well with dissociation.</p><p>Some researchers <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/1359178995000100">divide</a> psychopathy into two types: primary or neurodevelopmental and secondary, an acquired form, which the original author Stephen Porter considered a dissociative disorder. Of course, the supposed existence of such a division heavily primes any research into that direction.</p><p>A strong genetic link has been demonstrated, as well, something that likely goes for most trauma. Genetic predisposition helps shape the <em>kinds</em> of trauma responses one might develop from e.g. abuse or neglect, but that doesn’t mean trauma is genetic.</p><p>I will return to ASPD/psychopathy later in this article.</p><h4><strong>The Polarized and Dissociated World of Narcissism</strong></h4><p>It’s unfortunate that narcissism is such a charged word, as I believe it — or better, narcissistic traits — would be a useful concept, if it wasn’t so misunderstood. The term has evolved from its original psychoanalytic connotations to NPD and troubling pop culture ideas, yet we are talking about one of the most common trauma responses.</p><p>As another example of dissociative black-and-white thinking, the media depiction of narcissists tends to be extreme, caricaturish and highly problematic. Many sources paint narcissists as so emotionally underdeveloped and monstrous that they’re barely even human, with no characteristics besides their unscrupulous grandiosity. This kind of a portrayal also makes it harder to recognize narcissistic traits in yourself.</p><p>A widespread myth is that narcissists love themselves. That’s where the word originates from: Narcissus who fell in love with his own reflection. It’s more like the opposite: their insecurity <a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/03/210325150223.htm">poses a need for attention and adulation</a> from others to supplant self-worth, though perhaps they can be said to be infatuated with their <em>image</em>, like the Greek mythical figure was.</p><p>Narcissism used to be widely divided into two subtypes: “grandiose” and “vulnerable”. Nowadays many <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-is-narcissism-science-confronts-a-widely-misunderstood-phenomenon1/">experts argue</a> this classification makes no sense, as no matter which aspect appears to dominate outwardly, the essence of narcissism is the <em>polarization</em> between these two sides.</p><p>This dichotomy is incredibly common. Trauma can leave you feeling painfully different from others, resulting in some parts dreading there is something fundamentally wrong with you. Other parts decide this experience of not belonging is in fact because you are <em>special</em>.</p><p>Many people are blended with the flawedness, often called “low self-esteem”, yet may feel special in some circumstances. Others lean heavily towards the grandiosity with the wrongness side exiled, yet still prominently influencing their lives.</p><p>This leads to the inner conflict of <em>believing you are special but not being able to feel it without outside validation</em>. You need constant attention, praise and recognition from others (and nothing is ever enough) or the belief conflicts with the reality of your life.</p><p>Narcissists are presumed to not feel empathy or only at low levels, but studies suggest it’s more about <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/intense-emotions-and-strong-feelings/202001/do-narcissists-actually-lack-empathy">turning this capacity off at will</a>, as is typical of dissociation. One paper even went as far as <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1300/J229v04n03_04">calling narcissism</a> “an inevitable result of trauma-generated dissociation”.</p><h4><strong>Other Personality Disorders</strong></h4><p>I will briefly go through the DSM-5 categorization of other personality disorders. Divided into three “clusters”, there are ten of them, though some are seldom diagnosed. Cluster A (“odd or eccentric”) contains paranoid, schizoid and schizotypal personality disorders. Paranoia is a highly prevalent feature of trauma, as is holding grudges, another supposed aspect of paranoid personality disorder.</p><p>Schizoid personality disorder is characterized by aloofness, detachment and withdrawal from social relationships and society. Such individuals typically feel disinterested in food or sex, though may possess a rich internal world. All the symptoms are common in severe dissociation.</p><p>Compared to it, schizotypal PD is portrayed as displaying more obvious eccentricity, as well as perceptual alterations, magical thinking and paranoia. Still, some authors regard schizoid and schizotypal as the same thing, while ICD-11 classes the latter under psychotic disorders instead. (My book also delves into the incredibly strong yet neglected connection between childhood trauma and psychosis.)</p><p>The main PDs covered in this article, BPD, ASPD and NPD, are contained in Cluster B (“dramatic, emotional or erratic”). Owing to this reputation, “Cluster B” as a term is often encountered on its own, as a slur or an ominous warning, such as regarding dating.</p><p>Additionally the category houses histrionic personality disorder, a label characterized by dramatic behavior and seeking attention or approval, frequently in sexual ways. Not surprisingly. it has been preliminarily <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15299732.2022.2119458">connected to childhood sexual abuse</a> in particular, though other types of trauma have also been implicated.</p><p>Cluster C (“anxious or fearful”) includes avoidant, dependent and obsessive-compulsive personality disorder. The last one is regarded the most common of the PDs, with alleged prevalence rates in the population of up to <a href="https://www.psychiatrist.com/jcp/prevalence-correlates-disability-personality-disorders/">7.9%</a>. OCPD should not be confused with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), which is portrayed quite differently. The diagnostic criteria of OCPD center on rigidity, stubbornness, perfectionism and a fixation on productivity.</p><p>A person with OCPD is also described as oblivious to the effect these traits have on their and others’ lives — <em>oblivious</em> being yet another of the numerous synonyms for dissociation that the DSM-5 has come up with. As discussed earlier, “need to control” represents one of the most typical manifestations of trauma, being among the core approaches for managing unsafety.</p><p>In avoidant personality disorder, the person desires relationships, connection and intimacy, but considers themselves inferior and feels terrified of rejection. The pain of this can spur self-harm and substance abuse.</p><p>The avoidance stands out from avoidant attachment, having more in common with anxious and disorganized attachment as well as social anxiety — it has also been known as anxious personality disorder. Dependent personality disorder, too, bears similarity to anxious attachment, with clingy, submissive behavior and a need to be cared for.</p><p>This is all the DSM. The other diagnostic manual ICD used to rely on a somewhat similar system, but the current version, ICD-11, applies a dimensional model. Rather than distinct categories, it focuses on supposedly pathological personality traits — ones criticized for <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/01410768231164780">closely aligning</a> with the “Big 5” domains of a normal personality. Now the definition of “disordered personality” has become more roundabout, constructible from little pieces of wrongness.</p><p>Beyond this change, no new personality disorders have been introduced since 1980, though multiple additions have been proposed. In the 1980s, there was an attempt to include “masochistic personality disorder” in the DSM, for anyone who “<em>remains in relationships in which others exploit, abuse, or take advantage of him or her, despite opportunities to alter the situation</em>”.</p><p>According to Judith Lewis Herman, who was a participant in this process, it became a heated debate between women’s rights activists and a small group of male psychoanalysts who “<em>admitted freely that they were ignorant of the extensive literature of the past decade on psychological trauma</em>”.<a href="#_64">4</a></p><h4><strong>Shame Underlies All Trauma</strong></h4><p>A core yet neglected aspect of trauma is shame, which has only recently began to receive proper attention in research. A 2022 <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01227-z">review article</a> by Luna Dolezal, et al, depicted shame intriguingly:</p><blockquote><em>“</em>[C]hronic shame is commonly characterised by the nagging and persistent possibility of shame, where, for the most part, shame itself is not necessarily realised in experience. Instead, what comes to dominate experience is a pernicious form of anticipated shame, or a persistent and heightened ‘shame anxiety,’ of which an individual may, or may not, be aware.<em>”</em></blockquote><p>The article emphasizes that like dissociation, shame can hide in plain sight: “<em>It is important to note that shame anxiety may not be experienced as shame. Instead, it may be dominated by shame avoidance and, as such, characterised by emotions such as fear, anxiety, self-consciousness, stress or powerful impulses to hide, avoid or escape.</em>”</p><p>Shame may be the most evident in trauma that gets cast as BPD. It is also a part of the diagnostic criteria of avoidant personality disorder. As would be expected, there are studies connecting shame to nearly all personality disorders, and I believe it plays a major role in all of them.</p><p>Drawing on the work of psychiatrist Donald Nathanson, the same review article lists tactics people use for combating shame: “<em>Common defensive behaviours include a variety of different reactions, all of which are damaging both to oneself and to one’s social bonds, such as anger, aggression, hostility, violence, narcissism, depression, perfectionism, apathy, withdrawal, avoidance, excessive deference, among others.</em>” That already covers the bulk of alleged PD symptoms.</p><p>In narcissism, shame has long been discussed in the context of inability to tolerate shaming spurring the person to shame others. Named by psychoanalyst Ludwig Eidelberg in 1957, <em>narcissistic mortification</em> is an extreme experience of primitive terror and dissolution of self when humiliated by loss of control. It can feel like actual death or even worse than death. The earlier cited “Mr. B” <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20120509062923/http://internationalpsychoanalysis.net/wp-content/uploads/2007/07/libbeypaper.pdf">described</a> it like this:</p><blockquote><em>“</em>I feel a blast furnace of embarrassment and self-consciousness, a shattering of language in my head which feels very violent, being blown to pieces, millions of shards in a washing machine being blown together.<em>”</em></blockquote><p>One of the main functions of therapy is to heal shame, Unfortunately, that becomes impossible when you start from the shaming frame of “personality disorder” (or when applying an inherently shame-inducing therapeutic modality, like DBT or CBT).</p><h4><strong>Shame and Psychopathy: Connection With Dissociation and Violence</strong></h4><p>It is commonly believed that psychopaths feel no shame or even that this is one of the core aspects of it. Early literature endorsed this idea and some sources still do, but more recent research has suggested it’s more about deficits in emotional regulation. Rather than there being no shame, so-called psychopaths have <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0047235221000659"><em>unacknowledged shame</em></a><em>, and any aggression may even stem from attempts to cope with or regulate shame.</em></p><p>This is what psychiatrist James Gilligan, who studied violent people in American prisons (as well as figures like Hitler) for years, also posited. In his famous book series about these experiences, he attempted to explain what he branded the <em>violence epidemic</em>. In Gilligan’s view, shame is a “necessary but not sufficient” condition for violence: “<em>The emotion of shame is the primary or ultimate cause of all violence, whether toward others or toward the self.</em>”<a href="#_66">5</a></p><p>When shame becomes so overwhelming it threatens the person’s self, there are no other means of processing it or mitigating conditions like guilt currently present, violence might ensue. Gilligan’s ideas sound quite similar to narcissistic mortification, some of the depictions poetic yet chilling:</p><blockquote><em>“</em>Shame is also experienced as a feeling, and an intensely painful one; but like cold, it is, in essence, the absence of warmth, emotional warmth, or love for the self. And when it reaches overwhelming intensity, shame is experienced, like cold, as a feeling of numbness and deadness. We know that cold starts out feeling painful, but when it reaches an intolerable extreme, it results in complete numbness and physical death. At first only a limb may die, but when the cold is sufficiently severe, the whole body dies. In the same way, the self dies when exposed to more shame than it can tolerate.<em>”</em><a href="#_68"><em>6</em></a></blockquote><p>Though James Gilligan has been widely cited, what no one seems to be addressing is that he clearly did not endorse the common distinction of biological vs. secondary (post-traumatic/dissociative) subtypes of psychopathy. His writing considers all of it, or at least in forensic cases underlying serious violence, to originate from shame and childhood wounds.</p><p>Another long-time researcher of violent criminals, forensic psychologist Abby Stein similarly pinned violent crime on shame and childhood trauma, though focusing more on the dissociative aspects of it. In her book <em>Prologue to Violence: Child Abuse, Dissociation, and Crime</em> she proposed a dissociative state called <em>psychosomnia</em>: a chronic, dream-like mode of experience in which the sense of agency and moral culpability are reduced.<a href="#_70">7</a></p><p>This is also what Ronald C. Naso’s fascinating book <em>Hypocrisy Unmasked: Dissociation, Shame, and the Ethics of Inauthenticity</em> is about: not just violence and psychopathy, but the origins of many different types of transgressions. According to Naso, dissociation allows people to block out guilt, shame and anxiety, as well as enabling them to act with a diminished sense of agency.<a href="#_72">8</a></p><p>At the core, behaviors that may come off as cunning manipulation are nothing but primitive attempts to evade unbearable manifestations of trauma.</p><h4><strong>Good and Bad Patients</strong></h4><blockquote><em>“</em>The most notorious is the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder. This term is frequently used within the mental health professions as little more than a sophisticated insult. As one psychiatrist candidly confesses, ‘As a resident, I recalled asking my supervisor how to treat patients with borderline personality disorder, and he answered, sardonically, ‘You refer them.’<em>”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>– Judith Lewis Herman</em></blockquote><p>We love to divide people into us (good) and them (bad), whether on the basis of gender, ethnicity or which sports team they support. This of course originates from trauma, but it also gets <em>applied</em> <em>to</em> trauma: our own trauma reactions easily seem like normal human behavior, while others’ are pathological. A common example is people who could be characterized as avoidantly attached insisting that their way of relating to others is the healthy kind, while those with anxious attachment are too clingy and needy.</p><p>In general psychology, this divisive tendency is called <a href="https://people.clas.ufl.edu/shepperd/files/SSB2008.pdf"><em>self-serving bias</em></a> (or <em>self-serving attributional bias</em>), which is closely related to one of the trauma responses with the most social clout, the <a href="https://www.scu.edu/ethics/ethics-resources/ethical-decision-making/the-just-world-theory/">Just World theory</a>. I prefer to use the more straightforward term <em>othering</em>.</p><p>This tendency is also rife in the field of mental health. I believe at the core of the problem is the system being <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/medical-trauma-6fa90c6ecab0">deeply traumatized and dissociated</a>. In line with trauma-based black-and-white thinking, it’s oriented on dividing its clientele into “good” and “bad” patients.</p><p>One of the worst insults a doctor can use is “noncompliance”, a term which has been lambasted for its moral and even <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0277953688901943?via%3Dihub">ideological undertones</a>. Noncompliance is controlling and paternalistic parts’ way of calling out <em>disobedience</em>.</p><p>Much of the perceived efficacy of therapy <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2003-04137-008">may be attributable</a> to people-pleasing tendencies in the client. If someone struggles or isn’t keen to please, a label of PD is applied as an explanation. A “bad” patient may be disciplined with punitive approaches created by profoundly wounded control-oriented parts, such as DBT, which is addressed a bit later in this article.</p><p>Even worse, a “bad” patient may also be regarded that way in other areas of healthcare or even the legal system, such as family court, so it’s a very dangerous label.</p><h4><strong>How Mental Healthcare Legitimizes Trauma Projections</strong></h4><p>Among the trauma responses most commonly exhibited in healthcare (as well as psychiatric research) is one I’ve dubbed <em>pathology orientation</em>. I regard it as having the following characteristics:</p><ul><li>Viewing trauma and mental health struggles through the lens of pathology and being excited by pathology</li><li>Viewing other issues, such as symptoms of physical illness, ongoing aspects of normal life or predicaments like grief, poverty or oppression as mental pathology</li><li>Employing terminology which is dissociative and othering such as “psychopathology” and “clinical population”, underlining the “shocking” problems or flaws that individuals with certain diagnoses supposedly have compared to you</li></ul><p>Pathology orientation is a prominent part or a constellation of parts, a form of trauma in itself, which unfortunately steps in the way of actually helping others. It’s not possible to support people if you posit yourself above them and insist they are fundamentally different from you.</p><blockquote><em>“</em>As caregivers tire of these chronically unhappy people who do not seem to improve, the temptation to apply pejorative diagnostic labels becomes overwhelming.<em>”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>– Judith Lewis Herman</em></blockquote><p>Of course, this is in line with how psychiatry and the medical profession works in general (Michel Foucault termed it <a href="https://bjgp.org/content/63/611/312"><em>the medical gaze</em></a>). Though much of the field of mental health is formally located outside of medicine, it has still inherited these nasty wounds. One of the papers I cite in this piece has an abstract consisting of seven sentences, which impressively contain a total of ten instances of the term “personality pathology”.</p><p>There are no “clinical” and “non-clinical” populations, just socially sanctioned and non-sanctioned ways of trauma expression. Somehow, the trauma response of pathology orientation remains widely considered acceptable despite being damaging and dehumanizing. It’s not so different from the shorthand of “evil” used in common parlance, discussed below.</p><p>In denial of the traumatized nature of the profession, it tends to hide that behind clinical terminology. For example, many sources conclude that patients with BPD evoke “countertransference” in their therapist. What this term refers to is the therapist being triggered and <em>projecting their own trauma</em> on the client.</p><p>As is common in psychiatry, which loves to cast everything as biological regardless of the evidence, PDs are often depicted as “biological and genetic”. Certain types of parenting are said to be “contributing” to the risk, to avoid uttering the word “trauma”. If you read e.g. Wikipedia entries on personality disorders, many of them spend enormous effort dancing around the word trauma.</p><p>Such denial is no coincidence. If someone suffers from a poorly treatable “biological” disorder, the provider can turn them away in good conscience, or only hand out a cocktail of psychotropic medications. Yet if the turmoil actually results from healable trauma, the clinician refusing to engage with it because they are triggered by it would be negligent.</p><p>Some diagnoses are associated with shame on the <em>clinician’s </em>part. There is no shame in <em>diagnosing</em> personality disorders, but many professionals are terrified of labeling someone as having dissociative identity disorder (DID), because of the reputation of this condition (such as the <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1521/psyc.2014.77.2.169">long-debunked claims</a> about it being “iatrogenic in origin”). The irony.</p><p>One well-known, though now dated, study reported that a significant portion of clinicians diagnosing DID faced intense skepticism or even <a href="https://www.ovid.com/jnls/jonmd/abstract/00005053-198809000-00002">repeated harassment from peers</a>. To diagnose a labile and dissociated individual as BPD rather than DID shifts the shame from the provider to the client.</p><h4><strong>Personality Disorders as Euphemistic Shorthand</strong></h4><p>In common parlance, personality disorders (especially ASPD and narcissism) serve as shorthand for evil. Specifically, psychopathy is depicted as cold, distant and sadistic. It represents archetypical evil with very little humanity to it, that we typically only encounter in the news or horror movies.</p><p>This feels comforting to many: the conviction that those committing atrocious acts are in some fundamental way different from you and I, even <em>born evil</em>. (Most of those fulfilling the criteria for ASPD or psychopathy never commit violent crimes, but the perceived connection between “psychopath”, “evil” and “violent criminal” is certainly strong.)</p><p>There are several popular books about psychopaths trying to terrify the reader from their ominous title onwards, like Thomas Erikson’s <em>Surrounded by Psychopaths </em>and<em> </em>Robert D. Hare’s older <em>Without Conscience: The Disturbing World of the Psychopaths Among Us</em>, curiously both hinting that this scary <em>other</em> lurks everywhere.</p><p>Depictions of narcissism tend to be slightly (but not much) more nuanced, usually still portraying manipulative evil. Something that appeared human, but it was just a trick you fell for. Borderline acts as shorthand for chaotic and volatile evil, typically your “crazy ex”. It’s likely the most human of these as its emotionality is very evident, though viewed as no less destructive.</p><p>I’ve occasionally been accused of trying to “excuse” abusers, which is very much not something I’m keen on. Obviously, pointing out the immense problems with these portrayals is not to minimize the harm done by abusive behavior.</p><p>I’ve had a number of very abusive people in my own life, some of whom were high in narcissistic or other demonized traits while others weren’t. The abuse was very similar regardless, because it was not the result of grandiose parts but dissociation.</p><p>Abuse is always unacceptable, whether it is conceptualized to result from psychopathy, narcissism, projection, shame, dissociation or some other cause, and trauma is no “excuse” for it. However, when it comes to actually mitigating damaging patterns, the real mechanism becomes of vital importance.</p><h4><strong>How the Harmful Diagnosis Functions for the Patient</strong></h4><p>Many people also cling to their own diagnosis of a personality disorder and I believe there are four main reasons for that. The first one is the negative self-concept. If you already feel like there is something fundamentally wrong with you, it’s easy to accept a diagnosis denouncing you as <em>intrinsically fl</em>awed.</p><p>Struggles with the sense of self form a part of the diagnostic criteria of BPD, but it constitutes a core issue with severe trauma in general. A diagnosis, even one with a poor reputation, helps to construct an identity.</p><p>Third, the relationship between a patient/client and their provider, or even a person with the whole system, often represents a <a href="https://amynordhues.com/trauma-bonding-and-abuse-in-the-therapeutic-setting/">trauma bond</a>. In this context, human value is determined by compliance. When you accept your diagnosis, you are a good patient — and if the diagnosis brands you as bad or difficult, rebelling against it would only serve as a <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/01410768231164780">confirmation of the assessment</a>.</p><p>A fourth reason is the conviction that the diagnosis must exist for a reason. If it was unhelpful, it would not be in use. Both patients and professionals regularly claim the diagnosis is important to guide treatment.</p><p>Yet all trauma can be successfully healed <em>the exact same way</em>. For example, among the modalities I use, in IFS all trauma manifests as parts, whereas in somatic work, it presents in the body. With EMDR, it would not make a difference, either. Many people with a PD diagnosis grapple with persisting in therapy, but this is an <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/i-want-to-heal-but-also-i-dont-why-do-many-feel-averse-to-therapy-and-trauma-work-5330be0aa99d">highly prevalent struggle with all types of trauma</a>.</p><p>Tragically, a diagnosis of a PD is only likely to <em>deprive</em> the patient of curative treatment and potentially lead them in harm’s way. This applies particularly to dialectical behavioral therapy (DBT), mainly used to treat people designated as having BPD.</p><p>Unfortunately DBT does not offer any solutions for trauma. Deeply shame-inducing, its main teaching is that feelings are irrelevant as long as you behave in societally acceptable ways, such as suppressing self-destructive urges. In my view, this makes it completely unsuitable for its target group.</p><p>It seems like cruel irony that someone already carrying deep wounds and likely labeled manipulative gets subjected to an abusive therapy containing manipulative and shaming elements like “withdrawal of warmth”.</p><p>Studies show that DBT can cause <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20240330195416id_/https://repository.uel.ac.uk/download/ec7001d42c25ce257235fdba70a32330370d15eb949c0faa6e316c30e34b6c24/4500971/2023_ClinPsychD_Lawson.pdf">considerable harm</a>, including retraumatization as well as experiences of shame, silencing and suppression of emotions. In an article titled <a href="https://www.madinamerica.com/2022/08/trauma-survivors-speak-out-against-dialectical-behavioral-therapy-dbt/">Trauma Survivors Speak Out Against Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT)</a>, an anonymous person comments: “<em>DBT was the worst thing that ever happened to me. I needed trauma therapy for years just to process the abuse that DBT was.</em>”</p><p>In <a href="https://bpspsychub.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/papt.12362">a study of patient experiences</a> of DBT and another modality called MBT (mentalization-based therapy), some of those who had undergone DBT described behavior from the therapists as belittling, critical or even “actively hostile”, which was much less common with MBT. 19% of the interviewed patients exclusively reported negative experiences from therapy.</p><p>In his book about gaslighting in psychotherapy, Theodore L. Dorpat wrote: “<em>Behavior therapy, for example, employs rewards and punishments for controlling and shaping patients’ behaviors. Except for the few older surviving followers of the non-directive methods of Carl Rogers, the majority of mental health practitioners in private practice today deliberately employ directive and manipulative methods to shape and control the behaviors and cognitions of their patients.</em>”<a href="#_74">9</a></p><h4><strong>The Peculiar Logic of Psychiatric Nomenclature</strong></h4><p>Psychiatric diagnoses as a whole face criticism for several different reasons, such as medicalization and stigma. Additionally, the labels have been disparaged as subjective and arbitrary: they may not correspond to any concrete entity. Something like hypothyroidism describes an objective, measurable disease process, while bipolar disorder is a collection of symptoms.</p><p>I have frequently criticized the concept of post-traumatic stress disorder, which originally I was going to leave out of this article as a separate matter. I do believe, however, that it’s an important aspect of the PD conundrum, too.</p><p>The label of PTSD isolates a specific trauma in the context of one’s life — and in the context of a highly traumatized society, which is completely ignored. It is elevated into a distinct condition with a particular symptomatology, heavily emphasizing certain aspects of trauma while neglecting others.</p><p>PTSD demarcates itself from conditions without trauma in their name. It’s like a concession the field made to trauma studies, that you can claim this one thing and the rest has nothing to do with it. Even though Judith Lewis Herman’s contribution of complex PTSD (cPTSD) is less stigmatizing and violent than PDs, I believe it does nothing to solve these issues.</p><p>Aidan Wright et al’s <a href="https://psyche.co/ideas/theres-a-growing-case-for-renaming-personality-disorders">proposed term </a><em>interpersonal disorder</em> sounds gentler than ascribing the disorder to personality, yet hardly communicates anything at all, since all mental health and human existence is interpersonal. Like PTSD, it contains the problematic implication that it’s pointing at a component missing from other psychiatric conditions. The same goes for Bruce M. Cohen et al’s <a href="https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(21)00478-8/abstract">suggestion</a> of <em>relational disorder</em> or <em>relational difficulty</em>.</p><p>Several authors have proposed renaming BPD to <em>chronic relational trauma disorder</em>.<a href="#_76">10</a> This is more descriptive, yet it is still fraught with the same issue that it could describe almost any condition included in the ICD-11 or DSM-V.</p><p>I find that the implicit question becomes obvious here. If there is no label that isn’t outdated, damaging and highly misleading and/or sounds like it comprises every single person with mental health issues, it might just be a sign that the label is unnecessary and does not point at anything meaningful.</p><h4>Book References</h4><p><a href="#_8">1</a> Andrew Moskowitz, Markus Heinimaa, Onno van der Hart. Defining Psychosis, Trauma, and Dissociation: Historical and Contemporary Conceptions. In: Andrew Moskowitz, Martin J. Dorahy, Ingo Schäfer (eds.).<em> Psychosis, Trauma and Dissociation: Evolving Perspectives on Severe Psychopathology, Second Edition</em>. Wiley 2019.</p><p><a href="#_18">2</a> Judith Lewis Herman. <em>Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence — From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror</em>. Basic Books 2015. p. 69.</p><p><a href="#_19">3</a> Regina A. Goulding, Richard C. Schwartz. <em>Mosaic Mind: Empowering the Tormented Selves of Trauma Survivors</em>. W. W. Norton &amp; Company 1995. pp. 263–264.</p><p><a href="#_31">4</a> Judith Lewis Herman. <em>Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence — From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror</em>. Basic Books 2015. pp. 116–122.</p><p><a href="#_35">5</a> James Gilligan.<em> Violence: Reflections on a National Epidemic</em>. Putnam 1996. p. 110.</p><p><a href="#_36">6</a> James Gilligan.<em> Violence: reflections on a National Epidemic</em>. Putnam 1996. p. 48.</p><p><a href="#_37">7</a> Abby Stein. <em>Prologue to Violence. Child Abuse, Dissociation, and Crime.</em> Routledge 2007. pp. 23–24.</p><p><a href="#_38">8</a> Ronald C. Naso. <em>Hypocrisy Unmasked: Dissociation, Shame, and the Ethics of Inauthenticity</em>. Jason Aronson 2010. p. 100.</p><p><a href="#_54">9</a> Theodore L. Dorpat. <em>Gaslighting, the Double Whammy, Interrogation and Other Methods of Covert Control in Psychotherapy and Analysis</em>. Jason Aronson 1996. p. xiii.</p><p><a href="#_57">10</a> Elizabeth Howell. From Hysteria to Chronic Relational Trauma Disorder. In: Andrew Moskowitz, Martin J. Dorahy, Ingo Schäfer (eds.).<em> Psychosis, Trauma and Dissociation: Evolving Perspectives on Severe Psychopathology, Second Edition</em>. Wiley 2019.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0b503a65851d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Online Communities So Often Turn Toxic]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/why-online-communities-so-often-turn-toxic-58e3f0243c4f?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58e3f0243c4f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Jun 2026 06:46:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-17T06:46:45.712Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Main Cause Has Nothing to Do With Anonymity or Even Being Online</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sHmZv-22lSyueuUV3wzoCA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo from Cookiecutter @ Pexels.com</figcaption></figure><p>The way social media can appear like a cesspool is commonly attributed to the relative anonymity online and resulting lack of consequences for hurtful conduct. A user may not even consider other names on the screen to be real people.</p><p>This idea has some truth to it, but it ignores a much bigger issue: people are extremely complicated and <em>all communities, including offline ones, have a high propensity to develop harmful interpersonal dynamics</em>. We are just much more likely to discuss gamers cruelly harassing a teen girl than 76-year-old Jeanne’s tyranny over the church bridge club.</p><p>And in other words, while some communities may be more prone to these kinds of issues, there is no type of collective that is immune to them, regardless of its size, topic, demographic, anonymity or method of communication. This article focuses on group dynamics in Internet communities in general, though most of the issues also appear offline.</p><p>On some platforms, everyone posts with their real name and picture and in the other extreme, there is social media where you can’t register an account at all, like some image boards and other forums. We have Facebook, Instagram, Discord, LinkedIn, Reddit, Twitter (or X), TikTok, online games, streaming communities and many more. Some people find text-based communication to flow naturally, but for others, it can feel impersonal, confusing or draining.</p><p>Certain forms of social media date back to the 1980s. I started my journey in 1995 on more oldschool platforms: BBSs, IRC, chatrooms, forums, mailing lists and Usenet newsgroups, places full of amazing people, yet also all kinds of questionable and at times even horrifying behavior. I have maintained multiple large communities for years and a smaller one for over two decades. In the course of that, I have made numerous mistakes, but also learned so much.</p><p>Importantly, while many communities succumb to conflict or even blatant abuse, often the most pernicious issues are much subtler. An example of this is <em>collective fawn</em>, discussed later in this article, which is easy to perceive as “harmony”, yet may lead to deleterious cult-like dynamics.</p><p>Some of my descriptions and explanations may sound like “therapy speak”. It’s hard to describe the intricacies of social systems without resorting to such language, but I steer clear from diagnosing or pathologizing anything. Also, the subject is vast and complex, so an article like this can only scratch the surface.</p><h4><strong><em>Tiny Slivers of Trauma Can Wreck Havoc</em></strong></h4><p>My view is that just about all human behavior results from trauma, which our entire culture is also built upon. (I cover this in much more detail in my free book <a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/"><em>Shattered White-Out: How Trauma and Dissociation Mold the World, Your Relationships and You</em></a>.) While many associate the word trauma with grave emotional wounds, it can originate from much smaller issues known as <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/contemporary-psychoanalysis-in-action/201506/micro-traumas-can-undermine-our-emotional-health">“small t trauma” or “microtrauma”</a>.</p><p>Our minds are full of contradictory ideas, feelings and remnants from the past. These inform how we react to things taking place in the present, whether these reactions come off as sensible or irrational. Stories are spun to make sense of it and our own explanations of our actions frequently miss the mark completely.</p><p>I use a highly simplified version of the <a href="https://medium.com/Program%20Files%20(x86)/Atlantis/As%20trauma%20is%20about%20unsafety,%20control%20is%20a%20tempting%20approach%20for%20parts%20to%20attain%20more%20safety.%20I%20believe%20that%20most%20people%20display%20at%20least%20some%20controlling%20behaviors">Internal Family Systems model</a> of <em>parts of the mind </em>to depict how these kinds of trauma responses and dynamics play out, both internally and between individuals. Rather than a singular “mind”, what we have is more like a fascinating collection of different modules.</p><p>Parts are also a <em>compassionate model</em>, reducing shame which is a common trigger for problematic patterns. Just because you have behaved questionably online or face-to-face, as almost all of us at least occasionally have, it doesn’t define you. Likely it’s just a tiny sliver of your entire personality.</p><p>Motivation is an example I often use to illustrate how parts function internally. You might have a part keen for you to get fit, while another part complains that life is exhausting enough as it is. At times the athletic part may get its wish and at others, you find yourself glued to the TV rather than hitting the gym, struggling to comprehend how that happened again. That might have other parts feeling frustrated and ashamed, even though from a parts perspective, the whole thing makes perfect sense.</p><h4><strong><em>Drama or Just Normal Healthy Conflict</em></strong></h4><p>Internal conflict can be tricky enough, but when two people are in contact, their parts rub up against each other in numerous different ways. With more than two individuals, the number of potential part interactions increases exponentially. That’s when we also start going into group dynamics, where A resents B for liking C and so on.</p><p>A common interpersonal situation causing hurt in all types of relations (including fleeting ones like customer service) revolves around criticism. One person has a loud judgmental part, while another carries a part which is very vulnerable to critical comments. Often the same individual harbors both types of parts, so this distressing conflict is experienced internally, as well.</p><p>Conflict is a normal and healthy part of human experience, yet traumatized parts can get incredibly triggered by it. In communal settings, disagreement all too often gets either demonized — as complaining, negativity or drama — or blown out of proportion.</p><p>An important aspect of trauma and human emotion is that none of us are purely rational beings. <a href="https://smw.ch/index.php/smw/article/download/1687/2255"><em>“Non-emotional conversations” do not exist</em></a>. Even discussions about facts, including facts of low significance, such as when a particular show is airing on TV, can trigger trauma responses in the participants.</p><p>As a common example, many are highly sensitive to the idea of someone perceiving them as having low intelligence. This part is often triggered when they are asked clarifying questions, even if no contempt or criticism is intended.</p><p>“Drama” can also materialize when there is an actual problem that someone is trying to bring up for a good reason, so the term also functions as a disparaging way to shut down legitimate criticism.</p><p>And to get back the idea that we don’t always consider “names on the screen” to correspond to real individuals, many people with severe trauma <em>struggle to recognize</em><a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09515089.2023.2294776#infos-holder"><em> even real-life connections (or themselves) as real people</em></a>.</p><p><strong><em>Dissociation</em></strong></p><p>Dissociation is a widespread trauma response that I even posit in my book as the foundation of society. It goes by many other names, some of which get glorified (like some forms of avoidance and aloofness) and others pathologized.</p><p>Though there are two main types of it: a deeper fragmentation and compartmentalization (<a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">structural dissociation</a>) and “zoning out”, both have the goal of obscuring information that one or more parts consider too painful to handle. The obfuscation makes it difficult to get a realistic picture of your own and others’ persona and interactions.</p><p>In addition, in my book I argue that <em>almost all harmful behavior stems from dissociation</em>, an idea drawing support from a handful of forensic researchers plus some other academic articles and books. Ronald C. Naso’s <em>Hypocrisy Unmasked: Dissociation, Shame, and the Ethics of Inauthenticity</em> is also a fascinating treatise on this.</p><p>Dissociation is particularly prone to hiding away shame and anger, which tend to only get worse when they are suppressed. Therapist Martha Sweezy wrote in the book <em>Internal Family Systems Therapy: New Dimensions</em>:</p><blockquote><em>“The ballpark message of shaming is that imperfection makes you bad, unacceptable and alone. Shaming someone else intentionally and cultivating a feeling of power in comparison to that belittled other can be quite effective in the short run at regulating shame.” (p. 25)</em></blockquote><p>Dissociated anger and shame also play a major role in narcissism. Though “narcissists” are often demonized in popular culture as irredeemable monsters, narcissistic parts are a highly prevalent trauma response. In groups their dark sides can show up in a variety of ways, from control to lying, derision, picking favorites and scapegoats and constant demands for attention. Sometimes they may even look bizarre, from setting outlandish rules to intentionally obfuscated speech.</p><p>Community moderators tend to be high in narcissistic traits, but they are rarely the only ones. This may turn into a dynamic where more submissive individuals focus on pleasing the high-status members who encourage this behavior. There is also a term <a href="https://www.southampton.ac.uk/~crsi/Gebauer_Sedikides_Verplanken_%20Maio_2012_JPSP.pdf"><em>communal narcissist</em></a> proposed for individuals who are keen on uplifting others in the same community, sometimes in idolizing ways, as their core belief is that they are <em>unusually helpful</em>.</p><p>Narcissism is often confused as “self-love”, but at the core it’s more the opposite: incredible vulnerability hiding underneath heavy dissociation. Acts that may come off as intentional manipulation or even the so-called <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10926771.2020.1774695"><em>DARVO</em></a> (Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender) are typically <em>experiences happening in the perpetrator’s own mind</em>: dissociation leading to denial and projection. Distorted perception makes it feel like they really are the victim.</p><p><em>Triangulation</em> is a term used in psychology for a phenomenon where a third person is drawn into a conflict between two people, such as to create division. This is also typically treated as a deliberate manipulation tactic, while I argue that it arises from dissociation. In general, triangulation does not seem like a very useful concept, particularly in dissecting group relations, which tend to be far more complex and nuanced.</p><h4><strong><em>Projection, Control and Gaslighting</em></strong></h4><p>Projection is a dissociative defense mechanism of perceiving things in others that aren’t really there, typically your own disowned qualities. Though it is a ubiquitous aspect of human communication, social media culture tends to reinforce it further. When there is less information available about the other party, trauma responses step in to fill in the gap and the result is rarely flattering.</p><p>One’s gender, name or (perceived) ethnicity can spark all kinds of projections. I’ve had people draw various bizarre conclusions about me based on single words in my Twitter profile and even get triggered by these ideas they made up. Those with e.g. brightly colored hair also regularly face “analyses” of their life, opinions and personality based on this singular trait.</p><p>Projection is one of the main aspects of collective fawn discussed later in this article. As an extreme example, in one such community a bully ended up blocking me, so he was not able to see any of my posts. That is all fine, except he kept guessing on their content based on others’ replies to keep criticizing me for things he imagined I was saying.</p><p>Albeit seemingly bizarre, I believe this might not be so different from more typical projection. Normally the other’s words are heard or seen, yet they are being twisted so heavily that often the person is effectively having the entire conversation with their own parts.</p><p>Whether microtrauma or more serious wounding, at the core trauma is about <em>feeling unsafe</em>. Control gives parts a tempting way to gain more safety and I find that most people display at least some controlling tactics. In his excellent book <em>Gaslighting, the Double Whammy, Interrogation and Other Methods of Covert Control in Psychotherapy and Analysis </em>(which covers much more than just therapy), Theodore L. Dorpat posited that much of this control occurs by projection. He believed controlling patterns are everywhere:</p><blockquote>“<em>Covert methods of control are some of the time embedded in the ways nearly all individuals in Western societies talk and relate to each other. In some people, these methods are used </em>most of the time<em> in communicating with others</em>.” <em>(p. 13)</em></blockquote><p>Projection also commonly leads to gaslighting. Traditionally it is another type of abuse viewed as intentional, but at the core of Dorpat’s book is him rejecting this depiction. Like other forms of projection, I consider almost all gaslighting to be dissociative reactions.</p><h4><strong><em>Trolling and Bullying</em></strong></h4><p>The infamous Internet phenomenon of trolling refers to intentionally posting provocative and often disparaging comments. While an important topic, I won’t focus on it in depth in this article, as it has already been covered by numerous other authors, unlike more complex dynamics.</p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/your-online-secrets/201409/internet-trolls-are-narcissists-psychopaths-and-sadists">Studies have associated</a> trolling with the so called “dark tetrad” personality traits: narcissism, psychopathy, Machiavellianism and sadism. As with narcissism, I regard the others, you guessed it, as trauma responses.</p><p>Small to moderate amounts of those “dark” traits are highly prevalent. When a part gets triggered, they can raise their head. I’ve seen otherwise friendly and thoughtful people engage in trollish activities when triggered. This, like many nuanced phenomena, would not be captured by research, as the individuals would not label themselves as “Internet trolls”.</p><p>Trolling is more about gaining attention while bullying focuses the attention on another person. Cyberbullying is one of the most tragic aspects of online communities, which has led to a number of documented cases of <a href="https://jaapl.org/content/early/2023/02/23/JAAPL.220078-22">suicide</a>. As a result, many jurisdictions have legislated harsh penalties against it, often more so than bullying offline.</p><p>Typically, cyberbullying gets associated with communities of teens and especially the gaming scene. Alas, you can find it on all kinds of social media, obviously offline, too. Among younger people, it may focus on spreading rumors, impersonating the person or making fun of their appearance.</p><p>Grownups bullying other grownups tends to look radically different. Instead of blatant insults, the bully might criticize every single thing that someone posts in public, but using relatively civilized language, and gang up with others to do the same. Even seemingly insignificant opinions and comments may be picked apart.</p><p>A classic sign of bullying both online and in real-life contexts on is <em>someone’s words receiving peculiar reactions</em>. Through projection, their views get interpreted in the least generous way possible. If you imagine another person in the community expressing the exact same thing, the reception would be very different.</p><p>The activity may escalate gradually, while others besides the subject may not pay much attention to it. Complaining about unfair treatment may be labeled overreaction, drama, fighting or personal attacks. This gaslighting further perpetuates the abuse. If the bullied person gets triggered, they might be the one getting banned or facing a timeout.</p><p>Provoking someone until they lash out and then blaming them is a classical abuse dynamic. Lundy Bancroft illustrates it in his book <em>Why Does He Do That? Inside the Minds of Angry and Controlling Men</em> (I completely disagree with him on the origins of abuse, but his depictions of how it manifests are mostly spot on.) This quote is from the perspective of a former physical batterer Ty:</p><p>“<em>Then [the police officers] would look at her, and she’d be the one who was totally out of control, because I had just degraded her and put her in fear. I’d say to the police, ‘See, it isn’t me.’</em>” (pp. 36–37)</p><p>Some types of bullying almost exclusively exist online, though can lead to atrocious real-world consequences. Posting personal information about someone on the Internet without consent is called <em>doxxing</em>. Such acts have resulted in real-life harassment and stalking. <em>Swatting</em> is a form of harassment where the police is called to the victim’s address falsely reporting something like a bomb threat, ensuring a drastic response.</p><p><em>Sockpuppeting</em> was already well-known in online communities in the 90s. The term refers to someone using multiple accounts pretending to be different people, with the goal of circumventing bans, boosting their own posts or harassing others. My own suspicion is that some cases of sockpuppeting stem from the inner fragmentation of structural dissociation: the desire to actually inhabit multiple distinct identities.</p><h4><strong><em>Collective Fawn</em></strong></h4><p>Fawn is a trauma response also known as appeasement, people pleasing, conflict-avoidance or lack of boundaries. It may manifest as an inability to say no, to stand out or to express any disagreement.</p><p>Fawn has assumed a central role in our society and is a load-bearing aspect of many communities. Most of us want to fit in somewhere, to belong, and fawn is a tempting method of reassurance of that. (In her <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/01/19/fawning-ingrid-clayton-book-review-are-you-mad-at-me-meg-josephson">New Yorker article</a> on fawning, Katy Waldman concludes that Instagram and other social media are a more plausible source of the pervasiveness of fawn than trauma. I disagree, but the claim is not entirely without merit.)</p><p>One can fawn in some contexts despite being a generally dominant and assertive person, with most of us occasionally exhibiting such responses. On the other hand, there is no shortage of individuals whose entire personality is structured around fawn to the point that they may harbor little sense of individuality.</p><p>While fawn is ubiquitous, it renders authenticity impossible. Thus I posit it tends to harm all parties in a relationship, though it’s particularly damaging to the fawner. When a whole community rests on fawn, it becomes much more destructive still, a tool for molding members’ views to conform to the allowed truth. Often this evolves just as close to an actual cult dynamic as it sounds.</p><p><a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/lurking-in-the-shadows-harmful-interpersonal-patterns-in-spiritual-communities-90890b9226ba">Spiritual communities</a> are particularly vulnerable to cult-like fawning, but it can happen in almost any type of group, online or offline. The most baffling one I’ve experienced has been with a music community. Fawning is strongly associated with women, but men also do it and I’ve also encountered collective fawn in male-preponderant settings.</p><p>Collective fawn leans on dissociation to facilitate its extreme denial. In a community established on fawn, there is a tacit agreement about holding certain opinions, even if they are at odds with reality. Some subjects are above any criticism and attempts at questioning that idea are viewed as bad faith antagonism.</p><p>Curiously, Theodore L. Dorpat, along with some other psychoanalysts, was of the opinion that groups are held together more by what is <em>denied together</em> rather than what is shared:</p><blockquote>“<em>Groups, whether large or small, are as vulnerable as individuals to denial and self-deception. . . . According to [Wilfred] Bion, a most crucial aspect of a group mentality are those basic assumptions about how to handle anxiety-evoking information. This includes an unconscious collusion by the group members about what to deny.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Persons in groups come to share a large number of schemas, most of which are communicated without being spoken of directly. Foremost among those shared, yet unspoken, schemas are what group members are tacitly enjoined to deny. When the persons in a group have made the tacit or unconscious choice about what they will deny, they have established a shared defense</em>.” <em>(p. 26)</em></blockquote><h4><strong><em>Community Dynamics Are Challenging to Make Sense of</em></strong></h4><p>It’s tricky to spot collective fawn, as the core belief tends to be that we are a <em>good community</em>, we don’t engage in drama or fighting. We don’t criticize the moderator, the music industry professional or the meditation teacher no matter what they may have done. If you allow yourself to see past that, you are already the antagonist, and trying to do anything about it is nearly impossible.</p><p>A telltale sign of a fawn-oriented community is the plentiful talk in private about the conduct of certain members or voicing other ideas thatin public would be off limits. This could be labeled triangulation, but that completely ignores the larger patterns at play.</p><p>In private, people may admit something is off about the dynamic as long as they don’t have to do anything about it. Of course, if you are knee-deep in the fawn, these direct messages may go to others, not you.</p><p>In the first very cultish community I was a part of, several members were struck by new-onset psychotic episodes, despite the group barely consisting of a dozen people. It’s hard to say for certain how much the denial-based dynamic may have contributed, but I strongly suspect it did.</p><p>“It’s just text on the screen” is also an argument used to devalue the importance of online communities and culture. They consist of real people (at least for the most part, in the age of AI) and depending on the dynamics can have a huge positive or negative impact on our lives and mental health.</p><p>My writings on trauma as the root of problematic conduct are regularly criticized with the concern that such ideas unfairly absolve perpetrators of responsibility. I don’t find this to be the case at all, however. Obviously no one is allowed to treat others in damaging ways even if that originates from their trauma, but in practice that is something pervasive.</p><p>I maintain that a more nuanced grasp of interpersonal dynamics and their potential origins helps us see more clearly what might be transpiring, and hopefully allows for solutions to arise, as well. How could one even assign blame without understanding what exactly is (and isn’t) going on? That is just likely to fabricate more layers of projection, something our communities already tend to be stacked full of.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58e3f0243c4f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[All the Preachers Are Broken]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/all-the-preachers-are-broken-3c93ad6d94f7?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c93ad6d94f7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rock-and-roll]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Sep 2025 12:11:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-29T12:11:12.629Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>My Spiritual Explorations in Buddhism and Rock’n’Roll and Their Traumatic Origins</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3O9w-BuEkgIIMBxY7cVDWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Joker Out playing at PIN Conference, Skopje, North Macedonia 12/2023. Photo by Maija Haavisto.</figcaption></figure><p>When I talk about rock’n’roll, I’m not talking about a music genre. Not all rock music is rock’n’roll the way I view it, while something like rap can certainly be (and drum ’n’ bass is <em>extremely</em> rock’n’roll). Rock’n’roll can point to an experience in a live show or it can refer to a lifestyle of the stars.</p><p>My first rock concert was at Helsinki Olympic Stadium in 1996. I was 12 and seated somewhere in the stands, not very close to the stage, with my dad. My first <em>Rock Gig</em>, however, was three years after that, in the second row of now-defunct Club Gloria. It was sweaty and primal and <em>perfect</em>, with unmistakably sexual undertones. I still remember having the ponytail of the girl in front of me constantly on my face as she flailed around wildly.</p><p>In the decades after that I’ve been to live shows in seven different countries, including nations almost no one has ever heard of (like three gigs in North Macedonia). Certainly I enjoy listening to music at home, too, but live it gains another dimension to it and for me, that is the <em>thing</em>.</p><p>Everything works better live. I find poetry readings enchanting and theater is a whole different beast from cinema. If you have ever been to a comedy show, you probably found it much funnier than similar material on video.</p><p>Similarly, many people love symphony orchestras, jazz bars, heartfelt singer-songwriter performances or pop idols with epic choreographies. For me, those generally don’t do much. Both the artist and the audience going wild is what takes it so much deeper for me.</p><p>I used to say that a good rock gig is like having sex while going to church. More recently, I formulated a more intense version of the same as “opening portals”. Other types of performances have never done this to me, they haven’t evoked powerful altered states and even mystical experiences.</p><p>Many others no doubt find a classical music concert transcendent, I just don’t. When my favorite Finnish band played a seated music hall show, it left me disappointed. There was probably nothing wrong with the performance. It just wasn’t what I’m looking for.</p><p>Around 15 years ago it first dawned on me how <em>spiritual</em> it all was. That a rock concert was a modern sacred ritual, a worship ceremony. If I didn’t hail from a rampantly secular family eschewing all forms of spirituality, I probably would have connected the dots far earlier.</p><p>A long time ago, when my health was better, I also used to frequent raves and similar dance music events. The connection between that and spirituality had been more obvious. Many of those events held in forests and other gorgeous nature. It’s such a different experience compared to the clinical insides of an arena.</p><p>That scene embraces altered states more explicitly — one of the main genres of electronic dance music is named <em>trance</em>, after all. Many seek them with the aid of substances, but the events itself are enough to provide such states.</p><p>The dance scene seemed to hold that the crowd created the atmosphere and in rock music, it was more about the artists on stage. I even heard claims that “Finns are silly for facing the DJ while dancing”, with the implication that we acted like we were worshiping them, how embarrassing. From what I’ve seen, people tend to orient themselves like that elsewhere, too. For some, DJs are certainly stars and idols just like rock bands.</p><p>My own rock’n’roll experience also necessitates being fairly close to the stage, preferably in the front row or at least near the front. From further away, it’s just not the same, as it’s partially about connection with the artists. Many fans are obsessed with “getting barricade” (front row) as a sort of trophy, sometimes willing to even physically fight for the coveted spots.</p><p>It makes sense that it’s easier to open a portal from close up.</p><h4><strong>Dipping My Toes Into Religion</strong></h4><p>In 2017, a very turbulent period in my health and other aspects of my life led me to trying meditation for the first time. Focusing on the breath never did much for me, but particularly <em>mettā</em> or loving-kindness meditation felt like I had come home.</p><p>Most people likely associate meditation with states of deep tranquility, but for me joy was the main draw. From the start, with mettā I was able to conjure up so much joy, happiness and love it almost felt like a cheat of some sort. Why wasn’t everyone doing this all the time?</p><p>Mettā practice was originally described by the Buddha and it quickly led me into Buddhism. They had invented this stuff, so surely they must have known what they were doing.</p><p>Coming from a secular background, Buddhism came off as cozy and down-to-earth. Though certainly not representative of the religion as a whole, the first time I happened upon the /r/Buddhism Reddit sub, they were cracking jokes about weird scriptural mentions of Gautama Buddha’s genitals. As a comedy fan, I appreciated that vibe, not taking things too seriously.</p><p>Religion is a fandom, that’s the whole point of it. I did enjoy some other devotional practices, but I never got into actual worship of the Buddha even if I was a fan of his <em>stuff</em>. Many are keen on it, however, or worship bodhisattvas, deities or gurus. Although meditation has been the focus of the Western mindfulness movement, most traditional Buddhist practices revolve around <a href="https://www.insightmeditationcenter.org/books-articles/rituals-in-buddhism/">offerings, ceremonies, rituals and devotional elements</a>.</p><p>It was easy to make practice the center of your life — that was not considered weird or obsessive, but more like the norm. A religion like Buddhism allows you to fill nearly 100% of your time, if you meditate, pray, chant, engage in rituals, watch dharma talks and study religious texts.</p><p>You can walk meditatively, eat mindfully and turn conversations into a practice. Some even attempt to maintain mindfulness all the time. For extra productivity, one can learn Tibetan dream yoga (<em>milam naljor</em>), based on lucid dreaming, so that you’re practicing even in your sleep.</p><p>Religions tend to promise a wealth of amazing boons, like eternal happiness. Buddhism goes about it slightly differently: it offers an end to suffering that no one else can deliver, enlightenment you can only attain by meditation.</p><p>Many people, even rational types, treat this as a fact, but I argue this isn’t any different from believing that Heaven is real and Jesus is the only doorway to it. For the intellectual, Buddhism has some clever attractions supporting its claims, allowing one to insist that it isn’t <em>really</em> a religion. I’ve even seen bizarre assertions that Buddhism is actually a <em>science</em>!</p><p>As an example, the Buddha described eight pleasant altered states accessible by meditation, called the <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/jh%C4%81nas-as-easily-accessible-insight-practice-everything-you-know-about-meditative-absorptions-2cbe7015a97e"><em>jhānas</em></a>. I was eventually able to access all of them and was very impressed by the whole thing. It also appeared to confirm that scriptural concepts did correspond to real-world phenomena.</p><p>I also underwent deeply profound and largely permanent shifts which mostly aligned with the <a href="https://www.mctb.org/mctb2/table-of-contents/part-v-awakening/37-models-of-the-stages-of-awakening/the-theravada-four-path-model/">stages and paths of enlightenment</a> from Theravāda Buddhism. These phenomenological replications helped strengthen my trust in that this religion could actually deliver what it promised — something that billions of others believe about their own faiths for reasons they find equally convincing.</p><h4><strong>Problems with Buddhism</strong></h4><p>Canonically, Siddharta Gautama left his family for his spiritual pursuits and many continue to be intrigued by the escapist, transcendent aspects of his legacy. If you shun relationships and enclose yourself in a cave for years, as some do, it’s much easier to imagine dharma and meditation can solve all your problems. Buddhist psychotherapist John Welwood, who originally coined the term “spiritual bypassing” for these kinds of ideas, believed this approach was very attractive <a href="http://www.johnwelwood.com/articles/TRIC_interview_uncut.pdf">for those with avoidant attachment</a>. For me such disconnection just never felt spiritual at all.</p><p>Originally I assumed that meditators, especially long-time practitioners, would be calm, loving, pleasant people. Yet the more time I spent in Buddhist communities, the more <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/lurking-in-the-shadows-harmful-interpersonal-patterns-in-spiritual-communities-90890b9226ba">troubled individuals I encountered</a>. Ones who had meditated for 10 years or 20 years or claimed to be enlightened, boasting how advanced their spiritual prowess was and how they did not have ego or self, just unconditional love.</p><p>Yet many of them remained deeply traumatized, which showed up in egoistic, narcissistic, controlling and manipulative tendencies or treating others with contempt. Some were cheating on their partners, enamored with alcohol or other substances or prone to bouts of explosive rage. These included actual teachers, too. Worshiping a person tends to cloud your judgment about them and makes it easy to ignore red flags.</p><p>Many of my observations matched the established concept of <em>spiritual narcissism</em>. <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/ejsp.2721">One study</a> on it concluded: “<em>[T]he self-enhancement motive is powerful and deeply ingrained so that it can hijack methods intended to transcend the ego and instead, adopt them to its own service. . .The road to spiritual enlightenment may yield the exact same mundane distortions that are all too familiar in social psychology, such as self-enhancement, illusory superiority, closed-mindedness, and hedonism (clinging to positive experiences) under the guise of alleged ‘higher’ values.</em>”</p><p>There was smugness, fighting and mansplaining. It saddened me how many people were stuck in distressing thought loops about whether their thinking or deeds or those of others were “wholesome” or “unwholesome”, right speech or wrong speech. Some even considered their resulting troubling fixations to <a href="https://www.mcleanhospital.org/essential/scrupulosity">resemble OCD</a>. In general, the whole idea of shaming people and concepts resembling sin are the opposite of what spirituality means to me.</p><p>One could argue that I was just unlucky with the company I found, that some other spiritual communities are free from these issues. Perhaps, though I’m doubtful, as people are people and religion does little to change that.</p><p>In some branches of Zen, practice may involve nothing but sitting on the cushion for years, during which not much is supposed to happen, until suddenly you become enlightened. Most other schools of Buddhism feature various “maps” of skills and levels, however. Even if you don’t feel a need to compare your abilities with others, it’s tempting to focus on these attainments, which may not correspond to improvement in well-being or interpersonal relationships.</p><p>I did certainly reap some benefits from meditation, though they were much overstated. This has been the general impression for most others I know, as well. As an example, it turns out that the so-called “no-self”, while kind of neat and helpful for some aspects of life, does little to eradicate suffering, let alone to fix concrete problems. I strongly suspect that many of the perks ascribed to advanced parts of the Buddhist path relate more to dynamics around traumatic dissociation, something outside of my experiential reality.</p><p>Alas, engaging in spiritual practices also led to severe bodily harm for me, including permanent organ damage. The <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/dark-nights-spiritual-crises-and-psychotic-breaks-6f3bdfb24f5a">risks of meditation</a>, both psychological and physical, have been known since antiquity and nowadays are also reported in academic articles, but they are easy to shrug off. I had heard disturbing things about “<a href="https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/wp-content/uploads/sites/360/2016/12/OTH16-Greyson.pdf">Kundalini syndrome</a>” before beginning, but didn’t really consider the potential hazards to my pre-existing health conditions. It was just quietly sitting, right?</p><h4><strong>Portals and Gateways</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*65bjBfRS0vN-Nv22ma2s5w.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>An unidentified DJ playing at a cave party in Helsinki, Finland 7/2008. Photo by Maija Haavisto.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Music forms a major part of their worship for many Christians. The same goes for some Buddhists, too, but others take the view that all music outside of monotonous chanting should be avoided, because it says so in the scripture (e.g. <a href="https://www.buddha-vacana.org/sutta/anguttara/05/an05-209.html">Gītassara sutta</a>). In Buddhist monastic code, music is entirely forbidden.</p><p>Dance is regarded with even more suspicion. Curiously, however, scholar Joseph Houseal claimed in an <a href="https://www.buddhistdoor.net/features/three-aspects-of-buddhist-dance/">article</a> in Buddhistdoor magazine that: “<em>Buddhism has more dance than any other religion. . .As religious art goes, there is no religion that depicts so much dancing as Buddhism does. It is everywhere in the cultures and in the art. It is a core religious expression, being energized life itself.</em>” To me, “energized life itself” sounds about right. I find dancing so obviously profound, sacred, nourishing and life-affirming that nothing could convince me it’s detrimental.</p><p>For lay practitioners, Buddhism isn’t too fussed when it comes to rules about sex and sexuality — though there are differing opinions on that, too — but monastics have strict rules forbidding even touch among family members of different genders. In other faiths, celibacy tends to similarly be required from monastics, yet in Buddhism, monasticism plays a central role rather than being a marginal aspiration.</p><p>In comparison to religion, rock’n’roll has always been subversive. It has embraced misfits, queer people and those with mental health struggles. To some extent also physically disabled people, though like with most scenes, with some major caveats. Rock gigs are a terrible environment for most individuals with chronic illness and certainly not doing any favors to my own body, either, especially with the grave risks posed by the ongoing pandemic.</p><p>Rock’n’roll doesn’t proscribe sin, it welcomes it with open arms. While Buddhism attempts to do away with suffering, rock’n’roll revels in it, turning a ubiquitous and perhaps banal experience into something beautiful and profound. Some comparisons could perhaps be drawn to the esoteric schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Unlike the more purity-focused approaches, Tibetan tantra <a href="https://www.wisdomlib.org/concept/five-conflicting-emotions">sees value</a> in both “positive” and “negative” emotions.</p><h4><strong>A New Beginning</strong></h4><p>After five years of daily practice, in late 2022 I mostly quit meditation. It seemed like I had got everything out of practice that I possibly could, which is how I still regard it. I thought I might get back to it, but so far that has only happened for short periods.</p><p>With my serious health conditions which most people found too challenging to deal with, there was little left in my life. Trying to find ways to fill that hole, I was sucked back into rock’n’roll. Initially it was a wonderful reunion, though soon it became clearer how problematic it all was, too.</p><p>When I moved to the Balkans, I fell in love with the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL164KejAoajz9pDIHeUMUNRFulcnww5dx">popular music of the region</a>. Rock’n’roll also became much more spiritual for me. The crowds here are a wild, ecstatic whirlwind with an intensity not quite matched elsewhere. Even listened to at home, Balkan music also has spiritual dimensions that I did not previously have access to, though it’s hard to put it into words, why does A feel more spiritual than B.</p><p>I suspect it partially relates to the disturbing trauma the region has endured in recent history, with dictators, wars and genocide during my lifetime. Mental healthcare was viewed as a weapon of the oppressive regimes, so art emerged as the main tool for resistance and healing alike. The biggest music festival in the Balkans, EXIT in Novi Sad, Serbia, originally <a href="https://www.new-east-archive.org/articles/show/8557/exit-festival-how-students-partied-bring-down-slobodan-milosevic">started as a political protest</a>, a highly successful one. Alas, after 25 years, this summer they announced they will be relocating out of the country, which is again struggling with an authoritarian leader.</p><p>Another component is the language. Honestly, I don’t find English very well-suited for music. I used to enjoy Hindu devotional music in Sanskrit, but now I prefer Slovenian, a descendant of Sanskrit that inherited the nightmarish grammar and the soft sibilants. Rich and mellifluous, vocals sound perfect in it. I also listen to many artists who perform in other South Slavic languages: Serbo-Croatian, Bulgarian and Macedonian.</p><p>My decades of ever worsening health have formed an unfortunate hurdle against one of my main values which is <em>aliveness</em>. Rock’n’roll is one of the few remaining sources of that quality in my life — which is quite ironic now that I’m very ill with heart failure. It’s not meant for people like me, but then nothing is.</p><p>Still, I’ve traveled to gigs in other countries, slipped into moshpits and dreamed of crowdsurfing knowing that these moments of aliveness could well prove fatal. Because why would you even live if not for being <em>alive</em>?</p><p>While both rock gigs and contemplative practices offer routes to altered states, the former have felt more meaningful and mystical to me. They are relational, shared and co-created, as well as highly embodied and unique. No two shows are ever alike.</p><p>I also relish witnessing the individual reactions of crowd members: bliss and tears, little kids and old people alike having a blast. Beautiful little moments of human connection.</p><p>When facing the prospect of death, many find comfort in faith, teachings and scripture. My prayers ring out of Marshall amps and are chanted by frenzied crowds. “We want more”, they shout in unison. And don’t we all?</p><h4><strong>Destructive Fame, Narcissism and Other Comorbidities of Stardom</strong></h4><p>Even if I never expected it to lead me to salvation, my relationship with rock’n’roll has been equally complicated to the one I’ve had with Buddhism. The scene doesn’t exactly have the best rep, with expressions like “sex, drugs and rock’n’roll” and “The 27 Club” hinting at its troubled history.</p><p>The 27 Club is, of course, a <a href="https://theconversation.com/the-27-club-isnt-true-but-it-is-real-a-sociologist-explains-why-myths-endure-and-how-they-shape-reality-242693">myth</a>.<strong> </strong>It is mostly based on a handful of legendary musicians who tragically died very young decades ago, which has biased media visibility of further deaths.</p><p>Nowadays, mental health treatment enjoys a vastly improved availability and is much less of a taboo. (Also, we have naloxone.) Though when I was a part of the electronic music scene, I did lose several of my favorite Finnish artists to drug-related causes.</p><p>I maintain that you have to be highly traumatized to pursue stardom at all and that prerequisites include e.g. <a href="https://www.proquest.com/openview/931065ca41253cf4982f46743d92f8ad/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&amp;cbl=18750&amp;diss=y">narcissistic traits</a> and people-pleasing tendencies. Successfully pulling it off takes a huge amount of charisma, which I (along with several other authors) classify as a trauma response, as I discuss in my free book <a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/"><em>Shattered White-Out: How Trauma and Dissociation Mold the World, Your Relationships and You</em></a>.</p><p>Narcissistic traits have a nasty ring and not without a reason. Yet they are a higly prevalent trauma response associated with severe <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">dissociation</a>, but not always with abusive behavior. Contrary to a common idea, narcissistic people don’t love themselves. They believe, or <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">a part of them</a> believes, that they are special, yet cannot feel it without constant adulation. Simultaneously they fear being fundamentally broken and this sense of inferiority threatens to break through.</p><p>The actual stardom may sadly result in further trauma and exacerbate existing trauma-based tendencies for issues like attention seeking, overworking, addiction to the buzz of fight/flight states, grandiosity, self-criticism, perfectionism, rejection sensitivity, “fawn” responses and other types of poor boundaries (with fans or colleagues). These may be followed by burnout, depression, paranoia, anxiety, body dysmorphia, escapism, hedonism, substance use and sexual escapades.</p><p>Most of these devastating issues I have witnessed in abundance in spiritual communities, too. There you may often find more of so-called <a href="https://healingtreenonprofit.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Trauma-Bonds-by-Patrick-Carnes-1.pdf"><em>compulsive deprivation</em></a> rather than hedonistic pursuits, but there are also gurus with lavish lifestyles.</p><p>No matter if you are a musician, actor or a visual artist, there is a temptation to inhabit the role of an <em>artist</em>, whether that is eccentric, mad, reckless, incomprehensible or long-suffering. With rock’n’roll, you can even play God. Trauma is often associated with a hazy sense of self and playing a role may further exacerbate this. What starts off as innocent roleplay may end in getting lost in the character.</p><p>It’s hard to fully grasp the all-embracing aspects of fame in stardom. I know I can’t, because I’ve only been a C-list celebrity in a small country. For some performing artists, recognition feels mildly unpleasant. For others, it’s completely intolerable past a certain point (in which case they are likely to shun actual stardom). A few find it addictive. Some celebrities never tire of attention, but most do.</p><p>Honestly, it seems astonishing to me that people can pull this off for prolonged periods, even decades, like many rock legends have. I suspect that dissociation plays a major part in tolerating the downsides, helping it feel worth it.</p><h4><strong>The “Fawndom”</strong></h4><p>People have always worshiped, whether gods, war heroes or fictional characters. A fandom is a sort of religion just like a religion is a form of fandom.</p><p>Instagram and other similar media have transformed worship and created new types of stardom. I’ve come to find this side of social media deeply off-putting. Even trying to follow artists I like has mostly come off like watching a shopping network, the opposite of what I seek from the scene, and only served to tank my interest.</p><p>Surprisingly similar dynamics emerge inside of fandoms as those formed between fans and the actual idols. “Superfans” queue all night for every gig and own every item of merch. They know the artist personally, or at least would like to think they do based on interactions they’ve had.</p><p>They mingle with the crews and other prominent fans and trade the latest gossip (about both the idols and their fandom). They make the rules for what is acceptable in queues and online spaces. If they wait for the band near the backstage for two hours, that’s normal, but someone else staying for three hours is creepy and stalkerish.</p><p>All of this isn’t necessarily bad. Some of it makes me think of unpleasant types I knew in spiritual circles, like people constantly namedropping their teachers and past retreats with little else to say. Or those who insisted that everyone is practicing wrong except for them and had highly detailed (and often frankly bizarre) rules of what qualified as right or wrong practices.</p><p>Some fandoms I’ve been a part of have teemed with constant drama, while others have turned into more of a <em>fawndom</em>, with fawning forming the predominant response to everything. The latter tends to come off as very cult-like, similar to some spiritual communities, and it’s a huge turn-off for me. But then, most communities contain highly problematic elements, anyway. That’s just how human relationships work.</p><p>The whole thing is a mess, like everything that is made of people tends to be. Perhaps the mess is a part of it. Rock’n’roll doesn’t claim to be a science or even to be good for you.</p><h4><strong>Deus Ex Machina</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JNqiCllZA8K7eKAnOEJsSA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Maika playing at PIN Conference, Skopje, North Macedonia 12/2023. Photo by Maija Haavisto.</em></figcaption></figure><p>My idols, if that’s what you want to call them, may not shoot dope, do lines or pop quaaludes to doze off at night. Yet many of them are workaholics who drink and smoke in excess. Depressed and burnt out, they are too wound up to sleep and constantly dissociate to cover up their anxiety. Then other fans eagerly comment on how happy they look, making me wonder “You can’t be serious? This person is hanging on to a thread.”</p><p>How can one idolize someone or something when you’re really witnessing a painful, destructive cycle of hypervigilance, shame and dissociation?</p><p>It just makes me feel sad, so I don’t think I can do that anymore, and maybe there is no need to. I will enjoy the show and delight in its profound, transcendental qualities. For brief moments I can still convince myself that these are modern gods when they take on such a role on stage.</p><p>Am I enabling something very unhealthy? Probably. Simultaneously, it provides emotional comfort and resonance for me and millions of others, mixed with subversion and rebellion.</p><p>One could argue that isn’t just about all spiritual seeking trauma-based. By “spiritual seeking”, I particularly refer to spirituality as a pursuit of a <em>fix</em>. In many ways, “spirituality” and “trauma” could even be treated as synonymous.</p><p>At the core, all of society is built on trauma. Both religion and rock’n’roll are journeys even deeper into the heart of trauma. This creates great intensity in both good and bad, and rock’n’roll is meant to be simultaneously good and bad.</p><p>Maybe that’s my practice now, trying to reconcile all this. Gods are broken, teachers and preachers are broken. The fans are broken too, we are all broken and yet pretend not to be, that some of us aren’t. That’s why it’s called a show and the longer you queue, the more convincing it is.</p><blockquote><em>“</em>In the day-to-day trenches of adult life, there is actually no such thing as atheism. There is no such thing as not worshipping. Everybody worships. The only choice we get is what to worship.<em>”</em><br><em>– David Foster Wallace</em></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c93ad6d94f7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gaslighting Death]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/gaslighting-death-4ead6f087de9?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ead6f087de9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chronic-illness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dissociation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaslighting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Jul 2025 11:28:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-21T11:29:15.280Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Life-Threatening Conditions Are Too Triggering and Get Dissociated Away</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mbFifW9mbWmvaoqyjwaDKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by Fitra Zulfy @ Unsplash.com</figcaption></figure><p>Those who like to think of themselves as particularly rational may feel aligned with the idea that humans invented religion as a “copium” against the reality of death, to banish it away. Yet <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">dissociation</a> and other related mental moves seem like much more common methods for such denial, often by these same people. It’s possible to accept death in some ways yet feel very triggered by or in denial of it in others.</p><p>Chronic illness hints at our mortality and the fragility of our bodies, which makes society highly uncomfortable with it. Some years ago I wrote an <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/why-healthy-people-abandon-their-chronically-ill-friends-2d7d6231949">article</a> about that explaining the mechanics of thought processes behind it, but this piece delves deeper into the explicit aspect of death and why many seek to gaslight it.</p><p>Disabled individuals who have been let down by their friends and families often suggest that others would react more sympathetically to an illness which causes you to either perish or get better, like many types of cancer, rather than something that lingers on for decades.</p><p>I strongly disagree. I believe that most grownups are entirely unable to deal with their own or someone else’s mortality, so they tend to find more obviously deadly and life-threatening conditions even more triggering.</p><p>It almost feels like there are two distinct realities with this. One is the world we read about in the news, where someone is diagnosed with cancer and others rally to their rescue, bringing homecooked meals and running marathons to raise funds for research. Having dealt with many life-threatening conditions, this is something I’ve never experienced, nor have most others I’ve known in such a situation.</p><p>In our reality, death just scares people off. Rather than running marathons, they run away.</p><p>Often you can hear in people’s words how <em>perplexed</em> they are by death. “I can’t believe my mother is really gone”, they say. Obviously, parental death is a huge shock and devastation, but there seems to be further disbelief underlying that: it was not supposed to happen. Not <em>yet</em> for sure, but also not ever. Not to me, not to us.</p><p>I used to follow the thought-provoking blog of a woman who was sick with an invariably fatal condition for several years, in an out of hospitals, her condition steadily and also visibly deteriorating. When she finally succumbed to the illness, several regular readers still expressed disbelief. How could this happen? How could she <em>really</em> die?</p><h4><strong>Gaslighting</strong></h4><p>Gaslighting, or attempts to distort others’ reality and make them doubt their own experience, has received increasing attention in recent years. Some even consider it an overused “fad” term. However, the book I believe describes this phenomenon the best, Theodore L. Dorpat’s <em>Gaslighting, the Double Whammy, Interrogation and Other Methods of Covert Control in Psychotherapy and Analysis</em>, was published in 1996.</p><p>As the title suggests, it focuses on gaslighting in psychotherapy, but also provides a helpful overview of how this phenomenon plays out in society at large. Dorpat believed, as I do, gaslighting to be a ubiquitous mode of communication, and contrary to the typical assumption, people tend to utilize it without conscious intent to. I view it as an extension of dissociation: <em>I refuse to accept this as a part of my reality, so it cannot be a part of yours, either</em>.</p><p><em>Medical gaslighting</em> in particular is finally receiving the attention it sorely deserves. The vast majority of <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=%22medical+gaslighting%22">papers on the subject</a> were only published in the last couple of years — I wrote a book in 2011 dealing with this topic, among others, and had very little to cite, and for my 2020 <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/medical-trauma-6fa90c6ecab0">article on medical trauma</a> there was only marginally more. <a href="https://www.jpsmjournal.com/article/S0885-3924(18)30229-X/fulltext">Dissociation in healthcare providers</a> is another subject that has only really begun to be studied recently, but I believe its true implications remain unrecognized.</p><p>For most chronically ill people, being gaslit by doctors is a habitual experience. Those around us do that, too: unable to handle our reality, they try to convince both themselves and us that it’s not real or it’s not <em>that</em> bad. Medical professionals can similarly get triggered by sickness and by patients not getting better. This denial connects to other trauma responses pervading the entire healthcare system, including power and control.</p><p>Even doctors who work with dying patients tend to experience denial and dissociation related to it. In oncology, a well-known tendency is <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26203912/">continuing cancer treatments</a> past the point when they are more likely to only do harm and reluctance to move onto palliative care. Many studies have found that contrary to a common narrative, in terminal cancer doctors are much more likely to <a href="https://www.bmj.com/content/327/7408/195">overestimate the remaining life expectancy</a> than to underestimate it.</p><h4><strong>My Own Experiences</strong></h4><p>For me, gaslighting about death began decades ago when I was just 16. I suddenly fell very ill and among other challenging and concerning ailments such as 24/7 fever, I developed major heart symptoms. Yet people around me told me they were nothing. Young people don’t get heart attacks, after all, so what else would it be?</p><p>When I finally sought medical care two years later, the automatic report from the ECG machine actually concluded that the abnormalities present suggested a previous heart attack. My doctor brushed it off, insisting that such technology makes mistakes all the time. He told me to exercise more.</p><p>However, even with the rudimentary search tools we had available in the early 2000s, I was able to confirm that my ECG was far from normal. It did not necessarily mean I had experienced an actual MI, but something was very off.</p><p>Several years later, I discovered by accident that this GP had diagnosed me with myocarditis, inflammation of the heart muscle. I was never told and I might well have never found out I had been given such a diagnosis by a doctor who recommended increased exercise, when the main treatment for myocarditis is to avoid exertion.</p><p>As years passed, I developed several other life-threatening conditions such as adrenal insufficiency and gastroparesis, which despite my best attempts others really struggled to comprehend. Only much later did it dawn on me how much those communication difficulties boiled down to the other party <em>wanting</em> to stay in the dark. Despite witnessing me lose 40% of my body weight and nearly starving to death, they preferred to maintain these as minor inconveniences.</p><p>In 2017, I almost succumbed to a rare acute kidney issue. When this condition recurred the following year, people around me were mostly dismissive. One guy even tried to convince me that the problem was caused by “rejection anxiety [something I’ve never even had, but he made it up] and insufficient fiber”. Yes, that’s exactly what causes life-threatening kidney dysfunction. An expert gaslighter and a bully, this individual is now also a professor of psychology in Finland.</p><p>Some years later I started experiencing bouts of dramatic cardiac symptoms. Not surprisingly, others again mostly assured me they were nothing. A close friend even got furious and terminated our friendship because he couldn’t deal with it, presumably my concern over this “nothing”. I was quite sure something was badly amiss, but especially as the symptoms could completely abate for periods of nearly a year, it was easier to concur that maybe it indeed was benign.</p><p>Alas, these nothings ultimately resulted in heart failure. Even all my years with myriad serious chronic ailments had not prepared me to the peculiar, even bizarre, ways people tend to react to the news.</p><p>Quite different from any of my previous diagnoses, others’ reactions mostly fall into four categories: 1) ignoring it or stopping replying to my messages altogether 2) acting overtly triggered 4) becoming very confused or reacting in a confusing way 4) concluding that it must be something fairly harmless. Few people have the capacity for more than that.</p><p>Dissociation is such a powerful mechanism of cognitive dissonance that it can even distort how language is processed. It’s hard to grasp how the words “heart failure” can be interpreted as something trivial, unless you realize it stems from a desperate <em>need</em> to perceive it like that. That it’s failing just a little bit, mildly.</p><h4><strong>Dissociation, Avoidance, Cognitive Distortions and Spirituality</strong></h4><p>Avoidance of troubling subjects is one of the most widespread trauma responses and dissociation is the main tool for that. By pushing disturbing issues outside of your awareness, one can avoid being bothered by them, at least in the short term.</p><p>The so-called <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/attachment-style-parts-and-internal-family-systems-3058f93bf72b">avoidant attachment style</a> stems from trauma in early childhood. Studies estimate it to roughly describe 20% of people in most cultures, even if individuals are obviously more complicated and multifaceted than such labels.</p><p>The avoidance is particularly associated with relationships, withdrawing to avoid perceived attempts at control and enmeshment, yet it also has a strong effect on how the person<a href="https://adultattachment.faculty.ucdavis.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/66/2015/09/Hart_2005_Attachment-self-esteem-worldviews-and-terror-management.pdf"> relates with the world as a whole</a>. Those with avoidant attachment tend to live their lives in dissociation and denial.</p><p>Death is one of the predicaments many avoidant people try to ignore altogether, sometimes with the help of a more or less conscious belief in <a href="https://www.scu.edu/ethics/ethics-resources/ethical-decision-making/the-just-world-theory/">Just World theory</a>. For many, it’s comforting to maintain that the world is just and we get what we deserve, as that means <em>I am protected from harm</em>. With the help of dissociation, it can be twisted into further mental acrobatics, such as that others who smoke can develop COPD and lung cancer, but <em>I</em> (and my loved ones) can’t.</p><p>Anyone who has ever peeked into health communities online has seen what near-religious Just World beliefs can look like: the conviction that any malady can be cured or prevented with ivermectin, bone broth, green juices or whatever happens to be your talisman of choice to confer supposed perfect health. Alas, that is not how human bodies work. Risks can sometimes be reduced but never eliminated, something too painful for many to accept.</p><p>My ex partner refused to engage with the topic of death in any form, such as the life-threatening conditions I had. He insisted death was such a <em>minor thing</em> that it didn’t even warrant discussion. Imagine being so dissociated you manage to convince yourself that your wife’s demise would be so <em>insignificant</em> to not merit any consideration.</p><p>He refused to familiarize himself with even knowing which diagnoses I had in case of emergency. When his good friend jumped out of a window and I inquired about their condition a few days later, this was also shut off, as the whole thing was old news, and obviously inconsequential, anyway.</p><p>A common manifestation of dissociation and avoidant attachment is so-called <em>spiritual bypassing</em>, the idea that all answers to practical and psychological problems alike can be found in spirituality. Insidious in spiritual communities, this attitude has potential for serious harm, which e.g. Buddhist psychotherapist John Welwood (who originally coined the term) <a href="https://www.johnwelwood.com/articles/TRIC_interview_uncut.pdf">eloquently addressed</a>.</p><p>Bypassing commonly contains the claim that when you are spiritually advanced enough, you realize death “doesn’t really exist”, so you can just ignore it. Also, if anyone else is bothered by the idea of mortality and thus displaying their lack of spiritual prowess, they just need a hefty dose of more nonduality YouTube or whatever to <a href="https://deconstructingyourself.com/nondual-fundamentalism.html">fix them</a>. (For me, the permanent experience of nonduality has not really changed my perspective of death, because we still inhabit this chop-wood-carry-water reality.)</p><p>This conveniently aligns with some common societal beliefs, like that not wishing to die quite yet equals (obsessive) fear of death and is a sign of psychological immaturity, which sounds like projection to me. Society is heavily built on such ideas stemming from avoidant attachment. One particularly dissociated friend has even tried to convince me that death is a net positive for the individual and not accepting that suggests you lack the clarity that he possesses.</p><h4><strong>Like Little Sniffles</strong></h4><p>While my focus in this article is on individuals with terminal, life-limiting or life-threatening chronic conditions and attitudes towards them, it’s unavoidable to address the elephant in the room. By now, the pandemic has been raging on for well over five years. While COVID has become less deadly in its acute form, unfortunately it continues to result in <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-022-00846-2">widespread organ damage</a> (such as cardiovascular and brain damage). This is often disabling for even the healthiest individuals and down the line can also be fatal.</p><p>Nowadays for many, including some who have incurred such damage, COVID represents a mere inconvenience if even that. “It’s like a cold”, a typical dissociative reaction to unpleasant aspects of reality. How the pandemic is discussed often brings to mind of “death is insignificant” rhetoric of my former partner, as well as the way heart failure can be contorted into something trivial.</p><p>Not only have we allowed these avoidant trauma reactions dictate the pandemic response, but also the way society responds to chronic illness in general and particularly how it tends to shut out life-threatening and life-shortening conditions.</p><p>I suspect many of the rallies organized for cancer patients and casserole dishes brought are actually instigated by <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/why-healthy-people-abandon-their-chronically-ill-friends-2d7d6231949"><em>rescuer parts</em></a>, wounded aspects of the mind trying to control others by attempting to fix their lives. Though they can be forceful and lead to major conflict, at this point I would prefer them to ones that just disappear on me or react in bizarre ways. Yet obviously I don’t get to choose how others’ trauma manifests.</p><p>The unfortunate reality of many chronically ill individuals is that our lives are being devastated by other people’s trauma responses, those of both medical professionals and loved ones, even more than our actual illnesses. The more sick you are, the more likely it is to trigger others, especially if the suggestion of mortality comes to play.</p><p><em>This article is dedicated to the memory of journalist and CFS/ME advocate Bridget O’Shea, whose heartbreaking </em><a href="https://x.com/Bridget_OShea/status/1944388657000911219"><em>last tweet</em></a><em> on Jul 13, 2025 was “</em>I called my mom. I told her I’m afraid I’m going to die. Her response? She hung up. #MECFS<em>”. Bridget died days later.</em></p><p>***</p><p>If you want to learn more about trauma (and how chronic illness and traumatized healthcare systems traumatize people), dissociation, spiritual bypassing, attachment styles and gaslighting, check out my new book <a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/"><em>Shattered White-Out: How Trauma and Dissociation Mold the World, Your Relationships and You</em></a>, which is completely free.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ead6f087de9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Want to Heal But Also I Don’t: Why Do Many Feel Averse to Therapy and Trauma Work?]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/i-want-to-heal-but-also-i-dont-why-do-many-feel-averse-to-therapy-and-trauma-work-5330be0aa99d?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5330be0aa99d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dissociation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychotherapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Dec 2024 13:19:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-16T13:19:31.890Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Anti-Healing Parts Can Complicate Therapeutic Work and They Are Often Sneaky Liars</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gw-3WbcJhTqpSiguotbxjA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Picture by Dan Smedley @ Unsplash.com</figcaption></figure><p>If this article feels difficult for you to read and you feel like not finishing it, it might be helpful to feel into why that is — could it be caused by the anti-healing parts that it discusses?</p><p>Note: This article discusses the aversion to trauma healing and psychotherapy arising from the nature of trauma itself. Obviously, there are also very concrete barriers related to the accessibility and quality of therapy, from cost to physical health constraints. There are people traumatized by past therapists or who fear, often entirely understandably, that a mental health professional would not understand their neurodivergence, <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/medical-trauma-6fa90c6ecab0">chronic illness</a>, gender identity or other types of core lived experience.</p><p>This piece is in no way intended to minimize these challenges and concerns. It is, however, sometimes possible to surpass these problems by working by yourself or with the help of a peer by teaching yourself effective modalities of trauma therapy, though in cases of very severe trauma this is not always advisable. It is also not my intention to judge or criticize anyone having the kind of difficulties discussed in the article, they are incredibly common.</p><p>Also, parts may have concerns about therapy that are based on misunderstandings. A common one is the idea that trauma work is based on thinking and talking about your most awful experiences. Luckily, effective trauma therapy is mostly not concerned with the original traumatizing situations, as that has a tendency to only strengthen the involved memory pathways. Instead it focuses on the effects the trauma has on the person’s <em>experience in the now,</em> such as on the level of the body and the autonomic nervous system, as well as limiting beliefs caused by it, rather than the narrative of <em>what happened in the past</em>.</p><h4><strong>What Are Parts and How Do They Affect Our Lives?</strong></h4><p>According to the theory in <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">Internal Family Systems</a> (IFS), our mind is made up of <em>parts</em>, kinds of subpersonalities, which make us the incredibly complex and fascinating beings we are. IFS and other parts-based frameworks are quite compatible with the current understanding of neuroscience. Parts are why we sometimes act in ways “uncharacteristic” to us, feel torn in multiple directions, do things we don’t want to do (like with addictions, bad habits and bouts of rage) or don’t do the things we want to do (like going to the gym or expressing our boundaries).</p><p>Most parts have developed in our childhood and may be mentally stuck there. They commonly harbor black-and-white views of the world, e.g. one part believing that something is completely awful and unacceptable, while another part has an opposite view. This tends to lead to a <em>polarization</em> between these parts, which often acts like a tug of war and explains why one can hold contradictory ideas or preferences at the same time.</p><p>Quite a few people want to hit the gym, yet struggle to actually pull it off, at least in the long term. Similarly, many would like to seek therapy, but never do or quickly give up on it. From the point of view of therapists, often also of the person’s loved ones, this can be frustrating, but it is very understandable when you look at it as a protective mechanism.</p><h4><strong>Healing Can Feel Unsafe</strong></h4><p>Trauma is all about the feeling of <em>unsafety</em>, whether it’s more about concrete lack of safety, such as the fear that someone will physically attack you, or more social and emotional unsafety, like that others will reject and abandon you. (For childhood trauma, these are in fact largely the same thing, as a child cannot survive if they are abandoned by their caretakers.) Some people with severe trauma feel this on a tangible level all the time, while for others, the sense of not being safe is more implicit and might only become obvious when they are triggered.</p><p>Trauma is awful. Yet peculiarly, <em>it tends to feel much safer than the idea of not having trauma</em>. The current situation, even if in many ways unpleasant or unsatisfactory, is <em>familiar</em>. We know what it’s like and that appears safer than something unknown, which may come off as a trick or a trap — parts may believe real safety cannot exist, so anything promising such a thing is inherently suspicious.</p><p>Typically, the current, traumatized state is closed off from many things. There may be patterns of social, emotional and romantic withdrawal and detachment, with the frightening implication that healing would mean opening up, being vulnerable and letting people in. Yet there may be such a disconnect from even your own self and your own body that the idea of re-establishing a connection to who <em>you</em> are may feel unbearable.</p><p>Parts may be aware that not only healing would change you as a person, it might result in concrete changes to your life. Reasons related to trauma make many people stick to romantic relationships, friendships, communities, toxic workplaces and fields that don’t feel quite right to them. It is also common for those coming from a family with severe abuse or neglect to hold a belief that their parents did not do anything wrong, allowing the maintenance of a relationship, while the subconscious likely knows this is not true.</p><h4><strong>Shame and Dissociation Make Us Go Into Hiding</strong></h4><p>Another factor complicating pursuits of healing is shame, a typical component of trauma, which may or may not be consciously experienced. “<em>In fact, it has been demonstrated that shame is a ‘potent treatment barrier’ for trauma survivors, leading to outright avoidance, and to dropping out and attrition once engaged with care and services.</em>” (<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01227-z#ref-CR43">Dolezal et al, 2022.</a>) Parts illustrate the way the human experience is often rife with conflicting beliefs. A survivor may believe that they do not feel embarrassed about past sexual abuse since they know it was not their fault, yet parts can carry shame on a less conscious level.</p><p>“<em>[C]hronic shame is commonly characterised by the nagging and persistent </em>possibility of shame<em>, where, for the most part, shame itself is not necessarily realised in experience. Instead, what comes to dominate experience is a pernicious form of anticipated shame, or a persistent and heightened ‘shame anxiety,’ of which an individual may, or may not, be aware.</em> […] <em>It is important to note that shame anxiety may not be experienced as shame. Instead, it may be dominated by shame avoidance and, as such, characterised by emotions such as fear, anxiety, self-consciousness, stress or powerful impulses to hide, avoid or escape.</em>” (<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01227-z#ref-CR43">ibid</a>)</p><p>Dissociation is also an important part of the puzzle. (For more about dissociation, see <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">this article </a>of mine.) The term refers to several mechanisms that exist to push horrible experiences out of consciousness to prevent them from overwhelming us. For many, it feels much more comfortable than the idea of healing. Why tear open old wounds when there is something in-built in humans that helps us turn away from pain and cushion us from its impact? Sadly, there are major trade-offs: dissociation also prevents us from fully engaging with life.</p><p>According to structural dissociation theory, which deals with the way severe trauma can fragment the personality, many people with severe childhood trauma have a strong <em>apparently normal part</em> or ANP (a term that curiously goes as far back as <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/BF03379560.pdf">studies of WW1 veterans</a>). They may appear highly dysfunctional, potentially struggling with such issues as psychosis, addiction, suicidal thoughts and violence, making it seem obvious to others that professional help could be valuable. Yet when the person is operating from an ANP, they may barely remember such struggles, more focused on basic functioning than experiences like joy or aliveness.</p><h4><strong>Why Do People Drop out of Therapy?</strong></h4><p>Normally when I make controversial claims in my writing, I try to back them up with research, but anti-healing parts seem very tricky to study. People who don’t ever seek therapy are not recorded in any data. Even among those who do, how could we accurately study the experience of someone who states they dropped out because they didn’t like their therapist or because they were too busy with their studies, even if the actual reason was apprehensive parts?</p><p>Of course, in the field of psychotherapy, clients quitting therapy early is a well-known phenomenon, referred to with terms such as <em>attrition</em> or <em>premature termination</em>. There is plenty of research on its potential causes, though I believe it fails to delve into the deeper motivations.</p><p>“<em>Studies vary, but we now know that between 20 and 57 percent of therapy clients don’t return after an initial session. Of those who do come back, another 37 to 45 percent will stay for only two more sessions.</em></p><p><em>Why? There’s a slew of potential reasons: people change jobs, run out of money, reconcile with their romantic partners, and so on</em>.” (<a href="https://www.psychotherapynetworker.org/article/reducing-client-dropout/">Psychotherapist Networker</a>)</p><p>Other reasons listed in that article and elsewhere include the client not clicking with the therapist, not trusting their methods, or feeling like the therapist is not empathetic enough, low motivation and stigma attached to therapy. Socioeconomic factors also appear to play a role. Labels like “low motivation” may not say much, though, as I believe that for most people, the <a href="https://www.wellandgood.com/trauma-drive/">motivation system is largely controlled by trauma-based parts</a>. For reasons detailed later in this article, I also suspect viewing the practitioner as strongly empathetic can actually be <em>more</em> triggering than perceived low empathy, obviously depending on the extent of such deficit.</p><h4><strong>Possible Deeper Causes for Premature Termination</strong></h4><p>No doubt these reasons can play a role in “therapy drop-out”. Yet none of these purported causes of really explain some factors associated with it, such as how commonly it occurs right after an apparent big breakthrough or major insight. One could suggest an explanation like the client not feeling adequately supported with such a big shift, as they can be unnerving and destabilizing, but I suspect parts triggered by the idea of healing play a big role.</p><p>Also, anti-healing parts may make the person start forgetting therapy appointments. When someone is inexplicably forgetting something, the reason is typically parts that are actively trying not to remember. Other clients begin to regularly cancel appointments, perhaps for seemingly minor reasons. These can both help strengthen the person’s belief that they really are too busy for this or otherwise aren’t cut for therapy at this point in their life.</p><p>The more effective therapy is, the more triggering it tends to be. Some people manage to stay in supportive psychotherapy or modalities with low efficacy for years, yet trying out a more powerful technique has them quit quickly. (There is a common belief that all schools of therapy have equal efficacy, based on research with questionable methodology, which I attempt to debunk in my free book <a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/">Loving Awakening</a>.)</p><p>Others are quite happy to work on more “cerebral” concerns such as productivity or stress, either by themselves or with a counselor. They might even boast how adept and keen they are on inner work, yet stay clear from anything that dives too close to their <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/attachment-style-parts-and-internal-family-systems-3058f93bf72b">attachment trauma</a> or other core wounding.</p><p>I suspect anti-healing parts often also oppose couples therapy. A common pattern is that one partner wishes to attend couples counseling while the other party does not see a need, though still wants to stay together. Again, there are multiple potential reasons for such apprehension, both related to relational dynamics and attitudes towards counseling in general, but I strongly suspect fearful parts can play a role, too. Being stuck in unhealthy roles in a relationship feels safer and more familiar than potential change.</p><p>In general, there may be parts that feel like it’s unfair you should be the one in the therapist’s chair when people who have hurt you, neglected you or perhaps even abused you just shrug off their problems. And in a sense, it is very unfair. Had they dealt with their issues, they would not have behaved in ways that traumatized you. That is really painful. The unfortunate truth is that you can’t make others heal. You can’t make them confront their apprehensive parts, you can only try to confront your own ones.</p><h4><strong>Aversion to Healing Outside of Therapy</strong></h4><p>Parts can also be triggered by books related to trauma or healing. Some trauma literature features material with an obvious potential to be triggering, such as descriptions of abuse. Yet curiously, I’ve found that one particularly common culprit is Jay Earley’s IFS guidebook <em>Self-Therapy</em>, which contains none of that. Quite a few people have told me they could not finish the book, because of how strongly it posited <em>healing being accessible and possible</em>.</p><p>Parts may even get revved up when they hear mentions of trauma or parts, things they interpret as therapy language, claims that trauma is extremely common, or someone insisting that you personally have trauma. They might interpret those things as blame or pathologizing even when that is not the intention. Obviously, sometimes such talk actually<em> is</em> patronizing, coming from parts trying to fix other people.</p><p>On the other hand, some people with anti-healing parts are very keen on self-help books. The genre promises change and healing — typically without any obvious mention of trauma. Consuming such titles makes you feel like you are doing something, while the reader <em>stays in charge</em> and can avoid delving too deep. I’ve known people who spent years devouring self-help and swore it had changed their lives, yet an external observer struggled to notice any difference.</p><p>Parts’ suspicions may not be limited to just therapy-adjacent things, either. Anything that holds the promise of change can seem terrifying. Rejection and abandonment frighten most people and it really hurts to feel misunderstood and unseen. Yet at least there tends to be a familiarity to those experiences, which may not be the case with love and acceptance. Even feeling understood can feel triggering, as can the prospect of things like joy, ease or excitement. For some with insecure attachment, even securely attached people appear to pose a sense of danger.</p><p>Typically, the main factor is whether parts believe something poses a risk of dealing with core trauma. As such, a therapist who doesn’t prod too deep could provoke less alarm than the promise of a healthy, loving relationship or even a warm and compassionate friend or mentor. There is often an apparent tendency in trauma survivors to seek out unhealthy, even abusive relationships. This is typically explained by re-enactment of trauma, but I suspect it can also relate to <em>avoiding people who come off as too safe</em>.</p><h4><strong>Dealing With Anti-Healing Parts</strong></h4><p>You can’t force parts into anything, but parts that oppose healing can be worked with like any other — with the obvious caveat that they might not be very fond of the idea. Yet like all parts, they do value being heard and their contribution appreciated, being treated with curiosity and compassion. The IFS motto is that <em>all parts are welcome</em>, because they are all trying to help.</p><p>The most important thing to understand about anti-healing parts is that they exist, you might well have them and that <em>they often lie</em>. If they try to convince you “this isn’t going to work”, a common reason is their fear that the approach <em>is</em> going to help. They might be telling you now is not the right time to do therapy, you are too busy, that the practitioner or the therapeutic modality isn’t the right fit for you, or that you aren’t doing the work properly, when it’s really about fear.</p><p>These objections can obviously be true, or they might be ideas stemming from parts that are terrified of change. It is probably worth thorough consideration to see if the concerns can be related to real issues, e.g. that the therapist really does not listen or seems inferior to someone you worked with in the past, or whether they could be distorted ideas coming from parts. If the practitioner feels off, might someone else be a better fit? Can you sense any panic or anger related to the situation? Something coming off as merely useless would generally not be expected to stir up such emotions.</p><p>I believe optimally, anti-healing parts should be something discussed both in therapy and in the wider conversation about healing and mental health, though this requires considerable nuance. Many trauma survivors have experienced gaslighting both related to their original source of trauma and when trying to seek professional help for it.</p><p>It is tricky to talk about something that easily sounds like “you might believe this, but it’s actually wrong, and if you think your therapist is bad, it can’t possibly be true” without the potential for feeling invalidated. On the other hand, it is well-known that trauma can spark distorted beliefs about the world that feel very real and it’s good to be aware of that possibility.</p><p>If you have trauma, accepting that is an important yet typically a highly challenging first step. Alas, I believe that paralyzing fear stops most of severely wounded people from ever getting that far, or their acceptance wavers depending on which part currently holds the reins. Accepting the presence of trauma means accepting there are things that could be very differently — that authentic connection to both yourself and the external world is possible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5330be0aa99d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Attachment Style, Parts and Internal Family Systems]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/attachment-style-parts-and-internal-family-systems-3058f93bf72b?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3058f93bf72b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychotherapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[attachment-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Apr 2023 03:55:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-23T09:21:53.777Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-3gWfiZPolSMTC2eS7SN2g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by Ketut Subiyanto @ Pexels.com</figcaption></figure><p>Insecure attachment can greatly complicate our relationships, friendships and parenting, even all areas of our lives. Viewing attachment styles as comprised of <em>parts of the mind</em> with the help of Internal Family Systems (IFS) can help clarify the intricacies of avoidant, anxious and disorganized attachment styles and what they actually boil down to inside of us, also helping to heal this trauma.</p><h4><strong>What Is Attachment Theory?</strong></h4><p>Based on John Bowlby’s attachment theory, now widely used in the fields of psychology and psychotherapy, we are all thought to have one of four attachment styles. None of them are set in stone or “bad”, some just add more challenges to your life. Sometimes when individuals with different attachment styles interact, it may feel like the parties are conversing in a different language, when everyone is just trying to get their basic human needs met.</p><p>If your early childhood is emotionally secure — a caregiver is present, attuned to your needs and soothes you when called for — you will likely grow up <em>securely attached</em>, which encompasses 50–60% of people. You are able to commit to a partner (without smothering them) and can handle things such as conflict or your spouse needing more or less space than you do.</p><p>Lacking that emotional security in your early years can lead to a type of <em>insecure attachment</em>. This can show up as e.g. being “clingy” (<em>anxious attachment</em>) or aloof (<em>avoidant </em>or<em> dismissive attachment</em>) in relationships — and clingy people often find themselves attracted to aloofness and vice versa, complicating things further. In other words, if you weren’t sure you could rely on your caregivers, even as an adult you may fear your partner is about to leave you any moment and become preoccupied with that (anxious attachment is also called preoccupied attachment). Avoidant attachment tends to associate with more severe trauma than anxious attachment — instead of fearing your parents wouldn’t be there for you, you <em>knew</em> they wouldn’t be.</p><p>Attachment trauma can ensue without any abuse. As attachment styles are primarily formed in early childhood, the person may also lack memories directly related to it. Postnatal depression or parental bereavement in the first two years of life can give rise to insecure attachment in the child, who might not recall any maltreatment or neglect. Even conditions during pregnancy, such as prenatal depression, are now considered to <a href="https://guilfordjournals.com/doi/10.1521/pdps.2017.45.4.542">potentially play a role</a> in attachment foundation.</p><p>While anxious and avoidant attachment styles can result from parents simply being “out of tune” with their child, abuse eliciting fear in the child (and possibly also caregivers being dissociated) may lead to <em>disorganized </em>attachment, also called <em>fearful-avoidant</em>. It combines neediness with a strong desire to withdraw, provoking a chaotic pattern of relations. It’s not the same as having anxious patterns in some relationships and acting avoidant in others, but more like enduring both simultaneously. This type covers just a few percent of people.</p><p>Disorganized individuals crave affection, but can’t take it, or may leave their partner preemptively to avoid being dumped. They may get diagnosed with borderline personality disorder (BPD), which is unfortunate, as it’s all about developmental trauma and wounded parts that can be healed, not a disordered personality.</p><p>New attachment wounds can develop in adulthood, but they’re usually not as overarching as our attachment style, formed in the early years. All attachment trauma is healable, which is discussed near the end of this article.</p><h4><strong>What Is IFS?</strong></h4><p><a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">Internal Family Systems</a> was developed by family therapist Richard Schwartz in the 1980s. In recent years it has rapidly gained popularity for a multitude of reasons. IFS can be used to treat simple and complex trauma, addictions, many types of mental health conditions as well as everyday issues like procrastination and perfectionism. IFS takes into account the person’s current situation (such as systemic injustices) and doesn’t pathologize or call anything maladaptive. In contrast to most types of psychotherapy, in many cases IFS can be practiced as self-therapy or with a peer, though severe traumas may be best left to professional IFS therapists.</p><p>The key concept of IFS is that our minds are comprised of <em>parts</em>, kinds of subpersonalities, which make us the incredibly complex and fascinating beings we are. Parts are why we sometimes act in ways “uncharacteristic” to us, why we may do things we don’t want to do (as with addictions, bad habits and arguing) or don’t do the things we want to do (like going to the gym or expressing our boundaries). Most parts have developed in our childhood and may be mentally stuck there, viewing the world through the lens of a child. Using IFS, we can contact these parts, hear them out, comfort them and solve many issues that way.</p><p>There are several other types of psychotherapy that rely on the concept of parts. The main thing that sets IFS apart from most of them is the concept of <em>Self</em>, which is outside of any part and the cornerstone of therapeutic work. When you are in Self, not <em>blended</em> with any part, certain positive qualities like curiosity and compassion naturally arise. Even though alcoholism or withdrawing emotionally may have ruined many things for you, from Self you are able to appreciate the parts behind these issues or at least meet them with curiosity.</p><p>Underneath all other issues, everyone has a Self, regardless of their attachment style, the severity of their trauma or any mental illnesses. The qualities of secure attachment do not stem from parts but Self, though that doesn’t mean securely attached people are always in Self or cannot have any tricky parts. Having access to Self makes it much easier to heal parts and provide an inner secure attachment figure to them. Trauma can make this more challenging, though even some heavily traumatized individuals quickly learn to get into Self, at least temporarily.</p><p>One way to access Self is to ask the currently present part (e.g. anxiety, frustration or self-criticism) if it is willing to step aside for a bit to let you access Self. And usually they do oblige! This may seem perplexing: I can ask my anxiety if it would go away and it does, how is that even <em>possible</em>? Because you’re not wishing for a part to go away, as we so often do, you kindly ask it to<em> step back for a moment</em> (unblend) for a good reason. If you discover another “negative” emotion underneath, you can similarly inquire if it would agree to do the same.</p><h4><strong>Attachment Insecurity from an IFS Perspective</strong></h4><p>Attachment styles are often viewed as labels, that you either are securely attached or not, but attachment isn’t about having one avoidant or anxiously attached part. Instead, it’s a network of dozens of parts in a complex interaction, which may form constellations that have you act avoidant in some situations and preoccupied in others. Even the most securely attached person likely exhibits some needy or avoidant traits. (Someone with dissociative identity disorder can certainly have alters with distinct attachment styles, but the alter would likely be comprised of different types of parts.)</p><p>In IFS, parts are normally divided into three types: <em>managers</em> and <em>firefighters</em> are types of protector parts guarding <em>exiles</em> that carry pain. Managers have more rational approaches to self-soothing, while firefighters fight fire with fire and may escape into addictions or even self-harm. Personally, I’ve often found the way <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561"><em>structural dissociation</em></a> theory categorizes parts more helpful. This system divides trama-related parts into five types: fight, flight, freeze, fawn/submit and attach.</p><p>Fight parts can be aggressive, judgey, paranoid or controlling, but may also direct their vitriol inwards. Flight parts fear commitment and flee into addictions and other escapism. Freeze parts feel numb, detached and scared. Fawn parts are ashamed, people-pleasing, conflict-avoidant and lack boundaries. Attach parts feel needy and seek comfort in others. Everyone, regardless of their attachment style (and whether they have actual dissociation or not), likely has all types of parts, as well as ones that don’t fit this categorization, just in different combinations.</p><p>As could be expected, people with anxious attachment tend to have strong attach parts and often also fawn parts, which may be willing to compromise on almost anything to maintain relationships. These attach parts can be very triggering for avoidant individuals, for whom fight, flight and freeze parts dominate, though they may also have prominent fawn parts. And unfortunately, fight and flight parts set off anxious people, creating a vicious cycle.</p><p>Avoidant attachment is also called “dismissive-avoidant” and it often comes with a markedly angry and judgmental side. Some avoidant people appear more distant and cold, having strong flight and freeze parts. Others can be warm and social, yet with ruthless criticism bubbling underneath, coming off dismissive rather than aloof. Anger and strong judgment both originate from fight parts.</p><p>Disorganized attachment may fluctuate between all types of parts, but freeze tends to be particularly dominant, and they even get triggered by their <em>own</em> attach parts. Their system is heavily built on highly reactive firefighter parts. Anything that could be perceived as even slightly off in a relationship may spark massive alarm signals. Often the only way for a disorganized person to manage this hurt in relationships is by attempting to sink into a constant freeze.</p><h4><strong>Shared Patterns in Insecure Attachment</strong></h4><p>In many ways, avoidant and anxious people seem like opposites. This is particularly obvious in the ubiquitous avoidant/anxious pairings, often featuring cat-and-mouse pursuits that serve as the cornerstone of romantic fiction and film in the West: will they or won’t they. From the perspective of drama, a relationship between two securely attached people would be a real yawner in comparison. Yet those with different forms of insecure attachment also have a surprising amount in common.</p><p>In IFS theory, “The 8 Cs” are eight qualities that emerge from being in Self. These are Compassion, Curiosity, Courage, Clarity, Creativity, Connection, Confidence and Calm. However, parts can also mimic these qualities. E.g. freeze parts may resemble equanimity or tranquility, while judgmental parts may believe themselves to represent confidence, courage or righteousness.</p><p>One particularly common pattern in attachment insecurity is parts that mimic compassion. There are various definitions for empathy and compassion, in psychology, neuroscience, philosophy and religious traditions (as well as different kinds of empathy recognized in psychology). It’s commonly asserted that if you feel compassion for someone, you will also feel their pain. For many people with insecure attachment, this is a major problem: they may feel others’ pain so strongly that it becomes unbearable.</p><p><em>This is not empathy or compassion</em>. It’s parts reacting to trauma and parts making others’ pain about themselves, which often leads other parts to resent this person and spin stories about them. From Self, you naturally feel compassion for yourself, your parts and other people, yet their suffering does not trigger or overwhelm you or feel like a burden. In this headspace, you project authentic caring and the problem doesn’t become about you.</p><p>Another common compassion mimic is <em>rescuer parts</em>, which can be found in people with all insecure attachment styles. These are parts of the psyche that want to fix or save others. Yet what having these parts <em>feels</em> like is being a deeply compassionate person burning to help others. This can be true, too, but deep down these parts’ motivations are not about altruism but control. It can turn quite ugly if the other party isn’t keen on being controlled or doesn’t appreciate the proposed solution.</p><p>Psychologist Jay Earley discusses the polarization of people-pleaser (fawn) and passive-aggressive (fight) parts in his IFS book <em>Self-Therapy, Vol. 3</em> (pp. 193–197). The people-pleaser dishes out promises, while the passive-aggressive part resents these offers and believes it must have been forced into them (because “it” didn’t make those promises, it was another part!). The resentment can make it view the other party as controlling or manipulative. This is a highly destructive pattern that may sound obviously avoidant, but I’ve encountered it with anxious people, as well.</p><h4><strong>Other Factors Playing a Role</strong></h4><p>Attachment isn’t just about the <em>types </em>of parts in your system, however. No matter your attachment style, you’re likely to have e.g. multiple attach parts and fight parts. The relations between parts as well as parts and the Self make a big difference and parts also interact with your current circumstances.</p><p>In dissociation, trauma is “split off” from consciousness so as not to feel unbearable, a stronger form of compartmentalization than just exiling a part. This provides a vital survival mechanism particularly in cases of continuing maltreatment, e.g. living with abusive or neglectful caregivers while attempting to behave in a way that minimizes their harmful actions. Those with disorganized attachment tend to dissociate heavily, though this is also a common pattern in avoidant people and found in anxious attachment, as well.</p><p>Dissociation refers to two somewhat different but related phenomena: “spacing out” (which may also be experienced as derealization, confusion or fogginess), and compartmentalization, which may not be noticed consciously. The former is usually caused by a single freeze part producing distraction to prevent the person from going anywhere near the trauma, while the latter is more about parts (typically a large number of them) becoming disconnected from each other. When severe enough, this is known as dissociative identity disorder (DID), formerly multiple personality disorder, but milder forms are very common. The actual attachment trauma may also be dissociated away, such as blocking out avoidant or clingy traits or using dissociation to gain the needed space in a relationship.</p><p>Other factors that may be involved include the parts’ age (how old they think they or you are), how extreme they are with their beliefs, how strongly they’re stuck in the past and how strongly polarized with other parts. Whether you get very blended with parts or are able to be in Self at least partially has a huge impact on how attachment patterns play out.</p><p>Someone, regardless of their attachment style, might have e.g. a part that believes their partner owes them consolation every time they feel bad. Depending on the person’s inner dynamics, there are many possible scenarios that can result. A securely attached individual with access to Self could view it as a belief they have, which may not be fair or true. This is what happens when a part is active but you are not fully blended with it, so you are able to question its perspective.</p><p>Another person could become completely blended with their “you must comfort me” part. Someone with anxious attachment could feel ashamed and inconsolable, while an avoidant person might perceive they were wronged and erupt in rage. If the part was more dissociated, it might show up as feeling lonely and dejected (anxious), or resentful (avoidant) without being aware of why, and possibly spin a story to explain this reaction. Someone with even more dissociation might just start believing their spouse is a bad person.</p><p>It’s also possible for parts to mistake someone in your life for your parents. You’ve probably heard of daddy issues and people looking for mother figures, and some parts want to pretend a partner or friend is your mom or dad, but sometimes a part will actually <em>believe</em> that this is the case. (Parts’ ideas of reality can be complex and confusing and this isn’t as icky as it may sound.) And as bizarre as this perhaps seems, parts can even be confused about who <em>you</em> are. You might have a part that’s convinced you are your abusive mom or dad!</p><p>Attachment trauma also interacts with one’s overall environment, such as the actual safety of current circumstances and how one’s attachment style is perceived. Studies have found different cultures to mostly have surprisingly similar rates of different attachment styles, yet some cultures as a whole are quite “avoidant” and others much more “anxious”. E.g. the US society is very individualistic to the point of glorifying avoidance in some contexts, such as dating, which would be more prone to creating strong parts ashamed by “clinginess” than a very collectivistic Asian culture.</p><p>There is a curious pattern I call <em>attachment introjecting</em> which involves internalizing patterns from partners’ or friends’ attachment trauma in adulthood (an introject part is one trying to mimic the behavior of another person). As avoidant people tend to be more dominant and more likely to be idolized, this is usually dismissive/avoidant patterns, which can be absorbed by avoidant and anxious individuals alike.</p><h4><strong>Other Aspects of Attachment Style</strong></h4><p>Often attachment style is only thought to apply to romantic relationships, but it also plays a role in friendships, parenting, other family relations and even situations that are not directly interpersonal.</p><p>Anxiously attached people tend to struggle with low self-esteem, experiencing a lot of shame and a sense that there’s something deeply wrong and flawed about them. The criticism they receive from avoidant individuals and avoidant areas of society (like the dating scene) may intensify these parts, e.g. if a partner labels them clingy or “too intense”. These feelings often coexist with other types of inner critics. The shame about being needy can lead to dissociating away attach parts or adopting seemingly avoidant strategies to reduce clinginess, like keeping a new partner at an arm’s length to not smother them.</p><p>Avoidant people tend to be much more critical of others. They may idolize other avoidants, but generally believe themselves to be superior to anxious and securely attached people. This doesn’t mean they can’t also have inner critics or even an overall negative self-image, however. An extreme example is narcissism. A narcissist is often suggested to “love themselves excessively” but is more accurately described as someone who never learned to love themselves as a result of childhood trauma and tries to get it through seeking validation from others. (Curiously, there has been <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.679168/full">a great discrepancy in studies</a> as to whether narcissists have been more likely to have avoidant, anxious or disorganized attachment.)</p><p>People with an anxious attachment style are often overall quite anxious and fearful and may come off as the chronic worrier type. The world can seem like a very dangerous place to them. Many avoidant individuals also have anxiety, but may be better at hiding and suppressing it, especially as they prefer dealing with it themselves rather than seeking support from others. The anxiety can seem to mirror the attachment pattern: avoidants may deal with nagging unease that is trying to distract them from things, while those with anxious attachment have anxiety begging for their attention.</p><p>Addictions also seem to follow a similar pattern. There is a dysregulated nervous system at the core, but for avoidant people, addictions are generally about escapism and distraction. As such, research has generally found those with avoidant and disorganized attachment to be the most addiction-prone. When anxiously attached people develop addictions, they may involve trying to get their needs met — e.g. food is for emotional soothing, shopping is <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S019188692200006X">an attempt to increase status</a> and video games help satisfy social needs.</p><p>However, addictions are complicated and comprise many different parts, with shame and firefighter parts trying to suppress it usually playing a major role. <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00727/full">Some studies have suggested</a> that heroin addicts may be more likely to be disorganized, those misusing cannabis are likelier to be avoidant and alcoholics tend towards anxious attachment, but the evidence isn’t clear-cut. Avoidant escapism can also manifest in seemingly positive ways, such as spiritual practice with the goal of leaving the world and other people behind, a form of <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/lurking-in-the-shadows-harmful-interpersonal-patterns-in-spiritual-communities-90890b9226ba"><em>spiritual bypassing</em></a>.</p><p>Securely attached people tend to be more skilled at self-regulation and managing impulses and more optimistic, patient, trusting and forgiving, qualities that emerge from Self. Parts can have similar traits too, but they often take them to unhealthy extremes — a fawn part quick to forgive <em>anything</em> may not be very helpful, while parts that believe things will <em>obviously</em> always turn out well for <em>you</em> are more characteristic of narcissism.</p><p>In general, securely attached people tend to have a more realistic view of both themselves and others. <em>Projection</em> is a common aspect of attachment insecurity, especially avoidance. It refers to seeing things in others that aren’t really there, typically your own qualities. Projected traits are often unpleasant — either flaws you deny having or issues that you are well aware of and believe others to possess too — but can also be positive.</p><p>Projection usually originates from the interaction of several parts involving exiles or dissociation. If you block out some of your own unfavorable qualities and possibly even events that have taken place between you and another person, it’s much easier to view them in a negative light. Avoidant or disorganized attachment can also lead to <em>lovebombing</em>, expressing fondness in an effusive, idolizing fashion early on, which later turns into devaluation, even demonizing. Lovebombing is often viewed as an intentional control tactic, but is more likely to stem from attachment trauma and dissociation.</p><h4><strong>Healing Attachment Trauma</strong></h4><p>If you suspect you or your partner might have insecure attachment, even being aware of it and what kinds of major parts it could entail can be transformative. The IFS slogan is “All parts are welcome” and it’s incredibly helpful to learn to appreciate the good intentions of all your (and others’!) parts, even if they have wreaked havoc in your relationships or have been shunned by friends or partners. Some of your parts likely hold perspectives about yourself and others that are not true. Believing ideas stemming from attachment trauma is rarely constructive, and learning to question them goes a long way, while inner critics judging and shaming such parts isn’t going to solve the problem.</p><p>Discussing all this with your partner or close friends can be illuminating and healing. IFS is also well-suited for communication: talking <em>for</em> your parts from Self instead of <em>from</em> your parts, such as “<em>It hurts my ashamed parts when your critical part judges me</em>”. However, not everyone is a fan of “therapy speak”. Many people won’t be receptive to ideas like parts or attachment style (this aversion also originates from parts, but it’s likely best not to mention this), or can take a long time to warm up to them. Emotionally mature people may appreciate someone pointing out some of their parts to them from Self, while yelling “You’re again in a flight part because you’re avoidant!” during an argument is unlikely to go down well.</p><p>A healthy romantic or therapeutic relationship with a securely attached person can help heal attachment wounds. Securely attached people can also generally deal with others’ insecure attachment much better. This also means that if you are in an anxious/avoidant relationship and your partner <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/i-want-to-heal-but-also-i-dont-why-do-many-feel-averse-to-therapy-and-trauma-work-5330be0aa99d">isn’t keen on therapy</a>, even just healing your own attachment trauma could help solve many of the hurtful patterns between you (obviously this is not the solution in cases of abuse!).</p><p>In IFS, the Self can act as an attachment figure, allowing parts to develop a secure base. You can work on most attachment-related parts using the same IFS techniques as on other parts. There’s also a somewhat IFS-like practice for attachment repair called <a href="https://www.ingentaconnect.com/contentone/phoenix/att/2021/00000015/00000001/art00004">Ideal Parent Figure</a>. Attachment trauma can of course also be healed with other types of trauma therapy, such as Somatic Experiencing and EMDR.</p><p><em>You can learn more about attachment, trauma, dissociation, parts, spiritual escapism as well as Internal Family Systems and other forms of therapy in my free book </em><a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/">Loving Awakening</a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3058f93bf72b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dark Nights, Spiritual Crises and Psychotic Breaks]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/dark-nights-spiritual-crises-and-psychotic-breaks-6f3bdfb24f5a?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f3bdfb24f5a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dissociation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Nov 2022 17:14:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-26T20:32:49.497Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Dark Nights, Spiritual Crises and Psychotic Breaks: The Side Effects of Meditation</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IxqpNrXJBpNkoqfzwX5RKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by Cottonbro @ Pexels.com</figcaption></figure><p>Meditation is often considered calming, relaxing and helpful for stress. As a result, it is now widely recommended by therapists and doctors for various purposes. Sam Harris even referred to Buddhist enlightenment as “the epitome of stress reduction”, but I feel the reality may even be the opposite of this claim.</p><p>I believe everyone who meditates for long enough will almost certainly develop at least moderate side effects from it, and even serious harm is quite common. My own issues have been mostly relatively mild, but I have watched friends writhing in pain, trashing around, rolling on the ground, involuntarily screaming, crying uncontrollably, going into psychosis and other symptoms that have been shocking to witness.</p><p>Three contemporary authors in particular have been documenting the adverse effects of meditation. Daniel Ingram, who is also a medical doctor, has focused on the Progress of Insight in his book <em>Mastering the Core Teachings of the Buddha. </em>David Treleaven writes about the interactions between meditation practice and trauma in <em>Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness</em> and some academic papers. Willoughby Britton and her research group at Brown University have looked more widely at different types of harm.</p><p>That spiritual practice can cause difficulties is nothing new, of course. Most Buddhist traditions discuss this at least in passing. The famous transpersonal psychologists Stanislav and Christina Grof coined the term “spiritual emergency” in the 1980s and wrote a book titled <em>Spiritual Emergency: When Personal Transformation Becomes a Crisis</em>. The Zen master Hakuin wrote of Zen sickness back in the 18th century. Yet the public discussion on mindfulness still neglects this aspect.</p><p>One of the most important papers on the side effects of meditation was published by the Brown University research group in 2017. They only interviewed people who had reported serious adverse effects and concluded e.g. that “<em>Meditation-related adverse effects that were serious or distressing enough to warrant additional treatment have been reported in clinical and medical literature. These include reports of meditation-induced psychosis, seizures, depersonalization, mania and other forms of clinical deterioration</em>.” (<a href="https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0176239">1</a>)</p><p>In that paper, it’s also interesting how the time range of the appearance of marked adverse effects varied from one day to more than ten years, the latter even applying to 25% of the respondents. On the other hand, 12% reported harm within the first 10 days of practice, so it was also quite common to experience harm almost immediately.</p><p>The field of Western psychology has generally neglected to report on the side effects of non-spiritual practices as well, simply focusing on their benefits, as has happened with psychotherapy research. The same has unfortunately applied to meditation, contributing to the idea of its harmlessness. “<em>First, the vast majority (&gt;75%) of meditation studies do not actively assess adverse effects; instead, they rely solely on patients to spontaneously report any difficulties to the researchers or teachers. However, patients are unlikely to volunteer information about negative reactions to treatment without being directly asked due to the influence of authority structures and demand characteristics.</em>” (<a href="https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0176239">1</a>)</p><p>There are differing opinions on whether severe side effects of practice are unavoidable or a sign that you’re doing something wrong. This, of course, is not a falsifiable claim, as one can always claim you must be doing something wrong, or you wouldn’t be experiencing these symptoms. No type of meditation is free of risk, but dry insight practices like <a href="https://www.mctb.org/mctb2/table-of-contents/part-i-the-fundamentals/7-the-seven-factors-of-awakening/">noting</a> have been claimed to be particularly risky. David Treleaven warns that even though body scanning can sometimes be helpful in trauma healing, he feels it’s also among the most potentially destabilizing practices. (2)</p><p>I strongly suspect that <em>The Mind Illuminated</em> practices are especially risky. Most people I’ve known in real life who practiced TMI developed severe side effects, including multiple cases of psychosis. Several of these people had been safely practicing other types of meditation for a long time and felt that the forceful focus TMI has on the unification of the mind, which can exacerbate <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">traumatic dissociation</a>, was heavily related to their difficulties.</p><p>There are several possible causes of the adverse effects from a materialist point-of-view. “<em>Meditation can cause symptoms of hyperarousal (anxiety, panic, traumatic-re-experiencing, perceptual hypersensivity) through multiple pathways, including sensitization, somatosensory amplification, dual process theory, and </em><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/11/relaxation-induced-anxiety/265313/"><em>relaxation-induced panic</em></a><em>.</em>” (<a href="https://www.cheetahhouse.org/fdnh">3</a>) However, some phenomena may not explainable by neuroscientific perspectives alone.</p><p>Personally I would divide the side effects of meditation into six categories, even though they aren’t fully distinct. Multiple things may be going on at the same time and it may not always be clear which category a particular symptom belongs in, as physical ailments tend to be tied to the insight stages and so on. This classification, like classifications often are, is incomplete and oversimplified.</p><ol><li>Physical symptoms, often called kundalini symptoms</li><li>“Dark night of the soul” and other insight stages</li><li>“Energy stuff” (purifications, processing trauma somatically)</li><li>Dissociation either worsening or lifting</li><li>Increased rumination (e.g. worsened anxiety, depression or OCD or increased awareness of physical illness or bodily processes)</li><li>Downsides of the intended effects of meditation</li></ol><p>Much wider categorizations have been used by some, e.g. in the field of transpersonal psychology. Monica Goretzki lists several additional categories of spiritual crises, many of which aren’t directly related to meditation, in her thesis “The Differentiation of Psychosis and Spiritual Emergency”, such as “the shamanic crisis”, “the crisis of psychic opening”, “the past-life experience”, “the near-death experience” and “spirit possession”. (<a href="https://digital.library.adelaide.edu.au/dspace/bitstream/2440/47986/8/02whole.pdf">4</a>)</p><h4>Kundalini Symptoms</h4><p><a href="https://www.yogajournal.com/yoga-101/types-of-yoga/kundalini/kundalini-awakening/">Kundalini</a> refers to a concept of “life force” energy that is central to Hinduism and Tantric Buddhism. It is considered to normally lie dormant at the base of the spine but can be “awakened” from there. Other schools of Buddhism do not have such a concept, but people practicing in those traditions can also experience kundalini symptoms.</p><p>Many Internet resources abound that discuss a number of symptoms of “kundalini awakening”. They often include a combination of physical complications but also a number of ecstatic spiritual/religious symptoms, such as ESP, spontaneous whole-body orgasms and the body spontaneously adopting yoga poses. Among people I know, the effects have mostly been more mundane, and in general the deeply spiritual symptoms often characteristic of the initial stages tend to give way to a different set of more chronic ailments.</p><p>Kundalini is particularly associated with effects that are subjectively described as feeling like “energy”, such as tingly, prickly and electric sensations, jolts and crackles and experiences of powerful energy rising up through the spine. The Brown University research group has conducted a very interesting study on this calling them “ELSEs” or “energy-like somatic experiences” to avoid the pitfalls of the kundalini framework. (<a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/12/12/1042">5</a>)</p><p>Other common physical symptoms include e.g. fasciculations, trembling, muscle pain and tension, <em>kriyas</em> (involuntary movements), insomnia, exhaustion, flu-like malaise, irritability, stomach upset, pimples and various skin rashes, eye irritation, nasal congestion, hot and cold flashes, migraines, changes in libido and lymph node swelling. Less commonly there may be vomiting, urinary retention, fever, vocalizations and hallucinations. Periods and the menstrual cycle can also be affected.</p><p>Some of these symptoms that seem like allergies (like nasal congestion) do appear to be essentially allergic in nature. Quite a few people I know have reported new symptoms of allergy or allergy symptoms that are associated with practice and that respond to antihistamines. Many sources, though most of them questionable in veracity, also suggest a link between kundalini and histamine. (<a href="https://www.biologyofkundalini.com/article.php@story=Histamine.html">6</a>)</p><p>One thing that must be emphasized when we talk about symptoms that are caused by energetic or psychological reasons is to<em> not assume causation too hastily</em>. For example, some practitioners are used to a bizarre variety of energy symptoms that may change on daily basis and they are likely to attribute any new symptom to such a cause. This can be dangerous if a medical condition is missed, or at least cause major discomfort that could have been avoided.</p><p>For example, vitamin B12 deficiency is common and it can cause tingling and other paresthesias — as well as numerous other symptoms — and is easily treatable, so it would be unfortunate to miss. Even in the pandemic, some people have reported symptoms that to me sound very suspicious of COVID, yet have concluded it must be just energetic.</p><p>One common question about kundalini is whether these symptoms, which can be intense and scary, can even be dangerous or cause damage to the body, and there doesn’t seem to be a clear agreement about this. Obviously indirect harm is possible, such as having an accident because of involuntary movements or sleep deprivation. One Brown University paper mentioned several cases where adverse effects from meditation impaired the ability to drive, including one actual incident where the person hit several parked cars. (<a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01905/full">7</a>)</p><h4>Insight Stages</h4><p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vipassan%C4%81-%C3%B1%C4%81%E1%B9%87a">insight stages</a> are a series of stages that everyone is thought to cross during the course of their spiritual practice, though their intensity varies greatly: some people feel they don’t even notice them, for others they are very clear. The most striking insight stage is Arising &amp; Passing Away, commonly shortened to just A&amp;P. If you practice <em>vipassanā</em> (insight meditation), you will probably notice how sensations arise and then pass away, but A&amp;P tends to be an intense, profound experience and its other aspects often still dominate. An A&amp;P can last from seconds to months, though from a few days to a few weeks seems to be the most typical.</p><p>People in an A&amp;P can resemble someone having a manic episode or even psychosis. They tend to feel great and energized and naturally wake up after 5–6 hours of sleep feeling refreshed. Their sexuality may be greatly elevated and they may report experiences that sound uncharacteristic or even unbelievable. All of these sound typical of a manic episode. There are also many other possible symptoms, such as seeing colorful lights when meditating and vivid dreams featuring spiritual or supernatural themes, colorful lights or vortices of energy.</p><p>Besides resembling mania or psychosis, A&amp;P can sometimes also lead to them. “<em>In other cases, intense positive affect did not alternate with low arousal states, but instead escalated into destabilizing conditions resembling mania and psychosis, which often required hospitalization.</em>” (<a href="https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0176239">1</a>) Sometimes an A&amp;P can happen spontaneously, without any spiritual practice, e.g. in a life crisis. Even if it feels pleasant, the mania-like intensity can make it terrifying, if the person has no idea what’s going on.</p><p>The term “dark night” originates from a Christian mystic St. John of the Cross, who was having a hard time with his practice in the 16th century. More recently it has become widely used in Buddhist circles. In the context of the insight stages, it’s synonymous with the <em>dukkha nanas</em> (knowledges of suffering), a sequence of stages that can feel very rough (or, if you’re lucky, only mildly unpleasant). However, others use the term only to refer to highly distressing and perhaps especially existentially wrenching phases of spiritual experience, whether experienced during the dukkha nanas or not, when I would be more likely to use a term like spiritual crisis.</p><p>The dukkha nanas kick off with a stage called Dissolution, which can feel a lot like low-grade depression: you’re tired and feeling low and everything feels a bit drab. It’s followed by Fear, which tends to have the jittery “fight or flight” consistent with fear, while actual fears may or may not be present. Sometimes really bizarre fears can arise at this stage.</p><p>The stage of Misery is usually not nearly as bad as its name suggests. It’s followed by Disgust which can feature some physical nausea or revulsion, but also more existential aspects. These can make it hard to differentiate it from the next stage, Desire for Deliverance, which can vary from very mildly unpleasant to nerve-wracking desire to get away from everything.</p><p>If Misery has a misleading name, so does Reobservation, just in the opposite direction. It can last anywhere from minutes to years. The first phase of Reobservation can feel like sadness, depression, anger and trauma blending into agony, often with severe fatigue and sometimes also flu-like symptoms or paranoia. Everything feels unpleasant, intolerable and off. The latter part of Reobservation tends to feel like exhausted relief. There is no known way to get “out” of the progress of insight, one can only practice to get through the dark night and end up at a much more serene stage called Equanimity.</p><h4>“Energy stuff”</h4><p>“Energy stuff” is a very nonscientific term that most of my friends use, typically in the context of “I have energy stuff coming up”. This generally isn’t the same as experiencing “kundalini symptoms”, but something more akin to how the term “<a href="https://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/bodhi/bps-essay_04.html">purification</a>” is used in some schools of Buddhism. Some people also call this “cleansing the energy body”. It just sounds much less clunky and pompous to say “Could we maybe talk about this a bit later, I have energy stuff coming up really badly?” than talk about purification and cleansing. Also, I’m not a huge fan of good/bad-focused terminologies involving things like “purity”.</p><p>So what is this “energy stuff? A poorly definable phenomenon that different people describe and experience differently, but generally it refers to strong emotions thought to be related to past trauma coming up both psychologically and in the body with the sense that they can’t be avoided and need to be processed. Sometimes it is related to something going on in your life, but often it comes randomly, out of nowhere.</p><p>I have also included “energy stuff” separately from other manifestations of trauma. Typical of energy stuff is that new stuff bubbles up almost constantly, it feels pretty much unavoidable and impossible to suppress and it tends to be heavily somatic — sometimes it’s only experienced in the body with no mental aspect. These experiences tend to be accompanied by symptoms like exhaustion, bodily pains, migraines, muscle tension and kriyas, feeling hot and cold, changes in body temperature, sometimes also outwardly visible signs like skin rashes or a runny nose.</p><p>The intensity of energy stuff also seems to have a strong correlation with how much the person dissociates. In one small study of practitioners of Tibetan Buddhism reporting mainly energetic and emotional symptoms, “<em>While some practitioners viewed these experiences in relation to a normative Tantric soteriology of purification, almost all practitioners with a trauma history reported traumatic re-experiencing and tended not to adopt a purification framework.</em>” (<a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/8/8/153">8</a>)</p><h4>Rumination, Trauma, Dissociation and Psychosis</h4><p>Especially developmental trauma, encountered in early childhood, often leads to <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">dissociation</a>: trauma is “split off” from the consciousness so as not to feel unbearable. This provides an important survival mechanism particularly in cases of continuing maltreatment, e.g. living with abusive or neglectful caregivers. Often people who dissociate manage to convince themselves they don’t really have trauma, as it’s blocked out. However, <em>nearly 10%</em> of the general population struggles with severe dissociation (<a href="https://www.hindawi.com/journals/eri/2011/404538/">9</a>), so this is not a marginal problem. I suspect that in spiritual circles the percentage is much larger considering that trauma is a common reason to seek out relief in spirituality.</p><p>Meditation can have a pronounced effect on dissociation, either making it worse or lifting it. I’ve had several people confide in me that they realized their practice mostly consisted of dissociating. One of them was still convinced that if he just continues to do more of his practice (of dissociating), it will fix the dissociation. Increased dissociation can also be confused with attaining meditative goals with a reduced sense of self, this also seems to be quite common.</p><p>The latter possibility, dissociation lifting, may sound like a positive occurrence, but dissociation is a protective mechanism that exists for a reason. When important safety barriers are pulled down at once, it can lead to overwhelm by trauma, potentially resulting in severe destabilization or an acute crisis. I suspect this is the main cause of severe spiritual crises where people even become <a href="https://www.pennlive.com/news/2017/06/york_county_suicide_megan_vogt.html">suicidal</a>.</p><p>Dissociation may be hard to catch, and people may have suffered from severe dissociation without having sought mental health care (or only sought it for temporary depression or anxiety, which does not appear alarming). One person I knew who developed psychosis on a retreat had admitted on the intake form that he dissociates, but was still allowed to attend. An article in the Buddhist magazine <em>Tricycle</em> recommends and I concur: “<em>If you are suffering from severe depression, anxiety, or PTSD, it is probably not a good idea to join an intensive retreat. Try meditation classes instead, or a one-day or non-residential weekend retreat.</em>”(<a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/meditation-sickness/">10</a>)</p><p>Meditation is unfortunately well-known for causing psychoses and they hardly seem rare — I know half a dozen cases even among friends I’ve met in real life. Sometimes psychoses or psychosis-like episodes only last minutes, but in several cases I know, they endured for more than six months. Some of these people have also had severe mental health problems like bipolar disorder, while most hadn’t. Psychosis is often connected to kundalini phenomena, though several of these people had no discernible kundalini symptoms at the time. Pretty much all of them, however, have had severe dissociation before the psychotic break.</p><p>Most of the psychotic breaks featured paranoia, as psychoses usually do, but in several cases, the most prominent feature was delusions of grandeur. A&amp;P is a common time for people to get psychotic, especially with the delusions of grandeur, while paranoia tends to hit in the dark night. Antipsychotics are not pleasant drugs at all and can have serious side effects, but sometimes they may be necessary as otherwise there may be a threat to life, other people, employment or important relationships.</p><p>Stanislav and Christina Grof listed some factors to tell spiritual crises apart from psychosis: those having a spiritual crisis tend to be “<em>much more objective about their condition, communicate and cooperate well, show interest in sharing their experiences with open-minded people, seldom act out</em>”. (<a href="https://www.spiritualcompetency.com/dsm4/dsmrsproblem.pdf">11</a>)</p><p>Excessive rumination and obsessive focus on mental and bodily sensations can be a feature of e.g. depression, anxiety, OCD and neurodivergence. Some studies have pointed out the propensity of mindfulness meditation to sometimes help these traits while making them worse in some individuals. Occasionally these tendencies can worsen to a highly distressing extent, like the person developing a constant hyperawareness of interoceptive bodily sensations which may be similar to what has been called <a href="https://psychcentral.com/ocd/sensorimotor-obsessive-compulsive-disorder">sensorimotor OCD</a>.</p><h4>Dark Sides of Intended Effects</h4><p>In some Prajnaparamita (Perfection of wisdom) sutras central to the Mahayana Buddhist canon, there are depictions of people vomiting blood and having heart attacks simply because they heard the Buddha talk about emptiness. (12) In the highly disturbing <a href="https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/sn/sn54/sn54.009.than.html">Vesali sutta</a> (SN 54.9), sixty monks succumb to self-destruction after the Buddha got them so disgusted by their own bodies. Luckily these kinds of things are not likely to pose a risk in modern times, but Buddhism didn’t develop as a relaxation practice for stress relief, but to dismantle some very core ideas about reality.</p><p>It is important to keep in mind that even when everything goes well, when you manage to dodge heavy dark nights and bizarre physical symptoms, meditation in itself is disorienting and destabilizing. It is meant to deconstruct parts of your cognitive structure, and what the process actually feels like is unpredictable. These changes are largely permanent, and while most people like them, not everyone does, and they can be harsh. Your worldview and interpersonal relationships might also be drastically affected.</p><p>In the <em>Tricycle</em> article, meditation teacher Daniel Lawton details the experience he had on his 15th or so retreat that caused PTSD and led him to quit his own practice. “<em>Intensive meditation has to some extent changed the way that I experience the world, and some of those perceptual changes just don’t feel very good.</em>” (<a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/meditation-sickness/">10</a>)</p><p>Meditation doesn’t give you perfect clarity or insight, but it does give you a lot of clarity. Clarity can be great, but many times it’s very unpleasant and can’t be undone. Especially if you’ve been suppressing things about your life, you might discover that you simply have to end your relationship, change careers or carry out another drastic life change, no matter the fall-out. Or as happened to me, you might discover how painfully your life feels “off” and unaligned without any opportunity to change it, which is a wrenching experience. (Privileged people often forget how common this is.)</p><h4>How to Reduce Harm</h4><p>With severe adverse effects, having a break in practice can help or even be unavoidable. However, with some types of unpleasant symptoms, this may not provide relief, as they are not so much about the active practice, but a process that keeps running whether you practice or not. In the case of dark nights, meditation can actually be helpful as it greatly increases the chances of getting past them.</p><p>The Brown University paper notes: “<em>For example, lack of sleep, inadequate diet, and lack of exercise tended to be associated with (or preceded) destabilizing experiences, and could be corrected as remedies by increasing sleep amount, making dietary changes, or getting exercise, as well as by engaging in other activities described as grounding, calming, or embodying</em>.” (<a href="https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0176239">1</a>) This can be particularly tricky in a retreat setting, which often involves little sleep and traditionally only two meals per day eaten before noon. In case of severe adverse effects, many teachers recommend a grounding diet, such as meat and other heavy foods, even drinking alcohol.</p><p>The same paper also suggests: “<em>For certain symptoms in the somatic domain, body-based healing regimens (such as massage, acupuncture, or healing techniques that manipulate the subtle “energy” of the body) were also attempted and reported as helpful by some but not others.</em>”</p><p>Seeking help for the side effects of meditation can be tricky, as the vast majority of medical practitioners and mental health professionals have no idea what is going on and the symptoms will likely be misdiagnosed. Altered states have a long history of being pathologized in the West as mere signs of mental disturbances. (<a href="https://drrogerwalsh.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Phenomenological-Mappping-and-Comparisons-of-Shamanic-Buddhhist-Yogic-and-Schizophrenic-Experiences-JORS-1993.pdf">13</a>) I know people who have experienced this concretely with deeply traumatic consequences.</p><p>In general, having the chance to talk openly about the experienced harm would be very important. In several articles and papers about the adverse effects of spiritual practice, people who had experienced such harm were disturbed that they weren’t allowed to discuss it, e.g. because their Theravada or Zen teacher told them that kundalini awakening doesn’t exist and so they should just stop having these symptoms.</p><p>Willoughby Britton’s team has compiled a <a href="https://www.brown.edu/research/labs/britton/meditation-safety-toolbox">Meditation Safety Toolbox</a> for teachers, which includes material about e.g. screening tools, informed consent, monitoring and the effects of trauma on meditation practice. The page also has a three-hour and 20-hour paid training courses available on the subject.</p><p><em>This article also appears in modified form in my free book </em><a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/">Loving Awakening: A Practical Guide to Embodied Spirituality and Healing with Metta, IFS, the Imaginal and Community</a><em>, which goes deep into both the benefits and downsides of spiritual practice and inner work.</em></p><h4>References</h4><p>1. Lindahl JR, Fisher NE, Cooper DJ, et al. The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in western Buddhists. PLOS ONE. 2017;12(5).</p><p>2. David A. Treleaven. <em>Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness: Practices for Safe and Transformative Healing</em>. Norton 2018.</p><p>3. First Do No Harm: Foundational Competencies for Working Skillfully with Meditation-Related Challenges. <a href="https://www.cheetahhouse.org/fdnh">https://www.cheetahhouse.org/fdnh</a></p><p>4. Goretzki M. The Differentiation of Psychosis and Spiritual Emergency. PhD thesis. University of Adelaide, Adelaide. 2007.</p><p>5. Cooper DJ, Lindahl JR, Palitsky R, et al. “Like a vibration cascading through the body”: Energy-like somatic experiences reported by Western Buddhist meditators. Religions. 2021;12(12):1042.</p><p>6. Biology of Kundalini — Histamine. <a href="https://www.biologyofkundalini.com/article.php@story=Histamine.html">https://www.biologyofkundalini.com/article.php@story=Histamine.html</a></p><p>7. Lindahl JR, Cooper DJ, Fisher NE, et al. Progress or pathology? differential diagnosis and intervention criteria for meditation-related challenges: Perspectives from Buddhist meditation teachers and Practitioners. Front Psychol. 2020;11.</p><p>8. Lindahl J. Somatic energies and emotional traumas: A qualitative study of practice-related challenges reported by Vajrayāna Buddhists. Religions. 2017;8(8):153.</p><p>9. Sar V. Epidemiology of Dissociative Disorders: An overview. Epidem Res Int. 2011:1–8.</p><p>10. Wendy Biddlecombe Agsar. Buddhism’s Biggest Open Secret. Tricycle. Winter 2021. <a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/meditation-sickness/">https://tricycle.org/magazine/meditation-sickness/</a></p><p>11. Stanislav and Christina Grof cited in <a href="https://www.spiritualcompetency.com/dsm4/dsmrsproblem.pdf">https://www.spiritualcompetency.com/dsm4/dsmrsproblem.pdf</a></p><p>12. Karl Brunnholzl. <em>The Heart Attack Sutra: A New Commentary on the Heart Sutra</em>. Snow Lion 2021. pp. 12.</p><p>13. Walsh R. Phenomenological Mapping and Comparisons of Shamanic, Buddhist, Yogic, and Schizophrenic Experiences. J Amer Acad Religion. 1993 Winter;61(4):739–769.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f3bdfb24f5a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lurking in the Shadows: Harmful Interpersonal Patterns in Spiritual Communities]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/lurking-in-the-shadows-harmful-interpersonal-patterns-in-spiritual-communities-90890b9226ba?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/90890b9226ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narcissism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-bypassing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Aug 2022 17:39:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-27T15:49:35.343Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Numerous spiritual gurus and teachers have been guilty of abusing their students, but damaging behavior also takes place in peer-led spiritual communities. Behind it is almost always trauma, yet some circles’ obsession with trauma healing can also go awry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WE_bHcHpEUEtST3D" /><figcaption>Image by Anna Svets @ Pexels.com</figcaption></figure><p>Communities with a spiritual or self-improvement bent are teeming with scarred and wounded people. People generally turn to these pursuits because they’ve had turbulent life. They may struggle with heavy trauma and mental illness. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing — those with poor mental health are often kind and lovely people with a lot of wisdom to offer to others.</p><p>On the other hand, most dysfunctional behaviors and interpersonal patterns are <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">caused by trauma</a>, and many of these traumatic patterns can play into each other. Spiritual communities tend to attract both people with significant problems and people looking to rescue others, people with parental vibes and those looking to be parented (not always a problematic dynamic, but can be), as well as people who manipulate and control others, but also insecure and highly suggestible individuals who are easy to manipulate.</p><p>Unfortunately, spiritual practices can, and often do, make these problems worse. Depending on the community, I’ve seen the whole gamut of reactions to such <a href="https://www.brown.edu/research/labs/britton/sites/britton-lab/files/docs/Britton2021%20Defining%20%2B%20measuring%20meditation-related%20adverse%20effects_PUBMEDversion.pdf">adverse effects</a>, from “meditation/our technique can’t possibly do harm” to “almost everyone develops psychosis from meditation at some point, so there’s no need to worry” to “it’s normal to believe you have God-like spiritual powers and can change the destiny of the whole humankind, it’s not related to mental health”.</p><p>In the world of spirituality and self-development, people also tend to assume that they and their peers are unusually mature, deep thinkers and capable of powerful self-reflection. This may often even be true, but it is a low bar, especially among young people — my communities have had a lot of people in their 20s who can be marvelous, but a thoughtful and mature 25-year-old is still likely to overestimate their emotional skills. Many spiritual seekers believe, and can fool others into believing, that because they can converse eloquently using Sanskrit, Western psychology or neuroscience concepts, they are much farther along than they really are. The implicit assumption is too often “I would know if I behaved in problematic ways and as a group, we are above such mundane issues.”</p><h4><strong>Spiritual Bypassing</strong></h4><p>Originally coined in 1984 by psychotherapist John Welwood, the term <a href="https://www.learnreligions.com/spiritual-bypassing-44950"><em>spiritual bypassing</em></a> refers to using spiritual practice to avoid normal emotions and human experiences. A typical form of bypassing is the idea that spiritual practice makes other types of psychological work unnecessary. (Of course, most of Buddhism would also fit under this umbrella, as it’s based on the idea that once you get rid of that pesky, illusionary self, all suffering ceases.)</p><p>Robert Masters <a href="https://www.robertmasters.com/2013/04/29/spiritual-bypassing/">put it</a> like this: “<em>Aspects of spiritual bypassing include exaggerated detachment, emotional numbing and repression, overemphasis on the positive, anger-phobia, blind or overly tolerant compassion, weak or too porous boundaries, lopsided development (cognitive intelligence often being far ahead of emotional and moral intelligence), debilitating judgment about one’s negativity or shadow elements, devaluation of the personal relative to the spiritual, and delusions of having arrived at a higher level of being.”</em></p><p>Then there’s of course toxic positivity, which can include accusing people of having “negative energy/vibrations” or “manifesting negative things”, a convenient way to blame and shame those with any criticism into silence. I also find the ubiquitous spiritual idea that the universe is benevolent and everything happens “as a part of a bigger plan” (something Western psychology generally views as pathological <a href="https://youmemindbody.com/mental-health/Narcissists-Magical-Thinking">magical thinking</a>, characterizing both psychotic-type conditions and narcissism) a problematic form of bypassing.</p><p>John Welwood had numerous good insights about bypassing and how it relates to more general avoidant patterns in this <a href="https://www.johnwelwood.com/articles/TRIC_interview_ut.pdf">interview</a>. “<em>Avoidant types tend to be dismissive of other people’s needs because, guess what, they’re dismissive of their own needs. What happens is that people feel justified in not respecting each other’s feelings and needs. Not surprisingly, “need” becomes a dirty word in many spiritual communities.</em> […] <em>If I’m not able to own my own needs, then I will tend to dismiss others’ needs and see them as a threat because their neediness subconsciously reminds me of my own denied needs. And I will judge others and use some kind of “dharma logic” to make them wrong or make myself superior.</em>”</p><p>There is also formal psychological research being conducted on spiritual bypassing, including a research scale titled <a href="https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2017-45103-001">Spiritual Bypass Scale-13</a> for measuring it. That same scientific paper lists, citing other authors, quite a shopping list of possible harms of spiritual bypassing, such as “<em>need to control others and self, dichotomous thinking, shame, spiritual obsession, fear, emotional confusion, addiction, high tolerance for inappropriate behavior, codependence, compulsive goodness, narcissism or ego inflation, obsession or addiction, blind belief in charismatic teachers, spiritual materialism, developmental arrest, and abdication of personal responsibility</em>”. I was going to add emphasis to the items that feel relevant to this article, but realized that would cover most of the list.</p><p>One nefarious form of spiritual bypassing can happen when people attain a permanent state of nonduality or get glimpses of it, and become convinced that problems (intrapersonal, interpersonal or more pressing societal issues) in the real world do not need to be tackled, since on the absolute level, everything is already perfect. I’ve called this confusion of relative and absolute levels “toxic enlightenment”, an intentionally provocative term that hasn’t appealed to everyone. Meditation teacher Michael Taft calls a similar issue “<a href="https://deconstructingyourself.com/nondual-fundamentalism.html">nondual fundamentalism</a>”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/589/0*FrqYlOkFkm1tv_Gi" /></figure><p>Especially Neo-Advaita teachings <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-Advaita#Spiritual_bypassing">may encourage</a> these sort of ideas about nonduality (which <a href="https://www.unbrokenself.com/spiritual-bypassing/">do not originate</a> from the Advaita Vedanta school of Hinduism, but its modern, mostly secular interpretations), luckily usually as a temporary stage. Those who attain nondual realizations from Buddhist teachings seem much less likely to have this issue. Some people on the /r/nonduality Reddit <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/nonduality/comments/qx5n35/spiritual_bypassing/">even argue</a> that spiritual bypassing doesn’t exist, it’s just these lower-level human beings trying to ruin your perfect enlightenment. Of course.</p><h4><strong>“I Told You I Was Hardcore” and Obsession with Healing</strong></h4><p>Religions generally don’t recognize the concept of trauma, yet some New Age communities are form around trauma healing. This may seem like the opposite of spiritual bypassing: working with emotions instead of ignoring them. In practice it often becomes a model fixated on healing, “cleaning” and integration to the point where people’s lives revolve around it — so it can actually become bypassing as other aspects of life are neglected — and the deeper you throw yourself into it, the cooler and more spiritual you are. And when you’re very cool and spiritual, it can be tempting to start advising others and insisting they copy your exact approach.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/559/0*G-hpoXggWeeu-LqC" /><figcaption><em>Meme by Kaloyan Stefanov</em></figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://academyofideas.com/2015/12/carl-jung-and-the-shadow-the-hidden-power-of-our-dark-side/">“Shadow</a>” is an originally Jungian idea that there are large aspects of ourselves that we have pushed away and repressed, when it would be wiser to face them and integrate them. Nowadays it’s a very popular term in the spiritual/New Age scene. Shadow is an easily understandable and down-to-earth concept that isn’t problematic in itself, but it can become damaging when people start submitting constant “bug reports” of their friends’ “shadow sides” or “blind spots”, which in some circles is common and even encouraged. As the concept hints at, it’s much more appealing to debug others’ shadows than your own.</p><p>Being nudged toward noticing something in yourself that was clear to others but outside your own awareness can be very useful, or it can be misguided and hurtful, a form of control and asserting superiority. Generally, the more eager people are to point out such things, the less accurate they tend to be and more likely to be projecting their own issues on you — and less keen to accept they could be wrong.</p><p>There is a reason why mental health professionals study psychology and psychiatric conditions for years (people often feel like even this knowledge is sorely lacking, but that’s another issue altogether). Concepts like shadow and energy blockages aren’t enough to deal with actual serious trauma. Especially severe childhood trauma is almost always accompanied by dissociation, which can lead to all sorts of <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">bizarre behavior</a>. Of the general population, <a href="https://www.hindawi.com/journals/eri/2011/404538/"><em>nearly 10%</em></a> struggles with severe dissociation (in spiritual circles likely a larger percentage) and in such cases e.g. <em>meditation may not even be appropriate</em> (see e.g. David Treleaven’s book <em>Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness</em>).</p><p>Carelessly thrusting dissociating people onto a supercharged healing or spiritual path can be immensely destabilizing for them, which others may shrug off as “everyone goes through <a href="https://www.mctb.org/mctb2/table-of-contents/part-iv-insight/30-the-progress-of-insight/5-dissolution-entrance-to-the-dark-night/">dark nights</a>”. <em>This is not the same thing at all!</em> Extreme but still normal effects of spiritual practice can be difficult to tell apart from serious mental health conditions like mania and psychosis, but ignoring potentially alarming behavior and mental health crises can be very risky.</p><p>Many spiritual people will tell you that feeling into an unpleasant emotion deeply enough will make it heal, similar to the core Buddhist idea that suffering only arises from resisting unpleasantness. Without resistance, there can be no suffering. This idea has a lot of truth to it, but reality is much more complex than that. It can be frustrating to attempt to discuss your problems with a person who is convinced everything can be solved like this. Here healing again crosses over to bypassing.</p><p>Related problematic ideas include everyone being responsible for their own stuff, possibly including just their internal emotional landscape, but sometimes external circumstances too, and that psychological pain is always beneficial, as it leads to more healing. These forms of spiritual bypassing often find their way into hurtful gaslighting. Especially combined with the magical thinking of “everything happens as a part of your story”, they can even be used to argue that if someone hurt you, they were actually doing you a <em>favor</em>. This not only enables abuse to happen, it’s <a href="https://tesswhitehurst.com/new-age-2-0-its-time-for-an-upgrade/">victim blaming</a> — a term that would be <a href="https://www.newagepower.net/the-real-new-age/new-age-victim-blaming-shaming/">hushed away</a> in many spiritual circles.</p><p>Both Western psychologists and healing-obsessed mystics struggle to tell apart two very different issues: past trauma and current hostile conditions. Living in major, long-term hardship is also known as <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8158953/"><em>continuous traumatic stress</em></a> (CTS) in trauma literature. CTS should not be confused with things like complex PTSD, which refers to unsafety of the <em>past</em>, while e.g. poverty, illness or living in a dangerous environment may take place in the <em>now</em>. The suffering caused by them can be compounded by past trauma, but the unsafety of the present won’t go away by “feeling deeply into it” or “letting go of resistance” (or getting enlightened, sorry).</p><h4><strong>Hierarchy and Control</strong></h4><p>Hierarchies <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5494206/">easily form</a> even in communities with no official leadership. People who have practiced for longer than others or gone on more retreats may appoint themselves as leaders and teachers. Believing in a larger range of “woo” ideas also tends to increase their sense of superiority and they frequently accuse more skeptical people of being on an energetically lower level or otherwise stunted. “More” always seems better than moderation. And people tend to reject criticism from those perceived to be below them — how could they know anything better?</p><p>I believe that most people display at least some controlling behaviors. There is a lot of discussion about controlling parents and dominance in romantic relationships, but much less about friendships. Almost all friendships, even if otherwise healthy and nourishing, have some uneven power dynamics with one or both people exhibiting controlling patterns at least occasionally. Even insecure and/or submissive individuals commonly have such patterns and they can be much harder to spot.</p><p>The way spiritual friendships tend to dive right in at the deep end can encourage unhealthy patterns. Sometimes it takes the form of something similar to <a href="https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-love-bombing-5223611#:~:text=Love%20bombing%20occurs%20when%20someone,lead%20to%20gaslighting%20and%20abuse.">lovebombing</a>. I’ve also had people trying to manage my life decisions within a couple of weeks of (barely) knowing me. These issues appear somewhat contagious: if you see those around you controlling others and no one bats an eye, it is easy to adopt such patterns.</p><p>Some types of manipulation are much easier to pull off in communities where it’s normalized to use spiritual and psychological jargon to explain one’s and others’ behavior, while in most circles this would come off as a major red flag in itself. One abusive person tried to convince me she wasn’t acting in a controlling way, I was merely projecting the behavior of others in the group on her, while several people have tried to blame some of their issues on my “blind spots”.</p><p>One rarely discussed factor is suggestibility. Of course, a skeptical view is that almost all spiritual experiences are based on suggestion and altered states, but it can also go much deeper than this. Suggestible individuals may absorb pack leaders’ opinions by osmosis or appear to change their world-view or guru du jour with every new YouTube video. They may even start mimicking the descriptions of others’ spiritual experiences. Many suggestible people are also <a href="https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/mind-guest-blog/the-emotional-blindness-of-alexithymia/">alexithymic</a> (both traits tend to <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320569143_Psychological_characteristics_of_dissociation_in_general_population">correlate with dissociation</a>), which means they <em>may not be aware of how they feel inside</em>, allowing others to talk for them.</p><p>Spiritual prescriptivism can be a major issue with controlling types. Only their way of practice is right, either because their guru said so or because they just decided it themselves. They push their gurus’ teachings (which might be an eclectic mix of e.g. Buddhist, Hindu and New Age teachers, but everyone else besides this bunch is wrong), and try to make you feel obliged to watch three-hour dharma talks you’d really rather skip. I used to be a member of an extremely toxic sangha where someone tried to dictate “rules” such as “Everyone should meditate for at least three hours per day and never take less than five grams of shrooms at once — less of either would be <em>worthless</em>.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rIrUvc5jARf6pO3S" /></figure><p>It’s peculiar how insistently some people have shoved their views on me even in groups that on paper didn’t adhere to any fixed ideology. It feels like Human Interaction 101 that others’ world-views should be respected and aggressively trying to override them isn’t okay. Certain perspectives become so ingrained in the collective New Age psyche that people push their ideas of how the world works <em>without even realizing they are doing that</em>, as to them it is not a belief, but obvious <em>truth</em>. Outside of Christian communities, someone continually insisting that Jesus solves all problems would come off as rather weird and unpleasant and would almost certainly be called out, yet more palatable attempts at conversion are widespread.</p><p>Controlling traits can manifest in seemingly benign or positive ways, such as what I call <em>rescue parts</em>. These are parts of the psyche that want to fix others, e.g. their practical problems, health issues or (perceived) spiritual stagnation. Rescue parts feel like you are just a very compassionate person burning to help others. This can be true, too, but deep down these parts’ motivations are not about altruism but control. Someone offering a hand can be great, yet if the offer is coming from rescue parts, it can quickly turn sour — the helper gets offended if their solution isn’t considered beneficial or suddenly sets conditions for receiving the help. I talk more about rescue parts in <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/why-healthy-people-abandon-their-chronically-ill-friends-2d7d6231949">another article</a>.</p><h4><strong>Dark Triad Behaviors</strong></h4><p><a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/dark-triad-personality.html"><em>The dark triad</em></a> is a concept in mainstream psychology referring to personality traits of psychopathy, Machiavellianism and narcissism, which may exist together or separately. Sometimes sadism is added for “dark tetrad”. Narcissist traits in particular are very common in spiritual communities. The web is full of articles on the subject of spiritual narcissism, though most I didn’t find particularly compelling. There is, however, actual research on the topic, as well. <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-science-of-spiritual-narcissism/">This article</a> in <em>Scientific American</em> is well worth reading. It cites several studies, such as one that found that yoga and meditation<em> boosted </em>the trait of self-centrality, instead of reducing it.</p><p>Narcissistic people are drawn to dominant roles. They tend to be charismatic, dominant, edgy and widely liked (but sometimes controversial) teachers or self-appointed sages with wild stories of travel to every astral realm and their generally shocking and extraordinary spiritual journeys.</p><p>“<em>Our results illustrate that the self-enhancement motive is powerful and deeply ingrained so that it can hijack methods intended to transcend the ego and instead, adopt them to its own service… The road to spiritual enlightenment may yield the exact same mundane distortions that are all too familiar in social psychology, such as self-enhancement, illusory superiority, closed-mindedness, and hedonism (clinging to positive experiences) under the guise of alleged ‘higher’ values.</em>” (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/ejsp.2721">source</a>)</p><p>Most spiritual communities have a surprisingly high tolerance for dark triad patterns, such as judgmental, manipulative, controlling and self-elevating behavior and plotting people against each other. People with narcissist traits may gloss over the stunts of other narcissists, and narcissists also tend to ramp up their level of disagreeability slowly with time, making it harder to spot. Still, it’s peculiar how claims like “<em>I’m a deeply compassionate person as shown by the fact that I do five minutes of loving-kindness meditation every day</em>” are often taken at face value over the person’s actual conduct.</p><p>The media depiction of narcissists and psychopaths tends to be extreme and highly problematic. Many websites (including one maintained by a narcissist!) paint narcissists as beings so emotionally undeveloped that they are barely even human. The definition of psychopathy has been based on the inability to feel empathy, though some research has suggested it’s not about lacking the capacity, but <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-23431793">turning it off</a>. Narcissists are also believed to not experience empathy or only low levels, but <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/intense-emotions-and-strong-feelings/202001/do-narcissists-actually-lack-empathy">studies have shown</a> that this is untrue, and they may also be turning this capacity off at will.</p><p>I’ve had several close spiritual friends with authentic deep compassion and care yet also some disturbing dark tetrad traits (which some of them have freely admitted to). This would fit with a concept called <em>dark empath</em>, a term sometimes used for people with high cognitive empathy who use their interpersonal skills for manipulation. <a href="https://theconversation.com/dark-empaths-how-dangerous-are-psychopaths-and-narcissists-with-empathy-178715">Originally</a>, however, it referred to individuals with dark triad traits who are also high in both <a href="https://www.definingempathy.com/development/affective-cognitive-model">cognitive and affective empathy</a> and also tend to be highly extroverted and fairly self-critical. In the original dark empath study, 20% of the study sample fit this classification, so this is no marginal group of people.</p><p>There are several different ways to classify narcissists, which can get a bit confusing. The most common one is <em>grandiose</em> vs. <em>vulnerable</em> narcissists (though both sides can <a href="https://www.psypost.org/2022/04/narcissism-study-sheds-new-light-on-the-relationship-between-grandiose-and-vulnerable-subtypes-6289">coexist</a> in the same person) or <a href="https://www.verywellmind.com/understanding-the-covert-narcissist-4584587"><em>overt</em> and <em>covert</em> narcissists</a> — so no, many of them are nothing like Trump. A classical idea associated with narcissists is that after a possible honeymoon period of flattery, they are constantly elevating themselves at the expense of others. <a href="http://www.southampton.ac.uk/~crsi/Gebauer_Sedikides_Verplanken_%20Maio_2012_JPSP.pdf"><em>Communal narcissists</em></a>, however, may be keen on uplifting people in the same community, sometimes in idolizing ways, as their core belief is that they are <em>unusually helpful</em>.</p><p><em>Closet narcissists</em> (sometimes treated as a synonym for covert narcissists while other authors see them as separate things) are also <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/understanding-narcissism/201712/how-the-3-types-narcissists-act-first-date">described</a> as “<em>being afraid that other people will see all their flaws. Instead they find ways to attach themselves to people, causes, religions, and other things that they admire and consider special. They then feel special by association.</em>”</p><p>People are of course very multifaceted, with much more complexity and nuance than psychology research tends to suggest. Possessing dark triad traits doesn’t invalidate someone’s spiritual progress or mean they can’t be genuinely kind and helpful. Narcissism is one way childhood trauma can manifest and interact with the rest of the personality. Real empathy and contrived, socially sanctioned niceness may coexist, and likely do in most of us. While most abuse relates to dark triad traits, not everyone with narcissistic traits is abusive. It does mean that some things they boast about in themselves (or others) may not be fully true, a helpful thing to keep in mind in social interaction in general.</p><h4><strong>Oppression vs. Radical inclusivity</strong></h4><p>Spiritual communities often perpetuate oppression, such as <a href="https://virginiarosenberg.com/blog/2016/7/10/converting-hidden-spiritual-racism-into-sacred-activism-an-open-letter-to-spiritual-white-folks">racism</a>/white supremacy, ableism and queerphobia. I’m a white disabled queer person, so I’m focusing on the latter two here, which is not to be taken as minimizing racism. This dynamic of oppression has been called “<a href="http://www.contemplativemind.org/files/ICEA_vol1_2017.pdf#page=85">structural spiritual bypassing</a>”. “<em>A core assumption of Structural Spiritual Bypassing in the mindfulness movement is that sociocultural power differentials are irrelevant, or even an illusion. This silences any acknowledgement [sic] of privilege, which becomes veiled in spirituality, denying the often obvious but sometimes subtle dynamics of power and privilege in our world</em>”. Just like with other damaging behaviors, people may feel like they are too kind, wise or self-aware to be acting in discriminatory ways.</p><p>The combination of spiritual bypassing plus the obsession with healing is often taken to mean that the universe is perfect (nothing to fix there), while simultaneously we are all imperfect versions of ourselves to be fixed. This can get particularly toxic when things like sexual orientation, gender identity, asexuality, neurodivergence and chronic illness are viewed as “attachment to body/identity” or “things just waiting to be healed”.</p><p>In general, even if there is no overt discrimination, the vast majority of spiritual communities fall into a huge spiritual bypass trap and fail to consider how to make different groups of people feel welcome. Every community obviously doesn’t need to cater to every demographic, but diversity also brings in a wider spectrum of perspectives and excluding large swathes of the population because of ignorance doesn’t seem very spiritual. When you’re boasting that you work “for the benefit of all beings”, are you really only considering beings similar to you?</p><p>Homophobia and especially transphobia are sadly rampant in spiritual circles. Besides “healing damaged masculinity/femininity”, ideas of masculine and feminine energies as two opposites (e.g. by <a href="http://jungpage.org/learn/articles/analytical-psychology/147-jung-and-gender-masculine-and-feminine-revisited">interpreting Jungian psychology</a>) can lead to narratives very hostile to LGBTIQ people. Discussion about gendered energies isn’t inherently heteronormative or transphobic, but very often it veers into this territory. I find it particularly sad considering how many spiritual cultures have celebrated gender variance in concepts like <a href="https://www.transfaith.info/articles/two-spirit-my-journey-home"><em>two-spirit</em></a> (a Western label for many different indigenous genders) and even seen it as divine, e.g. in <a href="https://www.spectrumsouth.com/divine-non-binary/">nonbinary deities</a>.</p><h4><strong>Have You Tried Yoga?</strong></h4><p>Ableism (discrimination against disabled people), especially focused on chronic illness, is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvZsb9Y7xtU">not hard to find</a> in the spiritual scene. I’ve long lost count of how many times I’ve been told that my life-threatening chronic illnesses can be healed with meditation, magick, manifestation, ayahuasca, trauma work or energy healing — implicitly and often also explicitly telling me I’m practicing wrong since I’m not cured. This ties to the <a href="https://www.scu.edu/ethics/ethics-resources/ethical-decision-making/the-just-world-theory/">Just World Hypothesis</a>, a pervasive form of magical thinking also behind a lot of non-spiritual ableism: if only we do things right, we are protected from nasty things such as illness.</p><p>As a result of this, chronically ill people tend to deeply distrust the whole scene. E.g. a common joke in chronic illness circles is “Have you tried yoga?” When I mention my meditation practice, many disabled people flinch, as they wonder if I’ll start preaching about mindfulness and crystals. This experience has been deeply alienating — it’s hard to find a spiritual home where I feel welcome instead of a problem to be fixed, but I feel too far out for most disabled communities too.</p><p>When multiple spiritual friends insist you should stop taking your meds, without which you would rapidly and inevitably perish, and to “trust magic” or “trust the universe” instead, it’s easy to grow disillusioned with the whole scene. This <em>is</em> too far out. It is <a href="https://www.thefreelibrary.com/New+Age+guilt%3a+dealing+with+the+unrealistic+expectations+of+positive...-a019802772">New Age guilt</a>, essentially the same thing as “If you had prayed more, your cancer would be cured”. It is curious though, considering that even the Buddha himself had chronic pain and many revered contemporary teachers suffer from chronic illness or died from it, but somehow I’m expected to get well.</p><p>There are different interpretations of the concept of karma, so not everyone who believes in karma holds this (unfortunately quite traditional) view, but telling someone they’re chronically ill (or e.g. LGBTIQ) because of something they did in their current or past life is abusive. The same goes for touting narratives where someone “chose” a disability or was “given” it before birth, so they could “learn a lesson”, as well as some world-class bypasses claiming that illness doesn’t even exist — honestly I shouldn’t need to say any of this. This is just as problematic as a “Christian” telling someone they’re going to Hell.</p><p>The most shocking example of ableism I’ve encountered was when someone actually started voicing support for eugenics. I asked abled people to stand up for me and condemn this view, but I was faced with silence. Imagine touting your infinite compassion and then shutting up when actual genocide is brought up.</p><h4><strong>How to Deal With These Issues</strong></h4><p>So how do we go about tackling these issues? I’d start with looking inside and asking if you’re contributing to any of these patterns yourself. As for others, issues should be called out in an appropriate way if it feels safe for you to do. This does not have to mean a punitive approach, but “Are you okay?” or “Are you and person Y cool or is something wrong?”.</p><p>If you’re founding a spiritual community, 1) set rules/terms/code of conduct for the members and hold to them, 2) consider how to make different groups of people feel more welcome, 3) make it easy to report misconduct or issues and 4) again, if you’re unsure if there is a problem, don’t assume there isn’t.</p><p>Many communities lack any sort of official rules. In my experience, one important reason you need them is that when someone starts misbehaving, it’s often a person you know and like, so you are tempted to let it slide. This has been a major issue in my past sanghas. People are also more likely to bring up abuse (especially discrimination) if it is explicitly labeled as unacceptable. If you’re a man, you might want to announce a non-male person to whom members can report issues and concerns.</p><p>I believe it can be very helpful to have some idea of what things like psychosis, bipolar manic episodes, <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">structural dissociation</a> and narcissistic manipulation are and how they might manifest in a group setting. Such issues will almost certainly materialize in your community at some point, if they haven’t already. This may seem like a tall order — if you are not a mental health professional, obviously Google University can’t make you one nor should you start diagnosing people. This is a complicated issue, but I also firmly believe it’s an important one. Setting up a spiritual community is much more than just opening a Facebook group or booking a real-life space. It comes with a large responsibility.</p><p>Recently, a puzzle game I’ve been playing for a couple of years introduced a groups feature. I set up a new group named “Metta”. It’s been nice to finally chat with people who’ve quietly been on my friend list for a long time. The conversation is superficial fluff, but there is something really lovely about that, too. We can have a good vibes-only group without having to bypass anything. They will not try to fix me or suggest I’m living my life wrong. Someone might recognize the word “metta” refers to Buddhist loving-kindness, but they aren’t going to demand details on my practice only to mock it. Wouldn’t it be nice if we could have such a guarantee in spiritual communities, as well.</p><p><em>This article also appears in modified form in my free book </em><a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/">Loving Awakening: A Practical Guide to Embodied Spirituality and Healing with Metta, IFS, the Imaginal and Community</a>, which also discusses interpersonal issues and spirituality in a wider context<em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=90890b9226ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Healthy People Abandon Their Chronically Ill Friends]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/why-healthy-people-abandon-their-chronically-ill-friends-2d7d6231949?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d7d6231949</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interpersonal-dynamics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chronic-illness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Jan 2022 15:11:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-01T18:45:22.739Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Why Healthy People Abandon Their Chronically Ill Friends: It’s Probably Not Why You Think</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y0lhNAgn1q4imSNu6IpQNg.png" /><figcaption>Some people find others’ suffering unbearable because of their own trauma. Photo of a severe CFS/ME patient by Lea Aring, press material from the German ME/CFS association.</figcaption></figure><p>Life with chronic illness can be very difficult and complex and others’ support is crucial, though sadly not always forthcoming. People are very complex. but we tend to neglect the complexity to lump others into categories like “he doesn’t care”.</p><p>This article focuses on why healthy or mostly healthy people sometimes abandon their chronically ill friends or family members, which usually isn’t because they don’t care, but for reasons people generally don’t even think about. These can also apply to romantic and romantic-like relationships, but of course domestic partnerships come with many additional challenges.</p><p>The TL;DR (short version) is: trauma. It’s not about you, or even your illness, it’s about them. Almost everyone has at least mild trauma. People get triggered by things they often don’t recognize as triggers which they tend to project on others. Many of those with the worst mental wounds <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561">dissociate</a> it (block it) away and may believe they have little or no trauma.</p><p>Apparent lack of caring may mean something entirely different. Many would rather be seen as bad people than weak or emotionally vulnerable. Similarly, it’s often easier to think of those who have harmed us as cold-hearted rather than mostly good yet flawed and traumatized people. Being abandoned as a severely ill person obviously really hurts, and it can even put you in harm’s way. Explanations don’t make it more okay for you. But still, I strongly believe it was most likely done because of trauma, not because of lack of compassion.</p><h4><strong>Parts of the Mind</strong></h4><p>Most of us believe ourselves to have one singular mind: that we are one person with traits such as kindness, compassion, patience and a sense of humor (and of course also some less appealing ones). The reality is much more complicated than that. Our mind contains numerous, frequently conflicting wants, aversions, fears and beliefs. It can be helpful to think of them as <em>parts of the mind</em>. There are several theories with similar perspectives, which may call parts things like schemas or ego states instead. In this article I’m mostly drawing from <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">Internal Family Systems</a> (IFS).</p><p>No one is kind or patient in every situation. People often don’t do things they want to do (like treating others well, going to the gym or voicing their opinions) yet may find themselves doing something they definitely don’t want to do, like shouting, procrastination or bad habits. All of this discordance boils down to parts. Then other parts react to these failings and make us feel guilty or ashamed — not because they want to hurt us, but because they are trying to help. It’s possible and even common to believe things you know to be false, like many people believe they’re lazy or a bad person while knowing it’s not true. We are incredibly complex yet in daily life mostly ignore this complexity.</p><p>It is a huge cliché, but most of our personality is molded when we are kids, and <em>often parts created in the childhood become stuck there with their goals and perceived solutions</em>. Some people’s early years have involved deeply traumatic events. Others get off more easily, but everyone experiences minor hurts that can lead to so-called “<a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/contemporary-psychoanalysis-in-action/201506/micro-traumas-can-undermine-our-emotional-health">microtrauma</a>” or “small-t trauma”, which is how most parts are formed: something seemingly insignificant but that still hurts and drives a part of your mind to change your thinking or behavior. All parts all trying to help and solve your problems, but especially the “young” ones commonly only make things worse. You wouldn’t want to have toddlers running your life, but in practice, this is what happens to many people.</p><p>Interpersonal situations can be particularly hefty for parts running amok, as they react to both each other and other people’s parts, creating a nearly endless number of possible conflicts. When an angry kid on one side reacts to a hurt kid on the other, problems often grow insurmountable. This is why relationships, particularly romantic and romantic-like ones, can be so difficult. We may have a hundred reasons to love our spouses yet also sometimes find a hundred and one ways to be annoyed by them — not to mention situations where we really consider breaking up with someone and face a flood of parts voicing differing opinions on this.</p><p>A model is only good if it helps you comprehend things. For me the IFS model has been extremely helpful for understanding myself, other people and the society as a whole. You might initially be skeptical of the concept — and it’s healthy to be skeptical, of course. The skeptical parts do their best to protect you from potentially harmful ideas. If you want to learn more about parts, you can read my <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">article</a> on Internal Family Systems. Or you can just go through the examples in this article and see if they feel familiar.</p><h4><strong>Fawn Parts</strong></h4><p>One way to understand parts better is viewing them as different types. In trauma theory, they may be divided them into fight, flight, freeze, fawn and attach parts. Of particular importance to this article are the fawn (also known as submit) parts, which are commonly created in childhood to appease our caretakers or teachers at the expense of our needs. Many chronically ill people also develop strong fawn parts later on, as we need to stay on the good side of friends, family, <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/medical-trauma-6fa90c6ecab0">doctors</a>, bosses and carers. Even if they have wronged us, it may feel safer to gloss over it.</p><p>Fawn parts are also known as people-pleasing or lack of boundaries, but to the person being fawned, they may feel like the other person is just being nice, understanding and helpful. While fawn parts are often easy to like, they tend to form complex dynamics with other parts and trigger them. Parts can be <em>polarized</em> with each other, wanting opposite things and engaging in a kind of tug-of-war. After you’ve put on a good face for someone you really dislike or played down a hurtful situation, you may feel resentful and disgusted.</p><p>Fawn parts may be polarized with fight parts that don’t feel like pleasing anyone (and they have a point, aiming to please is generally not a healthy habit) and flight parts that just want to get away from everything. Despite their name, fight parts aren’t always looking for actual fights. Their anger may take the form of frustration, resentment or acting cold and controlling. They may shut down the fawn parts when they perceive someone else is acting controlling. Sometimes that person might be you, even when you didn’t do anything to warrant that, which can feel confusing and hurtful.</p><p>Psychologist Jay Earley discusses the polarization of people-pleaser (fawn) and passive-aggressive (fight) parts in his book <em>Self-Therapy vol. 3</em>. The people-pleaser dishes out promises, while the passive-aggressive part resents these offers and believes it must have been forced into them (because “it” didn’t make those promises, it was a different part!). The resentment makes it view the other party as controlling or manipulative. Someone may promise to e.g. help you with practical things on their own volition, yet <em>their parts may feel like you manipulated them into it</em>. I’ve sadly experienced this dynamic with several different people.</p><h4><strong>Mimics for Empathy</strong></h4><p>There are many different definitions for empathy and compassion, in psychology, neuroscience, philosophy and religious traditions (as well as different types of empathy recognized in psychology). It is commonly asserted that if you feel empathy or compassion for someone, you will also feel their pain. For some people with severe trauma and lack of emotional boundaries, this is a major problem: <em>they may feel others’ pain so strongly it becomes unbearable</em>. They can’t deal with it, which tends to activate freeze and especially flight parts.</p><p><em>This is not empathy</em>. I’ve sometimes called it “toxic empathy”, but even that is a problematic label, as it suggests it is still a form of empathy. It’s parts reacting to trauma. It’s parts making others’ pain about themselves. As with all parts, they are trying to help, but end up only making things worse both for the person and their loved ones.</p><p>Like all trauma, these parts can be healed, though they are often very resistant to the idea, as they tend to feel morally superior. They believe they represent real empathy or even a special form like “hyperempathy”, that they are what makes the person “an empath”, a good person or more specifically, <em>makes them a good person, unlike those horrible, ruthless people who treated them badly in the past.</em></p><p>None of this is true. But the parts really believe that and believe that not crumbling from others’ pain would be terrible.</p><p>Having this kind of parts doesn’t mean one isn’t empathetic or compassionate underneath them. When you’re in the state of <em>Self</em>, as IFS calls it, you’re not blended with any part. Instead of wanting to fight, flight, freeze, submit or to attach, you feel grounded and spacious. In Self you naturally feel compassion for yourself and others, yet their suffering does not burden you. That may sound incredible to someone who has only experienced parts-based “compassion”, yet this is an innate capacity. It does not make you “cold” or “distant”, quite the opposite. In this headspace you project authentic caring and the problem doesn’t become about you. You can think clearly about the best course of action and need not worry about <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compassion_fatigue">compassion fatigue</a>.</p><p>In short, many people who abandon their chronically ill loved ones don’t do it because they don’t care.<em> They care in a way that hurts them deeply</em> and they believe this is what caring means. It becomes too much and the only solution they know is getting away. Does that make it okay? No, it doesn’t, but we don’t always have the clarity to do the right things, let alone when emotionally overwhelmed.</p><p>I’ve talked to quite a few people who’ve admitted to having this kind of parts, but most people lack the emotional skills to realize any of this happening. Those with severe trauma are often in a constant state of turmoil and only really notice whether it gets better or worse. When they’re in contact with someone who “causes” them to feel more pain, they conclude that the other person is “bad”. They may even get angry at you for “making them” hurt and make up an explanation as to why you caused this anger and it’s justifiable. Remember, they are likely blended with parts that are <em>effectively young children</em>.</p><h4><strong>Rescuer Parts</strong></h4><p>If you are chronically ill, you won’t have missed other people’s rescuer parts. They tend to be similar to the fawn parts that find your pain unbearable, but while your suffering makes some parts feel really helpless and awful, rescuer parts see it as a challenge: they will save you. These parts have always wanted to save a family from a burning building and now they see smoke.</p><p>Different rescuer parts may have different ideas of how to accomplish this. Some choose to help you practically, which can be lovely, but these parts are difficult to satisfy. Whatever they do, they can’t <em>save</em> you, and eventually they may blame that on you. Others rely on God to save you (also not the best track record for success), while some try to come up with medical solutions. They may ruminate for hours pondering the best ways to change your life, which makes other parts resent you “for using up” a lot of this person’s energy!</p><p>You’ve no doubt encountered some rescuer parts online, asking if you’ve tried yoga, CBD or going gluten-free. But these can also be parts of loved ones, who may have more sophisticated and personal approaches or may not, but even if they base their suggestions on medical literature, it usually feels like they “mansplain” and talk over you. It’s like they consider you completely helpless (if you were more resourceful than they are, how could they possibly rescue you?). Rescuer parts can lead to codependent relationships, where one person becomes the rescuer and the other, the rescued.</p><p>Occasionally rescuer parts or parts associated with them can act in extreme, unhinged ways, as happened to me with a new friend I barely knew, who yelled at me on the phone and believed she could force me to see a new doctor even though I didn’t consider that a helpful idea. In this case, I was the one who decided to let go of this budding relationship, even knowing she had good intentions. In my experience, rescuer parts are very likely to sour the friendship. And it’s a big letdown: while sometimes these parts irk you from the start, in other cases it may have felt like you finally found someone who cares. And they <em>do</em> care, their parts just don’t know skillful ways to handle it.</p><p>Of course this doesn’t mean everyone who wants to help you in some way does that because of rescuer parts, but they are often involved in at last some way.</p><h4><strong>Other Trauma-Related Issues</strong></h4><p>A lot of the ableist attitudes in society are caused by parts believing in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis">Just World hypothesis</a>. You will surely recognize people with such a belief: those convinced that if you eat healthily and go to the gym, you’re immune to disease (sometimes it’s hard to differentiate rescuer parts that try to help you from morally righteous parts who just want your inconvenient disability to stop existing, and ultimately it may not matter). The world is a scary place, but it can be comforting to believe that if you just “do everything right”, you’re safe from nasties like illness. Many people with chronic conditions prove this idea wrong just by existing, and it’s very unpleasant for such parts to handle.</p><p>A somewhat similar attitude held by parts who are frightened of reality is “the law of attraction”: the idea that if you want something enough, you’ll get it. Like with Just World, if reality did operate with this logic it would surely make life much nicer and easier. If only! Of course, this world-view suggests if you’re sick, it’s because you want to be, which can be disturbing to them (and has the potential to endanger the nice, fluffy world-view), but much more disturbing to you.</p><p>Many people really <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/gaslighting-death-4ead6f087de9">struggle with the concept of death</a>. Your illness may make them face their own mortality in a way that puts the Just World hypothesis in question, or they might be terrified of you dying, perhaps because the previously mentioned parts that fear their own unbearable suffering that would result from it. Such fears are mostly not voiced or necessarily even admitted internally, as fear of death is considered embarrassing, a sign of weakness.</p><p>It’s common to have parts that struggle with responsibility, duty or commitment. Fear of commitment is not just an issue in romantic relationships! If people with this kind of parts end up in a situation where they’re helping you, including in ways that are considered ordinary and noncommittal when helping out abled acquaintances, such as giving someone a ride, their parts may begin to resent this responsibility or “being your carer”. This usually relates to the already mentioned dynamic of people-pleasing parts polarized with passive-aggression.</p><h4><strong>The Role of Disbelief</strong></h4><p>One of my own disabilities is chronic fatigue syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis (CFS/ME), a highly debilitating neurological condition, which still doesn’t have the recognition it deserves. People with poorly understood chronic illnesses such as mine often believe this lack of recognition is why others disappear from their lives: those people don’t believe the illness is real. I don’t doubt this can happen, but I think it is often more complicated. Those with widely accepted diagnoses tend to experience similar levels of abandonment. Not to mention that a caring person not burdened by their own trauma would not desert a loved one even if that person <em>did</em> suffer from actual hypochondria. Or if someone <em>was</em> making up their whole illness, that clearly suggests they are doing very poorly.</p><p>Even if people say they’re stepping back because of not accepting your diagnosis, I think it is more likely related to the factors I described earlier. In cases of actual disbelief, it is often about Just World hypothesis: <em>rather than your diagnosis, they actually disbelieve someone could be sick without it being their own fault</em>. The skepticism can also be a front for the lesser socially acceptable feelings, like fear of death, feeling helpless or not being able to deal with your suffering. I suspect it may also be about those earlier explained parts that unfairly and misguidedly believe you’re manipulating the person. If they can’t figure out what you’re supposedly manipulating them with, they may conclude it’s actually your illness.</p><p>Of course there is a social acceptability factor: it’s considered the sign of a truly awful person to abandon someone with cancer. Cutting contact with someone with e.g. fibromyalgia, anxiety or mast cell activation syndrome would not be viewed as nearly as deplorable, even if in practice that person was sicker, needed more help and had less of a support network available. That’s not to say those with cancer never get dumped — but in such cases, people may be more likely to begrudgingly stay.</p><h4><strong>How to Fix This</strong></h4><p>The sad thing about this all is that even when you understand someone’s problems, you can’t fix them. Only that person can. It sucks and it’s hard to accept, but there’s nothing you can do about it. Most people who have severe trauma are <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/i-want-to-heal-but-also-i-dont-why-do-many-feel-averse-to-therapy-and-trauma-work-5330be0aa99d">terrified of healing it</a>. Others do go to therapy, but how they react to your illness (which they may view as your problematic behavior anyway, instead of their own) is not likely to be a priority among their issues.</p><p>But if there is someone in your life, or perhaps among the people reading this, who is hoping to change their ways, this article can serve as a starting point. These parts can be healed like all trauma, with the help of a professional or using Internal Family Systems in self-therapy, as detailed in my <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b">article on IFS</a>. If you are someone who believes themselves to be an empath who can’t deal with others’ pain, the good news is that you can heal from that and discover real empathy. That will greatly help you deal with even the most difficult situations in life.</p><p>And if you’re the person who’s sick, because deep down this is not about you or your illness, it means hopefully you will find more people without trauma triggered by your disability. <em>If someone says or implies that you are a burden, what they are really saying is that their own trauma is burdening them.</em> Perhaps one day, some of these people learn to heal and you might reconcile. Either way, I hope you will find people who appreciate you as you are.</p><p>***</p><p>Several years later, I have written a kind of sequel to this piece focused more on why life-threatening illnesses in particular are so triggering for people, titled <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/gaslighting-death-4ead6f087de9">Gaslighting Death</a>. You can read more about trauma responses and their effects on interpersonal relationships, trauma caused by chronic illness and how healthcare systems are deeply traumatized and triggered by chronically ill people in my free book <a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/"><em>Shattered White-Out: How Trauma and Dissociation Mold the World, Your Relationships and You</em></a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d7d6231949" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to Internal Family Systems]]></title>
            <link>https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/introduction-to-internal-family-systems-422d6865700b?source=rss-fb9260ffae05------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/422d6865700b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ifs-therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-help]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internal-family-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychotherapy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Maija Haavisto]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Dec 2021 11:18:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-23T09:23:39.656Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Introduction to Internal Family Systems: a Groundbreaking Psychotherapy, Self-Therapy, Communication Method and World-View</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yX_3faiqCKJflRQWqkdyzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by Cottonbro @ Pexels.com</figcaption></figure><p>Internal Family Systems (IFS), developed by Richard Schwartz in the 1980s, is a form of psychotherapy that recently has been rapidly gaining popularity for several different reasons. It can be used to treat simple and complex trauma, addictions, many types of mental health conditions as well as everyday issues like procrastination and perfectionism. Its effects are often quickly apparent. IFS takes into account the person’s current situation (e.g. systemic injustices) and doesn’t pathologize or call anything maladaptive. In contrast to most types of psychotherapy, in many cases IFS can be practiced as self-therapy or with a peer, though severe traumas may be best left to professional IFS therapists.</p><p>The core concept of IFS is that our minds are made up of <em>parts</em>, kinds of subpersonalities, which make us the incredibly complex and fascinating beings we are. Parts are why we sometimes act in ways “uncharacteristic” to us, why we may do things we don’t want to do (like with addictions, bad habits and arguing) or don’t do the things we want to do (like going to the gym or expressing our boundaries). Most parts have developed in our childhood, and may be mentally stuck there, viewing the world through the lens of a child. We can contact these parts, hear them out, comfort them and solve many issues that way. Healing a part may take time, but occasionally a life-long issue may be resolved in half an hour.</p><p>In IFS, it’s usually helpful to treat parts like real people, even if you think of them as just facets of your mind — real people who want to be seen, heard, understood, valued and loved. One of the core concepts of IFS is that <em>all parts are welcome</em>. Even if some parts make you feel like they’re sabotaging your life, they are just trying to help. A part may be stuck at age four, and four-year-olds generally aren’t so good at tackling adult problems. They may hold extreme beliefs like “If I’m not perfect, no one will love me” or “Nothing will ever get better”.</p><h4><strong>Self and the Parts</strong></h4><p>IFS is not the only form of therapy focused on parts of the mind. The established schools of schema therapy (a type of CBT), ego state therapy (which has largely gone out of fashion) and Gestalt therapy also use the concept of parts, as do hypnosis parts work, many NLP techniques and Voice Dialogue. The Inner Child is a common concept in pop psychology, though it feels a bit funny from the IFS perspective — there is no one “inner child”, there are dozens of inner children!</p><p>The difference between IFS and most of these other parts-based therapies is the concept of <em>Self</em>, which is outside of any part and the cornerstone of therapeutic work. When you are in Self, not <em>blended</em> with any part, certain positive qualities like curiosity and compassion naturally arise. Even though alcoholism or withdrawing emotionally may have ruined many things for you, from Self you are able to appreciate the parts behind these issues or at least meet them with curiosity. Most other forms of parts work either have you go into a part or communicate with it indirectly, e.g. by writing.</p><p>Typically in an IFS session, the goal is to be at least mostly in Self when you communicate with parts, though sometimes approaches like consciously blending with a part or a part talking with another person’s Self are used. If you are reacting to a part or the session with emotions such as frustration, anger, anxiety, resentment, impatience or fear instead of warm openness, you’re not in Self, but blended with a part and your target part can sense that. It’s also possible to be blended with a <a href="https://personal-growth-programs.com/agenda-driven-self-like-parts-in-ifs/"><em>Self-like part</em></a>, one that believes it’s Self, which makes it difficult to progress with therapy.</p><p>Self is not just a tool for therapy. The long-term goal of IFS is to become <em>Self-led </em>in daily life. The more parts you heal, the more your system begins to trust Self and you’re less likely to react to things from a part. When you are in Self, you are not emotionally reactive and can face the difficulties of life, including interpersonal issues, with calm spaciousness and compassion for both your own and other people’s parts. After all, if someone hurt you, that was likely caused by a hurting child part of theirs.</p><p>In the IFS model, parts are divided into three types. <em>Exiles</em> carry pain and are guarded by protector parts, <em>managers</em> and <em>firefighters</em>, who try hard to stop the pain from coming to your attention. Managers have more rational approaches to this, while firefighters fight fire with fire and may escape into addictions or even self-harm. A protector may have multiple exiles and an exile may be guarded by more than one protector. You are supposed to ask a protector for permission to work with its exile. In practice, this classification is often too simplistic and I’ve rarely found it useful in my own IFS work.</p><p>There are also other ways to classify parts. Severe childhood trauma often causes <em>structural dissociation</em>, where parts carrying trauma are alienated and split off. In extreme cases, the personality may become fully compartmentalized, as is the case in DID (dissociative identity disorder), formerly known as multiple personality disorder. Structural dissociation is common and behind many mental conditions and <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/yes-means-no-no-can-mean-anything-and-everything-is-terrifying-75f53a8c5561#aecf">interpersonal issues</a>. In structural dissociation theory, trauma-related parts are divided into <em>fight, flight, freeze, fawn/submit and attach parts</em>. However, even people without dissociation often notice such parts in themselves.</p><h4><strong>Communicating with Parts</strong></h4><p>In IFS, parts can communicate with words, images, emotions, felt senses (vague vibes that may be difficult to put into words), spatial locations and bodily sensations and movement. Many people can see their parts, often down to detail such as their facial expression, body language, clothes or haircuts, but this is not necessary. Parts may look like you as a child, or something different altogether, e.g. archetypal/symbolic, a cartoon character or even an item. They may resemble someone you know, like a family member or an ex-partner.</p><p>When people first hear of IFS, they often imagine it as an inner negotiation process, and sometimes it does involve negotiation, but this approach can become you telling your parts what to do, when IFS is all about<em> listening and being there</em>. Sometimes being heard is enough to heal a part. For most people, IFS tends to revolve around <em>soothing and comforting your young parts</em>, which makes sense as most parts are children.</p><p>Most parts crave nurture, safety and/or play the most, though for people who’ve been severely neglected as children, they often aren’t able to receive these things at first. It can take a while before a part trusts you enough to say anything or even be present to you. Nurture and safety are usually best provided from Self, though some people have or develop nurturing parts to take care of other parts. Occasionally parts want imaginary scenarios where they break things or hurt or even pretend-kill people who have harmed you. This may be disturbing to other parts, but it is harmless and often empowering.</p><p><em>Polarization</em> refers to two or more parts holding strongly opposite views and engaging in a kind of tug-of-war. E.g. addictions usually feature many polarized parts. One very common polarization is one part that wants to work very hard and another that just wants to play or relax. The goal is to heal all involved parts or at least negotiate with them, so they all agree to let go, at least a bit. IFS books tend to recommend meetings for the parts to accomplish this, but I’ve generally had good results just by healing all the involved parts with normal IFS work.</p><p>Often “meta parts” crop up when doing IFS. They may be annoyed at the number of parts showing up and feel the whole thing is a chaos, want the work to progress quicker, be convinced you’re doing it wrong or just imagining everything or they may be critical of IFS as a whole. They may be voicing their real objections, e.g. an inner critic grumbling you can’t do anything right, <em>but they may also be covertly attempting to interrupt the whole process</em>. Most traumatized people carry strong <a href="https://medium.com/@maija-haavisto/i-want-to-heal-but-also-i-dont-why-do-many-feel-averse-to-therapy-and-trauma-work-5330be0aa99d">anti-healing parts</a> — to the point they can even stop you from reading IFS books. There may also be parts that make you feel tired, scatterbrained, confused or prevent you from accessing a part in order to hinder you from doing IFS or getting to a particular exile.</p><h4><strong>Miracle Questions and Other Impressive Techniques</strong></h4><p>The classical “magic question” in IFS is asking a part “What do you fear would happen if you didn’t do your job?” What would happen if that part didn’t make you drink, procrastinate or act snarky? You may discover very surprising motivations that would have never occurred to you via rational analysis, because emotional logic isn’t really amenable to analyzing. (Perhaps your sensible explanation for that behavior <em>is</em> true, but there may be several other parts behind it, as well!)</p><p>Many parts live the past and their sense of time can be quite strange: they may be angry at your boss yet still not realize you’re an adult. It’s often very helpful to <em>let parts know your current age</em>, that you are an adult who is capable of dealing with this issue, and e.g. that abusive people of the past are no longer in your life, perhaps also that you have a job, a partner or friends, if you do. This is one of the most powerful “IFS moves” and sometimes is enough on its own to heal a part.</p><p>Another very impressive move is asking a part if it is willing step aside for a bit to let you access Self. And usually they do oblige! This may seem perplexing: I can ask my anxiety if it would go away and it does, how is that even <em>possible</em>? Because you’re not wishing for a part to go away, as we so often do, you kindly ask it to <em>step back for a moment</em> for a good reason. Even if a part doesn’t immediately agree to let go, if you assuage any fears it has (e.g. let it know it’s can still follow the session and intervene if needed) or promise to get back to it, it often complies. Also, if a part is trying to flood you with its pain, you can ask if it is willing to tone down so that it’s easier for you to communicate with it. Just like with people, if you treat someone with kindness and respect, they tend to respond well to your requests.</p><h4><strong>Locating Parts</strong></h4><p>The trickiest aspect of IFS for many people is locating the first part to work with. For some this comes quite naturally: the concept of parts makes immediate sense to them, and they may have been noticing parts all their life. I’m not one of these people: I had no idea about parts before I encountered a somewhat IFS-like technique called Internal Double Crux and met a baby part that didn’t fit in the IDC framework.</p><p>The easiest part to locate may be one of your inner critics, which is perhaps voicing derogatory views of you. Or you may sense your addiction as a “monster”, but this is likely something too heavy to start practicing IFS with. You can try bringing to mind a situation where your parts tend got triggered and see if that leads you to a part.</p><p>There are many ways to locate a part, but in my opinion, through your body may be the easiest and most beneficial way. If you sense any emotions in your body, you’re already sensing parts. Even if you don’t normally “feel emotions in your body”, you likely experience some physical sensations connected with feelings, such as nervous tension or trembling (perhaps in anticipation of an IFS session), a knot in your stomach, or stress or anxiety tightening your chest or throat.</p><p>You can see if focusing on that area of your body gives you any words, images or felt senses. Finding the part behind such a coarse sensation can help you later locate other parts that may not cause any obvious physical sensations. <em>Once you discover just one part in your body, it often opens the door to locating many, many more, which can open your whole experience into a more embodied direction.</em></p><p>Some common types of parts include:</p><ul><li>judges others</li><li>avoidant</li><li>makes you aloof and disconnected from your emotions (e.g. can’t cry)</li><li>seeks intimacy/connection/commitment, polarized with parts terrified of those things</li><li>terrified of rejection and abandonment</li><li>terrified of conflict</li><li>people don’t love me if I’m X/unless I’m X</li><li>shame (especially related to sexuality)</li><li>seeks sensations of aliveness and vibrancy</li><li>hates the grown-up world or finds it drab</li><li>feels burdened with gender roles</li><li>angry at people who’ve harmed you</li><li>reacts to money, food/eating or sex</li><li>can’t tolerate boredom</li><li>can’t tolerate responsibility</li><li>gets angry if you’re told what to do</li><li>people-pleaser, polarized with passive-aggression</li><li>terrified of being alone</li><li>feels you aren’t human (common in severe trauma)</li><li>controlling (of other parts and/or people)</li><li>hopeless/catastrophizing</li><li>overreads into social interactions (e.g. everything means people don’t like you)</li><li>impostor syndrome</li><li>fixated on how bad your life is or how unfair that is</li><li>crushed by others’ pain and believes it to be empathy</li><li>wants to rescue or fix others</li><li>wants you to be rescued</li><li>fixated on solving every problem</li><li>trying to earn your parents’ love</li><li>wants to “show someone”</li><li>wants you to “leave your mark”</li><li>afraid of expressing your wants, needs, boundaries or possibly anything at all</li><li>causes issues with your voice</li><li>terrified of you healing your trauma or dissociation lifting</li><li>“I’m probably doing this wrong” (IFS or other things)</li></ul><p>They are all just trying to help, and deep down they just want to feel safe and loved. Does reading this list evoke any reactions in your parts? Remember that such reactions may also be defensive (“that’s ridiculous!”).</p><h4><strong>The Process of Healing</strong></h4><p>Some IFS books suggest a series of “rituals” performed to heal a part: reparenting, retrieving, witnessing and unburdening. Which ones of these are done and how always depends on what the part wants and needs.</p><p><em>Reparenting</em> is utilized in other therapies too, but it works much better when done from Self. It may involve going back to a particular memory in the role of an ideal parent and possibly changing the situation, e.g. defending the child against parental abuse. Reparenting may also be done with an adult part carrying trauma. Most of the time, however, parts just want you to be there for them, in the now, e.g. soothed, held or tucked in.</p><p><em>Retrieving</em> refers to helping the part out of an unsafe past situation into a safe environment, e.g. your home or your body. However, sometimes parts aren’t afraid of the past, but a situation in your current life, such as interacting with a parent or someone being angry at you, or another part. In that case, the part’s safe place might be something like a fortress.</p><p><em>Witnessing</em> is the part showing you memories of why it adopted its current role, <em>to make you understand how awful the whole thing was for it.</em> It is important to note that often this is unnecessary: we now know that <em>normally in trauma therapy, you don’t have to focus on the original trauma</em>. However, the events to be witnessed need not be horrifying trauma, it could be e.g. occasions of your parents calling you lazy: so-called <em>small t-trauma or microtrauma</em>.</p><p><em>Unburdening</em> is based on the idea, to my knowledge unique to IFS, that many parts carry a <em>burden</em>, even though the part may believe it <em>is</em> the burden — similarly to how an entire human, blended with a part, may believe they are nothing but a failure. A burden is an emotion like shame or a negative belief like “I’m unlovable”. The part can be asked if it carries a burden and if and how it’d like to dispose of it. The typical way isdissolving it into the elements, like burning with fire or burying in the ground. I once guided someone’s part in disposing its burden into a washing machine.</p><p>Parts with severe trauma may be terrified of witnessing or unburdening. In that case, it’s possible to reassure them that you can start with just a portion of the burden. One can initially witness 20% or unburden 10% of a particular trauma. If the part agrees to this, the remaining trauma can be stored in an imaginary box or another container between your sessions to stop it from bothering you. (This may also sound like unbelievable play-pretend, but the box technique is also used in other therapies.)</p><p>In practice, these steps are not always needed. My own parts usually aren’t in a “place” and can’t be retrieved, they rarely show me any memories and their burdens almost always heal without explicitly focusing on them.</p><p>A part healing may make you feel more spacious, cause different physical sensations and often it moves you to tears. Afterward it may want to find a new role in the system, e.g. a critic becoming a mentor. Or it just wants to go on a holiday and rest. (In IFS theory, healing a part doesn’t make it disappear, but occasionally they do seem to vanish.) Healing a part can often be completed in one session, sometimes it takes many. Sometimes the burden heals but comes back later and additional work is needed. If you notice no change in the issue you worked on, there might also be more parts involved.</p><h4><strong>Different Approaches to IFS</strong></h4><p>There are many ways to do IFS. The most popular IFS guidebook, Jay Earley’s <em>Self-Therapy</em>, is valuable but also somewhat formulaic and prescriptive. I feel IFS should be more like improv. Janina Fisher’s IFS book <em>Healing the Fragmented Selves of Trauma Survivors</em> focuses on stabilizing the system when there is severe trauma and structural dissociation, e.g. by naming all emotions as coming from a part rather than “me”. Susan McConnell’s <em>Somatic Internal Family Systems Therapy</em> utilizes e.g. touch, movement and breathwork. Parts you sense in your body often respond well to touching that area.</p><p>IFS can also be combined with other types of psychotherapy. I’ve had great success with integrating IFS with somatic experiencing (SE), a trauma therapy that offers more techniques of working with parts through your body and is particularly helpful for severe trauma, as well as angry parts.<strong> </strong><a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/how-i-healed-my-severe-trauma-e24b6913cd77">I healed all my trauma</a> with IFS, SE and loving-kindness meditation.</p><p>Combining IFS with hypnosis or EMDR is also relatively common. Therapists working with children may use play therapy or sandtray therapy from an IFS perspective. <em>All psychotherapy works with parts, explicitly or not.</em> When you benefit from therapy, it’s because it healed one or more parts. It just tends to be much more effective to access parts consciously and directly.</p><p>IFS and meditation can be combined in many different ways. I’ve also mixed IFS with (or influences from) e.g. coherence therapy, solution-focused brief therapy, Alexander technique and drumming. Some people do IFS under the influence of psychedelics or MDMA. You can journal from a part or to a part or let parts express themselves through art, music or poetry. The IFS framework can also be a very helpful tool for writing fiction.</p><p>IFS is a deeply relational therapy that takes into account the person’s living conditions and systemic factors. Most parts are stuck in the past, but a part may also be reacting to a current physical illness, unhealthy relationship, poverty, <a href="https://maija-haavisto.medium.com/medical-trauma-6fa90c6ecab0">medical abuse</a>, systemic racism or other ongoing oppression. In IFS, no reaction is ever considered “pathological” or “maladaptive”, unlike in CBT. And sometimes e.g. voicing your needs really <em>isn’t</em> safe.</p><p>IFS was developed based on family therapy, and it is also used in family therapy and couples therapy. Concepts from IFS can be used in communication outside of therapy settings too, e.g. one member of a family talks for a part of theirs from Self, while other family members listen trying to stay in Self. When people are familiar with the IFS frame, it can be used in everyday conversations too: “It really hurts some of my parts when your critical part judges me”, which tends to be better received than I-you-talk. <a href="https://ifs-institute.com/store/163">This book</a> contains an excellent chapter on communicating with IFS.</p><p>There are no panaceas and obviously IFS is not going to be a good fit for everyone and every problem, but it can relieve a surprisingly wide range of different conditions and issues — as well as giving you perspective into why people act the way they do and how the whole society works. The world is full of hurting child parts who long to be heard, and you can start with yours.</p><p><em>If you’re interested in learning more about IFS and trauma, I have a free new book titled </em><a href="http://www.lovingawakening.net/">Loving Awakening: A Practical Guide to Embodied Spirituality and Healing with Metta, IFS, the Imaginal and Community</a><em>. I also guide IFS combined with more somatic and imaginal approaches.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=422d6865700b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>