<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Malcolm Ryder on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Malcolm Ryder on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@malcolm-ryder?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 04:12:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@malcolm-ryder/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SHOOT THE MESSENGER]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/shoot-the-messenger-475f18818cee?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/475f18818cee</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photojournalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Jan 2026 01:58:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-11T01:58:49.058Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>In the public controversy about the new film <em>The Stringer,</em> photographer Nick Út is featured as a carrier of truth, and the film itself is positioned as a carrier of truth, but under audience scrutiny, both fare badly. Ten key factors matter in weighing the response, not just the film</strong></p><p><strong>I. The Business</strong></p><p><em>In any given week, on any given day, Netflix can drop $100 million fresh on lawyers. And that’s not even the fun part. The fun part is that if they have to do it to fend off a suit as a defendant of a slander or libel charge, they’ll win long before the trial is over, and the extra unnecessary days will earn them money.</em></p><p>If you’re an opposing lawyer, that scenario has to be considered. But what’s this about, anyway? Let’s peel the layers.</p><p><strong>Netflix, which we remember is in the movies business</strong>, <strong>picked up and released a very cinematic documentary about an investigation. </strong>First seen at Sundance, the film <em>tracks </em>the investigation. The investigation was about a rumor that seriously questioned journalistic integrity. The outcome of the investigation was that three of the four primary parties investigated agreed that the questioning was reasonable enough to cast doubt. The documentary’s coverage of the investigation let that come through unfiltered.</p><p>The documentary follows the chief investigator, a private one who, while not quite rivaling Elliot Gould in <em>The Long Goodbye,</em> has a memorably even-tempered presence throughout: subdued, but insistent.</p><p>Unwrapping one thing after another less by prediction than by hunch, he ends up with some unanswered questions, some people get hurt, and he walks away, but things are different in a way that can’t be undone. Heroes are deprecated but also something of America’s better angels glows; unheard voices have come out alongside celebrities; and when the credits roll there is a bit of a cliff-hanger.</p><p><strong>This is a no-brainer story for Netflix.</strong></p><p>It’s called <em>The Stringer.</em> In it, one of the most important photographs ever published, <em>The Terror of War,</em> gets its provenance studied. We are freshly reminded of its power to affect good, but something is not quite right under the bright lights.</p><p>Getting distributed by Netflix is an incredible longshot for most filmmakers. This film, and the reaction to it, are a cultural flash phenomenon. But months are going by, and the flashing hasn’t stopped.</p><p>From a bird’s eye view, here is what’s been happening. Looking for truth, an investigation of the photo’s provenance pursued something questionable; then the investigation itself was deemed questionable; then the documentary pursued the investigation; and then the documentary was deemed questionable. There is now more drama <em>around </em>the documentary than there is <em>within</em> it. (This is, by the way, perfect for a film distributor.)</p><p><strong>II. The Players</strong></p><p>The film’s detractors savage it. But the film’s appeal rises easily from something sure-fire: violating taboos.</p><p><em>Within</em> the film, one taboo is the subject: a revered news photo editor is accused of breaking journalistic ethics, falsely accrediting an epically historic picture known popularly as “Napalm Girl”.</p><p><em>Around</em> the film, a different taboo is featured: the discrediting of Nick Út, a popular cultural hero, by presenting a story that denies his reputation as the historic photo’s source.</p><p><strong>Reactions to the film have largely merged with reactions to the investigation <em>documented by</em> the film.</strong> Or it is probably safe to say that usually the two have not even been distinguished by the public in the first place.</p><p>In the bird’s-eye perspective, the documentary is the messenger and the investigation that it covers is the message. This might seem too nuanced a point, but public criticism has been robust that the film itself is a bad or failed film, not meeting what many believe is the purpose of a documentary.</p><p>Yet, if we look at how the film covered the investigation, it is pretty difficult to conclude that the film does not do the job well. There are no points at which the film fabricated something about the investigation that is not true about the investigation or how it proceeded.</p><p>Regardless, per most of the film’s most outspoken viewers, the investigation itself held harsh but highly debatable news, and the film’s interest in publicizing the investigation is seen as having a motive that warrants condemning the film.</p><p>As for Netflix, its decision to show the film is roundly disparaged as being exploitatively self-interested at the expense of an undeserving victim, hero photographer Nick Út. That same judgement is passed on the real-life investigator, photojournalist and political activist Gary Knight.</p><p><strong>III. The Mediums</strong></p><p><strong><em>The Stringer </em>is a case of one medium being used to convey ideas about another one. </strong>There is the matter of how photography serves a purpose, and then the matter of how filmmaking presents that use of photography. The film focuses on the investigation as the way to see the activity about the photo. Because of that, the key “medium” at hand, the intermediary conveying the story, is the investigation. The film forms how we see the investigation; but the investigation forms how we see everything else.</p><p><strong>Much of what is going on about this film raises fundamental questions about how media is used to serve public interests. And there is a historical dimension to that which is rooted firmly in technology.</strong> In 1972, when “Napalm Girl” was shot, the technology to publish it was a cumbersome affair requiring ground transportation, chemistry, printing and radio transmission. Today getting such an image from the moment of its capture in the camera to an audience of millions is two clicks to Instagram on the internet. Furthermore, consider how easily we anticipate live video as another option.</p><p>Not only is technology inherently a mitigating factor of presenting the image; we actually base our sense of meaning on it. In the passionate controversy over the authorship of a still photo’s origin, all of our expectations or needs about the still photography format are front and center of why the authorship story is important.</p><p>Still, with all presumptions about still photography in place, the basic question underlying the investigation’s dispute about the picture’s authorship is “who took the picture”.</p><p>The heart of the investigation is the idea that a different person, not the usually credited one, is an equally credible candidate as the author of the photograph. And that has to do with being equally<em> capable for the occasion</em>. <strong>As far as the public is concerned, the author of the photo is a “medium”, too, invoking one world’s presence into another world.</strong></p><p><strong>IV. The Agents</strong></p><p><strong>Mastery in photojournalism is as much defined by the actual achievements of practitioners as by any code of practice.</strong> Usually, there is a demonstrable divide between photographers who have an opportunity to make a special picture and those who actually get it done. Those who do it frequently are justly celebrated, as are all special performers in human endeavor. In photojournalism, the performance magic starts with the ability to be in the right place at the right time; shifts instantly to being aware of what makes the moment important to someone; then leveraging the photo instruments to create the corresponding image.</p><p>The answer to the question, “what kind of person is capable of making a picture like this?” is the heart of public disagreement with the investigation covered by the film.</p><p><strong>But in the investigation, there are two key persons performing in the practice. </strong>One is the photographer on site in the field of action. The other is the photo editor in the photolab or office who surveys all gathered images and decides which of them to present and how. In their relationship, <em>the ethics are that the photographer “tells the truth” with the photograph, and that the editor tells the truth about the photograph.</em></p><p>Critics of the investigation in <em>The Stringer </em>say that it both unnecessarily and incompetently questions whether the ethics in that relationship have been upheld. In that view, both the photographer and the editor of record, based on their own well-demonstrated special qualities, had already set their story and their reputations beyond suspicion by the time of the alleged incident. The essential challenge to the investigation, then, is the question, “Why bother?”</p><p><strong>V. The Motives</strong></p><p><strong>A repeated counter-claim for the photo’s authorship offers the reason to investigate the usually accepted version of the authorship narrative.</strong> But opponents of the investigation and of the film push deeper; they want to know what motivated taking the counter-claim seriously in the first place.</p><p>We can assume that if the counter-claim merely provoked curiosity enough to start an investigation, any subsequent lack of substantive evidence would likely have ended the effort.</p><p>Even with substantive evidence, the investigation’s drive to being completed aims only so far as to create persistent reasonable doubt about the usual narrative (“Photo by Nick Ut”). To do that, it must make its case logically, more strongly than just a preponderance of circumstantial evidence. How strong? <em>For the case to resolve in the counter-claim’s favor,</em> <em>the counterclaim must make as much sense as the prior claim lacks.</em></p><p>Accordingly, the investigation does not just present an opposing narrative to the prior established one; it seeks to undermine the idea that the accepted narrative’s details “add up”.</p><p>The most prominent of those details include what photographer was in position to take the shot; and what happened between the editorial discovery of the shot and the publication of it.</p><p><strong>VI. Prosecuting the Case</strong></p><p>Amidst that challenge, the <em>court of public opinion</em> about the investigation and its impact has been on a pendulum swing.</p><p>On one end, it’s about whether the investigator’s evidence is credible; on the other, whether the investigation’s logic is strong enough. Over any period of time, any detractor may cover the full spectrum.</p><p>In one prominent example of the reactions, seen in <strong>facebook, </strong>a top public social media forum, commenters on <em>the investigation</em> are overwhelmingly negative about both ends; and as a group they are outnumbering the combined positive or undecided commentators by a ratio of more than 8 to 1. In the negative commentary, it is common to doubt what the investigation presents as evidence because of its being too difficult to verify by witnesses. That leaves the investigator appearing to try overly hard to make his logic work. In turn that raises for them the question of why he is trying so hard.</p><p>In protests against <em>the film</em>, suspicions about the investigator’s motive frequently overwhelm or even prevent close study of the investigation’s evidence. In such examples, the <strong>Washington Post</strong> ran an extensive article “rebutting” the film’s claim to legitimacy, and <strong>Medium.com </strong>posted a passionate “prosecution” of its credibility.</p><p><em>Example 1:</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/732/1*RuTKodAdugjHqRu5J-is0w.png" /><figcaption>Witnesses testify against the investigation’s findings presented in the film. The film was cited as if it is the investigation rather than the documentary about the investigation.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Example 2:</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/773/1*078rjEKGQIynRz1K3NgCRw.png" /><figcaption>Writers attempt to methodically discredit the value of the investigation’s claims as evidence. The film itself was treated as the investigation’s “lawyer”…</figcaption></figure><p>But not everyone shares that perspective. In fact, <strong>“standard of proof” works the same way for the investigator as it does for those objecting to him.</strong></p><p>Two particular assessments, both presumably unbiased, hold more significance than others.</p><p>· The <strong>World Press Photo </strong>organization rescinded its authorship credit to Nick Út; given new evidence, the organization decided that Its standard of proof for credit turns out not to have been met.</p><p>· And when <strong>the Associated Press</strong> finished its own investigation, its conclusion was that no other party had a strong enough claim now on the authorship to warrant removing the credit from Nick Út. In effect, it said that the standard held by AP in the past would be accepted regardless of what its standard is today, but that today AP neither proved nor denied that Nick Ut was the photographer.</p><p><strong><em>Both organizations, in other words, landed on reasonable doubt</em>. </strong>As the leading representatives of their field — photojournalism or Press photography — their decision actually leans in favor of the investigation. Yet nonetheless it clearly struggles to find acceptance by most members of the field.</p><p><strong>VII. Consequences</strong></p><p>Despite the finished film and investigation, 50 years of celebrity for Út did not just evaporate; he is still famous, still supported, and none of his good deeds over the decades have been undone. Meanwhile, the historical significance of the photo was never an issue and still isn’t.</p><p><strong>Even including the AP and World Press conclusions, this has left <em>controversy</em> as the <em>most important immediate consequence</em> of the investigation.</strong></p><p>Then, surrounding the investigation, there is the film. For the film, the consequence is different. <strong>The issue with the film </strong>for its detractors is that even if the investigation won its case, the harm of that outweighs the good and was unnecessary. They ask why doing the investigation at all was so important. They hold the film responsible for going beyond telling the story about the investigation: <strong>it is challenged to justify <em>why it tells</em>. Pending that, <em>mistrust</em> is the immediate consequence.</strong></p><p><strong>VIII. Fact versus Fiction</strong></p><p>The film exists in a broad social context: the role of the <em>documentary</em> genre. The expectations of a documentary are usually that it intends to present something that has inherent meaning, subject matter that is meaningful by default. What the film can do, as documentary, is to supply powerful additional context to make that meaning explicit.</p><p>And just as most audiences of “news” photography require it to be truth-telling, the photographic and narrative claims of “documentary” are also expected to be truth-telling.</p><p>As <em>non-fiction narrative</em>, still photography and film are each put to the same two tests. One test is veracity; the other test is credulity.</p><p>In this case, those tests extend more broadly than to the photo; there is the <em>news agency process</em> that took Nick Út to prominence is in view. And they are broader than the film; there is the <em>commercial</em> <em>film distribution process</em> that takes <em>The Stringer</em> to prominence.</p><p>Each process is subject to being evaluated, both for its veracity and credulity.</p><p>Some ask, “is the photo credit allowed to be uncertain or even unexamined because it helped maximize the influence of the picture?” And others ask, “is the film’s dramatization of the investigation acceptable because it increased attention to the issues the investigation raised?” Anyone can ask, “did they both just do what is necessary, or did they both go too far?</p><p><strong>IX. Disinformation</strong></p><p>One thing largely obscured in the shockwaves of the controversy is that holding the investigation itself to <strong>ethical </strong>standards <em>does not</em> automatically require it to meet <strong>journalism’s </strong>standards.</p><p>In fact, <strong>the more obvious standards that apply to the investigation are those of an actual court of law rather than either journalism or a court of public opinion.</strong> In a legal court, evidence can be thrown out or accepted, juries can stalemate without conclusions and even be replaced, and a judge can dismiss testimonies, witnesses, lines of inquiry, or even entire cases. Arguably, the actual investigation covered by the film subjects itself to all of those tests; the question is whether the jury is impartial.</p><p><strong>Another thing that gets suppressed by the controversy is the investigation’s actual intended story about the harm of <em>dis-</em>information.</strong> If the investigation juxtaposes the story of Nick Út’s celebrity against the story of a humble stringer, <strong>Nguyễn Thành Nghệ,</strong> denied his rights, its drama is in establishing that the former <em>caused</em> the latter.</p><p>We know, without needing to be reminded, that such exploitation would be morally (personally) and ethically (societally) unacceptable. What the film viewers presumably did not know beforehand is that it might have happened behind the scenes. That makes the posture of the film, even if just an allegation, an “expose”. Taking the obvious cue from the film’s title, <em>The Stringer,</em> we can assume that the documentary’s interest is in making this perspective the context that gives the investigation its meaning.</p><p>In the public protest to the film, however, the tendency is to cast <em>The Stringer </em>as a matter of Nick Út’s honesty versus Gary Knight’s motives. Because of that, <strong>the plight of the real stringer, Nguyễn Thành Nghệ, sits dimly in the background of the controversy.</strong> As a thought experiment here in the waning days of 2025, we can speculate on whether <em>The Stringer, post-controversy,</em> will be understood and categorized in the future libraries of film and publishing as a “social justice” story.</p><p><strong>X. Judgement</strong></p><p><strong>Photojournalism done right has been indispensable for decades as the awareness of the world became more and more broad and complex.</strong></p><p>But we now live in a time when technology has increased disinformation’s risks by orders of magnitude — through pervasive social media and AI; the allure of echo chambers and fakes; bias versus knowledge.</p><p>With journalism’s intended role now under siege as a result, anything that further undermines public confidence in it can only expect to attract fierce opposition to it from the field of practitioners.</p><p>But the public controversy’s focus on Nick Út’s reputation probably itself perpetuates a lowering of standards.</p><p><strong>The need to attend to the fuller implications of dis-information past and especially present is exactly the true significance of the investigation and of the film about it.</strong></p><p>Without a return to such attention, the actual justification of <em>photojournalism’s</em> importance — trust — is obscured to a degree that the discipline becomes untenable. The film itself is not an example of disinformation unless the public insists on reacting to it that way, and then we have to ask ourselves why they would insist.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=475f18818cee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Witness]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/i-witness-367ee4637687?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/367ee4637687</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Jan 2026 14:02:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-06T22:39:04.321Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Belief in Seeing</h3><p>Analysts now say that eyewitness testimony in court cases is actually unreliable. Yet when trial is underway, most people, most of the time, will elevate the testimony of someone who says “I was there, and I saw something”…</p><p>If that testimony works against your interest, the key defensive tactic is to erode the <em>credibility</em> of the testifying party. <em>“Regardless of what you think you saw, why should we believe you?”</em></p><p>When you think it through, the power of this question involves two things.</p><p>One, if you, as well as the witness, were at the scene yourself, you would compare your own confidence in what you saw against your confidence in what they may have seen. Did the “data” collected by their look at things match what you likely would have noticed?</p><p>And two, you would compare your idea of what importance should be attached to what they say they saw, gauging why that attachment might be too weak to withstand debate. Is it logical? Is it relevant?</p><p>Yet another thing, pointed out in the famous “Invisible Gorilla” experiment, is that what we notice when we are looking around is heavily preconditioned by what for some reason we are expecting beforehand. The key finding in this experiment is that we <em>don’t </em>see as well as <em>do see</em>, based on why we are paying attention.</p><p><em>(This video features co-creator Daniel Simons explaining the original experiment and includes the famous footage where you can test your own awareness.)</em></p><p>… <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtKt8YF7dgQ">The Invisible Gorilla (featuring Daniel Simons)</a> …</p><p>And a final interesting phenomenon is that in seeing, the human brain does something automatically, which is to try to predict what’s coming before it comes, or inject what’s missing that “ought to” be there. Mostly this allows us to see a part of something and, based on that, imagine the rest of a “whole”. The question is, what do we think that whole thing is? Are we right, or wrong?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*3LW3k-6BGSV_3t0jZ6CvjQ.png" /></figure><p>Furthermore, that applies to things that are moving as well as to things that are not.</p><p>So far, the above may not have brought up anything of news value to you. But it gives a kind of framework within which to understand how some images affect us as viewers, and highlights that when we are viewing we are <em>interpreting.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K3u1fbsOA_NW544ws5qvgQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Malcolm Ryder</figcaption></figure><p>In this chart above, we see that in step 4 there is a big opportunity to contest or confirm the credibility of a “witness’s” claimed information. We might just go make ourselves witnesses, too, assuming that the important data still exists at the scene or can be <em>proved </em>to have been there. Unfortunately, this sometimes can happen only as a <em>re-enactment</em> of conditions that will argue <em>“it must have been this way” </em>(or <em>“it couldn’t have been that way”</em>). For simplicity’s sake, let’s call that test “<em>Plausibility</em>” because it is not the same as “Certainty”.</p><p>And, let’s call that notion of reenactment <em>Re-Presentation</em>. The weakest case in our favor, then, is one where a representation is plausible — acceptable in the absence of hard core verification and certainty by contact with the original phenomenon.</p><p>All of that usually gets bundled into the category of information called “evidence”.</p><p><strong>Getting from step 4’s evidence to step 5’s non-fiction is not as easy as it looks. </strong>Using evidence to build a story is one way that things could go. But the other way is to use a story as the selection criteria for evidence. When that second pathway is chosen, the question immediately arises as to how we decide the story is the right one to use. The story organizes information into patterns that have meaning. This is essentially what “modeling” is, and in studies of perception, the notion of a <em>mental model</em> is predominant. It’s how that gorilla winds up “not showing”, or why tiny amounts of some given color in a scene are suddenly vivid only after we are told to find them.</p><p>Analysts call this mental modeling <em>cognitive bias.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/252/0*A89O2z9mSCI8p3XL" /><figcaption>Faces? Or a goblet?</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ur03iFG61da8PKve.jpg" /><figcaption>Two dancers? Or a bearded man’s face?</figcaption></figure><p>When the preconceived “story” tells us how to interpret the evidence, there is no absolute version of <em>objectivity</em> available to say what is correct or incorrect.</p><p>Instead, there is <em>relevance </em>and <em>correspondence</em> that is tested by our own strength as being interpreters. And the more we want a certain interpretation to be accepted, the more we have to evaluate the importance of two things: why we want that to happen, and where the story is coming from. Those are bundled together in the singular descriptive term <em>circumstantial</em>.</p><p>How do we see that in terms of whether something is fictional or non-fictional? The real difference is not in the result of the interpretation. Instead, it is in the <em>intent</em> of interpreting. Non-fiction holds itself to a standard of high-fidelity to verifiable evidence as the qualifier for what gets modeled into a description or explanation. The model then is acceptable whether the evidence is circumstantial or not.</p><p>That represents the <em>quality</em> of the model, but it does not define the <em>value </em>of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/0*dktr-FLTc7ifg-Qp" /><figcaption>A 1922 illustration from the Swedish and Norwegian magazine Allers Familj-Journal. Photograph: Alamy</figcaption></figure><p>Back when the earth was flat and the sun revolved around the earth, circumstantial evidence was so convincing that most people didn’t question the story that used it. The actual gap between description and explanation wasn’t strongly felt, because the subject matter itself (the cosmos) was not something easily accessible in most people’s “real life” experience, but the representation gave a reliable explanation of something they cared about.</p><p><strong>History, Science, Journalism, News</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r9S3WnR7PolfMvdlHAM7Ew.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Observation, Representation, Images, Photography</strong></p><p>With 150 years of photography under our belts, we have fully adopted expectations of what it offers as virtual witnessing of the world of visible environments and events. We typically spend no time wondering whether it can do it well.</p><p>But the effort to have it done is just one of three dimensions of its effectiveness a value. The other two dimensions are our ability to interpret photographs, and the motivation for making them (instead of doing something else). So, in the above flowchart, we see at the left the mindsets that govern our attention, and at the right the reasons why there is value.</p><p>Below, there is a more specific accounting of what is happening as a credible witness generates a plausible representation.</p><p>Usually we’re okay with proceeding <em>as if plausible is as good as “truthful”. </em>In detail, it points out how we might get from information (at left) to “truth” (at right)… Its description of photography is included to address photography’s legacy value of being inherently the most truthful of all visual mediums. But the idea that this outcome is inherent in photography is a fallacy; only the <em>capability </em>is inherent. In photography, there are (as seen here) fifteen (15) different opportunities to depart from the plausibility that we want to call truth. It is, instead, only the ethic of the imagemaker that prevents those departures from occurring when they might. Otherwise, if they do occur, someone has to correct them.</p><p>That faith in the image-maker is why we caution ourselves to “consider the source” when we evaluate received information. The more we think we know about the source, the more confident we are in our ability to evaluate whether the image’s plausibility is useful as “truth”. <em>Truth is our agreement to trust in the plausibility.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XKBL3kxtJooiWOe2QBTGWg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>False Witness, Fake News, Artificial Intelligence</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/985/1*Q1gI9vLKLezJPBkr1pWiyA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Is this guy a Camper, a Believer on a Pilgrimage, or a Bather in a Spa? Here are three different images, but one image on its own can “represent” multiple stories, so this display is not of one truthful image and two not-truthful ones. We need context to be interpreting it, and trust that the source intends for that context to help us. But that also means the interpretation of the information can be skewed in the direction that the image-<em>presenter wants to skew it; there is nothing inherent in photography that prevents them from doing that.</em></figcaption></figure><p>As we think about documentation, journalism, news, and history, we can note their distinguishing kinds of rigor in practice. Our precaution of <em>considering the source</em> is important in each of the four practices. The contemporary environment of our exposure to images is now dominated by our powerful personal ability to transport a given image from one context to another, independently of what other people intend. And there is a community-level culture of “sharing” that is more about stimulating desired interpersonal relationships than about “truthful” knowledge. This social culture, powered by digital media technology, effectively shrinks the domain of influence for objective verification, leaving it more as a special purpose effort in the broader societal-level culture, and far less as a default basis for social stability and progress at that level.</p><p>A viewer’s trust in the practices of the image-maker is part of perceived value all across documentation, journalism, news, and history. Each of those practices loses meaningfulness when the image-maker does not present verifiable evidence of a “chain of custody” of evidence connecting what is <em>re-presented</em> to what has actually occurred.</p><p>Pretending to be a witness, reporting something that did not happen, or fabricating evidence are three powerful corruptions of an acceptable chain of custody. The safeguards and remedies against these problems must include both behavioral and pragmatic approaches.</p><p>There may not be any “silver bullet” solution to the runaway proliferation of what we today call false witness, fake news, and AI imaging. But in an evolutionary strategy, an obvious approach it to upgrade the existing mechanism that already systematically addresses the problems: <strong>Publishing</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/622/1*DRDkwA8emYcPARLmxABIhA.png" /><figcaption>Society and technology can both progress to support explicit ways of implementing these success factors for trustworthy visual presentations. (Image © Malcolm Ryder)</figcaption></figure><p>There are many high-impact practices in society and the environment that are too useful to diminish but too risky to leave unmanaged. The way they are dealt with — from hunting to driving to construction to law to medicine — is by granting an earned <strong><em>license. Licensed practitioners carry the standards for value and risk management into the public domain.</em></strong><em> </em>Conversely, accepting content, service, or assurances from unlicensed practitioners is a kind of personal risk-taking that makes a person directly responsible for the consequences.</p><p>It will be crucial for publishing to not allow a popular belief that reputations and degrees are sufficient instead of licensing. But it is also crucial to recognize that licensing itself can cover differing levels of competency to coexist within the same set of safeguards.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=367ee4637687" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Photography as a “Medium”]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/photography-as-a-medium-1163c19a81a9?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1163c19a81a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[photography-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jan 2026 16:25:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-04T19:13:12.365Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The thing about the word “medium” is that it <em>always </em>refers to something <em>in between</em> one thing and another.</p><p>So, what gives the word any special flavor or import, when used, is actually derived from the things that are on either side of it, not the thing that is within it.</p><p>In talking to the spirits of the dead, you are on one side and the spirits are on the other. Your medium could be a psychotropic drug or someone behind a bead curtain who burns herbs and has a crystal ball.</p><p>In making pictures, your initial real-life visual experience of something can be reiterated — with any amount of interpretation, translation, and encoding — through <em>forming</em> selected materials into a <em>corresponding </em>arrangement that can be presented for viewing, as <em>another </em>experience.</p><p>Things get interesting when we acknowledge that in our times, pictures themselves are routinely part of immediate real-life visual experiences preceding future moments. Or, having a memory can easily be the experience in real life that is at the front end of activity that then generates a presentation on the other end.</p><p>Calling that activity a “medium” is not metaphorical at all; it just points out that the presentation does not spontaneously appear. But what is included in the activity is effort that intends to produce a detectable <em>meaning. </em>This is not difficult to understand at all:<em> </em>anyone who accepts that a <em>translator</em> can convert English to French in conversation has a way of getting the meaning intended by the speaker to recur in the mind of the listener. The translator is a medium.</p><p><strong>Functional Form</strong></p><p>A medium has a lot of influence on how something can be <em>conveyed</em> from one place to another. Let’s take something like an instrumental love ballad and compare it to a literary love sonnet: Mostly dissimilar materials, mostly similar meaning, entirely different technical activity, yet enormously similar <em>formative </em>skills. Music and literature — although two very different mediums — can start at the same place (intention) and end at the same place (influence), through differing causes and effects.</p><p>Photography was born as a way of extending human mastery in conveying the <em>experiential impacts </em>of the visible environment in two ways: depicting the environment’s forms and its content. What became <em>extended</em> was the efficiency in re-presenting verifiable observable conditions as hi fidelity visual facts. And <strong>regardless of any future developments in technologies, photography will always refer back to drawing as its “DNA”.</strong></p><p>What was NOT extended was the range of interests that predetermined what kind of facts and what conditions were practically preferred as a matter of cultural, psychological, or occupational predisposition. That range was already huge and photography did not make it larger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YzRbt4mcYhbD-O3ibohb5A.png" /><figcaption>Ancient drawing: one of the earliest “negatives” and its positive imprint as the carved cylinder rolled on and across clay.</figcaption></figure><p>Rather, <em>selectivity </em>has always been at the core of any photography that was done intentionally for future presentation or conservation. This is why even a very low resolution photograph <em>can</em> be enormously meaningful. What matters is not how many facts; rather, <em>which</em> facts.</p><p><strong>And again, pictures themselves become part of the realities of visual experience, just as knowledge becomes part of the realities of cognition.</strong></p><p>As part of that, we also become more familiar with how materials can be arranged into <em>expressive form. T</em>he materials themselves can become the primary subject of attention because as humans we are innately invested in <em>effective</em> communication and in <em>designing experience</em>. As an analogy, vocabularies and languages change and grow, without becoming inscrutable or unusable, although they can go unlearned or be abandoned. <strong>Visual phenomena become the material “language” of pictures.</strong></p><p><strong>The Who Cares Test</strong></p><p>An important dimension of that communications and design is sociological: the exercise of power through influence, in order to conform experiences to the objectives and goals of the power holder. All of us have lived with this in, for example, religion, education, youth slang, and… art. Here, it is crucial to not confuse the power agenda with the value nor with the definition of the medium.</p><p>Preservation of cultural “standards” and biases is always traceable to a power holder, whether the holder is a collective or individual source. Histories, it is also said, “are written by the winners.” There is a crucial difference between the histories and predispositions of what gets deemed “art” versus the actual history of a medium. As qualitative judgement of values gets centralized in societal institutions, the inherent possibilities of a medium are consistently subordinated to expectations of propriety (agreement with certain values). Such proprieties saturate conventional histories and attitudes about art.</p><p>But regardless of them, serious artists exist in large numbers across the full span of those who, said casually, are unrecognized versus recognized, newcomers versus long-timers, or experimenters versus craft-masters.</p><p>There is not some singular intersection of those dimensions of <em>status </em>that defines a medium nor its “correct” goals or evolution. Some sub-culture or another can go about enforcing its own perspective on what is important, to satisfy the holders and subscribers of its power. But what intrinsically distinguishes <em>serious </em>artists from other artists is that they have a work ethic and a conscious awareness of methodological function and personal procedure to get the medium to be their instrument for communication.</p><p><strong>Getting the Picture</strong></p><p>In its earliest occurrence, a photograph was a product of a method of optically manipulating light to <strong><em>draw </em></strong><em>(as in the Greek “graphe”)</em><strong><em> </em></strong>an image.</p><p>In the strictest sense, that is photography’s activity understood as a medium.</p><p>The fact is that in practice a so-called photograph <em>can </em>also be <em>originated </em>at different “places” — that is, by a variety of differing <em>methods </em>that produce the same desired <em>type </em>of effects.</p><p>But over time, <strong>known and discovered effects</strong> of the practice accumulate together; as produced by this activity, they are collectively <em>photographic </em>images; then less rigorously, by <em>synecdoche, </em>the collection is seen as “the medium”…</p><p>Those two senses of “medium” — a method and a type — are not the only ones however.</p><p>Beyond them, a formed “photographic” <strong>image </strong>can be “transported” from its current location to another location.</p><p><strong>Outside the Image Production</strong></p><p>In the evolution of <strong>the</strong> <strong>mediums </strong>of <em>photo</em>-<em>graphic</em> presentations, there is one vector that runs through video, digital effects, and computational generative imaging; while there is another vector that runs through printmaking, radiography, and direct electro-neural stimulation of the brain.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/943/1*dQj-eAbFFXkw8WCwBNI0gQ.png" /><figcaption>A simplified map. We can speculate on why anyone would care about whether GenAI images and mental hallucinations are “photographs” or not, but we are unlikely to sense any end to the way that photographs <em>expanded </em>our ways to interpret images for meaning. In general, when we mean “photographic”, we casually call the image a “photograph” unless we’re told that it isn’t.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Inside the Image Production</strong></p><p>We also know that <strong>within </strong>the “photography” medium, there are numerous <em>modalities</em>, <em>genres, and styles</em> that get committed, to being <strong>expressive</strong>, just as in other mediums. The variety displays a kind of natural “biodiversity” that sprouts from why each of us, different from each other as we are, <strong>chooses </strong>to talk in one way or another, about one thought or another, making our expression personal, <em>idiosyncratic, while </em><strong><em>our idea is the subject.</em></strong></p><p>Meanwhile, a type of expression — the <em>how</em> — can be what leads us to <em>what </em>we try to express, just as a certain musical instrument leads us to a kind of music we think of playing. This is exactly what is meant by <em>per-form-ance,</em><strong> </strong>and we can love performance itself just as much as we are interested in any other idea we care to present. Across a wide range of expressive efforts, <strong><em>performance can be the subject.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Artful Vision</strong></p><p>But from their historical beginning, photographic images have ALWAYS been able to<strong><em> re-present</em></strong> experiences by implying, illustrating, rendering, documenting, and symbolizing. At the same time, in the what, how, and why of their production, they create experiences, too.</p><p>What is in common across that broad scope is that <strong><em>attentive seeing makes the experience of “presence” itself into subject matter </em></strong><em>— or literally, what matters as a subject</em><strong><em>. </em></strong>We can anticipate that impact, for example, as discovery, proof, attraction, or resonance — all affecting our ongoing perception, recognition, and engagement through seeing. Photography’s legacy connection to seeing with the naked eye still amplifies our awareness of seeing as something beyond witnessing the world; rather, as something that shapes what we experience as being “real” about the world.</p><p>****</p><p><em>Malcolm Ryder is the designer and former manager of the NEA Visual Arts Fellowships Grants jurying in Photography; a practicing art and business photographer and writer; and on the Board of Directors of the East Bay Photo Collective and Oakland Art Murmur in California. His degree in visual culture is from Princeton University.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1163c19a81a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Keepin’ It Real: Decoding Pictures]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/keepin-it-real-decoding-pictures-75642d0ffa22?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75642d0ffa22</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology-of-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-theory-and-practice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Dec 2025 13:52:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-30T13:52:01.652Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Introduction</strong></h3><p>On the one hand, writing conjures something from “nothing” and can easily end up producing an <em>experience</em> of “the real world”. That is, of course, because language allows us to bridge the gap between cognitive and conceptual awareness. We look at the visual shapes called letters and we translate.</p><p>On the other hand, translating can just as easily result in experiencing what we deem “un-real” or even more severely “non-sense”.</p><p>Overall, it’s using <em>code. Inventing, agreeing, applying, interpreting, breaking… </em>all of those useful functions are the difference between writing making language functional or dysfunctional. We never think of language as being legitimate, relevant, or valuable in only one way. We think of it as a “medium” that is highly indifferent to what we are trying to accomplish.</p><p>Given that, all language seems kind of pointless without a <strong>motivation </strong>to use it. It’s fair, I think, to say that the fundamental “subject matter” or “content” of language is that motivation, and the purpose of writing is to convey it. In other words, as a medium, writing’s job is always to combine both the What and the Why of the formed expression that, through translation, is transported from the originator to the interpreter.</p><h3>Defining the Real</h3><p>For most of us, it’s hard to think of anything that we take more for granted than language. But most likely that exceptional thing is vision. Horribly, if one has language capability but falls mute, or has vision but goes blind, the exact importance of these two becomes evident without further explanation. But like writing is a medium for language, picturing — aka visualization — is a medium for the <strong>translations </strong>of vision’s images into seeing.</p><p>Here, in the matter of visualizing, is where the idea of what is “real” or not real often somehow carries confusion in photography. While we can think of most people we ever encounter being language capable and vision-capable, people are no more likely to be especially good visualizers than they are to be especially good writers.</p><p>The confused part I’m pointing at is the false presumption that visualization ought to count on “realism” as its primary source of value, and that most people, because they are vision-capable, can thereby claim high competency in visualizing based mainly on the primacy of realism.</p><p>Some fields such as <strong>scientific research, journalism, and biography/history</strong> put presumptive realism in the foreground as a major element of interpretation. In their process, these fields invite one to accept their interpretations as representing (<em>re-presenting</em>) realities while leaving their content subject to being verified.</p><p>But numerous fields including <strong>psychology, criminal investigation, and art</strong> routinely refute this presumption. Cognitive bias, the unreliability of eyewitnesses, and imaginative illustrations are all facts of life, undercurrents of experience, and even communications strategies that quickly map back to <em>motivation.</em></p><p>So what does “real” actually look like?</p><h4>Summary of relationships</h4><ul><li><strong>The Physical World:</strong> The <strong>Actual</strong> is perceived through <strong>Observation</strong>.</li><li><strong>The Record:</strong> Observations are recorded as <strong>Data</strong>, which are verified into <strong>Facts</strong>.</li><li><strong>The Meaning:</strong> Facts are woven into <strong>Non-fiction</strong> narratives in an attempt to convey <strong>Truth</strong>.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K3u1fbsOA_NW544ws5qvgQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/721/1*yoWebXRht9ub1QpzvVGj1w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/730/1*GQh2z9u08YEuZobMP1_yTg.png" /></figure><p>And how does that fit into the experience that <em>results from interpretation </em>of the <strong>visible</strong>? Here is a description that I’ve arranged specifically to account for a wide range of possible outcomes, not just highest probabilities.</p><h4>Summary of Relationships</h4><ul><li><strong>The Vantage Point:</strong> You look from a <strong>POV</strong>, filtered through your <strong>Perspective</strong>.</li><li><strong>The Cognitive Filter:</strong> Your perspective is colored by <strong>Bias</strong>, which solidifies into <strong>Beliefs</strong>.</li><li><strong>The Explanatory Structure:</strong> Collective beliefs form <strong>Myths</strong> (narrative), while structured analysis forms <strong>Models</strong> (functional).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*suTfZskG6DeZXNskw_x8jw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/734/1*_AJrIXZPCXQXwg1CkZArEw.png" /></figure><h3>What We See</h3><p>Overall, the connection between <strong>representation</strong> and <strong>explanation</strong> shows up as a pretty large cloud of different possible combinations.</p><p>As a photographer, one has some <strong>motivation </strong>to be a visualizer, to make pictures, and to have those pictures <em>convey</em> something that is at least recallable “through” experiencing the picture, whether that recallable thing is an idea (concept, message), a sensation (visceral or emotional), or some association of the two.</p><p>And that is why the vast majority of pictures can be functionally grouped into philosophical, analytical, celebratory, or documentary images. But in every case, when we study a picture, we are busy decoding it according to our own capability. <em>We don’t all have the same capability.</em></p><p>In addition, <strong>there is nothing that prevents a given picture from being interpreted in multiple different ways — except for some special effort made by the presenter and the viewer to agree on which interpretation matters.</strong></p><p>We can certainly question why the agreement is made, and that means the motivation of the viewer is as important as the presenter’s.</p><p>So let’s look at the range of interpretation where photography, with its facility for re-presentation, is concerned:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/929/1*bmmUKxJYrQVm4zrSXA7qZg.png" /></figure><p><strong>How They Logically Inform Each Other</strong></p><p>The terms function as a “supply chain” of meaning:</p><ol><li>An event occurs and leaves a <strong>Record</strong>.</li><li>That record is interrogated to become <strong>Evidence</strong>.</li><li>That evidence is styled into a <strong>Representation</strong> of the past.</li><li>Those representations are sequenced into a <strong>Narrative</strong>.</li><li>That narrative is presented under the label of <strong>Documentary</strong>.</li></ol><p>And here, following, is<strong> a comparison of specific examples</strong> of pictures that each have had their own respective claim on “realistic” imaging. Here we describe the difference between <strong>a tracing, a super realist painting, and a photograph</strong> in terms of why each one would be preferred over the others. What is at stake here is the idea that the “same” image of something verifiable is being conveyed in differing ways for given reasons. It takes into consideration the <em>intent</em> of the presenter and the <em>need (interest)</em> of the viewer. <em>(For convenience I have used AI discovery to develop my sample set of three types of </em><strong><em>differing examples</em></strong><em> from various knowledge bases, which I then curated for maximum simplicity of recognition. All of this is descriptive; none of it is prescriptive.)</em></p><p>A key distinction between a tracing, a super-realist painting, and a photograph lies not in <em>what</em> they show, but in the <strong>relationship between the maker, the subject, and time</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/1*-I3B82J0oUiV-XKHyhdUBg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QeIZWUftXYk_Pvnf_cvG2g.png" /></figure><h4>1. The Tracing</h4><p><strong>Preferred for: Structural Analysis and Pedagogy</strong></p><p>A tracing is a reductive process. It is preferred when the goal is to <strong>filter out noise</strong> to understand the underlying structure or “skeleton” of an image.</p><p><strong>Why choose it:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>To Understand Mechanics:</strong> An anatomist or architect prefers a tracing because it ignores surface distractions (color, shadow, texture) to isolate the contour and proportion. It forces the creator to physically re-trace the decisions made by the original designer or nature.</li><li><strong>To Commit to Memory:</strong> The physical act of tracing moves information from the eye to the hand, creating “muscle memory” of a form. It is a tool for learning, not just capturing.</li><li><strong>To Standardize:</strong> In technical fields, a tracing (or vector) creates a clean, scalable line that is mathematically perfect, removing the “messiness” of the real world.</li></ul><h4>2. The Super-Realist Painting</h4><p><strong>Preferred for: Awe, Materiality, and Psychological Tension</strong></p><p>A super-realist (or photorealist) painting is an additive process. It is preferred when the goal is to create an <strong>object of contemplation</strong> that questions the nature of reality itself.</p><p><strong>Why choose it:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>The “Wow” Factor (Virtuosity):</strong> It is preferred when the artist wants to showcase human capability. The value lies in the <strong>labor</strong> — the realization that a human hand applied pigment to create an illusion indistinguishable from a photo.</li><li><strong>Subjective Intensity:</strong> Unlike a camera, which captures everything broadly, a super-realist painter can manipulate focus and intensity. They can make a chrome bumper or a bead of sweat “more real than real” (hyper-reality), forcing the viewer to stare at mundane details they would normally ignore.</li><li><strong>To Create an Object:</strong> A photograph is often seen as a <em>window</em> to a moment; a painting is an <em>object</em> in the room. It has texture, surface, and physical presence that a flat print lacks.</li></ul><h4>3. The Photograph</h4><p><strong>Preferred for: Immediacy, Verification, and The “Decisive Moment”</strong></p><p>In this case, a photograph is an instantaneous capture. It is preferred when the goal is <strong>indexicality</strong> — proof that a specific arrangement of light and matter existed at a specific point in time.</p><p><strong>Why choose it:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Forensic Truth (The “Record”):</strong> It is preferred for journalism, law, and science because it is (historically) viewed as a mechanical witness. It proves <em>existence</em>. A painting, no matter how realistic, is always an interpretation; a photo is a trace of light.</li><li><strong>Temporal Precision:</strong> Only a photograph can freeze a split-second — a splashing drop of water or a fleeting expression. A painting takes months to create; a tracing is static. The photo is preferred for capturing <strong>flux</strong>.</li><li><strong>Democracy of Vision:</strong> It captures the “unintentional” details. A painter chooses every brushstroke; a camera captures the trash in the corner or the stray hair that the artist might have subconsciously ignored.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aCdvVFP6tQ7OV-jKiuN9Kg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Practice</h3><p>The kind of differentiation above emphasizes that there is a <em>functional </em>aspect of visualization that is <em>intentional</em>, not accidental or merely peripheral.</p><p>But where intentional use is the concern, the further significant idea about these techniques is that their production method makes them a tool or an instrument for the intentionality.</p><p>The two cases are synonymous; but the situation is that all instruments are also tools, whereas all tools are not instruments.</p><p>A <strong>tool</strong> is designed to reduce effort and deliver a predictable result (like a hammer driving a nail).</p><p>An <strong>instrument</strong> is designed to extend human capability, measure the unknown, or facilitate expression (like a telescope, a violin, or a seismograph).</p><p>It seems pretty clear that photography gets used both as a tool and as an instrument. Photography is an excellent tool for realistic rendering of actual (verifiable) physical phenomena — rendering that provides <em>the visual material used by the photographer to intentionally encode and convey expressions of any kind</em> within a broad range of agreed interests, preferences, and needs.</p><p>Given that, it is equally clear that no single type of “realism” is the defining characteristic of photography. The acid test is that if no <em>documentary </em>photography continued to be performed, there would still be an enormous amount of photography produced for other reasons. And no one reason is the defining characteristic of the <em>medium</em>.</p><p>The reasons are where and why we find a picture to have <strong><em>value. </em></strong>There can be a proposed agreement to offer a “non-fiction” mode of representation but that is readily exposed as a <em>contextual</em> factor that applies as easily to other forms of visualization as well as <em>sometimes </em>to <em>some </em>photographs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vx0pl5D3A4N1dz-PDmSeww.png" /><figcaption><strong>Documents? Crime Scenes? Ads? Art?</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0u1yaXDGvWw4k7JZtVVoKw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>In the progression of fact to meaning, this scene has “encoded” information that we can interpret. Nonetheless, It doesn’t matter whether what is depicted actually exists — unless we want it to matter.</strong></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Seeing and Believing</strong></h3><p>In generating the photo with a camera, the original lighting is mediated by the lens, and that in turn is mediated by the composer, whose arrangement is mediated by the expressive intention, which is mediated by the circumstantial occasion of its viewing, which is mediated by the interpretive capability of the viewer, which is mediated by the interest or need of the viewer. Every point is one at which the experience of the eventual presented image can be modified.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KFqTImkvfTpNYURtxqSYiQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Presenting the picture is preceded by all but the last step above. The meaning of the picture, a perception, is dominated by the last three steps.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Interpreting visual data in a photograph <em>can </em>be guided very strongly by an expectation or belief that the data re-presents actual (physically detectable) visible phenomena. Realism exists when the intention and the interpretation together promote factuality as the foundation of perceived meaning that is obtained in the encounter through the medium.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mv9NZJCGodRFtzPp2IHdIA.png" /><figcaption><strong>In Realism, the “supply chain” of meaning is a chain of four or more <em>value assessments built on the presumption of factuality. The presumption is held by the viewer even if not by the picture-maker.</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>But the importance of holding that perspective is context-sensitive, and the actual experience provoked by the encounter in the presentation of the photograph is what the “-ism” in realism is about. Even including all of the above, hallucination and false narrative can be the experience produced by realism.</p><p>Realism is a <strong>capability</strong> of the medium, not the defining characteristic of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75642d0ffa22" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Imaging After Photography]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/imaging-after-photography-eb768d33e9d0?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb768d33e9d0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[visual-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Dec 2025 23:21:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-26T14:20:16.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>AI image generation does not change photography as a practice nor medium, nor category. What AI changes about photography is our presumption of what is distinctly differentiating about it, in our expectations of what it can uniquely do. When those expectations change, the decisions that lead to a demand for it or an application of it also change. It’s the decision-makers that change, not photography.</em></p><p>This month in AI, which will be the Dark Ages by Autumn of 2026, still features a general angst about what photorealistic AI-generated images are doing to the (a.) business, (b.) demand for, and (c.) understanding of what we’re used to calling <em>photographs.</em></p><p>We’re so used to calling them photographs that we’ve long since forgotten that they are <em>photographic images</em>, and that what we’re using calling a photograph is actually a photo<strong>gram. </strong>(You can look up the difference yourself, which will make it more memorable.)</p><p>We have a notion of what “photographic” is, and it is heavily loaded by default with something between a preference and a bias for visual “realism” — or said differently, re-presentation of natural visual experience.</p><p>But “photo-graphic” literally refers to <em>drawing with light. </em>There are a lot of types of images that can be produced by guiding light waves to create a visible pattern in a field of view. The “graphic” aspect speaks to drawing both literally and metaphorically. But our conventional interest in “photography” generally begins with the further expectation that a drawing will present a form as a <em>subject</em>. <em>Only something identifiable can be a subject, whether it is an actual or virtual item, a physical or conceptual construct.</em></p><p>That observation leads to another: <em>all “subjects” are real. Realism actually refers to any subject with a verifiable presence. Necessarily, then, any image that “visualizes” an idea is doing something that a photograph can do. But if it does it differently, there is a possibility that its method is better for some kinds of ideas than for others.</em></p><p><strong>ORIGINS AND PATHWAYS</strong></p><p>Fast-forwarding a bit from that thought: images that are actually photo-graphic have a long history that encompasses far more than documentary realism supporting photojournalism and art. I call out those two highly <em>intentional </em>disciplines because in our current imagination those two have the most to competitively lose by the ascendancy of generative AI as an imaging technique.</p><p>To press this issue harder: why should GenAI imaging care about “photography” at all in the pursuit of imaging? It is as different from its predecessor as quartz drives in Swatches were to Swiss Movements in Bulovas. As indifferent as the Word Processor was to IBM Selectrics.</p><p>Frankly, there are image-makers who will use whatever they need to use; and there are “photographers” who will use what they need to make a photograph. The only serious question is, when does a photograph solve a need that is not solved by some other form of imaging?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fqyXJK5TaGzC5X5zkZHijw.png" /><figcaption>An image of an image of an image of an image of an image. From idea to finish: studio creation and staging, 2 days. Or AI computed, 3 minutes. Which one is this? Who cares? (Go ahead… guess.) © Malcolm Ryder</figcaption></figure><p>The two dominant arenas of defining and servicing need are <em>curating</em> and <em>marketing. Both are built on an editorial function that addresses an explicit value system. Neither one’s value system defines “photography” as a whole.</em></p><p>Intentional imaging has called on photographic image production for well over a hundred years; but the audience for photographic imagery has also been increasingly diversified and increasingly “visually literate” as consumers. The audience’s idea of the <em>practice</em> of photography easily spans its pervasiveness in their environment because the audience relates to most photography as <em>manufactured </em>imaging. The audience’s main concern, and its main presumption, is about why the photography was used.</p><p>Below is a chart wrestling many brainstorming notes into a somewhat chronological sequence of changes in our observation and mastery of imaging as recorded and curated. In my view, the most important aspect of its story is in the curation aspect, which always featured human decision-making.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*16elXySyxFVzex0IRW5W-w.png" /><figcaption>Mastering light, and technologies that support and expand the mastery and the demand for it.</figcaption></figure><p>There is a history of curating photography that is fundamentally about editing, something that spans all optical, electrical, and digital photographic imaging. But of course there’s always a reason for curating, and when there’s no market for your reason or your effort then you’ll just have to do it because it makes you happy.</p><p>That marketing refers to some criteria of demand, and if you are a curator/editor, you can set the criteria however you like.</p><p><strong>IMAGINING IMAGES</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/790/1*2LtypeTPmC0YxHqmX7GJ9Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Visualization technique: painting, photograph, or digital render? Primary determinant of the visualization’s form: the material, the recording, or the imagination?</strong></figcaption></figure><p>This image: <strong>Decorator’s color sample? Crime scene evidence? Therapeutic metaphor? </strong>Context rules interpretation, and interpretation imposes criteria as “values”…</p><p>Farther than editing: there is a school of thought that calls for <em>custodianship of certain values. </em>That role usually includes requiring that in order to grant “value” to the image, it must be from certain means of production.</p><p>In this school’s broader formula for “value”, <em>Specific Production Method + Specified Product Qualities = Distinctive Importance.</em> But the custodianship role further acts on the presumption that what it deems important is the most valuable of all values.</p><p>There is also a school of thought that appoints certain custodianships as being more important than others. We’re familiar with exactly this kind of thing from our experience with Clergy. Such a custodial role is a direct manifestation of a culture: the <em>responsibilities </em>of custodianship represent <em>value </em>to the Culture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9k-g5NmRD1RjLfx0imjFZw.png" /><figcaption>[Diptych generated with Gemini AI]</figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile, in the formula that designated custodians apply as Curators, the Specific Product Qualities point out what makes a photographic image important to the value of the custodianship. Simply put, the dynamic is that, per the criteria of the Curator, the image somehow represents the Culture.</p><p>That dynamic holds whether the culture is, for example, science, history, or art.</p><p>There is an argument that over time, these cultures “evolve”. In some examples of that evolution, science expands standing knowledge; history refines the acuity and perspective on standing evidence; and art tests innovation in established perception.</p><p>But it is quite common that curators both optimize the recognition of prior exemplars and propose how subsequent works meaningfully extend or change that recognition. In that way, a curator can be a “bridge” across the difference.</p><p>Meanwhile, changes can redefine the boundaries of how we evaluate a medium. Said differently: something atypical could come to be recognized as a known prior thing.</p><p>But by far, in art, such changes over time do not “redefine” a medium.</p><p><strong>Just as photography was not a new form of painting, AI image generation is not a new form of photography.</strong></p><p><strong>THAT OBSCURE OBJECT OF DESIRE</strong></p><p>It is very easy for an AI-generated image (right) to offer the same qualities of, for example, a Richard Estes super-realist painting (left), and for both of them to offer the same qualities of a camera-generated image. We have to remember, however, that those “qualities” are ones that are preselected as being important. What are they? Verifiable facts? Plausible narrative? Sensory impact?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/1*qKlZI9ud_tR2xDE3drCjLw.png" /><figcaption>Left: a painting. Right: a similar AI-generated image.</figcaption></figure><p>We can see here that it is entirely possible for different types of media to meet the same selection criteria.</p><p>But there are three key factors of differentiation among (for example) painting, photography, and AI as image generators.</p><p>One is <strong>the human labor.</strong> We acknowledge execution; but we empathically sense performance. 12 minutes of prompting; 4 hours of shooting; six days of painting?</p><p>Another is <strong>the rendering instrument. </strong>We engage form; but we interpret presence. What created the observed effects: brushes; computer; camera?</p><p>And the third is <strong>the anticipated context </strong>of the image’s presentation. We acknowledge logic; but we desire preference. Documentary? Advertising? Fantasy? <strong>In any specific situation that we care about, why would we especially want a photograph? </strong><em>[Spoiler alert: photography’s role in non-fiction recording anchors its preferred role in “realist” depiction across several industries, but that defines a “use case”; it doesn’t define the medium.]</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_ITI4h6yS7nRoXVGEm-IRg.png" /><figcaption>Advertising and Journalism relying on figurative factual rendering of verifiable occurrences.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VALUE IN PHOTOGRAPHS</strong></p><p><em>Appreciation </em>is the term for “attributing value” — and with art, most appreciation is <em>psychological.</em></p><p>We engage form; but we interpret presence. <br>We acknowledge logic; we desire preference. <br>We admire execution; we empathically sense performance.</p><p>In satisfying our selves psychologically and exercising our appreciation, we can grant curatorial and/or custodial roles to ourselves or to others. The choice we make is mainly a matter of how it supports the position we want to hold in our cultural and social relations, but also in our private world of personality and identity.</p><p><strong>Some thinkers in the world of art are especially interested in the notion of how a work has “authenticity” </strong>based on its adherence to some definition of a medium. But the only consistent standard for authenticity is the degree of self-awareness that an audience (like a visual art viewer) has about its own requirements when the audience promotes its own selection of works.</p><p>In the practice of photography, this kind of difference is often evident in how an image maker categorizes their “personal” work as distinguished from their “commercial” or “commissioned” work. The values pursued in personal work will naturally align to the imagist’s interest in how to support their psychology, regardless of what market (if any) may also have demand that matches it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*If3iHkSelVlK0IhsjEQYrg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>EXCERPTS</em></strong> — How did we get from Julia Margaret Cameron to Man Ray to William Eggleston?</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Photography’s cultural “clergy” is a market-maker </strong>serving a full range of roles — priests, disciples, prophets, believers, preachers, and so on. In their domain, it is accepted that there is <em>orthodoxy </em>certifying how an image has value. It takes on a responsibility for admitting or converting aspirants that are either images or viewers. And it applies <em>interpretation </em>to set the boundary of how its qualifications are recognized.</p><p><strong>But new <em>experiences</em> of images — not new types of image production per se, </strong>are what expands or replaces our existing boundaries of psychological differentiation. Of course it makes sense to attribute a new experience to whatever produced it. But as shown above, experience is strongly affected by interpretation, and interpretation is also strongly affected by predispositions that are independent of production methods and even of the producer.</p><p><strong>SEEING THE LIGHT</strong></p><p>What actually preceded AI as a digital imagemaker is CGI. But like CGI, AI image generation does not change photography as a practice, nor medium, nor category.</p><p>What AI changes about “photography” is our presumption of what is distinctly differentiating in our expectations of what photography can uniquely do. When expectations change, the decisions that lead to a demand for it or an application of it also change.</p><p>The use of a camera (<em>or most specifically, an optical lens</em>) to manipulate light does more to differentiate the “core” of photographic practice than any other single thing that immediately comes to mind. It is fair to ask the question, how far can camera-based manipulation of light go to generate a meaningful image? Probably as far as any musical instrument can go to generate a meaningful sonic work.</p><p>In photography this immediately embraces the entire spectrum of imagery from visual non-objective abstraction (bearing no representation of anything other than its own characteristics), to visual concreteness depicting something else through figuration. Thought of that way, there is no more of a limitation on what a photograph can look like than there is on any other medium of graphical effects. <strong>We can try to identify something other than that pictorial range, that we would argue is somehow a defining characteristic of photographs — but being able to do that would not change the medium; it would just change who cares.</strong></p><p>Likewise, AI imaging just means that we’ve now covered chemicals, dyes, electrons, and pixels as of 2025. Beyond that, what is there? Implants for direct instrumental stimulation of brain cells?</p><p>As with most other art forms, an image maker’s attention may be focused on exploring how an audience interprets forms when other factors — including the environment, memory, and compositional strategies — are explicitly manipulated and incorporated as part of the presentation of images. Most of the interest in that will ride on how that is done — within the boundary of an image, externally around that boundary, or both. It is a direct interest in psychological differentiation of the experienced production. And this can correspond with expansion or modification of an audience’s <em>appreciation — </em>its terms for attributing value.</p><p><em>— MR</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb768d33e9d0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Art of Engaging Artworks]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/the-art-of-engaging-artworks-da390b5d2c68?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da390b5d2c68</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-and-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Dec 2025 20:03:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-25T20:04:43.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Understanding Art Engagement</h3><p>It’s 2025, and in much current topical writing about what makes today’s art valuable, <strong>authenticity</strong> is fighting hard to top the list as the word most likely to appear.</p><p>That may be due to the pervasive unholy trio of doubt-makers: social media, politics, and Artificial Intelligence. Given their rampant indifference to <em>veracity, </em>a backlash is overdue.</p><p>And meanwhile there is the expectation that “fine” artists are independent (i.e., not compromised). For relief from disbelief, that makes artists good alternatives to go to. We then want them to be “authentic”… their works to have authenticity.</p><p>But what makes using the term “authenticity” wobbly is its current role as a signal for <em>sincerity, truth, morality, </em>or<em> essence </em>— too often the lexicon of preaching to the choir, or of hype. Yes, #<em>virtue</em> is their hashtag.</p><p>But what people are typically getting at when using “authentic” that way is that something is <em>exceptional</em> because it exceeds the accepted business-as-usual offer by meeting a definitive high standard. This also assumes that the standard they have in mind is “superior” to other standards.</p><p>What makes this further problematic is an assumption, both tacit and arbitrary, that the corresponding <em>originator </em>of the exception is equally rare. Exaggerated, that gives the idea of the thing itself being <em>a proof, not just a sign, </em>of its originator’s (author’s) character. This actually collapses “authenticity” into “standard-bearing”, making it a bit harder to distinguish from fandom, political correctness, or other things readily susceptible to fickleness, manipulation, and marketing.</p><p>If we are one of those people, it’s easy to understand how that idea of “authentic” pertains to the experience of art. Psychologists call it <em>mirroring. </em>And with lots of art, that works.</p><p>But the real meaning of authenticity, and its power, are seen more clearly at a deeper level: in the larger context of how the <em>encounter </em>with art work comprises both the launch and the target of <em>engagement</em>.</p><p><strong>In engagement:</strong> active adherence to a chosen set of values is observed as <em>integrity. </em>Integrity becomes expressive of the value holder, who initially is the source creator of the work produced. “Authenticity” labels the experienced presence of that integrity. (That explains why it is easy to associate that behavior with the art worker as “identity”… a persona that charms, reassures, or recruits us from our anxiety of uncertainty.)</p><p>In art encounters, however, that authenticity simply is not enough to account for art’s power to attract and influence. And it certainly cannot be a prerequisite because, as we’ll see, other factors prove to be powerfully independent of it, whether we want them to be or not.</p><p>Still, the notion of an artist’s <em>set of values</em> being the formative principle of doing art <em>work </em>elegantly encompasses everything from conceptual art to DaDa, surrealism, impressionism, expressionism, realism, neorealism, pop, hieroglyphics, or whatever.</p><p>And the point of that is, authenticity is not an imperative; it is a strategy. We can always ask <em>why</em> we want it or need it, and we can always acknowledge that sometimes we neither need it nor want it.</p><p>Just as we experience tangible reality in three dimensions (if not four), an artwork has a multidimensional presence. on a case by case basis, we can need or prefer (i.e., <em>value) </em>any one of the dimensions more than the others; but the work always features all dimensions to one degree or another.</p><p>Seen as below, the more an artwork includes all three, the more powerful is its attraction and impact. Our vocabulary for what we get from a work and how we react to it consistently points at how these are dimensions of attraction in engagement. This doesn’t argue that any one of them is inherently more important than the others. But where authenticity matters, we can see what experiences it helps to generate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Sn_7fkTd8ZU9ZAvbac8Ing.png" /><figcaption>© Malcolm Ryder / Archestra Research</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da390b5d2c68" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Frames Per Second vs. Authenticity]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/frames-per-second-vs-authenticity-c3413651b3f1?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3413651b3f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[street-photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[directing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-non-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Dec 2025 21:57:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-06T22:03:43.105Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Some “streaming” filming of the horrific scene, <em>The Terror of War</em>:</p><p><a href="https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/video/napalm-attack-on-village-of-trang-bang-vietnam-south-news-footage/1182617625">Napalm attack on village of Trang Bang;</a></p><p>The contact sheet strip of the still camera negatives, unedited, from the scene:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*aC3WPSirihlgmAYr.jpg" /><figcaption>(Associated Press)</figcaption></figure><p>The edited (i.e., <strong><em>reframed</em></strong>) “print” (published) version of the image:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xW3uhhxsUeTmf8qu.jpg" /><figcaption>(Associated Press)</figcaption></figure><p>Editorially and compositionally, this version of the scene gets a grip on us because the young girls frontality and empty hands say, as <em>body language, that her vulnerability is Innocence, </em>and it makes us the party she is addressing. Further, the cropping of the image puts us “in” the foreground, again making us the party she is addressing. This is the added dimension to what is otherwise the same “facts” visible in the film and in the other still frames.</p><p>The point is that, being completely frank about all of it, this famous image was merely <em>beginning</em> to develop when the image was initially captured in negative. That part is the only part that the photographer — <strong><em>this time </em></strong>— takes full responsibility for. This famous image was completed by separate photo editor(s). As far as giving an audience a credited party for the <strong>final image</strong>, <em>the editor may as well have been the photographer on the scene.</em></p><p>This point is not at all a departure from what is normal in photography. Namely, the shooter is as likely as not to be the first and final editor. That depends on the requirements of the channel used to distribute the image.</p><p>Compositional rigor here is largely a disciplinary requirement due to the limitations of timing, transience, and point of view. The more options those elements of opportunity have, the less likely a heroic first-and-only effort is necessary to the viewer. (Ask any film or stage director!) The compositional competency is a fusion of what the photo gear allows and what the circumstances allow. The competency is neither necessarily momentary nor linear in its completion of its task. <em>Whoever is the editor, their control of visual language is accountable for the meaning expressed within the boundaries of the view and the boundaries of the instrument</em></p><p>A photographer shooting again and again during an event is arguably “<em>journaling</em>” it as soon as the hint of a story occurs in the photographer’s mind as the motivator for shooting. From that point forward, the main issue is whether the “story” is fiction or non-fiction. And subsequent to that point, the main issue is mastery of visual language.</p><p>Photography is NOT inherently journalistic. What makes photography journalistic is the commitment of its practice to a set of principles and standards that define <em>journalism,</em> not that define photography.</p><p>What is unavoidable is that an intentional photograph is always essentially a fabrication. But it is a fabrication with an objective. Being fabricated does not mean that it is not faithful to the realities of the viewed scene. It simply means that it re-presents, selectively. And the photographer initially controls the selection. The notion of photojournalism being authentic is not based in photography. Photography is a medium; authenticity is in the correspondence of the photographic presentation to the verifiable conditions of the subject. The medium <em>conveys </em>the correspondence.</p><p>Spread across the lifecycle stages of identification, selection, arrangement, contextualization, and presentation, photographic craftwork and the journalistic mission can each contribute something at each stage. Where there are expectations of the practice, it is important to distinguish between what is habitual for any reason versus what is actually inherent in the exercise. This applies regardless of how fast the full lifecycle is progressed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3413651b3f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding Art Engagement]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/understanding-art-engagement-fd76dc010e63?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd76dc010e63</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aesthetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-appreciation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Dec 2025 19:35:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-06T19:35:43.745Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s 2025, and in much current topical writing about what makes today’s art valuable, <strong>authenticity</strong> is fighting hard to top the list as the word most likely to appear.</p><p>That may be due to the pervasive unholy trio of doubt-makers: social media, politics, and AI. A backlash to their indifference to <em>veracity</em> is overdue, and the expectation that “fine” artists are independent (i.e., not compromised) makes them good alternatives to go to for relief from disbelief. We want them to be “authentic”…</p><p>But what makes using the term “authenticity” wobbly is that role as a signal for <em>sincerity, truth, morality, </em>or<em> essence </em>— too often merely the lexicon of preaching to the choir, or of hype.</p><p>What people are typically getting at when using it that way is that something is <em>exceptional</em> because it meets some definitive standard. The problem usually comes from the tacit arbitrary assumptions that there is necessarily only one “correct” originator (the “author”) or that the standard in mind is “superior” to other standards.</p><p>Observed as active adherence to chosen values, <em>integrity</em> becomes expressive of the value holder, namely the source creator of the work produced, and “authenticity” labels the experienced presence of that integrity. (Which explains why it is easy to associate that behavior with the art worker as “identity”… one that charms, reassures, or recruits us from the anxiety of uncertainty.)</p><p>It’s easy to understand how that pertains to their experience of art. But both the meaning and power of authenticity are clearer in the larger context of how the encounter with art work comprises both the launch and the target of <em>engagement</em>.</p><p>In art encounters, authenticity is simply not enough to account for art’s power to attract and influence. And it certainly cannot be a prerequisite, because other factors prove to be powerfully independent of it, whether we want them to be or not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3GbKRYizDer_k3OQ1FrTRA.png" /><figcaption>How and why an artwork can engage the audience.</figcaption></figure><p>However, the notion of an artist’s set of values being the formative principle of doing art <em>work </em>elegantly encompasses everything from conceptual art to DaDa, surrealism, impressionism, expressionism, realism, neorealism, pop, hieroglyphics, or whatever.</p><p>And the point is, authenticity is not an imperative; it is a strategy. In art, we can always ask <em>why</em> we want it or need it, and we can always acknowledge that sometimes we neither need it nor want it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd76dc010e63" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[News and the Abstract Truth]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/news-and-the-abstract-truth-a16127151d30?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a16127151d30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photojournalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary-film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary-photography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Nov 2025 17:31:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-28T19:25:59.626Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Six separate takes on a controversial new film — not from a film critic but from a photographer who considers various aspects of how we view pictures and the medium.</em></p><p>The new documentary <em>The Stringer, </em>released Nov. 28 on Netflix, refutes more than 50 years of celebrating Nick Út’s authorship of the iconic <em>“</em>Napalm Girl<em>”</em> photograph from the coverage of the Vietnam War. Since the film saw its first public showing at Sundance, passions pro and con have been running very high about its central accusation that the prize-winning photo was credited to the wrong photographer.</p><p>But most of the controversy is fueled not by the facts the film presents. Rather, it is fueled by the reality that one side <em>wants to believe </em>the accusation is true, and the other wants to believe it is not true. In a time when viral disinformation is a norm, the film as a documentary faces a big challenge: does its “evidence” at best merely prove what we want to believe, or does it instead just prove that we can’t know?</p><h3>NOTE 1.</h3><p><strong><em>What price, Glory?</em></strong></p><p>Real athletes work hard, doggedly, to get to a point where they can do something special. But for most athletes, that special moment surfaces rarely, and by surprise, leaping out of an ongoing stream of committed but “just the usual” effort. The athlete arrives in “the zone” - everything is clicking, the hard is easy, and the success comes, but not accountable to anything done differently. For most athletes, finding themselves in the zone just once, ever, is enough to justify all that came before it. It’s a moment of self-actualization that transcends all other judgments and all lesser tries afterwards, too. It’s the achievement of a lifetime. It happened and can’t be taken away. And with luck, there were witnesses.</p><p>For some, however, craft, instinct, and opportunity seem to converge fairly frequently. The line is blurred between whether the athlete creates these special moments or is just great at hunting them down.</p><p>Like athletes, we photographers shoot endlessly and hard, and can happen upon moments. The great part for us is that a “personal best” picture can hang around long after its initial moment, so the number of witnesses to it can just keep climbing. <em>And the more witnesses there are, the better that “best” becomes, all to our credit.</em></p><p>Vietnamese photographer Nick Út, credited for the amazing image popularly known as “Napalm Girl”, had such a moment in 1972, and that moment became permanently glorious. Út was declared the 1973 Pulitzer Prize winner for photojournalism, and the winner of the World Press Photo’s 1973 Photo of the Year. Whether more as a creator or a hunter, he is still feted for it decades later, on the record and in live appearances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*48N6LDCL2UfQBu_5.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Copyright: the Associated Press</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>But what if he was neither?</p><p>If we believe the claim made in the documentary film <em>The Stringer</em>, Nick’s real achievement may turn out to be that he won a lifetime of rewards for one score that wasn’t his. Casting doubt on whether Út actually took the shot, the film could stop the ongoing celebration that he has enjoyed, and his glory could be taken away.</p><p><strong><em>Game Changers</em></strong></p><p>The provenance of “Napalm Girl” has not been questioned by anyone publicly influential for decades.</p><p>Legendary Horst Faas, the Associated Press (AP) chief of photo operations in Saigon who published the picture in 1972, is thought of as the AP’s journalistic and business hero of the time, racking up numerous industry awards for the news wire service and setting quality standards for peers.</p><p>The whole point of a “wire service” agency such as AP is <em>to tell truths as news</em>, so logically there is a continual and confident invitation to all comers to validate its sources. Faas set the publication credit for the photo to Nick Út, along with the formal title of the image, “The Terror of War”. … A gruesome, unforgettable scene of unjust and unnecessary human<br>suffering, it crystallized the horror that motivated the US anti-war movement and shifted public tolerance. It is often credited for leading to the final withdrawal of US troops from Vietnam and the end of US involvement in the war.</p><p>What the public has taken for granted, then and now, is that an attribution by the Associated Press is beyond reproach.</p><p>But in the documentary The Stringer, a deep investigation triggered by a 2022 tip from a 1972 witness argues that this decisive, career-defining moment for the photographer Út wasn’t properly his moment at all. It has embroiled him in a controversy that could revise his personal history as dramatically as the image revised the course of the war.</p><p><strong><em>Business as Usual</em></strong></p><p>In the news business, reporting something isn’t “news” if it isn’t saying what you haven’t already heard.</p><p>But mistakes are not hard to come by. In the rush to get the word out, journalists can stumble: what seems at first to be right can get undone by a closer and longer look.</p><p>Retractions, on the other hand, can be pretty hard to come by. If breaking news seems to have its footing in a gray area, the public is still the beneficiary of being alerted that something warrants inspection, which creates some leeway if not approval.</p><p>A news agency such as the AP is unlikely to apologize for trying, above all, to get a profoundly shocking news image such as “Napalm Girl” distributed asap. And on its own, the image has never been suspected of being anything other than truthful. That end rationalized whatever the means were.</p><p>Enter The Stringer, and a few journalists unwilling to ignore stubborn facts when they belatedly present themselves. In contrast to the usual tolerance of questionable “means”, the filmmakers show explicit diligence in the pursuit of evidence. Yet many among its audiences insist it is an ambiguous film about an ambiguous event.</p><p>This could surely be a sign of the times. Our contemporary culture complicates the controversy over the film’s central accusation. We are saturated with <em>fabricated</em> imagery, beginning with programmed television, and then (in order of increasing artifice) commercial film, social media, special effects and digital editing tools, and generative “deep faking” A.I. We are used to fully embracing that artifice even as we, ironically, hold a heightened skepticism of it. This is today’s convenient practice of a “suspension of disbelief”, released from the theater and touching far more of real life.</p><p>But this makes it easy to ask why the film’s concern about authorship is even important. After all, given how significant the image was on its own, who other than photographers ultimately cares about which photographer took it?</p><p>Perhaps Út, an AP employee, did not make that picture: but so what? And what if the AP chief editor Faas intentionally credited the picture to an AP employee, namely Út, rather than allowing a non-AP freelancer (aka “stringer”) to be recognized as the originator of the picture? After all, if Faas did that, well, it was both possible and a frequently tolerated practice.</p><p>Against that, photography’s original core value proposition is being factual. (It is not, after all, a painting.) Photojournalism takes this claim further — its credibility rests in providing sourcing of the information it presents. In the case of crediting “Napalm Girl”, the film questions that “inherent” credibility, by looking into the matter as being a breach of ethics by both the photographer Út and the AP.</p><p>This is where the elaborate mechanisms of public demand — including recognition, awards, and rewards — surface as central to both the notion of wrongdoing in the film and the excited controversy over the film.</p><p>If Út is stripped of the credit that drove his ongoing celebrity, the implication immediately arises that he conspired to perpetuate a self-serving fiction at someone else’s expense. Yet half of the film audience is willing to discount the evidence. Among Út’s supporters, he is not found innocent, but he’s not found guilty.</p><h3>NOTE 2.</h3><p><strong><em>The Evident versus the Apparent</em></strong></p><p>The problem with <em>ethics</em> is that usually they are circumscribed by context.</p><p>In 1972, AP’s standard procedure for crediting and releasing information may not ever have exceeded what was at the time acceptable in public and business as practice. Said differently, no one at the time may have considered AP’s decisions and actions to have been <em>irresponsible</em>.</p><p>On the other hand, if either or both Út and Faas knew that falsely crediting the picture to Út would deny the true image-maker of significant earned benefits, then the false crediting was <em>immoral,</em> regardless of any other circumstances.</p><p>Based on what <em>The Stringer</em> offers, how would we know which is the case? Well, in fact, <em>both things can be true, </em>and arguably that is the version of things that finds the most support from the limited evidence generated so far, whether by the accusers or the accused.</p><p>The storyline: first, multiple photographers were on the scene when the village of Trảng Bàng was bombed with napalm, but only one of them is the true source of that “decisive moment” picture, “The Terror of War”.</p><p>Then there is ambiguity in the chain-of-evidence drama of how the negative was delivered from the photographer in the field to, eventually, AP’s Saigon bureau chief Faas.</p><p>And finally, there is the intentional distribution of the image, which required Faas to break a standing AP censorship policy (no frontal nudity for children), but as a result pumped the AP and Út up to the pinnacle of its business and society’s rewards.</p><p>Paralleling that plot of three decisive points is a three-part formula for justifying the usual story of what is believed to have happened. There is first the reputation of the photographer’s known talent; second, the motivations of the editor; and third, the public’s desire to be informed. All three of those influences — talent, motivation, and desire — are presumed to be positive <em>and benevolent</em>, unless proved otherwise.</p><p>Of those three matters, the most important one today is the third one,<em> the audience’s influence on information. Increasingly, today, the audience prefers what it wants to believe</em> over <em>what it needs to know, </em>the recipe for myth-making and propaganda. That makes the controversial reception of the documentary even more ironic: the subject photo of the film was important precisely because it pierced the propaganda that supported conducting the war fifty to sixty years ago.</p><p>Meanwhile, the filmmakers believe this documentary pierces the propaganda of Nick Út’s celebrity.</p><p><strong><em>We Have Met the Enemy, and He is Us</em></strong></p><p>It seems almost quaint to spend so much time on one bit of possible misinformation. But today, we are fully submerged in an Era of Disinformation — the intentional use of information to fabricate an unproven illusion of reality.</p><p>Beyond mistakes or imagination, fabrications posing as truth can go further, exceeding any individual’s personal tolerance or recreation, such as with propaganda.</p><p>The danger<em>: </em>the excess<em> </em>risks becoming socially disruptive. As the <em>Washington Post</em> would put it: “Democracy Dies in Darkness.” In poly-cultural populations like ours, bias, discrimination, manipulation, and repression are collectively a destructive toxin.</p><p>Yet we accept more and more fabricated information anyway. That acceptance also fosters a demand for it, one that overlooks the risks. As an audience, do we take responsibility for our own demand?</p><p><strong>In that perspective, what <em>The Stringer</em> ultimately accomplishes is to tweak the public about its own complicity in the controversy over whether the right person got the credit for the photo.</strong></p><h3>NOTE 3.</h3><p><strong><em>Public Opinion on Trial</em></strong></p><p><em>The Stringer</em> prosecutes.</p><p>But the AP and its anointed photographer defend. Let’s review the case.</p><p>First, the Photographer: if Út didn’t make the photo, it is possible that he knew he didn’t and refused to say so for fifty years. Yet there is some possibility that he honestly believed he did make the picture. Proving one or the other of those things now is a newsy drama that can overshadow the other issues (below) at hand, <em>but either way it doesn’t weaken the historical importance and acceptance of the image in the public eye.</em></p><p>Second, the Agency: it has resisted, but not stonewalled, the pressure for transparency about its role and processes. The question is, if the AP in 1972 did not know who took the picture, would that have prevented it from being released asap as news? If the answer is yes, then a best-guess attribution, a plausible one, can be argued for its merit in supporting the public interest with the release. But <em>there’s no reason for AP today to say that someone other than Út (in this case, freelance photographer Nguyen Thanh Nghe)</em><strong> </strong><em>made the photo if they don’t believe someone else did. The only evidence that matters is evidence available about conditions in 1972.</em></p><p>But in this court case, there is a third party, the Audience. This film’s current controversy concerning honesty about authorship exists in a current climate of fabricated information being normalized, and wherein belief is preferred over facts. As a society we are increasingly guilty of attributing value to information only when <em>“proof” supports our preference</em> — the basic formula for myth-making.</p><p>In our culture, marketers and politicians know that all too well, and literally spend billions of dollars a year to keep us predisposed that way. Against that condition, journalism’s challenge is to somehow still work as intended, presenting factual truth. Bu<em>t in a culture where perspective is driven by marketing and ideology, can truth avoid being subordinated?</em></p><h3>NOTE 4.</h3><p><strong><em>Conclusively Inconclusive</em></strong></p><p>A big revision of history is a news event.</p><p>Often, the newsworthiness of the revision is that it exposes what was thought to be truth as not being the truth. With <em>The Stringer</em> we confront what we thought about photography, about news itself, and finally about ourselves.</p><p>The basic role of photography is usually presumed to be recording discovered facts, bearing witness. When what it conveys is intended to be news, its credibility is in <em>the confidence that it is re-producing facts.</em></p><p>In evaluating the reliability of news, the key has always been to “consider the source” — we want to know how the facts were obtained. With news we factor in both the investigative method and the investigator of its facts.</p><p>But also, the more impact the news has, the more we tend to credit the source as being special. In this dynamic, it is easy to assume that only special people are capable of breaking special news, as if the news would otherwise not come to light.</p><p>With <em>The Stringer</em>, the special protagonists are the “Napalm Girl” photographer <em>(in this case, whether Nick Út or freelance photographer Nguyen Thanh Nghe)</em>, the photo editor Carl Robinson, and the photo publisher Horst Faas. In the story within the film, each of them is called into question. We first deal with that as a need for more facts.</p><p>But whereas news uncovers facts, documentary creates narratives. The power of facts is not just in being verified but in<em> what they affect</em>. In contrast, the power of narratives is in <em>how they convince</em>.</p><p>As documentary, photography goes beyond the basics. It is expected to find a story in the facts, or even to make one. And we expect the story to be convincing.</p><p>However, a major problem today, and going forward, is that we cannot presume that information in a photographic image is factual, and it gets increasingly difficult to verify. Stories can be even more suspect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CYV8dofiUocF5FR5.png" /></figure><p><em>The Stringer</em> arrives at a time when both journalism at large and documentary photography in particular, face unprecedented challenges from information technologies, ones that present reality as synthetic, as an end product more than as a beginning condition of truth. Less a certainty, more a story. More an effect of of <em>mediation </em>than of <em>medium</em>.</p><p>But even without that problem, The Stringer is challenged to argue facts in a most believable way. It toils in the problem of truth, but it depends on the nature of proof. It’s a film that wants to revise history. But the film wants its facts to sell the story, while we in the audience want its story to sell its facts. This burden falls on the film’s investigator (and originator) photographer Gary Knight.</p><p>On the surface, “The Stringer” appears to be an exposé — Gary Knight’s story of how one person stole from another and was celebrated for doing it. The allegation and its possible veracity is dramatic news.</p><p>But beneath that surface, the drama in the <em>history </em>is not about the photograph or the photographer. I<em>t is about the way they both were used. </em>The way they were used broadens the message of the film: it is about photography as a medium and about making news - and in both cases, about the nature of “truth”.</p><h3>NOTE 5.</h3><p><strong><em>The reality of appearance</em></strong></p><p>We expect journalism (at least through research) to get the facts that become the material of a documentary’s narrative.</p><p>Photo-documentation — a practice of capturing facts — has been a fundamental support for documentary narrative that positions journalism’s stories as reusable fact.</p><p>It is the two-way interaction between fact-finding and storytelling that explains how photography is a <em>medium</em>. But, as procedures, documentation and narrative are now each called into question by the film.</p><p>That is despite the film’s detractors accusing it of being the very example of what it aims to attack: a fabrication driven by suspicious motives.</p><p>The film’s presentation of facts clearly raises questions about whether, and how, we can trust the news. Its facts argue that in 1972 potential breaches of ethical news practice may have happened– due to competition, racism, politics, money, or power. (Check all that apply.) The story in <em>The Stringer, </em>whether its specific accusation is true or not, portrays our vulnerability to such influence.</p><p>Its relevance today is that those conditions are persistent, and so is our vulnerability. Left unchecked, they transcend any one case or event, and run deeper than any particular communication channel.</p><p>In the film we are shown the resulting harm caused. We see the loss of opportunity, the denial of rightful recognition, and a resignation to a meager and obscure life — that befell the photographer who possibly was denied due credit.</p><p>And we don’t need to amplify the facts much to suspect underlying bias, discrimination, and manipulation. Now, in reactions to the film, the backlash to the very idea of such exploitation damages others in the story as well, with longstanding friendships and reputations at the top of the at-risk list.</p><h3>NOTE 6.</h3><p><strong><em>Authorship, Authority, and Authenticity</em></strong></p><p>It is important to hold on to the value of <em>“</em>Napalm Girl<em>” </em>as truth-telling, even if the editorial process that authorized its release was flawed, and even if the person claiming credit doesn’t offer convincing evidence of being the true author. We don’t know what would have happened if a different photographer, and/or a different publisher, had come out with this picture.</p><p>But the documentary’s call to action is not to convict Nick Út nor the AP for their past. Rather, the AP’s final pronouncement on the film’s accusation is that they can’t prove it is false but they also can’t prove that it’s true. This conclusion is unacceptable as a status of any future journalistic work released by AP as news.</p><p>The overall importance of the film is mainly cautionary: that accepting such failures of ethics and practice <em>actively </em>undermines the journalist’s mission, and when that happens, there will be significant negative consequences.</p><p>Even more essential, as <em>The Stringer </em>Executive Producer Gary Knight commented in a recent live interview, journalists are neither elected nor appointed by the public — and yet journalists are expected to hold everyone accountable. That can’t work if journalists don’t show that they hold themselves to the highest standard of accountability. This makes determination of authorship required <em>in principle; it is about the practices, not about the image.</em></p><p>But what we most need to embrace about the film is that its focus on authenticity in truth is a two-way street; both the journalist and the audience are responsible. Who are <em>the mediators of truth </em>going forward?</p><p>Together we need to demand authenticity in both sides of the matter and determine how we can embed it into the rapidly evolving future.</p><p><strong>So far, today’ conditions, including culture and technologies, are even more likely to make news work unreliable or to cause damage. How are we to take responsibility for preventing that?</strong></p><p><em>— Malcolm Ryder is an urban cityscape photographer. He is also a strategist, solution developer and knowledge management professional in both profit and non-profit companies across business, IT, and the arts.</em></p><p><strong>Postscript </strong><a href="https://www.malcolmryder.com/artdotdot/hashtags/1"><strong>#1</strong></a></p><p>Quoting a line used in a 1944 column by George Orwell, “history is written by the winners.”</p><p><strong>Postscript #2</strong></p><p>Many people point out how the two photographers have vastly different bodies of work standing behind <em>the credibility of </em>their claim to be the “Napalm Girl” photographer. However, the fact is, Nghe was at the scene on purpose, with a camera on purpose, which he knew how to “operate”. And if he was just simply lucky enough to be in the right spot at the right time, he EASILY could have taken the shot. It does not make sense at all to assume that as a human witness to what was happening, Nghe would have not instantly recognized the importance of what he was seeing, and that alone would be enough 99% of the time to make a photographer <em>frame up and press the button</em>. He wasn’t writing a script, casting, directing, or controlling the visibility. He didn’t need any other qualifications at all — no artistry, no other works, nothing.</p><p><strong>Postscript </strong><a href="https://www.malcolmryder.com/artdotdot/hashtags/2"><strong>#</strong></a><strong>3</strong></p><p>The most significant reaction so far to the findings in the film is the perfect clarity of the World Press Photo Foundation. It declared the photographer of the picture to be anonymous; the award it gave is about the photo, not about the photographer, and is unchanged.</p><p><strong>Postscript </strong><a href="https://www.malcolmryder.com/artdotdot/hashtags/3"><strong>#</strong></a><strong>4</strong></p><p>The documentary photography of the American Civil War is most famously credited to Matthew Brady. Yet we know, over 160 years later, that 15 or more different photographers had their work credited to Brady, including two very famous ones, Alexander Gardner and Timothy O’Sullivan. We also know today that a photograph so influential that it was banned in China — the so called “Tank Man” picture — was thought to be pro-Chinese propaganda by its initial authorized Chinese distributor, but taken as anti-Chinese propaganda by its non-Chinese audiences worldwide, causing the Chinese government to attempt to eradicate the image post-publishing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*ul9SxeedKBsBnQOi.png" /></figure><p><em>The title of this article: inspired by the album “Blues and the Abstract Truth” by saxophonist Oliver Nelson, recorded in February 1961 for the Impulse! label.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a16127151d30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI and Visual Truth]]></title>
            <link>https://malcolm-ryder.medium.com/ai-and-visual-truth-f46c803be610?source=rss-ee989e36660e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f46c803be610</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malcolm Ryder]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Nov 2025 00:53:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-30T04:58:35.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Any image generated optically with a camera lens might be acceptable in many different ways. It could be an entertainment or a crime scene. Evidence or an accident. Theater or documentation. What differentiates the “value” is not the photographer, nor the photographer’s intent. It is actually differentiated by the use that the viewer wants to make of it.</p><p>But the RELATIONSHIP between the scene and the viewer (aka meaning) is always only one of three relationships that can be important. The other two are the relationship between the photographer and the viewer (aka expression) and the relationship between the photographer and the image (aka intent). Entire industries and careers have been built and evolved based on cultural, social, or commercial agreements about those three relationships.</p><p>In all three relationships, the agreement could be “non-fiction images”. Some people will be interested in and motivated by that option. It will be tough times ahead for those who will not consider other possibilities. But the world of other options will not obsess about the word “photograph”. The word “image” is going to suffice (it already does). Image makers can help themselves by making their part in the expectations readily verifiable. Viewers will have to learn that distribution channels, not the medium, should be where they place their expectations.</p><p>All that said, most of the time, there is a practical reason why cameras would be preferrable to a pencil or a computer: <strong>creating a visual record</strong>.</p><p><strong>Records </strong>exceed the notion of “documents” in that a record is always attached to <em>a concern about</em> something specific, not just a view of it.</p><p>There are several ways to create a visualization of some <em>event or condition </em>thought to be relevant.<em> But most of them </em>might not be reliable as a source of their real-world facts.</p><p>We go through this any time there is a measurable distance between the existence of what we’re concerned about and our direct witness of the concerning thing. The appearance of the image is asked to match the experience we would have if we were there.</p><p>Cameras, at their initial introduction, were instantly famous because of the relatively high fidelity their images offered — not only versus being at the scene, but versus any prior existing imaging method.</p><p>This is why anxiety over the trustworthiness of a photograph is 90% based in achievable optical <em>resolution, and only 10% in why it was made.</em></p><p>But ever since the <em>screen </em>was invented, and at least since the paintings of Seurat (pointillism) and Lichtenstein (Ben-Day Dots), we have been able to generate images that at sufficient distance “resolve” to whatever they showed, because we had control over where any of their dots went — at least comparable in labor to weaving.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*LIj1ESBf9f6JV8Dm.png" /></figure><p>Having enough automation now to make dot rendering nearly effortless hasn’t changed much of anything. It’s just that the dots are now electronic — nearly microscopic and extremely easy to individually reposition any number of times by using instructions that run on computers like calculations.</p><p>So in effect, with our new <em>instruments </em>for generating an image, more emphasis is placed on those of us who “play” them to be able to prove that we are the decision makers and the instructors that programmed and approved the display.</p><p>The credibility of the imagemaker, per the maker’s expressed intent, is what is at stake.</p><p>New A.I. image generation is completely indifferent to anything other than its instructions. <strong>The more we are willing to accept an image maker’s explanation </strong>of why they made the image the way it looks, the less it matters to us that the maker has fabricated the image without recording being a part of the process.</p><p>T<strong>he future value of photographic recording </strong>will be hugely diminished in situations where recording as a proxy for direct witnessing is not necessary — not required by our concern to verify something’s <em>appearance</em>.</p><p>But we can also understand when that requirement is not negotiable. The requirement to proxy witnessing is high any time our concern is represented by saying<strong><em> “IF X is true, THEN…”.</em></strong></p><p>In that formula, which presents our key concern, a visualization of “X” is subject to any verification of its fidelity to something actual.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/740/0*yH7iaX7VhCPdlUIj.png" /></figure><p>But if viewers don’t have a particular concern, then the value of the image is left to however much the viewer is interested in whatever way it provokes them.</p><p>The usual way to anticipate that is in terms of where the viewer chooses to go look, and why. For example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*21ukb7KEDtxKTjUprkGjDQ.png" /></figure><p>In this picture, incentives, expectations, and inhibitors are seen related to each other. But their overlaps also suggest that what crops up in one area can mistakenly be evaluated in terms of another area. As a simple example, treating hearsay as if it is the result of research is easy to do if we are not openly cautioned against doing that.</p><p><em>See ongoing observations about AI in Visual Arts at </em><strong><em>www.artdotdot.com.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f46c803be610" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>