<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Max Ungar on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Max Ungar on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 17:14:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@maxungar/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There is No Place to Start]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/there-is-no-place-to-start-a1a9e5952a46?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1a9e5952a46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rationalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaproblems]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sam-harris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paradigm]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Mar 2025 17:08:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-30T17:08:24.638Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m trying to write a manuscript for a book called Metaproblem. It’s partly based around the ideas of a wicked problem and a metagame; ubiquitous structures which are scaffolds for generalized problem solving tools that most people don’t know about, in various ways. The purpose of invoking these structures in this way is to clarify the fact that they have structures, which can be analyzed and understood in systematic ways, and apply procedures to interact with them meaningfully. Even for the people who know about the ideas I want to write about, there is an incompleteness, and lack of technical competence, such that knowledge of the concepts provides little practical value. And even for people who are competent with many of the ideas, there is still a lack of a cohesive framework for these ideas to be used in conjunction with each other. This is bad, because of how useful these ideas are; the benefits that are missed, and the lapses which occur, because these ideas in their systemized forms are missing from the zeitgeist. There are many overpowering difficulties with communicating these ideas. I will list some of them haphazardly, and hopefully generate insight through this exercise.</p><p>Not knowing what hierarchy to place them in, or other organizational schemes. I know all (or possibly most) of the ideas I want to communicate, but I’ve developed my understanding piecemeal over a long time, and ideas tend to be premised on other ideas within a now pre-existing framework. I’m having a hard time untangling what are the most fundamental premises, although the difficulty might be some unrelated psychological difficulty with organization, rather than purely technical.</p><p>Not knowing what is the most viable format. Would a book formulated in its most structurally logical form be interesting or readable? Are the ideas more usefully presented in sequence, or arbitrarily, or some other nonlinear order? How much time, and what kind of support should be given to any particular idea? Is a book even the most useful or viable format for what I want to accomplish? I was thinking that I should give anecdotes and thought experiments; with anecdotes, I’m concerned about coming off as statistically irrelevant and stylistically self-help; with thought experiments, I’m concerned about coming off as too abstract, ungrounded. Thought experiments are a major topic to be covered, though, so it may be worth investing considerable explanation and justification into the thought experiment mechanism. I may also consider the Gladwell approach, to find examples in pop culture which can be analyzed through whichever lens is at hand.</p><p>Gaining attention while being true to my values. I very much dislike common marketing trends, and view them as producing, or being symptomatic of, outcomes which I’d like to diminish through my work. I’m sure that I’ll have to make compromises to get anything done at all, but the distaste for certain things is psychologically stifling.</p><p>Intuition and pre-existing framework of bad ideas and motivations. We are not taught or socially reinforced to generate logically organized premises with uniform competence. Most prevalent ideas and ideologies tend to work through analog and consensus, rather than independent, principled verification. This structure enables people to believe many things which contradict their stated principles, and to reject things which are consistent with their stated principles. This becomes more true the more emotionally and socially charged the topic becomes. This makes it profoundly nonfeasible to communicate, for example, the principle of contextualism [and falsifiability]; that the value of anything depends on the context in which it arises. Now, people might agree with it in the abstract, but when it comes to something they personally care about, there is less willingness to consider the threshold at which their cherished premise becomes falsified. Beyond that, trying to be logical provokes all kinds of nasty attitudes, and generally makes you look very uncool in most circles, especially when it contradicts dominant opinions.</p><p>Psychological difficulties. I live with people I hate, and am miserable most of the time, and have a large number of complex problems, so I have a hard time working consistently and staying on task. I’ve spent a long time thinking about these problems and wondering what can be done about them, in a way which solves fundamental issues. There have been varying levels of success with different solutions, but they all tend to fail in some way or another. Most recently I’ve been entertaining meditation again; I always doubt that I’ll succeed, given empirical data; but I know the only remotely likely way to succeed is to keep trying. I’m at the bottom of the well and there is no one at the top to throw down a rope. There are many problems which are infrastructurally derived, and cannot be resolved on the individual level.</p><p>Aesthetic argument. This is one of many spinoffs of intuition. My ideas are anti-romantic and technical, in a way which eschews common stylings of personal and social improvement. My understanding of them explicitly rejects the veneer of inspirationalism that successful media wears on itself. That’s not to say I reject inspirationalism or romanticism wholesale, but that they have a time and place, which is probably away from fundamental understandings of the world. I view common strains of self-help emotionalism as trojan horses for various kinds of benign and malignant bullshit, a relatively easy means to make money and get attention. Of course, educational and social infrastructures are lacking, such that more technical conceptual material is largely inaccessible to the public; even if not in theoretical capacity, certainly in willingness to read such material; and even more certainly, in willingness to take a leap of faith into such material from an unknown author.</p><p>Another aspect of the aesthetic argument is social rejection of weirdness. Extrapolations to a logical conclusion tend to yield results which don’t conform to normative thought patterns, which can often produce hostile reactions. Weirdness can succeed in some forms in some contexts, but I have no confidence that something I produce will escape this rejection.</p><p>In summary, I don’t know how to organize my manuscript, or how to reconcile its relatively technical nature with a market which is unlikely to be receptive to it. I have thought about Thomas Sowell’s Basic Economics, an economics primer written in plain language. That was a very long book, which I expect would be offputting. That may however be a necessary formatting choice. I continue to be motivated to work on this project, which I view as profoundly useful and rewarding to think about, and a potential ticket out of the hood, but I’m also dejected, despairing, miserable.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1a9e5952a46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problem is Too Big]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/the-problem-is-too-big-70a76d05dca3?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70a76d05dca3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dysfunctional-family]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Mar 2025 19:21:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-18T19:21:34.999Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The problem is too big. To be more precise, it’s not the overall contour of the problem that’s unmanageable, but the bottleneck of pathological obtuseness. There is a tragedy of being with people who cannot say, “I caused a problem”, or “I am currently causing a problem”, or “the problems I am currently causing are fundamentally related to problems I have caused in the past”. People who not only can’t say those things, but can’t even let you finish describing an initial aspect of the problem, because even acknowledging the <em>idea</em> of their own potential accountability is so deeply intolerable. It’s one thing when you have the resources to move along and say, I don’t want to deal with those people anymore, I’ll try to work on these things by myself. It’s another thing when the resources of your lifetime have been tied up in their whims. Your access to socialization. Your ability to practice being your own person in the world over the long term. Having your lifestyle micromanaged, being shut off from anything outside the house which doesn’t correspond to their pristine, hypocritical ideals. The skillsets, both tangible and intangible, that are developed through engaging with these connections and experiences. You miss out for most of your life, and then it’s just you and the people who have forced you to stay shut in. They seem like normal people to the outside, but their behavior on the inside is that of a cartoon, the kinds of conversations and behaviors and lifestyle enforcements you would not believe are real if you didn’t see them directly. There is no recourse, anyone to believe or care, anyone who is both connected enough to you and with sufficient resources to help out. Traditional institutions you might consider for solving these problems are functionally bankrupt and have nothing to offer except many years of nonsense and disappointment. These many years of trying to fix your problems don’t matter; you can see the structure of the problem, but you are at the bottom of a well, the sides are slick, and there is nobody at the top to throw down a rope. You will be stuck indefinitely.</p><p>You cannot even have the conversation. You’ve tried having conversations, many times, but there is a steep emotional penalty for engaging. Every statement dismissed out of hand, every sentiment polemicized. There is no sense of constructive collaboration to work towards shared understanding and practical solutions. There is no progression in understanding between parties, to build up complex knowledge, or anything more than they knew going into the conversation. They really do not care about your opinion’s functional relevance, and they certainly don’t care enough about it to remember. There have been times of engaged conversation at the sometimes-weekly dinner table, but those conversations avoid our personal practical concerns; as soon as the topic is practically consequential, you are a non-entity whose opinions don’t matter; you are a noxious ingrate. It is a jarring juxtaposition, to have a one conversation where they actively recognize a depth of knowledge that’s beyond them, another conversation where you apparently lack the intellectual horsepower to produce input worth considering. To live and interact (and to mostly go out of your way to avoid interacting) with these people over the years degrades any willingness to share anything, any sense of warmth or affection, any capacity to build and work toward the things that make life worth living, any sense that they care about your real problems in a way that is meaningful. There is no hope.</p><p>What’s even worse is that I don’t feel unique at all. I’ve interacted with and seen from afar, people with such parents, whether it’s narcissism, cluster B, some arbitrarily, vaguely or un- defined brand of unregulated, absurd personality or attribute which has no business in the home or heading an organization, but is nonetheless there, for all manner of reasons. It is incredible that everyone in this situation seems to reinvent the wheel for themselves, or more likely, fail to reinvent the wheel. This cultural lack is a contributing motivator for my manuscript called Metaproblem; a project which I don’t expect to finish, given current lifestyle conditions, but will continue to think about and work on nonetheless. The floor of common wisdom is in hell, and I would like to see that changed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70a76d05dca3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Spiritual Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/spiritual-politics-092f8de1eb62?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/092f8de1eb62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritualism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decision-making]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jul 2024 14:06:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-30T14:06:41.129Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>after writing most of this post, i don’t think it would be very useful to convince anyone of anything. it’s too long, and asking the reader to imagine too many different things. it might eventually be useful as the base of a more cohesively written parable. i hope to illustrate a better version of these premises in the future, because these are very important ideas that many people do not seem to take seriously.</p><p>cutting to the chase, this post is commenting on the absurdity of religious and mystical people and cohorts criticizing others for making irrational decisions, when they have not applied critical analysis to their own lifestyles and beliefs. this applies both to rightists and leftists; probably moreso to leftists, given the zeitgeist premise of an enlightened younger generation. a demographic superset of supposedly rational, educated, science-based, socially conscious people should not be indulging so heavily in astrology and tarot, and based on these behaviors they have relinquished their supposed epistemic superiority to the right. the fact of astrology being so ubiquitous in these crowds is one of the more painfully obvious flaws to criticize, but it’s just the tip of the iceberg.</p><p>an adjacent point i want to make is that if you believe in these things, why not go all-in? why do religious christians tolerate immodestly dressed women, or allow attractive women with makeup on prominent television channels? why isn’t there bible study on fox news? (is there bible study on fox news? i haven’t been paying attention.) why aren’t there more publicly visible religious learning activities? why are people going to football games every week, when they should be praying, learning, and doing good deeds? the religious right are poseurs who have not been godmaxxing. i might start to respect their follow-through if they match the efforts of orthodox jews. if you believe heaven and god actually exist, and that you are rewarded according to both your personal merit and collective social merit, why would you leave any heaven-credits on the table? heavenly merit is worth infinitely more than anything experienced in the earthly plane. if you believe in god and heaven, no cost in this world is too great to be worthwhile. if you can’t resist the siren song of temptation, or a phase-shifted siren song which prevents you from bearing heaven’s burdens, have your crew tie you to the mast, or push you into your necessary suffering. an issue in these regards is that people only believe in heavenly reward as an abstract idea, rather than experience it directly beforehand, and therefore lack the conviction which can only be achieved by visceral experience.</p><p>and likewise with astrological leftists. why is there no large political campaign to have society restructured according to the principles of horoscopy? because, if you actually believe horoscopes work to optimize social organization, you’re allowing your whole society to continue being lonely and miserable, instead of enjoy lives of love, social fulfillment, and general happiness.</p><p>again, these are just obvious aspects of lack of follow-through. there is much more about all of these cultural philosophies which i disagree with.</p><p>—</p><p>The vast majority of people would agree with the premise that decisions should be made based on the facts of the matter, rather than the falsehoods of the matter. if you’re considering eating something, it is consequential whether or not you can know, according to reality as it exists, that the thing is poisonous or safe. if you’re spending time and money to buy a new car, it matters that the car can drive, and that it even exists in the first place. if you’re a normal person, it would probably bother you if your friend Alice, or even just a random person, was talking about how they spent tens of thousands of dollars on a car that could teleport. it would bother you if Alice said the car could make people do what she wants them to do, or tell her who she should marry. it would be worrying if Alice paid the money, and the seller kept pushing off the delivery date, for various reasons. it would bother you if she bought such a car, and then was complaining about her friend Felix, who bought a couch which he claimed would make people like him through the will of the furniture-maker, embedded into the couch’s fabric. it would bother you if Alice became famous, and convinced her fans to send her money to buy a car that could do all of these things, and more; and it would bother you if they spent their money to buy such a car for themselves. Now, of course, it would be wonderful if there were cars that could teleport (if their operation was governed effectively), but most people in current year agree that teleporting cars don’t exist; although this unanimous acknowledgment may have more to do with long term exposure to car behavior, rather than fully reasoned-through logic.</p><p>Let’s say you believed such a car existed, even though it didn’t. it would *really* matter that you learned it didn’t actually exist. imagine how much time you would spend fantasizing about it, only to be let down when you see it doesn’t work. or. imagine you get the car, and it doesn’t work, but the seller tells you that you need to charge its teleportation battery with your the power of your wishes; and no matter how hard and how long you try, he keeps giving reasons why it doesn’t work; or he claims that it’s working, but so far, only in increments of distance that are imperceptible to humans; and you continue to believe him. the potential of learning of the fakeness of teleportation ability depends, in part, on two factors: 1) that someone communicated that it doesn’t exist, and 2) that you had the intellectual and emotional capacity to seriously consider the information they have to offer. it’s important you know the truth — a teleporting car would be amazing, and you don’t want to abandon the possibility of owning one if you don’t have to abandon it; but you also don’t want to flush a year’s wages down the drain, and you don’t want to spend large amounts of time and effort trying to do something which can’t be done.</p><p>the thought experiment of the teleporting car may not be sufficiently obvious, because in real life, it’s intuitively obvious that teleporting cars don’t exist; and this intuition may overpower one’s ability to understand the abstracted premise of epistemic uncertainty.</p><p>so instead, imagine that we find out aliens are real, and they’ve integrated into human society. a day after they arrive, an alien comes to you and offers you a teleporting car for $50,000. since you have no frame of reference for alien culture and technical capacity, you have no way of directly intuiting whether the offer is valid or bogus. therefore, you would need to rely on other epistemic mechanisms to evaluate the offer, like the experiences of other people over a period of time, or actually getting to verify it for yourself.</p><p>now imagine scenarios where the stakes are arranged in a way where the relevant effects aren’t directly perceptible on the individual level, but which have enormous social consequences. 1) there’s a skin cream you like, which may or may not increase risk of cancer by 10%. even if you get cancer because of it, it’s impossible for you to know if it was the cream tipped the balance. 2a) the president passes a law, mandating a new chemical is put into the water, which might make the population 5% more stupid. 2b) the president passes a law, preventing a chemical being put into the water, which might have made the population 5% more intelligent[, according to whichever theoretical metric of intelligence you think is accurate and useful].</p><p>imagine again, in a normal world without aliens, that a person makes one of these various decisions. — —</p><p>while they are profoundly stupid, in one way or another, for buying such a product, maybe they have an otherwise great life; they’re healthy, well-educated, and have a loving, well-adjusted family. even given these additional factors, would you trust them to dictate public policy? what kind of reasoning do you think underlies the gamut of their life decisions? do you think they would process information differently, depending on whether that information is related to their personal life, vs unrelated to anything they will directly experience?</p><p>now imagine</p><p>tragedy of commons</p><p>percentage increase of cancer in long term</p><p>[</p><p>— need to bridge the gap between the parable and horoscopes/religion</p><p>— aliens come down; no pre-existing frame of reference to have assumptions;</p><p>real world is like this; so many things outside of our direct awareness and understanding</p><p>— large scale effects at the population level often not knowable at individual level based solely on traditional heuristics like personal experience</p><p>— illustrate how difficult it is to know certain things, both mechanistically and topologically</p><p>— faith, trust, heuristics;</p><p>we are heavily conditioned over the long term towards these modes of thought;</p><p>we don’t register these shortcomings of thought as being relevant unless we have repeated, direct, profound exposure;</p><p>and we must be habituated, whether by others or ourselves, to achieve relevant awareness and ability to cope with these things</p><p>commonplace forgetting to write down after brief distraction</p><p>]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=092f8de1eb62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ADHD and Opportunity Cost]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/adhd-and-opportunity-cost-d95988901ebe?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d95988901ebe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jul 2024 14:02:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-29T14:02:00.050Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>1 — short remark</p><p>2 — list of topics that i wish i could be writing about, right now, simultaneously; and which i hope to write in the future</p><p>3 — [topic of the day]</p><p>1: short remark</p><p>when contemplating what to cover for the blog, i get very frustrated at all the things i want to say, but which are restricted by the facts of life. i feel as frustrated as ever.</p><p>2: list of topics</p><p>missed opportunities in education (procrustes, mnemonics, and much more)</p><p>Redspace: meta-chain reactions, crab trains, plus everything else</p><p>response to scihub creator’s about page, about economics and more</p><p>meta games, meta difficulty, and i love you phillip morris</p><p>the astounding illogic of canvassing</p><p>elon musk’s understanding of social progress</p><p>wallfacers and epistemic veils</p><p>the way jews love einstein; the functional implications of cults of personality</p><p>airplanes are amazing, and so are death rays pointed at my head</p><p>the scourge of romanticism</p><p>market certifications, and intermediate political cohorts</p><p>politics as social coordination</p><p>social configurations</p><p>the misunderstood premise of retarded as a slur</p><p>parametric inversion</p><p>and much, much more</p><p>3: adhd and opportunity cost</p><p>i’ll talk about adhd epistemology, and then opportunity cost</p><p>i find the premise of adhd incredibly annoying. caveats are that it’s possible that there’s a grain of truth in there somewhere; and as with all knowledge, i apply the principle of the recursive redpill: that nothing can ever be known with complete logical certainty. that being said, common discourse on adhd is extremely vague, and applied to any difficulty. even if it did have a useful definition, it’s been so abused by the zeitgeist that any common understanding is useless. there is not a clear statement of whether adhd is defined by underlying causes vs symptoms. adhd seems to be applied to any situation where a person’s ability to perform intended tasks is inhibited, even in situations where there are already reasonable explanations. my own life has been largely defined by functional difficulties, and there are many reasonable explanations other than adhd. as mentioned in a previous post, i was inspired by the videos of jeffrey kaplan to return to college. i tried out his method of note taking in a continuous, 2.5 hour study session, in the dining room. unlike most other times i’ve tried to study in recent years, i didn’t have a phone or computer in the environment, and i wasn’t in my room. besides my parents doing whatever, later in the session, it was a completely undistracted study session, and i was astounded that i was able to maintain complete focus the entire time. while i continue to have many other difficulties relating to my ability to perform academically, or to produce creative work more generally, the simple fact of having a designated, focused environment nullified what could reasonably be described as adhd in today’s discourse. and you might say, the fact of having to create some system or tool for myself to do creative work is the entire point of adhd — that it’s something i couldn’t do in some kind of “natural”, internally possessed state of mind. but isn’t the entirety of human history characterized by people and institutions creating tools, environments, rituals, and social structures to do particular kinds of labor? of course, there are some tasks which some people do in any area, but there are limits to this.</p><p>while several distractors have been mentioned on a surface level, it’s worth dwelling on phones and social media for another moment. i’ve assumed that it’s commonly accepted knowledge that these products are heavily engineered to be as hypnotically attention-capturing as possible. if someone disagrees with this, then that premise would have to be explored as a prerequisite to further discussion. or, it could be a situation where people are willing to acknowledge the general principle, but fail to recognize that it applies just as much to them as to everyone else — this is a common perceptual limitation, of whose name i’m unaware, but am making a note to look up.</p><p>perhaps another aspect of phone and social media addiction is based on accepted ideas of “responsibility”, which is on my wish list to expound upon, but is very difficult for me to do with the rigor that the written format demands, and which life constraints inhibit. very generally, my perception of moral issues — that is, issues about humans’ game theoretic economic systems (“economic” not meaning “relating to money”, but rather meaning “the allocation of scarce resources which have alternative uses”; the label of “resources” applying to things like knowledge, emotions, thinking capacity) — is that they are systems for maximizing utility (i.e., maximizing social benefit); and that things like justice, fairness, and deservedness, are merely *instrumental* towards maximizing utility, and that their fulfillment is not identical with utility maximization. in fact, they often come at the expense of maximized utility.</p><p>(i am aware of the relative inscrutability of the previous paragraph, and a goal of the blog is to allow breathing room to explain all of these premises with the proper focus devoted to each premise.)</p><p>so, with the premise of responsibility, which is a moral issue, we feel personal responsibility for having wasted time (this impression bolstered by the fact of being the owners of our phones, and our perceptions of being the primary agents of our own behavior), and do not have the intuitive perception of something like, the phone and its apps having been explicitly engineered to be as addictive as possible — a socially accepted and even obligated analog to cocaine, or whatever.</p><p>i would even guess (with a degree of certainty which inherently must remain undefined, given the unknowabilities of the world which comes with the vantage point of an ant) that tech companies bolster the premise of adhd, to reduce the possibility of any stigma developing around the absurd ubiquity of tech. and of course, the meme of adhd can also be an emergent cultural effect, given things like social feedback loops, the fact that the idea of adhd is intuitively obvious, whether or not it holds up to logical scrutiny; the fact that it’s incredibly satisfying to have a label for our difficulties, which appears both simple and functional. the use of adhd mirrors the culture of astrology in many ways, which is another topic i would like to discuss at length.</p><p>adhd is aggravating because it is a symptom of many huge social issues. it is unfalsifiable in the minds of those who believe in it; that is, there is no evidence or logic you can apply to it, at which point, someone who believes in it would say, “oh, you’re right, it *is* bogus.” the fact that our world culture indulges the behavior of accepting logical impenetrability as the near-universal norm is a civilizational nightmare that i wish to solve. this is fundamental to such a huge number of huge issues, and the fact that nobody i talk to about it views it as worth acknowledging, drives me crazy. i have never been more explicitly aware that humans are social creatures, and that the overwhelming tendency is to care about what other people are talking about, with zero attention paid to how much social value it offers. of course, i’m aware that i’m hyper-generalizing, but unfortunately that is necessary when talking about trends.</p><p>adhd is also symptomatic of our culture’s approach to medicine and psychiatric health and social structure. these are all extended topics by themselves. i reflect on my life experiences and think on all of the poor decisions that have been made at different stages, and the unwillingness to question fundamental operating premises. is the thing we are doing working to satisfaction? if not, is there an alternate approach? what are the reasons for the things we’re doing? how are we communicating the purposes of these various things to all the people affected? i feel rage at the uniform, systemic obtuseness of my social environments.</p><p>the conversation about adhd also relates to opportunity cost. as aggravating as it is, and as much as i would like to research, understand, and address this social phenomenon at length, i only have so many hours in the day and in my life. there are other things that relate more directly to the benefit maximization of my life and goals. recently i saw a video, in which thor of pirate software asserts that the problem of twitter is that everyone feels like they have to be involved in everything, and then moralize when others aren’t involved in the things that they care about. while i never got into twitter, i see this in other aspects of life and online culture. given how difficult it is to understand an issue in a useful way, and how certain subcultures produce moral obligations to avoid reckoning with the opportunity cost of functional usefulness, it creates terrible social results. it’s hard enough to develop a baseline coherent understanding of the world in general. it makes me think of the fact that political campaigns cater specifically to the lowest common denominator, as a necessity of gaining popularity. when i say lowest common denominator, i don’t mean that in the sense that “people are idiots”, but that, given the huge volume of intellectual labor a politician, their staff, and the government at large has to perform; and given that any individual social issue could entail an entire profession; it’s absurd to assume that some random schmo can have knowledge that is remotely useful to the task at hand, or that they even have the inclination to develop that capacity, relative to hierarchy of life priorities. obviously, our political curation mechanisms are absurd. i’ve thought of a general solution (essay about the premise of “social solutions” is on the docket) to political curation; instead of them claiming a rasterized opinion on a particular practical matter, select based on generalized mechanisms of reasoning. this is an extended discussion which i am now realizing i’m not prepared to have at this moment.</p><p>i hope to eventually consolidate the following premise. the idea isn’t original, but i think the particular formulation may be. i will probably repeat it many times, because of how useful it is. it also resembles premises from the cixin liu short story, Taking Care of God.</p><p>consider a medieval person. while they have the same raw capacity for intelligence that a modern person has, they lack the basic fundamental information for understanding what a television is. maybe if you had enough time to explain it, you might eventually be able to figure it out — or maybe not. but also, they don’t care about what you have to say. you’re full of nonsense words, and they have better things to do.</p><p>you [the girl reading this ;-) ] are the medieval person in this analogy. or, if i’m not making that joke, the medieval person is our entire society. we cannot even have the conversations which will enable more effective conversations. we lack the capacity to create better knowledge, at least on a large scale social level. this is one of the huge meta-problems that i am thinking about. this is one of the most fundamental problems of civilization. this is related to my intended post, The Jeremiah Principle.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d95988901ebe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Penny Saved is a Penny Earned]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/a-penny-saved-is-a-penny-earned-d6268723672e?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6268723672e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[responsibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jul 2024 21:36:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-24T21:36:09.780Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>need to re-edit this essay. focus will be about the incredible capacity for consistent, willful stupidity; how this infiltrates our society (people with authority, and generally being responsible for social and economic functions), and these premises being motivation to think about *actually* useful solutions.</p><p>a benefit of trying to argue with the most cartoonishly obtuse person you can imagine is that it motivates you to create the most explicit justifications of your ideas as you possibly can. while this still isn’t enough to convince such a person (because their mode of logic is based on social heuristics, intellectual habit and comfort, confirmation bias, rather that critical analysis) it still has useful properties as an intellectual exercise, and reinforces the idea that while direct discourse may be the only option in some settings, more creative, indirect, and long term strategies are required for productive social intervention. recently, i was discussing the idea of a greatly increased salary to one such person; say, $100k/year vs $25k/year. he brought up the point that a penny saved is a penny earned, and that people with large incomes often increase their spending habits to match their incomes — as if this were a reason why it doesn’t matter how much one makes per year. while it’s true that many people with large incomes spend much of that money, and are perhaps driven to increase their spending past what they earn, in a way that is maybe less likely to occur given a meager income (i have no idea what the data are on this), it misses several important ideas. one is to remember that an outcome is a function of multiple factors, not just one. given, for example, the ultimate goal of “accruing as much wealth as possible”, limiting spending can be a useful strategy in some situations, but there are obviously other strategies, like earning money. the more money you earn, the more money you earn; 1 = 1. and actually, a penny saved *isn’t* a penny earned; x — 0 =/= x + y, where y &gt; 0. it is a penny which one has avoided spending. the “penny saved” aphorism may function as a psychological trick, to make someone feel good when they avoid frivolous spending; and it may increase the *economy* of one’s net expenditures, relative to the counterfactual of spending on frivolity; but it is ultimately obfuscationist, which in a literal sense, does not make sense.</p><p>the real sin of logic is the fact of perseverating on such a point! the fact that it’s repeated in such discussions, as if it were some profound economic dogma, and emphasized like a point of central concern. everyone makes mistakes, which are an important and necessary component of intellectual growth. if one willfully neglects to examine their own thinking, and look for (or be willing to have pointed out to them) and analyze mistakes and stupidities, they will fail to grow intellectually.</p><p>of course, most real people in the real world aren’t solely optimizing their life for accruing financial wealth. money is an instrumentality to achieve things like wellbeing, enjoyment, security, and the ability to perpetuate these things. if you make $25k/year, you can save some portion of that, but won’t get the benefit of your own home, or having a family, or doing nice things with family and friends, except maybe sometimes at other people’s expense, and certainly not at will. if you make $100k/year, you can acquire and experience all these benefits and more, and still save $25k/year, or whatever amount. In the case of a person whose financial irresponsibility increases proportionally to income, then there may be a problem. In the case of a person who knows what they want and has the training to achieve it, then at least in straightforward scenarios, there is not much of a problem. it’s important to acknowledge that problems in the real world are complex, and have multiple relevant parameters. while some intellectual models may usefully simplify such problems, it’s important to consider when something has been simplified too much, and when is it useful and necessary to introduce greater complexity.</p><p>I am interested in continuing to explore, and trying to understand the fundamental dynamics of the patterns underlying the discourse and behavior of such obtuse people, to find useful social solutions and improve society.</p><p>while the essay might’ve ended already, another note that i can’t think of how to fit in elsewhere, which is related to my personal experience with obtuse discourse.</p><p>when i describe various economic inefficiencies (or general bad practice) of any corporate entity, says “they probably have a reason”; as if the *possible* existence of a good reason is identical to its *definite* existence, no matter how stupid its outward facing result seems. this is similar to how i used to think about proofs for god, when i was religious; as long as the existence of god was theoretically possible, i didn’t have anything to worry about. in real life, though, it’s more useful to think of practical realities (and belief in god is certainly a practical, meta-economic reality — roughly speaking, it informs whether or not you should invest *your entire life* for reward in the next life.) in probabilistic terms. as a general principle, it’s more useful to invest our resources (time, money, effort, emotions, thoughts, belongings, social status, etc) based on information that is more likely to be true, than information which is less likely to be true. sometimes we cannot assess probabilities, and we have to do the best with what we have. a useful phrasing from nassim taleb’s antifragile is reckoning with domain independence. there is often a failure to extrapolate principles from one context into another context. we can, maybe, think probabilistically in the context of economics, but then fail to apply the same principles in the context of religion, which also is an economic context with a different flavor; economics and meta-economics will be explained in a different post.</p><p>oh, looking back at the goals for this essay, i didn’t address how it infiltrates our society or whatever. umm, i’ll probably address those later, but you can think about the following. first of all, everyone is wrong or ignorant about something or other, right? i think that’s a premise that most people can agree with. another agreeable premise is that nobody ever reaches a terminal point, at which they are saturated with the proper truths of the world. of course, in order to be functional, there must be some degree of confidence in one’s own knowledge, in order to perform the functions of life. it’s important to remember that this confidence, and various other egoistic mechanisms, override the ability to accept one’s own ignorance. this applies to you, yes you, the girl reading this ;-). everyone is a vector for mismanagement, and as social systems we continuously fail, in incredible ways, to maximize practical reasoning capacity in ourselves.</p><p>we also give people incredible social power, despite severe incompetence, merely because this is how it has always been, and i guess because nobody’s thought of a better way, or how to institute a better way. my parents are extremely bad at being parents, and they refuse to acknowledge doing any particular thing poorly. they say things like, “there was no manual for parenting, and i did the best i could.” whether or not this is an accurate or useful premise, these self-admitted incompetents were chosen by default to have control over me for 18 years. besides the various sufferings this entails, it is also an incredible mismanagement of economic resources. what boon to society might i have been, with parents who actually know how to parent? this moaning on my failed upbringing isn’t to negate my responsibility (the premise of “responsibility” is an important topic for extended discourse) for my own development, but to illustrate social negligence as the default, perhaps even the mandate. i can train all i want to run a marathon, but that’s going to do me only so much good if the people with power over me slash my achilles. i *want* to run the marathon, i want to do my part, and i want to be supported in this goal, and i want to support other people in their goals.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6268723672e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Auslander, Hypermodesty, Cruise, University]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/auslander-hypermodesty-cruise-university-d910bbea4109?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d910bbea4109</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[auslander]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[modesty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transitions]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jul 2024 13:40:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-22T13:40:55.594Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>on the way back from work this morning, i was considering which topic/s to write about. i became frustrated at my inability to choose any particular topic. i always have so many things i want to talk about. this inability to emotionally cope with opportunity cost has been massively debilitating for a long time. this is one of many reasons why my return to university is exciting — being locked into particular obligations by an external force. this is related to discourse on freedom, which i have much to say about, but not here. this post will be a potpourri; and in fact, probably most posts will be.</p><p>auslander</p><p>hypermodesty</p><p>cruise reminisce; asher and south asian couple</p><p>trip between target and ccac</p><p>on this shift, i finished shalom auslander’s book, foreskin’s lament. the beginning was very funny and i laughed out loud multiple times. the similarities between his life and mine felt profound, and it was interesting to think about the mechanisms of similarity within a demographic. i was very touched at the end, describing life with his new family, especially juxtaposed with his parents’ final visit. it’s similar to what i fantasize about with my own life. i was thinking about how many stories there are of people trying to escape their religious communities, and how such problems persist with no end in sight. it’s difficult to express my thoughts on the topic, because of the extensive prerequisite knowledge needed for them to sound sensible, and also because it’s interrelated with so many other issues. i will nevertheless say several things.</p><p>an approach that i have about most social solutions is to view them as primitive prototypes; merely the first iterations, requiring a long and critically analyzed process of development.</p><p>sphexishness; the profound and ubiquitous tendency to persist in a behavior or strategy, ignoring (whether consciously or unconsciously) feedback of empirical information.</p><p>brute force strategies; the tendency to assume that the most simple, most obvious solution is the best, or even viable at all, or to do it even if you think there are more productive alternatives, maybe for emotional or energetic reasons, or based on social incentive.</p><p>the way we conceptualize childhood, and condition children to be dependent. children are prohibited from exercising agency, and therefore prevented from developing agency, in many areas that are centrally important to adulthood. children are also placed in social contexts which operate by completely different rules from the adult world. for example, the incentive of money as motivation for professional labor, along with the ability to choose how to spend that money, is very different from the incentive of getting a good grade, in many important ways. a profound facet of this is lack of balance between short vs long term incentives.</p><p>from the perspective of a child, there is no clear counterbalance against the abusive behavior of their parents and authority figures. they lack realistic, pragmatic recourse, and often even the emotional or intellectual capacity for recourse. ignoring various educational reform premises for now, i would be interested in options for group or independent living, with various possibilities of mentor figures and group dynamics explored. it would also be useful to consider workplace options. there are many kinds of labor in today’s economy which require extremely basic understanding of the world (i.e., intellectually accessible to toddlers), like the job i’m about to leave. considering the worthlessness and profound harm of large swathes of my varied educational experiences, and the profound benefits of economic independence, this would be a useful direction to entertain for advocates against long term, realistically inescapable abuse. it is, of course, profoundly necessary to consider the various ways such systems can (and will, murphily) be gamed, and other second-order and n-order effects. the fact that children lacking the clear presence of a traditional family unit may be more vulnerable to external abuse and manipulation. the fact that children may lack the capacity to consistently make decisions in their own long term self interest. the fact that such a system may incentivize parents to abandon their children, or force or coerce them to leave. of course, all of these things and more. as such, counterbalances to these would be designed and implemented, if feasible and useful. and people will screw things up, like always. it’s important to remember, though, that the imperfection and even harm of new strategies must be compared to the imperfection and harm of preexisting strategies; or rather, one utility function must be compared with another utility function. a lesser evil may be evil, but it is, importantly, lesser.</p><p>hypermodesty</p><p>for whatever reasons, i have the urge to make various proclamations about myself, sometimes in ways that come off as extremely egoistic, other times pathetically despairing. i have a self-perception of extreme objectivity, which has several components. one aspect of it is differentiating between how i perceive myself directly (and its drastic changes over time), vs how i perceive others’ perceptions, in direct and indirect ways. this has been a point of conflict between me and my parents, in which they have persistently maintained how much other people like me, in various scenarios, where it can be intuited and extrapolated in obvious ways that either those people didn’t like me, or that them liking me is irrelevant, relative to the totality of my social existence. despite their expressed dogmatic optimism about others’ perceptions of me (which i assume, without explicit evidence, is based on their perceived obligation to boost the social self-esteem of one’s child, no matter what), they also often express opposite sentiments when it comes to their personal frustrations with my level of performance in various endeavors. the dualities of opinion are baffling and aggravating. my father has commonly said that i’m one of the smartest people he knows; but almost uniformly, disregards my opinions in discussions and arguments, in a variety of ways. if i didn’t have such a strong sense of my own judgment, and was operating solely based on my parents’ feedback, i would be quite confused about myself and the world. another aspect of my sense of objectivity is reckoning with various aspects of uncertainty, and that which can’t be known. my sense of self is heavily related to my understandings of epistemology; that while there can be substantial certainty, it can never be complete. that human psychology has numerous, extreme irregularities which can be confounding to navigate. that perception is more reliable when analyzed relative to experiential aggregates. i’ll mention here that this these insights largely stem from a breakthrough i had in therapy, about how the professions for servicing our society’s mental health needs are functionally bankrupt.</p><p>i call my approach to self-regard “hypermodesty”. (idk if there’s an ideal approach to word-styling, but i tend to go for the smushed compound, with some exceptions when clarity is an issue.) communications on the premise of modesty in various cultural spheres has been mixed, and logically contradictory, relative to my understandings of the world. some people define modesty as lessening personality and aesthetic expression, and expression of socially valued attributes, relative to one’s cultural milieu. some people define it as an internalized perception of worthlessness, particularly in religious contexts. jocko willink says it’s that even if one excels at one parameter, they inevitably are lesser at another parameter; i think this outlook, while maybe having contextual social value, is stupid, because the social relevance of maximizing socially valued parameters tends to outweigh the social relevance of merely being average, or not-as-good, with unspecified other parameters. it’s also absurd because his public engagement is contingent on his valued traits’ relevance to that scenario. (i think his premise of humility is more reasonable if adjusted to say something like, “i’ve traitmaxxed, but it’s silly to focus so much on that, relative to other desirable traits,” which is a stance i respect.) these two ideas may be conflated or conjoined, but are distinct from each other: superiority along a valued parameter, and practicing respect and appreciation towards others, respectively. my rejoicing at valuable attributes need not conflict with my positive or neutral regard towards others. i don’t feel certain that i’ve articulated my premise clearly.</p><p>i also have had the sense in the last few years, that i intensely enjoy being myself. i love the quality of thoughts i have, and i’m so impressed and proud and entertained at the things i think. i didn’t have this sense before these past few years, pre-commonplace. i have a stark internal differentiation between my self-perception, and how other people feel about me. even though i love myself intensely, i’m also all too aware of my various failures in most areas of life, and these can be quite depressing for me.</p><p>these stark differentiations are a direct extension of my epistemic method. there is a common tendency to overgeneralize on all manner of issues, and inability to distinguish between similar but different things. these epistemic failures have extreme consequences in all spheres of life. this is an extensive topic that i will hopefully address later.</p><p>cruise reminisce; asher and south asian couple</p><p>i’ve been at target for just over a year, and was thinking about the cruise my family went on last year, from late june to early july, immediately preceding my time at target. i knew i would have a bad time, and i had a bad time. i hate the idea of cruises in many ways, and am explicitly aware of the various ways they conflict with my lifestyle preferences. in any case, on that trip i met a south asian couple, and an extremely charismatic man named asher, who claimed to have been a professor at evergreen and know bret weinstein. (bret is interesting and important to me; via youtube, he provided an extremely valuable introduction to evolutionary biology. his entrance into podcasting has been extremely counterproductive, and i haven’t really paid attention to him for several years, outside of his and heather’s book, of which i have listened to about half. i have similarly mixed opinions about his brother eric weinstein.) i spoke with asher and the south asian couple about epistemology and spirituality. i’m something like a secular rationalist in this context, and they were hindu(?) spiritualists. the woman dropped the old “you have to get outside of your own mind and gain more worldly experience”, which was galling and fascinating. i’m blown away at people’s tendencies towards blunt heuristics like age, rather than explicit chains of reasoning (which i recognize are much more difficult, intellectually, emotionally, and in the context of socially strategic rhetoric). i’ve also hardly ever heard acknowledgment of the disadvantages of age and experience, relative to intelligence; ossified beliefs; the fact that people respond to the incentives, constraints, visceral experiences of only their own lived circumstances, and the implications this has for worldly understanding; limitations on their sphere of knowledge, based on their taste of information, and what the people around them have to say, and who they choose to surround themselves based on information and social preferences; the confidence that comes with age and success, whether earned or not, and which may not be reasonable to translate to other strategic contexts; conflation between self interest vs the various simultaneous configurations of collective interest; that experience can reinforce previously existing, incorrect worldviews, if not analyzed critically, and correspondingly increase the difficulty of future critical self-analysis; and more that i can’t think of right now. i do think that experience, perspective, and interaction are extremely useful epistemic tools, but that they have their place, which is not everywhere and at all times. i’ve been propagandized about the wisdom of my elders throughout my entire life; i thought it was dumb as a youngster (when expressed as a uniform principle), and that impression has persisted and strengthened with age. i am impressed at the profound stupidity of people who are older and more successful than me, and i’m glad that i’m aware of the contextual value of attributes, because otherwise i might despair. the resources that have been squandered by these idiots are substantial and of great consequence. (i have an extended discourse on the premises of “idiots” and “stupidity” and “intelligence”.)</p><p>i was trying to articulate, to the couple and to asher, the procedures of my belief in what i imagine was excruciatingly boring waffling for them all; asher was kind to admit that i was “thorough”. this is a manifestation of one of my extreme weaknesses; the general inability to express complex ideas in a concise and palatable manner. i don’t know that i’ll ever develop that skillset, although i hope someday to foster collaborations relating to this set of issues. i do recognize, though, that my ability to communicate is not just because of my poor communication skills, but also because of the extremely low quality of intellectual and educational infrastructure that exists in our civilization, for many reasons. i frequently take note of the gaps in communications of public figures, past and present. from mister five sauce himself, to the drastically overrated carl sagan (albeit great novelist), even the peak of popular discourse is an intellectual swiss cheese.</p><p>trip between target and ccac</p><p>between the end of my time at target and the beginning of my time at ccac, i’d like to take a trip somewhere, with my state-mandated b-t goth gf. i hardly ever do anything outside of daily grind sorts of things, so it would be quite nice to cut a tiny slice into the persistent mundanity of my mostly solitary, working, lethargically timewasting homebody life. it will also be good and pleasant to remember the marker in time between one life station and the next. i have no idea what it might be, probably a beach somewhere.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d910bbea4109" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Outer Limits of Reason]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/the-outer-limits-of-reason-ff6658236449?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff6658236449</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vsauce]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jul 2024 17:04:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-19T17:04:47.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Vsauce recommended the book The Outer Limits of Reason in one of his videos, and it sounded compelling, given my long term interest in fundamental epistemology, so I bought it. i expect it will be a very useful book, but i’m on page 2 and already have extreme disagreements with some basic statements, which are hard to articulate, especially in a short form format, but i’ll try. the author yanofsky claims that civilization progresses through reason, but this is only partially true, and also partly false. in evolutionary biology, a basic principle is that “the value of any attribute is relative to the context in which it arises.” you can have a genius at the bottom of a well, and a dummy next to a fruit bearing tree. it’s obvious, in this heavily simplified case, who will survive. this is the case with biases and heuristics; being able to make rapid, approximately accurate decisions in the face of danger, is much more valuable in a primitive evolutionary context, than the processes of thinking through the mechanisms and ramifications of a particular mode of behavior. obviously there are some contexts where this intense and expensive thinking is more advantageous than quick, semi-accurate thinking. but when discussing the premise of “context”, it’s important to keep in mind that contexts are indefinitely subdivisible and reconfigurable, and that a context can be a sub-context relative to another context, and a context can be a meta-context relative to another context; and a context is always both. (unless there’s an atomic theory of contexts, in which there’s a logical or empirical endpoint to context extrapolation.) and that since contexts are always changing relative to each other, it changes the value of an attribute, sometimes in ways that are relevant to the goals of the evolutionary entity, and sometimes not. for example, a classroom is a context. in that context, there are subcontexts and overlapping contexts; like student A’s individual relationships with the teacher, and student B, and student C, respectively. another subcontext is student A’s *collective* relationship with these same people. and maybe in the class there are multiple cliques, such that he has unique relationships relative to each of these groups individually. also, A has a relationship to his notebook — maybe he hates the cover, but likes the quality of paper. and the attributes of the notebook are subject to change; for all he knows, the company might change aspects of the product for next time he buys it. maybe if they change the cover, he’ll have an increased satisfaction in his life, boosting his academic performance. maybe if they change the margin proportions, it won’t be relevant to his workflow. and a metacontext relative to the classroom is the government. there can be a policy mandating free lunches one week, and then repeal that policy the next week, with significant consequences on A’s lifestyle.</p><p>evolutionary contexts can be evaluated based on parameters, like everything else. it can simultaneously occur that one parameter is constant over the long term, another parameter changes in a shorter term, and another parameter is in regular flux, and another parameter changes every microsecond. so a society can advance in the sciences, while maintaining primitive understanding of social mechanisms.</p><p>there are many things in our life that we accept without thinking about, and in fact it may be impossible for most people to think about, given the operating conditions. we have roles, responsibilities, social and moral norms, but the thinking in most cases never goes beyond “this is good because i like it and it produces good results”, or “this is bad because i dislike it and it produces bad results”. in fact, it’s often the case that people leave out “produces x results”, and only think as far as, “this is good because i dis/like it”. i live with people like this, who are empirically more successful than me, along conventionally relevant parameters, like yearly income, community inclusion and status, are married with children, are homeowners, have certainty about the course of their life. my perception of these people relative to me is that their modes of reasoning and behavior, relative to important life goals, are often foolish and destructive; and yet society is filled with people like this, and we are still technologically advanced, relative to the rest of history.</p><p>you don’t need to understand the mechanisms by which something operates in order to use it. the dumbest asshole can use facebook on a mac. *some* of the time you need *some* knowledge to do things, but this can be allocated to tiny minorities of a population, or can even have been allocated to people in the past. someone can design a pencil, and create the infrastructure for its production. that person dies, but you don’t need to understand why or how the design process occurred in order to keep manufacturing the same product; you just need to be able to perform the manufacturing process, with or without understanding. this is how social norms work, and it applies to much of social behavior. it happens to be that the paper that we write on changes quality, and we poke through the paper more often, and it’s frustrating, but it’s not sufficiently motivating to do the whole rigamarole of redesigning the infrastructure of paper manufacture from scratch to get better paper.</p><p>there’s also a premise that it’s darkest before the dawn — not in terms of social events, but in terms of mechanisms of competent success. for example, using a weapon. it’s extremely simple and effective to throw a rock at someone. it’s extremely complicated and difficult to design and build a gun to shoot someone. you can be dumb and unskilled and throw rocks to great effect. if you’re medium smart and medium skilled, and try building and firing a gun, you could easily kill yourself and other people when your gun explodes because it wasn’t designed properly. you could even be a complete smartypants, and you’d still get terrible results. even though a gun is absurdly more effective than a rock in many use cases, there is a functional threshold to surpass, before which trying to use a gun is drastically worse than using a rock.</p><p>even based on these first two pages, i have much more to say, but i can’t because it would be too expensive to articulate here and now. i’m also not sure if i’ve articulated the point i want to make, but i have college admissions tasks to get to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff6658236449" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Factorian Returns to School?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/factorian-returns-to-school-8b80d401ceee?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b80d401ceee</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scifi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[redspace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[factorio]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[engineering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jul 2024 14:21:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-18T14:21:11.839Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The segment in brackets is what I started writing a couple days ago. I intend to eventually write and refine the rest of the premise, but I have other things to say. i’ve written a lot on these topics, but only in my notes, which are not in a format that is understandable by anyone except for me, and also are mixed in with writings on all kinds of other subjects.</p><p>[</p><p>there are many fundamental ideas in the world which we misunderstand. many of these we are taught from before we can remember, such that their meaning is so obvious, to the degree that it would never occur for us to question them. their meanings are so obvious that even if you did question them, nobody would take you seriously. even if we learn alternate meanings, they may be understood in a superficial way, but our functional, intuitive understanding is based on our long term conditioning.</p><p>freedom</p><p>freedom is only a coherent concept when understood relative to specific parameters. there is no such thing as absolute freedom, even within the context of a single individual, because inevitably, one freedom will contradict another freedom.</p><p>opportunity cost</p><p>in a situation where someone is allowed by their social structure to do whatever they want</p><p>need to give several concrete real life relevant examples</p><p>family structure; even in a “free” society, domineered by parents, peers, etc</p><p>/]</p><p>a few days ago I discovered the youtube channel of jeffrey kaplan, philosophy professor in greensboro NC, hometown of one of my favorite authors, Orson Scott Card. 2 vids in particular of relevance: note taking technique for effective study, and that doing well in college courses doesn’t need to be hard. the evening of watching the note taking video, i sat down in the dining room with a chemistry textbook and studied according to his method for 2.5 hours. this was a revelation, compared to my previous experience with studying, given a variety of factors. it is another in a long series of affirmations about the deeply profound nonsense of the milieu of my upbringing, and that there is a better life. since dropping out of college 8 years ago, i had written off formal education as being a low- to negative-value investment. more recently, i started listening to cal newport’s books about lifestyle and study habits for achieving straight A’s in a balanced way, and another about “deep work”; listening to these, because of my general interest in pedagogical and didactical theory and practice and their relationships to institutions, both existent and theoretical; and my concerns about my own abilities to learn effectively. again, blowing my mind about how a better life is right there to grasp, if we can just stop picking our nose for a second. so i watch these lectures by kaplan, then try it out, and it’s a revelation, and i decide i want to go back to university. i lack a variety of basic skills for figuring out loans or a plan, but i’ve reached out for help.</p><p>this time around, i’m interested in engineering, particularly chemical engineering or materials engineering. average salaries are attractive, and induce fantasies of financial and lifestyle independence. of course, it’s important to also keep in mind the incredible distance to that goal. i’ve also wanted to study the sciences for a long time. i’m a big fan of hard science fiction, which i’ve been reading for a long time. i’ve had many ideas for stories i’d like to write; already in this post i’ve wanted to go on long tangents several times, but am trying to stay focused on the immediate narrative. just a teaser; the most substantial story premise i’ve been working on (for about 14 months) is called Redspace. Redspace germinated as a reductio ad absurdum of pokeballs; they have this incredible, infinite compression technology, and they only use it to store pokemon? imagining the economic, societal ramifications for logistic industries; and variants depending on the constraints of the technology. what if it can only compress biological matter, and how would you configure the premise such that it occurs in a scientifically sensible way? (eg, how would a beam of light* be able to differentiate between organic vs inorganic matter?) how might the industry change as the technology improves over time? what would be the implications for the consumer market? the premise blossoms with indefinite variations across parameters and disciplines. i have a very long backlog of notes to sort and compile. there are many challenges with it which i certainly cannot meet anytime soon, but it’s a premise which has consistently enthused me.</p><p>Real quick, another aspect i’m obsessed with is parametric inversion, which is an extended topic on its own. but in the case of redspace, i think about scifi, and how everything is in space; and that setting, at least on a surface level, has become very boring and cliche to me. But what if you could invert it? instead of traveling huge distance with various difficulties, what if you could make small, even microscopically tiny distances incredibly difficult to contend with? since redspace compression would have its own fabricated physics, and since the diagetic technology is in flux, it allows for generating all sorts of dynamics and constraints, and interesting solutions, that just wouldn’t be relevant in a traditional space travel scifi context.</p><p>the parametric inversion of distance dynamics in science fiction is related to another premise, which i call “avatar aleinu”. aleinu is a prayer in judaism, and one expounding of a verse in aleinu states that despite the extreme overcrowding you would expect from all jews in the world returning to jerusalem, a miracle will occur to allow everyone the proper space to bow down. (an alternate morbid interpretation just occurred to me, which is that space to fully bow would be due to a reduced population of jews.) and avatar refers to the james cameron movie, specifically the second-body inhabitation mechanic. (worth noting that avatar 2 was a real stinker which i would have paid the price of admission to not have gone.) but instead of using huge bodies, people use tiny bodies. again, a world of fascinating possibilities to explore. one thing, for example, is thinking about how traditional mechs are enormous and not-feasible relative to current engineering constraints; but if they were meching for tiny people, no problem. and again, humanoid design for mechs is kind of boring and cliche; more interesting is wondering how the would look and operate when designed for specific purposes.</p><p>fuck, just remembered another premise of redspace that i’m extremely excited about: pairing time dilation in rough proportion to degree of compression. so with extreme spatial compression, you would have a corresponding temporal compression. (or contraction; i’m not sure if there’s a science-appropriate set of semantics or terms for these concepts.) and the same goes in the opposite direction — redspatial dilation corresponding to time dilation. the implications are wild. one of them being able to evolve organisms in a short amount of time, and engineer these evolutions. let’s so you’re a corporation wanting to customize an evolutionary process; compress for a redspace-eon, then have your corporate paleontologist examine the fossil record. okay, that’s enough redspace for now, but i could keep going indefinitely.</p><p>I’m also a huge Factorio head, and the *real* real motivation for majoring in engineering is to become the world’s most proficient Factorian. I have so many fantasies of mods i’d like to make, or games i’d like to design. of course, i’ve hardly accomplished anything outside of my ideas, but the future is pregorante with possibility. i got burned out during the pandemic while playing the space exploration mod, so for the most part haven’t played much in the last 3 years, but i think about it all the time. after i learned about cold chains, i thought that dynamic would be so cool in factorio. i’m excited about perishable goods in the factorio expansion. of course, of course these relate to my ideas about redspace — it’s all intertwined. factorio is a game with many themes, one of them being logistics. redspace has huge logistics implications.</p><p>one aspiration regarding a return to university via engineering is connecting with other people sharing such interests and aspirations, to some degree or other. my first time in college, i was timid and uninvolved. this time around, i’m wondering if i might start a student club, something about the intersection of engineers and science fiction. who knows what exact form it might take.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b80d401ceee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nothing Seems to Fit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@maxungar/nothing-seems-to-fit-62154007b8a2?source=rss-46b2a6b7b320------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62154007b8a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pragmatism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[goal-setting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rationality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Max Ungar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Jul 2024 11:44:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-16T11:44:55.842Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>guideline</p><p>minimal edits</p><p>publish at least 3 times per week</p><p>i have so many thoughts but almost never publish anything. I always have a feeling that anything i do is incomplete in some way, and it doesn’t fit a particular format for publishing. i almost never refine to a degree of internal acceptability. so even though i’ll keep being upset, i’ll publish anyway, on this blog. i’ve gone through this thought process with a number of formats, but haven’t followed through. i think this time it’ll be easier, though. every work shift i take notes of my thoughts, so, in a case where i can’t figure out how i want to present or explain things, i’ll just present the notes verbatim, and reserve the right to follow up with explanations of the various thoughts. also, while i may create some semblance of order, i won’t be consistent with it. don’t be surprised by non sequiturs and redundancies.</p><p>formatting, presentation, and audience tailoring have always been extremely troublesome to me. i always feel uncertain about whether or not requisite knowledge is mutually known or understood on a certain topic, or if some gross misunderstanding has taken place, and struggle to find the most explicitly clear language to explain a particular concept. this set of concerns entails a lot of problems. so maybe for this project, i’ll try to dial back the expression of these anxieties, and if anyone pays attention and is wondering about something, they can just ask.</p><p>i have so many topics of interest, which relate in many ways to each other, that it feels impossible to know how to present them in a coherent format. it’s possible that some platonic structure exists, with perfect formatting and clarity and entertainment value, but i’ve accepted that it is out of my reach, at least for the foreseeable future. so i’m settling for a mode of explanation that is sloppy and pathetic and embedded with whatever other undesirable but pragmatically necessary traits</p><p>i’ll probably talk about my emotions too. in general, i think my intellectual observations are much more interesting than my particular emotions, but it’s also useful to examine the psychological reality that accompanies various modes of thinking. Psychological capacity in general is one of the most fundamentally powerful resource sets, and it would be prudent to pay close attention to it, to study and understand it and hopefully capitalize on it. Emotions are useful signals. Emotions are a large part of humans’ functional interfaces. It would also be nice to expound on these emotions in a way which susses out meaning that isn’t articulated in common modes of discourse. And also, wonder about the functional implications of various emotions. This is important to evolutionary biology, and thinking about the abilities and limitations of people relative to modernity. And also the discourse around emotion relative to these premises, which is extremely lacking in various useful qualities. For example, the common appeal to naturalism; I think there are two distinct terms in this regard, and I often forget which is which. In any case, the tendency to think that what is natural is right, or useful, or relevant, or accurate. My opinion is that everything has its place, but that emotional reflexes are blunt tools, not calibrated to the demands of current society, and implications of these saturate our world. This is a point where I feel like I could branch off in a thousand directions, and which in a “proper” format I wouldn’t know how to continue. But since the premise of this blog project is to largely eschew formatting and organizational concerns, I can disregard this thing that would otherwise be a problem. I might talk about these things later; there are other things to say.</p><p>there are things that i imagine for other formats. for example, most recently, i’ve wanted to produce a youtube video about Sister Sage from The Boys, about how she’s what a dumb person thinks a smart person is, and many other points. but i’m stuck/working through many technical details to try to achieve my vision for the video (compiling and editing the script, figuring out background footage, trying to make custom character animations to play during the reading of the script, sound recording, and general editing), and while my intention is to work through them, given my track record, i’ll most likely never finish the video. and so, this blog’s anti-format comes to the rescue. i’ll just compile my notes on the topic and publish that; maybe neaten it up a bit, but the point is to not make such a big deal about it, and indeed to treat it as something of an afterthought, in a bid to maximize likelihood of completion and publication.</p><p>i have extreme ambitions, despite what i’ve accomplished in my life so far. i’d like at some point to create and semi-regularly update a roadmap document, to make it clear to the audience what i hope to accomplish, and make my theoretical social utility more apparent. unfortunately, i am at the bottom of a proverbial well that i cannot escape on my own, so if one finds my work interesting or useful, support in a variety of forms is welcome. not just in regard to money, but also communication, social connections, networking, pointers to resources, or whatever one might think of that could be useful in some way.</p><p>another aspect of this project is that, given my prolific production of thoughts on all manner of subjects, it’s impossible for me to concisely communicate what is interesting or useful about me and my goals. this blog, and maybe other published media, will function as an extended, ongoing communication on that topic. there’s a phrase i think sometimes, “everything you know is wrong”, which applies along significant parameters of common knowledge. i use many ideas that i find in the wild, but many of the syntheses, extrapolations, and conclusions i draw, i do not see reflected anywhere. it’s possible they exist, but i’m not aware of them, and even if they do exist, i consider it worthwhile to contribute to their proliferation. i’m hyper-aware of the perceptions of egoism, charlatanism, and delusion which these kinds of statements are likely to arouse. it’s a topic i’d like to address at some point, because i have many thoughts about it, and i think it’s an interesting topic with angles that one would not expect (of course, if “everything you know is wrong” is a reasonable statement, then almost by necessity it would have unexpected implications), but that’s for another time. this topic is extremely relevant to my habitation of the proverbial well, and is much of the basis for my motivation to produce intellectual labor. My opinion is that ubiquitous bad thinking is the most fundamental social bottleneck, and i’m interested in starting processes of resolving this incomprehensibly large metaproblem in ways that accommodate pragmatic realities. this statement has been an incredibly blunt representation of an extensive body of thought. i observe and experience some of the many ways that bad thinking destroys precious resources in all spheres of life, which are extremely painful, and which need not be the case forever.</p><p>if there’s a specific topic you want me to address, leave a comment or send a message. idk how this website works.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62154007b8a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>