<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mathias Agbo Jr on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mathias Agbo Jr on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 02:02:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nigeria’s Institutionalised Prejudice against Small Businesses]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/nigerias-institutionalised-prejudice-against-small-businesses-a757eecc7ce3?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a757eecc7ce3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[small-business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Aug 2018 10:47:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-31T10:52:22.224Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>First published in THISDAY Newspaper of 17th<strong> </strong>February<strong> </strong>2016</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*xGQEsveEd4vm50ume7Mn4g.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“I believe in the dignity of labour whether with the hand, or with the head; and that the world owes no man a living, but that it owes every man the opportunity to earn a living” - John D. Rockefeller</blockquote><p>In 2013, the Small Business Administration (SBA) announced that the US Federal Government, after eight years of persistence, had met and even surpassed its goal of awarding at least twenty-three percent of all its prime contracts to small businesses. This, according to the SBA, was a very significant milestone, as it further reinforced the US President’s promise to lead the way in small business support and promotion. The US Federal government proved that this feat was not a one-off accomplishment when, in 2014, the SBA annual small business procurement scorecard showed that the US Federal Government awarded 24.99% of its contracts to small businesses, translating to around $91.7bn worth of projects and creating approximately 550,000 jobs in the process. Interestingly, within this remit, the US Federal government has also created further ring-fenced provisions for certain categories of small business, such as women-owned businesses (with a target of 5% of contracts), small disadvantaged businesses (5%), service-based veteran owned businesses (3%), and ‘Historically Underutilized Business Zones’ or ‘HUBZONEs’ (again at 3%). These ‘set-aside’ provisions ensure that even amongst small businesses, the interests of certain disadvantaged demographics are amply catered for.</p><p>The US government isn’t alone in opening up the contract space for small businesses; in the UK, new reforms have seen the central government relax the conditions for contract pre-qualification hitherto set for small businesses. Examples include the abolition of certain pre-qualification requirements like the POQ — a more than 40-page-long questionnaire used as screening for certain categories of government contracts — so as to help small businesses more easily secure government contracts. The UK Central government reported that between 2013 and 2014 it spent £11.4 billion doing business with small and medium-scale enterprises. This figure represents 26% of the total value of all UK central government contracts awarded within that period. Subsequently, the UK Minister for Cabinet Office, Matt Hancock, also announced in August 2015 an ambitious target for the UK government of spending at least £1 in every £3 doing business with small and medium-scale businesses by the year 2020.</p><p>Here in Nigeria, small business promotion has been on the lips of government at all levels, for as far back as one can recall. Through its different agencies the federal government has, over the years, designed a handful of intervention programs to assist small and medium scale businesses, amongst them programmes such as YOUWIN, SMEDAN, and MSME Funds. Through these interventions, the government selectively distributes micro-credit facilities to small and medium scale enterprises. These interventions, though helpful in their own way, have not exactly translated into long-term successes across the board for small businesses. This is because these programmes have very limited reach and scope, and poor implementation strategies; furthermore, they only partially address the root cause of the under-performance of small businesses in Nigeria.</p><p>Consequently, while some of these interventions might work for certain categories of small business, they won’t work for others, because not all small businesses require massive start-up capital — especially those in the service sector. For instance, professional businesses that provide services such as auditing, accounting, legal, actuarial, translation, and architectural and design consultancy, typically do not require much in the way of physical or tangible inventory to ‘set up shop’ — more likely just a few office consumables. They can run on their own right from day one, hence they do not need government loans or grants; they need only patronage to become profitable in their very first year of business. They are so flexible that they could be run from home offices or even virtual offices until they gain traction and, as their businesses grow, move into permanent offices. Their core expertise is typically built around the skill-set of their principals; the rest might run entirely on an indirect and transient workforce. Hence, such businesses will most often initially not require a full staff, at least until its work load increases.</p><p>Ironically, in spite of the posturing and the heavy ‘small business’ rhetoric espoused by the various tiers of government over the years, they have consistently refused to trade with small enterprises, whom they have in fact systematically excluded from the award of government contracts. A typical pre-qualification requirement for government contracts in Nigeria reads like a well-curated ‘litany of exclusion’ for small businesses. These contract award criteria effectively decimate the chances of small businesses clinching government contracts, and only those who bribe officials and falsify documents ever get through the process. It is sad to note that in spite of the supposed stringent conditions attached to government contracts, a good number still end up in the portmanteau of charlatans and their briefcase companies, some of whom are not even registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission. Sadly, this is not a one-off incident but in fact is gradually becoming very standard practice across the country. In some cases, those who win these contracts go ahead and resell the contract award papers to third parties, who themselves in turn resell them without ever setting foot on the project site; with each group pinching huge chunks off the stated contract sum, the final executor (who will most likely be a small business) is left with peanuts to execute the contract, thereby emerging with wafer-thin profit margins.</p><p>Consequently, by its refusal to patronize small businesses, the federal government has set a very bad precedent for the state governments to follow; most of whom have also adopted the same draconian pre-qualification contract requirements often requested of small businesses. If government does not trust small businesses enough to patronize them, why should anyone expect private entities to do so? Sadly, the discrimination and bias against small businesses in Nigeria have become so firmly entrenched that they have been institutionalized across every tier and arm of government. Some of the requirements — such as participation in contributory pensions, or contribution to Industrial Training Funds — are such that most small businesses cannot meet them: they don’t do enough business to cover these costs.</p><blockquote>The future looks very bleak for small businesses in Nigeria, and a casual observation reveals a current reality whereby most small service businesses in Nigeria will permanently remain small businesses, subsisting only on the few jobs they can scrounge from time to time from a very limited pool of private clientele. Others meanwhile will simply fold up, as their owners abandon their entrepreneurial (mis) adventure, dust off their CVs, and head back into the densely saturated labour market in search of nine-to-five jobs to keep body and soul together.</blockquote><p>As Nigerian universities annually churn out tens of thousands of graduates trained for white collar jobs, it is important that the avenues for gainful employment are made available for them. I believe when a person goes through school and trains for several years to become a lawyer, an architect or engineer, it is not only imprudent, but indeed an aberration and a mockery of our educational system, for him to be told to go to the Bank of Industry and queue up for a business grant or loan, to start a laundry/dry cleaning business or go into grass-cutter farming. Yet, government won’t patronize small businesses that are willing to employ these professionals. I think every graduate professional deserves to be given the opportunity to work in the field of expertise that will make use of his professional skill-set and experience. This will not only give him/her professional fulfilment, but will also give Nigeria the opportunity to build and develop local manpower by encouraging professional specialization.</p><p>Whenever government preaches entrepreneurship, it is important that it also backs this up with the appropriate behaviour that honours this commitment. Small businesses in Nigeria have as much stake in the future of this country as do big corporations, and it is unfair and outrightly biased for government to continue to exclude small businesses from executing government contracts. The Federal government, as the biggest individual spender in the Nigerian economy, has the moral obligation to ensure that small businesses actually get the opportunity to do business. Therefore, it must patronize them: because it is not enough to provide handouts in the form of grants or loans for certain categories of small businesses, without creating the enabling climate for others to even exist. This exclusion goes against the principle of fairness and against that of equitable distribution of wealth. It is therefore not a coincidence that the gulf between the rich and the poor is widening by the day; it is this attitude of governments over the years that has bred and nurtured not just this disparity, but also the accompanying schadenfreude and class hatred that has ensued.</p><p>The advantages of promoting small businesses are innumerable. And with the current economic challenges the country is faced with, small businesses have the potential to give the government more value for its money. They have the capacity to stretch every kobo as far as possible; because unlike big corporations, small businesses do not have large overheads to pass on to the government when executing contracts; rather, they thrive on their thriftiness and lean organisational setup.</p><p>Small businesses have the inherent capacity to evenly redistribute wealth faster than big businesses, and the trickle-down effect will be felt sooner by the general populace. Small businesses also have the capacity to cumulatively create millions of white-collar jobs for Nigeria’s teeming graduates, because only small businesses typically take the risk of hiring inexperienced professionals and training them on the job. Small business owners can also work as allies with the tax authorities by helping to document and also bring under the tax net their employees, sub-contractors and artisans, who otherwise do not pay taxes and have no way of being tracked.</p><p>It must be stated that small business owners are not lazy people waiting on the government for their next meal, but hard-working Nigerians that have taken on the momentous and very intimidating challenge of setting up business in Nigeria, in spite of the massive odds stacked against them. Therefore, the very least the government can do is to patronize them sufficiently to get them on their feet. This will not only boost their confidence, but also compel the private sector to treat them better and pay appropriately for their services.</p><p>Government does not need to lower the bar just to accommodate small businesses, because most small businesses today have already met the very discriminating standards of the private sector; hence, they will no doubt surpass the current pedestrian standards government contracts are being executed by. Rather, the government should abolish all the red tapes and needless impediments that are currently precluding small businesses from bidding for some categories of government contracts. The government should also forget about any pre-qualification requirements besides expertise. Small businesses should in the first instance be encouraged to present themselves for government contracts before being asked to meet any other requirements.</p><p>I must concede that small businesses do not possess the requisite technical expertise to bid for all categories of government contracts, hence I suggest that rather than lump all government contracts together, the government should create dedicated contract categories for small businesses, giving them at least 15% (for a start) of all federal government contracts, and encouraging states and local governments to do same. For instance, no government agency needs to hire a law firm staffed by Senior Advocates of Nigeria (SANs) to draft a basic tenancy agreement on its behalf, when it can hire a small law firm of young lawyers, who most likely will be willing to do the job for a fraction of the fees the former would have collected. International donors and foreign embassies can also take a cue from this, by ensuring that a sizeable percentage of all donor-financed projects go to small businesses.</p><p>Until all this is done, most small businesses will remain ineligible to bid for government businesses, thereby denying the government of their rich repertoire of technical expertise — until such a time comes, small business owners will continue to <em>siddon look</em>.</p><p>Written by</p><p>Mathias Agbo Jr</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a757eecc7ce3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[WHAT IS LIFE?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/what-is-life-2a7079f80f4a?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a7079f80f4a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jan 2018 22:30:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-03T06:17:02.701Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>WHAT IS LIFE?</strong></p><p>To the rich; it is an avalanche of merriment. <br>Of a big barn, a large cellar, massive chariots, a large safe and a big harem.</p><p>To the newly wed; it’s a minute of bliss in each others` arms and enthusiasm for tomorrow and all that it holds.</p><p>To the sick, it’s a festival of bad health. Of aching backs and excruciating pain, of hopelessness and an adamantine desire to taste of Socrates’ hemlock.</p><p>To the heart-broken, it’s a season of torment, of oblivious whirling of the winds of time. Of endless hope against hope of their lover’s return.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VvW1C9TvfTZiEapgSBQpKA.jpeg" /></figure><p>To the debtor, it’s a morbid fear of tomorrow; cowed by every footstep and shadow at his doorstep, lest it be that of his creditor.</p><p>To the labourer toiling day and night in anticipation of harvest, it’s a hard smile at the thought of payday, as he gropes in a pool of his miry sweat.</p><p>To the poor, it’s the lowest ebb of dignity, a life sentence of penury, and decades of indigence, hunger and bad taste.</p><p>To the dead, it’s the coinage for an indefinite repose from the long and torturous trudge on the bye-ways and highways of life.</p><p>To Mother Nature, it’s a wonderful rendition of the creator’s artistry and invincibility. And an eternal exhibition of His superior craftsmanship.</p><p>And what is life to me? Hmm…what is life to me? <br>To me it’s an opportunity to make the best of a borrowed entity…life; and afterwards return it to the supreme creditor.</p><p>Photo Credit: Sadguru.org</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a7079f80f4a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Automation: What I saw in Stockholm and my Growing Fear for Africa]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/automation-what-i-saw-in-stockholm-and-my-growing-fear-for-africa-477110e2e7c1?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/477110e2e7c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Mar 2017 03:57:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-30T11:07:00.975Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lMG8GhikGyXMs1IouPvlXw.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the twilight of my month-long design residency in Sweden, last July, I took out time to meet with an old friend in Stockholm. We were course mates at design school, and had agreed to have dinner that evening at an Italian restaurant in commemoration of our days in Florence. We met at the campus of the Royal Institute of Arts at Skeppsholmen and strolled from there to Stockholm&#39;s medieval downtown, Gamla Stan. We leisurely wove through Gamla Stan&#39;s labyrinth of cobble-stoned streets, and narrow alleys for at least half an hour, before we spotted an Italian restaurant. Once we entered the restaurant, the cashier issued each of us a plastic chip card that looked just like EMV cards, but bore only the insignia of the restaurant on them. The place was packed to the rafters and we had to wait in line to get a free table. After waiting for close to five minutes, we eventually found a vacant table. I surveyed the crowd of diners again, and couldn’t help wondering how hard the waiters there worked.</p><p>When it was time to order food, I walked up to the chef at the service counter, and was issued a contraption that looked like a covered &#39;saucer&#39;; my first impulse was to take the &#39;saucer&#39; back to my table and eat the appetiser inside it, then I got confused when the the chef entered my order into his computer and asked me to place the issued plastic card on top of the &#39;saucer&#39;, it gave out a faint beep, and he said I could go back to my seat, and that I would be notified as soon my order was ready. I went back to my seat and sat down, after which my friend who had been keeping vigil over our table left to place her order. I looked around and observed that most people had my kind of small &#39;saucers&#39; on their tables as well, but none of them made any attempt to open or even eat out of them, so I laid mine gently on the table and went about other businesses, as I waited for my meal to be sent in. I got busy with one of my favourite past times - mental design critique. I was seizing up the decor and spatial layout of the restaurant; taking mental notes, of what I liked and what I would have done differently. I was deeply engrossed in my sanctimonious reverie, when the &#39;saucer&#39; started vibrating, and emitting an intermittent glow of red light. It was the chef buzzing me-my meal was ready. I looked at the buzzing &#39;saucer&#39; again, and then smiled ashamedly at the thought of almost ripping apart a &#39;harmless&#39; device in search of a freebie. I waited for my friend to get back, after which I went for my food.</p><p>When I got back, I asked my friend what she thought about the &#39;saucer’. She smiled, and went on to inform me that Near Field Communication (NFC) devices like the one we were given, are becoming a common feature in restaurants these days-as most Scandinavian businesses are turning to technology to save cost on manpower; and that, the &#39;saucer&#39; effectively eliminates the need to have an army of waiters in a large restaurant like the one we were at. I turned this over in my head for a while and agreed that it was truly an ingenious innovation, considering that the Scandinavia has one of the most generous pay packages in the world for blue collar workers, hence by this supposedly simple technology, the restaurant could have made savings on at least half a dozen waiters at just one of its outlets. Then for a moment, I couldn’t help imagining the possibility of this technology being introduced at my favourite restaurant back home in Abuja. And I was instantly startled by this juxtaposition, because, I kept wondering which of my waiter-friends would be asked to go home; all the guys, whose names I now know, and whose good-natured disposition keep me going back even when I thought the vegetable soup there, no longer tasted as good as I knew it to. This unsettled me for quite a while; because I suddenly realized that ingenious technologies like this had the potential to further enlarge the well over &#39;one-hundred million-man strong&#39; army of the unemployed, across Africa and other developing and emerging economies in the global south.</p><p>I imagined these technologies were symptomatic of a very unsettling future for economies in Africa, especially with the ballooning global rate of unemployment which according to ILO’s World Employment and Social Outlook – Trends 2016, is expected to rise by as much as 2.3 million in 2016 and by a further 1.1million in 2017, which will eventually bring the number of global unemployed to about 200 million in the next couple of years (WESO 2016). These projections by ILO does not even take into account the number people who are underemployed, or those grumblingly employed at poorly paid jobs they would rather not do, if they had a choice.</p><p>I am even more frightened by the plausibility of job automation in Africa because, most countries in Africa have wholeheartedly embraced globalization. Especially as evident by the attendant successes of Africa’s home-grown capitalists, all of whom have acquired the shrewd business acumen of their opposite numbers in the west, and the accompanying greed that goes with it. This group will have no qualms adopting these technologies if placed within their reach.</p><p>In spite of how much technology has done for the growth of African economies, I still believe that rather than the blanket adoption of all new technologies and innovations, Africa must allow it local sociocultural and socioeconomic realities dictate how much it’s economies evolve with it. This might not be the most profitable thing to do for most businessmen and women, but it is without doubt, the right thing to do. This is because, the gulf between the rich and the poor across the continent is already too wide as it is, and Africa must do all that it can, not to deepen the ravine too.</p><p>Africa must acknowledge that this widening gulf isn’t infinitely elastic, and at its breaking point, the continent will be confronted with the appropriate repercussions. And that the continued widening of the wealth gap and the accompanying kerfuffle will eventually set the stage for widespread social unrest that will in due course consume all the fortunes built with indifference to the plight of the larger populace. This is even more pertinent considering that most countries in Africa have barely enjoyed up to five decades of uninterrupted political stability. Consequently, all the pre-existing socio-political faultlines are still quite visible in our polity; hence too many jobless people on the street, poses a real and imminent danger for the generality of the citizenry. Therefore, I believe is in the overall interest of the continent, that it makes a conscious decision well in advance, to skip every technology that upsets the prevailing ersatz peace in its communities; so as to guarantee in the long run, the right social climate for the continued existence of its local businesses.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=477110e2e7c1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Form Follows Function: A Fallacy Taken Too Far]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/form-follows-function-a-fallacy-taken-too-far-6e19cb081432?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e19cb081432</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[function]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-process]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forms]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Feb 2017 14:59:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-22T15:10:03.938Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*ntEC5Tu2y-wWSi21BuOoSg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The authorship of the maxim ‘form follows function’ has been as controversial as the dictum itself. It has, at various times, been ascribed to Italian Jesuit monk and architectural theorist Carlo Lodoli, then American sculptor Horatio Greenough and even to Frank Lloyd Wright. Although Greenough’s collection of essays was published in a 1947 book titled Form and Function: Remarks on Art, he is not the author of the phrase; the author of the dictum is actually one of Greenough’s admirers, American architect Louis Sullivan. The actual quote reads as “form ever follows function” and it first appeared in an essay written by Sullivan titled “The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered”. And it was first published in March 1896, by the now-defunct Philadelphia-based monthly literary magazine Lippincott’s Magazine, which at that time periodically published articles and poetry, as well as literary criticisms.</p><p><em>Photo credit: design.fanpage.it</em></p><p>In Sullivan’s essay, he explains how he thought an ideal sky­scraper – which he referred to as the office building – should be designed. His argument was against a misconception and trend at that time, where each floor of the skyscraper was uniformly sub-divided to create a uniform spatial layout on all floors; he was of the opinion that, ideally, floors should be separately spatially sub-divided, based on the functions they were expected to perform. Therefore, the crux of his discourse was to discredit the prevailing practice at that time, and this is how he put it:</p><p>“<em>All of these critics and theorists agree, however, positively, unequivocally, in this, that the tall office building should not, must not, be made a field for the display of architectural knowledge in the encyclopaedic sense; that too much learning in this instance is fully as dangerous, as obnoxious, as too little learning; that miscellany is abhorrent to their sense; that the sixteen-story building must not consist of sixteen separate, distinct, and unrelated buildings piled one upon the other until the top of the pile is reached</em>.” (Sullivan, 1896)</p><p>The summary of the above quote from Sullivan’s treatise is that every floor of the ‘tall office building’ must be designed independently of the others, and must be designed based on the function it is expected to perform. These arguments by Sullivan are, indeed, an accurate prediction of how we have been designing skyscrapers until this day. Contemporary sky­scrapers are now designed with a multi-functional or mixed-use approach, where the array of functions each skyscraper caters for could be as varied as the number of floors in the said building. It is, today, commonplace for a single skyscraper to pack within its frame multiple functional spaces like luxury apartments, hotels, and entertainment and retail spaces, with each floor, or set of floors, designed to precisely accommodate the functions which it is supposed to perform. Naturally, if Sullivan’s treatise had been solely restricted to the context of the design and spatial planning of the ‘tall office building’, he would have indeed been deemed to have alluded to a universal truth. But somehow, the treatise strayed well beyond the context of the design of ‘the tall office building’, to assume a supposed role as a general principle of design as is being alluded to today, as could be inferred from the later part of his essay, which says:</p><p><em>It seems ever as though the life and the form were ab­solutely one and inseparable, so adequate is the sense of fulfilment. Whether it be the sweeping eagle in his flight, or the open apple blossom, the toiling work-horse, the blithe swan, the branching oak, the winding stream at its base, the drifting clouds, over all the coursing sun, form ever follows function, and this is the law. Where function does not change, form does not change. The granite rocks, the ever brooding hills, remain for ages; the lightning lives, comes into shape, and dies, in a twinkling.</em></p><p>“<em>It is the pervading law of all things organic and inorganic, of all things physical and metaphysical, of all things human and all things superhuman, of all true manifestations of the head, of the heart, of the soul, that the life is recogniz­able in its expression, that form ever follows function. This is the law.</em></p><p>“<em>Shall we, then, daily violate this law in our art? Are we so decadent, so imbecile, so utterly weak of eyesight, that we cannot perceive this truth so simple, so very simple? Is it indeed a truth so transparent that we see through it but do not see it? Is it really, then, a very marvellous thing, or is it rather so commonplace, so every day, so near a thing to us, that we cannot perceive that the shape, form, outward expression, design, or whatever we may choose, of the tall office building should in the very nature of things follow the functions of the building, and that where the function does not change, the form is not to change?</em>” (Sullivan, 1896)</p><p>It is from the above excerpts of his essay that the now notoriously famous dictum ‘form follows function’ was instantly coined. All of a sudden, modern theorists elevated this dictum well beyond the realm of the design of ‘the tall office building’, to a supposed principle or even a universal law of design. This posse of theorists has gone to town with tons of unproven rhetoric, which untidily attempts to validate the significance of this dictum in the design sphere. Furthermore, in their quest to harness the full alliter­ative potency of their new dictum, they have also left out the ‘ever’ in Sullivan’s original phrase, to make it ‘form follows function’. Ever since then, this meaningless string of words has become the favourite dictum of design maestros and neophytes alike, and a supposed rallying cry for design zeitgeists around the world. At this point, one is no longer sure if Sullivan was still referring to the law in the context of the spatial subdivision of the high-rise building or whether he was referring to the entire sphere of design.</p><p>My first instinct was to assume that Sullivan was heavily mis­understood by this group of theorists, and has, indeed, been erroneously quoted out of context. I considered this a very plausible explanation because of his writing style, which isn’t particularly concise; it is more rhetorical and is outwardly far more poetic than it is cerebral. It, indeed, takes a series of readings and re-readings to fully decode the full yarn of his discourse. Hence, it is almost natural to conclude that Sullivan was quoted out of context. This much was alluded to in a recorded quote from one of his protégés, Frank Lloyd Wright, when he said: “Form follows function – that has been misun­derstood. Form and function should be one, joined in a spiritual union.”(Wright, 1908)</p><p>Although it is still unclear in what context Wright made this statement, there is no doubt that he was referring to the dictum that had been made popular by Sullivan’s essay. Who better to know what Sullivan meant than Wright, who had worked closely with him as his draftsman at Adler &amp; Sullivan, before he was fired by Sullivan for moonlighting and taking on commis­sions outside the firm?</p><p>We could all have easily concluded that Sullivan was misquoted and probably long left the matter at that, but Sullivan himself had already set the stage for the current misunderstanding when he tried to reinforce this dictum by saying: “This is the law. Shall we, then, daily violate this law in our art?” Yet he explicitly failed to say which law he was referring to. Even if Sullivan’s allusions were drawn from a valid law, it is one that is obviously flawed on numerous fronts; at least contemporary design, in practice, over the years, has repeatedly defeated the reasoning behind such a law. Not even his mere allusion to nature and its forms makes it credible because his inferences were not backed by any known or proven logic. Sadly, modern theorists have long gone to town with the new ‘law’, as supposedly propounded by Sullivan, as they basked in an imaginary eureka moment for design. The real tragedy here is that this dictum has already been unquestioningly accepted by the universal design community, and is probably amongst the first dictums that welcome thousands of freshmen to design schools all over the world each school year; yet it is one that isn’t backed by any known empirical or scientific deductions, except for a heap of rhetoric and misplaced analogies. The import of this is that this set of young designers will spend the rest of their design careers trying to figure out how to apply this law in actual design practice, struggling to sieve through all the rhetoric and analogies that had been heaped upon them, in order to make sense of it.</p><p>If, today, we were to literally translate this law, it would simply mean that designers are been asked to worry less about form and focus squarely on function, since form is expected to naturally follow whatever function it is assigned. This dictum seeks to emphasize the supremacy of function and the near-in­consequentiality of form in the design process. This, by every standard, is no mean fallacy, for the proponents of this dictum have failed to realise that in contemporary architecture and design form is, by itself, a function. This is because it is the very first point of visual engagement between the consumer and a product; hence, every piece of design, with its form rather than its function, first aims to trigger a desired emotional feedback from its users. Forms respond to emotional needs; the ones upon which design consumers are most likely to base their decisions, such as whether to buy a product or not. The building or product’s overall suitability will first be judged by its general form, even before the consumer has had the chance of making use of it or physically experiencing it. It is, therefore, very important to note that emotional needs are equally as pressing as corporal needs, and experience shows that the lines between the two sometimes become so blurred that you can barely tell one from the other. Therefore, the continued insistence that form is secondary to function is a denial of reality and a negation of what we truly practise. The pretension that an object’s form is usually decided long after its function has been apportioned is a severe canard, and the premise that function must be consid­ered before form is a denial of reality. For how can form follow that which does not yet exist? Function can only exist within a form, because function on its own cannot exist in a vacuum: it needs space (form) to exist in. Even if a function were to take place in an open space, the activities therein would still have to be restricted within certain perimeters, because these activities cannot occupy space infinitely, since infinite space will never be available at any given time. It is, therefore, this ‘restricted space’ that becomes the form that houses the function. But if we are so enamoured with the rhythmic alliteration of ‘form follows function’ as coined for us by these theorists, and are determined not to let go of it, maybe a more plausible phrase would have been ‘function follows form’; at least that is a lot more reflective of the realities on the ground today (even though I still think we are better off altogether without any of these platitudes).</p><p>It is evident, therefore, that the context in which Sullivan made his famous dictum is not consistent with the realities on the ground, and if in actual design practice we seldom observe this rule, why then do we keep trumpeting this over-used cliché with such an unquestioning reverence? Ironically, in actual practice, this is the first rule that gets discarded in contemporary design; today, it has almost become commonplace for designers to infer that the morphology of the buildings or products they designed were inspired by everyday objects like, say, a boat’s sails (Burj Al Arab, Dubai); a human eye (L’Hemisfèric, Valencia); Ethiopian oval drums (proposed Ethiopian Parliament building, Addis Ababa); crazed pottery (Bird Nest stadium, Beijing); African calabash (Soccer City, Johannesburg); speech balloons (Comic and Animation Museum, Hangzhou); or whatever other object catches the fancy of its designers or the project owners. And true to form, these buildings no doubt always turn out looking like the forms that are said to have inspired them, yet they are able to perform the same functions that are expected of their con­temporaries that were designed and built with ‘conventional’ forms. Therefore, if form truly followed function then all bank buildings would look alike, all hotel buildings would be identical and all schools would look like schools – whatever they look like. We should at least be able to stand across the street and judge a building by its form, confidently saying, “Hey! That’s a bank,” or “That’s a school,” since all buildings’ forms are naturally expected to conform to their functions. Curiously, no one has ever asked what a bank, hotel, school or any other building should look like. Even if we got an answer, who is most qualified in this case to decide what form is best or most appro­priate for any given function or set of functions?</p><p>The fact is, as much as most designers do not openly admit it, in actual practice the designer will typically come up with an already preconceived morphological output or a signature form that he seeks to make functional, irrespective of the building or object’s intended function. The exception to this is the religious building where he is, to some extent, compelled to include certain insignias and geometries as part of his design, and even this has a very limited influence on the final morphological output of his design. It is to these predetermined forms that he consequently assigns functions, or a set of functions. And this approach hardly poses problems to the functionality of the said product because, with good imagination, a good designer can always readapt almost any form to cater for a desired function or set of functions.</p><p>The visible reality today is that design has crossed into the realm where form is the single biggest consideration for choosing a piece of design. This is because we have attained a position where functionality isn’t even an issue, because through our techno­logical advancement over the years, we have so well perfected the mechanics of functionality that it is possible to deploy those mechanics into making just about any and every form function­al. That is why today if a designer decides to build a contraption that looks and feels like a car but does not have a functional car engine, he cannot yet call it a car until it functions like one. This is so because the mechanics of functionality in every product must first be roundly established before we can ascribe any appellations to it; therefore this contraption must at least meet the minimum functional requirements of a car to be called one. Interestingly, the car’s form, as with that of most objects, is gradually becoming less and less predictable, to the extent where one day it will become difficult to say exactly what a car should look like. The difference in the form between yesterday’s cars and what we have today goes a long way in demonstrating the flexibility of form. Images of most of the futuristic concept cars gracing the prime displays at auto shows today are clear in­dications of the form tomorrow’s cars will take.</p><p>Even as designers, we encounter scenarios on a daily basis in the course of our work that roundly contradict Sullivan’s dictum; in fact, there are no shortages of instances to quote as I believe almost every designer has a personal experience he can relate to. About three years ago, I received an unusual project brief from a client who asked that I design an oval office for him, within his new office block. Of course, his current office – a rec­tangular one – worked just fine; he has, in fact, been carrying out his day-to-day business from there without any qualms for several years. He was on the verge of building a bigger office block, which his architect had already designed, and just before the final construction documents were prepared he asked that I reworked the floor plans to create an oval office for him, in place of the rectangular office that had been designed for him by his architect. For him, it was no longer about the function­ality of his space; he probably already concluded that, with my expertise, I would possess enough dexterity to ensure that his space functioned efficiently, irrespective of the form it took. Rather, he was simply interested in its overall form: an oval office, which was more or less an expression of his innate feeling of power, one that probably reflected his new status of power or authority, the type associated with its more famous opposite number on sixteen hundred Pennsylvania Avenue. Literally, he wanted to think, or work, outside the box. Whatever his aspi­rations were, they were at least very legitimate ones and, as his designer, it was my lot to create for him an oval office, ensuring that it didn’t function less effectively than his old ‘box’ office. Under these circumstances, if we were to go by Sullivan’s dictum of form following function, how would the functions of an oval office have differed from that of the traditional ‘box’ office? Can we then deny that the new form of my client’s oval office on its own is serving a very valid function?</p><p>It is becoming increasingly evident on a daily basis that today’s design briefs are now written in the language of philosophy rather than in verbal specifics, and it is these philosophies that sometimes determine the form most buildings and products take. Today, the geometry of contemporary buildings takes the form of those philosophies, with a client telling his designer what his vision for his brand or space is, and it being the ultimate task of the designer to transmute that vision into bricks and mortar. His design has to become a part of his client’s identity and must project a pre-agreed image of his client. Therefore, despite contemporary designers abandoning traditional design ornaments, they are employing a new style of ornamentation that is vested in a design’s overall form than in any of its other features. Hence, it wouldn’t be out of place to conclude that these forms have, in their own right become the new ornaments. Even in circumstances where it costs a lot more to realise most of these complex building forms, property owners around the world are still increasingly craving them, shelling out tens and hundreds of millions of dollars without any qualms to achieve their desired form. The aesthetics of these buildings essentially lie in their curvaceous, tessellated, tapered or even undulating forms. Yet, there are die-hard modernists out there who will argue that aesthetics are but a trivial detail, but they can’t say why design consumers around the world are going to great lengths and trouble to patronise architects and designers who can create dramatic forms from their project briefs irrespective how much it costs to build.</p><p>Resources are becoming scarcer, and as the scramble for them is getting fiercer, our daily living is becoming more complex. Hence, it is the ingenuity of designers that the world solely relies on in order to readapt desired functions to any given space (form). Today, no designed form is confined to a definite and specific fate of functionality during its lifetime; its function changes as other variables change. Before now, industrial designers created objects in certain streamlined forms that ensured they were able to perform their functions appropriately; but today’s designers have found other ways of ensuring that even if the current space is altered these functions could still be performed in alternate forms, which is why it is now common to see buildings or other products change their function twice or more in their lifetime. Adaptive reuse has therefore become an indispensable field of design and contemporary designers are daily demonstrating that almost any form could be rede­signed to perform just about any function. Several case studies exist that demonstrate how form could be determined independently of function, we simply need to look around us to see them.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Every spring and fall, new design students take up their seats in design faculties around the world. Sadly, one of the very first dictums they will pick up in design school will be ‘form follows function’. Awed by the alliterative spell cast by these words, they will hold on to them tightly, without giving them a second thought, until they leave design school, only to realise that this dictum has no place in actual practice. This is no mean disser­vice both to the designers-in-training and all those in-practice who might be too cowed to rise above the grip of precedence or pedagogic tenets to ever question the status quo.</p><p>This treatise, therefore, is an appropriate opportunity to beseech design mentors and educators to re-evaluate every dictum on its merit and refrain from making laws out of them on account of precedence, because precedence on its own rarely confers legit­imacy. Every postulation must at least be made to undergo the natural process of empirical and scientific testing before it is passed off as a universal truth. Our educators must be prepared to raise a new corps of designers who should be encouraged to question age-long traditions that are not in tandem with immediate realities. For the designer’s greatest asset isn’t his drawing skill but his imagination. With that he could achieve anything, including creating any function out of any form. The designer must first and foremost be a good thinker; one who can rigorously turn over every problem in his mind, objectively weighing up every scenario to arrive at a befitting conclusion (solution).</p><p>I would like to conclude this discourse with a quote from Walter Gropius, from his May 1937 interview with Architectural Records, shortly after his appointment as professor of architec­ture at Harvard, which was also published in the March 1957 issue of Architectural Record:</p><p><em>I want a young architect to be able to find his way in whatever circumstances; I want him independently to create true, genuine forms out of the technical, economic and social conditions in which he finds himself instead of imposing a learned formula onto surroundings which may call for an entirely different solution. It is not so much a readymade dogma that I want to teach, but an attitude towards the problems of our generation which is unbiased, original and elastic. It would be an absolute horror for me if my appointment would result in the multiplication of a fixed idea of ‘Gropius architecture.’ What I do want is to make young people realize how inexhaustible the means of creation are if they make use of the innumerable modern products of our age, and to encourage these young people in finding their own solutions.” </em>(Gropius, 1937)</p><p>Written by</p><p>Mathias Agbo Jr</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e19cb081432" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Much Havoc Have Computers Wreaked on Architecture?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/how-much-havoc-have-computers-wreaked-on-architecture-a89c1d7980d5?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a89c1d7980d5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cad]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Feb 2017 08:59:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-11T09:09:59.222Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jJVNLZKglbmSWh8Z0c5QMg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Photo Credit:http://paper4pc.com</em></p><p>Today, the design turf is changing, or to put it better, has changed. Computer screens are the new workspaces for creative design and have become the contemporary designer’s insepa­rable companion, thereby taking the place of T-squares, set squares and drafting tables. This transformation has been so fast and swift that no one could ever have correctly predicted things as they are today. CAD now offers a wide range of platforms for designers, architects, engineers and other construction professionals to converge and collaborate on multiple fronts. These programs now offer multiple interfaces with diverse outputs, varying from two-dimensional schematic drawings to three-dimensional graphics. The outputs of these programs have also further evolved from mere ‘dumb’ graphics to intelligent and malleable graphics. The advancement in CAD technology has also made it possible for designers to go far beyond creating virtual 3D graphics, to actual 3D printing and rapid prototyp­ing, where pre-designed, virtual 3D models are converted into printing paths, using several coats of bonded plaster to rapidly generate solid, accurately sculpted physical prototypes, formed precisely according to the designer’s intent.</p><p>Unfortunately, in spite of all these innovations and the rapid evolution of CAD, the criticism of its widespread deployment as a design tool has never been louder than it is today. Currently, a semblance of a generational debate has ensued over the propriety of CAD as a creative design tool. Whereas a genera­tion of architects insists on hanging on to the age of drawing pens, tracing paper and drafting tables – or, as they often put it, to ‘preserve our architectural heritage and respect for tradition’ – the other generation has wholly embraced the spirit of the times and the technologies that it brings with it. Consequently, the former group has, at every conceivable opportunity, invariably spoken up against the widespread use of CAD, and ultimately blames it for every ‘disagreeable’ piece of design in sight. The din is getting louder by the day and the credibility of the designs emerging through this media has been routinely questioned and even subjected to outright ridicule. At the end of the day, the verdict in this court is that architects and designers are becoming less creative because of the influence of CAD in the design process. And it is because of the fear of these critics of CAD that contemporary designers, even in spite of their pervasive use of CAD technologies, are still quite wary of giving any form of credit to how much CAD has changed the way they work; they fear that admitting this will spell an indict­ment on their creative competence.</p><p>Over the past couple of years, I have stumbled across a handful of criticisms of the use of CAD as a design tool, but none, in my opinion, have so coherently expressed this position than that of Israeli architect and town planner Gerard Heumann. Heumann, in his essay titled “The Havoc That Computer Aided Design Has Wreaked on Architecture” which was published in the Israeli newspaper Haaertz on June 22, 2012, blamed CAD squarely for the decline in creativity amongst architects, which, as he put it, has, “severed the age-long and miraculous connec­tion between the mind and the hand”. Amongst other things, he blamed CAD for reducing an illustrious process to a factory-like operation, with designers duplicating and speedily running designs through the mill at the click of a mouse button. The bones of his treatise can be summarised in his closing remarks, where he says:</p><p>There is growing evidence that the CAD tool is, in many respects, incompatible with meaningful creative activity, leading designers either to overreach their goals or to be restricted to what the tool is capable of.” (Heumann, 2012)</p><p>The quality of Heumann’s writing is impressive and it is probably the most articulate and coherent CAD critique that I have ever read. Regrettably, like almost every other criticism of CAD, Heumann’s treatise trades more in sentiments and stereotyping rather than verity. The essay, as with those of every other CAD critic, fails to firmly state what the ground rules should be for the engagement of computers in creative design. The terse caveat ‘Computers are great tools but should be used carefully’ which traditionally appears at the foot of every CAD critic’s tirade cannot suffice in any way; we must at least be told in clear terms what CAD should and should not be used for. There should at least be an established line beyond which architects and designers should not go, or else they will probably never know when they cross it and, as such, will carry on ad infinitum with the status quo. The tragic irony of all this is that most CAD critics have obviously never touched it, and neither have they at any moment taken the time to understand its workings; they have simply stayed away from it and drawn their own conclusions based on their prejudices and on the work of a few architects and designers.</p><p>The argument that computers numb critical thinking is very subjective and in reality implausible, because the designer’s creativity is neither in his drawing pens and pencils nor in his computer mouse; rather, it is an innate, distinctive attribute, tucked far within the recesses of his consciousness, and is only an additive in an already initiated design process, of which the final design is its output. The reality is that there are as many bad designs that have been hatched today with pencils as there are with computers. In fact, bad designs have long-preceded CAD; whatever we do, wherever we turn, there will always be one piece of bad design or another staring down at us. Therefore, it is a very misleading notion for one media to be identified as the sole purveyor of bad design. Rather than make blanket assertions like this, each piece of design should be singled out, examined and judged purely on its own merits. As with every human endeavour, there are very few in-betweens; they will always be two extremes, irrespective of the media involved, so each design must be engaged on its own merit, because no one media has the monopoly on bad designs. In fact, bad architecture is as old as architecture itself. So, to ascribe to CAD the title of purveyor of bad design is an assertion made in very bad taste. Besides, the term ‘bad design’ is even becoming too subjective these days. Furthermore, if today we were to open an inquisition into what constituted bad design, very few pieces of architecture designed by some of our famed masters would still be standing by the end of the day.</p><p>The insistence by most CAD critics that the widespread use of CAD at design school is responsible for the dwindling level of creativity amongst today’s designers and architects is quite mis­leading; if an architecture or design programme isn’t teaching its students how to draw then the gripe should be with the curriculum not with CAD. Even with that, it is still quite difficult to explicitly associate creativity with either hand drawings or CAD. Rather, experience has shown that the absence of CAD on the design school curriculum has the opposite effect. For instance, in Africa and most of the third world today, very few students ever get to use CAD programs before the completion of their undergraduate studies in architecture. They typically draw by hand throughout the duration of their undergraduate programme and take few CAD lessons, which are mostly taught on the blackboard or with close to a hundred students crowded around the instructor’s computer. Their first real experience with CAD comes only after they graduate from design school and can afford to buy all the relevant software and hardware and also pay for private CAD lessons. But in spite of their long-standing dependence on the traditional drawing medium, we are still yet to see any unusually creative piece of design or architecture from this group of designers, besides the various shades of the wheel that are still being reinvented there on a daily basis. Unlike their peers in the developed world, upon graduation they have the disadvantage of having to relearn and readapt their creative skill-set to the acceptable industry standard, which indisput­ably is CAD. This group of designers have stuck exclusively to their pencils, drawing pens and tracing paper not by choice, or the need or obligation to preserve and honour a sacred tradition of drudgery like some of our CAD critics, or even to maintain “the invaluable sense of intimacy between the architect and his work”, like Heumann suggested, but rather because they are bound by necessity and the absence of the desirable.</p><p>In spite of what the CAD critics want us to believe, experience has shown that the traditional drawing methods are more likely to throw up bad designs than CAD, because they are one-tracked. Imagine that, as an architecture student, you have been working for over a week on a project for your design studio class, which in two days you should hand in, and you suddenly discover, on the penultimate night before your submission, that you have made a significant error in your work. Correcting it will mean going back to edit over fifteen different sheets of drawings that you have already inked. Your natural instinct will not be to start all over again, but rather to ignore the error and pray that it is not noticed by your supervisors or jurors. This, without doubt, is the path that almost every student in such a situation would naturally take; otherwise he won’t meet his submission deadline. Regrettably, this has become the fate of most students in the third world; for them, creativity ends the moment they conclude their brainstorming and initial drafts. And to them each school project simply becomes a task to be completed rather than a process of developing and fine-tuning an idea. For this type of student, the moment they place their tracing paper over their pencil sketches and start inking with their drawing pens, they are ultimately condemned to their fate; there is nothing more that can be changed and they will have to stick resolutely with those pencil drafts until the end, or else they will inevitably miss the submission deadline.</p><p>But, for their contemporaries working with CAD, the situation is different. They are granted the leverage to con­tinually fine-tune their designs until the very last hours before submission, thereby giving them ample time to better understand their designs, and hence correct mistakes if there are any. The CAD platform ensures that they can do that without the back-breaking grind of having to place tracing paper over, say, fifteen sheets of drawings to correct and re-draw each one of them. This is a very priceless creative asset, because as a designer you sometimes start out with an initial design idea and end up with a final design that is only one-fifth of your initial concept, all depending on the direction your creativity leads you in and also on what the prevailing exigencies might dictate. Therefore, it is becoming increasingly evident that what most of these CAD critics see as creative work is actually a number of common, repetitive tasks that in the end amount to nothing but plain drudgery.</p><p>CAD critics also often accuse all designers working with CAD of hastily hopping on to their computers to design, without first brainstorming or properly developing their initial ideas and drafts on paper, thereby inferring that all CAD using designers do not so much as produce any initial pencil sketches during the brainstorming stage of the creative process. This is not only misleading, but is, indeed, slanderous on the part of all those who make these allusions, because this is rarely possible: real­istically, it takes uncommon creativity to commence a design from scratch on a CAD platform without a single pencil sketch or draft, and it would probably take an unusual level of crea­tivity and the utmost mental discipline to achieve this. As with most credible design schools today, pencil sketches are still a prerequisite for the critique of a student’s initial idea and design concepts. Therefore, if there are designers out there who initiate and complete their designs on CAD platforms, they are the exception rather the rule.</p><p>And even the assertion that CAD gives the architect a very limited feel for his designs is evidently untrue. Contrary to what these critics say, it is the pencil sketch that is difficult to feel, for it is as physically flat as the paper on which it is drawn. Besides, no one ever carves a piece of sculpture on drawing paper; they are carved so that they are solid and can be felt in three dimensions. In the same vein, 3D design, just like a sculpture, brings out the designer’s intent in a solid form and allows him to see, feel and even test his creation virtually, before its actual realisation.</p><p>In his essay, Heumann also alleged that the ease of duplication in CAD is encouraging architects to create homogenous and repetitive building designs rather than initiate original designs for each project. I have no doubt that I will be speaking for all the proponents and antagonists of CAD alike when I say it is dishonest for any designer to short-change his clients by repeating a single design over and over again (unless of course the client has specifically requested the same design). This type of behaviour says more about the integrity of said designer than it does about CAD as a design tool, and it is the responsibility of the paying client, in this case, to demand his money’s worth if dissatisfied. The fact that CAD makes it easy to duplicate a drawing at the click of a mouse button isn’t a valid reason for blaming CAD for the mass duplication of designs by some architects, or else we might as well blame the Ferrari for all of its drivers’ speeding tickets. It can also be argued that this type of designer did not suddenly emerge because of CAD; rather, they have always been there and, with or without CAD, they will still find a way to exploit other drawing mediums to mass-produce their work. That said, it is also important to state that there are clients who specifically commission specific architects and designers because of their signature forms, and expect them to bring the same to their own project; therefore, it would be unfair to blame CAD or even the designers in circumstances like these.</p><p>Heumann also faulted what he called the computer’s “over precise results” which he said are both “misleading and inap­propriate”. Ironically, it is the above statement that is rather misleading, for architectural drawings are neither paintings nor fancy art illustrations, hence they must at least conform to and respect standard measurements in the context in which they will be used. Unlike artwork, they are created for neither enter­tainment nor pleasure, but as blueprints for the construction or manufacture of a product. So if a blueprint isn’t precise then the final product will be imprecise. Therefore architecture, just like product design, is a more precise science than it is a fancy art; hence there is no doubt that precision must remain one of its non-negotiable attributes.</p><p>CAD has also made it possible for rapid prototyping and 3D printing to be used as a creative tool. As 3D printing technology is gradually being domesticated across design studios and print shops around the world, designers are gradually abandoning the traditional way of making scaled-down physical models in favour of embracing the new, faster technique of rapid prototyp­ing. As a direct consequence of this technology, rapid manufac­turing could soon become a possibility in the coming years, and when this technology is properly perfected there is no doubt that it will become a potent alternative way of easily getting things made. It will reduce the time lag needed to fix a faulty machine part: the needed parts or components of a machine or product can be easily designed, fabricated and installed in the shortest possible time. For this type of operation, it is important that every component is very precise, and this would never have been possible if not for the very precise output that CAD generates. All of these advancements in CAD technology have made it possible for contemporary architects and designers to achieve what their predecessors only dreamt of: every conceivable form, geometry and scale is today easily realisable, because CAD platforms have made it possible for these supposedly complex geometries to be defragmented into manageable bits for ease of fabrication or construction.</p><p>Another very important reason why architects have no choice but to embrace CAD is that the days of the architect as the master builder are long gone; the reality is that the complex­ity of today’s building regulations have ensured that he no longer has the absolute say in the design process. Architects and designers now have to negotiate a maze of building codes and zoning laws and answer to a battery of regulators in order to get their building plans approved. This is a very tedious and painstaking process and it is daily becoming more difficult for architects to run one-man shows. For his work to be acceptable, he must make allowances for inputs from a medley of other professionals, including mechanical, electrical, acoustic, and hydraulic engineers and a long list of other allied professionals. The more complex the design, the longer the list gets. Hence, it is the aggregate of these inputs that culminates in the archi­tect’s final design. For the architects, engineers and all those involved in this process CAD has become the standard language of engagement and conversation in the architecture, engineer­ing and construction (AEC) industry, and the architect’s final design is expected to make allowances for all the inputs of these professionals. Architects can either choose to embrace CAD or be left behind altogether. Whether they choose to be part of it or not, the world will still find a way to move on. In this age and time, no one is indispensable. Hence the architect, as a matter of necessity, has no choice but to embrace CAD wholly, or else his relevance in this process will further diminish and he could one day be entirely left out of the process all together; we have seen worse things happen.</p><p>While brainstorming for this essay, I came across excerpts from the book Co-Designers; Cultures of Computer Simulation in Architecture, written by Dr Yanni Alexander Loukissas, who is a principal researcher at Harvard University’s metaLAB, Berkman Center for Internet and Society. The book chronicles the history of computer simulation and also deals extensively with the overall application of computer simulations in design. Based on the strength of his work, I queried him on what he thought the role of CAD should be in architecture and design. I also asked his position on the prevailing criticisms of the use of CAD in contemporary architecture and design, and whether he agreed that computers were in any way short-circuiting the creative process. I had wanted a direct response from him, but he told me I could find answers to my questions in his afore­mentioned book, specifically in chapter three, ‘Special Men and Universal Machines’. True to his words, I found his opinion on the issue there. Chapter three of the book commences with the description of a new relationship that has been negotiated between designers and CAD simulation. Loukissas compares the architect–computer relationship to that of a master– apprentice relationship. This, for me, is the most fitting descrip­tion of the type of relationship that currently exists between the architect and his computer. He amply illustrates this with a story about Paul Morris, the principal at Morris Associates, and his apprentice, Drew Thorndike, which goes thus:</p><p>Morris still relies on pencils to develop new ideas. However, within his office, computer modelling is replacing many of the traditional tasks of pencils such as drafting and rendering. Although Morris rarely touches the machine, it transformed his inter-personal practice as well. He often works on a concept phase of designs with an apprentice who helps him model a range of design ideas.”</p><p>According to Loukissas, Drew Thorndike was the one charged with the onerous task of modelling Morris’s designs on the computer, since Morris had neither the knowledge nor the experience to work on them himself. Hence, whenever Thorndike sat behind his computer, Morris stood behind him, giving him instructions about what he wanted to be done.</p><p>Now it is not unusual to hear Morris say to Thorndike, ‘let’s go look at your computer’. The concept and sketches are still drawn by Morris but as the project progresses, he and Thorndike work together at the computer. Thorndike operates the computer while Morris gives him guidance. From the first interaction on the Project, a pattern emerges. Morris makes a sketch and Thorndike translates the sketch into a geometric model on a computer. Morris always asks Thorndike to print out the computer images he generated. Then Morris and Thorndike will sit together with a roll of tracing paper as Morris draws revisions over Thorndike’s prints. As the project progresses, Morris stops request­ing prints and begins to look directly at the images on the computer...” (Loukissas, 2012)</p><p>By looking directly at the computer, Morris was able to request changes to Thorndike’s design. He could, by now, make out the graphics on the computer and request changes as they progressed. The moral of Loukissas’s story is that the appren­tice is only a medium through which the designer realises his vision, hence the apprentice will never be able to take credit for any creative output that emerges from a process like this, save for the drudgery, of course. As can be seen from this analogy, the role of the computer is only to capture and interpret the intentions of the designer, and the designer, for his part, must also accurately convey his intentions to the computer in order for him to achieve the desired final output. So, just like the computer, Morris’s apprentice Drew couldn’t change on his own any of the directives given to him by the designer Morris. That would be seen as misinterpreting the designer’s intentions, and it wouldn’t have taken long for Morris to realise that his intentions had been misrepresented and Drew would have been reprimanded appropriately.</p><p>The above scenario with Morris is, indeed, very evocative of the kind of relationship that existed between celebrated Bauhaus modernist architect Walter Gropius and his collaborators. Walter Gropius, even by his own admission, couldn’t draw well. Hence, as an architecture student, he hired other people to do all his drawing homework for him, and when he did set up his own design practice after completing his apprenticeship at Peter Behrens’ studio, he still relied heavily on the collaborators he hired to draw out his ideas on paper. He simply instructed them on what to do, just like Morris did with his apprentice, Thorndike. This was the creative pattern that endured throughout the duration of his very eventful career. There is no doubt that if CAD were popular in Gropius’s days, it could very well have been Gropius seated behind his own Drew Thorndike, instructing him on what to draw. So, in the same way that Gropius relied on others to capture and interpret his inten­tions, today’s designers rely on CAD to capture and realise their intentions. This, in my opinion, is a very healthy relationship and has almost nothing to do with the creativity or otherwise of the architect; if we were to go on the arguments of critics then we might as well dispossess Walter Gropius of all the acclaim his works have garnered over the years, because his hands did not physically draw out his designs on paper. But then we must also ask, are the hands more consequential creative assets than the head? If today, for instance, we discovered creative deficiencies or shortcomings in Walter Gropius’s designs, is it rational to blame them on his apprentices (collaborators) or on Gropius himself? Why, then, should we today blame a defenceless computer for an architect’s creative shortcomings?</p><p>From the above analogies it is apparent that the arguments against the use of CAD in design and architecture are far more emotional than they are logical. Those arguing against the use of CAD, unlike Morris, have probably not taken the time to truly understand how these platforms work. Most of them sound as if there are complete architectural blueprints lodged somewhere within the recesses of laptops and desktops, waiting for designers to extract and append their signatures to them.</p><p>Sentiments aside, it is quite difficult to sincerely understand how the presence of CAD in the design process invalidates the creativity of the architect or designer. Contrary to the belief amongst the CAD critics, rather than demystify the architect, CAD has made him invincible and near-infallible; it has, indeed, provided him with the oppor­tunity to see and experience his designs in three dimensions and possibly correct any anomaly that could have arisen long before the actual building project commences, thereby elimi­nating costly errors and the resultant waste. This is, indeed, the golden age for architecture and design; the designer has, today, conquered every known form and built on even the most treacherous of conditions and topographies, because computer simulations have made it possible for his designs to be taken through a battery of simulated tests, ranging from earthquakes and acoustics, to aerodynamics and photo simulations, similar to what the buildings could experience in real life. Consequently, it is important to note that computers and CAD platforms should never be seen as having usurped the creative role of the designer; rather, CAD should be viewed as the designer’s indispensable ally in the creative process, and no matter how intuitive CAD becomes in future, the designer rather than his work tools should be held squarely responsible for any failings in his work.</p><p>Written by</p><p>Mathias Agbo Jr</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a89c1d7980d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Good Design, Bad Design; Who Decides?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mathiasagbojr/good-design-bad-design-who-decides-ccde601d107b?source=rss-c17262c9b508------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccde601d107b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mathias Agbo Jr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Dec 2015 05:17:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-03T07:56:41.174Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*tcZAo_yOZzFh7ryZc93dTg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Foster and Partners’ Gherkin — Photo Credit: <a href="http://www.housetohome.co.uk/">www.housetohome.co.uk</a></figcaption></figure><p>George Nelson, in his essay “Good Design: What Is It for?” defined good design as“…neither a book of etiquette nor a social register. Good design, like good painting, cooking, architecture, or whatever you like, is a manifestation of the capacity of the human spirit to transcend its limitations…it is a statement not a gadget.” (Nelson, 1957)</p><p>Nelson’s essay was, indeed, a direct reaction to the 1950s ‘good design’ exhibitions that were organised for the Merchandise Mart in Chicago by New York’s Museum of Modern Art. The exhibitions, which were held twice annually, were the brainchild of Edgar Kaufmann Jr, the director of industrial design at MOMA. They showcased home furnishings designed by a coterie of designers, amongst whom were notable names like Charles and Ray Eames, Le Corbusier, Harry Bertoia, Arne Jacobsen and even George Nelson; all were handpicked by Kaufmann and his associates. At these exhibitions, the selected home furnishings (considered to be good design by the jurors’ standards) were collected and exhibited by Kaufmann. Nelson and other critics of Kaufmann’s ‘good design’ exhibitions thought the concept of good design went beyond merely putting together a set of items from a handful of privileged designers and labelling them as such, but Kaufmann simply defined it thus: “Good design in any period is simply: the best its designers produce.” (Kaufmann, 1950)</p><p>Realistically, neither Kaufmann’s simplistic characterisation of good design nor Nelson’s carefully crafted rejoinder can ever suffice, because it will be difficult for anyone today to glean from them, or any other definition for that matter, a practical criteria by which to judge every piece of design and say if it is good or not. This is because these characterisations are mostly ambiguous, restrictive or simply prejudiced. Hence it would be impossible to immediately tell a good piece of design by simply measuring it against any of these criteria. The good design debate is one that has been around for quite a while, and it is, indeed, a subject matter that everyone lays claim to an opinion on, either as consumers and observers of design or simply as self-appointed design critics. This subject has always been a point of discord between the groups that define and divide our society, such as modernists versus post-modernists, rich versus poor, conservatives versus liberals, baby boomers versus Generation X, designers versus columnists, and architects versus engineers, and all the other lines along which our society is delimitated, with each group laying claim to a superior understanding of what they believe is good design.</p><p>I still remember vividly how this debate played out in my days at design school. We were each encouraged to create and keep a journal called the Good Design, Bad Design Journal. We were to enter into the journal every design product we came across during the school year. Under each entry, we were expected to state if we considered a particular product to be a good or a bad design. After we had done this we occasionally had general critique sessions in class, and during these sessions we examined each entry together. We took on a wide range of designs, from handmade Italian luxury designer products to eerie, hastily assembled contraptions shipped in from back-alley factories in the Far East. They all fell under our hammers and we made mincemeat of their designers, as we revelled in our new-found roles as design critics. Today, as a practising designer, I now look back with a sense of déjà vu and a bit of remorse about what we did back then. My guilt stems not entirely out of the total misplacement of our critiques — some of those designs actually had it coming — but rather it is born out of the sudden realisation that my work, and that of every other designer, is vulnerable to sometimes groundless criticism; criticism that would often be largely based on mere visual perception, rather than actual user experience. Very few of us in those critique sessions at that time ever used or actually experienced firsthand any of the products we criticised; and, indeed, we had no idea of the backstories behind these designs. We knew neither what the project briefs were nor why the products turned out the way they did; we just vilified their designers anyway. Expectedly, even at our amateur critique sessions, there was almost never a consensus about the status of any given piece of design, because what was called a bad design in one journal often ended up being entered as a good design in another. And what was hailed as good design on Monday could end up being called bad design on Friday; such was the fickle nature of these critiques. This is the fate of every piece of design today: just like the critique journals we kept at design school, in the court of public opinion every piece of design is simply tagged as either good or bad depending on the critic’s personal disposition towards that particular piece of design or its designer; these dispositions are often fuelled by nothing more than individual perceptions and prejudices.</p><p>Just as Edgar Kaufmann did with the ‘good design’ exhibitions, there still exist sub-groups of our society who, on their own, will seasonally congregate to present awards to selected designers who have been chosen amongst their peers as winners of this or that award. These awards are made based on the judges’ own preset criteria, but even amongst this group it is still sometimes difficult to arrive at a unilateral consensus; the winning entries are usually decided upon based on the design with the highest number of votes amongst the judges. Even as these groups are daily awarding medals for what they label as good design, a sizeable section of society, armed with their own contrary opinions, are coming down hard on those choices in the opposite direction.</p><p>In May 2004, Swiss Re opened its new headquarters building at 30 St. Mary Axe, a one-hundred-and-eighty-metre high skyscraper in the city of London which was nicknamed the ‘Gherkin’ because of its striking resemblance to the fruit of the same name. The building, designed by Foster and Partners, won the Stirling Prize from the Royal Institute of British Architects in 2004, as well as other acclaim. It has become one of the most recognisable landmarks and tourist attractions in the city of London, almost as renowned as Big Ben. But in spite of all the acclaim the building has garnered, there is still a good number of people who think the Gherkin deserves no more than the <em>Building Design Magazine’s </em>Carbuncle Cup, which is given annually to the ugliest building in the United Kingdom.</p><p>In his July 22, 2006 article in the <em>Washington Post</em>, “A Thrill to View, or an Eyesore on the London Skyline?”, Roger K Lewis, an American architect and professor at the University of Maryland, took an outright swipe at the building; he was of the opinion that the Gherkin failed the urban design, contextual relations, architectural scale, and aesthetic expression tests. And he there-fore concluded that, “This systematically designed but highly idiosyncratic building is unlikely to serve as a template for future high-rise office buildings, whether in London or elsewhere” (Lewis, 2006).</p><p>In the course of writing this treatise, I randomly sent out queries to a few of my friends, acquaintances and a handful of strangers. I asked them what, in their opinion, should be termed good design; the responses I got were very varied. I received one from an architect cousin of mine who simply said, “You will know a good design when you see it.” And I thought hard about it and couldn’t help agreeing with her. Yes, you will just know when you see a piece of good design; in fact, you will feel it because, based your pre-existing prejudices, your mind has long decided what should be considered as good design and that anything outside that sphere isn’t. That is why a piece of architecture that has received very significant laurels from one of the most credible design entities in the world could be subjected to this depth of criticism by such an influential section of society. One would have thought that if a body as illustrious as the RIBA awards a medal to the Gherkin, the rest of us mere mortals would simply fall in line behind them and cheer. Therefore, it is possible that the criticism of the Gherkin could be based on the prejudice held by those who are more at home with a city of neat rows of brick-and-stone Tudor or Georgian architecture than with towering, gleaming edifices of glass and steel. Therefore, this group of people could probably never bring themselves to accept any other architectural style, not even on its own merit. The scenario above typifies the fate of every piece of design today: a design could be showered with many accolades and garlands on one side of town, yet it could still be labelled a bad piece of design on the other.</p><p>After carefully observing the contrasting trail of euphoria and aloofness that greets every new piece of design, I am of the view that the above scenario aptly demonstrates the heterogeneity of our design tastes and preferences. Hence, I have come to realise how complex it has become, in a society like ours, to perform a task as supposedly clear-cut as telling a good design apart from a bad one. It has become almost impossible to objectively set aside sentiments, and all the baggage they bring with them, when judging a piece of design; this, of course, is barring the fact that every design, whether considered good or bad, must first and foremost meet the minimum standard of functionality.</p><p>In the face of these varying individual design preferences, will it be possible to ever arrive at a universal consensus on what to call good design? And even if we succeeded in arriving at such a consensus, wouldn’t that be enthroning a tyranny of taste, no different to the socialist propaganda that asked us to ‘trim our hair in accordance with the socialist lifestyle’? And that tyranny, without a doubt, would eliminate one of the most basic prerequisites for a free world.</p><p>This brings us to the resulting spin-off question: whose preserve is it to decide which designs are good? Is it the preserve of self- or peer-appointed design connoisseurs to point us in the direction of good design, or is it the prerogative of the larger society which observes these designs every day? Where does all this leave the client who in the first place initiated the design and pays for it with his hard-earned money? So, the question now is whether a good design is one that amply satisfies a client’s brief, or is it that which agrees with societal expectations? It would have been easy to say good design is that which satisfies both, but unfortunately there are times when the two will be irreconcilable, making it impossible to find a middle road between what the client wants and what society expects. When a client hires a designer, he expects certain services and he expects the designer to meet certain expectations of his. While honestly trying to meet his client’s expectations, the designer sometimes creates designs that go against the design preferences of a section of society. The design of the Gherkin must, no doubt, have made its owners happy and indeed satisfied them, but it also left a very sour taste in the mouth for a section of the society in which it was built. In this case should we then un-equivocally say society is the most qualified arbiter to decide if a design is good or bad? This is the dilemma of contemporary designers, because today’s consumer, in the quest for distinction and utopia, is tasking his creativity in unimaginable proportions and is taking it in unexampled directions. It is no longer laughable for a designer to receive design briefs from a client who wants his house to take the form of an airplane taking off with its nose pointed towards the sky. As much as the majority of us will never personally want to live in a house like that, we still cannot deny that it is an honest aspiration and a legitimate need. That is why I believe that it is not a coincidence that some of the most vilified contemporary designers around the world today still run the busiest design studios; they are probably busier than everyone else, running projects from Changsha to Rotterdam, commanding as much as eight-figure professional fees, creating what their clients will happily call good design, in spite of the hue and cry from a section of society. Hence it is important that we recognise that to some extent the decision about whether a design is good or bad is often an emotional one, and our free world has conferred on everyone, without exception, the freedom to decide what, in their opinion, is good design; this is decided by people’s own standards and shaped by their own experiences and, unfortunately, their own prejudices, for these are all inseparable as that is how we are all wired.</p><p>If your aim in reading this discourse is to fully grasp the meaning of good design, please accept my apologies as I have disappointed you; I did not set out to heap more rhetoric onto all that you already have to contend with in your quest for the characterisation of what good design is or isn’t. I am only writing in order to share the personal opinion I have formed about what I think it is, but if I must leave you with a clear-cut definition, I would say: good design is that which we find to be the most agreeable with our individual experiences, ideologies and professed faith. All of which, without question, were shaped over time by our personal experiences and our accepted doctrines, which in the long run firmly establish our prejudices. This, in my opinion, is the psychology behind how we come to label every piece of design as either good or bad; because our opinions are shaped entirely by the psychology of our individual perceptions, fueled by our prejudices. Can we ever rise above our prejudices to judge a design objectively? The answer is no, because these prejudices are part of who we are; they are the aggregate of our experiences, our beliefs and our sociocultural leanings. They are, in fact, the summations of what makes us <em>us</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccde601d107b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>