<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Marcel Schoppers on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Marcel Schoppers on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 01:05:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Meaning Of Life, Part 2: Creating An Ethic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/the-meaning-of-life-part-2-creating-an-ethic-e8479610a427?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8479610a427</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning-of-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Apr 2026 06:46:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T05:31:28.233Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xSAdpd_9aMTWPFo4" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@garri?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Vladislav Babienko</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Foundation For Part 3</h4><p>The vast majority of humans are stuck inside their own heads. They think “men” is a thing, “women” is a thing, “masculinity” is a thing, “femininity” is a thing. No, those “things” only exist in your own head, and they’re not even the exact-same notions as other people associate with those words. You cannot point to the set of all “men” (or “women”, or others), you can only point to the tiny, tiny subset in your own experience. You can’t identify who’s in and who’s not-in the set; 4 billion “men” identified one-per-second would take you 380 years of 8-hour days, to classify them all. You can’t even identify them in-theory by means of genetics: there are bodily women with an X chromosome, there are people with XXY, XYY, XXYY chromosomes. In other words, scientific team-work has already busted your group-noun delusion. You can’t go by genitals: There are intersex people. You can’t measure everyone’s inclinations: LGBTQIA+. The set of “men” (or “women”) exists only in your sexist imagination. “Masculinity” and “femininity” are for silly young humans mistaking what they feel/want as if it’s “in the air”. This is what Gender Studies are on about when they say that “gender is a social construct”. To me, there are humans, period. Much more importantly, for each of us: Who are the very, very few people that I can live with, and they with me, and stay friends? (“Friends with benefits” (and commitment) is the long-term GOAL!) That might be one in a thousand, even one in a million. What do I perceive to be different/important, about me for them, and about them for me? <a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/out-of-the-animal-trap-83f5139bde90">But that’s a whole other essay</a>. Here, I’m only concerned with how to treat people — all people—and how I would like them to treat me: An ethic. In Part 3 of this series, I will apply this ethic more specifically to friend-, family-, and love-relationships. To many people, this Part 2 will seem unarguable, maybe even not kind enough. Then Part 3 will be a shock, because (it seems) our lovers, families and friends aren’t “other people” we need to treat ethically; they OWE us like nobody else, they SHOULD do what we want! (I don’t think so.)</p><p>LET’S GO</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/the-meaning-of-life-part-1-834f9d9d2498">Part 1 of this series (on “The Meaning Of Life”)</a> observed that you MUST create yourself. You have no other choice, because no-one else can ever occupy the same spaces at the same times; no-one else will ever experience ANYTHING that has happened to you, in precisely the same way; even your brothers and sisters had a different family than you did: they had to cope with YOU. And what you decide to do with all that unique experience is, how you create yourself; is, how you are inevitably unique in all the universe, and for all eternity. No-one can tell you how you SHOULD respond to anything, except by ignoring your uniqueness! From there, “the meaning of life” lies in HOW you create yourself.</p><p>Decide, you must, over and over. Everything you want, but have to choose; everyone who wants something from you (e.g. your time, your sex, your money, your personal data); people who simply TAKE what they want — your space and your stuff and your limited lifetime/attention (interruptions, commercials, children); how are you going to handle it all? One of the decisions you must make is, Are you going to live by any principles, a code, an ethic? Which one(s)? Absence of a decision is also a decision.</p><p>Near the end of Part 1, I advised to create yourself regardless of all the SHOULDs that all sorts of people will gladly heap on you. Here’s why I said that. Take the opposite position: that you SHOULD and SHOULD-NOT do whatever ANYONE else says. Ridiculous, right? Then try a more moderate position, that you only SHOULD and SHOULD-NOT do SOME things other people say. Which things? You’re the one choosing this. Why choose that you SHOULD obey any SHOULDs at all? Mostly, because such obedience is forced onto you before you’re old enough to think. Now, THINK, and choose — which implicitly means that you’re allowing that you’re under no prior obligation to ANY SHOULDs or SHOULD-NOTs. And so, by a different path, you again discover that you MUST create yourself.</p><p>Why DO people heap SHOULDs onto you? Well, what’s in that, for them? No sooner asked than answered: (a) Ego, or moral superiority, or making you make them right, or even, they want to feel like they can control you with mere words; (b) Everything “society” considers virtuous is for the benefit of anyone but yourself, and people can free-load on that. You SHOULD be generous (to me). You SHOULD be brave (and put yourself in harm’s way, for me). You SHOULD stay in your lane (for my benefit). But if any SHOULD doesn’t go both ways in practice, it’s hypocrisy. And if you’re not virtuous (gullible) enough to volunteer (fall) for those SHOULDs, then you SHOULD be! (That was sarcasm, BTW.) I completely don’t understand where “You SHOULD have children” comes from.</p><p>Lastly, I remarked that, in advising us to ignore all the SHOULDs, I was myself ignoring some people for whom SHOULDs are mere pot-holes in the road to a life of crime, or of exploiting others. Some such exploitations are legal (e.g. under-paying workers while keeping $millions for yourself) and even admired, but that doesn’t make them right. Serious question: Why SHOULDN’T someone “create themselves” by considering themselves superior, and therefore exempt from other people’s pitiful inhibitive morals? Human predators do exactly that. Why SHOULDN’T someone “create themselves” by getting as rich as they can, at poorer people’s expense? In this essay I’ll address that ethic-hole.</p><p>CREATING THE DIAMOND RULE</p><p>Being thorough and consistent drives me to realizations and discoveries. In this case, I’m afraid I can’t be so thorough and consistent without uttering a “rule” that sounds a lot like a SHOULD. In defense of my semblance of inconsistency, I wish I could say “Thus says the Lord!”, but I wouldn’t dare; I made up this ethic, like a hypothesis. I’ll explain why this is not a SHOULD, near the end of this essay. Here’s my Diamond Rule:</p><blockquote>[DON’T] let yourself do unto anyone as they [DON’T] wish done to themselves (unless they have already done to others what those others did not wish).</blockquote><p>The two “[DON’T]” parts mean, either exclude both, or include both. If you EXclude both, the first line is a variation on the Golden Rule, known as the Platinum Rule (explained just below). If you INclude both, the first line is a variation on the Silver Rule. So there’s actually two “rules” there. Beyond those, I’ve packed in several subtleties, that I’ll explain in a second.</p><p>In passing, I’ll point out that this is an example of ME creating myself. When the above “rule” came to me, I felt like I was re-defining morality for all humanity, and putting myself in God’s place. The rule’s close relative “love your neighbor as yourself” is at least 3,500 years old, written down in Leviticus 19:18, and that verse even ends with God banging down His gavel on the bench of authority:</p><p>“Do not seek revenge or bear a grudge against anyone among your people, but love your neighbor as yourself. I am the LORD.”</p><p>Who am I, to decide what’s morally right and wrong? And yet, that’s what I’m doing, because, clearly, the way the Old Testament put that, hasn’t accomplished very much in 3,500 years (unfortunately). Here’s why not: Some of us interpret “your people” as “only my kind of people”; some of us think that “not seek revenge or bear a grudge” is all the “love” there needs to be; some of us ask “But who is my neighbor?” (Luke 10:25–37); and some of us don’t love ourselves! So many loop-holes… They remind me of my favorite Bible verse that doesn’t exist: “God made Man righteous, but they have sought out many devices” (ref. Ecclesiastes 7:29). So yes, I’m tweaking ancient wisdom, and creating myself in the process, and it felt a bit alarming. But really, the only people I might be “harming” with this, are the ones exploiting the loop-holes! “Harming” those people is entirely consistent with the second line of my Diamond Rule.</p><p>Here are the subtleties I’ve woven into the Golden and Silver Rules.</p><p>“<strong>… as THEY wish … done to themselves</strong>” — The original Golden Rule, “Do unto others as YOU wish done to you”, is obviously ego-centric. What you wish done to you is irrelevant to what others wish done to them. It makes only slightly more sense in the Silver Rule, “DON’T do unto others as you DON’T wish done to you,” but if their wishes differ from yours, why not. So we see that THEIR wish is primary, not your wish. This version of the Golden Rule is called the Platinum Rule.</p><p>“<strong>… let yourself …</strong>” — The Platinum Rule reads “Do unto others as they wish done to them.” If they wish my entire life’s assets given to them, SHOULD I? That is clearly missing my agreement, hence I added the “let”. I LET myself do to others as they wish, but I don’t have to do that; and I DON’T LET myself do to others as they DON’T wish.</p><p>Checkpoint: so far we’ve modified the Golden and Silver Rules into this:[DON’T] <em>let yourself</em> do unto others as <em>they </em>[DON’T] wish done to <em>themselves</em>.</p><p>And just like that, I’m already controversial, implying that assisting suicide is not immoral — IF there is indeed no-one else who doesn’t want that suicide “done to them”, e.g. parents or friends. (Assisting in crimes against others IS immoral, and a suicide might be such a crime.)</p><p>“<strong>… do unto anyone …</strong>” — But why are the Golden/Silver Rules only about what I do unto “others”? According to “love your neighbor as yourself”, I should also consider what I do to myself. So I replaced “others” with “anyone” including myself. This has the beneficial side-effect that, contrary to some readers interpreting “others” very specifically, as if the Golden/Silver Rules only apply to SOME others, I’m deliberately making those rules apply to “anyone” (including myself).</p><p>Checkpoint: [DON’T] let yourself do unto anyone as they [DON’T] wish done to themselves.</p><p>“<strong>… to themselves …</strong>” — This may seem like an insignificant part of the Platinum Rule, but it’s actually important. I’m not obliged to [NOT] do what “they” [DON’T] wish done (period), as if everyone else’s SHOULD-NOTs can fence me in; it’s only about what “they” [DON’T] wish done “to themselves”. So, take your SHOULDs and SHOULD-NOTs and shove ’em, unless they’re about what I SHOULD-NOT do to you.</p><p>If I engage in ANY practices in privacy or only with consenting adults, why do you think you have anything to say about it? (Further providing I’m not violating anyone’s trust, either.)</p><p>“<strong>… unless …</strong>” — Given only the first line of my Diamond Rule, I’m not even allowed to do to a criminal what that criminal doesn’t wish done to them, even when s/he is already violently breaking the Golden/Silver Rules. The second line says that I AM allowed to defend myself, and others. Further, the second line makes clear that it’s not just what others wish, that limits what I can and can’t do; it’s the rule itself. Break it, and others are allowed to break it AGAINST me.</p><p>I’d prefer if all counter-breaking was proportional to the breakage, but my Diamond Rule is already complicated enough.</p><p>“<strong>unless they have already done to <em>others</em> …</strong>” — What if someone does harm to themselves, and I believe that they don’t REALLY wish that done to themselves, have they then broken this rule, and therefore I’m allowed do unto them, what they DON’T wish? Am I allowed to forcibly, perhaps violently, prevent self-harm?! In general, I don’t think so, not even to prevent suicide. So the Diamond Rule says that I’m only allowed to break this rule by “doing unto” people who are harming OTHERS.</p><p>And thus we’ve come to the complete Diamond Rule:</p><blockquote>[DON’T] let yourself do unto anyone as they [DON’T] wish done to themselves (unless they have already done to others what those others did not wish).</blockquote><p>There are still some “edge cases”, like children, or seniors with dementia, unwittingly harming only themselves. The Diamond Rule says I’m not allowed to do unto them what they don’t wish. And yet, I have prevented my own daughter, when she was about 3 years old, from slapping her hand down on an open flame and hot burner on a gas cook-top. She got angry at me for that, and slapped me about the knees (cute), over her right to do it anyway, and I forcibly stopped her burning herself, several times. I resolved the situation by picking her up (against her will, as she tried to slap me again) and taking her hand in mine far above the flame, and slowly lowering it until it got hot and she pulled away, and then she stopped wanting to burn herself. But it did take me doing, unto her, what she did not wish, and stopping her doing, to me, what *I* did not wish. And so it went on, for 16 years. Sorry not sorry, as they say.</p><p>What about [NOT] doing unto people who don’t exist yet? I don’t know yet.</p><p>REJECTING THE RUBY RULE, AND PETER SINGER’S 1972 PAPER</p><p>There’s a variant of the Diamond Rule that I liked, for a while. I’ll call it the Ruby Rule:</p><blockquote>[DON’T] let anyone (“the former”) do unto anyone (“the latter”) what the latter [DON’T] wish done to themselves (unless the latter have already done to others what those others did not wish).</blockquote><p>Don’t let someone assault or bully others. Don’t let the police be brutal. Don’t tolerate famine. There is a place for all of those. Conversely, this Ruby Rule also says to not let anyone do unto yourself as you don’t wish done, because you are “anyone” too, and so the Ruby Rule clearly advocates boundaries. There’s nothing wrong with any of that; indeed it’s DESCRIPTIVE of what many people think, although they don’t DO it (what does “We stand with Ukraine” mean, physically; who’s “we”). The question is, do I want to make that PRESCRIPTIVE, as if everyone SHOULD behave like that? I choose not to go there, for several reasons. In short, I called it the Ruby Rule because it implicitly advocates a lot of blood.</p><p>1. There is no OBLIGATION (anymore?) to place yourself in harm’s way to STOP anyone doing harm unto others, so I’m not going to prescribe that. Some people wish that “men” SHOULD place themselves in harm’s way for “women”’s benefit, but I find that sexist, and in a desired egalitarian context, it’s also hypocritical. Some people think that they should place themselves in harm’s way to stop Mr Putin doing unto Ukraine; they’re free to volunteer; again, I’m not going to prescribe that. (If I did prescribe that, we should also all be defending Iran against ITS superpower attacker. But I’m not seeing any “We stand with Iran” lawn signs.) This line of thinking leads to the observation that there is a lot of “doing unto others” that should ideally not be happening, and my Ruby Rule would then expect everyone everywhere to prevent all of that. “All for one, and one for all!” It would be great if they/we did, but it’s not PRESCRIBABLE.</p><p>2. If there were a moral obligation to stop unwanted behavior, that would ignore the potential consequences. I don’t think I should save a stranger from an attack, only to leave my own wife without a husband, and my own children without a father. Hence, I can at-most prescribe a careful situation assessment and plan of engagement and escape (that’s first-responder language). The media never sees past the hero-who-got-lucky to the potential disaster.</p><p>3. Suppose that everyone believes the Ruby Rule, and therefore I put on a bullet-proof vest and “get physical” about stopping an assault. Now I’m committing an assault myself, and under the Ruby Rule, everyone is obliged to stop me. And then everyone is obliged to stop them, etc. It’s an infinite regress, which is a clear sign that the Ruby Rule needs some restriction.</p><p>4. Morality comes with expectations, and my Ruby Rule sets expectations in the wrong place. For example, when we all believe that “Thou shalt not kill,” it’s not necessary to thank everyone for not killing me. Under the Ruby Rule, we should all be fighting in Ukraine, and it wouldn’t be necessary to thank us for doing that. Nah, that’s just a wrong answer.</p><p>5. Last but not least, I’m deprecating my Ruby Rule because I don’t wish to say what anyone / everyone else SHOULD and SHOULD-NOT. If I did that, I’d be making a hypocrite of myself.</p><p>In passing, one <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer">Peter Singer</a> wrote a paper in 1972 called “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famine,_Affluence,_and_Morality">Famine, Affluence, and Morality</a>”. In it, he argues that all of us “Western” people, being well-off relative to much of the world, are evil, for not doing what we easily could, to alleviate suffering in the rest of the world. He begins with a postulate that if you CAN alleviate great suffering, without sacrificing anything of moral significance, then you have a moral obligation to alleviate. That postulate is controversial, but I’ve heard it said that no-one has proved or disproved it. I just did disprove it, by applying Mr Singer’s postulate to violent crime instead of famine, and then showing that the Ruby Rule’s moral obligation to alleviate the victim actually leads to a cycle of violence (point 3 just above). More generally, I’ve just proved that there is NOT a general moral obligation to alleviate suffering. I don’t owe everyone who calls themselves a victim, unless they’re a victim of something *I* did. If there is a moral obligation (to help) to be salvaged, it must be restricted in a different way.</p><p>Can we recover some of what’s RIGHT about the Ruby Rule?</p><p>THE SHIELD RULE</p><p>The foregoing discussion might be viewed, very abstractly, as considering a rule</p><p>[DON’T] let X do unto Y what Y [DON’T] wish done to Y (unless Y has already mis-treated others)</p><p>where X and Y are either “anyone/they/them” or “yourself/you/yourself”, with the former set of people including yourself. Then there can be four such rules (each one containing a pair that is formed by excluding or including the DON’Ts):</p><p>0 | X = anyone | Y = anyone/they/them | the Ruby Rule, WRONG</p><p>1 | X = yourself | Y = anyone/they/them | the Diamond Rule</p><p>2 | X = anyone | Y = yourself/you/yourself | the Shield Rule</p><p>3 | X = yourself | Y = yourself/you/yourself | subsumed</p><p>We ruled out Rule #0 for creating a cycle of violence. We don’t strictly need Rule #3 because it’s a special case of all of Rules #0 — #2, but it’s worth noticing that (a) many people let themselves abuse themselves, or (b) don’t let themselves be kind to themselves. I’ve long had Rule #3 for myself, in the form “Don’t be stupid (especially when you want to be)”, so it’s interesting to find it here as a moral issue, derivable 3 ways! We’ve discussed Rule #1 the Diamond Rule. We now discover Rule #2, the Shield Rule, as a restriction of the Ruby Rule, and as a complement to the Diamond Rule: You may refuse to let others mistreat you. That can be unwise, but at least it’s not morally wrong.</p><p>A too-concise synthesis of the Shield Rule and the Diamond Rule, together, might be</p><blockquote>May I help us (without victimizing anyone who’s not a victimizer)?</blockquote><p>A COMPLETE ETHIC THAT DOESN’T SAY “YOU SHOULD”</p><p>At the end of Part 1, I advocated to “ditch” everyone else’s SHOULDs and SHOULD-NOTs, thus creating an ethic-hole criminals could walk through, claiming they’re “only creating themselves”. By defining the Diamond Rule, I have closed that hole, not in the obvious way — saying what everyone SHOULD and SHOULD-NOT — but with the “unless” clause of the Diamond Rule: Those who victimize others can have their own consent violated.</p><p>Not once did I say that anyone else SHOULD or SHOULD-NOT anything. My Diamond Rule says only what *I* SHOULD and SHOULD-NOT, and I’m taking that upon myself voluntarily. In other words, I’m choosing to lead by example. What you do, is on you.</p><p>NOT ANOTHER ETHIC-HOLE, LEADING BACK TO THE POINT</p><p>By beginning my Diamond Rule with “… let yourself …”, I seem to be question-begging: When I have the option of letting myself do what someone else wants, by what ethic do I decide whether-or-not to do it? For example, if I perceive that someone wants me to lie to them, may I? Or, is there perhaps another ethic that applies to me regardless of what anyone wants? There could be many suitable ethics: I might agree to the lie-ee’s wish, as I don’t know everything about their situation, and they might even be right that, in their plight, ignorance is better. Or, I might know enough to diagnose that, in this case, avoiding the truth will lead to more suffering later, in which case I might decline to do what they want, and (gently) tell them the truth they DON’T want (utilitarian). Or, I might refuse to lie because “You shall not bear false witness” (deontological) — which, by the way, is not about lying in general, it’s about lying in a court, leading to injustice. Given those options, I don’t even know that I would always do the same thing. Therefore I feel obliged to not answer this question, because, again, there is no NEED to PRESCRIBE. My over-riding concerns, already expressed in the Diamond Rule, are to factor-in what others wish done to themselves, and to leave everyone maximal freedom to create themselves (per <a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/the-meaning-of-life-part-1-834f9d9d2498">Part 1 of this series</a>), UNLESS that harms others than themselves, and even then, I’m not (always) obliged to intervene.</p><p>Polluting our Earth is an example of harming others. Indeed, the Industrial Revolution — based on burning fossil fuels (starting with coal) — was always a colossal exercise of privatizing profits while ignoring or distributing the costs: black lung disease, mine cave-ins and floods, gas poisoning, steam engine explosions, coal fog, mine scars on the Earth, toxic run-off, gas emissions. Focusing on the latter: Carbon dioxide being a greenhouse gas was discovered by Eunice Foote (1856) and John Tyndall (1859). By 1898, Svante Arrhenius (a Nobel Prize winner) had deduced that the Industrial Revolution would warm up the planet. And there are many other pollutions, all of which are called “externalities” by the field of economics — in other words, they’re costs not being priced in, they’re damages borne by people who aren’t benefiting from the industry, people who “don’t wish [that damage] done to themselves”. If “we” had bargained with them about what “we” wished, the damage to them would’ve been front-and-center, remediating those damages might’ve eaten-up “our” profits, and/or “we” might’ve been obliged to be sustainable, from Day 1. The Diamond Rule is strongly aligned with environmental justice. The Diamond Rule might’ve saved the world. (The Silver Rule was too ego-centric to do that.)</p><p>If we were ever to encounter an alien intelligent species, I would hope that they, and we, would abide by the Diamond Rule, i.e. not do to us/them what we/they don’t wish done to our/themselves. One wonders if that’s what other aliens are already doing with us, while they’re waiting for us to figure it out. And perhaps God is doing that, as well.</p><p>— — — — — — — — — —</p><p>Matthew 7: “Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you. Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye? How can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when all the time there is a plank in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye.” — Jesus, also NOT saying “You SHOULDN’T say ‘You SHOULDN’T’ ” !</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8479610a427" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Meaning Of Life, Part 1: Create Yourself]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/the-meaning-of-life-part-1-834f9d9d2498?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/834f9d9d2498</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[individuality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Jan 2026 23:35:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T05:19:35.353Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>You have no other choice, anyway.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5EOaGVrtRRLnJOR6" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@neom?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">NEOM</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>“What is the meaning of life?” This is a terribly vague question, which is why it has been discussed forever, and every direct answer is unsatisfactory. Let’s start by asking, What on earth does that mean?</p><p>If you ask “What is the meaning of all (bacterial and plant and animal) life on Earth?”, you start to see what’s wrong with the original question. You might only care about bacterial and plant life because it supports animal life, including humans, including you.</p><p>We might even ask, What about viruses? They’re not even alive, they’re just biochemicals, like tiny dust from bigger life, and they’re mostly not good for anything or anyone, but here they are. Do viruses have “meaning”? Sometimes when you “fill in the gaps” in the original question, you come across extremes you never thought of before, that might very well affect the answer. In this case, viruses seem oddly in conflict with the idea of “meaning”, which is a clue.</p><p>The “meaning” of life implies that there must be some observer to whom “life” has a “meaning”, like there are hearers to whom language has meaning. Thinking of viruses, you immediately see the possibility that “life” and language don’t really have “meaning” in-and-of-themselves, they only have “meaning” to some observer. If the “meaning” of “life” is indeed like the “meaning” of language, heaven help us, for language can be meaningless, e.g. every language you don’t understand, and languages like Sumerian or Mayan, that specialists have to spend centuries decoding. As Ludwig Wittgenstein concluded after a life-time of hard examination of language(s), “Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must remain silent.” He didn’t mean “Shut up”, he meant, “Words have no physical meanings, and conversely, many things can’t be said at all.”</p><p>And in passing, is there “the” meaning of life like there is “the” human body, as if everyone is the same??</p><p>So, “the meaning of life” is just a terrible question. Let’s try replacing “meaning” with something similar but less vague, like “purpose”? “Purpose” of life, like “meaning”, still presumes that there is an intelligent agent somewhere, with that “purpose” in their mind — but “purpose” injects something more active than mere “meaning” and passive observation. Does this sharpened question feel like it’s on the right track to what you really want to know?</p><p>What is the “purpose” of viruses? To inflict disease and/or speed up evolution? Maybe, but I don’t think that’s what you were asking. Do you like, What is “the” “purpose” of “life”? There’s an obvious answer to that: More life! This planet has suffered multiple mass-extinction catastrophes, but every time, life re-blankets the planet in no-time (geologically speaking). A lot of humans have “the purpose of life”, too: Have a baby. Of course we do, we ARE “life”. Having babies is just what animal life does. It does that even when we wish it wouldn’t. Gophers that eat my veggies, swarms of termites and flocks of parrots that destroy my house, plagues of locusts, accidental babies. That’s “life”.</p><h4>Let’s Drill Down</h4><p>“The meaning/purpose of life” also ask us, “In whose head(s) does that purpose exist?” God’s? Yours? Other people’s? The entire human race’s? Let’s immediately reject the notion that there is any “purpose” in the heads of the entire human race. There is nothing the entire human race agrees on, besides the survival of their own small groups. Even “the entire human race” is practically unidentifiable, given all the variety, Siamese twins, unlikely fringes and mutants, damaged and sick brains — people and behavior you’d never imagine. There are strange varieties of human-like beings that existed in the past, and others will exist in the future, if we don’t go extinct. If you really want to know what the vast varieties of humans think the “purpose” of human life is, you clearly can’t ask them all, so the question becomes futile.</p><p>Maybe God has a purpose for “human life”, but what’s that got to do with you?</p><p>So we come to, the purpose TO YOU of “human life”. I merely presume that if I have any kind of purpose, then other humans do, too. Do they have a purpose TO ME? Does the whole world exist just so it can give me whatever I want? That belief has gone by many names over the last 70 years, such as, the power of positive thinking, envisionment, believing in “abundance”, the law of attraction, manifestation mastery, quantum consciousness — it’s all the same thing: If you expect it, some people might give it to you. The motivational speakers who teach this don’t say “some people might”, they say “the universe WILL (give it to you)”, but I know from experience that Nature doesn’t care what I want. I still get sick, computers mis-behave regardless of how clear I am about what I want, scared squirrels bite me even if I’m trying to save their lives, and billions of people on this planet don’t know I exist. So, if I have wants, they’re only going to be fulfilled by accident, or by my efforts, or by “some people”. Even some people who said they loved me, reacted to almost-everything I wanted as if I was wrong to want it. I learn from such things.</p><p>Is the “purpose” of human life to make us learn, like it or not? I observe that some people utterly refuse to learn from me, even when I’m very clear we’re coming to a bad end. Some people think that if I say anything they don’t like, it couldn’t possibly be true, I “must have” malignant motives. IF (IF) the “purpose” of human life is to make us learn, why are so many of us willfully failing? Anyway, the purpose TO ME of “human life” is a pretty self-centered question and leads to weirdness, as you see.</p><p>That leaves the “purpose” of YOUR life, as understood by God, or you, or a FEW other people. If there is a purpose for your life in God’s mind, why didn’t He tell you what it is? That’s so passive of Him that it seems deliberately unhelpful! Some of you may think that the Bible gives us an answer, but the Bible was written long before you existed. If that contains the “purpose” of YOUR life, it has to be a purpose that’s much more general than just you-here-and-now.</p><p>What is the purpose of MY life TO a few other people? The real answer is, Unless they tell me out loud, I’d be making it up. I’m not interested in organizing my life around “what other people might think of me”. That leads to manipulation, pretense, fabrication, fear of being caught out, and an endless list of things I SHOULD and should not do, all of which I’ve merely fantasized into other people’s heads. To avoid that, I could ASK people what they REALLY think of me… but “No, I can’t do THAT, that’d be awkward!” That’s one way to never be wrong, just become delusional.</p><p>And now, the only option left is, the purpose TO ME of MY life. Ah, doesn’t that feel like it’s making sense, at last. I can even be active about that — I can CHOOSE my purpose(s)! Since I’ve always been interested-to-excited about mathematics/physics/control systems, maybe the purpose of my life is, to make some novel things work. Why not? Why can’t the purpose of my life be, whatever I DECIDE to do with it — or even, whatever I DO with it, decided or not?</p><p>At this point, some of you will be thinking, But what about having a family, isn’t that a “purpose” for everyone? Firstly, if you like yours, you have no idea how lucky you got. Secondly, mind your own business: What seems good to you is not a SHOULD for everyone else. Reproduction is common because we’re all “life”, but there are always exceptions. Thirdly, “family” is pretending that a natural process is a blessing. We’ve got human reproduction under control now, but many of our attitudes are still stuck 200 years ago, when we had no choice but to accept whatever came and call it a “blessing”. Today, why advocate a ubiquitous reproduction process that even mice and mosquitoes can do? I was born into a “family” I ran away from, because it became life-threatening (to keep it short). Your parents, siblings, and children are never your choice, and often not what you’d want. Some children fight for assets before their parents are even gone. Some spouses turn into a different person the day you say “I do”. Some of us don’t get lucky, and when there is no hope left, it’d be self-destructive to still make “family” be “the purpose” of our lives; only exploitative “family” would demand that from you. Friends, on the other hand, and a spouse who is a friend — “the family we choose” — that’s a whole different thing. And that takes us right back to, What I DECIDE.</p><h4>I Am Who I Am</h4><p>Why WOULDN’T it be the right answer that the purpose of my life is, just, to be me? Here we all are, each of us completely unique in the entire history of the universe. Nobody else will live in all the same times and places, ever, in all eternity. Because I’m unique, I’m quite likely to experience something no-one else has experienced, see something no-one else has seen, come out with something novel and useful to others. To the extent that we keep our eyes open and dare to say what we observe, being unique is inevitable. So sad that so many people try to force-fit everyone — including themselves — into whatever they think the world SHOULD be.</p><p>Of course, if I DECIDE to make something my “life’s purpose”, I might succeed at it, and sometimes, succeeding is quite the rush, especially if it has taken a whole life-time to accomplish it. If I were to take MY experience of such a rush as “proving” to me what my purpose is, that purpose is, to build something unique and have it really work. I didn’t get into building spacecraft for any noble purpose, like, so that y’all can discover something about the universe and humanity’s place in it; that’s just how it turned out (I did very deliberately choose JPL). But I don’t NEED to decide that that’s my purpose. Maybe the purpose of my life is, to serve as a warning to others! I think that the purpose of my life is just, to be me, to experience and say and do whatever that turns out to be. Maybe God doesn’t tell each-of-us-specifically what the purpose of our life is, because He’s carefully leaving it up to each of us to create ourselves. Indeed, we MUST create ourselves, BECAUSE we are all unique and have no other choice. Create yourself, or let yourself be run-over by SHOULDs coming from others. (Some people are chock-full of SHOULDs. If you let them, they’ll take over your life; if you push back, they’ll blame you for it; you lose until you walk away.) On the contrary, why SHOULD I care about other people’s SHOULDs, and why SHOULD they care about mine? To each, his/her own; live and let live. “Leaders” and influencers, I don’t need you; I create myself. I “make a difference” and “show the world” without even trying — as we all could.</p><p>And what’s with the common fear, or guilt, that you’ve failed to do something you SHOULD’ve? Get to the bottom of all the SHOULDs, even your own SHOULDs to yourself. If you still worry that you’ve treated someone unnecessarily badly, you can try to fix that, and then there’ll be one less SHOULD.</p><p>What is the purpose of your life? In my opinion, it is, to create your life, whatever that may be. No pressure, literally. Every other answer is inapplicable.</p><p>(I think I can help and/or educate a person or two; maybe even, help to re-design the future of humanity on this planet.)</p><p>(In this essay I’ve deliberately left-out thinking about people to whom our laws/SHOULDs are inconvenient impediments for exploiting people, or for a life of crime. This becomes the issue driving Part 2.)</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/the-meaning-of-life-part-2-creating-an-ethic-e8479610a427">The Meaning Of Life, Part 2: Creating An Ethic</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=834f9d9d2498" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Wish You A Medium Christmas!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fourth-wave/i-wish-you-a-medium-christmas-1ed69f441a83?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1ed69f441a83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[equality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Dec 2024 11:01:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-31T17:57:52.922Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>And I’d like to propose a roast of 2024</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RehVKgHZOqQDJ2YFs2GizA.png" /><figcaption>Composed by the author</figcaption></figure><p>Before proceeding with the roast, I feel obliged to explain where I’m coming from.</p><p><strong>Feminist Type 1, a.k.a. egalitarian or humanitarian:</strong> Someone who regards all people as human and deserving of equal rights, opportunities, <em>and obligations</em>.</p><p><strong>Feminist Type 2, a.k.a. partisan:</strong> Someone who pulls for rights and opportunities they want, regardless of whether their rights and opportunities now exceed those of men; regardless of ongoing obligations only on men (a.k.a. “buffet equality”); regardless of the fact that every ideology is cruel to some, and every giant generalization is riddled with ambiguity and exceptions (e.g. “the patriarchy,” and “generational wealth,” which I will never get 1c of); regardless of whether statistics are biased, mis-stated, or mis-interpreted (e.g. by the Gender Equity Policy Institute); and regardless of what most men have to suffer, in the past, present or future.</p><p>I’m absolutely feminist Type 1; I’m absolutely not feminist Type 2. As feminist Type 1, I have little respect for the Men With Microphones driving the manosphere. Nevertheless, I still have lots of sympathy for the young men who are being misled and suckered by the Men With Microphones, hence my suggestion that women could corner the dating market, and then could impose a mutually beneficial price for admission, 2/3 down in this essay:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/i-wish-i-could-trust-men-50cd418281b0">“I Wish I Could Trust Men!”</a></p><p>And now, ladies and gentlemen! For your holiday amusement: a round of jokes roasting feminism Type 2, because that’s what came at me in 2024, through the feeds from medium.com, where young women have been much more numerous and strident than young men. It’s supposed to be satire; I’ve found that it comes across funnier if read out loud (much slower). I hope that you-all can take it, and maybe even say “point taken” sometimes. Enjoy! Happy holidays, and I wish you a happier 2025!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qXnQ-cka5Huc69ip" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@juniorferreir_?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Júnior Ferreira</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>How Many Feminists Does It Take To Screw In A Lightbulb?</h4><p>· None, because the lightbulb has to want to change itself.</p><p>· 1, because men can be feminists too. (This is an old one.)</p><p>· Empowered women can screw as many lightbulbs as they want!</p><h4>· 42, because we’re playing for Life, the Universe, and Everything:</h4><p>1. one to suggest the whole “screwing” bit is too “rape-like,”</p><p>2. one to deconstruct the lightbulb as being phallic,</p><p>3. one to maintain that “men are trash,” so, when “trash” men become trans women and then make lightbulbs much faster than cis women, that must be stopped (biology cannot be allowed to refute ideology),</p><p>4. one to speculate that men may make lightbulbs because men have darkness within them,</p><p>5. one to conclude that men only make lightbulbs for other men, that’s why they’re so fragile near women,</p><p>6. one to blame men for merely using and discarding lightbulbs,</p><p>7. one to re-conceptualize the use of lightbulbs as domination,</p><p>8. one to blame men for inventing such a faulty means of illumination,</p><p>9. one to blame men for even creating the need for illumination,</p><p>10. one to blame men for discouraging women from changing lightbulbs,</p><p>11. one to blame men for expecting women to change lightbulbs,</p><p>12. one to blame men for making women change too many lightbulbs,</p><p>13. one to blame men for inventing a means of illumination that requires unpaid labor to change lightbulbs,</p><p>14. one to ensure that women who get their lives paid-for by men are viewed as “free lives” and hence “unpaid labor” (not free to the men, but men’s costs don’t count ‘cos they’re the oppressor, OK?),</p><p>15. one to compute how much men owe women for thousands of years of unpaid labor, changing lightbulbs, assuming that all those women were homeless and starving, and should’ve been paid as licensed electricians,</p><p>16. one to point out that men are still handing over their entire life’s wages to their wives, how sad that men are still stuck on being “providers,”</p><p>17. one to deny that a woman electrician should give her entire life’s wages to her spouse, like men electricians do,</p><p>18. one to wonder why men don’t stop stupidly working for their families, when they should be working on their feeling and empathy instead [with what paid-for time, in case this isn’t obvious],</p><p>19. one to allege that men changing lightbulbs “have had it all” for thousands of years,</p><p>20. one to say “Oh boo-hoo” when men point out that they weren’t here a thousand years ago, there were no lightbulbs a thousand years ago, and lightbulb manufacturing was never anyone’s dream job,</p><p>21. one to want any job EXCEPT lightbulb manufacturing,</p><p>22. one to blame men for keeping women out of lightbulb manufacturing,</p><p>23. one to demand becoming CEO of Lightbulb Corp without ever working for Lightbulb Corp,</p><p>24. one to diagnose how lightbulbs are because of the patriarchy,</p><p>25. one to head up the proud new Women’s Department of Women’s Illumination Studies For Women,</p><p>26. one to forget that that sexism, and men paying for women’s lives, and scholarships for women only, and affirmative action, ever happened, so as to then claim that “women pulled themselves up, and men should, too,” and proudly rename the Department to, Gender Studies, while color-blindly ignoring the differences between white &amp; black &amp; indigenous &amp; other peoples,</p><p>27. one to forget that deliberate lack of discrimination, and rename the Department to, Intersectionality, now advocating for everyone in proportion to their victimhood, except straight white men,</p><p>28. one to award the lightbulb precisely 3.4 victim points for not being straight AND not being white AND not being a man,</p><p>29. one to make the men of the Lightbulb Workers Union attend a mandatory lecture about “white male privilege,”</p><p>30. one to say “Cry me a river” when the Lightbulb Workers Union responds that they’re WORKERS who never had authority to hire or fire anyone, and they’re 50% Black, and they waste their lives making lightbulbs, only to give their entire life’s wages to women, so who’s privileged now,</p><p>31. one to point out that if you sum the wealth and power of Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg, Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, and the King of England, and average it out over all white men everywhere, then every white male is massively privileged, how can you argue with that,</p><p>32. one to quietly ignore the Lightbulb Workers Union when they respond that if you average the Earth’s water wealth over the entire surface of the Earth, we’re all swimming in it 1.6 miles (2.6 km) deep, and yet, here we all are, high and dry and SO NOT swimming in it, how can you argue with that,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RehVKgHZOqQDJ2YFs2GizA.png" /><figcaption>Composed by the author</figcaption></figure><p>33. one to ask a man to change the lightbulb, give up waiting, and blog about it,</p><p>34. one to shame all the men reading her blog (regardless of the cost to herself), to please stop being dim bulbs and just “step up,”</p><p>35. one to mock men who change lightbulbs by using their muscles instead of their brains,</p><p>36. one to just do it herself,</p><p>37. one to make a video of it, and post it as evidence that men are unnecessary,</p><p>38. one to alert the media that women are now out-lightbulbing men,</p><p>39. one to say that only silly men would think that “men” means #AllMen,</p><p>40. one to say that the Pelicot case proves that “men” DOES mean #AllMen,</p><p>41. one to say that men are now so confused that they’re even wishing for tradbulbs when they could have us — not!</p><p>42. one to form a 4Bamerica movement: No choosing dim bulbs, No bringing home dim bulbs, No turning on dim bulbs, No making more dim bulbs. (And no resemblance to Men Going Their Own Way, either.)</p><p>Please charge your glasses…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EhueUwKaK7j9RZRF" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@skylakestudio?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Quan Nguyen</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>In Case You Missed It</h4><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/out-of-the-animal-trap-83f5139bde90">Out Of The Animal Trap</a></p><p><em>For more stories like this you probably should not follow </em><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave">Fourth Wave,</a><em> since this is a definite one off. But if you’ve got a story or poem that focuses on women or other disempowered groups, s</em><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/submit-to-the-wave-7c92f095e86f"><em>ubmit to the Wave!</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1ed69f441a83" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/i-wish-you-a-medium-christmas-1ed69f441a83">I Wish You A Medium Christmas!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave">Fourth Wave</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“I Wish I Could Trust Men!”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fourth-wave/i-wish-i-could-trust-men-50cd418281b0?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/50cd418281b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dating]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence-prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[understanding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Dec 2024 11:01:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-16T14:32:48.154Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Some are criminals, but there are many devices and tactics women can use for safety</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ITkkKz2lvER22NcsoXuRzQ.png" /><figcaption>Graphic by the author</figcaption></figure><p><em>Summary: The title of this article, and many discussions of sexual assaults, have appeared on Medium recently. I’m completely convinced it’s a huge problem, and has been a huge problem for millennia. I not only sympathize, I empathize. The unfortunate short-answer is that no-one can identify future criminals and prevent them. However, the situation is not hopeless. #1 There are surprisingly many defensive options, available to women, some of which have elicited reactions that need to be re-considered. #2 A whole new option becomes available if/when enough women stop dating. #3 To get as constructive as possible, I also consulted my wife. She has been sexually assaulted several times. The part that came from her is the final section, “Meet My Melanie.”</em></p><p>Here is a sampling of the conversations about sexual assault that came my way through the daily feeds in the last half-year. I presume there is much more, including how to deal/help with it.</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/women-choose-bears-over-men-and-theres-one-reason-for-it-d0482868a81b">Women Choose Bears Over Men and There’s One Reason For It</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@mayastrong/the-myth-of-the-good-ones-09a9d2168932">The Myth of the “Good Ones”</a></li><li><a href="https://praisedominic1997.medium.com/it-is-all-men-ce4c797e5add">IT IS ALL MEN</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@tommytuba/why-men-dont-talk-about-rape-d0a2debaeb80">Why Men Don’t Talk About Rape</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/liberty-76/we-are-asking-the-wrong-question-in-the-horrifying-pelicot-rape-case-a67b790c5cab">We Are Asking the Wrong Question in the Horrifying Pelicot Rape Case</a></li><li><a href="https://madelainehanson.medium.com/the-masculinity-i-admire-and-why-so-many-modern-men-have-lost-our-respect-40eda5fb7198">The masculinity I admire: and why so many modern men have lost our respect</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@author.PoojaPatil/dear-men-30bbae218c0a">Dear Men,</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/the-diarist/what-women-truly-mean-when-they-say-we-hate-men-ddb60686f67a">What Women Truly Mean When They Say “We Hate Men”</a></li><li><a href="https://madelainehanson.medium.com/men-need-to-understand-that-its-not-1-in-a-1000-men-it-s-more-like-1-in-4-22a7fe1faafa">Men need to understand that it’s not “1 in a 1000 men”: it’s more like 1 in 4</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/write-a-catalyst/how-body-keeps-the-score-44c334c4ee13">How Body Keeps The Score</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/wokeup/all-men-are-rapists-and-thats-all-they-are-e9aad7499eb1">“All Men Are Rapists and That’s All They Are”</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/saoirse-ronan-shows-the-world-is-different-for-women-3b3555e5e11e">Saoirse Ronan Shows the World is Different for Women</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/write-a-catalyst/list-of-defence-strategies-i-had-to-learn-as-a-little-girl-e3188406bcda">List of defence strategies I had to learn as a little girl</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/write-a-catalyst/my-friend-has-been-raped-by-our-friend-6b423f31c193">My friend has been raped by… our friend.</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/modern-women/what-men-dont-understand-about-women-and-sexual-harassment-e0d2ecee1444">What Men Don’t Understand About Women and Sexual Harassment</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/write-a-catalyst/history-will-teach-you-there-were-all-such-willing-wives-6b3ddb2310d3">History will teach you there were “all such willing wives”</a></li></ul><h4>What it’s like to be assaulted</h4><p>I empathize, because I was bullied for four years, ages 12–15. In a school of 400 kids, there were five routine bullies, and another five who would pick fights occasionally. (I’m speaking of boys. There were a similar number of female bullies.) There was a gang on the school bus who hit people so hard that people arrived at school in tears, every single day. The bullies hit people on the way home, too. So I avoided the bus, and started walking to and from school, and riding my bike, even in rainstorms. Of course the same bullies were at school, and I got broken lips, a hurt nose, a black eye or two, kicked legs, and stomped-on toes. Since they were either twice my weight, or came three bullies at a time, I knew better than to fight back on-the-spot.</p><p>Another victim was less strategic. He lashed out angrily once, and later found himself isolated in a field near the school, surrounded by a circle of about 20 boys. I recognized the boy who was surrounded, realized what was going on, and fetched a teacher, who shouted, picked them up bodily, and threw them away. I expect he’d be fired for that today, and that’s a hint. (See the first paragraph below under the heading “There are useful answers.”)</p><p>My mother sent me to judo and karate classes. I hated learning how to hurt people. Eventually, one of the bullies picked on me, the time was right, and I rapidly pinned him to the ground. None of the other bullies came at me to rescue him, much to my surprise. After a teacher arrived, I walked to the principal’s office, shaking and crying, from the distress of having to defend myself, over literally nothing, despite having won, quickly and gently. From then on, I was left alone.</p><blockquote>I empathize, because I was bullied for four years, ages 12–15. In a school of 400 kids, there were five routine bullies, and another five who would pick fights occasionally.</blockquote><p>When I posted these memories to Facebook, I learned that there was similar bullying going on among the girls, with fists and all. I didn’t know about that until I asked, 40 years after-the-fact. What you discover! — when you allow that you don’t know everything.</p><p>Today, in the US, men report domestic violence about half as often as women (see the NIH web page linked below), but men are more likely to not report at all because they expect to be (a) mocked, for not defending themselves from a woman, or (b) jailed, if they do defend themselves. But you never hear that balance; you only hear young women pushing #AlwaysMen. False! Men get hit too, by their wives.</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK499891/">Domestic Violence</a></p><p>After handling the bullies at school, and after fleeing from a paranoid-schizophrenic father who said he’d have to shoot us all, I found myself almost always drifting off to sleep with my teeth clenched and my heart pounding, and with my own head inventing violence/disaster scenarios in which I had to quickly figure out what to do. Where would I run/kick/hit/shoot? It was like self-inflicted combat training, every night. After 25 years of that, I finally thought, <em>Maybe I don’t have to do this?</em> And then I found that I could interrupt it through deep breathing, and thinking of something else.</p><p>For me, the bullying stopped in my last year at that high-school. For women everywhere, there may or may not be actual assaults, but the risk doesn’t go away for decades.</p><p>I don’t know what it’s like to be sexually assaulted. There are shades of it, from standing too close, to an unwanted kiss, to a grope, to rape and/or knife wounds, to broken bones, to murder. I can definitely understand that some cases can take decades to cope with.</p><h4>“Look at me (a woman) as a human being”</h4><p>I always have looked at women as human beings. I don’t think I’m unusual in this. On the other hand, I do perceive that many GenZ men have gone off the rails, due to the manosphere on social media, and online pornography. More precisely, what comes through cell phones and social media is a tiny sliver of reality that leaves people not even knowing what-all they don’t know anymore.</p><p>Goodbye the lesson of unintentionally breaking things; goodbye nonverbal clues to other people’s feelings; goodbye body language altogether; often even goodbye tones of voice; goodbye disagreements being handled politely; goodbye disagreements being opportunities to understand; goodbye hanging-in long conversations to figure out where feelings came from; and goodbye empathy, especially for strangers.</p><p>In my early teens I was struck by how much of people was invisible, like an unknown cake completely hidden under icing. I expect that I came to this from observing my paranoid-schizophrenic father and stone-wall mother. Almost everything that’s important cannot be seen, nor heard. People’s experiences may be voluntarily shared, but that was taboo not long ago; my mother (born 1926) wouldn’t elaborate to me even when I asked her to. I wished there was a snapshot for personalities (Myers-Briggs is crude). Personalities can only be pieced together from long and careful observation, like listening to a classical symphony dozens of times until its themes and structure become clear. Such observation costs precious time. So I’ve always seen (all) people’s bodies as HIDING what I really need to know. Especially if what I don’t know about them might be dangerous, toxic, or harmful to my career.</p><blockquote>Almost everything that’s important cannot be seen, nor heard</blockquote><p>Unfortunately, all of us are born ignorant and in fantasyland, a.k.a. delusional (you’ll see that if/when you have children), so there’s no guarantee that what we believe about ourselves is true. 80% of us think we’re above-average drivers, maybe above-average everything, and inclined to self-justify and rationalize, so, what we believe of ourselves can be just as wrong as anything else we believe. Previous generations were not very introspective, or articulate. And some of us are still not very observant, nor analytical, hence never notice our own ego-defensive bubble. Men who offer that they’re “nice” often turn out to be working to prove it, and then they’re not. The same goes for women, and I became a victim of that, but of course most women don’t date other women, so don’t know that everything goes both ways. This experience is why I now strongly believe in “truth before ego,” while admitting that that requires practice and self-discipline, and is no easy thing to detect in others. As a leg-up, see this book:</p><p><a href="https://warrenfarrell.com/product/women-cant-hear-what-men-dont-say/">Women Can&#39;t Hear What Men Don&#39;t Say (Hardcover)</a></p><p>I did have three advantages relative to other men, and I relate these here because they’re partly why Melanie (now my wife) gave me her last chance before giving up on men entirely.</p><ul><li>I’m so analytical that mimicking other people doesn’t come natural. I can’t assume much, nor fake anything. Everything I CAN do, I have to study, and practice. I long wondered if I had a learning disability, but in other ways it has served me very well, e.g. in understanding people and relationships, and in engineering.</li><li>I’ve lived in three countries. In my second country, at the age of eight, I observed that cultures/customs are strait-jackets, and I often opted out. In my third country (the US) I felt permanently foreign. I don’t get embarrassed anymore: your expectations are not my problem. This paid off in my early teens, when the bullies on the school-bus taunted each other about being “real men”, and I thought, <em>“Bullshit. Whatever I become IS a real man. Why would I (a) let you take that away from me, and then (b) jump through YOUR hoops to get it back?”</em> So I’ve never cared what “masculinity” means, nor “femininity” either.</li><li>When I was 16, I encountered God, and for the next several years, words I’d heard from the New Testament came back to me, unsolicited. One of those sayings was <em>“You shall love your neighbor as yourself,”</em> clearly meaning all humans. Another was Jesus saying, more specifically, <em>“Everyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart.”</em> So I did my best to avoid that sin. I had no time to fool around, either: I spent my teens and 20s desperately investing in my career. Call me naïve and inexperienced if you like; I was, and I’m very fine with that.</li></ul><h4><strong>But here’s the problem</strong></h4><p>If there had been any electronic communications way back when I was in high-school (1970–73), I might’ve thought to write an article asking my schoolmates for help, just as some women today write articles wishing they could trust men. Obviously, my bullies were only a tiny fraction of the class (not #AllMen). And the girls’ bullies were girls (not #AlwaysMen). I might’ve hoped that it’s ALL MEN’s responsibility to stop the bullies, but that would not have helped me then, and it doesn’t help today, for the same reason: The men reading these articles are not the ones doing the bullying/assaulting, and the men doing the bullying/assaulting don’t care. Thus, articles asking men to help, have the unfortunate effect that only the ones who do care are the ones who feel blamed/shamed for crimes they never committed. More of that, doesn’t help.</p><p>I’m also sorry to have to point out that asking men to prevent bullies/assaulters is a disconnect. Just as I can’t prevent thieves in random places, I can’t prevent any crime unless it’s being perpetrated against me, or next to me.</p><p>This conversation might benefit by calling people who commit sexual assaults “criminals” rather than “men”. That would instantly make the conversation more pragmatic.</p><h4>There are useful answers</h4><p>While there is probably no way to prevent criminals from existing at all, there is a shocking fact that’s very relevant, and parents might ponder it: Most of the damage, both domestic and terrorist, is done by young men who were raised WITHOUT FATHERS. It’s now known that, in single-parent households, men do (on average) a better job as parents, than women. Much better for boys, slightly better for girls. For details, see Warren Farrell’s 2019 book “The Boy Crisis,” Part IV. One reason is that mothers are inclined to prevent harm to the children, at the parents’ expense, so that the children LEARN NOTHING except that parents will fix it. But fathers will carefully let the children solve their own problem, or hurt themselves, so they do learn — without him having to inflict any punishment. The “natural consequences” might sometimes go so far as to inflict on a child what s/he’s done to others, so that s/he gets some empathy. Mothers who watch fathers do these things tend to call the fathers “bad parents” and “abusive.” But the fathers’ method works better for everyone, yielding children with better self-control and more consideration. The present rash of misbehavior in young adults seems to be caused in part by mothers raising children without fathers.</p><p><strong><em>Well-known defensive options</em></strong>. Some immediate answers to misbehavior against women are well-known, e.g. women can move in groups, or bring a man they trust. Women can scream, carry a bear-siren (!), mace, pepper spray, a rock, a Taser, or a small pistol. Plus, there are self-defense classes. There is a catch-22 in the law, though: injuring or killing anyone, even merely threatening someone with a weapon, without good evidence that it’s self-defense, can be a crime in itself, depending on your jurisdiction. There is a longer list in this article:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/saoirse-ronan-shows-the-world-is-different-for-women-3b3555e5e11e">Saoirse Ronan Shows the World is Different for Women</a></p><p><strong><em>Anti-rape devices</em></strong>. [<a href="https://researchonline.gcu.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/27220392/Innovating_the_problem_away_white_mcmillan.pdf">White &amp; McMillan 2020</a>] is a study of anti-rape devices, from insertable and wearable things thru communication-only apps. This is worth reading for the many options, and for the many HYPOTHETICAL consequences. All the devices are speculated to be at risk of normalizing sexual violence and/or commoditizing women’s safety. As an example I investigated myself: In 2013, a start-up called AR Wear advertised anti-rape (AR) underwear that seemed pragmatic, to me, but the controversy they caused was a circus! Feminist academics immediately attacked them for NOT ALSO producing anti-rape underwear for other genders or children; for dealing only with rape; for assuming that rapes were committed by strangers; for “making” women wear a constant reminder of their vulnerability; for giving society cause to blame women for NOT wearing anti-rape wear at all times; and, someone should just make criminals stop raping. What an astonishing display of “expertise” — “academic” the bad way. In similar style, the police could angrily refuse to wear bullet-proof vests because the police can get shot in the legs too; the vests might normalize cop-killing; and someone should just make criminals stop shooting. No-one dared to say that. Today I can’t find AR Wear as a business. Sigh.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*JOrXFaZc1aZbxN9nuYmjcA.png" /><figcaption>A commercial from AR Wear in 2013</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>PERS / Medical Alerts.</em></strong> There are many companies selling Personal Emergency Response Services (PERS). They almost-all advertise as Medical Alert systems, when in fact they can quickly (within 10–20 seconds of you pushing the panic button) connect you to any emergency service (911 in the US) nearest your present location, wherever that is. If you want the police, you push the panic button, get the service company’s dispatch center, OPTIONALLY talk to a trained operator (via the device), and get forwarded to the nearest police dispatch.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ITkkKz2lvER22NcsoXuRzQ.png" /><figcaption><em>How Personal Emergency Response Services / Medical Alerts work</em></figcaption></figure><p>You could do this faster via cell phone going direct to 911, but the specialized devices and apps have three advantages:</p><p>1. The device can be a pendant or a wrist-band. (The batteries in the pendants are bigger and last 10x longer.) If you’re being threatened or attacked, you could push the panic button by feel, without having to look for it, without making it immediately obvious what you’re doing, and without having the device slapped away from you.</p><p>2. Some of the devices talk to satellites and work even where there’s no cell phone connection. However, this advantage applies only if the service company has integrated such devices into their system.</p><p>3. The “on the go” devices and apps incorporate GPS and/or triangulation from cell phone towers, and automatically tell the dispatch center where you are, within a few meters. That’s how they know which local emergency service to switch you to, and they automatically forward your position to the police as well.</p><p>I found reviews of medical alert (service) companies that said it costs $25–$50/month for this service.</p><p>Here are some complications (I talked to a medical alert sales rep about this). For false alarms, there is no extra charge FROM THE SERVICE COMPANY, but if you summon an ambulance by accident, that’ll cost you. When you push the panic button, the service company’s operator will answer through that same device, but there is no alarm sound from your device. (I was hoping that an optional alarm might tell the attacker immediately that the police are already on their way, without you having to explain that, but I didn’t find such a device. Incorporating an alarm into the devices requires minor re-engineering by the device manufacturers, who are entirely different companies than the service providers.) If the attacker rips the device off you, or destroys it, or prevents you from speaking with the dispatch center, the operator still knows where you are, and contacts the three phone numbers you previously gave them, which could be 911, neighbors, relatives, or friends. The operator may or may not announce loudly-enough that the police are on their way. If the attacker muzzles you and tells the operator that the call was an accident, the operator may or may not notice that the service-customer is female while the person answering is male. The service companies generally don’t record the sound/conversation through your device; such recording only begins when you reach the 911/police dispatch.</p><p>I can’t find a device, or app, that presents a panic button, issues an alarm sound, calls emergency help, sends your position, and begins sound and video recording. The “red panic button” app for (some) cell phones and wearables does most of that. It provides the panic button, no alarm sound, text messages or emails to contacts, position, configurably a call to emergency services, and configurably a short voice and/or video recording can be transmitted. It shouldn’t be hard to make a slightly more capable app, for a wearable? (Immediate transmission of any amount of sound/video is essential to preserve the evidence even if the device itself is stolen or smashed.)</p><blockquote>If an assault is prevented, there is no assault. A THREAT of assault may or may not be punishable in your jurisdiction. Self-defense that does damage, without good self-defense evidence, might be prosecuted . . .</blockquote><p>Unfortunately, in any legal proceeding, evidence is crucial and very problematic, due to “innocent until PROVEN guilty.” If an assault is prevented, there is no assault. A THREAT of assault may or may not be punishable in your jurisdiction. Self-defense that does damage, without good self-defense evidence, might be prosecuted. Recording a conversation without permission may be illegal. An attacker seen leaving might still reduce to he-says-she-says. An actual crime has to happen and make identifying and incriminating (but legal) evidence, to be convicting. So it would seem that deterrence is the primary goal, which might even be achieved by a device or app that is bluffing… unless an assault does occur, then you REALLY want all the evidence.</p><p>I’m in touch with a manufacturer of PERS devices/apps. They will need to be convinced that there’s a market for the device/app I have in mind, assuming (say) current service prices. I understand that the POTENTIAL market is the entire female population, but how many would pay $25 — $50/month? Give me a clue in the Responses.</p><h4>Cornering the dating market</h4><p>Today’s circumstances, and the existence of the 4B movement (women not dating/sleeping/marrying/having children with men), make me realize that women can collectively corner the dating “market” in a way that is potentially beneficial to all concerned. Consider: If there is no other way to get a date, what “price” might a person be willing to pay, to get one? Let’s make that “price” an experience that is beneficial, as follows:</p><p>Before each and every date, the parties are required to sit through a short-ish anti-Red-Pill “lecture” covering such points as: The averages of un-trained competence scores, for men and women, are statistically indistinguishable (see the link just below); we’re all humans with whole lives, not just mobile sex organs; if one wishes to be GIVEN something, one cannot force that, because forcing it makes it theft, or worse; how not to shut-down each other’s different opinions, but explore them; how to have an emotional conversation that is SAFE (see Warren Farrell’s “Women Can’t Hear What Men Don’t Say” linked again below); and, how painful rape is (because young men can’t know). I suggest not to expand the “lecture” to ancient history nor “white male privilege” — just the here-and-now interpersonal.</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/liberty-76/busting-the-myth-that-men-women-are-biological-opposites-113a579839da">Busting the Myth that Men &amp; Women Are Biological Opposites</a></li><li><a href="https://warrenfarrell.com/product/women-cant-hear-what-men-dont-say/">Women Can&#39;t Hear What Men Don&#39;t Say (Hardcover)</a></li></ul><p>Only after this “lecture” can there be a date, WITH A CHAPERONE at some short distance, no expected-kissing and no expected-sex, just safely meeting in a place they can actually talk. The chaperone could be a female friend or a relative, e.g. a retired person eager to be helpful. Chaperones found further afield must be vetted, somehow, to not be a predator themselves.</p><p>This might be called Educational Dating — conditional on agreeing to the above process, AND men cannot bring their own friend nor a weapon, or the date is immediately over. If something goes seriously wrong, the chaperone is an adjudicator/advisor, and a witness, and the offending party might be black-listed or even prosecuted. On the bright side, such a chaperoning service could also convey the parties’ feedback or closure politely, instead of ghosting.</p><p>This idea is a less extreme solution than the 4B movement. Nevertheless, since this idea does rely on scarcity of dating, I wish the 4B movement much success, in hopes that young men and women (who wish to do so) may be “cornered” into understanding each other sooner than later.</p><h4>Meet my Melanie</h4><p>How to handle less violent circumstances, like being wolf-whistled, cat-called, followed, or stared at? Having no experience of this, I consulted my wife.</p><p>My Melanie is a blond beauty. (That’s not what I was looking for, but it’s a very nice bonus.) She used to radiate so bright that when she entered a room, people would stop to look at her. She hated that, never dressed to invite it, never got used to it. She was sexually assaulted several times — unwanted kisses, groping, and a rape. That’s not counting the middle-school guy who used to wait for her so he could punch her on the arm hard enough to cause bruises — until she swung and hit him with her flute-case.</p><p>Here are pictures of my Melanie, at 10-year intervals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YEm8E0a2WnyWx4ot_-rioA.png" /></figure><p>The rest of this essay relates Melanie’s viewpoint. Her response to wolf-whistles and cat-calls is: If you just ignore it, it’s likely to get louder and ruder. Engaging them is what they want, but don’t do that. The best response is to look them in the eye and wave them away. Maybe throw in a sad head-shake and a sigh, no smile. Take a picture of them, for potential future reference. The worker(s) will have all day to worry about it.</p><p>Being followed: If you’re in a car, drive round a block and see if he’s still there. If so, drive to a police or fire station. If you’re on foot and alone, and there’s anyone or anything else in sight, walk up to them while calling the police (so everybody knows what’s going on). If the police pull you over just because they like your looks, and ask for a date (immediately, or by phone later), ask the cop’s name and then tell him you’re going to report him to his superiors, and do that.</p><p>Being stared at is subject to interpretation, she reports. Maybe someone was staring into space and you just happened to walk across their gaze. No matter what the intent was, merely looking them in the eye will usually be sufficient. If they’re ogling your body parts, moving your hands from those parts up to your eyes (“I’m up here”) will interrupt them.</p><p>Having these things happen to her often, as a young woman, she too assumed most men were guilty until she developed these “tools,” then she could figure out if she was right or wrong about someone’s intent. She concluded that not all men are “that kind of man,” and wishes that more women would figure this out and stop pushing “#AllMen,” which is unjust and not helping anyone (she said).</p><h4>In case you missed it</h4><p>Melanie’s and my relationship was a deliberate first-of-its-kind experiment that succeeded, for us:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/out-of-the-animal-trap-83f5139bde90">Out Of The Animal Trap</a></p><p><em>For more stories about rape culture and how to counteract it, follow </em><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave">Fourth Wave</a>.<em> Have you got a story or poem that focuses on women or other disempowered groups? </em><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/submit-to-the-wave-7c92f095e86f"><em>Submit to the Wave!</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=50cd418281b0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave/i-wish-i-could-trust-men-50cd418281b0">“I Wish I Could Trust Men!”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fourth-wave">Fourth Wave</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Versus Religion? “Here, I Am” (Part 5)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-5-0eb3e4dde7fc?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0eb3e4dde7fc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion-and-spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[god]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Nov 2024 23:08:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-07T02:23:15.486Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How I Met God, And Got The Problem Of A Life-Time</h4><p>This year is the 50th anniversary of my meeting a non-physical, transcendent “Someone”. Back in 1974, when I was 16, it was such a powerful experience that I’ve been unable to describe it ever since, without bursting into tears of gratitude, or avoiding that by carefully walking round the edge of it. I finally held myself together and wrote it up in 2014, 40 years after-the-fact.</p><p>I can’t “prove” any of this to anyone. But, if any of our internal life is real, if any experience that can’t be measured is real, if an over-night conversion that’s apparent to everyone in the vicinity is real, then this was real. So real, that I can examine it all these years later, like putting a diamond under a magnifying-glass.</p><p>First, a little context. 1974 was the year we escaped from my father, who had said that he might have to shoot us all (long story, omitted). We went into hiding for a couple of months, still in Launceston and fearing for our lives, then left Tasmania under assumed names (the Stuarts) so my father couldn’t trace us. We landed in Canberra as refugees, with literally nothing, and cast ourselves on the charity of a Christian church. My mother was accommodated by one family, my brother Andrew and I were effectively adopted by a couple of men who were about 26 at the time (thanks forever, Gus De Vries and Mike Steketee). Andrew immediately went to a new school (Deakin High), where he made some new friends, went to a “Christian Revival” event, came home in tears, and called himself a Christian. Mum worried he might be “possessed by the devil” and took him to see the pastor!</p><p>About three weeks later, I considered trying to believe in God, myself. Despite being raised in a household that went to church every Sunday (which I found very boring), me trying to believe in God felt like trying to believe in ghosts — nutso. And it felt like, talking to the walls. “God, if you’re there…” Or maybe I said “Jesus”; I don’t remember that.</p><p>What happened next might be called a vision. FYI I hadn’t had any alcohol nor any drugs in my entire life, and obviously I was not asleep. I had no illnesses I know of. I have no idea how long it lasted; it could’ve been seconds, or hours. The bedroom disappeared, and time stood still.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*emQlBrR7h7Qk7kzJ" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@nitishm?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Nitish Meena</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I found myself on top of a cliff, standing at the very edge, but not nervous (like I would be if this was physical). The ground I stood on, and behind me as far as the eye could see, was a vast, flat plain of dried mud, cracked into irregular tiles. I now know it looked like a dried-up lake-bed, but I’d never seen one, then. In front of me was a “canyon”, so vast that I couldn’t see anything through it, nor beyond it, not even a far horizon. Everywhere in that “canyon” was a glowing orange fog, like a sunset through a haze, except that the sun would’ve had to be well below the horizon and still shining, somehow. And that infinite space was full of a Presence. It was like being brought to the edge of the Earth, to meet this vast Presence.</p><p>Out of that “canyon” came a summons. I remember this like it happened last night. It came all-at-once, in a time-less instant, without any words or even thoughts, and yet with absolute clarity, like an in-divisible diamond. I’m only pretending to describe it, by picking out facets of its meaning.</p><blockquote>I am the light that fills the infinite space before you.<br>I am the knowledge that is not your own.<br>I am the name that has no sound, and I am the meaning in the silence.<br>I am the moment that lasts forever.<br>I am truth without flinching and without doubt.<br>I know all your thoughts and motives.<br>I know everything you’ve done. Everything.<br>I am the arbiter of what is true, and what is good.<br>I am also forgiveness.<br>You cannot understand me, but you can know me.<br>You can only trust me, and act accordingly, and risk everything<br>(because I will make of you a different person than you are).<br>I demand acceptance of truth, and trust, and faithfulness.<br>Surrender yourself, and come to me.<br>Here, I am.</blockquote><p>It was the strangest combination of non-language, and utmost precision. I’m not using quotes because there were no words, no interpreting, no ambiguity; it was pure meaning, direct to the brain. Or, maybe it was pure meaning, direct between God and the spirit-part of me. I don’t know how it worked, but that’s not strange: I don’t know how my hearing works either, it just does. It was so precise that sometimes I don’t know exactly the right word; so precise that it needs the comma in the last line. It was so distinctive and recognizable that, if it had happened to me multiple times, I could imagine even careful-engineer-me getting the confidence to come out with “Thus says the Lord…”! Maybe it happens more-frequently to other people. With such communication, I can understand how prophets could write nearly-exactly what God wanted written (after searching for the nearest words); and, how Jesus could be representative of God. But it took ME 40 years to figure out how to say ANYTHING close-to-accurate about this encounter. I would’ve made the worst messenger.</p><p>I recall immense clarity, and respect, and trepidation. Jump into nothing-ness? Trust? Risk everything? I looked behind me, and knew that that vast dried-up plain represented the life I had been leading, and could continue to lead if I chose. There was not one hill, not one plant in sight. It meant “nothing to lose”, and I agreed with that. So, I turned back toward the orange glow, and thought back, “For whatever you may wish to do with me…” Then I jumped into that abyss… but did not fall. I floated in that orange glow, weightless, ecstatic, completely known and understood, and loved beyond imagining. This was the reason for EVERYTHING.</p><p>I don’t recall going to sleep, I don’t recall the next day. Mum was now doubly-worried about devil-possession and took ME to see the pastor, too. But I floated on cloud 9, like being in love with God, all through my University years. Everything spiritual or moral was suddenly immensely more important than everything physical or practical. Immediately, I was made sharply aware of my own “sinfulness” (even though what that meant, remained vague to me until very recently); of being forgiven and loved; and of an invitation — that was humbling and en-nobling at the same time — to talk to this literally-awesome God, directly. I was like a triangle in “Flatland” (a book) being shown that the importance of everything in the universe actually lies in an invisible dimension. Hence all the language in the New Testament about being “born again”, being “made alive”, “the peace that passes understanding” — I discovered what that meant.</p><p>It’s interesting to look back on this with my now-more-developed analytical skills, and notice what was NOT in this experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*udidZPQoe5QVhRkq" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@stevenvanelk?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Steven Van Elk</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>There was nothing recognizable from any religion. There was no claim of knowing-everything, beyond my interior life. No claim of knowing everyone else’s lives as well (omni-presence). No claim of omnipotence. No mention/promise of heaven nor hell; nothing about being “saved”. I had no fear, neither of this Presence, nor of being condemned. Nothing but a declaration, and an existential choice. And I was not told to tell anyone anything. (Note: I don’t know what this same Presence might “say” to other people.) And, it never crossed my mind to doubt any of what was communicated, nor question motives. It remained an in-divisible experience, for 40 years… until I did “language-based violence” to it, as above.</p><p>It kicked-off years of healing, and learning about God’s presence and love after/despite the family-disaster I grew up with. All the Bible verses I’d hated as a boy, sitting through endless church services, came back to me if/when they were appropriate. I felt like there was an angel sitting on my shoulder, teaching me better than any parent I knew of — and (unlike most teen-agers?) I was starving for some teaching. Who needs a human hero or idol, when you’ve got THIS? I came to feel that God even has a sense of humor. Not the human flavor, of laughing at people being humiliated or hurt; more mock-surprise amusement like “Good Lord, what will they think of next? Oh. I’m glad I asked me, or I wouldn’t believe it.”</p><p>Here’s some of what I learned that way. (I expect to offend almost everybody, a little.)</p><ul><li>Truth is everywhere. It has nothing-at-all to do with ego, or status, or fame, or authority, or public opinion. Truth fares better OUTSIDE human brains.</li><li>“You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart… This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it, You shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments hang all laws and all prophets.” I immediately understood the second commandment as the Golden Rule, about symmetrical consideration. That up-ended my motivations for fighting-off my mother: I still had to stop her dishing out guilt-trips, but I could afford some compassion. I also understood that my “neighbor” is, whoever I can reach, as Jesus went straight from “your neighbor” to the story of The Good Samaritan (a foreigner, crossing the road, to offer help). But it took me until I was in my 50s, and had lost my daughter (long story, omitted), to finally understand how the first commandment is the foundation of the second: truth is the foundation of justice, honesty is the foundation of love, repentance and forgiveness occur on the approach, compassion holds it all together, and that whole structure is, what’s good.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*cbOm38dSe0bVY8GfR9aMgw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This Is What’s Good, and “Here, I Am”</figcaption></figure><ul><li>“Perfect love casts out fear”. If you live truthfully and considerately, then you have nothing to fear, nothing to hide, and nothing to lose, and therein is massive strength. There’s no hiding anything from God anyway. S/He knows EVERYTHING I’ve done.</li><li>“I am the way, the truth, and the life…” “A new commandment I give you: That you love one another as I have loved you.” Truth-in-action, and love, are inseparable. EITHER, you can be honest with yourself, and be sorry, and be forgiven, and try to act congruently with your words and beliefs, and be loved for who you are; OR, you can hide/posture, and rationalize/justify yourself, and be liked for your mask. I knew which one I’d rather have.</li><li>“In the way you judge, you yourself will be judged; and by your standard of measure, it will be measured to you. Why do you look for a speck that is in your brother’s eye, but not notice the log in your own?” I’m not better, for finding ways other people are worse — that’s what fault-finding and ridicule are about. But neither is the solution, total tolerance. “First take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly enough to take the speck out of your brother’s eye”.</li><li>Putting the previous points together results in a different morality than a merely human one. There is a higher standard: an accountable integrity. That’s a very different thing from give-people-what-they-want. This understanding freed me to care about people voluntarily, rather than being driven by popular “shoulds”, or obligations, or even worse, concern about what-people-might-think-of-me, which is actually selfish. Integrity and honesty, but not brutality: the “accountable” part means, be kind about it, that’s not difficult.</li><li>Why pray? I can talk to God anytime I want, and directly; nobody needs a priest or pastor. And not only when I want something. Nor does S/He need me to tell Him/Her how great and wonderful S/He is. What is that — buttering-up? And I don’t have to repeat anything over and over, nor solicit a crowd to pray with/for me; S/He heard me the first time. I can think of Him/Her as my best friend.</li><li>In church, I wondered how everybody could just calmly stand up, sit down, stand up, sing the next hymn on the list, endure an hour of formula. The God I knew, cared not a hoot about any of that. Why get dressed up for church, when God cares what’s in people’s hearts? Why BE in a church when we could simply be friends helping each other? How does the pastor/priest/reverend get to tell everybody what to pray? I imagined God chuckling, “I hear one duck, and a hundred ducklings wondering where he’s going.” With our pastor (Donald K Baird), I argued like nobody else, even asking him how he had the gall to get paid for being a pastor, when the Apostles didn’t get paid? I was a firebrand. (However, at the same time, I was also a church organist, and I gave some sermons, without even breaking the mold.)</li><li>For a few years, I soaked up Systematic Theology, until I concluded that it was academic in the worst way. After that, I was quickly at odds with all religious organizations, including the church I went to at the time, as causing division over mere theories, and wasting large amounts of money on irrelevancies like buildings. (E.g. there are about 7 theories of exactly-how Jesus’ death made it possible for God to forgive people. All 7 could be wrong.)</li><li>And I had all the reason I ever needed, to reject any philosophy (e.g. of science) that says we can’t know anything we can’t measure. That’s irredeemably simplistic. On the other hand, how do I explain this experience to anyone? I can’t. That doesn’t make it false. But it did give me an epistemic problem that took me 40 years to solve to my own satisfaction.</li></ul><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-what-a-silly-question-part-1-587268ba4512">Science Versus Religion? Silly Question. (Part 1)</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-3-f4c24568a898">Science Versus Religion? (Part 3)</a></li></ul><ul><li>Indeed, the material world seemed vastly un-important, after this. Appearances were irrelevant, possessions were irrelevant, and they still are (though I’m glad I have my comfy bed). Even “fun” was merely a distraction from the happiness I felt. I’d love God for my present life even if there was neither heaven nor hell.</li></ul><p>This encounter with (who I take to be) God was the most important thing that ever happened to me. I know I’m a different person because of it — just as S/He “said”, via full disclosure on Day 1, WAY ahead of me. It’s driven what I care about, my philosophy of knowledge, my understanding of love, and lately my thinking about truth/justice, honesty/love, repentance/forgiveness, and compassion. I know I’m only visiting this planet; I’m grateful for the life I’m having, even with my disastrous parents, even with a failed marriage, even with losing my daughter; I’d still be grateful, if I had to die tomorrow; and I know that dying won’t be the end of me. I don’t need to believe, or have faith; I KNOW these things now, as surely as I know anything-else from observing it. And I do consider this experience to be an observation.</p><p>BTW I take no credit for any of this. I can’t take credit for God’s doings, just as I can’t take credit for anyone’s personality, or how they reveal themselves to whom; all Persons decide such things for themselves. Nor am I now “the chosen people”. I only consider myself blessed, for no reason I’ve been told, and I don’t need to make one up.</p><p>Lately I’ve been thinking that I might write a booklet about the philosophy I’ve come to, and I might call it “Person-ality: The Spitting Image of God” — since most of us ARE spitting at God. S/He’d appreciate the pun.</p><p>Lastly, a thought about the (uncomfortable?) notion of repentance. God doesn’t need my apology, nor repentance, nor restitution, because S/He never had anything to lose, other than my gratitude, which S/He can “live” without. But meeting Him/Her causes heightened self-awareness and repentance to happen. His/Her forgiveness is immediate. But for us humans on the receiving end of others’ offenses and crimes, we have only a short life, and things to lose, so a perpetrator’s repentance assures us that the damage won’t happen again. And restitution is part of recovery, and justice. It seems only sensible to demand something BEFORE we (for)give the perpetrator permission to repeat the damage. But that’s us, physical beings, with limited life-times. From God’s point of view, I think that the inevitable repentance and forgiveness might be adequately translated as, APOLOGY ACCEPTED. Apology for what? For having had the hubris to think that I/we can DECIDE what can and cannot be true. For not treating other people as fully human. For being cruel. Etc.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*cbOm38dSe0bVY8GfR9aMgw.jpeg" /><figcaption>APOLOGY ACCEPTED</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0eb3e4dde7fc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Out Of The Animal Trap]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/out-of-the-animal-trap-83f5139bde90?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/83f5139bde90</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dating]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[respect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Oct 2024 13:32:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-10T19:55:16.256Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Sexism, the Life-Cost of Money, Symmetry, and Beyond</strong></h4><p><strong>MOTIVATION</strong>: The essay below has been 20 years in the making (I’m 66 now). In other words, I apologize in advance if young people today find it offensive for reasons I don’t know about. A few months ago I waded into today’s American dating scene (with my cultural anthropology hat on) to find out first-hand what all the noise is. I’m now convinced that social media and dating apps are doing more harm than good (our youngsters hardly know real people, only self-selected words &amp; videos). I found the back-and-forth rage-baiting horrifying, and it motivated me to at-last finish this essay, which I hope provides a bridge over troubled waters. In my estimation, that requires ripping off “everybody’s” blinders about the do-or-die corner men have been in for thousands of years. But now, women apparently decline to return the financial-support favor. In Epilogues 3 — end I provide some hopefully-constructive answers for everyone.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fedv_bNEaYTQ&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dedv_bNEaYTQ&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fedv_bNEaYTQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/aac616f742ea01f7f0dea1174cb738f3/href">https://medium.com/media/aac616f742ea01f7f0dea1174cb738f3/href</a></iframe><p><strong>SUMMARY: </strong>Relations between the sexes aren’t what they used to be (thank goodness). While sexism is not nearly over, now young men are refusing to put up with it too. Therefore, what’s coming is, a stand-off. Young men and women can now very well live without each other, so they approach relationships as a “deal”, offering my “inflated” “assets” for his/hers, and usually conclude that the “deal” isn’t worth doing. That’s right, it’s not, for three excellent reasons: #1 NO “deal” is a basis for a good relationship, #2 NOTHING is worth half of someone else’s life’s worth, let alone being worth ALL of it, and #3 Let’s stop making men work themselves into an early grave while someone else spends all his money and insults him for paying the life-time cost; that’s just cruel. I hypothesized a solution, and bet my life on it, and it worked, I found my one-and-only Melanie. Moreover, my hypothesis explains other good relationships, and why they’re rare: You both have to escape the ANIMAL TRAP, stop USING each other, even pay for your men while THEY go shouting about what’s unfair to THEM (as men did for their women, 60 years ago. I saw it happen, I was there, most of you were not and have been misled).</p><p><strong>WHEN YOU’RE IN A HOLE, STOP DIGGING</strong></p><p>For millions of years, men have had heavier and stronger upper bodies than women, so handled heavy or dangerous animals, rocks, logs, weapons, and eventually, heavy machinery. Meanwhile, women were almost permanently pregnant (when families had 7 living children, plus 5 infant mortalities) or breast-feeding and/or child-rearing, so, fully occupied for most of a life-time. Also meanwhile, men had no way to know who was their own child, and who wasn’t. These biological differences were amplified into extreme role differences. Men ended up obligated to hard labor, selling their life-times to pay for everything, being robbed of time with their families. Women were “contained” in homes: they should get married by the age of 20, and never-mind any education past high-school.</p><blockquote>In short, men risked and sacrificed their lives to war and work, while women risked and sacrificed their lives to child-bearing and -raising. Survival first, everything else second, including family dynamics.</blockquote><p>Those “obligations” remained with us, even into the 1970s for women in Western countries, and to the present day for everyone else, including all men everywhere. Women have been shouting about it for a century now, but men can’t even hold protest rallies because then who will pay for their food and shelter? Certainly not today’s women. We find young women expecting to be, simultaneously, dependent (entitled to spend ALL HIS money) and independent (he’d BETTER NOT tell her what to do with it)! Why would he sign up for that — getting looted? Conversely, we find young men expecting to be served for free, since she can earn her own money. Why would she sign up for that — a job and a “man-child” (as some women call it)?</p><p>What a hole we’ve dug. As the saying goes, “When you’re in a hole, stop digging!” What “stop digging” means, in practice, is the subject of this essay. First, the ridicule: let’s mock the vestiges of centuries past, this time from the exploited-male perspective (balancing Judy Brady Syfers’ 1971 essay). Then, I’ll offer some serious Epilogues. The big picture for the Epilogues is,</p><blockquote>We are the only animals on this planet who have the ability, and, now, the opportunity, to over-rule our instincts and DECIDE our future behavior. Our entire species may be climbing “out of the animal trap”.</blockquote><blockquote>Readers may wish to jump to my suggested solutions at Epilogue 3 “Beyond Symmetry”, about 2/3 down (skipping my deconstruction of “the deal” in “the animal trap”). You’ll need this definition when you get there: “Symmetry = what goes for the gander goes for the goose goes for the gander goes for the goose”.</blockquote><p><strong>(I’M A STRAIGHT MAN, AND) I WANT A HUSBAND!</strong></p><p>Bear in mind: I’m 66, and writing about circumstances that I lived through before many of my readers were even born. Some of this is, deliberately, setting-on-fire a straw-man that’s already half-gone. I think it should be all-gone (but people will do what they will do). And my point here is not to blame anyone for how it used to be, I’m just setting it on fire, that’s all.</p><p>In the spirit of <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=web&amp;cd=&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=2ahUKEwiRv9bL-ej7AhWeHEQIHUXeBiUQFnoECA0QAQ&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsfcs.k12.nc.us%2Fcms%2Flib%2FNC01001395%2FCentricity%2FDomain%2F10659%2FI%2520Want%2520a%2520Wife.pdf&amp;usg=AOvVaw0hdj1LyUtm1EapfhUN_gQl">Judy Brady Syfers’ 1971 essay “I Want A Wife”</a>, I’m a man who’s often thought “I want a husband!” One who will give ME a free life! And expensive gifts, too! I would love money to just appear in the bank account, without thinking that every penny comes from him having to sell his life-time — crowding whatever’s-left-of-him into the ONE DAY PER WEEK of life-time that’s left (if he’s lucky) after dressing, commuting, working, eating, and honey-do chores — selling life-time with which he must think and do whatever he’s told, selling life-time he can’t do-over and will never get back. And after he’s been stressed-out all week, he’d better work for ME on weekends! I too want a “right” to stay home, never have a boss, nor customers, nor deadline stress, nor performance reviews, nor layoffs. I too want to never ask whether I can afford to take a vacation day or sick day. I too want to make someone else buy everything for me, while I go on complaining that I’m “unpaid labor”! I too want to be paid to do whatever I choose to do at home! I wish! But unfortunately I’m a man and have spent most of my adult life being the VICTIM of such expectations. So I offer this essay as a more philosophically-based step beyond Judy Brady Syfers, still in the direction of symmetry, but 53 years later and yet the world is still swimming in sexism — also at the expense of “men”.</p><p>I put “men” and “women” in scare-quotes because you mistakenly think that those group-nouns mean something. They don’t. You won’t be able to distinguish those sets of people in your entire life, because there are 8 billion people, so it would take you 253 years to categorize them all (one per second). You might think you can distinguish them “in principle”, by resorting to genetics, with XY=male and XX=female, but no: There are cis women with XY chromosomes, and people with XXY, XYY, XXYY. You can’t rely on genitalia: There are intersex people. You also can’t resort to stereotypes: I’ve known women who would never admit they’ve gotten anything wrong, and refused to ask for directions, and wouldn’t even admit they’re lost. Every group-noun is an over-simplification of a dizzying natural variety. There is no such thing as the set of “all women” to admire for anything, nor mock, nor blame, for anything (“all men” likewise). Similarly, there is no “us” alive today who were oppressed 60 years ago, and no “them” alive today who did that oppressing 60 years ago. I’ve never been part of, nor met any remnant of, “the patriarchy” (I’ve never met Donald Trump). Yet I find myself in a society that paints “women” with one shade and “men” with another, “mothers” with one shade and “fathers” with another; a society that disavows racism while simultaneously talking of dog breeds’ characteristics as if those are NOT races! The problem is the nouns in your own heads, people! Nouns refer to concepts that exist only in your heads, and those concepts have negligible relation to reality unless you work hard to discover that relation (which is what science does). In the real world you’ll see only “somewhat similar” and “less similar”, and nouns don’t have the hard edges you only-think they have. Group-nouns are collective delusions. But unfortunately, I have to use them, because you-all do.</p><p>To judge from advertising, pulp magazines, and tabloids, “women” (I’m going to drop the scare-quotes now) should aspire to be precious luxuries: beautiful, expensive, only babbling and laughing (useless). (I’m not confused, I’m talking about the pernicious FANTASY pushed by advertising.) Behold, clothes absolutely-not designed for heavy lifting, sweat, dirt, or danger. Behold her so precious that she “needs” teensy little panties for 10 TIMES the price of men’s undies, per ounce. Behold finger-nails so long that the hands can’t do much, can barely even type. Behold shoes designed so she can’t run to save her life, nor carry anything. Behold hair and skin that never get dirty. Behold HOURS per day spent on self-beautification and self-indulgence, and “essential” arts and crafts. IT’S A FANTASY. What’s the un-stated, ignored back-ground all this requires?: A world already made flat and air-conditioned for her convenience (but not by women), plus money to burn AND time to kill. No working stiff gets any of that. We either sell our life-time, then we have money but not-enough time left to spend it, OR, we have no work, then we have time but no money! The advert-fantasy is only possible if someone else sacrifices their life-time working, so a woman can be a luxury.</p><p>But unfortunately, advertising is what it is because it WORKS — some women want it, some demand it. This fantasy is as one-eyed as some women asserting a “right” to stay at home or work, when their staying-home is only possible if someone-else pays all the bills, and therefore does NOT have the same choice! That’s not a “right”, it’s a domination. If a man doesn’t see through it immediately, he will, eventually. This is one of the big-3 reasons (mis-named “fighting over money”) why men walked out — she’s getting a free, stress-free life, entirely in charge of her time, limited only by how much money he gives her, and she’s COMPLAINING about that?! — never-mind how much of his life he must sell and have no control over, because he has to pay for HER and all her wants?! I WISH I could have her life! I’ve NEVER had a choice to stay home and do what I want, let alone think about what I want. The only choice I’ve ever had is, work or starve, and even my work had to be competed for, it was never a right. Apparently, some women think they’re entitled to “rights” I’ve never had, and never will. And, again, advertising (products, services, materialism, where the money is) is TERRIBLY not-helping, it’s FANTASY-LAND, and guess who watched those commercials during work-hours.</p><p><strong>A CHARICATURE THAT RECURS TO THIS DAY (CAUGHT IN THE ANIMAL TRAP = NO DEAL)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OlvcrqIT5b6cKQRx" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@lancereis?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Lance Reis</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/fools-gold-digger/">https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/fools-gold-digger/</a></p><p>In October 2007 (when I was 49), a young woman (25) “put [herself] out there in an honest way” as “beautiful (spectacularly beautiful)” in search of “MARRIAGE ONLY” (her capitals) to a man who earned at least $ half-a-million / year. She wondered why any such men have “settled for” “plain Jane” women when they could’ve had herself? A “gentle respondent” in her desired age and income-range replied that (1) it’s a bad deal for him because “my income increases but … you won’t be getting any more beautiful! … By 35, stick a fork in you!” (he wrote) and (2) her wanting “MARRIAGE ONLY” was a hypocrisy because “If my money were to go away, so would you. So when your beauty fades, I want out too.”</p><p>I’m told that similar conversations happen to this day. In brief, a man says “You want A, B, C, D and E from me, what will YOU bring to the table?” She replies “Me!” or if she’s a strong, over-confident woman, “I AM the table!” So he walks away, amused, and writes her up in his blog.</p><p>The above exchanges seem to me a much-needed and many-centuries-overdue step toward equality, though so far only as her thesis + his anti-thesis, and disappointingly short of a syn-thesis! That synthesis is,</p><blockquote>SYMMETRY: what goes for the gander goes for the goose goes for the gander goes for the goose.</blockquote><p>This turns out to be a very sharp sword indeed. Equality only when it suits women is not symmetry. For example: no calling it “work” if you’re doing things you chose to do, when “work” for him means, having NO choice about selling his life-time to demanding bosses or customers; no choosing to not-have-a-job just because you don’t like your options, you get to be in the same do-or-die corner men have been in for centuries; no taking part-time or low-stress jobs as-if some man should pay for almost-everything; no socializing, no long personal phone-calls, no soap-operas, during work-hours, unless you want a pay-cut; no expecting a man to make the first move, nor pay for the first date, nor propose, nor expecting expensive rings without giving him any, you are on those hooks (too); no expecting him to spend his lifetime paying for you, unless you’ll spend your lifetime paying for him, and not a little bit; if every “man” who doesn’t earn a fortune is a “loser”, so is every “woman” who doesn’t earn a fortune; no rescuing “women and children first” as if you’re somehow more essential than fathers; no expecting him to die for you, you get to die for him (too). Level the field, or call yourself a sexist. That’s symmetry.</p><p>The “gold digger” above seems utterly oblivious to the feminism of the last 100 years pointing out that women are not possessions nor sex objects. The “gentle respondent”, for a financially savvy man, did a very poor job of analyzing the “deal” she sought. I want to berate both of them, and in the process, blow away all the silliness that continues to this day — in some corners of the backs of some people’s minds. Symmetry, to the rescue:</p><p>1. She wanted a (“MARRIAGE ONLY”) commitment for (a) half his existing assets, and (b) half his life’s future income, to buy her fleeting beauty! He sensibly nixed that.</p><p>2. Is he buying her beauty as-of the purchase date, or is he buying its up-keep over time? This is a logical extension of the point he did notice, namely that her beauty is a depreciating asset, like a car. If he’s buying her beauty as delivered, he’s not paying for the future: It’s on her to stay beautiful. Furthermore, he’s also not paying HER for the past. Since she is only 25, and her parents spent 21 years feeding and grooming her, apparently for sale in the high-priced beautiful-meat market, her parents deserve 84% of the money (like a dowry). One re-pays the farmer who raised the meat, one doesn’t pay the meat for eating the farmer’s hay! So it turns out that he should pay HER for only the thin sliver-in-time in which she maintained herself, and that thin sliver-in-time is hardly worth any fraction of his entire life’s wages.</p><p>3. Alright then, let’s try it the other way = he should pay for the upkeep of her beauty. The more expensive she looks, the more she’s worth, right??? Expensive hair, expensive skin, expensive make-up, expensive eye-lashes, expensive jewelry, expensive finger-nails, expensive bras, expensive clothes, fantastically expensive panties, expensive hand-bags, expensive toe-nails, expensive shoes. A man should APPRECIATE how much of his money she “needs” to spend on herself. OMG, men, RUN! Unfortunately the costs will increase dramatically over time, as it becomes very difficult to look like she’s still 25. This brings up the question of limits. Exclude everything but beauty products. She can’t be so foolish as to think that she should be paid for eating, for grooming herself, and for merely walking about under his roof, as if any of that is “work”!</p><p>Nowadays, she will put on all her expensive looks just-before walking out the door, and take them off right after coming home. He should pay her to be beautiful to everyone BUT him??</p><p>4. So it comes to this: Exactly how much of his annual income should he hand over, to purchase her fleeting beauty and/or upkeep? If this is not stipulated, he runs the risk that what’s his (income) will be deemed “ours”, and what’s “ours” will all be spent by HER (because he’s too busy to even think about spending it). If she does earn any money, then that will be hers too, because she earned it fair and square. (Obviously, he DIDN’T earn HIS fair and square, while SHE’s making up the rules.) If HE gets a bonus, he should spend it on her, and if SHE gets a bonus, he should celebrate HER. Thus she will suck down both their incomes, leaving him in a bind to pay HER taxes, and making him fight to get any of his own money, not to mention he should still somehow fund her retirement despite her spending, and he should be grateful, GRATEFUL!, if she lives long enough to suck down all his retirement-savings too, so there’ll be NOTHING left for him, not now and not ever. I’m not making this up, all this was said and done to me. It’s what some/many women have been doing since the 1960s: HIS income is “for the household”, but hers is HERS — and then they wonder why men get angry! A reality-check is many decades overdue. She gets to spend HER income ONLY, and she gets to live and save and retire with THAT, and if she gets ANY of his money, she gets to be accountable to him for that, and if he gets a bonus or promotion, she gets to celebrate HIM for that (and NOT pay for that celebration with his own money). EVERYONE pay your own way, 100%, like it or not. That’s symmetry. (It’s not the goal, but I’ll get to that later.)</p><p>5. Why should he pay for the wedding in addition to (BEFORE owning) her “spectacular beauty”? What if he’s already paid the wedding costs but then she changes her mind, how will she pay him back? From her NEXT husband’s assets? Awkward…</p><p>6. She advertised for a marriage, but said nothing about, what that “marriage” should entail. Does she expect to be admired for her “spectacular beauty”? But he’s already bought that, it is his, so she should be admiring HIM being able to purchase it, like owning a spectacular car or house. If she desires to be admired BY him, then she needs to order this service from him for a stipulated period and rate, and his time is not cheap.</p><p>7. Obviously, this beauty-for-money bargaining is not going well. Perhaps they should take a different tack in which a man is expected to spend his entire life paying for something else? One thing men are expected to pay for is (“Don’t you love me?”) their own love of their wife and children! But then, applying the Principle of Symmetry, since the woman hopes to earn nothing, she has no love for her husband, not one penny’s worth. He SHOULD feel like he’s nothing but a walking wallet, or a pocket being picked. Some women go even further and claim that he should be grateful that she’s putting up with him, so he’s paying for both, his own love, and her disdain! That’s a helluva bill she’s handing him, in the name of “love”! Let’s give HER such a bill, shall we (symmetry)? He gets to disdain HER unless she pays him for HIS respect, with her entire life’s worth, and it’d better be GOOD! Point made?</p><p>Of course, Round 2 of this argument goes that “love” “should” “rise above” such “trivia” as money. Unless it’s on her to pay for everything, then it’s not love nor trivia. See Epilogue 3.</p><p>8. Rising to this challenge, some women have of course suggested that their men are actually paying for something valuable — When all else fails, make stuff up, and if he’s stupid enough to believe it, he DESERVES to be despised. (What a good relationship, NOT.) She may suggest that he is paying for her at-home work — but he’d better not believe it, for he will be told very quickly that she’s NOT his employee, and he’d BETTER NOT think that he’s the boss of her! So she’s saying: She wants his entire life’s income as HER income, for doing whatever she chooses. If/when that works, she claims to be “unpaid labor” and demands to be paid AGAIN. I WISH such employers existed, I want one too! Dream on. (And let’s not over-look that her “work”, being entirely under her own control/discretion, is less stressful than any paying job, which pays you to NOT do what you like, actually demanding your brain full-time, and demanding more work than there is time for: If you finish anything early, you get more work, so that you’re ALWAYS stressed-out, on purpose. And then they wonder why men die 5 years younger!) So, “employment” wasn’t nice enough. Alright then, let’s suppose that this relationship is more like he’s hiring her as a contractor. Same problem: in both employment and contracting, the employer says what’s wanted, and approves and owns everything the employee/contractor produces/fixes while being paid. So it is all his — parts and labor, time and materials, all bought with his life’s-worth of money. When a contractor fixes or decorates a house, they don’t own it too, do they! I gather that she doesn’t like this deal, either. She wants it so that, the more of his money she spends on the house, the more the house is worth and the more her half is worth, and that is in fact how the law works now. The more of his money she spends on the house, the richer she gets! If I were granted such legalized looting of husbands, I too might make up a “new era of unlimited abundance”, and mock men for not seeing it! I too would like to roll in someone else’s money. I WISH I could find a generous man.</p><p>9. Unfortunately — and it’s most regrettable that any women ever went here — it is also suggested that a woman’s sexual services are a valuable part of a marriage “deal”. Most regrettable, because this makes marriage about sex-for-money, which is usually called prostitution. Fortunately, the Principle of Symmetry reveals this “deal” for the fraud it always was: Doesn’t she owe him equally much money for HIS sexual services? Or are we to think that she wouldn’t care if she’s sex-less for her entire life? I don’t believe it. And, even if this payment-for-services WAS imaginable as a “deal”, it’s a very bad deal indeed: Since she wants to be paid $500K per year for the 2,200 hours of services in a normal work-year, he would be paying her $227/hour (tax-free, by the way), which is more than enough to buy a hooker for EVERY WORKING HOUR. Since a wife will “put out” only a tiny fraction of that, she’s just made herself insanely expensive compared to a hooker. Obviously, somebody didn’t think this “deal” through at all. And now, here come Artificial Intelligence sex robots. This sex-for-money “deal” is doomed.</p><p>10. Finally, there’s the having of children. She doesn’t need a man for that, she could use a sperm bank. That would solve three problems at once: (a) no man wants to be used as a walking sperm bank, (b) her biological clock is nobody else’s problem, and (c) apparently, lots of men do not agree that she can choose to have or not-have his child regardless of his wishes. Use a sperm-bank, problems solved. Unless she wants a man to be her walking wallet, but that’s a serious mistake, for many reasons: A. USING a man as a walking wallet will end badly for everyone involved. B. How does a birth entitle her to live at his expense — breast-feeding is unnecessary, and done in months — why wouldn’t a birth entitle HIM to live at HER expense? C. Let’s turn this viral question around (“What would you rather meet in the woods, a bear or a man? The bear!”): What would you rather meet in the woods, your wife with children, or a gang of armed criminals? The gang of armed criminals! They don’t want your children, the worst thing they can do is kill you; they can’t take your FUTURE wages; can’t divorce you to get another half of whatever’s left; can’t demand alimony too; can’t rob you of your children; can’t force you to pay child support for children that aren’t yours (by paternity fraud and/or estoppel); and when the gang assaults you, everybody will believe you. There is no recovering — not ever — from a wife’s destruction of a man’s life. (For those who don’t see any death here: The only suicide in my circles was a man who shot himself over this, on his ex-wife’s birthday. RIP, Paul Aglio.) So, let’s also send this one back to the women it came from: “As long as we can’t trust all of you, we can’t trust any of you.” (Clearly, many young women weren’t mature/sympathetic enough to see the symmetry.)</p><p>What an unholy mess! Centuries of relationship built on NOT thinking, let alone thinking symmetrically! Good relationships are not based on any kind of deal. Neither are they built on fending-off the losing side until that side finally says go-to-hell. Hypocrisies and exploitations will not endure. When men can afford to demand what THEY think is fair (less labor time), “the deal” will fall apart even faster than it is now. Au contraire, the Principle of Symmetry says what the “gentle respondent” wrote to the young woman on the web: “You could always work to earn [ALL] your own money, and then we wouldn’t need to have this difficult conversation.”</p><p><strong>EPILOGUE 1: THERE’S NO SUCH THING AS A FREE LIFE</strong></p><p>Fortunately, I recognized the Principle of Symmetry when I was 16 (50 years ago), and I still say “fortunately” even though some women find it a road-block to a free life. Of course it is: There’s no such thing as a free life. If anyone will not work, s/he cannot buy food, nor clothes, nor shelter, nor a bed, nor furniture, nor anything else. Somebody has to pay for all that, by selling their life-time. Nobody’s getting a free life at my expense (so not free) and then calling it “unpaid labor”. Someone can get a free life at my expense only if I can get a free life at their expense. Not just “[they] WOULD (return that favor)” pie-in-the-sky, as if babbling noble intentions (would, but never will) is worth ANYTHING, let-alone worth everything I have to work for. I’ll have my free life, for-real, and right-now! And if I don’t get to tell my wife what to do with her free life, she doesn’t get to tell me what to do with mine. Symmetry cuts both ways.</p><p>Part of what’s behind the above tug-of-war is, who owns what why. A hundred years ago, women could legally own nothing, and there are echoes of that, above. As reprehensible as that was, treating a man like a walking wallet is equally reprehensible. When she wants to stay home (maybe “for the baby”, maybe because she doesn’t like a job), he gets shoved out the door to work, and is forced away from his children, and then, she wants to be PAID for this monstrous theft of his family, when she should be compensating him for it! Then follow decades of sexist stupidity — as if he should pay everything for her, free life, free children, and all — decades in which he gets no time to think about relationships, no time to think about himself, negligible spare time, until he’s desperate for ANY time he’s not being yanked around, while it never matters what he wants, not at work and not at home, until asking him what-he-wants causes confused silence, his spare life-time is so scarce that you can’t MAKE him think about mere paint-colors or hair-colors or nail-colors, so she runs him over, and mocks him for not knowing/caring about everything he has no time for, due to the forced labor she herself has inflicted on him, every day including weekends. “He’s no fun anymore” ‘cos there’s nothing left! Use him up, and blame him for it too. When they get divorced and she totally-steals his children, he is expected to go on paying her so she can bribe his children away from him with his own money — and then she wonders why he refuses to help her with that! Employed married men have NEVER owned either the products of their labor (their employer does) nor their wages (their wife does), nor their children. What’s left for him?! Only his wife’s exertion for his wants and wishes — THAT’s how someone who’s being given a free life should return that immense favor — full-time, even.</p><p>But nowadays, whether she’s working or not, he gets no such consideration (in Western countries); he should pay up and shut up. I’ve even heard a woman complain loudly and self-righteously, in a restaurant, that her husband had asked, what was left for him? and her response was “That’s not a marriage!” (But it IS her marriage. See what I mean about group-nouns, e.g. the dizzying natural variety of “marriages”, getting strangely hard edges in people’s heads?) Finally, she paid for all those Ladies Who Lunch In Luxury, and collected their thanks. (I too would like to be generous with someone else’s money, and take all the credit.) Her husband wasn’t there ‘cos he had to work for 6½ HOURS to earn back (with taxes) the money she blew on her friends in 1 hour. He got nothing — no thanks from her, no credit from anyone, not even his own money spent on a lunch for himself. In only 10 minutes, she demonstrated that she was exploiting him, and blamed him for knowing it, and other women said nothing. OK then, since “that’s not a marriage”, FIRE her.</p><p>More generally, “the rules” of “who owns what why” are unclear, and conflict, and change over time. The book “Mine!” (2021) by Michael Heller and James Salzman, is an education about the issues, but doesn’t dare to even mention “the battle of the sexes”. The law was not fair 100 years ago, and it’s not fair now.</p><p>The Principle of Symmetry is merely a more-explanatory name for the Golden and Silver Rules: “[Don’t] do to others what you [don’t] want done to you.” It was first written as “Love your neighbor as yourself” 2,500 years ago, and most of us STILL don’t get it. It takes imagination and compassion to see how far-reaching it is. Had this Principle been practiced much, there would have been no racism, no nationalism, no wars, no slavery, no sexism, no human trafficking, no drug lords, no arrogant royalty nor egregious profiteering, no crime at all — except that perpetrated by sick brains. Unfortunately, many humans are more inclined to do whatever they want and take whatever they can get, by verbal hook or actual crook. To mitigate this selfishness/theft, we make bargains, agreements, and contracts, but some people blithely welch on their agreements because “it’s different now”… and it’s ALWAYS “different now”, sucka (e.g. it’s an hour later). The defenses against such betrayals are, either, no agreement at all, or agreements that are short-term (no commitment), or agreements that continually deliver value to the payer, much like, oh, employment. If you’re not paying your own way, someone else is, and THEY’re entitled, to what THEY want out of your time.</p><p><strong>EPILOGUE 2: TITANIC INEQUALITIES</strong></p><p>In the famous movie “Titanic” (1997), Jack exists so he can save Rose from “society” and then drown for her benefit. Celine Dion sang “My heart will go on” on Rose’s behalf, never-mind Jack’s heart freezing, that’s not even an irony. Never-mind Rose’s husband at all. YES she had a husband, too. We heard (about 15 minutes into the movie) that she later married, had 2 children, and an adult grand-daughter is accompanying her on the boat, so there had to be “some man” in her life. But the pictures Rose puts beside her bed, at the end of the movie, don’t identify him. He doesn’t matter. Almost no viewers notice. When Rose dies, she meets Jack on the Titanic; her husband, and the father of her children, isn’t there, either. Why would any man be any woman’s husband, if all he gets for it is, being used-up when alive, and erased when dead?! Rose was, and is, so self-centered that it’s a poke in the eye. HER heart will go on, that’s all that matters. “Titanic” was lauded as a “romantic” movie, but I find it exploitative, of men. Are we all seeing that gigantic blind spot yet, that sends men away to work, and then erases and even insults what’s left of them? No deal anymore!</p><p>But Jack is all play, and no work. Guess what, that’s wrong too. He would’ve needed a free life at HER expense. That’s such a horrible ending — to sexists — that they rather drowned him than make people think about it… even though he could’ve floated on the same piece of wood as Rose, and any woman worth having, would’ve saved HIS life too. Indeed, imagine the whole movie with the roles reversed. Jack would let Rose babble and freeze for his own benefit, Jack’s future wife would be invisible, and Jack’s heart will bravely “go on”. Women would hurl insults at it. What does that tell you? Two things: #1 Men’s lives have always been disposable, and that particular inequality is A-OK, and #2 Where are the men loudly insulting “Titanic”? The silence is deafening. Ah, there’s one of those men, still risking his life for a cat:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3TLnZq_j4BpWYCx3" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@cgbriggs19?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Chris Briggs</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The new movie “Barbie” is mockable. We hear from Gloria how conflicted it is to be a woman, but nobody puts in one balancing word for men, and again, nobody notices. Here’s what Allan could’ve said: Some women show off their bodies, then blame men for looking; some women think men rude for not opening doors, others slap men for doing it, how DARE he think she needs that; some women ask for help, then call it man-splaining; some women ask a man to apply muscles, then mock him for doing it; some women complain to HR about unwanted attention, then complain when they’re left alone; some women call men sexists for offering to help, then blame men for not-helping when needed; most women don’t want construction or engineering jobs, then blame men for still dominating those fields; men should sacrifice their home-lives to support their families, AND be authentic, AND never angry; men should “open up” (be vulnerable) and “man up” (get rejected, A LOT).</p><p>After that list of irrational double-binds, several Kens should be snapping out of their servitude to being the “provider-protector” for Barbie (as Barbies snapped out of their servitude to Ken). But we’re not done. Here’s a paragraph from Warren Farrell’s “The Boy Crisis” page 89: “We want our son to have integrity, but [not turn] himself in to the police because he went 59 in a 55 mph zone. We want him to be assertive, but not aggressive; to be empathetic, but not naive; to be ‘a doer’, but also introspective [but not “over-think”]; to be perseverant, but not stubborn [nor a harasser]; to be prepared, but not obsessive; to help people, but not enable them.” Now how many Kens do we still have to wake up?</p><p>What IS that bizarre scene of the Kens fighting each other, turning into an over-long dance in colorful nowhere-space? I can’t see how that mirrors anything oppressed women did/do in the real world? I don’t know what to make of it, other than, it’s an ideological feminist jab at men waging war, as if Ukrainian men are ridiculous for buying time (with their lives) so their women and children can flee? Are we seeing “Thanks for nothing?” Men’s lives are disposable, again, and that’s supposed to be funny?</p><p>The movie could’ve ended with BOTH stars “getting real”, but no, it’s more fun and profit to equate “patriarchy” with “all men”, leave them all behind, and sell female chauvinism. I recall when male chauvinism was a bad thing. I naively expect that female chauvinism is a bad thing too?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*veSFJXHhrit1Anfq" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jramos10?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Josue Isai Ramos Figueroa</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Ah, there’s a few more of those men, carefully avoiding death, and handing their wages over to their women, so these men still can’t afford to go shouting about the anti-symmetries revealed by “Titanic” and “Barbie”.</p><p>The solution is: symmetry. Symmetry cuts both ways. It includes: Don’t do unto others what you don’t want done to you. Turn-about is fair play. Men could boycott supremacist women, just as some women went on strike against entitled men in the 1960s (while those men kindly went on buying those women their food and shelter). EVERYONE beware what you do, for, in the fullness of time, it may be done back to you.</p><p><strong>EPILOGUE 3: BEYOND SYMMETRY</strong></p><p>Now that many women are earning their own incomes, and sometimes out-earning men, they’re starting to “get it”: Why on earth should she marry a man with less wealth, less status, less looks; why hand over her assets to someone who has no idea how much stress she’s under, and who spends it as if money is free, on whatever he wants, and still complains, that he has to do everything in the house, for free (?!), and she’s no fun? Ladies, I so sympathize: Welcome to being a man! Welcome to handing over your pay-check to a stay-at-home spouse. Symmetry is arriving, at last! Or not. It’s causing women to find the prospect distasteful; they’d rather not have that husband role. Guess what: For THOUSANDS of years, BILLIONS of men would rather not have that husband role! Now they’re RUNNING away from it. This is causing some women to complain that they can’t find a generous man. If he’s got it, he should hand it over; if SHE’s got it, it’s hers. Clearly, “gimme” comes much easier than symmetry.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FEAlDZ3Fcnbo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEAlDZ3Fcnbo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FEAlDZ3Fcnbo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c9e1081e91131ea61d5202929d5900e8/href">https://medium.com/media/c9e1081e91131ea61d5202929d5900e8/href</a></iframe><p>Symmetry is a sharp and entertaining diagnostic tool, as above, and it’s a strong defense against selfishness, entitlement, and hypocrisy, but it’s not an efficient use of human resources. Men, women, and others, each having to do half of everything, is inefficient and occasionally even impossible. Couples MUST deviate from symmetry; but not willy-nilly just because one is more selfish, or more hypocritical, or more socially-sanctioned, or full of “shoulds”, or faster with self-serving rationalizations; but deviate from symmetry care-fully, in ways that benefit both; and with those gains they must give back to each other, in consideration, and in representing each other, to their kids and to others.</p><p>Just as there was-and-is “the woman behind the man”, there was-and-is “the man behind the woman” (and similarly for same-sex couples). Since “the man before the woman” was always so, at women’s expense, until they demanded more respect for themselves, now there is “the woman before and behind the man” while men get no credit at all (in Western countries; and recall “Barbie”). That’s SO the wrong answer. If s/he (is a home-maker and) makes things and gives them away? Or makes friends while taking the kids/dogs to a park during his/her partner’s work-hours? The “social glue” owes his/her slack-time to someone else, and needs to ensure that that partner gets as much thanks and social credit as s/he does. Conversely, the working partner could not be so productive without the home-maker’s support. Be warned: From symmetry, only deviate care-fully, or the grateful give-back that’s missing now will cause an ugly divorce eventually. Screw what “society” “thinks” (“society” doesn’t have a brain), couples must be best friends and include/represent each other, always and everywhere. Consideration and reciprocity.</p><p>Symmetry is not a practical solution; continuing adjustment-by-agreement, of offsets-from-symmetry, IS a solution. But, behind continuing adjustment-by-agreement, there is the need for good mutual understanding, and compassion for each other’s sacrifices and distresses. You get such understanding and compassion by (a) you find a partner who has both, similar nature, and similar experience, as yourself, after (b) you have faith that such a similar person exists, “even” in the opposite sex:</p><blockquote><strong>Look For Your Psychological Twin.</strong></blockquote><p>(This is the exact opposite of “opposites attract”.) This is a very difficult thing to do, for many reasons, e.g. many of us are so sexist that we can’t imagine that such a person exists (s/he does now); many of us care more about “assets” than anything deep; we’re all rare people who initially don’t know our own distinctiveness, and many of us would need help to figure that out (being “weird” is a very helpful clue); many of us are repelled by the idea of loving someone like ourselves (which is also a very helpful clue, e.g. lose the fe/male chauvinism, criticism, contempt); and, many of us want an easy way out (let someone else make us feel whole temporarily, that’s why “opposites attract”). But what’s our intelligence for, if not to save us from our dumb instincts AND from ideologies! So I inferred the concept of “psychological twin”, and then, deduced how to find “my one”. Some examples: • Coming from the same culture avoids lots of potential mis-understandings. • Having the same “love languages” (Chapman 2009) lets both sides feel loved, effortlessly. • If one of you is “The Highly Sensitive Person” (Aron 1996), it’ll help a lot if both are. • I’m very auditory (as opposed to visual), but for 50 years I didn’t realize how influential that was. It’s why I remember so much of what I hear, and love music, and distill-out patterns-over-time, and love silence, even during conversations, and notice what is NOT said, and dislike noise and interruptions. After I figured it out, I found Melanie, who is also auditory. Now we don’t need to argue about noise in our house. You see how it works? We turned out to be so similar that when we went shopping for floor-tiles, we independently picked the same design, out of thousands. Thus I learned to trust her choices. We even had similarly stone-walling ex-es, and helped each other understand why — we’re both analytical, too — and with all honesty and sympathy, nothing left to hide. The more similar psychology, the better the understanding, the easier the agreement, the more appreciation and happiness.</p><p>Do you see any looks or status (size, health, career, rank, wealth, education) in the above selection criterion? No. Such superficial criteria… That’s what animals do. NONE of that is any reason to think a relationship will be good. We’re mostly animals in our teens and 20s (evidence: in “Bachelor In Paradise”, hot-ness over-rules everything, for both sexes; they make me wonder how any marriage ever survives), and we’re enticed to stay mere animals, by advertising, which wants us hooked on products and services they can sell us. It’s an ANIMAL TRAP.</p><figure><img alt="Even birds care about looks and status." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/469/1*wABVTNVpLE79De1uUyZoYw.png" /><figcaption>Even tiny bird-brains can select for looks and status.</figcaption></figure><p>Vendors can sell us everything but the one thing that matters most:</p><blockquote>Humanely and deeply understand each other, first. Animal attractions and other boxes-to-check, second.</blockquote><p>This priority has the salutary effect of always regarding each other as independently human, and not as, only here to be USED for what I want (including being used for sex, or fun).</p><p>Aren’t I merely saying that money’s not important, after all? No I’m not, because (a) that usually means “YOUR life’s time and worth are not important” which is an insult and a hypocrisy, and (b) money is as important as symmetry, which is the burden of this essay. Money is storage for the value of life-energy that goes into work INSTEAD OF having the life you want. It has always been that. My money, my choice; for both men and women, or for neither.</p><p><strong>EPILOGUE 4: DIFFICULTY IS NOBODY’S FAULT</strong></p><p>In Epilogue 3 I proposed that the solution was, “Look for your psychological twin”, I and explained why that was difficult. There is more to that difficulty, and it’s worth explaining, in hopes that we can all stop blaming “the opposite sex”, as it used to be called.</p><p>Melanie &amp; I watch “The Bachelor/ette”. The human dynamics are interesting, but “the math” is actually important. The star bachelor/ette is given 25 candidates of opposite sex (mid-20s to early-30s) and dates them to find 1 best match. Around the time there are 2 candidates left, the star bachelor/ette feels s/he could marry either of them, so 1-in-10 seem perfect, to them. I thought 1-in-10 was far too easy, which made my science-brain turn on. Can we get a better handle on that fraction of people who might match? Yes, because that Bachelor/ette show has been — unintentionally — conducting a very revealing science experiment. There have been about 30 bachelor/ettes, times 25 candidates each = 750 possible pairings. After some searching, you find only 5 actual marriages. That means two things:</p><p>#1 Of the 30 televised heart-throb engagements, 25 blew up after the show was over. But the young participants still think “the process works”. Like many humans, they don’t ask, “What do I NOT know about this?”</p><p>#2 More importantly, 5 actual marriages out of 750 possible pairings comes to 1 match per 150 possibilities. I’d like to say “good match”, but we don’t know how good those marriages are; and I’d like to say “random possibilities”, but they’re not random: The participants know how the show works, and must believe that 3 dates is enough to decide to marry someone, so they’re wildly-optimistic risk-takers, a.k.a. reckless. It’s very likely that, in the real world, the chance of a good match between 2 RANDOM people is far worse than 1-in-150. When you consider that half of marriages end in divorce, and of the remaining marriages, only some fraction is happy, it’s not hard to believe that the chance of a good match between 2 random people might be 1-in-1000. For rare people, it might even be 1-in-a-million.</p><p>A 1-in-1000 probability is a very bad bet. Instead, one must change the odds, by knowing what one is looking for, and knowing where/how to find it (see the next paragraph). If one lacks the necessary insight or self-discipline to solve that problem, the result will be, many bad relationships. After such bad experience (which is virtually inevitable in our 20s and 30s), most of us blame the people we’ve been dating, who just happen to all be the opposite sex! But it’s got nothing to do with the opposite sex. You think LGBTQ+ people don’t have all the same problems? It’s just far more difficult than anyone expects. That’s nobody’s fault.</p><p>Blaming the opposite sex is worse than useless because it avoids asking oneself the question that unlocks all the others:</p><blockquote>Why have I been so wrong?</blockquote><p>(Answer: read Harville Hendrix; get out of the animal trap; stop dating, casually get to know many real people.) Is the good-match problem so difficult that I should be using my human-brain to over-rule my animal-brain? (Yes.) What kind of selection criteria DO make a good match? (Truth before ego; reality before ideology and bigotry; empathy instead of criticism or contempt; similar family histories, deeply understanding each other; same “love language”; considerateness; and much agreement about what we like. I wrapped all that up as, “Look for your psychological twin” — assuming you are so qualified!) Where can I find, and how can I identify, people who meet such criteria? (Visit public places somewhat peculiar to me, phone down, eyes up, and strike up chats about personal stuff. The people you want will happily “get real”.)</p><p>When I had practiced that for 3 years, and then met Melanie, after only 5 seconds of hearing her voice I felt like I was having an out-of-body experience and stepping through a wall — like I already knew her = impossible. (Later, she told me that she also felt like she already knew me, before we’d even locked eyes. Neither of us can explain it. However, with only one such example, I can’t say it should be like this for everyone.) It took me 52 years to find her. Then it took us another 6 years of healing (much detail omitted), to earn a wedding week full of joy. She’s my one-and-only. All’s well that ends well, and we remain grateful beyond words.</p><p>Indeed, we now feel irreplaceable, to each other. This is quite the opposite of the “animal trap”, which makes people superficially interchangeable and therefore individually worthless.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FE5dPtkVCRsg%3Fstart%3D272%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D272&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DE5dPtkVCRsg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FE5dPtkVCRsg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8b32747357c493d16885b51889c755f4/href">https://medium.com/media/8b32747357c493d16885b51889c755f4/href</a></iframe><p><strong>EPILOGUE 5: ON SYMMETRY, ONE MORE TIME</strong></p><p>Melanie has read this essay, of course. She’s one of the few people on this planet that “gets it”, from many angles, having worked as HR. Now she’s the most hands-on, brains-on, sweat-equity general-contractor I’ve ever seen. For example, a kitchen remodel with herself as principal worker; and making my new working-from-home office functional and tolerable just because I have to be shut in there all day every day. In my tiny slivers of spare time, she makes excellent dinners, that are the best parts of my days. I don’t think of her as an employee, but she respects the life-time-cost of money, and delivers it too, and I appreciate that, deeply. I tell her she could do less, but she does it how she wants it.</p><p>Some readers might wonder, Is the juice EVER worth the squeeze? Absolutely yes. • If/when you find the right person — if/when you are so qualified yourself — there is no squeezing to do, it’s all just kindness. You’ll still irritate each other occasionally, but you’ll often realize that you’re doing the same thing to each other, so it’s more like “Oh, of course”, almost-never a fight. • My mother had a saying from The Netherlands: “Shared sorrow is half the sorrow, shared joy is double the joy.” • There is financial resilience against layoffs, ill health, or even, becoming disabled. • There can be love and sex that feel like, I’m happy now, forever. • It might even be possible to equitably raise a family.</p><blockquote>BUT, all of these are “the cart”, which can only come after “the horse” of deeply understanding each other. Putting the cart before the horse is, unavoidably, USING each other, and highly unlikely to succeed.</blockquote><p>A demand that men must pay for the first date is not only anti-symmetrical, it’s also putting the cart before the horse. (She may demand, he may refuse, or this could start a conversation.)</p><p>I’ll summarize the rest of this essay into a few bullet-points:</p><p>· Fighting for equality only when that suits women, is not symmetry, it’s supremacy.</p><p>· Those women who push their supremacy will find only lesser men (duh). (Same the other way round.)</p><p>· Having a reaction to anyone because he’s a man, and the continuing chatter about “women are like this, men are like that”, is all stereotyping, sexism, and bigotry. Avoid anyone engaging in it, for they cannot see the individual standing before them.</p><p>· I refuse to be shamed, or guilt-tripped, or apologize, for crimes I’ve never committed.</p><p>· The vast majority of men still sacrifice their life-times to working for their families, and can’t march for more human-time and father-time, because women decline to buy them food and shelter (as men have done for their wives forever, including when their wives went on strike, 60 years ago).</p><p>· Advertising is nothing but animal trap, AND it’s full of fantasies, some of which are toxic. How is it OK that ads routinely mock men now? THAT’S NOT FUNNY, shouted in the reverse direction, 60 years later.</p><p>· Intolerance, of alleged/perceived intolerance, is still intolerance, and therefore, hypocrisy. It’s still “You must live inside the box I define for you, or else.” See the next paragraph.</p><p>Does “diversity, equity, and inclusion” mean everyone EXCEPT straight white men, now? Please see Cassie Jaye’s documentary “The Red Pill” (it’s not about Red Pillers). I see, in Cassie, an excellent human. She’s a feminist film-maker who went out of her way to find out what she didn’t know (rare!), who listened through her own biases (rare!), and who got shut-down by feminist hot-heads yelling about “misogyny” and “hate speech” before they could’ve ever seen the film. Feminists shutting down a feminist discovering men’s issues — how intolerant, how disappointing. Voltaire knew the answer 300 years ago: “I [may] disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it” [S.G.Tallentyre = E.B.Hall, in <em>The Friends of Voltaire</em>, 1906].</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Red_Pill">The Red Pill - Wikipedia</a></p><p>I hope this essay will spread some understanding (that crucial word again) and help us to “stop digging”, but I know from experience that the people most in need of this essay will be the least likely to read it and take it to heart. We are all born with confirmation bias (self-justification, rationalization, unrealistic ideology, friends chosen to agree with us, echo chambers) versus asking, How might I (and all my friends) be wrong. And, we can’t yet mitigate one of Nature’s cruelties: IF we want children, we must have them before we know enough to climb out of the “animal trap” and find our “psychological twin”. Thus, it has taken me 66 years: born naïve, then idealistic but wrong; gain this perspective, suspect a solution, bet my life on it, and succeed; and realize that I might have something valuable to say, even today.</p><p>The video embedded above (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EAlDZ3Fcnbo">The complaint of modern women: the downside of being high-value</a>) covers a small part of this essay. Its last sentence is a cliff-hanger: “My own behavior reveals that I don’t believe that this is the appropriate basis of a relationship”. Hallelujah! What IS the appropriate basis? He doesn’t say. My answer is Epilogue 3, tested and successful:</p><blockquote>Get out of the animal trap, put away social media and group-think, stop dating, casually meet real people, think symmetry and beyond, and figure out how to find your psychological twin.</blockquote><p>Symmetry Not Supremacy! Symmetry Not Supremacy!</p><p>Out Of The Animal Trap! Out Of The Animal Trap!</p><p>Here’s a metaphor for, where we could (?) be going. It’s the finale of Felix Mendelssohn’s “Elijah”: “And then shall your light break forth”. Note the glorious back-and-forth between male and female voices. And the magnificent, soaring, 7-fold Amen. It wouldn’t be possible without both men and women. It makes me cry, with gratitude, and hope. “Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus Dominus Deus Sabaoth; pleni sunt coeli et terra gloria tua!” Maybe I’ll come back in 1,000 years, to see whether we’ve all grasped symmetry yet.</p><h3>Thank You For Clapping (Hold Down The Button!)</h3><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBLmxrq_FY-o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBLmxrq_FY-o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBLmxrq_FY-o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4725c333d60661f02f6997a67732fcff/href">https://medium.com/media/4725c333d60661f02f6997a67732fcff/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=83f5139bde90" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Versus Religion? Contra Karma (Part 4)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-4-dc91c45670ad?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc91c45670ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-between-lives]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[karma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-of-evil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-of-suffering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Oct 2024 22:02:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-07T02:14:38.745Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Trouble With Spirit Life Between Lives, And With Karma</h4><p>The following is an open letter I sent around to many people who teach reincarnation and/or karma as a foundation for morality or justice. I sent it around in 2018, and have received not one response, ever since. Shocking, I know. But also, that lack of response is a pity, I really am offering myself as an experimental subject. That’s the least I can do, given my philosophy of knowledge and belief.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-3-f4c24568a898">Science Versus Religion? (Part 3)</a></p><p>In a few months, in 2018, I read dozens of books, mostly by psychologists with PhD degrees, such as (in alphabetical order, among others) Michael Newton “Destiny of Souls”, Robert Schwartz “Your Soul’s Plan”, and Brian Weiss “Many Lives, Many Masters”. They report that some of their patients, under hypnosis, recall previous lives, sometimes dozens of them; spirit-lives between their human lives; and group-meetings of spirits, planning the experiences about to be lived, from all sides. Hence these authors provide an explanation of why we’re all here having the lives we’re having. For me, this amounts to a metaphysical theory, and I couldn’t resist thinking-it-through, in hopes that it might provide some answers I’ve been sorely missing for decades. After some thought, I came out disappointed, yet still hopeful that answers — scientifically respectable answers, even — might be found by these methods. This letter lays out the problem yet to be solved, and I’ve sent it to all the authors I could find contact information for. No response.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pP4jHlCh2SSj_QZC" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@purzlbaum?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Claudio Schwarz</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Ladies and gentlemen (I’m sending this letter to many people):</p><p>Please allow me to explain why I’m <em>unhappily agnostic</em> at all your books. I had a religious experience when I was 16, 50 years ago now, and have never doubted that there was a jaw-dropping intelligence in it. To this day it remains the most formative thing that ever happened to me. For some years after it, all my Christian Sunday schools and sermons came back to me, as if Jesus himself was teaching me about humanity, and how to live. Eventually, I found systematic theology non-practical, and church-attendance rote, and realized that, in my conversion experience, I had seen or heard nothing that identified any existing religion. Subsequently, I earned a PhD in engineering, and of course that education was pre-disposed that my experience was a delusion, while simultaneously teaching me to stand on my own discoveries! These contradictions drove me into epistemology, where I’ve now synthesized an answer that is satisfactory to myself.</p><p>Meanwhile, millions of conversion experiences and near-death experiences are hardly “no evidence”! There is <em>Someone</em> or <em>something</em> there. But what else do those experiences tell us? Unfortunately, religions, lay-people, and highly-trained scientists, are all prone to believing far more than is actually in evidence. Hence the need for the epistemology in Karl Popper’s “Conjectures and Refutations” (1962). In summary: Theories are (always) approximations of reality, and we can use them as such, but the goal is to refute them (with repeatable evidence), find better theories, and repeat. For me, this applies in all realms of life, from physics, to what I believe about the people I “know”, to what I believe about the God I “know”. We should “walk humbly with our God” — humbly enough to know we don’t know anything perfectly, but not so humbly that we swallow anything whole, neither church doctrine nor spirit guide. God, after all, should have nothing to fear from anyone’s search for truth and/or difficult questions.</p><p>The many books I’ve read, on reincarnation and life-between-lives, seem to agree at the scale of individual experience, but the theory doesn’t scale-up to larger immoralities. As most of the authors do assert that there is something-or-someone God-like behind all the spirit / after-life contacts you’ve had, the “problem of (the existence of) evil” continues to press. It’s perplexing to me, that none of you have addressed this problem, on any scale bigger than an individual person. I wonder if you-all — or those informing you — are carefully avoiding it?</p><p>The problem of evil leads quickly to three kinds of solutions:</p><p>1. There is no God, and nothing survives our death. (This is pseudo-scientific over-belief.)</p><p>2. There is a God but he/she/it cannot be all of: omniscient, wholly-good/loving, omnipotent, and just. (Karma is here, by setting our free will above omnipotence.)</p><p>3. God has all those properties, but he/she/it declines to account for evil. Effectively he/she/it is saying: “Contrary to what you see, trust me.”</p><p>You are unanimous against #1. You assert reincarnation, and karma on the scale of individual people, but let me ask you a few difficult questions about larger immoralities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0_3zRrte5OBSNZGL" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jontyson?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Jon Tyson</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>• If, as you allege, all kinds of sufferers (e.g. battered men and women) planned their own suffering before they were born, shouldn’t we let them have what they wanted? If <em>they</em> read, in your books, that they planned to grow from this suffering, shouldn’t we <em>still</em> let them have what they wanted? If, on the other hand, your books alleviate their suffering (as you claim to be hoping and practicing), then haven’t you defeated their plan?</p><p>• Apparently you (authors) are implying that some rape victims plan, before they were born, to be raped, they just don’t know it now? And you describe that the rapist is actually another heavenly soul reluctantly agreeing to commit the crime, out of love for the soul that wanted such a “challenge” (as Mr Schwartz found in some cases)? Do you think that this kind of agreement exists even when a platoon of Myanmar soldiers gang-rape 12-year-old Rohinya girls (e.g. on July 5, 2011)? If that was <em>not</em> “planned”, should we believe that the victims must deserve it, for being evil people in a previous life (as this is how karma “explains” suffering)? Or, if the victims <em>didn’t</em> deserve it, those soldiers are now evil people (of course they are), so will karma make them, in their next life, endure a similar crime at the hands of someone else? Will that someone-else then be made to suffer also? How does this ever end? What kind of “explanation” is this, really?</p><p>• How could any murder victim “grow spiritually” after their own death? Or, are murders planned for the benefit of the murderer? How do we <em>not</em> conclude — from your written hypothesis — that a serial killer is doing it for their own spiritual growth, and we should lovingly let him/her kill more people??</p><p>• Some of you write that we must forgive others because “we have all done it all” (crimes in previous lives). Indeed, there must be as many perpetrators as there are victims, but your published case-histories don’t reflect that. Your patients/subjects should be (but aren’t) reporting horror at their own brutality, as often as they report being brutalized. Somebody is suppressing half the truth, to be suspiciously innocent. How do you know that your subjects aren’t viewing who-knows-what-lives, with an obviously-unrealistic bias toward being victims, via some mechanism you haven’t noticed? Who can say whether your “spirit guides” and Masters might be colluding in a comfortable deception?</p><p>• When Germanwings flight 9525 crashed into the Alps at 10:30am on March 24 2015 — because the co-pilot, Andreas Lubitz, was committing suicide and taking 150 passengers down with him — was that an act of great love “pre-planned at the soul level”? Had all 150 people on-board agreed to that before they were born? Or, if that happened for the “benefit” of the passengers’ families left behind, how many thousands of people were present in the “planning room” when this crash was “planned”?</p><p>• Are we supposed to accept that our arch-villains Adolf Hitler, Josef Stalin, and Mao Zedong, were welcomed into the after-life? (Neale Donald Walsch wrote, in “Conversations With God”, that his God said exactly that.) If their 100 million civilian casualties (total) were all “planned”, those three people “must be” the most loving souls of all time, each of them teaching millions of souls many valuable lessons? Or, will karma impose suffering on those three, for their next <em>million</em> lives? Or, did all those deaths not matter so much, since souls are eternal anyway?</p><p>I’m sorry, but your books make no sense to me. In fact, I feel short-changed, by y’all not even raising these questions.</p><p>Perhaps you can find answers. I’d like to offer myself as a subject in your investigations, in part because I suspect that my mind might be the right kind of unhappily-realistic “filter” for the questions I (and other analytical people) want answered. Besides the problem of evil, I would also love to explore:</p><ul><li>The topology of time (calling it an “illusion” is a feint, I think it’s a dense lattice, maybe depictable with Poincaré maps),</li><li>“Vibrations” of what medium, at what frequencies,</li><li>“Dimensions” and “planes” not as metaphors, but relative to those notions in physics,</li><li>Can “soul energy” be observed via any kind of device, present or future?</li><li>Might it be possible for me to “remember” a previous life, “see” something physical, and then confirm its existence in the present day — without the possibility that I somehow knew/read of that thing before I “saw” it, of course.</li></ul><p>Disappointedly Yours…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc91c45670ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Versus Religion? Practical Epistemology (Part 3)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-3-f4c24568a898?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f4c24568a898</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[language]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Oct 2024 20:50:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-07T02:12:36.643Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*y0iLI3hk8SuFgp8c" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@crimsonmiraclet?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Ariel Tang</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>EPISTEMOLOGY (n): The philosophy of knowledge. Investigation of what distinguishes justified-or-true belief from possibly-biased, ill-informed, or incorrect opinion.</p><p>(This series starts here:)</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-what-a-silly-question-part-1-587268ba4512">Science Versus Religion? Silly Question. (Part 1)</a></p><p>A very-up-tight special case of epistemology is the philosophy of science. The 2nd-most important book I ever read is Karl Popper’s “Conjectures and Refutations” (1962). It proposed that we <em>approach, converge toward, </em>the truth via experiments that reveal the flaws in our theories. Said differently, we may know that certain data are true, but we can never know that a theory is true, even though a good theory is as reliable as truth itself, surviving decades or even centuries of practical tests — until it doesn’t, if an empirical flaw appears.</p><p>I’ve since lived life that way. I was born knowing nothing, and everything I now “know” is an approximation to the truth. As I live, I “pick up” theories (concepts, mental models) imprecisely, e.g. I might think I know what a “tree” is, but do trees include conifers (no leaves), or palms (no bark and no branches), or aspens (one shrub the size of a forest), or trees-to-be 5 cm high? Below, I “blow up” the concepts of “men” and “women” the same way — anyone’s theory of those nouns doesn’t “hold water”, either. There are much more abstruse theories, like (human) “culture”. We even hold theories about people. I know (some of) the reactions I expect from my friends, but I can always be wrong in my theory of their personality. (Who people really are, is more important than my wish to be right, my ego.) Being correct requires careful observation and diligence. Indeed, the sooner I find myself wrong again, the faster I converge to the truth. Understanding correctly does not come for free.</p><p>But nobody goes around applying the ideal scientific method to everything — you can’t do any/all experiments on people — and hence I’ve long known that there are very important domains of truth beyond the present-day reach of science. And yet, I’m also too disciplined/philosophical to believe-what-I-like-whether-it’s-true-or-not; or even, to believe something equivocal. Consequently I’ve slowly wrestled/relaxed Karl Popper’s philosophy of science to the point where it now matches my experience/practice.</p><blockquote>Marcel’s Personal Philosophy Of Knowledge:</blockquote><blockquote>A. A phenomenon is true, if-and-only-if it is unambiguously observed (at least once).</blockquote><blockquote>B. A phenomenon is true AND communicable, if-and-only-if it is unambiguously AND probably observable.</blockquote><blockquote>C. Absence of <em>unpredictable</em> evidence is not evidence of absence. (Absence of <em>predicted</em> evidence <em>is</em> evidence against a faulty theory. This is a minor correction of Carl Sagan.)</blockquote><blockquote>D. Lots of people believe what they like, whether it’s true or not. I try to believe what’s true, whether I like it or not.</blockquote><p>This is much, much weaker than Karl Popper’s criteria for science. For my purposes: testable isn’t necessary, controllable isn’t necessary, measurable isn’t necessary, objective isn’t necessary, reliable isn’t necessary, predictable timing isn’t necessary, a mechanism/model isn’t necessary.</p><p>I can even let go of probably-observable (backing-off from #B to #A) when it suffices what <em>I</em> know, even if I can’t communicate that to anyone. A single miracle that is unambiguously observable — via pre- and post-examination, or feeling it first-hand — proves beyond doubt that there’s something very important going on outside the realm of (present-day) science. I may or may not have witnessed miracles, I don’t know. I went to faith-healing meetings where others believed miracles were occurring, but I couldn’t tell, and got worried about people falling down on-stage and just lying there, so I was called “O ye of little faith.” I wished I could’ve taken some of those “miracles” to a hospital for examination.</p><p>If I want to convince anyone else, or let someone convince me, I want the evidence, and I want it “unambiguously and probably observable” (#B), meaning that I want a strong-enough signal that’s not debatable and not mis-interpretable, and I want it either preserved and immune to tampering, or re-observable in much less than a life-time.</p><p>Without all that, there’s nothing left but “Believe me” and “You’d know it too if you weren’t so negative!” In that shady region live the entire new-age/new-thought movement, many religions, karma, voodoo, ghosts, UFOs, and everything I carefully don’t swallow. (But I can’t argue they <em>don’t</em> exist, either, see #C.)</p><p>I like to single-out beliefs about whole genders (in both directions) as <em>not known</em>, for failing my criterion #A. Whole surveys-of-surveys have examined the human race and have failed to measure, with at least 95% confidence, any distinction between the thought/feeling competence of “men” and “women”. Notice what I said: I don’t care which brain regions are working harder, A-for-effort proves nothing, I said (there’s no confidently-measurable difference in) <em>competence</em>. Unfortunately there’s boat-loads of popular press that confuses brain-activity with competence, and doesn’t even mention statistical confidence levels. All of that is merely selling readers what they’d <em>like</em> to believe (#D). Nobody has ever shown that men/Mars women/Venus is real. Many of us <em>assume</em> it’s so (a.k.a. confirmation bias, prejudice, self-selected friends, echo chambers), without ever testing that assumption by (a) living in close quarters with our own gender, or (b) asking LGBTQ+ people whether <em>they’re</em> Mars or Venus (we’re <em>all</em> odd and biased).</p><p>In the previous paragraph I put “men” and “women” in scare-quotes because, once you take epistemology of any kind to heart, you discover that words, such as nouns, are merely random sounds that mean nothing in themselves, they only relate to <em>concepts</em> in one’s head, which concepts are usually very poor approximations of what’s real. There is no set of people you can identify as “men”, no set you can identify as “women”. There are far too many of them (roughly 4 billion of each) for you to identify each-and-every member of those sets of people. There are only a few in your vicinity, only a few you’ve ever heard of. There is only the abstract notion (concept) in your head, making you feel <em>as if you might </em>be able to do such an identification, and <em>as if</em> those sets have clear criteria/definitions; but they don’t. You can’t resort to genitals: there are intersex people. You can’t even resort to genetics, with XY=male and XX=female: There are cis women with XY chromosomes, and people with XXY, XYY, XXYY. You can’t resort to stereotypes: I’ve known women who’ll never admit they’ve gotten anything wrong, and refused to ask for directions, and wouldn’t even admit they’re lost. There is no group “men” nor group “women” to admire for anything, nor mock, nor blame, for anything. Every noun-concept, indeed every word-concept, is deliberately an over-simplification of a dizzying natural variety. That mere naming-of-simplistic concepts is how/why language is possible at all. But lots of us are completely blinded by words, never-mind everything mere words can’t say, and everything mere concepts can’t do justice to.</p><p>Despite my caution about what to accept as truth, I’ve still had to “ditch” much of the scientific standard, for my beliefs outside the domain of science, because: Ask <em>me</em> the same question twice and you won’t get exactly the same answer. Two people who know me will not agree what I’m like. Scientists can’t demonstrate that I’m the same person from one day to another, or that there is anything resembling the folk notion of “personality”. But let’s not be stupid: I exist, and I am who I am, scientific opinion be d@mned. The same is true of a certain other Person whether he/she/it has a body or not — I have personal experiential evidence of that (#A) that I cannot write off as a delusion. But for some reason, scientists will swallow me whole, personality and all, on no more evidence than my physical body, while for any dis-embodied Person, the standard of proof is so high that even I wouldn’t meet it.</p><blockquote>Science is a tiny subset of believe-what’s-true, and believe-what’s-true is a tiny subset of believe-what-you-like.</blockquote><p>It’s taken me “forever” to be so clear about it.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-5-0eb3e4dde7fc">Science Versus Religion? “Here, I Am” (Part 5)</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f4c24568a898" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Versus Religion? Contra Scientism. (Part 2)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-contra-scientism-part-2-017e445fb9d7?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/017e445fb9d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Sep 2024 23:22:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-26T23:23:47.299Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Science Versus Religion? Opus Contra Scientism. (Part 2)</h3><p>First take the log out of your own eye, then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7-DGbXRaYJmPNet4" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@marcospradobr?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Marcos Paulo Prado</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’ve had-enough of pseudo-scientific atheists (Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Christopher Hitchens, Bill Maher) climbing onto a pedestal and claiming victory. As if the fields of science have no skeletons in their closet, no assumptions they cling to religiously, and no arrogance! So this essay is an explanation, and catalog, of the many, many ways that some un-philosophical scientists, the public, and especially silly-men like Hitchens and Maher, exaggerate what science knows and can do.</p><p>Let’s begin with an uncontroversial statement (see e.g. Karl Popper’s book <em>Conjectures And Refutations</em>): Science is empirical and refutational, which means: If you can’t measure something repeatedly, and so test/refute your theory, then it’s not science. Theories must posit only natural laws as explanations because, of course, if you’re allowed to explain things with God or miracles, you can explain everything, and learn nothing. So the scientific method proceeds as-if only natural laws exist, and then makes them up as needed, like covering a puzzling hole with ragged patches of cloth stitched together. It may or may not end up being pretty: Some big holes have plagued physics for 100 years (mentioned below). Nevertheless, (atheistic) naturalism is built into the scientific method. That restricts what can be called “science”, and that’s fine.</p><p>But an operating-assumption is not a fact. That mere operating-assumption doesn’t mean that everything not-science is second-class. It absolutely doesn’t mean that “If you can’t measure it repeatedly, and so test/refute your rigidly-naturalist theory, then it’s not <em>real</em>!” More concisely, “If it’s not natural (measurable), it’s not there!” That’s a statement about what’s <em>not</em> natural, so that’s not a scientific theory. In fact it is naturalism as a faith, which is called “scientism”. I’m about to refute it, good ‘n hard. But until now, such nothing-ing of everything-that’s-not-science is exactly what some/many of us seem to think and feel, and some of us are intimidated by it, despite the many absurd consequences (listed below).</p><p>Careful science knows that we may-or-may-not really know what we think-we-know now, because we can always find ourselves wrong-again. In fact, we already are wrong-again:</p><ol><li>What are dark matter and dark energy? They’re not in our theories and they’re not measurable on Earth, they’re only showing-up vast light-years away.</li><li>The 100-year-old incompatibility between quantum field theory (for very small things) and general relativity (for very large things).</li><li>We now believe that neutrinos have non-zero mass, and therefore the Standard Model of elementary particles is broken.</li></ol><p>But none of this makes scientism any humbler.</p><p>(The likelihood of being wrong-again is also why climate scientists are reluctant to sound sure. They won’t know their climate models are close-to-right until their predictions are right — too late to prevent serious global warming — and even then they’ll only be not-wrong-yet.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XXVnPzkZKYeaYIT4" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@markusspiske?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Markus Spiske</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Here’s a laundry-list of all the things science doesn’t know now, and might never-ever know:</p><ul><li>All the so-called “soft sciences”. For example, you can’t do the same experiment on the same economy twice, because the first experiment will perturb the economy, and you can’t roll it back to the same starting-state, so no-one can replicate your experiment. So economics is not science, but do economists know nothing, and economies aren’t real? Tell them that.</li><li>Similarly psychology. Because nobody can measure my personality directly and completely, and predict how vast numbers of situations will elicit vast numbers of responses from me (and not the same response every time, either), therefore my personality doesn’t exist? Don’t be stupid, Mr Scientist.</li><li>Some things are potentially-measurable but so difficult/expensive that they haven’t been measured and modelled. Personality might be one. The quality of music or poetry might be another. “I can <em>imagine</em> quantifying it” is not “It <em>has</em> been quantified, validated, and published in peer-reviewed journals”. Blithely jumping-to-conclusions across that gap is precisely what science <em>doesn’t</em> do, because it’s likely to be wrong. So science is practically-limited by what’s affordable and actually-done!? Who knew?</li><li>It’s <em>impossible</em> to empirically observe that something <em>doesn’t</em> exist. Show me it, not-existing, not anywhere? That can’t be done. So trash your atheism. Trash your pseudo-science argument that humans are “nothing more than meat-machines” (Dan Dennett). On the contrary, nobody knows for-sure-for-ever that we <em>don’t</em> have souls and don’t survive our physical death, and no scientist can observe (yet) what does/doesn’t happen to us after we die.</li><li>It’s also <em>impossible</em> to empirically observe that the laws and constants of the universe have been constant since the Big Bang — this is taken on faith. And BTW, the Big Bang amounts to, “Give us one inexplicable miracle for free, and we’ll figure out the rest!”</li><li>But science needs more such miracles. It is alleged that a soup of dead chemicals gave rise to the first self-reproducing molecule — before natural selection could apply. Nobody to this day has created a self-reproducing molecule from dead chemicals, and the odds against it are stupendous. So how did it happen? Wherever there is no demonstration, there is scientific faith. BTW, someone <em>making</em> it happen in a test-tube would pollute naturalism with intelligent design, so that’d be a self-defeating demonstration. See the controversy around the book “The Signature In The Cell” (2009).</li><li>For all we know, evolution <em>is</em> guided. Maybe a small change in some creature’s genes made it grow to twice (or half) its size in one generation. Science merely assumes-on-principle (naturalism) that such things never happen. It’d look like a gap in the fossil record, and there are lots of those.</li><li>Every human is different from both their parents by 30 mutations or so. In general, the more complex an organism is, the more mutations occur between generations. Why does science believe that <em>every</em> mutation is “pure random chance”? That’s quite a faith you’ve got there. Prove it.</li><li>Who-knows what kinds of radiation- or force-fields we don’t know about yet. Once-upon-a-time we didn’t know there were Xrays, therefore they don’t exist, what superstitious nonsense, don’t waste your time looking for them!</li><li>Why can’t there be a “free energy device” driven by a kind of field that mainstream science hasn’t discovered yet? 200 years ago, electromagnetism was in exactly that situation and a coil of wire near a lode-stone was a “free energy device”. Today we call it a dynamo, alternator, or turbine.</li><li>There are a vast variety of effects that are never-ever going to be subject to controlled experiments. Near-death-experiences, for example, because causing them is un-ethical.</li><li>Why does anyone think that CT- or fMRI-scans of brains have anything to say about mystical experiences, when nobody has ever had (and probably never will have) a spontaneous mystical experience while lying inside a thumping brain-scanner? And even if a mystical experience did happen right-then, the scan would prove nothing, no matter what it saw, because brain-activity not-equals the experience, nor the cause of the experience. And administering psychotropic drugs to make a “mystical-like” experience happen, tells you nothing about really-mystical experiences, or why/how they happen spontaneously. And happen, they do — there have been millions.</li><li>Speaking of which, subjective experience isn’t measureable, predictable, and refutable, therefore it isn’t real? Don’t be stupid, Mr Scientist. And don’t be stupid, Mr Philosopher. I searched the world-wide-web for a philosophy of knowledge (epistemology) that allowed subjective experience to be real, and couldn’t find one! 2½ thousand years since Plato, and our internal lives are as invalid as God is. That says it all, doesn’t it?</li></ul><p>So, get back in your box, Mr I’m-an-atheist-because-science-is-the-answer-for-everything-there-is, you’re <em>waaay</em> over-reaching.</p><p>While we’re here, let’s consider a couple of other angles. Some atheists/scientists like to portray religions as pyramids of authority without any reality-checks on their doctrines. Well, I’ve seen science be a pyramid of authority too, with “elder statesmen/women” at the top, controlling the contents of journals and conferences. The “scientific process” is <em>nothing</em> like the rational debate lay-people think it is; it’s actually a food-fight for publication space, wherein (for some scientists) any excuse to reject someone else’s research is a good excuse, because “I” need to get attention for “myself”. Big advances are not accepted over-night, some take decades to become accepted even though they were right the whole time (for example, the discovery of penicillin by Ernest Duchesne circa 1890, not by Alexander Fleming in 1928; similarly plate tectonics took 50 years, from the 1910s to the 1960s). “Science” is a very human, very egotistical process (see Thomas Kuhn, “The Structure Of Scientific Revolutions”, 1962).</p><p>Well-known joke: Why are academics such hard-fighting, un-cooperative prima donnas? Answer: Because there’s so little respect to fight over!</p><p>So I walked away from being a relatively successful academic researcher, and became an engineer, because in engineering there’s no room for my-ego-is-bigger-than-your-ego BS. Either you cooperate to get a thing working, or Nature will prove you wrong quick-smart.</p><p>What about the reality-check angle? Obviously, science observes physical matter and energy, and corrects itself … eventually. How about, religions are correcting themselves too, replacing their creation-stories with the scientific story? But, religions also have sacred texts subject to interpretation, plus lots of human experience, accumulating to this day, that they blithely ignore. So I concede this point, and only this point: Religions could make use of more data and a broader reality-check.</p><p>This is precisely the point atheists seize on when they attack (all?) religion, and then they push this point too far, also: “Science is willing to correct itself because it can be wrong about <em>everything</em>. Are you (religious ones) willing to correct your belief about anything, let-alone <em>everything</em>? What would it take to make you admit there is no God?” You mean, besides atheists needing to back off from the above-listed stupidities, after which there is <em>more</em> room for God? I still smell a rat. Let’s take the first half of that challenge and render it:</p><blockquote>Science doesn’t know anything for-sure-for-ever (because theories can always be wrong).</blockquote><p>Dear Pseudo-Scientist, do you know <em>that</em> statement for-sure-for-ever? If you answer Yes, you know <em>it</em>, and you’ve just contradicted your own statement. If you answer No, you don’t know it, so why do you bully other people with it? You’ve become the religious authority you claim to detest.</p><p>(I see an atheistic meat-machine exploding, after realizing that it was trapped in its own paradox. Even Socrates, 2400 years ago, was too smart to blow himself up with that one.)</p><p>But to answer the challenge myself: I have personal experiential evidence, of a once-in-a-lifetime nature, that a non-physical, transcendent intelligence exists. The scientific method, correctly practiced, will never be able to demonstrate that he/she/it does not exist. Science may assume, as hard as it likes, that God is doing nothing; that doesn’t make it so. Applying “Hitchens’ razor” (“Anything that can be asserted on no evidence can be rejected on no evidence”): I can safely reject that God is doing nothing, and have fun making an atheist’s head explode (again): I assert that “If natural laws are <em>not</em> just figments of your pattern-seeking imagination, but are actually obeyed by Nature (at least until you realize that you’re wrong again), then that’s so because God is making it so! Go on then, prove me wrong.</p><p>Meanwhile, even miracles aren’t incompatible with those laws-you-don’t-really-know. Yes, miracles. I’ll let you in on a secret: We engineers routinely build in a “back door” to every computer, including our Mars Rovers. Nobody can tell that it’s there — it’s all physics as usual — until we use the “back door”, and then we can do things you (users, operators) can’t. I like to call them “miracles”. If human engineers have thought of this, you think God didn’t?</p><p>Here are some examples of currently-known “back doors”.</p><ol><li>Genetic mutation, maybe it’s not <em>always </em>an accident.</li><li>Quantum states are probability distributions, maybe what you measure isn’t <em>always </em>a random draw.</li><li>Chaotic processes, like the weather, require super-computers capable of modeling the quantum states of every molecule involved — again maybe not <em>always </em>random.</li><li>The emotions and thoughts of every human on earth, maybe we aren’t <em>always </em>free from divine influence.</li></ol><p>Poor atheists… start by proclaiming that Man is God, and they get to decide what’s true and real… and end by concluding we’re all as meaningless as dirt. Enjoy, I guess…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*nq2xUmBgV0kqR8xa" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@benhershey?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Ben Hershey</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>This series starts here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-what-a-silly-question-part-1-587268ba4512">Science Versus Religion? Silly Question. (Part 1)</a></p><p>Next episode:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-part-3-f4c24568a898">Science Versus Religion? (Part 3)</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=017e445fb9d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Versus Religion? Silly Question. (Part 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-what-a-silly-question-part-1-587268ba4512?source=rss-0800d13b1e3c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/587268ba4512</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marcel Schoppers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Sep 2024 23:49:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-28T20:41:57.326Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>There is an epistemology that makes room for most of both.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8pPEHgLvp6NJFIx5" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@neom?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">NEOM</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>This is, in part, a response to <a href="https://medium.com/u/f5171a454ea">Clem Samson</a>’s article:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-haven/scientists-climate-change-is-the-least-of-our-worries-0b3bc2d90676">Scientists: Climate Change Is The Least Of Our Worries</a></p><p>“This” is, what he calls “belief”. On one hand, how refreshing, to find others thinking about, what we believe or know, and how ego gets in the way, a lot. (Even in scientists. The classic book about that is Thomas Kuhn’s “The Structure Of Scientific Revolutions” (1962).)</p><p>On the other hand, Mr Samson has gone too far, from post-ego to post-belief. Many commenters on his article have observed that Mr Samson believes in giving up beliefs. He has fallen into the trap of the so-called Socratic Paradox, which is: “I know that I know nothing”. But Socrates, 2,400 years ago already, was too smart to say that. On one account, he actually said “I know nothing except that I know this (statement).” But even that is open to debate. Today, there’s a better answer, three paragraphs down.</p><p>The big question is epistemological: How can we know anything? Is knowledge “justified true belief”, or is that a regress, because now we have to know what’s “true”? Isn’t “science” the modern pinnacle of what we know, evicting religion? Not so fast, there are several very important details in the way, and those details point to a wholly different kind of answer: The tentative adoption of beliefs, which, with diligent observation, can converge to the truth, and might even already be true. But it is not for any mere human to decide that they <em>are</em> true. Even the popularity of a belief has nothing to do with it: Every belief began with one person who was all alone in the world, for believing it, but that didn’t make him/her wrong. Does that mean you’re “entitled to your opinion”? Yes for preferences, No when there is presumed to be “the truth”. That seems indisputable, since any belief that there is no truth reduces to “This belief is not true”. If this is all very confusing, let me explain…</p><p>Mr Samson takes “science” as evidence that an after-life doesn’t exist. So he believes in “science”. But he goes too far: This particular use of “science” is un-scientific! (Physical) science is a <em>methodology </em>that realizes it can’t <em>usefully</em> explain anything by reference to gods or miracles. This does not rule out gods or miracles actually existing… until the methodology is turned into a belief system of its own, namely: If you can’t repeat it (as opposed to, waiting indefinitely) and measure it (as opposed to, observing or feeling it), then it’s not there at all. This is <em>empiricism</em> or <em>scientism</em>, a faith, and it’s absurd. You can’t measure my feelings, so they don’t exist? You can’t roll <em>me </em>back and repeat the same experiment on me twice, so <em>I</em> don’t exist? In fact, once upon a time, almost everything we call “science” today was unreproducible and unmeasurable. Electromagnetic fields, and brain activity, for example. The <em>scientism faith</em> should logically say, There’s no such thing as subjective experience. (What fMRIs measure is electromagnetic, not experience. Taking correlations for granted is what science does <em>not</em> do.) On the contrary: Science is <em>still</em> merely stumbling haphazardly into the great unknown. Science can <em>never </em>say “It doesn’t exist”. Maybe we don’t understand time properly yet. There might even be ghosts, for real (though probably as unrepeatable as I am).</p><p>I take Karl Popper’s famous book “Conjectures and Refutations” (1963) as the beginning of a philosophically satisfying solution. He dispenses with the repeatability part; a <em>scientific </em>hypothesis is anything you can conjecture and test/refute. I’ve generalized it beyond science, to this:</p><blockquote><em>All conjectures, hypotheses, theories, beliefs, concepts, even nouns, are approximations, subject to refutation/correction by evidence, such as personal experience.</em></blockquote><p>You haven’t had a near-death experience <em>yet</em>? “Absence of evidence (to you) is not evidence of absence” (Karl Sagan). If/when you do have one, and come back from being dead for (say) 15 minutes, the last-gasp-brain-activity “explanation” of near-death-experiences will seem a lot less plausible, and you will find yourself having apparently-irrefutable evidence no-one else can evaluate. That doesn’t make it false. It just makes you one of the luckiest, and probably calmest/happiest, people on the planet.</p><p>Prof. Popper further qualified that <em>scientific</em> beliefs <em>must</em> be refutable. There does seem to be a truth scientists are approximating better and better as time goes by. We can never <em>know </em>that we have it 100% correct now (subject to future refutation), but we may well be 100% correct about some things (just not <em>knowing</em> that we are). That draws a boundary around what qualifies as “scientific”, for now. It doesn’t make un-scientific beliefs false. Again, science will never be qualified to pronounce that things don’t exist at all. Maybe, on some exoplanet, there are unicorns, and pigs fly.</p><p>One of my favorite lines as an engineer is, “Your Ideal Gas Law is very nice. Too bad (it’s only an approximation and) there’s no such thing as an Ideal Gas!” So, how do we decide whether an aircraft is going to fly through our atmosphere’s mixture of non-ideal gases? We test the real thing and push it to its limits. That’s a potential refutation. “Go on then, make me wrong, and I’ll learn something.” Post-ego, but not post-belief. Indeed, my designs make allowances for my being potentially wrong, even in ways I can’t guess at yet (unknown unknowns).</p><p>Let me put my version more sharply, like this: If you pride yourself on being scientific/empirical/rational, you cannot have a <em>scientific </em>hypothesis that there is no God and no after-life, because you cannot test that. You can believe that those “things” don’t exist, only by abandoning your claim to be scientific/empirical/rational — or, by hypothesizing that (current) absence of evidence <em>is </em>evidence of absence, but that hypothesis has been proved wrong many, many times. In other words, you can rationally be agnostic, but you cannot rationally be atheist.</p><p>Let’s hit this point hard. The nature of God is a hypothesis. There have been many logical arguments that God doesn’t exist. More precisely, there have been many logical arguments that <em>some hypothesis</em> of the nature of God is <em>logically inconsistent with easy observations</em>. Most of these are arguments against the Christian hypothesis of God, who is assumed to be all-mighty, all-knowing, all-good. But, what if that hypothesis is not precisely correct? (For example, Karma, and some versions of Christianity, posit that God gave humans free will and allows us to suffer the natural consequences too.) Then, what the arguments against “God” have achieved is, knocking-down a hypothetical straw-man. Which is fair enough; it’s similar to arguing that the Ideal Gas doesn’t exist… and yet, here we are, breathing. Even if we manage to refute, as being inconsistent, <em>every</em> hypothesis we can come up with about the nature of God, we will have “logically proved” only that there are limits to the expressiveness of our logic. We already knew that, as scientists have remarked that “Nobody can make [logical] sense of quantum theory”, and similarly, Kurt Godel’s Incompleteness Theorems proved that there are mathematical statements which can be neither proved nor refuted by arithmetic over the natural numbers. In other words, reality is under no obligation to abide by our (limited) logics. Hence, eventually, one comes to an existential choice: Am I entitled/empowered to <em>decide</em> what reality is? The only sensible answer to that is, No, I’m not. Am I entitled to <em>decide</em> that God does not exist, simply because none of my own God-hypotheses are consistent within my own logic? No, I’m not. God may be someone I don’t (maybe can’t) understand at all. And that’s not strange: I also don’t (maybe can’t) understand many other persons.</p><p>Here is the point almost-everyone gets wrong. Near the beginning, I said very carefully: “… it is not for any mere human to decide that [hypotheses, beliefs, whatever] <em>are</em> true.” No amount of confirming evidence makes anything 100% true; and absence (to date), of refuting evidence, proves nothing, either. We can only decide that beliefs are <em>false</em>, when we have refuting evidence. There is only one way to believe that something is <em>true</em>, and that is, if you first believe in (accurate!) revelation from an infallible source. <em>Deciding </em>that something is true is, declaring <em>yourself </em>to be such an infallible source. That’s arrogance, hubris, and humanism. Sometimes I suspect that that is “original sin” (which doesn’t mean that I believe it).</p><p>My own philosophy has converged to the following two ways of saying the same thing: “Get real” and “Truth before ego”. In physics, if I get it wrong, a machine will do something nobody wants. Physics doesn’t care what I believe. Only animals and people can be bull-shitted, and only for a little while. In relationships, if I get it wrong, people will react differently than I expected them to. In physics and in relationships, all my self-justifying rationalizations and defensiveness (ego) will not help; they will only get in the way of me learning something = correcting my beliefs = getting a better approximation/model of the world.</p><h3>. . .</h3><p>Unfortunately, due to most humans mistaking confidence for truth, only over-confident blow-hards get elected. We elect people to run countries, who would fail miserably as engineers or diplomats. Therefore, wish us all luck, we’re going to need it!</p><p>(PS: A friend of mine has written a book about how a government would work if politicians could think like our best systems engineers, or if the electorate would only realize that they’re electing the very opposite of the humility that’s needed to make systems work well in practice.)</p><p><a href="http://engineersmanifesto.com/">Engineer&#39;s Manifesto</a></p><h3>. . .</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@marcel.schoppers/science-versus-religion-contra-scientism-part-2-017e445fb9d7">Science Versus Religion? Contra Scientism. (Part 2)</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=587268ba4512" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>