<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Marco Nuzzaco on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Marco Nuzzaco on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 17:44:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[For and against psychoanalysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/for-and-against-psychoanalysis-5378e3794cf4?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5378e3794cf4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freud]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[werner-herzog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marco Nuzzaco]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Sep 2026 18:35:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-07T18:35:20.030Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QqO_Kx91HUFpE7YZlFrQAg.png" /></figure><p>Haven’t you noticed that today therapy has never been so popular? We are increasingly surrounded by friends, partners, colleagues, you name them, who are in analysis, or who, at a certain moment in their lives, decide to go to a shrink to talk about their problems. We know the motivations can be varied. Personal growth, to go over a past/toxic relationship, resolve past traumas with their parents etc. Everyone seems to join Portnoy in a collective complaint, and that is not, or is it? exclusive of a certain social class, a bourgeois fad so to speak, but it is increasingly extended to people of different social extractions. Like a mobile phone, a holiday to an exotic destination, reached through a low-cost flight, so it is your therapist. I’m not going to spend hours boring you with sociological explanations, theories or whatever can be about a capitalisation and commodification of therapy. It is hard to tell whether it’s a true necessity dictated by our lifestyles, needs or just a well-being activity like Pilates, Yoga, a ceramics course or horse-riding. You choose it. Anyway, it is because of this mass explosion that I was thinking of the reasons for and against it. It might be a pointless exercise, I know, but I found an interesting pastime somehow. That’s what I’ve come up with.</p><p>Reasons for: Popper would say that it is just a form of pseudoscience, like astrology or acupuncture. You cannot falsify any of its statements: I can’t find the right person for me, “well, that’s because of the Oedipus complex, you still have a sexual bond with your mum that blocks you”. I actually can’t stand my mum, “well, you are probably in denial, and that’s why you cannot find the right person for you if you keep hating women”. I never said that. I don’t hate women, you say. Well, maybe not all of them, surely no more than men. And you get a dry reply like, “see, you are in denial again. Are you sure about it? You said something interesting now. This thing about men could be related to your dad. We should dig deeper into it”.</p><p>All right, maybe. Maybe that’s too harsh. One reason for: it might not be scientific, all good, but no one can deny that the ideas of the <em>Id</em>, the unconscious, the interpretation of dreams, the libido, our slips of the tongue and transfers have significant merit in our civilisation. One can add that they are a proper watershed between the 19th and the 20th century in our history of ideas, and we keep hearing that, exactly like the Copernican revolution, evolution, they changed how we perceived ourselves in the universe, especially in relation to ourselves. Before Freud came around, it was enough to say <em>I think, therefore I am</em> to be sure that we were rational beings, conscious of ourselves. And then it took one guy asking questions to women lying on velvety sofas in Vienna to show that we are not so rational after all! And it is not just about the power that our genital organs exert on our lives, a proper slavery, trust me, that causes so much pain and suffering, tears and divorces. But then Jung came and said that it’s more than that! All art and religion and culture can be understood as a manifestation of the unconscious, of Platonic archetypes, of symbols through which we can interpret and find ourselves and traces of our past. Not too bad!</p><p>Anyway, before you get too excited about it, and hail our therapists as the new healers of our past traumas and broken marriages, you should not forget about the authority that we are bestowing upon them: in the past, priests were the only ones who knew everything about our secrets. It only needed a confessional and a few <em>Our Fathers</em> to know who was cheating on whom, the sins of unfaithful husbands and dissatisfied wives. Today we have replaced the priest with the shrink, who is inflating our extreme individualism in the name of our happiness, who has become the depositary of our misdeeds, fears, secrets and dreams.</p><p>You can object, however, that I should not be so drastic, oversuspicious and dramatic. I could hear now the voices of an array of rejuvenated patients vividly and confidently hollering from their tribunes that after all, therapy helps a lot of people overcome their problems, understand their past and other aspects of ourselves of which we were not aware before. A good chunk of them would add that it can be a healthy way of calling oneself into question, to see situations, relations with other people, our whole lives from different perspectives, and that it is not a bad thing either if it can help people to grow and become who they want to be. A nice hoard of fierce feminists saying that it can be conducive to important and better decisions for our professional careers, our jobs and our relationships, which otherwise people would never start. A fabulous tool of emancipation to empower minorities. How can you argue against that?</p><p>But then came Herzog. Yes, the film director, the one of <em>Fitzcarraldo</em>. I was on the couch, scrolling compulsively on <em>Instagram</em> to fill up the void moments of my days, which — and that’s between us — are becoming increasingly numerous, long and frequent, when I heard him thundering from the little screen that I hold in my hands that psychoanalysis is a stupid mistake, a catastrophic event of the 20th century. He said that wanting to explain every dark and little corner of our soul is a very unhealthy, dangerous and stupid thing; and that we should not do that, period. He used an analogy that struck me. He said that when you live in a house and want to explain every dark corner of it, then it becomes just uninhabitable. I was musing for a while as that got my thinking: mustn’t there be secrets that we should not reveal even to ourselves? Shouldn’t we keep something inside us as a mystery? Is this the secret lying behind any form of art and creation, behind our imagination, behind our freedom, folded in our dreams, buried in the nooks and crannies of our memory and past experiences? Do these dark corners contain the reasons that keep us curious and alive and never reconciled with ourselves because we will never be, at any rate? Can our demons be our guiding angels? What if they are the local and perennial dwellers of our abodes, our guardian spirits and our Lares, instead of uncanny and invasive intruders?</p><p>I guess one can interpret the quote as it pleases. I leave it to you. For what concerns me, whether for or against psychoanalysis, I take it as a way to admit that we should probably surrender to the fact that we’ve got to live with our contradictions no matter what, without being afraid of dark corners. They will always be there. It is just a matter of sharing spaces with our uncanny hosts.</p><p>It’s a good metaphor. Can you tell me more about it?</p><p>Who are you?</p><p>Well, I am your therapist, and this is our weekly session.</p><p>Oh, is it?</p><p>Well, I am afraid it is. And you better come to yourself if you don’t want to be referred to a psychiatrist with a diagnosis of schizophrenia.</p><p>Alright, alright. I was letting it go a bit too loose.</p><p>Well, I have seen it. And I think it’s ok for today. We can keep this conversation about contradictions for next session if you don’t mind.</p><p>Why? I was making very good progress.</p><p>I hear you, but our time for this week is over.</p><p>But that’s unfair!</p><p>Well, I am afraid it is. Maybe we can talk more about your feelings of unfairness next time.</p><p>That would take me a long time.</p><p>No problem. No rush.</p><p>Everything started when I read Karl Marx for the first time. I was gripped by the idea that money converts concrete human labour into an abstract tool of control measured by time. It was an eye-opening experience!</p><p>That’s very interesting. We can start from there next week.</p><p>Thank you.</p><p>Now, how would you like to pay today?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5378e3794cf4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[About Cemeteries]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/about-cemeteries-3de2d5b05762?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3de2d5b05762</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cemetery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marco Nuzzaco]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Sep 2026 22:17:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-06T22:17:36.533Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z9G6Ahzqz2AHIz3kuI6vzw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cimiterio da Saudade, Campians SP, Brasil</figcaption></figure><p>I´ve always liked cemeteries. Whenever I visit a new city, and whenever I am seeking a quiet place to go, I always make sure to take a stroll in a cemetery. I like the idea of slowing down time as I walk past the graves, losing myself in their alleys. Maybe it’s because I share with Morrissey that thought that <em>when you go inside and gravely read the stones</em>, you cannot help but ask, <em>all these people where are they now? </em>I’m aware that the thought might be sombre and depressing, and maybe it’s because often cemeteries are considered gloomy and depressing places, related to death, sadness, mourning, loss and melancholia. But there is something about them that attracts me. Some people would say that, after all they are peaceful and quiet places. Someone else might object that you feel that way until you don’t have a personal reason to loathe them or to go there in the first place. The burial of a dear person, of a parent, a sibling, the death of someone special that makes you reconsider your position in life, your priorities. A reason that causes you sorrow, an absence that cannot be replaced, the wrestling of your memory to preserve a presence and save a life from oblivion.</p><p>Some religious people from the Far East, Buddhists and Taoists, the Romans with their pyres, would rather cremate corpses instead of burying them. It’s much better to give back to nature what belongs to it, in a cycle of generation and destruction. Nothing can be created or destroyed but only transformed, to use the words of the Lavoisier’s law in a religious context. Or one could simply say, <em>for dust you were and to dust you will return</em>, to use words more familiar to our religious tradition, disregarding, however, any belief in resurrection attached to it.</p><p>One reason in favor of cemeteries over cremation is certainly the relationships that they have with memory. We go there to remember, to keep the memory of the dead alive. And there is also the memory of the dead: something is preserved from oblivion in a picture, a date of birth, a sentence. Minimal information, sure, but enough to raise questions about an entire life, a story, with secrets, unknown moments, grey areas, mistakes, resentments, sufferings, joys, a whole array of feelings and contradictions. Edgar Lee Masters knows something about it. Every cemetery can be a<em> Spoon River Anthology</em>. The relation with memory and death is then twofold: they can be reminders of death, places which work as <em>memento mori, </em>but they can preserve memory from death.</p><p>A more careful observer will see that cemeteries are places where time stops. At least the time of human consciousness. For Marc Augé, a place should be identity-forming, capable of creating meaning in virtue of its relationship with history and memory, in contrast with non-places like shopping malls, airports, and train stations, which are only transitional, where people are anonymous, and social ties are absent. Yes, in this sense, cemeteries are repositories of individual and collective memories; they are tied to our history and culture. That’s why some would still go to La Recoleta in Buenos Aires, Highgate in London, Père Lachaise in Paris and the Non-Catholic Cemetery of Rome, with the same interest and spirit with which we could visit a local cemetery of a small town or village.</p><p>With this in mind, we can take a further step back, focusing only on the binary relation between the places of the living and those of the dead through an image. Cemeteries could be seen as the bottom half of any city’s hourglass. Like grains of sand, each of the living inhabitants slowly falls from the little narrow passage that connects the upper half to the bottom half of the dead. Grain after grain, we can imagine the number of dead growing. Will the number of dead eventually be bigger than the number of living? One can replace the old graves with new ones, put the bones and ashes into ossuaries and urns, but the dead at some point will always outnumber those alive. We don’t know if we have already passed that moment, in our history, when the two halves were identical, containing the same number of grains, of living and dead. What we do know is that the dead will always outnumber the people alive today. We are all running down through the funnel, in the same way we follow the arrow of time. If cemeteries are our hourglass to measure the time of humanity, it won’t be wrong to say that they are not only the places where the time of individual consciousness ends, but also the physical time of humanity, in a world where no more newborn babies are born.</p><p>In his <em>Invisible Cities, </em>when describing the city of Adelma, Calvino makes Marco Polo say that<em>“we come to a moment in life when among the people that we met, the dead are more than the living”. </em>All the Hindus, Pythagoras, Plato and Buddha’s beliefs in metempsychosis, the belief in the transmigration of the soul, reincarnation, are the dream of humankind: to turn over the hourglass and start the count of the living, using the grains of the dead again to defy death in an endless cycle. No one will be there, unfortunately, to flip over our hourglass on the other side. In the <em>Phaedo</em> Socrates tries to defend the idea that dying is not something that we have to fear, Plato uses his argument from the opposites to show the immortality of the soul: life and death are opposite, but also complementary: life cannot exists without death in the same way cold cannot exist without hot, and presence of one is just the absence of the other in an eternal cycle of alternations. Peace for Plato, his idea won’t be sufficient: logically death is the absence of life, yes, but the absence of life is not a necessary condition for the existence of its opposite: presence and absence of life are not symmetrical, and they do not complement each other.</p><p>Consider now this simple fact: most of the dead are unknown to us. Nonetheless, when I look at their pictures on their grave, I often imagine them and me alive at the same time, at the same moment in history, crossing each other’s path. Then their faces suddenly become potential friends, maybe enemies, good colleagues, great loves that could have made me suffer, and who knows, maybe a wife who I will never marry. An impossible scenario, I know. Once again, the Platonic myth of the two soulmates looking for each other is broken fever. I know it well. But, as I sit in front of a tombstone now, I ponder that maybe there is a silver lining in this story: if none of these things are possible, then I promise myself to change my gaze on people after I leave the cemetery. I will try to see anyone who will cross my path and is now alive with me today, in this time, as a grain of sand in the same half of hourglass in which I am standing; a preset-time fella who, just by a lucky coincidence, is sharing the same time that we are given now, among anyone who is living and dead today. A thought experiment, a change of perspective to see and experience people differently. A mental exercise to embrace the whole of humanity from a different point of view. It is though this change of perspective that I understand better the meaning of Calvino’s words about the city of the dead, <em>Laudomia</em>: <em>“the cities of the living need to find in the cities of the dead the explanation of ourselves to be more confident and sure about us”.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3de2d5b05762" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Camus´ Stranger.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/on-camus-stranger-80fc382d4cd8?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80fc382d4cd8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[albert-camus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[happiness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-stranger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[absurd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marco Nuzzaco]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 May 2026 00:50:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-01T23:19:28.382Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OWz63l_j1lSagBOPVGrdpw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>On Camus´ <em>Stranger.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Happiness as the other side of indifference</em></strong></p><p>L´<em>Étranger </em>is not like any other book. At least for me. Much has been said and written about it, especially about the philosophy that it represents. A book about the absurd, the meaninglessness of life, certainly generated many interpretations and discussions, and it is still widely debated. Sartre famously read the book in his existentialist fashion, Colin Wilson in his <em>Stranger,</em> emphasized the sense of alienation and detachment of Meursault, Roland Barthes stressed the flat prose and the dry style of the language which reinforced the emotional distance and sense of absurdity. Recently there have been post-colonist interpretations. It is famous Kamel Daoud´s <em>Meursault Investigation </em>which retells the story from the point of view of the Arab, killed by Meursault; and you constantly see articles online, on newspapers, replete with Camus ´quotes from the book, references to happiness and to the absurd and so on. And now Francois Ozon´s film. Simply stunning. It starts with an intro which contextualizes the relationships between French and Arabs in Algeria before the war; and it ends with a moving scene out of the book´s plot, which tries do justice to the post-colonial criticisms received by the novel in the years, especially from the Arabic community, which shows the sister of the Arab, also victim of the abuses of Raymond, mourning her brother on his grave, with the blade of the sun reflected on the sea at sunset. A great film which successfully resisted any comparison with Visconti´s version and with the interpretations of Mastroianni and Anna Karina. It was actually Ozon´s film that gave me the opportunity to go over my personal ideas about the book. I always had clear and distinct ideas about it. I don´t expect them to be original, neither perfectly in line with the most famous interpretations reported above. This is, however, what I think and say to my students and to the people that ask me why I like it very much and what I think of it: I don´t think that Meursault is apathetic, alienated, emotionally disengaged at all. He is different from conventional people, that´s true, and he is a good example of an anti-hero. However, there is in Meursault a silent, underlying passion for life. I know it might sound odd if I put it this way. But I am happy to take this risk. So here I will try to defend my claim by putting forward two theses: 1. the book shows that happiness can be the other side of indifference, if by indifference we refer to the<em> gentle indifference of the world</em> as a lack of an ultimate meaning, not Meursault´s. 2: the book is a literary experiment to show how people, our society in general, react when threatened by too much truth and honesty that society cannot tolerate.</p><p>Regarding thesis 1, there are in the novel moments, passages of extraordinary beauty which I take as attempts to describe beauty itself. They sometimes break the dry prose and speak about his sensations and what he sees around him. Yes, <em>The Stranger</em> is a book of intense physical sensations as well as powerful images. Its ideas speak through its images, and through the physical impressions that it conveys to the reader. The short sentences and the dryness of the language well show his silence, what he does not say; but what he thinks and feels oozes from its language. It transpires through vivid and poetic pictures: the wind that coming from the hills, brings the smell of salt with it when he arrives at the homecare for his mother funeral in Marengo; the rows of cypresses leading up to the hills next with the scattered houses against the red and green earth. Many images of the sky are scattered here and there, together with numerous references to its light, they constitute powerful imagery. They are crucial elements in the first part of the book. The sky and especially the light do play different roles, and often they make Meursault a prisoner of his sensations: the heat in the morgue, the burning sun of the countryside during the funeral, and later on the beach: the scorching, ruthless and blinding light of noon, falling mercilessly and indifferently on everything and everyone without respite. It is like an invisible hand, and it seems to accompany and guide the actions of Meursault, and finally it directs him towards his fate: he passively surrenders to it when he is blinded by the light reflected in the knife´s blade of the Arab. The blazing and blinding light of the sun, under which he walks and reels on the beach, turns into his own destiny, and it becomes the only justification that he presents to his judge for his crime. Like in a Greek tragedy, the sun and the light act like external forces against which Meursault cannot oppose any resistance. He is transported by them to the point that his shooting seems an unmotivated twist of fate supported, however, by the underlying and unavoidable necessity of the unbearable heat and a blazing light that obscures reason.</p><p>But there is also the soothing light of dawn and sunset. This, with its reddish and pink shades, in many moments of the story, appears like a silent vision of beauty and a promise of passionate happiness. At the same time, however, he seems to sweetly relish what he feels and sees. Detached from everything, he watches the crowd leaving the stadium, the street starting to teem with people for the evening stroll, going to the cinema, the first lights of the lampposts against the reddish glow of the sunset, whilst he smokes on the balcony. Again, a passive spectator, a passive flaneur, a stranger indeed, detached from the crowd, he feels differently. But he also contemplates life flowing while the streets become alive after the hot Sunday and the unbearable heat that keeps people shut inside their houses, with the blinds closed to keep the houses cooler in the early afternoon after lunch. The imagery is not solely Algerian, but purely and exquisitely Mediterranean. It explains the fascination and the connection that Camus had not only with Algeria, but with Greece and with the entire Mediterranean civilization which inspired the pages of <em>Nocês</em>, <em>L´éte,</em> <em>Le Pensée Meridian</em> of <em>The Rebel.</em> All these elements are also present in <em>The</em> <em>Stranger.</em></p><p>An intense sensuality seems to pervade his relationship with Marie. Another weird and bold remark, I know. But I refuse to think that there is no tenderness, no passion in the swim that they take together, in the moment when he softly touches her breasts whilst helping her to get on the float, when he is laying on her stomach and listening to the heart beating softly. And later, when he is alone, he tries to find the salty smell of Marie´s hair left on the pillow. Many would find this image at odds with his dry replies when she asks him if he loved her, and he coldly says that that meant nothing to him. I take that as another brushstroke of Camus to deliberately paint a provocative character who does not believe in the hypocritical truth of absolute and conventional social values, but that nonetheless is able of passion, and that acts honestly and passionately whilst remaining honest to himself and to others. The logic of his actions is consistent through and through at his mother’s funeral, where he does not conform to the norm of what most people would expect that anyone would do in his place: crying, asking to see her one more time. But again, when looking at the sky, at the landscape in the evening, and also in prison, he says <em>´I felt I could understand Maman better´</em>, her melancholic relief, her desire to live her last past of her life with a fresh start, with the gentle company of someone beside her with whom share her days. No one had the right to judge her and pity her for it, not even at her funeral. I thought this was beautiful, a genuine form of compassion much more sincere and heartfelt than any common reaction that anyone would expect in a similar circumstance. Thus, all the scenes of the first part of the book contribute to put together a portrait which is very consistent: he is the same when he indifferently replies to his boss the moment he offers him a promotion in Paris, in his relationship with his neighbors, with Raymond, with Solimano and his dog. In all these circumstances, there is always a difference between what he shows and what he feels. At the same time, I´d like to think that the inner world of Meursault is a world full of passion, feelings and sensations. The world of someone who does find beauty in this world, someone who savours intensely the sensations that come with the feeling and the experience of being alive: the smell of woman on a pillow, the touch of her skin, the glowing colours of a sunset. Together with these feelings also come the despise for anyone who blindly conforms to empty norms, who recites empty formulas; whoever tries to justify their vices or weaknesses through lies and social conformity and hypocrisy. However, the book is not trying to teach any lesson, to impose or condemn any particular moral. It would have been too easy to do that, and I guess it was not Camus´ truest intention. I interpret in this way Meursault’s indulgence, or at least indifference, towards behaviours that any reader would find intolerable, like Raymond´s. This is why I think that Meursault is more of a symbol than a real character. It would be impossible to live in the way he does, without acknowledging and reacting to other people´s feelings like in the case of Marie´s proposal, or to people´s evil actions as in the case of Raymond. Yet, I see in him a symbol of all human contradictions, limitations, that at the same time feels and experiences beauty and loves without hypocrisy.</p><p>The second part of the book, his unmotivated murder, his imprisonment and execution are linked to my second thesis. The first part paints a picture of a character only to pave the way for what comes later. After the picture is sketched, it seems to me that Camus needed a pretext, an event, a cause to show what happens to a man like Mersault, somebody who does not lie and does not justify his actions in the way other people expect that anyone else would, especially in the eyes of justice. The scorching sun, the same as the day when he buried his mum, that makes him reel on the beach at noon, the fiery breath of the sea, and the dazzling blade of the Arab´s knife, are the forces which like Greek gods, weave his fate. They pushed him to shoot the four shots that were like<em> four knocks at the door of unhappiness</em>. He cannot fight against these agents; they are natural powers stronger than him, and they end up possessing him. They act on him with an unbreakable necessity against which he cannot do anything but surrender. The unfortunate contingency of his offer to take Raymond´s gun, completes the fulfillment of his fate.</p><p>In the eyes of the law, he ends up being responsible for his actions against his own will. But there is no acceptable motive in his defense. Or at least, a motive reasonably acceptable by societal morals and by the law. A well-crafted literary gimmick to show how people react when threatened by too much truth, and by the type of honesty that society cannot tolerate. Like Sisyphus’ boulder falling down from the top of a mountain, Meursault runs inexorably towards his fate without opposing any resistance, but instead he offers his honesty and his truth. This idea is supported by Camus himself in a lecture that he gave in the USA many years after the publication of the book, and which figures in the introduction of the 1955 American edition of <em>The Stranger:</em></p><p><em>“The hero of my book is condemned because he does not play any game. He is foreign to the society in which he lives […] Some readers have been tempted to look upon him as a piece of social wreckage. A much more accurate idea of the character will emerge if one asks just how Meursault does not play the game: he refuses to lie. To lie is not only to say what isn´t true, and, as far as the human heart is concerned, to express more than what one feels. This is what we do, every day, to simplify life. He says what he is, he refuses to hide his feelings and immediately society feels threatened”.</em></p><p>The whole trial is a literary test, and another symbol. The symbol of the absurdity of life itself: the more honest he is, the closer he gets to his death penalty. No one would reasonably admit the sun and the heat to be the truest causes of his action; no one would find good enough the answer that he loved his mother, but that was like for anybody else; or acceptable the fact the he had a romantic date the day after the funeral of his mother. He would not be an absurd hero if, instead of saying that he felt remorse and repentance for killing the Arab, he said that he was <em>annoyed. </em>A word, vague enough, which seems to evoke the blurred and confused sensation of having disrupted a natural order, which equally involved his life and the life of his victim, and at the same time the inability to communicate such a fracture in the order of things.</p><p>The trial shows that the judgment and the laws of men are not perfect, but it also reveals that there is no ultimate justice or providence that will restore the absence of an ultimate order. The belief in God, in a final judgement and the ideas punishment and redemption are just a form of escapism. They are an illusion, a lie to comfort men of the absurdity of life which affirms the lack of its meaning. In this scenario, the world becomes indifferent to us; it does not answer our quest and desire for meaning. Mersault knows about this, and for this reason refuses any form of consolation that any priest could provide. That would amount to lie to himself, and to turn his face away from the only reality that he knows. And yet, his passion still burns. I am also faithful to my thesis till the end, like Meursault is to himself until his execution. Even in prison, when he has lost all his freedom, Meursault finds something to fulfil his heart with a silent and tranquil serenity, hidden to the eyes of everyone, who find in him just an apathetic and dangerous man. He finds solace in the memory of his house, when — as in an exercise of inner freedom — he remembers every single detail of its furniture and its objects; when he looks outside the window of his cell and he senses <em>the sweetness of the evening coming on, </em>as he was doing on that Sunday evening watching the crowd going out of the stadium; or when he looks at the sky changing colour, waiting for dawn, soothingly approaching after a sleepless night. Little things which are enough to fulfil the heart of a man, as he will say in the <em>Myth of Sisyphus</em>. These were also the moments when we find him thinking that <em>a man who had lived only one day could easily live for a hundred years; </em>or when he remembers that his mother used to say to him that <em>you can always find something to be happy.</em> Signs of his passion in which the main message of the whole novel is contained.</p><p>I find it interesting that a book about the meaninglessness of life turns itself into an opportunity to talk about the creation of meaning. The final pages show that in the face of the indifference of the world, of an ultimate purpose, the task of creating and giving meaning to our life is ultimately in our hands, and it is not found in the world <em>a priori.</em> There is paradox at the heart of this truth, which could be glimpsed in the last few passages: if there is no ultimate meaning and we are not so special in the universe, we come to see ourselves as ultimately similar to anything else that there is in the universe; we are just one more part of it, and not an important one. At the same time, however, our ability to create meanings, to fabricate narratives and values, sets us aside from everything else. We are part of the same universe of stars, stones, and boulders. Yet, the life of our minds, our ability of bestowing and creating values and meaning — in the way art, science and philosophy do — detaches ourselves from everything that surrounds us. It is in this paradox that probably lies the relation between indifference and happiness. In this peculiar and paradoxical position, then happiness is no more a final goal, a state of mind or a fleeting emotion; it lies in the same very ability to accept the world and ourselves for what they are, with their pleasures and beauties as well as with their limitations and their contradictions. Happiness is then an offshoot of our power to build narratives around our own experiences, about our lives, and to accept them even in the face of the silence and the indifference of the world. This is what Meursault ends up doing: his apparent apathy vanishes in his outburst of anger when he sees all his life and the life of his mother with a new meaning; maybe a minimal one, but sufficient to make him say that he was ready to live everything again. All his silent but burning passion that made him feel alive in an existence void of purpose, finally comes out when he wakes up the night before his execution and he looks up to the sky filled with stars against face. The image evokes the Kantian line of the starry sky as something that fills the human mind with ever new and increasing admiration and awe. The moral law, however, is replaced in Meursault’s heart with the passion with which he lived his life. That is enough to give meaning to everything that he did, even if it had none. This is a negative truth, true, but sufficient to establish a code of conduct, as he says in the Myth of Sisyphus: to live passionately in face of the absence of an ultimate meaning and purpose. This is already a narrative, a new meaning <em>per se</em> which is born from this very reasoning. It is quite paradoxical, or we should probably say absurd, that even when Meursault says before dying that he <em>opened himself to the gentle indifference of the world</em>, a new meaning is born, even if that is to affirm the meaninglessness of life itself. This new meaning blooms the moment he feels closer to the world, in a night full of signs and stars just before dying. From this perspective we can see his happiness as the other side of indifference, if we respond to it with an unmotivated and burning passion which is indeed absurd but not meaningless.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80fc382d4cd8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On non-existing philosophical texts and philosphical pastitmes.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/on-non-existing-philosophical-texts-and-philosphical-pastitmes-b1e349334f4c?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1e349334f4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[language]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tractatus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marco Nuzzaco]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Apr 2026 15:57:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-11T17:40:35.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>On non-existent philosophical texts and philosphical pastitmes.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>An attempt at rewriting the Tractatus as a reflection on progress in philosophy.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Preface</strong></p><p>The text that follows was born by mistake, as an attempt to take notes about a lesson on YouTube. It is totally accidental, and (almost) unintentional. The only intention was to clarify some ideas to myself. The video was a divulgative lecture by Prof. L. Floridi, Founding Director of Yale&#39;s Digital Ethics Center, as<strong> </strong>part of a series called <em>Orbits</em>. Each episode discusses problems like the nature of reality, power, democracy, artificial intelligence, ethics, etc. A well-made attempt to divulge philosophical ideas for a large public to help us understand what it means to be human today and to live in a digital era. Anyway, the episode on reality caught my attention. I was trying to summarize it by breaking down the different parts of his arguments. I was in the thick of it, and I suddenly realized that the different ideas could be organized in a way that could imitate Wittgenstein´s <em>Tractatus </em>or at least inspire a short version of it.<em> </em>What started as a mere typing task, a philosophical pastime, turned out to be a challenging game: rewriting a famous text by keeping the form and its original style, but with the ideas of another philosopher. Imagine Van Gogh´s Starry Night painted in the cubist style of Picasso. Something like that; you pick your favorite analogies. Well, I took the game half-seriously, and this is what followed:</p><ol><li>The world is not only physical.</li></ol><p>1.1 The world does not divide only into facts, objects, and atomic facts, but also in ways of acting and ways of being.</p><p>1.2 Abstract nouns, such as justice, love, and democracy, are also real.</p><p>1.3 They are real in the sense that they are not <em>things, like chairs and tables, </em>but ways of acting</p><p>1.4 Adverbs express ways of acting that we add as qualifiers to nouns and the properties of nouns (adjectives).</p><p>1.5. Example: A pillar-box red car which moves quickly.</p><p>2. Qualifiers are as real as objects and their properties.</p><p>2.1 Our substance-properties philosophy stresses the reality of physical things over ways of acting.</p><p>2.2 This is a characteristic of our language, of speaking of things, properties of things, and processes that link things with properties and with other things which have other properties.</p><p>3. This is reality described by Predicate Logic.</p><p>3.1. This can be considered our commonsensical way of appreciating reality and how it appears to us.</p><p>3.2 This is a prejudice of our way of appreciating reality, but science and philosophy do show that reality is made up of events and processes and structures.</p><p>3.3 This prejudice is the result of embodied existence.</p><p>4. Our body acts with the external, whereby our language prefers to conceptualize our sensory impressions.</p><p>4.1 Our words signify in this way: nouns refer to objects, their properties are expressed by adjectives, processes are expressed by verbs, ways of acting are expressed by adverbs.</p><p>4.2 This is an advantage that allows us to abstract these ways of acting and transform them into other things: <em>moving quickly, living democratically, acting intelligently, loving tenderly.</em> This process of abstraction makes it possible to create further abstract nouns such as speed, democracy, intelligence, and love.</p><p>4.3 This is what we could call the furniture of the world as it appears to us to describe the processes around us.</p><p>4.4 It would be a mistake, however, to treat adverbs which refer to processes as to entities or substances that we could move as we move chairs and tables.</p><p>5. This would resemble Ryle’s category error: to search for intelligence in a machine, the government in a palace, love in a present, in the same way Oxford University won’t be the set of its buildings (additional comment, definitely not part of original lesson).</p><p>5.1 The world can be described differently not through the general form of a proposition, but according to different orders of logic.</p><p>5.2 The Logic of predicates allows us to speak of objects and their qualities. The logic of the second order, for example, allows us to describe qualities of qualities.</p><p>5.3 The logic of the second order also allows us to talk about the relations between ways of acting.</p><p>5.4 Thus, our ways of acting lie at the bottom, and our descriptions become layered and increasingly fine-grained as we scale them up adverbs and through different orders of the logic of our language.</p><p>5.5 They are the result of a process of abstraction which allows us to talk about processes, events, and relations.</p><p>6. In this way we find ourselves dealing every day with different ways of qualifying our ways of acting: adverbs, nouns and adjectives form the whole set of relations that later crystallize into the abstract concepts whereof we speak every day.</p><p>6.1 After climbing up the ladder, we will see our adverbs as the prior condition of our concepts: by qualifying actions, they contribute to show us the fabric of the world as a dynamic reality made of relations whose knots become the abstract ideas through which we are trying to grasp and talk about what otherwise will escape the abilities of our language.</p><p>6.2 Those who have opened all the Russian dolls will come to see these propositions not as meaningless, but as a way of clarifying our language.</p><p>6.3 It would be a mistake to find one single definition for all of our words, in the same way in which not all our definitions would be of equal value: it would be a mistake to find one single definition of love, intelligence and democracy without thinking about the way we act when we behave democratically, intelligently and tenderly, as it would be erroneous to have a single definition of a chair.</p><p>6.4 From what we said, we can also conclude that the sense of the world lies not outside, but inside it: by coming to see and recognizing how things interact and behave with each other.</p><p>6.5 Ethics is not the mystical: we come to see our ethical concepts, like goodness, justice and love, as tantamount ways of being and behaving, not reducible to a single definition — Moore’s naturalistic fallacy docet.</p><p>7 Only whereof we recognize how it acts and behaves, adverbially, whereof we can speak.</p><p>I´m not sure whether this kind of transcript does justice to the original ideas of Floridi´s lesson. It was just a short summary. For those interested in the full lesson, here is the link:<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOrM8FYgWdA"> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOrM8FYgWdA</a></p><p>The video ends surprisingly with a quote from the <em>Aeneid,</em> with the words of Dido, queen of Carthage, who, after promising not to fall in love with anyone after the death of her husband, Sychaeus, falls in love with Aeneas. The moment she realizes that she says: <em>“I recognize the signs of the old flame, of old desire” </em>(Aeneid, Book IV, 30–32). A nice quote that stresses the idea that our abstract concepts, like love, democracy, and justice, are the result of patterns that we recognize, of what we have been exposed to before; we have experienced that particular way of being or behaving, and even if not identical to other similar instances, we can recognise and name it despite the absence of a particular definition. This was the moment when I bizarrely realized that what Floridi was talking about fitted better with the later Wittgenstein of the <em>Philosophical Investigations</em> rather than the <em>Tractatus</em>. Maybe what holds together ideas of love, democracy, justice, etc., is at most a <em>family resemblance </em>between experience and fact, that we come to recognize as sharing something in common. This made me realize that maybe a philosophical text becomes a classic the moment it can be surpassed. Umberto Eco would say that it is like a survivor that was able to resist the test of time and become part of a canon of ideas that contribute to shaping our way of thinking. Ideas, however, are alive when they can grow, change, and assume different forms that turn them into new ones. This is maybe similar to the autonomy of World 3, which Popper talks about in his theory of three worlds. The Tractatus idea that language can express only propositions whose logical form can mirror facts could be seen as the step without which other ideas, like<em> family resemblance </em>and the idea of adverbs as capturing ways of behaving expressed by Floridi, would have never seen the light. The connections made here are purely arbitrary, and they are not meant to retrace a particular history of philosophical ideas. The trajectories and paths that philosophical ideas might take are unpredictable. But the idea that philosophical progress occurs thanks to the impact that texts like the <em>Tractatus</em> had on other ideas still holds, together with the fact that this progress is indeed arbitrary, and the result of a collective effort. Thus, it makes sense to say with Wittgenstein that we could understand his propositions only after we have climbed through them, on them and over them, and that now we can throw away the ladder. And it is probably the case of being silent too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1e349334f4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Philosophical images: on Whitehead’s remark on objects, events, and the power of abstraction.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@marco.nuzzaco_51307/philosophical-images-on-a-remark-of-whitehead-on-objects-events-and-the-power-of-abstraction-88fa4570191d?source=rss-f472b7bbdbad------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88fa4570191d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Marco Nuzzaco]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2026 00:11:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-06T16:58:19.707Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8QklFParEr_asP4-Mnbr-A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Philosophical images: on Whitehead’s remark on objects, events, and the power of abstraction.</em></strong></p><p>Camus once wrote about thoughts expressed through images. Russell expressed a similar idea when, in his <em>ABC of Relativity</em>, he said that we interpret the word pictorially. The history of philosophy is full of famous images that have conveyed powerful ideas about reality: Plato´s cave, Descartes´ demon, Kant´s dove flying through the resistance of air.</p><p>Talking about his Method of Abstraction, in <em>The Concept of Nature</em>, Whitehead came up with a less notorious but powerful image:</p><p><em>“The event which is the life of the Great Pyramid, yesterday and today, namely the Great Pyramid yesterday and the Great Pyramid today. But the recognisable object which is also called the great pyramid is the same object today as it was yesterday” p.77.</em></p><p>The Great Pyramid as an event, but <em>we</em> do see it as an <em>object</em>. The background of the quote is our ability to abstract qualities of entities, organise them into categories, and make different models with which we manipulate and tinker with reality. We do this all the time, with math and the natural sciences, physics and chemistry, but it is the same for the human sciences and philosophy. Floridi´s <em>method of abstraction </em>provides us with a good example of this process. The idea has a Kantian origin: we will never know how reality is <em>in itself</em>, but we can adopt different models by isolating different observables, that is, different aspects of a system, whatever this may be, to analyse it for a particular purpose.</p><p>Now, back to Whitehead´s quote. Imagine we could isolate the geometrical features of the Great Pyramid of Giza to calculate its volume; its architecture, its historical and geological features to learn about its age and history; and its archaeological and religious functions to understand the purposes for which it was built. We could abstract different variables — <em>observables</em>, with Floridi’s vocabulary — from the same system to analyse it from different perspectives.</p><p>One could rightly ask at this point: from what perspective is Whitehead considering the Giza Pyramid in the context of his process philosophy? My take is that it invites us to consider it not simply as an object among others, from a specific angle or a specific level of abstraction, so to speak; but instead from a general and very abstract view. We should imagine what looks to us just like a massive geometric solid made of stone differently: as an event instead of a thing, that is, a process which is <em>becoming</em> instead of a being, an entity in the solid sense of any materialistic philosophy. An event made of occasions, to say it with Whitehead’s jargon. That is, an event made of other events, a series of ordered occasions that cut a portion of the <em>space-time.</em> Not a pyramid anymore, but a knot of occasions ordered through a structure. Something like a sequence of “<em>successive notes of a song”, </em>Russell would say, that perdure so long as they don´t perish and, little by little, become something else: a grain of sand of the surrounding desert, molecules and atoms that are taken far away by the wind, subject to erosion, hit by the Sun’s photons, by the rain which slowly turns it into somethings else: other occurrences interacting with other things, maybe magnetic fields that transform themselves in other events:</p><p>“<em>In the case of the great Pyramid, the object is the perceived entity which as perceived remains self-identical throughout the ages; while the whole dance of molecules and the shifting play of electromagnetic fields are ingredients of the event”</em> p.78.</p><p>If these words serve as an interpretation of reality, I imagine the scene and my thoughts while staring at the Great Pyramid under the scorching sun, against a blue Egyptian sky. The city of El Cairo sprawling and almost devouring the pyramids with its outskirts. At their feet, queues of tourists waiting to enter, taking pictures and videos, and buying souvenirs before starting their visit. Imagine now a camera, a Super 8, filming the view from far away. A series of moving images, more dynamic and appropriate to any process philosophy. A photo would be more adequate to Wittgenstein´s picture theory. The camera slowly moves away, zooming out, and the contours and shapes of people, the pyramids, the outskirts, the surroundings, everything become less vivid and sharp as the distance increases, until everything else soon becomes blurred. The colours, the lines, and the shades of the pyramids´ sides merge with the colours of the sky, the fuzzy little dots of people below, the buildings in the background, like an impressionist painting. Then the distance increases further to the point that nothing can be distinguished from each other. The dream of a view <em>sub specie aeternitatis</em>. For a process philosopher it would be more appropriate to say <em>sub specie mutationis.</em> A continuous storm of occasions continuously becoming something else, intertwined with each other, being constantly born and constantly perishing, generating new occasions.</p><p>A flight of imagination, of course. But it allows me to picutre things and events beyond their solid apparent substances and their properties. I try to form an image in my mind consistent with what the natural sciences reveal: a reality made of events, processes and structures rather than objects. When doing maths, we abstract quantities and variables, and we deal with Platonic entities that represent “ideal events without any extension”. Physicists tell us that words like <em>electrons </em>and particles are already a form of abstraction, and that we should rather talk about <em>event-particles</em> to capture their dynamic and relational nature. But our language is more limited than our imagination, but at the same time imagination needs language to shape thoughts and images.</p><p>Science and philosophy remind us that reality can be quite chaotic if we were not able to model our sense experience without the categories of our mind. The reference is to Kant again. Deleuze wrote that philosophy, art and science <em>want to tear open the firmament and plunge into chaos. </em>That is the pars destruens of our knowledge. The <em>pars construens </em>teaches us that they help us create order to protect us from chaos itself. Any order is impossible without a little certainty, an <em>objective antichaos, so to speak, </em>the guiding idea of an external reality outside our minds with which we interact, and which we can organise and describe. In this sense I take Whitehead when he says that <em>“recognition is the awareness of sameness” p. 143, </em>and that <em>“we are comparing objects in events whenever we can say</em> <em>‘there it is again</em>’”<em>. p.144.</em></p><p>Back again to our pyramid scene. The camera gets closer, the contours become sharper and nitid again; the great pyramids still there, the people still waiting and sweating, still taking pictures, going in and out. Despite their constant and endless becoming, things take back their solidity. I imagine Whitehead, however, standing under the Great Pyramid and seeing no difference between two occurring events: the stones that have been there for centuries and the fleeting passage of a cloud above his head. In that moment of temporary respite from the heat, under the shade of the cloud, he looks at the pyramid and says: <em>there it is again!</em></p><p>Russell said that abstraction can have a practical power: a broker who deals in goods and assets does not need to have seen the stuff he deals with; he is interested in their values. The same goes for statisticians: they can make predictions without travelling to different places, or without having seen the stuff that someone else is producing. But I guess there is something else about abstraction. Besides its advantageous uses, there is another quality: the ability to subtract weight from reality. Whitehead´s picture returns to me an image of a fleeting and impermanent reality. The elegant quality of simplifying and reducing everything to minimal terms. Whitehead’s occasions reduce an event, a particle, a body, an entire society to the same minimal ontological level. Like a lowest common multiple, occasions are a reminder of any relational philosophy: we are (and we are surrounded by) processes and events. Everything becomes what it is because of relations and processes of other events before the <em>relata</em> that they connect, like a pyramid, a cloud, a person and an entire society.</p><p>After these considerations, I think of our language. I feel stunned when I think of words and nouns that stand for solid objects, e.g., tables, chairs, pyramids, and words that describe things that our perception considers dynamic processes and events, e.g., a waterfall, a storm, etc. The proof that language also works through abstraction. It gives solidity and stability to our experience. But we know that beyond the limits of our perception, reality is much more dynamic than what we can perceive. A precious reminder to our common sense that reality is not made of solid facts.</p><p>References:</p><p>Capra, F., <em>The Tao of Physic</em>s, 1976 Flamingo.</p><p>Deleuze, G., <em>What is Philosophy?</em> 1991 Columbia University Press.</p><p>Floridi, L., <em>The Philosophy of Information</em>, 2011 Oxford University Press.</p><p>Russell,<em> B., The ABC of Relativity</em>, 1925 Unwin.</p><p>Whitehead, A. N., <em>The Concept of Nature</em>, 1920 Dover.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88fa4570191d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>