<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Frein on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Frein on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@markfrein70?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 11:44:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@markfrein70/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Career Era of 2025]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/my-career-era-of-2025-015e948a6f2c?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/015e948a6f2c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[careers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Dec 2025 16:26:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-02T22:57:43.801Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We are blessed and cursed with memory and blessed and cursed with foresight.</p><p>The myth goes that Epimetheus, brother to the more famous Titan Prometheus, just plain ran out of positive gifts for all the animals and humans got nothing, so Prometheus took pity on us and gave us fire. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:La_tortura_de_Prometeo,_por_Salvator_Rosa.jpg">That turned out not-so-well for him as it pissed off Zeus pretty badly</a>.</p><p>I picture it all like a scene from some odd movie combining Clash of the Titans with Charlie Brown’s Halloween/Great Pumpkin where we humans show up to the door of two big bearded brothers and they say, oops, no more candy. Let us see what we have in the back …</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oeuUc6Zsaqahc4UkU_G_kw.png" /></figure><p>Epimetheus ran out of good stuff to give because being “past-minded” he couldn’t plan.</p><p>Well, we are indeed fundamentally past-minded just like poor Epimetheus, but fortunately we are also future-minded. The Danish philosopher Kierkegaard, half a century before Freud, theorized that when we are too past-minded we become depressed, and when we are too future-minded we suffer from anxiety. As with most things, the art is to find a balance in these powers and ride that line of balance through the waves of life best we can.</p><p>The challenge is to find the present. It’s remarkably hard to discover.</p><p>2025 was a very interesting year for me, career-wise and life-wise, and I conclude the year feeling that epimethean/promethean balance for the first time in decades. I weathered through some pretty big challenges but also experienced a ton of personal development in ways I did not expect and could not have foreseen.</p><p>Those who know me are already aware I’m a learning-maximizing person. In both good and bad ways, I tend to think about career and work opportunities as “what can I learn?” before “what can I earn?” Maybe it is an outcome-limiting principle, but I can’t help myself. It is hardwired in me so deep I’d have to stripmine it out if I wanted to (and I don’t).</p><p>But how did I get to this balance in 2025? I only really felt I found it recently, and it wasn’t easily earned. I’m writing now on a end-of-year holiday in Grand Cayman, and reflecting on the year, my state of heart and mind is radically different than it was earlier this year. My family got very upset with me on a different Caribbean destination trip in the early summer when I was such a wreck I couldn’t enjoy the first few days of the holiday at all. I was a disaster, constantly checking email, on Zoom calls, worrying about work.</p><p><strong>Coming into 2025</strong></p><p>For more than a decade before this year, I had spent time in the venture-backed technology sector as a C-suite operational executive (sometimes as a Chief HR officer, sometimes as a Chief Operating officer, often a mix of both roles). Most of my “stints” were with firms entering their highest growth phase — exploding with very large funding rounds and rockets burning hard to power past the market gravity wells and enter long-term exit orbits in IPOs or similar mammoth outcomes.</p><p>When you join “rockets” in the venture industry, you hope you might get on one that escapes into the rarified regions of success where you can choose to work (or not) for the rest of your life. But the Series A funding to IPO rate is very small (let’s liberally call it under 10%). Very small numbers of venture-funded firms exit for 1b+, and many fail to exit for more than the capital they raise which means that most equity grants given to most workers in startups amount to little if any value.</p><p>I didn’t really understand this when I first joined a venture-backed startup more than a decade ago. I learned fast. I keep signing up for the next stint not because I think my chances of getting on a big exit are any better, but because a) I keep being asked b) I’m very good at building functions in startups and scaleups c) It’s useful and emotionally gratifying to be sought out and paid to do something you are good at d) It’s sometimes/often fun for some/part of the time e) It’s <em>always</em> a learning expeience.</p><p>But it’s been challenging. I’ve been part of planning and conducting 10 downsizings over 10 years, sometimes including myself and multiple members of my direct team. Not an average you tend to want to put on your LinkedIn accomplishments, even if there’s an importance in doing all facets as well as you can.</p><p>The thing is that most of the venture rockets go up with speed and fireworks, just like actual rocket ships, then come down slow and with a lot less excitement. But hard work, sometimes really emotionally and intellectually hard work, is involved in the downward or stabilizing trajectory too.</p><p>Despite all of this I count myself as fortunate. I’ve had a fantastic career overall. “I’ve seen things you people wouldn’t believe” says Roy Batty in Blade Runner, as he reaches the end of his short replicant lifespan. The gift of working in the startup industry is that I’ve seen so much of business in such a short time frame … births, maturations, deaths, multiple times. I’ve seen almost every business mistake, made multiple times, and seen the more rare business strategy that actually works. I’ve seen businesses across multiple software segments from martech to edtech, from AI/data to HCM software. It’s like multiple careers compressed into a insanely high velocity decade … like a High-G rollercoaster, where you are breathless but walk out the exit and back into the entry.</p><p>Most venture success is sheer dumb luck, timing, and a lot of punishing hard work — in that order I’d argue.</p><p>I needed a break. I didn’t even realize I needed a break, which is in itself fascinating. In fact, I adamantly would have said to anyone earlier in 2025 that I didn’t need a break. I said as much to the wise and esteemed Molly Graham, who for years has told me I need to take more breaks. She’s right, of course. And, I finally did. At least mostly. :)</p><p><strong>What I’ve Learned</strong></p><p>For 9 months of this past year, I focused on working as a solo professional service provider. That’s the longest period in which I haven’t worked for someone else (and managed teams of people) since the late 90s. Enormous gratitude for my clients across AI/Robotics, non-profits, K-12 edtech, and AI/data. Learning(s): 1) I’ve still got my sales mojo, even in a tremendously challenging tech work market 2) there’s no use in pride when it comes to letting your network and fans know you could use referrals; referrals are where 95% of close-able leads originate; everyone needs help from time to time 3) selling my time on my terms is enormously gratifying emotionally in ways I always forget when I’m a W-2 wage worker.</p><p>Even if you aren’t a closet Marxist, you can likely appreciate the concept of alienation — a growing gap between our labor and a sense of self when we rent our labor in the form of wages for the totality of our work time. Particularly at risk are our creative abilities and imaginative powers. Stepping away from work-for-others and into work-for-myself this year has helped me pull together some fractured elements of myself — has helped unite creativity in and throughout my work. I haven’t felt “together” in some time in this respect. I’ve always been at my very best and happiest when I can bring creativity and my passions for music, theater, literature, games, philosophy into my “work” on a regular basis.</p><p>I learned about my coaching practice. I’ve done executive coaching formally (as a consultant) for almost a decade , and informally (as a senior HR executive) for another decade. I’ve had some amazing client experiences in the past — really breakthrough moments where I’ve felt I’ve grown as much as my coaching client. I was often younger than my executive customers through much of this prior experience. Where I’ve felt I achieved best results in the past is when I worked with my client on how their conception of self relates to their leadership choices — how self-awareness leads to the leadership performance they enact.</p><p>But this past year, I’ve realized that by far my biggest asset is my experience. I used to tap into my background as an educator and process consultant for my coaching, but I “woke up” to the funny reality this year that I frequently have 10 or 20 years of managerial experience more than my typical client nowadays. There’s a funny but oddly cozy humility with the realization that I’m older than my customers now. In my coaching work now, I move between different modes much more fluidly — sometimes “coaching”, but often being more of a think-plan-act-reflect partner with my clients. We work on business problems together, with me contributing my wisdom.</p><p>With more flexible time this year, I reached out to past work colleagues and friends more than I’ve done in a long while. When you are in the heat of extreme scale-up work as an executive, you barely have time for anyone — yourself, your family, your friends. That’s been my last 12 years, largely. This year, I had a bunch of conversations with people I enjoy, about “nothing in particular” (can’t resist the Smiths reference 🎸 ). I strongly recommend aimless and pointless conversations … we can forget the joy to be found in such things very easily.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/mark-frein_life-on-titan-life-on-titan-activity-7407520706848149505-w2E5?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop&amp;rcm=ACoAAAAFSuYBt0dmeys93hga9iUFEYC3WjTGeNk">I worked on music again</a>. I’ve always made time for music, even in some of my otherwise most frantic work-life periods. Music is a sacred creative space for me and rejuvenates me. However, oddly enough, I’ve done less music-making this year than music listening. My theory on this is that I turn to music as a bit of an outlet for stress. I’ve been less stressed, particularly through the back half of 2025. So I’ve <em>listened</em>. My big gains on listening in 2025 have involved Gustav Mahler, and I’ve devoured his symphonies and a biography.</p><p>I can’t say that I enjoy all of Mahler. Can anyone say that? But his 2nd symphony in particular (“The Resurrection”) has been something I’ve turned to repeatedly. Herbert Blomsted’s 1994 recording with the San Franciso Symphony is glorious. I’ve teared up repeatedly listening to this work. It feels like it is exactly where my own soul is at this year.</p><p>I started writing again, seriously, for the first time in almost 30 years (and have been paid to do so on one occasion). More on that hopefully in 2026 and beyond, but for now, it’s been wonderful pounding out paragraphs on the keyboard with a focus I’ve not had since my doctoral thesis. I was worried I’d lost my ability to write anything but Slacks, emails, or LinkedIn posts. But I’ve been able to find my writing “engine” again, which at its highest RPMs can do 5k words per day and not break a sweat.</p><p>I’ve learned about fear and anxiety. Fear of failing … to provide enough income for my family, to “win” in the job market, to achieve certain kinds of accolades, to achieve 5k LinkedIn followers ;). Our work world really can do a trip on us when it comes to the fear and anxiety of failing. I have friends and former colleagues that have done much better than I in the startup “lottery” and you just easily fall into a pattern of evaluating yourself as a comparative failure. The problem is that it’s incredibly difficult to reflect and find yourself not only “good enough” but deeply, objectively “good”, period. Which fundamentally means “at peace.”</p><p>We can choose the rulers by which we measure ourselves successful. I’m not such a devoted stoic that I believe all our suffering is in our heads, but what I choose to be proud of and how I represent my successes and particularly my pride in my achievements to my friends and family is what really matters.</p><p>I’ve been given an opportunity to explore resilience and emotional/mental toughness when it comes to my children’s lives. My eldest is struggling with unemployment during one of the hardest markets for young people in decades, and two of my other daughters have struggled with Crohn’s/Colitis throughout the year. Just this week, the fates sent a broken ankle/foot our way for my 11-year-old on our holiday. I hope for a better year for them in 2026, especially. For parents, hardship for our children is suffered 10-fold ourselves it seems.</p><p>Related, I’ve learned that solving for healthcare in the United States is clearly the generational economic problem we face. Among all the fears in 2025, the prospect of not having a way to find reasonable medical insurance for my family as a sole proprietor seems fundamentally at odds with how America ought to work. I’ll resist the urge to comment much on politics beyond noting that it actually gives me some hope that both left and right political camps at least to some extent are realizing we do not have a viable healthcare system in the United States.</p><p>In and around my children’s challenges, though, has been an ability to be present for them. That has been a great and powerful gift. The simple acts of helping with school work, cooking meals.</p><p>I’ve learned that having a supportive life partner — my amazing wife Jessica of now 2 decades+ — is crucial. Even when I’ve doubted myself, she hasn’t. Sometimes I can tell she’s worried as well, but she’s never worried about our ability to figure it out.</p><p>I have spent more time with close friends — laughing, enjoying shared interests. I’ve been more available and more energized around friendships and that has had the unsurprising effect of being an upward spiral. More energy to spend toward friendships means greater energy overall.</p><p>When I’ve been most stressed in the past, I’ve also probably exercised the most but also consumed the most. Being less stressed has had the interesting effect of being more in <em>balance</em> overall — consistent quality exercise, a growing dedication to my Tai Chi practice, better moderation in food, drink, etc. I hope to keep that up no matter what comes in 2026.</p><p><strong>In Sum, in Hindsight</strong></p><p>We are time-bound phenomena, we humans. We think forward, we think backward. At the boundary of physics there is speculation that the concept of time is something we fabricate because our brains are formulated to work with a before-and-after logic.</p><p>What we seem to really struggle at is thinking and being <em>present</em>. Maybe because it is logically impossible. What would it mean to think and be present? Already in completing the thought and typing the words the present is gone.</p><p>What 2025 taught me was that being here, <em>now</em>, is hard work. Being fully embodied in our moments, is difficult. Yet, it is <em>essential</em> work for our overall well-being and in the search for realization of a productive life, including a productive professional life. Our careers so often pull us forward in time and backward and time. Think of typical interiews: “What would you say was your greatest achievement?” and “What would success look like after your first 90 days?”</p><p>An odd question I think I’ll ask someone if I’m interviewing anyone in 2026 will be “Why are you here, now?” They’ll think I’ve lost my marbles.</p><p>I question I have asked people I’ve interviewed for client work in 2025 was “How can I make this 45 minutes we have together really helpful for you?” It may not be a perfect version of the question, but I was searching for something that took the better part of a year of my life to find: the grace of the time we spend together, however fleeting, and the shared meaning we gain from that those moments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=015e948a6f2c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HR and Ethics in the Workplace]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/hr-and-ethics-in-the-workplace-893774561c68?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/893774561c68</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics-and-morals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-resources]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Aug 2022 07:12:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-15T07:12:04.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By training I’m a moral philosopher. I spent more time studying to be a moral philosopher than any other single area of training or education in my life over seven years of graduate school. There’s no special certification that mints you a “professional philosopher” but if there were, I’m a card-carrying and proud member of that professional body.</p><p>When I was in my late 20s, I fully expected to spend the rest of my career as a professor focused on practical ethical questions involving how we teach and learn. Both my MA and PhD were in the areas of Philosophy of Education — I even wrote a Masters’ thesis on the ethical implications of testing in the public school system, which in many ways has similarities to the material I discuss in this essay.</p><p>Life didn’t work out the way I expected and eventually I ended up in the business world and over several career twists and turns became a People/HR executive in the technology industry. I would never have imagined that is where my career journey would take me. I especially wouldn’t have thought my academic and very theoretical background would have much practical <em>business</em> application.</p><p>Now, much older, and reflecting, it is clear to me that my training in ethics and philosophy has been a major contributing factor to the work I’ve done as an HR professional. To the extent that the People or Human Resources function is the primary business unit responsible for matters of human interest and human conduct, it is likely the closest thing there is to an “applied ethics business unit.”</p><p>This essay is an exploration of the ways in which moral philosophy can be a useful lens to investigate a wide range of business problems — culture, values, behaviors, and policies. In this piece I will use “ethics” and “morals” to be practically the same thing and use ethics as a shorthand for “moral philosophy.”</p><p>Fair warning: applied ethics and moral philosophy is as much, if not more so, about <em>asking questions in better ways</em> than it is about supplying answers. The 20th century giant of philosophy Ludwig Wittgenstein considered philosophy to be, in a sense, therapeutic in aim, addressing puzzles we create for ourselves in how we use language. Bernard Williams, another major figure in 20th century moral philosophy focused much of his work on showing why an overarching theory of ethics was likely doomed or, at least unhelpful. Similarly, I hold good moral philosophy to be about unpacking and turning problems around in different ways more than supplying rules or definitive answers.</p><p>Sure, answers must come in many business contexts. Yet the business world sometimes treats <em>impatience</em> as a virtue. The clamor for simple answers, fast resolution, and quick frames-of-reference is understandable given business pressures. This predilection for simplicity, speed … the “TLDR” mentality … is often unhelpful in imagining new opportunities and resolving tricky conflicts. Businesses tend to optimize for speed over depth of thinking. That’s likely the right tendency excepting for cases that are, in fact, deeply morally problematic.</p><p>Most importantly, philosophy is a form of thinking/speaking/writing and it is as much if not more about how you walk a road than the destination. I’ll be <em>doing philosophy </em>here and the subject matter is HR practices.</p><p>So how does ethics and moral philosophy come into play for day-to-day business problems?</p><p>At the most general level, many decisions in the workplace are about people and impact people whether employees, customers, or shareholders. Much attention has been given to the ethics of business outcomes from questions about impact on the environment to profit-making with high-priced pharmaceuticals.</p><p>In this piece, I’m going to focus exclusively on questions that face business decision-makers when it comes to standards of treatment for employees — the rules and norms defining rights, responsibilities, and “goods” due the employee (goods = pay, benefits, perks, promotions, etc.). This is the realm of human resources policy-making.</p><p>Employment law sets some hard boundaries for how employees are treated and depending on what country a business is operating within, those laws can provide greater or lesser degrees of employee protections. In the US, we have “at-will” employment which simply means that in almost all cases there is no necessary grounds for terminating someone’s employment. In contrast, in Canada, a business must provide some grounds for dismissal — “just cause” — or be required to give termination notice or pay in lieu of notice. Practically, it is rare in the US for no notice or severance to be given but the law doesn’t stipulate this as a requirement. Other countries can provide even greater employee protection.</p><p>The law is not the same as morality, but it is a backstop of a kind. An employer, for example, in the US can guarantee severance for departing employees. That isn’t legally required, but the company can decide it is the <em>right</em> thing to do (and the word “right” signals a question of ethics).</p><p>What many companies do is to codify both the ways in which they intend to observe employment standards <em>and</em> go above and beyond the letter of the law into a formal document: the modern literary marvels of employee handbooks.</p><p>While often maligned in corporate culture and ridiculed in comedy or satire on corporate life, employee handbooks can stretch beyond legal protection for companies into culture-definition. <a href="https://www.valvesoftware.com/en/publications">Valve Software’s employee handbook is both a good read and does its job</a>. When I was leading HR at one former employer, my team worked to design our employee handbook in such a way that staff would be proud to show it to friends and associates in other workplaces (and they did!).</p><p>Yet even the best employee handbook doesn’t address all possible ethical issues encountered in the workplace. The problems with relying solely on explicit rules in employee handbooks are:</p><ol><li><em>No document can be exhaustive or complete about all potential workplace behavioral issues</em>. You could imagine the mother-of-all-handbooks as some thousand-page volume that describes every conceivable thing a worker could do in the workplace and the associated response from the employer. While such a handbook would satisfy the desire for completeness and give the business something to point to for a wide range of infractions, it would still not contain all possible behavioral transgressions.</li><li><em>Stated rules are stated by someone and usually enforced by someone else</em>. My 8 and 11 year old children are already capable of pushing the envelope on reasoning around rules of the household: “Why can’t we stay up later tonight? Our friends get to stay up until 9 pm on weekends.” My spouse and I can provide a wide range of responses but as parents know, at the end of the day, the answer that stops the questioning is “Because I said so, that’s why.” The benefit to the employer or HR professional from having stated rules that lay out expectations beyond legal minimums is that it serves as an impersonal reference point when employees raise questions or when, in particular, an employee is being denied a “good”, reprimanded, or punished. We assume since something is written in a quasi-legal document, that it is sound reasoning, grounded, and/or somehow validated. But someone wrote it or copied legal boilerplate from someone else. Corporate handbooks however impersonal sounding are still a) written by someone b) and most importantly what is written only comes alive when someone chooses to enforce what is written.</li></ol><p>Regardless of how well-defined a workplace is when it comes to employment standards, rights, norms, and obligations, there is always interpretive and enforcement work to be done. This is often the role of the HR professional. Historically and still in some situations, HR is seen as the employment policy “police.” <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/microsoft-hr-layoffs-not-your-friend-former-vp-chris-williams-2022-7?r=US&amp;IR=T">This article was published recently by a former HR executive from Microsoft</a>. Williams’ quote on HR “not being your friend” is the sure thing to be re-quoted and misses some important points from him about the structural demands of the HR role. I do find his key points overstated for effect, however. <em>No one</em> is paid to be anyone’s friend in a workplace. An HR professional is paid to help the business perform by addressing human issues in the workplace and can do that impersonally or with empathy, respect, and caring. The best HR professionals take the latter approach.</p><p>“Addressing human issues” will involve interpreting policy where it exists on individual cases and advising the business (typically managers) on how to move forward on ambiguous and fuzzy aspects of such policy.</p><p>Let’s look at a couple of practical examples to see this in action.</p><p><strong>Example 1 — Open Vacation</strong></p><p>Instead of specifying how many days per year an employee can take as holiday, a number of workplaces in the last decade have adopted a policy (or absence of a policy) whereby an employee’s holiday time is, in effect, not tracked and, in some cases, not limited or bound, at least in principle.</p><p>Here’s one way the policy might be stated or written down in a handbook: “Take as much time as you need to be your best at work.” Sounds fantastic, very humanistic, and employee-centered.</p><p>The trouble starts in practice. Let’s listen in on a possible dialog between an HR professional and a staff member at an open vacation organization ….</p><p><em>Employee: “I need to take the next six months off to be my best. Is that OK?”</em></p><p><em>HR: “Absolutely not.”</em></p><p><em>Employee: “Why? I don’t understand. The holiday policy says I can take as much time as I need …”</em></p><p>[So we revise the policy: “Take as much time as you need to be your best at work. AND get your manager’s approval.” The typical answer to the employee’s objection is that taking that amount of time is <em>unreasonable</em> or some synonymous … that word choice being worth noting]</p><p>Later … after we’ve revised the handbook language.</p><p><em>Employee: “My manager said it would be fine for me to take the next few months off. I know I’m critical to the project underway right now, no one else can really do the key work required, but after speaking about it with my manager, we both agreed it’s a good time for me to take a solid break.”</em></p><p><em>HR: “Uh huh …”</em></p><p>[Back to the drawing board and likely now we are calling issue with the reasonableness or prudence of both the employee and manager’s decisions. We revise the policy again, and put the following in the employee handbook: “Take as much time as you need to be your best at work. Get your manager’s approval. AND your maximum time allotted for any one holiday is 2 weeks, with a maximum time over the course of the year 4 weeks.” To try to maintain the spirit of the original thinking, we add, “PLEASE take off all of your 4 weeks per year to ensure you can be at your best.”]</p><p><em>Employee: “I didn’t take off 4 weeks this year and it says you want me to take off 4 weeks per year. A lot of companies pay out for those remainders … or, can I carry unused time this year into next year?”</em></p><p><em>HR: [palm-to-forehead]</em></p><p>Most HR professionals have had very direct experience with conversations exactly like those above. We also have had the palm-to-forehead moments. However, every single question or statement by the “Employee” above is, on the surface,<em> completely</em> <em>reasonable from their point of view </em>even though the exact critique the HR professional would apply is one of unreasonableness.</p><p>Regarding the policy language itself, one could add further clarification and qualification to the policy statement — specifying no carry-overs, no pay-outs, etc. Although, it is worth noting that what started as an open holiday policy was revised with greater direction and clarity and essentially morphed into a pretty run-of-the-mill 4 week annual policy.</p><p>And whew. Well that solves it usually … excepting, of course, for the case where someone is a star employee, hasn’t taken much in the way of holiday for years in a row in order to advance the business, and asks to take a special holiday with family in one particular year that will push the maximum time to 5 weeks. To make matters even worse, the star employee threatens to quit over the inhumanity of a denial of the holiday request.</p><p>Oh boy, then what does the HR professional do?</p><p>In many the HR professional makes an exception or the HR professional is pressured or encouraged to make an exception by a business leader that wants to placate the star employee. In doing so, she/he/they open themselves up immediately to the understandable attack of playing favorites and being unfair and essentially ignoring their own guidance in the policy as set out.</p><p>This is where the heart of the matter lies and this is the sort of issue that HR professionals face daily. This is the Charybdis and Scylla of HR and those of us in HR know that almost any move out of problems like this makes our life harder.</p><p>To frame the problem most concretely:</p><p>Is it justifiable for the employer — as represented by an HR decision-maker — to make an exception to a clearly-stated policy meant to apply to all employees on the basis of the context of a case involving a single employee?</p><p>The word “justifiable” is a helpful signal in the paragraph above that we are in the ethical realm. Particularly, we are in the complex philosophical territory of justice and fairness.</p><p>As an outsider the snap answer may be “no, it is not justifiable to to make exceptions to stated policy.” Equally, to employees in general in this imagined company, the snap answer might be “no, that’s not fair” … unless you happen to be the employee in question. That employee, the star employee, may not particularly care that the policy will be violated, the fairness of its application called into question, and the integrity of the HR professional and others challenged. That employee may — again, reasonably — just want to catch an extended break after enormous effort in service of the business and believe (with reason) that she deserves special consideration given her contributions to the business success. To her, the policy may feel restrictive and not suitably generous. To her, she may be fighting for more generosity for all employees at said company. Hard to fault that person, eh?</p><p>It is simply the case that these are the real issues of applied ethics (as fairness questions) that HR professionals face on a daily basis. It is also the case that proclaiming what is the “right” answer on this particular case is at best unhelpfully vacuous and at worse misleading. If I were talking through this case with a colleague, I’d need to know more about the person in question. I’d need to know more about the case history for how judgments about exceptions have been made. Maybe I would come to believe the existing policy isn’t generous enough and this “case” is the impetus to revise it for everyone.</p><p>The more defined, exhaustive and “complete” the behavioral policies of an organization are, the less room for judgment is allowed for individual cases or the more problematic it becomes for decision-makers when looking at cases warranting individual treatment. In contrast, with no policies specified, there is ample room for discretion and judgment, but very little in the way of clarity to members of the organization on intent or rules-of-the-road.</p><p>Both the policy “loose” and policy “complete” approaches have benefits and drawbacks. Venture-backed startups (where I’ve spent the last decade of my career) are more typically on the “loose” end of the spectrum. Large public organizations, with a greater need for controls in general, are more typically policy-heavy and policy-defined businesses.</p><p>To complete our example, there are certainly <em>good</em> framings of open vacation policies that thread a needle between being so ambiguous that they offer no guidelines for employees and being so specific that they are, in effect, a standard and traditional vacation policy. Such a framing gives a sense of norms and guidelines but also specifically notes that exceptions can and will happen and are subject to review or approval (e.g., “We expect that in most cases, employees will take between 4–6 weeks of holiday. Holiday requests beyond the norm will be reviewed by the employee’s manager and HR”).</p><p>However, the point is this: policy alone is a set of written rules about decision-making. Policies do not make decisions. They are the text against which decision-makers interpret case situations and make day-to-day decisions. In many situations, those decisions are ethical in nature given they touch on fairness. They are complex, case-specific, and open to disagreement.</p><p>It is tempting to reference policy in the workplace and abdicate decision-making responsibility. I’ve seen this happen many times. A manager references an HR document in telling his/her/their direct report that they can’t take holiday or some other bad news item: “Well, I’d approve it, but the HR policy says I can’t.” Or sometimes even HR professionals themselves quoting policy and noting “It’s against policy.” People don’t like the responsibility of giving bad news — it’s natural. It’s far easier to point to a document written by who-knows-whom and at a point in time of who-knows-when.</p><p>Yet, at the end of each workday, <em>people</em> make decisions whether or not they wish to invoke the justification of policy documentation. World history has plenty of examples of individuals in power following the rules without owning their agency in doing so.</p><p><strong>Example 2 — Pay for Performance</strong></p><p>Let’s turn to a second example of ethics at play in the business world and the typical work of an HR professional. In the first example above, the question is really the limits of how tightly a policy such as vacation can be defined and the consistent application of that policy. Even there, we hopefully saw things are not as clear-cut as we’d think on first blush and <em>judgment </em>comes into play.</p><p>Where judgment becomes even more important — but also more problematic — is on the matter of pay.</p><p>The statement that a company seeks to “pay for performance” is one of the most common core principles of compensation in the modern workplace. At its heart, the statement means that differences in pay where they occur between the same roles in an organization should be based on performance (or put differently, variable contribution to the goals of the enterprise).</p><p>For many in the business world, it is an aphorism that elicits general agreement from business people without much discussion.</p><p>But why should anyone be paid differently in a place of work? As workers, we have notions of pay so ingrained in our consciousness that we don’t often ask ourselves this basic question. But it’s worth asking. Why wouldn’t every person in a company be paid exactly the same salary? That would be most equal, obviously. Would it be most fair?</p><p>In the history of businesses, we’ve adopted a wide variety of justifications and explanations for why people are not paid exactly the same. From the point of view of ethics, we should consider these to be <em>justifications of inequality</em>, noting that absolute equality is sometimes, but not always the most “fair” approach. It would not be reasonable or fair to treat a 5 year old child the same as a 35 year old adult in a variety of contexts such as obligations and rights in the community (and the law specifies as such). Where we pay <em>unequally</em>, we traditionally have come up with grounds for why unequal pay is a better and hence more reasonable and fair approach than absolute equality.</p><ol><li>We accept that different kinds of jobs pay different amounts [“<em>we” being business people in major democratic, capitalistic economies</em>]. This is typically explained (and justified) on the basis of supply and demand in the marketplace and scarcity and demand of skills (e.g., a software engineer is compensated more than a customer support person, a CEO is paid more than a junior line employee).</li><li>We do not accept that demographics such as gender, age, or ethnicity have any bearing on compensation. In many cases, we did at various times in history accept implicitly if not explicitly that these characteristics were acceptable reasons for differences in pay or lack of pay whatsoever, but (thankfully) we’ve changed our laws and beliefs on these matters. Of course, in many of these situations we still have a long way to go to actually realize equality of pay on the basis of these characteristics … an unfortunate reality in the history of inequality on compensation.</li><li>We <em>sometimes</em> accept that tenure justifies pay differences, but not always. In certain contexts, either from policy-driven automatic annual cost-of-living increases or other tenure-based rules, individuals will have different pay rates based on how long they’ve been employed with an organization. Term-of-service becomes an explanation and justification for differences in pay, in essence.</li><li>We <em>usually </em>accept that pay is reasonably different based on where someone lives (and by extension informed by the cost-of-living and cost-of-labor in different locations). Historically, we’ve explained and justified differences in pay for roles based on the relative costs of living for where someone is employed. Very interestingly, with the rise of distributed, global work, arguments that location is not a justifiable grounds for pay difference have been advanced with greater frequency and intensity. It could be over time that location becomes more like a demographic factor and is not seen as justifiable grounds for pay differences, at least by some segments of the global economy.</li></ol><p>Notice that I write “explained” and “justified” in the examples above. What I mean by separating these two is that we often do both when we talk about why people are paid differently. The two concepts often mean the same thing when we are discussing pay differences, but not always or at least not everyone is clearly using the words equivalently when they use them. Someone might, for example, say “oh well, CEO’s are just paid more than Vice Presidents” as a statement of fact. That may be largely true, but it doesn’t carry the force of saying it <em>ought</em> to be so.</p><p>All of these statements above have a similar form in that the justifications rest on fairly objective criteria, the most subjective being qualifications on a resume, but even so a resume can be backed up with various pieces of evidence.</p><p>“Performance” is quite different than than these. Here’s what we might say: we strive to pay for performance and generally accept that differences in pay based on performance in role are justifiable.</p><p>Well and good. But who is the judge of performance and what is this thing called “performance?” In most cases, managers and leaders, sometimes with the assistance or contribution of HR judge performance and the entire performance management industry has had a long multi-decade journey. If I’m going to be paid differently based on my performance, I sure as heck want to know the criteria on which I’m being judged.</p><p>But there is the heart of the problem. I’m a proponent myself of pay-for-performance as I think it’s the only sensible way to run a for-profit enterprise in particular, but even I get somewhat anxious thinking about the issues here.</p><p>There are jobs that can be clearly objectively measured — sales is clear one, and anything with a numerical output is at least tied to something measurable. Yet, there are many jobs — especially management and leadership jobs — that are not easily measured by concrete outcomes. Further, there are the very real situations of individuals that achieve numerical goals but at the cost of the well-being of humans around them (the high-performing asshole archetype).</p><p>In almost every instance, judging performance is indeed a matter of <em>judgment</em>. We can invent competency schemes, we can calibrate multi-rater inputs, we can do all sorts of work to make judging performance less subjective, but we can never remote subjectivity completely in most instances. Ultimately, pay-for-performance is a matter of someone judging me to be a good contributor (or not) and we can’t escape that potentially fallible act.</p><p>Which simply means that my pay is decided on the basis of someone assessing/judging me reasonably and fairly against others in similar roles. What if I don’t trust my manager or worry they don’t have an accurate understanding of my contributions? What if I’ve been given unreasonable goals? What if I’ve focused on a set of A deliverables and not B deliverables for the good of the team but I’m judged on B regardless?</p><p>Oh boy.</p><p>This quagmire is one that HR professionals and managers handle every day around the world and it is one of <em>ethics </em>even if not recognized as such. It is essentially ethical given that it is a question of fairness in judgement and the reasons supplied for that judgment. The outcomes are very real and about livelihood. Is it <em>right </em>to give more money to Worker A because they showed up on time every day for a year versus Worker B that was often late, often disrespectfully so to others, but produced more observable output? If we say yes, <em>it is right</em>, are we hurting the productivity of the company? If we say no, Worker B should get more money, what kind of organizational community and culture do we foster?</p><p>The ethical decisions are made all the more complex by the constant reference point of productivity and business success. We might make a policy that says employees are able to work anywhere from zero to 8 hours on any given day depending on their energy level. This may very well foster human welfare, but the business would (almost certainly) lose productivity to a degree. But at the same time … hopefully/probably? … even if we could demonstrate that keeping office areas uncomfortably cold led to greater productivity, we’d chose not to do that because it is wrong to inflict that degree of human misery on employees.</p><p>Every day, Human Resources/People professionals are tackling ethical problems in the workplace. They are usually the primary “interpreters” of policy or, in the case of low policy workplace environments, they make policy up on the fly as best they can.</p><p>Rather than see them as “policy police” — a metaphor that burdens the HR professional with a ton of unfortunate baggage — I’d suggest they are seen best as <em>public magistrates or judges</em> for the daily cases that manifest in every workplace. I suggest this change of metaphor given that “police” do not have a role in interpretation of the law, only applying the law. The “law” in the business setting is nowhere near as robust as in actual legal systems and the HR professional must, especially in certain kinds of business settings, apply their best judgment. [<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casuistry">For the philosophy-inclined reader, the ethical work of the HR professional is highly <em>casuistic</em> in nature, drawing on some of the better aspects of that applied ethics tradition</a>]. It is true that HR is sometimes called upon to enforce policy, but speaking as an HR professional, I’d say 80% of the daily routine is interpretative, communicative, and judicious as opposed to “policing.”</p><p>If the reader will accept my metaphorical shift — from police to magistrate and from enforcement to interpretation — then a crucial skill for the HR professional is the reasoning common to ethical problems. Aristotle termed it “practical reasoning” (φρόνησις / phrónēsis). It is essentially sound <em>judgement</em>, and the ability to discuss ends or outcomes and the wise path/means to achieve those ends. It is actually much simpler and safer for HR to stick to policing and not interpreting workplace “policy” given that action can reference the rules (“I didn’t write the policy, but I have to enforce it”). This is just simply not the reality for HR professionals in many aspects of workplace decision-making. Every day there are new cases that don’t fit snugly inside existing policy, or we, as HR professionals, must balance the interest of the business and the interests of one or more employees.</p><p>Although I can’t say that courses in applied ethics will make the HR job easier, an understanding of applied ethics — methods, history, examples — will equip the HR professional, especially in roles such as the HR business partner, with ways to explain, communicative, and most crucially <em>justify</em> decisions.</p><p>— Mark Frein, business ethicist &amp; proud HR professional</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=893774561c68" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Politics @ Work:]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/politics-work-705a3eb86af1?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/705a3eb86af1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 May 2021 13:56:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-09T13:56:59.986Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What if we designed our work communities to support deliberative disagreements?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*leSwL0alFnNKqZHSylxU0g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@shelaghmurphy?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Shelagh Murphy</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/debate?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The topic of “distracting political discourse” at work has <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/27/business/basecamp-politics-ban.html">made big news</a>. From Coinbase and Brian Armstrong’s Medium blog last year to <a href="https://world.hey.com/jason/changes-at-basecamp-7f32afc5">Basecamp CEO Jason Freid’s </a>blog that supposedly spurred almost a third of employees to resign, there is clearly an anxiety among some tech founders about the character of conversation in their organizations.</p><p>There are many challenges one might advance against the “no politics at work” position and most of those have already been made. I want to focus on a very specific aspect of the general argument that disturbs me the most. Put directly, taking these positions in the most generous way possible, the claim at the heart of them is that political discourse is divisive and distracting and therefore creates unhealthy cultural tensions in what<em> should</em> be a united community.</p><p>My concern is that while I can imagine situations where such cultural dysfunction ends up being the outcome of political discourse within the workplace, I can equally imagine situations where cultural strength is the outcome. Indeed, I believe that democratic society <em>requires</em> embracing discourse in which people advance ideas that are quite possibly unreconcilable and quite often uncomfortable. Further, I reject the notion that having a united community is the optimum (whatever “united” might actually be in this context).</p><p>It is not <em>that</em> the discourse is political that is the problem in and of itself. Rather, the problem is a desire for homogeneity of voice or a belief that such a homogeneity = business success.</p><p>I do not know either Mr. Armstrong or Mr. Fried. Referencing internal “strife” at Google and Facebook, Armstrong wanted a Coinbase that was unified and free from distracting political divisiveness. Referencing taking company dialog to a “dark place”, Fried seems to want to restore a business focus for internal communications that does not make employees uncomfortable.</p><p>I like to start with empathy and the highest level of generosity about their motivations. I’ve been a CEO myself and it is hard work to run a company. It’s especially hard to run a company when people are in conflict over purposes, aims, and intent. For good reasons, businesses want a strong team spirit where everyone is pulling together for business results. Cultural divisiveness can <em>appear</em> to make it hard to have the “one team, one mind” kind of experience.</p><p>But appearances are very deceiving when it comes to pluralism and inclusion. Silence is not the same as agreement. Not speaking about issues does not banish the feelings of resentment and fear.</p><p>Suppose that based on my politics, I’m uncomfortable about the notion of profits? Clearly, as has been noted by a number of commentators, the discourse internal to any company will continue to be “political” in so far as companies presume certain values (e.g., pursuit of wealth). The rejoinder will be that I’m free not to enlist a company that doesn’t support my values … however, there is simply no company that could be said to be operating in some abstracted pure politically-neutral territory.</p><p>Instead of working to eliminate or reduce political discourse, what if we actually tried to make it <em>more</em> present in our work communities? What if an organization’s power and ultimate success were to come precisely from its ability to sustain impassioned, strong, and different points of view? What if the source of innovation were closely tied to plurality of viewpoints, strongly held beliefs, and a willingness to speak one’s mind?</p><p>It may very well be that open discourse, community inquiry, and tolerance of difference does indeed drive higher innovative output (as many thinkers have argued going back centuries). Even if such an assertion was not absolutely and provably true, the question for me is what kind of life is worth living and what do we want to be true about the human condition in our company environments?</p><p>Our work communities <em>are</em> our lives. We increasingly blend work and not-work “life.” If we accept that work should be free from politics, where will political discourse go? That is what I’m deeply afraid of. We may forget how to have positive political conversations at all.</p><p>At the heart of the urge to stop political discourse at work is discomfort in listening. I do not want to be exposed to that which makes me uncomfortable.</p><p>What if the only way to create and sustain a truly inclusive community was precisely to be exposed to that which makes me uncomfortable (on a fairly regular basis) and to have to sit with that discomfort? Can I care about you even when I don’t agree with you? Can I hear you out with the same respectful listening I expect from you?</p><p>These are the real skills of being part of civil, deliberative discourse of all kinds.</p><p>In their classic book on the dispositional requirements of democracy, philosophers Amy Gutman and Dennis Thompson argue that a cornerstone to successful democratic ways of life is the ability of citizens to engage in “deliberative” conversations (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Disagreement-Amy-Gutmann/dp/0674197666/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&amp;keywords=democracy+and+disagreement&amp;qid=1620323888&amp;sr=8-1"><em>Democracy and Disagreement</em></a>).</p><p>Stated most simply, the concept of deliberation puts additional requirements on <em>how</em> we talk to each other about difficult issues. Gutman and Thompson advance the notion that a society committed to deliberation is committed to moral reasoning and furthermore, committed to mutual respect. There will be times when we simply cannot agree, but we can still find alignment, culturally, on our civic duty to respect each other as reasoners. We can commit to listening, in effect. In this way, the notion of deliberative discourse is a model for the way that psychologically safe teams would address profound disagreements as well (see <a href="https://www.ted.com/speakers/amy_edmondson">Amy Edmundson’s brilliant work</a>).</p><p>Now, companies are not democracies nor are set-up to model democratic process. Yet, at least in the United States and other democratic nations, they exist within a culture that celebrates a democratic way of life. We simply cannot leave our politics behind when we step inside the office building and further, we <em>ought</em> not to do so even if we could. I’d go so far as to say we have a <em>civic duty </em>to not accept a request to silence ourselves politically in any institution that exists within our democratic system.</p><p>My fear is that the more we tolerate the denial or suppression of reasoned, respectful political and moral discourse in any context, the more complacent we become to autocratic demands to silence our voices.</p><p>If I get used to “shutting up” about my beliefs while inside a company environment, I may just become more willing to shut up about them in general. After all, I live most of my life at work. We are conditioned animals. Giving voice to my beliefs is a bit like a muscle. Unexercised, quieted, my propensity and willingness to talk about what I believe to be right, just and good atrophies.</p><p>In recent times, we have not had great role-models on the public stage of deliberative, compassionate disagreement (or agreement!). Across the political spectrum, there is no shortage of hostility, inflammatory and personalized accusations and a complete lack of generosity of spirit. If we have not already lost the ability to talk <em>with</em> each other as opposed to <em>at </em>each other or <em>past</em> each other, we are at severe risk of doing so culturally.</p><p>I believe it is fully within a company’s right to establish norms for <em>civil</em> discourse. Personal attacks, hate speech, discriminatory language … I would happily use my power as a CEO to, quite simply, dismiss offenders from the community (aka fire them). I recognize that there will be subjectivity to my decisions on issues of civil discourse and mistakes can and will be made. Yet, in so far as a company is a private community, it strikes me that it can justifiably wield power to protect civility. That is a completely reasonable use of authority.</p><p>In a highly polarized political climate, it may be idealistic of me to hold to the hope that we can have work communities where disagreements are both civil and essential. I am simply not willing to give up on that ideal as I believe it is crucial to sustaining a free, democratic society at large. We must strive to make our work communities model examples — to the best extent possible — for how we wish to live our lives generally. If those work communities become closed, homogenized islands we may very well be contributing to the very polarization in society that we feel is playing out in work conversations.</p><p>Let us not confuse <em>uncivil</em> discourse with conversations that make us uncomfortable on account of the fact we are exposed to beliefs and arguments that are different from our own held positions.</p><p>An organization that intentionally makes room for political discourse will have a high bar for transparency, learning and education, and organizational “citizenship” behaviors. It is a worthy pursuit, even if difficult, uncomfortable, and hard. Instead of closing down on dialog, private companies could show the way forward on how to address some of our seemingly intractable public disagreements. I can stand shoulder-to-shoulder with someone whose beliefs challenge mine politically and work hard to achieve something that makes life better for a customer. There is the possibility of community unity, even in disagreement.</p><p>I’ll close with a short story. In 2016, I was consulting at a small tech company. I went into the office after the night of the presidential election. The CEO called a general meeting for lunch and around the room the employees talked about their feelings given the election result. Perhaps unsurprisingly given the demographics of the technology sector, and the overall demographics in Austin, TX, the vast majority of the room spoke of despair, sadness, or anger at the Trump victory. One employee, when it came to be their turn, said, “I voted for Trump, so today is different for me than for many of you. I just want you to know that I care about you all and I hope I can still be a teammate.” I caught myself on first blush with my own judgment … my own emotions about the politics. What was really remarkable, however, was how the people on either side of the employee reached out and showed caring. The room felt safe enough for that expression and caring enough for it to be simultaneously OK that many people were angry or in despair, and at least one person voiced joy.</p><p>All expressed caring.</p><p>There is are also times and places for righteous rage that may not always feel “civil.” Many, many people have suffered in our society and continue to suffer disadvantage and oppression. There is a <em>public </em>time and place for such and our 1st amendment protects as much. Focusing company discourse on <em>civil</em> conversation does draw limits to the nature of how ideas are expressed, but I believe is a justifiable boundary given the collective purpose of a business.</p><p>If we have any chance of sustaining a society founded on informed, civil discourse, we must make room for caring, civil conversations where all feel welcomed. We must practice this in our lives day-to-day and given how much time we spend at work, our workplaces <em>must</em> be a key venue for this practice. It may just be that some of the most successful private ventures in the coming decades will be exactly the kinds of places where a plurality of people feel included and welcomed and they select those places of employment on the basis of a pluralistic, inclusive culture.</p><p>My hope for company leaders is that they opt to use their authority to create space for <em>disagreement</em> instead of imposing silence. I hope that they use their power to role model empathetic listening, holding space for deliberative discourse, and inclusive conversations. If we can set a high bar inside private enterprise for such behavior, it can only help bolster the public dialog at large.</p><p>Mark Frein, philosopher-at-work</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=705a3eb86af1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I Joined Lambda School As Chief People Officer]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/why-i-joined-lambda-school-as-chief-people-officer-7739cf3143e5?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7739cf3143e5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[student-loans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[edtech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[edtech-startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 May 2020 13:15:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-06T13:15:11.686Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/1*fBcHbDzAeV4-SD_rfifDvA.png" /></figure><p>My father likes to tell the story of when he went to the financial aid office at Carleton College, a liberal-arts school outside of Minneapolis, Minnesota. “Mr. Frein, we are here to help you apply for what your son will need. Half of our students are on financial assistance of some kind,” the financial assistance officer noted. My dad replied, “Does that mean half of the parents just write a check each year?” Our reality was so far away from the financial situations for families that could afford to do that.</p><p>I was on full tuition assistance for most of my 4-years and took on substantial personal debt while also working my way through college in a variety of part-time campus jobs (highlight was “dishroom”). I did not have enough awareness at that point of the differences between myself and my roommate — we both worked shifts at campus jobs to pay for our schooling — and at least half the campus that did not have any work responsibilities. I didn’t have any sense of the differences between my own reality of working summer jobs and those of other classmates that would go on travel adventures solo or with their families during their breaks.</p><p>Despite the debt I incurred during my schooling, I grew up with an enormous amount of privilege. Primarily, that privilege amounted to educational and social advantage. My father was a professor and humanities scholar at the University of North Dakota. I had an incredible preparation for my educational future. I was surrounded by a very high level of home literacy. I have vivid memories of my father reading the D<a href="https://www.amazon.com/DAulaires-Book-of-Greek-Myths/dp/B00A7G72TE/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1PYTHKSFVLZYY&amp;dchild=1&amp;keywords=d%27auliers+book+of+greek+myths&amp;qid=1585750714&amp;sprefix=d%27auli%2Caps%2C170&amp;sr=8-1">’Aulaire’s amazing mythology books</a> to me as a grade-schooler, as well as adaptations of Shakespeare for children and Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. I am also white, male, and heterosexual with all the accompanying social advantages that comes with being those things. In our little town of Grand Forks, I lived in a bubble when it came to truly seeing and understanding the nature of those privileges. Later, when I left my home-town, I truly began my personal journey understanding all the aspects of my advantage.</p><p>My father and I were comfortably middle-class, although that term is obviously subjective. All wealth is relative. I am thankful for what I had as a child, but when I began to see what economic advantage can be, I realized how stratified America was even when I was young. I grew up in a single-income household, and UND paid among the lowest (if not the absolute lowest) of academic salaries in the nation in the 70s and 80s. We lived in a small apartment, and my father drove a beat-up second or third-hand used car. We had what we needed, and for that I am forever thankful.</p><p>Our savings — mine from years of birthday money and other gifts, and my father’s contributions to my college savings — were entirely consumed in the first year of my college journey. When I finished undergraduate school with a double major in Classics and English Literature, I carried substantial debt into my career future. I was able to delay repayment for five more years while I pursued two graduate degrees in Education, and despite having grants for my graduate studies, I accumulated more debt in grad school.</p><p>It would take me more than a decade to fully repay my educational debt. The debt was a major stressor on me and my family while I was attending graduate school, and at that point with a newborn. The repayments led to credit card max-outs, working multiple teaching gigs, depression, anxiety, and poor physical health. I remember digging in the couch cushions to find change to take the bus so I could earn income teaching undergrads in the daytime while writing my doctoral thesis at night.</p><p>These experiences shaped me in profound ways, some which I only now realize in reflection. These experiences are also some of the most important reasons why I was so excited when I received a call about a role at Lambda School for a Chief People Officer.</p><p><a href="https://lambdaschool.com/">Lambda School</a> is an online school that over nine months provides a robust and deep technical education for adults pursuing a career as a data scientist, web developer, or iOS developer. But we are more than a typical computer science and technical training provider. <a href="https://hbr.org/2019/10/what-if-your-university-tuition-was-based-on-your-future-salary">We are also one of the pioneers of the Income Share Agreement</a>. The ISA is a cutting-edge and disruptive means to create equality-of-access for students pursuing education and training. It is also a means to align incentives between the provider (Lambda School) and the student. We do not make money unless our outcomes (i.e., job placement) are consistent and demonstrable.</p><p>We must do better as a society enabling equality-of-access for education. The loan structure I experienced in my 20s and countless students are graduating with today not only creates potentially crippling debt burdens but also has misaligned incentives between educational providers, students, and financial institutions. Further, loan options are not even available for many individuals based on credit ratings.</p><p>In December, <a href="https://medium.com/@markfrein70/career-life-and-the-remarkable-beauty-of-figuring-it-out-along-the-way-28f8c19834d2">I wrote a piece about trying to figure out my next career step</a>. I was focused in late 2019 on being of value to organizations and people with whom I felt a deep connection. Work does not feel like work when you are connected and collaborating with your co-workers. On the other hand, work can be suffering when you do not have human connection in your workplace. I wanted to make my choice about a new role carefully.</p><p>I spent time researching the company, reading up on the business model, and meeting the senior team already in place.</p><p>I decided to join Lambda School as an executive for what it stands for — a means to provide life-changing education and training to people, regardless of current socio-economic circumstance. At this point in my career, I couldn’t possibly imagine a job where I could combine virtually everything I feel passionate about: remote work, curriculum and instruction, and building a strong culture and People function to support that culture.</p><p>I also choose Lambda School after meeting the people who would be my colleagues. For me, it is was critical to see that they shared a commitment to what the school stands for. I was moved by the conversations I had. That was a powerful experience. It is one thing to join a company where everyone wants to be “successful” as a company. That is the baseline norm for almost all startups — let’s ride this launching rocket together! It is quite another to join a company where the other leaders joined for a shared commitment that runs deeper and is about social impact.</p><p>We need educational and training options that break down barriers to access. Lambda does this in multiple ways — not only through the ISA financial model but also by being an all-remote provider. We are extending our reach by breaking down barriers of all kinds, physical and social.</p><p>We have considerable opportunity to change the game here at Lambda, but also must push to innovate for our students. I am deeply committed to taking the technical firepower and creativity of the startup economy and putting it to use for students across the United States (and potentially beyond) that are seeking to enter the technology industry. Yet, there is significant social distance between the average Silicon Valley entrepreneurial experience and that of students in rural communities or urban centers across the US.</p><p>Our success will depend on our ability to evolve our offering by profound student empathy. We must ceaselessly adapt our programs to the needs of employers and the needs of our students.</p><p>Fundamentally, I believe that the gifts I was given in regards to education — from my father and my childhood experiences, combined with my own formal educational journey — helped me dramatically improve my earning power over my career. I always wanted to be an educator, and those roots run very deep in me. For the last decade, I’ve been focused on being a “startup” executive and to some extent accepted my days as an educator were over. At Lambda School, I’ve recaptured key components of my career and educational journey, and in so doing, found more I can bring of myself to my new place of work.</p><p>Mark,</p><p>Startup Exec, Educator, and Loan Survivor</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7739cf3143e5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Work in the Time of Covid-19]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/work-in-the-time-of-covid-19-de03e0f380e7?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de03e0f380e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-working]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2020 18:43:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-13T18:43:30.935Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Svsn2ggdzFzTdQR_xm5Cjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sunset off my back porch in Austin, TX</figcaption></figure><p>Today, schools shut down in Austin, TX and my 5 year-old and 8 year-old woke to the happy news (for them!) that they wouldn’t be going to school. Then we went to the grocery store to stock up a bit and stood in a 30-minute check out line.</p><p>The anxiety hangs in the air like its own kind of airborne virus.</p><p>Earlier this week, my workplace (<a href="https://lambdaschool.com/">Lambda School</a>, an online school for technical skill training) closed our San Francisco and Salt Lake City offices. Although a large number of our 200 employees were already working remotely, it has been an adjustment for many of my colleagues.</p><p>Work+life has gone remote in a big way, very quickly. It is a hard adjustment for hundreds of thousands of workers. Companies are searching for solutions, techniques, and sometimes “silver bullets” to the work-from-home reality.</p><p>The bad news is that there is no simple strategy to ensuring everyone works from home effectively. The good news is that we humans are generally adaptable, our technologies are dramatically improved for digitally-mediated work, and there are some basic principles that help.</p><p>A thought experiment — imagine our current situation in reverse. Suppose we had been all working, digitally-mediated, for generations. We log into an online medium, interact with each other through computing technologies, and never see one another in person to do work. A massive digital virus hits our infrastructure and we must suddenly, literally overnight, all go to <em>workplaces</em>. (Gasp, OMG, the horror!)</p><p>We’d search for the rare situations where people have been working this way and ask for help, tips, solutions. We would have an interestingly similar set of questions, just posed as if from a mirror-world: “How can I get anything done with the distractions of people around me?” “I lose so much time each day traveling to this workplace!” “I am socially uncomfortable in the presence of other people. It is impossible to focus and I feel overwhelmed.”</p><p>The only honest answer to all of such questions is that <em>we must adapt</em>. For human beings we are lucky enough that adaptation can come as a product of learning. The fastest route to learning will be immersion, in a supportive and developmental environment.</p><p>Immersion in the time of Covid-19 has some very basic elements. For those of us that have been working for some time as remote/distributed workers, we appreciate how important it is for everyone to play on the same field. Simple things:</p><ol><li>When on a video conferencing platform, everyone is on their own screen.</li><li>Pick communication technologies, ensure everyone uses just one per medium/mode (e.g., one video platform, one messaging platform).</li><li>Tell people where to obtain static information (e.g., wiki’s for FAQs) and encourage as much self-service as possible. This avoids high traffic noise in an online environment.</li><li>Support each other. You are in it together.</li><li>Give people outlets to just <em>talk and share</em></li></ol><p>In my company, we created a Covid-19 Slack channel and a Remotelife Slack channel earlier this week. Both are being <em>heavily</em> used. Just to share stories and empathize. One team member opened up about how difficult it is for her to be planning a wedding that is almost certainly going to be dramatically impacted by the pandemic. She received an outpouring of emotional support.</p><p>There are many, many more tips and strategies. <a href="https://lambdaschool.com/the-commons/expert-advice-for-successfully-transitioning-your-company-to-remote-work">I’ve written or spoken about some elsewhere</a>. The internet is flooded with them right now.</p><p>Here, I’d just give one piece of advice:</p><p><em>Physical distance is not emotional distance. Draw closer, together, as teams, and companies. Stand together and on common ground.</em></p><p>As human beings we crave connection. Surviving the isolation and social distancing of Covid-19 — quite apart from the health crisis — will require us to band together despite being socially distanced. We are just so fortunate to have the technological tools for this, now.</p><p>What can working remotely for some period of time teach us about encouraging caring, inclusive and supportive environments? What can it teach us about seeing and hearing people for whom they are and whom they choose to be?</p><p>What if we used this experience, as workers, as an opportunity to discover what it means to be a whole person at work? There are nothing but screens, cables, and microphones in our way.</p><p>Mark Frein</p><p>Remote but present</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de03e0f380e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Career, Life, and the Remarkable Beauty of Figuring It Out Along the Way]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/career-life-and-the-remarkable-beauty-of-figuring-it-out-along-the-way-28f8c19834d2?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28f8c19834d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-paths]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Dec 2019 14:11:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-10T14:12:33.280Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m turning the big 5–0 in 2020 and fortunately haven’t been hit with any of the standard crises of “midlife” (optimistically thinking 49 is possibly a life midpoint!). No desire to buy a sports car, although I would love to pick up a blue Gibson SG custom shop electric guitar … But generally, life is wonderful, and I do not need to remind myself of youth. I just want to be the best 50-year-old husband, father, friend, leader, and colleague I can be. After almost a decade of building People Teams at venture-backed SaaS companies, I’ve more recently enjoyed helping out a wide variety of startups think about structure, strategy, operations, and people practices while also volunteering as President of the Board at my daughters’ school.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GQlvFn_wPWJNEiN1-7yU3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me figuring it out along the way several years ago during one of those wine &amp; paint activities my team at the SaaS company Return Path did during an offsite.</figcaption></figure><p>However, one thing that I’ve spent a lot of time recently thinking about is career longevity. Being in venture-backed technology, I’m now <em>ancient</em>. I remember only a couple of years ago having a bolt-of-lightning moment where I realized I was the oldest executive and one of the older employees in a relatively large company. Holy sh*t, I thought. It was a very sudden change and took me by surprise. I’ve since been processing what career “late afternoon” means in this industry. It was a key moment where my view of myself changed almost overnight. I hadn’t felt I was “old guard”. I certainly didn’t feel wisened. And, I’m not tired, thank goodness.</p><p>My sense is that I’ll keep working until I can’t, at least in some capacity. I’d love to write a novel or two at some point, but I just plain like doing what I do. I get a thrill from helping businesses solve people and structural problems. I learn a ton from new business challenges, particularly the operational and scaling challenges faced by venture-backed companies. I embrace the teaching aspects of being a leader but I also love to learn new things myself. I do all these things whether volunteering or working for income. If I didn’t have to work, I’d still do these things.</p><p>I’ve been so lucky through my career. I have had some great mentors, been provided wonderful opportunities by people that took risks on me, especially given in many instances, I had an atypical background for the job at hand. I’ve thrown myself into each new opportunity with everything I had, and tried to create a legacy of growth and betterment. I’ve accomplished things, failed at things, and learned along the way. I think I feel best about the developmental opportunities I created for other people — first jobs, career-defining moments, and experiences that have launched great future success. Thinking on it now, what I remember as the most profound personal accomplishments are moments of growth in people and teams around me.</p><p>My career past and the road I’ve traveled makes sense, at least upon reflection. Even though my career has had many twists and turns, it has made me what I am, and given me the tools with which I approach problems. I find myself, however, at a funny place when it comes to the future.</p><p>“What do you want to do next?” Or, as I was recently asked, “What haven’t you done that you’d like to do?”</p><p>What simple and yet intimidating questions. Maybe a decade ago I’d answer such questions with more artfulness, trying to match my answer to what I thought the person wanted to hear. These days, I find myself blurting things out that are truer to my heart and thus more real. Although, I suspect that they don’t impress the questioner. In the last couple of years, when asked this, I often start with the answer of:</p><p>“I don’t know.”</p><p>There’s a lot I <em>do</em> know about what I <em>don’t</em> want to do in the time I have remaining in both work and life. I believe it ought to be perfectly reasonable for someone to be unsure of where they want to go in their career. I had no clue upon entering college what I wanted to major in — I needed to learn to figure it out. I had no clue what I wanted to write my PhD thesis on when I started my graduate studies. I had to learn to figure that out too. I had absolutely no conception of what it would be like to be a Chief People Officer or Chief Operating Officer in venture-backed technology when I was in my 20s. It took all the wonderful and odd twists and turns of my career to figure those things out, and I’m still learning and figuring it out.</p><p>I admire people who have a straighter and tighter vector to their career, and more (apparent or professed) certainty but it’s not me, and that’s OK. I’d argue it is OK for more people than we think and in more situations. The reason why it is important that this answer is welcomed, is that uncertainty and doubt (especially self-doubt) have traditionally had low stock prices in the world of venture-backed tech businesses. I feel they are poised for a bull run. Recent news-dominating examples in the tech markets have shown precisely what can happen when uncertainty, doubt, and self-examination are driven out of the premises.</p><p>So, yes, “I don’t know” is a pretty unimpressive response. It’s also an honest answer and more true for me now than it was when I was younger. I may not always know what I want to do “next”, but <em>I do know who I need to be and how I need to be</em>.</p><ol><li><em>I need to tell the truth</em>. In the world of business, there are often a lot of pressures to massage, spin, smokescreen or otherwise “work” the truth. I’m not so naive at this point in life to feel there aren’t many “truths” … there are always perspectives aplenty. Yet, it is increasingly important to me to speak up, speak out, even when it is uncomfortable for me or others. I endeavor to do so with genuine love for people and an earnest interest in growing together.</li><li><em>I want to work with people that share my values about humans at work.</em> I’d take this over many things these days. I don’t need or want a work environment that is homogenous when it comes to religiosity and spirituality, politics, and cultural points-of-view. I do care an awful lot — more than ever before — about working with people that share a fundamental commitment to <em>people</em>. I can distill my values in this area as such: Work provides people with an opportunity to contribute to something of themselves to a collective endeavor. We work to <em>be ourselves</em>, and consequently the best workplaces enrich life and open opportunities for growth and development. Some workplaces look to get the most “out” of employees. I’m interested in how a workplace can invest <em>in </em>the development of employees.</li><li><em>I don’t always need to have fun, but I have to always feel valued</em>. I’ll willingly and happily bleed, metaphorically at least, for a job if my contributions are valued. I’m too f&amp;cking old to bleed otherwise. If I’m not valued, what’s the point? I’d much rather be fired than be of questionable value.</li><li><em>My life isn’t defined by my work, but I want to be ALIVE in my work</em>. Boy am I thankful to even be able to think of work this way. It is a relatively recent phenomenon in human history and obviously part of the reality of the privileges of the when, where and whom of my birth that I’m afforded this luxury. I know many in the world struggle to even have work, much less enlivening work. Personally, I’ve never been able to create a dividing line between my life and my work which is why the “work to live as opposed to live to work” maxim doesn’t completely resonate with me. Work has not been <em>instrumental</em> to me in that way. It doesn’t enable anything outside itself when it comes to who I am, although it enables things like income and opportunity. I find myself in my work from time to time, realize myself through work, and do my best to avoid losing myself on occasion.</li></ol><p>All of this nets to a desire, at this point in my life, for work and a workplace where I feel <em>at home</em>. Ironically, since I’m a devoted work-from-home professional, I enjoy the privileges of actually being at home, physically at least. However, it is all too easy to feel alienated and unwelcome while sitting in one’s home office. Indeed, working from home physically reminds me how precious the experience of being welcomed, seen, and heard at work is.</p><p>If you can find a work opportunity where you can be wholly and unconditionally yourself, treasure it. It is very similar to the rarity of finding a life partner that wholly and unconditionally appreciates who you are. You’ll have to work hard to keep mutual trust alive and strong, just as with family, friends, and partners, but there is no substitute for a true feeling of belonging. The problem of diversity in the technology industry is, in large part, a question of “belongingness” and inclusion. I’m not sure we are collectively very good at welcoming people to our workplaces and teams.</p><p><a href="https://blog.usejournal.com/designing-people-experiences-employee-onboarding-130456123ed2">In a past role at a major software company</a>, my team chose to name our new employee on-boarding program <a href="https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenia_(Greek)"><em>Xenia</em></a><em> </em>— a Greek word meaning “guest-friendship.” We have plenty of models of workplaces in technology that emphasize elite performance and the continuous earning of spots on the roster — the tech company as professional sports team theme. We could remind ourselves to temper such models with heart and soul, no matter how high of standards for outcomes we hold. I do not believe a workplace can or should ever be a “family.” I do believe a workplace can and should be a place where you feel welcomed … whether or not that is on Day 1 or your last day.</p><p>I’ve enjoyed many twists and turns in my career. A few people that have asked me for career advice over the years say something like “You have such an unusual career journey!” All of the job paths I walked down in my career to-date were things I enjoyed at least to some degree. I have learned from every opportunity and am grateful. I’ve enjoyed meeting new people and helping them solve problems in every new organization I’ve encountered.</p><p>My unusual career path is a blessing and a curse, for sure. I often haven’t known what I’m going to do next. I’ve tried to be <em>career curious</em> … an explorer of the lands where what I can do is discovered not only by myself but by and with others. As I enter into what is probably the last decade of highest productivity and output of my career, there are a few things I’m realizing now that I did not realize when I was younger.</p><p>What I do at work is less important than with <em>whom</em> I get to work. What I do is less important than how <em>we</em> do it <em>together</em>. What role I play, what title I have, what money I make … all of this is important. But it is not as important as the life I am living through work and at work. I didn’t see it before as clearly. I do now. Some things were never truly important, but I only fully woke to that now. Better late than never.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XgJwoKV9scs9y7vmFOHCBA.png" /></figure><p>I titled this piece alluding to the late Nobel-prize winning physicist Richard Feynman’s book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Pleasure-Finding-Things-Out-Richard/dp/0465023959/ref=pd_lutyp_crtyp_simh_1_1/139-1139961-0719126?_encoding=UTF8&amp;pd_rd_i=0465023959&amp;pd_rd_r=75940bbf-245e-4eac-8c66-d7b8dea10cae&amp;pd_rd_w=pXZtY&amp;pd_rd_wg=MRrkI&amp;pf_rd_p=11bf186d-590b-449a-8161-5414a5d28305&amp;pf_rd_r=S4D2X6Y5HAF4R0VBFYJ8&amp;psc=1&amp;refRID=S4D2X6Y5HAF4R0VBFYJ8">The Pleasure of Finding Things Out</a>. A quote from Feynman, who was a role-model for holding a continuously curious, “beginner’s mind”, reads: “I can live with doubt and uncertainty and not knowing. I think it’s much more interesting to live not knowing than to have answers that might be wrong.”</p><p>I can live without knowing where my career, at this relatively late stage, may take me. What I do not want to do is work — which is “life” for most days — in a situation where I’m not <em>alive</em>. We use the phrase, “dying inside”, and we all know what it means. It means that our self is shriveling up, atrophying. Work environments which inflict this on people are, regardless of how business successful, not ennobling. They are not human-successful. This past week, I read the <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/5/20995453/away-luggage-ceo-steph-korey-toxic-work-environment-travel-inclusion">Verve’s piece on Away</a> with likely the same set of reactions as most people in the tech sector. There can be a disaster-enthusiasm mentality at work how we read, slack-jawed, the latest expose on Away or WeWork or any other recent headlining organizational catastrophe. My heart immediately goes out to <em>all</em> the people involved (leaders included). It is easy to judge, harder to understand and empathize. The pressures in these environments are immense.</p><p>The question for me … as someone that has seen multiple recessions, managed a company through the Dot.bust, worked with companies for multiple decades on culture, leadership, and people practices … is this: <em>what are we doing to ourselves</em>? It is maybe a little too easy to gawk at the stories out of these companies and not consider the long-term trends that continue to repeat. Some of us, old like me, will remember the <a href="https://ea-spouse.livejournal.com/274.html">EA spouse blog</a> from the early 2000s.</p><p>I’ve myself on more than one occasion worked too long, too hard, and set bad examples for my teammates from time to time. I traveled 80% or more during the first year of one of my daughters’ lives and I can’t get that year back. I’ve tried to provide good role modeling, and be present for my family and friends, keep myself healthy. I’ve succeeded, sometimes. For every Away that makes the headlines, there are countless other tech companies with similar stories that won’t, and where everyone still suffers. We all have to look in the mirror in this industry. Maybe the recent level of heightened awareness on these issues will prompt some serious introspection. If enough firms consistently fail to achieve value on the basis of their cultures, things <em>will </em>shift. The culture problems become economic problems.</p><p>For me, the relationship between career discovery, career curiosity, and the pleasure and beauty of wandering paths is precisely the importance of <em>being a person before one is a job or a role. </em>I simply don’t feel my team or my manager or my organization can possibly be long-term performant if it isn’t an ensemble of human beings, living full lives<em>. </em>Yes, we can point to value created on the backs of suffering. We can recognize that people sign-up for big payoffs, trade-out life balance for potentially high personal return, and that should be OK too. But as the great quality guru and business philosopher W.E. Deming noted, “You can whip a horse to make it go faster, but only for so long.” Deming, whose work is more timely now than perhaps it was even in the era of the Toyota Way, called for a simple, consistent high-standard: <strong><em>we ought to be able to take joy in our work</em></strong>.</p><p>Now, as I stand at the threshold of whatever “late career” means in this industry, I want to take joy in my work. And, heck, I don’t know what that is “next” but I am so curious to find out.</p><p>— Mark, career curiously yours</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ewVBS2YqzEQPvWgNuFH5eg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The finished product. It didn’t look anything like what we were supposed to paint. But it was my first painting since I was maybe 5 years old, and I’ve hung it above my home office workstation to remind me of the joy of figuring things out (in my own way).</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28f8c19834d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remote Tools 1: I Got Zoomed]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/remote-tools-1-i-got-zoomed-6b495009c32?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b495009c32</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[zoom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[saas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-working]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Dec 2019 14:00:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-09T14:00:54.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have wanted to do a short piece series on remote tools for a while. We are still in the infancy, in my view, of the remote work revolution (RWR) and the technology platforms that enable it are evolving rapidly. As well, competition is becoming fierce and the stakes considerable as we are seeing with Slack and Microsoft Teams. Remote work is distinctive as a movement in that it is being led by companies in the business of collaborative tools at scale (e.g. InVision, Automattic, Gitlab) and also powered by a suite of SaaS (software-as-a-service) applications for collaboration.</p><p>These are not <em>reviews</em> in the formal sense, and are not aimed to provide a balanced or in-depth examination of product features. Rather, I want to discuss how and why particular software platforms/tools have stood out from the pack and become household names and loved brands for remote workers. The pieces are ultimately less aimed at experienced remote technology-users than folks out there that may not have been exposed to remote-working or the tools that power the remote-work wave. [silly disclaimer … I’m not in the employ of Zoom, nor was I asked to write this piece].</p><p>I figured what better place to start than with <a href="https://zoom.us/">Zoom</a>, the video application powering conversations between remote workers every day across perhaps thousands of distributed organizations around the globe.</p><p>I’ve been playing with technologies for remote work for almost 25 years. <a href="https://medium.com/@markfrein70/the-distributed-workplace-15ef447fa926">Elsewhere</a> I wrote of an experience in the 90s when I was a teaching assistant during my graduate work. Myself and the lead professor for an ethics course used early video-based technologies to give lectures for a group of students in Castlegar, British Columbia from Vancouver at the University of British Columbia. Given the two places are separated by steep mountains, often snowed-in over the winter, it seemed like a good experiment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xSVboCgrHGavTFPW9WDKgQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>With permission from Eric. Yes, I look like an absolute fan-boy and he looks like he just had an IPO (which he did).</figcaption></figure><p>It rarely worked well. When it worked, it worked only so-so and lag issues were constant. Our fault tolerance for video-based meetings has gone up so enormously even in the last few years, largely due to the wonderful technical improvements in current platforms.</p><p>Times have changed. The progress has been incredible. I don’t know how many video calls are made daily worldwide across all platforms (I bet Zoom has a decent estimate), but I would guess it is increasing right now at a staggering rate year-over-year.</p><p>There are many great options for video-based meetings on market today. I’m not writing as an in-depth market researcher, a software design expert, or a technologist but rather as a <em>daily user</em> and paying customer that has worked the majority of my days distributed/remote for most of the last decade. This is my story, and my user experience, on how I got “Zoomed” and why, in particular, I made a key choice recently to buy my own personal professional license.</p><p>Those of us that work in technology companies often have access to amazing software tools. In many cases, our workplaces provide all the hardware and software we will need to do our jobs (and sometimes way more than we need!). It is more rare for us to <em>personally</em> purchase enterprise-class software licenses for technologies that are primarily for work. The reason why is partly about the community of users. We get value from user-communities.</p><p>In the world of software, we talk about “network effects” and Zoom, as with other communication platforms like Slack, MS Teams or even technologies like Trello for project workflow, make their future(s) or are broken from the success or failure at achieving and sustaining network effects. Simply, a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect">network effect</a> is a commercial situation in which the value of a good is dramatically enhanced to each user on the basis of how many users adopt the good. There is zero value for a Zoom user base of 1. But the value climbs exponentially with user adoption.</p><p>Given that video-based communication providers have offered solutions both for B2B (business-to-business) and B2C (business-to-consumer) situations, you can have what I’d call “contained” or closed network effects within enterprises or more open network effects among the public at large. Indeed, there is both the effect of people embracing the <em>technology</em> (e.g., video calls) and a particular technology platform. If a business is going to provide a video platform to its employees, it makes a ton of sense to pick just one.</p><p>Zoom certainly has positioned itself as a B2B solution. It was not the first-mover in video-based communication for either home or business use. However, its business success is a wonderful case-study of market and product strategy. I feel that Zoom had a very clear sense of the future of remote work, or, they just got very, very lucky in timing (probably a bit of both). As more and more work happens with people not in the same place, easy technologies not just for room-to-room meetings but for room-to-home, home-to-home, and multiple variants of all of this have become essential to business operations.</p><p>I first encountered Zoom just over three years ago at <a href="https://www.invisionapp.com/">InVision</a>, where I was an executive. InVision is among the world’s largest all-remote/distributed employers. For InVision, having a single-source for “live” facetime was essential. Prior to InVision, I had used a number of other video solutions — some oriented more toward the personal user (i.e., Skype) and some toward the business user (WebEX) and some in-between (Google Hangouts).</p><p>I was immediately struck by Zoom’s ease-of-use. But I have continued to be impressed with how they’ve evolved since I’ve met them. For a remote workforce like InVision (or Hashicorp, Gitlab, Zapier, Automattic and plenty more remote-focused companies), culture is created and sustained by the technologies that mediate communication. Strong culture — which, at the end of the day, is about relationships — is built on the foundation of frictionless communications. A high-growth technology company has plenty of scaling challenges that will impact culture … it does not also need to have the tools themselves getting in the way.</p><p>My detailed user impact and delight list goes like this:</p><ol><li><em>It just works</em>. This has been a big focus by Yuan and team. I was immediately impressed, and continue to be impressed, by the speed-to-load, the quality of video, and general uptime with a bug-free experience. It’s not perfect, especially at low bandwidth, but it does just work.</li><li><em>It plays well with others.</em> Among the many small pieces of genius design, I feel the ease of scheduling and integration with calendaring, messaging, emailing, etc., make Zoom so frictionless to use and, particularly, to adopt. I shoot a url to someone I want to join me via any other communication medium (calendaring, emailing, text chat), and the time to get up and running without major software install has been a major competitive edge. Not to mention out-positioning other B2B solutions that required expensive hardware. Many feel this single-point host model has been Zoom’s killer go-to-market strategy. The ease of adoption has certainly increased virality.</li><li><em>It’s its own thing</em>. I actually like that as of now, at least, Zoom isn’t a small piece within a bigger empire. It can feel as though some other video meeting solutions are freebie hooks meant to imbed in your flesh for other reasons. Personally, quite aside from software, privacy, or other considerations Skype <em>felt</em> different to me after the Microsoft purchase. I have nothing against Microsoft or big tech. But there are times when being part of these large multi-solution platforms really helps a solution shine and times when the software “feels” like a castoff. Zoom, in my mind, realized an incredible IPO last year in a very mature and crowded field of video communication solutions because of rare kind of strategic <em>focus</em>. Let’s do one thing, and do it better than anyone else.</li><li><em>It works great for simple use, and has more depth for power use</em>. What I mean here is that I can launch a call with my 86-year-old father easily but I can also do screen share with markup, recordings, one-to-large groups, and other razzle dazzle stuff. In computer gaming, there is an art to making the game easily playable right from “on” versus games where you can only really have a full experience if you read a manual or watch YouTube videos. Each has a market. But the true art is making a gaming experience that has <em>both</em>. Immediately playable, but with surprising strategic or play depth discoverable over time.</li><li><em>It is fun</em>. Last but not least, Zoom has a sense of humor. In the pic above, Eric was showing me a feature then only available on Mac, but now available on PC. I can look like I’m on a beach, in outer space, or in the Hobbit Shire. For me, this is a key characteristic even if not a businessy one. Enterprise software can be humorless at times. Trello, a Kanban application for team projects, has done an amazing job making its brand personal and loved (with a cute puppy named Taco even!). Evernote did this for me, for a time (elephant!). Zoom is doing the same, at least for me, and it hasn’t even needed an animal mascot. ;) I run online D&amp;D groups using Zoom and everyone now has their go-to fantasy theme background.</li></ol><p>This last point about fun is an important consideration, at least for me, when it comes to Zoom’s success in the holy grail of ubiquity (i.e., the volume of users that have used it, are using it, in the market) but also product stickiness. I LIKE using the software. There’s a lot of software I use, but I don’t necessarily enjoy using. I have a positive brand affinity for Zoom. I recommend it (and hence contribute to its NPS or net promoter score). I take a little bit of <em>pleasure</em> each time I click the Zoom link to open a meeting. I’ve recently seen Zoom not only in businesses, but for the board meetings of community centers, small schools, and other organizations not usually at the cutting-edge of business tool adoption. This bodes well for them, and the entire segment, frankly.</p><p>The personal punchline.</p><p>When I no longer had access to Zoom through my employer, I faced a tough situation. <a href="https://www.zoom.us/pricing/?zcid=2502&amp;creative=356421677196&amp;keyword=zoom%20pricing&amp;matchtype=e&amp;network=g&amp;device=c&amp;gclid=CjwKCAiAuK3vBRBOEiwA1IMhunatNLsUOpaDvSGJLmCvo3Im-MeFUhZalplPZG0G5WRpH4dQhOotqxoCqDwQAvD_BwE">Zoom has a great free version</a>. You get use out of the platform for a reasonable chunk of time. And, it is nothing like having the Pro version in terms of flexibility, and having unlimited time. I was using the free version at a new employer — a small startup in cash conversation mode where I was a remote employee, but many of the workers shared an office. It didn’t obviously make sense to go enterprise (yet) on a paid plan.</p><p>Maybe a month in, I navigated Chrome to Zoom.us and looked at the paid plan for Pro. It was an absolute no-brainer. Zoom got me. In my mind, it had become equivalent to having a phone. I couldn’t function without it. I didn’t think of it as “a” video solution but <em>the</em> solution and literally as something I had to have for both work and play. I assigned myself a custom Zoom profile number (same as my cell). Emotionally, it was like paying for an annual phone service, or for a key website domain name. I don’t know what my upper price point limit would be, but at the moment, the $14.99/month/host Pro plan is an easy decision. Heck, I get value from D&amp;D games alone on that pricing.</p><p>Zoom will have to continue to refine, adapt, evolve and outposition rivals. It was already a tough field, and it will get even tougher. I believe they got me by a) diligent strategic operational focus b) diligent focus on user experience. Good businesses are built on the basis of simplicity, in almost every situation. I think Zoom reminded us of that and I hope they continue to do so.</p><p>— Mark, remote worker, Zoomer not Boomer</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b495009c32" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Company Culture Conundrum]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/the-company-culture-conundrum-8d16545119cf?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d16545119cf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[naturallanguageprocessing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[company-values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[company-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Sep 2019 16:17:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-28T21:08:27.444Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WHET9aeeNlk0iWAXG9lDVA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@hyw1?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">John Doyle</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/puzzle?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Company culture has become big business. Last week, <a href="https://www.smartcompany.com.au/startupsmart/news/unicorn-culture-amp-series-e/">Culture Amp</a>, perhaps the leading “culture tech” company world-wide secured $82m in funding pushing it into “unicorn” territory (at least from an Australian dollar perspective). As someone that has been both a customer and fan of Culture Amp for almost a decade, I would both congratulate them and also celebrate the work they’ve done to make culture analysis a major topic in executive meetings, board rooms, and company all-hands. They have also elevated “people geeks” to center stage in the tech sector, securing a special status for those HR professionals that use rigorous data to understand cultural realities and recommend company strategies.</p><p>Yet, “company culture” remains a complex and ambiguous concept. We are still only at the doorstep when it comes to understanding cultural factors at play in modern organizations. Further, we have quite a distance to go if we want to truly measure and report on culture in similar ways as we do on metrics such as “weekly active users”, cash flow, or employee attrition. The concept of culture itself is so thick, and so inviting of argument and discussion, without even adding the modifier of “organizational” or “company” in front of it.</p><p>I will thus not be attempting to offer anything radical or new on the questions of “what is culture?” or more specifically “what is company culture?” Practical and academic literature on these questions is extensive and hotly contested.</p><p>Instead, I want to make sure that as we build technological solutions to assessing and measuring “company culture”, changing it, and developing it, we ground ourselves as clearly as possible. Otherwise, our solutions — product or service-oriented — are likely to miss the mark.</p><p>Edgar Schein, MIT/Sloan Emeritus professor, offered this definition: “The culture of a group can now be defined as a pattern of shared basic assumptions that the group learned as it solves its problems of external adaptation and internal organization, that has worked well enough to be considered valid and, therefore, to be taught to new members as the correct way to perceive, think, and feel in relation to those problems” (Schein, Organizational Culture and Leadership, 2nd edition, 1993).</p><p>Schein’s definition, now 35 years old, still stands for me as the most practical conception of organizational culture we have. What is key in the utility of the conception is the focus on adaptation — <em>it is a group’s collective problem-solving</em>. Culture is a set of strategies, formally and informally taught to members as correct. It is reinforced in rituals and practices such as new employee onboarding, company values, company mission, policies around promotions and pay increases, and anything else that determines what is or is not good behavior in an organization.</p><p>With this conception in mind, we can look at a variety of problems or challenges with understanding, measuring, and acting on company culture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jhEBjzjjvbOMyQ0s3s5Udw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@bel2000a?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Belinda Fewings</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/sentiment?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Sentiment is not the same as culture</strong>, although we sometimes act like it is.</p><p>Occasionally, we celebrate positive company engagement (or employee net promoter score/eNPS) as a proxy for culture overall and pat ourselves on the back. And, in contrast, declining or low sentiment against benchmarks is bemoaned as evidence of a cultural “problem” or weakness.</p><p>To be fair, engagement itself is a big concept that requires a lot of unpacking. Engagement supplanted earlier terms such as morale or job satisfaction and is, in turn, now being disrupted itself by articulations of “employee experience.” Without contesting turf on the terminology, for the sake of clarity, let’s focus on aspects of engagement that squarely report on positivity about membership in an organization. Questions such as “I would recommend X company as a great place to work” (which is a way of assessing employee net promoter score), or “I am proud to work at X company”. I’ll take eNPS and this basic view of engagement as effectively synonymous.</p><p>One of the biggest boosts to eNPS is company over-performance. One of the biggest drags on it is company under-performance. A company can solidify eNPS around almost any rest or unchanging state in a company but as with motion in general, people <em>feel</em> the accelerations and decelerations, not the steady-state velocity. A simple rule would go like this — the perceived change in company momentum directly impacts eNPS whereas constant “velocity” of company performance will generally not change eNPS. One could easily study this hypothesis. But the effects are primal and obvious— our actual <em>physiologies</em> respond in one way to winning, and another to losing.</p><p>Fundamentally, concepts such as eNPS and aggregate engagement are measuring very important dimensions of a population’s temperament. However, just as “mood” is temporary and fleeting and we would not generally say that a person’s mood is a major defining characteristic of their personality, engagement is not a major defining characteristic of a company’s <em>culture</em> per se.</p><p>Sentiment does clearly play an important role in culture, however. I believe the link is found in the readiness for change. Consider — it is very easy to imagine an environment where a strong, adaptive “culture” is characterized by dissatisfaction with the status quo. This is how revolutions happen. An oppressed group ought not to be happy with their lot. A losing team ought not to be pleased with itself.</p><p>Following the same metaphors related to acceleration and inertia as above, I would suggest this maxim:</p><p><em>Company engagement is the way an organization feels about itself (proud, enthusiastic, despondent, complacent, etc.). Engagement is a source of culture change friction. The higher engagement is, the less inclined an organization is to adopt significant culture change. In contrast, low engagement signifies a reduction of barriers to change.</em></p><p>Telling a winning team that is high on itself that it must fundamentally change how it operates will be met with considerable friction. However, as performance dips and engagement follows, the barriers to culture change diminish. Following Schein’s conception of organizational culture, a team or group that is “winning” will keep teaching and affirming the “ways things are done around here.” It is possible that key leadership could push the issue of culture culture in an organization that is wildly successful, but the deck is stacked against such action.</p><p>In an important way, engagement or eNPS tracks the willingness of an organization to question itself and the two factors are inversely related. A team struggling with engagement is going to both ask for and be more open to changing the way things are done (at least to some degree). The exception to this maxim would be circumstances where the drop in engagement is produced by culture change efforts! Then, an organization is seeing the fight-back of change resistance at play and likely a population that is holding onto the ways things <em>were</em> done.</p><p>What I think <em>is</em> a crucial indirect measurement of culture when it comes to engagement data is how resilient a company is. A company that weathers performance accelerations and decelerations without overly strong impacts to employee engagement or eNPS is very likely a highly resilient organization. Again, similar to competitive sports teams that aim to avoid “too high highs” or “too low lows.”</p><p>None of this diminishes the importance of engagement data for a people-centered, humanistic company. I would simply argue that we must be careful holding up engagement data (alone) as a measure of <em>culture </em>and how adaptive (or misaligned) culture is to company strategy.</p><p>Clearly, as well, <strong>company culture should be viewed as a subset of industry or sector culture</strong>. With the transience of Silicon Valley/tech workers, where in many instances average tenure has shrunk below 2 years, culture conditions are as much the product of the sector, which in turn is a product of the culture(s) of people that tend to be found in that sector (e.g., well-educated).</p><p>The average worker, for example, in Software-as-a-Service companies such as Salesforce.com or Atlassian has more in common, culturally, with workers within that sector than with workers, say, in the mining industry. I’ve worked in both sectors. A group of mine managers and a group of SaaS managers will share immediate and obvious belief systems, outlooks on life, etc., <em>within</em> their groups and have dramatic differences between them. I think this holds true even across geographical boundaries (i.e., Atlassian is an Australian company and SF.com has its headquarters in the Bay Area).</p><p>A potentially instructive comparison — it strikes me as evident and clear that different professional sports teams have very different team norms and strategic approaches. They have different team “personalities.” I think of the personality of the San Antonio Spurs during their championships era with the big three of Duncan, Parker and Genobili. The demeanor of the team as well as its strategic choices seems, at least on the outside, to have a lot to do with the personalities and temperament of the key players and particularly the coach; Greg Popovich in this case of the Spurs. In accounts such as <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Sacred-Hoops-Spiritual-Lessons-Hardwood/dp/1401308813/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3W46XH6QGYKP5&amp;keywords=sacred+hoops+by+phil+jackson&amp;qid=1568128731&amp;s=gateway&amp;sprefix=sacred+hoo%2Caps%2C158&amp;sr=8-1"><em>Sacred Hoops</em> by Phil Jackson</a> you get a look inside how the Bulls normed their team and Jackson even discusses team cultural differences between his Bulls and the Seattle Sonics. (sadly, I was a huge Sonics fan back in the day and that 1996 championship was a heartbreaker …).</p><p>However, professional sports teams of all types are culturally influenced as much by the shared histories related to collegiate sports, high-school sports and other factors. It seems safe to say that an athlete’s understanding of how to be a “team player” … something that has roots in years of prior athletics … is significantly at play in how she or he adapts to a specific team culture. Indeed, in many instances, there is likely dramatic unlearning that is required (Jackson describes this and his unusual methods for it in the book cited above).</p><p>The point here, in sum, is that we ought to consider company culture as a rather <em>weak filter</em> on a set of norms and pre-existing patterns of behavior as opposed to a determinant of behavior in an organizational context. As with athletes on professional sports teams, workers in the software industry (or any industrial segment) have already learned adaptive patterns of how to show up as a <em>software worker</em>. This includes implicit and explicit norms around the use of communication tools (email, Slack, Zoom) but also norms and expectations for what adaptive behavior looks like in general in these contexts. After all, “adaptive behavior” is just a way of thinking about Schein’s notion of tools and their correct use.</p><p>Consequently, if we are to study, analyze, influence, and make claims about local and specific culture in any company, we have to look to how groups within that context shape particular norms and practices. Specifically, we will need to gauge how groups within an organization scrum, jostle, and debate what strategies are advanced as correct and adaptive to deal with internal and external challenges.</p><p>Finally, there is the problem of <strong>who gets to say what a company’s culture is</strong>?</p><p>Clearly those in positions of senior leadership in the modern organization get to say what it <em>ought</em> to be. But there is a significant gap in many instances between what leaders want to be true of the culture of a company, and what workers in general are willing to abide by.</p><p>When we want to point to company culture, we can turn to stated company values and principles but also stated “valued behaviors” in policy documents that guide performance management. But it is the interplay of these explicit norms and the <em>unstated norms </em>— often in the forms of histories of rewards or punishments — that create a lived-in organizational culture. Further, what we might in the final result refer to as culture in a company is how a community of workers actually makes sense of all of this.</p><p>If I want to know what a company’s culture is, I ask people. A lot of people. I don’t ask (only) the leaders. Asking leaders or founders is helpful, but it is like asking an architect how it feels to live day-to-day in a building.</p><p>What is certainly true is that companies will have something that their employees refer to as the company “culture”, for good, ill, or usually somewhere in-between. They will be eager to share perspectives on this. Individuals may feel aligned and enthusiastic about a company’s culture (and their place within it) or may feel skeptical or even alien to it or, often, a combination of all of these!</p><p>A company does not gain its culture by the act of stating its values. What such articulations can do, if done well, is clarify, call out, and celebrate what kinds of norms and ultimately behaviors a community aspires towards.</p><p>I have found in organizations I’ve worked within but also organizations where I’ve consulted on culture or values, the best “values” are those that shine light on what is already deeply normed within a company as differentiated, important, and aspirational.</p><p>What we <em>practically </em>care about when it comes to company culture is how supports and enhances organizational performance. For example, if “we” — say founders or leaders of a company — strongly believed that survival of our enterprise depended significantly on unfettered creativity and free-flow of ideas, we would want to see such behaviors in the community of work and workers. We ought to state that clearly and reward those that exemplify it.</p><p>Our desire to see that culture flourish is not the same as it actually doing so. The larger our organization(s) become, the harder it is to hold together a clear and consistent fabric of cultural aims. When a company is very small, the words of founders and senior leaders ring loud and can guide a culture’s development. At 10,000 employees, culture work requires much more than any single person’s words or deeds.</p><p>Ultimately, <em>everyone</em> gets to say what a company’s culture is. There is no privileged vantage-point. There is no small set of people that have an exclusive claim of what a culture <em>is</em>, even if there is limited set of people that can, with authority, speak for the organization about what culture <em>ought to be</em>.</p><p>This makes the challenge of understanding company culture particularly complex. Where to look?</p><p>Going back to Schein’s conception, we can underline the notion that culture is a set of beliefs that can be taught — <em>is</em> taught — as useful and correct in the solving of problems. We teach through language, as a species.</p><p>So the first clue as to where to look when it comes to actual, emergent culture in an organization is how a community of work talks (and writes) about itself. Cultural anthropologists and ethnographers have done this sort of work for over a century. The systemic study of patterns of language use, and how those patterns manifest in daily rituals and practices is the mainstay of ethnographic research.</p><p>CEO’s I’ve worked with over the years without exception turn to the exhaustive open comments on engagement surveys when the engagement report data comes in. Occasionally, this bias can lead to anchoring on individual (and negative) comments. But there is a basic, correct intuition at play. If you want to know the sum of people’s beliefs about your company, listen to what they say.</p><p>Not all language-based content is <em>cultural</em>, however. A large amount of it is “noise.” It would be a stretch to say that daily back-and-forths … whether verbally in-person, verbally on video calls, in emails, in messaging apps … that are procedural in nature have high “cultural content.” Example (in a direct Slack thread): “How are you doing on that TPS report?”/ “Almost done, will send by end-of-day.” Pulling out from context, you could argue that some content on language-use such as this does have cultural weight — regarding norms around timeliness, accountability, etc. But it has what I’d call <em>low cultural density</em>.</p><p>In contrast, assertions to belief, claims on meaning, and a variety of possible <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/speech-acts/">speech-acts </a>surrounding the advancement of norms or knowledge … these have <em>high cultural density</em>. Example: “At XYZ company, we take very seriously how the customer experiences our service provision and what they feel about us as a service provider.”</p><p>Further, it is not only the content that is culturally meaningful, but the emotive “energy” attached to it. It is the difference between someone verbalizing the principle above, droning on as part of a ritual of customer service that has lost any passion behind it and someone with fire-in-the-belly reminding a group in a company that a customer’s experience <em>really</em> matters.</p><p>Culture is shown and re-enforced by how emotionally invested people in an organization are in the norms and practices that Schein refers to as the “teaching content” or the <em>cultural</em> <em>curriculum</em> of an organization. We might say a culture that has high investment in those practices has a strong culture (for good or ill), and one where the emotive investment is low has a weaker culture. You could expect people to rally behind a cause in a strong culture — even when the chips are down — precisely because of the strength of emotional investment.</p><p>Edgar Schein’s conception remains a practical characterization of what culture is in an organization. I would add to it the following, when it comes to where to look for culture, particularly with the increasingly powerful analytical tools we have at our disposal:</p><p>A company’s culture is the network and interplay of beliefs about how to (successfully) be a member in that company’s community. Further, it is the <em>beliefs and sentiment about those beliefs</em>. Importantly, it is not only that a company teaches new employees a set of norms and knowledge at new employee orientation — <em>it is how the teachers feel and what they believe about what they are teaching</em>. It is probably typical of most company cultures that they are conflicted places, fundamentally, where groups of people have very different beliefs about the stated and explicit norms. Rarely, a company aligns strongly, near-uniformly, and with passion about culture — sometimes in a good way, and equally in bad ways (e.g., Enron).</p><p>If we wish to develop scaled solutions (i.e., software) to study culture, we must find ways of studying these patterns of belief at scale. Likely, the only suitable target is language-in-context. Fortunately, our ability to use technologies such as natural language processing (NLP) and deep machine learning give us considerable analytical power that was not available when Edgar Schein wrote about organizational culture in his landmark text. These technologies are still in their infancy, and come with a host of questions including ethics surrounding privacy, analytical reliability, and technological complexity. If we can understand an organization’s emergent beliefs about itself by cataloguing language with high cultural density, we will take a key step from doorstep to fully within the realm of cultural analytics.</p><p>Mark Frein,</p><p>Culturally curious</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d16545119cf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In-Person Moments:]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/in-person-moments-2234cea73bc4?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2234cea73bc4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-working]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Jun 2019 15:05:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-07T15:05:23.479Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How to Make the Best of On-sites When Off-site/Remote is the Norm</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6amwP1mnuy0zB9gxZwyNQg.jpeg" /></figure><p>At <a href="https://www.invisionapp.com/">InVision</a>, one of the largest fully-distributed companies in the world, we have an ongoing challenge of how to get the biggest impact from the rare occasions when groups of us gather in person.</p><p>There is a natural inclination to gather people together for “rhythm of the business” moments: quarterly business reviews, planning sessions, etc. Clark Valberg, InVision’s CEO, noted to me some time ago that if we could not figure out how to do these things while remote, then remote would simply not realize its potential. In effect, if we could not <em>operate</em> the business as distributed management teams, we would never be successful in the distributed model.</p><p>So if not for business operations, is there a case for “in real life” meetings? (“IRL” as we acronym it at InVision)</p><p>I believe the opportunity that physical togetherness provides is fundamentally about connection and relationship. Despite all the mediating technologies that allow us to work at-a-distance, we are still bodies, in addition to being minds. There remains something irreplaceable about hearing the laugh of a colleague resonate against the walls of a room, or being able to shake hands, give and get a hug, and share meals together.</p><p>A month ago, I had the opportunity to bring my senior team of leaders in the People function together in Austin, Texas, for 24 hours. Two of us live in Austin, and one of the team members was already here for a meeting with other business leaders at the company. While not quite as a convenient as asking everyone out for a coffee or drinks after work at a brick-and-mortar company, it was a serendipitous seizing of a work opportunity.</p><p>We spent a morning catching up with each other and talking about key projects and programs for the quarter. We also just co-worked in proximity — all in a WeWork room. Then, we went out to dinner and laughed and talked some more. We had an agenda for the time together, and worked through a number of crucial topics related to the team. The most critical dimension of the time, however, was <em>how</em> we approached working as opposed to what we worked on.</p><p>As a team, we have focused for well over a year on increasing levels of interpersonal openness. There is still work to do — there will always be work to do. The progress can be slow at times in helping team members be comfortable enough with each other to let guards down and speak from places of authenticity and honesty. As Patrick Lencioni persuasively argues in his book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Five-Dysfunctions-Team-Leadership-Fable/dp/0787960756/ref=sr_1_5?crid=2EVZ5LM4RKGHZ&amp;keywords=patrick+lencioni+books&amp;qid=1559394998&amp;s=gateway&amp;sprefix=patrick+%2Caps%2C161&amp;sr=8-5">The Five Dysfunctions of a Team</a> a team cannot truly perform at its best unless it builds a foundational level of trust.</p><p>Similarly, a<a href="https://rework.withgoogle.com/guides/understanding-team-effectiveness/steps/foster-psychological-safety/">pplied research by Google on team dynamics confirmed prior studies by Harvard professor Amy Edmondson</a> on what fosters deep team connections, creativity and collaboration. If team members feel safe to express themselves authentically, take risks, and make mistakes, the team develops the resiliency to perform at peak as a unit.</p><p>Authentic and vulnerable self-expression creates the space for true interpersonal intimacy. Intimacy fosters trust. Trust allows teams and individuals to explore tough topics honestly and without holding back.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r7xa_GdVLbC1PadWsV-ZZg.png" /></figure><p>It is a virtuous circle of dialog— if we express our truths about our own emotional states, our hopes, our dreams as <em>people</em> on shared journeys, we will also feel willing to talk about business realities as colleagues and peers without politics. We will not fear well-meaning and developmental critique, and teammates will not distort realities to protect ego.</p><p>In contrast, if we do not personally feel we can take risks in what we say, the group will be unable to build the ability to be honest with itself. Not only does this lead to a team not facing tough business or operational realities, but erodes psychological safety. Over time, the inability for a team to speak honestly — among team members and to/about itself — leads to real business risks … sometimes, famously, <a href="https://www.history.com/news/how-the-challenger-disaster-changed-nasa">with disastrous consequences</a>.</p><p>Psychological safety has become a critical concept for teams and organizations since Edmondson introduced it. However, there is often skepticism about how to truly foster it in demanding work environments. It can seem to conflict with other notions such as “radical candor”, where the interest is ensuring that people challenge each other directly and openly. As Edmondson herself notes, psychological safety does not demand that people feel <em>affirmed</em> all the time in their viewpoints nor are free from challenge. Quite the opposite. In a team environment where psychological safety is present, I know I am required to challenge my teammates’ ideas and points-of-view <em>while still caring about them as persons</em>. Teammates in such environments know that everyone is striving toward excellence and the needs of the ego can be left at the door. We can disagree— passionately, even — but openly, and constructively since our relationship is built on care and interpersonal intimacy. Such is the basis of truly compassionate and radical candor (“candor with compassion” happens to be an InVision principle).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*we1Az5VwfS_Pqtja7h_ROQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.bennadel.com/people/823-kenny-bundy.htm">https://www.bennadel.com/people/823-kenny-bundy.htm</a></figcaption></figure><p>When InVision gathered together all 800+ team members from around the world last February for an annual IRL meeting, the first and foremost theme of the event was <em>connection</em>. We also aimed to align, and excite the company as our fiscal year began, but the goal of connection was primary. We programmed and designed the event for connection at all levels — to the company’s mission, between departments and teams, and ultimately interpersonally.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*whh6pREGD9OU_Zq3uHLSaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The all employee InVision House Band (“The Prototypes”)</figcaption></figure><p>It’s not easy to design an event for almost 1,000 people that fosters relationship-building and connection. Each time InVision experiments with “in real life” meetings, we iterate on how to achieve deep personal connection at scale. We still have a long, long way to go but we approach the events striving to be <em>people first</em>, before roles and titles. When we are able to show up and simply be with each other, celebrating being a community of humans, bonded by work relationships, but fundamentally <em>just people</em> working together the best we can, we allow the space for authenticity.</p><p>Solid work relationships are built on solid human relationships. Teammates do not have to be friends outside of work, but why not try to be <em>friendly</em> at work? We have to guard against hiring people that we “like”, since we tend to like people similar to ourselves. Teammates that all think the same way and believe the same things do not produce truly great things. Teammates — and communities, nations, etc. — that meaningfully care about each other despite such differences unleash profound human collective potential.</p><p>“In-person” is not simply about <em>where</em> people meet — i.e., in real-life, unmediated by technology. We need to remind ourselves of the <em>person</em> part of “in-person”.<em> I </em>am here, with <em>you</em>. In-person means gathering together as people — as human beings trying to be better together as people, first, and as a business second. If we approach in-person events as celebrations of communities, we will ensure that the time is spent deepening relationships, connecting, and strengthening shared culture.</p><p>Mark Frein — Striving to work <em>personally</em>, IRL or remote.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2234cea73bc4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Virtue of Fallibility for Leaders]]></title>
            <link>https://markfrein70.medium.com/the-virtue-of-fallibility-for-leaders-2c1866c21e93?source=rss-aa4a103f1ab------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2c1866c21e93</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Frein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 May 2019 16:51:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-21T16:51:20.493Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9rpYBtSjreRD_NBlzE5nuA.png" /><figcaption>By Alvaro Marques Hijazo, <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=75835795">https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=75835795</a></figcaption></figure><p>The notion of ennobling character traits or virtues has a <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-virtue/">long history</a>. Greek philosopher Aristotle described a system of ethics based on virtues of character. Chinese philosophers including Confucius articulated similar ways of understanding “doing right” as “being good” — i.e., being an upstanding person by habit and self-discipline.</p><p>Prominent virtues include honesty, courage, charity, prudence, and love. At <a href="https://www.invisionapp.com/">InVision</a>, the company where I work, we hold humility in high esteem given it not only informs our behaviors with each other but is critical for the empathy needed to listen deeply to customers. We place our customers’ voices first and listen deeply not only to understand problems but to resonate with the person articulating the problems.</p><p>Properly, “fallibility” is a word meaning the “capability of being wrong” and is a bit of a stretch as a virtue without further explanation. Given that we humans are imperfect, we are all fallible. I mean here something more pointed, however. I sometimes ask executives, “How is your <em>practice</em> of being fallible?” It is a question similar to asking someone how their yoga practice is, or about someone’s chops on a musical instrument, or the battle against oneself in improving one’s putting game in golf. My intent in asking it this way is to suggest that something like fallibility is a core component of the overall art of being a leader (as putting is to the overall golf game).</p><p>It is different than being humble but related. If humility, in a way, is ensuring that you do not overreach your sense of your impact on the world, fallibility is ensuring you do not overreach your confidence of your beliefs and judgements about the world.</p><p>Shakespeare’s <em>King Lear</em> is one of the ultimate demonstrations of the lack of fallibility. Lear awards his kingdom to two of his three daughters after they have professed false and exaggerated love to him. To the daughter that actually does love him (Cordelia), but will not embellish her declaration, he gives nothing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*Xfr9HHvhSIW6WYsjwuPxvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>No attribution, Creative Commons</figcaption></figure><p>Lear is many things — proud, vain, blind. He is also clearly narcissistic, a character trait I believe is the most direct opposite of having a good practice of fallibility. Lear says, after he has descended into madness from his mistakes, “They told me I was everything, ‘tis a lie, I am no ague-proof.”</p><p>Power can corrupt in an insidious way. Sometimes it is not the risk of overt abuse of power gained, but rather the risk of ego inflation so great the leader sees himself or herself as superhuman — incapable of error. Making this problem worse are the echo chambers that can surround senior leaders. Many subordinates do not feel comfortable challenging their senior leaders and leaders can unconsciously or consciously surround themselves with the proverbial “yes” individuals.</p><p>After all, it is very satisfying and emotionally boosting to be right. I believe all leaders struggle with the demon of narcissism. As an executive myself, I will cast stones only after recognizing my own journey to fight this demon. Over a 20 year leadership career, I have had feedback I’m stubborn, arrogant, don’t listen, make assumptions, create spin, etcetera. All the things and all of them no-fun to receive as feedback. I consider myself fortunate that very early in that leadership journey there were people around me that had the courage to call me on my BS. Many years ago, a person in the office I managed simply gave me a little red ball to put on my desk — a subtle reminder to ask a question before giving an answer.</p><p>At its most basic, fallibility in the way I’m using it here is the readiness to admit you are wrong. More importantly, it is not simply the readiness to admit one is wrong in the face of overwhelming opposition or when doing so is tactically to your benefit. Nor is it the readiness to <em>begrudgingly</em> admit one is wrong after making everyone else feel belittled.</p><p>It is a demeanor, a high standard, and an approach to life, hence a virtue even in the classical sense. It is consistently showing up as a person who is capable and willing to be wrong when engaged in rational inquiry. It is showing up — behaving in such a way — that others know you are open to new ideas, challenges, and to revising your viewpoints on a wide array of things. It is being transparent about what beliefs you hold that are and are not revisable, and always seeking to inform yourself about those.</p><p>It is showing others you are capable of self-doubt.</p><p>Some leaders assume that admitting mistakes is equivalent to admitting weakness which in turn makes one weaker as a leader. It seems to be true, at least in part, that some followers want a leader that continuously asserts with some degree of bravado in their perpetual “rightness”. Indeed, when we look around at the world leaders of today, it is rare to find anything other than this posture.</p><p>I can’t claim that leading from perpetual “rightness” is ineffective just given what is obviously true of whom has risen to the top in a wide variety of corporations and governments. It has <em>worked </em>for leaders in a wide variety of contexts, at least to gain them power.</p><p>I do not, however, think it is leadership that supports and sustains open, democratic society nor open, transparent and principled private sector organizations. Fundamentally, leaders are granted power by followers. I don’t personally find “Always Right” bravado in leadership appealing and generally-speaking, no one I’ve ever worked with that was creative, adaptable, reflective or emotionally self-aware does either.</p><p>Being fallible is a cornerstone of participating in a society or organizational culture that seeks to evolve its practices openly and rationally. It creates space for dialog and creativity and is highly engaging for people that want to have full voice and contributions. It enables participatory, inclusive, and diverse human systems.</p><p>Let’s call the extremes of the two styles Open Leadership or Closed Leadership. The first is, I believe, required for successful participatory and transparent cultures and societies. The second is fundamentally autocratic. Each can “work” in so far as there are clear examples of each both historically and at present around the world in all types of communities and human systems.</p><p>However, if there is a reason to insist on Open Leadership not only in governments but in private sector organizations where we do not vote our leaders into office, it is this: Open Leadership … leadership where there is a strong practice of fallibility … encourages and builds attitudes and norms that we desperately need to preserve to sustain open, democratic institutions in general. If all of our private institutions are examples of Closed Leadership, and if all the myths and narratives of corporate success celebrate autocratic-style leaders, we may become numb to the need for Open Leadership in our governments.</p><p>I would hazard to say that may just be where we find ourselves, at least in the United States. I find myself saddened by the degree to which popular media is dominated by leaders across the political spectrum continually asserting — shouting and fist-waving — their “rightness”.</p><p>We need to ask, “How might we all be wrong here?” “How might we be wrong about always needing to be right?”</p><p>Dr. Seuss’ <em>Bartholomew and the Oobleck</em> has one of the greatest parables I can think of illustrating fallibility. Like Lear, it is the story of a king that loses touch with his humanity.</p><p>King Derwin wants something different to fall from the sky other than rain, fog, snow, etc. (HIS sky). The king proceeds to go to every length to obtain what he wants and disregards the advice of his young page, Bartholomew Cubbins. The king leers over Bartholomew and rages “Boy, don’t you dare tell me what I can or cannot have! Remember, Bartholomew, I am King!” He gets for his demands a disastrous green guck that glues up his entire kingdom.</p><p>When finally, almost drowning himself in the green oobleck, Bartholomew confronts the king and roundly scolds him for his pride, the king at last says simply, “<strong>You’re right</strong>! It<em> is</em> all my fault. And I <em>am </em>sorry!”</p><p>In many ways the story illustrates pride, lack of humility, and hubris. It also illustrates something about the nature of <em>certainty</em>. The king refused to believe his page that he couldn’t have what he wanted. Bartholomew was, for King Derwin of Didd, utterly wrong in contradicting the king’s desires. Further, it is easy to see that prior to the story, the King was <em>unable to be wrong in general</em>.</p><p>We live in an age in technology work where leadership “distortion fields” are celebrated. In many scenarios, they are rightly celebrated for providing the impetus and vision for people to contribute and create beyond their own self-imposed limitations. Great leadership does indeed call out of people things they did not think possible.</p><p>It is equally true that the most devious distortion field for a leader is the field that self-deceives — a leader can fall easily prey to the demon of narcissism and believe his or her own deceptions. One of the worst of these is the the irony of the self-deception that one is always right. It is a lie about truth itself that leaders can tell themselves.</p><p>The more authority and responsibility I get in my career, the more at risk I feel I am to falling prey to losing a practice of fallibility and the more I must work on it. As with all character virtues, it requires habit, diligence, and work. It is the daily “chopping of wood” in the mind’s eye of self-reflection. My mantra is “I am human, and I am wrong, about a lot of things, all the time. I look forward to finding out where I’m wrong <em>not</em> so I can be right, but so I can remind myself of my humanity.”</p><p>The best advice I can give leaders for their ongoing journey — their practice of fallibility — is to ensure that they have as many Bartholomew Cubbins around them as possible. People that express themselves with compassionate candor (another one of InVision’s principles) and, when necessary, as Bartholomew did for King Derwin, take leaders to task with righteous fury.</p><p>Mark Frein — A soul on the profoundly human journey of making mistakes</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2c1866c21e93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>