<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Matthew Sahagian on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Matthew Sahagian on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 22:29:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@mattsah/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No War But Class War]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/no-war-but-class-war-ef1844caa751?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef1844caa751</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[independence-day]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[property]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jul 2017 20:26:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-04T20:26:04.454Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It was brought to my attention recently that, contrary to earlier times in history marked by tribal and national war…</p><blockquote>…self-interest, via capitalism today, drives an entirely different motive now, not one of war and violence, but the idea of peace and exchange.</blockquote><p>In an <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2014/12/the_world_is_not_falling_apart_the_trend_lines_reveal_an_increasingly_peaceful.html">article from 2014</a>, Slate appears to agree. Homicides are down. Rape and sexual violence, down. Child abuse, down. Genocides and mass killings, down. By nearly every metric that one could think to imagine the world seems to be getting more and more peaceful. Even by contrast to the mid 1900s, the number of armed conflicts is also down with “battle deaths” seeming to be at a historic low.</p><p>But there’s a problem with this picture. Even if we concede that war and inter-personal violence was more common, more bloody, and more all encompassing in human history we’re still only talking about a particular form of violence.</p><p>Nowhere in Slate’s article do they mention, for example, the increasing number of police killings, or the number of premature deaths now caused by poisoned water, the indiscreet spraying of pesticides near schools. There’s no comparison of deaths by natural disasters whose increasing severity can be linked to climate change. And not a single death of a single migrant worker, fleeing for better opportunities and ultimately meeting their demise on their journey, was mentioned.</p><p>Such statistics are much harder to come by, not for the fact alone that the data is far more incomplete, but simply because these are not considered in the traditional notions of violence. Violence by these standards requires a perpetrator and when the perpetrator is “the system” we consider such deaths to be merely deaths of circumstance if not “natural.”</p><p>But these forms of violence, like other forms of violence, are in fact the product of human antagonisms with one another. Furthermore, even if such deaths are also as historic lows, the shift from individual human antagonisms as a cause of early death towards systemic human antagonisms is palpable for many members of the working class. There is a distinct difference between an inability to access clean drinking water because the means or knowledge to build the requisite infrastructure do not yet exist and the inability to access it because of a political decision to save costs to the city.</p><p>The latter is a form of political violence which comprises some measure of human agency, while the former is, in some regard an expression of our lack of agency, or at least our agency’s ability to master the conditions of our own material circumstances. The former can, thus, be blamed on ignorance, while the latter must be attributed to the positive knowledge of decision makers as to how their decisions will affect those for which they decide.</p><p>The inevitable shift from one form of violence to the other is not accidental. We do not suddenly find ourselves capable of producing the means of sustaining and promoting dignified human life with no ability to discern whether or not we should. Rather, with each progressive step in our capacities, decisions are made with respect to where those developments in knowledge, technology and materials will be invested. In a capitalist system where exchange dominates as a mode of production, the investment of resources into increasingly grander means of production is tempting.</p><p>In a market of limited supply, if I can produce faster than my competitor, I can sell more than my competitor by getting to market faster. If I can produce more overall, then I can sell more overall. The more I sell, the more I can invest. The more I can invest, the faster I can produce; the more I can produce. This once revolutionary mode of production is, thus, responsible for the massive increase in overall material wealth which modern capitalism has brought to the world. It has, in its progressive phase, lifted millions of people out of general poverty and created the means by which we are, in fact, capable of sustaining dignified human life for all.</p><p>But once this mode of production has begun, it becomes increasingly difficult to stop and the production of goods to be sold on a market, although inadvertently as a means of fulfilling the needs and wants of the many is not executed towards those ends, but towards the expansion of production itself. A failure to sell your goods is not the success of having provided all those who need/want them with them, but the failure of the system itself — a failure to expand production. It is a contraction, a recession, a “market correction,” a loss of value, not in the concrete in terms of available goods/resources, but in the abstract in terms of profit realization.</p><p>So when this mode of production has succeeded in its capacity to create all the means of dignified human life, it continues on by finding new ways to expand value in the abstract. Perhaps it is at first by trying to cheat the customer here or there, give them a bit less for the same amount and hope they don’t notice. When they do, then cheat the worker, give them a bit less and take from them the same amount (maybe more) and hope they don’t notice. When they too notice, appeal to the politicians and to the state for intervention. If you do not gut consumer and workers rights you will make my business impossible. We will take all our money, resources, technology, and flee. We will lay off thousands, hundreds of thousands, maybe millions. Your society will return to the days of strife and violence which preceded our rise.</p><p>So in, the violence of general poverty is converted to the poverty of general violence. It is not that the state intends to personally poison you with lead or drown you in a flood, but they must do so to save cost, to give tax breaks, to pay for the police to patrol your neighborhood as your wages go down and crimes of desperation increase, to beat China in GDP growth, to fund the bombing of people in Syria and Yemen, to secure a trade deal or a new oil pipeline — to expand production.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef1844caa751" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Against Fascism; Against Capitalism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/against-fascism-against-capitalism-37e8957095d3?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37e8957095d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Feb 2017 00:25:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-06T00:25:43.174Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have some bad news for <a href="https://medium.com/u/c8052f58c241">Jake Fuentes</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/u/5a42a52f9a39">Yonatan Zunger</a>. Your premise is flawed. Insofar as the media is the fourth estate, whatever checks and balances you believe to have been instituted here in the U.S. have long, if not always, been subject to the unified ruling of the fifth estate. The only distinction between then and now is that the fifth estate has entered full on crisis mode.</p><p>Unlike the fabled “constitutional crisis,” better known as the catch phrase of the month, the crisis of the fifth estate is <em>real</em>. By this, I do not mean to imply that the effects of the policy du jour are somehow <em>unreal</em> for the millions of people who do and will suffer from them. No, these are real problems with severe consequences. But there is certainly something unreal, or at least surreal, about asking people who are facing such terror to reflect on the nature of a 200+ year old document written by wealthy white men.</p><p>But this is exactly what <a href="https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/trial-balloon-for-a-coup-e024990891d5#.5lx7gktg4">both</a> <a href="https://medium.com/@jakefuentes/the-immigration-ban-is-a-headfake-and-were-falling-for-it-b8910e78f0c5#.ihrbd2c2g">articles</a> do in one way or another.</p><p>That these calls are now being forwarded by a guy whose tagline includes “Startups” and another whose includes “Forgotten History” can probably be best explained by Marx’s old addage:</p><blockquote><em>History repeats itself, first as tragedy, </em>second as farce<em>.</em></blockquote><p>Of course, it seems pretty clear even from Marx’s context that such farce need not be any less tragic. Unlike Marx, I lack the discipline and time to devote myself to a more concrete analysis. That is, I will not so readily “demonstrate how the class struggle in [the United States] created circumstances and relationships that made it possible for a grotesque mediocrity to play a hero’s part.” Needless to say, I do think such a part is being played and by no less grotesque a mediocrity.</p><p>In this story, however, we are not constrained to such a single all-important (least-important) character. Rather, if it is a character at all, it is at least not the character of a single individual. Instead, we are treated to a host of individuals playing the character of the self-aggrandizing fourth estate, who, much like the first, second, and third estate seek to mask their increasing impotence by boasting of greater and greater political powers.</p><p>From where does this impotence arise?</p><p>Contrary to what Google may tell you, the fifth estate is not a poorly rated thriller about the trials and tribulations of civilian intelligence operations working diligently to expose state secrets. It is none other than the institution of capital. In contrast to other branches of government which are, in fact, wholly owned subsidiaries of capital, its laws arise not out of the conscious deliberations of its masters, but from its own historic material development.</p><p>Capital, like our constitution and contingent political forms, is riddled with contradictions. But this is not because we seek to limit its excesses and believe that through a system of checks and balances it should be prevented from doing us any harm. Instead, these contradictions are inherent to it. It cannot exist without them.</p><p>One such contradiction is found in the dual nature of the commodity. Things which are produced for exchange have both a use-value and an exchange value. But wherein, through technological development, we find ourselves capable of producing more and more use-value, the increased productive capacity as expressed through a supply boom correlates to a reduction in the value of the thing(s). The production of more with less, thus, gives rise to a bust. There is “too much value.” This reveals itself through time and market as crises of overproduction for which there is little recourse but to destroy some portion of the value created, either in the abstract through plunging stock prices or concretely through the abandon or willful destruction of some quantity of the goods produced.</p><p>In the worst instances of such crisis, one can imagine a culmination of the various sub-crises, not merely the traditional overproduction of mechanical productive forces and consumer goods, but also the overproduction of another commodity: <strong>human labor power</strong>.</p><p>Herein the full brutality of capitalism is unveiled for the world to see. No longer capable of sustaining the mass of workers which the system has brought fourth, it reacts accordingly. As expressed in <a href="http://www.international-communist-party.org/CommLeft/CL06.htm">Communist Left №6</a>:</p><blockquote>In a regime permitting only capitalist solutions, starvation is the tragic answer, and Auschwitz was simply a case of organising the death of the starving in a very methodical way: it was the solution arrived at after the concentration in ghettoes caused “law and order” and “logistical” problems.</blockquote><p>The failure of bourgeois press to correctly discern and report on such a problem should be of little surprise. Likewise, it should not be shocking that the vast waves of new media contributors are steeped in idealized notions of political struggles between the three recognized branches of government. Rather than address what is at the root of the current political situation, we are told instead that we are “falling for a headfake,” and that we should “pay journalists to watch for the head fake.”</p><p>In this case, the “headfake” being referred to is Trump’s muslim ban which, according to our intrepid <a href="https://medium.com/u/c8052f58c241">Jake Fuentes,</a> is merely a distraction for the “shakeup” in the National Security Council. The solution (aside from paying journalists) is to focus our popular attention “less on whether we agree with what the government is doing, and more on whether the system of checks and balances we have in place is working.” That is, we should focus on re-establishing the traditional and accepted political institutions in order that we may defend against the new and emerging ones.</p><p>But what are political institutions, if not the means by which one section of society, the ruling class, mediates the conflicts and antagonisms with which that society is confronted? And from where do such conflicts and antagonisms arise if not from the actual circumstances of our lives, <em>i.e. our increasing inability to acquire the means of subsistence</em>? Whether those means have become limited due to drought brought on by climate change, drone bombs sent to decimate our infrastructure, or merely our inability to afford our higher education and find a job, is largely inconsequential. The increasing severity of such antagonisms always demands the increasing severity of political solutions.</p><p>As the overproduction of human labor power reveals itself to a system unwilling and incapable of sustaining it, the needs of all competing capitalist nations will trend towards increased protectionism, added restrictions on migrant labor, more severe exploitation of local labor, expansion of austerity, and more risky and provocative diplomatic relations with one another. Where such trends are bucked by popular resistance, we should fully expect to see deadlier police repression and state violence. The consolidation of political power is but one integral component of the political system’s capacity to respond to this underlying phenomenon with the efficiency needed to restore capitalism.</p><p>The role of race, religion, sex, gender, orientation, national origin, etc, as a mechanism for dividing workers and making the general situation more palatable for some, or, indeed, by getting some to actively support it, will persist. Furthermore, just as each nation has its own particular cultural and political history surrounding these divisions, so too will each nation have its own particular manifestations of fascist movements. This is not a failure of this or that government’s political checks and balances. It is a failure, again, of the capitalist mode of production.</p><p>All political systems will need to assimilate or risk external interventions.</p><p>But, if paying journalists and honoring the faces on Mt. Rushmore can’t save us, then what will? Share your ideas in the comments below.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37e8957095d3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to Labor Vouchers: Basic Reproduction and Distribution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/introduction-to-labor-vouchers-basic-reproduction-and-distribution-753a4405505a?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/753a4405505a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Jan 2017 20:53:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-21T20:53:59.336Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Basic Reproduction</h3><p>Each establishment produces in accordance with a standard unit, e.g. tons of iron ore, pounds of apples, number of cars, etc. The reproduction time of a single unit is comprised of the following equation:</p><pre>[(p + c) + l] / Up = Tr</pre><p>Wherein:</p><pre>p  = Fixed Means of Production (machine)<br>c  = Circulating Means of Production (raw materials)<br>l  = Labor<br>Up = Units Produced<br>Tr = Time of Reproduction (Per Unit)</pre><p>As a simple example, we will use a hypothetical economy wherein corn is the only product. We will begin with a rough estimate for the total time required to produce an bushel of corn, 1 hour. This estimate will trend towards the actual reproduction time of corn with each iteration based on the labor required to produce a new quantity.</p><p>In this example p = 0 as there are no fixed means of production, all labor is performed manually.</p><p>We will begin by using 3 bushels of seed corn, and assuming the labor required to plant, tend, and harvest the output is 40 hours, and that the total Units Produced is 25.</p><pre>[(0 + 3) + 40] / 25 = 1.72</pre><p>Obviously our estimate was off. Let’s plant 3 more.</p><pre>[(0 + 5.16) + 40] / 25 = 1.8064</pre><p>Again…</p><pre>[(0 + 5.4192) + 40] / 25 = 1.816768</pre><p>Again…</p><pre>[(0 + 5.450304) + 40] / 25 = 1.81801216</pre><p>Again…</p><pre>[(0 + 5.45403648) + 40] / 25 = 1.818161459</pre><p>Repeat a few more times and if it wasn’t clear already, our limit is 1.818181~</p><p>In this hypothetical economy with only one producer, 1.818181~ hours is now the reproduction time of a bushel of corn. If our laborer is issued labor vouchers in accordance with their total time laboring, they receive 40 labor vouchers, which means, as one expect they can acquire 40 / 1.818181~ bushels of corn… or… 22bushels.</p><p>You can see from this simple example how the reproduction costs are factored into the output available for individual consumption.</p><p>What happens if the birds get hungry though? Let’s say they eat 5 bushels worth of corn, thereby reducing the total output to 20 bushels.</p><pre>[(0 + 5.454545) + 40] / 20 = 2.272727~ / bushel</pre><p>But now there’s a problem! 40 / 2.27272727 = 17.6 – which only leaves 2.4 bushels left over for reproduction. Note that we still account for 40 hours of labor, based on the fact that even the bird-eaten corn would have to be cleared during harvest. So how do we solve for this?</p><p>One method is to ensure that we account for current reproduction time in the used up raw materials. So in this case, since we used 3 bushels of corn and 1 bushel of corn now requires 2.272727~ hours to reproduce, then our actual reproduction cost of c is now 6.818181, but this means that our laborer can no longer be issued40 hours of vouchers, or else we must compound the the reproduction time such that the actual reproduction time of corn is:</p><pre>[(0 + (2.272727 * 3)) + 40] / 20 = 2.340909~ / bushel</pre><p>But the reasoning for this is rather simple. We have intertwined the production and distribution. In an attempt to ensure that our laborer is always issued 1 voucher for every 1 hour worked, we have confused the two.</p><p>Is there then a simpler solution?</p><p>Because the same number of hours producing less output constitutes an increase in the <em>Time of Reproduction (per unit)</em>, we can just as easily say that the same number of hours must constitute less of a share of the <em>Total Social Product</em>.</p><p>In this case, the <em>Total Social Product</em> available for consumption is 20 * 2.272727, or our original 40 + 5.454545 hours. Instead of then compounding the <em>Time of Reproduction (per unit)</em>, we could instead subtract the requisite hours to reproduce c – or in the case of a more complex example (p + c) – as a component of distribution.</p><p>See: <a href="https://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/07.htm">https://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/07.htm</a></p><blockquote><em>The following principles then apply to the distribution of TSP: each individual economic establishment, whether it be of the productive type or of the GSU type, at first withdraws from TSP as much p as has been calculated for it in its production budget. As soon as this has been carried out for all economic establishments, they have replaced once again their consumption of p, and therewith p has been distributed in a fully correct proportion. Proceeding further, each economic establishment withdraws from TSP as much c as has been computed for it in its production budget. As soon as this has been carried out for all industrial or other establishments, then c also has been distributed in a correct proportion and has been returned to the total system of production.</em></blockquote><p>That is, since we must redistribute 3 bushels of corn to the next production cycle, there remains 3 * 2.272727 labor hours which are not available for individual consumption. As such, the total number of labor vouchers that can be issued <strong>is not</strong> 40, but 45.454545 - 6.818181 or 38.6354.</p><p>Since we have already accounted for (p + c) in distribution, we need now only account for l. The ratio of 40 / 38.6354 is our <em>Factor for Individual Consumption</em>. In this case 0.965885 or 96.5885%.</p><p>Let us now consider that 1 hour of labor does not constitute 1 labor voucher, but instead, 1 share in the <em>Total Social Product</em> available for individual consumption. If our <em>Factor for Individual Consumption</em> is 0.965885, then in this final instance our laborer receives 40 * 0.965885 or 38.6354 labor vouchers. At 2.272727 per bushel of corn, wherein 3 are redistributed for the reproduction of corn, we find the final component in our equality: 38.6354 / 2.272727 = 16.99957804 or the remaining 17 bushels from our last output of 20.</p><p>This is not to say that all work is yet considered equal. That is, were we to introduce 2 workers who both worked 20 hours, it may be determined amongst themselves that one worker’s labor is worth more than the other. As such, each individual worker’s <em>Rate of Contribution</em> may differ. Where one worker is afforded 1.1 share in the<em>Total Social Product</em> for individual consumption, the other may only be afforded 0.9. As such they would receive 1.1 * 20 * 0.965885 and0.9 * 20 * 0.965885, or 21.24947 and 17.38593 respectively.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=753a4405505a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[CalExit: Same Old Nationalism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/calexit-same-old-nationalism-2a49fa620ab8?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a49fa620ab8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[communism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nationalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Jan 2017 06:06:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-28T15:19:27.235Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If one were to score and order all the ideological enemies which stood in the way of workers’ self-emancipation by a ratio of the damage they caused to the subtlety of their deployment, few, if any, of those enemies would even come remotely close to the enemy of nationalism. It should then be of little surprise in this time of heightened class struggle to see new expressions of nationalism arise from the depths of bourgeois intellectualism. At a time when the U.S. has succumb to direct political control by members (not just representatives) of the ruling elite, the potential for the development of a new left working-class opposition is at the highest it has been in decades. In the past year alone, we have seen three major developments which should lead us in the general direction of cautious optimism.</p><p>Firstly, millions of young people received their introduction to politics from an aging independent Senator prone to defending socialism (albeit a concept of socialism which differs from modern state capitalism in little more than name). Secondly, and closely related, was the complete and utter disillusion of the Democratic party, the historic “working man’s party,” as a mechanism for advancing workers’ interests. Third, and finally, was the rise in national visibility of victorious movements defending and expanding the existing gains of the American working class (Fight for 15, Strengthen Social Security Coalition, etc).</p><p>This, of course, is not to say that things are good. The danger of the Trump presidency looms large over the heads of working immigrant families, low-wage workers, retired seniors, and women, for whom the right to choose is an essential component of their economic equality. As a result, what appears at first glance to be chaotic despotism ushered in by the victorious Republican party, the liberal defense wing of the capitalist class have taken it upon themselves to protect the status quo against all enemies, both foreign and domestic. Trump threatens so openly to strip the thick layers of veneer so delicately applied by his predecessors to cover up the stains of capitalism that he leaves little room for subtlety. That he is one of their own is of little concern — he has given rise to an opposition which must be thwarted at all costs.</p><p>Enter, Yes California.</p><blockquote>In our view, the United States of America represents so many things that conflict with <strong>Californian values</strong>, and our continued statehood means California will continue subsidizing the other states to our own detriment, and to the detriment of our children.</blockquote><p>What are these “California values” of which they speak?</p><p>Are these the values of private property, wage labor, and “democracy?” Are these the same values which enable millionaire mansions to dot the Hollywood Hills while homelessness and poverty fills the banks of Skid Row? Perhaps they are the values that have enabled the mass poisoning of school children by dangerous pesticides in the Salinas valley for years, possibly decades? Or maybe they are the values which killed Alex Nieto, Mario Woods, and Jessica Williams in one of the most “progressive” cities in the United States.</p><p>And what is the cause of these “values?”</p><blockquote>Although charity is part of our culture, when you consider that California’s infrastructure is falling apart, our public schools are ranked among the worst in the entire country, we have the highest number of homeless persons living without shelter and other basic necessities, poverty rates remain high, income inequality continues to expand, and we must often borrow money from the future to provide services for today, <strong>now is not the time for charity</strong>.</blockquote><p>But of course, it is our charity! For those that stand in disbelief of the notion that our <em>charity</em> is the cause of all our homelessness, environmental racism, and the continuous murder of black and brown people by state officials, all will be answered soon. Alas, it is not our charity to ourselves which is the issue, but our charity to the rest of the country. We have given so much to the rest of the United States that we cannot help but to discard the mentally ill, poison brown people, and fill black bodies with lead in our streets.</p><p>Like the abused spouse, we give too much and expect too little all while suffering at the hand of our beneficiary.</p><p>It’s time to leave we are told.</p><blockquote>However, this independence referendum is about more than California subsidizing other states of this country. <strong>It is about the right to self-determination and the concept of voluntary association</strong>, both of which are supported by constitutional and international law.</blockquote><p>We are asked to believe in the right to <em>self-determination</em>. But where is this right for the working class? We are not a nation, merely a majority oppressed among all nations. This self-determination is not our self-determination. It is, instead, the concept of <em>voluntary association</em>, for nations, wherein men and women are daily forced to sell their labor power or risk starvation, homelessness, and jail. It is the voluntary association of a particular form of our oppressor. The voluntary association to oppress.</p><p>Perhaps though we are mistaken:</p><blockquote>It is about California taking its place in the world, standing as an equal among nations. We believe in two fundamental truths: (1) California exerts a positive influence on the rest of the world, and (2) <strong>California could do more good as an independent country than it is able to do as a just a U.S. state.</strong></blockquote><p>Inevitably we are informed that in order to secure our rights, we must first secure the rights of the nation. The rights of nations, we are assured, is more important, or at least a prerequisite for the rights of <em>all</em> humans.</p><p>But when has the rights of nations ever secured the rights of <em>all</em> humans? Certainly the founding of the United States secured some rights for some of its inhabitants, did it not? Of course we see that it did! It secured first and foremost the right to property, the right to enrich one’s self through the enslavement of others, the right to genocide native peoples, the right of rich white men to their hard coming, hard fought, hard won <em>self-determination!</em></p><p>Rosa Luxemburg wrote in 1909 on The National Question:</p><blockquote>If we recognize the right of each nation to self-determination, it is obviously a logical conclusion that we must condemn every attempt to place one nation over another, or for one nation to force upon another any form of national existence. However, the duty of the class party of the proletariat to protest and resist national oppression arises not from any special “right of nations,” just as, for example, its striving for the social and political equality of sexes does not at all result from any special “rights of women” which the movement of bourgeois emancipationists refers to. This duty arises solely from the general opposition to the class regime and to every form of social inequality and social domination, in a word, from the basic position of socialism.</blockquote><p>What then should be the response of those whose <strong><em>duty arises solely from the general opposition to the class regime and to every form of social inequality</em></strong><em>?</em></p><p>Struggles for national emancipation have long been more than distractions for the international working class. They are consciously divisive mechanism which pin worker against worker arguing instead that we should join with our oppressors for the sake of “our nation.” They are a means by which to secure anew the right to oppress by some disaffected subsection of the ruling class. Where Trump vows to remove the veil, organizations like Yes California swiftly move to place it back on the heads of disillusioned workers, guaranteeing a better life and a more promising future if we would just unite, class aside, for our common national interest. We have no such common interest with our oppressors.</p><p>In order to combat this we must resist the urge to see our struggle as one with the forces of national self-determination. We must instead proclaim our continued and unified opposition to the ruling class of all nations and wannabe nations alike. Where capital moves freely across their borders, we do not. Nationalism in all its forms is not the struggle of the working class, but the struggle against the working class as a class united, a class capable of achieving its own self-determination independent of this or that national allegiance. Nationalism is the struggle for the self-determination of capital.</p><p>We, the working class, and those who stand with us must stand firm. We are against national interests; against every form of social inequality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a49fa620ab8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To-Do List for Donald Trump]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/to-do-list-for-donald-trump-c773f824ffbc?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c773f824ffbc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Nov 2016 02:28:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-10T02:31:49.853Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dear Mr. President-elect,</p><p>Per a recent article in the Washington Times, you were quoted as saying the following:</p><blockquote>I’m still waiting for the democrats ‘to do list.’ Any democrat, just tweet me… yet I’m only getting hate from the left…</blockquote><p>While I’m not a Democrat, I am on the left so if you would indulge me for a moment, I’d like to share with you some of the ideas that I’ve supported throughout this election cycle. These are ideas which I think will benefit our country and the world as a whole. Admittedly, they are ideas you may strongly disagree with for a number of reasons, not to least of which I believe, is because I’m under no illusion as to your “independence” from the vast system of wealth which currently underlies our political system.</p><p>Whatever may be said of your support (or lack thereof) from many establishment Republicans and the traditional corridors of wealth which prop up their political clout, I see no reason to distance your own personal financial circumstance from your victory. The sad reality is that although you have no prior political experience, the ability of millions of working class Americans to achieve what you have achieved is non-existent. That is to say, even if I were to grant you the loftiest of intentions, an impeccable work ethic, and an impervious integrity, there are quite literally millions of hard-working American people for whom any equivalent ascent to political power would remain impossible. A 60-year old African American seamstress who labored her entire life with honor and integrity to help those around her could never do what you have done this election cycle.</p><p>To what we should attribute this reality is debatable, but that this is the reality is not something which I believe even you would contest. Not only are such people cut out of that political process due to the necessity of their laboring, but no matter how sound, well-formed, or even supported their ideas may be, there is no platform large enough for them to introduce themselves to the world that could compete with the attention and access your wealth would provide you.</p><p>Worse, were I to concede still that such a person could, starting from a young age, build their fame and fortune equivalent to your own in order that they could achieve such a feat, the problem would remain. Even a totally self-made individual is still a “made” individual and what it means to be “made” in this society is of a very particular nature. As such, there is no evidence to support that anyone could ever be simultaneously working class and a viable presidential candidate.</p><p>With this in mind, what I offer you is a simple to-do list from a working class perspective (albeit still a better off sector of the working class than most). In addition to the concise version of this list, I will aim, in future articles to expand on my reasoning for each so please keep your eyes peeled for my tweets:</p><ul><li>Drastically reduce budgetary and discretionary defense spending on military expansion and interventionism around the world while expanding that portion of which goes towards making good on our promise to our vets.</li><li>Cut funding and especially military aid to foreign state actors which violate international law and basic human rights. Redirect said funds to NGOs and non-profits which provide aid and relief directly to civilian populations, especially those that help build infrastructure.</li><li>Work to develop and fund programs of community policing that grow out of the communities themselves and include civilian oversight of traditional police with the ability to hire and fire.</li><li>Make your litmus tests for Supreme Court nominees that they will not overturn Roe v. Wade and will overturn Citizens United.</li><li>Work with doctors and nurses organizations to create a universal healthcare system that prioritizes preventative care and access to medication by rapidly expanding community clinics and pediatrics centers.</li><li>Re-invest heavily in infrastructure, education (public Pre-K - College), and assistance services for disabled, unemployed, and homeless people.</li><li>Provide incentives to states which initiate state-bonded green/renewable energy programs that convert state and local infrastructure (schools, offices, transportation, etc) to renewable energy solutions.</li></ul><p>While I know that most (if not all) of these suggestions will be met with various criticisms and attempts to discredit their viability, I would strongly encourage you to look into the long term savings and benefits. I know you believe that we should have a strong military, well-funded/trained police departments, and overall less reliance on the federal government. However, I would encourage you to think of ways in which these ideas can be implemented that do not conflict:</p><ul><li>A smarter and leaner military with less waste, fraud, and abuse instead of one which is predominately designed to increase the wealth of defense contractors.</li><li>Police departments that work with their community and as an extension of it (complimenting rather than antagonizing) and therefore are wilfully supported by their community and taxpayers.</li><li>Focus on helping communities succeed and gain more dignity thereby increasing federal independence rather than dependence longterm. Work more with small business and public resources which the community takes ownership over rather than through large businesses and faceless corporations which feel alien (applies to healthcare clinics, energy independence, and public schooling/pre-k).</li></ul><p>Many of these programs will, of course, cost money, and while I don’t emphasize deficit spending or the national debt as serious concern (we always seem to have money for bailouts and wars afterall), it is, in my opinion, part of the hard work of governance and public service to resolve that fundamental contradiction.</p><p>If you can, as you say, consistently deliver under-budget and ahead of schedule while still maintaining quality, service, and availability, then I suspect this list will present little challenge to you or our long-term solvency.</p><p>Thanks for reading.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c773f824ffbc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sorry Bernie, Hillary’s “Shift” on College Is Not Your Doing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/sorry-bernie-hillarys-shift-on-college-is-not-your-doing-186bc8443242?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/186bc8443242</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jill-stein]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Jul 2016 20:39:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-06T20:49:37.447Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The online Sanders’ communities are abuzz. Apparently Hillary has shifted her position on tuition-free college to the left. According to most accounts from Bernie supporters, this is a sign of some victory for a slowly fading Sanders campaign. Of course, when asked to explain how Sanders was able to achieve this victory so late in the game, we get little more than faulty reasoning padded by long silences.</p><p>Hillary’s shift is <strong>not</strong> because of Bernie Sanders. It’s because of Jill Stein.</p><p>While it is true that Bernie supports tuition-free public college, Jill goes a step further. Namely, Jill is pushing for a complete bailout for the millions of indebted college students around this country.</p><p>More important, Jill has crafted what may amount to the strongest possible messaging on this issue. Rather than framing this simply as a means to address the changing technological vs. jobs landscape, Jill has <em>rightly</em> compared her plan to the trillion dollar bailout of Wall Street. Given Hillary’s Wall Street ties, the political potency of this comparison should not be underestimated.</p><p>Surely though, Jill is not the only person who has called for cancellation of student debt, right? And even if Bernie didn’t address the debt crisis as strongly, or have the same strength in messaging surrounding free college, why should we attribute this shift to Jill? How could she possibly have more sway over Hillary and the Democratic party than Bernie?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FlM2RaFUgyKQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DlM2RaFUgyKQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FlM2RaFUgyKQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/403c1ba2e86423530881838396f8ae43/href">https://medium.com/media/403c1ba2e86423530881838396f8ae43/href</a></iframe><h4>Bernie Is No Longer a Contender</h4><p>The fact that this announcement was made just following the FBI’s decision not to recommend indictment is not insignificant. The FBI was, if you will, Bernie’s last serious hope at capturing the Democratic nomination. So while Bernie can continue to try and take over the Democratic party machinery from the bottom up, the simple fact is that <strong>the only significant threat remaining to a Hillary Clinton presidency is a third-party “spoiler.”</strong></p><p>Assuming <em>Brand New Congress </em>has any legs to begin with, they will not represent any serious threat to the Democratic establishment until 2018. The platform drafting committee was successfully railroaded on all but the most insignificant of concerns. Debbie Wasserman Schultz was internally decommissioned weeks ago. And lastly, even some of those progressives which Sanders’ helped to promote <a href="http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/russ-feingold-endorses-hillary-clinton-says-she-s-ready-to/article_d8c3f885-b5f7-5c34-8858-b15c6700b402.html">have taken to endorsing</a> Madam Secretary.</p><p>While it may be the case that Bernie has paved the way for someone like Jill Stein to begin getting more of the media attention she deserves, any future concessions that Hillary or the Democratic party as a whole make to Bernie supporters are predicated on the serious threat posed by her candidacy. This is why the concession was <em>what</em> it was. This is why the concession was <em>when</em> it was.</p><p>The only questions that remain is whether or not Bernie recognizes this fact and, if so, what is he going to do about it? If Bernie is interested in continuing the political revolution he set out to spark, he will have to realize that his power doesn’t lie <em>within</em> the Democratic party, but outside of it. More, he’ll have to act on that realization.</p><p>See you in Philly.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=186bc8443242" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Case for an Independent Bernie]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/the-case-for-an-independent-bernie-36a4d2fde048?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36a4d2fde048</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Jun 2016 05:10:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-19T07:18:05.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Today marked the first day of signature gathering for a letter compiled by our local grassroots organization urging Bernie Sanders to commit to three simple positions.</p><ol><li>Do not concede the Democratic Presidential nomination.</li><li>Continue to disavow, not endorse, Hillary Clinton.</li><li>Immediately begin laying the groundwork for an independent or third party run.</li></ol><p>As you can imagine we were met with very mixed results. While overall the letter was met with a 50/50 positive vs. negative response, there are two other benefits which were already derived from our efforts. The first of these is our ability to seriously talk about issues concerning the “two-party system” and the ongoing failure of our democracy to produce the positive changes which are needed at this historical juncture. The second benefit is the capacity to assess where the general population is at politically, but why.</p><h4>Political Fearmongering and the Continuation of the Status Quo</h4><p>Among many of those who were concerned with the possible outcome of pushing Bernie to make an independent run, the layman prophets of the Santa Clara Farmer’s Market were out in full force. Not only are they able to predict that both presumed nominees and their future campaigns will succeed in their respective corners of the political market, but they are also able to predict the precise outcome of a Bernie Sanders run.</p><p>Spoiler alert: Trump wins.</p><p>Interestingly, there was one individual who was concerned that an independent run by Bernie would guarantee Hillary the White House. Despite the seemingly contradictory prophecy, only the name of the inevitable winner had changed. The overall message, undoubtedly revealed to this and all such individuals, remained the same.</p><p>The message:</p><blockquote><em>We can’t allow that to happen. Allowing X to become president is not only overtly dangerous, it may very well, in fact, result in the collapse of the United States and the end of the world. At the very least we will lose all semblance of freedom and democracy.</em></blockquote><p>This perennial argument is seemingly not dependent on the specific major party candidate or their potential spoilers. The real irony is that all while decrying the threat of a third-party candidate, the same freedom and democracy they say we risk undergoes continuous attacks.</p><p>When “a vote for Nader is a vote for Bush,” there is no impetus to seriously consider, investigate, or inevitably fix the clear cases of voter suppression, broken electoral systems, and outright fraud. Instead we are assured that we know why Gore lost. We had <strong>too many</strong> choices! We had <strong>too much </strong>freedom!</p><p>In short, we are told that Gore lost because we dared to practice democracy for a single election cycle.</p><p>As a prerequisite to this, any serious attempt to fix the actual problems in our democratic institutions, is necessarily a distraction from the real goal of protecting our freedom and democracy by not electing “the other.” We’re told we can always address those things later. Right now, we just need to unify and win this one, else we may lose our democracy altogether!</p><h4>The Benefits of Limited Democratic Forms</h4><p>Of course no system, no matter how terrible, is not without its benefits. But benefits are never without recipients. And benefits to all are no benefit at all. So who benefits?</p><p>The so-called “two-party system,” which “we have” and “can’t fix, so we have to make a choice,” definitely has its benefits. For Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump (currently), but more broadly for the two parties that constitute that “system,” those benefits are obvious.</p><p>In that system, you don’t have to be an excellent choice for president, you need merely be better than your opponent. More, you don’t even need to adequately make a case <strong>in favor</strong> of you and your policies, merely to make a case <strong>against </strong>your opponent’s. Indeed, it’s best if we don’t talk about policies at all very much. That might actually require us to commit to something. We can, instead, focus largely on the individual character which is preferable for a number of reasons, not the least of which is that it affords us the most speculation about how horrible their presidency will be.</p><p>In an effective “two-party system,” wherein the phrase itself justifies its own perpetuation, one does not need any sort of plurality to become the leader of the “free” world. Quite the contrary, the more people you can keep out of the system, the more likely you are to win. Although Bernie often makes this point as a criticism of Republicans only, recent events have shown this truism clearly extends to the Democrats too. The only problem was is that Bernie forgot he wasn’t a Democrat, or at the very least, he forgot he wasn’t as much of a Democrat as his opponent.</p><p>Again, we are faced with a condition wherein the incentive for change is conveniently suppressed by the most basic assumptions of our electoral process. If it will always be a fight between Democrats and Republicans then both parties have a vested interest in exclusion. They simply don’t need to convince as many people to be afraid of the alternative.</p><h4>How Do We Regain a More Worthy Democracy?</h4><p>Bernie began his campaign by pointing out the fact that the United States was dangerously approaching a system that appeared more as a form of oligarchy than it did democracy. He even suggested it may be, “too late,” as a way to hedge his own political viability.</p><p>Over a year later a huge number of the concerns he and his campaign expressed have been proven inconsequential by his own victories. This is not to say, for example, that money in politics is not a problem. <strong>It is.</strong> But it is not, at least yet, an insurmountable barrier. This is precisely why it is so important to strike while the iron is hot.</p><p>There may come a day not too far off wherein this barrier does become insurmountable. It will be a day when we don’t have a demonstrably progressive candidate with 30+ years of experience and personal integrity. It will be a day when the the voting rights act is an even more distant memory. It will be a day when we have failed to organize a viable grassroots presidential campaign for 8 or more years.</p><p>In order that we may protect our freedom and democracy, we must practice our freedom and democracy. What this means practically is that we must encourage choice, not discourage it. We need to assert our freedom to vote for who we want, not merely against those we fear. Any defense of the notion that can protect our freedom and democracy by consciously limiting choices we should have and the choices we should make is self-defeating. We must oppose all such language regardless of who we will inevitably vote for and whatever our reasons for that vote may be.</p><h4>A Message to the Vigilant Pragmatist (Bernie)</h4><p>For those who remain unconvinced by the philosophical argument, let me make a more practical case for an independent Bernie. In the past few days Bernie has amassed ~7000 people who have registered in the interest of running for local offices. Thousands more still have offered to volunteer. Combining this with the existing database of his own supporters, Bernie has the capacity to bootstrap a broad base of people who seek to expand the political revolution.</p><p>While this mitigates a number of concerns one might have for local and state level contests, we are left without a viable mechanism at the national level. A concession and endorsement of Hillary Clinton will not merely result in disillusionment of millions of enthusiastic supporters, it will sideline the coordinated organizational gains while efforts are redirected towards her support. Despite the political foresight required to admit Trump <em>may</em> win if we “split votes,” there is essentially no mention of what happens if Trump wins regardless. There is no mention of what happens if Hillary proves to be a significantly flawed candidate, incapable of victory even with the support of Sanders.</p><p>Pragmatists should not believe in prophets and despite all the self-assurances they can muster, a failure to form a contingency plan is perhaps an even greater disaster than not having one for the sake of “unity.” Without an ongoing and capable third option we find ourselves, potentially, in the weakest position possible. Namely, what we may find ourselves with is a floundering Democratic party; a party not merely incapable of victory, but equally incapable of offering a serious defense against future encroachment. Perhaps worse still, believing they need to actively foster such encroachment to regain their own political power.</p><p>In a system mired with advanced forms of voter suppression and potential election fraud, the 7000 candidates will face increasingly significant challenges. Without the immediate ongoing participation and continued engagement of Sanders supporters at a national level we will see months and potentially years of organizing gains washed away. An entire infrastructure may become lost for a handful of tepid attempts to restore what could amount to an self-obsoleting political machine, the Democratic party.</p><p>There is quite literally nothing to lose. If the fight between Clinton and Trump is close, then a nationally organized independent campaign can make a clear appeal to its supporters weeks before the election about the immediate need for political expediency, e.g. to vote for Clinton. Not only do those supporters remain engaged and more likely to receive that message, the message may, in fact, be much stronger because of the clear and imminent risk of a Trump presidency. In making such a last minute appeal as opposed to a highly speculative one based on vague concerns, the organizational arm of this new progressive movement, the political revolution, will be at the height of its strength with months of additional development.</p><p>Still, this appeal is a conscious and transient decision with the clear intent of doing what is politically expedient in that instant. The organization gets to continue immediately on its way, not missing a beat and may, in fact, gain more strength as “queen maker.”</p><p>Alternatively, should Trump inevitably win anyway due to the existing and real threats to our freedom and democracy, only with this effort will we remain in a position to immediately organize in opposition and to defend against the inevitable future attacks. Lastly, if Trump pulls significantly ahead, we may be the only viable opposition to truly defeat him. Perhaps too, we might simply win in what, regardless of our actions, could already be a three way race.</p><p>To become a third or fourth option is not and cannot be rightfully construed as a threat to freedom and democracy. It is necessarily the realization of freedom and democracy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36a4d2fde048" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Response to Adam Kokesh’s “Every Bernie supporter needs to hear this”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/a-response-to-adam-kokeshs-every-bernie-supporter-needs-to-hear-this-d845865b217b?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d845865b217b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[communist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[libertarian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jun 2016 02:23:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-17T10:47:39.423Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let me begin by saying that I genuinely support what Adam does in terms of media, outreach, and discussion. That said I strongly disagree with his analysis of the current system and message on how to move forward. In a recent video titled “Every Bernie supporter needs to hear this,” Adam presented a handful of questions to Bernie supporters prior to making his pitch for volunteers to support his Presidential run in 2020. Due to the length of some of my responses, I chose to respond to this in written form, but I would be happy to have a longer or direct conversation with Adam via video if he sees this.</p><h4>Why does socialism have to be nationalized? Could it be more effective at the community level where it could be voluntary instead of coercive?</h4><p>At the risk of sounding trite and pedantic, we must first understand what we mean by “socialism.” Socialist movements have a deep history which have progressed through a number of different phases.</p><p>Early socialists held Utopian and religious ideals of fraternity and brotherhood which found little basis in the real economic conditions of their time. During the industrial revolution, the development of Marxist theory turned this notion on its head by positing and demonstrating the basis for socialism in the real development of material conditions. The modern day meaning of “socialism,” although influenced by both these lines of thought, is largely a product of mass media and educational institutions bound by the same or similar conditions as private industry. Only recently has this begun to change with the freedom now offered by widespread internet access and free media.</p><p>What results from this is a modern understanding of socialism that is often contradictory and purposefully demonized. The evidence for this can be found in the very same video in which you ask these questions, wherein, you call socialism “idealistic” while at the same time immediately constraining it to the real existing condition of the nation state. If socialism is idealistic, then what constrains it to this or that particular ontological condition?</p><p>Keeping this in mind, it is important to realize that I answer these questions as someone who is steeped in the Marxist tradition. That is, I believe that socialism arises and develops out of real material conditions. As such, despite being a hypothetical system of the future, certain aspects of its nature can be gleaned from existing conditions.</p><p>To answer your question more directly, socialism <em>cannot</em> be nationalized. Nor can socialism be “effective” at the community level. Contrary to the false dichotomy you have presented, socialism can only arise at an <em>international</em> level.</p><p>Before I address why this is the case, let me take a moment to address your second and related question. I will begin by examining a number of assumptions which are inherent in your question.</p><p><strong>Assumption #1: That which occurs at the national level is inherently coercive, while that which occurs at the community level affords voluntarism.</strong></p><p>There seems to be no obvious defense for this assumption. Even if history were on your side, which it’s not, any attempt to deduce such a conclusion would be mired by the huge variety of nation states which have existed throughout history, not only in different forms, but size and scope as well.</p><p>Were early U.S. colonial communities not often coercive, even distinctly so from the British empire (think religious intolerance)? Did the federal constitution not seek and in many cases afford increased liberty (think religious liberty)? What of the civil war and the emancipation proclamation? Even in modern times, it is often those countries with failed states where we find the worst violations of human and civil rights at the level of individual communities, sometimes reverting to forms of tribalism resulting in genocide, forced labor, and perverse restrictions on human freedom.</p><p><strong>Assumption #2: Voluntarism is more effective.</strong></p><p>Effective at what? Developing productive forces? Generating wealth? Increasing human well-being? Almost undoubtedly you believe it is more effective at all these things, but again that pesky thing called history intervenes. This is not to say that historical examples disprove the effectiveness of voluntarism, merely that the basis for your understanding of “effectiveness” has only been developed under the auspices of this or that form of coercion.</p><p>The development of capitalism over the last 500 years is founded on genocide, expropriation, slavery, and forced colonization. There is no measure of its effectiveness under a voluntary form and there’s no indication that it would have developed as quickly as it did under voluntarist principles. Even upon shedding its most overt coercive tendencies during the last century, one would think, based on your critique, that you are in complete agreement that it remains a system of coercion wherein the direct violations of human dignity and rights have been merely superseded by more indirect forms of oppression and coercion.</p><p>Do not confuse what I am saying for a <em>defense</em> of force, but merely a summary analysis how we have developed thus far. Of course, I would be remiss not to address the obvious libertarian rebuttal to such statements, namely, that were these forms of coercion less present or perhaps non-existent, we would have already far surpassed our current level of development and be flying around with jet packs and what have you. To this one only need to respond, what evidence do you have of this?</p><p>Even if one were to concede that modern forms of voluntarism far surpass the productive capacity of capitalism <strong><em>as we know it</em></strong>, e.g. open source, free media, crowdfunding/sourcing, etc, one cannot separate these forms of production and finance from the material conditions in which they arose. These conditions remain a product of the <em>real historic</em> development of capital, not the idealized voluntarist mode of production of the anarcho-capitalist. There is no way to determine that they would have developed so readily, or would be sustainable in their modern form without their historical antecedent.</p><p>Returning then to my previous point, that socialism necessarily develops internationally, we see in all the examples above various levels of free production <em>and</em> distribution. We see that technology has afforded us both a direct and indirect means of production. The former, direct means, being realized in the development of programming, 3D-printing, robotics, etc. The latter being the near instant communication of ideas, organizational tools, finance, etc. In <strong><em>no circumstance</em></strong> do we see such voluntarist development constrained to the community or national level. Instead, what we find in every circumstance is the directing of those forces in accordance with their own <strong><em>socially</em></strong> organized desires and capacities at an <strong><em>international</em></strong> scale<em>.</em></p><p>Unless one wishes to find themselves returning to stone-age technology, production is <em>necessarily social</em>, not individual. Furthermore, in the current phase of that development of those real material conditions, it is <em>international.</em> It is therefore a absurdity to believe that one can maintain or exceed/improve the current state of affairs by producing solely at the national, state, or communal level.</p><p>Of course, it is not production with which you are concerned, but distribution. But what of modern social and international production without distribution? How does one produce any modern product without first receiving through some form of <em>distribution</em> the requisite machines, materials, and labor? How is labor itself maintained or reproduced if not for the <em>distribution</em> of means of subsistence, shelter, etc?</p><p>Therein lies the inherent contradiction of capitalism in all its forms. Whether it be the real form which we see before us today or the idealized form conjured by the “voluntarist,” capitalism is “capped” because while it seeks to develop its wealth socially, it can only conceive of distributing it privately. In doing so, it necessarily becomes unbalanced. It is this lack of balance which leads to the cyclic tips and turns, the over-production and over-correction, the mass conversion of living value (labor) to non-living value (capital) and therefore a falling rate of profit in a system who’s very well-being depends on a growing rate of profit.</p><p>Socialism in an economic sense is merely the resolution to this problem, thus, it is necessarily international.</p><h4>Does centralizing power inevitably corrupt it?</h4><p>Again, at the risk of sounding trite and pedantic, we must first understand what we mean by “power.” In systems of exchange where the livelihood of any individual is dependent on their ability to exchange that which others desire for that which they desire, is wealth (broadly speaking) not a form of power? In a systems wherein such exchange becomes the dominant form of human interaction, thus, wherein money arises to mediate any and all such exchange, is money not a form of power?</p><p>Does then the concentration/centralization of wealth as a form of power also inevitably corrupt it?</p><p>As almost undoubtedly you propose severely limiting the centralized control of political power, should we then not also limit the centralized control of financial power? In the same sense we should divest from the executive authority of a president, should we not equally divest from the fiscal authority of a CEO? A wealthy financier? In short, should we limit the amount of wealth a single person can have, just as you, presumably, intend to limit the political authority a single person can have?</p><p>I don’t believe that centralizing power inevitably corrupts “power itself.” I’m frankly not even sure what such a question means. But I think it is obviously the case that the centralizing of power will inevitably afford someone in a position of power the capacity to exercise even their most minor personal corruptions. More, it will undoubtedly create a heightened point of attraction for those who would seek to use that power to do so.</p><h4>Should anyone have as much power as the President of the United States?</h4><p>In what sense? Morally speaking? No. It does not seem morally sound to me that a single individual can unilaterally destroy the lives of other human beings via drone strikes with no real accountability.</p><p>Politically speaking? Possibly. That is to say I think political systems arises out of a genuine need to mediate the antagonisms in an otherwise divided society. As such, the levels of political authority afforded to a given individual within that society will and probably should reflect the depths of those antagonisms. Otherwise one creates political power vacuums from which even more extreme forces may arise.</p><p>Overall though, the question doesn’t seem well put. This is a bit like asking whether or not one should invest in Raytheon. Morally speaking I think the answer is pretty clear that investing in a company who’s primary purpose is to profit off death and destruction is unacceptable. Economically speaking, depending on the current market context, it might make a lot more or a lot less sense to do so.</p><p>Understanding that there is a distinction between these two questions is important. The lack of such understanding is precisely why we see the conflation of certain political systems and/or ideologies with moralistic ideas of good and evil. Inevitably this leads to dogmatic associations between certain features of this or that political-economic system with moral attitudes. To see a demonstration of this, simply refer to the first question wherein “effectiveness” becomes a catch-all for moral, economic, and political intentions which have yet to have been demonstrated as fully compatible to begin with.</p><p>Again I will repeat the question from the previous response: In systems where personal livelihood depends on the ability to exchange, and wherein there is a universal means of exchange (money), is this too a form of power which we should seek to limit just as we might seek to limit political power?</p><h4>Do you own yourself or does the collective own you?</h4><p>Neither. I don’t think ownership is an applicable concept to “the self,” nor do I think we benefit by applying conceptions of property to our relationship to ourselves. The only thing which historically has been gained from this is a defense of property by conflating human rights and property rights, i.e. a defense of the current system.</p><p>I don’t need to “own myself” to have a right to life or liberty. In fact, were I to own myself under the terms of modern property rights, it would be wholly possible for me to negate my rights to life and liberty by forfeiting myself as a slave. While this is currently possible in a superficial sense, it is not possible in a real sense wherein I would lose the right (legally or ethically) to life and liberty. Even in that sense the existing notions of life, liberty, etc, have narrowly escaped the confines of property relations at the highest legal levels.</p><p>Putting aside whether or not our right to life and liberty are <em>meaningfully recognized</em> in the the current society, I would imagine that we both agree we have such a right and that such a right is <em>inalienable, </em>as such we are in no position relate to ourselves as we would property (which has no rights of its own).</p><p>It precisely on these grounds that one can critique property not as a prerequisite to liberty, but as inherently antithetical to it. In a system wherein, again, wealth may constitute a form of power, it will always appear as though there is some link between property and liberty. Those with more power are perceived and often granted “more freedom.” But this is only because the system is, in itself, not free.</p><p>It is only because you are not truly free that your liberty must be expressed in some third-term, in this case property or as realized under capitalism, money. Were you in a truly free society, your liberty would be self-evident and need no form of expression other than your own personal self-expression.</p><p>As a communist, I believe that human rights, freedom, and morally just forms of governance, indeed voluntarism, necessitate the abolition of private property and, therefore, along with it existing and future class antagonisms. With the overturning of such relations, the need for a political state to mediate such antagonisms disappears, and only then can we talk of freedom in every sense of the word. To quote Marx:</p><blockquote>Free state — what is this?</blockquote><blockquote>It is by no means the aim of the workers, who have got rid of the narrow mentality of humble subjects, to set the state free. In the German Empire, the “state” is almost as “free” as in Russia. Freedom consists in converting the state from an organ superimposed upon society into one completely subordinate to it; and today, too, <strong>the forms of state are more free or less free to the extent that they restrict the “freedom of the state”.</strong></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d845865b217b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why The Filibuster Is a Political Victory for Democrats]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/why-the-filibuster-is-a-political-victory-for-democrats-508dbe3aa1fe?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/508dbe3aa1fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[filibusters]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guns]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Jun 2016 08:00:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-16T08:17:18.960Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We begin with a quote:</p><blockquote>Cynicism is a refuge for cowards. — Cory Booker</blockquote><p>Unless of course that cynicism is reserved for things like universal healthcare (inclusive of mental health) and tuition-free public colleges. In that circumstance, cynicism is <em>pragmatism</em> and instead of being a <em>refuge for cowards</em>, it’s a sign of experience and political viability.</p><p>Let me be clear. I support strong regulation of guns and personal access to firearms. In my opinion, not only should we have a much stronger and instant background check system, but a meaningful ban on assault weapons, federal gun registration, and insurance requirements. This article, however, is not about gun control. Neither was the “filibuster.”</p><p>While I think it’s true there are such things as skillful politicians it’s important to distinguish between the type of skill that allows a politician to get things done on behalf of their constituents and that which allows a politician to get things done on behalf of themselves and their party. That said, let me also be clear that I am passing no personal judgement on Senator Murphy. I am able to concede that he not only began, but continued, and ended his fight with the best of intentions and only a desire and willingness to try and protect future victims of gun violence. My argument does not rely on ill intent of him or anyone else.</p><p>The political victory which was had, beginning on June 15th and ending on June 16th in the U.S. senate, is not a political victory on behalf of constituents. The action taken by Murphy and other senate Democrats passed no legislation nor did it prevent anything particularly heinous from reaching a vote. Unlike actual filibusters, the goal was not to delay or prevent the vote on the upcoming bill, the <em>Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act</em>, but rather so that a vote could be had on legislation for universal background checks and preventing those on a terrorist watch list from passing such checks.</p><p>I have no crystal ball, but I suspect (and suspect I’m not alone in thinking) that neither of these measures will have much success given the make-up of the current house and senate. Furthermore, if either of them does pass it will constitute more of a pleasant surprise rather than a resounding affirmation of some well thought out political plan. This, of course, assuming the concessions even comes to fruition.</p><p>I know what you’re saying Mr. Booker, “cynicism is a refuge for cowards.” But I’m no cynic with respect to gun regulation. That is to say, I’m not so jaded as to believe that nothing can happen with respect to tightening gun laws. In fact, I believe quite the opposite is true of most legislation, including legislation which I would consider far more radical than what you and your colleagues proposed today. I believe not only is it possible to get such legislation recognized, but to see it passed.</p><p>What I don’t believe is that this requires skillful politicians willing to stand and speak for 14 hours+. Nor do I believe it requires a <em>willing</em> house or senate. And I most certainly don’t believe it requires the massacre of 50 innocent people in an Orlando night club.</p><p>What I believe is needed to make real and lasting change in this country is for millions of people to stand up and come together and put pressure on the powers that be. That includes legislative power as well as economic power through actions such as the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, which ironically also seeks to prevent the countless deaths of innocent people by gun violence. The only difference being that while you and your colleagues are willing to stand on the floor of the senate for 14+ hours to prevent one type of gun violence, you’re more than willing to do everything in your power to perpetuate the other kind.</p><p>While your actions today have successfully won over yet another news cycle, the arguments of Sanders’ appointees to your own party’s platform drafting committee remain quietly overlooked, despite their fighting that other type of gun violence. There, if not for the voices of a few, former Democratic congressman Wexler would have spoken unopposed on the need to avoid questions like “should we call it an occupation?”</p><p>I heard a lot today from fired-up Democrats about the needless slaughter of 20 children in the “filibustering” senator’s home state. Not a single mention of the nearly 500 Palestinian children estimated killed in a single month by Israeli forces in 2014. Should we also expect that Hillary intends to execute Cuomo’s suppression of the BDS movement in NY at the national level? Should we “unite blue” on this?</p><p>Do I say this to deny the victims of our most recent national tragedy some form of justice or reconciliation? Of course not. Rather, I say it to point out that while it is easy to use the convenience of tragedy for political aims, the Democratic party seems all too willing to overlook such tragedy when it is not in their interests.</p><p>Today was a huge political victory for Democrats. You got the opportunity to fire-up your base only one day after the final primary in a long and contested battle for the Democratic nomination. You got to use the <a href="http://www.bustle.com/articles/167323-why-isnt-bernie-sanders-at-the-filibuster-he-is-supporting-his-fellow-senators-from-twitter">not so mysterious absence</a> of Senator Sanders as a means to propagate a continued false narrative about his position on guns. You even convinced people (at least on twitter) that whatever faith they’d lost in your party warranted restoration.</p><p>All this with just 50 lives and 14 hours. Imagine what you could do with 500 lives and 4 years. If it’s cynicism that’s your enemy, I suggest you first shine that light inwards to expose the cowardice in the midst of your own political party.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=508dbe3aa1fe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Four Things Bernie Missed in the Brooklyn Debate]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@mattsah/four-things-bernie-missed-in-the-brooklyn-debate-2d2fc448be1b?source=rss-5e7fd07303ce------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d2fc448be1b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Matthew Sahagian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Apr 2016 06:20:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-15T17:38:52.508Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>While I think Bernie won the debate overall, that belief is largely predicated on the fact that I’m not ignorant of Hillary’s record. Her previous statements and her general tendency to give “every answers,” i.e. non-answers to direct questions, are well known to me. However, many people watching the debate are likely less informed. Even for those who aren’t, they may be more willing to accept many of the things she says at face value.</p><p>Unfortunately, there’s no good excuse for why Bernie didn’t take the many gifts given to him during this debate. I suspect at this point that this must be some personal limitation of his. That is, either he believes that pointing out these facts would be too negative or he’s simply not interested in taking the advice of others on the topic of debate.</p><p>I’m going to give that advice anyway.</p><h4>On Wall Street Influence</h4><p>Bernie absolutely must be clearer on this point. This is not about an immediately obvious quid pro quo. That would result in ethics charges and perhaps even bribery charges brought up against nearly every politician by their political opponents. While there may be some instances of such things, <a href="http://www.ibtimes.com/clinton-foundation-donors-got-weapons-deals-hillary-clintons-state-department-1934187">those instances</a> will be heavily obfuscated behind the immense breadth of the Clinton Foundation.</p><p>The point is a rather simple one. If my viability as a political candidate is tied to money (which it is) and if my money is largely provided by high-paid corporate donors with their particular industry or business interests (which it is in the case of Hillary) then I am going to think very long and hard about doing anything that pisses them off too much. Sanders gets some points for effort on this, as he did attempt to point out the issue of <strong>inaction</strong> as opposed to having taken a particular action.</p><p>However, voting “no,” is in itself an action and he was extremely remiss not to point out <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12mJ-U76nfg">the long standing example as provided by his colleague, Senator Warren</a>. This would have been a clear and direct answer to the question as it was asked.</p><h4>On Foreign Policy Judgement</h4><p>It seems Bernie forgot the lessons of the past debates where he pinned Clinton on her relationship with the war criminal Henry Kissinger. While it’s important to address the issues (both past and present) of the middle east, Hillary came <a href="http://www.democracynow.org/2016/4/13/hear_hillary_clinton_defend_her_role">fresh off her own New York Daily News interview defending her judgement in supporting the Honduran coup</a>. The coup is widely recognized as being the fundamental precursor to the cold-blooded murder of beloved activist Berta Caceres. Of course, Kissinger had a particular interest in “spreading democracy” in Latin America as well, one which <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor">resulted in equally disastrous political repression and the murder of activists by their own U.S. backed governments</a>.</p><p>Then again, unlike in the middle east, <a href="http://www.telesurtv.net/english/news/Nearly-9000-Child-Migrants-Have-Fled-Honduras-in-2015-20150725-0002.html">the “problems” caused by these types of decisions</a> are not separated from us by large bodies of water.</p><h4>On Israel Palestine</h4><p>The occupation of Palestinian territories by Israel and the expansion of settlements is illegal under international law. To say merely that we need to respect both sides is to ignore the elephant in the room. Whenever Israel is mentioned, both the former Secretary of State and Bernie feel the need to emphasize the simple fact that Israel has a right to exist and has a right to defend itself.</p><p>Does Palestine?</p><p>Palestinians are not simply faced with high unemployment. They are continuously having their rights stripped and further restricted under the pretences of Israeli defense. This includes <a href="https://www.amnestyusa.org/pdf/mde150272009en.pdf">the IDF targeting of water cisterns</a> and <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/03/israel-air-strike-un-school-gaza-rafah">the shelling of a school</a> which sheltered those already displaced from fighting.</p><h4>On Women’s Rights</h4><p>Despite having perhaps the strongest record on supporting a woman’s right to choose, period, Bernie was targeted by Hillary’s unapologetic two-faced pandering. At this point in the debate, I thought it was over for the Secretary. Alas, Bernie failed to respond adequately to what would have amounted to political suicide in any fight where he, or for that matter any candidate, had been adequately prepared.</p><p>The simple reality is that there is <a href="http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2015/09/29/hillary_clinton_i_could_compromise_on_abortion_if_it_included_exceptions_for_mothers_health.html">only one democratic candidate who is open to a constitutional restriction on a woman’s right to choose</a>. That candidate is not Bernie Sanders. And yes, I said “a <strong>constitutional</strong> restriction.”</p><p>Despite her attempt to paint Sanders as one who would belittle the importance of women’s rights, it appears Hillary doesn’t even completely grasp the depths of them.</p><p>Unfortunately, as with the case of Kissinger, Bernie failed to come out as strongly as he has in previous showings where he had made it clear, much like many pro-choice advocates, he understands the issue as an issue of <strong>equal rights</strong>, not simply as one of health and empathy.</p><p>I’ll leave you with his words as expressed in the Fox Town Hall in early March:</p><blockquote>And I’ll tell you something which I don’t like in this debate. There are a whole lot of people out there who tell me the government is terrible, government is awful, get government off our backs. My Republican friends want to cut Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare — Medicaid, education. <strong>But somehow on this issue, they want to tell every woman in America what she should do with her body.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>I am very strongly pro-choice. That is a decision to be made by the woman, her physician and her family. That’s my view.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d2fc448be1b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>