<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Max Demyan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Max Demyan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@maxdemyan?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 21:36:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@maxdemyan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Zero Fees and Interest-free Loans in Decentralized Credit Networks]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/zero-fees-and-interest-free-loans-in-decentralized-credit-networks-7dc9e2b5b42d?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7dc9e2b5b42d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[p2p]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[network]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[layer-3]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Apr 2019 10:25:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:18:28.336Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RXpNdDG0I9jhJ0UEAj_q6g.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">Blockchain</a> <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology</a> is moving very fast and transforming a lot of industries. Decentralization is regarded as an effective way to increase the transparency of transactions and make them simpler in many fields. In particular, the application of decentralization has shown a great potential in finance. Blockchain can disrupt the traditional banking industry, enabling new business models, and making the traditional financial infrastructure more efficient. Some people even think that blockchain technology can replace traditional banking with coming decentralized financial system, where users will be able to take advantage of censorship-resistant financial services, store and transfer their assets and money, take out loans without the need of intermediate central authority, and have a full control of their wealth and personal data.</p><p>A lot of this new infrastructure is currently being built, radically changing the way people do business and spend their money. Decentralized financial networks are based on smart contracts and peer-to-peer (P2P) services which replace banks as a trusted party. They can give their users access to complex financial tools for creating and protecting their assets and managing risks. Such systems have the potential to fully reshape the financial world by providing real-time transactions, ubiquity, and fairness.</p><p>One of the fields in finance that has shown a great potential for decentralization is money lending which is the core principle of any functioning economy. Decentralized lending based on blockchain has become possible only in the last 5 years. Decentralized credit networks which have recently seen a rapid increase of popularity promise easy and global access to credit and loans for business and the public by immediately connecting borrowers and lenders on the platform. Users of decentralized IOU credit networks can even take advantage of <em>interest-free loans and zero fees</em>.</p><h3>What Is Decentralized Lending?</h3><p>Peer-to-peer lending is not a new concept. This is the way how loans and subsequent payments were handled in the past before the rise of banks. This system was based on interpersonal trust but over time, P2P lending was replaced by traditional bank loans where banks act as intermediaries and provide an extra layer of protection. Unfortunately, that protection comes with high fees, the complexity of regulations of lending and borrowing, and slow processing time.</p><p>After the global financial crisis 2008–2009 which as largely caused by toxic pools of debt artificially created by banks, the chaos and fragility of the system aroused dissatisfaction with commercial banks among regulators and businesses that resulted in an attempt to create a more transparent financial system. New laws and regulations were introduced to improve transparency and to democratize the funding process. They opened the door to new lending institutions many of which operate on the popular peer-to-peer model which is free of bank bureaucracy. The result was the rise of peer-to-peer (P2P) platforms which directly connect investors with borrowers and are a new type of “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharing_economy">sharing economy</a>”.</p><p>P2P platforms remove the middleman from the process and use technology to determine creditworthiness and other factors related to borrower’s ability to properly pay back a debt. They offer more transparency, simplified procedures, and better interest rates deal for both a borrower and a lender. The P2P model has proven to be successful and according to <a href="https://www.statista.com/">Statista</a>, the global peer-to-peer lending market is expected to reach $1 trillion in the near future.</p><h3>Advantages and Challenges of Blockchain-based Decentralized Credit Networks</h3><p>Bankers may tell you that the traditional financial system is global and efficient, moving trillions of dollars a day and serving billions of people. In fact, bank loans can give businesses access to capital which boosts economic growth. But the modern financial system is rife with problems which open opportunities for fraud and crime and add costs which consumers ultimately have to pay.</p><p>Why is the traditional financial system so inefficient? It is based on ineffective industrial technologies and paper processes. Being centralized, it is resistant to change and vulnerable to malware attacks and system failures. And it’s exclusionary so billions of people are denied access to basic financial tools. Today’s financial system operates through a limited number of powerful intermediaries who make money by providing services that can be easily delegated to software.</p><h3>Enter Blockchain</h3><p>Blockchain technology is a real game changer for the financial industry. Blockchain is built on a distributed ledger that runs on millions of devices so it is decentralized by design. It makes possible to transfer ownership of money, bonds, equities, and virtually <em>all other kinds of assets</em> from one person to another securely, privately, without the need for an intermediary because the trust is established not by governments and banks but by network consensus protocols, cryptography, code, and collaboration. <br>The key features of blockchain-based financial services which make them superior to their centralized counterparts are:</p><ul><li><em>Permissionless</em>: Any person can access decentralized financial networks using the internet and no one can be denied service based on who they are, where they live, and what their income level is.</li><li><em>Trustless</em>: People don’t have to rely on a central party to ensure the validity of transactions.</li><li><em>Censorship Resistant</em>: At some later point of time, no central party can deem validated transactions invalid.</li><li><em>Programmable:</em> Using plug and play architecture, it is possible to create financial services at a low cost.</li><li><em>Transparent</em>: Public blockchains are fully transparent.</li></ul><h3>Decentralized Lending on Blockchain</h3><p>Conventional lending is limited to locations where regular banks operate. This model is unfair because now more than 2 billion people who live in poor countries have no access to finance as they often have no official identification and no bank account. Many lending agreements in regular banks are opaque in design with hidden fees and penalty rates.</p><p>Decentralized credit networks allow people to get a loan without going to bank and lending is not restricted to local markets. Decentralized lending solutions on blockchain are based on the timeless peer-to-peer model which makes the entire process seamless. They offer a cheaper and more secure way of making personal loans and give people equal access to the global lending market. They provide significant benefits particularly to ordinary consumers and small-to-medium enterprises that often face difficulties with access to credit in regular banks. With a decentralized credit network, everyone can get access to a loan if there is a device with an access to the internet.</p><p>There is no middleman. Consumers and businesses can submit a loan request and be connected directly with willing lenders from all over the world who in turn bid to provide a loan. As a result, borrowers can access very competitive financing. Interest rates in decentralized credit networks on blockchain are agreed by participants. People from all countries have the same access to lending and to competitive interest rates.</p><p>Smart contracts act as loan agreements and contain data about the parties involved, creditworthiness, capital, collateral, and what happens in the cause of default. With smart contracts which are secure by design, lenders can easily access the counter-party’s trustworthiness and vet the borrowers. Lenders can also validate transactions and perform other routine administrative tasks related to the lending process almost momentarily which reduces costs and accelerates the process.</p><p>All information about transactions is open for audits and a credit rating can be assigned to every address. Anyone can see the details about transactions of a specific address and analyze them. If a loan provider notices some suspicious or unusual activity, they can simply withdraw from offering a loan.</p><p>Decentralized lending is still in its infancy and only time will tell if it will become a global system that gives all people equal access to a worldwide lending market. There are challenges that can make its widespread adoption difficult. They are related to determining creditworthiness, establishing and verifying identities, know-your-customer (KYC) rules.</p><p>Collecting loans made on blockchain may not be easy and will test the legality of smart contracts. It will require the adoption of a regulatory framework on the global level for P2P cross-border lending. Currently, courts are unlikely to recognize the validity of smart contracts in doing business. Although records of transactions are stored on a distributed ledger, there are no procedures for evaluation and management of risks. At this stage, blockchain doesn’t seem to be appropriate for complex financial operations. But that doesn’t stop entrepreneurs from adopting blockchain technology for performing simpler tasks so there are a lot of projects running on blockchain platforms such as SALT, Ripio Credit Network, ETHLend and some of them have the potential to grow.</p><h3>IOU Credit Networks</h3><p>In recent years, we have witnessed a growth of IOU credit networks that combine credit and social trust. This model is based on transitive trust or credit between permissionless users. First, users express trust and strategically decide how much credit they are willing to extend to each other. Users who don’t directly trust each other can provide transactions by exchanging IOUs along the chain of trustlines in the network. Today, IOU credit networks serve as a backbone of real-world payment systems of Ripple and Stellar which are also deployed by different banks worldwide.</p><h3>Ripple</h3><p>Ripple is one of the most popular decentralized financial systems as a fast and low-cost method for performing payments in existing fiat currencies, Ripple’s own cryptocurrency — XRP, as well as other cryptocurrencies. It enables people from all over the world to exchange money, goods, and other assets almost in real time — on average, this process takes from 5 to 10 seconds. <br>The network maintains the distributed ledger that stores information about all accounts in the system. It creates a credit/debit network that works in a similar way to traditional banking systems. Ripple users can buy goods or deposit their money to another user, for example, a <em>Gateway</em> — an existing bank or an online platform and the system keeps track of the balance for each pair of users. Validation of transactions is carried by <em>Validators </em>— special servers of organizations and individuals.</p><p>XRPs were pre-mined by Ripple and can be purchased by users after they open an account within the system. The system collects a small XRP fee for each transaction and destroys it after the transaction is confirmed. XRP payments are straightforward and don’t require any cooperation from users who receive the currency. But users who want to receive IOU payments, must create a trustline with other users and declare the amount of trust towards each of them. Users need to specify the amount of trust for each currency.</p><h3>Stellar</h3><p>Stellar acts as an inexpensive intermediary for international transactions that connects payment systems, banks, and people. This decentralized financial services platform was originally a Ripple fork but now it is a separate platform that works on the Stellar Consensus Protocol and has its native asset called Lumens (XLM). Stellar is a non-profit so it doesn’t charge its users for the network access but it has received initial funding and donations from supporters.</p><p>Stellar supports multi-currency transactions. The network makes it easy to send money across the borders due to almost instantaneous transactions (from 3 to 5 seconds) and uses anchors which issue assets on the Stellar Network. Anchors can hold a deposit and issue a credit and act as a gateway between different currencies and the Stellar Network. When people deposit money into their online accounts of an anchor on the Stellar Network, the deposits are recorded as credits in their accounts. After that, people can send payments and receive them from other users. All the money transactions are performed in as credits issued by anchors through trustlines. Users pay for each transaction a comparatively low fee of 0.00001 lumens. All the transaction fees are transferred into a fee pool and distributed among users through an “inflation vote.”</p><h3>SilentWhispers</h3><p>SilentWhispers is a decentralized path-based-transaction network without a public ledger presented by Moreno-Sanchez et al. This network is privacy-preserving because it doesn’t require a ledger to protect the integrity of transactions. SilentWhispers network was implemented as C++ library. The network enables transactions among users and guarantees their privacy. It uses a new distributed payment protocol for calculating a credit available between a sender and a receiver and doesn’t reveal any information about the credit. The experiment showed that transactions can be performed in about 1.3 seconds. Researchers think it can be deployed in the real world because it is efficient and scalable enough to cope with a growing number of users and money transactions.</p><h3><a href="https://www.geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a></h3><p>GEO develops a protocol for decentralized P2P value exchange network of mutual trust. The unique feature of GEO Protocol is that it is not based on a common ledger and is <em>blockchain agnostic</em>. That allows it to connect various blockchains, as well as non-blockchain-based assets. Transactions are performed by local off-chain consensus of the participating nodes only. All data is stored by the nodes between which composite channels (a combination of state channels and trustlines) are installed.</p><p>GEO node is so lightweight it can be installed and ran even on an ordinary smartphone, turning it into a personal financial hub. There is no network fee for conducting transactions in the GEO network.</p><p>Due to its flexible infrastructure, GEO Protocol can be used as a highly efficient trustless payment network layer for existing blockchain systems and to simplify payments in fiat money through a network of distributed trust. That enables the creation of a de-facto decentralized credit network between the GEO network participants.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T5sRl9e-GUUbgyTPA7FDIQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>By default the loans in the network are free (provided that particular participants trust each other, it’s like you give a small loan to your friend). But GEO Protocol also allows the creation of third-party dApps, where any functionality can be implemented, including the creation of commercially motivated decentralized credit networks.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Peer-to-peer lending is an age-old practice that was traditionally associated with high risk and extreme locality. Today, the P2P model is being successfully digitized and delocalized and blockchain technologies such as immutable ledgers and smart contracts build additional trust and transparency on top of the existing P2P lending models. Decentralized credit networks on blockchain ensure global access to loans with competitive interest rates for individual borrowers and businesses by connecting them directly with willing lenders.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geocommunity">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7dc9e2b5b42d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/zero-fees-and-interest-free-loans-in-decentralized-credit-networks-7dc9e2b5b42d">Zero Fees and Interest-free Loans in Decentralized Credit Networks</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trustlines are the new IOU]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/trustlines-are-the-new-iou-17e71dc79458?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17e71dc79458</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trustline]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[credit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[p2p-payments]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[state-channels]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Apr 2019 10:36:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-19T23:10:49.170Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Trustlines are the new IOUs</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P4Pp6mW-Khhr06Wr1Z02Zw.png" /></figure><p>The concept of debt first appeared in ancient times in the form of barter exchange. Later, when a monetary system emerged, it became an integral part of the financial system, and new kinds of debt obligations came into existence.</p><p>We can’t imagine our world without deferred payments, credits or ordinary loans. Nowadays all these ties and relationships are supported by centralized financial institutions — banks and governments. But, thanks to distributed IOU networks, things could change drastically in the near future.</p><h4>What is an IOU (I Owe You)?</h4><p>Imagine you loan $10 to a friend. Now you have your friend’s IOU on the sum. In other words, IOU, or debt obligation, is an unwritten (verbal) contract confirming that obligation.</p><p>Now you can ‘spend’ a debt obligation of this kind, for instance, by asking another friend of yours to pay for your coffee, and telling him that the money will be returned by your first friend. Such a debt obligation has several distinctions: you’re able to spend it within a particular circle only, i.e. people who trust one another; also you can issue your own IOU only for the amount of money your second friend (your creditor) trusts you with.</p><p>There are a number of other kinds of debt obligations. Look at the table below for the key differences between them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/409/1*9hcY_05Qru84JQJkOpNHyA.png" /></figure><p>In the real world, we are dealing with IOU systems much more often than we think we are — virtually every day in fact. We’re talking about ordinary (fiat) currency here, that is essentially a variation of an IOU obligation. By accepting it we thereby confirm our trust in the issuing government, and, since we use fiat money very frequently, the amount of trust we hold in a state corresponds to the total sum of its currency we possess and/or accept.</p><p>Essentially, banks are trust intermediaries in this kind of IOU system. We give our money to a bank in exchange for its IOU, and then we pay other people with those debt obligations, plus the bank itself collects a small amount of interest.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/917/1*A4IHOrKbjQ_IpPQX_oZ-2g.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Schematic representation of the modern banking system</em></figcaption></figure><h4>But what if anyone could be an intermediary?</h4><p>The advantages of such a system are obvious: there would be no central emission body, there would be no commission fees, there would be no need to trust in a state or government etc.</p><p>In this article, we will describe existing and potential solutions to make this happen.</p><h4>Hawala</h4><p>One of the most prominent examples of existing IOU alternatives is Hawala. It is used for money transfers bypassing the banking system. It’s easier to explain how it works with an example.</p><p>Let’s say a citizen of country A plans to perform a money transfer to country B. But for a number of reasons (fees, legal issues) he doesn’t want to do it through the banking system. In this case, he could use the Hawala system, through a hawala broker (known as <em>hawaladar</em>). Our citizen finds a hawaladar in his country A, hands him the needed sum of money and gets a secret code that he then has to pass to the recipient. Then hawaladar of country A communicates to hawaladar of country B and tells him to give the sum equivalent to the secret code bearer. So, the transfer takes place, but at the same time, no money leaves the country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*asshEfeQRmPiPNMO3Y8fOg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>This is how hawala works</em></figcaption></figure><p>Now hawaladar of country A owes money to hawaladar of country B. But this debt could be covered when a reverse transfer from country B to country A takes place.</p><p>There are also more complicated schemes for mutual debt coverage. In the above example, brokers from countries A and B could work within a broader network of brokers. After the first transaction, broker A owes broker B. But broker B has a client that wants to transfer to country C. If he doesn’t have partners in C, he could turn to broker A, and ask him to find a connection there, another broker that owes to A. So, when hawaladar C pays the recipient on behalf of broker B, all debts between A, B, and C considered to be settled.</p><h4>Trustlines and blockchain</h4><p>The emergence of distributed technology can’t help but lead to the transferral of these kinds of relationships to the blockchain sooner or later.</p><p>The idea of creating such a system was first described in “<a href="http://library.uniteddiversity.coop/Money_and_Economics/decentralizedcurrency.pdf">Money as IOUs in Social Trust Networks &amp; A Proposal for a Decentralized Currency Network Protocol</a>” published by Ryan Fugger back in 2004. It led to the creation of an entirely new technology — trust lines, which was later used in projects like Ripple, Stellar, Trustlines Network, and others.</p><p>The name of the technology suggests that there is trust involved between at least two participants of a particular network.</p><p>So, in our example, Alice and Bob set up a trust line of $10 from A to B. That means that Bob can use this sum at any time for a purchase. The trustline balance is specular: in other words, if Bob uses the funds, then on his side the balance will become positive and on Alice’s side it will become correspondingly negative (+10 and -10 respectively).</p><p>The negative balance of one of the participants, in this case, means that another participant (Bob) owes her (Alice) the sum of this balance. Whether this debt will be settled depends on the debtor entirely. So that is why <em>trustlines</em> have their name. One should credit only the trusted ones, otherwise, there is a risk of money loss.</p><p>But when you have a large number of users of such a system, a possibility emerges to create an entire credit network, where participants could perform mutual settlements with different currencies or with debt obligations derived from them.</p><p>So let’s see how trustlines technology is used in different projects.</p><h4>Ripple</h4><p>Ripple is probably the most famous and the oldest project on our list, and for now, it also holds the third place among all cryptocurrencies in terms of market capitalization, according to CoinMarketCap.</p><p>Since the Ripple project itself consists of several technologies (XRP, xCurrent, xVia), everything written below is related to XRP only, and not to Ripple in general.</p><p>The initial idea of Ripple was to make the exchange of debt obligations more decentralized, but later on big financial institutions became the target audience of the platform, so, in order to maintain the system’s operability, a certain degree of centralization was introduced (for instance, centralized control over the list of validators, to determine who is responsible for transaction validation in the ecosystem). As xCurrent gained more and more new partnerships with banks and various payment systems, the xRapid project, where the original idea was embodied, slowed its development pace.</p><p>Trustlines in Ripple are called <em>Ripple State Objects</em>. When created, each of these objects has a number of parameters responsible for its particular characteristics, such as the user that will pay fees, limits for every party, the possibility of <em>rippling</em> (cleaning), etc. To create a new trustline one needs to reserve 5 XRP, which will be returned after the trustline’s deactivation. Also, Ripple has a feature called <em>Authorized Trust Lines</em> that allows for limiting a circle of participants who can own funds issued by a particular user.</p><p>One of Ripple’s main trustline features is the possibility to perform <em>freezing</em>. There are several variants of freezing:</p><ol><li>Individual freezing (freezes a particular trustline, forbids a counterparty from decreasing the balance of it);</li><li>Global freezing (freezes an address and forbids anyone from decreasing balances in all trustlines connected to this address);</li><li>No freezing (forbids switching individual freezing on, as well as switching global freezing off).</li></ol><p>Also, Ripple has gateways that enable deposits and withdrawals of currencies in exchange for their XRP blockchain equivalents. Generally, the gateways can follow three basic business models:</p><ol><li>Deposit and withdrawal of money in and out of the system</li><li>Liquidity pool for currencies exchange</li><li>Services provided in exchange for internal system currency</li></ol><p>Gateway incentives are enabled by deposit/withdrawal fee, transfer fee, exchange rate spread, services payments, etc.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/793/1*qjV9n0sOBFLmIjzLNrhsFA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Trustlines Network</h4><p>Trustlines Network is another project that is aimed at the portage of real-life social and credit relationships to a decentralized basis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/989/1*13v8fh4GZiTaonFpPUIqxw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The digitized network of trust</em></figcaption></figure><p>The maximum quantity of possible user trustlines is unlimited, which undoubtedly is one of the project’s advantages. But in practice, the real number of set connections won’t be higher than 150 (according to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number">Dumber’s number</a>). But creators of private currency networks can set this parameter as they wish. Unlike Ripple, there is no possibility of trustline or account freezing in the Trustlines Network, but the developer’s team has considered the possibility of establishing an analogue of the <em>no-ripple-flag</em> function in the future.</p><p>A serious disadvantage to projects utilizing trustlines is a new connection establishment fee. And the Trustlines Network is no exception. There is an ETH commission fee for establishing a new connection. New asset creation, as well as current trustlines balancing, happen on-chain. On the one hand this protects the project with admired blockchain security and also avoids network spam, but on the other hand, this could repel new users and create some obstacles for scalability. The project’s developer team plans to sort out this issue in the near future in cooperation with the Raiden project.</p><p>Trustlines Network also lets its users issue their own currencies with their own characteristics and limitations, so a user could explicitly define a circle of potential users of his/her currency. All issued assets will be implemented on the Ethereum blockchain with the help of the currency network contract.</p><p>While discussing trustline technology we can’t help but mention its safety and the dispute-resolution mechanism. When a problem caused by a network or node failure arises, a procedure for conflict situation solving is defined for each separate customized currency network. If such rules and procedures weren’t defined, the conflict would be solved directly by its participants. An automated cycle closure is built into the Trustlines Network’s routing algorithm (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dijkstra%27s_algorithm">Dijkstra’s algorithm</a>). For the sake of node synchronization (for example, the agreed trustline balance), all the information is stored in a smart contract on the Ethereum blockchain. So if one node suddenly fails, it could check its balance on such a smart contract. Despite its obvious simplicity and ease of use, this solution has a significant disadvantage: constant smart contract updates require a huge amount of gas, so when there are more users, it would be not feasible to support the network. Trustlines itself is also set on-chain in the Trustlines Network.</p><p><strong>Stellar</strong></p><p>Stellar is a Ripple fork that appeared in 2015. Lumens (XLM) is a native currency of this project, but there is the possibility to create other tokens. There is no need to set up a trustline for XLM transfer, but you would have to use them if you would like to transfer other assets. Those assets are issued by special actors — so-called <em>anchors</em>, who act like PayPal, i.e. accept a real asset and issue a digitized Stellar version of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/842/1*Yrd5JLoTgV-wEUBJF-9gLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>An anchor operation scheme in Stellar</em></figcaption></figure><p>Anyone, from a private individual to a major company, can be an anchor. In order to create a Stellar asset, anchors require special accounts. Every new asset gets its own unique code. The code could be in any format for the majority of assets, except for currencies and securities where it has to meet the ISO 4217 and ISIS standards correspondingly.</p><p>The anchors are able to freeze any asset (even the one created by another account) or limit access to it. In contrast to that, there is an option to opt out from a freeze possibility.</p><h4>Silent Whispers</h4><p>In this project, trustlines exist in the form of credit connections. The main problem that the Silent Whispers project is eager to solve is privacy in all its manifestations. By privacy, it means privacy of sender, privacy of the receiver as well as privacy of the credit connections themselves. In similar systems, i.e. Ripple, Stellar, there is only pseudo-privacy instead, since all the transactions are transparent and there are ways to connect them to real persons or entities by means of various analysis methods.</p><p>Privacy in Silent Whispers will be provided by special nodes called <em>beacons</em>. Their main task is to build credit routes (a credit route enables a user to lend or borrow funds without setting up a direct connection with a counterpart, by utilizing existing connections of other network participants), as well as to provide privacy. The latter is achieved by <em>Shared Multi-Party Computation</em>, a technology that enables several participants to conduct a computation that depends on secret input data of each one of them (these are their credit connection balances), in a way that no other participant could access any information of the secret input data of others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/941/1*wTyll4ZqBOJOwzWVABi31Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Private credit limits calculation</em></figcaption></figure><p>The dispute-resolution mechanism is quite simple. Every transaction leads to a balance change that counterparties have to sign and put a timestamp on. If any of the transaction participants have an objection at any time, it can request an additional verification. To perform this procedure in Silent Whispers a <em>Judge</em> protocol is sent. Every party submits their data about the current state of the channel. The validity of this data is checked (signature verification), and if the transaction participants are in the settled state (are not performing any transactions that could affect the balance), the system rolls the channel’s state back to the latest timestamp.</p><p>By utilizing all of the above-mentioned technologies, users of the system are able to enter trusted credit relationships with one another, thus forming a credit network.</p><h4><a href="https://geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a></h4><p>Our own project, GEO Protocol, aims to build a decentralized P2P infrastructure that allows the exchange of any kind of assets and values. It also enables users to choose on what basis they want to perform such an exchange: whether trusted (using trustlines), or trustless (using state channels).</p><p>Trustlines in the GEO network have a number of peculiarities. First, all trustlines are off-chain in GEO; for complete information about balances, connections with other nodes are stored locally within each separate node. This local storage does not contain excessive data about the entire network and allows a node to be a completely autonomous entity, independent from third parties (like relay-servers etc), and also means they don’t have to pay for their services. This approach greatly adds to the network’s scalability and economic effectiveness.</p><p>Also, GEO network supports the issuance of various equivalents (called <em>cross-units</em> in GEO), so any user can create his/her own currency or asset for free and unrestricted exchange.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/769/1*F-0fE7VyERDeL2i_0axi0Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>In GEO, all the relevant data is stored locally in every node</em></figcaption></figure><p>Although local data storage has a number of advantages, it requires a dispute resolving mechanism in the case of unexpected situations. There is such a mechanism in GEO Protocol — the <em>trustline audit</em> — that is performed on a regular basis (frequency can be set by the user), or in a case of critical parameter change (for instance, generation of a new set of encryption keys).</p><p>In the course of the audit, participants’ balances are checked, as well as incoming (the sum a counterparty trusts you with) and outgoing (the sum you trust your counterparty with) trust of both sides of the trustline.</p><p>Since GEO is aimed at enabling a free and unrestricted exchange of any assets, no complete or partial freezing possibility of either account or trustline is provided by the protocol.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>The development of debt obligations (or IOUs) has come a long way from ancient barter to the modern decentralized systems of various solutions. Of course, there are still major challenges, like on-chain based trustlines, centralization attempts, legal issues, and a social acceptance problem. The latter is especially topical, since the recent huge pump and consequent dump of all cryptocurrencies undermined some people’s trust in the industry and the technology, to the extent that those people started to view them as something complicated, less stable, and sometimes even ‘illegal’.</p><p>Of course, the very idea of trust-based transfers sounds quite futuristic for a contemporary audience, since the majority of the population tend not to trust one other, but life has taught us that this idea is viable and could be practically implemented.</p><p>When it is implemented, it could redefine a number of ingrained practices, as well as opening a whole new horizon of vast possibilities.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17e71dc79458" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/trustlines-are-the-new-iou-17e71dc79458">Trustlines are the new IOU</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why there is still no full-fledged Internet of Value?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/why-there-is-still-no-full-fledged-internet-of-value-eecc58889a56?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eecc58889a56</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-value]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[network]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[layer-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[layer-3]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Apr 2019 15:55:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:39.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Despite the emergence of new technologies (both information — data transfer — and financial — blockchain and cryptocurrencies), the world of modern finance is still characterized by isolated networks for creating, storing, transmitting and exchanging values. But why, having entered the era of fast, easy, effective and cheap information exchange (the internet), have we still not entered the era of the Internet of Value? What’s the problem, and is there any new technology that could contribute to its solution?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0Bmfz9AG5nL851DY" /></figure><p>Over the past two decades, we have witnessed the explosive development of information processing and transmission technologies that have revolutionized many aspects of human life, including the economy, as well as our daily lives. At the same time, however, technology for transferring value remains to a large extent at the level it was in the middle of the last century.</p><p>This technological and social skewness cannot stay forever. Following the Internet of Information, the Internet of Money must come true. Or in a broader sense, the Internet of Value, where the transfer of value will occur as quickly, easily and cheaply as the transfer of information occurs today. In addition, the entire global economy as a whole, and each of its participants, in particular, will be able to feel the results of the<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect"> network effect</a> in this sphere.</p><p>But what still stands in the way of this undoubtedly revolutionary innovation? After all, it would seem that there are no limitations to it: a high level of development and penetration of information, <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/network">network</a>, and mobile technologies; the fact that most of the money supply is already digitized (non-cash money); the globalization of the world’s economy — all of this would automatically lead to the emergence of the Internet of Value. However, we still see only its most timid rudiments.</p><p>Of course, these problems are primarily organizational and ideological in nature: financial market players are not in a hurry to overcome inertia, to change established methods of doing business and work patterns and so forth.</p><p>However, another compelling reason why the Internet of Value ​​still remains just a concept is that to date there has been no technology that would allow this to be put into practice.</p><p>Even the emergence and further development of innovations like <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">blockchain</a> and cryptocurrencies, which were created with the hope of sorting out precisely this issue, have yet to yield the anticipated results in this respect. The reasons why this has not happened are on account of the following: blockchains are just another alternative implementation of a value and/or asset registry, which, like other registries (for instance a bank registry, or of an exchange or payment system) is poorly or not connected at all with other value registries.</p><p>Of course, blockchain and cryptocurrencies perfectly solve the problem of trust in a payment system. Thanks to the use of blockchain, payment systems and other value and asset registries build on this technology can get rid of the necessity to have an intermediary or an arbitrator that other participants have to trust, making such systems trustless. But this does not solve the problem of interaction and integration of these systems with other systems, even with those build on similar tech.</p><p>In this sense, blockchain-based ecosystems are not much different from traditional payment ecosystems. Even the most popular blockchains are completely incompatible with each other by default. In addition, most of them have scalability problems, i.e. natural technological limitations on transaction speed and cost. And despite active development of Layer 2 solutions that are designed to overcome these restrictions, these solutions still do not solve the problem of interoperability even within the cryptocurrency market, not to mention the integration of this market with the world of traditional finance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/907/0*sI_B3qJndeBT-AyK" /></figure><p><em>Today the existing local networks of value are isolated with little or no interoperability.</em></p><p>Thus, today we have many heterogeneous ecosystems (local networks of value transfer and exchange), which do not (or at least insufficiently) interact with each other. It is almost like if, instead of the global internet (the network of networks), we had only a bunch of unconnected or loosely coupled LANs (local area networks of information transfer and exchange).</p><p>We now have exactly the same situation in the sphere of finance without the Internet of Value: we have many individual banks, we have payment systems, we have stock exchanges (both traditional and crypto), we have e-wallet providers, etc. We even have several blockchain-based cryptocurrencies, and other value registries. In other words, we have a lot of local networks for value transfer. But they are all poorly connected or weakly interact with each other.</p><p>In the world of siloed networks, competitive spirit oftentimes outweighs cooperation incentives. However, the success of any given network soon reaches its limit, unless the network learns how to benefit from integration within the global ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Creating a universal ecosystem for value transfer networks</strong></p><p>So how can we solve the problem of<a href="https://hackernoon.com/how-off-chain-solutions-can-become-a-tcp-ip-for-the-internet-of-money-17a58922d93b"> creating a global network for value transfer and exchange</a>?</p><p>Different value transfer networks need a universal solution that provides a technological opportunity to interoperate, to lower the costs and to accommodate the growing number of transactions with no speed or safety sacrifices. Such a solution should be open-source, support multi-equivalence, be lightweight, have high productivity and throughput, i.e. it should become, in fact, a network transport protocol for the Internet of Value.</p><p>Today there are at least two technological solutions that aim to deliver this by developing an appropriate technology, which has the potential to become for asset transfer an equivalent of what TCP/IP has become for the ordinary internet. These solutions are Ripple’s subsidiary technology Interledger and<a href="https://geoprotocol.io/"> GEO Protocol</a>. Let’s briefly compare and analyze these two protocol solutions, focusing on their differences:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*evCvNfOPhxdTsO7FXcIuEw.png" /></figure><p>As we can see, GEO Protocol has a number of advantages, that could add up for a better network effect. All that makes GEO potentially a very promising candidate for the role of a universal protocol for the future Internet of Value.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*m-kBdJdP-x1qqRYz" /></figure><p><em>GEO Protocol interconnects various isolated networks of value into the global Internet of Value</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eecc58889a56" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/why-there-is-still-no-full-fledged-internet-of-value-eecc58889a56">Why there is still no full-fledged Internet of Value?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why DLT Is Still Not Adopted en Masse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/why-dlt-is-still-not-adopted-en-masse-5617e28794ce?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5617e28794ce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[layer-3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mass-adoption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trustline]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dlt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Apr 2019 09:21:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:41.814Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Layer 3 development is the next step for blockchain</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vpwoiUttCk2zGGbGR-2gug.jpeg" /></figure><p>Blockchain incompatibility has prompted the idea of <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/the-need-for-layer-3-on-the-internet-of-value-2a62f8e93160">“Layer 3.”</a> Blockchain <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology</a> is one of the most over-hyped technologies in recent years. It suffers from serious teething problems, to say the least. After showing promise being able to overhaul the top-down model of relationships, implementable decentralized solutions in the real world are still a long way off. They are either not fully decentralized or poorly scalable due to low throughput and/or lack of compatibility with other blockchains. Hence, there really is no ecosystem that has adopted it en masse. In this piece, we will take a glance at the main pain-points of existing blockchains and the solutions which aspire to alleviate them.</p><h3>Decentralization Vs. Scalability: a Story of One or the Other</h3><p>The major disappointment is that you cannot achieve all the advantages of blockchain at once. You have to choose one or the other. The necessity of this choice is known as the DCS Theorem, which states you are allowed to implement only two options from the triangle of ‘decentralization — consensus and scalability.’</p><p>Since one of the key features of blockchain is decentralization, every node keeps a full copy of the network status. As a consequence, the blockchain can process only a limited number of transactions. Therefore, a number of nodes capable of dealing with the load can be reduced to a bare minimum, and everything returns to the same old centralization.</p><p>Without the two first qualities of the DCS Theorem — decentralization and consensus — the system loses its original advantage and stops serving the purpose of true decentralization and equality. The more you focus on these two goals, the more complicated it is to apply the system to global markets that require speed and scalability.</p><p>Although the scalability issue has already been addressed by layer 2 solutions, which became all the rage in 2018, this is not the main focus of this post.</p><p>But first, let’s touch upon what they are all about. Layer 2 solutions are an off-chain superstructure on top of a base blockchain represented by state channels or side chains, which allow us to vary the mechanisms for achieving consensus between counterparties. The base layer is reserved for the most sensitive and security-demanding transactions and for anchoring data from sidechains.</p><p>The idea of a state channel reimagines the mechanisms for achieving a consensus between counterparties — it happens locally on the network, not globally. To take advantage of state channels, you have to create a payment channel with a node that is connected to a larger network. The payment lines established between counterparties allow them to transact as many times as they want. The state of the performed transaction is transmitted to the underlying blockchain, hence the name ‘state channels.’ Counterparties do not have to trust each other because their interaction is guided and executed in the form of a smart contract. You can open multiple state channels so that the blockchain is not limited in its scaling.</p><p>The best-known second layer implementations are Liquid and RSK sidechains for Bitcoin, Plasma for Ethereum, and also for projects like the Lightning Network, Raiden Network, and Celer Network. Their main point is increasing throughput, assuring flexibility supported by high security of storage, and transferring value at the base level of the network.</p><p>If we turn to a particular implementation of layer 2 by the Lightning Network, the idea comes down to the capability of opening the payment channel between two users by including a special funding transaction in the underlying blockchain. None of the participants can willfully withdraw money, as both parties sign each other’s transactions.</p><h3>Lack of Interoperability</h3><p>Another standalone, yet related problem, caused by separately developing technologies is the lack of interoperability, which, in practice, means the impossibility of combining patchy blockchain ecosystems to freely exchange values.</p><p>There are a hefty number of incompatibilities in the world that weren’t eliminated at the origin. There are different types of sockets, right- and left-hand traffic, or various railway gauge standards. Many of us have traveled by train at least once in our life, crossing the boundaries of different road standards. The difference in just a few millimeters in width between the rails causes a need to replace the wheels under each car or transfer passengers to another train. At the production level, incompatible standards lead to a situation in which the same train cannot be used on the lines of, for example, Spain and the rest of the EU. This requires a huge investment in the development and testing of individually customized technical nodes by manufacturers.</p><p>The same goes for blockchains, which are all written in different languages and configured for different tasks. If they were interoperable, we would be enabled to transfer values quickly and not rely on centralized exchanges. But there is no law or agreement in place that would force developers to create a one-size-fits-all network.</p><p>None of the projects related to layer 2 address this problem, except Lighting Network’s plans to kick it further down the road. But is it even possible to solve the problem of interoperability at this level?</p><blockquote><em>Insufficient interoperability among payment systems and blockchains is not a task of layer 2 solutions. Ensuring interoperability of separate ecosystems should take on a separate niche, namely </em><a href="https://hackernoon.com/the-need-for-layer-3-on-the-internet-of-value-85ae3ab2a9ea"><em>layer 3</em></a><em>.</em></blockquote><p>The project embarked on advancing the concept of a <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/trustlines-are-the-new-iou-5a10fde5881a">trustline</a>, which resembles the Lightning Network and Raiden’s bidirectional channels. The idea is based on the local consensus of only those users that are involved in a particular transaction but are implemented in the form of mutual trust between them instead of multisig liquidity.</p><p>The system is fuelled by a network of users on different blockchains and digital payment platforms who trust one another to issue and settle IOUs (I owe you). This means that one user can borrow from another who trusts him and then issue a token acknowledging the debt. Participants can create a large network of users who trust one another in the form of chains. This means that two users who do not trust each other can transact through a common intermediary with which they both have a trusting relationship.</p><p>Another concept is the idea composite channels, which are a combination of <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/trustlines-are-the-new-iou-5a10fde5881a">trustlines</a> with user-issued assets and classic state channels with cryptocurrency locked up in an on-chain multisig wallet. This combines scalability with a trustlessness of the base layer <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">blockchain</a> or multiple blockchains.</p><p>The features of <a href="https://hackernoon.com/the-need-for-layer-3-on-the-internet-of-value-85ae3ab2a9ea">layer 3</a> technologies allow finding a common language not only for blockchains but also for decentralized cross-chain exchanges, payment systems, dApps, and IoT-fuelled solutions. The whole point of <a href="https://hackernoon.com/the-need-for-layer-3-on-the-internet-of-value-85ae3ab2a9ea">layer 3</a> technologies is that they are not obsessed with blockchains, but instead, they help them find connections with traditional financial systems, thereby speeding up the adoption of decentralized technologies. This allows us to combine different values holding these systems into a unified Internet of Value, with no boundaries for exchanging various types of assets: cryptocurrency, fiat money, or digital equivalents of virtually any goods and services.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The exchange of values is likely to happen through decentralized solutions. However, the obsession with blockchain and the growing commitment to decentralization is hardly going to be the right way to bring about its adoption en masse. Existing blockchains and auxiliary tools that increase throughput are no longer enough to make it to the end user, who would need to be ready to make purchases and money transfers through DLT.</p><p>It’s safe to say that the interoperability of private blockchains and their compatibility with exchanges and payment systems, both blockchain and server-based, will require new solutions from the developers of layers 2, 3, and beyond.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5617e28794ce" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/why-dlt-is-still-not-adopted-en-masse-5617e28794ce">Why DLT Is Still Not Adopted en Masse</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evolving from Decentralization to Centralization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/evolving-from-decentralization-to-centralization-33e7db8aadd2?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33e7db8aadd2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trustline]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[offchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Mar 2019 14:50:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:24:37.661Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Back to a Decentralized Future</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VC_SNh41tnjECxY3" /></figure><p>Believe it or not, decentralization is nothing new. It first began with the social organization of ancient human societies. They lived together in small Neolithic decentralized communities of less than 100 people where everyone was accountable for one another. Small populations simply made management easier. Such small communities could easily trust one another and the close relationships maintained by individuals made it hard for any of the group to get away with bad or selfish behavior.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6hoFpFFYkFT_OhfE" /><figcaption><em>Decentralized (peer — to — peer)</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>(Image courtesy of</em><a href="https://www.slideshare.net/johanngevers/johann-gevers-the-four-pillars-of-a-decentralized-society"><em> Johann Gevers</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>As a result, the social structure that existed prior to the agrarian revolution consisted of a decentralized society where interactions were between individuals living in a society with a limited hierarchical structure.</p><p>Basically, there was no need for rulers to govern and control interactions since everyone was self-reliant.</p><p>However, as communities began to focus more on agriculture as a means of food production, suddenly there was more food and communities grew from paltry groupings of 100 people to larger societies of several hundred people.</p><h3>Neolithic Age: the birth of the Agrarian Revolution</h3><p>History is not precisely clear on what triggered the agrarian revolution. However, as communities became more sophisticated, the Neolithic Age became marked by a period of transition from small nomadic groups of hunters and gatherers to larger settlements of early agricultural civilizations.</p><p><a href="https://www.history.com/topics/pre-history/neolithic-revolution">History</a> also reveals that this period started in the fertile crescent of the Middle East. This is where humans first came up with farming tools around 10,000 BC, shortly after the Stone Age. In fact, some scholars call this period the <a href="https://www.history.com/topics/stone-age">New Stone Age</a>.</p><p>This is because during this period, even though humans had just started practicing agriculture, they still depended on stone tools and hoes to eke out an existence.</p><p>Even in the early stages of the agrarian revolutions, communities were only able to sustain a small population that practiced hunting and gathering as a subsidy to their farming practices.</p><p>V. Gordon Childe (an Australian archeologist who coined the term Neolithic Revolution) mentions that this period coincided with the separation of the Neolithic people from their Paleolithic ancestors who were known for their rudimentary chipped stone tools. Just as new technologies such as the internet (in present times) created a shift from old social norms to new ones, so did agriculture.</p><p>But how did these small communities transform into hierarchical complex societies dependant on centralized forms of government?</p><h3>Formation of cities and towns</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YynxCZ7jAw67XkJz" /><figcaption><em>Centralized (Command &amp; Control)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The idea of a ruler dictating the day to day lives of their subjects came about as a result of seeking solutions to developing problems. The agrarian revolution resulted in increased food production and as communities grew larger, it simply became impractical to maintain order without a central authority to oversee social interactions.</p><p>According to conventional views, it was after the Neolithic period that cities began to form. Even with the lack of evidence on the conditions that gave rise to towns and cities, theorists speculate that the growing human population and the benefits that come with dense settlements must have contributed to the formation of early cities and towns.</p><p><a href="https://www.history.com/topics/pre-history/neolithic-revolution">According to Childe</a>, it was during this time that humans started living together in organized communities. Actually, most researchers agree that there was no single factor that triggered the Neolithic Revolution; however, scientists theorize that perhaps the end of the Ice age 14,000 years ago must have led to climate change with the earth getting warmer hence triggering the agrarian revolution. The aftermath was increasing advancement towards agriculture, marked by a growing network of interactions among human beings that necessitated centralized social structures.</p><p>It is believed that farming immigrants replaced foragers and increased food production, resulting in higher population density per unit of land, hence increased development of towns and cities. Adding to this idea<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_city"> is Paul Bairoch’s</a> book titled Cities and Economic Development. He argues that agriculture appears to be a necessary precursor to the formation of towns and cities.</p><p>After all, at the time, living in dense populations as opposed to sparsely populated communities had clear advantages including:</p><ul><li>Reduced costs of transportation</li><li>Interaction and exchange of ideas</li><li>Large local markets</li><li>Easy sharing of natural resources</li><li>Easy access to amenities such as security, access to running water and sewage disposal</li></ul><h3>How did empires emerge?</h3><p>Well, as communities evolved to have increasing dependence on agriculture, people started learning how to produce a variety of products. For instance, they learned how to increase labor intensity through the use of animals. Cultivation increased and they began to produce wool, milk and other products. This increase in food and resources further increased the population from about 6 million in 8,000 BC to about<a href="https://www.khanacademy.org/partner-content/big-history-project/agriculture-civilization/first-cities-states/a/intro-to-agrarian-civilizations"> 50 million in 3,000 BC</a>.</p><p>Larger communities resulted in the increased complexity of disputes that had to be solved. And, with more interactions, some individuals found better and faster ways to trade and acquire wealth.</p><p>Therefore, as a need for better organizational structures arose, chiefs and village elders took up the responsibility of facilitating trust and accountability in the growing communities.</p><p>Eventually, social structures completely changed and as the complexity of trade increased, a small group of the population became increasingly wealthy and powerful. The idea of money gained traction as people devised new ways to exchange farm products.</p><h3>The evolution of a monetary system</h3><p>One of the most important modern inventions that came about as a result of the agrarian revolution is the idea of money. At the time, history reveals that the barter trade was the most common mode of trade. Eventually, however, the drawbacks of bartering as a medium of exchange increased and traders started using commodity money such as cows, salt, wine, and precious stones.</p><p>But even commodity money proved to be an unsustainable idea. There was also a period where metallic money became popular among early traders as a form of currency, but due to issues of trust, weight, and purity, a new concept of money was needed.</p><p>For this reason, kingdoms emerged as a way of giving legitimacy to paper money in the form of IOU contracts to the monarch.</p><h3>The rise of government</h3><p>It is not clear how monarchs came to be, but it can be assumed that early communities needed better management of projects like irrigation and building of surplus food storage facilities. In fact,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number"> Robin Dunbar</a>, an award-winning anthropologist, and evolutionary psychologist, believes that beyond the amenities that are accessible in cities and towns, one of the biggest contributing factors to the move from decentralized societies to centralized ones was the need for armed protection against neighboring groups.</p><h3>Dunbar’s Number</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yCPFJUZ2Y6Gy2RDI" /></figure><p>In his theory, Dunbar’s number limits the number of individuals in a community with whom we can maintain stable relationships. The theory of<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number"> Dunbar’s number</a> holds that 150 is the maximum number for any group of humans to maintain harmony as a community. Beyond that threshold, people will have difficulty keeping track of each other, leading to a collapse of society. Dunbar’s number explains why it became increasingly difficult for community members to trust one another and have healthy social interactions.</p><p>According to Dunbar’s theory, the reason why 150 is the limit to healthy communal relationships among humans is that it takes effort for the individual to build networks beyond this number. An individual has to commit to giving more time to nurture personal relationships through gifts and favors that improve interdependence among members of a community.</p><p>These relationships were vitally important as they enabled individuals to pay back in kind during trade and other social interactions. Therefore, establishing a sense of trust and security, according to Dunbar’s theory, was achievable with a small community. However, above the 150 marks, communities required a centralized authority to keep track of who was trustworthy and who was not. To resolve this, the monarch provided a trustworthy borrower of money that was used to pay the army for the protection of the subjects. It also provided a judicial system for the benefit of the subjects.</p><h3>Back to governance</h3><p>Therefore, out of the need for armed protection, empires emerged. The power that was previously controlled by wealthy individuals became institutionalized into political and religious groups. The political groups provided protection as well as a reliable trust system for trade and the flow of information.</p><p>As you can see, all throughout history, agrarian societies were marked with extremes of rigid<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarian_society"> social mobility</a> and social classes. Even though the specific point in time where the development of human government started is not clear, studies show that the development of irrigation technologies for agricultural projects was a catalyst in the developing need for governance.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government">David Christian</a> puts it vividly in his book ‘Maps of Time’ where he says “Farming populations gathered in larger and denser communities, interactions between different groups increased and the social pressure rose until, in a striking parallel with star formation, new structures suddenly appeared, together with a new level of complexity. Like stars, cities, and states reorganized and energized the smaller objects within their gravitational field.”</p><p>Ultimately, the land became the major source of wealth; the development of social hierarchy based on land ownership was inevitable. This gave rise to the governing class and the masses. In some areas, tribal chiefs were elected by various rituals that tested an individual’s leadership and military strength while in other cases a group of elders acted as the ruling class of the community. Eventually, the landowning strata became a combination of religion, the government, and the military. These three social elements justified enforcement of ownership, leading to a rigid stratification of the societies as seen in the<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarian_society"> Caste system of India</a> and other examples.</p><h3>The Pros and cons of centralization</h3><p>Obviously, there is a clear-cut difference between centralization and decentralization. Already, we have seen the importance of a centralized system in its role to create order, reliability, and trust.</p><p>But, as society became more complex, the structure of centralized societies evolved as well. Centralized governing structures developed better levels of consistency that were more cost-efficient and fair to all. Waste was eliminated and the ruling class was able to focus on long-term planning and decision-making to the benefit of the whole community. Furthermore, a mix between decentralization and centralization was established to enable flexibility and peak performance of development projects.</p><p>Other advantages of centralization that stood out included:</p><ul><li>With a centralized authority in place, cost of production eventually reduced due to standardized procedures of trade and production</li><li>Uniformity in action was also achieved thanks to the control of central administration</li><li>Improved quality of work was also attained</li><li>Finally, with direct supervision and control, centralization enabled better coordination in society.</li></ul><p>Overall, the main advantage of adopting a centralized system was and still is efficiency. Decisions are made quickly in a centralized system and there is little to zero duplication of roles. Plus, as a result of centralized authorities, societies can become fairly stable, consistent and predictable, especially when it comes to projects that involve the collective. Besides, it’s also easy to establish control and accountability in case things don’t work out as expected.</p><p>But of course, such advantages don’t come without drawbacks. While there are clear positives, that have added to the rise and success of centralized systems, most of them also have a number of pitfalls that sometimes outweigh the good to a significant extent.</p><p>Some of the shortcomings of centralization include the following issues.</p><h3>Abuse of power</h3><p>One of the biggest downside to centralization is its assumption that the top leadership always has the interests of the subjects at heart.</p><p>All through history, it has been shown that a centralized system of authority attracts the worst of characters or rather turns good characters to bad.</p><p>One notoriousexample is how Hitler managed to assert his autocracy that led to a massive genocide of the Jewish community. Even though Germany at the time had a democracy, the state was characterized by a weak democracy that easily gave way to Hitler’s autocracy.</p><p>Other examples of autocracy as a result of centralized political structures include the Roman emperors who declared themselves gods, not to mention Napoleon Bonaparte who took power, declaring himself emperor.</p><p>The reality is that throughout the history of civilization, centralized forms of governance always end up with autocratic forms of leadership and as<a href="https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/absolute-power-corrupts-absolutely.html"> John Emerich Edward Dalberg Acton (1834–1902)</a> would put it, “Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”</p><h3>Slow down inefficiency</h3><p>As centralized systems develop further, they experience a reduction in the level of efficiency. For starters, since most of the decisions are made at the top to affect the subjects at the bottom of the pyramid, there is bound to be a disconnect that results in resentment by the subordinates. Plus, since the top leadership is tasked with making the decisions, the entire approach can be overwhelming and thus the quality and speed of arbitration eventually goes down.</p><h3>Censorship</h3><p>Apart from the abuse of power, and the eventual reduction in efficiency, another disadvantage of centralization is censorship. In the political sphere, China has had the most centralized form of government in the world.<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralisation"> Centralization of authority</a> was first introduced in China during the Qin Dynasty. The dynasty entailed a consistent effort to concentrate authority to the Qin government. The first Emperor, Qin Shi Huang, managed to control his territories by setting up new laws and regulations. However, even though the military and government of ancient China thrived, the situation escalated into a high level of censorship.</p><p>Currently, as a result of a long history of extremely centralized forms of government, China has no freedom of the press and information is constantly filtered by the government to control people’s perceptions and ideas.</p><p>In fact, economist.com reports that China’s internet is the world’s most centralized and most censored. Furthermore, the report shows that there are over<a href="https://www.economist.com/special-report/2018/06/28/china-has-the-worlds-most-centralised-internet-system"> 2 million content controllers</a> working in China’s internet industry today. Plus, some Beijing based tech companies are working to enroll blockchain <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology</a> in order to come up with<a href="https://www.economist.com/special-report/2018/06/28/china-has-the-worlds-most-centralised-internet-system"> a technological world domination system</a>.</p><p>Just in the same way the internet has been used as a tool to exert centralized censorship, so has education. While education is supposed to teach children critical thinking and evaluation of information in the form of intellectual debates and arguments, countries like Iran are banning the teaching of English in order to limit “<a href="https://www.studyinternational.com/news/op-ed-centralized-education-stealthy-censorship-tool/">Western Cultural Invasion</a>”.</p><p>As is evident with the above examples, any form of centralization will lead to a concentration of all the power at the central top point in the pyramid.<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QlYgNH2t43U"> Just like a pyramid</a>, the larger the base (i.e. the larger the number of commoners <strong>C</strong> at the bottom), the larger the power concentrated at the tip of the pyramid, hence the greater the risk of anarchy. You can almost always guarantee that when there are no systems of checks and balance on the ruling elite, the ruling elite will become bad actors in the system and censorship will prevail.</p><h3>Why decentralization is important</h3><p>The above examples, among other bodies of evidence, highlight the problems caused by highly centralized systems. Basically, if left unchecked, centralized systems will lead to unbalanced exertion of control by the select few elites. For this reason, decentralization, a process that distributes and delegates decision-making and planning away from central authority, is important. Throughout history, and even in the contemporary world, the concept of decentralization has been applied in order to improve the shortcomings of centralization. Right from the start, western civilization has been marked by instances where mankind has attempted to break down the pillars of centralization. Some of the main examples include the following cases.</p><h3>The birth of democracy</h3><p>Democracy is mostly viewed as the bedrock upon which decentralization thrives. In fact, the entirety of western civilization is founded on first attempts made in Athens to bring power to the people. Granted, the Athens approach was still centralized in that only a select group of individuals could vote in a leader. However, it was a major advancement towards decentralization compared to a system that placed the fate of an entire civilization on one individual. The concept of democracy has been impaired by issues of corruption and lack of efficiency. However, since its invention in 508 BC in Athens, it still remains one of the noblest endeavors in human civilization. This system of governance has resulted in great artistic and scientific innovations as well.</p><h3>Printing press</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/0*6R29BXtow3OWcS9k" /></figure><p><em>Early Press, etching from Early Typography by William Skeen</em></p><p>Compared to medieval Europe, the world today is far more knowledgeable with a wealth of information at arm’s reach. This was not always the case. Before the invention of the printing press, the flow of information was controlled by a highly centralized system led by religious leaders and the government. For instance, religious texts such as the Bible could only be read by religious leaders who the people trusted for the right interpretation. Thanks to the printing press, information that was previously under the control of the elite, including the Bible, was finally easily accessible. Using technologies such as the pigeon post, ideas were shared around the world and the centralized control over the flow of information collapsed. Even though the owners of the few available printing presses at the time could still exert control over information at the time, the rise of libraries enabled decentralization of information and power.</p><h3>Internet</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lWPwLZy7ph3L8uOz" /></figure><p>The printing press brought about the beginning of print as consumable media; however, it eventually assumed a centralized approach where owners of the newspapers and publishing houses controlled the flow of information. The gatekeepers maintained their position for quite some time until the advent of the internet. Today, the internet has made it possible for everyone to act as their own publisher and there is little censorship in the sharing of ideas. In fact, apart from consumable media, the internet has decentralized a lot of industries including finance with the invention of digital money.</p><h3>Decentralized distributed ledger technology</h3><p>Distributed ledger technologies are not new. They have formed the backbone of cloud computing and they provide a reliable solution for accounting and record keeping. A DLT is a protocol of interconnected machines in a network that has no central server disseminating information, rather, the connected machines agree with each other to reach a consensus for the sharing and storage of information. Thanks to the consensus protocol that all the machines agree upon, once the information is stored on the ledger, it would require the consensus of all the machines for that information to be changed. This provides immutability, security, and transparency in a trustless system. DLTs such as blockchain have made it possible for cryptocurrencies to function and thrive. Now, the concept of money is also getting decentralized through cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. This is possible since digital money can now have an immutable digital identity and thus solve the problem of double spending. Even though cryptocurrencies have a long way to go before they become universal legal tender, it goes without saying that this new technology holds a lot of potential for further decentralizing in the <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/future">future</a>.</p><h3>Final thoughts: the future is decentralized</h3><p>As you can see, decentralization is essential for the advancement of civilization. Furthermore, decentralization through technologies like blockchain can bring about transparency and accountability in governance, finance, and communication. Sectors such as supply chain management, property rights, contractual agreements, and digital identity can benefit tremendously from decentralized technologies. Overall, it has become quite evident that blockchains have a role to play in good governance, global sustainability, and equitable economic development. In fact, the United Nations is already looking to leverage alternative financial mechanisms with the help of blockchain technology in order to support entrepreneurship and advance its<a href="http://www.undp.org/content/dam/undp/library/innovation/The-Future-is-Decentralised.pdf"> sustainable development goals (SDGs</a>). Programs by global organizations such as the SDGs can set the pace for broader levels of transparency, collaboration, and exchange across the globe. In the next chapter, we will look deeper into the reasons for decentralization and how it can shape the future.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33e7db8aadd2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/evolving-from-decentralization-to-centralization-33e7db8aadd2">Evolving from Decentralization to Centralization</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Meaning of ‘Trust’ in the Fintech World]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/the-meaning-of-trust-in-the-fintech-world-9bfc2a5ccd6a?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9bfc2a5ccd6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Mar 2019 14:55:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:43.068Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JIRuoM5PB5jKXC3z" /></figure><p>Believe it or not, a major issue that has bedeviled the financial sector, especially after the widespread adoption of digital payment methods, is an overreliance on trusted third parties — or simply ‘trust’ — to complete transactions.</p><p>It could be argued that trust is now a highly valued commodity and indeed, many players in the financial sector have it as their primary product on the market.</p><p>That is not such a good thing, however, for a number of reasons.</p><h3>How exactly is trust a pain point in the delivery of financial services?</h3><p>The ‘trust’ pain point can be experienced in four ways:</p><h4><strong>1. The vulnerability of user data in centralized data centers.</strong></h4><p>Data is critical in the provision of all kinds of financial services, especially so in the case of centralized payment systems. It is through data that service providers can authenticate customers, measure risk, ascertain credit score or worthiness, predict revenue flows or, to put it simply, make financial transactions possible.</p><p>But collecting, storing and manipulating this data is a very complex undertaking. In particular, keeping it safe and secure means locking bad actors out of centralized data centers who happen to be highly skilled and motivated.</p><p>Stakeholders and, in particular, consumers have to trust that those entrusted with the data centers will prevail at doing their job correctly at all times.</p><p>But most importantly, they have to trust that these data stewards do not themselves turn out to be the bad guys. The motive to misuse the data under one’s care for financial benefit is almost always present.</p><p>It must be said that in centralized systems that power many financial services, consumers are completely helpless, not only as to how their data is secured but also how it is used. They only have to trust that someone is competent and of good intentions.</p><p>Unfortunately, cases of data breaches are so common and abuse of user data is almost the norm.</p><h4><strong>2. Difficulty in authenticating an identity of counterparties in transactions.</strong></h4><p>Establishing, ascertaining and authenticating the identity of counterparties and stakeholders is at the core of transaction execution. That is the case with both centralized and decentralized payment systems.</p><p>Obviously, it is never a great idea to take at face value what people present themselves to be. That is because people always have reasons and motives to misrepresent themselves, especially where value is involved.</p><p>This is why financial service providers have to rely on robust systems to help identify those they deal with. The need is made necessary even more by the ‘know your customer’ (KYC) regulatory compliance requirements.</p><p>But to make the process easier, service providers and customers have to trust third-party validators to provide accurate data. They also have to trust that the data reaches them without being tampered with in one way or another. This is especially critical given that data in digital form, especially in centralized systems, is not immutable.</p><p>And the cost that financial institutions have to incur to establish identity is always substantial. According to a <a href="https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/Accenture/Conversion-Assets/DotCom/Documents/Global/PDF/Dualpub_9/Accenture-Future-Identity-Banking.pdf">report prepared by management consulting firm Accenture</a> on identity and banking, financial institutions spend more than 30% of their security budget on authenticating identity.</p><h4>3. Difficulty in providing legitimacy to digital signatures.</h4><p>Even with the substantial digitization of financial services, it is still difficult to approve transactions, especially where substantial amounts are involved, without certain steps for approval being performed manually.</p><p>In most systems, it is necessary for a few trusted persons to have the ability to ensure that transactions are legitimate and meet required specifications. While this is a helpful preventative measure, it slows the movement of value and the completion of transactions.</p><p>But even more importantly, it makes it almost impossible to sign transactions without sharing personally identifying information to trusted overseers and others. And this increases the risk of privacy infringements.</p><h4>4. Slow settlement and reconciliation of transactions</h4><p>Because of the need for trusted centralized facilitators to manually settle cross-border transactions and perform reconciliations, service delivery is slowed even though the internet has made the flow of information fast.</p><p>It is common for users to wait through the weekend or public holidays to the next business day to have their transactions confirmed or approved.</p><p>And even after the transaction is completed, it might take several weeks before a trusted third party gets the time to conduct reconciliation, which makes it hard to catch errors in real-time when they are fresh and easier to fix.</p><h3>So what is the meaning of trust in the fintech world?</h3><p>The cumulative cost that goes into acquiring different forms of the notary, auditing or approval services from trusted third parties makes financial services expensive. <a href="https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2018/04/19/financial-inclusion-on-the-rise-but-gaps-remain-global-findex-database-shows">According to a World Bank report</a> that was funded by the Bill &amp; Melinda Gates Foundation, over 26% of the 2.5 billion adults who are unbanked around the globe cite the cost of transactions as their reason.</p><p>Within the fintech space, is actualized in many ways. But let’s start with what it actually means.</p><p>In general, trust means treating the customer fairly and being transparent, including the fees charged for transactions.</p><p>More practically though, it means putting data protection and user control in the hands of consumers.</p><p>It also means stakeholders having a single source of truth from which they can establish the verifiable identity of those they are doing business with. That translates to having the ability to prove that people are who they say they are without them exposing personal data or having trusted third parties to vouch for them.</p><p>It also means consumers being able to carry their proven identity, credit score and profiles across platforms with the ability to prove that the data is credible.</p><p>Trust also means having transactions settled and reconciled in real-time so that all stakeholders get to notice at the time when things are not done, executed or recorded appropriately.</p><p>In particular, this means having stakeholders have access to an immutable shared ledger where they can see transaction settlement and reconciliation.</p><h3>How exactly is financial technology achieving this kind of trust?</h3><p>Financial <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology </a>— or fintech — is all about using innovation to fix pain points that consumers face when accessing financial services. This can be achieved through existing institutions or new and fresh startups built as challenger financial institutions.</p><p>The ultimate goal of gaining this new form of trust is to improve service delivery, secure transactions, protect user data and cut costs involved.</p><p>The technology that is achieving this very efficiently is decentralized ledgers, popularly referred to as blockchains.</p><p>Blockchains allow for storage of digital data in an immutable state. The technology also makes it possible for many stakeholders to securely have access to a shared ledger that they maintain through real-time consensus on a peer-to-peer network.</p><p>An extremely revolutionary concept about blockchains, though, is that through public-private key cryptography, user data is encrypted on the shared public ledger. With that done, only the owner of data can grant access.</p><p>And even then the credibility of the data can be proven without its details being disclosed because not even the owner of the data can change it.</p><p>The immutability of digital data on the <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">blockchain</a> makes it possible for users to move across platforms with their already proven identity. Those who transact or come into contact with the identity do not have to trust the owner because they can easily and with no significant cost prove its credibility.</p><h3>Beyond the blockchain and decentralized ledger</h3><p>While blockchains are decentralized, the different types of ledgers currently exist as siloed systems. There are over 3,000 independent major public and private blockchains, and the number is growing very fast with new projects launching every year.</p><p>Meanwhile, it is unrealistic to think that centralized payment systems will become obsolete anytime soon. That means solutions to nudge the industry into efficiency and also deal with monopolization and make integration less complex are needed.</p><p>And that also means that for there to be free flow of value around the world, the different payment and value transfer systems have to interoperate. In other words, they have to be part of a ‘world wide web’ of some sort for value.</p><p>The quick fix to create this <em>Internet of Value</em> is to have trusted third parties to interpose between platforms. Unfortunately, that takes us to the initial problem of relying on trusted third parties to complete transactions.</p><p>Avoiding this cycle is exactly what open source projects like <a href="https://geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a> and Interledger are working towards fixing.</p><p>The general solution they offer is creating trustline-based protocols that act as paths for value across different platforms without the need to trust centralized entities. This is achievable in particular through IOU architectures that rely on state channels and similar technologies to settle cross-chain transactions.</p><p>In particular, it involves leveraging trust that exists in peer-to-peer interactions, which is known as ‘transitive trust.’ Simply put, it means that we trust our family, best friends, colleagues and so on. But, we also trust those people who our family, friends, and colleagues trust. If I trust my boss, I also trust those people whom my boss trusts. This creates a chain or path of trust that value can flow through without the need to rely on a third party to determine the credibility of this or that network participant.</p><p>These trustline-based protocols that vouch on transitive trust across different blockchains and centralized payment systems can give the movement of value what the internet gave to the movement of information. And the best part? For this to occur, we don’t need to trust huge centralized entities.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9bfc2a5ccd6a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/the-meaning-of-trust-in-the-fintech-world-9bfc2a5ccd6a">The Meaning of ‘Trust’ in the Fintech World</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[TRUSTED VS TRUSTLESS: THE ROLE OF TRUST IN THE MEANS OF EXCHANGE OPERATION]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/trusted-vs-trustless-the-role-of-trust-in-the-operation-of-means-of-exchange-2215ea9ba383?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2215ea9ba383</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Mar 2019 13:18:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:44.456Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rnlECb7UfnHB3jeO" /></figure><p>‘Trustless’ has become a rallying cry for <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/bitcoin">Bitcoin</a> evangelists, focusing public attention on the fact that Bitcoin enables P2P transactions without the participation of a trusted third party acting as an intermediary.</p><p>Bitcoin makes it possible to conduct money transfers without intermediaries. Intermediaries who could otherwise gain control over funds in a transaction, censor transactions or act as points of failure. Does this give grounds to assert that Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are a form of money that does not require trust? Is it possible to completely eliminate trust from monetary relations, and is there even a need to? This article is devoted to the study of the role of trust in monetary transactions (including cryptocurrencies), and its main conclusion is that this role is hard to overestimate.</p><p>The article is divided into four sections. First, we analyze the role of trust in monetary relations, including the role of trust in Bitcoin’s functioning, and show that trust is necessary for any money. Next, we proceed to justify the need for credit and credit money, which cannot exist without trust. After that, we will look at the limitations of trustless solutions for cryptocurrency-based off-chain transactions. Finally, we will propose a method to overcome those limitations, essentially by expanding the range of means of exchange that are used in off-chain transactions.</p><p><strong>The role of trust in the functioning of money</strong></p><p>In the book “<em>Money between violence and trust</em>”, Michel Aglietta and Andre Orlean formulated three forms of trust associated with the functioning of money [1].</p><p><strong>Methodical trust.</strong> Money differs from ordinary goods by the characteristic of direct exchange. Individuals are willing to exchange their goods for money, only because they believe that the monetary form can then be exchanged for any other product on the market. That is why the functions of money can be manifested through such relatively useless things as scraps of paper or records in a database: a person doesn’t care what money is made of if they are sure that they can exchange it for any product or service.</p><p>This belief arises mainly from the previous experience of the successful exchange of goods for money by many individuals. The high frequency of such exchanges strengthens the payment community’s confidence, united by the use of money, that this unwritten rule of exchange will be observed in the future.</p><p>Will Bitcoin be able to perform the money functions if individuals do not believe that they can always exchange it for any product or service, or at least for other money? No. Before the appearance of market makers who began to buy and sell bitcoins, thus strengthening the public’s faith in its relatively stable exchangeability with money, Bitcoin was merely a plaything for a narrow circle of cypherpunks. If for some reason this belief is lost, Bitcoin will only retain the modest role of a digital collectible item.</p><p><strong>Hierarchical trust.</strong> Methodical confidence in itself is quite fragile. In pursuit of profit, the rules of money exchange on which this form of trust is based could be violated. For example, bad actors could produce fake money or suddenly refuse to accept money as a means of payment, demanding something else in return. So, an authority with the ability to enforce monetary rules must support the honest members of the payment community. Hierarchical trust is the belief of individuals in the ability of this authority to maintain established monetary rules, including possible punishments for violators.</p><p>As a rule, this function is performed by the state. For example, the state has the capacity to punish counterfeiters. The harm that counterfeiters bring to the economy is not limited to the losses of those who received fake money in exchange for their goods or in repayment of a loan. Counterfeiters undermine the methodical confidence of all members of the payment community: confidence in the rules of exchange as well as in counter-parties. And confidence in the payment community itself, without which normal economic relations are impossible.</p><p>The state has legitimate instruments for coercing individuals to use money with the status of legal tender. A debtor can be sure that he/she will be able to pay off his debt with this money regardless of the whims or tricks of a creditor. A seller of goods can be sure that he/she will be able to use the money received for the goods for his or her future purchases. Thus, methodical trust is strengthened by hierarchical trust.</p><p>One of the slogans of Bitcoin evangelists is the formula “code is law”. In their opinion, government coercion to execute monetary rules is not necessary if these rules are hard-coded into Bitcoin. However, experience shows that the code regularly turns out to be imperfect and this can be used by intruders for the “illegal” emission of a cryptocurrency [2]. <em>“What blockchain does is shift some of the trust in people and institutions to trust in technology.” </em>[3]</p><p>If we ignore the possibility of abuse of all sorts of bugs, then there is, for example, a 51% attack that allows a bad actor to perform a double-spend of bitcoins. Such an attack can also be compared to counterfeiting of a fiat currency.</p><p>Bitcoin, unlike national currencies, does not have the status of a legal tender. Nobody is obligated to exchange goods or money for bitcoins, nor to accept it as a mean of paying off debts.</p><p>Will the methodical trust of Bitcoin be strengthened if the state punishes anyone who attempts to profit by breaking the rules of this payment community? Will methodical trust in the Bitcoin be strengthened after one or more states declare it legal tender? You do not need to be a professional economist or sociologist to answer these questions.</p><p><strong>Ethical trust.</strong> The state strengthens methodical confidence in money, but there is a third, more fundamental form of trust that limits political power over money. This is the trust of individuals in the social system offered by the government. If individuals lose faith in the project of the society proposed by the authorities, or the authorities violate the values ​​of this society, then individuals can begin to introduce new rules of exchange, despite government efforts to save their existing monetary system.</p><p>The importance of the ethical form of trust is particularly pronounced during periods of social upheaval, especially during wars. Each of the belligerents can issue their own money, and individuals can accept money from one party or another based not only on coercion, but also on the project of society they support. A less tragic example of the role of ethical confidence in money is the confrontation between supporters of gold and fiat money. If gold money is supported by free market advocates, then fiat money is supported by those who believe that government should interfere in the economy.</p><p>Bitcoin emerged as an alternative to the project of a society determined by state authorities. This alternative ideology, another project of the society that gave birth to Bitcoin, is called<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto-anarchism"> crypto-anarchism</a>. In this system, there is (by definition) no central authority that can win or lose the trust of individuals. But this does not mean that Bitcoin is not vulnerable to potential crises of ethical trust.</p><p>Even in Bitcoin’s short history there are examples of a kind of “civil war”, during which the payment community was split on the basis of ideology. The material result of such splits are forks. The most prominent “civil war” was a dispute over the size of the block. The party of crypto-anarchists were in favor of limiting the block size to protect the network from centralization, and the business-oriented party supported the increase of the block size for their commercial reasons. Crypto-anarchists who have lost faith in the privacy of the Bitcoin transactions, due to the development of services like Chainalysis [4], have switched to Bitcoin forks with increased privacy, or to alternative cryptocurrencies that use ring signatures, or zero-knowledge proof.</p><p>There is another example of ethical trust’s role in the history of the Bitcoin [5]. In periods of economic and social crises, when state power and the money offered by it has lost the trust of individuals, Bitcoin has come to the rescue — precisely due to its stateless nature.</p><p><strong>The role of credit and credit money in the functioning of the economy</strong></p><p>Bitcoin was conceived as digital cash, allowing exchange without intermediaries. Today, transactions in the Bitcoin network are de facto carried out through intermediaries: mining pools and third-party wallet services that store the private keys of their users. But this does not change the essence of Bitcoin as digital cash. You can still run a full node, store your keys by yourself and try to add your own bitcoin transactions to the <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">blockchain</a>.</p><p>Whatever the form of a given type of money — gold, paper, or digital — it cannot serve the economy alone. For several centuries, cash has been working in solid lockstep with credit money; or, as it is also called, non-cash money.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_theory_of_money">Credit money</a>, as the name implies, is based on credit. Therefore, before we talk about credit money, it is necessary to say a few words about credit itself.</p><p>The need for credit arises from the fact that different manufacturers and different products have different terms of production and sale. Thus, economies always contain, on the one hand, individuals with temporarily free resources; and, on the other hand, individuals experiencing a temporary need for additional resources. The former provide the latter with their resources for temporary use, thereby maintaining the continuity of the capitalist reproduction process. Capitalism cannot function and develop normally without credit. Without credit, the modern economy is simply unthinkable.</p><p>The first medium of exchange that was born out of credit relations is a promissory note. A buyer of goods on credit wrote out a promissory note to a seller, which was an obligation of the buyer to pay a fixed amount of cash within a prescribed period. The seller could transfer this bill to a third party in exchange for goods or cash, and the spread of such practices led to the fact that promissory notes of exchange were used as a medium of exchange along with cash.</p><p>The advantage of promissory notes in comparison with cash, (the functions of which were performed by precious metals), was that promissory notes were much more convenient and cheaper to store and transport. The disadvantage of promissory notes was their limited term of validity, and the absence of a fixed range of face values (that would allow any given amount to be paid with this kind of means of exchange).</p><p>These drawbacks are overcome by a banknote: paper money, representing credit money issued by banks. The banknote was a debt instrument with no fixed validity term, (i.e. it did not have an expiration date), and could be redeemed in metal money at any time. In addition, banks issued banknotes with a fixed number of face values.</p><p>Banks issued loans with their banknotes against the security of commercial promissory notes, thereby “re-minting“ the bills of merchants into their own debt obligations. This made it possible to grow the circulation of credit money to a new level, since banknotes coped with the role of ‘means of exchange’ much better than commercial promissory notes.</p><p>Often, a classic banknote is a banknote fully backed by a precious metal; but in reality, the full security of banknotes was an exception. The issuance of banknotes in excess of collateral satisfied demand when the market was hungry for cash. The limited supply of gold is a natural barrier to an increase in the supply of means of exchange, for which the growing capitalist economy has shown increasing demand. Credit money allows the economy to go beyond this natural limit.</p><p>The need to issue banknotes in excess of collateral is particularly pronounced in periods of economic crises, when cash rapidly leaves circulation in preference of savings and thereby causes a shortage of means of payment.</p><p>An example of an attempt to ban the issue of banknotes without full security is the Robert<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_Charter_Act_1844"> Peel Banking Act of 1844</a>. This act gave the Bank of England a monopoly on the issue of banknotes, but at the same time limited its issuing activity by requiring a 100% security of banknotes in gold [6]. Three years later, with the onset of an economic crisis, the government exercised its right to suspend this act. During the economic crises of 1857 and 1866, it did the same. The Bank of England was able to issue banknotes in excess of the available collateral to cope with the shortage of means of payment without aggravating the crisis. Choosing between full provision of banknotes and the rescue of the economy, the British government wisely chose the latter option.</p><p>The refusal of the US Federal Reserve to reduce the deficit aggravated the economic crisis, contributing to the Great Depression. The period of the Great Depression is replete with examples of how private credit money without full security can be a salvation from economic crises and cash shortages. During this period,<a href="https://blokt.com/news/how-distributed-technology-can-help-regional-currencies"> thousands of local communities</a> in the United States, Canada and Western Europe created their own credit money systems, including examples without full cash support. As a rule, these local means of exchange functioned successfully until the government prohibited them, (seeing them as a threat to their monopoly on the issuance of money [7]).</p><p>Despite the fact that governments maintain a monopoly to this day, the modern economy is dominated by private credit money issued by commercial banks. As before, banks issue credit money, “re-minting” the debt obligations of their borrowers into their own debt obligations. The share of cash in the money supply of developed countries is less than 10%. Commercial banks issue credit money without full provision of national currency, but the government does not see this as a threat to its monopoly on issuance. On the contrary, governments support the movement towards a cashless economy [9].</p><p>Vouchers are also debt obligations, but unlike banknotes are redeemed in goods rather than money. These debt instruments can solve various problems. The sale of gift cards and other vouchers allows the seller to receive a free loan, which will be repaid with the seller’s goods in the future. Bonus points that can be exchanged for goods can increase customer loyalty. Writing off small change to the buyer’s account, which they can use for future purchases, allows the seller to continue to trade during any shortages of small-face-value cash. The possibility of transferring vouchers to a third party, as in the case of commercial promissory notes, allows them to be used as a means of exchange.</p><p>Despite the popularity of the trustless principle in the cryptocurrency ecosystem, there remains a place for credit money. Bitcoin’s primary trading pair (as of December 2018) was stablecoin Tether (USDT) [10]. USDT is electronic money secured by US dollars. Like the classic banknote, the USDT collateral is not stored in a smart contract, but in a bank. The user of USDT trusts the issuer of this stablecoin and the bank in which the collateral is kept: he/she believes that, if necessary, they will be able to redeem their USDT for USD at face value.</p><p>Despite rumors about the absence of full security [11], the lack of transparency and the absence of any guarantees of repayment at face value, the USDT maintains its undisputed leadership in the stablecoin market. USDT and four similar currencies (TUSD, USDC, GUSD, PAX), which are also electronic money backed by US dollars, account for more than 90% of the total capitalization and exchange turnover of stablecoins.</p><p>The role of credit money in a cryptocurrency ecosystem is not limited to the “replication” of national currencies on a blockchains. In fact, they solve the problem of Bitcoin’s scalability without increasing the block size.</p><p><strong>Payment channels: scalability within trustless limits</strong></p><p>Banknotes successfully replaced gold as a medium of exchange because exchange using banknotes was faster and cheaper. Banknotes became the representatives of gold in the sphere of exchange. Gold sat, unmoving, in the bank’s vault; but at the same time it served the exchange of goods through a banknote as its representative.</p><p>If Bitcoin is digital gold, then ‘digital banknotes’ of some kind could act as ordinary banknotes did for ordinary gold. In order to make bitcoin-based transactions faster and cheaper, they must occur without progressing the blockchain. If transactions without actual cash movement are called cashless, then transactions without bitcoin movement on the Bitcoin blockchain are called off-chain transactions.</p><p>One can freeze bitcoins at a special address and, using these bitcoins as a collateral, issue a ‘digital banknote’ in a side-chain or other blockchain; but this, strictly speaking, is not an off-chain solution. Although the bitcoins with which such notes are secured are static, the notes themselves move in a side-chain or other blockchain.</p><p>But payment channels, (or rather, a network of bilateral payment channels), are a true off-chain solution to the problem of Bitcoin network scalability. The parties of a payment channel deposit bitcoins on the multi-signature address, after which they can transfer their deposit to the other side of the channel without moving bitcoins along the original Bitcoin blockchain. Nodes that are connected through payment channels to more than one node form a network of payment channels. By combining payment channels into a network, off-chain transactions can be carried out not only within one channel, but also along a chain of channels (hops).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/282/0*56IAFV90Gp0CpRWZ" /></figure><p><em>a) balances of nodes before payment b) balances of nodes after payment</em></p><p><em>Figure 1. Multi-hop payment with one intermediary.</em></p><p>Multi-hop payments through a chain of payment channels allow for off-chain transactions between nodes that do not have a direct connection. Figure 1 shows the simplest payment scheme. Node A has a 0.1 BTC deposit in the channel with node B, and node B has deposited 0.05 BTC in the channel with node C. The presence of an intermediary (in the form of node B) allows node A to make an off-chain payment to node C in the amount of 0.05 BTS via the A-B-C chain, despite the fact that A and C do not have a direct payment channel with each other. Node B in this case is not a trusted party who can illegally seize the A’s bitcoins. It will get access to these bitcoins only after it makes payment to C. This property of multi-hop payments is called atomicity: the chain of payments is either fully implemented or not executed at all.</p><p>A related payment may occur through a chain in which there is more than one intermediary. Theoretically, one could build a network topology of bilateral payment channels in which it becomes possible to lay a chain of related payments between any two of its nodes.</p><p>The most well-known and most developed network of bilateral payment channels for Bitcoin is the Lightning Network [15]. Despite significant progress in the development of the Lightning Network’s infrastructure [16], a considerable increase in the number of network nodes and payment channels, and in the amount of bitcoins deposited in these channels [17], the functionality of this network has a number of limitations. Some of these restrictions are related to the fact that the Lightning Network operates on the trustless principle, which requires full security of off-chain transactions. Let us consider the Lightning Network’s restrictions, and the current proposals for their mitigation, in more detail.</p><p><em>The funds throughput of the chains of payment channels.</em> Let’s go back to the example of a multi-hop payment discussed above. If node A has deposited 0.1 BTC in the A-B channel, and node B has deposited only 0.05 BTC in the B-C channel, then node A will be able to pay node C only 0.05 BTC. The monetary throughput of a chain of payment channels is measured by the smallest deposit in this chain.</p><p>To overcome this limitation, the concept of atomic multi-path payments is being developed [18]. Off-chain transaction can be divided into several chains. For example, if in addition to the A-B-C chain, which has a throughput capacity of 0.05 BTC, there is an A-D-C chain with a carrying capacity of 0.07 BTC, then payment from the node A to the node C of 0.1 BTC becomes possible. To do this, the payment is divided into two parts: one part of the payment passes through the A-B chain, the other through the A-D chain.</p><p><em>Freezing deposits of intermediaries.</em> In the multi-hop payment A-B-C, participant B, who acts as an intermediary between A and C, will be able to manage bitcoins received from A only after C confirms receipt of payment from B. If C doesn’t confirm receipt for a while (for example, it could be offline), then B must wait until the waiting time for confirmation has expired. Only then will B be able to initiate the return of its bitcoins. The longer the chain through which the multi-hop payment is made, the more intermediaries in this chain freeze their bitcoins until the final recipient confirms receipt or the multi-hop payment is canceled.</p><p>How does this affect network performance? While the intermediary’s deposit is frozen, it cannot be used for other payments. The longer the deposit is frozen, the greater the costs of lost profits for the intermediary. The longer the average freeze of deposits, the greater the deposit needed to ensure the specified monetary throughput of its node per unit of time:</p><p>IМB = ID / ATF</p><p>where IMB is the intermediary’s monetary throughput per unit of time, D is the intermediary deposit (deposit), and ATF is the average freezing time of the intermediary’s deposit (average time of freezing). The higher the deposit required to maintain a given node capacity, the smaller the number of participants who can deposit such an amount; and, therefore, the higher the centralization of the network.</p><p>The possibility of prolonged freezing of the intermediary deposit is a potential vector of attack on the network. To create interruptions in the network, the attacker will seek to freeze the maximum amount of deposits in the maximum number of channels for the maximum period.</p><p>The authors of the Sprites [19] off-chain network project have proposed an approach to organizing multi-hop payments which shortens the maximum time for freezing deposits. This reduces the costs of lost profits for intermediaries, mitigates the tendency to centralize the network and the consequences of an attack in the mentioned scenario. However, this decision “… requires the flexibility of Ethereum-style smart contracts … and therefore cannot (we conjecture) be implemented in Bitcoin. “ [20]</p><p><em>Replenish and partial withdrawal of funds from payment channels.</em> If a channel participant has exhausted its deposit and its current balance in the channel is zero, then it has two options for further use of the channel. First: wait for an incoming payment from another channel member, thanks to which its balance will be replenished. Second: close the channel and open a new one in which it will make a new deposit. Both of these options are not very convenient. Further, withdrawing bitcoins from the channel is only possible by closing it. Permanent closure and opening of channels, in addition to the additional costs of channel participants, leads to temporary loss of nodes from the network and makes it difficult to make related payments.</p><p>Splicing [21] will allow on-chain transactions to replenish payment channels, as well as enabling the withdrawal of bitcoins without the need to close and re-open a channel. It is assumed that the development and implementation of this solution will make possible both on-chain payments from off-chain balances on the Lightning Network, and on-chain payments on off-chain balances.</p><p><em>Payment channels re-balancing.</em> There could be distortions in the balance of payment channels, which complicate their usage in the on-chain payment network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/234/0*_7CxbP1UrFZz4fib" /></figure><p><em>Figure 2. The imbalance in the balance of payment channels.</em></p><p>Figure 2 illustrates an example of balance skewing, when payments from one participant to another move cyclically in one direction: A only pays B, B pays C only, and C pays A only. Such a payment pattern causes the payer’s balance to be exhausted in each channel, and the balance of the payee to accumulate.</p><p>In this situation, participants have two options to continue using payment channels. The first one is to use multi-hop payments instead of direct channels, which can be more expensive if the intermediary charges a commission for this. Second: to replenish the channel with the help of on-chain transactions, which also requires additional costs.</p><p>Strictly speaking, in the simplest case with one user, there is a third option that does not require additional costs. The user can move the balance from one channel to another by performing a circular off-chain payment to himself [22]. “However, in a broader context of different users, different payment channels, different objectives and different payment amounts, it was not clear how a set of re-balancing transactions could be created.” [23]</p><p>The Revive protocol [24] alleviates the problem of balance skewing in payment channels in the aforementioned “broader context”. This protocol allows partial re-balancing of states in channels without the need for on-chain transactions. We say “partial” because Revive does not allow transferral of deposits, made at the opening of one channel, to another channel. Rather, it allows the clearing of off-chain balances of network participants whose payment channels form cycles. In other words, “this means that, when modeling the participants as nodes and the payment channels among them as edges, any such graph that contains no cycles is not re-balanceable.” [25]. Re-balancing using Revive does not happen automatically: for this to happen, participants in the off-chain payment network need to be combined into special subnets and take an active part in each rebalancing round [26].</p><p><em>High entry threshold for intermediaries.</em> The trend towards network centralization has already been mentioned above in the context of the maximum term for freezing intermediary deposits. A much more significant factor determining this tendency is the business model of intermediaries itself, which consists of charging fees for an off-chain transaction.</p><p>If each intermediary in a chain of multi-hop payments charges a fee, then a decrease in the number of intermediaries in the chain leads to a decrease in the commission that the user pays for sending an off-chain transaction. The more payment channels the intermediary has opened, the more users can make a multi-hop payment with the minimum number of intermediaries equal to one. A larger number of channels requires a larger amount of deposits. The greater the amount of deposits, the smaller the number of participants who can deposit such an amount and, consequently, the higher the centralization of the network.</p><p>The predominance of unidirectional payments that do not form cycles requires the intermediary to spend additional time and money on deposit management. If that entails tens or hundreds of thousands of small payments of buyers to large sellers, then the costs of deposit management can be substantial.</p><p>To reduce intermediary costs, the Liquidity Network project [27] proposed an alternative to two-way payment channels — an n-party non-custodial payment hub. This solution reduces the deposit requirement of an intermediary acting as a hub operator. The intermediary does not need to deposit cryptocurrency in the channel with each user of the hub, since Liquidity Network does not use two-way payment channels. In order to carry out a trustless off-chain transaction, an intermediary needs only to deposit a pledge in the smart contract equal to “the volume of transactions during the period of time allocated for transactions litigation.” [28] User balances are updated every 36 hours and another 36 hours is given to execute transactions. Thus, the intermediary must deposit funds to the amount of off-chain transactions that await final confirmation within 72 hours.</p><p>The number of users that can join the hub is unlimited. If the user wants to join the hub only for receiving off-chain payments, without making a deposit, then he/she does not need to send on-chain transaction for this. Instead he/she can do it off-chain. If the user wants to make a deposit, then he/she must send the deposit by an on-chain transaction to the hub’s smart contract address.</p><p>Liquidity Network operates on the basis of Ethereum and the direct implementation of this solution on the Bitcoin network is problematic. According to the authors of the project, “our scheme also requires an environment for the execution of smart contracts, similar to that provided by Ethereum”. [30] Bitcoins cannot be directly deposited in the Liquidity Network smart contract, but <a href="https://www.wbtc.network/">WBTC (Wrapped Bitcoin)</a>, for example, can be deposited [31].</p><p>Unlike the Liquidity Network payment hub, channel factories [32] can be implemented in the Bitcoin network, and their functioning does not require an intermediary operator to deposit collateral to ensure trustless transactions.</p><p>Channel factories are designed to reduce the costs of opening payment channels and moving deposits between channels. This solution, which acts as an intermediate layer between the blockchain and payment channels, will relieve users from having to send on-chain transactions whenever they want to open a new two-way payment channel. Instead, users will be able to open an unlimited number of payment channels within the group they have created in an off-chain mode. Creating a group requires each participant to make one on-chain transaction to deposit bitcoins at a multisig address. After creating a group, participants will be able to move their balance from a channel with one group member to a channel with another group member without on-chain transactions and in trustless mode.</p><p>Another difference between the channel factory and the Liquidity Network hub is that the number of factory participants cannot be increased, since it is set at the moment the multisig address is created.</p><p>It is not yet known when channel factories will be launched on the Bitcoin network. The concept of channel factories is at an initial stage of development and its implementation in the Bitcoin network will require a soft fork.</p><p>So, we looked at solutions that are designed to overcome the Lightning Network’s monetary throughput limitations in various ways, and to reduce the costs of using and maintaining an off-chain network. However, all these solutions have a general limitation, (which imposes a trustless principle on them). That limitation could be stated as: “a payment can only be made if the sender and all intermediaries have a sufficient value of deposits”.</p><p>Trustless + Trusted &gt; Trustless</p><p>A multi-hop payment of a sum x in the chain of channels requires that the deposit of each intermediary in the chain be not less than x. Thus, the total minimum amount of deposits of intermediaries for the multi-hop payment is:</p><p>TMID = x * n</p><p>where TMID is the total minimum deposit of intermediaries required to make a related payment of x (total minimum intermediaries’ deposit), x is the amount of payment, n is the number of intermediaries participating in a multi-hop payment.</p><p>A reduction in the average number of intermediaries of multi-hop payments, while the total amount of intermediary deposits is constant, increases the cash flow of the network per time unit. Abstracting from direct payments, we can present the simplest formula for the monetary network throughput as follows:</p><p>NMB = TID / (ATF * n)</p><p>where NMB is the network’s monetary throughput, TID is the total intermediaries deposit, ATF is the average time of freezing of the middleman’s deposit, and n is the average number of intermediaries servicing the multi-hop payment.</p><p>NMB can be improved by minimizing the ATF, by reducing the number of intermediaries in the network to one, and by optimising the deposit management practices of intermediaries. But otherwise, NMB can only be improved through an increase in the TID. The limit of the TID growth is the intermediary’s own capital. There is only one method to go beyond the limitations imposed by the intermediary’s own capital, the method any entrepreneur would use — credit. Credit provides the possibility of continuous commercial activity in the face of recurring shortages of capital.</p><p>Let’s consider an example. Node A, (a client of the intermediary node B), wants to make an off-chain payment to its counterpart node C, (another client of node B), in the amount of 0.1 BTC. But B has only deposited 0.05 BTC in the B-C channel. If B does not currently have funds available in its other channels to replenish the B-C channel, it will not be able to process this payment. If node C agrees to accept 0.05 BTC from the intermediary node B as a trustless ‘banknote’, and another 0.05 BTC as a trusted one issued by B, then the payment can be made. In turn, C will be able to use the trusted banknote for payments through B or to repay B in case of a need for ‘cash’ bitcoins.</p><p>This is the simplest example. A chain of related payments can be longer and contain various combinations of trustless and trusted links. In particular, credit can be used not only by the intermediary, but also by the sender of a payment.</p><p>Expansion of the range of exchange tools used in the off-chain network of bilateral payment channels, through trusted tools, allows us to increase its cash flow capacity and reduce the costs of intermediaries for deposit management. Reducing costs, in turn, allows intermediaries to reduce fees for off-chain transaction.</p><p>The<a href="https://geoprotocol.io/"> GEO Protocol</a> [33] makes it possible to perform off-chain transactions not only with the help of trustless banknotes (IOUs), but also with the help of various means of exchange based on trust. In terms of securities, the means of exchange that the GEO Protocol supports can be classified into three types:</p><p>1. <em>Trustless</em>. Means of exchange, fully secured by cryptographic assets deposited in payment channels.</p><p>2. <em>Trusted with full collateral</em>. Means of exchange, fully secured by off-chain non-digital assets. For example, electronic money secured by national currencies or precious metals.</p><p>3. <em>Trusted without full collateral</em>. Such means of exchange include, primarily, promissory notes and vouchers denominated in various units of value.</p><p>Means of exchange, such as electronic money, promissory notes and vouchers, have a long history of successful operation around the world, and the rules governing their use have been developed and tested in detail. On this basis, it can be argued that these means of exchange deserve even greater methodological, hierarchical and ethical trust than cryptocurrency.</p><p>GEO nodes can use any of the listed media in any combination for transactions with each other. If they want to conduct trustless transactions with each other, then they can open a channel by depositing cryptocurrency. If they want to use means of exchange based on trust, then they can open a channel (trustline) without depositing crypto assets and denominate their debt obligations in any convenient accounting unit. At the same time, each node of the GEO network independently sets a credit limit for each of its counterparties, within which the node agrees to accept one or other medium of exchange.</p><p>Multi-hop payments in the GEO Protocol can occur in chains that contain any available trustless and trusted combination of channels.</p><p>Increasing the throughput on the GEO network is not only achieved through the principle of “trustless + trusted”, described above. Atomic multi-path payments [34] and automatic cycled clearing [35] have already been implemented in the GEO Protocol.</p><p>A fixed supply of bitcoins restricts the throughput of the Lightning Network as a superstructure over the Bitcoin network. Spreading the Lightning Network to other blockchains would overcome this limitation. However, the Lightning Network will only be able to support cross-chain off-chain payments between blockchains with a compatible hashing algorithm. At the GEO network there are no such restrictions on cross-chain transactions; and, therefore, there are virtually no restrictions on monetary throughput.</p><p>In addition, the Lightning Network has technical limitations on network scalability. The GEO Protocol does not have them.</p><p>Ultimately, the GEO Protocol allows one to create not only payment channels, but also generalized state channels. This extends the functionality of the GEO Protocol far beyond the simple movement of cryptocurrency between nodes of the off-chain network.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Money can not exist without trust and Bitcoin is no exception. Even traditional cash, which is used in P2P transactions, requires methodical, hierarchical and ethical trust for its normal functioning.</p><p>Credit and credit money do not arise by chance, but by necessity. Capitalism needs credit, and cash needs credit money. Economic history provides many examples of how credit money, including that without full collateral, helps economies to function, develop, and mitigate the effects of crises.</p><p>Banknotes made it possible to reduce the costs of, and speed up, transactions that were previously conducted with precious metals. Digital gold transactions can also be sped up and cheapened thanks to digital banknotes that circulate outside blockchains. Off-chain transactions in networks of bilateral payment channels allow Bitcoins to be stored without movement in the blockchain, but at the same time maintain economic turnover through digital banknotes.</p><p>The trustless principle limits the cash throughput of the off-chain network (NMB). This restriction can be formulated as follows: a payment can be made only under the condition that the sender and all intermediaries of the payment have a sufficient value of deposits. This limitation can be overcome by combining trustless transactions with trusted transactions.</p><p>The driving force behind the evolution of networks of bilateral payment channels from trustless, to trustless + trusted, is the increase in monetary throughput (even when the supply of cryptocurrency is limited).</p><p>The logic of this evolution is as follows: the NMB rises by increasing the number of nodes, the number of their payment channels and the amount of their deposits. When this type of growth reaches its limit, growth in NMB occurs due to the centralization of the network. After centralization of the network, further growth in NMB is possible due to an increase in the intermediary deposits. The limiting factor of this stage of growth is the stock of intermediary cryptocurrency. The intermediary may use various methods of deposit management to more effectively distribute their deposits through channels, but these solutions still have an upper limit — the value of intermediary deposits.</p><p>A further increase in the monetary throughput of a network of bilateral payment channels is possible only through credit, and therefore through transactions based on trust [36].</p><p>In the GEO network, nodes can use three classes of exchanges: trustless (fully secured with a crypto asset deposited in the payment channel), trusted with full collateral (fully secured off-chain non-digital assets), trusted without full collateral (promissory notes and vouchers).</p><p>The GEO Protocol can be used both by those who support the ideology of crypto-anarchism, and by those who adhere to a more traditional project of society. Moreover, the ability to use trustless and trust-based tools in the same off-chain network simplifies the interaction of the former with the latter.</p><p>The introduction of credit-based means of exchange makes the monetary throughput of an off-chain network unlimited only in theory. In practice, each network participant sets a trust limit for each counterparty with whom he or she enters into a credit relationship. Expansion of the range of media operating in a network of bilateral payment channels, through trusted tools, allows us to achieve results that are unattainable for off-chain networks limited by the trustless principle.</p><p><strong>Sources:</strong></p><p>[1] M. Aglietta A. Orlean, <em>La violence de la monnaie</em></p><p>[2] Zcash Discloses Vulnerability That Could Have Allowed ‘Infinite Counterfeit’ Cryptocurrency // <a href="http://fortune.com/2019/02/05/zcash-vulnerability-cryptocurrency/">http://fortune.com/2019/02/05/zcash-vulnerability-cryptocurrency/</a></p><p>[3] Schneier B. There’s No Good Reason To Trust Blockchain Technology // <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/theres-no-good-reason-to-trust-blockchain-technology/">https://www.wired.com/story/theres-no-good-reason-to-trust-blockchain-technology/</a></p><p>[4] Chainalysis — Blockchain analysis // <a href="https://www.chainalysis.com/">https://www.chainalysis.com/</a></p><p>[5] LocalBitcoins Volume (Venezuela) // <a href="https://coin.dance/volume/localbitcoins/VES/BTC">https://coin.dance/volume/localbitcoins/VES/BTC</a></p><p>[6] Smith M. On Central Banking “Rules”: Tooke’s Critique of the Bank Charter Act of 1844 // <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of-economic-thought/article/on-central-banking-rules-tookes-critique-of-the-bank-charter-act-of-1844/82FDB770461975FBD6A529630A8A6C62">https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of-economic-thought/article/on-central-banking-rules-tookes-critique-of-the-bank-charter-act-of-1844/82FDB770461975FBD6A529630A8A6C62</a></p><p>[7] Bernard Lietaer — The Future of Money, 2001.</p><p>[8] The Fed — Money Stock and Debt Measures // <a href="https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/current/default.htm">https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/current/default.htm</a></p><p>[9] Brito J. The Case for Electronic Cash: Why Private Peer-to-Peer Payments are Essential to an Open Society, c. 4–7 // <a href="https://coincenter.org/entry/the-case-for-electronic-cash">https://coincenter.org/entry/the-case-for-electronic-cash</a></p><p>[10] Cryptocompare December 2018 Exchange Review, p. 18 // <a href="https://www.cryptocompare.com/media/35309385/cryptocompare_exchange_review_2018_12.pdf">https://www.cryptocompare.com/media/35309385/cryptocompare_exchange_review_2018_12.pdf</a></p><p>[11] Central Bank Reports Prove Bitfinex / Tether DO NOT Have Banking in the Bahamas with Deltec // <a href="https://blog.zerononcense.com/2018/12/22/breaking-central-bank-reports-prove-bitfinex-tether-do-not-have-banking-in-the-bahamas-with-deltec/">https://blog.zerononcense.com/2018/12/22/breaking-central-bank-reports-prove-bitfinex-tether-do-not-have-banking-in-the-bahamas-with-deltec/</a></p><p>[12] The Stablecoin Index // <a href="https://stablecoinindex.com/marketcap">https://stablecoinindex.com/marketcap</a></p><p>[13] Blockstream Liquid // <a href="https://blockstream.com/liquid/">https://blockstream.com/liquid/</a></p><p>[14] Zamyatin A. et al. XCLAIM: A Framework for Blockchain Interoperability // <a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2018/643">https://eprint.iacr.org/2018/643</a></p><p>[15] Lightning Network // <a href="https://lightning.network/">https://lightning.network/</a></p><p>[16] Balaji A. From #reckless to Wumbology: Lightning Network’s Infrastructural Build Out // <a href="https://www.theblockcrypto.com/2019/01/18/from-reckless-to-wumbology-lightning-networks-infrastructural-build-out/">https://www.theblockcrypto.com/2019/01/18/from-reckless-to-wumbology-lightning-networks-infrastructural-build-out/</a></p><p>[17] 1ML — Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine // <a href="https://1ml.com/statistics">https://1ml.com/statistics</a></p><p>[18] Osuntokun О. AMP: Atomic Multi-Path Payments over Lightning // <a href="https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/lightning-dev/2018-February/000993.html">https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/lightning-dev/2018-February/000993.html</a></p><p>[19] Miller A. et al. Sprites and State Channels: Payment Networks that Go Faster than Lightning // <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.05812">https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.05812</a></p><p>[20] Ibid, page 2.</p><p>[21] Russell R. Splicing Proposal: Feedback please! // <a href="https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/lightning-dev/2018-October/001434.html">https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/lightning-dev/2018-October/001434.html</a></p><p>[22] The Collateral Management Challenge in Payment Channels — аnd one sight of light // <a href="https://blog.liquidity.network/2017/11/16/the-collateral-management-challenge-in-payment-channels-and-one-sight-of-light/">https://blog.liquidity.network/2017/11/16/the-collateral-management-challenge-in-payment-channels-and-one-sight-of-light/</a></p><p>[23] Ibid.</p><p>[24] Khalil R., Gervais A. Revive: Rebalancing Off-Blockchain Payment Networks // <a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/823.pdf">https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/823.pdf</a></p><p>[25] Ibid, p. 4.</p><p>[26] Ibid, p. 5–6.</p><p>[27] Liquidity Network // <a href="https://liquidity.network/">https://liquidity.network/</a></p><p>[28] Khalil R., Gervais A. NOCUST — A Non-Custodial 2nd-Layer Financial Intermediary, c. 12 // <a href="https://liquidity.network/NOCUST_Liquidity_Network_Paper.pdf">https://liquidity.network/NOCUST_Liquidity_Network_Paper.pdf</a></p><p>[29] NOCUST 101 // <a href="https://blog.liquidity.network/2018/11/21/nocust-101/">https://blog.liquidity.network/2018/11/21/nocust-101/</a></p><p>[30] Khalil R., Gervais A. NOCUST — A Non-Custodial 2nd-Layer Financial Intermediary, c. 4 // <a href="https://liquidity.network/NOCUST_Liquidity_Network_Paper.pdf">https://liquidity.network/NOCUST_Liquidity_Network_Paper.pdf</a></p><p>[31] Wrapped Bitcoin (WBTC) // <a href="https://www.wbtc.network/">https://www.wbtc.network/</a></p><p>[32] Burchert C., Decker C., Wattenhofer R. Scalable Funding of Bitcoin Micropayment Channel Networks // <a href="https://www.tik.ee.ethz.ch/file/a20a865ce40d40c8f942cf206a7cba96/Scalable_Funding_Of_Blockchain_Micropayment_Networks%20(1).pdf">https://www.tik.ee.ethz.ch/file/a20a865ce40d40c8f942cf206a7cba96/Scalable_Funding_Of_Blockchain_Micropayment_Networks%20(1).pdf</a></p><p>[33] GEO Protocol // <a href="https://www.geoprotocol.io/">https://www.geoprotocol.io</a></p><p>[34] LINK TO THE ARTICLE ABOUT PAYMENT ALGO</p><p>[35] LINK TO THE ARTICLE ABOUT CYCLED CLEARING ALGO</p><p>[36] A further increase in network liquidity within the framework of the trustless approach is possible only by eliminating bilateral payment channels. We are talking about the elimination of the intermediary thanks to trustless solutions that allow the use of an off-chain deposit for direct payments to any member of a payment hub or multilateral payment channel, and ideally to any member of the network. However, in this case, the need for credit does not disappear. The liquidity of the n-party payment channels/hubs network still comes up against a limited cryptocurrency offer, and this restriction is overcome by credit.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2215ea9ba383" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/trusted-vs-trustless-the-role-of-trust-in-the-operation-of-means-of-exchange-2215ea9ba383">TRUSTED VS TRUSTLESS: THE ROLE OF TRUST IN THE MEANS OF EXCHANGE OPERATION</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Decentralized P2P Lending: Services vs. Networks]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/decentralized-p2p-lending-services-vs-networks-5484d03e2f2d?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5484d03e2f2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Feb 2019 11:28:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:46.076Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>In this article, we will look at the rapidly emerging P2P lending market. We’ll explore some decentralized blockchain-based credit services (SALT, ETHlen, etc.) and compare them with decentralized credit networks. We’ll consider the advantages and disadvantages of these approaches in maturing and extending the P2P lending concept, and taking advantage of an increasing network effect.</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0h9fXqEpiaapFx3vw1-MZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>But we’ll begin with a brief overview of…</em></p><h4><strong>What is traditional P2P lending?</strong></h4><p>Peer-to-peer lending (crowdfunding) is an alternative financial system, the essence of which is to provide individual lenders and borrowers with a way of lending money to unrelated persons, or equal parties, without involving a traditional financial intermediary.</p><p>This method of individual lending has a long history and is even culturally traditional in certain regions of the world. But in modern manifestations, it is usually found in the form of specialized online platforms that bring together those willing to lend with those who would like to borrow. Since such websites operate exclusively online, they have fewer and lower fixed costs, and can, therefore, provide their services cheaper than traditional financial institutions.</p><p>As a result, borrowers can earn more than interest on deposits and other investment products offered by banks, and borrowers can get a loan with lower interest rates. That’s even taking into account the commission of the P2P lending provider itself, which it charges for its services of bringing together borrowers with lenders, as well as the service of checking the creditworthiness of a borrower.</p><p>It is expected that by the year 2050, the global <a href="https://www.nasdaq.com/article/the-rise-of-peertopeer-p2p-lending-cm685513">P2P lending industry will reach an annual turnover of 1 trillion USD</a>.</p><p>This is also a great moment to create decentralized P2P lending platforms, as more and more countries are now beginning to regulate their P2P lending industries. In countries such as the USA, Canada, Australia, and Germany (where the industry is already regulated), it’s already become a popular alternative financing model. Across these countries, about 25% of the population is already using decentralized P2P lending to borrow funds.</p><p>China (where P2P is largely unregulated) and India (where P2P has until recently been largely self-regulated) also have a potentially huge P2P market. As more and more countries recognize P2P as a mainstream financing option, startups in this area will only look better.</p><p>A decentralized credit system is a very attractive idea, especially when compared to conventional systems tied to large credit institutions. However, it also has its own innate problems.</p><p>In particular, the creditor’s investments in P2P lending are usually not protected by any government guarantee. In some services, lenders may try to reduce the overall risk by diversifying their investments among different borrowers, and to reduce the risk of bad debts, having the ability to choose the borrowers to which they provide loans. But then the question arises: what information forms the basis to make this choice? Some P2P lending services use external Know-Your-Customer (KYC) solutions as well as solutions for determining the credit rating of potential borrowers. In other words, one must arbitrarily rely on the decisions of trusted third parties.</p><p>Other problems include the limited scalability of local P2P lending services on an international scale. This ties in with the aforementioned problems of loan repayment guarantees, as well as with regulatory issues (rules and regulations vary from country to country). There is also work to be done on accelerating the process of granting loans, etc.</p><p>Also, despite the supposed decentralization of P2P lending platforms, they still retain a certain degree of centralization. In particular, all records and identification data are stored and maintained by the central party, leaving room for human error or manipulation. This point may also impede the growth and coverage of a platform since centralization makes a system more vulnerable to regulations at the regional level. These regulations may differ significantly from country to country, which makes things even harder.</p><p>And this is only a small sampler of the problems that traditional P2P lending services face; which, by the way, are in one way or another characteristic of all traditional financial institutions. Taken as a whole, they not only slow the business down but also reduce the possibility of scaling.</p><p>However, there is hope that <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/blockchain">blockchain</a> <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology</a> will solve most of these problems.</p><p>First of all, the property of decentralization, already inherent in the P2P industry, makes it the blockchain’s natural use case. Also, transparency, equality of interest rates, and improved due diligence analysis makes the use of blockchain technology in the P2P lending industry a good fit for both lenders and borrowers.</p><h4><strong>Decentralized Credit Services</strong></h4><p>Unsurprisingly, we’ve already witnessed the first P2P lending services beginning to appear on the blockchain. Let’s consider a few of them. We’ll divide them into several groups, and start with cryptocurrency-to-fiat P2P lending solutions, before considering pure cryptocurrency P2P lending solutions. Finally, we’ll discover how they all differ from decentralized credit networks.</p><h3><strong>Cryptocurrency-to-fiat P2P lending solutions</strong></h3><h4><strong>SALT</strong></h4><p>SALT (Secure Automated Lending Technology) is a centralized cryptocurrency credit platform. Currently, SALT is the leader in the realm of blockchain-based loans.</p><p>SALT is differentiated by focusing on institutional cash loans, which are backed up by cryptocurrency, whereas many other projects in this area use a pure peer-to-peer approach. However, both options should have a place in the market. In addition, SALT competes with more traditional platforms that provide loans secured by crypto assets, but do not use a specific token.</p><p>Based on this, the main advantage for SALT borrowers is the ability to borrow FIAT cash against the security of their crypto assets, which looks more practical to ordinary people in terms of their daily needs than pure cryptocurrency lending solutions. But that’s exactly what leads to the fact that P2P lending must impose more stringent requirements on its users.</p><p>First, this service is available only to customers in 33 states of the US, the United Kingdom, and New Zealand. Thus, potential users in other parts of the planet are forced to look for other (similar) services, which in general does not contribute to scaling, as well as interoperability, as we mentioned above.</p><p>Secondly, you can become a lender only if you are an accredited investor. In the US, that requires being able to demonstrate a net worth of at least $1 million. Finally, SALT will require a client to undergo KYC / AML (Know-Your-Customer / Anti-Money Laundering) validation before he or she can create contracts in the service.</p><p>The SALT loan process differs from that of ETHLend (see below) only in the fact that a cryptocurrency backs FIAT money loans in the SALT system, unlike the pure cryptocurrency-based operations in ETHLend. After the terms of the loan are agreed and approved, the lender will make a deposit, (for example, US dollars), into the borrower’s bank account, while the smart contract will lock the borrower’s cryptocurrency. The borrower will be obligated to make repayments in US dollars on a regular basis; and in the event of a default, its crypto assets will be transferred to the lender. Today, the lending accepts only ether (ETH) and bitcoins (BTC) as collateral.</p><p>SALT tokens, also known as <em>membership tokens</em>, are ERC-20 tokens that a user spends to become a member of the SALT lending platform. In addition, one can use these tokens to repay interest on loans, get better rates and purchase goods in the SALT online store.</p><h4><strong>Nexo</strong></h4><p>In general, the Nexo project followed almost the same footsteps as the SALT, taking advantage of the hard lessons learned by the latter. As with SALT, Nexo tokens can be used for discounted interest rates and loan repayments; they can also be used as collateral, and according to the Nexo website, they even plan to pay holders some of their profits.</p><p>The loan approval process is fully automated, which allows borrowers to receive borrowed funds immediately. Nexo has also announced plans to issue loans worldwide, including in “at least” 36 US states. The plans also float the possibility of using ERC-20 tokens as collateral and issuing a crypto credit card.</p><p>At the moment, deposits can be made in a range of cryptocurrencies including BTC, ETH, and NEXO. Loan repayments can be performed in US dollars or euros, as well as in the cryptocurrencies.</p><p>Nexo reserves the right to change the loan-to-value ratio at its discretion based on historical volatility and market liquidity of an asset. Currently, the loan-to-value ratios are as follows:</p><p>BTC: 50%</p><p>ETH: 50%</p><p>XRP: 40%</p><p>Nexo: 30%</p><p>Essentially, this means that if you lodge 2 bitcoins as collateral, Nexo will lend you FIAT money with a total value of 1 bitcoin (i.e. 50% of what you gave them).</p><p>Nexo loans have a pretty simple interest rate policy: either 16% or 8% per annum. Interest rates are not based on the size or duration of a loan, and do not depend on the borrower’s credit rating. A loan of 16% per annum is the standard rate that everyone pays. However, it can be reduced to 8% for one of two reasons: first, if the borrower uses the Nexo token as collateral for the loan; second, if it repays the loan using Nexo tokens. Nexo interest is not compounded and is charged daily to the borrower’s account. No interest payments are due during the term of the loan so a borrower does not need to make any repayments whilst the loan is outstanding.</p><p>Benefits of the service: the Nexo lending model has no fees and has a fixed interest rate. That provides a competitive advantage over SALT, and is provides some stability against market fluctuations.</p><p>Cons: Although the company claims to offer loans at 8%, in fact, this is just a publicity stunt. In most cases, the real figure will be on average twice as large.</p><h4><strong>Ripio</strong></h4><p>The Argentinian startup Ripio has facilitated P2P micro loans for more than 200,000 users in Argentina, Brazil, and Mexico. After attracting 37 million dollars during the ICO in 2017, Ripio became one of that rare breed: a crypto company with an actual working financial product. The funds raised by the ICO were used to create their own P2P loan service that efficiently connects individual borrowers and lenders around the world using smart contracts.</p><p>Current plans are for the full deployment of the micro-loans service to follow the Beta test, in which more than 800 clients in Argentina have received loans. Ripio now claims that there are already several thousand lenders issuing loans in local fiat currencies through their platform, equivalent to between $150 and $750. These are lenders mainly from the Asian continent, and they help to fund people throughout South America.</p><p>Unlike the most similar lending and exchange services, unbanked users of cryptocurrency can access new Ripio lending services. The South American market is known for a diverse and often extremely complex relationship with the financial industry. For example, recent World Bank reports show that up to 54% of the adult population of Colombia do not use banking services, and up to 30% in Brazil. Ripio’s internal survey found that 19% of its users did not have a credit card. They used convenience stores to deposit money and top-up their wallets. However, thanks to the Ripio credit service, such people now have the opportunity to keep a permanent record of their debt payments, which can help them receive other financial services in the future.</p><p>Ripio plans to expand its services to markets in Uruguay, Chile, and Colombia, although this is dependent on overcoming a variety of local regulatory restrictions. At the same time, political and economic instability, an opaque regulatory environment and security problems stopped the service from entering the Venezuelan market.</p><p>Despite the fact that borrowers get their micro-loans in FIAT currencies, the Ripio service is supported by its own token — RCN. The lender sends the loan using RCN. At that moment, a cut goes to all parties involved, including credit rating agents, identity verification services, <em>cosigners</em>, etc., before Ripio finally converts it back into fiat and then delivers the funds to a specific borrower.</p><p><em>Cosigners</em> is a security feature that protects lenders from bad debts: the guarantor of the borrower. This improves the terms of the contract and retains access to the borrower’s local legal system, securing the loan in case of debtor’s default.</p><p>Overall, this service very neatly solves the specific problems of a particular region, and this is its undoubted plus. The question of how applicable this solution is, outside the region, and its global scalability remain open.</p><h4><strong>BlockFi</strong></h4><p>BlockFi, another participant in the P2P lending race, is a recent entrant with a much smaller burden. Unlike other platforms, BlockFi did not conduct an ICO: all financing was made by institutional investors. “Raising funds from this audience comes with stringent requirements and diligence on our platform,” a BlockFi representative said. “This requires us to be the most trustworthy and reliable lender in the space.”</p><p>Since there was no initial coin offering, the BlockFi token also does not exist. BlockFi says that this saves them from the problem of yet another crypto asset: “There is no need whatsoever for a utility token in a lending business model. Having one creates a conflict of interest and confusing user experience.”</p><p>The company is actively spreading into new jurisdictions. It recently entered California and Maryland, and, in total, provides its services in 45 US states.</p><p>The advantages include the fact that the company provides some of the lowest prices on the market. Loans are quick, charged at about 13% per annum and can provide about 35% leverage.</p><p>Cons: the company is shamelessly centralized. Unlike SALT, they do not match lenders with borrowers; BlockFi is the lender.</p><h3><strong>General disadvantages of cryptocurrency-to-fiat P2P lending solutions</strong></h3><p>Overall, cryptocurrency-to-FIAT lending solutions are more like traditional semi-centralized P2P lending services, with nearly all their associated problems and disadvantages. In fact, they act as a third party and escrow in the lending transactions between their clients. The only difference from ordinary P2P lending services is that they don’t limit users to working with fiat, but facilitate the use of cryptocurrencies, and also use their own token for various services and additional incentives for customers. On the other hand, the ability to get cash for cryptocurrency collateral is a very attractive option, which is currently more in demand in real life than pure cryptocurrency loans.</p><h4><strong>Pure cryptocurrency P2P lending solutions</strong></h4><p><strong>ETHlend</strong></p><p>ETHlend is also a decentralized cryptocurrency credit platform, but, unlike SALT and Nexio, it operates exclusively through Ethereum smart contracts. Thus, ETHlend never stores the funds or assets of its users. In addition, this means that when entering into a contract through ETHlend, borrowers and lenders can only use ETH or ETH-based assets (for example, ERC-20 tokens), such as OmiseGo, Augur, etc.</p><p>This is perhaps the biggest disadvantage of a pure cryptocurrency ecosystem. Most of us still make deals in FIAT currency and will most likely want to receive loans in them: US dollars, euros, or some other local currency. But, of course, we should remember that by adding a FIAT currency to the equation, we increase the level of centralization, which has both positive and negative sides.</p><p>On the other hand, a fully decentralized cryptocurrency ecosystem most likely won’t comply with most of the laws of a country or a state. However, it will create a much more accessible system for people all over the world.</p><p>The lending process at ETHlend is quite simple.</p><p>When creating a smart contract, ETHLend requires borrowers to send ERC-20 compatible tokens or Ethereum Name Service (ENS) domains as collateral for ETH loans in the event of a borrower’s default. Currently, only borrowers can create loan applications for ETHLend. To place a request for a loan, the borrower must establish data such as the loan term, the interest rate and the number of tokens required for collateral. If the lender agrees to these conditions, a loan agreement will be created and the lender will be able to send its ETH.</p><p>Further, the borrower repays the debt, in accordance with the contract, plus interest on the loan, sending them to a smart contract. The lender receives its ETH and interest from the smart contract, and the pledged tokens are unlocked and sent back to the borrower. In the event that the borrower cannot repay its loan, the lender will receive the announced security of the borrower in the form of tokens, which it can dispose of at his discretion.</p><p>The ETHLend LEND token is an ERC-20 compatible token that was sold as part of a pre-sale offer and an ICO. The LEND token performs several important functions in the dApp. In particular, users of LEND tokens will receive a 25% discount on the fee for the platform compared to payment through Ethereum. Although LEND tokens can be bought and sold on coin exchanges, the main use of LEND is to create a discount when paying fees for deploying the ETHLend dApp.</p><p>Quarterly airdrops will be distributed to active lenders and borrowers. ETHLend plans to use 20% of its decentralized fees from filing applications for the purchase of LEND from the market, and to distribute that LEND between all lenders and borrowers on ETHLend. Airdrops will be used to increase user acceptance, as well as to increase loan volumes. In addition, particular services on ETHLend will only be available to be purchased for LEND. Examples of these services are lists of featured loans, as well as email marketing campaigns. Finally, ETHLend plans to additionally use LEND to reward lenders and borrowers, who invite new members to the decentralized lending platform (referral bonuses).</p><p>ETHLend also plans to offer unsecured loans to its users in the future, i.e. loans in which the borrower does not provide any collateral. Such loans are much more risky for the lender. To help lenders deal with the difficulties of assessing the underlying risk of unsecured loans, ETHLend plans to create a decentralized credit rating for all its users. In short, ETHlend borrowers will be able to build their reputations over time, as they successfully repay loans.</p><p>Each ETHLend borrower will have a decentralized credit rating created from several data sources. The main data source for these credit ratings will be Credit Tokens (CRE), which will be issued by ETHLend itself. Credit tokens are special ERC-20 tokens that will be used exclusively on ETHLend to represent the reputation of the borrower. These tokens cannot be exchanged or even transferred to another address. The more credit tokens associated with a user account, the more reliable that account it. For each borrowed 1 ETH that the user successfully repays, the user will receive 0.1 CRE. In addition, ETHLend plans to “burn” credit tokens from accounts that cannot repay loans. A user with a large amount of CRE will be able to get loans that another user with a low amount of CRE could not have access to. Users with higher CRE amounts will be rewarded with better interest rates, and will also be required to provide lower levels of collateral for similar loans than users with lower CREs.</p><p>Reputation-based lending will allow ETHlend to introduce the concept of unsecured loans to users, as well as to provide more information for potential lenders. In addition, ETHLend plans to provide users with the opportunity to broadcast their decentralized credit rating to other blockchains. Borrowers will then be able to use their well-earned credit rating in applications on other ecosystems.</p><p>But whatever the case, the ETHlend service will remain enclosed within the Ethereum ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Elix</strong></p><p>Elix is yet ​​another Ethereum based platform for lending, crowdfunding and payments. Developers are primarily focused on mobile platforms and usability in order to attract as large a user base as possible from the very beginning.</p><p>We won’t consider here the payment and crowdfunding functionality of this solution, but concentrate only on its lending aspect.</p><p>The uniqueness of this system lies in the fact that Elix offers a peer-to-peer lending program based on mutual incentives for the lender and the borrower. In traditional credit systems, the borrower pays the lender via a series of installments over time. In addition to repaying the loan sum itself, these installments also include the interest rate specified in the loan terms. Such a system does not provide any additional incentives for the borrower to repay the debt on time, except for the risk of dealing with collectors.</p><p>In Elix, both the lender and the borrower are incentivized by the system to meet the terms of the loan. When applying for a loan, participants can choose a mining period in order to receive additional rewards after the loan has been fully repaid. If this option is enabled, the lender must hold the ELIX token in his wallet for a certain time in the system (similar to the <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/evolution-of-consensus-mechanisms-from-classical-methods-to-local-consensus-4e29959ecf9a">Proof-of-Stake</a>). When this retention period ends, the Elix system gives out rewards in the form of a new token, “Token P” (this token will most likely have a different name in the future).</p><p>If the borrower pays the loan on time, the reward is divided between the lender receiving 65% and the borrower who receives 35%. If the borrower has late payments, the lender receives 100% of this fee.</p><p>Token P will have a fixed maximum supply that the team expects to achieve in only a few decades.</p><p>ETHLend (see above) is probably Elix’s largest competitor in the P2P lending industry. ETHLend supports a wider range of cryptocurrencies that users can borrow, but there is no rewards program like that which Elix offers.</p><p><strong>Maker DAO</strong></p><p>Over the past few months, the Maker DAO ecosystem has grown steadily, while the price of ETH has declined. The total issued debt today is more than $76 million in Dai (a stablecoin linked to the US dollar) with more than 2 million ETH (worth more than $200 million at the current exchange rate at the press time) as a collateral. This means that for every dollar issued in Dai, about 3 dollars in ETH are pledged as collateral. This is done to compensate for the volatility of ETH.</p><p>Maker DAO is one of the most valuable dApps in the Ethereum ecosystem, and has been successful due to its decentralized management structure. Thanks to a rather complex system of smart contracts, users can borrow dollar-bound Dai tokens with ETH locked as collateral.</p><p>The CDP (Collateralized Debt Position) is a smart contract that allows creation of the new Dai tokens with ETH as collateral. If the ETH price falls below the price level of the collateral, then the position is liquidated, and the user keeps borrowed Dai tokens. CDPs are becoming increasingly popular; despite the bear market, the total number of CDPs has increased by 300% over the past four months on the Maker DAO platform.</p><p>There are several reasons why CDPs are beneficial for both the ordinary borrower and the crypto speculator.</p><p>Firstly, as a regular loan: just as people borrow money on their houses or gold, one can borrow dollar-pegged Dai with Ethereum as collateral. But the difference is that the process is automated, and also more risky due to the ETH’s volatility.</p><p>Secondly, these are leveraged positions: one can borrow Dai and use it to buy more ETH. For example, let’s say you take 15 ETH and open the CDP to get Dai worth 10 ETH. Now, if you buy ETH with the borrowed DAI, then your exposure becomes 25 ETH instead of 15. But this is obviously associated with the risk of liquidation if the price drops significantly.</p><p>Thirdly, as an arbitrage token: let’s say you hold ETH. Now, instead of liquidating your position, you can just borrow Dai and use it to buy other tokens. If the token outperforms ETH, you can sell a part of this asset and redeem your ETH back, while preserving both the excess tokens you purchased and your original ETHs.</p><p>The Maker DAO ecosystem is managed by the Maker (MKR) token. Its market capitalization is a whopping $313 million, making it one of the most valuable ERC-20 tokens.</p><p>In general, the Maker DAO has several applications, the primary of which is their stablecoin. But the loans function is also significant. Nonetheless, it remains a pure crypto lending service only; additionally, the service is de-facto “trapped” within a single blockchain ecosystem (Ethereum).</p><h3><strong>Disadvantages of Blockchain-Based Solutions</strong></h3><p>As we see, the market for decentralized P2P lending solutions is gradually filling with projects based on blockchain technologies. However, all these solutions have a number of impossible (or at least difficult-to-overcome) limitations.</p><p>One of the main limitations is that most of these solutions are “closed” within a single cryptocurrency/blockchain ecosystem (Ethereum, in particular). But even when some of these lending services work with several different crypto-assets, their variety is often limited to a couple of the most popular ones. In addition, most of the services are trying to tie their users to their native token — that contributes to the exclusiveness of these systems, rather than to their openness. So, in these cases, we can leave out any network effect, serious scalability, or possibility to build a more or less global network.</p><p>In other words, blockchain-based decentralized P2P lending solutions inherit all the same problems from the basic Layer 1 blockchain projects (Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc). These problems also include the lack of <a href="https://dailyhodl.com/2018/12/15/new-approaches-to-solving-atomicity-problems-in-distributed-databases-and-off-chain-networks/">transaction atomicity</a> (in cases where cross-chain transactions are involved, or there are fiat-to-crypto transactions).</p><h4><strong>Decentralized Credit Networks</strong></h4><p>Unlike decentralized credit services, the <a href="https://www2012.universite-lyon.fr/proceedings/proceedings/p559.pdf">decentralized credit networks</a> can not only overcome the above-mentioned disadvantages of blockchain-based services, but also significantly expand the opportunities offered to existing and potential users (including businesses).</p><p>The principal difference between decentralized credit services and decentralized credit networks is that the latter, in addition to ensuring greater scalability and interoperability, also provide the transitivity of trust. The services must rely on third parties (in particular, to assess the creditworthiness of borrowers). In contrast, each network member in the transitive trust networks establish his/her own trustlines with other users. And by doing go he/she evaluates and weighs all the risks. At the same time, other participants can use its trustlines (for example, when making multi-hop payments, etc.). A dishonest participant will have fewer trustlines with other network members, or indeed have none at all. Thus <a href="https://www.usenix.org/legacy/events/netecon10/tech/full_papers/Dandekar.pdf">self-regulation of the credit network</a> will occur without the need for additional involvement of third parties.</p><p>All this is made possible by the special technological solutions used in them.</p><h4><strong>Trustlines Network</strong></h4><p>Trustlines Network is an Ethereum-based P2P platform for creating IOU networks. Based on the original concept behind Ripple, introduced by Ryan Fugger in 2004, the Trustlines Network will allow users to create money and make secure payments among themselves. The high-level idea is that individuals provide credit for the people they trust, and only for an amount they consider fair. This provided credit is money that is valid for anyone who trusts the creditor. Thus, Trustlines Network is like the current credit-based monetary system, in a sense, but instead of just banks, anyone can become a creditor.</p><p>Since the system’s scalability depends on well-connected users, users are motivated to establish as many connections as possible. This is done by including a small capacity fee in every transaction, which is paid to users/nodes that work as middlemen connecting two end nodes. In addition to the capacity fee, there is a relay fee (more on relays below), an imbalance fee (a fee for adding imbalance to a used trustline), and the Ethereum transaction fee. Optionally, users can also add an interest rate to any of their debtors.</p><p>There can be an arbitrary number of currency networks within the Trustlines Network ecosystem, using a related Currency Network Token Factory smart contract. Thus, there is no single “Trustlines token”, but instead an arbitrary number of coexisting currencies that share only the Trustlines Network platform, which are called Trustlines Money. From the point of view of Helsinki, this type of dynamic IOU network would essentially mean that the city should act as a central bank of sorts.</p><p>The idea is quite promising, but TN is still tied exclusively to the Ethereum platform, which severely limits the versatility and scalability of this solution.</p><h4><a href="https://geoprotocol.io/#overview"><strong>GEO Protocol</strong></a></h4><p>The GEO Protocol is a decentralized P2P protocol for value transfer. The basic idea is very similar to the idea of ​​the Trustlines Network (or rather, <a href="http://ripple.ryanfugger.com/">Ryan Fugger’s original ​​Ripple idea</a>). But, unlike TN, the GEO has a more global approach to the problem — plus it is not tied to Ethereum or any other Layer 1 blockchain.</p><p>The GEO is a Layer 3 protocol solution, one of the main goals of which is to solve the interoperability problem of various cryptocurrency and blockchain ecosystems, as well as interconnecting them with traditional financial systems. In other words, the developers of the GEO Protocol set themselves the task to provide the possibility of creating the so-called <em>Internet of Value</em>: a universal system that unites all possible carriers of value, as well as systems for its transfer, into a single global network of value exchange.</p><p>As you can see, this task is much broader than that considered in this article. However, the GEO Protocol also enables the creation of a number of use cases based on its technology, one of which is a decentralized P2P credit network: a network in which each user can define, create and maintain their own credit links.</p><p>Other benefits of the GEO Protocol technology include the following:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/how-to-be-sure-that-your-transfer-is-through-d9828a605b79">Provides atomicity</a> of all payments (including cross-chain payments).</li><li>Automatically finds payment paths between nodes with no direct credit links, and also determines the maximum payment (maximum flow) capacity of these paths.</li><li>Allows automatic clearing of mutual debt obligations (finding and closing debt cycles between several network participants — up to 6 hops).</li><li>Off-chain and blockchain agnostic protocol.</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/evolution-of-consensus-mechanisms-from-classical-methods-to-local-consensus-b38ca0d3d9f2">Local consensus</a> between the nodes directly involved in a particular payment; a unique system for resolving possible conflicts, based on Observers.</li><li>Increased privacy (all information about connections and payments is stored locally on the nodes themselves), plus the <a href="https://www.livebitcoinnews.com/blockchain-cryptography-and-the-quantum-threat/">post-quantum cryptography</a> is utilized in the protocol.</li></ul><h4><strong>Dharma Protocol</strong></h4><p>The Dharma Protocol is also a protocol solution, but with a view to debts’ tokenization in the broad sense. The project plans to achieve this by standardizing the process of issuing, certifying and administering tokenized debts.</p><p>Earlier, the Dharma development team tried to implement individual solutions for specific types of debt obligations but later realized the need to create a global and universal solution, which is what they started to do.</p><p>Possible use cases are building the following specialized solutions on the Dharma Protocol such as:</p><ul><li>Tokenized municipal bonds: municipalities often finance public infrastructure projects by issuing municipal bonds. Using the open debt standard, municipalities, large and/or small, can sell tokenized bonds directly to their citizens in a process similar to an ICO.</li><li>Decentralized margin lending: a healthy financial system requires both speculators and skeptics, so buying and selling margins are fundamental components of any liquid financial market. Using the open debt standard, peer-to-peer margin lending schemes can be built using smart contracts and price-feed oracles.</li><li>Tokenized SAFT: projects often raise staggering amounts of capital in order to finance their eventual token sales in vehicles known as SAFTs. With an open debt standard, SAFT agreements can be tokenized as generic debt tokens, where the expected repayment is defined in units of the soon-to-be deployed protocol token.</li></ul><p>So, Dharma is an interesting project with an appropriate approach to a specific problem. But they are eager to solve exactly this particular problem, rather than dealing with broader goals. However, this project can contribute greatly to those broader tasks.</p><h4><strong>Conclusion</strong></h4><p>The real power of decentralized P2P lending solutions will be recognized only if they manage to become not just services, but networks (or an integral part of more extensive global networks). Then, in fact, the original idea of ​​these systems will be fully realized, and their utility for everyone will increase in proportion to the number of lenders and borrowers in the network (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect">the network effect</a>).</p><p>Any (largely or entirely) centralized service, or its binding to any of the existing ecosystems (or the creation of its own one, closed and/or unconnected to the rest) represents half measures only. That would be an attempt to limit and prioritize what should be open, borderless, and accessible to all.</p><p>At present, most of the existing solutions so far represent, to a greater or lesser extent, these same half measures we just mentioned. However, technologies such as the <a href="https://geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a> are emerging, giving the opportunity to unleash the full potential of decentralized credit networks and more.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5484d03e2f2d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/decentralized-p2p-lending-services-vs-networks-5484d03e2f2d">Decentralized P2P Lending: Services vs. Networks</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evolution of Monetary Functions in the Context of Their Specialization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/geoprotocol/evolution-of-monetary-functions-in-the-context-of-their-specialization-8f07ffbdb7a1?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8f07ffbdb7a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Feb 2019 09:31:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-30T12:07:53.857Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Evolution of Monetary Functions in the Context of Their Specialization</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xrLJLTw6qlIAhk2eGf6FVA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In our previous article, we examined in detail the history of <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/on-the-path-to-absolute-money-4621cf024108?source=---------0---------------------">the emergence of money and the evolution of monetary relations</a>. We discussed the gradual abstraction of the measurement of value, moving from a physical medium (material carrier) into pure information expressing value.</p><p>We actually concentrated mostly on the first function of money (measurement of value). Therefore, in this study, we would like to consider in more detail the issue of the evolution of money functions directly.</p><p>Today economists allocate many functions to money. However, we’ll concentrate on the three main ones, namely:</p><h4>1. Measurement of value</h4><p>As we discovered in our previous study, the value is an abstract concept that only exists in the context of a specific historical and economic framework, and is closely associated with human activity and perception (or rather, that of a human community or even communities). The practical function of value is the adoption of a common criterion for evaluating, measuring, and comparing the usefulness (in the broad sense) of all goods and services in relation to one another. Money, in this context, serves as a sort of conditional unit — a measure of value. Exploiting this function of money allowed humans to escape from the pre-monetary barter system, and also contributed to the development of economic relations. Its appearance enabled the evaluation and comparison of the practical utility of any goods and services and therefore allowed us to build various models of economic interaction on this basis.</p><h4>2. Means of circulation / payment / settlement</h4><p>In an everyday setting, money is used as a helpful intermediary for the practical circulation of goods (buying, selling, exchanging, etc.). To do this, money, or rather its tangible carrier (medium) must have a number of properties and characteristics, namely:</p><ul><li>Liquidity, i.e. the ease and speed with which money can be exchanged for goods and vice versa;</li><li>Fungibility, the property of individual units being essentially interchangeable. For example, one coin must be identical to any other — principally in terms of expressed value;</li><li>Durability, the ability to withstand continual use;</li><li>Portability, the ability to be carried and transported easily;</li><li>Cognizability, the ability of the face value to be easily identified;</li><li>Stability (or low volatility), i.e. a low fluctuation of the relative value (ideally).</li></ul><h4>3. Store of value</h4><p>Funds accumulated, but not used (temporarily taken out of circulation), allow the transfer of purchasing power from the present to the future. This also enables accumulation of funds for making larger acquisitions or investments, or savings transfer (for example, to the next generations), etc. To effectively implement this function, money must have the following properties:</p><ul><li>Can reliably be stored for long periods;</li><li>Can be removed from storage fairly easily;</li><li>Has predictable liquidity (ease of practical use) after removal from storage;</li><li>The value of money, to be suitable for accumulation, must retain stability (or even increase) in value over a long term.</li></ul><p>From the above, it is clear that the requirements for the properties and physical characteristics of the cash carrier (medium) of the second and the third functions of money are quite specific; in fact, here we are discussing what we would today call <em>utility</em>. Moreover, for each function, the requirements for these characteristics are quite specific.</p><p>Meanwhile, the first function of money has no special requirements for the carrier, other than the essential property of storing information about the value it expresses. Therefore, the first function is easier to abstract, which we talked about in detail earlier.</p><p>Thus, different forms of money (the evolution of which we discussed in detail in the previous article) may carry different sets of functions. In other words, they can both perform all the functions or just some of them; they can even specialize in one of them. Moreover, all of this (that is, the set of functions that a particular monetary form performs) may also change over time.</p><h4>So, let’s consider this in more detail.</h4><p>After the transition from barter (a cashless system) to commodity money, mankind had, as a rule, more than one type of money. Many different types of money existed, in the form of goods of varying appropriateness for performing monetary functions. And exactly this variety actually contributed to their greater specialization (greater, that is, when compared with the situation to which most modern people are accustomed).</p><p>So cattle was more suitable for the first money function (as a measure of value) and, to a lesser extent, the second function (as a means of payment). Salt was suitable for both the first two functions (even more so than cattle, albeit only in cases of what we now call micropayments), and the third function (accumulation), and so on. Some goods were more convenient to accumulate or transport, some had more liquidity or fungibility, some goods were more durable or were better suited for division into smaller parts (while some others, such as livestock, were not suited for it at all), and so on.</p><p>With the transition to metal coins, there came a relative centralization and consolidation of monetary functions into a single medium. Coins made of precious metals very successfully (as much as possible for that level of civilizations’ technological development) combined most (if not all) of the characteristics necessary to perform all three basic functions of money.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rOf1pqAKGR7pyUcYoPlUog.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig. 1. Coins of silver and gold combined all three basic functions of money.</em></figcaption></figure><p>It can be argued that during the reign of coins made of precious metals, the centralization of the functions of money in one medium reached its peak. However, with the progress of civilization, the development of monetary relations and resultant development of monetary carriers, we can observe a process of gradual specialization.</p><p>So, after the abolition of the Gold Standard from the 1950s to 1970s, national currencies of most countries switched to fiat money; a monetary system based on the trust in the issuer of a currency. Actually, the transition to fiat was due to the objective economic necessity of providing the economy with more money that could be provided using a scarce resource, such as gold. This was due to the need for credit, to increase the total money supply, etc.</p><p>But the potentially unlimited emission, as well as human influence in the manner of monetary policy over fiat money regulation, has led to fiat money becoming greatly subject to the inflation effect. By inflation we mean the gradual rise in prices for goods and services, which is essentially connected with a decrease in purchasing power of monetary units as a consequence of an increase in their number (in this case, as a result of the issuance of additional money supply).</p><p>All of this has led, therefore, to fiat money becoming less suitable to fully perform the third function of the accumulation of value. However, it continues to perform the role of a measure of value, and especially the function of a means of settlement and payment. For that latter function, fiat paper (and later fiat electronic) money is much more suitable than metal coins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_1QDtmqLXEofI2VUW0s1cg.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig. 2. Fiat money (both paper and electronic) is most suitable only for performing two of the three main functions of money.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Thus, we can observe here the process of inverse centralization of the functions of money: specialization.</p><p>During this period of the unchallenged dominance of fiat money, the third function of money hasn’t disappeared. It’s passed to (or, more precisely, remained with) precious metals — gold, silver, and platinum. It’s not by chance that those are actually called the “bank” metals).</p><p>This situation persists to this day, more or less. However, with the advent of blockchain technologies and cryptocurrencies over the past decade, further specializations have become possible. Although these innovations are still in their infancy, they have already gone through several stages of their own evolution. So we can already speculate a little on what could be waiting for us in the near (or not-so-distant) future.</p><h4>Future: Store of value</h4><p>It’s unlikely we will be able to bypass fiat money as a measure of value in the immediate future, for a number of reasons. First of all, because traditional cryptocurrencies are inherently unable to regulate their money supply depending on economic circumstances — in fact, if cryptocurrencies could do this, they would be little different from fiat electronic money.</p><p>At the same time, cryptocurrencies (especially Bitcoin, at least for the time being) seem to be able to claim the function of a means of accumulation. Bitcoin is increasingly referred to as “digital gold”, due to holding the greatest market adoption among all existing cryptocurrencies. All other cryptocurrencies and tokens are de-facto denominated in bitcoins (since the absolute majority of them do not have a direct conversion to fiat). There’s also the clear limitation on its max supply, and regulated emission until it reaches that cap — Bitcoin being a digital scarcity, as we have discussed before.</p><p>At the 2018 Upfront Summit, Fundstrat Global’s co-founder <a href="https://youtu.be/GGberGnxiJk">Thomas Lee described Bitcoin</a> as the Holy Grail of portfolio allocation, citing the ever-decreasing correlation of its price with stock and bond market fluctuations and an inverse relationship with the price of gold.</p><p>One can also look at practical examples of countries such as Venezuela, where the government’s monetary policy has led to an inflation forecast from the IMF of 1,000,000%for December 2018. As a result, Venezuelans have turned to Bitcoin and Dash as viable alternatives to the national currency — primarily for means of value preservation, but also to use as a vehicle for payments.</p><p>However, it turns out that Bitcoin is not the ideal solution as a mean of payment due to certain technological and ideological limitations. Bitcoin transactions are quite slow, and with the increase in its price are no longer as cheap (unless employing a third-party layer 2 solutions, aimed for transaction price optimization).</p><p>All this suggests that Bitcoin (like similar cryptocurrencies) may not be the best candidate for the first two functions of money. But in the future, it may well take its place as the main, or at least a major, means of storing value (the third function).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*43raPGNoCjjayPqy_Kx_Qw.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig. 3. Bitcoin is the most promising digital asset candidate for specialization in the field of store of value function.</em></figcaption></figure><p>To date, this possibility has been hampered, largely by the excessive volatility of the crypto market in general and Bitcoin in particular. But that’s most likely a consequence of the immaturity of this market and technology, the (still) low level of market acceptance, the lack of integration into real economic and business processes, an excessive concentration of crypto assets, as well as their mining capacities, and so on. But after these and other challenges are overcome, our prediction may well become a reality.</p><h4>Future: Means of circulation</h4><p>Thanks to technological development, the future of any means of circulation function will most likely involve an inability to circulate anything. Custodians will be able to store or account for our assets; only digital liabilities, backed up by these assets, will circulate. Such a system will permit exchange via mere record-keeping of transactions and clearance, without the redundant transfer of actual goods and assets.</p><p>Thus, it won’t be a single asset (like cryptocurrency or fiat money) that acts as a mean of circulation, but rather a set of rules that regulate such circulation. In other words — a protocol.</p><p>In the last article, we mentioned our project, (<a href="https://geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a>), although we did not describe it in depth. Now seems an appropriate time to do so, at least in general terms. The idea of GEO Protocol is simply to overcome the limitations of all existing and prospective blockchain-based projects and cryptocurrencies, as well as other digital assets; to create a system capable of combining them, and of connecting them to the systems and assets of the real world economy.</p><p>This will be done not only by enabling the possibility of circulating cryptocurrency and fiat assets in one system but also by facilitating the digitization of any physical assets in the form of digital liabilities (IOUs) or equivalents, (called cross-units in GEO Protocol).</p><p>In essence, the task is to create a universal protocol for value transfer within the so-called <em>Internet of Value</em>. Just as, for example, TCP/IP became a decentralized protocol for transferring information between individual computers, and different local area networks, giving rise to the global information network — the Internet.</p><p>It’s precisely this problem we intend to solve with GEO Protocol. In fact, its goal is to become the most perfect system for the realization of the second main function of money — the means of circulation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oZdWK4uUCkWny-Xcb2Ping.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig. 4. GEO Protocol as a universal system for implementing the second main function of money — the means of circulation.</em></figcaption></figure><h4>Future: Measure of value</h4><p>But let us return to the function of value measurement. As we stated above, in the near future we are unlikely to see the global economy nor leading national economies depart from fiat money as a means of value measurement. Of course, the form of this type of money can change, becoming more or even exclusively electronic (as is already happening). But the essence of fiat currency — regulation of emission and monetary policy of central banks (or their analogs) — is unlikely to disappear soon. For us to witness this, the whole world as we know it, and the global economy, would have to change beyond recognition; and this would require time at the very least, even before considering the substantial — perhaps even catastrophic — catalysts that would be necessary.</p><p>However, speaking more generally, a change in the means of value measurement is at least theoretically possible. If you decouple value measurement from the concept of currency, then you can fully use any relatively stable asset for that purpose — even “exotic” units such as a kilowatt of energy, for instance.</p><p>Energy is a kind of universal equivalent indeed, since the creation, functioning, and even consumption of any commodity requires energy; it is used everywhere. The need for energy will not end as long as humanity, or something created by it, is around.</p><p>Of course, energy can’t act as a measure of value in its natural form, but rather only as a digital equivalent. By the way, this equivalence (a cross-unit, as we mentioned) can also be created on the GEO Protocol network.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>As we see, the logic of the development of monetary functions forms a kind of upward spiral:</p><ol><li>In the early stages of the development of monetary relations, the three main functions were distributed among several types of money (with some very hazy specialization).</li><li>In the later stages of sufficiently developed economic and monetary relations, all three main functions of money were concentrated in one medium (coins of precious metals).</li><li>Following on, and due to the complication of these relations, we see again a tendency towards specialization, namely the separation of certain functions of money (accumulation) from the primary monetary units (fiat money) used for the first two functions (a measure of value and means of circulation).</li><li>And finally, as a result of the development of technology, we may witness in the future a new peak of absolute specialization, wherein each function of money will find its own carrier, the properties, and characteristics of which will most fully meet the requirements for performing their respective functions.</li></ol><p>In addition, it is possible that this deepening of specialization will continue. Namely, there will be more territorial or functional fragmentation of equivalence; certain functions of money will be performed by different units of equivalence depending on the territory or context of use.</p><p>But in one way or another, we will require some kind of distributed system, where all this decentralization would be quite convenient and effective. And, we may note, it was precise as a system of this kind that GEO Protocol was conceived.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8f07ffbdb7a1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/evolution-of-monetary-functions-in-the-context-of-their-specialization-8f07ffbdb7a1">Evolution of Monetary Functions in the Context of Their Specialization</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol">GEO Protocol</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Path to Absolute Money]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/on-the-path-to-absolute-money-4621cf024108?source=rss-9f917a957842------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4621cf024108</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[absolute-money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Demyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Feb 2019 09:03:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T10:29:47.412Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The origin of money and the evolution of monetary relations</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GnGSh60SBnrg_4UVfWEXrA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Essentially, money is one of the forms of social contract. It’s the universal equivalent (or equivalents) used as the measure of the value of all goods and services. In a broader sense, money is a universal means to express, transfer, and accumulate value.</p><p>When we consider its origin, we realize that despite the variety of forms money has assumed over the course of its history, (even physical forms), it’s actually an abstraction with a particular meaning and value only within the framework of a particular historical period and human community. But the concept of value itself is an abstraction as well; meaningless without the context of socio-economic relationships.</p><p>This thought is worth a more profound deliberation, but first, let’s briefly consider the origin of money so we can better grasp the big picture. In the course of this consideration, we will also focus our attention on important aspects of the evolution of monetary relations in general.</p><h3>Barter: moneyless trade</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*taXsbOAEthWMqM8KjqWuhg.png" /></figure><p>At the initial stages of societies’ development, money as such did not exist. Societies largely engaged in subsistence farming, and the exchange of their own commodity surpluses for the needed commodity surpluses of other people or groups was carried out using barter. If one community caught more fish than it needed, for example, it could exchange the extra fish for grain grown by another community. And our fishermen, as a rule, were the final consumers of this grain; the consumers of the exchanged fish were those who harvested the grain.</p><p>In other words, at the dawn of civilization, people exchanged their goods directly and without the mediation of any value equivalent.</p><p>Since goods were exchanged in their natural state, bartering presented certain barriers for potentially more lively and productive exchanges. It was also quite difficult to save and transfer value. Therefore, human communities were forced to seek solutions to the problems that arise in the process of market development.</p><h3>Commodity money: utilitarian objects as a measure of value</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lnHILTDscd0b8YcDkNoUJg.png" /></figure><p>One of the first and most obvious solutions was the emergence of commodity money. Commodity monies are certain types of goods that, by virtue of their physical and consumer characteristics, were a more convenient means of exchange suitable for the role of value equivalent.</p><p>In many cases, those goods were cattle or salt. Cattle, in addition to its direct commercial value, also had the advantages of mobility and self-replication, and rendered additional services (transport, for example). Conversely, there were also natural disadvantages to cattle: the possibility of illness or death. Salt was used as a taste modifier, as well as a food preservative. It was relatively difficult to obtain and limited to specific geographic ranges (mainly on the periphery of the continents or near salty seas), which gave it additional value. It was also quite simple to store, transport, and accumulate.</p><p>These two types of commodity money had a significant impact on civilization, which is reflected in language. For example, the Portuguese word <em>pecunia</em> (money) comes from the Latin word <em>pecus</em> (cattle); the word <em>capital</em> comes from the Latin <em>capita</em> (head). The English word <em>salary</em> and Spanish and Portuguese <em>salário</em> (salary) are derived from the Latin <em>sal</em> (salt).</p><p>Other types of commodity money in different countries at various times include wood, sugar, cocoa beans, tobacco, yarn, cloth, etc.</p><p>The problems of commodity money were the fluctuations of their value, the impossibility (without losing utility) of dividing them into smaller parts, and the ease of damage or destruction. All this hindered their full application in more advanced forms of commercial trade.</p><h3>Metals and the first signs of value measure abstraction</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Aun0ATLkrrIy5j5NOXy80Q.png" /></figure><p>The discovery of metals and their processing technologies led not only to revolutionary changes in the production of weapons and tools but also to the emergence of new physical forms of money.</p><p>Along with their immediate utilitarian properties, the advantages of metals as a mean of exchange include their durability, divisibility, and the relative ease of movement and storage. In addition, their values were enhanced by the complexity of mining and processing, as well as knowledge and skills in the respective fields, which were limited or inaccessible for most people.</p><p>Initially, metals were most likely exchanged in their natural form, just like other types of commodity money (which, at this stage, they were). But they were later used in crafted forms (ingots, jewellery, and so on). Proto-coins then appeared as miniature metal emulations of physical goods, resembling earlier forms of commodity money. Thus, in the Middle East, tiny copies of swords, knives, or keys were in circulation; in Greece, copper and bronze coins in the form of small animal skins.</p><p>This is a very important point because here we can already witness the earliest manifestation of abstraction in measuring value: that is, the endowment of objects (still physical) with a value that may not be inherent in terms of their immediate utility. Thus, money began to acquire characteristics of true equivalence, rather than being simply items that are easy to trade (commodity money).</p><p>Those characteristics became even stronger as coins evolved alongside their societies, into small pieces of metal of more or less standardized shape, size, and weight with an issuer’s seal that guaranteed their (face) value.</p><h4>Gold and silver: scarcity and the cultural factors</h4><p>It is obvious that value in the case of coins was already an abstraction since the most precious metals (gold and silver) had the least practical value at the time. They were poorly suited for the production of anything more utilitarian than jewellery but were much rarer than the cheaper iron or copper.</p><p>Here, in fact, one of the most important characteristics of universal value equivalence — scarcity — is demonstrated quite clearly. Why do we think that this characteristic is the most important one? We will return to this question later.</p><p>In addition to objective characteristics, such as rarity and corrosion resistance, purely subjective factors propelled gold and silver to the top of the monetary Olympus.</p><p>First of all is the aesthetic beauty of these metals, which is something neither truly natural nor objective, since beauty (as we all know) is in the eye of the beholder. Secondly, religious traditions and habits probably played a role here. In primaeval civilizations (particularly Babylon) priests, knowledgeable about astronomy, taught the close mystical and divine relationship between gold and the Sun, silver and the Moon. This inspired beliefs in the magical properties of these metals, as well as objects made of them. Ancient rulers, who ultimately took control of the precious metals’ mining and minting, used these beliefs to sacralize their own power. One of the earliest historical figures to strike his profile on coins was Alexander the Great, of Macedonia, who was also famous for proclaiming himself a descendant of various gods and even a god himself.</p><p>Another possible reason why gold and silver prevailed was the result of Gresham’s law — <em>“bad money drives out good”</em>. If there are two forms of commodity money in circulation having a similar face value, the more practically valuable commodity will gradually disappear from circulation.</p><p>These and similar factors only strengthened the abstract essence and value conditionality of precious metals and coins made of them, which brought them even closer to the true equivalent of the abstract concept of value, compared with more ancient means of its measure, exchange, and accumulation.</p><h3>Paper money: the pinnacle of value abstraction in the pre-digital era</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bf3VVNZG1_JK8ha6f5xavA.png" /></figure><p>It turned out that money made of precious metals was such a successful invention that it accompanied Western civilizations, at least, for quite a long period of time: in fact, right up to the last century. But finally, the time came for the next stage of abstraction of money. So paper money came into play.</p><p>The first paper money emerged in ancient China (9th century AD). In Europe, its forerunner began to appear in the Middle Ages. Despite the relative convenience of storing and moving metal money, it was still quite difficult to settle accounts using it (especially if we’re talking about transporting large sums). Also, the expansion of what we would now call international trade required a more convenient method of payment.</p><p>Transportation of significant funds, even for more or less insignificant distances, was fraught with many risks: from trivial robbery to loss, for example, at sea in a shipwreck. Therefore, it became increasingly common practice to store money and items made of precious metals in relative safety with a jeweller, who would in exchange issue a special receipt stating that he took the such-and-such amount of money for storage from the such-and-such person (or company). These documents could not only be conveniently stored and transported but also easily transferred to others, (thereby transferring the right of ownership for valuables stored in a safe place).</p><p>Exactly these practices later became the prototype not only of the banking system but also of paper money: <em>banknotes</em>. At that moment, an abstract value was no longer expressed by the utility of a physical object. It was expressed only by the face value written on a piece of paper; that is, on a physical medium, which in itself doesn’t have even a fraction of the value it represents.</p><p>Thus, paper money can be considered the pinnacle of abstraction among all iterations of value measurement in the pre-digital era.</p><p>Unsurprisingly, many people initially regarded paper money with distrust. The transition from precious metal coins to banknotes turned out to be a degree of abstraction too far for the broader masses. The process of gradual abstraction of value measurement has, however, not actually been interrupted since the inception of money; rather, it has constantly gained momentum.</p><p>But paper money itself also underwent its own internal evolution, driven by the development of credit relations, as well as by the need for an increase of the money supply to cover the demands of both national and the world economies (in fact, this was one of the main reasons why paper money started to replace metal coins in the first place). So national currencies underwent a further value abstraction process and finally departed from the so-called Gold Standard (when paper money was backed by the issuer’s actual stock of precious metals, for which this money could — at least theoretically — be exchanged at a certain exchange rate). Finally it led to full conversion of the national currencies of most countries into a fiat (from Latin <em>fiat</em> — decree, command) or fiduciary (from Latin <em>fiducia</em> — trust) money: that is, credit and unbacked banknotes, the value of which are based solely on trust in their issuer, as well as in their monetary policy.</p><p>It worth mentioning that, as in the case of the minting of coins made of precious metals in earlier periods, the issue of paper money was ultimately also monopolized by the state in the form of central banks. Thus, trust in fiat currencies is essentially trusted in the governments issuing them, in their monetary policy, and, in a broader sense, in the economies of those respective countries.</p><p>The practice has shown that such a basis is not very reliable for a number of reasons — principally due to human factors that directly affect the current and future value of a particular fiat currency, (or more precisely due to the need for unconditional trust in it).</p><p>As we can see, paper money became a kind of pinnacle of the evolution of money, in terms of the value abstraction process. But at the same time, it exacerbated the problem of general stability and predictability of the monetary system based on fiat money, as well as the need for trust to the issuer.</p><p>We’ve seen that both conscious and unconscious abuse of such trust has repeatedly led to disastrous results in the economies of entire countries, leading, in particular, to the loss of people’s savings in fiat currency at scale.</p><p>However, before we try to find a response to such a challenge, we will continue our consideration of the evolutionary stages of money development.</p><h3>Electronic money: the absolute abstraction</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*as7DRoHHCSq9oaNkyha6Pg.png" /></figure><p>The next significant milestones on this path were credit cards and, in a broader sense, electronic money.</p><p>As with mistrust in the transition from metal (“real”) money to paper money, some were initially wary of credit cards and electronic money. In their eyes, “real” money was that which they could hold in their hands, (that is, paper).</p><p>But in fact, electronic money is just another stage of the abstraction process already familiar to us. This time it was made possible by technological progress in the fields of electronics and communication.</p><p>At this stage, the money that previously existed in the form of physically-transferred credit notes turned into electronic records of accounts and transactions, stored in special electronic accounting tables (ledgers) on servers of centralized institutions (central and commercial banks), or providers of other types of electronic money, (in cases other than national currencies).</p><p>In an economic sense, we are still dealing here with fiat money, the value of which is based on the trust in their issuer and in their monetary policy.</p><p>But formally, such money is already almost an ideal abstraction, since it no longer even exists in a physical medium, but as pure information. On the one hand, this type of money provides us with unprecedented amenities and opportunities. Electronic money is fairly well-protected from the possibility of physical theft or loss, it’s easier to transfer than ever, can be simply and quickly sent over almost any distance, is easier to accumulate and store in almost unlimited quantities, etc.</p><p>But at the same time, the centralized form of classic electronic money has a number of new flaws and very serious threats.</p><p>First of all, it represents the surrender of virtually complete control over the funds of individuals and organizations to someone else (banks, the state, financial service providers, etc.). There’s also the possibility of total monitoring of any business and private financial activity by both the banks and the state, as well as other centralized structures whose intentions may not always be good (especially when it comes to totalitarian states). Transactions in centralized systems can potentially be blocked, cancelled or changed, funds can be frozen or confiscated, and so on.</p><p>Moreover, potential attackers are not limited to those who control the centralized system. Third-party malicious actors who obtain illegal access by, for example, hacking or other mischiefs only increase the list of potential threats.</p><p>In short, centralized electronic money carries as many new challenges as solutions to old problems. But most importantly, it doesn’t solve the fundamental problem of any fiat money — the problem of the need for confidence in their issuer and its monetary policy, as well as the problem of predictability and rationality of such a policy.</p><p>Thus, despite the fact that ordinary electronic money is a kind of absolute abstraction of the measure of value, makes it a contentious claimant to the title of “absolute money”.</p><p>Fortunately, evolution has not ended here.</p><h3>Cryptocurrencies: absolute money?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2XO-t7S7Y_Tc83RTeCVQtg.png" /></figure><p>Only a decade ago, during the global financial crisis of the late 2000s, an unknown programmer (or group of programmers) under the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto created Bitcoin, the world’s first digital currency based on a cryptographically protected distributed ledger: a new <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/technology">technology</a>, called blockchain.</p><p>Unlike traditional digital money, cryptocurrency has a number of advantages; answers to the problems of both conventional digital money and fiat money in general.</p><p>The primary advantage is that a cryptocurrency is an essentially programmable money, which means that all the rules for their emission and further operation are strictly defined in the system code itself and are virtually immutable. Even the creator cannot interfere in the code once the system is launched, and any change is possible only with the consensus of the whole community supporting the particular cryptocurrency. These rules, furthermore, are transparent to all participants. The operation of cryptocurrency is therefore as predictable as possible (since everyone knows all the rules in advance) and almost indifferent to human factors. There is no central authority of decision-makers on issues of cryptocurrency, its monetary policy and so on — as would be the case with fiat money, or any other types of money as well.</p><p>As already discussed, in addition to transparent rules of operation, cryptocurrencies have another important feature: namely, clear emission rules, as well as the final limit of this emission. This property sharply distinguishes cryptocurrencies from all other types of money, where no one (not even the issuer) knows exactly what amount of the currency is in circulation at any particular moment of time, nor how much there will be in the future. In the case of cryptocurrencies, we always know exactly how much is in circulation now, how much there will be in the future and when. This brings the control of inflation and its predictability to an unprecedented level. In addition, cryptocurrency allows any programmable model of operation, including a deflationary one (wherein the amount of money does not increase over time, but decreases predictably).</p><p>But regardless of the model, almost any cryptocurrency (with rare exceptions) has an ultimate indicator of max supply. This means the maximum number of coins that will ever be released is defined, and it will be impossible to release more than that specified amount within a specific cryptocurrency. <a href="https://hackernoon.com/tagged/bitcoin">Bitcoin</a>, for example, has a max supply of only 21 million coins.</p><p>Thus, for the first time in the history of mankind, a true distributed digital scarcity has been created.</p><p>We talked about scarcity above, as one of the important characteristics of money. Gold, precious metals and other rare materials, being naturally occurring and naturally scarce, can theoretically lose scarcity in various circumstances. For instance, a previously-unknown deposit field could be found, or another source of obtaining a resource could appear; or scientists could learn how to synthesize or produce a resource artificially at a relatively low cost (as has happened with diamonds, aluminium, and others). If the resource is utilitarian, then its value may decrease when a cheaper replacement is found, or products in which it is used become obsolete. In short, mankind cannot fully control the scarcity of any physical or natural resource, and therefore its future value cannot be guaranteed.</p><p>Meanwhile, the degree of limitation of digital scarcity can be clearly stated and programmed. This creates an unprecedented degree of certainty and predictability.</p><p>But are cryptocurrencies really the absolute money? Unlikely, if we’re talking about pure cryptocurrencies. After all, they also have their drawbacks.</p><p>There’s the impossibility of direct integration between various blockchain solutions — the isolation of each cryptocurrency or ecosystem from other similar solutions, as well as from the traditional financial world. Further, the high technical complexity of traditional cryptocurrencies significantly limits comprehension of the principles of their functioning by most. Non-intuitiveness, and in general a low focus on the end-user experience, feeds into scalability issues with currently existing solutions as well as other technological and ideological limitations.</p><p>All this continues to hinder the adoption of cryptocurrencies by the market and users (to an extent which the technology probably deserves). Although an individual cryptocurrency may not be the absolute money, cryptocurrencies in general, as the newest monetary and economic phenomenon, promise an evolution in the very concepts of money and monetary relations.</p><h3>A new look at money and monetary relationships</h3><p>The emergence of cryptocurrencies not only provides solutions to many seemingly-eternal problems of money, but it can also serve as a catalyst for change in the very nature of money. Modern society is used to seeing money as something ‘official’, ‘global’ and ‘serious’ ‘backed by the authority’ of its (largely state) issuers.</p><p>Money is, however, in the first instance an abstract measure of value. And value can be very diverse, and more specific in focus than a national fiat currency can address. Value can take many different forms: attention (content views), approval (likes on social networks), support (crowdfunding, charity), delegation (elections), and so on.</p><p>Previously, all this could be encapsulated in a single form of currency (the world currency, or at least the dominant one in a given country or region). Now, the ease of creating cryptocurrencies and tokens allows almost everyone to create a currency with programmable characteristics for their own unique purposes. There could even be separate currencies for a single purpose, or for a certain type of activity, or for different financial uses (international payments, micro-payments, settlements, loans, savings) and so on. And each of them can be designed and optimized to extremes for its specific task.</p><p>Moreover, new currencies could choose not to claim to be ‘universal’ at all, nor to strive for widespread acceptance (for which any currency would struggle). Any group of at least two people sharing value of some kind can create a currency for transferring, storing and exchanging it, and that currency need be accepted only by that group.</p><p>It’s difficult for us to even imagine all the possibilities, let alone the social and economic implications of this kind of ‘currency liberalization’.</p><p>But it’s much easier to imagine the challenges that such a future holds. And one of the more apparent is the question of the effective interaction of all existing and potential cryptocurrencies. Of how to link all this diversity into a single global financial and economic system, simple and intuitive for end users — most of whom are not always willing and able to grasp all the technical and economic subtleties of a system or technology.</p><h3>So what’s next?</h3><p>Studying the history of money and the evolution of monetary relations, as well as being inspired by the opportunities and prospects that appeared with the emergence of blockchain technology, we came to the conclusion that it is necessary to create an open distributed system designed not only to overcome the limitations of existing cryptocurrency solutions but also to link the world of digital assets with a universe of real-world assets and values.</p><p>In other words, the ultimate goal is the integration of the whole variety of existing and prospective economic, monetary and, in a broader sense, value ecosystems into a single universal ecosystem, where trustless systems can effectively coexist with systems based on trust.</p><p>So the idea of creating the <a href="https://geoprotocol.io/">GEO Protocol</a> was born.</p><h4>Follow GEO Protocol at:</h4><p>[ <a href="https://medium.com/geoprotocol/">Medium</a> | <a href="https://twitter.com/geo_protocol">Twitter</a> | <a href="https://github.com/geo-protocol">GitHub</a> | <a href="https://gitter.im/GEO_Protocol/">Gitter</a> | <a href="https://t.me/geoprotocol">Telegram</a> | <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/geoprotocol/">LinkedIn</a> | <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3jEvQvZAmCUXa7dCoX9_Lg/">YouTube</a> ]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fdde502%3Fas_embed%3Dtrue&amp;dntp=1&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fupscri.be%2Fhackernoon%2F&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=upscri" width="800" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href">https://medium.com/media/3c851dac986ab6dbb2d1aaa91205a8eb/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4621cf024108" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/on-the-path-to-absolute-money-4621cf024108">On the Path to Absolute Money</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>