<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Ortiz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Ortiz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 06:09:47 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@markortizauto/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[But Can Kennedy Win?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto/but-can-kennedy-win-358d85a8fa0a?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/358d85a8fa0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[independent-candidate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2024-elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2024-presidential-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2024-prediction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robert-f-kennedy-jr]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Ortiz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jan 2024 18:25:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-22T18:25:04.769Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am supporting Robert F. Kennedy Jr. in his independent / new party campaign for president. I am doing this despite having disagreements with him on some issues, notably Israel/Palestine and Bitcoin, because he is the only candidate who combines sound positions on most issues with polling numbers that suggest he can actually win the election.</p><p>At this writing (January of 2024), Kennedy has dramatically higher approval ratings than Biden, Trump, or any prospective duopoly (Democratic or Republican) nominees. In three-way election matchup polls against Trump and Biden, he is averaging around 18%. That’s people who say they’d vote for him; those who say they approve of him are over 50%. He is doing this despite his raspy voice, despite half the country not even knowing he’s running, and despite about half of those who do know he’s running only knowing the defamatory propaganda about him from the corporate “legacy” media. People who actually listen to the man predominantly come away impressed. This strongly suggests that he can dramatically improve on that 18%.</p><p>But how much does he need to improve, to get 270 electoral votes? What happens if he falls short of that? Is this a realistic project, or an exercise in wishful thinking?</p><p>I do not hold with those who don’t want to think about “what-ifs”. I come to this with the mentality of the engineer, not the motivational huckster. I know enough to take a hard look at a proposal and try to see if it’s feasible. I know it’s better to think in advance about what could go wrong than to find out the hard way.</p><p>I do not argue from authority or credentials. I do not ask you to take anything on faith. I do not want to waste my own time and energy, or yours, on a cause that has little chance of success.</p><p>I already knew, just from studying previous elections, that in a three-way presidential election, where the two popular vote losers run close, and all three candidates have nationwide rather than predominantly regional support, as a rule of thumb a candidate starts winning some states at around 20% of the national popular vote, and has at least an even chance at an electoral vote majority at around 37%.<br> <br> But I wanted something a little more scientific, so I did a simple feasibility study. I will explain how I did it, so you can check my work, and do similar studies yourself. I used nothing but a pocket calculator, pen and paper, and 2020 election results by state, obtained online.</p><p>I would emphasize that this is not an elaborate simulation, and is not intended as a guide to where to put campaign resources. It is a simple, “back of an envelope” exercise to get a rough idea what a Kennedy victory might look like, state by state, to see if the picture that emerges that way looks believable or not.</p><p>Any such calculation necessarily involves assumptions. For a first try, I am assuming:</p><p>· The duopoly share of the vote splits the same as it did in 2020.</p><p>· The non-Kennedy, non-duopoly vote (Green, Libertarian, No Labels, et al, combined) is 2% of the total vote in each state. This is about what the national figure was in 2020. 2024 could easily see this get as high as 4%, if the Greens get ballot access in as many states as in 2016, and there is a No Labels candidacy. There is always some state-to-state variation, but I am assuming 2% for every state in the interest of simplicity.</p><p>· Also for simplicity, I am treating Maine and Nebraska the same as the other states, ignoring the fact that they assign some of their electoral votes based on plurality wins in congressional districts, and just using the overall popular vote percentages for those states.</p><p>Applying these assumptions, I use the following methodology:</p><p>1. Find state-by-state 2020 presidential results online. Most sources will have the same vote totals and percentages. Make a list of the states, plus DC.</p><p>2. For each state, calculate the duopoly winner’s share of the duopoly vote, expressed as a decimal. I will call this the lopsidedness index, L. This will be a little higher than the winner’s share of the total vote. The equation is L = W / (D + R), where W is the winner’s percentage of the total vote, and D and R are the percentages for the Democratic and Republican tickets. In all cases, L will be a number greater than .500 and less than 1.000. Enter the L value next to the state name or abbreviation on your list.</p><p>3. Enter the number of 2024 electoral votes for each state on your list, next to the other entries. Note that these will be different than the 2020 values, due to reapportionment following the 2020 census.</p><p>4. Try a hypothetical whole-number percentage for Kennedy, and see if it wins. To see if it wins, assuming 2% other non-duopoly, first subtract the trial Kennedy percentage from 98, which is 100 minus the 2. That’s the total duopoly percentage. Multiply that by L. That gives you the duopoly leader’s percentage, which is the number Kennedy has to beat. Is the trial Kennedy number higher or lower? If it’s lower, it’s not enough for a win; try a higher Kennedy number, and repeat. If it’s higher than the duopoly leader, it’s enough to win. If it wins by a point or more, try a lower one and see if that wins. You will quickly find the lowest whole-number percentage that will win that state, given the assumptions used. With this method, for 2024, the lowest percentage will be 33. Do this for each state and enter the result next to the state name or abbreviation in your list.</p><p>5. Add up the electoral votes for the 33% states on your list. Is the number at least 270? If not, add the electoral votes for the 34% states, and see if that gets you to 270. If not, just keep going like this until you have at least 270.</p><p>I found that I had to include up through the 36% states. With that set of states, I got 274 electoral votes, from 22 states. If Kennedy can get at least 36% in these states, he wins. There are 5 states where he only needs 33%.</p><p>33% states: AZ(11), GA(16), NC(16), PA(19), WI(10) 72</p><p>34% states: FL(30), MI(15), NH(4), NV(6), TX(40) 95 (+72 = 167)</p><p>35% states: AK(3), IA(6), ME(4), MN(10), NM(5), OH(17), VA(13) 58 (+167 = 225)</p><p>36% states: CO(10), KS(6), MO(10), NJ(14), SC(9) 49 (+225 = 274)</p><p>Some readers will note that this method could easily be written as a spreadsheet. If you’re comfortable with that, by all means write one. You can then try all sorts of values.</p><p>I have just tried one other set at this writing. 2024 promises to be a year full of surprises, and at the best of times, in the words of Yogi Berra, “Predictions are hard to make, especially about the future.” We may very well see Biden, Trump, or both, NOT being the duopoly nominees.</p><p>However, we can get some idea how the race is shaping up by comparing those two candidates’ polling now with the numbers just before the 2020 election, and adjusting the actual 2020 numbers by the difference. Biden was polling about 54% in two-way matchups then. He’s polling about 49% now. Differences from 2020 will not be the same in all states, but, again trying to keep it simple, I took a look at how the numbers change if the Democratic ticket uniformly gets 5% less of the duopoly vote than in 2020. That would increase all the L values by .050 in all the 2020 red states, and decrease L by .050 in all the 2020 blue states where it was over .550. In the 2020 blue states that were under .550, the state flips to red, and the L value is then .500 plus .050 minus the previous amount over .500. For example, if the state was blue and L = .512 in 2020, it flips to L = .538, and the candidate to beat is now the Republican.</p><p>I also increased the hypothetical non-Kennedy, non-duopoly share to 4%. 2020’s 2% share is a bit low. 3% is about average. As mentioned earlier, 4% might actually be low, especially if No Labels fields a candidate.<br> <br>Intuitively, we should expect that the 2020 blue states get easier for Kennedy to win, and the red states get harder. We should also expect that the higher other-non-duopoly percentage makes things easier, or at least makes the necessary percentages lower. But what is the net effect?</p><p>Running the exercise this way, the number of states needed increases from 22 to 23. However, Kennedy almost doesn’t need any 36% states. He gets 264 electoral votes with just the 35%-or-less states. He just needs any one of the 36% states. If we add all the 36% states, which include California and Texas, he has an electoral vote landslide (&gt;2/3, or &gt;359): 381 electoral votes! There is one state, Virginia, that he could almost win with 32% — but not quite.</p><p>33% states: CO(10), ME(4), MN(10), NH(4), NM(5), VA(13) 46</p><p>34% states: AZ(11), DE(3), GA(16), IL(19), MI(15),</p><p>NJ(14), NV(6), OR(8), PA(19), WI(10) 121 (+46 = 167)</p><p>35% states: CT(7), FL(30), NC(16), NY(28), RI(4), WA(12) 97 (+167 = 264)</p><p>36% states: CA(54), IA(6), OH(17), TX(40) 117 (+264 = 381)</p><p>15 of the 22 35%-or-less states are in the previous set of 22 36%-or-less states. Ohio is also in that set.</p><p>Kennedy could lose any two of the four states with the most electoral votes (CA, TX, FL, NY), and still win the election, if he gets at least 36% in the other 24 in this set. If he wins CA or TX, he can afford to lose the other three biggest.</p><p>But what if Kennedy doesn’t get to 270, yet does carry enough states to prevent anybody from getting 270? What if he doesn’t carry any states, but peels votes disproportionately from one or the other duopoly party, sufficient to tip some individual states, and these are enough to tip the electoral vote? Both of these are quite possible, and they form a rational basis for duopoly adherents, or people merely resigned to duopoly rule, to shrink from voting for Kennedy once they get in the booth.</p><p>Taking the latter possibility first, there have been a number of recent polls that include a two-way matchup, and also a three-way with Kennedy included. These consistently fail to show a statistically significant effect when Kennedy is added. Both duopoly candidates get less, of course, but in some cases one does worse by a couple of points, and in other cases the other does worse by a couple of points. In some cases, there’s no effect at all. Two points is not a statistically significant change, especially when even the direction is inconsistent.<br> <br> However, there is some chance this could change a bit as Kennedy gets better known, although we don’t know how much, or which direction.</p><p>What if nobody gets 270 electoral votes?</p><p>First of all, this is less likely than people tend to think, because of the electoral college system’s tendency to amplify small margins of victory. Of the 59 presidential elections so far, there have been 10 where more than two tickets carried states. Only one of those went to the House, and in that one, four tickets carried states. Nevertheless, it is possible for this to happen in a three-way race.</p><p>If nobody gets 270 electoral votes, the House of Representatives chooses the next president. This occurs after the House is sworn in, so it’s the representatives just elected who are voting.</p><p>When the House votes on this, they don’t do it in the usual manner, with each representative having one vote. Instead, each state has one vote, and the entire state delegation have to settle among themselves how to cast that vote. The Constitution does not say how they are to make that decision, and it does not say whether a majority of those 50 votes is required, or just a plurality. It only says they have to choose among the top three electoral vote getters. However, it is probable that the state delegations will decide internally by plurality vote, and it is probable that most of the representatives will vote by party. This would result in a Republican win, even if the Democrats narrowly retake a House majority, because a lot of those Democrats would be from large-population states that only have one vote, just like all the others.</p><p>For the Kennedy candidacy to change the outcome of the election by sending it to the House, it has to be an election the Democratic ticket would otherwise win. For that to be so, the Democratic ticket’s performance in November has to be quite a lot better than Biden’s polling in January. The trend at this writing appears to be the opposite way, while Kennedy’s numbers are improving.</p><p>Then again, Kennedy has farther to go. But he’s got nine months.</p><p>In 1998, Jesse Ventura demonstrated, as the Reform Party candidate in the Minnesota gubernatorial election, how an outsider candidate’s numbers can improve over the course of a campaign. Before the televised debates, Ventura was polling at 9%. People who didn’t know him tended to assume he was just some knucklehead wrestler. Then they heard him speak. He won the election with a 37% plurality.</p><p>A similar dynamic applies with Kennedy.</p><p>It is quite likely that there will be no televised presidential debates in 2024, provided Kennedy gets on the ballots. The duopoly parties know he’d clean their clocks, no matter which of their prospective nominees they choose. In all likelihood, they will rely on the corporate media to try to keep Kennedy unheard, defamed, and marginalized.</p><p>But now we have the internet.</p><p>It’s going to be an interesting year.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=358d85a8fa0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOW TO COUNT VOTES]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto/how-to-count-votes-3ba26c1150c?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ba26c1150c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Ortiz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Mar 2020 15:24:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-18T15:24:20.884Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Mark Ortiz</p><p>Rev. 1, 3/18/2020</p><p>Reproduction for free use permitted and encouraged.</p><p>Reproduction for sale subject to restrictions.</p><p>Contact author at <a href="/service/mailto:markortizauto@windstream.net">markortizauto@windstream.net</a> for details</p><p>This document describes a method for counting votes, using no computers or non-transparent technology for the counting. It provides any person with a way to verify the count in any precinct in the country using only their own eyes, and a computer or other device on which to watch a video. It not only provides a way to detect any inaccuracies, but also provides a way to accurately ascertain their exact numerical effect, thereby providing a remedy for any error.</p><p>This method is suitable for elections for multiple offices, as seen in the US. It can be performed accurately by people who are tired, distracted, or interrupted. Almost any person can use it with minimal training. It avoids unobserved custody of ballots. It requires no expensive devices — only a couple of video cameras or the equivalent, capable of running for several hours with access to electrical power at a polling location. Even these are not necessary for the counting process itself.</p><p>It is possible to use this method with long ballots where all races are on a common sheet, but it is better to use a ballot in the form of a small booklet where each race is on a separate page. Most conveniently, these can be loose and bound with a plastic slide binder, or they can have a perforation line so they can be torn out and counted separately. For most situations, the pages can be somewhere between the size of a playing card and a half-sheet of typing paper (8.5” x 5.5”). In most cases, the print can be at least as large as on current American ballots, or often significantly larger.</p><p>The voters mark the ballots by hand, in a private booth, and put them in a ballot box, which can be equipped with a counter if desired — not to count the votes but to count how many ballot booklets go into the box. This can be electronic, but a simple mechanical device is fine, and as mentioned, the presence of any counter is optional.</p><p>At poll closing, poll workers separate the ballots and sort the sheets by race and by candidate or option selected. Depending on number of races and number of options, it may be convenient to sort just by race first, or not. Sheets can be color coded by race, making sorting faster and easier and making any mis-sorted by race detectable at a glance.</p><p>The entire sorting and counting process is done immediately, in the presence of observers. It is video recorded, preferably with one camera taking in a wide frontal view of the counting table and nearby area, and another looking down on the counting table. The sorter exposes each sheet to the camera as the sorting is done, creating a record of the sorting process.</p><p>As the sheets are sorted, they are placed in piles, and if desired in zip lock bags or even boxes if there are a large number.</p><p>Once the sorting is finished, the counting begins. The counter takes a pile or bag, and deals out two rows of five single sheets on the table. Observers, and the camera, get a second look at the ballot sheets, allowing any sorting errors to be caught. Five of anything is easy to see at a glance, and two rows of five is ten. The ten are then placed in a stack on the table, and the process repeats, with the stacks of ten likewise being placed in two rows of five. When there are two rows of five stacks of ten, that’s 100. The hundreds are rubber banded and placed in a row. This continues until all votes for that option in that race are counted. The process repeats for all races and all options, all with the camera running. Observers are allowed to record independently as well.</p><p>This method is superior to the hand counting method most seen in the US, where readers call out votes they read from long ballot sheets, and another person records these on a board or large sheet of paper with tick marks. It is relatively invulnerable to interruptions or distractions, or lapses of attention. It can be done accurately by a tired person, while carrying on a conversation. Anybody reviewing the video can see any errors. Not only can any error be identified, but its numerical effect can be ascertained, providing an easy way to correct the count without repeating the whole process.</p><p>Videos from every precinct are posted on line, without delay. Precinct totals are reported electronically to county boards of elections, who then post the precinct totals on line, allowing the observers and workers at any precinct to verify that the numbers from that precinct are correctly tallied. This is the appropriate way to use the internet in vote counting. Anybody can view and download any video or web page, providing multiple, independent backup files. Videos can be played back at reduced speed, making any attempts at sleight of hand difficult.</p><p>This is better than having some expert tell you that a process or device you cannot check yourself has integrity. You don’t have to decide whether to trust anybody. You can see the whole thing happen.</p><p>After the election, it is possible to keep the ballots so they can be recounted. US federal law requires keeping ballots for 22 months if federal offices are involved, and many states have similar requirements for non-federal races. However, I would discourage reliance on recounts as a safeguard of election integrity. Recounts are intrinsically subject to ballot custody problems, even when ballots are all paper. A manual count, done visibly with observers and video recorded, is more reliable and less subject to tampering than paper records stored and recounted days or weeks later.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ba26c1150c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Start a New Party the Way Lincoln Did?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto/start-a-new-party-the-way-lincoln-did-207eed0c1f19?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/207eed0c1f19</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[draftbernie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[third-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[republican-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peoples-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Ortiz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Aug 2017 22:50:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-08T22:50:49.918Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Mark Ortiz</p><p>Revision 1, August 8, 2017</p><p>Reproduction for free use permitted and encouraged.</p><p>Reproduction for economic compensation subject to restrictions;</p><p>contact author at <a href="/service/mailto:markortizauto@windstream.net">markortizauto@windstream.net</a></p><p>Did you know that Abraham Lincoln left the party he had previously been a leader of, ran for president as the first nominee of a new party, and won the presidency? It’s true. And I bet you knew. And you may have heard recent calls for Bernie Sanders to do the same thing Lincoln did, because that’s the proven method of launching a new party that can win and endure.</p><p>But I bet you thought the party Lincoln was previously a leader of was the Whig Party, the new party was the Republican Party, and the year was 1860, right?</p><p>Nope. The party he was previously a leader of was the Republican Party, the new party was the National Union Party, and the year was 1864. And his running mate was a Democrat!</p><p>Far from unifying the less than a decade old Republican Party and making it a lasting force in American politics, Lincoln as President precipitated a split in the Republican Party that led to it nominating a different candidate in 1864. Yet the Republican Party survived and did become a lasting force in American politics, while the new party that formed around Lincoln rapidly collapsed and is so obscure that most people have never heard of it, even though it had two presidents.</p><p>Lincoln was not a leader in the Whig Party. He was a member, and served one term in the US House of Representatives as a Whig (1847–49). But he was not a leader, and had no significant following.</p><p>Lincoln was not a founder of the Republican Party. He was not at its founding convention in Ripon, WI. He was not an early leader of it, although he did join within two years of its founding. He was not its first presidential nominee. The party had considerable electoral success before it ever ran Lincoln for anything, and the first time it ran Lincoln for office, he lost.</p><p>The Republican Party was founded in 1854, mainly by former Whigs but not exclusively. Lincoln had not held public office for five years at that point, and was not involved. The Republican Party’s first presidential candidate was John C. Fremont, in 1856. He carried 11 of 31 states. Three parties carried states in that election. The third one, the American Party, ran a former president, and carried only Maryland.</p><p>Fremont was also the Republican Party’s third presidential nominee, in 1864. Or more properly, he would have been, if there had been any Republican nominee. The faction backing Fremont renamed itself the Radical Democracy Party, and there was officially no Republican presidential nominee on the ballot. Fremont withdrew in September as part of a backroom deal with Lincoln that involved removal of Postmaster General Montgomery Blair.</p><p>Lincoln’s first run for office as a Republican was in 1858, for US Senate in Illinois. He lost. (It should be noted that in those days we didn’t have popular election of Senators. Lincoln lost in the Illinois legislature.)</p><p>Lincoln won in 1860 not because he was a charismatic leader with a following, but because he was the abolitionist candidate of a party formed around abolitionism, in an election that was to a large degree a referendum on slavery.</p><p>Prior to the 1860 election, the Republican Party already had a plurality in Congress and was able to pass things by coalition with two other parties. Four parties were represented in Congress at that time. The Republican Party got to this level of success without Lincoln. Earlier than that, it even had a majority — sort of. Its congressional candidates then ran under the name of still another party, the Opposition Party.</p><p>A large number of Republicans did follow Lincoln in bolting the Republican Party in 1864, and a large number of them won election, along with Lincoln, in an election that didn’t include any of the Confederate states. But they ran under a variety of party names, as the National Union Party never had a presence at the state level in its own right. But in 1868 the National Union Party collapsed, and they all went back to the Republicans.</p><p>So if you think you want a new Lincoln to form a new party the way Lincoln did, <strong>really</strong> study the history, and be careful what you wish for.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=207eed0c1f19" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Should Alternative Parties Support Ranked Choice Voting?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto/should-alternative-parties-support-ranked-choice-voting-8c6b53ebf602?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c6b53ebf602</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ranked-choice-voting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[instant-runoff-voting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[third-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Ortiz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Jul 2017 00:59:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-16T00:59:10.805Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Should Alternative Parties Support Ranked Choice Voting?</p><p>By Mark Ortiz</p><p>Revision 1, July 6, 2017</p><p>Reproduction for free use permitted and encouraged.</p><p>Reproduction for economic compensation subject to restrictions;</p><p>contact author at <a href="/service/mailto:markortizauto@windstream.net">markortizauto@windstream.net</a></p><p>Once upon a time, a bill was introduced prohibiting the hunting of wolves. This bill included a reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of any violators of the ban.</p><p>The leaders of the sheep read the bill. Sheep don’t have the greatest reading and comprehension skills, so they misunderstood the wording and thought the bill instituted a reward for people who did kill wolves — so they announced that they supported the bill, and declared that any sheep who didn’t were traitors to the sheep community. Most of the sheep, being sheep, followed them.</p><p>Seeing this, the wolves decided that since the sheep were supporting the bill, it must be a bad thing for wolves, so they opposed it.</p><p>Thus, both the sheep and the wolves were on sides of the issue that were diametrically opposed to their own actual interests.</p><p>This story may seem farfetched, but in fact this sort of thing is fairly common in real-world politics.</p><p>A case in point is the idea currently promoted in the US as “ranked choice voting” (RCV) — previously promoted as “instant runoff voting” (IRV).</p><p>For those unfamiliar with RCV/IRV, the idea is to institute a system similar to that used for the lower house of the Australian Parliament, the House of Representatives. Instead of voting for one candidate, the voter ranks all the candidates. In Australia, any ballot without all the candidates ranked is considered “spoiled” and not counted. It is also possible to have a similar system, without this rule.</p><p>All ballots are first counted by first-ranked candidate. If this does not result in a majority for any candidate, the candidate with the lowest total is dropped and all ballots for that candidate are recounted by next-ranked candidate. If there is still no majority, the hindmost is dropped again and the process repeats until somebody gets a majority.</p><p>This is widely thought to be beneficial to new or alternative political parties. The Green Party has supported it for a long time, and they still do. Justice Democrats also support it. Many Libertarians support it, although to my knowledge the party has taken no position as a body. I’ve heard Nick Brana of DraftBernie say he supports it, although again that’s not an official position of the organization. The system is actually in use in the US for some municipal elections. Voters in Maine recently adopted the system by referendum, although the state’s constitution didn’t allow the resulting statute to be fully implemented without a constitutional amendment. Legal wrangling continues in Maine at this writing. The legislature nearly passed a law repealing RCV, but the House and Senate couldn’t agree on specifics so the statute adopted by referendum stands for the time being.</p><p>Most adherents of the dinosaur parties oppose RCV/IRV, because they want to maintain the dinosaur party duopoly and detest any challenges to that. They automatically assume that any idea advanced by those seeking to challenge the duopoly must <em>ipso facto</em> be bad for the duopoly.</p><p>Some alternative party advocates have gone so far as to blame the lack of RCV for their party’s poor showings in elections, and insist that they will never have a fair chance to win elections until the system is changed to RCV. How they propose to change the system so they can win elections, when they can’t win elections under the current system, is not too clear to me, but that in itself doesn’t necessarily make RCV a bad idea.</p><p>Adherents like RCV because it eliminates the “spoiler effect”: the dilemma of voters having to choose between voting for the candidate they like best or the “lesser evil” of the duopoly candidates. It also arguably ensures that the winner receives the votes of a majority of voters, although not necessarily a majority of their first-rank votes. This is held to be superior to the plurality-to-win or “first past the post” system we have now, in which a candidate can win despite a majority of the votes being cast for two or more other candidates.</p><p>Noting these apparent advantages, and being a long-time alternative party advocate myself, fifteen years ago I supported RCV/IRV. I have changed my mind.</p><p>The truth is that <strong>RCV/IRV is bad for any party wanting to seriously challenge the duopoly, and good for the duopoly</strong>. The situation is just like the one in my fictional allegory above. All parties in the situation, with the possible exception of Justice Democrats who want to keep progressives within the Democratic Party, are adopting positions contrary to their own actual interests.</p><p>RCV/IRV only benefits, say, the Green Party or a new anti-plutocratic party, if the party’s real objective is not to actually win seats and change laws and policies but instead merely to “influence the debate” and to provide careers for its own candidates and officers without threatening the dinosaur parties. If the idea is to actually win seats, the present plurality-to-win system is not only acceptable — it’s <strong>better</strong>!</p><p>RCV/IRV is also inferior from an election integrity standpoint. The only way to have an honest vote count, verifiable by people without special training, is to hand count paper ballots at the precinct, before the ballots have been in any unobserved custody. If all the ballots have to be counted at a central location, they will necessarily be unobserved at least while being transported, and a hand count of so many ballots will take a long time. It might be possible to do counts at the precinct, transmit the counts and publish them on line, and recount at the precincts as needed. This might be feasible for one or two races, but for a large number of races, with a large number of candidates, it would tend to be really burdensome.</p><p>An electorally weak outsider candidate has no chance of actually winning under plurality or RCV. A weak candidate might get more first-round votes under RCV than ordinary votes under plurality-to-win, but what difference does that make if the candidate is still eliminated? The actual benefit is to the duopoly candidate most likely to be the second or third choice of the outsider candidate’s voters.</p><p>An electorally strong outsider candidate has a better chance of winning under the system we have now. An example occurred in the Minnesota gubernatorial race in 1998. Reform Party candidate Jesse Ventura, whose slogan was “Don’t vote for politics as usual” won with 37%. This was possible because the Democratic and Republican candidates split the remainder fairly evenly. Republican Norm Coleman had 34%. Democrat Skip Humphrey had 28%. The remaining 1% was split among four minor parties. If the election had been held under RCV, it is very likely that Coleman would have won. Based on my own experience with Humphrey Democrats, most of them would definitely want politics as usual and would predominantly have Coleman as their second choice.</p><p>This illustrates the fact that any system with any form of runoff, “instant” or otherwise, and a majority threshold for victory, tends to move outcomes toward the status quo — toward politics as usual; toward the option least disliked rather than the option most liked. Compared to plurality-to-win, majority-to-win increases the system’s stability, at the expense of responsiveness, regardless of how an eventual majority is guaranteed.</p><p>This can be good or bad, depending on the situation and one’s point of view. In a situation where somebody is trying to make major change of a kind you oppose, a system that makes change difficult is good for you. If you’re trying to make major change yourself, it’s bad. Generally, outsider candidates and parties will accept a greater risk of change they don’t like, to be able to have a better chance to institute the type of change they want.</p><p>Bottom line: if your main objective is merely to have fewer alternative party spoilers, you should want RCV. But if you want more alternative party winners, you are shooting yourself in the foot by advocating RCV.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c6b53ebf602" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[So You Want to Start a Party?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@markortizauto/so-you-want-to-start-a-party-122f42799645?source=rss-46eb33c5f9e5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/122f42799645</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[third-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[draftbernie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-elections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Ortiz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jun 2017 00:38:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-26T00:38:09.382Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Mark Ortiz</p><p>Revision 1, June 14, 2017</p><p>Reproduction for free use permitted and encouraged.</p><p>Reproduction for economic compensation subject to restrictions;</p><p>contact author at <a href="/service/mailto:markortizauto@windstream.net">markortizauto@windstream.net</a></p><p>It appears clear at this point that there will be a new anti-plutocratic electoral party launched in the United States this election cycle. The question is not whether there will be one. The question is how many there will be and what they’ll look like.</p><p>I am not going to bother making the case for the general idea of starting a new party. If you love plutocracy, you don’t need a new party and you probably won’t continue reading this article, unless you’re doing opposition research. If you’re still on board with the Democrats after the last two years and aren’t hot to find something better, stay with the Democrats. You deserve each other. If you think the Greens are the answer, work with them for a while (been there, done that, myself). I’ll still sign your ballot access petition. If you think the Libertarians can be steered toward the tradition of Thomas Paine rather than Ayn Rand and Murray Rothbard, have at it. If you’ve abandoned voting altogether due to the provable rigging of our elections, I can’t really blame you. But if you want a new party, I’m talking to you.</p><p>If you want to start an electoral party and have it succeed and make a difference:</p><p><strong>Make up your mind what you’re building.</strong> If what you want is an electoral vehicle, be clear about that from the outset. Structure your organization with that purpose in mind. Don’t start a pressure group or a cultural movement or a religion and then try to turn it into an electoral political party.</p><p><strong>Read the rulebook before you design the vehicle.</strong> Study election laws. Study ballot access laws. These are different in every state and you can’t learn all of them. However, you need to become as conversant with them as you can. The earlier you do this, and the more you do this, the better.</p><p><strong>Know your limitations. </strong>Understand what you do and do not control when you found a party. Founders control what the party is called, what its bylaws start out as, and who is initially approached to get involved. In the US, a party does not start with a comprehensive manifesto. Founders do not control the platform, the messaging, or even the choice of nominees, at least not beyond the earliest stages of the party’s existence.</p><p><strong>Decide how to decide.</strong> Your first decision, or a very early one, needs to be how you make decisions as a body when you are not able to reach unanimity. Even a provisional or exploratory leadership group needs to resolve this at the outset.</p><p><strong>Don’t look for a messiah.</strong> Do not fall prey to the myth that successful parties are started by leaders or celebrities with an existing following. History actually shows the exact opposite. Starting a political party around a celebrated political figure is the road to a flash in the pan for that person, followed by organizational collapse. Lasting political parties form around an issue position or small set of issue positions which have a proven constituency that existing parties are ignoring or suppressing.</p><p><strong>Avoid foreign entanglements.</strong> Don’t try to transplant a party from a country with a different form of government. There are good people and good ideas all over the world, and there’s nothing wrong with learning from them, but the United States has a unique legal structure that constrains what a political party is and does. International solidarity is basically good, but if you want a democratic US organization it is vital that this organization be answerable to its members and to the voters, and not to any organization outside the United States.</p><p><strong>Good intentions and ideas are not enough. You must execute.</strong> Any effort succeeds in the real world only if it is executed in a competent, organized manner. A mediocre concept with superior execution will generally beat a superior concept with mediocre execution. To successfully do the right thing, you must do the thing right.</p><p><strong>Avoid front office mentality.</strong> If you’re building it, the nuts and bolts are your job, not somebody else’s. If you think you can merely promote, promote, promote, and the details will look after themselves, you are launching the Tucker or the DeLorean.</p><p><strong>Pick a good name.</strong> The party’s name is important, and it’s one of the few things the founders really do control. You can deliberate about the name until you are ready to launch and pursue ballot access. Past that point, you’re pretty much locked in, because the name is what you’re getting on the ballots and publicizing. A few pointers:</p><p>1. Make the name descriptive of what you hope the party will stand for, and/or whose interests you hope it will serve.</p><p>2. Make it easy to pronounce and spell, and not overly long.</p><p>3. Has the name been used before? If so, do the parties that used it represent a history you want to be associated with? (There have been at least three People’s Parties and at least three Progressive Parties in the US already.)</p><p>4. Avoid creating confusion. In particular, avoid using the word “independent” or “independence”. This may lead people to register with your party when they think they’re registering unaffiliated. In states where party recognition or legal status is linked to voter registrations, this may be helpful for securing party recognition but you shouldn’t be pursuing that or anything else by confusing or tricking people. Also make sure the name does not resemble the name of another existing party, including relatively obscure ones.</p><p>5. Don’t call the party “new”. You’re hoping it will endure until it’s not new, right?</p><p>6. Think about what an adherent or member will be called.</p><p>7. Think about what the party’s name will be in other languages, and what an adherent will be called in other languages, especially Spanish and probably also French. (One possible way around this is to pick a name that simply does not directly translate, and therefore will have to be adopted in its English form — e.g. “Main Street Party”.)</p><p>8. What do the initials of the name look like? Do they make a clever acronym? An embarrassing one? In Spanish? French?</p><p><strong>Make full use of modern communication.</strong> This will be the first major effort at launching a party since use of the internet became widespread. Most people recognize that this means using the internet to promote the party. Evidently it is less obvious to many that, at least to start with, the organization can be set up and governed on line. The founders can set up an organization and have discussions and votes without needing to meet in person. This is invaluable when you are trying to create a nationwide organization but have limited means. I am in favor of hand-counted paper ballots for ordinary elections because this is the only way to guarantee a valid count, verifiable by anybody, and maintain ballot secrecy at the same time. However, if an organization is willing to have its members vote without anonymity, voting can be done at any time using nothing but a listserv and a spreadsheet. It is no longer necessary to have in-person meetings or even an in-person convention at all. I realize that some people still do not use computers. I have reservations about computers myself, and I don’t like excluding anybody, but there are a lot more people who can’t afford the time and money to attend a convention in person than there are who don’t use the internet.</p><p><strong>Think about the possibility of hostile takeover.</strong> Those who have been attempting a progressive takeover of the Democratic Party are finding out that the party is set up to prevent this, and they are outraged. Some who see this as reason to start a new party are determined that any new party should be more open. I certainly think it’s wrong to rig primaries and pull strings behind the scenes, while publicly representing that you have an impartial process where the voters choose the nominee, the way the DNC has done. However, I would urge you to think about how it’s going to be when the shoe is on the other foot: when you have a progressive party strong enough to be a threat and the corporatists try to overrun that. Take a look at how the Libertarians have dealt with this. Their party governance at the national level is more restricted to sympathetic insiders than the Democrats’ — only they don’t lie about it. Try to imagine what would happen if they didn’t restrict voting rights at their national convention to Sustaining Libertarians.</p><p><strong>Look way down the road.</strong> Don’t let the desire to retain momentum lead you into rashness or keep you from doing things right. In 2017, we are coming off the surprising showing that was the Bernie Sanders phenomenon, and many are keen to seize this moment. This is understandable, but it is important to bear in mind that the Bernie phenomenon was not something that sprang into being because Bernie waved a wand. It was the most recent culmination of processes and tensions that have been building for decades, and these will persist. The need for a new party isn’t going to go away, and the issues and the constituency that produced the Bernie phenomenon aren’t going away. Let’s be patient and get it right this time.</p><p><strong>Launch with a bang.</strong> If the intent is to have a major party that wins serious numbers of seats and has a real shot at making major change, the launch needs to be a tidal wave, not a trickle. If you don’t have the backing to pull off a dramatic and powerful launch, don’t launch. How do you know if you have the backing? The DraftBernie folks have the right idea in having a CrowdPAC where people pledge to contribute, if a decision is made to actually launch. I have criticisms of this effort, and of Bernie, but the idea of lining up pledges is sound. I would suggest having at least two such CrowdPACs, one to cover general operating expenses and the other purely for ballot access. A decision to launch would depend on the amount pledged for ballot access reaching a target that would cover petitioning costs to get the new party on the ballot in all or most states in six months. This cannot be done purely with volunteers. The amount of work is such that people have to be paid to circulate the petitions, and to supervise the circulators and make sure the petitions are properly handled. I estimate that $2.7 million would be a reasonable threshold. That would be 100,000 $27 pledges, or a bit over 1% of what Bernie raised for his primary campaign.</p><p>The ballot access campaign should be timed to achieve ballot access in most of the country early in a four-year election cycle. If that means waiting until the next cycle, so be it. Details of ballot access petitioning could be the subject of an article by themselves. What I want to emphasize here is the importance of doing this quickly, and early. Failure to do this is a major reason new parties don’t make it. They barely get ballot access before deadline, have no time to attract downballot candidates, and have nothing to promote but a presidential ticket that few people have heard of. They then fail to make threshold to stay on the ballot, and repeat the same process the next cycle. Over a series of election cycles, the party develops a track record of failure and the public dismisses it. It is vital to avoid this at all costs.</p><p>This is a time of great opportunity for a new party representing the 99%. However, despite unusual levels of discontent with the Democratic and Republican Parties, the dinosaur parties are extremely entrenched. Any effort to challenge the duopoly will face big challenges. But perhaps it can at least avoid the known pitfalls that have relegated previous efforts to the margins.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=122f42799645" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>