<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Matt Ryklin on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Matt Ryklin on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 01:18:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mattryklin/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections from the Archipelago]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin/reflections-from-the-archipelago-6ff25ce92530?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ff25ce92530</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genocide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matt Ryklin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Sep 2016 21:41:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-16T21:41:47.064Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a history fraught with tragedy, the darkness of the Soviets hangs as one of the heaviest. Alexandr Solzhenitsyn is less a hero than a madman, whose recounting of the Soviet Gulag system is the product of eloquent scribbles. Despite heavy citation, his work does not resemble an academic thesis, but is rather draped in anxiety, as if he were racing against the clock, his pen briskly attempting to record the mass of thought and memory from his head into permanence, afraid of nearby entities ready to erase him at any moment. And yet, this anxiety never led itself to brevity, instead encompassing a stubborn determination to realize every possible thought, opinion, and fact, never hesitant to break the scholastic in favor of waxing philosophical.</p><p>I cannot help but make the comparison to Elie Weisel’s <em>Night</em>, which also conveys the reality of a European tragedy. Both men transmit the horrors of their experience, and yet their methods are opposed. Where Eli Weisel brings the reader with him on his apocalyptic journey for a brief and intensely personal hundred pages, Solzhenitsyn writes like a thorough and frank obsessive, exercising his thoughts in well over 1000 pages, hovering somewhere between memoirist and journalist. But, the work is not just Solzhenitsyn’s own memoir. It is the memoir of the millions who suffered and perished with him. His liberal use of anecdotes paints a shocking picture that at first instinct feels surreal, but is quickly and constantly supported by punch after punch from Solzhenitsyn’s heavy fists. He wants to show the reader that this, too, is humanity.</p><p>He often expresses a maniacal shock and laughter at his reality. Perhaps what most separates the Soviets from the Nazis is the constant ridiculousness of their behavior and methods. Solzhenitsyn accounts a situation in which Stalin visited a factory, of course welcomed by an unmatched applause. The applause could not end, for who would be so brave as to be the first to stop clapping for the infallible and inimitable Stalin? It lasted for five minutes, six, seven, ten! Finally, after eleven minutes, the director of the factory ceased clapping. The director was later arrested. He was sentenced to ten years in prison. The interrogator told him to never be the first one to stop clapping, to which Solzhenitsyn remarks “and just what are we supposed to do? How are we supposed to stop?” This is the impossible Soviet reality, a far cry from the ruthless Nazis, who could rationalize their actions and made no qualms about their intentions, simply executing their work efficiently and without excuse.</p><p>The Soviet reality borders on hilarious in the same way as some Adult Swim shows. Does the scene I just described not sound like a caricatured satire that would be at home in a dark comedy? But, we remember the victims of the farce were very real, and perhaps that is why Solzhenitsyn does not stop, because we can believe in tragedy, but this? How can we believe this to have been real? This is a tragedy wrapped in an enigma, wrapped in a joke.</p><p>“If only it were all so simple! If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?”</p><p>For me, this is the passage that most accurately reveals the whole of the book. To confront the absurd reality of the Gulag is to confront humanity as a whole. Just as those interrogators and prison guards should have asked “what if it were me?” before they humiliated and devastated the lives of their victims, so should we have asked ourselves, what if it were us? I don’t mean to consider if we were victims, I mean to ask if we were the <em>perpetrators</em> of the atrocity. Why could it not be? Do you think you are too good? We cannot pretend that millions of Soviet soldiers and officials were tricked overnight into becoming agents of the apocalypse. No, they were convinced that what they were doing was right, just as we fight for our flag today and believe our enemies ought to be defeated, so did they believe they were righteous amongst hordes of infidels, traitors, and undesirables. They were like us, and we are like them.</p><p>Deep within all of us is the capability for great terror, a state in which everything we have built is torn from our self and we recede and disappear into an ancient programming that cannot recall any flavor of enlightened thought. We are Mother Nature’s greatest accomplishment, and yet we are still her child. We cannot escape. We are not special, not in the way we are taught to believe. Would you have acted any differently? Honestly confront yourself. Had you been living then, would you have rebelled? Do you think you are capable of such heroics? I think you would have sunk into a meek and submissive state, an unrecognizable state so terrifically removed from what you thought you were capable of, and so distant that you are not even at liberty to think these thoughts, you are instead only living in this moment, too filled with despair and an ironic will to survive, and too weak to take that survival into your own hands, and so you wait, afraid to make any decision because you might be wrong, and so pathetic that you do not have the confidence to be right, not like you thought; in fact, you are nothing like you thought you would be, you are like everyone else and you will fall in line with everyone else because that is comfortable and easy and that is your best chance at survival, and so you say your yessir and you bow your head and you remove the humanity from the other until he becomes a pure other, and a pure other does not require nor deserve your respect — he is an animal, and therefore your selfishness is rationalized as easily as removing the pests from the house, and so you can sleep easier knowing you did as you were told and you will live another day, because taking a stand would require you to actually be special, and you are not. Instead, you feel your heart drumming in your throat, nauseous, helpless, desperately fluttering through possible antidotes for this anxiety, always landing on the most pathetic of remedies, bowing your pathetic head in submission.</p><p>And, so, too, are the slaves pathetic—and in much the same way. They who outnumber their captors walk in tight clumps with their eyes on the ground, frail and spineless animals backed into a corner and too held by anxiety to create even the idea of a rebellion, somehow continually yielding to power, hoping for someone <em>else</em> to save them. But, who? You are acknowledging your own failure by surrendering any agency in your future! Your entire being is no longer within your purview. And even if you have been made a slave by chain, you have surrendered your mind of your own will, completely inadequate to risk the idea of insurrection. Solzhenitsyn marvels at how all those arrested go in peace, sometimes even publicly taken through the streets, all without incident. He cannot believe how rare an occurrence it is to hear an accused man squealing for help as he is heaved from street to street. Shouldn’t this man, who knows he has done nothing wrong, struggle? Instead we submit quietly, hoping the person whose hands now hold our life will perhaps be generous, even if we are apparently aware that only tragedy and injustice await us. We let these things happen, somehow.</p><p>The victim and victimizer are two sides of the same strange coin. Both are paralyzed by a higher power into acting in ways they never thought they could. This higher power is usually an idea that has been convincingly implanted within us by the few great people gifted enough to do so. These great people are often enraptured by broad ideas that they have embedded to become their own, though sometimes they develop their ideas independently — in either case they do not bow. They would rather die than be the meek victim. They are not capable of such submission. They do not accept that “this is the way the world is”, but instead are heroic or villainous enough to attempt to make the world in their vision. This is the human tribe, full of sheep, scattered with herders. It is visible from Nazi Germany to Soviet Russia, Genghis Khan’s Golden Horde and Pol Pot’s Khmer Rouge. If we accept that we are all equal, then we must also accept that this human behavior, however extreme, is still within the human spectrum, because no man conducts a genocide on his own. Within these armies of the apocalypse are thousands and millions of soldiers who are just like us.</p><p>Recall the Milgram Experiments, in which a test subject was told to transmit an electrical shock to a stranger on the other side of a wall. The experiment was meant to test the way humans respond to authority. There was no person on the other side of the wall, but fake cries of pain were used to convince the test subject that he was responsible for the torture of an innocent person. When the test subject protested, the test administrator would calmly state “please continue,” or “the experiment requires you to continue.” A majority of test subjects indeed continued, ultimately inflicting the maximum electrical shock. This led Milgram to conclude that “Ordinary people, simply doing their jobs, and without any particular hostility on their part, can become agents in a terrible destructive process.” What does it say about our moral and ethical codes if we give in so easily to an authority who orders us to violate those codes? What kind of judgment can we really pass on those participants in genocide, systematic imprisonment, or any other atrocity?</p><p>It is hard to extrapolate from this experiment full and concrete evidence that explains the Holocaust, Soviet Gulag system, or the genocide in Darfur. While these experiments only lasted an hour and the test subjects operated under assurances that no one would be <em>permanently </em>harmed, the aforementioned atrocities lasted years, its participants had time to reflect on their actions, and they were often fully aware that they were torturing and taking lives. But, at the same time, the participants in Milgram’s tests were not under any threat. They merely obeyed a stated authority. Surely, one would think that if these Milgram participants knew the pressing of the buzzer would lead to the death of a stranger, they would not act so opposed to their morals and ethics. There must be a limit. And so while the damage inflicted by these test subjects was much less than the genocides of the 20th Century, so too were the stakes. Perhaps an authority that explicitly or implicitly punishes those who disobey with death or exile would be able to turn people so far from their moral code as to commit murder.</p><p>Milgram’s experiment is not an outlandish explanation. After all, is there a better one? How do we explain the mass participation and bureaucracy involved in these atrocities? It must be rooted in some aspect of human nature. Here, too, Milgram proposes the agentic state theory in which people begin to view themselves not as independent beings, but merely as instruments that carry out the will of others. This absolves them of responsibility. Again, this is a stunningly submissive and arguably selfish state in which the agent has abandoned their morals and ethics, perhaps in order to survive. We tend to think we would not behave this way, but most of us apparently do. Power and authority are inescapable realities that often confront and conflict with our ideas of equality.</p><p>The utopia in which we want to live — in which everyone is equal and possesses the same inalienable rights, in which injustice is rare and thoroughly punished, in which “love thy neighbor” is universal — is such a delicate place as to almost be unnatural. That does not mean we should not strive for that utopia, but clearly achieving it is to overcome our very instincts. Murder and injustice is more natural than peace and equality. But, we have put a man on the moon, and that is far from natural. This is much more complicated and demanding, but not impossible.</p><p>Solzhenitsyn’s catalog of atrocity and absurdity is a building block towards this future. To never forget is to never repeat and to do better than before. Today’s mass literacy and interconnectivity also contribute to an increase in empathy. It is much more difficult to infringe harm upon those with whom we sympathize. As atrocities become more and more documented, it becomes easier to not only learn from them, but to actually <em>remember</em> what we learned, so that we recognize the terrible roads down which we may be heading, hopefully soon enough to exit. And yet, we are clearly also capable of inflicting harm upon a fellow human being — a fellow American — on the other side of an experiment wall, simply because we are told. How could we not have empathy for that person, who we just met, and with whom we could have easily swapped positions? Clearly this is about more than empathy. It’s about recognizing our innately human flaws and overcoming them. In the same way we are taught to control our anger, lust, or other primal desires, we must also be educated on how we are affected by authority. Only then can we overcome it.</p><p>One of the participants in Milgram’s experiment wrote to him years later saying that that experience was the main reason he was willing to risk imprisonment instead of accepting the call to be drafted to fight in the Vietnam War. Milgram had inadvertently made him aware of the flaws in his tendencies. He recognized his morals were to be tested and this awareness allowed him to overcome the power of authority. By learning about Milgram and by reading Solzhenitsyn we prepare our minds for the ridiculous and unbelievable realities of human nature. Only by understanding our primal instincts can we ever hope to overcome them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ff25ce92530" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Internet Microscope]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin/the-internet-microscope-513fbc5e0b60?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/513fbc5e0b60</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[xenophobia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matt Ryklin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Aug 2016 14:09:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-31T14:09:44.890Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek made improvements to the microscope, he could finally see what had always been there. When he peered into the fabric of the objects and living creatures around him, his perception may have changed, but the world was no different. This is how it always had been — cells, mitochondria, DNA, all the little building blocks working harmoniously to create everything around us. The targets of his observation were always there, he could just never have seen them without the right tool. And so today, when we see the immense violence and destruction our world has to offer, we are not seeing anything new. It is only new to us. The Internet is a microscope that allows us to peer into the lives of people all around the world, and being the morbid creatures we are, our gaze often fixates on the visceral atrocities.</p><p>This microscope tricks us. It convinces us that this is the world — a tragic construction of people and plants and animals all falling apart faster than ever before. ISIS and Alton Sterling and rampaging trucks in France and the deaths of our heroes, like Muhammad Ali. But, we live in the most peaceful time in history. It’s as if Van Leeuwenhoek looked into the microscopic world, discovered the terror that is bacteria, and concluded it was going to kill us all, when in reality it had always been there, and had even mitigated over time. Looking at any number of statistics — homicide rate, infant mortality rate, sexual assault rate, prevalence of autocratic governments — will show you that the world is more peaceful today. And yet the news would have you believe that the world is falling apart, that violence is inevitable, that no one is safe.</p><p>We are mostly unequipped to handle all of this information. We grow up with our families, understanding this world of only three to six people. Then we are thrust into a school, and our world expands to twenty people, maybe one hundred. Then we see the Internet. Our parents give us a phone or we clumsily begin to access the family computer. Our world grows to 7 billion. We see our family, we try to understand them, why does mom yell at dad, why does mom kiss dad, what is in the refrigerator, why can’t I watch cartoons, and we see our little school class, and maybe our community, and we try to understand the way teachers think and the way our classmates feel about us, we try to understand the bully, we try to understand why we are not so good at soccer, why we succeed at baseball, why we read well, why we do math poorly, why we like girls, why we’re mean to girls we like, why they’re mean to us, can we ride our bikes to the other side of town? And then our world explodes and we see 7 billion people and all of their problems and how different they are, and sometimes how similar they are. 7 billion people. There is nothing that adequately prepares us for this. There is no class to teach you how to process this information, and so we often process it like all 7 billion people are our neighbors. In our little communities of a few hundred people, four murders would be a crisis, and so we see the violence on the news and the Internet and we are worried for our community, but we forget that community is actually 7 billion.</p><p><strong>Big Numbers</strong></p><p>Working with such huge numbers is very difficult for our brain. When we hear 6 million Jews were killed during the Holocaust, we understand that to be a massive number of people, but do we really understand such a number, especially when it’s human lives? A small middle school in Tennessee started a project in which they collected paper clips to symbolize each of the deaths of the Holocaust. When we stare at the massive sea of paper clips, it helps reinforce how great a number this is. But, then try to think about the total casualties of World War Two. 60 million people died. How do we even process this number of deaths? Would 60 million paper clips help to show the loss of human life, each as intricate as your own? Is death more tragic today than it was then? How did they cope with 60 million dead? Every death hurts someone. If a family member dies, your world stops. If three cops are killed, the news cannot stop covering it. 60 million people is such a staggering amount of dead. You could kill everyone in greater New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Washington DC and you would not reach 60 million people.</p><p>Do you think Boston is an important city? It has a mere 700,000 people. Do you know where Lagos is? It’s the biggest city in Nigeria. It has 16 million people and you probably don’t know anything about it. It’s bigger than any city in the United States. There are 16 million people and each has their own stories and struggles and their own sense of humanity. There are cities in China and India that casually host millions of people and I would bet 98% of Americans don’t know they exist. Am I the only one whose brain explodes at trying to really wrap my head around these numbers?</p><p>Our political debates are constantly filled with posturing about our soldiers putting their lives at risk in the War on Terror, and of course it’s terrible that Americans are dying, but, it’s been over a decade since the War on Terror began and we’ve had less than 7,000 members of the U.S. military killed. 7,000! That’s it! I don’t mean to sound insensitive, but isn’t that remarkable? We’ve been at war for over a decade and we’ve only lost 7,000 soldiers. That’s a mere one third of the average attendance for a Major League Soccer game. During the Vietnam War, over 200,000 U.S or allied military personnel died. During World War Two, 400,000 U.S military personnel died. And while these numbers seem huge compared to today, in none of these cases did we even lose 1 percent of our population. Not even half a percent. In World War Two, Belarus lost 25% of its <em>entire population</em>, not just soldiers. We are literally incapable of comprehending this. From 1998–2003 there was a war in the Congo and between 2.5 and 5.5 million people died, and you probably didn’t even know it.</p><p><strong>Do We Understand How We Value Human Life?</strong></p><p>The less connected you are with someone, the less you value their life. You value the lives of your family the most, then your friends, then the people in your community, then the people in your country, then the people who look like you and share a similar culture, then, finally, maybe you value the lives of people completely foreign to you. It’s not wrong to think this way. It’s only natural. You would be destroyed if your best friend died, but you probably don’t take as much time to consider the over 100,000 civilian deaths from the War on Terror. We, as Americans, think more about the 7,000 U.S military deaths, and that’s natural. But, everyone that dies is important to someone, and so their death brings about the same feelings you would have if someone close to you died. The most objective conclusion is that all these lives should be weighed equally. In some ways we believe this, and anyone speaking in public would state it firmly, but obviously most of us don’t really feel it, because we are programmed to see the world on a community scale.</p><p>This is, again, something with which I find it difficult to cope and process. It feels wrong to look at 7,000 dead U.S military members and think, “Great, that’s actually an almost irrelevant number of deaths — we’ve had a pretty successful campaign there in terms of loss of U.S lives.” It feels wrong to look at the number of murders in Chicago, 468 in 2015, and think, “that’s a pretty statistically irrelevant number considering there are over 2 million people living in Chicago, 350 million in the United States, and 7 billion in the world — what’s 468 <em>really?</em>” Is approaching human life like a computer really the answer? I don’t think so. I feel it is probably unhealthy to process human life so rationally, because eventually you might forget you’re dealing with individual, complex human beings, and not just numbers.</p><p>But, maybe there are benefits to being a computer. A computer may theoretically save more lives than we and our complicated governments and organizations do. I assume most people would think that it is a good goal to try and save as many human lives as possible. And, in addition, if we assume that all human lives are equal, then saving the life of someone in Sudan should be an equal accomplishment to saving the life of someone in Chicago. Given the two scenarios, trying to save around 500 lives in Chicago, or trying to save 500,000 lives from genocide in Sudan, should we not choose the latter? It obviously sounds terrible to dismiss the lives in Chicago, but is it any worse than the way we often fail to consider the lives of Iraqi civilians, instead dwelling on the lives of U.S military? Again, we are predisposed to favoring the lives of those closer to us, and I think that’s normal, but maybe it’s not the right thing to do. I don’t know the answer, I’m just asking a lot of questions.</p><p>I think most people would agree that saving the most lives possible is a good idea, but I imagine they also think that truly living up to this statement would be rather difficult. It would be nearly impossible for most people to shun the problems in their own community in favor of trying to save people on the other side of the world, even if they acknowledge the problems in their own community affect less human lives than those elsewhere. It’s reasonable to assume people would give their best aid effort to causes they feel closer to, so maybe it is actually more efficient for everyone to attempt to save the lives near and dear to them. Maybe we should not feel guilty about placing greater value on the lives of those closer to us.</p><p>However, I noticed a recent phenomenon that would run counter to this notion. Following some of the terrorist attacks in Europe, there was a group of people who bemoaned the fact that we, as Americans, paid more attention to these tragedies than to similar terrorist attacks in the rest of the world. The implication of this was that we, as Americans, only cared about European lives and white lives. Personally, I am divided on this. One part of me, as described in this piece, thinks maybe we should literally treat every life as equal, thus the most pressing issues should be those that affect the most people — a few dozen people dead in Belgium should be irrelevant when considering the hundreds of thousands dead in the Middle East. The other part of me recognizes human nature — that we care more about those closer to us. Thus, when I heard this criticism of coverage of the European terrorist attacks, my first reaction was to wonder why anyone was really surprised at all? Did you not realize that the United States is most politically and culturally aligned with Western Europe? I didn’t think that was news. Obviously we are going to care more about a terrorist attack in France than one in Lebanon or Bangladesh. We share more in common with France. A terrorist attack there is not only more relatable, but more shocking because of that relation. This is not to say that we should not care about attacks or tragedies elsewhere in the world, but to imply that they should receive equally as much news coverage is a complicated declaration. I don’t think we want to play that game, because as I’ve demonstrated, there is essentially always some horrible tragedy going on in the world and it is very easy to engage in an endless circle of competing for which is worse and more deserving of our attention.</p><p>A brief aside — I acknowledge that these last two sections may have gotten a little off track, but ultimately I think they contain important information to consider in order to understand the central thesis, so let me bring it back to that. We are not equipped to process 7 billion lives. The Internet has opened this world up to us in a new way and this often distorts reality. How do we cope with this? I’ve tried to demonstrate just how difficult it is to comprehend tens of millions of lives, let alone 7 billion, and I’ve also tried to demonstrate how thinking about all these lives can call our morals into question through an analysis of how we might value human life. So keeping in mind the problem of big numbers, next I am going to look at how our reality is distorted by the Internet microscope.</p><p><strong>Making Mountains Out of Molehills</strong></p><p>The reason I spent so much time talking about big numbers is because you need to remember them and you need to remember how hard they are to process. Again, we instinctively and emotionally react to many events as if they were occurring in our own community, and this effect is intensified when you have something in common with the affected parties. So, again, as Americans we generally feel closer to crises in Western Europe. As an American Muslim or Jew, you probably feel closer to crises affecting the Middle East, and same goes with any other minority, particularly of an immigrant background. Additionally, the Internet fosters this environment because we are more easily able to relate to the far reaches of earth, so even as a white upper class American, you are able to empathize with the workers of an impoverished factory on the other side of the world because the Internet allows you to witness their humanity. We understand tragedies around the world through this intrinsically tribal lens, thus the more disasters or murders we witness, the more we start to feel a sense of anxiety and danger.</p><p>This sense of anxiety is very natural. It’s a defense mechanism. We are drawn to the worst scenes and events of humanity because they spike that sense of terror that is necessary for our survival. If you lived in a community of 100 people and there were a series of 3 murders in a couple of weeks, you would be on edge in order to protect your family, friends, and neighbors. You would be scared for your life and for theirs. Knowing about this violence is information significantly more important for survival than knowing about something positive, like the charity work someone in your community is doing. I think this is why the news mostly shows us bad and tragic events. Unfortunately, we are innately and helplessly drawn to this information.</p><p>It is here where we are duped. Our prehistoric senses and instincts are tricked by the massive quantity of information to which we have access. We are liable to let our minds run wild, overreacting and drawing the wrong conclusions. Trying to remember the bigger picture helps us to control this instinct. It helps to put into perspective the tragedies we see.</p><p>Go into Google and type in “2016 worst year ever” and you will get a lot of articles and tweets lamenting how horrible 2016 is. There is also the occasional article that has adopted my perspective, playing on the fact that 1492 was probably a lot worse than 2016. But, that article itself only came about in response to enough public decrees that 2016 is the worst. Next, type “2015 worst year ever.” Then do 2014 — Buzzfeed has 26 reasons 2014 was the worse, and they wrote that in April. Obviously I’m not the only one to conclude how ridiculous this trend is, but it persists nonetheless, and year after year there are plenty of people who can’t help but think they are living in the worst year ever.</p><p>We consistently overreact and forget perspective. Something can be a tragedy without being an international crisis or a bellwether for the apocalypse. One example can be seen in traditional xenophobic movements. At this year’s Republican National Convention, a few people were brought out who had a family member who was killed by an illegal immigrant who was released from custody. This is a tragedy, and one that everyone obviously wishes could have been avoided. But, rather than merely acknowledging the tragedy and discussing reasonable preventions, people drew the conclusion that illegal immigration will definitively lead to more murders, or, more problematically, that illegal immigrants (re: Mexicans and other Central Americans) are <em>inherently</em> murderous or criminal. This is a remarkably inaccurate conclusion derived from a few unfortunate anecdotes. The Department of Homeland Security stated that between 2010 and 2014, 121 illegal immigrants released from custody committed a murder. Again, this is still incredibly unfortunate, but we need to put it into perspective, so let’s look at big numbers. There are somewhere between 11 and 12 million undocumented immigrants in the United States, according to the Pew Research Center. So, those 121 murderers represent about one thousandth of a percent of the total number of illegal immigrants — and that’s in four years. One thousandth of a percent is .001%. Do you know how remarkably irrelevant that number is? It’s less than your odds of being struck by lighting in your lifetime (according to the National Weather Service: 1 in 12,000 or .08%, compared to 121 in 12,000,000 or .001%). So, anyone using these few unfortunate anecdotes to conclude that illegal immigration is leading to mass violence and murder is drawing the wrong conclusion — they are forgetting big numbers and perspective. They see these tragedies and they go into survival mode — eliminate the foreign presence, trust only those in my community — and they are plainly wrong.</p><p>Of course, this type of xenophobia is as old as immigration itself. There are also phenomena of overreaction that I think are more unique to our modern Internet Microscope. It seems like every week there is an incident that gets the social media world fired up, only to die down sometimes a mere two days later. It’s as if we see a couple reported cases of the flu and all of a sudden conclude there is an epidemic. I saw this with the lead up to a few international sporting events, namely the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi, the 2014 World Cup in Brazil, the 2016 Eurocup in France, and the 2016 Summer Olympics in Rio de Janeiro. Leading up to each of these events was a monsoon of negative press and doomsday proclamations. Sochi was rife with rabid stray dogs, nothing — from electricity to plumbing — would work properly. Brazil was a dangerous place where people were consistently murdered over soccer games — it would be a bad idea to go to the World Cup, it’s not safe (spoiler — my friends and I went to the World Cup. It was awesome.) France was a hotbed for terror attacks — it would be dangerous to step foot in any soccer arena (spoiler — my friends and I went to the Euro Cup. It was awesome). Rio was completely unprepared to host the Olympics, events would surely be cancelled, and the pools and the water would get everyone sick.</p><p>While you couldn’t argue any of these events went 100% perfectly, you also have to acknowledge that they were all ultimately executed smoothly with very few setbacks, a far cry from what the media would have had you believe leading up to the events. We take a few bad incidents and explode the story into chaos. Rather than merely acknowledging that hosting such a massive event is difficult and will inevitably experience some mistakes and problems, we get wrapped up in declaring certain danger, destruction, and failure. I imagine in the 1960’s there were also a lot of problems organizing the games — we just would not have heard about <em>all</em> of them. My point being that the issues have always been there, it is just that now we have the Internet Microscope to see them all, and because we focus on the problems rather than whatever it is that is going well, we make the wrong conclusion. If there were 50 bad incidents in the lead up to the Rio Olympic Games, we would interpret that as a crisis and conclude that the games would certainly fail. But, what if there were 10,000 things that were actually going right, most of which we would not hear on the news or social media? So only .5% of the stuff going on is bad, which is not very much at all, and perhaps not even that much better or worse than when the games were hosted in Rome in 1960, or Tokyo in 1964. By the way — there were zero reported cases of Zika linked with the Olympic Games.</p><p>There is a reason that statisticians require sufficient sample sizes to make conclusions. Using a handful of anecdotes to make broad conclusions about the path of society is dangerous. There is so much statistical bias in those anecdotes because, again, we are more likely to hear about the bad incidents, thus coloring our entire view as bad. I am not, however, advocating the elimination of these anecdotes, because in many cases they serve an incredibly important function — eliciting empathy, which in turn inspires action that hopefully improves the lives of those in need. But, it is still necessary to step back and try to put those anecdotes into perspective, because while in some cases a heart wrenching news story will be the impetus for necessary change, in other cases we interpret these stories wrong, leading to inefficient and misplaced action, or, worse, discrimination and xenophobia.</p><p><strong>When the Microscope Works</strong></p><p>So far I have described how the Internet Microscope creates a problem for us — namely that we are ill-equipped to process 7 billion lives and 7 billion stories. I have gone over the moral conundrums we face in trying to process all of these lives, and I have examined some of the problematic conclusions we arrive at because of this confusion and our failure to maintain perspective. However, the Internet Microscope is neither bad nor good. It has a profound affect on our society, and that affect is sometimes bad and sometimes good. In the spirit of keeping a comprehensive perspective, I want to now examine the positive outcomes of our ability to see and know everything and everyone.</p><p>I think the Internet Microscope has been most insightful and important in the way it has exposed both the problems and successes of minorities and non-Western people. Obviously in a country that is mostly homogenous, the media will largely, if not exclusively, feature people and stories from that homogenous group. I imagine that in China nearly all of the TV programming is about Chinese people, starring Chinese people. Throughout most of the 20th Century, I imagine the United States was in a similar situation — mostly white Americans as the stars of any story and mostly white Americans on the news. However, the Internet Microscope has helped to change this in a country that increasingly has to confront the reality that it is not, nor has ever been, homogenous. Whereas centralized, powerful studio executives were, and still are, less likely to create projects featuring minorities, the Internet has allowed those stories to grow, and the effects of this have been overwhelmingly positive, both in the spirit of diversity and also in the development of activism to address chronic problems in those communities.</p><p>The Internet allows for the decentralized production of content, which allows for people that may normally be on the fringes of society to actually be heard. Whereas previously these people would have had to jump through a thousand hoops in order to make it into the ears, eyes, and minds of the country, now their stories can be easily and quickly proliferated all around the world. Our newsfeeds may be constantly full of tragedy, but sometimes that is necessary. Poor factory conditions in Southeast Asia may have been easily hidden from consumers before, but these situations are become increasingly more difficult to conceal. A news story featuring one of these tragic workplaces exposes the American people to a situation many may have not even known existed. The spread of this story leads to empathy — rather than thinking about it as some factory on the other side of the world, we see the humanity and the tragedy and it calls upon us to take action. The effect is bolstered by the Internet’s ability to transmit visual content. Reading about the appalling conditions is bad enough, but seeing them through pictures or video is a much more visceral reaction.</p><p>Video has also been a key component in the rise of activism in the United States concerning police brutality. It seems obvious to some that police brutality has been a plight upon the Black Community for as long as this country has existed, but much of White America has actually been uninformed, often maintaining that such examples of racism are a thing of the past. From the murder of Michael Brown, to those of Alton Sterling and Philando Castile, video evidence has been a key component in mobilizing and informing the American population that police brutality is very much alive and disproportionately affects Black Americans. With nearly everyone possessing a cell phone and an Internet connection, these incidences of violence are significantly more likely to reach the public.</p><p>The subsequent public outrage is good. This is a case in which we need this visceral reaction in order to be made aware of actual statistical evidence that demonstrates inequality. This is the opposite scenario described before concerning xenophobia, in which tragic anecdotes create a narrative that runs counter to the statistical evidence. The Internet Microscope can both trick us and illuminate new and important parts of the world. The only way to know which purpose it serves in any given moment is to, again, remember perspective.</p><p><strong>It Only Feels New</strong></p><p>In the introduction to this piece, I described how bizarre it would have been if Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek had looked into a microscope, seen bacteria for the first time, and concluded that it was going to kill us all. In reality, there was no cause for alarm, because the bacteria was not new — it had been around for millennia, and we had survived. But, of course, Van Leeuwenhoek’s discovery also allowed for the development of modern medicine. It’s hard to acknowledge where we can make progress without also going mad at the potential dangers around us.</p><p>In addition to using perspective in order to determine what news stories provide us with a signal of real problems and which are pushing us towards false conclusions, we also need to use perspective to help manage our expectations and anxiety. When I talk about the Internet Microscope having a positive effect by showing Americans that racism is not dead and that police brutality is real, we should also remember that this is not a indicator for the end of the world or that society is approaching some sort of all time low. Again, the opposite is actually more accurate — the world is generally a better place than it was. That does not mean it is perfect.</p><p>That imperfection also implies that we are not perfect. As I have tried to present, one of those flaws is our consistent inability to cope with and process all of the information we have available today. This information is powerful, but we were mostly not built to handle it — maybe our children, who will be connected from the time they are toddlers, will be different. But, for us, we often draw the wrong conclusions from this heap of stories, transforming a few anecdotes into a state of emergency for our communities. And while sometimes this new access to information leads to positive change, it is misinterpreted often enough that we should try to be more careful in our analysis and in the conclusions we draw from that information.</p><p>If there is anything I’ve hoped to transmit to you through this discussion, it is to acknowledge the importance of this perspective. Just as a mother tries to ease her young son’s broken heart after a teenage breakup, or a father calms his daughter’s stress over one bad exam, I am trying to do the same, as audacious as it may sound to place the world as my child. Nonetheless, a teenage breakup is not the end of the world, it only feels like it. And, one C in 8th grade will not plunge you into homelessness, it only feels like it because you are young and this test represents such a huge portion of your world. So, as much as humanity will present its worst to us, its terrorist attacks, its racism, xenophobia, its appalling labor conditions, its evil corporations and politicians, its senseless murder, it is important to always hold tight to perspective. These things are not new — they are as old as humanity itself, and while that does not mean they should not be fought with every ounce of our strength, it is also surely unhealthy to absorb all of these problems, to convince ourselves that the world is a terrible place, and to constantly fear the end. Rather, from time to time, perhaps we should break from the Internet Microscope and take a moment to reflect on the good in our world and in our communities, and remember that all of the fighting we do is, slowly, but incredibly, working.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=513fbc5e0b60" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Big Numbers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin/big-numbers-be075b16c42f?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/be075b16c42f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war-on-terror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoughts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genocide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wwii]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matt Ryklin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Aug 2016 22:59:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-27T22:59:52.017Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is a small part of a larger article</em></p><p>Working with huge numbers is very difficult for our brain. When we hear 6 million Jews were killed during the Holocaust, we understand that to be a massive number of people, but do we really understand such a number, especially when it concerns human lives? A small middle school in Tennessee started a project in which they collected paper clips to symbolize each of the deaths of the Holocaust. When we stare at the massive sea of paper clips, it helps reinforce how great a number this is. But, then try to think about the total casualties of World War Two. 60 million people died. How do we even process this number of deaths? Would 60 million paper clips help to show the loss of human life, each as intricate as your own? Is death more tragic today than it was then? How did they cope with 60 million dead? Every death hurts someone. If a family member dies, your world stops. If three cops are killed, the news cannot stop covering it. 60 million people is such a staggering amount of dead. You could kill everyone in greater New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Washington DC and you would not reach 60 million people.</p><p>Do you think Boston is an important city? It has a mere 700,000 people. Do you know where Lagos is? It’s the biggest city in Nigeria. It has 16 million people and you probably don’t know anything about it. It’s bigger than any city in the United States. There are 16 million people and each has their own stories and struggles and their own sense of humanity. There are cities in China and India that casually host millions of people and I would bet 98% of Americans don’t know they exist. Am I the only one whose brain explodes at trying to really wrap my head around these numbers?</p><p>Our political debates are constantly filled with posturing about our soldiers putting their lives at risk in the War on Terror, and of course it’s terrible that Americans are dying, but, it’s been over a decade since the War on Terror began and we’ve had less than 7,000 members of the U.S. military killed. 7,000! That’s it! I don’t mean to sound insensitive, but isn’t that remarkable? We’ve been at war for over a decade and we’ve only lost 7,000 soldiers. That’s a mere one third of the average attendance for a Major League Soccer game. During the Vietnam War, over 200,000 U.S or allied military personnel died. During World War Two, 400,000 U.S military personnel died. And while these numbers seem huge compared to today, in none of these cases did we even lose 1 percent of our population. Not even half a percent. In World War Two, Belarus lost 25% of its <em>entire population</em>, not just soldiers. We are literally incapable of comprehending this. From 1998–2003 there was a war in the Congo and between 2.5 and 5.5 million people died, and you probably didn’t even know it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=be075b16c42f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Good, Bad, and The Nature of Imperfection]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin/good-bad-and-the-nature-of-imperfection-92d254dc564a?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92d254dc564a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[muhammad-ali]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[imperfection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matt Ryklin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Aug 2016 17:12:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-13T22:03:18.808Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“If only it were all so simple! If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?”</p><p><em>Alexandr Solzhenitsyn</em></p><p>How do we the public decide who is good and who is bad? Do we weigh what they’ve done in their life and make determinations about which is greater, the sum of the good or the sum of the bad? If a dictator donates five million dollars to feed poor families, does it begin to outweigh his murder of fifty thousand dissenters? What if he donated five hundred million dollars to feed poor families? Then, is he a good person? Or is he a bad person that committed a good act? If an actor stars in multiple Oscar winnings roles, founds a charity that provides clean water to millions of people, and publicly fights on behalf of gay marriage, how much does it matter that he raped a woman when he was 19? Does that outweigh all the good he has done? Is he a bad person now? Or is he a good person who committed a bad act? How do we process this dichotomy? What if that actor simply stole a woman’s purse? Surely, that garners less negative weight and we would regard him still as an overall good person, right?</p><p>Why is it that it takes years to build a reputation, and only a moment to destroy it? We all seem to acknowledge this is a little unfair. We all recognize that people make mistakes, and yet we freely participate in a system in which we gleefully assist in dragging a person’s name through the dirt, never to be clean again. We tell our children that no one is perfect. We know we are not perfect. Nevertheless, it often seems we expect perfection, and as our technologies allow us to know more about people, that perfection becomes harder to find.</p><p><strong>There Will Never Be Another Ali</strong></p><p>Muhammad Ali is almost universally considered one of the greatest athletes of all time. He earned this distinction not just because of his prowess as a boxer, but because of how he used his platform to advance what we believe are excellent causes — namely civil rights and his protest against the Vietnam War. He sacrificed years of his athletic prime in protest of the war and he stood up to the racist institutions that tried so hard to tear him down. He is the embodiment of a modern hero. There will never be another public figure like him. By that, however, I do not mean there will never be another great athlete who uses his public persona to affect change. That will happen again, I’m sure. There will never be a Muhammad Ali because no one with his record could possibly survive the public stoning in which we now regularly, and often joyfully, engage.</p><p>Muhammad Ali called Joe Frazier an ape. He cheated on his wives relentlessly. He said those who participated in interracial marriage should be killed. He believed his woman was his property. What a shockingly horrible person, even by the standards of his day. But, Muhammad Ali is The Greatest. We weigh the bad against the good, and the good wins, as it should, in my opinion. What he did was so singularly important for both America and the world that those bad acts should not tarnish his legacy as a hero. They should not be forgotten, and they should be condemned, but it would be blasphemy to suggest those acts make him a bad person, whatever that ephemeral term really suggests.</p><p>But, try to imagine a figure so polarizing today. His infidelities would not just be whispers. His derogatory comments would not just find their way into newspapers and magazines, but would be amplified exponentially via the Internet and the 24-hour news cycle, finding their way into the heads of 10-year-olds and 70-year-olds alike. Some would excuse them and some would vilify him. But, as a whole, I cannot imagine him attaining the same heroic status with those blemishes on his résumé. We would not allow it. We no longer tolerate imperfection. Judgments are immediate, often made on the basis of blurbs rather than well-deliberated discussion or writing.</p><p>None of this is to sugarcoat the past and pretend like Muhammad Ali was not immensely controversial in his day. But, save his abstinence from the draft, he was allowed to fight and to speak publicly. Today, such a figure could lose their job or even be barred from his profession entirely were he to say similar statements. Twitter would have a field day. LeBron James can speak out against police brutality — and rightfully so. He and some of his compatriots have taken the mantle from Ali and regularly use their position to promote issues they care about. But, imagine if in addition to those words, he said something like, “fuck cops — I smile when a white cop gets shot. He probably had it coming.” This is a terrible statement and he would get ripped apart in the media. The league might even have to take some action. He would likely hold a press conference in which he would apologize and state he was just angry about current events and he let that anger get the best of him. But, his legacy would be tarnished. Large portions of the population would not be able to forgive him and it would be brought up every time anyone referred to him as a hero — “how could a hero say something like that?” All the good he has done, outweighed by one mistake, possibly never redeemed.</p><p>The strangest part is that if LeBron said something like that, we should really be more understanding. Are we not all guilty of saying something we regret in a moment of passion? Is this not doubly understandable given his connection to the issue? I do not deride Muhammad Ali for what he thought and said. This is a man who won an Olympic Gold Medal for the same country that would not let him eat in certain restaurants. I would probably hate white people, too. I can disagree while still understanding perspective. As Ali grew older, his beliefs changed. “The man who views the world at 50 the same as he did at 20 has wasted 30 years,” he said. Just as we have all been guilty of saying things we regret in a moment of passion, we also are all guilty of regretting things we said or did when we were younger. We, as common people, are given time to grow and learn. Yet, today we expect our public figures to come out of the womb as the heroes we imagine them to be. Many who love Muhammad Ali and give him credit for growing as a person as he got older also deride and have no patience for young public figures today who misstep. A slip up at 18 requires years of deliberate work, and often pandering, to rectify itself. We do not take the time to understand. We can condemn an action without vilifying the actor, and yet we so often forget that.</p><p><strong>Our Evolving Analysis of Past Figures</strong></p><p>If Muhammad Ali’s bad acts were ultimately redeemable, whose are not? Both Martin Luther King and Malcolm X could be put into the same category as Ali. They were not perfect. King was known to be adulterous, though we definitively believe those bad acts are outweighed by the good he has done. Malcolm X took a little longer to become well regarded by the public at large. He began in the Nation of Islam as someone who believed in the full separation of black and white people and that white people were the devil. Through his life’s journey, he would come to represent and fight for ideas much more palpable to our modern tastes, and so he is remembered more fondly, even gracing a U.S. Postage Stamp. His good acts outweigh his bad. This is evidence that the court of public opinion is ever changing when it comes to our historical figures. The scale that measures a person’s good acts and bad acts is not constant. Our perception of those good or bad acts changes over time, and so they are assigned more or less weight, which in turn affects whether we regard that person as a good or bad person. While history has looked favorably upon Malcolm X, we can look to the system he fought against to find those whose bad acts have ballooned to the point that the individual is no longer widely regarded as a good person.</p><p>A lot of old, dead, white men were racist. If we go back far enough, nearly all of them were racist. And now, a recent trend has emerged in which college students are calling for buildings on their campus to be renamed, because, naturally, these buildings are mostly named after old white men, often deceased, often racist. However, these old white men did have buildings named after them, so of course at some point they were looked at as good people, even heroic. You don’t name a building after someone you think is bad. Our values change over time, and so the weight we place on a person’s achievements and faults also changes. The most comprehensive example of this is Woodrow Wilson. He has been regularly ranked in the top 10 by polls asking people who they believe the best presidents in history to have been. I think in 50 years he will be remembered much differently.</p><p>Students at Princeton University, where Wilson was the school’s president, have petitioned to have the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs renamed because of Wilson’s history of racism. The first thought that may come to mind is that Wilson was born in the Antebellum South, and so of course he was a racist. He was a product of his time, and so how can we really hold him dramatically accountable for his racism? If we go back far enough in history, our modern eyes would likely see all of our ancestors as terrible people. But, Wilson’s case is especially pertinent, because it can be argued that while he certainly grew up and lived in a racist period, he was also especially racist, even for his time.</p><p>Before Wilson became president, many of the Washington D.C cabinet offices were actually desegregated. Wilson, clearly more than a casual racist, actually made an effort to re-segregate them. His staff was made up of pro-Segregation Southern Democrats and he went so far as to patronize a delegation of black protestors by telling them that segregation was not a humiliation, but actually a benefit. Wilson believed that segregation removed “friction” between the races. As I read more and more into Wilson’s history of not only racist beliefs, but also actions to proliferate those racist beliefs, I find it hard to think of this man as anything but bad. When I imagine weighing all the good and bad he’s done, it is hard to imagine the good outweighing all of these bad acts and I am inclined to agree with the Princeton students, many of them black, who feel uncomfortable going to a university that celebrates this man.</p><p>But, I also have to consider the good that President Wilson did, because there is a reason he is often voted as one of the greatest presidents this country has had. I imagine those voters are not basing their selection on his racist actions. Wilson was a leading voice in the early 20th Century Progressive Movement. He imposed an eight-hour workday for railroads, benefitting formerly exploited workers and helping avoid a strike and subsequent economic crisis. He passed the Federal Reserve Act, Federal Trade Commission Act, and Clayton Antitrust Act, all cornerstones of the modern economy. He endorsed the 19th Amendment, which gave women the right to vote. Towards the end of World War One, he released his Fourteen Points, which functioned as the foundation for the newly created League of Nations, itself the predecessor to our United Nations. He helped push the Treaty of Versailles in order to bring peace to Europe. He was a staunch advocate of international cooperation and the promotion of democracy. It can be argued that his actions helped to bring about a world in which nation-states rarely, if ever, openly war with each other.</p><p>It is fair to say Woodrow Wilson, a former president of Princeton University, is a very fitting namesake for the university’s School of Public and International Affairs. His legacy in that arena is nearly unmatched by any other American president. But, how do we reconcile that legacy with the legacy of racism? It is hard to argue he was a <em>good</em> person — he told black people that segregation was a benefit and he proudly screened <em>The Birth of a Nation</em>, essentially a Ku Klux Klan propaganda movie, in the White House. But, it’s also hard to call him a <em>bad</em> person. His actions paved the way for modern international relations, a world in which countries, for the most part, work together and avoid armed conflict amongst each other. We can argue over the inefficiencies and flaws of the United Nations and other international organizations, but it’s undeniable that they promote peace and provide aid worldwide.</p><p>Whereas I can tell you with confidence that I think Muhammad Ali, despite some flaws, was an ultimately good person, I do not know what to do with Wilson. I believe if I were to declare him a bad person, I would be guilty of taking a lot for granted. I think those who are so eager to tear his name down from any building or school in Princeton also take a lot for granted. We take the good he has done for granted because much of that good helped shape our modern world and we cannot imagine anything different. He supported women’s suffrage, but also supported segregation — how do we reconcile that? His actions led to the United Nations, but he also filled his cabinet with pro-segregation Southern racists. He was good, and he was bad.</p><p>We are slowly shifting Woodrow Wilson’s image, assigning more weight to his bad acts. This is not necessarily a <em>bad</em> thing in itself — it is important to highlight the terrible parts of his personality and presidency, especially since those parts have long been overlooked. But, these bad acts should not in any way diminish the good he accomplished. That is just as naive as praising the good while ignoring the bad. These bad acts add to his legacy, muddying it, showing us that the closer we look, the harder it is to make the distinction between good and bad.</p><p>I try to imagine some extreme thought experiments. What if aliens declared war on earth and stated that in 48 hours, they would fire a laser at our planet, destroying it and everyone on it? And, what if George W. Bush, somehow, saved us. What if he engaged in an epic negotiation, or maybe he even assassinated the alien leader? What if he saved the entire planet? I imagine we would weigh that act so heavily that we would no longer dwell on his mishandling of the Iraq War, his participation in the lead up to the 2008 Financial Crisis, and anything else we currently use to consider him a bad president, or even bad person. He would instantly shift from bad to good in the eyes of many. What if our savior was not George W. Bush, but Donald Trump? Somehow, he saved us, and maybe in doing so he even sacrificed immensely, perhaps losing his legs, or something like that. As much as he is a fool, would we not have to place such immense weight on that accomplishment that his image would shift from ignorant racist buffoon with little to no redeeming qualities, to global hero with some dark marks on his résumé? But, maybe as we got far enough into the future, we would take for granted that he saved the world, and we would again focus on his negatives.</p><p>Maybe, it’s possible. Or maybe we should be less severe in our judgments. Maybe it’s entirely irrational to make these broad designations of good and bad, and we should, as rational beings, be capable of acknowledging the complexity behind every hero, and every person. Maybe we are too quick to dismiss a person’s accomplishments, or too quick to ignore their faults. Maybe the person we are so heavily criticizing will grow and learn and become the next Muhammad Ali. Should we not give them the time to realize their greatness? We know no one is perfect, but how should we deal with that?</p><p><strong>A Poor Way of Handling Things — Cooperstown</strong></p><p>In 1994, talks between the owners and players in Major League Baseball came to an impasse. The result was a strike. Baseball became the first major professional sport to lose an entire playoff postseason due to labor conflict. The following season, after players and owners finally arrived at an agreement, fans showed their disgust with the situation by not watching games. There was a 20% decline in attendance. Television ratings also fell dramatically. Baseball was in crisis.</p><p>Its saviors would be two very large men — Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa. In 1998 they battled all season to set the new MLB home run record, held for nearly 40 years at 61 by Roger Maris, who had beat Babe Ruth’s long-standing record of 60. The 1998 Home Run race has been credited as restoring fan faith and support in the sport. Its participants, McGwire, Sosa, and later, Barry Bonds, were hailed as other worldly heroes. None of them are in the Baseball Hall of Fame at Cooperstown.</p><p>Eventually, it came out that all three of them were likely on steroids at the time of their records, forever marking their numbers with a looming asterisk. They were not the only ones — their era has become immortalized as the “Steroid Era,” and baseball has since instituted strict testing and punishments for the substances that make men’s arms and heads grow and put balls out of parks. Baseball is flush with cash because of local TV deals, but it has fallen behind the NFL and NBA in grabbing the headlines. The controversy over steroids has tarnished the game in a similar way the 1994 strike did. Fans have lost their faith in the institution. All of a sudden, the players and teams they rooted for in the late 1990’s and early 2000’s do not matter — it’s as if it was all a fantasy. Major League Baseball does not want these players to be remembered. They want to wipe this whole thing from their history, and their handling of the situation has actually been debilitating to the game itself.</p><p>These players who were once remembered as good are now remembered as bad. Many of baseball’s old heads refuse to see beyond their steroid use, creating an environment of constant paranoia and accusation that only serves to disillusion the fan base. Rather than trying to condemn their very existence, baseball should embrace these players, emphasizing their good qualities and their importance, while simultaneously acknowledging that their use of steroids should be condemned.</p><p>Cooperstown functions not just as a Hall of Fame for baseball’s best players, but also as a museum for the sport most tied to America’s history. It has its fair share of racists and degenerates like Ty Cobb and Babe Ruth. It also probably has its fair share of drug users, as cocaine and other amphetamines are documented to have been prevalent in the 1970s and 1980s. This raises a question: why do we apparently consider steroid use worse than this other bad behavior? Is it because steroid use directly impacts the player’s performance in the game itself, whereas racism is merely a personality trait disconnected from the player’s performance? But, we could also argue that the racism of players in the early 20th Century was a contributing factor in keeping black players out of the league, and had those black players been allowed to participate, then the statistics of those great white players may very well have suffered due to greater competition. This argument certainly requires some assumptions and is not as simple as the connection between steroids and improved performance, so I understand why the public at large would not grasp it, but still — after a careful and deep analysis, shouldn’t we remove Ty Cobb from Cooperstown? And if we want to expand this argument, we can definitely argue that the amphetamines used in the 1970’s and 1980’s impacted player performance. Why not remove them from the Hall of Fame, too?</p><p>Or, is the reason for the vilification of steroids actually a temporal one. In the same way that LeBron James could probably not get away with being as controversial as Muhammad Ali was, the steroid users may also be victims of the Internet Age. Their trials in front of U.S Congress committees were broadcast on TV and plastered on SportsCenter and blogs. Everyone contributed a hot take. They were naked and exposed and had no way of defending themselves besides denying their use and involvement — a lie that most could see through. We get wrapped up in the news and forget about everything else, as if the emotions we felt during the home run race were somehow fabricated, as if the charity work these men did with their money did not actually help those in need. We embrace Tommy John surgery, an elbow procedure that repairs an injured throwing arm, but demonize all steroid use without pausing to consider the potential similarities. We expect these baseball players, as we do of all our public figures, to be perfect. To me, this seems like a relatively new phenomenon. I don’t know for certain, but maybe back in the day we just expected them to be good ball players and we excused some of their personal imperfections.</p><p>Rather than look upon Babe Ruth as good and Barry Bonds as bad, baseball needs to acknowledge that both men were incredibly complex, that they had their faults and their successes both within and outside of the game. Many have advocated for baseball to allow steroid users like Bonds into the Hall of Fame and to simply have information on their plaque that describes their steroid use, rather than hides it (incidentally, a similar solution was suggested for Woodrow Wilson at Princeton). That way, we can celebrate their importance to the game without the endless moral quibbling about whether they are good or bad. We can embrace greatness while realizing it does not imply perfection.</p><p><strong>Back to Politics</strong></p><p>We project heroic images onto athletes, but with the exception of a brave few, they are merely entertainers. By analyzing the way they are perceived in society, we can learn a lot about the way we process information and make judgments. But, our perception, often hastily created, does not ultimately weigh too heavily on the future of society at large. Unfortunately, this behavior seems to apply to all public figures, even those of serious consequence.</p><p>There is no better place to look than 2016’s terrifying election. On the one side, we have Donald Trump, a man with seemingly no redeemable qualities. He does not exactly fit into any argument I’ve made thus far. It is immensely difficult to weigh the good and bad of Donald Trump, because there is, from my perspective, not a whole lot of “good”. I have not even hastily arrived at this conclusion via a few cleverly constructed Daily Show videos. I have done the research. It would appear mostly bad. Maybe I’m just biased — I don’t want to get into that. There is, however, an immense complexity in assessing his supporters, a group of people whom I think the liberal intelligentsia is guilty of oversimplifying. But, that’s a discussion for another time.</p><p>Opposite Mr. Trump, we have Hillary Clinton. Together with Mr. Trump, these two are the most disliked presidential candidates in history. While Trump blatantly alienates large swathes of America, the dislike heaped upon Hillary Clinton is more complicated. She has her good and her bad, and we weigh that good and bad, and clearly a lot of people feel the bad outweighs the good. I also do not think it is ludicrous to speculate that if her opponent was anyone more competent than Donald Trump, many of her more recent supporters would be more hesitant to give her their vote. So, two questions arise for me: the first, does she deserve this hatred? That is to say, should it really be the case that her bad outweighs her good? And, second, is this predicament a temporal one? That is to say, is she, to a certain extent, a victim of our modern form of media?</p><p>To begin, it seems ridiculous to hate Hillary Clinton. You can dislike her because of her policies or mistakes she has made during her career, but hate? She is not perfect, but her imperfections pale in comparison to those of, say, Woodrow Wilson. I can tell you with confidence that, after going through all the good and bad she has done, hatred is certainly not the valid emotion to feel. In many ways I do think there is a palpable sense of sexism behind the hateful sentiments. To merely dislike her, however, is much more reasonable. If you want to argue that she is a bad person, I will hear your argument. So, putting sexism aside, is it rational to rate her as a bad person?</p><p>Some of Hillary Clinton’s faults include the following — a historical connection to socioeconomic power players and the resulting implication that she is bought by banks and corporations, her flip-flopping on issues such as gay marriage, financial legislation, and drug or criminal policies, her strangely placed lies (like her claim that she landed in Bosnia under “sniper fire” in 1996), her robotic demeanor and apparent lack of personality, her handling of Benghazi, her e-mail leaks, and more. First, I want to briefly debunk some of these faults. Flip-flopping on issues such as gay marriage is an incredibly minor fault. Yes, she is an older person who probably grew up not believing in the legalization of gay marriage, and she stood by that conviction while her constituency largely agreed with her. Since then, she has come around, whether solely because of her constituency’s changed disposition or because of her own maturation. Either way, how can you say it is a bad thing that she went from being against gay marriage, to being for it? Is that not what we want to see from a politician? I personally think this is great, not a faulty “flip-flop.” Like Muhammad Ali or Malcolm X, not everyone is correct when they are young and their life’s journey leads them to a better understanding. In this case, I am proud that Hillary Clinton matured. Most of society has done the same along with her. I cannot blame her for this first point. I would also lump some of her and her husband’s past support for certain legislation in with this. Policies and views evolve over time. Showing the ability to adapt and listen to your constituency is important.</p><p>Her personality is not <em>bad</em> in a moral sense, but I do find it to be a fault. Her husband, Bill Clinton, and Barack Obama, are both famous for their charisma. Not everyone has this. Again, this is not so much <em>bad</em> as it is a fault. My only problem with it is that Mrs. Clinton tries so painfully hard to be hip and relate to young people. You’re an old white woman — it is perfectly normal for you to not relate to young people. Just show them that you will listen and take their perspective into account during policy making. Ultimately, I suppose this could contribute to a dislike of Mrs. Clinton, but I do not think it should be an indication that she is a bad person.</p><p>Her handling of Benghazi and the e-mail leaks are complicated issues that I do not what to get into in detail, but I do think it is fair to argue that it was, in some ways, a mistake, though again, I find it hard to make the conclusion that her actions would indicate she is a bad person. I suppose it’s possible to argue that the e-mail scandal indicates she has some evil ulterior motives, but that also seems like a stretch. Really, as you go through all of these faults, it is hard to rationalize them as anything more than mistakes, some of which have even been rectified. Is the spirit of politics not to be able to disagree with a politician’s ideas and policy without also concluding they are a bad person? So, why is it that enough of us conflate her imperfections with the idea that she is somehow bad?</p><p>Again, I want to try to discuss this issue without getting into sexism, racism, or any other clear bigoted bias. I believe our tendency to conflate imperfection with morality is present amongst all politicians, from Hillary Clinton, to Barack Obama, to John Boehner, to Mitt Romney. Discriminatory biases certainly do exacerbate this problem, but again, I want to simply discuss our modern trouble with imperfection.</p><p>The present environment is, more than ever before, an echo chamber full of hurried facts and opinions. When we view the news or go to our Twitter feeds, we often seek out people that broadly agree with us. We do not have the patience for hearing out anyone with dramatically different viewpoints. Instead, we cheerfully find as much bad information about Hillary Clinton as possible, shunning anything positive. We want to be right more than we want to know the truth. It feels good to be right and it feels good to tear at people who are considerably more successful and important than us. We gravitate toward the negative news, because this excites us. But, without the positive, our portraits of public figures become shadowy and depressing. Instead of seeing a whole person, their good and their bad and their imperfection, we more than ever have the ability to focus in on the bad, and that incomplete picture allows us to make the conclusion that this person must be bad, because how could a good person possibly have done all of these bad things?</p><p>But, we are all amalgamations of good and bad. If someone only knew the one or the other, the conclusion they would make about us would be incomplete. If I showed you a man and only told you he was rabid adulterer and heavy drinker, you may be inclined to think he was a bad person. But if you found out this same man was a brave leader of the civil rights movement, you would probably reconsider. People are complex, but today’s echo chamber allows for the suppression of the good and the intensification of the bad. There is a reason that the field of public relations has swelled to the point that our ultra exposed figures have battalions of PR soldiers analyzing every public move or statement. One misstep and years of hard and good work go out the window as that mistake reverberates from brain to brain, plastered on our TVs and magazines and social media.</p><p>Hillary Clinton is not any more or less perfect than any other presidential candidate in our nation’s history. But her errors and imperfections have been magnified more than ever before, and I imagine our candidates in 2020 will only have it worse. But, what if something remarkable happens? What if we are forced to contend with the contrast between our own imperfections and the impossible standards we ask our public figures to meet? Is it possible that we are currently living in the public relations sweet spot, or, more appropriately, sour spot, in which this phenomenon is strongest? Is it possible that in the future we actually become more understanding?</p><p><strong>We Live in Public</strong></p><p>One of the craziest things about our grandchildren is that they will be the first generation to truly know their grandparents. Right now, we only know our grandparents as old people. We do not know what they were like when they were younger, other than the little we glean from old blurry pictures or questionably accurate stories. But, our grandkids will be able to see us in our full glory. They will see us at our most mundane, our most proud, and our most disgusting. When they are 17 and doing the stupidest stuff they’ll ever do in their lives, they can look at us on the Internet doing the same.</p><p>Right now, we can sit on our high horse and criticize our public figures, safe in the knowledge that our mistakes and demons remain fairly well hidden — or at least that no one is looking for them. But, won’t we all be vulnerable one day? The little scandals that leak from our politicians and entertainers are blown up now, but what happens when today’s 12 year old eventually becomes president? He or she will have a whole life on the Internet, unlike our current politicians, many of whom were already too old to participate fully and authentically in Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, or any other form of social media. We already have scandals like Anthony Wiener’s sexting fiasco, but imagine if someone as exposed as a presidential candidate had multiple nude photos leaked? They would obviously get torn apart. But, what about the 10th instance of a presidential candidate having nude photos leaked? At some point, do we come to terms with the fact that this is part of life now? At what point is this no longer shocking or deserving of intense scrutiny and criticism?</p><p>Young, liberal voters are already less inclined to look down upon an uncovered picture or video of Barack Obama smoking marijuana. The subsequent generation will likely be even less bothered by such occurrences. When all the information is out there, when everyone’s good and bad are so easily available for anyone to see, then maybe it will be much more difficult to rush to judgment based on <em>one</em> incident. We will more easily have the whole picture available. Strangely, Donald Trump may provide a small lesson on this. He says so many ridiculous things at such a frequency that it is almost impossible for any of them to individually stick. He has made so many mistakes that we have trouble focusing on any single one of them. Instead of using one instance to make a rushed conclusion about his personality, we have enough instances to make a well-rounded and confident conclusion that he is probably a bad person.</p><p>If in the future everyone’s past mistakes and successes are nearly transparent, then maybe we will be able to make more comprehensive judgments and move beyond the pettiness, acknowledging that imperfection is inevitable. As any statistician knows, the more data you have, the more accurate your conclusion will be. Or maybe with all that data, we will still rely on questionable sources with ulterior motives who will filter all the good and bad in order to tell us what to care about and what to think, mostly showing us the bad, of course, and we will still fail to really know anyone as a whole person.</p><p><strong>If We Were All Angels</strong></p><p>It is no doubt easier to go about this whole business at the end of someone’s life. Their mistakes and accomplishments all part of the past, we can look at their life as a whole, and we can weigh the good and the bad, and we can determine if this person was good, bad, or, like most of us, a little bit of both. With the young, it is much more difficult because we know so little about their life. The nature of youth tells us that the little they have lived is likely filled with a greater density of mistakes than they will ever commit again. I fear that the way we handle these mistakes and the way we judge our public figures will make it so they will not be able to reach that judgment of old age. I fear they will be branded a villain too young, unable to claw their way out from that designation. When we scold the 20-year-old collegiate athlete for his behavior, we should not let that reflect upon who he is as a whole. When we rip apart the headstrong young politician for a past mistake, we should remember for whom and for what she fights.</p><p>Whether there is an afterlife, I do not know, and whether there is a God that judges you upon entrance to that afterlife, I also do not know. But if there is, I hope that wise being exercises better judgment than we do.</p><p>When here on earth, in the United States, we are judged by the legal system itself, there is a provision to ensure that no one — no matter how guilty, no matter how heinous the crime — is sentenced without the court knowing about the good stuff. Judge Rakoff said it poetically, “if ever a man is to receive credit for the good he has done, and his immediate misconduct assessed in the context of his overall life hitherto, it should be at the moment of his sentencing, when his very future hangs in the balance. This elementary principle of weighing the good with the bad, which is basic to all the great religious, moral philosophies, and systems of justice, was plainly part of what Congress had in mind when it directed courts to consider, as a necessary sentencing factor, ‘the history and characteristics of the defendant.’”</p><p>And so my hope is that we can all be a little bit more like Judge Rakoff at a sentencing. We can disagree on what is good and bad, on who is good and bad, on what good and bad even means, but at least in that disagreement we find some effort at comprehensive understanding. The only terror is in stumbling with unhindered confidence towards an ill informed and rushed judgment. Those we villainize today could very well be the heroes of tomorrow, and today’s heroes aren’t perfect, but that’s okay, because neither are we.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92d254dc564a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts from Chuck Klosterman’s Latest Book]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattryklin/thoughts-from-chuck-klostermans-latest-book-c98357450fec?source=rss-2f7643160ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c98357450fec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage-equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chuck-klosterman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matt Ryklin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Aug 2016 17:42:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-10T17:54:54.322Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I was fifteen I had ridiculous opinions. Of course, at the time I didn’t think they were ridiculous, I thought they were well deliberated, intelligent, and insightful. Everyone looks back with some feelings of disgust and amazement at how they behaved when they were younger, but the opinions I’m talking about weren’t only related to music, or fashion, or how to get girls. When I was fifteen I was of the opinion that we shouldn’t legalize gay marriage. Now, I couldn’t imagine holding this opinion, and I even look disdainfully upon those who do. How could you not legalize gay marriage? It has no effect on anyone except for the positive effect it has on people in love who want to be together. I can’t possibly imagine not being for the legalization of gay marriage. And yet nine years ago, I didn’t think it was necessary. This is where my head went when I first heard of Chuck Klosterman’s newest book.</p><p>I want to analyze fifteen-year-old Matt and figure out why he thought what he thought. First, and most simply, he had no contact with any gay people. I think this is really the most important point. In my high school of over 1200 students, there were maybe a handful of gay people, and they were all, to my knowledge, in the closet. There were whispers that maybe they were gay, but none of them were out and proud. I understand why. I don’t think it was necessarily an antagonistic environment, but it certainly wasn’t a welcoming one and I can’t imagine how horrible it would have felt to be gay and afraid to let your classmates know. It was not a friendly environment for gay people and I can only hope it has improved.</p><p>This lack of exposure led to two main problems for me as a would-be ally to the gay community. First, I had no way to understand the gay experience. Second, the plight of gay people was peripheral and irrelevant to me. It didn’t feel like a real problem. I think these two dilemmas arise in any situation in which someone experiences a lack of exposure to any other group. I was privileged enough to grow up in a town where my school was only about 50–60% white. My exposure to other ethnicities has been fundamental to my intellectual development. I am familiar with a variety of other cultures and I understand their experiences in America. I also have the benefit of having immigrant parents myself, and so it has always been easy to relate to non-traditional American ethnicities (by that I generally mean ethnicities of a non-Western European origin). Conversely, until college, gay people were totally unfamiliar to me. These conditions are what allowed my thought process to arrive at not supporting gay marriage.</p><p>The reason I was not in support of gay marriage, however, was not because of some hatred of gay people. I arrived to the conclusion through what I thought at the time to be impeccable logic, but I later learned is a traditional logical fallacy — the slippery slope. I subscribed to the belief that if we were to endorse gay marriage, then it would pave the way for perhaps supporting bestiality, prostitution, or any other number of things that we still hold to be taboo. Chuck Klosterman’s book comes into play now. Thinking about the past as if it were the present. As a young history buff, my rationale was rooted in the past. In the year 1900, I claimed, it would have been inconceivable to imagine a society in which gay marriage was legalized. Perhaps it would have even been as inconceivable as it sounds to us today to imagine a society in which a man can marry his goat. I claimed that as time went on, societal taboos would continually become destigmatized. At some point we would have to stop, right? We can’t allow a man to marry his goat, right? Well, of course not. But if you asked Matt born in 1867 about gay marriage, he probably would have said the same thing. Matt born in 1991 thought, at age fifteen, that gay marriage should be the stopping point in order to prevent future goat marriages.</p><p>It’s obvious that I was immature and wrong. I see that now, clearly. Since that age, I have experienced more and more of the world and it has opened my mind and refined my logic. It seems preposterous for gay marriage to be illegal. I don’t know anyone, save my 80-year-old Russian grandparents, opposed to gay marriage. While fifteen-year-old Matt may have arrived at the wrong conclusion, I think there may be some value in the logical process in which he engaged, and I don’t mean by a reassessment of the slippery slope. Klosterman’s book is all about trying to imagine the future. This is, as he states, an incredibly difficult process, because often the future is so unbelievably different than the present, that no one could have possibly predicted it. This is what fifteen-year-old Matt was getting at — if in the past we found gay marriage to be crazier than flying pigs, and now it’s legalized, what will be legalized in the future that we now think is crazier than those pigs?</p><p>Klosterman reckons with the idea that we could be modern day Aristotles and that in 1000 years people will laugh at how stupid we are, just as we are baffled Aristotle could have ever thought a rock doesn’t float on account of it’s <em>desire</em> to be on the ground. He chats with some very smart people who refute this idea. Neil Degrasse Tyson, in particular, asserts that since the year 1600, the scientific method has assured that any advancements we make in science are objectively true advancements and that we will not, one day, be Aristotle’d. Looking at science since 1600 would seem to prove Tyson correct, but of course everyone in Ancient Greece probably thought the same.</p><p>Bringing this back to societal taboos, I wonder now whether we are perhaps approaching a universal correctness that will not be undone, similar to the universal scientific correctness that Tyson maintains. That is to say, we will legalize gay marriage and guarantee human equality, but we will never allow a man to marry a goat. Maybe there is some agreed upon line beyond which society will never venture. In some ways, this seems like the natural culmination of a very old idea, perhaps begun in the time of Aristotle — the core pillar of democracy, that all men are equal. It has taken over two thousand years for this principle to near realization. Maybe we as a human race have innately agreed that this is the principle that should unite us, and the only reason we keep destigmatizing societal taboos or outcasts is because those disenfranchised people have good logical grounds to protest their exclusion from this core tenet. Their reasoning comes across as valid to enough of population that society decides to include them in the “all men are created equal” designation. Slowly, we begin to realize the phrase. And, perhaps when we do, it’s over. There are no man-goat relationships because that would breach the core value of equality. Animals are not humans. There is no slippery slope, or, rather, the slope is slippery, but we eventually get to the bottom of the hill, and there we can rest.</p><p>So, great — I think I’ve arrived at what appears to be an enduring theory of progress in relation to society’s acceptance or rejection of its members’ behavior. I’ve outwitted fifteen-year-old Matt and I think I am in a position where 90-year-old Matt won’t look back at 24-year-old Matt as an idiot (at least not in this regard). But, as Klosterman suggests — when you think you know something, you need to reconsider — the future is never what we expect. And so, the biggest conundrum of Chuck Klosterman’s theorizing is this reevaluation of <em>how</em> we should think. If we accept that it is nearly impossible to predict how our values will be seen in the future, that we could be “wrong”, then how do we defend anything with conviction? How can we hold tightly to any system of beliefs if that system is subjectively tied to the time in which we live, and could very well be deemed as “wrong”, reprehensible, or immoral in the future?</p><p>We could acknowledge this fact, but ignore it. The lack of any eternal objective moral code or values could resign us to simply fighting for the contemporary code. I don’t care that people living in the year 2540 look back at us as being bigoted for not letting a man love a goat. Right now I think it’s wrong so I will not allow it. But, how do we even decide what is contemporarily right? If it’s possible for someone’s ostracized beliefs to one day become the moral standard (and as with gay marriage, this process can occur within a couple decades, not centuries), then how can I with any certainty fight for what I see as right today?</p><p>We could take a look at one dichotomy — fighting for a progressive idea versus fighting for a conservative one. It would appear throughout history that fighting for something progressive is remembered more fondly. Fighting for civil rights, for gay marriage, for refugee assistance, for drug decriminalization — all of those who fought for these rights are now remembered fondly by our society at large. Conversely, all those fighting against these rights are perceived more and more as ignorant. This would suggest that perhaps we should just always be liberal, because society has tended to move in that direction, and so we will be looked upon favorably by our future generations.</p><p>I think that’s a pretty fair prediction — that future society will progressively appear more liberal to us in the present. For example, I think in 25 years our conception of gender and its fluidity will be remarkably different than today. Younger people tend to be more liberal and older people more conservative, and so as the older people die, society moves forward. Past liberals become modern conservatives and give birth to more liberal babies, who will one day become conservative relative to their society, too. But, again, this assumption is largely based on trends over the past few hundred years. It’s theoretically possible that conditions push society more conservatively. After all, Rome toggled back and forth between Emperor and Republic multiple times. Predicting the future to consistently be more liberal is still too tangential of a conclusion. We need to get closer to a core understanding of human nature, and perhaps that will help us predict.</p><p>Maybe just as Neil Degrasse Tyson believes we are moving towards an objective understanding of the known universe and the rules that govern it, we are also moving towards an objective understanding of humanity and the values we hold and are “meant” to hold. Or maybe humanity is and always will be confusing. Is “all men are created equal” really an objectively correct statement towards which we are hurdling at never before seen speeds? Or is it rooted in the same selfishness that has always governed human action. When the Founding Fathers of America came up with this liberty, were they seeking to help humanity? Or were they simply seeking to put in place a system that would prevent kings, because kings were bad for them, personally. This group of men was born into a powerful position, but their designation as Americans meant they could never reach the true upper crust of European power. They were always subservient to a king. There was no upward mobility in the system, so they could not acquire more power without usurping the system itself. They asserted that all men were created equal not because they really believed in its virtues — in “all men” — but because that designation and the support for it simultaneously lifted them and lowered the king. Through that statement, Jefferson, Adams, and Madison would eventually become president of a new nation, a position they could have never attained in the old system. “All men are created equal” was rhetoric used for the acquisition of power.</p><p>I doubt that the first political champions of voting rights for African Americans or women were suddenly awoken from their ignorance and spurned forth by their innate moral compasses. They probably saw a personal reward in these fights. They would win the black vote, guaranteeing them more power. And those opposed to the black vote were opposed as long as they thought the existence of the black vote would weaken their power and position. And so “all men are created equal” still functioned as rhetoric for power acquisition, disguised, as always, as a moral imperative.</p><p>Today, a part of the Republican Party’s platform is the installment of stricter voter ID laws. This, despite evidence to show that voter fraud is almost non-existent. The unspoken impetus for this is that, most likely, the people lacking ID would vote Democrat. It’s not really about voter fraud — it’s about winning elections. And would the Democrats be so opposed to these laws if these voters were not assumed to be theirs? We can’t know for sure, but I imagine they don’t want to lose elections either, and so they care. Again, the history of “all men are created equal” in America is a history of elections and power.</p><p>This brings me back to men and goats. While it’s possible that the inclusion of all people into our equal rights rhetoric will bring an end to the legalization of former taboos, I also fear the eternal quest for power will render morality timelessly subjective. If enough men want to marry their goats that it could sway an election, and those men have enough social justice allies, maybe a political party will jump on the opportunity. They will be attacked by the media and by the other political party — just look at Republican rhetoric about gay marriage — but history tells us taboos are only taboo until enough people tolerate it and it is dragged out into the public. Then a taboo becomes pride. When a cult gets big enough, it’s called a religion.</p><p>And for the most part, my morality and the morality of my era deem this progress to be good. Even if the motivation behind the political endorsement of new movements is shrouded in pragmatic selfishness, the result is good — more people have more rights, and less people are stigmatized for who they are. This is a good thing. We believe this to be progress, and we have been on this path for hundreds of years as more and more people are welcomed into society’s accepting arms. Perhaps the only wrong point of view is to be against this progress, even if we are talking about men and goats. Klosterman, in fact, covers the possibility that in the future our conception of intelligence changes and we come to believe animals have greater intelligence than us, possibly because of the way they process emotions. If we become that much of an animal loving and worshipping society, then why can’t a goat be in love with a man? And who is to say no one will see an advantage in pushing this idea towards general acceptance?</p><p>As Klosterman says, we have no way of really knowing these things. We cannot use our value system as a way of predicting the future, because values change dramatically across generations. However, I question whether we can use history to make some possibly timeless generalizations about humankind. Is it wrong to characterize human history as an endless quest for power? If we assume this is standard human behavior, then while it is still difficult to predict what the future will be like, we should be able to make some broad predictions based on this understanding. Or maybe humans stop becoming a power-seeking species. Maybe we all live in virtual reality chambers, pleased by endless goat pornstars, lavished by virtual Michelin Star chefs, floating in eternal pleasure and contentment, never to read a book again.</p><p>But, for now, I recommend reading Chuck Klosterman’s latest book — “But What If We’re Wrong — Thinking About The Present As If It Were The Past.” It will likely send you on your own personal adventure, as it did for me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c98357450fec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>